Google
This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for generations on library shelves before it was carefully scanned by Google as part of a project
to make the world's books discoverable online.
It has survived long enough for the copyright to expire and the book to enter the public domain. A public domain book is one that was never subject
to copyright or whose legal copyright term has expired. Whether a book is in the public domain may vary country to country. Public domain books
are our gateways to the past, representing a wealth of history, culture and knowledge that's often difficult to discover.
Marks, notations and other maiginalia present in the original volume will appear in this file - a reminder of this book's long journey from the
publisher to a library and finally to you.
Usage guidelines
Google is proud to partner with libraries to digitize public domain materials and make them widely accessible. Public domain books belong to the
public and we are merely their custodians. Nevertheless, this work is expensive, so in order to keep providing tliis resource, we liave taken steps to
prevent abuse by commercial parties, including placing technical restrictions on automated querying.
We also ask that you:
+ Make non-commercial use of the files We designed Google Book Search for use by individuals, and we request that you use these files for
personal, non-commercial purposes.
+ Refrain fivm automated querying Do not send automated queries of any sort to Google's system: If you are conducting research on machine
translation, optical character recognition or other areas where access to a large amount of text is helpful, please contact us. We encourage the
use of public domain materials for these purposes and may be able to help.
+ Maintain attributionTht GoogXt "watermark" you see on each file is essential for in forming people about this project and helping them find
additional materials through Google Book Search. Please do not remove it.
+ Keep it legal Whatever your use, remember that you are responsible for ensuring that what you are doing is legal. Do not assume that just
because we believe a book is in the public domain for users in the United States, that the work is also in the public domain for users in other
countries. Whether a book is still in copyright varies from country to country, and we can't offer guidance on whether any specific use of
any specific book is allowed. Please do not assume that a book's appearance in Google Book Search means it can be used in any manner
anywhere in the world. Copyright infringement liabili^ can be quite severe.
About Google Book Search
Google's mission is to organize the world's information and to make it universally accessible and useful. Google Book Search helps readers
discover the world's books while helping authors and publishers reach new audiences. You can search through the full text of this book on the web
at|http: //books .google .com/I
r
/
I
A
COMPLETE COLLECTION
OF
State Trials
AND
PROCEEDINGS FOR HIGH TREASON AND OTHER
CRIMES AND MISDEMEANORS
FROM THE
EARLIEST PERIOD TO THE YEAR 1783,
WITH ^OTES AJ^D OTHER ILLUSTRATIOJ^S .
COMPILED BT
T. B. HOWELL, Esq. F.R.S. F.S.A.
AKD
CONTINUED
FROM THE YEAR 1783 TO THE PRESENT TIME;
BY
THOMAS JONES HOWELL, Esq.
VOL. xxin.
[BEING VOL. II. OF THE CONTINUATION]
S3 & 34 GEORGE III A. D. 1793 & 1794.
LONDON:
l^riMUd hy T. C. fiMiord, Feterhonmgh'Cwtrt, Fleet-Street :
FOR LONGMAN, HURST, REES, ORME, and BROWN ; J. M. RICHARDSON ;
BLACK, PARBURY, akd ALLEN; BALDWIN, CRADOCK, and JOY;
E. JEFFERY; J. HATCHARD; R. H. EVANS; J. BOOKER; J. BOOIH ;
BUDD AND CALKIN ; AND T. C. HANSARD.
1817.
t I
LmARY OF THE
LELAND STANFORD JR. UA'/\/ER8ITY.
AUG 27 1900
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TO
VOLUME XXIII.
=sssss^ssssssasaassssgaBm
GEORGE THE THIRD^ A. D. 1793 & 1794.
587. Proceedings in the High Coun of Jui^cuny at Edinburgh,
agaiiitt JAMES TTTLER, for Sedition, a. d. 179S 1
[Now fine pnbliah^.}
588. Plrooeedingt on the Trud of JQHN MORTON, JAMES ANDER-
SON, and MALCOLM CRAiO, for Sedition, a. d. 1798 7
[Nov fint 'pi4>liA9d.]
589. IVooeedmgs against JOHN ELDER and WILLIAM STEWART,
for Sedition, A.n. 1798 ....a t. 25
[Now first published.]
.%
590. n-ooeedings against JAMBS SMITH and JOHN MENNONS,
for Sedition, a. d. 1798 33
[Now first published.]
591. Ptooeedings on en Information exhibited by the Lord Adrocate of
Scsotland, against Captain WILLIAM JOHNSTON, for Con-
tea^ of Court, a.0. 1798 • 43
[Now first published.]
59S. Proceedings against JAMES THOMSON CALLENDER, WAL-
TER BERRY, and JAMES ROBERTSON, for WriUng,
Printing, and Publishing a Seditious Libel, a. n. 1798 79
[Now first published.]
593. Proceedings on the Trial of THOMAS MUIR, Esq. the younger,
for Sedition, a. d. 1798 .^ « 1 17
Addsvda, p. 1405.
594. Proceedings on ihe Trial of the Rer. THOMAS FTSHE PALMER,
for Seditious PracticeSi a.d. 1798 S37
595. Proceedinga against ALEXANDER SCOTT, for Sedition, a. n.
1794 383
[Now first published.]
TABLE OF CONTENTS.
Page
596. Proceedings oa the Trial of WILLIAM SKIRVING» for Sedition,
597. IVoceedings on the Trial of MAURICE MARGAROT, for Sedi-
tious Practices, A. D. 1794 • 603
Vkk AooBiQia* p. IMKT.
598. Proceedings m the Case of CHARLES SINCLAIR, for Sedition,
A, D. 179* 777
[Now first published.]
599. Proceedings on the Trial of MSSim GEtlR ALD, for Sedition,
A.D. 179* ^. « 803
Tide Addenda, p, 1407.
600. Trial of DANIEL ISAA€ EATON, for publishing a Seditious
Libel, intituled, *' Politics for the People, or Hog's Wash,''
A.D. 179* -; lOlS
601. Proceedings against THOMAS WALKER of Manchester, Mer-
chant, WILLIAM PAUL, SAMUEL JACKSON, JAMES
CMeEt«A!<l,<NLlVEIlPEARSALL,«ENJAltrN©OaTH,
and JOSEPH €OLUER, for a Conspiracy to overthroir the
Constitution and GoTermneirt, and tb aid and assist the French
(being the King's Enemies) in case they should invade this
Kingdom^ A.D. 179* 1053
602. Trial of ROBERT WATT, for High Treason, a.d. 1794 1 167
ERRATA.,
Vol. XXIII.
p. 542, 1. 24, for as read so.
1. /o«/, for choose read chose,
p. 543, 1. \yfor choose read chose.
laU line but 6, dele of.
p. 545, 1. t6yfor make the use read make use.
p. 548, 1. 8,./iw there read three.
]. 27 from bottom, fur resolutions read resolution,
p. 550, 1. 23/«wn bottom, after and imert it.
p. 551, 1. to, for these read their,
p. 681, 1. 9, dele the.
1. 2S/nwB bottom, for of r«a<i on.
1. 7 /rom 6o^om, for attainment, — for instance read attainment, for
instance,
p. 682, 1 32, /or reason read reasons,
p. 684, 1. 24 from bottom, for or read of.
p. 688. 1. 4 from bottom, for breasts read breast,
p. 689, 1. 23, /or them, away ; read them away;
1. 35, after interpretation ituert a comma,
]. 96, deU the comma. '
p. 690, \,U,for Mr. Margarot? The read Mr.Margarot, the
1. 22 from bottom, for form read frame,
p. 691, 1. 20 from bottom, for corporal read corporate,
p. 692, 1. 5, for adding read stating.
p. 696, 1. 25, for triumph ; and read a triumph, and
U. 28 & 29, Jor duties. That read duties— that
1. 19 fnm bottom, for every read my.
p. 697, L 32 from bottom, for us an read us as an.
p. 702, 1.31, /or meeting. He read meeting, he.
p. 791, 1. 13, for republics read reipublics.
!$> la^ line but one, for republiae read reipublicc.
STATE TRIALS,
587. Proceedings id the High Court of Justiciary at Edinburgh^
against James Tytler^ on an Indictment charging him
with Sedition^ January 7th: 33 George HI. a. d. 1793.
Cuna Justidaria S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nova Sessionis domo de Edinburgh, sep-
tiniodie Januarii, millesimo septingen-
tesuno et nonogesimo tertio, per bono-
labiles viro» Robertum Mac Queen de
. ;&axfield Dominum JusUciarium Cleri*
com, Alexandnim Murray de Henderland,
Davidem Rae de Eskgrove, Joannem
Swintotty et Alexandnim Abercromby de
Abercrumby, Dominos Commbsionarios
Justickutis dicti S. D. N. Regis.
Curia legitimife affirmata.
HlBE which day the diet of the criminal
letters raised and pursued, at the instance of
Bobert Dundas, esq. of Arniston, his Majes-
^'8 Advocate for his Majesty's interest,
a^inst James Tytler, chemist, residing in
lun^s Park, in the neighbourhood of ^in-
bur^ and in the county of Edinburgh, being
called ; which criminal letters make mention,
That albeit, by the laws of tlds and all other
well eovemed realms, the wickedly and felo-
niously writing or printing, or causins to be
written or prmted, any seditious nbel or
writing; as also the wickedly and felo-
niously distributing and circulating any
such seditious writing, or libel, when so
printed ; or Ibe causing the same to be dis-
tributed and circulated among the inhabi-
tants of a populous ci^, the metropolis of
a country, are crimes of an heinous- nature,
dan^rous to the public peace, and severely
punishable; yet true it is, and of verity, that
ne the said James Tytler has presumed to
commit^ and is ^iltv of all and each or one or
other of Uie foresaid crimes, actor or art and
Srt : in so far as, upon one or other of the
lys of the month of November in this pre-
sent year 179Sy or of the month of October
immediately preceding, or upon some other
day in this present year to the public prose-
cutor unknown, the said James Tytler aid, at
Edinburgh, in Uie county of Edinburgh, or at
VOL. xxni.
some other place to the public prosecutor un-
known, wickedly and feloniouslv compose
and write, or cause to be composed or written
a seditious libel or writing, addressed ^ To
the People and their Friends," whereof the
tenor follows :
** To the People and their Friends.
'^ A reform in Parliament being now uni-
versall^f talked of, it seems necessary for you
to consider of the means by which that reform
is to be accomplished, which means have not
vet been seriously taJcen into consideration
by any person, or number of persons, that I
have heard of. It is said, that Mr. Pitt will
perhaps brine in a reform ; and I understand
that tnis has been held forth to you by certain
colonels and captains (perhaps I may mistake
their titles), hi whom I wish you to put no
confidence. What right has Mr Pitt to
make the parliament eood or bad as he
pleases ? Or what right nave the parliament
to lengthen or shorten the time of their own
sittins ? Will you still suffer yourselves to be
duped, and to be made the tools of every one
who thinks proper to assume the authority
over you ? I have been told, that those who
would be your leaders, advise yon to petition
parliament. The proposal involves itself in
contradiction. The parliament has alr«u3^
showed itself unworthy of confidence, and it
has usurped a power to which it has no rijB;ht.
If the House of Commons is composed ofthe
representatives ofthe people, these must be
the servants of the people. Will you then
be so absurd as to petition your own servants,
or people who ought to be so? But the
trutn is, that the menbers of this house
have become the masters not only of the
people but ofthe king also. How many pe-
titions have of late oeen presented to the
house of commons, and how few to the kxn§ ^
As the Popish priests absorbed the worship
due to the Deity by stocks and stones ana
B
SI
33 GEORGE III.
Proceedings against James T^ler
[4
rascally saints^ so have the house of com-
mons artfully drawn away tiie attention of
the people of Britain from the king to them-
selves. Those who advibe you to petition the
house of commons, insidiously and slity tell
you, that these are your only just and lawful
masters; yet these very persons will rail
against the comiptions of the house of com-
mons as much as any body ; nay they are
part of the house whom they desire you to
petition; so that their advice ends in the
very modest request that you would peti-
tion themselves! But, besides thb ab-
surdity, you must consider the house of com-
mons as your enemies. They affect to con-
sider themselves as the democratical part of
the constitution. They are not ; they arc a
TUe junto of aristocrats. The majority of
them arc landholders ; and every landholder
is a despot in the most true and literal sense
of the wonL He can^ directiv or indirectly,
extort from the country what he pleases : Ue
can raise the price of provisions ; he can turn
people out of their possessions ; be can drive
them to the utmost ends of the earth ; and, in
short, turn the country, at least that part of
it which he possesses, into ft wilderness, if
be pleases. It is this monstrous power of
the landholders that you have to combat;
and it is the want of somethine to balance
this power, that is the true foundation of all
the grievances you labour under. If you wish
ft remedv for the evils which vou suffer, and
are resolved to petition, surely you must pe-
tition the person who has it in his power to
grant the remedy; and this is no other than
the king, whom you seem entirely to have
forgot. You cannot be ignorant that the king
can dissolve parliaments, and call them toge-
ther when he pleases. If you wish parlia-
ment to sit only three years, petition the king
to dissolve it at that term ; and, if he con-
sents, you have your desire, at the same time
that the jparliament has no reason to com-
plain. It vou wish to have an equal repre*
sentation, let those who are not represented
petition the king : let them set forth, that
they are oppressed and enslaved by an as-
sembly of aristocrats, who call themselves
the representatives of the people, but are not;
let them request that the king will allow
them to choose representatives for them-
selves ; and that they may choose any person
ofgoodunderataiKlingand character to this
office, though he should not be a landholder;
Bay let them make an exception, that these
representatives shall not be lanaholders, and
it will be 90 much the better. Let not the
minister, or his spies, however, deceive you,
by promising a reibrm, and admitting tiie
inferior class of landholders as electors, or
ewpable of being elected, as I am told he has
ottered. Thus you would be overwhelmed
with an inundation of tyrants, and in a worse
situatioii than you are. Let not money, or
land, or houses, be thought to make a maa
£t for being an elector or vepiQseDtative ; an
honest and upright behaviour is the only
aualification. Wealth has too lone usurped
le place and the rights of virtue; let virtue
now resume its own power and dignity, to the
exclusion of eveiy uiing else, iiemember,
that it was by an unwarrantable stretch of
power, that the commons enlarged the dura-
tion of their own sitting. If they get this
power sanctified by a petition from the na-
tional convention, it is precisely what they
want : and instead of obtaining any reform,
the chfluns of the nation will be rivetted.''
Which seditious hbel or writing the said
James Ty tier delivered to William TumbuU,
printer in Edinburgh, upon one or other of
the days of the saia month of October in this
present year, or of the month of November
following, and employed him to print the
same ; and he having accordingly done so,
and thrown off five hundred copies, or there-
by, thereof, which were delivered bv him to
tlic said James Ty tier, on the 26th day of the
said month of November, or some one or
other of the days of that month, or of Octo*
her preceding, or of December following, he
the said James Tytler did, immediately tSiere-
afler, and upon one Or other of the days of
the said months, wickedly and feloniously
distribute and circulate, or cause to be dis«
tributed and circulated, amongst the inhabi-
tants of the city of Edinbursh and its suburbs,
a considerable nuifiber of Uie said seditious
libel or writing, so printed, as aforesaid, to the
amount of two himdred and fifty, or the]reby.
And the ssud James Teller, with the view,
and for the purpose of inflamine still more
Uie muids ot the inhabitants of the said city
of Edinburgh and its suburbs, inciting them
to break the public peace, and of inspiring
them with sentiments hostile to our happy
constitution, and injurious to the peace and
happiness of the inhabitants of tnis realm,
dia, within some few days afVer the so priot*
ing, publishing, and distributing and circubii-
ingofthe said seditious libel, as aforesaid,
compose and write, or cause to be composed
and written, a wicked and seditious para*
graph, of the following tenor :
^* If the king do not hear you, our Magna
Charta hath this for its basis, that the people
need not pay any contributions towards the
public exigencies of that country to which
tliey do not belong; for it bears^ that we
must appear, either in person* or by our re-
presentatives, and calmly and aehberatebr put
our hand, as it were, to our pocket, and pay
what we please, or what b agreed to ; ana as
this at present is not the case, but only with
a small number, the rest of the nation are
either slaves, or not of their comoMinil^: and
consequently not imder their law. until such
time, so to speak, as we be natoraliied. This
is the law ot our Magna Charta : and as we
we without the natiomi bond, in this we are
beyond their kw, as by it we amst have our
voice in framing our kws, or they are none of
ours; oonsefuentlyy we may as timidJy sub-
81
Jbr Sedition*
A. D. 179S.
[6
nut to laws imposed on us by tho pope, as
submU to laws imposed on us l^ such a junto.
The conclusion is, if the king hear you not,
keep your money in your pockets^ and frame
your own hiws, and the mmority must submit
to the majority."
Which seditious writ'mg or paragraph the
said James Tytler did, upon one or other of
the days of the said month of November, in
thb present year, or of October preceding, or
December rollowing, also deliver to the said
William TumbuU, with directions to print the
same on the back or second page of the afore-
said wicked and seditious libel, that had been
so printed, as aforesaid ; for which purpose,
the said James Tytler returned to the said
William Tumbull such of the copies of the
said seditious Ubel or writing that had been
ptinted as aforesaid, as had not before that
fasQR been distributed or circulated by him the
said James Tjrtler, to the number of two
hundred and mly, or thereby; and the said
William Tumbuil having accordingly, in terms
of the said directions, printed, or caused to
be printed, the said wicked and seditious
writing, or paragraph, on the back of the
copies of the aforesaid seditious libel, that had
been so returned to him for that purpose by
the said James Tytler, he did thereafler de-
liver the whole of the same, or nearly so, to
the said James Tytler: and he, the said
James Tytler, did thereafler, on one or other
of the days of the said month of November,
or of October preceding, or December follow-
ing^ wickedly and feloniously distribute and
circulate, or cause to be distributed and cir-
culated, amongst the inhabitants of the said
dty of Edinburgh and suburbs thereof, the
said seditious libel, originally printed and
thrown off aa aforesaid, with Uie addition of
the ssdd seditious paragraph so printed on the
caid second page of the same. And the said
James Tytler having been apprehended on
suspicion of being guilty of the said crimes,
aoa carried before .^hn Prinsle, esq., sheriff-
depute of the county of Edinourgh, he did in
his presence emit and sign a dec&ration upon
the 4th day of December 1792, which was
likewise subscribed by the said John Pringle;
and being to be used m evidence against the
said James Tytler at his trial, will for that
purpose, together with two printed papers,
(^e one which is marked No. 1. being oue of
the aforesaid seditious libels so first printed
and circulated as aforesaid, and the other
marked No. 8. bdng one of the aforesaid
seditious libels to which a paragraph was
allerwaids added and printed on page 2nd
thereof, and afterwards circulated as aforesaid,
both also subscribed by the said James Tytler
and the said John Pringle^ esq. and other
persons, be lodged in due time with the
clerk of the high court of iusticiary, before
which the said James Tytler is to be tried,
that he may have an opportunity of seeing
the same. At least, times and places afore-
said, the said wicked and seditious libels or
writings were written, printed, published, dis-
tribute, and circulated, as aforesaid, and the
said James Tytler is guilty actor, or art and
part thereof. All which, or part thereof,
being found proven by the verdict of an
assize, before our lord justice general, lord
justice clerk, and lords commissioners of jus*
ticiary, the said James Tytier ought to be
punished with the pains of law, to deter
others from committing the like crimes in sdl
time coming.
And the said James Tytler having been
often times railed in court and Uiree times
at the door of the court house, he failed to
appear to underlye the law for the crimes
specified in the said criminal letters.
Whereupon his majesty's advocate moved,
that sentence of fiigitation and outlawry
might be awarded against him; and a^he
understood bail had been given for the ap-
pearance of the said James 1 ytler when ap*
prehended by the sheriff of Edinburgh, he
craved that the bail bond might be forfeited,
a^d the penally recovered.
^ The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
sioners of justiciary, decern and adjudge tiie
said James Tytier to be an outlaw ana fugi-
tive from his m^esty's laws, and ordain him
to be put to his highnesses nom, and all his
moveable goods and gear to be escheat, and
inbrought to his majesty's use, for his con-
tempt and disobedience m not appearing this
day and place, in the hour of cause, to have
underlyen the law for the crimes of sedition
and others specified in the said criminal
letters raised against him thereanent, as he
who was lawAiTly cited to that effect, and
oftimes called in court, and three times at the
door of the court house, and failing to appear
as said is ; and ordain the bond of caution
granted by James Hunter and Robert Ross,
booksellers in Edinburgh, for the appearaned
of the said James Tytier, under thejinalty of
six hundred merks Scots to be forfeited, and
the penalty therein contained to be recovered
by the clerk of this court, to be disposea o
as the Court shall direct.
(Signed) Robert M'Queen.
J. P. D.
7]
S3 GEORGE IIL PraceetRngt agamH JiAn Morion and others [8
588. Proceedings on the Trial of John Morton^ Jamss Ander«
soN^ and Malcolm Cbaig^ on an Indictment charging
them with Sedition. Trjed before the High Court of
Justiciary at Edinburgh, on the 8th, 9th, and 11th Days
of January: 33 George IIL A. d. 1793.^
Curia Justiciaiia S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nova Sessionis domo de Edinburgh,
octavo die Januarii, raillesimo sepUn-
fentesimo et nonoeesimo tertio, per
onorabiles viros Rooertum Mac Queen
de Braxfield Dominum Justiciarium
Clericum, Alexandrum Murray de Heu-
derland, Davidem Rae de Esk^ove,
Joannem Swinton de Swinton, Dominum
Gulielmum Nairn de Dunsinan Baro-
netum et Alexandrum Abercromby de
Abercromby^ Dominos Commissionarios
Justiciaris dicti S. D. N. Regis.
Curia legitime affirmata.
• Intran,
John Morton, apprentice to Stewart Ruth-
Ten and company, printers in Edinburgh.
James Anderson, journeyman printer with
Mundell and Son, pnnters m Edinourgh ; and
Malcolm Craig, also journeyman printer
with the sdd MundeU and Son, printers in
Edinburgh, Panels.
Indicted and accused at the instance of
Robert Dimdas, esq. of Amiston, his ma-
jesty's advocate for his m%iesty*s interest, for
the crimes of sedition and others mentioned
in the criminal libel raised against them
thereanent, bearing, That where by the laws
of this and of every other well governed realm,
the uttering seditious speeches, tending to-
create a spirit of disloyalty and disaiTection to
the sovereign and to the established jgovem-
ment; more especially when such discourse
and speeches are addressed to persons in the
xnilltuy service of the country, whose peculiar
province it is to protect the kmg and constitu-
tion as by law established, and uttered with a
▼lew to corrupt and witibdraw them from their
dutjr and alle^ance to their sovereign and
their countrv is a crime of an heinous nature,
tending to the subversion of all order and go-
yemment and severely punishable; yet true
it is and of verity that the said John Morton,
James Anderson, and Malcolm Crais, are all
and each or one or other of them guil^ actors
or art and partf of the foresaid crime aggra-
vated as aforesaid. In so far as the said
* Compiled from the records of the court
of justiciary, and the periodical publications
of the time.
t As to this, see in this Collection the case
of David Hackstoun, ante. Vol z. p. 807, note.
persons above complained upon with others
their associates did with a seditious and
wicked design, in the evening of the 18th
day of November of this present year 1799^ or
upon one or other of the aavs or nights of Uiat
month or of October preceding, come into the
Castle of Edinburgh in the county of EdiiH
burgh, and having gone into the room com-
monly called king James's room, in the lower
canteen or sutlery of the said Castle, and
having called for some liquor, they did thcD
and there, all and each, or one or other of
them, in the presence of Thomas Hume»
corporal in the Grenadier Company of the
d7tn reeiment of foot, and of Thomas Huxter,
Alexander Stronach, and Michael Fish»
soldiers in the saud 37th regiment of foot, then
garrisoned in the odd d^e, and some of
whom had been purposely sent for to join
their company, among other wicked and sedi-
tious speeches^ propose or drink or cause to be
drunk as a toast, ** George the third and last,
and damnation to all crowned heads*'— or
words of the same meaning and import; and
thev the said persons complained upon, did
fartner insist upon the said corporal and other
soldiers aforesaid then present, to join vdth
them in the said wickea and seditious toast ;
and they the said John Morton, James Ander-
son, and Malcolm Craig, or one or other of
them, did at time and place fores^d seditiously
and feloniously endeavour to raise discontent
in the minds of titiesaid corporal and soldiers,
or of one or odier of them, and to seduce them
from their du^ and allegiance to their sove-
reign and their country, by falsely and insi-
diously pretending that their pay was too
small, and holding out to them the prospect
of higher pay if they would ioin a certain de-
scription of men whom tne said persons
styled " The Friends of the People,*' or a
*' Club for Equality and Freedom." And the
said John Morton having upon the 90th day
of November 1793, been brought before John
Pringle, esq. our sheriff depute of the shire of
Edinburgh did emit and sign a declaration ;
aad the said James Anderson liaving upon
the said SOlh day of November 1799, been
brought before the sud JohnPrinele, esq.,
did emit and sign a declaration ; and the saia
Malcolm Craig having upon tiie said 90th day
of November 1799 been brought before the
said John Prinsle, esq., did emit ajKl sign a
declaration; which three declarations above
mentioned will be used in evidence against
91
JbrSttBtitm:
A. D. 1793.
[10
the said John Morton^ James Anderson* and
lialoolm Craie respectively, and will for that
purpose he loaged with the clerk of the hieh
court of Justiciary before which they are to he
tried that Uiey may have an opportunity of
seeing the same: at leas^ time and place
above mentioned, the foresaid seditious
speeches were uttered, and the said wicked
attempts made to seduce the soldiers from
their outy and aU^;tance, and the said persons
shove complained upon are all and each or
one or other of them guilty actors or art and
part of the sud crime; all which or part
thereof being found proven by the verdict of
an assize before our lord justice general, lord
justice clerk, and lords commissioners of jus-
ticiarv, in a court of justiciary to be holden
by them within the criminal court house of
Edinbursh upon the 96th day of December
instant, vae said John Morton, James Ander-
son, and Malcolm Craig, ought to be punished
with the pains of law to deter others firom
committing the like crimes in all time
coming.
The libel being read over to the panels
in open court, and th^ being severally inter-
ro^ted thereon^ they answered they were not
guilQr.
Pr</r$for the Pro«ecii*or.— Robert Dundas,
esq., of Arniston, his majesty's advocate
[atterwards lord chief baron of the ex-
chequer/]
Mr. Kohert Blmr, his majesty's solicitor-
general [afterwards lord president of the
court of session.]; and
Mr. John Burnett^ advocate.
Agent, Mr. Hugh Warrender.
Prt/n for the PaneU. — Mr. Alexander
'Wight, advocate.
Mr. David WiUiamton, advocate ; and
Mr. James Ferguuony advocate.
Agentj Mr. Hugh Robertson.
Mr. FerfusBon for the panels, represented,
that the cnme here charged of uttering sedi-
tious speeches was one which had not oc-
curred in this country as a subject of trial in
the memoiy of anv man livmg. That in
former times it haa often been prosecuted,
but that those were times when tne freedom
of the subject was not so secure as now.
That tiie words here used were ambiguous in
their import! were mere verba jadantia uttered
in convivial discourse without any wicked or
seditious design, and that the statement in
the minor proposition did not amount to the
crime described in tiie major proposition-
that wi^ Regard to the part of the libel
which charges an attempt to seduce the mili-
tary firom their duty and allegiance, he con-
tended that it appears that the panels had
only expressed what many people may think,
also, that the soldiers had too littie pay, but
that they did not thereb^r mean to seduce or
corrupt ttiem . That in this there was nothing
crimind than in saying that the stipends
of the 'clergy were too small : that the pa-
nels had no -intention to offer any thing
hostile to the constitution; they have no
connexion with any of the clubs or associa-
tions, and their going to the Castle was merely
accidental^ as wUl appear upon investigation ;
and if the libel should be found rdevant'
craved a proof at large in exculpation and
alleviation. He also mentioned tne inexpe-
diency of bringing to trial a crime of this
nature, of which there had been no recent
example upon the records of court ; and that
it might be of dangerous consequence, to in*
troduce as a precedent the trial of a crime of
such difficult proof, and of so ambiguous a
nature.
Mr. Burnett answered, that in this case per-
haps, more than in any other, there was the
matest room for the question of intention.
That no doubt words of the most seditious
tendency might be uttered without any view
to stir up seaitioxi, but from mere rashness
and folly. The intention however must be
jttdeed of from the whole circumstances at-
tending the case, from the occasion and time
when, the place where, and the persons to
whom such speeches are uttered: that the
whole circumstances appearing from the ^ce
of the libel joined to the obvious meaning of
the words themselves, exclude eveiy pre-
sumption of any thing else, than a wicked
and seditious design ; and therefore the state-
ment in the minor proposition is fully tanta-
mount to the crime cnarged in the major.
The panels are printers conversant in the
meaning of words ; they must know that in
an established government, every act to dis*
turb that government is highly criminal at
common law. There could, therefore, he
contended, remain no doubt of the relevancy
of the charge now brought -. and he did not
oppose a proof at large in exculpation or
alleviation.
The Lord Advocate after complimenting
the counsel for the panels, for the very
able manner in which he had expressea
himself, said, that he considered it as in
a peculiar manner his duty, to advert to
what had been stated with regaid to the in-
expediency of bringing this offence to trial.
His lordship said that the conduct of those in
the situation which he held, with respect to
the bringing to trial offences of this nature,
must be regulated in a great measure by the
existing circumstances of the country. That
what at one time would be considered as an
act of mere folly and rashness, and as having
no seditious tendency, is, at another, and at a
different conjuncture, an act of a more mis-,
chievous and serious nature. That at the
time when the words and speeches were
utterred, that are stated in this charge, the
country was in a verv alarming situation in-
deed : principles had been openly and avow-
edly published, that were hostile not onlv to
that nappy constitution under which we live,
but subversive of all order, and of every ostarr
t
m
1 II SS GEORGE III. Proeeedingi agamd John Morion and oiken [19
blish«d g^vermnent That persona who oo
aiich an occasioDy and at mch a GODJiincture,
eipressed themselves in the manner in which
it is stated ^ese panels did, could have
heen actuated hy nothing else than a most
wicked and seditious purpose, with a view
to stir up that spirit of popular insurrection,
and to puroduce those scenes of riot and anar-
chy, wjbich had htea so dismally experienced
by ^e inhabitants of a neighbouring countiv.
liiat when attempts were thus made to sun-
vert the constitution, and so violent an out>
rage committed on the law of the country, he
thought it the dut^ of every good and peace*
able subject to endeavour to counteract them;
and more particularly the duty of the public
prosecutor to bring those persons to trial,
who had been in any shape accessory to the
commission of such outrages. That as he
all alons considered the conduct of the pa^
nels in tnat light, and that they had been
actuated with a seditious intention at the
time, he conceived, that he would have failed
e|;regiously in his duty to the public, if he
bad not brought them to trial. With respect
to the relevancy of the indictment, his lord-
ship did not conceive, that there could be the
least room to doubt, that fix>m the whole cir-
cumstances as appearing upon the face of the
indictment, joinea to the obvious purport of
the words said to have been utterea, a crime
of a very aggravated nature had been com*
mitted, ano^which well deserved the most
aerious attention both of the Court and^ury.
Their lordships then severally delivered
their opinions.
Lord Hewierland, — My lords; I am ex-
trefkiely sorry to see three youns men, indus-
triously brought UP to a usera profesnon,
placed at your loroships bar as panels. I
am bound, m this stage of the business, to
presume they are innocent, and humanity
mduces me to wish they may be found so ;
but that is not the question before us ; our
present province is, by examining the indict-
ineBt to determine how far a crime is properly
charged in what is called the m^or proposi-
tion, and, if so, whether the facts stated in
the minor, amount to that crime, and are re-
levant to infer punishment?
The indictment chai]ges, in the m%|or pro-
poation, that the uttering seditious speecnes,
tending to create a spirit t>f disa£Ssction and
disloyuty, especially among soldiers, and with
a view to withdraw them from their duUr,
is a crime. Who can doubt it ? Thepanners
counsel admit it is so. The facts staked in
the minor proposition are in substance. That
the pannels having sent for certain soldiers,
sarnsoned in the Castle of Edinburgh, to
tneir company, did propose to drink, drink,
or cause to be drunk, in their presence, as a
taasi, ^* George the third and fist, and dam-
nation to all crowned heads.'' What was
this, but ouvertly expressing a most wicked
and flagitious wish that our gracious so-
vereign, under whose mild and auspici-
ous sway, this nation has arrived at m
pitch of prosperity uneiyoyed and envied bj
most of the other parts of Europe, should be
damned? — a wish, that in his person a period
might be put to that happy constitution, by
which our lives, our liberties^ and our proper-
ti^ have been protected and secured I It
was admitted to be most flagitious, but it
seemed to be denied thst of itself it was a
crime tryable in this court. In my opinion,
itis of itself a crime well meriting the cog-
nizance of this high court, and to be tried by
the most respectable jury of this realm.
Openly to avow a desire to overturn the con-
stitution ; an impious wish that our benefi-
cent sovereign, aistinguished by private and
public virtues ; his sacred majesty, the father
of his people, would be damned ! — What can
be more criminal? But this is not the crime
meant to be here chaiged, for these words, in
the indictment, are coupled as follows; and
they, the said persons, did further insist that
said soldiers should join them in said toast.
Was not this very act an attempt to with-
draw the soldiers from their dutv and allegi-
ance, and thereby to break tneir militaiy
oaths and engagements ?
The indictment farther proceeds— That
the panels did seditiously and feloniously
endeavour to raise discontents in the minds of
the said soldiers, and to seduce them from
their duty, by pretending their pay was too
small, and holding out to them the prospect
of higher pav, if they would join persons of a
descn^tion therein named. What means of
seduction could be employed apparently more
effectual? It was saia that the persons or
clubs mentioned in the indictment, held and
avowed principles favourable to government
and to the constitution. I can know iiothmjg
of these clubs in this place; I like not their
names. The Priends of the People, and a
Club for Equality and Freedom ! What oc-
casion for such associatipns, with such names ?
Are not the people protected in the enjoy*,
ment of their constitutional rights, and in
reaping the fruits of their indusUy ? A club
for equalitv and freedom! Freedom is a
name we all revere, and we enjoy it; but if,
by equality, be meant an equal division off
property, it would be a downnght robbery to
mtroduce it ! To say that all men have
equal rights when born, b a proposition from
wnence no consequence can be drawn. Or
to maintain that all men are equal, is neither
founded in truth nor nature — scarce two chil-
dren are born precisely alike. Among men
we difier in the simplest powers of the bod^.
Few men possess the ability of walking m
such perfecfion as the celebrated pedestrian.
Has every man abilities, natural or acquired,
to qualify him for a minister of state ? Or
does the extensive knowledge of trade and
commerce, wliich so eminently distinguish a
Hopeof Amsterdam, and even, some of our
fellow citizens here, who have, much to their
own honour and country's advantage, ac-
IS]
JyT SeeSiion.
A. D. 179S.
[U
quired krge fortunes in the same way, belong
to all men? To reduce them in point of
^raalth and riches to a common level would
be an unprincipled and nefarious robbery.
£veiy man has a risht to acquire wealth and
riches, but it must be by the same or equally
lawful means. But suppose the object of
such societies to be no more than to an-
nounce the above unconsequential proposi-
tion; or that their principles are favourable
to o^r and government ; that they mean to
support the constitution. — Be it so. — What
then ? In every nation, among every peo-
|4ey which can deserve the name of a state,
there must be different departments, dif-
ferent powers of state, of public civil do-
minion, which are distinct, by whomso-
ever exercised, out of which difierent rela-
tions and duties arise. Internal controversies
produce the judicial power; wrongs from
without, the fecial ; the necessity of general
rules of conduct, the legislative; of a public
reveime and property, we fiscal ; and thepub-
iic force necessary to carry into effect the de-
terminations of all the others, with the regu-
falioiia belonmg to it, constitutes that branch
of public civu dominion, which is called mi-
litaiy ma^stracy; it matters not of how
manv parts it consists, or in what form it be
employed, whether it be called the king's
host, as fomerly with us, coBsistine of mili-
tary vuialsy a pm$e emmMu$^ a mintia, or a
standing army raised under the authority of
parliament.
All these diffeient departments or powers^
czeicised by one or many, have their separate
duties and dependances : and by that com-
mon law which arises from the constiUiUon
of government itself, a transgression or an
attempt to bring about a transgression of
thmemustbe punishable. It may depend,
deedy upon circumstances, before what court.
The military, when raised, are under the
mramand ot the king, and of the officers set
over them by his maiesty. To withdraw, or
to attempt to withdraw soldiers from such
constitutional dependance and discipline, and
place them under any other influence or au-
thority whatever, must be a crime, and of
course punishable ; and if made by one not
under military command, may be tried and
punished in tnis high court.
It was said, in the way of defence, without
admitUng the tm& of the charge, That the
attempt must have been unpremeditated —
the whole affiiir acddenUd — ^tluit the panels
must have been drunk — or it must have pro-
ceeded from kvity. To c^mstitute murder,
it is not necessaiy that the slaughter should
have been long premeditated. If the act be
committed, intention and a design must be
presumed, unless suc^ circumstances of acci-
dealt could be establidtied as rendered the
slayer an involuntary agent; such, for in-
stance, as the head of an axe flying off, and
killing a man. No such circuuistance could
occur nere^ — Drunkenness could be no alle-
viation-^ were it, the greatest criminals would
escape.* How many instances have we of
men gettine drunk to embolden them to com*
mit crimes^ Levity can be no excuse. The
proverbial wisdom of this country teaches,
" it b dangerous to play with edged tools.''
Most crimes discover want of consideration-p-
all want of just reaaoning and sound judg-
ment. I shall be happy if the jury can find
any ground consistent with their oath, and
with their duty to their country, upon which
the panels may be acquitted. In the mean
time it is mine to say, that the above defences
hinted at by the panels' counsel, ought not
in law to avail them, and that your lordships
will pronounce an interlocutor finding th
indictment relevant.
Lord Eskgrnroe considered the crimes
charged in the indictment as of a very dan-
gerous nature and tendency ; and he entirely
concurred in the opinion which had been
given.
Lord Stointon. — My lords; the miestion now
before the court is not. Whether the prisoners
are suilty of the crimes laid to their charee ?
for uiat IS the province of the jury. Neitner
is it the heinousness of the crime, charged in
the general proposition of the indictment;
for that is admitted. But the present ques-
tion is singly. Whether the particular articles
in the charge amount to [the crime laid in the
general proposition ; and whether relevant to
infer the pains of law ; so that issue may be
joined upon them, and sent to a jury, ujpoa
the plea of not guilty? This question has,
however, been treated so properly and so
fully by such of your lordships as have alreadv
delivered your opinions, that I can only tread
in their metsteps, and shaU therefore use few
words.
Tho essence and criminality of the chareo
depend entirely upon the intent of the woras
spoken by the prisoners, and their behaviour
acoompuiying these words. 80 the question
is, whether the articles charged infer a felo-
nious and criminal intent.
Though the prisoners have pled not guilty
in genend, yet their counsel have laid in for a
special defence, by explaining, that though
some of the words had really been spoken,
yet, loose expresuons in the warmth of con-
viviality oiignt not to be laid hold of^ as
iinporting any thing serious or criminal.
Whether that construction can be put upon
(hem, or whether liquor and conviviality
brought out the sentiments that were upper-
most (as m tnno iteritat) would depend on the
proof which was not knjw hci ; we were now
only to consider whether the charge is rele-
vantly laid. This would best appear by con-
sidering the tenor of the indictment.
First, It is charged, that they sent for some
of the soldiers to join their company, to drink
with them.
II. II I IM ■»■ I.M. I I ■ II I ■ ■ ■■ .1 I. 1,1 ■ II
• See Vol. XXII. of this Collection, p. 5«0,
noUj and the autherities there referred to,
15]
S8
Proeeeik^
[16
This is a clear charge of intent What had
thev to do with the soldiers^ if they were not
of their acquaintance ?
Sdly, They proposed to them to drink a
toast^ which, if not importing even a treason-
able mtenty certainly imported a most sedi-
tious and wicked wish, a^nst our most
gracious and beloved sovereign, a sovereign
not only exemplary to monarch^, but to pri-
vate men ; a wish ** that he might be the last
of his race/^ and at the same time adding
^ Damnation to all crowned heads.'' Can such
a wish be called the loose and thoughtless
expression of juvenile conviviality? or does
it not rather import a seditious speech, in-
tending to inspire disloyal sentiments into the
minds of the soldiers ?
Sdly, But the charge does not rest here,—-
interest is the serious aigument with mankind,
especiallv of the lower rsuik : the charge
states, that this was not overlooked. The
prisoners tell the soldiers their pay was too
amall — what b sixpence a day to a soldier?
You shall have hiener pay if you will join
with the friends of the people, or a club for
eauality and freedom? Friends of the people 1
what are friends of the people? Are the
people friendless ? The people, who are they ?
->-No doubt the common people — Is not this
a clear innuendo, that the common people are
friendless, have no friends but this club ? that
they are oppressed ; and joining tlus mth the
toast and the damnation, what is the inuendo ?
And who is held out as the oppressor ?
Then this club for ecjuality. — ^Tis a general
equality ! The absurdity and impossibilitv of
such an equality have been already described.
The club Tor freedom too ! as if we were not
free, as if we needed thb club to assert our free*
dom. Is there one here present who can name
a time when this nation had ever more freedom
than now ; had more security for life, liberty,
and property, than at this moment, or indeed
so much? The state of the nresent times,
both at home and abroad, is toe strong in*
eredient to. make the intent serious and manl-
iest. I am, therefore, clear upon the whole,
that the particular articles amount to the
crime stated in the general charge, viz. sedi-
tious speeches, tending to create disloyalty
and disaffection to his majesty, tmd to the
established government, and an attempt to
corrupt and seduce the militaiy from their
duty; and, therefore I concur m the inter-
locutor upon the relevancy that has been
proposed.
Lord Ahererwnhy observed, tlfot the words
as stated in the indictment, stripped of every
other circumstance^ were in themselves highly
wicked and seditious; and, that had the
panneisgone a little farther, they would have
been guuty of high treason.
Hislordshij) then adverted to the numerous
seditious meetings and associations in different
parts of the oounti^, and to the means that
had been every where so industriously em-
ployed by the members of such associatwns to
produce efiects similar to what had taken
place in a neighbouring kingdom-— effects
which his lordship characteriiseu as the roost
oppressive despotism. That when such at*
tempts were made, he thought it the indis-
pensable duty of his majesty's advocate to
oring to trial every person who had been
guilty^ of such seditious practices; and he
considered the conduct of the panels, as
appearing from the statement in the libel, as
of a very aggravated and seditious nature. ^
The lard Judiu CUrk^ after expressing
his entire concurrence in tiie sentiments de-
livered by all of their lordships, observed,
that it was no good defence to say, that the
words here spoken were mere verCa jactantia.
They were obviously of a most wicked and
seditious import; and no plea of rashness,
wantonness, oir conviviality could be admitted
as an excuse. His lordship illustrated this
by referring to the horrid crime of blasphemy,
where, though the words uttered could he
nothing else than mad or foolish in the
extreme, still they were impious and wicked,
and might, in certain circumstances be cog-
nizable, and severely punishable by a criminal
court.
The Court then pronounced the following
IVTEaLOCUTOR.
The lord justice clerk, and lords commis'
sioners of iusticiaiy, having considered the
criminal libel, raised and pursued at the in«
stance of his Buyesty's advocate, fot hisma-
jes^s interest, mmst John Morton, James
Anderson, and l^dcolm Craig, panels, with
the foregoing debate. They find the libel
relevant to infier the puns of law ; but allow
the panels, and each of them to prove all
facts and circumstances that may tend to
exculpate them, or alleviate their guilt: and
remit the panels with the libel, as found
relevant, lo the knowledge of an assize.
(Signed) Robt. M^Qvebu, J. P. D.
The following persons were then named,
to pass upon the assize of the panels.
William Lamb, upholsterer in Edinburgh.
David Tkomumf merchant there.
Thomas Brown, merchant there.
Alexawkr LMlaw, tin-plate worker there-
Andrew Boog, cuUer there.
James Banken, Wight, there.
Orlando Hart, shoe-maker tiiere.
John Fairbaim, bookseller there.
James Dewar^ cloth-merchant there.
Feter Hill, bookseller there.
Dand Rmnsay, printer there.
John Bell, bookseller there.
Jmnes Hunter, merchant there.
Thomas Reid, watch-maker there.
Alexander Anderson, merchant there.
Who were all lawAiUy sworn, and no ob*
jection on the contrai^.
The Drocurators ror the prosecutor, for
proof 01^ the Jibel, proceeded to adduce tiie
following witnesses^ who, being all lawfully
17)
JarSedUum:
sworn, purged of malice and parUal counsel,
enutted their depositions vha voeCy in pre-
sence of the Court and Jury, without
being fMluced ixM writing, in terms bf the
statute.
ist, HUmms Hume, corporal in the mn»-
dier company bf the 37 th regiment of foot,
deposed, That, on Sunday, the 18th Novem-
ber last, when sitting in the canteen, a sol-
dier of the name of liuxter called him, and
said, Uiere were some persons in king James's
room (this room is bn the opposite side of
the canteen) who wanted to see nim : That he
^tecordingly went there, where he saw eight
persons, amon^ whom were the prisoners:
Thai Anderson mimediately arose, and taldng
him by iht hand, said, ^ You are a clever
* fellow, and ought to join our club for free-
* dom uid hbei^/ Upon this he took some
^ver firom his pocket, and holding it out to
him, said, ' Your pay is very smaU— 4i<. a-
' day— what is that! Were you to join us
' you would have li. 6d. ardav/ That at thb
time they were drinkLog, and Anderson pro-
posed as a toast, ' George the third and last,
' and damnation to all crowned heads:' That
the others aJso joined in this, but he, the cor«
poral, refiised, and drank ^ Success to Geor^
'sd. vod all the roval family/ Upon this
Anoerson made a blow at him, which he
returned, and then went out of the room to
Captain Cameron, the senior officer then in
terison, whom he informed of what had
Sappened: That Captain Cameron desired
him to order the barrier- guard to let no per-
^n go out of the garrison without his ex-
press orders. Having done so, he returned
to the canteen, at which time the panels,
along with the other persons who were in
thiNr company, were coming through the
ismiare, when one, but he could not say which
of them, cried, Damn the Ring and the
Castle too.
Snd, Thomas Smiih^ drummer in the 37th
lament of foot.
Sid, Aluonder Sinmack^ soldier in the
97th re^ment.
4th, UUhael FUh^ soldier in the 37th
lecimentof foot
5lh', Jame$ Lawion, sofdier in the 37th
regiment of foot.
6th, Janut Erwin, soldier in the' S7th
regiment of foot.
7th, Captain Alexander Cameron^ of the
said S7th regiment of foot.
8th, Jame$ Girvane, journeyman hair-
dresser in Edinburgh.
9th; p^ffge Knoale$\ journeyman hair-?
dresser in Eoinburgh.
' It having been observed bv the Court, that
said George Knowles, the last witness, had
been c;uilty of gross prevarication upon oath ;
therefore the said lords grant warrant to
and ordain any of the macers of court, to
apprehend the said George Knowles, and to
commit him prisoner to the Tolbooth of
'Edinburgh, therein to be detained till Tues-
VOL. XXIII.
A. D. 179S. ili
day, the 99d day of January instant, and
then to be set at hber^.
(Signed) Robt. M^Qvbev, J. P. D,
lOth, Alexander RenteuL keeper of the
Lower Canteen, in the Castle of Edinburgh.*
The prosecutor being then about to adauce
witnesses for proving the declarations, the
panels judicially admit that the declara-
tions libelled on, were emitted by them res-'
pectively, voluntarily and freely, of the dates
they bear, and that they were at the time
sober, and in their sound senses.
(Signed) James Anderson.
John Morton.
Malcolm Craig.
Robt. M<Qusbv, J. P. D.
The declarations being then read over in
open court, his majesty^s advocate declared
that he closed his evidence.
On the part of the panels, several wit-,
nesses were called, some of whom said, they
did not recollect such toasts being drunk.'
Their evidence also went strongly to prove,
that the panels had no bad intention when
they went to the Castle; and it was pretty
clearly established, that one part of the com-
pany went for the purpose or seeing a young^
flrl, and to present ner with a breast-mn.
he girl's evidence was to this effect. 'Ihe^
other part of the company accounted for their
going to the Castle by showing, that it was*
in order to gratify their curiosity to see king
James's room. They also brought witnesses^
to prove, that they belonged to none of the
societies called the Friends of the People,'
and that theur characters were unimpeach-^
able.t
The following were the witnesses in ex-
culpation.
Ist, William Grierson^ apprentice to Mr.^
James M^ensie, goldsmith in Edinburgh.
Snd, Robert TAonuon, brush- maker, at the
brush manufactory in Edinburgh, carried on
by the representatives of the deceased Wil-
liam Muirhead, brushmaker in Edinburgh.
3rd, Thomas Huxter^ soldier in the 37th
regiment of foot.
4th, Janet M^Farlane^ servant to ensign
Frederick Rudolph Bruce, of the invafict
company, in the Castle of Edinburgh.
6tn, Catharine Laudowny alias Knowles^
wife of George Knowles, journeyman hair«
dresser in Edinburgh.
dth, Francis Rae, journeyman printer* in
the office of said Mundell and Son.
7th, James Scrymgemir, apprentice to the
said MundeU and Son.
»
* The above nine witnesses corroborated
the evidence of Hume; but I have not been
able to procure any account of their testi-
mony.
t Of the evidence adduced on behalf of
^tkt panels, I regret that I have not been
able to procure a better account than the
above. ^
C
m
SS GEORGB m. Proceedings against Join Morton and others [80
8th, Akxander Ctnfrae^ jotttiyymMt prio*
ter, m the office of Stewart, Rulhveiiy and
company, printers in Edinburgh.
0tn, Robert Btcnti» journevman printer,
in the office of the said Mund^l and Son.
10th, Thrnnat Russeltf foreman in the
office of the said Mundell and Son.
nth, Charles Statt^ journeyman printer,
in Edinbun^h.
ISth, Archibald Tod, foreman id the office
of Stewart Ruthven, and company, printers
in Edinburgh.
. 13th, Adam Dowie, printer in |lie office
of Murray and Cochran, printers in Edin-
burgh.
14th, James JRitfiven, printer in Edinburgh.
15th, TAomaf Itfurte, apprentice to Stewart
Buthven, and company, printers in Edin-
burgh.
The procurators for the panels thereupon
declarea^ that they closed their evidence in
exculpation.
The Lord Advocate, in a very eloquent and
impressive manner 'summed up the evidence
on the part of the Crown.
In the course of his speech, his lordship
took occasion to observe, * That with respect
* to the association denominated the Friends
* of the People, he found no fiiult with the
'name. . He, as bis fathers before him,
* always did, and would profess himself a
* Friend of the People, but that friendship
* could only be through the medium of the
* law and the constitution ; that in any other
' way, the real interests and happiness of the
^ people never could be promoted; and that
* any other person, who, by any other means,
* pretended to benefit the people, was, in
* place of being their friend, tneir grei^itest
* enemy.'
Mr. Wifht next addressed the Jury with
much abilitv and ingenuity on the part of the
panels, and stated every argument to take
•ffthe force of the evidence. He admitted
that the crime charged was of a very aggrSf-
▼ated and heinous nature; that he was no
friend to those associations denominated the
Friends of the People; that wi^ regard to
Paine's book, he never had read, nor evei
would read it, as he understood the doctrines
were equally absurd as seditious. He then
went into the merits of the proof, and en-
deavoured to show, that the panels could
have had no serious intention to create any
sedition, from the circumstances attendinja^
their conduct all along; and that the evi-
dence adduced on the mot of the prosecutor
was in several respects defective.
The Lord Justice Clerk charged the
jury, and stated with Kreat accuracy and
ability, the substance of the whole of the
evidence that had been adduced on both
aides.
The assize were tiien ordained to enclose,
and return their verdict next d^y at 11
o'clock.
Wednmday, m JoMWtry, 179$.
Intran,
John Morta»f «ppreQittce to Sjtewarl
Ruthven and company, printers in EdiQ*
bureh.
James Anderson, joivne;^man printer ^th
Mundell and Son, printers in Edinburgh; and
Malcolm Craig, also journeyman pnnter
with the said Mundell and Son, prinlcarQ ia
Edinburgh — ^Panels.
Indicted and accused as in the preceding
sederunts.
The persons who passed upon the assize
of the panels, returned the fi^wipg ver-
dict:
At Edinburgh, the M day of January, 1793.
The above assize having inclosed, made
choice of the said Orl^do Hart to be ^eir
chancellor, and of the said David Thomson
to be their clerk ; and having oonsideiBd the
criminal libel raised and pursued at the in-
stance of his m^esty's advocate for his ma-
jestv's interest against John Morton, J^SBita
Anderson, and Malcolm Craig, panels,
the interlocutor of relevancy pronounced
thereon by the Court, the evidence adduced
in proof of the indictment, aiyl evidence ad*-
duced in exculpation ; they all in oiie voacie
find the libel proven. In witness whereof
their said chancdlor and clerk have sub*
scribed these presents, consisting of this and
the preceding page, in their names and by
their appointment place and date foreeaid.
(Signed) Orlahdo Habt, cfaaneeUoTr
David Thomsoit, derk.
^ The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
sioners of justiciary, supersede consideration
of the forgoing verdict till Friday next at
eleven o'clock forenoon.
Friday, 11th January, 1793.
Jftfron, ^
John Morton, James Anderson, and Mal-
colm Craig, before designed.
Indjcteu and accu^ as in preceding
sederunts.
The verdict of Assise having been nead
over.
The Lord Justice Clerk mentioned, that last
night he had received a letter subscribed by
the prisoners, which, though addres^d to
him, was in fact addressed to the Court at
large. He therefore desired the clerk to read
it as follows :
My Lord Justice Clerk ;-— It is with a good
deal of coiicem we trouble your lordship upoa
thb occasion; thistine. however, to your
well known candour and love of justice, tnixed
with mercy, we beg to state to yogr lordship,
and to the other honourable judges, our pr^
sent bard &te; and we hope, upon an impar-
tial and &tr consideration of our case, you will
be inclined to pass a judgment as lenient as
may be consistent with justice and public
m
JB^M ^D^hJB^^m^^
A. D. 1798.
[se
irtili^. We do nM pietHid, nqrioid, to jo*,
tiiy oundves in oor oondoot^ ^ire know it hu
Imwb Iboiisb, and we hope wbsl ne hsve
alPMiTj imflrrnd tm Trmint nf it wilibsves
Mirteflect<m ourftttoie eoodoct^ Thew-
Sel of a juiy cf our fellow-citiaeiiBy hsi^ no
doidiL eottie out eg^unat usa this wm with
dieamfaieM sulnmt to^ is being the effect of
an institalioii tiie oMmt valuable we eiyoy as
British subjects; an instilotion which, as well
as M the oUier parts of our eioellent oonsti-
IntioDy we hope efsr to Tmerate and support.
Nothing, my lord, could have been more die*
treasing than being arraigned at your bar for
aoy disaffKlion to our sovereicn, or the coik
stitution of the countiy<— We nave uniformly
professed our attachment to the present con-
atitudon; and, as appeared pretty evident
Irom the psoof led at your bar, and which we
aokmnly declare to be the facL are connectsd
with no dub or society of Friends of tbe
I^eople, or any for refonn. We have, my
lord, great reason to reflect on the felly of
goinr to the Castle on the unfortunate day
Sat has been the cause of so much trouble to
the high court of justiciary, and the gentle-
men of the jury, as well as vexation to our-
sdhres, and an expense and loss of time that
we are veiy unable to support — We howev\^
dechcre, in the most solemn manner, and we
hope it was established satisfectorily by the
proof, that there was no intention en our
parts, of the crimes laid to our charge. — That
^mnds nnght have been used among us very
improper, considering the situation of the
coonliy and the place, we will not deny.
Our former imprisonment, and the expenses
jacurred, has oeen already no saaall punish-
ment on us : this, when considered in a cool
and delibenite wav, will, we hope, tend to in-
fluence your lordships in giving judgment.
We areyoune men, beginning die world, have
been fermeny guilty of no transgression
against the laws of our country ; are proven
to have been hitherto of most unexception-
able characters. We therefore hope, that all
dicumstances oon^dered, the purposes of
kotioe, as wen as public utili^, may be served
by a slight punishment.
We feel mnch for ourselves, and the feelings
of our aged parents and connexions would be
truly disUessmg should any ignominious pu-
nishment be inflicted : we confess we have
been guilly of a piece of gross folly, and flatter
oursehres that your lordship will be sensible,
that the situation of the countiy, makes it
more criminal than it would otherwise have
appeared.
Xhisting, therefore, to your lordship fbr all
the l^ty consbting with propriety, We are,
Your lordship's most devoted.
And very humble servants^
(Signed) Jaxss Akdxrson,
Malcolm Cbaxo,
Job* Moatov.
ToUmdhf Jan. .10 179^
P. 8. Our bail-bbiid was of small amount,
yet we did not fly our oountiy, but voluntarily
delivaed ourselves before your bar, yesterday
-morning. Befbre we appeared, we knew,
from the iutunation of our friends, that the
jury had found us guilty; yet we, trusting to
the mercy of the Court, stood forward ac-
oordinely.
Ad£essed,-*7%e Rigki Hon. tke Lord Jui*
tke Clerk.
After the letter was read, their lordships
proceeded to deliver their opinions with re-
gard to the punishment to be inflicted.
Lord Btnierland. My lords ;-— we are now
arrived at the most disagreeable and distres-
sing part of our duty, to pronounce sentence
upon these three young men, panels at the
bar, asainst whom the charge contained in
the indictment has been found proven by a
verdict of their country.
They have had a fair trial ; and in addition
to what your lordship was pleased to take
notice of'^ on the conduct or their counsel,
Mr. Wight, I will bes leave to say, that I
never heard a more wle or a more proper
charge made to any jury in behalf of a crimi-
nal. Nothing was omitted that could aid
them; every argument was forcibly, and
with becommg ix>ldness, urged, that could
weaken the force, or remove the effect of the
proofs brought against them ; every circum-
stance^ the slightest— laid hold of to render it
improbable, or alleviate their guilt ; but with
a dignity that became his high rank at Uie
bar, — ^with an indignation Uiat suited his
situation as a resnectable citizen, he exposed
and refuted the fallacy and fatal consequences
of those dogmas which have been publishe4,
or are supposed to have gone abroad, which
might tend to overturn our happy constitu-
tion, or shake our allegiance to our sovereign.
In shdrt, he has displayed the powers of an
able advocate, combmed with the duty of a
loyal subject
After all^ the crime has been found proven;
— a crime it is of most dangerous tendency :
— ^in the letter now read, the panels have
acknowledged the justice done by the re-
spectable jury; they have expressed contri-
tion for theis guilt; they deprecate punislv-
ment. — ^In certain circumstances and directed
to certain objects, I can have no doubt that
even an attempt to excite mutiny or sedi-
tion among soldiers, may be punishable with
death. It was so by the Roman law [1. i.Jfl
ad Leg. JuLMajJ^, It was so by the laws
of hiany nations m Europe. By the 12th of
queen Anne IBruu's MitUary Lawy tit, 9, f.
44], simple mutiny was made punishable by
an arbitrary punishment; but by an act iu
1715, it was again made punishable with
death. Mutiny, or an attempt to raise it,
amotmting to treason, mav still be punishable
as such. It is worth while to take notice,
that Bruce^ in giving an account, of the Mur-
tiny Act of queen .£tine^ as to soldiers be-
99]
dS GEORGE IIL ProceeJUtigi agatMa Mn Morion ^nd atk^ |9I(
vond seaSy saysy ^'Ni^, whosoever iMtn any
'mutinous or seditious words spoken, and
* does noty with all possible speed, reveal the
* same to his commanding omcer, is puniah-
* able with death.' Aim, by the present
Mutiny Act, concealment of it is pumshable
in the same way. Seditious persons, then, —
I mean flagitious and detestable men, mean-
ing to undermine the constitution^ — had need
to beware how they attempt the soldierv of
this country, steeled as the^r are by the love
of the constitution, and their loyalty to their
prince, and whose conduct is guaranteed by
auch severe function.
This author, who published so far back as
17 17, and whose works are of great authority,
and much resorted to by us in all geneiia
questions of this kind, proceeds in a passage
which I will take the liberty to read to your
lordships;— ^< By the foresaid Britbh articles^
' all officers and soldiers are strictly prohi-
' bited not to use any traitorous words ag^st
' the sacred person of his or her majesty,
' upon pain ot death ; — ^and according to the
' Dutch instructions, all cursing and reviling
* the states general, the council of state, or
' governors of provinces, is in the same man-
* ner punishable' [369^ 370].— Here are the
enactments of a republic on this subject ; and
what is still more remarkable, b^ the regula-
tions of this very republic, article 7, * all
' such as keep night conventicles or nightly
' meetings, &c. are made punishable as muti-
* neers,* IBrucc's Military low, p. 268]. What
shall we then say of invitmg soldiers to modem
and seditious associations ? — But permit me to
proceed inreadingour author.in theiUx>ve place
as applicable to all: ^ Ana indeed,' says be
* such expressions are fitly compared to the
* cutting of a razor,' (Psalm lviii.8.); so hence
it is that Solomon most sagely enjoms (Eccles.
X. ult.), * to forbear cursing the king even in
* our thoughts ;' for sure there is not a more
evident demonstration of a malevolent dispo-
sition of mind against prince or state, than
such reviling traitorous expressions. — The
traducing a government being, we know, the
prelude to the castms it off; mutinous and
seditious words the forlorn hope to rebelhon.
And though out of an affected ceremony, Uie
Roman emperors Arcadius and Honorius
refused to punish intemperate speeches, be-
cause, say they, * Si inde levitate processerint,
' contemnendum est; si ex insani&, misera-
' tione dignissimum ; si ob injuria remitten-
dum,' " — ^a text quoted by the ingenious gen-
tleman who elegantly and ablv opened the
panel's defence, — " yet it is obvious," pro-
ceeds our author '^ to any who have looked
into the lives of these two princes, that this
idle and unseasonable clemency turned to a
very sad account to iAem, the^ having run
more risk of forfeiting both their crown and
lives by the mutinies and rebellions than any
other of all the Roman emperors."
I ask pardon, my lords, for this digression.
I have been led into it by the novelty of the
t
caae, and the singular situation of the times*
To avoid it in future, I shall say nothiitg o^
these iUeffal associations that have been
formed, and of the foolish or nefiurious tenets
that have been sent abroad. But I am boun4
to take notice, that his majesty, by his royal
proclamation, has called upon us, in oommoa
with the o^er citizens, to watch over that
spirit of sedition which has been disseminated
by evil-designed and traitorous men within
the kingdom, and fomented by foreign ene-
mies from without; a measure which all
men must admit to have been cautious and
8alutary,-«>which frequent publications, and
appearances avowedly hostile to the constitu^
tion — ^which the records of this court by dif*
ferent proceedings within these few days*
establish to liave been wise and just : — and
we are called upon, I say, by that just recom-
mendation of duty, whilst we pronounce «
sentence strictly agreeable to law^ — ^the only
rule of our conduct,-— to apply it so as to answer,
the purpose so laudably brought under our
view. In the present instance, however, the
crime during the whole trial having been con-
udered only as the object of arbitrary punish^
ment, our choice must be much narrowed.
We can only choose one of three punish*
ments ; — either transportation to Botany-bay,
— ^banishment for seaition to Enjgland is out
of the question, — corporal punishment by
whipping and imprisonment, or imprison-
ment alone. Were the panels aged and
inveterate offenders, whom there were litUe
hopes to reclaim, — be they of what pro-
fession they may, the more literary tiie
fitter for such* punishment, — I should have
had no scruple to deprive them of the enjoys
ment of this happy constitution, agamst
which thev had offende<L and obliged them,
by hard labour in an infant colony to repair,
in some measure, the injury they had none
here. But it is a rule which a criminal judge
ought ever to have in view, ' Exemplar cum
^ severitate, personam cum misericordift, in-
' tuendam ;' to regard the crime with due
severity, to look on the criminal's person
with an eye of pity and commiseration. I
cannot, therefore, leave personal considerar
tions out of view. The panels are young;
their habits have been mdustrious, theur
former character peaceful. However on this
occasion infected by bad example, or seized
with political criminality, they have expressed
their contrition, they may be reclaimed. I
cannot, therefore, propose sending them to
Botany-bay. To punish them by whipping
abandons them to despair, and diseraces thei^
parents : one of them is a respectable citizen :
— ^My mind revolts at a punishment whicl^
banishes shame, and thereby precludes
amendment ; unless the subject be perfectly
depraved, or the severity indispensably ne-
cessary. Wishing, in this part of my duty, to
follow the example and embrace the senti-
ments pf our gracious sovereign, who ever
tempers justice with mercy, I wish to adopt
the punbhment of imprisonment alone*
m
Ar AkbMa«
A. D. 119S.
i»
Long impiisoBfde&ts ate luiml in our
ivfagKhoiiring ffountTy ; tbeir acGommodations
Sot it are great: — tbey are not usual here.
Bad there been, as there ought to have been«
a prison in the Castle of Edii^urgh, where
these young men mi^t have b^en kept,
untainted by other vice, 1 should have been for
it longer imprisonment. But to throw them
into theTolbooth of Edinburgh for a very long
time; to make them denizens, as it were, of
thai unhallowed place, which is the sink of
corruption^— -where every thing that is vicious,
base, and criminal are hudcued together, —
where, if th^ preserve their heaUh, they
cannot, in a long tract of time, escape the
conta^on of vice, and more sordid criminality,
— appears to me a measure which the necessity
of example upon such persons, in the present
instance does not absolutely require. We
are entitled to punish, we would wish to
amend, but we must avoid the means of
greater oonuption.
I would, therefore, with deference to your
lordships, propose, that the sentence or the
Court should be, to commit them prisoners to
the TolbootU of Edinburgh, therein to be
detained in close confinement, for the space
only of nine months from this date ; and that
they should be taken, bound each under the
penalty of one thousand merks, to behave in
an orderly and peaceable manner for the space
4>f three years thereafter ; and to be further so
confined, till they find such security, by close
ponfinemeot. I mean, that there shall be. no
xbeeting of associates, no gossiping or drun-
keMMS penaitted within their placte of eon«
iinement & that they may be left seriously and
solepmly to reflect on their past, and thereby
be enabled to amend their future conduct.
The other judges unanimously agreed tot
the sentence proposed by lord Henderland,
which was then recorded as follows :
The lord justice clerk and lords commis*
sioners of justiciary, having considered
the verdict of assize, dated the 8th, and
returned the 9th day of January current
against the said John Morton, Jamea
^derson, and Malcolm Craig, whereby
the assize all in one voice find the Hbel
proven;
The said lords in respect of the said ver«
diet, decern and adjudge the siud John Mor-
ton, James Anderson, and Makolm Craig, to
be carried from the bar back to the Tolbooth
of Edinburgh, therein to be detained for the
space of mne months from this date, and
tnereafter till they shall find sufficient cau-
tion and surety, acted in the books of ad-
journal for their good behaviour and keeping
the peace for the space of three years from the
date of the bail bond to be granted for that
efiect, and that under the penalty of one thou-
sand merks Scots for eacn person, and upon
the elapsing of the said nine months, and
finding caution as aforesaid, ordain them to be
set at liberty, and for these purposes the said
lords grant warrant to all proper officers of the
law.
(Signed) Robebt M^Qveev, J. P. D.
589. Proceedings in the High Court of Justiciary at Edinburgh^
against John Elder and William Stewart^ on an Indict-
ment charging them with Sedition^ January 10th: 33
George III. a. d. 1793.
I^^uria Justiciaria S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nova Sessionis dome de Edinburgh de-
dmo die Januarii, millesiroo septingente-
simo et nonogesimo tertio, per honor-
abiles viros Robertum Macqueen de Brax-
fidd, Dominum Justiciarium Clericum,
Alexandrum fidurray de Uenderland,
Davidem Rae de Eskgrove, Joannem
Swinton de Swinton, Dominum Guli-
elmumNaime de Dunsinan, Baronetum,
et Alexandrum Abercromby de Aber-
cromby, Domioos Commissionarios Jus-
ticiariie dicti S. D. N. Regis.
Curia legitime affinnata.
Intran,
John Elder, bookseller and stationer. North
Bridge Street, Edinburgh— Panel.
INDICTED and accused at the instance of
^hert Dundas^esq. of Arniston, his Majesty's
Advocate for his Miyesty's interest, for the
erime of Sedition and others in manner men-
tioned in the criminal libel raised against him
and William Stewart, merchant in Lcith
thereanent, bearing. That, whereas by the
laws, of this, and of every other well governed
reahn, the wickedly and feloniousl^r writing
or printing, or causing to be written, or
printed, any seditious Ubel, or writing: As
also the wickedly and feloniously making or
casting, or causing to be made or cast any
medal or medids bearing inscriptions of a se-
ditious tendency : As abo the wickedly and
feloniously distributing or circulating any
such seditious writing or libel when so print-
ed, and any such medal or medals as above
described, or the causins the said seditious
writing and the said medal or medals to be
distributed and circulated in di£ferent parts of
the country, are crimes of an heinous nature^
dangerous to the public peace, and severely
17J
SS GBORGB UL
Proceedugi lifMitf Jti* Eider and
c«
pamBbtble. Yet trat h it ioirf of rta^^
tiiat the said Wilfiam Stewart, aad John
Blder are both and each or one or other of
them, goil^ actorsy or art and part^ of all and
each or one or other of the foresaid crimes. In
ao ibr as upon one or other of the days of the
month of September one thousand seven
hundred and ninety^two, or of August pre-
ceding, or of October following, the said Wil-
liam Stewart and John Elder did both and
each, or one or other of them, somewhere in
Edinburgh or Leith, both in the coun^ of
Edinburgh, or at some other place t6 the
public prosecutor imknown, wickedly and
feloniously compose, or write, or cause to be
composed, or written, or at least did wickedly
and felomously cause to be printed a seditious
libel or writing intituled, ^ Rights of Man
delineated, and the Origin of Government,*'
whereof the tenor follows,
" DECLABATION
OF TBB RlOHTS OF MaN AHD OF CXTIIEKS,
Bt tHB National Assembly of France :
Which ts aobbeablb to Soitnd Reason and
Common Sense/'
'' I. Men are bom, and always continue, free
and equal in respect of their rights.
Civil distinctions, therefore, can be
founded only on public utility.
^ II. The end of all political associations
is the preservation of the natural and
unprescriptible rights of man ; and these
rignts are liberty, property, security, and
resistance of oppression.
^ III. The nation is essentially the source
ofallsbvereiffnty; nor can any iddivi-
dual, or any b(Ddv of men, be entitied to
any authonty, which is not expressly de-
rive4 from it.
** IV. Political liberty consists in the
power of doing whatever does not injure
another. The exercise of the natural
rights of ever^ man, has no other limits
than those which are necessary to secure
to every other man the free exercise of
the same rights ; and these limits are
determinable only by the law.
<< V. The law ought to prohibit only actions
hurtful to society. What is not prohi*
bited by the law, should not be hindered ;
nor should any one be comfMslled to that
which the law does not require.
^< VI. The law is an expression of the will
oftheoommunitjr. All citizens have a
rig^t to concur, either personalJy or by
their representatives, m its formation.
ItdiouldbethesMBieto'all, whether it
protects or punishes; and all beii^
Sual in its sight, are equally eligiMe to
honours, places, and employments,
according to their diiferent abilities with-
out any other distinction than that cr&*
ated by their virtues and talents.
^ Vil. No n)ui should be accused; arrest-
ei^ or held in coniiMwaetit, except in
eases determined by the law, and ac-
cording to the forma wfaidi it has pm-
cribed. AH who promote^ solicit, exe-
cute, or cause to be executed arbi-
trary orders, oUght to be punished, ted
every citizen caUed upon or i^pprehended
by virtue of the law ought immediMely
to obey, and reii4ers himsdf culpable by
resistance.
^ VIII. The law ousht to impose no o^r
penalties, but such as are absolutely and
evidenUy necessary; and no one oUriit
to be Dunished, but in virtue of a uiw
promulgated before the offence and le-
^ gfcUy^p'plied.
Everv man being presumed inno^
cent till he is convicted, whenever his
detention becomes indispensible, aJl
rigour to him, more than b neceisary
to secure his person, ought to be pro*
.vided against by the law.
^ X. No man ought to be molested on
account of his opinions; not even on
account of his religious opinions, pro-
vided his avowal of them ooes not dis-
turb the public order.
^ XI. The unrestrained communication of
thoughts and opinions being one of the
most precious nghts of man, every citi-
zen may speak, write, and publbh freely,
provided he is responsible for tbs abiM
of this liberty.
'< XII. A public force being necessary td
give security to the rights of men and
citizens, that force is mstituted for the
benefit of the community, and not for the
particular benefit of Uie persons wiUi
whom it is entrusted.
** Xin. A common contribution being ne-
cessary for the support of the public
force, and for defiraying the other expenses
of government, it ought to be divided
equally among the members of each com*
muhity according to their abilities.
'' XIV. Every citizen has a right, either by
hiihself or his representative, to a free
voice in determining the necessity of
public contributions, we appropriation of
them, and their amount, mode of assess-
ment, and duration.
'' XV. Every community has a ri^t to
demand of all its agents, an account of
their conduct.
** XVI. Every community in which a sepa-
ration of powers^ and a security of rights,
is not provided for, wants a constitution.
** XVII. The right to property being in-
violable and sacred, no one ousht to be
deprived of i^ except in cases oT evident
puolic necessity, legally ascertained, and
on condition of a previous just indem-
nity.
" Qti€re, Would not the people of every
nation in the world, by enjoying the
above rational principles, be in a happier
condition? They have but to insist oH
them, and they will get them.
W]
WUStm SUmHjbr Se^m^
A. 0. nw.
[30
^ Ibr a noHan to he/rt^ U is wuffident that
iiwi&sii:
a.
^ii u hui vdMMory to
ORIGIN OF GOVElKlCEirT.
€t
I. The nation is esfieatiaUy tl^ MM^oe of
all soviereigDty.
*< II. The right of altering the gpyerDmeDt
w a national rights aiM not a right of
govevmnent
** fil. The authority of the people is the
only authority on which government has
a r^t to eiiit in any countiy,
** IV. Govemment is nothing more than a
national association^ acting on the princi-
ples of society.
*' V. Government is not a trade, which
avyhodyofmeh has a right to set up,
fjud exercise for its own emoluipent, but
1$ altogether a trust from the people. It
WsoTitaelfno rights, they are altoge-
ther duties.
^Ineiveiyfieecounti7,the artist^ mecha-
jQic^anq labouiine maxiy has a right to
bsigain for his labour; and how is it
that in Britain, which if callod the land
of freedom, they are by laws deprived of
that natural rid^t? Why are they noit
M.(f^ to io»ke their own bargain as the
l^w-mafcers are to let their jrarms and
houses at what they deem their value ?
^ Tbe^^eatbody ofthe peopkalloyring these
laws to eiist, and that curse tQ liberty,
iicrBvss WAEBAKTS, at the caprice of go-
vcnunentto be issued, is tolerating the
malBst ri^its helongiog to n^flt^kind to
be violated and keptfrom them.
^ XbefirajtandjQohlest sentiments that ought
to be engraved on the hes,rt ofeyeiy son
of freedom should he»
EQUAL REPRESENTATION,
JUST TAXATION,
AND UBERTY OF CONSCIENCE ;
and the opposers of those just and equi-
table prinaplesy should he considered by
the people as tyrants, and ou^ht to be
Ifealed as such by them.
^ Isi a nation where the greatest body ofthe
people have no right or voice in choosing
tbctf representatives, and ane, at the same
lime, oiormously taxed,
** Querfif Are they not treated in every res-
pect as slaves or fools ? Even to be the
inhabitants of a oonquered country would
be as enviable a situation.
** Quo-Cf If a nation chooses a certain num-
ber of men to represent them for a fixed
noiod of years, suppose three, and that
iMdy, of their own will and accord, pro-
long their sittin^^ to double the number
of years for which thev were elected ;
bow fa can such conduct be constitu-
tional, or GOBsisteiit with common sense,
aQ4 4nb rigjbu of tbs peqyl^ who elected
ttiem?
'< Can the people of Scotland reflect without '
i^j: . ^jj the conduct of a certain-
particular]
tion was lately made for a reform in the
b— hs of 8 ■ d, and was reject^
by them with the greatest supercUity simI
Qontempt?
^ From the free-willaodaccordof such men,
the people of Britain have very littie
chance of getting their representation
extended on a more rational and equal
plan. Such a reform must be aocem*
plished by themselves."
Which seditious Ubel or writings the said
William Stewart and John i^lder, or one or
other of them, deliv^ ed to John IDisrling,
printer in Edinburgh, upon one or other of
the days of the month of September Sfore-
said^ or of August preceding, or October fol-
lowms, and employed him to print tiie same;
and he having accordingly done so, ^^
thrown off 3,000 copies, or thereby, of the
said writing, some or which copies were by
orders of the ssid William Stewart and John
Elder, or .of one or other pf them, put up in
packages, each containing several hundreds of
the said copies, and directed to different
booksellers m Glasgow, Paisley, Port-Ghu*
gow, and Aniftrutber ; ^d which said parcels,
t<^ther with a number of other lopse copies
or the said seditious hbel or writing having
been immediately, or soon thereafter, caniea
to the shop of the said John Elder, the said
Wiiham Stewart and John Elder did both
and each, or one or other of them, daring the
course of the month of September foresaid,
or of the mqnths of October, November, and
December following, wickedly and feloni«
ousl; distribute end circulate, or cause to be
distributed and circulated, a number of copies
ofthe svd seditious writing among the inhap
bitants of the city of Edinburgh and its vi«
cinity; and the said William Stewart and
John Elder, or one or other of them, aid also^
some time in the course of the mmiths of
September, or October, November and De«
cember foresaid, transmit, or cause to be
transmitted to different booksellers in Glas-
gow, Paisley, Port-Glasgow, add Anstruther,
to be there di^buted and circulated, several
hundred copies of the s«d seditious writing
contained m the different packages above-
mentioned/ And further, the said WiUiam
Stewart and John Elder, or one or other of
th^ra, did, some time in the month of Sep-
tember last, seventeen hundred and ninety-
two, or of the Hionth of August, preceding, or
of October following, wickedly and feloniously
compose or write, or cause to be composed
or written, somewhere in Edinburgh or Leith
aforesaid, or some other place to the public
prosecutor unknown, inscriptions for medals,
of the/ollowingtenor. — * Liberty,Equality,and
' an end to Ingress Warrants/ * The Nation
SI]
SS 6E0R6& IIL Pf^ceeibigs agahd Jokk Elder and
Z9i'
< is esaeiltiany the Source of all Soverdgnty/
* liberty of conscience, Equal Representation^
* and Jnst Taxation/ * For a nation to be free
* it is sufficient that it wills it.' Which in-
scriptions being obviously calculated to stir
up a spirit of insurrection and opposition to
th<f established government, the said persons
above complained upon or one or other of
Ibeoiy did sometime in the said month of
September last, or of August preceding, or
October following, put into the hands of
James Bell, tinman, or white iron smith in
Leith, and did employ him to cast and throw
off several thousands of the said medals
bearing the said inscriptions ; which he having
done accordingly, ana delivered to or causea
lEt> be delivered to the saids William Stewart
and John £lder, or one or other of them,
they did, both and each, or one or other of
^m, upon one or other of the days of the
said months of August, September, or Octo-
ber aforesaid, wickedly and feloniously distri-
bute and circulate, or cause to be distributed
and circulated, amone the inhabitants of the
city of Edinburgh and its vicinity, and in dif-
ferent parts of the country several hundreds
of the said medals, bearing the said inscrip-
tions: particularly the said William Stewart
and Jonn Elder, or one or other of them, did
some time during the course of the months
foresaid, transmit, or cause to be transmitted
to difierent persons in Glasgow, Paisley,
Port-Glasgow, and Anstruther, several hun-
dreds of the foresaid medals bearing the said
inscriptions. And tlie daid William Stewart
having upon the twentieth and twenty-first
days of December, one thousand seven hun-
dred and ninety- two, been brought before
''ohn Pringle, esq. our sheriff depute of the
eounty of Edinburgh, he did in his presence,
emit and sign two separate declarations of
the respective dates aforesaid : And the said
John Elder having been upon the nineteenth
day of December, seventeen hundred and
ninety-two, brought before the said John
Pringle, esa., he did, in his presence emit
and sign a aedaration ; which three declara-
tions: together with a printed copy of the se-
ditious writing, printed and circulated as
aforesaid, intituled ' Rights of Man deline-
^ated;' and * the Origin of Government;*
and subscribed by the said William Stewart,
and John Elder, and others ; and two of the
medals cast, circulated, and distributed, as
aforesaid, upon one of which is inscribed on
the one side, * liberty, Equality, and an end
* to Impress Warrants ;' and on the reverse,
^ the Nation is essentially the Source of all
* Sovereignty;' and upon the other, ' liber^of
* conscience. Equal Representation, and Just
* Taxation ;' and on the reverse ' for a nation
'to be firee, it is sufficient that it wills it,' will
aU be used in evidence against the said Wil-
liam Stewart and John Elder, and will for
that puroose be lodged in due time with the
clerk of^ the high court of justiciary, before
which they are to be tried, that they may
have an opportunity of seeing the same.
And ftirther the said William Stewart and
John Elder, are desired to take notice, that
five letters will also be produced and used hi
evidence against them. The first addressed
to William Stewart, esq., Leith, dated * Edin-
* burgh, 80th September, 1799,' and bearing
to be signed ^ J. Campbell.' The second is
addressed to the said William Stewart, esq.,
merchant, Leith, bearing to be dated ' Glas-
* gow, isfth September, 1799 ;' and to be
signed ^ A. Campbell, secretary to the com-
' mittee.' The third addressed to * Mr. John
^ Dariing,printer,Advocates-closc,Edinburgh,*
without date or subscription. The fourth
addressed * Mr. Elder, bookseller. Bridge,
' Edinburgh ;' dated * Leith, S4th September,
* 1792,' and signed * William Stewart.* The
fifth addressed * Mr. Elder, bookseller, Bridg^,
* Edinburgh ;' dated < Leith, 25th September,
' 1792,' and signed, « W. Stewart.' Ail which
letters will in due time be lodjged with the
clerk of the high court of justiciary, before
which the said persons above complained on
are to be tried, that they may have an oppor-
tunity of seeing the ssime. ^ At least times
and places foresaid, the said wicked and se-
ditious libels or writings, were written^
printed, published, and circulated as aforesud ;
and the said roediUs, bearing the inscriptions
aforesaid, were cast off and distributed as
aforesaid ; and the said William Stewart and
John Elder, are both and each, or one or
other of them, guilty actors or art and part bf
all and each, or one or other of the foreuid
crimes. All which, or part thereof b^ng
found proven by the verdict of an assize, be-
fore our lord justice general, lord justice clerk^
and lords commissioners of justiciary, in a
court of justiciary to be holden by thetn
within the criminal court house of Edinbergh,
upon the tenth day of January next, tiie 'said
w illiam Stewart and John Elder ought to be
punished with the pains of law^ to deter
others fiom oommitting the like crimes in all
time coming.
And the said WjUliam Stewart being oft'
times called in court, and three times at the
door of the court house, he failed to appear.
Whereupon hfs majesty's advocate moved
the Coiut that sentence of fugitation nugiht
be pronounced aeainst him, and as he &d
found caution ifbr his appeanince in the she-
riff court books of Edinburgh, craved that the
bond of caution might be forfeited, and the
penalty therein contained, recovered.
The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
sioners of justiciary deoem and adjudge the
said William Stewart to be an outlaw and a
fugitive from his majesty's laws, and ordain
him to be put to his highness's horn ; and all
his moveable goods and gear to be escheat
and inbrought to his migesty's use for his
contempt and disobedience in not appearing
this day and place in the hour of eause to
have underlyen the law for the crimes of se-
dition and others specified in the wM crimi*
WSSam Simoftfar Se^ion*
SSI
ml leHen KlMd aainsi hiiB tfaereaaent as
he wbD !««» law/ill^ dted to that effect, and
oftSimes called in ccMurt, and three times at
the door of the court bouse, and &Uing to
appearas said is; and ordain the bond of caution
ffranted for the appearance of the said WiX-
turn Stewart in tne sheriff court books 4>f
Edinburgh, to be forfeited and the penalty
tberein ooDlaiiied to be recovered by the clerk
of this court to be disposed of as the court
shall direct.
(Signed) BoBsax M'Qussn, I. P. D,
Thereafter his majest^r's advocate repre-
aented that he was determined to use every
endeavour to apprehend the person of the
nid William Stewart and still to bring him to
trial along with the panel Elder, and with
tlMt view he was under the necessity of
moving tb«r lordships for a continuation
a^unst the panel to some distant day, be-
twixt and wnich he would use every effort
to brii^ Stewart to their lordships bar.
llie lord justice clerk and lords conmus-
A. D. 179S.
[M
sionera of justiciarjrf continue the diet at the
instance of his majesty's advocate for his ma*
jesty's interest, against John Elder, book*
seller and stationer, Nortii Bridge-street,
Edinburgh, till Mondav the 11th day of Fe-
bruary next, at ten o'clock forenoon, in thjs
place ; ordain parties, witnesses, assizers, and
all concerned then to attend each under the
pains of law.
iUh Febtuarv, 1793.
Diet continued against Elder, till Monday,
the 85th day of February instant.
^SthFebruarv, 17 93.
Diet continued against £ldei( tiUMondayi
the 11th day of March next, at ten o'clock
forenoon.
iUh March, 1793.
Whole diets of court continued till Monday,
the 18th day of March instant.
There does not appear on record any fur-^
ther continuation, or procedure against Elder*
590. Proceedings in the High Court of Justiciary at Edinburgh^
against James Smith and John Mennons^ on an Indict*
meat charging them with Sedition^ February 4th : 33
Geobgb III. A. D. 1793«
Curia Jtistidaria S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nora Sessionis domo de Edinburgh,
quarto die Februarii, mlllesimo septin-
eentesimo et nonogesimo tertio, per
nonorabiles viros Robertum Macqueen
de Braxfield, Dominum Justiciarium
Clericum, Alexandrum Murray de Hen-
derknd, Davidem Rae de £8kg|roTe,
Joannem Swinton de Swinton, Dominum
Gnliehnum Naime de Dunsinnan, baro-
netum, et Alexandrum Abercromby de
Abercromby, Dominos Commissiona-
lios' Justicisiriae dicti S. D. N. Regis.
Curia legitime affirmata.
Jn$ran,
John Menmaiu, printer in Glasgow**Panel.
INDICTED and accused at the instance of
Robert Dnndas, esquire, of Amiston, his ma-
jefty'a advocate, for his majesty's interest,
ibr the crime of printing and publnhing a
fleditioas paper or writine, in manner men-
tiooed in the criminal libel raised against
him thereanent; bearing, that albeit by the
Jftws of this realm, the wickedly and'felo-
nkrasly composing; and writing, or the wick-
edJy and feloniously printing and publishing,
or the wickedly and relomousl^ causing to be
composed and written, or prmted aira pub-
Balied, any seditious paper or writing, tending
S» create ftspirit of disagoction to us, and of
VOL. xxm.
discontent witli the present excellent consti-
tution of our kingdom, and to excite tumults
and disorders therein, or which publicly ex-
press approbation of works of a seditious and
mflammatory nature, — more especially when
the practical use of these writings arc ex-
pressly recommended to the coimnunityj —
are crimes of an heinous nature, subversive
of order and good government, and severely
punishable: Yet true it is, and of verity,
That the said James Smith, and John Men-
nons, have both and each, or one or other of
them, presumed to commit, and arc guilty,
actors or art and part, of all and each, or of
one or other of the said primes ap;gravated as
aforesaid : In so far as upon Thursday, the
twenty second day of November lasl^ or
upon one or other of the days of that month,
or of October preceding, or of December fol-
lowing, a roeetine of the inhabitants of the
Village of Partick, in the parish of Govan,
and county of I^nark, having been called by
b^t of drum, to assemble that evening at
the house of Allan Craig, innkeeper there, a
nutnber of pe6ple did assemble accordingly;
and' when so assembled, they thought proper
to form themselves into a club or association
to ineet weekly therestfter, under the deno-
mination of * The Sons of Liberty, and the
^ Friends of Man,' — in order to bring about a
reform in parliament, and a redress of sup-
posed grievaacea in our present exceUent
. D
^] S3 GEOttGl: tIL Procuimp agatiH Jinm SmM and [98
coiksUtution; that of this association. John
Auchindoss^ saddletree-maker in rartick,
was elected president^ John Gibson, appren-
tice to David Kessock, linen printer at Mea-
dowside, contiguous to Partick aforesaid,
Tice'presidenty and Peter Hart, apprentice
or print cutter with the said David Kessock,
secretary, for the evening; in which respective
capacities the V officiated aocordingljr:-— -That
the meeting oeing thus constitute, the said
James Smith did produce a paper containing
resolutions, which he proposea should be by
them adopted; and which resolutions be hai
some davs before wickedly and feloniously
composed and written for that purpose:
That these resolutions were accordingly, with
some small variations^ adopted by the meet-
ing^ and were transcribed by the said James
Smith, in their presence, and signed by their
presidMit, vice-president^ and secretary ; which
resolutions, as also a preamble to them, like-
wise written out b^ the said James Smith in
presence of the roresaid meeting, are of the
fbliowing tenor:
'' FaHkK Naoember S3, 1799.
'^ The inhabitants of the village of Par-
tick, and its neighbourhood, animated
with a just indignation at the honour of
their town being stained, by the erec-
tion of a Burkified society, have formed
themselves into an .association, under
the name of the Sons of liboty, and
the Friends of Man. — At this meeting,
from its number, equally hopeful to the
people, as formidaoie to the tools of
tyrants, the followins resolutions were
unanimously, adopted: 1st, That the
society do stand forward in defence of
the Rjghts of Man, and co-operate with
the respectable assemblage of the Friends
of the People in Glasgow, and with the
innumerable host of reform associations
in Scotland, England, and Ireland, for
the glorious purpose of vindicating the
native rights of man, liberty, with a fair,
full, free, and equal representation of the
people m parhament. dnd. That the
Sons of libertv in Partick, having atten-
tively perused the whole works of the
ImmortEil author of the Righti of Man^
Thoh AS Paike, declare it as their opi-
nion, that if nations would adopt tne
practical use of those woika^ tyrants and
their satellites, would vanish like the
morning mist before the rising sun!
that social comfort, plenty, good order,
peace, and joy, would dinuse their be-
nign influence over the human race.
John Auchikcloss, President.
John Gibson, Vice-President
PsTBR Hart^ Secretary.'^
And the sud James Smith, after having
prevailed upon the meeting to adopt these
resolutions, with the preamble above-men-
tioned, likewise proposed that directions
should be given lo nave tfaem insertied in one
of the Gtesgew newspapers, which wAI done
accordingly; the said resolutiona wiifch tha
preamble above-mentkmed, having been by
general consent carried by one or other of
the meeting, or by some eiher person or per-i
sons to the public pfosecutor unknown^ td
the printing-house ot the said John Mennona
in the town of Glasgow aforesaid, were, after
being revised by him, inserted in thenewspapef
called the Glasgow Advertiser, and Evening
Intelligencer, No. 730, from Monday, Nov»
19th, to Friday, November 93xd, and five
hundred copies or thereb^r of the said paper,
containing the said resolutions, with the pre-
amble above-mentioned, in the form 4>r an
advertisement, were printed ofif, and sold or
distributed by the said John Mennons. And
the said James Smith having, on the aightli
day of December last, been broueht before
William Honyman. esquire, fiierin depute of
Lanarkshire, did then in his presence emit
a declaration tending to show his guilt in the
premisses; Which declaration is subscribed
by the said James Smith, and the said Wil*
liam Honyman: and the said John Mennons,
having, on the said eighth day of December
last, been brought before the said William
Honyman, esquire, did likewise emit a decla«
ration in bis presence^ also tending to shew
his guilt in the pi«mis8es; which oedanlioii
is likewise subscribed by the said John Men-
nons, and William Honyman, esquire, said
both which declarations, togetii^ urith the
manuscript copy of ^e above-mentioned re-
solutions, as written bv the said James '
Smith, and snbscribed by the said Johii
Auchindoss. John Gibson, and Peter Hart,
together witn the preamble above-mentioned^
also written by the said J^mes Smith, with
the libellous and seditious book or publica-
tion hitituled, '' Paine's Whole Works,? (to
which the above resolutions expressly refer)
containing the following passages :
(Pamphfet, intituled Common Sense, p. 19.)
^ Government by kinss was first intro-
duced into the world by the heal^ens^
from whom the children of Israel
copied the custom. It was the pnost
prosperous invention the devil ever set
on toot for the promotion of idolatry.
The heathens paid divine honours to
their deceased Kings, and the christian
world hath improved on the plan, by
doing the same to their living ones.
How impious is the title of Sacred Ma*
jesty, applied to a worm, who, in the
midst of nis splendor, is crumbling into
dust I As thiB exaking one man 8&
{greatly above the rest cannot ba jush;
tified on the equal rights of nature, so
neither can it be defended on tho
authority of Scriptuie; for the will oC
the Almighty, as declared by Gideoia
and the Prophet Samuel, expressly dis«»
approves of government by kings. (p«
13.) Monardiy is ranked in Scriplureir
as . ono of the sins of tlM Jews^ foo
ar]
«Mki MenMomJbr SedHiotu
A. IX n98.
[38
nfhkhaeme ia tesenre is demmiiced
(Pswe 800
^ In short BKmHGiiy and aueeesnon hsve
kid not this or tlMt kingdom onl^, but
Ihe worid) in blood and ashes; it is a
§oaa of gD^ramment which the word of
€k>d beusteslimoDy against, and blood
wiUallendit
(Page «l.)
^Wby is the constitution of Enriand
sid4y» but beoaase monarchy nath
poiaooed the vepublic; the Crown hath
cnproaaed 'the Common&r<»In £ng-
hundy a long hath little more to do than
to make war^ and give awaj places;
which in ]^lain tenns is, to impoverish
the na^^on, and let it toother by the
cafa«— A pretty business mdeed, for a
snaQ ts be albwed eight hundred thou-
sand pounds steriing aryear for^ and
worshipped into the bargain—^ more
worth IS one honest man to society^ and
in the sight of God, than all the crownM
saffians that ever lived,
(P^ S7.)
^ But wbercL sav some, is the king of Ame*
lica? IvriUtdyou^fnendyhereignsabove,
and does not make havoc of mankind
like the Toysl tyrant of Britain.
(Bicdbts <i Man, part 1st p. 39.)
Many filings in the English government ap-
pear to me the reversoDf what they ouent
tobe»andofwhattheyaresaidtobe. The
parliament^ imperfectly and capriciously
eieeted as it u, is nevertheless supposed
to hoU the nalioiial purse in trust for
the nation; but in the manner in which
an Knglish parliament is constructed, it
• i» like * man being both mortgager and
moitgigee; and in the case of misappli-
^€tAon of trust, it is the criminal sitUng
in judgpwaent upon himself. If those
who vole the supplies are the same
persons who recnve the supplies when
voted, and are to acoount for the eipen-
^ture ef the supplies to those who voted
them, it ia themselves accountable to
themsslycs; and the Comedy of Errors
conchidea with the Pantomime of Hush,
--^either the mimsterial party nor the
eppositioa will touch upon this case;
the natlnnal purse is the coimnon hack
wtiich each mounts upon ; it is like what
the country people odl ride and ti»-*
You ride a litOe way, and then I.
(Ptge78.>
^ Ikey seder these things better in ¥Wmbe.
What aie the present governments in
Xarope but a seeoe of iniquity and
«ppn»sioB? What is that of England?^
de not its own inhabitants sa}r it is a
maiieet where eveiysaanhas his price,
end wiMre eonuptioa is common traffic
at tiMexpease or a deluded peopled No
wondsiv then^ thit the Iniiflh nvelution
•~
(P^5e79.)
'* Adnutting that government is a con*
trivance of human vnsdom, it must
necessarily follow that hereditary suc-
cession and hereditary rights (as they
are called) can make no part of it;
because it is impossible to make wisdom
hereditary; and, on the other hand^
that cannot be a wise contrivance
which, in its operation, may commit Uie
government of a nation, to the wisdom
of an ididt. The ground which Mr.
Burke now takes is fatal to every part
of his cause. The argument changes
from hereditary rights to hereditary
wisdom; and the question is, who is the
wisest man? He must now show that
eveij one in the line of hereditary suo»
eession was a Solomon, or bis title is not
flood to be a king. What a stroke haa
Mr. Burke DOW made ! To use a sulor's
phrase, he has swabbed the deck, and
scarcely left a name k^ble in the Ust of
kings; and he has mowed down and
thinned the House of Peers with a scythe
as formidable as death and time.
(Page 83.)
'^ When Mr. Burke says that his majesty's
heirs and successors^ each in their time
end order, will come to the crown irith the
same contempt of their choice, with which
his miQesty nas succeeded to that he
wears, it is saying too much even to the
humblest individual in the country, part
of whose daily labour goes to making
up the million sterling a-year, which the
country gives the person it styles a king.
Government with insolence is despotism ;
but when contempt is added, it becomes
y$fone; and to pay for contempt, is the
eicess of slavoy. This speaes of go-
vernment comes from Germaoy, and
reminds me of what one of the Bnins>
wick soldiers told me, who was taken
prisoner by the Americans in the late
war : ^ Ah !' said he, ' America is e fine
free country; it is worth the people's
fighting for; I know the difference, bjr
knowing my own. In my countiy, if
tiie prince says, eat straw, we eat stmw !'
God help tbat country, thought I, be it
England or elsewhere, whoM liberties
are to be protected by G^hnan principles
of govemoient, snd princes of Brunswick.
(Page 90.)
^ The English may wbh^ as I believe they
do, success to the pnnciples of liberty
in France or in Germany; but a German
elector trembles for the fate of despotism
in his electorate; and the duchy of
Mecklenburg, where the present queen's
fomily eovems^ is under the same
'Wretched stale of arbitrary powei^ and
the people in a slavish vaswlage*
<Pa«8 85.)
^ But tiie second need, that of a aatbis
estsWishing ikjMtfticuhr iaaily withfaes»»
»3
55 6E0R6B IIL Proceedings againa James SmiH and
[40
ditaiy powers, does not present itself as
despotism on the first reflection ; but .if
. men will permit a second reflection to
take place, and carry that reflection for-^
ward but one remove out of their own
persons to that ot their offspring, they
will the^ see thut hereditary succession
becomea in its consequences the same
despotism to 'Others, which they repro-
bate it for themselves.
(Page 86.)
^It operates to preclude the consent of
the succeeding generation ; and the pre-
clusion of consentis deS[K>tisro. Wnen
the person who at any time shall be in
possession of a government, or those
who stand in succession to him, shall
fiay to a nation, I hold this power in
contempt of you, it signifies not upon
what authority he pretends to say it.
It is no relief, but an aggravation, to a
person in slavery to reflect that he was
sold by his parent; and as that which
heightens the criminality of an act can-
|iot be produced to prove the legality of
it, hereditary succession cannot l^ estab*
lished as a legal thing.
(Part 3. p. 30.)
<' All hereditary government is in its na^
ture tyranny. An heritable crown, or
an heritable throne, or by what other
fanciful name such things may be called,
have no other significant eiplanation
than that mankind are heritable pro-
perty. To inherit a government is to
inherit the people as ii they were flocks
ilnd herds.*
(Page 63.)
'' Monarchy would not have continued so
many ages in the world, had it not been
fDr the abuses it protects. It is the
master fraud which shelters all others,
by admitting a participation of the spoil
it makes itself friends; and when it
ceases to do this, it will cease to be the
idol of courtiers.
rPageSl.)
** The act callea the Bill of Rights comes
here into view ; what is it but a bargain
which the parts of the government made
with each other, to divide powers, pro-
fits, and privileges ? You shall have so
much, and 1 will have the rest; and with
respect to the nation, it .aaid, for your
share you shall have the right of peti-
tioningi 'This being the case, the Bill
of Rights is more properly a bill of
wrongs and of insult. As to what is
called the Convention Parliament, it
• was a thing that made itself, and then
made the authority by which it acted.
A fe\i^ persons got together, and called
■> tjiemselves by that name. Several of
* These are some of the passages on which
tiie iaformatioB afiainst Paine was fouoded ;
p^ bispase^ antfi, Vol, 32, p. i07^ etseg.^
them had never .been dected, and tione
of them for the purpoee.-^rom the time
of William, a species of government
arose, issuing out of this coalition bill of
rights, and more so since the oorraptioa
introduced at the Hanover sucoession
by the agency of Walpole, that can be
described by no other name than des-
potic legislation. Thoueh the parts may
embarrass each other, the whole has no
boimds; and the only right it acknow-
led^ out of itself is the right of peti-
tioning. Where, then, is the constitu*
tion either that gives or that restrains
power? It is not because a part of the
government is elective tiiat makes it
less a despotism, if tiie persons jo elected
possess afterwards, as a parliament, un*
limited powers; election, in this case,
becomes separated from representation;
and the candidates cire caodidatea for
fiespotism.*
(Page 64.)
^ The attention of the government of Eng-
land (for J rather choose to call it by this
name than the English eoverorocnQ ap-
pears, since its potitical connexion wttii
Germany, to have been so completelf
engrossed and absorbed by foreign aj*
fairs, and the means of raising taxes» that
it seems to exist for no other purpose.
■ Domestic concerns are neglected; mid
with respect to regular law, there is scar*
cely such a thing.*
(Page 58.)
*' With respect to the two Houses of which
the English parliament is composed they
appear to be eflfectually influenced into
one, and, as a legislature, to have no
temper of its own. The minister, who-
ever he at any time may be, touches it as
with an opium wand, and it sleeps obe-
dience. But« if we look at the distinct
abilities of the two Houses, tiie diflerence
will appear so great as to show the incon-
sistency of placing power where there
can be no certainty of the judgment to
use it. Wretched as the state of repre-
sentation is in England, it is. manhood
compared with what is odled the House
of Lords; and so little is this nickname
House regarded, that the people scarcelv
inquire at any time what it is doing. It
appears also to be most under influence,
and the farthest removed from the gene-
ral interest of the naUon,*
• (Page, 88 )
^Having thus glanced at some of the de«
fects of the two Houses of Parliament, I
proceed to what is called the Crown, upon
which I shall be very concise. It signi*
fies a nominal office of a million sterling
e year, the business of which consists in
receiving the money ; whether the per-
son be wise or foolibb, sane or insane, a
Dative or a foreigner, mattMB not Every
ministry acts upon the aame idei^ that
411
Jcim Menmmijor Sedition.
A. D. 17dS.
[42
Mr. Burke writes^ nam^yy that the peo-
ple must be hoodwinked^ and held iu su-
pentitious ignonmce br some bugbear or
ether ; and what is called the Crown an-
swers this purpose; andthereibre an-
swers all the purposes to be eiipected from
it. This is more than can be said of the
other two branches. The hazard to which
this ofioe is exposed in all countries, is
not from any thing that can happen to
the man, but from what may happen to
the iiation«-the danger of its coming to
its senses.*
(Page iS5.)
• M The fraud, hyprocrisy, and imposition of
goverument are now beginning to be too
well understood to promise them anv long.
career. The farce of monarchy and aris-
tocracy in all countries is following that
ofchivahy; and Mr. Burke is dressing
lor the funeral. Let it then pass quietly
to the tomb of all other follies, and the
mourners be comforted. The time is not
very distant when England will laugh
at itself for sendins to Holland, Hanover,
Slell, or Brunswick, for men at the ex-
pense of a million a year, who understood
petthcr her laws, her language, nor her
interest, and whose capacities would
acaccely have fitted them for the office
of a parish constable. If government
could DC trusted to such hands, it must be
some easy and simple thing indeed ; and
materials fit for all the purposes may be
found in eveiy town ana village in £ng-
]and.*«
(Part 3nd, Page 68 )
** From a small spark kindled in America,
a fiame has risen not to be extinguished ;
without consuming, like the uUtma ratio
regumy it winds its progress from nation to
nation, and conouers by a silent opera-
tioD. Man finds himself changed, he
scarcely perceives how. He acquires a
Jknowledge of his rights, by atteuding
justly to his interest ; and discovers, in
the event, that the streneth and powers
of despotism consist wholly in the fear of
resisting it; and that, in order to be
£ree, it is sufficient that he wills it.
(Part 1st, Page. 106).
** When we survev the wretched condi-
tion of man under the monarchical and
bereditary svstem of government, drag*
ged firom his hbme by one power,
or driven by another, impoverished by
taxes more' than by enemies, it be-
comes evident that those systems are
bad, and that a general revolution in the
principle atid construction of governments
IS necessary."
Aa also other passages, of a tendency
cqaaUy seditious and infiammaloiy, tonther
wnih the newspaper called ** the Outwnr
Advertiser andEveDii^ Intelligencer, from
Honday, Novefsber lOtb; to Iwkf Noiram-
her 93d, ir99 (No. 730) :" bdng all to be
used in evidence against the said James Smith
and John Mennons respectively upon their
trial, will, for that purpose, in cfue time, be
lodged in the hands of the clerk of the high
court of Justiciary, before which they are to oe
tried, that they may have an opportunity of
seeing the samt;. At least, times and puu:es
aforesaid, the said seditious paper or writing
was wickedly and feloniously composed, writ-
ten, printed and published, and an approbation
of the seditious and inflammatory writings of
the above-mentioned Thomas Paine was
publicly expressed, and the practical use of
them expressly recommended to the commu*
nity : And the said James Smith and John
Mennons are both and each, or one or other
of them, guilty actors, or art and part thereof.
All which, or part thereof, being found proved
by the verdict of an assize, before our lord
justice general, lord justice clerk, and lords
commissioners of justiciary, in a court of justi-
ciary to be holden by them within the criminal
court house of £dinDurgb, upon the fourth day
of February next, the said James Smith and
John Mennons ought to be punished with the
pains of law, to detor others from committing
the like crimes iu all time coming.
And James Smith, gunsmith in Gorbals of
Glasgow, likewise indicted in the said crimi-
nal letters being ofltimes called in court, and
three times at the door of the court house, bj
a macer of court as use is, he failed to appear:
whereupon his miyesty's advocate moved, that
sentence of fiigitation and outlawry, might
be pronounced against him.
The lord justice clerk and lords commis*
sionert of justiciary decern and adjudge the
said James Smith to bean outlaw ana fugitive
from his majesty's laws, and ordain him to be
put to his inghpess's horn ; and all his move-
able eoods and gear to be escheat and in-
brought to his mi^csty*s use, for hb contempt
and aisobedience m not appearing this day
and place m the hour of cause, to &ve under-
lyen the law for the crimes specified in the said
criminal letters, as he who was lawfully cited
to that effect ofttimes called in court and
three times at the door of the court house, and
filling to appear as said is; and ordain the bail
bond eranted for his appearance tp be forfeited^
and the penalty therein contained to be re«
covered oy the clerk ofthis court to be dis-
posed of as the court shall direct*
(Signed) RoaaaT M^Hvubm^ L P. P.
Thereafter his majesty's advocate repre-
sented that it was his wish that the panel
and Smithy the person nowfudtated soould
stand trial together, and as ttiere was still
a prospect ofapprehending Smith and bringiBg
him to trial, he would move their lordships for
an adjournment against the panel for a fort-
night.—(}ontmued till Monday the 18th Feb*
ruaiy instant.
. SIo fiirtber procedure toek plaee.
45]
SS GEORGE HI. Proceedings againa CapiaiM Wm. JohHiian [44
591. Proceedings before the High G)urt of Justiciary at Edin*
bnrgb^ on an Information exhibited by the Lord Advocate
of Scotland^ against Captain Willum JoHNsroir, charging
him with a Contempt of the said Court, January 25tb,
29th, 31st, February 12lh, 14th, 15th, 19tb, 23rd:
33 George III. 1. d. 1793.
Curia Jiuticiaria S. D. N. Reeis, tenta in
Nora Sessionis domo de Edinburgh, ^i-
cessimo quinto die Januarii, miilesimo
acptingentesimo el nonosesimo tertio,
per honorabiles Tiros Robertum Mac-
queen de Braxfieldy Dominum Jtistici-
arium Clericum, Alexandnun Murray de
Henderlandy Davidem Rae de Esk^ve,
Joannem Swinlon de Swinton, Dominum
Gulielmum Naime de Dunsman, baro-
netum, et Alexandrum Abercromby de
Abercromby, Doroinos Commissionarios
Justictariae dkti S. D. N. Regis.
Curia le^timi affirmata.
The which day his Muesly'd adfocate re-
presented that there had appeared in an
Edinburgh newspaper intituled ** The Edin-
burgh Gazetteer/' dated the 16th current, an
account of the tnal of Morton, Anderson, and
Craig,* lately tried and conricted, before this
* The following was the account of the
frial of Morion, Anderson, and Crais, inserted
in the Gaaetteer of January 16th, widch fjsfe
rise to these proceedings.
'^ High CoiraT of Justiciaet.
^ The Lord Justice Clerk, previous to the
examination of the witnesses, made many ob-
seryations on the excellence of the British eoiv
stitution. He observed, in a most Sequent
sjbeech, ' thai his conscience disapproved of
* French reformation, as they are a nation of
'Atheists; and I wish that we could avoid
''the danger of their principles. They deny
'-their de^endance on the great God of Pro-
'-vidence m irfiose sight we are mere mush-
* rooms. Our blasphemies can do na harm
' -to him who is all powerful ; he looks on us
'aa beneath him.— But to biaspheme against
' his most nadous majesty; what impiety I
' when uD&r his government we eqjoy sae
* mony blesungs. The reformers tsuk of
'[liberty and equality^ this they hae in every
'^thinff consistent wi' their happiness, and
'.fquality s^lso. However low Dom a man
*my beu yet his abilities may raise him feo[
* the highest honours of the state. He may]
' rise to DC a lord chanceljor. theliead of the'
' law ; he Rftiy rise to be amUabop of Can-
' terbiuy, the head of the kirk; and tak pie-
high court, to which he considered it his duff
to call the particular attention of their bni-*
ships. That the account given of the said
trial, was not only partial, untrue, and unjust,
but by imputing partiality and injustice to
the Court, in the conduct of that trial, as weU
as from other circumstances appealing in the
paper itself, a copy of which was produced,
was clearly and evidently calculated to lessen
the regard which the people of this country
owe to tho supreme criminal court ; and ap-
peared to him in its whole tendency to afford
a precedent highly dangerousto the constitu-
tion of this country. Thatoonsidering this
account as a high indignity offered to the
Court, and aa an imputatien upon the ver-
dict of the lory, he felt it pwuliarly his
dutv to call their lordships attention to it.—
And as William Johnston, eso. appeared, from
the paper now produced, to be the publisher
and in the printed proposals also produced,
published in September last, bearing hb sig-
cedence of a' ranks but the bloed-rovaL
What mair equaliljy wad they hae ? If they
hae abilitv, low birth is noti^ainsl them*
But that they hae a right to a representa-
tion in parliament, I deny: the hmded
interest alone should be represented in
parliament, for they only hae an intereat in
the countiy. In God's name' let tlian gang.
I wish them not to stay ; but I deny they
hae a right to representation in pariiament.
I also maintain that the landed interest pay
all the taxes. The shoon, I ailow, are
Nearer by almost a half than I remember
them, owing to the additional taxes on
leather, which the exigencies of the state
requires ; but it was not the mechanic nor
the labourer that paid the tax, but the pro-
prietor of the kna; for I remember when I
could pay a labourer wi^ half the sum
which I now doew He was therefore of
opinion that the present oonatilutioa' was
the best that ever existed.'
** The irst wttnesa examined on the part of
the prosecutor, was corporal Home; he de-
poned that he was sitting" in the outer hall,
mm king James's room, in company, with
oiher soldiers when Thomas Huestsr, alontf
with J. Anderson^ one of the panels called
fofr him tojoin then; conpaay; ^wfaenjie wast
into the roomi Anderson took him by the
45]
Jar Contempt of Cmtlrt.
A. D. 179S«
lie
nature, and dated from his dwelling house^
North Frederick-ftlreety avowed liimself to be
both the principal proprietor and conductor
of the above newspaper, then about to be
pidriyshed; — he submitted that, agreeably to
the practice observed in similar cases, their
Jcidships would take into their immediate
and serious consideration, a matter which
in his appr^ension concerned their own
authority, and the general welfare of the
countiy.
The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
noners of justiciarj, having considered what
18 before represented, and the dangerous con-
sequences of such publications^ do order and
appoint William Johnston, publisher of the
aaid newspaptf intituled* ^ the Edinburgh
Gasetteef* to sist himself personally in court,
fviikdn the New Session house of Edinburgh,
npon Tu^daj the 39th day of January instant
mt two o'clock afternoon, to answer for his
eondactywith certification; and ordain this
order to be intimated to him personally, or at
faand^ called him a brave fine fellow; said he
flbouM join their dub for fireedom and liberty,
and that his pay should be It. or U, 6d, per
^y, which was better than 6<<. ; that Anoer-
flon also took money out of his pocket, which
he held in his hand, offering hun, which he
fefiised to receive, fie then heard Anderson
five the toast o(* George III. and last,' and
iorton added 'damnation to all crowned
* heads,^ that he took the pot and drank,
* God bJees the king and royal fiimily,' when
Anderson gave him a blow, which he endea-
voured to return, but could no( reach. him
across the table ; That he then went out to
the commanding officer and received an order
to shut the barrier gate, and keep the whole
company nrisoners, till sir C. Koss should
return to the garrison. That after receiving
the order, he returned to the canteen, when
M. Craie threw the pot at him, which struck
against uie wall, ana broke in pieces,
** Several other soldiers swore to some of
the above circumstances; but, differine in
particulars. Home positively swore tnere
were no other soldiers in the room with him.
** Smith deponed he was in' the room with
hxm along with the soldiers. — Stronach
swore, that Anderson laid money on the table,
and that Craig struck Hucster.
Captain Cameron deponed, that Home
came to him apd said he had been ill used by
some townsmen in the lower canteen ; that
one of them had struck him a blow, but that
he had knocked him down ; and he wished
to have an order to keep them prisoners.
The captain, who is a gentleman of consum-
mate professional abilities, gjltve'thls order,
but desired the soldiers to use them with
civility, till fib Charles Ross should return to
the Castle*
''The witnessed Ibr the panel all swore,
that BO such teaals wefo given; some of
tlwm aevsr heard aa expraeioi^ of disloyalty.
his dwellang house, by a macerof court for that
purpose, who is hereby appointed to serve
him with a copy of the above information
andof this order, and to report an execution
said day, bearing his having done so.
(Signed), Host. Mac Qubeh, J. P. D^
CuriOf 4rc., 29th January, 1T9S,
The which day the sud lords proceedrd to
take into consideration the order of Court, of
date the 35th current, respecting the attend*'
ance of William Johnston, pubhsher of the
Edinburgh Gazetteer, at the oar of this court^'
this day.
The macer reported an execution of the
order being duly served.
Mr. Alexander Wights advocate, as counsel
for Mr. Johnston, represented that he was
confined to his house, and to a dark room, on
occauon of a severe inflammation in one or hiif
eyes, and had been so since the beguiling of
this month, by reason of which, he could not
go out without danger ; for evidence of whichr
— *Grierson swore, that it was him who took
the corporal by the hand, and called him a
fine fellow : That the words said to have been
S'ven as a toast, were only talked of betwixt
m and Morton, as having been seen in some'
newspaper, or stuck on the College gate.
'< Rnowles deponed^ that he broke the
handle of the pot| in going round the table, and
threw the rest of it down, as he had paid m it«
<^The landlord also swore, that the pot,
when broke fell at hb fee^ and that he was'
standing betwixt him and the panels, and
could not see by whom it was thrown ciown^
as he was stanmng with his back to them.
^ Thompson, another witness, swore also^
that Knowies broke the pot, throwing it into
ajar-hole.
^* We forbear making an v comment on this
evidence. We onl^ remark, that it is a pity
any boy, who by his own account was only
about rourteen years of age, should have been
received as evidence on such an interestins;
trial ; or that anv officer should converse with
the witnesses, while in court One of them
placing himself exactly opposite to the evi-
dence, could not, in our apprehension, be
altogether Justifiable ; for, though Ire are'
fully convinced of the corporaPs rectitude,
such conduct might have a tendency to in*
fluence the minds of sol^ars."
^* One of the prisoners., M. Craig, is so daa-' '
gerously ill that his life is despaired of,"
^ The great pressure of interestmg matter
prevents us from fiilJUling altogether our pro**
mise in our last, in giving to 9ie public the '
full trial of the three printers ; but we have'
eiven such parts of it, as will, in our opinion,
lead the public to form a correct judgment of
this interesting business.'^
The trial of Morton, Anderson, and Craig,
is reported in this Volume, p. 7.
47] SS OBOROE Itl.
he produced % oeitificate on soUl and coo-
science, under the hands of a surgeon and
physician, which certificate, with tne execu-
tion of service, wexe read in open court
The lords commissioners of justiciaiy,
having considered what is before represented
with the certificate produceci, Xhej appoint
doctor Alexander Monro, professor of anatomy,
and doctor James Hamilton, one of the physi-
cians to the Royal Infirmaiy of Edinburgh,
and Messrs. Alexander Wood, and Benjamin
Bell, surgeons in Edinburgh, or any three of
them, to proceed to the house of the person
designed in the execution returned, * William
< Johnston, esquire, publisher of the news-
• paper intituled the Edinburgh Gazetteer;*
and to inspect and examine his person, and
the situation of his health, and to report to
this high court upon oath upon Thursday
next, at two o'clock afternoon, whether the
said person be in such a situation of health
as that it would be dangerous or hazardous to
his Ufe to bring him to the bar of this court ;
and appoint Uie macer to attend the said
physicians and surgeons, or any three of them,
at any time when it shall suit their conve-
nience betwixt and said time to take such in-
spection, and make such eaamination; and
ordain this appointment to be intimated to
them forthwith.
(Signed) Alex. M vrrat, I. P. D.
Curia^ ^c, 3 lif January, 17 93. ,
The order of Court at last diet beins read
over, his majesty's advocate represented, that
the gentlemen appointed to visit the before-
mentioned William Johnston were in attend-
ance, and they being called, appeared and de-
poned as follows :
^ Compeared, doctor James Hamilton, phy-
sician in Edinburgh, and one of the physicians
to the Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, who
being solemnly sworn and interrogated, de-
pones. That in consequence of the appoint-
ment of the Court, the deponent, alongst with
doctor Alexander Monro, prolessor of ana-,
tomy, Messrs. Alexander Wood, and Ben-
jamin Bell, surgeons in Edinburgh, pro-
ceeded to the house of the person aescribed
to them by a roacer of court who attended
them, " William Johnston, esquire," which
house is in North Frederick-street, Newtown ;
t)iat they did so yesterday at eleven o'clock
forenoon, and then and there inspected the
person; and examined the state of health of
the said William Johnston. That said
William Johnston complained of an inflamma-
tion in his left eye, of a headache, and he ap-
peared languid. That the deponent exa-
xpined the left eye of the said William John-
ston, and It appeared to be inflamed. That
the deponent did not observe any other
symptom of disease or disorder about the said
Wilham Johnston, except the inflammation in
his left eye, and languidf look. Depones, that
he is of opinion, that the said William John-
ston would incur bo bazaid or danger of his
i^nna CapMn Wm. Johmion [4S
life by bdns brouji^t to Ae to of this
court ; and oeinc interrogated, whether or abc
said William Johnston would incur any
risk or hazard of losing his eye, Inr bong
brought to the bar of this court, depone^,
that he cannot give a precise answer to this
question; that exposure to the light mi^ghl
aggravate the inflammation in said Willnni
Johnston's eve, and if it did so he cannot say
what might be the conseauence of that : and
being interrogated, whetner he thought th^
said William Johnston in the way of recovery,
depones, that he did not hear the circumh
stances of said William Johnston^s case so
minutely described, as to be able to ibrm a
precise judgment with respect to his recovenr ;
but from what the deponent observed, he
rather thought that said William Johnston's
eye was in the way of recoverv. Depones,
that he cannot say when the inflammation of
his eye will be eone, causa tcientUt pctetg and
this is truth as ne shall answer to God.
(Signed) James Haviltok.
Alex. Murray, 1« P. D.
Mr. Alexander Woody surgeon in Edinburgh/
being solemnly sworn ana interrogated, oe*
pones and concurs with the said doctor James
Hamilton in all things, with this variation :
That he thinks he was told by William John-
ston himself, that his eye had been worse two
days before, than it was when the deponent
examined it. That it seemed to be a veiy
sore eye, and the deponent^oesnot know but
it might turn worse to day; as there is no
saving what turns such disorders may take,
which is truth as he shall answer to God.
(Signed) Alex. Wood,
Alex. Murray, I. P. D.
Mr. Bef{famtn Be//, surseon in Edinburgh,
being solemnly sworn ana interrogated, de-
pones and concurs with the said doctor James
Hamilton in all thinss with the following
variations : That besioes the inflammation ia
said Johnston's left eye, the deponent also
observed, that the eye-lid thereof was swelled.
Depones, that about a fortnight ago, he had
occasion to attend said William Johnston in
the way of his profession. That an operation
was then performed on the said William John-
ston's eye by scarifying it round the eye-ball..
That from what he then observed of the state
of said eye, compared with what be remarked
yesteiday, the. deponent is of opinion thift
said eye is considerably better, and that it is
most likely, that said eye will be free of in-
flammation in six or seven days, all which is
truth as he shall answer to God.
(Signed) Bemj. Bell,
Alex. Murray, I. P. D.
The lords commissioners of justtciny,
having taken into consideration the foregoing
depositions, they renew the order of court for
the attendance of the said William Johnston
to Tuesday the iSth da;{r of February next,
upon which, day the said lords ordain the
said William Johnston to sisi himself at tbe
tSf}
Jbr QMmHft ^ Court.
A. D« 199S«'
[50
bo oC ibit cdwt «l two •^dock aAenttoon, |
NDdoidBiilhisaierlobe intimated to him
iMiiiiiitfliy> by s nacet of coorty who is to
r^Qrt an exeomoii of bis having done so.
ifikffmA) -Albs. Muekat, I. P. D.
Curia, ^c, t2tk February, 1T93.
Tlie 97hich day the order of court of date
tiie SlBl day of January last, being read over,
the IDBCV reported an execution oithe service
tfiereof ; and in obedience to said order,
WiUtam Johnston, printer of the newsfuiper
iatitukdt ^ The Edinburgh Gazetteer,'^ sisted
himself at the bar, and m having been caUed
opciDy emitted the following declaration.
The said Wilham Johnston being examined
and inteiTogftted, declares, that be is the pub-
lisher of paper intituled. * Proposals for a new
' paper intwuled The Edinburgh Gazetteer, to
* be publish^ at Edinburgh every Tuesday
* and Friday;' a printed copy of which lias
been shown to the declarant, and is now sub-
acribed by him, and the lord president of the
court as relative hereto; declares and ac-
knowledges that he b the piiblbher of a paper
intituled, ** The Edinburgh Gazetteer/' bear-
ing dmte, ^ Tueadav^ January l^th, 1793 ;"
m printed copy of which has been now shown
-to the declarant, and is marked by liim and
the lord pre^dent of the court as relative
hereto.
(Signed) W. Johnston,
Al£x. Murray, I. P. D.
I>iet contianed till the 14th instant; and
the said William Johnston ordained to be
committed prisoner to the Tolbooth of Edin-
IninEfay therein to be detained till that time.
^SiereaAer there was presented to the said
lords a petition in the name of the said Wil-
liam Johnston, and subscribed for him by the
swd Alexander Wight, advocate; humbly
riieinng. That a warrant having been granted
hy the Court for committing the petitioner to
the Tolbooth of Edinburgh till Thursday next,
at two o'clock aAemoon ;
That in the petitioner^ present sitoation of
health, his being confined to prison, would be
stteoded, be apprehends, wUh considerable
dajjger.
l%at as the offence with which he is
charged, he humbler apprehends, is bailable,
mid as he is ready instantly to find caution
for his appearance at the bar at the time
apecified m the warrant of commitment, and
at all other diets of court to such extent as
their kHtlships amy think proper. Praying,
therefore, it might please their lordships to
recall the warrant of oonunitment granted
fifunst him, and to adnut him to bail.
The lords commissioners of justiciary hav-
JM considered the fore^oin^ p<^ition, they
find that the |iH^|itic«^ may be admitted to
hail; and m. I^is case mpdify the bail to six
4houHUid merks SooM, a^ upon the peti-
dooer findii^ «ifficient caution and surety,
acted in the books of adjournal, under
that penal^ for bis af^eara^e at the bar
VOL.XXIIL.
upon the said fourteenth day of Fabmaiy in-
stant, and whole after diets of court, recall the
said]warrant of commitment, and ordain, the
petitioner to be set at liberty.
(Signed) Alsx. Murray, I. P. D.
Curia, — 14** Fehruary, 179S. *
William Johnston miblisher of the ^din*
burgh Gazetteer, sistea himself at the bar in
terms of the order of court, dated the 12th
current, and he beino; again examined and in-
terrogated, emitted tne following declarfition.
Compeared the said William Johnston and
being mterrogated, declares that a paper
intituled '< Substance of Captain Johnston's
apology to the Lords of Justiciary upon Tues-
day the 12 th day of Februarv current, for the
insertion of a paragraph in his newspaper of
the 15th of January last, relative to the trial
of Morton, Craig, &c.'' was siven in to the
clerk of court, and is subscrmed by the de«
clarant (and the Court order said paper to be
inserted in the record of court an^eable to
the requisition in the end thereof, and now
repeated by captain Johnston) ; and the said
William Johnston being furtjtier interrogated,
declares that Simon iJrummond, printer in
Edinburgh, is the person alluded to by the
declarant, in that paper, as the person who
superintended the publication of the news-
paper intituled << The Gazetteer,^' and to
whom he gave instructions not to insert any
thing in said newspaper without his tbe de-
clarant's approbation, and this he declares to
be truth.
(Signed) W. Johnston.
AL£X. Mt7RRATy I. P. D.
The lords commissioners of justiciaiy
having considered what is before declaiea,
order and appoint the said Simon Drum-
mond, printer, to sist himself personally at
the biur of this court to-morrow, at two o'clock
afternoon ; and ordain this order to be inti-
mated to him by a macer of court imme-
diately: And the said William Johnston
also to sist himself at the same hour.
(Signed) Alex. Murray, I. P. D.^
Of which paper intituled, * Substance of
* captain Johnston's Apology to the Lords of
' Justiciary, ttc,' and referred to in the fore-
going declaration, the tenor follows :
Mv Lords; — I am deeply to regret, that I
have ui^ortunately incurred tne displea-
sure of this Court. Unfortunate I con-
sider it, because I am inclined to think
that every honest man must feel it a
mbforUmetobe suspected as capable of
giving deliberate offence to the aaminis-
tratcm of justice.
I am seriously to lament, my lordsw that
the eentlemen who attended me auring
my ifiness, conceived it. proper to send a
certificate to the Court, stating the
situation of my health. Had I been ac-
quainted with the forms, I solemnly
protest that no motives, however urgent,
£
51]
S3 OfiORGB ni. Proceedings againd Capimn Wm. Jckndcn [59
no personal conaderalion for the nfet j
of my eye, should have restrained me
one moment from paying implicit obe-
dience to your lordships summons.
I have always thought, and i trust I shall
continue to think, that the loss of health
or of life itself, are not to be put in com-
petition with a stain upon my character.
The crimes of which I am acaised, i know
I am incapable of committing. If I
have erred, my lords, it was an error the
chastest reputation might have been
guilty of— an error whoUy unknown to
me — committed contrary to my direc-
tions, and at a time when I was in a
state of blindness. The responsibility
attached to my particular situation as a
proprietor of a newspaper, is, thank God,
my only crime ; to that responsibility I
smill most cheartully plead guilty.
Were I capable, my lords, to treat the
laws with disrespect, the proceedings of
^8 or of any court of justice with con-
tumely— ^were I capable of wantonly
holding up to ridicule or censure the
equity of its decisions — were I so great
a fool, and an idiot, so entirely desti-
tute of common prudence, and common
discretion, as to convey an imputation
on tiie high judicial situation in which
your lordships are placed, I should set
myself down as an unworthy member of
society. I have always venerated the
laws — I know their necessity, and their
utility* — ^No man holds a court of jus-
tice m higher respect, or more reveres
than I do, that dignity witii which your
lordships as euarolans of those laws are
investea by the constitution.
I am extremely sorry that I do not see a
learned lord [the lord justice clerk]
in hb place, to whom 1 should have
been happy to have addressed myself,
to whom, in some measure, I think I am
bound to make an apology, but not for
a fault committed by me. I ofiercd this
aV)nement in defence of my own repu-
tatbn as a gentleman — as well as for
that respect I bear to the official depart-
ment in which that learned lord pre-
sides, and the regard to which he is en-
titlea; this, mv l^ds, is the hrst day I
have ventured abroad since the begin-
ning of the year, — and it is only within
these ten days I have been out of dark-
ness. From the commencement of Ja-
nuary to the lOtli, the day I underwent
a severe operation in my eye, had the
treasures of the world been . laid at my
feet, I could not have dictated, read, or
wrote one line. To those who know the
agony attending a violent inflamed eye,
J shall appeal, if what I have said is an
exaggeration.
At \& time I was taken ill^ I did every
thine that the most cautious prudence
coula sqggest; t bad given the most
positive orders to the penon who super-
mtended the paper, not to insert any
thing without my knowledge, and ftp-
probation ; in the condition I was in,
some degree of confidence was idiao-
lutely necessary; but I . narrowed that
confidence as much as it was possiUe^-*
The paper which had reflected on tho
trial Wore the court of ju^ciaiy, and
which gave much offence, was i^nnted
on the 15th ; at that period, and indeed
both previous and subseqnent to it, I
was incapacitated from attending to ai^
business whatever, and I continued in
total ignorance of the existence of this
paper, until the 9%tA or 2Srd, and even
then I heard of it by mere accident fhmi
some gentlemen. I must conies^ that
my astonishment was great. Had I then
been in a convalescent state^ I should
certainljr have adopted that hne of con-
duct which candour will ever pursue. I
wotdd voluntarily have requested to
have been admitted at your krdshins
bar, and then I would have ingenuously
explained in the simple language of
truth, the situation of my health, and
my Ignorance of the business ; I should
have then avowed what I now do— -my
innocence in point of fad— my guilt iii
point of responsibility.*
CapUun Johnston be^ that their lord-
ships will allow this to be entered, in
the minutes of the records of the court.
(Signed) W* Joh bstov.
* From a memorial presented by captain
Johnston, to the first division of the court of
session, and dated March 1, 1817, I extract
the following passage relating to this a£bir :
** The complainer also thoueht proper to
refer to some proceedings whicn were insti-
tuted against the memoriatist, twenty-four
years ago, on account of a publication in a
newspaper, which he at that time conducted,
which gave an unbecoming and incorrect
account of some proceedings in Uie court
of justiciary. Thememorialistwastherelegally
responsible as principal, being publisher of
the newspaper, although, from bad health at
the time, ne was entirely ignorant of the
matter, and was not able to discover who
was the author of the paragraph. The me-
morialist, in these circumstances, was sub-
jected to the displeasure of the Cow^ and in
consequence of nis legal responsiblhty, suf-
fered unprisonment, which, from the sitiia«
tion in which he then stood was attended
with great patrimonial loss, and rendered
doubly severe from bad health. The real
author of the paragraph kept himself con-
cealed for eighteen years, and confessed the
circumstance to the memorialist about six
years ago. The memorialist has stated thai
circumstance^ because the mention of that
case might, to those who are ignorant of the
circumstances, attach a degree of blame to
himi which be no way merits*''
B0] f» CMmpl ofCauH.
X^iiria, ^c.-^tSth February, 17^3.
'Wybsm JobnstoBy designed in the prece-
ding atdtsunt, sgun sisted himself at the
bar; and in conaaquenoe of the order of
coort of yeslnday'a dat^ Simon Drummond,
arinter in Edinboigh, sisted himself at the
Mr likewiae; and he beii^ examined and
iBtenogBted, declares that he leceived in-
alractioDa fix>m Mr. William Johnston, pub-
lisher of the Edinburgh Gazetteer, to super-
intend the pdbfication of said paper, from some
tiflse in the month of December last, for the
apace of twelve months; declares. That he ac-
otdingly did stmerintend the publication of
and newspaper miring the month of January
last; decbaea in partioilar, That he did super-
ialaid'die pufaikatien of the Edinburgh Ga-
aelleer, dalted Tuesday, January I5th 1793;
9k eofij of vhich has been now shown to
him, and is sohscribed bjir the declarant, and
the Jard president of the court, as relative
bereto; That for three or four weeks before,
«t the time, and sometime subsequent to the
BoUicatieD of said Gazetteer of the 15th of
Jannaiy, the declarant was very much in-
dispoaed in bodily health. Declares, That he
pemctly reo^lects tbe insertion of a passage
va said paper, be^nning < High Court of
* Justiciary,' and giving an account of what
was said to have happened at a trial before
that court; and being interrogated whether
or not he has the manuscriot fhHn which that
pangraph was printed ; oedares he has it
not, nor does be know what has become of
it^ tliat pi^iers intended to be inserted in
ai(id newspaper, axe sometimes put into
a slit in the door at which there is a box, and
aoroetimes given into the office itself. That
in which of these ways the manuscript above
mentioned came into the ofhce, or m what
wn^f it so came, the dedarant cannot say, as
it came to the office in his absence as he pre-
sumes ; and he found said manuscript among
other packets, which had been sent to the
office^ and were designed for publication. —
That the declarant cannot say, whether he
read the whole of said manuscript, but that
he read part of it ; and to the best of his re^
collection, .that part which contains an ac-
count of the depositions of the witnesses.
That he then put said, manuscript into a bag
with other papers. That said manuscript was
taken^rom the said bag by aboy of the name
of M'Lay. then empk>yed in the office of
Grant and Moir, in which printing-office the
Gaaetteer was then printed, and a considera-
ble part of said manuscript was taken off in
tvpes> which were sett or composed before
the declarant knew of its being so done. That
the dedaiant did not read, nor hear read
the above past of what had been so composed.
That he does not recollect^ whether he read
or heanLiead».tbe whole of what remained of
said passage^ ader it, was composed, but re-
m^oiheravt^ he. r^ that part of it which
conlaina the depositions, of the witnesses,
A.O. 1793.
[54
which ha had fbrmerlv read in the manu-
script, and knew it to be the same with what
he nad so read from the manuscript. That,
the declarant afler the whole of the said
passage, which describes certain proceedings
as having passed at said trial, was composed,
dictated the five last lines* in the said column
which lines begin '^ the great pressure,'' and
end with the word '< business.'' That the
declarant cannot be positive of his having
dictated as above ; but, .to the best of his re-
coUection he did so. That whilst the types
were setting, or after they were sett, but oe-
for the paper was printed, several persons
came into the office, and by their accounts
of what had passed at the trial, confirmed
what l^e declarant had read as above men-
tioned. That John Moir, printer in Edin-
burgh, corrected the typographical errors in,
the proof copy of the passage above alluded
to. Declares, That he cannot assign any.
particular reason for believing that the above-
mentioned manuscript is not now in exist-
ence, but supposes it may have been destroyed
from the general waste which often occurs
in printing-offices^ where there are such a
number of boys; but this he can say, that
said manuscript has not to his knowledge
been destroyea, toprevent its being produced
here. Declares, Tnat he did not know the
hand-writing of said manuscript, nor at the
time it was perused as above, aid he suspect
by whom it had been written. Declares,
lliat he thinks he composed, that is, sett the
types of some part of the above passive ; and
he believes it is that part in which Huxter is
mentioned. All which he declares to be
truth.
(Signed) S. DaumioND.
Albx. Mvrrat*
Thereafter his majesty's advocate re|>ro-
sented. That from the foregoing declaration
emitted by the said Simon Drummond, it
occurred to him, that he was guilty of a con-
siderable degree of criminality, respecting the
publication now the subject of inquiry, and
therefore, he considered it to be his auty to
move their lordships, to have him committed
to prison, till their lordships further pleasure
should be known.
(Signed) B. Duvdas.
The lords commissioners of justiciary
having taken into consideration the said
declaration with the foregoing motion, they
adjourn the consideration of tnis matter till
Tuesday next, at two o'clock afternoon in
this place, and in the meantime, ordain the
said Simon Drummond to be committed
prisoner to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh,
therein to be detained till that time. And
ordain the before-mentioned William John-
ton, likewise to sist himself at the said Ume«
(Signed) Alex. MraBAy, I. P. D.
* See them aiUt, p» 4^^ ncte.
55}
S3 GEORGE IIL Proceediagi agaiuU C^tkOn Wm. Johnttan (M
Thereaff^ tbe^ was pfesented tollie said
lords a petition in the name of and snbscribed
by the said Simon Dnimmond|
Hmnbly shewing; That a warrant having
been granted by uie Coart, for committing
the petitioner to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh,
herein to remain till Tuesday next at two
d*dock afternoon, upon a charge made
against him by his majesty's advocate, as
bSing concerned in the mserting an account
of the trial of Morton, Anderson, and Craig,
in the Edinburgh Gazetteer :
' That the petitioner is at ()resent in a veiy
weak state of health, and his being confined
in prison might be attended with considera^
ble danger, And as the ofience with which
he is charged appears to him a bailable one, he
therefore makes this application to their
lordships to be admitted to bail. Praying
therefore, it mi^ht please their lordships to
Consider the petitionees case, to admit him
to bail, and to modify the extent of the bail
bond, and upon his finding sufficient caution
and surety acted in the books of adjournal,
vnder such penalty as their lordships shall
think fit, for tiis appearance at the bar^ at the
time specified in tne warrant of commitment,
and ail other diets of court, to grint warrant
for setting the petitioner at liberty.
The lords commissioners of justiciary
bavine considered the foregc»ing petition,
find that the pttitionet may be admitted
to bail ; and, in this case modifies the bail
to two thousand merks Scots, and upon the
petitioner's finding sufficient caution and
surety acted in the books of adjournal under
that penalty, that he shall appear at the
time specified in the waArant of commitment,
and WBole afler diets of court, grant warrant
for setting him at liberty.
(Signed) Albx. MuaaiLY, t. P. D.
Curia, ^c. 19th Feb., 1793.
William Johnston publisher of the Edin-
burgh Gazetteer, and Simon Drummond
{printer in Edinburgh, sisted themselves at
he bar in obedience to a former order of
court.
Mr. C. Hopey advocate,-appcared as counsel
for the said Simon Drummund. The said
Simon Drummond represented, that he
wished to have his former declaration emitted
before this Court read over to him, and to be
allowed to make a further declaration, and
some conections of what he had formerly
declared.
The smd declaration being accordingly read
over to him, he emitted tfa^ following decla-
ration :
The said Simon Drummond being ac-
cordingly examined and interrogated, declares,
That the time at which he engaged with Mr«
Johnston to superintend tiic publication of
the Gazetteer, as mentioned in his former
declaration, was on the evening of the 19th
day of December, last Deoiares, That he
cannot be positive as to the name of the boy
who took the manuscript of the passage
mentioned in his former aedaiation fretti the
bag, though he has in said declamtidb ci^cd
him M^Diy. And the former declarationa
emitted by captain Johnston, and the paper
given in by him to court, intituled, ' Apek>gy.
&c.,' being at the declarant's own desire read
over to him ; he of himself declares^ That
till such time as captain Johnston was served
with an order to attend this Court, the decla-
rant never received any particular instructions
from taptain Johnston as to the oonduol of
the Gaaetteer, except not to insert any thing
that was libellous, that is, what he the de-
clarant might himself concdve to be a libel,
and so far was the declaram from being re-
strained in otho* particulars, that he remeoH
hers to have sent some papers enclosed in a
packet to captain Johnston, concerning the
publication of which the declarant doubted,
and captain Johnston returned said packet
to the declarant unopened^ with a verbal
message that he might do as he pleased.
Declares, That it was the declarant's inva*
riable practice, as soon as a complete printed
copy or the Gazetteer was oast off, to send it
to captain Johnston's house in Frederic- street,
by one of the boys in the office, and to wait
upon the captain next day after the publica-
tion of the Gaaetteer, and to talk over with
him what had been contained in the publica^
tion of the preceding day. That he reooiteels
accordingly that he waited on captain Joim-
ston the day after the publication of the
Gazetteer, dated the 15tb of January last,
and carried a copy of said Gaeetteer alongst
with him; and remembers particularly to
have mentioned to the captain, that as there
was an dficer reflected on in the passage
contained in said Gazetteer, which passage
gives an account of the proceedings before the
high court of justiciary, he the cwclaraat was
anaid that said officer might call at the
printing-office. That the declarant read over to
captain Johnston that partof said passage which
berans * We forbear makioff any comment,'
and ends with the words * influence the minds
* of soldiers.** That upon this captain John-
ston siud to the declarant, 'If any officers
' call at the office, send them to me, and I
* will give them any satisfaction they chooee,
^ as soon as my eye is able to face the sun.'
That what is above declared so happened on
the forenoon of the I6th of January last between
ten and twelve o'clock, but the declarant cannot
be positive as to the precise hour. That there
was no person present with captain John-
ston and the declarant at the above conver-
sation and reading, except captain Johnston's
son, who is a young boy. Decfares, That since
the above-mentioned passage was piriilished,
the declarant has had repeated conversations
with captain JohnstoUi as to the account
.A..J.
* Sec this passage of the paper compiatiied
of <intif p. %6f noU.- <
«3
JkQmtmp^qfCmirt^
A. D. 1T9S.
[58
ghran ia mi fniiiiigr of Um prnrawiiny
Sdfoce the higb eoun of jiuticiaiy^ axia la
partkoUv csptaia Johastoii asked th^ de-
itlMiiit if tfiece vere aay witaesfies who could
prove the truth of .the account given in said
passage of aaid proceedings^ to which the
dadarant aoswared, that he understood there
areie.. That the declarant was desired by
«8ptain Johnston to make inquiries after
ivitnesses who could prove these facts ; and
the declarant accordingly did so; and in par-
^cuLar found two or more persons who said
thai ^ witneea, as the deponent thinks a boy
called Smith, belonging to the regiment in the
Castle, had, after he was examined before the
Court, gone to the Castle, got his dinner, and
agsin returned to the outer house where the
other witnesses were inck>sed, where he re-
tailed to them what he had swore to in pre-
sence of the Court. That the above conver-
sations with captain Johnston, happened some
of them before, and some of them aAer cap-
tain Johnston was cited to appear before this
.Court That the declarant Defi>re such cita-
tion, remembers to have informed captain
Johnston, that the accounts given in said
(lass^ge were confirmed by people who came
mio the office as mentions in his former de-
claration, that the declarant had been in-
formed of the particulars relating to said boy,
Smith, before said citation, and nad told cap-
jUun Johnston of it, but it was after said cita^
Sstoa that the captain ^ve the declarant paa^
tkular instrucUons to inquire after witnes9es
to that fact Declares^ That he now recollects
that he had read that part of the pMBftge
,ifhicb leflects as to the boy aged fourteen,
jkod the officer plaaing himself opposite to the
wttmesses, before the types were sett^ that is,
m the manuscript Dedares that he remem-
Ders to have mentioned to acquaintances the
convfnations he had with captain Johnston
0D the 16th 9f January last Declares, That he
lias amtiniied in caf>tain Johnston's employ-
jnent down to the publication of the Gaxet-
teer of this day. All which he declares to be
tnitb* And nirther declares That captain
Johnston, on the 16th of January, last, ap»
:proved of that part of the passage so often
above-mentioneo, which the declarant then
lead to him as sdimve, and this he also de-
clares to be trath.
(Sig^ied) 6. DRviiifoiiD,
Albx. MoRaAT, I. P. D.
Contkued till tfie 93d day of Feb. 1798.
Curia, 4c. 93d february^ 1793.
Thewfakhday Wtlfiam John8ton,publisher
of the fidinbiirgh Oeiettecr.-i-And Simon
Dnmnnondprmter in £dinbiu]gb, sistedthem-
MhnBsattheiMff*inobedienoetoa former at'
4«r of Court
• Jf^of't fat tk€ jmhUc Fto$etttiorf Robert
^Soadas^esqvhuMns^estjr's advocate; and
Mr. Mobert BUur^ advocate, his m^^esty's
soKoitor ^eneiaL •
Frcr^i far Hri Jpkntiw, A&. Alaxaader
Wight advocate; and for Simon Drummond,
Mr. Charles Hope, advocate.
Mr. Hope as counsel for the said Simoo
prummond represented, that no proceed-
ings could be had against his client upon the
matter now at issue, but that he fiell to be
nmpliciUr dismissed from tlie bar. That it
would occur to their lordships, that he stood
in a very different situation from Mr. John-
ston the other panel. That Mr. Johnston
was accused by the public prosecutor of a
very heavy offence offered against this high
court, rn the publication now under eonsi&
ration, and he was accordingly sisted at the
bar to answer that charge. That in the course
of the proceedings Drummond was called upcm
for the special purpose of fixing guilt upon Mr.
Johnston, and sucn beins the case, he is here
in the precise situation of a witness called br
the. public prosecutor, and has given his testi-
mony accordingly. Now it is well known, in
the practice of this Court, that a person being
once adduced as an evidence, can never after-
wards be brought forward as a panel for the
identical crime which is the subject of in-
quiry. That it would occur to their lordships,
that this was a matter of the utmost conse-
quence to the criminal proceedings of this
country, and therefore he hoped Mr. Drum-
mond would instantly be dismissed from the
bar.
Advocatui answered, that the objection now
stated in bar of proceedings, proceeds entirely
upon a mistake, as appears firom the records
of court, and the whole circumstances of the
case. That Drummond was by no means
called upon as an evidence agpnst Mr. John^
ston, or for the purpose of fixing guiit upon
him. That after Mr. Johnston was accused,
had been sisted at the bar, been heard upon
his defence, and had emitted a first and se-
cond declaration, it occurred to the court, that
from Mr. Johnston's declarations, it would be
proper that Mr. Drummond should be sisted
at the bar, and an order was given for that
purpose ; Mr. Drummond accordingly appear-
ed, and emitted a long declaration, after
which it occurred to him, in his capacity of
public prosecutor that a considerable degree of
criminality respecting the said publication fell
on Mr. Drummond, and therefore he consi-
dered it to be hk duty to move the Court for
having him committed, which was done ac-
cordingly. At next sederunt Mr. Drummond
appHea to the Court to emit a farther decla-
ntion, which he did in the character of a
panel, and after he had been accused bv the
public prosecutor as said is. That this being
the fiict, there is not the shadow of rele-
vancy in the objection ; he is now in the cha-
racter ofapuiei under a formal accosation,
and never was brought forward as a witnes^r
against Mr. Johnston, and therefore the ob-
jection would fall to be repelled.
- Tlie lords commissioners of justiciary hav-
ing-cansiteed the foregoing ob^edioa oflRHed
SS] 33 GEORGE IlL Pnceedk^t ^iad Coftmn
CM
in bar of proceedings against Simon I)finn-
mond, wilQ the answer thereto—They 'repel
the objection, in respect Simon Drummond
was called before the Court as a party to an*
swer for himself, not as a witness against Wil«
liaro Johnston.
(Signed) Alsxavdek Mubrat I. P. D.
Mr. Alexander Wight, on the part of the
said WiUiam Johnston, and Mr. Charles Hope,
on the part of the said Simon Drummond
were then heard at great length.
Whereupon theC«urt havmg asked the said
WiUiam Johnston and Simon Drummond
whether they wished lobe allowed a proof of
any iarther facts and circumstances now
stated, and they having declared that they
did not desire any further proof but rested the
matter upon the evidence now before the
Court; the following judgment was pro-
nouneed.—
The lords commissioners of iusticiary hav-
ing taken into consideration the publication
in the newspaper intituled, ^* The Edinburgh
Gazetteer," of date the 15th day of January
last, pretending to eive an account of the trial
of Jonn Morton and others, tried and convict-
ed before this Court, with declarations emitted
by the said William Johnston^ and paper eiven
in by him intituled " substance of capt. John-
S)ton*s apology," as also the declarations emit-
ted by tne said Simon Drummond ; and hav-
ing fully heard parties and their procurators,
and that they have declined to adduce any
further evidence; they find that the said
publication is a false and slanderous represen-
tation of the proceedings in the said trial, and
a cross indignity offered to this high Courts
calculated to create groundless jealousies, and
doubts of the due acuninistration of justice by
the supreme criminal Court of this part of the
Unitea Kingdom. That the said William
Johnston, proprietor and publisher of the sud
newspaper, and the sadd Simon Drummond,
conductor and printer thereof, arc guilty art
and part of printing and publishing the Mse
and slanderous representation aforesaid.
Therefore the said lords discern and adjudge
the said William Johnston and Simon Drum-
mond to be carried from the bar ; the said
William Johnston to the Tolbooth of Canon-
gate of Edinburffh, and the said Simon Drum-
mond to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh, therein to
be detained for the spaceof three months from
this date, and thereafter, till thev find suffi-
cient cautk)n and surety acted in the books of
adioumal, in manner following for their eood
behaviour for the .space of three years from
the time of their liberation respective viz.
the said William Johnston bv himself with
two cautioners for the sum and under the pe-
nalty of five hundred pounds sterling ; and
the said Simon Drummond by himself with
two cautioners for the sum and under the
penalty of one hundred pounds sterling; and
upon elapsinff of the said period of imprison-
inenf^ and uiuing caution in manner fore-
said grant warrant to and 4»tdaiii the
trates of Edinbuigh andCanong^te^ aadlnep^
era of thdr prisons, to set them at liberW*
(Signed) Alei andbk MukraYi I. P. O.
Bespecting this case see Mr. Hume's ebser*
vations inserted in Vol. 19, p. 1340 of tUs
Collection.
In the year 1794, proceedings were instituted
agunst captain Johnston, which, being
closely connected with tiiis prosecution
are here subjoined.
Curia Justiciaria S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nova Sessionis domo de Edinburgh, vi«
cessimo die Januarii^ millesimo septin-
fsntesimo et nonagefflmo quarto, per
onorabiles viros Robertoni Mac Queen
de Braxfield, dominum justidariom cle-
ricum, dominum Gulielmum Nahne de
Dunsinan, baronetom, et Alexandnim
Abercromby de Abercromby, dominoe
commissionarios justiciaria dicti S. D. N-
Regis.
Curia legitime affirmata.
THE which day there was presented to
the said lords a petition and complaint in
the name of his Maiesty's advocate, and sul>»
scribed by Mr. John Burnett, advocate d^
pute. — Shewing, that in the month of January
179S, the petitioner brought to trial before
your lordships, John Morton, James Andersen,
and Malcolm Craig, all journevmen printers^
for the crime of sedition ; and they having
been convicted by an unanimous verdic^
received sentence accordingly.
That upon the 15th of the said month, of
January, there appeared in an Edinburgh
newspaper, intituled ** The Edinburgh Gazet-
teer," an account of tlie trial of the said Mor-
ton, Anderson, and Craig, imputing partiality
and injustice to the Court in the coarse oi
that trial.
Your petitioner felt himself called upon
to state to your lordships, that he considered
the said account or publication to be clearly
and evidently calculated to lessen the regard
which the people of this country owe to the
supreme criminal Court ; and that as it ap-
p^ued to him, in its whole tendency, to a&rd
a precedent highly dangerous to the constitu-
tion, he requested your lordships attention to
it; and as William Johnston, esa., reading
in North Frederick-street, Edinourgh, had
avowed himself both the principal proprietor
and conductor of the said newspaper, your
petitioner submitted, that you would take inUi
your immediate and serious consideratioiip a
matter which concerned the general weliaie -
of the country.
Upon this representation your lordships qf
this date [Jan. 2^, 1793] maide an order and
6tJ
jSf Coniempt pfOskrt.
A. D. 179S.
[62
«pp«iDtflMnl upon tfie said William John*
atoii to sist himself penonaUy in court upon
the 49tb of the said month.
• Inconseonenceof thisorder^along mves*
tmtioo, and a variety of proceedings, to<^
pace before 3roar lordships, unnecessary to be
Iiere particukrlY recited ; the result of which
#«s, that your (DidshijpSy of this <kte [Feb. 3,
1793], found the pubhcation a false and slan-
derous representation of the proceedings in
the said trial, and a gross indignity offered to
the Court, calculated to create groundless
jealousies and doubts of the due sSministra-
tion of justice by the supreme criminal court
of this pairt of the united kingdom, Found,
That the said^ William Johnston, as proprie-
tor and publisber of the said newspaper, was
psaiXs ait and part, of printing and publishing
the rate and sknderoas representation afore-
said; therefore, you decerned and ordained
the said William Johnston to be carried finom
the bar to the Tolbooth of Canongate, there-
in to be detained for the space of three
nontlis from that date, ^ and thereafter un-
aii be shoaldfind sufficient caution aud surety,
acted in the books of adjournal, for his sood
MuiTiour ibr the space of three vears m>m
the day of his liberation, himself with two
cautioners, for the sum, and under the pe*
nahy, of five hundred pounds sterling.'' And,
«tpon elapsing of the said petiod of imprison-
ment,'and fbMin^ caution in manner afore*
said, your lordships granted warrant for his
lifaeration. All which proceedings appear
ihim the reccnds of Court
That the said William Johnston having
amdeti^Diie the said imprisonment, he with
Di>. Francis Home, physician in Edinburgh,
and James Campbell, writer to the signet, as
cautioners and sureties, acted in the books of
adjournal with him, bound and obliged them-
selves, conjunctly and severally, their heirs,
executors, and successors, that he the said
¥riUtBra Johnston^ ** should have and main-
tain a eood behaviour for the space of three
years, from the SSd ds^ of May instant (179S)
under the penalty of five hundred pounds
sterling, in terms of and conform to a sentence
of the high court of justiciary, pronounced
aaonst him the said William Johnston, upon
the esd day of February last.*' As the said
iKxnd of caution, lodged with your lordships
cierks, hears, that the said bond having been
accepted, and a certificate of the said William
Johnston having obtempered that part of the
senteDce awarded against him having been
ghren,he was accordinelyliberated firora prison.
The i>etttioner had little doubt that these
proceedings, and the severe, but just and pro-
per, censure infiicted upon Mr. Johnston by
vour lordship!! would have insured his good
Maviour to the public at least for the period
mentioned in the sentence. In this, however,
,fae has been mistaken : for he is sony to sav,
firom certain proceedings which have lately
been laid heme him in tus character of pulv
lic proseoitor, he finds hhnself called upon,
in dischar^ of the official duty which he owe*
to the public, to state to your lordships such
fiw^tsand circumstances respecting the con-
duct and behaviour of tlie said William
Johnston, as, in the petitioner's apprehension,
are of such a nature and tendency as to for-
feit the bond of caution granted for his good
behaviour. Your lonlsoips need iiardly be
informed, as the matter has been so lately
and so frequently under the consideration of
the Court, that upon the S9th day of Octo»
ber last, a number of persons^ styling then>-
selves a general convention of the Fnends of
the People, assembled in a ^nason lodge in
Blackfnars Wynd of this city ; and though
their proceedings were at first conceived, or
at least veiled, under the pretext of applying
for a reform in parliamentin a constitutionu
manner, yet it nas been since discovered that
the purpose of their meeting was in truth of
a most dangerous and seditious tendency, and
obviously calculated for the purpose of con-
temning and resisting the authority of the
legislature, and inflaming the minds of the
people against the constitution and govern-
ment of the country.
From the written evidence to be afterwards
stated, it already appears that Mr. Johnston
considered this meeting in the light which
the complainer now states it, and was abun-
dantly aware both of the tendency of the
meetmg itself as hostile to the pubnc peace,
and that his Ittendance in, or having any
connexion with it, would infallibly subject him
and his sureties in a forfeiture of the penalty
contained in the aforesaid bond.
This notwithstanding, he appears to have
corresponded with a person or the name of
William Skirving, who has, within these few
days, been tried aud convicted by a jury be-
fore your lordships of the crime of sedition,
for accession to such meeting, on the subject
of its future conduct and proceedings; and
to have taken upon himself a very active
share in directing the said Skirving, as to the
manner in which such meeting or convention
was to proceed. And thougn he appears,
from the said written evidence, to have been
aware of the criminality of his conduct in so
doing, and to have at first declined being a
meznoer of, or appearing in, that convention ;
yet he nevertheless ventured, of this date
[Oct. 31, I79d]|^ to attend one of the meetings
of said convention, as a visitor, to have taken
a part in their debates, and to have counte-
nanced, and encouraged them in their pro-
ceedings.
The above mentioned William Skirving
having been apprehended, and his ]»pers
seized, there was found in his possession, a
scroll of the minutes of this meeting or con-
vention, herewith produced. And a question
having occurred among them, as to the pro-
priety of petitioning ^e king or the house of
commons, upon certain topics unnecessary to
be here mentioned, these minutes bear, that
^< captam Johnston having come in as a visi-
CS]
SS GEORGE UL Procmbiff ^igainai CapimM Wm. JohuUm [64
tor, the rev. Mr. Doasldiitt aoved» tkiltiie
cafilain's opinion ahonld be had upon the
qiKStion; and the eenvenftion baring, ueon s
motion by the depute secretary, wavoa the
segulation excluding TiBitora mm speaking,
captain Johnston expressed his sense of the
oompiiment paid him, and assured them of
Ibe continuanoe cf his steady zeai in the
cause ofrefoim, but assigned a very satisfiic^
tory reason for not taking any hand at pre-
sent in the business betore them." It a^
pears from the minutes, that the debate then
proceeded : but near the conclusion of it,
captain Johnston seems to have altered his
resolution, the minutes bearins, ** That cap-
tain Johnston at last rose, and made a short
speech, and stwagiy recommended unanimity,
but expressing it as his decided opinon, that
it was Doth ilwgal and improper to petition
the king, and t&t such a step would actually
ruin tiie cause.''
This meetinc or general convention, as
above describeo, broke up in a day or two
thereaAer. But several seditious and evil
disposed persons, having arrived from £ng.
land, for the purpose, it would seem, of at-
tending it; the above mentioned William
Skirvinc drculated adverlisemehts for calling
the said meetine together a second time,
which aceordingty met upon the 19th of
November last, and continued to sit daily
from thence forward, till the 5th of Decem-
ber last, when their conduct aid proceedings
became cf so flagrant a nature, that the ring*
leaders were taken into custodvy and their meet^
ings dispersed and prohibited m future, by liie
aimorilgr of tfae4>roper manstrate. The peti-
tionep4s entitled to term the second meeting
highly seditious, because two of the rinzieaders,
Skuving and Margarot, have within ^ese few
days been, on account of their attendance and
accession thereto, convicted of sedition,- by
two unanimous verdicts of their country. .«
It appears from the minutes of this last
meeting, found in the possession of Skirving,
their secretary, that captain Johnston had, as
fytt down as the dOth of November, or as it is
termed in the minules, ^' eleventh day*s sit-
ting,'' again been present in it, and bad taken
an active |>art in its proceedinss. The ml*
nuies bearing : '' It was moved that captain
Johnston should report some circumstances
to the convention; for which purpose the
house resolved itself into a committee, when
he read an aocount of the trial and sentence
of D. Hok, for reprinting the duke of Rich-
mond's and Mr. Pitt's resolution for a par-
liamentary reform; after which, the chair-
men being. replaced, the secretary moved that
captain Johnston should be allowed the ho-
nouBBofthe sitting."
The petitioner submits that this conduct of
JMLt. Jofmston was highly aggravated, not-only
by the consciousness, whtdi be appears to
have ail along felt, of the impropriety of his
behaviour, btu that, on this IsAt occasion, the
mctfUng or cenveationi had by the cbangie of
its aame^ the ferm 0f itsiprooatee, the vaftove
of the motioBs made, awl the purport of the
debates and haraogiMS» which took plaee Im
it, clearly and unequivocaliy proved tne sedi-
tious, jiay treasonable nature of its proceed-
ings; and had previously demonstrated to th«
world that a reform in parliafnent was merely
a pretext, under which was hardly omoealed
a deagn of subverting the oonstituUon, and
resisting the le^lative authority of the state.
The authenticity of the above-mentioned
minutes, the petitioner will establish by the
most satisfoctory evidence. Four letters, hok>-
gnmh of Mr. Johnston, three of which are
adclressed to the above-mentioned Skirving;
and the fourth to Mr. Scott, or Mr. Ross, the
publishers of the Edinburgh Gasetteer, aie
herewith produced. As also a copy of a m*
cular letter by the ^venaientiGiied William
Skirving, wrote, it would aeem, in consequence
of the suggestion and directions, in one of the
above-mentioned letters to him from the said
William Johnston ; and of all which copies
are annexed to this ooasplaint by way of
appendix. The petiti<mer will likewise coiroi*
borate and support the above-mentioned
written evidence, as well as the whole other
^ts and circumstances charaed against Mr«
Johnston, by the testimoniesotthese witnes8e%
whose names are annexed to this petition and
complaint : these being established, the peti*
tioner cannot entertain a doubt of your lord*
ships being of opinion, that the said William
Johnston has forfeited his bond of caution*
and that you will declare so accordingly ; and
grant warrant to, and ordain the clerks of
court to proceed in diligence in^common foma
ag;ain9t tne said William Johnston, and the
said Doctor Francis Home, nsA James Gamp»
bell, as his sureties, for reoovei^ of the penalty
of 500/. sterling theroin contained, to be du«
posed of as to your lordships shall seem meet.
Your petitioner subjoins a list of witnesses
and written evidence, by which the foiecoing
facts are to be proved, if the same thul be
denied by the said William Johnston and his
cautioners, in order that they may be suffi*
ciently apprised of the naturo of the evidence,
to be adduced in support of this complaint.
May it therefore please vour loroships to
ordain this petition and complaint, with
the list of witne8ses,and wfitten evidence
hereto 8ub|oined, to be served upon the
said William Johnston, and the said
Dr. Francis Home, and James Campbell,
and to appoint tbem to give in answers
thereto, it they any have, within suck
time as your lordships shall think proper ;
and if the factsand circumstances herein
set forth shall be denied, to grant vrarrant
for letters ofdilig^ce, at t& petitioner's
instance, for eiung the witnesses ^
proving the 9«iie; and, upon the said
Ucts and circumstances bca»gestablisfae4
to find, that thehond of caution, ^ranlad
for the sood behairiour of the said Wil-
liiim JqSnston, is forfoited; and to grant
9S}
;^r GMMpI ^CouH*
A. D. 1793.
[M
wttrtnl tD Ifatf dirk of court to proceed
in Al^Mee agtiBfti him and Us sureties,
£ir H>eo»ciy «r tfie peetlty tlMrein con-
tained^ to be disposed of in «uch maimer
as TOUT lordships maj tbinJc proper.
ABOf haXWp t& make such farther order
as to ^roor KMPdsliips shall seem meet, for
cBSunog the good behaviour of the said
• William Johnston, ibr the period speci-
fied in Ihs sentence.*
According to justice, &c.
John Burnett, a. d.
On t}u3 petition and complaint, the follow-
ing interlocutor was pronounced by the Court:
BdMmrgh, %fMh January, 1794.
Th»lord jus^e eieark, and lords oommis-
aionersof justkaai^, haringconsidered the fore-
goins petition and complaint, they ordain the
iaaM to be served upon the said William John-
•iQii, doctor Franeia Home, and James Camp-
* ' /
. The fi»Uowing are the documents sub-
joined to ifae Petition and Complaint
* LsmAf^Mr, Johuion to Mr. William
\ - -• Skirving,
Desirous as I am, that the Drocecdings of
tbe ap|>roaching convention oi delegates may
ht' earned on with the utmost solemnity and
regularity; I flatter myself vou will forgive
my talking the liberty of addressing you on
the subject.
' You cannot but be sensible, that the greatest
aatislaction which the enemies of reform could
leel, would be to see disunion among the
Fiiends of the People, — avoid the rock. I was
told yesterday by Mr. Miller, the advocate,
that yon had already denounced lord Lauder-
dale: I assured him it was a mistake ; that
he bad been misinformed,— that no such
denunciation had taken place; and that I
had too high an opinion of the spirit and
good sense of our friends, than to think they
would evtn dondewend to notice his lordship
in any manner whatever ; that the advocates
ibr our natural and constitutional rights, saw
toothing in any of the boasted opinions of such
Arislocrats, than party principles ; that they
looked ' to principles alone, not to any one
man or set of men.
I am inclined to think, from the conversa-
tion I held with Mr. Miller, that an indus-
trious ninurar had been purposely circulated,
to make yoor meeting declare hostilities to
every man who would not go the length of
mummal pariimmenttf and univeraal right cf
m^fragt, I am perfectly aware that it would
be a most desimble object, to have an tmani-
uityin the kingdom on these two specific
Iprmciples; but I should not think it advisable,
\rf vn means, to throw censure on any indi-
vidmi^ although his mind may not be made
up on so extensive and deep a reformation.
u ibe nomature state in which the sodetiea
are at present, it wouM be infinitely more
noiitie to B^eu^ than to eianerale by hasty
mmmrialions.— If ymi do deaounoei firom
vw^xxni.
bell) bf delivering to each of them a fuU copy
thereof, of the list of witnesses, and written
evidence, thereto subjoined, and of this de*
liveranoe thereon ; and ordiun than to print
and give in answers thereto within fourteen
days after service; and the said William
Johnston to sist himself personally at the
bar of this court upon the lOth day of ¥€*
bmary next, with certification. And ap»
point this complaint, with thp list subjoined,
to be printed and given in with the answers.
Robert IfQuczN, I. P. D.
6th February^ 1794.
There was this dav present to the said
lords, a petition in the names of the said
William Johnston, esq.« Dr. Francis Uoine,
and Mr. James Campbell, writer io the Sig-
net, and subscribed by the hou. Henry Era*
kine, dean of faculty, tbeir procurator, praying
it might please their lordsoips to ulow the
petitioners fourteen days to print and give in
answers to the said petition ; ana to appoint
that moment you will be considered as pur*
suins a similar conduct with the Jacobin clubt
in France ; and instead of bringing about a
constitutional redress of grievances, that you
mean to mark characters for the intent of
destroying them. My reflections are con-
stantly turned on this interesting subject. I
am convinced that we have the bail at our
feet, if we manage with common address;
but should we proceed to violent denuncuh-
tiont, the next course to be adopted will be
vioUnt measures; — both ought to be avoided.
If I might privately suggest a rule for your
conduct, I would earnestly recommend to yoU|
first, an union of sentiment Sdly, A solemn
league with the delegates, never to shrink or
be Qcterred from a pursuit, in so glorious an un-
dertakinj^ as a radical reform. Sdly, To adopt
a mode for holding a monthly correspondenoe
in the business. 4thly, A determination to
manifest to the whole country, an orderly but
a firm conduct 5thly, As a rule never to he
departed firom, to expunge those persons from
the societies who shall be found guilty of
riotous and disorderly proceedings*-if some
such resolution is not brought forward, govern-
ment will contrive to introduce men among
you, for the purpose of drivins yon into- in«
temperate proceedings. You know, as well
as any man can know, that there is a time
when relaxation is the shrewdest policy-*-
when vigour would be as impolitic, and so
viee versa.
As I have observed already, I shall again
repeat it — ^that as no man uving is a more
ardent advocate than myself to every prin*
ciple, which will lead mankind to rtBol and
substantial happiness ; and as no one mea«
sure can more bring that much wished for
object into view^ than a reform in the Com*
monSy which will, when obtained, produce all
thad we can wish or want:— & am I at the
same time equally convinced^ that nothing
will more inSntre success to the friends m
J?
(571
33 GEORGE III. Proceeding* agaimt Capiain Wm. Johnston [68
The lord justice clerk and lords oommift-
sioners of justiciary having considered the
foregoing petition, and that bis nu^esiy's ad-
vocate has no objection to the delay prayed
the petitioner, William Johnston, to sist him-
self at the bar on the 24th instead of the 10th
day of February current, or on such other
day as to their lordships should seem proper.
riberty, than candour, Jirmntss, and constitu-
.tionaJT integrity. — ^I am yours, ic &c.
(Addressed) Mr. William Skirving, Colgate.
Mr. Johnston to Mr, Shirving,
Dear Sir ;— I am favoured with your's this
moment' in answer to it, I shall once more
take the liberty to remark to you, that my
objections to the principle of denunciation,
do not arise from any absurd apprehension
of holding up the character of this or that
man, however exalted his situation — ^all I
meant to say, although I might have ex-
pressed mytielf obscurely, that however de-
serving of the markf that this was not the
thie. The steadiness and moderation of the
people, must bring these people to some
avowed declaration of principles, how far they
propose to go — and depend upon it, that it is
from the real Friends of the People — the tone
of these party men must be taken, and this
must soon happen. — Policy, however, should
now be our guide. — ^Coolness and inflexible
perseverance will do the business.
My interest with those persons whom you
mention, is such as I decline to use : 1 de-
cline it, because I am finally of opinionj that
it would be doing them too much honour to
bestow a thought on such; and indeed I do
not think they are of that consequence, I
must honestly declare that I entertain a very
poor opinion of the whole ; I have sacrificed
nealth, friends, and more money than I can
afford, to a cause which I am ready to lay
my life down to-morrow, to see obtained:
' my peculiar situation renders my attendance
impossible, — you know it, — ^I hope the world
knows it, — take my advice,— mmd no body,
i^go on, — let Magna Charta and the Bill of
Rights direct your conduct, — don't waste your
time in weak and trifling debates— be dig-
nified and constitutional. — ^Yonr's,
Monday 18. W. J.
(Adcfressed) Mr, Skirving.
Mr, Johnston to Mr, Skiroing,
Sir ; — I observe by the Gazetteer, that you
have called another convention of delegates
to assemble on Tuesday the 19th current. I
dare say you will think with me, that this
'measure will create a ^od deal of bustle in
the higher orders, and that every endeavour
and almost every artifice, will be adopted to
render it ineffectual. To avoid the tricks of
power^ I am inclined to suggest to you the pro-
priety of writing yourself to the different socie-
ties, and inform^tn cm of the real circumstances
which have occasioned a second delegation.
By this mode you will secure, in the first place,
a certain attendance ; and, secondly, you will
obviate the precarious uncertainty of the so-
cieties not taking up the utility of the busi-
aess in a compr^ensive point of viesv. 1 am
of opinion, that the convention should be aa
full and as respectable as possible. The ob-
jects it must hold out to tne country, of an^
nttal parliaments andufsivenal right of suf-
frageyhting of vast magnitude. The minds
of the dele^tes ought to be made up on the
subject, previous to their arrival, not merely
to stifle an interesting animated debate on
these measures, but to impress on the minds
of all, the unanimity on such an occasion;—
rely upon it --you will meet with many ob-
stacles, but do not be daunted at what nwy
follow, — look fully at the objects, — leave
consequences to themselves : should any at-
tempt oe made, either to prevent the meeting
or to make it contemptible, let us, as meOy
not forget that our intentions are honest;
that we are the true friends to peace and good
order, and are determined to pursue the glo-
rious business with intrepid moderation, and
constitutional dienity. I shall not sign my
name but with the initials,
6th Nov. 1793. W. J.
(Addressed) W. Skiroing, Esq,, Cowgate.
Circular Letter hy William Skirving,
Sir ; — ^I have the satisfaction to infonn you
that tlie delegates from the societies in Lon-
don have at length arrived in Edinburgh*
Delegates from the other societies in Eng*
land, and who are now upon the road, wul
soon also be here to wut upon the friends of
the people, in order to estaolish an indissolu-
ble fraternity "between the two nations, and
to adopt those measures which at this ateful
period may have a tendency to save the
country.
Solemnly pledged as you are to a common
and iust cause, no hardship and no expense
can be thought too great tor you, while you
are conscious that you are discharginj^ your
duty. With no propriety can you retuse to
attend upon your brethren from England,
who, at so much expense, and from so great
a distance, have Come to unite their affections
and deliberations with you.
I feel it my duty, in coincidence with the
sentiments of the general committee here,
again to recall the societies by their delegates
to this place. Every moment is precious,
and delay is synonimous to treachery.
I expect, therefore. Sir, to have the honour
of seeing you on the 19th current in the ge^
neral convention of the delegates, in conk-
pliance with the public advertisement which
1 was bound to insert in my official capacity
in the Gazetteer of yesterday, to which I in-
treat your particular attention.
If you cannot possibly attend, it will^ be
proper to call the committee of your society
to appoint One or two in your place. No
exertion on the part of a friend should be
vranting at this important emi$ to render
69} ^ Contempt rf Court.
for; they mrogite the time Tor the pett*
tioneis lod^^ their answers for fourteen
days fiom this date, and ordain the petitioner,
WiHittn JohoflDQy to sist himself at the bar
upon If onday, the 9ith day of Feh. instant.
(Signed) RoBEar M'Quisbv, I. P. D.
Answers were accordingly printed, but
tb^ do not appear upon record. They were
follows :
A. D. 1793.
[70
Answers, &c.
• In making an answer to the petition and
complaint exhibited against the respondent,
at the instance of his majesty's advocate, the
ooly question to which the respondent has
to appW himself, is simply this, whether the
jMfftiouuur facts set forth, and the writings
Ibeiein founded upon, are sufficient to forfeit
tbe baitboDd, by which the respondent and
bis cautioners stend bound for nis good be-
liAviour; which bond was granted by them in
consequence of a sentence of this high court,
<ni the 3d of February 1793 f
It becomes necessary, therefore, for the
re^Mmdent, 1st, To consider the nature and
turns of the bauUbond itself; 2ndly, To take
a iriew of the facts that are charged a^inst
him, as amounting to a forfeiture ot this
bond; and lastly. To endeavour to show
your lordships that the facts charged, are
insufficient to operate the forfeiture con-
tended for by the public prosecutor.
The respondent, some time before the sen-
tence of the Court above-mentioned, had
ajeaeed in the publication of a newspaper,
caOed the Edinburgh Gazetteer, on which he
laid out a considerable sum of money, pro-
mising himself a reasonable profit from the
adventure*
tiiis convention still more respectable; and
none who have the cause at heart, and dis-
cerns how much is at stake, will be remiss.
Let it be our ardent prayer to God that
his wisdom ma^ direct thev measures, and
that his benediction may attend the execution
of tbcnni^ — i have the honour to be, Sir, yoiu-
JDOSt obedient servant,
Willi AK Seirvihg, Secy.
Edinburgh, Nov, 7, 1793.
P. S. Being well assured of your good will
to the cause of reform, I have used the free-
dom to send you the above copy of the circular
leMer to the delegates from the various so-
cieties for this important business, hoping
that you might be induced to use means to
colkct a lew friends, in order to send up a
ddceate to the proposed general convention,
whioiy if now duly honoured, may be the
happy means of procuring peace to this dis-
tracted country, at least ot preventing much
of the calamity impending.
If you can procurs a meeting in vour town,
tboi^h but ot 5 or 6, to draw up a declaration
in favour of universal suffirage in the election
of mhuslersy magistrales, and legislatures;
It ihust occur to your lordships, without '
any assurance to that effect from the respon«
dent, that it is no easy matter for the best'
intentioned and most accurate proprietor of'
a newspaper, in the hurry attending the pub- '
lication, to prevent improper and offensive
parag^raphs from finding their way into a
repository of so general a nature. At the
same time, there can be no doubt that the re-
sponsibility for any thing that shall be therein
inserted, necessarily attaches on the pub-
lisher. Unfortunately for the respondent
(though he is conscious owing to no blame
on his part), a para^ph of a very improper '
nature, animadverting upon certain proceed-
ings of this Court, was put into the hands of
the person who managed the detail of the
publication for the respondent, and which
was, without any knowledge or approbation
of the respondent, at that time labouring
under a severe indisposition, inserted in the '
Gazetteer.
The public prosecutor having felt it his
duty to represent the matter to your lord-
ships, the order of the Court mentioned in
the petition, was served upon the respon-
dent, who sisted himself accordinsly at the
bar of this court, upon the t9lh of January
1793. The consequence was, that your lord-
ships found the respondent wits guilty, art
ana part, of publishing the passages com-
plained of; and therefore decerned and or-
dained him to be carried from the bar to the
Tolbooth of Canongate, therein to be detained
for the space of three months from that date,
* and thereafler, imtil he should find sufficient
' caution and surety acted in the books of
' adjournal, for his good behaviour for the
and to appoint one of your number to repre-
sent you at our meeting of the 19th current,
it may soon procure you the thanks of all
your fellow citizens, and at any rate must
give you personal satisfoction, as tending to
unite our country in the bond of fraternity,
the chief resource of men in the day of evil.
— In hopes of your patriotic exertions in the
good cause, I am, &c.
Letter, — Mr. Johntton to Mr. Scott, or Mr,
Ron.
I take the liberty of inclosing you a few
resolutions hastily drawn up, which I am in-
clined to tliink ought, or something similar
to them, to be adopted by the convention, to
bhow its abhorrence of the conduct both of
the judge and jury in the trial of Mr. Holt.
I don't send you the resolutions as beins
perfect, but merely as a model. — ^Do with*
them as you think proper — shew them to
Mr. Callender— ^at any rate, something you
should 'do. — Can you procure me a copy of the
Bill of Rights?— Why, through a false deli-
cacy wait for Mr. Skirving? a public cause re-
Suires the active exertions of every man — and
elicacy is out of the question. — Your's&c.&c.
/ W. J.
(Addmaed) ilir. iS^, or Jlfr. liaii.
71]
S3 GEORGE III. Proceedings Mgainst Grptef » Wm. Johnston [78
* mce of three years Irom the day of his
f^iberatioD, himself, with two cautioners, for
* the sum, and under the penal^ of five hun-
* dred pounds sterling.' And upon elapsine
of the said period of imprisonment, and
finding caution in manner foresaid, your
lordships granted warrant for the respoiu
dent's liberation.
This sentence of your lordships called the
T^pondent's most serious attention to the
predicament in which he stood as proprietor
of a newspaper, for every part of which he
was responsible; with a view therefore, not
only to relieve himself from any such risk in
future, but to prevent his being, even igno-
rantly or inadvertently, the means of con-
veying to the public any thing that might
be offensive or dangerous to the commumty,
the respondent res^ved to give up the con«
cern^ which he accordingly did at a very
considerable loss to his £unilv, as the conti*
nuation of the publication had been too short
tf allow him to get back the sums necessa^
nly expended Lu the commencement of the
work. A fair conveyance of the concern was
accordingly made, and from that day to this,
the respondent neither directly nor indirectly
has had any connexion with the conduct of
that paper. During the time the respondent
had the conduct of the paper, he nas the
^tisfaction to think, that although it was
made the channel of communicating to the
public the resolutions of various societies
^d descriptions of men on the subject of
parliamentary reform, it caimot be found to
Have contained any thing of a seditious
nature on that subiect Of this, no better
evidence can be adduced than, that notwith«
standing the laudable vigilance of the public
prosecutor to suppress and punish every pub*
lication of a seditious tenaency, no judicial
measures were by him taken against the
respondent, on account of any thing that ap-
peared in that paper. And as it will not oe
HUpposed, that while the respondent was
called before your lordships, for the offensive
publication already mentioned, the public
prosecutor would pass over any other irre-
gularis that called for his animadversion, he
humbly conceives, that he is entiUed to avail
himself of this conclusion to the ftillest
effect.
The respondent has no hesitation to ac-
knowledge, that he is one of those whose
opinion leads him to consider a moderate
xeform in the representatbn of the Com-
mons in the British Parliament, upon prin-
ciples cc»ngenial with the nature ot our free
and happy eonstitution, as an object of the
greatest magnitude and importance to the
happiness and prosperity of these kingdoms ;
while, on the other hand, no one can be
more forward to reprobate the late proceed-
ii^s of those rash and misguided persons,
w&D, under the designation of the British
Convention, have, by a variety of proceed-
10£S. hishly uacoustitutkmaL aiid danceious.
brought into hacard, ss £ur as it was in their
power so to do, the very constitution which
It is the object of a moderate and ktwiiil
reform to invigorate and preserve, and who
have thereby subjected themselves to the
punishment of the law.
The association here alluded to, it will be
observed, had no existence at the time when^
in consequence of the judgment of the Court.
the respondent found caution for his good
behaviour. A society of a very diffnent
nature, and under a duFerent name, had for-
merly existed ; tlie object of which was, by*
the legal mode of application to parliament^
to obtain that constitutional reform in the
representation of the Commons, which had,
on several former occasions been adopted hy
many of the most respectable men in the
nation; and had been repeatedly brought
forward in parliament, not only by difiereat
members in their places, but even by some
of those entrusted at the time with the hiebest
offices in the state, and the most con£dea>-
tud situations in administsatioD ; partaculariy
by the present first minister, who, both wkn*
in and out of office, brought forward in the.
House of Commons, motions to that effiect,
and in associations out of doors, formed for
the express purpose of obtuning a parliamt»»
tary reform, gave the measure his cotmts.
nance and support.
As mentioned in the petition, on the Mh.
of October 1793, a certain number of persona
began to meet, under the designation of »*
fl;eneral convention of the Frioids of the
People; voA it is admitted in the complaint,
that the object which they avowed, wm an
application to parliament for a refonn in the
representation of the Commons. On the
supposition, that their object, as well as the
means of pursuine it, were constitutional, the
respondent would not have considered hia
inrolling himself as a member, to be a mea^
sure that would justly afibrd any argument
for forfeiting his bail, as no man will pretend
to say, that a person's exerdsing his consti-
tutional privilege of concurring in a petitios'
to parliament, praying for a reform in the>
representation of the Commons, could be
construed to a breach of good beliaviour,
which could only arise firom'a breach of
the law, tending to subject him to legal
censure and punishment. The respondent,'
however, was perfectly aware, that wnen tawn
are once met together, even on the moat too-
stitutional grounds, seal may oflen get the
better of discretion, and they may be teinpted
to concur in measures very difierent mm
their original intentions, and beyond the
pale of law and the constitution; and thaly*
even independent of any error on their pert,
they may be imphcated in the rashnesa or
criminality of others in their proceedings and
meetings, where they themselves may not be
: present. These oonsideratioBS, joined to the'
i particular sil;iiatton in which he stood» made
tbe lespcpleat reiolve iy»t tq hoMM »
7SJ
Jim CmUmfi ^(Umri*
JL IX 179a.
[74
memb^ of avjr web Meie^y «l least till he
sbcHiU faave a niU opportuot^ of faeiiiig lalis-
fied, tlwlttbeir views were constitatioivuy and
their fsxioeediiigB legsl end orderly. .
The firti cham »ade agjunst the tespon*
deoty ss a grouna for forfeittng his bail-hand,
is, his beiac present at ooa meetiiig of this
flocie^ of we Fiiends of the People on the
SMi October last; and if the charge is well
feuDded» it must be on this snHind^ that
somethiiig said by the lesponaent at that
flseeting was illegal and seditious, for it is
admitled, that the subject of deliberation was
a petition to psriiunent in &vour of reform,
Iban which nothing could be more legal and
conslilntiQnaL It must have been in the
aesliment expreseed by the respondent, that
any wrong existed. What ^e respondent
ia and to have expressed, is thus stated in
the petition and oomplatnt : '^ That captain
Johnstun at last rose and made a short
apnach, and strongly recommended unani-
jaiQTy but expressing it as his decided opi-
nioi^ that it was both illegal and improper
tp pctitkMi the king, and that mtch a step
would ottmeMy rain the coaM."
The words in Italics, the respondent has
no recolkction of havins spoken ; but taking
the passage as it stands, ne presumes to main-
tain, that it offitains nothing more than what
is perfectly warrantable It is impossible
aeneiisly to deny, that to petition the long for
a rtfiDnn in one of the houses of parliament,
vrofdd be in &e hi^est degree unoonstitu-
tiooal: It is thought the learned prosecutor
liill scarcely refuse his assent to this pro-
position. And even as to the words which
am impaled to the respondent, but which
he cannot admit his having uttered; they
are no more than an opinion, that an uncon-
stitutional mode of pursuing a constitutional
cbject, may be prejudicial to its success. The
respondent is confident, therefore, that your
loraships cannot entertahi the most remote
idea, that, taking the &ct as charged, it im-
ports the slightest ^kgree of criminality
against the respondent, and far less such a
^leffet of misbenaviour, as to forfeit the bail-
bond, which it is himibly thought, no con-
duct on the part of the respondent could do,
that would not he sufiBcient to convict him of
a crime, or at least to warrant a court of law,'
to bind him over for his good behaviour.
That neither of these are tte case with the
ftct now charged upon, the public prosecutor
warrants the respondent to conclude, as not
a single step whatever has been taken against
any person who was present at that meeting,
eaoept Mr. Skirving, and beine present at
Ifcat meeting, was no part of what was laid
to his chaise ; on the contrary, he was con-
"wted on the proceedings of a totally different
society, the British convention, who, instead
of adopting the constitutional mode of peti-
tioaiBg parhament^ totally disclaimed anv
such idfla, and adopted measures, which
others to the punishment of the kw Ibr sedi-
tion.
This convention, as motioned in the peti-
tion, having broken up, the society known
by the name of the Bntish Conventicm came
to be constituted. On the supposition, that
its object was also a constituUon^ reform,
the respondent does not conceive, that though
he had become a member of it, it n^owd
have afforded any ground for forfeiting his
bail-bond, as it wouM have involved no degree
oforiminality.
With refiard to the character and senii*
ments of toe persons who came from Eng-
land to attend this meeting, the respondent
was perfectiv isnorant, and it was equally
impossible tor nim to foresee the tone amd
conduct which the new society were to as*
sume.
Mr. Skirving had been a member of the
former society; he was understood to be
pruicipaily concerned in the one about to be
instituted ; and the respondent being desirous,
in confidence to communicate to him what
occurred on the subject, he wrote him the
letters annexed to the petition and complaint.
The letters are unsigned, and it perhaps
might be difficult for the public prosecutor,
to prove them to be of the respondent's
hand- writing. The respondent, however,
considers it to be his duty, not to rest any of
his defence upon a probable defect of [nroba-
tion, and he therefore readily admits the
letters to have been written by him, and
sent to Mr. Skirving, to whom they are ad-
dressed. It is upon those letters, that the
second charge is founded, upon which the
pubUc prosecutor seeks to forfeit the respon-
dent's bail-bond.
Before proceeding to consider the import
ot these letters, and how far they contain
iny thing criminal, the respondent begs leave
to suffgest a doubt, whether, as thej are mere
confidential communications to an mdividual,
not intended for the public eye, and which
do not even appear to have been communi-
cated by Mr. Skirving to any person whatever,,
they would afford a ground for criminating,
the respondent, even to the effect concluded
for, altnough they had contained exception-
able matter. The respondent, however,
wishes by no means to shelter himself on
any such ground, and he is humblv hopefiil
he has no occasion to avail himself of any
such plea, as he trusts it will appear to your
lordships, that, 00 a sound constraction of
these letters, they will not be found to con-
tain any criminal matter, whatever gloss it
may be possible to put upon particular pas-
sages tatcen Yxy themselves. Independent of
the rest, and without regara to the evidence
tiiat arises from the proo^e^ngs of the socie-
ties with which the respondent was formetty
Connected, which were confined to the legal
mode of obtaining a constitutional reform,
vis. an application to parliament by petition.
In thefimt pkce^ thflP) il Mh l9 oe iiqniied,
73]
SS GBOR6E III. Proceedkufp agitinti (U^pimm Wm. Johmttm [76
whether the meidy aMMtainiiig a& opi-
nion in favour of annual parliaments^ and uni-
versal right of sufiirage, and of suggeatine that
to any individual as an object to be fegiti*
mately pursued through the medium of peti-
tions to parliament be criminal, and sufficient
to subject a party to legal censure or punish-
ment^ The respondent humbly conceives,
that this question must be answered in the
negative; whatever objections may lie against
ao very wide a reform in parliament as this,
in point of political expediency, the respood-
ent humbly conceives, that even that object
may legally be suggested to parliament, if done
in a proper and respectful manner; and he
humbly conceives, tnat the judgments of your
loidships against some of the members of the
British convention, who have been convicted
of sedition, were not founded u[>on their having
met for Uie purpose of obtaining annual par-
liaments and general suffrage, but upon tneir
having daringly and seditiously avowed their
determination to obtain that obiect by means
^e most unconstitutional and illegal. Of the
justice of this observation, the respondent can
entertain no doubt, when he reflects, jthat a
nobleman of the highest rank in the kingdom,
and now enjoying an office of the first trust
and confidence under the king, published to
the world, in the most unet^uivocal terms, his
aentunentsinfavour of universal representa-
tion, without sulg^^S himself to anv judi-
cial accusation, or losing the &vour and con-
fidence of his sovereign. Petitions too, pray-
ing for a reform of the very same nature,
were last session of parliament presented to
and received by the House ot Commons.
Sur^y, therefore, the same opinion signified
confidentially in a private letter to a single in-
dividual, and never communicated to the pub-
Ik. cannot be considered as fixing such crimi-
aality upon the respondent, as to subject him'
to so heavy a penalty as the forfeiture of a
bond for so laree a sum as that in question,
however impruuent or ill founded the opinion
itself mav appear to be.
Nevertheless it is for your lordships to
judge, whether, in any other part of the letters
finmded upon in the complaint, the respond-,
ent has been guilty of enaeavourine to insti-
Ste, throueh the medium of Mr. Skirving the
en intended convention to any illegal or se-
ditious measures for obtaining this object.
With great deference to the public prosecutor,
be conceives, that neither the letters in gene-
ral, nor those passages in particular, pnnted
in italics, with a view no doubt to infer crimi-
nality, will warrant any such construction. It
is true, they contain no express words recom-
mendine an adherence to the constitutional
mode 01 petitioning parliament; but when
taken, as they certamly must be, along with
the respondents sentiments in fiivour of that
mode of proceeding, contained even in the
words imputed to the respondent in the
former convention, it must in justice be pre-
sumed^ th^t eyeiy suongeypressioa thftt these
leUers coiil»i% with regsfd to the unanimity '
firmness, and perseverance wit^ which, in to
opinion, the intended cmivention ou^t to '
proceed, must be construed to mean, peite->
vering inthat constitutional mode of appUca-
tion, m the only quarter from which the ob-
ject could be constitutionally obtahoied.
But it is necessary for the respondent to
fat^e your lordships with a minute and cri-
tical investigation of the fiur import of all
those passages in the said letters, on which
the public prosecutor seems to incline to lay
stress. The letters are before your lordships,
and on them^ as a whole, your lordships vrill
form your judgment. The respondent, how-
ever, must call your lordships partia^ar*at-
tention to a few pusages, which nilly demon-
strate, that in giving the advice these letters
contain, the respondent had in view no devia-
tion from the law and constitution. Thus in
one letter he says, ' If you do denounce, from
that moment vou will be conside^Ml as pur-
suing a similar conduct with the JaoMn-
ciubi in FrancCy and instead of bringing
about a comtiitUional redress of grievances^
that you mean to mark characters fbr the in-
tent of destroying them.' In the same letter.
He recommends a determination to manifest
to the whole country an orderly ^ but firm
conduct ; and to expun£e those persons from
the societies who shall be found guilty of
riotcui and dmrdtrly proceedings.' And in
the close of the letter he says, * That nothing
' will more insure success to the friends of U-
berty, than candour, firmness, and conttUu"
tional integrity.'
In the next letter he says, ^ Let Mmgna
Charia and the Bill of R^ht$ direct your
conduct.' But unconstitutional proceedings
and a strict adherence to Magna Charta and
theBill of Rightsare perfectiy mconsistent; for
these are the pillars on which undoubtedly rests
the constitution itself; and the same letter
concludes with these words : * We are the
' true friends to peace and good order^ and ara
* determined to pursue the glorious business
' with intrepid moderatian and conttitutional
' dignity*
The respondent is perfectiy aware that it
may be said, that nothing is more common
than for persons to cloak the most seditious
proceedings under an affected zeal for the law
and constitution. In no case, however, is this
a fair or just presumption, unless where the
measures they recommend to pursue ere, in
themselves, inconsistent with both. It is a
cloak too that can only beassumed in writinn
intended for the scrutinudng eyes of the pub-
lic. Where such expressions, therefore, aro
used in a private and confidential correspond-
ence^ there is not the smallest room for pr^
suming that they are employed for any delu-
sive purpose. They must, therefore, be held
as meant in their true and proper sense ; and
the respondent has no doubt that :f our lord-
ships candour and iustice will give him credit
for the meaiUDg tbal the words codycOt, as*
77]
fiiT Cof^^isMpi ofCoutt*
A. D. 179S.
[78
the rest of the letten^ however stioDghr ex-
pieftsedy conlaiD no aeatiment, or any adTice,
that may not bear a correspondent coastruc
Ahhougfa, therefore, the respondent hear-
tily regrets that he should have entered into
any communication with Mr. Skirving upon '
the anhject, although he disapproves as much
as any body of the illegal ano seditious pro-
oeedhngs, in which that person, by a total de-
viation from his foimer professions, did i^-
tarwards engage ; yet as at the date of those
ktten, thoM views, which afterwards came
to light, could not be discovered by the res-
nopoent, he trusts that ^our lordslups will
De inclined to exculpate hun from any ille^
or seditious intention in this correspondence,
which was finally closed before that m&tuatcxl
body of men. stvhng themselves the British
Convention, iiad even begun to meet. The
foblic proeeculor has been pleased to annex
to the pNBtitbn and complaint, a circular letter
said to have been written by Mr. Skirving in
consequence, as is alleged of the respondent's
suggestions and directions^ contained in one
of ms letters. There is not, however, the
emallest evidence, that the respondent ever
saw or approved of that circular letter, and
thoueh he suggested in general terms, that a
chrahr letter uiould be written, it is impossi-
ble to make him answerable for the contents
of it ; espectalhr as it appears to be in a very
different stvle nom that pointed at in the res-
]iondent's letter, which is confined to a mere
communication of the intendt^d meeting. The
respondent, therefore, is not under the neces-
aitv of attempting any vindication of the cir-
cular letter, seeing that whatever blame may
be attached to it, it is impossible that any part
of it can be thrown upon the respondent, far-
ther than, independent thereof, can be imput-
ed to him from his own letters to Mr. Skirving,
upon which he trusts he has already satisfied
yjwr lordships, that however rash and ill-ad-
vised such a correspondence may appear to be,
it cannot fix upon him any criminauity suffi-
cient to subject him to tmy penal consequen-
ces in the shape of a trial, and consequently
cannot iustly be made the ground for forfeiting
his bail bond.
The only remaining charge is, the respond-
ent's having been present at a meeting of the
British Convention, his having read aloud
upon that occasion, the trial and sentence of
B. Holty for reprinting the duke of Rich-
mond's and Mr. Pitt's resolutions for a parlia^
mentary reform, and having been allowed bv
the meeting, what they were pleased to call
the honours of the sitting ; and a particular
stress appears to be laid upon this being the
€leiienih meeting of the convention ; from
which the respondent presumes, it is intended
to be inferred, that he knew, and must have
approved of all the former proceedings of the
Bntish Convention.
In point of iiMt, however, vour lordships
iriU be informedy that Ibc British Convention^
as they called themselves^ had their first meet-
iBg on Tuesday the 19th of November last^
in the evening, after which their meetings
wereregulariy held in the evenings. At none of
those meetings vras therespondent present; nor
is it charged, that he had any communicatien
with members, bv which he could know what
proceedings had been held from time to time,
nor had he any means of knowing this, except
from the publication of their speeches and
proceedinjgs in the newspaper, called tho
Edinburgh Gazetteer. On the forenoon of
the SOth of November, the respondent very
rashly and improperly, as he acknowled^,
was tempted by curiosity, to go fer a few mi*
nutes into a meeting of one of the comxnit«>
tees. There were there present a very few peo*
pie; nobusiness was done while the respond-
ent was there, nor any resolutions made ; the
persons present were merely engaged in sepa-
rate conversations with each other, when tho
respondent, who had taken up a newspaper,
containing the trial and sentence of D. Holt;
was desired by some person present to read it^
which he accordingly did, without making
any particular animadversions upon it, and he
soon after left the meeting. If what is
called the honours of tiie sitting were conferred
upon him, of which he has no rccoUeetion, he
cannot perceive how any absurdity of a meet-
inj^, of which he was no member, in the shape
ofan honour, which he neither asked nor ao*
cepted of, can be charged against him^; and
how, at any rate, sucn an absurdity can be
reared up as a ground of crimination, unless
the meeting had passed unconstitutional or
seditious resolutions; in which -case, such a
ceremony, if accepted of by the respundent^
might be construed into an accession, on his
part, to such a resolution. But it has been aU
ready mentioned, that no resolution of- any
kind was passed ; nor is the contrary charged
in the complaint, far less any resolutions con*
descended upon to which the respondent'^ ac-
cession can be inferred.
Neither can it be said that the respondent
by being present at this meeting, became ac-
cessary to any of the former, and fer less to
any of the latter proceedings of this conven-
tion. Even though the respondent had been
a member of the convention, it may be
doubted how far he could be chargeable with
an accession to their proceedings, unless in so
far as he either expressly concurred in such
proceedings, or was present when they were
passed, without objecting to them. This
must clearly be the idea of the public prose-
cutor himself; for although a great number
of persons were present at the meetings, no
measures have oeen taken against any of
I them, but such as actually concurred in reso-
lutions of a criminal nature. At the same
time, it would not impair the respondent's
argument, although it should be your lord-
ships opinion that ever^ person inrolled a
member of the convention, should be an-
. sweiable for all thior pcoccediogs^ whether
T93
SS GfiORQE KI.
peraoQBlIy preset 'orii6C; fof rtip^»o»iDg thi»
to be die case, the respondenty wno was ao
meaiber^ and wbo never was. but at one com-
inittee meetings where no resolution was
yaased, can in no view be criminated from any
fhuig that passed, either at the previous or
tubsequent meetings.
It is material also for your lordships to be
informed^ that although the meeting at which
the respondent was nresent is odled the
eleventh meeting of tne convention, yet at
that time their proceedings had only been
published down to Saturday the SSrd of No-
vember. These resolutions appeared in the
bazeUeer of the ftath, and no other paper
was published till some days afler the SOth,
the dfliy on which the respondent is charged
to have been present at a meeting of the con-
veation; and it will be particularly observed,
that these proceedings, previous to the SSrd,
which were all the respondent could possibly
be aoquaioted with, contained none of those
seditious resolutions for which some of its
inembers have so properly been called to
account.
The respondent, therefore, when he un-
guardedly went to that meeting, had it not in
his power to know that any seditious measures
had been adopted by the convention, or even
that they haa depaxtcd from the apparently
i^Histitutional footing on which it is admitted
in the complaint they set out. On the con-
trary, the only resolutions which at that time
had been published^ were still holding out the
pleasure of petitioning parliament, as appears
by the speech of one of the members pub*
Jished ip the Gaietteer of the 96th of No-
vember, which contains the whole resolutions
which had been made public previously to the
meeting at which the respondeiit is charged
with having been present In that speech
the member propoaes the petition to parlia-
ment to be rendered as respectable as possible
by the number of names adhibited thereto.
Althouffh, therefore, it may be true, that be-
tween the S6th, when the Gazetteer contain-
ing the previous resolutions came out, and the
j0Hm TkomMi CaUender [SO
seth, the day on which. tbteraBixHMlctat was
present at the committee meetins, seditious
resolutions may have passed in the conven-
tion, yet of these the respondent was neces-
sarily in Ignorance, till several di^ after,
when the next Gazetteer came out, aad his
presence at that meetin({, therefore, can afibrd
no reasonable presumption of his having ap*
proved, since he could not know of these pro-
ceedinjgs. As therefore nothing was done of
a criminal nature at the only meeting at which
the respondent was present, and he had no
connexion either more or less with any other
meeting, he is humbly hopeful that your lord^
ships will be satisfied, that this charge cannot
amount to any such behaviour on the part of
the resDondent, as to warrant the Rirleiture of
the bail-bond in question.
On the whole, when your lordships reflect
that the respondent has already suffered thre^
months imprisonment, besides a heavy lost
upon giving op the Gazetteer, in oonsequenc^
or the former sentence of your lordships, and
that however imprudent he may have been>
in holding any communication with Mr^
Skirving; that the respondent's letters, how*
ever unguardedly expressed, import nothing
beyond a view to a constitutional reform in
parliament by constitutional means, while
the single meeting at which he was present,
passed no illesal resolution, and the respon-
dent was totafly ignorant at this time, that
any such resolutions had passed at any former
meetings ; he trusts that your lordships justice
and htunanity will lead you to be satisfied,
that no cause has been shown for forteitins
the bail-bond ; and he even flatters himself,
that thouffh a sense of his own duty, and a
just regard for the public interest, induced the
public prosecutor to make the present appli-
cation, he will not be inclined, now that mat-
ters are explained, to regret that your lord«
ships should dismiss the compkiint. In re*
spect whereof, &c. Henrt Erskive.
No further procedure took place, nor did
captain Johnston sist himself in court.
59S. Proceedings in the High Court of Justiciary at Edinburgh,
against James Thomson Callender^ Walter Berry, and
James Robertson^ for Writing, Printing, and Publishing
a Siedilious Libel^ January 38th, February 18th, 19th,
23nd, and March 18th : 33 George III. a. d. 1793.
Curia Justiciada S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nova Sessionis domo de Edinburgh,
vicesimD octavo dieJanuarii, millesimo
septingentesimo et nonagesimo tertio,
per honombiles viroa Robertum Mae
Queen de firaxfield, Dooiinttm Justid*
aikim CleriouBB, Afexandium Munay de
Henderland, Davklera Rae de Eskgrove,
Joannem Swinton de Swinton, Domi«
num Gulielmum Naime de Dunsinao,
baronetum, et Alezandrum Abercromby
de Abercromby, Dominos Commbsion-
arios Justiciaris dicti S. D. N. Regis.
81]
nnd Minjbr a Seddwu UM.
A. D. 179S.
[8S
Curia kghimi affinnala.
Water Berry^ bookseller^ South Bridge
Street, JBdinbufgh; and
JoMf RoberUottf bookseller there, and
fnnter in the Horsewynd of Edinburgh
— Ptoels.
INDICTED and accused at the instance of
Robert Dundas, esquire, of Amiston, his ma-
jesty's advocate, for hb majesty's interest, for
the crimes of writing, prmting, publishing,
and circulating a seditious pamphlet, m
manner mentioned in the criminal hbel raised
Ibereaoent ; bearing, that albeit, by the laws
of this, and all other well governed realms,
tiie wickedly and feloniously writing, and
fnnting, or causing to be written and printed
any araitious pamphlet, containing false,
wickedy and seditiousadsertions, calculated to
degrade and bring into contempt our present
happy system of government, and withdraw
therefrom the confidence and affection of
our subjects ; as also, the wickedly and felo-
niously publishing, circulating, and selling,
any such wicked and seditious pamphlet when
ao printed, or the causing the same to be pub-
lished, circulated, and sold, among the inhabi-
tants of this country, arecriines of an heinous
nature, dangerous to the public peace and
severely punishable : Yet true it is, and of
verity, ttkat the saids. James Thomson Cal-
lender, Walter Berry, and James Robertson,
above complained upoxK have presumed to
commit and are guilty of all and each, or one
or other of the aforesaid crimes, actors or art
and part : in so far as, upon one or other of
the aays of the month of May, in the year
one thousand seven hundred and ninety-
two, or upon some other day in that yeaf to
the public prosecutor unknown, the . said
James Thomson Cal lender did at Edinburgh,
in the county of Edinburgh, or at some other
pkKe to the public prosecutor unknown,
wickedly and feloniously compose and write,
or cause to be composed and written a sedi-
tious pamphlet, intituled, ' The Political Pro-
* gress of Great Britain, or an Impartial Ac-
* count of the principal Abuses in the Govem-
' ment of this Country, from the Revolution
' in 1688. The whole* tending to prove the
' ruinous consequences of the Popular System
* of War and Conquest— the World's Mad
'Business. Part ist' Which pamphlet is
of a wicked tendency, and contains the fol-
lowing, among other wicked and seditious
passages, (pages nineteenth and twentieth
of the pnntra copies of said pamphlet):
^ There is a cant expression in this country,
that our sovemment, is. deservedly, * the
wonder ana envv of the world.' With better
reason it may oe said, that parliament is a
mere out work of the court, a phalanx of
mefcenaries embattled asainst tiie reason,
the happiness, and the liberty of mankind;
The game laws, the dog act, the shop tax,
VOL.XXIIL
the iirindow tax, the pedlar tax, the attor-
ney tax, and a thousand others, give us a right
to wish that their authors had ^n hangS."
A^n, in a note at the bottom of page seventy-
third of the printed copies of the said wicked ^
and seditious pamphlet : ** What our most-
excellent constitution may be in theory, I*^
neither know nor care. In practice it is alto^.
gether a conspiracy of the rich against the
poor." Again, in page fifty-eight : ** The
German princes, and among others, the
elector of Hanover expressed their highest
disapprobation of the projected peace. The*
arguments of George, if such they may be
called, are too frivolous for confutation, or in*-
sertion here. , Portugal and Savoy seconded
the German corps. The emoluments derived'
from war, were greater than their expecta-'
tions fiom peace. The money of the raari- •
time powers and chiefly that of England,
more than the territories of the House of
Bourbon, was the grand object of those petty
Grants, * who fed on the blood of subjects whom
they let out for slaughter.' Compared with
merchants of this (Ascription, an ordinary^
offender is a paragon of innocence. When a
nation sends for sovereigns from such a school,
there appears but a melancholy presaeeof
the prospect before it" Which wicked and
seditious pamphlet containing the foresud
wicked ana sediUous passages, the said James
Thomson Callender delivered to the said
James Robertson and Walter Berry, or to one
and both of them, or one or other of them
upon one or other of the days of the said
month of May, in •the year one thousand
seven hundred and ninety-two, or of April im-
mediately preceding, or June immediately
following, or upon some other dav to the
public prosecutor unknown, in order to be
printed ; and the said James Robertson and
Walter Berry, did one and both or one or other
of them, accord inglv print the said wicked
and seditious pamphlet, or cause the same to'
be printed at the printing office of the said
James Robertson in the Horsewynd aforesaid,
upon some of the days of the said months of
May or June, in the year one thousand seven
hundred and ninety-two, and having caused a
thousand copies or thereby of the said wicked
and seditious pamphlet to be thrown off, they
were sent to the shop on the South bridge
possessed by the said James Robertson and
Walter Berry; and the said James Robertson
and Walter Berry, did one and both, or one or
other of them, during the months of July.
August, September, October, Novrmber, and
December, .in the said ye-ar, one thousand
seven hundred and ninety-two, sell or cause
to be sold many copies ot the said wicked ani
seditious pamphlet from their said shop in
South Bridge-street of Edinburgh. Ana the
said James Robertson having been appre-
hended and carried before John Pringle,
esquire, advocate, our sheriff depute of the
county of Edinburgh, be did upon the twenty*
ninth day of December, seventeen hundred
0
m
S3 GEOKGB III.
P'roceidingt agSmt Wdter Berry
m
and nineiy-lwo, in his presence emit a decla-
ration, which however he refused to sign ; and
the said Walter Berry being likewise exa-
mined in presence of tlie said John Pringle,
esquire, did emit and sign a declaration upon
the said twenty-ninth day of December, seven-
teen hundred and ninety-two ; and the said
James Thomson Callender having been exa-
mined in presence of the said John Pringle,
esquire, on the first day of January, seventeen
hundred and ninety-three, did also of that
date emit and sign a declaration ; which three
declarations are all signed by Uie said John
Pringle, esquire, and being to be used against
the said James Thomson Callender, James
Robertson, and Walter Berry, respectively
Upon their trial, will for that purpose together
with a printed copy of the foresaid wicked and
seditious ))amphlet, being one ef those sold
by the said James Robertson and Walter
Berry as aforesaid, which is subscribed by the
0aid Walter Berry, and the said John Pringle,
esquire, and other persons, be lodged in due
time with the clerk of the high court of jus-
ticiary, before which they are to be tried, that
they may have an opportunity of seeing the
same: At least, times and places foresaid
the said wicked and seditious pamphlet con-
taining the foresaid wicked and seditious
passages, was written, printed, published, cir-
culate, and sold as aforesaid ; And the said
James Thomson Callender, James Robertson,
and Walter Berry, above complained upon,
are all and each, or one or other uf them,
^ilty of the foresaid crimes, or one or other
of them, actors or art and part. All which;
' ar part thereof, being founa proven, by the
■verdict of an assize, before our lord justice
general, lord justice clerk, and lords commis-'
Soners of justiciary, in a court of justiciary, to
be holden by them within the criminal court
house bf Edinburgh, upon the twenty-eighth
4ay of January instant, the said James
Thomson Callender, James Robertson, and
Walter Berry, ought to be punished with the
pains of hw, to deter others from committing
the Ii(ce crimes in all time coming.
And James Thomson Cullender, messenger
at arms, and writer in Edinburgh, likewise m-
dicted in the said criminal letters, being
oft times called in court, and three times at
tlie door of the court-housfe, as tree is, failed
to appear.
Wnereupon his majesty's advocate moved,
that sentence of fligitation and outlawry,
might be pronounced against him.
The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
fioners of justiciary, decern and adjudge the
said James Thomson Callender, to oe an
oiltlaw and furtive fi'om his majesty's laws f
aAd ordain hiin to be put to his highncss's
horn, and all his moveable goods and gear,
to be escheat and inbrought to his m?ijesty's
use, for his contempt and disobedience in not
appearing this day and place in the hour of
cause, to have underlyen the law, for the
crimes specified in the said criminal letters,
raised against him, thereaneni^ ib he who
was lawSilly cited to that efiect, and ofttimes
called in court, and failing to appear as said is.
(Signed) Robt. mac Queek, I. P. D.
Thereafler his majesty's advocate repre-
sented, that he was deterrtiined to use every
endcavoiu to apprehend the person of the sedd
James Thomson Callender, and still to bring
him to trial before their lordships, and a jury
of Iiis country, along with the panels. Berry
and Robertson, and with that view, he was
under the necessity of moving their lordships,
for a continuation against the panels to some
future day, between and which, he would use
every effort to bring Callender to their lord-
ships* bar.
The diet continued against Berrv and
Robertson till Monday the 11th aay of
February next, at ten o'clock.
[In the record of the proceedings of the
Court on the llUiof Feoruary this case is
not mentioned.
No farther proceedings took place witE,
respect to Callender. Berry and Robertsoa
were then proceeded against on another in*
dictment.]
Curia Justiciaria S. D. N. Regis, tenta in
Nova Sessionis dome de Edinburgh,
decimo octavo die Febniarii, millesimo
septingentesimo et nonagestmo tertio, per
honorabiles viros Robertum Macqueen
de Braxfield, Domininn Justicianim
Clericum, Davtdem Rae de Eskgrovc,
JoannemSwintonde Swinton, Dommum'
Gulielmum Naime de Dunsinan, baro«
netum, et Alcxandmm Abcrcromby de
Abercromby, Dominos Commissionarios
Justiciarise dicti S. D. N. Regis.
Curia legitime affirmata.
Intranm
Walter Berry^ bookseller, South Bridge'%
street, Edinburgh; and,
James Robertson^ also bookseller there, and
printer in the Horsewynd of Edinbur^ — >
Panels.*
Indicted and accused — at the instance of
Robert Dundas, esquire, of Amiston, hisma-
jcsty^s advocate, for his majesty's interest, for
the crimes of printing, pnblishmg, circulating^
and selling a seditious writing or pamphlet,
in manner mentioned in the criminal libel
raised against them thereanent; bearing, that
albeit by the laws of this, and of all other
well governed realms, the wickedly and felo-
niously printing, or causing to be printed^ any
seditious writmg or pamphlet, containing
false, wicked, and seditious assertions, calcu-
* A short account of ihts Ca!^ was piibli^ed
by Dr. Anderson in the Bee^ Ko, M, AprQ
24th, 1793.
ami Jwmu Bdmrium^Jw a Sediiiotti Libel. . A* D. 179d«
8&]
toted to dq^ade and hriag ioco oontempt our
nreaenlhaf))Dy system of government, and with-
Ojaw thereovoi the coAfidence and affection
of our subjects; as also the wickedly, andfeloni-
puslypuUisbiag, circulating, and selling such
inrickeo and seclitiotts writing or pamphlet,
when so printed, or the causmg the same to
be publisfied, circulated, and sold among the
inhabitants of this country; are crimes of an
hftinous nature, dangerous to the public
peace, and severely punishable : Yet true it
16, and of verity, tliat the said Walter Berry
aipd James Robertson above complained on,
liave presumed to commit, and are guilty of
all and each, or one or other, of the aforesaid
crimes, actors, or art and part: In so far as
|ipon one or other of the aays of the month
of May, in the year 179^, or upon some other
dsy in that year to the public prosecutor un*
koown, James Thomson Cal lender messenger
at arms, and writer in Edinburgh, having at
jEdinburgb, in tiie county of £cunburgh, or at
some other place to the jpublic prosecutor un-
known, wickedly and feloniously composed
and written, or caused to be composea and
written, a seditious writing or pamphlet, in*
tiluled, ^The Political Progress of Britain, or
an Impartial Account of the principal Abuses
in the Government of this Country, from the
BevoiutioB in 1688. The whole tending to
prove the ruinous Consequences of the Popular
System of War and Conquest The World's
Mad Business. Part 1st. ' which writmg or
painphlet is of a wicked tendency, and con^
tains among other wicked and seditious pas-
sages, the following (pages 19th and 20th of
the printed copies of said pamphlet) : ^ There
IS a cant expression in this country, that our
fiovamment is deservedly ' the wonder and
* eavy of the world ;' with better reason it
nay be said, that parliament is a mere out-
vork of the court, a phalan^i of mercenaries,
embattled a^nst the reason, the happiness,
and the Hberties of mankind. The garoe.laws,
4lie dog act, the shop tax, the window tax, the
pedkr tax, the attorney tax, and a thousand
4illien, give us a right to wish. that their
authors had been hanged." Again, in a note
aft^ie bottom of page 2Srd, of the prin ted copies
of the said wicked and seditious pamphlet ;
^ What our most excellent constitution may
he in theoij, I neither know nor care ; in
firactice it is altogether a conspiracy of tlie
jich against the poor.^ Again, m page 68th,
^ The Grennan princes, and among others,
the elector of Hanover, expressed their highest
disapprobation of , the ]irojeeted peace. Tlie
atniroenCs of George, if such they may be
called^ are too firivolous for confutation, or
insertion here. Portugal and Savoy seconded
the German chorus. The emoluments de-
rived from war, were greater than their ex-
pectaU<His from peace. The money of the
maritinie powm, and chiefly that of Eng-
land, more than the territories of the house
of Bourbon, was the nand object of these
petty tynsois^ * who fea on the blood of sub-
[86
Ejects whoni they let out for slaughter.'
Compared with merchants of this descnption,
an ordinary offender is a paragon of innocence.
When a nation sends for sovereigns from such
a school, there appears but a radancholy pre-
sage of the prospect before it.'' And the said
James Thomson Callander, having delivered
the said wicked and seditious writing or
pamphlet, containing the aforesaid £lse^
wicked, and seditious pass^es, and others
of a similar tendency, to the said James
Robertson and Walter B^rry, or to one
and both of them, or to one or other of
them^ upon one or other of the days of the
said month of May, in the year 1799, or cf
April immediately preceding, or of June im-
mediately following, or upon some other day
to the public prosecutor unknown, the said
James Aobert^on and Walter Berry, did one
and both, or one or other of them, wickedly
and feloniously print the said wicked and
seditious writing or pamphlet, or caused thci
same to he printed, at the printing-office
of the said James Robertson in the Horse-
wyiid, aforesaid, on some of the days of
the said months of May or June in the
year 1799; and having caused a thousand
copies, or thereby, of the said wicked and sedi-
tious pampblet to be thrown off, they, or
part tnereof, were sent to the shop on the
South Bridge, possessed by the said James
Robertson ana Walter Berry ; and the said
James Robertson and Walter Berry did, one
and both, or one or other of them, duriofl;
the months of July, August, September, Oc-
tober, November, and December, in the said
yjear 1793, wickedly and feloniously sell and
circulate, or cause to be sold or circulated,
iropi their said shop, in South Bridge-street
of Edinburgh, many copies of the said wicked
and seditious pamphlet so printed and pub-
lished by them. And the said James Thom-
son Callender having been indicted at the
instance of the public prosecutor to stand
trial before the high court of Justiciary upon
the 28th day of January last, for the crime of
writing and composing the said seditious
pamphlet, he, conscious of his guilt, and ih
order to evade the punishment of the law,
did abscond, and has been fugitate by a sea*
tenc€ of that high court And the sud James
Robertson having been apprehended and car-
ried before John Pringle, esq., advocate, our
sheriff depute of the county of Edinburgh, he
did upon the S9th day of December, 1 792, in his
Eresence, emit a declaration, which however
e refused to si^: and the said Walter
Berry being likewise examined in presence
of the said John Pringle, did emit, and sign
a declaration npon the said 29th day of De-
cember, 1702; which two declarations are
sigped by the said John Pringle, esq., and.
bemg to be used in evidence against the said
James Robertson and Waiter Berry, respec-
tively upon their trial, will, for that purpose,
together with a printed copy of the foresaid
wicked ai|d seditions pampmety being one of
87]
83 GEOKGE UL
Procetdiag$ agniut WaUer Benjf
pa
those sold by th6 said James Robertson and
Walter Berry as aforesaid, which is subscribed
by the said Walter Berry , and the- said John
Pringjle^ esq., and other persons, be lodged in
due time with the clerk of the high court of
justiciary, hetbfe which they are to be tried,
that they may have an opportunity of seeins
the same : at least, times 4uid places foresaid,
the said wicked and seditious writing or pam-
phlet, containing the foresaid wicKed and
seditious passages, and others of a similar
tendency, was wickedly and feloniously print-
ed, published, circulated, and sold, as afore-
said; and the said James Robertson and
Walter Berry, above compluned upon, are,
both and each, or one or other of them, guilty
of the foresaid crimes, or one or other of Uiem,
actors, or art and part AM which, or part
thereof, beine founa proven^. by the veraict
of an assize, before the lord justice general,
lord justice clerk, and lords commissioners of
Justiciary, in a court of justiciary to beholden
Dy them, within the criminal court house of
Edinburgh, upon the 18th day of February,
instant, the said James Robertson and Wal-
ter Berry ought to be punished with the pains
of law, to deter others from committing the
like crimes in all time coming.
* The libel being read over to the panels in
open court, and they being severally interro-
jgated thereupon, they answered they were,
pot guilty.
Fro^rs for the Protecyior, — Robert Dundas,
esa., of Arniston, his majesty's advocate.
Mr. Robert B/oir, advocate, hb majesty's
solicitor general ; and
Mr, James Montgomery, advocate.
Pro'n for the Pahc^.— Mr. Alex. Wight^
advocate; and
Mr. Arch* Fletcher^ advocate.
Mr. FUtcher for the panels, represented,
that he hoped their innocence would be vin-
dicated upon a fair investigation of this mat-
ter. That in the outset ne would observe,
that they had been both in America during
.the war there, where they had manifestea
the highest loyalty, and suffered deeply by
.loss of property on that account. That the
case now before the Court, involves in it no
.less than the liberty of the press, and, tf the
tendency of this prosecution shall strike at
that privilege, it must be infinitely more in-
jurious to the happy constitution of thiscoun-
.-tiy than fifty pubhcations such as that now
-under discussion. ■ If the liberty of the press
is affected, a total darkness in political know-
ledge must ensue, the constitution must re-
ceive a mortal stab, and majr, at last, perish.
•That it is submitted, in point of relevancy,
that, in judging of the pamphlet hbelled,
. the whole must m taken together to decide
on the character of the book, not the three
•passages selected. That the panels surely
. omnot be worse than the author, and his
ncaiiiQg must be sought The coarseness of
«tbea]g«aNO|is are iqore stnkiDg than the
Mtotiment. that the words used meant mora
to mend the constitution, than to bring it in-
to contempt. That the author, it was piain^
was not writing aj^st the institution of
parliament, but against the practice of it;
and the influence of the Crown was a topic of
discussion in the house of Commons itself.
Every subject has a right to canvass and exa-
mine the acts of the ^gislature, and deliver
their opinions; no crime can be inferred;
unless with intent to degrade, and bring into
contempt, the system of government. But
this publication seems to be written from bene^
volence to mankind in general ; — not to vilify,
and calumniate, but with a wish to correct
and reform, and the same words almost have
been used in other authors published long
ago, viz.. Resolutions by the duke of Ricb^
niond published in 1780, and Dr. Burgh's
Political Disquisitbns, ps^ 40a. But, sSly.
whatever may be the criminality of the au-
thor, the same does not apply to the panels.
They only received the copy, printed, and
sold it in the way of their busmess. The
simple act of printing and selling, is not cri-
minal ; besides, great part of it was printed
before in a publication called the B^^^ and
not considered of any seditious tendency.
The panels sold it with no* such view, bat
merely for gain, and not by stealth, but
openly and fairly, and the same was sold by
almost evei^ other bookseller in Edinburgh,
and therefore he craved, that the libel might
be found not relevant.
Mr. Afofi/^omery answered, that the charge
now brought against the panels was not print-
ing certain passages pointed out in the libel^
but the whole pamphlet, which, taken toge*
ther, is a wicked and seditious libel. That
the liberty of the press can only be supported;
bv suppressing; puolications such as that now
libelled on; for, if such licentiousness is not
curbed, the liberty of the press, and the
liberty of the people, must fall together.
That the passages recited were highly crimi-
nal, and inde^ admitted by the counsel for
the panels, and the intention must be pre-
sumed, from the first reading of them. That
passaftges similar may have teen wrote is no
excuse. The temper of the times nnist merit
consideration. Tne minds of the people may
be inflamed to gross enormities by pulliic»-
tionsat one time, that would have no bad
efiect at another, and the record of the Court
will show how iU-timed, this pubUcation was.
9dly. The printer and pubUsher, in* this case,
was worse than the author, as in forgeiyv the
circulating is worse than the fotger; -and^
therefore, upon the whole, there could remaim
no doubt of^the relevance. And the panels
with the libel, ought to be remitted to the
knowledge of an assize in common focm. *
The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
sioners of justiciarv, having considered the
criminallitel laisea and pursned^at the in-
stance of his majes^^s advocate, fw his. ma-
89] ami Jamet BeiaiU(m,fur e SmSHotu UbeL A.O. 179S.
[DO
jostj's interaiCy a^MiMt Waher Berry, aid
James Robertson, panels, with the foreping
ddMte; they find the libel relevant to infer
the fNUDS of law; but allow the paneU and
each of them to prove all facts and circum*
stances, that may tend to ex€ul]iaie them, or
alleviate their guilt, and remit the panels
with the libel as found relevant to the know-
ledge of an assise.
(Signed) Robt. M'Quebk.
The following persons werd then named to
pass upon the assize of the panels. '
John Balfour jun., merchant in Edinburgh.
Alexander Wrigh^ wine merchant there.
Archibald Campbell, brewer there.
Thomas Hotchfcis, brewer there.
James Clark, larrier there.
Wadler Smeatoh, painter there.
James Milne, tanner there.
John Wilson, coachmaker there.
Alexander Ponton, architect there.
Peter Cunningham, goldsmith there.
Archibald Borthwick, banker there.
William Ainslie, sadler there.
James Hamilton, upholsterer there.
Alexander Laing, builder there.
Alexander Reid l^uilder there.
Who being all lawfully sworn, and no ob-
jection to the contraiy,
The pfocorators for the prosecutor, for
proof of the libel, prooeeded to adduce the fol-
lowingwitnesses, who being all lawfully sworn,
putted of malice and partial counsel, emitted
their depositions viva voce^ in presence of the
Court and Juiy, without being reduced into
vrriting, in terms of the statute.
1st, John Bromn, journeyman printer in
the{»intine-office of James Robertson, printer
Horsewynd, Edinbuigh.
[Lord Henderland came into Court.]
. Snd, Thoautt Oliver, apprentice, as a com-
poeitory to the said James Robertson.
3rd, James Bertie, apprentice, as a compo-
attor, to the said James Robertson.
• 4tfa, William Curror, writer in Edinburgh.
SihfWillittm MiddUttm, sheriff-officer in
Edinbur^.
' 6th, .Robert Hamiit<m, numing-stationer
m Edinburgh.
7 th, Jama Rae^ servant to the countess of
Hyndford.
8th, William Wood, bookseUer in Edin-
biireh.
> Thereafter the prosecutor being about to
adduce witnesses for proving the oeclarations
Hbelled on — The panels judicially admit,
that the declarations libelled on were emit-
•ted by them respectively, voluntarily, and
freely, oi the di^te^they bear, and that they
were sober and in their sound senses.
• Afler the foresoin^ admission was wrote
out, the panels declined signing the same,
and the following witnesses were adduced for
proving the decbuations.
9th, WilHam^Scoit, procurator fiscal of the
county of Ediiibiirgh. ....
lOtby Jotipb Maekj writer in Edinbimh.
The declamtions libelled on, having Men
proved by the depositions of the two last
witnesses were read over in open court.
And thereupon the protrs for Ihe pro-
secutor declared, that they closed their evi^
dence. And the following witnesses were
adduced in exculpation.
1st, John Lamb, apprentice to the said
James Robertson.
Snd, Captain Alexander Cameron, of his
majesty's 37th regiment of foot, presently
quartered in Edinburgh Castle.
Srd, Mr. William Creech, bookseller in
Edinburgh.
4th, Elphingston Balfimri merchant there.
5th, The Rev. Mr. Jamee Fraaer, minister of
the eospel residing in Edinburgh.
6tn, John Bf//, bookseller in Edinburgh.
7th, Alexander Thmiuon, tea-dealer in
Drummond-strect, near Edinburgh.
8th, John Millar, optician and mathema-
tical instrument maker in Edinburgh.
9th, ITumtae Reid, watchmaker in Edin*
burgh.
10th, Jomei Dickson, bookseUer in Edio-
biureh.
The procurators for the panels thereupon
declarea, that they closed their evidence in
exculpation.
The evidence was then summed up on the
part of the prosecutor by his majesty's advo-
cate, on the part of the panels by Mr. Alex^^
andcr Wight, advocate, and lastly by the lord
justice clerk.
The assize were then ordained to enclose
and return their verdict next day at two
o'clock.
Curia, Sfc. \9th February, 1793.
Inlran,
Walter Berry and James Robertson, before
designed — Panels.
Indicted and accused as in the preceding
sederunt.
The persons who passed upon the assize
of the panels, returiira the following verdict :
4t Edinburgh, the ISth day of Feb., 1793.
The assize having inclosed, made choice of
the said James Hamilton to be their chan-
cellor, and of the said Alexander Ponton to be
their clerk ; and having considered the cri-
minal libel raised and pursued at the in-
stance of his mayest^'s advocate for his ma*
jest/s interest agamst Walter Berry and
James Robertson, panels, the interlocutor
of relevancy pronounced thereon by the
Courty the evidence adduced in proof of the
hbel, and evidence adduced in exculpation ;
thev all in one voice find it proven, that the
said James Robertson did pnnt and publish,
and that the said Walter Ber^ did publishonly^
the pamphlet libelled on*. * In witness whefe«
of the aiud chancellor and defk bate sub*
01]
33 GfiORGB III.
Proeee^Utigt dgaitut Waker Bflrrjf
cw
sctUbed these pretieiiU, in their names aud by
tfaflir appoiatmenty place, and date foresaids
.(Signed) James H^jhlton, chancellor.
Alex. Pomton^ clerk.
Parties procurators having been beard upon
the import of the foregoing verdict, the
lords commissioners of justi<!iary supersede
^vising the foregoing verdict, and debate
thereon till Friday next, the 33d instant, at
two o^clock aflemoon.
In obedience to the order of Court In the
trial of James Robertson and Walter Berry,
the following minutes were made up and
given in :
Wight for the panels represented, that
upon comparing together the criminal letters,
the interlocutor upon the relevancy and the
verdict returned by the jury, it would be
evident to the .Court, that no punishment
could be inflicted upon the panels, but that
they were well entitled to eipect a judgment
dismissing them tunplicUerfrom the bar. The
criminal letters set forth in the m^or propo-
sition, that, ^ the wickedly and feUmiouzi^
fainting,, or cauung to be printed, ai\)r ted^
ttbttf writine or pamphlet, containing false
miched, ana udUidus assertiontf wculaied
to degrade and bring into contempt our pre-
sent happy tystem ^ gooemment, and with^
draw tHer^rom the confidence and affection
ef our tutyecUf as also the wickedly and
feloniously publishing, circulating, and sel-
ling any such wicked end seditious writing
or pamphlet, when so printed, or the causine
the same to be piibhshed, circulated, and. sold
among the inhaoitants of this country, were
crimes of an heinous nature, dangerous to the
public peace, and severely punishable." And
m the laew of showing that the panels were
guilty <* of all and each, or one or other of the
aforesaid crimes, actors or art and parL*' the
criminal letters proceeded to state, that James
Thomson Callender, messenger at arms, and
writer in Edinburgh, had wickedly ana felo-
niously composed and written, or caused to be
composed and written, a seditious writing or
pamphlet, intituled ' TnePonttcal Progress of
* firitain,'&c. containing certain passages par-
ticularly inserted ; and then went on as fol-
lows : " and the sud James Thomson Cal-
lender having delivered the said wicked and
seditious writing or pamphlet containing the
aibresaaid false, wicked, and seditious pas-
sa^s, and others of a similar tendency, to the
said James Robertson and Walter Berry, or to
one and. both of them, or one or other of
them, upon one or other of the days of the
•aid month of May in the year 1792, or of
April immediately preceding, or of June im*
mediately following, or upon some other day,
J> the public prosecutor unknown the said
ames Robertson and Walter Berry did, one
pxid both, or one or other of them, wiekedfy
futd feloniously print the said wicked and
seditious writing or pamphlet, or caused the
tame (to be.pimted, ai iheipriatiA^ffioe af
the s^d Jiimes So^ertson in the fiArstwyail
(ifor^said, &c. And \\m said James Rolieit*
son .and Walter Berry did, jone ^uid bolfa, or
one or other of them, dicing tiie months of
July, August, September, October, Kovem*
her, and December in the said ^year 170$,
wickedly and feloniously sell, and circuiate, or
cause to Jbe sold and circulated from their
said shop in South Bridge-street of S^din*
burgh, many copies of the said wicked and
seditious pamphlet, so printed and pub-
lished by them, &c. At least times and
places foresaid, the said wicked and sedi*
tious writing or pamphlet cpntaining the
foresaid wicked and seditious passages, and
others of a siipilar tendency, was wickedly
and feloniously printed, j}ublished, circu-
lated and sold ^ aforesaid: and the said
James Robertson and Walter Berry above
complained upon are both and each, or one
or other of them guilty of the foresaid
crimes, or one or other of them actors or
actor, or art and part thereof. All which or
part thereof being found proven by the verdict
of an assize before the lord justice general, lord
justice clerk, and lords commissioners of jus-
ticiary, in a court of justiciary to be hofden
bv them within the criminal court-house of
Edinburgh, upon the 18th day of February
instant, the said James Robertson and Walter
Berry ought to be punished with the pains of
law, to deter others firom committing the like
crimes in all time coming.'' Such was the
charge exhibited against the panels; and
upon considering that charge, the Court by
.their interlocutor of relevancy ** found the
libel relevant to infer the pains of law.; bui
allowed the panels and each of them to prove
all facts ana circumstances that may tend to
exculpate them or alleviate their guilt, and
remitted the panels, with the libel as found
relevant to the knowledge of an assize/' Hie
question, therefore, that came now to be de-
termined hy the Court was, whether the jury
have or have not found it proved, that thi
psuiels were guilty of the cnmc imputea- to
tbiero, in the criminal letters thus fouxid rele-
vant by the Court And in order to show
that they had found no such thing, it was
only necessary to look at the verdict, which,
after mentiomng their having considered the
libel, the interlocutor of relevancy, and the
proof, proceeds shortly as follows : '< They all
m one voice find it proven that the ssud
James Robertsuu did print and publish ; and
that the said Walter Berry did publish only
the pamphlet libelled on." To trouble the
Court with a long comment upon tlie import
ofthis verdict, would be equallv indecent 83
it must be unnecessary. For although hours
were to be spent in doing so, the result could
only be, that it went no further than to find
that one of the panels did print and publish,
and that the other did publish onlv the
pamphlet libelled. This, however, could not
possibly amount to a finding that the .crimes
miputed to the panels in the libel, and found
95] and James Ro6ert»nyJbr a Seditioit's Libel. . A. D. 1799.
P*
rtlev^nt by the tntdddbatot of the Coort, to
isfer the {Mmi9 6f fctw, were in any degree
pioTed a^inst (hero. For in the first p&ce,
ti^ vermct was totally deficient in this re^
speet/ that it did not establish any corpni
Mkti; for, althongh it fonnd that the
pampbYet libelled on was primed and pub-
nshed by one of the piuidlS) and published by
the oth^, it did not find that the said pam-
jlblet wad, as alieged in the libel, a seditmn
pamphlet. Had this pamphlet been de-
scribed only as a sediticftts pamphlet, or as
contaimng certain wicked add seditions pas-
flBges inserted in- the fibel, there might perhaps
have been some colour (atthoiigh a narrow
one) for pretending that the verdict imphed
that the pamphlet was seditions. But the
Court woiud observe^ that the pamphlet i^as
described in the criminal letters by its title;
and although the lft)el afterwards alleged,-
that it Was of a wicked tendency, and con-
tained, amon^ other wicked and seditious
passaged, the following^ &c. ; yet, ^ere was no
pound to conclude from the verdict, that the
jmy, by referring to the pamphlet libelled,
did fina the innuekidos against that pamphlet,
or idxaX it was of a wicked tendency, ana con-
tained seditious passages, proved; Bven sUp-
paslng it probaMe that, by referring to the
pamphlet libelled, they meahtto reler to the
pamphlet as hbelled ; or, in other words, to
the sedUums pamphlet hbelled, it would be
sofficient for the panels to observe, that they
had omitted to do so, and that the omission
could not nOw be supplied. In the next
phce, the Court would observe, that the
crime imputed to the panels in the libel, was
iMt simply their having printed or published
the alleged wicked and Seditious pamphlet
therein mentioned, but their having done so
wnckedhf and fthnibutly. The public prose-
cutor was sensible that d pamphlet, hovvfever
wicked and seditious^ mis^nt be printed and
published by a printefr or bookseller, without
soch printer of bookseller's having the
smallest intention to excite sedition, or with-
out his ev^ knchving that the pamphlet had
such a tendency. It did not, therefore, occur
to his lord&hip to bring the panels to trial
before this Court for the mere act of printing
or publishinTg what he considered to be a
seditious pamphlet ; but, on the contrary, he
brought them to trial upon a charge of their
having wicktdfy and feloniously published
ttid pamphlet; therebv clearly connecting
the printing and publishing with a criminal
6r seditious intention^ ^and making such
intention the very essence of the criminal
charge. But upon looking into the verdict,
the Court would perceive, that the jury had
not found it proved that either of the panels
vrereguiHy in that respect; or that in prrint-
ibg and publishing the pdmphlet, they either
Acted wickMlly and feloniously, or with a/iy
<iriminal intention, or w<Jre actuated by any
other mOti^e^ but what liiust be admitted to
be hrwful, Til. the prosectfting their respeuire
etnptoyments for the support of thtoateWef^
mve their ^lilies. In snort the jvMyoni/
found it proved, that they did what the poblip'
prosecutor had not imputed to them as a cii^'
minal act. Nor would it avail the prosecutor
to found upon that part of the libel whieh^
charges art and part; fot even there they
were charged only with being art or part tti
feloniously and wickedly printing and pab«
hshing. The panels should think themselves^
much to blame if they were to resort to argu-
ments, in order to sliow that the verdict of
a jury musli be taken, as the jury have eitei#
it ; and that it must be in vain either wt ^
public prosecutor to allege that it meansr
more, or to a panel to contend that li mean#
less, than what the words in which it is ex-*
pressed do, in the common acceptation of Ibftw
guage, convey. The panels might with safety
admit, that if in this case the juiy had found
it proved, < that the said James Robertson did
' print and publish, and that the said Walt^#
' Berry did publish only, the pamphlet libelled
* ori, in the manner' or * in the terms libelled/
there would have been somfe colour for mtSn^
taming, that they had found it proved, that
the panels had done so wickedly and f^lo-^
niously, and that the verdict was tantamount
to one finding them guilty of the crime \i^
belled ; but as the jury, in fact, only found thai
they printed and published < the pamphlet
' libelled on,' without adding a single t^ora
to such fmding, it was perfectly clear, thai
they had neither found the panels guiltv of
the crime libelled, nor of any other crime.
For how plausible soever it might be, to tell
a jury, that the printing and publishing a se-»
ditlous pamphlet, did of itself necessarily
imply, in the printers and publishers a sem"
tious, or wicked and felonious intention, witlW>
oul the necessity of proving such intention
aliundt; yet it was necessary that a jury
should speak in plain, direct, and positive
terms : and as, in this case, they had confined
their verdict entirely to the printing arid pub-
lishing, it was impossible to make sfuch finding
imply that such printing and pubiislrins pro-
ceeded fix>m a criminal intention. If the
jury hjld iri this case, af\er finding it proved,
* that the said James Robertson did print and'
* publish j and that the said Walter Berry did
* publish •only,' the pamphlet libelled' on,
aaded, ^ but find it not proved that they did
* so with a seditfous, Wicked, or felonious in--
* tention,* it would certainly have behoved
the Court to assoilzie the panels, and to dis«
miss them immediately from the bar. But
although the verdict actually pronounced by
the jury was not so particular as the one here
supposed, it was in ejQTect and substance the
same, ind must be attended with the same
legal cohsetiuences : for as it did not find
the panels guilty of the crime fchar^ed against
them, but only of an act, which> from aught
that cOuld appear f^om the verdict, even when
compared with the libel and the interlocutor
of relevtt&cy, might have bee& perfectly in«
96J
Sd G£OR6E III.
Proceedings dgaintf Watier Befr^
fSff
Bocentyit was impossible that any pimishf*
ment eould be inflicted upon them. Were
there any doubt in this case, it misht be re-
moved by putting cases of a similar natore;
and although the panels were unwilling to
consume the time of the Court by a variety
of illustrations of that sort, they would take
the liberty shortly to put the case, that a per-
son had been charged in a criminal libel with
having received stolen goods, knowing them
to he atolen^ and that the juiy had returned
a verdict, finding it proven, that the panel
had received the good* libelled. It evidently
could not be maintained, that, in conseauence
of such a vei^ict, he could be punisned as
euilty of the crime imputed to him in the
£bel. Nay, even although the jury had
found it. proved that he nad received the
etolen goodi libelled, it would have been
egually incompetent to punish him as a reset
or theft, seeing that they had not likewise
found, tnat he knew the goods to be stolen,
as in that circumstance consisted the essence
of the crime. But if this be so, it must of
course be admitted, that no punishment can
1m inflicted upon the panels, in consequence
of the verdict returned against them, in re-
spect that although, by that verdict^ the juiy
found it proved, that they had printed and
publbhed the pamphlet libelled on, they nei-
ther found it proved, that such pamphlet
¥ras a seditious pamphlet, nor that the panels
printed and puolished it wickedly and felo-
niously, with a seditious or wicked intention.
Without, therefore, troubling their lordships
fiirther upon a point that appeared to be so
exceedingly clear, the panels would now con-
clude in the firm confidence of its being the
decided opinion of the Court, that no further
procedure could be had asainst them, and
that they ought to be assoilzied from the cri-
mixud prosecution, and immediately dis-
missed from the bar.
Advocatw answered, that with whatever
show of confidence the panels a£Pected to
talk of the objection which they had now
stated to the legal import and c^ctof the
unanimous verdict returned agginst them,
be trusted in bemj; able, by a veiy few
observations, to satisfy the Court, that the
verdict was amply sumcient for carrying the
dear intention of the jury into effect, and
obliging their lordships to pronounce the
judgment of the law theredn i^nst these
panels. That in one observation ne perfectly-
agreed with the counsel for the panels, that
it was not the mere printing or publishing a
Mditious pamphlet which was the oftenee
imputed to the panels in the criminal let-
ters under which they had been tried, but
the printing and publishing it with a wicked
and felonious intention ; - and it was impos-
sible to read. the criminal letters without
observing at one glance, that this was the
only offence imputed to them, and to the
truth or falsehood of which imputatbn the
▼trdict could alone apply, Thai it was almost
unnecessary to remind their loidsHips, that,,
by the criminal law of this country, juries
were at liberty to adopt what form or style of
expression they pleased in their verdicts, and
were tied down to no precise form of words
in the expression of their opinion upon the>
matter wtiich they were sworn to try: that
thev might either return a general verdict of
guilty, or not guilty, proven, or ^ not proven ;
or a special veniict, as was done in the present -
case, finding certain facts and circumstancea
of the charge proven, and thereby devolving-
on the Court tne duty of expounding the ver-
dict, and applying the law to the facts which
they had found proven. That it was only ne-*
cessary for the verdict to express, in termS'
sufficiently certain and unambiguous, what*
was their opinion, and what was their mean-t
ingy to the exclusion of all other meanings*
whatever; particularly so, that the veniict-
should not admit of being construed into an-
opinion of the jury that the panels were
innocent; in which case, he admitted, that -
no doubt could remain of their Icudships
adopting the milder construction, by holding
it as a verdict of acquittal ; or, if it was abso- '
lutely inextricable and unintelligible, lefiising.
to give any effect to it whatever, and, as a*
necessary consequence, dismissing the pa*
nels iiom the bar. The question, there-
fore, was, whether or not the jury had found,
with sufficient certainty of expression, the.
truth of the offence imputed to the panels.-
And a little attention would satisfy the Court»
that they had not only found the guilt of the.
panels with sufficient certainty, but that it
was impossible to twist the verdict into any.
other meaning, or to construe it into a verdict*
of acquittal. The words of Uie verdict werei'
VThey all in one voice find it proven, that the'
' said James Robertson did print and publish, -
' and that the said Walter Berry did publish.
^ only, the pamphlet libelled on.' This finding,
of the verdict proceeded in the common and
usual form, upon a narrative of, and reference
to, the criminal letters themselves. And to-
dbcover what the opinion of the jury was.
with regard to the pamphlet, was to look back
to the ubel itself, to which they had referred
in their verdict, where it was described dis-
tinctly and precisely as a wicked and seditious .
pamphlet, and to the interlocutor on the re-
levancy of that libel, which the jury had also
referred to, by which the Court had found it
to be seditious, and sent as such to the jury
for their consideration : That it was in vain,
therefore, for the panels to contend, that the
corpus delicti was not here tbund, or that
the jury had not, in plain and clear termb,
found, that the pamphlet was seditious ; bo-
oause, although the preamble or title page of
tiie pamphlet itself is quoted in the libel, yet
the prosecutor did not simply describe it as
a pamphlet bearing that title prefixed, but as
a seditujus writing or pamphlet intitul^ * The
Political Progress, &c.; which writing or
pamphkt is of a wicked tcnden^' That
9n
mi tmm Utiertiimjor a ttMitui UheL A.1I. ITMT
Pi
mdi beiDs the punpUel libelled on, tke
juiy woukf liBve been iDTohring their verdict
a obaeitritf if thej hftd used a single word
moie tfatB they OAve done to ex[f ress tMr
Ofhiinii of the penmblet bdng seditious ; and
mpmk this point or the ngument, he was in
the judgment of the Coui^ thai the objee*
taao was perfectly frivolous. But what seemed
to be due&v- trusted in by the panelsy was
the other objection to the verdict viz. that
thoi^ the jury had found the pmitine and
pwUiahing proven, vet they haa not KHind
tfaoB to have been done by the panels, with
a wieked and seditions intention, as charged
in the crimioa] letters; and as the mere
pvialing and pubiishinc a seditious pamfjhlet
w«s Jiot imputed to the panels as a crimen
and might be done with perfect innocence,
tfcM yaef had not found it proven, what the
fffosecutor had allefled against them. That
at first si^t, tM objection bore a
>ie appeaianoe, it would appear to the
J on a httle attention, perfectly fallacious ;
lor it was clear, ^at the juiy did not mean
to aoquit the prisoners, as m that event, they
vpoola unquestionably have returned a ver-
dict either of not cuilty, or not proven. In
l^ace of this, they had feund the printing and
fmbliahing proved against the one, but the
publtshin|[ only aaainst the other. By doing
thk, the juiy had in feet found the panels
salty, m two reasons: Ist, Because the
finding it proven, that the panels had printed
and published a seditious pamphlet, implied
that the Jjwy thought this was done with a
felonious mtentioB ; as otherwise they woidd
have found that it was not done with a felo-
nious intention; or, in other words, would
have retunaed a verdict not guilty, or not
proven : and 9dfy, Because printiDg and ptib-
nslung must be taken in the sense in which
tharo words were used in the criminal letters;
w. a wicked and fdomous printing and pub-
Ishmg, and which was the legal and only
aacepmtion of theee words, when used in the
vwdiet: thatitwottldhavebeenavery diflfe-
nat case, if the criminal letters had contained
iltunait condueions ; or if the words * print-
< mg and publishina' had been used by tiiepro-^
Wbemof in a two-fold sense; 1st, as a felo-
niottB arinting and publishing a seditious
pUBpluet; ami 9dly, merely printing and
pohlslune such pamphlet, without saying whe-
thtf a felonious intention accompanied the
pliBltin^ uid publishing, or not. In such cfl!se,
the clhfoction of the panels would have been
very forcible indeed ; as it would have been
hapoeaibie in such ease to have maintained,
that the jwy had used the words in the fiiat
aanse, to tfc!e eachision of the second ; and
th«r finfing wiookl rather have applied to the
second sense, in which the terms * printing
< and publishng^ were used in the libel c but
tfMit it was hnpossible to nmintaia an^r such
aoetnne at present, where the toms printmg
and pubfishing wero used in tte libel only in
VOL.XXIIL
one sense, viz. a wicked and felonious arinting
and publishina, of which the panels weiS
therein accused, and upon which the jury had
rotumed a verdict, finding that the panels had
prinUd and puhUtked^ t. «. printed and pub^
lished as charged in the libel, and in no other
sense whatever : that if the jury had meant
merely to find the feet of printing and publishi^
iniTy in contradistinction to the printing and
publishing charged against the panels, it vaa
their duty, and they most unquestionably
would have said so ; as was done in the case
of Mr. Stein for bribery, where the jury found
the feet of eiving the money proven, but
found it, at the same time, not proven that
the same was done with a crinunal intention.
The verdict in that case, was, ^ The jurjr
unanimously find the delivny of 500/. sterling,
to Mr. Bonar proven ; but So not find the ii^
tention of seclucing and coirupting the said
John Bonar proven.'' The prosecutor can
hardly doubt that, if the last part of the find-
ing, in that case, had been omitted, and th^
jury had simpler found, upon trial of the in-
moictment against Stein, '^ the delivery of
500/. steriiag, to Mr. Bonar proven," your
kwdships would upon the import of that
special yerdict, have pronouncea an adequate
judgment against Mr. Stein; because, by
finding the dehvcry of the money to Mr.
Bonar proven, the jury found the truth of tha
fects stated in the indictment, vis. a criminal
not an innocent delivery, and for which Mr.
Stein was responsible ; but the jury in that
case, being of opinion, that though the mere
delivery was proved, yet the criminal nature
of that delivery was not, found so in expresa
terms; and had the iury in the preseift
case, been of opinion that the mere act of
printing and ptiblishing a pamphlet, whether
seditious or not, was all that was proved
against the present panels, but that th^
wicked and felonioiis printing and publish*
Ing charaed asainst them was not proved^
they woiud in like manner have followed up
their verdict, upon the bare fiict of printing
and publishing with a declaration to that
e#ect, similar to what was done by the jury
who tried Mr. Stein. In the case ox a charge
of murder, for instance, if a jury had found
that A fired a pistol at B, by which B was
wounded, and of which wound he instantly
cKed, ana, as they are bound to no precise
form or style of words, had been pleased t6
return their verdict to your lordships in that
shape, in place of the mora simple and ob-
vious verdict of guilty, your lordships, as in
the case of all special verdicts, being obliged
to decide upon tneir import and to deduce the
legal inference firom the facts foimd by the
jury, would in the prosecutor's apprehension
save been obliged to pronounce a capital sen-
tence. But, ir the jurv in such case had, as
in Stein's case, followed up such finding witti
a decl8ratk>n, that the intention to mutder
did not appear to them proved; seotpnoe df
H
9S\ 9S 6EOROE IIL . . Pheeedu^ agmatt WitU^r Baiy
£10t
death could not have followed, but an arbi-
n punishment, adequate, as your lordships
„ ^ t think fit, and suitable to the circum-
stances of tlie case before you : that tlie pro-
secutor farther admitted, that, as it was the
duty, and in the power of a jury, expressly to
fioa, that the wicked or felonious intention
xhar^d, was or was not proved, so it was
equaUy competent fur them to do this by im-
phcation ; and that cases mi^ht occur, where
4he verdict could only admit of being con-
atrucd into an acquittal from the offence
charged, and into a tinding that the intention
.was not* proved ; but tliat this was not the
^case now in hand, where tlie verdict could
only admit of being construed into an unani-
inous opinion of the guilt of the panels, as
chargea. Had the jd^, for instance, in the
present case, found in the following terms,
*' Tliat James Robertson printed and pub-
lished on/y, and Walter Berry published mtfy
the panipldet libelled,'*— The prosecutor ad-
mits, that in his opinion, this would have
l»oen tantamount to finding, that the panels
liad only printed and pubh&iicd, but not in
4he sense charged in tlie criminal letters, vis.
.tluLt they had done so wickedly and lyoni-
ciisly, and would have been, ex J^acra ver-
^harum, as unambiguous and effectual an opi-
nion of the panels innocence, as if tlie jury
^uwd returned a verdict of not piiUy, or not
jproven, in general terms, or had found as in
Uie case of Stein, <pecta%, that thoueh the
*lact of printing was proved, the wickra and
felonious intention ot doing so was not. But
in the present case the jury had not used the
Jul verb onl^ in that sense ; nor was it possible
4o give to It any other effect than this, that
Bobertson was guiltv of both printing and
•publiahing as charged in the indictment but
that Berry was eudty omfy of publishing, as
charged in the indictment. The adverb ^ only''
.was not a technical term, admitting of IhU
one sense, but was like every other word used
}n common speech, pliable and generic, which,
placed in one part ot a sentence misht convey
cne meanine,and placed in anouier, would
implv just the reverse, in the mouth of the
speaker or writer. If it had been used twice
in the verdict by the jury, as above supposed,
it would, as already observed, have been tanta-
mount to an acquittal; but used only once, with
relation to Mr. Berry, and for the piu-pose of
distinguishing his case from that of Mr.
Kobertson, it lias just the oppobite effect, and
.affords positive and incontrovertible proof of
•the very reverse, vix. That this is a verdict of
conviction, and that verdict as clearly and
.sufficiently expressed, to the exclusion of
.every supposition of an intention to find the
.nanels innocent, as if the jury, in place of
innding, which they have a right to do, a
speci^vcrdict, bad adopted the more simple
mode of a general verdict of proven or guilty.
•That tlie pruseculor, in support of wbt he
was now stating, could not avoid refemqg
their kxdshlps to the case quoted fur the
panels in the course of the pleading, Bes
venui Woodfall,* which, so tar firom beiog
for their argument, dkl, in bis apprebe&sioiv
completely sup|»ort the view whicn he had-at
present given of the legal import and efei
of the present verdict. Mr. Woodiall was
tried upon an information brou^t j^nst
him by the attorney-general, tor pnntiag
and publishing in the Public Advertiaer.a
seditious libel signed Junius. Upon th^ trkl
the jur^r found him guilty of the printing aad
pubushing o»/v. The coimsel for the CroNm
insisted that this was a verdict of guilty; <ba
counsel for the defendant on the other haai^
insisted that the addition of the term aa^
made it amount to a verdict of acquittal; .at
least, that it was an imperfect verdict, aas
that a new trial ought to be grani»l. Xbe
cause was iuUy hea^ before lord MaasfieU^
on Friday the S8d of June, and Tuesday, tb#
Sd of July 1770 ; and after full deliberation^
his lordship, on the SOth of November thcnh
after, delivered the opinion of the Court as
follows: <<The prosecution is an informa-
tion against the defendant, for printing and
publismng a libel in the Public Advertiser,
si^ed Junius; the tenor of which is set out
with proper averments, as to the meaning of
the libel, the subject matter, and the persons
concerning which and of whom it speaks,
with innuendoes filling up all the blanks, and
the usual epithets.''t. ^^ lordship then pro-
ceeds to state the import of the evidence,
which was clear, and tne verdict of the jury,
whichwas '< guill^ of the printing and publish-
ing oitfy;" — and after stating some qiecial
circumstances not connected with the main
question, and that it was the opinion of the
Court, tlttt the word omfy must stand part of
the verdict; and \hat it was impossiUe, as
the attomey-eeneral had argued, to vail that
word, his lordship stated it, ** Beins therefore
a question of law upon the foce of taa verdict,
the defendants motion must be considered
upon the ground of the word omfy standing;
was a omitted there emld he no donSi.
Guilty of printing and publishing, where there
is no other charge, is ' guiHy'; for nothiag
more b to be foiuid by the jury.
'< In the case of the King and Williams^
the jury found the defendant ' ^lilty of printixtt
' and publishing the North Briton, No. 45?
the clerk entered it up * gtfilty*, ai^ no ob>
jection was ever made.
*^ Where there are more char^ than one,
guilty if some omfy^ is an acqwttal as lo tbs
rest.
** But t« this imfonmotkm there is ao ckmrgt
except for printimg umd puhiishimg,
** clearly there can be no judement of ae*
quittal; hecoute the Joet foisdhy the jmrj^ tt
the very crime tkey mere to try.
** Theonly question is ' wh^her by an^ pos-
* ability, the woid omfy, can bavo a
• See it anti^ Vol. 30, p. 893.
t AiUt^ Vol 20, p. 917.
1013
mnd Jamet iUherUtmJbr a SeiBHuu LiieL A. D. 1793<
[10*
< iifs tdiich troiild afiect or contradict the ver-
* diet/
** That the law, as to the sul^ect matter of
the verdict, is, as I have stated, has been so
Men unanimously agreed by the whole conrt
mon ereiy report I nave made of a trial for a
BDel^ tint it would be improper to make it a
question now in this place.
^ Airiong those that concurred, the bar
Vflll recollect the dead, and the living not now
bere.
^ And we all again declare our opinion,
that the direction is light and according to
law.
*^ This dhieetion, though often siven with an
express request from me, that if there was the
lei^ doubt they would move the Court, has
never been complained of in court. And yet if
had been wrong, a new trial would be of
course. It is not now complained of.
^ Taking then the hw to be according to
tlus direction the question is, ' Whether an^
* meaningean be put upon the word onh, as it
* stands upon tibe rccora, which will afiect the
* verdict.'
*^ If they meant to sanr^ they did not find it
a libel, or did liot find the epithets, or did not
fmlany express malicious intent, it would
not afiect the verdict; because none of
these tl^gs wereto be proved or found either
way.
** If, by ** only" they meant to say, * that
* ihey did not find the meaning put upon the
' paper by the information,' they should have
acquitted him.
*' If they had expressed this to be their
meaning, the verdict would have been incon-
sistent and repugnant ; for they ought not to
find the defendant guilty, unless they find the
nieanine put upon the paper by the informa^
tion and jud^ent of acquittal ; ought to have
been entered up.
''If they had expressed their meaning, in
any of the other ways, the verdict would not
have been affected, and judgment ought to be
entered upon it.
** It is impossible to say, with certainty, what
the jury really did mean ; probably they had
different meanings.
** If they coura possibly mean that which,
if expressed, woukt acquit the defendant, he
ought not to be concluded by this verdict.
** It is possible some of them might mean
not to find the whole sense and explanation
put upon the paper by the innuendos in the
mformation.
'^ If a doubt arises from an ambiguous and
unusual word in the verdict, the Court ought
to lean in favour of venire de naoo,
' We are under the less difficulty ; because,
in favour of a defendant, though the verdict
be fiill, the Court may grant a new trial.
^' And we are all of opinion upon the whole
of the case, that there should be a venire de
w/vor* That it was almost unnecessary to
« Aid^i Vol. SO, p. 919--9S1,
comment upon the distinct and perspicuous
opinion here given, or to demonstrate now di-
rectly the principles'of it apply to and govern
the case in hana. All the doubt, in that case-,
turned upon the import of the word only. Had
that been left out, lord Mansfield was clear
that the verdict was equivalent to a general
verdict of guilty ; and that there would not
have been a doubt upon the subject. In
the present case, the word wdy is out of the
question altogether, as tu the import- of tlie
verdict; because it clearly neither affects nor
contradicts the finding of the jury, farther than
it discriminates the situation of Beny , in respect
of printing, from the situation of Roberstofi
in that respect. Had the verdict stood
thus, " Finn James Robertson ^iUy of prinr-
insand publishins, and Walter Berrvrttiftj^ of
publishing onfy, the pamphlet libelled," it is
believed, that the panels would not have ven-
tured to dispute the import; or if they had
done so, that your loraships, without even
feelinff it necessary to have followed earl
Mansfield's opinion, would have instantly re^
polled the objection. Does it then alter the
case, that in place of the word guilty, the jury
have adopted the usual and most common
Scotch law phrase, proven f Unquestionably
not. The word guilty by itself,* or the word
proven in itself, would, without any addition
whatever, have been amply sufficient for con*-
viction. The question might have been asked
by the panels, of what have ihe jury found us
guiky ; or what is it our jury has (bund prmen
against us ? The answer would have been the
same then as is given now, and as was eiven
by my lord Mansfield in the case of Woodfkll;
you must look to the indictment for that, where
" there is no charge, except for printing and
publisliing, and because the fact found by
the jury is the very fact which they were to
try ;" in the present case, you arealone accused
ot bavins wickedly and feloniously printed
and published, and the jury have, in general
and sufficient terms found you guilty, or foimd
the fact proven. But the jury have gone far-
ther ; for they have found that the panels did
print and publish the pamphlet libelled. The
question is, in what sense and meaning did
tney use these words? — And the answer is
obvious, the sense and meaning in which these
words are alone used in the indictment, viz. a
wicked and felonious printing and publishing.
That was the fact, and the only tact alleged
against these panels; and the jury have
found the truth of that fact proven, after a full
and deliberate trial of its tnith or falsehood.
It was in their power to find, either generally,
or specially, as they pleased ; and they have
chosen to do the last. They have found the
printing and publishins proven against one,
and the publishing only against the other.
The charge against them is one and entire,
viz. a wicked and felonious printing and pub-
lishing. It is, in lord Mansfield's words, there-
fore ^* The very crime which the jury were tp
try/' and the very crime therefore which they
IM]
98 GEOBGE lU,
Ptoetedu^ »gaitd WalUrBtrrg
[10*
tove«kme found nrovco. That wUh these
Dbservation& he left the question as to the
le|^ uttptrfTof this verdict — and to the pro-
aecutor it appealed one ef extreme importance
fo the criminal law of Scotland to the consider-
ation of the Court It was more peculiarly
IB&portant in the present case, that the ver*
diet of the jury should have full eficct, as the
ipriminaJ law of Scotland did not admit of a
new trial, as was die case in England ; and
where, even in the case of Wood&U, the
jpourt unanimously refused to hold the ver-
dict as an acquittal, but directed the informs^
j^ion to be again tried. Nay, the counsel for
ihe defendant did not even venture to rest
idn the ai^gument, that it amounted to a verdict
i>f acquittal, but cbieflv trusted to what the
icourt afterwards founa, that it was so defeo-
live as to render a new trial necessaiy. Had
jthis case been precisely similar, the prosecu-
tor might have admitted that there was no ce-
inedy, and thatno iudgment could pass upon
the verdict ; but where no such doubt occurs,
where it is evident that this verdict if laid be-
fore the court of King's-bench, upon the seUP-
Mme day with WoodfalPs, must have inial-
libly, and without doubt, been construed into
# verdict of guilty, the prosecutor concludes,
by expressing hie hope that your lordships
will be of opmion that the objection, however
plausible at first sight, is not solid; and
that full effect ought to be given to the import
and meaning of the unanimous verdict re-
lumed against these panels by a jury of their
country.
^Afler recording the foreeoing minutes, the
counsel for the panels applied to the
Court, and were allowed to print and give
in a reply on or before Monday the 82d
instant.]
Reply in the minutes of debate upon the
import of the verdict in the trial of Robertson
and Berry.
Dtcanu» [The Hon. Henry Erskine] for the
lianels replied, that the learned and ingenious
argumeot slated on the part of the public
prosecutor, on the import of the verdict,
#nd likewise the decision of the court of
King's bench, in the caseof JEtex venia Wood^
iall, appeared rather to support than con-
fote the objection taken to the verdict on the
part of the panels. This will appear cleaiiy,
Ist, From considering how the law of Scot-
Jaad stands with r^ardto criminal mdict-
ments, interlocutors on the relevancy, and
verdicts general or special ; and 2ndly, By at-
tending to the law of England on this subiect,
as it was understood at tne time of the dect-
.sion in the caseof Weodfall, and as it stands
now explained by the very important act
passed in the last session of parliament, for re-
moving doubts respecting the functions of
juries m cases of libel, from which it wiU ap-
i>ear, that the observations made in that caae
Dy the learned judgei on wiiich the pnisecutor
&unds an srgwMOt to allow thai Ike pwnai
question would be decided in Eneland eon*
trary to what iaaow maifriained by the panels,
are clearlv in &vour of the panels plea ; and
that if the precise question now before yow
lordships were to occur in England, the objeo*
tion must be sustained, even according to the
opinion of the learned judge, in the caae of
Weodttl, applied to the real sUte of the law
of England with regard to trials by imy ia
cases of libel, as explained and declared by the
above-mentioned act* Bjf the law and prac-
tice of SootlajAd, every mdktment is and
must be conceived in a s^llogistio form. Tbf
major proposition sets rorth a erime by its
le^ technical name, and in an altemativa
dracribes its nature and essence; as, for in*
stance, murder, or the wilfully and malici-
ously depriving a man of his life ; theft, or the
firaudulent abstrac^n of goods beion|^ng ta
another; receipt, or the receiving stoieii
goods, knowing them to be stolen, and the
nke. The minor proposition then states ne*
cisely the particular tacts alleged to be dona
by the panel, as amounting to the crime
Ubelled; and as tntailM^/tica^ crMNMy it is es-
sentially necessary that it be chaiged in the
minor propoeitkin, that the nets were dona
with such a design and intention asconslitiita
the crime ^nerally annouaeed in the m^ior
proposition, or therein specially described^
Thus an indictment for murder in the miaor
proposition must indispensablv chaise, that
the panel wickedly, maliciously, and feloni^
ously killed the defunct, because otherwise
the crime soecificd in the nuyor proposition
would not M charged in the minor, asu for
ouslit there set fiirth, the panel might nava
killed the deiiiact by accident or in self-de»
fence. In like manner in thef^ the sooda
must be chareed to have been firaudufentlj
taken ; for otherwise, though charged to ht
the floods of another, and to nave b^n taken
by mt panel, they may have been taken by
him from havine mistaken them for his owa
property, or under the authori^ of a knal
warrant, or in a variety of other ways» either
innocent, or not amounting to then. Thus
also in receipt, it must not only be charged in
the minor proposition, that the panel received
goods which were stolen, but that he knew
Uiem to have been stolen; for otherwise the
charge would not exclude hiB^ having received
them innocently, as by donation or purchascL
not knowing how the giver or seller acquirea
them. As to the conclusion, it subsumes,
* that all or part whereof,' (thatis of the &cts
charged), * being found proven by a verdict
^ of an assise, the panel ought to be punished
^ with the pams of law,' &c., the mean-
ing of which is. for example, in murder, thai
if as much iA the facts libelled shall be found
proven as to satisfy the minds of a jury,
not merely that the panel did kill the person
* See the stat 38, Geo. S, c. 60, inserted ui
the caae of Stockdale, anU^ Vol* SSy p. 306.
IW]
mtdJomm RoUrU<m^ a SfAMpttf ISieL A. TL 179S«
riot
«lMt9id to iHm kmi dcfwred «f bfe, Km
that he did wkkediy, insdic&ouslyy or fek>-
BkHMly kdl himp being the descriptMnof the
crune in the major propotitioii, and the
aptjciJM? charye of tact in the auaor, he ought
to be p'Hf'^ with the paina of law. So
moch with regard to the form of the indict*
aieot. With rqiard to the relevancy of it, on
which it is the province of your lordships to
decide, it ia impossible to dispute, that to
fender a hbel relevant, that is, to make the
m^or and minor proposition infer the ooo-
dusion, the iacts charged in the minor propo-
aitien must amount desrly to the crime gene«
rally charged, and particularly defined in the
■omer proposition. Thus, were a libel to
charge in the n^jor proposition that mur*
der, or the wilfully, nwJUamisly, and feloni-
ously killing, or depriving a man of his life, is
a cnme ofa heinous nature, and severely pa*
nishable, and in the minor, that the panel
had been gyilty of the said crime, in as much
ma that he did, upon a particular day, with a
certain mortal weapon, wound A. B., of which
wound he died, your lordships could Aot sua-
tmin this libel aa relevant to mfer the pains of
Ikw ; because the fact might be proved, and
Cthe panel not only be iuaocent of murder,
guiltless of any crime whatever: He
■aight be unfortunate enough to have killed
bis neighbour by accident ; he might have
be«n justifiable in killing him in self^fence;
or fate might have heSn commendable for
kitting him in baule in defence of his country.
The same observation applies to the other
eaaes above supposed, and to everv one that
can be figured. Such then being the duty of
the public prosecutor, in framing a crimmal
libely and of your lordships in judging of the
velevancy of it ; and seeing that if not found
relevant, it caimot oo to the knowledge of an
nafiJTr, — let it next be considered wliat is the
province of the jury. When the panel, on
tticb a Ubel, is remitted to their knowlraae,
ihey noay ^ther pronounce a general verdict
nf guilty or not Ruilty ; in doing which, they
arc virtually judges of the law aa well as of
tbe fiut ; tor though thev may pronounce a
^Krdict of not guilty, merely because they are
OS' opinioii, that although the facts charged in
the minor proposition & amount to tbe crimes
afaarged in the major, and that both proposi-
tions taken t(^ther do infer the conclusion,
yet the &cts are not sufficiently proved to
fimnd a verdurt, guilty ; yet itis impossible to
depute tbtt they mi^ judse also ot the legal
Inportaod effect of the nicts charged in tne
aainor proposition : and if they s&ll think
tfaem insufficient to make out the crime
^tofglBd in the major proposition, they may,
notwithstanding the interlocutor of relevancy,
find a verdict not guilty, and thereby aciiuit
tbe panel, though they could not, consistently
'with their oath, have returned a verdict not
proven. That this is the right of a jur^, by
the law of Scotland, and has been invariably
cmisdered so. ever since the weUicnawn case
ef Carafe of Fmhaven, * no one will dis»
pute ; ami where a verdict, not guilty, is re*
turned, there is no iurisdiction that can in-
ouire or ascertain whether the jury thought
tne &cts not proved, or were of opinion they
were proved, but considered them as not
amounting to the crime charged in the maior
proposition. Again, the jury, if they are
satisfied that tbe Iacts contained in the Bmwr
proposition are established by evidence, may
nna the libel proven ; in which case, the facta
having alreaoy been found relevant to infer
the pains of law, judgment must pass ananst
the panel, unless he can satisfy your lordships
that there are some le«al grounds for arresl-
injg judgment, on which it is the sole province
of^your lordships to decide;, and in deter-
mining upon whxh, you must hold the whole
fiKts charged in the minor proposition as
proved, utftly. If the jury think that some
ftart of the Amis charged in the minor propoM*
tion is proved, and some not, or are unwiihi^
to find the panel guilty of the crime Iibelle{
albeit the whole facts in the minor ]>r(^[K>ution
are proved to their satisfiiction, beins doubt-
ful perhaps of their amounting to the ciirae
charged in the aiajnT proposition, they may
return a special verdict, finding certain focla
proven; and then the province of the jury
becomes devoWed upon the Court, who must
determine whether the fads found proven are
sufficient for conviction upon the libel as it
stands. If tltese facts amount either m^
cisely, or substantially to the whole facta
charged in tbe minor proposition, things are
in the same situation as it the jury had found
the libel proven. If the facts tall short of
the charee in the minor proposition, then
your lordSiips come to decide whether they
amount to the speciei yocfi which by the in-
terlocutor of relevancy has been found to con-
stitute the crimes charged in the migor pro-
position, and therefore to infor the pains of
law concluded for. In this part of your lord-
ships duty, however, your lordships must hold
every fact ^roeerita^ that is found proven by
the jury, and must take it into consideration
in deciding on tbe verdict If any fact
charged in the minor proposition is found by
tbe verdict not to be proven, it must be held
by your lordships as not true ; and where the
verdict is silent as to any facts charged in the
minor proposition, the consequence is the
same ; your lordships must hold it as found
by the jury not to be proven ; nor can you do
otherwise, without returning a verdict, instead
of judging of that which is returned. Thus,
to recur to the illustrations formerly given, it
must be precisely the same thing, whether
the jurjr find it proven that the panel did with
a certain mortal weapon wound the person
charged to have been murdered, of which
woundhedied; but find it not proven that the
panel did so maliciously or tetoniously, or
find it merely proven that the panel did, with
« 6flc this caesy «i<«i Vol. I7| p. 71.
ion
8S 6£t>mGE IIL
Pt9teedhgi ^mult WiJUerBemf
[im
a certtin mortal weapon, wound the person
murdered^ ofwhich wound he died; because
aft in the nrst alternative, the jury find directly,
ao in the last the^ find virtually, that the
killing was not malicious and felonious : and
supposing even that this could be held not to
be implied, by discarding the presumption
for innocence, one of the most b^uitiful attri-
buU>8 of the law, the result would be the
same; for the question is, not what the jury
may have thought or intended to find, but
what they have actually found ; and nothing
but the miding of a jury either directly or by
an inseparable consequence of ' what they
have found, can found a judgment of convic-
tion; and as it cannot be maintained that
killing a man, &r neces9itiUe involves a mali-
cious or felonbus intent ; that taking another
man's goods, necessarily implies a fintudulent
taking for the purpose of appropriating ; or
that receiving stolen goods, necessarily in-
volves the knowledge of the person who took
them that they were stolen; it must be ad-
mitted, that where a verdict of a juiy finds
xiothing more proven than that the defunct
was kuled by the panel, that the goods
libelled were Ukea by him, or that the stolen
^oods libelled were received by him, convic-
tion can no more follow, than if ihe verdict
had expresslvibundit not proven, that the
panel who killed did so maliciously or feloni-
ously, that the panel who took, did so frau-
dulently animo wnireciandi, or that he who
received did so fraudulentlv, knowing the
goods to have been stolen. It only remained,
Sierefore, to consider how far these rules,
which indisputably apply to every other case,
are inapplicable to a criminal prosecution for
printing or publishing a hbel or seditious
writing. To constitute this ^rime, it is per-
fectly evident, 1st, That the panel must be
guilty of printing or publishing a writing;
findly. That that writing must contain libel-
lous or seditious matter; and lastly, That
the person accused must print or publish it,
understanding it to be seoitious, and with an
intention of exciting sedition. That there
was no occasion, however, in tlie present case,
to use any arguments in support of these pro-
positions, supposing them to require it, be-
cause the criminal letters do not merely charge
the crime of which the panels are accused, to
be the printinjg and publishing a seditious
libel, but the wickedly and iieloniously printing
and publishing a seditious writing ; and this
they justly charge to be crimes of a heinous
nature, dangerous to the public peace, and
severely punishable. The crime charged in
the major proposition is, wickedly and mali-
ciously printing and publishing. 'The minor
pipposition then states, that Callender had
wickedly and feloniously com^iosed and
written a seditious writing, intituled, ' The
* Political Process of Great Britain ;' that the
panels did wickedly and feloniously print
and publish the said seditious writing; and
that they did wickedly and feloniously sell
and cbeukte, tiie said 'wicked and
writing, &c.; and so anxiously does the
minor proposition attach the charge of
wicked and malicious intention, to the
alleged printing and publishing, that even
the general and sweeping clause which this,
like any other mmor proposition contains,
charges that at least tne said wicked and
malicious writing, £cc. was wickedly and
feloniou^y printed, published, and sold;'
and that the pao^s^ or one or other of them,
were guilty ot the foresstid crimes, or one or
other of tnem ; which can have no other
meaning but this, that they are guilty of
having wickedly and feloniously printed the
said wicked and seditious writing. That
such being the precise nature of the charge,
it was clear, that when vour lordships fnmd,
in general terms, the libel relevant to infer
the pains of law, it was precisely the -same
thing, as if you had found specifically, that
the panels having printed the said pamphlet,
the same being a wicked and malicious writh-
ing, was relevant to infer the pains of law ;
and it is evident, that if the libel had not
charged the pamphlet to be wicked and sedi«
tious, and supposing it to have so charged if,
if it had not also charged it to have been
printed and published by the panels wielc-
edly and feloniously, your lordships could not
have found the libel relevant Any argument,
however, upon this head, is superseded by the
admission of the prosecutor himself, that a
wicked and felonious printing and publishing
was the fact, and only fact alleged against
the panels ; or, in other words, that to render
the libel relevant, it was necessary to chai^,
that the printing and publishing was wicked
and felonious ; and, indeed, the greatest part
of hi& lordship^s argument is rested on this,
that there is no charge of printing and pub-
lishing, separate from the charge of felo-
niously printing and publishing. Such bein^
the charge in the lioel, what sort of proof
became necessary to support it ? Was it not
first, that the writing printed and published
was wicked and seditious ? And if the juiy
had found it not proved to be wicked and
seditious, of what avail would it have been,
that they found the panels did print and pub-
lish it? It was equally necessary, that \X
should be proved, or appear from tlie
circumstances proved, that the panels did
wickedly and feloniously print and publish
it ; and though the jury had found the libel
to be wicked and seditious, and that the
panels printed and published it, what would
this have availed if they had at the same
time found that it was not proved, that the
panels printed and published it with a wicked
and felonious intention ? Indeed, the learned
prosecutor admits, that if they had so found,
judgment would not have passed upon the
verdict; but he seems to think that the
jury's finding simply, that one of tlte panels
Erinted and pubushetl, and the other pub-
shed only, without finding directly> either
W9\
ami /«Mt RoberUonJar » SetSHout libeL A. D. 1798.
[116
.tbat it was proved that ,they did not do so
. malicioiBly or fekmiously ; or neffslively, that
it was not proven, that they did so mali*
eiously or feionkmsly, cannot have the same
effect: and he seems to rest this conchision
on two grounds ; Ist. That the printing and
fmbiiahio^ a seditious libel, implies a mali-
cious and felonious intention ; and Sndiy, That
as the indictment charges the printing and
fMihlishing to have been malioous and felo-
nious, a special verdict finding that the panels
pfinled or published, implies a finding, that
they did so maliciously and feloniously.
Tmu both these arguments, however, are
&Dacious, is obvious : a writing, may be sedi-
tious, and yet a person may pnnt and publish
it innocenUy ; it may be wntten in a foreign
tongue, wiudi he does not understand, and
consequently in printing it, he must be
.merely an innoeent instrament; or, it may
discuss topics bevond his capacity or educa^
tion. Indeed the prosecutor, by libelling
that the printing and nublislung was mali-
cious and felonious, admits, that it might
have been printed without a malicious or
IcUmuous intention. Agam, it is equally in
wain to say, that because the libel charges
the panels with having wickedly and felo-
oiouBly printed and published, findine it
proven that they had printed and publiained,
15 equivalent to finding that they did so
wickedly and feloniously. The conclusion is
<lirectly the reveiae. Had the crime been
xiuirder,and the minor proposition had charged
t.lie panels with maliciously and feloniously
JdlJing A. B. and the jury had found no more
than that he killed mm. the prosecutor, in-
deed, seems to think that this would have
been a verdict equal to guilty. It is impos-
sible, however, to maintain such a proposi-
tioo. As well might it be said, that because
A libel for murder, charges a panel with hav-
^ing given A. B. a wouno, of which he died,
a verdict finding it proven, that he gave A.
B. a wound, was not only tantamount to
finding that he gave him such wound mall-
«aou9ly and felonknisly, but to findins also
that be died thereof; ibr if the vermct is
|x> be stretched beyond its words to include
all that is libelled, it will just as effectuallv
imply that the jury have fimnd it proved,
that the person wounded died of the wound,
aa that the person who did so, did it mali-
ciously and feloniously; for the conseauence
ef tlie wound is just as particularly lioelled,
as the intent with wluch it was given. In-
deed, by the same rule, if it were charged
that a panel having conceived deadly malice
a^aiast A. B. lay m wait for him, and gave
hua a wound with a sword, of which he
died, and the jury were to find it proved,
that the panel lay m wait for A. B., it might
be maintained, that this was equivalent
to finding that he lav in wait tor him,
wKwaded and killed him, as referring to
the libel in which all that is charged. The
flsaiiaous and feHmiooa intention is a ftct
for the determination of the jury, distinct
and separate from the fact chared to have
been done with such intention. The proba*
bility is, that a roan who wounds his neigh*
hour does so maliciously and feloniously, and
it is also probable that a man who has been
proved to have been maliciouslv wounded
with a mortal weapon, died of the wound ;
but neither will oe presumed, unless so
found by the jury, because the wound may
have been innocently given, and it jnay not
terminate mortally; and the intention of
^ving the wound, and the consequence of
ue wound being charged in the indictment,
can never be taken to help out the averment.
The prosecutor's argument too is the more
inadmissible, because the verdict does not
find the pamphlet to be wicked and seditious,
which it finas the panels to have printed and
published ; it says, * the pamphlet libelled,'
that is the pamphlet intituled, * The Political
* Progress of ureat Britain, &c.' not the
pamphlet as libelled, viz. the said pamphlet
oeine a wicked and seditious writme, &c.;
so that, although so dangerous a doctrine
could be for a moment listened to, as that
verdicts were to be extended by imjrfication,
and that judges ought to resort to the evi-
dence, and from thence to supy»ly what jurys
may be supposed to have omitted to find,
there would be no room for appl^ng it in
tlie present case. The libel says, ]s^ That
the panels printed and published the pam-
phlet libelled ; Sndlv, That they did so wick-
edly and feloniously; and lastly, that the
pamphlet that they did print and publish was
a wicked and seditious writing. AH these
facts were essentbl to found a verdict— guilty.
They must dl, therefore, have been found m
a special verdict, in order to lead your lord-
ships to pronounce that judgment against the
panels, which a verdict of the Court finding
nim guilty would warrant; if any one of the
facts IS awanting, the verdict is insufficient ;
and it matters not whether that fact be the
actual printing and publishing, the malicious
intention chafed to have given occasion to
such publishing, or the sraitious nature of
the pamphlet printed and published. They
are all awanting in the verdict in qiiestion^
except the actual printing and publishing;
and although it could be held that the libel-
lous nature of the pamphlet is found, which
the panels do not admit, this would not be
by implication, but directly by holding that
the verdict, by the woras the pamphlet
libelled, describes directly the pamphlet
charged to have been wickedly and feloniously
written by Callender, and to be a seditious
writing, containing the wicked and seditious
passages libelled. But there is not a single
word m the verdict which amounts to finding
that the panels printed and published the
|iamphlet libelled wickedly and feloniously ;
and could presumptions and suppositions, to-
tally unfonnd^ m any part or the verdict,
be admitted as a part of the verdict itself, the
Ill]
SS GEORGE UI.
rttHStttnBgt MgmMi W^uMtt Bttfg
[IIS
jiut pvesumplioQ aad tuppoutkni is directly
the contmy, it being impossible for human
iBgeQui^ to figure a reason whv, if the jury
thought It proved, that the panels |ninted and
frubhshed with a wicked and felonious inten-
tion, they did not either find them guilty» or
the libel proven; or if they chose, without
the smallest necessity, to find a special
verdict, why they aid not find, in so
many words, that the panel, James Robert-
son, did wickedly and maliciously print and
I»ubUsh, and the panel, Walter Berry, did pub-
ish only the pamphlet libelled. The verdict,
therefore, in sound reason, can bear no other
iateipretation but this, that the iury saw
nothmc proved, but tlMt one of the panels
winted aud published, and the other mib-
fished the namphlet mentioned in the indict-
ment : ana that instead of taking upon them
to judee bow far its being provM, that they
printed or published without a malicious in-
tention made tbem guilw of the crime libel-
led, they chose to find, Sy a special verdict,
the only fact that was proved, and to leave the
effect of it to be judgea by the Court : tluit it
therefofe only remained to sav a very few
woffda on the case of WoodfaJl, which the
prosecutor had been pleased to consider as
support'mg his plea, though, with ereat defer-
ence, it appears to have a totaUv opposite
tendency. It will be observed, that as the
kw of England was held by the judges at the
time of tluit decision, the jury were entitled to
judge of nothing in the case of a libel, but
the simple question of fact, whether the pri-
soner was guilty of publishing or printing.
The facts whether the printing smd publishing
was done maliciously and whether tne writing
contained libellous matter, were at that time
erroneouslv held to be matters of kw, com-
petent only to the Court; and accordingly
nothing mare was, or could be cbai^ged
against Woodfall, but printing and publishing
the paper si^ed Junius. Lord Mansfield
accordingly observes, ' guilty of printing and
* publtshmg where there is no other charge, is
' guilty, for nothing more is to be found by the
' is no charfle except for printing and pub-
* jishing.'* His lordship thmfore properly ob-
served, that had the word onUf bMi omitted,
there would have been no doubt; and it
seems to have been his lordship's opinion,
and indeed be expresses it, that if by using
the word << only,'' they meant ^ to say they did
not find it a bbel," or '< did not find the epi-
thets, or did not find any express malicious
intent, it would not affect tne verdict, be-
cause nome of these things were to be proved,
or found mtber way."t As the law was then
understood, all this was perfectly well-
founded, beeauae if the jury found the only
• Ant^. Vol. 90^ pp. 919, 9S0.
t Vol. «0, p. 980«
kct they had a right to judge of, piwvcd, via.
the printing and publifl^ii^; their findings
even directly, that there was no malicious in-
tention, could not have affected the verdict;
and still less, their not finding the mali*
cious intention; but had the kw been un-
derstood then to stand, as it is now de-
clared to stand, by the authority of the
legislature itself, that the intention as well
as the libellous matter, whether it is con-
sidered as matter of fiict or matter of kw, ia
within the province of the jury to deode
upon, could the learned judge have said, that
the jury's meaning to say, that they did not
find any malicious intent, would not affsct
the verdict, because that was not the thing to
be found either way } And is it not equally
clear, that if, in tbit case, the charge kut
been not simply printii^ and publishing, but
wickedly ana fetoniousTv printing and puk>
lishing, and the verdict had been silent as to
the malicious intention, the learned jvdse
could not have said as he does, * there can be
' no judgment of acquittal, because this kct
* found by the jury is the very crime they
' were to try;' for the fact would not have
been printms and publishing, but wickedly
and feloniously printing and publishing. Oil
the contrary, his lordship's opinion must
have been directly the reverse. Let lord
Mansfield's reasomne then be applied to the
present case ; though his opinion proceeded
upon an erroneous view of the kw of Eng-
land, whkh never had an existence as to the
kw of Scotland; and if it had, weold have
been removed by the late statute. The
charge in this case is doubk; it is of a
wicked and malicious intention, and of car*
rying it into efiect, by printing and publish*
ing. The panels are not found guilty of
both ; only one of them, viz. printing and
publishmg, is found proved asainst them;
consequently, according to his lordship's opi-
nion, they are acquitted of the other. It ia
sufficient however, that it is not found
proved that the printing was wicked and felo*
nious s for wicked and lelonious printing and
pubUshing being thrchai^, a verdict which
finds that the ranels printed and published^
can just as little afibra ground for conviction,
as a verdict finding them guilty of printing
and publishing on^, triiich the prosecutor
admits, would have supported the objection
now made, or a verdict expressly finding a
wicked and felonious intention not proven, or
even finding directly that the panels printed
and published thepamphlets libelled, without
anv wicked or felonious intention. The
judgment therefore, in the case of Woodfall
when properly attended to, supports the
present objection, and, at the same time,
^ves a striking proof how favourably the
judges of Ettgkndf decide upon any objection
to a verdict in a criminal case, as it is evi^
dent that the information having charged
noUiing but printing and publishing, and iht
prisoner having been fooM goihy of priutiag
llSQ Old Jamt$ tUtberUmJ^ a SeiStiout Libd. ' A.' 6. 1793.
tii*
ig, which was tlte whole chaige,
the maertioD of the word only in the verdict,
as it could not be sapfKwed to apply to any
tldng as to whkh the jury had a righf to
ted, it did by no means qtiatify the violet,
and only involved it m a seeming obsciirity,
which in no degree afiected the senseor im-
]NNtof it.
March l^h^ 1793.
hdfwu.
Walter Berry, bookseller, South Bridge-
street, Edinburgh ; and
jtames Robertson, also bookseller there, and
pnnter in the Horse wynd Edinburgh — Panels.
Indicted and accused as in former sede-
ronts.
The verdict of assize behig read over, the
locds proceeded to take into consideration the
intoiites of debate upon the import thereof
4befoie recorded, and pronounced tne following
opouonsi
Loid Henderland thought that the verdict
was' to be understood as finding, with re^rd
to Robertson, that the printing and publish-
ing had been wicked and felonious, the maltu
4Bitttms being necessarily inferred from the
printing and mihlishing; hut he thought the
Tesult was dinerent in die case- of Berry, who
was found only to have published. One may
Utter a hank note, not knowine that it was
Ibmd; and so otae may pulmsh* a book,
wlme ignorant of its real tendency. In the
Scots acts relative to Leasing^ rocking, his
loidflhip observed, something is required to
be done necessarily inferring imlus aninrns :
and in various cases this distinction* had
been observed, as in. the case of Fraser, and
that of Mr. Dundas ' in 1712 : so too
'Buchanan's book, de' jure Refrii, was sup-
pressed by act of parliament, without any pu-
nishment ' being inflicted upon' die- piri)hsher,
act 1564. C 1S4.
' Lord £d^rooe.— This is a special verdict,
and ftom the terms of it a seditious intent is
necessarily unplied, so far as regards Robert*
son, from the reference to the libel, where the
(ampfakt was described as wicked and sedi-
tiopus. The case is the same as if the jury
had found Robertson guilty of printing and
publishing a seditious liM. This cannot
De dmie without a maluM animus, every
person being called upon to consider what
ne prints and publisnes: there is more
doubt as to Berry. We have no law here as
in England, which makes the publishing and
selling of a libel a crime ; therefore, where
there is a verdict of pubUshin^ we must de-
cade from the circumstances ofthe case ; and
if the writing be veiy short, as a seditious
faandlaU, a knowledge of its contents will be
necessarily inferred from the publicadon;
but here the pamphlet being oi some size,
the same inference may not oe warrentsbly
drawn.
Lord Daastansa-'agreed with the judges
VOL. XXIII.
who had spoken as to the diflferencfe betweeA
the two panels.
Lord Abercromby. — Our law in this respett
has always been different from the common
law of En^Und, where, id the case of libel,
ihe jury till a late period were jtidges- of the
feet, biit not of the law. With us, even in
matters of libel, the jury have always deter-
mined both as to the law and th^ fact. In
this case, if the jury had thought either of thte
panels not gtrilty, their verdict would have
been in different terms. To publisli a sedi-
tious libel is a crime at common law, every
person being presumed to know the contents
of what he publishes, even although the book
may be written in a language unknown to
him ; and in some respects the publisher*is
more guilty than the printer, the crime by
his means becoming complete, and the injury
to the public put oeyond the possibility of
recall.
The question here is, whether the verdict
is altogether defective ? I do not think so ; I
cannot go to the proof, but I may to the in-
dictment or libel, and must consider the case
in the same light as if the jury, instead of a
reference to the pamphlet, had recited it : the
jury mieht hate found the seditious intent
proved, but in my opinion they did better by
a special finditig ast6'the fact, leaving the
Court from thence to judge of the intent ;
noi^'can I distingOish between the two panels
so as to acquit Berry, against whom a hnding
as to the |)ubhshtng only has been eiv^n.
Jgvery publisher is presumed in law to Know
the contents of what he publishes, in the
same manner as the user and utterer of a
forged deed is presumed to be art and part in
the foreery, the onus probandi of the contrary
being thrown upon hun. This is the law, and
it is expedient tnat it should be so.
The Lord Justice Clerk (Braxfield) deli-
vered his opinion nearly in the same words.*
» • «
The following Interlocutor was then pro-
nounced :
The lord justice clerk ahd lords commis-*
^—1— ^— ^^IM I I I .Ml ■ ^1^ ^■■l , I ■ M I ■■■■■■■■ 11 ■ I ^■^^^M^
* " The Court wer6 not unanimous, but
the • majority - were of opinion, that bv the
verdict's referring to the pamphlet libelled, it
must be expounded by reference to the in-
dictment^ and must be viewed in ihe same
way as if the pamphlet itself had been en-*
grossed in the veraict. That being the case,
the publishins and printing such a pamphlet,
or tne publishing only (which was all that
I was found against Berry), was unquestionably
I punishable. The Court in this case took
, occasion to observe, that, by the law of Scot-
land, no distinction ever was made between
the case of a libel, and of any other crime ;
the jury's province being always understood
to be, to' take into view the nature of the
writing, as well as the feet of publishing.'' —
Bumelt on the Criminal Laws of Scotland,
p. «43.
I
125]
PropeeAigi 0g9Uuf W. Berry tmi J. Roberts^. {1}^
sionen of jinrticiaiyy ImTine considered the
▼erdict of assize dated the IdUi^ and returaed
the 19th <hy of February last» in the trial of
Walter Beny and James Robertson, panels,
whereby the assise ail in one voice find it
proven that ti]« said James Robertson did
print and publish, and the said Walter Beny
,did publlsn only the pamphlet libelled on;
with the minutes of debate upon the im-
port of the said verdict given m in conse-
.quenoe of the order of Court, of date the said
19th day of February last^ and before re-
.cordcd; Ihey repel tne objections offisred in
arrest of iudgment, and in respect of the said
verdict, decern and adjudge the said Walter
Berry and James Robertson to be canied from
tl^e bar to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh, therein
to be detained, the said James Robeitson for
the space of six monthsw and the said Walter
Berry for the space of three months from this
date, and thereafter till they shall find suffi-
cient caution and surety acted in the books
of a4]oumal for their good behaviour for the
space of three years after their liberation re-
spectively, and that under the penalty of
one hundred pounds sterling each ; and upon
elapsing of the said periods of imprisonment,
ana finding caution m manner foresaid, grant
vrarrant to, and ordain the magistrates of
Edinburgli, and keepers of their lolbootb, to
set them at liberty.
(Signed) Robert M'Queen, I. P. D.
I extract fifom the Journal of the House of
Lords the following entries relating to
this case:
RoBEBTSON and Bebrt against his Majesty's
Advocate.
** Die Mercuriif 1* JUoti, a. d. 1793. — An ap-
peal of James Robertson, bookseller in Edin«
Dursh, and printer in the Horsewynd there,
and Walter Berry, bookseller, on Soi^th Bridoe-
street, Edinburgh, now prisoners ip the 1^1-
booth of Edinbiu^h, was presented and read;
complaining of two interlocutors or judgments
of the court of justiciary in Scotland, of the
18th of Februanr and 18th of March, 1793 ;
and praying, *That the same may be re-
* versed, varied, or altered, or thai the peti-
^ tioners may have such other relief in tht pr»-
* mises, as to their lordships, in thieir great
* wisdom, shall seem meet.'
** Ordered, That the said appeal be reierted
to a committee, to consider and report,' vrhm
* ther the same ought to be entertained/
** Ordered, That the petitioners be at liberty
to be heard by one counsel before the said
committee if they think fit ; and that notice
thereof be gi^cn to the lord advocate for
Scotland. Their lordships, or any five of
them, to meet on Monday next at the usual
time and place, and to acyourn as they please.
^ Ordered, That all the lords who have been
or shall be present this session, be of the said
committee.
<< Larue, d* JIf att.--Ordered, That the sitting
of the committee, to whom is referred the
appeal of James Robertson, and Walter
Scurry, prisoners in the Tolbooth of Edinbui^^
from the court of justicivy in Scotland, pre-
sented on the 1st of this instant, May^ which
stands appointed for this day, be put off to
Wednesday next*
** Mercarii S"" JUait.— The lord Cathcart n^
ported from the Lords committees, appointed
to consider and report whether the appeal of
James* Robertson, bookseller in Edinburgh,
and printer in the Horsewynd there, aw^
Walter Berry, bookseller in South Pridaer
street, Edinbuigb, now prisoners in the lo£>
booth of Edinburgh, complaining of two in^
terlocutors or iudements of the court of ju*>
ticiary in Scotlana, of the 18th of Februuy
and 18tfa of March 1793, and praying, ' That
* the same omy be reversed;' ought to b<
entertained : ^ That the committee had met;
^ and had heard counsel for and agaipa^
' the petition, and taken into consideratioii
' the matter to them referred, and are of opi-
^ nion, that this petition of appeal ought not
'to be entertained.'* Which report being
read by the clerk, was agreed to by thf
House.
^Ordered, by the Lords spiritual and tem-
poral, in parliament assembled, That this
tition of appeal ought not to be received.''
— p—^.™.— ——.»<— ^—^—~ I .— ^— .^— — ^— .»i^— ^»
^ As to this see the note to the case of
Nairne and Ogiivic, arU^. Vol. 19, p. 1331.
lilt
A. D. 170S.
[IIB
593. Proceedingg on the Trial of Thomas Muir> E»q., Ihe
Younger, of Honter's-Hill^ on an Indictment charging
him with Sedition* Tried before the High Court of
Jnsticiarjr at Edinburgh^ on the SOth and 3Ut Days of
August : 33 George III. ▲. d. 1793.*
FrU^, AnguM SOth, 1793.
A PEW miiiiites aiW ten o'clock in the
nonuns the Court was opened hy lord justice
detk (M^ueenland four lords commissioners
ef ju&ciaTy^ lonl Henderland, lord Swinton,
loid Dnnsunuiy and lord Abercromby.
"Upon calling Rc^wrt Dundas, esq. his roa-
jestf's adrocate for his majesty's interest
i^amst Thomas Mair, Mr. Muir did not an-
swer to his name, on which the lord advocate
nwe to address the Court, but Mr. Muir'sagent
said he would appear in a few minutes : and
Mr. Minr presently came into court.
Mr. Mmr was reprimanded lor keeping the
Gooit waiting; and was then desired to at-
tend to the mdktmenty which the depute
cfcrk of court read as follows :
^Geom,&c. Whereas is humbly meant
aad oompi^ned to us by our right tnisty Ro-
bert Dundas, esq. of Amistouyour advocate
for our interert, upon Thomas Muir, yojunger.
of Hunterslull, that* by the laws of this and
every other well-govemed realm, the wickedlj
and feloniously exciting, by means of sedi-
tious speeches and harangues, a spirit of dis-
k^alty and disaffection to the king and the
Mtablishcd government; more especiallv
wfaeneuch speeches and harangues are ad-
dressed to meetings or convocations of per-
aotiSy hrou^t togeUier b;^ no lawful authority
and uttered by one who is the chief instru-
■aent of calling together such meetings j as
alao^ the wickedly and feloniously advising
and esbortine persons to purchase and peruse
aeditioiis and wicked publications and writ-
ngjL cafeolaled to produce a spirit of dis-
krralty anddisafediiMi to the kine and govem-
floient; as also, the wickedly and feloniously
distributing or circulating any seditious writing
or publication of tbetendencv aforesaid ; or the
canstngtodistribute or circulate any such sedi-
tiona writing or publication ; as also, the
wickedly and feloniously producing and read-
ing aloud, in a public meetinjr or convocation
•fpersons, a seditious and innammatory writ*
ing, tending to produce in the minds of the
people a spajt of insurrection and of opposi-
-----
* Of this trial several accounts, — ^not how-
ever materially difiering, and in no instance
contradictory, — were published at the time of
its (loeumnoe : these I have carefully exa-
Buoed and compared; and from them the
feppit bait printed is eompiled.
tion to the established government ; and, the
publicly approving of. and recommending, in
said meeting, such seditious and indammatory
writing, are all and each, or one or other
of them, crimes of an heinous nator^ dan-
gerous to the public peace, and severely pu-
nishable : yet true it is, and of verity, that the
said Thomas Muir is guilty actor, or art and
put, of all knd each, or one or other, of tiie
said crimes, aggravated as aforesaid : In so
&r as on the Sd day of November, 1792, or
on one or other of the days of that month,
or of October immediatoW preceding, or oi
December immediately following, uie said
Thomas Muir having bleen present at a meet-
ing in the town of Kirkintilloch, parish of Kir-
kintilloch, and county of Dunbarton, denomi-
nated, * A Society for Reform,' or bearing some
such name ; and also,having some timeduring
the course of the said month of November
aforesaid, been present at another meeting at
Mlltoun, parish of Campsie. and county of
Stirling, which meeting was also denominated,
' A Society for Reform,' or bore some such
name (and both of which societies above-
mentioned the said Thomas Muir was the
chief mean of instituting and forming); he
did. at times and places aforesaid, with wicked
and seditious intention, address and haransue
the said meetings; in which speeches and ha*
rangues, the said Thomas Muir did seditiously
endeavour to represent the government of
this country as oppressive andtyrannical, and
the legislative bodv of the stato as venal and
corrupt; particuJarfy by instituting a compa-
rison between the oretended ezistmg »)vem«
ment of France and the constitution <» Great'
Britain, with respect to the expenses neces-
sary for carrying on the functions of govern^
ment, he endeavoured to vilify the monai^
chical part of the constitotion, and to repr^
sent it as useless, cumbersome and expensive:
at least the said Thomas Muir did use
words and arguments of the above seditious
tendency and import. Further, the said
Thomas Muir did, some time during the
course of Septomber, October or November,
1799, in the town of Glasgow, in the county
of Limark, Kirkintillodi in the parish of Kirk*
intilloch and county of Dunbarton, and
Mlltoun in the parish of Campsie and county
of Stirling aforesaid, and elsewhere, wickedly
and feloniously exhort and advise several per-'
sons to purchase and peruse various seditious^
pamphlets and writmgs; particularly tba
a 19]
$s
AIL
Ptoc^edbigi ag0h^ Thomoi Miir
[ita
said Thomas Muir did, some time in the
months aforesiud, within his father's house at
Glasgow, aforesaid, or some other pl^ce tothe
public- prosecutor unknown, wickeidly and fe-
loniously advise and exhort John Muir, sen.,
late hatler in Glasgow, Thomas \Vilson,barber
In, Gj^gow, an4 John Barday^ residihs; in
the parisli of Calder.and county of Lanark, to
read Faine*s Rights i>f Man, and to purchase
the same ; which book or paniphlet, intituled
Paine's Rights of Man, is a most wicked- and
seditious publication, calculated to vilify the
constitution of this country, to produce a spi-
rit of insurrection among tne people, and to
stir them up to acts of outrage and opposition
to the established government. Further the
*^ said Thomas Muir did, in the course of the
months of September, October, or November
aforesaid, wickedly and feloniously distribute
and circul^te^ or cause to be distributed and
circulated, in the towns of Glasgow, Kirkin-
^lloch, and Miltoun aforesaid, and at Len-
noxtoun in l^e said parish of Campsie and
county of Stirling, or elsewhere, a number of
sedijtious and inflammatory writings or pani-
phlets; particularly a book or pamphlet inti-
^ tuled, * The works of Thomas Paine, esq.'
Also, a writing or publication intituled, ' A
f Declaration of Rights, and an Address to the
* People, approved of by a number of the
* Friends ot Keform in Paisley ; * also a paper
or publication intituled, ' A Dialogue betwixt
* the Governors and the Governed ;' also, a
paper or publication intituled, * The Patriot :'
narticularly the said Thomas Muir did, some
time in the months of October or November
aforesaid, at Kirkintilloch aforesaid, or at
some other place to the public prosecutor un-
known, wickedly and feloniously deliver and
put into the hands of Henry Freeland, weaver
in Kirkintilloch, a seditious bookorpamphlet,
intituled, • The works of Thomas Paine, esq.,
vrhich the said Henry Freeland carried away
with him ; which book or pamphlet, along
urith the other wicked, seuitious, and in?
flammatory passages contains the following:
Paine's Works, p. 13. " Monarchy is
ranked in Scripture as one of the sins of the
Jews, for which a curse in reserve is de-
nounced against them."
P. 20. ** In short, monarchy and succes-
sion have laid not this or that kingdom only ;
but the world, in blood, and ashes ; it is a form
<^f government which the word of God bears
testimony ag^nst, and blood will attend it."
P. 81. "why is the constitution of Eng-
land sickly, but because monarchy hath poi-
soned the republic f—^the Crown hath en-
grossed the Commons.
. " In Fpgl^d, a king hath little more to
do than to make war, and to jgive away
places ; which in plaip terms, U to impoverish
the nation, and set it together by the ears.
A pretty bubiness indeed for a man to be
allowed eignt hundred thousand pounds ster-
ling a year for, and worshipped into the bar-
. ifipun !.. Of more worth is one honest man to
^ w
society, and in the sight of God, than aU the
crowned ruffians that ever lived."
• P^ 7^. . " What are the preseat ^vero^
ments in Europe but a scene of iniquity and
oppression. What is thatof Bij^land? Do
not its own inhabitants say it is a market
where every man Yofi hif pficetiand where
corruption is common traffic, at the expense
of a deluded people ? No. wonder then that
the French Revolution is traduced."
P. 85. " But the second head, that of a
nation establishing a particular family with
hereditary powers, does not present itself as
despotism, on the first reflection ; but if mea
will permit a second reflection to take pboe,
and carry that reflection forward but one
remove out of their own persons to that of
their offspring, they will thep s^e that herer
ditary succession l^ecomes in its consequences
the same despotism to others which they rer
probate it for themselves."
P. 86. <' It operates to preclude the coo*
sent of the succeeding generation, and the
preclusion of consent is despotism."
part II. p. 30. ^ All hereditary govern*
ment is in its nature tyranny. An heritable^
crowq, or an heritable throne, or by whatever
fanciful name such things may be called^
have no other sienificant explanation, then
that mankind are neritable property. To in->
herit a government is to inherit the people,
as if they were flocks and herds."
P. 5 1 . *" The act called the Bill of Rishts
comes here into view. What is it but a bar*
gain which the parts of the government made
with each other to divide powers, profits, and
privileges ? You shall have so much, and I
will have the rest ; and with respect to the
nation, it said, for your share you shall have
the right of petitioning. This being the case,
the Bill of Rights is more properly a Bill of
Wrongs, and of Insult.' '
P. 64. '^ The attention of the government
of England (for I rather choose to call it by
this name, than the English government) ap^
pears, since its political connexion with Ger-
many, to Jiave been so completely engrossed
and absorbed by foreign afiairs, and the means
of raising taxes, that it seems to exist for no
o^her purposes. Domestic concerns are neg-
lected; and with respect to regular law, there
is scarcely such a thing."
P. 12G. ** The time is not very distant
when England will laugh at itself for sending
to Holland, Hanover, Zell, or Brunswick,
for men, at the expense of a million a year,
who understood neither her Uws, her lan-
guase, nor her interest, and whose capacities
would scarcely have fitted them for the oflke
of a parish constable. If government coold
be trusted to such hands, it must be some
easy and simple thing indeed, and materiels
fit for all the purposes may be found in every
town and villaee in England."
And the saicT Thomas Muir did, some time
in October pr November aforesaid,' within his
own or his father's house at HuntershiU^ in
JSI]
JTit "Joiktm
A^D. ITM*
[1211
ihbocKMv^LmmkfW^ some other plaee
to tine '^wme prMBddtof' unkoowii, wkkedly
and felMoosly put i«lo the hands of William
Miir, wttwrer in KirkintiUoch, elevien nom-
ben of a seditioas book or pamiyhtety inti-
tuM, «< The Patnot,'' whidi the said William
Mm carried Mray with him, and- kept poa-
sessioa of; and which book of pamphlet cod-
tamed among others the foUowing seditious
Patriot, Ko. V. p. 168 and 169. ^* Thej
have lost the distiiiguishiiis character between
freedom and blares ; they nave lost the dis*
tingdishing character of Englishmen ! They
kave lost what ^ most tynanicai kings of
England would never force from them t
They.luLve, in a great measm^, lost what
their fcre^tbers spent their blood and
tPttsaTe. to defand^-the greatest jewel that
any people can possess— uieir constitutional
and natural liberty — ^their birth-riffht and in-
iMEsritanoe derived from God and nature !
nueyhave lost die constitutional means of
redress for. all their grievances ! What is it in«
deed they have not lost by that hated septen-
nbl law, which has fettered down the elective
power of the people, like a dog to a manger,
who is only sumred to go abroad once in
seven years for an airing \"
• No. VI. p. 184 and 185. *^ Rouse then, ye
Britons! Awake from the slumbering state
of apathy in which you have so lon^ suffered
younelves ingloriously to remain! Open
vour eyes to the injuries which have been
heaped on you ; and assert your right to have
them redressed. Evince to all the world that
jou are the true descendants and sons of
your once famed glorious ancestors; prove
yourselves worthy to inherit, in its highest
degree of perfection, tha^ constitution, which
they raised by their valour, and cemented with
their bipod: — Raise your voice — the voice
ol the people — and sound in the ears of ty-
rants and their abettors, that ^oy will be free
and you are so : That voipe is the noble, the
migh^ fiat, which none can, or dare to, at-
tempt to gainsay."
No. XL p. 375. '' And what would he
Cearl of Chatham) have thought, if he had
lived to hear people now talk of a happy and
glorious oonatitution, evidently built upon
comiplion, and supported by peculation?
And what would he have conjectured, had he
aeeo a proclamation issued to intimidate and
fvevent the people from exercisine their right
of conferring upon, and ptd>lishing their
grievances I*'
No. XII. p. 414. ^' But we should ask,
here, what is the difference between a king
of England taxing his subjects without eon-
aent of parliament, and taxing them with
the consent of parliament, which parliament,
the king, or his minister can influence as he
pleases to approve of war or peace, and to
vote such 8up;>lies as may be required; no
matter how grievous or burthensome, nor for
what base or cosrupt purposes they, are
gfaHted. One would think that the latter
method is equally oppressive, and ddservingf
of reprobation ; for being done with a seem-
injg legality, and under a form and semblance
orconstitutional procedure, the people are
made parties to their own oppression, and
the g^reatest insults are added to the heaviest
injunes/'
P. 419. " Here we see clearly the origm
of the immense overgrown landed property of
our race of nobles and rich commoners ; a
right founded in murder, desolatioti, rapine,
and proscription of the first owners and
holders of the landed property, in this king-
dom, among our Saxon ancestors; and by
this we may easily trace the means by which
our nobility are at this moment not only in
Eossession of one branch of the legislature by
ereditary claim, but by which they have also
monopolised, with the addition of a few rich
commoners, the majority of voice in the
House of Commons, which, shame to tell, is
barefacedly called the representation of the
people. This we pledge ourselves to prove
to the satisftction of our readers in the course
of this work, and indeed of a few more num-
bers/* And the said paper or publiration,*
intituled, *< A Declaration of Rights, and
Address to the people, approved of by a num-
ber of the Friends of Reform in Paisley,''
distributed and circulated as aforesaid, con-
tained the following passages :
Paisley Declaration, p. 4. ''1. Being sub-
ject to the legislation ot persons whom other
men have placed over you, it is evident you
are denied that which is the right of every
one, and without which none are free. For
to be enslaved, is to have no will of your own
in the choice of those law- makers, which have
power over your properties, your families, your
lives, and liberties. Those who have no votes
for electing representatives are not free^ as-
the rights of nature, and the principles of our
constitution require, but are enslaved to the
representatives of those who have votes.*'
P. 5. '* 3. Should you not associate in
your own- cause, and with one voice? the
voice of united millions demand reform in the
national representation/'
P. 8. ** 10. But such a -parliament cannot
be had unless we will revert to the first prin-
ciples of our constitution, which we have so
smimefully abandoned. A government where
the executive and legislative power meet in a
single person has no more pretence to free-
dom : It is perfect despotism : and the people
who submit to it are in a state of slavery. If
the will of the prince must be law, in what
manner it is announced, whether the man-
date issue directly from the throne itself, or
through the medium of the House of Com-
mons, is a matter of indifference. If that
assembly is no longer the representative of
the people, the constitution is changed. If
those men who are said to* represent us arc
only the re^sters of the royal edicts, the go-
vernment 18 degenerated into an absolute
4
Its] SS GBOBiGX UL Proeeedbigs i^fiiM Tkamu Mmr
[IM
ippiwrcby. Since eleeting a Mrliaiaaiit is
our only decurity iguBstan aroitfary power
in the crown, efecUon itself must be not onl^
the common rkhty but the common duty, of
ell the people.'*^
P. 15. ** But the evils of long narliaments
—ore they not written in tears ana in blood ?
And have they left us aught of liberty but the
name? With the poor exception, then, of
cAe year of freednm in seven, and that in
hvoar of not one-seventh part of the nation,
it is demonstrated that you are constantly
taxed without being represented, and com-
pelled to obey laws to which you never gave
assent. Are not these the veiy definitions of
slaverv ? And, are you not thus degraded to
a level with the verv cattle in the field, and
the sheep in the fold ; which are a property
to those who rule over them, and OKve no
power to say, whv are we bought and sold ?
Why are we voked and laden with heavy
burthens? Why are we fleeced and led to
the slaughter ? Demand then with one voice,
firiends and countiymen, that share in making
your own laws to which, by the constitution
and the laws of nature, you are entitled ; call
for the bill which would restore your lost
constitution and recover your slokai rights!
Fursue the onl v course which can ever effect
any considerable reduction of debts and taxes,
or materially advance the interest of manu-
factures and commerce ! In short, be free,
prosperous and happy ! and give your poste-
rity the same cause to revere your memories,
as vou have to bless those proj^enitors who
left you an inheritance in a free constitu-
tion.^
And the above writing or publication, inti-
tuled, *' A Dialogue between the Governors
and the Governed^" distributed and circulated
as aforesaid, contamed among others, the fol-
lowing passages
Dialogues. ** ChU Gwoernon. The law
enacts that ye be submissive.
^ FeopU. The law is the general will, a
new order.
** Civil Gtfwmen. Yoa will be a rebel-
liouspeople.
'' People. Nations cannot revolt; tyrants
are the only rebels.
" Civil Governors, The Kuij; is with us,
and he commands you to submit.
*' People. The kingly office originates in
the people, who elect one of themselves to
execute it for the general good. Kings,
therefore, are essentially indivisible from
their nations. The king of ours, then, cannot
b(D with you ; you only possess his phantom.
And the military governors stepping forward,
said, * The people are timid, let us menace
* them, they otuy obev force. Soldiers, chas-
' tise this insolent rabble/
** People. Soldien^ you are of our own
blood! Will you stnke your brothers? If
the people perish, who will maintain the
army? — And the soldiers grounding their
armS) said to their chiefs^ • We abo. are the
* people, we are tbe enemies of i/
wherety n the eccleMsstical governors said^
* There is now but one resource left. The
'people are superstitious; we must firidilen
* them with the name of God, and ot rali*
'gion. — Otir dearly beloved brethren, oar
'children! God has appointed us to govern
'you,*
^ People. Produce to us your heawnly
powers.
" Priettt. You must hatre faith, reeaoQ
will lead you astray.
** PeopU, Do you govern then without
reason?
" Prietti. God ordains peace ; leligioii
prescribes obedience.
" People. Peace presupposes justice; obo*
dience hss a right to know tiie law it bows to*
^Prietii. lian is only bom into this woiid
tosufier.
" People. Do you then set tis the example*
^'Priedi. Will you Uve without God and
without kings?
** Peofle. We will live without tynnts^
without impostors.'*
Further, the said Thomas Muir having^
upon the lltb, ISth, or 13th days of De«
cember 1792, or on one or other of the days
of that month, been present at a meeting
calling itself ** The Convention of Delegates
of the Associated Friends of the People,** or
assuming some such name; which meeting
was held in a room commonlv called Laurie*s
room, in James's-court, in the city of Edin-
burgh, he did then and there, with a wicked
and seditious design, produce, and read aloud
to the said meeting, a writing or paper, inti-
tuled, " Address from the Society or United
Irishmen in Dublin, to the Delegates for
promoting a Reform in Scotland.^ Which
writing or paper was of a most inflammatory
and seditious tendency, falsely and insidi-
ously representing the Irish and Scotch na-
tions as in a state of aownright oppression,
and exciting the people rebeffiousiy to rise
up and oppose the government. And which
paper or writing, among other passages, con-^
tained the following :
P. 1. ^ We take the liberty of addressmg
you in the spirit of civic imion, in the fellow-
ship of a just and common cause. We greatly
rejoice that the spirit of freedom moves ov<et
the 8ur£u» of Scotland, tiiat light seems to
break from the chaos or her internal govern*
ment, and that a country so respectwle for
her attainments in science, in arts^ and in
arms, for men of literaty eminence, for the
intelligence and morality of her people, no#
acts from a conviction of the union between
virtue, letters, and hberty ; and now rises to
distinction, not by a calm, contented, secret
wish for a reform in parliament, but by
openly, actively, and urgently willing it, with
the unity and energy ofan embodied nation.
We n^oice that you do not consider ynuiw
selves m merged, and molted down into
125]
JOr SSdBUt\3n*
A.1X ITSS^
[126
mother eoonfiy, bat libatiB this great na-
tional quesCioii yoa are itili Sootland."— <
Also,
. P. 3. ^Wa wiUlaj open to jou oar hearts:
Our cause is yoor cause. If there is to be a
stnjerie between us, let it be which nation
abafibe foremost in the race of mind. Let
this be the noble ammosity kindled between
us, who shall first attain that free constitu-
tion fiom which both are eoui-distant. Who
shall first be] the savioor of toe empire. The
sense of both countries, with respect to the
iniblemble abuses of the constitution, has
been clearly nuuuiested, and proves, that
•ur pohtical situatioDs are not dinimilar,
^ our.rights and wrongs are the same.''-
Abo,
P»0. ^Wewill not be the dupes of such igno-
ble artifices. We see this scheme, of streng^
cning political persecution and state inquisi-
tion, hy a ftesh infusion of relicious fanaticism.
But we will unite, and we wiU be free. Uni-
versal emandpation, with representative
J^shtnre, is the polar principle which guides
our Society, and shall guide it, through all
the tumult of factions, and fluctuations of
parties. It b not upon a coalition of opoo-
Mtion with ministrv that we depend, but
upon a coalition of Irishmen with Irisfainen ;
and in that coalition alone we find an object
ivorthy of reform, and, at the same time, the
atreneth and sinew both to attain and secure
it. It is not upan external circumstances,
upon the pledge of man or minister, we de-
pend, but upon the internal energy of the
Irish nation.o-We will not buy or borrow
JSberty from America or from France, but
snanafiu:tare it lor ourselves, and woric it up
with those materials which the hearts of
Iii5hmc»iffmdi them with at home.— We
dd net worship the British, far less the Irish
constitution, as sent down from heaven ; but
we consider it as human workmanship, which
man has made, imd man can mend. An
imalterable constitution, whatever be its
xurture, must be despotism. It is not the
constitution, but 4*. people, which ought to
be inviolable; and it |^ time to recognise and
leoovate the righu of the English, the Scotch,
and the Irish nations.'^— Also^
P. 1 1. ^ Tou have our ideas— answer us, and
that quicklyw-— This is not a time to procrasti-
iiata^-*-Your illustrious Fletcher has said, that
She fiberties of a peqile are not to be secured
without pasttngthrough great difficulties; and
vo toil or labour ought to be declined to pre-
serve a nation from slavery. He spoke well;
and we add, that it is incumbent on every
natioB mkim adventures into a conflict for
Ire^lom, to remember, it is on the event
(hfwever absurdly) depends the estimation
cfpuUie opinion; honour and immortality,
tf mrtunate ; if otherwise, infamy and obli-
iFion. Let thb check the rashness that
rushes unadvisedly into the comnuttee, of
natiimal character; or, if that he already
wde, let the same considenttOn impel us
with Mive, not passive perseveralice, with
manly confidence, and calm determination,
smiling with equal scorn at the bluster of
offioiar arrogance, and the whispers of private
malevolence, imtil we have planted tne flag
of freedom on the summit, and are at once
victorious and secure."
"* M^AUMter^ lOS, Grt^Um-street^ PrinierJ*
Which seditious paper or writing, contain*
ing, among others, tne aboVe passage^ tbe
said Thomas Muir did, immediately tnare«
after, wickedly and feloniously, propose
should be received, and lie on the table of
the said meeting; and did also move, that
the thanks of the meeting, or some acknow«
lodgment, should be returned to those from
whom the foresaid ^pBper or address came.
And moreover, the said Thomas Muir did,
then and there, wickedly and felonknidy ex-
press his approbation of the sentiments con-^
tained in the said paper or address, or, at
least, did dedare, that it was altogether haitn-
les^ or used words and expressions of a
simtlat' import, notwithstanding that many
of those who were present at the foresaid
meeting did oppose and olgect to the foresaid
paper or address being read, or allowed to lie
on the table, or in any shape acknowledged
by the said meeting. And the said Thomas
Muir having been brought before John Prin*
ele^ esq. our sheriff<mute of the county of
Edinburgh, upon the 9a day of January 1799,
did^ in his presence, emit and sign a decla-
ration : but immediately thereafter, the sakl
Thomas Muir, conscious of his guilt in the
premises, did. in order to evade punishment,
abscond and leave the kingdom; and having
been indicted at the instance of our advo*
cate, for our interest, to stand trial before
the hifdi court of justiciary, upon the 11th
day ofFehruary last, the diet was afterwardi
continued to the 95th of that month, to give
him the better opportuniQr of apporing, if
he was so disposed; but the said Thomaa
Muir having notwithstanding; failed to ap«
pear, he was, on the S5th of^ February hurt,
nigitate by a sentence of the said high court..
And the said Thomas Muir having lately, in
a private and clandestine manner, come into
this country, by way of Ireland, he was dis«
^covered at Portpatrick, apprehended, and
committed prisoner to the Tolbooth of Stran*
raer, in the county of Wigton. on the 90tii,
or some other day in the montn of July last;
and, at same time, sundry papers found in
his possession were, together with his pocket*
booK, sealed up in the presence of William
Ross, esq. one of our justices of peace for
the shire of Wigton, under tbe seals of the
said Thomas Muir and the town seal of
Stranraer. And the said Thomas Muir
having been afterwards transmitted to Edin-
bur^, by warrant of our high court of jus-,
ticiary, siong with the said pocket-book and
papers, the sealed parcel containing the same
was opened in presence of him, the said
Thomas Muir, and Harry Davidson, esq.
127]
38 OBOB6EUL
Proceedings against T/umas Mtdr
[188
sheriff-substitote of the comity of Edinlnifeh,
upon the lOlh day of August current, 5ke
deals haying been pieyiously inspected by the
aaid Thomas Muir, and declared by him to
be entire, and an inventoiy of the contents
thereof was made, and signed by the said
Thomas Muir and Harry Davidson, and
dthers then present And the above-men-
tioned declarations emitted by the said
Thomas Muir before the sheriff-depute of
Edinburgh, upon the Sd of January 1793,
together with a copy of " Paine's Works,"
recommended and circulated as aforesaid ;
as also, a copy of the said ** Declaration of
Rights, and an Address to the People, ap-
proved of by a numbf r of the Friends of
Reform in Paisley," circulated as aforesaid;
as also, a copy of the *' Dialoeue between
the Governors and the Governed," circulated
as aforesaid; as also a copy 6(" The Patriot,"
circulated as aforesaid; as also, a copy of
^' the Address from the Society of United
*^ Irishmen in Dublin, to the Delegates for
** promoting a Reform in Scotland," pro-
duced, read, and approved of by the said
Thomas Muir, in manner aforesaid, and at-
tested by the subscriptions of James Den-
holm, James Campbell, and others; and also,
a book, intituled, ** The Book of the Records
of the Association of the Friends of the Con-
stitution and of the People of Kirkintilloch,
YOlume 1st, entered at Ku-kintiUoch, Novem-
ber 1793 ;** and also tiie foresaid inventoiy,
made up tefore the said Thomas Muir and
the Sheriff-substitute of Edinburgh, upon the
said 10th day of August current, with tiie
"whole articles and papers therein contained
and referred to, wiu all be used in evidence
Munst the said Thomas Muir, and -will for
that purpose in due time be lodged with the
olerk or the high coOrt of ji|sticiary, be«
fore which he is to be tried!, that he may
have an opportunity of seeing the same. At
least, times and places above-mentioned,
the said seditious speeches and harangues
were uttered, the said seditious books or
pamphlets, recommended to be purchased and
perused, the said seditious books or pam-
phlets, circulated and distributed, as afore-
said, and the said wicked and inflaroma-
tonr address produced, read, recoonmended,
and approved of, in manner above-men-
tioned ; and the said Thomas Muir is
guilty actor, or art and |>art, of all and each,
or one or other of the foresaid crimes. All
which, or part thereof, being found proven,
by the verdict of an assize, nefore our lord
iustice general, lord justice clerk, and
lords commissioners of iusticiary, in a
court of justiciai^ to be holden by them
within the criminal court-house of Edin-
burgh, the said Thomas Muir ought to be
punished with the pains of law, to deter
others from committing the like crimes in
all time coming.
UST OF WltV£S8St.
John Brown, wesver at Lennostoun, in the
parish of Camp6ie,and county of Stuiin^.
John- Speir, weaver at Lennoxtotta.8fore8aid<
William Robertson, excise-officer at Lennox^
toon aforesaid.
Francis Clark, caUko printer, at Lennox MiU,
parish and county aforesaid.
Afexander Johnston, bleacher at Kiacaid
Printfield, in parish of Campsie aforesaid.
Henry Freeland, weaver in KirkintiUoch.
William Muir, we^er in KirkintiUoch. -
John Scott, wrttht in KirkintiUoch.
Robert WeddeU, weaver in KirkintiUoch. '
James Baird, hosier in KirkintiUoch.
The Hev. Mr. William Dunn, minister of Kir«
kintilloch.
John Scott, weaver in Townhead of Kirkin-
tiUoch.
WUliam Knox, weaver there.
James Muir, student of divinity residing at
Campsie.
Anne Fisher servant, or .late servant, to Mr.
John Carlisle, coUector of the cess in
Glasgow.
Thomas WUson, barber in Glasgow.
William Reid, bookseller and stationer in
Glasgow. •
James Brash, bookseller and stationer there.
David Blair, manufiicturer in Glas^w.
John Muir, senior, late hat>manufacturery
presentlv residing in Glasgow. i
Jcmn Barclay, residing in the parish of Calder,
in the oounty of Duiark, and one of the
elders of the said parish.
The Rev. Mr.' James Lapslie, minister of
Campsie.
James Campbell, writer to the signet.
James Denhofan, writer in Edinburgh.
Hugh Bell, brewer in Edinburgh.
Jomi Buchanan, baker in Canongate of Edin-
burgh.
Mr. John Morthland, advocate.
William Skirving of Strathruddie, residing in
Edinburgh.
Lieutenant- colonfil William Dalrymplc of
Fordell.
Mr. Robert Forsyth, advocate.
Richard Fowler, student of medicine, residing^
or lately residing in Edinburgh.
John Pringle, esq. sheriff-deputeof tlie county
of Edinburgh.
WiUiam Scott, solicitor-at-law, and procu-
rator-fiscal of the said county of Edinburgh.
Joseph Mack, writer in Edinburgh.
Sir James Colquhoun of Luss, baronet, sheriff-
depute of the shire of DusJiarton.
WUlmm Honeyman,e8q. aherift^epute of th«f
shire of Lanark.
Harry Davidson, esq. sheriff-substitute of the
county of Edinbujqgh.
George WiUiamson, messenger in Edinburgh.
Mr. James Carmiehael, commander of the
Justice hulk, in tliet service of the board of
customs.
WiUiam Boss, esq. one of the justices of
pea^e for the county of Wigton.
19Sf]
JbrSttBiUu.
A.D. 1798.
[130
. Tatfai8iBiiie«iii«iit Mr«Muir pleaded. Not
Guilty.
. The* Lard Juttke Clerk then asked who was
lus counsel ; and if he or they had any olyiec-
tkuiywhythe sadd indictment should not be
remitied to the knowledge of an assize ? .
. Mr. Afiu'r. My lord» I am my own counsel ; *
nor shall I now trouble the Court with anv
observations whatever, but reserve nwself
entirely till I come to address the jury, whom
in this country I hold to be judges both of the
I law and the fact
The Lard Justice Clerk then demanded
what ezcul{»atory proof Mr. Muir proposed to
set up, as it must now be stated^ otherwise it
wouu not be allowed.
. Mr« Muir observed, that he had shortly
given in writing the exculpatory proof lie in*
tended to offer ; that he had been accused of
seditious harangues, and of circulating im-
proper bookfi^ and that he intended to prove
the reverse.
The Conrt then desired to know, as it might
save trouble^ whether he admitted that he
bad recommended the particular books libelled ?
To which he answerra in the negative ; but
that he had advised reading books on all
aides of the question.
In point of form, it is required in Scotland,
th^t the person accused should communicate
upon the evening preceding the trial, in writ-
ing the substance of his defence, with a list
oftfae witnesses intended to be adduced in
exculpation. Mr. Muir had complied with
this rule, and the clerk of court read the
following
nCFENCBS.
The criminal libel is false and injurious ;
so fax from exciting the people to riot and in-
surrection, it can easily be proved, by a nume-
rous list of witnesses, that, upon every occa-
sion, the panel exhorted them to pursue
measures moderate, legal, peaceable, and con-
stitutional. The charge of distributing sedi-
tious publications, ana of advising the people
to read tiiem, is equally fsdse and calumnious.
The panel admits^ that on the great national
question, concemmg an equal representation
of the people in the House of Commons, he
exertea every effort to procure in that House,
a fall, faiWy and equal representation of the
people, as he considered it to be a measure
(ana still does) the most salutary for the inte-
rest of his country. But the panel offers to
prove, that as he considered the information '
of the people to be the chief thing requisite
to accomplish this great object, he uniformly
advised them to read every publication^ upon
either side, which the important question of
parliamentary reform had occasioned.
(Signed) Thomas Muir.
-
*«See a.note to the case of Joseph Gerrald
lA^this Volume, poi^i containing an extract of
a letter from the hoiif Henry ErsHine.
voLxxni.
Annexed -are a list of witnesses in esculv
pation.
Under protestation to add and eik.
LIST OP WITNESSES
adduced in Exculpation,
William Riddle^ baker in Glasgow-
John Hamilton, manufacturer^ St Andiew'fr-
square, Glasgow.
David Dale, jun. manufacturer there. 1
Basil Ronald,ofBroomlone, glover in Glasgow.
Alexander Park,- writer in C^asj^w.
George. Waddel, manufacturer m Glasgow. >
George Russei,. merchant in Gsdlowgatt^
Glasgow.
John Brock, manufacturer in Glasgow.
John Wilson, shoemaker in Gorbals of Glas*
• ROW.
John Lockhart, mason there. .
Walter Hart, heritor in Tradestown, Glasgow*
Hugh Moodie, spirit dealer in Glasgow.
James Cooper, snoemsdcer, Glasgow.
John Gray, manufacturer^ Glasgow.
Daniel M'Arthur, one of the masters of the
grammar-school, Glasgow.
James Richardson^ sen. merchant, Gla^w.
William Clydesdale, cabinet* maker there.
John Tennant, brewer there.
George Bell, jun. manufacturer there.
George Stayley, manufacturer in Balmanno-
street, Glasgow.
Robert M*KinTay, print-cutter in Mr. Fidton's
employment, near Paisley.
William Orr, jun. manufacturer in Paisley.
James Craig, manufacturer, Water nrae.
Paisley.
James Gemmel, merchant, Storie-street,
Paisley.
William Muir, Fisher-row, Paisley.
Hamilton Ballantyne, Storie-street,, Paisley.
James Muir, weaver. Shuttle-street, Paisley.
John Buchanan, foreman at Kincaid prini-
field, in the parish of Campsie.
Robert Honarie, printer there.
Patrick Horn, printer there.
Smollet M^Lintock, block-cutter there.
William Henry, of Borrowstown parish, Bal-
dernock.
James M'Gibbon, printer, at Kincaid print-
field.
John Freeland, distiller in Kirkintilloch.
Andrew Rochead, younger, of Duntiblaemilly
parish of Kirkintilloch.
Robert Boak, surgeon in Kirkintilloch.
John Edmond, print-cutter, Kincaird print-
field.
Robert Millar, weaver in Cambauslang.
The Rev. Mr. VyiUiam Dunn, mimster of
Kirkintilloch.
David Wallace, late servant to James Muir
of Huntershill, now to James 3tark of
Adamslie.
Robert Scott, weaver in Kirkintilloch.
Archibald Binnie, type-founder, Edinburgh.
Charles Salter, brewer in Edinburgh.
Peter Wood, teacher in Portsburgb.
John Buchannan^ baker in Canon^ate.
1
Hi]
S3 G£ORG£ m.
Proeeediagt «pS»ii Tk^nuu Mmr
tm
••'i--*^ Ben, tobaeoifnist, Canongate.
Wiiiiam Skirving, Edinburgh.
Maurice ThoaiM>n> 8tarch*maker there*
Andrew Wilson, brewer in Portsburgh.
John Smithy weaver, Lothian Road.
Peter Hardie, brewer in Port&burgh.
Col. William Daliymple, of FordeU.
Wilfiam JdiBstoi!, era. Edinburgh.
The Right Hon. Ix>rd Daer.
— -^ Newton, residing St. PatrickVsquare,
* Edinburgh.
Inunediately afterwards the lord justice
clerk asked Mr. Mnir, if he had any thing
^krther to state, in support of these defences,
as in the farther course of the trial he would
be precluded from adducing any thing entra-
tieotts. - '
Mr. Muir then rose up and said. Accord-
ing to the nde 6f Court, I have the even-
itig before this day communicated to the pub-
lic prosecutor the substance of rov defence in
writing. The truth of every word in that de*
fence I shall stronriy prove before I leave this
^l»r. I admit that lezerted every effort to pro-
cure a more equal representation of the people
in the House of Commons. Ifthatbea crime,
i I plead guilfy to the charge. I acknowledge
that I considered the cause of parliamentary
reform to be essential to the salvation of my
eoudtry ; but I deny that I ever advised the
people to attempt to accomplish that great ob-
fec^ by any means which Ibe constitution did
* not sanction. I grant that I advised the peo-
ple t6 read different publications upon both
<aides, which this great national question had
excited, and I am not ashamed to assign my
oiiotives. I consider the ignorance of the
people, on the one hand, to be the source from
Vhich despotism flows : I consider, upon the
<itber hand, an ignorant people, impressed
with a sense of grievances, and wishing to
tliave these ^evances redressed, to be exposed
to certain misery and to complete ruin. Know-
ledge must always precede reformation, and
who shall dare to sa^ that the i>eople should
be debarred irom information, where it con-
terns them so materially ? I am accused of se-
dition ; and yet, I can prove by thousands of
Ndtxkesses^ that I warned the people of the
danger of that crime, exhorted them to adopt
none but measures which were constitutional,
ilind intreated them, to connect liberty with
knowledge, and both with morality. This is
what I can prove. IfthesearecrimesI am
• guilty.
Their lordships then proceeded to givetheir
^ opinion on the relevancy of the inmctment.
' iMd Htnderland, My lord justice clerk ;
Tlie crime with which the indictment charges
the batiel at the bar, is that of exciting ais-
'Confentfimonistthepeople ^ofendeavounngto
c^te a rebellion ; otfeloniously disseminating
wicked and seditious piblications,,and advising
their perusal. It cnarges him likewise with
recommending, printing and approving decla-
ntionscalcufamd to produce riotand confusion ;
f and partieufaurly irituattacking kingly govern-
teent»a i^lar op whiA^h^ciattihitoi hiiif c^
and which if undermined or pulled dowiH mm
fttve rise to the most serious eotaequenees^
Had he observed the history of thb coimtiy^
he would have seen the pemidous coiiae^
nuences of the crimes laid to hit charm; or
had he observed the situation of a neightiour-
ing counti^, he would have seen that amilar
cnmes had like an earthquake swallowed up
her best citizens^ and endangered the lives
and properties ot all. Sorry shall I be, if of
such a crime any man be found guilty. I hope
the panel at the bar may be able to exctilpiae
himself; but if the charges libelled are fouml
to be true, they in my opinion must be fbuad
relevant, to infer the pains of law, and those
pains include ev^ thing short of a o^ital
punishment.
Lord Swinton sedd. he never had heard suck
an indictment reaa, and he did not believe
that in the memory of man, there overbad
been a libel of a more dangerous tenden^
read in that Court There was hardly a line
of it which, in his opinion, did not amount to
high treason; and which, if proven, must
inter the highest punishment the law can in-
flict.
Lord Duntinnan and lord Abercromhy coio-
cided in opinion with lord Henderlaod and
lord Swinton as to the dangerous tendency of
the crimes charged ; and that if proven, the
highest punishment should be inferred.
Lord Juttice Clerk* The crime herechaigedy
is sedition ; and that crime is aggravated ac*
cording to its tendency; the tendency here is
plainly to overturn our present happv conatif
tntion — the happiest, the best, ana tne most
noble constitution in the world, and I do not
believe it possible to make abetter; — and
the books which this gentleman has circulated
have a tendency to make the people believe
that the government of this country is venal
«and corrupt, and thereby to excite rebellion.
Ills lordship, therefore, agreed to find the
libel relevant to infer the pains of law.
The Court then pronounced the fdlowin^
IltTBRLOCVTOB
^ '* The lord justice clerk, and lords commis^
sioners of justiciary, having consider^ thie
criminal libel, raised and pursued at the io-
stance of Robert Dundas^ esq. of AmistoBj^ his
majesty's advocate, for his majesty's inlexest,
against the said Thomas Muir, panel, they
find the libel relevant to infer the pains, of
law, but allow the panel to prove b\\ fitcts
and circumstances that mav tend to exCuJ^atte
him, or alleviate his giuit; and remit the
panel, with the libel, as found relevant, to
the knowledge of an assize.'*
The interlocutor having been pouooneed,
tbe derk of court gave the loid jastke clerk
the following list of forty five jmyBien.
Sir John Clerk, of Pennycuick, banmet.
Sir William Dick, of Prestonfidd banxoet* -
Sir John Inglis; of Cnmond| baitipel^
issi
JSf aOkion.
A. Dl ITM.
[1»
^ ttArdiiMklHofB»«fCiai^iaHbaf«>iuH.
-. Bit niUip Ainslie, of Coaley-bnik bvonet
Charles Wataon, of Saughtpii.
James Forest, of ComisloD.
' Hiomas Craig, of RiccaitoD,
' C^aptaiD JofanlBg^of Auchindinny.
John Wauchope, of Edmonttone.
. John BalfiMr, ybnmr, of Pilrig,
IHvid Johnston, ofBavekw.
• Jolm Davie, of Oaviside.
Aiidiew Wauchcfe, of Niddry Bfarishal.
John Trotter, of MortoohaU.
Gilbert iBoes, of Stow.
John Davidson, of Ravelrijx.
James Rocheid, of InverictttL
John Newton, of CurriehiH.
James Caiderwood Durham^ of Pollon.
Theaoas Wright, of Greenhill.
Jamea GiUe^ie, of Spvelaw.
Thomas 8ivewrieht of South^house.
James Kerr, of Woodbum.
John ANes, of Dalkeith, portioner.
Fatrick Pridie, batter in Bdinburgh.
Thomas Brown, bookseller there.
Andrew Smith, periiimer there.
James Charles noeier there.
Alexander Inglis, merchant there.
William Pattison merchant there.
William Cooper, ooholsterer there.
Andrew Ramsay, slater there.
Thomas Duncan, bookseller there.
William Dalrymple, merchant there.
PiVicis Bnchan, merchant there.
James Mattsfield hanker there.
Donald Smith, banker there.
' James Dickson, bookseller there.
Samuel Peterson, merchant there.
George Rinnear, banker there.
Andrew Forbes, merchant there.
John Homer, meidiant there.
Afaander Wallace, banker there.
William Nairke
Alex. ABEacaoMBT
JOBN SWINTOM .
The Lttrd Jiutice Clerk proceeded to name
ihe jury* and called Sir James Fowlis^ of Col-
liagton bart, and captain John IngUs of Au-
chudinoy.*
Captain Jngtitf before being^ sworn men-
tioned that he was a servant ot government ;
^t be understood Mr. Muir was accused of
a crime against government ; and that he
did not consider it as proper, that Mr. Muir
should be tried bvajury composed of servants
of government ; Uiat bis mind felt scrupulous
labom:ed under much anxiety, and he begged
leave io decline being a juryman.
i Captain Inglis was informed by the Court,
that there was no impropriety in his being a
juryman, although belonging to the service of
^ govemment.t
*^
w^immm
..«v>v
* For the mode in whicha Scots junr is ap-
fointMil, aee the note to the case of James
Vol. i«, p. 11.
t As to this see VoL S8; p. 1038.
• The T^rd Jnxtice Gto*ik, in the ueoal formt
asked Mf. Muir if he had any objections to
stale to the first five gentlemen, whose namea
he had selected from the Ibt of assize.
Mr. JIftftr said;-^Of these gentlemen I
have no oersooal knowledge. Their situa*
tions in lile are resneetable, and I believe them
to be men of train and of honour ; yet my
situatkm and theirs it so peculiar, that I am
ohli^id to object to them being upon thia
jury. The question of parliamentary reform
nas ablated deeply, in pfoportbn to its mag-
nitude, the minds of men in this country r
difierent opimons have been adopted, and diif»
#f«ient parties have been formed. Thcsegeo^
tlemeo beloas to an association which assem*-
bled in GowTsmith's-hall, calling themsehee
the fiisnds of the eonstitution, united to sup-
port it against repubticans and levellers, and
exoressing their zeal to suppress tumult and
seoition. I belong to the association c^ the
tFriends of the People. Viewing a refonn in
the representation of the aeople as a measure
the most conducive to tne stability nf the
oonstitiition, and to the felici^- of the peoploL
we united our oonuMon exertions, by legm
measures, to accomplish that object. \
To the eonairitiilion, in its genuine nrinci*
pies, we have solemnly pledeed ourselves^M*
Never have we professed to oe its eneo^ei^
yet the association in Goldsmith*»4udl, by a
delibemte and public act of their's, have dc^
clared, that we were the enemies of the co»>
stitution. Bqualty zealous in our declarations
to U)e workU--in our reprobating riot and se-
dition, and sincere in our hearts, that asao-
ciatiou has denounced us to this country, sn
attempting to kindle the torch of civil war,
and to lay it in blood and destruction. The
Aut upon which I found this charge is noto-
rious, and cannot be denied. A convention
of delegates, from all the societies of the
Friends of the People, in Scotland, assembled
in this dty, upon tne 1 Jth dav of December
last. Of this convention I had the honour qf
being a member. The convention accorded
with the association at GoldsmiUi's4Min, in
their seal to support the eonstitution, iu their
abhorrence of seidition, and in thdr determi-
nation to concur with good citizens in the
suppreasMMi of riot and of tumult. To testify
tiien to this association, their principles ana
their object, the convention ordered a number
of its members to repair to their hall, and to
subscribe the book wnich they had opened of
adherence to the constitution. In this number
I was included. We did so. And, what were
the consequences^ The association erazed
our names, and published in the papers of
the day their proceeding. Was not this an
aot of public proscription against us all ? Ac-
cused this day of sedition, of an attempt to
^overthrow the oon8titution,(shall those men
be my jurymen, who have not merely accused
me, but hke wise judged and eondemned me
without knowing me, without leaving me the
poasihility ofth^pqwerofvindicalloii? This
135]
SS GEORGE. m.
Proceedings ag^umt Tkomas Muir
[156
is DO trivial matter. It afiects me, but
It afiects the countiy more. The noiae of it
will pass down to other times, and posterity
may limey their most valuable rignts con-
nected with its consequences.
A respectable gentleman of the five to
whom 1 now object, has felt the delicacy of
his situation, and has honourably avowed his
acruples. Such sentiments, so respectful in
themselves, I trust are common to all his
colleagues.
^ This is not the only objection I stale to the
{;entleawn of GoldsroithVhall beine of my
jury. 1 am accused of circulating the works
of Mr. Paine. That association has publicly
^advertised their horrors at the doctrines con-
tained in these books. Nay, more, they have
offered a reward of five guineas, to any one
who will discover a person who may have
circulated them ! If this is not prejudicating
my cause, I demand to know what prejudica-
tion is?
Upon these two objections, I shall make
no nuther observations. To suppose them
not well founded, would be to msult the
common sense ami the common feelings of
mankind.
1 demand justice. Let me be tried fidrly,
not by a jury of the Association of Goldsmith's-
>hall, not by a jury of the Association of the
Triends of the People, but by men uncon-
nected with either, whose minds cannot po»-
aibly be supposed warped with prejudices. I
therefore solemnly protest, that no person
who is a member of the association in Gold-
amithVhall, should, or can be, of the jury in
my trial.
The S&lietior General [B^tr] replied, that
he considered this objection to he ot the most
extraordinary nature. The panel is accused
of forming associations contrary to the consti-
tution, and he presumes to object 4o those
gentlemen, who formed associations in its
efence. With eifual propriety might the
panel object to their loraships on the bench,
to be his judges in this trial *. their lordships
had sworn to defeml the constitution.
Mr. JIftttr. — This day, I will not descend
into the Quibbles of a lawyer. I object to
these gentlemen, not because they associatoi
in defence of Uie constitution ; — I too, as wdl
as they, have associated in defence of the
Aoostitution ; — ^but my objection is, that they,
by an act of their*s, have publicly accused me
of being an enemy to the constitution, have
already pronounced the sentence of condem-
nation, and have imposed upon my name the
seal of proscription.
Lord Jwtke Clerk, — ^If the objections of
the panel were relevant, it would extend fiir
indeed ; it would go to every person who had
taken the oaths to ^vernment. I can see
nothing in the objection, and I am clear for
repelling it.
l/>rd Henderland. — I can see nothing in
theobjec&Hi; these 'centlemen entered into
^ society for a paxtiouur pvrposeiaQd had the
right of judging of the qualii&cation «f their
members ; they did not think Mr. Muu-or his
friends proper members. In no trial whatisver
could this be A good obiectioD.
The Court repelled the objection.
Mr. Muir, however, made the same objec-
tion to the next five that were selected, and
again to the last five.
When the list of the five last was presented,
he said it was not sufficient to say tnat these
gentlemen were free to form a society; this
IS a'fiict which no man in his sound senses
vrill dispute. But this society, when formed,
had opened, in a public place, a book for pub-
lic subscription, By repeated advertisements
they had called upon every firiend to the con-
stitution, every enemy to sedition and tumult,
every person inimical to a pubUc division of
property by a levelling system, to come and
subscribe their names in that book, as expces-
sive of their attachment to the constitution,
to property, and to peace. Every porter, every
chairman from the streets, was allowed to in-
sert his subscription. Why were the names
of the panel and his fieiends expuujged ? Was
it not a public denunciation of their being the
supporters of that system of plunder aM. of
disorder,. which that association was to op-
pose?
Their lordships were unanimous in repel-
ling theobjection,and the jury was impanelled
consisting of
Sir James Foulis, of Collington.
Captain John Inglis, of Auchindinny.
John Wauchope, of £dmoni|on.
John Balfour, younger, of Pilrig.
5 Andrew Wauchope, of Niddry-Marishall.
JohnTrotter, of Morton-HalL
Gilbert Innes, of Stow.
James Rochead, of Inverleith. '
John Alves, of Dalkieth, portioner.
10 William Dalrymple, merchant, £din. .
Donald Smith, banker, £din.
James Dickson, bookseller, Edin.
George Kinnear, banker, Edin.
Andrew Forbes, merchant, Edin.
15 John Horner, merchant, Edin.
When the jury were sWorn in, Mr. Muir
aeain stated, that he believed them to be meli
of truth and integrity, but never would cease
recalling to their attention the peculiarity of
their situation. They had already determined
his fate. They had already jud^ his cause ;
and as they valued their reputation, their own
internal peace, he entreated < Here
Mr. Muir was interrupted by the Court, who
concurred in opinion that his conduct was ex-
ceedingly improoer, in taking up their time,
as the objection had been repelled.
The lord advocate then proceeded to call
the witnesses.
Alexander Johnston,
Mr. Muir objected to this witness. He
said he did not Juiow him. He did not re-
member if ever he had seen him, but he could
clear^ prove, by reapaOable wtttMsses^ that
187]
fitr SciHim
A. D. 179S.
[J38
Htb penoB bad Mid, upon hearing of his ar-
livai in Scotland, that he wooSd do every
thiog in his power to have him hanged.
' Mr. Muir was asked if he could condescend
upon any particular circumstances of malice,
which this witness entertained against him.
He repHed. that he did not know him, there-
fore could specify no circumstances from
which the proposed witness might have en-
lertdned malice against him; Init the fact
that he had so expressed himself was certain
and true, and if permitted, he would imme-
diately substantiate what he had asserted by
the most convincing proof.
The Court observed, that witnesses might
i>e iiverse ti> bear testimon;]^. That for thb
poryN>9e they might make similar assertions
u order to disqualify themselves. That if,
upon objections of this kind^ they were to be
<isitf the ends of public justice might be de-
Ittled; besides, it was observed, that the
witness would be purged of malice upon oath.
The objection was unanimously over-ruled,
and the witnesses were adduced.
Alexander Johnston
Depones, that he was present at a meeting
in RirkintiUoch, some time in the month of
November last, but does not remembo'the
day. That the meeting had then no name,
but has been since known by the name of a
Reform Society.
[The lord justice clerk here reminded the
witness that he was to tell the whole truth ;
that though such a meeting might be
illegal, nothing could be laid to his
cha^ now he was a witness : and the
only harm he could do himself was
by perjury. — Mr. Muir having here ob-
served that his lordship insinuated that
these meetings were illegal, was desired
by his lordship to »t down. The wit-
ness prooeedea.] -
Mr. Mmr was present, who haransued the
meeting. As iar as he recollects, Mr. Muir
addressed the president;, stated the disadvan-
tages in the representation, some borouehs
being rotten, others having no .vote. He
.stated the population of England and Scot-
land, and mentioned, that from the smalloeius
of the iiuml)er who voted, the people were
not fiiliy represented. Mr. Muir said, that if
a man paid SOgOOOt for a seat in parliament,
•he. behoved to derive some interest from his
seat, and he referred to the people whether it
I was reasonable that a man snould pay so
. much for a seat in parliament witliout deriv-
ing some emolument in return. That the
.di»e of Richmond had complained of this,
. but that 30,000/. had been put into his pocket
to silence him. — That Mr. Muir compared
our constitution with the French, and said,
that b^ond a doubt they would be success-
fijJ. That they were more equally i^^e*
sented, and their taxes much less. That
two-thirds of the French national debt was
aheady p^id. That a manufiiciuiyr ia this
country could not bring his goods to market
with the same advantage * as the French
manufiuturers ; of course, we should lose our
trade. Mr. Muir said, the society ought to
be acquainted with the principles of those
members they admitted. That the sole in*
tention of these societies was, to procure a
more equal representation of Uie people, and
a shorter duration of parliament. That tha
means these societies were to use, for these
ends, was, to petition parliament, and to com;*
municate their resolutions, and extend their
knowledse, b]r publishing and circulating
usefiil publications. That in order to obtain
that knowledge, they ought to get all political
pamphlets from a neighbouring booKseller;
but he did not mention any pamphlet in par*
ticular. ' ,
Being interrogated by the solicitor-general
if there was anything said about the royal
Amily, he answered, that there was nothmg
said on that subject, except that thev were to
hold it legal to have a king ; but there was
nothing said about the powers of the king^
nor the expenses which his government might
incur. That a person present inquired into
the principles of the society, and one near
him said, that for his part be had no need of
any explanations ; for he had read *^ Paine's
Rights of Man." Being questioned as to the
circumstances in which Paine's book was
mentioned, he said, it was spoken by. one
neighbour to another, and he did not know
that Mr. Muir heard the conversation. The
most of the members were young weaverSi
from eighteen to twenty years otage. He
knew of no previous meeting at Kirkintilloch,
this one being the constituting one. Mr.
Muir did not come into the meeting till afUr
it was constituted, but had promised in Uie
morning to be there. He seemed to be the
principal man in tliat society, and said, he
belonged to other societies of the same sort c
be recommended to the people who intended
to form themselves into societies to do so
soon, that they might be able to cooimunicate
their sentiments to one another, and lay their
petition before parliament
Being cross-examined by Mr. Muir, he de»
poned, Tliat Mr. Muir did recommend order
and regularity to the meeting, and observed
that any tumult or disorder would ruin their
common cause. He told the meeting, that
there' was no other mode of procuring redresss,
but by applying to parliament ; and be re-
commenaed to the meeting to be careful
of what members they received, and to admit
no immoral characters. He likewise re*
commended reading political pamphlets ia
general.
' Robert Weddell
Depones, That he remembers a meeting in
Kirkintilloch, about the beginning of Novem-
ber last, which was called the meeting of the
Friends of the People,, or for a Parliamentary
Refi»in« That Mil Mw was at this moetk^,
I
)S6l SS GEORGE lA.
irhtch was6w oonstilHliBg ncetiiig^adBe ia
after the meeting began, and saaae m speech,
in which he advised regiilarit(y in thtir pro<^
oeedings; andmentioaed that they ought to
prooe^,* in a constitutional manner, as the
law now is, by king, lords, and commons.
He ssid nothing about the expence of a king,
nor the burthen of tares, nor the compaiatiiPe
expense of the French sorermneat, nor did he
mention the success ottheir arms. He spoke
about ten minutes. After the meetiuff lNt»ke
op, the witness met Mr. Muir, with some
others, in Mr. Wallace's, baker in Kirkin-
tilloch, where the conversation was about the
politics of Uie country— there wereabout^ght
present ia Mr. Wallace^ not eiia*foiartfa of the
number that was at the meeting. The wi^
ness was vice-president of the meeting, Mr.
FM^and was president, and James BaSd was
norstaiy; there were no other officers, and
mil these were with Mr. Muir in Wallace's.
He does not remember the particulars of the
Mversstion, but Flower on the French Om-
fltitution was mentioned, whkh he never b»>
Ibrs had heard of. He thinks it was Mr.
Ifair that mentioned this book, in speaking
of Hew publioations,aad he remembers books
Ittii^ spoken of. Depones, That at the meet-
ing, one Boyd asked Mr. Muir's opinion about
Ptene's Works, when Mr. Muir said, that it
was foreign to their purpose. He remembers
this, because he was angry at the question
being asked.
The Lord Advocate asked the witness, Whe-
tfier Flower's book had been recommended ?
Mr. Muir objected to the question. The
witness was removed.
Mr. Mair.— -There is no accusation brought
atainst this book in the libel. Let it be ad-
mtted that this book is of a seditious or a
treasoniMe nature, yet, as I am not accused
<»f either reoommending or chrculating it, how
can anything under this indictment, concern-
ing it, be adduced in evidence against me ? I
read imon a sreat princi[>le of natural justice :
look forward to other times, and I tremble
for the precedent. If this were not the case,
I would not say that I merely approved of
ihat bodk of Mr. Flower's ; but, in this j^eat
audienoe, I would recommend its principles,
in general, to every man who vakied the in-
teiests of nis country, and whose feelings in-
terest him in the happiness of human kind.
Lord Advocate — ^The charge against the
' f/AMl is sedition and il is branched out under
"Various heads. One of these was, advising
people to purchase seditious boc^s ; and he
was entitled to examine as to such facts,
%houch every particular book or (act was not
condescended on in the libel.
Mr. 3fttt>.-<-Neither in justice nor in law
has the public prosecutor a right to bring
Against me a seeferal chai^. l^ery criminsil
oKarge upon uie facts must be special, in order
that the panel may know the crime that is
alleged agah»t him, and acconUndy prepare
tlie spmal natter orhisdfiMoe,wWd it
l%mas Mnir
tI40
be lair in thaLsid Adfocafa, if hfe(Mr. Muir)
had been tried for rabbeiy^ to bimg a nroof
that he was suiltj of murdes f be could luva
proved that Mr. FlowGT^s book b no libel, or
oe might have brought evidence to prove that
he never recommended or ciicidated it, but
here an unfair advantage was taken of him;
it was a secret trap, an engine laid to ensnare
him.
Lord JuMiice Clerk. — By the statute of
James 0th, wherever art and part is libelled^
there can be no objection to the genemlity.
This is a proper question; it has a tend«DCj
to establish the m^or proposition, and it
ought to be susteuned.
Their Lordships were goin^ to give their
opinions on this point, when the Lord Adv<^
cate gave up the question.
The witness was agun called in, and de«
poned. That there was something mentioned
at the meeting about purchasing books, and
Henry's History of England was mentioned.
Being intercogated as to what books were pua*
chased in consequence of this conversation^
Mr. Muir objected to this question upon the
same grounds as before; out the objection
was repelled by the Court
The witness was then again interrogated
what were the books he had paichased or
any other person he knew ; deponed. That
he had purchased two or three copies of the
Political Progress of Great Britain, and three
or four copies of the Paisley Declaration of
Rights. Tnat these purchases were not made
for the Society, nor in consequence of the
conversation which took place at the meetings
but merely for his own amusement. That he
kept one of the copies for his own use, and he
got his own money for the other three copies
of it. That a copy was laid upon the table
before the meeting was gatherea. He knew
of no cofiies of Paine being circulated ; he
had read it, but did not recollect from whom
he had received it ; he never saw the Dialogues
between the Governors and the Governed, but
had seen one number of the Patriot, which
was shown to him by William Muir
Upon being cross-examined by the. panel,
depcmes. That Henry's Histoiy of England
was spoken of bv Mr. Muir. That Mr. Muir
did not advise tne people to riot, but that he
advised them to constitutional measures, and
said the more constitutional the more suc-
cessful they would be.
Being interrogated by the solicitor-general
concerning theooject of the Society, and what
he meant by a reform in parliament, was
every man to have a vote? he hesitated and
said there were dijfferent opinions, but that in
general it meant a more equal representation
of the people.**But what did he mean hy a
more equal representation of the people? Who
were to have votes? As the witness did not
readily replv to this question, the solidtor-
general took occaakm to dbserve, that he
wiandeiid what Mr. ifaiir intandatf l» aaka
1413
-^^ry t^^nW^^MrKv
of Hw p«Ofk ; wd ^lil if att Um mtmbefs of
4be socieQr ivwe as ignotuit as this vice pre**
ndent, tfacy tunst anom neMsiz about tiie
-Matter, laea the wiiaesB stated^ Ibat there
^vrere two opinioAs in the society, one party
was for having the Ttahts of volmg oenfiocd
to kDded property, tEe otherivas for every
aian having a vole.*--Which par^ was he of?
He had not fuliy made nf his miiid upon the
question. Did Mr. Muir give his opinion
iipon the point? He did not
Upon Mr. Muir's interrogatory) depones,
SliatMr. Muir recomraendM to avoid riot,
and saidy that tumult would ruin the cause-;
lie also advised them to take care oi the moral
cinracter of the members whom they ad-
mitted. He does not remember whether Mr.
Muir said he would desert them if they he-
tame unoonstilutionaly and he does not re-
member that he recommended them to pur-
i^hase any other book than Henry's Hutory of
Bn^and.
"^ Rev. Mr. J€mies Laptlie.
• The public prosecutor next adduced as a
witness Mr. Lapslie—
« Mr. Mtitr.— -Let this witness be removed,
1 have many objections to state against him.
Mr. Lapslie was accordingly removed.
Mr. Muir, — ^I have said that I have many
objections to state, bodi to the admissibiK^
imd credibility of this witness. My delicacy,
with regard to that man, will at present per-
mit me to adduce the least weighty only ; lor I
mean to prove the most important, in a difier-
«nt shape, in a cnminal prosecution against
him, when he and I shall exchange places
at this bar. I know not what title this re*-
verend gentleman has to act as an agent for
the Crown; but this I olfer to prove, that he
assisted the messengers of the law in explor-
ing and citing witnesses a^inst mef that he
attended the sheriffs in their di£fereot visits to
the parishes of Campsie and Kirkintilloch ;
that, previously to the precognition,* he con-
^rsea ivith the witnesses of the Crown ; that
lie attended their precognition, put questions
to them, and took down notes ; nay more,
that, ivtUiout being cited by the prosecutor,
be efiered himself ultroneously against me^
andinsbted that his declaration should be
taken in the unusual form, with his oath at-
tending it, to attest its truth. Upon other
'matters I shall not dwell ; it is sufficient ibr
me to say, that*thb witness attended the pre-
ceoiftion of other witnesses. The tmiform
and the late decisions of your lordships have
sustained this objection— Qie witness therefbre
cannot be examined.
The Lard Aduocate said, that Mr. Muii^
objection was twofold *.— that 'he accused Mr.
I«pshe ofbeing present at precognitions taken
ixmre the sheriff; and abo of being an agent
* As to the taking precognitbns, seetiic
note to the case of Smwalifl Ferguson, ante
Vol. iO, p. Ut^
A. D. 1795. [US
in the cause, that the fennar contaiiMd a
question of importance, which he would not
tnen agllale except it wereneoeisaiy : aadre-
quested that Mr. Muk mishtfothave his
proof confined to the establiwing the agency
of the witnesses.
The Lgrd Juttice Clerk acceding to thU, t^
proof of the objection, Mr. Muir odied
Henry TruUmd.
Depones, That he knows Mr. Honeymaa
(sheriffof Lanarkshire) and saw him atKirkin*
tiboch, in company with Mr. Lapslie and ano-
ther gendeanii a writer in Glasgow. Mr. Ho^
neyman examined the witness aM>ut Mr. Muir ;
and, during the preoogDition, Mr. Lapdie alsa
put questions to the witness. He asked hiaa
if he had got a college edacalloB, which be«
ing answered in the negative, Mr . Lapslie ssid
he was a clever fellow, and when he saw hint
write, he said it was apiiy such a dever feHow
should be a weaver, and that it was in Mr*
Honeywood's power to prooare him a birth»
which was said in presence of Mr. Honevoui*
That when Mr^ Honeyman euKtaoA htm
abottt how %}htxk Mr. Muir had been at Kirki»-
tilloGh meetla«, Mr. Lapslie also asked him if
Mr. Muir had been more than once there^
That on the above occasion, when Mr. lapslio
ptaised the wilnesaes's abilities, tlie witnesa
answered, that it was tattery, when Mr.
Lapslie clapped him on the shoulder and said,
it was no such thing, but that it was preba*.
ble Mr. Honeyman would aae him agam.
Mr. Muirtmn caUed
Hobtrt Henryy
Who deponed That he was examined by Mr.
Honeyman about Mr. Muir, that Mr. Lapslie
was present all the time he was so examined ;
but ad^ed no questions.
The Lord Jio^u Ckrk here reminded Mr.
Muir thai he should confine himself to the
question of agency.
Mr. Muir replied, that he concaved that if
he would brinff forward a string of witnesses,
at thetakingot all of whose precosnttions Mr.
Lapshe was present and more or less active^
that that tended in the most effectual mannejr
to estaUish the point of agency. Ue \heik
caUed
Jlobert M'Xinleyy
Whodepciied, That he was examined at
Campsie oy Mr. Honeyman, in presence
of Mr. Laps^ and Mr. Shields. Mr. Laps-
Ue spoke to the witness before the exa-
mination, suDd told him to speak the whole
truth, and frequently exhorted him, during
the examination to tell every thing as it con-
cerned Mr. Muir and not him the witness.
Mr. Mtur proceeded to call James M^b«
bon,wfaen m lord advocite gftve up Mr.
Ijtpslie'sevidenee ; oonsequentily there no lon-
ger remaned any neoessitv to examine tnore
wKnesses %riUi regiid to theconluct of that
genttcuan*
US]
33 GEORGE UL
ProceeeUngt agahf^ Tkomas Muir
L144
The Lard JdoBcate said, thai he gave up
Mr. Lapfilie as a witness, not on the gTbiind
of his being present at the precognitions, but
because he appeared, if not an agent, at least
to have taken too active a part in the busi-
ness ; reservingto himself, however the power
of taking the opinion of the court upon the
former point at another opportunity.
The evidence for the Crown then pro-
ceeded.
Henry Freeland.
When this witness appeared, Mr. Muir ob-
served, that the jury would remember, that
fiom what this witness had already deponed,
it would am>ear that he had got the promise
of a good deed. .
Then the witpess being examined, de(>ones,
That he was present at a meeting in Kirkin-
tilloch, which was called a society for reform,
on the third of November last He was pre-
ttdent that night and sat in the chair. Mr.
Muir was there and made a speech of about a
Suarter of an hour. The general purport of
lie speech was about shortening the duration
of parliament, and a more eqiul representa-
tion. He thought the taxes might be lessen-
ed by these means. That the reform was not
to anect the King and House of Lords, but
only the Commons. He mentioned the suc-
cess of the French arms, and that liberty
would be established in France ; but witness did
not understand that there was any comparison
between the government of France and tlus
country.' He spoke of books in general, but
he does not recollect the name of anv being
mentioned but Henry's history of England } it
was political books in general. The books
this witness remembers to have seen, are the
proceedings of the Westminster Association,
the Patriot, and Paislev Declaration. He de-
poned that Mr. Muir had sent for him to the
house of Mr. Wallace innkeeper in Kirkintil-
loch, that Paine*s book was mentioned by Ro-
bert Boyd, and Mr. Muir said it was foreign to
their purpose. The witness likewise deponed,
that when he was sent for by Mr. Muir, he
said, that he had heard of a society for re-
form being formed at Kirkintilloch, and that
he was. concerned in other societies, and
wished to talk to him about it; the wijtness
had never seen Mr. Muir before; and^ afler
some conversation, he asked Mr. Muir if ever
he had. read Paine's book, and what he
thought of it, Mr. Muirsud, that it had ra-
ther a tendency to mislead weak minds, the
witness said he wished to see it, Mr. Muir
told him, that it was in his great coat pocket,
which was lying on a chair m the room ; the
deponent then took the book out of the great
coat pocket; he was surprised that Mr. Muir
did not recommend it to him because every
body ebc spoke well of it, and was surprised
that Mr. Muir said it had a bad tendency.
The witness said to Mr. Muir that he believed
that the Kioft't proclamation was directed
against Mr. Pane's book, and Mr. j^uir agreed
that it was the general opinka. Thatthewtt>
ness took the said book home and read it ; that
he also ^ve it to others to read, viz. to John
Scott, wnght, and John Stewart, cooper, mem-
ber of the society, who was angry that it was
given to Scott before him„, because he wanted
to read it first.
The witness also depones, that the Paisley
Declaration was not mentioned at this meet-
ing, but that he had afterwards written a lei*
ter to Mr. Muir, informing him that the books
which were in circulation gave great satlsfac-
tion. The Paisley declaration was then in
circulation.
The reason of the deponent's writing to
Mr. Muir, was, to get his opinion, on the case
of a newspaper, addressed to the witness,
which had been sent by the postmaster of
Kirkintilloch, to Mr. Grey, a justice of the
peace, and inqumng whether it would be pro-
per to prosecute the postmaster and the iustice
of peace, and the circulation of the books waa
only mentioned in the postcript, after having
stated the case.
The deponent received two letters ^om Mr.
Muir, neither of which took any notice of the
circulation of the books. In the second letter,
Mr. Muir said, that a convention of delegates
of the Friends of the People, was to be held
soon in Edinburgh, and he hoped to see him
there. The witness never purchased the
Paisley Declaration : copies of it were pur-
chased for the socie^. It was mentioned
at difiTcrent meetings as published, and it was
thought proper to purchase some for the so-
ciety. The copy ot Paine^s Works produced iii
court was indentified by the witness to be the
book which he took out of Mr. Muir's coat
pocket. When he took the book, the leaves
were not cut open. The witness added a^n
that he mentioned the oook first to Mr. Muir.
That William Muir was present when the book
was taken, and the witness believed tliat the
reason Mr. Muir sent for him to Wallace's
might be, bec^uise he was a distant relation.
when cross-examined by Mr. Muir, the
witness deponed. That he had a conversation
about forming a reform society before he saw
Mr. Muir. That Wallace, the keeper of the
public house in which the meeting took place
was an old servant of Mr. Muir's father, and
Kirkintilloch is within four miles of Hunters-
hill, his father's house. That Mr. Muir re-
commended no particular book, except Henrv*s
History of England : but that he recommenocd
reading political books in general. That he
cautioned them to be careful that they ad-
mitted none but persons of good moral cha^
racterinto their society — advised them to fol-
low none but legal and constitutional mea-
sures, and said, mobs would ruin their cause ;
that Paine^s book was foreign to their pur-
pose; that there was no wa^ of obtaining a
reform but by petitioning parliament. When
asked by Mr. Muir — why were you so desirous
to see Paine*s book,— he answered — because
I wa5 infgfmed that the king's proclamutioii
145]
for Sedition.
A. D. 1793.
[I4ff
was directed against it, and I was curious to
see a book that was so much spoken cf.
[About this time Mr. Wy Me, advocate, who
was sitting at the clerks table, handed a
note to Mr. Muir ; upon which, Mr. Muir
requested that he snould be inclosed as
an exculpatory evidence. Mr. Wylde,
after having retired for a few minutes, re-
turned, and pointed out something in the
note which Mr. Muir had not observed.
Upon which Mr. Muir began to apolo-
gize for what had happened, which was
owin^ to a part of the note having escap-
ed his observi^tion. But he was inter-
rupted by the Court, and told that he was
not in a place for making apologies ; then
Mr. Wylde rose, and in a most candid
and manly manner, stated, that the note
he had given to Mr. Muir was simply
mentioning, that a similar requisition was
made to him, and he would have lent
Paine's book if he had had it in his pos-
session.]
William Muir,
When tlie oath was proposed to be admi-
nistered to this witness, he refused to swear,
as being contrary to his religious principles,
being asked what these principles were, he
declared he was one of tnose, who are called
the mountain* : That he had no objection to
he examined ; that he would tell the whole
truth, but could not wron^ his own conscience
by taking an oath, which he thought un-
lawful.
The Court observed to him, that if he would
not swear, no other alternative remained to
them but to commit him to prison ; that there
was no way by which he could ever obtain his
liberation, and that his imprisonment would
be perpetual. He replied, that he could not
belp it, and that he knew the Lord was pre-
sent in prison as well as any where else.
The judges asked him, if he believed in the
Bible ; to which he answered he did. He was
then interrogated, if he could point out any
pulicular passage which tai^ht him the un-
lawfiilness of taking an oath. In order to
remove his scruples they quoted several passa-
ges fixim the Bible, but he still adhered to his
first declaration, saying, that he could not take
the oath without deserting his principles, which
he was determined never to do.
The Lord Advocate moved, that this person
should be committed to prison for his contu-
macy, informed him there was no way by
which he could ever be set free, and in express
wonls declared, that his imprisonment would
be eternal.
- Mr. Muir, — I believe this person to be a
* A relieious sect commonly known by the
name of the Cameronians, descended from
the Covenanters in the reign of Charles 2.
Qrig.Edit. as to the Cameronians see the notes
in Vol. 10, pp. 849| 865 and Vol. 11, p. 949 of
this Collection.
VOL. XXIIL
^ood and conscientious man. Whether he be
right or wrong in refusing to take this oath,
is not an object of my inquiry. He is adduced
as a witness by the prosecutor against me.
I have therefore the most material interest
that he should be sworn, but rather than he
should suffer for acting according to the dic-
tates of his conscience, I wave my right, and
I will admit every word which he utters,
although not upon oath, to be as true as if it
were.
The Court observed, that neither they nor
the jury could listen to any evidence but what
was given upon oath. The law expressly re-
quired it, and it could not be dispensed with,
and that the prosecutor and public justice
were concerned in this matter also.
William Muir persisted in his refusal. The
Court committed him to prison, declaring,
they knew no mode by which, by the law of
Scotland, he could be liberated.
By the officers of the court he was con-
ducted to prison .•
John BroBon
Depones, That he was present at a meeting
in Milltoun of Campsie, about the month of
October or November last, and recollects that
Mr. Muir was present at the meeting, and that
he spoke tliere*. that he was not at the
Kirkintilloch meeting, though he had heard
of it : that the Campsie meeting was af\er
the Kirkintilloch meeting : that it was some
lads of the place and people of the neiehbour-
hood who called the meeting at Multoun :
that he does not understand these meetings
were called by Mr. Muir. He saw no books
at the meeting. He had seen Paine^s book,
but not at the meeting ; he had bought it.
The deponent was not positive that the book
was not spoken of at tne meeting ; it might
have been mentioned, but he does not re-
member it. The purport of Mr. Muir's
speech was, recommending sood morals and
constitutional measures. He does not re-
member at what time he bought Paine's book,
nor whether it was before or af\er the meet-
ing : that he bought it at Glasgow, having
seen it accidentally in the window of a shop.,
Bein^ further interrogated as to what he had
heard Mr. Muir say ? Depones, that he re-
commended sobriety, morality, and every
good and constitutional book ; that there were
some things in Paine which would hardly do, '
and which were not constitutional. There
was no mention made of France, nor of the
French constitution. The witness had read a
small part of the Political Progress. \
Anne Fi$her
Depones, That she was some time servant
to Mr. Muir's father ; she knows, about the
m^^^^mm0m
* See Bingle^'s case upon a commitment
by attachment for a contempt in refusing to
answer interrogatories, cited in the case of
Benjamin Flower, A. D. 1799, post.
L
)47] S3 GEORGE, lU.
Proceedings agtuust Tiomas Muir
ri48
lime tibelled, Mr. Muir was much busied
about reading and writiDg, but does not know
the subject : that she was sent to Mr. Men-
nons'y printer in Glasjgow, with a message
from Mr. Muir, and with a paper, which she
thinks was intituled, " A Declaration of
Rights,'^ which had not been printed as he
wanted, to get it corrected. She saw at tliat
time, a good many country people coming
about Mr. Muir*s father's shop : that Mr.
Muir has frequently said to these country
people, that Mr. Paine's Rights of Man was a
Yery good book: tliat she has frequently
bought this book for people in the shop, and
that this was sometimes at the desire of Mr.
iHuxTt and sometimes at that of these people.
She bought both the First and Second Part of
Paine, at different times, and when she re-
turned with them, she sometimes laid them
on the table, and sometimes gave them to the
people ; that she bought two different parts
at different times, for Alexander Muir, Mr.
Muir*s uncle : that she was sent for a copy by
Mr. John Muir, hatter, but is not sure
whether or not she got it : that John Muir was
much pressed upon by the panel to purchase
the book : that she bought the book at Brash
and Rcid's : that, to the best of her remem-
l^rance^ she bought one for pne Barclay, a
"veaver, from the parish of Calder : that she
knows Mr. Muu'^s hair-dresser, Thomas
Wilson, and she has heard Mr. Muir advising
him to buy Paine's Rights of Man, and to
keep tkem in his shop to enlighten the people,
as it confuted Mr. Burke entirely^ and that a
barber's shop was a sood place for reading in ;
that she herself reaa Paine's Rights of Man,
as she was curious to see what was in it : that
the copy she read bdonged to Mr. Muir's
servant : that she has seen several copies of
the book, one in writing paper with raine's
head, and seve^ in coarse paper, that she
had seen Flower on the French Constitution,
lihat she has also seen the Declaration of
Rights in Mr. Muir's room, and in the dining
room; and also the Dialogue betwixt the
Governors and the Governeo, which she has
beard him read to hb mother, sister, and
others, hut does not know any other persons
who were present ; and that this was in the
shop. That Mr. Muir said it was very clever,
and written by one Volney, one of the first
wits in France : tliat she cannot recollect any
of the persons present : that she does not re-
member to have seen the Patriot: that she
thinks she has heard part of the Paislev De*
claration read by Mr. Muir in the said back
shop, in presence of somebody, that being the
common place where he read these books*,
that she has been sent from the back shop
tipstairs for loose copies of Paii^'s Rights of
Man, but does not know how many: that
Mr. Muifs conversation was commonly on
political subjects; ac^d that he frequently
read French law books : that she recollected
bearing a conversation wherein Mr. Muir
said, that if every body liad a vote he would
t
be meroher of parliament for Calder: tliat
members of parliament would then have
thirty oi forty shillings a day, and that none
but honest men would be members of parlia-
ment, who would keep the constitution clean
from encroachments; and that they would give
new councillors to the king, such as wouldgo^
vern the nation with justice : that she has heard
it said by Mr. Muir, that France was the most
flourishing nation in the world, as they had abo-
lished tyranny and got a free government : that
she heard him say, the constitution of this coun-
try was very good, but that tnany abuses had
crept in, which required a thorough reform :
that the court of justiciary woiud need a
thorough reform too, for it was nonsense to
see the parade with which the circuit lords
came into Glasgow : that they got their
money for nothing but pronouncing sentence
of death upon poor creatures ; that this con-
versation took place about the time of the
last harvest circuit: that she remembered
about that time Mr. Muir was counsel for two
soldiers at Glasgow ; and that in conversation
afterwanis upon that subject, she heard him
say, thai he imd tlien told the judges and the
jury what they had to expect
Mr. Muir arose ; and upon his motion, the
witness was removed.
Mr. Muir then said, that the conduct of the
lord advocate was in every fespect highly re-
p»rchensible. He has put a variety of ques-
tions to witnesses, with regard to crimes of
which I am not accused. The indictment
charges me wilh making seditious speeches at
Kirkmtilloch and at Campsie, vilifying the
constitution and the king, and inflaming the
minds of the people to rebellion. It chamss
me with distribuUng seditious books ; and it
specifies, that I gave away Mr. Paine*s ^Vorks,
some numbers of the Patriot, the Dialogue
by Volney betwixt the Governors and the
Governed, the Paisley Declaration of Rights,
and of having read, in the Conventioa, the
address from the Society of United Irishmetf
in Dublin. The indictment charges nothing,
more, there is not a single letter within its four
comers which points out to me the chajcge of
speaking disrespectfiilly of courts of justice,,
tending, in any manner, to excite the people
against the administration of the law. Com-
pared to a crime of this nature, the givia^
away to single individuals, single copies of
hooks and pamphlets, which may be esteemed
seditious, is a ' trifle light as air.' If the public,
prosecutor had evidence that I was guilty of
this crime, he was deficient in his duty to the
public, in not making it an article of accusa-
tion. He should have manfiiUy, in the iiglU^
brought it forward ag^nst me, ieined a &ir
issue betwixt us, and then I would have de-
fended myself in the best Mray I could. But to
attempt to steal it in as evidence in this wav^
to prove a crime which he durst not openly
libel, because he knew it could not be sup*
ported, merits the severest reptohatinn. But
what is the tendency of this little BSii this*
140)
JhrSedm^i.
domestic aBd well'tiitDred wpy it brought to |
prove words which may irritate vour minds
agsdnst me, — ^Tes, this is the artifice, this is
its oi^ecty but jour justice will render it inef-
fectual. You will feel the same contempt
which f do.
Let us pass from that — ^I contend upon the
great principle of natund justice, upon the
coosdtutional law of this country, that no
person can be tried for a crime of which he
nas not been previously accused. What is
the purpose of an indictment, but to specify
the crimes which are to be proTed, in order
that the j»anel may have an opportunity to
prepare his defencef Why is the indictment
aerved upon him fifteen days before the trial,
but to enable him to accomplish this purpose ?
It is vain to say that under the general
charge of sedition, every thing tending to
prove it can be adduced, although not specially
mentioned. If this is now to oe adopted as
law^ what portion remains to ns of our
national liberties is for ever torn away.
Eveiy thing is insecure, an indictment will no
IcM^r be regarded but as a piece of unmean-
ing paper. The unfortunate man who re«
cerves it may say, I am charged with robbery.
I have many witnesses to prove I did not per-
petrate this crime, but #hat avails preparing
ti defence ? Not a single witness mayjj>erhaps,
be adduceil against me for that offence. I
may never bear a word of it in court, but I
ina.y be instantly called upon to defend myself
ag^!init a charge of murder, of sedition, or of
high treason. In short, if under tlie specious
pretence of being allowed to introduce what
IS not specified in the libel to support its
generality, you establish a precedent of this
Sind, you strike the fkXal blow against indivi-
dnai security, and of general safety : what
has been called the criminal law of this
country, its fonns, its precedents, and its prin-
cipIeSy are for ever gone. It is vain to say,
that the statute of James 6th, allows this pro-
cee^ng; that statute is now obsolete. By
the law of Scotland it has gone into desuetude.
It was enacted under a despotic reign, when
the freedom of Scotland was trampled under
thefoot of power. It opposes everV principle
^f justice; and will you, after the lapse of so
many yearsy descend into the mve, drag up
the p^ilential carcase, in order that it may
poison the political atmosphere? — One word
more upon the subiect: the charge against
me is sedition. That crime, from its very
mture, supposes, and, in fact, it has often
happened, that it may be attended by rapine
and by murder. If, therefore, under the
geaeraaty, yoii allow a charge of vilifying the
eonrts of justice, which I never heard of
before, you must, by the same parity of
reasonings allow a charge of plunder, equally
unheard of, to be adduced as an aggravation
af the general crime of sedition.
This question is of little importance to the
individual, who is now strutting for the
13>erties of his country. But the eves of your
children will be fixed upoalfais trial| and they
A. D. 119S. H^
trfll tremble and shudder at the precedent
I feel tor the country, — I ftel for posterity ,-;-
I will not sanction the procedure which is to
produce to both, a system of Injustice, of ruin,
and of murder.
The Tjord Advcatte said : — Mr. Muir is in-
dicted for the crime of sedition, and that
crime may consist of many facts and circum-
stances, and of these the strongest must be,
feloniously and seditiousW stirring up the
inhabitants against a lawful king and a good
constitution : that, to prove this, he was en-
titled to bring in evidence every word or ex-
pression which he held in his own family,
and every conversation with ignorant country
people, and upon that ground he was entitled
to prove the facts by every witness that can
be brought against him: that no person
could deny the relevancy of the fact, viz. the
abusing and vSi^ing the courts of justice to
be an aggravation of the crime of sedition:
it is that crime of which the panel is accused^
and he certainly would be permitted to bring
forward every thin^ which could support the
charge. If it haa been necessary to specify
in the indictment all the facts against the
panel, that indictment would have covered
as much paper as would encircle this court.
Mr. Muir. — ^l*his is not the time to enter-
tain your lordships with frothy declamation,
with sounding but unmeaning periods. I
E leaded upon just principles; every person
ere must see their strength, and must admit
their truth. — If these are given up, if these
are violated, property and hberty and life
are insecure. Once more can the lord ad-
vocate himself say, that if he were to bring
the general charee of murder against me, and
should specify that I had murdered James,
would he be allowed to prove, under the ge-
nerality, that I had murdered John? Catk
there be any thing more plain, more just, and
which requires less argument 4han the sim-
ple proposition which I support? That if
vou accuse a man of a crime, you must tell
him what that crime is, in order that he may
be able to defend himself against the accusa-
tion. Particular acts must be specified, in
order that the panel may be able to prove,
that either these acts in themselves were in-
nocent, or that he was not accessary to them.
If you destroy this proposition, if you sanc-
tion the reverse, what remains to this coun-
try, but the melancholy prospect of ruin and
of despair ?
Their lordships gave their opinions, as
follows :
Lord Swinton said, that it was the general
proposition of the libel, that the panel went
about sowing sedition, and as the courts of
justice were parts of the constitution, he was
of opinion, tnat reflecting on them, was in^
eluded in the general charge.
Lord Dunsinnan concurred with lord Swin-
ton, and declared, that every particular cir-
cumstance which may come out in evidence
need not be speeified.
Lord Abtrcromfy 8»d, there wa^ no neces*
151]
3d GEORGE III.
Proceedings agaiiui Thomas Muir
slty for ftpecifying in the libel every par-
ticular scaitious expressioa that might have
been used.
Lord Justice Clerk was clearly of opinion,
that when one crime is charged, another, and
a different one, cannot be proved under that
libel. This none could dispute. But was
that the case here.? The panel is accused of
sedition ; and will any person say, that it is
not a circumstance oi sedition for the panel
to have inflamed the minds of the people
against courts of justice, so important, and so
material a bianch of the constitution? Under
the statute of king James, wherever art and
part is lilteUed, the prosecutor can prove every
tact and circumstance, and no objection of
generality is admitted.
The ohljection was over-ruled.
The witness was called back, who de-
poned, that she had heard Mr. Muir say,
that he was for a monarchy under proper
restrictions, and a parliament that knew wnat
they were about : that a republican form of
government was the best, but that the mo-
narchy had been so long established in this
country, that it would be improper to alter it.
She also deponed, that she has been sent
l)y Mr. Muir to an organist in the streets of
Glasgow, and desired him to play ca ira,
Mr. Muir was asked, if he had any ques-
tions to put to this witness. He replied, I
disdain to put a quebtion to a witness of this
description.
The witness, on her part, asked of the
Court, if she might put a question to Mr.
Muir?
The Lord Justice Clerk said, he would not
permit it, but that Mr. Muir's expression was
very improper, and added that he had never
heard a n[iore distinct and accurate evidence
in his life.
Lord Henderland observed, that had Mr.
Muir not been standing at the bsur as a panel,
he would have ordered him to prison for the
expression.
As the witness was withdrawing, a juryman
(captain Inglis) called her back, and asked
ner, if she had had any quarrel in Mr. Muir's
father's family at parting ? to which she re-
plied, that so far from that, her mistress had
given her 5s. more than her wages, and that
miss Muir had given her a petticoat, with
some other presents.
Thomas Wilson
Depones, that the witness was in use to
dress Mr. Muir, and dressed him in the
months of August and September last: that
Mr. Muir bavins asked the witness if he had
bought Paine*^ Works; on being told that he
had not, he advised him to get a copy, as a
barber's shop was a good place to read, but
he did not press him to buy it : that the wit-
ness did not purchase a copy of Paine's
Works, but that he bought the Address to the
Addressers, and had it a day or two in his
ishop, but took it away when it began to be
called down: that he remembers one day
[152
an old oian coming into Mr. Muir's raoro,
while he was dressing him, and that Mr.
Muir said to the witness, in a laughing style,
* this is a keen reformer,' or * a great re-
* former.' That the witness recollects no-
thing farther of the conversation: that he
could not recollect the man who was present,
nor if any thing was said about Paine's Works,
or whether it was a good book or a bad book,
and never recollects of its being mentioned
upon any other occasion.
Upon being interrogated by* Mr. Muir,
depones, that he has heard Mr. Muir say,
that he would maintain the constitution :
that he wished for peace and good order,
and good morals among the peonle ; and that
he never heard him say any tning andnst
the king : that he has seen Mr. Muir's library
in the country, which is a large room not
locked, but open to all the family. '
The Jjord Advocate stated to the Court;
that he was informed that William' Muir, the
person committed to prison, was a parishioner
of the Rev. Mr. Dunn's, minister of Kirkin-
tilloch, one ^f the witnesses inclosed azainst
the panel. That if Mr. Dunn was allowed
to converse with him he might remove his
error, and preserve hira from suffering the
dreadful punishment due to his obstinacy.
He therefore moved their lordships to allow
Mr. Dunn to converse with William Muir
for the purpose.
Mr. iduir opposed the motion. — He said,
he had already consented, and would still
consent to admit the declaration of Williani
Muir against him to be true, although not
accompanied by an oath. To prevent the
witness from suffering any punishment, he
would surrender the right which the law gave
him ; but, that he certainly would object to
conversation betwixt that witness and Mr.
Dunn : not that he suspected any thing im-i
proper to take place in that conversation, but
that this was a great and important cause; a
trial Uiat might create precedents dangerous to
those who might come after. By the law of
Scotland all witnesses must be examined
apart from each other.* The law is jealous
of their conversation : The law dreads their
collusion, in framing together a consistent
story. If, in this case, you allow Mr. Dunn
and the witness, of both of whom I have no'
suspicion, to converse together, you cannot
refuse it to others. It wul be sufficient for
two witnesses, who may have an interest in
a trial, to play the same concerted game, in
order to tell the same concerted story with
more accuracy and with greater safety.
The Lord Advocate declared, that he would
depart from Mr. Dunn as a witness, and that
the conversation should proceed in the pre-
sence of an officer of the ccHirt, or of some
person on the part of Mr. Muir.
Mr. Dunn being called in, sUUed, that he.
* As to removing witnesses while others
give their testimony, see the notes ant^ Vol.
13, Pi U3, and Vol. 19, p. 390.
IBS]
fit SedUion,
A. D, 1793-
[154
cmild not promise to remove the man's scni*
pies, but thai he would endeavour to do so.
He was then sent to converse with the pri-
soner io the robing room in presence of one
of the macers ; but was ordered to confine
himself solely to the removing of his scru-
plesy and not to say any thing "on the subject
of the trial.
Mn Muir
Deponed, that he is acouainted with the
panel : that he was at his tathefs house in
Glasgow in the month of September last:
that Mr. Muir asked him if he had seen
Paine^s book ; and the witness answered that
he had not, but would be much obliged to
Mr. Muir for the loan of it : that the panel
answered that he had not the book, but that
be might buy it; upon which the girl was sent
out to buy It : and when she returned with
the book, she said she had purchased it at
Brash and Reid^s. The witness does not re-
member the price, but gave the ^irl the money
with her. Beins interrogated if he would
have read the book if this conversation had
^ot taken place ? he answered, that he would
have read it if he had seen it. And being
interrogated if be would have purchased it r
he sai<^ he would not, if he could have bor-
rowed it. When cross-examined, he de-
poned, that he never heard Mr. Muir speak
about the oonstitution.
John Barclay*
Deponed, That he is acquainted with Mr.*
muir : that he bad a conversation with Mr.
Muir about Paine*s book *. that he asked Mr.
Muir what book it was, when he answered,
that he might buy it, if he chose, as it was
printed; but afterwards said it was not a book
tor us, that he bought it for himself.
Upon Mr. Muir's interrogation deponed,
That he is an elder of the parish of (Jalder,
and that he voted on the same side with Mr.
Muir in the election of a minister ; that, iu
conseauence of this, he was frequently with
Mr. Muir; and, in his hbrary, from which
he borrowed some books ; that he had many
conversations with Mr. Muir, and heard him
say, that this constitution was an excellent
oDCy and the best in the world; that he has
heard him praise the kine, and always heard
him speak of order, regularity, and obedience
to the ruling powers ; that he called upon
Mr. Muir since he came to Scotland, who
sent ik>wn a message that he could not see
hiniy'^ he.|i((|gjd have no correspondence
whh any wHo ifiight be cited against him
as witnesses on this trial, until it was
finished.
Jmnes, Campbell
• Deponed, That he was present at the
jneetiog of delegates from tne Societies of
* On taking the oath, Barclav qualified it,
by saying he would tell the truth as far as he
£ould re«»llect Orig, Edit,.
Friends of the People, in December last, in
Lawrie's room at Edinburgh ; that he called
there on his way home from the parliament
house; that Mr. Muir was not there, but
came in soon after, and read a paper, which,
being shown to him, he admitted to be the same
with the Address from the Society of United
Irishmen of Dubl'm ;• that colonel Dalrymple
I.- ■■■■■■ t I I ■.*
* The following is a copy of the Address :
'* Address from the Society of United Irishmen
in Dublin, to the Delegates for promoting
a Beform in Scotland. William Drennan,
chairman. Archibald Hamilton Rowan, sec.
" We take the liberty of addressing you,
in the spirit of civic union, in the fellowship
of a just and a common cause. We greatly re •
joice that the spirit of freedom moves over
the surface of Scotland, that light seems to
break from the chaos of her internal govern-
ment ; and that a country so respectable for
her attainments in science, in arts and in
arms ; for men of literary eminence ; for the
intelligence and morali^ of her people, now
acts from a conviction of the union between,
virtue, letters, and liberty ; and, now rises to
distinction, not hy a calm, contented, secret
wish for a reform in parliament, but by openly,
actively, and urgently willing it witn the
unity and energy of an embodied nation. We
rejoice that you do not consider yourselves
as merged and melted down into another
country, but that in this great national ques-
tion, you are still — Scotland,— the land where
Buchanan wrote, and Fletcher spoke^ and
Wallace fought.
" Away from us and from our children
those puerile antipathies so unworthy of the
manhood of nations, which insulate indivi-
duals as well as countries, and drive the ci-
tizen back to the savage. We esteem and we
respect you. We pay merited honour to a
nation in general well educated and well in-
formed, because we know that the ignorance
of the people is the cause and effect of all
civil ana religious despotism. We honour a
nation ree|iilar in their lives, and strict in their
manners, because we conceive private morality
to be the only secure foundation of public
policy. We honour a nation eminent for men .
of genius, and we trust that they will now exert '
themselves not so much in perusingand penning
the histories of other countries, as in making
their own a subject for the historian May we
venture to observe to them, that mankind nave
been too retrospective, canonized antiquity,
and undervalued themselves. Man has reposed '
on ruins, and rested his head on some frag-;
ments of the temple of liberty, or at most
amused himself in paving the measurement
of the edifice, and nicely limiting its propor-
tions ; not reflecting that this temple is truly
catholic, the ample earth its area, and the
arch of heaven its dome.
" We will lay open to you our hearts^ Our
cause is your cause — If there is to be a strug- '
155]
33 GEORQE ItL
Proceedings agaimi Thomas Mtdr
[156
and others apposed the paper being read, and
talked of takine a protest ; that, afler Mr. Muir
read it, he saianothisg more ; but, before he
read it, he spoke %>( answering it ; but, in this,
there was no vote taken: that he does not
gle between iis, let it be which nation shall
c foremost in the race of mind : let this be
the noble animosity kindled between us, who
shall first attain that free constitution from
which both are cqui-distant, who shall first
be the saviour of the empire.
*• The sense of both countries with respect
to the intolerable abuses of the constitution
has been clearly manifested, and proves, that
our political situations are not dissimilar;
that our rights and wrongs are the same.
Out of 32 counties in Ire&nd, 29 petitioned
for a reform in parliament, and out of 56 of
the royal burghs in Scotland, 50 petitioned
for a reform in their internal structure and
government. If we be rightly informed,
Siere is no such thine as popular election in
Scotland. The people who ought to possess
that weight in the popular scale, which mi^ht
bind them to the soil, and make them chng
to the constitution, are now as dust in the
balance, blown abroad by the least impulse,
and scattered through other countries, merely
because tliey hang so loosely to their own.
They have no share in the national firm, and
are aggrieved not only by irregular and il-
legal exaction of taxes : by misrule and mis-
management of corporations ; by misconduct
of self-elected and irresponsible magistrates ;
by waste of public property ; and by want of
competent judicatures ; but, in our opinion,
most of all, by an inadequate parliamentary
representation — for, we assert, that 45 com-
moners, and 16 peers, are a pitiful represen-
tation for two millions and a half of people ;
particularly as your commoners consider
themselves, not as the representatives of that
people, but of the councils of the burghs by
whom they are elected.
" Exclusive charters in favour of boroughs
monopolize the general rights of the people,
and that act must be absura which precludes
all other towns from the power of being re-
stored to their ancient freedom.
" We remember that heritable jurisdictions
and feudal privileges, though expressly re-
served by the act of union (20th art.) were set
aside by act of parliament in 1746; and we
think that there is much stronger ground at
present, for restoring to the mass of the peo-
ple their alienated rights, and to the consti-
tution its spirit and its integrity.
Look now, we pray you. upon Ireland.
Long was this unfortunate island the prey of
prejudiced factions and ferocious parties. The
rights or rather duties of conquest were dread-
fullv abused, and the Catholic religion was
made the perpetual pretext for subjecting the
state by annihilating the citizen, and destroy-
ing not the religious persuasion, but the man;
not popery, but the people. It was not till
know how the paper came, and thai a copy
was afterwards sent him in a blank cover.
Being interrogated whether the purport of
Mr. Muir^s speeches approved or not of this
paper, says, he knows nothing more than
very lately, that the part of the nation, which
is truly colonial, reflected that though their
ancestors had been victorious, they them-
selves were now included in the general sub-
jection; subduing onlv to be sm>ducd, and
trampled upon by Britain as a servile depen-
dency. When therefore the Protestants
began to suffer what the Catholics had suf-
fered and were suffering ; when from serving
as the instruments the^ were made them-
selves the objects of foreign domination, then
they became conscious they had a country ;
and then they felt— an Ireland. — ^Thev re-
sisted British dominion, renounced colonial
sabservience, and following the example of a
Catholic parliament just a century before,
they asserted the exclusive jurisdiction and
legislative competency of this island. A
suclden light from America shone through
our prison. Our volunteers arose. The
chains fi»ll from our hands. We followed
Grattan, the angel of our deliverance, and in
1782 Ireland ceased to be a province, and be-
came a nation. But, with reason, should we
despise and renounce this revolution, as
merely a transient burst through a bad habit;
the sudden grasp of necessity in despair,
from tyranny in distress, did we not believe
that toe revolution is still in train ; that it is
less the single and shining act of 82, than a
series of national improvements which that
act ushers in and announces ; that it is only
the herald of liberty and glory, of Catholic
emancipation, as well as Protestant iudepen*
dence; that, in short, this revolution indi-
cates new principles, foreruns new practices,
and lays a foundation for advancing the v^hole
people higher in the scale of being, and diffusa
ing e<)ual and permanent happiness.
British supremacy changed its aspect, but
its essence remained the same. First it was
force, and on the event of the late revolution
it became influence : direct hostility shifted
into systematic corruption, silently drawing
off the virtue and vigour of the island, with-
out shock or explosion ; — corruption, tliat
glides into every place, tempts every person,
taints every principle, infects the political
mind through all its relations and dependen-
cies ; so regardless of public character as to
set the highest honours to sale, and to ptir*
chase boroughs with the price of such prosti-
tution ; so re^rdless of public morality, as to
legalize the licentiousness of the lowest and
most pernicious gambling, and to extract a
calamitous revenue from the infatoation and
intoxication of the people.
'' The Protestants ot Ireland were now sen-
sible that nothine coukl counteract this plan
of debilitating policy, but a radical reform ki
the house of Uie people, and that without such
V
157]
Jot Sedition.
tiiat he proposed its bein^^ read and answered.
Depones, Tnat it was assigned as a reason for
not receiving the address, that they had no
oonoexion with it; that Mr. Muir thought
there was no impropriety in receiving and an-
swering it, and would tale the bortben on his
own shoulders.
ifform the revohition itself was nominal and
delusive. — The wheel merely turned round,
hut it did not move forward, and they were
as distant as ever from the goal. They re-
solved— They convened — They met with arms
— ^They met without them — ^I'hey petitioned.
But aU in vain— for they were but a portion
of the people. They then looked around and
beheld their Catholic countrytnen. Three
millions — we repeat it — three millions taxed
without betn^ represented, bound by laws to
which they had not given consent, and po-
litically lead in their native land. The apathy
of the Catholic mind changed into sympathy,
and that begot an energy of sentiment and
action. They had eyes, and they read. They
had ears, and they listened. They had hearts,
and they felt. They said — * Give us our
* rights as you value your own. Give us a
' aluaeof uvil and poUtical liberty, the elective
' fisachise and the trial by jury. Treat us as
* men, and we shall treat you as brothers. Is
' taxation without representation a ^evance
* to three millions across the Atlantic, and no
' grievance to three millions at your doors ? —
* Throw down that pale of persecution, which
' still keeps up civil war in Ireland, and make
* us one people. We shall then stand, sup-
' porting and supported, in the assertion of that
' liberty which is due to all, and which all
' should unite to attain.*
** It was just — and immediately a principle of
adhesion took phice ibr the first time among
the inhabitants of Ireland — All religious per-
suasions found in a political union tneir
common duty ,and their common salvation.
Ib this society and its affiliated societies, the
Catholic and the presbyterian are at this in-
fllant holding out their hands and opening
their hearts to each other, agreeing in prin-
ciples, concurring in practice. We unite for
immediate, ample, and substantial justice to
tho Catholics, and when that is attained, a
combined exertion for a reform in parliament
is the condition of our compact^ and the seal
of our communion.
*• British supremacy takes alarm. The
haughty monopolists of national power and
common right, who crouch abroad to domi-
neer at home, now look with more surprise
sad less contempt on this ' besotted' people.
A new artifice is adopted, and that restless
domhiation which, at first, ruled as open war.
by the length of the sword ; then, as covert
coiTuptk>n, by the strength of the poison;
now assumes the style and title of Protestant
Ascendancy ; calls down the name uf religion
from heaven to sow disconl on earth ; to rule
by anarchy, to keep up distrust and aatipatJhy
A. D. 1793.
Jamei Denkolm
[I5S
Deponed,That he was present at a meeting of
the convention in December; that Mr. Muir,
was there and he heard him read that paper cal«
led the Irish address ; that objections were made
to its being read, and Mr. Muir answered,
among parties, among persuasions, aniongfii«
milies, nay, to make the passions of the in-
dividuals struggle like Cain and Abel, in the
very home of toe heart, and to convert every
little paltry necessity that accident, indolence,
or extravagance bring upon a man, into a
pander for the purchase of hb honesty and
the murder of his reputation.
** We will not be the dupes of such ignoble
artifices. We see this scheme of strengthen-
ing political persecution and state inquisition,
by a fresh infusion of religious fanaticism ;
but we will unite and we wUl be free. Uni^
versal emancipation with representative le-
gislature is the polar principle which guides
our society and shall guide it through sdl the
tumult of factions and fluctuations of parties.
It is not upon a coalition of opposition with
ministry tnat we depend, but upon a coali-
tion of Irishmen with Irishmen, and in that
coalition alone we find an object worthy of
reform, and at the same time the strength
and sinew both to attain and secure it. It is
not upon external circumstances, upon the
pledge of man or minister, we depend, but
upon the internal energy of the Irish nation^
We will not buy or borrow liberty firom Ame-
rica or from France, but manufacture it our*
selves, and work it up with those materials
that the hearts of Irisnmen fiirnish them with
at home. We do not worship the British, far
less the Irish constitution, as sent down from
heaven, but we consider it as human work-
manship, which man has made, and man can
mend. An unalterable constitution, what-
ever be its nature, must be despotism. Tt is
not the constitution but the people which
ought to be inviolable, and it is time to re-
cognize and renovate the rights of the Eng-
lish, the Scotch, and the Irish nations.---
Rignts which can neither be bought or sold,
granted by charter, or forestallea by mono-
poly, but which nature dictates as the birth*
right of all, and which it is the business of a
constitution to define, to enforce, and to es-
tablish. If government has a sincere rcganl
for the safety of the constitution, let them
coincide with the people in the speedy reform
of its abuses, and not by an obstinate adher-
ence to them, drive that people into republi-
canism.
" VVe hav^ told you what our situation was,
what it is, what it ought to be : our end, a
national legislature ; our means, an union of
the whole people. Let this union extend
throughout the empire. I^et all unite for all,
or eacn man suffer for all. In each country
let the people assemble, in peaceful and con-
stitutiooal conventiou. Let delegates fium
139] S3 GEORGE IH- Proceedings agdimi Thomas Muir [160
that he saw no harm in it. Co)oncl Dalrymple i* sent to the Irish address: that Mr. Muir
protested, and ?ie believes, Mr. Bell did so t never advised any deviation from the consti-
also ; but he does not remember Mr. Morth- , tution : that he never h^rd him advise the
land being thore : that he thought it possible ; people to sedition, tumult, or riot : and never
it might be illegal : tjiat he saw it on the ta^ | heard him make any speeches that had that
i
ble, but does ; not knuw whether Mr. Muir
brought it or not : that he understood that Mr.
Muir moved that an answer should be sent
that this was dissented to, but he does not
recollect for what reason, and he thinks that
it was carried, that no answer should be sent.
The address being shown to him, he admitted
i( to be the same which he had formerly
agned.
being interrogated by Mr. Muir; deponed,
that he was in the convention all the days
that it met : that he never heard him say any
thing unconstitutional : that the purpose of
the association was to get a reform in parlia-
ment : that he knows of no other object, but
that he understood their object was an altera-
tion, and that he was not a member of the
convention.
Robert Forsyth
Deponed, That he was present at a meetins
of the convention, that Mr. Muir was tliere and
read a printed paper addressed to him : that
there were some oojections made to the read-
ing of it : that the witness himself made one
which was, That it was nut expedient to have
an^ connexion with others: that it was a paper
which we ought not to have any thing to do
with ; that it was a paper containing some ex-
ceptionable passages such as, '' an mviolable
constitution was a tyranny," and the witness
thought they should have nothine to do with
it ; at the same time he did not think it a se-
ditious paper, but that it contained some ex-
pressions that were too strong. That Mr.
Muir defended the paper, and proposed that
it should lie on the table and be answered.
Upon Mr. Muir's interrogatories, the wit-
ness deponed, that he remembered the con-
vention coming to a resolution of adhering
to the genuine principles of the constitution ;
that the object was to reform the elections,
and shorten the duration of parliament : that
he was not present when a resolution was en-
tered into aoout sedition, and for expunging
such members as behaved riotously : that Mr.
Muir proposed a suitable answer should be
each countiT digest a plan of reform, best
adapted to the situation and circumstances of
their respective nations, and let the legisla-
tures be petitioned at once by the urgent and
unanimous voice of England, Scotuuid, and
Ireland:
" You have our ideas. Answer us, and
that quickly.— This is not a time to procrasti-
nate. Your illustrious Fletcher has said, that
the liberties of a people are not to be secured^
without ])assiDg through great difficulties;
^nd no toil or labour ought to be declined to
preserve a nation from slavery. He spoke
well ; and we add, that it is mcumbent on
every nation who adventures into a conflict
tendency.
William Muir.
The scruples of this witness having been
removed^ he was brought to the bar, and con-
sented to take the oath. Deponed, That he
was twice present in Wallace's house in Kirk*
intilloch, once before the society was formed,
and once along with Mr. Muir : that Freeland
was there, and Wallace : that at this meeting
a copy of Painc's Works was taken out of
the great coat-pocket of Mr. Muir : that he
does not know whether Mr. Muir desired
it to be taken out of his pocket : that he dde»
not remember what was said about the book :
that he is not sure that Mr. Muir spoke of the
will of the people being the sovereign will,
but that it was said that Paine saitl so ; that
he got eleven copies of the Patriot, and a copy
of the Political Progress ; that he got them
from Mr. Muir in his father's house, at Hon-
tersMll, who bade him keep them, and to show
them to a society he was in, which was a so-
cietv for the purpL of purchasing and read,
incbooks.
Being interrogated by Mr. Muir, depones^
That he does not remember (o have beard
him speak against government; that Mr,
Muir did not advise unconstitutional measures,
that he heard him speak about the go-
vernment; that he heard him tell how Old
Sarum was represented.
Mr. Muir observed, that there was one of
the witnesses for the Crown whom the lord ad-
vocate had omitted, viz-. William Ross, esq. one
of the justices of the peace for the county of
Wigton.
1 ne Lord Advocate answered, that he did
not think it necessary to summon him.
Mr. Muir was very sorry that he was not
summoned, as he had some material questions
to put to .Mr. Ross; but seeing his name ia
the list of witnesses for the Crown, he bad
not cited him in exculpation.
The Lord Advocate caused the sentence of
fugitatiou against Mr. Muir to be read as fol-
lows,
for freedom, to remember it is on the event
(however absurdly) depends the estimation of
public opinion ; honour and immortality, if
fortunate; ifotiierwise, infamy and oblivion*
Let this check the rashness that rushes unad*
visedly into the committal of national ch^
racter. or if that be already made, let the same
consideration impel us all to advance with
active not passive perseverance, with maalj
confidence and calm determination, smiling
with equal scorn at the bluster of official ar->
rogance, and the whisper of private malevo-
lence, until we have planted the flag of free-
dom on the summit, and are at once victo-
rious and securCt''
16J] M SedHtian,
SeBTEVCS of FVGITATIOV,
Februafy 35, 17?S.
The vbich day the diet of the criminal let-
ters, raised and carried on at the instance of
Robert Dundas, esq. of Amiston, his majesty's
advooate for his majesty's interest against Mr.
Thomas Muir younger of Uuntersnill, advc^-
cate, being called, and the said Mr. Thomas
Muir havmg been ofltimes called in court,
knd three times at the door of the courthouse,
he fsdled to appear.
Whereupon his majesty's advocate moTed,
that sentence of outlawry and fugitation
night be awarded against hira ; and as he un-
deratood ^at bsul had been eiven for his ap-
pearance, when apprehended by the sheriff of
the county of Edinburgh, he craved that the
penalty m the bond might be forfeited and
recoverca.
** The lord justice clerk, and lords commis-
sioners of justiciary decern and adjudge the
said Thomas Muir to be an outlaw and a fur-
tive from his majesty's laws, and ordain him
to be put to bis highneas's horn, atd all his
nofeable goods and gear to be escheat and
nibroiigbt to his majesty's use, for his con-
tempt and disobedience m not appealing this
day and place in the how of cause, to have
nnderlyeii die law for the crimes of sedition,
and others spcjcified in the said criminal let-
ten raised against him thereanent, as he who
waa Iswfiillv cited to that effect^ and oAen-
times eidka in court, and three tnnes at the
door of the court-house, and faiUug to appear
«s said is. And ordain the bond of caution;
granted Ibr the appearance of the said Mr.
Tlicinas Muir, in the sheriff<ourt books of
£dinbui^, to be ibrfeited, and the penalty
therein contained to be recovered by the clerk
of this Court, to be disposed of as the court
shall direct.
(Signed) Roar. M^Qumsv, J. F. D*
The Lord Advocate then proposed to prove
the dttlarations before the sheriff, and the pa-
pets that vfexe found upon Mr. Muir when oe-
fore the magistrate at Stranraer. In order to
save time and trouble, Mr. Muir agreed to ad-
mit them without proof, but un^er this express
condition, that none of these papers should
be used in evidence against him ot any crimi-
nality.
If these papers, said Mr. Muir, had afforded
my wei^tv uiscoveries of my guilt, the in-
dictment should have so stated. It was im-
possible that these papers could afford the
smallest presumption against me, and there-
fore there is not a single article of the indict-
ment alleging that they were of a culpable ten-
dency, it is indeed asserted in the libel, that
these papers were found upon me ; but that
they are of a felonious or a seditious tendency,
is no where set forth. In the concluding pro-
position of the indictment, in which the wnole
criminal charge is recapitojlated, these papers
aiepassed over in silence. In proof of this
fKjnit me to read the condonon.
voi..xxni.
A. Sk im*
ti6i
^M bftst^ times and plaees above men-*
tioned, the said seditious speeches and na-
rangues were uttered, the said seditious books
or pamphlets recommended lo be purchased
and perused^ the said seditious books or
pamphlets eiiculated and distributed, as afore-
said, and the said wicked and inflammatory
address produced, read, recommended, and
approved of in bianner above-mentioned ;
and ttie said Thomas Muir is guilty actor, or
art and part, of all and each, or one or other
of the aforesaid crimes* All which, or part
thereof, beins found proven, by the verdict of
an assize, b<3bre our lord justice general, lord
justice derk, and lords commissioners of justi-
ciary in a court of justieiary to be holdea by
them within the criminal court-house of Edin-
burgh, the said Thom^ Muir ought to be pu-
nished with the pains of kw, to deter others
from committing the like crimes in all time
eoming.
The Lord AdpecaU^ in reply, stated, that he
was intttied to bring forward every circum*
stance which could criminate the panel, al-
though these cireumstances were only collate-'
ral, vad not in issue or necessary in the coodu*
The clerk of court accordingly read the
following documents:—
Declaration of Mr. Muir before the Sberifl^
M Edinburghy tU ^nd cf January 179^.
The which day compeared, in jpresence of
• John Pringle, esq. advocate. Ins majesty's
sheriffdepute of the shire of £dinburg^h,
Thomas Muir, esq. advocate ; who, being
examined by the sheriff, and being intcr-
' rogated. Whether- or not the declarant, in
the month of November last, was in the
. towns of Kirkintilloch, Lennoxtown of
Campste, or Milltown of Campsie f declares.
That he declines answering any questions in
this place, as he considers a declaration of
this kiud, obtained in these circumstances,
' to be utterly inconsistent witii the con-
stitutional rights of a British subject : that
he has solemnly maintained this principle
in nleading for others in a criminal court,
ana that, when it comes to be applied to his
own mrticular case, as at nresent, he will
not aeviate from it: declares. That he
neither composed, published, nor circulated
books or pamphlets, inflammatory or sedi-
tious : that, in public and private, he always
advised, and eamestiy entreated those who
might be engaged in the prosecution of a
constitutional reform, in tne representation
of the people in the House of Commons, to
adopt measures mild but firm, moderate but
constitotional; and that be has always in-
culcated upon all whom be may have ad-
dressed upon any occasion, that there was
no other mode of'^accomplishing a constitu-
tional Ireform, in the representation of the
people in the House of Commons, but by
the mode of respectful and constitutional
163\
SS GEORGE DL
Proceedingi a^^aiM Tkanuu Muir
[164
petitioiis to that House* for that purpoee :
and that he did not doubt but the wisdom
of that House would listen to the Toioe of
the people, when thus constitatiooaUy pre-
sented : and being shown three numbers of
a paper, intituled, ** The Patriot,'' the first
dated, << Tuesday, April 17th, 1799 i" the
second dat«i, ** Tuesday, June 18th ;" and
the third, ^ Tuesday, July 10th ;" without
mention of the year ; and being interro-
gated if he gave these fKsmphlets to
William Muir, weaver in Kirkintilloch, and
eight other numbers of the same publica-
tion? declares. That he adheres to the
principles whicn he has mentioned in the
-preceaing part of tiiis declaration, and de-
clines answering the question. And beins
shown a book, mtituled, *' The Works of
Thomas Paine, escjk'' and interrogated, If
he did not give said book to Henry Free-
land, weaver in Kirkintilloch, and first
?re8es of the reform society there } declares,
'hat he adheres to his principle, and de-
clines answering the question. And being
shown a pamphlet, intituled, ** A Declara-
tion of Rights," and an ^< Address to the
People ;'' and interroeated. Whether or not
he gave the aforesaid pamphlet to the said
Henry Freeland? declares. That he de-
clines answering upon the aforesaid prhi-
ciple. And being mterrogated, Whethcv
or not he eave to the aforesaid Henry
Jreeland, a l>ook, intituled, *' Flower on
the French Constitution r declares. That
he declines answering the question upon
the aforesaid principle; and all the belore-
mentioned books are marked as relative
hereto, of this date. And being interro-
gated. Whether or not the declarant was a
member of the Convention which met in
Edinburffb, in the month of December last,
iftyling uiemselves the Convention of the
Associated Friends of the People, and nro-
duced to that meeting, a paper, intituled,
** Address from the S^^ty ot United Irish-
men in Dublin, to the Delegates for Reform
in Scotland, 9Srd November 1709," and
moved, that the thanks of the meetine
should be returned to that society, for said
address } Declares and declines answering
the ouestion, upon the aforesaid principle.
All this he declares to be truUi.
(Signed) Thomas Muir.
JoflK PaiVGLE.
Copy DiSclabation of George Williamson.
At Edinburgh, August 10, 1793.
Gebree Williamscm, messenger in Edinburgh,
declares^ That on Friday, the 2nd of August
instant, he received a warrant of the court
of justiciary^ for bringing the person of Mr.
Thomas Mwr. youQger, of Huntenhill, finonn
the prison or Stramaer, to the prison of
SdinVureh; in consequence of which he
went to Stranmen and arrived there on the
morning of SuiMaj the 4tl> instant, when
he received the person of the said Thomas
Muir ; and he also received from Mn Kerr,
one of the majgistrates of Stranraer, a parcel,
sealed, and intituled ^ Papers belon^g
and found on Mr. Thomas Muir, W. R. J. P.^
And which packet was sealed with the seal
of the burgh of StranTaef, and also with two
seals, which he noWheafs Mr. Muir declare
to be his, and* which parcel he now ex-
hibits, with (he seals entire.
And the foresai<^ parcel having been opened,
in presence of the said sheriff substitute,
Hugh Warrender, esq., Mr. William Scott,
procurator fiscal of the shire of £dinbu]]g;h,
George Williamson, messenger in Emn-
bursh, and Joseph Mack, writer, sheriff
clerk's office; and also, in presence of Mr.
Thomas Muir, who admitted, that this was
the parcel containing the articles beJonging
to him, which were sealed up by the ma-
gistrates of Stranraer, and to which he then
affixed his seals, and which he observed to
be entire, previous to its being opened in
his presence *. the same was found to
contain,
1. Ten copies of a pamphlet, intituled^
** Proceeaii»s of the Society of United
Irishmen ofDublin. DubUn, printed by
order of the Society, 1703.''
S. A printed copy of iht trial, at lam, of
Samuel Bushoy, and Judith his wite.
3. Twenty-nine copies of a printed paper,
intituled, ** Unitra Iri^men of Dublin,
7th June 1793,'' being an address from
the Catholic committee to ^eir Catholic
countrymen.
4. Five copies of another printed paper^
being, ^ Resolutions of the Societv of
United Irishmen, held on the 15th of
July."
5. Twenty-two copies of a paper, purportinjg
to be an abstract of the trial of FraiMn&
Graham, esq. one of his nuyesty's
justices of peace for the county of Dubun,
on the 9th July 1793, before the bon.
baron Power.
6. A printed copy of an act to prevent
tumultuous rismgs, &c. of the S7th Geo.
3, printed Dublin, 1787.
t. Eighty-four copies of a printed paper,
dated, "Rath Coffey, 1st July, 1793;"
containing a quotation from Milton, on
the liberty of unlicensed printing.
8. Letter, signed J. Muir^ dated '' ulasgow,
91st July 1793 ;" beginning with, 6ear
Sir, but having no acraress.
9. Letter, signed Thomas Muir, and ad-
dressed to captain George Towers, of the
American ship, the Hope, from Baftimorey
care of Messrs. Cunningham, and Co.»
merchants, Belfost, and dated Dublin,
27th July, 1793.
10. A red Turkey pocket-book, containing :
1. A passport from the department of Paris^
in mvicmr of citizen Thomas Muir, dated
Sdrd April, 1793, havioff upon the back
an indorsement, dated 5m Mm, 1793.
S. Receipt by A. M'Dougal lo Mr^ Moir^
165]
Jit Station*
A. D. 179S*
icRc MO IvmSy for bis pattnge in tiie
•calnn of the ship finom mvr&-de-Gncey
to the port of New Nork, dsited Havie-
de-Grace, Itfth Ifav, 1793.
3i Certificftte that Thomas Muir has beea
^uJjr elected one of the members of the
Society of United Irishmen of Dublin,
dated 11th Jamiaiy, 1793, signed Archi-
bald Hamilton Rowan, secretary.
4. Sealed letter, directed, '< The Rev.
Thomas Fische Palmer, Edinburgh/'
4^ Ditto, directed, << Norman M^Leod.eBq.
M. P. Scotland." ^^
€. Ditto, directed '« to Mrs. MH:onnick, at
Dr. M'Coimick's, St. Andrew's, Sout-
land."
7. Anotber passport, of the department of
Calais, in &vour of citizen Thomas Muir,
dated 15th January, 1793.
3. Passport of the Commissary of the
Section of the Thdlleries, in favour of
citizen Thomas Muir, dated 4th May,
1795.
9. Declaration of residence, dated 3d April,
1793, in &vour of Thomas Muir.
10. Letter, signed D. Stewart, dated, No.
53, Frith-street, Soho, London, Febnugry
1st.
Ist. (Addre8sed)JofaaHurford Stone, esq.;
or Thomas Muu) esq. advocate, No. 99,
Palais Royal, Pans.
11. Letter, signed James Campbell, dated
No. 10, St Andrew's-sguare, Edinburgh,
95th Januaiy 1793 : addressed to Thomas
Muir, esq. ^unser, of Huntershill.
12. Letter, signed D< Stewart, dated, 59,
Frith-street, January 80; addressed,
Thomas Muir, esq. advocate, to the care
of John Hurford Stone, esq. Paris.
^3. A Letter, signed W. Skirving, without
date, addressed to Thomas Muir, esq.
younger, of Hunterslull.
Copy Certificate.
Society of United Irishmen of Dublin : I
hereby certificate, that Thomas Muir has
been dul^f elected, and having taken the
. test, provided in the constitution, has been
admitted a member of this society.
(S^ped) Abch. Hamilton Rowan, Sec.
No. 905, Jan. 11,1793.
On the mai^ of .the original is the f gure of
a harp, with this motto, " It is new struo&
and sbflill be heard."
Which whole pieces of writings, printed
papers, and letters, were signed oy the
nmials of the sheriff^bstitute, Mr. Scott,
Geme Williamson, and Joseph Mack, of
this date; and those taken out of the
pedcet-book were again replaced in the
pocket-book; and the whole of the said
writiogs, &c. were also signed with the
initials of Mr. Muir, esceptine the three
sokd letters, which he declin^ to put his
initials to, in regi^ he did not consider
Ihem $M bos property. He fqilher required
[166
that thi sheriff^bstitute should imme-
diately transmit these three letters to the
respective persons to whom they are ad-
dressed^ as any other proceeding would be
a vk>lation of the private rights and property
of the persons to whom they bdong. Scott,
cm the .part of the public prosecutor, repre-
sented, that this last request caimot in his
opinion be complied with, seeing these
letters, with -the -other papers in the sealed
paroel, were traosmittedto this office under
warrant of the court of justiciary, for the
purpose qf being inspected.
Keceipt of .Captaih M^DovqAL, for Ma.
Muir's passage fipm Uavrerde-Grace to
New York.
Received from Mr. Mwr, the sum of nine
hundred livres, ibr his passage in the cabin
of the ship, from Havre-de- Grace to the
port of New York, in finding him with aU
stores. A.M'Doi;oAL.
Havre^e'Graee^ May 16, 1793.
PASSPORT AT PARIS.
aETUBLIQUS .TRAlfCAISE, DBPAaXEKBHT DB
PARIS.
Pastnort dUivri en execution de la loi du
7 Decembre^ 179%, Van premier de la JUpub*
lique Frangaise,
Vu Favis du Conseil general de k ComnMme
de Paris, laissez passer le citoyen Thomas
Miiir, allant a Phikdelphie, domieilie a
Paris, municipality de Paris, departement
de Paris, natir d'Ecosse, homroe de loi, ftg6
de vingt huit ans, taille de 5 pieds 3 pouce^
cheveux et sourcils chatain, yeux ^bleuz,
. nez aquilin, bouehe moyenne, menlon rond.
firontnaut, visage lone et plein, — pr6tes-lui
aide et assistance, an besom.
Fait en directoire, le 23 Avril mil sept cent
quatre vingt treise; V an deuzieme de la
ll^publique Fran9aise; et a ledit eitoyen
Muir sign^ avec nous administrateurs com*
posant le Directoire du Departement de
Paris. Approbalif.
Thomas Muir. Lbblauip,
Dubois. Nxcoleau, ffrend.
£. J. B. Maillaro.
Vu par nois Minlstres des Aflaires Estrao-
seres. A Paris, le S9 Avril V an S'me de
la Republiquo.
liE Brun.
Maillib, Garat, Grs
PASSPORT AT CAtjOS.
REPUBLIQUB FRAVCAXSB, AU HOK DB LA LOT.
D^rtement du Fat-de^^alaii, Diftrid, Jftiiti^
cipam de Calais.
Laissez passer le citoyen Thomas Muir, £cos-
sais, domicilii a Edinburgh, municipalitl de
—.« district de-^— department de~- a g^
de28ans, taille de5pieas3 pouces>chfiyeux>
167]
S3 GBORGB UL
Procudingi ugrind T%omas Muif
[I6&
sourdl^ cfaatain, yeat bleiis, net aqtniiii^
bouche moyeDne, meaton rood, firont rond»
visage loDg et plein; et pretez-hii aide
et assistance en cas de besoin, allant en
France, et due a Tetranger.
Pelivre en la Maison Conunune de Calais,
le 15 Janvier, 1793, Tan premier de la Re-
publique Fnin9aise.
Thomas Mvia.
Mavssy, Offider Muincipal,
Cellierboullie, Secretaire ef (xrtjfier
qui a iigni anec mwt le preteni.
Wben the lord advocate desired the letter
signed J. M. to be read, Mf. Muir arose and
objected to that fmd the otiier papers being
read; not that he cared for their oeing read,
but because they had nothing to do with his
trial. He was certain there was no paper
found on him which he would wish to con-
ceal; but tliere was nothing in the indictment
charging criminality on those papers.
[Here Mr. Muir read the passage in the in-
dictment, in which the papers and pocket-
book are mentioned.]
He said, not a single word of criminalitT was
surmised in the libel in the part tliat rerars to
the papers. He was therefore entitled to'con-
tenu ttiat in point of general justice, these
papers ought not to be read ; that he saw it
was vain for him to make any objection;
however strone it might be in law, it was sure
to be over-niied; but every mind tinctured
with humanity, would shrink at the wanton
disclosure of the anxiety and the grief of a
private family, for the purpose of mdulglng
an idle curiosity.
, The Lord Advocate. I wish to indulge no
idlecurbsity; but I have a right to have read
what I conceive necessary to establish my
charge; and I shall afterwards have an op«-
portunity of showing their import. All I wysh
at present is, to show that he was conscious of
his guilt: nay I go farther, his defence of
being prevented from returning, and his vo-
luntarily suirendering himself are all asser-
tions standing contradicted by these letters.--
But these circumstances are only collateial;
not in issue, nor necessary in the conclusion.
Mr. Muir. I will trifle no longer upon this
subject. I am conscious of po guilts there is
nothing in the papers which I wish to con-
ceal on my own account; I gladly join issue
with the pfbsecutor, andeotisent to these let-
ters being read.
The clerk of court the^ read tine following
letters : *
Letter -from J. Muir,- to Capt. George
Towers.
GUug(w,2iJufy,U9S.
Pear Sir ; — I am at a very gre^t loss how to
answer your letter, as it's not understood
by me; but if it's tbe friend that I have, if
it's he, I would be overjoyed to see his
hand-writing, and to know what has be-
eomc of hknU^ese three months*. I thought
he had been ail PMaddbhia er^ now, where
letters are fovwarded ror him; and if you
are to stay any time at Bellkst, be so kind as
to write in coitfse^ and I will come over and
see you and him. You can write ^e time
you mean to stay. Jllr. John Riobudson,
a son of deacon James Richardson, I saw
him this week at Greenock, where he is to
sail in the Almy of New-York directly, who
hiis two packets of letters for him; and
there is many letters wrote for him to the
first people in America. And once he were
there, he *11 get letters to general Washing*
ton; and I hope, dear sir, you'll show him
.every civility m your power, which I hope
some day gratemlly to thank yoa for it.
There is a trunk also in the Almy for him,
. which Mr. Richaidson will deliver into his
own hand. Only I sincerely wish yon a
safe, pleasant, and successful voyage, and a
happy meeting with your friends. And I
mS^n, dear ^.your^ humble lernuM,
J. Muxa.
If it 's the person I mean, a cousin of his,
William Muir, formerly of Leith, is lyinz at
Philadelphia. His ship is an American bot-
tom. The loss of this youneman has been
a dreadful aifiiction to us. Please give pur
friend this letter. I honoured his draft in
favours of Mr. Masey . He '11 get his letters
at the post-office Philadelphia.
I hope in a year or two he can return, if he
doth not love America; and be so good aa
cause him write me one line in your letter.
You can direct it; and if he doth not cAvic
to tign it, you can put to your initials.
(llie Address torn off.)
liBTTER from Thomas Muir, to C4Pt. Georgb
Towers.
DttUia, 97th Jufy, 179S.
Dear Sir;-*This ds^I received your^, and will
be down upon Tuesday evening. I have
taken my place in the coaph for t«>»mQrrow«
I am happy to hear my friends ate well. I
irill write them from Belfisist. Of this vou
can give them information. I am, dter
sir, your respectful friend,
Thomas ]!$€|R.
Capt. George Towen, of the
American tkip the Hope,
from Baltimorc-'^Care ^
Meters. Cunningham, aM
Co. merchants Selfatt,
After these papers had been read, the lord
advocate declared the proof finished on the
part of the Crown, and Mr. Muir commenced
his proof in exculpation.
PROOF IH BXeULPATIOH.
William Skinnng^
Bepones, Thitt it was thought proper that
* See his trial fbr seditkm^ IntU^ voluilie,
infri^ .. .... '
i
160]
JbrSidiiiait*
A. D, 17fl8.
[170
3ir. Muk %hoM attend a meetiiig of the
FrieDdsf^ibeP^fe in London: tfaatoothis
aoootoii he left EoinlNirgh) and went toLon-
don» in Jamiaiy last : t&t he received a letter
ftom Mr. Mior, dated fh>m London, mention-
ing that he bad appeared in the Societvat
LondoOy of which Mr. Grey [Charles, after-
wards second earl Grej] is a member, and
giving an account of what had been done
there: that owing to some late circumstances
which occurred in hb family, he cannot at
present find Mr. Muir's letter ; but that, ac-
cording to the best of his recollection, he
thinks Mr. Muir wrote him, tbett it was the
opinion of some friends, that the event irfiich
was then dreaded to happen in France, would
be of great detriment to the common cause ;
and it waa supposed that if Mr. Muir were to
ga to France, he might have some influence
with the leading people in mitigating the fkle
of the king. That wliile Mr. Muir was at
Paris, he received a letter from him, men-
tioning that he was too late to e£fect the
object of his journey and that he would
return as soon as his friends should be of
opinion his presence was necessary in Soot-
land : that he has been frequently with Mr.
Muir in private, and has oflen heard him
speak in public in the societies : that he never
heard him speak against the constitution, or
advise the people to disorder or sedition, but
that be always inculcated upon them, that
there was no other mode of obtaining the pro-
posed reform, than by applying to parliament
oy respectful petitions : and that Mr. Muir
never submitted to his consideration any plui
of government ; that the general tenour of
Mc Muir's address to the people in the so-
cieties was, to impress upon their minds the
necessity of good order, and that before they
attempted public reformation, they should
begin by reforming themselves : that he does
not believe Mr. Mair is connected with any
society, abroad or at home, for the purpose of
exciting sedition : that he never neard Mr.
Muir speak against the monarchical part of
our constitution, and that he has been in
his company in his most unguarded moments :
tl^t he remembers a onvate conversation
with Mr. Muir, in which he disapproved of
many of the pnnciples in Paine's book, and
both agreed tnat many of them were imprac-
ticable : that he was happy to find the panel
of this opinion, and he dien told the ]»nel,
that he bad put bis thoughts concerning
Paine in writing, and that he had some in-
tention of drawing theni up in the form of
kctmes, and delivering them publicly against
Bsine. Mr. Muir wasliigbly pleased with ^e
^an, and said that he would take^gh^or an
hmdred tickets from the deponent
Upon the interrogation of the lord advo-
cate, if he was not the person who had de-
s^oed himself on a late occasion, secretary
meral to the Association of the Friends of
the People ;*-«i8wered. That it waaamere
nislake mifritiBg out the petitioni for he was
secretary to tbe General Association of the
Friends of the People.
Being interrogated by Mr. Muir, if he le^
membered the tenor of the answer which he
proposed in the Convention to the Address of
the Society of United Irishmen in Dublin,
depones, Tiiat he cannot recollect. It being
observed that he was concerned with Mr. F.
Palmer in a seditious hand-bill, tbe witness
stated, that he had received a summons to
attend Mr. Palmer's trial at Perth : that if it
was intended to try him for that paper, he
supposed the trial had fallen of course ; but,
however, the witness did not intend to plead
that circumstance with a view of avoiding the
trial ; he would not flinch ^m it.^
* III the Appendix to one of the printed
accounts of this trial, the following article
was inserted : —
Letter from W. Sktrvino to D, drcwART,
esq. No. 52, Frith-street, Soho, London;
Secretary to the Society of the Friends of
the People,
Edinburgh, Sept. S, 1703.
Sir ; — ^I ought to have wrote you on Satur-
day, to give your Society the means of contra-
dicting tne aspersion, which you will see by
the accounts of Mr. Muir's trial, has been
thrown upon them. I have not been able to
command a settled thought since the alarm-
ing issue of that astonishing trial. I never
hm a higher opinion of any person's inte-
grity, u|Mrightness, and philantnropy ; nor is
It diminished, but increased. The' feelings
which I must therefore have had, since that
event, will plead my excuse with men of feeling.
In the evidence which I was called on to
sive, I stated the reason for his going to Lon-
oon, and that I had received a letter from
Mr. Muir, when at London, explainine the
cause of his proceeding to Paris ; which letter
I was verv sorry that I coidd not produce,
though I tiad preserved it carefully. Being
desired to state, if I could recollect the reason
which Mr. Muir assigned in that letter for his
journey to Paris, I said, that it was the opinioa
of friends, that if Mr. Muir would go to Paris,
he might have great influence with many to
mitigate the sentence of the French king.
These friends were taken for your society ;
and much freedom was used, to reprobate both
the Society of the Friends of the People in
London, for presuming to send a missionary
into another country, and Mr. Muir, for ac-
cepting such commission. But I declare,
upon my honour, that the thought of his
being sent by the Society of the Friends of
the People in London, never came into my
mind : and if I expressed myself so, which it
is impossible I could do, I expressed a false-
hood ; and which I am bound, in justice to the
Sodety , in this manner lo contradict.
Mr. Muir is behaving with astonishing
manliness.
I amy Ski your obedient humble servant,
W. S«avl^c.
171]
33 GEORGE ID.
Jama Campbell
Pneeec&^t agiAut Thmuu Muir
[172
Depones, That in the beginning of last win-
ter, he acted as agent for Mr. Muir: that
while the panel was in France, he received
from him two letters from Paris, and that he
had brought these letters with him ; he was
desired by the panel to read them ; unon
^hich the witness handed them to the cierk
of the court, and also another letter sub-
scribed James M^ntoshy* London, which was
first read: and the witness being interrogated
by the Court what Mr. M'Intosn it was from
whom he had received this letter, the panel
answered, that it was the author of the Ftn-
dicU GaUiae. The letters were as follows :—
Letter from Mr. Muir to Mr. Campbell^
writer to the Signet, Edinburgh.
PariSy Jan. 83, 1798.
Dear 8ir ;— I wrote you from Calais and from
Paris, and impatiently expect jrour answer.
Write me fully about mv private affairs,
but about nothing the. Whenever you and
my friends judge it expedient or proper,
I will immediately return, but I cannot
leave Paris without regret. I am honoured
by the notice and friendship of an amiable
and distingjuished circle, and to a friend of
humanity it affmds much consolation, to
find according feelings in a foreign land.
Present my best wishes to all our fiiends,
to Messrs. Johnston, Skirvine, Moffitt,
Buchanan, &c, Intreat you to find means
to send over the numbers of the two Edin-
burgh newspapers. The London papers
come here but irregularly. One wishes to
know what is ^ine on at home; but tell
nnr friends, it is omy through the channel
or newspapm I can receive that intelli-
gence. Write me under the following
cover, ^ Au Citoyen de Coudile, hotel de
Toulon, No. 1, rue des Fosses du Temple.''
Communicate this address to all my friends,
Liform them no letter can reach me, if not
part of the {lostage is paid in Edinbureh. —
I am, dear sir, yours, &c. Thomas Muir.
Jamu Campbellj £ff . Writer to the
Signet^ Edinbur^hy Scotland.
P. S. — ^My compliments to Mr. Dick ; en-
treat him to take the chai^ of my things.
Second Letter frt)m Mr. Muir to Mr Camp-
bell.
Parity Srth Jan. 179S.
Dear Sir;— -I have written you frequently,
^dienever you thmk it proper I shall return.
At the same time, honoured as I am b]^ the
civilities and attention of manv amiable
characten, it would be with rductance I
could quit Paris for a month or two. About
my vnvate business write me, but not a
word on any other subject. Remember me
* In 1803 Mr. Mackintosh was appointed
recorder, of Bombay, on which occasion he
also received the honour of knighthood.
to Johnston, Skirving, Moffiit, ice Tell
them no distance of space shall oblitecate
my recollection of them. Write me punc-
tually, I intreat you. Cwaae them likewise
write me. Oout no post.. My address is
under cover, ^ Au Citoyen Coudile, hotel
de Toulon, No. 1, rue des Fosses du
Temple.'' — I am, yours, &c.
Thomas Muir.
James Campbelly Esq. Writer to the
Signet, Edinburgh, Scotland.
Letter firom Mr. M'Intosh to Mr. Campbell*
Sir; — I have to acknowledge the receiptor
your letter respecting the business of^Mr.
Muir. I did not lose a moment in finding
a safe and speedy conveyance to him at
Paris for your letters, and those of his other
firiends in Scotland, sent to my care. I
delayed from day to day in the perpetual
expectation of seeing Mr. Muir here on his
return. It is now, however, become neces-
sary for me to inform vou, that he is not
yet come; and, considering the extreme
anxiety which he must have felt to return
as soon as possible, I think it vety probsK
ble that this delay oueht to be ascribed to
the embargo laid on the vessels in the ports
of France, which may perhaps have ren-
dered it impossible for nim, though even
at Calais, to make his passage to England.
I think tnis probability at least sufficiently
great to be pleaded for a delay of his trial,
and it is to enable you and his friends to
make any use of it that you may think fit,
that 1 have now thought it necessary to
* In two of the Reports of Mr. Muir'sTrial^
the following article is inserted : —
Letter to the Friends of the People.
[Published in the Edinbureh Gazetteer,
March 1st, 1793.]
PariSj February 13, 1793.
Upon the evening of the 8th of this month, •
I received letters from my father, and from
my acent, Mr. Campbell, mforming me that
an inoictment was preferred against me, that
my trial was fixed for Monday the llth in-
stant; the distance, and the shortness of the
time, could not permit me to reach Edinbuigh
by that d^. war is declared between Eng^
land and France, and the formalities reqiusite
to be gone through before I could procure my •
passport, would at least have consumed three
days. I will return to Scotland without de<»
lay. — To shrink firom danger would be unbe-
coming mv own character, and your confi-
dence ; I dare challenge the most minute in-
vestigation of my pubuc and private conduct.
Armed with innocencrf, I appeal to justice |.
and I disdain to supplicate favours. I have
hastened to give you an account of my inten*
tion ; and I am happy that a private gentle-
man, who leaves Paris to-morrow, afifords mo
an opportunity for the communication.
Thomas MutR«
173J
,/Sf Siddutti»
A. D. 1796.
[174
communicale ibis state of facts to you.* — ^I
am, sir, yours, &c. Jaices M'Imtosh.
Si. CharUfttt Street, P&riUmd Piaee,
Feb, 7, 1793.
Upon the panel's inteffoffatory, he de*'
pones, That he never beard him attempt to
exdle the people bf the societies to sedition
or outrage ; that he exhorted them to avoid
riotous conduct, to behave orderly, peaceably,
and, above all, to attend to the moral charac-
ters of those whom they admitted members t
that be also remembers Mr. Muir's opinion
of Mr« Paine'sbook was/that it might be dan*
gerous for people of weak minds.
Jokn Btuhanan
Depones, That he has oflen heard Mr. Muh*
speak m the societies: that he never advised
aedition, liot, insurrection, nor unconstitu*
tional measures, but, that they should act
peaceably and orderly : that he said, the con-
atitutmi ought to direct all their applications
to parliament; and, that he used to say in
oonv^sation, that the constitution ought to
be to us the polar star, and that we snould
bc|^ our reformation by first erecting amone
ourselvea the temple of morality : that he had
inoce aeese than to think of procuring a re-
dress of grievances byany other than oonsU-
tutional measures. The witness never heard
the panel recommend any pamphlets, nor
ever heard him express any opinion about
Paine; but thai he always wished the people
to infimn their minds.
Wittiam Johuton*
Depones, That he never heard Mr. Muir
faaiangue the people to excite sedition : that
he had heard him speak in several public
meetings; and though he could not conde-
scend upon particular expressions, he could
recollect the general tenor of his speeches,
which was for firmly supporting the constitu-
tion as it stood at present; and that all the
other princioles held by him grew out of thb
one; that Mr. Muir never advised tumult,
but recommended sobriety, and said, that no-
thing would do but an application to parlia-
ment by way of petition ; that it is mcon-
fiistent with his knowledge that Mr. Muir
circulated Bny books or pamphlets; that
while Mr. Muir was in France, he received
from him one or two letters upon general sub-
jects, but that he remembers Mr. Muir ex-
pressed in them his intention of returning
soon to this country : that he had soueht for
these letters^ but could not lay his hand upon
them.
Maurice Thornton
Depones, That he once heard Mr. Muir in
a sooetv of the Friends of the People deliver
a apcecn, but does not remember much of it;
that he heard him speak about reform, mea-
* See the proceedings against him before
the Court of Justiciaiy; for a Cootempt^ p. 4S
of this volume.
sures which were constitutional, and the ne-
cessity of bemg moderate, and never heard
him advise the people to excite disturbances.
Charles Sailer
Depones, That he was present three or four
times in societies with Mr. Muir: that he
aiways heard him telling the people to follow
constitutional measures : and that if ever they
did any thing unconstitutional, he would be
the first man to oppose them.
Peter Wood
Depones, That he has heard the panel
speak in societies : that the ceneral tendency
of his addr»»es to the Friends of the People,
was exhorting them to support the constitu-
tion and to petitition parliament: that he
never heard him speak against the King or
House of Lords : that he never saw him dis-
tribute any books or pamphlets ; and that he
heard him say, no members should be ad-
mitted into the societies who were inclined
to faction.
David DaUpjun.
Depones, That he has seen Mr. Muir at
the Star Inn at Glasgow, in meetings of the
Friends of the People : that he remembers a
motion was made, that political books should
be recommended to the socie^: that this
motion was opposed by Mr. Muir, who argu-
ed, that most books were written too much
in tbe spirit of party : that no truth could be
got from them, and that the only way to pro-
cure knowle^ was by general reading: that
he advised the people to inform themselves
on both sides or the question ; — to seek re*
forml^ measures calm and constitutional:
and that they had no other mode of obtaining
it than by petitioning parliament; that he
never heara him say any thing which had a
tendency to excite sedition: and that he
always advised the people to be quiet and or-
derly : that he never knew of his distributing
books, or recommending Paine's Works : and
that he advised the Fnends of the People to
expel any member who might behave sedi-
tiously or disorderly : and said he would ab-
sent himself if unconstitutional measures
were adopted.
Mr. Muir asked bim^ if ever he heard him
speak against the constitution ?
Witneu, Will you be pleased, Mr. Muir,
to explain what you mean by the constitution,
and then I shall be able to answer the ques-
tion?
Mr. Muir, Did you ever hear roe say any
thing against the King, Lords^ and Com-
mons ?
Witneu. I never did.
Being interrogated by the lord advocate,
Depones, That it was at a meeting of the
Friends of the People, at the Star Inn, that
he heard Mr. Muir oppose the recommending
of particular books: that he does not recol-
lect Uie particular month when thb occurred.
175] 8S GEORGE HI.
Proceedings ^aimt Thomas Muir
[176
Being interrogated, if be recollects when
Mr. Muu- was first apprehended, depones, he
could not precisely. Being asked, if he
thought it was in tlie month of January, or
in any of the succeeding months ; depones
he could not be positive nut thinks he might
have heard it about live months ago.
Lord Adoocete, You have a very short
memory Mr. Dale.
Wiinsss, I have a very short memory, my
lord.
William Bidden
Depones, That he has been present at se-
veral meetings at Glaseow with Mr. Muir :
that he never heard nim recommend anv
hooks or pamphlets : that he heard him ad-
vise the people to peace and good order, and
not to admit inunoral clnracters among
them: that the meetings were frequently
numerous, but the witness never saw any
^foorder in them.
William Reid
Depones, That he is a 'bookseller in Glas-
gow, and acts in the company under the firm
of Brash and Reid: that he remembers to
have asked Mr. Muir*s opinion about the pro-
priety of selling Paine's book : that Mr. Muir
said It was an imiwoper book, and that in
selling it there might oe dancer.
Mr. Muir then questioned Mr. Beid, if ever
he heax d him say any thins against the con-
stitution of this country .-^-Jjdr. Ileid replied,
he never did.
Being questioned by the Court respecting
the time when he had this conversation with
Mr. Muir, he said he could not remember
the particular month or day; being asked if
he could remember any circumstances that
might lead to a recollection of the time he
haa said conversation with Mr. Muir, he re-
plied, it was a few. days before Mr. Honey-
man, the sheriff of the county, came to take
precognitions concerning that book.
George Waddel
Depones, That he has been at meetings of
the societies of the Friends of the People in
Glasgow : that at one of these meetings, he
remembers col. M'Lcod and Mr. Muir oeing
present: that when a motion was made for
recommendine particular books, both col.
M'Leod and Mr. Muir opposed it, as in most
books there was too great a mixture of truth
and falsehood : that me only books which he
remembers the panel to have recommended,
were, Blackstone's Commentaries upon the.
Laws of Endand, and Erskine's Institutes of
the Laws of Scotland : that Mr. Muir ad-
vised moderate measures : that this was the
continual subject of his discourse : that he
said he would glory to have the table of the
House of Commons covered with petitions:
that he spoke to Mr. Muir about an address
of eongratulation to the French in imitation of
Dundee, but that Mr. Muir disi^zvved of it
John Russel.
After this witness had been sworn, the
common question was put to him, if any per-
son had mstructed him what to say? He
answered, None, except to tell the truth*
Being asked who instructed him so ? He re-
plied, he could point out no person in partir
cular, but that it was the general advice of
all to whom he spoke. He was obliged to
produce his summons to be a witness, and it
appeared that the citation had been g;iven him
only four days before his examination. He
was informed by the Court that any who
spoke to him, must have done so in the in-
terval of these four days, and that therefore
it was impossible that he could forget all their
names. The witness replied, that the gen&»
ral instruction to speak Uie truth was so com«
mon, that he could not remember at preaent,
any particular person who had given it.
The Lord Advocate moved, That the wit*
ness should withdraw ; and observed thai as
there appeared evident signs of a desire to
conceal tiie truth in this man, he hoped thor
lordships would punish him by ordering him
to be committed to prison.
Mr. Muir arose, and attempted to speak in
defence of the witness, but as he was begin-
nmg, was interrupted by the Court, who com*,
manded him to sit down, as he had no right
or titie 4o interfere in the business.
Lord lfeiu{fr/^c{ gave his opinion: Evexy
appearance was against. the witness ; that he
wished to conceal the truth ; that he merited
punishment, and should be committed to
prison for a certain period.
The rest of the judges concurred with lord
Hcndcrland ; and Mr. Russel was committed
to prison for the term of three weeks, as
guilty of concealing the truth upon oath*. .
♦ In the Appendix to two of the editions
of this trial, the followin|; article relative to
the examination of this witness was inserted :
ADDRESS TO THX PUBLIC.
In the different accounts which have been
published of Mr. Muir's trial, mention is
made of my having been committed to prison
for prevarication, or an attempt to conceal the.
truth. These accounts, in so far as they re-
gard me, being defective, I think it incum-
bent upon me, in justice to myself and my
character, to present the public with a candid
statement of the whole matter.
Being called to the bar of the court, and
having taken the oath to tell the whole truth,
and nothing but the truth, I was interrogated,
** Has any person instructed you what you
should say V . I answered. None ; but men'p.
tioned that several persons had desired me to
tell the truth. I was then asked, who had
done so ? My answer was, that I did not re-
collect : but that no person had given me any
particular instructions, what I alluded to
Laving been only the general observation of
177]
Jbr Sedition.
A. D. 1793,
[178
JdhftBretk
Depftfnesy That he was at one meeting of
the Friends of the People, in the Star Inn at
GlaseoK^ where he h^d Mr. Muir recom-
meno adherence to the constitution, and to
good order, and that he declared, he would
leare the Friends of the People, if ever they
should proceed to riotous measures : that he
has heard him speak of hooks of the law, hut
cannot be positive to any in particular, only he
thinks he remembers to have heard him men-
tiofn a work of Mr. Locke's.
WiUUtm CliddesdaU
Depones, That be never joined himself to
Ml J society of the Friends of the People, but
that he is a member of the society in (Hasgow,
foff the reform of the boroughs : that about
^■^i^i— — ^1— ^■— M^— — ^— ■^■^^—— ^— I I 'm
dercrml persons with whom I had spoken on
the sobject I was then questioned when I
had been cited as a witness ; upon which I
produced my summons, bearing aate ^e 2dth
ofAugast; I was again interrogated, if it was
afto- uie citation that I had the conversations
teferred to, add with whom I held these ? To
which I replied, that it was both before and
after citation ; but, as it was only a kind of
general instruction, I could not recollect any
particular person.
I was then ordered to withdraw ; and, on
being again called into court, was ordered to
prisonfor three weeks.
This sentence not a little surprised me, as
I was totally at a loss to guess the cause, not
liSTino^ been conscious ofany wrong. Indeed
the wnole error ( if it may be so called) was
tbeefiect of confusion and mistake, which
were natuial enough, considering my utter
^aorance of law proceedings^ and that I
never before had been examined as a witness
in a court of justice.
I do not mean to reflect on the Court, but
to justify myself from the charge of prerari-
cstion, or ot concealing the truth, which I
had no idea of committing. On the contrary,
it appears to me that I was to blame onlv for
an over-anxiety to tell the whole truth in
terms of my oath ; for had I answered the
first questwn in the negative (which I was
entitled to do, as no person had put wor<is in
sny mouth), I wQuld not have bad the mortifi-
cation of being imprisoned.
Conscious of the purity of my intentions,
lavAmiit my case to tne public; and, leaving
il with them to judge with candour, I have
only further to observe, that I grieve not so
much on account of my confinement, of the
injory it may do me in business, of my repu-
ta^on, as I am sorry that^ from my being re-
jected, Mr. Muir may be the greater stittcrcr
0f the two, as he was prevented from having
the benefit of my evidence, which would have
tended highly to Ms exculpation of the charges
i^ainsthm).
JSdMurgh T<^Mih. - JoHV Hcssti.
VOL. xxm.
the 13th of December last, Mr. Muir, when
the witness was present, visited that society
said that the borough reformers had made
great exertions; recommended to them per-
severance, firmness, and measures which
were peaceable; that he did not exhort them^
to riot or insurrection : that he remembers
of hearing Mr. Muir ol)serve, that there were
some things in Paine's book, which might be
good in the sight of some men, but many bad
and that for his part, he thought his system
was impracticable : that he reprobated Liberty
and Equality, as it implied violation of pro-
perty, and assigned, that a division of pro-
perty was a chimera which never could exist,
Georgt Bdl
Depones, That in the society of the Friends
of the People at Glasgow, he has heard Mr,
Muir speak, and that he has heard him de-
clare, that he would admit no members into
the society, but such as acknowledged the
King, House of Lords, and House of Com-
mons: that he never heard him speak agaiaat
the constitution ; and that he din not recent
mend any books in particular, but only such
books in general as gave moral instruction,
inculcated sobriety, and tended to make meo
good members of society.
Rev. Daniel W Arthur
Depones, That he remembers to have had
a conversajtion with Mr. Muir in the cofite
room at Glasgow, in the months of September
or October last: that he saw Mr. I^iiiir and
another gentleman walking together: the
gentleman having gone away, Mr. Muir came
up to the witness, and said, that the person
with whom he had been, was chairman of
the societv of the Friends of the People ih
Edinburgh: that the witness said to Mr.
fMuir, Do you not think this a wrong time
for to insist for a reform in parliament, see-
ing what had happened in France ? To which
Mr. Muir answered. That he thought It a
proper time, as the country enjoyed the bless-
mgs of peace ; that there was no comparison
betwixt this couhtry and France: that iji
France, they had sought a revolution, and
had brought it about, but that in Britain we
wanted no revolution, but only a moderate
reform.
Jamet JM^Gihbon
Depones, That he was a ihember of the
socie^ for Reform in Campsie : that he has
seen Mr. Muir there, and that he did not re-
commend any books in particular, nor did he
speak against the King, House of Lords^ or
House of Commons.
Robert Henry
Depones, That he is a member of the same
society with the preceding witness : that Mr.
Muir came into that socieW : that the witness
was present during the whole time that he
wa^ Aere; but was not \Vith him in the prl-
N
""
179]
33 GEORGE III.
Proceedings against Thomas Muir
[180
▼ate company ; and that he did not hear the
panel speak unconstitutionally, but heard him
Tocommend peaceable and orderly measures.
The Lord Advocate said, it was unnecessary
for Mr. Muir to bring so many witnesses to
prove the same thing.
Mr, Muir replied, that he intended to
bring witnesses from every part of the country
where he had attended societies for reform,
that he might clearly prove his innocency ;
that he had only a few more witnesses to ad-
duce, and then he would close his evidence.
William Orr
you
wnen
have heard. The
the truth or false-
sideration of what
moment is come, ^
hood of what is laid to the charge of the
panel at the bar, is to be ascertained. He
is a man who, as I shall afterwards show
you, has been, under the specious pretext of
of a reform, sowing the seeds of discontent
and sedition: — He appears here, before you^
after being a fugitive from his country; ana
it is now that by your verdict,— a verdict which
is uncontrollable, and from which there b no
appeal, — his guilt must be established, or the
imputation tmown out against him completely
WtlUam Urr ^ ^wiped away. This is a moment which 1 have
Deponed, That Mr. Mmr and colonel long anxiously looked for, and I declare, that
Dalrymple, came to Paisley: that in the * • ^ ^ «. r_, •. .
company of the witness the^ visited, and ad-
dressed the different societies of the Friends
of the People there : that Mr. Muir, in his
speeches, inculcated a firm attachment to the
kmg and constitution: that he recommended
peace and regularity, and reprobated riot and
sedition : that he exhorted the people to be
in the range of my official capacity, among
the numerous list of offenders whom I have
brought to this bar^ if there has been any one
whose actions particularly pointed him outfor
prosecution, whose conduct appeared the most
criminal, wlio has betra^^ed tne greatest ap*
pearance of guilt, this is the man: — he m
every •thing betrays a most decided spirit
steadfast to the constitution, and to endeavour against the constitution, and all under ~th»
to obtain their object, by every legal and con- |i veil of parliamentary reft
stitutional means. The witness never saw
Mr. Muir but that night: that after. having
Sine through the different societies, Mr.
uir, colonel Dalrymple, and the witness
went to Sinclair's inn, in Paisley : that in the
course of private conversation, he heard Mr.
Muir say nothing against the king and con-
stitution, but that he heard him say, that
the king was the best of princes.
James Craig
Depones,Thatinthe societies of the Friends
of the People in Paisley, he heard Mr. Muir
declare, that the constitution was a good con-
stitution, and that the king was the niend and
the father of his people.
James Richardson
Deponed, That he is a member of the same
societjr of the Friends of the People in London,
of which Mr. Grey, M.P. is a member; that
he is not a member of any society of the
Friends of the People in Scotland, but that he
was present at a meeting of the Friends of the
People in Glaseow, when he heard Mr. Muir
exhort the people to keep by the constitution,
and that if any of them were against it, they
should be expelled ; that in a masterly man-
ner he exposed the absurd idea of liberty and
equality if it implied division of property,
and that he said such a system was totally
impracticable ; and he used every argument
to excite the people to keep to the old con-
stitution.
Mr. Muir now declared. That he had finish-
ed the proof in exculpation : that it was in his
power to adduce many more witnesses, but
that he deemed it totally unnecessary.
The Lord 4^vocate. — Gentlemen of the
Jury; It is my duty now to require your
most attentive, serious, and deliberate con-
parliamentary reform.
We all know the pernicious effects of the
seditious writingjs and conduct which have
lately appeared m this country; and aU of
those persons who have had the courage t»
come and stand a trial at this bar, have met
with the same fate ; — they have all been found
guilty. And I trust, that as the evidence has
clearly unfolded the diabolical and mischiew^
ous conduct of this person, he will receive
a similar verdict. Who could have con-
ceived, that a man who has received a liberal
education, who has practised as an advocate
at this bar,* should be found on every occa-
sion, among villagers and manufacturers, poor
and ignorant, for the purpose of sowing among
them sedition and discontent ?
The charges exhibited against the panel
divide themselves into three distinct heads,
which however all center in the general charge
* Mr. Muir had, at the time of his trial, been
expelled from their society, by the Faculty of
Advocates, as will appear by the following ex-
tracts from their records, to which, by the
kindness of the present dean, M. Ross, esq.
I have had access : —
^* Edinburghf Snd March^ 1793.
*^ The Dean present;— The dean [the hon,
Henry Erskinej represented to the Faculty,
that one of their number had a sentence of
fugitation and outlay^ pronounced against
him, by the court of justiciary, for not obeying
a citation firom that court ; he wished to know,
how far it was proper to continue a person €#
that description upon the roll of the tacul^ of
advocates: after some short conversation up^
on the subject, it was moved and agreed tQ»
that a meeting of the faculty should be held
on Wednesday next, for taking this matter
under consideration, and therefore the derk
was ordered to issue circular letters requesting
181]
Jot Sedition.
and diwonte&t by various
A. D- 1793.
[182
ofexdtmg
stops of conduct
rastyHe has circulated Pune's Rights of
MaDy a book which one of his witnesses says
be dedaied to be dangerous to weak minds;^ —
y«t has he wilfully circulated this book, with
aa obstinacy and pertinacity which plainly in-
dicated that his wish and intention was, to
overturn our happy constitution.
Secondly, He has been always found mak-
ing seditious speeches and harangues among
knots of ignorant labourers and poor manu-
&/cUirer8> who, I am entitled to say, had it not
been for him, would have remained peaceable
and contentc^ and never thought of that in-
cendiary Paine, nor of formmg meetings,
till be came, like the dxmon of sedition, re-
commending that club government, which in
another country has produced so much an-
archy and coomsion, and which no well es-
tablished government could allow.
Thirdly, He has been in a meeting, calling
themselves delegates for obtaining a parlia-
mentary reibnnw — Gentlemen, we all remem-
ber the transactions of last winter; it was then
that sedition raised its hydra head, which the
spirit of this country crushed, and since that
day has held in detestation: it was then that
cood men felt and trembled; and thou^ some
ule circumstances may have given cause to
suspect that discord is still endeavoured to be
etctted, I have not a doubt that you will, by
jour verdict this day, show that you still en-
tertain the same abhcHrence of these practices.
There, in that convention,— I shall call it by
BO other name^— he almost alone was found
the supporter and defender of a paper highly
seditican, if not treasonable, whicn came irom
a socieW in our sister kingdom, styling them-
selves United Irishmen, and which even in
that convention was considered as dangerous;
yet thb person was the rindeader to produce,
to read, and approve it, ana who insisted that
it ^ould be received and answered.
These threecharges, then, gentlemen, which
umte themselves in one,— tlmt of exciting dis-
content, nay almost rebellion against the go-
vernment, that most dangerous kind of sedi-
ticm, whicm, according to judge Blackstone, is
VfoX to high treason, — have been brought with
deliberation ; and it is now my duty to show
the attendance ot the members on that day,
at the rising of the court."
" 6th March, 1793.
** The Dean present; — The Faculty having
■Mt tUs day, according to their appointment,
Saturday last, they took into consideration a
sentence of fugitation of the high court of jus-
ticjary pronounced against Mr. Thomas Muir,
advocate, for not appearing to stand trial oa
an indictment raided a^nst him by the lord
advocate of Scotland, tor seditious practices ;
they unmnimousljf order the name of the said
llr. Thomas Muir, to be expunged from the
fist of the Faculty: which was accordingly
done in their presence.
you, have been established by the evidence.
In one thing I agree with the person at the
bar, — THAT THIS TRIAL IS OP CONSEQUENCE TO
posTERiTT ; — ^I grant that it is ; but whether as
it strikes him, you are this day to judge. It has
been my wish to obtsdn, in this case, the ver-
dict of such a respectable jury as I now see.
Gentlemen, you are to determine, whether
sedition be a crime of such a detestable na^
ture as I represent it; to cnish it, I bring for-
ward the arm of justice, which by the verdict
you are to ^e, it is in your power to invigo-
rate or to pdsy in a moment. You will con^
sider the conduct of the panel, and then say
whether it is such as in your minds, ought to
be passed over.
GeuUemen, as the charges are threefold,
the witnesses must also be of three kinds.
I shall speak of each in their order; and I
must say, that if ever a strong body of evi-
dence appeared in a difBcult case, if ever there
was a respectable set of witnesses whose tes-
timony stands on the basis of truth, they are
to be seen here ; and in place of being con-
tracUcted by his e^dence, they are completely
corroborated by them.
Now, gentlemen, as to the first chaige, that
of making seditious speeches and harax^gues.
and encouraging improper meetings, we find
him in different parts of the country, exciting
amono; the people a spirit of disaffection to the
lawful government. There has he been, re-
commending books to enlighten their minds !
a measure in which, however, he has been
very unsuccessful, if we may take Weddel, the
learned vice-president of the Kirkintilloch So-
ciety, as an example of its effects. The evi-
dence I chiefly rest upon here, is Johnstone
and Freeland, particularly Johnstone, and no
evidence can be more distinct, connected, and
clear. He and Freeland agree that the panel
spoke of the success of the French arms.—
With what motive could he discourse on such
a subject to weak, uninformed, illiterafte peo-
ple, but to fulfil his seditious intentions f He
talked of the weight of taxes. Gentlemen,
we may see these burthens lightened ; but if
this gentleman's mode of doine it were to go
on, what sort of relief we should have by the
diminution of our taxes, and the payment
of our debt, are topics on which you will judge
as you oufht to do. He said, that their taxes
would be less if they were more equally repre-
sented ; and that from the flourishing state of
France, they could not bring their goods to
market so cneap as Frenchmen. What could
possibly be more calculated to produce dis-
content and sedition? Had such societies pre-
viously existed, the case would have been di&
ferent; but he appears as the ringleader ; he
was there on the Tuesday preceding, convers-
ing about it; he came to the meeting and hac-
rangued them ; he adjourned with them after*
wards to Wallace's. Can any evidence be
more connected or more clear that he was
the main instrumentf
The second charge is the circulat^ig eediti-
183] SSGEQJlOJPm.
Proeeedingi ag^dM Thomas Mutr
[18ft
ous book8» contiinipff the pawyi libelled in |
the indictmjeDty whicD. you may. read. Free-
land is again an evidence here; and I must
observe tbat it appears to be doubtful, whe-
ther he told all he knew; from his face, he
piainlv prevaricated; and when closely ques-
tioned, the sweat broke upon it. He told ytou
the story of getting Paine's book out of Muir's
pocket. — I may here observe that such a mode
of circulating a book, is that which a man in
bis situation will naturally adopt; he will not
go on openly, but privately, and under various
pretexts; by his fruits must you know him ;
you must compare his actions with his profes-
sions and then judge.
We have evidence of his recommending,
a^d buying the Paisley Declaration and otb^
1)ooks, which go to prove he is tainted from
bead to foot, and is as unworthy to live un-
der the protection of the law as the meanest
felon.
The next witness I shall speak of is Anne
Fisher; and though the panel, by an expres-
sion which he made use of has endeavoured
to prejudice you against her, I dare say, gen-
tlemen, you will agree with me, that her evi-
dence is correct, well-founded, stands on the
basb of truth, and is corroborated by the evi-
dence of others. But what was the conduct
of the panel? The only thing indeed which
he could do, — ^an endeavour to shake her tes-
timony by an illiberal and unfounded insinua-
tion, that we procured our information only
from domestics.
To what then amounts her testimonv, which
stands beyond the possibility of a doubt? —
That she was sent repeatedly firom her n^as-
ter's house, the panel's father, who I un-
derstand is a respectable man; — far be it from
me to attach any criminaUty to him; the
panel has the miserable reflection that the dis-
tresses which have embittered the Uves of his
parents have been brought on by himself; —
that she was repeatedly sent to purchase Paine's
book and other works for cnuntiy people who
came into the shop, who, b^ this man's per-
suasion, must out with their miserable six-
pence, to purchase Painc*s Rights of Man ; and
that he used constantly to be reading seditious
publications in the back shop; — it was there,
in that cathedral of sedition, he sat like a spi-'
der, weaving bis filthy web to ensnare the un-
waty.
The witness specifies the people for whom
she procured Paine's book. One of the jper-
sons she condescends upon is the uncle ofihe
unfortunate wretch at the bar, John Muir the
hatter ; but I declined bringing the uncle in
as an evidence against his nephew. The
other persons whom she mentions, are Wil-
son the barber, and Barclay, the Elder. Wilson
corroborates the evidence of Anne Fisher,
when he depones that he was advised to keep
a copy of Fainc in his shop, to enlighten his
customers minds ; for that it confuted Burke
entirely — ^Mr. Burke, a man whose wonderful
talents ^nd genius have lately been so much ex-
erted in tfaeservioaofliiscountiy. Kowygentle*
men, I have only to desire vou to read tba pUp
saees quoted from tlttt book in the mdictmeat,
and if you are loyal to your king, if you love
your country and are desirous to preserve it^
you will return a verdict against this man, who
has dared to recommend that wretched out-
cast and his writines — works which I never
read till my official duty compelled me to it,«
and of which I need not give you my opinioiu
since the determinations of courts of law, and
the unanimous opinion of the country, have
marked the detestation in which they are held.
[Uis lordship here read some of the passages
inserted in the indictment.]
What avails then, gentlemen, all this evK
dence of attachment to the king and conalitu*
tion, when he unequivocally approves sentt*
ments such as these? We are told, indeed, by
oneof his witnesses, that he advised him not to
sell Paine ; but unfortunately the answer given
to the question put to him upon his croas-exa*
mination, proves that they were not his real
sentiments, but for fear of danger, as the book
began to be taken notice of.
It appears fiom the evidence of the girl,
Fisher, that even the poor organist could not
pass the house of this demon of mischief, but
ne must be Btop|>ed and desired to play ^ tre
— ^a tune which is made use of in that un-
happy country, France, as a signal for blood
and carnage. He used to say too, that if
every man had a vote, he would be member
for Calder, and members would have thir^
or forty shillings a day. All these circum-
stances go to prove incontestibly, that France
and French principles were continualy in bis
view, and that he aimed at the destnictioB'
of the present government; with respect to
which, however, I hope his prophecies wiU
be as false, as they have already been in re-
gard to the success of the French. It may
be said, that the evidence of this girl Fisher
is, in a trifling instance, contradicted by the-
elder, Barclay ; but you should recollect the
salvo* which that old gentleman chose to
introduce when he took the oath:— That did-
not look well.
I now come to the third charge, which re-
lates to Mr. Muir's conduct in the convention.
It is here incontestibly proved, that he read,
approved, and defended the Irish address.
Will you approve this paper ? Will you dis-
regard tliis convincing proof of his guilt } Be
his studies ever so great, be his views ever so
extensive, will you permit him arrogantly to
set up his seditious opinions, in oppontion to
the government and constitution ? His con^
duct in some instances would almost appear
to be marked with insanity were we not
finding him the determined ringleader in an
uniform scheme of sedition.
* When Mr. Barclay made oath, he added
to the clause, ^* to tell the truth so far as yoa
know," these words <' and can reooUect."
Orig. EdU.
189]
jvT flCQIvKflit
A. D. 179S.
[186
lli^ mllfllBeI^ fiiu4hQ9 1117 rM^
the eviaeoee — upoD the evidence whkb I
thiok is icrindbU; .but there we two topics
on which I must beg to make some obsetvc^
tioiis*
Jlir. Muir told us that he was carried out
of this couotry by business of imoortance,
that he was detained in France, and that he
always wished to have a trial. I could have no
objections to his proving this; it would have
argued some degree of honour. But his pro-
fessions are false and confuted. He left this
country under an impression of guilt, and
lately returned, the pest oi Scotland, with
the same intentions as before.
J was never more surprised at any thing
than at the evidence of Skirving, when he
ssud that the panel was sent to France by the
persons styUng themselves the Friends of the
People to save the life of the kiug ! Never
was I more astonished than at the impudence
of this. Did. the witness know, or recollect,
that he was then almost accusing him of high
treason, by making him a missionary from
a society in this country to France N--a cir-
cumstance which greatly confirms his euilt
But why was he interested in this event r It
vras an event, as bis witnesses tells you, that
would hurt the common cause — what cause \
TnaiR IKTBVTJOll OF SVPECTIKO A CHAVGE
XH THB OOVEaMMEMT OF THIS COUNTRY.
He says that he always wished to have a
trki; let us see how this corresponds with
&cts. When the trial was coming on I post-
poned it longer than I ought to have done, to
give him eveiy chance; and I inserted it in
the iMipers, which might perhaps reach him
roaming in some part of the world.
The ship master's receipt bears date the 16th
May. What became of him from that date till
the Slat of Julv when he was apprehended ?
He informed nobod v of his intention of retumr
inc. How unlucky, how wonderful that not one
soUCary letter was wafted over by the winds
and waves to the Edinbui^h Gazetteer, or
the Caledonian Chronicle, to ^ive notice of
what he says was. his earnest wish ! — ^The re-
^werse in fact appears to have been the case.
By the letter ot J. Muir, his father, we find
him in Ireland, doing we know not what,
except what we learn from the diploma of
the warthy society of United Irishxnen. He
is at last apprehended, returning into this
country with ail the insula of seaition about
htm.
I hare but one remark more. You may in
some degree judge of a man by the company
he keeps. — ^Among Mr. Muir's papers, ^we
find a letter, — ^here in my hand,~addressed
to the rev. T. Fyshe Palmer,* a man who is
•indictsd to stand trial at Perth, in the course
of a few days, and whom most of you must
know. The imfiression of the seal too is
worth remarking, it is the cap of liberty on a
spear, and under it is the motto (d tra.
* See his trial for sedition^ in this volume,
I beg your attention eendemen to the quo-
tation I shall now read from a French author*
in treating of the British constitution.
[The passage his lordship read, was Arom
De Louxie on the Constitution of £ng«
land, from the middle of p. 5S4 to the
end.]
I hope, gentlemen, this case will be viewed
by you in such a light as that you will pro-
tect your king from the attacks of his ene-
mies, that you will protect this temple of
freedom from the attempts of the factious,
but particularly ag^ainst that man at the bar,
who has been sowing sedition with so libend
a hand. You mav now, however, seize him
in his career, and by your verdict do justice
to your country and honour to yourselves.
Mr. Muir, — Gentlemen of the Jury ; I riset
in my own defence. All that malice could
devise, all that slander could circulate, haa
been directed against me. I speak with
joy and with triumph. After an investi-
gation into my pubUc transactions, and into
my private conduct, the most minute and the
most unexampled which ever occurred la
this country, my moral character stands se-
cure and unimpeached. With the anonymous,
the worthless, and the paid assassins ot public
reputation, I disdained to'enter the lists. To
this day I looked forward with expectation ;
when before you, in the presence of Scotland,
I should not merely remove the suspicion of
fiilt^ but should demonstrate my innocence,
will not imitate the example of the public
prosecutor, who has finished his pleading.
Sonndine and unsubstantial declamation is
unsuitable for you, and it Is unworthy of mo.
Thu is not an hour to temporize, llie eyes
of this country are fixed upon us both. The
recoids of this trial will pass down to post»-
ri^. When our ashes shall be scattered by
the winds of heaven, the impartial voice of
future times will rejiidge your verdict. Let
faction rage : — let the spirit of party, in tli^
present hour, proudly domineer : — the illusion
will soon vanish away. In solitude the power
of recollection will assume its influence ; and
then it will bo material to you, whether or
not you have acted uprightl;^, or sinned
against your own eternal conscience, in my
acquittal, or in m^ condemnation !
Before I enter into a particular vindication
of myself, let roe take notice of two circum-
stances, strongly insisted upon by the public
prosecutor, which have little relation to th^
general nature of the evidence which has
een adduced. — Long, indeed, has he haran^^
gued upon them; and has concluded his
speech by exhibiting them in every shape
which his imagination could invent. He
maintains, that a consciousness of jguilt ob-
liged me to leave this country after an infor*
* De Lolme was a Genev^se.
187]
S3 GEORGE HI.
agttiiul Thomat Muhr
£188
mation had been filed against me, and after
i had been examined by a magistrate. I will
admit the fact of my departure. — ^In these
days — in these circumstances — ^is that to
be ascribed to conscious guilt alone ? If the
whole strength of arbitrary power is extended
against an individual^ is there merit in ex-
posing himself as a sacrifice which cannot be
useful to the country, and which may only
present posterity with a new addition to the
immense catalogue of the victims of despo-
tism ? If two motives had only existed to
which you could assign my departure, vou
are bound to ascribe it to the most charitable.
— But what were the circumstances attend-
ing my departure? Did they bear any re-
semblance of a Right? Did I not publicly
announce it the preceding evening in a nu-
merous meeting of citizens ? Did f not cause
k to be published in a public paper ? Did I
affect the garb and disguise of concealment?
In London, did 1 remam in obscurity ? Did
I not appear in a distinguished society, the
society of the Friends of the People? And
did not that society publish afterwards a re-
solution, announcing in its preamble my pre-
sence among them ?
But I went immediately afterwards to
France. Mr. SkirVing. who was examined
with regard to a letter he received firom me
i>efore my departure from London, has said,
in his evidence (and his words I have accu-
rately in my notes) that I proposed to go to
Paris^ as it was the advice ** of Some Friends,''
and might be of some service in mitigating
the fate of the late kin^.
The wordsof Mr.Sk]rving,''Some Friends,"
have been curiously represented. — ^It is stated,
that these ** some friends," must have been
the members of that truly respectable society ;
and it is boldly aigued, that I went to France
as a missionaiy from that body. — ^Nothing can
be more ridiculous— Nothing can be more
injurious.-»Mr. Skirving never said so ! — No
person can, or dare say, that I ever went as
a missionaiy, delegated from individuals, or
by societies, to any foreign power. Building
then upon this unsubstantial basis of words,
never uttered in evidence by Mr. Skirving, nor
which ever could possiblvbe uttered, I am
accused of a species of high treason, in corres*
ponding m\h a foreign power without any
liegal authority from home. The charge of
correspondinjg with foreign power is equally
ridiculous with the misrepresentation upon
which it is founded ; but let it be considered
as serious, I dare the proof.
I challenge the prosecutor to adduce the
smallest vestige of evidence.
Yes; I will admit, I wrote to Mr. Skirvine
my intention of going to France ; nor will 1
deny the motive. I saw, in the execution of
the late king, a specious pretext to plunge the
country in war, and to extend the effusion of
human blood to every comer of the world !
I may have erred. I may have acted from
enthusiasm; but it was enthusiasm in the
cause of man. If, at the period when it was
free to every person to publish their senti-
ments upon that awful question, I wbhed
likewise to publish mine, can that be imputed
to me as a crime? Can the intention of
pleading the cause of mercy, of individual
and of general humanity, t>e construed into
guilt? If it can, I am then guilty. Has
not the prosecutor lamented iwX disastrous
event ? ^d will he accuse a man who wished
to prevent it? — who, wiUi many friends
to numanity, of every nation, and of every
party, in private, in public, in conversation,
and from the press, exerted their abilities to
ward off an event which they foresaw was to
introduce years of blood and sorrow ? But
aUow,that at first glance, my departure from
Scotland, my journey to Paris, anbrded a pre-
sumption of guilt, that presumption is obvi*
ated by my return.
The prosecutor has boasted of his huma-
nity, in granting me the delay of a few weeks,
by postponing my trial, in order that I might
return from Paris.— But was he ignorant that
hostilities at that time were commencing —
that the communication was closed— that it
was tedious and difficult to procure pass-
ports? Of that difficulty no person here can
possibly have any doubt.
Do not all my private letters, which have
this day been read, prove my uneasiness upon
account of the delay, and my anxiety to re-
turn ? But, at the period when I procured
my passport, the fiames of war were blazing
over most of Europe — ^I knew only two ways
by which I could possibly return home. The
first, by the way of Hamburgh ; the second
by the longer, but the more certain circuit of
America. — I adopted the latter, as more safe,
and less liable to interruption. — ^I lefl Paris.
— I went down to the port of Havre -de-
Grace. I found a vessel which was to sail
for New York. — The receipt found in my
pocket-book, when I was stopped upon my
landing in Scotland, from the master of that
vessel for the payment of my passage, proves,
that I had actually taken ray passage m that
ship. That vessel, in taking ner flight, and
by an embargo, was detained for near three
months.-^In this interval, another American
ship, the Hope, of Baltimore, arrived. The
captain was to touch in at Belfast in Ire-
land, for part of his cargo, on his return to
America. — This I considered to be a fortu-
nate accident. — ^I immediately embraced this
opportunity of returning by the way of Ire-
land to my country, not to implore &vour,
not to ask protection, but to dekamd justice.
To pass from France, to any of the dominions
of Britain, I had no oassport — ^my passport
was to America. I braved evei^ danger.
After a short passage I was landed in Ireland.
There I remained no longer than nine days,
I concealed not mv name. I appeared pub-
licly, and in the places of most public resort.
To ail I announced my situation and inten-
tion.
189]
fat SedUUm.
A. D. 1798.
[190
The prosecutor has either deugnedly at ig>-
iionuiu)rylaid hold of the circumstance of the
indoTsatian of the municipal officers of Havre-
de-Grace, upon my passport. The depart-
ment of PiBxis granted me a passport in the
end of the month of April, and I arrived at
HaTTBon the 3d or 4th of May. The first
step which a stranger is obliged to take, upon
arriving at the place of his destination in
Prance, is to proceed to the municipality, to
ahow to them the passport from whence he
came, to have it revised and attested by
them, in order to enjoy security within then-
jurisdiction. The indorsation, as I have
stated, of my Parisian passport, by the muni-
dpal officers at Havre, is or the Sd or 4th of
May last. From this circumstance, the lord
advocate infers, that I must immediately have
found a vessel to carry me home. He makes
no allowance for the state of the two nations;
lie makes no allowance for the difficulties
which neutral vessels have in passing betwixt
both; and he knows nothing of the embar-
goes which these vessels must constantly ex-
perience in the different belligerent ports.
Well, then, some time in the month of May I
must have landed in Ireland ! Public report
has said, that insurrections have been in that
country. The prosecutor has cried out, that
I was the daemon of sedition ! and he insi-
nuates, that there is a probability that I was
the cause of these insurrections. I smile at
the accusation, which he himself in hb own
mind must deride. It could have been easy
for me, by the testimonies of my friends in
Ireland, whom I love, and whom I honour,
lo prove how I passed my time. But for me
to dwell upon this is imnecessary. You, of
the jury, must have experienced the same
emotions, and at present indulge the same
feelings as I do.
Fh>m Ireland, the prosecutor says, I at-
tempted to land in Scotland in a clandestine
manner ; and so says his composition, the
indictment.
In the list of witnesses adduced aeainst me,
I saw the names of Carmichael, the person
who first recognized me at my landing at
fortpatrick, and of Mr. Ross, the magistrate
at Stranaer, before whom I first appeared.
The lord advocate chaises me with coming
to Scotland in a clandestine manner. He
serves upon me, in the list of witnesses, the
cnly witnesses who could prove the fact;
Carmichael, the custom-house officer, and
Mr. Roes the magistrate, to whom I surren-
dered. I expected Carmichael and that gen-
tleman would have been inclosed with the
other witnesses of the crown. I would have
•dduced them as witnesses to prove, that so
iaf from concealing myself, I announced mv-
self publicly, and without disguise; so &t
from attempting evasion^ my only anxiety
was to put myself in the lumds of the law,
and under the protection of its magistrates.
The conduct or the public prosecutor is in
every respect uniform. Heis giultyof ano-
ther piece of disingenuity, by serving upon
me in the list of the witnesses of the crown^
the names of Carmichael and Ross. I could
not entertain the least possible doubt, but
that they were to be adduced. This was an
art to prevent me citinz them at my own in-
stance. It has succeeded. I am deprived of
their testimony. But why did not the pro*
secutor, at least^ produce the declaration
which I made before the magistrate at Stran-
raer? That delaration, freely and volunta*
rily emitted, would have proved^ that I came
into the country in no unoecommg manner.
Much of the invective of the prosecutor
was founded upon my coining into this coun->
try in concealment. This circumstance, the
indictment charges as an aggravation of the
crime. Judge, then, gentlemen, of the rec-
titude of the prosecutor's conduct, when he
declaims upon a fact which he shrinks from
proving, and which by his art in serving the
list of witnesses upon me, he has prevented
me from confuting.
I trust, novF, you will be convinced that no
consciousness of guilt led me from Scotland ;
no improper motive carried me from Ei^gland
to France; and that no deep and secret inten-
tion induced me to return in disguise to my
country. The object of that return was to
demand justice, to wipe away the imputation
of that crime with which I now stand charsed.
And what b that crime ? Sedition. — Is there
a term so vaeue and so undefined? so familiar
to power, so familiar to corruption ? All who
ever diured to oppose arbitrary power, and who
in the hour of danger came forward to save
their countrv, have been branded by the
epithet of seditious. The term is therefore
no loneer a term of opprobrium. In one age
it has Been applied to men rejected by society,
whose names were honoured by after-times^
and upon whose virtues, and upon whose suf-
ferings, the succeeding age reared the majes-
tic pular of the constitution. I am then ac-
cused of sedition, and I ask you of the jury,
to point out the comer of this land where se*
dition has existed. And tell me trulv where
the smallest vestige of this crime has ap-
peared. Upon you the eyes of the people are
now placed. Upon your consciences the
oath of God is binding. Point out then to us
where the shadow of sedition has been des-
cried. Have Uie sacred riehts of property
been any where invaded ? Has the blood of
the citizens flowed by the hands of the Friends
of the People? O! No. — But the prosecutor
has talkea of the danger the people of this
country were in last winter 1 of deep-laid
plots! and of tremendous conspiracies! and
I am the man, whom he charges as the au-
thor of the whole, whom he represents si-
milar in malignity to the daemon of mischief !
and whom he honours with the title of the
"* pest of Scotland !'' Well, then, let it be
supposed, that an attempt was formed to
overthrow the constitution, to kindle the
torch of civil war, to lead rapine and murder
191]
S3 GEORGE III.
Proceedings against Thomoi Mvir
\m
Along the land: where has the proof of this
design been found > Has it been discovered
in the meetings of the Friends of the People,
who, conscious of the purity of their inten-
Uons, affected no concealment, assembled
with doors open to all, and who hatched their
hellish designs (if such they were) in no mid-
night cavern? Could in the crowds, that
were admitted to attend the deliberations of
these societies, be found no ruffian, who
tsould at least give a bold and manly testi-
mony against them, and against me ? But
to support the accusation, the walls of a pri-
vate iM>use must be invaded ; domestic se-
crets must be explored^ and the testimony of
a miserable scullion girl and a hair-dresser,
must be brought forward, with regard to
words, spoken where suspicion the most y'vA-
l^nt must have been asleep, — under the
guardianship of a paternal roof. And are
these the witnesses, who are lo prove against
me this mighty crime, which, supposing them
to have been honoured by my conSdence,
would have required the co-operation of thou-
sands of bearded men in arms }
Gentlemen of the jury. Let us this night
throw away vain pretext : let us act fairly and
candidly. I smite at the charge of sedition.
You yourselves are conscious that no sedition
has existed in this country, and in your own
minds you deride the aoeusation. I know
^ for what I am brought to this bar, it is for
having strenuously and actively engaged in
the cause of parliamentary reform ; for hav-
ing exerted every effort, by constitutional
measures, to procure an equal representation
^ of the people, in the house of the people.
Let not the prosecutor sculk in darkness:
let him come manililly forward, and avow
the cause which has impelled him to brine
me here. I will give Vou little trouble : I
will prevent the lassitude of the judges : I
will, save you, the jury, from the wrotched
mockery of a trial, — the sad necessity of con-
demning a man, when the cause of his con-
demnation must be concealed, and cannot be
explained. Yes, I plead guilty. I openly,
actively, and sincerely embarked in the cause
of a parliamentary reform, in the vindication
and in the restoration of the rights of the
people. Nor will I bhish to unfbld to you
my motives ; they are supported by their own
iti&uisic strength, but they are hkewise held
up by the great and the venerable names of
the hving and of the dead. I contended for an
equal representation of the people^ in what I
shall ever call the house of the people, be-
cause I considered it a measure essentially
necessary to the salvation of the state, and
to the stability of your boasted constitution.
Wherein then consists the excellency of that
tiiAe- tried fabric, cemented by the blood of
your fathers, flowing from the field and from
the scaffold ? I will tell you : It consists in
the due balance of its three impelling powers,
King, Lords and Common : it one of these
powers loses its. vigour, the constitutioit in
I
proportion loset its vigour; if one of these
powers becomes only a shadow of What it
ought to be, if it becomes merged and ab-
sorbed into either of the other two. your con-
stitution then also becomes a shadow, and it
is annihilated. And do you not know, and
does all the world not know, that if any
where the proud structure of the constitution
has suffered the ravages of time or of corrup-
tion, it is in its popular branch ? Is it not
a fact indisputable, that the representation of
the people is not such as it once was, and is
not such, as I trust in God, one day it shall
be ? The roan then who sounds the alarm,
when he discovers the approach of danger,
who summons all who may be concerned in
its reparation, is surely no enemy to the
country, no foe to the constitution, because
he labours in its preservation and protection.*
Such were the motives of my conduct If
I am guilty, I have in my guilt many asso-
ciates, men who now enjoy the repose of
eternity, whom your fathers admired while
living, and to whom you, their children, have
erected statues. I have no time to nm over
all the venerable catalogue. But, is there a
man ignorant of the illustrious Lcibke ? And
was not this sage in philosophy, this advanced
champion in the cause of lioerty, and of man ;
this friend to the E^tish constitution, who
wrote his Treatise on Government in its de-
fence,— in defence of the last glorious revolu-
tion, by the desire of the prince, who was the
leader of the men who planned it ; — was not
he an advocate for a reform in parliament, for
a more equal representation of the commons
in the House of Commons ? Will you venture
to tear the records of his fame, to stigmatize
his memory, and to brand him with the epithet
of seditious?
Let us rapidly proceed down to more mo-
dern times. Let us pass over in silence many
illustrious names, whose memory with that
of the constitution, will perish together. Let
us come to your own days. Are ye ignorant
of Blackstone ; — ^the man who first collected
the laws of his country, from the deformed
chaos into which they had been thrown, who
* ^ And, as it is essential to the very being
of parliament, that elections should be abso-
lutely free, therefore all undue influences
upon the electors are illegal, and strongly
prohibited. For Mr. Locke (on Gov. p. 2. \
982.) ranks it among those breaches or trust
in the executive magistrate, which, according
to his notions, amount to a dissolution of the
government * if he employs the force, trea-
* sure, and offices of the society to corrupt the
' representatives, or openly to pre-engage the
^ electors, and prescribe what manner of
* sons shall be chosen. Fot thus to regiilate
* candidates and electors, and new^modS the
* ways of election, what Is it, says he, but to
< cut up the government by t^e roots, tasA
* poisdn the very fountain of priblic seewrity ?'"
—Blackstone, B. l. ch. 9, p* 178.-^Ofi^. Bd.
t
193]
^ Sediiion*
A. D. 1798.
[191
arrapged . Ihem with eleamcy, and who
adorned them with every nower which the
classic field could produce? Are not the
volumes of this reverend judge in the hands
of all ? Should thev not he familiar, at least
to those who are called to decide concerning
the constitution ? And has not Dlackstone,
soft with the levity of ill-pondered, words^ not
in the private hour of relaxation, not in the
Leat of popular debate, but in the calmness
and solitude of study, maintained the same
propositions which I maintain, been guiltv of
the same sedition of which I am guilty, when
be pronounced that the constitution was im-
perfect, in its popular branch, and if any
where alteration was necessary, it was there
to be desired ? I entreat you to listen. I will
read you, what this best expounder of the
constitution has said. Let the words be en-
graved on the tablet of ]^our hearts.
'^And this constitution of suf&ages, is
framed upon a wiser principle with us, than
either of the methods of voting, by centuries
or by tribes, among the Romans. In the
method by centuries, instituted by Servius
Tullius, It was principally property, and not
numbers that turned the scale : in the me-
thod by tribes, gradually intro<luced by the
tribunes of the people, numbers only were
regarded, and property was entirely over-
looked. Hence the laws passed by the for-
mer method, had usually too great a tendency
to aggrandize the patricians or rich nobles ;
and^ose by the latter, had too much of a
levelling prmciple. Our constitution steers
between the two extremes. Only such are
entirely excluded, as can have no will of their
own : there is hardly a free agent to be found,
who is not entitled to a vote m some place or
other in the kingdom. Nor is comparative
wealth or property, entirely disregarded in
elections; tor though the richest man has
only one vote at one place, yet, if his pro-
j>erty be at all diffused, he has probably a
right to vote at more places than one, and
therefore has many representatives. This is
the spirit of our constitution : not that I assert
It is m fact, quite so perfect as I have here
endeavoured to describe it ; for, if any altera-
tion might be wished or suggested, in the
}}resent frame of parliament, it should be in
avour of a more complete representation of
the people."*
It Blackstone, then, wished for a more
equal representation of the people, if he
dared to publish, and to enforce his wish ; and
I have merely done the same, where is the
difference in our guilt ? But there is a dif-
ibrence, and that difference is great. A
learned professor of the laws of England, in
the University of Oxford, a grave writer, in
the solitude of his retirement, a solemn
judge, upon the tribunal of l^ngland, pro-
clauniog that a reform in the representation
* Bl. Comm. book 1. c, ii. vol. i. p. 171,
172«
VOL. xxin.
of the people was just, and essential to the
true spirit of the constitution ; how superla-
tively criminal must his conduct be, when
compared with mine !
But vengeance ceases at the verge of thd
grave. There factions and parties rage in
vain. If I have been guilty of an atrocious
crime, I shall not demand the protection of
the dead, I shall not wander among the tombs,
and cry for the support and the assistance of
those who cannot near me, but I shall loudly
demand the protection of the living, of men
high in rank, exalted in power, and who
enjoy the confidence of their l^ing. Can it
lever be forgotten, that in the year 1783, Mr.
fipiii was stained with the same guilt ? Did
not he preach up the necessity of a reform in
the representation of the people ? Did not he
advise the people to form societies ; and did
not he countenance these societies, by his
irPresence ? I appeal to the resolutions which
he subscribed, in the Thatched House Tavern.
I attest the motions which he made for Re-
form in the House of Commons. Beware
how you condemn me. Beware how ^ou
brand me with the opprobrium of being
seditious. At the same time you condemn
the confidential minister of the king* Nay
more. Sir, in bringing this charge a^nst m^
you accuse your sovereign; for can it be sup-
posed, that he would permit a man to enjoy
his confidence, who m the year 178S, by
being a reformer, as I am in the ^ear 1793,
wished to precipitate this country into anar-
chy, desolation^ and into all the horrors which
you have described.
But if the attempt to procure a reform in
parliament be criminal, your accusation must
extend far and wide. It must implicate the
ministersoftlie crown, and the lowest sub-
jects. Have you forgotten that in the year
1783, the duke of Richmond, the present
commander qf the forces*^ was a fiammg ad-
vocate for the universal right of suffrage F Do
you not know, that he presided in societies,
and, like Mr. Pitt, advised a universal for-
mation of such societies all over the kingdom ?
Have you never read his famous letter to
colonel Sharman ; in which his principles,
his testimony, to a full and complete repre^
seotation of the people, are indelibly recorded ?
Is guilt the passing unsubstantial fashion of
the day ? Does it vary according to times,
and to seasons, and to circumstances ? Shall
what was patriotism in 1788, be criminal in
17P3 ? You have honoured me this /night, by
the title of the pest of Scotland. And if the
same offences merit the same appellations,
you must likewise liberally bestow tiiis epithet
upon the first lord of the treasury, and upoa
the commander of the forces. But what term
of super-eminent distinction will not you,
the public prosecutor; you the lord advocate
* The Duke of Richmond was not com-
mander of the forces, but master general of
the ordnance.
I O
not you, not many montlis ago, Kkewise a
reformer i Did not you conteno and act for a
more equal represeatation of the people in
the House of Commons? Were not you one
of those men, who, for that purpose, assembled
lately in this city, in what they called a con-
vention, and assumed to themselves the title
ofdelegatcB from the coimties? Were not you,
yoursefi', employed in framing a bill for the
extension ot the elective franchise? Even'
charge in your indictment against me, recoils
upon yourself; in accusing me, you charge
yourself with sedition. If it was lawful fcr
^ou and your friends to meet in societies, and
IB conventions, forthe puipose of areformin
parliament.unlessthestandardofguilt shrinks
and extends as caprice or power may order, it
surely muat have been pCTmilted to me and
my mends also to meet, and to act on the
same principle.
But I. advance in this track no farther;
although my assertions and my arguments
are just, yet the subject of them is so con-
nected wiih ridicule, as to render them not
■0 seeming in this solemn trial.
Gentlemen of the Jury; If the real cause of
my standing as a panel at your bar, is for
having actively engaged in the cause of a
parliamentary reform, I plead guilty. My
conscience, however, will whisper consolation
10 me under my condemnation. I engaged
in that cause, for I thought the measure was
10 save the country ; that a more equal re-
firesentation would dry up the sources of cor-
ruption, would diminish our taxes, and stop
the effusion of our blood. That such were
my motives, appears from every part of the
evidence against me. The public prosecutor
shrunk from the examination, even of the
testimony of his own witnesses. He averted
his eyes from the proof, in order to indulge
liimself in vain declamation and unbecoming
■inverlive. I will not, however, imitate his
conduct. I will examine minutely every
branch of the proof whicli he has adduced
against me; and you will be convinced that
after every word and action of mine has been
scruiinized; after even the levity of the un-
guarded hour lias been cvplored, and while
instructed spies have watched every look, and
marked every word, not the vestige of sedition
can be discovered.
The first charge a^inst me is. That at
meetings of the peopfe which 1 myself had
convocaled, I made seditious harangues ;
vilified the king and constitution ; repre-
sented the monarchical part of our govern-
ment as cumbersome and expensive; insti-
tuted a comparison betwixt our system and
that of France, and did every tbing to inflame
the minds of the people to insurrection and
rebellion. It is particularly alleged that I
Was guilty of these crimes at two meetings,
the one at Campsie, and the other at Kirkin-
tilloch.
To prove this cbai^ Alensder Johnstone
fered to prove that this witness had expressed
me; that he would do all in his power to get
me hanged. By respectable witnesses, I
could easily have supported this avetmentj
but Iwasnot allowed by the Court, as I could
not specify the particular cause which had
excited the malice ofa man I did not know,
and whom I do not remember to have ever
seen. But what does even Johnstone sayF
I will read you from my notes the whole of
his evidence. Correct me if I have erred in
taking down any thine differently from what
has been stated. 1 bdieve that my notes ate
accurate, but mistakes are not impossible.
[Here Mr. Mnir read over the whole of
the evidence.]
Wliat does this witness then say I He says,
that I stated, in the meeting at Campsie, the
disadvantages in the representation, from
boroughs Deing rotten, and from others
having no vote, the population of England
and ^tland, the small number of electors
in both, and that the people were not liilly
represented. And is tliis sedition? Is not
the fact notoriously true? Has it not been
resounded innumerable times within the walla
of the House of Commons itself? Has not
the table of that House been covered with
petitions, expressing it in language infinitely
stronger than mine? If to state truth be sedi-
tion, why did our legislature slumberf Why-
slumbered the law ? and why 'was not public
vengeance armed with the sword (rf justice,
when this crime dared to pollute Ihc sanctuary
of the legislature, by its appearance within itr
Johnstone depones, that I sud. If a man
cave 90,000/. for a seat in parliament, he
behoved to derive some interest from it. Is
not the fact true? Do not we daily know of
sums of money bcine given for seats in that
House,and can there be a conclusion in Euclid
more certain than the inference which I draw
from the fact? It may be said, that the House
may be pure and uncorruptcd, even although
such sums of money itc given for admission
into it ; that men ma^ do so in order to serve
tbeir country, or lo display their own abilitiea.
Grant all this; but have ne not seen much
greater sums thrown away at contested elec-
tions, hymen whonever opened their mouths
within the walls of St. Stephen's Chapel;
whose patriotism never shone forth ; and
whose abilities were never discovered P llie
witness depones, that I said the duke oF
Richmond nad been bribed into silence, by
30 or 30,000J. And supposing I had said so,
that this was a salutary opiate, which calmed
and cooled the fever of ins biain, and pro-
bably saved him the mortification of standing
his trial, also, for the crime of sedition; whal
has this to do with the present matter? Ills
not the duke of Richmond, but it is tbo
king himself, that I am accused of vilih'ing.
This assertion of Johnstone's is indeed ton
ludicrous for serious argument.
197]
fift Sediiiotu
A.D. 179S.
119B
Oeotlemeo, befine I proceed farther, let
ine make one remark. I am to be tried by
the law of Scotland ; and, by that law, two
wilnesses are necessary to prove a crime. —
Thb is a rule full of humanity ; but, at the
same time, by cutting off proof, it may, and
bas upon some occasions defeated the ends of
public justice. If, however, the concurrence
of two witnesses were to be rigorously insisted
upon, it roust be in a case similar to mine,
where their testimony is to go to words,
volaniia verba^ neither engraved in marble,
nor recorded in brass. You know the infinite
variety of circumstances depending upon the
speaker, the occasion, the manner, tne per-
son to whom they were uttered, and his situar
lion ; by which, the meaning of the same
words can be diversified and modified, tor-
tiued into guilt, and explained into innocence.
By the law of Bngland, which is likewise the
same with cur's m the case of treason, the
hue utteiinc of words, without any overt act,
cannot be admitted as evidence to prove the
Johostone depones, that I compared our
,coDstitutioB with the French, and said, that
their anns would be successful; that their
representation was more equal ; two-thirds of
their debt paid ; and that their manufacturers,
in the competition with ours, would have the
advantage. Who ever heard before, that it
was unlawful to compare the British consti-
tu^n with that of another country ? If the
British constitution is the boast of ages, the
pride and the glory of the world, can it suffer
Dy any oompanson } On the contrary, will not
its splendour brighten by the foil? But does
Johnstone say, that I gave the superiority to
the French constitution over the British?
industiy. Nothing can be truer than the in-
ference which Johnstone says I drew, that a
people equally industrious must have the adr
vantage over another, who pay greater taxes,
and wno groan under the burthen of a greater
debt. If I were connected with this last na-
tion, I certainly would advise them to take
every constitutional step to procure a dimi-
nution of their debt and of their taxes.
And what does Mr, Johnstone say ? That I
advised the society to petition parliament,
and that the sole intention of these societies
was, to procure a more equal representation
and a shorter duration of parliaments. Do
you say then, that the object of these
societies is unconstitutional ? Or do you say,
that these societies, in the means which I ad-
vised them to make use of in order to accom-
plish that object, were to act unconstitu-
tionally? You can do neither. Under the
free government of Britain, every man has
a right to look after those whom he is sup-
posed to deleg^ate to the House of Commons,
to be the arbiters of his liberty, his fortune,
his life. He has a right to come and state to
them his wronzs and nis apprehensions ; and
the mode which the constitution has pointed
out is by petition.
Johnstone depones, that I advised the peo-
ple to consult together, to communicate and
diffuse their knowledge: the advice was a
good advice : and such an advice as I would
give were I still in the same situation.
/What ! is the time now come when the mind
must be locked up; when fetters must be
imposed upon the understanding; and whea
the people, the great mass of human beings^
must be prohibited to receive information,
and to communicate among themselves the
Ko. — ^Does he assert, that I exhorted the i information which they may have received.
meeting to reject the British constitution, to
9dotii tae Ft-ench, and to adopt the French
as tDe better model ? No; not a word. What
then says he ? That I merely compared the
two together. Is this sedition P Alas ! we
are all seditious. Is there a man here, or in
this country, who has not, in his own mind,
^od who has not in woras^ made a similar
conparison?
Jonnstone next observes. That I mentioned,
that two thirds of the French national debt
Miserable people ! — Country to be deplored I
-^Ignorance is the source from which despo-
tism flows. The remembrance of former
liberties will make you only more wretched.
Extinguish then (if possible) the light of
heaven, and let us grope, and let us search
for consolation, if it can be found, under the
darkness which shall soon cover us. But
the prospect before us is not so dismal. — We
(live, we act under the British constitution ;
— a constitution which, in its genuine prin-
already paid ; that their taxes were les8,Jrciplcs,has for ages consecrated freedom. We
and that I ascribed this to the people being
more eaually represented in their legislature.
I may nave said 90, or I may not have said
so. My remembrance does not cany me.
Whether the fact was true, at that time, that
X Mfjok/e in the meeting, of two-thirds of their
national debt being p^d, and of their taxes
bein^less, I know not Certain it is, before
and unce^ I have oflen heard it to be so, in
^HTOfd and in writing ; but I will sav this to
jfoq, and I will say it to all Scotiand, that an
ci|taix«presentation of the people is the most
direct and salutary method to diminish and
|Miqr off the national debtj; to alleviate the
licight of Xku^ and to reiDove the clogs of
live, and we remember the glorious revolur
tion of 1688, which banished despotism, and
placed the family of Hanover uoon the throne.
We remember the Bill of Rignts ; nor shall
we forget one of its most sacred clauses,
which declared, established, and sanctioned
the unalienable claim of the citizen to peti-
|tion parliament. Now, as members of the
British constitution, acting under the Bill
of Rights, how should our conduct be shaped?
Do we complain of general grievances, such
as an unequal representation of the people?
It would be arro^nce in a part to speak the
language of the whole. Let those, then, who
feef n^st sensibly the pressure of this general
199]
33 GEORGE III.
Proceedings against Thomas Muir
[200
grievance, not presume to complain for the
nation, but consult the nation. And how
are they then to consult the nation, but by
bringing the people together in societies to
■deliberate and to resolve? Would you wish
the people to act unadvisedly? Would you
propose they should, cany petitions to the
doors of the House of Commons, without
Icnowing the real signification of Uie import
of these petitions ? Let us apply to our poli-
tical conduct a rule sure and unerring in pri-
vate life. — ^Think, deliberate before you act.
An unequal representation is a general griev-
ance.— Before we seek to obtain its redress,
let us inquire, in the first place, if it is gene-
rally felt ; and in the second, if redress is
generally wished for. In applying for a gene-
ral remedy, let us first be convinced of the
general disease. Without this, a few fiictious
may presume to speak for the nation, may
impose upon the weak, and may plunge the
many into inextricable confiision and misery.
The great proposition, then, which I main-
tained is, that the people should consult
together ; that they snould form themselves
into societies; for it is only by so doing that
thev can conduct themselves with wisdom,
and hope for success.
The Bill of Rights declared the unalien-
able, imprescriptible right of the people to
petition parliament, and if you condemn me
for advising the people to petition with re-
flection, with united and general deliberation,
for the redress of general grievances, ye
tear the record of our liberties, and scatter
the fragments where they never can be col-
lected.
In advising, then, even according to John-
stone's evidence, the people to inform them-
selves, reciprocally to communicate their
information, and then wisely and deliberately
to petition parliament, you do not condemn
me, but you trample upon their liberties, and
Tou proscribe the constitution. If I de-
cl^ea, at the meeting of Campsie, that the
people should adopt every mean to instruct
themselves with regard to their political
rights, I declare and I inculcate the same
now before you, and before this great
audience.
Hear farther what Mr. Johnstone says. I
have his words accurately in my notes. I
advised the society to get all tne political
pamphlets from a ncignbouring bookseller.
— ^Tne advice was a right advice. I did not
list myself under the nanners of faction. I
combated neither for ministry nor for opposi-
tion, for the ins nor for the outs ; I fought in
the cause of truth, and how is that cause to
he successful, but by general, complete, and
impartial information of the different argu-
ments advanced upon either side of the great
question of pariiamentary reform? Gentle-
men, remember who the witness is, who
"brings forward this important truth in my
favour. It is Alexander Johnstone, the first
witness adduced by the pEosecuior, against
whom I objected on account of the expres-
sions which he had used, indicating his in-
tention to ruin me, which, by respectable
witnesses, I ofiered instantly to prove, but
which proof was not allowed by the Court.
When tnis man speaks what is strongly in
my favour, you cannot suspect him ; nay,
more, what he has said aftbrds a clue to my
conduct. Fond of reading myself, purchasing
for information almost every new publication,
was it not natural and just for me to recom-
mend a similar line of conduct to men, who,
from their union, were enabled to defray the
expense ? If I had been the tool of party
and of factions ; if truth had not been my
object, I would have said to this society,
^ purchase not the books which are written
against parliamentary reform ; they are
merely the productions of pensioned hire-
lings; but read every treatise written in its
defence. — ^These are the productions of en-
lighted, and of philanthropic men, and they
are stamped by the signature of genius.'^
You will remember what the witness has
said upon the interrogatory of the solicitor-
generaJ, relative to what I mentioned con-
cerning tlie King, Lords, and Commons.
What was the reply of the witness? It was
this, that I said, the constitution ought to
consist of King, Lords, and Commons. Is
this vilifying the monarchy? Is this repre-
senting that part of the' government as ex-
pensive and cumbersome, as the indictment
sets forth ? Is this inflaming the minds of
the people, and exciting them to insurrection
and rebellion ?
This witness has likewise deponed to a re-
markable fact. I will state you his words
accurately : if I am in error, you will correct
me from your notes. ** In that meeting there
was mention made of Paine's Rights of Man,
but not by Mr. Muir. One man in tiie
society, not in a public manner, but to his
neighbour privately, said, that he had read
Paine's Works.** What was that to me?
And supposing I had overheard this man
use these wonis ; could I be blamed for
merely possessing the faculty of hearing?
Does Jonnstone say, that I participated m
this private conversation ? He says no such
thing. Does he swear that I recommended
Paine's Works, or introduced the mention
of them in the meeting? No. How then
is the other charge in the indictment sup-
ported by the testimonv of this witness, of
my advising the people to read seditious
books, and circulating such among them ?
Johnstone has told you, that most of those
who composed this meeting were weavers,
mostly young men from eighteen to twenW
years of age. What is the inference which
the lord ad\'ocate has deduced from this ? I
blush to mention it. — ^That people, in that
situation, and at that time of life, have no
right to interfere in public afimira ! People
in that situation! — ^What situation? Who
compose the great mass of. society? Who
aoi]
jtjif S&dii$on»
A. D. 179S.
[802
support the state? Who contribute to its
wealth? Who must fieht in its defence?
People at that period of life ! — What period ?
^hen the heart is uncorrupted; when the
soil is best prepared to recoTe eood seed, and
when the feelings of the mina can be most
easily led over to the side of virtue and
humanly. Because the msyority of the mem-
bers of that society mi^ht be weavers* they
must be held up in dension ! Because the
niijoi'i^y ^^ ^^m might be young men, they
must lie censured for presuming to interest
themselves in the happmess of that country
in which they were to spend their future
daysy and whose constitution was to operate
on tl^dr fliture lives ! But you have seen
several of the members of tmtt sodety, and
those too adduced bv the prosecutor (Mr.
Johnstone in the number), and did you think
them so young, so frivolous, and so ilUtaught
ms he represented ? This is a matter which
r^ards you, as you were tjie witnesses, and
you must judge for yourselves. Finalljr, bear
the conclusion of the deposition of this wit.
ness, which states, ** That I recommended
peace and regularity to the meeting, and ob-
served, that any tumult or disoraer would
Ttt'm their common cause ;*' and that I told
them, ^ there was no other mode of pn>-
curing redress, but by applying; to parlia-
ment;'' and that I recommended to them
^ to beware of admitting any immoral cha-
racters as members."
The next witness adduced for the prose-
cutor is Robert Weddeli, vice president of the
society at KifldntiUoch, who swears to the
particulars which occurred at the same meet-
ing, in which Uie preceding witness was pre-
sent ,
£Mr. Muir then read over his notes of thb
witness's deposition.]
In what respect doestnis witness criminate
me ? Does he not agree precisely with
Johnstone concerning my general conduct?
I am accused of vilifying the king and con-
stitution : — and what does this witness say ?
Tliat I made a speech, in which I advised
fegularity in their proceedings; and that
they ought to nroceed in a constitutional
manner, as the law now is, by King, Lords,
and Commons. The indictment alleges,
that I spoke, and reprobated the monarchical
branch of the constitution. But the witness
swears, that I said nothing about the expense
of the long, nor the comparative expense of
the Frerum constitution, nor the success of
their arms.'^Gefttiemen, I speak with can-
-dour; it- is not in my remembrance, that I
spoke concerning the comparative excellency
fk the French or British constitutions. You
hear one witness declaring, that I merely com-
pared them together ; you hear this witness
•dedaie, that I made no mention of either
-eodstitution ; both of them may have spoken
4ruth according to the impression which was
<^n theur min£, but they show you the dan-
ger of trusting to the meiaoiy of witnessee^
when it relates to words spoken in the
warmUi of a public discussion, and attempted
to be recollected af^r the lapse of many
months. But give whatsoever degree of
strength you choose to Johnstone's evidence,
dfaw from the comparison which I instituted
between the French and British constitutions,
an inference as highly criminal as you possi-
bly can ; the testimony of that man is com-
pletelv overthrown by this witness. Mr.
Weddell has stated to you what passed after
the meeting was over, in private company,
in the unginided hour, when the mind dreads
no danger, and when vigilance is asleq).
Can any thing prove more stsongly than the
deposiUon of mis man, the innocency of my
conduct? The conversation related to poli-
tics, and to new publications; and surely
materials of that kind are infinitely more
noble in their nature, than those which de-
form convivial society, and disgrace the man.
He remembers my speaking or Mr. Flower*s
book upon the French Constitution ; a book
which the lord advocate, although not speci-
fied in the libel, wished to insinuate as being
seditious, and consequently an aggravation of
in^ crime. Of the truly respectable author
of^this book I know nothing; but if from
writing, a true idea may be formed of the
heart which guides the nen, there is no man
that I would more fondly call my friend. It
is true, I recommended Mr. Flower there,
because I recommended his principles every
where. — ^I will do so still ; I will do so in
your presence, in the presence of the Court,
and to this great audience. You, who wish
for a reform in parliament, read and weigh
well the lessons which this good man has
g[iven and inculcated. — Let personal reforma-
tion precede public ; let the torch of know-
ledge lighten the path of liberty; but, above
all, let sound morality, and genuine Chris-
tianity be the goals irom which you com-
mence your political career. A people igno-
rant— never can enioy freedom ; a people im-
moral— are unwormy of the blessing.
The witness next mentions, that the only
book which I recommended to be pur-
chased, was Dr. Henry's History of Eng-
land. I am an enemy to the constitution,—-
and yet I recommended to the people the
book best calculated to instruct them in its
principles, and in its progress: a book ap*
plauded in private and m public by the earl
of Mansfield, and upon whose application. the
author received an honourable pension from
the king ; honourable to the granter, to the
receiver, and to him who first noticed the
modest merit of the writer.
The witness next proceeds to mention,
that at the meeting, a person of the name of
Boyd proposed, that Paine's Works should
be purchased and recommended. What was
my conduct upon the occasion ? I said, it was
foreign to their purpose ; and foreign, surely^
inde& it was. without approving of Mr.
Paine's principles, without condemnuxg them,
SOS]
SS GEORGE in.
Proceedings agabisi Jlkoniai Muir
[204
I shall afierwaids mon fully show you, that
the advice was such as became them and me
ia our situation at the time.
The witness mentions, that he purchased
lor the society three or four copies of the Po-
litical Progress. Does he say, that it was at
my desire, or on my recommendation ? No. —
That he purchasecT for his own use and that
of his neighbours, three or four copies of the
Paisley Declaration of Rights : that he got
a copy of Paine's pamphlet, but knows net
from whom : that he never saw the Dialogue
betwixt the Governors and the Governed,
one of the charges against me in the libel ;
and that a Mr. W illiam Muir showed him a
number of the Patriot. In the name of com-
mon sense, what connexion have I with this
extraneous matter? How does it tend to-
wards my crimination ? The witness swears
positively, that the only book which I recom-
mended to be purchased by the society, was
Henry's History of Britain.
The witness declared, that a more e<^ual
representation of the people was the oli^^t
of^the society. Being asked by the s<dicitor-
general, what he meant by a more equid re-
presentation, he stopt for a moment to con-
sider. O ! what matter of triumph was this !
Then burst the contemptuous sneer; and
then with affected ridicule was pointed out
the absurdity of men so ignorant, embarkixig
in the cause of reformation ; when even their
vice-president, the witness, who from his sta-
tion, if any had known, he should have been
the man. But by all, — excepting by Mr. Pitt
and the duke of Richmond, — who contended
for a reformation, no specific plan ha& yet
been proposed. In all that was said in the
late debate in the House of Commons, no
specific plan was brought forward. Is it
then a matter of surpnse that the witness
stopt for a moment to consider his answer to
the question ? His answer was such as did
honour to the coolness of his mind, and to
the soundness of his understanding. Two
opinions, replied he, divided the society. One
was for confining the right of election to
landed property ; the other for extending it to
the body of the people: that he, for his own
party had not yet made up his mind upon
either. Being asked my opinion, he swears,
I ^ve none.
The witness depones to my express lan-
guage, that I said to the meeting, that they
woiud be the more successful, the more tliey
were constitutional. Is Uiis preaehine up
sedition ? Is this infiammg the minds of the
multitude to rebellion ? With every witness
sulduced against me this day, this witness
.likewise corroborates my earnest advices to
the people^ to be regular, to be moderate, and
to be moral.
The next witness proposed to be adduced
aeainst me was, the rev. James Lapslie. My
objections to his admissibility were sustained,
before I advanced upon the threshold of my
j)ioof, by the lotd advocate's giving him up.
Sony am I indeed for the prosecutor^s timeljr
precaution ; proof was thickening fast against
this gentleman ; proof of practices, proof of
crimes, which but I go no farther;
the day will come, when this gentleman and
myselfshall exchange situations at this bar.
I trust that by your verdict I shall be ac-
quitted, and the moment after, I solemnly
pledge myself to this nation, to exhibit against
him a criminal accusation of the most serious
kind. To say more would not be risht, as
tending to excite a prejudice against him in
the day of his own trial. It is sufficient for
me, that, even in this stage of the business,
after the proof I was leading, my most ran-
corous enemy would have blushed to have
brought forward this man's testimony.
The next witness was, Henry f reeland,
president of the society at Ku-kintilloch.
The indictment charges me with having con-
vocated the societies at Campsie and at Kir-
kintilloch. The witness depones, that there
was an intention of having a society at Kir-
kintilloch, long before ever he saw me. Does
thb witness, the first president of that society,
who, if any man could, must have been well
informed of the circumstances leading to its
formation, support the charge in the libel ?
Quite the reverse. I shall postpone the most
material part of his deposition to the last. Ia
my speech, he mentions, that I spoke about
shortening the duration of parliaments and a
more equal representation : that I said, that
I thought taxes might be lessened by these
means, and that the reform was not to take
place as to the King and House of Lords, but
only of the Commons. Call you this sedi-
tion ? Does not every thing brought forward
by these witnesses of the crown, confute the
false, the injurious, and^the scandalous charge
in the libel, of vilifying the constitution and
of exciting the people to rebellion against the
king?
Mr. Freeland said, that I mentioned the
success of the French arms, and that liberty
would be established in France. Call you
this likewise a crime ? At the time when I
spoke, was it not true ? Were not the armies
of France in every part victorious ; and could
I, not possessed of the power of penetration
into the future, be sure that they were not to
accomplish their object? Are not opinions,
after all that has happened during the last
months, as much divided as they were then ?
Can you go into private or into public com-
pany, where this topic forms not the most
material part of their conversation? If
merely to speak upon this subject be sedition
you are all contaminated.
Mr. Freeland concurs with the other wit-
nesses in remembering, that I reccmimended
no other book to the meetins; than Heniy's
History. That I told them all riot would be
jruin to the cause; exhorted them to be con-
stitutional and regular, and told them, that
they were to petition parliament, and that
there was no otoer .way of getting » reform.
90S]
Jbf SftSMoiit
A.D. 1798.
[20G
I now come to the most material part of
Mr. Freeland's evidence, wluch relates to my
lending bim a co^ of Piune's Works. Now
let us take his CYidence in the connesdon of
time. He tells you, that, havine heard that
a proclamation was a^inst that Book, he was
upon that account curious to see it, and that
he first spoke of it to me ; that upon Tues-
diy, eight days before the society met, when
I luippened to be at Kirkintilloch, in the
boose of Wallace, to which I had sent for
him, that I bid him search in my great coat
pocket, and he would find the book ; but that
ne had before this time, for the reason which
he had mentioned, asked the loan of it irom
me. He farther tells you, that when he first
spoke of that book to me, I said I thought it
Imd a tendency to mislead the people ; that
he was surprised I did not recommend it, be-
cause every body else spoke well of it, and
that I did not approve otit.
This is Mr. Freeland*s deposition as to what
passed between him and me, when he re-
ceived Mr. Paine's Works. But his testimony
goes &rther, and corroborates that in which
all the witnesses are unanimous, concerning
what passed in the society when that book
was mentioned; of its being suggested by
one Boyd, to purchase it; but that I shook
mj head and said, it was foreign to the pur-
pose.
Gentlemen, this is the most material evi-
dence which the prosecutor has been able to
produce. A wide field is now before us, and
that I may deviate as little as possible from
precision, I shall arrange what I have to say
tinder distinct beads.
In the first place, the indictment charges
xne with feloniously and wickedly circulating
and distributing this book, in order to inflame
the minds of men against the constitution.
You are the judges ofthe law and of the fact.
Your decision will not separate them from
each other, but combine them both togeUier.
Is it necessary for me to inform you, that,
without a criminal intention, there can be no
crime? and has not the indictment itself set
Ibrth, that I did not circulate these books
merely, but that the circulation proceeded
from such intention ? Now, I ask you to lay
your hands upon your breasts and to say,
where, in the circumstances of this case, is
the shadow of felonious design \ The Works
of Mr. Paine had been published and sold
every viiiere. The papers of the day teemed
with successive advertisements, announcing
where they were to be procured. What ex-
cited this curiosity in the public mind, with-
out uttering a single syllable upon the intrin-
sic merit or demerit of these works, is easy to
tell. The situation of France roused the at-
tention of Europe. To that country every
e^e was turned, and evcrv man who could
wield a pen, was employed in discussing the
principles which the revolution had brought
ft>nrara. Mr. Burke entered the field of
contxoversy. The name of that gentleman
would give sale and diflbsion to any produc-
tion. Mr. Burke fought upon one side of
the question. He was encountered upon the
opposite by Thomas Paine. Both of them
champions of approved vigour, and of un-
doubted prowess. — ^Could public curiosity not
be awakened to the contention of such men f
It was so most completely : and the Works of
Mr. Burke and of Tnemas Paine flew with a
rapidity to every comer of the land, hitherto
unexampled in the history of political science.
Is there a sinele man among you, who has
not read the Works either of Paine or of
Burke? Is there a person upon the bench,
upon the juty, or in this audience, who has
not either purchased or lent the Treatise upon
the Rights of Man \ Now, if one of you lent
to a finend or relation, who might participate
in the common curiosity, a single pamphlet
of Mr. Paine'Sy you are as guil W as I am ; but
why should I use the term cuifty ? None of
us are guilty in lending that Dook, because we
harboured no evil design.
If there had been a public law of the king-
dom condemning that book, the presumption
of imorance could not be admitted by its
rigid rule : and the mere act of giving away a
single copy would have been considered as a
violation of its letter. But at the period when
I lent Mr. Freeland Paine's Works, was the
sentence of reprobation thundered against
them ? No. I then was guilty of offending
no existing law. I was not certified of my
danger. 1 was not put upon my guard.
Was there a judgment of an^ court in Eng-
land or in Scotland antinst this book at that
time? No. Then I had no cause for alarm.
But some months before, a proclamation
against seditious writings lusid been issued. A
proclamation, gentlemen, is not law. It can
declare and it can enforce what the law has
already enacted, but it has no le^slative au-
thority. But was there any mention of Mr,
Paine's Works in the proclamation? None.
What were tlie consequences of this procla^
mation? You know them well. Ir there
had been a demand before for political books^
that demand increased in a ten-fold propor-
tion. Concerning the particular books to
which the proclamation might be supposed
to allude, curiosity was more highly excited,
and conversation became more keenly inte-
rested. Now mark the circumstances in
which Mr. Freeland applied to me for the
loan of that book. Here, take notice of his
express words, " that having heard a procla-
mation ofthe king was issued against it, he
was, upon that account, curious to see it, and
first spoke of it to Mr. Muir." Now, I ask
you, if any thing like felonious intention in
Freeland can be discovered, in applying for it
to me? a proclamation had oeen issued
agunst seditious books, and a natural curiosij^
was excited in him to seewhat these books were,
which he had heard reported to be seditious ; a
curiosity which, at the time, was common to
all, I ask; if you could suppose there was a
807}
S3 GEORGE UI.
Proceedings agtiMt Thomas Muir
[S08
felooioufi iotention in my lending it? Did I
introduce the conversation by sf^aking of it?
Did I advise htm to read it, to adopt its prin-
ciples, and to contribute hia exertions to carry
them into practice ? No. He expressly tells
you, that I did not approve of the book; that
I said it had a tendency to mislead the peo-
ple; at which he was surprised, as it was
otherwise approved by all. To what then
reduces itself this mighty crime of sedition
for which I stand here ? To gratifV the na-
tural curiosity of a person who teus you he
lives in my neighbourhood, and is a distant
relation, I lent a book, which was in univer-
sal circulation, unnoticed by courts of justice,
imcondemned by law.
If you have come here this day with ap
intention to bring me in guilty, whether right
or wrong, say so boldly, openly, and let me
add, honestly. Resort not to wretched pre-
texts and expedients to justify a stretch of
power. These pretexts are soon seen through
oy the penetrating eye of mankind, and to the
guilt attending uie determination, will be
added the contempt which the pretext will
justify.
Gentlemen, in the second place, I would
direct your attention to what Mr. Paine's
writings are, and to the particular manner in
which they are presented in accusation in my
trial. I will allow that any writing which calls
upon the people to rise m arms, to resist the
law, and to subvert the constitution, is some-
thing worse than seditious, — that it is treason-
able; but do the writings of Mr. Paine stand
in that predicament ? Can you point me out a
single sentence where he provokes insurrec-
tion ? Mr. Paine's writings are indisputably of
a speculative nature. He investigates the first
principles of society ; he compares different
lorms of government together; and where
he gives the preference, ne assigns his rea-
sons for so doing.
I have neither time nor inclinaUon to en-
tertain you by dissertations upon the liberty
of the press. If that liberty is sicklv,^the
constitution is likewise diseased. If that li-
berty is extinguished, the constitution expires.
You will ask. What is the precise notion
which I affix to the term liberty of the press?
I will tell you honestly, and without disguise.
— By the liberty of the press, I mean not the
power of assassinating the reputation, of tor-
turing the feelings of individuals ; — no crime,
in my estimation, can be more heinous ; — by
the liberty of the press, I mean not the
power of de^ading, and of contaminating
the public mmd by corruption of public mo-
rals;— by the liberty of the press, I understand
not the power of inflaming the minds of men
against the constitution, of stimulating the
people to insurrection, and of tearing down
the barriers of public property, and ot public
security. Where government b established,
that government must be respected. And
the truest republic which ever vet existed,
never could tolerate the internal foe, who,
within its own precincts, sounded the charge
to civil war. — By the freedom of the press
I understaud the inalienable eight of
PUBLisui2iG tauth; of presenting to the
world whatever may tend to public good, and
may not hurt the feelings of individuals, mo-
rals, nor established laws.
Constitutions of government are the work-
manship of men; that constitution is the
most perfect, which can be most easily
amended. There are constitutions, wlucli,
step by step, without convulsion, and without
blood, have advanced to superior degrees of
perfection; which, by their own mternal
energy, have effected their own reformation^
and avoided the calamities of a revolution.
These progressive constitutions, if I may use
the expression, must always cherish and sup*
port the liberty of the press, as tlie chief in-
strument of their preservation. Look back,
I beseech you, to the ancient system in
France. To you the observation may be sin-
gular, but I am confident in my own mind it
is just. If, while the vestiges of their ancient
constitution still remained, while the remem-
brance of the States General was not yet
forgotten, the freedom of the press had not
been annihilated, their constitution would
have become progressive ; its reformation would
gradually have been operated, and by the
exertions of good men and of patriotic writers,
all the calamities which we now deplore in
the revolution would have been averted.
How grateful should we be to eternal Provi-
dence, that our constitution possesses in itself
the power of amendment; that, without a
revolution, it can rectify its abuses ; and that;
silentlv and without disorder, it Gt»- advance
towards that chastened liberty, which consti*
tutes human felicity. You have read the
history of the British constitution ; and what
is it, but the history of a continual progress \
You will next ask, what has been thfi hn-
pellmg cause of this progress ? I answer, the
right of the universal dinusion of information
by means of the liberty of the press. If you
destrojf that liberty, you accomplish one of
two things. — ^The people will be buried in ig-
norance : the iron throne of despotism wilf ,
be erected, and the silent I cannot, will
not contemplate the picture. If you destroy
the liberty of the press, you may perchance
do something else, which is horrible to think
progressive perfec-
tion. Evil will proceed to evil. What ori-
ginated solely from corrupted men, will be
imputed to the constitution itself. By un-
derminine its best prop, its most solid and
massy pillar, — ^I repeat it, and never shall
cease to repeat it, — the liberty of the press--^
you ex|K)se this holy fabric to a blow, whic&
shall shake it from its foundations. Let lu^
then apply this argument to the case of Mr..
Paine. This work is merely of a speculative
nature upon the principles of government*
900]
Jir Sedition.
IfMr. F^e'swofkis inconsistent with the
British constttutioD, what is the consequence?
If ibe book is written with ingenuity, it will
acquire readers. No man in his sound senses,
the keenest advocate for a parliamentary re-
fbraiy but will avert his eyes, bathed in tears,
and in horror of soul, from a revolution. He
will compare the principles of Mr. Paine with
the constitution. If Mr. Paine has pointed
out any thing defective in the constitution,
he will contribute his humble efforts to have
that defect repaired. If, upon the other hand,
he shall imagme, that Mr. Paine has taken
an erroneous view of this edifice, has misre-
presented its properties, he will become more
and more sensible, from his inquiry, of the
security which he enjoys under its protecting
roof. The sense of danger will be removed ;
and his mind, undisturbed by gloomy appre-
hensions, will enjoy tranquillity. O! now
little do ye deem the British constitution,
who think that it is built upon the sand,
which when the rain descendeth, and the
floods come, and the winds blow and beat
upon it, that it shall fall. No ;— when the
rains descend, when the floods come, when
the winds blow, it shall not fall, for it is
founded upon a rock. I then maintain, al-
though not in accents sweet to the ear of cor-
ruption, ^tefdl to courtly pride, nor accep-
table to lU-^t power, that those speculative
writers who mvestigate the principles of our
constitution, who compare that constitution
withthoseofother countries, perform a me-
ntorious service to this nation : these writers
either impel us to rectify that which is wrong.
or more strongly confirm us in our love ana
in our attachment to that which is right.
liSt Mr. Paine then be considered as the bit-
terest enenw to our constitution, yet as long
as he confines himself to speculation, we
should be grateful. Our best interests are
involved in the constitution, and like those
of a still higher class, superior to, time, and
which extend to eternity, are too apt to be
forgotten, and to make litUe impression. If
Mr. Paine then has called our attention to
the constitution, he has performed to us an
essential service, he has led us to contemplate
aU its perfection, and roused us from our le-
thal^ to rectify wherever, by time and by
oomiption, it may have suffered decay.
Shall the lending of a single copy of
the works of this writer be held crimmal ?
When was there ever such a violation
of the rights of Britons? Mr. Paine has
composed no model of a perfieict common-
wealth, as Mr. Hume has done ; yet the po-
litical works of Mr. Hume you have all read,
«dn1 you have all applauded. If you con-
demn a man for lending Mr. Paine's Works,
TOQ' do what even was not attempted to
be done in the reign of Hennr 8th, when the
constitution lay expiring on the rack of des-
potism, making exertions which only could
discover remainmg life, but at the same time
the privation of strength. Along with equa-
VQL. xxni.
A, D. 1793. [210
fity of political rights, has Mr. Pdne preached
equalil^ of property ? a chimera which may
enter into the bnuns of those, who may dream
of a golden age, but who know not human
nature. Yet, under that arbitrary reign, did '
not sir Thomas More, enjoying the conndence-
of the king, and placed at the head of the
law, publish his Utopia, the plan of his re-
public, of which an equal division of property,
an Agrarian law, an universal community,
formcSl the basis i In this enlightened age,
when, after so many fier^ trials, our constitu-
tion, in its pure and genuine principles, stands
unveiled to our view, will you condemn a
man for lending a work, equally speculative
and if such a thmg existed as a well-founded
panic against levellers, infinitely more dan-
gerous?
I should be the last man to propose to your
imitation, the conduct of despots ; but I call
upon you to ponder well the words of a man,
who rendered the terms republic and pure
and undefined despotism the same — Crom-
well. Under his protectorship, when Har-
rington published nis Oceana, informers de-
nounced the work. ^ My cause is too strong,'^
said Cromwell," to be hurt by paper-shot ;"'•
and if you say that by any publication, the
British constitution can be injured, you, your-
selves, are guilty of the crime of libelling ita
strength.
To conclude upon this head, I maintain,,
that to suppress works purely speculative,,
provoking not the people to disobedience to
the laws, nor to rebellion, however much
these works may differ from the constitution^
is to destroy the liberty of the press, to tram-
ple upon the best and surest bulwark, which
defends the approaches to that respected
building. If, to lend the works of Thomas
Paine to-day be sedition, to lend a translation
of the Republic of Plato to-morrow will be
treason. Gentlemen, the works of Mr*
Paine are lying before me. I could read to
you many passages to prove, that they ar&
merely of a speculative nature. You are ex-
hausted ; equally so am I. And yet, we have-
some length of field, before we conclude, to-
travel pier. For these passages I refer you
to the celebrated speech of Sir. £rskine,t
one of the best friends the constitution ever
knew, although of that reprobated cast, the*
Friends of the People. Gentiemen, I trust
that you will now be persuaded, that neither
the publishing nor the lending of a specula*
tive political book is sedition. But I now.
call your attention to another circumstance,
the manner in which criminality is attached
to that book and to nwself. ' Various detached
passages are quoited from it in the indictment.
They are cuied wicked, inflammatory, and
seditious. In the sacred name of justioe^ will
■■ - ■ ■ ■ 1 1 III .^^^^j^ I I ■■■■*■■ ■■■
* This is better told m lord Erskine's De-
fence of Paine, ant^. Vol. 29, p. 46^.
t See the eloquent argument in defence
of Paine, ant^^ Vol. 22;. p. 410.
P
SI I] 53 GEOE6E 111. Proceedings ugmmt Thomas Muir
cni
yoa condemn tnj book for dHaehed ftsHiges
iefiarsted from tbe whole contteiioa, cut off
from teciprocU ezpfanatioiiy aad finm wbidi
neitber its genefsd tenor nor toope ctn be
discovered? Ifyondotftiis^vlieiQisthelKiok
in whidi yoii cannot discover sedttionyl^ di*-
secting its separate sentences and pan^iaphs?
For my part, if you proceed on in this man-
ner, I do not know a more dattgerous collec-
tion than tbe books of holy inspfaration. Se*
parate verse from verse^ aAd then canbinB
them, according^ to your jdeasMre^ and ;^oti
mav make the bible one or the mostseditioiiB
and treasonable books which ever was writteii.
But you are neither to eondemn that book,
Aor me, for those detached passages exhibited
in the indictment. You must carry abo^
with you tbe whole works of Mr. Painty
you must scrutinize, line by line, and you
roust pronounce upon the general context.
If you find it provoLinft the people to resist^
ance, calling them forth to arms to subvert
the constitution, then, no doubt, it is sedi-
tious. But, if you find the author indulging
himself in nothing but philosophical and po-
litical speculation, however much your prin-
ciples and his may d^Eer, you cannot con-
demn him for composing it, or me, after it
was composed and publuhed, for lending it
toarektion.
If you condemn books for being seditious,
upon account of passages ^Ued from this
page and from that pagis, and artfully
combined together, you nave it in your
power to awaSd a proscription a^jsiost books
and universal literature. As I have already
sneationed, there is not a sinele book, in
which, by dissecting it in this manner,
aentence fay semtencey and passage by
aassace, you nuLj not discover immorality,
Waspnemj and treason. Indeed, if the pid
objects ofrefieotion whicfa present themselVea
to my mind, when I contcmoplate the state ^f
mf countiy, coUld permit Hie to indulge in %
vein of riaiciile» I would advise you at onee
In lay the axe lo the root of the tree, aad to
bring an indictment agpinst the alphabet it-
aelf, as it is the source of tbe evil vou dread,
•a its parts form the eompooent ewtoepts of
•eptenoes and of paragmpis, wbi0b may oon-
lain the most dangerous ec^itiony end the
aiost horrible treaeon. Bui ttue id not an
liour to indu||[e the epgft of humou?.
i wiM admit, th«t the pasM^ee from Mr.
Paine attdiha books exhibiied m the indict-
majr be highly ciimiDaJ, but will aqy
1 vBMtara to aaQKp Ihal I ImH tiies^ books,
oeataiBing oudh peHBi^s» tbst I per^icu-
lariy pointed them out, end gave them my
wannettappiobaAian? If the pfotemitor has
a richt to preaumc^ that k wae upon account
of these passages I lent these wntingfi, I too
have a right to draw a contrary presumption
in my fiurour. If there are sentiments in the
works of Mr. Paine (and many such there are)
fnuaghtwith universal benevolence, inculcate
ing universal amity and brotherhood^ and of
peraoo
ibr ceo
a tendency to diopelllioae fMskme md diose
prejiidiees, whkh animate end impel imtioii
against nation ialo the iieU of blood and of
carnage, I am entitled to pleed i^n these
peeaages: I have a right to 8ay» tibel it wae
the antidote, and not the poaon I reeeio*-
mended: and you must know, thet Hm law
of this country oblU^ you, where epaosing
Kesumptions are ofequal strength^ to let the
lance preponderate on the side of meecy.
Gentlemen, I shall conclude upoft the sub*
ject of Mr. P^e's Works by observing, that
all the witnesses have unifcrmly sworn, tluit
I refused to rceomaiend them; thai when the
matter was proposed, I said, the principles cwh
tained in them might mislead the people^ as
thev were foreign to the object of the society,
and ought misgmde week minds. There is not
a witness adduced by the prosecutor* who asgri
the contrary of this; and will you agree m
opinion, that the charge in my indictment of
circulating and recommending these book%
has the slightest shadow of support? I will
teU.you the reason why I did not recommend
Mr. Paine's books to tbe societies in Scotland^
and why I declared them foreign to their pur*
pose. — ^Mr. Paine is a republican, and the
spirit of republicanism breatbs through ^ his
writmgs. This is hie darling aystem. The
ol^fect of these aoeielies w«3, by conetili^
tionsd means, 4o proeqre a refwrnation in Ibe
constitution, afid not a sevolutKMv whieh imr
plled its destruction; to have th^ long k^t
rights vestoiedy but not the assumptbn of
new rights daived from a different weton^
The people of Scotland were rapidly ediveiicr
ing to a true sense of their ooostiUitionel Hf
berties: they demanded an appU^^tjon to
them of tbe constitution, in its genuine prk^
ciples, in which they beheld ^ir eet^tiri^
confirmed, and their huppinese eetabUshed.
That they might adva^ice with more erdOMr hs
this cause, it was necessaiv that they should
know tbe constitution; what it had heap im
its vigour, and what it now is in its decay, in
CDnse()uence of ^e corruption of men and
of ages. What did I do to effoclMata thi^ W*
gal and peaceable ol;ti^t? I did not preseat
to them the splendid fabrics of aneieni or 44
modem republics; I wished them to k^
their eyes confined at home, to repair tjb«tr
own mansion rather than puQ it dowq, and
expose themselvea to the inooiwenienpes and
to the dangers of building upon new plans,th/p
advantages or disadvantage of whtch eouM
be only known by the uncertaks eapetif n^e
of future ages. All tbe iritnessee who speak
of my conduct in the societies tell you. ti&at I
recommended none but coostitutionfll mea^
sures; and that the only book whipb I r^
commended to them, was Hennr's HiMoiy of
England, as the best ealouktedf by its a^oiv
racy and plainness, to give tbem in9ig;bl ip0
the nature and progress of their ooo»tifti^!i.
If, in my library, in conveisation upoii tba
subject of government, the nlsjn adoptiad by
different politkal writers baa been diimiaed.
tlQ
J^H Qg^^MM-
4.D. I»S^
L9»
Av«ft% Ami tkote wUi^X<)oiBid6rad it my
&ior to«ltiMei nben aodng undir ma et*
tabliahfd oonstitutioD, and empk^jrafl ia those
naamammkkk it pouttadvut, to effectuate
m TidraBS of niewiceB. When Mr. Hume
fMUbei his matmy upon a Perfect Common-
wtaHk, did act he, aa ttraogly as he posaibl j
imddf dadaie that he tfaoi^t this model
pemdde to the BiritiBh sonstitutioiiy even
m its yurpit and best principles? But sup-
ywttg Mr. Hume to have been a meaaber
«f the SodeQr 9f the Friends of the People^
what woiiM have been his conduct in itf
Woodd he have said lo men who were as-
sembled to lenoivate constitatiooal rights
MiVy you most^ve up the constitution en-
tirely; it is defective and imperfect when
comimred to the o&pring of my ^cy; it
la tbb last which you must adopt, and re-
ject die foimer ? ^t Mr. Hume would have
neld forth no audi lan{;uage; he would have
flnjd to them, ** The snevances of which you
CMBpiaiBy can be redressed by the ener|nr of
oar own oonsUtution; the redress of these
grievances is the only object of your assod-
aiion. If then reformation is your object,
and not revolution, however much you may
mpfnv¥€ of my speculative system, it must
not operate upon you for a moment in
it was upon this prind^e that I sefiisad to
fewammnntt ifas works of Mr. Paioe; tliati
anid, *^at they were Ibreigp to tiie purpose,
said nnffatmiedead weak minds. But was it
Jew bobre hekl criminal in an aMthor, to
paUisfa what specuhttive ^sterns of goveni-
SMttt be pleaseo, provided he confined him-
adfin the retirement of specuhttion. and did
not advance fi»^ to the field of action?
Was it a crime cf Plato, under the Athenian
wyafalir, to compose his beautiful srjrstem of
one more perfectP Was it high treason in
CieeiOy uoder the Boman Commonwealth^
to write thoae applauded works, which have
been ioat in the darkness of the gothic nicht,
and of which a fiew fra^ents only coula be
fbundy when the mommg of letters began to
dawn noon Europe P Was sir Thomas More
led fiBTtn to the scafibld for composing his
UUHNa» Hatrineton proscribed for his Omna,
or Hnnie exifid tor his Commonwealth f
These anthors indulged themselves in a li-
berty, which if we now are to be deprived
s^ we most be lef^ hopeless and in despair,
as the attempt at amendment and refbrma-
tkia win be for ever preduded.
Open the prindple which I have explained,
I afanoM hftve thought it equally, if not more
dai^geroas and inexpedient, to nave recom-
msMcd in a sodety of tiie Friends of the
People, Fbto's Republic, or Hume's Com-
BOiiwsahh. Inexpedient! because these
wrilngs mi^ have had a tsnden^ to lead
these sodeties from thdr constitutional ob-
jects danaeraissl because, if presented to
^reak taiBBrtlandingSi and tt> ftrvid imagi-
t
ludiaDS, they ^hlbsvomfluentodttkemto
depart from those ends, which, by calmness^
perseveiance, and legal measures^ th^ were
sure at last tonocomplish, in pursiut of chi-
meras, briiliant but delusive^ always secn»-
ingly approaching, but always in mJity fly-
ing farther away .
Gentlemen, 1 conclude my obaervationa
upontheaulgectofMr.Paine's Works. You
will remember it was only a aingk copy
which I lent; the drcumstances attending
i^ which, admitting the book to be as se-
ditious and as treasonable as can be imagin-
ed, preduded the idea of a felonious drcula-
tion. You are the first jury in Seotiand,
before whom Mr. Paine was either directly
or indiiectlv brought; I trusty that 50U wiH
act in such a manner as to do honour to
youisdves, in doing justice to him aad lo
me ; that }rou will not attempt to annihilate
political science, fagr oondemning a work in
Its nature purdy speculative; that, uei this
country, wnere our chief glory has arisen
from literature, vou wOi not lunit her re-
searches, but inoulge bar in her unbounded
flight, into everf region where the materials
of^human happinsss and human improve-
ment can be collected. Above all, I entreait
you, that you would not set the dangerous
precedent of condemning a book, for sen-
tences detached firaon the whole, when yo«
do not consider the general tenor and toope.
I tell you that if you do not carry awqr tnb
book from your table to your chamber, read
every line, and compare the whole in ooiw
nexion, you do me most flagrant injustice.
Finally, I must tell you, that you are not
bound by what any ^ury has done in Ens-
land — ^you are bound by the law of Scptlana ;
aod this is the first trial of the kind which
ever occurred here:— even the decisions in
England have lost the respect due to them,
altnouf^ th^ were to be held out as prece-
dents. We have seen juries one day cod«>
demninff the author aod the publishers, and
upon «£e succeeding day, we have heard
other juries pronounce a verdict tffaoquitlal.*
The next witness is Anne Fisher, a Mte ser-
vant in my fikther'e house. Her evidence
comes forward to yeu with peculiar distinc-
tion; caressed by the prossoutor, and com-
plimented by the Court; — her wonderful ao*
curacv extolled, and her abilities admired.
I will soon show you, gentlemen, that she
has but few pretensions to that eocura^, i>f
* See the trials of Thomas Paine, of Daniel
Isaac Eaton, and of Daniel Holt, aa/^, Vol.
SS. For publishing Paine's writings, many
other persons were prosecuted and brought
to trial, whose cases I have omitted, not hav-
ing met with any report of them worth pre-
serving. Some account of the contradictory
verdicts returned on these occasions, will bo
found in Daniel Holt's Vindication of the
Conduct and Princij^es of the Printer of tiie
Kewaric Herald, pp. 90, 8i«
1
815]
S3 GEOROfi m.
Proceedingt i^oitut Thonuu Muir
t9I6
which the lord advocate spoke in siich terms;
—that her memory possesses a singular qua-
lity, retentive to whatever may militate agamst
me, but hesitating and confused to whatever
may seem in my favour. What this domes-
tic and well- instructed spy has given in evi-
dence against roe, fills my mind with little
concern ; on the contrary, it affords me much
satisfaction to find, that when I was sur-
rounded in the place where I expected most
security, — ^where all, suspicion was lulled
asleep, my conduct was so guarded
What do I say? — Guarded ! Innocence has no
need to be on the watch ;--My conduct has
been such, as even malice itself cannot con-
demn. But before I proceed to read her evi-
dence from my notes, let me solemnly cau*
<tion you against the dangerous precedent of
giving credibility to witnesses of this kind,
under accusations of this nature. The crime
of sedition, if you attend to its essence, never
can be committed within the walls of a pri*
vate house. It supposes the highest puoli-
city, the convocation of many. But if power
'shall say, that words spoken m an imguarded
moment within the sacred walls of a family,
amount to this crime, what will follow ? Not
those with whom you may have acted in
your political life, and who, vnth the impres-
sion of the oath of God upon them, can best
tell the truth; not those whom you may have
Emitted to your friendship, and to your con-
fidence, and who best know the secrets of
your soul ; but the meanest of your domes*
tics, who could hardly approach your pre-
sence even in their menial duties, who (if
the expression may be used) to the members
of a family are almost unknown; — These!
These! Tlie meanest and the lowest — ^will
be brought forward to swear away your pro-
perty, your reputation, and your life: and
such is this witness, who is aclduced against
me with such parade. O! beware how ye
sanctify the shameful proceeding. It is not
me you wound alone, but you destroy the
confidence which subsists between man aiMl
man; you lead, by ^our own hands, to the
fire-sides of your children and your dearest
relations, the fiends of suspicion and of dan-
ger; and ye for ever put an end to that reci-
procity of communication, which enlivens
and endears domestic society.
Now let us hear what Uiis witness has to
say ? I will read you from my notes her evi-
dence. If I have erred in taking it down,
you will please to correct me.
[Here Mr. Muir read from his notes, the
evidence of Anne Fisher.]
The testimony of this witness seems to
relate to two of the principal charges in the
indictment; the first, to my havme made
speeches in pubhc societies, vilifying the king
and constitution. The second, to my having
distributed and recommended seditious books,
viz. Mr. Paine, the Patriot, the Paisley Decla-
raUon, and the Dialogue between the Gover-
nors and the Governed. Under these two
different articles, let us examine the testimony
of this witness.— First, to my makingc sedi-
tious speeches ; Secondly, To my circulating
seditious books.
Every thing which the prosecutCMr could
adduce si^inst me, he has told you that he
would adduce under the generality of the
term sedition, even although it should not be
specified in the libel. The Court likewise baa
permitted him so to do ; and in the case of
this witness, you can see an exemplary illus-
tration of this right, if it can be so called.
Accused of makmg seditious harangues in
public, this wretched girl is adduced to swear
to what she says, she may have heard in
private, when instructed to take her watch^
she stood and marked to destruction those
who fed her.
And what is the dreadful language she has
heard me use in my unguarded moments ? I
will repeat all that she says, I will recall to
your remembrance her express words, and
upon them I will make no comment. ^ That
if^ every body had a vote, I would be made
member for Calder ; ^that members of parlia^
ment would have thirty or forty shillings
a-day, and that, in that case, there would be
none but honest men to keep the constitutioa
clear." You remember how the public pro-
secutor enlarged and expatiated upon these
words of this witness. Now, afler labouring
so long in vain, he fancied he had got some*
thing against me. I smiled at the mdecency
of his exultation ; but next moment I blushed
when I reflected he was a lawyer, and chief
counsel in Scotland for the crown. ** Here,'^
said the prosecutor, ** you see the cloven foot.
— You see French principles manifested.
Here you discover the whole tincture of his
soul. Members of parliament to have thirty
or forty shillings a dav for their attendance. —
to be honest men, and to keep the constitu-
tion clear! Is not this evidence, that he
means to introduce in place of our House of
Commons a National Convention, on French
principles, and according to French forms ?"
Sonv am I to record the ignorance of this
lord advocate of Scotland. Is there a man
who has hardly opened the volume of the
history of our constitution, who does not
know, that until a very late period indeed,
when corruption glided in, and tainted and
poisoned the whole, members of parliament
received their wages from the hands of the
feople alone ? O ! now I speak it with joy when
view the past : with sorrow, when I contem-
plate the present ; thev would have scorned
to have received the price of their attendance
from any other hands, than from the handa
of the people. Then the constitution pos-
sessed all its energies. Then towered the
constitution in the strength of manhood, but
with the bloom of youth. The people dele-
gated none but men whose virtues thev knew,
and none but men who possessed public vir-
tues could be found to undertake the impor-
tant mission. Look back, I entreat youi to
2in
^fiif StditwHtr
A. D. 179S.
[218
all the g|reat.iod cood'tten whom Eogliah
history recoids. Turn your eyes to the
fiampdeBs^ to the Sidneys, to the Marvels of
former times ; to those men whom but I
stop; they received their wases directly
fit>m the people. Let the lord advocate pro-
nounce their eulogium by his invective. If
what i have said be sedition, when overheard
by that spy Fisher, I shall next moment
render myself infinitely more criminal ; for I
declare to yoU| that vre never can expect a
virtuous House of Commons, a constitutional
House of Commons, a House of Commons
such as it once was, connected with no other
interest than the interest of the people, until
such time as its members shall receive a
oomoensation for their attendance from the
peo^, and from no other quarter, be entitled
to no other reward than the approbation of
their own minds, and the applauses of their
fellow-citizensL of whose rignts, and of whose
liberties they have been the undaunted, un-
conunted defenders.
Fisner proceeds to state, that she has heard
me say, that France was the roost fiourishine
nation in the world, as they had abolishea
tyranny, and got a free government : and that
farther, she has heard me say, that the coosti-
tution of this country was very good ; but
that many abuses.had crept in, which required
a thorough reform.
Gentlemen, even in my most unjguarded
hours, this domestic spy cannot, by her evi-
dence, support a tittle of the indictment,
vrhere it cnar^ me with vilifying the king
and constitution.
Of her idle story of what I said concerning
courts of justice, that they needed a reform,
and that this court in particular got their
money for nothing, but pronouncing sentence
of death upon poor creatures, and that their
paiade in coming into Glasgow was useless,
I disdain to take notice. Only, you will dis-
cover her exquisite art. This day, I am tried
before this very Court, and she supposes, that
by inventing and throwing in a circumstance
of this kind, in order to irritate the judges
i^ainst me, she will more completely execute
the wretched job she has undertaken to
perform. Were there not more servants in
the house, who had infinitely better opportu-
nities to hear my conversation ; and must she,
the lowest of them all, with whom she cannot
pretend I had ever two minutes conversation,
be singled out, and pitched upon for this
drudgery ?
This witness depones, that she heard me
say, a republican form of government was the
best, but a monarchical form of government,
under proper restrictions, would be the best
in this country. With all her art, and with
all her memory^ she cannot depone to a
sin^ circumstance which can strike aeainst
me. £ven from her own account of my
private conversation, it appears, that when I
spoke of republican forms of government, it
was purely m the abstract; without any allu-
Non to this eountr^r, without expressing an^
wish to see any particular mode of them intro*-
duoed ; and tlut when I spoke of this oountiy,
I never deviated from me constitution, but
said that a limited monarchy under restric-
tions, was the best adapted to its interest.
The next article of sedition to which she
depones, is of the most extraordinary kind,
that I had sent her to employ an organist in
the streets of Glasgow, to play the French
tune of ftf ira. What was a tune, unintelli-
gible to the multitude, to light up the fiames
of civil discord, and to be the forerunner of
the revolution? Have you read the words of
that popular song ? Could you discover a sin-
Sle allusion in them to the state of England?
iut supposhig you did, there is a presumption
from your station in life, that you are ac-
quainted with the French language ; but is it
so with the multitude of our weavers in that
quarter of the country? Britain has aJways
cherished freedom, and shall it be deemed
criminal in me, to listen to the efiusions of
joy poured out by a neighbouring people, on
obtaming that first of human blessings, which
always constituted our peculiar distinction?
But I know it well. The word " freedom '' is
soon to be proscribed from our language ; it
carries alarm and sedition in the sound. If I
had caused to be recited one of those noble
choruses of the Grecian drama, in which, with
the enthusiasm of liberty, the glories of Uie
republics of Athens or of Sparta were dis-
played, in language more than mortal, my
offence would have been deemed the same
with that of amusing myself, bv hearing the
national song of France. If it nad been pos-
sible for me to have caused to be sung, upon
the streets of Glasgow, one of the psalms of
the Hebrews, in the original language, in
which the triumphs of the people and the
destruction of tyrants are recorded in a strain
of the highest poetical inspiration, the crimi-
nality would have been the same with that of
listening to ga ira.
Let me abandon the subject My poli-
tical career has neither been obscure nor
inglorious. It has undergone the severest
scrutiny which ever fell to the lot of man;
and after every engine has been employed,
after heaven and earth have been moved, the
tremendous charge of sedition is to be sup-
ported by the testimonies of domestic spies,
swearing, not to my serious occupation, but to
the amusement of an idle hour, in listening to
a foreign tune.
Let us next attend to the evidence of Fisher,
as far as it relates to seditious publications.
She swears that I used to recommend to a
Seat many country people who came to my
Iher's shop, to purchase and to read the
Works of Mr. Paine, as they composed a very
good book. How can you believe the general
averment ? In the number of country peoples
she can only specify one, John Barclay ; and
when you come to his evidence you will see
that he gives her the flattest contradiction.
8^
83 GEOKOR III.
Proceedbigi t^ldmi SB^of Mmr
{m
She de|x>D<^ IhM A» has Uw»>il, «t »#o dif*
ferent trnte^ ix «qr tede AfaxuMkr Mtiv^
at my ilesirei a eopy of the first paiti vni a
co^y ^the wcond fiiit of the Rights «f Man.
Can you suppose^ that if tt^r^oMentiotisliad
been felontous, I v»M hvft intranhicsd siidi
writines mto mv dim fsnily f Cda you iaoa-
S'ne that I tould htte wished to involve, in
lecimflagration <of my countiy, my nearest
rebtiohs lb nvfacise property I miy eventually
succeed f Why is not Alexander Muir broittiht
forwsnrd as a witness? Ceitain it iS| that be
was closely intetrogatotly befote the inqoisi-
lion held hy Mr. Steiff Honeymaa. But the
lord advocate says, that his feelings would not
perasit him to examine the uncle asainst the
nephew. Wondetial humanity ! Goodness
ever to be temembered and extolled ! But did
not youy Sir, advise «id direct the whole pro-
ceedings against me ; and will you have the
effrontery to maintain that Alexander Muir
was not dragged like a felon from his own
home, by the mvrmidons of power, carried
before your friena Honejman. and that every
art was employed tu wring from him every
domestic secret ?
Speak then to us of your htmianity-Mwnti-
Hue to speak to us of yoiu* feelings !
Fisher next depones, that I much pressed
John Muir to purchase Palne*s Works, that he
was prevailed upon, and that she was sent ac*
cordmgly to purchase them. Now you will
hear the evidence of this man immediately, in
express iootttmdiction to this witness. She
next tells you, that I advised another domestic,
Wilson, mv hair dresser, to purchase Paine's
Works, and keep them in his shop, in order to
enli^ten the people, and vou will hearWil-
son mimediately express himself kx other-
wise. She spwcs of ttefrymg some palter,
wMch she thinks was n DeclanSion of Rignts,
to a iitiriling office %o be coiteoted. £very
thinfr iti her evidence is made to tally with
the Ihdietm^nt ; I am accused of cveulating
a paper, intituled a Declaration of Kights hy
theTriends of Reform in Paisley. Axtd Ais
respectable personage! so hiehly eompli-
meuied by the Court, most nxevnee swear
something concerning this. Yet her tenacious
memoi;v utterly ikils her. She thfa^s she
atA only remember what the title was, but
nothing more. She knows nothing of the
substance of the writing; but her evidence is
to |ive a colour to the allegation of my having
eiittilated that paper from Paisley, and to
fnmish^ground for insinuating, thait-»I my-
eeAf was the author of it
^ntlennta, the witness next swears to a
Ihet %faich must rouse, as having domestics
JoUr^H^es. your keenest indijpiation. Tigi-
iatit hasr tms &mily spy been m the course of
herdut<^. She tells you what books she has
seen Iving upon my table. Not contented
•with describing the title of the books, she
tnust go more oeeply ; and she informs ^ou,
^mt she saw, in my house, a copy of I^une's
^writings upon fine paper, and one or two !
oophs upmi momemi Oiailismiiii, Itom ttm
aoMnMftit, lock op your libraries* If tkigr are
axttBsi««,as yea hate iMari mine k^lhmia
ho crime sa the whole catalogiie, of wfaiph^
by the teftimony of yoar wwn servants, ymi
may mit be found ^mf. The possessioii of
Pkto. of Haniagtoii. or of Hiime^ win nunk
you down for Topnhucana. The misibrtmie
of havteg the Akomn of Mmhomet will eanse
the shipwreck of yoor fidtfa, and sS^imatiae
J ou as the disciples of Ae conqueror of
leooa. Well do I eonmtidate the kid ad^
vocate of Seetlaad;— He nas dieoovered a new
region in the sphere of criminality .--tie will
toot merely confine himself to a ^yage of dia-
eovety; but,alongwitfahisassoGiales,hewill
amke many voyages to this fertile land, and
reftom home loaded with many vataablo oar*
goes. But seriousness becomes this place.
Can it be believed, that in the dose of die
eighteenth eentury, that this tustat the ser-
vants of a man should be esaminedooiioeminig
what particular books he may tern had in lus
house ; and that the pix)of %a the possession
of particular books may rum his reputatioD;
sweep away his property; and depnv« him
of his life?
Let us proceed with this wimess. If you
possess the common feelings of mte, eveiy
sentiment of indignation must be excited, not
against her^she is to be pitied— 4ier task haa
been a dreadful one ; — but a^unst the manner
in which this crime of sedition has been a^
tempted to be proved.
Tne libel charges me with feloniously ciiw
culating a Dialogue betwixt the Govermus
and the Governed extracted from the Ruins
of Volney. This dialoffoe is narrated in the
indictment, and it is oiarged to be felonious
and seditious. There is not a word in this
diabgiie which is not true. Alas! in colours
but too faithAil, it deUneates the mouinfal
histonr of 0>000 years ; — the crimes of despots,
and the artifices of impostors, to subjugate^
and to blind the peopfe. It is purely ah-
Btracted. It is entirely speculative. To no
particular nation, much less to England, does
tt allude ; if to any, it most be to Fmnc^
tmder the aneient system. Yet, this dial<Mnie
is libelled as seditious and infiammatoiy. The
truth is, the crime of sedition must be brought
home against me ; and the tnssession of
any book, as well as that of Volney, must be
employed to sttbstantiale it. Let us hear what
the witness wys concerning the fekmkus cir«
culation. She heard me read it in tiie pie*
sence of my mother, shMr, and some other
people ; that I said it was very dever, and
done by Vehiew, one of the first wits in
Prance. Who were those other people who
were in company with my mother and sister
when I read it? Her aoeoracy, so much ee.
toUed by the Court, totally f«&htr. But the
propagation iif sedition must notte oonfined
to a mother and a sister; it most here e wider
range ;-'-o1her people "presettt! and foundii^
upon his beloved geameltty, the proseontor
9»ri
Jia^SediHun.
A. p. n93.
m$
kt» niM«tf li^ aifut^ iWit might 1utv0 twi «
full ^omftta^, a nwnerpiM loaeiiag^-^HMiyy--*
m uwiMiiM oQiigrogftti«ii«
Yon ivne hmii liw t««|iMMi^ U Fishes
and thtM avt th« ttrts, Md of thi* class aia
the witaat^nn^ b^r vkiek I am %» C^U. Qy va*
cem^f weli tas|iaiooy» yoa for avev mttiaQr
domaatie miety, aod yaii bkAi Uie bloaaoMt
of teuly aomeiieei ; yctt leodor all aua<
picisiia af aU ; aach retalio^ %9 baMd ia
aachy a tei^ foe*--nADd ia ii aol tiittfiiml
la veap af tr fHihlk calamttia^ Ituit ifwlo*
spceading jctolatioa, wbicl^ al prastn^ pasaes
Qwtr iliaoaiimi; Wat whvi wa mtir^ la aur
own booMa, wa mm be obliged lo eoafoe
ottnelvQS IB adisvMdM^iludey gmiidedbf M10-
fNciDa imd by daager, wbeie na iModi^ affec^
tamsciii cater, and wberenoieaipiooaleaa^
eeiatiaa 4aii ba advviited ?
I beeten over tbe evidence of tba reaiatii-
ing wjtaeeeee njnimt me. I am aveveoma b^
tba asiKtiope of Uu» d^; mod ya« r9m% be
greatly aahewntted.
The aaat i« tba avidaaoB of Tbooias Wileea^
my hair-^ditaMr, aad be is )>raui^t to bring
yp tbe rair af Fisher's testupooy. He de»
pooaBi that I asM him if be bed bov^
vuim^n Woiki, aa4 thst I edvisad him to. geit
a espy of tbeai» asabarber's shoa waa a gaed
l^Iacelo laiMiia. Does tbi^ coo&i^ the tes-
timopy of fishery who says, I dasiied him to
Sr thai work, aod to keep it in bis shop^ ift
er to exdif^fclan the people? Mark tba art
of Fisbar. Hair stroagly she paiots urbat
autfhl M0in ^ strike aminst me— to em*
lig^Mao the people ! But does WiUoa e^mf^ur
lu lb Ja ? No. WilsQii— tbe person who should
hams best roDsmabered-^toe pecsoa to whom
-tte fsofda veia addiessedj-^Wilson tells yeu»
thai he boagltf a copy of the Addi«ss to tbe
Addresaers ; bat ^t was not by my adyice.
He even Taeolfects the levity of fionversatiom
An old man, from the country, came in while
he vraa dreesiM me; he remembers me say*
in& that this old anao was a great reformer.
VTaw eaid aa^ :I wish it may not have beea
in jest, but in earnest ; aad that the fact, with
i9ffgd ta tba mao» was true. For I know of
aana wha should be greater refivmers of
thansseWes and of others, than those who are
fHaiMttng oa the brink of the grave, and
paotiog upon alemitv. But I am afnud thai
this wttiMas remembers onlv a piece of un-
nMeaiiig gaiety. Foe he adds, the old mm
aaid I waa onlijr tani^g him.
The oondusion of the evidence of Wilson
90bfda ma high consolation. It is a proof of
the ioaeoaaoy of my private life, in momenta
when I eoula not possibly think of the alFe^*
tatkm of integrity. He swears, that he has
always Ivard me say, that X would main-*
tain the cwatiUilioq, and that I wished for
paMM^ and good Older, and good morals among
the paaple ; mtd that he never heard me
speak a^unat the king.
Tbe next taatimoiiy is that of John Muir.
Be tells yau» thai be had a convermtion with
m? in September last, abeqt Paiae^s book, in
my daher's house ; that he asked the lea^ of
it fsam me; that I toU him I had it not.
D«sa lias vesembla the conduct of a maa ao-
cuaed af disuihutiiag these books to all and
sundry^ aad scattenng t}>em ov^r avecy por-
tion of the land ? He, says^ I mentioned that
I apeuld send a servant who woukl get it for
him V that a aswant girl ^i^Doordingly went and
gal it; .Does ihot this completely caaAite th?
testimaay of Fisher, who aArms, that I much
piessed Um maa to purchase that bookP and
he tells you, that he himself a^ed the Ipaa
♦fit
Is not this a eomplete contmdktioo of her
testimony?
The next witness is John Biarolayy that
oUaiid venerable persm^ whom you mw adr
dMced aa a witness by the prosecutor; aod
what does he say in his testimanw } That wa
were eklers in tl^ same parish— the paiHsh of
Gaidar, in which the lands of my fathei afe
situated. He informs y€si» that at tfae last
elaetiDn of a mAoisier for that pariah^ a disr
IMXte had arisea coaoecrnqg th? right af elec-
tion, and thai he voted upon the sam^side
af the qaestioa with my^^lf* This inlrodu«94
ac^^ntaoce> and acquaiataaca pioduced
fiiendsbipu The k>iFd advocate^ ia speakiag of
this virtuous aod venerahlo old maa* exclaimed
with insolept ^ontemp^ 9uch man. 93 these
are the companiops,, and such men as these
are the friend3. of Mr, Muir ] Yes, I tell the
lord advocate, I t^U tha aristocracy of Scot-
land, I gloiy ipore in the friendship of such an
oUy foor, and virtuous maa^ tnaQ. la tba
frienashitf of the bigbest-tiitled peer, who de*
rives the source of bis guilty grandeur from
the calamities of the people ; who wrings out
a splendidi but a misier^bie reveuue from their
sorrow ami distress, from their tears and
from ^l^ir blood) which ha squanders in djs^
Satioa, to the ruin of private virtue^ and tA
[ie contandnation ot'pubhc morals.
Let us see then what Mr, Qiarclay says
against me* That he askad my opinion con-
cerning Paine*fi books^ and that I told him h^
might purchase them if he choscu as they
were pnnted ; hut that I afterwards said, it
wi^ not a book for uSy IXoes Mr. Barclay^
evidence support the criminal charge in the
Ubel, of my advising people to read seditious
books, and of my circulating them over the
country? Does not Mr. Barclay^s evidenca
corrobon^te the testimony of every other wiu
ness ? That for the reasons which I fully ex.-
plained} I nev6r recommended Mr. Faine's
Works ; but that even when that worl^ ex-
cited the peatest attention of the country ;
when mention of it was introduced into every
company, and into everv conversation, I uni-
formly expressed myself that it was not a
book for o^r purpose ;-^(or our purpose, who
wero engaged in the cause of a parliamentary
and constitutional reform I Is there a single
witness brought forward by the prosecutor,
who hasy in the smallest degree^ stated aoy^
^
S23]
S3 GEORGE III.
Proceeding* against T%<mai Muir
[m
conversation of mine which was unconstitu-
tional? Hear what Mr. Barclay says; — ^that
h^ was frequently with Mr. Muir, and in his
library, from which he borrowed some books;
that he had many conversations with him,
and heard him say, that the constitution of
this country was an excellent one ; that he
praised the king ; and that he always spoke
of order, regularity, and obedience to the
ruling powers. In short, gentlemen, all and
each ot the witnesses for the prosecutor use
the ~same uniform language, attest that,
neither in public nor in private, ever a single
expression dropped from me, which the most
violent asaociator could construe into guilt.
The last witness of whom I shall take no-
tice, 18 William Muir; the person whose
religious principles at first induced him rather
to suffer, according to the elegant expression
of the lord advocate, eternal imprisonment
than to take the oath, until his scruples were
removed by the rev. Mr. Dunn. He swears,
that in my father's house, at Huntershill, I
gave him eleven numbers of the Patriot,
and a copy of the Political Progress. From
these numbers of the Patriot, several passages
are quoted in the indictment. Of the Political
Progress, there is no mention made ; and I
maintain, that every passage in the Patriot,
quoted in the libel, is highly constitutional.
The sentiments advanced m them, may not
sound musically sweet to the ears of corrup-
tion. They call upon you to arise and vin-
dicate the purity of your constitution; to
vindicate your long-lost rights; and, if my
feeble voice could extend to the remotest cor-
ners of Scotland, I should resound the same
sentunent, in the same language. These
nunibers of the Patriot, speaK to you con-
cerning septennial parliaments. And I say
to you, that the act which converted triennial
parliaments into septennial, violated our holy
constitution, tore the charter of our national
liberties, and paved the way for the inroads
of a frightful despotism.
But this witness concurs with all the pre-
ceding witnesses, with regard to my conduct
and to my principles. He swears, That he
does not remember to have heard me speak
against government; that I did not advise
unconstitutional measures; and that he heard
me tell how Old Sarum was represented. Old
Sarum represented ! And, do not the friends
of the constitution weep, and do not the
enemies of the constitution smile, when they
hear of such representation?
Before I speak to the third article of accu-
Gould be so infatuated as to retain id my
possession, that which must have been at-
tended with, to me, certain destnictioa?
Among my papers, there is not one which
can be construed into guilt. They consist of
pamphlets unconnected with the politics of
the day ; and of the various publications of a
society, pure and untainted in its principles,
of which I have the honour to be a member.
But every thing must be 'ransacked to heap
crimination upon my head. One of the letters
which I had undertaken to detiver in Scot-
land, is addressed to the reverend Fyshe
Palmer. Mark ! cries the lord advocate, the
company which this man keeps. — ^Who is Mr.
Palmer? — ^A person whdm I have indicted
for sedition, and who is to be tried in a few
days at Perth !— Unheard-of cruelty ! — ^Un-
exampled insolence! — What! Before ibh
Court, this jury, this audience, do you at-
tempt to prejudicate and condemn Mr. Pal-
mer, in his absence, undefended, and with-
out any possibility of defending himself? But,
exclaims the lord advocate, — ^The seal upon
the letter is a proof of the most atrocious
mlt. What is it ?— Horrible to tdl ! It is
Sie Cap of Dberty, supported upon a spear,
with the words ga ira above. All is consis-
tent. When you attempt to banish the sub-
stance of f^edom— the shadow must follow f
When a new coinage takes place, you have
eiven a most excellent hint. The officers of
tne mint will profit bv the lesson, and they
will no more scatter seclitH>n through the landf,
by impressing upon our halfpennies the figure
of Britannia witn a spear in ner hand, mount-
ed with the Cap of Liberty. But I am
ashamed to enter into such trifles. If that
letter had contained proofs of sedition, or of
treason against me, Mr. Palmer, or the writer
of it — ^the seal — and the spear — ^and the Cap
of liberty, would have been its feeblest pro-
tection.
■^ Gentlemen, I now come to the last charge r
That of having read, in the convention of
delegates, the Address from the society of
United Irishmen in Dublin.
I admit the fact, and I glory in the admis*
sion. The prosecutor has represented that
society, as a ning of mean and nefarious con-
spirators; and their diploma of my Bdmission
into their number, as an aggravation of my
crime. Let me tell the lord advocate of Soot-
land, that society stands too high to be af-
fected by his invective, or to require the «iA-
of my defence. I am a memoer of that
society ; and, in the last moments of my life.
sation, the reading in the convention the ^o have been so shall be my honour and my
address of the society of United Irishmen in pride. The lord advocate has represented
Dublin, permit me to make one observation, to you, in general terms, that this address
on the manner in which the prosecutor spoke amounts almost to treason ^ but he durst not
of the papers found in my custody. Do they attempt to point out, in his speech, a single
correspond with the view which he presented passage which could support the aspersion,
of them ? Are they the documents of corres- . Ji maintain that every line of that address Is
pondence with foreign or internal foes? And ^ ^ strictly constitutional. You must carry th^
supposing I had involved myself in a corres- "whole of it along with you into your chamber^
pondence of that ^ivtture^ do you believe I and not judge of passages scandakHisly
fiSSJ Jnt SedUhrn
tibted in tbe iadietment The miitilatioii of
the Tery first paragraph of tbe address is a
proof of the ftimesSy and of the ingenuity of
the nroseciitor. I hc^ leave to read how it
atanos in the indictment^ and then to read |
what foUows in the address itself.
** We take the liherty of addressing you, in
the spirit of civic union, in the fellowship of
a just and common cause. We greatly re-
joice that the spirit of freedom moves over
the surface of Scotland ; that light seems to
hreak from the chaos of her internal govern-
ment; and that a country so respectable for
her attainments in science, in arts, and in
arms ; for men of literary eminence ; for the
inteIHgence and morality of her people, now
acts from a conviction of the union oetween
virtue, letttfs, and liberty; and now rises to
^hstinclion, not by a caun, contented, secret
wish for reform in parliament, but by openly,
actively, and urgently willing it, with the
iinit^ and energy of an embodied nation. We
lejince that you do not consider yourselves as
inemd and melted down into another coun-
try, but that in this great natbnal question,
you are still — Scotland."
This is tbe first paragraph libelled /tfn. But,
even as it is in the mdictmeiit;<r^l8 it not
permitted to the united Irishmen in Dublin,
to congratulate this unfortunate people upon
accountof former eminence in literature, in
arts and in virtue ; — and to eipress the wish
that they would still retain that enviable dis-
thiction? And, is that last and foiiom pe-
riod now airived, when those who express such
a wish, must be called nefarious conspirators,
and he who has been the organ of its com-
monication, must be branded with the epithets
ol^ a '^ wretch," of an ** oracle of discord," of
^ a fiend of sedition V The children of your
children, in afler ages, will not foiget this
ever-to-be>remembered night. But here let
ns stop. J have said that this indictment
mutilated this passage, as it does every other
passage in this Address ; it breaks off the pa-
laeraph at the words, ^ You are still Scotland."
It broiks off in the middle of a sentence ; and
ibrwhat purpose? — to countenance an insi-
ayation, that the united Irishmen in Dublin
wiahed a dissolution of the union betwixt
Scotland and England. The prosecutor cuts
off the remainder of the sentence which de-
snonstnited the sense in which the United
Iriafamen understood the words " still Scot-
land," expressing solely their idea of her
still being dbtinguished by her former lustre.
A. D. 1795.
[226
The wonto which are separated from the sen- consider as the passport to the only acquaint-
lence are in the Address as follows : '* That
yaa are still Scotland — the land where Bu-
chanan wrote,' where Flistcher spoke, and
'Wallace fought" Yes, I give my solemn as-
sent to this . wish, and to this hope of the
United' Irishmen. My voice shall resound,
Scotland shall still be the land, where Bucha-
nan has written, where Fletcher spoke/ and
where Waiiace fought.
IjRt US attend to the mutilation of another
VOL. xxm.
passage in this axtraordmary indictment. I
shall read it as it stands : —
** We will lay open to you ouf hearts. Our
cause is your cause — If there is to be a strug^
fie between us, let it be which nation shall
e foremost in the race of mind ; let this be
the noble animosity kindled between us^ who
shall first attain that free constitution from
which both are equidistant, who shall first be
the saviour of the empire.
'* The sense of botn countries with respect
to the intolerable abuses of the constitution
has been clearly manifested; and proves that
our political situations are not dissimilar)
that our rights and wrongs are the same."
Tbe passage libelled upon stops at the
words ** rights and wrongs are tne same.''
But it forbears to take in the remainder, in
which the similarity of our riahts and wronga
is specified. The self-elected magistrates of
burghs — the unequal representation of the
people in parliamentr— and the total privation^
m Scotland, of the shadow of popular elec-
tion.
Gentlemen^ I will read over many passages
of this Address, not merely because they are
tlie production of an immortal pen, but be-
cause every word is regulated by the spurit of
the constitution.
[Here Mr. Muir read most of the Address.] .
Can you call this address seditious or in-
flammatory, which contains the following
sentiment? ^' If government has a sincere
regard for the safety of the constitution, let
them coincide with the people in the speedy
reform of its abuses, and not by an obstinate
adherence to them, drive that people into re-
publicanism."
Gentleraen, the lord advocate has repre-^
sented the authors of this Address as the
meanest of mankind, and has expressly called
them infamous wretches, who had Bed from
the punishment due to their crimes. What
slander ! — what false, unfounded slander !—
Has Doctor Drennan, — has Mr. Hamilton
Roffan. — wlmse names are at the head of
this address, fled from crimes and from
punishment? ** And they are infamous
wretches V If ever afler ages shall hear of
my name,.! wish it may be recorded^ that to
these men I had the happiness of being
known. To -be honoured by the notice of
Doctor Drennan, is an ambition to which, in
the most exalted station of life^ I would
fondly aspire. To have it said, that I was
the fi-iena of Mr« Hamilton Rowan, I would
ances whom I value — those who found their
claim to distinction upon the only true basis,
their own virtues. Mr. Rowan is indeed in-
dicted to stand trial in Ireland, upon a charge,
similar to my own. Mr. Rowan has not fled.
He will boldly meet his accusation ; and. let
me say, along with those who know him,
that althOUjgh it is impossible to add any new
lustre to his character, yet, as he has often
come forward in tbe cause of individual hi»-
Q
227]
8S GEORGE HL
'veee^mgi
tfM
nanity^ he wiU display himself nbcm. that '
occasion, the 6rniy the intrepid^ and I hope.
the successful champion of the liberties of his I to uneiavn^led in Scatlandv •▼err actios I
cord of mj (kparted doprs* The enediMt^af
reform have senilinized» m a manner hither*
native co«ntry.*
I hasten to a conclusion. Much yet re-
mains to say. But after, upon my part^ the
unremitted exertions of sixteen hours, I f^\
myself nearly exhaasted.
- Look once more, I entt«eal ye«, to the in-
dictment, and compare it with the evidence.
The first char^ against me is, tdMit in puh-
Mc speeches, I vilified the king and constit»-
tioB. AH! the witnesses adduced attest, that,
bot^ in public and iti private, even in my
most unguarded moments, my kngnage was
always respectftil to the king, and that I al-
w^s recommended the c(mstitution»
The second charge against me is, that of
tidvisin^ the people to read seditious hooka,
knd of distcibutins inftfeunmatoiy publicatlonB
among them : and vou hear it proved, by the
unaRimeus voice or all the witnesses for the
€rown> that I revised to veeommend any
books, and that the only one which I rccom*
mendra, wa» Dr. Henry's History of Eng-
landvi You will not forget the eircumstantes
m which I lentFreeland acopyof Bfr.Pliine*8 ! and to puft an end to the proAision of their
Works ; nor will you' forget like manner in ■ blood. From my infiamcy ta this moment, I
which the writings of that man were intro* I have devotodr mysdf to the cause of the
duced Jn conver^on with Wilson, Muir, and ! people^ It is a good cauee. — It shall uki-
may hav^peifcfmedl, mrywrnl im^imm
uttered.--Of dunes, most foul and honifali^
have I been accused. Of attempting to rear
the standu^d of civil war, and to phmge tfiia
land in bloody and to cofver thie kmd with^do^
solation. At every stepy as the evideoee of
the Crown advanced, my inaocency haa
brightened. So far from infiamiag the minda
of men to sedition and outrage — all the wit-
nesses have concurred^ that my* onkj anxie^
was, to impress upon them the necessitj of
peace, of good onler, aad of good mendsL
What then has been my crime ^ Not the
lending to a relation a copy of Mr. Paine's
Works; not the giving awi^ to another a Siw
numbers of an umocent and eonstitutiaBai
publkation; but^ for having dared to be, aa-
cording to the Buasure of my feeble abililies,
a strenuous aad aetvee advocate for an eqii^
representation of the people — in the Howe of
ti» people ; — foe havins dared toatbmpt to a»-
compliah a measure, hy legfat mean^ whidi
was to diminish the weight of their
mately^mevail. — U ahali foaally triumph. Sajr,
then, openly, in your verdict,if ^vou do cond^
with Barclay. With regard to o«her books
and pamphlets m^ntbned in thehbel, there
is not any proof. William Muir has deponed^ j mo, 'wtiich'l presume you will not,— Th«t it
that I gave him one or two numbers of the < is for my attachment to this cause alone, and
Patriot, and* some other pamphlets, whose not for those vaia and wretched pretents,
^tles I cannot remember. William M^iv is stated in the indictment^ intended only to oo->
but a single witness to this faet; and you 1 lour and disguise the real motives of my aa-
knowthat, by the laws of ScotTand* t^etes* ! cusation. Tne time will come, when nan
tiftumy of a single witness cannot claim any j must stand or foil by their actions; when aU
weight; but I frankly adhiit and acknow- , human paeeantrv shall ceaee; when the
ledgje,, that I gave him those numbers of the hearts of aU shall be laid open. If yon t»-
Piatriot, and, if I were not now entirely over^ ■ gard your moift impoitttit mtereals— if ymi
Gome by faiigue> I could dismonstrate to> you, ]
that, in those numbers) th^e is not a single
bcttiiment unconstitutional or seditioua.
I am- accused of reading the Irish Address
in tk\e Convention, and oi movitog a solemn
iwiswer in return,, Thataddress is neither se-
ditkrus, wicked, nor inAamrmatbry. There is
toot a sentence in it, which I have not de^
fonded in your presence.
You neither can do Justice to me, nor to
*he country, tf you condemn these different
^H^Hcations, up<)n account of the scandal-
"ou^ly mutilated extracts from them in the
libef. You must carry the whole of them
-along with you from this place. It is not
tq>on detached passages you are to judge^ but
you must decide upon the whole.
• Gentlemen of the Jury :— This is now per-
•haps the last time that I shall addrese my
<x)untiy. I have explored the tenor of my
pagthfo. Nothing shall tear from me the re-
• With respect to the* imputaHion on Mr.
'^7?o,**ere afliide*to» see Margarot's defence
oa his trial, in tftiiavoluiae--^if.
wish that your conscience should whiapen to
you words of oonsdation, or speak to yon in
the terrible langu^e of remorae^-weij^ vdl
the verdict you are to pronomice. As tor bk,
I am carelesaandindmecent to my fata, I
can look' danger, and I can look dealh in tte
face, for I am sluelded by the consciouMMas
of my own rectitude. I may be condemned
to languish in the reoesses of aduneeen>— I
may be doomed to ascend the acaifoId*-»No-
thing can deprive me of the recoUection of
the past— Nothing can destroy w^ inwnod
peaoa of mind, arising from the rememtanuDOB
of having discfaar{{!ed my dutgr.
[WhenMr. Mmr sat down, an unantflMNu
burst of applause waa eapressed by tba
audience.
When the acdamationa had aeaea^ be
arose and said f]
I have omitted tD take notice of the avi-
, denoe adduced upon my parU I am lint
going; to detain you a moment longerv^lBo
you X iMTe the import of the whole of Ihni
evidence.
k
,^W* afttHUti*
h. D. 1793.
[9S0
flOiOlf «0 UP.
|wUtBMB,istbe]4Mi|iC9t I have ever seen,
«neeIlMid1iie hGnoar to «t in this couit;
mnA is to be Hied hy a gmt mimber of tit*-
•cumntincigi R Khul be my bumieas to sim^
pliiy il ts OM^ ee I on.
A relevaaft charge^ gentlemen. May be ctftt^
laned n a few lines ; biit the kumane prin'-
dple on wliidi tke practiee is canried on, is to
etaile die ^rtssft some length^' for the benefit
«f the prisoner; and on this principle the
lord advocate has acted in the prasentoase.
But, Mitiemen, although the Akcts are
thasAilfy stated; it is by no means absolutely
necessarv to prove the whole, in order to es^
tabliA the euilt of the pfisoner. You have
•nly to look at the concluding sentence of
the indictment^ which runs thus , ** all which,
«r part thereof being feuad proven," &c. from
which you clearly peroeive that you are to
consider if as many of the facts libelled are
fMwed to your satisfaction as will establish
the geneml charge.
The ^piestion, then, gentlemen, for your
cofBuderation is simply tins: On the miole
«f the preef led, when taken in connexion, do
ftm Ihmk the panel guilty of sedition or not ?
Now m esmmining this question, there are
two things which you should attend to, which
— temiire no proof. The first is, that the Bri-
tisti constitution is the best in the world ; —
for thetnith of this, gentlemen, I need only
sippeal to your own fecKogs. Is not every
nan secure in his hie, liberty, and property ?
Is not happiness in the power of eveiy man,
except those perhaps, who, from disappoint-
inent in their schemes of advancement are
w^ disoonlentedf I>oes not every man ci^joy
unmolested the fruits of his industry f And
does not every man sit safely under his own
vino and his own ^-tree, and none shall
make him afraid ^ The other circumstance,
.^.Mitlemen, which yon have to attend to, is
the smie of this country during last winter.
There was a spirit of sedition and revolt going
.^^ abroad which^ade every good subject se-
flievMly nneasyr I observed the reflection of
tile master of the ^rammer school of Glasgow,
who loM Mr. Mmr, he ooticelved that propos-
lurefiirmtiion was venr ill-timed ; I coin-
cm in Usat opinion, and I leave it for you to
jti%e, whether it was perfectly innocent or
not in Mr. Muir, at such a time, to go about
among ignorant country people, ana among
the lower classes of the people, makins tb6m
leave off their work, and inducing tSem to
believe that a reform was absohitely necessaty
to preserve their safety and their liberty,
whioibad it not been for him, they never
wonld have suspected to have been in danger.
Tou wffl keep this in remembrance, and
jodge whether it appears to you, as to me, to
be sedition.
You will nest attend, genticmen, to Mr.
liuir's conduct at Kiikmtilbcb, which is to
be ceUectcd chieily from the evidence of
Jofaostofie, Weddel, and Freeland. You will
observe partioulariy how he ran a parallel
between the French and £nglbh constitutions^
and talked of their respective taxes, and their
causea^ and (how he gave a preference to the
French. You are to judge of the tendency
of such harangues. With respect to drcalat.
ing Paine*s book, Mr. Muir has said that it
hu never boMi condemned. But, gentle-
men» Mr. Mutr should reooUcct« and you
must be sensible, that a jadgment i^ a
cottrt of ^w is by no means necessary to
make it seditious. It is in itself most sedi«
tioiis, traasonable, and dangerous. Sedition
in England, gentlemen, mMSt be sedition
here ; and sedition here must be sedition in
England ; and it would be right id forming.
your opinion to have an eye upon the judg<-
monts of the £nglish courts, who have con-
demned the publication of that work. Tlie
other writinas mentioned in the indictment
are much of the samfe stamp. I agree in
the idea that the passages should be taken
with their context. You will do this when
vou look over them, and have only to recol-
met a simple proposition, that to render a
book seditious, it is not necessary it be aH
sedition.
Now, gentlemen, the fact is clearly ptoven^
of his having circulated some of these oooks;
it is for you to draw the consequence.
Ask attack has been made on the young
woman, Fisher. But I must confess I ne«e*
heard a mora distinct evidence; and no
grudge between her and the fiunily has been
condescended on. On the contrary, from hetf
answer to a very proper question put to her
by one of yourselves, she appears to havejeft
the family on very good terms.
Gentlemen, Uie onlv v/ith of the prosecutotf
can be to bring offenders to iustice; and ha
must make use of such evidence as the case
admits. Her testimony, however, in several
material fiutts has been supported.
You will next attend to Mr. Muir's beha^
viour m the convention, when he read the
Irish Address. Instead of depying this fhc^
Mr. Muir has asserted the innocence of it|
and enlareed upon its merits. Gentlemen, I
cannot help saying, I think it a most sedi-^
tious and inflammatory paper. You will take
it with you and judge of it. '
You have next to turn your attention to
the mitlawary. AunninK away from justict|
gentlemen, must always he considered an evi-
ence of guilt.* Mr. Muir has attempted to
set up 4n apology for his non-appearance;
but I would ask, why, at such a crisis, ha
should go to France ? Independently of that;
he ahould have recoUected that an embassy
to a fbrei^ comitry, withoutproper authority,
is a epecies of reMllion. Tnis proves, hovr-
——— — *— — -'-II — — - — --• .....■-- — ^
• See the observations of Mr. Justice Day
on the case of Judge Iphnson, in the court of
Kiog's^bench of JxdniA, a. n. 1605, psvT.
SSI]
SS GEORGE in.
Proeeedingt agabuf nomas Muir
i9S»
ever» that he wm supposed to have conside-
rable influence with those wretches, the lead-
inj; man there, and establishes his connexion
with them. And what characters are these ?
I never was an admirer of the French ; but I
can now only consider them as monsters of
human nature.
As Mr. Muir has broueht many witnesses
to prove his general good behaviour, and his
recommendiujg peaceable measures and peti-
tions to pvliament, it is your business to
judge how far this should operate in hu &-
vour, in opposition to the evidence on the
other side.
Mr. Muir might have known that no at-
tention could be paid.to such a rabble. What
right had they to representation ? He could
have told them that the parliament would never
listen to their petition. How could they think
of it ? A government in eveiy country should
be just like a corporation ; and, in this coun-
try, it Ls made u p of the landed interest, which
alone has a right to be represented ; as for
the rabble, who have nothing but personal
Broperty, what hold has the nation of them ?*
v^hat security for the payment of their taxes?
they may oack up all their property on their
backs, ana leave the country in the twinkling
of an eye, but landed property cannot be ro«
inpved.
Thetendency of such a conduct was cer-
tainly to promote a spirit of revolt; and if
what was demanded should be refused, to
take it by force.
Mr. Muir's plan of discouraging revolt, and
all sort of tumult was certainly political : for
until every thing was ripe for a general insur-
tection, any tumult or disorder could only
tend, as he himself said, to ruin his cause ;
he was in the mean time, however, evidently
poisoning the minds of the common people,
and preparing them for rebellion.
Gentlemen, ^ou will take the whole into
your consideration. I now leave it with you,
and have no doubt of your returning such a
verdict as will do you honour.
The Lord Jtutiee Clerk bavins finished his
address about half |»ast one oxlock in the
morning of Saturday, the Court was a^jourped
until 1 3 o'clock of that day, and the jury were
immediately enclosed.
Saturday f Augu$t Si$i.
The Court again met according to adjoom-
menty when the jury returned the following
YEKDICT.
Edinburgh, Augutt Sill. 179$.
The above assize having enolosed, made
choice of the said Gilbert Innes to be tiieir
chancellor, and the said John Balfour to be
• * These exnressions were animadverted
upon with mucn severity bjr Mr. Fox in the
House of Commons. See m the New Pari,
tlistory. Vol. SO, his speech on Mr. AdaQi's
motiop, March IQth 1791.
their clerk ; and having couj^dered the crimi-
nal libel, raised and pursuea,\t the instance
of his scKs^est^'s advocate for his majesty's
interest, agamst Thomas Muir panel, the
interlocutor of relevancy pronounced thereon
by the Court, the evidence adduced in proof
of the libel, and the evidence in exculpation >
they are all, in one voice, finding the panel,
Thomas Muir, Guilty of the crimes libelled ;
in witness thereof their said chancellor and
clerk have subscribed these presents, con-
sisting of thi^ and the preceding page, in their
names and bv their appointment, place, and
date aforesaid.
(Signed) Gilbert Ikkes, Chan,
John Balfoub, Clerk.
The verdict beinc recorded, the Lord Jwt^
Oct Clerk addressed the Jury, and said. That
this trial had been of the greatest importance.
He was happy that they had bestowed so
much attention upon it, and informed them,
that the Court highly approved of the verdict
they had given. He then asked their lord-
ships severally their opinion unon this verdict,
and what punishment should oe infiicted.
Thev delivered their opinions as follows :-*«
Lord Henderland observed, that the alarm-
ing situation in which this countcy was during
the course of last winter, save uneasine«i to
all thinking men ; his loitisnip said, that he
had now arrived at the most disagreeable part
of the duty incumbent upon him, which was
to fi;i the punishment due to the crime, of
which the panel was found guilty. The
indictmept cqarges him with sedition, with
exciting a spirit of discontent among the
inferior classes of people, and with an attadc
agjunst the glorious constitution of this
country ; the jury, by the verdict which they
had returned, and to which the Court had
alone recourse, had found the panel guilty ;
and it was their lordships only duty, now to
fix the punishment due to the ofience. His
lordship said, that he would not dwell upon
the evil consequences of the crimes committed
by the prisoner. The melancholy example of
a neighbouring country, which would for ever
stain the paee of history, rendered it unne-
cessary for him to recapitulate the circum*
stances of the case. In that country, the conse-
quences of such measures have produced every
kind of violence, rapme, and murder. There
appeared, he saia, to have been in this country
a regular plan of seditious measures. The
indecent applause which was given to Mr.
Muir, last ni^ht, at the conclusion of his
defence, within these walls, unknown in that
high court, and inconsistent with the solem-
iiity which ought to pervade the administra-
tion of justice, and wnich was insulting to the
laws and dignity of that Court, proved to
him, that the spirit of sedition had not as yet
subsided. He would not, be said, seek to
aggravate the offence committed by the
panel, by the misconduct of his deluded
friends, in order V) increase the puniahmenl.
8S9]
^arSkBUcn.
A. D. 1793.
[234
TIm uunishsMDl to be kAkted is-vlHtmy^of
which there is a variety, and we have our
choice ol banishment, fine, whipping, impri-
sonment, and transportation. Bamshmen^
he obsf rvedy wonid oe improper, as it would
on]y be sending to another country, a man
dangerous to any, where he might have the
opportunity of exciting the same spirit of dis-
content, and sowing with a plentiful hand, se-
dition ; fine would only fall upon his parents
who had already suffered too much by the for-
fdture of his bail ; whipping was too severe and
^sgracefiil, the more especially to a man who
baa bore his character and rank in life ; and
imprisonment, be considered, would be but a
temporary puni^ment, when the criminal
would be agisin let loose, and so again disturb
the happiness of the people. There remains
but one puiu»hment m our law— transporta-
tion. It was a duty he considered he owed
to his oounlrvnien to pronounce it, in the
situation in which he sat, as the punishment
due to his crimes. His lordship said, I am
sorry, it wrings my very heart to think that a
gentleman of his description, of his profes-
sion, and of the talents he possesses, should
be giulty of a crime deserving such a punish^
inent, Imt I see no alternative^ For woat se^
curity could we have aednst his future opera-
tions, but lus removal from this country, to a
j^aoe where he could do no farther harm?
His lordship was therefore of opinion, that
the panel roould be recommitted to prison,
there to remain, till a proper opportunity
should occur for transporting him, to such
place as bis majesty, with the advice of his
privy council might appoint, for the space of
rourteen years mm the date of the sentence ;
with certification that if he return within
that time, he shall suffer death.
Lord Swinton, — ^The crime with which the
panel is, by the jur^ of his country, found
guOtv, is seaition. It is a generic crime, and
which is defined by our lawyers to be ^' a
commotion of the people without authority,
or the exciting of such commotion, to the dis-
turbance of the public peace/' This crime,
he observed, consisted of many gradations,
and might ftutve run finom a petty mob about
wages, even to hieh treason. He thought the
punishment should be adapted to the crime.
^Tbe question, he said, was then, What was
the degree of the crime the panel had been
gaaltj of? That was to be discovered from the
Bbel, of which he lias been found niilty by
the unanimous verdict of a respectable jury of
l)is eountrv. It appeared to him to be a
crime of the most neinous kind, and there
wraa scarcely a distinction between it and high
treason. As by the dissolution of the social
compact it made way for, so it roisht be said to
include every sort of crime, muraer, robbery,
xapine, fire-raising, in short, every species of
wrong, public uid private. This was no
theoritical reasoning, for we had it exempli-
fied befiire our eye«, in the present stated of
i^ under the pretence of asserting
liber^. the worst sort of tvranny was esta^
blisheo, and all the lesal and moral ties which
bind mankind were broken. Nay, shameful
to telL even religion itself was laid aside, and
publicly disavowed in their National Conven-
tion.
Certain wicked persons have set on foot in
this happy kingdom, the first steps of the
same plan under the specious pretences of
liberty and equality ; assuming to themselves,
most falsely and msidiously, the respectable
names of Friends of the People, ana of Ae-
form, although they deserve the very oppo-
site denomination ; by which means they
have misled, and drawn after them, a great
number of well-meaning, though simple and
unwary people.
A most respectable jury has found the pri-
soner guilty of endeavouring to excite this
sort of sedition : — ^and how dm he attempt to
explain and justify himself ?— By denying se-
ditious intent, and alleging his motives were
a desire of reformation, and that the mode
he proposed for obtaining it, was a legal,
peaceable, and constitutional petition to the^
House of Commons. But how were these
motives reconcileable with the principles in
the writings and pamphlets which he justified
and circulated? The fundamental doctrine
of these books is, that the whole people are
in effect to judge of, and direct in every thins,,
and that to obtain their end, they have only
to WILL it. Is not such a reformation a sub-
version of our wise and happy government ?
And is a petition of millions of people who
have WILLED to have what they pray, a legal,
peaceable, and constitutional petition ?
With regard to the punishment, I observe,
that the maxim, that the severity of punish-
ment ought to be in proportion to the atrocity
of the crime, does not hold in our law ; for
that, with us, punishment is not revenge nor
atonement. If punishment adequate to the
crime of sedition were to be sought for, it
could not be found in our law, now' that tor- *
ture is happily abolished. The sole object o%
punishment among us is only to deter others
from committing uke crimes in time coming.
In this vievr I concur in the proposal that
has been made of transportation for fourteen
years, which is a mild punishment, consider-
ing the offence, and considering the danger
oflhe times.
By the Roman law, which is held to be our
common law where there is no statute, the
punishment was various, and transportation,
was among the mildest mentioned. Paulus,
L. 38. Dig. de Poenis writes, ' Actores sedi-
' tionis et tumultds, populo concitatb, pro
^ qualitate dignitatis, aut m fiircam tolluntur,
' aut bestiis obiiciuntur, aut in insulam de-
^ portantur.' — We have chosen the mildest of
these punishments.* By the Codex, lib, 9,
* See Mr. Fox's remarks on this passage in
his speech in the House of Commons^ March
lOth^ 1794. New Pari. Hist; vol. 30.
235]
33 GEORGE m.
Proceeding ^0imt TkomoM Muit
tssff
t. so. * de seditious «t his qui picbem contra
* rempublicam audent colletere/ 1. 1 asid «.,
socfa persoDs are subjected * ad mntetam gra-
< vissimara.' — ^Baldus wrftes, ' Provocans tu-
* BHiHiim et elamerem 4r poptdo, debet nori
' poenft seditionis/ — And by a constitutioB of
the emperor Leo : * $ubdandos sutem pe&nis
* eis ({«as de seditioms et tumultds anctoribus
' Yetusttssima decreta sanxertnt/
Itie crime here, thoii^h very near to trea-
son^ does not amouirt to it. The mildest of
the punishments for the sedition of nirhidi the
pisoner has been frand gatHy is transporta-
tion ; and I thiidcit is ^e pmiirtunenftni this
Lord Dimttflinan. — His kirdship spoke in so
low a tone of voice that we had not im oppor-
tunity of foBowine hhn throughout the whole
of hiso|nnion. He, however, agreed, with the
test of their lordships, in the nunishment
wfaidi they said Mr. Muirdeserrea, viz, trans-
portation for fourteen years, with the usual
oertiBcation, ore.
Lord Ahercromhf. — ^I think it by no means
nece^sarv to say much of the enormitsr of this
crime, after what has been already said. By
qur old law it would have amounted to trea^
aon ; and even by the statute of Edward it
comes very near it.
Had the paneKs speeches produced an^f riots
or tumults, it mi^t have involved him in
high treason. This rendered him cautious ;
fbr otherwise he might thb day have received
sentence to suffer the punishment due to
traitors.
Another reason why he avoided tumults
was mentioned in his speech, that a revolu-
tion oould only be effected by an insurrection
of the general mass of the people ; trifling
tumults would not answer.
^Hcre Mr. Muir rose and said — ^ 1 deny
it, my lord ; it is totally false."]
If a^y thing could add to the improper na-
ture of the panel's defence, it was his pre-
tended mission to France, and the happiness
ite expressed in the circle of ac(|uaintance
he had there. It is evident, that his feelings
dvi too much accord with the feehngs of those
monsters. — His lordship coincided with the
rest of their lordships, in regard to the punish-
ment, which, they nad given as their opinion,
Mr. Mtiir deserved.
Lord Justice CUrk, — ^His lordship ssud, he
was censiderabiy afifected to see the panel
stand trial for sedition, a man who had re-
ceived a fiberal education, was member of a
respectable society, possessed considerable
talents, and had sustained a respectable cha-
racter. The lowest species of this crime is
heinous; but when a^ravated by creating
disloyal^ and disaffection to government, it
amounts to the highest sort oi sedition. It
borders on treason; and perhaps it is owing
to the humanity of the lord advocate, that the
panel had not to stand trial for his Ufe.
His lordship agreed in the propriety of the
proposed pumshaea^ and he observed, that
%
«ie Suueu&Bt t^pplatifle whicn ifss given Ae
panel last Bigb^ «acivtnced tuni, that a spirit
of discontent stifl iurked in the minds of the
people, and that it would be dangerous to
a§ow him to remain in this coimtry. His
lordship said. Hiis eircumstance had no little
weight with dim, when considermg of the pu-
nishment Mr. Muir deserved. He never had
a doubt but Uansportatioii was the proper
punishment fur sucn a crime^ but he only he-^
sitated wlietfeer it should be for life of fbr the
tenn of fourteen yean— the hrtter he pre-
ferred, and he hoped the panel weuld reflect
on his past conduct, and see tiie impropriety
whidi m hadxx>mmitted, and that if he snould
be asaifi leatured to his country, fae might
still have an opportunity of showing himself
to be a good oKember of that eonstitutioii
which he seemed to tle«>ise so much.
After his lonAship had delivered his opinion,
and during tlie time the sentence was re-
conKne, Mr. Muir rose and said : —
My lord justice clerk, I have only a few
words to say. I shall not animadvert upon
the severity or the leniency of my sentence.
Were I to be led this moment from the bar to
the scafibld, I sbould feel the same calmaesa
and serenity which f now do. My mind tells
me, that I nave acted agreeably to my con-
science, and that I have engaged in a good, a
just, and a glorious cause — a cause which
sooner or later must and will prevail ; and, by
a timely reform, save this country fiH»m de*
struction.
The clerk then read the sentence.
The lord justice clerk, and lords cominis-
sioners of justiciaiy, having considered the
foregoing venlict, whereby the assize, all
in one voice, £nd the panel Guilty of thd)
crimes libelled ; the said lords, in respect of
the said verdict, in terms of an act passed in
the 25th year of hb present m^esty, intituled,
<^ An act (or the more efTectuaf transportatioa
of felons and other offenders in that part of
Great Britaui called ScoUand," ordain and
a4)udfi;e that the said Thomas Muir be trana-
porteo beyond seas, to such place as his ma*
jestv, with the advice o^* his privy council^
shaU declare and appoint; ana that for the
space of fourteen years firom this date ; ivilh
certification to him, if after being so Iraos-
ported, he shall return to, and be found a$
large, within any part of Great Britain, during
the said fourteen years, witiiout some lawful
cause, and be thereof lawfiilly convicted, he
shall suffer death a3 in cases of felony, witii-
out benefi.t of cler^, by the law of EngUfid c .
and ordain the said Thomas Muir to be car*
ried back to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh^
therein to be detained till he is delivered over
for bemg so transported, Ibr which this she]}
be to airconcemed, a 8u£Bcieat warrant.
(Signed) RoBSRT M^usav.
^* In the library of the Antonlan monks at
8t. Sebastian; Rio Jandro, we were shewn an
887] Jb^SkttkiL
a A bod^ peeaeated by Th^rnds liuir,
tiM fQlk>«iriiig lnc» m a bfaMh ImI:
QnA'nw Sbndi ilnlMiiyraerMl
€H<igi iiuiiitip HUB
!i%fMiaf Mmr, <fo Hmilcrf At//»
GM^e iSbotvf, iliiuni <»r6is terrarmm citis
OSctHm^ O Ungmmfeiici kngumqme mperifa
Ante alias patria, Hero6m tanctiuima teilutf
Divm optm^jMmukt tirtr, httumnm (oinpir,
iXnumaua memorvre teo manmamqaie nuiioium
Vkenktu [^. verifW\,
dttomw
Et HMFpe$ igiumMat tt barbtmajtmm,
Et mo$ pmtrusfinet et dulcia Unquimus arvOf
JBf «m iingem iUrdbmtm ssquor,
SamDk Sebattiani^ 9S Ma, 1794.
A. D* 1193.
[9W
^ We hame todesvoiif ed !• eorrect the fkb»
Lstisi wbifchr our copyist has made ia.sevend
ksteacet^ bul miast refer him back to aoiiM
better cop^; and we should have liked ta
hanre kaoiini ifat name of the book pre»
sented/'— Review of an Accoant of a Voyaaa
l» catablish a Colony at Fort St Philip m
New South Walesy by J. H. Tuckey ; Genlla-
manias Magaime^ April 13Qi5^ pp. 337 — 9.
Heapectiag this case» see in the New Par*
liaMWrtnry Uistory the debates in the House
of Levda^ January S9tb^ 17^4 ; in the House
ofComBMnSy March 10th» 17d4; and in the
ttaiirte e€ Lorda, April SMh, 1794. See alsa
in this volume the cases of Palmer^. Skirvioi^
Marsaroty Sinclair, and Gerrald, particularly
thelast.
59t.
Proeeeding^r on fbe Trhd of the Rev. Thomas Fyshe Palmisr^
on fln Iii4i€tineiit barging hioi mill) Sedikioiu Piactices*
Tried before tbe ClfCttit Coast of Jarticiary^ held at Fertti^
on the 13th and IStb September : S3 George HI. a. d.
Jhmtdi^^ tkptmber \% 1799.
llieCoiirlttet afrei^o'olnckiA theflMffDii^
Mr, BURNETT (advocate depMa for the
Crown)— ttie iiwrt case I mean to minr befbre
your kirdtfhip ia thai of Thojnaa- Visehe Pal^
nefy for seditkms practices,
Mr. Htiggaft (eeua06l' for tike panel).-^
My knds, the panel at the bar is Thomaa
Tysbe Palmer, W the ladictBaeii^ does noit
apply to that geotlemaii.
iMrd iM|rro«e,^Weniusthearfiiirti^ whe-
lAier he^pieads guilty) or not guilt/.
Bllt. Wtg^atk-^ak 4ft not tiie peison^ my
lord.
Lord Ahercrombie. — In paint of ibmi> the
indidtnefft tmiat be read first.
[The I^sdfctment read as follo«rst]
•Geoige, &o. Whereas, it is faumbljr' meant
and conrplaatied tb us by our right ttusty
Robert I^uiida9, esq., of Amiston, our advo-
•cale for our imerest^ upon Thomas Fische
Palmer^ clergyman, sometime residing in
Dundtoe, and commonly designed Unitarian
mimster: that, by the laws of this> and of
every other well governed realm, tlie widi*-
'edly and feloniously writing or printing, or
liie causing to- be written and printed, any
seditions or inAammatoiy writing, calculated
to produee a spirit of discontent ib the minds
* Of thia trial there are twa printed ao-
'Comila ; tlieaa I have earefully compared^ sad
from thooiy the lepei* heie given isxjoiBpiM.
of Mie people, against the present happy oon*'
stitHtioa and government o£ this ceuntiy,
and tOirouaa them up to acts o# outrage and
vtoieao^ by insidiously ealumnialing and
mismpmenting the measures of government^
and fidsely and seditiously jualifying.and'vii»-
dioatin^ the enamiea of our country, wiih
whom we am at open war: as also the- wicJ^^
ed^ and feloniwisly diatsibutuig and circu-
latina^ or tiie causing so be distributed and
dmu&Klad, any seditious and inflaiMnatofy
writing, are crimes of an. hmnouk natuia^
dan^^erous to the public peaoe^ and aavefely
pimishahle: yet true it is,, and of varityy
tint the said Thomas Fische Paimeiv above
cam^idned upon,, is guilty^ aolor or art and
pait$. of all and each, or one op other of the
foresaid crimes ; in so far as^ aometiiBe dur-
intf the mondi of July 1793, or of June pre-
oeaii^, or of August foUowins, the said Tho»
maa jnache Palmer, having neeni present at
a meetiiw held at Dundee, and county of
Forfar, which meeting denominated itself
** ASodety of the Friends of Liberty," or bore
some snoh name,* and of which meeting or
sociaiy, the said Thomas Fische Palmtn* is
or was- a member; he did? then and there
put intO' the hands of George Mealmakeiv
weaver in Dundee, a manuscript or writings
of a wiekediand seditiotts import, in the form
of an Addiesa to their Friends and Fellow
CitaacBs; which manuscript or writings waa
aomelinie during the months aforesaid^ at
IDundM aforesad^ or at some other place
to tite public piosaculor imkaiomiy wiclifidlir
£39]
Praaeiingi
aad feloniously written ,or oonpoted by the
said Thomas Fische Pahner, or by him caus-
ed to be composed or written; and which
mianuscript or writiog, after it had undergone
several alterations, suggested by the aforesaid
meeting, was, by desire of the said meeting,
again put into the hands of the said Thomas
Pische Palmer, in order that it might, by his
means, be published, printed, and circulated.
And the said Thomas Fische Palmer did
thereafter print, or at least did wickedly and
feloniously, sometime durine the months
aforesaid, cause to be printed at Edinburgh,
or somewhere else to the public prosecutor
unknown, the said seditious and mflamma-
tory writing, whereof the title and tenor
follows s
"Dundee^ Bertan Meeting House^ July 1793.
At a general meeting of the Friends of Li-
berty, they unanimously resolved to pub-
lish the following Address to their feUow
citizens.
^Friends and fellow citizens; — ^You, who
by your loyal and steady conduct, in these
days of adversity, have shown that you arc
worthy of, at least, some small portion of
liberty, unto you we address our language
and tell our fears.
** In spite of the virulent scandal, or ma-
licious efforts of the people's enemies, we
will tell you whole truths, they are of a kind
to alarm and arouse you out of your lethargy.
That portion of liberty you once enjoyed is
fast setting, we fear, in the darkness of des-
potbm and tyranny ! too soon, perhaps, vou
who were the world's envy, as oosseuiea of
some small portion of liberty, will be sunk in
the depth of slavery and misery, if you pre-
vent it not by your well* timed efibrts.
*^ Is not every new day adding a new link
to our chains ? Is not the executive branch
daily seizing new, unprecedented, and un-
warrantable powers? Has not the House of
Commons (your only security from the evils
of tyranny and aristocracy) joined the coali-
tion against you? Is the election of its
members eitlier fair, free, or frequent? Is
not its independence gone, while it is made
tip of pensions and placemen ?
' ** We have done our duty, and are deter-
mined to keep our posts, ever ready to as*
sert our just ria^hts and privileges as men^
the chief of which we account the right of
universal suffrage, in the choice of those, who
serve in the Commons' House of Parliament,
and a frequent renewal of such power.
" We are not deterred or disappointed by
the decision of the House of Commons con-
cerning our petition. It is a question we did
not expect (though founded on truth and
reason) would be supported by superior
numbers. — Far frombemg discouragea, we
SEfe more and more convinced, that nothing
ean save this nation from ruin, and give to
the neople that happiness which they have
a^igntto^ook for under goveroment, but a
reform in the House of Commons, founded
upon the eternal basis of justice, fair, free>
and equal.
** Fellow citizens: — The time is now come^
when you must either gather round the fit*
brtc of*^ liberty to support it, or, to your eter-
nal infamy, let it tin to the ground, to nam
no more, hurling along with it, every thine
that is valuable and dear to an enlighienea
people.
'* You are plunged into a war, by a wicked
ministry and a compliant parliament^ who
seem careless and unconcerned for your in*
terest, the end and design of which is almost
too horrid to relate, the destruction of a
whole people, merely because they will be
free.
** By it your commerce is sore cramped
and almost ruined. Thousands and ten
thousands of your fellow citizens, from being
in a state ot prosperity, are reduced to a
state of poverty, misery, and wretchedness.—
A ,list of iMunknipicies, unequalled in any
former times, forms a part in the retinue of
this quixotic expedition; your taxes, great
and burthensome as tliey are, must soon be
greatly augmented; your treasure is wasting
fast; the blood of your brethren is pouring
out, and all this to tbrm chains for a free
people, and eventually to rivet them for ever
on yourselves.
** To the loss of the invaluable rights and
privileges which your fathers ei^ed, we
impute this barbarous and calamitous war.
our ruinous and still growing taiaticm, and
all the miseries and oppressions which we
labour imder.
^ Fellow citisens;— The friends of liberty
call upon ^u, by all that is dear and worthy
of possessing as men; by vour own oppresr
sbns; by the miseries and sorrows or your
suffering brethren; by all that you dread;
by the sweet remembrance of your patriotic
ancestors; and by ail that your posteri^
have a right to expect from you^ — ^to join us
in our exertions for the preservation of our
perishing liberty, and the recovery of our
long lost rights.''
Further, the said Thomas Fische Palmer
did, some time during the months of June
or July aforesaid, widcedly and feloniously
distribute and circulate, or cause to be dis-
tributed or circulated in Dundee, Edinburgh,
and elsewhere, a number of copies of tne
said seditious and inflammatory writing
Printed as aforesaid. Particularly, the said
*homas Fische Palmer did, sometinoe in
the month of July aforesaid, transmit, or
cause to be transmitted or delivered, to Wilr
liam Skirving of Strathruddie, residing in
Edinburgh, 100 copies, or thereby, of~.the
said seditious and inflammatory writing, to
be by him distributed and circulated; and
which accordingly, or the greatest part there-
of, were by him distributed and circulated.
As also Uie said Thomas Fisclie Palmer did,
sometime la (he mouth of July aforesaid^
2(1]
faf SedHioh*
A. D. 1?9^.
[249
deliver to ettti of Edward Leslie and Robert
Minery both stationers and booksellers in
Dundee, a number or parcel of the said sedi-
tious and inflammatoiy writings, to be by
%hem distributed and circulate. As also,
the said Thomas Fische Palmer did^ on the
fiOtb of July aforesaid, or, upon one or other
of the days of that month, transmit to James
Smiton, wri^ht in Newburgh, and county of
Ftfe^ 20 copies, or thereby, of the said sedi-
tious writing, to be by mm distributed and
circulated ; and which accordingly were dis-
tributed and circulated by the said James
Smiton, among several persons in the neigh-
bourhood. And the saia Thomas Fische Pal-
iner having, upon the 3d and Sd days of August
1T9S^ been brought before Harr^ Davidson,
esq. sheriff-substitute of the shire of Edin-
burgh, he <fid in his presence emit a decla-
ration, which the said Thomas Fische Palmer
having refused to subscribe, was siened by
the ^d Harrv Davidson : which declaration,
together with seven copies of the above-
mentioned seditious and inflammatory writ-
ing, whereof three of them attested on the
bade by the signature of the said Harry Dar-
vidson and others; two of them so attested
by Alexander Riddoch, esq. provost of Dirn-
dl, and others ; another of them so attested
hr Thomas Horsburgh, sheriff-substitute of
^e, and others ; and another copy of them
attested on the back by William Baine, ser-
vant to James M'Duff, shoemaker at firidge
of Turret, uid others; together with a ma-
nuscript copy of the said seditious writing,
attested by the said Harry Davidson, Alex-
ander Riddoch, and others: as also, two
pieces, or parts, of two letters, wrote by the
said Thomas Fische Palmer, and found in
the possession of Alexander Morrin, grocer
and spirit dealer in Edinburgh, and attested
by the said Alexander Morrin, Harry David-
son, and others; together with the scroll of
a letter, seemingly addressed to the said
Thomas Fische Palmer, b^ the said Alex-
aiukr Morrin, and found m the custody of
the said Alexander Morrin, and attested by
his subscription and that of the said Harry
IDavidson aforesaid; together with three
other letters, one dated the Sd of July 1793,
signed with the initials of T« F. P., and ad-
dressed to ** Mr. Ellis, at James Ellis's, stay-
maker. Chapel Shade, Dundee," attested by
' the signature of the said Alexander Riddoch,
and others; another, dated '* Dimdee, July
9, ITW/' signed " T. P. Palmer," and ad-
dressed ^ to Mr. Skirving, opposite Old As-
sembly Close, Cowgate;" ana another, dated
acnh July 1793, signed '< T. F. Palmer/^ but
"without any address, and begin mne *' ray dear
friend;" wliich two last letters above-men-
tioned are respectively attested by the sig-
nature of the said Harry Davidson, and
others; as also, a letter, signed ** James Ellis,"
dated *' Paisley, March 18," and addressed to
^ James EUis, staymaker, above St. Francis's
VfeU, Dundee ;" which letter is attested by
VOL. xxni.
the signatures of Thomas Farquharson and
William Moncrieff, together with a book,
attested by the subscription of William Airth^
weaver in Dundee, will ail be used in evi-
dence against the said Thomas Fische Pal-
mer; and will, for that purpose, be lodged-
in due time with the clerk of the circuit
court of justiciary, before which he is to be
tried, that he may have an opportunity of
seeing the same. At least, times and places
aforesaid, the said seditious and inflamma-
tory writing, was wickedly and feloniously
composed and printed, or caused to be com-
posed and printed; as also, wickedly and
feloniously distributed and circulated, or
caused to be distributed and circulated, in
manner aforesaid; and the said Thomas
Fische Palmer, above complained upon, is
guilty actor, or art and part, of all and each,
or one or other of the foresaid crimes. All
which, or part thereof, being found proven
by the verdict of an assize, before our lord
justice general, lord justice clerk, and lords'
commissioners of justiciary, in a circuit
court of justiciary to be holden by them, or
any one or more of their number, in |he
criminal coiu-t-house of Perth, the 12th of
September next to come, the said Thomas
Fische Palmer ought to be punished witli
the pains of law, to deter others from com-
mitting the like crimes in all time coming.
Our wUl is, &c.
List of Witnesses.
1 James Matthew, weaver in Dundee, and
at present or lately employed in keeph*
iug a shop belonging to Jobson, Mil-
ler^ and Company, cotton-manufac-
turers in Dundee.
3 William Moncrieff, one of the town-offi-
cers in Dundee.
3 James Yeamen, baker at Scouring-Burn,
near Dundee.
4 William Stewart, weaver in Dundee.
5 David Rattray, weaver in HiUtoun of
Dundee. •
6 George Mealmaker, weaver in Dundee.
7 Thomas Ivory, watchmaker in Dundee.
8 Mr. Thomas Donaldson, minister of the
gospel at Dundee.
9 Edward Leslie, stationer and bookseller
in Dundee.
10 Robert Miller, stationer and bookseller in
Dundee*
11 Thomas Colvile, printer in Dundee.
12 William Airth, weaver in Dundee.
13 James Ellis, cotton-«pinner in Glasgow,
at present residing m the house ot tlie
said Thomas Fische Palmer.
14 James Ellis, staymaker in Dundee.
16 George M'Intosh, clerk to Hugh Handy^
side, merchant in Edinburgh.
16 William Middleton, sheriff-oSicer in Edin-
burgh.
17 Alexander Morrin, grocer and spirit-deakr
in Edinburgh.
18 John Morrin, printer in Edinburgh.
U
tiS] 83 6E0RG9 IIL Proceedings againsi the R&o. T. Fyike Palmer [S44
Alexander Wood, merchaal in Elie.
40 James Chalmers, merchant there.
John Fair, writer in Colinsburgh,
Andrew Whyte, writer in Crail.
Cathcart Dempster, merchant in St. An^
drews.
Robert Key, merchant there.
45 Alexander Bonthron of Edensgrove.
Rob. McQueen.
Wm. Nairnb.
Alex. Abercromby.
Lord E$kgr(rt>e — Are you, Mr. Palmer,
panel at the bar, guilty of the crimes laid to
your charge in this indictment, or not
guilty ?
Mr. Palmer— 'I am not the person named
in the indictment
Lord JEsA^rove— And that you plead.
Mr, Pa^wSr— Yes, my lord.
Mr. Haggart—My lords, the case now be*
fore your lordships is of the last importance;
it directly relates to the liberty of the press,
the most invaluable privilege of a Britbh
subject. I wish the part allotted to me in thia
case had been in better hands : circumscribed
in point of time,« from my situation, not hav-
ing recourse, to many authorities, — nothings
but a sense of professional duty, could have
induced me to make my appearance now be*
fore your lordships.
Buty my lords, knowine that I shall m*
ceive mdulgence from the Court, and expect-
ing, in a case of the magnitude of which the
present is, assistance from the Court itself, I
come forward, and with confidence, to suIk
mit to your lordships, even that, if certain
preliminary objections which I shall state are
over-ruled by the Court, I shall make ont,
that the libel is not relevant Now, my
lords, the preliminary objections which oceur
in this case are two ; In the /irct place, to the
name, the indictment is laid against theRer.
Thomas Fische Palmer. Now, my lords, it
is very true that liiere is in the county of Es-
sex a respectable family of that name, but
from that &mily the panel has not the ho«
nour to descend. I can prove, by ample tes-
timony, that his name is Fythe Palmer; the.
name in the indictment diflMng in no leas
than two letters from that of the panel. He
is called in the indictment Fuche ; the |^<-
nePs name is Fy$ke, differing, your lordships
see, in no less tnan two letters from the name .
that is in this indictment Your lordships
will observe that, in the middle of the name^
there are the letters k.*
* " It is a flaw in any indictment, and shalL
hinder it from beinjg sent to an assize, if it-
be materially wrong m either the name or de*
sienation of the panel ; or if it give so gene-
ral, or 80 equivocal a description of him, thett
it does not certainly appear, to what periMn •
the charge was meant to apply. Thus, one
being i^cied under the name of James
Brj[cei(lMiW%hl LMardi^ and d| 1619} and
19 William Skirving of Stiathruddie, resid-
ing in Edinburjgh.
50 Alexander Aitchison, student of physic,
residing in Canongate of Edinburgh.
51 Alexander Scott, printer in Edinburgh.
32 James Smiton, wright in Newburgh, in
the parish of Newburgh, and shure of
Fife.
S3 James Fisher, schoolmaster at Newburgh
aforesaid.
34 John Ilarroway, innkeeper at Newburgh
aforesaid.
85 Harry Davidson, esq. sheriff- substitute of
the county of Edinburgh.
S6 Joseph Mack, writer in Edinburgh.
27 Alexander Riddoch| e^. provost of Dun-
oee*
28 William Scott, . procurator-fiscal of the
county of Edinburgh.
29 James M'Duff, shoemaker at Bridge of
Turret, in the narish of Mony vaird, and
county of Perth.
Sa William Bain, servant to the said James
M'DiiC
List of Assise.
Francis M'Nab of M^ab.
Chadles Campbell of Loehdochart.
Hope Stewart of Ballechin.
Charles Grant of Kinnaird.
5 lieutenant Adani Stewsirt of Cluny.
Kobert Stewart of Clochfoldich.
John Stewart of Crossmount.
James Stewart of Derculich.
Alexander Fergusson of Balyoukan.
10 William Stewart, writer in Perth.
Jao^es MorisoD, merchant tliere,
Tibbmas Sandeman, merchant there.
Patrick Stewartj writer in Dunkeld.
Daniel Stewart, writer there.
15 John Fisher, writer there.
Thomas Kimoch of CcMm,
David Liurd of Strathmartine.
Hercules Taylor, esa. Montrose.
Alei^ander Ferrier of Kiptroc)&et.
SO John Duncan of Rosebank.
David Anderson of Bal^y.
JohQ Ouchterlony, esq. Alontrose.
Ale;iapder Lamond, merchant in Mon-
trose.
George Mackie, merchant in Montrose.
S5 David Cook, merchant in Dundee.
Robert Miller^ bookseller there.
William Robertson, junior, merchant in
Arbroath.
William Miln, merchant there.
Gilbert Pennycook, merchant in Brechine.
SO John Smith, junior, merchant there.
The Honourable Robert Lindsay of Leu-
chars.
Col. John Thomson of Charleton.
James Calderwood Durham of I^rgo.
James Lumsdsdn of Innergelly
35 Alexander Duncan of Castleneld.
Patrick Lindsay of Coats.
Andrew Johnston younger of Bcnnvhill.
Alez«fidier Cunningh«m of Pittha^thie. ^
9I5J
Jbr Sediikm.
A. D. 1798.
[246
iMtd EtkgfVDt'^Tbstt isy c is brought in
•vrbkh ought not to be there, and there is i
la the place of the y.
Mr. ifd^Aff — Now, my lords, if there be
any one thiiK more important than another,
in the case of a criminal indictment, it is the
jDame of the panel. Andj^ my lords, a va-
riety of decisions have been pronounced by
yoor lordships, in other cases of less impor-
tance than this, where objections of a very
trifling nature have been sustained ; for in-
stance, in the noted case of Deacon Brodie
there was an objection sustained to a witness ;
he €4)iecting that his name is James Wight,
and tnat bS never has been known by the
name of Biyee; this matter is continued over
till another day, and no farther proceedings
take place on the chaige.
^ In tike manner, JamesStobie and William
Berry, are dismissed from the bar [July 81,
170i,] having been indicted under the names
of William Scobie and Alexander Berry. In
the case of John Watson, James Cantley, and
others, [Jan. 90 and 37, 178.5,] the objection
is sustained for Cantley, that he is not de-
icribed in the libel by his proper and ordinary
designation of wright in Stirling, but as ser-
vant to John Don, late sheriff-ogpute of that
county. Again, [Dec. ld» 1736,] in a prose-
cation at instance of Menzies of Culdares,
against certain thieves and depredators, it is
iound to be a good exception on the part of
two of them, tbftt they are not described by
their proper surname of Kennedy, but only by
certain Hirhiand nicknames and patronymics,
which had occasionally been applied to them.
More lately, [Oct. 11, 1797,] a young woman,
indicted under the uame of Elizabeth or Ally
Duncan, having pleaded and verified with evi-
dence that her name was not Elizabeth, but
AUtoHf she is found to have a good excep*
lion to trial on that indictment.
^ In short, all material variations in either
the name or designation of the accused ; as if
he be called John instead of James, or be cie«
scribed as weaver instead of shoemaker, or as
residing in Edinburgh instead of Leitb, or in
Castlehill instead of Canongate; as they may
possibly, so are they presumed actually to oc-
casion an uncertainty of the application of the
Hbel, andaretlie ground, therefoi;e, of an ob-
jection in Jaw to the charge. Tliis conse-
^[oenoe #iay sometimes enBue^ on the varia-
tton even of a single letter^ if the name be
tnily altered by such variation, and made a
dmrent name, to vulsar and common appre-
hension, from that of the panel; A, for in*
stance, by calling him Blain instead of Blair,
Jjsm insti»d of hsfm^ "Dcaown instead of £av-
$oni, or the like.
^ On the other hand, there are many, and
jnorc considerable variations than ai)^ Of
thes^ of winch in oiiT practice little account
is made; bi^aiis^ they are variations of the
s(>dl]Bg only or pronunciation of the na<ne,
tnd do notfainder it from being substantially
she was desigoed Hihbert, instead of Hebbert.;
there, there was only one letter difl^rent ;
but in the case even of a witness,, which I ap-
prehend to be of less importance than this,
that objection was unanimously sustained. I
have a variety of other cases which I shall beg
leave to mention to your lordships; and it is
from a source that I am sure will not be dis-
puted by my brother on the other side; it
comes from the fountain where, last session,
he and I, under a most respectable profes-
sor,* were endeavouring to imbibe the prin-
ciples of criminal law.
the same name, in the opinion of all who
hear it, as that of the accuseds for instance,
DarympU and Dalrymple ; Johnston and John-
stone ; Clerk and Clark : Davidson and Drf-
viton ; Robinson and Robison ; Rae, Ray, and
Reay; Stuart, JSteuart, and Stewart. These,
-and many others that might be mentioned,
are only slight and immaterial modification's
of names; on which no reasonable, but a cap-
tious plea only of misnomer can be founded.
It is indeed the genius of the English prac-
tice, to observe an extreme and punctilious
accuracy in such matters; but I cannot find,
that in this respect we have ever been dis-
posed to follow their example, but rather,
and I think with as sound a judgment, to dis-
regard such criticisms as unseemly niceties,
wnich serve only to disappoint the course of
justice, and to bring the law itself in to contempt.
" And here, I may refer to the case of El-
speth Robertson, where an objection of this
character was urged without success. On her
indictment for child-murder, [Oct. 29, and
Nov. 5, 7, 15, 1728,] this woman pleaded^
that there is no such name as iSlspeth; at
least, that her name was not E/sveth, but
Elizabeth. The answer was, that Elspeth and
Elizabeth are truly one and the same name ;
and that under the name of Elspeth, letters
of exculpati6ti had been issued to her, at her
own request. A plea of the same character
was moved, and with no better fortune, for
Fyshe Palmer, on his trial at Perth for sedi-
tion, [Sept. 1793,] on a Hbel, in which his
name was. not spelt as above written, but
Fische?'--- Hume's Contm. Tr. for Cr. Vol. l,
p. 251.
• Mr. Huine. — ^The following is the state-
ment of cases on this point given by professor
Hume himself: — ** Respectmg the Jegree of
inaccuracy in the name or designation of a
witness which will serve to set him aside,
nearly the same rule will suit, as respecting
in erroT in ^e name of the panel himself.
A critical and punctilious accuracy is not in-
dispensable; but the citation is void if there
be any material variation, such as poay pos-
sibly mislead or deceive the panel, in his in-
quiries concerning the individual who is sum-
mohjed. In the trial of James Gray, [July 1 1 ,
1737 J It was held a, good objection that a
wlthcss was named Thomas Farm in the list,
who ^Ucrib^d his name Fairholme, which
2|7] 3S6E0RQE\III. Proceedingt agoifuiihe Reo. T. Fyske Palmer ^9tS
of cases which might be referred to. But,
my lords, in a case of this kind, I don't wish
to take up the time of the Court. I would
mention, however, that the regulation of
1672 can have no meanins, unless it be, that
the proper names, and tne proper designa-
tions be given. But this I must insist, that
the indictment, bearing the name of Fische
Palmer, as the panel's name, that is not Tas is
I attested by a certificate under the hands of
William 8teel Maxey, of Northill, Bedford-
shire, taken out of the parish register), the
name of the panel, but that his name dmers
in two letters, as I have already mentioned.
But, in addition to this certificate of the pa-
nel's name, I have to produce to your lord-
ships, authority of a different kind, if writ-
ten authority is not sufficient. Mr. Palmer
is a man of letters,t and is well known in the
Now, my lords, in a case which occurred
before the high court of justiciary, upon the
29tli of August, 1791, there was a person ad-
duced of me name of law, but it was ob-
jected, that there was there a mistake in the
name.
Lord Eskgrave—y^BS it in the name of a
witness, or a panel ?
Mr. Haggart—lt was the. name of a wit-
ness, in the case of Smith ; the person there
v,'^ designed Lao:, instead of Jjow ; there,
there was a difference of but one letter, here
there. is a difference of two letters. And in a
case of the name of Wilson, the same year,
.there was this obiection stated, that the witr
ness was designed Adertony instead of Andcr-
$on, one letter being omitted; but the objec-
tion was likewise there sustained.
Now, my lords, these are four of a variety
» ■
we often pronounce Farm in common dis-
course. In the trial of Dick and others,
XNov. 94, 1763,] Alexander Menzies was set
aside, being designed tailor in Dundee^ where
he did not reside at the time of citation. In
the same trial the hke objections were sent to
proof, witi[i respect to Alexander Macdonald
and Ann Vallentine, both described as dwell-
ing in Dundee ; but the proof was not suffi-
cient, and they were therefore received. In
the trial of Smith and Brodie, [Aug. 87, 1788,]
• Mary Hibbut was challenged, because her
same was written Mary Hubbart in the list:
one of the iudgcs gave his opinion for sustun-
jjig this objection, and the proseciitor then
consented to dismiss her. Ip the list for the
trial of Tenant and Molyson, [Dec. S8, 1789,]
jsobel XiCes was described as servant to Alex-
ander Clark; and it was sustained to set her
Aside, that she was not servant to Alexander
Clark at the time of serving the indictment.
In Wilson*s case, in January, 1700, William
Heard designed tenant in Ulston, was in the
list of witnesses; and it was held relevant to
exclude him, that it was not he who was te-
jiant there, but his brother, to whom he was
overseer or servant : but the panel failed to
prove his allegation. In the case of William
Smith, [Aug. 29, 1791,] a witness was re-
jected on account of a variation of one letter
only; and this with good reason, her name
\;)eing written Isobel Lav in the list, instead
of Isobel LaW' The like variation was equally
fatal in the above-mentioned case of Wilson,
where W^illiam Wilson was set aside, being
described as residing in .^nderstonelee, in-
stead of Jc(derstonelee, the true name of hb
dwelling-place. Even if the name be right,
atlll it may afford a ground of exception, if
the witness either is not designed at all, or not
in such a way as to distinguish the individual,
**1 will lay before the student some instances
also of judgments on the other side; though
as to some of them, I think there is room tor
difference of opinion* In the trial of Janet
lliddell for chdd-murder, [Dec. 29, 1701,1
JldTariim Patersoa was received though named
MargarH Paterson in the panel's copy of the
list. In the trial of William Smith, L-^tig. 29,
1791^] already mentioned, it was objected to
William Stoddart, designed ' collier at Siobb-
' hill ia the parish of ^rthwick/ that there
was no sucn place in that parish, thou^
there was in the parish of Newbattle ad^om-
ing : this objection was repelled. In the trial
orOwens and Collins at Glasgow for mur-
der, [Sept. 20, 1792,] it was objected, to Iso-
bel Maccallum, wife of John Maccallum, that
her maiden name was Fraaer, and that she
ought to have been described accordingly.
But Uie answer was justly held to be good,
that the individual was clearly distrngubhed,
and that in practice thb was an ordinaiy way
of naming a married woman/'— fume*! tamm.
Vol. 2, p. 181.
t Gilbert Wakefield having occasion to no-
tice a criticism by I^r. Palmer, thus speaks
of him;— " Sicut verissim^ interpretaturT.F.
Palmer ; vir doctus, ipgeniosus, et omni laude
cumulandus, ov xoajMc ux nv a|iot* ide6qua
barbari homines ac ne&rii, vei^ viw a«rwXridK>
ad solitudines Novs HoUandiae releglirunt ;
■■ sed sidera testes
Intendunt oculos."
SUva Crkiea, P. V. 45.
In Belsham*s Memoirs of the Rev. Theo-
philus lindsey, I find the following account
of Mr. Fyshe Palmer: —
" Among these sufferers, the person on
whose behalf Mr. Lindsey was in tiie highest
degree interested, was the Reverend Thomas
Fyshe Palmer, a gentleman descended from
a respectable and opulent family in Bedford-
shire^ who having oeen destined to take or-
ders m the established church, had been edu-
cated at the university of Cambridge, and was
a fellow of Queen's College. This gentleman,
in consequence of perusmg the writ^igs ox
Dr. Priestley and Mr. Lindsey, became a de-
cided unitarian; and being a man of an ar-
dent, active spirit, he devoted himself to the
pro{»gation of those principles^ which to hUa
S49]
jbf SfdstwJi*
A. D. 1793.
£250
literary world aa an autkor, and I have one
of his publications to produce in Court ; but
if this should not be deemed proper evidence,
winch I submit to ^our lordsnips is the regu-
lar and proper evidence, I uncterstand lile-
wise, that the name in this indictment is the
name of a respectable and honourable family
in Essei, and that the arms of that family,
and the arms of the family of my client, are
perfectly different
Mr. Maamochie, — ^Is Fyshe his Christian
name or his surname ?
Mr. Hagghrt. — I do not answer any ques-
tioos of that sort.
Lord E»kgrooe, — ^Whynot?
Mr. Heggart. — I submit to your lordship,
it is not incumbent upon me to give any in-
formation of that kind ; the learned gentle*
man himself ought to be able to answer that
question. But the question is unnecessary,
as Fysbe is a part, and a material part, of Mr.
Palmer's Dame, in the understanding of the
orosecutor himself, otherwise he would not
have inserted it at all.
But, my lords, I shall mention another ob-
jection before I sit down, which is insur-
mountable; for, next to that I have already
'stated, itb an indispensable requbite, that
the panel sboold be served with a true copy
of the libel, as laid down by the regulations
of 1672.
My lords, I hold in my hand the indict'
ment served upon the panel, and in one part
there is a total deviation in words, ana in
sense. Now I shall mention to your lord-
ships what that is, if your lordships will be so
^ood as de«re ibe clerk to read the first para-
graph of the hand-bill.
Lord Eikgraoe. — If there are any witnesses
here ibr or against this gentleman, they are
desired instantly to come into the place ap^
pcnnted for them ; and if they remain here
after this notice, they will be committed to
inrisoii ; and they will have time to consider of
at before they get out of that prison.
appeared scriptural and evaneelical. In the
j^ 1799, be was preacher of the unitarian
doctrine in ScoUand, where his official la-
Dcnirs were chiefly employed in the town of
Dundee, in which a considerable society of
unitarian worshippers had been formed, by
the united exertions of himself, Messrs. Chris-
tie, Millar, and other respectable inhabitants.
Mr. Fyshe Palmer was a man of excellent un-
derstanding, unimpeachable morals, and of
great sim^icity of character; and being a
zealous friend to liberty, and upon all occa-
siMis ardent, he, perhaps inconsiderately, was
concerned in the repubtication of an Address
to the People of Scotland, concerning th^ re*
form oi parliament ; for which, in the autumn
of 1793, he was tried by the circuit court of
jo^^daryJ'-^Beiiham'i Mtmtrin of Undsey^
p. 351.
fioflwell has recorded the particulars of an
iatermw between Dr. Johnson and Fyshe
Palmer, m his life of Johnson, vol. 3, p. 381.
[The clerk read.]
' Friends and fellow citizens,»you, who by
< your loyal and steadv conduct in these days
' of adversity, have shown that you are wor-
^ thy of at least some small portion of liberty,
*' unto you we address our language, and tell
^ our fears.'
Mr. Haggari-^'Sow, my lords, in the copy
served upon the panel, it is, < unto you we ad-
* dress ^our language ;' totally different in
words, in sense, and in every difference that
I can possibly conceive. If they were their
own words that they were adchessing to them,
this panel could not have been brought to
your lordships bar for addressing his words ;
but it is unnecessary to illustratey-^the thing
itself is so obvious to any body who under^
stands the English language, or thelangaage
of Scotland, that I am sure it will not be ar-
gued on the other ude, that there is not a
pointed, a clear, and indbputable variation.
And, my lords, upon that ground, I do sul^
mit to your lordships^ that it is impossible
that this indictment, m the first place, cao
apply to the panel at the bar ; or, if that ob-
jection should be got over, that that impio.
priety, that capital mistake in the word your^
instead of our, ought undoubtedly to cast this
indictment.
Mr. JlfocoiMcAitf. •— My lords, I cumot
hesitate a moment in presuming vour lord-
ships will fiod the objections to this indict-
ment deserving' no serious consideratioB.
This trifling deviation in the spelling cannot
possibl}r be of any consequence, when the pro-
nunciation is exactly the same, foty alliiough
Mr. Ha^gart had strained his voice to the
utmost pitch, I do not believe he made the
pronunciation the least different ; and as fkr
as my powers of pronunciation go, I cannot
find any possibility of making a distinction;
they appear to be pronounced the same.
We cannot suppose the public prosecutor
could have corresponded with Mr. Palmer so
as to have the opportunity of knowing the
Erecise letters he used in spelling his name;
e had spelt it so as exactly to hit the pro-
nunciation, which is not in any desree affected
by the difference. And it would be a strange
thing, if the public justice of the country was
to be disappointed, merely because a gentle-
man chose to speU his name in a particular
way.
The learned gentleman had adduced cases
indeed, and those from very great autkotUy^
his own manuscript notes 1 but they do not
afiect the case in ]K>int, and, my lords, I think
it is hardly necessary to make any observa-
tions as to them.
In the first case cited, they were two difib-
rent names; Low and Law are as different
names as can be conceived; andwhm the
panel was desired to inquire afler a witness of
the name of Law, he was put upon a fleise
scent. I should therefore suppose that, in
the case of a witness, there can be no doid>t
but that was ah improper designation;, and
251] S3 GEORGE III. Proceedhgi agaUuiike Rev. T. Fyshe Palmer [258
in the case of a paael, tike name being per-
%^tlv different would be a sufficient ground
lor the objection being sustained ; but wher^
is the difference liere ? — There seems none.
Mr. Hagg^'s seoood oljecUon is still more
insigtiificiuity suppose the prosecutor was to
pass from the erroneous hne altogether, — I
suppose that is not the passage in tne indict*
ment upon which he wholly relies ; but they
do address language^ which language is cir-
culatedy and forms the gist ^ the indictment
This would introduce stranse doctrine into
the court, that an indictment should be render-
ed indfectuai for such an evident, trivial, and
unmeaning error in transcribing. The spirit
of the law aims at substance, not merely at
words.
Mr. Btime^^— My lords, I have only to add
to what has been now so properly stated, that
the ol^ection, which has just been urged by the
counsel for the panel, resolves itself into this
not that there is any enor m the designation
of this man, not that there 4s any doubt to
whom this indictment applies, but the objec-
tion that has been urged is, liiat there is an
error in two letters in the christian name of
this panel. It happens that the prosecutor
lias spelt it Fische, in place of what Mr. Pal-
mer now chooses to say it ought to have been.
In what situation does this ^ntleman appear
at the bar? There are productions here,
which I shall have oocasion to 'State to Uie
jili;y as written evidence, in which he has
written his name T. F« Palmer. This gentle-
man, so long as he has been in this country
has not favoured us with spelling hb name;,
he pleads that we have not sp3t his name
right ; it was utteriy imposable for the prose-
cotor to know what was his christian name
when he wrote it in that manner. Had we
erredrin the pix>]>er name of this oum, had we
erred in his desienation, tiien it would not
apjpear lo whom ue indictment applies : but
this is an error in a small addition which he
has chosen to ^ve to the name of his family.
I understand his proper name and family Is
charging him with sedition, such an error
.would materially affect the cause. Here the
difference is of no consequence.
Under these circumstances I submit, vour
lordships cannot listen to the objections, there
being no material deviMion ; and though by
the Eiw of EngUtnd, which does very often
give effect to matters of form, and often leaves
out the substantial part of an indictment of
this kind, they might be sustained, yet the
law of this country, which does not follow
that of any other country, disallows them.
Mr. Haggatt, — ^My lords, theanswers which
have been made by the counsel for the Crown,
are such as I expected ; as they had no suffi-
cient answer to give me upon principle^ they
took the liberty of stating theu* own opinions,
and pretty strongly their own averments, in
opposition to my authorities ; my authorities
stand as they did, their opinions will not alter
them.
As to what has been said by Mr. Maco-
nochie, of the pronunciation being the same
no attention can possibly be paid to it, since
if pronunciation were to regulate judicial ac-
curacy, that procedure woula vary with every
different dialect, and be eitremely inaccurate.
It is impossible that gentleman can himself
be serious in maintaining such a proposition,
and at any rate it can never be adopted.
As to the attack which Mr. Maconochie
has nikde oh my tone of voice I did not ex-
pect the time had been just yet come when I
was to have been indicted on that head, much
less could I have expected Mr. Maconochie
would have been the indicter.
' The obseivation of the advocate depute,
that the precision of the desisnation ought tp
do away the inaccuracy of uie want of two
letters, is of as little weight as that of his
assisting counsel ; both name and designation
ought to have been correct.
My lords, the learned gentleman has said,
that Mr. Palmer, in his practice of writing his
name, had only written, T. F. Palmer; that is
a mistake, and I did not expect it to have been
that of Palmer. 'Indeed different modes of I stated; for he must know that, when this
spelling names are very common. Now, sup-
pose this eentleman's name had been Stewart,
aome speU it with a w, and some spell it
withu; suppose his name had been Stewart,
and he had been used to spell his name with
the w, I submit to your lordships, it would
not have been a valid objection to this indict-
ment, that it was spelt Stuart ; but my lords
Fyshe is the mere christian name of this
man; it is not his proper name, it is not the
name of his £unily. And, my lords, I could
adduce many names in like manner ; Smith,
SoQrth; Millar, Miller ; Abercrombie, Aber-
cromby; Burnett, Burnet.
JAy lords, another objection (but which is
so trifling as scarcely to require an answer)
is, that the record copy or the hudictment
differs from that served upon the panel. Had
the recoil copy chatged him wi^ murder,
and had he been aeivSd with an indictment J
gentleman underwent a formal examination,
he did spell his name at length, Thomas
Fy^e Palmer. In the publication that I hold
in my hand, it is spelt in the same way ; let
them deny that fact if they can.
My lords, the name of Fyshe is the proper
name of his family, and I will tell your lord^
ships, though I am not bound to tell the pub-
lic prosecutor; that this gentleman's Either
was the first who chang^ his name from
Fyshe to Pakner; so that I do submit to your
lordships my objections stand unconfuted;
and I do trust they will be attended to by your
lordships in an important case of this kmd.
Lord E$kgrote, — ^If the panel^ad not been
properly served with the indictment tlie «rror
is material. We have, in this country, as fair
a mode of trial as any id the world, and ar^
real objection would certainly be sustained.
But if tbe first ebjeition be sustained^ what
853]
/qt Sedition. ,
A.D. 179S.
[954
is the consequence? obIv to poetpone his
trial fiApeo dajt longer, till a new indictment
could be served ; and he would be committed
to priaooi so that it is a mere matter of moon--
shine which can serve the panel no eood pur-
pose. With respect to the merits of the ob^
jectioo, the instances that have been given
were only those of witnesses ; — ^witnesses are
tffought into court to ^ve evidence for, or
against a party, the trial is commenced befoie
they come, and there is no such thing as post-*
poning the trial, if he is not properly brought
before the court ; and when a man of the
same of Thomas is called as a witness, and
fais designation is James^ he is a person not
summoned ; and the law will not allow a man
to volunteer, to come and give evidenee^ he
is compelled to come ; that would be a final
deciaon of the matter, and the trial must go
on. So that the greatest attention is neces*
sary in the summoning of witnesses. Not
(me of these olnecUons meet the present case^
which is that of an alleged error in the name
of the person broueht before the Courts whieh
if sustained, woula only answer the purpose
of a few days dday. But even were they
casea of the same nature, and were they ob-
jections to the panel, instead of to witnesses,
they would none of them meet the present
case. In this case the identity of the panel
is proved both by name and designation. In
the case of Brodie I had the honour to sit
upon the bench ; there, it was the case of a
man whose name was known to all the peo-
ple there, to be a different name from that l^
-which he was designed; and the families were
well known to be- as distinct as the names
and families of an;f two gentlemen in ih\&
court. Every man in court knows the mate-
rial difference between the names of Low and
Law. We have, heard of the famous Law
who went from France to the Mbsissippi, and
we know him to be a different man from pro-
vost Low of Brechen. If this objection were
sustained, inexplicable difficulties would occur
in the practice of our courts. I know of
Stewarts, my own relations, who differ' from
one another in the spelling, of their name, as
Mr. Burnett has mentioned. If a person
wrote the name of Stewart as applicaole to
the office of steward, and thought if after-
wards better to call it Stuart; and an indict-
ment was to come against him by the name
of Stewart, and it had been objected to, would
it not be a strong answer to show tiiat the
name was formerly Stewart ? In this case is
not the pronunciation exactly the same? Nay
is not the pronunciation of y and i in such
cases veiv generally alike? whether Mr. PaU
spelfsnis
name with a y or an i, still is he
not a fak f Your lordship's own surname is
often wrote b^ persons wittt a y at the end of
it, instead of le ; and the same with my own
name, some, particularly in England, spell
my name Ray, some Rea, and others Kae,
and yet no man would hAsitate to say they
meantthe samej therefore this objection is not
at all applkabte to the case ; the public prose*
cutor has named him right in pronunciSEtion at
least,, and Mr. Haggart* mentions no person of
the same name by whom a mistake cowdd pos**
sibly happen ; he has brought us no person
of the name of FisChe Palmer who also resides
in Dundee, and is an Unitarian preacher ; and
if there was any error at all, I must look to the
indictment ; and when I see a variety of writ-*
infp produced which are all signed T. F. Pal*
mer^ I must hold it as fiiU in evidenee, that
these are his writings, in which Palmer being
the principal name, T. F. is sufficient, to be
sure ; but that does not show whether it is
written with an i or a y.
There is another circumstance that is re-
markable, and that is, that there was a deda^
ration taken before the sheriff of Edinburgh,
when this gentieraan was called to answer
3uestiens>patto him, and after it was taken
own, he thought fit to refose to sign his
name, perhaps with a view to this objection, r
Mr. Haggari, — He was illegally appre*
bended^ mry lord.
Lord £fftgn7O0.— Illegally ! Hewasbrou^t
there legally for examination ; and his reftSai
to sign appears to me rather to favour the
suppofution that he did so in order to intro«
duce this quibble. ][t is no sisn of innocence
when a panel refuses to sign his name. But
farther, your lordship knows that, under this
name ofThomas Fiscne Palmer, when brought
before tiie sheriff^ he found bail ; and if he was
not the person, why is he here ? He is here
to answer to the name of Thomas Fische
Palmer, and he acknowledges himself to be
the person by coming to this bar; I do not
find fault with gentlemen in every case iot
making objections, far from it ; but I am peiu
fectly dear there is nothing in this objection.
I ma^ add, that even were it necessary to
have evidence upon the^ manner in which he
spdls hiS' name, such certificates as that
produced, brought we know not whence^
nor horn whom^ could not be admitted ; far
less his name' on the title of this piiblicatioh
of his, denying the Diviniti^ of Jesus Christ--
whether trat is his publication or not I do not
know, he is not impeached' here for denying
the Godhead of Christ.
With res]>ect to the second objecticnr, there
is 110 error either in the allegation of the crime
or the narrative, but merely in transcribing
the hand-lnll libelled. in omitting the lottery.
But this is not to be founded upon; it is -an^
evident error, and makes the reading non-
sense ; and even should this copy be errone<*
ous, how will tiiey set ovterthe printsd hand-*
bills themselves, vouch are lodged wiUi the
clerk of the court, agreeable to form ? — My
lord, I Uierefore think that, .upon the whole,
there is as little ground for this objection as for
the first.
Lord il60rci\»fi5y.— -I agree vrith yourlord-
diip in the observations that your lordship
has made^ Had Mr. Palmer beeft<:a}led as a
witness upon the trial of another person^ and
935] SS GKORGB IIL Proceedings against the Ret). T. Fyske Palmer [S5d
bad he been called Thomas Fische Pahiiet'y
and properly designed a Unitarian minbter, I
think it would be no objection to his being
received as a witness, though there was the
most satis&ctory evidence of a disconsonance
in spelling the name of Fyshe.
With regard to the second objection^ it is a
mere recital in the indictment, of the publi-
cation libelled, that does not affisct the cnarge
agunst him in any respect ; and more espe-
cially, as the original copies of that publican
tion are referred to in the indictment and
produced : I am free to say there is no ground
m the objections.
Lord Eskgrove. — ^Now, Mr. Palmer, these
objections l^ing repelled, I ask you again,
Are you guilty, or are you not guilty ?
Mr. Palmer, — I am not guilty, my lord.*
Mr. Haggart. — Mv loras, m what I am
farther to take the tiberty of stating to the
Court, I hope I shall meet with the approbar
tioQ of both your lordships. I certainly did
not mean to state any thing that was not of
importance, and if I have erred it is because
I conceived it to be my duty to my client.
Mv lords, the preceding objections bemg over-
ruled, I now come to the objections which
occur to the relevancy of this indictment ;
and, my lords, in arguing upon the relevancy,
it is necessarv to state the facts as taken for
granted, which is labouring under a ver^
great disadvantage ; and, if in any case it is
so, it is peculiarly so in this, when instead of
my client being the author of the hand-bill,
he does not bear that character. But, taking
the &cts as they are stated in this indict-
noent^ it comes now to be considered by your
lordships, in the first place. Is this indictment
accurately and properly laid ? Secondlv,
supposing it to be accurately and properly
laid, is uie publication arraigned in that in-
dictment libellous and seditious ; yea or no ?
And I hope I shall succeed in showing your
lordships, in the firstnlace, that this indictment
is not accurately lain ; and, in the next place,
that the crime laid upon the face of that in-
dictment (supposing Its accuracy), cannot in-
fer any punishment, or the pains of law.
My lords, I need not tell your lordships
what great sticklers for liberty have been our
forefathers; and so scrupulous have they
been, that there should be no infringement of
their established right and invaluable privi-
l^e of trial by a jury, that though, in every
other instance, they permitted form to give
way to substance, yet, so zealous sticluers
have they been for uiis bulwark of their li-
berty, that they permitted no innovation to
be made. The same essentials which are laid
down in the 80th chapter of the QuoniamAt-
tachiamentaf as requisite in a criminal indict-
•
* While Mr. Palmer seemed rather to he-
sitate, Mr. Clerk, one of his oounsel, called out
to him to say not guilty. Mr. Clerk's con-
duct was disapprove by the Court Orig,
Edit,
nient, are at this day held requisite. Frbm
the most remote period that we can trace in
criminal libels, the syllogistic form has been
adhered to ; and, excepting one solitary trial,
where the contrary practice took place, there
is no one instance to be found of the form be-
ing departed from. Now a syllogism consists,
as your lordships well know, in a major and
minor proposition; the major proposition
must contain, what is the crime that is
meant to be charged ; the crime is set forth
in the major proposition, and the facts chareed
in the minor proposition must make out that
crime which tne maior sets forth.
Now, my lords, allow me to call your lord-
ships' attention to the major proposition in
this indictment ; and let us see what the crime
is that is there stated. The words of the ma-
jor proposition are, — ^ Whereas by the laws
of this and every other well-governed realm^
the wickedly and felomously writing or print-
ing, or the causine to be written and pnnted,
any seditious or inBammatory writing, calcu-
lated to produce a spirit of discontent in the
minds of the people against the present happy
constitution and government of this country,
and to rouse them up to acts of outrage and
violence, by insidiously calumniating and
misrepresenting the measures of ^vemment,
and falsely and seditiously justifying and vin-
dicating the enemies of our country, with
whom we are at open war; as also, tiie wick-
edly and feloniously distributing and circu-
lating, or the causing to be distributed and
circulated, any such seditious and inflamma-
tory writing, are crimes of an heinous na-
ture, dangerous to the public peace, and se-
verely punishable—"
Now, your lordships will see what all this
is pointed at; it is directly and positively
saia, that the seditious writings here alluded
to^ must be calculated to inflame the minds
of^ the people against the happy constitution
and government of this countr}*. Now, allow
me to call your lordships attention to what is
stated in the minor proposition, which I sup-
Eose. for I can see nothing else stated, is this
and-bill. It is said, this hand-bill is an at*
tack upon the constitution of this country.
My lonls, I deny that there is any attack up-
on the constitution of this country from the
beginning to the end of it. I say, the most
perverse imagination cannot discover it. I
say, here is a free animadversion upon the
measures of government. I say, there is a
censure upon the House of Commons. I say,
there is a censure upon the executive govern-
ment; but shall I be told, that that is the
constitution of this country? I say, that the
constitution of this country is founded in &in^.
Lords, and Commons; and I say, there is
not in this paper any insinuation tending to
overthrow, or insinuating an attack upon the
constitution of this country, as so constituted.
I will aflerwards show, that the whole inten-
tion of tills was, to obtain a parliamentary
reform; but, iu the present sta^ of the argu-
957]
JbtSedUkm.
A. D. 1798.
[858
menty itis siiAeient for me to say, thut the
iwoaecutor has failed to make out, in the mi-
nor proposition, the charge contained in the
major. He ought to have stated other facts,
whether true or false, in order to have sup-
ported the major proposition; he ought to
Lave stated, that my client wickedly and se-
ditiously meant to overthrow the House of
Lords; hut there is nothing of that kind
stated; and therefore I submit to your lord-
ships, that the minor proposition can never
applv to the major profiosition, which is here
set KNTth. The syllogism is not complete ;
and unless the Court is, in this instance, to
dispense with the best established form known
in the law of this country, it is impossible that
any trial can proceed upon the present m-
dictment.
But, my kurds, as I have said, I hold it tq
be my inherent right, and it is the inveterate
practice of this country, to censure severely
the ministry, or any one department of go-
▼emment. These censures will be the means
of removing ministers if they are bad.
Jly lonb, holding, therefore, that such
censure is not only not blameable, but that
it is hi^ly praise*worthy, that it is hif;falv
mentonous m any individuals, who think
they are injured bv anjr thing under which
they labour, to tell thev fears and alarms; —
yet if, on the contnuy, they should exceed
juat bounds, if they should go to excess, if
tbev should use unwarrantable language, and
it should please the public prosecutor to come
forward, and say, you are guilty of using im-
proper and unwarrantable expressbns; it
IblJows, from the very nature of a criminal
trial, that it is requisite, that it u necessary,
that the panel be put in possession of those
facts, which are meant to be brought home as
criminal against him. No man, who sits
down to wnte, can write under the lash of an
imprimatur or a licenser ; and, though inac-
curacy of expression, or too much liberty,
may be used in one parwaph, yet, if the
whole is. meant for a laudable purpose, there
is DO precedent to show that that has been
foaaa £uilt with; but, when a criminal
.charge is brought by a public prosecutor, -it b
incumbent uoon him, to put the panel in a
flstuadon to anow what he is to answer;
.and, if it were necessary to illustrate, what
baa passed in this case already anords a
atrong proof of the expediency of the mea-
sure.
Hie paper which is arraigned, has already
been admitted not to be altogether libellous ;
pTf at least, the senior counsel for the Crown
baa said, that there was one passage which
Ac magtned was not to be founaed on. If so,
I sa]r, the public prosecutor was called upon,
by his duty, especially to point out those pas-
sages, or innuendos, as they are callea in
£nglaod, upon which he meant to draw his
.cpnciusion, that the publication was libellous.
.Without t^is, the panel could not possibly
al^pe his defence to meet, those pigrticular
VOL. xxm,'
passages which, at the time of trial, the pro-
seoutor might choose to select This the pub-
lic prosecutor has totally &iled in doing.
Here no one passage, more than another, la
pointed out; but the panel is brought to your
lordships bar upon tne whole of that hand-
bill; and is most improperly called upon, not
only to vindicate what is wrong, but to jus-
tify what is admitted to be right I say, that
this is not a precision, and this is not an accu-
racy that is agreeable to the usual forms of
this Court; it is totally adverse to the practice
in England, aa your lordships well know;
and I am not out of rule in applying to the
law of Bncland; for the law of England and
the law of Scotland are happily now the same
in these particulars. If, however, this inac-
curacy M also to be got over, I trust I shaU.
be entitled, as well as the prosecutor, to tadce
advantage thereof, in the remaming and most
important abjection.
But mylords^ on the supposttioo that I
should be so unfortunate, which I shall not,
as to fiul in satisfying your lordships thst
there is not here acomplele sylkigism ; and, in
the second place, altnoiigh I shoukl have
fiuled in satisfying your lordships, that the
prosecutors have «uy given me a paper, oon-
taining confessedly matter that is not bbel^
lous, intermixed, as he will aver no doubly
with matter that is Ubellous, and upon whicb
he means to found ; I say, thongh I shodkl
be so unfortunate as to have those objectkms
over-ruled, yet my lords, may I entreat your
serious attention to what I am now to stattf,
and that is that, takinc the whole scope of
this band-bill (and my dient must have tbb
same ri||;ht whkh the arosecutor has of takiaff
no particular passage, imt a complex view or
the. whole that is wntten) — I take upon ma
to say, that any person who will deliberatai|r
read it will be satisfied in his mind, will not
hesitate to declare, that the whole scope, and
the whole burthen of this publication is ifi
recommend another petition to parliament,
as the petition which had been presented waa
refused. And on calling' to recollection for *
moment the general opinion whkh for a lo^
time has been prevalent, of the necessity of n
parliamentary reform, and what has been tlie
general tenor of many petitions presented la
the House of Commons for attaining thatobject,
who can doubt that the object of the paper in
?Uestion was entirely directed to that end?
t is addressed wholly to those of a sl€«4lf
and loyal conduct, and expresses fears and
alarms. It details a list of grievances, sug-
gests ** a reform in the House of Commons,
founded upon the eternal basis of justice, fair,
free, and ec|ual," and calls on the friends of
liberty, to join in the recovery of *^ their lone
lost rights.'' But is there any thine in all
this which can be termed libellous r It is
true that the language is, in psriicular pas-
sages, firm and nervous, and in one passage,
the grievances may perhaps appear exagge^
fated, as in another the fears, it is hoped, are
'5
859] SS GEOIIQE lU. Proceedings against the &«. T. Fyshe Palmer £960
and-bjT take the liberty of meotioDBig to your
lordships. At this meeting house, a society;
consisting of a number of respectable people,
of the middling classes of society^ of manu^
facturers, mechanicSy and others, was held ia
•the town of Dundee ; and the members of
this society wished not to be beliind others in
showing, that they were zealous for the joint
cause, which your lordships know was a more
equal representation in parliament; whatever
their ideas may be upon that subject, I would
not undertake to detend them, but those peo*
pie have the same claim to suffrs^, as our-
senses, as I, and I believe a minority of land-
holders in Scotland have, when we contead
that 100/. Scots in land ought to be the qualifica-
tion, and which, at this moment we are all as-
sociatins and petitioning for and expect, I have
declared that 100/. is my minimum; that I
would be satisfied with tryine that experimenl.
I have been endeavouring, for years, to bring
down that to be the opinion of the inhabitants
of Perthshire; and though there are perhaps
one half of them of opinion, that it ought to
continue, I hope there is nothing seditious in
that. — ^ You, who by yom loyaT and steidy
conduct in these days of adversity, have shown
that you are worthy af at least some small
Iiortion of liberty, unto you we address our
anguaee, and tell our fears. ''<-^My lords, tiiere
is surely nothing seditious in this, but the
most loyal and steady attachment to the con-
stitution. Can a more chaste exordium be
imagined for the purpose, for which they
were assembled? They had petitioned par-
liament, but their petition was refused, and
their purpose was, to rouse up others to jjoin
them in a second petition, by whose united
efforts they hoped their petition would be re-
ceived, and as they believed (whether tijglit
or wrong is of no conseauence) the constitu-
tion would be saved. The pen of a Cicero or
a Demosthenes mieht have copied this; and
I will show your lordships that a great deal
of pains has Men taken to collect Siese pas-
sages tosether, and that nothing can be more
foreign from sedition than what these people
had in view.
<' In spite of the virulent scandal, or ma^
licious enorts of the people's enemies, we will
tell you wliole truths, they are of a kind to
alarm and arouse you out of your lethargjr.
That portion of liberty you once enjoyed is
fast settins, we fear, in the darknesa of des-
potism and tyranny ! Too soon, perhaps, you
who were the world's envy, as possessed of some
small portion of liberty, will be sunk in the
depth of slavery and misery, if you prevent it
not by your well-timed efforts/' The fear
which is here expressed, I h<^ as much as
any one is ill-founded ; but what then } There
is surely nothing seditious in expressing fear:
on the contrary, does not this strongly mark
the attachment of the assodaiHon toihe cea-
stitution ? If tliey had not had a sincere at-
tachment, they •could liave liad «b 'soob se-
sious !fe«r. If tdo 4here mu leaHyvedMiMi
ill-founded. But what then? Those very
fears show the determined attachment of the
Bereau Association to the constitution and
government; and the particular expresJHons
n\ade use of, as immediately will be shown,
are such as immemorial custom and the best
authorities support. In writings of any kind,
if particular passages only are selected, it is
an easy matter to find out the appearance of
exceptionable matter ; as any person may sa*
tisfy himself, by taking tO'pieoesanypartof a
political woik. But as tne liberty of the
press abhorred the lash of an imprmaative's
^od, it was from the ^hole scof)e ota writing,
explained by the time, place, and circum-
stances and impression under which it was
written, by which alone.it was to be inter-
preted. In arguing on the relevancy as I
CLOW am, I am obliged to suppose my oUent
the author of the puolication in question, but
it will this day appear (if the evidence shall
be adduced) who toe real author is. It will
appear that this publication was composed of
detached sentences eked together from news-
papers, the production of a journeyman weaver
copying what had been said before by his bet-
ters, who. by this very harmless, or certainly
well meaning occupation, is supposed very se-
jiously to have assailed our constitution and
gavernment.
I have admitted that the publication in
question contains some strictures and aaim^
adversions n>n the House of Commons, and
implies censure on the conduct of the exiecu'^
tive government: but who can maintain
4hat this is not warranted by the Hberty of
•the press, and by the first principles of our
government? Who can deny that the cus-
tom is immemorial and inveterate? But cen-
aures are not only not blamable, but are praise-
worthy and meritorious. They compel un-
worthy representatives and bad ministers to
l)ecome good, or pave the way to removal or
.punishment, if they continue to be bad.
But farther, not only is the general scope
not objectionable; even if the apparently most
axceptionable passages were to be culled, my
client would not commit himself by saying
they are warranted by the liberty of the press,
as defined by very high authorities ; and of
»much stronger language he certainly can
.point out, both in parliament and out of it,
innumerable examples : and in that case, the
consequence will be, that your lordships
must dismiss the libel as not relevant. If
your lordships have a printed copy of this
hand-bill, I nope your lordships will be able
to follow roe in the observations I shall have
the honour to make.
This hand-hill sets out with <' Friends and
fellow-citizens'' — It bears that " At a gene-
ral meeting of the Friends of Liberty, at the
Dundee Berean meeting house, they unani-
laously resolved to publish tbe following Ad-
dress to l^eir irienos ;*' and I am entitfed ^
eay, that these associations have precedents,
and pi:iBcedente of the bigkwr sort, asl will by-
9613
Jir SedUiotu
ui espressiog their fean^ is not the whole
pMsage gualdtd by the word perhaps f It
must be uooecessaiy to eolarge further on
this passage, as it is impossible to be main-
tallied that there b any thinj; like what ought
tp be constnied sedition in it. Is there the
shadow of any tlung like overturning the con-
stitiUion, or resisting any established autho-
rity?
Then go to the nest paragraph, and you
will see upon what these fears are founded ;
here is another enumeration of erievancesy
mod I will show your lordships authorities for
H^and I will sbiow your lorashlps the origin
of ic — ^ Is not every new day adding a new
link to our chains? Is not the executive
branch daily seising new, unprecedented and
uQwarraatsble powers? Has not the House of
ComBDons (your only securit^r from the evils
ofiyranuy and aristocracy) joined the coali-
tion against you i Is the election of its mem-
bers ettfaer fair^ free, or fire(|uent ? Is not its
indepeod^ce gone while ii is made up of
pensioners and placemen V* Now, your lord-
ships will aittena to what is the burthen, and
what is the sco^ the intention, the clear
and undoubted intention of this hand biU,
and the grounds upon which these alarms,
whether just or not, are founded. — ^' We have
done our dii^, and are determined to keep
our posts, ever ready to assert our just rights
and prkvili^;jB6 as men, the chief of vfhkS we
account the rij^t of universal sufferage, in
the choice of thSse who serve in the Commons'
House of Parliament, and a frequent renewal
of su6h power."
** We are not deterred or disappointed by
the decision of the House of Commons con-
cerning our petition. It b a question we did
not expect (though founded on truth and rea-
son) would be supported by superior num-
bers.—Far fiom being discouraged,'^— by what?
by the rejection of their petition, surely.-^—
^ Far iirom being discounted, we 9re more
and more convinced that nothing can save
ibis nation from niiq, and give to the people
that happiness whidi they have a right to
look for under government, but a reform in
the Hbouse of OmpEunons^ founded upon the
flenial basis of justice, fair, -free, and equal/'
Is this a libel upoa the constitution ? I s«^,
thne can be no worda better adapted ; they
are forcihle» and the occasion required an
energy of eiEpression to rouse the lethargic to
that measure, which it appeared to this 9ieet-
ing to be proper tp take; they mieht be er-
K>neous, but I say they had a right to hold
out these opinion^^ as well as a Locke, or a
Hiune, or any partizaa that ever wrote^ or
■oay write, or may hereaAer eiist. I snisht
go over the rest of this paraoraph, but allow
KM to cull and select out of this hand bill
tibofis passages which must be the most libeL-
Imtfif if there be any ISieUous matter here,
mmd allow me lio call your lordships atten-
tioo to ^ source of Ibis libellous matter,
if it is libdkm. YwjW loid^ps will then .
' A. a 1T9S- £268
attend to the first sentence which I take
for granted cannot be libellous. — " You who
by your loyal and steadv conduct in these
days of adversity, have shown that you are.
worthy of, at least, some small portion of
liberty, unto you we address our language and
tell our fears/' Now, then, follows a cati^
logue of the grievances on which tho^ fears
and those apprehensions are foimded. ^' Is
not every new day adding a link to your
chains?" The obvious meaning of this pas«
sage, must also supersede the necessity of
enlar|;iag upon it; it is the common cant e»«
pression for new taxes, extension of the excise
laws, or new burthens of any kind, and is
sunely very harmless. Now in the situation
of this country, we have no reason to expect
that tliese burthens will not be accumulating ;
the very expensive war in which we are en->
gaeed will necessarily increase that expense,
and every subject of this country is permitted
to have an opmion as to the necessity or im-
propriety of a war ; that is the common, and
what I take to be the obvious meaning of it;
and I dare say the author of this pa^er, whom
your lordships will have occasion to see before
you, will tell vou the same.
Then, my lords, if the explanation that i
have given of these words should be said not
to be a just one, why, my lords, I find in a
newspaper a &rther illustration of it. I don't
sav it is my opinion of the matter, but I find
other people think of chains more grievous
than those of accumulating taxes. The as^
sociators at the Berean Meeting-house, had
perhaps other fears suggested to them by the
speech of a very able a^ respectable member
of parliament, Mr. Michael Aneelo Ttaiylor,
in the House of Commons, inserted in the Star
of the %$d of February last, where he very
forcibly points out the inexpediency of the
plan which was then in agitation, or erecting
barracks all over the kingdom. He said, that,
" in the present temper and disposition of
parliament, any motion comins from that side
of the House on which he had the honour to
sit, no matter how constitutional, he had no
doubt would be met with the epithets of
seditious, factious, and inflammatory. Such
had been, indiscriminately, applied to every
motion broi^ht forward by those gentlemen
with whom ne had the honour and happiness
•f acting. In the present case he did not
suppose that recourse would be bad to the
stale assertion, that he and his friends were
the advocates of France, because they opposed
the most unconstitutional measure that ever
threatened the liberties of a free country. He
spoke as the advocate of Enzlishraen, and
supported those ancient prejuoices and jea-r
lousies, which, time out of mind, they have
manifested with respect to a standing army,
What could he a question of greater import or
magnitude than to see a large army raised in
the heart of the country, ana barracks erected,
to select and separate the soldiery from the
great mwi of thspeoptel At the W hour a^
963] 35 GEORGE lit. Procee£ngs against ike Rev. T. Fyske Palmer [364
"Which he rose, he did n6t wish to enter infe %
lar^ field of argument^ however copious or
ferule the subject On the subject of stand-
tne armies it would be still more superfluous,
when it was imprinted on the heart of every
true Briton, that no country^ which suffered a
kurge standing army to exist,' long boasted
the name of freedom. No man, however
great a sceptic in politics, would have rashness
or folly to oppose this doctrine. No nation
ever lost its lioerties, but by an armed ban-
ditti. The same army that elected Cromwell
lord protector, afterwards placed Charles
the second on the throne: there was no
reliance to be placed on the military the
moment they got the upper hand of the
people. The military had been always, and
ever should be watct^ with a most jealous
eye. Impressed with the impolicy of encou-
TAging a standme military force, it was stipu-
lated, in the Bul of Rights, that no army
should be raised without the consent of par-
liament, for, if once that was not the case,
SLrliament should shut up the doors of the
ouse. During the present reign, the
ttandine army had been much the same ; but
since the reign of queen Anne, it had aug-
mented to the number of 18,000, a number
by much too large. — He reminded the Uouse
that if they did not agree to his motion, that
a great augmentation was meditated in the
peace establishment. He had seen, he said,
a letter from the secretary at war to the gen-
tlemen appointed to raise independent com-
panies. I'he letter was of great publicity,
and declared, though the war did not ])roceed,
the captains were to proceed in raising the
complement of men required. To smooth
their conduct, ministers say we have no
cause for apprehension in the military, as we
may place the most implicit futh in the offi-
cers. It would be invidious to say, that be
would not trust the officers, but the nature of
the service rendered them obedient to the
Crown, they looked up to the Crown for pro-
motion, and therefore as an augmentation of
the armjr was adding to the prerogative of the
Crown, in a constitutional point of view he
could not accept of the confidence, which it
is sud ought to be placed in military gentle-
men, as a sufficient apology for the conduct
of his Majesty's mimaters. That the prero-
gatives of the Crown were not axiemented by
an wigmeutation of the army did not admit
of derate, for we hate recent instances where
officers have been struck out of the list of
the army, without ever being called to a
courtrmartial, merely because it was supposed
that they held opinions inimical to aominis-
tration. It would, he had no doubt, oe
arniedonthe opposite side, that a mutiny
bin must take place annually. It was happy
for the country it was the case in times like
the present, aiod when it was next brought
forward he would make some objections,
which he defied the HiMite in its-candour to
Rsitt. Before he tubmitled his motiou to
the House, he would state the grounds on
which he proceeded. The army estimates,
and its augmentation were generally voted in
a thin House, and no satisnctory reason was
scarcely ever given for the measure. Why
was a standing army admitted in a fines
country? merely because there was a con-
nexion subsisting between the soldier and the
citizen, that rendered it impossible for the
militaiy to carry into efiect anv measure
repugnant to the constitution, or the liberties
of^ the country. Blackstone bore him out in
this assertion, which was strengthened by the
arniments of Mr. Ptettiam, Mr. Pullen^, and
other great men and eminent politicians.
Mr. Hurdy, in 1748, arguing against an aug-
mentation of the army, ask^ the House,
' What would be the object if the troops were
* drawn from their quarters ? If they were not
' continued to be quartered on publicans, bar-
' racks would instantly be erected. This would
* lead to a despotic government, and that
* friendship contracted between the citizen and
' the soldier, would by their beinz denied a
' friendly intercourse, turn into dislike and
' hatred. They would, thus disposed of, begin
*to look upon themselves as masters, and
^ would be ready to obey all ordevs, though
* directed to use their bayonets against their
^ countmnen.' Mr. Pultenev was ever deci-
dedly, for these reasons, also against the
erection of barracks ; and Mr. Pelluim looked
upontliem as the greatest terror to a free
nation. These were sentiments delivered bv
men in power at that time, and were sucn
sentiments as he could wish to see manifested
in the conduct of the minister of the present
day. He quoted a passage firom Gage. In
1739. he had also declarM, * That nothing
' could be more fatal than to have a large body
* of the military confined to barracks, and kept
' in force : such a measure was the finishing,
* he declared, to the liberties of a free nation/
The men should be ever quartered on publi'-
cans ; for barracks were fbrtressei calculated
to involve the kingdom in destruction, whence
soldiers were always ready to rush at the insti-
gation of any despot or enemy to their country,
if such a scheme was apprehended or medi-
tated, it was the duty of every Englishman to
draw his sword, and not to sheath it until the
authors were^ punished. There may be new--
fangled doctrines opposed to these arguments;
but what he had stated were strictly accor-
dant to the wholesome rules of the constitu-
tion. He was aware that one apology would
be made, that it was a great hardship to the
inns to have the troops billetted on them,
because that thev receive no more at present
than they have done several years ago. This
was a matter easily obviated; for let the
dragoons pi^ the same as others, and in this
there would be a saving to the nation, as it
would render the erection of barracks lume*
cessary. It would be also said, that troops were
better disciplined vdien in barracks, than
when billetted on the public; astotbeirdis*
t65]
•Jot Stfmi9dtt»
it W9$ ft OMitter of little GoneMCy if
fhej ¥rere not diadplined agunst the constt-
tatkm. Banscks have ever been erected in
§FPt couBtfies to overawe the people, and are
generally fortresaee from whence military
sally ftrth to stifle the murmurs of the public.
He declared, that he believed in his con-
sdence^ the only ol^iect for erecting bamcks
wasy to create a disunion between the mili-
tary and the people. The present minister
had been calleMl a dorioos, an imniaculate
and a eonstitutionar minister. He sincerely
wished that the friends of the constitution
should be tried like the friends of religion ;
not by their words, but by their deeds. It
has Men said by a ttntlemauy whom he
hoped to see support him this night (Mr.
Itoke) that the * Influence of theCrownhad
* ineressed, was increasing and ought to be
' ^minished.' If anv thing had since that
period been pared off the mfluence of the
Crawn, Bfr. Pitt, he said, had taken care to fill
up the dMsm, hv the patronage of India, and
other matters that rendered that influence
more formidable than ever it has been at any
former period. He was concerned to see so
many oesertiiiff from the standard of liberty
to tally roumf the throne. He was not
averse to tiie piety of administration, but he
was coDcomed to see men dead to the
foelingB of liberty, crowd to church to
tiear contending priests debatins of divine
lights and passive obedience. Mr. Taylor
cmiduded by moving, that the House should
eipress its abhorrence of the system of
erecting bamcks, a system reprobated by
the abfest political writers, whose recorded
ojpinionwas, that it was totally inconsbtent
vnth the soirit of our firee and excellent con-
stitution, tnat the soldiers should be divided
Irom tiie great mass of the people by being
quartered m barracks.*^
My lords, I have taken the liberty of stating
iM^mlj that I may not be charsed with
quoting partially; and your lordships will
see, in wnat strong language this gentleman
speaks of the unccmstitutional measure of
raising barracks; that the intention of it is,
to separate the standing army from the
people, and consequently to add new chains, or
stieidithe power of the executive government.
Thb barradc svstem was not defeated by Mr.
Michael Angelo Taylor's speech, or by those
other able speeches that supported his side of
the question. The associators at Dundee had
seen barracks afterwards erected at Perth,
which was not very distant, and the comuMm
report being, that other erections of the same
kind were to be made in the vicinity of
Dundee, they had surely as much reason to
have their fears and alarms as any member
of the House of Commons ; and they appeal to
the wsnage which has beoi read, that their
A.. D. 1793.
[966
* See in the New Parliamentaiy History,
Mr. M. A. Tavloi's speech m the House of
Commons, February Sfnd 1793.
fliars are more moderately and chastely ex-
pressed.
Now, my lords, will your lordships be
pleased to go to the second interrogator}',
which I apprehend will likewise be said to
contain the most libellous matter } **1% not
the executive branch daily seizing new, un*
Srecedented, and unwarranteble powers?''
7ow, my lords, what b the meaning of this f
Why I will immediately refer to parliamentary
language ; but, in the first place, I would call
your lordships* recollection, to what has been
these hundred years past the uniform Ian*
guage both in parliament and out of it. I
will go no fiiurther back than Mr. Dunning's
celebrated motion in the House of Commons
(which is in the recollection of all of us) that
the ^ influence of the Crown hasi increased,
is increasing, and ought to be diminished.'^
Did not thus a regular vote of the House of
Commons say as much as this hand-bill says f
And was it not proclaimed in all the news-
papers?
But in addition to this let us remember Mr.
Burke's famous Refoiln bill for taking down
this ** influence,'' and his speeches on that
occasion ; Mr. Burke was surely a fitter obiect
for an indictment than Mr. Palmer. I snail
just beg leave to read a very small part of this
speech.
^ You would," said he, ^ have the court
deserted by all the ndbiUty of the kingdom.'^
*' Sir (addressing himself to the Speaker),
the most serious mischieft would follow.
Kings are naturally lovers of low company ;''
Lord £ffAgro9e.«-Then low company should
like kines.
Mr. Haggart, (Continues reading) ^ they
are so elevated, above the rest of man-,
kind, that they must look upon all their
subjecU as on a level : they are rather apt
to hate than to love their nobility, on
account of the occasional resistence to their
will, which will be made by their virtue,
their petulance, or their pride. It must in-
deed oe admitted that many of the nobility
are as perfectly willing to act the part of
flatterers, tale bearers, parasites, pimps, and
bu£foons. as any of the lowest and vilest of
mankina can possibly be. But they are not
properly Qualified for this object of their am-
bition. The want of a regular education,
and early habits, with some lurking remains
of their dignity, will never permit them to
become a match for an Italian eunuch, a
mountebank, a fiddler, a player, or any re-
gular practitioner of that tnbe. The Rtunan
emperors, almost from the bepnning, threw
themselves into such hands ; and the mischief
increased every day, till the decline, and final
ruin of the empire. It is, therefore, of veiy
great importanoe (provided the thing^is not
* See the Debate in the House of CiMnmons
on the above Resolution moved by Mr.
Dunning in the New Pariiamentary litstory,
Vol. SI, p. 340.
967] 33 G£ORGE IIL Proceedings agaimi ike Rev. T. Ftfshe Palmer [868
overdone) to contrive such an establinhmeot probsteB them aa oppreflaive in the highest
as must, almost whether the prince will or sense, (reads.)
not, bring into daily and hourly offices about I '* But at the same time, the rigour and
his person a peat number of his first no- arbitrary proceedings of excise laws, seem
bility ; and it is rather an useful prejudice . hardly compatible with the temper of a free
that gives them a pride in such a servitude.
Though they are not much the better for a
court, a court will be much the better for
them. I have, therefore, not attempted to
reform any of the offices of honour about the
king's person/'*
What is this but saying, kings in general
are animals fond of low company f But was
this language of Mr. Burke thought sedi-
tious?, pfo, it was meant to enforce a great
plan of reform. The plan was approved, and
was carried ; and no prosecution was thought
cf acainst Mr. Burke.
my lords, I will now read to your lordships
the speech of Mr. Wharton, in the House of
Commons,f upon the constitution, and the
wmds that he makes use of in this mo-
tion upon the present state of the constitu-
tion. I shall not read the whole of it, but
he asserted (and said, he risked nothing by
Hm assertion, for no man would be haidy
enough to deny it,) and he pledged himself to
frove it in a committee of the House, '< That
all that was valuable to the people of this
country, all the provisions which were stipu-
lated to secure the peaoe and prosperity, the
individual hberty and the general property
of the people of this land, hm all been, since
the revolution taken awav-^All."
Here, my lords, \% the language of a mem-
ber of parliament; and there is a respectable
division in the House, of eleven to seventeen.
I do not mean to justify that language, but
^len such language is used in uie British
senate, and circulated in newepapers and
pamphlets through every corner of the king-
dom, is the panel to be prosecuted, or is a
society to be bhuned for speculative opi-
niMM on matters of g;ovemment? There is
no overt act of sedition alleged; no act of
But, my Lords^ laying that aside, is not the
eitensioa of the eicise laws a topic of con-
versation? And does any body pretend to
justify it? The only justincatioD that can be
made of it is, that a great deal of money is
raised by it, and that, I am sure, is the only
thing that would allow parliament to con*
tinue it; but it must be admitted that it is a
grievaace, and has all along been considered
as an oppression. And now, my kurds, allow
me at the same time to mention that which
every body sees in every newspaper, and
hears in every public and private company,
and what people in their own houses feel;
and let mo call your attention to the famgutge
in which the grave judge Bladutone con-
demns the extension ^ these laws ; he re-
* See New Pari. Hist. Vol. 91, p. 53, 54.
t See in the New Parliamenti^ Histoiy,
Mr. Wharton's speech on May 3ist t799.
nation. For the frauds that might be com-
mitted in this branch of the revenue, unless
a strict vratch is kept, make it necessary,
wherever it is establisned, to give the officess
a DQwer of entering and searching the houses
or such as deal in exciseahle commodities, at
any hour of the day, and, in many cases, of
the night likewise. And the proceedings in
case of transgressions are so suamaipr and
sudden, that a man may. be eonvieted m two
days time in the penalty of many thoieand
pounds, by two commissioners or justices of
the peace ; to the total exclusion of tlie tnal
by jury, and disregard of the common law:
For which reason, though loi^ Clarendon
tells us, that to his knowledge the Earl of
Bedford (who was made lord treasurer by
King Charles the First, to oblige his parlia*
ment,) intended to have set up the excise io
England, yet it never made a part in that un-
ibrUmate prince's revenue; being first intio*
duced on the model of the Duti^ prototypey
by the parliament itself after its rupture wiUi
the Crown. Yet such was the opinion of its
general unpopularity, that when, in 1049,
^ aspernons were cast by malignant peisona
* ufkon the House of Commons, that they
^ intended to introduce excises, the House fot
* its vindication therein did declare, that these
'rumours were fiUse and scandalous; and
' that their authors should be apprehended,
* and brought to condign punishment' How*
ever, its original establishment was in 1643,
and its progress was gradual; being at first
laid upon those persons and commodities,
where it was supposed the hardship would be
least perceivable, viz. the makers and venders
of beer, ale, cyder, — "• — ^When we are roused
to complain to parliament on that head, no
wonder strong langiuigje is used, when now,
without exa^eration, it may be said almost
eveiy thing we eat or drink, comes through
the hands of an excise officer.
My lords, with these variety of examples,
with the language of parliament, the autho*
rj^ of BlacJutone, — and if it were not de-
tainingi your lordships, I migjht quote more
authonties, for it is the daily practtcey—
but — I say, with Mr. Dunnins's motion, the
Opinion of Blackstonc, and the speeches in
the House of Commons, I put it home to
Cr lordships, whether the language of this
d bill is not comparatively moderate ? i
sav, it is lau^uase chaste in the extreme,
which it is entitled to a Briton te use, and of
which, I trust, your lordslups will not de*
prive him.
Now, ii\y lords, I will refer your lordships
to the third interrogatory ; if I am taking up
too much of your lordships time> it is not
mtmmm
!•«■•*■
• 1 Bl. Com, dl8.
269]
fit oitBMMfU
A. D. 179S.
[270
my UaiBiis, tiife libel being laid so iodeB*
Bittlv, that I am obliged to go thrmigh the
whole of it.
Lord i<ferCTtfw6tg.*>-Takc vour own time.
Mr. H^ggort. — I am much oMiged to your
loidship.
Lm AbercrmMe. — ^No, you are not obli-
ged to me^ it is your privilegp^ and your right
Mr. Hii^«rf.-»My lords, the third inter*
logaitoty iSy *' Has not the House of Com*
moas (yonr own securitjr from the evils of
tyranny and aristocracy) joined the coalition
against you f^
And now, let me call your lordships at-
tention to a petition from the Friends of the
People in Lonoon to the House of Commons
on the 17th of May last. I shall not read
the whole of it, although the whole of it is
much stronger than any thing that is here;
but I shall rad this paragraph,
^ Your petitioners inform your honourable
House, ano tbey are ready to prove it at your
bar, that they have the most reasonable
Erounds to suspect that no less than one
hundred and fifly of your hooourtible mem-
bers owe their efections entirely to the inter-
ierence of peers; and your petitioners are
prepared to show, by legal evidence, that forty
peers, in defiance of your resolutions, have
fK>ss^5ed themselves of so many burgage
tenures, and obtained such an absolute and
uncontrolled command in very small boroughs
in the kingdom, as to be enabled) by their
own positive authority, to nstum eighty-one
-of your hoBoorable members/' *
My lordSy whether they can prove the fact
or not, here is the language, and that la»-
^uage is not looked upon as libellous or sedi-
tious. And, my lords, when it comes into
the great vdiicie of^the .|>ress, that freedom of
speech, that sacred covering which the mem-
bers of the House of Commons have, is taken
off, and you must take this either as a Inatter
libellous, or not libellous in itself. My lords,
in addition to this^ I may call to your lord-
shi|>$ reeollection what has been again and
again averred, namely, that the nabob of
iSvot faimaeif, returns fourteen members to
the House of Commons. The only dispute,
if I recollect right, is whether he returns
fourteen or seven. Is the language then of
this hand-Ull to be ibund fault with? Can
it be said, that eigbtv members introduced by
peers, is not an nigh aristocratical influence?
Can it be denied tmt members of the nabob
of Arcot are those of a tyrant ? I pray God,
that petitions and all legal means may be
used, that such language as this may be
used again and ^gaiu till this pestilence in
the constitution is rooted out. And I do
subnntto your lordships, that these instances
Mte infinitely stronger than is necessary to
^thorize the language here used, and will
Justify the use which is here made of it.
• * See m tthe New Pari. Hnt. the petition
presented by the honourable Charles [after-
^waids second earl] Grey on May 17th 1793.
Motr, my lordsy the neit query which fol-
lows (and I hope I shall soon exhaust the
libellous matter in this paragraph), is, ** Is
the election of its members either mir, free,
or fireauent?" My lords, if I have made out
my otner positions, which I submit to your
lordships I have made out, by the speeches
in the House of Commons, the aulliority of
Biackstone, and others whkh I sliall present-
ly read, I have shown, that the election of its
members is neither fiur, free, nor frequent; if
peers interfere, when constitutionuly they
nave no title to interfere, and if the nahob of
Arcot has so manv votes in the House of
Commons^ (and when a respectable petition
from London asserts that they will pro^e it,
yoii must take tiie fact for granted), it is a
monster in the constitution, and I sav, ner-
vous language may and must be used to get
rid of that monster.
Now, your lordships will allow me (and I
believe I shall have done upon this subject^
to refer you to the Morning Chronicle, that I
read above, and likewise to the Edinburgh
Gazetteer which is in your lordships hand.
I shall not trouble your lordships with repeat-
ing them; it is a repetition of the same pro-
positions as iu the second and third interro«
gatory.
The next interrogatory is, — " Is not its in-
dependence gone, while it is made up of
pensioners and placemen ? *' Tf I understand
any language, it is just a repetition of what
was said before ; that it is the fact is indfs*
putable, and it is as indisputable that^ being
the fact, it can be no libel whatever Upon the
constitution. Without troubling your lord'>
ships with reading any more quotations from
newspapers which I have in my hand, I
submit to your lordships, that talking in the
freest manner of the depraved -state of the
House of Commons is the language of par-
liament itself, and shall I be told, when that
is the fact, that I am not entitied to make
use of such language ? Is then such liberty
of speech lawfiu in newspapers and unlaw-
ful in hand-biils? No; nothine either libel-
lous or seditious can be attached to it Those
whose chief return from their members of
parliament are their speeches^ are well en-
tided to see them.
Now, my lords, to go to where I lefl ofF,-*-I
shaU not trouble your lordships with going
over the whole of it : *' We have done our
duty, and are determined to keep our posts,
ever ready to assert our just riehts and pri-
vileges as men, the chief of which we account
the right of universal sufTraee, in the choice
of those who serve in the Commons House
of Parliament, and a frequent renewal of such
power."
Now^ my lords, tliis your lordships see, is
complaming, that tiie rigdt of universal suf-
frage ought to be in thepeqple. As I have
already said, I will not take upon me to say,
what ought to be tfie state of representation;
but tbasl win 'take upon mQ to say|«^i«t they
37 1] S3 GEOJIGE UL Proteedingi agaimd ike Jim T* FyAe Pdmer [S72
have a right to hold ofunionsy and that they
have a rifht to speak it out; and, as I have
mention^ already, they are as much entitled
to have an opinion upon that subject, and to
petition pariiament, or to express their fears
to their members, just as much as I have.
Allow me to state to vour lordships, that up-
on this point there have been associations
and resolutions at former periods, and the
language here I take to be copied from those
resolutions. Here is a letter from his grace
the Duke of Richmond to colonel Sharman of
the Irish volunteers, in which he says, " The
subject of a parliamentary reform, is that
which, of all others, in my opinion, most de-
serves the attention of the public, as I con-
ceive it would include every other advantage
which a nation can wish; and I have no
hesitation in saying, that from every consi-
deration which I have been able to give to
this great question, that for many years has
occupied my mind, and from every day's ex-
perience to* the present hour, I am more and
more convii^ed, that the restoring the right
of the hon. William Pitt, on the fth instant,
for the appcuntment of a eommitteeto inquire
into Uie state of the representation of^ the
people of Great Britain, and to report the
same to the House ; and also wluit steps it
might be necessaiy to take, havinj^ been de*
feated by a motion for the order of the day, it
is become indispensably necessary that appli*
cation should be made to parliament, by pe-
titions from the collective body of the people,
in their respective districts, requesting a sub-
stantial reformation of the Commons House
of Parliament.
'* Resolved unanimously, That this meet-
ing, considering that a general application by
the collective body of the people to the House
of Commons cannot be made before the close
of the present session, is of opinion, that the
sense of the people should be taken at such
times as may be convenient during this sum-
mer, in order to lay their several petitions be-
fore parliament earlj^ in the next session,
when their propo!«dA for a parliamentary re-
formation (without which neither the liberty
of voting universally to every man, not inca- 1 of the nation can be preserved, nor the per*
pacitated by nature for want of reason, or by
law for the commission of crimes, together
with annual elections, is the only reform that
can be effectual and permanent. I am fur-
ther convinced, that it is the only reform that
is practicable." There is a publication that
never was conceived to be a libel, and the
language there is more direct and pointed
than any thing in the publication now before
your lordships. He goes on to say farther,
that ^ It is from the people at krge that I
expect any good. Ana I am convinced, that
the only way to msdce them feel that they are
really concerned in the business, is to con-
tend for their full, clear, and indisputable
lights of universal representation.'' There
was neither libel nor sedition supposed when
this came from the duke of Richmond.
Now my lords^ to 00 from that to the detail
of the meeting itself, which is directly the
form of this Berean Meeting-house Society,
only it happens to be at the Thatched House
tavern in London. (Reads) *^ At a numerous
and respectable meeting of members of par-
liament, friendly to a constitutional reforma-
tion, ai]^of members of several committees of
counties and cities : Present
The duke of Richmond,
Lord Surrey.
Ix>rd Mahon.
The Lord Mayor,
Sir Watkin Lewes,
Mr. Duncombe,
Sir C. Wray,
The hon. William Pitt,
The rev. Mr. Wyvill,
Major Cartwright,
Mr. John Home Tooke,.
Alderman Wilkes,
Doctor Jebb, &c. &c.
<< Relolved unanimously, That the motion
3
manenceofa wise and virtuous administnir-
tion can be secure) may receive that ample
and mature discussion which so momentous
a ouestion demands.''*
My lords, there is the resolution, and in
consequence of that, your lordshira know to
what extent associations took place. The
county which took the lead in thisjmat efibrt
for political reformation was that ofVork. Not
less than 600 noblemen and gentlemen as-
sembled at York and their example was
followed by 99 counties. The petitions of
these associations procured redress oy stopping
the American war ; while Burke's bill pro-
duced the reform. In some coiyities they pro-
posed to bind their members by oath^ to vote for
reform. Every man was at this tune called
to associate ; and addresses from associations
were never supposed libellous. No. my lords,
people of all descriptions were called forward
oy these high sounding names, every man
was dedarea to have a right to be free, and
to judge for himself. Since that time, peti-
tions and addresses have been still more fire-
quent. In 1784, a petition from the Associa-
tion of Dundee would not have been rejected.
Now, my lords, I take it, that the only
other paragraph with which I need troabie
your lordships is this^ ^ You are plunged into
a war by a wicked ministry and a compliant
parliament, who seem careless and uncon-
cerned for your interest, the end and deaiasn
of which is almost too horrid to relate, — ^ibe
destruction of a whole peo^, merely because
they will be firee."
Now my lords, here is a very strong and a
very pointed opinion expressed with regard to
the war ; but I am sure I can show mote
« See the Resolutions inserted in a note to
lord Erakine's Defence of Frost, awrl/ Vol. S3,
p. 49S
S75J
for SedUion*
A. D. 1793.
[274
pmnled avennentSy and stronger language
tl^n that which is used in this passage ; and
I take it, that no person will now say but
that, at least, there are great numbers of that
opinion, even the necessity of the war itself
eccasioned a great dispute and violent de-
bates in the House of Conunons, and after
the declaration of the minister, which your
lordships will allow me to read a single pas-
sa^ from, it is nossible that these Bcreans
might be alarmea, and that the words of the
minister himself might lead them to tear that
it might be continu^, till what were called
French opinions were totally eradicated.
Now it certainly will be admitted, that the
French revolution at its commencement, was
looked upon as a great era of liberty, and
there was no person whatever, but rejoiced at
H. It was the language of every person :
every body rejoiced at it. That corruptions
Itave crept in, that enormities have taken
pkice, every person must regret ; the French
Lave gone far indeed, but many respectable
people think the war is carried far likewise.
Ana to go to Mr. Pitt himself, when he de-
bated upon the war, he enlareedon the causes
of it, VIZ. — the principles of France. And
althcHigh he at first only threw out that till
these were totally subdued, ^e would contend
with them to the latest hour of our lives; he
afterwards said, he would not pledge himself
but he might interfere with their internal go-
vernment. This certainly supposed we were
io interfere with the internal and fundamental
S^vemment of France. Now, my lords, if
e executive government of this country is
to go the length of overturning that constitu-
tioD which was founded upon the basis of
freedom, I saj, if any other constitution is set
up by the allies, it is overturning a constitu-
tbon &at was universally acknowledged to be
a good one; and I say that these conven-
tioners, these persons meeting at the Berean
Meetine-house in Dundee, fiave a right to
hold ana express the same opinions which
the minority in the House of Uommons held
and expressed, that if the war was carried
fiu-ther than driving the French from Holland
where they had no title to be, it was carried
too Car : their frontier towns might also be
taken as hostages, but why again make in-
iwda into France ? Docs not this infer that
the minister wishes to interfere in the French
government, and, in conjunction with his
allies, to le^slate to France } It is impossible
to justify such an interference. I say, my
lords, impressed with these ideas, they have
made use of such language which, as I have
shown your lordships, was copied from their
superiors. It might also be said, we indirectly
were concerned in taking away the libertj^ of
the Poles. Russia and Prussia were the im-
mediale mstruments, we were their aUies. I
hope there is no Briton who approves of the
procreadings of these despots, and I trust we
are not^arout to follow tneir example in our
inlerference in France. Such interference
VOL. XXIII.
goes to the overthrow of all government.
The lust of the empress of Russia mlgtit have
been glutted by the dismemberment of Tur-
kev and Poland, — but her ambition is insa-
tiable and unbounded ; — her late manifestos
show that it is her will and pleasure that
liberty be eradicated from the face of the
earth.
Now, my lords, I cannot conceive of any
other passage that can be deemed libellous,
except one, and that is this, <^ A list of bank-
ruptcies, unequalled in any former times,
forms a part in the retinue of this Quixottic
expedition." With regard to the facts pre-
viously stated, there is ground for sajing, that
a great varietv of bankruptcies have occurred,
and that by the war your trade is sore cramp-
ed, and almost ruined, and that thousands
and ten thousands of your fellow citizens,
from being in a state of prosperity, are reduced
to a state of poverty, misery and wretched-
ness. I believe, my lords, that is not at all
exaggerated, whether from war or not I can-
not say, but it is certain that is the fact; and
as to the term Quixottic, the gentleman who
composed the address, perhaps wished to show
his great learning in having read Don Quix-
otte, but at any rate the term is extremely in-
nocent, by the word I understand notning
more than romantic ; and 1 say they were
entitled to say so ; and I believe most people
are now satisfied, that that which was once
thought a most pious thing, anS the forerunner
of an ascension into Heaven, a crusade to the
Holy Land, is ndthing but Quixottic.
My lords, the same language is used by
Mr. Fox in his letter to his constituents, and
that I should think would be sufficient autho«
rity for the use of this expression, if no other
were to be found upon record. If it were ne-
cessary, I might follow the duke of Rich-
mond to Ireland, and refer your lordships to a
speech of Mr. Grattan, who was called the
Irish Demosthenes, in which he uses great
strength of language ; and I shall bes leave
to read a single passage from it : — " The ar-
guments which tiie right hon. gentleman had
advanced on that occasion, wont only to
prove the necessity of taking measures against
the specific assembly, which was apprehend-
ed, not to show that the law of the land was
against all conventions whatsoever. The
question was then, whether a declaratory law
snould be enacted, or one pointed only against
a particular object. The papers, or* letters
missive, which the right hon. gentleman had
produced, showed it was become necessary
to guard against the specific measure that was
intended; out he would not, under that pre-
text, agree to a perpetual law ; as well might
they repeal the Haoeas Corpus law^ because
of a temporary rebellion.
'' But it was said, that the law of the land
is already what tlie bill declares it. He had
already considered that question. He had put
the question to the learned gentlemen, wne-
ther mere deputation to consider of matters
T
275} 33 GEORGS III. ProeeeJKngs againsi th^ R^, T* ^yAe Pdmer [979
of public copcero cQQstituied an unlawful a»-
^mbly? To ibis they had made no answer.
The next question was, whether this state-
ment arose from the act ? He here read the
preamble, and showed it declared, that depu-
tation for any of three purposes was unlaw-
ful : first, deputation for preparing petitions ;
second, for redress of grievances ; and, third,
for considering any matters of public concern-
ment. If then mere deputations for consi-
dering matters of public concern were not un-
law jful by law, the preamble of the bill de-
clared for law what was not so.
House having resolved itself into commit-
tee, Mr. Burgh in the chair, Mr. Grattan
went on ; he said —
" The gentlemen on the other side had not
S roved, that mere deputation, such as the bill
escribed, was illegal, but had confined them-
selves to assemblies, purporting to be general
representatives of the people. These, they
had said, w^re illegal, not because there was
any statute or any adjudication against them,
but by the principles of law : for as one repre-
sentative assembly, the Parliament, already
existed^ the people had no right to choose an-
other. But surely, if the purposes for which
this second assembly was chosen were dif-
ferent from those of tbe first, the bodies were
no longer of the same kind, and therefore the
argument did not hold. He granted, indeed,
that the people had no right to appoint an as-
sembly to exercise the fimctions of parliament,
but tney might appoint one for minor pur-
poses— as to petition parliament, and the
like. The argument was a quibble : if car-
ried to its full extent, it would illecalize all
those smaller representative assemblies which
are appointed b;f particular descriptions of
men for commercial and for religious purposes;
it did not therefore sup}H)rt the bill.
^ Gentlemen had taken pa'ms to confine
the idea of Ulegality to deputation from great
^dies of the people for national purposes. —
The bill was much more comprehensive^ for
It expressly declared ille^l all deputations,
committees, &c. purporting to represent any
* number' or * description* oflhe people what-
aoever, * in county, city, town, or oorough,' for
thepurpose of petitioning parliament, or consi-
dering matters of public concern.
" Gentlemen had also said, that no such
Relegated body had ever been tolerated in
Oreat Britain. The answer to that was, there
was such an assembly at this moment exist-
ing in Scotland, for the purpose of effecting a
Parliamentary reform. They had existed, and
D^en tolerated in England aliK>.'' — [He then
read several extracts from the Annual Regis-
ter of 1781, containing an account of the pro-
tcedin^ of a meeting of deputies from ' eigh-
* teen' hlnglish counties, appointed to present
t pet\^on to parliament on the subject of the
expenditure of public money, which petition
Was presented, and received by the British
Parliament.] — ^* This meeting, of which the
duke of Rutland, the marquis of Bucking-^
ham, sir G. Savile, lord 3peDcer» Edmund
Burke, and n^aoy oUiers ot the most dislii>«
guished characters in England^ were mem*
berSy was a complete refutation of tbe hon.
and right hon. gentlemen's as^ertioo^ that
deputed assemblies for the purpose of peti-
tioning and discussing matters of public con^
cern were illegal and unknown in England.
He wished, therefore, tiiat the words * Be it
' declared,' should be omitted, that the bili
might not be declaratory; and if gentlemen
would agree in that, then he should move
such amendments in the enacting part, as
would confine the operation of tbe Dill to tbo
specific assembly which was dreaded, and
also limit the duration of the bill to a year."
I am aware that it may be objected, that
these appeals to the language of parliament
are not in point, as a greater liberty of debate
has been allowed in parliament tnan out of
it. The answer is obvious. So long, un-
doubtedly, as the speeches of members are
not committed to writing or publication, the^
are not accountable for what they say ; and if
they are published without their knowledge,
they arc as little accountable; but the mo-
ment they appear in newspapers, they are
without the privilege of parliament, and tbe
publishers are accountable ; instance the late
case of the archbishop of York, who took up*
on him to say, that the hon. managen m
Mr. ^astlngs's trial acted like a parcel of
Marats and Kobespierres—not very decent
language fur a bishop. But in the House of
Commons, when it was argued, they had no
doubt that his grace could not be called to ac-
count for what he iiad said in his place ;* and
the only remedy was against the publishera
of the newspapers, in wlxich the speech ap-
peared. On consulting precedents, however^
they dropped even the prosecution of him, as
imn^emorial practice had sanctioned the news-
paper detail of speeches.
But it is not on newspaper authority
alone that n^ client has to rest; GroUiis,
Puffendorff, De liolme, Hume, and all writeca
of any note, who have canvassed constilu-
tionafquestions, are all agreed, that free and
unlimited commuoicatMn of sentiment is ea-
scntial to, and the great charactensUc of, free-
* Tbe expressions alluded to were uttered
by the archbishop of York [Markba^l.}» in
Westminster-hall, on Saturday, May 95tli»
1793^ the hundred and fourteenth day of Mx.
Hastings's trial, and were occasioned by tli^
manner in which Mr. Burke conducted nina*
self on the cross-examination of Mr« AurioL
On the 12th of June, Mr. Whitbr^d, in ther
House of Commons, complained of the arch-
bishop's speech, as reported in th.^ Wftf*
called '' The World,'* and mpved that it waae
scandalous libf 1 on the conduct of tb^ 9M^
nagers. Mr. Dundas thereupon moved an ad-
joiyn^^icnt, vfhicb, ^ adiviUQQ) wm carrM
by a voajbrity of 6Q to S^^— See the N«W ¥^l*
U»U vol.30.
I
877]
JbrSddU&n.
A. D. 1793.
IS78
doM. Let the csftll fcnti Ibrdalifps atftotiofi
to a fbreigA writer, Imt whose bbok has gont
dnfough as many edi^M as tliih sermons of a
T^sMctable der^maii. 1 teean to ofipose tb
Dr. BIftir the ' Constihitioh at Engfa^nd/ by
Mr. I>e Lolme; and t believe it has eveu
MEAiot Dr. Blalr; Th. Brair having gone
thtotigh bat i^ edItiofiSy and Dt Lolme, 1 be-
ttereThdving goAe throu*^ 24 edifrons, Whi6h
ilsrvtes to show #h«t fespcct the inhabitants
df this coimtiT bear to that writer. Upon th^
MitjiM of Kbels, he says, *< That though t6
squeak in of individuals was deserving of re-
fnrefciteiKsk>ni, yet the pubFic acts of govern-
taeni o^rik toK^ open to public ^xarhina-
iion, And that xl was a service done to the
itate to canvass then^ freely .''^[See Serjeant
OlytMi's speech for Wotodlall, in the pro&ecu-
tk>iti^nstthe latter, by the attorney gene-
ral, ior publishing Junius's * Letter ia the
Kior.'— Vd. fO, «f this Collection, p. 899.T
Tbete tb^ kin^ Was attaicked as an inai-
vidlttd; and he wserves-^ And indeed this
tttfeine security," speaking of th6 llbertv of
tttftj^Vte^ ** wHh Whi^h ever^ man in Eng-
Ittid is enabled to comnHmicate his senti-
KMnts to the public, and l!he genera) con-
cern which matters relative to the govem-
iiMt are always sure to create, has m^onder-
^ multiplied all kindis 6f public papers.
Ics thos^ which, being published at the
toA &t every year, moioth, or week, present
to tlv^ reader a recapitulation 6f every thins;
iiMereacing that may have been done or said
dtttiog their respective periods, there are se-
wenA ^filers, ^hich, making their appear-
ance everyday, or every other day, commu-
nicate to the public, the several measures
talcen by the government, as well as the dif-
£ftrent causiis of any importance, whether
civil or criminal, that occur in the courts of
jiafttice, and sketches from the speeches
^tiier of the advocates, or the judges^ con-
periled in the management and decision of
tbfeiii. During the time the parliament con-
tifiues sitting, the votes, or resolutions of
the House ol Commons, are duly published
by aitth^ity; and the most interesting
Meeches in both Houses are taken down in
aAott-htnd, and communicated to the public
mtkmt.
** Lastly, theorivate anecdptes in the me-
ta^vpolis^ and tne country, concur also to-
wms filling the collection ; and as the se-
vi^ral poblic papers circulate, or are tran-
^lerftea into otners, in the different countrv
townSy and even find their way into the vif-
Ijgiifly wheiv evsty itiim, down to the la-
b«u#er, peruses th^m with a sort of eager-
BMBi every individual thus becomes ac-
cpudnied with the state of the nation*, from
M6 end td the othf^r; and by these means
ibt general intercourse is such, that the
three kingdoms seem as if they were one
■Bue tklwtl.
fAM H b ttts public ndtofietv of all
llniqfi^^ IhM MtttitntM th^ supptement^d
power, or check, which, we have above said*
IS so useful to remedy the unavoidable ha-
sufficiency of the laws, and keep within
their respective bounds all those persons
who enjoy any stiare of public authority."*
By this it is not intended to throw an^
disrespect, by this respectable writer, upon
the magistrates, but it is saying, in otnejr
words, as I Win immediately read from ai>-
other authority, fhlt it will force bad men U>
be good, or show them in what way they \rill
be punished, if they continue to be bad.
Mr. Cierk. — Jly lord$, I will read your
lordships, page 451, of Mr. De LolroeVs book^
" In air monarchies (and it is the same id
republics), the executive power in the state
is supposed to possess, orlgmally and by itself^
all manner of lawful authority ; every one of
its exertions is deemed to be legal ; and they
do not cease to be so, till they are stopped by
some express and positive regulation. The
sovereign, and also the civil magistrate, tiU
so stopped bv some positive law, may cgme
Upon tne suoject when they choose; they
may question any of his actions ; they may
construe them into unlawful acts ; and infUc(
a penalty, as they please : in these respects
they may be thought to abuse, but not to
exceed, their power. The authority of tlv6
government, in short, is supposed to be unli-
mited so far as there are no visible boundaries
set up against it, within which boundaries,
hes whatever degree of liberty the subject
may possess.
" In England, the very reverse obtains. It
is not the authority of the government, it iS
the liberty of the subject, wnich is supposed
to be unl)ounded. All the individual's actions
are supposed to be lawful, till that law is
pointea out which makes them to be other-
wise. The onus prohandi is here transferred
from the subject to the prince. The subject
is not at any time to show the grounds of his
conduct. When the sovereign or magistrate
think proper to exert themselves, it is their
business to find out and produce the law in
their own favour, and the prohibition against
the subject." And, in a note, he says, " I
shall take the liberty to mention another fact
respecting myself, as it may serve to elucidflte
thb above observations, or at least my
manner of expressing them. I remember
when I was beginning to pay attention to
the operations of the Englisn government, I
was under a prepossession of quite a contrary
nature to that of^a gentleman whose opinions
have been discussed : I used to take it for
granted that everv article of liberty the sub-
ject enjoys in tnis country, was grounded
upon some positive law by which this liberty
was insured to him. In regard to the freedom
of the press, I had no doubt but it was so^ and
that tnere existed some particular law^ or
* De Lolme on the Constitution of £ng-
.land, book ii. ch. IS, pp. S98-^00; ed. of
1816.
fi7ff\ 33 GEORGE III. Proceedings againU Oe Rev. T. FyAe Palmer [S80
rather series of laws or legislative paragraphs,
by which this freedom was defined and care-
fully secured : and as the liberty of writing
happened at thai time to be carried very far,
and to excite a great deal of attention (the
noise ahout the Middlesex election had not
yet subsided), I particularly wished to see
those laws I supposed, not doubting but there
must be something remarkable in the word-
inv of them. I looked into those law books
I had opportunities to come at, such as Jacob's
and Cunningham*s Law Dictionaries, Wood's
Institutes, and Jud^e Blackstone's Commen-
taries. I also found means to have a sight of
Comyns*s Digest of the Laws of England, and
I was again disappointed : this author, though
the work consists of five folio volumes, had
not had, any more than the authors just men-
tioned, any room to spare for the interesting
law I was in search of. At length it occurred
to me, that this liberty of tne press was
grounded upon its not being prohibited, —
Siat this want of prohibition was the sole,
and at the same time solid, foundation of it.
This led me, when I afterwards thought of
writing something upon the government of
this country, to give the definition of the
freedom uf the press, which is contained in
p. 295, '^96 : adding to it the important con-
sideration that all actions respectmg publica-
tions are to be decided by a jury.'**
Mr. Haggart, — In addition to what Mr.
Clerk has read, I shall onlv state a circum-
stance, which, in the statute law of Uiis coun-
try, your lordships will find an authority for,
thatduiinj the reign of Charles 1st, during the
rci^ of Charles Cd, or part of it, and for a
period of years about that time, there was
known a court called the Star Chamber, a
part of whose duty was the licensing of aU
that was published ; publications were in the
same situation then, that they are in Spain at
this moment, but your lordships know, that
was one great mean by which the glorious
Revolution was brou^lit about; and since
that time, an unbounded freedom has suc-
ceeded upon the broad basis, upon which your
lordships now see it.
I will now read to your lordships part of
^the speech of Mr. Grattan of Ireland; he
says, speaking of the associations: — ^^ But
there is not a man in Ireland, there is not a
grand jury," &c.
[Here the learned counsel read some quotar
tions from Mr. Grattan's celebrated speech in
the House of Commons on the subject of the
Dun^nnon meeting, in which Mr. Grattan
justified not only meetings and associations
within doors, but what he called a great
original measure, meetings in the fields. Mr.
Haggart did not mean by quoting to ap-
prove of what Mr. Grattan said ; but, said
he, is there any such proposal started in the
* De Lolme on the Constitution of Eng-
land, book 2, second part of chapter 17. p.
417, edit, of 1816.
Berean Meeting-house? No. Thelangu^
there is constitutional and proper. Yet no
prosecution was thought of against the
publishers of this speech, but the compua-
tively innocent publication of the Bereaa As-
sociation is arraigned !
My lords, the next authority I shall state
upon the same subject with De Lolme, is that
of the immortal Milton. — ** We have them
not,'' says Milton, '* that can be heard o^
from ancient state, or polity, or church, nor
by any statute left us by our ancestors, elder
or later, nor from the modern custom of any
reformed city, or church abroad ; but from
the most antichristian council, and the most
tvrannous inquisition that ever existed. Till
then, books were ever as freely admitted into
the world as any other birth; the issue of the
brain was no more stifled than the issue of
the womb."*
I shall n^xt call your lordships' attention
to the celebrated Mr. Hume's opinion upon
this business, and, my lords, it oeing a thing
perfect] v well known, that Hume was a
monarchical man, and attached to monar-
chical principles, the authority of this author
IS as great an authoritv as I can possibly refer
to. After showing the advanUi^es of a mo-
narchy, he says, — *' It is apprehended, that
arbitrary power would steal in upon us, were
we not careful to prevent its progress, and
were there not an easy method of conveying
the alarm from one end of the kingdom to
the other. The spirit of the people must fre-
quently be roused, in order to curb the ambi-
tion of the court; and the dread of rousing
this spirit, must be employed to prevent that
ambition. Nothing is so effectual to this
purpose as the liberty of the press, by which
all the learning, wit, and genius of the nation,
may be employed on the side of freedom, and
every one ne animated to its defence. As
long, therefore, as the republican part of our
government can maintain itself against the
monarchical, it will naturally be careful to
keep the press open, as of importance to its
own preservation. "f
Now, my lords, I shall beg leave only to
mention farther, lord Chesterfield's opinion
upon this subject, which is extremely short,
but very emphatic, and very expressive, in a.
speech delivered by him, in his place as a
member of parliament. ** The stage, vas
lords, and the press, are two of our ou^
cen tries; if we remove them, if we hood-
wink them, if we throw them in fetters, the
enemy may surprise us."t
* See Milton's Areopagitica, as cited ill
lord Erskine's defence ot Paine, ante, Vol. 92^
p. 439.
t See Hume's Essay on the Liberty of the
Press, as cited in lora Erskine's defence of
Paine, anti. Vol. 89, pp. 441, 449. •
X See lord Chesterfield's speech on the.-
Play-house bill as cited in lora Erskine's de-
fence pf Paioe^ ani^ Vol. S9, p. 4^3. Respect^.
881]
Jilt SeiUtM,
A. D. 179S.
[282
My Lords, there is jmt one authoHty more,
andyalthoagh it is not an authority of that
atanding, jet it iuts reason within it, and will
apeak for itself; and if any addition be want-
infr to the name of Stanhope, the reasoning
trill have its weight. ^' If,'' says his lordship,
^ our boasted liberty of the press, were to con-
sist only in the liberty to write in praise of
the constitution, this is a liberty enjoyed under
many arbitrary governments. I supoose it
would not be deemed quite an unparoonable
offisnce, even by the empress of Russia, if any
roan were to take it into hb head to write a
panegyric upon the Russian form of " )vem-
ment. Sucn a liberty as that, might there-
fore properly be termed the Russian Liberty
of the Press. But, the English Liberty of the
Press is of a very different description: for,
by the law of England, it is not prohibited to
pubUsh speculative works upon the constitu-
tion whether they contain praise or censure/**
I say, there is langua{;e expressive of itself;
it is beyond all authonty. it is drawing that
contrast, wluch I hope will long continue be-
tween the government of Russia and the
government of this country.
Having encroached so much upon your
lordshipr time, but conceiving it to be my
Lord-^^croin6v— Take your own time.
Mr. Haggart — I 8^, I think I was called
upon to show, that, if criminality is to be at-
tached to the liberty of the press, infinitely
rreater freedom than that used by my client,
Eas been made use of. I shall not take up
your lordships time with a recapitulation of
the speeches or of the authorities. But, my
kffds, to bring my argument to a point : I
hope I have, in the first place, clearly shown,
that the minor proposition docs not in this
case make out tne facts which are stated in
the major proposition, and besides the indict
ment is otherwise defective and informal. I
aay tliat there is not through the whole of
this» any attack upon the constitution of the
country; and if your lordships are of opinion,
that there is no attack whatever upon the
constitution of this country in the whole of
that pau^r, you will dismiss it as not properly
laid. But if your lordships should be of opi
oion that these objections should be overruled,
I have to state to your lordships farther, that
upon the whole face of the paper there is no
sedition ; that the sum ana substance, that
the whole scope and meaning of the paper is,
to encourage the presenting another petition
for parliamentary reform, to stir up their
ing this speech of lord Chesterfield, see lord
Kenyon*s observation inp. 443, of the same
Volume.
* See this passage cited by lord Erskine in'
his defence of Paine, anU^ Vol. 29, p. 444.
From the coincidence of the preceding quota-
tions, I infer that the learned counsel must
have had in view the eloquent argument of
lord Erakine^ Ip which 1 havt aUt«M.
friends and fellow-citizens to apply again to'
parliament; and after tiie examples ana autho-
rities I have given, I trust no one will call in
question the right of British subjects as often
as they choose to exercise that privilege. I
say that is the whole sum and substance upor^
the foce of that paper, and that being the
case, I do submit and humbly hope, your lord-
ships will have no difficulty in finding that
the matter which is here charged, is not rele*
vant.
My lords, I will only farther add, that if
alarms some time ago went abroad, those
alarms are unquestionably now at an end.
If anjjT period is more to be dreaded than ano-
ther, it must be a crisis of this kind : histoiy
informs us how difficult it is to stop short
when the cure is performed. The natural
progress is from one extreme to another, and
without much circumspection a disease more
fatal than that meant to be removed is the in-
follible attendant In the hands of your lord-
ships I know there is no risk. As you your-'
selves received it, so I trust the precedent of
this day will transmit to your posterity the
effiisions of the press, as the immortal Milton
has expressed it, « as free as the issue of the
womb."
Mr. Mnc&nochie. — My lords, in collecting
from this very long speech, what is the im-
port of the objections that are opposed upon
the part of the panel, I find myself not a httle
at a loss ; as far as I can comprehend, the
whole drift of Mr. Haggart's speech goes to
attack the major proposition m the indict-
ment, as not containing sound law For as
to the minor proposition not amounting to
the contents ofthe major, I can scarcely sup-
pose that any man m this house or else-
where, in the use of reason and common
sense, could examine the conduct and lan-
guajge contained in the minor, and hesitate
an instant to see that the facts come up to
the tn^or proposition. If it be true that the
conduct or this man, or that man, the lan-
guage of this man, or that man, may be
quoted as evidence of the law of Scotland t»
your lordships, that such lan^age may be
used with impunity, and that therefure this is
the law; if your lordships adopt that, then it
overturns the major proposition. But that it
contains law, I am sure no'lawyer can doubt ;
no man can doubt, not only that it is the law
of Scotland, but it is impossible any govern-
ment should exist if it is not law 1 he words
of it are, •* thit by the laws of this, and every
other well-governed realm." &c. ! See the In-
dictment.]
Now, I should humbly apprehend, that if, as
I assert, this is the clear law of this land, and
the clear law of every country, what your
lordships have to inquire is, not how often
this law has been infringed with impunity,
not how often the greatest men in the king- '
dom or the most insignificant have dared to
violate it ; but what your lordships have to in-
quirt into is^ whether or not tmder the circum-
SSS]
83 GEORGE lit
I againd Ot Rev. T. Fythe Palmer f SSI
geQtkmto's other mfcoiitieg, lie ^ not
Suote the French Bewspaoers, where every
ay they are saying how ttiey stick by their
posts. I eapectod that that would hate been
one of his authorities.
It theti floes on, ** ever ready to assert our
just rights/' &c. [See the Indictment.]
Then hear what they state, and it what
words they assert the universai right of suf-
frage. Is there amy such right to be found in
the law of Britain ? Is there any such right to
be found in the constitution of our ancestors }
or m any tonstitution of the world, except
that of France ? and I am hn>py to tbittv,
that I know something of the nistory of our
constitotiony because I am sur6 there was no
period when there was any thing like uni^
versal sufirage; ther^ never was a period
yrhtn it was so much like tmiversal as at pre-
sent In what way Are they to assert it ? h
cannot be done by legal means, for no kw
recoflkiaes it, although they were tbf assert it
as their iust right and privilege^ and as the
chief of their just rights and privileges.
Then, my lords, they go on to sa^Ty that they
are not disappointed by the decision of the
House of Commons concerning their pettti6n.
'^ It is a question we did nbt expect, though
founded on truth and reason, would be sup^
ported by superior numbers.'' TtM Ibamed
gentleman therefore is clearly rotstidcen in
misery, if they prevent it not hj their weil- : saying, that the object of tms paper was to
timed efforts. Ilavins said this, it goes on to produce a second petition, for thev say^ they
tell them, what are the misfortunes thaC are '■ were not disaippomted in their defeat. Sn
sinking them in this depth of slavery and short, ii is now the time when these gentkk*
misery (and very great misforUmes they are, men are to assemble, inconse^ieilceof their
if they are true), and assures them that every not having been disappointed m the petttioor
day Is adding a new link to their chain. Thas which they presented pro /armi ; and noi/
is the general statement, I appreitend, of the ! they were to assert their fights by another
evil, that every day is adding a new link to , mode, not by petitioning, because that was a*
our chain, which, by the way, is a plain asser- , measure that they knew to be nugatory, for
tion that they are at present slaves, and in I thev say, they were not disappointed,
chains, to which new links are adding ; and it ' Then they go on, '* Far from being discoo*
goes on to state what are the chains. ^ Is ! raeed," &c. [See the Indictihent.]
not the executive branch daily seising new, | r^ow, upon what principle of law, or, upon
imprecedented, and unwarrantable powers ?*' what principle of common sensfe it is fbunoed,
Tlien it goes on to attack the other branches t know not, but' so it is, that those gentle*
of the legislature as well as the ki^g. ** Has : aoen set up this in the same way that they
not the House of Commons (your only s^cu- - might set up a claim to tfhare the property ^if
rity from the evils of tyranny and aristocntcy) eVery gentleman in At country, or Co sdxe
joined the coalition against you ?" I am now J^pon any franchise belonging to another,
speaking as to the plain scope and intend- That is not the species of liberty granted by
ment of the words ; what does any man of , this constitution ; the constitution of thi»
common sense understand by it i^ Is it not country, when it confides a franchise, ceofidea
stances stated, the productkm UbdM itpofi,
amounts — if proved to have been written or
circulated by the person at the bar^-to the
statement of the law in the sn^or proposi*
tion?
Now, my lords, I apprehend that the circu^
lating privatelv this publication (it was a sort
of smuggled business) which cannot be pe-
rused iimnout seeing that it contams in it all
the ingredients charged as criminal in the
major proposition, is sedition in as far as it
directly tends to rouse to acts of sedition and
violence. I apprehend that veiy slight ob*
servation will be sufiBcient to satisfy every
person that I am stating no more than the
import of that paper amounts to. I do not
niean to fellow tne learned gentleman through
his various evolutions with reprd to it, but
amply to call the attention ofyour lordships
to the nlun and obvious import of it^ as it
meets tne eye of a man of common under-
standing. It commends, first, their fellow-
citizens for their loyal and steady conduct in
these duys of advertity, that they have shown
that they are worthy of at least some small
portion of liberty ; but then it promises to
rouse theni from their lethaigy, and it tells
them, in order to rouse them from tiieir
lethargy, that the small portion of liberty
they once enjoyed is fast setting, and that
they would be in the depth of slavery and
plainly sayine, that the House of Commons,
vrho should be ^our protection against the
executive and aristocratic part of the govern-
ment, have joined that coalition that is formed
it to a part, for the benefit of the whole ; it
does not confide it to the mob, it doea not
confide it to a disorganiaed mob ; but it con-
fides it where it has the least reason to expect
against the people by the other two bodies of ; it to te albused : and we ihaok God, it has
the legislature f The indictment is not for been so Uttie abused, as Id product a House of
treason, but I apprehend there are words Commons, to answer every purpose of g»-
there that would amount to treason ; but if
they do not, surely they will amount to sedi-
tion in what is stated in the major proposition.
The Address then proceeds to say^ ^* we
have done our duty, and are determmed to
keep our posts.'' Xwonderiamoagtbeleinied
vemment ; to prodikce, upon the whole, such
a House of Commons, as no body of men inr
anv countrv can be pot in coinpetttion with.
Where is there a coUection of meb by ddfr-*
SitioB, that can be compared to the virtue,
e integn^ mMtm dMiactec of tfie Btifisb
S65)
Jit Sedition*
A. D. 1799.
[286
Honse of ConmotiB; having preserved tat
tiro centuries % cbancter that no senate ever
nunntainedy for bij^ spirit, for an equal rmrd
to the intensi ofthe country at large, ror a
regard to the interest of the meanest, as well
as the hi^dkest ;— a regard that keeps them,
nnd has Kept them Move 150 years, within
the precincts of their own ri^ts and privi^
leges, without encroaching upon those other
powers equally necessary tor the existence of
a government; — a situation that will place
them in the annals of mankind, as high as
any body of assembled men ever stood, or
can stand ; — a situation in which they are
now unrivalled, when compared. Indeed, it
is uimecessary for any man who can read, to
think of stating tlie comparison between them
and the body of men collected according to
those Utopian systems of universal suffrage,
which were a disgrace to mankind, and
Inrou^t confusion upon a nation which was
tefore enlightened and civilized.
Hien it eoes on, having stated this claim,
and that tney are to assert it, and having
warned their &lk>w citizens that petitioning
was good for noUiing, for nothing was to be
expected from it, tlicy say, " The time is now
come,'* &c [See the Indictment]
Is thb the language of a petitioning people,
who are calmly stating their sentiments, in
erder that they may meet with a free discus-
taooL } Is it not rather a trumpet to collect for
H great original measure^ which Mr. Hi^gart
baa mentioned ? It is the import of Mr. Rat-
tan's language, and I defy any man of com-
mon selise to read the paper without seeing,
that this original measure of the people as-
aiuning their own powers was here alluded to.
[Here Mr. Hageart reminded Mr. Macono-
chie that he old not speak in approbation
of the measure.]
** The time b now come,^ &c [See the
Indictment]
Undoubtedly, if the time is come, according
to this language, to assemble round the fabric
•f libert;^ m order to preserve it, the country
should rise as a man to protect it, for the
ftd>ric of British liberty is well worth protect-
ing; bat it is not to be protected by such
hands.
^ You are plunged into a war by a wicked
ministry," &c. [See the Indictment]
These gentlemen, havine now arraigned
the constitution, having tola you in their ad-
4ie8s to their fellow ciuzens, that the whole
|iarts of the legislature were corrupt and
joiiied in a cosdition against the people,
having stated their claim to a right of suf-
llage, hostile and ruinous to t^ constitu-
tion, which would be fatal to it the mo-
ment it was accomplished, that could not
exist, either without a king, or a house of
]«ids. Uavins arraigned these, and statad
their plan of claiming an univsersal suftage,
waning the people to rouse themselves,
, as the horrible e£RKt of oiir present
CQnatitutiQiiii the king with the parlia-
ment are joined in a coalition, the end and
d^ien of which is, the destruction of a whole
people, merely because they will be free ! — a
most horrible design, indeed, it would be!
For who can doubt that if the legislature
of this country concur in the design of des«>
troying a whole people, merely because they
will be free, that tnat legislature should be
consigned, not only to detestation, but to
destruction and punishment? It should be
put an end to— I say, the nation should rise
and extirpate such a legislature, as would
concur in the desii^n of extirpating a whole
people, because tKey will be free; instead
of such an object they ought to rejoice in the
dissemination of^ freedom ; but will any per-
son say with truth, that that is the conauct
of this country } S6 long as France kept to
their original revolution, this nation, and all
good men looked on with satisfaction rejoic-
mg at what took place ; but when they for*
sook their own proper ground, at the moment
that our liberties were uireatened,and our con-
stitution was attacked, when foreign enemies
by the most insidious and artful means, aided
our intestine foes to misrepresent the con-
stitution, and excite the people to spurn the
gifU that God in his mercy had showered
upon them, more than he had ever bestowed
upon any other neople, then it became not
only lawful but aosolutely necessary, for us
to join in the war i^inst men who, having
destroyed every particle of liberty in their own
country, endeavoured by the worst of means,
by rebellion, and by every sort of treachery
and villany, to disseminate the same cursed
principles in other countries. Then it goes
on to mention the natural consequences of
this war, consequences, which I say must be
attributed, in a ereat measure, to such so-
cieties as the Addressers; for if there had not-
been those infamous connexions with France,
those connexions that have appeared in pub-'
lie, from societies calling themselves Friends
of the People in this country, there woidd
have been no war; without the encourage*-
ment afforded by such principles, and such
societies, the French never would have been
so mad as to have thought of attacking the
British nation; but when malcontents, and
societies of malcontents were rearing their
heads here, the rascallv part of France, in-
sidiously attempted to tnrow this country into
confusion, that they might enjoy the fruits,
at the expense of all that was good or worthy
in the country. — ^Then they go on to tell a
gross &lsehood, but highly fitting to kindle
an alarm in the minda of well-meaning
ignorant people. *' To the loss of the in-
valuable rights and privileges which our hi-
thers enjoyed,*' &c. [See the Indictment]
Taxes are oppressive and hard, but they are
often the price of great and important privi*
leges, of great enjoyments, and at any rate
they are the least of two evils; better pay
taxes than be under the government of a
mob, or of the base and unprincipled charac-
387] 33 GEORGE IIL Proceedingi againH the Reo. T: Fyshe Palmer [S8S
ters that are dosigoed to be the leaders of it.
War is a great evil, but a necessary war,
though a great evil, must be borne. But
these gentremen state a list of bankrupts,
which they are pleased to attribute to the
war, which I have no objection to, but they
state these evils as brought on by wickedness,
because government did not sit with their
arms folded across unmindful of their dut]^.
Where are those invaluable rights and pri-
vileges which our fathers enjoyed? What
rights did our ancestors enjoy which we do
not enjoy in the fullest manner, and with im-
provement ? 1 know of none ; and I defy
all those who arraign the constitution and
the government of this country, and all the
passages that have been summoned and
scraped together from every quarter for the
purpose, to show me one privilege that they
enjoyed which we do not now enjoy. This
b a gross, a palpable, and a most seditious
falsehood, for there is nothing that tends more
to kindle discontent in the minds of the lower
classes of people, than the idea of being de-
prived of what their ancestors purchased, and
endeavoured to transmit to them. Can there
then be a grosser crime committed, than, in
a serious matter of this kind, to endeavour
to stir up the i^orant, by telling them a
gross and abominable falsehood of that
nature ? Having gone this length, they con-
clude with a solemn appeal, and it is such
an appeal that, upon momentous occasions,
might certainly with great public virtue be
given, but it is such an appeal, that, as long
as government exists, can never be endureo,
and can never be understood in any other
light than that of an (triginal measure^ as the
gentleman has termed it. The words are
these, " Fellow citizens, the friends of liberty
call upon you," &c. [See the Indictment.]
Such language as this, would have im-
mortalized tnose who used it, had it been
published at the era of the revolution, when
the bishops * were sent to the Tower, when
the king assumed the right of levying taxes
without the consent of parliament, and of
modelling our religion ; these were the days
which sanctioned such language ; and if such
times should come again, let it be used, but
not till they come aeain. Shall the rights
and privileges of the freemen of this country
be sported with ? Shall we be deprived of the
benefits of that free and happy government
iinder which we live by sucn vile incendia-
ries? Or, shall we, to our face, have the
ignorant part of the country solicited to rise,
to deprive us of our privileges which we have
enjoyed for a century past? And, shall we
not have a power in the law of this country,
to punish the intentional rebel^ who would
endeavour to stir up the people to make use
of a power which tne law never gave them,
which their ancestors never gave them, and
• Sec their case Vol 12, p. 183 of this Col-
lection.
for which they never could be fitted ? Sach
an act must seem to every person, whatever
are their sentiments^ as long as government
exists, as most atrocious and iniquitous ; as a
thine that calls for piinishment, and, for
whicn, no plea of justification can possibly
be set up in a court of justice : the only plea
that can be set up is, the plea of the sword —
none else. The time may come when such
spirit may be properly snown, and then I
hope there will be spirit and virtue in the
country to assert its rights. — The coimtry
lately showed its power to assert its right, not
against the executive power, not against the
representatives of the people, but against
those who were organizing a different repre-
sentation, those litUe self-elected parliaments,
those self-constituted societies, trum which
a convention was to have been formed; then
there was reason for alarm to the good
citizens of the country, and the good citizens
came forward, and sijgnified Uieir resolution
to abide by the constitution with their lives
and fortunes, and to share its fate. And, £
hope, if our relispon, or our civil liberty is
again attacked, if a king or a mob shall dare
to nersecute us for our freedom, that there
will be spirit in this country to assert its right,
and maintain our constitution. — Such thmgs
may be — I can scarcely venture to figure them;
yet kings are but men, and we ought to be
thankful for such a king as we have ; but if
a king were to come wno was to send the
bishops to the Tower, because they refused
to read a prayer or a litur^ disowning the
Godhead of Christ ; were the time to come,
when men should be punished for refusing
to pay taxes, 'imposed by a king without the
consent of parliament, — were the time to
come, when men were to be tried without
form of law, without judges or juries, but by
the arbitrary power of the Crown, by their
minions and delegates, then would be the
time for every man of spirit in the country
to assert their rights. But till then, while
your lordships sit in judgment, you are bound
to consider such language as is here used, as
a gross and most violently criminal act, an
act approaching to high treason, if not ac-
tually high treason. But I am not called
upon to go so far. I am only called upon to
point out to your lordships, that there was in
this libel, matter that came up to the full
statement of the major proposition ; and it is
impossible to consider it in any other view,
than as an attempt to insinuate to the people^
that they have been oppressed, injured, and
deprived of their rights, contrary to what is
known to be the fact ; and that they are liv*
ing under a wicked and abominable govern-
ment, when they are living under the best
government that ever existed; and endeavour-
ing by falsehoods to excite them to tumult
and finally to appeal to the sword.
Mr. Haggart. — My lords, whether it has
been my nuUt in not making what I meant to
say sumciently perspicuous^ or the fault of
sse]
>•
A. D. 179a
LS99
tbe jKOfiecutor in not being attentive to what
I sud, I know not, but he has totally mis-
taken the furst great and capital objection
which I stated to this indictment He says,
I told your lordships, that the miyor proposi-
tion, stating what is sedition, is not sound law.
My lords,! never stated such an idea, and I am
equally astonished that such an idea should
have occurred to any lawyer, and particularly
sliould have occurred to the learned gentle-
man. What I meant to state was, that the
indictment as it stands does not form a syllo-
gism ; that what is stated there is sedition no
person can doubt, but what I stated was,
that the practice having made it necessary
that the strict syllodstic form should be
adhered to, unless the minor proposition
stales frets that would make out that attack
upon the constitution which is stated in the
major, the syllogism is incomplete, and that
therefore you cannot attend to it.
Afflin, I did not say that high titles, &c.
justified the language they have used; I only
averred that uninterrupted practice lieyond ail
memory and that practice unchallenged is
consuetudinary law, which is the best law and
best precedent we have. If it should please
our nappy constitution of King, Lords, and
Commons, if it should please them to make
a declaratory law to say, henceforth there
shall be no such associations, then I would
hold it to be illegal, because it would be pro-
hibited by the only Icugal authority, that is,
an act of parliament, but without such law
the nractice cannot be iliegal. The learned
gentleman dwelt a long time upon the word
ckaim. Since the learned gentleman seems
not satisfied with the explanation I have
l^ven him, he may have another. It may
allude to self-elected magistrates, who, while
lending deaf ears to every sort of reform,
are deckine themselves with gold cAatM ; at
least I tliimc I have more merit in my expla-
nation than the learned gentleman has in his
dissertation on French posts. In a word, I
understand these chains to refer to the abuses
of parliament. My lords, I must take the
liboly of stating, that Mr. Maconochie did
lay himself not a little open in what he
concluded with; he said, if I have taken
down his words right, — and he will correct me
if I have not — he said, as there was no law
that lays down, that universal suffrage is to
be recognized in this country, that no person
IS entitled to form a speculative opinion upon
it, or to express that opinion in a petition to
the House of Commons.
1^. MaconoclM. — I did not say a word of
speculative opinions,
Mr.Ha(ggart. — But you said, that no sub-
ject of this country had a ri^ht to go into the
mode of assembling and petitioning the House
of Commons^
Mr. Maconochie,'-^! said no such words.
Mr. Haggart.^^^Thea what you sdd was
this (I hope I shall be rijght the third time),
that this was a language £^ted to a ^"eat era,
VOL. xxin.
such as the Revolution; and that if there
were to exist wicked ministers, if it was then
to be the case, that the reverend bench of
bishops were to be sent to the Tower for re-
fusing to read the confession of faith, that
Mr. Maconochie proposed then the kingdom
would be entiUed to rise. I shall beg leave
to know what people are to rise 1 is it only the
bishops who are to arise ? or would common-
ers also? Mr. Maconochie inculcated, that
in such time the people might lawfully go
into open rebellion. This is sedition with a
witness — ^I abhor that idea. — I disclaim that
idea. I say the constitution does not admit
of it I say that it is more a libel upon the
constitution than any thine I ever heard writ-
ten or said. I say Mr. Maconoclue's plan is
sedition in the highest d^ree, when opposed
to me ; he is for rising with open arms, and
all that I contend for is, that I may have thr
freedom of petitioning parliament; that is
the whole scope and tenor of the petition and
resolutions in this case; and I hope I shall
not be told that I have no right to petition..
If a time shall come when petitioning shall
be held illegal, or be prohibited, I shsdl thea
think that the libefty of the subject and
every thing belonging to this happy constitu-
tion, is transferred from the people to the
crown of the monarch.
Lord E$kgrooe.-^Thomsa Fyshe Palmer
stands accused of the crime stated in this
indictment ; he is indicted upon principles of
law and Justice ; and though he stands there^
he is to be presumed at present an innocent
person. I should be extremely happy in this^
as in every other case, that the issue should
prove that he is innocent. But at present,
where the consideration is the lukture of the
charge against him, in order to establish the
relevancv or irrelevancy of this libel, it is my
rule ana the rule of this court, to take the
charge as if it were true. Afierwards it will
be to be inquired into, whether he committed
the crime or the crimes with which he is
charged, or no, in case the relevancy of this
indictment shall be estabhshed. My lord,
the libel consists of two propositions, in the
usual form of criminal indictments in thb
country ; it consists of the msyor proposition^
which sets forth the nature of the general
charge, and proceeds, in the minor, to state
the facts from which the prosecutor infers-
that the panel has committed Uiat crime.
My lord, with regard to the major proposi-
tion, the counsel for the panel has admit-
ted, that it is sedition; and no person can
entertain a doubt, that, if there is any such
thing as a government or a constitution ex-
isting in this country, the nugor propositioa
does set forUi a crime of a very high nature
against such government. It states that,,
* whereas by the laws of this, and every well-
governed realm, the wickedly and feloniously
writing or printing, or causing to be wrote
and prmted,' &c.— TSee the major propositioa
of the Indictment.^
U
S90 S3 GSORG& HL Proceedings agaiki^a0Rffo..T.Fif9he Palmer (ttSft
I said before, that the counsel for iht
panel disclaims disputing the relevani^ of
(his general chaise. Inaeed, my lord, it
would be the strangest country in tile woridj
and the strangest government that ever ex-
isted, which could l)e compared to nothing
but that anardiy which unfortunately prevails
In France, if a person who docs that
which will raise a spirit of discontent in the
ininds of the people is not punishable for so
doing. For this address, in order to rouse
the people, has calumniated the measures of
government, as tyrannical ; and vindicated the
enemies of this country, representing that we
are at war with them, because they will be
free, and recommending them as object* of
great commiseration, and that it is a fault in
parliament, to make war against a people who
are brethren, and whom we should support.
Such a publication is seditious; l^ the old law
cf this country it was more, for sedition,
and raisine commotions Among the people,
was considered as a species of treason; and,
my Ibrd, though I am thankful that we are
not called upon in these days, to carry matters
to that extent; yet it is said' by the counsel,
that it approaches very near to treason : that
it fs very difBcult to draw the line between
trying to inflame the people against the king
who IS one of the brancbes of the le^slature
1[which is called trteson), and endeavouring
to overthrow not only the King, but the
King, Lords, and Commons, which cannot
he a lesser crime. The minor proposition
here sets forth, tliat this person, the person
liere described, a clergyman by profession,
|>residing at Dtmdee, over a set of religious
people (to which I have no objection — a man
in this country can enjoy his relifi;ion with
)i»eriect freedom, and never be caffedTin ques^-
tion^ — ^that this gentleman, one of the society
of the Friends <n the People (I have no ob-
jection to the title of any society, if their
actions are eoodj-^did thein, and there, put
into the hands or George Meahnaker, weaver
In Dundee, a manuscript or writing of a
wicked and seditiooB import;^ &c. composed
by the said T. F. Palmer, or bj him caused to
be composed; there is no distinctton bet^i^een
A man's writing with his own hands^ or his
dktftting to anotiier to clompose. It after-
•wards underwent various aiteratkma, sug-
gested by the fbresaid meeting^ and by
-Sesire of tile said meetings ^t^as ^^n put into
-his hand, that it might 1^ his- means be
printed and publtelved.
Then follows the title of it, wMch b^ins
"with '^ Dondee Berean MeeUn9-hoii9e, jtdy
17^.— 'At a general meeting of Uie FViends of
'LibertT, they unanimously resolved tb publish
"Uie following Address to their Fello^'citiiens.''
•It does not rest there alone, witii having
written and pnbl9sh'ed this p^r^ but^oes on
farther, and tayfr, ^^FUnherthesiiidliiomas
Fisdie Painter, dM sometime during the
'month, of Jtdy iifbresaid^ wickedl||^ana fdo-
niously distribifte, and cbeniite^ m*Dund^,
fi^tibnrgfa, and d^ewliere'^ ^r ekislrf tb hi
ctrculat^,*' &c.— And these tart ih^ -ptcfii^
cular acts condescended upon;-^Thi8 g^dei-
man at the bar, is alle^ to have circulHtH
this composition, if it » an innocent ahd k
harmless paper, all these things will' gd tbt
nothing, that man wa» not to btame Ibr com-
posmg it, or for writing; or causing ii td be
written, or for circulating; or causing i]t tb be
circnlated ; if not^ such writing, printing, or
circidatibn is crimmal. If it i^ a paper vshd^-
ing to cause tumuhs and rebeUions; arkl'over-
turn the government, w^are toconsid^r^very
circumstance ^ attending it. One thhig I can-
not depart from, which, if it i^ a seditious
writing, is not a little of a stton^ nature.
This gentieman's counsel tells tfe, thai' he is a
gentleman, born of a respectable famify in the
South of Fneland. A strstnger com«^^t6 this
country, with an intemion to tetech and pro^
pagate his religidu!( priticiple^ aAKM^ these
p^pte; I have no objection to that, ifnti had
confined himself to pi'eaching the doctrines he
chooses to adopt ; but when here he ought to
conform to the laws of this country, but in:-
stead of doing that, he tu^ns hfs iheetihs-
house into a houseof s6^ion,^ fiM- It stiit^it^
as dated fhm the patadb^ Beteto Meeting
house. AH nations ar^ Ihifble to Intre hSi
men among them; but I own, we ^e'ttitlift
obliged to strangers, who, coming; here under
the pretence of preaching i^hat wey dall the
gospel, should preach sedition amobg the
people.
My lord, this teads me to the nat^ire of tfti^
paper; and before I go minutely intd it t do^
for one, hoM, that the liberty of this countSy
b doitbtiess closely connected with the right
to petition all the branches of the le^lature;
and when they present that petition m proper
form, and in decent langita^ (which I am
sori-ytosatwe hiVe not an mistance of this
'day quoted to us from the bar), then I hope
the legislature will take tfrbper means* fbr re-
dress. But, if on the otnerhand; instead of
applying in the regular maimer to the tMf
qiiarter where redress can be obtained, ant
publBc or private man, cl^rgy^ or laity, shall
think proper to call meetings and ^collect to^
ther mechanics, and those whose Mueatito akid
circumstances d6 not entitle or qualify them
to judge of matters of legislation — ^people
ignorant altogether of the vetv nivt^nce^
which they are toM they are loaded wife, till
they are assembled and taught that they wette
ui a state of opprdMiioh^ the case is ext^dhigly
different. Now let us look into this papef.
** You, who, by your loyal and steady conchict
in these days of adversity," &c. [See tXile Ihs*
dictment.]
■■> .■^..'i
* His lordship supposed, that as the iiMH^
was dated from the Berean M^seting'hoUM,
that this Berean meeting-'hodM was Mr.
Palmer's pkce of w<^hip ; tfaiaivasnotthe
case, and was afterwards exptuhed lohi^ Iwdi-
sl^p. Orig, Edit:
983}
^W V^ N^PVVflv W^^a •
A. a I7SS*
ESM
<<Dpl^ of advifttt/'— It d^es nq^ occur |o
me ibi^lluacQuiiuy was in a greater state of
advenuty (fiurther tbao beii^g epeaged in a
war) in the month pf July &L tfian at any
<Hher period ^r-'' they are only worthy of
flome ^mall portion pf liber^ ;'' I hope all
men here know and experience mnre liberty
$h^n any subkct of any other country upon
the £ice of the earth. We know very well
Ihaly in the month of November, there were
many such meeting3 held, and many such
Sibhcations; and we know a stop was put to
em, by the noble spirit that appeared for
supporting the constitution ; and I ({id not
thmk thaty in July last, there would have
been any person so bold, as to make an at-
tempt which had proved so fruitless before.
This paper goes on to say— *' we will tell you
whole truWf they arc of a kind to alarm and
«iQuse you out or your lethargy." Here this
writer is supposing that his auditors are in a
atate of letfiarKy, which implies a state of
contentment, tliey are in a paci^c contented
state. But this writer is to awaken them
from their lethargy. '< That portion of liberty
you once enjoyca is fast setting, we fear, in
the darkness of despotism and tvranny."
Where are these words exemplified? That
the sun of liberty is setting in the darkness of
tepotism and tyranny, we observe in the
case of the subjects of a country, who have
just cause to endeavour to rcfoim their consti-
tution, and who took measures at first that
nught possibly have had that effect It shows
that, when reformation gets into improper
bands, they are the greatest tyrants and the
g^^atest enemies to liberty; such a state of
anarchy, of murder, -and of arbitrary power,
never was seen since the world began. '' Too
soon perhaps you who were the world's envy,
as possessed of some small portion of liberty," I cover any thing that might be wrong, I do
" " /...*..-- . * not object to it. * Ever ready to assert our
just rights and privUeees as men, the chief of
which we account tne ri^ht of universal
sufiirase.'' I have no objection to a petition
to parliament, desiring them, if they think fit
to alter the constitution, which I have no ob-
jection to, if they choose to allow it \ their
wisdom will be better than mine; but is it
not to overthrow the constitution ? Is it not
making a new constitution ? For, to the pre-
sent time, no such thing as universal suffrage
ever existed : it is a speculative matter, and, I.
think, if we look to a neighbouring country,
where guillotines, massacres, and murders are
going on, it is no ereat encouragement to ex-
periments of this kind, and I was surprised to
bear my friend Mr. Hasgart at the bar in
place of a universal suffrage of the people,
limit the right of voting to 100/. Scots a year :
I rather suspect there is not one in all tlie
Berean congregation who could boast of so
much property ; this society, therefore, need
not distress themselves about a suffrage, which
even Mr. Haggart does not seem disposed to
allow them. Then it goes on, " we are not
deterred; &c.^ [See the Indictment.]
small portion of liberty ! No, my lord,
we possess all of us liberty more than we ever
possessed, and all that is con^stent with a
free and naBpy state — ^ will be sunk in the
depth of suiveiy and misery/' — ^what words
are there that can tend more to impress the
minds of men, and especially men not so well
acquainted with the history of this country, to
take up their swords, in order to save them
from that despotism and slavery ? ^^ Is not
every new day adding a link to your chains?'*
Where are the chains of arbitrary power ? Is
there a man existing in this country who
does not enjoy his liSerty, his religion, the
freedom of exercising his art, his ingenuity,
his industry, his trade ? Is Uiere any man who
does not exercise those privileges to the ut-
most extent that human wisdom can devise ?
" Is not the executive branch daily seizing
new, &c. powers ? Has not the House of Com-
mons joined the coalition against you?''
Against you ! — What does this represent to
these innocent eood people, who were called
to be the disciples or the person who wrote
this paper) I nooe it was not that gcaitleman,
hot I am oUigeo to consider it as if it was.
What d6 you think of it? Would it not strike
eveiy man that it meant, that thfe king, or ni^
ministers are daily seizing unprecedented and
unwarrantable powers, or in other words are
daily exercisine acts of despotism ? Has Mr.
Haggart at the oar offered to prove that this is
a truth ? Is it not consistent with the know-
ledge of every man who hears me, and is able
to read and look at the history of this country
of late, that nothing has been done by either
kin^g or ministry without the sanction of the
legislature? Then that is to represent the
king^ in the first place, as a tyrant. Then who
are the next set ot people ? '' Tyranny and aris-
tocracy." No countjy was ever more happy
under a more amiable prince, and the father
of his people. Who are the aristocracy^
The House of Lords. Then comes the House
of Commons, they are the barrier, and no
doubt they are the true and proper barrier to
prevent encroachments by king and lords:
put they are not to be trusted, they are joined
in a combination with the king and the lords
against your liberty. " Is the election of its
members either fair, free, or freauent ?*' That
is to indicate, that the people or this country
are to have no confidence whatever in that
branch of the legislature ; and thus instructed
they can have no confidence in their rulers.
Were this a time or place to look back on our
history, how opposite the conduct of our
rulers has been, might be easily demonstrated ;
I shall only meution the general warrants.
— ^Have we not evidence in this, as in many
other instances, that the constitution contuns
in itself principles of amendment ? and it will
be daily amended. The Addressers sajr, ** We
have done our duty and are determined to
keep our posts." I will not say any thing
about the word posts, if it means only to dis-
S95] S3 GEORGE IIL Procudingt agmna ike Rev. T. FyAt Palmer [296
I cannot but aeree with Mr, M'Conochie,
that it is impossiole for any man to read this
paraeraphy and avow what Mr. Haggart has
pleaded, viz;, that the whole intention of this
was to encourage the people to petition,
when the very words of it are, we neither ex-
pected, nor do expect to succeed in a petition
to parliament; and therefore something else
must be intended. What else ? every man,
who hears me, must see; it could not be to
carr}' on the measure that they knew parliar-
ment was resolved not to adopt. An original
measure seems to have been in view, to rise,
to carry through what oarliamcnt have re-
lused to grant. Then follows the next para-
eraph, " the time is now come, &c." [See
U)e Indictment.3
My lord, this appears to me^ in the first
place, a gross falsehood, in saying the fabric
of liberty is in danger : it is safe, and I hope
will be safe in this country to the latest pos-
terity, but those people are to rise to over-
jhrow that constitution, which is the happiest
in the world. " Yon are plunged into war/'
&c. [See the Indictment J
This is to awaken the minds of the readers
to the object of the present war in which we
ture engaged (which is owing to the ambition
abd maimess of the unfortunate people we
are engaged with), and evidently tends to
lead them to th'mk that we mean to fraternise
a people with the sword, agreeable to French
practice; and the way of fraternizing them is
with swords and guns, as they attempted to
do in Brabant, and other countries; but
they .soon found themselves in a state of mi-
sery and slavery : and did they not show an
inclination to come into this country to fra-
ternize us too ? Did they not talk of sending
forty thousand men to force us to accept of
liberty ? And ¥ras not that a cause of alarm
to the friends of true liberty, and occasioned
them to rise in a way that, I should have
thought, would have put an end to those at-
tempts? Had these fraternizing principles
been only heard in France, we might have
c;ared the less, but here, in this country, so-
cieties were formed wno were ambitious of
this connexion. Tlie war in which we are
engaged is in self-defence a^nst the greatest
invasion of our rights and nberties, that ever
was attempted ; but that we are at war, for
the purpose of destroying a whole people,
is an insinuation so gross and so cruel, that
it is impossible any government ever can.
maintain itself, if it suners such falsehoods to
escape. '^ By it your commerce is sore
cramped, and almost ruined. Thousands and
ten txiousands of your fellow-citizens from
being in a state of prosperity, are reduced to
a state of poverty, misery, and wretchedness-*'
This is not the people they are speaking to,
for they are in a state of lethargy : are they
to awaken ihem to tell them there is no com-
merce, that all is gone to wreck ? Poor ho-
nest tradesmen ! The^ think nothing of that
1*111 they are told by this preacher of Uie gos-
pel, and warned to rise. The conclusion is,
" The blood of your brethren is pouring out ;
and all this to forge chains for a free people^
and eventually to rivet them for ever on your-
selves ?*' So that the object of this war is to
enslave this nation. '' To the loss of the in-
valuable rights and privileges which our fa-
thers enjoyed, we impute this barbarous and
calamitous war. our ruinous and still growing
taxation, and all the miseries and oppressions *
which we labour under." Now taxation is
only one complaint; but there is, besides
taxation, all the growing miseries we labour
under : taxation is necessary, without it a na-
tion cannot exist ; it is an unavoidable mis-
fortune, we cannot help it ; but these worthy
people are told, besides the taxes, all the mi-
series you are labouring under. When did
we enjoy privileges that we are not now in
the possession ot ? And which I hope will
be transmitted to the latest posterity. The
Friends of Liberty call upon you " by all that
is dear and worthy of possessing as men, by
your own oppressions, by the miseries and
sorrows of your suffering brethren," that is,
by the miseries and sorrows of the people in
Prance,—" by all that you dread; by the
sweet remembrance of your patriotic ances-
tors ; and by all that your posterity have a
right to expect from you,— to join us in our
exertions for the preservation of our perishing
liberty, and the recovery of our long lost
rights." What a strange representation is
this for a people ! One would suppose this
man was preaching to a set of people in Rus-
sia, or Otaheite, as ignorant of Britain as one
of those people. Docs ht say in what manner
these rignts arc to be asserted ? Not a word.
Does he say the meaning is that you concur
in a petition to parliament? There is no
such tnine ; but you are to " gather round the
fabric of uberty." I wonder he did not men-
tion the tree of liberty. But if any govern-
ment 8u£Fers such an attack upon the consti-
tution, makins the man miserable who was
happy before (nothing can have a worse effect
to make men unhappy, and to bring anarchy
and confusion into the country, among a set
of originally well-disposed persons), it will not
long be a government. Is there any person
livine so abandoned as to be desirous, that
this happy country should be put into that
miserable and wretched situation to which
they are so much attached ? They talk of li-
berty ! Wliat madness to talk of liberty on
French principles ! Why a man was executed
the other day for saying, that one tyrant was
no worse than seven nundred, and direcUy
his head was cut off. As to the liberty of the
press, I believe it never was in the situation
it b in now in France. I am a true friend to
the liberty of the press, when printing in the
ordinary course of publication ; why let a man
exercise that proper liberty, which I hope
every man is entitled to; let him speculate on
principles of government, and print his spe-
culations : but when that press la made the
8W]
^or Sedition.
A. D. 1793.
[998
trumpet of rebeDioDy to circulate libels aod
aedilious publications in the form of a hand-
bilL there never was an advocate for the liberty
of Uie press who pretended to justify it.
We have heard a great deal about speeches in
Farliamenty I do not Icnow whether they ever
were made or not in the Houses of partiament,
in which they were said to be deUvered ; they
are not understood to be in the hearing of
anybody; but we do not know upon idiat
authority they have taken upon them to as-
sert, that such and such men make use of
such expres^ns ; but supposing they were
true, it is the business of parliament to take
cognizance of its own members; it does
not bclcmg to me to inquire into it; if they
have said any thing wrong, I am very sorry
for it ; but, if there are a thousand instances
of crimes that go unpunished, is that an ar-
gument to be used by a lawyer ; because per-
sons are ^ilty of equal crimes, and have not
been puntshea, that therefore a supreme court
is to stamp an authority upon crimes brought
before them ? Let us suppose for a moment
that a murderer were brought to this bar,
what should we think if a counsel should plead
•that many murderers, ave murderers of title
and respectability, had passed unpunished,
let this man go too. That is the strangest
argument I ever beard. Our duty, my
lord, b merely official. I said before, we are
not the judges of, whether this man is guilty
or not, we are here considering whether he
has committed a crime that ought to be pu-
nished. 1 can have no hesitation in saying,
in my conscience, that there would have been
an end of all government ; every man would
be unworthy of existing, who held, that a per-
son finding fault with the constitution, and
raising insurrections in the country, is guilty
of no crime : and because others have done it
that we are not to sustain tlie action, is an
abomination^ that if a court of justice were
capable of it m this country, it would deserve
and be worthy to receive the fate of that
other country, in which all courts of justice,
all liberty, and all relijgion have been over-
thrown. I am of opinion that it is perfectly
relevant, that there is no occasion to separate
it, and say, this ^passage is seditioAs, ana that
is seditious, but, that the whole of it is se-
ditious: and I believe there is scarce any
thing in it but is seditious ; and I am happy
that, in this country, Scotland, greater pnvi-
leges have been enjoyed than in England. I
am happy to say, that a late incident has
shown that we have had more liberty than
England has^ for in questions of libel, and in
questions of seditioas publications, it never
was in the breasts of the jury to say, whe-
ther it was a libel or not in England till
lately ; it is so now, which is another proof,
that the parliament will amend themselves
when they see cause for it ; in so doing they
only adopted in England what is and was the
l^w of Scotland; and therefore, I shall give
my humble ofHnion^ that the hbelifi relevant^
and I humbly move your lordship to find if
cnminai. and allow the panel to prove all
lactsana circumstances tnat majr tend to ex^
culpate hhn, or mitigate his guilt; and to
refer it to an assize, to examine and consider
upon the whole of the evidence, whether this
is or not a most scandalous and seditious
publication, and whether this man has com-
mitted the crime of writing, publishing, or
circulating, yea or not.
Lord Abercrombif,'^yLy lord, before I give
any opinion upon the relevancy of the Ubel, I
must take the liberty to observe, that by far
the greater part of the argument, maintained,
upon the part of the panel. Seemed to me to
apply to a question, which, in my apprehen-
sion, has not the most distant connexion with
the issue of this trial ; I mean the whole part
of the argument which respected the tiberty
of the ]>ress, and the danger which that li-
berty might incur from the event of this trial.
I agree with the authors, quoted by the coun-
sel for the panel, that the liberty of the
press is one great bulwark of our free and ex-
cellent constitution, and, as such, I hope, my
lord, we shall ever preserve it ; but, in what
does that liberty consist ? It consists in this,
that every man may write, may print, mav
publish what he pleases, free from the lash
of a licenser, free from the controul of an im-
Srimalur, as the counsel for the panel stated.
ly lord, with us the liberty of the press is as
free as the liberty of speech itself; as every
man in these kingdoms may utter b^ speech
whatever he ukases, so he may write, may
print, may publish what he pleases, without
constraint, without being made amenable to
the lash of the law. But, my lord, he does
so under one condition ; tha^ if he speak trea-
son or sedition agunst his king or his coun-
try; if a man speak blasphemy against his
God ; if a man speak slander against his
neighbour ; then becomes he liable to prose-
cution jfor that treason, for that sedition, for
that blasphemy, and for that slander. Li
Uke manner, with the utmost liberty to print
what he pleases, if he print or publish nlas-
phemy, treason, sedition, or slander, for such
writings or publications he is punishable by
law when convicted by the verdict of a jury
of his country, to whose unfettered judgment
it must go, whether he has been guilty of
speaking, writing, printine, or publisning any
thing cnminai. My lord, that being the nature
of the liberty of the press, it cannot be affected
in any degree by this trial, in whatever way
this trial may terminate; for the press has
had full liberty to print, and the single ques-
tion now to be tried is, Whether this writing be,
or be not a seditious writing ? that question the
jury must ultimately decide. If there be no se-
dition in it, then the writer or publisher of it
has been guilty of no crime ; if^ there be sedi-
tion in it, then he has violated the laws of his
country ; and ought to suffer for so doing.
My lord, the sinde question which now
occurs for our consideration is, Whether this
jp09J dS (iSQR&E IIL Prwaedingi agah^ik^Bm^. T. FyAe Palmer ^^60
be^tfdilioviiWitipgorop? A^SAm m,^9^
that IS » queet^ga y^ny;}^, % i^grff) wtti) yoyr
Iprplsbip^ ae$ixi3 4o am not & ^mi^ of t|)«
^ip^llest doubt: for I bdiere there U not
within these wails one inan of common un-
^fdr^tanoing, whose mind it not ^arped by
^me strange bias, by some fo^ccoynlable
prejudice^ who do^ pot concur m the opinion
given by your lordship. As your lordship has
given that opinion so fully, and as the learned
counsel for the prosecution spoke of it so
iullv, I should tl^mk it improp^ in this stage
of the cfuise, to detain the coiurt with any far-
ther observations. That the mayor pro^si-
tion is sound law, and defines what is crimi-
nal no man can deny. It only remains for
me therefore to find the libel relevant to infer
4e pains of law; but allpw the panel to
prove^ in the usual form, any and all facts
and circumstances that may tend to exculpate
Iiim and remit his guilt.
The following gentlemen of the jury were
then sworn :
Charles Campbell,
Robert Stewart,
James Stewart,
Thomas Sandiman,
David Laird,
David Anderson,
Col. John Thompson,
Jas. Calderwood Dur-
ham, Chan.
James Lumsden,
Alexander Duncan,
Patrick Lindsay,
Alex. Cunningham,
Alexander Wood,
John Fair,
Andrew Whyte, clerk,
&c. &c.
EYinEVCE FOR TH|i CEOWV.
The Court GTsnted warrant to apprehend
the person of William Moncrieff, town-officer
in Dundee, who was lawfully cited to appear
as a witness in this cause, and ikUed to ap-
pear. - The court also fined the said William
Moncrieff in the sum of 100 Marks Scots.
Marry Davidton, sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Burnett*
Look at that declaratio«i, and see whether
it is the one that you hicard the panel emit?
— Yes.
Did he emit it voluntaril}^ ?^Yes.
He appeared to be sob^, and in his senses
at the time ? — ^Yes.
There was no force nor compulsion made
use of ?— No.
Look at tho$e subscxipiionsy and see if they
are yours at the back ?— Yes.
They were produced to you in the sheriff's
clerks office, were not they ?--Yes.
Is that your subscription ? — Yes.
It is signed by you ? — Yes.
Look at those two leUei:s ?— Yes, they have
my subscriptions.
Mr. Mack also identified the hand-writing
of the declaration and some letters, and pro-
duced a letter addressed to Mr. Skinrmg,
fpund in Mr. Skirving's house.
G^utMt MiMhmaker.. hpool —^fixamiiMd bv
You m a weaver in Dundee ?— Y^.
Mr. Ckrk^lt wm be proper to ^U thia
witness^ that there is notnipg that he iQay
say mmst himselfy tha^ can aflerwarda bo
brought Mtinst him in a crinupal prosecu-
tion ; and for verv oarticular rpasoiis^ I wi^
the witne^ to withqmw a minute.
iThe wi^csss wa9 oi^ered to withdraw.]
Ir. Clerl^. — My Jords, the fi^:t .n^ost cer-
tainly is, that this witness was himself tli^
author of the hand- bill whicli is now prose-
cuted ; this is a fact of a very delicate pature
for the witness to confess* ao^ therefore when
that-question comes to be put to him, I sub-
mit to your lordships, it would be very proper
to give him a very special wamiqg,and a very
special infosmation mdeed, that there is noth'^
iqg that he can acknowledge, a^ to his beinff
the writer or the publisher of this hand-bil^
that can affect his own personal safety; or that
it is possible that he can be brought to trial
for the publication of this haod-bul.
[The witness called, in again.]
Lord Etkgrove. — ^You are, upon the oath
I put to you, to tell the truth ; and I can as-
sure you that nothiog that you can adtnow-
ledge, or say, regarding your own conduct,
can militate against you : you cannot be ac-
cused of it ; however you must take care not
to charge yourself falsely, for whatever is not
true, you are liable to answer for.
Mr. Burnett, — You are a member of a so-
ciety in Dundee ?*— Ye% these are two societiea
in Dundee.
What are they called ? — One is called tb»
Friends of the Constitution, and the other,
the Friends of Liberty.
Which are you a member of? — The so*
ciety of the Friends of Liberty.
Where do the Friends of Liberty meet?
— ^They meet at present in a place, called the
Bcrean Meeting-house.
Were you in the use of attending their
meetings generally? — ^I generally attended,
them.
Are you acquainted with James Yeamao,
at the Scouring Burn ?-^Yea.
Is he a member of that society ? — Yes.
Are there officers in this society, people
that have any distii^uishing name ?-— Yes.
llave you a preses ?-^Yes.
^Vhat>other o^ers are there ? — ^We have a
sccretacy and a treasurer*
Did you bear any of these offices ?-^Yes.
What were youP— X was once treasurer,
and once president.
Do you remember a qiaouscript at any
time l>eing produced in this society, upoix
any particular occasion? — ^I remember diffe*
rent manuscripts.
Do you remember a manuscript in the form
of an address to frienil^ 9Dd leUow citissiis?—
Yes.
At what time was that, as far as you re-
member?—Sometime in, July month.
£&].] Jbr SeOilm.
Do you mmembei' the t&le of that.maitus-
cript ? — ^I remember it was called an address
to fellow dtizens^ or an address td the Friends
of liberty. I do not i^memher the words
exactly.
Who was it that produced this addre^, do
you Jmow N— The first part that was produced
was at a committee ; it was madit by the so-
ciety in general, afterwards according to their
liking. . .
Bat who produced the manuscript; th'^ first
fart of it ?— That which is but a pstrc of it I
produced.
The first part of it ?— Yes, what was iii be-
ing of it at that time.
Was that manuscript read at that meeting ?
—Yes.
Who readthe lUantiserlpt as fkr as ym tt-
coUect?^ln the committee I believe it ^^
lUd upon the table, imd A^r. I'almer. bdng
invited by me, and some others, to that scf-
de^, reaid it.
Bid Mr. Pidnker read it all thlrcrugh ?:-A^
far as I recollect he read it over.
What pass^ at the meeting f-^No more
passed at that meeting coticernmK it.
Was there ait after xticeting, Mien it' teas
produced ?i— Yes.
Was theits any other manilscrij^t produced
nt that metetlfig f— No other that! knovir of.
Lord Eskgrot>e,^WBs the nreedng a com-
mittee, or a full meetingf — ^li was What wks
called in our notice, a general extraordinary
meeting.
When wa^this getf^lral'^tti^rtlnyaTymteet^
ing called, as far as you recollect ? — ^I do not
positively rememher as to tbat.
Was it called by that coththfttee that you
were first in ? — Yes.
What was the princijple of calling tiiat ge^
oeral extraordinary meeting f-^Concermn^
the particnlar concerns of the socie^, in the
first place ;' tod then to publish an address td
Our fellow citizens^ upon the critical situation
of the country.
Was it proposed at that committee, that
this manuscript should be read in the genersd
extrabidinary meeting?— Yes.
Who pTodaced the manuscript afterwaxdi
at the general extraordinary meeting ?•— The
society was sometime gathered before t ^ent
in, and who broueht it into the houselcaii-
not tell; there had been some consideration
before I d&me itrto the meeting that night,
and then I sa^ i^ lying upon the table first I
tiunk.
Was it read at that general extraordinary
meeting^ — ^Ye^.
Who read it ?— M6.
Was there any debate upon ii ?^Ves> there
vraa.
Was the M9.of the Address complete at
that time ; was it finished ?— -No, it was not.
Wheh Mras it finished ?-*It was debated,
andvarioos alterations proposed and agreed
to, and those alterations ordered to be made
out.
A. D- 1793.
IS02
Was any thing dohe at the meeting after
those altelrations w^re made, any orders given
dbdut it? — It was ordered to be printed.
Now recollect yourself before you answer
this question, Who was it that tlie meeting
ordered to get it printed? — As far as I recoC
lect it was delivered to Mr. Palmer and James
Ellis, or one, or both of them.
Does it consist with your knowledge that
Mr. Palmer was a member of that meetmg ? —
He ehtered a member about tbat time.
Is there any form at the entry of a member?
(Jt'^ri^ book kept of the society's proceed-
ings ?'^There was a book with a test aiid the
names of the society — subscribing to a small
Declaration, and the reasons why they signed
it.
Arid eWy weihbfet signed that when he
entered? — Yes.
WbUld you ktto\y, if yoii were to see this
address, whether it was the same addrcs^,
that was apprbved of at that meeting and
t^rflered to be printed ?— I aih not very surte.
Look at this?—-! have seen a paper like
this beior^. I could not swear that it is alto-
gether the same, wotd for word, but th6 general
of it is the saifie, I think; but I could no't
SWeair to the whole.
Look if your subscription is at th'^ back
of that?— Yes. . , . . ^
You mctitioned sbmdlinib kgo, th^i' ther^
was only part of tne. address' m^de up and
prbdtTce'd at the comnilttee, and you men-
tlorted afletwatds, that this draiigBt wai pro-
duced aft^rtirjEirds 4t'tM' general meeting, or
part of it ; now^ as far as you recollect, was
an^ addition xhade to thi^ MSi fVohl the time
it was produced at the committee^ to the time
it wais produced it the gSnelr^ exUabrdii^ary
meeting ? — ^There were some additipU^.
tib ybUkiioW who nia^e the additioi^l?— I
was not present, and I at riot know.
V6yp\x know in Who^ po^sessioh the ili^i
was, frbin the time of tne committee to the
^enet^ rheeting i'-^As ^r as I know,^t was in
the possession- of Mr. Palmer.
yfks there) a^ far as ydu recolllect, an^
iliirig mentioned in the book's of the society^
when this MS. i/^sis read ; was any minute
taken dowii ? — ^No, th^re was not, that I re-
memh^r; if there was, I did n6t see it.
Look at this paper— is that,^as far as you
recollect, the MS. copy produced at the gene-
rid exUaordlnary meeting ?--tt b not.
Look atit again, and see if you know whose
hand-writing it is ?— I do not kridw.
Do you know any. hand-writing that it is
Wke ?— That is a question that I cannot meddle
with.
Lord Eskgrove^—You are obliged' to say
whdse you believe it to be. — I do not know;
and no tnan living can make me say more
than I know.
You must tell iis, what is your opinioii.—- I
can form- no opinion concerning that paper ;
I'do not know who wrote it, nor whose hand-
writing it IS.
SOS] S3 GEORGE III. Proceedingi againsi $he Hea. T. FyAe Palmer [804
Mr. Burnett. — ^Do you know the penon
who wrote that paper, that was afterwards
product at this general extraordinary meet-
ing?— The one produced at the general meet-
ins was the same paner with some additions.
Lord Eskgrove, — -Was it the same hand-
writing ? — It was the same paper with altera-
tions.
Mr. Burnett, — Whose hand-writing were
the alterations ? — I do not know.
Mr. Maconocfue, — Whose hand-writing
were the additions ? — I do not know.
Do you know the hand-writing of any thing
that was put upon that paper ? — I cannot say
as to that, because I wrote some of the alte-
rations myself.
Lord Etkgrove. — Did you write any thin ^
upon that paper between the two meetings r
— ^No.
Were there some alterations made between
these two meetings ? — ^Yes.
What opinion did you form? Did you be-
lieve it to be written by any one person m
particular ? — What I believe, I will not swear.
But you must tell us what vou believe. — ^I
thought it was Mr. Palmer who had done it,
but was not sure. I thought he said he had
wrote it; but am not sure whether he said
so or not.
Mr. Burnett, — ^Are vou acquainted with a
person of the name of James Ellis ? — I have
some acquaintance of him.
Did you ever see any letters of James
Ellis, or any writing of Ellis ? — ^I do not re-
member at present any letters, or writings of
bis.
Do you know hb hand-writing ?— No, I do
not.
You would not know it if you were to see
it—No.
^ Mr. Maconochie, — ^Were any of the altera-
tions, that were made before the committee,
or before the society, suggested by Mr. Palmer
in your presence ? — I have heard him in the
course of conversation speak about it^ and
propose alterations.
The question that I put is, Whether any of
the alterations, that were accually made, were
suggested by Mr. Palmer?— There were so
many of them speaking, that I cannot re-
member whether he did positively propose
amy of those things that were carried mto
efiect, or not.
Was he one of the speakers? — YeS; he did
speak upon it.
Lord Eskgrove. — You have said that the
society ordered the Address to be printed ;
and I think you said, it was delivered either
to Mr. Palmer, or some other person you
named. I want to know whether that order was
made by the meeting in general ? — Yes, by
the unanimous will of the society^ without
anytlissention.
Mr. Maconochie. — ^You said it was com-
mitted to Mr. Palmer, or Ellis, to get it
printed,— was any report made to the Society
by this gentleman^of its having been printed ?
— The first report I heard was, that it was to
be printed, and they accepted the offer, and
that they should get it printed.
Lord Eskgrave. — Upon the oath you have
taken, who was it made the offer to get it
print^i? — I said, these two gentlemen
adopted the offer of the society, that they
should get it done.
And when did you hear that it was printed?
— ^The first that I heard of it was, when I first
saw the printed copies in the meetins. — I bez
pardon^ I saw some in the hands of some cJ
the members before I saw them in the
meetine.
Mr. Burnett, — ^Who produced them to the
societv ? — ^I cannot say.
Dia you see any in the hands of Mr. Palmer
in the society ? — I do not remember whether
I did or not
Did you receive any of them from Mr.
Palmer? Recollect yourself before ^ou make
the answer. — ^I remember of receiving one,
but I am not sure whether I did not ask him
for it
Mr. Maconochie, — ^Were vou treasurer to
the society at this time ?— N o.
Do you know whether the society paid for
the printing of these copies ? — ^Yes.
Whom aid they pay for them ? — I heard
that they were paid for, smd saw the receipt
for them. I saw an order given for the society
to pay for them.
To whom ? — ^To Mr. Palmer.
And you believe that order was obeyed,
and actually paid to Mr. Palmer ? — I beheve
so.
Mr. Burnett, — Did you hear from Mr.
Palmer, or any other person, where this paper
had been prmted? — ^I never was informed
properly where it was printed, so as to telL I
might hear a rumour, out I cannot tell.
Where did you hear it was printed?—*!
heard it was prmted at Edinburgh.
Would you know the society book, if you
were to see it a^n ?'-I am not sure.
Look^ if that is the society book ? — ^I cannot
say positively what this book is, it is not un^
like it, but I am not sure, because I see
nothing to give me an assurance of it.
Do you know if there had been any leaves
torn out of the society book? — ^There was, I
heard, leaves torn out of the society book,
but I did not see it.
Do you know what the leaves contained,
that were torn out of the book ? — I cannot
say as to that, because I did not see them
torn.
Were you told what they contained ? — I was
told they contained the names of the society.
And what were the names subjoined to ?
were they subjoined to a test ? — ^Yes.
And that was torn out too, I suppose? — ^I
cannot say.
Lord Eskgrove, — Did you hear, whcthe^
the test was torn out?— I cannot be positive
whether I heard so, or not.
SOS)
Jbf- Sedbioiii*
A. TJ. 179$.
[300
George Ifeslnafterw^^iosfl-examined by Mr.
Clerk.
Bid yoa sign the test of the society F^Yes^
Do you remember the substance of the
test ?— I cannot positively say I remember it,
3a as to repeat it.
Recollect as weU as you can, and state
what it is in substance, not the very words,
but the meaning of it? — ^We, whose names
are hereunto su^oined, do declare, that we
are not altogether satisfied with the present
representation of the people, that we are for *..^ j^. ^-^ «« *«.. * „.a.,^. ^ ^i.
a shorter duration of parliaments, and a more I address of that sort F—No, I never did.
equal rspresentation, or something to that | Did you ever ask him to compose an ad^
pujpose, in the House of Commons^ dress?— I do not remember whether I ever
Was there any line or measure chalked ' did or not positivelv ; there was a talking of
out? — They were to use every legal means in I two addresses, or three, or more that were to
their power toobtainit. | be presented, but whether I asked Mr. Palmer
Was it a short or a long paper ?--It was | to wiitc one or not, I am not sure. I advised
prettv short him to make such alterations as he thought
What part of a page in this book did the ! necessaiy
tions that took place upon the Address, be«
tween the meeting of the committee and the
general meeting, what was the nature et the
alterations ?-rI do not remember as to the
alterations positively what was the nature of
them, but I believe the words that Mr,,
Palmer had thought too harsh, were taken'
out of it, or marked and interlined.
Was there any alteration in the spelling ?— *
Yes.
Was that the chief alteration ?^YeSy it
was.
Did you ever ask Mr. Palmer to write aa
test take up?--Not quite so much as the
fourth partof apage.
How maiqr hnes did it make ?— I do not re-
member the number of lines.
Do you remember it beins proposed to
Mr. Palmer himself, that he should write an
address ? — I cannot be sure at present of that«
Lord Abererombie, — ^You have showed that
Does it consist with jrour knowledge, who the Address remained in the hands of Mr.
wrote the Address when it was first produced ? Palmer, from the time of the committee, till
-^Yes. I the general meeting, and you said just now
Who made the original draught ? was it ; that you desired ^ir. Palmer to make what
Mr. Palmer? — ^No. \ alterations he thought proper; I should be
I think you said Mr. Palmer had, in the elad to know at what time you desired him to
course of conversation, and you betieved, no so. — At the committee it was given to
othenNOse, as he was a speaker in the meet-
ing, proposed alterations in the hand-bill?— ^
Yea.
Can you tell what was the nature of those
altpations? — ^As far as I could understand,
they were of a softer nature than the thing
was at first
What do you mean by a softer nature? —
The terms were not so harsh.
Mr. Palmer was for an address in softer
terms— not so harsh .' — Yes ?
Did Mr. Palmer ever sfiMeak to you of the
impropriety of publishing it at all? — In the
orieinal committee, Mr. Palmer was against
publishing it altogether.
Has Mr. Palmer a house at Dundee, or
near it?— He dwells in Dundee, I beheve,
sometiDH^ ; I have seen him in what I be-
lieved to be his own house.
him, and the committee ordered him to look
it over, and see what alterations were ne«
cessaiy.
Mr. Clerk, — ^You have said that some of
the alterations were made by yourself? — Yes.
Were those alterations made, after it came
out of Mr. Palmer's hands ?— Yes.
Lord Eskgrave, — Were your alterations
adopted ? — Yes, they were agreed to.
Mr. Clerk, — ^Am I to understand that those
alterations, that were made in the paper after
it came out of Mr. Palmer's bands, were
adopted? — Yes, ev^ry clause was debated
upon, and then agreed to.
You have already said, that Mr. Palmer
was a speaker in the debate— Did he encou-
rage those alterations that were proposed in
the society, or did he disapprove of them,
or what part did Mr. Palmer take in. the
Where does James Ellis live? — I have seen debate at the general meeting? Was he for
softening the terms, or makins them more
harsh? — I remember he was for softening
the expressions that he thought were incon-
venient ; and I do net remember bis propos-
ing any alterations that nisht tliat were for
making itj in my opinion^ harsher, but still
to be softer.
Did Mr. Palmer, at the night of the gene^
ral meeting, continue to dissuade them from
{publishing the paper at all ? — I do not recol*
ect righUy whether he was against publish-
ing it Uien ; but he was at last for uubliahing
it, ia agreement with the rest of tne society.
Do you kaowi or did you understand^
hiniy and h«ve reason to believe that he lives
with Mr. Palmer, but not altogether ; I cao-
not say that he Uves always wiui him.
Do you know at what time Mr. Palmer
was admitted a member of this society? — I
camot recollect the day of the month, but I
canrecoUect the time; it was on that night
of the general meeting that I formerly al-
luded to.
Lord Eikgreve. — ^Did not you say that he
was at the committee? — ^Yes, my lord; but
I also told ^rour kndship^ that he was invited
there that night
Mr. Clerk. — You have speken of altenu
VOL.XXm»
807] 53 GKOROE Ifl. Proceedings agaimtihe Ref>. 1\ Fyshe Painter [S08
what was the object of the society in ptib- a manusoript va^ produced «ul raa4 ?-^Yc«j
lishing this same paper ? what good conse* I was present.
quence did they expect from it? — ^I be]iev« Do you remember what time that was? —
tne meaning of the society was, if I rightly I do not positively recoHect th« date ; but I
understood them, that, in the present situa- think alx>ut six weeks ago, perhaps more.
tioQ of the country, and in the part that we | Who was it produced that manuscript? — ^I
had taken in the afiair, we were determined . was not there when it was introduced ; it was
to call upon our fellow-citizens, by a spirited in a person's band when I ^aw it.
address. We meant nothing in the work) but
to make way to their feelmgs, and not to
their passions ; we had no idea of sedition in
it; and if there was, it was from want of
knowledge in us : our ignorance is to blame;
and what we expected firom it was, in the
course of our prosecution, to cause a re-
form, we thought it necessiury to put, forth a
paper of that kind, to animale our fellow-
citizens to go on in getting that redress which
we had not yet got.
Was the propriety of publishing an address
debate at more 'meetmps than one? — We
had considered the publishing of an address
for two or \hree months.
And how many meetings might take pkee
in that time ? — ^I cannot say, te:au$e we va-
ried the times of our meeting ; sometimes we
met once a week, and sometimes not so
often.
And this was to animate your feliow-dti-
2ens in the same cause ? — ^Yes.
Did you propose to petition parliament ibr
a parliamentai^ reform at that time f— I do
not remember that being proposed ib the
Address ; and what we were to do afterwards
was to be guided by circumstances ; we were
not sure as to that of petitioning any more ;
we had not come to our re6ohita(»i in that
point.
Thanuu Ivory sworn. — Examined by Mr*
BurnetL
Q. What profession are you of? — ^.4. A
watch-maker in Dundee.
Do you know of any societies in the town
of Duadee that went by any particular name ?
— ^Yes, I do.
What names had they? — I know the
society of the Friends of the CoDstit«tk>B, and
a soeiety under the name of the Friends of
liberty.
Where did the society of the Friends of
Liberty meet at Dundee ?'— In the Berean
Meeting-house.
Lord Etkgrove. — ^It is fit that I should tell
you, that nothing that you ean say in point of
fact, with respect to yourself, can at all affect
ywL at any future time: you have nothing to
fear ; but to tell the truth.
Mr. Burnett, Were you a member of the
•ociety of the Friends of Liberty? — ^I was a
member.
At what time did you become a member?
do you recollect ? — I cannot be poiated as to
that.
A consideratble time ago ? — Yes.
Do you remember, upon any particular
occaskm, being present at that meetmg when
In whose hand was it ?— In George Meal-
maker's hand.
What was the tenor of that manuscript
so far as you remember ? what title had it .'-^
It was an address to the people.
What was the tenor of it, as far a^ you
remember?— I did not attend much to it, as
it did not meet much with my own ^^proha--
tk>n.
Upon what grounds did you disapprcFve of
it? — I did not asree to the arguments con-
tained in it, nor the matter contained in it.
What was the matter, so far as you recol-
lect?— I never attended much to the paper.
If I was hearioe it read, I could probably tell
what displeasea me in it.
What kind of a paper was it — a pamphlet,
or a book, or what ? — It was a short address,
contained upon a page of paper, I think.
Should you know that address by seeing a
copy of it? — I think I would.
Was it a manuscript or a printed copy that
was produced ? — I heard a manuscript copy
read.
Had you the manuscript in your own hand ?
—No, never.
Then it is only to the substance of it tbat
you can speak ?— I saw that copy once in the
town-house of Dundee ; but ^at was not the
oopy produced at the meeting, I think.
Read it. — I think this is the copy, at least
the substance of the copv.
Are you aisquaintcd with Mr. F^she
Palmer? — I know him by sight.
Was he present at that meeting ? — Yes, he
was.
Was there any debate? — ^Did any of the
members speak about the manuscript ? — ^Yee,
Mr. Paimer spoke with regard to something
in the written copy, as being too strong.
Were there any atlera^ons made that were
adopted upon that paper? — ff I remember
dialiBctly, I think some things wexe rendered
into questions which were in the written copy
assertMms.
Lord Ahercpomby. — Who was it that oen*
verted the assertions into questions ?— I think
Mr. Palmer did it.
Mr. Bc*rfiet#.— Did you hear any lliiBg
about printing tiiat paper ? — I do net rcmcm-
ber hearing any thing with regard to tlM
printing of it.
Da you know the purpose ^ that meeting i
— ^I understood the purpose of the meeting
was iK> appreve ear r^ot the paper then pro-
duced.
£>id you remain the whole time of the
meeting? — ^No, I remained a very short time.
What passed r«speoliDg that manuteript?
SOT)
Jbr S$dUion,
A. D. 17d8.
[SIO
—I do not ^lecoll^ any tfatDg> exoei>t Ibe
slnall alteratiOM I now ineolioDed.
lit. M9wnoehie.'^*-DiA they come to the
tesolutioQ of printing the manuscript while
you wen tkei<e?-^Not that I renember. I
ihiok it was to be submitted afterwards to
wine committee. I think some of the mem-
hen of the meeting spoke to that purDose.
Button did not stay? — ^No, I staio but a
short tune.
Mr. Bmmett,*^Vo you temember seeing
this manuscript after it was printed ? — I never
saw the manuscript after it was printed.
Bat did ^on see tibc paper f^Yes, I saw it
posted op m diierent parts of the town.
Did you see any of those printed papers hi
Mr. PsSmier's noasessionf*-! do not recollect
whettier i dia or not. I think I never was
in Mr. Pahuer's oompooy to see hun after
that night.
iiave ye« had occasion to be acquainted
with the hand-writing of Mr. Fyshe Fahner ?
«-<-I hvne seen it.
. Do yott think you should know say wrilting
of his that was shown to you ? — ^I cannot say
that I positively would know ; but I might
4iseem a vesemblanoe probably.
Look at those, [showing him some papctal
•^l think it bears soitae resemblanbe. I
caasot say /or these two last ones *. I do not
think there is any great resemblance.
Lodk at tiut. [showing him the address.]
»*-I caanet speak as to the hand-writing
IftalL
Are you acqusanted with James Ellis at
I>undee?— I cannot say that I am much
acguainted with him ; I know him.
Had you ever any occasion to see his hand-
vritine i — ^Never.
Lo(£ at that, [ft letter] do ^ou knowthait
hand- writing?-!-! think that is like to Mv.
Palmer's.
Mr. Ckrk» — My lords, I wish the witness
fb be removed one moment : it is not to make
any objection to the witness ; but I am sure
jour kiraship will see the propriety of it in
what I am ailiout to state.
[The witness ordered to withdraw.]
Mr. Cterk,-^ am going to mention to yiour
lordshtps a fact that has only come to mv
Jcnowledge within these two minutes; and^
my lordsy it is this, that there is a reraarksble
resemblance betweoi Mr. Palmer's hand-
writing and his brothers hand-writing, who
lives in England. Your lordships must kaow
very well, that it often takes place, that
there is a family likeness in hand-writings as
well as in laces, i have here some <m his
iRvther's haad^writtng which I wish to show
koBiy and ask hkn H that is not Mr. Psftmer's
fcand^writog. I mean to take your lordship's
^>inaon ttpon it
Jjbrd Jfif Af r9W.*^lf the public prosecutor
•lyeded to it, I do not know that the Court
«o«kl allow k: but I nnderstand they do not
l>igect to it, hat wish every indulgence to be
l^vsn.
[The witness called in iigaui.]
Mr. CUrk. — ^I wish to ask a question or
two first. You said you were present at this
meeting of the Friends of Liberty when this
address was canvassed ? — ^Yes.
Did Mr. Palmer take a part in the debate f
—I said before that he spOKe of putting whait
was asserted in the written copy into ques*
tions in the printed copy.
Did Mr. Palmer .propose any other altera
tions ? — I think, although I cannot say posi^
tiveiy, that he wished Sso to soflen some of
the other phrases. I cannot say positively as
to that.
Did you propose any altendkms yourself?*-^
No, I did not.
You disapproved of it yKwrsdf ?--Yes.
Please to look at that writing, do you think
that resembles Mr. Palmer's hand^writing?-^.
I cannot say I think it does. I never saw
any tf his hand-writing so large.
Upon what occasion did yon ever see Mf.
Palmer's hand-writing?— He wrote to ma
once ft'Om Edinburgh^
And you knew tnat that was his hsii&>
trriting?— No, I never said that I did posi-
tively know.
Do you kn<tw that that letter which yon
received from Edinburgh, was the hand'-writ^
iag «f Mr. Palmer ? — It was signed by Mr.
Pumer, and had a strong resemblance to
somd titles that I have seen on books of Mr.
Palmer's.
James Mattheet sworn. — ^Examined by Mr.
Burnett.
Were you a member of any society ki the
town of Dundee ? — Yes.
What society were you a member of ?-*-The
society of the Friends of Liberty.
Are you acquainted with Thomas Fyshe
Palmer r — I know that gentleman. I sQways
called him Mr. Palmer.
Did you see Mr. Palmer at any of thoaa
tnoetings ?*— Yes.
Do you remember any manuscript being
produced at that meeting ? — Yes.
Do you remember an Address to the Friends
ofIiber^?---No, I remember an Address to
Fellow Citizens.
Was Mr. Pakner present at that meeting?
—If I remember right, he was.
Who produced tmit address ?-^I did not see
it produced.
In whose hand was it ?— I cannot remem-
ber. It went from hand to hand. I believa
i had it in my own hand.
Did you hear it read ? — ^Not wholly thnnighi
i heard it read paraeraph and paragraph.
Was there any debate «pon it ? — Yes.
Did Mr. Palmer speak upon that occasion I
Did yon hear what he said ? — ^The substance
of it was, whether it should be printed or not.
What do you remember Mr. PahneT saying
then h^ remember he spoke against print-
Sll] S3 QEORGE III. Proceedingi agtunsi ike Re^. T. FyAe Palmer J^Vi
Ton heard it read. Would jwl know the
paper again if vou were to see it, and read it
over; was it tbe printed or the manuscript
copy that you heard read ? — A manuscript.
Do you know if it was printed } — ^I cannot
pay. I saw a printed paper afterwards that I
thought was it.
Look at this printed paper, and see whether
jrou think that was the paper you heard read
u substance? — ^Yes, I dare say that is the
paper.
Where did you see the printed copy } Did
you eet any printed copies from any person ?
< — ^I had some left at my house one night,
vhen I was not at home.
Do you know who left them } — ^No, I never
iaouired, and nobody told me.
t>id you «ee any other copies besides dx>se
left in your house? — ^I have seen sevoal
pasted up in the town.
Do you know if the meeting ordered any
person to print it ? — I remember there was a
desire to get it printed.
Who was desired to get it printed ? — Mr.
Paimer.
lUd.Mr. Palmer undertake to do it?— I
heard him refuse to write it; they wished
him to write it over again, and he refused to
do that
Did any person ag^ree to copy it, or did you
eee any person coi>y it ? — ^No, I did not.
Are YOU acquainted with a man of the
name of James Ellis?— Yes, I know him.
Was he at that meeting ?— Yes.
Do you know what was the purpose of the
society in ordering that manuscript to be
printed ? — The reason was merely to call
people's minds to the business of reform.
Do you know EUis's hand- writing ? — I am
not acquainted with it.
Did you hear any thing said in that meet-
ing about distributing this paper ? — It was a
general instruction from the meeting to tell
eveiy member to distribute it.
Are you acquainted withjthe hand- writing
pf Mr. Palmer?— I have seen some papers
that I bave thought was his hand -writing;
but I cannot say I ever saw him write.
Look at this letter, and ;see if you think
that is Mr. Palmer's hand-writing ? — ^I see a
similarity between that and some papers
that I have thought were his.
Did you hold any office in the society ? —
Not at that time.
Lord Eikgrave. Have you ever been presi-
dent of the society ? — ^Yes, I have.
Mr. Burnett. Were you ever in possession
of anv letter written by Mr. Palmer? — I cannot
tell if I was in possession of a letter wrote by
him, because I am not a proper judge whether
it was his or not.
Were you in possession of any letter that
was signed by a person of that name ? — I
bave been in possession of letters signed
y. F. P. and T. F. Palmer.
L(v>k at ^at letter, and see if you were ever
jp possession of it. Look at li, and ^nafce
vourself certain ? — I certainly think I have
been in possession of that letter.
Did you deliver this letter to any person ?—
No.
Did any person get it in vour custody ?— It
was taken out of my pocket-book, if I r^
member right, by a gentleman that I did not
know : his name I heard ; he came from
Edinburgh.
Where was it? — ^In my own house.
Do you know William Moncrief ? — Yes, he
was present.
Was any person paid for the printing of
this paper?— I saw it paid one night.
Whom was it paid to ? — [t was paid to Mr.
Palmer.
And by whom was it paid? — ^It was paid
by a member of the society, George Luke,
who was treasurer at that time, if I remember
right.
Was there a man of the name of Roes that
was treasurer there ? — I do not know.
Do you know if there was any book kept
by the society? — Yes, there was one book
kept.
uo you know of any leaves beii^ de-
stroyed ?— The last time that I saw it, it was
entire.
Did you know of any leaves being taken
out ? — It was reported so ; but I did not know
any thing of it.
Lord Etkgrave. Would you know the book
if you were to see it again ? — ^That is nearly
the size of the book ; but it was thicker, and
there was some writing in it
Do you think this hand-writins is the hand-
writing of Mr. Palmer? — I think it is some*
thing like the letters that I had.
Are they his hand-writing ? — I cannot make
up my mind as to that ; only I think it is
something similar to what I have thought was
his writing.
Mr. Burnett. Look at that letter, and see if
you can speak as to that ; is that the hand-*
writing of Mr. Palmer, as far as you know
and believe? — ^I cannot say but there is a
similarity ; one is a letter addressed to Bin
Skirving, and another a fragment of a letter ;
and the other is a letter to Mr. EUis.
You speak of a letter in your possession ad-
dressed to Ellis ?— Yes.
How came you by it ? — ^I had il from Ellis ;
he gave it to me about some money trans-
actions.
Jamei Matthew cross-examined by Mr.
Haggart.
You say, that a man from Edinburgh came
and took* your pocket-book finom you — hdw
came he to do that ? — I was seized some days
before, and was obliged to find bail : I was
seized on Monday morning afler breakfast : T
was taken into my own house ; he desired me
to open my trunk, and he searched the house s
he asked me what I had in my pockets ; I
argued against that ; and he told me, if I did
not do it peaceably, he must force mej and
315]
fifr Season*
A. D. 179S.
[314
then look ttff lepers out of my pocket-book.
IMd he show you any warrant that he had
for doing so?*— No.
You »id, that this written form of the Ad*
dress was submitted to the consideration of
the meeting ?— Yes.
Was there any debate upon that ?-^Ye8.
What was the nature of the debate, and
who took part in it? — ^It was whether it
diould be printed ; and whether it should be
printed in a newspaper, or how ; and con-
cerning some alterations that tliey wished to
Bake m it.
Which of the members proposed printing
it in a newspaper ?— Mr. Palmer.
Was he out-voted ? — ^Yes. I helped to do so.
Was Mr. Palmer one of the people, or who
was it that were for altering the terms of it?
— ^Different people; and 1 believe myself
likewise proposed alterations.
What sort of alterations did he propose ? —
The principal design of them was; as the
society had nothing but good intentions, he
wished to make it so as to give offence to
nobody.
Lord Es^^roce.— Were they adopted? —
They were some of them.
Was Mr. Palmer out-voted in those soften-
ing alterations? — In some of them he was.
- What was Mr. Palmer's reason for putting
it in the newspapers ? — ^The principal reason
that he assigned, was the savme oi expense.
• Mr. CUrk, — Do you know who made the
original draught of the address?—! know
ivho owned it to be theirs.
Who was it? — George Mealmaker.
What did Mealmaker do, or say at this
general meeting, when the address was under
consideration? — He spoke of it just as a man
would, who had a work of his own under
Gonstderation.
Do you remember any thing particular,
that he said ? — Nothing particular, more than
in a general way acknowledging it to be his;
when alterations were proposed, he defended
the orieinal copy.
Did ne defend it with obstinacy?*— Some-
times, be certainly defended it with a good
degree of obstinacy ; he was anxious to have
it continued as it was.
Was there any of the meeting that sus-
pected it was an illegal paper ? — No, I be-
keve not ; for my own part, I'had no thought
of it.
What purpose did you mean to accomplish
bv it?— My own idea was to call the peo-
ple's attention to the object of a parliamen-
taiy reform.
Mr. iHoeimocAie.— What did you under-
stand,, when you desired the people to gather
roimd the fsmric of liberty to support it ? —
IVfaaKtl understood by it was, that it was just
to join in petitioning parliament. . .
■ What did jTOU mean by telling them, that
it was in vain to p^titi^n parnamtot, that
yaa were not disappointed by the decision of
the House of Comowns concerning your pe-
titlon, and that it was a question you did not
expect (though founded on truth and reason);
would be supported by superior numbers?
Was that encouraging people to present ano-
ther petition? — ^What we meant by it was,
that we thought we could not get it this ses-
sion; but we were not so much disappointed,
as not to endeavour to petition again next
session.
Was it pasted up in Dundee in several
places ? — Yes.
Mr. Jia^gar^— This gentleman asked you
the meanmg of one passage of this paper,
but you will be so good, as answer me, and
tell me what you mean by different passages
of it. In the second Mrasraph " In spite of
the virulent scandal,'' &c. [See the copy of the
Address, in the indictment]. — Our idea was^
that, as we thought the representation in
parliament was now confinea to a few, in<^
Stead of being general, if people could get it
more general it would be better.
Now the next paragraph — " Is not eveiy
new day adding.*' [See the copy of the Address,
in the Indictment].-- That was just what we
thought; that there was a coalition against
us; and that there was a proof, that they
were not so ready to listen to us as they
ouffht to be
Lord Eskgrove. — ^You cannot go through
these paragraphs in this way; we cannot
hear his opmion of them.
James EUis, jun. sworn. — Examined by
Mr. Maconochie.
Where have you resided for some time
past? — In the house of Mr. Palmer.
Where?— In Dundee.
Are you a member of any of the societies
in Dundee ?— Yes, I am a member of boUi of
them.
How long have you been a member of those
two societies? — I have been a member of
them about eight weeks.
Is Mr. Palmer a member of them? — ^He is
a member of one of them.
Was he admitted before you? — I believe
we were both admitted the same night.
Do you remember what passed that nighty
»-Yes. The chief thing was an address to
be presented to our fellow citizens.
What was the title of that address?— I do
not recollect that it had any title.
Was it in manuscript ? — It was.
Do you know whose hand-writing the ma-
nuscript was ? — I certainly do know whose it
was. I am certain it was in the hand-writing
of a lad of the name of George Mealmaker.
Was all of it his hand-writing ? — Yes.
Were there any alterations in any other
hand-writing ? — ^Yes. There was one word.
Had you it in your hand ? — ^I had.
. Did you read it? — ^Yes.
And It was all his hand-writing, except one
word?— It was-
What was that word? — ^Either hurling, ox
drag^g; I cannot say which.
S15J S3 G£ORGB IIL Proceedings againd the Rev. T. Fyshe Palmer [316
Whose band*writiiig was tint?-— I caottot
tell.
Did the society make any alteratums in it?
— Ves.
In whose hand*writing were they made ? —
I cannot recollect.
Were any of them made by Mr. Palmer?—
Not that I know of.
You were then.- all that time, wera not
you ?-^Yes. I recollect thalt several people
had the Address in their hands, and several
people had pens in their haads ; but I cannot
say who made the alterations.
Was it ordered to be printed by the meet*
ingf^-Ittras.
And who iindeitooic to print it ? — ^I did.
Did any body else say any thing about it?
.—Mr. Palmer said he could safely get it
printed; and I am not certain whether he
undertook it, but we were both together.
Was it delivered to you, or to Mr. Palmer ?
— ^It was deUvered to me. I wrote a copy
for the press, ainl left the original copy lying
in Mr. Pahner's house ; and I do not know
v^at became of it afterwards.
What became of your copy ? — ^I was taken
ill, and I do not know what became of it
Did you ever see it after it was printed P —
I have seen it several times since it was
printed*
Have ^u seen it in Mr. Palmer's house
since ? — ^Yes.
Do you know whether it was paid for, or
not ?— I do not know.
Do you know whose printing office it was
printeoat? — No.
You never heard ? — No.
Did you inform the meetiag, that you
knew a person who would print it f — ^I in-
formed the meeting, that I would get it
printed.
Was there any person that you and Mr.
Palmer had agreed upon should print it, after
you had wrote it ? — ^No.
You left the manuscripts-Yes.
You had no conversation with Mr. Palmer
about the printing of it afterwards P — ^None.
Is that your hand- writing P — Yes, I believe
it is.
Was that the copy you wrote for the press ?
— I will not pretencf to say that
Did you write no other copy ?*— No.
Then that must be the copy you wroto for
the press. — Certainly.
Look at the date; is that your hand-writ*
ingf-^-No, that is not my hand I think.
Whose hand is that, to the best of your
knowledge and belief? — ^I am sure I could
not say whose hand>writing that is.
Lord Ahercnmby. — You are upon oalh;
and if there is no absolute certainty, you are
bound to tell the Court and jury what your
belief isP — My lord, I can only bdi^r^e a
thing that I know to be certain; and. if I
have but slight grounds for my belief^ it is
rather supposition than behef.
You are really bound by yonr <»th to tdi
all that youbdievev with fegard to that letter;
and, as to the htuid^writing, you are bound to
tell it; and if you do not tdi it, you sweat
falsely.*-My krd, I am so oonscbus of the
seriousness of the oath I have taken, that I
am really not to say any thing but what {
know, because I may be vastly mistaken.
You may be mistaken, but you are bound to
tell what your belief is. — I can only say, that it
is Kke Mr. Palmer's writing, but I can say
nothing farther.
Look at that letter ; did you ever see that
letter before p — I do not know whether I ever
did or not
That is a letter addressed to yen ; y«u ai«
desired to read it ; and having read it, you arc
desired by the oath of God to say^ whether
you ever saw it before or not?*-*-! can only
say, that I have seen a letter similar to that
Similar in writing ? — ^Yes.
And simihkT in matter?-^ Yes; but I vastly
dislike suppositions.
Do you believe it to be the same letter ?—
It has every appearance of it.
Do you believe it to be the same? If you
do beheve it and do net s^ tt, you aro entity
of perjury, and the Court wUl act with von
accordingly. The question to ^^u is a pkin
one. Do you believe the leuer in your nand
to be a letter which you have formerly re-
ceived ?-^I received a letter from Mr. Palnier
similar to that, but this direction here^ I lie*
lieve^ is different; and therefore I am not to
go upon a thing that I am not absolutely
certain of. I rather think tliat the letter,
that I reoeited from Mr. Palmer, was not ad*
dressed to Mr. Ellis.
You are, upon fronr oath, bound to say^
whether you think it is that letter that you
received iiom Mr. Palmer, yea or no}*^I
have told your lordship my reasons for doubt*
ineit
I really must caution you ; you now stand
upon the brink of a precipice : you say, you
received a letter from Mr. Palmer, tfa^ sub*
stance of which appears to be the same with
that, and the handowriting appears to be the
same ; now, what became of that letter which
you received from Mr. Palmer ? — I gave it to
James Matthew.
Did you never set it back from him ?—No.
Did he ever tell you what he made of it, or
what became of itP-^-I do not recollect hia
ever telling me where it went
Mr. MacoMK^.'^'Didi you ever hear or
not what became of it ?«^Yes, I have beard
from the repent of t^ town, which every
body hear^, that it was delivered to a man
who came from Edinburgh to Dundee.
Lord Abercramky^'^Yd/t your own sake, I
muaft again put that letter into your hand to
read it over agam, and sav upon your ^reat
oath, whether that is the letter you received
from Mr. Palmer, yea, or no, and which you
gave t6 James Matthew ; and you will attend
to the date of it, and to the recent date of it
Nqw do you^ or not> beikve that letter to.ba
5r/]
Jhff Sedition*
A. D. 179S.
C318
the same letter that y<m r^eived from Mr.
Palmer, and which ^ou gave to Jamefi
Matthew ? — ^I believe it is. 1 have now rea^
SOD to think it is.
Why did not you say so before ^—Because I
want to go upofn absolute certainty.
Mr. Maconochie, — Look at that paragraph ;
is it with regard to a printer? — Do you know
any thing about the printer ?— ^I have heard
TcpoTts.
You are quite iflaorant from that letter, who
is the printer of it? — I am cruite iennorant
of it.
Lord Abercromby.-^(re9;^) **^My letter to
Smiton, and part of my letter to the printer*s
brother are in evidence against me.'' Now,
will you say that Mr. Palmer never told you
who was the printer ? — No.
Did he never write to you who was the
printer f^ — ^No, he speaks of the printer's
Wother.
Mr. Burnett. — ^Do you know yoqr own hand-
writiiig when you see it? — Yes.
Is that your hand- writing? (tkowing him a
ktfer,) — ^Ycs, indeed is it.
J4me$ EUi$, jun. cross-examined by Mr.
Haggart.
Do you recollect being in company with
Mr. Palmer some time in the mon^ of June
last ? Where is Mr. Palmer's house f — In the
town of Dundee.
la it up a close ? — ^Yes, it goes by the name
of the Methodist Close.
Were vou in Mr. Palmer's house in the
month of June last^-^I do not think I was.
Do you recoiled Mr. Palmer and you com-
ing out of his house together?— I do not recol-
lect that.
Were you ever in company with Mr. Pal-
mer in the month of June last, when any
r)ple stopped you and him in the street ? —
remember being in company with him,
when aomebodv stopped us in the Close.
Do you recollect who stopped you ? — George
Mealmaker was- one.
What is he ?— A weaver in Dundee.
One of the witnesses here? — ^Yes.
Do you recollect any other name?— Yes,
Ibere was one Alexander Wood.
Is he a witness too ? — ^Yes.
Was there any other body ? — ^I believe there
were one or two, but I do not recollect their
names.
Do you remember what passed upon that
occasion ? — ^Yes, Mr. Palmer and I were going
up to Mr. Palmer's house, and those people
stopped us in the Close, and George said to
Mr. Palmer, I l)elong to a society of the
friends of Liberty, that meet in this Berean
Seeting-house above here, and told Mr. Pal-
mer at the same time, that they intended to
publish an address to their fellow citizens, and
that they would be very elad of Mr. Palmer's
aaetslance in it. Mr. Palmer asked them
what number of you meet there, and what
are they that compose your society ? and Meal-
maker, I think it was, answered* says he,
there are a vast number that belong to the
society, but there are not more than 30 that
re^ilarly meet there ; and we are composed
chiefly of tradesmen and labourers. Then,
says Mr. Palmer, you are so few in number,
I think it is a great folly in you to think of
{niblishing any thing ; it would answer very
ittle purpose, and would only bring an ex*
pcnse upon people that are little able to bear
It ; and Mealmaker said, we are not like the
other society, for we have money by us, and
we will publish it. Mr. Palmer said, he
thought it was folly to publish any thing at
present, that it would be only putting them
to an unnecessary expense, and he advised
them to publish uothmg ; and he made that
answer, that they had money by them, and
were determined to pubHsh. Then I went
back with them, and said, if you are deter-
mined to publish, I think two or three of
you should draw up an address, and bring it
with you ; and that which best pleased the
society, should be adopted — and we parted
upon that; however, I asked Mr. Palmer to
be so good as attend their next meeting.
Was not Mr. Palmer a member ?--No, he
was not at that time ; they asked it as a fo«
vour that he would attend their meeting.
Did Mr. Palmer accordingly attend, do you
know ?— I believe he did. The next day I
said to Mr. Palmer, Have you written any
thing for these lads yet? and Mr. Palmer sudf.
No; he did not intend to write any thing; ho
thought it was only bringing an expense upon
them that they were little able to bear. I
said, I think you are vastly mistaken ; there
is very little written upon that subject, and I
wish you would write something; and I asked
him, day afler day, to do it, and he always
put it on. He went to the society ; and when
tie came back, I asked what they had done^
and he said, some of them had given an ad-,
dress to him to look over and correct. I de-
termined to go to the next meeting ; and I saw
Mr. Palmer deliver back this adoress to Meal-
maker into his hand, and he said. As I am
not a member, I have not taken the liberty to
alter a single word but one.
What word was it ? — Something about hurl-'
ing or dragging; except, says Mr. Palmer,
what relates to the grammar and to the spell-
ing. Mr. Palmer said at the same time, I
would not have you publish this; at least,
says he, if you do, it must be materially al-
tered; and Mealmaker said, when I wrote
that address, I was conscious to myself that
there was not one word in it but was true ;
and, if it is materially altered, I will scratch
out my name in the book. After that, Mr.
Palmer desired that it should be debated,
clause by clause ; but it was first put, whether
they should publish or not? which was car-
ried; and the next question was, what they
should publish? and then they debated it,
clause by clause; and a number of alterations
were made.
S13J S3 GEORGB IIL Proceedings againd the Rev. T. FtfAe Palmer [316
Whose hand-wfitiDg was diat?^I caottot
tell.
Did the society mnke any alteratkms in it?
— Ves.
In whose faaod^writiDg were they made?—
I cannot recollect.
Were any of then made by Mr. Palmer ?«-
Not that I know of.
You were then,* all that time, were not
you ?-^Yes. I recollect thalt several people
had the Address in their hands^ and several
people had pens in their haads ; but I cannot
say who made the alterations.
Was it ordered to be printed by the meet*
ingf-*ItWM.
And who undertook to print it ? — ^I did.
Did any body else say any thing about it?
.-^Mr. Pateer said he could safely get it
printed; and I am not certain whether he
undertook it, but we were both tosether.
Was it delivered to you, or to Mr. Palmo' ?
— ^It was delivered to me. I wrote a copy
for the press, and left the original copy lying
in Mr. Palmer's house ; and I do not know
what became of it afterwards.
What became of your copy ? — ^I was taken
ill, and I do not know what became of it
Did you evfer see it after it was pnnted P—
I have seen it several times since it was
printed.
Have you seen it In Mr. Palmer's house
since ? — ^Yes.
Do you know whether it was paid for, or
not ?— I do not know.
Do you know whose printing office it Was
printed at? — ^No.
You never heard ? — No.
Did you inform the meeting, that you
knew a perton who would print it ?~I in-
formed the meeting, that I would get il
printed.
Was there any person that you and Mr.
Palmer had agreed upon should print it, after
you had wrote it ? — ^No.
You left the manuscript?— Yes.
You had no conversation with Mr. Palmer
about the printing of it afterwards P — ^None.
Is that your hand- writing? — Yes, I believe
it is.
Was that the copy you wrote for the press ?
— I will not pretend to say that
Did you write no other copy ?*— No.
Then that must be the copy you wrote for
the press. — ^Certainly.
Look at the date; is that your hand- writ-
ing ?^-No, that is not my hand I think.
>Vhose hand is that, to the best of your
knowledge and belief? — ^I am sure I could
not say whose hand-writing that is.
Lord Abercromby. — You are upon oath;
and if there is no absolute certainty, you are
bound to tell the Court and jury what your
belief is.^ — My lord, I can only beli^r^e a
thing that I know to be certain ; and. if I
have but slight grounds for my belief^ it is
rather supposition than behef.
You are really bound by yonr <»tfa to tell
all that you bdievev with regard to that letter;
Imd, as to the hand-writing, you are bound to
tell it ; and if you do not tell it, you sweat
ftklsely. — My lord, I am so conscious of the
seriousness of the oath I have taken, that I
am really not to say any thing but what I
know, because i may be vastly mistaken.
You may be mistaken, but you are bound to
tell what your belief is.-^I can only say, that it
is Hke Mr. Palmer's writing, but I can say
nothing farther.
Look at that letter; did you ever see that
letter before ? — I do not know whether I ever
did or not
That is a letter addressed to you ; you are
(lesired to read it ; and having read it^ you arc
desired by the oath of God to say* whether
you ever saw it before or Bot?*-^I can only
say, that I have seen a letter similar to that
Similar in writing ? — ^Yes.
And similar in matter?-^ Yes; but I vastly
dislike suppositions.
Do you believe it te be the same letter ?—
It has every appearance of it. .
Do you believe it to be the same ? If you
do beheve it and do not Say tt, you Iffo suilty
of perjury, and the Court wlu act with von
accordingly. The question to yow is a plain
one. Do you believe the letter in your nand
to be a letter which you have formerly re-
ceived ?-^I received a letter from Mr. Palmer
similar to that, but this direction here^ I lie*
lieve^ is different; and therefore I am not to
go upon a thing that I am not absolutely
certain of. I rather think tliat the letter*
that I reoeited from Mr. Palmer, was not ad-
dressed to Mr. Ellis.
You are, upon frour oath, bound to say*
whether you tbank it is that letter that you
received from Mr. Palmer, yea or no?— ^I
have told your lordship my reasons for doubt*
mgit
1 really must caution you ; you now stand
upon the brink of a precipice : you say, you
received a letter from Mr. Palmer, tli^ sub*
stance of which appears to be the same with
that, and the hand^writing appears to be the
same ; now, what became of that letter whicli
you received firom Mr. Palmer ? — I gave it to
James Matthew.
Did you never set it back from him ? — No.
Did he ever tell you what he made of it, or
what became of it?---I do not recollect his
ever telling me where it went.
Mr. JUiaconodUe.^^Did you ever hear or
not what became of it .^^^Yes, I have heard
from the repent of f^ town, which ev^y
body heard, that it was delivered to a man
who came from Edinburgh to Dundee.
Lord ilforcrofnjy.-^For your own sake, I
must again put that letter into your hand to
read it over agam^ and sav upon yaur g^t
oath, whether that is the letter you received
from Mr. Palmer, yea, or no, and which you
gave to James Matthew ; aod you will attend
to the date of it, and to the recent dale of it.
Now do you^ or not> beikve that letter lo.bo
ar/]
^ SetHlionw
A. D. 179S.
CSI8
the same letter that you received from Mr.
Palmer, apd which ^ou eave to James
Matthew ? — I believe it is. I have now rea-
son to think it is.
Why did not you say so before ?-— Because I
want to go upon absolute certainty.
Mr. Maconochie. — Look at that paragraph ;
is it with regard to a printer? — Do you know
any thing about the printer ?— ^I have heard
reports.
You are quite ignorant from that letter, who
is the printer of it? — ^I am quite ignorant
•fit.
Lord Abercromby^-^ireidR.) ^ My letter to
Smiton, and part of my letter to the printer's
brother are in evidence against me.'' Now,
will you say that Mr. Palmer never told you
who was the printer I — No.
Did he never write to you who was the
t)nnter> — No, he speaks 'of ^e printer's
DfOuier.
Mr. Burnett. — ^Do you know your own hand-
writing when you see it? — ^Ycs.
Is that your hand- writing? (tkowing him a
ktter.) — ^Yes, indeed is it.
Jamu EUUy juD. cross-examined by Mr.
EaggaH.
Do you recollect being in company with
Mr. Palmer some time in the month of June
last } Where is Mr. Palmer's house I — In the
town of Dundee.
Is it up a dose ? — Yes, it goes by the name
of the Methodist Close.
Were vou in Mr. Palmer's house in the
month of June last?--I do not think I was.
Do you recollect Mr. Palmer and you com-
ing out of his house together?— I do not recol-
lect that.
Were you ever in company vrith Mr. Pal-
mer in the month of June last, when any
r^ple stopped you and him in the street? —
remember being in company with him,
when somebodv stopped us in the Close.
Do you recollect who stopped you ? — George
Mealmaker was- one.
What is he ? — A weaver in Dundee.
One of the witnesses here? — ^Yes.
Do you recollect any other name?— Yes,
liiere was one Alexander Wood.
Is he a witness too ? — Yes.
Was there any other body ? — ^I believe there
were one or two, but I do not recollect their
names.
Do you reinember what passed upon that
occasion? — ^Yes, Mr. Palmer and I were going
up to Mr. Palmer's house, and those people
stopped us in the Close, and George said to
Mr. Palmer, I belong to a society of the
Friends of Liberty, that meet in this Berean
Seeting-house above hwe, and told Mr. Pal-
mer at the same time, that they intended to
publish an address to their fellow citizens, and
that they would be very elad of Mr. Palmer's
assislaBce in it. Mr. Palmer asked them
what number of you meet there, and what
aie they that compose your society ? and Meal-
maker, I think it was, answered; says he,
there are a vast number that belong to the
society, but there are not more than 30 that
re^ilarly meet there ; and we are composed
chiefly of tradesmen and labourers. Then,
says Mr. Palmer, you are so few in number,
I think it is a great folly in you to think of
publishing any thing ; it would answer very
little purpose, and would only bring an ex-
pense upon people that are little able to bear
It ; and Mealmaker said, we are not like the
other society, for we have money by us, and
we will publish it. Mr. Palmer said, he
thought it was folly to publish any thing at
present, that it would be only putting them
to an unnecessary expense, and he advised
them to publish nothing ; and he made that
answer, that they had money by them, and
were determined to publish. Then I went
back with them, and said, if you are deter-
mined to publish, I think two or three of
you should draw up an address, and bring it
with you : and that which best pleased the
society, should be adopted — and we parted
upon that; however, I asked Mr. Palmer to
be so good as attend their next meeting.
Was not Mr. Palmer a member?— No, Ke
was not at that time; they asked it as a fo-
vour that he would attend their meeting.
Did Mr. Palmer accordingly attend, do you
know ? — I believe he did. The next day I
said to Mr. Palmer, Have you written anr
thing for these lads yet? and Mr. Palmer said.
No ; he did not intend to write any thing ; ho
thought it was only bringing an expense upon
them that they were little able to bear. I
said, I think you are vastly mistaken ; there
is very little written upon that subject, and I
wish you would write something ; and I asked
him, day afler day, to do it, and he always
put it off. He went to the society ; and when
tie came back, I asked what they had done^
and he said, some of them had given an ad-,
dress to him to look over and correct. I de-
termined to go to the next meeting; and I saw
Mr. Palmer deliver back this address to Meal-
maker into his hand, and he said. As I am
not a member, I have not taken the liberty to
alter a single word but one.
What word was it ? — Something about hurl-'
in» or dragging; except, says Mr. Palmer,
what relates to the grammar and to the spell-
ing. Mr. Palmer said at the same time, I
would not have you publish this; at least,
says he, if you do, it must be materially al-
tered; and Mealmaker said, when I wrote
that address, I was conscious to myself that
there was not one word in it but was true ;
and, if it is materially altered, I will scratch
out my name in the book. After that, Mr.
Palmer desired that it should be debated,
clause by clause ; but it was first put, whether
they should publish or not? which was car-
ried; and the next question was, what they
should publish? and then they debated it,
clause by clause; and a number of alterations
were made.
319] 33 GEORGE III. Proceedings aguimt the Men, T* FyAe Palmer [320
Who took a part in it?— Myself and Mr»
Donaldson. Mr. Donaldson suggested a mo-
tion to me.
Did any body take part in the debate be-
sides yourself and Mr. Donaldson ?— Mr. Pal-
mer took part in it.
What was the nature of the part that he
took in it? — Mr. Palmer desired them fre-
quently. If you do publish, you must soften a
number of those phrases; not, says he, but I
believe that every word in it i9 really as true
as the Gospel ; but the people in power will
be vastly ready to make a handle of it against
you : he said, that it might be laid hold of by
the people in power, and they would get into
trouble.
What was the avowed intention of the
meeting in publishing that paper ? What was
their ooject? — Their object was to induce
their neighbours to join with them, to procure
a reformation in parliament by all peaceable
means ; to awaken the minds of the people,
that they should join together, and petition
the legislature for the removad of what we
consider as grievances.
What were the reforms you pointed at ? — A
more eaual representation of the people. He
earnestly advised them not to publish at all,
but, if they did, every word that was offensive
he desired to be altered ; and it was often car-
ried against him; and, when put to the vote,
they were ordered to stand.
It was George Meaimaker who wrote this
paper?— Yes.
How do you know that he was the person
that wrote it ?— He says to Mr. Palmer, when
we were going out, I would thank you to write
over a clean copy for the press, for my band
is not easily read ; and he asked me to do it,
and I did it.
. Did you see Mr. Palmer return it to Meal-
maker? — Yes; I did it at the next meeting.
Did Mr. Palmer pay the expense of publish-
ing this paper?— I saw Mr. Palmer get the
money in the society one evening for publish-
ine it; it was paid m my presence.
Mr. Maconochie^l asked him before, and
he said he knew nothine about the payment
of it. — I believe not; if i did say so, I was un-
der a vast mistake.
Mr. Hag^arf — What did you understand to
be the meaning of that address P Did you
suppose it to be any thing farther than for a
reform in parliament ? or what was yaur opi-
nion of itr— I can only answer for myself,
that there was no seditious intention in it ;
for I made a motion afterwards, that a name
might be put to it; for as there was no name
to It, they would say we wished to steal into
the world ; and we were sorry that those in
power should think that we meant any thing
wicked.
^ lord Abercrombu — In what capacity did you
live with Mr. Palmer?— As a visitor merely,
nothing Luther.
Alexander Morrin called in.
(Ordered to withdraw.)
Mr. Clerk — I object, that no such person
is cited as a witness upon this trial. Tnere is
a Mr. Moran cited as a witness, but not the
person who was in the presence of the Court
a little time ago; the name is spelt wrong;,
there is a variation of one letter.
Mr. Byrnett. — I submit to your lordship,
that this is the same objection that was re-
pelled by the Court in the outset.
Lord Abercromby — It is no objection at all*
The Witness sworn.
(Examined by Mr. Burnett,)
Do jou remembei* being in possession ^of^
any printed Address to Friends and Felled-
citizens? — ^Yes.
How many of them had you in your pos-
session?— ^I had what they called 1,000 copies
in m V possession.
Where did you get them from ? — From the
printer.
Do you remember, upon your oath,— and
think before you answer the question that I
am to put to you, — What printer did you get
them from ?— From my brother.
What is his name ?---John Morrin.
Was he the printer of them ? — ^I believe so.
Do you know by whose orders these papers
were printed ? — Yes.
Who ordered them to be printed f-^It was
Mr. Palmer.
How do you know that? — I got a letter,
from him ; but I do not know whether it is
his hand-writing or not.
Had you ever received any letters firom
him before? — ^Yes, but I never saw him
write.
Did you think that it came from Mr. Pal*
mer? — Yes.
Was it sig[ned by Mr. Palmer? — ^Yes; it
was si^ed with his initials.
Was there any manuscript copy sent to you
to get printed ? — Yes.
wi ■ -
ho sent it ? — Mr. Palmer.
Look at that paper, and see whether that
is it or not ? — ^Yes ; it is.
Did that piece of a letter come with it ? —
No.
Look at that.— This is the psq^er that came
alons with it.
When did you get this; before or aftcr-^
wards ? — ^I think I got it before.
Are you sure you eot it at all ?— I think so.
Look again, and l)e certaia whether you
got it or no? — ^I jgot it before,, but tlieie was
nothing printed from it.
Do you know any thing about tlie tearing
of these letters? — No, I know nothine about
it,, except by accident: I did not think they
were of any conseouence..
What became ot them af\er you got th^n.f
were they torn while they were in your pos-
session?— ^Yes; I suppose so.
How got they out ot your possession ?-^Tbft
S2I]
fir Seditictu
A. D. 1795.
[S9S
offieerB came and searched my shop ; and I
actually did not know there were such papers.
Do you observe any alterations made in
them smce? — No.
Was the manuscript got at that time? —
Tesy upon the search.
Were you present at the search ?— -Yes.
Had you any directions to. destroy the
letters, or the manuscript, either the one or
the other ?-*No ; I had no orders to destroy
them.
Not fmn any body ?— No.
Look at that; what is it? — ^A paper that
was found by the officers in my possession.
Did you send off the principal ? — ^No.
It was intended to have been a letter?—-
Yes.
To whom ?— To Mr. Palmer.
What did you do with the 1^000 copies that
you got from your brother ? — I sent them, as
oesiredy to Dundee.
Did }[ou send them all to Dundee?-*! kept
ISO copies.
You sent the rest to Dundee ? — Yes ; I was
desired to give 100 copies to Mr. Skirving.
i^nd you kept them for him ? — ^Yes.
And did he get them from you ? — Yes.
Did he call tor them, or send ibt them ? —
He sent for them.
To whose address did you send those that
youseot to Dundee ?— The person that desired
me to g^t them.
Who was that ?^Mr. Palmer.
Which way did you send them ? — By the
carrier.
Did you send 900 to Dundee then ?•— I ima-
gine so; I did not count them.
Did Mr. Skirving get the whole 120? —
Ho; he got but 100.
What became of the 20?^They were left
In my shop.
Did you part with any of them ?— Yes; I
gave some odd ones of them away.
Did Mr. Palmer apply to you afterwards
about them ? — ^No.
Did you ever hear from Mr. Palmer after
be had got the rest of the ifiOO copies? — No.
Did you get any payment for them from
any person ? — No.
I>o you know if your brother was paid?— I
cannot tell.
John Motrin sworn. — Examined by Mr,
Maconochie.
•
Were you employed to print an address to
the^Friends of Liberty at Dundee ?-— Yes.
Who employed you? — ^My brother.
How many were printed?-— 4 or 500, I
imagine.
Were you paid for it ? — ^No.
You never were paid ? — ^No ; never.
IMd yon know wno employed you?-^It was
my brother.
Did he pronuse vou pavment?— Yes.
Do you know who set nim upon the busi-
ness?—No.
Did you ever ask iuBk?-»No.
voL.2yan.
Did you send him all that were thrown off?
— ^Yes. *
Did you debit him in your account-book'
for them? — ^No; I have no acoount-books.*
Look at that ; is that the one that you print*
ed? — It looks like it ; another might prmt it
just in the same manner.
Look at that : Is that the manuscript that
you printed from ? — I dare say it is.
George M^Intoih sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Maconochie,
You are a clerk to Mr. Handyside in Edia*
burgh 7 — Yes.
Do YOU remember ever getting a copy of a.
printed address? — Yes, I got many a one.
What address is it? Is it an address to
Friends and Fellow Citizens?— I would know
it if I saw it.
Look at it. — ^Yes ; I have seen that paper.
Had you them in your possession ? — ^Yes.
Who gave them you? — Mr. JMorrin; he
gave me only one.
Did you see any more copies of that adr
dress ? — Yes, in sheriff-Clerk's chamber.
No where else ? — ^No.
William Middleton sworn. — Examined by .
Mr. Maconochie. '
Were you employed to search the house of,
Mr. Skirving ? -Yes.
Who was with you ?-r-Mr. Dingwall^ Mt
Joseph Mack, and Andrew Scott, a sheriff's
officer.
Was Skirving present ?— Yes.
What dkl you find in that search ?•— There
was a letter found in a writing-desk^ said to '
be wrote by Mr. Palmer to Mr. Skirving.
Is that the letter (showing it to him) ? — '
Yes.
[It,is ready addressed to Mr. Skirving, dated
Dundee, July 9, 1793.]
Letter from Mr. Palmer to Mr. Skibviho* .
Dundee, July 9th, 1793.
Dear Sir; I wrote to you some time ego,
wishing to see Mr. Wharton's answer, when
it came to hand. M'Farlane sets out on Fri-
day, and if you deliver a letter or parcel on '
the Thursday, it will be time enough. I wish
you would send me some of the b<K>ks on the
Liberty of the Press.
The Friends ef Liberty have sent to Mr.
Morren an address to get printed. It was'
written by a common weaver, I think it ad-
mirable. We want a copy to be sent to all
the societies of the Friends of the People, if
you will take that trouble. You may ask Mr.
Morren, grocer, Luekenbooths, for 900 copies ;
if you wish to decline the trouble, send ttie a
paper with the address of each societv, and
take 50 or 100 for the use of Edinburgh.
I would have you write to Mr. Roberts,
writer in Forftr, he has long had money by '
him for the use of the convention. You may
apply at the same time for the payment of
ai^ advertisement in th» Chioniok and the
Gazetteer.
. Y
SSS] 83 GEORGE III. Ptoceeding$ again^ the JU^ T. Fifshe Palmer [||4
Tht Frieda go on here with um» degeee
of spirit, they hive mtroduced the practi^^'of
tieaaing letters, extracts, and amatt pamphlets,
4Qd then eoforciag thecD hy Hgument, which
seems to be hkely to produce ipuch good.
]>t j^e hear mm you by the cetum of the
carrier, and tell me aU the political news with
^u. pudhope Castle, cloie by this town, is
§oing to be converted into Barracks, to keep
own any efforts for our freedom. A ship
master just come from Glasgow says, nothing
was ever like the distress at Glasgow, that
while he was there,'two men dropt down
dead in the streets, famished for want of
food.
Yours, with best remembrance to all friends,
(Signed) T. F. Palmbe.
You found that letter in the house of Skirv-
iog?-«Yes, in tiie wiithie-desk and bureau.
Look at that paper. — There were several
copies of that delivered to me by Mr. Skirv-
ing.
^ You were likewise employed to search Mor*
rin's d>op ?— -Yes.
Morrin was present ?•— Yes.
Did- you find any oof ies of tbaX paper in his
house? — ^Yes; af|^.
Are those the papers you found in his
housed — Yes.
Ednard Leslie sworn. — Examined by Mr.
BumeH,
You are a stationer in Dundee ? — ^Yes.
Do you remeuf)^ Keceiving a letter from
%Mr. Eoss?>-Yes.
At wnat time did you receive it? — I cannot
charge my memory wiCh the time.
Do you remember the direction of the
letter ? — It was directed to me, bu): addressed
to another man.
Do j^'ou remember having in your possession
any printed copies^ of an address, to friends
and Felloi^-citi^ens?— Ye9.
Whom did you get those pdqlfd. tx^s
fioffi?-r-Froai Mr. Palmer.
Can you tell what time this waa?«-^I auwot
v^ooUeci the time.
In what way did you get them ?— He gave
me them with hia own hwd.
How many conies ?— I never counted them.
How noAsy oo you slqtpoae?— Icaafoon
ao idea, of it.
Were they put^up in a huadki^No.
Were, there two copies or mpre?— Thece
w^smorethaohalf a doten of i themi; audi
locked them ky*
WhatdidMr^SaJnessaytayou, lyheiilie
ge.ve.3r0u themiP— Koihing at. all
Eer whttt purpose did you.fluppo8e he gave
them you?— I supQosed tagive^aooiy.
. Did you give, them Awa9r?-^TwQ or three
ecmiesldid, toith6.besl.df:<ihyjGememhraiii&
V(hat heci^me at, them^L hwai themu
What made, ypu bura themi^Becauae I
vmgkx ix wee «at «i£i%a:butt.yiemiamy
custody*
Do you know vhelher iii^ Fafa»er gave
^them \a. aay body elaeV-I hdieve be gaiM
some to Mr. MiUer th^ hookseUec
Mr. Haggartr^Yow say you Immt 1|»tni
copieOf hadyou heard of any aeaichiogf—
It was after Mr. Palmer waa taken u^ thai I
burnt them.
David Miller, sworn. — Examined by Mr,
Maconqc^ie. '
Look at that — did you ever see a copy^l
that production before P-^YeSy I have.
Upon what occasion did you see it^*-It
was brought into my shop biy Mr. Fakner.
Were there any considenble number of
them ?— A few.
Were there half a dozen? — ^I dare say there
was that.
A dozen?^I cannot aay, fiv I did not
count them.
Did you get any orders ftom Mr. FlJodusr
relative to it 7— No; upon my oelh I camiol
say that I did.
What did he sayf— He said^ il was a
wonderful composition to bo the pmdiictioa
of a common weaver.— -I supiiosea thai they
were to be given away.
Did you uoderstandi when you gpt tbem«
that they were to five away ^-^It was natnral
tosupposesoy who) they were brought to me
in thai way-~-Mr. Palmer did not sayjthej
were to give away.
Did you disknbutealiy of theni?«»Not to
my knowledge.
What did you do with them ? — I took theaa
off my counter; and tliere is a board that
covers over where li cut my paper; I wit
them in there; and some htUe tim« aner
burnt them.
Why did you bum them?-—! did not like
them ; I suspected tliat some misd^f mighti
arise fiom.them.
You didi that, before any notice maa taken
of themf^I cannot say, whether A waa w
not— they lay in my shaving-tub some ooH*
sideiable time.
James SmiUm, sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Macanockie,
• • •
Did you receive that letter^ [Shonriiigit
him.] — ^Ycs.
Whom is it wrote by ?-^I suppose it is wdu
ten by the person who si^s it.
Who signs it?— -It is signed T. F. Falmefy
hut Idciitot timik itie hiasigoatiiiie.
What makes you think it is not hk, tm*
nature F—I think the name haa been addea ;
I am nret^ fvsitive it has.
Did you give that letter to the shecyT at
Fife ?— Yes.
Was not Mr. Pahnex'ii name to i^ vhfta
you vut your su^iacription iqpo^ itl^-nlke
mitialswere, but not the full name^
That you say upon yo^ cntidi,. Aat the
initials only., wen there, aad soft tii^ ftU
name ?— -Yes.
Do you know^vba puLitihnai^rK^
linrillM^tl^iiiitiids?-.!^ F. P.
LoA tigaih^ and be certain beibi% you
mfftifr % noi*; remember jotoi are upoh your
oath, and you are asked that question. Cdn*
aider before you speak. — ^I will not swear to
the lettM, mtt I will swear that the name
w^ not dt full length.
l^rd Etkffraoe.T'Ycia say upon your oath
^t tberfe was nothing but the initials when
you itccited it ?— Yes.
Mr. Maemufchk, -^jyo you know Mr.
^almer*s hand-writing? — ^I never saw him
^tie.
Have you ever recdved letters from him ?
— Tes. .
ts that the same hand-writing with the
other letters you received?— -Yes; I think
•i » .
It 18.
' The letter read as follows :
I^etter to Jahes Shiton, Newburgh, (signed)
T. F. PALMEa.
My dear Friend; If I was severe in reproof,
it was far from my intention. I would not,
ofi any account, give you pun. The account
you give of the oamnhlets is curious. They
ahaii soon be repiacea, when I can get them
an. Have you a copy of the Letters to Phi-
losophers ? I send you some addresses writ-
ten bj a eonunon weaver, some Wharton's
speeches^ uod one incomparable address on
A..D. JTBS.
rsfs
I will send you by-and-by a book on Ande-
rica ; my friend, if you could but muster cash
enough to go with me, I could almost trust
20U; to Jive my days with you. James Ellis,
UmA Hudies, and ftmily, talk of ^ng with
me. Dr. Priestley cannot sleep qmetl)r in hia
bed owinf to the unceasins persecutions of
the high cnurch party, and be is goinealso ;
las foot worn are there. He has been obliged
more than oii6e si^ce he has been at Hf£k-
nqr to leave his house, least he should be
txmit alive.
' Tlie patrrats have defeated the rebels at
NsDls^ 8,000 kiHed, rOO taken prisoners.
I^BPe you not Cooper's pamphlet; I mean
hia answer to Burke ?
Johft Baiiingatt was here, went away on a
fiunlay, never called, and never meant to
worship with us. I heard Pine to my no
anall entertumnent ; it requires some inge-
nuity to be so excessively absurd, Farewdl,
jour's.
(Signed) T. F. Palmer.
July «0, 1773.
i hkve g'ot three copies of the Address to
Ptotesiant Clergy to sell. If you or others
Kav^ a miiid to purchase a copy of Letters to
£hl^[)sopher8, r will order it from London.
Both pamphlets are one shilling each.
Did you receive any copies of the printed
fmet with that letter?— Yes.
' n6w many ? — I did not count them.
Were there a doseit?— I believe there
■ig)iili hot I did not count thetitt.
Did yoB Asdd the'addr«§s ?<— Yes.
Did yon giv^ tfaein away to any bo9]^ ?^^
Yes.
Whom did ybu give them to ?'-^fgkve One
to a Mr. HarwcM; one to Mr. 'Fisher, and
one to James Blvth, and one to John ^lin*
gall; and I do not recollect that I gave any
to any body else.
Who sent ydu them?— They came with s
letter.
Mr. Htiggart.^hx tiiat letter, which is said ta
have been writteh by Mr. Palmer to you, some
pamphlets ai'e mentioned and recommended
m it; what "iras the nature of those damph«
lets? were thfe^ of a religious o> or a poli:
tical kind ?— One was a rengioui pampnlM^
and the other a political one. One was an
Address to Protestant Clergy, entirely on the
subject of religion; and the other was Hofde
Tooke's Trial.
Mr. BuHkBtt, — Gentlemen, the parole evi-
dence on the part of the prosecution beine
now closed,, there are several papers whlcfi
will be read to von in evidence, aiid amorrgftt
others the declaration of Mr, Painter him-
self.
Declaration emitted by Mr. Palmer, at Edin-
burgh, the second day of August, seven-
teen hundred and ninety-three years.*
»
The which day, compeared in presence of
Harrv Davidson; esmiire, sherin substitute
of the shire of Emnburgb^ Mr. Thomail
Fische Palmer,^clerKynian m Dunde^ pre«
s^y vA Edmbur^, who bong ezammed
and intern^te, when he went last to Dun-;
dee, he ansyvered, That, net knowing the
tendency 6f the questi6n8 to be put to him;
and being unacquainted vrith the .law of
Scotland, and not havins ieen the petitioil
upon which he has been mught to town, h^
decfines answering this 6r anv other qjuestionl
that may be put tn him; and being mteitou
gated, whether or not he is acquainted wiUi
William Skirvin^ of Strathruddj|^, residing in
Edinburah, and sometimes desianed, secre-
tary to Uie Friends of the People, at Edin-
burgh, or with Alexander Morren, grocer and
spint-dealer in Lockenbooths, Edinburgh,
Mr. Palmer deClases, and declines an^wermg
any questions. Being interrogate whether
he has corresponded with either of those gen^
tlemen since he went to Dundee, he^ declmea
answering any question ; and bein^ shown a
part of a letter, or writing, and being asked,'
whether it is of his hanl-writing, and whe*
ther the name, F. Palmer thereto, is of hi^
hand-writing, declares, it is like to his hand*
writing and subscription, and which writing
is manced, as relative hereto; and being
shown two pieces of writing, or part of a
letter, now tacked together, and asked whe-
ther it is of his hand-wri^ng, he declines an«
swering the question, which pieces of writing
is also marked as relative hereto. And bein^
shown a writinff^ dated, << Dundee, Berean
Meeting-house, July, 1793,'' and intituled
SS7] S3 GEORGE UL Proceedings againsi the Reo. T. FyAe Palmer [3SS
thus. «< At a iroifiral meelane of tbe Friends answer to the duestionSk and added that it
thus, ** At a general meeling of the Friends
•f Liberty, they unanimously resolved to
publish the following address to their Friends
and Fellow-^tizensJ' And beine asked, if
he ever saw this paper before, declines an-
swering the question; and being asked,
whetiier the words at the top of said
writing, " Berean Meeting-house, July 1793,"
are ot his hand-writing, he declines answer*
ing the question ; and being asked by whom
the said writing was wrote, with the above
exception, after the date, he declines an-
swering the question, and which is also
marked as relative hereto, and being shown
the copy of a letter, referred to in the decla-
ration of Alexander Morren, of the first inst.
and asked, wheUier or not he, the declarant,
leceived a letter from Alexander Morren,
of the like or a similar import, he declines
answering the question, and which copy letter
is also marked as relative hereto, of this
date ; and being shown a printed paper, dated
*^ Dundee Berean Meeting - house, July,
1793," and narked as relative to the declanu
tkm of John Mocren, and Peter l>uSj of this
d^te, and being asked, whether he had ever
seen any printed copy, or copies of said
paper, he aedines answering the question;
and being asked, if he corresponded with any
person wnatever, in Fife, or Perthshire, re-
lative to the said printed paper, and in parti-
cular with James Smiton, Wright in New-
burgh, or. had .ever sent him printed copies
of said paper, he declines answering the
toestion; and being shewn a letter, dated
^. July ^, 1793,'' (signed) T. F. Palmer, and
bcffinnine wiUi,^' My dear friend,*' and being
asked, whether said letter is of his han£
Writing, and was subscribed by him, and to
whom it was sent, he declines answering the
question ; which letter is also marked as re«
lative hereto of this iiate : declares That when
last in Edinburgh, he resided with Mrs. Do-
naldson, Old Assembly Gloss, Edinburgh,
and though he paid her off before he went to
Dundee, part of his effects are still in the
two rooms which he possessed in her house ;
and being asked whether, before leaving
Edinburgh, he gave to the foresaid Alexander
Morren, any written or printed papers, he
declines answering the question; and beine
asked whether or not he is acquainted with
James Matthew, weaver in Dundee, he de-
clines answering the question; all this he
declares to be truth. And after the before-
written declaration was read over to Mr.
Palmer, and being asked to sign his deciara*
tion, he declinps to do so. And the aforesaid
Mr. Thomas Fische Palmer, being again cal-
led in before the sheriff, and there having
been shown to him, the netition of William
Scot, procurator fiscal or the county, upon
which the warrant for his apprehension was
granted, of yesterday^s date, and he having
nerused tlie same, the sheriff asked him, if
he would now answer the questions formerly
putto hmiy Mr. Palmerdeclined to make any
answer to the questions^ and added that it
was not from any contempt of the court, and
Mr. Palmer also declines signing this addition
to his declaration.
Edinburghy Sd August, 1793.
The said Mr. Thomas Fische Palmer being
again examined, and his declarations of yes-
terdav*s date being read over to him, he was
askea by the sherifi^substitute, whether he
still adhered thereto, or would now answer
the questions that were there put to hitii;
Mr. ralmer answered, That it appears to him
inconsistent with justice, to desire a man to
answer questions which might criminate him-
self. That from his io^norance of the Scotch
law, he is ignorant of the tendency of the
questions, and how far he might be impli*
cated by his answers, which, and no con-
tempt of the authority of the sheriff, are his
reasons for declining answering. And he
declines to subscribe this declaration. This
he declares to be truth."
(Signed) Harry Davidson.
Witnesses present at the above declaration i
— ^William Scott, procurator fiscal, Joseplr
Mack, writer, and William Middleton, she-
riff-officer.
Copy of Writings contained on two separate
shps of paper, found in A. Morren's
house, and alluded to in the foregaiog
depositions.
Paper First.
Dear Sir;--I will thank your brother ta
Erint three hundred copies, on a half sheet,
ut not long- ways like the last; but in the
manner of a quarto, I think it may be con*
tsuned in one half- sheet Destroy the copy,
and do not let a soul know who wrote it«
You may give Skinring 50, and Mr. * * *
Paper Second.
« «• • • We would have • • • • ♦ ^thousand
printed, on one half sheet** * * paper in pica
print, that the * * * of it may he contained
m the paper. • • • Mr. Skirving calls, let
him have 3 or * * * what he wants, the re-
mainder sent to me by M'Farlane^ with
a bill of the expense.
On another part of this paper a signature^
'* F. Palmer," remains.
The scroll of a Letter from Alexander Moiren,
intended to' have been sent to T. F. Palmer.
Dear Sir ; — I received your favour of the
5th inst. am very happy to hear of the pro-
gress of the Friends of Liberty in Dundee; I
wish them success with all my heart. I hope
this address will do good; as I think it most
excellent. As you very prudently wish it
kept secret, that the authors of it may not
be traced, I have been thinkine you should
keep away the date fit>m it, or the words at
the head of it, of (Dundee Berean Meeting-
house; July> 1793), and have for that pur<^.
»9]
f^he^iaiu
A; D. Vm.
[S80
pose, and t» know whether the paper and print
ptese, tioubied you with these few hnes,
wbidi, if you please to answer in course, you
can have the number wanted this week by
Mr. M'Fulane. I have called on Mr.
Skirviag.
(Signed) Alex. Mokren.
Letter, signed T. F. P. to Jas. Ellis, Dundee.
In Edinburgh Jail,
Dear James; — ^I was imprisoned all last
night, because I would not answer any ques-
tions put to me, and am now in the sheriiPs
chamner, waiting a second attempt.
Lest I should miss of Mr. Bowker, I in-
close the note of Mr. Miles Bowker, his
brother ; last year he paid me on the streets of
Edinburgh, 1/. 15«. thinking that was all ;
I thoughty and said, he was wrong at the
time : the bUl now shows that he owes me
1/. 10$. ed. more. The bill will show too for
what purposes he received the money from
me, now I believe near two years ago.
My letter to Smiton, part of my letter to
iSbt printer's brother, ordering them, are in
evidence against me. Th^ think James
Mathew was the author. I have been per-
mitted to see no one yet. Was not allowed
bail last night, I suppose I shall this morn-
ing. Yours,
(Signed) T.F.P.
July 3, 1793.
Mr. Burnett, — ^The evidence on the part of
the prosecution is now closed^ both parole
and written.
EVIOBHCB ON 8EHAI.F OF TBE PaHEL.
WiUiam Siewart, sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Clerk.
»
Where do you live ?— In Dundee.
Do you know of any societies there ?•— Yes ;
I know of two there.
Is there « society there named the Friends
of the People?— The Friends of Liberty.
Are you a member? — ^Yes.
How long have you been a member?-—! do
not recollect rightly, but I have been for
sometime.
Do you know Mr. Palmer ?— I have seen
Was he a member of the society ? — ^Yes;
he was a member for some time.
Do you recollect when he was admitted ? —
No, I do not recollect what day of the month
it
Were you a member 'of the society or Mr«
Palmer first ? — I was first.
Do you remember any address that was
publisbedby this society?— Yes; I do. \
Do you luiow who drew up that address ?—
It was drawn up by the society.
Do you know who proposed it first ?— No,
I do not recollect who proix>sed it first.
Do you recollect bdng alone with one or
two of your companions of the same society.
and meeiEing inth Mr. Palmer in the Me-
thodist Close ?— Yes.
Who was with you? — Tvro lads, George
Mealmaker and David Wood.
What did you say to Mr. Palmer concern-
ing the obejcts of the society ? — ^I don*t recol-
lect what passed that night; but we gave him
an invitation to come to the meeting.
Was Mr. Palmer a member of the society
at that time?'<-No; he was not.
Did Mr. Palmer go with you? — ^No; we
had no meeting that night
Was there a meeting of the committee soon
after ?— Yes.
Were you present at that meeting ?— -Yes ;
I was.
Was there any draft of an address produced
that evening?— There was one laid upon the
table that evening.
Do you know who composed it?— I do not-
know rightly who composed it ; but. as far
as I know, I think it was George Mealmaker.
When you consulted Mr. Palmer upon that
subject, did he advise you to compose the
address, or not to compose it?— I do not
recollect if he advised us that night or not.
Was he for publishing an address or not?—
He was for publishing it in the newspapers,
only.
Was he for publishing it in the newspapers
at that time or ailerwards ?— It was after-
wards.
What do you mean by afterwards ? — ^At a
meeting afterwards.
What sort of a meeting was that whkh
took place afterwards ? — A weekly meeting.
Lord Abercromhy, A general meeting or a
committee meeting? — A general meeting,
held once a week.
Mr. Clerk. On the night that you met
with Mr. Palmer was there any body with
him ?-— There was another lad with him, but
I do not know who it was.
Did you see him to^ay ?— It being daik, I
did not take notice of him .
Did you propose to Mr. Palmer to write
this address ? — ^It was proposed before that
time that an address shoula be made out by
the society.
But did you urge Mr. Palmer to write the
address ? — No.
Did Mealmaker or Wood urge him to it?—
I cannot recollect that
George Luke sworn. — Examined by Mr. Clerk*
Where do you live ? — In Dundee.
Do you know of any societies in Dundee ?
—Yes.
Do you belong to any of them? — Yes; I
belong to the society in the Berean Meeting-
house.
Were you an officer in that society ?— Yes.
You were treasurer, were you ?— Yes.
Do you recollect an address to Friends and
Fellow-citizens being proposed in the society ?
— Yes.
Was it proposed to be printed ?-^Yes«
3Sl] 3S GBOnGB IlL Proceedings againd, fte Kev. T. FyAe Palmer [AK
. Wftfii daisied ia tk« 8«biety# WkeAetit
should be altered and amoidid/or Whether tfe
ahmiUbe pUflishtttf-^Yc^I IMme it wii.
t)o you recollect Mr> P^litier takiBg en/
part in that deb«le N^Yes.
Did Mn Palifter speak f-^Yeft^
Did he make any objection ?—- Yes, he
wanted it not to be printed in a hand-bill.
Ubffd Ahircwmkijf. Did he wish it to be
printed any other way ? — I do not recollect.
• Mr. CUrk4 — ^Do you reeolWct iny altera-
tions being made in theconrse of the debate }
-*•! do not know.
Were you there during the whole of the
^Bbat»f-^Yeft; but I Was not in office at that
tune ; I went out, I believe, before it was all
drtiated.
"Do you khow Oeorge Mealmaker ?— Yes.
Did he speak in the course of the debate ?
do not fitoperly recollect that.
Mr. Bttrnel^^ Gentlemen of the Jury;
Oentlemcn, in dischamng this part of my
duty, which requires ofme to slate to you the
ihirport of the evidence which has been laid
before you in this case, upon the part of the
prosecutor, 1 know, I shall meet with this
concurrence of sentiment in all of you, that
this is a cause of the utmost importance to
the country in general. When you conskier
the nature of the offence charged agstinst this
panel, and when you consider the party
mmself^ who now stands at the bar, and I
will add, the consequences which the verdwt
that yott ikvf pronounce in this case, may
hare inon the ninds of the people at huge^
yoii wiH readfly see the importance of &e
task before yott.
Gentlemen, tiie crime stated in this indkl-
iMot is pn^#ly that of sedilion, committed
bjr wriliag, and eompoaiiig, and et#cuUi€xig s
asditions and iMamnaloij peiper, caleuhled
to create a spirit of opposmon to the esta-*
UMed flovernofcest, tor raise a ferment iaf the
minds of the people, and txr bring along with
it rilthoso evils that popuhr fmy and iBMir-
rec(k>v occasion.
GenHemen, this ofience, wben att the evils
attending upon popular fury and insorrection
are eonsidefed, I aih confident alt of yon will
join with me in thinking to be one which
slamb foremost in the list of hnmanr crimes s
for your own experience may teach yotr^—
histoiy, and that of a very modem date, may
teach you, that when people are ©Ace roused,
especially npon politiear subjects, there is no
violence however great, there is no ontrage
however wild, they may not be led to commit.-
He, therefore, that is the Author and instal-
ment of sedition, in whaitever way it is ap-
plied, ought rightly and properly to be con-
sidend as the author, aM me committer of
all thosecrimesy that sedition naturadl^r begets;
and h^ that attempts to commit it is guilty
<if aa offence of ^t atrocious nature which
every civilized state in Eiu-ope, in the worid,
mustaad dees fsttadi with the utttotftseterity.
: Getdemen, it tHll bb iA the reteH^edoa of
^ of voi% that much about thie period last
Year, there were in almost evety comer of the
kinedora, thb tnost dangerous symptonu of a
seditious spirit, which manifested itself in a
variety of shapes. In the other part of the
united kingdom, it is well known that pro-
ductions were sent forth to taint the mmds
of the people^ filled with every argument thftt
falsehood, perfidy^ and treason could hatch, to
excite and stimulate the minds of the people
to outrage and violence. One of these pro-
ductions, with a purpose but too plain, was
levelled agiunst thd private chftraclers of thb
most respectable persons in the 8tatc,without
excepting the supreme magistrate himself,
loading them with abuse. And, in this
part of the kingdom the same spirit sliowed
Itself, not only by associations under pre-
tence of reform, that insidious catch-wora in
the mouths of those, who, when their pobUc
or private characters are considered^ have the
least title to use them, but by seditious and
tumultuous meetings, iiriuch levelled their
efforts against personal safety and endangered
even the life of one, whom this country does
and will long acknowledge as* its greatest bene-
iiictor. Those disturbance^ which certainly
did create a very serious alarm in the minds
of every peaceable and well disposed subject^
created adresid, that similar oisasters might
take place here, which have taken platie in
another kingdom, and that the system of
doveromefrt would be here foltowed, which
luetakefi place in that kingdom, and whicb
is certainly a most unexampled scene of
wretchedness and miseiy. 1 say the in-
surrectfons which created those alarofs were,
by the timely assistance of the body of the
sute, fortunately eot' under, at least so far,
that those who had been so industrious in
their jtatriotie pretences, were mii6hr less fn-
dostnoiis in mat seditious attempts; for
whatever colour they might me to tnerr pro*'
ceedings, they unquestionably had that scope
and tendency; and the betteif and more
respectable part of the commnnity concurred
to p^ down that spirit ; which was so strong,
so uneodvocal, and eflectual » dispisy of the
feneraf sense of the nation^ that it was' not to
e expected that any man, m whaltever situa-
tion he was placed, would be so wicked, and
so madly fodish, as to attempt afterwards to
excite that spun. The wisdom of the nation
saved the country then. The voice of the
people was heard'. AfVer so general a display
of the sense of the nation, it was not to be
snpposed that any man woidd be so mad as
agam to renew such attempts. If I am'not^
however, much mistaken, the evidence you
have heard this day does evince, that there
were seme pei^ns, and those not in a very
obscure situation in^ Mfo, who were afetoateiF
by that wickedness, and by that madness of
folly.
Gentlemen, what the partel at the bar for-
m^lywasyor What htocoBdnct may have
888]
_^^BIiB' mm^^H^^'WWf^wm
A. a ITOS*
[3M
liMD Mm^cfdem Iftbis wriUnganddioidaliM
the p«pcr iducliUtfaesu^«ctofUk« trial,]
do not nuh to ei^ter tq>oii firther thun I9 oIh
itsryey tbgX if ^ may judge from the asio^
ciation to which he belonged^ and whtch,
whalerer name it nay have borae^ and the
name itself is aa anumoiis name, the aaao-
ctatiaa of the Fnenda of Liberty, must im*
press you ^n^ no very fovmuable opinian of
his intentions. I say, if you Judga from the,
compaiur he kept, you wiB not auMoaey that
lus conduct, anteisedent to this pttbhcation,
vas any other than is clearly e!vin»d 1^ the
proof in this day^stir^ N^jr will it tum opi
to be a dfcumitanQeui his faTour that he. ia
W^nofe88ionac2flr^[yifUNi; but a clergyman
of that descris^n whose pijpKdpks am. as
hostik to tbe witgion of hia coun;tiy, a& to the
established gDveniment of it^ he does not
however Hand at yoiir bar for hia sd^igiciua
ptfiocipleBk
Gentlemen, when thai is /die nature of the
offence charged agamst this panel, whien ybia
take along with you al3o the e£Fect8 wmch
this same npiiit may have had upon theminda
of the people, aiid ^hen you taka >also > alonj^
with you thai that spiot, which onob mani-
fiesled itself in this oouatry.amon^ a certain
class of f e^Ie, thoujrii got under, is not alto-
gethenputODm, and. that the verdict which
vott may ifats day prooounoe^ whatever it may
be,wilinotpass unnoticed m an;f oomer of
tiie kingdom,! am sure you will give td tfaia
evidence that a(ttention which it so juatljir me->
nts, and will judge of it under this impms*
aion, that ^ou ace discharging a most neces-
sary and important duty-»to the public at
laige — ^to the conatitntion of this, countiy'-^to
that constitution under which you and your
Others have long lived happy and secure,
thatoonatitution, and that ttfarie of govara-'
ment, which has withstood many a tempos-
toousd^, and many a poHtioal convulsion,
and which it ought to be tho prayer of every
good subjedi thu it may kmg' continue, and
that you yourselves may long enjoy that go-
▼enunent, with the same security, and uie
same pvotection.
Gentlemen, the charge which is (^ootaiqj^
in this indictment may be said to be Ihseo-
fold; iint, thatof being the author and the
oon^oeer of the peper, stated in thb Indict-
ment to be seditious; and there is also chu^
eda^iainstthis panel, the printing, 01. caus-
ing it to be printed ; and thirdlv the circu-
1^. or. causine it to be circukted-^And,
m, in judging how far the eyid^nco
upon the part of tbe prosecutor^ esta-
blislies all a^d eacn of these diifeKtit^offeneesi
the first preliminary tlung which faUaiet you
to eoasidier ia, whemer or not the paper> which
is the cofptu Mecti in this case, which ia the
Vmy femsdatian of the trial, is or not of the
dasermtion ataied in this indictment^ You
Iviw lieaid it laid down, by the honourable
Judgas^ who stated their opinions upon the Fo-
levwcy of the indictmsnti that you ought^ to
MisUeiv not only the mere ftot of elroulatioc^
but whethfr or not the paper saidlaVe daeur
lated, is qr &at«f a seditWua te^4en(^--^that
ia your province, as much as it la to judge ii
the mere act of circuhting. Injbe^ tieforea
jury can judga of th* guilt or innoceooe of a
party, charged with an oSenoe of this kind,
they must take into their oooaid^tion the
nature of the fAper itself; and, if you are
aatisfied that this paper is not sections, there
is no occasion for you to inquire whether the
printing ia proved, oi the cumulating ia provu
ed; beoune if the paper ia huaocent, no act
Sf the panel with regard to it can be oonsi-
ered as cnaainaL You Gentlemen then am
to coosidor, whether this. sAper is on not of
that daaoiiptbn. In tha tbrmer past of tl^
tna^you had ooc2gNoh^.'hnr a ve^y Icmg
argument indee^L wi^h respect to this prela-
maoaiypoinl^ whether- thte paper ia oriaaDt
seditioua ; and there were some things thraw|i
out which were obviated by the counsel en
the same aide which I have the honour to
take^ which I must also take some notice o£
In thafintplaoe^ it has beennow^ as on aM
similar occauon8,«dvBaoed aa aik ^awummit^
and a vera pdpular argument it jb, ttM tho
liberty of .tne press may be aiimted by the
issue of such m trial, — a libesty • vhioh ia, the
birtha|}ht of every British subject, and with*
out ^hioh govenuneni could not exist* Qen«
tlemen^alWr what ^ouhaiveheardon thia head^
there- is littlo occasion ibs me to enlarge upon
it ;> very fenv tcorda wilt be sufficient to showr
you, thu the liberty of the press has no mom
connection with the question, that is the
subject of this trial, than your pevsondl
hbmea at thb moment have with it; Ibr^
^sntlemen, to say that the liberty of the
press is to be ttfiected by s trial .of tiiia
koEid, 1^ the piQoseoution of a person charg*
ed with pubhshing an inflammatory and se»
ditbus libel, is as absurdasto say, that the
UbeBt)( of the siUiject, or the British oonstilut
tian ia to be affkted by the trial of a hi^
wayman, or a robbea. The^ trial and convi04
tioa of these penons are absolutely neoessaiy
ibr.the pmsorvation of both the one and the
oUi^b; mraa in the one. case we may aMy
say there could be no penonali freedom what*
ever, if robbeiy.weretopassunpunished,.so.in
the ether case there would be no re(ti liben^.
Qitt» ptosS) if sedition is permitted to pase
unpunnih^* Therefore I am sure you wilt
be satined that the liberty of the presa can
have nio earthly connexion wilh the casebe»*
iSMreycii.; for ir you are satisfied thatthiaie
an inmnmatoiy paper^ the liberty of the
press, instead of bein^ injured bv a prosecu-
tion of 'this kind,ia confinned^mostreogthen^
ed by iW (
dmHeflseny lailh respect to what wasatsted
at so greatlengtlvby the counsel for the panel,
«^i 8^, whh respect to the diffsient quoti^
tions mat he maoe from several speedies that
viere^seidto have been delivered in theHousea
0^ Farliftmeftt^ and the various qootatkmtf
SS&]
Procecdingi agaimd tiie
from authors upon the conbtitution of this
oountry, and which were said to be as sedi-
tious as the paper now before you, I appre-
Iwnd the argument founded upon them is not
more applicable than the argument with res-
pect to tne liberty of the press. Yet admit-
ting that the extracts from those speeches are
genuine, admitting that the authorities from
which they were taken are genuine (by the
way you will remember, that many of them
were read from the Edinburgh Gazetteer and
the Morning Chronicle), if these could be held
by you as legal evidence that such speeches
were delivered^ yet that has no earthly
connexion with the question before you. For»
though there is such a thing as freedom of
speech, in parliament, which is a privilege be-
longing to every member, those speeches, if
made among the people, might have a very
tiifierent tend^ficy from what they have on the
persons to whom the members of the House
of Commons address themselves; such Ian-
suage in parliament is addressed to men who
Save Imowlcdee to weigh, and judgment to
resist the fuse impressions which such
speeches are calculated to make; but ad-
dressed to ^e lower classes of the people, the
ignorant and the illiterate, such language
becomes dangerous indeed. But, gentlemen,
it is certainly unneoessary for me to take up
* more of your time with respect to the preli*
shinaiy arguments, stated by the counsel for
tiie pfl^, which were fully and clearly an-
swered by the learned counsel, and by tfie
bonourable judges who spoke after him.
Gentlemen, you are to consider, whether
ihts paper is truly or falsely described, in the
libel, to be of a seditious and inflammatory
tendency; and I am sure, it is almost im|K)s-
aible for any person to peruse that paper with-
out being completely senuble. that the person
who was the author of it, and who circulated
it, did it for the most wicked and the most
seditious purposes. The whole paper, firom
beginning to end, breathes the languaee of
aemtion, and of opposition to the estabhshed
government; it is written in a style which
marks the school from whence it came ; it is
▼iolent, hyperbolical, and declamatonr; it
calls upon tne people to rise up and vindicate
their just rights ; it speaks of a just and neces-
sary war, as being undertaken <^ by a wicked
ministi^, to forge chains for a free people^
and to rivet those chains upon ourselves.^'—
GenUemen, when a paper of this kind is ad-
dressed to the lower classes of the people who
are ignorant of the nature and pnnciples of
Sovernment, I say, when a paper of this ten-
ency is addressed to such people, what efibct
must it have upon their mmds } Will it not
lead them to acts of violence, to do every
thing in their power to destroy the esti^lished
constitution ot this countiy } And must you
not be satisfied, that the person who composed
it, and sent it into the world, had s^itious
intentions? — GenUemen, it is not necessary
for me to read over the particular parts of
this seditious paper; almost evoy part of it
breathes the language of sedition. The first
two paragraphs say, ^ That portion of liberty
you once enjoyed," &c. [See the Indict-
ment.]
GeuUemen, what is this, but making the
common people of this coimtrv believe, that
they are not only oppressed, but absolutely
slaves ; and if they once have this belief, can
you believe that tliey will not endeavour to
exert themselves, as much as possible; to des-
troy that government under which they live
as oppressed slaves? and can you believe, that
a person sending such papers among them,
did not intend to excite them to acts of out-
rage? It is unnecessaiy for me to read any
more of the paper which is. the ground-work
of this trial, — I leave it entirely to your con-
sideration, gentlemen, whether this himd-bill
may not oniv be considered seditious in itself,
but written tor seditious purposes ; and I am
perfectly satisfied you will be unanimous, that
this paper does contain matter of a seditioua
tendency, and indeed, supposii^ the wovdb of
this paper had been very different to what
they ar^ supposing the intentions of the au-
thor and circulator had been difierent to what
they are, the manner in which it was circu-
lated and sent abroad, must satisfy you, that
theie was some such wicked intention on the
part of the person who sent it abroad. If this,
man had considered, that this paper con-
tained nothing of a seditious ana inflamma-
tory nature, can you believe he would have
circulated it in the way be did — agoing to twa
booksellers, and getting it printra in thedaa-
destine way in which he did get it printed f
if this was -not his intention, he certainly,
would have published it in a very different,
manner; but the proof of this man's intei^
tion does not rest upon the way in which he
circulated it. because the paper itself shows,
from the wnole tenor of it, that the person
who wrote it did mean to create a spirit
of disaffection to the established government.
Why then, gentlemen, it is for you to oonsi-
der, whetiier this man's being the author of
this paper, and whether his printing, or caus-
ing to print, and circulate this paper, is
or not established by the evidence; and,
gentlemen, the proof in thb case appears to
to me to be so v&ry dear, and so condusive^
that I should think it ver^r unneoessary to
take up much of vour time in recapitulating
the substance of tiiat evidence. I take it to
be most dearly e^Ablished in proof, that
this panel is the author of the paper contained
in the indictment ;-'-and the evidence upon
that head, to which I shall call your atten-
tion, b that of M^maker.
G^ntiemen, George Mealmaker depones,
that there were two societies in Dundee, one of
the Friends of the Constitution, the other of '
the Friends of liberty, of which last he is a
member. He tells you, that he remembers^
in July, an Address to the Friends of Liberty,
that Mr. Palmer^ being invited with some
3S7]
Jbt Sedaion.
others to the meeting, he read the address;
that there was sometime after a general ex-
traordinaiy meeting, to consider the busi-
ness of the society and the situation of the
«»untry; that it was proposed at the com-
mittee, that it should oe read at the general
meeting ; that he read the address, and that
alterations were proposed and agreed to ; that
it' was ordered to be printed ; and, so far as
he recollects, it was delivered eitlier to Mr.
Faiiher, or Mr. Ellis, or both of them :
but that part of his eyidence, establishes
in as clear a manner as can be, that this
panel was, in law, as well as in ^t, the pro-
per author of this paper; he says, that part of
the address only was produced at the com-
mittee, that at the general extraordinary
meeting, it was produced more ftiU; — and,
gentlemen, he goes on, and says, that the ad-
itions were in the hand-writing of Mr. Pal-
mer ; he says that the society unanimously
gave orders to Mr. Palmer or Ellis, to set it
printed; and, that they accepted the oTOr of
the society ; that it was printed, and the so-
ciety paid the ex|>ense of it ; he saw an order
given by the society for the payment of it ;
that he heard it had been printed in Edin-
burgh ; and ' tluit he hevd that leaves
were .lorn out of the book. So that you see
it is established, by the evidence of Meal-
maker, that although the. whole of it was
not written by Mr. Palmer, yet that it was
left in Mr. Palmer's hands, and afterwards
when produced in the general extraordinary
meeting, the several adcUtions and alterations
were in the hand -writing of Mr. Palmer.
" Gentlemen, I do beg leave to submit to
you, that this must, of itself, show that Mr.
Palmer is, in the eye of the law, and must be
held and considered in the eye of the law, as
the author of this paper. And I must beg
leave to observe, that it is by no means a pro-
bable story which Mealmaker has told, and
some others have concurred with him in say-
ing, that he was the author of what be called
the first part of it, if you look at the stvle of
writing, — look at his subscription, that is
clearly the style of a man of no education,
and the style of the paper is tliat of a man
baving had a liberal education ; and I cannot
but believe that Mr. Palmer is the author
of the first part of this paper ; but it is
not in evidence, how mucn of this paper
was the production, that was laid before the
committee at the first meeting. That Meal-
maker wrote part of it, and perhaps a great
part, I am uot disposed to deny, but the panel
taking it under his charge so long, and alter-
ing the composition wc know not how far,
must be held as the writer. It is true, we
bave heard that he laboured in the generd
meetii^ to soften the expressions of this pa-
per; but what does this amount . to ? only a
demonstration of the criminaUty of his inten-
tions. . These deluded ignorant people knew
not their danger ; the panel did, therefore,
ta ayoid the consequences which he knew
yoL xxiil.
A. D. 1793. [338
might follow (not that he in other respects
disapproved the strength of language), labour
to sonen the expressions. Now, this part of
Mealmaker's evidence is confirmed by the
evidence of Ellis, who depones, that Mr. Pal-
mer said, that, he did not think there was
any thing exceptionable in the paper ; that
he held it to be as true as the gospel, and, in
his opinion, innocent, but that he was afraid
people in power would take notice of it
Now, when you see that Mr. Palmer softened
the expressions, this is one of the strongest
circumstances, which must convince you of
what Mr. Palmer's intention was here. Mr.
Palmer was certainly the best informed per-
son in that meeting; he knew that if he was
to insert expressions palpably seditious, he
could easily oe brought to punishment; but
he softens the expressions, and shows, that
he did not intend to be brought into trouble
for this paper, but that it should come forth
in the shape in which you now have it.
Gentlemen, taking thereforethe whole of the
evidence which you have just now heard, lam
confident you will be of opinion, that the first
part of the indictment is proved, that Mr.
Palmer was the author of this seditious paper;
but whether he was or not, you surely can
entertain no doubt as to his being the person
who caosed it to be printed at Edinburgh ;
and, to this end, I would call your attention
to the evidence of Morrin; he says, he eot
one thousand copies from his brother, v^o
printed them ; that Mr. Palmer ordered them
to be printed ^ that he had a letter from Mr.
Palmer ordenne them to be printed; and
when you consider the import of that proof;
you will he clearly of opimon, from the com-
parison of the hand- writing, that all these
letters said to be written by Mr. Palmer are the
same hand-writing.
Gentlemen, I own I find myself so much
fatigued, and so unwell firom the heat that is
now in this room, that I am hardly able to
go throu§[h the whole of the evidence ; fortu-
nately this part of the evidence at least, needs
not my assistance. The last charge in the
indictment is, the circulation of this paper,
which is, as to the evidence, the most clear
and conclusive. You have the two booksel-
lers of Dundee; both of whom expressly t^U
you, that Mr. Palmer called at their shops,
and left them several copies of this paper,
that they afterwards burnt them ; ana their
evidence is confirmed by the evidence of Smi-
ton, who received &» letter from Mr. Palmer,
mentioning, that he had sent a number of
copies of this paper ; and, he says, that he
gave them to a Mr. Uarwood, a Mr. Fisher,
and some other persons; so that the charge
of circulating this seditious paper is cleany
established beyond a doubt by the proof be-
fore you.
Gentlemen, I will not take up any more of
your time, tor I feel fnysclf so very much ex-
hausted, that I am not able tq goon* I leave
the case with you, o^nfident that you wiU be
Z
93Sf] 3d GEORGB III. Proceedings againU (he jRetf. T. Fyihe Palmer [S40
•aiisfiecl in ^ouf mlnds^ thai each of tbe ar-
ticles in this indictment is substantiated by
proof; and whether you shall be of opinion
that Mr. Palmer wrote every line of this
paper or not, that the other parts of this in-
dictment are proven, namely, that he caused
the paper to be printed, and when printed,
did distribute, and diddrcukteit. With these
observations, I leave the cause in your hands,
gentlemen of the jury^ and have no manner of
ioubl^ you will brmg m such a verdict as will
exonerate youfselveSf aAd serve your country.
Mr. John C/erJb.*-*-<7entlenen of the Ju^ ;
It is now my duty to address you in behalt of
the panel. That you mean to try his cause
£urly and impartially I have no doubt; and
yet as a preliminary to my remarks, I must
lake the liberty (without ofience I hope) to
guard you against ^rtain prepossessions,
which often lead to the greatest ii^ustice in
cases like the present. Unhapnily the times
are so violently distuibed by {Knitical animo-
iities that the opposite parties, not contented
with disputing about their public principles,—^
a contention that may subsist without per-
sonal differences, — seem now to exhibit in
many instances a degree of mutual hatred and
•ancour, which couid hardly be exceeded, if
there was a civil war in the kingdom. The
friendship and cordiality, that very lately sub-
sisted amon^ us, has been so much affected
by these political squabbles, that friends and
lelations nave separated with mutual disgust.
The clamour of party spirit resounds in every
quarter. Nobody escapes the fury of the
tunes. If one is a whig, he is distrusted and
avoided by the tories v if he is a democrat or
a reformer, He is execrated. On the other
hand a tory is exposed to the hatred of the
opposite factions. The common charities of
life are lost in the whirlwind of political
phrenzy, ^hich now agitates the minds of
men. Happy they, who in the midst of such
a ferment, can look on calmW and dispassion-
ately, ana form candid and moderate judg-
ments, as to the conduct of Uieir fellow-
citizens.
Gentlemen^ though I am not personally
acquainted with any of ^ou, I am satisfied
that I now address a sensible, an enlightened,
a well informed jury. Whether you have
mixed m the pohticai disputes, to which I
have alluded. I do not know. Should you
disapprove ef schemes of refbrtn hi parlia-
ment, or innovation of any kind^ I hope your
disapprobation is not of. that violent sart,
^hich is now so comnum. But* whatever
your sentiments upon these subject may be, I
earnestly intreatyoutu remove fromyourminds
tbe prefiidices, which at present more or less
affect the nundsof most mea« If you think the
III ■■■«!
* By the assbtance of Mr. Clerk I have
been enabled to conect snimeffOtts errors
which had crept into the reports of tliis
speech in the printed tccounts of Palmer's
panel's opioitaa are unMUftd or daagefoua,
reflect^ that he may still be an kmocent and
a worthy man. If he has said or published
any thing that does not agree with your own
sentime]^ recc^leel that in this land of
Uberty men are freo to speak Uieir minds,
-and even to print their opinions and views of
public affairs, though they may be such as it
would be inexpedient, and even dangerous ti>
folk>w.
Gentlemen, Mr. Palmer has been iodielcd
for the publication of a writfa^ alleged to be
seditious. It certainly shows abunoance of
that party leeal, of which tiiere have been so
many examples. But tliough the language is
not to be eommended for its moderation, it ia
another question whether sudi terras are se«
ditious, and punishable as a state crime. The
language of party is intemperate, abusive, too
often sfanderoos, — ^without candour, chanty,
or decency,— disgusting to all k)vers of qniel
and moderation. Asperity is natiiraUy mci*
dent to controver^es of alLkinds^ and itia
eminent)^ so to the party disputes of ooff
country, in the course of whkh dispotnts^
availing themselves of our free constitution,
indulge without restraint in venting thdr
anger and indignation. The abominable
msuignity of our religious contentions during
the progress of the reformation, and after-*
wards, is not yet forgotten. Tbe virulence
of party rage in the reigns of tbe Stuarts
abated in the following reigns ; but we have
generally had enough of heats and dissenlions
ready, and as it were in a state of preparation
for breaking out in violent animosities.
Gentlemen, some of you may remember
the political disputes in tbe beginning of tbe
present reign. No colours were thought by
the disputants to be too black for representing
the character and conduct of politica) advMu
saries. Ax last a new topic of discontent w«s
introduced or rather revived, I mean the sab*
ject of reform in the government, into which
as it was alleged a number of eoiniptions lad
gradually made their way. A long and disas^
trous war with America had terminated dis*
graceful! v to Britain, leaving behind it an im«>
mense addition to the pubtic debt The mio*
fortunes of the American contest were ascribed
to disorders in the administration, and reform
was loudly called for as the proper remedy for
these abuses. On the ether hand the abuses
were denied, and the reform opposed. The
bitterness of these disputes is far from being
exceeded in the hana bill now called a sedi*
tious libel. In this wav the temperate laB>
ffua£e of reason and moderation was given dp
for the more animated efinsion of parQr teat*
The taste of the public, or of those who imie
interested in such discussions, again soug^
the excitements of violent and infiaimnaloiy
dedamatton. Any other wi^ of treating po»
litical amiments would have been held as m*
sufierabjy tame, tasteless, and insipid, and
vould have been utterly disregarded as luke«
warm and contemptible. \ may refer yen W
341]
fit SstUHon^
|b9 Mt«f» ef Jmmtf aft a ««11 lo^oim easifdc
ff jpoUliffJ wi^aoepty exceeding iaelegaace,
bill not iPiicii if lit all, ID acriiBOny, m^y of
tbe eoteiBpomy pubii«atio»8. Tiie petJUeos
to parliaiDeait ilMlf, not to speak of other do-
fwofflts, asd tbe powiBon publications rela*
tive So fefonuL fer a anniber of years past,
may be gsmeraily refened to, as evidence of
th$ beat and violence of the reformers aod
their adveraeiies.
GeoUemop, I need hardly nention that
those plans of reforni f OQc^mnj; which the
Iridic Blind Jmu been so ^nueh aj^itatod, were
tint suggested in consequence oi certain opi*
niensy as to the infiuence of the Crown, and
the eesploynent of that influence. It was
thought by persons of the highest conudecao
4ion in ^ state, and optnly asserted even in
mirUanMiat, ihi^ the kuAuenee of the Oom
md iaeiesied to a degree, and had been ueed
in « manner highly dangerous to the liberties
^ the people. The same assertions were
naade at public meetii^es, and eagerly listened
to by all those who wished for a paruameatary
mfima as a resedy for grievances. It was
observed that the Anerkan war, though it
was popular at first, became urtry aiucli the
reverse^ Aftd yiet the minister, through the
influenee of the Crown, found means to conr
fitnie thai nontest ei«en after it was universally
d^eslsd for its i^instice and impolicy^— *The
infiueaeeef the Crown enabled nim to keep
his Bujonties in parliameni, who totally dis-
regarded the voice of ihe people. It was ob*
aerved -that the representation of the peopie
io pariiatQeat was unc^uaii : that individuals,
s number of whom were:peera, had the nomi-
nation to seats in the liouse of Comau»is, by
which nominatioas the people were in no way
represented. That a very few persons could
by these neaainations command a msyority of
the House of Commons, and a majority of that
kind natesaaitly fell under the influence of
the Geewn, so that the constitutional right of
the peepto to a voice in the legislature by
their ftyifeentatlvee, was nearly lost, if not
entirely abolished. It was said that a state
of thiD^ so dangerous to the tiberties of the
peoole, urgently requinsd reform. Accord-
ingly ^aos for a more equal re|»resentation
were proposed in parliament, but they were
deleatad by parliamenaajry mmorilies. Still,
however, die propoaers of femrm continued
their exertions, and eadeaK^oared to influence
the public miad b^ pubhcations of different
aerts^ in hopes ef carrying through their
^wourite measure bv its popularity. I need
hardly obsenre, eenttemen, that these plans
of refoim in paiuament wese supported with
l^eat seal by his grace the duke ofRichmond,
and by Mr* Pitt, as mdi as by saany other men
^napertanee. Mr. Piti .oootiMied his sup-
port of padiamentary aeform, even aft^ he
was mmiaier, and vidded the influence of the
Crown with that asaiatanee of borough nomi-
iMtioB, wfaKhbehad ao strongly reprobated.
A. O. 1708. IStSi
Even Mr. Duodas' hioaself, did at last imoti
one ocQasion, make a speech for reform^ waen
he was secretary of state.
Gentlemea, at this period, though the fdan
of reform was keenly opposed as well as sup-
ported, and the contest of interests and opi-
nions jupoQ a subject so impertant necessarily
produced a good deal of that warmth that ^s
attendai^ upon party er political disputes, no-
body had.^ heard pf the ^rious charge of
seditkm bemg made, either on the oue side or
the pther^ The language employed by the
promotem of reform was pomted, zeak)us,
acrJMiomous, iflaputing eonuption in plain
terms» te the system ef which they demanded
a referm ;-— but it was the iangus^eef contro-
versy, noit the hmguage of sedition. It was
the lani^age ef freemen, who had a right tp
oomplam e« their grievances for the purpose
of havipg them redressed. It was the lan*
guage of discontent, and it had a tendency to
spread the discontent But stiil it was not
seditioui^ nor in any other respect illegal.
He who speaks or writes to raise discontent
or disturbance, or to bring the government
into hatred or contempt, is seditious ; and he
whose speeches or writings have that tendency
is seditiotts, unless in eittier case the speaker
(^ writer has a legal object in view. But
eon inmrimn faeii qui jure tuo utitur. Men
may mtve a right to complain, and to coro-
plsun loudly, though their complaints should
be discreditable to government If thejr
bond Jide seek neform, or any thing else re-
lating to their rights, whether public or
private, they do no wrong, though their exer*
tions in the defence of those ri^ts which they
still possess, or the recovery oi those of which
they have been unjustly deprived for a time,
should raise discontents or disturbances. In
every case of this Jdnd, the question of right
is ftrat to be disposed of. Gentlemen, 66 it
was thought for a long course of time, and in
ndation it> many examples of all sorts, in
which individuais or men in collective bodies
loudiy set forth the gross abuses that had
taken place in adminiatmtion and representa-
tion. I apprehend that (the proposers of re-
form were not mistaken in law, as to the
le^ility of their proceeding. I apprehend
that the law is now, as it was then. Mr. Pitt
and the duke of Richmond were guilty of no
sedition, and the same law that appiied to
their case does now protect Mr. Palmer.
Gentlemen, there is no change in the }a#,
but there toA been a very considerable change
in the views of die disapprovers of reform. I
do not merely allude to the opinion which is
now much stronger and more prevalent than
it was formerly against reform, but to the in-
crease of violence and hostility against the
reformers. Gentlemen, I have already cau-
* AAerwards lord viscount Melville. SeJb
in this Collection, po$tf bis trial before the
iiouse of Lords on an impeachment by the
1 iiouse of Coomion?, a. n. 1806.
393] 83 GEORGE HI- Prouedtngi agaifui tte Jtec.T. Ft^she Palmer [344
tkmed you against the prejudices which may
arise from such sentiments. Justice is due
to every man, even to a reformer. But I
roust notice the cause of the increased ran-
cour of our dissentions. It is closely con-
nected with the view that ought to he taken
of the present case hy all men of sense and
prpbity.
Gentlemen, before the French revolution,
tlie argument was all on the side of the re-
formers ; and so much was this the case, that
the most sensible men I know declared them-
selves to be convinced, that a moderate re-
form in the House of Commons would be of
the most essential service to the community,
by strengthening the constitution. But the
French revolution took place, — an event un-
paralleled in the history of human afiairs, —
and a mighty monarchy, anpBurently secure
and unassailable in its establishments, was
suddenly overturned by its own corruption.
At the nrst news of this great change, it was
supposed to be a sort of reform in France, in-
troducing a representation of the people, but
with a continuance of the nobility, ana all the
filory and splendour of the mon&rcny. Every
benevolent and liberal mind in this country
rejoiced, that the French had recovered their
liberties. But new events took place. Gen-
tlemen, the glory of ihe revolution was done
away, and anarchy and confusion succeeded.
But many people m this counti^, who had at
^rst applauded the revolution, still continued to
think — notwithstanding those unfortunate
circumstances — that the French revolution
would be of advantage to France itself, and
jkotbe rest of the world. Gentlemen, the
people who applauded the French revolution
did not suddenly chance these opinions, but
tfieir numbers lessened by degrees ; and on
the other hand the proceedings in France at
an early period of the revolution had been so
atrocious, that a violent party in this country
lirose, decided enemies to every sfiecies of re-
form. Thus a new flame was kindled here,
^nd the most furious debates took place in
parliament upon the (]|uestion of reform.
And, gentlemen^ those discontents, and the
virulence of parties was aggravated by the se-
paration and the quarrels of men who had for-
merly entertainea a warm friendship for each
o^er, and had cordially acted together in
public affairs.
Gentlemen, at-this unfortunate time, when
.parties were runninjg so bieh, popular writers
in this country applied the aoctrines circulated
for the most insidious purposes in France, to
the state of our afiairs, ana assuled the vulgar
mind with arguments too well suited to. the
vulgar in all ages, though wicked and highly
dangerous in their nature. They were^ an-
swered by writers on the other side, witW the
vinilence of invective ; ' and matters ran so
high, that men of opposite opinions could
scarcely speak to one another, or communi-
cate their sentiments on political subjects.
I reaUy believe that, if. you go backin the
history of this country to the most violent
times ever known, such animosities did not
exist— You have heard to day from my friend
Mr. Burnett, that the existence of govern-
ment itself has been threatened by the r«.
formers. On the other hand, you are no
strangers to the hand-bills and pamphlets,
that are circulated by the latter, treating the
doctrines advanced by Mr. Burnett, as the
doctrines of despotism and tyranny.---In short
the two parties have exhausted against each
other every topic of abuse.
Now, gentlemen, while matters were in
this situation, and parties ran so high as thc^
did, the king's proclamation was published^
stigmatizing certain publications in vindica-
tion of the French aoctrines, and the other
new doctrines which have been graited upon
them. Gentlemen, the proclamation men-
tioned no book in particular ; but it was well
known that it alluded to Paine*s book.~Such
was the liberty of the press, or the licence of
the press, that the book was universally cir-
culated throueh the kingdom, and reoom*
mended, nobody supposing it to be = a libel,
that is, an unlawful writing. Nobody sup«»
posed, though it contained aoctrines in them-
selves dangerous, that either the author, of
the printer, or the publisher of such a book,
had been guilty of any crime ; and so little
did the people suspect it to be of that nature,
thatdifferent societies advertised ineveryncws-
paper recommending the writings of Paine;
and they were at pains to have cheap editkms
printed and circulated amone the lowest of
the people. I believe no booK ever had such
a mpid circulation ; and yet even the lawyers
were not aware that this book was a libel, till
the opinion was at last announced to them,
upon authority, entitled to great respect in-
deed, thou^ not properly speaking ^ legal
and binding authonty.
In the mean time it was supposed that the
populaice were infected with dangerous opi-
nions, in consequence of the dittierent po-
pular works that had been distributed among
them. And this happened at the same time
that the French had been successful in driving
their enemies out of France, and even in
over-running a great part of the Low Coun-
tries. A sudden alarm was spread among
the higher classes, and many were afraid that
their property was in danger firom.the per-
nicious influence of the doctrines that had
been circulated among the people-^the footish
and extravagant doctnne or Paine concerning
the Rights of Man.— Now. gentlemen, I need
not state how much that alann must necessa-
rily have increased the violence of party pre-
judices ; nor need I stale to yoii that those
gentlemen, who still thought that a reform
m parliament was necessary to keep down the
increasing influence of the Crown, were un-
fairly confounded with those who entertained
the pernicious French doctrines; and it was
not veiy difficult to represent them fs men
of the same principles^ oecause every person
346]
fi/r Sedition*
who entertained the French principles, wan
aeocesarily a reformer; though it did not
follow that every person who was a reformer
approved of those daneerous doctrines.
. GenUemen, manv oetest the cause of re-
form ; many consider it as most dangerous to
the countiy ; many even consider Uiat it is
absolutely necessary to stifle every mention
of reform. But, gentlemen, that is a mere
opinion upon the expediency of reform ; for,
however pernicious the doctrines of Paine
may he, however pernicious doctrines may
be that are directly hostile to the constitution,
that faave a direct tendency to overturn the
government altogether, however illegal to
entertain a serious design of introducing such
a reform as, that monarchy should be abo-
lished, that the House of Lords should be
abc^ished, and democracy set up, however
illegal such a design may be, I have never
h«tfd from any tolerable authority, that the
cause of reform, a fkW, free, and equal repre-
sentation in parliament, even when prosecuted
bv the meanest of the people, is an illegal
object to pursue. Various gentlemen have
proposed their plans of reform ; the present
-chancellor of the exchequer, the prime mi-
nister of Great Britain, has several times
made motions in the House of Commons for
leform in pariiament : it is well known that
the duke of Richmond did the same thing.
It is well known that Mr. Flood, who died
lately, Ukewiae introduced a plan of reform :
and when these plans of reform, however per-
<oicious, were brought forward, it was never
thought illegal to pursue such an object. What
38 more — a reform in the county representa^
don of Scotland is at present m agitation;
and even the public prosecutor himself, the
lord advocate (and I am happy in the op|>or-
-tonity lo express that esteem for him, which
every body who knows him must feel), has
appeared as a delegate in Edinburgh in the
cause of that reform. Nar more—is it not
well known to every body, that a reform is at
this moment a subject before the House of
tonimons,— a reform in the royal boroughs
of Scotland^ — A respectable committee of the
House of Commons has been appointed, and
is to repcKTt, upon the subject of reform among
these boroughs, it is vain therefore to pre-
tend, that tne cause of reform, however per-
nicious or inexpedient it may be, is ill^Bal.
If the prisoner at the bar is a reformer, his
ideas may be exceedingly pernicious and dan-
^geroiM in their tendency ; but if they be legal
and constitutional in themselves, however
inexpedient they ma^ be, other men, who
difier with him in opinion, have no right to
impute to him.views or intentipns of a cnminal
nature.
It has been pretended that nobody should
interfere in such affiiirs, but men who from
their rank, their property^ talents, or other
circumstances, have acquired some impor-
tance in the counti]y, and that the vulgar^
or the )ower ranks m socjetyi have po tijtle
A. D. 179S. [316
to disctiss such subjects, or to associate them-
selves for the purpose of obtaining a parlia-
mentary reform. Gentlemen, I was glad to
observe, that no such idea was started by
the public prosecutor; and I am sure you
would not have listened to it The law of
this country knows no such distinction of
persons. No man is better entitled than ano-
ther to consider what is good or beneficial to
the state, or to petition parliament for a rt-
dress of grievances. The beggar in rags has
a right to give his opinion upon the most im*^
portant of our affairs ; and if a set of men
who had no other means of livelihood than
that of begging from door to door, were to^
form themselves into a society, for the pur-
pose of obtaining a parliamentary reform, or
for the redress of any other syievance, such
association would be as legal as if it were
composed of the higher classes.
A passage from a celebrated writer was
read to-day concerning the hberty of the
!>ress. It is also an authority as to the privi*
eee of the subject to canvass the measures
of government It shows that the subject'
is entitled to petition parliament, or any-
branch of the legislature, for a redress of,
grievances. Now, where is the law pointing'
out a distinction between man and man inr
this particular ? There is no prohibition; and
De Lolme, who is now established as a great
constitutional authority, who has not one
single sentence in his book- which may not be
re^rded as constitutional law, states to yoti,-
That there is a difference between our go-j
vemment and all others in this respect, that
the privilege and liberty of the tubfect is here'
in the same situation with the government in
other states, to this effect, unless the liberty"
of the subject be restrained by positive laws,
it is understood to be the law and the con-
stitution of this country, that his privilege,
as a british-bom subject is, to do whatever
he pleases; and it is incumbent upon the
Eerson, who pretends that it is not lawfiil for
im to do this or that, to produce some law
prohibiting him from doin^ it.* And, there-
fore, I must now, firom what I have said,
state to you, that, however inconvenient it
may be, in the circumstances of this country,
that small and insignificant societies should
be gathering in every village for the purpose
of reform, you are only to consider whether
they, in doing so, are guilty of a breach of
any known law. I sluul say no more upon
that subject. I consider it as a very clear
and indisputable point, that they are entitled,'
how mean soever they be, to pursue that
object.
Gentlemen, the panel did connect himself
with a very insignincant society in the town
of Dundee. The object of the society was, to
promote a parliamentary reform, by legal and
* Sec De Jjolme on the English Constitu-
tion. Book 2. c. zvii.. p. 446, 447. ed. of
S17] 33 GEORGE IIL Proceedings agawl iJu Rev. T. Fyshe Palmer [319
constitutiooal oustiu. GentlemeOy you know
Weill the dlft'erence between such ajplao^ wd
% project formed on Uie new and oanjieroua
doctnnes. But certainly there is no evidence
that the society with which my client con-
nected himself entertained any ideas hostile
to the constitujtaon. On the contrary, it is
pjBOved that they, 4m a former occasion, laid
a ilutiiisl petition before parliament, praying
i» the re^Mrm tbey wished for, a reform of
the aune nature that had been sought by so
many excellent men in this country.
And, Bentkmen, on the other hand, it
has not been proved, that the prisoner has
embiaced any of tlie new ana dangerous
doctrines; his only object was the same re-
ibrm in parUamenI;, which has been a}ipro¥ed
of by so many, and has been stigmatised by
none as illegal; and there is the best
negative evidence, that no idea hostile to
the constitution was entertained by any one
member of that sodety. Their debates, their
designs snd acts went no &rther than to the
same legal reform; and however inexpe-
dient you may think it, ygu must never
loraet tbat the objeet wsa not illegal.
Andy gentlemen, I must here take tiie
liberty to give you another caution^ Gentie-
veiiy you must judge of this cause, <' sectm-
dum allento et probata," that is, upon the
libelaadtneevidenoelaidbefofe the Court. I
know nothing of this cause* but what I have
bensaUe to learn from the prosecutor's allees^
tionl and the.evidence upon it I cannot go oe*
yona them in my endeavour to vindicate the
priatner ; nor are you, gentlemen, at liberi^r to
do jBo. You may be well acquainted with
itiA pert of the country; and you Miay know
or miptcl that some of the people, assocMled
with the prisoner, bad embraced the docdines
of Paine. If that bad been proved, it might
have aiected the prisoner, though very little
if be is not a convert to the same doctrines*
But, j^lemeo, nolhix^ of this is proved
dther against the prisoner or his fellows in
the society^ and yon must lay your prmU
hMtmUdge, or snapicion, if you have any,
entirely out pf consideration.
Gentlemen, having said so much as to the
lepi and constitutional object of the society,
ttie next consideration is, with regard to the
measures that were pursued for its attain-
ment. For thoi^h an end is lawful, it will
not justify unlawful means. But, ^ntlemen,
the means loere lawfijd, and in particular, the
band-bill for whieh the prisoner is indicted,
contains no etatement that is not warranted
by law. It contains some free remarks upon
the measures of government, but the subjects
of Great Britain nave a right to discuss all the
measures of gevenMnent--It is a printed
paper, but the liree subjects of this country
are entitled to discusB the measures of go-
vernment by means of the press : And, gjen-
tieroen, notwithstanding the just onuses
univermHy bestowed upon the British con-
stitution, It has hardly ever been doubted that
even this great and gloiioiH ettahUahment,
excellent as it may stf>pear in its contiivance^
would be totally inadequate for the purposes
of a free floverument, or for the maintenaocc
of civil liberty, or for the oomfort of society at
all, were it not fiir T«a uaaarY or the jpaass.
De Lolrae, in the passage read to von, says
so expressljT. The same'priociple is laid down
in the wriUngs of Hume, the great phUoso*
pher and historian, whose authority, which is
otherwise nf the greatest weight, is muds
greater on this pomt, from the general tenor
and tendency of his political doetrtnes. He
wae nu advocate for reformations ; en the
contruy, he was a Tory writer, who prefivred
the monarchical part of the constitution ; and
the whole of his arguments have a leaaug to
that side. He tells us expressly, after showing
the advantages of public freedom, provided li
is duly contPoUed and prevented Arero run^
ning mto disorders, that '^ These prinetpka
account for the great liberty of the jvess m
these kingdomi» beyond what is uduifled
in any other government. It is aj^heMM,
that arbitrary power would steal m •pon ^^
were we not earefiyd to prevent its nfearesi^
and were there not an easy method of ooiw
y«yiog thealarm from one end of the kin^
dem to the oUier.'^ Here the author pr»>
supposes that the peopie have n ngM» by
means of the liberty of the press, toprioa
againatany measure of government uf « dan.*-
serous teiuleacyi and convey their sentimeaia
mm 4«e end' of the kingdom in thoiothcr ;
and he dechu-es his opinion, thai the eaoeU
lent strueUive of eur govemssent in eefaer
respeds, with ail the provisions of law^
would be totadlv inadequate, without some
•meh enipe as tlus, to keep the people eoiw
tinually m a state of alaim about tfieir )a-
berties. <The epirit of the people must fr»-
' (j^enUy he Mused, in order to curb ihe amb»-
*tu>u of the court; and the dread of myosing
' this spirit must be employed to prevent that
* ambition.' These are stnkiag passages, and
one would think that, if Hume had antici-
pated such a trial as &is, and had intended
to give his opinion upon it, he could not
have used eipressions naore directly appUr
eaUe to tiie case.^^-^ The spirit of the people
must frc<iuently be roused, in order to curb
the ambition of the court; and the dread of
rousing this spirit mnst be employed to prevent
that ambition. Nothing is so e&ctual to this
purpose as the liberty S the press, by which
ail tme lesrnii^, wit, and genius of the natioo,
may be employed on the side of freedom,
and every one be animated to its defence.
As long, merefore, as the oepubllcan f>art of
our government can maintain itself against
the monarchical, it will naturally be careAd
to keep the press open, as of importance to
its own prGservalien.*''«-And here, gentlemen,
yen sliould he very careful to distinguish be^
•^mfm^tw^
* On the liberty of the Fvess^ Essays^ iroL
l^p. iS,9vt. ia09.
8«]
J^f SidUhft*
iweeo fniblic ceft9iire cirouiMed by neans of
tbe pros agakwi the meawirei of govern*
meiit, and privierte censure or scandal.
Privnte sfamdefy while it has a tendracy
to raise heats and anhnositics, and eten
penonal violence between nan and man,
IS not recommended by ntiiity of any sort,
tfid certainlr it is of no use as a means of
preserving the public liberty, and therefore ft
is ptunsbable as an injurr to the part^ who is
flfaoMlered. It is iUeeaf because it is inju^
rions. The Wanderer has no rig/u to defeme
fan ne^bour. But where men have a right
to ea]xress their sentiments, and only use
thai rig^t, they are not punishable, thoueh
others ma^ suiter by the use which they make
of their right. The most grievous censure
is that which is justly hiflicted, the censurer
havm a right td censure. You must there*
fore disttnguish between a censure of certain
public measures, and a defamatory libel
against the private character even of that
individaal) who is responsible as a public
mittister for the same public measures. A
libel against the minister, Mr. Pitt, as an
individual, in his private character, is action-
able; but a censure of the measures of Mr.
Pitt as a minister, is not actionable ; and the
reason is, that the free subjects of this coun-
try are entitled to discuss the measures of
government, witti praise or blame, according
to the opinions they have formed of those
measuresr; aad this right of discussion may
be used either by v^^ords, writing, or printing
— and especiaUy by the press, wcause with-
out the liberty of' the press, the liberty of
the subject could not possibly be maintained*
But if this be granted, and it seems indis-
putable, it necessarily follows that in dis-
cussions on public affairs, whether by words,
writing, or the press, false or disputable
statements may be made without criminality.
For if false or disputable statements upon the
measures of government were punishable by
government itself, or by the courts of law, it
B plain that the people would soon lose the
right to say what is true. Even falsehood is
not without its use in discussions on public
afibirs, as it gives an opportunity to set the
matter in its true light, and fix the public
o|»nion upon just grounds. But if contests
of this nature are to be adjusted by indict-
naents for sedition and sentences of trans-
portation, for opinions against the conduct of
men in power, nobody will venture a pubHc
statement against the most wicked and cor-
rupt ministers, or tbe most unwarrantable
measures, lest the jur^ on his trial shbuld
differ in opinion with him. It is evident that
unless men were allowed the finee course of dis-
cuaaionin publishing tiieir thoughts, whether
well or ill founded, upon public aifairs, the
liberty of the press would be a mere name,
and we should no longer have the smallest
benefit from it
And here I must object to the definition
which y«u have heard of the libeity of the
A. D. 1793. j[S50
press. You have been told that it consists
merely of freedom firom restraint in publish-
hig, that it is quite of the same nature with
tbe liberty of speech, which cannot indeed
be restrained in the first instance, because
every man has it in his power to say what he
pleases; but still ever^ man is answerable
for what he says— so it is said that we enjoy,
on the same terms, the Hberty of publishing
what we please, but we must be answerable
for what we print, and if it liappens that we
print a libel, or any criminal matter, we may
be punished for it, just in the same way as
we may be mmished for speaking. But this
idea of the liberty of the press^ is very im-
perfect. Such a privilege as tne prosecutor
describes would be of no use — while it would
operate as a snare to unwary persons, who
in printing their sentiments would sub-
ject themselves to the persecution of a cor-
rupt arbitrary government. The true liberty
of the press appears firom the enlightened
works of Hume and De Lohne. It is the
liberty of fair and free discussion without the
danger of persecution.
Gentlemen, it is hardly necessary to give
you instances of the liberty of the British
press being so exercised. Such instances are
to be found in- every newspaper ; and thou-
sands of publications upon the measures of
government published every year, afibrd
examples of the freedom of discussion allowed
by our laws upon all topics of public concern.
Gentlemen, you were told, that many libds
beine circulated, and passing unpunished,
afforded no argument, in a court of law,
why the panel as the author of a libel should
not be punished. But, gentlemen, do not
you see that this is altogether a begging
of the question ? The question is, whether
this which is called a libel is sadi or not ? In
other words, whether it is a seditious jmper.
Now it is cleariy not Kbellous or seditious if
the author had a right to dbcuss In such
wcnrds the measures of government. I have
argued in support of the right as being
founded in utility, or rather in the necessities
of the constitution as bylaw established-^snd
what stronger argument can be adduced as
to the sort of publication on public measures,
that falls withm the rUle as to the privilege
or liberty of the people than an argument
founded on the undeniable usage in such pub-
lications? The fact that thoosands of them have
passed without notice and unprosecuted, is a .
proof of the law and the constitution of the
country, that the people lAiouId have it in
their power, to sound the alarm from one
end or the kingdom to tbe other, upon every
occasion when they think it necessary. But,
gentlemen, if these publications are libels,
as has been hmted, what must you think
of the public justice of the countnr? The
public prosecutor has aOowed all tnese in*
famous libels to escape, daring a course of so
many years. Shall it be saia, that all these'
libels have been winked at; that the public
3i7] 33 GEORGE III. Proceedings againU ike JUv. T. Fyshe Palmer [S48
coDsUtutioaal oustos. Oendem^Oy you imow
well, the difference betweea such a jpl&ny «ik1
a project formed on the new and danf^eious
doctrineft. But certainly there is no evidence
that the society with which my client con-
nected himself entertained any ideas hostile
to the constitution* On the contrary^ it is
pjBOved that they, 4M a former occasion, laid
a duuful petition before parliament, praying
fof the reform tbey wished for, a reform of
the aune nature that had been sought by so
many excellent men in this country.
And, eentkmeD, on the other hand, it
has not been proved, that the prisoner has
embraced any of Uie new ana dangerous
doctrines; his only object was the same re-
ibrm in parliameni^ which has been a}ipn>ved
of by so many, and has been stigmatised by
none as ille^; and there is the best
negative evidence, that no idea hostile to
the constitution was entertained by any one
manb^ of that sodety. Their debates, their
designs and acts went BO ftifther than to the
same legal reform; and however inexpe-
dient you may think it, ygu must never
fivi^ that the object w9a not illegal.
Afld, gentlemen, I must here take tiie
liberty to give you another caution^ GiMHle*
vsp, you must judge of this cause, '< secim*
dum allento et pvobata," that is, upon the
libelaadtheevidenoe laid befofe the Court. I
know nothing of this cause, but what 1 have
beeaaUe to learn from the prosecutor's allees^
faiaai and the.evidence upon it. I cannot go oe*
ycmd them in my endeavour to vindicate the
priMner; nor are you, gentlemen, at liberty to
do jBo. You may be well acquainted with
this pajrt of the country; and you ^lay know
or Mciptfc^ that some of the people, associsAed
with the prisoner, bad embraced the doctrines
of Paine. If that k^d been proved, it might
liave affected the prisoner, though very little
if be is not a convert to the same doctrines.
But, ^sntlemeo. nothing of this is proved
either against ina prisoner or his fellows in
the society, and yov must lay your prim^
hmoviedge, or suspicion, if you have anyi
entiisely out of consideration.
Gisntlemen, having said so much as to tbo
lepi and constitutional object of the society,
Itie next consideration is, with rej^d to the
measures that were pursued for its attain^
ment For thoii^h «in end is lawful, it will
not justify ufilawAU means. But, ^ntlemen,
the means n)ere law^ and in particular, the
hand-bill for which the prisoner is mdicted,
contains no statement that is not waqunted
by law. It contains some firee remarks upon
the measures of government, but the subjects
of GroBA Britain have a right to discuss all the
measures of ge¥!emment.--It is a printed
paper, but the liree subjects of this country
are entitled to discuss tiie measures of go-
vernment by means of the press : And, ^n«
tiemen, notwithstanding the just praises
univemHy heatowed upon the British con-
stitution, It has hardly ever been doubted that
even this great and gloiioiH ettaMishmeni^
excellent as it may appear in its contrtvaoce^
woidd be totally inaoequate for the purposes
of a free floverument, or for the "rffyttnanfr
of dvil liberty, or for the comibrt of society at
all, were it not for t«ic LiaaarY of tap jpassa.
De Lolme, in the passage read to von, saya
soexpresdjT- The same'priociple isJaid dowa
in the writings of Hume, the great phiioso*
pher and historian, whose authority, which is
otherwise of the greatest weight, is much
greater on this jpomt, from the general tenor
and tendency ot his political doctrines. He
was nu advocate for reformations ; on the
contrary, he was a Tory writer, who preferred
the monarchical part of the constitution ^ mid
the whole of his aiguments have a leanmg to
that side. He teUs us expressly, aflter showm^
the advantages of public freedom, provided it
is duly contPoUed and prevented from runr
ning mto disorders, that ''These prindplca
account for the great liberty of the preae ia
these kingdom^ beyond what is udulfled
in any other goveromont It is aj^htttcM,
that arbitrary power would steal m apon us>
were we not ^ffeful to prevent its prMresi^
sAd were there not an easy method ot con-
veying the alarm from one end of the kin^*
dob to the oUier.'^ Here the author pr^
supposes that the people have « iigM» by
mesffs of the liherty of the press, topiiat
agalnatany measure of ^ovenunent of a dan.*-
geroiis teiuleacyi and convey their sentimeata
trom one end' of the kingdom to the mother;
and he dechu-es his opinion, thsi the exoeL-
leat strueUive of eur govemasoQt in eeher
rpapecis, with ail the provisions of law,
wouki be tota^v inadequate, without some
mkh eA|^ as Uus, to keep the people con-
tinually in a state of alaim about ibeir )a-
berties. <Tha spirit of the people must ire-
' (Wently he mused, in order to curb the ambft-
<2tf>n of the court; and the dread of nmsing
' this spirit nuist he employed to prevent that
^ ambition.' These are stnkiog passages, and
one would think that, if Hume had antici-
pated such a trial as tiiis, and had intended
to give his of»nk>n upon it, he coidd not
have used eapressions more directly 44>pli;-
eaUe to tiie case.-^^ The spirit of the people
must frc<iuently be roused, in order to oirb
the ambition of the court ; and the dread of
rousing this spiht must be employed to pvevent
that ambition. Nothing is so enectual to this
purpose as the liberty S the press, by which
ail the learning, wit, and genius of the nation,
mav be employed on the side of ii:«edom,
and every one be animated to its defence.
As long, merdore, as the oepublican f>art of
our government can maintain itself against
the monarchical, it will naturally be easeful
to keep the press open, as of importance to
its own prGservalieQ."'«->Aad here, gentlemen,
yeu should he very careful to distinguish be^
iWV^flF.WF'
e On the liberty of the Fvess^ Essays, vol-
l,p. 19,9vt. 1999.
340]
J^f SedUitm^
tiraen public oeftsure circiibied by ifteam of
the ^resA t^insi the measures of govern-
ment, and pdvate oensore or scandal*
Private slander^ while it has a tendcoty
to raise heats and anitnositics, and eten
peraanal Wolcftce between nan and man,
n not recocninended by utility of any sort^
and certainl? it is of no use as a means of
preserving the public liberty, and therefore ft
» pnadahable as an injurv to the party who is
midered. It is illegal because it is inju-
rioya. The akanderer has no righi to defktne
his neighbour. But where men have a right
to express their sentiments, and only use
that ri^t, they are not punishable, thoueh
others may suirer by the use which they make
of their right. The most grievous censure
18 that which is justly hiflicted, the censurer
hsnne a tight to censure. You must there*
fore dtstingaish between a censure of certain
public measures, and a defamatory libel
against the private character even of that
individaaJi, who is responsible as a public
minister for the same public measures. A
libel against the minister, Mr. Pitt, as an
individual, in his private character, is action-
able; but a censore of the measures of Mr.
Pitt as a minister, is not actionable ; and the
reason is, that the free subjects of this coun-
try are entttied to discuss the measures of
government, with praise or blame, according
to the opinions they have formed of those
meaRiresr; and this right of discussion may
be used either by v^ords, writing, or printing
•— 4ukI especially by the press, because with-
otit the liberty of" the press, the liberty of
Che subject could not possibly be maintamed.
Bat if this be granted, smd it seems indis-
putable, it necessarily follows that in dis-
cussions on public affairs, whether by words,
writing, or the press, false or disputable
statements may be made without crimhiality.
For if (klse or disputable statements upon the
measures of government were punishable by
government itself, or by the courts of law, it
n plain that the people would soon lose the
ri^t to say what is true. Even falsehood is
not without its use in discussions on public
affiiirs, as it gives an opportunity to set the
matter in its true light, and fix the public
opinion upon just grounds. But if contests
of this nature are to be adjusted by hidict-
nents for sedition and sentences of trans-
portation, for opinions against the conduct of
men in power, nobody will venture a public
s(tatement against the most wicked and cor-
rupt ministers, or the most unwarrantable
measures, lest the jtiry on his trial sh6uld
dtfier in opinion with him. It is evident that
ifflleas men were allowed the fiee course of dis-
cttssion in publishing their thooghta. whether
well or ill founded, upon public aflisurs, the
liberty of the press would be a mere name,
and we should no longer have the smallest
benefit from it
And here I must object to the definition
whieh y^u have heard of the liberty of the
A. D. 1793. j;S50
press. You have been told that it consists
noerely of freedom from restraint in publish-
ing, that it is quite of the same nature with
the liberty of speech, which cannot indeed
be restrained in the first instance, because
every man has it in his power to say what he
pleases; but still every man is answerable
for what he says— so it is said that we enjoy,
on the same terms, the fiberty of publishing
what we please, but we must be answerable
for what we print, and if it happens that we
print a libel, or any criminal matter, we may
be puni^ied for it, just in the same way as
we may be punished for speaking. But this
idea of the liberty of the press, is very im-
perfect. Such a privilege as tne prosecutor
describes would be of no use — while it would
operate as a snare to unwary persons, who
in printing their sentiments wotdd sub-
ject themseltes to the persecution of a cor-
rupt arbitrary government. The true liberty
of the press appears firom the enlightened
works of Hume and De Lohne. It is ti)e
liberty of fair and free discussion without the
danger of persecution.
Gentlemen, it is hardly necessary to give
yon instances of the liberty of the British
press being so exercised. Such instances are
to be found in- every newspaper ; and thou-
sands of publications upon the measures of
government published every year, afibrd
examples of the freedom of discussion allowed
by our laws upon all topics of public concern.
Uentlemen, you were told, that many libda
beine circulated, and passing unpunished,
afibrded no argument, in a court of law,
why the panel as the author of a libel should
not be punished. But, gentlemen, do not
you see that this is altogether a begging
of the question } The auestion is, whether
this which is called a libel is sadi at not f In
other words, iriMther it is a seditious paper.
Now it is cleariy not Kbellous or seditious if
the author had a right to discuss in such
wcnrds the measures of government. I have
argued in support of the risht as being
founded in utility, or rather in toe necessities
of the constitution as bylaw established-^and
what stronger arsument can be adduced as
to the sort of publication on public measures,
that falls withm the rule as to the privilege
or liberty of the people than an argument
founded on the undeniable usage in such pub-
lications ? The fact that thoosands of ^em have
passed without notice and unprosecuted, is a .
proof of the law and the constitution of the
eountry, that the people should have it in
their power, to sound the alarm from one
end or the kingdom to the other, upon eveiy
occasion when they think it necessary. But,
gentlemen, if these publications are libels,
as haa been hinted, what must you think
of the public justice of the counti^ ? The
public prosecutor has aOowed all these in-
famous libels to escape, durine a course of so
many years. Shall it be said, that all these
libels have been winked at; that the public
S51] S3 GEORGE HI. Proceedings agaifta the Bee. T. Tyshe Palmer [35S
prosecutor has neglected his du^, and.be*
traycd his country in not prosecuting thesjB
libels, in order to wreak the whole of his
vengeance at. last upon Mr. Palmer? — ^The
public prosecutor knows the liberty of- the
press better ; it was not til) party spirit had
risen so high, that the prosecution of such
writings was ever thought of.
Gentlemen, the liberty of the press is not
to be used as an insliument of sedition ; but
still it would be most mischievous to prevent
it from being used as a means of ascertaining,
correcting, nursing the public opinion, as a
salutary control over wicked or foolish
ministers.
Gentlemen, there is no danger in that
liberty of the press which I contend for.
It may be fully enjoyed with the most perfect
safety to the government. Our standing
army, which is kept up even in time of peace,
puts the government in complete safety
a^ust any supposable disorders, which can
arise from the liberty of the press. That great
establishment was itself long opposed as being
highly dangerous to public liberty ; but now
that it is absolutely fixed, an attempt is made
to take from the people their chief protection
against its evils — tne liberty of the press,
without which no government can be subject
to the control of public opinion.
Gentlemen, our ancestors made a long stand
against tlie appointment of a standing army,
but at last It was established ; ana it has
gradually increased in numbers. It is fully
siiiBcient, to curb any seditious spirit arising
in the populace. In 1780,* when the popu-
lace of London were actuated by a sort of
phrenzy, in which their object was the des-
truction of public and private property, did
we not see that a few regitnents brought up
to the capital, quickly restored order, peace,
and tranquillity ? Such a standins army com-
pletely secures the peace of the country
against any sedition that can arise among the
people, and this perhaps is the principal use of
a standing army. So it has been observed by
Dr. Adam Smith, that while there is a stand-
ing army, the liberty of the press may be
safely extended ; for should the abuse of that
liberty at any time produce tumult, the exe-
cutive government of the country may be
supported, and quietness secured by means
of a standing artny.
Now, gentlemen, if such is the true nature
of the liberty of the press as an essential part
of the British constitution, and absolutely
necessar^r for the preservation of the public
liberty ; if it is legal to print and publish free
statements upon the measures of government,
in order to lead the public opinion, and direct
It against administration, you will turn your
Attention to the language tliat has been em-
• See in this Collection Vol. SI, p. 485, the
r^oceedings agunst lord George Gordon,
on an indictment charging him with high
treason.
ployed in statements of that kind. Calm sod
moderate argumentation upon public afi'sifs
is free to every man ; but we are told that
violent, inflammatory, or seditious language is
punishable. All this may be very good, but
what does the prosecutor mean by it ? What
is seditious language ? Is it sedition to write
with animation or eloquence on a subject so
deeply interesting? Gentlemen, if a writer
on political subjects, accusing a minister of
corruption, or tolly, must assume tlie com-
posure of a mathematician in his demonstra-
tions, he may lay down his pen. His style
must correspond with his subject. If he is
not at liberty to use the language which is
appropriated by usage to that subject, he haa
not truly and substantially the liberty of dis-
cussion. We must therefore appeal to tiie
usage, which proves the style and manner
that is allowed in political controversy.
Now, gentlemen, I hold in my hand,- a
pamphlet against the present minister, ex-
pressed in such terms, that it must have been
the subject of prosecution, if it had been
punishable by law — and yet no prosecution
has followed on it. The hand bill now before
you is mild and moderate, when compared
with it This, gentlemen, is a publication in
the form of a letter to the right hon. William
Pitt, upon the subject of his conduct wztli
respect to a reform. It begins with accusing
him of apostacy from that cause; and, hav-*
ins stated in general the subject of the pam-
phlet, it goes on thus — " The annals of an
cientor modern apostacy contain notliingso
flagrant. It was reserved for our days to add
this variety to the various combinations of
fraud and insolence, which have in. former
ages duped and oppressed mankind; and it
was peculiarly reserved for a statesman,
whose character reconciles the most,- repug-
nant extremes of political depravity, the
pliancy of the most abject intrigue, with the
vauntmg of the most lofty hypocrisy : — It
was reserved for him, not alone silently to
abandon, not alone even publicly to abjure
the doctrines of his former life ; not alone to
oppose, with ardour, with vehemence, witli
virulence, those propositions from others, by
which he himself had earned unmerited po-
pularity, and climbed to unexampled power;
but by a refinement of insolent apostacy^ to
convert into a source of obloquy against
other men, a measure which had been the
basis of his own reputation and importance.
It was reserved for such a man to repeat
those very comqion- place objections to the
measure, and those very common-place-
slanders s^inst its movers which had been
ur^ed against himself, and which he him-
self haa justly despised, or victoriously re-
futed. It was reserved for him, unblusb^
ingly to renew all the clamour against no-
velty, and all those affectionate alarms for
the British constitution, which patriotic;
borough-mongers had so successfully em-
ployed against himself. Yesi, Sir, it waji^'
SMf}
Jbr
A. D. 1^95.
[354
Teaerred for tbe son of Cbatham thus to
stigmatize the < dving legacy' of his faUier,
and thus to brand his own * virgin effort/
" You will have already perceived, that it
is on your late conduct in the cause of parlia-
mentaiy reform, that I am about to animad-
vert Though I feel a dislike not unmixed
with contempt for politics purely personal,
and though I should be the last man to be-
tray and degrade the great cause of reform,
by mingling it with uie petty squabbles of
party, yet when I see the authority of an
rtate character opposed with impudent
rdity, to the cause from which he apos-
tatized, I think it at least fit that that ob-
stacle should be removed, and that the va-
pouring language of such a delinauent should
oe counteracted by the merited orand of his
crimes.
'' The cause of reform demands that the
nature of your present opposition to it,
should be understood by ttie people. The
interest of tbe people demands that they
^ould well understand the character of him
who may yet be likely, in some possible com-
bination of events, to offer himself to them
as the champion of reform, and perhaps ulti-
mately to prove the leader in more extensive
and dangerous measures. And it is g^ene-
raUy fit that no signal example of trmm-
phant apostacy should pass with impuni^.
*^ These are the public reasons, Sir, which
f^ad me to call public attention to your con-
duct; reasons which have infiuenced one
who has no respect for your principles, and
no exaggeratea opinion of your abilities,
which he has sometimes admired without
idolatiy, and oflen opposed without fear.
That I am in no abject or devoted sense a
partisan, I trust even my present sentiments
will prove. I am only, flierefore, your enemy
so far as I believe you to be the enemy of
my country ; aud I am not unwilline to adopt
for the creed of my personal politics, the
dying prayer of a great man, f Ut ita cuique
* eveniat ut quisque de Republica mereatur.'
** The three general grounds then on which
I shall proceed to examine your conduct are,
your apostacy— your present pretexts for op-
posing reform — and the probability of such a
niture conduct in you as may render it ex-
tremely important that the people should
Justly appreciate your character.
** Your entrance into public life was marked
by drcumstances more favourable than anv
Banish statesman has ever experiencedf.
W^ aJl the vigour of your own talents, with
all the reflected lustre of your father*s cha-
racter, jou appeared at a moment, when the
yng;raciou8 toil of opposition was almost past,
when little remained but to profit by the
^Gfect of other men's efforts, and to urge the
^1 of a tottering ministry, whose misconduct
had already been fatally proved by national
misfortune. The current of popularity had
already set strongly against the minister.
Tbe illusions of American conquest and Amc-
VOL. XXIII.
rican revenue were dispelled. The eyes of
the people were openecf to the folly of the
cabinet. You had only to declaim against
it. Tbe attention of the people was called
to those defects in their constitution, which
permitted such a cabinet so long to betray
the public interest, and to brave the public
opinion. You had only to put yourself at
the head of the people, to declare yourself the
leader of reform. In this character you had
recourse to the same means^ and you were
assailed by the same objections, with every
past and every future leader of reform. Des-
pairing that a corrupt body should spontane-
ously reform itself, you invited the interposi-
tion of the people. You knew that dispersed
effort must be unavailing. You therefore en-
couraged them to associate. You were not
deterred firom appealing to the people by such
miserable common places of reproach as thoib,
of advertising for grievances, diffusing dis-
contents, andprovoking sedition You well
knew, that m the vocabulary of corrupt
power inquiry is sedition, and tranquillity is
synonimous with blind and abject obedience.
You were not deterred from joining with the.
associations of the people by being told they
were to overawe parliament. Yuu knew the
value of a jargon that does not deserve to be
dignified by so high a name as sophistry.
You felt for it that contempt which every
man of sense always feels, and which every
man of sincerity will always express.
"As you were regardless of the clamour
against the necessary means for the acconv
piishment of your object — as you knew that
whoever would substantially serve the people
in such a cause, must appeal to the people,
and associate with the people ; so you must
have had a just and a supreme contempt for
the sophistry which was opposed to the mea-
sure of reforming the representation itself.
You were told (every reformer has been told,
and every reformer will be told) that of inno-
vations there is no end, that to adopt one is to
invite a succession ; and that though you
knew the limits of your own reforms, you
could not prescribe bounds to the views which
their success might awaken in the minds of
others. To so battered a generality it was
easy to oppose another common place. It.
was easy to urge that as no government could
be secure, if it were to be perpetually chang- .
ed ; so no abuse could be reformed,, if insti- .
tutions are to be inflexibly maintained. If
they calt the courage of a reformer temerity^
he IS equally entitled to represent their cau-
tion as cowardice. If they speak from con-
jecture of his future interest in confusion, he
may, from knowledge, speak of their actual
interest in corruption.
** They told you that extravagant specula-
tions were abroad ; that it was no moment to
houe for the accomplishment of a temperate
reform, when there were so many men of
mischievous and visionary principles, whom
your attempts would embolden^ and whoo^
. 9 A
355] 33 GEORGE III. Procadfingn againsi the Rev, T. Ft/$he Palmer [356'
your reforms would not content. You replied,
that the redress of real ^evauces was the
surest remedy ajgainst iroasmary alarms ; thai
the existence ofacknowleaged corruptions is
the only circumstance that renders incendi-
aries formidabte; and that to correct these
corruptions is to wrest from them their most
powerful weapon.
" By a conduct thus natural you pursued
your measure. Of that conduct indeed I
should not now have reminded you, had
it not been for the sake of contrasting it with
some recent transactions. It is almost un-
necessarv to add that you found it easy to prac-
tise on the generous credulity of the English
people, and that for the first time in the pre-
sent reign, the king's advisers thought fit to
choose tiicir minister from the knowledge of
his bein^ popular, actuated bv the dmible
policy ofaebauching a popular leader, and of
surrounding with the splendour of popularity,
the apostate agent of their will. But with
the other parts of vour public life I have no-
thing to do, nor will I trace minutely the pro-
gress of your pretended effnrts for pttrli«iBe»-
tary reform.
" The curtain was dtopped in t785. The
farce then closed. Other cares then began to
occupy your mind. To dupe the enthusiasts
of reform ceased to be of any farther moment,
and the (juestion itself slept, until it was re-
vived by Mr. Flood in 1790.
^ There was Kttle danger of the success of
his motion, maintained by himself with little
pertinacity, and seconded neither by any |mr-
liareentary connexion, nor by any decisive
popular oninion. To it therefore you thought
a languid opposition from you sufficient.
You reserved more aetive opposition for more
formidable dangers, and you abandoned the
motion of Mr. Tlood to the declamation of
Mr. Grenville, the logic of Mr. Windham^ and
the invective of Mr. Burke.
*^ That more formidable danger at length
arrived. A reform in the representation was
brought forward by a gentleman of the most
powerful abihties, of high consideration in the
country, and of a cha^^cter the most happily
untainted by any of those dubious transac-
tions of which political parties are rarelvable,
for any long period, to escape at least the im-
putation* Such a character was odious to
apostacy. Such an enemy was formidable to
corruption.
'* The debate on the notice of Mr. Grey
iytistrated the fears of corrupt men, and the
malignity of apostates. It was then tiiat
alarms which had slumbered so long over in-
cendiary writings were suddenly caned forth
by the dreadfm suggestion of a modenrte,
and therefore, of a practicable reform.
'* Nor js the reason of this difficult to disco-
ver. These incendiary publications might
render signal service to a corrupt government^
by making the cause of freedom odious, and
perhaps by provoking immatured and ill-con-
certea timmlts, the soppresaoik of which
might increase the strength, and justify the
violence of government. No such lui|^py
effects were to be hoped from the proportion
of Mr. Grey. Impracticable schemes are ne-
ver terrible, but that fotal proposition threa-
tened the overthrow of corruption itself.
Then your exertions were indeed demanded :
Then your pious zeal for the constitution was
called forth.
** Theoretical admirers of the constitution
had indeed supijosed its excellence to consist
in that trial by jury which you had nanowed
by excise ; ana its salvation to depend on that
liberty of the press which you had scared W
prosecution. Such misht have been the idh
ravings of Locke or Montesquieu. But yoa
well knew its practical excellence to depend
on very different things.
** Already, in your imannation^ that citadel
of the constitution Queemorough, that sanc-
tuary of freedom Midhurst, tottered to their
foundations. Ahreadv, even Cornwall itself^
the holy land of freecfom, was pierced by the
impious ^m of reform. Actuated by anrms,
so nonest and so wise, for such sacred but-
walks of the constitution, no wonder thstt
yov magnanimously sacrificed you)* own
character. No wonder that yon stopped
to rake together every clumsy sophism, and
every malignant slander that the most
firontless cormpUon had ever circulated, or the
most stupid credulity believed. Nor was it
I even wonderful, when we consider it in this
' view, that you should have pronounced an
elaborate, a solemn, a malignant invective,
against the principles which you yourself haa
professed, the precise measures which yoa
had promoted, and the very means which you
had chosen for their accompfishmenL There
is something in such a parade of apostacy,
which, in the minds of certain persons, may
ef&ce those vestige? of distrust and repng*
nance, that the recollection of a pc^ular coi^
duct m early lifo must have imprmtcd.
*' The disgraceful triumph of that nig^
will Indeed long be remembered by those who
were indignant spectators of it. A minister
reprobating associations and condemning any
mode of coilectine the opinion of the peopw
for the purpose of influencing the House c^
Commons. — He who con^menced his care€r
Sbeinsr an associator, and who avowedly
iced an his hopes of success in the authok*-
lity which general opinion was to have ovef
the House of Commons. He who continued a
minister in defiance of the House of Com^
mons, because he supposed himself to possess
the confidence of the f>eople. He who gave
the first example of legitimating and embody-
ing the opinion of the people against the voice
oftheir representatives. He was the minister
who adopted this language. It b not, Sir, aa
that night to the splendour of your words, nor
the music of your periods, that you owed the
plaudits of the borough-mongers of WiluAnre
or of Cornwall. They take no coj;iiizaaace of
any dexterities of fiopnistiy or felicities of de«
357}
Jbir Smimmi*
A. D. 1798.
[356
dam&tion; tli«poiBpous4K>tfaiiigDe8Sof Aber-
xorn, and the sordia barbarity of Rolle, are
more oa a levd with their understanding and
more in unison with their taste. They ap-
plauded you for virtues like their own, for im-
pudence in asserting falsehood, for audacity in
defending comspUon. Their assent was con-
.demnation — their applause was ifipnominy —
their disginceiiil ' hear hints* oucTit to liave
^called to yocr recollection the depth of in-
^^y into whi«h you had at length plunged."
Gentlemen, it gives me no pleasure to read
these violent expressions ; whatever opinions
may be entertained with respect to Mr. Pitt's
conduct in the cause of reform, he is certainly
a man ofeminence and talents. I shall say no-
thifjgjGuFther with recard to him, nor would I
liave Tead any thing from this jwmphlet, if I
bad not conceived it to be useful for the
defence of my dient; you will judge, when
reading this pamphlet which has never been
prosecuted, whetner it is more or less fit to
raise sedition than the hand bill. The truth
is that th^ will admit of no comparison in
thai respect, and I think you will make none
between them ; I am sure you will say that
if Uus band bill is a libel, that letter to the
right hoB. Wm. Pitt upon his conduct in re-
form^ is much more a hbel ; and yet it has
not been prosecuted as a libel; and, I may
venture to say, never will be prosecuted ; be-
cause it has already been circulated through
the countiy, certainly to the hurt of Mr. Pitt's
potitical reputation ; and yet Mr. Pitt and the
public prosecutoi^ haarc thought proper to
•take no notice of^tt.
GentJemeiiy I misht read a great many
more passages to &e same eflect; but J
liave spoken very long,* and am extremely
fatigued, and indeed any thing stronger than
the passages I have read can hardly be ima-
.gioed ; but before I close upon this point, I
must observe tliat the parliamentary debates,
vhen published in a newspaper, have no
orivilege, and the publishers are liable to the
Jaw agunst Ubel or sedition, in the same
yx^^^'M'y as if the reported speeches had never
been spoken in the Houses of Parliament.
The privil^^ of parliament does not protect
the members in printing and publishing
npeecbes, that are libellous or otherwise
illegai. What then must we think of those
i^qwrted speeches in the daily newspapers
contaiiiing every word in the hand bill over
and over reseated, but never called in ques-
tion by public prosecutors ?
Gentlemeo, you will remember the Arch-
biabop of York's case— be compared some
flpeecbes in parliament, which he disapproved
«^ to the harangues of a Marat or a Robes-
piem.* No language could be more violent
or inflammatory, than that which his grace
was pleased to use. The most abominable
. duuracters that ever appeared, wretches uni-
iposally execrated, he compared with the able
1^1 > ■■!
* gee the note, onXl^ p. 376.
and respectable managers who are conduct-
ing the trial of Mr. Hastings. This was no libel
when spoken by the archbishop. He had
the privilege of parliament, but tne printer of
the newspaper had no protection from the
known fact, that he only took down from the
archbishop's mouth, what his grace bad said
in the House of Peers, fiut what followed?
Why, eentlemen, the managers thinking
themselves insulted, and the House of Com-
mons insulted through them ; a motion was
made in that house, that the printer should
be prosecuted as for a libel. But it is re-
markable that the House refused to interfere
in the matter. Language nearly of the same
effect and tendency, was used in news-
papers every day. The practice had been
established, and it waa necessary for the
public safety; and tnerefore the House
would not give orders to prosecute the printer
of the archoishop's -speech^
Now, eentlemen, you have seen, that a
writing of the most inflammatory nature, and
containing the strongest expressions against
the minister personal^, has never been pro-
secuted as a ubel ^ you have seen, that the
strongest expressions used against the mana-
gers of Mr. Hastings' trial was not considered
as a libel ; vou must all know the violent ex-
pressions that are daily used. Gentlemen,
all this can only be accounted for by the fair
dbtinction between the public and the private
character of a politician. Mr. Pitt's private
character is as safe as any man's m the
nation; no person in the House of Com-
mons, no member of parliament can dare to
say any thing personally to Mr. Pitt in his
Envate capacity ; it is onlv as a minister that
e can be attacked : Mr. Pitt himself in
one of his letters alludes to it, by undertaking,
both M a minitter and as a many to Support
some measure, — I do not immediately recollect
what. In short, the distinction between the
roan and the minister is fully established.
What could have given rise to thb distinc-
tion? Nothing certainly but the acknowledged
doctrine that the subject of this country is
at liberty to censure tne measures of govero-
ment as he pleases ; while the minister in his
private character has the same protection that
IS due by law to other individuals.
Gentlemen, this society at Dundee was
assembled for a lawful purpose. They em-
ployed the press ; but the liberty of the press
IS unbounded, so far as men only canvass the
measures of government, and mean to go no
farther. The language as well as the matter
is leA to the Judgment, taste, and discretion
of the author, or publisher. But it has been
said, that the purpose of the hand bill was
wicked and seditious, and that the privilege of
the press does not extend to such publications.
Gentlemen, I will not contend that a wri-
ting, malicious — seditious in itself, and calcu-
lated to raise sedition among the people — can
be excused by the fact that no sedition was
raised. In general it is true in criminal cases
359] 33 GEORGE III. Proceedntgs agahui the Reo. T. Fyshe Palmer [960
that intention is not sufficient to criminate,
unless the crime be perpetrated. But in
cases of sedition I am disposed to admit that
tlie intention is carried into effect, and the
crime is committed by the act of publishing
the seditious writing. But, gentlemen, what
are the circumstances here? It is not
proved that the purposes of this society went
any farther than a moderate and a rational
reform. The hand-bili complained of the
very grievances which are always enumerated
by reformers; anjd it was not either intended
or calculated to raise sedition. It is true in-
deed that every publication against the mea-
sures of government must necessarilv raise
discontents in the minds of the people ; for
no such writing ever was published with
any other intention than to show the people
what their true interest was, and that it had
not been consulted by government. Dis-
content is unavoidable where public measures
are wrong, or thought to be so. But dis-
content is very different from sedition. The
]>eopIe may be perfectly quiet amidst the
greatest discontents. To render a writing
seditious, it must be intended or calculated to
urge %he people to actual violence, and how
can it be said that the hand bill is of that de-
^ription ? Where is the excitement to illegal
acts of any sort? What outrages had Uie
society, or any of its members committed ?
There was a petition to parliament; was
there any outrage in that ? It was stated by
all the witnesses, that the intendment of the
hand bill was, to rouse the minds of the peo*
pie, in order that they might again apply for
a moderate reform; and the words *' they
were not to be discouraeed by their defeat in
the House of Commons, were very naturally
explained ; Meaimaker, the author, told you
their true meaning, that though the House of
Commons had not granted them their desire,
they hoped, that by perseverance, it would
become a popular cause, and that the House
would thence be inducea to grant them their
wish.
Gentlemen, you will attend to the aver-
ments in the hand-bill, in which nothing
whatever is stated or even insinuated that has
not been stated by evei^ set of reformers,
those who are best known to have po wish
but for a moderate and a rational' reform,
and those who have been most exemplary
for the legality of their conduct. The differ-
ent grievances alluded to in the hand bill,
. and which have been so uniformly repeated,
prove that the panel and his friends had the
same common object with the most moderate
and conbtitutional reformers.
As to the concern which Mr. Palmer had
with the hand bill, I think I may be allowed j
to say, that he certainly was not the author
of it. Meaimaker composed and wrote it, ;
*and the fact is proved as well by his own
testimony, as by the other evidence. Mr.
Burnett endeavoured to raise a doubt upon
thisy but the public prosecutor cannot be al-
lowed to contradict his own witnesses. It is
proved in the first place, that Mr. Palmer
condemned the publication; that he wished
there should be none ; he was afiraid that it
might bring them into trouble, from the
public prosecutor; and when he was oveiw
ruled, he used his whole endeavours to pre*
vail upon his friends to soflen their expres-
sions, lest they should give offence. All the
witnesses mentioned the struggle he made at
the general meeting, after me paper had
gone through the committee, and it was
rather invidious to say, that in softening the
language, he meant merely to avoid a pro-
secution. Would it not have been mueh
fairer, to say that Mr. Palmer had better
motives in wishing to moderate the ^pcpres-
sioBs? Mn Palmer did think there was
nothing illegal in the publication of this
hand bul, while at the same time he was of
opinion, that it was an inexpedient thing,
and did not suit the purposes of this society;
and he wished to moderate the terms of the
hand bill, because he did not choose to in-
flame the minds of the people by warm or
intemperate language. «
Gentiemen, a topic of some delicacy re*
mains — I beg leave to state, though with
hesitation, tlut consideration may be due to
certain peculiarities in the character of Mr.
Palmer. I feel much pain in alluding to
them, but I must be excused. GenUemen,
Mr. Palmer is a person whose ideas upon
many subjects, and upon one in particular,
are so very singular tnat though he actually
had upon this occasion, gone to a greater
degree of extravagance than could have been
justified in another man, the peculiarity of
his mind would have been sufficient to account
for his conduct, without the imputation of a
criminal intention. As an example of the
extravagance of Mr. Palmer's notions upon
religion, I shall read, some passages firom a
pamphlet of which he is the acknowledged
author, vindicating his principles as a Umtfr-
rian. — No ! I cannot read these wild efiiisions—
I am afraid they would be considered as unfit
for a public reading. I shall only say that
no one upon reading the pamphlet (if indeed
it can be read) would think toe mind of the
author perfectly rational.*
* The state of Mr. Palmer's mind was afUr*
wards taken notice of in the House of Com-
mons ; and as the merits of his case were
brought under consideration, I insert the con*
versation which took place rospectinjg him.
Mr. Sheridan rose to present a petition from
the Rev. Thomas Fysche Palmer, an unfortu-
nate gentieman who some time since was fellow
of Queen's College, Cambridge, andwas at pre-
sent on board a transport for Botany Bay, in
conseauence of a sentence of transportation
passed upon him for sedition by the high court
of justiciary in Scoiland. The petition stated^
that the sentence was ** iileeal, uiyust, oppre»-
sivcy and unconstitutional;'' and prayea suQh
i86V] Jor SedHum^
This IS & malerkd ctrenmstance to be con*
'sidened in deciding upon the case. Mr.
Palmer nii«l»t be excused for some impru-
dence, or misconception in expressing himself
upon a political question, when it appears that
^relief as the House in its wisdom should see
fit to afford. As far. as he (Mr. S.) had been
able to examine the sentence^ his opinion,
with regard to the illejahty of it, was pre-
cisely smiilar to that of^the unfortunate suf-
ferer.
Mr. Fkt said, this was a petition against
'the seBlence of a court of iustice, solemnly
and deliberately pronounced ; it appeared to
h^ to be of a most extraordinary nature, and
one which he -should hol^ it his duty, in the
fint instance to oppose ; for there never had
been, as far as his recollection served, an in-
stance of an application to that House, to in-
terpose its authority between the judgment
and the execution of a sentence pronounced
by a competent court; the proper and regular
mode of application for mercy would be to the
down. It it could be shown that the judges
had acted either illegally or unjustly, the House
of Commons might interfere by an address to
remove them, or by an impeachment. But
in this case a man, tried, convicted and sen-
tenced by a competent tribunal, when the
sentence is about to be carried into execution,
applies to the House of Commons to travel
out of their province, and interfere with the
duties of the executive power : after sentence
was passed, all that could be given him was
mercy, which was vested solelv in the
crown by the constitution of England. He
considered the motion equally unprecedented
and improper.
Mr. Fox said, he hoped the right hon. gent
-would not persist in his objection. The right
bon. gent, nad observed, that no appeal lay to
that House to prevent the execution of a sen-
tence, though complained of as illegal, unjust,
and unconstitutional. It might be possible
that he (Mr. I- .) had totally mistaken the Bri-
tish constitution ; but if he had not, he would
maintain that it was a principle, universally
admitted that a petition mijght be presented to
the king in parliament, m other words, to
the le^slature, against the decision of any
court of justice, from which there was no ap-
peal by law to any court of judicature. In
pursuance of this principle it was, that, on the
opening of every session, the House appointed
a committee upon courts of justice, which was
always considered to be sitting and exercising
a perpetual and vigilant supenntendency over
all the inferior courts, that the people might
know that their representatives were ready to
receive complaints tor which redress could
be obtained m no other place. In the case set
forth in the petition, the House well knew
that there was no appeal to any judicial
court; they could not therefore refiMe to take
the petition into consideration without de-
serting their duty. And it was certainly high
A. D. 1798.
[36S
upon a subject of still greater iriiportance, he
fell into the most unmeasurable extravagance.
Gentlemen, after having detained vou so
long, I leave the Prisoner in your handEs.
Lord Abercromby. — Gentlemen of the jury;
time for the benefits of the English laws to
be extended to all parts of the United King*,
doms, when it had been determined that
there lay no appeal from the court of justici-
ary in Scotland to the House of Lords in Eng-
land. If they were also exempt from the ap-
pcllaot jurisdiction of the House of Commons,
what remedy was there for the utmost pos-
sible abuse of the principles of justice in tneir
proceedings? Supposing that, after sentence
was pronounced, tne House of Commons had
been applied to by petition, stating unanswer-
able allegations of fact, to interfere and reverse
it in the case of lord Russel or Algernon
Sydney, he fancied it would have startled
even the men in power of those times if they
had been answered as they were, << We ac-
knowledge that the judgments against then!
are illegu and unjust; but it would be un-
precedented in us to interfere while the sen-
tence is in process of execution. Let them be
beheaded, and then we will reverse the sen-
tence completely fulfilled." The chancellor
of the excheq^uer had said, that an applica-
tion to them in their legislative capacity was
irregular and improper ; in such a declaration
the right hon. gent, had been mistaken : 'in
the present case it was to be observed, that it
had been decided, that no appeal lay to any
superior court of law; consequently no alter-
native remained for a man compliuningof the
illegality of a sentence, but a petition for its
reversal to the legislature. A petition to his
majesty for mercv was of a nature totally difl
ferent ; it generally set out with admitting the
legality of a sentence, but prayed an abate-
ment on the ground of mercy. The only re-
source, as fiEtr as he could see in the present
instance, was the one that had been taken.
And whatever mieht be the opinion of the
right hon. gent, with respect to the particular
merits of the case, he trusted that he would
not attempt to give so deep a wound to the
constitution as refusing to hear it would cer-
tainly be.
Mr. Pitt said he believed there was not a
sin^e instance of such an application to that
House. He admitted that it was the duty of
parliament to inquire into and rectify the
abuses of the courts of justice. But in what
manner? not as a court of appeal, but as a
court possessins the power of inflicting cen-
sure and punidmient on those who^abused
their judicial authoriw. To receive such a
petition as that offered, would form a prece-
dent for making parliament a regukv court of
appeal, and confound the legislative and ju-
dicial functions, the distinct separation of which
had been justly held to be one of the greatest
advantages of tne British constitution. The pro-
peiy ana indeed the only regular mod« of pro-
S6SJ
Proceedings agabui
at thU late hour, and after the close and fa-
tiguinfi; attentioii you have paid to this trial,
I sbau detain you but a short time with a
few remarks upon the nature of this case,
which I confess is a very serious one mdeed.
ceedins, would be, by moving to impeach the
judgesby whom the sentence had iseen pro-
nounced. At the same time he did not at
present wish to deliver any decided opinion
upon the subject, not having formed one.
Im only anxiety was, that substantial justice
sfaMmld be done; and as this was a point of
veiy great importance, of which no previous
notice had been given, and as he wished to
examine more into the precedents on the sub-
ject, and not to hazard a rash opinion, he
trusted a motion he should propose would
meet with no opnomtion, viz. ** That the de-
bate be adjoumea till Thursday or Monday ;
but as Thundav had some business allotted to
it, and was rather too early, till Monday the
9a of March.'' This he expected would meet
n^ith general approbation, as no doubt gentle-
men on both sides would wish to consider more
delib««tely a point of such momentous im-
portance.
Mr. Foa woukl not oppose the question of
adioumment, because the point undoubtedly
called for mature consideration. He was not
prepared to state what precedents might be
Ibund, which would support an application to
that House for its interference for the suspen-
sion of execution of judgment after sentence
passed; but undoubtedly there were prece-
dents for reversal of judgment after execu-
tion ; and a man must be of a very curious
turn and composition of mind, who would
8up|K)rt the one and resist the other. He did
not imagine that his hon. friend would obiect
to the delay, as no doubt he would wish to
iuive before him all the knowledge which
could be collected on the subject.
. Mr. put said, that as the interval before
Thursday might be too short a time for ma-
turelv considering the question of the petition,
he should wish the deoate upon it to be ad-
journed till Monda]^ next.
. Mr. Sheridan said, aft^r the good effects
that had arisen, or rather were likely to
arise in the present instance from reconsider-
ation^ in consequence of what had been said
by hw right hon. friend (Mr. Fox), he could
have no manner of objection to the adjourn-
ment.
Mr. Francis wished to call the attention of
the House to a point, which, though of im^
poftance, had been overlooked by gentlemen
on both sides, viz. the actual situation of the
unfortunate petitioner. He hoped his ma-
jesty's ministers would not put in execution
the sentence till the petition had been dis-
cussed ; and by that means deprive the peti-
itioner of all possibility of benefit or advantage
.from the result of the discussion.
Vr. JIf. A. Tby^r said, thal^ after the great
doubts tbalhad \ma entertauied by persons
In this case, gentlemen, two separate ques^
tions occur for your consideration. — ^The first
is, whether the writing Ubelled on, be of a
seditious tendency, or i^ectly innocent? for,
if you think that it is altogether innocent,
competent to giye an opinion on the subject,
both with respect to tine relevancy of the ube],
and the legality of the sentence, tKe execu-
tion of that sentence ought to be suspended
till the House had come to some decision on
the various relative points in question. An-
tecedent to that, it would be indecent in
ministers to suffer a sinele step to be taken
towards the execution of the sentence. Mr.
Taylor said, that it was not a few whisjiers^
as had bfi«n insinuated, but the serioua
doubts of manv men of great repute in ihe
law, that had been held, of the legality irf*
this sentence, which ought to weigh in the
minds of the House. He could not therefore
a^ee to the acyoumment, without first r&-
ceiving some assurance, that the execution of
the sentence should be postponed,
Mr. Dundoi begged the House not to ad-
journ with an impression on thdr minds that
Sivemment intended the smallest dday in
e execution of the sentence. As far as con-
cerned him, the sentence had been earned
into execution some time, for the warrant for
the transportation of Mr. Palmer had passed
the council board, and he, with other con-
victs, was already received on board the
transports appointed to carry them to their
place of destination. If the execution of it
were to be delayed in consequence of such a
petition aa that offered to the House, applicar
tions of the same sort might be expectcSa from
every other person in a similar situation with
Mr. Palmer. The opinion of the hon. gent.
(Mr. Tavlor) upon the legality of their sen*
tenees, bad been given as a matter of autho-
rity; they were not, however, to be directed
by presumed authority, but hj reason ; and
tberaore he should consider it as no other
than the hon. gent's, own opinion, against
which, with great deference to him, he was
ready to oppose his own; for he had not yet
heard a single argument which had induced
him to alter an iota of those sentimenta
which he had declared in that House to
be the sentiments that be entertained on
the subject, when it had been first al-
luded to, and which he was ready Jp
support, whenever gentlemen should be m-
posed to bring forward the discussion; viz.
that the sentence was le^; and that the
court of justiciary, in passing that sentence,
had exercised a sound discretion. He con-
demned the conduct of gentlemen on the op-
posite side as unnecessarily tardy and pro-
crastinating, since they had negiecied the bu-
siness Xhey had undertaken Tor so long a
time, and now called upon htm to stop the
execution of the sentence. If they had been
so ea^, and in any expectation of obtaJMiig
the inteiiBEence of the House to have the
S65]
Jiyr Sedition.
A. D. 1793.
[366
then there is no occasion to inquire, who
was the author of it? who the publLsner of
it? or hy whom it was circulated? That
therefore is the first question for your con-
sideration — Gentlemen, in judging of the rele-
senteoce respited, they might have offered
the petition at any former time since the
meetmv of parliament.
Mr. 3f. A, Taylor said, that whete a peti*
tion for mercy was presented to the king, it
was always customar;^ to suspend the execu-
tion of the sentence till the petition had been
decided upon. Surely the same rule ought to
be observed where a petition was presented
to Parliament complaming of a sentence as
iUepd.
Mr. Adam said, it afforded him some satis-
faction, that the chancellor of the exchequer
bad not persisted in the hasty rejection of the
petition which he had first suggested. Let
that right hon. gent, recollect that this case
of Mr. Palmer was a case in which there was
no appeal to any court of law, and that par-
liament was the only place to which the pe-
titioner could look for redress. The petition
was of so n^uch importance, that, with all the
mconTenience to which he must expose him-
self, he would defer making the motion he
intended to have made that day until the
House had decided upon it He wished, how-
ever, to obtain that decision on Thursday the
S7th, because the transport in which Mr.
Palmer was embarked , waited only for a con-
voy. If the transport should sail before the
decision of the house upon the petition,
there would be no occasion to search for pre-
cedents ; for it would not then be an applica-
tion for the interposition of the House between
sentence and execution, but for the House to
nrene a sentence after execution.
Mr. W, Smith said a few words to the same
Mr. Fox felt himself particularly interested
the turn which the debate nad latterly
taken. He had not paid any visit to Mr.
Pshner, whom he had never seen ; but had
conversed upon his case with gentlemen who
had at different times had interviews with
him. Thoujgh he maintained the power and
the duty of^parliament to superintend and
control the juridical proceedings of other
courts, yet he thought it prudent to resort to
that control in cases of necessity only. As
his bon. and learned friend ^Mr. Adam) was
about to bring in a bill for allowing an appeal
ikam the court of justiciary to the House of
Lords^ in which the committee would be in-
struct^ to give it a retrospective operation
OQ all the sentences of the year 1793, it might
be best to wait for the chance of an appeal to
the regular supreme court of justice. Of the
subsequent delay he could say nothing. A
petition little niore than four weeks after the
sneeting ofparliament, was presented to the
House. Minister desired time to consider
of that petitions and it was at least Incum-
vancjr the cqurt had occasion to jftve their
opinion upon that question. The decided
opinion or the court was, that the writing
libelled on, b of a seditious tendency: but,-
gentlemen, neither our opinion, nor the opi-
bent upon them to suspend the execution of
the sentence, as long as they themselves re-
quired to consider of a petition complaining
of the illegality of the sentence. A secretary
of state, i fa petition had been dven him to
present to his majesty in behalf of a con*
demned criminal, and he had doubted of the
propriety of presenting it, certainly would not
nesitate in delaying the execution till his
doubts were satisnecC He had no reason to
expect at the time that his friend's motion
would be so readily disposed of, and he was
not sure that the advice he gave might not
have influenced in some decree the conduct
of Mr. Palmer and his friends in drawing up
the petition ; that as little time as possible
mignt be lost, he moved that the debate be
adjourned to Thursday the 87 th.
Mr. Adam declared, he spoke without the
least knowledge of the unfortunate persons
on board the transport. He spoke indepen-
dently of every consideration, except that of
his duty as a member of that House, and in
that view it did seem to him that this was
a question on which the House ought not
to nesitate a moment, either to agree to delay
the sailing of the vessel, or to take the sub*
ject into consideration as early as possible.
Mr. Whitbreadf sen. called the attention of
the House to the peculiar case of the peti-
tioner, which^ he said, was an object well wor«
thy their senous consideration : Mr. Palmer
was a man descended from one of the most an-
cient and honourable families of the county of
Bedford; and the unfortunate situation in
which he was placed^ had been the cause of in-
expressible erief to his numerous friends; even
supposing tne sentence pronounced upon him
legal andjust, a question upon which he felt
himself by no means competent to decide, he
was nevertheless an unfit object of prosecu-
tion and punishment, being considered, all
his life, a man somewhat deranged in his in-
tellects. He believed from his neart the pe-
titioner had no evil intention against the
fovernment of this country; and he was
rmly persuaded that any twelve genUemen
of Beafordshire, who knew him, and were
summoned onajury of lunacy, would bring
him in insane. He thought it his duty» as a
member of parliament^ and also in compli-
ance ivith the applications of the friends of
Mr. Palmer, to eive the House this informa-
tion, which fell within his own particular
knowledge.
Mr. J. Smith said, he should vote for the
earliest day, because, under all the circum-
stances, that appeared to him be the best.
But he could not help making this observa-
tion— If the principle maintained by the se-
cretary of state was carried to its full extent^
367] S8 GEORGE III. Proceedings against the Re^ T. FyAe Palmer [868
nion of any counsel, is biDdine upon you;
and I am happy to think, and happy to say,
that that is the case ; for it is not only your
right and your privilege, but it is your indis-
pensable duty to form your own unbiassed
Judgment upon that writing, and to say,
whether it be, or be not, a secUtious writing.
Gentlemen, you have been told at great
lengthy Uiat it is not a seditious writing ; be-
cause m this free country it is the right of
every man to canvas the public measures of
ministers, and the measures of government.
Gentlemen, I agree that such is the right of
every man in Uiis free country; and I am
happy to think that that is the case : but,
gentlemen, no man is entitled, under the
pretext of canvassing the measures of govern-
ment, to commit a crime; and the question
for vour consideration is, whether a crime has
or nas not been committed? In this case it
will be for you to consider, whether it can be
called a fiiir and a legal discussion of the mea-
sures of government to tell the people of this
country, that '' the portion of liberty which
they once enjoyed is fast settins, we fear, in
the darkness of despotism anatyranny." I
sav, sentlemen, it will be for you to consider,
wnemer tbat can be called a fair, and a legal
discussion of the measures of eovernroent.
in like manner, you will consider, how far
tellinj; the neople, ** that the^r will soon be
^ sunk in the depth of slavery, if you prevent
it not by your well-timed efforts," — whether
that can be considered as such a canvassing
of the measures of government as any subject
of this country is entitled to. In like maner,
you will consider, whether telling them '' Is
not every new day adding a new Jink to our
chains? Is not the executive branch dally
seizing new, unprecedented, and unwarrant-
the sentence of the court of justiciary must be
executed, even if it should be death ; and the
only remedy to be allowed to the person com-
? laming, was, an inquiry into the justice of
is sentence afler his execution. He wished
to know whether there was in nature any
thine more absurd than such a proposition.
Tne question was then put upon the
amendment, and the debate upon Mr. Palmer's
petition was adjourned to Thursday, when it
was brought up, read, and ordered to he on
the table.
, On a subsequent day Mr. Sheridan remark-
ed that, '' an honourable and worthy member,
had upon a former night, stated, with motives
which no doubt did honour to his feelings, an
insimiation respecting the sanity of Mr. Pal-
iDer. This unfortunate gentleman, now on
board the vessel which is to convey him to Bo-
tany Bay, had, in a letter which he held in his
hand, declared that not all the severities of
his unmerited fate, had touched him so sen-
sibly as this imputation; and he earnestly
desired that it might be understood, that in the
petition which he had offered to the House,
and to the foot of the throne, he had demand-
able powers? Has not the House of Ckmir
mons (your only security from the evils of
tyranny and aristocracy) joined the coalition
against you." It is for you to weigh, for you
to form your own judgment, whether these
expressions, and man^r similar ekpresstons
that you will find in this writing, and which
I will not detain you with running over, are
to be considered as such a fair discussion of
the measures of government, or of the con->
duct of public men, as any subject of this
country is entitled to ?
Gentlemen, you have been told, that reform
is a fair and proper object. It may be so:
but the question for you to consider is^ how
far such a writing as this can be considered
as tending to obtain such a reform, or as
tending, in the terms of the libel, to excite
a spirit of sedition in this country? — ** We
have done our duty, and are determined to
keep our posts, ever ready to assert our just
rights and privileges as men, the chief of
which we account the right of universal suf-
frage, in the choice of those who serve in the
Commons* House of Parliament."
Gentlemen, the right of universal sui&age
is a right which the subjects of this country
never enjoyed; and were they to enjoy it,
they would not long enjoy either liberty, or
a free constitution. You will therefore con-
sider, whether telling the people that they^
have a just right to what would unquestion-
ably be tantamount to a total subversion of
this constitution, is such a writing as any per-
son is entitled to compose, to prints and to
publish.
The learned counsel who spoke last, told
you that I was under a mistake in stating
that the freedom of the press, consisted only,
in being free from a hcenser. You were told^
ed justice, not implored mercy. The mistake
had probably arisen firom the circumstance
of there beine a brother of this gentleman, a
clergyman, who laboured under the misfortuncL
mistakenly, and no doubt kindly, attributed
to him." Mr. Sheridan was followed by Mr.
Whitbread, junior, who " alluding to what
had fallen on a former night from a gentleman
very near and veiy dear to him, respiting an
insinuation of IVlr. Palmer's insanity: de^
clared that he believed the idea was suggested
by the purest, the most humane motives^
but he bore equal testimony to the sanit}r of
Mr. Palmer; he had seen him, known him,
and had the honour of corresponding with
him ; he was a man of the most engaging
manners, and of the most enlightened mmaT
The greatest proof, if anv proof were ncces-'
sary, of his firmness ana fortitude, was, the
undaunted and philosophic mind, with which
he bore up against this unheard of oppre»»
sion. He was a man on whom < The gods
' themselves may look with envy.^ See in
the New Parhamentary History, Vol. SO, the
debate in the Uousc of Commons, March
10th, 1794.
S69]
fi/f SedUioii*
a; D. 179S.
[370
that that was altogether a mistake ; because
that, in this country, men are entitled to
canvass the measures of eovemment : but I
must again repeat, upon tne most constitu^
tional authorities, particularly judge Black-
stone, that there is nothing else in which it
consists or can consist ; because, though every
man is entitled to canvass the measures of
government, if he commits a crime, he must
be brought to punishment for it, and there-
lore every man must necessarily write, and
print, and publish at his own risk. And
Blackstone says, that the best and truest se-
curitjr of the liberty of the press, is the right
of bringing persons to trial by a jury of their
country for seditious, treasonable, or slan-
derous expressions. The liberty of the press
therefore, I must repeat, has, in my humble
apprehension, been most improperly intro-
duced into this cause ; because it has no con-
nexion with the question you are to try.
And, as I before stated, you have but two
questions to consider, whether this be a sedi-
tious writing or notF and if it be, whether
the panel has been guilty of writing, and
printme, and publishing tliat libel ?
Gentlemen, I shall leave this part of the
case to your own unbiassed judgment ; — ^you
idU consider the whole of the evidence ;^-
jou will judge of the whole scope and ten-
dency of it; and upon that ^rou will form
jour opinion, whether it is an innocent pub-
lication, or whether it was not a publication
tending to raise a spirit of discontent in this
country?
There were some circumstances mentioned as
tending to exculpate the panel, which I am sor-
ry to ^ struck me fl do not know how they
mav afiect your minus) rather as aggravations,
and rather tending to evince that this writ-
ing is of a seditious tendency. — It was men-
tioned, that it was published in the month of
July last, after the French revolution had
taken nlace; after the progress of that revo-
lution had agitated the public mind ; after
unheard-of cnmcs, unexampled in the history
of nations, had been committed, and all the
Iiormrs of that revolution had taken place ;
after the writings of Paine had been dissemi-
nated with the most unremitting assiduity ;
after they had poisoned the minds of the lower
order of people; and after an alarm had been
universally spread in this country :— That
was the season chosen for the publication of
this writing. You^ will consider; but as far as
I can judge, these circumstances rather in
my mind seem still farther to evince the evil
tendency of this paper.
Gentlemen, having stated these observa*
tions, I shall leave it with you to consult
jour own understandings, and to say, whe*
ther this writing can be considered innocent,
or a writing of a seditious tendency.
If you, eentlemen, shall find the seditioas
nature of this paper established, vour next
consideration is, whether the panel be suilty
of wriUng, printing, publishing, or circu&tiog
VOL. xxm.
that writing?— And, gentlemen, the libel
states, that the panel '^'has been guilty of
writing, or causing to," &c. [See the In*
dictment]. If therefore, upon cuAsidering
the evidence, you should be of opinion, either
that this writing was printed, or caused to be
printed by the panel, or that he was art and
part in publishing, or causing to be published ;
if you think he was guilty of doing it en-
' tirely, or that he was art and part in the
publication, in that case you will be justified
in a verdict finding him guilty, either in
whole or in as far as you find it proven. On
the other hand, if, upon considering the evi-
dence, you should be of opinion, that he nei*
ther wrote, printed, nor published, nor was
art nor part in so doing, in that case it is
equally clear that you will pronounce a ver<*
diet acquitting him of the charge.-— There-
fore, gentlemen, it is material to observe^
how fir the charge is brought home to him
by the evklenoe. I shall not, at this lata
fatour, and after the attention you have paid
to the evidence, run over it again. In gene-
ral. I shall state to you what appears to me
to be the substance and the import of it.
With rag&rd to the writing of this paper«
the cvidance amounts to this, that MeaU
maker drew the first draft or scroll of it|
which he produced at the meeting of this
society; that he gave it to the panel to
revise ; that the panel carried it with him ;
that it was again produced at another meet*
ing afterwards; ana that additions were madtt
to it, which the witness swears he believes
were made bv Mr. Palmer. In this he is
corroborated bv various other witnesses, and
above all, by James Ellis, the fi-iend and the
visitor of Mr. Palmer, who swore pointedly
to the manner in which the writins was re-
vised by Mr. Pakner, corrected by liim, and
additions made to it. It was stated, in alle*
viatiun, that he took puns at tliese meetings
to soften the expressions. Elffs gives a ^17
particubr account of that, which well merits
your attention: he says, Mr. Palmer pre^
posed to soflen the expressions, although he
told the meeting that, in his opinion, they
were as true as tne gospel, and in his mind
innocent, but that they might be taken hold
of by peoole in power, and for that reason
he desired that the expressions should be
softened. Gentlemen, various other witnesses
mention the same thing.
As to the question concerning the printing
you have it in evidence, that the panel pro-
posed, at the general meeting, for ttie sake o^
saving expense, that it shouldbe printed in the
newspapers : nay, that Mr. Palmer actually re->
ceiveo firomthe secretary to the society the
Eayment of the expense of printing. You
ave also the letter to Morrin. You have Mor*
rin swearing to their being printed, and about
90a of them trtmsmittea to Mr. Palmer.
You will be to consider, whether that does
not amount to a complete proof as to the
printing.
% B
371] 33 6EOROJB lU. Proceedings againsi the Rev. T. Tydte Palmer [ST*
The only mnaauiig quMlion is ibe miblish*
iog ; and upon that you have the evidence of
Uie bookaeilers. Their names are Leslie aod
lliUcry who swear, that Mr. Palmer gave
each of them a parcel of papers, which they
distributed. This is confirmed by Smiton,
who received a letter -Irom him, and a parcel
of papers. I have heard no objection to the
vahdity of these witnesses. You will consider
how & they are to be believed.
. Gentlemen, with these observations I leave
thiS'Case with you. There is only one farther
eircuipsiance that I shall mention. Much
hss been said of the puritv of the intentions of
the society: it is said, they had nothing in
view but moderate reform- But^ gentlemen,
you will consider, bow iar that is consistent
either with the tenor of the address itself, or
with what is sworn to by Meaknaker, who
^w the first draft of it, and who swears ex-
pressly that at that time, he had no second
petition in his contemplation, and that what
was afterwards to be done would have de-
pended upon circumstances. And I confess
I much fear that Mealmsker is here telling
the truth, and that if thev had not been
attended to, the conduct of this f«ciety would
not have proved so pure as their intentions
pre said to have been.
Gentlemen, I shall detain you no loneer.
J leave this case with you, not doubting but
you will return a verdict, upon that fiur opmion
which you will form in your unbiassed judg-
stent, such as wiU exonerate yourselves, and
prove serviceable to your country.
Yofi will return your verdict m this place,
at two o'docli to-morrow.
Friday, September 13, 1703.
Attwo o'clock, the Jury returned the following
VERDICT.
It Perth, the Uth day of September, 1793*
The assize .before-mentioned having in-
closed, thev made choice of James Calder-
wood Durnam to be their chancellor, and
Andrew Wbvte to be their clerk ; and haidng
eonsidered tne criminal libel, raised and nup-
sued at the instance of his- magesty's advo-
cate, for his Miyesty^s interest, against
Thomas Fyshe Palmer, clergyman, some
lime residing in Dundee, and commonly de-
signed Unitarian Minister, present nrisoner
in the Tolboothof Perth, panel; and having
heard the interlocutor of relevancy pro-
nounced thereon by the Court, evMence ad-
duced in proof of the hbel, and evidence
adduced in exculpation of the panel; they
all, in one voice, find the Address mentioned
in the libel to be a seditious writing, tending
to inflame the minds of the people; find, that
the pand wt^art and part gudty in writing
the said Address, aqd that he is gui^ <?
causing the said Addresalo be printSsd, and
that be is guilty of distributing, somI causing
to be distnbuted, the said seditious and i»*
flammatory writing. I9 witness whereof,
their said chancellor and derk have subscrib-
ed these presents, in their names, and by
their appomtment, place and date as above.
(Si^ed) Ja. C. Durham, Chencelhrn
Andrew Whytk, Clerk,
Lord Eskgrave. — Gentlemen of the jury;—
You have executed your important trust with
the greatest attention : you have returned a
clear and accurate verdict, which I am per-
suaded will prove a lasting blessing to your
country; ana you are now discharged from
your attendance.
It only remains, at the conclusion of thi»
trial, to do our duty, in respect of the pu*
nisbment to be inflicted upon this gentleman
at the bar, who stands convicted by hia
country. Your lordship will have the good-
ness to give your opinion of what punishment
ought to be inflicted.
Lord Abercromby, — My Lord ; — After a fair
and an impartial inquiry, in which every
possible indulgence was shown to the panel
at the bar, he stands convicted, by the una^
nimous voice of a jury of his countiy, of a
crime the most heinous, and of a most Am-
gerous nature. It now becomes the province'
of the Court to say what punishment shall
follow upon this conviction. And it is with
peculiar reluctance that I am constrained to
observe, that, deep and heinous as the crime
is, in the present mstance it is acoompahied
with circumstances of peculiar aggravation.
My lord, in the first place, I consider the
time when this crime was committed as an
aggravation of the offisnce; your lordshii>
knows, and every person now present knows
with what industry, with what uncomn^oii
assiduity, a spirit of discontent, of groundlesa
discontent, and of sedition, was attempted to
be excited in this country not many months
ago. My lord, by the virtuous exertions in
every corner of the country, of men of every
rank and every description, all uniting in one
voice of loyalty and attachment to the coontiy
and the constitution, that spirit of discontent
which some months before had so violently
raged, was, in a great measure, subdued.
My lord, in we month of July last, thia
Gountry was enjoying peace and tranquil-
lity— 9M alarm had ceased; and it is im-
possible for me not to feel, and feeling it, not
to- express, that the object of the panel in
composing, in printing, in publishing fbia
hana bill, as it is called, was to excite that
spirit which had awakened so well-grounded,
an alarm in this country, to raise and foment
sedition.
Mt lord, there is another circumstance
whieh I c<msider as an aggravation of the
crime; and that is the situation in life, and
the character of the panel. My lord, he is a
der^man, whose peculiar duty and whose
pvevinoe it i^ to mstruct citizens in their
duty to Ood aod to man. atfid not beeotoe anr
eaciter to crio^ of the Hiost dMDgereul^
9rs}
Jbr
<>•
A.D. 179S.
fJ574
ttftture,—- My lord, il afibrds mttier of much
meluicholy reflection to see a man of liberal
eAicationy a man of his 8tatioD--of his ap-
peannce^of his knowledge— ^f his talents,
assodatine himself with, makine himself a
ttiember of such societies as that of the Friends
of Ijherty, as they call themselves, in the
town^ Dundee,— ^f a chib of such men, as
we saw yesterday were the president and
aecrelary, — ^to see Mr. Palmer a member of
that society, telling them, in express terms,
thateveiy word in that address was as true
as the eospel ; — ^nay, telling them so, when
that acmess contained expressions which, he
himself was at pains to prove, were stronger
than even those infamous expressions which
fit now contains. My lord, is it to be wonder-
ed lAi9t the minds of the lower order of men,
«ucfa as we saw yesterday, should be poisoned,
when we see persons of Mr. Palmer's situa-
tion, and possessed of his talents, descending
to such arts? — ^When we see such a man
taking from these weavers the fruit of their
iionest industry, which ought to have been
applied in supporting themselves and families,
.lor tiie purpose of defraying the expense of
printing such a paper, — a paper,)whi€h a jury
of this country nave properly denominated a
seditious writing, tending to inflame ' the
minds of their fellow citizens, to excite them
to tumult, his crime is much aggravated. —
And here observe, that, unfortunate as Mr.
Palmer is, he is, in one circumstance, a
Ibttunate man; that this writing, and the art
wfth which iv^^ns inculcated, have not led
theae deluded men to go on any farther ; for, if
this address of his, calculatecf to rouse them
from their lethar^, had produced the slightest
insurrection, had it produced the sUghtest tu-
mult, tending to attain the obiects of this
address, then, he and they would have been
involved in the guilt of hieh treason ; and then
Mr. Palmer would have neen to answer for
the blood of these men deluded by him.
My lord, were I not unwilling to load the
unhappy man at the bar, with all the aggra^
vations that mieht be mentioned, I might
add, that even the nature of the defence set
u^ by him yesterday is an aegmvation of the
crime charged against him ; mr your lordship
knows^ that that defence principally rested
upon a bold and a confident vindication,
which he set up in the face of his oountryy of
that very writing, and of those very measures
which he had pursued. My lord, we were
told that, by the law of this country, every
subject and every citizen was entitled, under
the pretence of canvassing the measures of
government and the conduct of ministers, to
publish, to circulate, and to paste upon the
walls of every toWn in the country, seditious
writings, nay treason itself; for if [Hibiic
sneasures only are canvassed, there is no
crime.>--My lord, if this were to be the case,
no crime could be committed, and no punish-
xnvnt inflicted.
My lord, i am imwfl]ing to detun your
lordship longer, or bad the unhappy man at
the bar. — ^I shall therefore conclude with
'humbly soliciting the mildest punishment
which; under all the chrumstances of this
case, it appears can with propriety be in-
flicted^And, my lord, that is, that the
panel at the bar, Thomas F^she Palmer,
shall be transported for the term of seven
years, to be computed from this day, in the
terns and under the regulations contained in
the late act of parliament.
IxMrd E»kfra9€ perfectly coincided with tha
sentiments just expressed. I lament particu*
larly, that it should have been thought neces-
sary, for the panel's defence, to have ad«
vanced doctrines which were heard with asto-
nishment, and which I consider with detes-
tation ; I mean that doctrine to which your
lordship' last alluded. We live in a country,
where we are told that every man is at liber-
ty, under the pretence of censuring the mis-
management of ministers, to paste up and
circulate that which tenas to inflame the
people, and to excite them to insurrection
and rebellioiK and to do it by expressions of
the grossest falsehood ; that it is lawful to stir
up sedition even by falsehood. To assert our
constitution to be worse than it is, although
the consequences can be merely insignificant
to the world at large, is a foise attack upon
the King, the Parliament, and the Constitu-
tion ; and still the law of this country is so
defective, as that this shall pass with impunity !
This is a doctrine entirely new to me. It is
not proved by the circumstance of many such
crimes having; passed unnoticed, therefore
they should always pass; but it is necessary,
fbr the peace of^ this country, that that doc-
trine must be declared to be raise.
My lord, with regard to the punishment, I
always shudder when it is incumbent upon us
to pronounce a punishment of this nature
against a person, such as the panel at the
bar. But, my lord, wet^an make nd distinc-
tion of persons, and if there was room for dis-
tinction, I hold that the more dignified the -
situatbn of the offender, the ereater is his
crime, and the sreater ought to be his punish*
ment ; it is but nttle short of going the length
that your lordship has pointed out, which
might have calledupon us, in certain circum-
stances, to have pronounced the sentence of
death. The pumshment your lordship has
suggested is the most applicable of any, fbr
this reason : in the first place, it is justified
by precedent in the high justiciary court of
this country; a sentence of the same 9on;M
a greater period of time, was pronounced.*
But what is necessary for us to consider, ih
the consequences of this sentence that we
shall award. How should I reconcile it to the
Judge of my conscience, to send a seditious
incendiary from tiie country of Scotland to
the country of Enghmd, to propagate the
^ See the sentence passed upon Mr. Muir,
p.836, oftfabvolumef ^
375] 35 GEORGE UU Proceedings against the Rev. T. Fyshe Palmer [376
same mischievous principles? Just aa if one
should catch a maa with 'a lighted torch in his
hand, and,^ in place of extinguishing his torch,
and removine him at a distance from his pre-
mises, he only sends him into tlie hous^ of
bis father or his brother. Such a sentence
my conscience could not submit to ; I could i
not reconcile to my mind, to my conscience,
and to the puhhc, any other sentence than
that which would remove this gentleman from !
that land, where, in place of propagating the
gospel of peace, he has endeavourol to raise ,
up the evil spirit of dissen^on among us; and
^ by sendine nim to foreign parts beyond the
seas, we &nall be taking as much care of our
neighbours as of ourselves. At the same time,
it is to be hoped, that in a mu^h less time
than the period of his sentence, all spirit of
dissension amor^g ourselves will be at an end,
and the whole body of the people will have
united in thanking God for the true liberty
thev possess, and the happiness they enjoy,
unoer the constitution of this country ; and
that this unhappy gentleman will have found
the error of his ways, and adopted principles
and practice more consistent with the honour-
able profession in which he is.
Mr. Palmtr — My lords, may I be permitted
to speak a few words?
Lord Ekkgrove^^Ye^y Mr. Palmer, you may
speak.
Mr. Palmer — My lords, I can appeal, with
conscious smcerity, to the great Searcher of
hearts, fur the good intentions and upright-
ness of my conduct. My life has, for many
years, l>een employed in the dissemination of
what I conceived to be religious and moral
truths, truths which I supposed to be of the
freatest importance to manlcind. My friends
now with what ardour I have done this, at
the total sacrifice of all my worldly interests ;
but, during the late great political discussions
that have taken place, it was entirely, natu-
rally impossible, in a man of my sanguine
disposition, to remain an unconcerned by-
stander. I felt as all around me felt; I caught
the general impulse; 1 thought, too, that I
perceived that politics were a great branch of
morals, if they did not comprise the whole of
pur dutv to our neighbour; for, my lords,
would but our superiors, would but all the
^orld, do to one another what they, in like
circumstances, would wish to be done to
themselves, our petitions would have been
answered, and every jgrievance redressed. I
trust, that my politics is the cause of common
justice, the cause of benevolence and of hu-
man happiness. It was under the influence,
I protest, of these considerations, that I was
led to enter myself into the society of the
Friends of Liberty. I thought, my lords,
that a parliamentary reform would enh^ce
the hajipiness of millions, and establish the
security of the empire. For these reasons it
was, and with these views only, as God is my
judge, that I joined that society of low wea^
< vers and mechanics/ ,^ you called thein, at
the Bereaii M«eting-house at Dundee; and
for these reasons too, to gain these ends, that
I assented to the publication of this hand-bill ;
for, the declaration and the test of the so-
ciety, and all their endeavours, as &r as I
have been able to learn, were solely confined
to that one object of parliamentary reform,
and a more equal representation of the
people.
It is not, my lords, the first time that I
have suffered in eiulfsavouring to benefit
others ; for this I have borne shame, odium,
reproach, and a great diminution of fortune.
I hope and trust, that it is my utmost ambition,
and all who know me will agree with me
that it has been the tenor of my life, to endea^
vour to add, if possible, to the sum of human
happiness. And, my lords, if I should be
called aeain to the like, or more severe trials;
if I should be called again to suffer, in what I
cannot but think the cause of men in general,
the cause of human happiness ; I trust, that I
shall be able to bear my sufferings, not only
with fortitude, but with chearfulness — with
the hope, my lords, that my sufferings will
not be wholly lost ; but will, by the blessing
of that great Being whom I serve, be ren-
dered efncacious toue good of my fellow crear
tures.
Perhaps, mv lords, I am out of time in
raentiomng, that three witnesses were omit-
ted to be called, who would have sworn, that
on the 6th of July last, George Mealmsdcer
declared he wrote every word of this address,
independent of any one else. — [Mr. Palmer
mentioned the names of these three witnesses
omitted.]
Lord tikgrove — ^II is usual, in all cases of
passing sentence, for the Court to give some
advice to the person upon whom sentence is
passed. I only wish, that you yourself may
view it in the proper light tnat, I think, will
be for your own felicity, the correcting of anv
errors you may have (alien into; and that all
here may take example from it (which is the
§reat end of punishment), and avoid those
angerous courses, dangerous to society, dan-
gerous to themselves, which have brou^t
you into the unfortunate situation in whidi
you now stand. You will hear the sentence
read.
The clerk then read the following sen-
tence:—
The lords Eskgrooe and Abercromh^y in
respectof the foregoing verdict; they, in terms
of an act of parliament, passed in the S5th
year of his m^esty's reign, intituled, " An
act for the more effectual transportation of
felons, and other offenders, in that part of
Great Britain called Scotland ;" ordered and
acyudeed, and hereby order and adjudge.
That the said Thomas Fyshe Palmer be trans-
ported beyond the seas, to such place as his
majesty, with the advice of his privy council,
shsul declare and appoint ; and that for and
during the space of ' seven >^ears' from and
after this date; with certification to him, that
§
977]
^Sediim*
A. D. 1793.
[878
ify after being so UaasiNtfled, be tfaall tetiim
to, and be found at laxge within any part of
Great Britain, without some lawnd cause,
during the space of seven years, beins thereof
lawfully convicted, he shall suffer death, as
in cases of felony, without benefit of clergy,
by the law of England; for which this shall
be a sufficient warrant to all concerned. And
farther decerned and adjudged, and hereby
decern and adjudge the said Thomas Fyshe
Palmer to be carried from the bar back to the
Tolbooth of Perth, therein to remain till an
opportunity offers of transporting him in man-
ner above-mentioned; reauiring hereby the
magistrates of Perth, ana keepers of their
Tolooothy to receive and retain him accord*
ingly.
In Belsham's Memoirs of Lindsey it is
stated, that ** after sentence Mr. Palmer ex-
perienced very rigorous treatment. He was
confined for some weeks in the common gaol
of Perth ; from which, without any previous
notice, he was hurried away at four o'clock in
the morning in the month of November, and
taJcen on board a cutter which brought him to
London ; where he and Mr. Muir, a geutle-
man of the faculty of advocates in Scotland,
who for a similar offence had been subjected
to a still severer sentence, were for some time
iodged in Newgate, and were afterwards con-
fined in the Hulks at Woolwich, where they
were treated by the governor with much
bumanity, and were allowed all the accom-
modations which their situation would admit.
•They were permitted to see their friends.
•Here they were visited by Mr. Lindsey and
Dr. Priestley, and by many other virtuous
friends of liberty and reform, who contributed
hy their sympatliy to alleviate their sufferixigs,
and who with others raised a very handsome
subscription to provide necessaries for ^eir
voyage, and requisites to their future esta-
blishment when they had reached the place
of their destination.'' And in a note Mr.
BeUham adds ** * Mr. Muir and Mr. Palmer,'
says Mr. lindsey in a letter to Dr. Toulmin
dated December 14th, 1793, ' are on board
* the hulks with the felons, and manv of jpy
' friends have been to see them. I also hear
' fi'om h\i. Palmer, and have sent him some
' books. Neither of them, I believe, is in
' want of any thing, the place consider^.
' But the situation is, upon the whole, horrible.
* Mr. Palmer, however, is most cheerful in the
* midst of it, and Mr. Muir not otherwise.' In
another letter to the same friend dated
January lOth, 1794, Mr Lmdsey writes:
*■ Since I last wrote, opinions have varied
* about the destiny of Mr. Palmer and Mr.
* Muir, as the Scotch judges have, upon revisal,
* adhered to the sentence pronounced upon
' them. Mr. Palmer's health and spirits are
/ most cheerfyl : Mr. Muir far from well in
'health since the cold weather set in: bothof
. * them supported by their integrity and future
' hepes. Some friends who visited the Hulks
* on Wednesday had a commission from Aome
< others to ofier a purse to Mr. Palmer ^d
' Mr. Muir. The former declined taking any
< thing, but Mr. Muir thankfully accepted it.^
Mr. Palmer afterwards saw reason to alter his
mind^ and accepted the proffered kindness of
bis friends. In a subsequent letter Mr. Lindsey
informs his friend, * that-the amount of the
< contribution was between five and six hun-
* dred pounds, and that it was vested in the
* hands of a committee of seven for the benefit
' of Messrs. Palmer, Muir, Skirving, and even
* Marg^rot, who as a joint .sufferer, was not to
< be overlooked, though his senersJ chiuucter
* was not so high as the others.' How true
this observation of Mr. Lindsev's was, and
how justly this person was entitled to parti-
cipate in the bounty of Mr. Palmer's friends,
those who were witnesses to his conduct to
that gentleman on board the transport in the
passage to New South Wales, could properly
appreciate." Belsham's Memoirs of Lindsey
p. 362.
The most ample (and apnarently authentic)
account of this person^ which I have seen,
was inserted in a periodical publication at the
time of his death, and is as toUows : —
'' Mr. Palmer was descended from an an-
cient and respectable family, in Bedfordshire,
in which county, and in Berkshire, there are
now remaining several branches of tlie same
family, possessmg very considerable property.
The subject of this memoir, was born at Jek*
well, in the parish of Northill, Bedfordshire, it
is presumed, in July 1747, as the certificate of
his baptism, taken from the parish register of
Northill, is dated August 16, 1747. Afler
receiving the usual elementary instruction,
under the rev. Mr. Gunning at Ely, he was
sent to Eton, where he spent four or five
years ; and in 1765, he was entered at Queen's
College, Cambrid^. In 1769, he took the
degree of B. A. In 177 S, that of M, A. and
in 178 1 , that of B. D. The exact lime of his
ordination does not appear, but he performed
the duties of curate about twelve months, at
Leatherhead, in Surrey. In a short time
afW he had taken this last degree, he became
dissatisfied with the doctrines of the Church
of England, and farther inquiry convinced
him of the proper unity of God ; and that
worship was alone due to him as the unri*
vailed Creator. In the year 1783, he took
leave of the college, and with that of his (Con-
nexion with the church in which he had
been educated. From Cambridge he went to
Montrose, in Scotland. His motive for mak-
ing choice of this particular place in preference
to others, was, tlu&t there ne might have an
opportunity of worshipping God with a society
of Unitarians, who had lately opened a chapel
under the auspices of Mr. W. Cnristie, author
of some admirable discourses on the divine
Unity, which were delivered to the society^ at
S79] 33 GEORGE lit. Proceedingi againsilUe Reo. T. FyAe Palmer [SSO
Palmer attached himself, and resided at Mon-
tiose about twenty months, when he removed
tol>undee, where there was also a respecta-
ble fiociety of Unitarian Christians. At Dun-
deehe remained several years, preaching very
frisquently in the neighbouring towns, and
i^iDages : and at Forfar, Edinburgh, and some
other places, he delivered a series of dis-
tourses in vindication of Unitarian principles.
Hi»distingui^ted zeal in tins cause made nim
enemies, who, though unwilling to raise a
persecution asainst him on account of religion,
were not displeased when his politics afforded
an opportunity of injuring his character, and
destroying his peace. Full ten rears he ex-
hibited au ardent and 'noble zeu in defence
of the doctrines which he had embraced, in
opposition to those which he had imbibed
'from early education. As a writer, on these
subjects, Mr. Palmer discovered considerable
talents, and no small share of biblical learn-
ing, in the few pieces which he gave to the
%rorld. Of these, one was intitul^i, ** An at-
tempt to refute a Sermon, by U. D. IngUs,
on the Godhead of Jesus Christ, and to restore
the loDg lost Truth of the First Command-
ment.'' This pamphlet is dedicated to the
Unitarian Congregations of Edinburgh, Dun-
dee, Forfar, Arbroath, Montrose, and New-
burgh ; it displays much critical acumen, and
a train of strone reasoning. Mr. Palmer's
other Theolc^cal tracts are, 1. An Attempt
to prove the fallen Angels to have been only
the Sons of Beth. i^. An Attempt to Explain
Isaiah ix. 6. 3. An Attempt to show that
the Cock crowing which Peter heard, was
the sound of a Trumpet 4. An Attempt to
Ascertain the meaning of ftn fialroXryn^t'
5, & 6. Attempts to Illustrate the xxivth
Chapter of Matthew's Gospel, and the first
ten verses of the Sd Chapter of St. John.
These, together with Observations on some
other writers in the same Work, are to be
found in the 5th and 6th volumes of the
Theological Repository, under the signature
of Anglo Scotus. Such were the labours of
Mr. PSmer as a Theologian and Divine. We
are now to view him in another character, as
a friend to the liberties of his country, in
which his zeal was equally distinguishea, for
the sake of which his sufferings were unme-
rited and severe, and at length terminated his
life in a foreign land. The exertions made
hy the friends of liberty, to obtain a reform
of parliament, in all parts of this island, in
the years 1792, 3 and 4, are in the recollection
of every person ; and the various prosecutions
and persecutions which th6 administration of
that period instituted against those who took
an active part in the cause of reform will not
easily be forgotten. Amone those in North
Britain, were the subject of Siis memoir, Mr.
Muir, Mr. Skirving, Mr. Gerrald, and Mr.
Mar^rot; the last-mentioned gentlemen,
tirere active in asslembliiig a Convention of
Delegates from the several societies associated
for obtaining a reform in the Commons'
House of Pkrlianienl ; the case of Mr. Palmer
was distinct and pecuKar. He -was indicted
end brought to trial in the month of Sep*
tember. If 98, for writing and publishing an
Address to the People, on the subject of re-
form. The fact ofpublication was distinctlr
proved, but with the drawing up of the Ad-
dress he had nothing to do; it was indeed,
avowed by one of the witnesses for the Crown,
to have been written by himself. Mr. Palmer
was, however, foond euilty, and sentenced to
transportation beyond seas for the term of
seven years. From the court, Mr. Palmer was
conveyed to Uie Tolbooth of Perth. In this
prison he lay some weeks, after which he was
conveyed by sea, to the Thames, and nut on
board the Stanislaus hulk lying off Woolwich c
while in this situation, he wb3 part of the time
in irons, but having permission to see his
friends, seldom a day passed in which one or
more, among whom was the writer of this
article, did not visit him with a view of offer-
ing him any assistance of which he might
stand in need, to alleviate the calamities inci-
dent to his situation. On the 1 1th of Febraary
1794, he was taken from the hulk and put on
board the Surprize transport, Patrick Camp-
bell, master. It was not, however, till the end
of April, that the fleet set sail, of which the
Surprize was one. The account of his sufler-
ings and those of Mr. Skirving, has been laid
before the public fSee a narrative of the suf^
ferings of T. F. Palmer, and W. Skirving,
during a voyage to New South Wales 1794,
on bowrd the Surprize transport, by T. F.
Palmer, 8d. Edit. 1797.] ; to that, the truth of
which was authenticated by a great number
of witnesses, we refer the reader, who will be
shocked ano astonished at the indignities and
cruelties inflicted on these worthy characters,
without even a pretence for the exercise of
this wanton abuse of authority. On the S(th
of October, they arrived at Port Jackson, New
Holland, from which place he and his fellow
sufferers dispatched their first letters to those
friends who had interested themselves in their
welfare. Mr. Muir, who, in comparison of
his associates, had been kindlv treated, bore
an honourable testimony to the conduct of
Messrs. Palmerand Skirving, and gave implict
evidence to the injustice of the charges brought
against them, and to the inhumanity which
they experienced through the whole of their
voyage. Soon after their arrival, Mr. Muir,
Skimng, and Palmer delivered letters of
recommendation to the governor of the
colony, from persons in England of the first
respectability ; houses were appointed to them
contiguous to each other, and Mr. Palmer
wrote to his friends saying, " we have no
cause to complain of any want of civility or
attention." rrora this time they emplovcd
themselves in cultivating the land allotted to
them, and the accounts given by Mr. Palmer
and Skirving, were of the most favourable
kind, both \mh respect to the climate 0f the
comitry, and the fertility of the land. We
S81]
JbrSedUum.
A. D. 1793.
[382
have alreadjT seen that Paimer, Muir, and
Skirving, arrived at Port Jackson, in October
1794. JBarly in the fc^owing. year, l^Ir.
Joseph Gerrald, who had engagS in the same
cause, was doomed to experience the same
barsh treatment. He had heen long confined
in a close room inNeweate, before he em-
barked for New Holland;, his health was
completely broken, and In a very short time
after he landed at Port Jackson he fell a
victim to Uie disease of the climate. By the
sentence passed on Mr. Palmer, he could not
set foot m Great Britain, till the middle of
September 1800, without incurring the penalty
of death. The voyage, however, would take
several months had it been made by the
shortest and Quickest route; he, therefore,
with his friends began to make preparations
for returning at the end of the year 1799. A
ship was purchased for tbe purpose, the prin-
cipal part of which was the property of^Mr.
Palmer, though captain Reed, Mr. Boston, and
Sir. ElUs had a small share in her. On the
SOth.of January 1800, they set sail from Port
Jackson9 with an intention of joing directly
to New Zealand, to take in timber for the
market at the Cape^of Good Hope, The ship
was in a wretch^ condition, and provisions
were taken on board for a voyage of only six
months, a period which they had fixed. for
their arrival at the Cape. Twenty six weeks,
however, they spent at New Zeaknd, durine
which the whole of their stores were expende£
Distress of the most alarming nature now
compelled them to go in search of provisions ;
thev steered lor TangaTaaboo, but there they
could obtain no relief^ in consequence of an
existing war between the natives of this, and
tbe neighbouring islands. Fron^, thence they
resolved to call at the Feegee islands ; at one
of which they procured a small supply, and
the favourable reception which they met widi
in the first instance, determined them to visit
the others. By end^vouriag to get to the
island of Goraa they ran their crazy vessel on
a reef, which carri^ awav alarge> part of her
keel, and in less tlian h^f an hpur, die made
seven feet of water ; but the surf rising, they
were driven off the^ reef into deep water^ Im-
mediately thev cast anchor, and with tiie
assistance of the natives, repaired their vessel.
To them also they were indebted, not only
for a supply of eveiy necessary while in that
state, but for a libenil stock to go to sea withr
They now determined to proce^ to Macao,
in China; but meeting with contAiy winds^
ihcv sailed till their provisions were exhausted,
andi the repairs of the ship were all opening
again. In this dreadful situation, ^ey were
compelled to put into the island of Guam,
though they well knew it was an enemy's
port. Upon coming to anchor, January lOth,
1801 , the Spanish governor, in reply to their
solicitations for provisions, assurea them, that
unl^s they departed in two hours, he would
detain them as prisoners of war, for to the
enemies of his country he could give no sup-
port whatever. Necessity obliged them to
submit to the hard terms ofiercd them. Iliey
were immediately taken prisoners, and a
guard put into their ship. Messrs. Palmer,
£llis, Boston^ Beed, and Harris, sen. and jim.
lived with the governor, and were treated
with hospitality. During their stay here,
which appears to have been a year and a hdf,
Mr. Palmer was seized with a dysentery, a
disease with which he had been perpetually
afflicted, since he left England, but for which
he conceived he had discovered an infallible
remedy in cerated glass of antimony and
ipecacuanha. In a letter to a friend in Lon-
aon, dated Sept. 10» 1799, he says, < I would
' not chanse my residence a week, withmit
' these medicines. I know that I should ioiiig
' have been dead but £ov them. I give horn
' 7 to 10 grains of the antimony, and alter-
* nately small doses of ipecacuanha. Oh, had
' I known of this remedv at Spithead, what
' leng^hefied misery, and wear and tear of
* constitution I should have escaped. Possi-.
' bly Gerrald and Skirving might now have
' been alive !' Whether Mr. Palmor was
now without his medicines, or what is more
probable, whether the fircquent attacks of the*
same disorder had we^ened his constitution
to a degree beyond the power ef medicine to
recruit, we have no information. He iin^red
under the disorder till tbe beginning of June
1803^ when a mortification took place, which
temunated his valuable life, on the second
day .of that month. — Monthly Mag. Vol. 17,
pp. 83^--85.
To one of the editions of this trial is sub-,
joined what is called <' Mr. Pahner's defence,
which he intended to have delivered, had he *
not employed counsel," a performSwce, of
which, as it throws no new light upon the
merits of the case, £airther mention is unne-
cessary.
383] 34 GEORGE III. Prcteedingi ^gamsi Akxander Seoit
[384
595. Proceedings before the High Court of Justiciary at Edin*
burghj against Alexander Scott, on an Indictment ex-
hibited against him by the Lord Advocate of Scotland,
charging hyn with Sedition^ Feb. 3: 34 George III.
A. D. 1794.*
Curia Justiciaria S. D. N. Reps tenta in
Nova Sessionis domo de Edinburgh, ter-
tio die Febniarii, millesimo septingen-
tesimo et nonagesimo quarto, per hono-
rabilcs viros Robertum Mac Queen de
Braxfield, Dominum Justiciarium Cleri-
cum, Davidem Rae de £sk grove, Joan-
nem Swinton deSwinton, Dominum GuH-
elmum Nairnede Dunsinnan,baronetum,
ct Alexandrum Abercromby de Aber-
cromby, Dominos Commissionarios Jus-
ticiarift dictiS. D. N. Regis.
Curia legitime afiirniata.
1 HE which day the criminal letters Raised
and pursued at the instance of Robert Dun-
das of Arniston, esq. his majesty's advocate
for his majest^a interest against Alexander
Scott, printer in Edinburgh, being called;
-which criminal letters make menUon that,
whereas, by the laws of this, and of every
other well governed realm, sedition ; as also,
the wickedly and feloniously printing and
circulating, or causing to be printed or circu-
lated, any writings or speeches of a seditious
import and tendency, calculated to excite the
people to acts of outrage and violence, are
crimes of an heinous nature, dangerous to
the public peace, and scvef-ely punishable :
yet true it is, and of verity, that the said
Alexander Scott, above complained upon, is
guilty actor, or art and part, of both and each,
or one or other, of the foresaid crimes ; in so
far as, during the months of October, No*
vember, and December 179S, a number of
seditious and evil disposed persons having, at
Edinburgh, in the county of Edinburgh, as*
sembled themselves under the designation of
a general convention of the FriendA of the
People; and having thereafter presumptu-
ously and seditiously assumed to themseivea
the name of the " British Convention of the
Delegates of the People, associated to obtain
Universal Suffrage and Annual Parliaments ;^*
did, in the whole form and manner of their
procedure, as well as in the principles they
avowed and propagated, clearly ana unequi-
vocally demonstrate that their purposes were
of the most dangerous and destructive ten-
dency, hostile to the peace and happiness,
and tending to subvert tne constitution of this
realm,^ imitating, in the form and tenor of
their proceedings, the convention of France,
'" ' III! I II —— ^1M^^^^—
* From the records of justiciary.
the public and avowed enemies of this coun*
try, and with whom Great Britain then was,
and still is, at war ; the members of the said
meetings calling each other by the name of
citizen; dividing themselves into sections;
receiving reports from said sections ; some
of which bear date " Liberty Court," ** Li-
berty Stairs," " Liberty Hall," ** first year
of the British Convention, one and indivisi-
ble ;" and of which some are superscribed
Vive h Convention^ and end with fa-tra ; insti-
tuting primary societies, provincial assem*
blies, and departnlents ; appointing commit-
tees of various kinds, such as, of ^* Organiza-
tion," of" Instructions,*' of " Finance," and
of "Secrecy ;" denominating their meetings
" Sittings;" ** granting honours of Sittings ;*'^
making " honourable mention in their mi-
nutes of patriotic donations ;" and inscribing
their minutes with •• the first year of the Bri-
tish Convention." And moreover, the mem-
bers of the said seditious association, under
the designations aforesaid, did, at time»
and places above mentioned, and particularly
in a room or Masons Lodge in Blackfriars
W^d, in the city of Edinburgh aforesaid, hold
various seditious and illegal meetings, wick-
edly and feloniously make harangues and
speeches, as well as motions and resolutions,
of a seditious tendency ; the substance of all
which was, under their authoritv, at least
with their knowledge and approbation, not
only minuted, but published in a newspaper
intituled " The Euinburgh Gazetteer,*^ and
through that mediimi circulated among the
lieges. In particular, at a meeting of the said
association, upon the 95th day of the said
month of November, or upon one or other of
the da^ of that month, or of the months
aforesaid, one of the members of the said
meeting, having, at the place foresaid, made
the following motion, or one of a similar ten-
dency, viz. " That in case the minister, or any
other member of either House of Parliament,
bring forward a motion for leave to bring in a
convention bill, such as has passed in Ireland,
to prevent the people from meeting according
to their just rights by the Revolution, the
same motion shall be notice to the delegates
to meet in convention, to assert their rights;**
the said motion was made the subject of dis-
cussion in the said meeting, within the room
or Masons Lodge aforesaid, upon the 97th day
of the said month of November, or on some
one or other of the days of the months afore-^
886]
^ SediUoiu
A. D. 17M.
[S86
Old, ^dienCbaries Sindair, a mcfmber of said
oomrendoo, did propose sundry amendments
tbnetOyOfa wicked uid seditious tendency;
and tl»e said motion, with the amendments
thereupon proposed by him or others, hav-
ing be«n, oy the said meetine, referred to
th# 8^ Charles Sinclair, ana some others
of the members of the said meeting, as a
committee to draw up a motion from the
whole, the said Charles Sinclair did, upon
the S8th day of the said month of Novem-
▼ember, or on one or other of the da^rs of that
month, or of tiie months aforesaid, within the
foom or Masons Lodge aforesaid; nead^o the
fltid illegal meeting, when there assembled,
the amendments upon the foresaid motion,
as agreed upon 1^ nim and the said commit-
tee, when mb said illegal and seditious meet-
ing did wickedly ana feloniously, then and
there, solemnly and unanimously come to a
Kesohition of the following import or tenor :
** That this convention, considering the ca«
lamitous consequences of any act of me legis-
lature which may tend to deprive the whole,
or may part of the people, of their undoubted
right to meet^ either by themselves or by de-
legation, to discuss any matter relative to their
€ommon interest, whc^er of a public or pri-
vate nature, and holdine the same to be to-
tally inoonsBtent with the first principles and
safety of society, and also subversive of our
known and acknowledged constitutional li-
berties, do hereby declare, before God and the
world, that we shall follow the wholesome
example of former times, by paying no regard
to any act which shall militate against the
eonstitution of our country; and shall conti-
nae to assemble, and consider of the best
means by which we can accomplish a real
representation of the people, and annual elec-
tion, until compelled to desist by superior
force.
** And we do resolve,
** That the first notice eiven for the intro-
duction of a convention bill, or any bill of a
smilar tendency to that passed in Ireland, in
the last session of their p^liament ;
^ Or any bill for the suspension of the Ha-
beas Corpus act, or the act for preventing
wrongous imprisonment, and against undue
delays in trials in North Britain ;
'< Or in case of an invasion ;
' ** Or the admission of any foreim troons
whatsoever into Great Britain or Ireland; all,
or any one, of these calamitous circumstances,
shall be a sinud to the different delegates to
Mair to such place as the secret committee
arthis convention shall appoint; and the
first seven members shall have power to de-
dtfethe sittings pennanent ; and twenty-one
shall constitute a convention, and proceed to
^The convention doth therefore resolve,
that each delegate, immediately on his return
boflM^do convene his constituents, and ex*
plais-ta them the netipssity of electing a dele-
Cite, or delegates, and of establishing a fund
VOJLXXm,
without delay, against any of these etnefgen*
des^ for his or their expense ; and that they
do instruct the said delegate or delegates, to
hold themselves ready to depart at one hour's
warning.''
And nirther, at the same time, and withut
the same place, after the foresaid resolution
had been so made, a motion was made in the
said meeting, in the following words, or in
words of a similar import and tendency:
'' That a secret committee of three and the
secretary be appointed to determine the place
where such convention of emergency shall
meet: that such place shall remain a secret
with them and with the secretary of this con«
vention : and that each delegate shall, at the
breaking up of the present session, be en-
trusted with a sealed letter, containing the
name of the place of meeting : this letter shall
be delivered unopened to his constituents;
the receipt of which shall be acknowledged by
a letter to the secretary, preserved in the
same state, until the period shall arrive at
which it shall be deemed necessary for the
delegate to set off :" The said meet'mg did
wickedly and seditiously unanimously approve
of the said motion. And at a subsequent
meeting, upon the 4th dav of December, or
upon one or other of the days of that month
or upon one or other of the days of the months
aforesaid, and within the said room or Masons
Lodge aforesaid, it having been moved by one
of the members then present, " that the mo«
mcnt of any illeeal dispersion of the present
convention shallbe considered as a summons
to the delegates to repair to the place of meet«
ing appointed for the convention of emergency
by the secret committee ; and that the secret
committee be instructed to proceed without
delay to fix the place of meeting ;** the said
meeting did unanimously resolve the same,
and appointed the secret committee to pro-
ceed as desired. AU which motions and re*
solutions, together with many others of an
equally seditious tendency, the said Alexan*
der Scott, who was then a member of the
said association, did at times and place afore-
said, wickedly and feloniously approve of and
concur in, and took besides an active part in
all their proceedings,^ and was frequency
named, and acted as a member of their com«
mittees: in particular, the said Alexander
Scott did, at times and place aforesaid, wick*^
edly and feloniously make a motion of the'^
following import and tendency : ** That be-
fore any delegate from the country shalUeave
his post, he shall write to his constituents Xd
sena another up in his room;" and which
motion was unanimously asreed to. And,
upon Thursday, the dth of December, 1703,
or upon one or other of the days of that
montti, the provost and masistrates of £din-
burah havine repaired to the foresaid roon^
or Masons Lodge, in Blackfiriar's Wynd of
Edinburgh, wbete the said illegal association
or convention was assembled, in order to dis-
perse the same; they were then and there
S C
987]
a aBORQE HI.
Proeeedingi dgtiiUt Akxander Seatt
[8W
roasted, and obliged, by the said association,
to use force to compel the members to leave
the room ; and who did immediately repur
to ft house or room in the Flesh -market Close
of Canoneate of Edinburgh, where they, not-
withstanding their recent dispersion, did, in
contempt and defiance of the civil magistrate,
deelarj3 their meetings permanent. And the
•aid association, or convention, having agreeil
to meet on the day following, in a room or
work*shop in Lady Lawsoti's yard, on the
south side of the street called the Crosscause-
way, in the parish of St. CuthberVs, and shire
of Edinburgh, belonging to John Laine, wright,
at which meeting the said Alezanaer Scott
was present; the sheriff substitute of the
county of Edinburgh was obliged to use a
similar mode of compulsion before the meet^
ing would disperse. Further, the said Alex-
ander Scott did, at Edinburgh, in the county
of Edinburgh, on the S6th day of November
1793, and on the 3d and 10th days of Decem-
ber of the said- vear, or on one or other of the
days.of the said months, wickedly and felo-
niously print and circulate, or cause to be
printed and circulated, three numbers of a
paper, intituled, *' The Edinburgh Gazetteer,"
l)eing Nos. 78, 79, and 80, ana bearing the
fespective dates aforesaid, viz. the 96th No-
vember, Sd and 10th of December 1793 ; and
all of which numbers of papers aforesaid, bore
respectively, •* Edinburzn, printed by A. Scott,
Gazetteer office. South Bridge, to whom com-
missions are requested to be addressed ;" and
which papers contained a variety of seditious
and innammatory speeches, motions, and re-
solutions, said to have been spoken, proposed,
and passed, in the foresaid meeting, styling
itself << the British Convention of Delegates
of the People, associated to obtain Universal
Suffrage and Annual Parliaments/' Thus,
in the paper aforesaid. No. 78, and bearing
date the d6th day of November, 1793, where
an account is given. of a debate in the sedi-
tious meeting, relative to a union with similar
associations m England : it is said. ^ Eng-
lishmen and Scotchmen has declared for uni-
Tersal suffrage and annual parliaments: for
to obtain these objects they have united; they
will proceed untU thcv are secured, or yield
the pursuit only with tneir lives.'' Afterwards,
it is ^d, *' Much of late has been said about
meetings of mobs : I apprehend that no meet-
ins of tne people can be called a mob, if their
deTiberations oe directed towards tiie public
good ; but if men meet for an opposite pur-
pose, for promoting the misery or the des-
truction ot the himian race, though they should
sit with crowns on their heads and sceptres in
their hands, they are truljr a mob." — ^Also,
** It may occur, that the voice of the people
will be wrong, when their understandings are
]»erverted by priestcraft, or darkened by poli-
tical superstition, like the voice once heard in
Jerusalem, of Crucify him. Crucify him!
when that nefarious deed was perpetrated, at
wiiich the 9«a bid his head in dark&ess and
in blood. But were the ffrants of the earth
as solicitous to enlighten as they are to punish
those unfortunate subjects; were governments
to instruct the poor, instead of han^ng up
their bodies on gibbets, the voice of the peo^
pie would then oe the voice of God.** Fur«
ther, in a paper aforesud. No. 79, of date the
3d of December 1793, after mentioning the
above motion, relative to the minister's wioe-
ing into parliament such a a convention biU
as passea in Ireland, the following passage
occurs :
** M. Margaret, -^Thu is an excellent mo-
tion, and the event which it alludes to, oa^tA
to be the toetin to the friends of libert;|r to
assemble.'' Afterwards, in the account given
of the debate in the said British convientioQ
relative to the foresaid motion, the following
passage occurs :
^ Tnoueh I could not get a copy of this
bill, the neads, of which I have read, are
sufficiently explanatory of its detestable prin-
ciples; and I hope the measure which has
passed this nieht will convince the minister,
that we are determined to guard against
every attempt that may be made to deprive
us of our rignts : and though by some it may
be thought a bold, by some a daring me»»
sure, yet it will be found the best for secvr*
ing the peace of our country ; for if such a
law were suffered to pass, if men were not
allowed to utter their complaints, a number
of fierce and rancorous passions would arise^
and we would seek to appeal to that last
terrible decision, the event of which is UDoer«
tain, but which God and nature allows.
*' If the servility of the people had been
less ; if the^ had dared to meet, and in place
of murmuring, to have told their rulers that
there was danger in seeking to deprive them
of their liberties, we wouM not nave had to
adopt this resolution to night; but when I
saw the calm, deliberate countenances of all
present, and the solemn manner in which it
was passed, I was convinced that it woukl
not only be a resolution of words, but a rule
of action."
Further, in the paper aforesaid. No. 80,
and of date the lOtb day of December 1799,
the following passaees occur :
^ We have already appointed a secret com-t
mittee, for fixing a place of meeting on cer«
tain emerjgencies, and we ought to be equally
well provided against the present case ; for if
we shall happen to be dispersed to night,
how or where are we to rally again?— To do
this your committee suggests a resolution
to the following effsct, but which I shall leave-
to l>e drawn up by the council of the table:
that the moment of our ille^ dispersion
shall be considered as a summons to every
delegate to repair to the place appointed by
the secret committee in cases of emergency.
^ And all grasping and domineerii^ aris-
tocratic influence pervades and overspreads
the kingdom, and by threats and promisee
endeavoqrs to terrify or seduce the people
380]
for Sedkum^
A. D. 179*.
[S09
frdUk the assertion of their ri|^t8^ and from
exerting that native energy which appertains
to them.
** Let DO^ however, the officers of eovem-
ment be objects of your indignation. * If they
.really knew how they were degraded as mo-
lal beines, by the service on which they are
irequenSy sent, they would not feel much
respect ror those who employ them. Let
these men, then, be the objects of our pity
«nd instruction. Though they are sent to
disturb us, not one of them, I will affirm,
has ever been informed of the supposed of-
fence which we are now committing.*'
Further, in the aforesaid paper, No. 80, of
date aforesaid, there is an article intituled,
" An extraordinary instance of public spitit
jn a opbler of Messina ;" which article is ob-
viously calculated to convey to the lieges of
this ooontsy a doctrine of the most horrible
aod diabolicEd tendency ; to hold forth, under
tee foinh of a moral tale, that massacre end
assassination are justifiable, nay, are .acts of
of public virtue. It is prefaced thus : ^There
is a sort of enthusiasm in public spirit, which
ftsoden it politically prudent in corrupt
statesmen to discourage it;, and yet there
i9 something so great and so divine in this
enthuaasm, that statesmen of a better turn,
tfaoiigh they dare not encourage, yet they
cannot but admire it— We have a shining
luod surfvising example of this in the cobler
of Mes^a, which happened in the last cen-
tury, aUd is at oncQ a proof, that public spirit
13 the growth of every degree ; and which is
a point that our great men ought to consider
with attention, that wherever corruption be-
comes flagrant and universal, this heroic lu-
pacy of public spirit is most Ukely to appear."
And concludes thus : <' So I think it would
1)6 happy for the ministers, who are either
entrusted by their masters^ or acquire to
themselves a boundless authority, supported
py bfyun.dless influence, if they would write
in a table book, and from thence refresh
their memories frequently with this sentence,
* What if the cobier of Messina should re-
vive/' Thereby; clearly signifying, that the
foresaid wicked and nefaiious principle ought
ik> be put ia practice here; or at least holdmg
out a threat to those who are in public offices,
in order to deter them from a due exercise of
their duty, and thereby exciting tlie wicked
and seditious to perpetrate acts of such enor-
mity. And the said Alexander iSoott, above
complained upon, having, on the 5th day of
December 1793. been brought before Harry
Davidson, esq. sheriff-substitute of the county
pf Edinburgh, did in his presence emit and
sign a declaration, tending to show his guilt
JD the premises. Which declaration, toge-
ther with five half sheets and three full sheets
ofpaper in manuscript, found in the printing-
omce of the said Alexander Scott; as also,
four copies of the Edinburgh Gazetter, beins
Ko.'s 78, 79, 80, and 81 ; as also, the scroU
$Kr draught of the nuayles of the mi ssneral
coaventien, firom 29th of October to the 4th
day of December 1793, consisting of 95 pages,
and found in the custody of William SRir-
ving, secretary to the said convention, when
apprehended bv warrant of the sheriff of
Edinburgh in the month of December last,
beine No. 1 of the inventory of papers found
in the said William Skirving's possession,
and made up in presence of the sheriff of
Edinburgh upon the 5th of December last,
with the said inventory itself, and whole of
the other papers and writings therein con-
tained ; as also, two lists or inventories, made
up before the sheriff of Edinburgh on the 7th
of December last, of sundry papers found
in the possession of Joseph Gerrald and Mau-
rice Mar^arot, two members of the said con-
vention, when apprehended in conseq4^QQe
of a warrant from the sheriff of Edinburgh ;
one of which inventories, consisting of ten
articles, subscribed by William Scott, pro-
curator-fiscal of the county of Edinburgh, and
the said Joseph Gerrald; and the other, con-
sisting of nine articles, subscribed by the
said William Scott and the sheriff-substitute^
together with Uie whole articles mentioni^ in
the said two inventories, excepting No. 1 ;
and also, an inventory of simdrv papers found
in the custody of Charles Sinclair, one of the
members of the sadd convention, and made
up in presence of the sheriff of Edinburgh
upon the 7th day of December 1793, con-
sisting of SI articles, with the whole of the
said 31 articles themselves; as also, a letter
signed Alexander Scott, dated " Gazetteer
office, Monday, 9th December, 1793," and ad-
dressed to ^* the right honourable the brd
advocate of Scotland;" will all be used in
evidence against the said Alexander Scott;
and will for that purpose be lodged in the
hands of the clerk of the hish court of justi-
ciary, before which he is to be tried, that ;he
mav have an opportunity of seeing the same.
At least, times and places above mentioned,
the said acts of sedition were committed ; the
said speeches, motions, resolutions, and ar-
ticle, printed and circulated in manner fore-
said; and the said Alexander Scott, above
complained on, is guilty actor,. or art and
part, of all and each, or one or other, of the
said crimes. All whieh, or part thereof, be-
ing found proven by the veraict of an assize,
before our lord justice general, lord justice
clerk, and lords commissioners of justiciary,
in a court of justiciary to be holden by them,
within the criminal court-house of Edin-
burgh, upon the third day of February next
to con^, the said Alexander Scott, above com-
plainea upon, ought to be punished with the
pains of taw, to deter others from commit-
ting the like crimes in all time coming. And
the said Alexander Scott being of\times call-
ed in court^ and three times at the door of
the courtrhouse he failed to appear.
Whereupon his majesty's advocate movea
that sentence of out-lawry and fugitation,
iQiglht be pr9n9U|9ced against the said i^kx^
3912 34 GEORGE lU. Proceedings agdna WOliam Skirving [399
aoder Scott, and that as he understood bail
had been s'lven for his appearance when he
was apprenended by the sheriff— he moved
that the bond might be forfeited, and the
penalty recovered.
The lord justice clerk, and lords commis-
sioners of justiciary, decern and adjudge the
said Alexander Scott, to be an outlaw and
fugitive from his majesty's laws, and ordain
him to be put to his highnesses horn, and
all his moveable goods and ^ear to be es-
cheat, and inbrought to his mi^esty's use, for
his contempt and disobedience m not appear-
ing this day and placci in the hour of cause.
to have underlyn the law for the o^i^e of
sedition, as specified in the said criminal
letters, as he who was lawfully cited to that
effect, oAtimes called in court,- and three
times at the door of the court-house, and
failing to appear as said is. And fartheir»
<the said lords declare the bond of caiitioii
granted for the appearance of the said Alex-
ander Scott to be forfeited; and ordain the
penalty therein centred, to be recovered
by the clerk of this court, to be disposed of
as the court shall direct
(Signed) Eobb&t M^Queev, I. P. D.
596, Proceedings on the Trial of Wiluam Skirting^ on an
Indictment charging him with Sedition. Tried before the
High Court of Justiciary at Edinburgh on the 6th and 7tl>
of January : 34 George IIL a. d. 1794.
By the right honourable Robert Dundas, now
[1817] lord chief baron of the court of ex-
chequer of Scotland, who, when the pro-
ceedings against Skirving and his associ-
ates were instituted, held the office of his
majesty's advocate, I have been favoured
with an exact copy of the minutes of that
assembly which had first called itself The
General Convention of the Friends of the
People, and which afterwards took the
name of the British Convention of the De-
legates of the People associated to obtain
Universal Sufirage and Annual Paiiiaments.
These minutes were received as evidence
on this and the following trials, and I here
insert them at fiill length.
[N, B, WhfUever i$ erased in the original
is here printed within brackets [ ] — wards
underscored in the same are printed in
italics'].
General Covventiov.
Edinburgh, S9th October, 1793.
Mr. JOHN M'lntyre being called to the
chair, the following commissions were given
in, r^, and foundvalid, viz.
From the Potterrow Society in favour of
Messrs. Adam Pringle, John Clark, James
Bell, Thomas Noble, James Paterson', Ran-
dolph Slack, Thomas Bell, George Turner,
James Dun, Geo. [Innes] Cotton, P., James
t^l^vis, treas., Jas. Tod, sec., Jas. Bell, Jo.
.Gilchrist, Thus. Watson.
New Town. — John Milne, P., John Laid-
law, S.
Cowgate.— Alexander Reid, Charles Salter,
Isaac Salter, George Callum, Wtlliatai M^Cub-
bin, John M4jiiyre| John Lung.
Canongaite, No. 3.— David [LaingJ Taylor^
Wm. Robertson.
Dundee Friends of the Con8tituUoii.«--'Bievw
Mr. James Donaldson.
Dundee Friends of Liberty.— Geoi^ Meal'
maker.
Dundee Friends of the Coostitutionj— -Rev.
Mr. Neil Douglas.
New Milns.--JameB CampbeU* of New
MUls.
New Town.—- David Bertie, John AnchliH
lech, John Muir, John Noble^ John M'Ar-
thur, Alexander Kbox, Archa. Gray, John
Graham, Jame8Bonrdon,Wm. Urquhart, John
Hodse, Alexr. Bremner, Andw. Newton.
Glasgow Friends of the People.-^Jame6
Seton] Robert Peacook, John Stark, Jas.
Gartley, [Eben. Millar] John Gartley, [John
Sinclair] Hinchelwood, Walter Hart, Willilbn
Millar. Jas. Little.
Goroals. — Geo. Millar.
Dunfermline.— James Boyd, John Morris,
John Philip.
Strathaven. — John Mitchell.
Paisley.-H'John M<Intyre] Taylor, [Jattiaft
Mitchell] Arcbd. Hastie.
Portsburgh. — [right hon. lord Daer] Messrs.
Peter Hardie, James Richmond, [John Smith3
Taylor, James Tweedie, Joseph Smeal, Jchn
Dickson, John Richmond, Adam Richmond,
Wm. Skirving, esq., Peter Wood, John Thom^
son, Geo. Anderson, James SmeaU, Fredk«
Milne, William Mofiat.
United Societies of Kirkaldy and linkton.
—William Todd, James Hally, Henry Bait.
Linlithgow. — ^Adam Dawson, Wilhn. Mai^
shall, Wm. Hinshelwood.
Canongate. No. 1 and S.— Alexander. Bell,
John Buchanan, Alexr. Fortune, f Johnj
James Someivai, [Geo. Ross,] Alekr. Aitdd*
son. Arch. Wright, Alexr. Callander, [esq.T
Bichd. Younger, John WanUaw, Yfr'
393]
JhrSeditioH.
A. D. 1794>.
im
SimMODy John Jnhnt^xm, ThomM K^aoedy.
Water of Leith.— Arihtir M'Ewan, Robert
Orrock, Willm. FarquharsoOy Wm. Goaford.
Perth.-^JobD Wbytock], [Robert Angus],
Robert Sands.
lintony East Lothian. — John Hepburn, P.
Geo. Mylnte, Andw. Taylor, sec.
OperativeSociety £dinburffh.^-J<^n Hjpne,
Cordon Murray, Thos. Miner, John Baillie,
Alexr. Cockbum, Wiilm. Johnston.
Haynilton. — John M'Laren.
Bridge Street — Archd. Binny, Mitchell
Young, Alexr. Scott, Andw. Simpson, Da-
vid uownie, John IneUs, Alexr. M^Ken-
ue, James Carmichae^ John Kirk, James
Peiguson, James Wilkie, David Lyon,
Geo. Cleland, Wm. Fleming, Jas. Foyar,
WiUm. Eelbeck, Wm. Ross, Ebenr. Stalker.
Laurieston. — David Weir, John Punn, John
Braidwood, David Govana.
Lawn Market Edinburgh. — Thomas Cock-
bum, James Lawson, Charles Ritchie, John
Grindlay, John Wilson, John Wyld, Wm. Ro<
manus, Saml. Paterson, J. Thomaon, John
Oourlay, and M. Burn.
Dalkeith. — Peter Leyden, James Mutter,
Thos. Taylor, Wm. Watson.
Calton.— Robert Christie^ William Pbilqi,
James Smith, William Brodie, Peter Huntei,
William Boyd.
Kilmarnock. — John Ronaldso% Tbomas
Boyd of CaprkkbiU, WUlm. Muir, Jas. Cun-
ningham.
Attchterfleiran.— John Todd, John Chal-
jnexs.
J^irkintulloch. — ^William Hay.
Pennycuick. — ^David Blown, James Smith,
|U>bert Smith, John Jackson.
Lennox Town.— John Brown.
Pathhead.— John [Hablow] Halley, Robert
Rait_
Additional Delegations.
Shotts. — [James] William Martin of Moor-
faalL
[Additional Delegations].
Wigton.-^Lord Daer.
Cn^ and Anchor London.— Charles Sin-
clair, Henry York.
London Corresponding Society. *~ Joseph
Gerxald, Maurice Mamrott.
Sheffield ConstituUonal S. — Matthews
Campbell Brown.
Glasgow United Scotsmen.— Robert Pea-
cock, Jchn Stark.
Miltown of Campsie. — Dugald Murray.
Mkl Calder.— Thomas Tweedaie.
Whitburn.— George Waddell.
Tmdestown.-^ohn Gartley.
Canongate^ No. 1 and 2. — ^Wiiliam Camp-
Mi, George Malcolm.
' Newton. — (apology signed I. M.)
Montrose.-— Colin Norrie.
Canoneate,No. 3.-4araes M'Kay, [Walter]
Peter Mo&t, Alex. Plenderleith.
Bkoiu^ton.-— WUlm, Bo&tbioDy
ItoBi Mm Fatrlqr«
Mr. Purvis paid to the general fimdiiom
the Potter-row socie^ l/. If.
The president having constituted the meet-
ing by prayer, vras continued in the chair
unanimous^.
A letter was read from Messrs Jamef
Bish<^ and Alexander Dove, president and
sectry. of the society at Johnstone, contain^
ing thtlr sentiments on public reform, with
an apology for not sendmg delegates, and
concluding with a very just complt. to Tho-
mas Muir, esq.
A similar letter of apolo^ was read frpm
Woodstow, and another nom Mr. Thomas
Watt at Dunbar.
The secretary also read a letter from Mr.
John Chalmers, secy, to a provincial conven-
ti<m held the I5th cunt, at the New Imi in
Fife, containing the resolutions of that meet*
ing, respecting a committee of correspondence,
an address to nis majesty to dismiss the pr^
sent ministry and put an end to the war.£e*
' Mr. Callender moved that the house should
be purged of strangers. — Mr. Binny moved
that a particular part of the house be al-
lotted for visitors, who should be admilleil
upon paying one shilling e^. At lasl i|
was resolved that all present should go as
near the door as possible, and each delegate
answer to bis name in the order of tiie r^«^
After which it was resolved ^at as thie house
was fabundantly rather too] rather too small
ff>r the delegates^ none else should be ad-
mitted.
Messrs. Alex. Lamond, David Leckie from
Musselburgh, Mr. Williams from
Manchester, Mr. Hunter [from]
and Mr. Yetts were allowed to continue as
visitors, and it was resolved that no yisitors
shoidd in future be admitted without giving
in their names to the chair.
A letter was presented and read from Mr.
Stephen Gibson of the Linlithgow Society,
respecting the objects of the assoc'ution.
istMotion.^A motion was presented and
rqad from Mr. William Philp, that <<this
convention adopt some measures for in«
structing the oeople at large in the nature,
principles, ana glorious properties of the
British constitution."— Orderea to lie on the
Uble.
Letter and commission read from Lennox<»
town Campsie. signed bv Mr. D. M'Nab, sect.
Mr. Callenaer moved that this convention
resolve to claim for themselves and their con-
stituents the right of universal suffrage and
annual parliaments.
A letter from a gentleman who does not
wish his name to be mentioned was aftep>
wards read, which the secy, had received,
accompanying a work in mS. entitled ** Re*
view of tl)e Constitution and Government of
Great Britain,'' and dedicated to this general
convention.
Mr. Downie moved to change the general
title of the associations, Oxdeted to lie •&
thetabtet
395J 34 OlEOROE til. Proeeeding$'againH ffOUam SUrvhg [396
^recommeodlng the penodicai work entitled
'the Patriot, and containing many judicious
[observations], (containing some humorods
remarks on the arguments [of] advanced
by the enemies of reform, which were re-
<:eived with great approbation.
Mr. Skirvine next read the printed paper,
contained in the said letter [entitled] address-
ed ta the unemployed artizans, &c. of Man-
chester, suid containing a number of excel-
lent remarks upon the calamities of war,
signed " Sidney."
Mr. Clark moved that a deputatk>n be sent
this nieht to wait on Mr. Muir. Messrs. Don*
glas, Wright, and Clark were appointed ao-
cordin^ly, and Mr. Douglas moved, that a
[oonsoToter]] congratulatory letter be sent to
Mr. Muir, m name of the convention, which
was agreed to, and Messrs. Douglas and the
president were appointed a committee ae-
oordingly.
Mr. Wright moved, that two members be
appointed to dine with Mr. Muir every dav
while the convention sita, at the expense of
the convention, which was unanimously
agreed to.
The depute secretary read a letter from
Henry Shipley, esq, secretaiy to ^e Not-
tingmm delates, with a copy of the printed
resolutions oT their 7th delegated meeting.
, An anonymous letter was afterwards read,*
which the secretary had received, covering a
^ guinea note of the Thistle bank.
* • A motion was made by Mr. Archd. Wright,
that the convention shall each night adioum
before 10 o'clock. Agreed to. if possible.-
A letter was read from the tour united
societies of Ireland.
Mr. Bell moved an address and declaration
of principles. Ordered to lie over.
Mr. Lamg made a simflar motion, which
was also ordered to lie on the table.
Adjourned at a quarter past four, till six
</clock in the evening.
Eodem ite.— Evening utting.— The Rev, Mr.
Jas. Donaldson in the chair.
Hie minutes being read, a motion was
presented and read from Mr. James Mitchell,
of I^iisley, that a petition be presented to his
miOesty to put an end to this ruinous and
deilnictive war.
Mr. Skirving moved, that a committee be
appointed to consider the apoloeies made for
absence and report ; and the following com-
j&ittee were appointed : — Messrs. Buchanan,
Hinchelman, wiih the president and secre^
tarr, and Mr. Clark.
The following gentiemen were admitted
▼isitorSf Mr. Sunuel Brown, from Virginia;
llr. Reid, Mr. Heron (recommended by T.
Muir, esq.), Mr. David Ritchie, Mr. Walter
Davidson, John Bennet, Gavin Malcolm,
and George Malcolni.
Mr. Skirving pres^ted and read a copy of
» letter wrote in name of the eeneral com-
mittee, and signed by Mr. Colander and
himself to|the lord provost, with [the] his lord-
ship's answer. After which he moved, that a
committee be appointed to consider of the
answer.
• Mr. Buchanan and the Rev. Mr. Douglas
thought it merited no replv, not being signed.
Afler some conversation the afiair was remit-
ted to the same committee, to consider the
lord provost's answer and report to the con*
rention.
Mr. Skirving read the thanks of the gene-
ral meeting of the Friends of the People at
Freemasons' Tavern, dated London, dated
London. May, 1793, as returned bv them to
the convention of delegates at Edinburgh, for
their seal and activity m the cause of parlia-
mentanr reform.
He also read a similar letter from Mr.
Thomas Hardy, dated London, 5th October,
1793, and another dated London, S6th Octo-
ber, 1793, respecting the appointment of
Messrs. Margaret and Gerrald.
Mr. Skirvmg next md a letter from Mr.
D. Stuart, secretaiy to the association at
London, dated Frith-street, No. 7. October
16, 1793.
Mr. Binny read a letter from the const,
society at Sheffield, dated 97th May, 1793,
and .signed Willm. Camade, secry. upon the
ot^iects of itfoim in geoend [and paiUcuhrfy
his
signed bv presd. and H. Shipley
secy, ana Mr. Skirving read a copy of hif
answer.
The Rev. Mr. Douglas moved that the
Nottingham resolutions should be reprints^
with such remarks as might be judged proper,
at the expence of the convention, ana circu-
lated. Mr. Newton moved some amend-
ment. Mr. John M^tyre also objected to
the republication. Messrs. Philips, Aitchison,
Wright, Boyd, and several oUiec speakers
supported tlie motion, whereupon the motion
was-agreed to, and the foUgwrng committee
was appointed :—
Messrs. Douglas, Donaldson, from Dun*
dee.— Sands, from Perth. — ^Hart, irom Glas-
gow.— Chalmers, from Fife. — Boyd, fiom
Dumferinline. — Bojd^ from Kilmarnock. —
Blitcbdl, from Paisley. — ^Messrs. Skirving^
Buchanan, Callender, Binny, Clark, Edin-
burgh.^Millar, from Gorbals, and Mr. Hep<^
bum, fh>m £. linton.
Mr. Skirving moved that a [committee] col*
lection be inunediately made for defraying
charges, and repeated at every meeting of tho
convention, which was unanimously asreed
to, and Messrs. Buchanan and Binny Seine
appointed coUectors, there was ooUectea
3/. 6s. 6di. which was delivered to Mr. Skir*
ving, in absence of the treasurer.
Mr. Skirving neit read a letter from the
delegate meeting of the constitutional socie^
at Leeds, dated 84th May, 1793, and signed
by Mr. Charles Hundley, together with a
Srinted copy of their [resolutions] addressB
edanition, and resolutions, signed by Messrs.
Joe, Firtb m Joseph Nuuer, preadt «ad
397]
Jbr Sedition*
^\J^..u JP**®' ^°* colonel ble meeting; that he 'presumed, aU n^eat
„r.."„._„%^ '^^S-?;.????-!!' I bad now assembled from approbation of ths
[Mn Geo. Ross announced that the loldiera
fwere under arms, and that patroles were
£[on3 abroad in the fstreets.] And Mr. Boss
moved that tlie lord provost and magistrates
should be invited to attend our deliMrations
to-morrow.
Mr. John Chalmers moved to present a
petition to his nujesty, to fall upon some
expedient for obtaining a general convention
of the whole fnation, to consider the griev-
ances of the people.
. Mr. Alexander Bremner moved that this
convention draw up a few leading features of
our srievancesy such as corporation lawsy test
[lawj acts, patronage, &c. which are all ini-
mical to the natural rights and liberties of
man, &c.
M?. John Sinclair moved that a subscrip-
tion be set on foot for the benefit of Mr. Muir.
All these motions were ordered to lie on the
table.
The secy
M'Leod, ds
his answer. Whereupon Mr. Caliender mov-
ed that a deputation be appointed to wait
upon colonel M'Leod, to see if he stood to
his principles. Mr. Caliender, the rev. Mr.
Douglas, Mr. Newton, and Mr. Clark were
accorainely appointed to wait on the colonel.
Mr. Afexander Scott moved, that every other
eentleman in the same predicament ought to
ne waited upon, and their reasons for absent-
ing themselves inquired into, and particularly
lord Daer. Mr. Skirving vindicated lord
Daer, but Mr. George B^ss seconded Mr.
Soott*s motion, and msisted that it should
be also extended to Mr. Hugh Bell.
Upon further arguing^ it was agreed to
"postpone [all] these motions till to-morrow.
All the committees were appointed to meet
to-morrow at 10 o'clock, and the general
meeting was [adjourned till] appointed to
meet to-morrow at eleven.— Mr. Callender's
motion to be first discussed.
Mr. Skirvine read a paper, presented by Mr.
Thomas Noble, setting forth, in his own
name, and that of the Potter-row Society, the
necessity of applying for universal suffrage
and annual elections to the King, and not to
the Parliament.
Mr. Clark [brought] gave in averhal re-
port [of] fix>m the committee appointed to
wait on Mr. Muir, that they were very [gra-
[ciously ] cordially received, and that it was his
wish, thiat if this convention wished it, six
could [wait] dine with him, but that it would
be uecessary to apply to the magistrates,
which, aflcr some reasoning to, was agreed
to, inquire first into tlie fact — be done to-
morrow.
The rev. Mr. Donaldson^ the chairman,
afterwards closed the meeting by a prayer,
very well suited to the occasion, as well as to
the times and circumstances; alter which the
convention was adjourned till to-moirow at
eleven.
. :The conventioo appointed the committee
A. D. 1794. [398
of instruction to arrange the various motions^
and report to-morrow morning.
The following entries were written on a se-
parate pafier, and marked on the back No.
3, and is partly another minute of the
preceding:—
Minutes taken in the Convention of the Friends
of the People, which commenced their sit^
tings on the 99th of October, 1793.
*
Mason-lodge Boom, Edinbui^hy
29 Oct 1793.
A great number of persons being assembled
here at noon, conformably to a c^ by public
advertisement, Mr. Skirvmg, the secretary to
the general convention of the Friends of th«
People, rose and ssud. That he found it his
duty, as being the only office-bearer at pre*
sent in the association, to open that respecta^
advertisement in the newspapers, and trans*
mitted also by circular letters,, a copy which
he held in his hand, and which he begged
leave of the assembly now to read to them. ^
Having read the public advertisement, he
requestea some token that they were met in
compliance with the call of the same. Upon
this, all present took off their hati. He tnen
moved, that one of the members prosent be
called to the chair, to preside until the cour
vention was regularly ascertained and con*
firmed. This motion being approved, he
stated, that as the last convention had en»
trusted the general committee of the associa-
tion in Edinburgh with the orderly meetins
of this present convention, he was authorized
to propose M'Intyre, A. M. to their
choice, as pre^dent, dunng the opening of
this present convention, and be was unani*
mously called to the chair.
M'Intyre in the chair.
^ The commissions firom the various societies
to the delegAtes sent up te this convention,
were ordered to be laid on the table, and the
same were all read, and the names of the de«
le^tcs, duly authorized, entered upon ^e
rou.— The roll, containing the names c^ one
hundred and fifty-three delegates, beine called
over, and no objections to it offered, the con-
vention was declared duly assembled; and
the president, upon a recommendation of the
societies in Edinburgh, and which was hear-
tily embraced by all present, rose, and in the
name of the whole, returned thanks to God
for this other opportunity of assembling, to
assert and chum their rights and libelees;
and supplicated his countenanee, protection^
and blessing, on thu convention.
It was moved, in confbimiw to the rules
of the convention, thatii prenoent be chosen
for the first sitting [of the convention!, and
the present chairman was oontimied, by the
unanimous voice oi^tlie coiiventioD.
SaSf} 3^ GEORGE IIL Proceedings agrnntt WiBiam Skiroing [400
KroUofaeongrattidirlory letter to lum, that
the same might be appooTen by the conven-
tion and transmitted. It was also resolved,
that another be drawn up, to be transmitted
to the rev. Mr. Palmer. It was fiirthermore
resolved, that six members, if allowed by the
ma^strates^ should dine with Mr. Muir every
day, during the sitting of the convention ;
and the convention f\u*thermore appointed,
that a poblic subscription should be opened,
for defraying the expense which these gentle*
men are put to,, because of their steady adhe*
rence to the cause of the whole.
A committee was then appointed, for the
purpose of selecting and publishing such parts
of the excellent a^dre^ses and communica>-
tions now and formerly read to the convene
tion, and particularly the printed resolutions
of the Nottingham Delegated Society, as were
calculated for public benefit. It was also re-
solved, that a [subscription] collection for de-
fraying the expense or the same, and of the
meetings, should.be made in the convention
every evening sitting.
The above mentioned committee of in*
structios, was appointed to meet at 10 o'clock
next morning, and to arrange and class the
several motions on the table, previous to the
sitting of the convention which was appoint^
to be held at 11 o'clock. But it was agreed
that the following motion by Mr. Callender,
and recommended by the greater part of the
societies should have the priority, in the order
of tlie business before the House.
Af^er the discussion of some occasional
matters, the meeting was adjourned with
prayer.
1st Sitting of the Convention.— Mintyre in
the chair.
Letters from several societies were read,
which contained apologies for nqt sending up
delegates to this convention, though tney
heartily approved of the meeting, and prayed
for its success. Several of these letters were
firom societies in England, and expressed their
sorrow that the intimation had not reached
them in time to send delegates from so great
E distance ; but assuring the convention of the
earnest desire of all there to co-operate with
tfaem in the firmest union of sentiment and
ynlL The secretary of the society of the
Friends of the People in London informed,
that a general meeting could not at that time
he called, but that some of its members would
attend the convention; and that whatever
the^ did, would certainly be approven by
their society.
The secretary of the Corresponding Society
in London informed, that their society had
met and chosen delegates, as had also the
Constitutional Society; and that others in
England might be expected to do the same.
Addresses firom societies in different places
of Britain and Ireland, and from individuals,
were also read, congratulating the conven-
tion, and earnestly requesting, in particular,
their speedv resolution concerning universal
suffrage and annual elections.
A Dook in manuscript, entitled, " A Re-
view of the Constitution and Government of
Greai Britain,'' and dedicated by the author to
the convention, was presentea by the secre-
tBiy, together with an excellent letter from
the author; as also an anonymous letter,
covering a guinea note of the Thistle bank.
After arranging some internal matters, the
.convention, with a view to proceed to the
husiness for which they had assembled, called
on all those who had motions to propose re-
lative to the same, that they would give them
in to the table of the convention in writing.
At half past four o'clock, the convention
adjourned till six in the evening, and con<-
cluded with prayer.
2d Sitting.
The convention met, conform to adjourn*
roent, and unanimously voted the rev. J. Do-
naldson to the chair.
James Donaldson in the chair. — ^The meeting
was constituted by prayer.
Thb minutes being read, a number of mo-
tions were laid on the table in writing.
The remaining letters and addresses from
societies, &c. were read, and received with
9nuch satisfaction.
Upon the motion of several members, a
deputation was appcdnted to wait on Mr.
Muir iosEhediiUely, to express the sentiments
of the coAvaation, relative to hb present suf*
ierings in thehroommon cause; and a com-
mittee was moreover appointed to dx»w up a
3d. Sittin* of the Convention.-'-The Rev. Mr,
Neil Douglas was called to the chair.
N. Douglas in the chair.
Af\er prayer, Mr. Scott reported the inner
turnkey of the Tolbooth, had strict orders
from the city magistrates, that he should not
admit more than two persons at one time to
visit Mr. Muir, and moved that therefore
more than two need not be sent to dine with
him.
Afler reading the minutes, it was suggestod
by a member, that the collections could not
be expected to do more than defray necessary
expences, and that therefore, a subscription
should be opened for dcfra^ng the expences
of the committee of public mstiuction. This
motion was approven.
A number of motions were now read and
ordered to be classed with general motiona,
to which they chiefly referred ; and theHouse
agreeably to former resolutions, agreed to g^
into the consideration of the motion for uni«
versal suffrage, usd annual delc^tion to par-
liament, as motioned by Alex. Callender and
others.
Mr. Callender, after reading the several mo^
tions and opinions of societies, on the resolu-*
tion proposed by him, rose and urged at con«»
sideiaUe length the adoption of his motion.
iOl)
Jhf Sttutuitt
The time of At sitting beirtg &r spent^ saA
the subject of great importance, t^nile some
of the members were iusl then called away
on the bti^ness of the convention^ it was
agreed that the ftirther consideration of this
IDotion be deferred till the evening sitting,
and that the same be wholly devoted to the
'dJBctissioii of it
A motion for changing the title of the con-
^rention was introducea and supported^ but
objections being offered by several members,
the' discussion gave place to sundry motions
relative to publications, and after some con-
aderation it was resolved, that the whole be
teferred to a committee to be afterwards ap-
pointed for drawing up a public address to
the nation.
A number of copies of the proceeding of
the friends to the hberty.of the press in Lon-
don, were presented by A. Scott, and dis-
tributed gratis.
After prayer adjourned till 6 o'clock in the
evening.
4th Sitting of the Convention. — ^Niel Douglas
in the chair.
AAer prayers the GonventioD proceeded to
tiie flffther consideration of the motions, &c.
on the table relative to the explicit con-
struction to be put on the two original
resolutions of the association, namely, '' A
more equal Bepresentatidn of the People
in Uie Commons House of Parliament, ana a
shorter Duration of Parliamenlaiy Delega-
tion;'' and it Vas proposed that ahhough
there could, and evidently would be, but otte
Molioient in the House that the Explicit
meaning of the first leaolution was universal
Mt^frnge, and of the second, annual eUctians^
and wlX nothing short of these two could be
adequate in the present universally corrupt
state of the nation, for attaining the radical
reform sought by all wise mtt, and that,
'therefore, the speeches would all be on the
same side of the question, yet the vole, upon
the motion before th^ house, should not be
put suddenly, but tlie members should be
permitted, and even requested to declare their
opimon seriatim upon a point of so great
magnitude, and that the vote should thcr^uter
be solemmy put.
A very full discussion accordindy ensued^
in whicb^ not only the natural right of all to
elect their representatives and governors was
clearly illustrated, but also the actual pos-
flession of this rignt, and the right of calling
to account, and ^ven cashiering their gover-
nors was snown to have been possessed oy ail
&9emen in Briton, in the original parliaments
of the nation which were denominated Folke-
motte. The necessity of following up the
principle to the fullest extent, was a&> clearly
establish^,, on the principle of expediency,
as well as of justice; and it was likewise
demonstrated, that the fears bf riot and tu-
fault at popiuar elections, whicli opposition
to the measure held furth as bughbears to
VOL.XXni.
A. D. 17d4. t4M
d^er from making the attempt were inJbcifid<^
ed, and that all such uproars at popular ele^
tions were the work of party spirit and bii-
bery, which by ihe reform desirod, would be
all removed with the causes which produced
them.
^ The members havins spoken fblly on ques-
tion, it was proposed, for the purpose of ex*
pressing the resolution of the convention ill
the most explicit terms, that the motioft
should be passed in the words of ^e di^ of
Richmond oti these points, namely,
Whichlyeing allowed, the quesUon was ac-'
cordingly stated appraoe or nd, when thb
roll being called, and every member prosenft
having voted, it carried neta. cott: Approve.
Whereupon all present rose, 2Jid joining han^
congiatulated each oiher on the resolution of
so important a point, and that with such
entire unanimity.
The secretary thereafter, rfead a letter whicli
had been just then sent in to him, to infbriii
the convention of a most barbarous outrage
committed by William Binny ^e inner jailor,
on two gentlemen who had gone up that eve-
ning to call on Mr. Muir, one of the gentlis-
raen^who had escaped without much blirt,
being present, gave a particular account 6f
the aradr, and the convention requested so-
licitor MoffiU to commence imoiediately a
leeaJL investigation of the matter.
The business being concluded with Orayer,
the meeting was adjourned till 10 o'clock nes^
morning. >
6th Sitting of the Convention.
The delegates convened according to ad-
journment, and elected Alexander Cailender^
esq. to be president.
Alex. Caiknder. in. the chair.
After prayer, the minutes being road and
corrected, upon the motion of several menv-
bers rospectmg the important and indefati-
gble Services of the secretary, the unanimous
anks of the convention were rendered to
him, and a proper return made.
An addross to the public having heea re^
solved by the convention agidn and again,
and never brought forward, it was now moved
by several members, that a scroll of it be
presented beforo the rising of the conventioik
for approbation; but after some conversation^
it was agreed that the delegates should collect
the sense of their constituents upon those
matters on which they should address th6
public, and within a month from this data
trani^mit the rosults to the secretary, and that
he should lay the same before the general
committee in Edinburgh, that from the whole^
the persons employed by them might be able
to draw up some complete publication; and
that the final rovisal bf said publication,
should rest with this committee.
It was now moved^ thst the tonveiitiod
403] S45 Gi^SiGE in* Proceedings againa WiUtam SUroing £404;
the public exf enses, and to be wholly at the
disposal of the convention. — ^Anid the con-
vention enjoined that the first collection o^
this plan be niade^ and remitted to the ixfs^
surer within one month from the bveaking
up of the present meetines of the conventiou.
— They further appointed that a publfc sub-
scription be openea by each society, for re-
ceiymg the assistance of friends to the cause,
who have not an opportunity of countenanQ-
ing it openly. .
Before adjourning^ the thanks of the con-
vention were unanimously rendered to th^
country delegates for attending this conven-
tion 80 numerously, and for their able assis-
tance hitherto in the business.
Concluded with prayer, and' adjourned to
10 o'dock next mornings
9th Sitting of the C«DveiLtion.
should follow up, and confirm the very im-
portant determination of last sitting,, by the
Allowing resolutions.
1st That the primary societies shall declare
publicly and severally, their approbation of
universal sufiirage and annual parliaments,
with their reasons for the same.
9d. That each society shall immediately
enter in their minute book, a new declaration
containing the two original resolutions of the
dissociation, and the explanation now g^ven
to them in the words of the duke of
Richmond, and that the members of each
already admitted, or that may hereafler be
.admitted, shall subscribe the same in testi-
mony of his hearty approbation of them, and
determination to prosecute them.
Both these motions were unanimously
adopted.
Tne several motions for addressing and
petitioning the King, and those for petition-
ing the House of Commons only, which were
;upon the table, were now taken under con-
sideration in slump, as referring only to one
or other side of the same question, when aHer
many words, it passed by a great miyority,
Ithat petitions for reform should be directed
to the House of Conunons.
Concluded with prayer, and adjourned till
6 o'clock.
-0th Sitting of the Convention^-*Ale»uldor
Callender in the chair.
It was unanimously a^eed, thut it be re-
commended to all the societies of the Friends
of the People to follow the example of the
convention, by commencing and concluding
their meetmgs with prayen.
The convention then agreed to express
their unanimous disapprobation of the Slave
Trade, and resolved, tnat the same be mark-
ed in their address to the public, with their
aamest wish for its immediate and total
4ibolition.
Upon a motion to adopt some measures to
bring to light and punishment, the perpe-
trators of oppressive and arbitrary acts, it
was recommended to societies, where the
facts were well substantiated to minute ac-
counts of the same in a book.
The motions relative to finance were now.
taken under consideration, and the conven-
tion in consideration of the debt already in-
curred, and of the impossibility of carrying
on with due eilect, the important business of
the association unanimously resolved, that
previous to the two ordinary meetings of the
convention in the year, each and* every so-
ciety, shall collect mm its members the fol-
lowing sums, and transmit the whole faith-
fully by their delegates, to the next ensuing
convention, — namely^ from every- member, if
b master, tiie sum of one shilling every half
year, and from every servant, if m employ-
neat 6 pence. These, together with the like
^ms psud at the entry qT members,, and all
public donations^ to be the fund for defraying.
dd Day's Sitting.— £(2in(urgA, 30. Oct. 17QJ«
The Rev. Mr. NM Dougllts in tiie chair.
The roll being called, and [prayer] a blessing
implored in name of the assembly by the pie-
sidenty — Mr. Scott reported, that the inner
^'ailor said he had an express order from the
ord prqyost and'ma^strates, not to admit.—
Resolved that [the president] Mr. Chalmers
and Mr. Mealmaker, dine witti Mr. Muir tl^
day.
Ist^ Mr. Ross's Motion was negatived.^—
Minutes read.
9nd.-^[Mr. Skirving] Mr. Gourlay moved,
that in addition to the collection made each
evening, a subscription paper shall be pre-
sented to the company, for the purpose df
raising a sum to defray the expenses of publica-
tions approved of by the society. — Agreed to.
Sd. — [Mr. Callender*s Motions to Petititei
for Universal Sufirage.]
A motion [from] was made by Mr. Miller,
one of the delegates of Glasgow, to draw op
an address to the people, which motion was
ordered to be classed with Messrs. Bell and
Bremner's— Mr. Sands from Perth moved>
that we should agree upon the future proceed*
ings of the friends of reform^ and to expli-
ciUy declare our principles.
Mr. W. Hart moved, tiiat it should be
reconynended to the editors of political pamph.
to print part of them on coarse paper, for
cheapiiess.
Mr. M' Arthur moved, tiiat a public prayer
shoidd be made by the societies for the load's
assistance in the cause of reform.
Mr. Gartiey from Glasgow moved^ that
wej the convention shouQ take [ourj ihtx>
theirjits consideration, the resolutions ca-
tered mto by the eonvention last year^ for
[
40ft]
Jor Stdkitm.
K D. 1794.
IM6
supporting members oppressed bythe arm of
power.
• Mr. Arch. WrighVmovedy tbst 4>y the re*
solution aeltiementy [that] ddesates have
fiberly'to meet and ceasult upon ueir griev-
ances.
Iff. Newton moved^ that fbe convention
when speaking of the constitution, should
drop the word glorious^ and say, '< the purity
of toe <»nstitution/'
flfr. Geo. Meliss Perth ^through the hands
Mr. Rt Sands) moved, that one penny
[per week should be collected' fix>m every
tnember of the societies of the Friends of
'the People, which was classed with other
^motions forfitiance.]
Moved by the rev. Mr. Neil Douelas, to
publish f tbeirj « disapprobation ofjLne slave
tiade. — All these [were] motions were ordered
to lye oa4he table.
Discttsswn of Mr.Callender's motien fer
iinivcrsal suffrage and annual parliaments
was called for. — ^Mr. Callender having spoke
upon it for some time, and [the] reaa several
printed papers [on] to sbownhe necessity of
Its <passuig (he was reminded that it was pro-
per >to postpone what he had further to say,
Wi order to wait on col. M*Leod, and there-
fore) the further discussion^ was delayed till
iBb» eveaiog sitting.
^o. 3d— *Rev. Mr! Donaldson in the chair.
' Messrs Philips, Cha1mers,an4 Gibson's mo-
taoDs, remitted to the authors to be condensed
against next sitting, in-conjunetionwith Mr.
Hinsfaelwood.
' No. 4.-«-Mr. Sownie's motion beiae -read,
Mefsrs. Geo.-RosB, Dowrae, Sands and-seve-
ml .others spoke for the motion — Messrs.
Wright, Aitchieson, Paterson, and several
others spoke against it. — Mr. Skirving moved
iiir a delay of any change 4if the title, till the
piimary societies -shouM ^be consuked, — ^Re-
solved, that the convention shall make no
alteration in the title of the general 4ttsocia-
liooy but leave it to the pfuttcular societies,
to assume what name they please.
' No. 5.^Messrs. Bell aud Bremner's mo-
tions being read^ with the condensed state of
both, and a similar motion by Mr. G. Miller
ixoui Glasgow. — After some argument, and
a motion OTtits being remitted to a commit-
tee, Mr. Donaldson proposed to keep doss to
the main point, and not to interfere with
other grievances. — ^Messrs. Douglas, Skirving,
Coekbuni, Philips and several others spoke
in fitvour of the measure. — ^Messvs Downie
and ^itchison objected to the word corpora-
tioB laws. — [Mr. Callender has] afler which
it mm resolved.to. remit the drawing up of a
iiroper address and declaration of principles,
Sci, to a committee, to be appointed to-morrow.
Messrs Callander^ Douglas and [Mofiat]
Newton, having setMmed from col. M'Leod^
ififorleA viva voce, the polite reception they
kao received from him, and the assurances
he bM gjiy^ them of his steady adheiei^
to4he cause, while the people proceeded in il
constitutional way [but that he had express
|sed ^Ms opinion at the same time, that the
^people were not askin? too much, not ripe
at present' for universal suffrage and annual
[elections, [being] which more than, in his
opinion would be granted, [he] though he
'himself thought they were justly entitled to
'it, and would support them as far as possible^
fso far as the people went in a-consftttutional
[way.]]
7he Rev. Mr. Douglas iu'the chair,
Jt was proposed that Mr. Callender's mo*
tion should now be resumed, but afier some
conversation, being now near four, it was
agreed to adjourn tm six.
A present of a considerable number of
copies of a pamphlet, entitled '' Proceedings
of^jthe Friends of the Liberty of the 'Press,"
was presented by Mr. Alex. Scott^ . and dis«
trihuted gratis. .
Eodem 4i»e.— Evening Sitting.— The Rev. Mr.
Douglasm the cnmr.
The. conuderation of Mr. Cal]ender*s mo«
tion being resumed, Mr. Skirving read an
extract from a pamphlet entitled '' An £ssa^
on Parliamentary Representation, and Magis-
tracies of [Royal] Boroughs Royal, aner
which Mr. Callender delivered a very ani-
mated speech upon the motion, shewing a
varie1;y of reasons for adopting it. — A dele-
gate from Dalkeith having started a questioa,
whether we have a right oy the qonstitutioa
of 1688i«.to claim universal suffrage, and an-'
nual parliaments, or whether we ought to
20 faitbcr back for authority, — Messrs Gour-
tay. Philips, Buchanan, Clark, Wright, Sands,
Kewton, Aitchieson and several delegates
from the country, delivered their sentiments
on this question.
The Chairman having lefl the chur,
A. Callender, esq. [in the chair] was called
to , it. Mr. Douglas then delivered a moat
judicious and sensible speech, upon the ab-
surdity of representing property instead of
men, and thus degrading the dignity jaf our
nature. — ^Messrs. Philips, John Smith, A. Bel),
Donaldson, and several other delegates from
Perth, Dalkeith, &c. spoke on the-same side;
one gentleman observed, that vthe establish-
ing of universal suf&^ge, would be only doing
justice to the.ra^6^ of Scotland, the uoine cf
England, andthe wretches of Ireland.
Mr. Dogglas iii the chair.
In the further discussion of><tbis 'Sub*
ject, aquestion was started, whether soU
diers .or sailors should be allowed to vote,
when Mr. Callender gave it as his decided
opinion, that both classes ought to have a
voioeinthc election of their representatives,
and particularly the latter, who suffer ao
much from impress warrants, which would-
Ai
407 J 84 6E0R6B lit. Proceedings ag^inH IFiWam Skiroing [40ft
)iave no exulenee, were universal sufiagea
established.
iAx. Skirving moved, thai a coUectioi^ be
■Muie for the expense of publishing tracts
upon the subject of reform^ when 51. 6< . Od, \
was collected, which with 5s, received this
fUlemoon, makes S/. 1 Is. o^. 4.
The subject of Mr. CaUender's motion being
fesuraed, the rev. Ht, PonaLdson argued at
considerable lenslth, lA £|vour of [the mo-
[don j ity and with [much] many historical and
scriptural* arguments, as well as several hu-
morous [arsumentsl remarks, supported the
motion. — Messrs. Mealmak^r and Doi^as
9poke on the same side, and said it would be
agreeable to a great majority of their cons^-
tuents.
' Mr. Donaldson proposed to pass the reso-
lution of this meeting, on Mr. Callender's
motion, in the words of the duke of Rich-
flooud^ of which he presented a copy, which
was read by Mr. Skirving.
Mr. Alex. Scott proposed to read a few
ip9Ltraels from [resolutions published by his
E grace! the pUn of parlismentary reform,
ramed and adopted by the Westminster As-
sociation, and introduced into parliament by
his grace, which being agrcea to, he read
them accordingly.
Mr. Skirving [having^ then moved, that the
:rote should be put, which was agreed to, pre-
T^ions to which nowever one of the delegates
fh)m Dalkeith said his colleagues who were ab-
sent, as well as the whole ofhis constituents,
were unanimous for universal suffrage anq
annual elecUons.
At\er some arguments respecting the state
oT the vote, it was stated approve or not; Mr.
Callender having previously agreed to Mr.
Donaldson's amendment : when upon calling
the roll and the votes being marked, it car-
ried nem. con. Approve ; whereupon all pre-
sent congratulated e^ch other by a hearty
shake of the hand.
Mr. Skirving then read a letter from Mr.
lAair covering a copy of a letter to the lord
provost, setting forth the insolent abuse and
outrage comofuUed by the inner jailor, Wm.
tinny upon [two members of the convention,
[Messrs. Charles Bi^ce and] two gentlemen
who had gone up to visit him upon necessary,
and demanding redress from the magistrates.
Upon this Mr. Archibald Binny moved that a
subscription be immediately set on foot to
prosecute the said William Binny. [But aft]
This wassecondedby severalmembers^ut aAer
some argument it was thou^lH proper to de-
lay all proceedings io this afiair till to-morrow.
Mr. Douiglas tnen closed the business with
1^ prayer suCted to the occasion, and adjourned
the meeting till to-morrow at 10.
Edinburgh, S\^ October, OS.
Alexr. Callender, esq. in the chair.
.fiPheiev. Mr. Doufflas having invoked the
bfessingof the Almigntyupon ourproceedings^
the minuiee w^^mlandceoectedyMessn.
Vidcers, "^odd, Blair and M' Leay, and Adam
Wilson, firom Psdsley were admitted, visitors.
Mr. Buchanan moved a vule of thanks to Mr.
Skirving for his very great and important e&>
ertjons in the cause of refom^ whiich wi4
unanimously agreed to. [Mr. Skirvinff read
several pages fiom the nuainess of the ad-
]dress to the D. Saml. public beiiur moved|
'Johnston's History of the Masna Cnarta.-—
"Mr. Skirving's motion being t^en into wm%
'sideration, several country members wished
thai a scroll ojf the addresa^
The business of the address to the publio
being moved by Mr. Mealmaker, and a wish
expressed fov him. and several other eouatr|i
delegates, that a scroll of it should be diawa
HB l^ore they go out of town^ it was resolved
after arguing (upon] at some It ogth, upon
1^ motion by Mr. Paieraon, seconded and
amended bv Messrs. Wright and Aitehison.
that a moQfth firom thb dale should be allowed
to the sodetiea in the country to commi
cate their ideas up<m this subject to theseey.to
be kid before the £din» monthly committee al
their meeting on the tst Thursday in De-
cember, to whom the final revisal oi the ad«
dress to be drawn up by the oommittee is
rcommitted] entrusted. — Mr. Skirving read
Srom Dr. Saml. Johnston's History of tho
Magna Charta, a chapter concerning tiie fin%
founder of the yearly foUynotte.
Mr. Skirving made the following [The se-
[cretary's] raotwns Fbeing read] via. 1. That
the convention shall follow up the unanimoos
resolution for univenal suffiage and aami^
parliaments, by recommending to their so-
cieties to declare pabhdy and sevendly tfaei?
approbation with their reasons.: and 9dlj
that each society be called ufoa to draw up a>
new declaratbn containing the two ori^al
resolutions of the association a»now explained
and according to the expUnation given by the
duke of Bichmond, and to require each mem*
ber alieady admitted, or to be admitted to
subscribe the same. These motions, after a
shod coBversakion, were unanimously agieed
to.
The different motions to address the king
being read, Mr. Mealmaker's waswitiidrawn,
vmI Mr. Skirving moved, that all these mo-
tions be compresMd into the simple questioB,
Whether we shall address the Icing or the
House of Commons. Upon this question va-
rious opinions wese delivered, some contend-'
ing that to petition the king was illegal, as
desiring one branch, of the legislature to en«
csoach on the j»rivilege of the others. Others
that it was stnctly legal to petition the king
to recommend il^ or at least to lay it before
the parliament to take such a measure under
consideratioB.
Messrs. Wardlaw, Scott, Donaldson, Ait-
duson, Douglas, Wright, Geo, Ross, Bocha*
nan, Callender, Johnston, Gourlay, [for the]
spoke against addressing the king, and Messrdi.
skirving, Chalmers, John lAing, and[several];
one or two oountiy delegates pled for the-
409] Jhr Snitftofi.
measure. [CapUun Johnstofi having come
in as a naUorytho ler. Mr. Donaldson mev^d
that the capteia'a opinion should be asked
«pon the questioB ; and tbe coiiTenkion hav-
[ii^ v^pon a inolion fay the dep. secy, waved
[the legulaliofi •xdiateg viaitova from $peak*
iDgyCapi. JofaDstOQ ejipressed his sense of
the compte. paid hioi) and assured them of
[the continwance el bis steady seal in the
^€aiise of refornit ^^ assigned a very satis-
'ftctoxy leasoQ lor not iSkkig any hand at
present in the business before ibem].
The debate beiae resume^ Mr. Wright
moved thai the different soaeties should be
left to adopt what measures they pkassed^ and
to petition either king or parriftment.*^Mr.
Geo. Roes propeeed to petition the H. of C.
and at th^ same time to address the king to
diwolve Ihe pairtiament-— Mr. Buchanan ob-
Jectod to any address of this kind to the kingi
as tending to increase the royal iniuence :
]fo Pkteison and Mr. Scott and Mr. Sands,
laofwaed that this eeavenllon shovld reoom-
mcflid it to the aocieties at large to petition
tJbeU. ofC. as their [only] representatives,
either really or virtual Fy. Mr. Chalmers io-
vstad te petitbn the kin^, and said that his
^constitncnts were determined that they woald
not aeain petition the House of Commona. —
Mr. Skirving said that upon our present plan
at would pmaps not ^ a single member
to present it.
[Captain Johnston at last rose and nude a
[short speech strongly recommending unani-
[mity, but expressing it as his deemed opi-
[nion that it was both illegal and improper to
petition the king, and th^ such a step would
(actually ruin the cauuX
• The rev. Mr. Donaldson d^vered a con-
•ciliatory speech, neplete with humour, but
•eeommendittg it to leave the aocieties to do
9s they may^ge proper.
[Mr. Skinrmg was sorry so serkMS a subject
[should he treated m a ludknmt metiner].
Mr. William Urquhart objected to petition-
ing the king as a deviation from our original
principles and declarations, and proposeopul*
ting tne question to a vote.
Mr. Scott took notice that the Fife dele-
flttes were not unanimous for addressing ti^
king;
A delegate from Fife expressed his disap-
fKobation of petitioning the king, and sud his
constituents would as soon petition the pope.
A Glasgow defegaile expressed similar sen-
j^ments [in name of his constttuents] in his
own name, [and] Mr. Jo^n Laing withdrenr
his motion.
Mr. Douglas in the chair^
Mr. Callender having left the chair, recom-
mended imanimity in a very amm«ted speech.
'-^Mr. from Fife, withdrew bis [bpi-
^ionl opposition. Mr. Chalmers also wi«i-
drew nis opposition, and begged that the mi-
mite of his constituents sheuM be returned
witb a proper official reoommendati^ii. The
A. D. 1794.
[410
[society] convention then resolved to petition
the H. of C. as the only competent branch
of the legislature to be applied to in cases of
reform, and in the representation. — ^Mr. John
M*Intyre congratulated the meeting o&the
unanimous decision of this debate on this
very important question.
Mr. Donaldson and Mr. Mitchell from
Paisley were appointed to dine with Mr. Muir.
— ^Adjourned at a quarter past 4 till 6.
Modem die, — ^Evening sitting.
Alexander Callender, esq. in the chair.
The minutes beiog read and cortected, the
thanks of the convention were g^ven to Mr«
Skin'iog from the chair, for Ins integrity and
services.
Mr. M' Arthur's motion respecting prayers
was unanimously agreed to.
Mr. Scott's motion as to lord Daer, and Mr.
Ross's as to H. Bell with-drawn.
The rev. Mr. Douglas's motion, to [exp] ex-
pnMs our disapprobation of the slav^ trade,
was unanimously agreed to; and it wasre^
8olve<i thutthis dregful and infernal traffick
should be taken particular notice of in the
Address to the Public, and the unanimous
wish of the convention, for its immediate and
total ab(^tioni expressed in stronar temis.
Mr. M'Cubbin's motion [amenned and a]
to recommend to the comauttee appointed to
dmw up a petition to paxliatoent, to obviate
the ol^ctsons made agamst receiving petitions
for reform, was unammously agreed to ^er
being amended as above.
Mr. Ross's motion.«-tbat in order to bring
to light and to punisn the perpetmtors of op*
pression and arbitrary acts, a person in every
town sh^M be appointed a suardiaa to dis-
cover, publish, and prosecnte all such proceed-
ings,— being read, it was agreed that [in
[cases] where the facts are welTsubstanttated,
societies should minute an account of them
in a book. Mr. Binny's motion to print the
names of the members withdrawn, but re»
solved, that those who haVe withdrawn from
the association shall be waited on, and their
proportion of exj^ses demanded.
[Mr. Sand's motion to recommend it to the
[societies to lay a penny per week on each
member. — ^Agreed to.
[Mr. Stephen Gibson's motion as to conoes-
[pondence, public instruction and finance.
[Mr. A. Buchanan moved a committee of
[finance.
[Rev. Mr. Donaldson proposed 5«. to be
[paid by each delegate.
[Mr. Buchanan proposed that the societies
[should pay [in] 10s. 6d. each.
[Mr. Paterson [proposed] moved one shillfi'.
Eto be paid by each master, and 6d. from each
person who was not a master].
Bftr. Skinring moved, that ererr member in
the assecialion, if a sernm^ and in empky^i
ment, shall be [requested} raquired to m^ Ad.
toimm d^fiaying the public idmi^} debt;
411] 34 GEORGE Ilf* Proceedings i^tOnH WtOiam SUrving [4t!}
if not a servant. Is. at least. That levety new
member to be sulraitted shall pay one ot these
sums; and that this contribution be levied
two times in the year, previous to every con-
vention, and sent up with the several dele-
gates, and paid into the committee of general
nnance. Carried imanimously, after some de*
bate, with this [proviso that amendment sue-
[gesUd by Mr. B.] proviso thaf the first col-
lection shall be remitted within the course of
the month.
Messrs. {[Binnyl Grourlay and G. Ross be-
ing appointed collectors for this night, the
sum otSL 13s. 9d, was collected, which, with
ts',6d, of overplus at dinner tins afbemoon,
makes in all 8/. 16s. Sd.
[Mr. [M«fiat] Sands reported, that the
lord provost had expressed his regret, that
any [obstruction should] insult should have
[been offered to any member of the conven-
'tion, or any friend of Mr. Muir's. That he
sympathise much with Mr. Muir, and ajgreed
)that six members of the convention sEoiild
'be allow^ed to dine with him; whereupon
|Mr. Wright moved, that the thanks of the
convention should be returned to the lord
provost, which was unanimously agreed to ;
out a member afterwards objecting, a warm
[debate ensued, which occupied much^ime;
and the question at last being put to the
vote, and the roll called, it carried bv a
'great majonty f to return thanks to] the lord
[provost and] The following ^ntlemen were
appointed to [dine with — wait on his lordp.]
to dine with Mr. Muir to-morrow, viz. Mr.
[Boyd, firom Dunfermline! Mr. Henchelwood,
Mr. Hepburn, Mr. Campoell, Mr. Mitchell,
Strathn. Mr. Philip, Dumfrs. Mr.CaUander,
P.
The rev. Mr. Donaldson read the scroll of
a congratulatory letter [of thanks] drawn up
by him and Mr. Douglas, to be presented to
Mr. Muir, which l^ing read, paragraph,
[passed was with] after a very [littl^ tew
amendments, met the approbation of all pre-
sent
Resolved also, to send a similar letter of
congratulation to Mr. [Muif] Palmer [mo-
[tiOn,] — Mr. Skirving moved, that the thanks
to the] of this convention be given to the
country delegates in general, and particularly
to the rev. Messrs. Donaldson and Douglas,
for their attendance on this occasion, wnich
was done accordingly, and suitable returns
liiade. The chairman concluded the buaness
of the evening vrith a prayer, suited to the
importance of the great and glorious cause we
are engaged in.
Edinburgh^ 1 Nov, 1793.
Mr. John Milne, from Newton, near Melrose,
in the chair. — Morning Sitting.
The secretary read the minutes of last sit-
ting. Mr. Downie presented a string of reso-
lutions for discussion, whea it was agreed,
that the time of the convention was too far
gone for these resolutions to have pcoper ef-
fect now, but agreed that they should be read
over at the opening of the evening sitting,
and lye on the table till next convention.
Mr. Hepburn moved, that the thanfks ef
the convention should be nven to Mr. Dar,
Clark, the victim of the oay, for his manly
exertions in the cause of reform. — Agreed -to.
It was tlien agreed to come to a macussion
of the mo^n presented by Mr. Jas. Mitcbell,
for petitioniag the kins against the war. —
^Mr. MitcbeH drew a lively picture of the
poor in support of the motion ; he said, that
commerce had been entirely knocked in the
'head by this war, and recoamended to the
convention, and every part of the kingdom
to petition agmntt «f].
After several animated speeches, breathing
the true spirit of benevolence and Christiam-
tv, it was unanimously agreed, to call upon
the people -of 6cotland to unite, as one man,
to petition the kine against the war.
Rev. Mr. Donaldson moved, that it should
be the secvetary's buaness to recommend to
the various societies, to send up those gen-
tlemen as delates, who are most able for
tiiat station. — Agreed.
Mr. Skirvkig moved, that the next conven-
tion should meet on the last Tuesday of
April — Resolved, and adjourned till the even-
ing.
Motion by Mr. Wright, respecting the right
of the people to choose delegates.— Agreed to^
fi&n, con*
Evening Sitting. — Eodem die.
Mr. Walter Hart, from Glasgow, in the chair*
The minutes being read, Mr. Gourlay's mo-
tion for recommendmg provincial assemblies
to be held, was discussed ; when it was re-
solved to recommend it to societies in the
country, to hold frequent intercourse with
each other, and to meet at stated periods for
that purpose; and also to establish societies
in those places where there are known to be
friends of reform; and likewise, in the into*
rim, to send frequent deputations to eaetk
other.
Mr. Skirving read a printed copy of his cir-
cular letter, and proposed to publish some-
thing regularl}' once a month, on the reform
business. — ^Resolved unanimously, to recom*
mend this plan to the encouragement of die
societies in the country, that ^bey may write
Mr. Skirving, withia the month, how many co-
pies they [may] intend to take.
Mr. Mealmaker's motion of thanks to Mr.
Scott unanimously agreed to, and a proper
return made by Mr, Scott. Mr. Richard
Younger moved to support the Gazetteer.
Resolved, to recommend to the F. of tke
P. that they ought to do all in their power to
support that paper in such manner as Mr.-
Scott may require.
A collection being made, il, 3«. 4d. was ooU
lected, which, with fU. iOd. balance of rcc-»
koning, is 3/. St. 2d,
Mr. Calleoder ioforip^ the me^tingy of
k
41^
ii*
for SudUiott.
A. D. 1791..
[414
(he leoepUon he had met with from the lord
pPOTOSt.
Mr. Sinclair's motion for a subscription f4>r
Messrs. Muir and Palmer. Mr. Skirvix^
xnoved an amendment, which was miani-
mously agreed to.
Mr. Callender moved the thanks of the
coBventJon to Mr. Wharton and his adherents,
for the glorious appearance they made^ on the
isubjcct of the constitution, on the 1st of June.
Seconded by the Dep. Secretaiy, and unani-
mously a^eed to.
Mr. Skuring moved the thanks of the con-
vention to Colonel M'Leod, which was also
seconded by A. A. and imanimously agreed
to.
Mr. Skirving moved^ that this convention
express its ament desire to cultivate a more
close union with the societies in England,
-wluich was likewise unanimouslv aereeif to.
Mr. M'Intyre moved the thaxucs of the
convention to Mr. Callender* Agreed to,
nem, con.
Mr. Binny moved a vote o£ censure on the
conduct of the lord provost. Withdrawn.
Resolved to support Mr. Clark.
Resolved, that Mr. Skirving should dine
with Mr. Muir to-monow, and take any friend
with him.
Mr. Callender moved the thanks of the
convention to the secretary and^edeputc-
sccretary, which were unanimously agreed
to; and the same compensation as formerly
"was voted him for his trouble, with something
snore when the funds can afford it.
The MS. pamphlet, entitled, << A Review
of the British Constitution,'' was remitted,
for want of time, to the consideration of the
Edinburgh monthly committee, and the se-
cretary was empowered to write the author. —
Closed by prayei — J. M'lntyre.^
Ad<litiotial Delegates
From Stirling, in favour of Robert For-
rester [tl. 2«. oJ.].
Darwell— John Cleland 1/. U. Od.
Dundee — Geo. Ross.
linlithgow — Stephen Gibson.
Calton— Peter Hunter, Wm. Boyd«
Strathaven — James Wilson.
Hamilton— Wm.Uaddow, James Hamilton.
EddlestoD— Thomas Noble.
Dundee, Newburgh — ^Apologies.
Pathhead— Robert Rait, John Halley.
Musselburgh— John Niven, Dun€an[Clark]
Charles.
Dundee — Geo. Mealmaker.
Fenwick & Kilmaurs — Robert Muir.
Forfar— Patrick Miln.
Selkirk — ^William Johnston.
Kov. 25. Dunfermline— Peter Reid.
Lmlithgow — George Brockley.
Edinhirgh, 6 Novem. 1793.
Oeoeral committee. — Citizen Urquhart in the
chair.
It was [Geo. Ro0s] moved, that stmngers,
who often attended the societies, and who
never came forward to subscribe the books,
should be called in question, and asked their
reasons. [Supported by Messrs. Scott and
[Benny, and M'Leish ; opposed by Messrs.
Laing Wylde, &c.] It was agreed for the
secretary to go round, and collect the names
of the strangers.
Citizen Hamilton Rowan, Simon Butler,
from Ireland— Margarott, Sinclair, and Ge*>
raid, from London — were introduced, and re-
ceived with acclamations. The secretary
read the minutes of last committee.
The secretary stated,. that inconsequence
of the delegates from London having arrived
too late for the convention, he, wiui advice^
had recalled the delegates from the country,
and appointed the 19th of [next] this month
to be the first day of meeting.
Citizen Margarott, from £)ndon, stated to
the committee, that 600 constables attended
their meeting: in London, in order to appre-
hend them when sending delczates to this
country : They overcame that obstacle. But
a journey of 400 miles is not a journey of a
moment. They arrived the day after tne con-
vention,, hoped that the recallm|; the dele-
gates would strike terror [into] m our ene-
mies ; and while we behaved accordins to the
laws of the country, we did not neea to be
afraid.
Citizen Buchanan moved, that the dele*
gates from London should tell us the situation
of their society.
Citizen Margaret answered, that the socie-
ties in London were very numerous, though
sometimes fluctuating. In some parts of
England whole towns are reformers. Shef-
field and invirons there 50,000. In Norwich
there are 30 societies in one. If we could get
a convention of England and Scotland called,
we might represent 6 or 7 hundred thousana
males, which is a majority of all the aduUs
in the kingdom, and ministry would not dare
to refuse our rights.
C/itizen Butler said, he did not know how
far he was at liberty to say any thing as he
was not a delegate, out he would give an ac-
count of Ireland : the executive part of the
government were almost omnipotent^ — The
landed interest is almost aristocratic — ^The
manufacturer idle, — ^last parliament was ex-
Eectedto have given Ireland emancipation,
owever that prospect was fiatteriujg, a few
weeks changed the scene. An infamous
coalition took place between the opposition
and ministry. — The Catholics retired witl]^
what they had got. No longer opposed by
them, the government turned their oppressive
measures against the friends of reform^ — the
United Irishmen were prosecuted, he himself
had experienced 6 months imprisonment.
Belfast was declared to be in a state of rebel-
lion ; tho' freedom was not cried up in the
streets, yet it dwelt in almost evei^ heart,
universal emancipation was the measure for
which he was an advocate. All that he knew
415] 34 GEORGE III. Proa
of this coiuilry was, that the first day his form
[he] was in Edmhurgh, he was arrested for
nothing that he knew exceptit was for beinsso
wickedas to come here. In Scotland they
yet met in convention. — ^In Ireland the par-
Itament bad enacted laws against it. Wnen
a law like that sliould take place here, he
was afraid freedom would vanish. [If you
{wish to guard agfdnst slavery—]
Mr. Cateider sud, that he noped those
tiiat would pass such an act of oarliamenty
should be forced to eat it, and noped that
Scotland and England should not submit to it
Citizen Gerrald said, that he came here arm-
ed wHh the power of delegation. If oor
fteighbour^ house is on fire the creater should
ht oat vigilance to prevent the name seizins
our own. A parchment piece of justice haa
been presented in Ireland, he hopes that if
J9ver it was passed here, we ^lould throw it
119 the face of our oppressors. Eveiy thing
the people had gained had been thro' con^
ventions, the revolution was the consequence
of 1^ omvention. The revolution established
^at trust abased -was revocable, the revolu-
tion excluded all placemen and pensioners; —
do we enjoy any benefit from that act? It
mad^ ministers responnble ; — how many bad
ministers have we seen go down to the grave
91 ]^eace, and honoured with aH the <Hgnitics
a kmg can confer ? [hoped that] union would
carry our principles mto execution. A citi^n '
^N>m Ireland told you, that as soon^ as the
Silarm bell was rung, the opposition joined the
minister, fiarty is ever a bira of prey and the
people their banquet.
Tne secretary read the cimilar letter he
intended to send to the delegates.
Citizen [Mr.] Soott read a letter addressed
10 the secretary apprhving his conduct in call-
cAs the new convention.
Mr. Buchanan advised the secretary to add
toUie circular letter to the delegates, that
they should make up their minds upon what
addiress they would give to the public.
The secretary stated to die meeting that an
order had come down for removing tne con-
irlcts, but to what place or when it was not
known, he tiiought that it [would] was meant
to raise a tumuh, by which [it] our conven-
tion might be stop^M^. He therefore read a
liand^biTl to be distributed among the people
to keep them on their guard.
Mr. Wright, Mr. Aitchison, and Mr. Scott,
were against the motioiy.
Mr. ^cott said that Mr. Muir suffered with
^ magnanimity that required our admiration ;
he begged to call their attention to a motion
which was made for a subscription for Mr.
Muir. He is suffered in our cause, we ow^
him a mark of our esteem ; he hoped the
greatest of all ties, gratitude, would^stimulate
our exertions.
The following committee is appointed to
[put] ciRTy into effect a subscription for citi-
tena Muir and Pahner, Mr. Skirving, Binny,
CaUendcr, Mofiat, UTquliart and Scott.
tigjoinst
[416
Adtben tnember mowd that we should
approve of the delegation from London and
testify our readiness to co-operate with them
in our gre^t undertakmg.
A coUection was drawn for the use of the
joneeting, 1/. was [drawn] collected^
[The chair! The thanks of the meeting was
£iven to the delegates firom London ana Ire-
land.
Citizen Sinclair sud that they did not
come here for thanks, but to merit them. He
said that it was only unanimity that could
ensiu« our success, let us then persevere.
Mr. HaoHlton Rowan said^ that
The chairman returned in a most sensible
and animated speech the thanks of the con-
vention to the deleptes firom £ngland and
the friends from Ireland; he said may a sense
of duty pervade the breast of every man, not
the distinction of Scotsman or EneOshman,
but as men exert all our abilities in tne great
cause.
Citizen Butier said, that the thanks of the
virtuous must always be felt by the firiends of
freedom.
Citizen Margalot did not rise as a delegate
from London, to express his acknowleqge-
ment of thai^s, but wished to know was tne
nature of the present society.— The secretary
gave the information.
It was moved am! agreed to that the hon.
Simon Butler and A. Hamilton Rowan should
be admitted.
Citizen Butler said that he had, in his own
society, taken a test to be steady in the cause
of reform, [he sai] it was a test engraved on
bis heart, and which he would carry to his
grave.
It was agreed that the powers of the dele-
gates of our convention continues until ano-
ther convention is called.
1st Bay's Sitting.— BrfiH., 19 tfav^ 1795.
Gekeral ComVentioh op Deleoates.
Mr. Walter Hart from Glasgow was called
to the chair 4 — ^The roll being called i[addi-
[tional d1 new commissions read, and addi-
tional delegates added to the list.
Mr. Margarot moved, that a committee be
appointed to draw up rules for the internal
government of the convention which was
seconded lind Agreed to. It was also resolved
af^r some argument upon this subject [that
[resolved] timt the tickets of admiaaion shall
4173
f&r Sedition*
A. D. Il9is
[418
be d^f ABd to the delegates to-morrow with
their names inscribed on them by the secre-^
tanr.
Ifr. Skirving moved that a committee be
appointed to draw up the address to the pub*
lie formerly resohreo on by the convention.
• The followine committee was appointed to
draw up the rules for internal re^mtion, viz.
Mr. Marearoty Mr. Brown, lord Daer, Mr. J.
C3arky Mr. [Hart] Sands, A. Callender, esq.
Mr. Gartley, Mr. Wm. Muir, Mr. Wm. Skir-
vinff.
Mr. Sinclair moved, that lord Daer's reso-
lutions presented to the first general conven-
tion be remitted to that committee^ which
was amed to. Mr. Gourlay moved that lord
Daer be called to the chair, which was se-
conded by the depute secretary, but op|>osed
by citizen Daer niraself, as well as citizens
Uerald and [Brown] Sinclair as savouring too
much of a spirit of [complimenting the] aris-
tocracy ; whereupon it was unanimously re-
solved to call Mr. Callender to the chair.
The meeting being constituted by prayer,
and the whole of the last minutes read, the
secretaiy [moved] repeated his motion, that a
committee be appointed to draw up the ad*
dreaa to the public.
' Lord Daer expressed his disapprobation of
trusting too much of the business of the con-
vention to committees. Mr. Brown from
Sheffield urged many arguments upon the
necessity of appointing committees on parti-
cular business.
• Mr. Margarott moved, that previous to pub-
lishing an address to the pubhc, a committee
be fiirtbwith appointed to consider the means,
and draw up the outlines of a plan of general
imion, [which] and corporation between the
two nations in their constitutional pursuit,
[which was unafy. agreed to] of a thorough
nariiamentary reform, which was unanimous-
ly Meed to.
• Mr. Margarot also moved, that tlie con-
vention sit but once a day, and that the eve-
nings be allotted to committees. A member
from Glasgow proposed as an amendment,
that the convention should sit in the evening,
and the committees in the forenoon.
• Lord Daer ovserved, that it would be pro-
per to avoid an aristocratical dependence on
committees, and to delay appointing of com-
mittees, till the mode of appointing them
was [adopted] agreed upo».
Bawlved, that committees shall meet in
the forenoon, and the ccmventioBy at five in
the afternoon.
. Mr. Wright moved, that the committee
appmnted to meet tomorrow, should be an
€>pen committee.
■• Mr. Brown fiom Sheffield, objected to it,
9S tending to obstruct the business of the
coflsmittee.
' Lord' Daer proposed, that in this particular
case, the past practice should be adhered to.
Mr. Bitmn replied, and several other
speakers, when it was iinanimously resolved.
VOL. XXIU.
thaft [all the] it should be a 'Shut committee.
Resolved, that all the delegates from Eng-
land, be members of this committee.
The depute secretary moved, 1st, That it
be enacted as a standing law, of this, and all
future conventions, that no member of [this
or] any [future] convention, shall be called
to the chair [twice during] above once during
the different sittings of [the] any genera
convention ;— and, Sdly, That no deieeaie
called upon by public acclamation or shew
of hands, shall upon any pretence refuse to
take the chair.
The meeting being closed by prayer, was
a^ourned till to-morrow ajflernoon at 5.
Second day's Sitting, 5 o'clock in the evening.'
— Alex. Callender in the chair.
This sitting commenced with delivering
tickets to the members of the convention;
The foUowios visitors were admitted, capt.
John [Gibson] Fisher, [Wm. Smeall,] from'
Glasgow, and Wm. Smeall, from Pennicuick;
John Wilson, from New Town Society; D.
Hutchison, from Kinross; D. Grieve,. from
Inverkeithing; D.Forest, and Messrs. Thom-
son and Paterson, from Stirling; R. Ogle,
Mr. Drummond, and Mr. Ramsay, from
Dumfries; James M'Kain, from the Opera-
tive Society, MelrOse; Simon Corfor, Chas.
McLaren, and Wiltiam Brown [Adam.]
Mr. William Watson, from the Dalkeith
Society, paid one guinea to the general fund.
The convention being- constituted by prayer^
and the minutes [bein^] read, and some
fi;eneral observations made, the secretary read
fthe following] two letters, one from Richd.
Davidson, secty..to the constl. society at
Leeds, apologizing for not sending delegates
to the convention, and another Tone] from
Newton, signed John Milne [D®.] offering a
similar apology.
Mr. Jackson, from Pennycuick, in the chair.
Lord Daer gave in the report of the com- '
mittee who sat this forenoon on the business
referred to them.
Mr. William Johnson, [delegate] from Sel-
kirk, paid Mr. Skirving one guinea towards
the general expence, in name of that society.
Mr. Scott moved, that the rule in the re-
port respecting the appointment of tliree
minute takers, should be first discussed,
lord Daer, [proposed to take] after explain-
ing what was meant by the term minute
takers, proposed to take up the question re-
specting the divisions first.
Mr. Sinny objected to the plan of divisions,
as tending to lose time instead of saving it.
Resolved by a shew of hands to consider
this question first. Lord Daer explained the
necessity and utility of such divisions, re-
pelled the objections that might be made
against the plan, and shewed tiiat it entirely
set aside the difficulty that had been started .
against the committee sitting in the forenoon,
as tending to throw the majority of the con-
2 £
419J 84 GEORGB UI. Procetdi^t against mOiam SUmag
C4S0
vention idle. U« also shevi^ed that this pLutk
would tend, both to repress the forward, and
to encourage the diffiaent, and would con*-
tribute Ikiuch to the in^rovement and instruc-
tion of all the members of the convention, by
making the members acquainted with eaca
other, and thus giving to many, good ideas
vhich. might be started in these small divi-
sions, that thro' modesty would nevo: be
brought forward in large meetings.
-. Mr. Brown reminded lord Daer, that one
iBRSonwhy the cpomiitftee iapproved of the
division plan, was that it pointed out the best
■mn3 of JtppothtSo^ cemmittJe^.
Mr. M'Intyre, objected to the plan of di«
visions, and recommended, rather to adopt
the genl. assblys. method^ [P^] of overtures,
as preferable.
^ Citizen Gerald, vindicated the i^iia of di-
visions, as tending to [prepare] enable the
omvention to make up their minds uiM>n the
business to come before them.
Mr. Buchanan proposed only 3 divisions,
consisting of [at] jarjB;e numbers.
Mr. Margaret vindicated the plan, as tend-
ing, to shorten the business of the convention ;
he insisted that the fiimiliar intercourse that
woukl take place in these divisions, would
be the chief juse of them.
. ' Mr. Geo. B.0S8 objected to the divisions^ as
tending to give influence to leaders.
A. member from Paisley, said this could
not happen, as the divisions "were to be
chosen by lot
Mr. Wright [and A. Aitchison,] agreed
with Mr. Buchanan, in appointing more
[number] numerous divisions, and said that
S5 ought to be the number.
A member having
Mr. Sinclair shewed the necessity and im-
portance of the plan of organization, and in-
sisted that the divisions were necessary, and
that the loss of a day or two ought to be of
no consideration, compared with the magni-
tude of the object.
Mr. Marmot promised in name of himself
and his colleagues from England, that they
«^mild grudge no time to execute with pro-
priety the business they were come upon.
Lord Daer vindicated the division plan, as
tending to prevent, that otherwise unavoid-
able assumption of power which took place
at the first convention, and which unavoid-
ably takes place at all public meetings.
Mr. Brown from Sheffield, rose to remove
any remaining objections that might be made
against the plan; he urged that the grand
iK>iht in raising a good superstructure, was to
lay a good foundation, to do which, ilo time
should be grudged, and shewed the great
utility of the plan in the nomination of com«
iailt^e&
Mr. Jo. Clark, expressed his approbation
of the plan, but started a difficulty about the
, mode of executing it
Mr. Skirving said, that the easiest and
nsadiest mode was for every del^ate to give
in his itcket, and when mixed in % bat or the
like, to take them out as they lay. . .
Mr. Callender moved the question, divide
or notf When it carried unammously in ^e
affirmative.
hotd Daer called the attention of the noieet*
ing to tike ouestion, as to the number in each
division, whether 15, or 20.
. Dept. secretary proposed !I5 as the num-
ber,
Mr. Scott pled for this measure.
Mr. Brown pled that 15 was a suffident
number, [and repeated lord Daer'saMs,]
^Resolved by a great majority, that [15
[shall be] that the number of each division "-
shall be about 15, and that J 1 o^clock shall be
the hour of meeting.
Lord Daer proposed aa the best mode of
division that it be done by lot. Agreed to
unanimously.
Lord Daer proposed as the period of le*
newal, once a weeK.--Agreed to nem, ctm»
He -then proposed that the best mode ot
dividing by lot wOuld be to collect the tickets
immediately, and then mingle and draw them
prolnispuously, and set down the namea
according as they shall be drawn« — ^Agreed to
unanimously, and M[ess]r. Callender having
collected the tickets they were drawn as
follows 5- -
J St Division. — ^Jas. Dun, Jas, Garlley, Wm*
Farquharson, John Stark, Alex. Ailciueson,
John Braid wood, John Muir, Tho, Codcbum,
Robt. Forrester, James Mutter, Kobt Cb^jstiei
Jdhn Buchanai^ Geo. Malcolm, Robt Muir,
James Smith.
Snd Division.--sJobn Taylor, Heniy Rait,
Jas. Cunningham, Jas. Tweedie, David
Gowans, Jas. Boyd, Geo. Cottdn, Geo, Milne,
D. Taylor, Wm. PhOp, John .Thomson, A.
Knox, Walter Hart, John Cleland, David
Bertie, John Gilchrist.
Srd Division. — Mitchell Young, Thomas
Noble, James Lawson, John Gartley,. John
Wilson, James Wilson, John Inglis, T. Cock^
bum, D.. Weir, Jas. Foyar, Jas. Smith; Sam*
Paterson, John Wild, Wm. Bonthron^ I>an
Downie, David Lyda.
4th Division. — ^PeterMofiat, Joseph MOre^
Wm. Robertson, Tho. Tweedale, Lord Daer,
John Jackson, J. Graham, Jas. Bourden^
Alex. Bremner, Archd. Gray, Alex. Callander,
R. Peacock, John Johnston, Peter Hunter,
John Grindhiy, Robert Sands.
5th Division.— Arch. Hastle, John Baillie,
Arch. Wright, Geo. Anderson, Adam Pringl^
[Peter Wood,] David Gowans, Geo. Bju^
Adam Ridimond, John'Smeall, Jamed Snfeall,
Alex. Flenderleith. Wm. Flemings Jobs
Wardlaw, Wm. M'Cubbin, Wm. Tod Links.
6th Division.^~John M^Intyre, Dnneaii
Charles, Chas. Dantzker,. Wm. Haddow, Jaa*
Bell, Colin Norrie, John M'Arthiir, Stephei|
Gibson, F. Watson, Chas* ^iclair, Jabn
Hepburn, Alegc. Fortune, \ra8« RtcluDOnd^ Bb
C. Brown, John Noble.
7tb Diviaioa.--Akx. Bell^ Peter Mill^ (fobl
mi
^J ^^ ^^•'^W^^Hf^^^
A. D. 1?0^
Hs^
^ourlay, John Rkhmond, Peter Hatdy, John
lAingy Wm. Ross, John Dickson, Jos. SmeaU,
•John Hehtelwood, Wq. Simpson, Alex.
Jif ^Keoziey Jeknes Purvis, Arch. Binny, David
Brown.
-i Stb I>ivi8ion;-^Geo. ClelaiKl, Wm. Ro-
manes, David Bum, Andrew Newton, John
liV41s(Mi, Wm. Urquhart, Geo. Mealmaker,
Maurice Maraarot, John Clark, Wm. John-
ston, Duvid Weir, Joseph Gerald, John Hodge,
Wm. Boyd, James Little.
9lh Division. — Jas. Paterson, W. Brodie,
Alex. Cockhorn, Geo. Waddle, Eben. Sulker,
Wm. Martin, Geo. Turner, Randolph Slack,
Thos. Bell, R. Orrock, Wm. Caspar, John
Thyone, John Fairley, Taylor, Peter
Leydea.
: tOth Division. — Arthur M'Ewen, James
Thomson, J. Auchinleck, James Tod, J.
Thomson, Jas. Calder, Rich. Younger, Wm.
Wal«on, Arch. Gibson, Wm. Muir, David
il^Bain, J. Lawson, C. Ritchie, Dugald
Httmy, Chas. Gray.
lldi Divbion.-*James Ferguson, Wm.
Skirving, John Kirk, James Carmichaej,
Andrew Simpson, Geo. Galium, James Wilkie,
James M'Kay, Wm. Eelbeck, Chas. Salter,
David Lyon, John Dunn, Hios. Noble, John
Nhren, Wm. Mofiat, Alex. Reid,
While these lists were making out, the
convention aipied the question respecting
the mode of appointing oommittees, when,
«fter a number, oi different speakers had deli-
vered their sentiments on the subject and
proposed diffisrent plans ;
* Itt Resolved, that the divisions shall name
% leet for the oommittees of the number of
whatever it may be.
Sd. That the priority unon a leet sha}l
defiend upon the number or individual votes
whicfa mil be marked upon the leet of each
division.
. BflMlved, The 1st division to meet in the
Canongate lodge.— The 9nd division to meet
in Mr. [Cotton's £. end Cross causeway]
PhSip'B schooL— The Srd in citizen Ross's
libeity Court— The 4th at the Gazetteer
office.^— The 5th at [Liberty] Gazetteer stairs.
T-Xba 0th at ditto.— The 7tb Mr. Robertson's
school Simon's square.*-The 8th Mr. Mullo's
J4b«rt5r itair.— Thedth to meet in the steward's
room.— The lOth to meet hi this lodge.— The
tftb Mr. Campbell Waniston close.
Lord Doer proposed that any new delegates
who may attena the cohvention after this
Amngemeot, shall be added to the different
diviiions in their order.
Mr. Scott announced as a new delegate
'tasdatxk Walker, disputed, but without a formal
eODmisstoii of delegation ftom citizens Muir .
salt Palmer, &c. at present on board the
Ami George.
Mr. Margarott moved, that a committee be
wpomled to consider and draw up a proper
plan of union betwe^ the two nations ad:ord-
Sie to the resolution passed yesterday.
l4Mrd Daer moved that it consist of 19.—-
Both motWDs were unanimously agreed to, } Callender suggested that it would be proper
CrtismaCallenderand the president wert
deputed to wait upon the society of shoemakers
and revest [tespecting] the use of the lodge
to-mcucrow [on' Friday] night [first]. Thf)
tickets beine delivered to the delegates, and
theplacesof meeting for the divisions resd
over, a motion wiEis made for a collection but
as many had now gone away, the collection
was postponed till to-morrow evenine, when
it is hoped it will be' tlte more liberal. The
chairman having closed the business by
prayertheconvention adjourned till to-morrow
at 5.
EdXrih. %\ '^^ 1793.
Mr. Jackson in the chair.
A motion was presented [firemj and read,
signed by Messrs. Robertson and Campbell;
trntt each stranger admitted shall' pay \t,
and all members of 4:he asso<iiation who are
not ddegates shall pay 6d.
Mr. Skirving informed the meeting that the
rev. citizen Douglas of Dmidee liad sent a
eircel of tx)oks entitled ^ Thoughts on Moderd
olitics^*^ which he authorised him to sell and
devote the one half of the money to the Funds
9f the Ccnveniion / Whereupon the [visUori
[admitted] Mr. Reid, Mr. Jas. Pearsonl
Fbtteor-row, Mr. D&i^d M^Knight, Charles
M'Laren, and George Brown, Potter-row^
John Thomson, Andrw. Cockbum, Mr. Smith,
from Pennycuick, Mr. Thomson from Stirling^
Mr. Petrie, Mr. Latorie New Town society.
The depute secy, moved that the thanks o(
the convention be r^turne<l to be returned to
Mr. Douglas for this instance of generosity. '
The foUowing visitors were admitted
(n Nov. 93. J
The minutes being read and prayers said,
Mr. Margaret was unanimously called to the
chair.
The reports of the divisions being given in
while the secretary was marking uie votes,
the depute secretary informed the convention
that he had last night received fiAeen shillings
firom 6 of the visitors who had been present
and which was paid to Mr. Skirving, with 3
shillings receivea from ^nsitors.
He also moved that a ^eral collectioii
should be made, which being agreed to^ and
Messrs. Callender and Scott appointed collec-
tors, there was drawn instantly 4/. 5s, 8d^l, of
which there were ft bad shillings, balance
4LS$,8d, . .
Mr. Binny was appointed to read the
reports of the different divisions a? stated in
the secretary's cross lists, and a leet bein?
taken from those who had the majoritv of
numbers, they were unanimously elected by
the convention, (except Mr. Buchanan^ who
declined the election) as a committee for the
purpose of forming u union, viz. Messrs. Mar*
garott, Gerald, Brown, Sinclair, Daer, Cal-
lender, John Clark, Sands, Mealmaker, John
Gartiey, A. Scott, Hart and Hastie. Mr.
i2S] 34 GEOEGE ill. Proce€dings,$igaind mUiam Skirving [424t
Which was dcKvered io the tteasurer, Mr.
Reid.
Mr. Sinclair proposed that the whole re-
ports of the committee should be delayed till
the report was completed.
Mr^ Clark and Mr. Sands proposed aa im*
mediate decision.
'Mr. Brown obviated Mr. Saods's fear of &
delay.
Mr. Sinclair urged as a reason for delay,
that lord D. was employed in completing the
report of the committee.
Mr. Brown proposed that the first rule be
immediately auopted, [agreed to] which was
at last agreed to, and the resolutions being
severally put, it was resolved unammousJy
that all the three resolutions be agreed to.
Mr. Callender moved to fix the hour and
place for the committees to me^t.
Resolved the committee on the regulatioas
meet here at 1 1 to-morrow.
The general meeting, at S o'plopk, fOid the
other committee at 8^ at the [committee]
Black Bull.
The names of the m.embers of the difierent
divisions or classes were then read over vnth
their places of meeting, after which the presir
dent concluded the business with a suitable
prayer, and the meeting adjourned till tOr
ipQrrpw at 3 o'clock.
,to enter into a discussion on the nature of the
[union] proposed union.
Mr. Brown moved the convention to re*
solve itself into a committee to afford greater
freedom of speech.
Mr. Burhanao objected to tlus proposal on
the supposition that it tended to take persons
by surprise.
Mr. Gejrrald stated that to honest men ao^
thing is so valuable as truth, and that nothing
can possibly tend so much to the disclosure of
truth as discussion and deliberation — that it
was also very important that the committee
should know as much as possible of the public
mind in order that they might act in unison
with it. .
Tbe convention then resolved itself into a
committee upbn the motion of Mr. Brown,
and many valuable hints were thrown out by
citizens Brown, Hastie, Mealmaker, Scott,
Callender, Urquhart, Buchanan, Campbell,
Gourley.— Gerald observed that whatever dif-
ference of opinion might exist in these walls,
we can never forget that our friends and our
enemies are in common, and that our object
is equally the same. He |_next] took a re-
view of t}>e means we %re to use in order to
secure our object. He entereid fully into the
subject of universal s^firaee and annual par-
liaments ; he fully proved the rights of the
people to these benefits by their ancient con-
stitution [and with an energy and eloquence
rwhich it were in yain to attempt to follow -
(he entered ii^, on, ^d reviewed the sound
fand universality] ; he minutely investigated
the principles of government ; he asserted
that the end of all government is the good of
the governed ; that if money be taken out of
his pocket against his consent, it is of little
consequence whether it be taken [without]
by the robber on ^he heath, or the ijionarch
9n the throne ; be made many [pertinent]
remarks upon the Revolution settlement and
^e benefits gained by the last Revolution,
and demonstrated clearly that they are now
totally taken away ; he warned the convention
against the choice of any other than known
and plain men like themselves, men uncon-
taminated by the pestilential air of courts.
Mr. Jackson from Pennicuick paid Mr.
^kirving a guinea towajrds the common fund
in name of that society.
Mr. Skirving moved that the convention
be resumed, and that some business be
chalked out for the committee— seconded by
Mr. Brown.
Mr. Sinclair, in absence of lord Daer, gave
i^ the continuation of the committee's report
respecting the election of presidents, of three
assistants, one to go out daily, and respecting
the council of the table.
The [door] collection at the door amounted
to ^.0 19 3
More ... ^.0 1 0
^.1 0 3
EdinWrgh^ 2S Nao. Friday.
4th Day*s Sitting.^ — ^Mr. Margaret in the chair.
The reports being called for and read, £the1
citizens John Clanc and Arch. Hastie ox
Paisley were foimd to have the two hiehest
numbers, Mr. Clark having 26 votes, and Mr.
Hastie 24; but Mr. Clark beine absent, it
was unanimously agreed that Mr. Hastie
[should be called] should be [was] called to
the chair.
The minutes being read, and Mr. Margimot
having said prayers,
Mr. Hastie took Uie chair.
The leets for asustants to the secretary
were then read from the different reports, and
the following eentlemen were found to have
the majority of votes, viz. Charles Sinclair^
Wm. Ross, and Geo. Ross.
Mr. Wm. Ross having pled an ^pologyi
which was sustained,
Mr. John Wilson was found to have the
next highest number, whereupon Messes.
Sinclair, Wilson, and Geo. Ross beine pro^
posed as assistants, were unanimously dected
ny the convention, and took their seats at the
table accordingly.
Citizen Sincuur then delivered the report of
the committee, containing the following reao«
lutions, which being readTrom the chair sqMK
rately, and the question put upon each of
I them, were unanimously acreed to, vis.
1st. That no person be decied io the chair
twice in one week.
Sdly. That strangers fshall] who wish to be
admitted as visitors sbaD send in their names
425]
Jot SediUoH.
A. D. 1794.
[486
10 the council at the table previous to their
admission.
3dly. That they shall all sit upon one seat.
4thly. That they shall not mingle with the
members of the convention under the pain of
exclusion.
Mr. Sinclair in name of the committee^isked
leave for the committee to sit again, which
was granted, and to morrow at 10 appointed.
Citizen Gordon Murray, the door-keeper,
received orders to put the laws respecting
visitors in execution.
(Thejbllowing was written on a separate paper,)
Mr. Sinclair read the report of the com-
mittee [who] and moved [and agreed to] se-
-veral resolutions, which were agreed to^
Read a motion made by Mr. FM'Intyre]
l^ewton for appointing a day of iastine, se*
conded by Mr. Mealmaker; after several gen-
tlemen were fully heard upon it, an ^mend-
anent was proposed by Mr. Gerald, namely,
that it be recommended by the convention to
the friends of reform in Great Britain and Ire^
land to invoke the blessings of Almightv on
their endeavours to procure liberty and hap-
piness and liberty to mankind.
. A motion for suoporting the Edln, Gazet-
teer, which was oraered to lie on the table»
Agreed that the regulations regarding
stran^^rs should be given to the door-keeper
in writing : agreed that those members who
are obliged to leave the convention should
ivrite to their constituent^ to appoint others to
0upply their place immediately.
Mr. Andrew Newton's motion given in last
Slight vras then read by the deputy sec.
stating a variety of reasons urging the pro-
priety of the convention appointing a day of
general fasting and humiliation — for our sins,
and for praying to the Almighty for success
to our cause. This motion was seconded, and
strongly supported by Mr. Mealmaker, as well
as by Messrs. Callender, John Churk, and
otheNy but [opposed] was objected to by
Messrs. Taylor, Sands, Margaret, Paterson,
and Aitchiesou as tendine to blend religion
with politics [and] to divide the friends of re-
ffum, and to render the convention ridiculous,
by enacting what they neither had right to
enact, nor power to enforce.
Citizen Gerald then proposed to recommend
the propriety and necessity of applying for
divine aid, but not to eiyoin any tnmg on the
subject — Mr. Skirvinc moved an amendment
to that purpose which was seconded by Mr.
John Wilson.— Citizen Gerald then [made the
following] moved the amendment in the fol-
lowing termsy which being read from the
chair, and the question put was [unanimously]
agreed to by a very great majority, viz.
*^ That thb convention do earnestly recom-
mend botli to the members of this convention
and to the friends, of freedom and reform
thrai^ Gnat Britain and [reform] Ireland
to invoke the blessing of Almightgr God, who
is the common Father of all men^ on the causa
in which we are engaged."
The original motion of course was laid
aside.
Citizen Skirving then moved, that the ad-«
dress to the pubUc should be drawn up by the
committee upon the union, which was una-
nimously agreed to. A motion to supp<Nrt the
Gazetteer signed by six members was read^
and ordered to lie over till to<-morrow.
A motion was presented by the secretary
and dep. sec. that a committee of finance bie
appointed. [The council of the table were
[appointed accordingly.]
Citizen Scott moved, that before any dele<^
gate from the country shall leave his post, he
shall write to his constituents to send ano-
ther up in his room — agreed to nem» con.
The sec then moved, that delegates from -
the country, who may run short of money
by the prolongation of the business of the
convention shall be [allowed] supplied by the
treasurer. The council of the table were ap^
pointed on this business. Messrs. Callender
and Fortune being appointed collectors^
1/. lOf. was drawn. — Tne chairman having
closed the meeting by prayer, the convtotion
was adjourned till to morrow at IS noon.
5th Day's Sitting.— Convention Hall. Aov. 38«
Citizen Hastte in the chair.
Reports from every [society] section^ ex*
cept No. 11.
Committee of finance appointed, John 6u-
chan, James, Gartley, [M. Campbell Brewer,]
Alex. Fortune, Alex. Scott, Cleland [and W\U
[son] from Newmilns equal.
Citizen Gerald appointed chairman for this
day's sitting, and citizen Binny assistant goes
out of course citizen Wilson, when citizen
G. Ross read the minutes of last sitting. —
The president stated^ that this morninc he
had received a letter from our friends in Nor-
wich, who desired him to inform the conven-
tion, that they remained steady in the canse,
and had nominated citizen Margarot, their
delegate, and that they would contribute their
shue of the expenses attending the conven-
tkm. Mr. Margaret accordingly accepted of
the office, who congratulated tne convention
upon the accession of such a great number
or friends.
Upon it being stated, that dtizen G^rakl
had business, public and private, to [exact}
transact immediately, and requested that be
should leave the chair — agreed to— and citi-
len Urquhart was elected to the chair.
A motion was read, that a voter of conven-
tion should prove the uni^ of the delegates,
firom the South and North.
Citizens Muir, from KUmamock, Margaret,
from Norwich, and several others, supported
the motion, which was unanunously agreed
to.-^itizen Sco|Lt proposed that all the mem-
\en should rise up and join luuids, as a proof
I
4S7] 34 GSOBGB HI. Prwedingt mffHutt mijtiam Siirving
im
pf the ludoft betvixt S^riand bod Sdot^d;
whkk 9i!!C myrjfwM as Britain— agreed.
It was moved, thttt. tbeocciftxrth the coa-
tenUoa •htirfd he il^ledih/s.Btitish Conven-
tion of the Delegjates of the People, A^aoci-
aled io ohtain.UoMrersal 8ufiraj;e» and Annual
ParliASn<Mit9. Agceed to unaounously.
. A nipiicffk was made for the convention,
aUoMring the members of the United Society
q( Irishmen, [he allowed to vote and j to speak
and vote hw^-^eferred io ike uciwns.
A oommittee was appointed to consider
the motion respecting the Gazetteer.
' Citizen Margamlt, £.:-r-Browik E. — [Wm.
Ross] Binny, E.— [Jo. WUson] fWylde] Skir-
ving, £.<^jCalienderl[DoMrnteJJas. Gartley,
£.«^ohn nepburn, £.— Meaiinaker, £.*-
• . Appointed to meet in citizen Ross's liberty
4»urt,at a o'clock this everuog.
r Citiaens Muir, Uastie, Ti^kor and Gun*
n'^g^wry requested Jeave of abseqcey which'
^ras naiUed upon condition* thai the^ wauki
4i> tbeit utmost to scud delegatea m tbuc
pieces.
Letter read from Mr. Colin Nome Mon-;
tnae, annouacmghis departureyiand lequeal-
iog minutes of ue convention. to be sent
hiniy answered thai he would receive them in-
the Gaaetteer.
Motion by Mr. Jas. Gartley, respecting di-
viding the country into departments, and |
appointing provincial conventions, whereby
they mayl>ecome more acquainted with each
^er's sentiments ;
Refiprred to the Committee of Union.
Mr. Skirving moved Mr. Binny, in place
of Mr. Muir, [Qastie] on the committee of
[Unioni regulation-ragreed.
Hn. Urauhart on do. in place of Mr* Sands,
and Mr. wiigbt, in place of Mr. UastiC) on
the Committee .of Union.
• ResoWed, thai all committees shall have
ii in their power, to invite the assistance of
such membera of the convention, as they
think may be beneficial to the business in-
trusted to their charge.
Can)«rsation on we sections^ resolved to
continue till Monday, as at present.
Motion by cit Gordon Murray, contain-
ing thanks»to the movers of the division inlo
cilasses, mentioning the advantages alread;^
obtained from it^ and requesting a fresh shui^^
He — ^referred to Uie committee of regulations*
-^Agreed that the ntembers of societies in
jEdinlmrgb, join the sections.— Citizen Miu>
ȴ gave in a report, respecting the use of the
fte president warned the sectbns to meet
as fiilly as possible on Mond^.
A4ioum«l till 5 on Monday.
Cth Days Sitting.— EAi?6ttrgA, 25 N<yo. 179S.
Mr. yrquhart In the thair.
The tickets were ordered to be gathered
from all pi-esent, and the dpor-keeper to col«
iect them hxm. ^hose who come in afterwards.
The following new commissions were lead^
.vi««
From Dunfermline, in favour of Afr. Peter
Read. — ^Linlithgow, M. Geo. Brockly.
The reports of the sections being called
for, were ^ven in and read, when citizen
M* C. Browne, was found to have a decided
rai\)ohly for being elected president.
Mr. Urquhart having conatituted the meet-
ing by praywv
Citizen M. C. Browne, was UBanimoasly
elected president, and took the chair accord-
in^y.
The reports of the sections being again
readj tlie choice of an assistant, citizen Young
was found to have the greatest number iA
votes, but being absent, dtizen Sam. I^ter-
son was found next highest, and was elect^
aocordingly.-^^itiEen A. Callender moved,
that in case the minister bring into the Comt
mone House, a motion for a convention bill,
it shall be notieed immedialel|y [ordered] to
the delegates.
9th Day's Sitting.
• •»
A potion was eiven in, for printing afl
fiapers respecting &e obji^ts i>f the conven*
tion in the C^etteer office.
A motion by Jas. Gaitley and Wm. Ross,
for not receiving any motion that may tend
to a religious discussion, was brought under
consideiatioD, which, after some mscus^on^
was, with 6ther motions of the same nature,
laid aade, and the convention passed to the
order of the dinr.
Citizen Sincudr's motion, relative tA ac^it*
tine the members of the United Society of
InSimen, to apeak and vote in this conven-
tion came forward for discussbn, when cxti*
zens Sinclair, Callender, Gerald, John Gart-
ley, Buchanan, and othm, spoke upon it, and
amed to and piaranteed by a solemn joining
of hands. — ^It being followed by a motion f6r
transmittine the w>ve resolution to citizen
Archibald Hamilton ]^wan, which .passed
accordingly.
Sec. Skirving, stated that he had just now
received from an unknown hand, &/. for the
use of the convention. — Honourable mentiofi
in the minutes, to be made of ttiis patriot^
donation.
A motion presented and read, signed by ci-
tizens MH3ubbin and Bremner, respecting a
periodical publication to be printed by &•
editor of the Gazetteer.
A motion was made by Mr. Sinclair, r^
specting the appointments of an interim com-
mittee at the end of every convention, to call
together' the delegates on extraordinary emer*
gencies*— These motions were ordered to lie
over for the
The dep. secretary having moved a col*
lection, Messrs. Sinclair anU Bell were ap-
pointed collectors, when 8/. Si. lOd.i weft
onwn apd given to Mr. Beid.
419]
for StJBSon*
K. D. 1794^.
[430
The Sections were
No. 1. — Arch. Binny, Wm. Philip^ Robt
]peacocky Wm. M'Cul>bmy John Thynne^ £ben.
Stalker, Alex. Bell, WUliam Eelbeck, Robert
Taylofy Wtn. Bonthroa, Cb. Ritchie, John
Johnstone, M. C. Browne^ John Gourlay,
Arch. Wright. — ^To^n^eet in Canoi^te Lodge,
Flesh Martlet Close.— Arthur U'£wen^ Geo«
Milne.
No. 9.-— Alex.. Plenderleithv David Weir,
lolm lAglis» Andrew Newtdo^ John Dua^
Wm. Rose, Joseph Gecalidy Alex. AitchiesoD^
John Oilchrist, Geo. Ross, J»8. Foyar, Da.
Gowuks, Ja& Garti^i^ Da. Bertie, James
M^Kay.^To meet in liberty Stairs.---Rober€
Bait.
drd Division^-^-Wm. Haddow, Geo. Brock-
Jr, Geo. Meahnaker^ Mauiioe Mai^^aiot,
ohn Wardkw,, Robert Christie, Jas. Wilson,
Jaa. LawaoD^ Gordon Mum^, Alex. Fartane,
James Bell, James Somerwdle,. Alex. Brem-r
Ber, Dsv. Downie, John Xung.-^MuUo's
fRoss'^ Liberty Stairs.---Jo. litster.
. 4th Divitton.— «Bich. i Younger, Alex. Mac
Kenxie» John Wild, Geo. Cotton, John Gifind*
lay, Chas. Sinchftur, ^f dhn Auchuikck, Thos.
Miller^. MitcheU Youngs Peter W06d, Da.
Tsvldr^ Alex. Callttnder, Walter Hart, Wm.
BcwertsoD, Jas. Smith, 'Jas» Thomson, Saori.
PstersoDw— In citizen Rioss^s.
, 5th DiwisiQn,-^Aiex. Reiid» . Peter Reid,
fefeer Mofiat, Jas. Tweedie, John Hinselwood,
Jas. Smith, Wm. Beddie, John Hodge, John
Ckiand, Robt. Muir, J(>hn Stark, Dav. Burn,
John Glark,. WjQ.€ainpbell, Wm. Romanes,
Wm. Fleming.— liberty Stairs.
6th Divifion.-r^ohn Gaickley, Dav. Lyon,
Jas. little, Thos. NoUe^ Thos. Cockbum,
Alex. Scott, John BuchansA, Alex. Knox,
Dav. Brawn, Jas. Calder, John Wibon, Wm.
Urqnh^rt, Jbl|n Wilson Wri^t, Wm. Moffiit,
James C^armichael [Sam. niterson], John
HephoixL
The contention being divided into sectionsv
Mr. Gartley mov>ed, that the motions should
be laid before the sections, and desired the
cobndl of -the table tx) condescend on those
that were to be first discussed.
. After argiuns for some tii;iie upon this sub-
ject, it was resolved simply to reaa the motions,
m the order kifVliick tl% are to be^' dis-
cussed.— ^This beiilg'dode^ the business was
closed by prayer, a&r which the coyo^ention
adjourli^ till to-tnorrow at 5.
7th Day's Sitling.-^jEitttittr^A, 96 Nov, 1793.
Citizen [Mr.] Matthew Campbell Brown, in
the chair.
Reports from sections. No. 1, 9, S, 5 and d.
were received and read, whereby it appealed
that a majority of sufirages in the sectkkns,
ware in f£rour of Mr.Sinclair.-^itiaen Sin-
dr, however pled that the section to which
he belonged, had nven ^'ir voices for Mr.
Clark, but that the seer. Was alMoit — It
was resolved, however, thai no verbal rn>orts
could be received from any section, where*
upon citizen Brown having ocmstiltited itib
meeiing by prayer.
Citizen Sinclair took the chair.
The reports of the.aections bemg again
coosull^, citiaen WavdOaw was found duly
recommended as assistant^ and waaaccordU
ingly elected. ,
The minutes being reaS, Mr. IBinny gave
in the report of the committee respecting the
supporting of the gazetteer— Mr. Scott not
bciing present, the convention ordered the
conimitfeee, to furnish Mr. Scott wi^ ques*
tions tpropbsed to be put to him bjr this coni>
mtUee, and to answer the same and to report.
The foHewing gentlemen were admitted
visltorfa^-dtizens John Beiiiai^,iABd*Ridge]y,
Wm. Mitchell, Robt. Brockley,. Wm. Ai^u»^
And. Twcedale, Jas. Muit'haid^ Alex. Lamorit,
Adam Melrose, Jas. Taylor, John Ha[^, Joh^
jBDnet,!:f]?hds. Wyki^ Robt. Still, >Wtiter
Aitken, Geo. King, John Thorbum, JasL
Oomnnghara, C. Scott, Mr. Mitchell, capt.
Hamhon Dun, John Wilson, Robert Ogle^
Georee Galium, citizen 'Jardtne, Gteorge Frier,
Jas. .Tborbum, Wm. Thomson, Jas. Farlie,
Charles Mather, Mr. Steel, Jas. Wai, Geo.
Mackintosh, John Robinson, John Kay^ John
Denhohn,- John Eelbeck^ Alexander Sitnpson
and .Dayjd Clark.->--Aftcr.[fuil] long discus^
sion upon Mr. Callendbr's motion^ they n-
ferred the same for further consideration till
to-morrow.
The collection for to night amounted to
1/. 9s. Id.
Measrs. Brelhner and " ."■'■'s mdfion
to employ the editor of the Gaaetteer, for all
papers relative to the oonvetition, was then
discussed at considerable length, when a
coocfliatory motion was made, but at last the
original motion was refe^ed to the commit-
teeoffinance.
Motions read — signed by Messrs. Camp-
bell'and Jas. Smith, thitt it 'be otrdered that
the convention shsJl cause a regular set of
bo6k$ to be kept for the inseition of minutes,
motions, and other proceedings, a book of
finance, &c. to be at all times subject to the
inspection of an intermediate- oommittee.
Moved by John Stark, and seconded by
James Carmichael^ that the hill of rights
be ordered to be prmted immediatelr.
Another mmion was nade^by dtizen Alex.
Mackenue, seconded by cit. Waher Uart|
that it berecdminetided'to'the different so*
ctetHas throughout the country, to cofiy the
1^1 of rights into their mhmtes books, as a
basis for their ph>ceediiig8, wd as a memetoto
to 'evefv good citizen, that, tiiey are doing
what 'tae constitution avows and admits,
in ohfer to prevent impit>per conatructions
from l>eing put [toj ou their conduct as
fhends to reform.
431] 84 GEOBGB UL Proceedings againd WiBiam SMroing f432
All these motions were oidered to lie oVef
to be considered by the sections.
Hie dep. sec. moved that in future, busi-
ness shall begin, and the [chainnan] presi-
dent take the chair precisely at 5 minutes
past 5, in order to save time^ which was una-
nimously agreed to.
Mr. Xjrourlay was unanimously elected
transcriber of motions.
The churman having said prayers, the oon->
vention adjourned.
BthDay's Sittii^.— £(2in. 27, Nov. 1793.
Mr. Sinclair in the chair.
The reports being given in from all the
sections, citizen John Clark was found to
have the majority, but he being absent and
C. John. Gsurtley being also absent, citizen
Mealmaker was recommended, and the ques-
tion being put, was unanimously elected.
— The foUowing visitors were admitted.
Messrs. Lvon, Wm. Thomson, Jas. Thomson,
Geo. Walker, Jolm Davies from London.
The chairman having constituted the meet-
ing by prayer,
Mr. M^maker took the chair. — ^The re-
ports of the sections as to the nomination of
an assistant being read, Mr. Young was found
to have the majority, but being absent, Mr.
James Wilson was unanimously elected.
The minutes being read, a motion was pre-
sented [and read] by Mr. Walter Hart, Snded
by. citizen Calder. That no notes be al*
lowc^ to be taken but
The secretaiy moved that it should be im-
mediately taken into consideration. After
arguing the matter, upon a shew of hands the
votes were found equal, 16 being for imme-
diate discussion and 16 for a dela^, whereupon
the president gave the casting voice for delay-
ing the motion for the consideration <^ the
sections.
Mr. Ellis from Dundee was allowed to
speak upon the business.
Mr. Callender's motion being then taken
under consideration, amendments were pro-
posed by citizens Downie, Sinclair, Bremner,
and John Gartley.
Mr. Marearot pled for adopting the spirit
of Mr. CaTlendor's motion, but thought it
would be more advantB|;eous to postpone
adopting till the conclusion of the conven-
tion's business.
Moved by Mr. Margarott that a committee,
consisting of the mover, seconder, and those
who have moved for amendments of Mr.
Callender's motion, be appointed to draw up
a motion from the whole that may probably
meet the ideas of the whole convention.
After some conversation it was agreed, upon
the motienof Mr. Calder, that ue vote of
the House be put first oq the spirit of Mr.
Callender*8 motion ; Sdly, on the words of the
motion ; and Sdly, on Mr. Margarott's motion.
— ^Agreed.
' The sense of the House being taken of the
first, it carried unanimously to adopt the
motion as to the tpirit. On the Sd, it carried
by a great majority not to adopt the motion
as so worded ; and Sdly, it was resolved that
said motion and all amendments be referred
as above.
The repott of the committee for supporting
the Gazetteer was then made ; bearing that
having received an unsatisfactory answer
firom Mr. Scett to him by the convention last
night, suggest the propriety of the House re-
solving itself into a committee for the pur-
pose of investigating the affair, and for coming
to a final deteitnination thereon.
The convention, afVer some consideration,
found that all the assistance which was com-
petent to them, was to recommend from the
chair to each delegate present to endeavour
to prevail with their several societies to collect
what money they can for the pecuniary assist-*
ance required, and the same was done ac-
cordingly.
The collection for defraying expences was
next called for, and the sum of 1/. 8s. 0{d,
Citizen Jov Gartley informed the conven-
tion, .that he was under a necessity to leave
the convention and return home. Leave was
granted upon the usual recommendation,
and upon a motion Dr. Taylor was nomi-*
nated to fill his place in the committee of
and unanimously elected.
The foUowine motions were presented|
read, and ordered to lie over.
1st. From Mr. Margaret, and 9nded by
Mr. Gerald, that a committee of 5 be ap-
pointed for the purpose of drawing up weekly
an abstract of the minutes of the convention,
in order that the same may be printed, and a
copy sent to every country society.
2ndly, From Mr. Archibald Wright, Snded
by Mr. John Johnston, That as ignorance is
the great support of oppression, and know-
ledge its destruction, moved that this oonveh-
tion take some method of enlightening the
Highlands of Scotiand.
Citizen Taylor was unanimously elected a
member of the committee of finance, instead
of citizen Cleland, who is gone to Newmills.
9th Day's Sitting.— Conventi(m Hall.
Nov, 28, 1798.
Citizen Mealmaker in the chair.
After the reports of the sections, it was
found that citizen John Clark had 10 voices ;
citizen Romanes, 9 voices; and citizens
Jkmes Gartley and R. Taylor, had each 8
voices for the chair. Clark and Romanes
being absent, it was thought proper to pro-
ceed witii the election of the assistant; af^er
which citizen R. Taylor was called to the
chair, and citizen John Stark from Glasgow
was elected assistant, and the following vi»-
Jar Sediiion.
tors were admitted. Mungo Barrowman,
James Jackson^ Tboipas Smith. Andrew
"Bbatl, Thomas Johnston, Alex. Laidlaw, John
Morton, Henry Vickars, Robert Gilchrist,
Andrew Cockburn, John Bartlett, John Bar-
Bet, James Muirhead, FMr.] Wyld, John San-
derson, John Lamb, John Finlay, John Eel-
beck, John Bone, Thos. Johnston, John
Wright, James Fisher, John McGregor, John
Ingnon, Alex. Galloway, Thorbum, Mather
Lowrie, Steel.
TA long discussion took place about the
[amnisnon of members.]
A S«>tt gave in the report of iin. respect-
ins Uie secretaries acco. and the same were
OTuered to be ingrossed. The committee of
&iaiice [and] begged [as they had not suffi-
tdent time as yet to examine the aocot. par-
ticularly]^ that they might be allowed to sit
again, wmch was agreed to. And they were
ordered to meet on ^turday at 10 o'clock,
and the Edinburgh committee of finance ap-
pointed to attend them [with their accots.]
A motion presented by G. Ross [to give in]
for the committee of union to give m thdr
report was read, and it was answered that
they would do so as the business was finished.
A letter from the societies in Paisley was
read, where they expressed their approbation
of the acts of the convention, and b^ged that
citizen Skirvinz should act for them as their
delegiste, which was granted accordingly.
Citizen Sinclair read the amendment upon
atizen Callender's motion, as agreed upon by
the committee, and it was [resolved] agreed
2K>n the motion of cit that
e House should resolve itself into a
committee for its mature consideration. In
the course of the conversation, citizen Brown
nve [an explanation] a lustory of the Habeas
Corpus act. Afier an excellent discussion of
the question, pertinent remarks, and amend-
SmentL Ftiie whole motion passed unani-
loosiyu the convention was resumed, and
e whole as amended being read over, the
members stood upon their f<^ and solemnly,
ahd unanimously, passed the [motion] Reso-
lutiiHis, as follows :
A. J>. 1794.
[4S4
Cilisen Gemld in [a manly] an energetic
aaMi animated address, expresiBed his happi-
■esa at the motion passed, and exposed tne
act of the Irish juiriiament called a Conven-
tion bill; and citizen Brown followed him in
a manly speech, and proved the influence
of the executive [power] government over the
parfiament
Citizen Margaiot read and proposed the
following motion, viz. That a secret com-
mittee of three, and the secretair, be ap-
poarted to determine the place where such
convention of emergency stiall meet-— That
such place shall remain a secret with tbem^
VOL.ZXIIL
and witH the secretary of thia convention,
and that each delegate shall at the breaking
up of the present session, be entrusted with a
sealed letter containing the name of the place*
of meeting. — ^This letter shall be delivered
unopened to his constituents the receipt of
which shall be acknowledged b^ a letter to
the secretaiy [pnn] preserved m the same
state, until the period shall arrive at which it
shall be deemed necessary for the delegate to
set off.— This motion was seconded by [Mr.
[W.] citizen Mofiat, and the same was passed
unanimously.
The following [gentiemen] citizens were
nominated [a secret] a secret committee oa
this business, viz. Margaret, Jo. Clark, [Skir*
tving] and [GeraldJ with the secretaiy
)rowne. Ana they were requested to devise
the best possible means of conveying this in-
timation to those societies, whose views are
the same with ours, but may not have dele-
gates at this con.
A collection was made, and 1/. 7s. drawn.
Mr. Binny complained, that he had receive
ed a letter siened by Robert Gilchrist, Wm«
Tod, James M'Leay, and Henry Vickers*
After reading; the letter, and arguing upon
the subiect, it was resolved that the letter
should be burnt, and the doorkeeper ordered
not to admit these visitors to any future
meeting.
The following motions were read, and or-
dered to lie over for the consideiution of the
convention.
1. By [Mr.] citn. Ellis, 9ded by citizen Jas.
Wilson, that a fund be loosed by subscriptioa
for defraying the expense of small patriotic
publications to be aistributed in the highr-
lands.
Every publication shall bear the figure of a.
Highlandman in fiill dress, with target and
brwid-sword, to attract the attention ot High-
landmen. No publication to cost more than
i a penny.
Sd. By citn. Calder and Gourlay, that a
Committee be appointed to diaw up a declfr*
ration of the i^tural, unalienable, and unpre*
scriptible rights of man, and that the same
be prefixed to the address la the people of
Britain.
d. By citn. Gourlay and CaMer, thatthia
convention do order the bill caOed the Con-
vention Act. passed iof Ireland last session,
tobepubHsned.
4. Citn. Hepburn and Binny, that when
any committee is nominated,, the convention
shall fix the day when they ought to give in
their report
5. By citB. J. Clark and^M. C. Brown, that
a committee of observation be appointed in
London, to give the earliest intiniatron of
any motion of the kind mentioned in the
fovegeiBg ResohitioBS to tiie difiereni societies.
Cbnventiom Hall, 1st year of the British
Convention, 99lh of Novem. AnnoDonu*
ni 17M.— 10th day's Sitting,
a F
435] 34 GEORGE lU. ProceedtHgt agaiiul WiUiam SHning
im
Ciiiten Taylor in the chair.
The reports of the sections being given in,
citizen James Wilson was chosen president,
and citizens Mofiat and John Clark were
elected councillors at the table.
The following visitors were admitted: —
John Coivilly James Leighton, Robt. Wilson,
Kobt. Hardie, Georgje Lawson, Daniel Camp-
bell^ James Smith, James Muirhcad, John
^uirhead, (Dnanond and Wallace^ two
$tndeiUs)^ George Frier, Wm. Auchinleck,
Davies William M'Gill, Robt. Ruthven,
Jlobert Campbell, Solon^on Wilson, Robt.
Still, Robert Barnet, David Kay, Wm.
Scott, James Archer, Davi'd Miller, John
MerryleeSy Thorburn, Mather, Cockson Jar*
^ine, John Lamb, James Laidlaw, Jaip^
Gray, Steel, Kennedy, Ga}letly, Dickson,
Gray, Mitchell, John Kepan, John Ferguson,
Kobt. Hay, Robert Martin, John Noble,
Palmer, Cater, Forrester, David Clark, Ogle,
Denoon, Watt, Fraser.
The secretary read a motiop [by] pres^ted
by M. Margarot and Jos. Gerald for weekly
l>ublication of the minutes, which after soipe
Siscussion, [and]with an amendment proposed
y citizen Brown, passed unanimously, ana citi-
9»ns Moflfatt, Cam|>bell, and Wm. Ross ap-
pointed the committee for drawing up th^
minutes.
Citizen Margarot ^ve in the report of the
eommitteeof regulations, which were ordered
to be printed, and copies [orderedj to be
given in to the -sections on Monday for their
consideration [and refer the printing to the
[referred] left it to the committee or publica*
tion, [who shall be print the paper for the
[convention] to employ what printer they
judge proper for printing the mattore entrust-
ed witn taem.
The secy, read John Clark's motion for a
committee of obs^rviltioo to be.^ppointed in
Ix>ndon. Citizen Margarot stated, that tiiere
m^aa no oocation for a committee of that oa^
ture in London, as there were several thou-
sand people in that city upon the look imi.
Jt was accordingly agreed that this oonvefi-
tion should request the London Committee of
Correspondence to give the earliest intelli-
gence ii^ what passes in parliament
Archbd. Wright's motion for ^qlightening
the Highlands, as well as John Qartley,
Bremner's, King's, and Ellis's; and Aroba.
Wridit proceeded to SMpport hi9 motion,
i^hicn he did bv enumerating many of tbs
ffrievances which our fellow-citizens In the
Highlands labour under, with several other
excellent remarks ^f his own. He was ee-
Qonded by M. C. Browne, who stated one
manner of enlisting [the high] soldiers in
the Highlands, which is too cru«l not to be
execrated, and too remarkable to passunno*
ticed ; that when a man is what they term
refractory, thev take off his shoes «nd ateck-.
ings, and hold his feet before the fire, until
^cniciating torments make him agree to
their nefarious measure.
A coUeclioQ was *made« and 1/. 16i, l(^»f
drawn.
[An anonvmous] A letter from a Friend^
&c. which bad beea transmitted to A. Scgtt
of the Gazetteer, was read, containing patri*
otic sentiments and two guineas. Andatiz^
Taylor presented ^ giunea from another citir
zcn, whose name he was not at liberty , t^
mention. It was stated [that] by the aelqr.
that a citizen from London was presenL wh^
was to give 5/. 5«. to the convention^ when |i
collectio<i shoukl be n>ade for enligbt^ing
the Highlanders. The thapks of the bouse
were uoanhneu^y giveo to the before-noen-
tioned patriote for tneir doDationa.
Citizens Wright, Callander, Calder, Ger^
rakl, and Sinclair we|re elected a committee
to take into their consideration the best me-*
thod of diffusing, by constitutional means,
political knowledge ii;i the Highlands.
Citizen Margarot propo^a that a subr
Qcription should be immediately entered into»
to carry the above into effect, and presented
one guinea for Germld and himself.
A subKripti^n w^ imm^diatdiy entered
into for the aboye purpose by several pitiTens,
and the treasury iqtrwt^ vitb the pap<»r,
and the money drawp. Tbf P9p€r \^ |o, lie
upon the table.
The convention at 10 o'clock adjourned till
to-morrow at eleven*
11 th day's Sitting.— SOth Nov. 179S.
Citizen Wilson, from Stn^thaven, constit
tuted the meeting by prayer, after whi^
citizen Haddow was called to the chair, whei%
t)ie secretary read a motion, that a committ^
be appointed to revise ^i^h d^y'i minut^^
immeaiately on the rising qf the Qonvt^ntiofli
for the purpose of sending thf^m to th^ pri^
to make hereafter a daily bulletin of ^ei
same. Signed M. C« GrQwn and M. M^rgVn
rot, the question being put, the motion p^^sy^
ed unf^nimously. The committee chosen toi»t
night were appd. for this purpose to b<k
changed bv a vole of th9 ponvenupn.
The foUowing visitors w^e admitted* vii«
Wm. Cranston, Wm. Rodger, Wm* 9oui;ke»
The secretary read a letter from James
Fiaher, wherehi he inform^ the cpuvt^^^n,
that English was the be4l language iw «d«
dressing the Highlanders- That, with 9ther«^
were <?der9d to b^ gjiven to tbv committee
iipon that suUe^tf
Citizen CaUender moved, th»t no person
should be allowed the honour of the ^Utins
nnless recommended by two membpiefs [unUIj
which with ami»ndm^tS| 49 in thp OMti^n
itself, paased unvuinou^ly*
A commiMion from the I^wn Market
Society, appointing citizen John Pavi^ «9 a
delegate from ^X ^\^\y tQ thi9 conventioo.
Yb^ ^t«mtiMry fe«d « vmUm ^ citiieo
4»] Jbr Se^^um.
lOfki ibr thcf Bin of tt%bU to be copied into
Hb hookoof each society. This moUon jAss-
^ li» « f«o0mill6*dirtioii fi>f etch societj to
IMM a my of the 9uae, and now publishing
by W. ikvrving, &c.
The seenitarjr reed a motion ^ for publish-
iliff tira oilural, tinalietiable^ and iroprescrip-
tifie rights Of man/' which was ordered to be
g&tieii to the oom. of union.
Ifovedf whenever a committee is nomi-
aatedi a day should be appointed for them
S'ving in their rMort [Agreed to] referred to
le committee o( reguiatieiis.
A HiotiOB for priating the eonrention bill
passed in the Irish paruament, which was
passed over.
It was moved that capt. Johnston should
ffeport some ciretmistantes to the convention,
lor whkh purpose the house resolved itself
sirto a commitcee, when he read the an ac-
cot. of the trial and sentence of D. HoH^
fyt teplinCkg the Duke Richmond's and
Wm. Pitt's resoHlflon for a parliamentary
teform. After whkh the chairman b^ng re-
plaoedy the 'Secretary moved that capt. John-
atone should be allowed the honours of the
tilting.
Citizen Wilson from Strathaven, and Haddow
fimn Hamilton, requested leave of absence
should be gjranted to them, and moved that
all the [societies! <jelegates wiio had lef% the
ooftvenoon should receive letters to return
iiMnediatoly and remain at their posts untH
the kapoitant business which was daily in-
troduced into convention should be properly
diicussed. A. Scott proposed that he would
^v» a cirouhr letter to the delegatee in ^e
GaMCt^er gratis.
A ttocien of WHlA. Campbells for a re»«
gular set of books for the insertion of minuted,
iMliOBs, Ins. and o*«f pfoceisding§, a book of
fiaanoe for Ihe inspection of [finan] an iiltfjF-
mediato eotnmifiee» ^bkh passed with ^is
assoBdttieiitithat evef^ person who made and
aeooadad » afNUtiou should subscribe hi» of
tfatirMmes in thebook for copying kl ih6
motions that have passed .
A motton* firom Atex. Fortune for rdliting
diamt made by aristocratic authors was re*
Icmd 19 the- committee of union.
A niotion from Mr. Margarot for everv
dafejgato to t(A)acribe the minutes as a mark
ef lns[approbatioftand} resolution to abide
brlhem which teys over for consideration of
toe eonventioa of monday:
Oitiien Brown [last] being appd. last night
to dratr up an answer to the letter which the
mii^ciition received containing d gs. read his
asawer, which was approved of, and ordered
toberpabHsbed iU the Gazetteer.
A motion of D. Downie to fine those mem>^
hen who did not attend their sections. The
Older of the day wks called for.
^ A naotioD for drawing out a scroll of a pe-
titibn to parliament being ready the order of
the day was moved uodn it.
Fottr'^tenKhaofaooUeeiionwas made, and
A. D. 17M. [450
the conventkm [moved] a^Joomed till5o*clock
on Monday.
Monday, 3 Decern., 1793.
1st Year British Convention.
ISth day's ^ttting.
Citizen John Clark Mason, in the chair,
and citizens Downie and Romanes assistants
at the teble, read the minutes of last sitting.
Upon it being moved that citizen Smith's mo^
tion for petitioning parliament be discussed
immediatelv. It was agreed that citizen
Smith should withdraw it and present ano*
ther.
The motion presented [yesterdayl on Sa-
turday by citizen Margaret was reau by the
secretary, when citizen Margarot rose, and
supported it as well as citizen Callender, who
^w the necessity of people subscribing to
their principles, [and stand] citizen Brown
did not see the motion necessary, as any
member of [it] the conveotion womd be lia^
hie to the penalties incurred by an act of the
convention altho' 40 miles absent from it at
the time it passed.
Citizen Margarot pled that no man was
bound for any act of the convention at which
he was not present. ,
Citizen Brown defended the opposite prin-
ciple, and Hkistfated his argument by the ease
Or a p^r who was hanged for bein^ in the
company of some poachers who killed a game^
keeper, tho' has lordship had left them before
the deed #a^ perpetrated.
Citizen Margarot presented ntt amendment
of his motion which was seconded by citizen
[Brown] CaUender. andfapproved of by citizen
Brown, who defenaed the lesdit^ of our meet-
ings and the constitnfionai principles upon
which we meet, and recommended unani^
mity as the basis of our strength and success.
Citn. Skirving insisted that all the mem-
bers both of ^e convention [of) and of the
pritnary societies should subscnbe a solemn
lemie and covenant.
Citizen Callender considered the whole
members to be alreadv bound.
Citizen Gerald pled for liberality of senti-
UientSy and compared the people and their
enemies to the worshippers of the true God
and B«tl. He afterwards read some para<>-
graphs froni tlte Edinburgh Herald, with suit-
able comments and compared the constitu-
tion of lt88 to a dead horse. He [defended]
showed the insipidity of the title gentleman,
and the popriety of the term citizen; — re-
marked the impropriety of the mode of pro-
mulgaling our laws by restricting them to be
sold oy one printerj and publishing them in
the Saxon charact^ which few can read. —
[He]. After many other remarks humorous
and serious, he concluded by observing that
the signature assumed by the author A. B.
was very proper as his knowledge did not
seem to go beyond the two first letters of the
alphabet.
430] M GGORGE III. Proceedings agaimi WUliam Shmng [MO
Citizens [Mofi&t] Newton, Mealmaker, and
AitchiesQD expressed their doubts of the ne*
cessity of the measure recommended in the
amendment which Mr. Browne removed.
Citizen Altchison said he was satisfied. —
Citizen Jas. Smith thought it savoured too
much of the measures of Ministry in fishing
for loyai addresses. — Citizen Mesdmaker was
oi the same mind.
Citizen Msurgarot defended the measure as
a good precedent for future legislators.— Citi-
2en Skirving also pled for the motion^ [and]
insisted that it was proper on idl occasions to
{consult] take the opinion of the primary
societies, and considered the convention as
only a committee of the people.
. Citizen Callender objectea to the measure
^ imnecessary, and acknowledged himself
.wron^ in having seconded it.
. Citizen Margarot showed several advan-
tages that would flow from passing the mo-
tion, particularly in stopping the mouths of
our enenies.
. Citizen Philip said, whatever became of the
motion, be would report to his constituents.
Citizen Browne msisted that as citizen
Callender had objected to the motion he had
signed, he begged his name mightbe inserted
in his stead.
. Citizen Margarot pled in favour of the mo-
tion, that the approbation given by many
.thousands of their constituents in London,
jShefEeld, Norwich, Leeds, &c.
The motion being put to the question was
aneed to with one dissentient voice, who
wterwards withdrew his opposition.
Citizen Brown read a spmted advertisement
from tl&e Nottingham society, inserted in a
Sheffield newspaper.
Citizens Mealmaker and James Smith be-
ins [were] appointed collectors— nineteen
shillings and three-pence three farthings were
drawn and delivered to Mr. Reid the trea-
surer.
, A motion was made by citizen Scott and
seconded by citizen Aitchieson, that the con*
mention shall pass some resolutions respecting
the late unprecedented and unwarranted in-
iirineements on the freedom of the press, par-
tiouarly the arbitrary sentence of Judge Wil-
6oa against Mr. Holt for reprinting the d.
Df Ricnmottd'8 and Mr. Pitt's plan ofreform.
The tickets being collected, the sections
were divided as follows:
No. 1. — John Noble, James Calder, James
Tod, Peter Moi&t, James Wilkie, John Wil.
3on, John Auchinlech, David Brown, Archd.
Binny, Wm. Bomanes, Jas, Foyer, Willm.
Fleming, Mitchel Young, M. C. Browne
Thomas Kennedy, Wm. Robertson, [Mr.
tCockbum] loglis, Davd. Lyon,Robt.Orrock,
U. Johnston! Dd. M'CiUloch.
No. 9. — Wm. Johnston, Wm, Eelback,
Peter Wood, John Wilson, Alex. Reid, Alex.
M<Kenzie, James Smith, Geo> Ross. John
Clark, James Lawson« John Muir, David
VQwsm, John Thynne, A. Knox, D, Taylor,
Thos. Cockbum, Jo. Johnston, Jo. Grin&y.
No. d.-iOeo. Mealmaker, Willm. M<Cub-
bin, Rob. Christie, John Dttvies, Alex. For-
tune, Will. Bonthorne, Alex. Aitchieson,Maur.
Margarot, Willm. Philp, John Wyld, . Peter
Hunter, James Bell, John Thomson, Andw.
Newton, Willm. Campbell^ Wm. Mo£bt,
David Bertie, Jas. Smith, Paisl^.
No. 4. — ^Archd. Wrieht, Jos Gerald, Alex.
Scott, Geo. Brockly, Jas. Thompson, John
Dunn, Dav. Gowans, Jas. Cannicasel, Willm.
Ross, Alex. Bremner, John Gourlay, John
Wardlaw, John Buchanan, Jas. Somervul,
Geo. Callender, Thos. Smith, Alex. Bell, James
Tweedie, George W^addell.
Citizens Alex. Scott and A. Callender
moved, that the British convention take im*
der consideration [whether they] a resolution
passed at last meetine of the Scotch conven-
tion, to petition the Commons House of Par-
liament for a parliamentary reform.
Citizens James Smith and Peter Wood
moved, that this convention take under con-
sideration, whether, afler the contemptible
manner in which the late petitions for partial
mentary reform were treated, they shall again
petition for reform, or at what period uiey
shoold recommend the same to tneir consti-
tuents.— ^The meeting concluded with prayer*
13th day's Sitting.
The meeting elected citisen John Wilson
president for this daVs sitting; and citiaens
xortune. Young, and WardJaw^ assistants at
the table.
The secretary read a commission from
Perth, appointing citizens Malloch and Smith
delegates for the societies in that town, which
appomtmentthe convention approved of una-
mmously.
The secretary having read last night's mi*
nutes, the convention proceeded to business.
Citizen Brown, of Sheffield, produced a
commission from the Leeds Constitutional So-
cle^, appointing him their delegate, wiiidi
was received ana approven of by the conven*
tion.
The convention, upon a motion by citizen
Campbell, recommended to the societies to
meet as usual, in their respective societies^
for receiving new members.
The committees were called upon for their
re{)orts. The excuse from tiie committee of
u|iion was received. The committee.of regu-
lations produced some additional rules for the
consideration of the convention, which were
[submitted] reported citizen Maiigarot, one
by one, after the convention biid agreed, 'Imf
a vote, to postpone the final consideration till
the whole should be printed, and laid under
the consideration of toe sections.
After hearing Mr. Marsarott, the additional
regulations were ordered to be printed, and
laid before the sections to-morrow.
, Upon a motion by Mr. Skii^ing, that the
list of subscriptions for promoting poiiticsl
knowledge in the Highlands, ^oulfl .be ie«
»41]
JhrStikum.
A. a 1704.
£442
miOei lo the cbrnmittee on dutt biuiiiess, be
promoted ia mch maimer u tfaey shail judge
neceasenr. The conventioii accordkigly re*
nitted the aune.
Blr. Soott's motions and lesohitions being
ready dttzen Aitcbieaon ^ms called upoiu in
ahsrace of dtiaen Scott, the mover, todetend
them, [butj who said, that his sole motive
in [signmg them] seconding them, was, that
they might get a &ir hearine.
Citizen Margarott oppoaea the business, as
foreign lo that which we were met upon, and
thought it unnecessaiy to attempt to lop off
the mnches, while [citJaenSkirvrng] we were
endeavouring to
Callender defended the resolutions,
as necessarily connected with the business be-
Ibceus.
Citizen Skirvii^ insisted, that we had no
proper data, or official infonnalion, to proceed
upon.
Citizen Aitchieson argued, that the news-
papers, however false in other respects, could
not err in relating matters of this kind, and
j^roaosed, that as Mr. Scott was absent^ the
farUier consideration of the mbtion and reso-
lutions should either be postponed till to-mor*
row eveninsL or remittea to a committee.
Citizen Margarot had no ol^jection to a de*
lay, but urted .many reasons why either no
notice sboidd be taken at all, or only a slight
passed, and mentioned
Citizen Brown arKued, that the persecution
of individuals served the cause of reform, and
therf^ore it would be improper to stop them
in their present career.
The president having put the question, to
proceed or delay the consideration of the mo-
tion, it was unanimously agreed to delay it till
to-morrow.
Citiaens Wild and Jo. Clark bmg appointed
collectors, eighteen shillings and nine-pence
were coBeded.
A commission of delegation from Paisley,
in favour of [Mr.] citizen James Smith, was
read^ and his name ordered to be enrolled.
The new delegates from Paisley and Perth
were added to the committee of finance, who
sppointed to meet at Ross \ past 3.
Citizen Aitchnon moved, that the office of
dep. sec. be abolished.
Citizens Gordon, Murray, and John Ward-
lawy moved, that the sentences of different
courts, asainst our brethren in the cause of
libei^, soottld be printed and jpublished to
the world, that the world may judge of the
merits of these merciAil sentences.
Citizen Mancarot moved an iionicel amend*
/neni of C. A. Scott's motion.
Edinburgh, '4 Dee. 1793.
14th ^tting of the B. Convention.
No reports being received fron^ any of the
secfiens, save one, after prayers by tKe presi-
dent of the former sitting, Mr. M^bbin w«8
unaniitiously caHed to the chair; James Wil-
son, from Paisley, to the council table.
Read the minutes of last sitting. Called
for the reports, if any, from committees.
M. Marffarot begged leave to bring in a mo-
tion, to uie effect that the moment of the il-
legal dispersion of the present convention, be
considered as our summons to repair to the
place of meeting appointed for the convention
of emergency by tne secret committee, and
that the same motion be considered thiseven-
ing.— Leave was accordinsly granted.
The convention then neard the only two
motions on their table read, wlueh regarding
the same matter, and it being objected that
the business of these motkins was to be taken
up to-morrow evenine, after some conversa-
tion It was carried, by a vote of the house,
to delay further conversation till to-morrow
evening.
M. Margarot being prepared to bring for*
ward his motion above* mentioned, the same
was taken under consideration, and is as fol-
lows:—
That the moment of any illegal dispersion
of the present convention, slmll be consi-
dered as a summons to the delegates to repair
to the place of meetins appointed for the con-
vention of emergency by the secret commit-
tee, and that the secret committee be en-
tnistcKl to .proceed without delay to fix the
place of meeting.
The convention having considered the mo-
tion fMly, unanimously resolved the same,
and appointed the secret committee to proceed
as desired.
Citizen Scott brought forward his moved
resolutions, relative to the severe sentences
passed agataist Daniel Holt, the printer, &c.
A commission to citizen James Boyd, from
the Friends of the People in Kilmarnock, to
represent them in this convention, was read
and sustained. An amendment was pro-
posed, by way of substitute to C. A. Scott's
resolutions; as was also another resolution,
by way of substitution to same, was o£ferea
by cit. Margarot, and read.
After some conversation, the convention,
upon a motion by the sec. agreed to refer the
motion, with amendments^ to the mover, the
amenders, together ii^ith citizens Brown, Ge-
rald, and Callender, and appointed them to
report against Saturday first, at the fiurthest.
Read the following motion by dt, Callen*
der:—
(BUmk.)
449] 94 GEORGB III.
Accounts of the proceedingt oC the Conven-
tion^ after it had assumed iXs second (ienmm-
uatian^ were published in Nos. 78, 79, and
80 of a newspaper called the Edinbis^
Gazetteer, and were admitted m et Idenee
against Skinring a(nd the others. Lortl chief
baron Duadas has kindly furnished me with
the ahove^aentaoned numbers of. the Ga»
setteer, from which I have extracled the ac-
counts in <][uestion.
(Eiinh. Gat. No, TB,)
** British Convention of Delegates of the
Pe^e, associated to obtain Universal
Su^age and Annual Parliaments. -
Tuaday^ November Idl^-W. Hart in the Chair.
^ After the roll was called, new coonniseions
•cad, and additional delegates added to the
Kst; it was resoived, on a motion by M.
Marsarotr-^
** That a committee be appointed to draw up
rules for the internal government of the con-
vention.
** And, on a motion by C. Sinclair —
^ That the resolutions presented by loid
Daer to the first general convention be re*
nitted to that committee.
<* J.. Ooiirlsfy moved, that lord Daer be called
to ^ chair, wfaldi was seconded by thedepu^
secretary, but opposed by lord Daer himself,
and by J. OeraM and C. Sinclair, as favouring
too- much of the spirit of aristocracy.
** Upon whicli-^
A. Callendcr was called to the chair.
** Seveml motions for appointing comautteea
kaving been made —
^ Lord Daer observed, that to avoid an aris-
tocr^tidU dependence on committees, it would
be better to dela^r appointing any until a pro-
per mode of electing them was agreed upon.
** ftesolved,
'' That all committees which may be here*
after appointed, shall sit in the forenoon, and
the convention in the evening.
Wedne$day: — ■■ ■ Jackson in the chair.
" Lord Daer read the report of the commit-
tee appointed to draw up a plan for the in-
temal police of the convention.
'^ The convention then proceeded tothedis*
cussion of the clause of the report which pro-
posed to. form the members into a number of
smail sectinos or divisions.
** lAjrd Daer read it a second time, and made
observations explanatory of the nlan. He
said, that in considering a methoa by which
the convention should conduct their proceed-
ings, the committee had not been suided by
the narrow principle of fonning a pmn suited
solely to the present meeting ; thev had en-
deavoured to present not what might be pro-
per for this convention only, but for otners
rocea^s ^g^uMd WUIum SUning [444
wfaifibfnay be more lespcctalde in nonAer^
and of pester importaaee to* tlK country.
His brddiip observed that this method of &.
vidine the convention into sections of a few
members each, wouM be found of the greatest
utility. It was veiy properly reSoWed, that no
Suestion should be determnied on the same
av OB which it was proposed. This was an es-
ceUent rule, btt it would not sitliciently
guard arainst the e^ is was intended to pre-^
vent People wovld frequently Ife as much
taken by Surpiise on the second day as oil
the first, but by debtfliag in the sections eveiy
question before it came to be discussed in tbie
convention, the members would understMKi
the subject clearly, would form their opinions
in their different sections, and come to the
convention in the evening determined how
they were to vote. — ^Thus a great deal of use*
less discussion would be prevented, and tiie
proceedings of the convention conducted witii
greater regularity, by having every question
previously debated.
^^ His lordship observed, thai this measure
would likewise be of great advantaee in brinj^
ing forwmd individmil abihty. In certam
classes of mankind, which Ind, of late, by
some nersons, been very much despised and
abaseo, sreat abilities were firequently to be
found. Many would deliver their sentiments
freely in small companies, who cannot in a
public meetini^ Ituis the pmctice of puMto
spMking wott^ be pmoiotea, diffident mem-
bers would acquire a proper degree of assur-
ance, and be able lo deliver tiien* sentiments
with ease, in the convention. He concluded
with saying, that it might, perhaps, have a
good effect in another view; those who were
exceedingly fond of speakinff would have an
opportumty of satisfying uiemselves before
they came here, and so give less interruption
to the business.
^* A very long and interesting debate took
place upon the question.
<< It was obsenred by Bfr.C. Brown, of Shef-
field, andafterwards repeated by lord Daer, that
the divisions would be of great use in choos-
ing committees. In large assemblies when-
ever a person was proposed for a committee-
man he was. however unfit for the ofiice,most
commonly elected, because it would be con*
nderiBd invidious in any one to rise and make
objections, especially before the person's face.
In the divisions this difficulty would be done
away. There the merits of every person pro-
posed conld be scratiniaed with freedom, and
their character and abilities inquired intu.^-»
II would be found, therefore, that the appoint-
ing of proper committee-men was one of the
greatest advantages of this measure.
** After She subject had been amply dis*
cussed, it was lesoived-—
1. '^ That the convention shall be fonned
into sections.
2. ^ That esds section ^udl consist of fif«
teen members.
S. *^ That they .shall meet every day at IX
445^
for SmUiionn
A. D, 1794^.
[446
o*clock A. M. in places appoioled by them-
selves..
4. ** That they shall be chosen by lot.
5. ** That they shall be ceoewed once .a
week.
The convention then proceeded to estsbUeh
the mode of choosing comsuttees ; and after
a long discussion it was deleriiuoed*tbattfaQr
should be chosen in the ioUovring manner,
▼is.
1, '' That the number of eoinmit|«&«ie&
shall be fixed by the convention.
9. *< That each section shall make out a
hst of names equal in number to the com*
9iittee proposeo^and affix lo each name the
number of voters.
3. ** That ffovi these lisle the secretary of
the convention shall make out a leetp^ eoo-
sisting also of the same nun^wr as the in-
tieodeo committee.
4. '^ The priority of the leet shall belong to
those who have the greater number of indi*
vidua! votes.
5. ^' That the leet so formed shall be read
hy the secretary^ and each name on the leet
sustained or rejected by a vote of the oonven*
tion.
^ It was next resolved, that a committee
ehould bo appointed for drawing up a plan of
union between the Scottish and EeRTi^ so-
cieties for parliamentary reform : and it being
determined that this committee should con-
sist of thirteen persons, the divisions were or*
dared to return lists containing that number
of names next day.
Thursday, — M. Margarot in the Chair.
^ The sections gave in the lists for the
committee of union, which. waS appointed
agreeaWy to the regidations establiaoed yes-
terdfur.
** When the election was concluded, the
president ebserved, that thU oommittee was
appointed for a moet important purpose* and
Whieb would produce an evest ctfipanlleled
in the history of mankiody m. the union of
the two eountriesy without the inletference of
government.
*^ A. Callender. As this is a business of so
momentous a nature, I propose that the oom-
initiee be empowered to request the siSsbtance
nf evisry member wiio can give any informer'
tion which may be useful in drawing up the
plan of union.
^ M. C. firown.-r»I agree that it is vexy pro-
1>er ibr the committee to get atl the informa-
tion possible from their fellow-citixens ; I
theremre move, that the convention be formed
into a general coomiittee, so that the mem*
bcffs may have an opportunity of detiToring
their sentiments aa onen as possible on the
autuect.
** Thb motion met with some opposition.
* '* Buchanan proposed that the oommittee
T^
»*»*
* Xeei is a Scottish word, signifying a list
drawn up for election.
should draw up a plan, give itinto the sections,
and Jet it come before the convention in the
proper form.
« J. Gerrald.^If we wish to anrive at truth,
it is necessary that we have as much infor-
mation as possible on the subject in whkh
we are engaged. The ooaversation of thie
meeting, though desultoiy, may afford man^
usefid tunts to the committse. Btkrt we sit
down to write, it is proper that we have pre-
pared our minds for the subject. In a busi-
ness of this nature, he wbo has only his pen
in his hand, will be butof little seinrice ; and
a wise man has told that in many counsela
there is much wisdom. I thenrfbce second
qitiaen Brown's motion.
<< The question being put to a vote was car*
ried in the affirmative.
General Committee. -^ M. Margarott re-
called to the chaSr.
'' M. C. Brown. — ^I beg leave- to observe,
on the behalf of my constituents (who, thot^h
stated to the convention at the lowest calco*
lal3on of 9,000, because we would avoid the
appearance of eiaggeration, are, I can assure
you, not much under 6,000), that a unkm
with their brethren in Scotland is the wish
nearest their hearts ; and, aa they have dele-
gated me to represent them in this conven-
tion, they will consider themselves bound by
what passes here.
'^ I would suggest merely as a hint, which
every citizen here may revohrein his mind,
to consider how conventions may be brought
to produce the greatest poss^>le advantage to
the country.
** It may be proper to determine, whether
the nextconventionistobe held in Engkmd or
not I throw out this hint that we may turn
our mincU to that object aa soon as possible ;
but whatever place is determined on, I doubt
not that it will be numerously attended, andL
if proper time had been given to the Sheffield
a9cie\y; in place of having only one delegate
at thia oottvention, I am convinced they would
have had at least forty.
^^ I have not a doubt if next convention
should be held in England, that it would be
agreeable to our brethren in this country.
Scottish citisods raa^ wish to meet the frienoa
of freedom on English ground. But whether
it be held in England w in Scotland, I hope
we shall always . meet with hearts imitsd to
promote the cause in which we are engaged.
«,. ■■ .Hastie. — I have no olyectionto the
proposition of citizen Brown, that the neat
convention should meet in England; but I
suppose the most material thing is to claim
our rights; the spot of ground on whie h we
do tlUs I appreheml is of little moment Eng-
lishmen iad Scotchmen have declared for
universal suffrage and annual parliaments; for
to obtain those ol^ects they have united ?
they will proceed until they are secured, or
yield the pursuit only with their lives.
" If any other place is to be fixed for the
447] 34 GEORGE III. ProceeMngs against WUUam Skirving [448
laeetioff of the aext conventi<>ii, I woiM |m>-
pose to tiold it on the bonlers of England and
Scotland.
« A. Callender. — This is a transaction
which I think never occurred before, the free
an<l voluntary union of the people of two
countries to recover their common rights —
rights of which they were deprived at the
same period : I mean at the union of the two
crowns. For no sooner had James got him-
self seated on both thrones, than he began
to violate the liberties both of the English
and Scotch, and used every endeavour to render
himself absolute.
*' V^e must publish the plan on which we
are united to the world ; we must prove to
the people that our meetings are for their
good, and that it will be to their advantage
if we obtain the obiects we have in view. We
may then proceed Doldly in our course, and be
certain, that in the end we shall be crowned
with success.
** J. Buchanan. — I propose that we shall state
what are our riffht% that all the societies shall
enter into a solemn engagement never to re-
linquish their proceedings until they have
obtained those rights, and that no partial re-
form given either to England or Scotland
Shall be satisfactory.
*' J. Gerald. — Wluitever difference of opinion
may arise within these walls, I suppose we
have all one common object in view. — ^We
all live under the same form of government
*->have the same grievances to complain of,
and seek the same redress. It- was justly ob-
served by citiien Callender tiiat soon aftejr
the union of the crowns of England and Scot-
land, the people of both countries were de-
vrived of some of their most valuable privi-
leges. It was from that period that the
greatest encroachments began to be made on
public liberty ; but if that union has of>erated
to rob us of our rights, let it be the object of
the present one to regain them. If the event
exists for our shame, as it has existed for our
chastisement, let it also exist for our instruc-
tion.
** Some doubts have been introduced respect-
ing our right to universal sufirage.— I appre-
hend that we may justlv claim it as our inhe-
ritance from nature ; but we can with confi-
dence, because we can with truth, appeal to
antiquity for our title to this right ; ana it wiU
be mund to have been exerpim by our an-
cestors in its fullest extent. It must be con-
fessed, however, that in the early periods of
our history, there existed a body of men GnUed
slaves ; happUy this distinction does not exist
m our days ; and if there are political t^yta^
h is time that they should exist no longer.
In establishing the right of universal suf-
frage, the convention may perhaps give of-
ience to the satellites of despotism ; but while
wc can esteblish our demand on the immu-
table principles of justice, we may at the same
time prove that it is perfectly agreeable to
the spirit of our constitution.
t
[ ** Under the Saxon government, the people
i met frequently in the difierent divisions of
; the country, in assemblies called Folkmotes:
: there they deliberated ; there every man had
a voice in choosing his representative; the'
concurrence of the people was necessary to
the. administration of government, and they
obeyed the laws which they themselves had
made. The king of England used to sit in
. the Folkmote; and I believe it would be*
more to his own advantage if he sat there
now.
" In the progress of time, however, great de-
viations have been made from the original
purity of the constitution, and the national
representation has been supposed to be some-
times influenced by. motives, not altogether
congenial to the happiness of the people.
Human nature is so constitoted, that eveiy
man is inclined to pursue his own individual-
interest in preference to that of others. If you
appoint a man to act as your agent, &nd niiake
his situation such that he has every tempta-
tion to betray you, without incurring the
danger of being called to an account, the pro-
babuity is that he will sacrifice your interests
to his own. It is therefore, that a iree suf-
frage of the people is what every man ought
to desire, as that alone can make the interest
of the representative and his constituent tiie
same. Tne sreat art of eovemment, I ap-*
prebend, is this, that all mould be governed
oy all ; but unnappv is the country where
men are called upon by every mterest to act
in opposition to tneir duty.
** Much of late has been said about meet-
ings of mobs — I apprehend that no meeting
ofthe people can be called a mob if their de-
liberations be directed towards the public
good ; but if men meet for an opposite pur«
pose, for promoting the misery or the destruc-
tion ofthe human race, thoueh they should
sit with crowns on their heads and sceptres
in their hands, they are truly a mob.
"Were Idl mankind to assemble m public
meetings, one of two things must follow, ei-
ther th^ wiU behave properly or improperlv;
if properljT, their meeting will tend to do
good;' if improperlv, it carries its own cure
along with it. The people will be soon
brought into a better memod, by a sense of
setf-preservation, by which they will conect
the errors into which they have Alien.
** It may occur that the voice of the people
will be wrohe when their understandings
are perverted ny priestcraft, or darkened hy
golitical superstition, like the voice once
eard in Jerusalem, of *^ cradfy him, crucify
him,'' when that nefiirious deed was perpe^
trated,at which the Sun hid bis head hi
darkness and in blood. But were the tyranta
ofthe earth as solicitous to enlighten, as they
are to punish those unfortunate subjects;
were goVemments to instruct the poor instead
of hansing up thenr bodies on gibbets, the
voice <K tu^e people would then be the vo9b
ofGod. .
449]
Jbf SeiUioth
A«^ IX 1794*
[450
'(By tfaeNormnicoiiqaesty ormther robbery
(fiiirtnattransactioD, likeerery o^ier, istofa«
comidered by its conseqtieDces) the right of
verting was greatly curtailed; out sorely we
GftDy with great propriety, meet to petition
parUament for the restoration of the right of
uniTersal snfira^ ; a ri^ht which is so ne-
cessary to the just administration of govern-
laent; for if any man comes and tells me
that I must pay a tax to which I never con-
sentedy neither by myself nor my representa-
livey What am I to think of the legality of
his claim ? Whenever money is taken nt>ra
the people by a military power, or by any
other authority not delegated by themselves,
cal that government what you will, it is a
government of force — it is the sword which
governs. The right then of universal suffrage,
of which we have been so unfortunately and
uqjustty deprived, I repeat, is not only a
national ri^t, but also an inherent principle
of the constitution. In the eariy periods^ every
man had a vote for his representative. With
some little variation, the practice continued
fer ages; it underwent considerable altera-
tions at the conquest; a period at which tiie
goodly fabrick of Anelo-Saxon government
was undermined, and toe structure of tyranny
erected in its stead.
^ It has been observed, that the revolution
of 1688, did not produce the advantages which
might have been expected from such an
evmt. It is true, that at the revolution, imi-
▼ersal sufifraee was not dispensed to the people
tvith that liberality whicn it ought to have
been ; but stiU the present form of govern-
ment in my opinion, no more resembles the
revolution, thui a dead putrid carcase does a
liviiur body.
'^ The pri^pal advantage of the revolution
waSy that it made the chief ma^ist^^ res-
ptonsible for his trust, by establishing the
right of the people to alter the line of succesr
frion to the throne. The house of Hanover, i^
tfaflj are wise, will not be averse to revolution
priiiciples ; for it is in consequence of those
|pruieiples, that the preseQt monarch reigns
JO Britain. ^A worthy member, J[ believe,
]vith the best of intentions, called another to
Older, and said he was going too far;-!-no
mas, I appEehend, eoes too far, unless be
goes beyond the nue of right — ^nlegs h^
violatey the truth. If the members who comr
pose a govemm^t ^b^se their trust, may
they not be resisted ? And Jf there existed a
fight in any preceding generation to amend
jthe .cQOstitutioo, can it. b^ said, ths^t that
r^t does not equally belp^g tp the present?
^ JUet us then endeavour to instructthe people
in tl^eir right^ and to inforpi them of our
yiqwa and our intentions^ tbey will come and
fiign our petitiona, and we shall be epabM
to send them up siibscribed by. a n^joritv of
the people. The vi^ of ^ people .wil( be
neard, whenever it is spoken in the Jaoeuag^
.of truth, and by a number so respectable as
to command attention ; and it wiir$o6n have
VOL. XXIII.
that respeetaibiUfy, if we have reason on our
side.
'^ As to the manner in which the union is to
be- formed, we may find precedents for it in
our early history ; but the first thing to be
done is to enhghten tlve people — endeavour
to diffuse the principle on which you act.
When you have got a sufficient number in
every district, estabhsh a correspondence
among them — show them the necessity of unit-
ing in the common plan of co-operation, then
the people assembled in the different depart-
ments of the country, will resemble the ancient
Folkmotes, and will speak in language too
reasonable to be confuted, and too peremp-
tory to be refused.
^ The manner in which they should or^ize
themselves, is of very important considers-
tion ; and they ought to be particularly care-
ful what persons they choose for delegates to
the next convention ;— let them be plain men,
such as I see here — none who nave ever
breathed the pestilential air of a court, or
bowed the knee to aristocracy. — ^liet us re*
nounce all attachment to parties, and be no
more deceived by the pretended patriotism of
the great. During the American war, refor*
mers and patriots sprung up like mushrooms^
without any diminution of public burthens^— •
Like mushrooms they were short lived, for
they sprung from a soil of dung — a hot'-bed of
corruption. Pitt has succeeded to Fox, and
Fox to Pitt, without any reform being ob-
tained ! but let us no longer put faith in such
mep, unless they bring forward a reform
founded on annual parliaments and universal
suffrage-^that only is the kind of reform
which will satisfy the people, and which they
will never cease to claim as their due. Depend
upon it,, whenever the leaders of parties see
that the people are determined upon having
their rights, they will not only endeavour to
swim suong tlie stream, but will strive to di-*
rect its course — Trust thex not — they did
not come forward in the hour of public danger
— ^why then should they be trusted, when
they seek your fayour only for personal con-
venience }
" The city of Yoric has been proposed as a
proper and centrical place for the meeting of
next convention ; but I can assure you tnat
city is the seat of a prowlaristo€racy,the seat
of an archbishop ; however, I would pot ob-
ject to going there — as the Saviour of the
world was often found in the company of
sinners, let us go there for the sameiraqious
purpose, to convert to repentance. . Tlie bor-
ders of this country and England, was men*
tioned by another member, and I should
rather prefer some place there ; for we should
have this pleasing reflection, that we met for
proipoting philanthropy and peace, on the
ground which had be«n often drenched with
the blood of our ancestors. Let us then, i'eU
low citizens, unite he^and band to bur they
hatchet, of natural antipathy, which the
wicked policy of Courts once instigated us to
2 G
451] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings dgainstwaium Slirving [452
wield; let us brighten the chain of national
friendship— let there be no other wish either
among Scots or English, than to obtain free-
dom, and no other rivalship than who shall
best deserve it
" The Convention resumed.— M. Margarot,
called again to the chair.
^ C. Sinclair read some of the articles of
the report of the committee of organization :
and it was resolved,
<< That the preses shall be chosen by tlie
sections: each section returning one name
every day, and the priority to belong to the
person who shall have the greatest number
of votes.
^ That there shall be three assistants, one
ef whom shall go out of office every day in
lotation, and be replaced by another person,
who shall be elected in the same manner as
the pr<eses.
^Tbat the preses, secretary, and assis-
tants^ shall form the council of the table.
Friday.'
-Hastie in the chair.
** C. Sinclair reported the farther proEress
of the committee of regulations, upon which
the following resolutions were passed, viz.
** That as soon as possible, after that com-
mittee shall have completed their report, each
section of the convention shall be furnished
with a printed copy.
''That the straneers shall send in their
names to the counciTof the table, previous to
admission.
'' That strangers shall sit by themselves,
on seats appointed for that purpose.
** That no stranger shall upon any accoimt,
ait among the members, under the pain of
exclusion.
'' The committee asked leave to sit again.
Granted.
" It was moved by— Newton, that
the committee dsould appoint a day of solemn
fasting, pra^^er, and humiliation, to be kept
by all the friends of reform, in Great Britam
and Ireland.
*^ This motion occasioned a very warm de-
bate, which occupied a great part of the time
of the meeting.
^J. Gerald moved the following amend-
ment^ which, in a great measure, conciliated
the different opinions, and was agreed to.
** That it be reconmiended to the individual
members of this convention, and to all the
friends of liberty, in Great Britain and Ire-
land; to invoke the assistance of God Al-
mighty, the common father of dl, in the
cause m which we are engaged.
*^ It was next resolved,
'' That a committee be appointed to inquire
into the state of the finances.
^' That it shall consist of five members,
and be open.
** &i<iirc2ay.— -— -Urqtdiart in the chair.
« In consequence of several country delegates
having signified their intenti<m of goina to
their respective places of abode this evenings,
and returning to their duty in the convention
on Monday ; and as the committee of union
could not possibly finish their business until
tlie end of next week; the following motion,
moved by W. Muir, jun. and seconded by
M. Margarot, was submitted to the convea-.
tion; that such delegates as intended tore-
turn home, might be enabled to inform their
constituents, that the union of the societies
of England and Scotland, had actually taken
place.
« Moved, that in order to manifest that our
principles on the great object of parliamentaiy
reform, respecting universal sufirage and
annual pariiaments, are one. We are of
opmion, that a vote of the convention should,
witiiout delay, determine the unity of the
members of the two nations assembled for
that ^rcat and interesting purpose ; in order
to satisfv our constituents, and to show la
the world that we are determined to prosecute,
by all legal and constitutional steps, the two
important objects above mentioned^ until we
have obtained the end of our association.
" This motion parsed unanimously, and the
secretary proposed that the convention should
give their assent to this important motion in
a more solemn manner, than their ususil me-
thod of a show of hands.
'' A. Scott proposed, that the convention
should exnress their approbation of this mo-
tion, b;^ all the members joming hands.
*' This being agreed to, all Uie members
rose up, and join^ hands round the roooL
" The President then addressed the conven-
tion as follows :
** FelloMT citizens;— The union which we
have now accomplished will, I hope form an
important epoch in the history of our country.
— The event, indeed, is unprecedented; it is
the voluntary union of the people of two
countries long separated by ancient prejudices^
and unnaturu animonties, which nave beea
cherished by ignorance, and fomented bv the
artifices of courts, and the intrigues of fito-
tion. May this solemn emblem of the union
of the people, of North and South Britain be
ever impressed on their minds: may they
consider themselves henceforth only as bre-
thren, and be stimulated to a firm and manly
adherence in defence of their mutual rights.
** M. C. Brown. — ^Permit me. dtizen presi-
dent, to remark, that I ho^ie the distinctiobs
of North and Sbuth Britain will be soon for-
gotten, and that these countries, shall only
be known by the common name offiritain.
** C. Sinclair. — Citiaen president, I beg
leave to make a motion which naturally arisips
fiom that resolution which has just now so
cordially and solemnlv been passed. ' It is.
That this convention shall, from henoefe^,
be called
^ The British Convention of Delegates of
458]
y^
A. D. 1794>.
[454
•the People, associated to obtain Uni-
irersal Suffrage, and Annual Parliaments.
** Agreed to unanimously.
** C. Sinclair. — ^I believe there are none
here who have not felt the most lively sensa-
tions of joy and affection, on partaking
hi the solemn transaction which has just now
taken place ; but let us not forget those who
are afflicted in a neighbouring country. Let us
remember our brethren in Irelana. They
have a sham parliament which lords it over
them, and they cannot have the pleasure of
meetmg as we do now. I have therefore
flrawn up a motion respecting them, which I
sbsdl DOW read to the convention.
* ^'The motion was read, and being con-
sidered of very great imporUmce, was ordered
to lye over till to-morrow evening.
^ A committee was appointed to take into
consideration, a plan for assisting and support-
ing the Edinburgh Gazetteer.
^ Jdmiay^ Nov. 35. — ^M. C. Brown in the
chair.
^ The first motion which came before the
tonvention for discussion this evening, was as
follows : —
** That no motion having a tend^cy to ex-
dte'a discussion on religious subjects shall
be admitted in this convention.
''* k was stated, that this motion was brought
forward in order to prevent a debate of the
nature of that which took place on Friday
last, inconsequence of the motion of Newton,
fiom occurring again. But it being observed
lltatthe convention might reject any- motion
proposed, tibey could avoid relijgious discus-
sions, by throwing out such motions as might
bave tbst tenden^r.-^-Passed to the order of
the ^ay on this and several other motions on
religious subjects.
^^ Read again and passed, C. Sinclair's mo-
tion respecting the United Irishmen, viz.
^ The British donvention of Delegates of
the People, associated to obtain universal suf-
irage and annual parliaments, taking into their
consideration the oppressed state of their
brethren in Ireland, and the unconstitutional
act of the last session of the parliament of
that kingdom, called the Convention Act;
and seeing, with indienation, that by it the
people of Ireland were aeprived of those rights
cheaply purchased with the blood of our oom-
mon ancestors, and which are confirmed and
secured to us by the great charter of our
liberties. Resolved,
^ That all or any of the patriotic members
of the Societjr of United Irishmen of Dublin
shall be admitted to speak and vote in this
convention.
^ Dividing the convention into new sections,
agreeably to the plan adopted on Tuesday,
occupiea the remainder of this sitting.
** November 2d.
** Read the report of the Oaietteer com-
nittee.
^ The following -motion of A. CaUender
came under the consideration of the conven*
tion.
** Moved, That in case the minister, or any
other member bring into the House of Com*
mens a motion for a Convention Bill, as
passed in Ireland, for preventing the people
from meeting according to their just rights by
the Revolution, the same motion shall be
noticed to the delegates of the respective
societies immediately to meet in convention
to assert their rights. -^
** M. Margaret. — ^This is an excellent mo-
tion, and the event which it alludes to ought
to be the Tocsin to the friends of liberty to
assemble. Sx seems, however, to be imper-
fect— it does not mention any place of meet-
ing ; neither does it specif the time when
the delegates are to assemble, for the word
* immediately* is indefinite, ana will not con*
vey the same meaning to persons residing in
different parts of the country. By those who
live near to the place of meeting, it will bo
understood that they are to repair the next
day ; by those at a greater distance within a
few days ; and by those still farther off, a week
after such information is received. But the
committee of regulations have, in their report,
an article of the same purport, which, in my
opinion, is (Mreferable to our friend Callender's
motion; and as this motion comes properly
under the chapter of regulations, I wish that
it were referred to that committee ; I there-
fore move. That the report be read, that the
convention may judge whether the article I
allude to sufficiently provides for the intentioyi
of the motion now oefbre the convention.
" [The part of the report referred to by M.
Mareaxot, and which had not as yet been de-
ddea upon by the convention was read : it
proposed to invest an intermediate committee
witn tiie power of re-assembling the conven-
tion on particvJar occasions.]
<< M. Margarotw — I believe that the conven-
tion will be convinced, that this clause of the
report of the committee of regulations, com-
prehends the spirit and intention of Citizen
Callender's motion, and also extends farther,
in as much as it provides for a number of
cases equally dangerous to liberty, as a Con-
vention Bill It will be found, also, that this
business of calling a meeting of the conven-
tion, had better be entrusted to a select com-
mittee, appointed for the particular purpose
of watchmg every act which may mihtate
a^nst the rights of the people : and I main-
tain, that the proper place tor this motion to
appear, is among the regulations of the con-
vention.
^ M. C. Brown. — ^I cannot sit in this assem-
bly, and hear any measure proposed, which
appeared to me improper, without putting in
my protest against it. The motion of citizen
Callender, is, I think, infinitely better than
tiiat of the committee. And what does the
report go to ? That there shall be an inter-
mediate committee^ which, on certain emer-
4WJ S4 GBOtiGB IIL ProceedtMgt ^kkut Wmm SUrung
[466
ffiaci^ riiall odl a eonveoiUMi : Now -what i read, a >vann debate cofluneBCed, wluch al-
as the consequence? This committee can
sever call the delegates together but b^r let-
tersy and those letters can never be certain of
arriving ; for our enemies are numerous and
powerful, and it may be sunposed, that they
would not hesitate on sucn an occasion^ to
open all letters at the post office, and stop
those of the committee, for the purpose of
preventing the meeting of the convention.
*^ I agree, that the ivonlmg of Citicen Cal-
lender's motion, is not altogether so proper as
it might have been ; it is not sufficiently ex-
pliciti and I think it requires some amend*
ment in that respect : but the great diflference
between it and the report of the committee is
this c — if a resolution of the convention stand
in the form of the motion, nothing can prevent
the delegates fix>m knowing when they are to
rally ; on the contrary, if it stand in the rwi-^
lations of the committee, it never can be
made known to us, but through that medium^
and as the letters of the committee must be
sent by post, their arrival will, in this case, be
totally uncertain.
** With regard to the time, it has been ob-
served, that the word immediately, is indefi-
nite, and it is so in a certain decree, but it
evidently carries this meaning with it, as soon
after as posatbie. It was also obiected, that
there is no place of meeting stated in the mo-
tion, but I think my friend Callender was
very rieht in not mentioning any place; it
would have been presumption in him to dic-
tate to the convention, in a matter of such
importance.
** But what I woald most particidarly im-
press on the convention, is this^ to oonsider
of the method, by wmeh, we can foe best
brought together, on such an important oc-
casion; one of the methods proposed, appears
to me liable to miscarriage and interruption^
the other is fixed and certain.
^* The greater part of the members spoke in
this debate, wiuch continued all the Evening,
and the meeting -acyoiuned witkout teonuai;
to any decisic^.
** Wednesday, — G. Mealmaker \nitie chair.
<< The convention resumed the canaiden^
tion of A. Callender's motion.
^ C. Sinclair. In moving an taneodment
to citiEen Callender's motion, I must confess,
that I think it atapossible to mend its spirit ;
it breathes the spirit of a una anxious for the
cause of freedom. Perhapa tha partiality
wfaich.everjr man has for his own composi-
tion, may induce me to consider the motion
vrhich I am now to lay before you in too
fiivourable a point of view, but, considering
it preferable to citiaen Cdlender's, I feel it my
duty to submit it to the considoution of the
convention.
*' This amendment of citizen Sinclaiir, and
several other amendmente of the same mo-
tion pcopoaed by diffiorent members, being
most entirely occupied this sitting : But as it
was merely the wording, and net the pto-
priety of the motion, which became the ob*
ject of discussion, we omit any account of tha
speeches.— It was at last determined that tha
president should take the sense of the house
upon the following questions, viz.
'' 1. Does the convention ai)prove of tlie
spirit of citizen Callender's motion?
" 3. Does the convention approve of the
manner in which it is worded?
** The first of these questions was carried
unanimously in the affirmative. The second
was negatived by a great majority.
** A committee was then appointed, consist*
ing of the mover, the seconder, and idl the
amenders of the motion, who were ordered
to prepare one motion, in such terms as ap-
peared to them most proper, and submit it to
the consideration of the convention next day.
'* The committee respecting the Gazetteer
finished their report ; and the president desired
all the members of the convention to rfr-
eommend it to their coostituenta to support
that paper by 8ub6cri|>tioas, and every other
encour^ment in their power.
* Thursday, ^R. Taylor, in the chair. '
" The committee of finance reported pro*
gross, atid asked leave to sit asain. — Granted.
** C.Sinclair. — Citizen presiaent, your com*
mittee, appointed to amend citiaen Callender^
motion, sat this forenoon; and I shaU now^
if agreeable to the convention, submit to theif
eoifaideration the report of that committee.*^
Fellow citizens, you will feel that this report
is of the last importance. It claims our
most serious attention ; and is to be deotded
upon hy our united wiadonii and supportcll
by our united integrity.
** The 'house restolved itself into a ^neral
committee to consider the report, which m*
derwent a long discussion, and received seve-
ral amendmente in the committee; and whili
the convention was resumed, it passed una*
nimously in the form of a declaration and sa*
solutions (vide end ^tkis case),
" J. Gerald. — I rise to conmtulate thecoft*
vention on the adoption of this resolution^
not only on the propriety of the maatae
itself, but on that unanimity and solemnitgr
with whkh it has passed.
*' I have not been able to procure a copy of
the iniquitous act which nas excited such
abhorrence, but I have here the heads of the
bill in the speech of Mr. Grattan, the man
who, while he spoke against that bill, at the
same time betrayed the liberties of his coan<*
try. This bill, commonly called the €omre»*
tion bill, which passed in the last session' of
the parliament of Ireland, and which is the
prototype of what may be attempted in Bit*
tain, breathes such a spirit of cruelty and op-
pression, that if tyranny were to be personi-
fied, it could not speak in laQ^;iHae move in-
sulting to the feelings ofmaJikindT . . !
*s7y
JktSedkkm.
A. D. 17M«
[4fl8
. «< By tfae/Srirhaidv the Mtgtttt»4>fthK|»o.
pie are not aMowed to foeet to petition par*
fiament. Buraly de^potimi could not l»e mora
ition^ espressed even in Turkey c — There
every bashaw listens to the petitions of his
treoabling slaves $ vet tbat pnvikfe is denied
to the people of Ireland. But it has been said,
to use a common expression, thb bill was
first passed in Inland to feel the pulse of the
people of Bhtaini that our rulers doaight know
if it beat faieh with indignatien, or if the
blood can ooldiy in our veins^ and we are
willing to how ^w necks to the yoke, and
suffer m lear and in silence^
^ In the Meond head, the^ are forhidden to
meet for the purpose of asking the redress of
grievaacesf Good God! What is ^vem-
nient instituted for, if it is not for the redress
of grievances? I had tliought that in the
meet despotic government uie people were
peraMtted to utter their complaints, cuid beg
to be lelieved of their sufferings; but, at the
dose of the eighteenth c^itury, we fiiud ^is
last indulgence to slaves, denied to a part of
the Briiisb empire. Our government boasts^
that it is the best in the world ; but it is not
in Ireland tbat we are to look for its excellen-
cies.— Whenever a government tells the peof^
that they must not pethion, that govern*
ment is granny ; and whatever you may be
told of its acts of parliament in favour ef li-
berty, these acts or parliament are set aside;
they are mere pieces of parchment, and of no
more value.
**The Mtd head makes it a capital ofience
to coneiderof any public concern. Now, to
noake a rasd or build a bridge are public con*
eems; and, of coune^ the people of Ifelaad
cannot meet on business of that naluK^ with-
out ma^ifi^ themselves liable to the penal^
of this law.
<' Though Icould not get a copy of this hill,
the heads which I have read are sufficiently
exptanaiory of its detestable principlesi and
I flope the mcnsuve which has paissed tibis
night, will convinoe 4he minister, that we are
deAermined to guacd against every attempt
that may he siade to deprive us of our rights j
and though hy some it may be thought a
bold, by aame a daring measure, yet it will
be found the best for securing the peace of
our €tmat$y ; for if suoh a law were suffn«d
to pass ; if men were not allowed to utter
their 0Mnplailits,.a numi>er of fierce and ran-
coffoos passions would arise, and we would
seek to appeal lo that last terrible decision ; the
event ol which is unoertaini hut which God
and nalHto -allows.
** Iftfaeservility of the people had been less,
if they had dared te meet, and, in place of
tounnurinfe to have tdd their nders that
there was danger in seeking to deprive them
•f their libertMS, tve wouUT not have bad* to
adopt this resolution to-night.; but, when I
saw the calm deliberate countenances of all
present^ and the sdenm manner in which it
w^ poasedi I was convinced that it .would
not only ben resolution of wotds, b«t a nile
ofaction.
*' M. CBiown^^I b^g leave to make a few
observations, on this ocoask>n, in addition to
those which have fallen from ciliien Gemld.
That member of the Irish liouse of Commons^
who betrayed the interests of his country, n*
ceived from the j^eneroealy of the people of
Ireland a handsome fortuqe^ cmd his conduct
may teach us what we have to expect from
the members of our parliameot.
'* In a mixed government, liberty is often
more in danger than if the people bad no
parliament to depend upon, and they may
even be made slaves under the forms of the
law. The great influence of the minister in
this country, by having the disposal of all
places, civil and military, may materially en*
danger the national liberties, although au the
forms of the constitution are preserved.
" In arbitrary governments, the prinqs ia
afraid to commit any extraorainary act of
oppression, because, m such governments
there is no power constituted for the purpoee
of guardix^ the interests of the people ; he is^
therefore, sensible, that if he adopt any mea-
sure which excites general discontent, the
public indignation wul he turned upon him*
self alone : But, in this countiy, and under all
mixed governments, if the prince possess an
undue mfluenoe, not warranted by the con-
stitution, he may, by means of that secret
influence, corrupt a majoritv of the represen-
tatives of the people, render himself oon^
pletely absolute, and procure, through the
medium of a treacherous parliament, the es-
tablishment of the most obnoxious laws ; for
he knows that the popuktr fury will seldom
be directed against him.
'^ History fi«'nishes many examples illusti»-
tive of the observations I have made. WliMBn
Angustus triumphed over the liberties of
Rome, and became emperor, he knew it was
not his interest to destroy the senate ; on the
contraiy, be made it the instrument of his
power, and directed it at his pleasure. Thus,
It wiU always be found, that lio despotism is
more ceitain in its opmtion than that wfakh
is veiled under the form of liberty.
** If James the Sd had tried to establish the
BomanCathoUc Religion bv the means of par-
lifiment, it is most probable that he would
hav« succeeded. Ift in place of seeking to
reign without a parliament, he had, like the
last lienry, understood how to make it
subservient to his will, he might have dona
whatever he fdeased, and his i^sterity wanki
stiU have retained possession of the throne of
Brimin.
<< Since I have mentraned Heniy eth, let nn
ask, what did not that monster do by the
tfteansof aaervile parliament? Was it not
with the arm of parliament that he brought
to the scaffold ^e woman whom he chused
to sacrifice to his liuts? Was it not in the
18th year of that reien, that the parliament
dechred that the will of the kuig shoidd be
459] U 6E0K6B IIL Procei
law? Did not fhe crin^nal laws which he
enforced exceed, in number^ capriciousness
and severityy those of Nero, Caligula, or
Domitian. The history of this reign proves,
that Henry exceeded the most tyrannical of
his predecessors for what the^ scarce dared
to do with fearful and trembhng hands, he
did boldly, and with lafety, under the sanc-
tion of parliament.
"^ A secret committee was appointed to fix
a place for the meeting of the convention,
under the circumstances mentioned in the
preceding resolution.
^ rrujoy.—— Wilson in the chair.
1[lie most important business, which came
before the convention, thb evening. Was a
motion by A. Wrieht, for diflusine political
Imowledge in the Iiigblands of ScoSand.
** A.V^ght.-**! have for a considerable time
revolved tkis question in my mind, and
thouffh, I have alw^s had the measure pro-
tweel much at heart, I believe I would not
nave brousht it forward, at this time, had it
not been auo suggested by our own brethren
from the South.
** I cannot at present enter into a full enu-
meration of all the various species of ty-
ranny exercised over the people of the High-
lands. I shall only mention a few of the
hardships under which they labour: and
iirst, the law which was surely meant to pro-
tect die poor, as weil as the rich, is stnun^
to oppress the poor Highlanders. The smal-
lest trifle is maide an object of dispute, by the
tacksman or superior; and the unfortunate
tenants not being able to support the expenses
of a law-suit, are driven from their habita-
tions and families. The next thing I shall
aotice, is the pride of those petty despots,
the Highland lairds. One instance, I shall
state, ^1, 1 believe, excite the astonishment
of this convention; a Hishland gentlemen
had aa avenue, about a mile long, into which
none of his tenants dared to enter without
taking off his bonnet, and if he had occasion
to go to the house, thoueh in the midst of a
harricane, he was obliged to walk all the way
bare-headed.
** We have all heard of the drowning of sheep
lately by the people in a certain part of the
Highlands, but all the circumstances of that
uncommon case have not been made public.
] am well informed, however, that it was oc-
casioned by the most enormous oppression,
and insulting provocation. I have heard,
that when some of these poor people went to
complain of their sufferings to one of their
petty tyrants, he repli^ to them, ^ Is there
not water enoueh? go and drown yourselves."
^ The excise laws are an excessive burthen
in this part of the country, but nothing like
what they are in the Highlands. Tliere the
people do not properly understand the law,
andf the exciseman, taking advantage of their
ignwance, reigns with unbounded authority
UQong them*
Ogouui
[460
^ with respect to the salt duty, it is a mal*
ter of great importance, and I beg leave ta
read some extracts from the Bee,* which will
perhaps elucidate this subject better than any
thine I can say : —
[Here citizen Wright read some passages
firom No. 1 and 8, of vol. 6, of the Bee.]
** Another hardship which these people are
doomed to suffer, is the cruel practice of
forcins them to become soldiers. We have
often heard of Uie bravery of the Highlandera^
and their courage and nllantry has been ac*
knowledged andadmirea inevery quarter of the
globe, but little did their admirers know, that
these men, though prodigal of their blood in
the day of battle, were not voluntaiy soldiers^
that they were forcibly embodied and torn
from the bosom of their fomilies, with idl the
cruelty which can disgrace the African Slave
Thide. I can speak of this practice with the
greater certainty, because I have been a siif-
feierbyit In my early years I was marked
out as a proper object for the army, and I
was fixed upon by the laird's son, who had
eot a commission for raising a certain num-
ber of men, and who was determined to force
metobecomeaoo£Mfi^€er; not having, *how«
ever, any inclination for the service, I saved
myself by fiight The horrid measures used
by the monsters who recruit in the High-
lands, are scarce credible ; they confine men,
and starve them until they consent to be
soldiers ; thej pursue them every where, and
hunt them hke wild beasts in the hills, till,
by these, or such like diabolical means, the
unfortunate people are forced to yield, and
are driven like cattle to the slaughter. Some
have been seized in church on Sunday; they
had thought that they might at least go there
m 8g£ety; but no where can the poor High-
lander find an asylum when his hard wants
volunteers. Such are the practices publick
carried on m a part of Great Britain, which
we are so frequently told, possess the best of
all possible constitutions, and is the most firee
and happy country in the world.
** Let us then endeavour to enlighten our
brethren m the Highlands: let us inform
them of die principles on which we act, and
disseminate amone them a knowledge of their
rights. They will dow no longer to the yoke :
They will soon cease to be at the disposal of
their tyrannical masters.
<« M. C. Brown spoke next In an animat-
ed speech (which we are sorry we cannot in-
sert) he urged the propriety of the conven-
tion agreeing to the motion.
^ It was then resolved unanimously,
^ That this convention shall adopt some
constitutional means of difiiising poli-
tical knowledge in the Highlands of
Scotland.
** A member announced that there was a
visitor* present who offered five pounds to
• A Periodical Work^ published in Edin-
burgh.
t
461}
foft SedHion*
A. D. 1794.
[462
begin a subscription for canyine the above
resolution into effect — ^Honourable mention
in the minutes.
*' A letter addressed ^ To the president of
* the British Convention/ and subscribed * A
* Friend to Virtue and Reform, and an Enemy
* to Vice and Tyranny/ was read. It contain-
ed many patriotic sentiments, and stated,
that as the author was under ministerial in-
fluence, he could not openly join the cause of
freedom, being certain that if he took such a
step, he would be turned out of the office
which he possessed, and which was the only
means he had of subsistence: That having
read the last week's proceedings of the con-
vention in the Gazetteer, and observing that
the state of their finances were under consi-
deration, he enclosed two guineas as a small
mark of his approbation of their views.
** Moved, that a letter of thanks to this
worthy citizen for his patriotic donation, be
published. — Agreed to wianimously.
'^A member gave in a guinea which he
had received from a friend, who was obli»)d
to conceal his attachment to the principles
of the convention, being in similar circum-
stances with the author of the letter wfcdch
bad just been read. — He was ordered to re-
turn thanks to his friend in the name of the
convention.
^ Saturday, --Vf, Haddow in the chair.
'^ Resolved, that a committee, consisting
of three, be appointed to revise the minutes
of each sittins, so that they may be sent to
the press, ana a bulletin of the proceedings
of the convention, published datlv.
** Bead a letter in answer to the unknown
dtiasen, who sent the two niineas last night. —
Approved of, and orderra to be published in
the Gazetteer.*
* The letter is inserted in another page of
the same No. of the Grazetteer, and is as
follows :—
** To the worthy, but unknown Author of a
Letter addressed to the President, and
signed,
^ A Friend to Virtue and Reformy and an
JEnevty to Vtu and Tyranny,
'^Fellow Citizen ;~It b with the most lively
satisfiKtion that I obev the order of the con*
vention, to acknowleage the receipt of your
truly excellent letter, with the patriotic dona-
tion of two guinea notes contained therein,
towards supporting the finances, and to re-
turn you its warmest thanks for the noble
and unaffected manner in which you have
conveved the intimation why you cannot
Dubiidy espouse that great cause which you
nave convincingly proved you are determined
aecretlv to support. It is much to be la-
sneniea that many thousands in the nation
stand in the same predicament wiUi j'oor-
self, and while their Dosoms beat highly with
most fervent impulses in favour of the gene-
No other business of importance during
this sitting.
" Monday^ Deeembir, 9.— J.Clark in the chair.
*' The following motion by M. Margarot,
was discussed this evening ;
** That every society sendine delegates Ui
the convention, be requested oy letter from
the secretary immediately afW the session^
to transmit to him a written approbation of
our proceedings.
** This was objected to by some, as being
unnecessary; but was supported by a far
greater number; and, at last,^ passed una-
nimously.
" In tne course of the debate, M. Margarot
observed, this measure would prove that the
convention were really delected by a nume-
rous body of industrious citizens, and that
they were not, as had been ^leged^ 800 in-
dividuals met without any one kiK>wmg whe-
ther they had constituents or not That the
society m London, which he and his col-
league represented, consisted of 13,000 or
13,000. That the societies in Sheffield and
the neighbourhood, amounted to about 10,000
persons. That the delegation which he had
received from the Norwich Society, conveyed
the accession of at least 3,000 men to the
strength of the convention. These numbers,
addea to the great body in Scotland, would
ral welfare of their common country, the im«
mediate preservation of themselves and fa-
mi] ies from want, and worldly misery, checks
the impetus of patriotic affection, by vi-
brating every cord which nature has so pow-
erfully placed around the heart, in favous of
individual offspring.
'* The man, therefore, who does all in hia
power, does all that he can, or ought to be
eipected from him; and the convention has
no doubt, but the worthy and laudable ex-
ample you have held forth, will be followed
by great numbers, who are similarly circum-
stanced, in favour of the general interests of
themselves and posterity.
^ It is, and wilt ever be, the pride of the oon^
vention, to acknowledge themselves sensibly
impressed with the most pleasing sensations,
in oeing thought deserving of individual, as
weU as collective approbation. They have
no object in view, but that of promoting
the general welfare and happiness of the
people, to whose consideration their proceed-
mgs will be continually submitted ; and who
fron^ thence will be enabled to judge with
candour and impartiality, of the extent in
which they ought to afford them their con-
fidence and supports — I am with great re-
spect, fellow citizen, your's.
W. S. Secretary."
*' N. B. I am ordered also by theeonvention,
to return thanks for the several other smaller
donations, and particularly for a one guinea
note ; through tne medium of a member/'
463] 54 GEORGE I(L Proceedings^ againH WiUiam Skirving [464
convince their enemies, that the oonvention
was not to be despised.
<< In the course of this sitting, some pointed
remarks were made by a member on a con-
temptibk publication, which appeared in a
hireling Edinburgh paper, of that evening,
noted for its serviife attachment to the base
and unconstitutional principles of the pre-
sent Reevesian system.
^The convention was divided Into sections,
i^cording to rule, and adjourned till next day.
** Tuesday^ Dec. 8.
^ Wilson in the ehair,
" M. C. Browne delivered a commission
appointing him the delegate of a society for
parliamentary reform in £eeds.
^ Part of Uie report of the committee of
regulations was read. — Ordered to be printed
and defivered to the sections.
^ Some resolutions respecting the freedom
^ the press proposed by A* Scott, were read
and submittea to the consideration of the
convention.
** M. Margarot. There is but one voice in
this convention relative to the freedom of the
press. Imprisonment and various other
punisdHnents have been inflicted on men for
what are called libels ; and it has generally
Wen printers or publbhers, and not the
authors^ who have been prosecuted. The
only objections I have to the jresolutions of
citizen Scott are tiieir inutility, and the imf»ro-
priety of this convention giving any opinion
on Ibe conduct of a jury.
^ Hie delegates from London might have
gone farther than any thing in these resolu-
tionfly for their constituents have resolved,
th^t to publish political truths can nc^er be
criminal; but as we do not meet here in a
legislative orpaeity, I am of opinion, that we
ou^ht to coonnc ourselves more to the sreat
object we have in view, the redress of our
gnevanoes by a reform in jtarliament, and by
no means pass a resolution v^iich seems to
convey a censure on the country ; for thoug|h
I am far from thinking that the twelve men
who found Mr. Holt guilty spolo^ the senti-
ments of a majority oT their countrymen, yet
the judgmeht of a jury is, in the eye or rtie
law, considered as the judgment of the country,
though it may have been given through a
corrupt medium.
* With regard to the judge, I tbit^ we have
more reason to thank than to censure him ;
such sentences help to open the eyes of the
people, and do more to convince them of the
necessity of a parliamentary reform than any
thins that he can say to tnem. Indeed the
conouct of our enemies is, in many cases,
marked with a degree .of insanity ; and, a^
Horace says, 'Quos Deus vult perdere eos
' dementit.'
** Here a debate took place, which continued
the greater part of this sitting, and an amend-
ment, to the following purport was moved by
M. Margaret :*—
I ^ That the thanks of this convention be
transmitted to lord Kenyon for the sentence
which he passed on Mr. Holt, as> all siich
proceedings tend to promote the cause of
parliamentary reform.
'^ Wedneiday^ December 4.
« MacGibbon in the chair.
'* M. Margaret. Your committee of regula-
tions have not been able to bring forwara Uie
remainder of their report this evening, they
have not, however, been idle, they have been
employed in another manner, in your service.
** It has been observed that we admit spies
under the name of strangers. I say they are
welcume, and if the men, by whom tbe^ are
employed, were to come here, they should
be welcome also, — for we have no secrets
which we dare not avow. But the intelli-
gence which I have to communicate, will
show, that those who are not friendly to
reform, and who have an interest in sup-
porting the existing abuses, are using evenr
endeavour to put a stop to our meetings, if
they abide by law, we are safe, for they
cannot deny that we are met for a legal and
constitutional purpose, but as the people in
power, may take measures azainst us, not
warranted by law, we ought to be prepared.
I have in my hand the outlines of a motiony
whiqjb I would wish to propose in a fuller
house; however, I shall in the mean time
observe, that I am informed, there are many
men who are desirous of dispersing us by
force ; we ought, therefore, to prepare a^inst
such dispersion. We have already appointed
a secret committee for fixing a place pi meet-
ing, on certain ememncies, and we ought to
be equally well provided against present case;
for it we shall happen to be dispersed tO-nigh^
how, or where are we to rally again t — ^to do
this, your committee suggests a resolution to
the following effect, but. which I shall leave
to be drawn up by the council of the table.
" That the moment of our illegal dispersion
shall be coosidoEed as a summons to eveiy
delegate to repair to the place appointed by
the secret committee, in cases of emersenc^.
** 1 hope, that what has been already ssdd,
will convince the convention, that your com-
mittee of regulations, though they have not
been able to oring forward their report, have
not neglected tiieir duty ; and it will convince
our enemies thai we do not altogether neglect
them; they wiJl see that we proceed with regu-
larity, andthat wehaveaneyeuponthem while
they^have spies upon us. I therefore move
for ]«ive to bring m this motion.— Oranted.
A. Scott withdrew his proposed resolutions
on the freedom of the press, for amendment.
The motion for petitioning parliament was
now proposed to be taken into consideration,
bat it was decided that it could not be brought
in until to-morrow, that being the dav already
appointed by the convention. When the
denate on the propriety of bringing forward
this motion, was closed, M. Margaiot's was
465]
Jor Seditiinu
A. J>, 179i.
im
Sffttn broii^t in, as drawn up by the council
<tf the table, and after a short discussioOy it
passed unanimously in the following terms.
*^ That the moment of anv illegal dispersion
of the present convention, shall be considered
as a summons to the delegates, to repair to
the place of the meeting, to oe appointed for
the convention of emergency. And that the
aecret committee be directed to proceed with-
out delay^ to fix the place of meeting,
^ Tkundty, December 5.
** S. Paterson in the chair.
^ The British convention assembled here
this evening, conform to the adjournment of
yesterday. Were informed by their secretary,
that be had been apprehended this morning,
by warrant of the sheriff, and by the same
vrarrant, sdl his papers had been seized and car-
ried to the shenff clerks chamber, and there
detained ; that, therefore, he could not present
the minutes to be read as usual, in the con-
vention, having reason to aporehend, that
they must have been abstractea somehow, in
the above-mentioned afiray. The convention
vras also informed, that Messrs. Margarot,
Gerald, Callender, Scott, W. and George
Boss, had also been apprehended, and were
still in confinement, — and likewise, that the
accusations against the whole of these mem-
bers related to their conduct in this conven-
tion, and are all of a general nature ; and
that, therefore, the ultimate designs of these
oppressions were planned agai&st the conven-
tion itself.
'' The convention then appointed their
treasurer to repair immediately along with
Messrs. Paterson, their chairman, Campbell,
Fortune, and others, who voluntarilv offered
themselves to give bail for such of their suf-
fering brethren, as might be in need of the
same. These gentlemen were not retired,
when the provost and magistrates of the city
came in, and demanded wnether the meeting
now assembled, was the British convention!
They were answered from the chair, that it
was the British convention of the delegates
associated for consulting on the constitutional
means, for obtaining their right to universal
suifirage, and the annual election of their re-
presentatives. Upon this answer being given
by Mr. Paterson m the chair — The rroy ost
replied to Mr. Paterson, are ^ou the president
ot the convention? and, upon his answer,
that he was the president for the time, the
provost, as chief madstrate, ordered him tq
leave the chair, and dissolve the meeting.
The president replied, I cannot do this with-
out leave of the convention, but as I had ^ot
r:nnission to retire just before you came m,
am willine,for my own part, to obey your
lordship. — W. Skirving. Mr. President, you
cannot retire yet. The convention resolved
last night that they would not give up their
right of assembling, nor be dismissed, till con-
strained. The lora Provost replied, that this ,
was nothing to him. lie commanded them,
VOL. xxni.
as chief magistrate of the cky, to dismiss s
and if they would not he would force them.
The secretary renlied, that, though chief ma-
eistrate, he coula have no authority but by
Taw, and such authority could only be exei^
cised in a legal way, that was, upon a com-
plaint lodged, and judicial proceaurc fbUow*
mg:—
** Lord Provost. — ^I insist upon your depart-
ing hence, you may meet in any private houses^
but you shall not meet here. — A Membar. —
My lord this is a private house, and the house
is ours for the time. — ^Wm. Skirving.— Yes,
my lord, I have taken this house for a tim^
certain for the use of the convention ; it is s^
Mason's Lodge and nothing can be more pri-
vate than a Mason's Lodge. Lord ProvosL
— I i|m determined you uiall depart. I look
upon this to be an illegal and unconstitu-
tional meeting, and its my duty to disperse
you. M. C. Brown.— My Lord Provost, I
demand your attention. Your lordship says,
' we are an illegal and unconstitutional meet-
* ing, and it is your dut^ to disperse us.' I^
my lord, we are an illegal and unconstitu-
tional meeting, we were so from the begin-
ning of our sitting, and it was your lordship's
duty to disperse us at the first ; we have now.
sat near three weeks, and till this moment
have had no intimation of the kind. Your lord-
ship's duty must therefbre, have been so long
asleep. If our meeting was t72^a/, we ou^ht
I to have had the earliest notice of its bemg
so, unless the laws are to be made use of, in the
words of the poet, as ^springs to catch wood-
^ cocks,' to entrap the unwary,- and then punish
him for being ensnared. But, my lord, I do
beg leave to msist, that our meeting is strictly
legal and constitutional. Since the first mo-
ment of it, we have done nothine but what
was open to the public, our doors nave always
been accessible to every one, as far as the
room would permit. We have all along ad«
mitted persons who were known to be sent
as spies upon our proceedings. Had we met
to natch sedition, or to promote any thin^
unlawfiil. we would have avoided this cab^
duct, ana acted secretly ^Lord Provost-
It is not so much your meeting at first that
was wrong as your publications ; you have
published things that ought not to t>e allowed
M, C. Brown. — ^That, my lord, is ano*
ther proof of the perfect conviction in our
minds that what we did was legal and con-
stitutional. Whoever published the proceed-
ings, could only do it by means of the free ad*
mission given to strangers, or in ether words>
those who were not members ; and it is a
most convincing proof, that we were neither
ashamed nor amiid of what was done in con^
vention.— — Lord Provost . — I have no fur*
ther time to argue. — I insist upon your dis-
persing.
*' Mr. Paterson, in the mean time, steptoiit
of the chair, and M. C. Brown, by the unani-
mous voice of the convention, was called to
succeed hinu
2 II
467} 34 GE0n6E llL
** M. C. Bhiwh in the cba!r.
^ '' Lord Provost — I 108191 upon your imine*
diate departure, otlu^rwise I soall be under tne
disaerceable necessity of using force.
" M. C. Brown,— I have been c^led to this
post, by the unanimous voice of the conven-
tion, and with their consent I shall sit bere|^
until compelled bv force.
** Several incmDeis supported the president,
\ipon which the lord provost calVcKl in the
constables.
" W. SkirvLng. — 1 move, * That as the con-
* vention cannot break up their meeting, un-
f less compelled ; and as thev are not willing,
^ nor prepared, to oppose violence : that if the
* provost offer to put the president from the
' chair, they shall accept of that as a sufficient
^ token, and dismiss accordingly.'
" It was then moved by a member, that th?
persons composing the convention should
araw off to one sic& of the house, and that
the provost should call on the constables,
who should insist on their departing imme-
diately.
^' liord Provost — ^Mr. Brown, do you agree
to this.
"M. C. Brown. — ^Mv lord provost, I entreat
you, and also the worthy citizens who accom-
pany you (upon hearins the W4)rd citizen re-
iterated by some of his lordship's attendants) ;
Mr. Brown added, I beg their pardons, by
whatever other names they choose to be call-
ed, I mean the eeutlemen in the gold chains,
to take notice, that I never mean to Hy in the
face of the laws. As chief roamstrate of this
city I will pay you all respect ; but I will, ne-
Tertheless oe bold enough to declare, that I
<fannot quit the chair till the convention de-
sires it, unless compelled by force.
^' Lord Provost^ will then act as chief
constable; and immediately stejiped up, and
pulled Mr. Brown from the chair.
« When at the bottom of the steps, M . .C.
Brown turned round^ and desired the gentle-
iQ^n in the gold chams to take notice, that
1k<^ could not possibly wish to be attended on
such an occasion by a more respectable chief
constable than the lord provost of Edinburgh.
*' The cry of violence was then raised ; and
% member got on one of the tables, and moved
to adjourn to the lodge at the nead of the
panon^te.
. '^This was immediately agreed to; and
the members of the convention departed for
that place, leaving the lord provost and his
attendants in peaceable possession of their
former place or meeting.
V It is unnecessaiy to observe, that though
the lord provost, in the whole of this affiur,
acted as a magistrate, determined to do what
he thought his duty, be never lost sight of
tlie behaviour and dteportment of the gentld-
man.
^ Conoogate Lodge, eig^ o'clock.
'' M. C. Brown in the chair
•*The convention being met, they
Pfoceedinp ttgaiM tViSkm SHrnng £468
ceed'ed to considerth^ kte(^ ptoper to 1^ tifteo
in consequence of Ihf^ butra|e (Wftli^tted
against them ; and It was then move^imd
tinanimously resolved —
*< Tb^t the convention bb Ib^t^tS;^ dfechlrf
pbmanent,
** It was alsb movetf. ^d umUiithiMtsiT re*
solved, to appoibt a commitiie to report, &c.
^Which Dcing dcJiie— ^
*^ The P^sideht claidfi^d th« lliteiition of
the assembly; And in a speech of consider-
able length, asserted and pointed. out their
rights. It b not in our power to nve the
whole, but the following has been sent to u»
by a person who was prlfetent:—
^ * An aM grasping and dothiheeHng Hris»
tocratic influeoce pervaded ^nd overspreads
the kingdom, and by thread and promises
endeavours to terrify or seduce the people
from the assertion of their rte^ts, and froni
e!ierting that native energy which appertains
to them, and which, (f once vih, ih moHon,
by a strict union, and peaceaife and consti-
tutional petitions, must overbear every oppo-
sition. Hence the dreadfiil and inimiitons
alarm which had lately been raised of plots
and conspiracies, which have not, nor ev6r
had, the smallest existenc^e, except in the fh*
tile and wicked brains of those who ^ri-
cated these barefaced falsehoods, and af^r-
wards industrious);^ b^ themselves, or thteSf
emissaries spread it aDr6ad. Hence the foi\A
and villainous ca)6(mn?e6 which are contlnvt*-
ally thrown out against the Friends to ftefbtixi
and Constitutional Societies, as in these tftigy
see, with terrified aspect, the future saviours
of the dearest rights of the people.
'* * The proceedings of this night, fello>Jr
citizens, ou^ht to convince you, that it par-
ticularly behoves us not to sleep upon buf
posts. The rights of Britons, the franchise^
and privileges "of freemen are in danger o^
being annihilated and destroye<I by a torrcfnt
of imhience unexampled in the annals of
the world. I do not lyish you to rely oh
nw authority for this ; 1 win gite you Xhuii
of lord Chatham, the father of the present
chancellor of the exchequer; who In %
speech in the House of Lords, on the 2d^bf
rebruary 1770, on the question of the Mid-
dlesex electiocu in which the H6u^ of Cpmi-
mons had declm^ « f(M to be greyer ^kA
the whole delivered hnnselif in t^e foftowiiQ/^
words :
^ ^ lie had not tre^pass^ on their lord-
ships patience at that late hour of ntght,
when the length of the debate must have
fatigued their lordships considerably : Vt
he could not apologise in a case so oe^ly
interesting to tne nation, no time can be too
long; no time can be lost; no hardships diA
be complained of.
*' ' He condemned the conduct of the
tloMie of Commons, in teitns of asperity.
He denominated the vote of that House,
which iud made colonel Luttrel, represen-
tative for Middlesex, agross invasion of the
pro-
vioiatiaiiof {
pa^H^tyJionT^ treacherous
of Uie inyfluable pfinl^ge of a
^'^d a CQrnipt'^ai^qfipe of tlieir owii
A^ D- ns*,
C4T0
f J^noyn These mejanfres he said, pafle a
f bart of that unhappy system, wfiich had
< oeen fpnued iu the present reSg% with a
f Vi0w to ^ew-qApdp| the consUtuUpn, as well
^ 1^ the goverpcrien^ These measures origi-
■^ n^ied. ne frould ^ot ^y with hi^ ifuyestv's
* Ifjoovfiedgfiy Dut m his m^es^'s councils.
5^£e ICotQnums luul slavishly obeyed the
^ jcpiaifqjapds of his m^sty^s ^erv^ts, and had
* th^reny ei^hited and proved, what might
5 have'heeo onjy matter of ^uspicipn before —
''.that minister held a corrupt influence in
^parliament—it was demonstrable — ^it was
f mdisputable/
** A Qpmmittee to report, with all conve-
pient speed, on the means to be adopted for
p^alqpe a spirit^ resentmept 9^ the illegal
prvceecun^ f>f this day^u^nst their honest
fixd oo^iitutiqnal proceeoingSy together with
^ solerop appeal to the public.
** The B)^ting was then adjourned to five
'<rclock» on Fr^lay evening, at the same place.
^ Dec. 6.- ^Campbell in the cbair.
** Several delegates were received from dif-
ferent p^s of t& country.
'^ The members of the convention who lu^l
been carried before the sheriff yesterday, were
xe^uested jto gjive ;in 9(cq9,^nt of tJbyBir exami-
j^tion.
f\ M. Marmot 4^scrihed the manner in
vhich heand )ij^ (^|1efigue were arrested by
,tne sheriff o^cer, who refused to show his
warrant for appreheodm; them; he informed
t)»e convention that alter baviog been de-
'tEUUed in custody frptfi seven A. Jd. till nearly
the same hour in thi^ even*m& he was cop-
du9te4, ii^io the sheriiTs ohainBer for exami-
.mttion : that (be questions put to him werp,
.^ Are yoi^ a i^ember i^f the British jCpnven*
^tjon^ I)/d yojii make or second any motion
t^er^jfcc. To which he gave one uniform
.answer, '^ I do not acknowledge the leg^ity
'i^f a priviste interrogatory." I)Je was fre-
'qo^tTy required to open a small trunk, into
"wWh pe bad put his papers^ but ailer hav-
ing refiised to open or to dehver the key that
It Tsugjd be opened in his presence, he was at
^ast, ./Iji^vnissed, upon finding bail to the
SHoapupt of SOOO merles.
*^ J. Gerald informed the convention, that
.JbeiHg somewhiat indisposed, nothing but a
sense of duty would have hrought him out
'jthis night. He observed, that proceedings
'nearly similar to those related by Margarot
'had taken place at liis examination; that
upon bein^ interrogated by the sheriff he in-
formed him that he would answer no ques-
tions, if they were demanded as a matter of
right ; hut if asked out of curiosity, he had
no objection to answer the present question.
To one question, he replieu, that he would
nqtaimwer it, unless he were put to the tor-
ture ; apd at )a^4Qp^9d. ^vu^g viv ansjver
whatever.
"While J. Gefald was giving an accoupt Qf
bb illegal ar^rest^ be perceivea 9 messenger
enter tn^room; he, however went on. °Jf
' government sends spies amongst us, they ace
^ctjng superQuppsly, for we say pothing ^f
which w^ have reason to be either afraid or
ashamed. At all events, spies will now b^
con^e as ^eless as they are contemptible ;
for the time is fast approaching when the
eneipies of freedom will be able to see with
their own eyes, tjet not, however, the ojO&-
cers of government be objects of your indig*
nation. If they really knew how they wepe
clegra^ed as moral beings bv the servi<*e
on which they are frequently sent, thqy
would not feel much respect ior those who
employ them.' Let these men, then/be U^
objects of our pity and instruction. Thou^
they are sent to disturb us, not one of them,
I will affirm, bas ever been informed of
the supposed offence which we are now
con^piittipg. Forgive them, therefore, for
they know not what they do.'
'' Citizen Qerald was now interrupted by the
entrance of the sheriff substitute for tHe
county, attended by the magistrates of Edin-
burgh, constables, &c. upon which he ex-
claimed, * the rights of Britons are violated
' by this ili^al mtemiption of our peaceful
* meeting. It is force Qpf reason, witn which
' our enemies assail us. I defy them to
' assij^ one reasop gainst the lawfulness of
' our meeting.' But if they thirst after our
'blood they may now gratify themselves;
* mine I shall see flow with pleasure, if with
* it flows the freedom of my country.'
'* M. Marsarot having been called to the
chair, he told the sheriff, thi^t the British
convention was a legal and constitutional
meeting, that it was composed of delegates
of the people, associated to obtain universal
suffinage, and an annual election of their rs
presentatives. That the question in the or-
der of ^e day, to the discussion of which
the convention were immediately to proceed,
was relative to the petitioning parliament;
he therefore observed, that we sheriff, by
dispeEsine this peaceable and orderlv meeting,
violated Uie constitutional rights of the peo*
pie.
'* The sheriff said he had orders to disperse
them bv force, and insisted that the meeting
should be immediately dissolved. The preses
required that some mark of force should be
shown l>efore he lef^ the chair, and upon the
sherifftakinghimby the arm* he came out
of lus seat. J. Gerald was called to the chair
by the unanimous voice of the convention,
and it being observed that the sittings of th
convention had always begun and conclude>
with prayer, and that they ought not to de
part from their usual practice on this occasion
the preses was desir^ to a4Journthe meeting
in the common form, citizen Oerald then de-
livered the following prayer.
471] 84 GBORGB UL Proceedingt againd mUimn Simxing f47S
** 0 thou €k)v>enior of the Universe ! we
i^dce that at all times, and in all circutn-
etances, we have liberty to approach thy
throne^^ and that we are assured, that no sa^
crifice is more acceptable to Thee, than that
which is made for tne relief of the oppressed.
In this moment of trial and persecution, we
'pray that thou wouldst be our defender, our
counsellor, and our guide. O be thou a pillar
of fire to us as thou wast to our Others of old,
to enlighten and to direct us ; and to our ene-
mies, a pillar of cloud, of darkness, and con-
fusion.
" Thou art thyself the great patron uf li-
herty. Thy service is perfect freedom. Pros-
per, we beseech Thee, every endeavour which
vrt make to promote thy cause ; for we con-
sider the cause of truth, or every cause which
tends to promote the happiness of thy crea^
tures, as thy cause.
** O thou merciful Father of mankind, ena-
ble us for thy name*s-sake, to endure persecu-
tion with fortitude ; and may we believe that
all trials and tribulations of life which we
endure, shall work together for good to them
that love thee ; and grant that the greater the
evU, and the longer it may be oontmued, the
greater good in uiy holy and admirable Pro-
' vidence, may be produced therefrom. And
this we beg not for our own merits, but
through the merits of him, who is hereafter to
Judge the work! in righteousness, and in
mercy.
** After which the same mark of force was
ahown, and the meeting adjourned."
The following Address, inserted in the Gazet-
teer No. 80, was likewise received as evi-
dence on this trial.
Friends of the People ;— The general com-
nutteeofyour societies here, which should
have met as usual on Thursday last, was ne-
cessarily postponed till Thursday first, by rea^
sons of the sittings of the convention. The
British convention being now constrained to
adjourn, to the placeappomted for its meetings
of emergency, the general committee of the
Triends of the People in and about Edinburgh,
Are reouested to assemble in a house belong-
ing to Mr. Skirvine, their secretary, formerfy
denominated the Cock Pitt.
As our meetings are perfectly constitutional,
and our prooedings such as we dare avow, the
meeting will be held at 12 o'clock at noon.
A full meeting is entreated, for the pur-
pose of adopting measures for defraying the
expenses of the delegates while attending
their duty in the convention.
Edinburgh, W. Saiavjvo.
December 10, 1703.
THE members of the Court of Justiciary
assembled precisely at ten o'clock in the fore-
noon. Mr. Skirvmg appeared, and placed
ftumseif at the bar*
His majesty's advocate, for his majesty's
interest, was then, in the usual form called
'against the panel. Mr. Skirving was dedred
by the lord justice cferk, to listen to the in-
dictment aeunst him, which was to be read
immediately by the clerk of the court. Of
that indictment the following is a true copy. '
" Oeoi]ge^ by the grace of God, king of
Great Britain, France, and Ireland, defender
of the faith, to macers of our court of
justiciary, messengers at arms, our sherifi^ In
that part conjunctly and severally^ spedallj
constitute, greeting. Whereas, it is numbly
meant and complained to us^ by our right
trusty Robert Dundas, esq., of^ Amiston, our
advocate for our interest ; upon William Skir-
ving, tenant or lately tenant in Damhead.
now designing himself of Strathruddie, ana
presently residing inEdinbiu^. Whereas,
by the laws of this, and every other wefl
foverned realm, sedition is a crime of an
einous nature, and severely punishable. Yet
true it is and of verity, that tne said William
Skirving above complained upon, is euilty
actor, or art and part thereof. In so far as^
sometime diuine the months of June, July,
or August, one thousand seven lumdred and
ninety three, a seditious or inflammatoiy
writing, calculated to excite the people to acts
of outrage and violence, by insidiously calum-
niating and misrepresenting the measures of
government, and seditiously justifying the
enemies of our country, with whom we are
at open war ; having been at Dundee, or else-
where, to the pubnc prosecutor unknown,
composed or written oy Thomas Fysche
Palmer,* clergyman, formerly residing in
Dundee, or by some other person or persons ;
and after having been printed at Edinburgh,
or elsewhere, a number of copies of the said
writing or paper, was transmitted, or caused
to be transmitted^ hy the said Thomas Fysche
Palmer to the said William Skirving, in order
to be by him distributed and circulated:
which seditious and inflammatory writing, or
paper, the ssdd William Skirving did, some-
time during the months of June, July, or
August, aforesaid, wickedly and feloniously,
circulate among various persons in Edin-
burgh, in the county of Eainburgh, or else-
where ; and which seditious writins, or pub-
lication, was of the title and tenor followmg :
* Dundee, fierean Meeting-house, July 1793.
At a General Meeting of the Friends of
Liberty, they unanimously resolved to pub-
lish the followixig Address to their Fellow
Citizens:' — * Friends and Fellow Citizens,
' you who by your loyal and steady conduct
* in these days of adversity, have shown that
* ycu are worthy of at least some small por-
* tion of liberty, unto you we address our
* language, and tell our fears. In spite of the
* vinuent scandal or malicious efforts of the
* people's enemies, we will tell you whole
* trutns ; they are of a kind to alarm and
* See his Caae, p. I2d&« of this Vohime,
473]
jiff otdUtofi*
A. D. ITM.
{474
sTouse you out of your letiuugy. That por-
tion of liberty you once enjoyed is fiist eel-
tine, we fear, in the darkness of despotism
mna tyranny.' Too soon, perhaps, you who
were the world's envy as [>osseaBed of some
simdl portion of tiberty^ will be sunk in the
depth of slavery and misery, if you prevent
it not by your well-timed efforts. Is not ervery
n^w day adding a new link to your chains f
Is not the executive branch daily seizing
new, unprecedented, and unwairantable
powers ? Has not the House of Commons
(your only security from the evils of tyrauny
«um1 aristocracy) joined the ooalition against
you ? Is the election of its members either
fior, free, or frequent? Is not its indepen-
dence gone, whue it is made up of pen-
sioners and placemen ? We have done our
duty, and are determined to keep our posts,
ever ready to assert our just rights and pri-
vileges as men, the chief of which we ac-
count the right of universal sufifri^ in the
choice of those who serve in the Gammons
House of parliament, and a frequent renewal
of such power. We are not deterred or dis-
appointed by the late decision of the House
of Commons concerning our petition. It is
a question which we did not expect (though
founded on truth and reason) would be sup-
ported by superior numbers. Far from being
discouiT^ed, we are more and more con-
vinced that nothing can save this nation
from ruin, and sive to the people that hap-
piness which they have a right to look for
under government, but a reform in the
House of Commons founded upon the
eternal basis of justice, friir, free, and equal
— Fellow citisens, The time is now come,
when you must either gather round the
fiibric of liberty to support it, or, to your
eternal infamy,. let it fall to the eround to
rise no niore, hurling along wita it every
thing that is valuable and dear to an en-
lightened people. You are plunged into k
war by a wicked ministry, and a compliant
parliament, who seem careless and uncon-
cerned (or your interest; the end and de-
sign of which is almost too horrid to relate,
the destruction of a whole people, merely
because they will be free. By it your com-
merce is sore cramped and uma%t ruined.
Thousands and ten thousands of your fellow
citizens from being in a state of prosperity,
are reduced to a state of poverty, misery,
and wretchedness. A list of bankruptcies,
unequalled in any former times, forms a
(Mtft in the retinue of this Quixotic expedi-
tion. Your taxes, great and burthensome as
they are, must soon be greatly augmented ;
your treasure is wastinglast ; the blood of
your brethren is pouring out; and all this
to forge chains for a free people, and even-
tuallv to rivet them for ever on yourselves.
To tne loss of the invaluable rights and pri-
vileges which our fiithers enjoyed| we un-
pute this barbarous and /calamitous vrar, our
niiAoi|»aad •till growing taxation^ and all
< the* miseries and oppressions which we
* labour unmr. Fellow citioens, The ftie&ds
* of liberty call upon you by all that is dear
' and worthy of possessing as men ; by your
' own oppressions ; by the miseries and sop-
' roi!^ or your suffering brethren ; by all that
' you dread ; by the sweet remembrance of
*yoiir patriotic ancestors; and by all that
^ your posterity have a right to expect from
* you, to join us in our exertions for the pre-
* servation of our perishing libinrty, and the
* recovery of our long lost rights/ — ^Farthei^
a number of seditious and evil disposed per-
sons, having during the course of the year one
thotttand seven himdred and ninety-three* or
previous tiierelo, at Edinburgh or elsewhere;
assoriated themselves under the denomina-
tion of * Friends of the People' but with pur-
poses inimical to the happiness of the people
and to the pMce and security of the countm
the said William Skirving, above complained
upon, bong then a leading and active member
or such ill^al association, and designing him-
self * SwxSbtj General in Scotland^ of the
same, did, at Edinburgh or elsewhere, on the
fourth diy of October, one thousand seven
hundred and ninety^three, or on one or otiier
of the days of that monthtor of the month of
September immedialelv preceding, or of No-
vember following, widcedly and feloniously
compose, or cause to be composed and written,
a seditious and inflammatory hand bill, (bear-
ing date, * Mason's Lodse, Blackfriars Wynd,
4th October. 1793,'^ caUing upon and incit-
ting other illegal and seditious associations to
convocate and unite together, and holding out
threateniags against those who either had
counterKtid or may counteract their seditious
proceedings. At least, the said William Skir-
vins did, time and place foresaid, approve of,
andrecommend such seditious huidbill when
written ; and, which seditious hand bill^ bear-
ing the name of the said William Skirving,
annexed to it, having been, by orders of the
said William Skirving, or or the association to
which he belonged, printed and published, a
number of copies, to the amount of sevend
hundreds/ was, by the said William Skirving,
or by his orders^ wickedly and feloniously di^
tributed and circulated in Edinburgh, and
elsewhere : which hand bill, written and dis-
tributed as aforesaid, contained, among othera,
the following passa^s : < The landholder is
' called upon to coalesce with the Friends of
the People, lest his property be soon left un-
tenanted : the merchant, lest the commerce
of the country be annihilated : the manu-
facturer, whose laudable industry has been
arrested in its progress : the unemployed ci-
tizen— the great mass of labouring and now
starving poor, and, finally, all the rabble ai«
called upon by the remembrance of their pa-
triotic ancestors, who shed their blood in
the cause of freedom, and to whose meau^
ries even the enemies of that cause are com-
pelled to pay an involuntary tribute of ap-
plause. They are caUed upon by the en-
475] S4 GEORGB OI* PtoceeiiMgi qgiAut Jimam SUromg
[476
deacing tppelbliim of fatihtr^ by tfao chuns
of their cniUrvDy and in the OMoej^f uaton
millionA, todemandy wiiiitbtArm and enap*
getic Toioeof juatice, thepoaoeaUavestitution
of their righta.'---' V. That the thanto of the
meeting ace due to Mr. Skirfing, of S^trath-
mddie, the seeretary, for his nnraautted at-
tention to the duties of his office an^ the in-
terests of hb ooimtry^ and partitidyly, for
having invited socbties of eveijf denomina^
tioa to unite th«r exertions in the ooniBion
cause^ by sending delegates to the ensuing
general convention/-^^ liad certain .geAtle-
mea counteoaneed tbisassoaiation laat.year,
instead of pledging their lives aad^Mrlunes
to prompt a corrupt and wmbitieMS sniaistry
to engage in a 'war, which oould only bring
fliilt and ruin on the nation, ve migbt have
been still eaioying uncommon prospaiity,
and a bappy understanding amongst ouri-
selves as brethren: and now, if they will
not manfully retract tiiat vei^ in^polsticstep,
and immediatd^^oin their influence to the
onlsr measuae which can prevent further ca-
lamitv, if notanarshy and ruin^ their pledse
may be forfeited, and the Friends of the
People will be Uasneless^— By order of the
committee. (Signed) W. Sk]rvine.*-2r. B.
Those members who do not attend, or send
an excuse, will be publicly- called upon to
give tbdr reamos for absenting them-
selves/— ^Accordingly, a eeneral ?ff*H^'mg of
]the said iUeeal associations baving taken puce
at EdinbuT^, in the month of Octi^r fore-
aaid, in conseoueooe of tbe above, band .bill,
distributed ana circulated as A&Mresud, and
which eeneni meeting, having aft fint as-
aumed me name of the General Convention of
the Friends of the People, and, having there-
after, pcesiimptuouslv and seditiously anx>-
gated to themselves the name of ^ The British
* Convention of the Delegates of the People,
* associated to obtain Universal Suffrage, and
' Annual Parliaments ;' did, in the whole
^orm and manner of their orooedure, as well
jks in the principles it publicly avowed and
fiiopagatea, dearly and unecjuivocally demon-
strate, that under the specious pretext of re-
form, their purposes were of the most dan-
MTous and destructive tendency, hostile to
toe peace and happiness as well as to the con-
jstitution of this realm, and too plainly indi-
cating the same rebellious maxims vHiiich have
governed, and do still govern the proceedings
of the convention of France, the public and
'avowed enemies of this country, and with
whom this uation is at present atjopen war.
In particular, the members of the said asso-
■ciation, under the names and denominations
aforesaid, did, in the months of October, No-
vember, and December, one thousand seven
-hundred and ninety-three, at Edinburgh
aforesaid, in imitation of the proceedings of
^e said French convention, call each other
•by the name of * citizen,' divide themselves
into < sections;' appoint4:ouunittees of various
-kindsy such as of * organization/ .of 'instruc-
< tiopi^' of' fipaiKBy'andof ' taoncy;' dofHisii-
natO their a»^tings * sit^ings;^ jgW)t ho-
nours of sittings; and Inscribe tbeir pmiiitaa
with * the first year.of the British ConvaijtM^/
The meipbers of which seditipus asaooatioii
did, nioreover, at times and pJacas aforesaid
malce bafa^ffiies and speeches^ as well as re-
solutions and motions, of the most seditious
tendency ( the wbstanqi pf which haraiigMes
and speeches, and of the said re^ljutioi^sand
motions were, by orders of said as^^^n,
not only minuted, but published in a news-
paper, entitled * The Edinburgh Gaz^teer,*
and through that medium circulated WM)ng
the lieges. Among other equally sei^ous
motions, resolutions and speeches, minuted
and published as aforesaid, were the ftdlow-
ing: [Scroll, Minutes^ p. 37, and 47.] ' that
' previous to publishing an address to |he
' public, a committee be forthwith appcnnted,
< to consider the ^neans» and draw up the out*
' linos of a plan of general union ana corpora-
^ tion between the two nations, in their pur*
* suit of parliiMnentary reform.' Which mo-
tion, or one of a simUar import, was unani-
mously agreed to, and a plan of union after-
wards resolyed on, thereby indicating their in-
tention of propagating their priuciples over
the whole nationy and exciting the people to
the same violent and upoonstitulional proce-
dure. [Minutes, p. 02.] ' Citizen Callender
' moved, that in case the minister bring into
^ the Commons House, a motion for a con-
' vention bill, such as was parsed in Ireland,
' it shsdl be noticed immedia^ly to the dele-
* gates.' — M leeet a motion of the abovp ten-
denev and import was made ; in consequence
of which motion, it w^s afteri^ards deter-
mined that a- convention of emergency should
take place; and a motion was maije in the
followmg tenns, or at least of the following
'mport and tendency: [Minutes, p. 67 .J
that a secret committee of threc^ and the se-
cretary, be app<Mnted to determine the place
whctre sudi convention of emergency shall
meet ; and such place shall remain a secret
with them,' and with the secretary of this
convention; and that each delegate shall, at
the breaking up of the present session^ be
entnwted with a sealed lettjor, containing
the name of the place of meeting ; this let-
ter shall be delivered, unopened, to his^con-
stituents, the receipt of which shall be ac-
knowledged by a letter to the secretsiy, pre-
aearved in the same state, until the pi^od
shall arrive at which it shall be deemed ne-
cessary for t^e delegate to set off. Which
motion was unanimously approved of.—
Moved, that the moment of any illeoal dis-
persion of the present convention, stiall be
considened as a summons to the delegates to
r^jnir to the place of meeting appointed for '
the convention of emergency by the secret
committee, and that the secret committee
be instructed to proceed, without delay, to
fix the-plaoe of meeting. The convention
having consi^red the motioQ fuily> unant-
4771
forSeH^m.
A. D. 17M.
[473
« iiiMBly te^lT«d the ttinie, ahd Appointmf
< the secret ootomtttee to pnlbeed ^ dMrad/
[P. ^7,'\ * Mov«d, that a cottitnittee he ep-
* poi&ted t& dmir u^ a declaration of the
' natural, uttdienabley and impitsciiptible
* H{zht3 of man, and that the same be pre-
< fi^ to the Address to the People of firi-
* taih.' [P. t$,] Whkh motion, it apf>ears,
was afterwards referred to the committee of
^^bn. fP. ^1 ' HbTed, thAt M the del6-
* gates Who had left the eoirv^iitioti should re^
■ eeive letters to retufti imtnedkrteiyj and re-
* ttMiki at their )»6sts t^l the important bti^
« Ms9, which Was dally hitrefiiii^ed into the
« cdh^ntlon, should be t^merly dbcussed/
Jkli ^hSch motiofis^ttid re^dMoM^ together
#Hh others ef th^ nke sedltlMM ieMleni^y, 4iA
ateo hfcian^iies tiAd speeches »^ift slmiliAr vm-
pM, wtre, by authority bf the-ftr^taid asso*
^iaUon, ordered te be toinMAbd, tmd InsMed
in the newspaper* cftlled < The Edhibttrgh Ga-
* «ettecr,' otTtafcsdayjNovitebeftrtWBbty-silth,
e^e thousand sevc^nund^afldliinet^thiee>
No.fd; of Tuesday, Dbceitabeir thiffl one
thoo!9)ind seven hundred ahd ntetty-thiee,
NV>.7^; and of IMea^, Digetober tenth,
evie thousand seven hiMtfwed aiMliaiAely4httee)
No. 80 And the sM WfAfcftxn Skirving^
^resaid, nott)Biy a meM%er df the laid am
^6dation, a^ theeMefi^trambnYbf oidlhig
tiMim together; tmtwasall along present at
the foresaid meetings, kcA acted, and was m^
knoM^ged to their ieAfieHrf; kt Whidt
times he voted far, an! m^^frdted of/ every
motien and reSokHioh IJhat passed ; and par-
tknlariy he wMedty and feloniously,, at times
tad ptee aftw esaid, veM for and sippiwted
of the melions anid tesoAutibiis lybove-tneiki-
tidned ; and net ovriy so^ but the uAd Wil^
fiam l^kirvin^, did himsel^-M ttokia and piase
tfft^esiud, wickedly and fbloniouiiilf impose
tad*moVe vesdluttons of thb st^mb miiamni»-
tory and sedMous tendency : and pariseulariy
tbe said Willidm SklrHns did, «iMne time dtt-
libg tlie mootfhs afo^retoio, at Edinbm-glh afor&-
tern, make the fdlolKiiRg, er nMioas of a
iimilar imffort and tendeni^ : ^Mimite^, p. 94,]
< That ihc convention esipress its ardent desire
^toctiUivafeamore ckwe «nion with the so-
^ cieties in ^gktfid/ [P. M.I ^That an ad^
* ^ese to the pubhie should W dta\i^«ttp by
' the comtnlnee of cmi^. tlillt k comiMtee
' of finidi<jb1)e appmnted. Tfaatthe detegtiefB
' from the cotmtt^, who may ran Mioit ^
< money by '«e prbtoMion of tite bu^lnsse
* of the cotf#«tttion, shan be sopplied hr the
< treasurer. Thiitt all the members, biih <df
* the eonteiUlen atfd of the pitnnry socMes,
* sbottld etftlscribe'a solemn leagQe'oMeov^
<naflt' And ihe tok) WiUiamlSldhPvtlig ^ftd
«b6 doncor in the moth»n ^itoerly iwto-
tlotied, 'ibr a setret committee, aereed Ho
be one^tbe sattnoy-anddid aet aeooiMiBgWIn
that capegjy; By all ^<»hiteh, aadyrtieito-
ly byhis actns'as secretaiy^,'8nd takmg the
chidltaaittUf^elftofthelMttliiMsofthe said
meetintfe, the said William Skirring showed
himself bn active ringleader of the said sedi-
tious asgociations. Further, upon Thursday;
the fifth day of December, one tnousand seven
hmidred aiid ninety-three, or upoh one oi^
other of the said days or nights of that mohth,
the provost and magistrates of the city of
Bdinmirgh, having, m pursuance of their
duty, repaired to a room or MaSon Lodge in
BhbckfmKI Wvnd, of Edinburgh, where the
Jbtesatd Illegal association was met, in order
to disperse the same ; the said William Skir*
ving, above complidned upob, with others,
his asAodates, members of the said meetings
did then and there resist (he authority of tlie
sttid magistrates, and refirted tb depart, ntole^
VMv #ct-e cdmpelled lb do so by force ; npod
^hlch the pft)yosi of some otbfer magistrate
then present, wtu^ ii^bllged te lay hold of the
j>erson of him who was theft acting as pr^
sident, and forcibly to dratvliim from hl^ fteat^
and to compel the other members to leave
theroom. Notwithstanding which dispersion^
the said William Skirving, aild others his
associated, did immediately repair to a house
ift that cki^, in the head of the Canongaie bf
Edinburgh, commonly called the Fle^h Marx>
ket Close, abd did there resu^ their foresaid
illegal meding , and In open contempt and
defiance ofthe civil magistrate, did then and
Ih^te declare their meetmgs permanent. And
th^ Aaid assoeiaUon having, on the d^y fbi>-
Ibwlflg, again met in a room or worinhop iti
hay lAWSbn's y^, situated' ofi the toUtb side
of tiic street called the Crosscauseway, ki the
earish of St. Cmhbeit*s atid shite of Bdte;
uig, belonging to or possessed by John Lun^
Wright, at which mcetitlg the said William
Sklrvibg waft ptesent, wvd again dissolved in
msDSner foresaid, by the sheriff substitute of
the tmtitf of Edinbtirgh, a^d others his asiAs-
tSttts, after being obhged to use a simtfto
mode ef compulsion. Further, notwithstand*
ing of the foresaid repeated interferences of
the chril magistrate; and notwithstaftdink
l^tthe lord provost and sheiiff of Edinburgh
httHf, on iSie seventh dby ef the said month of
DetJember, issued a proclamation, giving no*
tice to the persons of the said association,
that if they persifiAsedftiholdlt^ their meet-
ings, tliey would be apprehended a!s disorderly
persons, and dealt with accordingly; anq
idSb prbhibfthM; the proprietors of nails and
etiier placed ofm^thig. from permitting such
^iSsodiftions to assemVle there, the said
William Skirring did Wtdtedy and folo-
niousW, upon die tenth day of December,
'One thousand seven hundred and ninety^
three, or upon one or other c( the days of
tiuit month, or of November preceding,
publish an advertisement in the Edinburgh
-Ostetfeer, 1^. m, of date the tenth of
December dfbiesaid, signed WilHam Skirving,
and addressed "To the Friends tif the Peo-
ple,^** mviting them to assemblein a house
■feMi
* See it, aaea p. 4n.
479] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings agabui WOUam Siitving
[480
belonging to him, William SkirvilM^ their
$Qcretaiy» fonnerWdenominaled the Cockpit^
on the Thursday following. In consequence
of which advertisement the magistrates of
the city of Edinburgh, thinking it their dvty
to prevent the foresaid meeting from taking
place, did accordingly, by a prohibition or
interaict of date the eleventh of Decembcn*)
one thousand seven hundred and ninety-
three, grant warrant to, and authorize me
officers of their courts and constables, and
all other executors of the law, to prevent and
suppress such unlawful convocation, and to
take into custody all such persons as should
attempt to contravene the same; which
judgment or prohibition was accordingly noti-
ced to the said William Skirving, who had
been brought before the mamtrates, and
had emittra a declaration of Uiat date ; ac-
knowledging his having inserted the said
advertisement. Notwithstanding of whidi
|m)hibition, the said William Sdrving did,
upon the twelfUi day of December, one thou-
sand seven hundred and ninety-three, repair
to the place where he had advertised, as
above-mentioned, the foresaid illegal asso-
ciation to be held, and in place of only read-
ing or notifying the Judgment of the magis-
trates to those who were convened, he diiC ftt
the said Cockpit, or at the entiy of the lane,
or passage thereto from the mss-market of
£dmbiirgh, produce and read a paper of the
following tenor : ' Members of the Commit-
* mitiee of the Friends of the People. The
* magistrates of the city having foroid your
f UffA and constitutional meeting, called this
< day by advertisement, and by their pro-
* ceedings to prevent it, having given occa-
* sion to a great concourse of people, which may
' issue in tumult^ and must hinder your deU-
f berations, it is judged proper to atiioum the
< meeting, and to lay the business of it before
* the several societies, for their separate de-
« termination. It i^ therefore proposed to
< you to give place to the violence used
* agfunst you : you will thereby convince the
< public that you did not deserve such treat-
/ ment; and now that your del^;ates have a
< permanent existence, your several societies
* will be multiplied greatiy, and means will
^ be used to lay the business before each so-
«ciety individually, by printed bulletins.
Which paper, holograph of the said William
Skirvine, being of a most seditious tendency^
and evidenUy calculated to excite the people
to a continuance of their foresaid illegal asso-
ciations, was forcibly taken from the said
WUliam Skirving, when in the act of reading
the same, by some of the magistrates, con-
stables, or peace officers then present. And
the said William Skirving, above complained
upon, having, upon the fifUi day of Decem-
ber, one thousand seven hundred and ninety-
three,- been apprehended in consequence of
a warrant granted by the sheriff depute of the
county of Edinburgh, and a numoer of let-
ters, nunutes, and other writings and papers,
t
having been found in his custody, they wese
put into two bass and sealed up in the pre-
sence of him and others, then present. And
the said William Skirving having thereafter,
upon the same day« been carried before Ilarry
Davidson, esq. sheriff . substitute of the
county of Edinburgh, he did, in his presence,
emit a declaration, which, as he declined to
sign, was subscribed by the said sheriff sub*
stitute. And the said two sealed bags beinz
at same time opened, in presence of the said
sheiiff-substitute, and the said William Skir-
vin|^ an inventory of the papers, and other
writmgs therein, was made up in their pre*
sence, and which inventory is also signea by
the said sheriff-substitute, as relative to the
foresaid declaration. And the said William
Skirving having, upon the eleventh day of
December, one thousand seven hundred and
ninety-three, been brought before the right
honourable tne lord provost, and Neil M' Vicar
and William Coulter, esqrs. two of the ma*
eistrates of the city of EdinburKh, did^ in
tneir presence, emit and sign a declaration:
and having on the twelfth day of the said
month d^ December, been again bfoucht
before the said William Coulter, did, in hia
presence, emit and sign a declaration.
Which declarations, together with three other
dedaxations, the one emitted and signed by
the said William Skirving, on the thirty-first
day of July, one thousand seven hundred and
ninety-three, before Hany Davidson, esq,
sheriff-substitute of the shire of Edinbureh ;
another emitted and signed by the said Wil-
liam Skirving, the seventh day of August,
one thousand seven hundred and ninety-tnree,
before the sud sheriff-substitute; and the
third, emitted by the said William Skirving,
upon the eighth day of August, one thousand
seven hundred and ninety-three, before the
said sheriff-eubstitute, and signed by him,
as the said William Skirving dec*lined to
sign the same; as also, a petition signed by
the said William Skirving, given into our high
court of justidaiy, on the thirteenth day of
August, one thousand seven hundred and
ninety-three; as also a copy of the above-
mentioned seditious paper, dated, << Dundee,
Berean Meeting-house, July 1798;" as also
copies of the s4)ove-mentioned hand-bill,
dated, <' Mason Lodge, Blackfriars Wynd,4th
October, 1793;'' and copies of the Edin-
burgh Gazetteer, numbers seventy-eight,
seventy-nine, and eighty; together with the
scroll or draft of the minutes of the general
convention, fttwn the twenty-ninth of Octobei.
to the fourth of December, one thousand
seven hundred and ninety-three, consisting
of ninety-five pages,* and found in the
custody of the said William Skirving, when
apprehended as above, being number first
of the foresaid inventory relative to the de-
claration of the said William Skirving emit-
ted on the fifth of December, one thousand
. , ■ "
* See it at the beginning of this case.
481]
JiffSeditioH*
aerenliiliidred and ninety- three; asa]ao,tlie
said inventory itself, with the whole other
papers and writings therein contained* and
leterred to ; as alsoj the paper produced and
read by the said William Skirving, at the
meeting at the Cockpity aforesaid ; as also,
a letter, dated << Dundee, July 9th, 1793,"
(Si^ed)'«t. F. Palmer/' and addressed, << Mr.
Skirving, ooposite Old Assembly Close, Cow-
gate;*' will all be produced in evidence
against the said William Skirving, and will,
for that purpose, be lodged in due time with
the clerk of the high court of justiciary, be-
fore which he is to be tried^ that he may
have an opportunity of seeing the same. At
least, times and places above-mentioned^ the
said acts of sedition, by circulating and (Us-
tributing the foresaid seditious productions,
convocatins the said illegal associations, pass-
ing and msQung the said mflammatory resolu«
tions and motions^ resisting and contemning
the authority of the civil magistrate employ-
ed in dispersing tlie said associations, were
all committed. And the said William Skirv-
ing, above complaint upon, is guilty actor,
or art and part, of all and each, or one or
other, of toe said acts. All whieh, or part
thereof being found proven by the ver^ct of
an assize, before our lord justice general,
lord .justice derk^ and lords comnussioners
of justiciary, in a court of justiciary to be
helden by them within the criminal court
bouse of Edinburgh, upon the sixth day of
January next to come, the said William
Skirvii^, above complained upon^ ought to
be punished with the pains of law, to deter
others from commitfine the like crimes in aU
time coming. Our will is^ &c.
IslST OV WITKESS£S^
To he adduced againti Wiiliam Skirting.
1 Harry Davidson, esq. sheriff substitute
of the shire of Edinbureh.
d Joseph Mack, writer in Edinburgh.
S John Dingwall, writer in Edinburgh.
4 William Scott, procurator fiscal of the
county of Edinburgh.
5 WiDiam Middleton, sheriff officer of Edin-
burgh.
6 Andrew Scott, king's constable of excise,
Edinburgh.
7 George Galloway, sheriff officer, Edin-
fiiirgh.
8 Alexander Morren, grocer and spirit dealer
in Edinburgh.
9 John Morren, printer in Edinburgh.
10 William Moffiit, solicitor at law in Edin-
burgh.
11 James Kidd, leather merchant in Edin-
burgh.
1^ Alexander Aitchison, student of medicine^
residing in Canongate of Edinburgh,
}5 William Ross, clerk in the Gaxetteer of-
fice, Edinburgh.
14 George Ross, derk In the Gazetteer of-
fice, Edinburgh*
VOL. XXIII.
A. D. 1794. [48S
16 Mitchell Young, punter in Edinburgh.
16 William Sawers, merchant, Lawn Market
Edinburgh.
17 Jphn Wairalaw, writer in Edinburgh.
18 William Urquhart, shoemaker in Uao-
over-street^ Edinburgh.
19 John Laing^ wright, in NicolsonVstreet,
Edinburgh.
fK> George M^colm, shoemaker in Canon-
sate of Edinburgh.
91 John Ckrk, mason in Edinburgh.
55 William Romanes, merchant, I^wn Mar-
ket, Edinburgh.
23 Charles Ritchie, mcrehant. Lawn Market,
Edinburgh.
S4 Thomas Cockbum, merchant, Lawn Mar-
ket, Edinburgh.
56 Samuel Paterson, merchant in Edinburgh.
26 Alexander Bell, tobacconist in Canongate
of Edinburgh.
97 Andrew Newton, formerly tobacconist in
Dunse, now residing in St ^atriek'a-
square, Edinburgh.
28 John Gonriay, watchmaker, EdinbuTEh*
29 Archibald Binnie, type founder, in E&^
burgh.
SO I>avicrDownie,gold8miih, in Edinburgh*
31 John Buchanan, baker, in Canongate of
Edinburgh.
32 Alexander Fortune^ leather merchant, in
Canongate of Eainburgh.
33 John M^Intyre. teacher, in College Wynd
of Edinburgh.
34 James Robertson, printer in Edinburgh.
35 William Lind, apprentice to the said James
Robertson.
36' James Eraser, sheriff officer in Edinbingh.
37 James Williamson^ clerk to William Scott,
solicitor at law m Edinburgh.
38 Archibald Welsh, also clerk to the said
William Scott.
39 The right honorable Thomas Elder, lord
provost of the city of Edinburgh.
40 Neil M< Vicar, esq. one of the magistrates
of Edinburgh.
41 William Coulter, eso. one of the magis-
trates of Edinbu ngn.
42 James Laing, one ofthe depute city clerks
of Edinburgh.
43 James Dove, town officer in Edinburgh.
44 Archibald Campbell, town officer in Edin-
burgh. ,
45 James Burnet, grocer in Edinburgh, preset
ofthe society of constables.
46 James Denholro, hat-maker in Edinburgh,
and one of the present constables in
Edinburgh.
(Signed) John Burnxtt, A. D.
LIST of assizb.
Sir Patrick Warrender, of Lochend-, hart
Sir Andrew Lauder Dick, of FountainhalJ,
hart.
Sir Hew Dalrymple, of North Berwick,
bart.
Sir James Hall, of Dunglass, bart.
5 Genertd Henry Fletcher, of Salton.
2 I
48S] 34 G£OKGS III. Proceedings agaitiH WWitm Skiroing [4S4
William Kisbet, of Dlrkton, esq.
John Hamilton, of Poncakiaiidy esq*
Robert Baird, of Newbyth, esq.
Francis Kinloch, jun. ^f Gilmerton.
10 Robert Hay> of Dnimmelsder.
Robert Hunter, of Thurston.
William Newton, of Newton.
John Ha^r. of Hopes.
James Wilkie, of Gilkerston.
15 John Glassel, of Long Niddry.
Alexander Mackenoe, of Seatoti.
David Anderson, of St. Germain's.
James Heobum, of Humbie.
John Caddell, of Cockenzie.
80 Tliomas Brown, of Johnstonbum.
James Craig, of Setonhill.
Francis Buchan Sydserf, of Ruchlaw.
. George Home, of Branxton.
James Syme, of Northfieid.
35 James Hay, of Nmiraw.
Jotan Miln^ iron-monger in- fidmbui^li.
William Lamb> upholsterer there.
Walter Brunton^ saddler there.
William Fettis, merchant there.
SO William Coof^er, upholsterer there.
Andrew Boog, cutler there.
Robert Buel^, painter there.
Robert Demipster, druggist there.
Thomas Armstrong, coppersmith there.
96 John Beugo, engraVer there.
Alexander Allan, merchant there.
Peter Fraser, merchatit there.
Francis Howden, jeweller l^ere^
David Milne, merchant there.
40 John Gloag, merchant there.
Thomas Smith, tinsmith there.
Robert Kerr, haberdasher there.
Edward Innes, confectioner there.
Francis Braidwood, - upholsterer tliere.
45 Angus McDonald, merchant there.
(Signed) RoBT. M'QrEEW.
John Swivton.
Wm. Naibne.
Alex. Abeeckomby.
I Andrew Murison, macer to the high court
of justiciary, by virtue of criminal letters,
dated and signed the twentieth day of De-
cember, current, raised at the instance of
Robert Dundas, esq. of Amiston, his ma^
jesty*s advocate- for his majesty's interest,
against William Skirving, tenant, or latelv
tenant in Damhead, now designing himself
of Stratbruddie, anid presently residing in
Edinburgh, in his miuesty's name and au-
thority, command and charge you. the said
William Skirving, to compear, and to come
and find sufficient caution and surety, acted
ia the books of adjournal, That you sliall com-
pear before the lord justice ^neral, lord jus-
tice clerk, and lords oommissioners of Jus-
ticiary, in a court of justiciary, to be hoiden
br^ them within the criminal court house of
Edinburgh, upon the sixth day of January
next, in the hour of cause, there to underly
the law, for the crimes specified in the said
crimimd ktteis; wd ^t ii&der the pains
I contained in thte acts of parliament; and
that you come and find^ the said caiktion and
surety, acted in manner aforesaid, within six
dvfs next after the date hereof, under the
nam of rebellion, and putting of you to the
nom, with certification as effiers. Of -which
criminal letters to the will, with a list of the
persons names and designations that are to
ve adduced as witnesses against you, and a
list of the persons na>mes and designations
that are to nass upon your assize, I herewith
give you full and exact copies, upon the thirty*
four preceding pages, upon this twenty-fii^t
day- of Decemoer, one tnousand seven hutx*
md and ninety-three years, before these wit-
nesses, WiUiam M'Beath, and John MfBeath,
both indwellers in Edinburgh, one word on
page third, one word on page fifUi, four words
on page nineteenth, five words on page twenty-
first, four words on page eighteenth, and
seven words on page twenty-sixl^, on the
aaid preceding copy of the criminal letters,
being delate t^fore serving.
(Signed) Andrew Mubxsok,
Lord Jutlice CUrk. — ^What do you say td
this, Mn Skirving ; are you guilty or not ?
Mr. Skirving, — I am conscious of no guilt,
my lord.
Lord Justice CferJb.— -Have you any counsel
for you?
Mr. SJfciTOwff.— No, my lord, I have the
misfortune to nave no counsel whatever.
Lord Eskgrove: — Mr. Skirving very well
knows that if he had wished for counsel, and
had applied to the Court, he might have had
counsel.*
Mr. Skiroing.-'-'Bach is the apprehensioil
that is gone forth of your prejudice against
the Friends of the People, that an agent he-
I fore the court said, it was almost giving up
his business to be seen doing anv thing for
the Friends of the People; and therefore, I
thought I would trust to the Court, and do aa
well as I could without counsel.--It is very
unfortunate that I have had so little time to
prepare for my defence; however, conscious
of innocence, I must trust myself in the
hands of the Court, and make the best de«
fence I can.
Lord Eskgrave, — ^We know very well, that
both the agents and the Court have so much
compassion, that they never refuse to assbt
any panel.
Lord Justice Clerk.-^The meanest subject
that comes to this court, may have counsel if
he appHes for it. Do you wish to have coun-
sel now?
Mr. Skirving,-^! should beveiy sladof the
assistance of counsel, but it would now be
taking any gentieman at unawares.
Mr. Solicitor General. [Blair, af^rwards
lord president of the Court of Session.]
My lords, as the panel has stated no par-
ticular objections to the relevancy, or to the
* See Gerrald's case in this volume, pott.
4853
fir SedUion*
A. D. 17M.
[486
fi>n& of tlie crioiiDal lib^l exhibited against
him, perha]>9 in point of forip the public
prosecutor might dispense with ^saying any
thinig at all upon the subject; at the same
tinie, in this case, I judgie it may not be im-»
proper, for the sake of the juiy who are to
try this case, before the proof is adduced be^
fore theni» to make some observations upon
the nature of the charge contained in this in-
dictment. Andy my lords, I would the rather
at this period of the cause, because I speak
under the correction of your lordships ; be-
cause, if I state any thing improperly, if I
draw any thine out of this mdictment that is
liQt apaeeable to law^ your lordships, I know,
will coffiect me.
My lords, the general nature of the charge,
exhibited aj^nst this panel, is a charge of
sedition, with regard to which, my lord, it
is unnecessary to sa]^ aiuy thine. My lord,
uoibrUmately we live in times when it is un-
necessary, in this criminal court, afler what
bas passed, to say a single word, either with
regard to the nature of sedition, or with re-
gird to the mischievous tendency of it. Your
rdships have repeatedly delivered opinions
upon that subject, and therefore it is unneces^
sary to say any thing upon it.
My lord> the particular acts of sedition,
charged in this libel, consist of two branches:
^-The first is a charge of circiUating, and dis-
Iributine a seditious libel : it is not necessai;^
to trouble vour lordships upon this hbel ; it
will be before the jury; and, I think it is im-
posable for aqy person to have a doubt^ that
It is seditious, and seditious in the highest
d^ree ; and it is onl}r uecessaiy to add, that
this paper, the circulation of which is charged
upon this panel, has been already adjudged
by two of your lordships, to be hiehly crimi-
nal;' which was followed up by toe oonvic«
lion, and judgment of Fy^e Palmer,* who
was charged with being the author of it,
this paa^l being pharged with the publication
of it
My lord, the second branch of the charge
relate^ to the proceedings of what is jermea a
Pritish Ck>nvention f in which this gentleman
is charged with takine a very principal part.
Now, my lord, wim resoect to this, taking
the facts as they are statea upon the face of
the indictment, I say, that tne meeting it-
seli^---tbat the whole proceedings of that
xneeting were, from first to last, illegal, sedi-
tious, and such as cannot be tolerated in anv
established eovemment. My lords, this wiu
appear, by tiuiing a view of those parts of their
proceedings, andoperations, which are stated
upon the Uce of the libel
•
* See his case p. 338 of this volume.
t A minute account of the. oriein and his*
toiy of the Convention will be lound in the
aecond repprt from the committee of secrecy
of the I)c^ pf Commons, to whom the seve»
nd papers referred to in his majesty's ines»
sage of ^ Ut^ a^y of Majr IT9^ were re-
ferred.
My k>rd, kt usbeeva in the first place with
the manner in which this meeting is called
together. The .Ubel states, tkat it was called
together by an adyertiaement, published by
this gentleman, Mr. Skirvingi in the indict*
ment it is engrossed, aiid ha» been read to
your lordships. There are two things in it of
which I beg leave to take notice. In the first
place, the people are caUed upon, to demand
with the firm and energetic voice of justice^
the peaceful restitution of their rights, — which
is just in other words, telling the people tliat
th^ had been deprived of their natural rights;
and that tliej^ are now called upon to meet in
this Convention, to obtain the restitution of
that which had been unfiiirly taken from diem.
It farther contiuns a menace held out to the
fnost respectable inhabitants of this country;
a menace is held out to those gentlemen who
a twelve-month aj;o associatea themselves to
maintain the lawful possession of the govern^
ment, in opposition to these illegal associa*
tions. '' Had certain gentlemen countenanced
this association last year, instead of pledging
their lives and fortunes to prompt a cornipl
and ambitious ministry to engaee in a war,
which could only bring guilt ancT ruin on the
nation, we might have been still enjoying un*
common prosperity, and a happy understand*
ing amongst ourselves as brethren : and noW|
if they wui not manfully retract that very im»
poUtic step, and immediat^y join their mflu«
ence to the only measure which can prevent
further calamity, if not anarchy and ruin^
their pledge may be forfeited, and the Friends
of the People will be blameless/' Their pledge
may be forfeited — ^that is to say, their lives
are to be forfeited ; and the Friends of the
Peofile will be innocent. This is the man*
per in which the meeting is called together,
and a menace held out to nliie-tenths.of the
inhabitants of Great Britain; a menace held
out to all the respectable people,.who had any
thiqg to lose by scenes of anarchy and oonfu*
sion. Upon this advertisement, the libel
states *' that a meeting did assemble, and that
the parties having at first assumed the name
of the General Convention of the Friends of
the People, and, having thereafter, presump*
tuously and seditiously arrogated to them^
selves the nane of the British Convention of
the People, associated to obtain Universal
Su&age and Anmial Parliaments ;" British
Convention of the Delegates of the People--^
thereby holding out, tlmt they were the re*
presentatives of the inhabitants of Gfeat
Britain«-^nothing more false,— nothing more
seditious; the people of Great Britam, we
have reason to be thankful, are represented
in parliament. The very name of British
Convention carries sedition alone with it ; it is
assuming a title which none, but the mem*
hers of the established government have a
right to assume. And the British Convention,
associated for what ? for the purpose of ob^
taining universal suffiage ; in other words, for
the puipose of subvnrUng the.govemoient of
"A
487] 34 GEORGE IH. Proceedings ngaimt WHUam SUrmng (488
plunly what they wore pointing at, thereby
to disgtM and alarm every sober, erery think-
ing, rational person; if the panel can prove
that this was his intention, that may be a
very good excuse; but, I say it is impossible
that any other apology or any other excuse
can be framed for it
Then, my lord, the libel states some par*
ticular motions and proceedinss of this assem-
bly, particularly a motion made by citizen Cal-
lender, directed to an event which they saw
might happen, — ^namely, proceeding in par-
liament to put a stop to their meetings. Ci-
tizen Callender's motion was, that notice
should be immediately given to the deleeates
— well, what follows ? a resolution that there
shall be called a convention of emergency.
When the proof comes before the Cour^ they
will see what those emergencies were ; one of
the emergencies was in case a convention
bill should be brought into parliament ; and
another that of a French invasion happening.
In eiUier of these cases, this convention of
emergencies was to take place, to assemble
togetner ; and what is more extraordinary, the
place of meeting is to be a secret amonest
themselves ; a committee of secrecy is to ne
appointed, of which Mr. Skirving is a member;
which is to be kept secret from the world and
ever^ body else but the committee. Does it
need language to express what this means, that
this convention is to meet together, and in a
place where no person is to know where they
meet? is it possiole for any construction to be
put upon this, but that it was in order to pre-
vent any measures being taken to stop tneir
meeting, which were contrary to law, and
could not be tolerated in any country? and
why should this matter be kept a secret if it
was only to petition parliament for ^ refbrm f
what occasion was there for secrecv and hiding
themselves in holes and comers r I sa^ this
eommittee of secrecy and this convention of
emergencies stamps sedition upon the whole
of the proceediqes.
My lords, I shall have only one other mo-
tion to take notice of, a motion made by Mr.
Skirving himself. " That the delegates from
tiie country, who may run short ofmoney by
the prolongation of toe business of the con-
vention, shall be supplied by the treasurer.
That all the members, both of the convention
and of the primary societies, should subscribe a
solemn league and covenant." I am sure no
words are necessar}[ to satisfy your lordship,
that this was most illegal and most seditious.
My lord, those are the principal acts of this
seditious meeting, which are stated in the
libel, and to which the attention of the jury
will be particularly attracted.
My lord, the indictment next goes onto
state some particulars, with regtud to the
dispersion ot this meeting, when the magis-
trates and sheriff found it their duty to disperse
them ; and you will find, that after being so
dispersed, they met again; another meeting
is nekl at the cockpit^ and there the magis-
Great Britain ; because, I will take it upon
me to affirm, that universal sufifiru^ is an idea
that never enteted the head of those who
framed the constitution, those who laid
the foundation of that happy constitution
under which we live ; nor was it ever main-
tained, or ever thought of by any body else.
My lord, I say it woirid be such an idea,
that, if it was once adopted, would be at
once declaring that the constitution of Great
Britain is at an end ; an idea that our ances-
tors never thought of, and never was adopted
in any country, ancient, or modem, at least
in any government of the extent of Great Bri-
tain It was never tried, except indeed in one
instance — a modem experiment, and one
which I should have thought that no na-
tion in the world would choose to repeat. I
mean the experiment made by France.
My lord, having assumed this name, which
I say carries sedition upon the face of it, they
proceed as is stated in the indictment, and
m the whole of their proceedings they assume
the names, and the language of the French
convention ; they have a convention ; they
have primary assemblies, they have the name
of citizens, which the members of the society
commonly pass by, — ^they have committees of
finance, ofinstraction, of organization; and
they date their proceedings, in the first year,
not of the republic indeed, but of the British
Convention. In short we find them constantly
departing from the language of this country
and adofHing foreign language ; which, when
connected with those scenes that it has pro-
duced, show a wish to adopt a model, which,
I am not a little surprised that any person in
this country could have thought of. Indeed,
this very arcumstance, connected with what
has happened in another coimtry, appears to
me so strong, that, had not our infomiation
been most strong and pointed, I should not
have believed it possible, that any set of men
could have held meetings that were, if I may
use the expression, consecrated to mischief;
using a phraseology which laid the foundation
of those scenes ot anarchy, — those scenes of
rapme, — those scenes of bloodshed, of cruelty
and barbarity hitherto unknown in the worla,
which have desplated that unhappy country,
and disgraced it among the nations of tiie
earth. I ^, I could not have believed, that,
in this country, any man, or set of men, with
those scenes before their eyes, for I say, not
one of them can be ignorant of what is going
on in France, — I say, with this awful me-
mento before their eyes, that they should not-
withstanding have chosen to form themselves
upon that wicked model. I can only see one
excuse, and the panel may plead that, and
satisfy the jury of it, that it was done with a
good and beneficial purpose ; that he and his
assodates, desirous to cneck that tide of sedi-
tion in this country tending to alarm the sober
minded people, that they, on purpose, as-
sumed this language, in oider to show, that
they had nowibioifii off the mask^ to shew
460]
jf&r&d&lew.
A. D. 1794.
[490
trates also dedsred, they must not meet;
tiDon which Mr. Skirving reads a paper^
wnich is* of a very invidious nature; it takes
care to mention every thing that can put
them in a passion, it is just as if I had said
every thine I could to put a man in a pas-
sion, and uien desired him to he calm ; tell-
ing the people, that to nrevent them from
assembling was an act of violence on the part
of the magistrates.
' My lord, such are the acts charged asainst
this panel, and which I have no difficiuty in
contending, are most illegal and seditious.
I might plead before your lordships, that a
meeting ot this kind was seditious, illegal,
subversive of government, at every penod
whatever; had such a meeting been held
five years ago, when every thing was quiet
in tnis count^, I should have had no aiffi-
cttlty to prove it was seditious : but you will
attend to the time at which this meeting was
held, the law is alwavs the same, immutable,
but the crime is of that nature, that the cir-
cumstances of the time must operate very
strongly; and what is a slight tning atone
period, ma^r be a very atrocious act at an-
other; for example^ to draw an illustration
from what some of us may remember, sup-
posing five or six years ago it had happened,
that a few persons in Edinburgh had assem-
bled[, put on white cockades, marched to the
€asUe-hiU^ and fired a shot or two, I pre-
sume nobody would have thoi^ht, at that
feriod, that that was high treason ; it would
have been deemed a riot, and not high trea-
'Son; but suppose the very same facts had
happened in the year 1745, they would have
amounted to high treason, and the peisons
'vroM have been tried, found guilty, and
suffered death as traitors; therefore I say,
the complexion of the times speaks theinten-
lionoftlie parties; and if ever there was a
period when a man was called upon to abstain
Irom seditious practices, it is the present,
when be has seen the misfortunes of a neigh-
houring country, when he has been warned
by the king, in whom he has vested the exe-
cution of the law, hks been warned by
proclamations, warned by proceedings in every
penal court in Great Britain, to abstain from
evenjr thing that looks like the appearance of
sedition. 1 say, if at these times men are so
perversely obstinate as to assemble such a
meeting, it denotes a criminal intention much
greater, than if the same things hatl hap-
pened at another period.
My lord, it is m vain for these gentlemen
to say (which is the language ostensibly held
by these persons), that their purpose was to
petition parliament I have no difficulty in
admitting, what it is im{)ossible to dispute,
that every subject has a right to petition the
king, has a right to petition parliament, and
OooTforbid it should ever be violated ; but w^
M know, that a petition to parliament mav
Jbe made a colour for much mischief; we ail
know what ' happened 19 our own timesy
idMMit twelve or thirteen vears ago, when a
set of persons assembled in St. George's*
fields in London; what was their object?-
The ostensible language was to petition par<*
liament for a reform of grievances, or for
something not to bad, to prevent parlia-
ment from altering the law ; they assembled
as petitioners ; ana they concluded, with be*
sieging the legislature, with insulting the
members, and in a few dajrs, spread fire and
bloodshed through the British empife.* God
be praised, there is now no danger, I hope^
of any thing of this kind ; but I mention it, to
show your lordships what crimes may be com-
mitted under this pretence. I trust in God,
that here Uiere is no danger ; and I trust that,
at present, notwithstandmg the spirit of se^
dition, which has gone forth, ana been pro-
pagated industrious^ among the uninformed
part of the commumty, the constitution is too
nrmly established upon the great basis of na-
tural justice, of the common good, and of
libcrtv, — that rational liberty, which is com*
patibie with a re^l government ; I say, it is
too firmly establishea, and too strongly fixed
upon^the hearts of the people to be shaken
by such instruments as tnese. Although the
government is not in danger, the attempt to
shake it, though impotent, I trust is not the
less criminal, — is not the lessjibellous.
I have made these observations, in order
that the jury, when the cause must go to
proof; as no objection has been made to the
relevancy, that they may be able to fix their
minds- upon those parts, which are the es-
sence of the charge ; and tf I have mistated
any thing, I am under your lordships ^correc-
tion.
. Lord Justice CUrk^You have given ns a
very good commentary upon the indictment ;
but there is one part which you have not
read, and I want to hear your commentary
upon the words of it. " And now if they will
not manfully retract that very impolitic step,
and immediately join their influenoe to the
only measure which can prevent farther cala-
mity, if not anarchy and ruin^ their pledge
may be forfeited, and the Fnends of the
People will be blameless.'^
Mr. Solicitor General— ThaXy whatever mis-
chief happens, the blame is not to be laid
upon the Friends of the People, because they
liave so ^ood a cause.
Lord Jiatice Clerk — ^I suppose the Friends
of the People mi^ht cut our throats with im-
punity; they would not be blameable.
Mr. Skirving— I should have been happy
if the pleadings of relevancy had been before
the jury.: I thmk the jury are entitled to
hear the relevancy, because the relevancy is
a matter for the jury to consider; and the
jury ought to be present, in order that no part
of my cause be prejudged.
♦ See the Trial of I-ord George Gordon for
High Treason, vol 21, p. 485, of this Col-
lection. '
491] Sif GEOBfiE III. Proceedings agmut WOUam SUroing
[498
' Lord JuUice Ckrk^Tlotey are aU present m
Court.
^Mr. ^kirving — ^But they are not in court,
my lord, nor upon oath; I am very willing,
however, to say any thing that I have to ob-
serve npon the relevancy before your lord-
ahips ; hut, I certainly think myself bound to
£0 over it again before the jury, afler the oath
of God is upon them. Not beine accustomed
to speak in public, I am not able to follow
the soUcitor-generaf in the long speech tiiat
he has made ; but I have thrown my thoughts
together, and shall beg leave to read them to
your lordships, from the paper in my hand, if
I am permitted.
In the mean* time I would observe, that I
am not accountable for the acts of the con-
vention ; I am summoned before your lord*
ships as an individual, and I dare say, the
convention are able to justify themselves for
what they have done, when called before
your lordships, and will certainly justify them*
selves. In that point of view, every thing
that the solicitor-general has said falls to the
i;roimd. Any thing that respects me, in tiiis
convention, I am ready to answer for; but I
apprehend there is nothing laid against me in
particular that is worth the noticing. The
eolicitbr-general thought it was unnecessary
to say anj^ thing with regard to the m^or of
the proposition m the indictment; .1 have
a very ai£ferent idea of it; because, I suppose
no indictment is properly laid, unless tiie
m^jor of the proposition in the isdictment^
answers to the major part of the proposition
in thd statute, upon which it is founaed^ In
mv indictment the crime laid is sedition—
what this transgression is, we are left to dis-
cover by an investigation of the several arti-
cles in the minor pvt of the proposition laid
in the libel; .that is to sa^r, from the overt
acts charged against me in it, so far as the
panel has observed in the indictment before
this Court But, surely the prosecutor ought
to have specified the crime, as defined in
some one or other of the statutes to which he
refers, and which are presentiy cognizable in
this Court, and in the transgression of which
he wisnes to prove that I have been guilty.
In the inoictment, I am chai^ged to com-
pear in a court of justiciary, to answer for the
crimes specified, ore. ^
Now, in the major proposition of the in-
di^nent, only one crime is laid, namely, se-
dition. Here you see crimes, not one crime,
but crimes are siad to be specified. Does the
prosecutor intend to bring forward more than
ne h3s given mc warning to provide my de-
fence against? The Court surely will never
permit nim to do any such thing. They will
not permit him to take me at unawares with
a single charge, more than what is laid in his
indictment' Now, this is sedition; and there
is not a single thing more than seditioti
charged i^ainst me.
Sedition ! I know not what the prosecutor
means by sedition : for be does not attribute
a sinsle quality, either of mind or actioD, to
it. X am not called on to declare any opinion
of it; he only says, ^ Wekreas,'' &c.-*and
he says no more. Surely, whatever idea he
has of sedition, yet af^er describing it as a
crime so heinous and so severely punishable^
he never could intend, that the things chaiged
in the minor proposition, went to make up
any such heinous crime, or indeed any crime
whatever. Would it ever enter into anv perr
son's mind to suppose, that acting in the ca-
pacity of secretary to a number of sodeties^
my receiving a parcel of papers according to
.the first charee in the Ubei, nrom one of these
societies, ana showing them to a few of thp
persons entrusted with the business of the
whole, in order that they might be able to
give their opinion of them, when submitted
to a meeting, was, in any degree, reprehensi-
ble? . When the fiscal, upon information qf
the Dundee address, got a warrant .to appre-
hend me fbr my concern in it^ I nanated to
the sheriff mv whole concern m the matter,
and he assoilzied me at once. But allowing
that I had really been chargeable in the matr
ter of the Dunoee Address, would it not be
both ungenerous and unjust, after citing me
as a witness on the part of the Crown, cairy-
ins me to Perth, and inclosing me with the
other witnesses a whole day, and after all, to
bring me in as a par^, upon the evidence cif
the very witnesses with whom I was so shut
up, and consequentlv exposed to converse
freely with them on the subject, being made
to believe, that nothing I might then reveal,
supposing I had been criminally concerned,
could ever come a^inst myself?
It would be uiyust in the Court to admit
such an unprecedented attack on an^ man;
and it is hoped, that they will not indulge
the public prosecutor iiithis; the more so,
as the whole of this business is to be brought
under the review of parliament.
As to the next tning, the hand-bU]^ by
which some general convention is said to
have been called, though I know of no such
meeting odled by that bill; the prosecutor
knows well, that ne can neither instruct that
I was the author, nor, in any degree, the
publisher of it And though I had been both.
It b not possible for him. to prove, that I
could be guilty of any crime in giving warning
to my country of its danger, or m calling
them to demand, in a constitutional manner,
rights which it cannot be denied have been
wrested from them, as appears from Whar-
ton's motion in the House of Commons,
which I beg leave to read.
'' Mr. Wharton rose to make his promised
motion. We heard, he said, on every side»
of the glorious revolution in 1688, a^d of the
constitution, as settied at the glorious revbp
lution. V . ^
'* It was a note which he had always lisr
tehed to with pleasure,and he repeated it himr
self with rapture.
tl Out wtoi^ w/u(jtbe laUonal foundation of
493]
A. D. no*.
[494
our satislBCtion at die recoUec^n of the glo-^
lious revolution ?
• *^ It assuredly nvas not, that the poflBession
of the throne, and the regular hereottaiy sue-'
cesdon to it, were at that time disturbed and
intemipted. It was not that we expelled one
king and one family, and appointed another
king and another &mi]y in tneir toouL The
necessity of such changes was at all times to
be deplored : and the events themsdves could
only be justified by the necessity.
** The only rational foundation of our ap-
probation of that revolution most be, that at
uat time such principles were confirmed, and
such wise and wholesome provisions made
for our constitutional security and happiness,
as might prevent all future necessity tor a si-
imlarrevmution.
^ MThoever approved of that revolution, de-
dared at the same time, that the constitutional
provisions then obtained were wise and whole-
some provisions ; that they were worthy ob-
jects of a national struggle; that they not
only justified tiesistanee, out made it mertto-
lious; and that they were cheaply purchased
at the price of all the blood tint was shed
upon that occasion, as well as the dethrone-
ment of a guilty king, and the extirpation of
his guiltless fiunily. But an appnA>ation of
that revolution went still farther. It declared
that if by any means,— by finrce or by fraud,
by violence or by comiption---if these whole-
some and necessary constitutional provisions
should by any means be taken awa;^ or frus-
trated, tbie stole objects would again justify
the same national struggle, and me same ex-
tremities, unless they could be recovered and
reH>btained by more gentle, more peaceful,
and therefore more happv means.
*^ He asserted (and said he risked notlnng
by the assertion, for no man would be
h^y enough to deny it, and he pledged him-
self to prove it in a committee of the House)
that all that was valuable to the ]^ple of
this countiy, aU the provisions which were
stipulated to procure the peace and prosperi^,
the individual libertr and the general pro-
fkerly of the people of this land, lukd all been|
sinca the revolution, taken away— All !
^*He must tntreat the attention of the
House for a few moments, whilst he very
briefly brought back to their recollection what
this countiy established by the revolution,—
first, To avoid all ftiture mistakes^ and that
the contract between prince and people might
be clearfy understood, the revolutionists began
by ahenng the oaths of the contracting par^
ties. They altered the coronation oath for
all future sovereigns in this realm : and they
altered the oath of allegiance for themselves
and for all future subjects. They cut up by
the roots the damnable doctrine of passive
obedience and non-resistance, by emphatic
calty specifyins and ordaining tl»t tfa^ ibl-
lowme words of their former oath^ (let Willm.
and fliary, ch. 8.) * I declare that it is not law-
' fill Hp<m any pretence whatever to take up
§
'arma against the king,' &c. &e. shonld not
fix)m thenceforth be required or enjbined.
<' It was not so much to relieve the con-
science of the subjects, that these words of
their former oalh were selected, redted and
abolished : for no oath of slavery ever did, or
ever will, or ever ought to bind ajnation, or
an individual. It was something worse than
penury or sacrilege to keep an oath of slsr
very. This alteration was made to prevent
the future sovereigns of this country from
beine misled, as the four preceding sovereigns
had Been, to trust to a senseless superstition
about royalty, which though many persons
fbt their interests have professed, no man of
common sense ever entertained.
** Their next care was to provide for the
due administration of the executive power,
and tibe responsibility of its confidential ad-^
visersw They therefore enacted 12th William
Srd, ch. H, that * All matters and things re-
lating to the wdl governing of this king-
dom, which are cognizable in the privy
council by the laws and customs of^tlus
realm, shall be transacted there; and all
resolutions taken thereupon shall be signed
by 0uch of the privy council as shall aavise
and consent to the same.' Thereby euard-'
ing, as far as laws could guard, against that
accursed engine of despotism, a cabinet coun-
cil, or ^hat more accursed instrument, an in- '
terior cabinet.
^ Thdr attention was next directed to the
double representation of the people; the only
possible security for all their other provisions
— their representatives in parliament and
their representatives in courts of justice — the
House of Commons and juries. They passed
over untouched, and left as they found them,
the nobility and the church ; they were con-
udering the solid and substantial parts of the
constitutional edifice, and did not much* con- '
cem tiicmselves about the gilding and the
varnish. They therefore proceed<3 to esta-
blish ihe principle of a fair, free, an4 frcouent
dection of the representatives of the Uom-
moos in parliament, as misht be seen by a
reference to the acts passM m the first and
second, and third years of 'William and
Maiy.
** And having thus, as they imagined, pro-
vided for the r^ election of the representa-
tive body in parliament, they secured the in-
dependence and integrity of that body afVer
its dection, by enactms tiiat-*^' No person
' who has an office, or place of profit under
'the king, or receives a pension from t(ie
* Crown, shall be capable of serving as a
* member of the House of Commons.^ 12 W.
Srdch. 2.
^ Having thus secured the purity and inde-
pendence of the people's representative in
parliament, they proceeded to the other im-
portant branch of their representation by jury;
and they decreed, that juries should be fairly
taken, without partiality; and should act
freely, without infiuence. 1st. William and
1
491] 3^ GEORGE lU. Proceedings agttimt WaUam SUrmg [498
^ Lord Justice Cier&^Tbey are aU jpresent in
Court.
^r. $kirving — ^But they are not in court,
my lord, nor upon oath; I am very willing,
however, to say any thing that I have to o&
^rve upon the relevancy before your lord*
ahips ; hut, I certainly think myself boimd to
go over it a^ain before the jury, afler the oath
of God is upon them. Not beine accustomed
to speak in public. I am not dble to follow
the solicitor-general in the long speech that
he has made ; but I have thrown my thoughts
together, and shall beg leave to read them to
your lordships, from the paper in my hand, if
I am permitted.
In we mean* time I would observe, that I
am not accountable for the acts of the con-
vention ; I am summoned before your lor^*
•hips as ap individual, and I dare say, the
convention are able to justify themselves for
what they have done, when called before
your lordships, and will certainly justify them*
selves. In that point of view, every thing
that the solicitor-general has said falls to the
ground. Any thing that respects me, in tins
convention, I am ready to answer for; but I
apprehi^d there is nothing laid against me In
particular that is worth the noticing. The
eolicitor-general thought it was unnecessaiy
to say BXif thing with regard to the m^or of
the projposition m the indictment; J have
averydi£ferentideaofit; because, I suppose
no indictment is properly laid, unless the
msioT of the proposition in the indicUnent^
answers to the msyor part of the proposition
in th^ statute, upon wnich it is founoed. In
my indictment the crime laid is seditbn—
what this transgression is, we are lefl to dis-
cover by an investigation of the several arti-
cles in the minor part of the proposition laid
in the libel:. that is to sajr, from the overt
acts charged against me in it, so far as the
panel has observed in the indictment before
this Court. But, surely the prosecutor ought
to have specified the crime, as defined in
some one or other of the statutes to which he
refers, and which are presently cognizable in
this Court, and in the transgression of which
he wishes to prove that I have been euilty«
In the inoictment, I am chaiigea to com-
pear in a court of iustidary, to answer for the
crimes spedfied, ore, >
Now, in the major proposition of the in-
dj^aent, only one crime is laid, name^^ se-
dition. Here you see crimes, not one cnme,
but cnmes are said to be specified. Does the
vrpsecutor intend to bring forward more than
he bus given mc warning to provide my de-
fence aeainst? The Court surely will never
permit him to do any such thing. They will
not permit him to take me at imawares with
a single charge, more than what is laid in his
indictment' Now, this is sedition; and there
is not a single thing more than sedition
charged against me.
Sedition ! I know not what the prosecutor
means by sedition ; for be does not attiibute
a siiwk quality, dther of mind or actioD, to
it. f am not csdled on to declare any opdnion
of it ; he only says, ^ Wekreas,'' &c.-— and
he says no more. Surely, whatever idea he
has of sedition, yet afler describing it as a
crime so heinous and so severely punishable,
he never could intend, that the things charged
in the minor proposition, went to make up
any such heinous crime, or indeed any crime
whatever. Would it ever enter into anv per-
son's mind to suppose, that acting in the ca-
pacity of secretary to a number of societies,
my receiving a parcel of papers according to
the first charse in the libel, from one of these
societies, ana showing them to a few of thp
persons entrusted with the business of the
whole, in order that they might be able to
give thdr opinion of them, w&n submitted
to a meeting, was, in any degree, reprehensi-
ble ? . When the fiscal, upon information c^f
the Dundee address, got a warrant to appr^
bend me for my concern in it^ I nanated to
the sheriff mv whole concern m the matter,
and he assoilzied me at once. But allowing
that I had really been chargeable in tiie mat-
ter of the Dunoee Address, wpuld it not be
both ungenerous and unjust, after citing me
as a witness on the part of the Crown, carry-
ing me to Perth, and indosing me with the
other witnesses a whole day, and after all, to
bring me in as a par^, upon the evidence of
the very witnesses witn whom I was so shut
up, and consequentiv exposed to converse
freely witii them on the subject, being made
to believe, that nothing I might then reveal,
supposing I had been criminally concerned,
could ever come agpinst myself^
It woiUd be uiyust in the Court to admit
such an unprecedented attapk on any man;
and it is hoped, that they will not indulge
the public prosecutor in this; the more so,
as the whole of this business is to be brought
under the review of parliament.
As to the next thing, the hand-bill^ by
which some general convention is said to
have been called, though I know of no such
meeting called by that bill; the prosecutor
knows weU, that ne can neither instruct thai
I was the author, nor, in any degree, the
publisher of it And though I had teen .both.
It is not possible for him. to prove,* that I
could be guilty of any crime in giving warning
to my country of its danger, or m calling
them to demand, in a constitutional manner,
rights which it cannot be denied have been
wrested from them, as appears firom Whar-
ton's motion in the House of Commons,
which I bes leave to read.
^ Mr. Wnarton rose to. make his promised
motion. We heard, he said, on every side,
of the glorious revolution in 1688, a^d of the
constitution, as settied at the glorious revbp
lution. . ,
''It was a note which he had always lisr
tened to with pleasure,and he repeated it him-
self with rapture.
^ Out ^Mi w/ti^lbe rational foundation of
m\
A. D. n94..
[494
our saftislsction at tiie recollection of the glo-
rious revolution ?
• *^ It assuredly vas not, that the poseession
of the throne, and the regular hereoitaiy sue-'
/cession to it, were at that time disturbed and
mterrapted. It was not that we expelled one
king and one family, and appointed another
lung and another family in tndr toouL The
necessity of such dianges was at all times to
be deplored : and the events themselves could
only be justified by the neoessity.
^' The only rational foundation of our ap-
probation of that revolution must be, that at
that time such principles were confirmed, and
such wise and wholesome provisions made
for our constitutional security and happiness,
as might prevent all future necessity for a si-
milar revolution.
*< Whoever approved of that revolution, de-
clared at the same time, that the constitutional
pfovisions then obtained were wise and whole-
some provisions ; that they were worthy ob-
jects of a national strugde; that they not
only justified liesistanoejnut made it merito-
rious; and tluit they were cheaply purchased
at the price of all the blood that was shed
upon that occasion, as well as the dethr<me-
ment of a guilty king, and the eztiiM,tion of
bis ginltless fieunily. But an approbation of
that revolution went still fardier . It dedared
that if by any means,—* by force or by fraud,
by violence or by comiption'-if these whole-
some and necessaiy constitutional provisions
should by any means be taken awa;f or frus-
trated, the same objects would again justify
the same national struggle, and \& same ex-
tremities, unless they could be recovered and
re-obtain^ by more gentle, more peaceful,
and thei^ore more happv means.
^ He asserted (and said he risked notlnng
by the assertion, for no man would be
hardy enough to deny it, and he pledged him-
self to prove it in a committee of the House)
that all that was valuable to the ]^ple of
this country, aU the provisions which were
stipulated to procure the peace and prosperhy,
the individual libertv and the general pro-
l^erty of the people of this land, lukd all beeUi
since the revolution, taken away— All !
**He must intreat the attenticm of the
House for a few moments, whilst he veiy
briefly brought back to their recollection what
this country established by the revolution.—
first, To avoid all future mistakes, and that
the contract between prince and people might
be clearfyunderstood, the revolutiomsts began
by altermg the oaths of the contracting par^
ties. They altered the coronation oain for
all future soverdgns in this realm : and they
dtered the oath of allegiance for themselves
and for all future subjects. They cut up by
the roots the damnable doctrine of pasdve
obedience and non-resistance, by emphatic
cally specifying and ordaining, that the fol-
lowing words of their former oath^ (1st Willm.
and Mary, ch. 8.) < I declare tiiat it is not law-
' fill up<m any pretence whatever to take up
'arm against the king,' &c. &e. should not
fh>m thenceforth be required or enjbined.
^ It was not so much to relieve the con-
science of the subjects, that these words of
their former oalh were' selected, recited and
abolished : for no oath of slavery ever did, or
ever will, or ever ought to bind agnation, or
an individual. It was something worse than
penury or sacrilege to keep an oath of slsr
very. This alteration was made to prevent
the future sovereigns of this country f^om
beine misled, as the four preceding sovereigns
had been, to trust to a senseless superstition
about royalty, which though many persons
for their interests have professed, no man of
common sense ever entertained.
^ Their next care was to provide for the
due administration of the executive power,
and tile responsilnlity of its confidential ad"
visersw They therefore enacted 12th William
Srd, ch. H, that * All matters and things re-
lating to the well govemiog of this king-
dom,- which are cognizable in the privy
council by the laws and customs of^this
realm, shall be transacted there; and all
resolutions taken thereupon ^11 be signed
by such of the privy council as shall anvise
and consent to the same.' Thereby guard-'
ing, as far as laws could guard, against that
accursed engine of despotism, a cabinet coun-
cil, or ^at more accursed instrument, an in- *
tenor cabinet.
*^ Their attention was next directed to the
double representation of the people; the only
possible security for all their other provisions
— their representatives in parliament and
their representatives in courts of justice— the
House of Commons and juries. They passed
over untouched, and left as they found them,
the nobility and the church ; they were con-
sidering the solid and substantial parts of the
constitutional edifice, and did not much* con-
cem themselves about the gtldine and the'
varnish. They therefore proceed<3 to esta*
blish the principle of a fair, firee, and frcouent
election of the representatives of the Com-
mons in parliament, as might be seen by a
reference to the acts passed m the fiirst and
second, and third years of William and
Maiy.
^ And having thus, as they imagined, pro-
vided for the r^ election of the reoresenta-
tive body in parliament, they securea the in-,
dependence and inte^ity of that bod^ afUr
its election, by enactme tiiat— * No person
* who has an office, or place of profit under
'the king, or receives a pension from t|ie
* Crown, shall be capable of servine as a
' member of the House of Commons.^ 12 W.
Srd ch: S.
^ Having thus secured the purity and inde-
pendence of the people's representativ!^ in
parliament, they proceeded to the other im-
portant branch of their representation by jury ;
and they decreed, that juries should be fairly
taken, without partiality; and should act
fredy, without influence. 1st. WiUiam and
495] 34 GEORGE ItL Proceedings ogainsi Wittiam Skirving
[496
Mar^9 ch. 3d. They also decreed, that ex*
cessive bail should not be required ; that ex-
cessive fines shonld not be imposed ; and that
illegal and cruel punishments should not be
inflicted ; and to secure these objects, they
ordained, that thenceforward the judge's
commissions should be made, * quamdiu se
* bene gesserint', and that their salaries should
* be ascertuned and established ;' in order to
maJce the judges independent of the Crown.
12th Wilham 3d, ch. S.
'^ Now, all these provisions (the objects
and consequences of the glorious revolution)
would have no value ; they would be nugar
torv and worthless; they would be a mockery ;
unless they went efiectuayy to obtain and
secure to the people of this land, these three
important pomts: first, an honest and re-
sponsible exercise of the executive authority
— secondly, real, independent, and faithful
representatives of the Commons in parlia-
ment— ^thirdl^, a fair and impartial admi-
nistration of justice in the courts of law. We
who had no predilection for any familv what-
ever (except as connected with these objects);
in the words of our ancestors at the time of
the revolution, did now again — * claim, de-
* mand, and insist upon all those, as our un-
* doubted rights : the true, ancient, and indu-
* bitable rignts, and liberties of this kingdom.'
1st William and Mary, ch. 9.
'' If then, by various means it had hap-
pened (as he asserted and undertook to prove
m a committee of this House) that this provi-
sional responsibility of the privjr council no
longer remains; that the election of the
House of Commons is neither fair, nor free,
nor frequent ; that this provisional indepen-
dence of its members is gone, and that the
House at present swarms with ' persons hav-
' ing offices and places of pront imder the
* king, and receiving pensions from the
^ Crown;' that juries are not fairly and im-
partially taken ; . that they do not act freely
and without influence; that excessive bail
may be, and has been required ; that exoes-^
sive fines may be, and have been imposed;
that illegal and cruel punishments may be
and have been inflicted; that the judges are
not independent of the Crown; that pensions
may and have been granted to some tjff them;
ana that lucrative offices may be and have
been conferred upon others ; by which means
it cannot be said that their salaries are ascer-
tained and established.
*' If these fects were so, he held it to be
the duty of all those who, without hypocri^,
praised the revolution, to endeavour to return
us a^in to our constitutional situation at
that period, and to recover those lost, or ne-
glected provisions ; that so we might effisc-
tually secure to ourselves and to our posterity,
what our ancestors endeavoured at the revo-
lution to secure to themselves and to us.
^ " He concluded with, moving, * That a
^ Committee be appointed to inquire, whether
^nyiand which of the provisions made by
* parliatnent m the r&ffk of William and
' Mary, and in the reign of William Sd, for
' securing the responsibte exercise of the exe-
* cutive authority ; for securing a real, inde-
* pendent, and faithful representation of the
* Commons in parliament ; and for securing
* a fair and impartial administration of justice
' in courts of law ; whether any, and which
* of these have by any means been invalidated
^or taken awav: and to consider whether
* any, and which of those lost or invalidated
* provisions may be fit to be re-enacted and
* restored, in order that tlie people of this
* land mav recover that situation and security
* in which they were placed by the glorious
< revolution in J 688.'"
N. B. It is worthy of remark, that at the
time of the delivery of this judicious and con*-
stitutional speech, no reply whatsoever was
made, nor has any sort of notice been taken
of it, by administration, or by those in oppo-
sition.*
And sure there was no crime in receiving
thanks for unremitted attention to duty. I
know, indeed, it must have given great pain
to the opposers of the Friends of the People
to be tola, as I shall also prove in their pre-
sence Uiis day, that by opfM>siDg that wise as-
sociation, they have brought their countiy
to the very bnnk of ruin ; and who now are
entitled lo the post of danger so much ? But
surely no man, unless those who were so for-
ward in pledging their lives and fortunes for
its defence, in his senses will offer the charge
of crime, or guiltiness, to an anxious concern
for the welfare of one's country, even thoueh
imprudently expressed, which, however, I do
not think has been the case.
Much indeed is averred in the indictment,
with the design of criminating the conven-'
tion ; but upon the most vague grounds. I
am ready to answer for the association of the
Friends of the People, and for all their pro-
ceedings from first to last, but at present I
am inmcted onlv as an individual Let me
be fiiirly indicted, as responsible for that cou^
vention, and I shall not decline to answer
to any indictment; knowing well that the
British convention is fully able to justify its
proceedings through me, or any other per-
son charged in their name. But, upon no
principle of equity or justice, can anv body
of men, regularly associated, be condemned
in any court, if not legally present. The pub-
lic prosecutor, as usual of late, has frequently
in this indictment, termed the Friends of the
People, collectively, and individually, sediti-
ous and evil-disposed persons; — havixig pur-
poses inimical to the happiness of the people
and to the peace and happiness as well as to
* See, in the New Parliamentary History,
Mr. Wharton's speech in the House of Com-
mons, May 3 1 St 1793. No debate took place ;
and on a division Mr. Wharton's motion was
negatived, the numbers being, for the motion
11; against it, 71.
497]
Jl» Sea&oau
A. D. 179«.
[498
the coQttitiiUon of the country, and too plainly
indicating the same rebellious maxims whica
have governed, and do still govern the pro-
ceedings of the convention of France, &g.
That the British convention, however, is a se-
didous and unconstitutional meetine, remains
to be proved, and cannot be proved, tiu the leeis-
lature declare them such; or until they shallbe
cited^ tried, and condemned according to law.
Till one or other of these events, they are to be
hdd, in this court, and in the opinion of the
public, as a constitutional society ; whatever
the lord advocate may allege to the contrarv.
And, therefore, as the Friends of the People
must be considered in this court, a constitu-
tional, legal, or allowable society, equally as
any ouier society (presenting responsible per-
sons of their number amenable to the laws of
their country, for all their proceedings) every
thing averred against the British convention,
or tneir delegates, in my indictment, must
go for nought in the present prosecution. For
fills same reason, and upon the same princi-
remams nothing more charged a^mst me,
pie of justice, every thing laid to mv charge
m this indictment, as said or done by me m
the meetings of that society, falls also to go
£or nought; unless it could be jHroven that I
did things unwarranted by the association. In
such case, if any thing so done by me in their
meeting, could be proven to be contrary to
law, then, as in justice^ I would be liable
singly ; but not till then.
To go into the prosecutor's views in this in*
dictment, would be to unhinge the very con-
stitution of the country, and nothing but the
most palpable inattention to the fundamental
Srinciples of the British constitution, or a se-
itious design to overturn it, could nave die*
tated an indictment such as this which I now
hold in my hand. Should such a proceedinjg
be allowed, there is an end of liberty: — it
would be a revival of the conventicle prosecu*
tions with a vengeance. The lord advocate
would only have to declare any association of
of the people, a number of seditious and evil
disposed persons ; and to get a jury to Qnd
some obnoxious person among tnem guilty;
and then everv meeting of the kind would be
deemed illegal and mi^t be dragooned, as in
the days oi our fathers, without the round*
about way of obtaining a declaratory act of par-
liament. He might next, for instance^ de-
clare dissenting meetings illegal, and ofa se-
ditious tendency.
If then, my lords, every thing in this in-
dictment, founded on the insidious and false
assertions against the British Convention,
falls necessarily to be expunged, — and it must
be expunged, unless you are determined to
condemn me, at the expense of that very con-
stitution, by authority of which you sit there
this day ; and which proposition I challenge
all my prosecutors to impugn ; — what remains
in the indictment against me ? Little indeed
against me, but much to mv credit and ho-
nour. These matters being fell out, which it
concerns the convention to vindicate, there
VOL. xxni.
that I need to waste your time in animad.
verting on. No idea of guilt,, or even of
fault, can arise in any man's mind on my
conduct towards the civil magistrate, in the
case referred to.
If the officer of ai civil magistrate shatt
come to me and desire me to go out of my
own house, I have a right to ask the reason ;
and if he can show me . no warrant, I may
turn him to the door as an officious intruder.
If his master shall deign to come himself,
and make the same demand, I have a right
to ask him his authority likewise, and to treat
him worse than his servant, if he show no au-
thority; for no magistrate has any power but
what the law gives him ; and even that poipcr,
which the law does give him, he must like-
wise exercise, not as he chooses, but only as
tlie law directs. The kind's prodamation
^. itself would be of no more rorce against oml
NT than one from the provost of Edinburgh, aaa
i. that would be nothing at all^ unless warranted
by law. Neverthelmk it is false, and alto-
gether unfounded, that I anv wav contravened
the proclamation of the snerin vid provost;
thoudi indeed I did consider it an unwar-
rantable, unconstitutional, sikI oppressive
act; and which they had no authority to
emit.— When apprehended by the warrant of
the provost, and canned before the council
for I know not what, though I id^rwaids
found that it was for nnr advertisenent of
the 10th, they were satisfied that my adver-
tisement was for calling a different meeting
altogether from the meeting which they had
taken upon themselves to proscribe; and
they dismissed me, after giving me my dln^
ner for my trouble. The advertisement was
as follows :—
'< Friends of the People. The general com-
mittee of your societies here, which should
have met as usual on Thursday last, was ne-
cessarily postponed till Thursday first, by rea-
son of the sittings of the convention. The
British convention being now constrained to
adjourn to the place appointed for its meet-
ings of emergency, the general committee of
the Friends of the People in and about Edin-
burgh, are requested to assemble in a house
belonging to Mr. Skirving, their secretary,
formerly denominated the Cock Pit.
<< As our meetings are perfectly constitis*
tional^ and our proceedings such as we dare
avow, the meeting will be held at 13 o'ck)ck,
noon.
'' A full meeting is entreated, for the pur«
pose of adopting measures for defraying the
expenses of the delegates while attei^ing
their duty in the convention.
W.Skirviko.'^
Edinburgh, Dee. 10, 1793.
Before coming awa^, the sitting mi^trate
did indeed signify, that they extended their
act of supremacy aniinst ibaX meeting, as
well as against the British convention ; and
S K
«99]
S4 G£ORGB lU.
this Hew dscUmioa I frnmused t6 tfead toihe
meetine mhiea aflBembM, and leave it to
themsmes td jud^ what vecard was due to
it. I went acooTdingly, rext day, to fulfil my
fMTOintse. And knowing the irritation of the
Ciople's minds at the ba8haw«*Ulce treatment
hich had been given to the British conrcn-
tion; and that they would not receive with
respect the messi^e I had received fer them,
in a hurry, beftjre leaving my own house, I
wrote the motion and proposal, which is nar-
rated in the indictment, (see page 479) and
which every person, not altogether bhnd with
prejudice, must consider as a prudent prono-
•al ; and intended solely to ))revent the colli-
aon of animosity, betwixt citizens and their
flBmstratea.
When I came With my worthy friend.
Mf, Charios Brown, from Sheffield, witn
whom I hsKi met accidentally, I found the
aieeting bouse bloeked up with an armed
force ; and seeing the people gathering fkst.
We made haste, for fear of tumult, whicli ex-
traordinary measures never fail to produce in
a populous city, to read, first the aeclaration
or the magistrates, and then the above pro-
posal. Upoti the same beine forced from me
violently. 'bat by whose orders I know not,
we left tnem with it and set off. It was very
fortunate ^ve came off so soon ; for the people
were assembling frdm all parts so quickly,
that their fiumber weiild in a few minutes
faaVe been so creat, as to embolden them to
inquire and judge who were right and who
were wrong in so shamefbl an affrsy. For
this service lo the magistrates, a number of
town officers and soldiers were hurried aflei-
and seizing us, walkinir upon the street
Proceedings ngMui WUUam SUndng {5M
my hk; aiid judge such seditlto the Mgh^t
virtue, because disinterestedly pursued lopro*
mote the public welfare. But in regard jo^
lordships have again and aeun detemuned
sedition to be the worst of alfcrimes, and in-
cluding every crime destructive of society, and
have agaiil and again for this venr crime in*
dieted punishments, in the eye of some even
Worse than death itself, I must insist, that as
Neither the crime itself, nor the law definlt^ it
and declaring its penahy are stated in my ni-
diciment, it is illeeal, and ought therefore to
be dtscharged-^and, especially, in regard that
f>ossibly my jury, taking up the crime of sedr^
ti^, as being merely the imprudently blaminj^
the measures of administration may thiflic it
v^fT exf>edient tod necessary to find roe
guuty, with a view, in the present circam^
stances of the couiitry, to strengthen the eze"
eutive govemtttent, and to cast the balanee
6f tK^wer into the hands of those, whom poa-
Siblyon other occasions they would check,
but at present jud^e it proper to trust to their
prudent and merciful exercise of discretionaiy
power. Some juries of late are said to have
acted from sucn motives; and we trust, for
the sake of justice, they have i^pented that
they left to others the judgment which they
were bound, by the oatn of God to render to
the accused themselves. And finally in re^
us
peaceably, lea us, as condemned criminals-,
throush the most public street, which, by the
tumultuous ninnine of the people from all
k|Uarter8 was completely alarmed, for every
window was crowded with head^, the saiiie as
during the execution of a criminal. They were
conducting us to the guard house, when Mr.
James Laing, one of the town clerks, counter-
manded the procession to the council cham-
ber. And after a consultation of the Uiagis-
intes, held with the sheriff, crown officers^ and
the assessors, we were dismissed simpliciter.
Now upon what date can guilt be chargied
against me from any part of tne whole of this
procedure ? It is impossible. Were the lord
advocate ever so anxious to affijt cHmitiality
upon me in these transactions, he would not
be able. But although my guiltiness might
be evident, what right has he now to Establish
it, after the magistrates have judged and ac-
quitted me?
Upon the whole then, if the matters charg-
cd'in thelitie], taking in the circumstances at-
tending them, or taking them up simply in
themselves, as laid in the mdictment, amounts
to the crime of sedition^ then sedition must be
a very innocent thing indeed. Nay, if my con-
duct from beginning to end in this business Is
•edition, I glory in it, as the hi|^^st service of
i
gard'this high crime of sedition is said to be
punishable oy acts of parliament, as in the
charge upon the indictment (and indeed no
punishment ^an be inflicted by any other au^
thority), it is therefore indispensablyjust, and
necessary that theM should be precisely spe^
dfied : or that the libel, as so laid, cannot be
proceeded on, but is altogether futile and irrc-
levtot.
If the tetm sedition be m any statute of otnr
law, then it will speak for itself. It #iH be
the tt^or of the proposition in the statute*
and the act or acts otthe minor, will suffid-
entit illustrate what the legislature intended
by the crime so termed ; and if the acts, with
the crhninating circumstances of intention,
described in the statute or statutes, be the
satne as tliose with which the prosecutor haa
chaiged me, I will necessarily be condemned.
But if no such law is stated upon the autho-
rity of which alone this Court has power to
ac^ and the public prosecutor will not point
out any. in this case this indictment must be
declarea without foundation: for no libel is
relevant, which is not a transcript of some
statute, and that both of its major and minor.
For, where ho law is, there is no transgress
sion. That is to say, the libel ought to state
the crime generally— the law whicli makes it
a crime — and then the overt acts, which
being proved, are the transgression of that
law, or laws, and which therefore constitutes
the general crime libelled.
None of these are done in this indictment ;
and indeed it must be evident to the meanest
capacity, that this very unprecedented libel
could not have any legal statute for its data
«J3
firSeHtiom.
A. O. 1794.
t5QS
9a4pi(t||si9A; fiMrwhptt leg^laturey possessed
^ WS fKifitifittl wifidoiQi could be so wesjk as
^^jr4 ft Qipdel for such a osribrniaDee }
U would appear, that tae lord advocate by
fMM9 blow would cut off dl comrouoication of
^fptiment aquMU' tibie people. But eurely
youi lordships lyiU not support the doctrine,
tl)a( excbaoge of sentiment among the peo-
ple, or mulual discuss^oQ of arnuneot in
society, — the natural exercise ana employ-
faent of tliose powers heatowed by tib^ Cre-
ator— ^is sedition, or any sort of crime. As-
sociation is the natural inheritance of the
Irute creation^ and would the lord advocate
denv the blessing to his fellow-cituens? And
if this privilege cannot be denied to any,
-why would he affix guilt to that mode of
^ercising the privilege, which his brethren
think best adapted for the purposes for which
it is vouchsated by the Creator. Jt is an
observation which I shSiLl never cease to
inake, when I have opportunitv, that the
grand political consequences of the state of
slavery, and that of liberty, or native effects
<»f their opposite principles, are these: namely,
that arbitral^ tyrannical power separates the
inan from his brother, ami infuses the selfish
unfeeling priiM?iple more and more in the
neart; but the principle of liberty — ^that true
principle w)uch Chrisjiianily implants in the
soul,— the principie «of liberty which Christ
has restored, and hy which he makes men
&se, is the loadstone which draws souls to-
gether; and estahUshes the social hand
which is the source of all morality. And
accordingly we are assured, by a testimony
which cannot deceive, that, as a certain
tokfiu of the approach of those halcyon days,
which we hope for, the inftvenoe of the
UBittng principle shall be temarkable. It
was the signal, and the mean of our fathers'
^liverance from popish domination. Its
effects axe now move wonderful ; and, being
JO the present case jaltogether volunlaiy, and
leas constrained by faxiy influence, promises
a still more glorious deliverance ; a deliver-
anoe wA from one Jtyrauny to embrace ano-
ther, but a deUverance from the principle of
tyranny itself; and which will establish the
love 01 mankind. You would do well there-
fore not to be found counteracting the work
of Christ in the earth. It may he the day
«f his coming which was to be thus ushered
isu '* Then &ey that feared the Lord spake
often one to another, and a book of remem-
brance was wrote Hot them that feared the
l4tfd, and thought uaon his name.*' — It may
be the day, the awnil '< day that shall burn
as an oven ; and all the proud and they that
4o wickedly shall be stubble." — Have they
not been atubble in a neighbouring country ?
And should not you be instructed by the
striking lesson before your eyes f If the
fttbttc prosecutor then cannot invalidate these
dbjeetions, which I have stated against the
refevaacy of the libel, and you are satisfied
inyonrown.mindsy lyt. T|;katas I cannot be
tried upon accusations made against li k)ng-
allowed society, which has not as yet been
tried, and legally convicted, unless I bail
been cited before you, as the proper and
ostensible representative of that society,
therefore the present indictment against nke
is illegal, and must be dismissed. 2d. That
it ought to be laid aside ; because neither the
crime, in the major proposition of the indicl^-
ment, nor the acts chafed against me in the
minor, are instructed to be referable to any
statute, cognizable by this the court of Jus-
ticiary. And 3dly. That though you mi^
think the jury entitled to proceed in this trial,
upon the idea which they must ha^ve, in their
own minds, of the word sedition; yet, as
they know not the idea, which the law judges
have in their minds of this crime, no statute
being libelled on, therefore by proceeding,
they might be guilty of the grossest injustice ;
because they nujght find me guilty of what they
would call sedition ; and Sieir idea of sedi-
tion being very different from that, which
the lords of justiciary have affixed to it in
their minds, viz. that it is the worst of aH
crimes, and including all otb^er cciatwss whal^
ever^ thi^ might an^dge me to the utnyist
rigour of punishment; while they onlyin*-
tended to sav, that I deserved some smail
check, to make me act more wisely for the
time 40 come.
If it is true, what has been affirmed of the
citizens upon some late juries, that they
sought to petition for a mitigation of the sen-
tence infiicted in consequence of the verdicts^
which had in this manner been given, because
they judeed them altogether disproportioned
to any idea which they had formed of the
crime submitted to their cognizance ; it fol-
lows that they injured their suffering bre^-
thren, nuut unjustly ; and it can be no rational
salvo to their mind, that they acted according
to tlidr light at the time ; and that the exr
treme rigour of the sentence is chargeable
not acainst them, but against the judges;
and that tor this obvious reason, that, in
effect, they actually and legally adjuuged
their brother to be possiblv ten times moi»
guilty than they believed him in their con**
science to be, since thev exposed him to tea
times more suffering than they thought h/9
merited. Had they made a point to have the
same idea of the crime charged that the law
and the judges of the law would have of it —
and this is uie first duly of every jury man^-^
they would then have found a very different
verdict; they would have found that he did
not merit such a degree of punbhment ; that
is to sav, they would have found that he wai^
not guilty of the cvtme libelled, as meriting,
such punishment.
This, therefore, I trust will be both a
warning and a lesson to juries, that the^r
wisely consider, first, what is tlie nature of
the crime indicted, and rtbe punishment that
will be inflicted, if the same shall be proven;
and then, whatever number of smaller criipes
SOS] 34- GEORGE IIL Proceedhgt agakut WtBkm
[9M
may be proven against the panel, if the
whole of these together do not merit, in their
Judgment, the punishment to be inflicted,
thevmust find the panel at their bar not
guiitv of the crime indicted ; that is to say,
not deserving of the pimishment adjudged to
the crime charged in the indictment.
<<The original intention of trials by jury
■was to guard against the partiality and injus-
"tice of magistrates and judges. The county
courts, the members of which were the an-
cient judges of this country, became so ex-
ceedingly corrupt, that Junes were invented
to remedy the many enormities and oppres-
sions daily committed by these courts. For-
merly the juries of Scotland were impannelled
in civil as well as in criminal actions. They
-are now limited to the trial of high crimes
and misdemeanors.''
** It is a common notion, that jurymen are
judges of ihtfact only, and not of the law**
** It has, perhaps, been too much fostered
by the injunctions of judges and magistrates.
It is ezceedinely natural, that plain simple
jurymen should look up with veneraUon to
the high rank and superior abitities of those
men who are appointed by their sovereign to
dispense justice over the nation. For this
reason it is, that the English judees are so
estremeli^ solicitous not to incukate their
own opinions on the minds of junrmen, but
to leave their determinations solely to the
dictates of their own consciences."
'<To what end," said lord chief justice
Vauehan, " arethe jurorscliallenged so scrupu-
lous^ to the array and poU ^ To what end
must they have such a certun freehold, and
be probi et UgaU$ homina (good and honest
men), and not of aflinity with the parties
concerned? To what end must they have,
In many cases, the view for their exacter
information chiefly ? — if after all this, they
implicitly give a verdict by the dictates and
authority of another man, when sworn to do
it according to the best of their own know-
ledge f A man cannot see by another's eye,
nor hear by another's ear; no more can a
man conclude or infer the thing to be re-
solved by another's understanding or reason-
ing ; and though the verdict be right, which
the jury give, yet they, being not assured
it b so from their own understanding, are
forsworn."*
- Sir Matthew Hale, in his Pleas of the
Crown, remarks, *^ that it is the conscience of
the jury that must pronounce the prisoner
guilty or not guilty; and to say the truth, it
were the most unhappy case that could be to
the judge, if he, at his peril, must take
upon him the guilt or innocence of the pri-
soner ;" unhappj^ also for the prisoner ; ** and
if the judge's opinion must rule the verdict,
the trial by jury would be useless.*'f
* See the case of Edward Bushell, Vol. 6.
p. 1013 of this collection.
t « Uale's P. C. ch, xlii.
** Though tbe proper businese of a jury be
to inquire into the truth of fiaurts, it is certain
that m many cases they judge of matters
also of law or relevancy . Thus, though an
objection against a witness should be repelled
by the court, the jury are under no necessity
of laying greater stress on his testimony than
they think just ; and in trials of art and part,
where special fticts need not be libelled, the
jury, if thev return a general verdict, there-
by make themselves truly judges of the
relevancy, as well as of the truth of the
facts deposed upon by the witnesses. A
general verdict b that which, without de»
scending to particular fiicts^ finds, in general
terms, uiat the panel is guilty or not guilty 4''
(Ersk. Inst. p. 741. § 101.) The same aiK
thor remarks, that M*Kenzie ** disapproves of
this institution of juries, because it is hardly
possible, in many cases, to separate the proof
of facts from their relevancy, the last of
which is frequently of too hi^ a disquisition
for such as are not learned in the law. But
no man's life or fortune ouglit to depend
upon too refined reasoning; and, if discern -
injg the nature of crimes l^ bevond the reach
ofjuries, which are presumed to consist of
men of common understanding, how caa
our criminal law be accounted a rule by which
eveiy artificer and farmer ought to square
his conduct ?" — Ibid. p. 738.
** From these most respectable authorities,
and many others that mieht, if necessary, be
1>roduced, it is evident, uiat jurymen, b^ the
aws of their countij, are expressly constituted
judees, in all crimmal trials, both of the Itm
andof the/irrf . I shall, however, hazard a
few arguments, derived from the nature and
intention of trials by jury.
** To prevent the misapplication of law bj
judges and magistrates, was one of the great
encM for which trials by jury were originally
devised by the wisdom of the legislature. ll^
therefore, the power of judging of the law,
as well as of the fact, were annihilated, the
very intention of the legislature would be de*
feated ; because the courts, and not the jury,
would then be the sole judges. Intention is
the essence of crimes. The tiicts libelled may
be distinctly proved. But if, from particular
circumstances, the jury are convinced in their
own minds, that the panel either had no in*>
tention to commit a crime, or that the crime
is not of so heinous a nature as to merit the
punishment concluded for in the indictment
m all cases of this kind, the iury have not
only a right, but they are bound, by the spirit
of their oaths, and by the laws of God and
man, to find the panel Not Guilty of the
crime laid to his charee. When a panel is
libelled for murder, ana the actual slaughter
is proved against him, yet, if the jury are sa-
tisfied that he had no design to commit the
crime, it is their duty to acquit him; because,
on this supposition, the intention is washing,
and, of course, the crime of murder has no
existence. A^fcin, suppose a culprit to be.in-
5051
>
^icMd fi>rn>bbenri or any other capital of-
fepce, and that the ftcts are clearly proved ;
stilly as Mr. Erskine iudiciously remarks^ if
the jury are convmced in their consciences^
tiiat the chief witnesses are either perjured,
or that their evidence should not have heen
admitted, their testimonies ought to be en-
tirely disregarded.
• '« Besides, if the powers of jurymen were
limited to facts alone, why are exculpatory
evidences permitted ? The facts libelled may
be fully proved ; but the panel, in alleviation
of his guilt, may bring such evidence as will
either alter the species of his crime, or con-
vince the jury of his innocence. When a j ury
are judging m a case of this nature, they not
only d^ib^erate concerning the two kinds of
evidence, hut they consider the nature of the
crime, and the punishment that ought, or
ought not to be mfiicted. In ail such cases,
the jury must necessarily determine both the
law and the fact.
** I know it to be the opinion of many jury-
men, that, afler the€ourt admit a relevancy,
they are fx>und by their oaths to find the li^l
either proved or not proveA. But these gen-
tlemen should consider, that their business is,
to give a verdict of a very different kind.
Tb^ are to judge both of the criminality of
the culprit, and of his exculpatory evidence.
The words, • proved,' or * not proved,' should
be for ever banished from the verdicts of ju-
ries. A relevancy may be found, when the
jurymen, who hear the indictment impugned,
are of an opposite opinion from the Court. A
crime may foe libelled, when the facts related
in the indictment, though completely proved,
do not constitute the essence of the crime
charged. Hence, whenever the minds of ju-
rymen are convinced, that a relevancy has
been improperly found, their verdict, how-
ever the proof may stand, should be, Noi
Guilty, indeed, the expressions, ' Guilty,' or
' Not Guilty,' ought alone to be employed in
verdicts. They are liable to no ambiguity,
and never can embarrass a court.
^ It is generally thought, and the maxim
has received great support from practice, that,
when a jury find a panel ' guilty,' but recom-
mend him to the * mercy' of their sovereign,
the culprit must either be pardoned, or re-
ceive a milder punishment tnan death. The
unhappy fate, however, of James Andrew,
who was lately hanged in Edinburgh, though
he had, in the strongest manner, been recom-
mended to mercy, by the unanimous suffira^e
of bis jury, must tend to remove this preju-
dice, and make jurymen very cautious of
their conduct. When a majori^ of a jury be-
lieve in their consciences, that a culprit,
though the crime libelled should be proved,
does not deserve to be cut off from numan
society, by the ultimate punishment of the
law, they should uniformly give a verdict,
imding the panel Not Guilty. This is a
high privilege, intrasted to you by the laws
6f your country, and you cannot b^ too
t
A. D. 1794. [606
anxious to prevent its infHngement or viola-
tion. Consider, the moment you desert a
panel by an indecisive verdict, your powers
are at an end. Bestow, therefore) that mercy
which you recomihend, and which you UiiuK
the culprit deserves, while it is in your power.
Never trust to future contingencies of any
kind; for the highest orders of men may
have prejudices; a thousand fatal accidents
may happen; misrepresentations may be
given; tne opinion of courts may not always
coincide with that of the jury; even negli-
gence of office has deprived men of existence,
after the mercy of the sovereign had been ob-
tained."
It was for this reason that I objected to
the trial of the relevancy till my jury was
impanelled, and that I shall yet bring the
previous question under their review, it you
shall at present give an unfavourable judg-
ment; because I shall consider your doing so,
as prejudging my cause in the most important
article, and m ul of which my jury alone are
entitled to judge.
If then, eentlemen ofthe jury, you are of
opinion with mc, that, with remd to the
first article charged, the Duncfee paper, I
have already been jud^d, and at any, rate
retained a witness aeainst the person con-
demned for it ; and which crime, in the opi-
nion of all the world, is now sufficiently
atoned for, by the punishment already in-
flicted. If you are of opinion, as you must
be, that I cannot be criminated, merely for
being a member of the British convention,
unless that convention was found guilty,
which cannot be found in this present trials
because I am not before the Court as respon-
sible for the charge brought against it. And,
lastly, my lords, as the charges respecting
the contravening the authority of the magis-
trates of this city, is a matter entirely betwixt
them and me, and as they have not joined
the public prosecutor in tus indictment, and
indeed could not have done so, the matter
having been already fully compromised be-
twixt us, you cannot avoid- assoilzing me
from the present charge, there not being a
single thing more in the indictment against
me. You are my sole and independent judges,
my country. No court can restrict or control
you. The lords of justiciaiy themselves arc
bound to declare, thmt to be law which you
finally determine as your verdict.
If, however, on the other hand, you are of
opinion, that the indictment as laid is rele-
vant, I am ready to enter upon a discussion
of every charge against me. Let us just now
proceed to make up before you the defect,
the constitutional defect of tiie indictment.
Let the prosecutor state in court, his mean-
injB^ of the word ' sedition,' his idea of that
crime, as laid to my charge ; what statutes it
is a breach of, and the idea of criminality
which the legislature has affixed to this
I crime, by the punishment annexed to it ; or
as the oharge> at the instance of the prose-
0011 S4 GEORGE UL Proceedings 0fm$l fmam SUroing [fitt
xutxw sutfsity ' tb» Mins coiKtained ia tbe I p^fle, they vbicU le^j tboe cause tiiee t^
HCU of psirUameAt' I am 6r from wishii^ | ecr, md destroy the waj of thy paths. 13.
to eacape tnal. I r^oiipe to tbink« I will now
have an opportonity to remove the public pre-
judices entertuned against me, and that now
my country shall recp^ise me io be, what
my heart tells me I am> its disinterested weU*
wisher.
Permit me then, gentlemen of the jury,*
to lay before you my own private opimon of
the crime of iSBdltion, the opinion which wa$
expressed from the bench, and to intreat yon
to fix some precise idea of the same, as the
standard by which to measure the decree of
criminality, in the actions, with the c^rcum^
stances attending them, which are charged
in the indictment
All crimes against the state may be divided
into three classes; treason^ sedition, and
petty misdemeanor. But m order to fix
guilt on the acts comprehended under these
several heads, two things must enter into the
description 01 them. 1st. Acts comprehended
in the term of misdemeanor, must, in theiF
consequences, or immediate effects, tend to
stir up sedition. Those again, under the de-
scription of sedition, roust, in like manner,
run into treason. Sd. These overt-acts must
severally appear to be performed, with the
evil intention to promote higher crimes ogainst
^ state. For example; a person may be
bound in dutv to say and do things direcUy
contrary to the present government of his
country, and which, in their immediate con.
sequences and native tendencies, are evi«
dently calculated to withdraw tlie affections
of the governed from their governors. But
here it will be admitted, by a Christian court
at any rate, that one roust obey God rather
than man; and consequently it must neces-
sarily follow, that, as a person so situated
could not be indicted for any criminal inten-
tion, whatever tendency the things which he
did conscisntiouslv might have to alienate
the afiections of the people from their rulers,
no crime could, in justice, be fixed on him.
Would the prosecutor say, tha^t the following
anecdotes of duty and patriotism^ which have
been preserved as examples of that liberty
wherewith Christ hath m^e his servants free,
were sedition? I shall read a few of them :
inMance the prophet Isaiah, ch. ix. v. 13.
^' For the people turneth not unto him that
smiteth them, neither do they seek the Lord
of hosts: 14. Therefore the Lord will cut off
from Israel head and tail, branch and rush,
in one day. \5, Tbe ancient and honourable,
he is the head ; and the prophet that teacheth
Ives, he is the tail. IG. For the leaders of
this peqife cause them to err ; and they that
are led of them are destroyed.?' Ch. iii. v. 1«.
^ As for my people, children are their op*
pressors, and women rule over them. O my
* Part of this pleading was delivered before
the jury alone; but tbe whole is given here,
that it may be seen at one view.— Oni^. Ed.
The Lord standeth vp to piead« and standsth
to judge tbe people. 14. The Lord will enter
into judgment with the ancients of his people^
and the princes thereof; for ye have eate^ vp
the vineyard ; the spoil of the poor ia in your
houses. 15. What mean ye tost ye heal my
people to pieces, and ^md the faces of the
poor } aaith tl^ie Lord God of hosts.'' Ch. k
21. ^< How is th&fiuthful city become an hac^
lot ! It was full of judgment ; righteousnesa
lodged in it; but now murderers. 92. Th^
silver is become dross, thy wine mixed witn
water. S3. Thy ]uinces are rebeUious, and
companions of thieves: every one loveth
gifU, and foUoweth after rewards: they judge
not the fatherless, neither doth the cause of
the widow come unto them. 84. Therefore,
saith the Lord, the Lord of hosts, the Mi^ty
One of Israel, Ah, I will ease me of mine ao*
versaries, and avenge me of mine enemies t
25. And I will turn my hand upon thee, and
purely purge away thy dross, and take awaj
all thy tin: 26. And I will restore thy judges
as at the first, and thy counsellors as at Sje
beginning: aflerward thou shalt be called.
The city of riehteousness. The faithful city.
27. Zion shall be redeemed with judgment,
and her converts with righteousness.''
Ezekiel, ch. xxxiv. v. 9. " Tbereibre, O
ye shepherds, hear the word of the Lord;
10. Thus saith the Lord God, Behold I am
against the shepherds ; and I wiU require my
flock at their hand, and cause them to cease
from feeding the flock; neither shall the
shepherds feed themselves any more ; ibr I
will deUvermv flock from their mouth, that
they may not be meat for them. 20. Behold
I, even I, will judge between tbe fiit cattle
and between the lean cattle. 21. Because ye
have thrust with side and with shoulder, and
pushed 9X1 title diseased with your boms, till
ye have scattered them abroad ; 22. Theye^
i^ie will I save my flock, and they shall no
more be a prey; and I will judge between
cattle and cattle. 23. And I will set up one
shepherd over them, and he shall feed tbeai,
even my servant David."
Would the lord advocate take upon him la
characterise these passages, as sedition F
Would he impeach the servants of the Most
High with this crime ? This would be to im*
peach our Lord Jesus Christ hioiself, who
not only commanded his servants to testify
such things against the evil rulers of the da^,
but corroborated what they had done by has
own personal deed, as we read in John.
John, ch. X. V. 7. ^' Then said Jesus unio
them again, Verily, verily, I say unto you, I
am the door of the sheep. 8. All that ever
came before me are thieves and robbers ; but
the sheep did not hear them. 11. I am the
soodshepheds the good shepherd giveth his
Efe for Uie sheep. 12. But he that is an hire-
ling and not the shepherd, whose own the
sheep are not, seeth w wolf ooming, and
309]
Jbr^edmm.
A. D. 1?94>.
[510
tesLveth ttie iheep, asiA ilMth; attd the wtdf
catcheth them, atid scatter^th thtr She^.^
The true denniticm of sedition then miMt
he, that^ich our own Scots statute^ sive
under the head of ka^ing-making agunst
the government of the bountr^, with a had
intention. 9p6akmg the troth can never he
aedftion ; tot truth, joa know, is tit libel.
If his lordship means Mid indkts, in the t^ord
sedition, a higher crime than that in om* sta^
tules under the head of leasinjg-maldng^ he
ought now to deehtite (MnAidly what he intends
by it; and the Court ougiht to fit hhn down
to such {precise definition ; lElnd they must also
dechu% the precise statute, or statutes, of
which his crime, so defined, is a breach ; ibr
without stating the precise standard, by tvhidb
the jury are to try my conduct, how can they
judge whether I have transgressed ? and how
hxx and how am I to justify my conduct,
against the charge of having transgressed ?
I know no law, cither of God, or man, that
I have trans^essed, in the matter of reform.
Wliat is the law which his lordship thinks I
have transgressed ? Let him now declare it^
if I have; and I will Vet pass over the in*
formality of its not being stated in the indict-
ment; though, as I am no lawyer, it would
be taking me rather upon too short warning.,
But if his lordship has no law by which to try
my conduct, except his own opinions, and has
raised thb process against me, trusting tliat a
jury in his sentiments will have the same
opinion of my conduct, that he has formed,
I will protest solemnly, that I cannot be tried
but by the laws of my country ; and as no
few nor statute, is stated in the indictment as
transgressed by me, I protest that my jury
may not proceed to find a law in their own
breast by which to try mv conduct; because
I hold it a privilege, of wnich a free man can
never be deprived, that he may do any, and
every thing not proscribed by the laws of his
country. I cannot know the private senti-
ments of my judges, by which I would, in
thai; case, be obliged to regulate my conduct,
if his opinion was my law. And what is sla-
very but this ?
' tx)rd Juttice Cfer/c.— There is one thing I
want fo know ; he says, he was odled as a
witness ; — ^was he examined f
Lord Advocate, — Palmer was brought to
trial at Perth, and Skirving was included in
the list of witnesses; but it was expressly
directed, that he should not be called as a
witness, unless it was found absolutely ne-
cessary to the conviction of Palmer.
Lord Jutlice C/tfrA.—That satisfies me; — I
always understood, that examining a man as
a witness, was an absolute preventative
against his being called upon afterwards^ by
a criminal prosecution; but he was not ex-
amined, and therefore that satisfies me.
Lord £ilMfrove.— The panel at the bar is
charged with sedition, and he has declined
to take the benefit which the laws of his
country afiford to eveiy criminal; he did npt
think proper to apply for counsel ; if he had,
hewtmtrf have received that indulgence; he
is now brought befoife a jtiry of his country,
and he will be allowed to bring any evidence
he thinks fit, to alleviate the charges against
hhii. My lord, 1 cannot think there is the
lea^ ground to doubt of tiie relevancy of th*
indictment. The gentleman says, it does not
mention anjr particular act upoh which it is
founded—it is very true it does not, but he
dertainlv does kno\«^ or may know, that the
law of Scotland is munded on many grounds,
besides diat o^ acts of parliament ; uiere are
many things in itv^hicn are established by
usa»e,— by the laws of God,— by the dictates
of the consciences of metf; and t believe, if
there is a crime apparent to the sense Of every
man, this crime, under the name of sedition^
is as well understood by every one in this
assembly, as by any one ofyour lordships. I
do not know what sort or government this
gentleman would vnsh to establish in his new
generation of government; but. I believe^
never any government existed, which did not
think it necessary to punish sedition among
the people, which might perhaps go the length
of overturning the government, which it does
not always do.; — it may have the tendency of
an attack upon government itself, according
to the nature of the particular charges ; but
to say, that an indictment charging sedition,
is not relevant without an act of parliament,
is contrary to usage, and contrary to law.
The first chai^ is, that of accession to the
publicaUon of Palmer's hand bill. M to that,
a jury of the country did find, that it was a
seditious libel. Had this gentleman been ad^^
mitted a witness there, I certainly would not
have allowed him to be libelled at the bar for
that offence; but he was not examined,
though he was cited as a witness.
The gentleman says, it is necessary that
the British convention should be first tried^
and convicted, before he can be charged, as
an individual, with the acts charged to have
been done in that convention. I do not un*
derstand that the convention is a body corpo<»
rate, but a convention of individuals; we
shall hear whether it was a convention met
for bad purposes or not; and whether this
gentleman was one of them. Suppose a meet*
mg of persons assembled under any name^
ana they should resolve amongst themselves,
that they would set fire to the city of Edin-
burgh; if the public prosecutor lays hold of
one of the persons that are present at that re«
solution, would it be consistent to common
sense, that he would have a right to say, I.
am not the representative of Uiat meeting ? ,
You must bring them and try them, before I
can be tried. My lords, it is not necessary
that that should be done, if he gave conciu--
rence to what was done in that assembly, that
is sufficient.
These people have chosen to follow the ex-
ample of the French convention ;~-the reso-
lutions that were come to, in their society,
511] 84 GEORGE in. PneeeiSnff agutut WUBam SUroHg
[SIS
by order of the same Gonvention, of which
this gentleman acted as secretary; — ^those
motions, those resolutions, and those ^)eeches
were published in a newspaper, by order of
the convention with the concurrence of the
panel. That is a circumstance that will
merit the connderation of the iurv, and the
Court. In cases of forgery, which is one of
those crimes, that we punish every day with
capital punishments, is one of those things,
which is of itself, in its nature a crime ; if an
hundred, or a thousand persons meet toge-
ther, ihey may be able to make the forgery
better, but if they use what they forge, if
they publish it, and carry it into the world,
then it becomes a capital crime at once,
though it was innocent while it remained in
their chambers. Those gentlemen meet, and
resolve to do this and that, and the other
thing, but they did not rest satisfied with
that, but they choose a Gazette of their own,
by which means they gain an influence upon
the minds of the people; and they order it to
be published.
My lords, taking all the circumstances to-
§ ether, it is, in the first place, for the jury to
ecide, whether the acts are proved ; or how
far they are proved ; and, secondly, whether
it proceeded trom a seditious intention, or an
innocent intention, — I should be very happy
if this gentleman can bring evidence to vindi-
cate himself I am very sorry to see this gentle-
man at that bar, amr the example of that
trial at Perth, and another, which are the
only two that have come within my know-
ledge. I am always extremely sorr^ when my
femvf subjects are charged with crimes ; but
it is my duty, and my country calls upon me
to sit here in judgment upon such pfiences.
I should be very glad, if this panel can
prove himself to be innocent ; but, ir be suilty,
wheUier it is occasioned by a disorder of mind
(for there are public insanities as well as pri-
vate ones), or whatever it may, I pity the sub-
ject of it ; but as a judge, I must conform to
the law ; every thing wilt come before the
jury ; and the panel will have the verdict of
his country.
Lord Swinton. If there is any wicked and
malicious attempt, by violence, to overturn
or disturb the present peace of the country, or
hurt the present government, that I under-
stand to oe sedition; as to the necessity of
founding it upon any act of parliament, it is
not necessary, though it is necessary for acts
of parliament to try crimes at common law.
As to whether the facts in the minor propo-
sition come up to the ofience stated m uie
major, I am ot opinion, that all these charges
come up, nay, ^ beyond the crime of sedi-
tion.
Mv lords, this hand-bill calls upon the
landholder '^ to coalesce with the Friends of
the Peonle, lest his property be soon left un-
tenanted: tlie merchant, lest the commerce
of the country be annihilated ; the manu%c-
turcr, whose laudable industry has been ar-
rested in its progress : the unemployed citi>
zen — the gieat mass of labouring and now
starving poor, and, finally, all the jabble are
called u\xm by the remembrance of their pa-
triotic ancestors, who shed their blood in the
cause of fireedom.'' Calling upon the rabble !
How are the rabble to do it P Can thev do it
in any manner but by outrage and violence f
Is there any other instrument in their hands,
but that of outrage and violence ?
Mv lords, I cannot help taking notice of
another tmng. ** Had certain gentlemen
countenanced this association last year, in-
stead of pledging their lives and fortunes to
prompt a corrupt and ambitious roinistxy, to
eneage in a war which could only brii^ euilt
and ruin on the nation, we might have been
still enjoying uncommon prosperity, and a
happy understanding amongst ourselves as
brethren. And now, if they wUl not man-
fullv retract that very impolitic step, and im-
mediately ioin their influence to the only mea-
sure whicn can prevent further calamity, if
not anarchy and ruin, their pledge may be
forfeited.'' — My lords, what was their pledge }
their pledee was their lives and fortunes. If
that is foifeited, that is to say they have for-
feited their lives and fortunes, and Uie
Friends of the People will be innocent : — in-
nocent ! of what? innocent of taking their
lives and fortunes from them: that is the
clear lanj^uage of this paper, and sad language
it is. lAhat does not breathe sedition, I do
not know what does. I am of opinion that
the libel is relevant.
Lord Dunsinnan. The fiicts stated in the
minor proposition, do, in my apprehension,
amount in a most a^ravated degree to the
crime of sedition ; a^ there can be no doubt
but this libel is relevant : and therefore, it
must of course go to the jury. It is unneces-
sary to add any thing farther.
Lord Abercromhie. It b the proidnce of
the iury, and of the jury alone, to judge
whetner the ^ts charged m the libel be true,
or not. The single point now before us is,
whether those facts, do sufficiently imply the
charge f My lord, upon this point, I should
be sorry indeed to have the least hesitation ;
I believe, there is not now present one
man possessed of common understanding^
who does not concur in the opinions whicn
have been delivered by your lordships, that
these charges do amount to sedition, and se-
dition of a most dangerous and aggravated na-
ture.
My lord, before the alteration of the law of
Scotland with reaard to treason, I think that
the fiu;ts charged in this indictment, might
have been laid as treason. Nay, my lord, if
a fact, which the solicitor-general stated,
should come out in evidence, tnat the British
Convention, as it is called, determined and re-
solved, that in the case of a French invasion, a
convention of emereencies was to be called, —
of courseto assist that invasion, — I think, if
that be a feet, the public prosecutor might have
515]
fir Se^tiori*
kid his charge as high treason ; but that is noi
the charse l^foreus ; it is a charge of sedition
only, aDdlani of opinion it is perfectly relevant.
Lord Justice Clerk, yLy lords, after what
I have heard, it is impossible to doubt that
the fact charged in the major proposition is
sedition. I am sure after the preceding
trials, and- the convictions following upon
them, it would be unnecessary for me, to use
words to satisfy your lordships, that sedition
is a crime by tne law of Scotland ; and, as to
whether the facts in the minor proposition,
come up to the major proposition, I think
tfab crime might hotre been laid as high
treason. I am veiy clear it might, b^
fore Ihe union. I will not say by the law of
England, it would have been tried as trea-
son; but I am sure it is sedition, both in
Scotland and in England. . .
[The interlocutor of relevancy read.]
Mr. Skirving. I hold that the jury are
judges of the relevancy, and that they are
equally judges of the law, as of the fact.
Lord Justice Clerk was beginning to name
the jury, when Mr. Skirving rose again, to
object.
Ijord Justice Clerk, I will hear you when
the first five are nominated, if you have any
thing to object.
Bfi. Skirving. The objections which I am
to make, being of a general nature, and not
personal, I wish to state them before any of
thejury are named.
Lord Justice Clerk proceeded to nominate
the first five of the jury.
Lord Justice Clerk. Have you an objection
to these fiv^ gentlemen.
Mr. Skirting, I object in general to all
those, who are members of the Goldsmiths*
Hall Association. And in the second place, I
would object to all those who hold places
under government; because it is a prosecution
hy government against me ; and therefore, I
apprehend, they cannot with freedom of
mmd judge in a case where they are materi-
ally parties.
Lord E$kgrov€, This gentleman*s objec-
tion is, that his jury ought to consist of the
convention of the Friends of the People ; that
every person wishing to support government
is incapable of passing upon his assize. And
hy making this objection, the panel is avow-^
ing, that it was their purpose to overturn the
government. *
Lord Justice Clerk. Does any of your
lordships think otherwise, I dare say not.
yir, Skirving. The ground of my objection
to these eentlemen, was not, that they be-
longed to that association, by no means ; but,
because they have prejudged me, in striking
my name out of their society.
Lord Justice Clerk. — I remember the same
objection was stated by Mr. Muir ; and was
over-ruled.*
— ^— ■^'— — ■■ ■' ' ' * ■ » ■ ■ ■ ■«
* See Mfiir*s case^pp. 134; el teq. of this
T<^ume.
VOL. xxm.
A. D. 17^4.
Names of the Juby.
[514
Sir Andreiy Lauder Dick, of Fountainhall,
hart.
Sir Hew Dalrymple, of North Berwick,
hart.
William Nisbet, of Dirleton, esq. '
Alexander Mackenzie, of Seaton.
5 David Anderson, of St. Germains.
John Caddel, of Cockenzie.
James Craig, of Setonhill.
Francis Buchan, Sydserf, of Ruchlaw.
John Milne, iron-monger in Edinburgh.
10 William La^b, upholsterer there.
Walter Brunton, sadier there.
Andrew Boog, cutler there.
Thomas Armstrong, coppersmith there.
David Milne, merchant there.
15 Edward Innes, confectioner there.
Evidence for the Crown.
Alexander Morren sworn. — Examined by Mr,
Buntetti
Do you remember in the course of last
summer, receiving any paper, or address from
the town of Dundee ?-^Yes, it was addressed
to friends and fellow-citizens, from the Dun-
dee Berean meeting house ; I got it from the '"
postroffice with a letter from Mr. Palmer, de-
siring me to get it printed.
Who did you employ to print it ? — My bro-
ther John ' Morren printed it : there were I '
believe a thousand copies thrown off, but I
am not positive. I was desired to give a few
to Mr. Skirving; and I gave a parcel of them
to a servant girl, that asked for them in his
name. . •' •
How many were there in that parcel ? — I
did not count them, but I believe there were
two quires, or two half hundreds.
Lord £f ftgrore— -They were printed m half "
sheets were they ?— Yes.
Mr. Burnett. — Had vou any conversation
with him, before or after you sent thi^ par-
eel ? — I heard that be had received it, but I
did not ask him.
Did you see him after you received Mr.
Paltner's letter?— Yes, I called upon him,
and did not see him; and he then called
upon me, and I showed him a copy of the
address ; he said he would see if some ^ends '
of his would approve of it, he would let me
know how many I was to keep ; and a man
called afterwards and told me I was to keep
a hundred copies for the society. I was to
have sent them ; but the girl came for them^
and I ^ve her two half hundreds.
Lord Justice Clerk, — Was the parcel di-
rected to Skirving ?^ — No, it was not directed.
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirving,
Does it consist with your knowledge, that
I knew any thins ef that paper, before you
mentioned it ? Were vou desired by the au-
thor of it, to take my advice in any respect ^ —
2 L
515] S4 GEORGE tO. Proeudiiigs ggakmi WiOiam Stirring fSMT
No, I was not. I was uneasy that Mr. Skir-
ving did not call upon- me ; ana therefore I
called upon him. I was afironted that he did
not approve of them ; for I approved of them
very mach myself.
How do you know that that girl, and that
man were sent by mc ?'-^I do not know ; they
came in your name.
Jamet Kidd sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Burnett,
Are yoii acquainted with Mr. Skirving?'—
jl es.
Did you receive any paper fipoqi him in the
course of last sununer? — Yes.
(The paper being produced] Was tbat the
]>aper ?-^I cannot recoliect^ it was about that
size; after reading the first two paragcapbs, I
destroyed it.
For what? — Because I thought the lan-
guage was too strong ; and I did not like it.
Ufrd Justice C/erX.-~Was it to thfit effect ?
— -I do not recollect one word of it,
Mr. Si^ieUor General, — Do you recollect
the substance of it ? — ^No.
Yott recollect nothing eactUy about it^—
No.
Lord Eskfnwe. — You say it was toc^stvoi^;
what was ue nature of it ? — ^As well as my
memory serves me now, it was something
about the Friends of the People, expressed in
such language that I did not like it
Lcn'd Advocate, — Since this indictment was
served upon the panel, have you had any
conversation with him, with any of his friends,
or with any of the other witnesses with reeard
to what you would say upon the subjectT— I
have had no conversation with him, nor no
person has instructed me what io-sayiyion
this sumect
I ask you again, have you had any conver-
sation with any of the other witnesses^ wiUi
ffe|ard to the subject of this trial ?— No.
Were yoa ever called upon, within, this
week, to attend a meeting of the witnesses
uppn this trial?— Upon my word, I never
was.
Do you know a man of the name of Bobb»
that lives upon the Sputh Bridge?-^! know
the man by sight I was in his bouse about
ekhteen months ago.
Were you there last Wednesday ?•— No, I
was not
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirving.
Did I give you this paper, or did you come
and set it from me?-«-I went up to ask the
paneihow he did, and he asked me if I had
seen that ; I asked him what it wajs, and he
said I might take it home and read it.
You said> vou destroyed it because you did
not like the language, and that vou only read
the two first paragraphs. I shall read as far
as that, and then ask you a question [reads
theml. I want to bring to his recollection,
t^t this was not the paper.' Is there any. part
fniNh^x I have TMud thatjm thiok olgection-
•able? — All I cab 9^ 1^ that as Ar aa I'
read, I did not like the language of it.
Were you a member of one of the sooatiaa
of the Friends ef Hit People ?--*Ya^ I «aa
once.
[The portion of ikm panel to tha Cdart^
when afipiehended in gau read].
Joseph Mack sworn. — Exanuoed bj Mr. .
BurneU.
Tlie witness ptoved the dedaattiABS'Of tW
panel.
Were ^qii employed ill tiba ticc8tie» of a
warrant issued, the begianing of December
last, by th|» sheriff of ^inburgb, against the
panel r-^Yes, I accomminied Fraxer andDtng-
wall^ to his bouae early m the morning, and
found htmr in bed; it was a warrant forsei»»
ing the panel, and such papers as we shoiikl :
find: we put the papers in two ba^ sealed
tbemrand ouried them to the shenff cleck^s
oSce.
WereAhey sealedup in the presence of Mr.
Skirvtng?-r^Yes, and thicy ware produced
before him, in the sheriff ckrkfs oAce*
Were yon present when the bag «9»'
opeaedl-^I tmnik sq^ but I am not aiiwof
Was Skirvins present when the bag waa
opened?—- Yesy.! am suie of thai. The pa«
pers that were Uiought materid wene put into
aainveutoiy^ and those that weoe not, were
^turned to Skirvin^; the imrento^am de^
clarationiscontalneftin one. Mr. Dingwall
wrote part of it, and J wrote part of it.
Iiook at thatf •— This is the general Inv^-
tory in my hand*writing, and this is the de« '
claration that was made at the same time.
Did yott identify those different documente.
in any way .--Yes, myself, the sheriff^ and
Mr. Dingwall put our initials upon them;
and upon those that were the most particular
ones we put our names at fiill length.
[The witness then examined the papers with
the inventory, and substantialed them ali
except article 24.]
Cross-exami,qed by 1^. Skirving,
When this dechiration 91st July waagivea
in, you were present ?-r-Yes I was.
Was IM that time dismissed simplidter^
— Yes^ you were not laid under bail at thai
time.
Was I apprehended under a watrant?-^!-:
believe you were.
You said you were present at the op^bg
of the bags?— I cannot speak positively to
the bag being opened before I came, or afletk '
JoAh Dingwall sworn. — Examined by Mr..
Burnett,
Do you remember a warrant being issued
in l^ecember last against the panel ?-^There *
were two different warrants, I remember '
particularly the last was upon the fourth of
December, and was executed^on the morning
of the fiAh; I was present at the execution '
3tn
A. D. in*.
f5I8
^ it» Iha papclfB ^re found we wtukd up hi
4tie presence of Mi. Skirvioft, and put my
.«Bal vpcui one part of the twgSy and Mr.
Skirrmj^ put his upon another; I saw the
.ha« affer thej wero brought to the office;
and they were entered into an inventory.
Were you preeent when the bags were
opened F-^-Yes, and Mr. Skirving too.
Did you sign this general inventory or any
ef the papers?--- Yes.
Were you preeent at the declaration to
which that kiventory refers ?^-Ye& I wrote
the first port of it**-it was emitted neely and
voluDtaruy, and be was sober and in his
Were the different artides in the inventoiv
«utheDtKated ?— ^id you mark them with
your initiais ?-*^ Yes.
]The witness then examined them with the
inventoiy.]
Cross-examined br Mr. Skirting.
Do you recoUecty when I was desired to
.«ign that declaration of the 5ih of Decem-
her, that I said I had made no deckurationy
^tod would sign no paper, and yrhesn the
abefiffeubstitute dki put his name to it, I
4lesired those who were present, to notke.
that I had made no decmratkm, and wouki
.^ign no paper.— I do not recollect it.
Ltftd Juatiee Cierk. — ^You did not take ahy
4hlng down but what he said ? — No.
If C William Scott sworn.— Examined by Mr.
Burnett. <
. Wore yon present when these declarations
men emitted by the panel?— Yes, they were
^iret and voluntary, ha was sobet and in his
' Were you present when the bags were
'Opened ?<— Yc% and the panel was present-^
an inventory was made out of them, and
iwihcnlicated by the persons present.
[The witness examines them with the in^
ventory.]
Lord Adtfoeate. — Had yon occasion to al-
lend the sheriff and maeistrates upon the
6th and ath of December Fast ?^Yes, on the
evening of Fnday the 6th, we havhig heard
that the British convention had a meeting
<SMoewfaere on this side of the town— I went
with the sheriff and magistrates, and found
4hem asaelnblcd in Lady Lawson** garden,
about 7 or 8 o^clock ; I went in, and I ob-
Mrved the panel and several others whom I
knew; the chair was then empty, whoever
had been in it before, and there was a call to
'tl^Lfihair. Mr. Margttot * took the chair.
The magistrates callea them to be dispersed--
Matnrot and others said they were met
ftnr legal aud constitutional purposes, and
thcrjr would net disperse till toey were com-
pelled by force; and desired us to hear Mr.
Gerrald'sf speech, who had been speaking
•*■•
.i&MbaMHHM
MMM
MM4fa
* See bis case in this vohime, in/rA
t See hia case in this vohmiei i^frik
IftfiM^ we came in, and Ae maristretes told
them that nothing of the kind would take
nlace. Th«re was then a general call for Mr.
Margarot to take the chair, and Mr. Gerrald
to go on. Mr. Margarot said he would not
leave the chair till he was compelled. Mr^
Davidson took him by the hand, and he then
left the chair; upon this there was a call for
I Gerrald to take the chair, whtch he accord-
ingly did; when Mr. Davidson required he
would leave it, and insisted upon their dis-
persing.
Did you hear what they were met for? —
Yes, XhaX they were met upon some business-
relative to petitioning the king upon some
subject Oerrald likewise reused to leave
the chair, till he was compelled ; Mr. David-
son said, he supposed the sam^ compulsion
would serve him as had done Mr. Marearot—
he took him by the hand, and he lefl the
chur. Then Mr. SkirvinjB; called upon some
one to take a 'protest agamst the sheriff; he
called for a notary — but no notary appeared :
somebody put them in mind that they were
permanent, and said tiiev would keep this in
view though they were oismissed now — they
wbuM reni^mber that they were a permanent
convention, or words to that eflect.
Do you know the house ? — ^Yes. it was at
Mr. Laing^^ a wrieht, in a work-shop be-
longine to him. The panel had been appre^
bended the dav before— was examined by the
sheriff, and had been admitted to bail : he was
apprehended as being a member of tnat con-
vention.
Cross-examined by Mr. Skiroing.
Did not you obtain a warrant fW>m the
sheriff to apprehend me, upon a petition
given in by vou, upon 3l9t July, relative to a
paper published from Dundee ?— Yes.
Did not your petition request the sheriff to
commit me to prison ? — ^It was the very pur-
pose of the application.
Was I not dismissed simpliciter on exa-
mination, and was not committed to prison
till eight or ten days afler, when I attended
again upon a citation of your own ? — ^No ; he
was taken, but it did not appear that he was
the author of it ; he was let to pass, but
upon findine that there was a correspondence
carried on between him and Palmer, he was
again taken up and examined ; and a letter of
Palmer's beuig found in his pocket, he was
committed as a party to the publication of
that paper, of which he received so many
copies from Morren.
At what time was this f — In tiie declarer
tion emitted 3l8t Julv.
Mr. Skirvmg. -^I beg that my declaration
at that time may be read.
[It is read.]
Mr. Skirting. -^YoM see 1 took a knowledge
of the letter at the very first,— I acknow-
ledged every thing that was laid against me,
tfiomoi^^was I not dismissed simpliciter at
thai time^ and was ji||^ taken up upon a new
519] 34 GBORGE IIL Proceedings agakut William SUroing [590
petition, though do new matter was brought
against me >
WUneu. — ^We suspected he was possessed
of that letter, and a warrant was issued to
search liis house, and the letter was found.
Did I not give up all the Dundee papers,
, and tell you I could not find the letter, but'
when I did, I would give it up ? — Yes ; but
you never did, though it was found in your
possession afterwards. -
Was I not at that time dismissed simpli-
citer, that is, without being desired. to come
again? — ^You were only allowed to go and
^arch for that letter.
The witness will recollect that he is upon
his oath, and I ask him, if there were any
such conditions ? — ^There cert9inly was; you
went away to find that letter.
Harry Davidson^ esq. sworn*
[In his examination on the part of the Crown,
confirmed the last three witnesses in every
particular, except the last part of Mr.
Scott's.]
Cross-examined by Mr. Skiroijig.
Were you informed, that we were met that
night particularly about a petition to parlia-
ment?— ^Yes, I think it was Margarot who
said, that they were then discussing a peti-
tion.
Was I not apprehended by a warrant is-
sued by you, upon, the Slst July last? — ^I be-
lieve you were.
Granted upon the petition of the fiscal,
requesting me to be incarcerated ? — I tliink it
is more than probable that it was so, but 1
do not recollect.
Was I not dismissed upon the declaration
I then made, without finding bEul?— Yes.
Only eight days after, did I not appear
before you again, upon the same subject ? —
Yes.
And you granted a warrant to search my
house? — I certainly did ^rant a warrant to
search your house, and to incarcerate you.
And of course, this was on a new petition
from the fiscal ? — I believe it was.
The
^d, he had been placed there by the au-
thority of the convention, and could not leave
it till he was compelled by force. I went
accordingly to the chair, to band Mr. Browne
out : there were three constables in the room
at the time.
Did you see the panel there that night? —
Yes, he said. They were a lesal and constitu-
tional meeting; and that uey were upon
business that was for the good of the countij,
drawing up an address to the kine, or parlia-
ment, or something of that kina; they dis-
missed peaceably soon after ; and I took the
key away with me. — I heard one of the
members in the comer of the room say, that
they would adjourn to some place in the Ca-
nongate ; upon that account, we sent down
some oficers to see if they did so, and were
informed, that it was a meeting of a society
for some charitable purpose, and not of these
people, who call themselves *'The Friends of
the People.'' — I was informed, that the
Friends of the People waited till that meeting
was dismissed, and then they took possession
of the place.
Ilad you ihformation of any meeting sub-
sequent to this ? — ^Yes, we had people placed
through the town to prevent tneir meeting
again : and we heard that there was to be a
meeting the next evening ; but it being out
of my jurisdiction, it uy more with the
sheriff; and 1 went with the sheriff sub-
stitute to disperse them; — it was in a car-
penter's shop. I saw several people there,
whom I haa seen the evening before, par-
ticularly Mr. Skirving, and I think Mr.
Callender.
Did they call themselves <* The British
Convention ?" — Yes.
Did they instantly disperse? — Yes; only
as the evening before, desiring some force to
be used by way of etiquette.
And Skirving was there that second night i
--Yes.
Was any thins said of their meeting being
permanent ? — Not that I remember^
Did any body speak of a protest, and call
for a notary ? — I neard Skirving offer to take
protest both nights. In consequence of
le right hon. Thomas EUer, lord provost, X-^'"''^''" T^^TT i.^'^J'^T^T"^."''^
Lord Advocate.
I
Had you ever any occasion in the course of
your duty, to disperse any persons in the
month of Deceipber? — I had. I went with
3ome of the magistrates and peace officers, to
a mason lodge in Blackfriars wynd, on Thurs-
day the 5th of December,~we went up to
what I understood to be the chair, and asked
f* '}f that was the meeting of the delegates of
the Friends" of the People ?" Mr. Skirving
answered, I think, and said " Yes, they
were ;" and so did Mr. Paterson who was in
the chair. Mr. Paterson soon after walked
out, and the meeting called from all quarters
for Mr. Browne to take the chair; wno took
iyt.9ccujdlngly ; and bemg desired to leave it,
meetings
the next day.
• Was that proclamation attended to, or dis-
obeyed ?-^It was disobeyed so far; that an ad-
vertisement appeared in the Gazetteer, on
Tuesday following, the lOth, signed by Skir-
ving, <' calling a meeting of the triendsof
the People, on the i2th;' in consequence of
which, I issued a warrant against Skirving
on Wednesday, the day after the advertise'-
men. appeared, when he eiuitted a declara^
tion. I then issued an order, prohibiting him
from calling that meeting at toe cockpit.
. '^id you give him a copy of it?— ^Ue might
have had it, if he desired it ; it was read over
to him,, and I think he said, he would read:
it the next day, .
fi21] Jbr, Seiidpn:
> " .Cross-exunined by Mr. ^ireing,
M;^ lord, when you came to disperse the
meeting in Bhuskfruurs wynd, was it not given
as a reason, why we did not disperse volun-
tarily, that it was a meeting of delegates sent
there by other people upon important busi-
ness. ? — Yes, I beheve you did say so.
• That the business we were engaged in,
and which was appointed for that nieht, some
'^lays before, was about petitioning the House
of Commons ? — I believe, words to that pur-
pose mi^t have passed, but I cannot be
positive.
Upon your saying, that you must use force,
did I not move, that as we had neither in-
clination nor abUity to oppose force, any sisn,
such as your going up to the chair^ should oe
considered as force ?— I did not hear any such
thing: I know, both you and Mr. Brown
said, you would not go without force.
You i^st recollect that the motion came
' from me, that we should disperse peaceably ?
•—No, I believe Mr. Aitcheson was the per-
.son ; he said it was the same thing whether
they went out, or whether tney were com-
pelled to go out.
Do you recollect saying, that you had ju-
risdiction over a public-house, but not a pri-
vate-house ; ana I said, we considered this
as a private-house ? — I believe you, or some
other body, did say something to that pur-
pose.
Was I not apprehended upon a petition of
the. fiscal; which petition prayed a warrant
of commitment f—Yes.
Was there an order given by the magis-
trates, not to show the warrant? — ^I know
nothine of such an order; I should raliier
think the order would be to show it. — ^I r^y
do not know.
A declaration was taken from me at that
time, and the afiair at the cockpit was after-
wards?— ^Tbat at the cockpit, was taken by
some, other magistrate.
And I was dismissed simpliciter? — ^You
certainly were, that evening.
And there was no action since commenced
against me, at the instance of the town coun-
sel ?— Not that 1 know of.
l^eil M* Vicar, sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Burnett,
m
Had you, as a magistrate, any occasion to
attend my lord provost at anv time in Decem-
ber last, to diverse any illegal meeting? —
Yes, I attendea my lord provost to B&ck-
friars wynd : Mr. Paterson was in the chair,
the lord provost went up, and asked him, if
it vras a meeting of the people, stylins
themselves ^' The British Convention ;'' ana
he said it was ; that they were met for a con-
stitutional purpose: and particularly, that
evening, they were met to petition the king
for annual parliaments and universal sufirage;
— my lord provost desired he would quit tiie
chair; hesaid^.ibey had not broke the peace
A. D. 1Y94..
[528
in any one instance, and it was a rule in the
convention that no one should leave ^e chair
without the orders of the convention, unless
by force ; my lord said, if he would notwith-
out, force would not be wanting. Mr. Pater-
son moved, that they should depart peaceably ;
he said, it was the duty of every nody to oe
submissive to the magistrates ; this was not
in general agreeable ; and Mr. Paterson hav-
ing left the chair, there was a loud cry for the
cluiir, Mr. Browne was called to it by a ge-
neral voice ; he addressed the meetine, and
said, as he was called to the chair by the
general voice of the meeting, he would not
leave it, but by force ; and immediately after,
lowering his voice, and speaking to the pro-
vost, he said, anv sien of force was sufficient
Soon afler, the lora provost said, I will act
as chief constable myself went up to the
chair, took Mr. Browne by the hand, and
gently pulled him away ; afler which the
meeting dispersed.
Was Skirving there? — ^Yes.
Did you hear any person speak of a pro-
test ?— No, I did not
Had you occasion to go to anv other placa
the night following ? — I went the night fol-
lowing, to a carpenter's yard.
Diayou see Mr. Skirvine at that meeting?
— No, I saw Mr. Callender and Mr. Mar-
garot; the meeting; was dispersed that night;
and the next day in consequence of a procla-
mation from the magistrates, Skirving emitted
a declaration in my presence, voluntarily and
freely.
He was sober, and in his senses? — Yes; I
do not know whether it was read over to htm,
I was not present
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirting,
I beg the latter part of my declaration be-
fore the magistrates, of the nth December,
mav be read, to refresh the witness's memory,
as he seems to have forgot a circumstance?
[It is read.]
Does it consist with your knowledge, that
the meeting which I called by that advertise-
ment, was totally distinct from the British
convention? — ^I remember very well, that
you were at great pains to convince us^ that
It was not the same meeting.
Mr. Burnett, — ^Was there a declaration read
over to tlie panel on the I2th, as far as you
recollect ?^ cannot say.
[The declaration read.]
Mr. Skirving. — Does it consist with your
knowled^, thisLt the fiscal gave in a petition
oomplaimng of my having put in that adver-
tisement, and craving, that I should be
brought up and punished ; and that a war-
rapt was issued, and I was examined upon
that petition ? — Yes, you were brought up in
conseouence-of that
Ana there is no process on that accoutit
against mein £dinburgh?^Not that I know of.
And I was dismi^s^ simpliciter ?— rl cannot
say.
iSS} "34 GfiOBGB m. ProuediHgSJigmd WWam ^ird^g fpUt
jnUiam pmitery esq. sworn.— Eummed by
Mr. Bumett.
Does it consist with yoar knowledge, that
« srocUmation was issued ittaiDst the people
filing themselves ^The British Conven-
#iMinL-Yes; on the 11th of December, and
en Thursdav the 19th^ soon after IS o'clock,
I went to the Gniss-market, where there was
a great crowd assembled at the entry of a
dose leadmg to the cockpit; and Mr. Skirr-
ing was reading to the people a paper which
he had in his hand ;-^^hen I gart mto the
heart of the crowd, I bemd that he would
denst, which he did ; and some of the peace
officers began to take the paper from hhn by
fnoe, 1 waved my hand, and desired them
not to use any foroe against Mr. Skhrving,
tmlesi he chose to give it up, which I believe
he did. Mr. Skirvhig wasy at my desire,
bfou^t before me, in the council chamber,
and examined ; and was afterwards carried to '
Goldsmiths-hall.
Was that declaration made m your pra-
seaoe?— Yes, Uiisis my subscription to it; it
was fiedv and voluntarily emitted^ and he was
tober and in his senses.
[Shows him a paper.] Was that the paper
you todcfrom the panel ?~I believe it is.
Croaa-examined by Mr. Skirving,
Was I apprehended upon a warrant on the
Wednesday, and sent to the council cham-
ber?—I do not know upon what warrant you
were s^prehended — I did not see the warrant.
-^I was present at ^our declaration.
' And I was dismissed without bail, or any
new process of law instituted against me? —
I know of no other process.
Jiimiff Laing swom.-^Examined by Mr.
Bumeti,
Did you attend the magistrates to the Grass-
market at any time?— Yes, to disperse an il-
legal meeting on Thursday, the 12th Decem-
ber: they were assembled in a close that
leads up to the cockpit. I saw Mr. Skirvins
reading a paper ; Mr. Browne was on his left
hand, and a magistrate came forward, and
spoke to Mr. Skirving, took hold of his hand*
and he put the paper in his waistcoat
pocket; he had read one side, and had turned
It to read the other.
Was he afterwards apprehended ? — ^Yes.
Were you present at his examination.— N0|
I was not
[The paper produced in court ; see indictment^
page 479.]
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirving.
Do you remember the first day that I was
examined after vou came in, I desired a copy
of it, that I mi^t read it ? — I do.
Does U consist with your knowledge, that
Idid not read it?.— ^No, I did not ses you
read it.
William Men MronL— -Eaaoiined bjf Mf . Btcr-
wit.
Were you, or are you a nmnber of Htm
BMeting of the Friends of the People ?— I aok
What is ytmr prafeamm?— A clerk- ia the
Gaattteer i^oe«
Look attfaat paper, 4th October 1793. Wh*
is the author of tluU hand-bill ?— I am tfaeau*
thor of the first coiumD, or half of it.
By vHxrae directions didyov compose it?-*
By no personls diiectioiha.
To whom were yon lo •ubmit that compost^
tion?— To the Friends of the People, in Iha
mason kidge, Bbckfrtai^ wynd, at a general
meetiiig at which I attended, I gaveit to my
brother to read it.
Was the panel a member of that aneetiag ?-«
I believe he was secretary.
Do vou know who composed the second
part of this paper f^^ do not know.
Does not it consist with yoor knowledge,
that that hand4>ill was cirookted ?«^I have
seen them about the streets.
Have you occasion to know where it was
printed ?— Yes ; in the Gazetteer office.
Had you any concern in the printing of it ?
—No.
Was Mr. Skirving's name anneaed to itf-*
It was, in the printed a^v.
Do you know who paid for the printing of
it?— To whose account it was put?— I xac-
ther think, but I do not know, that it was put
to the society of the Friends of the People.—
I am a clerk m the office, but I do not np»
nage that part of the business.
Who does ?— Mr. Scott.
Had you any conversation with Mr. Skii^
ving about it ?— I do dot recollect that I saw
him at that thae.
Were you a member of the convention of
the delegates of the people, the British con-
vention ?— Yes I was, I attended it the first
Was there any subsequent convention met
afterwards ?— Yes, there was.
And the re-assembling of the whole co».
ventioD, do you recollect where they met?
it was this winter, was it not?— Year
Did you attend that meetina;?— I did.
Who acted as secretary to that meeting ?—
Mr. Skirving ; I do not know whether he vf^
secretary, but he acted in that capacity. ^
Were there any other secrctanes, assuUnt
secretaries, or depute secretaries, or substiUite
secretaries, who acted at that meetmg?—
Yea ; Mr. Aitcheson was appointed by the
meeting to assist Mr. Skirving. ^ ^ ■
Any body else ?— You, or your biolhcr ?-*
I never did. My brother used to take notes ;
and several other persons did the same : I do
not recollect who they were.
Were their accounts, to your knowledfl^
of the proceedings of this convention publun-
ed weekly in the Gazetteer, or abstraeto?—
Do you know that thererwas a flcmll of i
ABl
faitSMiafh
A. IX i7m;
JjS^A
nutes made up 9$, each sitting N-^Yes, then
werOp which were sometimes lead «t the neil
fiEieetingy and sometimes not.
Were there ever any corrections^ or altera-
tvonsy made upon the leading of those mi-
nutes ? — Yes, by Mr; Skirvin^and Mr. Aitche-
eon: but there was a committee proposed to
he appointed to revise the minutes.
Did this scroll o§ minutes Gontain an accu-
rate statement of what p»sed ?*— They con-
tained ^e Biibsttmoe of what passed.
Should you know the scioU of minutes
again, if you weie to see themf-*>I saw them
in the shoriff^lerk's office.
Look if you know any body's hand wrtting
thsce. [Shows htn the scroU.]^^!! is like my
brewer's hand^wnting.
Do you know Skirving's hand-wriliiig ? — I
have seen papers which were said to be his
but I never saw him write ;
this koks hke what I have been told was bis ;
hut I cannot say, ae I never saw him write.
Lord Dunsinnan. Do you tlunk it is like
hb hand-writing f-^I tiitnk it resembles it.
Lord ildaoc4il0.-«Did you use to take down
the debates of the convention in short-hand *
—Yes.
For what inirpose ? — ^For publication in any
rnxf I tboy^t proper.
In the cSzetieer ? — Yes.
Was what was published in the liews-
paper, in geneml, a correct statement of what
passed in the convention, as fer as you know ^
— -My notes were very incorrect; having ta-
ken a bad cold which affected my hearing,
but I made tfaiem. as near as I could.
Were you accurate with regard to the names
cf the speakers!— I cannot say.
Do y^Ni remember any motion being made
in particular by Mr. Skirvine? Did you ever
hear of « solemn league and covenant in the
convention (and consider before vou give an
apswer) or any thing resembling loose words ?
—I cannot say.
Did vou ever hear him make any motion at
all in the course of their proceedings ?— 'There
were so many spoke that I cannot tell.
What! did ae sit dumb during all this
lime ? — I do not recollect bis making any mo-
tion.
Do yott know of any committee called a se*
cret committee, being appointed b^ the con-
vention'?— I recollect something of it.
Do you remember if the secretary was a
member of that N-*I cannot remember that.
Lord Abererombie. You have sworn by Al-
mighty God to tell the truth and the whole
truth ; if therefore you say, you do not recoK
lect what you do recollect, you are guil^ of
periuiy. — I am very much obli^d to your
lardship for the admonition; but I do not re-
collect that
Lord Advocate* I ask you again, who ^ere
to lie the members of that secret committee f
— ^I cannot recollect that*
Do ycu remember what was to be the bu-
rio^M of this secret committee f«-4t was to
I
V
appoint a place cf meeting for the membert
present.
Was thie place of meeting ta be made
knewtt to any bedy besides the membersof
this secret committee? — ^I suppose it was U^
be communicatad.
And upon what occasion w«8 it they were t0
meet think you ?— In certain cases.
What cases ^— Cases of emevgency ; I ca»*
not recollect them all.
You need not repeat them aM ; but you
must tell us some of them before we part?*^
One was, in case of a \M being brought uito
parliament^ similar to the convention billinr
Ireland.
That is one: now tell us any other ^-*-icaIl-»
not recollect.
Upon your oath^ did you ever hear of any
other being mentioned f— I do not recoHectt
them.
You have told us there were some others ;
now you must know something about ^am;<
was any thins mentioned about a foreign ph-^
vasien? I aal you upon your great oath?-**
There was something about a foreign inva-
sion, but I do not know that that was one of
the cases of emergency.
How came it to be mentioned at all ^— I
cannot say; it might be at the beginning of »>
motion, or something of that kind.
Was it upon the occasion of debating upon
a convention of emergency F*— I cannot say.
Was a dispersion of the meeting ever g|ven»
as one of the cases of emergency ?— -There
was some conversation about that^ the night
before;
I see you are very correct in some things,
though not in others. Did you ever hear oi
the &oteh act of 1701, against wron^ua imi-^
prisonment ? *^~I have heard of it.
Did you ever hear it mentioned in the con*
vention, as one of those cases of emergency,
if a motion should be made for suspending
that act of parliament?— recollect yourself?—
I think I do recollect it
Did you ever hear of the habeas corpus act
in England ?-— I Itave frequently heard of it-
Did you hear of it in the convention the
other day ? — ^Yes.
If a motion should be brought into par-
liament to suspend the habeas corpus act;
was that a case of emergency ? — Yes.
Were there any other cases of emergency
mentioned? — ^I do not recollect any more.
Look at that, is that one of the papers pub-
lished iit your office ? — ^Yes.
And these ? — Yes.
Do you know if they contun the substance
of the proceedings of tne convention^-— Yes.
What was the common name by which the
members were addressed y— You will see in
the papers.
But we want to hear from you ? — Sometimes
citizen.
Did you ever hear the word section used
-— ■ ' ■ * ■■■.i» -i ,.i I .. . ■■
*Seevol. 19 page 62 of this Collection. J'
587] 34* GE0&6E III; PrdceetUngi againtt WOUam Skirving [528
in tb6 convention? — ^Yes, they were divided
into classes, or divisions, or sections ; a sec-
tion consisting of fifteen or thereabouts : they
met every morning, and reports made in the
evening.
Were you a member of a section. — ^Yes, No.
4; we met in 8imonVsquare.
Were you ever present in the convention,
when reports were made by other sections ? —
Yes.
Did you ever receive any strangers in the
convention ? — Yes.
Did you tver confer any mark of favour
or honour upon any sixangers ? — No.
Did you ever hear or know that there, was
at any time honourable mention made of any
person ?— I cannot say that I ever did.
Did you ever see or know the honour of
^e sitting given to any person that came in?
—No ; I do not recollect it.
Have you had, since the indictment was
served upon Skirving, a meeting of the wit-
nesses on his trial? — I have been in compa-
ny with some of them, but do not know of
any meeting appointed.
Do you know a man of the name of Robb ?
-^I have been in his house.
Were not you there last Wednesday even-
ing ? — ^Yes.
Was Mr. Marwot there F-r-Yes.
And SomerviUe ? — Yes.
There were ten or a dozen of you ? — Yes, I
believe there was.
Do you know the purpose of that meeting?
•^It was newryear's day. I heard that they
were to dine there, and I went over to them.
Mr. Solicitor General, — Who told you of
that meeting ? — ^I do not recollect I did not
know of it tni within an hour of the meeting.
You went upon the summons of you do not
know whom— was it ^r. Margarot?— No.
Was it SomerviUe? — ^No.
Your brother? — No.
John Clark, the mason? — ^No.
Was he there ? — No.
At that noeeting, was this trial the subject
of conversation? — It was mentioned that the
trials w«re. coming on this week.
And what was^aid about them ? — I do not
recollect.
And do you think we are to believe that? —
I cannot recollect any thing particularly re-
lathag to the trial, or with regard to the peo-
ple who have been summoned as evidences.
Was any thing scud about what was to be
the event of the trials ; or about the evidence
upon the trials ? — ^Not that I recollect.
Lord DuTuinnan^ — ^You will remember, that
you are to answer at the great tribunal of Al-
mighty Ood for what ^ou now say. — I cannot
recollect that any thing particular was said
about it.
Cro89*examined by Mr. Skirving,
If I put^y ooestions respecting the con-
vention, it. is tor the sake of occasionally
taking any blame from them, and not as it
respects myself, because I do not hold mvself
responsible at present for what they tlo.-^
Does it consist with your knowledge that
ever a deputy-secretary was appointed by the
convention ? — No.
Did the convention ever acknowledge any
minutes of their proceedings, till a committee
of their own had drawn them up? — No, I be-
lieve not
Did the convention appoint any names to
be used by its members in preference to
others ? — ^No, not that I know of.
Did the convention appoint any established
form of procedure, or were they only con-
sulting about it? — ^If I recollect rieht, plans
had ^en given in, but none of them were
adopted berore it was broke up.
Had you ever tlie . least apprehension of
any design to raise tumult, riot^ or any thing
like sedition, in all the proceedings you have
seen of mine in that convention ?-*-I never
had the smallest idea of it.
On the contmry, have I not always urged
attention to order, and regular proceedings ?
— I have always seen you attentive to good
order, and regularitjr-
Does it consist with your knowledge, that
meetings by delegates were preferred to go- '
neral meetings, in order that things might
be more regularly carried on ?— I understood so.
And that tbe principal business of the con-*
vention from first to last, was an application
to parliament for reform? — ^That was the only
object that I know of.
Tiiis secret committee, — was it not surely
a committee of confidence, and appointed for
the purpose of timeous remonstrance, against'
a quietism -bill, by a speedy call of the con-
vention the instant that a motion for such a'
bill passed the House of Commons? — ^I under*
stood it so.
Alexander Jitcheson^ sworn. — Examined by
Mr. Burnett.
Are you a member of the society of the
Friends of the People? — ^Yes; I became a
member upon the memorable 9th of August,
1793. 1 joined the general association at*
that time. I afterws^s attended at Bar-
ber's-hall ; and afterwards, I joined the first
meeting of the Canongate Society.
Were you a mem^r of the British con-
vention ? — Yes, I was a member of all the
three conventions by delegation firom the-
Canongate Society.
Was the panel a member ? — Yes, he acted '
as secretary.
Did )rou bear any office ? — ^Not in the first
convention, but afterwards in the second and
third, I did assist Mr. Skirving. I took notes
to the best of my knowledge of the business.
Were they in general as accurate as you
could make them ? — ^To say they were ac- '-
curate, would be paying too great a compli-
ment to myself^ out I did it to tlie hui of
my abilities, «
SgS]
Jhr StdihoH*
A. D. 1794k
[530
Look «t the scroll of miAutes,- and see if il
is your hand-writinx ? — ^Part of it is.
Do Tou know Skirving*9 hand-writing^ —
Koy I do not.
Is that like it? — ^I cannot say; there were
other geotleroen appointed at the last conven-
tion as assistants to the secretary } and I be-
lieve I could guess at Mn Ross's writing ;
here are two or three pages of his ; there are
several other hands, but none that I know
except Mr. Ross's and mine.
Is this any tiling like any hand-writing
tfiat you know? — ^Is this like Skirvine's? —
It seems like a great many hands mat I
know; it is a very general kind of hand, and
never having conesponded with him, I can-
not swear to his writing; when I have been
absent from the convention, and have come
in after the sitting was besun, I have seen
him write, but paid no sudi attention as to
be able to swear to it
Did you offer to give in a resignation of
your tiUf to be there as a member ? — ^Yes, I
fyaod it inconvenient to my business, but
they reJused to accept it, saying, I might
come when I could ; and they appointed two
delegates in my room.
Do you know if the minutes were revised
by a committee of the convention; — Yes,
before engrossing, they were always first re-
vised by acommittee ; and ordered by the com-
mittee to be entered in a book, and after-
wards printed.
Do you recollect any thing about the pro-
ceedings of the convention, particularlv the
names that the members went by ?--! do not
know what you allude to by that question.
Was Mr. Skirving called William Skirving,
or what? — No, we were not a society of
Quakers.
Did ^rou eter hear the word citizen in the
convention?— Yes, and I think it is the best
title a man can have. I should blush for
myself, as a burgess of Edinburgh, if I did
not think so; and it is preferable to master,
because we are commanded to call no man
master.
Mr. SolieUor General, — ^Did you at any
time hear any thing pass relating to a con-
vention bill? — Yes, 1 remember a motion
was broueht forward, that in case a conven-
tion bill should be brought into parliament,
tome resolutions might oe entered into, re-
specting it.
And that was done, was itP — ^Yes.
Did Mr. Caliender make anv motion upon
that business?— I Uiink he did, but I cannot
aajr unless you will permit me to look at the
minutes [looks over the minutes]. It is impos-
aible that I should remember, what is here
mentioned, because it is not in my hand*
writing, I was not present at the time.
^ Do you recollect any thing about a rao-
Ikm for appointing a secret committee? —
I recollect such a circunwtance had taken
place, when I was out; and when I came in,
as soon as I had taken my seat^ a motion was
VOL. XXUI.
made by Mr. Sinclair,* that a motion that
had now passed should be bunit. I got up
and opoosed it. I said that our proceedings
were all free and open ; and I was told that
the resolutions had already passed. All that
was meant was, that some place should be
appointed for us to convene in, in case we
snonld be stopped by any compulsive mctt*
sures.
Was there any particulaf name ^iven to
this meeting ? — It was a committee of secrecy*
But the meeting that was to take place,
was called ^Yes, a copvention of emer*
gency.
Did you hear or understand, why it was
proposed, that this resolution should be burnt?
— I never learned it any farther than this,
that when Mr. Sinclair proposed its bong
burnt, it was resolved that the motion^
instead of being burnt, should be reported
andpublished.
[The witness read from the minutes the
resolution that Mr. Sinclair moved, shoald
be burnt.]
Look at the |>age befbre that? — That is
not my hand-writing ; I was not present, nor
I do not think it is Mr. Ross's hand-writing.
Mr. Solicitor General — ^Here it is said the
members stood upon their feet, and solemnly,
and unanimously, passed the resolution as
follows, and then comes a blank of a page.
Mr. Burnett, — Do you remember any mo->
tions being made by Skirving in the oonven*
tion ? — Yes, many; but I have so bad a me-
mory, that, unless there is something parti-
cular passed, I think no more about it. [Reads
from the minutes.] ** Citizen Skirving mov-
ed, that all the members, both of the conven-
tion, and4>f the primary societies, should sub*
scribe a solemn league and covenant'' But
I remember very well, that Skirving was
never called upon to explain what he meant
by it. [Reads.] " Citizen Skirving moved,
that the convention express its ardent desire,
to cultivate a more close union with the so-
cieties in England, which was likewise una-
nimously agreed to."
Is that ^our hand-writing? — ^Yes.
[The witness read, several motions, made
by the panel, in the British convention,
from the minutes.]
Lord Advocate. — Were you there the night
on which Skirving and others were taken up?
—Yes, I was there, when the lord provost
paid us a visit.
Do you recollect any resolution that was
come to by the convention, that if vou shbuld
be dispersed, thtt should be one of the cases
in which the conventwn of emergency werer
to meet? — I heard such a resolution.
Were you present in the convention, when
you heard it? — I cannot say ; I rather think
not, but I think I heard it.
Do you know of any other cases in which
they were to meet?— I have heard that one
' See his cftse in this volume; infrd.
S M
591] 34 GEORGE UL ProceetUngt agaiiut WiUimn ^ndng
[5S2
was, in cas&the island should be invaded by
a foreign enemy ; another was in tlie case of
a convention biiJ.
. Did you ever hear that the suspension of
the habeas corpus act was one of the cases ? —
No;
Was the convention ever, to your know-
ledge, divided into sections or classes ? — ^We
were divided into divisions first, and then
elates, and afler that a section was thought
to be a better name than either of the others,
9.nd, for the last fourteen days, the word sec-
tion was used.
Was it common in the convention, to give
in motions in writing ?— Yes, that was an
early rule adopted, that ail motions should be
^ven in writing, and signed.
Look at that paper ? [showing the witness.
Mr. Callender's motion respecting universal'
suffrage] — ^The indorsement, at the back is
written by myself.
Look at that? [a motion by Mr. Margarotl
— ^I have seen that motion before, but I haa
no hand in it.
Look at that? [a motion made by David
Downie,* for regularity and order] — I think I
recollect having seen that before, but it has
not my hand to it.
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirving,
Did the convention appoint any name in
preference to another? — No.
Were any minutes acknowledged bv the
convention, till a committee had revised them ?
—No.
Was there any appointmient of you by the
convention as deputy secretary ? — ^No.
Was this meetmg, which you say, was for a
convention of emergency, to take place upon
a motion to bring in such a bill, or upon such
a bill being passed ? — I cannot be certain, but
I understood it to be when the bill had passed.
Did not you understand that it was a con-
fidential committee, to be mimed with a view
to have a place in readiness, that whenever
the thing was mentioned in parliament, the
delegates would know where to meet, in order
to draw up a petition a^inst it? — ^Yes.
. Did not the convention frequently alter on
one day, what they had done the day before ?
— Yes, many things that I have written in
these scrolls, were dashed out by order of the
convention, and others were left as they were,
till the committee should revise them.
Had the convention finished their regula-
^ons and appointed them, or were they only
consulting about them, when it was broken
up ? — Tikey were only consulting about them,
they had not finished by any means.
There is a motion which is said to be in
my name ; did you understand that I could
have any other motive than that of regularity
and good order? — The expression surprised
me, and I took but little notice of it
Did you ever suppose I had any thing like
♦ See his case iu this Volume, infrd.
a seditious intention in any thing thai I did ?
— So far from it, that I have heard you say,
}'ou were sure the only way to support the pre-
sent form of government, by king, lords, and
coramoasy would be to obtainti timely reform.
Do you remember when the motion of the
duke of llichrapnd's plan of universal suffrage
was acquiesced iUfl agreed to it, because that
nothing less coula overturn the corruption ?—*
Certainly ; and we were sanctioned in that
opinion, by what the duke and Mr. Pitt had
published, a dozen years ago*
Mr. Burnett, Do you read the gazetteer?-^
Yes, but for several weeks pas^ I have re-
ceived them and not read a single line.
Did you read the proceedings of the con-
vention ? — No, I did not ; as tney contained
nothing new^ I thought I would look at them
at any time.
Do vou remember receiving at any time,,
from tne panel, an address from Dundee ? — ^I
remember I saw that naper at a meeting of
the Edinburgh monthly committee; it was
handed to me bv one of that committee as a
curiosity; I diet not receive it at that time
from Mr. Skirving; I advised against its being
read in our meeting, as there was something
in it which, I supposed, might be construea
seditious.
Mr. Skirving, Does it consist with your
knowledge that the convention had any con-
cern with the paper, called the gazetteer ?— -
As individuals we all wished it weU as a paper,,
tending to the spreading of universal liberty^
but not as a convention.
George Ros$ sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Burnett.
What profession are you of? — A clerk in
the Gazetteer-office.
Do you remember a hand-bill that was
published in October last ? — ^Yes.
Do you know who composed that hand-
bill ? — Yes, me and my brother; it was laid
before the general committee ofihe Friends of
the People, who ordered it to be printed.
Was Mr. Skirving present at that meeting j
— ^lic was ; it was atlerwards published in the
Gazetteer. Mr. Skirving renised to put his
name to that, or any other which was not pro^*
duccd by himself.
His name was afterwards annexed to it f —
Yes ; and there were some thousands of them
published.
Did the convention meet in consequence of
that ? — No. There were several meetings of
that sort
Did you attend the meeting of the 29th
October ? — Yes, and Mr. Skirving was there ;
he was secretary to the convention of the
delegates of the Friends of the People, but
not secretary to the British convention ; there
was a scroll of minutes of their proceedings.
Were any of their debates taken in short-
hand ? — ^Yes.
Did you assist in taking them down?— No.
Was there a particular place assigned in the
5SS]
Jhir SediiiaH.
A. D. 179*.
[53t
£ODveiifi<»i for die seeretair and sbort-haiM)-
fnan ? — ^There was no place for the short-hand-
man at all.
Were they published as minutes of the pro-
ceedings of the convention? — No. Theywere
published as news.
Do you remember a motion for a secret .
committee? — I remember there was a motion
about a committee for appointing the place of
meeting of the convention, but I do not know
how it came by the name of secret com-
mittee ; I never knew the convention call it
t>y that name.
Was the panel a member of that eom-
mittee? — ^I cannot say.
Was Mr. Margarot a member ? — ^I believe
Le was.
Was Mr. Browne? — ^I eannot say.
Do you know any thing of a convention of
emergency ? — ^Yes ; in case any bill was passed
to stop their meetings.
Was anjr other emergency mentioned? —
No. That is all that I recollect
"* Recollect yourself, if you ever heard of any
other case of emergency ? — ^The grievances of
the nation.
Was any thing mentioned about foreign
troops landing? — I never iieard of a Frepch
invasion; I heard of Hessian troops and
Ilanoverians-being brought into the kingdom ;
it Was reported out of doors, that in that case
the convention were to meet.
But you are sure you never heard-of French
troops landing ? — ^I am sure of that.
Air. Solicitor General, Did you write any
of these minutes ?— Yes, I did.
Look at that, and tell us what these words
allude to : ** the members stood upon their
feet, and solemnly, and unanimously passed
Jthe resolution ^is follows ?''— I do not know
what it alludes to.
Was it the common practice to pass resolu-
tions in that solemn manner ? — I do not know
any thing of it, I do not recollect what it was,
but I suppose it was a resolution respecting
the Irish convention bill.
What follows is a blank; can you explain
that? — ^Noy I cannot; I suppose it is mis-
placed.
Lord Advocate. Does it consist with your
knowledge that this convention was divided
into sections ? — Yes ; I called them sections
myself; I was a member of a section which
met in an empty house in the Gazetteer-office
stair, opposite to one MuUo's; it was our
business to choose a preses, and if any motion
was made the preceding evening, we made it
our business to discuss it, and make oiu'selves
acquainted with it.
Did your secretary ever make a report to
the convention ?— Yes. [points it out in the
minutes, and reads it. J
Did you ever admit any strangers in the
convention to hear your proceedings ?— -Yes.
Was there any particular mark of honour,
or attention paid to them?— No: no par-
ticular mark of honour, except a seat next the
door. Did you ever form yourselves into a
committee to take in a member ? — ^We have
formed ourselves into a committee to read a
newspaper, containing Mr. Pitt and the auke
of Uichmond's resolutions.
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirving.
This report which has just now been read,
you say was written by you. Was it wholly
done of yourself, or was it directed by the
meeting?- No; it was entirely of myself;
the convention had no concern in it.
Was the committee on the convention bill
to meet for any other purpose than to draw up
a remonstrance against it ^ — I never heard of
any other. .
And was not this the reason for declaring
the time of the meeting of the convention to
be at the time of the motion for a convention
bill, for the purpose of getting the remon-
strance into parliament in time ? — No doubt
of it.
Mr. Solicitor General. — Did vou ever hear
in the convention, a proposal ror a resolution
to be burnt ? — I do not recollect any , sucb
thing.
Did not citizen Sinclair make such a mo J
tion ? — Not that I know of.
[Giving him a paper.] Is that one of the
Edinburgh Gazetteers?—! believe it is; it
looks like it.
Was it your intention to give the world an
aocurate account of these proceedings? — It
was; as nigh as we could make it.
Mr. Skirving. Did the convention order the
publication of them in the Gazetteer? — No.
Or had any concern whatever with them ?—
No.
Lord Advocate. — Was it known to the con-
vention that your brother attended, and took
notes for publication f — I dare say it was to
■ msmy of them ; he was a delegate himself.
Is the panel a subscriber to the Gazetteer?
—Yes.
Was he frequently in the Gazetteer office ?
— Yes ; but not so often during the sitting of
the convention as before.
Do you know his hand- writing ? — I cannot
say that I do. ^
Look at the minutes, and see if you there
see any thing like his hand wriUng ? — ^I can-
not say.
Look at the two last paj^esy and see if it is
your brother's writing? — ^No; it is not.
Do you believe it to be Aitcheson's ?— I be-
lieve part of it is.
Do you believe this to be Skirving's hand-
writing?— I have seen much of his writing.
Is that like it ?<^I cannot say.
David Downie swum. — Examined by Mr.
Burnett,
Were you a member of one of the societies
of the Friends of the People ? — Yes ; I was a
member of the British convention, and I un-
derstood Mr. Skirving to be the secretary.
Look at that paper, and see if it was a mo-
093] S4 GEORGE IIL Proceedings Qgaind William Skkwng [5S6
tion Uiat was made by you in the conven-
tion?— ^Yes, it is. fReadsit.]
Look at that, and see if it is a motion of
your's. — It is. [Reads it]
Mr. Skirving, — Did the (convention pass
cither the one or the other of the motions you
have now read ? — ^To the best of my know-
ledge they did not
Jamet Jlobertton * sworn, and examined by
Mr. Burnett,
Look at that printed letter, and teil me, if
you know where it was printed ? — I piinted
exactly sueh a letter as this.
Was it by Mr. Skirvtng's authority that you
did it? — Yes, it was.
Is that his hand-writing ?-<-I cannot say.
I am a very bad judge of any iiand- writing.
Did you ever employ him to keep your
books? — He has directed newspapers, and
assisted me ; but I say now, as I did to the
sheriff; I cannot positively swear that it is
his hand-writing, but it is something like it.
[Showing him another paper.] — Is that his
band-writing? Upon the oath I have taken,
I do not know; I do not think it is.
William Lind sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Bumeit,
You are apprentice to Mr. Robertson, the
printer ? — Yes.
Look at this, and see if it consists with
your knowledge that that came out of Mr.
Robertson's office? ...Yes; it was printed
there.
Do you know by whose order ? — ^No.
Should you know Mr. Skirving's hand-
writing, if you should see it?— No.
Did he never write about your master's of-
fice?— I believe he has, but I cannot swear
to his writing. I have seen a great many
people's hand like Mr. Skirving's.
Is that like his hand-writing? [Showing
him a naper.] — It resembles it.
Is that like it? [Showing him another.] —
It resembles it.
Cross-examined by Mr. Skirving.
Did you ever see me write ? — Yes ; I have
seen you write twb^or three passages, or pa-
ragraphs, when the'paper was going on.
And upon the recollection you have of what
I then wrote, you think that is my writing ? —
It resembles it very much.
[A letter read — no address-^signed Wm.
Skirving.]
Ijfrd Justice Clerk, to Mr. Robertson. —
Do you know what number of copies were
thrown off of that letter ?— There were four or
jive dozen ; I cannot say exactly.
[This panel's declaration of 6th of Decem-
ber read,]
Lord Justice Clerk. — Have you any excul-
patory evidence to adduce, Mr, Skirvinjg?-—
'I he day is already so far spent, my 5rd;
■■ ■ — ' ■ ■■..I
♦ »e^ his case, p, J9, of this Volumfc
and it appears to me bo wmecesaary to bring
forward any exculpatory evidence, the public
prosecutor having proved nothing criminal
against me, that I shall entirely decline it,
especially that even the witnesses for the
Crown faiave exculpated me from every suspir
cion of seditious intention.
Lord Advocate/^ [Rt hon. Robert Dundas,
afWwards lord chief baron of the Exche-
Quer.] — Gentlemen of the jury ; William
akirvin^, the panel at the bar, stands charged
in this mdictment with the crime of sedition;
a crime which has been known and recoenised
by the common law of Scotland, and by the
common law of every civiUzed government
upon earth, from the earliest records to the
latest peiiod; which, when stated, carries
alone with it, to every person who hears it
statra, as precise and distinct an idea as the
crime of murder, of robbery, of theft, or any
of the greater or lesser offences, which arf
the subjects of criminal law, and the objects
of courts of criminal justice to punish.
The minor proposition of the indictment
sets forth, fully and distinctly, the variona
facts and circumstances imputed against thia
man, and from which the legal conclusion
is inferred, that he has committed the offence
stated in the major proposition. To that
charge he has this day, in your presence^
pleadi^ not guilty : he has told us, indeed^
within these very few minutes, that it would
be idle and impossible indeed, for him to
avail himself of that right, which the law of
this country gives to every criminal, of excul-
pating, or even alleviating the crime cliarged,
ny any evidence he thinks proper; berause
he has* had the confidence to state to you,
that he does not think, nor does he see any
thing, that has yet been proved against him,
or any thing to be the subject of a proof in ex-
culpation. Upon that point he and I are at
issue; upon that point you arc this night to
return your verdict ; and to speak, not with
too much presumption, not with too modi
confidence, I cannot but express my belief
that this verdict will teach this man, and
others his associates, that his conduct has
been highly criminal, not innocent, as he idlj
{>retends, and foolishly imagines you will be-
ieve ; and that it is gross ufectation in hint
to pretend that he is entitled, in your impar<'>
tial judgment, to a verdict of not guilty, or to
a verdict of acquittal, in respect that 1 have
not proved my case to you. I must, for one,
till taught otherwise by your verdict, against
which it is impossible, either for the panel or
me, to lifi up our voice with any effect in this
country; I must consider it in a very dif«>
* In the original printed account of this
trial, the speech of the lord advocate wat
grossly, and, I believe, intentionallv, misre-
E resented. That learned person, howeveF,
as obligingly communicated to me a cor-
rected report of his ai^Kuroent, which I have,
in the Unt, substituted for the other.
asr\
JbrSedUhm.
A. D. 17M.
[538
fertat point of view indeed. I sball, in the
MQue]^ take the liberty of steliDg to ^ou —
and of demanding from you, a yerdict in fiei-
vour of the prosecution. — ^I shall state to you,
that that verdict will be founded upon a body
of direct parole, and written evidence, so sa-
tb&ctory and conclusive, that, if your minds
are not yet made up upon the subiect, I trust,
ere I sit down, to satisfy you, by selectins
^m that enormous mass of seditiouB, I had
almost said treasonable matter, upon the
table before you, that you cannot have a
doubt upon your minds of returning a verdict
in my fiivour.
I nope to be credited, gentlemen, when I
etate to vou, upon my own behalf, that al-
though this person, who in the end of July
iast was taken up for his accession to that
paper, which constitutes the first article of
the cb»m against him ; and, although it was
judiciously and proj)erly directed, that he
ahould not be exammed as a witness against
Palmer, who has already suffered a verdict of
fais country against him, as the person more
directly concerned in the composition of that
paper;*- 1 say, that I hope to be credited
when I tell you, that, if this man's conduct
had been of a different complexion since the
ISth of September last, the date of Palmer's
conviction, althoueh it was competent for me,
at the meeting of this winter sessions, im*
mediately to nave brought my indictment
against him, upon that fact alone, I trust
vou will believe me when I say, that if that
bad been the only criminal matter against
him, I shoukl not have found it expedient,
proper, or necessary, to have preferred any
charge against him on that account. I had
erroneously imagined, that after the recent
trials of Muir and Palmer, one in this city, the
Other at Perth, and the distinct and clear opi-
nion two different juries, in different parts of
Scotland, had f^iven of the criminality of those
seditious practices, in which these men, and
this panel now at your bar, had so deeply and
obstinately eneaged; after the severe, but
adequate punishment these two persons had
been subjected to, the benefit of example
would not have been thrown away ; and that
be and others, if not utterlv reclaimed by
these salutary warnings, would at least have
adopted, from prudential motives, a more
peaceable demeanor, and concluded their pro^
ceedines with more caution, and rceard to
the puolic quiet and public opinion, tie has
complained of me to-night, that I did not im-
mediately bring htm to trial in August last,
for his accession to the offence of which Pal-
mer has been convicted. I have now told
bim my reasons. Had he benefited bv the
salutary warning given him, I never snould
have troubled you or him on his past conduct,
or thought it worth while to pay to it any
more attention. But when, as I shall soon
satisfy you, the cmiduct Df this man has,
ainee that period, only become tnore vk>lent,
darings and dsBgerons, I trwt yea will think
with me, ^t a dure and melancholy necessity
indeed has been imposed on me of bringing
him to trial for his sul^equent proceedings,
and that it was indispensable in roe so to (&;
that he may either receive at your hands that
acquittal, which he so confidently assumes as
certain, or, if guilty, that punishment which
his pertinacity in sedition, if I may so express
myself, most undoubtedly merits.
Amone other irrelevant and foolish remarks
the panel to-day complained also, of Apreju-
diety as he termed it, undsr which the two
former juries, and I presume, eentlemen, you
hkewise, entertained and feU against him
and his associates ; a prejudice in favour of
the existing order of thmgs, and of those evils
which he and they avowed as their objects
to have removed. In other words, that you
are prejudiced in favour of the British consti-
tution, as by law established, and are there-
fore not competent or unbiassed jurymen, to
try such a case as Uiat now under considers^
tion. Upon my word, if you are not compe-
tent to sit as jurymen, I know not who are,
or where they are to be found. Are we to
take a jury to try Skirving from the lists on
tho table of the Briti^ convention? Is the
sheriff, in returning his roll of 45 names on
the assize, to inquire previously'who are at-
tached to the constitution, and who revile and
conspire aeainst it I to return only those of
the tatter description, and to exclude all the
former ? Are traitors only to sit as jurymen
on trials for high treason ? Long, I trust and
believe, will this prejudice, of which the panel
complains, subsist, in full force and vigour,
through all ranks and orders of men in this
free and prosperous country, notwithstanding
the aealous artifices of him and others to unr
dermine and destroy it; which, so far from
having^ the effects intended, have only rivetted
their attachment to it more doselv, and added
force to that national spirit, which would lead
us all to defend that admirable form of go-
vernment our ancestors purchased by their
blood, and transmit it entire to our posterity ;
as safe against the republican and democratic
doctrines, no^v so boldly preached up and
acted on, as against the attacks of despotism,
or the inroads of arbitrary power.
Gentlemen, the facts and circumstances
stated in the minor proposition, though
branched out into a variety of different arti-
cles, appear to me properly to be compre-
hended under two general heads. — His acces-
sion to the guilt of Palmer, in circulating (not
composing) that hand bill, which is there
stated ; and, in the second place, his endea-
vouring from the 4th of October, 1793, when
this hand ImU was publ'ished, down to the
19th of December last, when he made that
extraordinary appearaiKe at the cock- pit im
the Grass-market, — his endeavouring, I can-
not indeed use the word endeavouring, but hb
persisting, during that period, in a seditious
intent, manifested by his writings, and mani-
fesled by bis condiact And I will tell bin
t
53Sf] 34GEOKGB'IIL Proceedings ag<UHSt WUliam SUrving [540
more, if he is so ignorant of the law and con-
stitution of his country as one would think
from his declaration to night he must be,
that if that meeting at the cock-pit had been
followed by tumult or by insurrection, coupled
with his conduct at the convention for se-
veral nights befpre, he would have stood now
at this bar, charged with high treason ; and,
as such, would have sufierea, if convicted, a
capital punishment, under the statute of Ed-
ward 3d, because it could not be construed
into any thin^ else but levying war aeainst
the lung, under that statute; and, I wul tell
him more, that when these indictments were
preferred against him and others, who now
near me, and who must soon stand before n
jury of their country likewise, my learned
friend and I had great doubts whether it did
not warrant us in such a prosecution'; how-
ever, we have taken the more lenient, and, I
trust, the more proper line of conduct ; he,
and tiiev, stand chained with sedition ; but of
^e truth or falsehood of that charae, and the
sufficiency or insufficiency of evidence, it is
now my business to argue, as it will be here-
after yours to give your verdict.
Upon Palmer's paper, I shall oi&r but a
very few observations ; a respectable and an
impartial jurv, as all juries in this country
ere, and^ as sul juries must be, I care not for
those injurious aspersions which men, such as
these, presume to throw upon their conduct ;
and, as little do I care for those arts that have
been made use of to intimidate them in their
4]uty ; I say, this has already been stamped
hj a verdict of the country, as a seditious, in-
flammatory paper ; and the person who com-
posed it found guilty, as such : but, God for-
bid, that the opmion of any Court, that the
authority of any man, or set of men whatever,
should influence your minds one moment, or
prevent you from now taking that paper under
your own serious consideration, and judging
of its import and tendency, in a manner as free,
and as untrammeled, as if it was now for the
first time brought under public consideration.
I desire you to read that paper. I desire you to
consider with 3'ourselves if it is a paper, such
as Palmer professed it to be, merely for ob-
taining a reform in parliament; and which he
gloried in the circulation of,' if vou are of
that opinion, it is idle to inquire whether the
fact ot circulation is proved or not ; he is not
only not guilty, but nas done that for which
he IS cntitied to praise, and which does not
merit censure:— but you will peruse that
paper ; and, if it appears to you, as it does to
me, as it does to the Court, by their permit-
ting it to be considered as relevant, a most
seditious and inflammatory libel, — to tell us,
** The time is now come, when we are to as-
semble round the fabric of liberty to support
it ; that we are plunged into a war by a wicked
ministry, and a compliant parliament ;'' when
it is not Itie parliament alone, but the united
voice of the country has justified us in going
to defend ourselves in a war- with a neigh-
bouring nation ; if that should be ytnxr opi-
nion, it will be your business to inquire, how
far the evidence brings it home to tnis panel;
As to the libellous and seditious nature of th<i
paper itself, I should think I obscured, instead
of illustrated, if I did any thing but desire you
to look upon it. You cannot but agree with
me, that it is as seditious and intlammatonr a
paper as ever was circulated among the ioha*
oitants of this country.
Gentiemen, amon^ the papers produced, is
one of the records ot the court, a petition of
the panel ; he being taken up as guilty of an
imputed offence, and after having it in his
power to give bail for his appearance, he chose
obstinately (from some desire of reform I sup-
pose,) to refuse to give bail, and insisted on
bis immediate liberation ; and that the officer
of justice should be incarcerated in his staA ;
or, at least, insisted befere this court that it
should be served upon him. In that paper he
tells you, that *' the chief business of the
Friends of the People, as preparatory to the
reform in parliament which they sought, was
the information of the public as to the
grounds of parliamentary reform, its import*
ance, and immediate necessity. Your peti-
tioner, therefore, judged it to be his duty, as
secretary, to submit every information to the
public which he received, and thought cal-
culated to illustrate these points; and the
individuals and societies, who had it in their
power to give such informatioir, naturally
transmitted the same to him as secretary.'' —
. Why, here is an explicit and an avowed de-
claration upon his part, that the information
of the public, and the grounds of it were what
he was bound to lay before them ; and, if ^ou
consider that paper as such an information^
as you will permit with impunity to be ciicn*
lated through all parts of Scotland, I give up
the question at once ; you ought to return a
verdict in his favour. He also adds, '^ Your
petitioner ha& already suffered too much for
attempting to prevent the overthrow of the
constitution of nis country, by the over- weight
of any of the branohes against the other, to
be guilty of willingly assisting in any such,
design. He considered the paper complain-
ed on, as merely the strong cffiision of honest
hearts, alarmecl by the measures of those la
administration, judging the constitution in
the utmost danger, and catchin^at the first
grounds of alarm which presented themselves
to their view." — ^This confession of his own
is confirmed bj^*one of the declarations just
now read ; — it is confirmed by the testimony
of M orren, and of Kid, both or whom, though
with considerable reluctance, deponed to their
receiving such a copy of it from him ; and
that he was the person who appeared to have
the charge of it. Morren indeed distinctly
proves, tiiat he received the paper from Paf^
mer for publication, that he was desired to
give so many copies to Skirving, if he called
TOT it ; — ^that he went afterwards to Skirving's
house^-^that Skirving sent somebody for it,—
541]
Jbr SedUioM.
A. D. W9*.
[542
that he sent bim a hundred copies;— they
are found circulating through the town, and
when the repositories of Skirving himself
Drere searched, the hundred copies were all
expended to two or three, or something with-
in half-a-dozen ; you will consider if these
necessarily were not all that remained out of
the thousand copies which were thrown off;
and, which these gentlemen were to send
round to the puhhc, to enlighten them on the
important business of reform. You will con-
atder whether you have not distinct satisfac-
tory evidence, that as he received those pa-
pers, knowing the purport of, and glorying in
them, whether the fact of his havms circu-
lated them, is not clearly and distinctly prov-
ed (not being contradicted upon the part of
this man), bevond the possibility of denial.
Havine said so much upon this part of the
charge, I come to the most material, the most
important part of it, — I mean all those pro-
ceedings from the 4th of October 179S, down
to the ISth of December 1793, when the au-
thority of the civil magistrate was contemned
and despised ; when nothing but the vigilance
and exertion of the magistrates, to whom the
country owes much for that public spirit with
!vhich they conducted themselves, could have
dispersed this seditious, this illegal, and, I
haa almost said, this treasonable meeting.
But the hand-bill of the 4th of October, is
very candidly to-day owned by one of the
Bosses ; and I have no objection to give him
the credit of that elegant composition. I only
impute to the panel the criminality of having
lent his name, as secretary of this genersd
committee, to authorize its circulation into
the world ; and, as such, having become res-
ponsible for it. It appears from Ross's ac-
count of it, to have been wrote by both of
them jointly ; it was wrote the evening before
the meeting of the general committee, at
which Skirving is proved to have been pre-
sent ; and, though from a particular kind of
irailty of memory, which seemed to distin-
guish both those able brothers, the}] did not
I)recisely recollect every question which came
from one side of the table, though, when they
oame to be questioned from the other, that
recollection revived in the most extraordinary
and most amazing degree; although they
did not perfectly recollect what he said upon
the subject, they only recollected that he
would not put his name to any thing but his
own composition ; there is enough to show
jou that, if he would not as an individual,
yet he had no objection to do it in his official
capacity,— in which capacity he now stands
at your bar, as secretary to the convention
of the Friends of the People ; it is perfectly
clear that he never in the smallest degree
comphuned of that seditious hand-bill bein^
handed about with his name to it, by which
he ratified and approved of the proceeding.
He has not told you, nor dare he tell you that,
when this paper was sent into the world with
his name to it, he did^ as every honest dtisen
ought to do, revoke it, and publish to the
world who were the persons guilty of it; and
therefore you must hold him as a person
responsible to you, and responsible to the
country for this hand- bill,- circulated with his
subscription annexed to it, and under hia
authority, though the two Rosses are per^
fectly satisfied that they wrote this hand-bill,
and that Skirving did refuse in the meeting
to sign his name to it.
Gentlemen, is it possible to read the con-
cluding paragraph of this paper, coupled par-
ticularly with the preceding advertisement of
Palmei^s, in which he is proved to have so
distinguished a share ; is it possible to read
the concluding paragraph of that paper, hold-
ing out a menace to an association, numerous
beyond example, which took place last year,
and to which every good and worthy man in
the country, of all ranks and denominations
was found a subscriber ;— -can you read it with-
out discovering an insolent and audacious me-
nace to them tor tliat conduct? If these meui
as states the paper, do not retract firom that
association, on themselves and on their heads
be the consequences. And the society of the
Friends of the People will now be innocent of
these. And what was the purpose for which
so numerous a body as the Goldsmiths-hall in
this citv, and the London tavern, were last
December associated, which these Friends of
the People dared thus to threaten with punish-
ment and revenge? An association for the
protection of liberty and property.
It also contains another menace, equally
seditious, and equally illegal. It is true the
inhabitants of this country have a right to
petition parliament for redress of grievances,
but is this, or any man, or any set of men
whatever, entitled under this pretext, when
the country is at peace and in quiet, to send
such a hand-bill as this among the people,—
to sound the trumpet of alarm amone those
who are contented and happy, — to threaten
even those men who may, in the moment of
delusion, have been led to join in their pro-
ceedings, but who became satisfied, as ninety-
nine persons out of one hundred are satisfied,
thattneir proceedingsare not tending to reform,
but to subvert the constitution of this country.
I know well there are many well-meaning men,
who having been misled by false reasoning,
imposed upon by the glare of some man s
sophistry, or the cant of some man's enthu-
siasm, have now withdrawn themselves from
that society into which they had once been
deluded, and that conduct which they had
once been betrayed to follow. And how are
such men, as choose to assert their freedom
pf withdrawing, equally as they did, in join-
ing this society, to be treated, if they so ven-
ture ? Mr. Skirving tells you in tliis advertise-
ment, that those members who do not attend,
or send an excuse, will be publicly called
upon ; and this is a paper of which thous&nds
were thrown off, as Ross tells you; those men
therefore, who choose to retract ox alter their
545] 84 GBOKGB III. Proceedings ftgnnd WOliam Skirtdng [544
opi&iotiSy who choose to come back aDd join
^e majority of the countrv, to be faithful and
loTal to their kinor, and attached to their con-
stitution, had this menace hcid oirt to them
that they would be publicly called upon, in
as public a way as this paper is circulated, to
account for their conduct ; intimidating them
firom following the dictates of their consci-
ences, and exciting them to join in forming
an arbitrary government, worse than that des-
potism, of which a neighbouring countr;^' af-
fords an example ; domineering over the minds
and bodies of their countrymen, and owning
no auUiority, but that which they mark with
atrocious acts of injustice and cruelty.
Gentlemen, let us now come to the mate-
rial point of the case ; let us consider the
proceedings of the British convention of the
delegates of the people, associated to obtain
universal suffrage and annual parliaments;
a convention which, in its name and in its
object, though the meeting was originally,
and has for some time past, gone unoer the
name of the Friends of the People, and only
holding out, as their end, the obtaining a
reform in parliament^ has now, with an au-
dacity which has excited, not the attention of
this metropolis, not the attention of Scotland
alone, not the notice of England only, but
of Ireland and, I believe, of^the whole em*
pire at large ; which has attracted the atten-
tion even of France itself, and been there
the object of admiration; — a meeting which,
in its avowed object, tends not to rerorm, as
they pretended, but to subvert the constitu-
tion. Let these men argue as they please,
let them declaim till they are sick, universal
sufirage is a thing which the constitution
of this country never did recognize, for the
liest of all possible reasons, because it is im-
practicable; and if ever attempted to be
carried into execution, as it was well ob-
served, by my eloquent friend to day, would
tend just to the precise same effects and per-
nicious consequences, which we have seen,
to the astonisnment of the present day, in a
neighbouring country.
Gentlemen, two things are to be materially
weighed and considered by you upon this
indictment.
In the first place, if the proceedings of
that meetine, of which this man was a
member, and not only a member, and an
office-bearer in it, but, as I shall afterwards
prove to you, in evidence, the ringleader,
and chief instrument in calling it together,
the first thing you must consider, with deli-
beration ana care, is, was it, or was it not
a seditious meeting? In this country you
have always possessed the right of detCN
mining the law^ as well as of the fact ; your
opinion must be made up upon the point. Is
this meeting seditious or not ? And, if you
deterniine it in the former case, then yon
will inquire into the sufficiency or insufB-
eiency of the evidence. It shall be my bu-
siness to efbdeavow to satisfy you, that you
have every evidence of the sediUous natoi^
of it that you can reasonably require, and
that the nature of the case admits; more'
indeed than, I believe, could have been ex^
pected from a meeting, such as this, which,
with all its avowed pretexts and pretensions^
I will point out to you in speveral parts of theif
conduct, their own firm conviction, that they
were acting a dangerous part ; and that the
conduct that they were following was not
such as the law of their eountry reco^ized^
It seems, from some parts of the evidence^
which I shall immediately notice, that they
could not even in these meetings stifle their
own consciences ; there was that silent mo*
nitor within which (with all that pretence of
reform, and that confidence which some have
expressed to dav, of the legality of their
proceedings), whispered to Uiem this, that
they were carrying on a kind of conduct
which, if discovered, they must suflfer for,
and proves their own conviction of and sense
of the seditious nature of their proceedings.
In a country such as this, — not indeed in any
country possessing an established svstem of
government, and much less, in such a coun*
try as this, where the opinions of the people
are made up upon the wisdom of that eo<
vernment, and are attached to it by Sie
surest of all ties^ — if the magistrates are
active in the execution of their duty, it is
not to be expected tiiat any such meeting a»
this would directly avow an attempt to sub-^
vert the government, or constitution of this
country ; you may rest assured you will al*
ways find some pretext or other held forth
to cloak their proceedings, till the moment
shall come when they shall think it safe to
avow them. Had we at present been trving
the conduct of this man, oy any thing which
passed in the four first days of this conven-
tion, before tbey assumed that name which
they have taken to themselves, and before
they came to those resolutions, which I shall
in the sequel read from the minutes, we
should have had such a case before us that
you would have had to decide whether they
were really and truly meeting for the purpose
of a reform, or whether they were acting
under a mask for the purpose of destroying
the government of the country. But nx>m
the date of the assumption of this name,
and during the subsequent week, or ten davs^
these gentlemen have done away even toe
shadow of a mask over their proceedings ;'
in every mode of their proceeding, every re^
solution which they adopt is framed directly
and positively upon the model of the French
convention; and I desire you to take this
along with you, when you consider this sub*
ject, that although this meeting was illegal
in every part of it, yet the main point of my
charge against them is this, that beino; a con-
vention formed upon the model of tnat notr
at this moment existing in France, and a
nation with which we are at war : tne panel
^ho was their seer etaiy^ and all those irl»»
MS\
JbrSedUkm.
A. IX I7M.
[540
•ngM^Bd m it, have proved, if not ioiidem
«rrUf, most dearly and unequivocally by
ev€fy ciroumstance of their oonduct, that
their sole purpose and intention was, not a
reform, but a aubversion of parliament,— not
a redress or cure of grievances^ imaginary or
rsaVin^Icg^ pea^able, aod constiUitKinal
na^, but a determined and systematic plan '
and resolution* to subvert the limited mo-
narchy and free constitution of Britain,
and substitute in its place, by intimidation,
loiee, and violence, a republic or a demo-
dacy, as wild, as cruel, as despotic, and as
abominable as that which at tlus moment
desolates France.
They make the use of the term citizen. A
amile I observe to drop from the panel at the
iMtf, and from hb friends^ who, I understand,
are now sitting round him, and some of
whom, I am ucaid, must soon stand in his
place, as if the assumption of the word citi-
aen was of no importance^ and as a very
high, and a very distinguished member <m
this societv, the deputy secretary, declared,
that as a Durgess of Edinbuigh, he should
blush for himself, if he did not think the
name of citizen a good one. The worthy
secretaiy, Mr. Aitcheson, is no doubt right;
we are all, I should hope and wbh, good
citizens of Great Britain : but then, gentle-
men of the jiuy, vou must take into vour
consideration, in what sense the term is here
used; and for this purpose you must recoi-
led, that it is used m a convention, I main-
tun, professins purposes directly subversive
of our establisaed constitution, and utteriy
incompatible with and hostile to its exist-
ence. The term then ceases to be innocent,
as when taken per $e^ and becomes a circum-
stance of incontrovertible evidence to prove
the real objects and purposes of this assem-
bly. Its use is one Fwk on the chain of evi-
dence, to show that sedition, if not treason,
was the obiect. In that case it comes to be
material, like the case put by my learned
brother, that he who a few years ago, with a
white cockade in his hat, should have march-
ed to the Castle -hill of this city, and fired a
few shots at it, would have been treated as a
madman; but he who, in 1745, had been
guilty of the same thing, would have atoned
perhaps for his conduct with his life. The
term citizen, of itself is no crime ; but used
in this manner, it is a circumstance, in the
chain of evidence, to show that they are a
set of French conventionists. I give them
no other name ; aod that, as such, they are
oflfendine against the known criminal law of
this ana every other country upon earth;
and, as such, are seditious. You find they
have committees of finance, of instruc-
tion, of organization; in short there, is not
a single entry, not a single motion, not a
single step taken by them which is not pre-
cisely formed upon the model of the French
convention; they date their {>rQceedings in
the first year, not 9f liberty indeed, but of
VOL. XXIII.
th». Bif tish . convention^members are ad-*
mitted to the honours of the sitting, and, in
short, every thing exactly upon that model.
Gentlemen, I staled to you, that the evi-
dence in this case was not only credible, bu^
what is much better, it is vrntten evidence,
which cannot be mistaken, which mnst be
true, and upon which, in the course of your
duty, ^ou are to form your opinion. Gentle-
men, it was not till we had full information
of the extent to which tlieir proceedings
went; nor, indeed, till they themselves en-
tered in the Edinbiurgh Gazetteer, that which
Mr. Aitcheson told vou was a paper favour-
able to liberty and to reform, till they had
entered in that paper the proceedings of their
convention, that a warrant was issued for
their dispersion, and for the detention of
their papers. These papers have been iden-
tified m the most satisfactory manner, except
article twenty-four, and it is your duty to
take them into your consideration.
Gentiemen, I shall now entreat your par-
ticular attention io the evidence arising out
of these minutes of their proceedings, wnich
put, I think, the, seditious nature of them
beyond all doiibt; and I shall confine myself
to that particidar motion which was made
by Mr. CaUeoder ; I beg his pardon, I mean
citizen Callender, for so the motion stands,
which I shall quote firom the minutes ; and I
shall beg leave to take some littie time in
commenting upon them ; and I trust I shall
not unnecessarily trespass upon your pa-
tience, if I follow the minutes from the first
appearance of this motion, respecting the
Convention Bill, till by the sudden and un-
ex|)ected arrival of the magistracy on the
5th of December, an end was put to all the
proceedings upon the subject.
Gentiemen, upon the sixth day's sitting (I
read exactly the words of the motion), bemg^
the d5th of November, and citizen Urquhart
being in the chair, citiaea Callender moved,
** That in case the minister should bring into
the Commons House a motion for a oonven*
tion .bill, such as was passed in Iielaod, il
should be noticed immediately to the dele-
gAles.*' — By the form of their proceedings it
should seem, — for those gentiemen conducted
themselves with amazing regularity, — ^that
this motion was not taken up at the same
sitting that it was made, and we see no mora
of it till the 97th, when we have the follow-
ing account of what passed i^pon the suli»)ect^
Mr. Modmaker in the ehair.
^ Mr. Callender's motion being then taken
into consideration, amendments- were pro-
posed by citiaens Downie, Sinclair, Bremner,
and John Gartley" (he I understand is the
town drummer of Paisley) ^ ^ Mr. Marsarot
moved for adopting the spirit of Mr. Callen-
der*s motion, but thought it would be more
advantageous to postpone adopting it, till the
conclusion of the convention.'^ ** Afler some
conversation it was agreed upon the motion
of Mr. Calder, that the vote of the house
2 N
M7J S4 GEOROI III. Proceedings Mgttmsi Wittiam Skirnng [5C8
be put I8t, on the spirit of Mr. Offltftjdflrt
Motion ; Sndiy, on tbe words of the motion ^
3diy, on Mr. Margurotfs motion to aiqix^int a
eommittee. Tl|e sense of tbe Hoase being
taken of the Ist, it carried unanimously to
adopt the motion as to die spirit. On tiie
Sndy it carrwd by a great majority, not to
adopt the motion as worded. And ddiy»it was
resolved that said motion and all amendments
be referred as above.^
9th day's Silting—Next ds^y, the 88th No-
vember.— Mealmaker again in the chair.
^ The minutesbear, citizen Sinclair read the
amendment on citizen Callander's motion, as
agreed upon by the committee, and it was
agreed upon the motion of citizen ,
that the house should resolve itself into a
committee for its mature consideration. In
the course of the conversation, citizen Browne
gave a history of the Habeas Corpus act
Afler an excellent discussion of the question,
pertinent remarks, and amendments, the con-
vention was resumed, and the whole as
amended, being read over, the members stood
upon their feet, and solemnly and unani-
mously passed the resolution as follows."
Here eentlemen you would expect to find
this resolution inserted. But in place of it we
have a blank in the minutes of near two pages
clearly left for and intended for its insertion*
but for some reason or other, cautiously and
prudently omitted. Hitherto the minutes are
of the hand-writing of George Ross. Imme-
diately after the blank thus leA, they are of
the baud-writing of Mr. Aitcheson. The
kttter admitted to-day on his oath, that he
did not this evening" eome into the convention
till late, and that ne superseded Ross as se-
cretary, who was previously acting as such.
He admitted also tnat when he came in, he
found the convention debating on a proposal
of Sinclair's, that a resolution of one kind or
other should be committed to tbe flames.
That he joined in resisting this proposal, for
the reasons he gave, and he concluded by at-
tempting to persuade us that this resolution
was, and could be none other, than the mo-
tion and resolution for the appointment of a
secret committee proposed by Mar^pot^ afler
Aitcheson entered the room, and furly m his
hand- writing entered in its proper place fewer
down, towaras the end of this night's meet-
ing. Whether Mr. Aitcheson was oo^y mis-
taken, or whether he was wilfully disguising
the truth, is of httle consequence. But that
'he is so, is obvious from the minutes tbeqi-
selves, and indeed from the very nature of the
thing. For immediately after the blank
pages, which Ross, with so much reluctance
and difficulty Was at last forced to admit, was
left by him for the purpose of receiving Cal-
lender's original, and Smclair's amended mo-
tion and resolution — ^The minutes in Aitch»*
son's hand-Writing proceed as follows : ** Ci-
tizen Gerrald in an energetic and animated
addr^ssy eipresaed his happiness at the mo-
tion passed, and tesposed ih* aok «f the
Irish parltainenty called a eonvention bUI ;
and citissn Browne followed him in a nmAy
speech, and proved the inAaeace of the
executive government over lite paiiiuBont.
Citisen Margarot read and proposed the ^-
lowing motion, vis. that a secret committee
of tiiese and Uie secretary be appointed to de-
termine the place where snchoonvestion'Oi'
emergency shall meet. That such place shall
remam a secret with them, and with 1^ se-
cretary of this convention^ and that eacb^de-
legate shall, at the breakms up of Ais pp^
sent session, be entrusted wiu a sealed letter^
containing the name of the place of meeting.'
This letter shall be delivered unopened to his
oonstituents, the receipt of which shall be ac-
knowledged by a letter to the secretary, pre-
served in the same state, until the period
shall arrive at which it shall be deemed
necessary for the delegates to set off. Thia
motion was seconded by citixen Moflbt, and
the same was passed unanimously. The
folk>wing citiaens were then nominated a
secret comrmittee : Margaret Clark, Browne,
and the secretary.*^
Now, gentlemen, I hold it to be demon*
strated by these minutes, that there were
two motions and resolutions passed this even-
ing. The one on Callender^s motion and Sin*
dair*s, before Aitcheson came in, and which
was the resolution for the meeting of a een^
vention of emergency, which Sinclair dread-
ing its consequences, and after all his eare
to amend, felt to be dangerous and cri-
minal, and insisted on having it ianne-
diately burnt: and the other resohrtion
for the appointment of the secret commit-
tee moved by Margarot, and distiactiydea-
cribed as tbe marhmeiy by which the an-
tecedent seditious and treasonable resolutions
was at the proper moment lo be carried into
execution. And although the words of that
resolution (probably burnt by Sinclair) do not
anpear, yet (;an any man doubt of its treasoo-
aole purport. The minutes of the former
evenings prove tbst if parliament in its wis*
dom, sbonld think fit to pass a convention
biU, or suspend the Habeas Corpus act, these
men were then to move in direct resistanoe
to such a measure ; 4md solemnly resolve on
and frame atreasonable ^stem to oanj that
intent into execution. The negative evidenoe
arising from the two blank pages, as explained
by Ross and Aitcheson, goes deeply to every
man's mind to prove that this was the nature
of that resolution : and it is clear to demea-
stration that this blank, which precedes the
speeches of Oeirald and Margarot, was left aa
Rest was forced to allow, for the subseauoit
insertion of this resolution on SincJaii'a
motion, and not as Aitcheson either erro^
neously or fidsely swor^ fer the inserticHi
of that founded on Margarot's motion far
a secret committee, which appears fttither
down in its proper place, and is flili|y and
fairly inverted od hngm.
atsi
fit f9(wlifigifi
A. D. 17M.
[550
GeBriflm^ I Ibdow aot wheilitr, in the
licaft of argyakenty I nm make mjstlf under-
^tiMMd^ Vut I am aatiflned of thisy that you
mast concur with iiie» not only that both the
Boaoea, but Aitcheaondid this evening conceal
the tnilh, to give their conduct no worse an
appellation. I think these minutes prove, by
incontroTertible written evidence, that what
Ihcy i^ is not the fact ; that something dii I
pass^ for which this opening was left :-^to
wit» the i4[»pointment of a convention of
emargsncy, which Margarot, by that subse-
quent motion of his, clearly and distinctly
points out, had passed before : for, if you find
a^y thing of it before in these minutes, my
aigument is good for nothing; — ^but circum-
atanoes do sometimes happen to come out in
evidence which the most artful cannot foce-
aee, and which the most wicked cannot guard
ngsonst; and, I say, this speech of Margarot*s
is as decided and as fortunate acircumslance^
to show that this blank is meant to be filled
«9 with that motion for appointing this con-
vention of emeigen<^, as u you had seen the
motion before you. Mr. Aitcheson tells
50U, that he came to the meeting at
nbout half past 10, and was informed
that there had been a motion respecting
« secret committee, and that citizen Sinclair
aaid it should be burnt; that Aitcheson ex-
claimed against it, and said, that their pro-
ceedings ought to be fair and open, and the
motion was not burnt. But mark this also,
that everv part of the minutes, previous to
the blank, IS admitted to be in the handr
writing of Ross ; every thing aAer the blank,
is admitted to be in the hand-writine of Ait-
cheson;— ^it is therefore perfectly clear from
Aitcheson's account, that this secret resolution
which he swears was come to by the conven-
tion, before he entered the room, and which
they told him he was too late in giving his
vote against, could not be that secret com-
mittee which was moved for aAer he came
into the room, but must have been the mo*
tion of citisen Callender, which citizen Sin-
clair wished to be kept secret, and was afraid
should see the light*
I hope and trust you follow me in the ar-
gument, because I think what I am now stat-
ing b indisputable evidence, that this motion
'for a convention of emergency was what
was meant to be put into this blank. It was
Sinclair's motion, to which Margaret after-
wards alludes, previous to the appointment
of the secret committee, which appears in the
minutes, in the hand-writing of Aitcheson,
but leaving the previous blank for the inser-
tion of Sinclair's motion. But if you will now
attend to the copies of the Grazetteer proved
and authenticated in the course of this day's
trial, this matter seems to be put out of all
doubt. That this most notorious newspaper
was the gaaette of this convention, and con-
tainod so far as it goes, an accurate and foith-
ful account of its proceedings^ is ascertained
iMgrond dispute. We have, m the first pkce.
the authority of the paper itself, and of Scoti^
its pnblisher, who in the paper of the 90th
November, the first publianed after the meetp-
ing, asserts, *^ that it contains an accurate
account of the proceedings of the British con«
vttition down to Mondav.'' We have like-
wise the evidence of the two brothers-^
George and William Ross, the assistant se-
cretaries, who this day were obliged to admit,
thoi^h with extreme reluctance and difficulty,
that the Gazetteer contained at least the sub-
stance of their proceedings. One of these
two is also a short-hand writer, and was
chosen assistant secretary for the express
purpose of being thereby enabled to publish
their proceedings in this newspaper. I think
therefore, gqntlemen, I may be allowed to as-
sume that the Gazetteer, though it may not
state every thing done in the eonvention, at
least, that so far as it goes, it does, as the
publisher, citizen Scott, admits, contain an
aecurate account. Now let us examine mora
particularly the account in this convention
eazette ; and see whether it does not, by irre-
nagable evidence, confirm all I have now
submitted to your judgment.
The Gazetteer of the Sd Decembei\ which
by-the-bv introduces the notice of Callender's
motion, by minuting the '^ Report of the Go*
Metteer Committee^" states that on the Tuesdav
evening, a long debate ensued thereon, which
continued the whole evening. To the import
of that debate, and to the violent harangue of
Mr. Margarot, you, gentlemen, will, prooably,
bestow some attention. This panel was pre-
sent, and to all these things adhered. He
protested not at least either against the sen^
timents or langugae adopted on this occasion.
But I desire not to load him with the guilt of
Margarot : Skirving has enough of his own
to answer for.
On the Wednesday — Mealmaker in the
chair — another worm debate is recommenced
on the words not the propriety of citizen
Callender*s motion; and is terminated by
the appointment of a committee to amend
the words. This report of Wednesday's pro-
ceedings concludes with a recommendation
to all me members and their constituents to
support the Gazetteer by subscriptions and
every encouragement in their power.
On the Thursday—Taylor in the chair —
this committee makes its report ; and after
stating that citizen Sinclair called the par-
ticular attention of the convention to this
matter, the Gazetteer proceeds as follows:
** The house resolved itself into a general
committee to consider the report, which un-
derwent a long discussion, and received se-
veral amendments in the committee; and
when the convention was resumed, it passed
unanimously in tlie form of a declaration and
resolution. " But being ordered to stand Ike
ia$t article on the record of tfie proceedings of
the convention, me cannot insert it till the ter^
mination (f the present session.^* Then fol-
lows a long account of two most inflammatory
551] S4 GEOUGB ilL Proceedings agian$t William SUroing
[552
barangues from Gemld «iid Browne, with
which, for the pr^nt, we have little to
do: bat the result is, as stated in the
Gazetteer, <' That a secret committee was a|^
pointed to fix a place for the meeting of the
convention, under the cireumsiance$ mentioned
in the preceding resolution"
1' do therefore contend, gentlemen, that
the committee of emei^cncy,moved for byCal-
lender, amended by Smclair, and passed with
so much solemnity in this illegal convention,
for which a blank of a page is left in these
minutes on your table, is one entirely different
from the subsequent committee moved by
Margarot as a secret one, and explanatory of
and relative to the former. This last was
only a consequence of the former antecedent
resolution, — that resolution which the^
thought it dangerous to insert in these mi-
tiutes; and which their accredited gazette,
the Gazetteer, pretended was only postponed
to the close of tne convention, a penod which
20U know, the magistrates did not allow to
appen.
This resolution, therefore, was the one
which Sinclair^ jusUy alarmed, was proposing
to have committed to the flames when Ait^
cheson entered the room, and assumed the
pen at the table : and that he is correct in so
marking, by his evidence, the period of his
entrance, is proved by inspection of the mi-
nutes, which beins previously of George
Ross's, are during the remainder of the even-
Ine, the hand-vmting of Aitcheson, and in
whose hand-writing we afterwards find the re-
«olution for a secret committee on the motion
of Margarot, and the seditious and inflamma-
toi7 harangue of Mr. Gerrald. With that
gentleman's speech, I shall not now trouble
you. He would have stood in the place now
occu|>ied by the panel, the day after to-mor*
row, if he had not, on his own ureent request,
been indulged with a delay ; but ne shiul one
Hay or other stand his trial in this court, be-
fore he and I have done with each other, I
shall assure him. But what I have now
particularly to advert to is this, that these
two resolutions are things perfectly dis-
tinct and separate : that the motion for, and
Adoption of a secret committee, is not as Ait-
cheson to day would in his evidence have us
to believe, the result of Callender and Sin-
dair's orinnal and amended motions; and
that a seditious, if not treasonable purpose
was in view of all tiiose who either framed
4>r amended, or concurred therein, is indispu-
tably proved, not only by what they wrote
and published, but by wnat they cautiously
abstained from either writing or publishing;
and that as to the criminal nature and pur-
pose, they stand by their own conduct vir-
tually condemned.
Gentlemen, let me look back again to the
minutes^ I am sorry to trespass so much
upon your time, but I feel it a duty incum-
bent upon me, and I confess I feel some kind
0f anxiety in a cause of this naturci however
clear the evidence may be, for the sake of
my country, or for my own satisfaction at
least, to leave no argument unstated which
may be necessary for your subsequent delibe*
ration. Mr. Margarot moved for a secret com-
mittee ; and that each delegate shall be entrust-
ed with a sealed letter, containine the name of
the place of meeting ; and the following citi-
zens were named as a committee. There are
only four members; and yet those persons
Aitcheson, who wrote the minute, ana Ross,
and his brother, the assistant secretaries, who
gave it as an article of news to the public,
could not remember the names of those four
persons, though such distineuished charac-
ters as those eentleroen are ; Messrs. Margarot,
fikirving, and Browne, three of the members
who constituted this secret committee, are
now at that bar.
Now, gentlemen, at the end of this day's
meeting, it is moved by John Clarke and
Matthew C. Browne, *^ that a committee of ob-
servation be appointed in London, to give the
earliest information of that kind, mentioned
in the foregoing resolutions." Clarke moves
the very same evening, ^ to establish a
eommittee of observation.'^ This, in com*-
mon form, lies over till the next da^. The
next day^ the 99tii November, in the first year
of the British oonventwn, annodomini, (which
I wonder they did not discard^ 1793, tenth
day's sitting — ^the secietary reaa the previous
motion of Clarke for a committee of observa-
tion, to be appointed in London. — Citizen
Margarot said, ^ there was no occasion for a
committee of that sort, as there were some
thousands of persons in that city upon the
look out." " It was accordingly agreed that
this convention shoidd request the London
committee of correspondence to give the eaiw
liest intelligence oi what passes in parlia-
ment." As they advance in their progress,
Sntlemen, the ringleaders become more au-
cious. Their conspiracy takes a wider
range, and assumes a more formidable shape.
Of this it would seem they were themselves
sensible : for on the evening before the con-
vention was broke up by the civil power, it
appears that Mr. Margarot had either heard
or suspected that they were now come to the
very utmost point of their guilt; and that
the sword of justice was just ready to descend
upon them; the very evening before the
other motions lying before them were dis*
missed, Margarot eot leave to bring in a mo-
tion to theeiieet, *' that the moment of any ille-
gal disperdonof the British convention should
be considered as a summons to the delegates
to repair to the place of meeting appointed for
the convention of emergency by the secret
committee, and tliat the secret committee be
instructed to proceed, without delay, to fix
the place of meeting." The convention having
considered the motion fully, unanimously re-
solved the same, and appointed the secret
committee to proceed as desired. Early the
next morning the ringleaders of tbi» P^ity
US]
jinf S^tBhciH*
A. D. 17M.
[564
were apprehended before da]r-tight, in Iheir
beds; and all their papers seized.
Now, gentlemen, permit me only to re-
mind yon of the evidence of Aitdieson and the
two Rosses, however ignorant they were, you
recollect they were extremely reluctant to
speak out upon the subject of this convention ;
both of them concurrea in telliue you at once,
i believe the last did not remember anv thing
at' all about the matter, but the two former,
Aitcbeson, and William Ross did tell you,
that in case of the parliament movine ror a
convention bill, simUar to that of Ireland,
that that was oat of the cases under which
thb convention of emergency was to take
place. They admitted that fact completely,
which they thought was very innocent; but
I beg leave to state, that it is the very re-
verse; and if I had nothing more to argue
vpon, in support of my propositbir, that the
proceedines of this convention were seditious
and illegal, I would ask nothing more than
they theoMdves have admitted to have been
the purport of citizen Callender's motion ; and
this case of emergency, as they themselvet
state it.
Gentlemen^ is it possible that you can
permit any iridividual, or set of individuals,
for any reason whatever, true or false, real or
l^reteiuled, to set themselves up in opposi-
tion to the legislatuTe, to take measures for
thwarting them in their deliberations for the
public gOK)d, to appoint secret committees^' to
call together delegates for thousand^ of per-
sons, as thev tell us they are, to fix upon a
place to rally ; and^ if government do pro*
ceed to act as the Insh (w-hamenl have done
before them, that that shall be a signal to
rally to a given point— and for what pitfpose f
the purpose is not spoke out, but it is ^our
duty and your business to conskler, that if a
quiet and peaceable petition to parliament is,
as we all admit, a reasonable and a proper
step, yet if you confound with that right to
peticion, a secret appointment of this nature,
the moment that such a bill is brought in, to
convoeate and call together in one given
point, the delegates from numbers of persons
all over the country — show me sedition: —
tell me what it is :--is it possible for you to
conceive any thing more directly falling under
the name of sedition, than this resolution of
Sinclair's, a step actually taken by them, to
carry that seditious intent against the parlia-
ment into execution ? they appointed a secret
committee, whether they appointed a place of
meeting or no, I do not care, for I take the
ineeting in the cockpit to be something like
it ; here then is a seditious intent acted upon,
as far as the magistrates suffered them to act
upon it. X^ntlemen, I believe you see here,
before yon, one half of the British conven-
tion of the delegates of the people,— the wor-
"thy representatives of eight millions of people,
and four persons, two of them now at your
bar. Are those men fit to be trusted with the
power of petitioning parliament peaceably
and quieUy? or M it reqtdre that these peo-
ple should appoint a secret eommittee to
watch the motions of parliament? or was it
necessary for a peaceable appeal to parliament,
on this, or any other question, that a conven-
tion of emergency should take place ? I say it
was nothing but an attempt, — ^if it was possi-
ble that the good sense of the country snould
be so mbled, — ^to take the -first * step in that
s;^stem of anarch]|r and disorder which they
wish for, and which has taken place in a
neighbouring country.
That a petition to the legislature was in
truth no part of their purpose, is evident on
the face of the minutes, and on the admis-
sion of the members themselves, no part of
their plan. At the meeting of the SOth Nov.
^ A motion for drawing out a petition to par-
liament being read, the order of the day was
moved upon nJ' On the 9d Dec. ** It beine
moved that citisen Smith's motion for peti-
tioning parliament, be discussed immediately,
it was agreed that citizen Smith should with-
draw it, and present another,'' and on the
evening before their dispersion, citizens
James Smith and Peter Wood moved, that
** this convention take under consideration,
whether after the contemptible manner in
which the late petitions for parliamentary re-
form were treated, they should i^n petition
for reform, or at what period they should re-
commend the same to their constituents." •
OenUemen, the conclusions will be unques-
tionably for you to draw; you are to judge of
men, not by their professions, but by their
conduct; and if you can reconcile theur con*
duct in any respect to quiet, to le^, to con-
stitutional proceedings, I will give up the
point. Gentiemen, 1 might have rested upon
this case of emergency, but I say it does not
rest there, the legu dispersion of the meeting is
proved to have been an additional case moved
and carried in the convention, upon the even-
ine of the 4th, when they were apprehensive
orbeing laid hold of. And will you permit
this man, or any set of men whatever, in the
face of your magistrates, who are obstructed '
in the execution of their duty, will you per-
mit them to make, what they call an illegal
dispersion of their meetings, also a signal of
this rallying of the convention of emergency,
in which Mr. Gerrald rejoices and exults, and
which Sinclair tells them, is to be supported
by their united efforts.
Gentiemen, last of all comes what depends
upon the evidence of the first Ross, and upon
the evidence of Aitcheson, that one case of
emergency was, that of a foreign invasion.
Ross cali^ it a French invasion. I think the
other man called it a foreign invasion, and
young Ross said it was in case of Hessians
and Hanoverians being brought over, but not
a word of the French. Gentlemen, you will
judge ofthis convention with all its French
terms, whether young Ross is to be believed,
or Aitcheson and his orotherare to be believ-
ed ; you will consider whether the emergency
fiSSJ 84 GEOSGB IIL Prwseedings ogamd Wmm SkmAig
[5S0
cf A 8tt8|)ai9iroft oflbe Habeas Catfm tct, m
of a motion in jMMrliament for a cooventioii
billy simibr to toat <ff the Iruh one, doea or
<loea not prove U to be a meetiiig for aedih
tioys purposes; you will consider what pur*
poses sucn a m^etiog, if they were peaceably
indinedy could serve, or whether such a dele-
gation, from thousands of persons, was not
calculated for some other purpose. It re-
mains unascertained, and unexpressed, be-
cause it durst not be expressed, whether this
convention of emergency was for the resistinir
a French invasion, or supporting it; you wifi
consider, holding the balance of evidence
strictly between the panel and the crown ;
viewing the conduct oi these gentlemen, u|>on
observmg Sktrving glorying in a paper which
accuses the parliament and the whole bodv
of this country of injustice ; going to war with
a nation merely because they will be free ;
looking to citizen president, and citizen thu,
and citizen that, — to the divisi(Mis into sec-
tions, to the vive la conventwif which ap-
pears to one report, and fa tra at the bottom
of it, admitting persons to the honours of the
sitting ; whether these men were, on these
events and emergencies, to meet together,
in places and under circumstances shrouded
in secrecy and obscurity, to follow a peace-
able and quiet, or a tumultuous and rebellious
conduct. I call upon you, as honest men, to
say if you think these men were met together
to resist an invasion, if such a thing siiould
happen, or to support. But if, as my opinion
is. tneir purpose was to assemble a convention
of delegates, representing as they say, thou-
sands of people, then the ccmclusion b inevit-
able, that the purpose for which this conven-
tion met was, to join those persons whom we
know within these few months have dared to
hold out, in their own country, that they
would la^d an army in this, and establish
what they pleased in it ; — would punish Lon-
don, the proud metropolis of Britain, for its
interference and defendmg itself as it has
done,— you will be of opinion with me that
they meant to hfl the hand of rebellion
against their sovereign, the constitution of
their country, and the liberty of their fellow-
citizens.
Gentlemen, before I sit down, I hope I
shall not be accused of unnecessarily trespas-
sing upon your time, when I profess the au-
thority from which I draw it, the reading, as
{»artof my speech, that of an able and mtel-
igeot man, pronounced very lately upon this
very subject^ I mean the Irish convention
bill,- and I think I cannot be imputed a pla-
giarist if I take the words of the solicitor- gene-
ral of Ireland * When the convention bill
was moved for last summer in Ireland, it re^
ceived all the censure, it was made the handle
of every topic of abuse, and of an attempt to
* Mr. Tolcr ; afterwards lord chief justice
of the Common Pleas in Ireland, and lord
Norbuiy.
iatena tbanads of the Irish afpynsl i^ bf
persons in that couatiy, of a atmibr deserip*
tioQ to those here ; it received an ample dis*
GuasioA in parliament ; and, to the henow -of
opposition m Ireland, who have ia a gieat
measure followed the hooovrable and pa»
triotic ccmduct of the opposition here, though
Mr. Grattan, the chief of their leaders, was
for limiting it to a certain time, it was uni-
versally aomitted to be a measure of absoh^
. necessity, and which^ in some effectual way or
other, though they differed in the mode, thqr
were bound to support Gentlemea, cive me
leave to read part of hb speech upon that sub-
iect, because it is immediately upon the peiat
oefore us ; and fiirther because it is more elo-
auent,better composed and moreargumentative
tnan any thin^ I could say upon the sul^ect.
£Ilis lordslup here read an extract from the
dtor general's speech in the Irish parlii^
mentl
I ask yourselves if that gentleman stood ia
this place, addressing you, instead of the Insk
parliament, if the circumstances would not
precisely justify an adoption of the same lan-
guage. We have a parliament assuming to
Itself the name, not of England alone, but of
England and Scotland, upon the French mo-
del, partaking in all its proceedings of the dis-
tinguishing marks of the proceedings of
France ; and I appeal to a speech of Mr.
Browne's particularly, as Mr. Margaret boas^
ed that thousands in li^ndon were upon the
look-out, so he encoiuaged this meeting in'
BlackfriarVwynd. tellinsr them that at Nor-
wich, and Sheffield, ana every where else in
England, there were many thousands, of
whom he was the worthy representative who
had delegated him to this meeting. Gentle-
men, there were also contributions levied
upon the poor and the ignorant, the deluded
and infatuated, many of these persons were
brought here to day before you. You saw
their appearance and their situation in life.
Altcheson indeed is in the employ of some
gentleman or other, but look at the list of
those persons, and you will consider what
Starving has to answer for, or what others of
a higher description have to answer for, who,
with the aid of superior talents and discern-
ment, have knowingly propagated the conta-
fion among such persons, by discourses and
y proceedmgs of that kind which are laid
in this indictment.
Gentlemen, I think I have now gone
through the greater part of what it appears to
me to be necessary to state. In the division
of the sections; the honour of the sitting ; a
compulsory attendance; in short, in every
point they form themselves after the model
of the convention of France. And they pass
to the order of the day; when one person, a
gentleman whom I shall not name, because
e must soon be responsible at your bar for
his conduct, appears and attacks the verdict
of an English jury, and the sentence of the
lord chief justice of England, he is admitted,
t
ssri
Jhr Sedition.
on thBt account, to the honour of the sitting.
I say this upon the authority of the mmutes.
And in one particular motion, I think made
by the secretary, a reflation is made that no
stranger shall he admitted to the honours of
the sittins» unless recommended by two mem-
bers, and^ a variety of other circumstances,
which it will be unnecessary for me to state ;
but I pledge myself, without fear of being
contraaicteS, that every single word that I
have now stated stands upon these minutes.
Here is a motion made by citizen Ross with
«ioe h convention at the top, and ca ira at the
bottom of it; here you have a body of cir-
cumstances together, perhaps each of them
9ewaratim, insufficient to found any serious
drairge, but all taken together, directly point-
ing to show that it was a meeting of a sedi-
tious tendency; besides that, you have a mo-
tion made by Mr. Margarot and Mr. Callen-
der, copied, I believe, exactly from one of the
resolutions of the French convention. Then
comes Mr. Downie^ motion, and in one word,
to brine the whole distinctly to the panel,
that, as ne was the secretary, so he is the chief
tool and instrument in bnnging them toge-
ther ; it is proved in the most complete and sa-
tisfactory manner ; first by the motion of Dow^
sie, which describes him completely in that
cluuucter, and on that account alone, as beinj^
the chief spring and tlie very soul of all their
proceedings, he seems to be indulged with the
power of speaking oftener than once. You
nave also two letters produced which call up-
on those delegates, in the most inflammatory
manner, whonad gone away previous to this,
to return to their duty at this awful period,
and come to their posts? You have aHo
what b still more material, and proves dis*
tinctly that this Skirvins is the person who
formed the idea of this delegation, and of this
meeting; — ^that he is the person to whom
this country is indebted for that wonderful
advantage which they have derived from the
presence of Mesrs. Margarot, Gerrald, Browne,
Odlender, and Sinclair. Here are two letters
found in the repositories of Skirving, one of
the 5th October, 1793, dated London, ad-
dressed Mr. William Skirvine;, head of tiie
Horsewynd, Edinburgh, signea Thomas Har-
dy/ two days before the meeting of th^ gi^
neral committee ; containing an observation
which goes to attack the conduct of the jury,
and of the supreme court of judicature of this
country.
** DnSi of a Letter from the Secretary of
the London Corresponding Society, to
Mr. Skirvipg.
'^ London, 5th Oetoher, 1793.
** Dear sir; — ^With pleasure I peruse your
favour of the 2nd instant ; but as yet ^ve
seen nor heard nothing of the two copies of
^T. Miur's trial, which you mention as bdng
• Sec his trial for high treason a. d. 1794,
infri.
A. D. 1794. [558
sent to the society, and to myself. Be kind
enough, notwitlistanding to return that gen-
tleman thanks for Ins polite attention ; and
assure him, that we view him in the light of
a martyr to freedom, as well as Mr. PsSmer;
and that our warmest hopes are, diat the op^
pressors of mankmd, will either be ashamed
or afraid of carrying their revengeful malice
into execution.
*^ The general convention which you men*
tion appears to Mr. Margarot (to whom alone
I have communicated your letter) and myself
to be a very excellent measure, and aa such J
could wish you, without delay, to coimnuii£*
cate it offiaally to our society, without any
ways mentiomng that you had written to me
privately. If in your official letter you should
require us to send a deputation to that o^eet-
ii^, I have no doubt but our sociely would
with pleasure accept the invitation^ and I aa&
persuaded it may do much good. Our free-
dom, as you justly observe, depends entirely
upon ourselves^ and upon our availing our-
selves of this opportunity, which once lost,
may not be ao soon recovered.— I am glad to
discover by your testimony, that I was by
no ways mistaken in the nigh opinion I a£
ways had of lord Daer's patriotism. A title
may be a bar to disinterested patriotism; but,
it seems, he has evinced it to be an insuper*
aMe one.
^' You are right— it is true that we have
had another general meeting^ at which a
hastily composed and sudden^ produced ad-
dress to the king was read, applauded, and
agreed to be nreseoted, but on a cool revi.
sal, the said address beioff found to be more
iU-natured than spirited, more dangerous
in its lanmoe tmn advantageous in its
ol^ect, besides being too long, the committee,
with the appcobation of the majority of the
society, have adopted another, much safer,
more apposite, and relating solely to the wan
Endosea you have a copy of it. But you
was misinformed when you was told we pass*
ed any resolutions at that meetinje, for we
only came to one, and that rather ofa private
nature, namely, < that the conduct of sir James
* Sanderson, in preventing the meeting of the
' London Corresponding Society at the Globe
* Tavern, Fleet-street, was of such a nature
' as to place him below our censure.' — ^I am,
most sincerely, your fellow labourer and
well wisher. Thomas Hardy.
" P. S. Mr. Margaret desires to be remem-
bered to you in the most affectionate manner.
Do not in future, on the address of your let-
ter, mention any thin^ of the (London Cor-
responding Society), for it was a thousand to
one that I received that letter by post. — To
Mr. Skirving, Edinburgh.*'
Gentlemen, this proves that upon tiie 3d
of October, Mr. Skirving had wrote to Mr.
Hardy, the secretary of the London corres-
pondmg society, stating, that which Hardy
says is an excellent measure, that he had
559] ^ GEORGE nL Proceedings agoimi WiOum SUromg {560
were to keep secret from all the worlds thai
it might not be known ; that a fire might be
kindled in a place where the eye of tl^ exe*-
Gutive power could not see it, and might rise
to such a height, that it would have been
perhaps impossible to have extinguished it*
Gentlemen, you find them the. next evenij^^
though out upon bail, a^in acting withm
the toimds of the city of Edinburgh. Here
they yielded to the authority of the chief ma-
gbtrate, but had they done what was oppres-
sive, had they presumed to have dispersed •
constitutional, peaceable meeting they might
have obtained redress. You find them again
assembled the next evening, and Skirving
particularly, under a thin pretext which you
will not receive, that the cock-pit was hia
own private house : they were to meet a^ee-
able to advertisement, upon the lOth or De-
cember; the British convention being now
constrained to adjourn to the place»appointed
for the convention of emergency, the general
committee of the Friends of the People, were
requested to meet at the house of Skirving,
at the cock-pit, at twelve o'clock at noon.
Can vou consider this meetine at that place^
finmaed upon the restraint wnich thejr had
met wttl^ and this advertisement being signed
by this veiy gentleman as secretary to them^
^-can you consider it as a^y thing but a
flims;^ pretence to shelter themselves undec
the wing of the law } Mr. Skirving was there,
and Mr. Browne, persons who were the ring-
leaders, and active, not only upon Thursday
the 5th, but upon the evening of Friday thk
6th; and when called upon bSbte the magis^
trates upon the Wednesday, to answer for
this insolent advertisement, he pretends a^
wish to obey the law; he gets a copy of the
prohibition of the magistrate ; and, to con-
chide what I have to say with regard to him,
what is his conduct? You find him reading
a paper which, my learned brother who spoke
earlv in the day— anticipated every thing I
could say upon the sul^ect, — is asmsidious,
as seditk>us, and as inflammatory a j»aper as,
under such circumstances, could possibly
have been composed; he writes it in the
morning before he goes to the place of meet-
suggested the plan of a general convention,
ana it contains an observation which, I hope,
will be made by these gentlemen upon the
chief magistrate of the ci^ of Edinbur^
who has just followed the conduct which
sir James Sanderson followed, and for which
that magistrate has received the thanks of, I
believe, nine-tenths of the city of London.
Upon the 34th of October, Hardy writes again
thuss
[Beads it.]
Gentlemen, I have now gone throitth the
whole of the evidence. It remains for me
only in a very few words to consider the con-
duct of thb man and his associates, after
tiie seiture of thdr persons and papers, on
the 5th of last month, and die repeated and
at last successfol exertions of the maostrates
to disperse the convention itself. For our
conduct on this occasion, to mv surprise,
have we been blamed.— It was asked in the
course of this day by the panel, wiiy, if I
considered the convention as so seditious a
meeting, did I allow it to sit so long? My
answer is, we did not choose to interfere, whifo
there was the least doubt, as to the legality
of their proceednip, or as to the evidence
which could, or might be recovered of their
suilt. But when the three VMubers of the
Gazetteer now on the taUe made their ap-
pearance, and other information came to mj
fLiiowledge, whkh led to the belief that then*
minutes contained criminal, nay» tieasonable
matter on the fiice of them, my learned
friend and I did then, after nilly and well
considering what we were doing, advise the
lord provost and sheriff of the county to do
their du9, and which the^ promptly, and
wisely, and effectually perfonned^-liMi re-
sult of our caution lias been to possess us of,
and to lay before you, what appears to me,
and wi^h I have endeavoured to satisfy you,
is as complete and convincing a body oif evi-
dence, as ever was exhibited in a court of
justice. — ^You have the evidence to-night of
the lord provost, the sheriff, and Laing and
Scott, the two clerks: and without particu-
hurlv commenting on the notes of what they
said, I need only refer you to vour own, and
then ask, whether it is possible for you to
doubt, that as the seditious conduct of thb
man before the morning of the 5th of De-
cember is already apparent, his behaviour
during the whole days of the week immedi-
ately subsequent, proves an obstinacy in
his criminal purposes/ and an inveteracy in
his rebellious intentions almost incredible.
When they were forced to retire from Biack-
firiars-wynd, upon the evening of the 5lJi,
they called out that they were to adjourn;
they acHourned to another place, and it is
proved by the Gazetteer, that that evening
the convention declared themselves perma-
nent; the event of an illegal dispersion, was
one of those events which was a signal for
the convention of emergency to take place,
the meeting place of which the committee
I
ing: axid, he says, ** The magistrates of the
ci^, having forbid your lem and constitu**
tional meeung^ called this day by advertise-
ment, and by their proceedings to prevent it,
having given occasion to a great concourse ot
people, which may issue in tumult, and hixK
der your deliberations, it is judged proper to
adjourn the meeting.'^ It was fStse when he
wrote this paper, that any assemblage of oeo-
ple had taken place ; whether it was likely to
t>e so or not, he could not know the fact which
did not exist; but this he coolly and com-
posedly puis upon paper before he goes, and
shows what was the object he sincerely wish-
ed should happen, that there might be a con-
course of people and a tumult, that he migfit
retire with precipitation from it, and leave,
perhaps, a misguided and deluded mob ta
061]
Jtxr Sediiion*
sufibr fbr their folly^if a tiiroult did exist ; or
If there was any chance, that upon this occa-
sion any riot wbs to take place, the tumult
would be ofadifierent nature, and a dange-
rous stop indeed, which would have directed
its force, if it had not been checked by the
ann of the magistrates, upon the heads of
those who were the real objects of it He
says, ** It is therefore proposed to you, to
civo place to the violence used against you :
Xou will thereby convince the public, that
you did not deserve such treatment; and
now that your delegates have a permanent
existence," — they had voted themselves per-
manent Ihe week before, when it wad carried,
that they were to assemble under another
name at the cock-pit; this proves that the
object was the same, that they were in a
state of permanence which the Friends of the
People nad not come to, but which the Bri-
tish convention undoubtedly had; and now
that they '' have a permanent existence, your
several societies will be multiplied greatly,
and means will be used to lav the business
before each society individually, by printed
bulletins.'' Still the same French expres-
sions, firom the moment that he appears
upon the stage, till his last appearance which
be makes upon it; and with which appearance
I take my leave of him.
Before you, o^entlemen, the only legal re-
presentatives of your country ; and to whom,
as such, your country look up, and who, I
know, will support your proceedings ; before
you, have I laia the conduct of this man, and
trom your hands I demand justice ajgainst
bim. I cannot conclude without remmding
you, of what it is perhaps indecent in me to
suppose, that you can be intimidated, or that
you can be overawed, or that you ran be dis-
suaded from exercising that duty which you
owe to yourselves and to your country, and
following the dictates of your conscience, by
the calumnious, false, and unjust aspersions
of any man, or set of men. I know, and I
trust, these will be treated by you with the
same contempt, with which I have treated
all those attempts, which have been made
upon me; with that contempt with which I
shall treat a]l that calumny to which I have
been lately exposed, with that contempt with
which I have treated even those anonymous
threats of assassination, which I have receiv-
ed in the course of these two or three months,
because I have dared to be vigilant and faith-
ful in the execution of my cmty ; from that
line of conduct, I shall not be induced to
swerve or recede. — ^llie office I now hold is a
high and important one, and my country has a
right to look for, and expect from me a steady,
and firm, and I trust, just and temperate dis-
charge of its duties, in which their peace and
tranquillity and good government, are deeply
concerned. Such is the line I have deter-
mined to follow at all hazards, and in every
event. I did hope that the example of two
recent prosecutions might have had then-
VOL. xxni.
A, D. 1794. [562
effect, but which the conduct of this man
? roves have been completely lost upon him^
shall however continue to discharge that
duty ; and every man who presumes to fol-
low the conduct of these persons, not only
those who are at present under charge, but
those who may not take example from what,
I trust, will be the result of the proceedings of
this night, they may depend upon k, that the
arm of the criminal executive justice of this
country, shall be directed to bring them to
punishment. I shall bring them into this
court, to this bar, before a jury of Scotchmen,
and in their hands I shall leave them; and I
know they will do justice. And, I trust, we
shall all, as Jurymen, as Prosecutors, and as
Judges, meet with the applause, and with the
support of every worthy, every good, and
every virtuous citizen; and the abuse or
threats of those of a different description I
shall account my highest honour, and consi-
der as my best rewanl.
Mr. Skirving, — Gentlemen of the jury; — it
gives me pain to think of detuning you, by
going over the whole that I stated on the re-
levancy ; but as you were not then in jud^
ment, I think it my duty to state again gene-
rally what I then said, and to which I now
call your judicial attention.
[Here Mr. Skirviug proceeded to run over
the substance of his pleading, before the lords
of justiciary, and having stated to the jury,
that it was impossible for a person, not accus-
tomed to speak in public, to follow out the
lord advocate in so long and elaborate a
speech, in which, however, he observed there
was, he might say, nothins to criminate him
personally, the most of it being occupied in
vilifying the convention, and in fitting up a
blank leaf of some notes, said to be of the
proceeding of the convention, and taken down
by a number of persons ; he went on to his
defence, and took the liberty to read and
speak alternately as follows :]
Though what I have stated already, in
pleading against the relevancy of the hbeF,
must have convinced you of the injustice of
charging any thing concerning that paper
aeainst me, after what had already taken
place relative to it ; yet, as the writing has
been condemned by a iury, and the prosecutor
seems still to lay much stress, in his endea-
vours to criminate me, upon my having re^
ceived some copies of it, and upon my giving
some of tiiem away to a very few people ; I
must call your attention to the amount of the
evidence produced on this point : although it
must strike every person, on the first reflec-
tion, that if I had thought that writing cal-
culated to any purpose which I had in view,,
instead of giving away the very few charged
on me, I might have' had them sent to all
places where there were societies of the
Friends of the People.
There appears- no concert, on my part, in
this business, nor previous knowledge of the
nature of the writings nor commcii^tioa oC
U O
I.
SQ3] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings ogamsi JVHUam Skirting [9M
il. No evidence, of my ever approving it;
and, 90 far from showiag an aaxiety to dis-
tribute it, I had taken no meaos to spread it
at al^ nor ever considered it as a wrtlios, tkat
could give offence, or in the si»alie$t cbgree
endanger ttie peace of the country. There is
not a single thing more oome out in trial,
than what [ acknowledged before tbe sheriff,
aned from which I wras assoilzied by him. Tbe
iiacal, who on no principle could be a witness
in this cause, dicl indeed swear diat I was
only dismissed to bring up the letter which I
Had acknowledged. But you see the sheriff
hhnself, with candour acknowledges, and you
see the fiscal himself declaring uie truth by
his conduct at that time, though the preiu-
dice of ills heart has operated a difierent idea
in his mind since that event. At tliat time
he believed his first petition to be judged aod
rejected, for he first gave me a new summons^
without a petition^ and then presented a new
petition by the lord advocate's orders, to
dave my pi^>ers searched, and myeslf incar-
eent^ted though, no new crime, nor addilionai
ctfcum stance to the former, was so much as
alleged in it. " The above petitk)n having
Im en read in court, the lord advocate, as the
petitioner has been informed, objected to it,
and said that the proceedings against the pri*
soner had been all taken m consequence of
directions given by him.''
The jury who condemned the Dundee ad-
dress, informed of the alarming society of the
Friends of the People, by the false and insi-
dious calumnies of vile and venal newspapers,
and magnifying the hideous picture, accord-
ing to their distance, might naturally enough
suppose, that, putting such a paper into the
hand of such men, was giving arms to the
•nemy, or a dagger to madmen ; but it could
never enter my thoughts, tliat such a paper
would ever excite the Friends of the People
to hot, or tumult. I knew them too well to
apprehend the smallest danger from their
readiAg of it ; the facts set forth in the paper
were alreadiy known to them. And if tnis
)>ai>er fell into the hands of others, it could
only have excited them to join the Friends of
the People, which to do, is synonimousto a
declaration, to avoid all riot and tumult ; and,
instead thereof, would have been subjecting
themselves to good order, and to wholesome
veeulations.
xhe public prosecutor must have been very
ignorant of me, if he thought my reading
was so contracted, as that I should be startled
at such a paper. I have tread manv, much
more strongly expressed ; and even the worst
of them did not come up to my klea of sedi-
tion, which is leasing making ; and, lot me
observe, that seeing this quality was admitted
Its essential to mdke up the crime of sedition,
at. the time of making these statutes, and
these were the times of arbitrary government
in this country, oould I ever suppose, that at
the end of the eighteenth century, telling the
truth would be found sedition. And; if the
authors, who^faavewitfte the soiso ttttags^
have rM}t told us the truth, m tbe iNkSsusos
which I will now read to yoM, ^"om wnom mm
we to got thetfutb? And whan aoe i^e'te
believe F
X have akeady read soae fMsagcs, and will
aAerwards read some idok.
if then, I, who kaew these diings, iroiiid
not believe tbe Dundee fMfer to be f^Ase sumI
caliunnious. How then can I he charjgeaMg
with sedition, £(x only foeeiving k,&iid fetAiBg
a few friends, who were all on ^ mo6t inti^
mate footing with me, get copies of it,, wAiea
desired. Besides, it is 4o be observed, that^
as they were sent to a society whose secretary
I was at that time, I might have giwen them
all without fau^ though tt had been a orimi«>
sal paper, because i might have given ihem
without looking at them, so as to judge of
their merit.
It is not proved, tiss^gb asserted in the ii<-
bel, that I gave a single copy to any, but to
those to whom it was sent, aM only to 4ifaam^
when they called fiar tL
No more is proven. And can "doing thb
admit the suspicion of seditious and ielonioiis
intention ? Surely no person hearing me cam.
believe it. I ask you again, has tte public
prosecutor proven a single thing more tfaam
what I acknowledged before the sheriff^ 0%*
cept giving one copy to Mr. Kid, and one to
Mr. Aiteheson, of both which, however, the
sheriff likewise knew, asid yet judicially a^
soilzied me ?
The prosecutor is not more successful m
his proof, relative to the second hand-bitt
charged in the indictment. He has neither
proved that I wrote it, nor that I signed k,
nor approved of it, nor published it, nor evan
that it is the address bv ^e society, to which
I am secretary ; nor, ttiat I was seoretary to
that society in particular. Nevertheless^ aa
he will not give up his chafge against ae in
this particular; and, as some may -suf^pasB,
that I must have been concerned in it ; and
yet, I trusty that none of my judges will pro-
ceed in judging me upon any thing, eaoei^t
what is fairly charged upon me in the indictr
ment, and also fully proved ; I will beg leave
to put that natural interpretation on the adr
dress, which unprejudiced investigation mxutC
be inclined to put. Si^pposing that a sociely
of the Friends of the Peeplef— for I can ooljr
suppose it, as the prosecutor has by no means
proved it, — had ^awn up .-this address to tbe
public, yet some of the witnesses said, :th«t
the meeting sefersed to, refused to pass theae-
resolutions. As all of them wme vasy aiiv-
cere, and conscientious, and of course aealovB
in the cause of reform, as bein j; that alone
which, in their humble estknatioo, ^eao save
the country ; can it be supposed by anyithinfe-
ing roan, that on such a.sutooct, tfasy^iaiiW
possibly cxfiress themselves more toodly?
They believe sinaerely thait thecf hawe betui,
as by peacemeal, deprived of all the riobta
whichjjthey bii9V€been instpiclod^ their blbaiip
MBT'
fir SeiUtm*
A.D. 1794.
[566
iMd yUMJMrt by thar blood-^ f»u offered
to ba- pnrfed in the House of Commonfl^ by
Mr. Wbsrtoo^ ft3 yon bave seen by hia motion
made tbere, and not contradicted, and which
I haivQ ab^uij lead to vou. In what other
tanwcaii you si^pose that they, as free born
Britoii, ivoold apply to those who kept them
up, tfaoB In the language of demand, and of
Bpstitation t If they have not been robbed of
their ririxts, thev are made to believe so by
thoBo mo ^QUM know best, — the members
^ tinl v«i7 house, which ^t is said, have sold
thacL Fully persuaded, and high in the
idsa, that tb|^ had allensth fitUenon the only
jlkMk bj wtudi they could recover their lost
ng^^-^and in which they thought their fel-
low citiaens were blind in opposing them, bo*
<aMae their opposition to the measures, ivhich
ijptsj judged effectual, hunied the ministry
into a destructive war, which, they dreaded
would end, as is now evident, in anarchy and
luin;— 4b what more moderate terms then
could they reproach them for their folly, in
being the evident cause of reducing their
OHintry to so great calamity and daiwer }
Ahfs all, — &r I must take every advantage
of the piiesocutor, because he has discovered
an unjustifiabte keenness to criminate me, —
yon will t>e immediately be convinced, that
all he has said, and all the evidence he has
brought, is quite foreign to the object before
ymt. It cannot any way be appMed to the
address in the indictment The hand4>ili is
deacribed, in tho indictment, to be a hand-bill,
in consequence of wliieh, a society, termed
£rsty ^ Tne General Convention ; and which
did aAerwards anogale to itself, the name of
< The British Convention,' " did assembie/Bot
all the witnesses have declared, ^t the hand-
bill, on wliich they bore testimony, was that
advertaement, whose object alohe was to call
the several meetings of the Friends of the
People, in £dinburgb, to meet in their re«
speckive bodies. It called no meeting of any
•tber description, as you will see by Sie parts
of the bill which the lord advocate has Indus*
tiiously Joept out of sight, and which parts
omiUed are as follows :
'* Friends of the People, Mason Lodge, Black-
friars-wynd, 4th October, 1793.
. ^ Consowus of the nurity of their motives
and the legality of all tn«r proceedings, which
lia^w been oolely confined to that great object
of national justice, a parliamentary reform ;
the Friends of the People have heard, with
tninil^ed astonishment and contempt, the false
aad mjurtoos aspersions bestowed upon them,
la the course of Mr. Muir's trial.
*^ In their own vindication, and to show the
world, tiaat neither the imbecile ridicule of a
crown lawyer, nor the unconstitutional opi-
nioBS of a judge, can make them desert tne
gtaataoid important cause in which they are
emlMBked^; a numerous and respectable meet-
ing of the Friends of the People, in and about
£aanburg|i, holden as above, have unani-
mously agreed to the following resolutions :
<< I. That '^ aocie^ is determined to ad-
here to the original principles of its institu-
tion.—* An equalremredentation of the people,
*• and a shorter duration of parliamentary dele-
< gatioB.'
^ II. That, without reflecting on a verdict
of the country, the meeting; consider it their
duty, to return thanks, in this public manner,
to Thomas Muir, younger, of Huntershill, for .
his manly and honourable exertions, in the
cause of a parliamentary reform.
" III. That this meeting likewise consider
it a duty to express their thanks to the rev. T.
F. Palmer, for his exertions in the same iia-
portant cause.
'' IV. That tlus society caHs upon tba
people of Scotland, to unite in promoting the
nappiness and prosperity of their country, by
assisting to obtain a reform in the Commons
House of Parliament, the only measure that
can seoire to them and to their posterity, the
inestimable blessings of peace; check an in-
creasing and oppressive system of taiuition,
and prevent the baneful influence of that cor-
ruption which has proved so inimical to pubUc
virtue, and so destriictive to private morals.'^
Then comes the part of this hand bill nar-
rated in the Indictment.
y Friends of the People. — The general com*
mittee call on you to meet in your respective
societies, at the times and places directed
below, for the purpose of admitting those who
now incline to join your several societies, and
thereafter to take the propter measures pre-
vious to the general convention, wfaidi will be
then submitted to your consideration.
" \yednesday, Oct. 9th.— The Calton and
lawriston societies, will meet at their usual
places^ precisely at 8 o'clock.
/< Thursday, Oct 10.— The Cowgate society
win meet at the same hour, in the Mason
Lodge, foot of Bhickfriars-wynd," &c. &c.
As I know of no other meeting, except
those nominated in the said hand-bill itself,
which did meet in consequence of the hana
bili^ the general meeting, as is stated in the
indictment, '^ assembled in consequence of
it/' must have been one of Reevea*8 associa^
tions ; and which might, witibi great propriety,
be termed an illegal association, for ail that
is known to the panel, for he was never coiv*
nected with any of them ; and has no know*
Iddge of any such illegal assodation.
But, it is actually proved, by the confession
of the person who was the authqr of the in-
dicted part of said hand-bill, and by the evih
dence of liis own brother, that the parts of
that publication complained of, namely, the
first naif of it, is not my composition, but his
own, and can any person suspect me to be the
composer of the remaining half of the bill,
when they see that it contains an address of
thanks to myseli^ if ever the same was at all
ordered .>
I, have shown &at tliere is nothing in the
first part criminal ; and wbat ia the last part
567] S4 GEOftGB IIL Proceedings agtma WUIiam
tses
is'iB^ronff? Who does not see, that after the
French nave conquered all Europe, they must
also conquer Britain? And if this country,
associators were sincere, they are now certainly
called upon to risk their fives and fortunes,
that is to say, they are called to oppose this
formidable enemy, who may take both life
and fortune from all those who have pledged
their lives and fortunes to oppose tii^m, if
they shall find them making good their pro-
mise, by still urging and aiding the veiy ruin-
iog^attempt to subjugate that people.
. The public prosecutor and some of the lords
of justiciary have grievously twisted the N.
B, at the end ; which, however, if considered
m the plain and obvious light in which it ap-
pears to every eye, not jaundiced with pre-
judice, cannot be construed to mean more
than a peremptory call, to make ffood their
£hare ot the public obligations of the society
in the present deficient state of their finances.
I have already said^ that the general meet-
ing, defined in the indictment is not any
meetmg called by this hand-bill. That at anv
rate, I am no way connected with any such
general meeting, as the one so charged with
sedition, and said to have met in consequence
of said hand-bill. The British convention,
whose secretary I am, is that well known
society and meeting, wliich was a prorogued
meeting of the convention of the Friends of
the People, that met on the 30th of April last,
and adjourned till October ensuing ; and then
assembled in conseauence of said adjourn-
ment, and of the following public advertise*
ment.; and not in consequence of any other
advertisement whatever.
r
r
Priends of the People, and of Parliamentaiy
Reform.
' ^ The general convention, at the last m|et-
ing in May, unanimously resolved, to perse-
vere in the cause of reform which they had
espoused ; and therefore adjourned to Tues-
day the 29th of October next, when they
would again assemble in the city of £din-
hurgh, in such a place as the Friends of the
People there should provide for the meeting;.
- ** The several societies are now therefore
x^alled on, to meet in their towns with all con-
venient speed, for the purpose of electing and
kistructing their delegates to the ensuing
general meeting.
" Societies lately formed, and those who
tiave not been yet affiliated with the ^neral
-association, and such as may now be formed,
-in consequence of this intimation, will not fail
to send with their delegates, an attested de-
claration of their adherence to die principles
und the ol]ject of the association.
- ** Another application for rodrefie of griev-
.ances,— tlie land of reform sought, and for
the not specifying of which, in the last peti-
tion to the House of Commons, it was rejected,
-—the mode of this a][)plication, — the vindica-
tion of the assooiatton a^inst the public
charges 4]f seditioKii and mahgoant design^ &c.
are subjects whidi will remiire the most deli-
berate discussion. The d^egales will, there-
fore, come up to this meeting, as to the durar*
tion of the sitting.
" Meetings, and incorporations of every de«
nomination, already established for necessaiy,
or benovolent purposes, in whatever fkart of
the kingdom, and who may not conveniently
change their form, but who are well disposed
to unite their efifbrts for a speedy reform, as
being that which alone can put a period to the
calamities of the nation, will be received a»
brethren in the persons of their delegates,—
for the Friends of the People seek not their
own reputation, but the universal eood of all.
*' The association, in Edinburgh, will ad*
vertbe the place of meeting in due time. .
<* W. Skibvivo, Bee.**
This is the meeting which I acknowledge^
and which I will defend if called on.
The minutes produced, niay be the minutes
of any other meeting. It is not proven that
they are the minutes of the true British con-
vention, with which I am concerned, and for
which I will ever be ready to answer. Not
one witness has declared that they are so;
and I have never been called on to instract
how these papers came into my hand. They
are evidently the notes and writings of many
persons. It is not proven that any of them
are mv writine; and though this had been
proved, it has been at the same time proved,
that they could not be the minutes of the .
British convention; because the British con*
vention appointed a committee to draw out
their minutes, and it is not even hinted, that
these are the minutes drawn up by this com-r
mittee; and how can they possibly be the
minutes of the convention which appointed
them?
The British convention of delegates is a
justifiable and justified association. It met
under the sanction, and after the example, of
the convention of delegates from the Durghs^
and of the convention of delegates from the
counties of Scotland, and both of these coun-
tenanced by the first characters in the king-
dom. It had the same legal authority for as-
sembling as either of these. When a few of
the pensioned, and to be pensioned, members
of these in this county, wanted to call in
question the propriety of their own conduct,
with a view to put a stop to our pensionless
associations of the people, they were pleased
to report the following, and transmit the same
to the other coimties : —
" Report 11th. In addition to this report
on the merits of the two bills, the committee
submit, that they entertain great doubts of
the propriety of sending delegates to the meet-
ing appointed for the 30th of May next. In
the present situation of this country, they
wish not to give their sanction to general
conventions for. the purposes of reform ; they
do not see any good that can arise from it;
for the business can be more fully and better
investi^ted in each count|r, where freeholders
sesf\
Jhr Sedition.
A. D. 1794.
[570
and oommisffloners of supply form a legally- |
ooosUtuted meeting ; but they have no powers |
by law to send ddegates to any convention.
Thet>oly lej^y-delegated body is the House
ofCooimoDs; and each county can give in-
structions to its representative, by which
node.the general wisn of the country may be
obtained in a constitutional manner.
" JoHH iNGLlSy Preset,**
- Tliis attempt of the committee of the
county of Edinburgh, evidently intended to
pave the way for a quietism bill, received the
fitilowing answer from a number of the prin-
cipal members of both these conventions : —
^. Answer 11th. The opinion of a meeting
thus constituted, will not^ it is hoped, have
much weight in the meetings of the 30th of
April, or with the commissioners of supply,
and the great body of heritors, entitled to at-
tend these meetings, it was the declared in-
tention of the last meeting of county dele-
gates, ^ to restore the risht of representation
f to all men who stood deprived of it by the
' act passed immediately preceding the revo-
^iution,' and by the (different explanations
given to it in the present century.
" It is curious that the committee of Edin-
burgh freeholders, most of whom were dele-
gates, and voted for the re-election of dele-
gates this year, should have made such a
proficiency m the study of law, during the
course of a month or two, as to discover the
illegality of meetings of this kind, and that
they should venture to state their opinion
against that of the lord chief baron of the
court of exchequer, who presided inf the last
jneeting, and of the lord advocate, upon whose
motion it was unanimously resolved, to re-
commend a 'new meeting of delegates this
year, without either the dean of faculty, or
any other of the eminent lawyers, or any of
the country gentlemen, having once suggested
3, doubt concerning the legality or propriety of
the measure.
* ** We entreat the committee of the county
4>f Edinburgh to recollect, that ev^ry meetine
is lawful upon the very prindples established
at the revolution, which they have so solemnly
bound themselves to stand by.
. **- The futility of the argument, that each
county may, without communication with
others, instruct its members on the mode of
amending a law, which is general over the
whole country, must be apparent to every
one. Were this attempted, we may be sure
no amendment whatever would take place ; for
it is next to impossible that any two counties
should, without communication, agree on the
same mode of amendment. Hence it must
appear, that the consequence of the commit-
tee of Edinburgh's resolution, is to allow
those abuses to remain in the law, which (to
use their own words) have rendered it impos-
sible for courts of law to follow uniform and
omsistent decisions.
•' Robert Graham, Pretest
It is evident then, that in being a member
t
of the British convention of delegates firom
the societies throuehout Britain, I am no
more chargeable with suilt, than his lordship
the prosecutor himself, or those other great
names who patronized the burgh and county
conventions; and the British convention is
also equally justifiable, and must be held so,
until legally condemned. One of the prose-
cutors, comparing this regular and well-
known meeUns, or society, to a mob collect-
ed for mischief, maintained, that any one of
the number might be taken up and punished;
but he by no means instructed, tnat either
by the law, or the practice of this court, any
man was ever punished for beiojg present at a
mob, if it was not also proved, that he had
an active hand in effecting the mischief that
was done by that mob.
If the British convention is to be esteemed
by you a mob, you cannot find me guilty of
any thing, but of those things only which tho
prosecutor has proven was my own individuid
act. If the prosecutor had charged me, as
the secretary to the British convention, and
therefore answerable in law for their proceed-
ings, I should have met him boldly in that
capacity, and challenged him to criminate
any part of their conduct; I should have been
prepared to answer every thing his ingenuity
could have suggested against those deserving
fatriots. I should have justified them fully,
n this case I would have stated candidly, tite
object and design of that body; their proceed-
ings down to the time of the violent attack
made on them ; and submitted the whole to
a fiiir and open trial. But to try me, indivi-
dually, upon parts and portions of proceed-
inss of a number of seditious people, as the
inaictroent states them to be, and which were
called in a very different manner from the
British convention^ which was summoned by
an avowed advertisement of mine, put into
the newspapers by their authority, as I have
already stated, and which was of a very dif-
ferent nature from that one narrated in the
indictment, b certainly the most extraordi-
nary and unprecedented attack; and which, I
am sure, the prosecutor could never have
made, if he had not known, that every per-
son and every thing would be at his beck,
like his faithfiil mmion, whose mistake has
been shown before his face in the C>ourt.
If the British convention, consisting of de-
legates fix>m the various societies of the
Friends of the People throughout Britain, is
justified by the example set them by the
whole nation, and which example I have
shown vou, was vindicated and justified by
some ot the first characters in the kingdom,
and cannot be condemned ; surely neither can
you condemn the business for which these
delegates were sent up, namely, to take the
proper measures for a substantial parliamen-
tary reform. Can any man have a doubt of
the necessity, the immediate and absolute ne-
cessity, of such a reform } I will not suffer a
doubt to remun about this necessity in the
S4f GEORGr III. Proceedingi ogtiM WSKam Skirvmg
5711
bresstofasj one wlio hews me. liHUtead
a few paragmphs ftom the puhhcstiofis of
^lose who should know, wm mmt know,
thatstfchnecesBityeKists; andif wenay not
betieve them, whom shall we bdieve? I
will first read you, fcom the earl of Bochan's
politiad essays, lately puhlished, the ophuon
ef men in the higher spheres of life.
^ A rich and powerful nobility (alias, an
oligarchy), must soon destroy the liberties of
any people among whom they are su&ied to
domineer.
** It is in vain to search for the moral and
rationi^ principles of government in the mili-
tary Gotnic age. In those wretched times,
men had no civic union, no proper inter*
change of political sentiment. Fixed, or ra-
ther chained, as they were, to the soil of their
insters, the people were without collision of
sentiment; had no organized societies for the
contemplation of common interests ; no high
faads, no posts, zio printing presses! What
is man in snch a situation, but the machine
6f re^l or princely ambition and luxury P'
** The struggles for liberty in Greece and
Italy, recorded so eloquently by Che Greek
and Roman classics, imbued the minds of
youth, and excited the feelings of the aged,
with the ardour of political sentiment. The
people then began to know truly what it is to
be a member of a free commonwealth, to be
a citizen. Dehghtful name ! Best of inheri-
tances, best of riehts; not to be surrendered,
but with the life Uiat accompames it ! With
these sublime and heart^engaging affections,
the study of the Scriptures en Moses and the
Bvanselists in the livine languages of Europe^
and we consolation of free agency in the
ch<Hce of religious opinions, remarkably con-
tributed to the creation of new political energy
among all ranks of men, but particularly
among the middling and lower classes of the
peoole, who, by religious controversy, were
maoe. as it were, artificial members of society,
and lelt the inexpressible and captivating de-
light of thinking and acting for tiiemsdves,
and of touching and affecting general society.
The clergy, irntatcd to madness by the disso-
lution of their magic superstition, and look-
ing forward to the total destruction of their
profitable fable of tlie church, persecuted the
thinking and reforming people ; and this laid
the foundation of that perception of reh^ous
liberty, which immediately connected itself
with political liberty in Scotland so early as
the reign of James V."
" To women, somehow or other, we have
been indebted from the beginning for fortu-
nate revohitions.
''To the beauty, gaiety, and imprudence
of Mary Stuart, the daughter of James V.
vfe are indebted for the present state of Bri-
tain, such as it is. Had Mary been prudent,
Scotland might have become a popish mo-
narchy. England at best would have been .
tinder its old monarchy (with proper address,
under the Stuarts), and ws should not ^ve
E57«
had oetasioD to deprecate Odic fwedum
With the noostrous insani^ of aodctn Eng*
lishmen; but Is d«i^re the wsnt of it.
^ I stoJ» rather to inqiate eoneemMic the
comparative state of Britain^ in tins phi£>so*
phical age of political sentiment witfi
France and other countries, that have had
inferior advantages.
<« Who but a clerk of the Treasuiy, or a
lord of the kios's bed-chamber, can contem^
plate this parallel without regret?
*' It was in the last war of George 9d« that
Great Britun laid herself under the necessity
of defending her wide-extended domink»;
and of asserting her claim tb be the first
nation tipon earUi. Hie contest was bloody
and expensive, but the end was glofioi»«-
The enemy prostmte and breaUiless, empire
extended, honour maintained, peace estak^
blished, and, like the sun rising after a stom,
a young and native monaith holding Uie
sceptre, and ascending the throne, amidst
the acclamations of the freest and happiest
people on the elobe.
** These acclamations are heard no more.
A system of oorruption, established and di«
gested early in this reign by a baneful aris*
tocracy, has pervaded every rank and order
of men, till the spirit of the consthution has
fled, and left only the caput mortuum behind.
The forms of our government have outlasted
the ends for which they were instituted, and
hsree become a mere mockery of the people
for whose benefit they should operate.
*^ The prophecy of Montesquieu is fiilfiiled ;
and nothing can save the country hot the
ftilfilment of the prophecy of Franklis.
What that prophecy was, what this prophecy
is, I leave to the cwious to learn. What I
have written, I have written; futtvity will
determine the truth of my own particular
predictions, and whether lean to be remem«
nered as a captious cynic, or a wise and Py-
thonic politician.
** To conclude : as I think it unnecessary
to delineate the spirit of tlie times in Eu-
rope with respect to government, so I think
it to be indispensably required at roy hands,
that I shoula, with respect to Scodand, de-
precate the refusal of a militia to my coun-
try, the necessity for which was ^o eloquently
set forth by my favourite Fletcher.
*'That I should mark with my blackest
coal the game licence act, which is an insi-
dious and dangerous disarming of the
Commons.
** That I should express my utmost detes-
tation and abhorrence of the conduct of a
first minister, who, calling himself the mi*
nister of the crown, with a treasonable au-
dacity, should dare to advise the dissoKition
of a parliament, against the sense of a Houefie
of Commons, the only legal org^in of the
voice o£ the people, let that House' be 'Cver so
ill constructed, and demand ever* so much
reformation.
"That I should loudly protest, that a
573]
JQT SfftnH^a*
A. D. 1T94.
[574
p«r]i»Tnent ouglit to be allowed to did a nftt»-
ni death. And,
" That if a parUament^ conteBnplalifig tbe
ibiebodifig, the oniiiuous imBeiiecUons of the
coastiUitioa^ should on iu aeatb-bed provide
for a remedy hy the equalizaliQfi of the refve*
sentatioD of the people, it would prevent the
daagerous concussion which must undoubt*
edly arise, and that quickly, frosa tbeir po-
litical franchises being brought to the l^el
of 9vrfoufidin^ nations with a violent jerk.
XiCt us not (said mv admirable pxecoptor and
friend, Adam Smith, author of the Essay on
the Wealth of Nations) rashly believe that
Great Britain is capable of supporting any
burthen.
^ Let us consider wbat bold we Jiave aomr
of the two ladies, of Canada, and our other
lucntive dependencies. A tdow may be
struck, a blow will be struck, that ahaJi
leach the vitals of pi^lic credit, and it is aa
event which nothing but political insaiuty
can ifidttce public minislers not to provide
a^nst. Bot no provision can 'be made against
tms event, eaoept that which has lieen
pointed out by m^ finger of liie genius of
Biitain's welfjetie.
" I vnll fiot oiier iaoense toche Jiving, but
to tte dead ; I iosciibe this and the foUowiog
sheets to the memory of Sir George Savile,
of Euffbvd -UaU, member of parliament for
the counly of Yodc.
<< In Scotland the rights and liberties of
the ipeople had been determined, and AxM
by f»uHipli«d instances of xiian^ttg the order
of succession, and attainting their sovereigns
for treason agatu&t the righte of the people ;
and it is to Scotland and a Scotchman that
the world is indebted for the establishment of
the pbibsophical and loj;ical principles of a
fne constitution, both m theory aiid prac-
tioe. George Buchanan, Uie greatest man
of his age, as well as .country, established,
by inefiragable arguments, in his treatise or
dialogue oonceming the rights of ihe tpeople
of Scotland, the rights cf all mankind ; was
the father of whiggery, and, what is jonudi
grander, tlie father of that system which will
one day verify .the prophecies of the Chris-
tian scriptures, to the abasement of kings
and the oestruction of pciestcsaft.
**• The same sentiments," he goes on to
add, ** ke|»t up the sacred fitre of freedom in
<Fnmce» in the midst of folly and despotism,
till the progioss of commerce, pcinting, phi-
losophy, and literature opened the eyes of
FreoGnmen every where to discover that tiiey
we9e men, and ougbt.to he citiz^a, that men
were pot bom wUh gold chuas about th«r
oeeksy with stars upon their bseasSs, or coro^
4ielS;upon their heads: that it is the nature
of 4di^s, as hitherto constituted, to consider
tlieir interests as sepacate from the inteiests
^'tbeir nations, and to watch contianilly
iihe wolves or ibnes fi» their pey, in order to
demioy the citisena committed to their chasge.
Thai It 16 oeCttsaajy^ therefore, that they
should have only the power of obeying the
laws made by the people, with that of doiiifi}
good ; bot thai the power of doing mischief
either by pcerogative or influence, oug^ to
be taken away. These were the orinciples
of Fletoher — principles that seemea extrava*
gaiit, disloyal, and impracticable in his days,
but which al'e now acknowledged alioost
every where, except in Spain, Germany, and
England.
^* From this busy period till the meeting of
the union parliament, Fletcher was uuition^
and indefatigable in his ]>arliamentarv con-
duct, continually attentive to the ri^ts of
the people, and jealous, as every fnend of
his country ought to be, of their invasion by
the king and fans imnisters ; for it is as much
of the nature of kings and ministers to in-
vade and destroy the rights of the people,
as it is of foxes and weasels to rifle a potthrj^
yard, and destroy ti^e f¥iultry. Ail of theoy
therefore ou^t to be muzzled.^'
I will next show you the public opinion, as
narrated by Arthur Youn^, in lus 18th and
10th volumes of the Annsus of Agiicuhuie^
and surely none will auspect Arthur Young
of pK^udioe against the present govemmenL
The passages which I shall reaM you out of
this book, are queries proposed to the publie
consideration, by Jdr. Lodt, a member of tfaa
firitisih senate, together with the &As«ex8 to
the same.
" Queries by Capel Lofit, esq. of Forston.
*^ Dear Sir, — ^You have often, and with
' suooess, invited discussions in the rtmarnliT^
on autyeots immediately or consequentially
affecting agriculture. Will 3'Ott approve the
wish oT proposing the ioUowifkft queries?
** 1. What number of agriiMilturi^, in ihc
several counties of this isuind, may be oom**
puted to he without a vote in the choice 4af
iiepreseiitatives?
«< S. What effect may this deficiency of na-
presentation be i«asonably segarded ae havi-
ing, pelative to agricuLtural intesests^
*^ 3. What influence, in this resneot, ought
to be ascribed to ^the septennial auiation of
jwriiaments?
<< 4. Are the interests of agticuhuBe at pie**
sent, understood and r^arded in parliament
in proportion to their national importance f
<* 5. It is probable that a retfoon in the
election and duration of parliaments, or iatber,
would cause them to be regarded ?
** 6. What reform in the representation
wouki be most conducive to this affect?
** f . What mode and circumstances of olec- •
tion?
^ 8. What duration of parliaments ?
*' 9. is this a fit season for such reform ?
^ Those who are directly engaged in agri-
cultre, either as owners, occupiers, or hu»-
-bandmen, form so great a part of the nation^
that a view of the subject as it respect<i them,
575] S4 GEORGE III. ProceitUngi againH WUUam Skining [576
will give a very general insight into its prin-
ciples/and tendency.
** I am persuaded you will not concur with
some, who think this question cannot be dis-
cussed without disordering the peace of the
nation, and endangering the existence of the
constitution: on the contrary, I am certain
there are those very friendly to both, who
look to such an inquiry as the very means of
preventing violent and precipitate measures,
promoting confidence and tranquillity, and
preserving the constitution.''
Annals of Agriculture by Arthur Young.
" Replies to Mr. Lofft's Queries.
" Frickley near Doncaster,
« Sir ; September 8, 1 793.
^< Before any attempt to answer Mr. Lofft's
very pertinent queries, it will be necessary to
premise, that whatever apparent weight, by
representation, the agriculturists, or any of
the lower orders of the state, may have
in the legislature, it is so utterly absorb-
ed, and rendered void by the superior in-
fluence of the crown and peerage, in the
House of Commons, that a calculation,
even of the number of agriculturists, who
actually have votes, must, by no means, be
considered as a datum for an estimate of their
Teal consequence in that House. While the
crown and peerage act in concert, the govern-
ment of this country is virtually an aristo-
cracy; and I fear it IS approaching fast to the
situation predicted of it, by the celebrated
Jtfontesqmeu, * II p^rira lorsque la puissance
* l^islative sera plus corrompe que Pexecu-
< tnce/ Esprit des Loix, torn. i. p. 324. The
lower orders, of course, lie at the mercy of
the government, until the middle class of
citizens, shall assert its consequence, and
obtain its natural level in the constitution ; a
circumstance as desirable and essential to
the ^neral interests of the nation at large
as it IS the real and durable interests of the
crown and peera^ in particular. By the
middle class of citizens, I mean those men
possessed of property, from the smallest
portion, to a moderate degree of affluence;
and this class may be defined, as endine
where the real utility and elegance of life
give place to its fastidious pleasures, magnifi-
cence, and pageantry; which last are only
within the reach of such as are aptly called
overgrown fortunes. This middle class in-
cludes all the inferior gentry, the yeomanry,
and farmers, with nearly the whole of the
manufacturing and commercial men in the
kingdom. This class, then, constitutes the
boc^ of the state, in the aggregate of its num-
bers and property; and if the crown and
aristocracy, or head of the state, will obsti-
nately persist in refusing to legislate, in union
with the body, where will be the barrier of
their defence, from the lowest members, in
any extremity of danger and public convul-
sion, which the history of mankind, in all
ages and nations teaches us, are almost pc^
riodically to be expected, as the blazing eo-
centric comets of the political hemisphere ?
What an awful warning our neighbour France^
presents to the towering pride of the great
men in the earth : the monarchy and nobi*
lity of that kingdom, the most powerful and
numerous in the world, could not resist the
shock of contending political elements, but
have now fallen victims to the want of iipion
and concord with the middle class, or body
of the state." '
" Replies to Mr. Loffl's Queries.
'' 1. I think there are, at least, one million
of agriculturists in this island (including la-
bourers, to whom, I presume, the query ex-
tends) without a vote in the choice of repre-
sentatives : these, with their families, amount
to more than five millions of souls, or above
the one half of the whole population of the
country.
*^ 2. This deficiency of representation, has
certunly the effect of dimimshing the conse-
quence of that which in common sense and
policy, ouzht to be the first concern in the
state ; it follows then, that the real interests
of atie agriculture of the kingdom, are very
little regpEurded or known in the House of
Commons.
** 3. As the House of Commons is now
constituted, it matters not to the agriculturists
of this nation, whether the duration of par*
liaments be septennial or septuagesimal ;
perhaps it would be better if there were none
at all.
" 4. The interests of agriculture are cer-
tainly not at all understood and regarded in
parliament : witness the duration of tythes,
the influence they and the manerial claims
have in preventing the inclosures of com-
mons, now utterly useless to the community,
also the enormous expense and trouble of*
applications to parliament for that purpose :
in addition to these discouragements, sufii-
cient of themselves to proscribe and destroy
the plough, as if it were an implement of no
use or value : has not an act been recentlv
passed, by which the American fanner, with
very trifling rents and taxes, and tythe free,
is allowed a competition with the British
farmer in his own markets, though he is crip-
pled as above stated ? Yet the British farmer
IS no advocate for a monopoly, and is ready
to allow, that the people of England have a
food right to be supphed with corn at a mo-
erate price ; take off his shackles, and the
British fanner will have the advantage in
competition with any farmer upon earth, with
a free com trade. Perhaps the best answer
to this query may be given, by stating these
plain facts : an annual import of foreign grain
to a vast amount: — ten millions of acres of
imcultivated land, waiting only for the fiat of
the legislature, to enable Ceres, with her gol-
den harvests, to triumph over the chaotic
reign of heath; and whins; aodmutloB-Unies.
67T)
fcT Se^kn*
A. D. ITM.
[678
If the seDAftors of Gpoat DritaiA ctid not lov<a
i^gciittaAd foy* hunting better than the plough,
coumthese tilings exist } I am here romiod-
^ of oiu good editor's reioarkB on the poor
peasants of jiaocoiirt, who were actually in-
dosing and cultivatinfl; the duke's wastes for
their own use^-{See his Travels in France, p,
sea.]
'^ 5. It is very probable, that a prudent re*
form in the election and duration of parlia*
ineDt, would secure to the interests of agri-
t»luire their proper attention.
** 6. Let the House of Commons consbt of
five huodred representatives for the counties
of this island ; the number for each county
to be proportioned to its extent and pecula-
tion.
'* 7. Let every parish, or small district in
ihe county, send a deputy resident in such
parish or small district, to the county town,
the deputy to be chosen by ballot, in a meet*
ing of the men of the parish or district, above
the age of twenty-one years. No person to
declare himself a candidate for this office, or
to canvass, bribe, or otlierwise endeavour to
obtain votes, on P&iu of imprisonment, and
confiscation of effects. The deputies of the
parishes or districts, thus elected, to assemble
as soou as possible after their election at the
county town, to proceed to the election of the
representatives ior their county in parliament.
Let the deputies, when assembled, choose a
president, the president immediately nomi-
nating, with consent of the assembly, a com-
piivtee of six deputies, who after such nomi-
nation shall, out of the place of assembly,
make out a list of such of the said deputies of
parishes, or districts, as they deem most pro-
per to represent the county in parliament;
the prestaent to read over the list to the
assembly, after which each person on the list
•skill be severally voted for oy ballot On all
occasions of equality of number, &c. &c.
** 8. The duration of parliaments to be tri-
ennial.
*' 9. All seasons are fit for reform, and the
present is particularly so: a wise man, in
prosperity will ever endeavour to secure
himself against the return of adversity, m the
best manner he is able ; and will not, by a
dangerous secoritv, delay a salutary desizn.
** It gives me pleasure to see that the editor
of the annals ot agriculture is not alarmed
with the idea of introducing that terrible word
reform, the bi^bear of weak and wicked
minds. How intolerable it must^ie, to the
spirit of a free and independent Englishman,
to bear the quondam reformers of parlianent,
men now possessed of high offices and emolii-
inentj^ make specious orations against relbrm.
Such men, being parties in the case, and reap-
ing to themselves the foul harvest oi abuses,
ought not, in coBUBKUi decency, to say one
word ; at least whaft they say ought no more
t* be attended to, by independent men, tl>an
ms tba speeehes of those who they know arc
ioteoding to decriv9 ^beaiy for tb«ir own pro-
VOL. XXIIL
fit 3 but the frequency of this lurcunHstance
must iiiduce honest men to fear dangerous re-
volutions, far more than to hope for salutary
refbrms; for I believe the present masters of
this country cannot even yet define English-
men, as the tyrant of Rome once did the do-
generate Romans, homines ad servitudinem
parati. Though I confess, the servile echoes
to the late proclamation, apparently give the
ministry some grounds for the assumption of
it as a principle, that we are a people reac^
for slavery, and to be managed as such : yet
ministry ought to know, that corporations ire
not towns, and that the great body of the
people, are not in habits of corrupt and cor-
rupting obligation to the nunierous host of
their creatures.^
After such information^ was the public not
to be alarmed ? And if things really are in
such a state — ^if our constitution is really thus
on the verge of destruction — ought not the
public to be roused by every means, to pre-
vent its total annihilation? Convincea of
this, could wise and prudent men with-hokl
from stepping forth, to prevent the evils to
be expected from such an event ; if, as it is
now apparent, the evil is unavoidable ? And
the more so, that the means which presented
themselves as the most prudent for counter-
acting the calamities, if they should fall upon-,
us, I mean the union of the people in heart
and mind, were the only means of averting
these calamities thems^ves; because the
only effectual means for restoring the con-
stitution to its original principles^ by a sub-
stantial parliamentary reform.
Our opponents use the most strenuous ex-
ertions to misrepresent our designs and pur-
poses; but have they proven that we have
endeavoured to overturn the constitiitiOir?
They have only given you assertions, and we
are not bound to prove the contrary, nor need
the contrary is apparent to everj unfiro-
we
judiced mind. It is because evils exist which
tend to subvert the constitution, that we oe
associated to seek the removal of these evils^
and to prevent their farther progress in tte
undermming of the same. And it is proven
to you, by the prosecutor's own witnessei,
that when Thomas Elder, esq ; and Hanv
Davidson, &c. and the multitude with swordb
and staves attending them, for I cannot call
them m^strates, not being able to recognise
any legal authority under which they acted;
— when they violently broke up the meetings
of our convention ;— when they came the first
ni^t to disperse us, we were actually begut-
ning to consult about the execution of a for-
mer resolution, via* about applying by petition
to the UoiMe of Commons, for that reform
which alone seemed to us adequate for the
temoval Of tiiose evils by which we appre-
hended our constitution endangered.' We
were interrupted in this legal and ctosttto-
tienal business thai we had that niffht. We
asaembled the next evening out of the town ;
tbue giving w^y to violoncc^ and proving our
57Sf] S4 GEORGE lU. Proeeedtngs ngobut WiUiam Skining
[580
disposition to peace, and that, as much as
was consistent with duly, we would avoid
fiving offence, in proceeding upon the same
usiness of an application to parliament. The
lord advocate nas avoided the taking any
notice of this circumstance, though, if these
arc the minutes of our convention, they must
contain, first, an unanimous resolution to ap-
ply to the House of Commons hy petition ;
next, a resolution to take under consideration
the means of executing that resolution; and
thirdly, a resohition to make this the subject
of debberation on that very evening, on which
we happened to be dispersed, expecting that
the previous matters would, by that evening,
be ail settled.
The solicitor general and the lord advocate,
have exerted all their powers to impress you
with the belief, that the convention must
have had a design to overturn our happy con-
stitution. They said we were pursuing a
thing inconsistent with the constitution, and
which never came into the minds of those
who framed the constitution : — that we were
seeking it on the plan of the French conven-
tion, and that they must be right in the ap-
prehension which they have formed, since we
were at so great pains to keep our doings a
secret.
As to tlie first of these averments ; no per-
son, in the least acquainted with the history
of Britain, can deny the former existence of
annual parliaments; and be must also ac-
knowledge, that universal sufiraee is the verv
principle of the constitution of Uie British
House of Commons. But the fact is this, the
British constitution is neither more nor less,
than the independent spirit of the nation,
always disposed to trust too much to their
rulers, but finding them, at any time, to have
abused this confidence, always chastising
them, and restricting their power where they
fonnd it dangerous, and increase the control
of their own will, as the circumstance of the
case required.
Much clamour has been made aeainst the
manner of our proceeding. The u>rd advo-
cate sees distinctly the revolution of France
in every step. Circumstances the most tri-
vial and accidental, arising from the wit and
humour of a very few individuals, and which
the convention never desired to open a
thought on, seems to have nven the greatest
alarm to those, who, misled by calumny, had
previously been made to believe that the
friends of the People were in concert with
the French. And, considering such calumny,
how could we treat it by more marked con-
tempt, than bv holding up such empty bug-
bears to the deluded, as nurses do to children
to frighten them to sleep.
The great burthen of the third division of
charges, and which have been magnified to
the highest by his lordship, is the supposed
motion of a convention of emergency, and the
appointment of a secret committee ; but con-
senting both of wluch not a timgit thing is
charged, as if done b^ me. I need not Uiere-
fore exhaust your patience tp hear me farther
on the subject; I shall only crave your atten-
tion to the evidence itself, of the witnessed
produced by the crown lawyers. To what
does it amount, supposing these to be the
true minutes of the proc^dings of the con-
vention, though not its rcai minutes? It
amounts to tiiese things onlj, namely, that
the convention dreading the introduction and
passing of a quietism, or conventicle bill,
which they cannot view in any other point of
lisht, but as the putting on of the grave-stone
of the liberty or Britain, — with the view of
restoring on a proper remonstrance against so
grievous a measure, and of gettins &e same
authenticated by the people's subscriptions
before the bill could pass tnrough the House^
agreed to have an interim meeting ; and iii
order to avoid the tedious forms of calling
such a meeting, prescribed by the standing
rules of the convention, namely the procuring
the consent of ten towns, having societies en
the Friends of the People, for an interim
meeting of convention, appointed the same
to be called by a confidential committee, in a
way which appears to them best calculated
for a speedy assembling of the delegates.
This confidential committee is named a secret
committee, and what is the difference between
the two terms, unless it be that the one is
shorter. Is there any thing seditious in this?
Is it sedition to complain and remonstrate
against what we judge of the most dangerous
tendency to the constitution ? If not, what
was there to be apprehended from calling a
meeting, to petition and remonstrate against
it, in the way that seemed to the convention
most adequate to the doing of this timcously.
The bringing foreigners into the countiy,
has ever been considered as the most danger
rous to the liberties of this country. It has
already been experienced in a way never to be
forgotten ; and the minister that woidd at-
tempt it, would be a traitor to his country. I
could not conceive a stronger reason for the
people assembling to remonstrate ; and I trust
that, in the present crisis, the measure must
appear, to every unprejudiced person, as the
most dangerous that ever could be adopted,
both against the liberties and peace of the
country. And I trust that you, gentlemen of
the jury, must approve of the honest patriot-
ism of the British convention, in providing
for a due remonstrance against this and every
such attempt.
Gentlemen of the Jury, afler what I have
already instructed relative to that part of the
indictment which charges me with contempt
of authority, and resisting the sheriff and m»*
gistrates of Edinburgh, it does not appear to
me as necessary to aod any thing. It is evi-
dentiy proven, as I then observed, that the
provost and magistrates, the proper jud^s of
such an offence, had already taken cognizance
of the whole of that matter, and hadalso as-
soilzied me; and tbeiefore, the lord advocate
Ml]
JcT Sediiion.
had DO right whatever to iostitute a new suit
ia this case, any more Uian in the afiair of
the Dundee address.
- I shall therefore now only request your
serious attention to a few paragraphs respect-
ing your own duty, which I shall read you
from a very sensihle book, though the same
must already be well known to you; and
then address you upon the whole in a few
words.
. " As juries have ever been vested with
such power by law, so, to exclude them
from, or disseize them of the same, were
utterly to defeat the end of their instituUon.
For then, if a person should be indicted for
doing any common innocent act, if it be but
clothed and disguised in the indictment, with
the name of treason, or some other high
crime, and proved, by witnesses,, to have
been done by him ; the jury, though satisfied
in conscience that the fact is not any such
offence as it is called, yet because [according
to this fond opinionl they have no power to
judge of law, and tne ract chareed is fully
]>roved, they shall, at this rate, he bound to
pad him guilty; and being so found, the
judee may pronounce sentence against him,
for ne finds nim a convicted traitor, &c. by
his peers. And thus, as a certain physician
. boasted, that he had killed one of his pa-
tients with the best method in the world ; so
here should we have au innocent man hanged,
drawn, and quartered, and all according to
law.
" Suppose, for instance, a man should be
indicted. For that he, as a false traitor, not
havJDg^ the fear of God before his eyes, &c.
did traitorously, presumptuously, against his
allegiance, and with an intent to a&ont his
majesty's person and * government, pass bv
such or such a royal statue or effigies, witn
}ns hat on his head, to the great contempt of
his majesty and his authority, the evil exam-
ple of others, against the peace, and his
majesty's crown and dignity. Being here-
upon arraigned, and having pleaded not
guilty, suppose that sufficient evidence should
swear the matter of fact laid in the indict-
ment, viz. That he did pass by the statue or
picture with his hat on ; now imagine your-
self one of the jury that were sworn to try
him ; — what would you do in the matter ?
** Nothing" can be clearer than tlie dutv of
jurymen as defined by Magna Cbarta. Wher-
ever the statute law has not provided a spe-
cific punishmeut for any crime, it is the duty
of the jury to determme the extent of the
pimiahment. The practice of leaving that to
the Court is a desertion of their duty, and
repugnant to the principles of the constitu-
** The words of Magna Charta arc, That
no fireeman shall be amerced for a small
fault, but ailer the manner of his fault, and
for a great fault afler the greatness thereof;
saving to him his contenement, and a mer-
chant saving to him his merchandise; and
A. D. 1794- [58?
none of the said amerciaments sliall be im-
posed, but by the oaths of honest and lawful
men of the vicinage. Thus our forefathers
not only prevented a judge from imposing
the fine, but likewise tied up the hands of
the jury from ruining a man by an excessive
fine ; — in all cases reserving to the criminal
the means of a future livelihood.
'' But on the other side, when the matter
in issue, in itself, and taken as a naked pro-
position, is of such a nature, as no action,
indictment, or information will lie for it
singly ; but it is worked up by special aggra-
vations into matter of damage, or crime;
(as that it was done to scandalize the govern-
ment, to raise sedition, to affront authority,
or the like, or with such or such an evil in-
tent) ; if these aggravations, or some overt
act to manifest such iU desien or inten-
tion, be not made out by evidence, ^en
ought the iury to find the party not guilty.
For example :
^^ If the jury shall honestlv refiise to find
the latter m cases where there is no direct
proof of them (viz. That such an act was done
fiilsely, scandalously, maliciously, with an
intent to raise sedition, defame the govern-
ment, or the like), their mouths are not to
be stopped, nor their consciences satisfied
with the court's teUing them, You have no-
thing to do with that; it is only matter of
form or matter of law ; you are only to exa-
mine of fact, whether he spoke suoi words,
wrote, or sold, such a book, or the like.
For now, if they should ignorantly take this
for an answer, and bring in the prisoner
guilty, though they mean and intend the
naked fact^ or bare act only ; yet the clerk
recording it, demands a farther confirmation,
saying to them, thus ; " Well, then, you say
A. B. is guilty of the trespass or misde-
meanor, in manner and form, as he stands
indicted; and so you say all?*' To which
the foreman answers for himself and his
fellows, " Yes." Whereupon the verdict is
drawn up — ' The jurors do say upon their
* oaths that A. B. maliciously, in contempt
' of the king and government, with an in-
' tent to scandalize uie administration of jus*
* tice, and to bring the same into contempt,
'or to raise sedition, &c.'' (as the words
before were laid); spake such words, pub-
lished such a book, or did such an act, agsunst
the peace of our lord the king his crown and
dignitv.
'* Thus a verdict, so called in law, qua$i
verUatis, because it ought to be the voice, or
saying, of truth itself, ma^ become composed
in its material part ot falsehood. Thus
twelve men ignorantly drop into a perjury.
And will not every conscientious man tremble
to pawn his soul under the sacred and dread-
ful solemnity of an oath, to attest, and jus-
tify a lie upon record to all posterity ? besides
the wrong done to the prisoner, who thereby
perhaps comes to be hanged (and so the jui^
in/oro conscientia are certainly guilty of this
SSS\ S4 GEORGE III. PnUedingt t^auut WiSiam Sldrang
C58i
fnurlher) ; or at least by fine, or imprison*
ment, uiukme, with all his fasuily, whose
just curses will fidl heavy on such un^t
Jur3m)eD, and all their posterity, that against
their oalhs and duty, occasioned their cause-
less misery. And is all this, think you, no*
thing but a matter of fonnality ?
** Much of the office of furors, in order to
their verdict, is ministerial; as not with-
dmwing from their fellows after tbey are
sworn; not receiving from either side evi
dence not given in court; not eating and
drinking before their verdict; refusing to
give a verdict, &c., wherein if they transgress
they may be fineaUe.
** To What end is the jury to be returned
out of the vicinage (that is, the neighbour-
hood) whence the issue ariscth ? to what end
must hufidredors be of the jury, whom the
law supposcth to have nearer knowledge of
the fact than those of the vicinage in gene-
ral? to what end are they challenged so
sorupuloHsly to the array and poll ? to what
end must they have such a certain freehold,
and be prM et. legele$ homines^ and not of
attttity witli the parties concerned, Arc. if
after all this, they implicitly must give a ver-
dict by the dictates smd authority of another
man, under pain of fines and imprisonment,
when sworn to do it according to the best of
their own knowledge f"
Gentlemen of the jury; — Having submit-
ted akeady some things that appeared to me
to be altogether necessary for your conside-
ration, ana for my own exculpatioiv I shnll
now, io a very brief manner, state the heads
of my defence. To these I would beg your
particular attention, because, by bestowing
ttiis, you will be the better able to judge the
cause, llemember you are called upon this
day, seriously to decide concerning; the con-
duct and fate of one of your fellow-men,
who has been accused of a crime of a very
heinous nature, no less than that of attempt-
ing to break the peace of society, and of
bemg engaged in practices hostile to the
constitution of this realm. You already know
what has been urged against me ; and you
wilt not discharge your duty to God and your
country, you will not fulfirthe sacred obliga-
tions which you have come under, if you do
not hear and consider my defence, with an un-
biassed mind, — with a mind anxious to dis-
cover truth, and to render a just decision.
But, gentlemen, I hope that you will not
onl^ judge my cause with that force of mind
which resists prejudice ; but in the confidence
of my innocence, permit me to add, I trust
that you will show that you possess that
rectitude which places you superior to influ-
ence, that you possess that honesty and
virtue of mind, which would make you, u»-
<fismayed, withhold your consent, when the
hand of power solicits your approbation.
I am cfiarged with seditiob, and in support
*f this allegation, it has been attempted to
be proved ftat I hftv« done suoh and such
acts^ or have spoken or written such and
such words, as amount to - Um crime.
My entire innocence of thia crime -of sedk*
don, I most solemnly avow ; and it is your
business then, when I deny the crime, t<>
investigate whether and how the charge bay
lieen proved. My defence divides itself m
two parts. You are to examine, in the first
place, whether the evidence of dififerent kinds
that has been brought before you, is sufficient
to prove the £icts alleged, or to fix on me
the writings, speeches, and acts, specified in
your libel : ana farther, being judges of kw.
as well as of fiict, you are, in the second
place, to determine whether these speeches,
6ic, even if they were proved to be mine,
constitute in their author the crime fsff se^
dition.
First With regard to the former of these
points, the pfoof of the simple facts.-^I b»*
lieve it is a maxim, not altogether fiilr, b«l
ajgreeable to the dictates of eomnton sense,
that when you are fiilsely aceused ot a foul crime,
you may, and indeed ought, to employ every
lawful expedient in your own defence. It is
not, therefore, from any mean desertii^n of
principles, it is not from any weak dread,
that any part ofmy conduct about politics will
not stand the strictest Kcruliny, and may be
tried by the severest rules, — thoite rules which
should ever regulate the conduct of eveiy
good man, and good cittsEfn, - I say, ft is not
Kom the apprehension that any of my speerhes,
writings, or practic es, are criminal, that I call
upon you to investigate the nature and
amount of the evidence adduced, ii> support
of the several charges Perheps, seme mar
think it was unnecessary to refuse, while £
am conscious ofmy own integrity, that which
i deem to be no crime ; and may therefore
judge it better that I should have admitted,
that all such things have been dr>nc by me, as
libelled, and should content myself with your
opinion of their quality and import. This^
however, I could not doj even supposing I
had been inclined to it for the purpose of
saving you some trouble, while measunes^
the most insidious, and, but for some harm^
less difference in political opinions, the most
unprovoked upon my part, are employed to
circumvent and destroy me, and mm my
family. I am fully warranted to deny, on the
whole, a charge so unjust. I db not beg then,
gentlemen, that you would have the geoero*
sity, but I demand that you will do me the
justice, to attend to every sentence of the
libel ; weigh the evidence brought in support
of it, and deliberately judge, how far the allo-
gations are truly proved to be matters of fkct,
or to have taken place simply as stated. Bcs
sides, you are to try the cause, and to decide
concerning the truth or falsehood of the
charges, m)m the evidence set before yoti,
and in no other way ; and this, gentiemeo,
you must know to be your boundan duty.
With these general remarks, I fe«v« you to
determine as to the truth, or Msehood of
the alleged facts.
5S51
fi/t StdUiwt*
A. D. I7M.
[586
gecotkRy. I will tiow beg your atttetitiofi to
the secom part of my defenee, iti whkh I
affirm tiiat the import of till that has been al-
leged, w speciiied to have been said, or
done by me, even though it were completely
pnvtd, will not amount to the crime of sedi-
tion, or to any crime whatev^. Under this
second, which in this case, is by far the most
ifAportant branch of your duty, you will ex-*
amine the facts, or matters charged in the in-
dictment, in two points of view. ^ Gentlemen,
in the first place, yon are to weigh the im-
port of the facts cnarged themselves ; and in
the second place, you are to consider with
what intention Uiey were done ; fbr unless you
can say from the proof adduced^ that the al-
leged speeches, and other matters libefled
on, are of a seditious import, and besides,
that they proceeded from a wicked and felo-
Bious iutention in me, the accused person,
j^OQ cannot find me guilty of the crime cnarged
in the indictment. Wfth respect to the for-
mer of these, I need not tell you, that, if the
words and actions ascribed to me can be
found, on a fair interpretation, to import no-
thins wrong, there can evidently be no crime ;
for sulowing that I had discovered the most
perverted and wicked intention in the matter,
jet, if adl that I did was of no seditious im-
port, or tendency ; weakness, and folly, could
only incur contempt, and be treated with de-
rision. Now, I have no doubt that I shall be
able to satisfy you, and all candid persons,
that every thing that is alle^ to have been
done by me, amounts to nothing criminal ; to
nothing more than wliat any Bnton, with the
most entire regard to the constitution of his
coimrry^ has a fiill and undoubted right to do.
ReatI, I beseech you, and take a connected
WW of the whole writings, speeches, and
proceedings referred to in the indictmcirt, and
you will then be able to jodge of their import,
much better than you can be from the partial
extracts and mistaken details inserted in the
libel. — What can yon discover there inconsis-
tent with the principles of the British consti-
tution, or subversive of the authority of the
Britiflfh government? is there aught else to be
fomid there, bat a sincere wish, and an ar-
dent, but honest attempt to procure that re-
lief from errors, or remaining imperfections, —
tb effect those political improvements, — to
S|iread that information, — and to enjoy that
friendiv and mutual intercourse and atlvice of
our fellow citizens, thai seem necessary, to
improve the situation of society in Great Bri-
tain,-*4o give its constitutiort purity and per-
feclaon, and to procure to the inhabitants of
these reahns, greater security, satislkcfian^
and peace.' l»tt not the birth-right, the old-
est and most invaluable privilege of every Bri-
ton, to possess the power of pemtirrg out* those
eri^s^ which he conceives to eiist in the ad-
ministrMion of government? if we discover
wherein, aceording to our opinion, the happy
tonstttution of this country, the constituuon
of the thieeesMc^of Kingy Lords, audCom-
m6ns, may be improved ;^if we saptyose,
with some reason, that the privileges of those,
connected with one estate, may require to be
extended and improved, and may retidily be
so, without on the one hand occasioning any
detriment to the royal prerogative or to the
privilejges of the members of the other estate ;
and without, on the other hand, introducing
disorder and anarchy among tl^ inhitbitants
at iar^ ;~^if> in the pursuit of Uiese impor*-
tent (H>jects, we reckon it improper to rely
wholly on our own opinion, and Wish there*
fore, to collect the sentiments of our fellow
subjects; and if we think it impertinent to
trouble the legislative body, who alone are
competent to remove the errors, grant the
reform, and confer the improvements sought
after, with our solitary and inept application ;
-^I say, when with these views we are aehi-
ated, is there any thing wrong in honestly de-
claring and avowing our senthnents, and
openly constdtins with our fe\krw (Citizens;
and, especially when we do so in ^uch a man-^
ner, as becomes the attentive and dutiful
subjects of a regular government ? Haanot
this, and even more than this, been done by
the feivourite minister of the day, and many
of his adherents ? they who now dfiscover then-
hot zeal for the constitution, by watching,
with such anxious concern and suspicion, the
actions of others. But I need not insist, kfc
it is known to every one what has been done,
and what has been said bv them. You know
thetr sentiments were the same with ottrs.
Yoti know that the friends of reform in those
less irritable times, met openly and without
obstniction, and tiiat their words and con-
duct (not less expressive of their sentiments,
than our words and actions are of oors at pre-
sent), if not approved of by every One as pro-
per, were not denied bv any one to be consis.
tent with the spirit of the constitution, and
the hberty ana discussion permitted by our
laws.
With such upright views, to meet with
uf^due opposition, contumely, and even op-
pression from our fellow snl^cts, who happen
to differ from us in opinion, must surely be
irksome, and calculated to exasperate. But
we have hitherto behaved, and will always
conduct ourselves with moderation and quiet-
ness. Though we have reason to believe, that
the present opposition to our sentiments and
concluct, is too pointed and too personal, to
arise wholly from a simple difference of opi-
nion ; and, though we may suspect that some
oppose US, because the^ derive advantages
from the corruptions, which we desire to have
removed, yet no bad treatment has ever yet
seduced us from our principles, or provoked
us to turbulence ; and it has been our constant
prayer to the God of Peace, that amidst the
shakings of the nations, he would bless
with unity ^nd concord, the inhabitants of
these islands. As we conceived the civil mil-
gistrales to be rash, and to act uncoilstitu-
Qomdlyy i& diapering and foibidding our
587] S4 GEORGE lil. Ptoeeeding* againsi WiOiam SUroing
meetion, our astonishmeni at what "we
deemea an unmerited insult, and our desire to
assert our privileges, will sufficiently account
for our wishing to continue our meetings. —
No rudeness, however, was ever meant or
shown by us, as the witnesses for the crown
have attested ; and another public meeting,
if it could not be procured in Edinburgh, but
at the risk of public order and Aranquulity in
the smallest degree, would neither have been
desired, nor attempted. You will see then,
gentlemen, that there is nothing of a seditious
OP inflammatory tendency, to be inferred
from our behaviour to the magistrates and
sheriff, even though in our opinion, they
unwarrantably and lorcibly deprived us of our
acknowledged privileges — Had we given place
to the arm of power, directed as it then was,
even more slowly than we did, it would have
heen no more but a trifling misdemeanor, by
no means an approach to sedition. It could
only be said, that our submission was shy,
for resistance we made none.
The interpretation which has been at-
tempted to be put upon some of the inscrip-
tions quoted in the libel, by the lord advocate
is altogether forced and constrained. Nothine
more was ever sought after by myself and
the other Friends of the People, than the in-
formation of the country, ana the acquisition
of friends to reform, to be obtained in a man-
ner consistent with the spirit of the constitu-
tion, and respectful to the legislature. If we
wished for more, it was the steady adherence,
and the amicable union of the friends of re-
form, and good concord and neighbourhood
with every class of citizens, that we might
give the necessary respectability to that cause,
whioh we judged of prime advantage to the
nation. Our solicitous perseverance in the
pursuit of a constitutional reform, can never,
in fairness, be construed as an insult to the
legislature of our country, far less can it be
branded as an attempt to destroy its approved
and happy constitution.
Tlie palpable misconstruction attempted to
be put on our conduct ; — I mean on the con-
duct of the general society or collection of the
delegates ot the Friends of the People, called
by way of distinction from tlie others, the Bri-
tish Convention; — from certain words sup-
posed to be similar to those used by the
French having been accidently employed, is
hardly deservmg of notice. The use of such
terms ma^ vex a weak ear, or enrage a
peevish mmd ; but it will neither disgust nor
alarm a sound and happy patriot, nor any
true friend to the British constitution. The
employment of these words arising wholly
from accident, or from the whim of one or
two individuals, might be defended ; as they
are sufficiently logical, not uncommon in our
lan^iage, and not disrespectful to anv thing
British : but they are too mconsiderable to re-
quire any farther apology.
[588
GROUNDED UPON, AND DISTINGUISH TBB SUP-
POSED CRIMINikL FACT, TttOUGH. YOU MAY
THINK THE SAME PROVED, FROM THE AGGRA-
VATING CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH ARE NOT
PROVED."
To conclude, allusions have been made to the
affairs of France. But with these I have no-
thing to do. This much, however, I will say^
that excesses and sanguinary measures make
no part of my principles. And I trust that such
measures, and such conduct as has been at-
tributed unjustly to that people, will never,
and far less at present, be adopted by British
tribunals, nor approved of by British subjects;,
and mav He who hath the hearts of all men
in his hand, influence you to an unbiassed
love of the truth, and direct you to^retura
such a verdict as will be consistent with the
future peace and consolation of your own
minds, — such a verdict as will accord with
those principles of free inquiry and commu-
nication, which are natural to men, as ra-
tional and social beings, and which are reco^
nized by the law and constitution of this
country. . ^.
Permit me to remind you of the advice of
a learned judge.
" I vtriiy," saith he, " had rather twcn^
evil doers should escape death through ten-
derness, or pity, than that one innocent maa
should be unjustly condemned.*'*
I shallconclude with that excellent advice
of mv lord Coke, which he generally addresses
to all judges, but may no less properly be ap-
plied to jurors :
^ Fear not to do right to all, and to deliver
your verdicts justly according to the laws ;
for fear is nothing but a betraying of the suc-
cours that reason should afford : and if you
shall sincerely execute justice, be assurea of
three things :
*' 1. Though |ome ma^ malign you, yet
God will give you his blessing.
" 3. That though thereby you may offend
great men, and favourites, yet you shall have
the favourable kmdness of the Almighty, and
be his favourites.
'* And lastly, that in so doing, against all
scai^dalous complaints, and pragmatical de-
vices, against you, God will defend you as
with a shield.—* For thou. Lord, wilt give
< a blessing unto the righteous, and with thy
* favourable kindness wilt thou defend him
' as with a shield.' *' Psalm v. 15.
"* TAKE NOTICE OF THE NATURE OF THE CRIME
CHARGE, AND WHAT LAW TH£ PROSECUTION IS
SUMMING UP.
Lord Justice Clerk. — Gentlemen of the
jury ; — After so long a trial, and after hearing
so much, I should not think it proper to de-
tain you long ; but without running over and
reciting the evidence, I would submit to jour
consideration, a few general observations^
which may be of use in forming your opinion
upon the case.
Gentlemen, the crime here charged is that
• Sec Vol. T, p, l*i9.
589]
Jot Sedition*
A. D. 17M.
[590
of sedition ; by the penal law of Scotland, it
is a crime verv difierent from the law of Eng-
land ; for it fs not necessary to have any act
of parliament for it. But gentlemen, although
there is no special act of fMirliament for it, it
is very well Known that it is a crime of a hizh
nature, and of a dangerous tendency. I take
the crime of sedition to be violating the peace
and order of socieW,; and it is attended with
different degress of aggravation, according to
what is the object of it. When sedition has
a tendency to overturn the constitution of
this country, it borders upon high treason;
and if it goes that length, it loses the name
of sedition, and is buried under the greater
crime of high treason ; and a very little more
than is contained in thiK indictment, would
have made it the erime of high treason. The
crime charged is that of sedition, and the
public prosecutor has, in the minor proposi-
tion^ enumerated a variety of circumstances
from which he infers this crime of sedition,
and the conclusion of the libel is, that these
fbcts or parts thereof, being found proved by
the verdict of an assize^ he shall be punished
with the pains of law.
Gentlemen, although the public prosecutor
in justice to the party, that he might see his
way clear, to make his defence, nas enume-
rated a variety of circumstances from which
he infers, that this panel was guilty of the
crime of sedition ; in order to procure a ver-
dict, finding him guihv of these crimes,
it is not necessary tluit all these facts should
be proved, but the question you are to try is,
whether he has been guilty, art or part, whe-
ther such facts and circumstances as are stated
are not sufficient to convince you, that the
panel has been guilty of the crime of se-
dition; if you upon the whole are satis6ed,
that what is proved against him docs not
amount to the crime of sedition, or is not
sufficient to establish his eiiilt, you will find
him not ^Ity, or the libel not proved ; but
if you think it is sufficient, then you will find
the opposite verdict that he is guilty, or that
the libel is proved.
Gentlemen, in considering this case, one
thing occurs to me, and that is the conjunc-
ture under which these facts are alleged;
it was during tfie time when this nation is
eng^ed in a bloody war with a neighbouring
station, consisting of millions of the most pro-
fligate monsters that ever disgraced hu-
inanity, justice will never enter into their
ideas, but they swallow up all before ttiem ;
and I say, gentlemen, that the greatest
union in this nation is necessary in these cir-
cumstances, to support us under this war;
and therefore, gentlemen, supposing that in
short this nation has been feeling some griev-
ances from any imperfection attending the
constitution, I say under these circumstances
this is not the time to apply for relief, and I
appeal to your own feelings, and your good
sense, if it would not be brought forward
belter at any other time^ and that we should
efbploy all our force t^ get rid of that foreign
enemy, upon which the safely and the happir
ness of the country does in a great measure
depend.
Gentlemen,any person who had never heard
of the name of Great Britain,and knew nothing
of its constitution ; if the proceedings of these
Friends of the People and this convention and
their publications were put into his hands, I
think the conclusion that would be naturally
drawn by such a person would be, that it Was
a nation, the most wretched under the sun ;
that we were living under the most despotic
government upon the face of the earth, and
were the most unhappy of mankind ; that I
think would be the idea of a man who knew
nothing of this country, upon re,ading the
publications of this convention. But, eentle*
men, I appeal to your own feelings ana your
own knowledee, how much it is the reverse
of that. I believe every one must admit,
that of all the nations under the sun, Great
Britain is the happiest ; and that under all
the imperfections that may attend their con-
stitution, it is the most complete system of
government that ever existea upon the face
of this earth, — ^with all its imperfections. I
am sure, gentlemen, you must all be sensible
that you enjoy your lives and your properties,
and every thing that is dear to you m per-
fect security, every man is certain that he will
not be deprived of any thing that belongs to
him, and there is no man, let him be as great
a grumbletonian as he will, if he is asked
where he is hurt by the imperfections of the
constitution, he cannot tell you, but on the
contrary that he is living happily under it
Gentlemen, when that is the case, what con*
struction must you put upon the proceedings
of a society, who represent this country as on
the very brink of oestruction ; I submit to
you whether that is the work of the people,
who have a real regard for society, and if you
are of opinion that these meetings are of a
seditious nature and of a seditious ten*
dency, when the question comes home
to the panel at the bar, you must find him
guilty; for, gentlemen, I must observe to
you, that it is a rule in law, and a rule in
good sense, that if a meeting is illegal, all the
members of that meeting are liable for every
thins illegal that is done at that meeting, the
whole meeting are understood to be guilty,
art and part in the crime that is committed,
and they are all and each of them amenable
to the laws of their country for what they
have done. And at common law^even in
the commission of the crime of murder, and
robbery, some persons may be more active
than others, but they are all guilty art and
part, and all equally liable to the punishment
of tne law ; and those who have been more
cruel than the rest may have a greater sting
in their own minds, but in the eye of the
law, they arc all guilty art and part. Then,
gentlemen, you are to consider how far you
can think Mr. Skirving mnoceat, when it is
591] a GBOSGE UL Proeeedingi ^anuf mHiam Skinug
[$«
promi ID yoii, by a number of wifaessesi--- I
■ome of tiieir owo conveotioOy and what is
best o( all, is his owo declaration^ — that he
himself whs not only present at aJl their
tntetingi, but was secretary of the society,
entmtted with every thine done b^ them, ,
and a'xording to the proof this day laid before |
you, wimzi the officers of the law went, they
seieed ait the papers and minutes of their
proceedings. 1 f you are of opinion that those
meeting are of a seditious nature, how is it
possible to find this man innocent } the whole
meeting being guilty art and part, and he,
Wing secretary, is the most active man, if
•OS man can be more ^ilty than another, it
tt that man now standwg at your bar.
Gentlemen, that is the general nature of
the cause I shall not go over the parUcukrSy
but there is one thing I must take notice of
just at the very first — Fyshe Palmer's publi-
cation, of all that ever I read, is of the most
seditious tendency, and a more wicked publi-
cation it was not possible for human inven-
tion to devise, and accordingly Palmer was
very justly indicted for that composition, and
he was found guilty at the last drcuitat Perth,
by a most respectable jury, in consec^ence of
wnich he is condemned to banishment, by
transportation. Gentlemen, it is clearly
prof ed and acknowledged by Skirving him-
self, that he was active in circulating that
libel, and there cannot be a doubt that if a
man circulates seditious libels, he is equally
guilty with the man who composes it ; if a
man composes a seditious libel, and it goes
BO farther, societv is not hurt by it, but the
man who publishes it, does more mischief
than the man who composes it To be sure
Palmer was justiy found guilty of sedition,
because he allowed it to go out to the world;
and I sav Skiivina is equally guilty of the
pains of law with Palmer ; and it would be
very difficult for me to conceive it possible,
that this man, now at the bar, can be found
not guilty.
Gentlemen, I will not run through all the
other evidence, for indeed almost every article
of this libel is proved ; but the next article is
the hand-bill ; it is tnie he does not soem to
be the author of that hand-bill, but his name
is at it, many thousands were printed and
circulated, sent to the convention, and he
does not find fault with it; that is acquiescing
in the thing, and by not opposing his name
at that writing, he renders nimaelf art sad
part in that publication, which publication
contains matter in itself, I think, of a very
criminal nature. I own there is one part of
it, the last paragraph that appeared to me to
be of a very criminal nature indeed, and it is
set forth in Iht indictment '^ Had certain
gentlemen countenanced this association last
year, instead of pledging their lives and for-
tunes to prompt a corrupt and ambitious
ministry to engage in a war, which could only
bring eiiilt and rain on Ine nation, we might
have been. »tiU enjoying uacommoki piospe-
Htv, and a happy understaQdin(;amaiig|8t ootv-
seives as brethren *. and now, if they will not
manfully retract that very impolitic step, and
immediately join their influence to the only-
measure which can prevent further calamity,
if not anarchy and ruin, their pledge may be
forfeited, and the Friends of the People wiU
be blameless.*' What is the consUiiction of
that language ? Why certainly that the people
would be boimd to nse, and that they were at
liberty to destroy such iyiants ; and that their
lives and property would be forfeited, and
these Friends of the People would do no harm
in the cause of liberty, by cutting their
throats :-~that is the plain En^shof that
paragraph, I can see no other.
Gentlemen, the other particulars are aQ
clearly proved, that they beld £uther meet-
ings in defiance of the orders of the maois*
trates. Gentlemen, they assumed that tLey
wanted merely to obtain a reform in parli»^
ment It is certainly a very lawful thing to
apply to parliament, and God forbid it should
ever be tnought unconstitutional ; but it was
not a reform m parliament that was their ob-
ject, but a reform to be brought about by
force of arms of their own procuring; for
they could not mean to obtam any redress
from parliame»t,when they called themselves
the British convention of the delegates of the
people, associated to obtain universal suf-
frage and annual parliaments. It was im-
possible they could ever obtain from parlia-
ment universal suffrage, and for a very gpod
reason, it is 9 thing tliat cannot. e;&ist; a
nation could not subsist under such a govern-
ment And therefore, it was very plain what
they meant, they could not mean to get re-
dress from parliament, because they described
parliament as corrupted, and the nation upon
the brink of ruin. — " Is not every new day
adding a new link to your chains ? Is not the
esLScutive branch daily seising new, unpreoao
dented, and unwarrantable powers? Has not
the House of Commons (your only s^curit^
from the evils of tyranny and aristocracy)
joined the coalition against you ? , 1$ thfEi eleo-
tion of its members either fair, free, or fr&*
^uent i Is not its independence gone> while it
is made up of pensioners and placcsnen."-^
Now here I appeal to ypurselves, whether ^«u
do not see that it was not a reform in parlia-
ment that was their object; but thai they
aoight rouse the copimon people, whose ims-
rest it was to join then> to Obverturn the go-
vernment. And indeed, gentlemen^ the qama
of citizen and the h^Aoura ^ the sittings aocl
all the rest of it showa^ that in shorty thc^r
went upon the mode] of France, adopting it
as their pattern; and they thought^ tha^ now,,
as the French had got mto tneir bands the
very dregs of the people, say tbey^ v»hy iwur
we not by the same means get into our haiw
the same description of people in ti^is covps-
try; and you see they haa a committee ^f
secrecy, and alao a convention of emei^enQr.
GentkaM% cao yos* iicfi a^p^ tn pwlSnwt
flBff}.
Jbr Sedkion,
A. D. 1794.
[594
&Mr » redreis of the g^evasees thai you may
labour uader ? It is an absurdity in itself, that
tbere should be any secrecy in that. They
vece about to establish acommittee of secrecy,
and a convention of emergency, which had a
tendency to raise the people in arms.
-Gentfemen, I have laid before you what
occurs to me, and I leave it to yourselves ; if
jrou think that the oommentaxy I have given
18 the proper one, and that the panel is guilty
of the crime charged, which is sedition, you
will find the libel' proved. If you are of the
oontracy opinion you will find the Ubel not
proved. I believe there is no crime known
amonjgst men. that has a worse tendency,
e^>ecially when it goes to overturn the esta>
Uished oonstitutionof Uie countiy.
Geatlemen, you will attend here to-morrow
at tvK>- o'clock, to give in your verdict.
Mr. Skirting, my lord, may I not be ad-
mitted to bail.
LordJutiice Clerk. , No, you caaanot ; it is
contnuy to a rule of court.
2Ws<2ay, Jan, T, 1794, 8 (/clock.
The names of the Jury called over.
Lord JuMtkc Clerk. Gentlemen, who is your
chancellor.
One of the Jury. Aleander M'Kenzie ; and
David Anderson, clerk.
VSRDICT*.
Edinhur^h, January 7, 1794.
The above assize having inclosed, made
choice of the said Alexander M*Kenzie to be
their chancellor, ahd the said David Ander-
son to be their clerk ; and having considered
the criminal libel, raised and pursued at the
instance of his majesty's advocate, for his
majesty's interest, against William Skirving.
panel, the interlocutor of relevancy pronounced
thereon by the Court, the evidence adduced
in proof or the libel, and the evidence in ex-
culpation ; they are all, in one voice, finding
the panel William Skirving guilty of the
crimes libelled *. in witness thereof their said'
chancellor and clerk have subscribed these
presents, consisting of this and the preceding
page, in their names and bv their 'appoint-
ment, place and date aforesaid.
(Signed) Alexand£b M'Kenzie, Chan.
David Anderson. Clerk,
Jjord Juetke Clerk. Gentlemen, you have
retttmed a* very proper verdict, and I am sure
you are: entitled to the thanks of your country
for the attention you have paid to this triaL
Mr. Skirving. Mv lords, owing to an acci-
dent, I have: been deprived of very considera-
ble assistance, namely, the adviee of counsel
from London voluntarily transmitted to me.
However, there is no help for it now; but
there is one part of the advice of counsel,
Vfbamti may merit- the attention, thooi^h not
ttcrfaaya very oidcrly as to time, but if your
lordship .will allow me, I will stat6 it. Upon
the first page of the indictment it is said,
*' Whereas by the law of this, and every other
VOL. XXIII.
well governed realm, sedition is a crime of a
heinous nature and severely punishable.'' The
observation of the counsel at London, is ** it
vrill be necessary to ascertun, correctly, the
definition of the crime of sedition.'' Erskine,
Inst. 8vo. Edit. p. 488, says *< sedition consist
in the raising or commotions or disturbances
in a state.'' He indeed adds that it is either
real or verbal, but sedition can onW be that
offence whereby an actiial breach of the peace
is committed m order to prevent the due
course of law, and thou^ words of a seditious
tendency may be furnished, yet where actual
sedition is char|^, as in this case,, words or
Hbels alone, will not without a real act of
sedition^ be sufikient to maintun the indict*
ment.
The crime charged is sedition, and the aver*
ment is, that the said William Skirving is
guilty actor or att ami part,* that is, in the
phraseology of the Scots laws^ that he is
either principal or accessory. But as this is
stated in the disjunctive, it does not appear
with certainty, whether he is charged as the
principal oar as accessory. He cannot be
t>oth mncipal and accessory, nor can he
be iBdicled for both ofirences-*«-therefoTe the
whole is void.
This is an objection which will apply in
arrest of judgment^ therefore reserve it till
after the vermct.
Now, my lord, if there is any thing in that
opinion, I plead it in an' arrest of judgment^
and as itis a thing not common in thiy courts
I appeal to your lordships* candour, that if
there is anyjustice to be obtained upon that
point, I may obtain it.
Mr. Solicitor General. — As to the nature of
sedition, it was fully discussed in aimmiettt
before your lord^ips yesterday. With re«
spect to this learned opinion of counsel, he
may be a very aood English lawyer, and
very eminent m his- profession, but is per-
fectly igtioiant of the law of Scotland; be*
cause as that is stilted, it would be impossible
for any person to be convicted of aliy crime,
because I never saw an indictment but vrbM
charged a defendant with being guilty actor,
or art and part thereof
Jjord Justice Clerk, — ^If there had been any
thine wrong in the proceedui^s, the? Gonrt
wouM have taken it into considerationi
Mr. Skin>ing.'-^Aiiet all that was stated
yesterday as to sedition, I could get no satis*
faction upon it.
Lord Eekgrove.-^My lords, the panel is
chareed in this in^ctment with sedition,
whicn has been proved in a very distinct
manner; and, my lords, I am always very
sorry to pronounce sentence upon any of my
fellow subjects for sedition, of the heinou:»-
ness of which I had flattered myself, from
two late instances, every man was so tbo<'
rouj^hly sensible that I should not have oc-
casion again to sit upon a trial of that kind.
I I ■- — ■ — — \ —
• See Vol. 10, p. 807 of this Collection.
8 Q
595] 34 GEORGE IlL Proceedings againa WUIiam SUroing (596
My lords, I still less expected to sit anun
upon the oflRence here charged. I nUeao ttiat
of attempting to imitate the example of the
late revolution in a nei(|;bboiiring country, in
which country now exists eveipr thing that is
horrible in nature — blood-shea— massacre—
murder; the throwing off the belief of a God,
and aboHsbine the Christian religion. I
should have &ought all this a reasonable
caiise, why people Uiat meant well, and were
only wishing to amend our gjovemment,
would have abhorred the idea of coinciding
with them, in what has happened there. But
my lords, nom this libel, which b now found
proved by ^e jury of this country, and a most
respectable one; it seems that there have
been unfortunately persons so disposed, so
misgiuded^ from motives, I hope good, as to
adopt the mnovatioa of the forms of proce-
dure of that country, in their meetings, and
which must strike eveiy dispassionate mind
with horroF.
My lords, it matters not what my opinion,
or that of any of us, is on the nature of this
offence; or what is the nature of his guilt,
independent of what has passed in this court;
for suppose, if I had been able to have at-
tended all the trial, which mv state of health
could not permit; but if I had^ and it had
been my private opinioB, that this man acted
from the nest of motives, that the evidence
against him was not complete, and that he
ought to haive been acquitted; all woidd
have been unavoidable, in the situation in
which I stand now; because, mv lords, tlids
libel has been found proven, and this panel has
been found guilty in general by a respectable
juiT of his countiy, and therefore I am bound
to believe that he is guilty of the crime of
sedition as laid in the m^jor proposition, and
ef one and all the foctschargedT against him
in the minor proposition; he is found guilty
therefore, art and part in the circulating and
publishing of that snockinj; paper, which was
the subject of the trial or Palmer at Perth,
and which is engrossed in this indictment.
The gentleman has been advised^ he says,
that a charge of being euilty art and part is
an irrelevant charee. My, tord it was well
said by the couoscJ for the crown, that that
counsel, however great and eminent he might
be in his profession of the laws of EngUmd,
is totallv ifnorant of the laws of Scotland.
And if he nad been a wise man^ he would
not have meddled in what he did not undei^
stand. The gentleman spoke of acts of par-
liament; he does not know that there is a
positive act of parliamtnt that the char^ of
art and part shall be deemed sufficient.
However, this panel, and I am very sorry for
it, is found gnilty art and part of the crime of
sedition as stated in this indictment, and the
court have recorded the verdict. Mv lords,
he is found guUtv art and part of toe first
branch of it, whicn is for circidating the sedi-
tious paper of Palmer. My lords, he is far-
ther found guilt^r an and part of the second
part of the libel, to wit, the
which is styled a seditious and inflammatory
hand-bill, bearing date. Masons Lodge, Btack-
Friars Wynd, 4th October, 1793, and bearing
the subscription of William Skirving, as the
author, by order of the committee.
My lord, this is a second paper, in which
he is concerned; the purpose of which is
charged in this indictment, as tending to
rouse the people to unite together, to incite
them to acts of violence, and the words of it
calling upon the rabble to remember their
patriotic ancestors, who shed their blood in '
the cause of freedom. I do not know wluit
knowledge this panel has of the pcdime of
the ancestors of the rabble, who shed their
blood. I think it b very plain that if the
rabble are to assist in the reformation of this
country, the shedding of blood should have
been omitted, unlesa it was to tell them ^at
that was the way of reform, by shedding of
blood. ** Had certain gentlemen counte-
nanced this association last year, inst^ of
pledging their hves and fortunes to prompt a
corrupt and ambitious ministry to engage in
a war, which could onlv bring euilt and ruin
on the nation, we might have been still en-
joying uncommon prosperity, and a happy
understanding amongst ourselves as breth-
ren: and now if they will not manfully re-
tract that very impolitic step, and immedi-
ately join their influence to tne only measure
which can prevent further calamity, if not
anarchy and ruin, their pledge mav be forfeit*
ed, and the Friends or the People will be
blameless.'^— Telling them that their lives
and fortunes would be forfeited, unless they
did as that advertisement required them. In
the next page it goes on, as to the British
convention, the tendency of it, the maxims
they held, and the purposes they had in view ;
in sal of which this is found, that Mr. Skirv-^
ins was an active member, making motions^
ai3 concurring in the resolutions that were
there made.
A &rther part of the char|^e is, for reAising
to comply with the authontv of the civu
ma^strates, when they were about to dismiss
these meetings, which no person wishing
well to the country could approve of. Ana
then he b found guilty of this last advertise*
ment, in which he speaks of the delegates,,
he says, ** your delef^tes haidng a permanent
existence, your several societies will be mul-
tiplied greatiy, and means will be used to lay
the business before each society individually^
by printed bulletins.''
My lord, these are the chief of the charges,
stated in this indictment, and whatever mr
private opinion of the evidence may be, I
dare say it was perfectiy sufficient; but even
if it was defective, I am bound by the verdict
of this jury, which alone is now before ine,
and they have found unanimously with one
voice, that this man is guilty in general, that
he is guilw of the whole indictment
My iordsy that being the case, as a judge of
POTJ
farSeMon.
A. D. 17d4.
[596
tlus court, I CMmot take into eonsidentioo any
iedinss of compassion for this panel. I am
Ix^ma to follow up this verdict of the country
Vlth the sentence which the law requires
of me.
Hy lordsy I need not say any thing with
leggrd to the fMernicious consequences of the
ermie of sedition, which certainly the dif-
ferent acts charged in the indictment amounts
to; it effects every thing that is dear to a
man, his life, his proper^, -his liberty; but
were I doubmil about it in my own mind,
I ^ould be satisfied with the judgment pro-
nounced by this supreme court, upon another
unfortunate gentleman, Mr. Muir. My si-
tuation of health did not permit me to be
present at any part of it; hut your lordship,
upon his being found guilty, did pronounce a
sentence of banishment to the plantations,
by transportation for fourteen years against
that gentleman ; and I cannot, from the whole
tenor of this indictment, find that Uie crime
of which this man is convicted, is one whit
less, and therefore I think the Court is called
upon to place him under the same circum-
stances.
Lord Smintan.-^My lords, in this case the
jury have found the panel euilty, not only of
sedition in general, out of all the particular
charges that are contained in that indictment.
It now comes to us to declare, and to inflict
the punishment of the law upon him. Your
lordship has heard an opinion upon that
Soint very full and very solemn, wnich ren-
ers it perfectly unnecessary for me to take
up much of your lordships time. I am afraid,
my lords, that this unfortunate man, and
many others, do mistake the nature of sedi-
tion, and he called upon the Court just now
to explain what it is. My lord, I did yester-
day, and shall again ^ve my o{»iniou of what
it IS: it does not consist merely in actual com-
motions and rebellion against the laws of the
country^ but it consists in every attempt to
excite, oy inflammatory discourses and illegal
associations — I say, by these means to ex-
cite—the people to outrage and violence
against the constitution, to hurt the public
peace.
My lord, the o£Fence of the crime lies in en-
deavouring to excite to violence. My lord, if
there is no intention to excite the people to
\dolence, many of these meetings may be in-
nocent, many of them ridiculous. In this
case they wished for universal suffrage and
annual parliaments. One of these is a most
ridiculous and absurd doctrine,— universal suf-
frage,— nothing can be so absurd; — annual
parliaments, or a shorter duration of parlia^
ments, may be matter of argument ; but what
I mean is, by inflammatory discourses and
illegal meeUngs, endeavourmg to excite the
peqple to force and violence. Say they, we
only meant to petition lawfullv : petitioning
parliament is most lawful, and I should te
sorry that any person should think it unlaw-
ful; but in what noaimer is it to be done?
My knrd, is it to be done by numbers and bv
force? In that case it is war; and if a peU«
tion is suffered to be offered in that manner,
the King may leave his throne, the Peers their
benches, and the House of Commons their
seats, for thc^ exist no more. My lord, if
spy violence is olSered, it ceases to be a peti*
tion. — If a poor person comes and asks ch».
rity, it is a petition ; but if he uses a pistol to
enforce it, it is no longer a petition ; it is a
robbery. The crime of sedition may be com-
mitted by illegal associations making use of
French modes and terms.
My lord, the question then comes to be,
what punishment the crime deserves. I con-
ceive nothine less than that whidi was in-
flicted upon Mr. Muir. I do not know but
the crime deserves more, but we cannot da
less than punish the same crime bv inflkting
the same punishment I have fkeaxd that
this panel has a great family, and son^ I am
for it; but the cases of Messrs. Muir and
Fyshe Palmer should have led him to be in-
dustrious for his family, followed an honest
occupation, and not have meddled with ille-
gal associations. I think the crime deserves
more; but taking every thing into considera-
tion^ with the circumstances of his family, I
prefer the opinion your lordship has given.
Lord Duntinnan, — My lords, this panel has
been found e[uilty, by a verdict of his country,
of a crime o? a very different nature, and of^i
more dangerous tendency, than those com*
mon crimes which occur, and which are the
dailv subjects of trials in this court. My
lord, it is the crime of sedition. — It has been
proved, that these persons met for the pur*'
pose of subverting and altering the esta-
blished constitution of this countiy, under the
pretence, indeed, of reform; but! say, really
to subvert the constitution of the country.
And, my lord, from some other circumstances^
which came out yesterday in the evening^
and upon which the jury found him guilty, I
confess I shudder to think of the horror tnat,
in certain eventi^ might have arisen from the
train which this man and his accomplices
laid, in different parts of this country w —
lliank God they are disappointed.— Thank
God we are still m possession of laws to pro-
tect the constitution, and to establish the ee-
curity of the subjects of it.
My lord, it is our duty,— called upon as lye
are, it is our duty to execute the laws; and
whatever our feelings may be for this un-
happy man, we are not at liberty to indulge
them at the expense of all that is sacred and
dear to us. My lord, I said that this was an
unhappy man, and I think I can say so, be-
cause no man ever had stronger examples be-
fore his eyes of the danger he was in ; but in
place of having the effect it should have had,
it has had no effect at all.
My lords, it is always painful to inflict
punishment ; but, my lords, it is also painful
that men will commit crimes ; and they must
be punished, or society would never be safe.
S9S] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings ageinH WiBiam Skirving [600
It is unnecessary for me to add any thing to
the opinions already given. ' I think the
fiunishment suggested by your lordship, b
the moderate and proper punishment, and I
most heartily concur with your lordship.
Lord Abercromby — My lord, this panel was
secretary to the society assuming to them-
selves the name of the BrHish Convention.—
My lord, the object which these societies
held forth to the public at first was, a general
reform, without specifying the nature or the
extent of it; and, my lord, I am disposed to
believe, that, at that period, there were many
welNdisposed persons, in e^ery part of the
kingdom, who joined these societies, with-
out an3r wicked purpose, believing that their
sole object was, to render our constitution, ex-
cellent as it is, btill more perfect, without en-
tertaining the most distant idea of overturn-
ing that constitution. "My lord, whatever the
views of these persons,— of these deluded
persons, may be, every thinking man, —
e%'*ry man of common discernment — might
see Vhat was the object of the leaders of this
society, and tiiat, under the pretext of re-
forming the constitution, they intended to
overthrow it.
My lord, about the beginning of the year
1798, It was well and justly observed, by a
person who, I fear, had but too good reason
to know the real views of these societies, that
if the friends of freedom^ as he termed them,
could obtain the reform m parliament, which
they were then demanding, that, my lord, it
would immediately have been followed by the
abolition of monarchy, and the total over-
throw of our constitution. My lord, after
they had been dispersed by the magistrates,
thev had a meetine at the Cockpit ; and, my
lord, they ventured to declare to the public
at large, and to their fellow citizens, that
their sole and only object is, to overturn the
present happy constitution, which we now
enjoy. — The name which they assumed to
themselves, denotes, in the clearest manner,
that that was their sole object, for they as-
sumed the name of the British Convention of
the Delegates of the People, associated to ob-
tain Universal Suifraee, and Annual Parlia-
ments. It was well observed, yesterday,
that universal suffrage, at no period, bad ever
obtained in any part of the constitution, and
never could in any slate whatever, except one,
which b France, where it certainly exists at
present in its fullest extent; and ^om the
effects it has ]>roduced there, sure I am, that
we have no reason to try the experiment;
we have no reason to change the most perfect
system that, I believe, ever prevailed m any
nation in the world, fur that svstefti of despo-
tism under which that nation lies.
My lords, such being the object they had
in view, we must alt concur in that opinion
which your lordships have given ; — and, my
lords, that being the case, I must also concur
with your lord^iips in regard to the punish-
ment I think that no man,— I think the
panel himself, eannot think Itet that ptmiali*
ment is too severe; — he must recollect and
must know, tliat his crime is tipon the rtr^
of high treason. He was their secretary,—-
he was one of the secret committee, whose
duty it vras, in this convention, to name a
place for holding a committee of emergency,
m the event of an invasion from France.
My lord, after this, no man can thi^ the
punishment too severe. My lord, a Tery
little more would have been necessary for the
public prosecutor to have charged him with
nigh treason. As it is, I must concur in the
opmion which your lordships have given.
Lord Juatice Cierk. — My lords, I feel TCiy
much for the situation of the panel ; but, my
lords, we must not allow our feelings to in-*
terfere with the discharging of our -duty; we
must feel for the welfare of the country; and
what would have been the situation of the
country, if tliey had executed the scheme tiiat
they were meditating? My lords, I coidd
have wished, and it would have made me
happy, if he could have given a proper vindi-
cation of his conduct, so as to have got an
acquittal from the crimes with which he \s
charged ; and I should be very sorry to think^
that he suffers for want of the advice of coun-
sel ; but, my lords, it gives me a great deal
of satisfaction, that after the proof that was
heard yesterday, the ingenuity of no counsel,
Scotch or English, could have been able to
have satisfied an intelligent jury, that this
man was innocent of the offenoe charged
against him.
My lords, if he suffers for the want of
counsel, he must, I am sure, impute that to
himself, for he must know, that a man ar-
raigned at the bar of this cotn^t, whether be
has money to pay counsel, or whether he has
not, he need not go without, for thisComt
would appoint him one ; but it is very od(L
that he snould in place of applying to coimsel
here for advice, go to an English counsel,
whose place it is not to know the law of Soot-
land, and who, certainly, had very little btisi-
ness with it. — But he reads something to
teach us a little of the English law ; but tney
certainlv have no business with Scotch law,
and he being to be tried in a court of Scotluidy
by the laws of Scotland, ousht not to have
meddled in it ; and I am sure however able an
Enelish lawyer be may be, he knows nothing
of me law of this country, to say that a man
cannot be charged as being guilty, actor,
or art and part thereof. Nothing but a
total ignorance of the criminal law of this
country, could have caused such an observa-
tion.
My brother took notice of an act made in
the reign of James 6th, saying *^ that if art
and part is libelled, the generality of the in-
dictment shall be no exception." Before that
act, the prosecutor was not allowed to prove
any facts or circumstances but what were set
forth in the indictment, and this was attended
with very great inconveniences, tiecause iu
6011
A. D. 1794.
1:602
the course of evidence veiy often facto and
circumstances came out, wbich were even
stronflor than those libeUed. The legislatufe .
•f this country saw the moonvenience, and
thenitwas enacted in James 6th, ^ That the
generality of the indictment should be no ex-
ception ;" so that it is competent to the pub-
lic prosecutor to prove facts And circprastances
not mentioned at all m the libel.
As to tiie other part of the objection stated
by Mr. Skirvioff, as to the nature of the crime
of sedition, I think we should not be deserv-
ing qf the trust reposed in us, if he had this
day to seek into the nature of that crime,
when we have wtibtn these two months for
the same crime, passed sentence of transpor-
tation against two pereons, Mr. Muir and Afr,
Pahner. It is paymg a very bad oompliment
to the Court, after that, that we should now
be told, we do not know what we are doing,
and that we are yet to learn what sedition is.
I thought we were fully apprized of what se-
dition was, even before the case of Muir,
which was followed by that of Palmer. And.
I will say, that that opinion that the panel
just now read, is absura in itself, because if
acts of violence must be committed to make
it sedition, it is impossible that the crime of
sedition can be committed at all, because it
then ceases to be Bedition, it becomes hi^h
treason ; and if any act of violence had fol-
lowed these meetings, the consequence would
have been thus, that gentieman would have
atood there tried for his life, and the forfeiture
of his estates, goods^ and chattels, would have
iUJowed.
My kfds, as to the puni^Mnent to be in-
flicted, as I have always considered sedition as
Uie most daaeerous crime that can be com-
mitted, I think we cannot discharge our duty
to the country, unless we inflict for that crime
a severe pumshment. Mr. Muir was trans-
ported for fourteen years, and the only hesi-
tation in that case was, whether it should be
limited to fourteen years, or not. I have no
inclination to go beyond in this case, but I
think it is impossible we can, consistently with
the justice of tiie country, pronounce a less
sentence upton this panel, than we did upon
Mr. Muir.
My lords, it is an aggravation of his crime,
that with the example of Muir and Palmer
before him, if he had before that thought his
conduct was innocent, and did not deserve a
hijgh punishment, he was told by the judges
ofthis supreme ^court in that case, the nature
of the offence ; and any prudent man would
have taken care to have regulated his con-
duct accordingly, and ^iven over those rebel-
lious practices; but m place of tint, he
continues their secretary, and attends the Bri-
tish convention. And, my lords, I do con-
ceive, that if any more trials ofthis kind shotdd
happen in time coming, it is still a &rther ag-
gravation, that they have had not only the
example of Muir and Palmer, but ofthis man
also, and my opinion is, tlikt we cannot do
less than transport him for fourteen years^
and therefore I pronounce the same mter-*
locutory that was pronounced upon Muir and
Palmer in the same form of words.
m£ SCNTCKCB.
The lord justice clerk, and lords commissi-
•oners of justiciary, havii^ considered the
foregoing verdict, whereby the assize, all in
one voice, find the panel Guil^of the crimes
libelled : The said lords, in respect of the said
verdict in terms of an acst pasa^ in the 95th
year of his present majesty, mtituled, '^ An act
for the more effectual transportation of felons
and other offenders, in that part of Great
Britain called Scotland?'' ordain and adjudge
I that the said William Skirving be transported
beyond seas, to such place as his m^eety.
with the advice of his privy ooundl, shall
declare and appoint, and that for the space of
fourteen years from this date, with certifica-
tion to him, if, afier being so transported, be
shall return to and be found at large, within
any part of Great Britain, during the said
fourteen vears, without some lawful cause,
and be thereby lawfully convicted, he shall
suffer death as m cases of felony, without be-
nefit of clergy by the law of England. And
ordains the said William Skirvine, to be car-
ried back to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh,
therein to be detained till he is delivered over
for being so transported, for which this shall
be to alTooncerned, a sufficient warrant,
(Signed) Robekt M'Queev.
Mr. Skirving, Conscious of innocence, my
lords, and that I am not guilty of the crimes
laid to my charge, this sentence can only
affect me as the sentence of man. — ^It is long
since I laid aside the fear of man as my rule.
—I shall never walk by it. — And, my lords,
I could not be ignorant of this sentence, be-
cause I knew it long before this ; — and I had
a letter firom London this very morning, in-
forming me that such a sentence was to take
place.
Lord Juitiee CUrk. You heard that from
the counsel of London too I suppose.
Mr. Skirving. No, I told your lordships
that was a voluntary thing, I consulted no
counsel.
My lords I know that what has been done
these two davs will be rejudged ; — that is my
comfort, and all my hope.
In pafie 456, line 47, afler the word, resolu^
tious, should have been added the following :
— but being ordered to stand the last article
on the record of the proceedings of the con-
vention, we cannot insert it till the termina-
tion ofthis present session.
603} S4 GEORGE IH. Proeee£ngi agumi Mamicc Margarot [€M
597. Proceedings on the Trial of Maurice Mabgarot, on an
Indictment charging him ^ith Seditious Practices. Tried
before the High Court of Justiciary at Edinburgh^ on the
13th and 14th of January : 34 George III. a. d. 1794.*
]Vf R, Marfarot.\ — Clerk of Ihe court, where
is the lord justice general of Scotland^ I do
not see him iD his place.
* Taken in short hand, hy Mr. Ramsey.
t See tile preceding and following cases.
In the Gazetteer, No. 80, 1 find the following
article relative to this case :
^ The London Corresponding Society.
^ The London Corresponding Society, unit-
ed for the purpose of obtaining a thorough
parlkmentary reform, and thereby a restora-
tion of the British constitution to that deeree
of purity in which it was settled at the Re-
volution, having delestted two of their
members to represent tiiem in the General
Convention then sitting in Edinburgh for the
same constitutional purpose, the two said de-
legates, M. Marearot and J. Gerrald, aAer
having attended Uieir duty in the said Con-
vention, from the 19th November, until the
4th day of the present month of December,
both days included ; and during which period
the General Convention had thought it expe-
dient to assume the titie of the British Con*
vention of Delegates of the People associated
to obtain universal sufTraffe ana annual par-
liaments, were, on Thursoay the 5th of De-
cember, at seven o*clock in the morning,
taken out of their beds in the Bull Inn on
Leith Walk, by four men, armed with blud-
geons, headed by a sheriirs officer, who ac-
tjuainted them, that he had a warrant (which
he refused to show them, although desired to
produce it) from the sheriff, for apprehending
iheirpersons, and seizing all their papers.
* *' Tne Delegates submitted their persons,
but protested a^inst the illegality of seizing
their papers. — This protest beinz, however,
of no avail against men armed with bludgeons
and with warrants, all the papers found in
their room, whether belonguig to them or
others, whether left there accidentally, or de-
sdgnedly brought in, were, for conveniency,
thrown promiscuously into a small trunk be-
longing to M. Margarot, together also with
two pocket books ol his, containing bills to a
considerable amount, memoranoums, and
private papers, his property. This done, J.
Gerrald and M. Margarot again renewed their
•nrotest . asainst such usage; and the latter
locking the trunk, and putting the key in
his pocket, forbade the officer to remove it, as
otherways he should have to answer for so
gross a violation of the constitutional rights
of a British subject. i
Clerk,—! do not know where he is.
Mr. Margaret. — ^I hold that this court is
not competent to try me. My lords^ I am
** The trunk was, however, taken. The
delegates were kept confined from that hour
untilfive in the ahemoon of the same day,
without the least refreshment, and in a room
where there was not even a single chair to
sit upon. Between five and six o'clock they
were sent for to partake of a dinner prepared
by an order of the sheriff; and at seven
o'clock, M. Margarot being ordered into a
private room, he inquired of the sheriff in
what manner he meant to proceed ; and be*
ing answered, by interrogatory^ he told the
sheriff, that he would not submit to such an
unconstitutional practice; that if he had of-
&nded against the laws, he would answer lo
his country, but it should be openly.
" The following questions were then put to
him :
"Are you a member of the British Con-
vention ? — I do not acknowledge the legality
of a private interrogatory.
** From what place or district are you a de<*
legate to the saia Convention ? — As above.
** Have you made or seconded any motions
in the said Convention, and what was the na-
ture of those motions ? — As above.
*' [A piece of paper with some writinc upon
It, being shown him, he was asked]
" Did you make said motion in the Con-
vention last night, or upon any other day?^«-
As above.
*' The procurator fiscal then desired that
the followmg question might be put to the
prisoner : —
'* Did you come to Scotiand upon any pre*
vious invitation of any person or persons in
this country? — Before I reply to this uuestion
I must inquire of the procurator fiscal, whe*
tber it be criminal in Scotland for any persoa
resident here to send an invitation to any
person residing in another country ; or whe-
ther it be criminal in any such person resid-
ing elsewhere, to accept an invitation from
Scotland^ and repair hither ?
^To this Question the procurator fiscal
with visible emoaiTSssment^ replied, ' Sir, vou
' were brought here not to ask questions, but
« to answer them.' ' Then, Sir, (replied the
* prisoner), I do not acknowledge the legality
* of a private interrogatory.*
** Here the examination ended.
** But tiie procurator fiscal wanting to pro-
ceed to examine the papers contamed in
005]
Jbr SediHon*
A. D. 1794.
[60tf
died before the lord justice getferal of Scot-
bud, the lord justice clerk, am/ lords cominis->
eioners of justiciary. Now we know this is
tbe hie)iest court in Scotland ; we know there
Is no m^her office in Scotland than that of
lord justice general, and we know, that if it
was an unnecessary post, it would not have
9fiOOL a year salary, annexed to it,* and we
know that the indicUnent would have run be-
^>re our lord justice general, or lord justice
derk, because we know that the public pro-
secutor will in this case and in every oUier,
trumpet up much the constitution, and as the
constitution of Great Britain is founded upon
lavns and those laws can only be delivered in
woros, so the least variation of words in a
the trunk, M. Margarot was desired to give
up the key. He refused complying with
this request; and having asked whether the
sherifF acted under the sanction of a general
warrant. Being answered in the ne^tive;
and well knowing that the laws, even in that
case, were still in his iavour, and that the
papers of a Briton are by these very laws held
as sacred as his life, he told the sheiiiF, that
force alone could wrest the key from him.
** Hie prisoner was then admitted to bail in
9|000 merks.
** The following is nearly the substance of
J. Oerrald's examination before sheriff Harry
Davidson. He applied for a copy of it, but
was refused.
^ Are you a member of the British Con-
vention?— ^You ought to have known that
before you sent for me here ; that question
Aerefore I conceive to be unnecessary.
** From what district do you come, and
what description of persons sent you here? —
Decline answering. The persons who sent
me here, however, and the district in which I
was chosen, will be found mentioned in the
London Courier published towards the end of
October.
^ How long have you been in Edinburgh ?
— ^I cannot predsely recollect ; but imagine
it may be about a month or six weeks. I
came soon enough, at all events, to do the
business on which I was sent
*^ What was that business } — ^To procure.
by peaceable means, annual parliaments ana
universal suffrage.
^ J. Gerrald aeclined answering any further
questions.
** Bailed in the same sum.''
* It has been recommended by the select
committee on finance recently appointed by
the House of Commons, that af^r the termi-
nation of the existing interest in the office of
lord justice general of Scotland, the president
of the court of session for the time being,
should assume the title, rank, and privileges
of lord justice general, and that the salary
now annexed to this office should be discon-
tinued. See the First Report from the Select
Committee on Finance, ordered by the House
of Commons to be printed, Much 27th 1817.
law, is a total objection to an indictment. My
lords, it may be said there is precedent for it,
but it is a fundamental prindple, that no man
is to hold out his own laches. Why is he not
here to do his duty ? — If this innovation is
suffered, perhaps the attendance of the lord
justice derk* will be dispensed with, and the
attendance of the other judges; and at last,
perhaps, the clerk of the court, or even the
macers, will form the high court of justiciary,
so that by one deviation and another, even the
forms of justice will be done away. And, my
lords, we cannot say that there has not been
a precedent, where the lord justice general
has appeared in his place, thoueh perhaps
that was not to the honour of Scotknd, where
the duke of Argyle sat as lord justice genera),,
for the purpose of trying a man, one James
Stewart,t for the murder of a man of the name,
of Campbell, and the whole jury were Camp*
bells except two, and that was the onlv in-
stance where the Scotch have enjoy edf the
privilege of having the lord justice general
sit in their court. I deny even the compe-
tency of this court to ar^e upon, or maintain
their own competency, because it is the ser-
vant pretending to dictate to the master. As
well may it be said, we do not want a king,
as for the lord justice clerk to say, we do not
want a lord justice general.
I have met the laws, and I beg ^is may
be taken under your serious consideration,
for what I say this day will not be coi^ned
within these walls, it shall spread fitr and
wide, and will undergo a revision in both
Houses of Parliament in England. You al-
ready know that there is an impeachment
hanging over your heads — ^you know it is
shorUy promised to be brought forward. And,
my loras, I object upon another eround, in
the criminality of which you are all ioiplicat-
ed, for there is this difference between the
lieges and the judges, that a man is always
presumed innocent till he is found guilty;
but the moment there is the slightest impu*
tation upon a judge, he is presumed to be
criminal till his innocence is clearly proved.
A judge ought to be like Cesar's wife, not
only spotiess, but even unsuspected ; thiat is
not tiie case vrith you, my lords. We have
the promise of many men in England of great
respectability who will bring it forward, and
you may, though you are now sitting upon
that bench, be brought to atone upon your
knees, perhaps with your lives, for any infrac-
tion of the laws you may be euilty of. My
lords, we well know that Cambvses ordered
an unjust judge to be flay*d, and the skin of
that judse covered the seat of his successor.
We also know, that in the reign of Alfred,
(and I hold my authori]^ in my hand, and
the history of England will furnish it to every
* As to the office of lord justice clerk, see
Vol. 10, p. 989, note.
t Sec his case Vol. 19, p. 1, of this Collec-
tion.
607] 34 GEORGE UI* Proceedingi agaifut Maurice Margaret
^08
ODft) that, ia one year, forty-four judges were'
hanged *— and you will know the fate of Jef-
ferys, who, thoudi the alow hand of the law
could not overtake him, was torn in pieces by
the people.t I do not mean to say that ^ou
are guilty — that remains for a higher decision
than mine, at th^ tribuxud- where you must
soon appear, to answer for those actions
which ypu have ccHnmitted ; but you will re-
member, that there will be at that.dav a. mix-
ture of guilt and innocence— may the inno-
cence appear predominant; — ^I dO' not wish, to
be one or vour accusers on that day,
M^ lords, the objection that I have stated
it is impossible to get over, for that man is
remarkwly accurate, — I mean the public
proseoutory^^-and if it was not necessary, he
would not have inserted it I expect no
mercy from, him, neitlier shall I expect any
thing like mercy from the Court in the situa-
tion m which 1 stand, if what I have heard
be true.
My lords, there is another objection also—
I need lord justice deck and lord Hender-
land's testimonies, as exculpatoiy evidences :
I wanted to bring them' upon their oaths tO'
the bar, but though it is the privilege of an
Englishmas — of a Briton I mean, for I wish
the name of Englishman to be annihilated
in that of Briton — it is a privilege granted to
us by that constitution which is so loudly
trumpeted up upon every occasion, that a
panel at the bar, shall have the same com-
Ssory method of bringing his witnesses that
prosecutor has, that has been denied m^*
The man whose business it is to cite witnesses
said, he would attend in court, and give his
reasons why he did not dare to serve those
judges with a citation. It i» true. I mention-
ed only the lord justice clerk to nim, and I
cluu'MKi him to tell the lord justice clerk
thatT wanted his evidence, and I anprehend,
that you ara not competent to determine.
uoon this* obiection. I have obeyed the laws.
IJbisis not ue hi^di court of justiciary, inas-
much as it lacks tne centre stone— inasmuch
as it' lacks the piincipid officer of the court,
and the man wno here should reiu'esent the
king ; and consequently the wording of the
indictment is loose, and renders it null and.
voidL I have done my duty, and I demand
to be discharged from your bar sirapliciter.
Lord Juttic€ CUrh. — ^What do your lord*
ship^ say to this objection ?
Lord aeHderlanir-*^j lords, the objection
as I imderstand it, is, that the lord justice
general does not attend this court, and it is
even said) that we are not competent to judge
of the force and validity of that objection*
Why, my lord, ^th respect to that, if we are
not competent to judge of it, who is to judge
* See Vol. 8, p. 196, of this Collection.
t Not quite so. Jenerys died in the Tower
of London : see the anecdote concerning him
at the end of Tutcbin's case, Vol. 14> p. 1199,
of this Collection.*
of itf It is from tlie necesaitvp of th&igii that
we must judge of it — no other person caa
judge of it, and therefore I hold that obj^o-
tion to be null and void. With respect to the
attendance of the lord iustice general— by>
act of parliament) it is declared, that any three
of this court shall be a quorum to try any oriw
minal, consequently, though my lord justice
general is absent, and. even if your lordships
and I were absent, any other members of the
court, provided there are three, is a 1ml quo-
rum sufficient for the trial, therefore I am of
opinion that the objection should be repelled.
Lord Juttice Clerk. — Does any of your lord*
ships think otherwise ? — I dare say not. &»»
pel the objection.
[The objection repelled.]
Lord'Ju$Uce C/er/k^^You. will attend to thcr
criminal libel that is to be r»d against you.
Mr. Margarot.— Before that is read^ myt
lords, I claim another privile;^ which is, that
of having my witnesses called- over, and if
there are any who do not attend, I insist — I
demand^ I do not ask it as- a favoun—I de-
mand it — ^you are on the seat of justice^ and
take heed how you administer that justice—
I demand it as my right, tliat a caption bei
granted against the absentees.
Lord Eskgrove, — With respect to what Mn
Margarot has said of his witnesses, I dare Bay
your lordships would not hesitate at sending a
messenger to serve even your lordships, or
any man in the kingdom with a citation. L
hope it is not true, that the officer refused to
cite your lordships; it was his duty, and he
ought to have done it.
Lord Juttice Clerk, — Mr. Margarot, stand'
up and hear the criminal libel read against
you.
The Indictment read as follows :
George, &c. Forasmuch ajt it is humbly^
meant and complained to us, by our right
trusty Robert Dundas, esq. of Arniston, our
advocate,. for our interest upon Maurice Mar-
garot, merchant inMarybone, London, No.
10, High-street, residing or lately residing^
at the Black Bull Inn, bead of Leith Walk,,
barish of St. Cuthbert's and county of Edin-
burgh : that whereas, bv the laws of this, uid
of every well governed realm, sedition b a*
crime of an heinou^ nature, and severely pu*
nishable ; yet true it is, and of verity, that the
said Maurice Margarot has presumed to ooh^-
mit, and is guilty actor, pr art and part of said
crime: in so &r as, tbersaid Maurice Mar-
I garot having been named a delegate by aa^
assoeiation of seditious people, cafiiog.thein*
selves the Corresponding Society of London,
did repair to Edinburgh with the wieked and*
felonious purpose of joining and co-operatinr
with an illegal association of evil /liMMOsea..
• and seditiouspersons, who originally demned >
themselvea^ The General Convention of the
Friends of the People ; but who have of late i
sumed the designation of, << the British o
^* vention of the delegates of the people^
1
609]
Jvr Seditioiti
A. t). 1791.
[610
^sociaUid to obtuD uniTersal suffrage and
«< annual parliaments;'* and which illegal
association, under the names and designations
above mentioned, have been in the practice,
during the months of October and November
last, as well as in the beginning of the present
month of December, 1793, of holding var
nous seditious and illegal meetings, at a Ma-
sons' lodge, or room in Blackfriars wynd, in
the city of £dinbureh, and elsewhere, to the
public prosecutor unknown ; and which meeU
f ings, though held under pretence of procuring
a reform in parliament, were evidently of a
dangerous and destructive tendency, with a
deliberate and determined intention, to dis-
turb the peace of the community, and to sub-
^ Tert the present constitution of the country :
with wluch view they imitated both in the
form and tenor of their proceedings, that con-
vention of people, the avowed enemies of this
country, wno at present usurp the govern-
ment of France, and with whom Great Bri-
tain then was, and still is at war : that the
aaid Maurice Margarot, from his arrival in
Edinburgh, did, as a delegate from the said
Corresponding Society, in London, constantly
attend the ill^al meetings of the above-men-
tioned associations, and did co-operate with
tbem, on different occasions, and act as preses
or chairman of their meetings, and did take
«n active and distinguished part in their de-
liberations and proceedings ; and that while
the said Maurice Margarot continued to at>
tend the said ille^l meetings, as a delegate,
or was officiating m the capacity of presiaent,
as above mentioned, various seditious and in-
flammatory votes and resolutions were past,
some of which he moved, others of whicn he
seconded, and to all, of which he gave his
concurrence and approbation, by voting for
passing the same; and which seditious votes
and resolutions, as also the inflammatory
speeches that were delivered on those occa-
sions, by authority of the said meetings, were
inserted in minutes of their procedure, taken
at the time, and which afterwards by their
order, or under their authority, were publish-
ed in a newspaper, called the Edmburgh
Gazetteer of Tuesaay, November 86th, 1793,
being No. 78; of Tuesday, December 5d,
1793, beins No. 79 ; and of Tuesday, De-
cember 10th, 1793, bein^o. 80, all of that
paper; and were by that means circulated
among the lieges; that the said Maurice
]IAargarot did also, when attending in his
capacity of delegate at the illegal meetings
of the said association, utter and make various
seditious and inflammatory speeches, tendine
to vilify our present happy constitution, anid
to withdraw therefrom the confidence and
attachment of our subjects; and did like-
wise move resolutions tending to disseminate
the seditious and unconstitutional principles,
by which these meetings were actuated. And
particularly the said Maurice Marsarot, at a
meetine of the said convention, heldonTues-
dfj I9to of November last 1793, or on some
VOL. XXIII,
other day of that month, in a Mason lodge*
or room in Black- fnars wynd, in the city of
Edinburgh, did wickedly and feloniously make
the following motion, or one of a similar im*
port ; ** That previous to publishing an address
to the public, a committee be forthwith ap-
pointed, to consider the means, and draw up
the outlines of a plan of general union and
corporation between the two nations, in their
constitutional pursuit of a thorough parliameup*
tary reform." Which motion or one of the
same tendency, having been ajjproved of, was
passed unanimously by the said illegal asso-
ciation; and which motion clearly denxm-
strated a wish and intention, on the part of
the said Maurice Margarot, of propagating
the seditious tenets of that association over
the whole kingdom, and of exciting our sub-
jects in England, in contempt of legal au-
thority, to adopt the same unconstitutional
conduct, which the said Maurice Margarot
and his associates had presumed to follow.
And farther, on Monday the 25th of No^
vember, 1793, or on some other dav of that
month, another illeoal meeting of the above*
named association, Held at the aforesaid Ma-
son lodge or room, in fiUckfriars wynd, or
in some other place, to the public prosecutor
unknown ; upon a motion being made in the
following words, or words of the same import ;
^' That in case the minister^ or any other mem-
ber, bring into the House of Commons a motion
for a Convention Bill, as passed in Ireland,
for preventing the people from meeting ac-
cordmg to their just risbts b^ the revolution,
the same motion shall be noticed to the dele-
gates of the respective societies immediately
to meet in convention, to assert their rights; '
which motion having become the subject of
consideration the following da^, the said
Maurice Margarot did then wickedly and
feloniously utter and make the following
speech, or one of the like import and ten-
dency : '* This is an excellent motion, and the
event, which it alludes to, ought to be the
tocsin to the friends of liberty to assemble. It
seems however to be imperfect : it does not
mention any place of meetine, neither does it
specify the time when the deleeates are to as-
semble ; for the word immediately is indefinite,
and will not convey the same meaning to
persons residing in different parts of the
country. By those who live near to the place
of meeting it will be understood, that they
are to repair there next day. By those at a
greater distance, within a few days ; and by
those still &rther ofi", a week af\er such in-
formation is received. But the committee of
regulations have in their report an article of
the same purport, which, m my opinion, is
preferable to our firiend Callender's motion;
which, as this motion comes properly under
the chapter of regulations, I wish that it
were referred to that committee. I therefore
move that the report be read, that the con-
vention may judee whether the article I al-
lude to, sumcienUy provides for the intention
2 R
fli] 34 GEORGE IIL Proeee£ngs againsi Maurice Margarci £619
•f the motion now before the convention.
** I believe that the convention will be con-
vincedy that the clause of the report of the
committee of regulations, comprehends the
spirit and intention of citizen Caliender's mo-
tiony and also extends farther, inasmuch as it
fwovides for a mnnber of cases equally da^nse-
»ous to liberty, as a convention bill, it will oe
fbund also, that this business of calling a
meeting of the convention, had better be en>
trusted to a select coounittee, appointed tor
the particular purpose of watching every act
which may militate a^inst the rights of the
people. And I mamtam that the proper
place for this motion to af^pear, is among the
regulations of the convention.''
And further, on tiie 98th day of the said
nonth of November, 1793, or upon one or
•tfaer of the days above mentionea, the said
Sle^ and seditious meeting did, aAer dis-
tussion of the said motion, in the room or
Mason lodge, in Blackfriars wynd aforesaid,
wickedly and seditiously eome to the resolu-
ion of the following import amd tenor. ** That
this coBvendoD consioerinff the calamitoas
consequences of any act ot the leeislatnre,
which may tend to deprive the wh<Me or any
fart of the people of their undoubted right to
meet, either by themsehres, or by dele^ttion^
to discuss any matter relative to tlieir com-
xM>n interest, whether of a public or private
nature ; and holding the same to be totally
inconsistent with tne first principles and
safety of society, and also subversive of our
known and acknowledged constitutional li-
berties, do hereby declare, before God and
the world, that we shall follow the wholesome
example of former times, by paying no regturd
to an^ act which shall muitate aeainst the
constitution of our country, and shaU continue
to assemble and consider of the best means
by which we can accomplish a real represen-
tation of the people and annual elecUon, until
compelled to desist by superior force.
'* And we do resolve^
'' That the first notice |[iven for the intro-
duction of a convention bill, or any bill of a
similar tendency, to that passed in Ireland in
the last session of parliament;
** Or any bill for the suspension of tiie Ha-
beas Corpus act, or the act for preventing
wrongous imprisonment, and against tmdue
delays in triaJs in North Britain ;
^ Or in case of an invasion,
** Or the admission of any foreign troops
trhatsoever into Great Britain or Ireland— all
or any of these calamitous circumstances shall
Be a signal to the diiierent delegates^ to repair
to such place as the secret committee of this
convention shall appoint^ and the first seven
nembers shall have power to declare the
sitUngs permanent, ana twenty-one shall con-
stitute a convention, and proceed to business.
''The convention doth therefore resolve,
that each delegate immediately upon his re-
turn home do convene his constituents, and
txplgin to them the necessity of elecwg a
delegate or delegates, and' of establniiing tt
fund without deny a^nst any of these enei^
Sencies for his or their expense, and that they
o instruct the said delegate or delegates to
hold themselves ready, to depart at one hour's
warning/'
And further, the Saad Maurice Margarot did
at the said illegal meeting, af^r the aforesaid
resolution was so passed, wickedly, and foio*
niously make a motion in the following words,
or in words of a similar import and tendeacv :
'^ That a secret committee of three, and mt
secretary be appointed to determine the place
where such convention of emergency shall
meet : that such place shall remain a secret
with them, and with the secretary of thte con-
vention; and that each delegate shall at Hxt
breaking up of the present session, be in^
trusted witn a sealed letter, oontainins tfat
name of the place of meeting. This letter
shall be delivered unopened to his cotiSttto^
ents, the receipt of which shall be acknow-
ledged by a letter to the secretary* preserved
in Uie same state until the period shall artiva
at which it shall be deemea necessaiy for Ihe
delegate to set off-— which motion was unapi^
mooslv approved of.''
And further, the said Maurice Margsrrot
did, on Wednesday the 4th of Decenhcar,
1798, or on one or other of the da^s of tbgtt
month, or November preceding, m aaothet
illegal meetins of the above-ol^ed associa^
tkm, held at tne aforesaid Mason Lodge, of
room in Blackfriai's wynd, or some othef
place to the public prosecutor unknown, wick'^
edl^ and feloniously utter and make ttie folp
lowing speech, or one of a sunilar import and
tendency :
^< Your committee of regulations have n^t
been able to bring forwiard the remainder eif
th^ report this evening, they have not h«i«^
ever been idle, they have been employedf la
another manner in your servke. It hie
been observed that we admit spies under tiM
name of strangers. I say they are welcome;
and if the men, by whom they are employed,
were to come here, they should be welcome
also : for we have no secrets which we daore
not avow. But the intelligence which I have
to communicate, will show that those who
are not friendly to reforrti, and who have aA
interest in supporting the existing abuses^ are
usln^ every endeavour to put a stop to oetf
meetings. If they abide by law we are safo j
for they cannot deny that we are met for a
legal and constitutional purpose ; but as tte
people in power may take measmtes againtt
us not warranted by law, we ought to be pi^
pared. I have in mv hand the outhnes <5f A
motion which I would wish to propose inn
fhller house. However I shall in the mestt
time observe, that I am informed thene am
many men who are desirous of dispersing us
by force, we ought therefore to prepare a^dtt
suth dispersion. W^ have already Appointed
a secret committee^ for fixing a place of mecff*
ing OB certain emergfeiiciM) aod w^ ought Ht
em
Jir Sediiion*
A. p. 17M.
[«M
be equally well provided a^^nst the present
Gate; for if we shall happen to be dispersed
to-night, how or where are we to rally again ?
To do this your committee suggests a reaolu-
tion to Uie following e0ect; but which I
shall leave to be drawn up by the council of
the table: that the moment of any illegal
dispersion of the present convention, shall oe
considered as a summons to the delegates to
repair to the place of meetiilig, appointed for
the convention of emergency by the secret
committee; and thai the secrot committl^ is
instnicted to proceed without delay to &( the
place of meetinff. I hope that what has
been already said, will convince the conven-
tion that your committee of regulations,
though they have pot been able to bring
forward their report, have not neglected their
du^ ; and il will convince our encfuies that
we do not altogether neglect them, they will
see that we proceed with re{gularity» wad that
^ have an eye uPOn them while they have
spies upon us, I tnerefore move f^r l^ve to
baasL IB this motion— which motion after-
warns passed unanimousljr*'' — ^The said Mau-
rice Margaret, after moving the said resolu-
.tion, not only gave his assent to paas tbe
same, but allowed himself to be named one
of the four ooembcrs of which said secret oomr
jnittee wias composed, and agreed to act in that
capacity. And further, on Friday, December
6tn, 1793, or some other day of that nKmth,
the said iHegal aASodiation having again as-
sembled in a 1:00m or workshop belonging
to, or possessed by John Laine, wnght, situat-
ed in lad^ Lawson's yard, souiui si£ of Cross
Causeway, in the parish of St. Cuthbert and
Sheriffdom of Edinburgh. The sheriff sid)-
stitute of Edinburgh, with others his assist-
ants, having, in the discharge of his duty,
repaired to the said room or workshop, with
a view to disperse said illegal association,
the said Maurice Margarot, with others his
associates, did then and there resist the seid
jsheriff-substitute, and did peremptorily refuse
to disperse until forced so to do : that on this
OGoasion the said Maurice Margarot was call-
ed to the chair, and acted as preses or cluiir-
xnan -of the said illegal meeting, a(\er thve ap-
pearance of the sheriff substitute, and in open
contempt and de&ance of all legal authority,
vindicated the proceetUings of the moeting,
and peremptorily refused to leave the chair
unless compulsion was used : in consequence
of which the sherift-substitute was under the
iieoessity of taking him by tfie arm and puU-
ii)g him out of the chair, and of using toroe
in dUpersing thexest of his associates*, that
.this conduct of the said Maurice Margarot
wj«s highly araravai^ by this circumstance :
tJb^t the said lUecd asso<jation had been the
•very evening befone disnersed by the civil
rmagislrate. And the said Maurice Margarot
JUM^mg been .apprehended and brought before ,
ihny Oavidsoi^ esq. .shieciff substitute of the
aUce,pf Edinburgh* oiv the 5th of December,
^7P^» did ia lus ^pronencp emiia declaration
•f that date, which is signed by the said
sherifif-substitute, the said Maurice Margarot
having declined to sign ihe same ; and wfattQi
the said Maurice Margarot had been so ap»
pcehended, sundry papers havine been fbiand
m his possession, or claimed oy him, the
same were afterwards inspected in his pre-
sence, by authority of the sheriff of Edin-
burgh, and two several lists or inimitories of
those papers were made up, one of which^
containing ten articles, is subscribed by Wil«
liam Scot^ procurator fiscal of the county of
Edinburgh, and by Joseph Gerrald, of Uait-
street, BloomsjiNiry-square, London ; and the
other, consisting of nine articles, is subscribed
by the said WilBam $cott, and by the sheriff,
substitute -of Edinburgh as the said Maurice
Margarot cefused to si^ the same. Which
invemtones, together with the whole articles
thereof, except No. 1, of the first inventory*
as also the foresaid declaration emitted by
him befi»e the sheriff^ubstitute of Edin-
burgh; to^^ether with a paper signad by the
sain Maurice MarfHurot, and by John Wttrd-
law, quoted on the back, ** Motion of M. Mar-
gsrot,'' and signed by the said sheriff-^substi*
tute, as relative to the foresaid declaration;
9» also the scroll or draught of the minulfss
of the said general convention, firom the 39th
of October, to the 4th of December, 179S,
consisting of 95 paees; as also Nos. 78, 79,
and IK) of the Eoinburgh Gazetteer above-
mentioned, being all to be used in evidence
against the said Maurice Marearot, will for
that purpose, in due time, be lodged in the
hands of the clerk of the hieh-court of jus-
ticiwy, before which he is <» be tried, that he
may have an opportunity of seeing the same.
At least tinges and places above-mentioned,
the said acts of sedition were committed, and
the said Maurice Maigarot is guilty, actor, or
art and part XhereotT AH which, or part
thereof, beins found proven by the veraict
of an assi^ before our krd justice general,
lord justice clerk, sod lords commissioners of
iusticiary, in a court of justiciary, to-be holden
by them within the criminal court-house at
Edinburgh, upon the 9th day of Jaouery next
to come, the said Maurice Margarot, above-
complained upon, ought to be punished with
the pains of law, to deter others from com-
mitting the like crimes in all times coming.
Our wul is therefore, 4cc.
liiST OF Witnesses.
1 Harry Diuvidson. esq. sheriff-substitute of
the .GODOly of Edinburgh.
S William Scott, procurator-fiscal of the said
county of Edinbuigb.
3 James Williamson, elerk to the said Wil-
liam Scott.
4 Archibald Welch, derk to the same Wii-
liam $cott.
5 Joseph Made, writer in Edinburgh.
6 James lyon, iodweller in Edinbuigh.
7 John M'X>onald, indweller in Edinburgh.
8 Neil M^Giashan, indweller in Edinburgh.
615] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings agmnst Maurice Margarai [616
9 AVilliam Ross, clerk in the Gazetteer-office,
Edinburgh.
10 George B^ss, clerk in the Gazetteer-office,
Edinburgh.
11 Alexander Aitcbeson, student of medicine,
residing in Canongate of Edinburgh.
•12 John Clark, mason, in Edinburgh.
13 Alexander Bell, tobacconist m Canongate
of Edinburgh.
.14 Andrew Newton, formerly tobacconist in
Dunse, now residing in St Patrick's-
SQuare, Edinburgh.
15 Jonu Gourlay, watchmaker, in Edinburgh.
16 Alexander Reid, joiner and cabinet-maker,
residing in Edinburgh.
17 David Downie, goldsmith, in Edinburgh.
18 Thomas Cockbum, merchant, Lawn-
market, Edinburgh.
19 John Wardlaw, writer, in Edinburgh.
SO Samuel Paterson, merchant, in Lucken-
booths of Edinburgh.
41 John Laing, wright, in Nioolson-street,
Edinburgh.
S9 The right bon. Thomas Elder, lord provost
of the city of Edinburgh.
iiS Neil M 'Vicar, esq. one of the magistrates
of Edinburgh.
<S4 James Laing, one of the city depute clerks
of Edinburgh.
425 James Burnet, grocer, in Edinburgh,
preses of the society of constables.
-fi6 Alexander Frazer, grocer, one of the con-
stables of Edinburgh.
J. ANSTftTTTHER, A. D.
List of Assize.
John Grindlay, rectifier of spirits, Edin-
burgh.
James Gordon, brewer there.
John Howdeu, sadler there.
Thomas Hotchkis, brewer there.
5 Samuel Gilmour, ropemaker there.
James Clark, farrier there.
Walter Smeaton, painter there.
James Mill, tanner there.
James Clarkson, baker there.
10 William Murray, merchant there.
William Scott, plumber there.
Robert Norie, painter there.
William Smith, stabler there.
Robert Armstrong, plumber there.
15 Charles Robertson, printer there.
Andrew Bruce, merchant there.
Thomas Cleghom, coachraaker there.
Henry Farquharson, carver there.
John Balfour, merchant there.
40 John Saunders, shoemaker there.
John Baxter, glazier there.
James Dickson, seedsman there.
John Wilson, coachmaker there.
Robert Young, upholsterer there.
•£5 William Ainslie, saddler there.
John Scott, watchmaker in Edinburgh.
William Fraser, tinsmith there.
Gilbert Meason, merchant there.
Alexander Weir, painter there.
SO Henry Murray, perfumer there.
William Marshall, plumber there.
John Brougli, wright there.
David Steimrt, merchant there;
John Young, architect there.
35 William Pirnie, architect there.
James Bryce, painter there.
John Hay, banker there.
Samuel Anderson, banker there.
James M'Leish, bookseller there.
40 Robert Burns, architect there.
Macduff Hart, shoemaker there.
James Fowler, stationer there.
John White, merchant there.
Adam Dalmahoy, merchant there.
45 William M'Lean, merchant there.
Robert M'Queen.
Alexander Murray.
David Rae.
Lord Justice Clerk, — ^What do yoa say t6
this } Are you guilty of the charges contain-
ed in it, or not guilty ?
Mr. Margarot. — My Lord, guilt does not
stand at your bar at present.
Lord justice Clerk.-^Are you guilty or not
guilty? — ^You must answer that question.
Mr. Margarot, — ^I am not guilty ! but I do
not understand what is done with, the objec-
tion I have already made.
Lord Justice Clerk, — ^It is repelled.
Mr. Margaroi. — Oh! it is repelled, is it;
according to custom ? then I must make an
open declaration of my intention, to enter a
protest aeainst the proceedings of this Court.
Ijord Justice Clerk, — Have vou any thing
to offer as to the relevancy of the libel ?
Mr. Margarot, — With regard to the libel,
if any exactness is necessary in a cruninal
libel, it certainly is not relevant, and here is
one thing, that alone is sufficient to q[uash it.
But, my lord, I desired that rov witnesses
might be called over, in order that I might
have a fair and free trial, and that if any of
them did not attend, I might have a caption
granted by the Court ; and that is an objection
which is not to be done away so easily. I
have not heard the answer of the court to that.
Jjord Justice Clerk, — ^Have you any ar^-
ments to offer as to the relevancy of the m-
dictment? if you have, you must mention
them now.
Mr. Margarot, — If your lordships will give
me leave to state the objection about the
witnesses afterwards, then I say, this libel
states, that by the laws of this realm, sedition
ris a crime of a heinous nature. I beseech
your lordship, to point out the law which
makes sedition a cnme, and also, that which
, shows the punishment that is due to it I
understand some people think sedition so
well understood, as not to need explanation.
I differ from them : I say it is not merely the
authority of a judge that is sufficient; he
must lay his finger upon the law-book, and
point it out to the subjects that they may know
where to find it when they are not before the
tjudge. Is there any law in the British con-
stitution, which points out sedition,., and
^affixes the punishment to it?
617]
Jbr Sedition*
A. D. 1794<.
[618
My lords, in |mge three of the indictment
are these words, which I understand to be
taken from the Gazetteer. ** This is an ex-
cellent motion, and the event which it al-
ludes to, ought to be the tocsin to the friends
of liberty to assemble." In the Gazetteer it
is, " the friends to liberty"—- here it is " the
friends of liberty.'' Tlierefore, that is a ^w
in the indictment, which quashes it at once.
My lords, if you ^ according to justice,
these are valid objections ; but if you think
proper to repel them — if it is only to state an
objection, and as soon as stated it is repelled,
you may do as you think fit ; but, if I have
not impartial justice done me, I will sit
down, not make any defence, but desire you
^ disband the jury and pass sentence.
Lord Jwtice C^rA;.— Have you any thing
Hiffiher to say as to the relevancy?
Mr. Margarvt, — ^It is irrelevant in toto.
Then my lords, again, at the conclusion of
this libel, I come back with my first objec-
tion— I see it both at the beginning and the
end, and it is not a mere matter of form —
no act of parliament can do it away, or if an
.act of parliament can do it awajr, why is not
the letter, as well as the spirit of the act
naintuned ? It says here, all which, or part
thereof, beins found proven by the verdict
of an assize before our lord justice' general,
lord justice clerk, and lords commissioners
of justiciary. It says so at the beeinning —
it says so at the end. My lords, this is an
inaccuracy that cannot be overlooked — ^it
must not be overlooked ; and, as you thought
proper ta repel it in the first instance, I urge
It again in the second, it is a flaw in the in-
dictment. There are three flaws, which I
think sufficient to quash the indictment en-
tirely.
lird Juiiiee Clerk, — ^Have you anymore
objections to make?
Mr. Sdargarot, — ^No, my lords ; three are as
good as three thousand.
Mr. Solicitor' General. — ^My lords, in an-
swer to what has fallen from the panel, his
objections are so extravagant as hardly to
merit an answer. The only appearance of
any thing like a legal objection is this: the
gentleman says he is accused of sedition, and
calls upon us to point out where sedition is
made a crime, and by what law, and what is
the punishment ^xed to it My answer to
that IS, that sedition was made a crime not
by any statute, but by the common law of
' Scotland ; and if the gentleman wishes ibr
authoiity, I refer him to the book called
** Regiam Majestatem,'' where sedition is
exnressly stated to be a crime, and I would
tell him, that it is there declared to l>e pu-
nishable as treason. That is in the oldest
book that we have upon the law of Scotland.
Since that, sedition has not been punished as
treason, but renuuned upon the footing of
the common law, punishable by what is
called an arbitrary puni^ment. As to a de-
finition of seditioni your lordship knows
there are many crimes of so complex and so
vague a nature, that it is hardly possible to
give a general definition to comprenend them
all. If I am called upon to give a definition
of high treason, I do not know any that I
could give, except by enumerating all the
difierent cases of treason ; ur, suppose I was
called upon to give a definition of falsehood or
forgeiy, there are twenty diffierent kinds of it;
no definition can comprehend the whole. So
also, I imagine, it stancl s with regard to sedition .
At the same time, if a definition is wanted of
the crime charged against that gentleman,
I will read him Mr. Erskine's definition of it
in his first institute : he divides it into two
parts, real sedition and verbal sedition; he
says, real sedition is generally committed by
convocating together a considerable number
of people without lawful authority, under
pretence of redressing grievances, to the de-
stroying of the public peace. Then he says,
generalsedition is inferred from the convoca-
tion of a number of people without lawfiil
authority, tending to disturb the peace of the
community. Is not this the very crime
chained aeainst this gentleman ? if there was
any &wful authority, the gentleman will tell
us what it is. Can there be a doubt, that if
the facts stated in this indictment be true,
they not only tended to disturb the peace of
the country, but to subvert the constitution of
Great Britain. Therefore, taking the charge
as it stands, there cannot be a doubt wiUi
any one of your lordships, that it does
amount to a charge of sedition, and Uiat se-
dition is a crime punishable by the law of
this country. If there is any other country in
the world, where sedition is not made a
crime by the common law, I wish these gen-
tlemen, next time they hold British conven-
tions, would meet in that country, for in
Scotland, I will assure them, there is a law
to punish them.
Mr. Margarot.-^My lords, I hold in my
hand a definition of'^ Mr. Erskine's a little
differing from what the gentleman has read ;
he says, ** it consists in raisinj; commotions
or disturbances in the state ; it is either verbal
or real. Verbal sedition ur leasing makine,
is inferred from the uttering of words, tend-
ing to create discord between the king and
his people ;" and I think it is that gentleman
who is guilty of sedition, inasmuch as he
seeks to alienate the hearts of the subjects
from their sovereign He says, *' it was
iformerlv punished by death and the forfeiture
of goods,' but now either by imprisonment,
fine, or banishment, at the discretion of the
•judge.'' Now it seems to me, that that
cannot be the sedition which this gentleman
means, for, if I understand rightly, the sedi-
tion I am charged with is something like that
of Messrs. Muir. Palmer, and Skirving.*
Now if their sedition had been the sedition
that is meant here, they would have been
* See these cases in tbi3 volume, anii. '
619] 34 G^RGE JUL Proceedings nfpanU Maurice Margarot [620
out It 111MI9 liviQg under -Ibe British coDstitu-
tioi^ ft light to exwiine that constitutkiDy
aad tp m^y I am told, that it is the finest
iftstitution in the world* and yet I it^ my
podcet emptied daily with taxes: I fed my
JubertiBs taken away one after another; and
yet I must not meet with ray neighbours to
th<( number of twelve^ to disQuas Uiose iiyu-
ries that I daily feel, and to inquire ailer the
meana of obtaining redress, but immediately
com^ a crown lawver, daps the word sedn
4ion upon it^ and I am punished. Then
another man is chaiged with sedition-^My
ease is brought forwaid as a preoedent» and
tbereA»re he must be punished in the samie
wny. I eaor, my lord, if every artide in tins
libel is poofedff it ledounds more to my ho*
nour than aciy thing else : it shows me the
friend of ray qtecies ; it shows me the friend
of my country ; it shows that I have done
my duty as a good citiaen ; that I have en-
4(^v«um to procure that for every one of
my fdlow-sul^ects that it is our right to
^i^y; that i do not wish to eiyoy a single
thing alone, meitber place nor pension ; that
I do not wish to eiyoy an^ thidsig exdusively,
but I seek a MStitution of our nghts, a reno-
vation of our oonttitutiony as it is aaid heve,
by univonal suflrage and annual parliaraaits«
My lords, perkiSps your memories may
fail you, for it is some time back when Mr.
Pitt, U tho Thatohed House tavern, being a
young man, roakii^ his debut in parliament,
n youn^ palviot making his entsee inio tiie
W9nd, insisted upon a rdbnn. It was then
highly oonstitutiond. My lords, I have in
my hand a resolution entered into at the
Thatohed House tavern, on the 16th of May,
17dft: ^At a numerous and respectable
meeting of members of parliament, friendly
to a oonstilutional refoimation, and of mem-
bers of several committees of counties and
dtie»." Here, gentlemen, ynu see delegates,
here you see a conveotion, though a conven-
tion is nothing new in Soodand ; because you
have had tiie borough reform convention,
and the lord advocate is hirasdf upon ^t
list My leids, at the Thatched House tar
vem were present the duke ^i lUchmond,
lord Sun^y, lord Mahon, the lord mayor.
Here you see amongi&t Ihem the first rauni-
punished by banishment wd notbytnm-
portation; and therefoije 4hve nuist be some
trifling mistake in that, my lords. Now it
says here, " for preventing riots apd tu-
mults it is enacted, tliat if any persons to
the number of twelve sbaU assemble, and
being required by a manstrate or constable
to fhsperse, shall nevertbdess continue to«
gether for an hour after sudi command, the
personsdisobeying shall suffer death.'' There*
fore that cannot be the sedition that I am
charged with, for the indicteent only pre<-
tends to know, what I am sure the Ahnightgr
never commissioned the lord adwooaHe to
inauire into, namely, our secret intentions.
I did not know before that there was an io-
<|uisition in Scotland, and lh«t be was gnmd
inquisitor; £v certainly, otherwise, the minds
of the people are only to be gslheied Aom
their behaviour.
« My lords, these nieetingp, I will maintaio*
were legd in tfaestridteat sense of the wnid ;
fiMT the claim of rights entitles the people to
petition parUament J and it is impoasiUe they
^ could petition parliament without meeting.
The general will cannot be cdlected as you
collect taxes from door to door. Good God \
what is become of the ooaetitutlen that you
trumpet up so much, if you give us the
name and take away the essence? if the
poople are net to meet to examine their
rights, and firoceed upon their rights.
My lords, there is not one so barefaced,
as to pretend to deny our right to f«tition
or address the king. The lord advocate him-
self has acknowledged that it ,is our right.
He himself is a reformer, and has heU sedi-
tious meetings as well as we ; but then in-
deed he brings forward a curious reason:
when the lora advocate is out of ]>lace, rn-
fi>rm is proper ; when in place, it is l^^y
improper; and that is the doctrine ofMr.
Pitt. Because we are poor, it is sedition in
us: but when your county meetings are
held, it is no lonser sedition, but it is a thing
that is authorizea. As long as they thouebt
we were not sufficiently fiMraaidable, and that
there was no danger of opening the eyes of
the people, so long did justioe nod ; zM she
only awoke when every man, hearing so
much tdk of the constitution, begvi to
examine what that constitution wea. And.
to be sure, it is a qurious fiction in law (and
you have a great many) by whj^ our bsppy
constitution has wiseljv guarded the pnsae*
cutor for the crown; by which meaos Hm
subject mav at any time be oppsessed fuid
persecuted d^ the officer of the crown, and
he can obtain no damages, no redress what-
ever. Happy if he gets off, happy if his
sentence does not come out of the pocknt of
a minister of state. My lords, our tianaac-
tions have been leg^l. The illegal actions
have been entirely on the part of our prose-
cutors. We have experienced the fitte of
general warrants, we have experienced the
fate of a jBtate in^pnaitioii. Good God! has
dpal officer in Eiwland, the load mayor, sir
Watfcin Lewes, Mr. Duncomb, air Cecil
Wray, Mr. Brand HolUs, Mr. Withecs, the
•hon. William Pitt, whom I mean to adduce
m an meulpatory evidence, ii nven the forms
of justioe aie allowed me-*the rev. Mr.
Wj^l, m^jor Cartwright,* Mr. John Home
Tooke,t sidermwi Wilkes,t Dr. Jebb^ Mr.
«» See the case of Danid Holt for a )^^9
^^l Vol S8, p. A 198.
t See his Uial lor a seditimis . Ubeily 4i«<c
Vol. 30, p. <)5l, of this Collection, and his
trial for htth to^ason, a* b. 1794, pMf.
]: SeiB lus jQBflCis in Vd. X9f of tbb Coir
Itctina,
621]
Jot SedUion*
A. D. 1794.
[622
Chuitfatn, Mr. Frosty* &c. &c. afi men of
Jwning, who wiell knevr what th^ cottstitti*
tion of this country is, and what it* oo^t 16
be — men who required not to botoloilfeMI
waa sedition and what not^^men who wddd
not h«^e risked themseWes if they had not
known that they were uj^on eonstitutioBal
ground, and they resolvo, *' That the motion
of the hon. William Pift, on the rth inBtant>
for the fR>pointanent of a oomniitle^ of the
House or Comtnons, to inottip^ Mo the
stirte of the representation or die people of
Grest Britain, and to repoi^Hie dame w the
House ; and also what steps H might |ke nc^
cessary to take, having bc^n defeaii^ bv a
notion for the order of the da^''*^which is
somethhig sinrilar to your repelling an objc^-*-
tton of the pamel, as soon ad iff is steten —
** having beki defeated by a esotion lor tht^
order or the day, it is bec^onte itfdrspensably
necessary that applieation shouldf be made to
parliainent, by petitions from the collectit^
Dody of the people in their respectsve dis-
tritttSh'^ They were not to peur into ^
Houses ei^ tfillk^ of pi^titibns, buv as
muDf pentioAs ffom as many districts as
they ootdd cOlfect together, <' te^utestiA^ A
ei^iantial re(bftnatk>il of the Cottunoi&d
tkfme of PorHafnent.
^ Besohed imaliinioti^y, ThM tbhf m^t^
itt^ oonstAttiNj^ thttt «k jgiMhH fitM>liea!lion,
bv the collective body Of the people, to the
Housfe of CoMMnons, canndt bef made^ before
the clobe of the phi^senf sesston^, is df opt'^
Aseff tlttt <he saise of ^e pedpte should h6
taken.'' And how is IhO'^n^ of Ibe pei^ple
to be ttMm. I wonld aUB tlM foartkicr ^ntKe-
ifM»of the law, 9f they ttve not donteHed f
•^Wbo iis ter take the stttfiie of the people^ if
il is to be ddne by gding round fma ttOA to
man, and if twelve fbnn « ^itk)ue ttieeto
kig, H will come, by-apd-hi^, peiHi^e' to two
or three, and it will be dBngerous for one
Aeighbonr to speak to another is t(ie sffeet,
ct any where else ihd«ed, ** that the sense of
the people should be talnsn stt such times as
Biay be convenient do^lhg this stnnmer, in
Older to lay their several petitions befote
fartiament, early in the next session, with
their proposals fbr a parliafflentlo^ reformat
tiony**~^bserve this, then of 6coti«nd!--
Obeerve this, Britons ! " wifliout t^hkh, nd-
ther the liberty of the nation ean be pre*
served, nor the permanence of a Wise and
virtuous administratien can be sectu^,'' and
I appeal to you all whethet there is nbt truth
and sound doctrine in it, ^' may receive that
ikmple and mature discussion Whidi so tno^
nentous a question demands.*
My lords, it seems to Imvti been in the
year lt8« a vety laudable and a VeJy consti-
tntional Ihing to assemble, to pseet tb con-
aider of the grievances, and to pton a meUiod
* See his trial ibr seditions wovds. VoL
49, p. 471 ^f this Colleaion.
by which thev weM to be redressed. In the
year ITW, when the very man who planned,
who iirst suggested this, who encouraged the
people thereto, imder his reien, I may call it,
for he is the guide of the hehn— the gnkle in
the cabinet, while he is in absolute power ;
thai shall be considered as sedition which he
himself first set on foot, in order to procure
himself that birth ; and, now he has got it,
he has alto^ed his sentfments-«-How rid^-
IMS for a crown lawyer to attempt to impose
upon a court of justice ; or for any man to
Mppott such imposition, that what was con-
stitutienal in 1782, should be criminal in
f7ff*.-^FdIow-citizens, and I fear not to call
yon by that liamle — we are fellow-citizens of
one society. By the word citizen I mean a
hffe man, a Wstsi enjoying all the rights and
aH the ^mleg^s, ana paving his quota to-
wards all the expenses of society; I say it is
aft insolent attempt upon your understand-
ings, to ^ndedvour to persuade yon that that
WMcn wa6 constitutional, that that which
tris ri^ht, that that which was justifiable in
t78Y «nro«dd be criminal in t794. It is tme
that an Enj^sh jury has sent to prison a man
fe# oniy reprinting those resolutions, fio)^
I Mnk his name is, the printer of the New-
81^ Jotimal, for reprimting in his papef^
wfeidh pays a daily tax to government, Vastk
#hi<^ the person to whom he pays ihe tax was>
the aathov of.* Thus y<m see how cfowtt
lawyers pervert the eonstitutkm. With higb
sounding words they disguise the most inno--
cent fkcts ; iStev sport with the fives, and
^rtfh that whidi ought to be infinitely mom
Aestf ^aen their tfveaiL-^ith the liberties of
his' fiuyesiys 8td>jeetl Men who feei wranga
eannot foel them without some degree of
iertmony, and when those wronga are rcK
peated, Uns acrimony must increase * and
these wrongs are done them in the king**
name ; but it is not the king, it is his ser-
vaMs who m^e use of his name ; his sedi-
tions servants who separate the king from his
people. My Imds, I know my doom. I am
a willing and an already devoted victim. I
have made objections, those objections have
been repelled. I shall insi^ presentiy on tiie
calling over of my witnesses. I shall then
demand a caption against such as do not
M^ear. If my just, mv legal, mv constitu-
fK>nal demimds afe repelled, 1 will- sit down;
I will beg the gentlemen of the jury not to
gji«re themselves any farther trouble; Twill
protest against the proceedings of the Court,
and beg of them to pass to sentence; which
I know it will be no difficuH matter for them
to do.
Lord F«nifer/rtfitf.— My lords, we are cftBed
upon to decide npon the relevancy of this in-*
dictment, which charges in the mtiot propo*
sition, that the crime of sedition, in this and
11' nn ~i wtn ~'' -"-^*^^*^
•*■«'
I
* Not so; see the note to the case of
Daniel Holt, Vol 2?, p. 1198 6t this Col-
lection.
623] S4 GEORGE III. Proeeedingi agaiiut Mttiarke Margarot
[694
every other well governed realm, is a crime
of a heinous nature, and severely punishable.
And, my lord, the first part of it (to which it
might be sufficient to confine myself at pre-
sent) charges that this society, calling them-
selves the mitish Convention of Delegates of
the People, met under the pretence of reform,
that it was of a dangerous and destructive
tendency, and was with the deliberate and
determined intention to disturb the peace of
the community, and to subvert the present
constitution of the country : and that this
gentleman, Maurice Margarot^ did take an
active and distinguishing part in their delibe*
rations ; and consec^uentfy, that he took an
active and distinguishing part in the deli-
berations of a society, met with a determined
purpose to overturn the constitution ; that is
the charge, true or false it is not our province
at present to inquire, that must be left to the
jury. The criminality does, to be sure, con-
sist in, that they met with a determined pur-
pose to overturn the constitution ; and the
jury, when they come to decide upon it, must
take into their view the several thmgs charjged
in this indictment, relative to this meeting.
As to the form that they assumed, how far
that was necessary to obtain a reform in par-
liament, it is the province of the jury to in-
quire ; and under all the circumstances of the
case, to lay their hands upon their heart, and
upon their great oaths to say what was the
purpose of that meeting, according to the
^cts before them. My lord, if that is made
out, which is the charge, and in considering
the relevancy I am bound to hold the charge
as proved, tnere cannot be a doubt that it
amounts to sedition. I say it approaches to
high treason; and I find in \he cases tried in
England, in 1745, as appears from Judge
Foster's report, the charges laid a^nst the
prisoners were very little different from those
contained in the present indictment.* It ran
in these terms : *' Also devising and as much
as in them lay, most wickedly and traitorously
intending to change and subvert the rule ana
government of this kingdom, duly and hap-
I)ily established under our present sovereign
ora the king, and also to depose and deprive
our said present sovereign lord the king of
his title,'' and so on. Now, m^ lord, the
chaige is, that the purpose of this meetinj;
was to 8u))vert the constitution ; and if it
was, where can the doubt be, that it does
amount to sedition i My lord, the gentleman
requires a definition of sedition. My lord, I
leave it to the sense of every man who hears
me, if an intention to subvert the constitution
of a country is not sedition. In matters of cri-
minal law you must go by the understanding
and the sense of mankind, and in . this in-
stance particularly the jury are to determine
upon the law as well as the fact.
My lord, with respect to sedition, it is of
* See the iadictment in the case of Francb
Towiiley, Vol, 19, p. 333 of thisCollectipn.
various kinds ; no doubt its general tendency
is to resist and undermine, or attempting to
resist and undermine the constitution ot the
country, and subvert the supreme power of
the state. It mav either be of a public or a
private nature. When of a private nature, it is
directed against matters of a private life, it
may be in direct opposition to acts of par-
liament, with respect to inclosures, division
of commonalties, turnpikes, and so on. But
of a public nature is the crime which is
charged against this gentieman : an intention
to subvert the constitution. My lord, sedition
mav be attended with tumult or without:
with rising in arms, or without rising in arms.
My lord, sedition of a public kind, is as va-
rious as the ingenuity of wickedness can sug-
gest It may be committed bv words, by
writing, by painting, by medals, by allegories,
by actions, by false insinuation, by false ar-
gument, by tumult and insurrection, by mobs,
by cabals, by open and secret meetings ; by
conspiracies and by conventions. If the jury
are satisfied in their minds that the intentioit
of this is to overturn the coostitution, it is
sedition. My lord, it was said that there was
no law aeaunst this. As to tiiat, my km),
every welT-resulated government roust make
it sedition ; because otherwise society could
not exist. It always has been, and must re-
main a common law crime, and must be pu-
nishable bv common law.
My lord, having said so much, I think
there can be no doubt that the libel is rde-
vant. The panel is at liberty to state what
he pleases in his defence. To insist it was for
a partial reform by legal means, and that no-
thing else was meant by this extraordinary
guise that this convention took upon them-
selves to assume, the juiy will upon tha
whole judge whether his defence or whether
the charge is relevant. In the mean time it is
my humole opinion that it is relevant.
Lord Eskgrove, — ^My lord, as to the crime
of sedition, I caniK)t read the indictment, nor
I think any body else, and say that if this
man was concerned in holding these meetings
for the purpose of disturbing the peace of the
community, and subverting the constitution
of the country, that that is not the crime of
sedition. My lord, it is not the province of
such men as these, to take upon themselves
the amendment of the government. The in-
tention of their meeting, thejr say, was to ob-
tain universal suffirage; or in other words,
to establish that every man living in this
country is to have a vote to choose a repre-
sentative in parliament ; a thing that never
did obtain, and that does not now obtain,
and never can obtain in this country. But,
my lord, it seems that if an act should take
J>lace for the purpose of suppressing such il-'
egal meetings, tnat this is to be their tocsin,
and their alarm-bell for the purpose of meet-
ing, when, where, or how, is to be kept a
deep secret — ^it is not to be divulged eipen
among themselves; but it was to be confiiMd
9m
Jor$ediiion,
A. a 179*.
[OBS
^ tlii^ gemtem^A, and two ^ tbr^e iqore*
IprhQ WW^tQ call a cpnye^Atiox) of ^wu^rg^a^y
aii4 ^W wcsr» Iq oomnu^ to a^sembl^ 8MA<1
%o| W obev such 1^1, if it should pa^s.
I^y Iprd, if the chturg^ ia ibis iudictioeot are
prQnedy i^ is impossibly to d^ny my as»^v^^
ibu t^y do in&r th« crim or stisduiou. I
am of opinioD that this libel is rele^vaoUy laid,
I simtt be 9](p4$edipgly happy if Uiis giootle-
inaa i^ ihund ionocent; mtXi that Ue$ with
ttiue jiy7y a^d not with us.
JifJi Smtiiif9'r—My lord, the q^^sAioa t\i«t
is pqlw uuder our consideration is, whejtber
this lib^ ifi relevant to iufer the pains of law.
Andy my lord, it has been so fully discusi^,
not oiniy al this time^ hut upon the occsr
aion of a very late trial, thajt it is perfectly
iMUMcesevy u> eo over the ground «ig»in that
i^ b^n alrea^ ^ne over. But, my loxdy
in Uus case the mdictment stat«, that a mo-
^nn wa9 made upon which the JP^^ s»ys,
^ thi» is an excellent motion. The event
which it alludes to, ought to be the tocsin for
ihe fiends of liberty to assemble." M^ lord,
this is a very iU-chosen word. Whal is this
tocsin i It 18 an Instrument made use of by
fh0 people in France to assemble. It Is bor-
rowed from a pls^ from which I would wish
lo hprcow very little. For what purpose
are they to assemble? They say to assert
thmr eights. Qy what means?— Can any
V^u he at a loss to make the answer?*-By
violence and outrage, and no other internre-
taAion.can be given to it. My lord, after-
wards a proposal is made for a sealed letter
to. be given .to the delegates, which was not
to be opened till a certain period : like an
order that is sometimes given to ships when
they wl, that they are not to open their in-
afcructions till they come to a certain latitude ;
imd the meaning is, that those instructions
ahall not be known, (or fear they should be
pieesentBd. There can be ^o other reason ;
and yet they afterwards say, we make no se*
ereks of any thing. Then there is a resoiu-
timv that this convention, considering the
calamitous consequence of any act of the le-
gislature, which may tend to deprive the peo-
ple of. their undoubted right to meet, declare
nefore God and the world, that we shall follow
the wholesome example of former times, by
paying no regard to any act which shall mi-
lit^ against the constitution of our country.
is not oiis declaring that they will oppose the
legislature itself? My lord, it does not re*
^mre a^y proof of its being sedition. Then,
my lord, among other cases of emergency, in
amioh they were to meet, it is mentioned,^
f^ or in case of an invasion.'' My lofd, for
phat purpose were .they to meet privately, in
nase of an invasion? The legtalature, the
•leeutive part of government is to look after
abat. J&very man mustfoel what they meant:
that they should assemble the delerates ^Uh
gjsthsr at a partkular time, and all at one
4imm itiey should meet, i^ case of an invasion.
Mydnnlyl^ve.my apntimwitavery fidly this
VOL. XXIII.
day pe'nnigibt uppn the same queation, and I
have not altered theip, but feel them strongec
and stronger. I am sorry to see so many ex-
amples brought before us, and I hope there
will be but few more; I am of opinion theft
t)ie libel is relevant
I/;)rd Vufuinnan, — ^My lord, the on^ ques^
tion at present for our consideration is, wW
ther the libel is relevant, and is laid pjmperly.
My lord, the ms^or proposition states the
cnme of sedition ; tP,e minor pxoposition
specifies a variety of circumstances, which, if-
tney come up to the crime of seditk>n, the
libel Fs relevant ; and, my lord, I have hut
one doubt upon this subject; and that is,
whether in some of these particulars it is any
thiujg short of the crime of high treason ; but
I thmk that it amounts to sedition, there oao
l^e no doubt ; and I think that the ordinacjt
interlocutory ought to be pronounced.
Lord Abercrwnbie.-'My lord, in this case,
as to the objections to the relevancy it is the
province.of the jury to inquire into the iacte
charged ; and if those facts are brought home
to this panel, — ^particularly, the resolutions, —
if they are brought home to him, I think the
necessary conclusion is, that he is guilty of
the highest species of sedition that can pos-
sibly bo committed. I am of opinion that itie
libel ought to be found relevant
Lord Juiticc Clerk.'^My, lords, I think it
very unnecessary to add any thing tp what
your lordships nave said; out I think any
man who knows any thing of the law of Sco^
land ; or that has the least understanding,
must think that the one hiUf of what 19,
charged here, if true, does amount t9 sedition;
and therefore I have no doubt in pronouncing
the ordinary interlocutory, that the libel 3
found proven to the knowledge of an assize is
relevant to infer the pains oflaw which the
jury will attend, is only an arbitrary punish^
ment, and allowing the panel to prove aU
iacts and circumstances that may tend to ex*,
culpate or alleviate his guilt.
Mr. Aforgnroe.— My lords, I may now put
in my former claim, of having my witnesa^a
called over.
Idird Jtutic0 ClerL — Surely both prosecu-
tor and panel ought to see that their wit-
nesses are all here. Let the macer go now
and see if they are here.
Mr. Margarof. — And likewise that tlie
Court and tus people at large mi^ be informed
the reason why I hi^ve not the privilege oi
lutving you as an exculpatory evidence, in
consequence of the fear of the messenger to
deUyer such a summone to you; that is »
thing proper to be known.
Lord Juttice CUrk.—li you have any thing
that it is necessary for me to prove> you shall
have the benefit of my testunony, and you
shall not want it neither.
Lord Abtravmbie,-^! am sure if the me^t
senger has refused to cite your lordship, he
has behaved most improperly. .
Mr. Margaret. 1 ^h|nk his name is Hoj^
S S
627 J S4 6EORGBIIL. Trooeedingn^innH Mauriee Margaroi [jGS8
cheeon ; he said he would be readv in court
to give a reason why he refused to do it.
[The interlocutory of the Court read.]
Mr. Mmrgarot, Tnere is likewise another
ihhig : you did not take notice of the two ob-
jections to the wording of the indictment,
which are material flaws. Your lordships have
not «aid a word to that.
Lord Justice Clerk,— The Court have con-
sidered all you have said, and they are of opi-
niouy upon the whole, that the libel b rele-
vant.
Mr. AfarfaroC.— -Here is the list of my wit-
nesses, my lord.
[The messenger was called, but did not appear.]
Mr. Margaret, — You will be informed, that
some of my witnesses live in England, that I
have had the exailpatory letters served there,
with what is called a subpoena in England,
and the affidavit at the back of the exculpa-
tory letters, now in the hand of the clerk of
the court, shows that they have been cited in
a legal manner, and therefore, as they are
material witnesses, I wish the list of them to
be called over.
(The list being called over, the following per-
sons were absent]
Duke of Richmond John M^nth-e
HeniyDundas* John Wright
WUliam Pitt
Lord Justice Clefk.-^As to the three that
reside in England, this Court cannot go be-
yond their jurisdiction : they cannot compel
any witness living in England to appear here;
and therefore a caption a^unst witnesses re-
siding in England is a Uiing altogether in-
competent and unheard of.
Mr. Margaret. Your lordship's objection
is not valid, as will ap|)ear to yourself, upon
reflection, inasmuch as if you are not compe-
tent to give a second citation, you were not
competent to the first. On the contrary, it
appears that the letters of exculpation found
no difiiculty in beins; backed by a judge in
England, and the subpoena was served upon
them according to the laws of England | and
therefore, by a second diligence, they will be
pursued in'^the same manner; and that will
be backed by a judge, and the same compul-
sion will be exercised upon them in Eng-
land as would be in Scotiand, if they resided
here. — And, my lord|, I w'di not permit this
to be passed over easily, they are very mate-
rial evidences— they are men of high station
in tiie state — ^they are men of great responsi-
Ability— they are men whose actions are pub-
lic, and the questions that I mean to put to
them' are of a very important nature. — ^There
is again another thing — ^it seems you over-
look some things and pry very closely into
others — it seems you are not competent to en-
ibrce thie attendance of a witness firom Eng-
* Afterwards Lord Viscount Melville. See
)iis ease, A. D. 1806| post.
land, bat it appears, by the libel, tfaatyoir
are competent to try oflfences oommitlea in
England. My lord, mete with an eaiud mea-
sure—let my objection be attendea to in a
proj^r manner. — It is a legal objection founds
ed m justice, and justice cannot deny it«-^
Grant me a caption for ny absent witnesses:
I demand it.
Lord Henderland, — My lords, if witnesses
resided in Scotland within our iurisdiction,
and did not attend, a caption mignt be granW
ed^ bat my doubt is, whether it is competent
to the Court to grant a second diligence, be^
cause in this case it must be altogeuer rniga*
tory.
Lord Eskgreioe. My lords^ — I do not know
an instance existing, eitiier in the civil or ctW
minal courts, of a warrant being granted to
bring a witness from England : to apnrehend
him oy habeas corpus, that is the only juris^
diction we can exercise. My lords, I under*
stand in England it is not an easy matter to'
obtain witnesses, before their own courts ; but
of that I profess myself ienoraiit ; but I Imow
of no instance in which this Court have taken
co^izance of the non-attendance of witnesses
resident in a foreign country; for £i)jgland,
with respect to the law, is as jnuch a roreign
country as Germany, Italy, or any other
coantry.
Lord Swini&n. — By our laws we cannot grant
a caption against a witness from a foreign
country, ana we cannot go beyond our power.
It is clear to me, that it was not onr finilf
that they did not attend — as to .those that are
lawfully summoned here, we can lay a fine
upon them.
Lord Duneinnan, — ^My lords, this Court
ought not to be treated with contempt, and
therefore your lordships would be careful to
issue no warrant- that you cannot enforce.
The authority of this Court cannot «> beyond
their jurisdiction, which b confined to Scot*
land.
Lord Abercrombie, — By the laws of this
country we have no authority ovei persons re-
siding in any other country.
Lord Justice Clerk, — We cannot possibly
differ upon this matter : — it is a downright w^
surdity, to issue a second diligence against
witnesses residing in another country. — ^I ana
sorry for it ; but ne has got a fair trial by the
laws of this country w — Am as to what dropped
from the panel just now^ he must be veij
much mistaken, if he thmks he is tried for
a crime committed in Engkmd >-^that is bj
no means the case ; he is tried for what he
did after he came to this country. But it was
very proper, in order to show the intention
with which he came here, to state the fad^
that he came as a delegate from a cenventioB
of the same kind in Engrland ', but it is for tha
crime that he committed in this coimtiy alont
that he now stands at the bar.
Mr. Margarot, — My lords, I do not i^
qiure the forms of justice, I require the es-
sence of jo8tice,*^t seems that a panel is v^
«S9]
Jbft Stt&noii*
A. D. 1794.
[630
titled to the tame compulsory method of ad-
diiciDfl; witnesses in his favour, as the prose-
cutor has to adduce evidence against him. —
Now general warrants liave been issued to ad-
duce evidence against me :— general warrants,
I say it, have been issued to adduce evidence
acainst me. — ^Now I demand nothing more
than the regular forms of the Coun, that
your caption may be granted, and see whe-
ther they will obey the laws of their country
or not — ^And I am sonv to hear it come from
the bench, that it would be nugatory; which
implies, that there are men in England above
the law. — ^Look to it my friends; — where is
your boasted constitution ? — If the first man
in England is not as amenable to the laws of
lus country as the meanest of you, you are
slaves.
lard Justice Clerk, — Yoy oome here to
«peak to the Court, and not to harangue the
miobi
Mr. 31argaroi, Do you call this audience
a mob, * my lord ?
Lard Justice Clerk* — ^You are not to ha-
raneue the multitude.
Mr. Margarot.'^l understaad that the
judges havehanto^ed the multitude too, and
they have gone mto a series of accusation
afamst me, which I did not know was a part
of the duty of a judge, who ought Jut dicere,
noi iui facene. It has been said too, that
England is as much a foreign country as Ger-
many or Italy; — that I do not understand; —
if this country is as foreign as Germany — Do
not talk, for God's sake, of the English con-
stitution; it does not belong to you — It is
your duty, my lords, to grant me in the whole
what you offer roe in part. — As to those that
reside in Scotland, you sav we can punish
them, but not thos^ m England; and yet you
could dte those that were in England : and it
was backed by a judge in England ; and if you
erant a second diligence, the same form will
DC gone through again ; and if, af)er a cer-
tain time, for I do not wish to avoid a trial, —
no, I wbh to come before my country, as
/every good citizen ousht, to obey the laws of
his country ; and I do it with a conscious
heart that I am totally innocent, and that I
deserve praise insteau of blame or punish-
ment;— ^therefore, I say I will concede to
you a part of the justice that I demand. — I
nave exculpatory witnesses of great import-
ance living in England cited by vour auiho-
iity ; in conseauence of that authority it has
been suj^rteu by the English judges, — the
* Lord Chief Justice Holt in the case of the
Queen v. Tooley and others (who had killed a
man by whom a woman had been irregularly
imprisoned) delivering the opinions of the
judges, of whom seven held that the offence
was manslaughter, and five that it was mur-
der, says, " U was objected by the five that
it is dangerous to allow such a power to the
moby but I think that no proper word to be
us«d in a court of juatice/'^li Mod. 251.
English judges will support your authority in
a second instance.— -Let them be cited; — let a
proper time be given me, and if they do not
appear at the second citing, I will consent to
^o to trial without them.— But, my lords, Jet
justice take place;— remember you have, ia
the course of this trial, to praise the constitu*
tion, it will be told the people how happily
they live under it — how free and how happy
every man is Uving under his own vine and
his own fig-tree.— -Let it be proved, let it be
proved that a court of justice aoes every thing
u) favour of the panel, as much as in fa-
vour of the prosecutor. — ^The objections that I
made have been repelled ; but they will be
noticed in a superior court. — ^There is a court
superior to your's, and there must be^ in
every well regulated government, an ap-
peal to a superior court, from whence tae
abuses of the servants of the crown may be
rectified.
Lord Juttiee Clerk, — ^I think you seem to
be unacquainted with the laws of any well
govemea state, and if you were not a foreigner
and a stranger, we would not have suroied
you to have said one half of what you have
said.
Mr. Margarot.'-^I demand a caption.
Lord Justice C^ft.— The Court have re-
pelled it
Mr. Margarot, — Oh! very well, my lords,
— ^however, permit me one question, and I
will put it to the generosity of the public pro-
secutor to answer it. My lord advocate, is it
in your power or not to bring a witness on the
part of the prosecution firom England? upon
your honour, answer me.
Lord Advocate. — No more than you can.
Mr. Margarot. — ^Does not an outlawry ex-
tend to England ?
Mr. Solicitor General, — ^For a crime it cer-
tainly does, but not as to a witness. — Suppos-
ing a Scotchman to be tried before a Court in
England, and in place of seeking the assist-
ance of some English counsel, as he ought to
do, he were to utter thinss of the same kind
that this panel has done, I doubt whether he
would be heard with the same patience with
which your lordship has heard him.
Lord Justice C/erft.— Do you wish a cap-
tion against those two witnesses who reside
in Scotland ?
Mr. Margarot. — ^No, my lords, — I do not
wish to punish two poor men, and let
three rich men go unpunished. — ^There is
another thing which I believe takes place be-
fore the impanelline of the jury, which re-
spects the opening of the doors of this place. In
looking over the claim of rights in the 37 th
chapter, I find it sud that, in criminal trials,
which are of so great import, the doors of the
Court shall be thrown open. — I demand there-
fore that the doors of this place may be
opened, in order that the people may partake
01 what passes.
Lord Justice^ Clerk.-^lt would be a very
pretty opening I think.
681] 34 GEORGE IIL Proceedhgt agidna Mutnce Margaret \SBIt
Mr. Miarr^ar0r.-^The doors af« itwtt, Md t
fUlderstand it is the custom of the door-keeip-
ers to take money, which is conttBty tt^ the
laws of the land.
Lord Juake Clerk.—ThaX yott bfl^e no bii-
tfinesswith.*
* Mr. BarriDgton, in his ohsferrations on
the following passt^s of IS Ed. 1, stat. 1.
(cap. 4'i & 44.) Se mareteallii domini re-
gii, defeodo camerar^^ custody hotti&nim in tfi-
nere iuttitiariorum : — <irdinatum ett qvod de
qualiiet assUA et juratd puun cuitodiunt, ca-
piunt decern denarioi tantvm^ et de cirdgraphii
nichiL — De ki$ qui voeaii $unt ante JHttitiarim
ad defendendum placitum sunm niehil capiant
fro ingritsA vel egresiA, ad plaeita corons de
fnilit^ duodend XIL denarii tantittn cupt-
anturt^wfs, **Tbe chief reason of my
maiung any observations upon this part of the
statute arises from the words seeming to
afford a strong inference, that the courts of
lliw were not at this time tmen amrtt in the
lense that they are now understood so to be.
An open court at present is generally so
erowded by idle q>ectators, that no one iHio
hath any real busmess to do can have access ;
or, if he procures a seat^ he is not so much at
Us ease, as those whose mterests aredependinjg
have a reasonable right to insist upon. This
•tatute tiierefore directs, that the plaintiff.
Or defendant should pay nothing; hut by im-
Cication seems to allow that thosfe who pro-
ibly constituted the idle part of the audi-
ence should pay one penny each for admits
tance, which may be nearW equal to a shil-
ling at present [▲. d. ITTstso that if the spi-
rit of the hiw was attended to, it would, in a
mat measure, prevent what is now so sensi-
Bly felt as an inconvenience. The statute
then injoins the judges, in these emphatical
words : * Qobd dominus rex justitiarits in-
* jungit in fide et sacramento quibus ei tenen-
' tur, quM si bujusmodi ministri contril pm^
' dictum statutum in aliquo iverint, pcenam
< eis infli^nt rationalem.' When the ser-
vants of judees at the Old Bailey, and the
officers of the courts of Westmmster-hall,
have, upon certain occasions, taken not only
a penny from the spectator, but even insisted
lipon gold; are tney not within both the
letter and spirit of this law ? and is it not in-
tombent upon the Jndg;es to put it in execu-
tion agreeaole to what is Injoined by the sta-
tute r
And ki a note he says, " in the ttiodem
sense of an open court, the legislature could
Hevler have allowed any fees to be taken for
admittance. I do not recollect to have met
in anv of the European laws with an injunc-
tion that till causes shall be heard ottiis aper*
ftf, except in those of the republic of Lucca.
See 1. 1. c. 10. Lucca, 1559, folio. In Scotland,
hy a statute of William and Mary, all causes
must be tried with open doon, rape, sodomy,
and the likie, being exce|>ted : lind I atn in-
formed, that the propriety of this regula^^
vtrsy.
lames Cordon, brewer in fidiflftrargh.
Thomas Hotchkis, brewer.
Samuel Gilmour, rope-matk6r.
James Clark, farrier.
James Mill, tanner.
Lord Justice Clerk. — Do you object to any
of these centlemen?
Mr. Margarot. — I have no personal olne6>
tion, but I must beg to know by what law
you have the picking of the jury, and that
you alone have the pickins of them ?
LordAbercrambie. — His lordship is not picto>
ins but naming the jury, according to the es*>
tablished law and the established constitution
of Uie country;* and the gentleman at tb4
bar has no right to put such a question.
William Smith, stabler.
Charles Robertson, painter.
John Balfour, merchants
John Wilson, coach- makers
William Ainslie, sadler.
William Pimie, architect.
Samuel Anderson, banker.
Robert Bums, architect
Macduff Hart, shoe-maker.
John White, merchant
EviDEKCt; roa rac CttoW!f.
[irt//iam Scoe^ called in.]
Lord Henderland^-^Uav^ you any olucc-
lion to this witness?
Mr. Margarot — According to thfe method
in which you proceed, it appears to me Very
ileedless to make objections ; othfervvise, un-
doubtedly, my lord, under the British con-
stitution, acting up to the spirit uf it, that
witness is not competent ; he is a dependent,
or hanger-on upon the public prosecutor,
and, in fact, acts as deputy public prosecu-
tor; you may repel it or not, as you please.
Lord Justice Clerk. — I darie say, your lord-
sliips will please to repel that objection.
[The witness sworn.]
Do you recollect, on the evening of the 5th
of December last, goins to apprehend th6
panel for examination f-— i do,
is found by experience, as it permits tbt
Judge and jui-y to ask questions with greater
fireedom, and prevents idle people from Icam-
inc many bad lessons.''
See also Mr. Banrington's Observations dh
<< Articuli super Chartfts,^' SB Ed. 1, «tat. 9,
wherein he notices, that from the expression
in the Fsalms ** they shall not be afraid to
speak with their enemies at the gate," !or&
Bacon has inferred, that the courts of jxjfetke
among the Jews wer^ open.
The Scots statute, mentioned by Barrtng-
ton, is the claim of right mention^ hyfm
patiel.
• As to the mode of appointtnte imfei ih
Seotlahd, Mi Vol. lit. p. 11, tirm& Cottee*
tbn.
§s^
J^ £)i0ii&&HI«
A. D. i794.
t6S4
W^$f^ ytiu jfrtftelM WhMl Kiife Wii brought up
IMr eismmation ? — I eoi^loye<) Lyon, the me^
eenger, to apprehend him, atid was present
fti ue fthenfi Gierke's ofi&ce, when he was
ezamioed.
Did he, upon that occaskm, make a decla-
ration?— He did.
Did he appear to be sober and of sound
ttatA^ at the time he emitted that declara-
tion?— ^Yes.
Freely, and without compulsion?— Yes.
Did you stA^scribe your witness to that de-
claration ?->I did.
Look if that is yonr snbscription.-^That is
fhe declaration.
Were any papers, at that thne produced^
claimed by the panel ? — ^The officer who ex9-
cctted th^ warrant reported to me, t^t he
fbund Mr. Margarot and Mr. Gertnld in the
same room ; that he had tak^ into his pos^
Hussion setend papelrs, part of ttiem he de-
scribed to be Mr. Oerrald*s, part of thiith to
b^ Mr. Margarot*^; they were pat into a
trunk together; this trunk was brousht to
the office, and after ht tiras examined, he was
desired to give* the key that it hiight be
ripened- he decBned to do so; tipon Which
We applied for a Ti^arrant to have the trunk
Openea, which was carried into execution;
it was inspected in the presence df Mr. Mar-
garot and Mr. Oerrald. He Was btou^ht to th^
office upon a second warrant, and Mr. Oer-
TaM also attended ; he refused then to give it
hp without force, and he held it in his hand
and said, I will not give it Up, but you may
take it ; he said, he would hot witness the
Irank behig opened, and turn<^d round and
looked out of the window. Upon the trunk
wing opened, them were Bomb ilrticles that
did not relate to the business in hand, parti-
cularly a pocket-book of Mr. Mar^rot*s, ind
something of Mr. Gerrald's, tirhich werfe re-
Stored ; and those that were considered as re-
lative to the business -were entered into an
inventory.
•Did you subscribe that inventory? — ^T did.
. Do you know that to be the same? [show-
ing hmi the inventory.] This is the same;
ft IS signed by Mr. Oerrald aud me on eveiy
Mge; but Mr. Mair^arot declined signing
Did you, at that time, identify the papers
T&at you found f— Yes.
Will ybu take the tronbte of looking ovet
these papers, and see if they are the same,
«Qd godirough them accurately?— The iirst
Is a ]»per containing two letters signed Wil-
Hftm Skirving.
These are the papers Mr. Margarot claittied
ttobls?-Ye8.
The second isatnandseri^t of a plan fbr
supporting the Gazetteer, submitted to ih'e
^totttldekution of the Friends of the People,
^^Uch is signed fai the same manner.
th^^fl ^ ""^ btiftdlfe bf "P^PJJ? ti^'^ ^P>
'tlbtt- iMBH^; *t^a{nM Ibt \s!tt OdttinSltte« of
UaiOD.
Tlie foc^ih is «t letteir, dated tM ISth Tfb*
vember, ir9S^ siped Thomas Ha)%>* «e-
eretary, addressed to 'Citizen Matr^ardt iemd
Citizen Gerrald, delegates.
The fifth is a letter fVom ditto to ditto, l22d
November, addressed Citizen Matgarot ^d
Citizen Gerrald.
The sixth is another letter^ the 89th of No*
vember, addressed to Maurice Margatot t^
Joseph Gerrald^ delegates.
The seventh is another letter ibom ThoiA^fc
Hardy, dated the 28th November, addressed
to Mr. Margarot and Mr. GerraM^ delegate!
ftem London.
The eighth, two pages of mannscript, be^
ginning, Denization of Primary Assemblies^
asseilipied ^r the Purpose of electing R0ptt*
sentatxves.
The ninth, a manuscript^ intituled HieCbtw
itituthm ; and ili it were round other jnipets,
relative to the regulatiohs to be adopted in the
conventioti.
Have you now gone through the Itrtidek
claimed % Mr. Mii^arot ?— Yes.
Were there several other articles cfauttre^
by Mr. Gerrald ?— Yes.
Were they identified in the same ttantier f
They were.
In the declaration you heard emitted by
the panel, of the 5th of December, did be re-
fer to any motion? — ^If your lordship Will
cause the declaration to be read, I smdl be
better able to tell you.
[The declaration handed to the tdtne»,
who reads it.]
Was there &ny reference to amotioh^ —
Yes.
Was any paper found in the panePs p6s-
sessibti ?-s-There was a paper found when Mh
Skirving was apprehended; tlicn, amongst
other papers, this motion was fotmd; and
when this gentleman was examined, this
paper was shown to him, and the question
stated in the declaration put to hhn ; it was
found in the possession of Mr. Skirving, the
secretary to the convention, upon the sam^
morning that Mr. Margarot was taken up.
Did you put any mark upon that paper, by
which you should know it again ? — Yes, I put
my initials upon it: it is a motion signed \m
Mr. Margarot, and seconded by John Wara-
law.
At the time the secretary's papers camtt to
be inspected in your presence, was there a
paper discovered amongst them, bearing to
ne the Minutes of the Convention f—Thepe
was.
Did you put any mark or subscription upon
that at the time, so that you should know it
again?— I did.
Did you look through it?— I did read the
whole of it.
How were these papers of the secretai;y
brought before your— % a Warrant. The
* See his¥Hal for High lYeason, A.t). It9«,
t
635] S4 GEORGE HI. Proceedings agaimt Muwrke Margarot £686
papers were found sealed in the secretaiy*s
nouse, and were brought, in that situation,
to the sheriff Gierke's office, and they were
there with the rest.
Did you attend the magistrates of this city
on the evening of the 5th of December, when
they went to disperse this convention ? — No ;
I did on the 6th ; the convention had assem-
bled ; the provost went along with the she-
riff's substitute, Mr. Davidson, and the ma-
gistrates, and I accompanied them upon that
occasion. I found Mr. Margarot standing by
a table, and the chair was standing empty.
The first thing that I heard was, Mr. Marga*
rot said, they were met for a constitutional
purpose, they were going to petition either the
King or the Parliament, 1 cannot say which , and
it was said by somebody, that they could not
Srocecd to business till the chair was taken :
Ir. Marmot was called upon to take the
chair, which he accordingly did. Mr. David-
son asked if it was the British Convention ?
Upon being told it was, he told them that
they came for the purpose of dismissing them,
and they should not proceed to any business ;
the answer was, that they would not till
/orce was used; and particularly the panel
said, that he would not leave the chair, as he
was then discharging his dut^, till force was
used ; to that Mr. Davidson said, he supposed
way thing that had that appearance would be
satisfactory, and took Mr. Margarot by the
hand, upon which he left the chair. Upon
bis leaving the chair, there was a call for Mr.
Gerrald to take the chair, which he accord-
ingly did, and the same form was used with
regard to him ; Mr. Davidson took him by
the hand ; and it was then called out, that
they never dismissed without prayer, and Mr.
Gerrald prayed, and then came out of the
chair. It was then said by somebody, that
though they were now dismissed, they would
remember that they were permanent, that
thev had voted themselves permanent the
nieht before.
Did this happen the dav after the panel
had been examined before the sheriff, and li-
berated upon his finding bail ? — Yes.
Was it on account of a charge of seditious
practices of the same nature, that he was
Drought before the sheriff? — It was for being
a member of that convention.
William Scott cross-examined by Mr. Mar-
garot.
By virtue of what authority did you employ
Lyon, the messenger, to arrest me? — By
virtue of a warrant which I had obtained
from the sheriff of Edinburgh, as procurator-
fiscal.
Was that warrant granted at your requisi-
tion?— It was.
Now answer me seriouslv one question;
from whom didyoif^ieceive the order to apply
for that requisition ?— That certainly has not
any connexion with the present business,
and I think I am not bound to answer that
question.
It has^ sir 1 and you must answer it as you
a|>pear before God at the great day. — [The
witness hesitated.]
Mr. Margarot, — My lord, I must have the
protection of the Court.
Lord Justice Clerk. — I do not think it is
pro{)er that he should tell who gave the infor-
mation.
Lord Abercrombie. — I am of the same opi-
nion.
Lord Etkffrove, — He acted as procurator-
fiscal of Edinburgh, and therefore he is no
more liable, or iMund, to say who was his
private informer, than my lord advocate is.
Lord Dunsinnan, — ^It is entering into an
investigation which the panel has no right to
make.
Lord Swiuion, — I am of the same opinion.
Mr. Margarot, — My lords, I hone I have
not put an improper question. I know it is
customary at Venice, they have a lion*s
mouth to receive all private secret informa-
tion ; but I did not know that it was so here ;
I thought that justice was open.
Lord Abercrombie, — I am sorry to observe,
that from the beginning of this trial, the ]^anel
has betrayed the grossest ignorance ot the
laws of this country ; and I must regret, that
he has not had the advice of those who know
better ; but if he is to object to things in this
way, I trust he will do it, for his own sake,
in a decent manner.
Mr. Margarot.— Then I am to understand,
that the reception of secret information is a
part of the laws of this country.
The officer found Mr. Gerrald and me in the
same room? — I was told so, but that is only
from report.
Where was that room? at the Black Bull?
— ^Yes, I was told so.
At a public inn? — Yes.
Was the door locked ? — I cannot say.
How do you ascertain that those papers
were mine which you have just now pro-
duced?— I have told you all that I can; it
was from Mr. Gerrald^s and your own point-
ing them out.
I understand you have said, that I emitted
a declaration. A declaration, if I understand
it rightly, is a certain verbal acknowledg-
ment.— A declaration may be negative, and it
is still a declaration.
Lord Justice Clerk. — ^You may make a de-
claration that you are innocent, as well as
that you are guilty.
Mr. Margarot. — It would have much the
same effect. — What reason did I allege for
refusing to emit a declaration ? — I do not re-
collect.
In the course of your practice do you^know
any law which eniorces a private interroga-
tory?
Mr. Solicitor General. — ^If the gentleman is
an attorney, as I am told, I should like to
know, whether be would be suffered to go on
in this way in the courts of Westminster-
haU?
887]
Jbr Seditiofii
A. D. 1794.
[6S8
Lord Juitiee Cl€rk.-^li is certainly not a
question fit for the witness to answer.
Mr. Margaret. — ^Havc you any mode of
distinguishing those papers found in my trunk,
from those that belonged to Mr. Gerrald in
the same trunk ? — I cannot say.
Then it may happen, that you may have
intermixed a paper of Mr. Gerrald's and a pa-
per of mine.^ — No; they were taken down
<listinct)y, and marked with your initials in
your own presence.
Who arranged the papers? — I arranged
tliem in your presence ; I took them out, at
least.
Lord Justice Clerk, — Did not you say, the
panel picked out his papers, and Mr. Gerrald
nis?'^Ves; there was a paper put in, and all
below that belonged to hnn ; the rest belonged
to the panel.
Mr. Margaret. — Did I not observe to you
at the time, that being at an inn, ^we could
not be answerable for what papers were found
in our roomf — I dare say you did.
Did I not say, that even liie messenger
aaiEht bring that paper if he thought proper,
ana hustle tliem mto the trunk at once?— So
you did.
By what me&ns are you certain, that the
papers which you found in Mr. Skirving's pos-
session, were minutes of the convention? —
From various circumstances ; but I submit
again to the Court, whether it is proper to
answer that?
Lord Justice CUrk. — ^Yes, you must give an-
swers to legal questions.
The minutes were established to be the
minutes of the convention by some of the
members.
You accompanied the sheriff to Mr. Laing's
loom? — ^Ycs
Did I say any thing to you at that time ? —
Yes, vou were the first person that called to
me, handed me a motion, and desired I
would read it. I told him, I had nothing to
do with it. It was a motion to petition the
King, or something of that kind.
Do you recollect the sheriff-substitute say-
ing, that he acted by orders ? — I cannot say ;
but he certainly told you, he came for the ex-
press purpose of dismissing that meeting, and
that you must do no business as a British
convention.
Did I not speak to you, and you af\erwards
answered me, that you were domg your duty ?
— ^Yes, by attending the shehfifs.
You say that the meeting ended with
prayer; can you recollect that prayer ?'-I
cannot.
Does beginning and closing a meeting, for
obtaining a reform in parliament, with prayer,
apply to the word sedition.
lird Justice Clerk. — That is a very impro-
per ^estioD.
Did the petition for the warrant state, that
I had met with others in Laing's workshop,
that I had been forced from the chair, that
we had said that we were assembled for pe-
titioning a reform of parliament, and closed
with prayer ? Was that warrant which took
me up then the same as before ? — ^The war-
rant could not mention it, because the peti-
tion was two days before the warrant was ob->
tained, it could not mention that which did
not take place till two days after.
Harry Davidson sworn.
Do you recollect the panel being brought
before you upon the 5th of December for ex-
amination ? — I do.
Did he at that time emit a declaration in
your presence ? — ^He did.
Did be do it voluntarily, and without com
pulsion ?— Yes.
Was he sober, and of sound mind? — Yes.
Did you subscribe that declaration ? — I did.
Look and see if that is it. — It is the same.
Is there any reference in that declaration
to a motion? — ^Yes.
Was there a paper found in the secretary's
possession which appeared to be that motion?
— Yes.
Did you put any mark upon the paper so
as to know it again ?— -Yes, this is it.
Do you recollect any other paper having
been produced at that examination or after-
wards?— ^There were no papers produced Haat
day; the next day there were papers taken
from a trunk of his, of which an inventory
was made, which I identified.
Was that trunk brought along with him P
— ^Yes.
Was he asked for the key of that trunk ?«-
Yes, and he declined giving it up.
Was there any seal put upon it?— Not in
my presence; I understood there was.
When it was opened the following day,
was any inventory made of its contents ?— •
Yes.
Were there any papers other than those
claimed by the panel ? — ^Yes papers belonging
to Mr. Gerrald.
Were those claimed by the panel separated,
from those claimed by Mr. Gerrald? — ^Yes,
and an inventory was made of both, and they
acquiesced in both.
And it was done in their presence ? — ^Yes.
Did you subscribe that inventorv ? — ^Yes.
Did you likewise put any mark upon the
articles which it contains ? —Yes.
Did you compare those articles which have
your subscription with the articles which are
in the inventory ?-*Yes ; it was only those
that were relating to the business in hand
that were put into the inventory [Examines
and compsires them]. They are aU nwfked
by me.
Do you recollect why Mr. Margaret was
liberated? — ^Upon finding bail.
What was the nature of the charge'against
him for which he was brought before you for
examination ? — For seditious practices, as be-
ins a member of the meeting calling them-^
selves the British Convention of the dele-
gates of the Friends of the People. '
$99] d4 GEORGE III. Proceedingi aff^mt tfoffsice Margartd [Q40
!>« you teodUeel^o b»ve gone in tiie enMu-
tiaa of y4)ur dai^ to « wright's $hop qq tho
milh vac of tiiue town, the 6ih of December,
i^tb a view of dispersing this meeting ^--I
did.
Be soi obliging lo mention to tlu Court and
Jury what paafiM when you so went to that
meeting— It was od Friday evenins the 6th
of December, I went and attended the lord
y^povoat; with the magistrates of the city ; a
j^tnumberof people were assembled in a
Wright's shop, and I went immediately up to
-|be ilftbtey where I saw aome people whose
faces I recognized, Mr. Skirving, Mr. Brown,
j^rv Afargftfot, aiid severe] ot&rs ; I asked
what .the meeting was ? I did not get a di-
rect answer; I asked if it was the British
ConMentioA? One of the members, and I
tbiok it was Mr. Margarat, said that it was ;
I told bim thai I was sheriff substitute for the
county, and that I came there to disperse that
Vioeting, which was an illegal one : upon this
m^BQfi coayersaiioii took place ; and i think
Mr. Margarot was the roan who spoke most
119 %QQOMn^ of the Convention; he said, they
were met peaceably, that it was a legal co&.
#liluti^nar meeting, and that they were then
na^ating upon a petition to narliament. I told
him tim ray resolution baa been taken before
I oame thece ; lihat t eame with a determi-
Mlm to dia|»eise that meeting ; that no words
were necessary ; no argument that they could
Qaa iCQiidd after my determination; some
more conversation took place. Mr. Margarot,
findlDg I vraa determined upon it, said that he
would take the ebair, with the approbation of
Ibe 9Keting» which w^ s then empty; accord-
ingly u^B this, he was unanimqusiy called to
tba chau" : I think beAnre he took the chair,
he saidy the meeting would not disperse with*
out force was used ; I told him, I hoped it
9oidd be unneceasaiy to use fotce, but if it
was oecesaary I should certai^l^ make use of
It. He took the chair, and finding they would
pot diaperae without aome Ibice, I took him by
ann» which he considered aa force, and
if came out of the chair ; immediately upon
lis doing so, Mr. Gerrald, another of thegei^
tlojoien preaent, took the chair ; I told hun,
I reaUy thought that it was improper that
another person should do the same thing, if
they were all to take the chair one after ano-
ther ; I hoped they would not think that ne-
oeasary ; however, I took the same method of
forcing Mr. Gerrald from the chair that I did
Mr. Margarot: Mr. Gerrald then made an
iaieaipoie prayer,* and left the eluir. Mr.
Mangasot, amongst other things that he men-
tinned, said, the meeting of me Convention
had declared themseWea permanent I told
him it might be ao, but I was determined they
fhotild not meet within the county where I
had a juriadiction. I think they called out
* In the original edition of Gerrald'a trial,
this pn^r waa inserted by way of appendix;
tee it in the cfae of Skicvmg, aM, p. 471.
1
for tibe ^ntlemen to diapers, ai^d h^ df^nees
they dispersed; and I saw the k»t peraQ^i
out, and saw the door locked, and took the
key
Yqu said you ic^ognized several persoAs ;
amonv others the p^nel at tl^c bar* and Mi,
Gerrald. How came you to reccsnize the
panel particularly ? — Beqwae he bad been be*
fore me the night before, and had been esa^
mined upon the charge I b^ve already meNe
tioned.
Yqu had granted h^il ^—- Yea<
Hany Davidton^ cross-examined by Mr. ttar»
gQrot.
How ana ^ou sure that the motion wlucli
jrou found m th^ possession of Mr. Skirving
IS in my handwriting, aa you have dedaiad
it to be?- -I did not assert that it was yow
handwriting, at least I did not mean to say ao.
Did I not give one uniform reason for dn».
cliAing to emit a declaration, for refosing to
give up the key of my tmok, and for aaseot*
mg the right of the convei\tion to meet; did
I not say, that the proceodlnga against mc
and ag^&t them were illegil f— You.certainly
did.
Did I nojt aak you, why you wiould intermpt
US in our legal proceedings ? and did you no|
answer me, that you acted according tp order?
Remember, sir, that you ana upon your oath.
*-I cannot say that I recollect, whether I
aaid by order, as sheriff substitute of the
county, I acted by my own authority; I do
not recollect the preqiae words I may have
used, but I waa ocartainly acting aa aberiff of
the county.
What could induce you to think that m
meeting like that was illeaa) ?
Lord Jttstice CUrk. — ^Tbat ia not a propei
queation.
Mr. Margarot. — ^It only hingaa upon fuu^
ther. Did you see at the time of your ei^
trance there, any confiiaion, riot, or ADsorder t
-^I did not.
Did you, on the contrarjr, peieem the bop
ainesa of the evening earned on with regular
rity^— There, was but little buaineaa going on
after I came in. M^. Gemld was upon )m
lees speaking, and I certainly iDtam^pted hini^
Was prayer called for?-rIt waa. I do not
know whether it was not you that said it wcm
not usual that the meeting ahould depart
without prayer, and I believe I ga?e conaeot
that prayer should be made.
G, you did conaent to that? Do you re-
collect the sul^ect of the debate?— I think
you, or some other person, put into my band
a small piece of paper, upon which waa wrote
a petition to jiarliament, which you aaid waa
the subject of the-r-
Mr. Margarai, — Of the order of the dajf. —
That the purpose of their meeting was to p^
tition parliament.
I hope the order of the day ia not an of»
fonce, becauae I believe it is made uee of
aofnetimea inl^iiouae of Gomnona*
641]
Jor Sedition^
A. D. 17M.
[64*
. Cammel for the €rovn.— The witness has
spoke of tlie motion referred to in the decla-
ration. Was there any paper found in Mr.
Skirving*s possession, which was entitled mi-
nutes of the convention ?— There were a
namber of things found in Mr. Skirvine's pos-
session ; amongst which a scroll of the xni-
Butes of the convention.
Should you know it a^n ? — ^Yes.
Look at that and see if that is it ?— It is.
Mr. Margarot. — How are you certain thai
these ai« the minutes of the British Conven-
tion.— ^I can only say, that these are papdris
which were found in Mr. Skirvine*s possession,
aadihey were acknowledged to oe so by vari-
ous people, who were examined before me ;
that is the only reason I have ; I did not see
them in the convention.
There is another question which I hope
your loidships will not think improper. In your
office as sheriff, have you, to tne best of your
judgment, acted aocoiding to the laws of vour
country, or have you acted by superior orders?
•^•I certainly would execute no orders, unless
I was certain they were according to th^ laws
of my country.
. Am I to infer from hence, that you re-
ceived orders ?
Lard Juttice Clerks — It is not a proper sub-
ject of evidence.
Mr. Margarot, — I put myself under your
correction at the time I started the Question ;
however, it mav not be amiss that tne ques-
tion was started, though it is not answered.
Joseph Maek, sworn.
Do you recollect being present when Mr.
Skirving, the laf e secretary of the Convention
of die Friends of the People, was brought be-
fom the sheriff for examination ? — ^Yes.
Were there certain bags of papers brought
along with him for inspection } — Yes.
Were you present when those bags were
•4H)ened? — I was, when they were put into
the inventory, which was very soon aAer or
immediately afler they were opened.
WasSkirvine present? — Yes.
Do you recoUect, among other papers found
in this ba^, one being tound, entitled the
scroll of the minutes of the convention ?—
Yes.
Was it in your hand^ that you had an op-
portunity of observing it at thattime ? — I both
saw it then, and at Mr. Skirving's house;
they were carried in a bag firom his house to
riieriffclerk*s office, and there entered into
an inventory — that is the paper.
And you now recognize it as the same ?^>
[Looks over il.] Yes, it is the same.
Jouph Mack cross^xamined by Mf. Jliir-
garoi
You act as notaxy, do you not? — ^No, I do
not.
Or as clerk^ to the sheriff P—Yes, writing
derk to the sheriff.
Did yau hear me protest against the illeg^-
VOL. xxin.
lity of all the proceedings which had taken
place ?— You offered to make a protest, but it
was refused to you.
You are certain that I offered to make one 2
—Yes.
A written one ? — I do not recollect whe-
ther it was written or not: I think it is pro-
bable it was, but I cannot say^I was not a
notai^'.
James Lyon called.
Mr. Margarot. — I have objections to tliat
witness, on account of certain expressions of
his, and I have a witness now attending to
prove those words. 1 do not know whethet
that witness should be brought in at present
to prove this, or whether it should be kepi
back till the witnesses for the prosecution are
gone through.
lard Justice Clerk, — ^What do you propose
to prove?
Mr. Jlfar^flro^— That he considered him-
self as my enemy ; these are nearly the words^
I Took upon myself to be your enemy; or
something to that effect.
Can you condescend upon any reason, whj^
he should have any enmity to you ?
Mr. Margarot, — I have not the skill of
other people; I cannot dive into mentis hearts;'
I find him a verv officious time-serving man.
Lord Justice Clerk. — He must answer that
question upon oath, whether bo has any
malice or ill-will.
[Sworn.]
Lord Justice Clerk. — I^ook upon the pane|
at the bar ; have you any malice or ili-will
against that person? — None at all.
Did you ever say that you were his enemy {
— ^Never.
Lord Justice Clerk, — You may ask him
the question again, Mr. Margarot.
Mr. Margarot.^^l would wish to have my
witness produced in court ; it is not my ask-
ing him the question merely, do you not re-
collect saying one day that you considere({
yourself as my enemy r— Not at all.
Lord Abercrombie. — ^The Court have uni-
formly raid this down as a rule, that no general
charge of a witness making use of an expres-
sion of that nature shall be sufficient to in-
validate his testimony, and for tliis reason^
that it would put it in the power of every
witness whatever^ if he wished to favour the
panel,- to disquahfy himself by uttering som<>
vague expression of ill-will.
Lord Eskgrove, — What are you?— A mes-
senger.
Lord^ Advocate, — Did you execute a warrant
against the panel ? — ^Yes.
And against any body else?— Yes; Mr.
Gerrald.
Where were you informed' these persons
resided ?^At the Black Bull.
Were you to take into your custody any.
papers that you found ?— Yes.
At what time in the morning was it ? — ^To
the best of my knowledge about seven o'clock*'
2 T
^3] S4 OfebkCrfi ill. ProQeedingi against Manrke Margtina {;M4f
Tell the Court and jury what uassed. — 1 1 — ^1 found some upon the top of ihe drftw^rs*
asked for sdch gentlemen^ I asked for Aeir
room ; the waiter declined showing me, but
told me the numbers of tlieir room ; I Went
into this room where Mr. Gerrald and Mr.
Margarot were; they were each in separate
beds in the same room.
Did you tell them you had a warrant agcunsl
them? — ^Yes; then I went to Mr. Sinclair's
room, and locked up all Mr. Margarofs papers,
and Mr. Gerrald's and Mr. Sinclair's also; Mr.
Margarot said he would put his papers into a
little tnmk, which 1 did not object to.
Did he accordingly do so? — He asked Mr.
Cerrald if he woula put his in, upon which he
agreed to it, and the papers were put in; and
\\lien I was away and came back for them|
he said he would not give them me; I saia
I would take them ; lie said I might take
them at my peril, and I said I should not
make any scruple about iL
Did the key remain in his possessioil after
the paper was taken away ? — ^Ves, the trunk
was locked and he kept the key. ^
Did you take the trunk and him with you
to the snerifTs? — Yes, and Mr. Gerrald.
Were you present when the trunk was
opened and the contents examined? I was.
Did the panel agree to open the trunk
himself, or was It opened? — ^The next day
when he was before the sheriff, he held the
key in his hand ; he said he would not give
it up, but we might take it from him ; uppd
which the sheriif- substitute desired roe to
take it from him, which I did; the trunk
was then opened and the papers inspected.
. Were those belonging to the panel distin-
guished from those belonging to Mr. Gerrald ?
— Each of them claimed separately what
belonged to himself.
Was there any inventory made of those
papers ?— Yes.
Did you put any mark upon those papers \
— ^I did.
Look at those papers deliberately, and sec
if they are the same ? — [Examines and com-
pares them with the inventory]* Yes, they
are the same, they have my initial.
When you went to the Black Bull had you
any assistants with you ?— Yes, John M*Don.
aid, and Neil M'GIashan, were both in the
room along with me.
Jcmef Lyon cross-examined by Mr. Margarot.
You found us in bed ? — Yes.
Did we show any disposition of resistance,
or rather testify the greatest alacrity to go
with you? — ^You showed no disposition to
Qudce any resistance ; you did not refuse to
come along with us.
Did we make you wait long in dressing ?
•^No.
Did you show us the warrants ? — ^No, nor
did you ask it.
Did we never ask you to see the warrant P
Where did you find the papei;^ in the room ?
head, some in the drainers, sLuQ soid^ out iii
a trunk.
Were the drawers locked ?— No;
Was the door of the room locked ? — ^N6 ; I
knocked at the door, and you desired me to
come in, and of course I opened the door.
Were the papers in a state of arrange
ment.when you took thefai off the draifrers,
an^ out of the drawers ? — No, by nb in^ns.
Wfere they not rathfer confused f— Yei, they
were a little confused.
. Were there some in one pUce, ijA dtUtir^
In others?— Yes, some I got out of thfe ^Hk,
and some in the drawers, and ^ome off the
drawers.
Werb th^re papbrs in more thah one
drawer? — I believe there wer6: I cantibt say.
Bht the drawers were not lotked? — I be-
lieve not, at least I broke non^ of theiii b^en;
John Maedanaid swoni.
Did you go along with Mr. Lyon, the itie»-
sen^er, to assist him to execute a warrant
against the panel at the ba^, on the 5th De-
cember last? — Yes.
Inhere did you go to?— To the Black Boll,
at the head of Leith Walk.
Tell us, as far as you recollect, what passed
upon that occasion. — I went into tlie nouse;
and stood there till the door was opened:
Mr. Lyon went in : we went up the StaSr, and
this gentleman ana another were in the bed*
room, but had not got their deaths ori, ana
we stood at the door till they were ready ; and
Mr. Lyon took what papers he coula find,
and they were put into a trunk ; the tnmk was
locked, and he put the key in his pocket, ana
there was a coach at the door; and I too)^
down the trunk, and put it in the chaise, ana
he came along with us, and I got at the badq
of the chaise, and went to the sheriff clcrk*S
office, and left the trunk in the office.
You have mentioned what passed in th^
room, and the manner in which the papers
were put in the trunk; now, did the
Kanel himself put any of the papers in? — Yes,
e was helping.
Did Mr. Gerrald likewise assist to put this
papers in the trunk ? — Yes, Mr. Gerraid*s pa-
pers were put in fi^st,and then Mr. Margarot'^,
and then tne trunk was locked and carried to
the sheriff clerk's office.
Join Macdonaid cr6s8*examined by Mr. '
Margarot.
Could you at that time dlscrimitiate which
were my papers, and which were thoSe . 9f
Mr. Gerrald ? — I can neither tell which wef^
yours, noV whidi were his ; but, it is my €|iW
nion, your's were put in first.
Were the drawers locked ? — ^No.
You did not sec a key in those draWets f
—No.
Was the room-door locked.?— No, it waa
open when I came in ; you were apprehend-
ed| I dare say^ before I came in*
m}
jfor Sedition,
A. D. 1794.
[646
We^ ih^ M>efs put into the trunjc tied
up in parcels oir\po^ei^} — Some were tied up,
aad some were loose. *
"' Did we tie up any of them before you? — I
did pot see any string tied on them!
%yho took them out of the drawers? -Mr.
Lyon took them but.
Do you recollect the reason why Mr. Lyon
would not show me the warrant? — You did
not insist upon showing it much.
Did he show it? and remember you are
uDon'yoyr oath. — I cannot recollect.
You well recollect that I asked him to
produce it? — ^Yes"
And you are not certain that he did show
it?— No.
But you perfectly recollect that I asked
Hm to show it ?— Yes.
Thomoi Cockbum called.
Ijord Justice Clerks — Have you any objec-
tion to this witness?
Mr. Margarot, — ^No, my lord, he looks
honest. [Sworn].
Are you a member of any of the societies
of Friend^ of the People?— I wa».
Were you a delegate from that society to
the British convention ? — Yes, I was a mem-
ber of both.
Did you attend regularly their meeting ?—
JWy business did not allow me a regular at-
tendance, but I attended as often as I could.
Do you recollect, during your attendance
at those meetings, whether there was any sub-
division, any smaller meetings that the con-
ventipp was divided into ? — Yes.
What were they called? — ^The first name
they got %as divisions \ but they were afler-
;ivards called sections.
What terms did the members of the con-
vention generally address each other by ? —
The terms were different; but the general
term was, citizen.
Do you recollect that vou had different
conunittecs appointed in that convention for
the forwarding of business ^ — I do not recol-
lect several committees.
But some ? — I have heard some mentioned.
And what were they called? — ^That that
I recollect most, at present, was the com-
mittee of union.
Did you ever hear of a committee of
jwcresy? — Yes.
A convention of emergency? — I do not
recollect the hearing of tjiat.
Do you recollect hearing the term orgiaui-
sation mentioned ? — I do not remember.
Had you primary assemblies to refer to } —
I cannot say.
How were your meetings called ? — It was
generally called the British convention.
But when you met on a particular night,
and ta^ed about it the next day, what name
did you give it?-^The British convention.
Did you ever use the name of sittings?'*
Yes, frequently.
You say you attended as often as your
business permitted ?— Yes.
Have you had occasion to see the panel
there? — ^Yes, frequently.
Did you ever see him act as preses, or
chairman at these meetings?— Yes.
Did you ever hear him move any resolu-
tions at these meetings, of any kind? — I
have very frequently heard Mr. Margarot
speak ; but unless some particular resolution
be mentioned, I cannot say.
Do you recollect at any -time, any motion
or proposal for a committee of union ? — No/
I was not present then.
Do you 'recollect his having delivered a
speech, at any of the meetings you have
mended,* that had any relation to a conven-
tion bill ? — ^I do not recollect.
With any reference to such a bill as had
passed in Ireland ? — No.
Mr. SolicUor-GeneraL^Ho you remember
a motion being made by Mr. Callender? —
Ves.
Do you remember any thing what it was
about? — I remember one of the motions,
about the people meeting in defence of their
liberties, m case of any bill being brought
into parliament, similar to a convention bill
in Ireland against the constitution of the
country.
What did Mr. Callender propose that your
convention should do in tnat case ? — I recol-
lect a motion of that import being intro-
duced, and that Mr. Callender acknowledged
the motion as his ; but as to any thing rela-
tive to that motion, I do not know.
Were you present when the motion was
made ? — ^Therc was a rule in the convention^
that no motion Should be discussed the
same night on which it was made ; t was
{^resent when it was brought in by Mr. Cal«
ender.
What was it that Mr. Callender proposed
should be done in case such a bill should be
brought into the British parHament ?
Mr. Margaroi.-—! object to that question^
as it respects Mr. Callender, and not me.
Mr. Solicitor-General, — It is charged in the
indictment against the very panel; and
therefore I wifl repeat the question. What
was it that Mr. Callender proposed should hie
done, in case it should be brought into the
British parHament ?— That the people should
meet to assert their right, so far as I recol-
lect.
Was there any debate upon it that night?
— It is a rule jlhat there shall be no deoate
when a question is proposed.
Were you present when it was discussed ?
— ^Not when it was discussed in that shape iu
which Mr. Callender introduced it; but I
was when it was amended -. so fkr as I recol-
lect, the spirit of Mr. Callender's motion was
retained ; out it was very much extended :
there was a proposal oi what, in certain
events, should take place. I do not clearly
remember the circumstances about it ; but ft
was a motion for a secret committee, in case
those events should t^e place.
€47] 34 GEORGE in. Proceedings againH Maurice Mttrgardt {[648
And of the suspension of the Uabeos
Corpus act ? — I heard that mentioned.
^ Was it proposed that the convention should
(Msemble in certain events? — Yes, it was, that
they should meet in a certain place, in cer^
lain events.
Now, be so good as tell us what those
^e.nts were, as far as you remember jthem ?
—The one already named^ was that of a bill
being brought into parliament similar to the
\|»nvention bill in Ireland ; as to the other, I
cannot remember.
Was anv thing said about the suspension
pf the Habe^ Corpus act? — \ think there
^as.
Was there any thing said about the repeiJ
of the Scotch act, 1701, of wrongous impri-
i;onment ? — I do not recollect that
Was any thing said in case of an invasion
of foreign troops? — I think I remember
that.
Was any place fixed upon for the meetings?
how was that determined upon ? — ^There was
a motion that the place should be fised upon
ly a secret committee ; they were to find out
a way of letting the delegates know of it.
Was it not to be published ? — No.
>Yas it to be told them immediately, or
only told tliem when that emergency should
{lappen ? — There was a mention of a sealed
letter to be given to each delegate.
Who maae this motion respecting the
place of .meeting ?— J .cannot recollect
Read that paper.
/ [The witness reads it.!
f ''Citizen Margarot proposed the following
motion: That a secret committee of three,
>vith the secretary, be appointed to determine
the place where such cox^vention of emer-
gency shall meet ; and such place shall re-
main a secret with them, and with the se-
cretary of this convention; and, that the
delegates shall, at the breaking up of the
I' ^resent session, be entrusted withi a sealed
ettpr, containing the name of the place of
» 'meeting. This Tetter shall be delivered un-
opened to their constituents ; the receipt of
which shall be acknowledged by a letter to
the secretar)^, preserved in the same state,
imtil the period shall arrive at which it shall
be deemed necessary for the delegates to set
.off. This motion was seconded by ciUzen
'Moifett. ■
Is that the motion?— To the best of my
recollection there was a motion of a similar
.import to that.
^ Do you know who were the members of
this secret committee ?— I recollect some of
them.
Was Mr. Margarot one of them?— To the
^ best of my recollection, he M-as one of them.
Do you remember Mr. Margarot making
any speech to the convention before he had
made his motion ?^I do nut.
Do you remember his saying any thing
at all about its being a tocsin r— 1 do not.
You remember that the case of the con-
.vcniion bill was one of the cases of emer-
gency ?— Yes. ' .
You also recollect something about an in*
vasion being mentioned ? — I think I do.
Did you near any proposal during the time
you attended this meeting that this convei^
tion should act in case they should be di»«
pe^sed ?— Yes.
Who made that motion ?— I do not recol-
lect at present.
Do you think Mr. Marjgarot made a motioli
Qf that kind ? — It runs in my mind that he
did ; but I cannot swear that it was he.
Did you hear Mr. Margarot make any
speech that had a reference to that case ? — \
thiak I recollect something of Mr. Margarot
speaking as to the propriety of such a thing.
Are you sure ? — I cannot be particular ; but
there is a conceit in my mind that he did.
Do you remember Mr. Sinclair making a
motion of that kind ? — I think I do.
Do you remember any thing particular about
the passing of that?— So far as my recollecr
tion serves me, we were pretty unanimous.
Do you remember all the convention
standing up at the time they passed it ? — ^Yes,
I think I (10.
Did it contain any particular expressions
of their declaring before God and the world
that they would do so and so ? Do you re-
collect that that made a part of the motion?
—Certainly tliese words were mentioned, but
I am not certain whether it was the decided
resolutipn of the convention or not
Do you remember whether this motion, or
the resolution of the convention, bore any
thin^ that they declared before God and the
world that we should follow the wholesome
example of former times ? — I cannot say ; I
do not remember it.
Did it say any thing about paying no atten*>
tion to a convention bill if it should be pass-
ed ? — I think there was a mention of some-
thing similar to this, but whether it was
made a part of the final resolution of the
committee, I cannot tell : there was a great
deal of loose expressions made use of.
Did you hear any thing said in the conven-
tion about burning that resolution of Sinclair's?
— No, I beard nothing^ of that.
Did you hear any thing said about buming
any of the other motions ? — I do not recop
Icct ; they seemed to be confident of what
they were doing, and were not acting under
the apprehension of fear.
Was there any thing said about destroying
or not inserting it in the minutes ? — I do nox*
recollect.
At the time this secret committee was ap-
pointed, was there an^ opposition made to
It ? — I do not recollect
Thomiu Cockbum cross-examined by Mr.
Margarot.
It seems you are a member of the British
convention ?— I was.
What is your profession ? — ^My prpfesaioii
649]
Jqt Sedition*
is partly a manufacturer in the weaving line,
and pertly a merchant.
Do you pay anv taxes ? — I do.
Do you find these taxes heavy ? — I have
very often thought them very heavy.
You are a member of the Friends of the
People ?— Yes.
What was .your reason for joining the
Friends of the People ? — ^The reason was, a
thorough conviction of the necessity of a
reform in the British House of Commons.
What was your reason of accepting the
office of delegate in the British convention ?
— ^It was to help forward that great and
grand object that so forcibly struck my mind.
Did you mean to help it forward by leg^l
means or force of arms? — Force of arms was
never mentioned in the convention, and it is
the last thing that I should wish to see^ a drop
of blood spilt in the cause.
In the British convention did you ever see
any tendency to have recourse to open force ?
— It was diametrically opposite to my views to
have the least recourse to open force, nor was
it the subject of discussion in the convention.
Have you heard of a committee of union ? —
Yes.
What was to be the purport of that com-
nittee of union ? — So lar as I recollect, the
design of that committee was, to draw up rego-
lations, by which the people of England and
of Scotland, of the same sentiments, might
join in their endeavours to obtain that object.
You have heard of a convention of secrecy
likewise ? — Of a committee of secrecy I have.
Have you ever seen it customary in any
clubs, if ycu ever belonged to any, that there
should be i certain degree of trust reposed in
a small number of conGdential men, who
should form a committee and retain some se^
crets to themselves, not to be divulged to the"
world? Have you ever witnessed any such
thing, or does it strike you as an unprece-
dented thing ? — So far from striking me as an
unprecedented thing, that it strikes me upon
many occasions as a necessary thing, pru-
dential iy to keep secrets of every society
when it is necessary for their interest.
Have you ever heard of a committee of or-
fmization in the convention ? — Yes, I think
have.
What was the drift of that committee of or^,
fanization ? — ^What I conceive to be the direct
esign of that committee was, to form rules,
by which the convention might regulate them-
selves in their present and in their subsequent
meetings, if they should see occasion for
any.
Do you think that that committee of orga-
nization did not likewise refer to the internal
regulation of the convention ? — As I meant to
express in mv last answer, I considered the
committee of organization to refer chiefly to
the internal affairs of the convention, and
with respect to future conventions^ if there
should be such.
It seems that you have heard that Aieetings
A. D. 1794. [650
of the convention wore at times called sit-
tings ? do you imagine that that expression
was adopted as borrowed from a neighbour-
ing country, or that it was an exjpression
which followed of course, and to which wc
are thoroughly accustomed in the English
language ?— However the reading of newspa-
pers might lead us to make use of terms, I
cannot say ? but it was certainly a word that
it was very natural to make use of.
You have seen me act as preses ? — ^Yes.
That word is Latin, is it not ? — ^I am ver^
little acquainted with Latin ; I meant presi-
dent.
You are sufficiently acquainted with it to
know that at present Rome is the seat of the
Pope, are you not ? — ^We have no doubt of that;
Consequently if there is any criminality in
adopting a French word, do you think there is
not an equal criminality in using a Latin
one ? — ^These things appeared to me to be so
triHine, that I did not think it worth my while
to male any objection to them ; some were of
French origin, and some of British, and some
of Latin ; but I did not think it worth while
to make any objection to it.
You have heard of a motion proposed by
Mr. Callender ; vou were present when it was
originally moved, that the people should meet
to assert their rights in the convention? —
Assert their rights^ were the words^ to the
best of iny recollection.
What do you understand by a convention?
— What I understand by a convention is, 9
meeting of men for any purpose that they
propose.
Are the men who meet in convention sup-
posed to be delegated by a large body of men ?
— I cannot pretend a critical disquisition of
these points, but it strikes me so.
■^ By the word convention, and meeting in
convention, did you understand a peaceable
assembly of men assembled to deliberate, or
did you understand by it, an assembly of men
going to adopt violent measures, and to
carry them into execution themselves ? — ^What
I understand by convention was, that they
met with a sincere and hearty design to pro-
mote the good of the country, by a thorough
reform in the British House of Commons,
and that they meant to do this by peaceable
means.
Do you imaeine there are sufficient abuses
at present in the legislature of this kingdom,
to legalize our attempting to address them by
petiuon, or any form that might be legal and
constitutional ? — I have already said that I am
deeply impressed with the idea of the neces-
sity of it : I see the most glaring abuses in it.
Do you imadne that if a convention bill
was to oe passed, or was even to be brought
into the House of Commons, that it would
not show a disposition in the House of Com«
mons to extend their privileges, and to en-
croach upon our rights ?--Such a bill has al-
ways struck me as sapping the very founda-
tions of ^civil liberty; and, indeed going be-
651] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings agaimt Maurice Margaroi [65S
yond the power of the lesislatops themselves^
to deprive the people of their natural rights.
You say it is your opinion that there are
already sufficient grounds for the good people
of this country to demand a reform in parlia-
ment ; do you think those grounds would not
be increased by two such events as the bring-
ing in of a convention bill, or a motion for
suspending the habeas corpus act, which is
one of the greatest privileges a subject of Bri-
tain enjoys, or the bill for preventing wron-
gous imprisonment ; do you think that would
not make a very considerable addition to our
complaints ? — I am satisfied in my own mind,
that it would increase the grievances of the
people, and be like a grave-stone to their li-
derties.
In what light did you look upon the mem-
bers of the British convention ? Did you look
upon them as a turbulent set of vagabonds, or
did you look upon them as a body of men de-
legated by some of their fellow subjects for a
certain purpose, and that these men so dele-
gated were industrious, peaceable, creditable
men ? — ^Their design, I have no reason to call
in question, was the good of their country :
as to characters, there is always a mixture in
all assemblies; but I believe, taking the
whole together, there was a creat degree of
respectability with respect to characters.
Then they did not appear to you to come
under the description of swine, rabble, or
l^etches ? — As the friends of their country,
I believe not.
When is the properest time for men to as-
semble and deliberate ? Is it in time of dan-
ger, or prosperity ? It appears that the con-
vention was to assemble in this manner, in
the moment that an invasion of foreign troops
should take place in Great Britain. Do you
conceive that to be a time of danger, and
calling for the attention of all Britons through-
out the island ; or do you think it a time for
them' to sit idle and suffer themselves to be
enslaved by a foreign power ? — I think it is
high time that a reform had taken place, as
it Ought to have done long since.
When you have any thing that interests
you very much, do you publish it all through
your house, and difierent parts of your family,
or sometimes keep a secret to yourself m
your private affairs? — Yes, bo doubt; and
every person endued with any degree of pru-
dence will find occasion to keep their secrets.
If you had a particular piece of business to
do, and that you were apprehensive that a su-
perior power, inimical to your design and to
your welfare, would prevent you from doing
that particular business at such a place,
would you inform that inimical power where
you were to meet to do that Dusiness ? —I
should certainly do every thing in my power,
from common prudence, to keep it from him.
When you send a letter by the post to a
friend, do you ever attach any degree of cri-
minahty to sealing that letter till he gets into
the country, especially if you wish the con-
tents not to be known to him till a certain
period ? — ^No.
Can you discover any thing of a seditious
nature in a convention, standing up to pass a
resolution ? — No.
I find here something which I do not know
whether it is thoroughly assented to by you,
that there was a declaration before God and
the world, that they would follow the whole-
some example of their forefathers ; what is
the characteristic of Britons > — ^That they are
strongly attached to the cause of liberty.
IIow came we by the revolution ? was it by
any exertion of our forefathers ? — ^It no doubt
was.
How came we by the Ma^na Charta f-^
So far as I understand the subject, it was cer«
tainly by the same means.
Did your forefathers do wrong in so exert-
ing themselves ? — My opinion is that they did
not do enough.
Do you think it impossible for a House of
Commons to do an unconstitutional act?—
There have been m^y things done in the
House of Commons, which 1 sincerely re-
gret.
We had orizinally parliaments, or some
time back, uarUaments pf three years ; now
by an act of parliament they are lengthened
to seven years; suppose another act should
make them during lite, and a third act should
make them hereditary, do you imagine that
would be an unconstitutional act ? — It has
always strucit me as a thing beyond their
power to alter or destroy the fundamental
rights of the people, or any thing that would
extend their own power.
Do you imagine that the power originates
with the people ? — ^I do so.
Do you imagine it to be either in the Bill
of Rights, or the claim of rights," expressed,
that the people should be at liberty to meet I9
communicate to each other their grievances,
and plan methods for obtaining repdress ? — ^I
have oflen wished to see the Bill of Rights,
the Habeas Corpus act, and all thtAse things ;
but I have never had it in my powe^ ; but, hXi
my opinion, the object of all govei^nment is
the goo<t of the people, and that the liberties
of the people ought to be carefully guWded by
them. \
It appears by what has passed here, that the
convention h^d some notion of a God : did
they ever pray in their meetings? — ^Thcy
did.
Did you ever see any disorderly behiiviour
there? were they riotous or tumultuous? —
Considering their number, they were free of
that beyond many meetings that I have seen
of the same number: I saw no riotous meetings :
there were sometimes disputes, but no riots.
As to the burning of tne nK)tion, you said
they were not acting under the apprehensioxi
of rear : did you suppose they could justify
their proceedings? — I always consideredL
that in the convention the members that had
occasion to speak, always spoke freely, be*
653]
for Sedition*
A. D. 1794.
[654
lieving that they had nothing essentially se-
cret to keep to themselves, but that tlieir
great object was the good of their country.
Did you ever discover in the convention or
in the members of it, either in or out of the
convention, any propensity to sedition, trea-
son, or rebellion ? — I have always said, that
so far as I could discern the design of the
convention, it was, to obtain a thorough re-
form in the British House of Commons by
peaceable and legal means.
Mr. Alexander Attckesan sworo.
Lord Henderlandd — ^Have you any malice or
ill will aeaiast the nanel at the bar? — It is
impossible I shoula^ my lord : on the con-
trary, I esteem him a second Sidney. — I am
vety much obliged to the public prosecutor, on
account of my family; otherwise, I would
much sooner appear here as the panel at your
lordship's bar, than as a witness.
Countet for the Crown. — Were you a mem-
ber of the British convention ? — Yes, of all
the three conventions, I had the honour to be
^ delegate from the Canongate society ; the
delegates, considering themselves as dele-
ptes for six months, adjourned their meet-
mg; but upon the account of the coming
down of the English delegates, they resumed
it again.
•Hiat was in November last? — Yes.
"Who were the English delegates ?— There
were four or five of them ; there was citizen
Marsarot, citizen Sinclair, citizen Gerrald from
Xjondon, and citizen Brown from Sheffield.
Now did you act as secretary or assistant se-
cretary?— ^Yes, assistant secretary.
Were there a scroll of minutes drawn up ? —
Yes.
Look at that, and see if any part of it is
your hand-writing. — Yes, a very great part
of it ; but there were some others who wrote.
Who were they ? — George Ross, and after-
wards the convention appointed three assis-
tants daily.
Who is George 'Ross? — Clerk in the Ga-
setteer-ofiice.
This scroll of minutes, did they contain, so
far as you could judge, a fair and distinct ac-
count of what happened in the convention ?—
To the best of my knowledge and belief they
did. I should have been guilty of palming
Iklsehood upon the public and the convention
if they did not ; but there may have been mis-
takes.
Were they corrected the day after they
were made out ? — By no means ; they were
postponed till a future da)[, till a committee
should be appointed to revise them.
Was Mr. Margarot present at these meet-
ings commonly ? — As far as I observed, tie
was a regular attendant.
Was hie sometimes chairman at tlie meet-
(Dgs?— Once he certainly was.
Look at that ; whose hand-writing is it ? —
It is mine. [Reads it.] Citizen Margarot
oaoved, that a committee oe appointed to con-
sider of the means, and draw up the outlines
of a proper plan for a general union between
the two nations, as before prooosed.
Did Mr. Margarot make that motion?-^
He certainly did, or 1 should hot have mi-
iluted it down. A simple fact, like that, I
cannot be mistaken in ; but in a speech, vivA
voce, I might have made a mistake. FReads
it again.] And give me leave to ada, I ex-
pected, from Mr. Margarot's abilities and the
spirit of the times, a more perfect system than
was made up by a sycophant faction in the
reign of queen Anne.
Look at that.— [Reads.]— Citizen A. Cal-
lender moved, that in case the minister bring
into the Commons House a motion for a con-,
vention bill, it shall be noticed immediately
to the delegates. The words, <* shall be no-
ticed immediately to the delegates,^ are in my
hand -writing.
Do you remember any discussion in the
convention upon that motion; particularly,
did Mr. Margarot speak upon the occasion?—^
Indeed, my memory is so treacherous, that I
cannot recollect any thing, especially when I
am taking notes. If I (& not write at all, I
remember tolerab ^ well the chief facts; but if
I do write, I recollect nothing.
Was there any thing said about that event
being a tocsin to the friends of liberty ? — I
never heard the word tocsin mentioned m the
convention.
Do you remember any amendment or al«
teration upon Mr. Callender*s motion, or if
it gave rise to any otlier motion in the con-
vention ? — Such things may have happened,
but I cannot recollect.
Do you know of a motion being made by
Mr. Sinclair, in consequence of, and follow-
ing up, Mr. Callender's motion ? — I was 9k>-
sent a variety of nights, when I wished to be
present, but particular business kept me
away.
But did you hear Mr. Margarot make any
motion in consequence of Mr. Callender's ?— •
— It is impossible that I can say.
Did Mr. Sinclair make any motion about
the convention meeting on certain events ?—
Yes ; there was a motion made, at least I un-
derstood so. I came in one evening, pretty
late, and Mr. Sinclair, or some person, had
maue a motion ; and as soon as I had taken
my seat, Mr. Sinclair made a motion, that
something that had passed before should be
burned, and I was surprised, and got up and.
opposed it, and was seconded, upon the
ground, that as every thing we had none be-
fore was open for the ptmlic, we should do
nothing secret, ^nd therefore the motion was
not carried.
Did that motion relate to the delegates
meeting? — I was surprised and alarmed at
any thmg being secret; but when I under-
stood that notning more was meant bv it
than merely concealing tlie place where they
were to meet, I thought there was nothing at
all in it.
655] S4 GROEGE III. Proceedings agaimi Maurice Margarot [656
Lard Juttke Clerk. — Did you hear any
thing of a committee of secrecy f — I inquired
next day, and was told the nature of it, that
it was merely to conceal the intended place
of meeting, m case of opposition, and in case
of necessity.
Did you hear any thing ahout the conven-
tion of emergency at all in the meeting? —
Yes, at the sections, and amongst our friends.
Read that. — [Reads from the minutes.]
Citizen Margarot read and proposed the fol-
lowing motion : that a secret committee of
three, and the secretary, be appointed to de-
termine the place where such convention of
emergency snail meet; that such place shall
remain a secret with them and with the secre-
tary of this convention, and that each dele-
gate shall, at the breaking up of the present
session, be intrusted with a sealed letter, con-
taining the name of the place of meeting ;
this letter shall be delivered unopened to his
constituents, the receipt of which shall be
acknowledged by a letter to the secretary,
preserved in the same state, until the period
shall arrive at which it shall be deemed neces-
sary for the delegate to set off; this motion
was seconded by citizen Moffat. The greater
part of that is my own hand-writing.
You see mention is made there of a con-
vention of emergency; now I want to know,
as far as you recollect, the cases in which
they were to meet? — As far as I recollect,
they were to meet in case a motion was made
in parliament, to brin^ in a bill similar to
that, that passed in Ireland, to prevent our
having any meetings.
Was one of the cases the suspension of the
Habeas Corpus act? — I do not recollect.
Was the case of an invasion of foreign
troops mentioned ? — Yes.
Do you recollect any other case of emer-
gency, in which the convention were to meet?
— I do not recollect any other.
Was there another case, if any attempt should
be made to disperse the convention? Was
that a case in which they were to meet ? — I
cannot say that I recollect that.
Were you in the convention the evening
before the apprehension of Mr. Margarot and
Skirving, and the other persons.?— 5 might,
very possibly ; but I do not recollect I was
present that evening, after they had been ap-
prehended in the morning.
But do you recollect whether you were in
the convention the preceding evening? — I
cannot charge my memory with it.
Look at that. — ^The whole of that is written
by another person. [Reads from the minutes.]
Citizen Margarot begs leave to bring in a mo-
tion to the effect, that the moment of any il-
legal dispersion of the present convention,
shall be considered as a summons to the de-
k^tes to repair to the place of meeting ap-
pointed for tne convention of emergency by
the secret committee ; that the secret com-
mittee is instructed to proceed, without delay,
to fix the place of meeting j and that the same
motion be considered next evening; which
was accordingly granted. My lords, I ob«
serve, from the whole of this being written by
another person, that I was not present at all
that evening.
Lord Advocate. — Look at the first of these
papers. Numbers, of the general inventory,
and tell me if you ever saw it before ? — [Reads
from the minutes a motion for a union be-
tween the two kingdoms, to demand the re-
storation of their rights.] I think it is a most
excellent motion, my lord, and am very sorry
it was not followed up.
I did not ask you for your opinion, sir. — Mv
lords, I beg to say, this prosecution, and all
of them, are for opinions; and I must, be-
fore God, in justice to my country, declare^
that it is for opinions as well as facts. Gen-
tlemen of the jury, it is a prosecution for
opinions.
Look at that paper, which has your mark
upon it. — It has, but it is not my writing.
Where did you receive it ? — From the con-
vention ; I remember reading it from.the be-
ginning to the end.
Who is James Gartley?— He was delegate
from Glasgow.
Is it your hand- writing upon the back of
it? — Yes, it is.
Had you an opportunity of seeing the news«
papers, in which the proceedings of the con-
vention were published to the worl(l ? — I had
an opportunity ; but was so extremely hurried
at that time with my own business, and that
of the convention, tnat I could not read them,
but laid them by to be a treasure of entertain-
ment at some future time ; for four weeks, at
that time, I did not read a single article in
the Gazetteer.
Have you read them since? — ^Onlyinthe
sheriff Clerk's chamber ; and that seemed to
contain a very accurate account.
And corresponded with the minutes yott
yourself had taken ? — ^Yes.
Alexander AUchescn cross-examined by Mr.
Margarot.
You were a member of the British conven-
tion?— Yes.
Were you, prior to that, a member of the
Friends of the People ?— Yes, long prior.
What was your motive for associating with
the Friends of the People.? — ^The public ^od^
which, I hope, I will always have at hean.
What do you understand by the public
good? — I understand^ by the public good^
that grievances should be redressed, and every
man made as happy as possible.
Had you any specific plan ? — ^Yes, we bad
just two objects; these two objects were, a
shorter duration of parliaments, and a more
frequent election of representatives ; because
we considered the length of parliaments, and
the difficulty in the slow return of elections^
to be the two great and fundamental causes
of all the grievances which the nation labouia
under.
657]
far Seditioni
A. D. 17M.
[658
. What soft of iom were these with whom
3[ou associated, the Friends of the People ? I
do not particularly mean what class, high or
l«Wy rich or poor; but what morals, what
temper, what behaviour ? in short, what opi-
nion do you form of thend in general P — I con-
sidered them to be a good, moral, respectable
set of people; not respectable in point of
riches, but in that respect which will be
looked at by the ail- seeing eve of the Al-
mighty, respectable in point of morals.
Did the^ ever show any disposition to trea-
son, sedition, or felony ? — Kot that I ever
saw.
Were you delegated by a society of the
friends of the People to the convention ? —
I was some time.
Did the other members of the convention
Tepreseni a number of meo from here? —
Yes,'
- Did it appear to you^ that the convention
adhered to the spirit of reform which was set
on foot by the Friends of the People? — They
certainly did, to the be^t of my ideas ; and
even when they followed up the primary idea
of shorter duration of parliaments, and more
irec[uent elections, and adopted the idea of
tmiversal sufirage and annual parliaments,
ihey went certainly no farther than the duke
of Richmond and Mr. Pitt had gone before.
You must take care not to mention that
ivord primary, becausef it may inculpate me
farther; for that is one word that is charged
ajgainst me. — ^I consider all words in our dic-
tionary lawful to be used ; and it is a dread-
ful crisis that we are come to, if a man is to
he criminated for a word.
'^ You spoke of the English delegates ; yoii
do not mean that they represented the people
of England? — Certainly only those who sent
ihem. I \mderstood that Mr. Margarot and
Mr. Sinclair represented ai)out 5,000 people,
and Mr. Brown about 5^000 from Sheffidd^
You have not positively sworn to the entire
flcfoll of minutes shown to you; some part of
it you do not acknowledge? — I can only swear
|o that that was wrote by myself; and se far
as my ideas led me to tbinky I was right in
imting them^
Though the name of Minutes is given to
. them, are they, in fact, the minutes of the
convention, till they have received the revisal
of the committee ?--Certainly not; to correct
and to expunge all errors whatever.
' Were they ever oSeted or sent forth to the
world by way of publication ?— Not that I
Jcnow-of,
Were they ever corrected by authority of
the convention? — t never heard of it.
. Are there any erasures, any interlineations
in them? — Several emendations were made
upon the motions of one or two members ;
'but when several emendations were proposed,
it was said, you may leave that to the com-
mittee.
, To, the best of yoar recollection, 1 made a
motion about the union of the two kingdoms ;h
VOL. xxm. 1
did it appear to you, that that motion had a
seditious tendency ?-rOn the contrary, I con^
ceive it would be for the good of mankind,
and the salvation of these kingdoms.
Do you look upon tocsin to be a French
word ? — I suppose so ; but I cannot say that
it is; I never heard it made use of in the con-
vention.
Are you sure that it is not, instead, of one
French word, two Chinese words ? — I cannot
say; I know nothing about the Chinese.
I have a notion it is ; then all the know-^
ledge you gained of a secret committed, was
the next day among the sections, and among
the Friends? — That reminds me of a mistake
1 made before ; for I find that 1 have recorded
that very motion which Mr. Sinclair moved
to be burned, and which was afterwards
aereed not to be burned ; and I heard farther
of the business next day.
There was a motion made for a convention
of emergency j did the convention ever fix
upon, or deUneate the plan by which they
were to act, or did that convention ever tak^
place ?•— Not that I know of.
In joining the Friends of the People^ and
in joining the British conventiop, for tiie pur-
pose of obtaining a reform, did yoU think
yourselves warranted by the constitution to
endeavour to obtain a redress of grievances?
— Perfectly ; and I would think 30 Still if I
were to .l>e sent to Botany Bay for it.
Are those snievainces done away?-^By n^
means ; and 1 am sorry for it.
. Are you of opinion, that if a Canventioii
Bill was passed in the British parliament, it
would tend to lessen those gnevaooes? — 1%
would '^xt^nd them twofold.'
What would be the consequence of the'
suspension of the Habeas Corpus act, and of
the act for preventing wrongous imprison-
ment?— It woiild lie ceriainfy a f^eat en-
CTM^ment upon the privilege of Britons.
Might not every peaceable inhabitant of
th^e realms run great danger^ in case of a
foreign invasion, of losing his property, by
the enemies plundering him of it, if they were
siiccessfid ?— -I have no douht of that.
Do you thiiiik it would be more constitu-
tional m EngHshmen, more constitutional in
Scotchmen, more penstitutional in Britons,
to sit idle, and look ai a foreign invasion, or
attend a convention of emergency ? — ^I dare
say the whole Court, and all the audience will
ag^. that to meet upon siich an occasion,
would be a work of necessity,
f Was foreign inVasion the expression that
"was made use qL or was a French invasion
ever mentioned?— As far as I recollect,
French invasion was mentioned iii some per-
son's motion: but I cannot say in whose
motion, or wheihef it was in doors, .or out of
doors; o^ in the convention, Or out of the
convention, t cannot say.
Then you mean to say, that an invasion
from France, was uppermost in the minds ot
th^ convention.?'-'! cannot say what was yp-
659} S4 GEORGE III. Proceediagi againa Maurice Margaret [660
permost; but I know I have heard that ex*
pression^ but I believe it was out of the con-
vention.
Was it customary for motions to be handed
to the table, which were not passed in thp
convention? — Many such were handed in,
and many not passed, and not taken notice of
at all.
Are you certain, that the two motions
shown vou just now, and which were in-
dorsed, by you, and, I presume, were given
in to you in that manner, are ypu sure they
were ever read in the convention? — Be so
good as show me them again [looks at them.]
One of these motions, is certamly new to me
since I came before the Court: a person
might sa,y to me, there is a question concern-
ing the union, and I might indorse it so with-
out ever readine it'
What was the mode of proceeding, in
opening and closing the business of the day P
'^As the business of all Christian people
should be, it was begun and ended by prayer.
Did you ever observe any thing of a se-
fiitious or riotous appearance in the conven-
tion ?^Not in the least.
Did you ever hear any thing mentioned, or
whispered in the convention, that might tend
to overturn the constitution ? — ^Ncver.
Did you ever hear any thing mentioned
fiiere against the king ? — ^Never.
Did you ever hear any thing mentioned
there against placemen and pensioners? —
Often.
That, I suppose, is the sedition that is
meant to be charged.
George Roes sworn, examined.
Witnest. — ^I thought it very hard that the
lord advocate, when I was here before, should
charge me with falsehood.* I hope he will
not 00 so now.
What profession are you of ?--Clerk in the
Gazetteer Office.
How long have you been in that profession ?
—Seven or eight years.
Were you a member of the meeting of the
Friends of the People P-— Yes.
Were you a member of the British conven-
tion ?— Yes.
Delegate from what Society P—Ftom the
Canon^tc society.
Did you act in any particular office in the
convention? — ^I sometimes acted as assistant
secretary.
Who else assisted thcf secretary ?— Several
persons.
Were there any persons who wrote'shortp
hand, and took down the debates ?— Yes, my
brother.
Look at these minutes, and'see if you can
find ^our own hand-writing P-^Yes.
Did you take down, to the best of your
* See th^ lord udvocate^s observations en
the depositions of this witoesPi oo the tiial
of SkttviDgyonfa,
abilities, what did really pass in the conven-
tion ? — I certainly would take nothing down
that I thought improper.
And you would take down nothing but
what passed ? — ^No.
Do you recollect, if it was the practice, at
the commencement of the meeting, to read
over the scroll of the minutes?— I have Seen
it done sometimes, and sometimes nof.
Do you recollect whether it was ever usual
to correct them upon reading them over ?— I
think, I recollect one night, there were some
corrections.
Are you acquainted with that gentleman ?
*-I have had the honour to see Mr. Margarot
many times, and been in his compan}r.
Was he a member of the convention P— >
Yes.
Have jou heard him speak ?<— Yes, I have
heard him propose motions.
Did you ever see him act as chairman ? — I
cannot recollect to a certainty, whether he
was or not.
Do you recollect any motion in the conven-<
tion with respect to a union between Endaud
and Scotland ? — ^I recollect the union witn the
societies of the Friends of the People in England.
Read that.-^Reads.] Margarot moved,
that a committee be appointed to consider,?—
I do not recollect that
Whose hand- writing is it? — I believe it is
3ir. Aitcheson*s.
You recollect there was such a motion ?—
Yes, that there was a union to take place be*
tween the English societies and the scotch.
Do you remember any motion being made
of a convention of emergency ? — ^Yes.
Do you remember any thing about the pur-
pose of that convention ; of the events io
which they were to meet? — ^To remonstrate
to parliament against a bill, such as a convex^
tion bill.
Were there any particular persons who
made a motion respecting it? — I beheve it
was made bv Mi*. Callender.
[Reads Mr. Calender's motion.]
Do you recollect that that motion was
made ? — Yes, it is my hand-writing.
Do you remember the events that were to
happen? — ^That, in case of a convention bill,
they were to meet in order to draw up a re-
monstrance to parliament.
Was any other event mentioned ? anything
about ^e Habeas Corpus act?— I do not at
present recollect.
Do you recollect any thing about a foreign
invasion, or any thing about foreign troops ?
— Yes, about the Hessians and Hanoverians
being brousht over.
You spoke about Mr. Callender*s motion :
when was it taken up?* the next day?— I
cannot say.
Was the convention used to take notice of
the motions at the time they were made, or
did they lie over ?— They generally laid over.
Was that motion of Mr. Callexder's taken
up afterwards ?— I cannot say.
661]
Jb/r SedHion*
A. D. 17M.
[662
Was there any debate about Mr. Callendei^s
motion respecting the convention bill? and^
recollect yourself before you give an answer.
*— >I cannot be particular.
Were there anv amendments proposed to
that motion ? — I believe there were.
Whai resolution was come to in conse-
41ueDce of the amendment? — I do not know
particularly; I do not recollect
Is that vour writing? — ^Yes. [Reads.]
Citizen Sinclair read the amendments upon
citizen Cailender's motion ; — and then there
-comes some other person's writing;— and, it
wasajj^r^, that the house should resolve it-
self mto a committeoi to consider of the
ivneodments proposed ; the convention beine
,fe3umed, and the amendments being read
over, the members stood upon their lees, and
Bolemnlv and unanimously passed the follow-
ing resolution.
Now recollect yourself, and tell us what
passed at that time. Was it a resolution upon
citizen Callender's motion ? — Yes.
Now recollect what that motion was^ — ^I
cannot tell.
Look if it is mentioned there ? — ^No, there
is a blank page follows it. The resolution
then passed, was reserved to be entered till
the end of the minutes.
Lmrd Advocate, — ^It is very material that the
jury ^ould take down these words ; for it is
that upon which I shall found a verv material
part of what I shall have to say to them. Re-
peat it aeain.
I think the resolution that was then passed,
was left to be entered at the last part of the
minutes.
liook, and see if you find any more blanks ?
—I believe there are not. [Looks over the
minute.] Yes, here is a blank of four lines.
Do vou remember any proposal being
made about burning any part of the written
evidence, or destroymg any motion or resolu-
tion the convention bad come to ? — ^No, I do
not recollect.
Do you know Mr. Aitcheson ?— Yes.
Do you recollect any objection being made
b^ him to burning or destroying any resolu-
tion that they might have come to ? — ^No, I
.do not.
Do you recollect any other person^ a mem-
ber of that convention, objecting to that
.measure?— I do not recollect any such thing.
Mr. Burnettj^I}o you remember a motion
f being made for a secret committee ? — ^Yes.
Mr. Solicitor Genera/.— Who was it that
proposed that motion, which passed solemnly
. and unanimously ?— I cannot say.
Did the members all stand up when that
.motion nassed so solemnly? — ^I do not re-
collect; but I should suppose so, from what
is written here.
Do you remember any thing about declar-
ing belbre God and the world, any thing?-— I
cannot say.
Do you remember any thing that was ssud
about caiamkous cJirumfftanres I-^Nqj there
was a resolution in case of a convention bill.
Do you xemember an^ thing about paying
no re«urd to such.an act if it passed ? — ^I never
would agree to that.
Do you remember any speech or motion
beine made as to what tne convention vrerp
to 00, upon the meeting being dispersed ?
--If they were disperse, they were to meet
in another place.
Who was it tiiat spoke with regard to that?
did Mr. Marearot sa^ anv thine, or make a
speech upon that subject? recoOect yourself.
-*I cannot recollect.
Was it debated ? Was there any difference
of opinion iqion that subject?—! cannot re-
collect.
Do you remember any motion being made
with regjard to it ? — ^I believe there was.
Was It Mr. Margarot that made the ro<^
tion ? — I am not very certain whether he did
or not. but I rather suspect he did.
Look at that paper [a motion for appointing
aplaceof meetme]. Did you ever see that
paper before ?«— Yes, in thb court.
Do you recollect Such a motion being
made, and if Mr. Margarot was the person
that made it? — ^Yes.
You ssdd some time aso that you acted as
clerk in the Gazetteer-omce, and that your
brother took notes in Short-hand of the d^
bates in the convention; now were they
printed ?'My brother took the notes.
Did you read them ?— Yes, after they were
printed.
So far as you yourself read, were they ac-
curate?— ^They were pretty exact.
Was any thing said, so far as you remem-
ber, in the printed paper which had not
passed in the conventions —I cannot say.
Was tiie statement ^ven in the Gazetteer
accurate of those motions and resolutions
which you yourself heard ?— I believe they
were.
Do you recollect any speech by Mr. Mar-
garot, or any body else, in which spies were
mentioned ? — No, I do not.
Who is the manager of the Gazetteer?-—
Mr. Scott
This is a paper which is printed in the Ga-
zetteer-office, I suppose? — ^it looks like it
Is it a copy of tne Gazetteer ?— Yes.
George Ron cross-examined by Mr. Margorot,
Are you a judge of sedition? — I do not
know what sedition is.
Have you any idea of treason?— Yes, I
have.
What is your opinion of loyalty ?— loyalty
is certainly to be true to the constitution of
the country.
Have you ever seen any thing in my beha-
viour of a seditious tendency ?— -1 do not know
what sedition is; ifyou will toll me what s^
dition is, I will tell you.
Tbat IS a difficult thing; it seems nobody
is agreed uDon ib^V here. Have ^ou ever
seen ^le benave ia an oulrageousy indecent
663] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings ngaimi Maurice Margarot [664
manner ?— »No ; you expressed a vish to have
grievances redressed.
Did .1 ever express a wish to overturn the
«onstitiitioo, or bring it back to its original
purity ?— -To bring it back to its origmaT pu-
Did I ever express a wish to throw every
thing into confusion, or to obtaun a reform in
parliament? — That was what you always
wished, to petition for a reform
Was my behaviour consonant to my pro-
fessions ill that respect? — ^Yes.
Have you ever seen me drunk ? — ^Never.
Have vou ever seen me in a passion ?— I
Bever did.
Have I ever had any revising of what has
here been called the Minutes of tne Convention
in the oflice of tHe Gazetteer ?^Neyer that I
^nowof.
Among your ideas of the convention of
emergency, did you imagine that that con?
Vention was to proceed to open force, or rar
tiier that it was to meet to deliberate F— To
meet and to petition parliaifient ibr a redress
pf grievances.
Tou heard mej it seems, njuentipn spies;
did I ever express any fear of them ?-— iHo, I
fio not recollect hearing you mention spies.
I understood that you siud so ? — ^No.
Did yoiu ever see any thing in the conven-
tion but what was perfectly peaceable and
prderly ? — I never saw any member behave
disorderly or unpeaceably.
Were there not some regulations drawn up
Ibr the more orderly regulation of the com-
inittee? Was not that the business which
we first set about ? — I do not recollect exact! v ;
but I think there was a committee of regufa-
fion.
The question I am going to put, will re-
auireyour recollection and the attention of
^e jury. Have you ever heard any man
fieclare himself my enemy? — ^I have heard
several people declare themselves enemies to
HS as tne British convention, but I cannot
^pdescend to recollect anv particular person.
Were you in the ^erifrs office Xhi same
day that I was ?--Ycs.
Did you hear me converse with any of the
messengers there ? — ^I recollect being in the
iiherifF derk's chamber when there were some
soietseogers there; Qne pf them and ypu h^d
aome words.
What did he say ?^I do not recollect the
£ articular word he said, but I know he said
>methine ^hich I thought im})roper at the
time ; I tbink it was one Lyon if I recollect
right
You cannot recollect what that man said?
»-No.
What was the subject of the dispute ; you
say there were words passed between us? — I
believe the substance of it was his manner of
seizing you ; that he would not show you the
warrant he hsd to take you up, or something
of that.
sion
And have fou entirely forgot his expres-
»n?-^Ye8«
You have been asked about burning or des-
troying a motion. Did you ever hear me say
any tlung to tiiat purpose ? — ^No.
Did you say I was chosen a member of the
secret committee ?— I cannot say.
Did that secret committee ever act to your
knowledge ?— Not that I know of.
Have you seen me act as preses or chair-
jDfin ? — I am not very certain.
What is the business of a president of the
convention ?— To keep order.
Is he merely to regulate the behaviour or
the speech of the convention ? — Merely to re-
gulate the behaviour of the convention.
His powers go no farther ? — No.
It appears that the blank that is lefl in
the minutes, that the writing just before it
is your hand-writing ?— -No| that was anothf^
blank for four lines.
WiiUam Jtou sworn,
Mr. Burnett —What profession are you of ^
— Clerk in the Gazetteer-office. '
Were you a member of the meeting of the
Friends of the People?— Yes. '
Were you a member of their society when
it got the name of the British Convention? —
Yes.
Was Mr. Margarot a member?— He was
there, and I understand him to be a member.
Do you know who acted as secretary to the
committee .>— Mr. Skirving.
Had Mr. Skirvine any assistance ?— I hftve
seen my brother taking notes.
Did you ever take notes?— Never as assis-
tant to the secretary.
And what was your reason far taking notes?
—For my own amusement, and forpublicap*
tion.
Do you write short-hand ?— Yes.
Did you take them in short-hand upon an j
occasion ?— Yes.
Recollect, if what you took down, was an
accurate statement, as far as your abilities
went, of what passed in the convention ?-^I
do not know whether it was an accurate state-
ment: I did not make it wilfuUv not inaccu-
rate ; I was taken with a cold, and did not
hear well
Lord Justice C/erA;.— You wished to make
it accurate ?— I did not wish to make il inac-
curate.
Were they afterwards published in the Ga-
zetteer?—Yes, from the notes that I took I
drew out an account, which was published in
the Gazetteer.'
Does it consist with your knowledge, that
the minutes were read over to the convention,
the next day after?— No.
Had you occasion to revise your notes in
the Gazetteer after they wore thrown off.—
Yps.
Did it appear to be an accurate statement
of what had passed in the convention ?<«-£x-
actly, as far as I recollect. *
Have you ever had occauon to see the scroll
of the mmutes of the convention? sbouUyou
665]
fer8te^ihn»
A. D. 17d4'.
[666
know them agaaa if yoa should see them?— >I
have seen them lying there.
Should you know your brother's hand-
writing?—Ves.
Was Mr. Callender a member of the con-
vention ?-— He used to attend there.
Did you ever hear any thing of a motion
made by him respecting the convention bill?
•*I recollect such a motion being made in
ihe convention.
Whom was it made by ? — ^I am not certain.
Do you remember hearing a debate upon
the motion respecting the convention bill ? —
I recollect there was a debate upon that mo-
tion, but I do not recollect the particulars.
Dio you remember any thing mentioned in
that debate respecting a convention of emer-
gency?— I think it was at the same time that
the convention of emergency was mentioned.
Do you remember any other event in which
case it was to take place ? — ^I do not recollect.
Do vou remember any thing havins been
* 1 about a foreign invasion m that debate ?
believe there was something said about a
foreign invasion.
Are you sure nothmg was said as to a French
invasion? — ^No.
Was anythinj; ssud about Hesuans and
Hanoverians ? — f do not recollect that; it was
in eenera) troops, and foreign invasion.
Was any thing said of fordgn troops land-
ing in this country ? — ^I believe there was, but
I cannot say I heard mention made of both.
Did you hear of the Habeas Corpus act? —
Yesy on the same occasion.
Do you remember any motion, or any
fl^ipeech naving been made with resnect to the
dispersion of the meeting, and wnat was to
be done in that event ? — ^I recollect something
being said about the dispersion of the meet-
ing ; that if they were iil^^y dismissed, the
convention should meet
Lcrd Justice C(erib.-*Do you mean the
convention of emergency? — I suppose it
meant the members then present.
Do you recollect who it was that spoke
wiUi regard to the dispersion of the meeUng?
— ^A. number of persons spoke, and I do not
recollect who it was.
Did Mr. Margarot make a speech upon
that subject?-— I think he did.
Did you hear of any motion being made
with regard to a secret committee?— Yes.
How many did it consist of ?— I do not re*
collect the number.
Do you remember who made the motion
with Tteaxd to it ? — ^I do not recollect.
Was Mr. Margarot a member of the secret
oommittee?— I do not recollect whether he
was or not.
Look at that paper; did you see it in the
convention at any time ?— I never did.
Did you hear that motion made for a con-
vention of emergency ?— I recollect a motkm
to that purpose having been made.
Do you remember any thing of a secret
^committee being appointed ?<*x«s.
Was Mr. Margarot a member of it?— I do
not recollect.
[Shows turn three Gazetteers.] Look if
they were published at your ofEce ? — ^Yes.
Lord Justice Clerk, Were these publican
tions known to the convention ? — They were
to individuals in the convention.
Was it never mentioned in the convention
that it was to be published ? — It was men*
tioned that an account of the proceedings of
the convention was to be published, but I
do not recollect that that was in the conven-
tion.
Lord Eskfrave. Was there no resolution in
the convention to support that paper?-— There
was some motion to tnat purpose, but I do not
recollect any resolution being come to upon it.
William Bms cross-examined by Mr. Mar-
gard.
You took notes for the purpose of publbh-
ing them in the Gazetteer. Did you ever
submit these notes to me before they were
published ? — ^I never did.
You say you were as accurate as posable f
— -I do not know that I was inaccurate.
Are you hard of hearing? — I was at that
time, and still do continue a littie so.
Was there ever any talk in the convention
of our convention of emergency being for the
purpose of assisting the French if they invad-
ed this country? — I never heard of such a
thing.
Did such a thing ever enter your head?-*
No.
Nor any body else, in their senses, I be-
lieve. You have heard of a secret committee.
Do you know whether that secret committee
overdid anv thing? — ^I never heard of their
doing any thing.
What was the mode of appointing commit-
tees ?— The general mode was, tliat they were
appointed by the sections.
Was there not among the regulations of the
convention, one which expressJv enjoined on
such members, as should be chosen to any
office, to accept of tiie same; that is to say,
that it barrea them a refusal?— I think I
have a recollection of that, but I am not posi-
tive.
You say I made that motion for the eon-
vention of emergency. Did I propose to re-
pair to that convention armed? — I did not.
near any thing of that sort.
Did I propose carrying on, by that means,
any correspondence with any foreign enem^
from whom an invasion was to be expectedr
—No.
Was the Gazetteer submitted to the con-
vention b^ore it was published ?— -That wsi
impossible.
Then they did not superintend the publican
tion of the Gazetteer ?— Surely not.
Did they ever order the printing of the Ga-
zetteer f—No.
At whose expense was it carried on?-^t
the expense of the publisher, Mr. Scott«
667] 34 GBOKGE III. Proceedings agamd Maurice Margarot [668
The coavention never furnished any thing
towards the expense of the printing } — Never
aiarthing.
T];ien it was carried on totally independent
of the convention?— I understood it to be so.
It seems that you recosnize the scroll of
what IS here denominated ue Minutes of the
Coi^ention; could you swear to it?~No, be-
cause I never saw it till I saw it in the sherifi^s
chamber. I have seen a scroll of minutes
lying upon the table, but I never perused
them.
Does there appear to be any alterations, or
interlineations m that pretended scroll? — ^I
have seen the pen drawn through some
words..
It appears then, that you know nothii^ at
all about-that scroll? — ^No, I never perused
any of it till I saw it in the sheiiff^s cham*
ber.
When the illegal dispersion of the conven-
tion was spoken of in the convention, did
grmi thereby understand a dispersion of the
convention in a constitutional manner, ac-
cording to the laws of the land, or did you un-
derstand a dispersing of it by force, unaided
bjr Iaw8?-^I understood the dispersing of it
without law.
Lord Advocate, — ^Did you understand, that,
by the words illegal dispersion, was meant
any dispersion by the magistrates of Edin-
burgh, or the sheriff of the county?— I un-
derstood it meant a dispersion without any
law.
Mr. Margaret. — ^What Is your opinion of
magistratesr are they to act according to
law, or do you apprehend there is a code of
laws in this countiy which is to be the rule of
their conduct ?— I understood that the magis-
trates were to act according to law ; and tnat
if they did disperse the convention, it would
be without law.
[John Wardlam was sworn, but appearing to
be intoxicated, was ord^^ to witndrawT]
iMrd AdoocatC'^lf we may judge from the
appearance of this man, he is in a state of in-
toxication, and certunly very unfit to be exa-
mined in a court of justice, as a witness ; I
ahould therefore, were his evidence never so
material, avoid examining him ; but before I
aoee to jpLve him up, I wish to be satisfied
whether it is the real state of the man at this
moment, or whether, which is possible, it
may be a mere pretence, and an appearance
put on by himself, on purpose to avoid being
examined ; if your lordship will allow him to
to be called back again, and put such ques-
tions to him as mav be deemed proper, that
the jury and your lordships may be satisfied
whether he is so or not.
liord Henderland, to the Macer. — Did you
observe any thing particular in the appear-
ance ofthis witness in the mommg ? — tie lui-
peared to be tho same in the mormng that he
IS now.
(The witness oalkd in again.]
Lird Advocate^ Were you inclosed . this
morning, at the same time, with the other
witnesses ?— Yes.
Have you got any provision since you went
into that room ?— Yes.
Have you eot any liquor? — Yes.
Any*consi(terable Quantity? — ^None at all.
Lord Advocate, lie says he is not in liquor,
therefore, we may proceed to examine him^.
Were vou a memoer of the British conven*
tion? — Yes, I had the honour to be a dele-
gate.
Did you frequently attend the meetings of
that convention ? — ^Yes.
Did you ever assist as secretary there, upon
any occasion ?-^Never.
Did you write any minutes of the meeting
at that time ? — ^When I was called upon to do
so, I did.
Did it happen at any time ? — ^Yes, once.
Have you seen the panel at any of those
meetings ? — ^Yes.
Did you ever see him act as preses^ or
chairman at this meeting ? — No.
Look at that, and see whose hand-writing
it is ? — ^I believe it is my writing.
Who g^ve you that motion! — ^I wrote it
myself.
Who proposed it to you?— I proposed it
myself.
Did you write it by desire of any body?---
No.
What is your profession ? — ^A writer.
Lord Advocate^ — ^Are you in anv writing
chamber ?~I am a writer, and that is
enough.
Lm Eskgrave,-^ In whose chamber do
ou write?— That is not the question, my
ord; you do not speak to the point; you
must speak to the pomt, my lord.
Lord Advocate. — Did you second the mo-
tion ? — Yes, I counted it a laudable and pro-
per motion.
Who desired you to second it ?— I did it
myself, of my own free will.
Did Mr.. Margarot report that motion?— I
believe he did ; because it was his motion ;
and I wrote it, and seconded it
Did you see Mr. Margarot sign it?— I do
not recollect his signing it; I oo not recol-
lect whether he wrote it or not Mr. Marga-
rot is a man of courage, and a num of honoun
and a man of virtue ; and a man that would
not deny his word— by God.
Lord Juttice C^Jb.— What is that you say ?
—I said he would not deny his word.
Lord Juttice C/erft.— But you said some-
thing else ? — ^I said by God.
l2rd Justice derk—He is either drunk, or
affecting to be drunk* l^y Qwn opinion is,
that he is affecting to be drunk ; and, supposing
he is not affecting drunkenness, he ougnt not
to get drunk,' knowing that he was to be
called here as a witness.
I
* See in this volume, j»a#, the second exami-
nation of Thomas Dunn, on the trial of Tho-
mas Walker and others^ ior ft conspiracy^
6603*
jfbf SediUan*
A.J). 179*.
L670
Lord Hentkrland.^ move thtt he be com-
mitted to prison for a month.
He was committed.
Samuel Fatcnon sworn*
Mr. SoHciior Gcfiera/.— -Are yon a member
of the British convention? — ^Yes, of the con-
vention that sat on the 19th of November.
Was it called the British convention ?— It
got that name afterwards.
You were acquainted with Mr. Callender,
who was also a member of that convention ? —
Yes.
Were you ever present in the convention,
when a motion was made by him^-*I can-
not recollect
Do you remember a motion being made of
what the convention were to do in case of
a bUl being brought into parliament like the
convention bill that passed in Ireland ? — I was
not there when that motion was discussed.
Were you ever present when any motion of
a rimilar nature wts discussed ? — ^No.
Were you ever present at any time when
the motion was made respecting the illegEd
dispersion ?^No.
Is that paper your hand-writing?— -Yes, it
is not only signed by me, but the body of it was
drawn up by the section to which I belonged^
and was by me transmitted to the conven-
tion.
Samuel Paterum crosa-ezammed by Mr. Jlfor.
garvt.
This motion or paper, or whatever it is,
was drawn up in your class and brought to
the convention. Was it ever read m the
convention ? — All that I can say for this pa-
per is, that it was di^wn up W the class to
which I belonged, and I was informed that it
was deliverer to the preses for the time
being, and I was not there that night; I was
only there four nights altogether, and per-
haps, once or twice only [resuls the minutes.]
jLord Juttice Clerk. — Did you give it in
yourself?— I am not certain; there was always
a return made every day of a new preses ror
the succeeding day.
Mr. Margarot, And you cannot tell to
whom it was delivered ?— -It was delivered to
the secretary I suppose.
How are you certain it was delivered, if you
were not present at the time of the deliveiy ?
•—I am not certain of it.
GenUemen, pray attend to this: by what
authority did the classes or the sections, or
whatever the v may be thought proper to be
called ; by what authority md they draw up
any motion or paper? Was it by .the express
command of tne convention, or was it an
authority that thev assumed of themselves,
as meanmg to send their intentions, their opi-
nions, to the convention there to be dis-
cussed?—It was generally by the authority of
the minutes from the convention the prece-
ding night ; but that paper was, as far as I
recollect drawn up without any minutes hav-
ing been sent by tne convention.
You say this was drawn up by the class
without any interference of the convention ?—
As far as my memory will cliarge me^ that
was the case.
You were originally a member of the
Friends of the People, and then a delegate to
the British convention, and I understand you
have seceded from them ? — ^Yes.
I must bee to ask one question. Does a
reform in paniament appear less necessary to
you at present than it did then ? — ^I must ap-
peal to the Court whether that is a propec
question or not
Lord Juttice Clerk. — ^We have eiven full
scope to the panel, because he is a foreigner ;
but when a witness refuses to answer a quea*
tion that is not proper, we are bound to say
he need not, unless he chooses.
Mr. Margarot, — I will not press upon a
sore place. Do you know that that was read
in the convention ?— I do not know ; I was
not there that night when the question was
debated.
Lord Adtocate.'-^Wiih the declaration of
tiie panel, we shall now close the evidence on
the part of the prosecution.
The declaration of the panel lead.
Maurice Margarot, merchant in Maiy-Ie^
bone. No. 10, mgh-street, London; being ezr
amined and interrogated, whether he was a
men^^erof the British convention of the de*
le^tes of the people, associated to obtain
universal sufiiraffe and annual parliaments^
assembled in £iinburgh ; declares, that he
does not acknowledge the legality of^a private
examination, and declines answering the
question; and being interrogated from what
place or district he is a delegate to the sud
convention, declares he declines to answer
the Question, for the reason above specified;
and oeing interrogated whether he has made
any motions in said convention, and of what
nature, he declares he must decline answer-
ing the question, for the reason above speci-
fic. And being shown the p&per, siened
Manrice Margarot and John Warolaw, of the
tenor following : that the moment of any ille-
eal dispersion of the present convention shall
be considered as a summons to the dele^tes
to repair to the place of meeting, appointed
for the convention of emergency by the se-
cret committee, and that the secret committee
ia instructed to proceed without delay to fix
the place of meeting.
(Signed) Maorics MiaoAaoT.
John Wardlaw.
-—And being asked, if he made any motion
in the convention last ni^ht, or any other
time, must decline answermg the question,
for the reason above-mentioned. And being
interrogated if he came to Scotland at the in*
vitation of anv person or person^ in this toun-
tiy, declares be must decline answering this
or anv other questions, for the reason above
specified: and this he declares to be truth.
This declaration was made aad re«d over to
67 1] S4> GEORGE III. Proceedings ofraina Muume Margarot (1672
biniy in the presence of William Scott, of
Hariy Davidson, and Joseph Pringle. '
(Signed) William Scott.
Harry OAvrosoN^
Joseph Pringle.
• Lord Justice Cferft.— Now is your time,
Mr. Margarot, to bring forward your exculpa-
tory proof.
Mr. 'Miirgarot. — How can I bring forward
my exculpatory witnesses, when they are not
present, and I am not granted a caption for
them?
Lord Justice Clerk. — Are there none of
them' here ? — ^Yes, my lord ; I will first call
the sherifT substitute.
Evidence for the panel*
Harry Davidson sworn. — Examined by Mr,
Margarot
When I was apprehended and brought be*
fore you, did not I make objections with re-
gard to the legaUty of the proceedings ? —
You did.
'. ■ Did not I complain of the treatment I had
received in having been taken out of my bed
ftt 7 o'clock in the morning, and kept in a
room where there was not even a chair to
sit upon, until five in the afternoon, as though
I' had been a criminal and a felon ? — ^You
mentioned these circumstances, and I think
my answer was, that I was exceedingly sorry
for it, but that they had not beencommunkated
to me, or I should have taken care that you
should be better accommodated.
Did I not state to you the illegality, as I ap-
prehended, of arresting a man without even
showing him the warrant ?«— You mentioned
that circumstance.
Did I not promise you that I would enter
& process agamst those proceedings ? — ^Yes.
Have I wen as good as my word } have you
been served with a protest ? — Yes I have.
Eight Hon. Thomas Elder, Lord Provost,
sworn.
All I mean to ask you, my lord is, whether
you could discern any connision, tumult, or
riot, at the meeting at Laing's workshop on the
6th of December, at your entrance ? — ^There
was no other riot that I know of than what
was occasioned by tlie ma^strates interfering.
Then it was the magistrates caused the
riot? very well, my lord. Were you acquaint*
ed with the business that the convention
were upon that night ?— No, I know nothing
farther than that it was a convention for ille-
gal purposes.
^ Do you apprehend, my lord, thai petition-
ing parliament is illegal? — Does your lord-
ship think I need answer that?
tord Justice Clerk. — I think not.
Mr. Margarot. — Were you not told that
the intention of the meeting was, to consider
of an address for a reform m parliament, by
petition to the king, or to that parliament ?— >
1 certainly heard some such thing.
, Whether^ upon the preceding night when
I was absent, when you iiiterhiirted the con-
vention, you were not likewise told, that the
business they were goine to proceed upon
was, whether it wouldbe best to petition the
king, or the parliament for a reform ?»-That
I was told by Mr. Skirving.
Mr. Margarot. — ^Now, my lord, comes a
Very delicate matter indeed. I mean to call
upon my lord justice clerk, and I hope that
the questions and the answers will be given
in the most solemn manner. I have received
a piece of information which I shall lay be-^
fore the Court, in the course of my quefr*
tions: first, my lord, are you upon oath ?
Lord Justice Clerk. — State your question^
and I will tell you whether I will answer
them or not;' if they are proper questions I
will answer them.
Did you dine at Mr. Rochead's at Inver*
leith in the course of last week ?
Lord Justice Clerk.^-^Aad what have you
to do with that, sir?
Did any conversation take place with re*
gard to my trial ?
Lord Justice Clerk* — Go on, sir.
Did you use these words ; what should you
think of giving him an hundred lashes, toge-
ther with Botany Bay? or words to that
purpose?
^ Lord Justice C^rfc.— Go on ; put your ques*
tions, if you have any more.
Did any per^n, did a lady say to ;fou diat
the mob would not allow you v> whip him ^
and, mv lord, did you not say that tne mob
would be the better for losing a little blood ?
These are tlie questions, my lord, that I wish
to put to you at present in ^e presence of
the Court : deny tnem, or acknowledge Uiem.
Lord Justice Clerk, — ^Doyou think I should
answer questions of that sort, my lord Hen-
derland r
Lord Eenderlandj^l^o, my lord, thev do
not relate to this trial: questions as to facts,
which are at all material to the charges con-
tained in this indictment, my lord justice
clerk is obliged to answer, but not otherwise.
Lord Esl^rooe, — ^What may have been said
in a private company, cannot in any way af-
fect this case as to the panel at the bar : it
certainly cannot throw any light upon the
subject : my lord, t have concurred in allow-
ing this gentlenuw. who is a stranger firom
London, to put sucn questions as I never be-
fore heud of in a court of justice, where, my
lord, every subject of this country, the mean-
est and the poorest that stands at that bar.
may have the assistance of counsel leaxoed
in the law. If his situation was such that he
could not afford it, he might have got it by
the authority of this Court, which would have
prevented many things that were stated upoa
the rdevam^. My lord, there has not heea
a question put to your lordshij) that,ooul4 at
all avail Mr. Margarot as to his innocent ia
this trial^ and your lordship very properly
waved answering them. I am of opmioQ
that you ought not to answer questions of
msi
Jift iSttunofi*
A. D. HM.
[67*
that aort» which casDpt involve the fate of
the trial ; I therefore think that it is not con-
sistent with the dignity of this Court, and
cannot he beneficial to the panel.
Lord Sainton, — Any tbin^ that may tend
to exculpate him, or alleviate the crime
charged against him, had he proposed ques-
tions of that sort, not only my lord justice
clerk, but every one of us must have ans-
wered them by the laws of the country ; but
the answer to none of these questions can
either tend to exculpate him or alleviate the
ofience of which he is accused. My Lord,
not one' of them are proper, not one of them
are competent, and ought not to be allowed
to be put ; and were he not a stranger to this
country, I should look upon it as an insult
offered to this Court.
Lord ' D|*nJYnf»an. — ^The panel is allowed
to adduce what exculpator^r ^witnesses he.
thinks proper; your lordship well knows
that by the constant rule of this .court, before
the panel proceeds with his exculpatory proof,
he IS called upon to state the nature of that
proof: he has put questions to your lordship,
and it appears to me that no answer to those
questions could in any decree tend to
exculpate or alleviate the cEarges ag^nst
him.
LordJuUke C^fc.— Have you any other
witnesses ? — It is needless, my lord, when I
am told that the answers to such questions
would neither exculpate. me nor alleviate the-
charges asainst me, but it would have gone
to snow we jury that I was pre»judged be-
ibre my trial came on; and I did mean in-
deed to have followed it up by another ques-
tion, had you been on your oath; but as
you are no^ I will not put it.
Lprd Juiiict CUrk, — ^liave you any other
witnesses to adduce?— Yes, my lord.
' Charles Stewart called.
Lord Advocate,^-lcoi what purpose do you
call him F
Mr. JUargorot.— To ask him 'a question
concerning something that appeared in one
of these papers, the ^inburgh Herald.
Lord AbercrombU. — That is not a paper
libelled upon.
Mr. Margarot.'^^o, but it libels me and
the friends of a reform in parliament; it is a
comparisoa between the nrien^s of a reform
in this country, and the anarchists in France,
and I want, but! do hot see why I need tell
my wants, unless he is to be called ; I want
to know from whom it was that he received
the original of this letter; that is a fair ques-
tion that I have a right to ask in any court of
justice, and it is a question that ought to be
answered: it is a paper that has mown an
odium upon the friends of reform.
- Lord Dunnnnan, — ^This would lead into a
very extensive field, if the panel be allowed
to go into *an investigation of all the writings
that have been pubushed, that have thrown,
as he says, an odium upon the friends of
VOL. XXIIL
reform, and there is nothing founded upon
it against the panel. .
Lord HenderUnd. — ^This paper is no part
of the evidence produced against Mr. Maiv
garot, otherwise he might be entitled to in-
quire by whom it was put in; but to go into
a question of every thmg that has been said
for and against the Friends of the People in
the newspapers, is totally irrelevant to this
trial ; for if Mr. Margarot has been injured in
that respect, the law is open to him, not oa
this trial, but on another occasion, and it caa
have nothing to do with this trial.
, Lord Swintan. — By an act of 1748, it is the
prisoner's duty by that act of parliament, to
g[ive in, the night before the trial, or some-
time before the trial, the facts upon which he
is to found his defence, and he shall be al-
lowed to prove nothing in his defence, but
what is contained in that list of facts ; but if
what he has now stated would be material to
his defence, I am sure the lord advocate would
allow him to prove it ; but there is nothing
here that could tend either to exculpate ot
alleviate; it would lead us^ into every thing
that has been wrote,' pro and can, upon the^
subject, and who it was that gave the founda-.
tion for it, and therefore I conceive it not
regular. •
Lord Etkgrofoe. — I am of tiie same opinion;
I think it can be of no avail to him upon the
face of the earth. .
Lord Justice Clerk.~Ai is very true, my
lord, that there is a statute of the late king,
and I think it was a very pipper rule that
was adopted by that statute, and I am sorry
that itis.no more attended to than it is^ and
I should be sorry to deny this panel any thing
that could avail him in his defence, and he
might have had the advice of Scots lawyers,
or agents, and therefore I am of opinion, that
it would onlv tend to criminate other people
who are not here, or are not put upon their de-
fence. I
Mr. Margarot, — ^Then it is needless saying
any farther upon that; it would only have,
tended to clear up the minds of the jury, who.
might have received unfavourable impress
sions, and which might have been done away
by some questions put to the printer; but
which, perhaps, some people would wish to
see encouraged.
James Calder sworn.
Lord Henderland, — ^What business are you ?
— ^A friend of the people. . » .
Do you live upon that? — ^I live upon my
fatlier Donald Calder, merchant in Cromartie.
What are you ?— [After some hesitation] I
am a student, and attend the university here.
Examined by Mr. Margarot,
. Were vou ever present at any of the meet-
ings of the General Convention of Friends of
the People in 179S, and the beginning of
1793^_Not in 1799, hjaX I was a member of
the convention of April 1793.
875]
S4 GEORGE IIL
(unuuA
0BT6
What is your opinion upon the views of
those convehtions? — I consider them to be
perfecUy legal.
What was the purpose of their assembling?
*— To obtain a reiorm in parliament.
Were you ever interrupted in those meet-
ings by the civil magistrates ?— No, as far as
Ivknow, I never was.
Did you ever hear in the course of your
communications with other people, that the
flngistrates deemed those meetmgs seditious
and illegal ? — No, I never did.
You do not know of any members of those
eonventioDs ever having been apprehended,
in consequence of their being members of
those conventions P — ^No, I never did.
Were you present at any of the meetings
of the last British convention?—- Yes, I was
occasionally.
Was there any material difierence in the
proceedings? — I certainly know of no differ-
ence; there misht be some little difference
in their mode of expression as to the objects
they had in view.
Was the mode of proceeding in those ob-
jects nearly the same ? — They were the same
as fiur as I know.
Were the one and the other equally void
of violence, tumult, or sedition ? — I never saw
any thing of the kind.
Were any seditious doctrines ever held or
authorized in the British convention? — No-
thing that I should call seditious myself, or
that! ever thought seditious.
Did you imagine it to be a part of the peo-
ple's right to meet in that maimer, to petition
parliament, or obtain a reform? — I always
understood so.
Were you present when I was said to have
made the motion with respect to the union
between Scotland and England? — I do not
recollect the time the motion was made ; but
I think I remember a motion of that descrip-
tion.
What was the intention of that motion, if
you can recollect any thing of it? as far as
you could infer from the words that it was
expressed in, was there any thin^ in it of an
evil tendency, with reeard to the king and
ffovemment of Britain? — ^As far as I recol-
lect, it was a general sort of a plan of operar
tions, between the societies in England and
Scotland.
To produce what end?-— To establish a cor-
lespondence between the societies of England
ana Scotland, ui)on a constituticmal mode of
proceeding to petition the legislature.
Were ^ou present when (as he is called,
here) citizen Callender made a motion re-
specting a convention bill? — I do not re-
collect It ; I do not think I was present at
the time that motion was made.
Bat you understood the nature of that mo-
tion, to have respect to the time, when a
convention bill should be brought into the
House of Commons: did you unaerstand that
the convention of emergency^ which was to I
take nlaoe on the introductian of such bill,
or rattier whether the del^atea of the eon-
vention of emergency were to assemble, im-
mediately upon ttie introduction of such bill,
or wait till it had passed in the House of
(Emmons? — They were to assemble, as far
as I recollect, upon the introduction of such
a bill.
I suppose that you thought that thiseon-
vention was to oppose that fill? — ^Yes.
In what way? — ^In a legal and eonstitu-
tional manner^ by petitioning parliaanent, er
by counsel.
Had you any apprehension that l^se dele-
gates meant to employ open viohmoe?— 41
never heard any thing of that land.
Were there any warlike prepanitieos fat
that purpose ? — ^No.
Was there any sum subocribed for that
convention ?— No.
Were any extraordinaiy measures taken to
g've strength to that convention, which Ibe
ritish convention did not then enjoy ?— Ne.
Were you present at the uMeting at
Laing*s ?-^Yes, I was.
What did vou hear the sheriff-substitute
say ? — I heara him desire them to disperse.
What reason did he give for the dispersionf
— He said he had orders to disperse them;— >
that it was an illegal and uncoastitiitiMal
meeting.
You are certain that he said he had Ofden?
—Yes, I am very sure of that.
Was he not informed of the constitutional
manner in which wo were proceeding to de-
bate on the question respeetmg an ad&ess to
the king, or petition to paruament, for a
reform ? — As far as I reooUect he was, though
I cannot say by whom, but I believe it
Mr. Skirving.
Were you there the preceding nighty
the lord provost came to disperse mat meet-
ing?— ^I came in about the time that he
came.
Were they peaceable before the knrd pio»
vest came ?— I was not there long before.
Were vou there when he came in?— -Yes.
Was there any confusion after he came ?<-«
No.
Did you hear it explained to the sheriff*
substitute when he dispersed them atLains^s,
what was the nature of the bustnesa of uie
evening? — ^Yesy I answered that questum
before.
When force was said to be necessary to
disperse us, after the token of force given by
the sheriff to the chairman, w«8 any forther
force necessarv f — No ; after Mr. Mafganrt
came out of the chair, somebo^ called Mr.
Gerrald to it, and he took the chair; and we
did not disperse till he went to prayerj^n d
then we went away.
Was it actual force that dispersed t»y or an
ideal force, a submissbn to orders that «*e
did not resist?— A submission to etdets; hut
I looked upon the oider of the magislvatea
to be force.
WTi
Ji/t Scdihoth
A. D. ITM.
[OTS
But the nenbors of the Britiib oonven-
tion, whea so dispersed, retired peaceably^
did they net ?— Yes.
John Ciark swora.— Examined by Mr.
Margarot,
What are you?— A mason in Edinburgh.
You were a member of the British con-
•vention ? — ^Yes.
With what view did you join that conven-
tioB? — ^I joined it with a view to obtuna
te^Rmn in the representation of the people.
Were you convinced in your own mind that
the attempt to obtain a reform was legal and
constitutional? — I thought so, or I would
not have been a member of it
You are on your oath, and I desire you to
answer this fairly ; if you had found that the
flnembers of the British convention had de-
parted from that constitutional line in which
th^ set out, and in which they were acting
when you joined tbem, would you have
abandoned tbem ? — If I had thought they
had deviated from that constitutional hne,
I certainly would have abandoned them, no
doubt of It ; but I have not found it.
You have not then abandoned them yet ? —
No ; not so long as they are constitutional.
What was tte tenor of the behaviour of
dbe coBvcBitioB i was it peaceable behaviour,
and orderly, or riotous and tumultuous? —
Peaceable and orderly.
Was any seditious doctrine encouraged or
promulgated there ? — I am at a loss to know
what seiditious doctrine is now, and I cannot
answer that ({uestion; I did not understand
it to be seditious.
Was any step proposed at any time that
▼ou might think imconstitutionaL from your
knowlrage of the constitution or the bill of
rights, and of the claim of rights? — ^No, not
anything.
What was the motive of the convention,
for endeavouring to promote a union between
Scotiand and England ? — ^I understood it was
to "promote a union between those societies
that wished for reform^ that they might unite
in adopting the constitutional means to ob-
tain it
You never harboured any idea that it was
for a sinister purpose, did you ? — ^No.
Did you ever understand that if the French
landed in Eneland, the convention were to
meet them?—Quite the reverse.
Do you know of any member of the British
convention |having any correspondence wba^
ever with France, directiy or indirectly ?—
None.
Were you present at the time the lord
provost dispersed the convention on the 5th
December ?— No.
Were you present at the time the sheriff
.substitute dispersed tbem on the 6th Decem-
ber?—I was.
Before the sheriff-substitute came in, how
was the convention with regard to order,
peatpe, aad deconiin?— It wa» perfectly oi^
derly, but I was a very sluNrt time ia before
the sheriff^bstitute came.
What did vou understand to be the sitl^
ject of the debate that ni^ht? — ^There was a
motion about another petition to parliament.
What was said to the sheriff when he at-
tempted to disperse us? — I believe he was
told that it was a peaceable, constitutional
meeting, and that his dispersing us was illo-
gal ; we were met for the purpose of petition-
ing parliament, and were entitled to do so by
the constitution.
What was his reply? — ^That he behoved to
obey his orders; that he did not come to
argue, but to obey his orders, to disperse the
meeting.
You are certain he mentioned the words,
his orders? — ^I think I am pretty certain of
that.
Did I as chairman require some sign of
force from him ?— You did.
What si£n of force did he make use of ?^
He touched you by the hand, and said, Come
out, and you said. No, it must be a little
more than that, and then he took you by the
arm and gently pulled you out, as I iwould a
friend, and then you came out; then Mr.
Gerrald took the chair, and it was moved,
that we should dissolve in the ordinary way,
with prayer, upon which Mr. Gerrald went to
prayer, and we came away.
Do you apprehend there was any idea of
resistance, or any attempt to resist, or that
any individual showed a wish to resbt?-«-
None that I know of, it is distant from my
idea.
Do you apprehend that the general appro-
hensioo was, at that time, that the sheriff
was acting unlawfully ? — ^I presume it was^
but I cannot say what they thouffht.
However, they retired peaceably ? — Yes.
And no riot ensued ?— No.
No drunken bout ensued that night, of the
Friends of the People? — None, to my know-
ledge.
John Clarkf cross-examined by Mr. Solicitor^
General,
You have bee.n talking about the bill of
ri^ts and the claim of rights, where faAve you
r^ them ? in what book is it to be found ? —
I do not recollect
Can you tell us any thing about this claim
of rights, any of the articles of it? — 1 cannot
teU tne whole.
You have upon your oath told us, that there
was nothing done in this convention con-
trary to the bill of rights, or the claim of
rights ; is the right of petitioning parliament
one ot the articles ? — ^Yes.
Did you ever read any thing about illegal
associations called by private authority, either
in the bill of rights, or claim of rights ?-— I
cannot recollect at present
Lord Abertrombie, — Did you ever act as
preses in the- British convention? — ^When I
was there as president, I wa^ keeping order. .
679] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings against Maurice Margaroi
[680
'* How often was that? — Only once.
Lord Advocate, — You were a member of
ike' secret committee? — ^I wks.
Who were the other members ? — ^Mr. Mar-
garot, Mr. Crown, myself, ^d the secretary.
• Mr. Margarot. — Vfid that secret committee
«ver act ? — ^Not that I know of.
Mr. Margarot, — I will, with the leave of
the Court, lend you the claim of rights to
read.
Lord Advocate — ^Did you ever read the
Habeas Corpus act? — No.
• Did you 'ever read the act of 1701, on
wrongous imprisonment ? — No.
' Mr. Solicitor-General. — ^Is it a Scotch or an
Enghsh act ?—An English act.
• Mr: Solicitor-GefieraL — So that is your
knoWledgeofthe'act of 1701?— Stop, I be-
lieve I am wrong, for the union took place in
1700^ ^ '
Lord Advocate,* — Gentlemen of the Jury :
—-You arc called upon in the common and
usual routine of your duty, to decide upon the
truth of the* indictment, which I 'have felt it
«ny dutv to prefer against the panel at the
bar, who is styled, and calls himself in the
paper which is termed a declaration emitted
X>T him, before the proper officer, a mer-
.chant, residing in Marylebone in London;
- -you, therefore, merchants of Edinburgh, are
his equals, and a proper and competent jury
to decide upon his guilt or innocence.
Gentlemen. I must again repeat the asser-
tion I made tois morning, at an early stage
of our proceeding?; that you sit here this
night in the common course and ordinary
routine' of public duty,' and that 'the accusa^
lion then made by the panel,* in his speech,
pr rather succession of speeches, — ^not with
much judgment or prudence; I think,^— of your
beins a packed jury, is as gross as it is un-
founded. I trust you know and feel, as I
iibpe the country at large know and feel, that
It IS not in the ^wer of the highest subject
of this country, be his situation what it may,
either here or in England, to pack a jury as
this man has' dared to assert, or to prevent
the meanest criminal fVom obtaining, what
the law ahd constitution of his country gives
him,^a just, a fair, and an impartial trial.
Something, if I charge my menloiy rieht, was
also said by the panel, of my object being to
impose upon^ and inislead your understand-
ings, ana you were cautioned against my
endeavours to do so. That observation, gen-
^ The system of . misrepresentation, of
<which notice has already been . taken in
ihe preceding case, p. 536 was resorted to by
the publishers of this trial, in the account
given by them of the lord advocf^'s address
to the jury. On the present, howevet^ as on
the. Conner occasion, lord chief baron Dundas
has enabled me to present to the reader an
^theotic report of nis speech, in which the
misstatements which have heretoib&e af^
tiemen, shall not deter' me now from doing
what still is incumbent on me on this tedious
and fatiguing^ trial, — to address you. to the
best of my ability, and to the best<^f iny .un-
derstanding, on the voluminous evidence this
day laid before you ; to arrange it under as
clear and distinct heads as I can; and-^ point
out what I think are the necessary ana un-
avoidable inferences to be drawn from it. The
panel, if he thinks I attempt to mislead you,
has a full and perfect right, both to say so,
and when I am done, to point out and ex-
plain to you why he thinks so. I assert for
myself, in the discharge of my duty as public
prosecutor, a complete and-perlect indepen-
dence. You, gentlemen, must feel the same
in the exercise of yours. Like you,'I can only
be influenced by-die desire of doing my duty
to the country, and a firm determination to
follow the dictates of my own conscience.
Whilst I do this to the best of my judgment
and understanding, as you will hereafter do
in forming your verdict, I care not what is
said either by a criminal, in a moment of in-
temperance, or by persons wiUiout doors,
endeavouring to attack the purity, of our trial
by jury, or to shake the confidence of the
people of tins country in this their most in-
estimable privilege. I deny that juries are
packed, or that any instance has existed,
or can possibly exist in this country, of so
foul and gross a calumny being just
Gentlemen, I am not without some appre-
hension, in conseouence of a severe indisposi-
tion under which I have suffered, since I la^
in this place addressed a jury on a trial simi-
lar to' this,-^that I may not be. able at this
late hour of ni^t, and in so crowded a court,
to do, what' is on all occasions my boundea
duty, and which is in the peculiar circum-
stances of -the countiy, at present. more par-
ticularly incumbent on me, to state clearly
to you the effect and import of that evidence
now lying on the table, and from which so
many passages have been read over in the
course of the day, — that I may fiul in placing
it before you in a clear and distinct light, and
in discriminating with the accuracy I would
wish, on what part of the volumeof factious,
seditious and treasonable matter on your table
you ought to dwell and rely upon ; what you
ought to reject and throw away. But I trust
in some degree to the goodnessof my cause.
I trust still more to the understanding of the
jury, and I trust something in that feeling of
regard to my country, and that spirit which a
^ood and loval subject ought and must feel,
in being still enabled to nuike out such a case
from the evidence before you, as must impose
upon you the severe, .but Just task of return-
ing a verdict of guilty against the person now
at the bar, upon evidence the most solid, con-
vincing, and conclusive*
Gentlemen, the panel at your bar stands
charged with sedition. Upon that subject we
have had to-day much discussion ; jand we
have bad| to my surprise, agreat dealof igDo>
I
681]
forSediium.
A. D. 1794.
[6B8
nnce of what it is, professed by persons who
ought to have' been the very last to make the
profession. ' Men who, at the same time, hold
themselves out to their fellow subjects as
persons so well advised and informed, so fully
instructed in all that regards the whole law
and frame of our constitution, as to be entitled
in this British convention to teach parliament
Itself what is the reform, qualified to substi-
tute in place of the one we enjoy, something
far oetter, — who have audaciously assumed
to themselves the important task^ and still
more important character, of bemg able to
improve tnat inheritance which our ancestors
in their wisdom, and on the gradual experience
of progressive centuries, have established
amount us, and left us to enjoy as the best
and wisest which could be devised. It would
have been well, I think, if, before they took to
themselves such a character, they haul begun
.by studving the law of their country a little
more closely than they have done, ere they
pretended to improve it, and bestowed some
portioi]^ of their time in understanding at least
the criminal law, which constitutes so pro-
minent and proud a feature of the constiti^
tion of our country, before they professed
themselves to-day ignorant of what sedition
was, and their utter, incapacity for the diffi-
cult duty they have presumptuously and cri-
minally arrogated to themselves.
Gentlemen, it is at present unnecessary for
me after what you have already heard, to re-
fer you again to books of law on this subject.
My learned friend who opened the case to-
day on the part of the prosecution, traced
aedition to the very earliest authority known,
and acknowledged in the law of Scotland, the
book of the *' Regiam Majestatem," and if
the panel at the bar, and his associates of the
British convention, who as witnesses favoured
us to-day with repeated professions of their
ignorance of what the meaning of " sedition''
was, had even only turned up ^e only book
of criminal law which we lawyers acknow-
ledge as of authority, namely, that of sir George
Mackenzie, they would there have found a
separate and distinct treatise, expressly defin-
ing the crime of sedition, and giving it its
technical definition, as precisely as that of
murder, ^sehood, forgery, rape, or any other
crime which stands on the list in our criminal
jurisprudence. If any number, or assemblage
of men, be their ostensible purpose what it
may, either a reform of parliament, redress of
grievances, or any other similar purpose, meet
and assemble together by their own authority
for the accomplishment of that avowed pur-
pose ; and if, when so assembled, they, in place
of proposing legal and constitutional mea-
sures, for its attainment, — for instance, by
petition to the king or the legislature, do
on the contrary propose and adopt measures
of a very different nature, and a very different
tendencv^ — if, by aping and imitating the ex-
ample, the language, and the forms of a French
conventk>n| a cotmtry with whom we arc in-
volved in war, they demonstrate their iiilei>*
tion of following its footsteps in revolution
and in blood, — ^if, as I shall prove to you must
have been the case, their intention was, to
overawe the legislature in the free and inde-
pendent exercise of its functions, by combin-
ing, as far as they could, a majority of the
people, to rise in arms and in rebellion against
any measures which the wisdom of parliament
might direct for the public security and safety.
— if, in the event of that invasion firom abroad
with which the pubUc enemy has menaced
us, they, in place of resisting, were to assemble
and join the invaders (for notwithstanding sdl
the professions of the panel and his associates
to the contrary this day in the course of the
trial, such, in the sound construction of the
evidence, and in common reason, I shall show
is the only conclusion possible to be drawn
from the past and umform tenor of their
conduct and lan^pige^, then is the crime of
which this panel is ^iilty, the crime of sedi-
tion, as clear and unequivocal as ever occurred
in the criminal practice of this or any civilized
country.
Such, gentlemen, is the view I entertain of
the evidence this day laid before you. Such
is the opinion I have formed of its import and
tendency. My opinion, however, is not biiid-
in|; upon you. It is for you to consider the
evidence, and form your own judgment : it is
now mine to state to you the reason why I
think you ought to concur with me in opinion,
and to comment on those partsofit,which have
mainly led me to that! now declare. You
will give to my reasoning your best attention
— You will lay your hands on your hearts and
say, whether it is not the only, the plain, and
the necessary deduction and inference which
arises, not from any particular expression,
circumstance, motion, resolution, or paper,
but from a general and complex view of the
whole, all tallying together, and bearing to
that point only, and much more when com-
pared witli, and fortified by the parole evi-
dence which was this day given in court, not
without extreme reluctance by the witnesses
adduced on this trial.
Gentlemen, the evidence is of two kinds,
written and parole : the principal and chief part
of it (and I say so, because it is the most cer«
tain and the most unerring) is, the written
evidence arising from the mmutcs of this self-
constituted convention; from the papers found
upon Mr. Margarot, contained and referred
to in the general inventory upon the table,
and from three numbers of the Gazetteer,
which in the sequel I shall show you to be
completely brought home to this convention.
Gentlemen, the first question which you
are to consider is, whether or not this meet-
ing, from the 19th of November (for I go no
farther back) till the 4th of December last,
where the minutes stop — because we aU
know, and it is proved toAlay, that the magis*
tracy of this city, did, early on the morning^ of
the 5tb, apprehend these persons and seizo
i
US] 34 6B0RQB III. Proceeiing$ agama Mmarice Margarat {QM
«bar fmn;«-'4he firat<|iie0tioii which jom | to Ihe coittUi;^ at hufe^wfao 4iiral ttUro |>o»-
«re to ftsk is this : Was itor not a meetinj^ of I session ef Ifais metcvpolis^ who dared
a seditious nature ? ibr if you are of opiiuoDy
that it was not a meetiitt of a seditious na-
ture; if you should oonsuer it in a different
point of yieW) to what I humbler presume to
do ; that it was an innocent, fatTy legal, and
constitutional measure, it is in ndn, superflu-
€Ni8» and unnecessaty for you to injuire, whe-
ther the panel is a principal actor in that
meeting ; because no man can be found guilty
of the proceedings of a meeting which a jury
ahali be of opinion, is within the pale of the
law, and sucn as the laws of this country en-
title anv man to call together.
Gentlemen, something was said to-day in
the comrse oif this debate (if I may so term
it), that was personal against myself, as a
member of another convention; some-
thing was said with resard to the astonishing
circumstance, of not oringing the borou^
lefbrmers to trial in this court, something was
said also with apparent marks of exultation
on the part of the panel; that though three
conventions of the Friends of the People had
taken fJace in this dty in the* course of
^hteen months past; no notice whatever
was taken by the public prosecutcn: of any of
those conventions, till, as Margarot^ I think,
stated, we took alarm, because we saw that
he and his friends were in danger of opening
tiie eyes of the people ; and that it was not
ttU we were alarmea, and that the eyes of the
people were about to be opened, to the exist-
ence of those abuses, which it was their ob-
ject to correct, that I (negligent in my duty
before) brought this man anaothers his asso-
ciates to answer for the ofience.
Gentlemen, my answer is this : I desire
not to enter into the question, how far con-
tentions by delegation are, <»r not legal* It is
not the question now under your considersr
tion; had these gentlemen confined them-
selves to what was the law of their country,
or adhered to what they professed to be the
case, I should not have felt it my duty to have
brought them to trial, for being assembled in
a convention, or any thing of&atkind, which
had for its otgect either the correction of the
county laws, of the borough laws, or any
other correction which the wildest and most
unreasonable speculatist might think it worth
bis while to aim at.
"^ Gentlemen, I never thought of bringing
before you the convention of 1798, the con-
venUon of April 1793, or the subsequent con-
vention in October last; nor did 1 think of
bringing the persons now charged before you
with s^ition, till the very name they assum-
ed, every advertisement Uiey inserted in the
papers, every thing verbal, or written, demon-
strated to my mind, demonstrated to Scot-
land^ demonstrated to Ensland, and to the
empire at large, that they v^re a set of French
— conventionists. — I give them that name ; per-
sons iNrho, as far as they durst, and their au-
dacity! believe was matter of astoni^ment
1
its walk to hold c«t the example of a French
model, holding; out ^ir example ae the prio^
dpleupon which they aeted, as tiie object
and the point to which their deUberations
tended.
Gentlemen, somethinc was said of orders
being given to Mr. Davidson, the sheriff sub*
stitute,>-that he acted by orders; whether he
acted by order or not ; whether he acted by
the orders of the respectable gentleman who
was sheriff depute of the county, but who has
since received a distinguishing mark of his
sovereign's favour; whether he went by my
orders, or by the orders of any body else, is
nothing to the purpose; I did consult wilJi
that gentleman ; I did consult with your chief
magistrate ; I desired them to attend to their
duty, if any desire of mine was necessary : we
acted in concert together ; had we done less,
we had been guiltjr of a breach of office ; we
had been guilty of neglecting the most im*
portant interests o^ msmkind.
Gentlemen, were I to run over every single
paper contained in that inventory; were I to
address you upon every motion which appears
in that scroll of minutes before you, I should
detain you this evening to a very late hour
indeed ; but I shall select a very few of the most
pointed and distinct motions, and evidence
therein contained.
Gentlemen. — I will say hardly a word ia
support of tiie authenticity of the writtpn evs^
dence which is now upon your table ;— it ap-
pears that the papers libeUed upon, which I
nave just descrioed to you, are traced home ia
the most complete and satisfactory manner
Sossible ; there is not a tittle of written evi-
ence — ^there is not a document now before
you which is not proved, beyond a possibility
of dispute, to have been found in the possess
sion of the panels— I refer in general to the
testimonies of Mr. Davidson ; or Mr. Scott,
the fiscal; Lyon; and, I think. Mack.— »
These four, t believe, distinctly trace them
from the room in which Margaret and Gerrald
slept into the sheriff clerk's office, and having
traced them there they are brought into court,
and it is impossible to inquire farther. In-
deed some question was put by the panel at
the bar ^who displayed I must admit a consi*
derable aegree or infinity, and acuteness in
his own defence), asif it might have happened
from the manner in which these papers were
found, that others might have been carried in
by Lyon the messenger — that other papers
mi^ht have been carried in, as they were re-
sidmg in a public inn in this city, by other
persons, and that they were not necessarily
the papers of Gerrald, and of Margarot.— In
every case where written evidence is libelled
upon, in support of any crime,! ask your-
selves if it is possible to give better evidence
of the identity of papers wan was done in the
present case-— or if you suppose contrary to
evidence, and contrary to fact, that Lyon the
685]
fift ioMlllOR*
A. D. I7M.
[680
floeflseBger, wts cntrutted by Mr. Davidsoii,
or Mr. PriDgle, or me, or the lord provost^
with papers oi a seditious nature, which he
earned into that room where th^ were sleep*
ing in order to eround a false accusation
aaaiost them ; — ^ifyou can suppose that possi-
ble, then to be sure any thing that I have
said, or have hereafter to say m support of
the charge against this man, certainly will
not be worth attending to. — Gentlemen, on
llie contrary, these papers were found in the
room where they slept, were put into a trunk,
which trunk was returned back to Margaret
and Gerrald, and you have it in evidence,
that when it was examined in their presence,
Gerrald selected Ids — Margarot claimed the
rest, or at least allowed them to be in-
ventoried without denying them, and those
which did not relate to this business, were re-
turned to them both.
Gentlemen.— I trust that quibbling defence,
for It does not deserve any other name, will
satisfy your minds, that the gentleman does
know tliat the import of these papeas bears
hard aeainst him; and that he wishes to
shelter nimself from the inference which vour
minds will draw, by slating a possibility,
which cannot exist, that they might have
been carried there by ether people, in order
to nound an accusatioB against him.
UeniAemen.r-Holdiag that to be clear, I shall
beg your attonlion, in the first place, to the
minutes of the convention, for it is the ground-
work and the basis of the charge against
him : it was a paper which I was veiy anxious
if possible to obtain, because I know that it
would have been impossible to have asked ajury
to have given a verdict against any man upon
suspicions, however strong those suspicions
might have been, and you wiU be satisfied
from what we saw this day, finom the manner
in which the witnesses gave their testimony,
citiaen Ross particularly, who has spoke out;
— and I am sure it gives me pleasure to ap-'
plaud the conduct of a witness. I have great
satisfaction and high pleasure in giving this
tribute of praise to citizen Ross, and the same
with respect to Cockburn, who, I think, from
the whole of his testimony, though a IHend
and assodate of the panel at the bar, has
given a f^, a true, ana a decisive evidence.
Gentlemen.—The first thing I shidl beg
your attention to are the steps previous to
and accompanying that whicn is stated in
pages fifth and sixth of the indictment. In
page fifUi you will observe stated a motion
rejecting a convention of emergency, and
the cases in which they were to meet are
proved in the first place by the negative evi-
dence of theic minutes, and confirmed by the
testimonies (^Cockbunii and of George Ross.
- Gentieme^.— That motion appears to have
been first made by a gentleman of the name
of Callender, to whom this day was eichi-
sively appropriated fisr meeting the justice of
bb ceualiy, but who has absomded, forfeited
his bail, aaddoes not, it seems, incline to stand
his trial ; and the first natioe given of this
motion, I will road fram the mtnules & 0<4
donft iUtingy t&tk Naomber^ 1793 ; etftssii
CaUender mtned^ ihM m casf the mimittw Mug
mSo the Commomi Hotue « mciianjor m eo&net^
Hon hUly U ikamld be nUieed immeditUefyto Hke
dtl$ftaei.^^Th» is the first appearance of tida
motion in ibe minutes, and as it was told ua
by several of the witnesses to day, the forms
<^ this house, as it is called, or of this conven-
tion, did not admit of a motion made one day
beio^ deliberated upon till the next ;•— the mo-
tioB ues over accoraingly tiU the ensuing day,
when you will find the meeting again reanm^
ed, and Callender^ motion being then taken
under consideraAbn; anendmeols were pro»
posed by several peisoie, and it wasaiMed b^
Mr. Margmrttf tk&l a ammUUef 4tmnHing cf
tht maeer^ teeomder^ and tAote that tmd nwsped
Jor ammuimenit be mfunted in d^nm np n «w»
tion tkatnunt meet the idea tfaUy aaKtng whom
was Mr. CaUender, the yoimg gentleoian whose
actual atteacbinoe upon t& university may
perhaps be presumed to have better ^alified
turn to discuss questions as to the reform
(or as I call it the aheraibon) of the con-
stitution, than the learned Mr. Jehn Clark»
or Mr. Wardkw, or Mr. Aiteheson, whose
utter ignorance of tiie law and oooatitotion of
the countiy was so conspiouous in the course
of the evidence to-day, and proved how
little entitled they were to assume to tiiens*
selves the important office which th«7 have
taken upon them. Citiaen John Garlley
moves, that the sense of the house he takes
upon the spirit of the mobon, upon the worde
of the motion, and afWwacds upon Mr. lUbow
garot's motion. Upon the first motion it asae
carried unammcuslv to adopt the motion aa
to its spirit; secondly, by a greaAmajority not
to adopt the words of it ; and, thirdly, thai
the amendments be referred to a eommiu
tee as above. — ^And at a subsequent diet, I
mean a subsequent sitting of the conwention^
the minutes tell us, thatctlirsn Sinclait mad
tbe amendmente upon cUiMen Calietuietfs mn^
tiany as agreed ttpoe by the commkieey and H
wat agreed^ upon the motion of citizen thai
the hmue should resolve itse^into n eommiUem
for its mature consideration^ In the course of
the cowcersationf dtizen Brown gave a history
of the Habeas Corpus act. After an eatceUont
discussion of the question, pertinent rtmarko
and amendments^ the convention was resumed,
and the whole as amended^ being read aver, the
mend>ers stood upon ihdrfeet, and soiemnfy and
unonimousfy passed the resolution osfMnoe :-^
Here gentlemen, all mention of the resolution
breaks off abruptly-— A blank in the minutes
of upwards of a paee immediately sncceeds--«
and the minutes Oien proceed as follows:—-
Cttuen Qerrdldy in a very energetic and an»-
nuted address, egpressed his happiness at the
motion passed, and citieen Brown, followed ism
in a manly speech, and proved the is^uence of
the executive government over the parliament,
Citieen Margarot then read and prcposed the
687] S4 GEORGE m. Proceedings against Maurice Margaroi [688
foUatoing motion : That a secret committee ef
thrtCf and the secretary (it is proved afterwards
that Clark, Margarot, Skirving, aod Brown,
were the four who actually composed this
committee) be apjtointed to determine the place
where such convention of emergency should meety
that such place should remain a secret with them^
and trith the secretary of the convention^ and
that each delegate shall, at the breaking up of
the present session, be entrusted with a sealed
letter^ containing the name of the place of meet-
ing ; this letter shall be delivered unopened to
his constituents, the receipt of which shall be ae-.
hnowUdgedby a letter to the secretary, preserved
in the same state, antil the period shall arrive
at which it shall be deemed necessary for the
delegate to set off. — This motion was seconded
hy Citizen Moffatt, and carried unanimously.
GentlemeD. — You have in the first place
this proved completely by the minutes, that
citizen Callender, in his first motion, which
was adopted as to its spirit, but rejected as to
its words, had neither more nor less than this
object in view, that as soon as parliament
should think it necessary or prop^, if they
ever thought it necessary or proper, to bring
in a similar biU, to that which passed in Ire-
land, that this should be the signal or notifi-
cation for calling the convention of emerj^ency
together; and that of itself, without ^omg to
other cases of emergency, was just this, tnat
thev were to act as a control upon parliament,
and to endeavour to overawe ^ou will consi-
der whether in a legal or an illegal way) the
firee exercise of the righ^ of the legislature —
Can 3rou 'suppose that if. their purpose was
le^, if they had not wished to overawe, and
intimidate the parliament from doing their
dut^r, would you have found them alarmed or
afraid of their conduct ? Had their purpose
been only to petition parlia^pent, and to stale
their remonstrances against such a motion (a
tight which every fi-eeman of this country
possesses), what explanation is to be given of
that secrecy in which this measure is wrapped
up, if their purpose was honest ? but is it so?
3rov^ find in this paper an account of a resolu-
tion whic)i they came to, in a most solemn
and most unanunous manner, but which reso-
lution does not appear in the fiice of the mi-
nutes— if it was a resolution merelv of the
quiet and loyal nature iust now stated, do you
suppose that it would have been left out.
Aitcheson, one of the three secretaries, gave
it to-da^ in evidence, that he was absent
when this resolution was discussed and agreed
to, but came in soon afler, and relieved Koss,
who was secretary during the former part of
the evening. In this he is confirmed bv in-
spection of the minutes, which are of^ the
hand- writing of Ross as far down as the blank,
in which the resolution ou^ht to have been
inserted, and the hand-writmg of Aitcheson
begins immediately below the blank. Can
you, therefore, gentlemen, doubt, will not you
believe, what Aitcheson also wasobliged to ad-
mit, that thereason of thisblank being lefiwas,
that doubts were entertuned how hr it
safe to insert it in the minutes at all, and it
was left for fiiture consideration, whether to
insert it or not ; especially when it was also
extorted from Aitcheson that Sinclair having
proposed the resolution should be burnt, he
(Aitcheson) spoke and argued against this, and
successfully resistexl Sinclair's proposal. Is.
this conduct characteristic of innocence?
Would burning of a legal, fair, and harmless
paper of so great consequence to the views of
this convention, and. to which they annex-
ed so h^h importance and solemnity, ever
occur to men conscious of the rectitude* of
their conduct ? Is it not, on the contrary, de-
cisive of guilt.
Gentlemen. — Let us then see what the pa-
role testimony makes out, and whether it
does not precisely confirm the conclusion,
and inferences, I am now drawing not only
from what is proved by the minutes, but dso
from what is not proved by the minutes, I mean
the insertion of this extraordinary blank, to
which there is nothing similar, except a blank
of four lines, in all the 94 pages of minutes
upon your table.
Gentlemen. — Cockbum, I think, tells you,
that besides this convention bill, there was a
variety. of other cases in which this conven-
tion of emergency were to meet: he told u&:
that they all agreed that the introduction of
a convention bill was to be one ereat object'
when the people should meet, and I wish you.
would looK at your notes, when the people*
should meet to assert their rights — ^Ir'am
not to descend to criticisms upon a word,
but I may at least beg to know whether,
if it was merely drawing up a respectful pe-
tition to the king or to tne parliament, it
was necessary to put so strong a declara-
tion as this to which Cockbum swears ; or was
it not better to speak out the truth, that,
they meant, in such an event, to remon-
strate against the measure, or petition par--
liament against its passing into a law f But
you have, on the contrary, an expression
which savours more of resistance than any
thing else^that they were to meet in this un-
known place, which was to be concealed even
from the delegates themselves, and of course
firom the eye of the executive power — ^that ia
that event they were to meet and assert
their rights, but as to the manner in which
they were to be asserted, whether in a peace-
able or tumultuous way, whether the mild
influence of reason was to be exercised up-
on the British parliament, or whether bj
drawing out numbers of deluded men to do it
by force, is your business now to decide^
and your province alone to determine.
Gentiemen— -The question was this day put
to me, was I an inquisitor of the private feel-
ings of men's minds ? Had I a right to dive
into the secrets of the human breasts, or to
discover what it was their intention to con-
ceal?— ^rhat, gentiemen, isjrour province, not
mine. It b the very busueas in which you
t
688]
Jhr
♦^
A. D. 179^
t690
are enm^ : the duty,, for the trtie and fnih-<
All pemmxuiDce of which you are now placed
by the law of your countrr on that bench.
Remember always, in considerinff this part of
the evidence, that men engaged in seditious i
and treasonable proceedings, are always cau*
tiousin their language and correspondence^,
and contrive, as mutm as is in their power/
to disguise and conceal the real and true ob-
jecty by ambiguous expressions, and general
terms, to which, when questioned or ar-
raigned they may aifii a very opposite and in->
nocent interpretation. It is for the jury in
thisy as in all other similar cases, to deliberate
well and impartially on tlie true and real
tenor and puiport of the writings laid before
them : ana when they find persons engaged
in seditious practices, adopting such general
expressions, as ^ntetin^ to astert. their righit,
to consider what was the real piupose of
the words so used. Not to take the profes-
sions of the persons using them, as they now
choose to explain them, away ; not to take
what they may noW|by a convenient versatility,
declare was what they meant and intended, —
but looking to all the collateral circumstances
of their conduct at the time ; looking to their
actions, to their words, to their proceedings,-^
whether these are secret, or public and avowed
-*~to form your impartiai determination,^ whe-
ther the scale of evidence preponderates in fi^
vour of innocence or of guilt. It is impossible
to expect the seditious lansuage or writings to
be conceived in direct and explicit terms, ad-
mitting only of one interpretation and di-
rectly and without dissuise, avowing resist-
ance to the established constitution and go«
vemment of the country. Had these men
put on their minutes, that they would meet
to assert their rights by open violence and
force of arms;~if they had dared to have
said or wrote, that if the British parliament
should suspend the Habeas Corpus act, they
would assemble to resist that statute by force
of arms ; — had they entered sdemnly on their
minutes, that if a French invasion took place,
they would assemble, not to oppose, but to
co-operate with, and assist, the invaders, I
question much if I should have brought Mr.
Margarot to trial at all. I should have con-
sidered him as little short of a lunatic. If I
had under such circumstances produced him
before you, I am inclined to believe you
would have thought I had brought a madman
to your bar. You might have returned a ver-
dict of. lunacy against him, but hardly consi-
dered him as a criminal, or a fit object of
trial or. punishment. But, gentlemen, attend,
I pray of you, to what has been this day
proved before you, and what the whole train oif
this man's laneuage, conduct, words, and pro^
ceedings have been during the period charged
in the indictment. We are fortunate to possess
in this country, a powerful and, I hope, vigi-
lant and active executive government. We
have laws, however, to control ai^ command
that,power,. and above all a jury can stop and
VOL, xxin.
check th^ progress of its measures in a mot-
•ment While such a government exists (and
it will exist I hope to all fiiture ages), yoa
must. expect that under its.e^e, and under its
power, men conspiring asainst the state, will
jrame their seditious words and writings, with
the most extreme ambiguity and the most
cautious obscurity. The best and safest rule
of interpretfllion IS to be drawn from the con^
duet and character of those who use them;
Who then is this Mr. Margarot ?— The panel
at the bar ? He is-a merchant, he tells us, m
London ; and the trade in which he is en^
{^iged, permits him, it would seem, from mo-
tives ot pure public spirit, and perfect disin^
terestedness, to dedicate six weeks of his
time to us, and to teach the people of Scot-
land how thev are to obtain those blessings
of law and liberty, to which they are told
they are strangers. He is a man of conside-
rable tajents and ability ;r well aware of what
he is about, and the ringleader of this British
Convention. He is the chief adviser, and di-
rector of all their proceedings ;— the framer
or aniender of all. or most of their resolutions
and minutes ;-*-the person in law and in rea-
son justly responsible for all the . actions of
this self-constituted body, consisting in. a
great, degree of ignorant, uninformed, despi-*-
cable. creatures ; some of them . to-night ap-
pearing intoxicated, and all of them the .tools
and instruments in his hands and under his
Guidance. The minutes afford ^bunduot evi«
eute, that he and others were conscious the
eye of the nu^istfaev either was. or ought to
be directed towards them, and the jealousy, I
had almost said certainty, of its interpo^tion,
was felt ttiany days before it actually took nlace.r
In measures directed by sucli a roan, ana pro«
ceedings dictated or advised by him, an artfu^,.
insidious, and ambiguous expression is un-
avoidably to be looked for and expected : and
that very circumstance proves todcnienstrationy
that Margarot, aware of the danger of disco*
very and detection, did, along with Sinclair
in Uie committee appointed to form the terras
of the resolution, cover and conceal the real
object of it, by as ambiguous and general a
form of words as could be adopted ; and even
>fter all, sensible of the real, truth, concurred
with Sinclair, if not in committing it to the
flames, at least in abstaining from it& insertion
in the minutes : because as Cockburn has ex«
pressly sworn, it was such a paper as. they
durst not insert — one wbicn the witness
thought neither he nor they could safely hold
their faces up to acknowledge : such a paper
as was to give rise to a committee of secrecy
and emergency ; with which, if the objecl
was legal and honest, secrecy was inconsis^
tent,— if criminal, then prudent, proper and
indispensable.
. Gentlemen,— The next thing I shall ob«
serve upon is, those numbers of the Gazetteer
which are now upon the table. Cttiiens of
Edinburgh, I use the word citizen, I hope and
I know m a fair and legal sense^ you cannot
2 Y
691] 84 GBOR6B III. ProceeAigs tfidatt MMriee Margaroi (WS
be ignorant of the Edinburi^
Sure I am I have the honour to be moat in-
timately acquainted with it, and it has done
me the honour to be most intimately ac-
quainted with me.
Gentlemen. — Let us look to that l»per,
and though some doubt may perhaps for a
moment arise either in your minds or in the
minds of those who hear me, as to the au*
tfaenticity of a newspaper, as matter of evi-
Hence, I will show you, fnom the evidence of
the minutes upon the table, that it u, what it
was meant to be, an authentic account^ and
that, as far as it f^oes, it states nothii^; but
what really and truly was the substance of
what passed in the convention. I trust, gen-
tlemen^ you do not suppose me'absurd enough
to call your attention to the paragraphs of an
idle newspaper,' if I do not prove its authen-
ticity beyond all doubt. That it was the le-
gitimate, privileged, and accorded Gaiette
of this British convention is unquestionable.
You have the evidence of two of the secreta*
Ties, the brotiiers Ross, that the minutes were
•ipressly taken dowu, for the purpose of
being inserted from day to day in the Gaaet-
teer^and they were so. On comparison the
originals and the Gazette so exactly corres-
pond, that there is hardly a shade of differ-
ence even in trifles, but in the purport and
general import of the nroceeding, none what-
fsver. It is recorded aJso in the minutes, two
days before the dispersion of the convention,
that the delegate for Montrose ' having been
prevented by indisposition ^rom commg to
Edioburghy and having wrote the secretaiy
Boss, for a copy of the minutes to be sent to
Ilim and his constituents, the answef ordered
was *^ unneeettarv^ n they wiUfind them m the
Gazetteer.** To dispute its authenticity, there-
fore, seems to be out of the question. But how
do these gentlemen dispute it? By denying all
knowledge of, or conneiLioift with it and its pub-
lisher ? No such thing. But the panel and
the witnesses to-day told us^they did not sup-
port the Gazetteer as a convention, or m
i^eir corporal capacity, but merely as indi-
viduals, and wished it well as such. I be-
lieve they did so. with all their hearts and
souls. But will this flimsy distinction serve
their present purpose, or snake the decisive
£ roof to the contrary above referred to? I
ave a better opinion of the panel's abilities
than to suppose he himself can rely on such a
distinction, or think it can impose on the
imderstandinff of any one who now hears me.
Now, ffentlemen, let us look to this Gazet-
teer, andfet us see how far it supplies any chasm
4Nr Iblank occurring in the minntes them-
selves, or explains any thing there left ambi-
guous or obscure. I conceive it does so most
effectually. For it states the general imnort
of that resolution which the panel and Sin-
• See in thu Vohune, p. 4S, the case of
«apt. JohnaltB, and p.der, the caso of A.
cUir ilpiahed to burii^ ^bnt winch AHaheaan
wished to preserve, because he tboaghi ifaeir
conduct -odffht to be open and avowed, and
the public had a risbt to know all tMeir-piio-
ceeduigs. A Aer adding the proceedions ^
the l^edn^day, when citizen Mealmaker ia
in the chair, and when Callender's motion ia
rejected in its words, but approved in 'spirit;
the Gaaetteer, in the account 6f the fvoe^ed-
ings 4>n next day (Thursdqr),defaab the Jtai*
pwt of thai reisomtion as then nisw-am^ed,
not in tha precise words cbai|^nitfae!indtet4
ment, but generally, in soch terms aalefttt no
longer matter of doubt what course sraa to be
pursued with this eonventiion. The daaetttar
then proceeds as ibllo#s : *« Citisen Sinclair
iaid : Qtiaen President, your oommittec sp.
pointed to amend citisen Callander's niMa%
met Uiis forenoon^ and I shall now,tf'<gife^
able to the cobvanti6n, submit to tbfeir xoiui-
deration the rapott of that cokmnittee*
Fellow- citizens, yen will feel timt this npett
it of the iatt importence. It cbdma tout whAi
serious attention, is to be deddod -by yam
united wisdom, aiid supported by year umted
integrity. The house rtsoWed itself into a
general committee to consider of this leffort,
which underwent a long discussioay and fa-
oeivod several amendments inthe eommittae;
and when the convention was resomed,' it
passed unammously in the foim of a declara-
tion and resolution: but being ordered to
stand the last article on the ^record of the pro-
cto)in|s of the convention, we cannot insert
it till we termination of the present session.*'
Soch is the aocountin the Gazetteer. That
this declaration and resolution was 'the same
as that which Sinclair' and tiie panel iasme-'
diatdy thereafter wished to bum ; that its
general impK^rt is faithfully slated,' is deat
from the coincidence of this ' account with
that on the original minutes^' and from ttie
parole evidence of the two Kodses, Aitcheson^
and Cockburn. The Gazetteer Slates, that the
suspension of the HabeasCoc^sactjthedis«»
persion of the convention, the latadit:^ of fb-
rdgn troops, Hessians or Hanoverians, and
invasion, were all emer^ncies to- which the
declaration and resolutbn related, but the
precise terms of which could not be Itsiled till
the close of the convention^ I have my
doubts, gentlemen, whether, if the hand of
the mi^istrates of this citv and conatrvhad
not immediately interpoiedtostopthefmhtr
meetings of this treasonable convention, the
nrudence of the panel and the other' riilg-
leaders would ever have allowed of this ^so-
lution being entered On their n^utes. The
written evidence^ however^ pr6ves undeniftbl|^
what the cases of^ emergency* were,— fWhatilke
events against which a committee of secrecy
were appointed to watch and meet That the
terms oftheirappointroent were considerodun-
safe and dadgeitm^ to be inserted on the ihK
nutes^ so much that the panel himself, andsAMv
ther ringleader, now under indidment, wished
to buM thMl M aoOn asfiramcd; aodthatoaly
«a
J^f- a^KtmOH*
A.O. 17M.
[OM
^laiiBdhjKtn.agreenipmttokeeptlieni Meret
till tbe tecaiisHiftioii of their sessicm ; andthtt
tfa&i dadantMn and sesokitiDn, with the sp»
pouHment of He committee of secrecy aad
emecgency» were come to and adopted by this
ooBvention with a degree of peculiar dellbe-
nlloa and aolemni^. These points inoon-
teitihly proved by wntten evidence, recovered
oatof llie hands of the panel and his asso-
ciateSy it is next for you to consider the parole
evidtmoe adduced in explanation and support
thereof; to look to the lehictant testunoniea
ef the three spcretaries, the biothers Ross,
cod Aitchesonu Cockbum and Peterson, and to
aay whether tnis decoration and resolution
is nojteleaily proved to have been in its terms,
as io its tendency and import, one not only
«fasedtttouSy but a treasonable nature; and
which, if it had been acted upon in the
slightest degree, if one single meeting of this
committee of secrecy and emttrgencjr had
taken place in consequence of it; if it had
been pnMred that they had assembled together
undpr these dccumslan^es of secrecy, m any
^ the cases to which th^ir appointment re-
isteji, the persons so meeting wouM have
^been ffoiltyi not of sedition, but of an overt
.fct of nigh treason^ under the statute of £d-
vanl irdy which, bv the 7th of <|ueea Anne,
is now the treason law of Scotland, Oentle-
siien, I naust now beg vour particular atten-
tion to the chaige in the indictment Afler
narrating in general, that a motion was made
on the S5tk November of the following
tenor: ** That in case the mim*ter or any
ether member, bring into the House of Com-
«iens a motion for a coBvenlion bill, as
passed in Ireland, for preventing the people
mm meeting^ acrordhlg to their just rignts
by the'revolution. the same motion shall be
noticed to the delegates of the respective so-
cieties, immediately to meet in convention
io assert th^ir rights/' — The indictment
firoceeds to charge Margaxot with having
made the ibllowmg speech'. ^This is an
excellent motion, and the event which it
alludes to ought to be the iitcdn to the friends
of liberty to assemble* It seems, however, to
l»e impcnect. It does not mention any place
of meetine ; neither does it spcciiy the time
when the oelegates are to assemble ; for the
word immediately is indefinite, and will not
convey the same meaning to pmons residing
in dilerent parts of the countiy." AAer
fKmm fiuther genenal reasoning, unnecessary
to be <]uoted, the panel process thus : '< I
Ibelieve that the convention will be convinced
thia the clause of the report of the committee
of regiiktions oomprehends the spirit and in-
tention of ' citizen Callender's motion, and
also extends farther, tmarnHMck a ii promda
fit e fmmker cf eofCif ^fualfy dMngermu to
idm^ Of a can^mUiam kUL It will be found,
also, that this business of calling a meeting
of the convention had better be entrusted to
« ikied tommktee^ appoinUdfor ike pmrtiaUar
fiVfoee o^ wedding eqtry uU w^ich may mU-
taU againU. He rifkU ef the petmle/* That
these words, or at bast words to tnis purpose
and of this import, were used by the panel,
Margaret, on this occasion, is proved by the
Gaietteer, in which the speech makes its ap-
pearance : that the effect of the motion itself
waa resbtance to4he legisiafave, in the ^ven
and supposed, and not unlike^ case there
^u^ and that resistance too immediaUy is im-
possible to be denied or doubted; and that
the panel, not content with the measure thus
avowed^and as thus directed to be carried
into ewct, did, in this treasonable speech,
endeavour, not only to encourage this con*
vention in their designs, but by every argii-
ment in his power, do his utmost to stunulate
them to lesisfeanee still more active, and or-
galeae a plan of secret rebellion still more
extensive and formidable, seems to me evi-
dent on its moat cursory perusal. This infer-
ence I leave to your inmartial consideration.
Then foUpws the following most daring
and 'seditkms declaration, on the notice
of which as soon as I received satbfactdiy
information of its existence, I had no dif-
ficulty in directing the magistrates of the
city and c6unty to do their dutv, first
by aeixing these ringleaders and afi their
papers; and next bydispersmg their iUenl
and treasonable meeting, if they shoiSd
again dare Io assemble wiUiin their respective
jurisdictions^ to which I must entreat your
most patlioiuar attention.
Thus is it charged in the indictment:-^
^ This fOBventidn, considenng the calamitous
conaequences of anv act of the legislature,
which msy tend to deprive the wholes or any
part of the people, of their undoubted right
to meet, either by themselves, or by del<^a^
Iton to discuss any matter relative to their
common interests, whether of a public or pri>
vate nature, and holding the same to be to-
tally inconsistent with the first principles and
safety of society, and also subversive of our
own and acknowledged constitutiona] liber*
ties, db Aerejy declmre h^bre God end the
world, that we shall follow the wholesome
example of former times, by fMgring no re*
gard to any act which shall militate against
the constitution of our country, and shall
continue to assemble, and consider of the best
means by which we can accomplish a real re*
presentation of the people, and annual elcx^
tion, until compelled to desist by superior
lorce.
y ** And we do resolve,
^ That the first notice eiveh for the intro-
duction of a convention bSl, or any bill of a
similar tendency to that passed in Ireland, in
the last session of their parliament;
** Or any bill for the suspension of the Ha-
beas Corpus act, or the act for preventing
wrongous imprisonment, and against undue
delays of trials in North Britain ;
^ Or in case of an invasion; or tbe^ odwif*
ssfii of any foreign troops whatsoever into Great
Britain: aller may eae of then ce/aaiifam ^if^
075] 34 GEORGE IIL Proceedings agtuMd Maurice Margarot
What is your opinkm upon the visms ofj
those convehtions?--I consider them to be
perfectly legal.
What was the purpose of their assembling?
*— To obtain a rerorm in parliament.
Were you ever interrupted in those meet^
hies by the civil magistrates ?•— No, as far as
Unow, I neyer was.
Did you ever bear in the course of your
communications with other people, that the
jMfistrotes deraned those meetmgs seditious
and illegal? — No, I never did.
You do not know of any members of those
conventions ever haviujg been apprehended,
in consequence of their being members of
those conventions P — ^No, I never did.
Were you present at any of the meetbags
of the last British convention f — ^Yes, I was
occa»onally.
Was there any material difference in the
proceedings? — I certainly know of no differ-
ence; there might be some little difference
in their mode of expression as to the objects
iJbey had in view.
Was the mode of proceeding in those ob-
jects nearly the same ? — ^They were the same
as for as I know.
Were the one and the other equally void
of violence, tumult, or sedition ? — I never saw
any thing of the kind.
Were an^r seditious doctrines ever held or
authorized in the British convention? — 'So-
thing that I should call seditious myself, or
that I ever thought seditious.
Did you imagine it to be a part of the peo-
ple's right to meet in that manner, to petition
parliament, or obtain a reform? — ^I always
understood so.
Were you present when I was said to have
made the motion with respect to the union
between Scotland and England? — I do not
recollect the time the motion was made ; but
I think I remember a motion of that descrip-
tion.
What was the intention of that motion, if
you can recollect any thing of it? as far as
you could infer from the words that it was
expressed in, was there any thing in it of an
evil tenden<^, with reeard to the king and
sovernment of Britain r — As far as I recol-
lect, it was a general sort of a plan of opera-
tions, between the societies in England and
Scotland.
To produce what end f— To establish a cor-
respondence between the societies of England
and Scotland, upon a constitutional mode of
proceeding to petition the legislature.
Were ^ou present when (as he is called,
here) citisen Callender made a motion re-
spectinfj a convention bil)?--I do not re-
collect It; I do not think I was present at
the time that motion was made.
But you understood the nature of that mo-
tion, to have respect to the time, when a
convention bill should be broueht into the
House of Conimons: did you unaerstand that
the convention of emergency, which was to
[BT6
take place on the intiodiictioii of such bill,
or rataer whether the del^alcB of the con*
vention of emergency were to assemble, im-
mediately upon tne introduction of such bill,
CM* wait till it had passed in the House of
Commons? — ^They were to assemble, as fat
as I recollect, upon the introduction of such
a bill.
I suppose that you thought that thiseon-
vention was to oppose that bill? — Yes.
In what way? — ^In a legal and oonstitu*
tional manner, by petitioning parliament, «r
by counsel.
Had you any apprehensien that these dde-
gates meant to employ open vioknee?— 4
never heard any thing of that Idnd.
Were there any warlike praparatiMis §ar
that purpose ? — ^No.
Was there any sum subsoribed for that
convention ?— No.
Were any extraordinaiy measures taken to
g've strength to that convention, which tho
ritish convention did not then enjoy ?-->N«.
Were you present at the meeting at
Laine's ?-^Yes, I was.
What did vou hear the sheriff-substitute
say ? — ^I heard him desire tiiem to disperse.
What reason did he give for the disperrionf
— He said he had orders to disperse them;—
that it was an Ulegal and unccmsUtMtiMal
meetmg.
You are certain that he said he had etden?
— ^Yes, I am very sure of that.
Was he not informed of the constitutioBal
manner in which we were proceeding to de»
bate on the question respectine an admress to
the king, or petition to parnament, for a
reform ? — ^As far as I peooUect he was, though
I cannot say by whom, but I believe it waa
Mr. Skirving.
Were you there the preceding night, whan
the lord provost came to disperse Uiat meet-
ing f — X came in about the time that he
came.
Werp they peaceable before the ford pio»
vost came ?~I was not there long before.
Were vou there when he came in?— -Yes.
Was there any confusion after he came N—
No.
Did you hear it explained to tht sheriff*
substitute when he dispersed them at Laiaff*s,
what was the nature of the business of toe
evening? — Yes, I answered that question
before.
When foice was said to be neoessaiy to
disperse us, after the token of force ghpen by
the sheriff to the chairman, wes any forther
force necessai^v f-— No ; aner Mr. Maraarot
came out of the chair, somebody called Mr.
Gerrald to it, and he took the chair; and we
did not disperse till he went toprayer,^nd
then we went away.
Was it actual force that dispersed t», or an
ideal force, a submissfon to orders thai wte
dkl not resist?— A submission to orders; but
I looked upon the order of the magtsmtes
to be force.
077} jfbr Sftfitton.
But iha Menb^rs of the Brituh oonven*
tiofi, when so dispersed, retired peaceably,
did they oet ?— YeSb
Johm Oath sworn.— Ezammed by Mr.
Margarot.
What are you?*-A mason in Edinburgh.
You were a member of the British con-
vention ? — ^Yes.
With what view did you join thatconvenr
tioii? — ^I joined it with a view to obtain a
«^form in the representation of the people.
Were you convinced in your own mind that
the attempt to obtain a reform was legal and
constitutional? — I thought so, or I would
iMt have been a member of it
You are on your oath, and I desire you to
answer this fairly ; if you had found that the
members of the British convention had de-
parted from that constitutional line in which
they set out, and in which they were acting
when you joined them, would yon have
abandoned them ? — H I had thought they
had deviated from that constitutional hne,
I certainly would have abandoned them, no
4loubt of It ; but I have not found it.
You have not tlien abandoned them yet ? —
No ; not so long as th^ are constitutional.
What was tte tenor of the behaviour of
tiie coBvcstioB ? waa it peaceable behaviour,
and orderly, or riotous and tumultuous? —
Peacttible and orderly.
Was any seditious doctrine encoura^ffid or
piomulgaied tiiere ? — ^I am at a loss to know
what seditious doctrine is now, and I cannot
answer that question ; I did not understand
it to be seditious.
Was any step proposed at any time that
vou might think unconstitutional, from vour
knowldge of the constitution of the bill of
rights, and of the daim of rights? — No, not
any thing.
What was the motive of the convention,
for endeavouring to promote a union between
Scotland and En^and ? — ^I understood it was
to 'promote a union between those societies
that wished for reform, that they might unite
in adopting the constitutional means to ob-
tain it.
You never harboured any idea that it was
for a sinister purpose, did you ? — ^No.
Did ywi ever understand that if the French
landed in Ensland, the convention were to
meet them ?— Quite the reverse.
Do you know of any member of the British
convention |having any correspondence what-
ever with France, directly or indirectly?—
None.
Were you present at the time the lord
provost dispersed the convention on the 5th
December?— -No.
Were you present at the time the sheriff
substitute dispersed them on the 6th Decem-
ber?^-! was.
Before the sheriff-substitute came in, how
was the convention with reggrd to order,
peace, and deconm?— It waa perfectly or-
A. D. ITM.
[OTS
derly, but I was a very short time in before
the sheriff-substitute came.
What did vou understand to be the sub-
ject of the debate that ni^ht? — ^There was a
motion about another petition to parliament.
What was said to the sheriff when he at-
tempted to disperse us?— I believe he was
told that it was a peaceable, constitutional
meeting, and that his dispersing us was ille-
^ ; we were met for the purpose of petitipn-
mg parliament, and were entitled to do so by
the constitution.
What was his reply? — ^That he behoved to
obey his orders; that he did not come to
argue, but to obey his orders, to disperse the
meeting.
You are certain he mentioned the words,
his orders? — I think I am pretty certain of
that.
Did I as chairman require some sign of
force from him ? — You did.
What sien of force did he make use of? —
He touched you by the hand, and sud, Come
out, and you said. No, it must be a little
more than that, and then he took you by the
arm and gently pulled you out, as I iwould a
friend, and then you came out; then Mr.
Gerrald took the chair, and it was moved,
that we should dissolve in the ordinary way,
with pmyer, upon which Mr. Gerrald went to
prayer, and we came away.
Do you apprehend there was any idea of
resistance, or any attempt to resist, or that
any individual showed a wish to resist ?-*-
None that I know of, it is distant from my
idea.
Do you apprehend that the general appre-
hension was, at that time, that the sheriff
was acting unlawfully ? — ^I presume it was^
but I cannot say what they thought.
However, they retired peaceably ? — Yes.
And no riot ensued ? — No.
No drunken bout ensued that night, of the
Friends of the People ? — ^None, to my know-
ledge.
John Clark, cross-exammed by Mr. SolkUoT'
General,
You have been talking about the bill of
rights and the claim of rights, where have you
read them ? in what book is it to be found ? —
I do not recollect.
Can you tell us any thing about this claim
of riehts, any of the articles of it ? — ^I cannot
teU tne whole.
You have upon your oath told us, that there
was nothing done m this convention con-
trary to the bill of rights, or the claim of
rights : is the right of petitioning parliament
one of the articles ? — ^Yes.
Did you ever read any thing about illegal
associations called by private authority, eiUier
in the bill of rights, or claim of rights ? — ^I
cannot recollect at present.
Lord Abererombie.'^Vid you ever act as
preses in the British convention ?— When I
was there as president, I m^ keepmg order.
€901 54 GBOROE III. Proceedings BgainH Maurice Margarot [700
low or Ckirka Iomw of the subject. But he
M not kaow what aeditioa was ; and he teUs
^NMy that the law of the oooDtry was coaie to
a sad pass indeed, when the word eUmeny
which he gkiried in, wae to constitute a- nan
crimina]. And he tokl yooy that the psinci^
pies of this convention were carried on in the
same way, or very little dificfent, from those
which BUffked the pryceedings and conduct
of the former convention. If they were, all
I can say is this; tiiat these former conven-
tiens kept their proceedings very much a se**
efet; for if I haa known that tliev bad done
so^ or come to uty resolutions similar to those
proved to-d9f a^nst this man^ the members
of that convention should, before now, have
sloed before a juiy of their countrymen. If
they did so, then all that I have to sav is,
that they were more cautious^ or they perhaps
did not think that the time was ^ite ripe to
express what they have since expressed. To
be sura, the term citiaen, taken by itself is
an innooeQt and a proper term ; I have i»ed
It to«nicht : we aie all ^low-citisens here to-
night And the word * tocsin/ whether it cornea
ftom Fianoe, or whether it comes from China,
er any where else, I feel nothing criminal in
that term, taken by itself; nor in the first
year of British liberty; nor indeed the de-
cades, which, by the bv, I find in one of the
phms for the support of the Oaeetteer, that it
shall be dmded into decades, and that each
decade shall take so many copies of the Ga^
aetteer; that is a Latin word; nor the first
silting; in the same way all the other expres-
Mone, which I will not run over, taken by
themselves, are surely and unquestionably in-
nocent; we all may use them in an innocent
tense, without the smallest apprehension, or
the smallest blame. But here is the point,
gentlemen, upon which I found the charge of
' criminality; it is for this purpose tliat I col-
lect these expressions, occurring in the pro-
ceedings of these minutes; and i collect them
as links in the chain of evidence, to show you
that this man has been guilty of apeing and
imitating the French convention, as acUng
upon that modi;! and that principle, as in the
, same way was done last year in Ireland, and
r was the cause of the Irish oarliament passing
that act^ it is a proof of tne animus and the
intent of the persons concerned in that meet-
ins, that they took for themselves the model
and example of the present convention of
Fhmce, imitating it in ever^ way in their
power; and the conclusion is irresistible, that
if they durst have gone forward, or if an in-
vasion had teken place, we would have found
these men joining that band of invaders,
whom they admired, praised, and imitated,
in their hostile attack on our countiy. You
will consider with yourselves, Uiying your
hands upon your hearts, whether it is possi-
ble to doubt, that this was the real, the true,
indeed the hurdiy disguised purpose of their
proceedings, when you find them, in all the
enumerated casesi organiaing a secret com-
aaktee, lomeetatasaolcQiicoUedevettinMn
its members, as a rallying point, whicb the
eye of the executive power of the atale could
not reach, and firom whence they mi^t diieat
themeansof insurrectaonand oonoperation with
the enemy, without runnii^the nsk of at least
immediate detection. Can you hesitate one
moment in thinking as I thmk, and as I be-
lieve, that if such an event had taken placg,
that men who form themaelves upon that
model, and aseumed, as for as in uiem lay,
and as for as they durst, the expressions of
the French convention, wi A which we are at
present At war, and by^ whom we are threa-
tened with that invasion, would have gone
against the persons who were their own ofa»>
wc^ of imitation, and that we would ooft
nave fiMind them consistent in their conduct,
by folbwing French examples still foither,
by accoraplishmg that which, to the asto-
nishment of Europe, has too sucoessfidly aa
suddenly been accomplished, a subversioa c(
all government, of all religion, and of all the
laws of society, and the establishment, in
thur stead, of « system, pretendinc to be, ior
to resemble, that of universal sumag^ one
ofthe great and leading objects of thiaoonveo-
tion, whose conduct and real objects you an
nowcalledupon to consider and declare?
Gentlemen. ^You cannot expect more di-
rect and convincing evidence of what passed
in their asinds. until the evil is gone to suck
an height, until the invasioo has taken place,
till the tumult or the insurrection has hap-
pened, which these nsen have endeavoured to
foment. Seditien then would no longer be
the crime; treason would be the shape it
would then assume: it would then be the
duty of everv fr^ and loyal subject to join
hand in hand against the^ traitors, whom we
have found, in the moineat of that invasion,
assembling in a ascret piece, aa the ddegsAea
of thousands, and whom we find proving
themselves, by every act by which it was
]K>ssible to prove thonselves, to be the sup>
porters and imitators of the French convef^-
tion. I call them French Cunventionisfs :
it is the essence of the chaise against them s
it is the point upon which 1 desire your attend
tion. If they were the mere innocent oon^
vention, or assembly, or association, or so-
ciety for reform in parliament, be their reform
never so absurd, or the instruments of their
meeting never so ineflbctual for the object, I
say God forbid you ahould find them guilty,
to the extent ofthe most trifling punishment
which the lai^ can fix upon them ; but ifytm
find them directly avowing, in handl^F ecjmvo-
cal and doubtful tenns, that an invasion shall
be one of the cases in which they shall assea»-
ble, not to do that which would be the glory
of a loyal subject, to sacrifice their lives and
fortunes in resisting the invaders; but if we
find them, insteedcvthat, shoaang their pre-
dilection for the cause of France in all ita
forms,— it is your duty and vour psovinoe to
dive into the recesses of the numanmiad; |n
701]
^/vf SflMMflk
A. D. VfU.
[702
dmaider the inference wbkh ttWM from sudi
prteeedings; — to consider, if you will not lay
the hand of criminal justice upon them, to
quell the conspiracy before it bursts into light ;
or if the deluded people»»I speak of the inha-
bitants of this city, I speak of the inhabitants
of Scotland at large, snd of what has peaaed
within these Uiree or four days,— «re so nucfa
in the power of these strang^s who have
latelv come amongst us, are to come in an iin»
usual mode to a oaurt of criminal justice,
either to o«er<4iwe that court, the prosecutor,
cr the jurymen ; if they are to be indulging
in ftlae and scandalous aspersions, -asthat of
packed juries, it is for you to interfere, and
check ttie evil in its bud ; now is the time,
this is the moment for you to mark your
sense of their proceedings, and stop them,
while their guilt still remains with a feature
of sedition marked upon it, i^eiging upMi
treason, with such a triflins distinction, that
it is admost impossible for a lawyer to find the
difierenoe. It is so Utile, that when the in-<
dictroent was preferred against Mr. Margarot,
had it not been for the promptitude with
which it was necessary to bring, him before
vou, I should have laid the case before the
king's council in England, as to the appoint-
ment of A secret commitflee, whether that,
per se, wasnot sufficient to ground the charge
of higb-tDsason. Sure I am, but for the act
of the Ttbof^ueen Anne, that the gentlemen
were for withm the ease of Scotch treasons ;
and in that case, Mr. Margarot would have
•toed at your bar tried for his life.
Gentlemen, before I sit down, let me re-
tttTB again to the evidence of Mr. Geom
Ross, who tells you that he had heard ora
convention bill, and of a number of Hessians
and Hanoverians tobe landed inthu countrv ;
that also was a case when it was proper ror
the eonv<Hition to meet at the secret place of
meeting, that is to say, and it is tiie case at
this moment, I believe, that as a body of
Hessians are passing towards France, if par-
liament should choose to allow them to land
upon this island, this was also a case of emer-
gency ; not that we could confide to the wis-
3om of King, Lords, and Commons, but the
British convention was to decide alone what
was tofbe done; a case exactly of the- same
kind with the other, even in the way that Mr.
Ross h&nself states it. But I will not wound
the feelings of thit worthy citizen (and I trust
that he hears me), bv saying, that he con-
oealed the truth, I will not say that; but he
ftas foreot that mighty event which his bro-
ther and Coekbum swore to^ which must have
fitr^ck the mind and ears of every man who
heard it; but his memory is a frail one, and ^
vmh that observation I leave him.
Gentlemen^ we are now coming near to
a close. You will find a variety of other evi-
dence, much of the same nature, in num-
ber S, of the inventory. You will find one of
the documents material to be attended to, in
considflnngtiw question: Whether the con-
vention is a seditious or « feir conventkmf
forthatisiheeistoftheiiuestion which you
are to try, and upon whioh yoiu are to mko
up your minds. Now these papers ai« traced
home to the possessionof Mr.Margsrot Mr«
Aiteheson, in his character of assistant seoie-
laiy to the convention, identic a P*P^r to
wmch he tells you, to this conventioo, he put
his subscription, entitled, ^ Jimtt wm-tke Qitn*
Hamif Unwn;*^ and in the inside see ibrae or
four di£feraat paners, which tiM witnesses who
made the search swear wen incJaaed in it,
and «11 relating to the solsnii wwf the w^
pointment of viat coamittee of umon, of
which Mr. Margarot was the tliainnan. He
appears to be the leader <^ this oNnmittce of
umon between England and firmthmd; a
union which tiiese gentlemen, it aesnis, had
authorify to make ; aunion whkb we vnifbi^
tunately have been deoeived, as wcJl as our
fethers, in dreamily that we have possessed^
and, as we thought, ei\)oyed since the year
1707, which Mr.Aitchtton told-us !was no»
tiling like the unkm brought about' by thfs
oonTentbn, with so much solemnity; a^wild^
sycophant union, I think he caUed it; and
Mr. Margarot is the person who takes the mv
tive part m this committee. Let us see wha%
it amounts to. 1 shall take the papor itself
which Paterson, a man who, mudi to hie
credit, has seceded firom that meeting* He,
as the head of his section, admits, t&t that
paper was drown up in his section, and was
by him sent in a letter to the oonventioa,
Mr. Margarot, feeling the force of these pa*
pers, desired to know. How aro you certain
that paper was in the conventbn ? I will tell
Mr. Maigarot how 1 am certain of it Mr*
Aiteheson subscribes it at the baek,'< Hints
respecting the Union ;'' and says, it must have
been put upon that paper in its reception. Mr.
Peterson tells you, he sent it in the common
form from his section, whieh met in the
morning, to the convention, which met in
the evening, and of which Mr. Aiteheson was
assistant secretarv ; and thero is no reason to
suppose, that it did not reach its place of des-
tination, the Masons Lodge, at the foot of
Blackfriars Wynd. And what is it? <* Hmta
upon the Question of Union." First, 'l^at
the people of Great Britain, disclaiming any
distinction of Scoteh and English, do now
and for ever unite themselves into one mass
and indissoluble union. Then it goes on —
Make known to all concerned, in exclusive
terms, that this shall be the motto : — ^Resto-
ration of Riffhts. What rights? Universal
Suffrage, ana Annual Parliaments; a thing
that never did, and that never can, exist.
Let them go back to the histoid of England ;
let them go back to the deepest antiqwty; it
never did exist. Those people, until tutored,
misled, and misinformed by Margarol, had
not heard of the Bill of Rights, nor the claim
of rights ; and knew not what rights they had
lost. But, gentlemen, I have been taught,
by every writer on Uiis subject^ either fiureiga
70S] 34 GEORGE IIL Proceedings again^ Maurice Mqrgarot [7M
or domes^c, a very di£Rerent doctripe. We
have all been hitherto educated in, and im-
pressed with,' the belief, that the free consti-
tution of this neat and happy country, era-
ilually improved and perfected by the wisdom
and. spirit of our ancestors, through succes-
sive centuries, and mellowed down by the
band of time, has reached its present boasted
pre-eminence, and tonterred the highest be-
nefits on its inhabitants, that it is possible for
human institutions to confer on a people. If
the doctrines and tenets preached by Marga**
rot and bis' associates be true, that annual
parliaments and universal sufl^age are neoes*
saiy to constitute freedom, we never. have
been free from all eternity, and are not free
at the present moment. I hope in God, in
that sense we never shall, because that never
can take place, for the best of all possible rea-
sons, as I beUeve the late Soame Jenyns says.
It is the best plan of the whole, says he, for
the best of all possible reasons, because it is
impracticable. It is tedious, gentlemen,, and
I am confident unnecessary, to dwell more
minutely, and more at length, on the irre-
sistible proof of a seditious and treasonable
purpose, deducible from a perusal of every
pace of the minutes of this convention. In
order, they say, that all occurrences may be
known from one end of the kingdom to the
other,.and in order to instruct every indivi-
dual of this great and indivisible mass, they
appoint a committee, for devising the most
eliectual means of disseminating their sedi-
tious proceedings, and circulating the conta-
gion as widely as their mischievous intentions
could invent. Always do they run upon the
French expressions in every part of their mi-
nutes, in every speech in their Gazetteer, con-
tinually recurring to French words, French
terms, and French expressions. In another
motion, made by James Gartley, which Ait-
cheson volunteered in telling me was not evi-
dence against Mr. Margarot — ^being found up-
on his person — it proves the nature of that
convention, of which he was not only a mem-
ber, but an active, leading instrument ; it is
also marked upon the back by Aitcheson, and
this motion signed James Gartley, who is the
town drummer of Anderston, near Glasgow,
is, ^' that the convention took into their Hriout
contideration tfie necessity of dividing the coun-
try into departments^ in order that the Friends
of the People may have an opportunity of meet*
tng in the particular department to zohich they
bewngy and thus form a sort (^provincial con-
7)entiony that they may become more particularly
tu:quain$ed with each other J'
Gentlemen. — ^The honour of the sitting ap-
pears to be given, by the French convention,
to persons they wish to favour ; so we find, in
the minutes, among other insignia of the ho-
nours of the British convention, secretary
Skirving stated, that he had just now re-
ceived five shillings firom an unknown hand,
for the use of the convention. ^ Honourable
mention in the minutes ^ras ordeied to be
made of thi» patriotie gift.''-^Upon my word;
I never was in the French convention, and I
hope I never shall be, but I should have sop-
posed, from what I have read in the news-
papers, that I was reading of the French con-
vention at Paris. Citizen Callender moved,
'' that no perwn be allowed the honour of th^
sittings without the recommendation of two per^
sons;** it is a favour not to be bestowed rashly
or lightly ; which, with amendments, passed
unanimously. Atlerwards it was moved, that
capt. Johnston,* and I am extremely sorry to
find him here, if he is the individual to whom
I allude at present, because it may perhaps
compel other proceedings against him; but
when he read an account in the newspaper of
the sentence of Uolt. the printer, of Newark,
for reprinting the nuke of Richnxtnd's and
Mr. Pitt's resolutions upon parliamentary re^
form,f it was moved, ** that capt. Johnston be
admitted to the honour of the sitting,**
Gentlemen, there is one other circam-
stance which 1 cannpt help just in passing to
take notice of, and it is that of a compulsory
attendance enforced upon those persons, who
mieht have the misfortune to be deluded in ar
rash unthinking moment, into a participation
of their proceedings, to shame them from
doing, as Mr. Paterson, much to his honour,*
did, return back to their duty. In this
manner you will find it resolved, that no
dele^te is to leave his post, or is to ^t per^
mission of absence from it, till he obtains a
new delegation, a substitute in his place to
act for him: of this arbitraiy, intolerant,
and despotic spirit, we saw I think too strong
symptoms yi the conduct of the panel to-^
day. He presumed to put and insist on a
most irrelevant question to the witness, Pa->
terson, which highly indulged as the panel
has been, the justice of the court woukl not
allow. He then sneeringly said, he would
not touch the sore heel of Paterson, for
having done that which, I am sure, jou will
join with me in thinking was to his honour.
Would to God every deluded member of thia
convention had spirit and sense to follow
Paterson's example. In one of the papers
citizen Wilson and another requested leave of
absence to be granted them, and it was moved
that all the delegates should have letters. to
return immediately, and remain at their
posts till the important business, daily intro-
duced in the convention, shall be properly^
discussed; and in page 100 of the minutes,
citizen Scott moved,. tiiat before any delegate
from the country shall leave his post, he shall
write to his constituents to send another ia
his room. Agreed to, nem. con.
Gentlemen, the two instances which I
have given are perfectly sufficient to show,
that in this respect also, as in their declaring
e See the proceedings against him^ aute,p^
pp. 43. 60. .
f. See Daniel Holt's case» Vol. 2'i, p. 1X&9>
of this Collection, .j
709]
Jot SedUkm.
A. D. 179l>.
[706
themflelreB perHMnMiit, whieh » proved by
all the wilnesses, and which is proved by the
Gazetteer, that they, in every paper, imitate,
it) the most minute particular, the proceedings
of the French convention. In one word, I
leave this ]>oint for your consideration ; re-
peating again, that those words, taken of
themselves, or in any different circumstances,
would have themselves been idle, and that
which you could have grounded no verdict
upon ; out taking them in conjunction with
the evidence of the Gazetteer, and the parole
evidence this day upon your table, certainly
do go to the point, that this was a highly
seditious, if not treasonable meeting, avowed
to be assemUed for the f>uTpose of overawing
parliament, and reusting any act which
might pass until compelled to desist by supe-
rior force : if you are of that opinion, you
will find a verdict in my favour; for with
Vizard to the panel being a ringleader in this
business, and being a man wno conducted
these committees, the evidence upon that
point is so clear, it is impossible to be dis-
puted; the moment you have come to a
determination upon the one pointy it neces-
sarily f<^ows, that he is a principal in the
guilt of being a member of that convention,
and a rinjgleader in it; and as sucb» he is
more responsible than the poor creatures
whom you have seen to-day, and who were
Hnder his guidance.
Gentlemen, I am afraid I trespass more
upon your time, much more than I had any
intention of doing, when I rose ; but I can-
not help taking notice of one thing which
dfopped from the gentleman at the bar ; in
the commencement of this dav's trial, he
told us, that he had cited several persons as
witnesses in his behalf, who have not ap-
peared this day upon the trial ; men bearing
the highest offices in the state, and at present
discharging the duties of those important
offices in England. And he brought evi-
dence, which I dare say is the case, that,
under the letters of exculpation which issue
of course, and in which tie can fill up any
name that he pleases, that he subpoenaed
them in London by the forms of the law of
England : in the course of his remarks on
this matter, and in which he digressed into
topics neither proper in themselves, nor
beftrins at all on his case, he referred to
myself and to my own candour, if the public
prosecutor had not higher powers in bringing
witnesses to this court tnan what he pos-
sessed. I have no difficulty, at all times and
seasons, to give my opinion to a panel,
whether I am bound to do it or not, and I
then did give him an answer ; I said I had
no more power of compelling witnesses to
come into this court, than the meanest cri-
minal at the bar. Our rights, in that respect,
and our powers are the same. I will give
biim an instance of it: the case occurred
twelve vears ago, when one of your lord-
ships, filled the office of solicitor-general of
VOL* XXHL
Scotland. A man of the name of Maekay,
a carrier of letters at the post-office, was ac-
cused of having embezzled letters and stolen
money entrusted to his charge. The princi-
pal evidence was a woman, a relation of bis
own, and who, immediately afler the fact
was <Kscovered, retired to England. The
solicitor - general brought his indictment
against him. I appeared as counsel Ibr the
panel. The trial was adjourned from week
to week, and from day to day ; because this
material evidence, the woman, would not
come, for obvious reasons, within the juris-
diction of our courts of law, to give her testi-
mony against the panel And how did she
at last come ? Having been concerned with
him, she came at last, because means were
found to notify to her, that if she did not
come and do her duty as the witness against
the panel, she herself would be tried in Eng-
land as an approver of the crime ; and there-
fore she came to save and redeem her own
life, and gave evidence, as she was bound to
do; and which she would have been com-
pelled to do, if she had been in this country ;
and I hope this instance will satisfy him,
that even the powers of the public prosecuted
are just exactly what his afe ; that he must
take his chance of bringing witnesses from a
foreign country, as we do ; and if he is not
successftil there is no help for it. If by the
complaint he made of the non-attendance of
these gentlemen, all of them now bearine
the highest offices in the state, the panel
means to found any plea of favour upon it, I
leave him in full possession of any benefit ho
may derive from it; merely observing that
if you were to give weight to such an objec-
tion, there is not a panel who would not be
entitled to the same benefit, be his crime
what it may, who will not tell you he has
witnesses in Germany, in France, in America,
or in the Indies, and you must always take
the panel's word for it ; and it is for you to
consider whether criminal justice in this, or
any country, could ever be administered, if
so fiimsv a pretence as this was listened to.
Gentlemen, before I sit down, I must
observe it was said, that in all their proceed-
ings they were not afraid of what they were
about. Compare this assertion with one very
material paper, which I trust mil satisfy you
that the gentlemen were both afraid and
aware of the danger of what they were
about. In a letter from Mr. Hardy, who is
the secretary of the London Corresponding
Society, which was found in the possession
of Mr. Margaret, after a long account of what
was goine on, and telling him, that they had
sent drafts tor money, and complaining of
the short coming of the funds which were
subscribed, it seems, for the carrying Mr.
Gerrald down to this country ; which, he says,
had fallen lamentably short of their expecta-
tions; and at last concludes thus: ^ I have
to inform you of the wish of the society, that
you. would ftvour them with the number of
S Z
7073 34r 6EPR0B m. Proceedings a§m4 Hmke Margarot ^
4^tag«tM in ib9 cwTCDtiQn froip Bnghncl,
an4 ^Ifto how the civil ^ nulitAry powfc
DsUsb^s your meeting/' Upon tb^ 8th of
Kov^inber> 1793, « ^w days afier Mr. Mar-
garot an4 Mr. Q^rrald arnved in tbi? ci^.
il|)9a an olyecl which they ^r^ not ashmiea
or afrajd to a^ov, ap ohj^^ for the psubUo
gQ0d» imm} of Gotland in particular, it ia
asNopethipg e«traQrdiDary« that it should come
ifttiQ the head of the secretary to the meet-
ing hy which t)i^y were appointe«ii^ tq ask the
ques&a bow the civU ai^d military power
teU^hed their meeting. The mUitaiy power
haa barer interfered: it cawiot interfere to
ehecl( 9|]cb neetiiigs as these, unless, what I
hc^ end trust pever eap be the (:ase> the
qpAsequence? Qf tbe^o. meetings were such
%i tQ render the Qiyil power coippelled to
aJQpt t^t lest a^d necessary measure.
Tiiieugbf were I t9 took at the speech of
^r. Memddy stated in the Gafetteer, men-
tioined in the. mbytes, and which he made
xmmediateiy after that solemn resolution was
cemt tOy—I wUi not at this hpur trouble
jc^ with quotmg it, — ^it is clear to demon-
stration^ 4hat Mr. Crerrakk at that moment
s)bowSi u^. express terms, what is his meaning;
t^at this resQiMtien was eome to, with tSe
purppse^ of resifitine lavftd authority, by force,
ecasCockbwn teQs y^^ paying no cegaid
vj^Vsver^to any such act of the legielafiiie.
^ that spe^h iieferred tp m, the min^Oes,
yd in the Ga^tteer* he 9^ys, '^ I iriae ux
qOjftmtiAst^^ the convention. OA the adoption
qf tein resohftion, not only on the psopnety.
^ thfi measuxe itseU^ but op thaA unanimity,
fpd solemnity with which it ie passed :" then
fipes on to a long stonr with re^tfd to the
IqiBb bill. 9u% the conpuj^oA ifi this, *^ thoi^h.
{ QQvld Qpt get a copy of this bjili, the. heada
yrbifik I haire cead ace sufficiently exnlanatory
of its dete^t^e priojciples,'' and wnat, gen^
tieiAep, is the bill thus strongl^r. execrated?.
Ope wwh was passed for toe wise and pnly
piurpese. of preyeotipg the meeting, of a con-
jeijiiop formed upon French models, a^
imitating French polities. I cead the othec
4ay a speech of one qf the able^ men in the
Irish ps^rhament upon thaA subject The
obi^t of that bill was, to check a society o£
Vai^d IcisbmejOL; a society with, whom I also
ba:^e the honour to. be acquaiple^; asocielgr.
Ybiph sent some papers y> this country of so
^ediJjiovs a nature, that even the first coor
irei^tion refused to receive it, as being a tcea-
sonable paper, for which the unhappjf movec
^ at this moment suffering the punishment
ttot the law baa awardfi£ He goes on:
•r^** I h/>pe the motion, which has passed this
9igh^ will convince the minister, that we
ice determined to guaro a^instevery attempt
that may be made to depctve us.of our rishts ;
9nd« though by some it may be thou^t a
ho)<L by Qtliers a daring measure, yet it will
be found the best for securing, the peace of
ihe countnr ( for if such a law were euiffisred
to pas^ if men were not allowed lo utter
their eompl^nU^ a Bumber of mmamm
passions would arise, and we wbuM seek to
appeal tp that last terrible decision, ^ event
of which is uncertain, but which God and
mature allow. If the servility of the peepls.
had been less, if they had dared to meet, uA
ip place of murmuring, had told the nili9V»
th^t there was danger in aeeking to deprmi
them of their liberties, we need not have had
that resolution to have recurred to to-night ; bul
whep I saw the oUm deliliemte countenaaee
of every one present, and the solemn mannec
in which it was passed, I was convinced that
it was not only a resolution of words, but %
rule of action.'' This is the conunentaiy
w4mc1v if you believe the Gazetteer, and wa
2^e b^od to believe it, after what we hw
heard,— this is the commentuy which Mr»
Gerr^ld gives to that resolution, to whick
I have already spoken so fid^ to-pighi^ rad
to which I ha^e afibed so criminal and aei
guil^ a eondusion. Can the trutb of mjF
Gonduaiop be doubted, when I refer you ta
the authority of Gercald in its support Oa%
of Qerrald's mouth is Margarot condemned,
Ilad the resolution itself Men never so cau-
tiously ana ambi|^ousl^ wozde^,— as but ioc
the aiikdecious conidence of these men ii^
l}ieiire;spectedsucces9, aU of ua wouki natu-
mlljre](pect would and must have been the
ce^--bAW could you, geatlemen, have hesU
tated in deducing from it the only tnu infiuw
e^(se. that rebeUiMk and trea»>n were the
r^ obkcts^ipview; when you nnd it avowed
ip the hearing of aud with the solemn oon-
c^rri?nce and approbation of this asaemblj,
ihfL\ iiO any of tbe oases of emergen^ theoeux
Sted» ijta ^rms were with them, ana all
»%9 ^ey representsd to be, not a le^hitioa
of mere wome only, but a sule of action? It
su^ persons, qt any persona are to meet and
cppsid^ aod d^eiae on what they call theisf
righ:t^ and fij( what measures of thelegiar
latpre are W entitle them to resort <^£a. Mot
lfl9f and tjerriide deci$ion^ Ake event cf whUsh
tjt. tf ap<f rota, M vhich God. and nature Maa^
-—if ypu, gentlemen of the jury, with whoai
alone it r^s to check such prooeedinfs, aee
to, sanction them, by your verdict, ana allota
^Mch audaoiity to pass free and unpunished^
where is the secunior of your laws^ your Uvea,
apd your liberties ? Whem is that protectic^
which this free government is said to bestosr.
Qo, vs. aU^ equally, and impastiaJly> bigh or.
Ipw, rich or poor, if these men's opinions,
weioe Uiey ever so.plausible, and the individuala
aexer so. wise, lo^ed, and expecsenced^ ac»
1^ be sex up. in opposition to the British, pan-
liament ?> If they are entitled to judge aft
what point t^ir resistance is to eodunenc^
apd when they are to lecur to that laatand
terrible decision, the event of which I trust
apd believe would not be uncertain, but
where tlie cause of mligion^ of law, ofi jus-
tice, ajQd freedom would ultimately psewly
thea ciyiL war ia with all its homr^ thft
ipfaUibie consficpmnce amongst us; andiha^
709]
th^ men u the mne which ba^ subverted
\ij tiie sAine awaos the most aadent md
KWerfiii montch J of Edrdpe in s mooientL
8 spread daadktiioii, and murder^ and blood
throuffhout the hitherto flourfstdiiB, riow
ndliea kii^doin of Fntnce^ and invcu^^ its
wreiched inhabitants in (biseries nnpatsl^
teled nod incredible.
\1 1 have Ttfldicated ^od^ as I hope I hkTe
ioKtty iff the connheAcenient of my air^ioient,
ftoffl the scandalous and unfounded iinputa»-
tion of behig pucked, as jcki were said to be^
may £ be permitted^ gentlemen, before I
conclude^ tp yindicarte myself kad the other
serrants of the emwu, as Marga^ot at Xhh
same time styled Us^ irom the imputations he
then indulged in again^A U9. If be means
the servants of dve cr6Wn in this country,
I UDsauestionably stand amongst them. It
m sua that tee are the persons guilty of sedi-
lion; that #e sowed sedition between our
BBteter and our fifellow* subjects ; that toe are
the proper persons to stand at that bar ; that
to ttt are to be imputed the offences with
whicfa I have ^iMirsea him. Upon that point
I now standy as we {mnel does, on my tria),
before a iury of my country, and 1 feel not
the least aifficulty in thinking, that upon that
charge I shall meet with a complete aecpiittal.
All that I now say is, that standinf^- m the
dtuation in which I do^ and ably assisted as
I am, I have never brought any indictment
Ugainst any man for any offoncei I never
opened in my life a bundle of papers whieh
were laid before nie, oootaining the case of a
proposed crimini^ without an awful feeling
upon my own mind of the delicacv and th6
extent fit thftt duty which dep^ndect upon the
eiercise of my understanding, and carefully
consulting my conscience upon the subject.
If you dmer with me upon this occabioft^ I
ahould at least hope^ — if it is possible w6
can differ upon the subiect^ — that you will
not think I have braudnt any improper or
oppressive pros^eution before you ; at leasts
if I am giulty of seditiously perverting the
duties of m^r office in this man's case, I shall
look back with some consolation, that in thd
predsely similar bne of his associate, Skir-
ving, I have received the best support which
eomes home to a man's consciencCi the una-
nimous verdict of a jury of my country.
Something was said of my being a place^
dian and a pensbner. I am a piaceman, it
is Wue; I have beeii for ten years in two
high official situations ; neither of them at
any time sinecures, but which, irom the
exertions and artifices of this man and his
associates, has of late been rendered to me
peculiarly laborious, painful, and severe. To
llie char^ of being a placeman, I therefore
plefbd gum^. That as such I am unpopular
in the firiush eonveniton, 1 have not a doubt.
Even the boy Calder dxdlted to-day ill
ipving biis evideiice, that he waa not a places
Absltfd M tbia impittatM n, Ml
A. a I'm.
1710
nawcrthy of my nbdi;e, I tintM fotb^^ s^-
ing that I sUouki foel myself mean indeed m
my own eyes^ if, by accepting the 6ituktidn I
now hold, hiy indeeetid^nte was ff^Uf^ in
thte smallest respect. If I httve be^n^ by
aockl^iltal cirebm&tances, Mrly bfdu^ht fot>-
WAid to a high situdtioh, if I found its duties
militating against the dictates of my owti
mibd, I ttust^ With all the emolument of it,
nothing should tempt tak io fetaiu it^ tir
preveht me from tbtowine it up. t have
dohe nbthing but brought the guilty Vo ju^
tice ; and as! to what they may s&y, I citre
not If the panel thinks he can be benefitdl
by attacking me on the groiiifd of my beihg a
placeman, Or on any oth^r t6pic whatever,
he both has the right to do so, aud my ftdl
and perfect approbation in s6 doing. As tb
being a pensioner, I aiU not ; and if that t^
is matter of reproach, it U not likely I shan
ever be liable to it. Born, gentlemen, in thft
city, you know my situation in life as Well Sfe
any body. From the hour I first cami t6 thb
bar, I have supported myself by iny prof<^
sion ; and were I turned out of my preselift
office to-morrow, I should retire behind thtft
bar again, with little else thad that hoildui^
able pUDf^ion to support me and my ftrmly,
as free of the public money, as independent k
man as I was in 1784» when I was nrst ihtro^
dwedwithm it. I beg pardon, gctift^mefi^
both of you and the Court, f^r having thvk
deviated firom the strict line and path 4f thff
datVf to notice matters personal to my^f^
and with which you will justly say, yoU'hav^
no concern. But having be^n attaeft^ \h
your presence and hearing, and as the paMl
may probably in the defence he has ntfw xM
right to make, indulge himself in faithet
a&usations against me, to which^ by Xhh
just and humsde practice of the Court, I hsiV6
no bpportunity to reply, I thought proper tO
8*y 80 mueh before I sai dowd, and be^ofe I
call upbn you^-which I hope ffnd Ifun Will
be the das^—to return that verdict which I
think is founded upon the evidence, that Xfnk
man is gulHy of the crime of sdlition witik
which I nave charged him.
Mr. Margaroi. — Gentlemen of the jury ; I
shall come undoubtedly with jgreat disadvan^
tages, after the fiond oratory of the pUbti^
prosecutor. However, he forumately for m^
has been so very orofuse in many points, thai
' it reminds me of 9hak^pear*s proverb,
j •' Two grains of wheat in a biishel of chatf."
I I address myself at present to my country^
and through the medium of a jury. — You ai%
the representatives of that country ; — ^gresit is
the trust reposed in you;<'you are meil, 1
make no doubt, of untainted, of unspotted
chahicters, and I hope you will prove yoitf^
selves suchd— High sounding wdrda I hop6
will yield to plam sense.
Gentlemen, I am ndt an attorney, tha)[ik
God, neither am I a memli^r or pafliai^
flMnty^thask Ood fik«^JBei-^Xt m tbi
71 1] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedingf agama Mmuriee Margara [719
public accuser's business to set forth, in the
most lively colours, every crime, or im-
puted crime, which he states at the bar of
this court. — I do not blame him for so doing.
I do not find fault with him for making the
most of his talents, or doing the noost for the
money he receives. — He has however tried to
prejudice vou in the first instance against me.
lie has thrown out that I have asserted that
you are a packed jury. — It is a falsehood.—
Forgive me, gentlemen of the jury, — foreive
me my country, if I speak bold but plain Tan-
guase. — I cannot give you (for I am not a sy-
cophant) high souuding words, but that which
you will understand. I did not say you
were a packed jury — I objected to not one of
you, but objected to the unconstitutional way
m which I said the jury were chosen out of
the g^ssize ; because it is in the breast of the
lord justice clerk to pick out such as bethinks
proper ; and therefore, though you are not a
packed jury, when he chooses to exert his
skill and penetration that way, you may be-
come a picked jury. However, at present
the cause is of great consequence ; it is not
merely a criminal at the bar that you see in
me ; — it is not the crimes of an individual ; it
is not the efforts of one single person that are
attacked ;— no, it is at present your own
riehts which are attackea, it is the rights
of your country, and ^our country look to you
to do those rights justice, and to sustain
them'
Gentlemen, the public prosecutor has found
means to blend trials, crimes, criminals, va-
rious persons and various articles of accusation
altogether, in order to make a sum total of
such a size, as shall seize upon your imaginar
lion, and make you behold a mountain ofj
fuilt, where in fact, there is not even a mole-^
ill of imprudence. — In me at present, I am
sorry for it, and it will appear perhaps a kind
^ of pride; but it is the truth, that in me they
cause of a parliamentary reform is this day
attacked — it is not the individual me — I
^ should have escaped notice ; but it is the dan-
gers impending from abroad, and the dangers
impending at home, on the heads of those
who now occupy some of the highest sta-
tions in the state ; — of those who, entrusted
by the crown with the greatest powers, may
perhaps have made a worse use of them than
they think they could answer for before a
parliament, fairly and freely chosen by the
vhole people of this country ; and yet that
very cause of parliamentary reform was es-
poused by these very men before they were in
place.
Gentlemen, the public prosecutor has said,
that I attempted, ooth in doors and out, to
shake the confidence of the people, with re-
gard to a jury; and he afterwards, with truth
added, that a jury was the brightest privilege
of Englishmen.— So it is, where a jury is
feithfuj to its trust, it is the greatest privilege
Ihe British constitution knows of; because,
geaU^menofthejuiyi when you are honest,
you stuid not between the law and the acb
cused, but between those in power ana the
accused ;— you see the due execution of the
laws; — ^you stand between theaccuser and the
man who is perhaps weaker than the accuser,
either in tongue or in knowledge ; and as he
has thought proper to avail himself of that
superiority and to carry it forth, I will uj^
doubtedly yield to him with regard to talents
and eloquence, but for the soundness of my
doctrine I will not yield to him. — Genllemen,
I never attempted > to prejudice the people
against a jury. I ever will lift up my voice
against any act of iniquity, in impannelling a
jury, — against every act ot iniquity, in trying
to mislead a jury, or in trying to influence a
jury ; even if the man on the bench tries to
influence a jury, I shall stop him, I shall
withhold him, and tell him, it is not his
duty, though he sits there as judge, and I
stand here as a criminal ; it is my nght as a
Briton, to keep him within the bounds of his
duty, to keep him close to the execution of the
laws, if he attempts to depart from them in
any one instance.
With the same spirit of inflation, the public
prosecutor has swelled out the treasonable
matter which he says lies on the table ; and
he is obliged, in the end, to tell you, that if
it appears to you that the British convention
reaUy had no sediUous motives, if they were
only, bona fide, seeking a reform in parlia*
ment, whether it was to be by annual parlia-
ments, or whether it was to be attended wkh
universal sufiiraee, or in whatever way it may
take place, yet tnat convention nlust be inno-
cent. But, says he, you roust concur with me,
that the parole and written evidence are more
than sufiicient to prove him guilty ; and adds
a very curious reasoning :— he says, if you
wait till you have positive proof, it will be too
late; therefore, make haste; avail yourselves
of the presumptive proof that I give you, and
condemn him ; which is to say, sport with
the lives, sport with the liberties or English*
men, for fear of accidents belling you here-
after.— Is that the language of mercy? Is
that the language of the constitution ? — ^Is it
the language of the laws ? — ^He calls his proofs
in the first instance solid and convincing;
although, at last he is obliged to have recourse
to that subterfuge; he says, it amounts to
more than sedition ; and arraigns the igno-
rance of the members of that convention, at
the same time that he arraigns their wicked^*
ness, that they pretend to be ignorant of what
really is sedition ; and yet he does not deien
to inform them. — He says, it is as stricUy
defined as murder, but he does not give you
that definition ; he only says, we are guilty of
sedition. — Now sedition must be some act;
it cannot be a concealed operation of the mind,
it must be an overt act ; and yet he wants you
to judge not of our overt acts, but of our inten*
tions ; which, all . the witnesses have agreed
in saying, were peaceful, orderly, and seem*
ingly k^. I say seemingly; because, as
713]
Jbt S^tUtum.
A. D. ]794.
[714
there is that idea of our appearance being
diflSerent from our real inteDtion, I put the
ivorci seeming into their mouths ; but I pro-
fess to you that our intentions perfectly coin-
cide with our operations. — He acknowledges
the right of the subject to address the king,
or petition the parliament ; and it is well that
he acknowledges it. — The afiront upon your
understandings ; I repeat it, the affront upon
your understandings--would be too gross,
were he not to adcnowledge that freemen
have a right to petition for redress^ when they
think themselves abused.
You are not to judge a curious reasoning ; —
gentlemen, you are not to jud^ upon any
particular fact ; — you are not to judge merely
upon the evidence brought against me ; — you
are not to judge upon those trivial matters
brought forth to-night, which apply entirely
to nSe ; but you are to judge from the contex<
ture of the whole. You are to judge from
gapers that are to criminate Skirving, Brown j
indair, Caliender; and, as I understand
there are a great number more against whom
indictments are makinz out, these papers are
to criminate all ; and &e conteiture is to cri-
minate all. He has wandered far from the
indictment; he asserts of his authority, —
however, it is but just that, while he allows
yuu the talent of prying into the hearts of
men, it is but right, he should retain some
share of the same penetration ; — and therefore
with that sagacity which he claims, he says
that our intentions were positively to ioiu the
invaders of Britain, let them be who they
would ; he does not name them ; and then he
desires ydu,-ih a most pathetic manner, to lav
your hands upon your nearts, and see if such
men ought not to be pronounced trutors to
their countr^r. Undoubtedly men doing so,
would be traitors to their country ; but how
does he prove that that was our intention?
lie brings you forward far more convincing
proof than written evidence; he brines you
forward ▲ blank to prove our guilt! He
acknowledges that no notice has heen taken
of three prior conventions ; and yet it will
appear to you, gentlemen, by those who have
attended these prior conventions, that this
convention acted exactly upon the same plan;
therefore the laws of the land were either
asleep at that time, or they are over-vigilant
at this. He calls us a set of French conven-
tionists. I dp not believe that there were five
men in the convention that can speak French.
i do not believe that there were five men
mho have an adequate idea of France ; and
it does not apoear, from the evidence that
has been brought before you, that any single
member of the convention has any intercourse
.whatever with France ; but yet it is criminal
in lis to adopt certain terms. Those terms,
taken hy themselves, he tells you, are not cri-
cnihal; but take them, at this present crisis,
^together, form a mass of guilt which it really
hulls him to mention, be is so tender. How-
^mer^ to tupfiort this allegallon, he does not
-bring any proof; he gives it merely as an a»^
sertion ; and which is as legal an authority,
as he undoubtedly held those orders which he
gave to Mr. Davidson, the sheriff* substitute ;
and which, by-the-by, he acknowledges. He
reflects upon me as beine, or pretending to be
an Englishman. Dare nc doubt it, or dare
he dispute it ? — ^I have been, I acknowledge
it, obnoxious to his uncle or father, or who*
ever he is, in London, and several other mem-
bers of the administration ; — ^those who profit
by the spoils of the nation ; those who once
were friendly to a reform in parliament, but
now they have got into the enjoyment of the
good things of the treasury, seek no more that
reform. Had I been a foreigner I should
have been long ere now sent abroad under the
Alien act.
Gentlemen, he alleges against me, as an
article of accusation, a motion said to be made
by me ; and he then reverts to the testimony
of Ross and Cockbum, and supports it bv other
charges of certain forms which Mr. CaUender
(who, it seems, has run from his bail in a
most disgracefiil manner) wished to introduce
into the convention. — ^A reform of parliament,
he will not admit — he calls it fbut it remains
for the nation to determine, whether he calb
it rightly or not) a change of the constitution.
A reform undoubtedly would make a change,
but it would not be in the constitution;
though, to be sure, a change from sickness to
healtn, is so far a change m the constitution ;
but it is possible that vou may recover your
pristine health, and make no alteration in your
former constitution ; you only doawavyour
disease ; and that is the way in which a ra-
form is meant to operate. He pleads much
against universal suffrage, and annual. parlia^
mcnts. Indeed annual parliaments he touches
more tenderly upon, and he is right. How-
ever, the same power that made them fxx»ii
annual to triennial, and from triennial to sep^
tennialy'may very likely go on to make them
for life, or even hereditary. But to show that
universal suffrage has taken place, I will give
Jrou a quotation firom a Scotch author. The
ord advocate has said, it could not take place
for the best of all possible reasons (and I
have heard that twice in this court), because,
it is impracticable, A lord, learned in the law,
and whose authority none here will deny, lord
Kaimes, says that, ^' with regard to this mat-^
ter one thing is certain, that the < Regiam
< Majestatem' was compiled in the days of one
of our Davids. The author, whoever he be,
declares that he was commanded by king
David, to compile this work, with the counsS
and advice of his whole realm." There, jgen-
tlemen, you see it was not the advice or re«
presentaiives ; not the advice of individuals ;
but it was the advice of his whole realm.
The same lord Kaimes does not fix a govern-
ment, or a constitution to any one particular
point, fie does not tell you that the consti*
tution of Great Britain^ is the very best that
ever existed from »U eteraity , dfi our learned
71S] 34 GEORGE IIL Proceedings ugaind Makriee Margaroi [71B
lord -does; or that it iriXL «Adtire to ftU etciiiih
Xj; liut he laySy ^ GoTeminent is one of the
arts which necessitT bu eiig^stedy whieh
time and experience have ripened, and which
13 suseepttble of inprovelnetits without end. ,
It must also be the privilegpe of every society
to hnprove upon its government." There you
see^ gentlemen, there yon see people of this
country, that it admits of improvements with-
out end ; and therefore that whiofa is good to-
says, '' It is the privilege of every society to
improve upon its govemnent;'' and what
sig^ifies the privilc^, if we are not to have
the enjoyment of it* I will warrant the learn-
ed kvd^ thsft whatever privileges he enjoys,
io his situation, be would not tnmk them pri*
vileges, if he were debarred from the enjoy-
meat of th^m. Then, why ihoidd a nation
be deprived of that wnich would be a loss to
an individail? Whote interest is it that the
gstemment shoidd be good } Is it the in-
terest of the few, or the interest of the many?
f— Undoubtedly it is the interest of the many.
It it the concera. of the many ; and conse*^
ifasa/lkf the interest of the many. He con-
tuBNscs,-^'' it must also be the privilege of
every societ^r to improve upon its government,
as well as its mamifactures, husbaiKity, or
other art invented for their good." — Here you
see if an improvetnent is admissible in an Art,
it is so in government. ^ No particular form
therefore can be essential^ as no particular
form is preferable to another.'' This is a
Scotch lord who speaks,*-^" unless by having
a greater tendenc^ to promote its end — the
flood of tiie society.'' Therefore, how excel-
but soei^er our constitution ma^ be in its pre«
sent form of three estates, and in the present
most excellent, most immaculate way of elect*
ine members of partiamont; yet, if there is
a better mode of electing members of parlia-
Boent, it is not only our right, but our duty to
do it ; yet meetings for that purpose are deem-
ed seditious, although there is no overt act of
sedition, but merely the construction of the
public accuser : for the doctrine that he has
pleaded is, that before a man is guilty you
shall hang him, that he may not become a
rogue.
Gentlemen, another great PoinC is the com-
]feiittee of secrecy; that galls him sorely. Un-
doubtedly We ought to have told him what we
were about. Wc said we had no secrets, and
immediately afWr appointed a committee of
secrecy. It is true,- and th^re is no inconsist-^
\ eoey m it. We had no secrets to go upon ;
our plan was perfectly conetitutional, artd
must operate for the common giood : but, at
the same time, feeling ourselves under the
arm of power ; feeling ourselves to be mih-
tsting against abuse all powerful, it was pru-
dent m us for the present not to expose our-
selves more than necessary; it wa^ prudent
^<4o setare tb our^elves^a sale phM^ o<* meeting;
Ho has said, it would \m iieMlion^ and an
<»wt*:i;4fttafstoa; A«tatiMt;.ld|>aotMa
how a secret meetinf can b^ vk of erf sst 6f
treason. We should have been aUe to repair
to thi place of meeting Secretly, faecaute we
knew tHtsTf stretch of power would be Inad^
use of agasnst us, and there is more tiian
ruisoa to suspect that the pfeseM war
with France, is not directed solely agaiast
France, but against the cause of reform iA
England. It was meant b^ that war. to divert
the attention of the public from that cause,
day may be better to-morrow. Lord Kahnet > ^ under the pretext bi that imcieot prgudice that
that country was always our natural enemy.
The numerous failures that are daily taking
place ; the numenms losses thlt we have ex-
perienced, botb^ — ^I am sorry to say it^ — biyth
by sea and by bnd, teach us that that wtr it
far from being a pit)fitable one; teach us, that
we are farther off ^ning our end now^ tltta
we were at the begmnrng of that wur ) for wt
are at this di^ less able to treat, or to treat vk
such advanti^eous terms with that nation w^
have io much despised, as w« wer^ at the hth
I ginning of the war. Ruin stares us in the fiu^
m every part of the kiilkjgdom. Every manu^
factoring town is labouring under the pt^AetX
misery* London shows no less than eight
thousand Spitalfields manufacturers' who are
I starving. Norwich, another great tradii^
town (from which I have appeared in th%
convention ate a delegate) is m so dnmal a
situation, that thi^ poor-rates, which were at
first, two years ago 1 think, or it montha
ago, but Ss. 6d. in the pound, nonT amount
to the enormous sum of 17t. 6d.; and,^ \gf
Lady-day next, they wiU be 9Q$. in the poun^
owing to the present war.
Gentlemen, I hope vou will not think h
impertinent iir me to foilow the example thai
has been set me, of reading from a newa^
paper. It is not altogether so pleasing a fact
to me, as that which the vrosecntor statei
from' the Gaaettcer #as to bun. It gate him
satisfaction that it crtminaied me^ — ^it eivtt
me pain that I am obliaed to criminate ttieaa
who arc in office. I wul read to you a letted
from a cler^iiian who visited the SpttalfieMs^
weavers; and made a report of that visit. Ydo
will by thia si^ part ofr the distress in which
they are now plunged, owing to the waT : it ia a
letter addressed to the reverend Mr. T- ■■' ■■■■
£^^8 it from Morning Chronicle as
follows :
To the Rev. Mr. T.
Dear Sir ^-Yon desired me to glv4 you my
optukm of the present state of want and
distress among the weavers in SpitalMdtt.
Being physician- to the Londoh- Dispen^
sary, where between two and 3,000 of
tb^ annually apply for medical relief^
I am called frequently to visit Aeir
wretched habitations, there the fivA
thing that eotemonly pnteents itself tm
view, is an empty loonr, and • Slarfittft
fomify; Seme kve had only half tben
iMiial wovfc foi fmit tkatk tnvehvitaoiite
I
717]
ft^SedkioH.
pii0t; tad many no work at all, for
tba Jbst Hs. months. Sometimea I find
QM or two children sick, and the
wretched parents lookins upon them
with, all the distress vhieh parental
afibctiony and the utmost degree of
poverty, can impress on the mind.
At other times, I find the husband and
wifi^ and not unfreque^tly both, sick in
the same bed, and several helpless and
Iwdf starved children looking up to them
{fv bread. Here anxiety and poverty in-
cieaae tk^ disease if thet did not produce
it, which however is onen the case. It
is impossible for words to ^ve a perfect
ideaof the distress which prevails amongst
Ibis ustlul class of the people. If any
doubt the truth of this representation, all
I can Si^ is> oome and see. Were diey
to aeoompany me in my daily visitations
fof a short time, they would be fiilly con-
irinoed, that this is a very imperfect out-
liiaa of the general misery amongst this
ftast of the labouring poor, who would
gladiv work, if they couki be employed;
and therc^e, the more deserving of help.
I am persuaded^ or, that you need only
to ha acquainted with real distress, to in-
terest yourself in the means of relieving
it in the present instance. Both you,
Wf and those who second your laum>le
endeavoisrs and beaevotont purposes, will
be doing a good work.Tri am, dear sir,
yei» sincere frieady
Old Bedlam,
I)ec. n, 1793.
JqjBN WaiTfiHEikD.]
Qenllemeii, I will also veadyoua paraeraph,
UBOoatmdicted by authociky^ ^m the Morn-
infi Cbionide, of 1st. of Januasy^ 1799. The
amor says, — ^' In on^ short month (Decem-
bcs 17M), an innovation was made on
Iha schma of Bntish society; and, in
qaa evcatftd vear, it Jms changed the
charaftaler o£ the nation, fiom the happy
nmfitioo of a people living together like
•■e large, fiu&il^, undev common laws;
we w^re broke mto sets, and put under
thr uMpuBition of clubs. Jealousy and
disoont succeeded oenAdbnce ^gkl union ;
tha most honourable connexions; the
aaoet imcient fviendships ; the social and
oadBfcing intercourses of neighbourhood;
na^^ the ilea of kindred were rudely^
wantonly torn asundes; and the better
10 seeuce to us the calamities of a foreign
w«L we were involved in the more dread*
fob' Mmoca of iaiernat feud. In the short
moe that wa oan allot to this article, it
fi-inpossibl^ for u» to enter into the pain-
iiil entunemlipB of the events of 1793.
Wiieo the &ithl«il( historian comes to re-
aopd them after passion* and tremor have
aubelded) iiwili be found to be- the most
diiastrou^ to constitutioaal Mberty, to
acicaoe^ to morals, and to. trade, that
ftMhrnd- ever knew, since the establish^
t
A. D, 1794. [718
mcnt of its freedom. What a reverse
from the animating and cheering picture
(^our prosperity and happiness, which a
Hberal correspondent gave to Hoe public,
through the medium of this paper, on
this cuiy twelvemonth. The gjreat events
of the year have covered with distress
the whole face of the island; the secret
history of the period we neither fully can
nor dare develape. It is sufficient to sa^
that acts of p«rsecution, unknown to
Eaehshmen, have been practised witii
applause; integrity and friendship have
been branded as unbecoming an exalted
mind ; and consistency in principles as
unsuitable to the times. Opinion has
been hunted into the retirement of
fiuailies, and he who dared to manifest
his pubhc doctrines, has been assaulted
on the side of his profession in life. The
pulpit, the army, the bar, and the press, '
ail furnish the shocking evidence, that
Spanish and Italian arts may flourish on
an English soil.''
What is that but 8a}^nv, that our constitu-
tion is greatly impaired within these twelve-
months ? If we do not ]oQk to it, we shall
have nothins but an Italian or a Spanish eon*
stitution left to us F How therefore are wo
to restore that constitution, but by a timely
reform? and how are we to obtain that re«
form, but by pursuing it with vigour? and
how are we to pursue it, if we are not to meet,
and if an English jury will permit a public
prosecutor (and believe every word he sajrs)^
to throw an odium upon them ; and say, that
though their meaning may be aood now, it
may m future be bad ; and therefore you miisl
condemn them as seditious. As a farther
prooi^ however, of the constitutionality of
these meetings, and the right we have to
revert to our original conMitutioii> and to d^
away the existing defects of that which is
termed the present constitution ; and whkh
in fact is nothing but errors engraft on our
constitution, I will read to you a letter feom
ford Bathurst to Dean Swifl ; although m hk
time the House of Commons was corrupt^
since that time no great effort has been made
to amend it; and we- all know that humai^
institutions, however good thev may be in
j their ferst setting out, go naturallv to d<K»y,
unless repaired. It has moreover been assert-
ed, that one of the glories of our constitu^oa
is, that it is of such a nature, that it ^11 admit
of repsurs, without being thrown out of order,
and will always be advantaged by it; an4
that repair must come from the people; but
hear what lord Bathurst says: *^ lam con-
vince<l that our constitution is already gone;''
luckily for us the public prosecutor lias found
it agamto-nightv ** and we are idly strugeiia^
to maintain whsA in tnil^ has been longlost ;
like someold fools hfire> with ^ut and palsies,
at fourscore years old- drinking the waters,''
he- was then at BaVh, *^ in hopes of hadth
again. If ttus* was not our case^ and that the
719] S4 6EORG£ IIL Proceedingfagainxt Maurice Margarat [790
eople are already io effisct slaves, ivouU it
ve been possible for the same minister, who
had projected Uie excise scheme (before the
heals it had occasioned in the nation were
well laid) tu have chosen a new parliament
again exactly to his mind ? and though per-
haps not altogether so strong in numl^rs, yet
as well disposed in general to his purposes as
he could wish ? Hb master, I doubt, is not
90 well beloved as I could wish he was :'' —
You see that even in the time of lord Bathurst
there were no greater enemies to the kin^
^an bad servants ; for none alienate the af-
fections of a people from a kins, so much as
bad servants of the crown. — **• His master, I
doubt, b not so well beloved as I could wish
he was : the minister, I am sure, is as much
hated and detested as ever man was ;'' — whe-
ther that applies to the present time or not, I
leave the people of England and Scotland to dis-
cover, '^ and yet I say a new parliament was
chosen of the stamp that was desired, after hav-
ing failed in the most odious scheme that ever
was projected. Afler this, what hopes can
there ever possibly be of success ? Unless it
be from confusion, which God forbid I should
live to see. In short, the whole nation is so
abandoned and corrupt, that the crown can
never fail of a majority in both houses of par-
liament. He makes them all in one house,
and he chooses above half in the other, four
^nd twenty bishops'* very upright men ^ and
sixteen Scotch lords is a terrible weight in
one; forty-five from one country, besioes the
West of England, and all the government
boroughs is a dreadfiil number in the other.
"Were his nuyesty inclined to-morrow to de-
clare his body coachman hb first minister^ it
would do just as well, and the wheeb of go-
vernment would move as easily as they do
^ith the sagacious driver, who now sits on
ibe box. Parts and abilities are not in the
least wanting to conduct affairs : the coach-
man knows how to feed his cattle, and the
other feeds the beasts in his service ; and this
is all the skill that is necessary in either case.
Are^ot these sufficient difficulties and dis-
couraeements, if there were no others, and
would anv man stru^le against corruption,
when he Knows that iThe is ever near defeat-
ing it, those who make use of it only double
the dose,' and carry all their points further,
and with a higher hand than perhaps they at
first intended?'' Therefore the poor reformer
generally comes off the worst; as perhaps
will be the case with those who are now at
your bar. Gentlemen, since the davs of lord
Bathurst, the dborders of the state have gone
on increasing, and we are now loaded with
such an immense debt, that it is incompre-
hensible how the nation supports itself under
it : and there are now forty millions more to
aad to it, for the sake of preventing a reform
in parliament. A foreign war was entered
Rito with that view, white the crown lawyers
have been highly busy at home : words have
been raked upof as iisur date back as a tvfelve-
mointh ; spies set in private fkmiHeB; servants
interrogated ; the man has been set against
his master, and the child against his parent.
Every art has been used to bring forth crimi-
nal proseaitions, in order that reform may be
discouraged in every shape ; and that those,
who hadbeen the foremost in attempting any
thin^ like refonn, should be stigmatized as
seditious, — treasonable, — as ringleaders ; «—
these words you have vociferated again and
again, till they must have tired your patience.
Gentlemen, here is a statement or the na-
tional debt, which perfectly applies to the
case in point. The national debt beeair'with
our happy revolution, which we are all bound
to prabe ; and would to God the constitution
was as sound now as it was then. The na»
tional debt was a scheme devised by William
and Mary, to secure their footing in England.
At first it amounted, I believe, to seven mil-
lions ; but during that reign it increased to
sixteen millions, and the wars of queen Anne
increased it to fifty-four millions — the amount
of the debt at the end of the war of 1748, was
78,250,000/. ; the amount of the debt at the
commencement of the war 1755, was 75 mil-
lions; af^er that there was a diminution took
pjace of about four millions, which were paid
off. At the end of lord Chatham's war, the
national debt amounted to 146 millions; it
diminished by the peace to 136 millions, so
that a peace, which lasted till 1775 diminish-
ed it .ten millions ; and in the war from 1775
to 1783,— the infiimpus American war,— >
where you will recollect the Americans were
first treated as rebels, exactly in the same
manner that the French are now treated:
they were deemed rebels ; they were deemed
a set of villains; they were deemed the wont
creatures upon the fiice.of the earth; and
whenever tney were spoken of, it was one
Hancock, one Adams, one thb, one that, and
one the other, till we found, at the end of ten
years war and expense of 134 nullions, be-
sides 100,000 lives lost in the war, we were
obliged to give up the war, and accept of an
aml^sador from them.: and, at the time of
Mr. Pitt's accession to the treasury-bench it
amounted to 270 millions. At this oresent
day it is upwards of 300 millions ; ana, if we
go on thus year af\er year, we shall soon
make it 400 millions. But the remariis in
this paper are more apposite to the point :
<< So immense a dent as 270 millions, bear-
ins an interest of about nine millions end &
half, was an alarming circumstance to the
public, after the loss of half the Britbh do^
minions abroad ; and something must begone
to divert the attention of the people from any-
serious inauiry into the corruptions and abuses
which had involved the nation in such luin.
<< Mr. Fox was for probing this ufeefated
wound to the bottom, and meeting our situa-
tion in an open, manly manner, but the secret
junto in the cabinet;" and that junto, gentle-
men of the jury, I will tell you originated in
Scotland. I know not at present^ whether it
7«1]
Jot SedkioH.
A. D. 1T94.
[782
continues ito root there or not; I atn much
ioclined to think it does ; but the secret junto
** foresaw, that such a measure would lead to
impeachments, refunding and confiscation of
property. He was therefore turned out of
office, and Mr. Pitt seduced from his friends
and party, to become the tool of those who
began to be alarmed for fear an investieation
should take place." Here then Mr. Pitt is
only the ostensible minister, while in fact he
is filled by a secret juncto. ^ A bubble was
invented to amuse the people, and stop the
mouths of the monied men, the weakest that
ever was formed, and the most ruinous and
wicked one that ever succeeded. The under-
atrappers in office,'' in England, gentlemen,
we nave imderstrappers in office as well as in
Scotland ** and treasury runners, were inces-
santly employed in blacking Mr. Fox, and cir-
culating in every companv, that Mr. Pitt was
to pay off the national oebt. The measures
he adopted for that purpose were cried up as
a master-piece of wisdom; and this was acain
rung in the ears of the credulous peopte in
everv comer of the kingdom, by the prosti-
tuted prints in the minister's pay. By such
means, this extraordinary bubble was blown
up to an enormous size, and the troubles in
Holland and France, as long as we kept in
peace with the last mentioned nation, were
favourable to these measqres. The prodigious
demand for our manufactures, the increase of
trade — --"
I was in France, gentlemen, between three
and four years ago upon a mercantile expedi-
tion. I had an opportunity of viewins aU the
mat warehouses m France, from the nor-
tnemmost extremity, to that very southern-
most noint of Toulon, which we have lately
abandoned ; and I will tell you, that in one
small town, not so large as Leith, there was
at that time English ^ods bespoke, and in a
great measure paid for, to the amount of three
millions sterling ; that kept our manufactures
afloat; that gave prosperity to the nation;
and that was m consequence of the commer-
cial treaty which was entered into between
the two countries about five years back, and
in which I am not ashamed to sa;^ that I lent
mjr humble assistance, not officially to the
nunister here, but unofficially to the minister
in France; because I knew the commercial
* connexion of two nations was the way to en-
rich both, and because I knew that to do away
that idea- that they were natural enemies,
and should go to war upon every trivial occa-
sion, was the only way to keep us in peace,
and prevent the shedding of blood, wnich I
/am always sorry for in any case whatever ; I
wish I could say so of our governors; — '^ the
influx of money from France, Holland, and
the convulsed parts of Europe, gave ministers
an opportunity of levying enormous new
taxes, even in time of peace," while we
were pretending to pay oft the national debt,
every year brought us new taxes; why ? Be-
cause a majority in the House pf Commdns
VOL. XXIII.
was to be secured. ^' Mr. Pitt took every ad-
vantage that all those favourable opportunities
save him, and loaded the ' people with such
neavy, partial,- and grievous taxes, as no mi-
nister ever before attempted, even in times of
war." I doubt not, people of Scotland, but
you labour under grievous taxes, as well as
we in England ; .there is one I will give you
an idea of, the salt tax, which ffies in the face
of common sense ; but it is kept up for a rea-
son whkh I will tell you by-and-by ; the col-
lection annually amounts from 19 to 30,000/.
but the expense of collecting it amounts to
30,000/. People who are unthinking nay
say. why does not the minister sell it when
he loses so much by it; it gives the ministry
at the trifling expense of 1 1,000/. per annum,
it gives them a patronage of 30,000/. " Mr.
Pitt's shop tax, fustian tax, his tax on the
poor servant maids, the extension of excise-
laws, his commutation tax, and others equally
obnoxious, are witnesses of the truth of what
I now advance; with all his low cunning,
artifice, exertions, spies, and informers."
Gentlemen, the convention is reproached
with adopting French words, and French
manners. It is now about six years ago that
the commercial treaty was, I must not say on
the tapis, but was pending in the case I men-
tioned before, in which my humble efforts
were used ; I had access to some of the de»
pendents of the French ministry, and I there
found that in PitVs calunet there was a sys-
tem of police ; — I made use of that word^
which is adopted in Ireland, in a great mea*-
sure in Lonaon, and verv likely will be soon
introduced into Scotland, if not already — the
French police ; Pitt applied to Bretagne, and
from them obtained every article of the French
police, spies, and informers, and every thine
except tne Bastile; they had but one, and
they could not spare that one : however, we
have made shifl without it, havinz converted
Newgate, and the Counter, and other prisons
to that purpose, until a proper one snail be
built; there is one building in the neighbour- '
hood of London, and I think I have seen
something like one building in the neigh-
bourhood of Edinburgh; he has imported
spies and informers, who have exerted them-
selves, and every one of them has been well
paid for it; spies and . informers^ — French
things as well as French words. And I be-
lieve tlie nation, at that time, though much
degenerated, I have reason to believe, that
at the first outset of spies and informers, the
police of England were at a loss to fiud
Englishmen willing to undertake those odi-
ous tasks : sorry I am to say, that that re-
pugnance is now nearly done away, that there
IS not a public company without a spy in it^
and even the servants of the crown glory in
their haxiog spies; some are more diligent
than others; I saw one here to-night, who,
though he keeps six spies daily, it is no un-
common thing tor them to re&;ret, at the end
of the week, that they have brought' him no
3 A
7SS] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings againtt Maurice Margaroi [7M
' intelHgence ; backed with the most extennre
commfcrce ever known, our msnufectures and
internal trade, poshed by industry, private
credit, and paper currency, to a pitch never
before heard of; and, in short, the whole
credit of the merchants, traders, and manu-
facturers, exerted to the utmost, to keep every
hand usefully employed, was not sufficient to
raise taxes to pay the interest of so immense
a sum as 270 millions of national debt, de-
fray the expenses of government, which, to-
gether with the interest, amounted to the
enonnous sum of about 17 raittons in time of
peace, without reckoning the millions to be
annually provided to support this bubble; all
this, notwithstanding tne flouri^ing state
which peace and the unexampled industry of
the people to revive our trade and commerce,
could not be annually drawn from their la-
bours, nor raised by any of the oppressive
means adopted, without arrowing new loans;
on one hand, as stock was purchased with
the public money, on the other, tha^is to
say, m paying the national dd>t, you took
the money out of one pocket and paid it in-
to the other ; but while you did that, some
of it always fell to the ground, which you
never will see again; that money is employed
in keeping up the price of stocks; some
thousands go weekly that way ; a reform in
parliament would do away that abuse. '' The
Bank, that sacred, public, and private repo-
sitory for wealth, was squeesed out of half a
million. This drew on them creditors for
the unclaimed dividends to a much larger
amount, and other means, eaually unjust,
were pursued to supply the denciency. But
all this would not do; the bubble must
sooner or later burst, and with a dreadful ex-
plosion, unless speedily prevented by a more
skilful financier than Mr. Pitt.'' This bubble
does not only threaten this empire with the
most terrible convulsions, but to spread mis-
chief mto other countries. We have been told,
that the Bank of Amsterdam, is intimately
connected with our own; if that fails, -ours
will, and that was given as the reason for our
going to war; and very likely our going to
war wll be a reason for our bank fainne : " it
is formed on such ruinous principles, that it
is im}H>ssible all the energy and industry of m
brave, hardy, and loyal people, when strained
to the utmost pitch* can sup|«ort it ; it was
setting the public to roll a heavy stone up a
steep mountain, which grows steeper and
steeper as the summit is approached. To
attempt to pay off the national debtby pur-
chasing stock, is one of the most barefaced
robberies.'^ — ^Here is language ! this in Edin-
burgh would be sedition ; it would go near to
be treason — ^^ the attempt to pay off tftie na-
tional debt by purchasins up stock, is one of
the most barefaced rolmenes committed on
the people, that ever was attempted in any
civilized nation.*' — ^Here you see Mr. Pitt is
called a robber, and the most barefeeed and
impudent Tobber thai ever was, ^ loading the
people withunbearable ta3(te, to eiiridi wbon ?
the stockholders, the monied-meny and gam-
blers, hi the Alley; these were suie to assist
the ministerial nianers in blownjg up tiib
bubble, which brought so much grist to ttieir
mill; by their unitra arts and unwearied ef-
fofts^ they actually raised the price of stock
to such a pitch, as to make tne public pay
more than 50f. alerting more than tlie in-
trinsic value, upon every 100/.^ And as
long as the industry of the people ooidd bear
such bui^iens as were heaped vpen then,
there is every reason to believe tney would
rise hifther and faisher; so tiiat the tttort
the public purchased, the more they woukl
have to pay for the rettuader, proviahig this
bubble was suffered to oontiBue. Mr. Pftt.
instead of paying off any part of the national
debt, in time of peaoe, by nis plan, has added
many millions ; and if we are to go on in this
ruinous plan, the increased price of the sloek
will load us with more than 150 raUHons
more than was ever owed or prstended to
have been borrowed.
There, gentlemen, in consequence of this
system, the nation will find itself debtor 150
millions more than ever was pretended had
been lent to it; an immense sum of itself,
but which the nation would have been bare-
facedly robbed of— 150 million sterling which
we never borrowed. ** It will easily be seen,
by examining the History of the Reveme, or
tills brief statement, that every war which
this country has been engaged in has nearly
doubled the former debt and taxes, let them
amount to what they might ; and yet the na-
tion has been phineed into a war, with this
heavy millstone of 1170 millions about lis
neck. The effects of this rash measure* has
been suddenly and severely felt; almost a
total staftnation in trade and commerce, the
revenue <)ecieasing in the most alarming
manner, all private credit destroyed:" the
neigbbcmrhood of Edinburgh will witness
that: look at Paisley, look at Glasgow, and
tbeir banks even, which will all oonvinee
you that there is truth in this assertion ; ^ no
one dare trust his neighbour, baiJcnpteies
innumerable, the industrious poor Ihrown
out of employment."— Do vre not see that
even in Eoinbui^, the poor are ready maA
willing to work if they couki get it? Are
tfaey not the same at Fwsley ? are tbejr not
the same at Glasgow f I have •I'^y in-
stanced to von in England, Norwich,Sheaekl,
and Manchester, where the poor aie out of
number; but here is an addition, *^ pravisioM,
and even fasy, sent out of the kingdom, lo
supply the Geman armies," not ti^ Mppty
our own troops, but forsooth, we nmft take
other troops into pay, whiks our poor ore
starving at heme in consequence of it, ^wiiieb
keeps up the price of meat to a hei^ ne^er
remembered at this seasan of the year; coala,
candles, soap, sugar, and many odwr artleies
in-comnon use, are talsed or iMptup , hi^wn-
se^nence of the war." Hereis an artiUe to
70]
Jar SidUkn.
A- D. ITMu
[726
wlucb I would tum youor ftttettkioBy tke article
of eoak^ the cily of London yearly consumes
about 400,000 chaUroD of C^Ua; every chal-
dioo of ooals pays one sbilUngy to whom ? To
a man who did not think proper, when cited
by the tows of his country, to appear before
you; and pays it to him, wbry? Because he
IS the descendant of a natural son of Charles
IL If he had been a poor man, and it had
been necessary to keep up an appearance of
respectability in h&s station, there would
have hwsk some excuse; but he has another
sinecure which amounts to more than he
spends; this is one of the abuses of a corrupt
parliament. — Our monev shipped off to pay
the troopsy and siiq^pl^r the be|u»rly German
princes oa the continent. The parochial
taxes prodigiously increased, by the nume-
rous poor thrown out of employment, or
borne down by the heavy load of taxes Mr.
Pitt has thrown upon them ; and threatened,
notwithstanding all that is said to the con-
trary, witli the ruin of another American war.
In such a state, is it possible to expect that
the public can bear to double the jpresent
national debt and taxes, without burstmg Mr.
PitVs bubble, formed for plundering the poor
to add to the rich. This man speaks very
plain English, and I am sorrv to say, he
speaks as truly, as he does plainly; \\ has
been a decided plan with those in power, to
plunder the poor to gplve to the rich ; and will
oonliwie so^ while useless places, while use-
less pennons, are suffered to exist, while a
lord justice general of Scotland, who never
attends in his place, though justice is the most
sacred duty a man can acquit himself of; the
duty of a judge is the most sacred duty that
a man can undertake, since it is the repre-
sentative of God himself; that he should
accept 9,000/. a year, and never attend in bis
placet to xlistribuie that justice for which he
IS so amply paid ; this is another proof of si-
necure places, and a proof that we want a
reform in parliament; you have now been a
hundred years, except one instance, without
the appearance of a lord justice general;
^OOfiOQl, therefore has been carried out of
Scotland and spent in England; therefore
ym annually lose S,000/. for which you de-
rive no advantage whatever. '< The crisis
draws near, when every inferior considera-
tion must give way for public good, and Mr.
Fox's .open a^d manly aoilities must be called
forth, to form an honest, just, permanent,
and upright ministry, to save the king and
people from one common ruin.''
I did not read this to you, gentlemen, with
a view to trumpet up Mr. Eox^ no man can
have a gpreater respect for his abilities than
I have, but X am far firom thinkine that no
man in the kingdom can save us but he; I
would not make any man a Crod ; let us not
trust them; let us not give them implicit
£uth ; let us trust to none of our rulers ; let
us trust cmly to our laws ; and while we give
ioi^it foiU) to them^ and see that our rulers
act according te those law*, we shall be
happy: the moment we do otherwise, we
shall be slaves. '< Apostates have raise(}r
false alarD>s of treason, sedition, rebellion,'
and every thing that can rouse up a generous
people, to revenge the insults and injuries
heaped upon them ; but the people are loyal,
love their kins, respect mild laws, and bear
an utter hatrM to all who attempt to impose
upon them, by apostacy, fraud, or treachery,
and are sworn enemies to all sorts of perse-
cutions." Would not you think that Uie
writer of this letter had some of the perse-
cutions which have lately taken place, m his
eye? You will see then, gentlemen^ that
it is not merely in Scotland alone ; that the
people in Scotland are not the only people
who see their true interests; that the people
of England, likewise, begin to discern that
they are imposed upon, that those who are
in office deceive them : open your eyes, there*
fore^ gentlemen, and be not deceived; let^
not the words of office, let not the high
sounding language of a crown lawyer trenan
you into a perjury, for if you suffer yourselves
to be deceived, thou^ not a wilful perjury,
it still remains a perjury, unless you give »
verdict according to the dictates of your con-
science; and the dictates of that conscience
cannot Uk% pkioe, till you have made a fair,
and candid examination of the ^[latter before
you.
His postscript says, '^ two hundred and
seventy millions b a sum the human mind
can hu-dly form any idea of: to give some
assistance in forming a notion of it, were it
to be laid down in smneas in a line, it would
extend upwards of 4,300 miles: if in shil-
lings, it would extend three and an half times
round the ^lobe ; aiid if paid in solid silver,
would require more than 60,000 horses to
draw it, at the cate of 1,500 weight to a
horse;" and yet the good people of this
country are, by their labours, to pay off the
interest of this debt, and are with the as*
sistance of Pitt's calculations, to pay off the
capital also. The number of inhabitants of
Great Britain has been mistated, as well as
many other thmgs, by the public prosecutor;
he has stated them to be iO millions; they
perhaps, do not go much beyond 7 millions;
out we will say 8 millions, and among them,
you cannot say there are more than 9 mil-*
lions of men; and, therefore 2 millions of
people are to pay titie interest of this debt^
which, if laid out in guineas, in a line, would
extend upwards of 4,300 miles. Good God!
when shall we get to the end of such a jour-
ney ; and yet We are daily increasing it by a
war; and, what is the consequence of that
war? not only expenses abroad, but it in*
creases salaries and pensions: we bought
Toulon with gold ; we left it for nothing : it
is true, we adopted again the French mea«
sures; we named commissioners : one com*
misaioner set out, with a service of plate, to
do honour to thA name of. an Englishman^
7S7] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings agauut Maurice Margarot [788
which cost 6,000/. and yet there are 8,000
Spitalfields weavers in a state of actual star-
vation ; and yet, to one man, is presented a
seiviceof plate, ofthatimmense value, pre-
vious to his going as commissioner to Tou-
lon ; he comes back aeain, and is now out
of office, but has retired upon half-pay: this
is "the wav the public money is squandered;
this is the way the public money will be
squandered till we obtain a reform in par-
liament. Therefore, no man, not the public
prosecutor himself, can 4ove the constitution
setter than I do ; but no man can detest the
abuses that are engrafted on that constitutien
more than I do; for I have seen so much
misery, m the course of ray .tours trough
Great Britain, which is Uie garden of Europe,
where there is not a man who would exert
his industij, but might earn a comfortable
livelihood if our constitution was returned
to that point at wbich it was settled at the
revolution; but it is all done away; I wUl
five you proof that it is done away; and I
ave taken care to give you that proof, or,
at least, that eadi of you may be (bmished
with a copy of it when you retire to debate
upon the matter that is brought before you :
it is in a speech of Mr. Wharton's, in the
House of Commons: I will read it to you;
and I |un sorry, that the public prosecutor
has retired; I would have attacked him per-
sonally; he was a member of the senate;
and, I believe, he was there at the time he
bore, he suffered this worthy man, — an ho-
nest member in the present British House
4>f Commons, — ^he suffered him to assert, that
•every jpart of our constitution was done away;
he did not rise to contradict him; though
here vociferous to the utmost, there he was
€ilent; I am seditious in seeking a reform,
but, when a man tells them, every iota of
the constitution is done away, the whole he
could do was, to vote silently against him ;
and the motion was lost, because trie majority
did not think proper to stake their future
fortune, reputation, or property, upon the
rcvisal of the constitution. May a friend be
permitted to read it for me ?
lard Juaice CZerA.^No, you must read it
jourself.
Mr.' Afargarof.— Gentlemen, you are en-
irusted now by your country, to give a ver-
dict, to examine seriously the cause that is
now before you. I have already told you,
1 am a willing and a devoted victim; I will
give you a proof of it; *nd you shall have
that proof home with you, in a letter, that I
wrote to Dundas, a twelvemonth ago, when
fTosccutions were hanging over the heads
of the people: I offered myself for prosecu-
tion ; I desired him to spare them, and let
his vengeance fall upontne: I escaped it in
London; I hope I shaU not find it in Scot-
land ; I hope the honesty of any jury will
rrevent its having the effect it was meant to
have. This is the speech of Mr. Wharton,
in tlic House, of Commons. HFTWtlu^n
rose to make his proposed motion. **We
heard,*' he said, " on every side, of the glo-
rious revolution, in 1688, and of the consti-
tution, as settled at the glorious revolution;
it was a note which he had always Ibteited
to with pleasure, and he repeated it himself
with rapture. But, what was the rational
foundation of our satisfaction, at the recol-
lection of the glorious revolution? It a^
suredly was not that the possession of the
throne, and the regular hereditary succession
to it, were, at that tikne, disturbed and in-
terrupted. It was not that we expelled one
king, and one feunily, and appointed another
king, and another fiBunily, in their room. The
necessi^ of such changes was, at all times,
to be deplored; and« the eventa themselves
could only be justifiea by the necessity. The
only rational foundation of our approbation
of that revolution must4>e, that at that time
such principles were confirmed, and such wise
and wholesome provisions made for our con-
stitutional security and happiness, as might
prevent all future necessity for a similar re-
volution. Whoever approved of that revo-
lution, declared, at the same time, that the
constitutional provisions then obtained, were
wise and wholesome provisions; that they
were worthy objects of a national struggle;
that they not only justified resistanceTlmt
made it meritorious ;" And yet, this is one of
the articles of crimination against me.
Gentlemen, it is said that the convention
meant to assert their rights : now^ assertion
may be made in various ways; it may be
made, vi et armii ; it may be made by ar-
gument; by reason; and, there is no direct
proof, that we meant to assert them by force
of arms; and, from the paucity, it is most
likely we should do it by argument. He saya^
'< they not only justified resistance, but maide
it meritorious; and, that they were cheaply
purchased, at the price of all the blood that
was shed upon the occasion, as well as the
detiironement of a guilty king, and the ex-
tirpation of his guiltless fietmily. But an ap-
frobation of that revolution went still farther.
t declared, that if, by any means, b^ force,
or by fraud, by violence, or by corruption." —
Jurymen, I request your utmost attention to
this; it is of the greatest conseouence. ** But
an approbation of that revolution [1688],
went still farther. It declared, that if, by
lany means, — ^by force, or by fraud, by vio-
lence, or by corruption, — if these wholesome
and necessary constitutional provisions should,
by any means, be taken away, or fnistrated,
the same objects would again justify the
same national struggle, and the same extre-
mities, unless they could be recovered, and
re-obtained by more gentle, more peacefiily
I and therefore, more happy means.'' We at
vpresent feel, that force or fraud, violence and
corruption, have taken away many of our
Iprivil^es : we wish to regain them ; not hy
force, but by tho^ more peaceful, and there-
fore, more happy means, which is a peaice-
789]
Jiff SedUitm.
A. D. 1794.
[780
able and latkNnl application to the kioSi or
to the parUamenty by an assertion of our
rifi^itSy made in such a respectful manner,
tiiat th^ shall not be refused; for, it is idle
to talk of the omnipotence of parliament;
the servant can nerer be greater than its
master; the three estates together, are not
equal in value to the whole nation: without
them, the nation could be a nation; but,
without the nation, they would become poor
individuals. ** He asserted [and said he risked
nothing by the assertion, for no man would
be hardy enough to deny it, and he pledged
himself to prove it in a committee of the
bouse], that all that was valuable to the peo-
ple of^this country, all the provisions which
were stipulated to secure the peace and pros-
perity, the individual liberty, and the eeneral
property of the people of this land, had all
Deen, smce the revolution, taken away — All !''
He asserts, in the House of Commons, and
pledees himself to prove, that all the security
of the subject, all the privileges of the sm-
ject, in the constitution, which is trumpeted
by venal hirelings, has been taken away;
and he pledges himself to prove all this; and,
to this, not a single man rises to give an
answer. '* He must entreat the attention of
the House, for a few moments, whilst he
very briefly brought back to their recollection,
what this coun^ established by the revo-
lution. Furst, to avoid all future mistakes,
and, that the contract between prince and
)ieople might be clearly understood, the re-
▼olutionistS' began by altering the oaths of
the contracting parties/' Here again I will
interrupt myself, to show you that the king
holds his crown, not bv a divine right, but
by a contract between him and the people,
which implies a mutual binding ; and, should
either of the contracting parties fail, it will
become void: men in business, you must
know it ; and, from business to politics, is a
very easy transition; the principle is the
same. << They altered the coronation oath
for all future sovereigns in this realm; and
they altered the oath of allegiance for them-
selves, and for all future subjects. They cut
np, by the roots, the damnable doctrine of
passive obedience and non-resistance:*' doc-
trines sedulously endeavoured to be inculcated
into you to night; that non-resistance and
passive obedience, tlioUgh couched in other
words, were the duty of the subject. I say
it is no such thin^; and here is an honest
maii declaring this m parliament, and nobody
daring to confute him. He says, '^ they cut
up, by the roots, the damnable doctrine of
]Nissive obedience, non-resistance, by empha-
tically specifying and ordaining the following
words of tbleir former oath, l William and
Mary, ch. 8. - 1 declare, that it is not law-
ful, upon any pretence whatever, to take up
arms against the king, &c. &c. should not,
horn thenceforth, be reipiired or enjoined.'*
Therefore, you see, gentlemen, that it is no
longer required of the subject to take an aath>
that he will not, in any circumstance what-'
ever, take up arms agiunst the king; because,
as this king comes to the throne, not by di«
vine right, but by a contract between the
king and the people, it was thought, if he
neglected hb contract on the one part, the
people were not bound by that contract on
the other; and, he hereby establishes Ahe
doctrine of resistance to oppression : in fact,
self-preservation is the first law of nature
with an individual; and, what is the case
with an individual, is much more so with a
socie^. " It was not so much to relieve the
conscience of the subjects, that these words
of their former oath were selected, recited,
and abolished ; for no oath of slavery ever
did, or ever will, or ever ought to bind a na-
tion, or an individual; it was something
worse than perjury, or sacrilege, to keep an
oath of slavery/' Here is the true spirit of
freedom, breathing in these words: it was
something worse uian perjury, or sacrilege,
to keep an oath of slavery. No; man was
not bom to slavery. ** This alteration was
made to prevent the future sovereigns of this
country from being misled, as the four pre-
ceding sovereigns had been, to trust to a
senseless superstition about royalty, which
though many persons for their interests have
professed, no man of common sense ever en-
tertained." Many of these doctrines are pro-
fessed at this day: men profess doctrines
very different from what tneir hearts feel ;
but while blinding the eyes of the public,
they are the most conscientious men living.
'' Their next care was, to provide for the due
administration of the executive power, and
the responsibility of its confidential advisers.
They therefore enacted, 18th William 3d
chap, d, that all matters and things relating
to the well-soveming of this kingdom which
are cognizable in the privy-council, by the
laws and customs of this realm, shall be
transacted there; and all resolutions taken
thereupon shadl be signed by such of the
privy^ouncil as shall &vise and consent to
the same." Here you see, gentlemen, that
the government of a large country, like Great
Britain, is of so public a nature as not to
admit of secrets; it is of such a nature that
a responsibility must be affixed somewhere ;
and therefore those persons who adopted
measures in the privy-council were to sien
the same, in order that the public misht
know where the blame or the praise lay ; this
has been done away, and you have heard to-
night, when a question was put relative to
orders, those orders were deemed proper to
be kept a secret ; thus we imitate the prac-
tices of those in higher stations; and infe-
riors will naturally catch at the defects sooner
than at the beauties of their masters beha-
viour. ''Thereby guarding, as far as laws
could guard, agamst that accursed ennne of
despotism, a cabinet council," — Which the
paper I just now read, calls a secret junto, —
^ or that more accursed instrument^ an in-
7Si> 'S'l-eEORGE m. Proceedings agaimt Mtturifie Margara [789
tenor cabiiMty^ from wbkh we have aol
be«f& free for ^ years.
** Their atte&Uon wu next directed to the
docile repreflentatioD of the people^ the only
pos^ble secuiky for all their other jprovisions"
•—There is uBWwbtedlv no provision, no se-
curity, for the liberty, for the property of the
sulnect, if he is not properly represented in
CiruAment: we are teo numerous to make
ws for ourselves ; we must therefore be re-
presented ; we must send delegates or com-
missioners to a parliament, where a convani*
ent number of them may meet and transact
the business of the nation; if that business
is not done foithfuUy ; if the men sent to do
that business are liable to be bought and sold,
we shall in our turns pay both purchaser and
purchased — ^* The House of Commons and
juries/' This is the double representation in
£ngland; we were the only nation who en-
joyed it. A neighbouring nation, thoueh
much run down, have lately arrived at the
possession of it. Juries consist of IS or
15 men, according to the country in vfbkh
they act They are not to stand in fear
of the judge, or in fear of the king ; for,
if they act according to their conscience, no
judge dare say any thing to an honest jury ;
thev have a double duty; the first to God,
and the next to theii country ; but th^
both of them form a moral duty, and an
one and the same thing. Jurymen are
absolute; they have a nght to ask ques-
tions ; they have a right where the least
doubt hangs over the mind, to inquire of the
panel; they have a right to inquire of the
counsel, and they have a right to call forUi
all the wisdom of the judges; while in ofike,
they possess the most unlimited power that
we know of in England. He says our ances-
tors *^ passed over untouched, and left as they
found them the nobility and thediurch; they
were considering the solid and substantial
parts of the constitutional edifice, and did not
much concern themselves about the gilding
and the varnish. They therefore proceeded
to establish the principle^ (^ a fair and free
and frequent election of the representatives
of the commons in parliament, as might be
seen by a reference to the acU passed m the
first and second and third years of William
and Mary.'' You see here, a term which at
first appears to be a kind of sneer or joke,
but it is founded in truth, and leads you to a
much deeper reflection. He says, ** our an-
cestors dKl not much concern themselves
about the gilding and the varnish," meaning
the nobility and the church ; and it is not
merely a jeer or a playing upon words, but
arises from the principle already laid down,
that the nation, and the natbu alone, is the
principal part: it is the people that are of
consequence, and nothing but the people.
^* And having thus, as they imagined, pro-
vided for the real election of the representa-
tive body in parliament, they secured the in-
dependence and integrity of that body af\er
ita election^ 1^ umtftinp that a» penan wba
has an office oc placa ofpcofit under the king^
or receives a pension from the crown, shaU be .
capable of serviiM as a member of the House
of Commons.'^ Now> if this took place with
regard to the aatioBal aMembl}[> where laws
are only made; undoubtedly a similar restric-
tion was understood to be in full ibrce ip that,
assembly, where tHae laws are carried into ea*
ecution, I mean injuries; fiw if men eiyoy*
ing places of profit under the crown are
deemed incapable of making laws, they should,,
by a much stronger reawn, be deemed inca*
pable of carrying them into execution, eq»e-
cially when there is no appeal from their
verdict ; or at least, an appeal, attended with
such difficulties and such expense, as to put
it out of the power of nine-tenths of those
who are tried to make use of the remedy.
** Having thus secured the purity and inde-
pendence of the people's representatives in
parliament, they proceeded to the other im*
portant branch of^their representation by Jurv,.
and they decreed, that juries should be fairly
taken without partiality, and should act freely
without infhience." Observe that, gentlemen;
I do not impute it to the case of to-day, but
when I say it is possible to pack a jury, i can
show my authority, when it has been asserts
ed in the House of Comraooa and haa not
been denied. ^ They also decreed, that ex*
cessive bail should not be required, that ex-
cessive fines should not be imposed, and that
illegal and cruel punishments should not be
inflicted; and to secure these objects, they
ordained that thenceforward the judg^' com*
missions should be made ' quamdiu ae ben^
' gesserint ;' and that their salaries should be
ascertained and established, in order to make
the judges independent of the crowik'* The
duty of a judge is, not to influence yoi^ not
to say any thing that has the least tendency
to influence you ; he is to explain tlie law ia
any difficult poini to you, but oy no means to
give you his opinion upon the case; he is
merely to state the law, and sav alw^s, hy-
}>otheticaUy, if the man is guilty of the oA
fence, such and such punishment is due to it;
but hie is never to sav let me beg of jcu to
say so and so ; it is ilieg^ it is the highest
pitch of wickedness in a judge so to do.
*^ Now, all these provisions (the objects and
consequences of the glorious Revolution)
woukl have no value, they woidd be nugatory
and worthless ; they would be a mockery, un«
less they were effectually to obtain and secure
to the people of this land these three impor*
tant points. First, An honest and respon«
sible exercise of the executive authority;
Secondly, Real, independent, and faithiiil rc^
presentatives of the commons m parliament.
Thirdly, A fair and impartial administration
of justice in the courts of law. We who bad
no predilection for any family whatever (es^
cept as connected with these objects) in the
words of our ancestors at the tune of the Be-
v<^lion, did now again claim, ^mand, and
t
7SS]
fir
A, D. 1794.
[734
imist, tipoD flil thoee •8«unnidiNriMed
the true, andein, aud mdnbitaible riehts and
liberties of this kingdom^ Ist, Wttuam aad
Mary, chap. S. If tM& by VBiious means It
has happened (as he asserted and ondertook
<to pre<ve in a coinmittee of thb House), that
•this provisiODal responsibility of the piivy
-council BO longer remams; that the election
of the Beuse of Commoiis is neither fair, nor
free, nor frequent ; that this provisional in-
dependeBce of its -members is gone, aad that
the House at present, swaraas with persons
having offices and places «f profit unoer the
king, and reeevving pensions from the crown ;
fibat jucies are not favly and impairtiaHy
-taken ; tliat they do not act freeljr and wvih-
out infiuenee ; that eicessivie bail may be,
and has been requited ; that excessive fines^
^rnftv be, and has been, iniposed ; thai iltegal
«na cruel pttnisbmonito, may ibe^ and Inive been,
'inflieted ; that the judges are not independent
of the crdwn ; that pensions may and have
•been, gmnled to some of them ; and that
4uGrailiv» offices am^ be, and have been, con-
•ferrsd upon olAiers;- by which means it cannot
kt said that tiieir snlanos are ascertained and
eslabUelied— 4f 'lAiese laets were so, he beld
•it to be the duty of all those who, without
4iypocri6y praised the Revolution'' — Most
men, perhaps all men, praise the Revolution,
4>utthey'do it with various intentions; but
he speaks here only of those who praise it
^rithoul hypocrisy. He says '< he held it to
l»eshe duty of all those who without hypo-
crisy, praised the Revolvtion, to endeavour
tofetuiti us again to our ooBstilutional situa-
tion at that varied, and to recover those lost
nr n^ledeo ptovisions, that so we might
^ffisctaally secure-to ourselves and to our pos-
terity, w4iat our anceaioTS endeavoured at the
Sevohition to secure to themselves and to
us.** I hope tiiat single passage will be suffi-
cient to do away all the criminality of the
wovd assert, in the mdictmcnt. It may be
done in two ways, bv fovce, or by argument ;
in «ither case it would be justified by liie pre-
sent glericais eonslitation, taken not ireni'-
calfy, not insidiously, as it is taken by some^
but literally, acoonling to the truth. Our
glorious conrtitation permits us to assort our
rights, and even pecmiSs us to resist oppres-
sion : however, from the tenor of the pro-
ceedings of tile conventioB^ you will see that
arms were the last things we should hav^e
thought of; being little imired to arms, and
being a small number to the bulk of the na-
tion, I mean the associated men, who have
aettt their delegates to the Briti^ Conven-
tion; and from what has happened to-d^,
you will see that the public amd is |»nting
for reform ; and i hope, gentlemen, if vour
countenances deceive me not, that you all, or
the greater part of you, wish for reform ; an
amendment can be attended with no ttl eon-
sequences. Mr. Wharton concluded with
movi^gy<iThatn4HMnmitteebe appointed to
iaqite whoth^anyi and which of the pvovi-
Mns made by padiament in the reign of
William and Mary, and m the leicn of Wil-
ftiam Sd, for seeunng the responsibk exercise
of the ciecotive autbority; ibr seeurinr a
veal, independent^ and faiwul representation
of the Commons m parliament; and ifa se-
curing a fair and impartial administration of
justice in the courts of law ; whether any, and
which of these hove by any means been inva-
lidated or taken away : and to consider whe-
ther any, and which of these lost or invalidat-
ed provisions may be €t to be re-enacted and
restored, in order that the people of this land
may recover -Uwt situatisn and security in
which they were phned \s!i the glorious Re«
volution in 1488.'** This motion, i have
aimady told rou, was lost, and it was lost by
a majority of 71 sileut men, against It honest
men who soppmHed it ; but the 71 did not
utter a single syllaUe, though I firmly believe
that the lewd advocate was in the House at
the time: ifhewas not there, his master, hie
iither, his uncle was these, and not « word
was said ; they put it eo the sileot vote, and
mtmbers carried it, which shows you what
chance we have of obtaining, bg^ a humUe
submissive petition to the House of Com-
mons, any redress ; tt shows 3W)u, that if we
want to (Mi>taiii redress we had much better
to to the fountain of redress, and apply, in the
rst instance to the king ; but that is a thing
that b matter of ooinion; however, it requires
consideration ; ana when the matter of reform
comes to be more public, which I hope it will,
it will then bear ample discussion.
Gentlemen* — ^I have, I believe, in the for-
mer part of mv defence, mentiened to you,
that the lord advocate, not being able to sub*
stantiate his 'Charges against me upon written
earidence, was ibrced to draw in a mom power-
ful aid ; namely, a blank, as a proof of cri-
minality ; he has laid great stress upon it ; he
has turned about in it like a horse in a mill,
and though he went back from it once o^
twice in the course of his spee^, h» was sure
to petum to tt again. He has likewise sought
to attach a great deeree of criminality to the
words convention of emersency, which is a
simple English word, signifies a case of great
moment, a case that rec[uires speed, that re-
Suires immediate attention, that requires all
iie exertions we can possibly bestow upon it;
therefiwe strip it of the epithets seditious, ma-
licious, lelomous, and all these high-sounding
words, and you find nothing in it unjustifiable
whatever. H« has also sought to criminate
me, with cftiargmr that my firiend Browne
ga^e a histoiy ^ the Habeas Corpus act ; and
he has wi^ed to attach more than seditkm,
a kind of treason, to the bare mentxm in the
convention of the wrongous imprisonment
aot; surely, if such an act exists, it is oompe-
tent to every subject of the reahn to see that
■pi*.
* See Mr. Wharton's speech and motion
on May 31st 1793,in the New Parliamentary
History, Vol. 30. p. ^61.
735] 84 GEORGE III. Proceedings qgaitist Mawrice Margarta [736
It is secured to them ; that it was (as I me-
sume all acts are) made for the benefit ofthe
public, and therefore it Is natural that men
should be anxious that those benefits should
be retained to them ; yet it should seem that
the bare mention of such a thing is treason in
Scotland. It galls those in power to think,
that they have got a power above them ; that
they are not entirely above control ; but I
have already said, that there is not a man in
the kingdom sibove control; even the king
holds his crown by a contract, and therefore
is not above control? he is not above the
laws; he is not, indeed, responsible; the fie ^
tion of law says, he can do no wrong, because
his contract holds no longer than he abides by
the constitution ofthe kingdom; the moment
that he would attempt, as a James, or a
Charles 1st. to break the contract between him
and the people, the moment he had broken
that contract, he would then no longer be un-
accountable to the people ; on the contrary, it
is most likely, the people would call him to
an account, as they have done in other cases
before, when they have ventured to ride pa-
ramount over the laws. The laws are made
for the weal of the nation, and are of more
importance than any individual, in whatever
rank society may have placed him ; thev are
of more importance than any individual, for
without laws there is no society; and without
any individual whatever, the society may still
remain a society.
Gentlemen. — I will now come to the mere
points of the indictment ; for the speech of
the public prosecutor, has wandered greatly
from the mere &cts stated in the indictment;
however, I was obliged to follow him, inas-
much as he did me the honour, on Monday
last, of trying me before another jury; font
was me more than Skirving that he tried ; it
was me he had continually m his mouth, and
to me that a great part of his speech then ap-
plied. He taxes us with holdine delusive re-
publican principles, and he builds his crimi-
nation upon our having adopted certain words,
which he seems to think were never in use in
England before the revolution took place in
France ; he is, however, much mistaken, for
there is not a schoolboy but can tell him that
section was as much in vogue, and made use
of in England, twenty years back, as it is now.
There is not a writ for the return of a member
of parliament, but has the word citizen in it.
The word citizen is in all the students cards ;
and even the pin-makers of London are ob-
liged to have the word citizen in their cards;
therefore it is not an adoption of any thing
new. As to regulations and orders, if they
are founded upon French principles, for God's
sake give me French principles ; and that we
were regular and orderly, I will take the .li-
berty to prove to you. By the regulations
that I will read to you, you will see that we
were hr from havmg any seditious or disor-
derly principles about us; but that we were
organizing ourselves into the most regular
body in tiie world; and, I believe, even free^
masons themselves, who have resulations and
secrets, and I believe some of their commit-
tees are pretty secret, ^meet together, and
therefore are guilty of all the crimes I am
charged with ; and I do not know that there
is so much regularity even in their proceed-
ings, as there was in our's : — ^* The conven-
tion shall henceforth be called. The British
Convention of the Dele^tes of the People,
associated to obtain Universal Sufirage and
Annual Parliaments. The delegates to thb
convention shall be elected annuisdly, on the
of , and shall meet where the
secretary and intermediate committee shall
think most advisable for the general intew
resf — You see it is for the gooa of the gene-
rality; not for the good of one description^
men ; not for the good of the opposition, who
are endeavouring to oust the ministry, ia
hopes of getting into their places. No, lei
us oust the abuses, and restore the constitu*
tion to the state in which it was in 1688. —
'^ The secretary and intermediate committee
may, at any time, call a convention ofthe de-
legates, on 14 days notice; but the^ shall Ins
responsible for a proper exercise of this au*
thority. The convention, after electing a pre-
sident bv show of hands."— Here we odl nim
a president; that is not a French word. I
fancv that is a word that has been used in
England for these 50 years back, and I can*
not attach any degree of criminality to it, be-
cause we did not put it in the power of a man
to sav, he was sent by a certain number of
people, unless he was intrusted with the oon-
ndence of those men, for the purpose of a
parliamentary reform, as I will show you by
the instructions that I brought from London,
which I have in my pocket, and which es-
caped the inquisition. «^^^ The convention^
after electing a president by show of hands^
shall proceed to the verification of powers^
and then to the division of the convention
into sections, in such manner as shall here-
after be provided." — Here follows the head of
oflke-bearers. The public prosecutor told
you, he could not tell what this preses meant;
this will explain it : — ^* There shall be a pre-
sident or preses, three assistants, a secretary,
a treasurer, and door-keeper. The three as-
sistants and the secretary shall form a coun-
cil, to be denominated the council of the
table. The office^f the preses is to maintain
order, to take the sense ofthe convention oa
all questions to be determined therein, and to
declare on which side the question is carried,
to call on the committees for reports, &c. ana
to sign all public acts."— You see there is no-
thing seditious in the office of preses ; unfer-;
tunately, that night there was no public act
passed ; I kept order, or endeavoured to do
It, as well as I could. I took the sense ofthe
convention, and declared on which side the
Questions were carried: an explanation of
that you will see by-and-by, under a separate
head. ** The office of the council of ibe tfr^
737]
jfvf* S^dtHoH*
A. D. 1794f.
[738
biey 18 tb ]te«p oiddr m ths btnaess of the
•onvflOfkm, a» pvUcidarfy specified under
ib» hesd odttncil. The offi^ or the secretary
k, to tikke charge of all writings and papers
beloaging to the oonvention; to issue sum*
* laonses, write and dispatch letters, &o. &c.
aflcording to the orders of the convention,
aad the request of any eommittee, during the
time (rf* their sitting; and shall have ac*
ces^ on all oocasionsy to every committee
^huine its sitting." This was made a crime
IB sEirving, when you see it was the
duty of his office to attend as many commit**
tees as he could spare time for. ** The offies
of treasurer shall be to receive and pay all
nonies subject to the regulations to be at any
l&iile adopted by the convention or the com«
mitSee of finance. The ofiBce of door-keepers
is, to prevent the admission of any persons
not members, exceot by special leave of the
council of the table." This was to prevent
improper company; I do not mean spies;
ibr, on the oontnoy, when thev were known,
thqr wefe preferably admitted, though with
the contempt they deserved, and which no
elau in society can detierve more than them-
selves^ unless it be the men who employ
them. And now follows the head of commit- .
teeS: — ^ No eommittee shall be composed of
more than 13, or less than three persons;
and the nomber of each committee shall be
decided by a show of hands in the convention.
All committees shall be chosen, unless other"
wiafc oidered, at the time of their appoint*
nent; and they shall be authorized to invito
the asaistaiiice of such members of the conven-
laoB aa they may think beneficial to the busi-
ness entrusted to their charge. All oonunit-
tees shall be elected fiom the leet of the sec*
tions, unless found necessary ibr some imme-
diate purpose, in which case thev shall be
appdnted by the convention, one by one, by
ft show of hands; and they shall sit and report
fCDgress, day by day, until their business is
completed. The first meeting of evety com-
adtteeto be fixed l^ the convention; every
subsequent meeting according to their own
adjournment." Now comes the bead of coun-
cif of the table. ^ There shall be three aa«
sislants, dbcted from a leet given in by dito
seelions, one to be renewed^ and the senior
ta^ go out of oflioe daily ." Those who had the
yaalcsi number of votes were elected ; and
Ml consequence of that, the convention* was
likely to. be best served, for they neither
holi^ their electors, nor sold them when
tinjir had boufht thOm. ** The secretary and
assotaatr sfaSl fbrm the council of the* table;
thev shall prepare a state of the business for
each day ; shall anange the order in which
the different eubiects shall be taken into coi»»
flideratioB^ which arraogemeat shall be ad*
heved to, unless the convention should akdr
tiie' samO by a vote; they shall permit a
member firom each section to take copies of
all motions, &c. to be submitted to the com
siderMkm of the sections^ and shall assist all
VOL. XXIIl.
members who request their aid, in the word»
ing of any motion they may wish to lay upon
the table." This brings me back again, to a
motion that has been mtroduced against me,
as written evidence, and which Wairalaw was
called to prove r he said, and it was not less to
the dbsrace of those who brought him for-
ward. Sum to the Friends of the People^ of
whom he was a member, ^ that he came m a
state of inebriety : he said he had written out
that motion ; so he did, and I am not a^med
of acknowledging that motion; it is a motion
drawn up, not by me, but by the council of
the table, and it is stated in the indictment,
'^ To do this your committee suggests a reso*
hition to the following effect, but which I
shall leave to be drawn up by the council of
the table." The spirit of the motion was that
which the committee, of which I was the re»
porter, had to report, and which motion was
to be drawn up by the council of the table.
** The council shall have the power to inter*
nipt any debate, for the purpose of proposing
to the convention any other business which
they may think more urgent; but the presi-
dent shall take the sense of the conventiwi by
a show of hands, whether the debate shall be
tetermpted ornot." Here you see this is the
greater part of their duty, to judge of such
motions as were lakl before ttiem; if th^
, were nugatory, they were to inform the |>er-
son who bruusht them oi| it; if otherwise,
they were to inSlorse them on the back; tfaqr
were to hand the motion to the president; he
was to read it to the conventkm, and then the
vote of the convention was to determine whe-
ther the business was of sufficient conse*
quence to depart from the order of the day.
Then follows an article which gives great
umbrage to those who are frightened at event
thmg that looks like French. It is the head
of sections. We had the name of divisioBs:
andof classes; but no name which was agreed
to by every body; at last, section was agreei
to fy a great minority ; and we thought ne
more of the French convention at thiU timoi,
than we did of our new ally, the grand IWk.
To explain to vou, then, what is meant by
sections, and the cause of adopting that word^
wtkh was more from accident tbm any thing
ds^ it gDoson:— ^ All the members ef the
convention shall be divided by lot, into sfo*
tions of 15 persons each." And wlnr divided
into sectM>nS of 15 persons eadi? ItwasBot
with i| view to overturn the government; it
was not with a view of betng secfitious, or
riotous, or anyithmgof the luce, but with a
view or the(r meethig, as we hlul many coun-
try deleeales who had much leisure on their
hands, rorthe purpose of giving them useful
employments. In the morning they used to
meet and discuss the news of the day, and
littie political topics, and thereby came better
prepared in the evening ; and in the course of
one week, we almd y found a great difference
ih their pohtk»l information; they had al-
ready learned to connect their ideai^ and ferin
3 B
739] S4 GEORGE IIL Proceedings agnnat Maurice Margarai {740
a more acairate judgment of the bosiness
they were about. They were also to pick out
the -men who were most proper for the nomi*
nation of president for tne next night, or for
the committees. These were the felonious
and seditious employments of the sections in
the morning. ** The members, who may not
be able to attend at the first division into sec-
tions, shall be divided by lot among the sec-
tions formed ; but if any section shall have
two more than its proper number, no new
member shall draw ibr that section until the
numbers are again equal. Every section shall
be furnished with a complete printed list of
the convention, containing the name, sur-
name, and the society which each individual
represents.'' And you see, gentlemen, here
is great regularity; and where men use such
regularity, they cannot be. called a riotous^
tumultuous assembly, ^* The sections shall
be renewed on eveiy Monday during the sit-
ting of convention." Now, I maintain, that
there is no principle in our British constitu-
tion, which prevents mutual communication
irom one man to another, but will encourage
that intercourse ; for union alone can make
us strong, as has been sud, though in a dif-
ferent sense, from the bench. " Tne sections
shall meet every forenoon, at eleven o'clock,
•ach in a separate place; and shall daily
choose a chairman fbr the section, who shall
report their leets of election, &c.; and if
these reports are not delivered into the coun-
cil of the table, immediately on the chair be*
ing taken, thev shall be deemed null. Each
section shall duly furnish itself with a note
of all tiie business, and with copies of all
motions and reports^ to be taken into consi-
deration that evening. The sections shall
daily discuss the business of the convention;
they shall prepare lists of such persons as
they may think most proper for oraces, com^-
mittees, Sec, ; but the sections cannot finally
decide any matter; nor, in their collective
capacity, give an opinion, or make a proposal
to the convention. No member in the sec-
tions shall be allowed to vote by proxy ."•^
We did not, you see, intrench updn the privi-
leges of the House of Lords, wher« they vote
by proxy; and we thought^ that as eveiy
man was equally interested in the business,
that he should attend as often as he could ;
and, if he did not, it should be his own loss,
by losing his vote. << The members of one
section shall not be received into any other
section, during ita sitting ; and no person>
not a member of the convention, can, on any
o6nsideration, be admitted." Ana I am sure,
there is not a man here, who would wish to
be intruded upon by strangers, in the social
hour, over the bottle,, but the servant comes
m with his name before he is admitted.
[Here Mr. Margarot drank a glass of wine.]
I beg pardon, gentlemen, for this interrup-
tion ; 1 should not have done it, if the exam-
ple had not been set me; we have no sudi
thing in England, gentlemen, as a jury eat-
ing and dnnkmg in court. i
Gentlemen^ the next head is thai of mo-
tions. A great /degree of criminality baa
been attached to the motions that baive been
produced; but, notwithstanding all this
written evidence, which is to tiansport us,
and prove us nearly guilty of high treason,
I will show you the innocent manner in
which these things were to be carried On.
<< All motions shiSl be in writing, signed by
the mover and seconder, ana transmitted
to the council of the table, who shall num-
ber and file them, according to the order in
which they are given in^ At the close of
each day's business, and before the adjourn-
ment of the convention, the seeretery, or
one of the council, shall read all motions
given in, during that sitting, according to ther
priority of delivery, in order that they may
be copied, and taJ^en into consideration, bv
the seveial sections; and, bdng so rMO,.
they shall come on for debate the following
sitting, in the same order of arrangement
made by the council^ unless the convention
shall think proper to prefer any one of them,
as containing matter of great importance
or more urgent necessity. A motion once
rejected, cannot be brought forward again in
the same session <»f the convention, unless
requested in writing by 90 members." This
was thought proper to be introduced, in order
to save us trouble, as there were some men
who could speak better than they could
write; and who, perhaps, might wish to be
busy; for we already began to suspect that
we bad got spies among us, and that motions
of a dangerous tendency might be brought
in ; and,Uierefore, we endeavoured to prevent
being led into a trap; for we found that, in
nneral, it is the most honest men that
become the dupes of knaves. ** In case of
two or more motions being on the table,
which relate to the same object, and tend to
the same end, the comicii and the respective
movers shall use their best endeavours to
consolidate them all into one before th^ are
discussed : but, in case the council and the
respective movers cannot agree in such mea-
sure, then the same shall be finally deter*
mined by the convention. ^ Notwithstanding
the above regidations, any member may
submit a motion at any time, to the oonside^
ration of the convention, which he deems to
be of greater importance, or more urgent ne-
cessity than any of those which stand in the
order of the Sbs ; and if from the reasons
advanced by such member, a majority of the
convention shall coincide in opinion with
him, such motion shall be mimediately
brought forward and determined."
Now, here is that which was dmwn m
with more care than any other part. Wb
know debates often lead to warmth; and,
that when disputants wax warm, tfa^y gene-
rally grow tumultuous and irregular. - We
have seen these tumults, and uiis riotous
manner of debating, even in 'the House of
Commons s we soi^t io avoid it; and there-
741]
fir Stdihcu*
A. D. 179*.
[742
fore we ordered that '' no person shalt speak
.in the ordinary sittings of ^the convention,
more than once on the same suhject, unless
it be to explain, or bj special leave of the
convention ; but, when all who wish to speak
to the question have done so, any member
may be heard again ; and evenr member who
opens a debate, shall have the privilege of
being heard the last in reply, before the
discussion be finally closed. If it shall ap-
pear to the mover or seconder of any motion,
or to any other member, liiat the matter con-
tained therein re<iuires the most ample dis-
cussion; on motion for that nurpose, made
and aereed to, the person shall leave the
.chair, for the purpose of the convention re-
. solving itself mto a general committee, in
^hich a chairman Seine first appointed,
every member shall be at uberty to speak as
often as the committee asay think proper to
bear him, till the question shall be called for
hj an apparent majority. As soon as the
question shall be called for, and the dis-
cussion closed, the president shall resume his
seat, and the question shall be determined in
convention. The council shall require the
.president or chairman, or either of these
.may, of his own accord, put a vote for closing
.the debate, when it appears to any of them
to Jbe the general wish of the convention, or
general committee; there shall, however, be
a vote taken ; .and two to one for dosine the
discussion, before it actually takes p&ce."
Here we sought, not only to avoid the heat
•of debate, but we eougbt to avoid partiality,
and we sought to avoid any prejudice that
.any man might have against another, or in
.favour of another. ^ The question of closing
the debate may, itself, be debated; but it
must be strictly attended to, that no member,
under pretence of giving reasons for or
against closine the debate, shall go into the
discusuon of me main question."
The next head is that of order; a term not
borrowed from France, but firom the House
of Commons of England ; for^ in the House
.of Commons, .the order ot the dav is a
common phrase. *'The convention shaU meet
daily, at &ve o'clock in the afternoon, and
shall proceed first, to receive and veriiy the
powers of any a^w members. Secondly, to
receive, without reading, the lists of candU
dates, from the sections. Thirdly, to read
communications addressed to the convention.
Fourthly, to elect, from the list of candidates,
the committees, if any have been ordered,
.the new assistant, and the new preses.
. Fifthly, to hear from the council, what is the
.whole business standincfor discussion; and
,wbat b that particularly appointed for the
day, with the order of priority, proposed by
the council; which priority may there be
.debated, and fixed. Sixthly, to read over the
, minutes of the preceding day, and any former
days, not finally settleo, and direct correc-
. tions of the same, if need be. Seventhly, to
receive reports from the different committees.
^ In goine through the business of the
day. the order of priority, fixed as above^
shall be adhered to, unless altered by a vote
of the ccMiventioo, which must, at any time,
be {>ut, if desired, by the council; or, if
required in writing, by any five members.
Ai^ point, once discussed and determined,
can neither be rescinded nor brousht forwara
again on the same dav ; nor at all, but by a
motion regularly made ; and for the brinj;in£
in of whicn, leave shall have been obtained
the preceding day. The reporter of any com^
mittee shall always have a preference to the
ordinary business of the day, to deliver his
report to the convention, so as not to break
in upon any debate which may be before it.
Members shall speak in the order in which
they rise for" that purpose ; and, if more than
one rise at the .same time^ the preses shall
decide who is entitled to priority.
" The president alone shall have the power
of interrupting any speaker who wanders
from the question; but any individual shall
have the right to suggest his opinion, by
writing the word ' order,' and handing it to
him.
" No member to be allowed to speak to
any subject after a show of hands has taken
place on W
You will see by this, that we were not only
far from seditiously inclined, but we did not
give our tonnies a loose : we were obliged to
speak in oraer, and methodically take our
turas, and say nothing farther than what we
were entitled to. You will firom that gather,
that a society so well regulated, could not be
for the purpose of overturning the constitu-
tion, wnich, in its original state, is regul»*'
rity itself: we were proceeding in a way that
directiy led to a reform. Tnese are the
heads; and there remained five more to be
finished, when we were apprehended by ge-
neral warrants, and the meeting dispersed by
the power of tioie sheriff, and of the lord
provost; therefore, if we are not in order.
It is not our fiiult, but the fiiult of those who
interrupted us; yet, you will see, that we
were not altogether so iltiterate as some
men^ and men of shining, perhaps more
shining than solid, abilities have thought
proper to represent us. We knew what we
were about : and all this was done openly ; we
have had fifty visitors of a night; any person
sending in his name to the council of the
table, was his admission ticket; and, as I
before observed to you, we sought nothing
but the public good ; we sousht a parliamen-
tary reform; we seek it still; and, Intrust,
we shall to the end of our lives ; and a reno-
vation—not a destruction, but a renovation-*-
of our constitution.
Gentiemen, I will now come to the plain
facts stated in the indictment, and then I
will make a few remarks upon the evidence
that has been given ; and, gentlemen^ I am
sorry to detain you so long; but it is my
duty to be as explicit as possible, in this
743] U 6EO&6E III. Proeeedingt ag&md Mmnrke iiargitrot [744
matter, wwellasyour^stolisteiitoit; were
it my own indiTidiail biudnetSy I frould meet
your verdict this iostaot; but I have elreedj
told yoiiy that I eoonder myeelf as the leaat
concerned in this matter; it is the cause of
reform.
The indictment, gentlemen, accuses me of
liamg been made a delegate by an associa-
tion of seditious people, calling themselves
the Corresponding Society of London*
Now, gentlemen, either the charge is true
or false ; if it is false, it is miUicious ; if it is
true, then I am the seditious person I am
V repiesenled. The London Corresponding
Society is not a seditious societv; it is a
society established upon as regular and as
sysiematicai a plan as that of the couTcntion.
We are proceeding to increase, to diffuse po-
litical knowledge, to make every man ac-
ouainted with nis . political rights : we are
formed into divisions, because we well
know, that large companies introduce disor-
der and confusion; therefore, we never
suffer, — except when general meetings take
place — we never suffer above a certain number
to assemble together; we assemble in pri-^
vate houses; neither eat nor drink; but
calmly and coolly discuss the political sub-
jects before us ; we instruct tne ignorant,
and receive instruction from those that know
^more than we do ; and therefore the charee
that this is an association of seditious people,
is a falsehood. And the public prosecutor
backed it with another fidsenood, on the niaht
he did me the" honour to try me, instead of
Mr.Skirvins; he asserted, that tins seditious
aocie^ had held a meeting for the purpose of
-choosmg delesates; and, that they were so
detested by the mob, that the magistrates
were obliged to protect them. I vras not at
liberty to answer him that nig^ht; nor should
I do it now, especialW in his absence, but
that impressions unfavourable may have
gone fortn. It is said, that the magistrates-—
an odd doctrine for a crown lawyer to ad-
vance,— ^were obliged to take under their pro-
tection the seditious Loudon Society, in
electing delegates to send to Edinburgh.
If the Corresponding Society was seditimis,
why did not the magistrates queU us ; they
were present ; and they came with a design
to disperse us; but the laws are paid greater
regard to in the metropolis than they are at
some distance from it; and, when itygy found
we were acting upon constitutional princi-
ples, they dared not molest us ; there were
600 consubles, and out of those 500, I will,
to be sure, say there were at least SOO out of
them who maintained the same principles
that we did, that a reform was necoMary ;
that it might have been imprudent if the
magistrates had acted otherwise than they
did. If any illegal open act of violence had
taken place, it must have been oocasbned by
4hem ; but they did not commit any act of
violence; on the contrary, we placed our-
selves under the care of the higti constable
andhispoasy; and tii^ attended; butyasin
the testimony of the lora provort, if any riot
was oooaaioned that day, it was from the
masMtmles and their att^mfftntt : &r our
society, being so numerous, we wace ohl]|^
to meet in an open field ; or at leaat a EM
inclosed vrith palincs ; it was in the naig^
bourhood of Spitalfields ; and the people ib
the neidibourhood, led bj curiositgr, and not
kept at name by work, bemg out of employ,
and might as vrell dine upon the fresh air aa
upon the stagnate air of Spitalfields itself,
they attended our meeting to the amount of
thousands^ and behaved as orderlv as those
men you saw to-day come up the streets;
they behaved with the utmost decency; and
the police majg;istmtes, from the police office,
with their police ninnors, attendeo, but did mit
dare to molest us more than that we invited
them to attend our meeting, inasmuch as it was
constitutional. Knowing that they should
displease certain persons in power, who shall
be nameless, they declined accepting the in-
vitation of attending; but, after 1 was nomi-
nated, I returned thanks for the polite atten-
tion they had paid us ; they asked us whether
we were to choose members of parliament ;
I replied, No ; that our object at Edinburgh
was to communicate with our brethren here,
who were, hke ourselves, pursuing a reform
^in parliament; that would be our business
in Edinburgh. I told them, if they had
any commands, I would execute them ; th«r
politely bid me a aood day, and drew M
their constables ; and found thems^ves to be
very happy in being protected by us; it is
true, sir, the high constable came to m$f
and begged of me, as a means of dispersing
the moo, that I would desirs the members
of our society to disperse quietly, forasmnch
as there mi||ht be some riot, some tumult.
I told him, if that was the case, we would
to a man turn out and assist the civil officer;
that as reform was our aim, so was order;
and that we would, on evesy occasion, proleet
the civil officer; and at the same time that
we assisted him in his duty, we would take
care that he did it
And, gentlemen, my behaviour has be^
perfectly regidar ; I have been always nmf
to come forward, and fiwe m v countr^r, agsiast
any charges, except, at toe first insSmee^
when I was assailed by six blackguards^ or
messengers ; or, whatever they were, I told
them, toke my word, that whenever thej^ re-
ouired my presence, I would be fbrthcooung :
tne same was the case in this eourt; I had
not renewed my bail in this court ; yet, I dkl
not hesitate to appear ; 1 never will fly from
justice; I will always abide b^r it Besides,
pntlemen, if the London Sodetv was sedi-
tious, but it is not, it is sanctioned by a letter,
a copy of which shall be given to each of
you, to peruse at your leisure: you will soe^
that tt.was a society founded^upon our coaati-
tutiunalprinciplaa; that none ofthaministers
daredofbndus: itis tnic^ last year, ffveml
rm
Jir Seiil6m»
A. D. im-
tW
•MMistiaiii fvtee IbiaMd aB 9v«r tlMldni^
demigod, it 18 thej ivlw aovaded tiie losw $
aody where did they onsiittle ? tbey «ng^
Hftied io about dicireii pfioeoieD : tkle pmu*
dent, the rhftirman of that aocietyy poMeaset
only five pliM^es ; ha was a cierk, or under-
strapper of lord Hawketbuiy; his name is
Beevesx at the same tiiouB, to prove to you
the farther coostitiitionalily of oor proceed-
ingHy we didy in the avrnth of April, hold an
essemblyy at the down and Anchor, in the
room dtKwe this very man, who was for pro-
testing propel^ agimst republicans and level-
lers: this leiy man, obliged to bite his nails,
in the room underneath, dared not show his
teeth ; but be can write; and he is assbted-*-
l will not say by the treasury, but he has pe-
cuniary assistance, and has laid the public
under contributions; and, here I apply to an
obsovfttion of the public fwosecutor, that we
drew money from tne poor, the deluded, and
the weak. Would to GSed, no man drew more
ifom the poor, the deluded, and the weak !
If no man enjoyed more sinecure places than
we do, every fanuly would have bread; which
is not now the case ; while those who draw
money from the poor, the weak, the deluded,
and, I may add, the oppressed, are revellinj^
in riot and luiury, ana all manner of profli-
gacy : while they sell themsetvea^ while they
sell others, and their crimes, they cut a
figure; but let them remember^ that every
guinea that tliey possess, oonsists of a cei^
tain number of drops of the blood of the
poor. He says» being named a delegate by
an association of seditious people, calling
themselves the corresponding society of Lon-
don, did repair to Bdinburgh, with the wicked
andfelonions purpose of joining and co^opeiw
aHng with an illegal association of evil-dis*-
posed and seditious persons, who origipalty
designed themselves the aeneral convention
of the Friends of the Peopfo. Now, it seems,
that the original Friends of the People, were
an illegal association, — were an association of
evil-disposed and seditious persons. In the
indictment, it says so; but, in the pleading
of the prosecutor for the crown, ne says
otherwise ; he savs, that the^ were harmless,
that they were allowed ; and indeed, the be-
haviour of the magistrates toward them,
seems to prove the legadity of their institution :
he goes on, and cbarses us with holding wi-
Tious illegal and seuitious meetings; haw
came they to be ille^ ? if the Friends of the
People, were in the first instance, legal, how
came they to be illegal and seditious? or
where are the proofs that hebringsof it? He
likewise says, they met underihe pretence of
procuring a reform. GenJLlemen,youarenotto
be caught by words: you are men of sense;
and sense alone is to opSerate upon you ; reason
and sound sense : bow is he to tell ? how is he
to prove ? in what manner has he proved that
these were only pretences ? On the contrary,
what I have already showed you betrays a
great system of regularity and order; and
t
.1
osier «^yi Mver 1m ifliroduioid for the Bake of
fbrwardiDg conftisieii; and yet, he oays, they
were evidently of a dangerous and destructive
teBdenqr,*^thoug^ I startle at the woids^
evidently of a dangerous and destnictive ten-
^Micy; yet, if you albw me to add a few
weros to that sentence, I will show they are
strictly true; fiir, if you appljf these woida ta
the abuses which have crept into the consti-
tution, you will make EngUsh, you will make
sense, and vou will make truth of iL He says,
we imitated, in the form and tenour of our
proceedingiB, that convention of people, the
avowed enemies of this country; these peo*>
pie, the avowed enemies of this oountiy^
ngbt with guns, b^oneCs, and cannon : we
do the ssme ; and yet I do not suppose that
we axe guilty for opposing arm to arm : the
House ^Commons, whom we are seeking to
reform and wish to new»model, if possiple,
upon the planofamorefiequentrenovatieo^
uses the same regulations tnat we do; but
order can never ve criminal. Gentlemen of
the jury, he mys» likewise, that I did act
as preses or chairman of their meetings : this,
likewise, he has fiuled to prove: he has
proved that I acted once as chairman, and,
therefore, cannot be guilty of acting as chair- .
man at their meetings; at least, he is inac-
curate in his languase ; but, in England, such
an inaceuracy would be fatal to the indict*-
ooent Although it has been said that I was
an attomejr by one, and. by another, that I
know nothinsof law, I nope to prove, that I
know something of tiie constitution, and^
that if I am no atlomey, I have as much ho-
nesty as any attorney, or any gentleman of
the gown. It goes on, that various inflaa^
mateqr votes and resolutions vrere passed.
Of this, I trust, the public prosecutor haa
failed to produce any evidence : there is ne
vote, no resolution of an infieromatorv nalyre ;
inasmuch as to understand the word inflAm»*
matoiy, it means, not merely, that which
will inflame itself, but that which will inflame
otiiers; now, the word introduced, as inflam-
matory, liad no manner of connexion with
the convention at large, and was ordered by
it, to have been burnt; time, indeed, he is
right; it might have been inflammatory;
when burning, it was inflammatory ; but tmit
inflammatory nature was no way seditious.
Continuing, then, in the swollen and delusive
language of the indictment, he states, that
the sain Maurice Margaret, did also ** when
attending in his capacity of delegate, at the
illegal meetings of the sajd association, utter,
ano make vanous, seditious, and inflammatory
speeches, tending to vilify our present happy
constitution, and to withdraw therefrom tne
confidence and attachment of our subjects.''
I have already proved, that the only end of
our meeting was, to revert to our constitu-
tion ; but. It seems, that there is a terrible
confusion of ideas. He accuses me with
having, while attending my duty, as dele-
gate in these meetings of the convention,
)47] M 6E0ROB III. ProceetUngi againU Mmrice Margard [748
with having made - several inflammatoty
speeches, tendine to vilify our present happy
constitution; and to withdraw therefrom tne
confidence and attachment of our subjects. |
That that is a wrone statement, will be evi-
dent, at first sight : by whift you have already
been told, you must have discovered, that
men, seeking a reform, cannot wish to do in-
jury to that very constitution which will pro-
cure to ^em that reform ; for, we are not so
blind as not to see, that our oridnal consti-
tution, if we revert to its originiu principles,
does give us the reform we want; but his way
of proving this inflammatory speech is very
cunous. And, particularly, the said ^ Mau-
rice Marearot did, at a meeting of said con-
vention, neld on Tuesday, 1^ November
last, 1793, or on some other day of that month,
in a mason Iodjg;e, or room in Blackfriars
.Wjmd. in the city of Edinburgh, wickedly
and feloniously make the following motion^ or
one of a similar imporf This, you will re-
collect, is to be the vilifyinj^ of our present
bappy constitution, and our withdrawing there-
irom the attachment of our sulgects. Now,
you will see what that motion is, which he
adchices in support of that proof : That, previ-
ous to publishing an address to the public, a
committee be forthwith appointed to consider
the means, and draw up the outlines of a plan
of general union and corporation between the
two nations, in their constitutional pursuit
of a thorough parliamentary reform. He
brings you forth a motion, as written evi-
dence ; and, he tells you, this is done for the
purpose of subverting our present happy con-
stitution, and withdrawing therefiom the at-
tachment of our subjects. You certainly will
not take it amiss, if I recall to your mind
what I said before, that it was an attempt to
impose upon your understandings; for mere
is not one of you fifteen that ma a servant
about your house, so imbecile as to suppose
that a plan of union would tend to vilify our pre-
sent happy constitution, and withdraw there^
from the confidence and^attachment of our sub-
jects.' It mieht, very well, when helped for-
ward with all the brilliancy of gesture, of
language, of action, which he is possessed
.of; bul^ when you come to look into it, it is
a direct falsehood : let us call things by their
proper name ; it is a direct falsehood ; it does
not support itself then farther, that motion
bavins passed imanimously ; and which mo-
tion clearly demonstrated a wish and inten-
tion on the part of the said Maurice Marga^
rot, of propagating the seditious tenets of
that association over the whole kingdom;
and, of exciting our subjects in England, in
contempt of legal authority, to adopt the same
tinconstitutional conduct which the said Mau-
rice Margarot, and his associates, had pre-
sumed to follow.
Gentlemen, I have been told, that in
Scotland, I am as much a stranger as if I had
come from Germany, from Italy, fixim Ame-
rica; and yet, a court which cannot bring
witnesses from Eneland, can tnr me for what
was charged to be done in Encund : in short,
it is a fanago of nonsense. Were I better ac-
quainted with Uie public prosecutor, 1 8ix>uld
have thought he meant to have set fordi my
poor services in the convention ; and, there*
fore, brought me forward to explain the na-
ture of it The contempt of le^ authority!
— ^Where has it been shown r No where:
on the contrary, we had the sanction of legal
authority; Pitt and Dundas both. knew w«
were coming down: the maeistrates of Edin*
burgh knew we were assemming for that pur*
pose ; unless the contraipt was, that we did
not go and ask them leave : perhaps, had we
been strolling players, we might ; for, I am
told, that a town-ball^ not far mm Edinbuigh^
was refijsed to the Friends of the People ; and,
the next night, permitted to a company of strol-
ling players: probably the strolling players
are the most beneficial members of socie^.
Gentlemen, you see what hardships I la-
bour under, not being able to get at my ex-
culpating witnesses and papers, the witnesses
being alK»ve the laws of the country. The
loid advocate, when he says it was in con^
iempt of legal authority, utters a fidsehood s
not even your lord chief justice Laing, who
goes about knocking people down m the
street, — his legal autliority had not shown
itself; and, therefore, it was not in contempt
of any legal authority whatever. We took our
own room ; burnt our own candles ; and no*
body .had any thing to do with it but our-
selves: there was no contempt of anylenl
authority; and, therefore, that part must be
expunged ? as also, that which relates to Eng*
land ; over which, you say, you have no ju«
risdiction.^ Again, I fina among my high
crimes and mi^emeanors, the word ^octta ;
and, a learned judge has said, that we took it
from the French : another pers6n has said,
taking up, I suppose, what hand dropped from
the learned jud|^, thai it was a French word :
unfortunately, it happens to be borrowed
even by them : it is a Chinese word, signify-
ing a shrill sound ; a bell that is rung when
danger is near ; and, you know, the greater
part, or all the words of the Chinese language,
mean one and the same thing; and, there-
fore, they are obliged to couple a number of
them, in order to convey what they mean, es-
pecially when it carries a cgmphcated idea
with it.
Again, a motion is deemed very seditious^
for having appointed a committee for the par-
ticular purpose of watching every act which
may militate against Uie rights of the people;
it IS first false, that such a committee has
been appointed : but, if it had been appointed,
we should, in tne French term, have deserved
well of our country, f6r our vigilance ; for let
me call to your mind, in all the high offices of
trust, you nnd very few people wiinng to step
forward, and serve you for nothing ; and that
would have been the case, if we had appointed
this committee : we should have been lar
T49]
JurSedUkn*
A. D. 1794.
[750
bouring for you^ tt our own eipense; being
your centinelfly walebingy that none of your
rights might be encroached on while jrou slept.
But it may be proper here to animadvert
likewise upon the \>mBk that was produced as
criminal, and itiore criminal than the written
evidence: it was said, that the resohition
which ought to fill the blank, was of such a
nature, that it must not appear till the end of
the resolutions. I will explain that to the
satisfaction of the jury ; but it must be by
reading to them the whole discourse. Here
^ is a motion, supposed to be made by Mr.
Callender -. — That in case the minister, or any
other member, bring into the House of Com-
mons a motion for a convention bill, as passed
in Ireland, for preventing the people from
meetinf^ according to their just nehts, by the
IJevoltttion, the same motion shaLT be noticed
to the delegates of the respective societies
immediately, to meet in convention, to assert
their ri^ts ; and then they make me say
^ this is an excellent motion ; and the event
which it alludes to, ought to be the tocsin to
the Friends of Liberty to assemble: it seems,
however, to be imperfect ; it does not mention
any place of meeUne ; neither does it specify
the Ume when the delegates are to assemble:
for the word immediately is indefinite, and
will not convey the same meaning to persons
residing in different parts of the country:
by those who live near to the place of meet-
ing, it will be understood, that they are
to repair there next day; by those at a
ereater distance, within a few days; and by
Siose still farther of, within a week after such
information is received.^' Gentlemen, you
will remember, I have read to you eight
chapters, the produce of the committee of
regulations; you will see what spirit actuated
them, when they drew up those regulations ;
and that there was nothing seditious in their
tendency. Here, I am then made to say,
that, ^ this motion comes properly under the
chapter of regulations : I wish it were re-
ferred to that committee ; I therefore move,
that the report be read, that the convention
may judge, whether the article I allude to
sufficiently provides for the intention of the
motion now before the convention.'' Here
you see. first, my dissent to that motion of
Mr. Callender's : the one which the commit-
tee of regulations had drawn up, was in a dif-
ferent style, and would have come in ex-
tremely well at the end of the regulations ;
instead of which, the convention spliced the
one witli the other ; they adopted the motion
of Mr. Callender, and pro]K>sea to bring it in
as amended by Mr. Sinclair, and others; and,
the next day, they proposed to bring it in at
the end of the proceedings. That is the only
mystery that has given so much uneasiness
td the public accuser; while, at the same
time, he might have done away a great deal
of your suspense, and, likewise, have made
bimself much easier; for I believe he'is in
possesion of that very motion^ but did not
ttiink proper to produce it, because it would
not have answered his end of criminating me.
However, I will invalidate it entirely, for the
public accuser is bound to bring forward^ the
oest evidence he can adduce: he has not
brought that evidence forward : he has told
you, that he has got it, but has not produced
It; therefore, you are not to believe him on
his word ; and, I believe, that is not the only
falsehood pointed out, that will engage you
to disbelieve any thing he may assert I will
read a passage from the Gazetteer, which will
show, that other meai have been the victims
of his falsehood, as well as myself. Gazetteer,
7 th January, signed by a man of great res-
pectability, both as to trutli and fortune; a
man still more respectable by education, and
by his virtue ; he is a man possessed of 6,000/.
a-year, and upwards ; lays the chief part of
that money out, not in luxury, or in piofli*
g.te living, but in relieving the necessities of
e poor ; I mean Mr. Archibald Hamilton
Rowan,* who has been called one of the
wretches of Ireland.
<« The lord advocate of Scotland, Robert Dun-
das^ having asserted, on the trial of Thomas
Muir, esq., that an address from the United
Irishmen of Dublin, to the delegates for re-
form in Scotland* to which my name was
fixed as secretary, * was penned by these in-
* famous wretches, who, like himself, have
' fled from the punishment that awidted
^ him.'f and an explanation having been
* See his trial for a seditious libel^ Vol. U9y
p. 1033, of this Collection.
f In none of the editions of Muir's trial, is
the expression to be found, which is cited as
having been uttered by the lord advocate in
his address to the jury on that occasion ; and
as reports of the trial were published by the
partisans of Muir, as well as his opponents,
it seems probable that the ofiensive expression
was an interpolation. In the correspondence
which took place on the subject, ana which I
have seen, Mr. Rowan stated that the wonis
were attributed to the lord advocate in the
account of his speech published in the Edin-
bureh Gazetteer ; it b therefore possible, that
in die warmth of extempore ar^ment, the
words may have been used ; and if so, I be-
lieve they must have had reference to the ce-
lebrated Mr. Napper Tandy. For the pur«
pose of obtaining an explanation from the
lord advocate, Mr. Hamilton Rowan, attended
by the hon. Simon Butler, proceeded from
Dublin to Edinburgh ; immediately afler
their arrival, however, Mr. Rowan was taken
into custody; and as the proceedings against
him are intimately connected with tnese cases
I subjoin an account of them, which was
printed at the time.
» Edinburgh, QQth October, 1703.
*' Unto the honourable Sheriff of Edinburgh
— ^The petition of William Scot, procura-
tor fiscal of court, for the public interest,
751] S4 GEORGE in. Proceedii^i (^tmd Muwrke Margarid [759
svoided, tmder the pretext of o<&ciil duty, I
find it oow necessary to declare, thai siicl»
assertion of tiie lord advocate is a fidsehood."
'* Akchisald Hakiltmi Rowav.
** Jhminu>dreet, DuUin, Dec. 17, ir98/'
'< Humbly sheweth ; That in the monthsof
November and December last, or thereby, a-
most daogeious spirit of sedition made its
ftppearanoe amonj^t many of the leidges in
this countiy, which was carried to a very
great height; and meetings pramoted and
called at many different places ror the avowed
parfKwe of creating distorbanees, and over-
turning the happy constitution of this coun*
try— -*— In particular the promoters of these
meetings and seditions purposes, procured
and brought about what they weie pleased to
term a conventionof the Friends of the Peo-
ple at £dinbui«h» some time in the bennnine
of December ust, which sat and deliDerated
upon their seditious purposes for several days,
during which period, or recently prior thereto,
Mr. Archibalo Hamilton Rowan, of the king-
dom of Ireland, designing himself secretary
to the society or United Irishmen in Dublin,
ifid, with a malevolent and wicked intention,
and with a view to promote and forward ihe
afofessdd seditious purposes, transmit, or
cause to be transmitted, to one or more of
the members of the said meeting, at Edin-
burgh, calling or soling themselves, the con-
vention of the Friends of the People, a printed
paper of a most dangerous and seditious ten-
dency, intituled, * Address from the society of
* United Irishmen in Dublio, to the dele-
' gates for promotine a reform in Scotland;'
wnich paper, and the dangerous sentiments
therein contained, were recommended by him
to that meeting, and tber urged in conse-
<)ue|ice thereof to adopt the same.— —That
in the course of the mooths-^f June, July, or
August last, the said Archibald Hamilton
Rowan, with the same wicked and malicious
intent, also sent more of these printed papers,
with other papers or pamphlets, of a seditious
and daneerous tendency to the constitution
of these kingdoms to Scotland, to be dispersed
aiMl circulateid there. And not satisfied with
this, he, with the same malicious and wicked
intent, and for other seditious and dangerous
purposes, is just now come to this country,
and is* within your lordshijp*s jurisdiction^^
In order, therefore^ to check such illegal and
* It is observable, that though this petition
and warrant granted thereon, which bears
date the 38th of October, 1793, states Mr.
Hamilton Rowan to be then- withm the juris-
diction of the sheriff* of Edinburgh; yet Mr.
Hamilton Rowan did not leave Dubun until
the evenine of the 3 1st of the said month,—
arrived in Edinburgh al one o^clock of the
4(h November, 1793; and in less than one
hour afterwards he was taken int» custody. —
OHg, Ed.
Tbis it wliat they eall in plalD vulgar Bag*
* ,. mimt a man the lye; miA when the
aelsaniedtoiLthis
duuf is of an equally
high diancter, aid bit intflnsie character
nHOws him Tank M least with te official cha-
pnwattantabto pwceedings, and prevent the
fotaleanseqatncea which mifthc ensue tbrn*
from; aaauo, that the said ArehibaklliamiU
Ion Rowaa may be ponished according to
lawifgniligr; ywir lorasfaip's wanaat to the
effect after mentioned is craved.
^ May it therefore please your lordship to
grant warm&t ta officers of court, and
other executors of the law, to search fov
and apprehend the person of the said
Archibald Hamilton Rowan, wherever
be can be found within this shire, and
to bring him before you for ezaminatiDn
-«and thereafter, if you see cause, to
commit him prisoner to the Tolboth of
Edinbuigh, or Canonnte, therein to re-
main until hberate in due course of lav
according to justice,
(Signed) Willijix Soot, P. F.
« Edinburgh^ 2Bth October, 1793.
^ The sheriff having considered this petition,
grants warrant to officers ofcourttoappre*
nend and bring before him the |>erson of^the
within-design^ Archibald Hamilton Rowan,
for examination.
(Signed) Jobv Phingle.
^ 4#A Natfember.
" The which day, compeared in presence of
John Pringle, esq. advocate, hie majesty^s
sheriff depute of the shire of Edinburgh, Ar-
chibald Hamilton Rowan, esq. of Rathcofiy,
in the county of Kildare, Irehmd, who being
examined* and. interrogated, whether or not
tiie decbwaat is acquainted with Mr. Thomas
Muir, younger, of Hunter's- hiU, presently
prisoner in the Tolboth of Edinburgh, de*
cbunes, that had the declarant been in his own
country when he was apprnhended, he wouhi
have reouested to see the warrant, but think-
ing; the tint duty of a good citisen, to be sulv
mission to authority, and appeal to the law
for redress, he has attended : but being igno*
rant of the laws of this oovntiy, and not
knovrin^ how far he may criminate himself,
and thinking the intetrt^gatoiy unconstitu-
tional in itself, he begs leave to decline aih*
swering.— *— Interrogaled, did the declarant
* This examination was carried on in si-
cret; the sheriff depute^ the sheriff's sub&t*
tute^ two derfcs, tne procurator fiscal, th
meseenmr^and Mr. Hamilton Rowan, wer
the onfy persons present. — Mr. HamUton
Rowan ieque«tod tnat Mr« Butier should be
admitted, but his reqtiest was refhsed; H
being contrary to tlse> custom Aid laws of
Scotbnd, to admit at such examination^ th»
presence of any person on beha>f of the pailgr
under examination. ■ 0»%. Rd*
fSS^
Jar SediHon*
A. D. 1794.
[754
ncler of 4be pubfie ptpaecutor. .1 dare say
]ie 19 not a mai), who would Bx hU iiamti to a
£ilflehoo4i fta<l u he had, his falsehood would
liave heen contradicted; and it seems that
b^ the public prosecytor b very full of
«l» tha jpopths of November, December, or
Janua^ last. transmilL or cause to be trans-
aiittedj to tne said Thomas Muir, or any
^tlier person in Scotland, a printed paper,
4atod November SSrd, 1799, intituled^ * Ad-
■* dress from the society of United Irishmen
* ip Dublin, to the delegates for promoting a
^ reform in Scotland^ William Drennan,
^ chairman, Archibald Hamilton Rowan, se-
'cratary;' dedaves, that for the reasons
^^lovMoanlioned, and because the declarant
sees that the accusations against him, are the
having transmitted such an address, he de-
clines answering. Interrogated— Did the
declarant write a letter to the said Mr. Muir,
«r an^r other person, desiring him to lay the
foresaid address before the meeting of dele-
^tes for promoting a reform in Scotland, de-
si^ine themselves the convention of the
Friends of the People in Scotland ? Declares
and declines answering for the reasons already
assigned. Interrogated. — Did the decla-
rant see the foresaid Mr. Muir in Ireland,
in the months of June, July, or August
last, and then ^ve Mr. Muir a copy ' or
copies of a printed pamphlet, intituled,
* Poooeedings of the society of United Irish-
* men in publin?' Declares that the decla-
rant oonceives the whole of this examination,
as tendinji^ to criminate himself; that he is
nipt conscious of having ever acted unlike a
good citizen, either here or in his own coun-
JUy, and appeals to the justice of his cause,
when legally and constitutionally brought
forward, mr his exculpation, declining to an-
swer the question.^— ^Interrogated. — At
what time the declarant arrived in Edinburgh?
Declares, that he arrived about one o'clock
in the afternoon of thisday. Interrogated.
— Has the declarant seen or spoke with
the aforesaid Mr. Muir, since the declarant
arrived in Edinburgh? Declares, that the
messeneer who took him into custody, found
him in Mr. Muir*s room.— Interrogated. —
Did the declarant come to Edinburgh at
present, as a delegate from Ireland, to attend
the convention of the Friends of the People
at Edinburgh ? Declares, that if he had had
the honour of being appointed as a delegate
to attend that meeting, be would have Waen
care to come before it had broke up. In-
terrogated.— ^Did the declarant write a letter
to any person in this country, intimating that
he meant to attend the aforesaid meetmg as
a delate from Ireland, or in any other ca-
pacity? Declares that he did not. ^Inter-
rogated.— Did the declarant receive an invi-
tation from any person or persons in this
country, to a^end a meeting, designing them-
selves a convention of the Friends of the
People, and whieh was held m Edinburgh
voL.xxm.
spirit, and therefore would haye n^scoted this
injury. He has silently acknowledgfed the
truth of it, and the man who will teU a false-
hood in one instance, will tell it in general;
therefore be wary how you trust merely to
last week? Declares, That he did not receive
such invitation, Interrogated. — Did the
declarant receive an invitation to attend ai^
other meeting for reform in Edinburgh, under
any other designation than that above-men-
tioned ? Declares, that he received no invita-
tion to attend any meeting whateroer^ in EtUt^
burgh. Declares and acknowledges, that the
petition of the procurator fiscal, with the she-
riff's warrant upon it, in consequence of
which the declarant was appr^ended and
brought before the. sheriff, was read over to
the declarant before the examination pro-
ceeded. All this he declares to be truth.
(Signed) Archibald Hamilton Rowav.
John Primgle.
*' The before-designed Archibald Hamilton
Rowan, being further examined, and shown a
printed pamphlet intituled, ' Proceedings of
< the Society of United Irishmen in Dublin,^
and interrogated, whether the declarant has
before seen the said pamphlet, or any copy of
it ? Declares tliat he knows, that the socieW
of United Irishmen published their proceeo-
ings, but does not know whether the copy
now shown him, be a copy of their proceec^
Ings or not. Interrogated. — Whether or
not the declarant, at any time^ acted in the
capacity of secretary to any or the meetings
of the aforesaid society of U nited Irishmen ?
Declares and declines answering this qujes-
tion, for the reasons already assigned. Being
interrogated, and desired to consider the pam-
phlet now shown to him, and to say to the
nest of his knowledge and belief, whether or
not it is the publication made bv the abov^-
mentioned society, as before declared to?
Declares and declines answering the quei*
tion ; and which pamphlet is marked as rela-
tive hereto of this date. All this he also de-
clares to be truth.
(Signed) Arc ai bald, Hamilton Rowan.
John Prinole.
^ The before written declaration, consisting
of the ten preceding pages, was freely aua
voluntarily emitted by Mr. Archibald Hamil-
ton Rowan, therein designed, in presence of
John Pringle, esq. advocate sheriff depute of
the shire of Edinburgh; Harry Davedson,
esq. sheriff-substitute, and Mr. William Scot,
procurator fiscal of said shire ; George Wil-
liamson, messenger, in Edinburgh; Josejxh
Mack, and James Williamson, writers in
Edinburgh. The declaration being wrote by
the said Joseph Mack.
(Signed) Harry Davedson.
William Scot.
JosLPu Mack.
Geo. Williamson.
Jau. Williamson.
755] ^ 84 GEORGE III. Proceedingt against Maurice Margarot [756
liis assertion, especially with an object like
this in view, the extirpation of abuses upon
which he and hb reiatiTes fttten; for his
uncle reaps now upwards of 20,000/. a year
of the public money as secretary of state.
«* ^h November, 1793.
^'The i>etitioner represents, that as the
within designed Archibald Hamilton Rowan,
esq. when under examination before your
loixlship, declined to answer several questions
Eut to him. The petitioner is entitied to
ave your lordship's warrant against Mr.
Bowan, to commit him for further examina-
tion. But as the inquiries and further exa-
minations may take up a considerable time,
and thereby la^ Mr. Rowan under confine-
iiient, the petitioner shall consent that he be
liberated for the present, upon finding caution
to stand tryal, in any criminal complaint to
be brought against him, for the crimes charged
in the petition, and craves that your lordship
will grant warrant accordingly.
(Signed) William Scot.
<* Edinhurgh, 4th Nowmber^ 1793.
*^The sheriff having resumed the considera-
tion of this petition, declaration of the within-
designed Archibald Hamilton Rowan, taken
before him of this date, with the before-
written minute, grants warrant to officers of
court, and Greorge Williamson, messenger at
arms, to apprehend, and incarcerate, htm in
the Tolbootns of Edinburgh, or Canongate ;
the keepers whereof are nereby ordered to
receive and detain him, ay and until he find
caution acted in the sheriff court books of
Edinburgh, to answer to abide tryd, and un-
derlye the law, in any complaint or criminal
prosecution to be brought against him, with-
in the space of six months, from the date of
such caution, before any court competent
upon the subject matter of this petition, and
that under the penalty of three thousand
marks, Scots money.
(Signed) John Pbingle.
M Edinburgh, the fourth day of Novem-
ber, seventeen hundred and ninety -
three years.
** The which day compared, colonel Nor-
man Macleod, residing in Georze's-street,
. Edinburgh, and judicially enacts, binds, and
obliges himself, his heirs, executors, and suc-
cessors, as cautioners and sovertys, acted in
the sheriff court books of Edinburgh, for Ar-
chibald Hamilton Rowan, esq., of the king-
dom of Ireland, presently in Edinburgh, that
be shaH present the person of the said Ar-
chibald Hamilton Rowan, esq. at any time
and place to which he sbaU be lawfully sum-
moned, within the space of six months, from
this date, and at all the after dyeis of court,
to answer to abide tryal, and undcrlye the
law in any complaint, or criminal prosecution
to be brought against him, within the space
foresaid, before any court competent, either
Were abuses to be rectified, these salaries
would be diminished; were these abuses to
be rectified, it is possible that his conduct
would be inquired into as most likely it will
speedily. You see by this,^ gentlemen, that
at the instance of his majesty's advocate, or
the procurator fiscal of court, upon the sub-
ject matter of the petition and information
presented to the sheriff of Edinburgh, whereon
the warrant of commitment against him did
of this date proceed, and that under the pe*
nalty of three thousand marks, Scots money.
(Signed) Nobman Macleod.
At Edinburgh, the fourth day of Novem*'
her, seventeen hundred and ninety*
three years.
^* What is wrote upon this, and the preced-
ing pages, is a just copy of the proceedings
before the sheriff of Edinburgh, respecting
Archibald Hamilton Rowan, esq.
Joseph Mace.
''The following is the copy of a letter from Ar-
chibald Hamilton Rowan, esa. to the sheriff
of Edinburgh, dated Novemoer 6th, 1793,
which is to oe held as a part of tiie decla-
ration.
Joseph Mack*
* My lord ;— In consequence of your kind
permission of this momm^ I trouble you
with the following explanation : upon reading
over the interrogatory, and examining my
papers^ I find an incorrectness might be ap»
plied from two of the answers I eave to you
in my examination, which I beg leave to elu-
cidate.
" * Interrogated. — Did the declarant re-
' ceive an invitation from any person or per-
* sons in this country, to attend a meetmg,
' designing themselves a convention of iSe
^ Friends of the People, and which was held
' in Edinburgh last week ? Declares, that
' he did not receive such invitation.— —In-
* terrogated. — Did the declarant receive an
* invitation to attend any other meeting for
' reform in Edinburgh, under any other d^
^ signation than that above-mentioned ? De-
* dares that he received no invitation to at-
* tend any meeting whatever in Edinburgh.*
^ Now I do find that I did receive a let-
ter in Ireland from an individual, which
contained the following paragraph : — 'I
^ could most eamestiy wish that you, or any
* of your friends, would, without delay, do us
* the honour of a visit.*
^ I did not recollect this paragraph when
I was brought before you, I hardly think it
can be called an invitation, I certainly did
not think it such; and I declare upon my
honour, that that letter was not the occasion
of my coming to Scotland.-^I am, my lord,
^rc.
(Signed) Arcsibald Hamilton Rowak*
757]
for Sediiwn.
A. D. 179i.
[758
where wf thing tending to exculpate me
could be adducedy he has kept it back; but
he has not done it simply and fairly^ but ag-
gravated it;^'' I have greater proof of this
man's guilty but I will not produce it ; where-
asy it 18 an extenuation of euilt."— Here is
another act of criminality in wis motion ; by-
the-by, it seems veiy inconvenient in the
practice of the law of Scotland, that one
crime may afifect many persons, if it is only
by holding finger to finger^ art and part as it is
called here ; and here, gentlemen, it may be
as well to revert to the opinion of the solicitor-
funeral of king William upon that subject,
ir John Hawles says, "As juries have ever
been vested with such powers bv law, so to
exclude them firom, or disseise them of the
same, were utterly to defeat the end of their
institution; for then if a person should be
indicted for doing any common innocent act,
if it be but clothed and disguised in the
indictment with the name of treason :*'— So
that you see, even in king William's time,
there were frivolous persecutions as well as
at present — I meant to call them prosecu-
tions, I beg pardon, — and that if the jury did
not step in between the crown lawyer and
the subject, the subject having no redress,
was incarcerated, fined, banished, or other-
wise ill-used; and all for things, which in
themselves were perfectly innocent, but being
clothed in tremendous language, appear hei-
nous crimes, such as I was mentioning just
now, and is reported here ; — ** If any person
should be indicted for doiujg any common
innocent act, if it be but clothed and disguis-
ed in the indictment with the name of trea-
son, or some other high crime, and proved
by witnesses to have been done by him, the
jury, though satisfied in. conscience that the
hci is not any such ofience as it is called,
yet because (according to this fond opinion)
they have no power to judge of law, and the
fiu:t charged is fully provec^ they shall at this
** N. B. Norman Macleod, esq. who became
the bail of Mr. Hamilton Rowan,- is member
of parliament for Invemesshire ; a gentle-
man of li^2e property and extensive con-
nexions. The circumstances of this business
being reported to him, while Mr. Hamilton
Bonran was under examination, he attended
at the sheriff's court, and although he was an
entire stranger to Mr. H. Rowan, yet he in-
sisted in the handsomest manner on becom-
ing bound as his bail.''
In justice to the lord advocate, I should
mention that in his correspondence with
Messrs. Butler and Rowan, he most distinctly
stated that the information of their journey
to, and arrival at Edinburgh, which led to the
above proceedings, came neither directly nor
indirectly from him.
With respect to the Edinburgh Gazetteer,
see the cases of captain Johnston, p. 43, and
Alexander Scott, p. 383 of this volume.
rate be bound to find him gjuilty.'^ Thus you
will, if you find me guilty, refer me to
the mercy of the Court.— I shall not detain
you much longer; you have attended me with
singular patience, gentlemen of the jury, and
I thank you for it; — ^you are doing your coun-
try good. Distinguish then the true fi>iends
ol your country from its foes. You have
seen that the testimony of every witness
adduced on the part of the crown is one
weaker than another; that it all turns upon
the point of the meeting being seditious;
whereas, in verity, as the law term is. the
meeting was founded upon the claim of nghts
— that it is the privilege of the subject to seek
redress ; and I must take the liberty of quot-
ing to you somethins from Defoe, which will
prove to you, that the people have a right —
that the original power rests with them, and
that they have a right to control that power,
and keep on it a continual check; for, aa I
said before, the servant is not greater*than
the master, and the king is but the chief
servant of the nation. It is true we do not
exercise our authority over him, or if we do^
it is but once in two or three centuries ; and
I hope it will be centuries before we shall
have occasion to exercise it agun. But there
are those who exercise the regal power in his
name, and the sooner they are brought to
condign punishment, the sooner it will pre-
vent others firom pursuing the same dastardly
pursuits. This is a chapter of Defoe ; he is
treating of the original power of the collec-
tive body of the people of England. " To
the king. — Sir, it is not the least of the extras
ordinaries, of your majesty's character, that
as you arc king of your people^ so you are
the people's kuig. This title, as it is the
most glorious, so it is the most indisputable
in the world. God himself appointed, the
prophet proclaimed, but the people's assent
was the finishing the roysd authority of the
first king of Israel. Your majesty, among all
the blessings of your reign, has restored this
as the best of all our enjoyments, the full
liberty of our original right in is actings and
exercise."
This was published in the year 1705, soon
after the Revolution. ^ Former reigns have
invaded it, and the last thought it totally sup-
pressed; but as liberty revived under your
majesty's just authority, this was the first
flower she brought forth ;'* that is to say, the
acting and exercises of our liberties ana ori-
ginal rights, which are those whieh you have
seen in Mr. Wharton's speech, of petitioning
and obtaining redress; of loping a constant
check upon every servant of the crown, in
whatever situation he may be placed ; and of
obtaining a fair and equal representation.
He says in another place, — ** I have ob-
served, when interest obUges any person or
party to defend the cause thev have espoused^
they please themselves with fancying they
conceal their private designs, like a late act of
parliament^ which in the preamble calls itself
159] 34 GEORGE lit
ftn act for Ihe relief of creditors; but ^ich
in its effect, was an act for the relief of deb-
tors." This is like men who cry up the con-
stitution, and live upon its defects. ** Thus
some gentlemen place fine specious titles on
their books; as. Jura Populi Anglicani;''A
Vindication of the Rig^hts of the Commons
of England, and a Vindication of the Hights
of the Lords ; and with large and high enco-
miums upon the excellency of our constitu-
tion, treat the levity of some people's judg-
ments with fine notfons; whereas, the true
end and design is defending the interest and
party they have espoused/'
Gentlemen, call to mind whether it may
not be the case with one of us two, the panel
or the public prosecutor, whether we may not
be trumpeting up or sounding the praise of the
constitution, and at the same time have in-
terested and private views ; and as it has been
said, you cannot penetrate into the minds of
men, you can only judge from the tenor of
their conduct ; hitherto he has acknowledged
himself to be a placeman, though not a pen-
sioner. Gentlemen, I take my God to wit-
ness, that were I to be offerecl one of the
most profitable places under government,
my conscience would not permu me to ac-
cept the emoluments of it, when I know that
it has been drawn from the blood and the
sweat of the poor : that there has been more
blood spilt within this last twelvemonth, for
the purpose of gratifying ministry, and keep-
ing the public mind from reform, than would
completely fill the largest ship that is now in
the British navy, and f speak within compass.
** The defence of the rignts of the represen-
tative body of the people, understood by the
name of the Commons of England in Parlia-
ment, is a great point, and so plain are their
rights, that it is no extraordinary task to de-
fend them ; but for any man to advance, that
tbe]^ are so august an assembly, that no ob-
jection ought to be made to their actions, nor
no reflection upon their conduct, though the
fact be true ; and that it is not to be examin-
ed, whether the thing said be true, but what
authority the person speaking has to say, it is
a doctrine wholly new."
You see, gentlemen, it was a doctrine new
a hundred years ago, in the time of Defoe,
but ts a doctrine renewed now to serve these
state prosecutions; it is highly seditious, and
of a very evil tendency in the public at pre-
sent to examine into the conduct of the House
of Comipons, and yet at that time it was
constitutional; why? because we have brought
in the present family, and that they had en-
tered mto a cpntract with the people ; they
would not suffer their servants to deviate
from it at first ; at present, through lapse of
time that is grown obsolete, ana their ser-
▼acfts' servants tell you, you are not even to
examine into it ; praise the constitution, and
think yourselves happy, whether you are so
or not. "It is doctrine wholly new, and
seems to me to be a badge of more slavery
Proceedings a^irut Maurice Margarai {760
to ottr own represenbfiveii, ^HUk enlt Ihe
people of England cweS them, of than evei*
they themselves expected. This therefoiey
together with some mvastonS of the people'*
rights, made public by several modem ai»*
thors;*' You see the rights of the peopi^
vrere begun already, then to be invadedf, **wti
the reasons why I have adventured (beidg
wholly disinterested and unconcerned eittier
for persons or parties), to make a short essay
at declaring the rights of the people of Eng-
land, not representatively, oai collectively
considered. And with doe deference to tfaie
representative body of the nation, I hope I
may say it can be no ditnimitlon of tlieir
riehts, to assert the rights of that body from
wnom they derived the poiwei^s and privileges
of their House, and which are the veiy foon-
dation of their oeing.**
This refers to what I said «b yt>u just now,,
the servant cannot be higher than the mas^-
ter; if they derive their powers frcra tis, we
entertain powers superior to theirs ; it h there-'
fbre our duty to see that they acqtrit thetti*
selves of the task reposed in them, and eon*
sequently all the meetings of the people finr
those purposes are constitutional, aim not
seditious and inflammatory, as sounded hy
the public accuser. ** For if the original
right of the people be overtiirown, the power
of the representative which is si^secment and
subordinate must die of itself, and necause I*
have to do rather with reason and the nature
of the thing, than with laws and precedents."
— I am happy to find that Defoe stood in the
situation I now do. I have, gentlemen^ Id
do before you with reason and the nature ef
the thing : I have to deal with your reasofas
I like that much better than uiw or Pjnect*
dents ; reason is an emanation of the divine-
Being ; laws are but the formation of tfaftt
emanation, and the farther the rays dnrerge
from the centre, the weaker they grew.
Gentlemen, you will find that the pHdftv
doctrine that I am laying down, has been the
language of all times aud all ages, is the doctrine
of truth itself; and that I am acting fbr the
public advantage, and hot for private or per*
sonal emolument ; and because I have to dA
rather with reason and the nature of tfaft
thing, than with law and precedents. Tmk
crown lawyers can confuse and confound ti
man not bred to the law : they can confound
a juryman with the dust from the old miisty
law-books, and lull his reasoning to sleep
with words conveying a very different mean-
ing to what ought to be attached to them.
** To come directly to what I design in the
following papers, it is necessary to Jay doWxi
some maxims other than what a late authot
has furnished us with ; salui populi ^pfefHa
/ejT." This will not be controverted by aoy
body, the welfare of the people is the first of ui
laws ; and remember this, gentiemeti, ** all
government, and consequently our whole
constitution, was originally designed and is
maintained for the support of the peopled
7el j for SeXiion.
property, who are ihe epvemtd.** It is Hat
the support of the peopfe, not for the support
of the governor. '^ that all the ftiembers of
govemfiienty wnether kmgs, lords, or com-
mons, if they invert the great design of their
mstitution — the public good, cease to be in
the same public capacity.^'-^You see, Defoe
absolutely suspends them from their function,
the moment they cease to derote their talents
to the public good. How many of our place-*
men and pensioners would be suspended, if
that law was still put in execution ! — ^ And
fK>wer retreats to its original, that no €ollec->
thre or representative body of men whatso*
ever, in matters of politics any more than
religion, are or ever hate been infallible .''
Here is the axe at the root of the omnipo^
tence of parliament, — "That reason is the
lest and touchstone of laws, afld that aH law
er power that is contradictory to reason, is
ipso facto void in itself, and ou|ht not to be
obeyed. Some other maxims less general,
are the consequence of these ; as first, that
such laws as are agreeable to reason and jus-
tice, being once made, are binding both to
king, lords, and commons, either separately
&r conjunctively, till actually repealea in due
form.'' Thus much 1 differ from many great
men in the law at present; who sav» that a
bad law when once found to be a bad law,
ought to be disobeyed in order to get it bro-
ken. On the contrary I am for obeying, and
eveiy good citizen is for obeying and paying
respect to the laws, and to notning but the
Xlaws; and while a law is in force, let it be
never so bad, I will obey it; I will point out
if I can the errors of the law, but I will obey
it while it is in existence ; from that confes-
sion of fiutb, you may easily suppoSi^ that
another article of accusation will tall to the
ground, which is that our convention was to
assemble and militate against the parliament,
in case of the introduction of a convention-
bill: we were to overawe— in the language
of the public ptosectitot- — to overawe the par-
liament ; to check them In their proceedings:
so we were : but how? by argument, by sound
reasoning. As a body of men we could do
nothing till we had a majority of the nation
on our side. When once the majority of the
societv is of one way of thinkingj^ it is proper
that the mimority should yield to it, and that is
the first law of society ; and as the general good
is to be paramount to every thing, so the
will of the few is to submit to the will of
the many ; and therefore, the object of our
institution was fifrst to dimise political know-
ledee; and secondly, to gather the general
will. If we found tnat general will to be for
a reform in parliament^ a reform in pariia-
ment we should obtain ; if we are to be slaves,
it b our duty then to sit down silent, and if
not satisfied, we may, as a noble lord nassald,
take our pack on our back, and be ttudging.
My lord, at another season I might not
talk improfitably; but at tiie present late
hour of tile night I think m my mind that I
A. D. 1794..
[76^2
hwt said stffHcieiTtly to acquit myself of all
the charges laid against me, if you will be
kind enough to divest yourselves of any pre«
judice which public papers, puUic rumours,
or public prejudices, may have inspired against
me to examine not merely the man, I am,
myself a willing and a devoted vktim to my
country, t know if I am left to the mercy of
the Court, how that mercy will display itself;
but if it can profit the cause that I should be
a victim, I am willing it sheiik) be so : I ha^e
ihced death before now i I am not afraid of it
now, you may see thai I am not agitated : I
am as cool as yourseFres : I have studied this
aifair well : I undertook it not sanctioned hy:
a Fnt, a Riehmond, or a Diiiidas; I adopted
It upon reason and justice, and I will qmt it
only with life.
Oeiit1emen> yon represent your country*
your situation is awful ; you are new to guard
its liberties; you are now to encourage the
plant of reform ; — a mild and peaceful reform,
according to the temper of menls mindB, now
may be easily effected ; but beware of perse*
cution carried on with too much rigour. We
know, and history shows us, that at a certain
pitch of oppression, the people will bear it no
longer, ana an uninformed multitude is what
everv well-studied government, evety well
conducted government should fear to incense.
It has been the policy of Europe ; and it is a
popish policy; and I am sorry to say, we now
number two among our alhes, who make
much use of that policy ;--.I mean those who
encourage the inquisition and the bow-string,
the Pope, and the Turk, who both have now
ambassadors at our court. It is their policy
that the people should be ignorant; it has
been the policy of the priesthood ; it has been
the policy of uilse politicians; but I hope the
time is coming, when men will open their
eyes to their true interest, and that seasoil
when riches are no longer to be poured upoA
one man without measure, while a thousand
others are starving. It is necessSry that there
should be a distinction of ranks, and it will
take place, but let merit be the way to public
offices; study that, and you will find your-
selves better served ; — not as the present ens*
tom is, the cousin of one lord, and the son of
another is to be the proprietor of a borough ;
these are things much wanted to be reformed.
Gentlemen, you have seen how slight the
charges a^inst me are ; you have had inti*'
mations ot what the mcn:^ will be that I shidi
experience; a farther intimation that orders
have been issued, though the parts from
whence tiiose orders came, have not been
developed to you; yet let me recur to your
daim of rights ; it is contrary to the laws of
Scotland, that any magistrate of Scotiand
should act according to any order whatever,
except it is according; to the laws of Scotland,
bat not according to the orders of any stranger.
You are in thb case, without any appeal in
Scotland. You are the representatives of the
people ; they have entrusted you with their
763] 34 pEORGE III. Proceedings against Maurice Margarot [764
rights and privileges ; you are to pronounce
on me, whether I am guilty or not. I have
appeared here to answer to my country. I
hope I have done it to the satisfaction of my
country, and I hope you will do it honour by
your verdict. Though the sophistrv of the
pubUc prosecutor has appearecl in all its de-
fectSy I hope that sound sense and reason are
at work in your minds, and I hope there is
not one among you fifteen, but who is possess-
ed of an honest heart. Consider, I tell you,
consider not me — consider your country. Con-
sider the cause, and consider the futility of
the charee that is brought against me. I am
sorry to nave detained you so lone, but it is a
serious affiiir, and your verdict willnot be con-
fined within these wails; the eyes of Britain
ara now upon you fifteen men, whom I do not
even know by name, and who perhaps never
saw me before, nor I you ; then examine me
well, see if there is any thing seditious in
my appearance or behaviour; see if there
is any thing illegal in what I have done,
though not versed in the qmrks of the
law; and I am glad of it, for I believe
the laws, and the perversion of the laws by
the practice, have made many an honest man
a knave. You will see whether I am guilty
of the charge laid against me; what propor-
tion of guilt is attacned to me ; whether any
part is proved home to me ; whether any part
IS legal proof, and whether I was not serving
my country ; and I cannot hesitate a moment
to think, but that your verdict will do honour
to your country, and justice to roe. — Gentle-
men^ I take my leave of you.
Give me leave now to call to your lordships
attention, your particular duty.
Lord Justict Clerk. — ^I will not receive any
instructions from you, sir.
Mr. Margarot, — I shall take the liberty of
checking your lordships, if you do not go on
properly.
Lord Juitice Clerk. — ^You have gone on for
four hours, and I would not allow you to be
intemiptea ; if you had not been a stranger,
I woula not have heard one-third of what ^ou
have said in four hours, which was all sedition
from beginning to end.
SUICMINO UP.
Lord Justice C^ft.— Gentlemen of the Jury;
— I dare say every man in court is fatieued, as
I own I am ; and afler hearing it will not be
necessary to detain you much longer ; but I
shall make a few general observations, which
I ^prebend may Be of some use in forming a
judgment upon this case. The crime here
charged is the crime of sedition ; and although
it is not founded upon any statute law, it is a
crime very well known in the common law of
Scotland, and indeed is coeval with the very
justice of society. When mankind are in a
state of nature, every man is a law to himself?
but as soon as society is formed, every mem-
ber of that society lie under obligations to one
another ; to that society of which they are
memb^^, to maintain the law and constitu-
tion of that society; and every attempt to en-
croach upon the constitution of that society,
is a very heinous crime, and very severely
punishable. Gentlemen, it is a crime which
afibrds different degrees of aggravation ; ac-
cording to the nature of it, it may be applied
to private matters, and mav be less criminal
in that case, according to the circumstances.
But whenever sedition has a tendency to over-
turn the established constitution of the kiiig-
dom, it becomes a crime of the most heinous
nature, and of the most dangerous tendency,
and it borders indeed upon the crime of high
treason. Gentlemen, the libel here laystne
crime charged in the major proposition, as
sedition ; and the public prosecutor has stated
a variety of facts and circumstances, from
which he infers the crime of sedition, and th^
conclusion of the Ubei is, that all or a part
thereof being proven, then he is to be punish-
ed wi(h the pains of law ; which pains of
law in this case, is an arbitrary punishment,
and which the Court will make more or less^
according as they think the circumstances of
the case deserve it.
Gentlemen, although the prosecutor has
detailed a variety of facts and. circumstances,
all of which I shall shortly state to you, yet it
is not necessary that every fact and circum*
stance should be proved, in order to obtain a
verdict of guilty; because, if you are of
opinion that such facts and circumstances are
proved, as are sufficient to establish against
the panel an accusation of the crime of^sedi-
tion, it founds you in a verdict of guilty. If
upon examination of the whole circumstances
of the case, you should be of opinion, that
nothing is proved sufficient to establish the
crime of sedition aeainst him, you will find
him not guilty, or tne libel not proven. And
gentlemen, tlie first thing Co be attended to
IS this, whether the society which call them-
selves the British Convention of Delegate^
from what you see of them, can be reckoned
a seditious society or not; — that b the first
thing you will investigate. And gentlemen^
it is a very material circumstance, which you
will have under your observation in forming
your iudgment ; and, it is this, that that society
stancls upon the record of this court not of
above six or seven days old, to be a seditious
society; when a person, a secretary to that
society, acting in tnat capacity, and as a mem-
ber of that society, was found guilty of die
crime of sedition, and has been by a judgment
of this Court condemned to transportation for
fourteen years ; that is a pretty strong cir-
cumstance to show that this was not an mno-
cent meeting. If it was a lawful roeetine, I
am afraid that poor man, Skirving, has suffer-
ed very unjustly. In the first place, there
was a unanimous verdict of a most respectablie
jury against him. And in the second place^
the Court pronounced judgmeut upon that
verdict. And indeed, gentlemen, independent
of what was estabUshed upon the trial of Skir«
t
765]
fit SediHon*
A, D. 179*.
[766
Ting, I think you will be to con^der^ whether
upon taking a full complex view of the pro-
ceedings of the society, as it has been es-
tablished this day by parole evidence, but
chiefly by written evidence, which is not so
capable of error as the other ;~^l say, whether
upon the whole of the evidence ansine from
what has been laid before you, that this was
not an innocent meeUng, but a meeting of a
most seditious nature.
Gentlemen, they say that the meeting was
for a lawful purpose, and that at the same
time that they complain of the grievances that
the subjects labour under, nothing more was
meant than to obtain a reform in parliament.
Gentlemen, that is the profession of the meet-
f ing ; but then they are obliged to say that
because their attempting a reform in another
mode, was a much more criminal act if they
did not prevail; but you will attend to the
facts, and see how far what is proved in this
case is inconsistent with the idea of ^ reform
in parliament; and when jou see them hold^
ing out that the parliament is guilty of the gross-^
est irregularities, as havinjg no regard to the
laws or the good of the subject, and in short,
that we are just upon the brink of ruin.-^—
When that is the light in which they pretend
to hold forth the parliament, it is impossible
to believe but they must mean somethmgelse
than a reform in parliament ; they could not
well expect to get a redress of their grievances
from a parliament whom they have thought
proper to state in such terms.
Gentlemen, if a society of so^many people>^
dividing themselves into sections, committees/^
oomine from the sections, motions made, and
upon tnis a committee of secrecy appointed,
and a convention of emergency estaolished,
and the sittio^s declared permanent, and all
that. — ^Was this necessary for a reform in par-
liament ? I think there could be no occasion
for all this secresy ; an application to parlia-
ment seems inconsistent with the idea of it.
I am afraid it must satisfy you ; — you will
consider the whole of it, whether the evidence
does not show you, that something else than
a reform in parliament was intended. You
see, that they have established a convention
of emergencv, in the case of a convention bill
being brought into parliament similar to that
brought into the parliament in Ireland. Ano-
ther was in the case of that meeting being
dispersed ; and the third was in the case of
an invasion, or in case of the landing of
.^. foreign troops. Now supposing that they had
nothing but fair and honest intentions in the
case of a foreign invasion, they were to join
the government to repel that foreign force,
wa&.ihere any thing there that was an object
of secrecy? I think the more public their
resolutions were, when of so virtuous a nature,
calculated so much for the good of the public,
the more public they were, so much the
""^ i>etter ; and it could not be a subject of secrecy.
That therefore taking all these circum-
fita^Ges together, I am afraid that them, is
nothing but what isirreconcileable with inno-^
cence. But gentlemen, in order to constitute
the crime of sedition, it is not necessary that
the meeting should have had in view to over-
turn the constitution b^ mobs and by vio-
lence to overturn the king and parliament.
For I apprehend, in some sense, tne crime of
sedition consists in poisoning the minds of
the lieges, which may naturallv in the end
have a tendency to promote violence against
the state ; and endeavouring to create a dis-
satisfaction in the country, which nobody can
tell where it will end, it will very naturally
end in overt rebellion; and if it has that ten-
dency, though not in the view of the parties
at the time, yet if they have been gmlty of
Eoisoning tne minds of the lieges, I appre-
end that that will constitute the crime of
sedition to all intents and purposes. Now,
gentlemen, take a view of the conduct of this
meeting, and attend to the time when all this
reform, and all this noise and declamation b
made against the constitution. It is at a time
when we are at war with a great nation, a
cruel ferocious nation, that requires all our
strength, and not only our strength, but the
strength of all our allies to get the better of
them; and the greatest unanimity is neces-
sary. I submit to you whether a man ^at
wishes well to his countrv, would come for^^
ward and insist upon a rerorm, parliamentarr
or not parliamentary, at such a crisb ; which
would create discontent in the minds of the
people, when every good subject would pro^
mote unanimity among the lieges to meet the
common enemy. I say in pl£;e of that, to
bring forward a great reform in parliament is
a thing totally inconsbtent with the consti-
tution of this country. I say, bringing it for-
ward at that period is a strong proof that
they were not well-wishers to the constitution,
but enemies to it. I say that no good member
of society would have taken those measures.
I appeal to you all, that you are living under
a happy government in peace and plenty, iu
perfect security of your lives and property,
the happiest nation upon the face of the earth ;
and when that is the situation of this country,
I appeal to you whether I have not given a
fair and just description of it ; for a set of
men in that situation to raise a faction in the
minds of the lower order of the people, and
create disaffection to the government, and
consequently make a division in that coun-
try ;— I say, these things appear to be from
the very conjuncture at which they are
brought forward, sedition of a very high
nature. Now, gentlemen, you will take into
consideration the whole proceedings of this
meeting, and take a view of what stands upon
the records of this court, that that convention
is already determined to be a meeting of an
illegal nature.
xhe next question is, whether you can pro-
nounce this gentleman at the bar innocent.
I will lay it &wn as a principle of law ; — and
not peculiar to this country; it is theprin-
767]
S4. GEORGE IIL
c^ of the civil lav^aod I believe the (no*
ci{de of ever^ law ia ^oiy weUngoveaed
staAe,«^that where a number of people are
couceroed in a crimen that M and each of
them are guilw, art and part of actiog in dif*
iisrent parts ot the commission of the ciime^
as some may have been more active than
others, they are all of them in the eye of the
law equally guilty, and liable to punishment;
that is the law of Scotland, and I believe of
every civilized country, and tlierefore if this
is an unlawful society, the man that is presi*
dentof that society, IS liable for every thing
done in that society; and is amenable to a
court of justice for the crimes there com*
miUed.
Now, gentlemen, the question is, if this be
a seditious society, whetther you can pro-
nounce Mr. Margarot innocent. In the first
place, ^ou see that the public psosecutor has
estabJisbed that he was sent down to that
inery meeting from England, as delegate ; he
comes down for no otner errand under the
sun. He leaves bis business of a merchant
in London, and attends this meeting in the
character of a delegate ; that I apprehend is
taking a strong part in the proceeain^s of this
seditious, illegal society. You see him at all
the meetings almost, and you see him the
mo^t active of all the meetmg, He is chair«
man upon one occasion, and he is making
apeeches and hangagues upon another ; and
you will attend to that motion by which the
convention of emergency was established, bv
which acommittee of secrecy wss established.
The comnuttee of secreey consists of ibur
membersi and the nane) is named one of the
four, that is in evidence before you ; and if
you take all these things together, he comes
down to Scotland, leaves his business in
liMidoQ, and attending these meetings daily ;
you see him taking the active part, making
n»otions» and nuking that very important
motion for a committee of secrecy ; and he
was named one of the committee. I leave it
to you, gentlemen, whether you can pro*
nounce him innocent of the crime of sedition.
Gentlemen, I own at the same time that
this panel shows a good deal of ingenuity,
though I cannot applaud his discretion or
judgment The crime charged is sedition;
and I think he tpok up four hours in a defence,
which was sedition from beginning to the
end ; finding fault with the constitution, and
X think a speech of a very seditious tendency,
and I will not tfouble you with any more of
it. I have given you the general idea of the
case ; if vou are of opinion nothing is proved
against this gentlemen, find him not guilty ;
on the other hand, it jfwx think the facts
and circumstanoes sufiiciently brought home
against liiro, you will find him guilty.
Tuesday, January 14/ A, 1794. — Half past one
o'clock.
The names of the Jury having been called
over, they brought in the followmg
i offAfui Mawrke Margard [769
vfiai»icT«
Edin^rgk, JanA^h, If M.
Tbe above assica tmvlac enclosed, made
choice of the said Samuel Anderson to be
their chancellor, and the said John Balfoor
to be their clerk , and having considered the
criminal libel raised and pursued at the in-
etatice of his majesty's advocate for his ma-
jesty's interest, against Maurice Margaro^
panel, the interlocutor of relevancy pronounced
tkereon li^ the Court, the eividence produced
in proof of <Aie libel, and tht evidence adduced
in exculpation of the nanel, they all in one
voice find the fjanei, Maurice Afafj^arot,
otJTLTT of the crimes libelled; in witness
whereof, their said chancellor and clerk have
subscribed these presents in their names, and
by Uieir appcnntment, place and date as above.
(Signed) Samuel Akderson, Chan*
JoBH Balfoub, Clerk.
Lard Justice Clerk, — Grentlenien you have
pronounced a veiy accurate verdict. This ia
a trial of great importance, and the country
is obliged to you for the attention you hav^
paid to the cause. If you have any thing to
say, Mr. Margaret, now is the time.
Mr. Margarot. Undoubtedly I have, my
lord. I dionot yesterday start objections ob
futile grounds. I objectM to the competency
of the Court ; I obJ[ect to it at present ; I in-
ibnned your iordsmps, that I meant to bring
an appeal against the whole procedure, in con-
sequence of that incompetency. You ttioujiblt
proper, at th^ time, to repel my objection,
out I now still sustun it : it is in consequence
of the absence of the lord justice genera] of
Scotland ; I was charged to apoear before him :
he does not appear m his place ; I did my
duty, he neelected his, and the court waa
not full ; and it certainly was necessary th^l
be should attend, otherwise the indictment
would have run, the lord justice general, the
krd iustice clerk or the other lords ; instead
of which, it ran, and the other lords of jua-
ticiary : that implies the absolute necessity
that he should be in his place; or, otherwise,
the Court was not even by the public prose-
cutor deemed complete. ^
I likewise mean to bring an objection, full
as forcible, which is that wnich I experienced
in the course of my trial. I was not able,
though I had performed all the necessary
legal ceremonies, — I was not able (because
some men do not pay tliat respect to the
laws which they ought to do) to adduce
several of my exculpatory witnesses: your
lordships refused to grant me a caption; your
lordships refused to grant me a delay ; con-
sequently, the most material evidences, that
I could have brought in my own defence, were
entirely denied me : but, my lord, although
that denial was in consequence of an asser-
tion of this Court, that your jurisdiction did
not extend to England ; yet, a part of my in-
dictment was founded on crimes, said to be
committed in Englaud, and relative to the
7C9J
Jint SedUion,
A. D. 1794.
[770
p^pUof&agknd. It is odd, that yoa should
take cogBbance, ^o this Court, of crimes
relative to the people of Englaad ; when from
Eoglandy you cannot compel the attendance
of a lingle witness in my favour.
There is, my lord, an objection again, which
is entirely local, which is confined to £din-
Imr^ itself; I have summoned three men,
as eiculpatory evidences; two of them were
atteoding, the third was not attending ; but
no notice was taken of him. These men I
wish to call into oourt, to examine as excul-
patory evidences for roe. The k>rd justice
clerk insisted upon my telling the nature of
the <iuestions I meant to put : I gave him the
outlines of them^ upon which the judges
thought proper to refuse the admfssion of
those .evioences.
Another charge relates to yourself: I had
ordered the messenger to summon your lord-
ship upon certain facts which went to prove
that it was very likely I had alr^v, before'
my trial, been pr^udged. Your lordship was
not summoned, in consequence of the fear of
this man of offending a person in power ; but,
at ^e beginning of the trial, your lordship
tola roe, and the public prosecutor— to his
justice be it said,— acknowledged that the
legal point should be obviated, and that, you
should attend as an exculpatory evidence;
buL when it came to the pointy you refused
to be put upon your oath, and to answer the
questions prof>osed to you. Those questions
went to criminate yourself, my lord; they
remain unanswered by the advice of your
brother judges. The consequence was, that
«iy defence was neither 90 complete, my ex-
culpatory evidence not so satisfactory, and I
make no doubt but it is owing to that that
the juiy,r-Qf whom I shall not take the least
notice at present; that is the business of
their country, not of me ; — that the jury have
thought proper to find me guilty.
There is another thing ; should these ob-
jections be repelled, I have another to bring
6>rwaAi, that you will not so easil v get rid of.
It seems the custom of Scotland, that the wit-
nesses are confined to a chamber by themr
selves, and no stranger admitted amongst
them ; that was not the case yesterday : a
person, of the name of James Carlisle, was
conversing with them a considerable time in
the 'outer bouse. These are great objections
for staying judgment. The two first objec-
tions go to can^ the whole proceedings, and
the tb^ee last at least to staying of judgment.
I ham no more to say at present
Lord JuHic9 Clerk, — ^i ou will not be al-
lowed to speak afterwards ; and therefore, if
you have any thing more to say, you must
speak out.
Mr. Margvr^t, — I have nothing more. It
^ns said yes^iday, I was not vosed in the
biws of Scotland: it i& true, lam not; but I
have, some sfigfat knomvlectee of the British
constitution ; and I must observe here, that
the pvooaedings of this Court have been ade-
voL. xxm.
parture, tn MOy from the British constitu-i
tion. I will say no more ; I await your sen-
tence.
Lord HenderUnd. — My lords, this panel
has stated the very same objections that he
stated yesterday, except one, which -states
that there were strangers with the witnesses
in the other room ; and, if it was so, the of^
ficer who had the charge of them may be culU
pable and punishable ; because it is contrary
to the custom of the court. But, my lords^
to say that it shall annul a verdict, or stay
judgment, does not appear to me to be at aU
the practice. It is impossible for the Court
but to proceed upon tne verdict ; and I must
give my opinion upon this head, that it is not
a valid objection.
Lord Eikgraoe, — My lords, the panel now
at the bar had more induUpence than tho
Court ever gave a panel berore, because he
was a stranger.
My lords, I cannot help taking notice ol
an in»nuation, on the part of die panel, to
the Court, by threats of impeachment, and
threats of bemg brouebt upon our knees, or
suffering the pams of death. I am happy the
panel has not thought fit to renew that Ian*
guage to-day ; yet f would not sit altogethei
upon this trial, without signifying my opi-
nion, that if it had not been, that we held in
contempt insinuations of threats to us, thai
are illegal, so, on the other hand; we will
submit to every appeal that is competent ; if
there is any superior authority, we will rea-
dily submit to their decisions. But, my lords^
it is not for this man, or any man, to think
to terrify this country into a subversion of
justice. Had he been a native of this coun*
try, he would not have been suffered to gO'Oa
as he did. I approve of his conduct to-day^
which is more temperate ; but, for the sake
of others who might be here yesterday, and
some who may hear of it, I will say> that It
is not the right of any prisoner to go out of
his defence, and attack the Court, who are
able to defend themselves when the attack i$
made.
I was of opinion, with my brothers, upoo
the objections yesterday, and therefore it is
not to be supposed I should not be of the
same opinion to-day, unless something new
had been urged. The objection as to the
lord justice general was fuMy answered yes-
terday, and does not deserve any notice. A$
to the question put to vour lordship not being
answered, it was not because of your being a
judge in this court, but because of their be-
ing irrelevant to his defence.
As to his objection of a stranger being ad-
mitted with tlie witnesses, I am sorry that
any such thing should happen. He may have
been sent from either party, or he might li&vc
no connexion with any party ; but it is a
strange thing to suppose, that such an acci-
dent should make null and void all the pre-
ceedinss of this Court agaimt this pane) ;
and 1 am the more surprised^t that objectieii
771] S4 GEOttGE III. Prweeedings againd Maurice Margaroi {773'
being made, on accmint of his being a native
of Bngland, where he must well know, that
it is toe general practice that the witnesses
are not at all inclosed, but they are in court
during the time of the trial ; not but we al-
low that it is sometimes ordered otherwise by
the Court, and in this case it seems to have
been by accident. It does not appear at all
that he was tampering with the witnesses ;
and therefore no blame lies upon the Court;
and it is needless to seek any redress in the
way in which it has this day been done from
this Court.
Lord Swintan. — ^My lords, the only new ob-
iection b, that a person of the name of Car-
lisle was admitted among the witnesses. If
that was valid, the objection is now too late.
It ought to have been made when they were
brought to be examined.
My lord, every witness, in a most solemn
manner, was sworn and asked upon oath,
whether he was instructed or taught as to the
evidence he was to give, and an answei was
made by every witness upon oath, that he
was not ; and therefore, if there was any
thing in the objection, it is done away by
that ; and therefore it is my opiniou, tfaiat it
should be repelled.
' Lord DttNnnnaii.—- I am of the same opi-
nion, and I do not think it necessary to enter
any farther into it.
Lord Abercromfne, — I am of the same opi-
nion.
Lord Jwstice Clerk. — I am entirely of the
•ame opinion; and I will tell the panel, that
if the Court were to sustain the objection, it
would not avail him as an absolutary from
the crime with which he is charged ; even if
it* would make null and void all we proceed-
ings ; because he would be liable to be tried
over again.
He must be convinced, that he has had a
fair trial ; he went on for four hours in his
defence; he is a stranger in this country, and
fiot having counsel, we allowed him to go on
in a manner in which we would not have per-
mitted a native of Scotland. He went on for
font hours in such a way, as was contrary to
the constitution of the country, and your
lordships will now proceed in givmg your opi-
nions upon what shall be the result of this
•Terdict.
Lord Henderland, — My lords, the jury hav-
ing discharged their duty to their country, by
a patient hearing of this trial, after, I am
persuaded, a fail consideration of tne evi-
dence^ it remains for the Court to consider
what may he an adequate punishment of the
crime he stands charged with.
My lords, the crime of which he has been
found guilty is sedition^ and, as it is detailed
in the minor proposition, taking an active
and distinguished part in the deliberations
* and proceeSinss uf a society, whose meetings
were held un£r pretence of porocuring a re-
form in parliament, but which were oia dan-
gerous and destructive tendency^ with a de-
termined intention to disturb the j^eace of the
community, and to subvert the present oon^
stitution of the countiy. My lord, it is a
most dangerous crime, and most extensive
indeed in its consequences. — It appears in
evidence that this was a convention, forming
themselves into a society, calUng themsetves
' citizens,' ^ sections,* * committees ;* in short,
assuming the form of a French parhament;
thereby showing, that tiiey wished proceed-
ings to take place here of a similar nature ta
those of France. My lords, I fear not the
sword of the enemy, or the pmgnard of the
assassin, while sit^g in my place, discharg-
ing the sacred office of ajudee. I shall nve
my opinion as it strikes my feelings; I snail
nve my sentiments, as they appear to me to
be supported by law. This chai]ge is that of
active sedition ; and the distinction between
this charge, and that of leasing-makin^ is an
imperfect one; for it is to demonstration ca-
pable of being proved^ that, before the union,
there did exist a sedition, eonunitted bv words
in false argument, by attacks upon the con-
stitution, and upon the legislative bodies of
the constitution. It can be denaonstrated, by
the records of this court, that there vras a
common law sedition, different fiom leasin^-
making; and upon which this Court held it-
self competent to found a libel, to iufer an
arbitrary punishment. Therefore, in what>
ever point of view I take the charge against
this man (though I think it amounts to active
sedition), I have no doubt that this Conrt has
power to punish it, by the highest arbitraiy
punishment.
My lords, I doubt not that what I now saj
will be made public. I observe that it is
falsely set forth, in one edition of a late trial,
that I said, it wrung my heart to mention the
crime of sedition. I am in the judgment of
your lordships, and every man who heard
me, I said no such thing — I said, it wrung
my heart (and I own that it did), to see a
gentleman, a young gentleman, who had re^
ceived a gentleman's education, and who had
discovered abilities not inconsiderable, should
be the object of such punishment.
My lords, this eentleman is a stranj^,
and sorry I am that he should have come mta
this country. I regret, as I must do, the
consequences it has bad, and the conduct that
he has assumed. It now becomes my duty,
as a judge, to say what sort of punishmenT
this crime deserves; and, my lords, I knov^
no other way in which I could discbarge my
duty to God, to my country, and to my own
conscience, bst by proposme to your lord-
ships, that this man should be banished
forth of this kingdom by transportation ; «r,
in common language, should be transported
to such part of his majesty's dominions, as
his majestjr, in council, sliall please to ap-
point; and there to remain for the space of
14 years, under pain and penalty of d(Hith,in
case of return.
Lord £<lcgnrae.— My brds, the panel has
77S]
for Seikiotu
A. D. 1794.
[774
been found^ by the verdict of a junr of his
country, guilty of the &ct9 charged against
him. My lords, we yesterday gave our opi-
nions upon the validity of the indictment;
all, in one voice, finding that sedition was a
hi^ crime, by the laws of Scotland. Your
lordships were also of opinion, that the facts
chai^ea and alleged by the public prosecutor,
in the minor proposition, amounted to the
crime of sedition. I will not now repeat what
has been well observed by my lora Uender-
land, who has gone before me, as to the
grounds of that opinion.
My lords, as the case at present stands, I
am sorry this gentleman should have been
guilty of such a crime; but a jury of his
country have found, that he is suilty of the
-charges in this indictment ; and therefore I in
1X0 way differ frqpi your lordship in thinking
that the iury have discharged a duty to their
country ; but, if I had been of another opi-
nion, my duty would have been one and tne
same, which is to pronounce the sentence
of the law upon the person found guilty, by
his country, of the crime charged, and carry-
ing it into execution by a punishment smt-
able to the offence. It is unnecessary to go
through the circumstances of this indictment,
upon all of which the jury have returned a
verdict, finding the prisoner guilty. My
lords, it may amount to the nndinjg him
guilty of leading, as well as assisting, a
number jof people, styling themselves
a sort of parliament in thifi country, for the
purpose, as I stated yesterday^ of subverting
the constitution of the country ; and then
there is a more specific enumeration of facts ;
it. sets forth, that they were to set at defiance
the authority of the legislature ; that even if
an act was moved for, disagreeable to them,
they were to meet in a secret convention;
they thought fit to be concealed, in order to
deliberate upon what was to be done ; they
were likewise to do the same, if there was
an invasion; and what invasion is to be
feared at this time, I leave to the judgment
of every one who hears me. Also, in case
of the landing of foreign troops, for the
support of the government of the country,
that was to be the cause of the sudden meet-
ing of this convention : also, if the Habeas
Corpus act was repealed : and lastly, if any
interruption was given to their meetmgs, this
convention of emergency was to sit. What
conclusion can be drawn firom such language,
but that they meant to subvert the constitu-
tion of the country ; that it was meant to be
carried on in a style of defiance and opposi-
tion to the legislative authority of this coun-
try ? Therefore, it is in vain for any person,
gretendiug to know any thing of the law of
cotland, to say this is merely leasing making.
I shall onljr say, that it would have been
difficult, if it had not been for the alteration
of the statute law, to know whether it would
not have amounted to the crime of high
treason.
My lords, the jury have found this roan
guilty: he is an Englishman; I am sorry
that any of that country should ever have
interfered in the peace and tranquillity, either
of their own country, or of this, which is a
part of the united kingdoms : but I think we
cannot pronounce a less sentence in this case,
than in the former cases ; and if any differ-
ence is to be made, 1 do not think it is in
favour of this defendant, who in his own
country might have lived peaceably and
3uietly. My lords, there can be no sort of
oubtwith regard to the powers of the Court:
by the laws of this country, before the act oi
1708, banishment from the realm of ^t-
land was one thing, and banishment to a
place beyond seas was another; and these
were as well known at that time as at this.
But, my lords, is it proper that a person from
England, being found guilty of attempts to
subvert the constitution, is it reasonable that
we should return him to England, in order
that he may continue his practices there if so
incUned ? If we were not able to do more,
we could not help it ; but, I say, the power
of banishment, b^ transportation, has been
long recognized m Scotland, as well as in
Ensland. The court can do no less than
make use of the power which the law gives
them, to send him to a place where he can
do no harm. My lords, if I had any doubt
about it, your judgment in the case of Mr.
Muir, where I was not present, but where
the other judges uniformly gave their opinion,
that this mode of banishment, by transporta*
tion, was the proper punishment for such an
offence ; that would be sufficient for me to
concur in the same opinion. If that punish*
ment was not too much for Skirving, the
secretary to this convention, who appears to
be a simple deluded man, it cannot be too
much for this gentleman, who is, so far as I
can judge, a man of abilities, of considerable
knowledge, and one who took the lead in
this convention; and therefore I concur in
the punishment mentioned by your lordship.
Lord Smnton, — My lords, I have no diffi-
culty in concurring with your lordships in
the pimishinent you have suggested; and,
after what has been said by your lordships,
I shall only take notice of a very few things.
My lords, the crime of sedition is worse m
one respect than most other crimes : many
other crimes are committed from the sudden
impulse of passion or lieat : but this crime
is conunitted with a premeditated, felonious
intention, by deliberating upon the means of
overturning our constitution. They begin
with seditious and inflammatory discourses,
endeavouring to draw simple and perhaps
well meauing people af^er tnem, by pointing
out imperfections which will be in everjr go-
vernment whatever, and placing them in a
strong light; and, in the next place, by sedi-
tious writings. My lords, in this case the
delegates meet, and they appoint a conven*
tion of emei^gency ; juad what are these con-
775] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings mgainsi Maurice Margarat [775
ventions of emer^nty} first of all, for the
purpose of over-«win^ parliament; and one
of their resolutions is, U> pay no reeard to
such an act of parliament, if it should pass;
that is, they despise the legislative authority
of the country. Then, in the case of an
invasion; and it is easy to see what sort of
an invasion was meant. I decline gpine
through all the other particulars of this libel,
which is found to be a true libel in eveiy
point.
My lords, what have they petendedf
They have pretended a reformation in the
constitution. I say, my lords, there is no
need for it ; our constitution reforms itself
With regard to trial by jury, which is the
palladium, in my memory three acts have
been brought in ror reforming this point ; one
lately, giving juries a power to decide upon
the wh^e matter, in case of libel;* and we
bavc no need of such reformers as these.
My lords, if there i;* any difference between
this case and tiiat uf others, the crime of
this man is highly aggravated ; he is not of
tilts country ; he does 'not feel any hardship
fr«m the government of this country; he
eomes from England for seditious purposes,
as stated in this indictmerit; and therefore,
If there is any distinction in this case, it is
milavourable to this panel. I am of opinion,
with your lordships, that transportation for
Iburteeu years is the proper punishment.
Lord i>ii nsin no n.— My lords, after the most
Eiient hearing of this case by a jury, they
ve come to that determination which sen-
sible, honest men alone could come to;
Bamely, finding this panel guilty. There is
no doubt but ne has been sent into this
country, in order to disseminate sedition;
and it is evident that he was very sedulous
in the execution of that office. The jury hav-
ing found a verdict of guilty, it comes to the
court to consider what punishment this crime
deserves ; and, my lords, though it is not
pleasant to pass judgment upon a fellow-sub-
ject, crimes^ dangerous as these, cannot be
overlooked.
My lords, I am of opinion that this man's
guilt b ags;ravated beyond that of others,
who have been in the same circumstances ;
and that transportation for fourteen years is
the proper punishment.
Lord Abcrcrombie. — My lords, it has been
jtKtly observed, that during the course of the
trial, the panel now at the bar met with an
tincommon share of indulgence; I believe
fkr beyond what any court of justice, either
in this or any other countr>*, ever a£R>rded a
panel. My lords, I do not feel, and never
•hall feel myself disposed to say one word to
load any man, who stands in the unhappy
situation that he does ; but I am sorry to
observe, that from the moment he appeared
at the bar, till the instant he was earned out,
fab whole conduct was of the most indecent
• Stat. ^ G. 3d, c.
vol. 99; p. 306.
kind. My lords^ the crime with which be
stands charged, and of which he b fomid
guilty by the unanimous voice of his country,
upon the most satis^tory evidence, is that
of sedition ; and my lords, his crime is highly
aggravated by one circumstance, which ap*
peared in the course of the trial, that he has
Deen stirring up sedition in this country, nod
instigating such unhappy men, as you saw-
here yesterday — ^for example, one of the
members of the British convention, who
was so ignorant of the constitution of his
own country, that he was oblised to admit
that he never so much as reaa the claim of
rights. My lords, b it to such men as these
that we are to resort, to get a redress of the
grievances of this country ?
My lords, if we are to judge of the means
he made use of from his speeches in the
minutes of the convention, and the speech
which we heard last night, sure I am, tbat
his intention was to stir up a spirit of disaf-
fection and discontent among the ignorant
and the uninformed ; and, my lords, I con-
sider the circumstance of thb panel being a
stran^r to this country as an aggravation of
his crime.
My lords, this society called themselves
originally the Friends of the People ; th^
aflerwards changed their name, calling them-
selves the British Convention of Delegates,
associated to obtain Universal Suffrage and
Annual Parlbments; a right which the sub-
jects of this country never did enjoy ; such a
right would tend to bring niin ai.d destruc-
tion upon tins country. I say, my lords, that
to this man they owed that change, and that
form which they assumed, and of which we
have heard so much.
My lords, I shall only add, that the pu-
nishment proposed is the mildest, wluch,
under all the circumstances of the case,
oueht to be pronounced.
Lord Justice Clerk.— Mj k>rds, after the
full discussion which this crime has under-
gone, within these three montl^ I shall
only just observe, that the crime of which
this panel is accused, and now stands con-
victed by the verdict of a most respectable
jury of this country, is sedition; — endea-
vouring to overturn the established govern-
ment of this country, which i% of all crimes
known amongst mankind, of the most hei-
nous nature and the most dangerous ten-
dency to society, and w^ell merits the high-
est arbitrary punbhroent that thb Court can
possibly inflict
You have had two trials before yoo, one
within these few months, in which the panel
was condemned to txansportation for 14 years,
and the other you condemned within these
few days for the same term. The moment I
heard the verdict I revolved in my own mind
the circumstances attending this case ; but it
IS impossible Umt we can, apeeably to the
justice of the countiT, infliict a less ponish-
mem; the only doubt thai occuned to me
777]
for SedHiofu
A. D. 1794.
{778
yna^ whether we ought not to go farther ; for
I did see a material difference; this case
hetog attended with circumstances highi^
aggratated and offensive to the laws of this
<iountiy. If this country suffers any griev-
ances, I am sure he fen none of them : he
lives not in Scotland ; has no property there ;
and, as a strancer, he comes into this coun-
try a man with a great deal of ahilities and
great elocution, — he comes here for the ex-
press purpose of disseminating sedition ad^ong
the lower order of people in this cpuntry, I
cannot consider it as any thing but sedition
highly aggravated. I did think that this
crime deserved a more severe punishment;
hut I have always more pleasure in inflicting
a mild punishment than a more severe one ;
and as your lordships are all of opinion, that
We should inflict the same puiushment as in
the case of Skirving and Muir, I concur in
the same opinion, that he shall be transported
lor the term of 14 years, with the usual
certification.
SSKTEMCE.
Tlie lord justice clerk and lords commis-
flioners of justiciary havmg considered the
foregoing verdict^ whereby the assize all in
one toiee find the panel guilty of the crimes
libelled : the Said lords, in respeet of the
said verditt, in terms of an act passed in the
35th year of his present majesty, intituled an
" Act for the more eflectual transportation of
felons and other off^ders, in that part of
Great Britain called Scotland," ordain and
adjudge, that the said Maurice Marsarot be
transported beyond seas, to such place as
his majesty, with the advice of his privy
council, shall declare and appoint; and that
for the space of fourteen years fW>m this
date; vritn certification to him, if, after being
so trahsported, he shall return to, and be
found at large within any part of Great Bri-
tain, durinv the said fourteen years, without
some lawful cause, and be thereby lawfolly
convicted, he shall suffer death, as in cttseh
of fok)ny, without bet^efit of clergy, hv the
law of England : and ordains the said Mau-
rice Margarot to be carried back to the Tol-
booth of Edinburgh, therein to be detained
till he is delivered over for being so trans-
ported ; for which this shall be, to all con-
cerned^ a sufficient wamnt.
(Signed) ROBEftt M^QtrESK.
Mr. Jfor^arwf .— My lords, I thank you.
598. Proceedings before the High Court of Justiciary at Edin-
burgh^ in the Gase of Charl£s Sikclair^^ on an Indictment
exhibited against him by the Lord Adfocate of Scotland^
and charging him with Sedition^ February 17th^ 34tb,
March 10th, 14th : 34 George III. a. d. 1794.
-CarlaL Justiciaria S. D. N. Regis tenta in
Nova Sessionis donio de Edinburgh,
decimo septimo die Februarii, millesimo
septingentesirao et nonagesimo quarto,
per honorabiles viros Robertum Mac-
Queen de Braxfield, Dominum Justicia-
rium Clericum, Davidem Rac de Esk-
gove, Joannem Swinton de Swinton,
ominom Oulielmum Naime de Dun-
sinnan, baronetum, et Alexandrum Abcr-
crombie de Abcrcrombie, Dominos Com-
missionarios Justiciarise dicti S. D. N.
Hegis.
Curia legitime affirmata.
Intrmnf
Vharlet Sinclairj residing or lately residing
at the Black Bull Inn, head of Leith Wal^
in the parish of St. Cuthbert's, and county
of Edinburgh, panel.
Indicted and accused at the Instance of
Robert Dundas, esquire, of Amiston, his
inajesty^s advocate for his majesty's interest,
*■! ■■■ Will— ^— ■■ -■■■■I ■ ■ I ■
** dee the preceding and following catfes.*
for the crime of sedition, in manner Inen-
tioned in the criminal libel raised against
htm tbereanent, bearing, that where by the
laws of this, and every well-governed realm,
sedition is a crime of an heinous nature, ana
severely punishable; yet true it is and of
verity, that the said Charles Sinclair has
presumed to commit, and is guilty actor, or
art and part of the said crime ; in so far as
a number of seditious and evil-disposed per-
sons having illegally assembled at Edinburgh
durine the months of October, November,
and December, in the year one thousand
seven hundred and ninety-three, the said
Charles Sinclair, above compluned upon,
did repair to Edinbur^h^ with the wicked ana
felonious purpose of jominz and co-operating
with the said persons, and did accordingly
become a member of the association fonnea
by them, which originally did bear the name
of •• The General Convention of the friends
of the People,*^ but which thereafter pre-
sumptuously and sieditiously assumed the
designation of " The British Convention of
the Delegates of the People, associated to
obtain Univerad Suffinge and Annual Parlia-
779]
S4 GBOfiGB UL
Proceedings agmnsi Charlei Sinclair
[780
ments." And wbich illegal usodation, under
the names and designatipns aforesaid, did*
dining the months aforesud, hold various
seditious and illegal meetings at a room or
mason lodge in Blackfiriars Wvnd, in the
city of Edinburgh and county of Edinburgh,
and elsewhere to the public prosecutor un>
known ; which meetings, thoueh held under
{iretence of procuring a reform in par-
iament, did evidently in the whole ronn
and manner of their procedure, as well
as in the principles they publicly, avowed
and propagated, clearly and unequivocally
demonstrate that their purposes were of the
most dangerous and destructive tendency,
hostile to the peace and happiness, and
tending to subvert the constitution of this
T£alm ; imitating in the form and tenour of
their proceedings, the convention of France,
^e public and avowed enemies of this coun-
tiy, and with whom Great Britain then was
and still is at war ; the members of the said
meetings calling each other by the name of
eititen; dividing themselves into sections^
receiving reports from said sections, some oi
which bear to be dated from Liberty Court,
Liberty Stairty Liberty Hall, Firtt Year of
the Britiih Canventionf one and intUviiible,
and some of which have Vive la Convention^
prefixed to them, and end with ga ira, in-
stituting primary societieSy provincial astem^
hliety and departments, appointing committees
of various kinds, such as of organization, of
instructioM, finance, and secrecy, denominat-
ing their meetings tittingt; granting honours
i)! sittings, and mscribing their minutes the
First Year of the British Convetition, and
making honourable mention in the minutes of
patriotic donations. And moreover, the
members of the said seditious association,
under the designations aforesaid, did, at
times and places above mentioned, make
harangues and speeches, as well as motions
and resolutions, of a seditious tcndenc^r^ the
substance of all which* was under their au-
thority, at least with their knowledge and
approbation, not only minuted^but published
in a newspaper, intituled '* The Edinburgh
Gazetteer," and through that medium circu-
lated amons the lieges. And the said Charles
Sinclair, above complained upon, was not
onlv present at the foresaid illegal meetings,
and. approved of the seditious resolutions and
whole procedure made and had tliere, but
was himself an active member of the said
illegal and seditious association, and did at
times sit as president thereof; was a member
of the committees and sections of the same,
and assisted therein ; and did himself wick-
edly and feloniously make motions, and utter
speeches both of an inflammatory and sedi-
tious tendency: and particularly, the said
Charles Sinclair did, upon the twenty-third
day of November, one thousand seven hun-
dred and ninetv-three, or some one or other
of the days of* that month, or of the months
aforesaid at Edinburgh, and within the room
or mason's lodg^ aforesaid, wickedly and
seditiously make the foUowinc motion, or
one of a similar import and tenoency. '' That
the said meeting should henceforth be called
the British Convention of Dele^les of the.
People, associated to obtain Universal Suf-
frage and Annual Parliaments"— which mo-
tion was unanimously adopted by the said
meeting or association. Anu thereafter, up^
the same day, and at the place aforesaid,
the said Charles Sinclair did wickedlv and
feloniously address himself to the said asso-
ciation or meeting in a speech to the follow-
ing or similar import : —
** I believe there are none here who have
not felt Uie most lively sensations of joy
and affection on partaking in the solemn
transaction which has just now taken
place, but let us not neelect those who
are afBicted in a neighbouring country
— let us remember our brethren in Ire-
land. Thev have a sham parliament,
which lords it over them, and they
cannot have the pleasure oi^ meeting as
we do now: I nave therefore drawn
up the following motion respecting
them, which I shall now read to the
convention."
'' The JBrifisA convention of delegates of the
Feople associated to obtain universal
suffrage and annual parliaments, takins
into their consideration the oppressea
state of their brethren in Ireland, and
the unconstitutional act of the last ses-
sion of the parliament of that kingdom,
called the convention act; and seeing
with indignation, that by it the people or
Ireland were deprived of those rights,
cheaply purchased with the blood of our
common ancestors, and which are con-
firmed and secured tons by the great char-
ter of our liberties, resolved,
'' That all or any of the patriotic members
of the society of united Irishmen of Dub-
lin, shall be admitted to speak and vote
in this convention/'
And which motion having been discussed
by the said meeting;, or association, upon the
twenty-fifth day ofthe said month of Novem-
ber, or some one or other of the days or
months aforesaid, and at the place aforesaid,
the same was agreed to ana "guaranteea
by a solemn joining of hands ; it being fol-
lowed by a motion for transmitting the above
resolution to citizen Archibald Hamilton
Rowan, which passed accordingly. '' And
further, at a meeting of the said association,
upon the said twenty-fiflh day of the said
month of November, or upon some one or
other of the days of that month, or. of the
months aforesaid, Alexander Callender, one
ofthe members of the said meeting, having,
at the place aforesaid, made the following
motion, or one of a similar tendency, viz.*—
<< That in case the minister, or any other
member of either House of Parliament, bring
forward a motion for leave to bring in a cpn-
t81]
fyr SedUiotr.
A. D. 1794.
[782
ventioii bill, such as has passed in Irelattd,
to prerent the ]>eople from meeting according
to their just riehts by the revolution, the
same motion shall be notice to the delegates
to meet in convention, to assert their rights."
The said motion was made the subject of
discussion in the said meeting, within the
room or mason lodse aforesaid, upon the
twenty-seventh day of the said month of No-
vember, or on some one or other of the days
of that month, when the said Charles Sin-
clair, above complained upon, did wickedly
and feloniously propose sundry amendments
thereto, of a wicked and seditious tendency ?
And the said motion, with the amendments
thereupon proposed by him or others, havina|
been by the said meeting referred to the said
Charles Sinclair and some others of the mem-
bers of the said meeting, as a committee to
draw up a motion from the whole, the said
Charles Sinclair, above complained upon, did,
upon the twenty-eighth day of the said month
or November, or on one or other of the days
of that montJi, or of the months aforesaid,
within the room, or mason's lodge aforesaid,
wickedly and feloniously read to the said ille-
gal meeting, when there assembled, the
amendments upon the foresaid motion, as
agreed upon by him and the said committee,
when the said illeeal and seditious meeting,
^id wickedly and feloniously, then and there,
solemnly and unanimously come to a resolu-
tion of the following import or tenour *. —
** That this convention considering the ca-
lamitous conseauences of any act of the
legislature whioi may tend to deprive the
whole, or any part of the people of their
undoubted right to meet either by them-
selves or by delegation, to discuss any
matter relative to tneir common interest,
whether of a public or private nature, and
holding the same to be totally inconsis-
tent with the first principles and safety
of society, and also subversive of our
known and acknowledged constitutional
liberties, do hereby declare before God
and the world, that we shall follow the
wholesome example of former times, bv
paying no regard to any act which shall
militate against the constitution of our
country ; and shall continue to assemble,
and consider of the best means by which
we can accomplish a real representation
of the people, and annual election, until
compelled to desist by superior force/'
And we do resolve
^ Tliat the first notice given for the intro-
duction of a convention bill, or any bill
of a similar tendency to that passed in
Ireland in the last session of their par-
liament, or any bill for the suspension
t of the Habea$ Carpus act or the act
for preventing wrongous imprisonment,
and against undue delays in trials in
North Britain ; ' or in case of an inva-
* sion ;' or the admission of any foreign
troops whatsoever into Great Britain or
t
Ireland; all or any one of these calami-
tous circumstances, shall be a signal to
the difierent delegates to repair to such'
place as the secret committee of this
convention shall appoint ; and the first
seven members shall have power to de-
clare the sittings permanent ; and twen*
ty-one shall constitute a convention, and
•proceed to business.
** The convention doth therefore resolve.
That each delegate immediately on his
return home, do convene his const! tuents*
and explain to them the necessity or
electing a delegate or delegates, and of
establishing a fund without aelay, aj^nst
any of these emergencies, for his or
their expenses, and that they do instruct
the said delegate or delegates to hold
themselves ready to depart at one hoar's
warning."
And further at the same time, and witlw
in the same place, after the foresaid re-
solution had been so made, a motion was
made in the said meeting in the following
words, or in words of a similar im|>ort ana
tendency: — ** That a secret committee of
three, and the secretary, be appointed to de-
termine the place where such convention of
emergency shall meet, that such place
shall remain a secret with them, and with
the secretary of this convention; and that
each delegate shall, at the breaking up of the
{(resent session, be entrusted with a sealed
etter, containing the name of the place of
meeting. This letter shall be delivered un-
opened to bis constituents, the receipt of
which shall be acknowledged by a letter to
the secretary, preserved m the same stale
until the perioo shall arrive at which it shall
be deemeo necessary for the delesate to set
oiF.^'— The said meeting did wickedly and se-
ditiously unanimously approve of the said
motV>n.— And at a subsequent meeting npon
the fourth day of December, one thousand
seven hundred and ninety- three, or upon one
or other of the days of that month, or upon
one or other of the days of the months afore-
said, and within the said room or mason-
lodge aforesaid, it having been moved by one
of the members then present, — *^ That the
moment of any illegal dispersion of the pre-
sent convention, shall be considered as a
summons to the delegates to repair to' the
place of meeting, appointed for the conven-^
tion of emergency ty the secret committee,
and that the secret committee be instructed
to proceed without delay to fix the place of
meeting."— The said meeting did unammously
resolve the same, and appointed a secret
committee to proceed as aesired. And the
said Charlefl^Sinclair, above complained upon,
having been apprehended upon the fifth of
December, one thousand seven hundred and
ninety-three, in consequence- of a warrant
issued by the sherifi' of Edmburgh; and
having been carried before" Harrv Davidson^
e9quire| sheriff bubstitute of the sirure of Edin-
783] 34 GEORGE lit Proceedings agasMd Ckarles Simdair
(78*
bur||^ on the flcventh day of the sud month
of {WcembeTy one thousand seven hundred
and ninety-three, did, in hb presence, emit a
declaration^ of which, part is signed by the
laid Charl^ Sinclair, wiod the whole signed
by the said Harry Davidson. And sundry
papers having been found in the possession of
the said Charles Sinclair, when ajpprehended,
and the same having been afterwards in-
snecied in his presence, and in presence of
tna said sheriff substitute, upon itih said se-
venth of December, one thousand seven
hundred and ninety-thre«, an inventory of
the same was made up, which is subscribed
by the said sheriff substitute. Which inven-
tory, together with the whole papers con-
tained therein, consisting of twenty-one arti-
deSy as also the foresaid declaration, eoutted
by the said Charles Sinclair, before the she-
nff substitute of Edinburgh, as also copies of
numbers 78, 79, and 80, of the newspaper
called— << The Edinburgh Gazetteer."— Also
the scroll or draught of Uie minutes of the said
general convention,* from the twenty-ninth
of October, to the fourth of December, one
thousand seven hundred and ninety-three,
consisting of ninety-five pages, and found in
the custody of William Skirving, secretary to
the Sfldd convention^ when apprehended by
warrant of the sheriff of Edintuirgh, in the
month of December last, being number first
of the inventory of papers, found in the said
WiUiar^ Skirvine's possession when appre-
hended, and made up in presence of theshe-
liff substitute of Eoinburgh, upon the fifth
d^y of the said month of December, also the
inventory itself, with the whole of the other
papers and writings therein contained : And
also two inventories made up before the she-
riff substitute of Edinburgn, on the seventh
day pf December last, of sundry papers found
in the possession of Joseph Gerrald, and
Maurice Margaret, two members of the said
convention, when apprehended in conse*
quence of a warrant from the sheriff of Ediri-
burgh, one of which inventories, consisting of
ten articles, subscribed by William Scot, pro.-
curator fiscal of the county of Edinburgh, and
the said Joseph Ocrrald, and the other con-
sisting of nine articles, subscribed by the said
William Scot, and the sheriff substitute of
Edinbureh, together with the whole articles
contained in Uie said two inventories, es-
cepting number first, being all to be used in
evidence against the said Charles Siuclair,
will, for that purpose, in due time^ be lodged
in the hands of the clerk of the high court of
judiciary, before which he is to be tried, that
lie may have an opportunity of seeing the
same, at least, times and places above-men-
tioned, the said acts of sedition were com-
mitted, and the said Charles Sinclair is guilty,
actor, or art, and part thereof,— -all which, or
part thoraof, heing found proven by the ver-
*4oe the case of William SKirvmg, page
391 of this volume.
diet of an assise, before our hud juMkegoMT
ral, lord justice clerk, and lords commiisien»
ers of justiciary, in a court of justiciary. It be
holden by them within the criminal ceurt*
house of Edinburgh, upon the seventeenth
day of February instant, the said Chariea
Sinclair above complained upon, ought to be
punished with the pains of law^ to deier
others from committing the like crimes, inaU
time coming.
The libel being read over in open court,
and the panel being interroeslsd thereupon^
he answered he was Not Guuty.
Pr&rtfitr the Prosecutor. — Robert Dundag,
of Amiston, esq. his majesty's advocate.
Mr. Robert Blair, aavocate, his majesty's
solicitor-general; and
Mr. Jamet Montgomery, advocate.
ProVf for the PaM^— The bon. Eemry
EnkiiUf dean of faculty ; and
Mr. Archibald Fletcher ^ advocate.
Mr. Fletcher, the junior counsel for the
panel, commenced by observing, that after
the judgments which the Court had already
given on the relevancy of hbels similar to the
present, it might ^pear presumptuous in hia
now to offer any objection upon the poiAt of
relevancy ; but he requested the Court to re-
collect that in the former cases decided ia
this court, the panels had not the aid of coui^
sel, from which it happened that the otyeo-
tions in law which he was now to state had
not been brought under the view of Uie Court.
He farther observed, that without regard to
this circumstance, it was both his du^ and
his right, in behalf of his clieAt, to state
every competent objection to the relevancy,
in the same manner as if this were the very
first instance in which the question came un-
der the consideration of their lordships.
On the merits of the case itself, he con-
tended, that in the criminal justice of every
free country, it is an inflexible rule, that in
every libel on which any person is brought
to trial, the law on which be is to be punish-
ed, and the nature of the crime of wnkh he
is accused, ought to be expressed with clear-
ness and precision, in oraer to enable him
with advantage to come prepared to defend
himself against the accusation ; but in the pre-
sent libel this essential rule of criminal justice
is violated at least in two very important par-
ticulars : for 1st. the libel is vague and uncer-
tain with respect to the law, in virtue of which
the panel is to be tried and punished : in-
asmuch as it had not informed the panel whe-
ther he was to be tried by the statute law, or
by the common law pf the land. Sdly. The
libel is uncertain or ambijguous, with respect
to the species of crime oi which the panel is
accused. It states in general that ** sedition
is a crime/' but does not mention in the ma-
jor proposition of what species of the crime
the panel is accused, whether of verbal or of
real sedition. He fitfther observed, that the
libel Mras Mocertain eTenwith re^ectlo the
fm
Jbr Sedition.
A. D. 1794.
[786
fvmUkBomi; henane from it the pai^el could
ikot know whether he was to undergo the
puaiihnwnt of verbal sedition bj the act
1706^ which was only arbitrary ; or whether
he was to sufier the punishment of real sedi^
tion, which was punishable, as treason, bj
death. He then contended, that to send a
Mbol of this kind, attended with so much am-
higuitr and uncertainty in its structure, to the
knowledge of an assize, was inconsistent with
ib» boasted freedom of our constitution, and
a^jualljr inconsistent with the chaiucter of cri-
mmal iustice in erery free country.
In this situation, therefore^ it must be ar-
gued on the fiicts as stated in the minor pro-
Ksition. The panel is only charged with
▼ing attended meetings, where he made
haransues^d to tend to the raising of sedi-
tion^ but without having actually produced
any commoUons, or rising of the jpeoide, to
obstruct the reeular execution of me law.
Now the hcta toere stated when duly consl-
teed can amount to nothing^ more than ver*'
kal seditioii, or leasing makmg, and so falls
under the act 1709, sm can be punished only
under that statute. Real sedition consists in
acts, or raising the people to resist the brd'y
nary coarse of law ; and verbal sedition or
leasing making in words only, and so cannot
be blended together, for the law has distin^'
guished between them, and affixed a diflerent
punishment. Now, from the fkcts in the
minor proposition of the present libel, rbal
sedttion cannot be inferred; but compare
them with leasing making, they will be foqnd
precisely to correspond.^*-»Vide act 1434, cbp.
S ; 1565, cap, 60 ; 1584, cap. 184 ; 1585, cap:
10 ; 1595, cap. S09 ; 1609, cap. 9 ; — from all
which it will appear that the offencie chptged
against the panel was only verbal sedition or
Msing making, and of course fell under the
act 1703, which limited the punishment of
that ofienee to fine, imprisonment, and ba-
nishment
^ Mr. Fletcher then entered on an examina^
tkm of the question, what was the meaning
•f the word banUhment used in the act 1708 ;
and he contended, that it meant exile or ex-*
pulsion forth of the kingdom only, exclusive
of the idea of transportation, which last he
maintained never was a punishment of Uie
common law of Scotiand prior to the act 1703.
This- proposition he endeavoured to establish
by arguments drawn from the authority of sir
Geoigo Mackenzie {title punishments] from
the very nature of the jurisdiction of the
courts of common law, which could exercise
no power beyond their own territory, and
from an examination and comparison of 8ev&.
ral statutes before the 1703, particularly one
in 1609, in which it was clear the term ba*
nishment was used as significant of exile or
expulsion forth of the kingdom only, and not
transportation; and which act of 1609 was
ooafirmed by and recited in the act 170S.
Having dwelt for a considerable time on
these various topics of argument^ Mr. Flet-
VOL. XXIII.
cher concluded hj observing, that as the of-
fence charged asainst the panel was leasing
making or verbal sedition, which fell clearly
under the act 1703, regulating the punish-
ment of that offeiice, this, aild the other sta*
tutes referred to in it, ought to have been spe-
cially libelled, according to the uniform prac*
tice of the court in former times, from the
Revolution, down to a very recent date ; and
that on account of this defect of not libelling
the statutes, and the uncertainty of the libel
with respect to the species of crime meant to
be charged, it ought to be found not relevant,
and, that at any rate, the Court, in the judg-
ment on the relevancy, ought to find the libel
relevant only to infer the pains of the act
1703, and to ascertain the meaning of the
term banishment used in that statute, in or-
der that the jury might with certainty know
of what species of crime the panel was ac-
cused, ana what punishment he was to sufier
in the event of his being convicted.
The Solicitor General said, that Mr. Flet-
cher had stated the defence with much abi-
lity and very great propriety. He heartily
concurred with hin^ in the observation he had
made in the outset of his speech, that although
some indictments had been already tried,
worded nearly in similar terms, yet that the
decisions in these cases ought not to be est-
teemed as res judicata against him ; and he
was convinced that if their lordships should
be of opinion, that they had acted improperly
in sending them to the knowledge of an assize^
they would cheerfully correct that mistake in
the present instance. He should, therefotB,
argue the case as if no such proceedings had
taken place. The crime chamd in the nuu-
jor proposition of this indictment is sedition.
Now Mr. Fletcher seemed to object, that w^
ought, not only to have stated sedition to be
a crime, but ought also to have mentioned
the particular law by which it was made pu-
nishable.-—In no case is it necessary where a
libel charges a crime to explain upon whatt
law it is laid. In the case of murder, or of
robbery, for example, it is not necessary to
specify the statute by which they are declared
criminal; but merely to say that they are
crimes by tho laws of this realm.
To give a precise definition of sedition
would be difilcult, perhaps impossible; but I
have no hesitation m.givmg this definition of
it, — ^thatthe act charged nmst be unautho-
rized by law, and niust be done with an in-
tention to disturb the peace of the commu-
nity. Sedition is divided into retd and
9erbaL The fiu:ts charged here amount » to
both verbal and real sedition; and real sedition
of a most atrocious nature. Real sedition
consists in acts to disturb the constitution of
the country^ or to excite others to do so. —
Seditious acts must be capable of being com*
mitted in a variety of ways, indeed so broad
as hardly to admit of a general definition. Mr.
Erskine says, that ^ resu sedition is inferred
from an irregular convocation, of a number of
3 £
787]
34 GEORGE III.
Proceedingt agnnst Charles Sindair
|78»
poople, wiUiout lawful authority, tending to
obstruct or trouble the peace of the commu-
nity ;"* and from perusing the facts stated in
the libel it clearly appears, that the British
Convention held at Edmburgh, assembled for
the glorious purpose of obtadnin^ Universal
Suffrage falls under this veiy definition. — Had
it been accompanied with the rising up of the
people it would have ceased to be sedition, and
would instantly have become high treason.
To show that sir George Mackenzie only
neant to give a particular and not a general
definition of sedition, Mr. Solicitor here read
a quotation from sir George Mackenzie on
one of the acts relative to leasing making,
where he says that sedition is a crime which
receives different degrees of punishment ac-
cording to the degrees of guilt, and that al-
though it was made a capital offence, the
kins's advocate had the power of framing his
libeT so as to restrict it to an arbitrary punish*
inent. I know of no crime, said Mr. Solici-
tor, that deserves to be so severely punished.
It is the forerunner of another and a greater
crime. The regiam mmettatem declares '' le-
ditio regnV to & panished with death, ^^ quia
tangit personam Domini regis*' There are a
number of different gradations from this crime,
which are punished according to the nature
of the offence, by an arbitrary punishment,
•Bd at the head of which, I have no hesita-
ticMD in declaring stands the present
jBome species of these have been taken out
o/ the common law by particular statutes, de-
clared to be hiffh treason, and punished as
such. Oneof&em, — act 1584, << anent the
authority of the estates of parliament,'' very
much resembles the present case. By it, it
is provided, '' that none of the lieges take on
hand to impugn the authority of the said
three estates, under the pain of death.'' That
the British Convention had come to resolu-
tions'yery similar to what was provided against
by this statute, is evident ; for they had re-
solved, ** That in case the minister, or any
other member of either House of Parlia-
ment bring forward a motion for leave to
bring in a convention bill, such as has pass-
ed in Ireland, to prevent the people from
meeting according to their just eights, by the
Revolution, the same motion shall be notice to
the delegates^ to meet in convention to assert
their rights. It is, no doubt, true that the act
I have alluded to, was so far abrogated in the
zeiga of queen Abu ;• and . although it is not
now punishaiblB by 'death, yet it remains a
crime punishable nl - aa arbitxary manner, at
Al^ discretion of the >eourti >. Siedition is well
knotf^xl .and .underiAood in . the. icommon
kw inaependentiiof »tbe -statutes altogether,
'^ftnd was punished accenting to thei. nature of
the offeince,; >< and 'therefore the ckxupf^ tore
made is not, leaaiBg' cmking,- . nor c laid upon
any of the Mtsbut-ai sedition,:^ and i^di-
TvT — V.Ml^^*'
rrrr
I * See £rS)]&iAe'8 .Institutes; lio^jaz, i^^tl?) 4.
ir
tion and leasing malong are by no meanar
synonimous terms.
The defence set up for the paael amoimted
to this, that the facts stated in the minor
proposition, amounted only to leasing making.
The facts do not amount to leasing making,
but to a great deal more. An act may be
leasing making which is not sedition, and
an act may be sedition which is not leasing
making. Supposing a number of persona
shall assemble together in a seditious man-
ner, and solemnly resolve not to pay any at*
tention to the acts of the legisiatinre, and eK««
cite commotions and discontent among ^e
people ; caof any man consider this as leasing
making? surely not. Had I called this leas-'
ing malcing in the indictment, I should have
b^ laughed at.
Mr. Smicitor here adverted to the different
names borrowed by the British, from the
French convention, and said, that ahhough-
the names of citizen, &c. might be innocent
enough in themselves, yet after what we have
seen, after what we have hwd, is it to be
imagined, that any person in this oountty,
suppose reform had been ever so necessary,
would, under the pretence of obtaining a re-
forxn, have been so far lost to the common
feelings of humanity, as to assimilate then:
proceolings to ^ose of the national convene
tion of France, which had] proceeded to such
acts of barbarity, as had disgraced human
nature ; and macfe us almost blush to be men ?
Thb was a conduct which posterity would
scarcely credit.
Mr. Solicitor then read a resolution of the
convention, upon a motion brought forwanl
by Mr. Sinclair, upon which they ** solemmfy
and unanimousfy' came to a resohition of me
following import or tenour:
^' That this convention, considerii^ the
calamitous consequences of any act of the
legislature which may tend to deprive the
whole, or any part of the people, of^their un-
doubted right to meet, eimer by themselves
or by delegation, to cUscuss any matter rela-
tive to their common interest, whether of a
public or private nature, and holding the
same to be totally inconsistent with the firat
principles and safety of society, and also sub-
versive of our known and acknowledged con-
stitutional liberties, do hereby declare, befoie
God and the world, that we shall follow the
wholesome example of former times, b^ pay-
ing no regard to any act, which shall mibtate
against the constitution of our country.; am)
^hall continue to assemble, and consider of
the best means by which we can accomplish
a real representation of the people, and an-
nual election, until compelled to deuU by t»^
perior force ;
" And we do resolve
<' That the first notice given for the intro*
duction of a convention bill, or any bill of a
similar tendency to that passed in Ireland,
in the last session of parliament; or any bill
for the suspension of the Eabea$ Corpus act.
I
789]
Jbr Sedition,
A. D. 1794.
[790
•r the act for previenting wrongous imprison-
ment, and a^nst undue delays in trials in
North Britain; or in case of invasion; or
the admission of any foreign troops whatso-
ever into -Great Britain, or Ireland ; aJl, or
any one of these calamitous circumstances,
shall he a signal to the difierent delegates, to
repair to such place as the secret committee
of this convention shall appoint; and the
first seven merohers shall have power to
ieclave the rittingi permanent; and twenty-
one shall constitute a convention, and pro-
ceed to business. The convention doth there-
§are resolve, that each delegate, immediately
on. his return home, do convene his consti-
tuents, and explain to them the necessity of
electing a delegate, or delegates, and of es-
tabliahmg a fund, without delay, gainst any
of these emergencies, for his or their expense;
and that they do instruct the said delegate,
or delegates, to hold themselves re»dy to
depart at one hour's warning/'
Is this resolution leating making f^^A re-
solution of the most audacious nature ! — A re-
solution to contemn the acts of the legislaturei
Supposing parliament should pass any such
acV this was to he a signal to these men to
assemble. What would have been the con-
sequence^ Ilad not this conspiracy, — I can
call it by no other name,o*been checked in
the hud, by the humanity of the civil magis-
trate, these men would now have been tned
for high treason, instead of sedition, and
then the penalty of their crime would have
been paid by the forfeiture of their lives : or,
had they been allowed to carry their schemes
into execution with success, then might Bri-
tain have bidden adieu to peace, and Si those
inestimable blessings ana nrivilefles which
ve at present enjoy, and hold so dear. Al-
though the panel had only been charged with
leasing making, under the act 1703, it would
not have made the smallest difference. Un-
der that acty your lordships have the power
of inflicting the punishment of transportation,
if you think the circumstances require it At
first view, to a person, not acquainted with
the law of Scotland, some doubt might arise
with respect to this. Prior to that period,
two different species of banishment were in
use; ontjwihqfthe kingdamf the other to
a particular place : such was the practice at
passioK the act 170S. If sir George Macken-
zie said that the latter species of oanishment
was not introduced into our common law, he
must have been grossly mistaken. A power
of transportation is inherent in the Court,
and recognized by the act 1701 : by that fa^
moua act, — an act made for the purpose of
increasing the liberty of the subject, — it is de-
clared that no person shall be transported,
wiikout the $etUence ^ a legal court. There
was no statute for transportation before that
Eviod, but there was a power at common
w to inflict that punishment. The act 1703,
abrogates the capital punbhment yinMid leas-
ing makings and dedares it to be punished
by banishroent; but as there were two dif«-
ferent modes of banishment then in use, and
as there was nothing to limit the signification
to one of them, it must be understood to
extend to both. It is impossible to imagine,
that when the legislature saw the court of
justiciary banishing people to the East In*
dies, if they wished to restrict it, they would,
in doing so, employ the very word used by
the court of justiciary in these sentences.
That the banishment mentioned in the act
1703 fi>r leasing making, unquestionably was
understood to mean transportation, may be
seen in a Hriety of cases about that time ;
and in particular in the case of David Baillie,*
who was indicted before the privy council of
Scotland (a court possessing very great
jurisdiction) in February 1704, no more than
five montbs alter the act 1703 passed for the
crime of leasing making; he was convicted
and sentenced to be pilloried and transported
to the East or West Indies. And from the
sederunt, it appears that both the lord presi-
dent of the session, the lord justice clerk,
and all the great people of the law were pre-
sent; and the panel was assisted by six able
counsel.
Although it is not common for lawyers to
pledge their characters to their opimons in
points of law, as counsel might firequently
differ on that head, yet in this case I do not
hesitate, in the most explicit manner, to as-
sert it as my positive opinion, that this act
allowed transportation;, and I am certain,
that if such a question occurred in a civil
case, no counsel woidd venture an opinion,
that the act did not extend to both the species
of banishment then in use.
The Lord Advocate. — Although this ques-
tion has been so ably and eloquently stated
on the part of the prosecution, I cannot re*
frain from saying a few words, as the point
is yet to be argura by the first abilities at the
bar.
If the indictment be ambiguous in its struc-
ture, there is no censure too severe, to which
the public prosecutor is not Uable; but I
trust I shall be able to defend this indictment.
If I have gone wrong, I have done so through
inability to understand the criminal kiw of
this country; and not through precipitancy.
The facts contained in the minor propo-
sition of the indictment, are amply sufficient,
and must certiorate the panel, that the crime
founded on is real sedition. Sir George Mac-
kenzie defines sedition to be, exciting commo*
tion among the people; but I am told, that
there must be not only a commotion, but an
inturrectionj to constitute real sedition. This
doctrine is inconsistent with law, and a so-
lecism in common sense, for the moment it
arrives that length, it loses the name of se-
dition, and amounts to high treason. Se«
dition is a crime of a different die, although
perhaps not differing in its nature from that
• See his case, ant^ VoL U, p. 103&.
791]
S4 GEORGE m.
ProceedifigM ogaiM CkarUi StneUAr
[Tfll
oftreasoiiy to whkh H ahimately and necea-
sahly tends. It is an actual commotion of
the people — a course of proceedings of an il-
legal kind, exciUng the people to molest and
jd^turb the public peace ; and the actual en-
ga^Dg in, and fomenting such commotion,
which constitutes the crime of sedition, and
of iirhich the panel is poaitively, distinctly
and clearly accused. Of this opinion is sir
George Mackenzie ; for he says that if the
object and purpose of the commotion is dif-
ferent, if it tends ad exUium principisy aut
cd mutationem republican it ceases to oe sedi-
tion, and becomes treason : if it does not go
that length, it remains the crime of sedition,
and is punishable as such.
His lordship quoted an opinion, which
stated, that the raising of the people to dis-
turb the peace, and making bonds or leagues
among the people, is sedition. The mere
convocation of tne people within burgh, for
obtaining redress of grievances, or any other
cause, is, by act of parliament, declared to
amount to toe crime of sedition.
[Here his lordship read several acts, such
as the acts 1457, and 1491, prohibiting
the holding of leagues or bands within
burgh, under the pain of their goods
being confiscated, and their lives forfeit-
ed; and the act 1606 prohibiting all
persons from taking upon them to as-
semble without gtying intimation to the
public officers, vmich declares such meet-
mes to be factious, and seditious.]
His lordship neit referred to the charges
in the libel, stating that Charles Sinclair came
into this country to attend a seditious meet-
ing, which he repeatedly attended, and at
whsph he made several speeches; and which
assembly, or British convention, met for the
express purpose of resisting the parliament
of these kingdoms, and continued to meet
tiE they were dispersed by the civil magis-
trate.— They assembled themselves as a Bri-
tish convention, and declared their intention
to resist the authority of parliament, until
by superior force they were dispersed. Is
not this sedition? Is not this what sir George
Iftackenzie calls a seditious convocation ? The
only real and grave reasons for doubt are,
whether it does not amount to the crime of
high treason, although I do not pretend to
be altogether versant in the law or England,
yet, from what judgment I have been able
to form of the statute of £dward 3d, I am
folly persuaded, that if the members of the
British convention had been tried in England,
. |hcy would not have escaped so easily, but
.';'must have been tried for high tceason. They
• professed themselves to be the delegates of
the people of this country, a name applicable
to none but the members of the British par-
liament; and they had assembled too, as ap-
pears from their own resolutions, for the pur-
pose of opposing the measures of govern-
ment, and ad mutationem republics. Unless
therefore sedijtion be a crune not known in
the law of this eoimtry, the British odbvciw
tion was clearly a comventus tedOieiUi* .
After the very aUe manner in which Mr.
Solicitor General has already argued the quea-
tion, I shall not trespass further upon your
brdships time.
The Dean of FaeuUy. -—An idea hae gooe
forth in the oountiy, that the persons ktcty
tried have suffered, because they had no
counsel. I think furoper to refute this no-
tion, because the respectable body to wkach
I belong, are always ready to give their as-
sistance to whoever may come before a Court;
but as the question has also been amtated in
difoent circles, I thought it would De better
that it shoukl'be solemnly discussed, mad
determined by the Court.
The dean paid many handsome compli*
ments to the lord advocate, and freed his wro-
ship entirely from any wish to narrow the in*
dictment ; but at tho same time argued, that
the minor proposition was not so full, nor- so
closely stated as it might, or ought to have
been.
I hold it to be a clear proposition, that the
object of the minor propositioB, is to point out
to the panel, as clearly as the thing will
admit, the nature of the charge afainst him.
When we say murder is a crime of a heinous
nature, it requires not the turning up of a
statute to ascertain wlnt is the natuie of
murder; but there are crimes of a ^nerio
nature which require a farther eiplanalion. Is
the late case of the starch-makers, there was
a whole page explaining the nature of Aie
crime. If in socie^ there are crimes existing^
or can exist, which demand a particular
description or definition, these certainly are
treason and sedition, for they are conneoted
with so many circumstances, and of sueh
qualities as renders such an explaaatioD
highly necessary, t'hat treason and sedition
are crimes of a heinous nature no person
can deny. If they were not crimes at
common law, a country intending to make a
law to protect itself to-morrow, might be
overturned to day. But in every state it be-
comes necessary to make particular statutes
against particular offences. Accordingly your
lordships will see particular statutes directed
against the crime of sedition, from the rtgimm
mujestatem downwards. If the lord advocate
and the dean of &culty, who were bred to the
law,were not atone upon the meaning of these
statutes, how should the panel at the bar, who
is no lawyer, be supposed to understand themf
The dean then stated the case of a person
tried for beating a minister of the gospel,
where the statute was not recited, in which
case their lordships, by their interlocutor on
the relevancy, supplied that defect.
The dean remarked, that he could not dis-
approve of the warmth which the solicitor
{general displayed when describing the situa-
tion of France ; but he observed that although
he argued this question^ in order that a m^
ment may be pronounced by their lorouups
79SI
Jbif SedtHott*
A. D. 17M.
[7M
as to the rdtevaney, ytt he mufi not be im*
dentood aa sfjproTiBg of that aygtem of f^
ittinmesity if it might be so caHed, whioh
aov prevailt in France. With respect to that
he would adopt the strone language ua^ by
a member of the House oi Commons on the
e|>peeition bench, ^ that he woukl ]wder
£nng under the government of Domitian
ee NerOy rather tbSn that tyrannical govern-
ment now ezereised in France.*'
With respect to thoie acts of parliament
regarding convocations of the people, he must
observe, that they were papsea when this
Qountiy wes in a veiy unhappy state of
government. One was passed to jprerent the
meeting of ih» geneml assembly ot the church
of Scotland, which was held at Aberdeen
against the king's will. In Aort, they were
»sde to prevent all meetings of whatever
kind ; so that two or three could not meet
together unless in the king's name, and by
hisspermission.
It the aots which respected convocations
of the people comprehended sedition, what
then would become of all the h\r ladies who
now filled the galleries of this Court ?— Why,
the lord advocate might carryall of them and
us together to prison as seditious persons. —
Indeed those acts as they forbid anv kind of
meetinc, so of consequence they include such
as may be held to support government, as well
as those of a contrary desoriptton.
The dean farther observed, that he and the
lord advocate had both attended county
meetings, called for the express purpose of
obtaining a reform in the laws for electing
members of parliament, and jret no such in-
terpretation was given to their meetings as
this act would infer. The lord advocate has
said, that rising against the kin^ is treason,
and rkine on a private aocount is sedition ;
there is, however, no rising charged in this
case, but only a charge of certain speeches
havmi been made tctiding to excite rising ;
theremre it is only verbal sedition. If the
lord advocate lays that a rising of the people
is sediticm, he may take his argument ; the
panel never did rise, and it is to be hoped he
never will rise.
About the time of the imxHi, it was fbund
necessaiy to define and arrange the laws
regarding state offsnoes. Now, when the
act 1703 was passed, treason was declared
punishable with death, and kasins makmg
was declared punishable by fine, imprison-
ment, or banishment Had the legislature
not con»dered that sedition was compre-
hended under one or other ^ these, it would
have been specially menUoned. It would
appear, that all which a mui can say or write
la punishable as leasing making, and all that
a roan can do is punishable as treason. Rait-
img sedition is diflferent from doing what
^eaiif to roite sedition. To advUe war is veiy
different from raising war.
The libel charges the panel and others with
having resolved not to obey a certain law if
such should be passed by the legislaturs.
But have they done 'more? Perhaps when
such a law does pass they will think other-
wise; and until they go nuther than merely
this resolve, the crime cannot go farther than
leasing making. If there is any law which
punishes active sedition with any thinff d^ort
of death, then the lord advocate should pro-
duce it. Sedition appears to have become a
common law crime since 170S. Banishment
can never imply transportation, although
transportation may imply banishment. Ba*
nishment only expels a man from the city or
country where he is. And surely no person
in court ean be at a loss to undestand the
meaning of the word banishment, for all have
in pari felt it, hi so far as they were involved
in that which was pronounced against our
first parents when they were banished fkom
the garden of Eden. But by this sentence
Ihey surely were not transported ; no— they
were led out of the garden and were dismissed
with these words : —
'' The world is all before you, where to choose
Your place of residence, and Providence your
guide.*'
When a eentlemanis banished from the
presMice of his mistress, it surelv does not
follow that he is to be traDsported : — it only
implies that he shall not come where she is.
If banishment includes transportation, theu
it becomes two punishments. Is it \he same
thing to sav to a man, << Sir, you must go out
of Scotland ; across the borders," from wnence
it is more than probable he will never wish
to return; or to take him in manacles, throw
him into the hold of a ship, and cany him to
a distant part of the world for fourteen years ?
Where banishment is mentioned in any act
of parliament, it certainly precludes a heavier
punishment. So, for instance, when a man
IS sentenced to be hanged, it certainly is not
understood that he shall also be htmg in
chains.
Bui it would appear, that the soundest
lawyers were of opinion, that this Court
cannot inAict the sentence of transportation
l^ common law. A sheriff cannot banish
bevond his jurisdiction, neither can any other
judge. Could any of your lordships banish a
criminal to Denmark? Surely not. The
jurisdiction of this Court does not extend
there. Such banishment must either be by
the laws of that country to wluch he is
banished, or by authority of your own legis-i
lature, who must have power over the country
to which he is banished.
Suppose, said the dean, that a man comes
down m)m England, fmd is guilty of a crime,
could your lordships, wishing to have the
punishment put in force in his native place,
order him to be whipped at York? He then
took notice of an ac^ authorizing their lord»
ships to transport those who refused to swear
against the conventicles, and maintained that
if their lordships had then been in plend pottt'
7S5] 84 GEORGE III. Proeetdi»gt agimit Quxkt Smdair
crse
tate of tnosporting, there would hate been
no necessity for that act
. In the cases of > transportation mentioned
by Mr. Solicitor Geneial^ when asked, he
said he had not taken a note of. the crimes
for which they were transported ; but what
he has omitted I have attended to. These
we^ cases where capital crimes were com-
mitted, and it was put in the option of the
panel either to suffer death, or be transported.
The dean contended, that there can be no
punishment at common law for crimes parti-
cularised in the act 1703 ; that the act 1703
relates to the act 1509, a time when there
was no such thii^ as transportation, and that
it was absolutely necessajy that the word
transDortation should have been used in that
act, it it was intended to infer such a punish-
ment ; and that this ofiience must either be
considered as treason or leasing-making.
Upon all these grounds, therefore, the dean
contended, that tbe Court must either dis-
miss the libel, or else, that it must be found
relevant to infer the punishment contained
in the act 1703 anent leasing making.
Lord Eskgrocej'^l am happy that this
point has been argued by counsel ; but, in the
former cases, though no counsel appeared,
the Court considered well and deliberately
before they gave judgment, and held them-
selves tkeny as I hope, they always will do, as
counsel for the pan^l, and inclined to the
side of mercy.
Although I listened with the greatest
attentipnto the arguments for the panel. I
am not in the least degree shaken in the
opinion which I formerly entertained firom
what I have this dav heard. I wonder how
it could have been doubted, that the indict-
ment here was relevant. The crime charged
is one which the common law, and that of
almost every state must punish independent
of statute.
As to tbe first objection ^ of the charge
being too vaeue and general,^' I may, m
answer, appeal to every indictment that has
been brought before this Court since the
revolution. The nu^or proposition almost
always is generaL It is laid sometimes on
the <ilaws of God," but oi^nest on the « laws
of this and every well-governed r^m,"
without specifying any statute. Thus murder,
robbeiy, theft, &c. are all laid in this form,
though in our statute books we have a variety
of acts applicable to these crimes. Indeed, in
judging of every indictment, it is not the
nuyor proposition only, but the subsumption
or minor proposition, and whole content of
the indictment, that forms the charge. This
it is that must be considered in the present
case ; and any one who reads tliis indictment,
which specifies distinctly the kind of sedition
charged, cannot seriously call . it vague and
general.
This supreme court, it is well known, is in
no degree limited to the trial Of crimes pointed
gut merely, by statute, and defined and ascer-
tained thereby. Statutory offences foim only
one part of their jurisdiction, and that a very
limited one. Their powers at common law
extend to every offence which common law
or right reason declares to be a crime. No
doub^ in these ofiences, which are the mere
creatures of statute (such as those which
arise firom revenue law), their powers are
limited, and must be regulated aereeable to
the particular statute introducing tne offence;
and the indictment must be founded on such
statute.
It often happens that a common law
offence is with us punished also by a statute ;
in such cases it is competent to lay the indict-
ment on the comtmm and ttattUe law; thus
stealing firom bleach-fields, &c. in these casea
the prosecutor has it in his power to insist
either upon the one or the other, and the
Court determines accordingly.
. Sedition is clearly a common law ofience,
mentioned even in the Scriptures, and in the
civil law. The argument by the panel's
coimsel went to show that sedition was no
common law offence, or, at least, that the
statutes with regard to it did, in iac^ abrogate
the common law, and reJider it a mere crea-
ture of statute. This, however, is perfectly
absurd, and a proposition untenable; the
statutes, no doubt, punished it with more
severity than the common law, but did not
thereby take away the common law offence ;
on the contrary, I am glad that some of these
statutes are repealed, m so far as by some of
these statutes^ capital punishment is tak^
away.
It is equally absurd to say, that it is neces-
sary, to constitute sedition, that there be an
actual rving or commotioit. The endeavouring
to excite commotion is held to be sedition,
as appears from the whole tenor of an act of
parluunent.
The act 1584, c. 330, was omitted by the
panel's counsel. This is none of the statutes
against leasing-making, or affected by the act
1703. The offence here seems to be that men-
tioned in the act 1584 ; thereby made treason ;
will it be said that, becau^ the Scots treason
law had been by the act of queen Anne re-
pealed, therefore this offepce is entirely done
away, and cannot be .tried to the effect of in-
flicting a punishmeni.iess than death? murder
under trusty the A by lauded men, was treason
by the Scots laW; . yet will it be said that
these af 8 noioUger crimes, because the Scots
treason jaw is reji^^led ? X know not whether
this differenoe would be treason by the Eng-
lish law nQw;" Xfiisl kQow^ an offence which
tbe Court can punish, and an offence different
from leasioe making cannot now to be sure,
be punished as treason, but still punishable
as a crime at oammon law, ,
The fact stated in the minor proposition
here is hizhlv aggravated apd atrocious — dif-
ferent indeea from leasing making. .[ His
lordship here commented upon various parts
of the indictment.] lie ppserved, that tbe
797]
fir Seditum*
A. D. 1794.
[798
vety title of the meeting showed it was in-
tended* to subvert the constitution. It is said
to be for the purpose '< of universal suffiage,"
ikc> This is against the principles, not only
of the British, but of every form of govern-
ment.
As the offence here; therefore, is not leas-
ing making, the act 1703, is entirely out of
the question. But, supposing it was, the act
1703, authorizes trans}K>rtation under the term
banishment. It is admitted that, prior to 1703,
the Court did, in a variety of instances, inflict
transportation. . The terms of the sentences
then were ** banish," either by sending abroad
to a particiilar place, or by mere exclusion
from the country ; so that transportation was
mentioned merely as the form of executing
banishment.
The spirit as well as the words of the sta-
tute 1703, clearly empower transportation ;
the act meant merely to take away the capital
punishment, leaving to the Court to inflict an
arbitrary punishment, tecundttm modum delicti^
less than death. Had the legislature meant
to deprive them of the power of transporting,
is it possible that they would have used the
word ^ banishment,'' which, for many years
before, had been understood as including
transportation, and had been so used in the
sentences of the supreme court? Further,
npthing could be more absurd, than a simple
sentence of banishment from Scotland, for an
offence of this nature, committed, too, by
persons who had come from England for that
very purpose ; — ^it would be merely sending
them back to their place of residence: this
would be no punishment, and ridiculous in
itself.
The Court by transporting, do not execute
a jurisdiction beyona their territory. The
ientence is not a combination of banishment
with imprisonment. — 'So doubt the person is
in custodv till he arrives at the place appoint-
ed. So tar necessary Uiis to explicate the
sentence. But when he gets to the place, he
is under a different law, and no certification
is contained in the sentence, unless he return
to Great Britain. Banishment is the expres-
feioo used, down to the year 1754.
Lord Svtfiton. — The only question here is,
the relevancy of the libel. Treason, sedition,
and leasing-making, are three different of-
' fences. Bayne's d^nition of sedition (in his
Compend. on the Criminal Law) is the best,
and applies precisely to the case here. The
convocation here intended to subvert the jgo-
verament, and it is these acts which tend to
Buch a purpose, which Bayne defines to be
sedition.
The act 1703, takes no notice of several
acts of parliament that punish sedition, which
are altogether independent of the acts against
leasing making.
llie sentences of this Court proved, that
banishment is a general term, apphcable
either to the sending abroad, or merely ex-
cluding from ScotUmd, Bbt banishment is
never used per se in these sentences, but al-
ways accompanied with words expressible of
the manner in which it is to be executed, as
appears clearly firom the different cases quoted
by the solicitor general. No answer has been
inade to these cases by the Dean of faculty.
Lord Dunninnan. — ^I have carefully con-
, sidered the subject, and always was of the
opinion of which I now am, which as it coin-
cides entirely with that already given, I think
it unnecessary to enlaxge upon.
Lord Ahereromhie. — ^fn tiie opinion I am to
deliver. I shall avoid repeating the observa-
tions already made by jo\xr lordships, bi which
I entirely concur.
We all know that the manners of a people
cannot be stationary. New manners neces-
sarily give birth to new crimes. In some
countries doubts may arise in what way, and
by what law such new c^rimes are to be pu*
nished, — ^wh^ther they require a special enact-
ment, or may be punished by the common
law of the country. In Scotland no such
doubt can arise, because the supreme criminal,
court here, always has been understood as
possessed of an inherent and radical jurisdic-
tion, to punish every offence that can be de-
nominated a crime, upon the principles of
sound reason and morality. This power of the
Court was recognized, particularly in one case,^
and was fully argued and considered, viz. in
the case of Thomas Gray, and others, in 1751^
who were charged with/orci6/e abdueHon and
marriage^ a crime not known in the statute hw
of Scotland. ' Here the lord advocate, as well
as the cotmsel for the panel, admitted that
there was no statute or precedent for this
crime. But it was argued by the prosecutor,
that there was an inherent jurisdiction in the
Court to try the offence, and to punish it at
common law; — ^while the counsel for the
panel insisted, upon the principles of the law
of England, that no punishment could follow.
This plea, however, was over-ruled, and some
of the panels were transported to the plantar
tions for fourteen years.
Atrocious as that crime was, it fell infinitely
short of that with which the present nanelstands
chaiged. But no man then, no lawyer ever
said, that when the Court in the year 1751,
transported these persons, they exceeded their
powers, or acted illegally.
Suppose no statute, however, in our books, or
any mention made of sedition, and that the first
instance of it had occurred in November 1793,
still this Court would have had power to take
cognizance of it, and to inflict by common law
the punishment of tmnsportation.
But the law of Scotland has not been silent
with regard to sedition; though I will say that
it has not provided for such an aggravated
degree of sedition as this case unhappily ex-
hibits^— a species new in itself, in its ten-
dency most pernicious, in its principle the
most wicked.
*Xhe argument of the panel was, that all
crimesy by the law of ScoUaod, against the
t
799]
34 GEORGE III.
Proceedings against Charles Sinclair
[800
iUUe, wen ao accurately defined by acts of
parliament, that none were left to the cog*
nicance of the common law. Now the re*
Terse of this proposition is the truth. The
statute law is rather too vague and indefinite
wiUi resard to such crimes. The act 170S is
proof of this» while it declares that the statutes
therein mentioned, were too vaeue and too
liable to be stretched, &c.; and the act of
queen Anne, introducing the treason law of
£ngland, b also a proot of this. That law
was introduced because it defined better than
any other, the crime of treason.
The act 1703, does in no shape apply to the
case before us. The crime here is very dif-
ferent indeed from leasing- making. Had this
cue occurred, suppose in the jrear 1704, no
lawyer would have dreamt that it was provid-
ed against by the act 1703, or that the statute
in any shape applied to it. This offence would,
unquestionably, have been then deemed trea-
son, as it fell under the Scots treason acts.
These being now repealed, it cannot be tried
capitally as treason, out may as a h'leh ofiFence,
by the common law, to the e£fect of subjecting
to an arbitrary punishment It b an abuse
of terms, to say, that a conspiracy such as
occurred here, was the crime provided against
by the act 1703.
But supposing that this was leasing making,
1 have no doubt that transportation could be
inflicted, under the act 1703 ; and my reasons
are the same as those already given by the
Court.
Lord Justice Clerk. — I never entertained
the least doubt with regard to the point that
has been now argued. Where a crime has
been created by statute merely, it no doubt
is the practice of this Court to libel on the
statute. But sedition b no stationary crime.
It is coeval with Uie existence of society itself;
is cognizable by the common law of almost
every state; indeed it b a crime which right
reason as well as law, must concur in repro-
bating and jHinbhing.
The constitution of this Court is such, that
it has an inherent jurisdiction in the trial of
such crimes, independent altogether* of sta-
tutory enactments. This power has been re«
cognized in a varied of instances.
As to the objection of the generality of the
libel, I consider it as completely ill founded.
I have thought that indictments are in com-
mon too special, nor is the prosecutor bound
to make them so. The act of James 6th re-
lative to art and part, shows that an mdict-
ment b completely relevant, though the
special circumstances accompanying the oom-
mbsion of the crime, are not condescended
on in the indictment
In judging of the generality of a Ubel, the
nuyor proposition b not to be taken per se,
but must be taken along with the subsmniH
tion. If the minor proposition b too general^
then there may be a ground of complaint
by the panel, biut the minor proposition here
b sufficiently sptoial and accurate.
As to the punishment in this case^ I ame
with the panel, that the former cases decided
cannot be a rei judicata against him. In
these to be sure no counsel appeared, but the
Court considered well of their powers, %ttd of
the law of Scotland before they pronouno*
ed jud^ent Had I thought afterwards
these judgments wrong, that the Court had
erred in point of law, or even that the matter
was doubtful, I should, for one, have applbd
to hb majesty for a mitigation of these pi^
nishments; but I never entertained but one
opinion on the sul^ect, which I formed with
the utmost attention.
I agree that when the punbhment of t
crime IS precisely ascertuneo by statute^ and
when that statute has excluded every other
punishment, this Court cannot infli^ a higher
one. But I have always held itf^—and emery
lawyer must be of the same mind,i— to possess
a common law jurisdiction to the effect of in-
flicting any punishment, accordins to the
quality of the offence, less than oeatb, for
every crime the punishment of which b not^
as above, specifically defined by statute.
The panel's argument was, that leasins-
making and sedition were the same. This
is by no means the case. SediticHi is a crime
of so generic and various a nature, that it
could not be regulated by a particular statute^
nor could nor ought a precise punishment to
be annexed to it ; it must be left to the dis-
cretion of the judge to ascertain the punbh*
ment, — a discretion which belongs to tfab
Court, and has for ages been recognised as
an inherent part of its jurisdiction.
Leasing making is not always sedition ; it n
in fact, properly, a species of verbal injury,
and is treated and arranged b^ sir Oeofge
Mackenzie as such. It consbts in false, abiK
sive, and in^jurious language, propagated with
a view chieflty to personal injury ; it ma^ be
committed without a seditious intention^
though no doubt when directed against par*
ticular persons, the effect may be a commo*
tion or rising of the people.
Sedition does not consist in words, or in m
verbal injury, though words may afiord evi*
dence of^ and be the instrument of seditiOD.
The distinction of verbal and real sedition,
has misled the counsel for the panel. Real
sedition may be committed by forming a se*
ditious conspiracy, though no actual overt act
of violence is committra. If actual violence
takes place, it then amounts to high treason.
The convocation or conspirinehere, amounts
▼eiy nearly to high treason. The conventioa
declares, *' that nothing shall stop them but
superior force.'' — Is this not a bold and daring
avowal of resistance? Is thb not a declara-
tion of an intention at least of levying wat
acainst the king, in the sense of the statute
of Edward Sd ? I am clear therefore that the
act 1703 has nothing to do with this ease.
But, suppose it had, it would have been equally
clear, that under tliat statute the panel may
be transported. TraosportatiDii is goly a
801]
Jw Seditiatu
A. D. n9h
L80&
mode of ezccuUng banishment by the com-
mon law of Scotland.
The presumption and construction of law
Uf that when a capital j^unishment is taken
away, the Court nave full power to inflict
any arbitrary punisliraent less than death ; —
nor does the law of this country allow the
supreme crimiual court to be limited in the
exercise of its jurisdiction by implication or
inference, without an express enactment.
Even the court of session, who have only an
incidental, not a radical jurisdiction in crimes,
can banish by transportation. There are in-
stances of this, in the crime of forgery, to
which that court is competent, as appears
from the act of sederunt.
The tenor of the sentences of this court
demonstrates the clear meaning of the term
** banithment,*' as comprehendmg not only
dmple exclusion from the country, but the
senaing beyond seas. — A Scots law term must
be construed according to the Scots law sense ;
and what can more completely demonstrate
the meaning of a legal term, than the uni-
form usage and practice of the supreme court ?
It has been said, that by transporting we
exercise a jurisdiction extra territorium ; but
this is a mere fallacy. The Court, to expli-
cate their jurisdiction, no doubt detain the
person of the convict till he is removed to the
place appointed; this always has been the
Practice. When the convict, however, is
Drought to the place appointed, then the co-
ercion and iurisdiction of this court ceases ;
we may send him to Botany Bay, but we can-
not keep him there. No doubt he will be-
come subject to the law of the place, which
may perhaps detain him, in the same way as
he would be liable to the law of any other
country, had he been simply banished, or ex-
cluded, from Scotland ; and, in both cases,
he is liable to punishment, if he returns in de-
fiance of his sentence.
^ The same argument of exercising jurisdic-
tion extra territorium would equally apply to
an act of parliament, authorizing transporta-
tion as to a sentence of a court oflaw : I shall
only say, that when I pronounced judgment
in the former cases, I considered that there
there was no other adequate punishment for
the offence than transportation,— none that
was more fitting to the crime, or answered
better the ends of public justice. Imprison-
ment I did not think adequate, either for ex-
ample or prevention. It is no bar to seditious
canals. Banishment from Scotland I would
have considered as a burlesque on public jus-
tice. To send back to the country from whence
he came, to another part of the kingdom of
Great BrhaiUf . a person who had purposely
come down here to stir up sedition against
the realm, would have been ludicrous and
absurd, and a disgrace to the criminal justice
of the coutitry^
I have fixed, therefore, on the only punish-
ment which, by the law andf constitution of
this country, by the usage and practice of
your lordships, I thought in justice to the
country, I could inflict, and, had I judged
otherwise, I should not have acted agreeamte
to my conscience, or consistent with my duty
to my countiy or my God.
The following interlocutor was then pro-^
nonnced.
The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
sioners of justiciary, having considered th^
criminal lioel, raised and pursued at the in-
stance of his majesty*s advocate for his ma-
jesty's interest, against Charles Sinclair, pa-
nel, with the foregoing debate ; they find
the libel releX'ant to infer the pains of laws
but atiow the panel to prove all facts and
circumstances that may tend to exculpate
him, or alleviate his e;uilt ; and remit the
panel, with the libel as found relevant, to the
knowledge of an assi2e.
(Signed) Robert Mac Quebn, J.P.D,
Continued till the 24tb of February, 1794.
34M Febnuny, 1794.
Continued till 10th March next
tOth March.
Continued till the 14th Marcb^
14M March, 1794.
Intran,
Charles Sinclairi^ designed in preceding
sederunts*
Mr. Robert Blair, his majesty^s solicitor-ge-
neral, represented, that on the part of &
Sublic prosecutor, he moved their lordships to
esert the diet of the present libel j^ro loco et
tempore.
The lord justice clerk, and the lords com-
missioners of justiciary* In respect of what is
before represented, desert the diet against the
said Charles Sinclair, panel, pro loco et tern-
pore,
(Signed) Robert Mac Queeh^ J.P.D«
VOL. xxnr.
3 F
^03] 34 GBORGE ill. Proceedings agatn^ Jok^A GemM \j^
599. Proceedings on the Trial of Joseph GfeHRALD^* on afi
Indictment charging him with Sedition. Tried before the
High Court of Juisticiary at Edinburgh^ on the 3rd^ 10th»
13th and I4th of March : 34 George III. a. d. 1794.
Mouday^ March Sdi794>
The members of the court of justiciary as-
sembled precisely at ten o'clock, in the fore-
noon. Mr. Gerraid appeared, and placed
faimself at the/bsr.
His majesty's advocate, for his majevW^
interest, having been, in the usual form, called
against the panel,
Mr. Gerraid said, my lord, I understand I
am authorized to demand that a list of my ex-
culpatory witnesses be read out in Court
before the trial proceeds.
Lord Justice Clerk, — ^The criminal libel must
b^ read first,— that is the first thing to be
done.
Lord Advocate, — Before your lordships pro-
ceed to reading the libel, I feel it my duty to
tell the panel, that if he means to persevere in
an application which he signified to me yes-
terdapr, by letter, the proper period for him to
do it IS at this moment, before the indictmtot
Uread.
Mr. Gerraid. — My lords, as I am totally ig-
norant of the law of this country, being a na-
live of England, I applied to several gentle-
y^ men of the profession, to advocate my cause ;
they unanimously refused — ^in consequence of
which, I wrote a line to the lord advocate, as
*he has stated/ mentioning that I should cer-
..^^^tainly make an application to the Court to ap-
^^pof ht me counsd. Your lordships very much
lamented, that in former cases, counsel had
not been applied for ; and, though the Court
arc bound to act as counsel for the prisoner,
yet the panel, no doubt, wishes to avail him-
self of every advantage that he can. I stand
peculiarly circumstanced ; because, not being
a native of this country, and behag ignorant
of its laws, without an advocate, I should be
deprived of the benefit of their benignant in-
terpretation, as the public prosecutor will no
doubt state the charge as strongly as he can
on the part of the crown : I therefore offer it
as a suggestion td your lordships coq^ider-
ation<
Lord Jwtice Cl^rft.— What do you say to
this, my lord advocate?
Jjird Advoeate.'^My lord, I do not see
that there is any thing put to me by the panel ;
it seems to be an application to the Court :
however, I will state, in a very few words,
what occurs to me ; and I wish that the pa-
nel should hear what I say, and that the gen-
f See the preceding cases.
tlemen of the jury, and of the ecHmtry at
large, should kAow what I have to Slate.
My lords, while this British colivefitioiiy 4Sr
what I shall nefver cease to term it, a conspi-
racy aoainst the con^tution of ^is country^
assembled for many days withih this city, and
when they had proceeded, by itay information^
to a len^h which called upon the officers of
Sublic justice to interfere, I had occasion to
irect those steps which appeared necessaiy
for an inquiry mto the su^ect; and, upoi^
the mommg of the 5th of December, the
ringleaders of tliis convention (and this paD<»
one of them) were apprehended.
My lord, the necessary investigations tool;
some time ere they were completed ; but il
was my habit to brmg those who appeared to
me the most guilty, to a fidr trial before their
country, as early as possible. The first per-
son that I brought forward in the li^ was thd
mah who appeared to be most gjuilty, I meaa
Skirving, wno stood trial, in this court, upon
the 6th of January ;* and the indictment that
I felt it necessary to bring next in order, was
the charge against theftanel now at the ba^
which was served upon him in the month of
December, and the day fixed for the 8th <t
January. The day after the libel wasexe^
cuted upon him, at his residence in Edin-
burgh, 1 received i'rom him a letter, in whick
he appealed to mv humanity as well as jush
tice, that I should consent to a delay of his
trial for a fortnight, that he might return t9
^England, and settle the affairs ot a family de-
pendent upon him. I instantly acceded to
the request, and gave him more tlian he
asked; I gave him till the 27 th of January;
and it appears, that upon the evening of Fri-
day tlie 24th of January, from his own a<>
count of the matter, he left London, wbicb
would have brought him into this city, a -few
hours, by the utmost possible expedition, a
very few hours before his trial was to com-
mence. By the accidental circumstance of ^
heavy fell of snow he was prevented from
reachmg it that morning. Your lordships
and the jury know what passed upon thai
occasion. I then felt it my duty to bring be-
fore the Court for trial, the voun^ man who
sits at his right hand,* and he did not state
any refusal to my brethren of the profession to
plead, — as I trust they ever will do — every de«
* See his case, page 391 of this volume.
* Mr. Charles Sinclair. See the preceding
case.
f^OBH for Sedition.
fence ivhicb thekifibest or the meanest crivai-
nal is entitled to state, at that hai, 1 cannot
^refore perfectly credit that what Mr. Sin-
clair received should be denied to Mr. Gerrald.
!Quty if it is sOy considering that he sat this
i^ff fortnight, at the side of that person, and
i indulged him agun at his own request, tel-
l)j^ him, t^at he need not attend last Mon-
day, but that this p^recise day was the da^ on
which I determined to go to trial with him ;
a foKnight affor4e4 him surely opportunity
enough to have applied to your lordship's
j^stice ; and every counsel at the bar would,
laoi sure, have appeared and stated for him
every thing that it was competent for him to
state. But at four o^clock yesterday^ I re-
ceived fcom him a letter, the purport of which
he has now sta^d ; and I sboula feel myself
aciiiig only in the proper and due execution
of my duty, if I were to argue to your lord-
"^^ ships to refuse that aoplication. But there
are circumstances whicn I know, and which I
trust will enter into your lordslups consider-
ation in giving your opinion upon this appli-
cation. I hope and trust that the administra?
^on of the criminal justice of this country^
however calumniated, however aspersed, as
able to stand the test in competition with the
administration of the criminal justice of Eng-
land, or of any country upon the face of this
earth« Ancl, l>^^e as he comes with his de-
nand, althoujjh, perhaps in a few hours, I
must ies^ve this country to attend my public
duty in London, that can be no objection;
the conduct of the criminal justice of this
country remains in abler han(fs than mine. I
trust your lordships (without aJQfording a pre-
cedent to other panels to come with an ex-
pectation of being listened to upon so late an
•-^application) will accede to his request, for
tihese reasons; and to satisfy Mr. Gerrald,
that if he has coine to this country, a stranger
tq its laws^ a,nd if he has presumed to offend
highly, as I charge that he has, that he h^
not only received that strict administration of
justice m this country, which he would in his
own, but that he has received that indulgence
vlfiph calumuy Itself cannot reach.
iord JuUice Clerk, — ^The panel is certainly
very late in his application; at the same time,
in the circumstances of this case, I am not for
cutting him short, however late he may be.
J think he is right in making application for
the ^sistanc^ pf coynsel as a stranger to this
covatry; and I do not see that he can be
supposed to know the laws of this country.
X think he is right, and I am, for my own
CMTt, forgiving him counsel. What do your
rtjships say to it ? x
Lord Henderland. — I own it is my opinion
that this panelj and every panel, whatever be
the charge against him, should come to your
lOE^sl^ip's bar prepared and assisted by coun-
sel. It is very true, that the judges are coun-
sel fbr the panel^ to ^ c^tain degree, but
th^if duty is limited; in th^ first pX»ce upon
||)e relevancy of the in^ic^poent^ \q /see that
A. D. 1794.
W^
no chai ge shall be admitted against i;>ane|
which does not necessarily and logically infe^
the crime; the next part of their dutvis, to
take care that no evidence shall be admitted
but what is legal and unexceptionable ; the
third part of their duty generally falls upon
the presiding judse to address the jury upon
the evidence, as by act pf parliament, ana to
st^te it to them fairly. If any error is com-
mitted, I dare say the Court would interfere :
that has never been the case, and I hop^
never iyill» while your lordship sits as judge ;.
but there are cases in which a counsel may be
of great use to a man : ar^ments may be
made use of, which might otherwise have es-
caped. I think he ought t9 bo assisted bv
counsel; and therefore! am extremely wd-
lii^g that he should, though I think this gen-
tleman has . come exceedingly late indeed.
I am not ready perhaps to inc|uire, because
I cannot know what were his motives for
being so lajte in hi^ applicat^n ; but I cannot
suppose he could be ignorant of the right he
had to apply for comisel. And I must regret
too that my lord advocate is going to attend
his duty in parliament, who has so well and
ably conducted the other trials; and in whose
humanity, as well as abilities, I think this
country may place great confidence. I must
rcjgret that he is obliged to be absent: vet not-
withstanding that, i agree with your lordship
in desiring ^lat tliis man should be assisted
by counsd, and that he should suggest who
are the gentlemen that he wishes to have, I
th\n)k that is the proper way ; the list of fa^
culty is open to nim, and I will venture to
say, there is not a man in it but what is fit in
proportion : 9ome of them mav be in expe-
rience more or less able, but there are none
of them but what may be very well intrusted
with his defence. However, in ordex to give him
every indulgence, he shall have his choice ; at
the same time recommendir\g to him not
wantonly to interfere with the superior ayocar
tions of a gentleman at the bar,* whom tl\e
* In order to ascertain whether he was the-
person here intended, I applied to my highly
esteenied friend tl^e honourable Ilenry Ersr
kine, who at the time of this trial held the
situation of dean of the faculty of advocates :
I am happy to avail myself of his permission
to present the reader with the following ex-
tract fropa hb reply to my application : —
" You are right m supposmg that I yas the
person alluded to by lord Henderland in Ger-
rald's trial : but I was not one of the counsel
to whom Gerrald applied, and who, he says,
unanipaouslv refused to undertake his defence.
Had he wished my assistance, I should cer-
tainly have appeared for him, however incon-
venient ^t mignt have been to me fit)m the
multiplicity of business in which I was in
those days involved, for I ever felt (as the
J lord justice clerk well expresses it) that no
gentiemm ought to r^u^ to defend a panel,
whatever be the nature ofhU crim^ I snoul^i
807]
34 GflORGE lU.
Proeeedingt ognnH Joseph Gerrald
[808
Court are not induced to trouble with impo-
sitions upon this head, from a panel.
LordJuttice Clerk. — Have you an agent.
Mr. Gerrald, — No, my lord; I have apolied
to two ur three, and they have refusea. I
applied to a gentleman to whom I have not
had the honour of being long known, but who
knows me and my connexions extremely well,
jand who would undertake my cause, but for
reasons which I am not authorized to tell in
court Mr. Laing is the only gentleman
whose refusal I have authorit;^ to mention.
The two gentlemen I would wish to employ,
are the dean of faculty and Mr. ]Laing, with
your lordships approlnition.
Lord Justice Clerk. — ^If the dean of faculty
does not object ; but if he should, he is a
gentleman whose attendance we cannot com-
pel.
Mr. Gerrald.^Jf the dean should refuse, I
shall prefer Mr. Fletcher.
Lord Justice Clerk. — ^We shall just now
pame Mr. Fletcher and Mr. Laing.
Lord Eskgrofve. — I think you had better
suggest one or two more, in case of any acci-
dent, that they cannot attend.
Lord Justice Clerk.^WHH jou name a
fourth.
Mr. GerraZrf.— No, my lord ; they will be
quite sufficient.
Lord Justice C/er^.-^Now, name an amit
Mr. Gerrald. — I will leave it to your wrd-
ships, if you please.
Lord Justice Clerk. — ^No, you must name
one yourself. Name two, and you will be
sure of one or other.
Mr. Gerrald. — Mr. James Gibson, and Mr.
Jjames Campbell.
Lord Justice Clerk. — Now, I am sure joa
must be conscious that you have had all kinds
of indulgence ; but you must be ready next
Monday.
Mr. Gerrald. — As to myself I am perfectly
ready to go on now with the defence which i
originally intended to have made.
Monday, March 10, 17M.
The Court met agreeable to adjournment,
when Mr. Gerrald again placed himself at
the bar. The assize being called over, and
Mr. Gerrald. — I feel extremely the indeli- ; the lord justice clerk having desired him to
cacy, and would rather be deprived of the be- listen to his indictment,
ncfit of counsel, than drag any gentleman Mr. Gerrald said, my lords, T feel myself
into an office, the duties of which he would under the painful necessity of objecting to the
reluctantly fulfil. lord justice clerk sitting "^upon that bench.
Lord Juxtice Clerk. — Even without the upon this plea, that his lordship has deviated
interference of the Court, I think no gentle- from the strict line of his duty, in prejudsnng
man ought to refuse to defend a panel, what- that cause in which my fortune and my fame
ever the nature of his crime might be. Now, . which is more precious to mc than life, is ac-
name another. j tually concen.ed. I bes, therefore, that that
Mr. Oerrald.—\ have the honour of being [holding a paper in his hand] may be made a
know to Mr. Gillies. : minute of this court. My lords, 1 am totally
' 1 ignorant of the mode of conducting the cvi-
at the same time, have qualified my compli- oence, and therefore shall rely upon your
ance with this condition, — that the conduct of lordships candour for setting me right when I
tile defence should be left entirely to me, . am wrong ; and I understand your lordships
knowing, as I did, that if he spoke for him- are counsel for the prisoner, equally with
aelf, he would avow principles and views those appointed by the bench.
which would supply the counsel for the crown
with the only thing they wanted to make out
their case, — the criminal intention.
" WhenSinclair, who was previously brought
to trial, applied to me, I consented to defend
Lord nenderland.'^\o\i must read it.
[Mr. Gerrald then read as follows :]
'< Joseph Gerrald stated, that before pro-
ceeding to trial upon the criminal letters rais-
him, on tke above condition only. He agreed. ; ed against him, he roust take the liberty of
The pleadings on the relevancv took place ; i declining the lord justice clerk, as having dis-
and the result was^ that the lord advocate : qualified himself ^om judging in the present
abandoned the prosecution. question, by having f>rejudged it In order to
" When Mr. Muir made a similar appljca- show that this objection was not made at ran-
tioQ, I gave him the same answer, stating j dom, Joseph Gerrald offered to prove that the
that I could not injustice to hiip, nor consis- lord justice clerk, had prejudgea the cause of
tently with my own reputation, act otherwise, r^ery person who had oeen a member of that
He declined my assistance on these terms. Assembly calling itselfthe British Convention;
He pleaded his own cause; — and you know ^inasmuch as he had asserted, in the house ot
the result.
'* I wish you to be acquainted with these
facts, not only as of some importance in the
histoiy of these trials, but that the public may
see from what it arose, that my name appears
but once in the record of these important
James Rochead, of Inverletth, that * the
* members of the British Convention desenrei
' transportation for fourteen years, and even
f< public whipping;' and that, when it was
Objected by a person present in company,
that the people would not patientlj endure
pases, which otherwise might be imputed to the inflicting' of that punishment upon the
' very difoent causes.'' members of the British ConventioD, the
809]
Jbr Sedition.
lord justice clerk replied ' that the mob would
<bc the better for the spilling of a little
' blood/* I pray that this may be made a mi-
nute of the court.
[The lord justice clerk then left the chair,
which was taken by lord Henderlandl.
Lord Henderland. — Have you subscribed
it?
Mr. Gerrald. — ^No, my lord, I did not know
that that was necessary. [Subscribes it].
Lord Henderland.^^Do you wish to be far-
ther heard upon it ?
Mr. Gerrald. — ^I desire to have the matters
alleged substantiated by evidence.
iSrd Henderland. — ^Your lordships have
heard the minute of the court, concerning
that respectable judge who has the honour to
preside as vice-president, in this court in the
absence of the lord justice general. My
lords, it is a thing per/ectly new in the annals
of this court; nor is there one instance to be
found in our records upon the books of ad-
journal.
My lords, you have heard the nature of the
complaint, which is as extraordinary as it is
unprecedented ; and it will become you, my
lords, well to weigh what is the import, and
what ought to be the le^l effect, of such an
objection offered, in such extraordinary cir-
cumstances, and at so early a period as this.
You had it ui a different form mdeed, in the
case of Margarot, but you will consider it in
this new form, in this new guise which it has
assumed ; you will consider how far it is im-
portant in Its nature, or how far it is the same
that was offered in the case of Margarot ;
you are not prohibited from forming a diflfe-
rent judgment upon it now from what you
might have done then ; but I thought it ne-
cessary to bring these matters under your
lordships view, before you proceed to give
your opinion upon this so unprecedented and
extraordinary a minute. It is now submitted
to your consideration.
Lord Eskgrove. — My lords, this objection
which comes before your lordships is a no-
velty in many respects ; and I do not think
this panel at this bar is well advised in making
it *. what could be his motive for it I cannot
perceive. He has the happiness of being
tried before one of the ablest judges that ever
sat in this court ; but he is to do as he thinks
fit, I am sure he can obtain no benefit if he
fains the end he has in view ; and therefore
cannot perceive his motive, unless it is an
inclination, as far as he can, to throw an in-
dignity upon this court
As to the objection, I think there is no
validity in it. In a former case, an attempt
was made to start the same objection, by the
person then to be tried. I do not observe
that this gentleman says his name was ever
mentioned in that conversation, or that any
thing was said of him individually; but he
* See Margaret's trial p. 672. of this vo-
lume.
A. D. 1740. [610
says it was an expression in common con-
versation, importing that honourable judo's
opinion, that the members of the British
Convention should be transported for fourteen
years, and even publicly whipped. I do not
conceive what interest this gentleman has in
it; he has not yet acknowledged himself a
member of that convention. My lord, one
man's conduct may be different from ano-
ther's in that assembly. As to the express
sion, it could only import hypothetically,thaty
if that convention was guilty of the crimes
stated against them, of Uiat attempt to over-
throw the constitution of their country, to
create rebellion and insurrection in the coun-
try, then the punishment adapted to such an
offence was, in his opinion, transportation
and public whipping. What is there in that
more than in the opinions given in this court
already, in causes of this kind ? My lords, it
has been said by all your lordships, in this
court, that if the persons who have been con-
victed had been Wought to trial before the
alteration of the treason law by the union,
they would not have been trie! as persons
liable to arbitrary punishment, but recogniza-
ble as high treason ; and the person at th^
bar under that accusation would have been
tried for his life, and on conviction would
have suffered the pains of death and forfeiture.
If therefore by an alteration of the criminal
law of the land, this crime which goes to des-
troy the constitution of the country, is made
an arbitrary punishment, that punishment
must be the highest arbitrary punishment
that can be inflicted ; and therefore I see no-
thing in that opinion which imports more
than your lordships have all said in this court.
I think it was nothing more than a general
opinion, given upon the nature of the offence,
as charged, that it was a convention of persons
meeting to overturn the happy constitution
of this country ; and giving his opinion that
such an offence merited that punishment.
I am sure that can be no disqualincation from
sitting in this court, where tne same opinion
has been given by all your lordships.
It is stated here, that it was objbcted by a
person present in company, that the mob
would not patiently endure the infliction of
that punishment. I do not know what could
be the motive of any person to make such an
observation if they had any reason to believe
such a thine; for my part, I think it is a most
erroneous observation ; for I have a better opi-
nion of the mob as it is called, the peopleofthis
country, than to think that they are capable
of associating for acts of violence in denance
of the laws. I think belter of the neoplc of
this country, than that they would meet
together for the purpose of stirring up insur-
rection and violence. But, my lord, it is no
more than saving this, that a mob, if they
should be so *iU advised as to break out into
an insurrection, with an intention to over-
throw the constitution, would not merit com-
passiou; in case the magistrates shotdd be
8il] 34GEO£GEI(I.
Proceedingt QgiAut Josepk Gerrald
im
reduced to the disagreeable necessity of re-
aistiiig force by force ; and that is ao obser*
Yation which I dare say, has been made by a
thousand people besides his lordship ; and it
cannot be supposed that that was to prejudi-
cate the trial of this gentleman, who wili^ by
his lordships and by the Court, be treated as
an innocent man, Ull he is found ^uiltv. My
lord, to say that is prcjudicating bun, because
be spoke of a punishment with one exception
1a corporal punishment) which had been in-
licted upon persons who had before been
convictea, is canying the objection beyond all
decree of reason ; and I can ascribe it to no-
thmg but malevolence and desperation.
Mr. Gerrald, — My lord. I come here not
to be the object of personal abuse, but to meet
the justice of my country ; had I been actuat-
ed by such moUves, I am sure I should never
have relumed to tlus country.
I/)rd BenderUmd, — I desire you will be-
have as becomes a man before this hijgh
court; I will not suffer this court to be in-
sulted,
Mr. Gerrald. — My lord, far be it from me
to insult this court —
Lord Henderland^ — ^Be silent, sir.
Mr. Gerrald, — ^My lord —
Lord Henderland, — I desire you will be
silent, sir.
Mr. Gerrald.'^^y lord, I am sure that my
coming to this country shows that I was ac-
tuated by the purest principles of justice.
Lord Etkgrcve. — If I have said any thing
wrong, I will very readily retract what I have
said ; but I was making an apology for this
ob^tioQ, that I cannot ascribe it to a solid
obfection of counsel, none of whom have stood
up to support it. I meant nothing more by
what I was saying ; I am very sorry for the
expression I made use of, and ask the eentle-
Rum's pardon ; but, upon the whole, 1 think
the olnection an irrelevant one.
Lora Swinton, — My lord, an olyection of
this kind, coming h'om any other man, I
should consider as a very high insult upon
the dignity of this court; but coming from
bim, standing in the peculiar situation in
which he now stands at the bar, charged with
a crime of little less than treason, the inso-
lence of his objection is swallowed up in the
atrocity of his crime. IJe has objected
against a most worthy and respectable judge,
that being in a public company at Inverleith,
he said that the members of the British Con-
vention should be whipped and transported ;
and u|)on alady*^ saving the mob would not
suffer it, his lordship is said to have answered,
* In the objection offered by Gerrald, the
sex of the person whose observation called
forth the sentiment alleged to have been
littered by the lord justice clerk, is not men-
tioned. Maroarot, however, in his interroga-
tories to the lord justice clerk, assigns Uie
observation to a lady. See Margarot^s case,
«sra p. 072.
that in that case they would deserve to lose a
little blood. It appears to me, that there is
not the smallest relevancy in this objecdon.
There is no doubt but there are reasons why
a judge may be declined according to an act
of parliament: the law is, that if a judge has
any interest in the cause, that he can either
win or lose by it ; if there is capital enmity
between a jud^ and the party, that might be
a eood reason Tor his being declined.
Mr. Gerrald. — My lord —
Lord Henderland. — Once for all, sir, I must
inform you that you are not entitled to inter-
rupt the judges; if you have any thing to ob-
serve, a&r any one of them has done, you
will be permitted to speak ; but I desire that
you will behave with that decency which be-
comes you.
Mr. Gerroii.—- My lord, I respect the laws
of my country, and I should not respect myr
self if I did not ; which I flatter myself I shiul
always do : for, I hope I never shall do any
thing which can constitute a ground of selu
desmdation in my own opinion : but I spoke
to his lordship, because I understood his lord-
ship had addressed me, and that was the only
reason of my speaking.
Lord Sminton. — My lord, I say there is no
relevancy in this objection. If aAy judge here
shall have enmity against any man whatever,
standing at that bar, it might, be a good rea-
son for his being declined ; but in this case
it would be absurd. I never heard of this
man's name in my life, before he came into
this country, and I dare ss^ his lordship never
did; and what interest he can have except
that of compassion for a man in that unfortu«>
nate situation, I cannot tell ; and I appeal to
the feelings of every man ; I say it is impos*
sible.
My lord, there is not the smallest ground
to suppose that this man was prejudicated by
that conversation; and therefore I think the
objection is irrelevant.
Lord Dvnnnaaft.!— My lords, this objec-
tion is new, and not a little extraordinary ; it
very much surprised me. I shall enter into
no observations upon his conduct ; and I tliink
your lordships ought to pay no attention to
It, either in one shape or another.
Lord Abercrombie. — My lords^ as to the
objection made by this panel — if a judge it
guilty of a breach of the sacred trust reposed
in him, he is amenable to the laws of bis
country, and may be impeached for that of-
fence ; he may be punished for it, and the
law of this country has provided a^nst it.
But, my lord, that is not the shape in which
this objection comes before you ; it comes in
the shape of a disqualification. Now, my
lords, I Know of no circumstances whatever
which can disoualify a judge from sitting to
dischai^ his outy, except those in the act of
parliament. Bu^ my lord, this objection
applies equally to every judge who sits here.
Sure I am, that upon evey occasion when I
have had an opportunity of giving my opinio^
813]
fiir TSeiElum,
A. D. 1794'.
[814
upon the subject, I hzve never hesitated to
say that I considered the British convention
as a consfjiracy of a most dangerous and of a
^cnost criminal nature.
My lord, with regard to the unhappy man
M the bar, there is not a doubt that the pre-
sumption of law is in his favour ; he is pre-
sumed to be innocent of the charges laid
a^inst him, till he is found guilty by a ver-
dict of his country. But I have no hesitation
in saying now, in the presence of that man,
in the presence of his counsel, and in the
presence of this audience, and of your lord-
ships, that if he should be eonvicted of the
crime charged against him in this indictment,
I shaH say that even fourteen years transpor-.
lation is too slight a punishment for an of-
fence of such magnitude. My lord, in the
case of Marearot, I had a doubt, but that
doubt was whether fourteen years transpor-
tation was not too slight a punishment for
the offence, aggravated as it was by a variety
of circumstances, and in particular, bv the
very improper and indecent conduct of that
man to the Court in the course of his trial *
trhich, for his own sake, I hope the panel
tK>w at the bar will not do.
Lord Henderland. — Your lordships have
delivered your opinions so fully, and placed
•this question in so many different pomts of
view, and expressed yourselves in so much
better language than I can do, that it would
be highly improper in me to eo over the
same grounds again ; I shall only say that I
pcrfecUy a^e m the opinion of the Court,
that this objection is not well founded.
My lords, it appears to have been a tran-
sient conversation, with respect to the crime
of sedition, and the punismnent due to it :
but is that to be the ground of declining a
judge f I appeal to the feelings of any man
who has conversed upon this subject; I ap-
peal to the feelings of every juryman who
judge, and therefore was not any thing like
a prejudication of what he might do in this
court; and we are to judge, whether by ^ir
inference it ought to be helo so, whether by
consultinjg the common sense of all mankind!,
for that IS the test of all crimina^ty. And
here^ my lord, a respectable judge, an honour
to his profession and abilities, whom I know
to be a man of the highest honour, and the
strictest integrity, is to be tried before us;
for we are his lury, and we are called upon
by our great oaths, as judges, and layine our
hands upon our hearts, to say, that this re-
spectable judge, by what is here allied, is
to be rendered incapable of sitting in this
chah* — to be d<^raded firom his office, and
held unfit to judge in the most important
trials in this country; wliere his aD3ittes»
steadiness, and knowledge in the law, are
most required — I cannot go such a lenstiv-^
I thhik it is contrary to law; and that tnere-
fore the objection is irrelevant.
[The objection was repelled.]
[Lord Heiiderland then left the chair, and
lord justice clerk resumed it]
Lard Juitke CUrk, — ^Joseph Gerndd, a^
tend ID the criminal libel that is to be rea4
against you.
[The indictment was then read by tho
clerk of the court, of which the follow-
ing is a true copy; —
George, &c. Whereas it is humbly meant
and complained to us, by our ri^t trusty
Robert Dundas, esq. of Arniston, our advo-
cate for our interest upon Joseph Gerrald of
Hart-street, Bloomsbury-square, London, and^
fresently or lately, residing in the Black Bull
nn, head of Leith-walk, m the parish of St.
Cuthbert*B and shire of Edinburgh ; that, by
the laws of this, and all other well-governed
realms, sedition is a crime of an heinous na-
ture, aritttcverely punishable : yet true it is^
nas tried these cases; I appeal to the feel- / and of verity, that the said Joseph Gerrald,
ingsof every juryman who will try thesecases ; 1 above complained upon, has presumed to com-
Would he think himself bound in the smallest I roit, and is guilty actor, or art and part, of
degree by such a conversation ? woukl he i th^ foresaid crime ; in so far as, a number of
think the case prejudged one iota? would
be thtfric himself hindered from examining
the evidence, or from weighing the argu-
ments with the greatest foirness, and with
the utmost accuracy? I am sure he would
not To say that these words shdl be held
by this Court as a prejudication of a^y judge
or juryman^ (for I know not how far the
objection may go) might lead to the most
extensive, and the most daneerous conse-
quences, for ought I know; I do not say it
is so. but it mignt go even to the exclusion
of all trials.
My lords, taking it in this point of view,
the words said ^to ^ expressed in the manner
in which they were expressed, and the oc-
«U CO tog^ether; and it is admitted they are
so fir fairly told you. It is not said that this
was a judicial opuiion given by tins learned
seditious and ilLdisposed persons having ille-
gally assemble^ at Edinburgh, during the
months ofOctober,|November, and December,
179S, the said Joseph Gerrald, above complain-
ed upon, did come into this countrv, for the
purpose of joining and assisting these per-
sons^ and became a member of their illegal
and seditious association and meeting; which
illegal and seditious association and meeting, at
first assembled underthedesignationof a ^ Ge-
neral Convention of the Friends of the Peo-
ple," but thereafter, presumptuously and se-
ditiously, assumed the name of '' The British
Convention of the Delegates of the People,
associated to obtain Umversal Sufilrage and
Annual Parliaments ;** and did in the whole
ca^on upon which they were expressed, musi^ -form and manner of their procedure, as well
as in the principles they avowed and propa-
gated, clearly and unequivocally demonstrate
toat their purposes were of the most dapge-
815]
34 6E0HGB III.
Proceeditigi against Joseph GerraU
[816
rous and destructive tendency, hostile to the
peace and happiness, and tending to subvert
the constitution of this realm; imitating, in^^egan to be made on public liberty; but, if
the form and tenor of their proceedings, the
oonvenUon of France, the public and avowed
enemies of this country, and with whom
Great Britain then was, and still is, at war;
the members calling each other, at their
xneetines, by the name Citizen; dividing
Ihemselves mto sections; receiving reports
from said sections; some of which bear date,
« Liberty Court," " Liberty Stairs," " Liberty
Hall," " First year of the British Convention,
one and indivisible;*' and some of which
have vii^ la convention prefixed to them, and
end with ^d ira; instituting primary socie-
ties, provincial assemblies, ana departments ;
appomting committees of various kinds, such
as, of organization, of instructions, of finance,
and of secrecy; denominating their meetings
sittings; &;ranting honors of sittings; making
honourable mention in their minutes of pa-
triotic donations; and inscribing their mi-
nutes, with the firstyear of the British con-
vention! and moreover, the members of the
said seditious association, under the deingna-
lions aforestdd, did, at times and place above-
inenticmed, and particularly in a room or
mason lodge in Blackfnar's Wynd, in the
city of Edinburgh aforesaid, hold various se-
ditious and illegal meetings, and did' in said
meetings, wickedly and feloniously, make
jiarangues and speeches, as yie\\ as motions
and resolutions, of a seditious tendency ; the
substance of all which was, under their au-
thority, at least with their knowledge and
approbation, not only minuted, but published
in a newsj^per, published at Edinburgh,
intituled "TThe Edinburgh Gazetteer," and
through that medium circulated among the
lieges. And the said Joseph Gerrald, not
only approved of and concurred in these wick-
ed and seditious motions and resolutions, but
did wickedly and feloniously make harangues
and speeches, and take an active part in all
the illegal proceedings of the said association,
was frequently named, and acted as a mem-
ber of their committees, and as president or
chairman of the association. And particu-
larly, upon Thursday the 21st day of Novem-
ber 1793, or one or other of the days of that
xnonth, or of the months aforesaid, the said
Joseph Gerrald. did wickedly and feloniously
address the said illegal and seditious meeting,
when assembled and resolved into a com-
mittee, for the purpose of considering of a
plan of union, in a speech of the following, or
similar import.
their most valuable privileges. It was firom
that period that the greatest encroachments
within these, walls, I suppose we have all one
common object in view : we all live under
the same form of government, have the same
grievances to comj^lain of, and seek the same
redress. It was justly observed by citizen
Callender, that, soon after the union of Ihe
crowns of England and Scotland, the people
of both countries were deprived of some of
that union has operated to rob us of our rights,
let it be the object of the present one to re-
gain them. If the event exists for our shame,
as it has existed for our chastisement, let it
also exist for our instruction.
'' Some doubts have been introduced re-
specting our right to universal suffrage. I
apprehend that we may justly cluni it as our
inheritance from nature; but we can with
confidence, because we can with truth, ap-
peal to antiquity for our title to this right;
and it will be found to have been exercised
by our ancestors in its fullest extent. It
must be confessed, however, that, in the early
.periods of our history, there existed a body
of men called slaves : happily, this distinction
does not exist in our days; and, if there are
political slaves, it is time that they should
exist no longer.
** In establishing the right of universal
suffrage, the convention may perhaps give
offence to the satellites of despotism ; but,
while we can establish our demand on the
immutable principles of justice, we may at
the same time prove, that it is perfectly
agreeable to the spirit of our constitution.
" Under the Saxon government, the people
met frequently in the different divisions of
the country, in assemblies called Folkmotes.
Tiiere they deliberated; there every man had
a voice in choosing his representatives ; the
concurrence of the people was necessary to
the administration of government; and they
obeyed the laws which themselves had made.
The king of England used to sit in the folk-
mote ; and, I believe, it would be more to his
own advantage if he sat there now.
** In the progress of time, however, great
deviations have been made from the original
purity of the constitution, and the national
representation has been supposed to be some-
times influenced by motives not altogether
congenial to the happiness of the people.
Human nature is so constituted, that every
man is inclined to pursue his own individual
interest in preference to that of others. If you
appoint a man to act as your agent, and make
his situation such that he has every tempta-
tion to betray you without incurring the dan-
ger of being called to an account, the proba-
bility is, that he will sacrifice your interests
to his own. It is therefore that a free suf-
frage of the people is what every man ought
to desire, as that alone can make the lnte>
rests of the representative and his constituent
" Whatever difference of opinion may arise the same. The great art of government.
I apprehend, is this, that all should be go-
verned by all; but unhappy is the country
where men are called upon by every interest
to act in opposition to their duty.
« Much, of late, has been said about meet-
inj^ of mobs. I apprehend that no meeting
or the people can Hie called a mob, if their
deliberations be directed towards the public
ai73
^SMUmu
good; but if nMn meet for ui opMsite pur*
poee, for promoting tbe mieciy or die destruo
tkm of the human raee, though they should
sil vith crowns on their heads and aeeptres
in their hands, they are truly a mob.
^ Were all mankind to assemble in public
mtetkigs^ one of two things must foUow;
eillier S)ey will behave properly or impro^
perly; if properly, their meeting will tend
to good; if improperly, it carries its own cure
mkmg with it. Th» people will be soon
bnM^ht'into a better method by a sense of
aelf^preservation, by which they will correct
the errors into which they have fallen.
^ It may occur, that the voice of the peo-
ple may be wrong when their understandmgs
are perverted by priestcraft, or darkened by
iK>litical superstition, like the voice once
heard in Jerusalem, of crucify him ! crucify
him! when that nefarious deied was perpe-
trated, at winch the sun hid his head in dark-
ness and in blood. But, were the tyrants of
the earth as solicitous to enlighten as they
am to punish their unfortunate subjects; were
governments to instruct the poor, instead of
Eanging up their bodies on gibbets; the
-voice <n the people would then be the voice
cf God.
'< By the Norman conquest, or rather rob-
bery (for that transaction, like every other,
is to be considered by its consequences), the
right of voting was greatly curtailed; but surely
we can, with great proprie^, meet to petition
parliament for the restoration of the right of
universal suffrage ; a right which is so neces-
sary to the just fultninistration of governmenrr
for, if any man comes and tells me that I must
pay a tax to which I have never consented,
neither by myself nor my representative,
what am I lo think of the legality of his
claim ? Whenever money is taken from the
people by a military power, or by any other
authority not deleeaied by themselves, odl^
th^t government what you will, it is a govern^
ment of force— it is the sword which governs.
Tbe right, then, of universal suifa-age, of
which we have been so unfortunately and un-
justly deprived, I repeat, is not onl^ a natural
right, but also an inherent prinaple of the
constitution. In the early periods, every man
had a vote for his representative. With some
little variation, the practice continued for
ages; it tmderwent considerable alterations
at the conquest; a period at which the goodly
fabric of Anglo-Saxon government was under-
mined, and the structure of tyranny erected
in its stead.
^ It has been observed, that the Revolution
of 1088 does not produce the advantages
which might have been expected from such
an event. It is true that, at the Revolution,
universal suffrage was not dispensed to tbe
people with that liberality which it ought to
Yiagm been ; but still the present form of
government in my opinion, no more resembles
the revolution^ thaa a dead putrid canase
does a living body,
VOL. xxm. i
^ A. D. 179*. f818
** The principal advantage of the RevoIutMft
was, that it made tbe chief magistrate respoi^
sible Ux his trust, by establishmg the right of
tbe people to alter the line of succession to the
throne. The House of Hanover, if they aro
wise, will not be averse to revolution princi-
ples ; for^t is in consequence of tJbose princi-
ples that the present monarch reigns m Bri-
tain« A worthy member, I believe with the
best of intentions, called another to order,
and said he was going too far :~no man, I
apprehend^ goes too far, unless he goes beyond
the rule of nght-^unless he violates the truth.
If the members who compose a government
abuse their trust, may they not te reinated?
And, if there existed a right in any precediM
feneration to amend the constitution, can it
e said that that right does not equally bekmg
to the present?
« Let us then endeavour to instruct the
people in their rights, and to inform than of
our views and our intentions ; they wiU come
and sign our netitions, and we slttll be ena-
bled to send tnem up subscribed by a mijo-
ritv of the people. The voice of the people
wul be heanl, whenever it is spoken in the
language of truth, and by a number ao
respectable as to command attention ; and it
will soon have that respectability, if we have
reason on our side.
^^ As to the manner in which the union is
to be formed, we may. find precedents for it in
our early history ; but the first thmg to he
done, is to enlighten the people ;— endeavour
to diffuse tbe principle on which you act.
When you have got a sufficient number in
every district, establish a correspondence
among them ; — show them the necessity of
unitins; in the common plan of co-operation;
then the people, assembled in the difiierent
departments of Uie country, will resemble the
ancient folkmotes, and wUl speak in language
too reasonable to be confuted, and too peremp-
tory to be refused.
'^ The manner in which they should organiie
themselves is of very important consideration ;
and they ought to be particularly careful what
persons they choose tor delc^Ues to the next
convention : let them be plain men, such as
I see here; — none who have ever breathed
the pestilential air of a court--K)r bowed the
knee to aristocracy. Let us renounce all
attachment to parties, and be no more de-
ceived by the pretended patriotism of the
great. During.the American war, reformers
and patriots sprung up like mushrooms,
without any diminution of public burthens.
Like mushrooms they were shortp-lived ; for
they sprung from a soil of dung, a hot-bed of
corruption. Pitt has succeeded to Fox, and
Fox to Pitt, without any referm being ob-
tained ; but let us no longer put fiiith in suoh
men, unless they bring forward a reform
founded on annual parliaments and universal
snffinge:— that only is th^ kind j)f reform
which will satisfy the people, and which they
will nev«r cease loclaimas their due. Depend
5 G
819]
34 GEORGE lU.
Pneetdingi agabut Jouph GemU
(880
tipon it, whenever the leaden of parties see
that the people are determined upon having
their riehtsy they will not only endeavour to
vwim along the stream, but will strive to
direct its course. Trust them not — ^they did
not come forward in the hour of public
danger; — why then should they be trusted,
when they seek your favour only for personal
convenience ?
^ The city of York has been proposed as a
proper and centrical place for the meeting of
next convention ; but I can assure you uiat
city is the seat of a proud aristocracy, the seat
of an archbishop; however, I would not
object to going tnere : as the saviour of the
world was often found in the company of
sinners, let us go there for the same eracious
purpose, to convert to repentance. The Dorders
of tliis country and England were mentioned
by another member, and I should rather prefer/
some place there ; for we should have this
pleasing reflection, that we meet for promoting
philanthropy and peace, on the ground which
liad been oraen drenched with the blood of
our ancestors. Let us then, fellow citizens,
unite heart and hand to bury the hatchet of
natural antipathjr, which the wicked policy of
courts once instig^ated us to wield. Let us
brighten the chain of nationai friendship.
Let there be no other wish, either among
Scots or English, than to obtain freedom, and
no other rivalship, than who shall best de-
serve it.*'
; Further^ at a meeting of the said associa-
tion, upon the 25th day of the said month of
November 1793, or on some one or other of
the da^rs of that month, or of the months
aforesaid, within the room or mason-lodse
•foresaid, Alexander Callender, one of the
• members, having made a motion of the follow-
ing or similar tenor, '< That in case the
mmister, or any other member of either
- House of parliament, bring forward a motion
for leave to bring in a convention bill, such as
' has passed in Ireland, to prevent the people
from meeting according to their just risnts
by the Revolution, the same motion shall be
notice to the delegates to meet in convention,
to assert their rights ;" the said motion was
made the subject of discussion in the said
meeting, on the 87th day of the said month,
or on one or other of the days of that month,
or the mopths aforesaid, when sundry amend-
ments, of a wicked and seditious tendency
were proposed; and the said motion, with
the amendments, having been, by the said
meeting, referred to some of the members
thereof as a committee, to draw up a motion
from the whole, Charles Sinclair, one of the
members of the said committee, did, upon the
28th day of the said month of November, or
on one or other of the days of tliat month, or
of the months aforesaid,, read to the said asso-
ciation or meetmg, when assembled within
the room or mason- lodge aforesaid, the
amendments upon the said motion, as agreed
on by him and the committee aforesaid; when
the said asaociatton or meeliiig fid wickedly
and feloniously, then and there, all the niem-
bers standing ca their foet, solemnly and una^
nimously come to a resolution of the follow-
ing import or tenor :
''That this convention, considering fhe
calamitous consequences of any act of the
Imslature which may tend to deprive the
whole, or any part of the people, of their un-
doubted right to meet, either by themselves
or by delegation, to discuss any matterrelalivie
to their common interest, whether of a public
or private nature, and holding the same to be
totally inconsistent with the first psindplea
and auety of society, and also subveruve of
our ownibcknowledsed ccMistitutional liberties^
do hereby declare, before God and the world,
that we shall follow the wholesome example
of former times, b^ p&ying^ im> regaid to anj
act which shall militate agamst the constitu-
tion of our country; ana shall continue to
assemble, and consider of the best means by
which we can accomplish a real representa-
tion of the people, and annuaj election, until
compelled to desist by superior force.
'' And we do resolve,
'' That the first notice given for the intro-
duction of a convention bill, or any bill of a
similar tiendency to that passed in Ireland^ in
the last session of their parliament;
** Or any bill for the suspension of the
Habras Corpus act, or the act of preventing
wrongous imprisonment, and against undue
delays in trials in North Britain ;
'* Or in case of an invasion ;
'< Or the admission oi any foreign troons
whatsoever into Great Britain or Ireland ; aJl,
or any one, of these calamitous circumstances,
shall be a sienal to the different delegates to
repair to sucn place as the secret committee
of this convention shall appoint; and the
first seven members shall have power to de*
clare tlie sittings permanent; and twenty-
one shall constitute a convention, and pro*
ceed to business.
*' The convention doth therefore resolve,
That each delegate, immediately on his return
home, do convene his constituents, and ei«
plain to them the necessity of electing a
delegate, or delegates, and of establishing a
fiind without delay, against any of these
emergencies, for his or their expense; and
that they do instruct the said delegate, or
delegates, to hold themselves ready to depart
at one hour*s warning.''
Which seditious resolution the said Joseph
Gerrald not only approved of, but immediately
on its being so agreed to and passed, did, on
the dav, and within the place aforesaid,
wickedly and feloniously address the said
meeting or association, in a speech of the
following or similar import :
<' I rise to congratulate the conveMion on
the adoption of this resolutbn, not only oa
the propriety of the measure itself, put on
that unanimity and solemniQr with which it
has passed.
891]
fm^ SedUum*
A. Dl 17M.
[828
"" *^ i baveBot been able to proGine a copy
of the iniquitous act which haa eicited such
abhonenoe; but I have here the beads of
the* bill iu the speech of Mr. Grattao, the
man who, while he spoke against the bill, at
the same time betrayed the liberties of his
country. This bill, commonly callodj^ie^on-
f Uiliuii billy which jpassed in the last session
of the parliament of Ireland, and which is the
prototype of what may be attempted in Bri-
tain^ breathes such a spirit of cruelty and op-
pression, that if tyranny were to be per-
sonified, it could not speak in language more
insulting to the feelings of mankind.
- ** By the first head the delegates of the
people are not allowed to meet to petition
parliament. Surely despotism could not be
more strongly expresseid even in Turkey.
There everv bashaw listens to the petitions
of his trembling slaves ; yet that privilege is
denied to the people of Ireland. But it has
been said, to use a common expression, this
bill was first passed in Ireland to feel the
pulse of the people of Britain, that our rulers
might know if it beat high with indignation,
or if the blood run coldly in our veins; and
we are willing- to bow our necks to the yoke,
and suffer in fear and in silence.
" '' In the second head, they are forbidden to
meet for the purpose of asking the redress of
grievances. Good God! What is govern-
ment instituted for, if it is not for the redress
of grievances ? I had thought that in the most
despotic government the people were per-
mitted to utter their complaints, and beg to
be relieved of their sufiterings ; but, at the
close of the 18th century, we find this last
indulgence to slaves denied to a part of the
BritiA empire. Our government boasts that
it is the best in Uie world ; but it is not in
Ireland that we are to look for its excel-
lencies. Whenever a government tells the
people that they must not petition, that
government is tyranny; and whatever you
may be told of its acts of oarliament in favour
of libertv, these acts or parliament are set
aside ; they are mere pieces of parchment,
and of no more value.
"^ '' The third head makes it a capital offence
, to consider of any public concern. . Now, to
make a road, or build a bridge, are public
concerns; and of course the people of Ireland
cannot meet on business of that nature,
without making themsdves liable to the
penalty of this law.
** Hioush I could not get a copy of this
bill, the heads, which I have read, are suffi-
ciently explanatory of its detestable princi-
ples; and I hope the measure which has
passed this night will convince the minister,
that we are determined to suard against every
attempt that may be made to deprive us of
our debts; and though bv some it may be
thought a bold, bv some a aaring measure, yet
it wul be found the best for securing the
)>eafe of our cotmtry; for if such a law were
suffered to pass, if men were not allowed to
utter their complaints, a number of fierce and
rancorous passions would arise, and we would
seek to appeal to that last terrible decision,
the event of which is uncertain, but which
God and nature allows.
** If the servility of the people had been
less ; if they liad dared to meet, and, in place
of murmuring, to have told their rulers that
there was danger in seeking to deprive them
of their liberties, we would not have had to
adopt this resolution to-night ; but when I
saw the calm deliberate countenances of all
present, and the solemn manner in which it
was passed, I was convinced that it would not
only be a resolution of words, but a rule of
action."
And further, upon the said 28lh day of
November, or one or other of the days of
that month, or months aforesaid, and within
the room or mason-lodge aforesaid, after tho
foresaid resolution had been so passed, and
the foresaid speech so made by tlie said Jo-
seph Gerrald, a motion having been made in
the said meeting, in the following words, or
in words of a. similar import and tendency :
^ That a secret committee of three and the
secretary be appointed to determine the place
where such convention of emer^ncy shall
meet : that such place shall remam a secret
with them and with the secretary of this con-
vention: and that each delegate shall, at the
breaking up of the present session, be en-
trusted witli a sealea letter, containing the .
name of the place of meeting : this letter
shall be delivered unopened to his consti-
tuents; the receipt of which shall be ac*
knowledged by a letter to the secretary, pre-
served in the same state, until the period
shall arrive at which it shall be deemed ne-
cessary for the delegates to set out;" the said
meeting did wickeoly and seditiously unani*
mously approve of the same. And at a sub-
sequent meeting, upon the 4th day of De-
cember, 1793, or one or other of the days of
that month, or months aforesaid, and wit in
the said room or mason-lodge aforesaid, it
having been moved by Maurice Margarot,one
of the memt>ers of the said meeting, ** That
the moment of any ille^ dispersion of the
present convention, shall be considered as a
summons to the delegates to repair to the
place of meeting, appointed for the conventioa
of emergency, by tne secret committee ; and
that the secret committee be instructed to
proceed without delay to fix the place of meet-
mg;'' the said meetins did wickedly and se-
ditiously, ^* unanimously resolve the same,
and appointed the secret committee to pro-
ceed as desired.^' And further, on Friday the
6th day of December, 1793, or upon one or
other of the davs of that month, or of the
months aforesaid, the said illeeal association
or meetins naving ag^ain assemoled in a room
or" work-shop belonging to, or possessed by,
John I^ng, wrigbt, situated in lady Lawson's
yard, south side of Crosscauseway, in the pa^
rish of St. Cuthbert's and shire of Edinburgh,
oS9j
34 GB0R6E UL
Proceedings mgidnd Jiueph Gerrald
Htfnr Davidscmy «m|. sheriff'SolMlilate of
Edinburgh, having, in discharge of hu dat^»
repured to the said room or work*shop, in
order to disperse the said illegal meeting, the
said Joseph Geiiald, with his associates, did
then and there resist the said sheriff-substi-
tute, and refused to disperse without being
compelled; and so mucn so, that after the
said sheriff-substitute had entered the room,
and desired them to disperse, the said Joseph
Gerrald wickedly and feloniously exclaimed,
** The rights of Britons are Tio&ted by this
illegal interruption of our peaceful meeting.
it is force, not reason, with which our ene-
mies assail us. I defy them to assign
one reason against the lawfulness of our
meetings ; but if they thirst after our blood,
they may now ^tify themselves; mine I
shaJl see flow with pleasure, if with it flows
the freedom of my country." At least, he
expressed himself in language of the above
import; and did aflerwaros take the chair as
wreses of the meeting, and presumptuously
did continue to sit and act, until he was, by
the said sheriff- substitute, pulled from the
chair; which conduct of the said Joseph Ger-
rald was highly ag^yated, from the circum-
stance that the said illegal association had
been, the precedmg day, dispersed by the
nu«istrates of Edinburgh, as being illegal ;
and also, that the said Joseph Gerrald had,
the preceding day, been apprehended on a
wairant of the said sheriff-substitute, and or-
dered to be committed to gaol, for being a
member of the said iHeeal association till li-
berate in due course of law. And the said
Joseoh Gerrald, when apprehended and car-
ried before Harry Davidson, esq. sheriff-sub-
ttitute of the county of Edinburgh, on the 5th
of December, 179S, did, in his presence, emit
and sign a declaration. And sundry papers
having been found in the possession of the
said Joseph Gerrald when first apprehended,
and afterwards inspected in his presence, by
«ithority of the sheriff of Edinburgh, two
lists or inventories of these papers were made
up; one of which, consisting of ten articles,
subscribed by the said Joseph Gerrald, and
William Scott, procurator fiscal of the county
of Edinburgh; and the other, of nine articles,
IS subscribed by the said William Scott and
the sheriff-substitute. Which inventories,
witli the whole articles therein contained
(except No. l. which had been returned to
the said Joseph Gerrald), as also, the fore-
said declaration, emitted by him before the
sheriff-substitutc of Edinbur^ ; together
with copies of Nos. 78, 79, and 80, of the
newspaper calfed, " The Edinburgh Gazet-
teer;'* as also, the scroll or draught of the
minutes of the said general convention, fix)m
the «9th of October to the 4th of December,
1793, consisting of 95 pages,* and found jn
• See the Minutes of the Convention and
the extracts from Nos. 78,79, and 80, inserted
in the case of Skirving, ante, pp. 391, et seq.
the custody of William 8ldrvi]ig, wecmtUy
to the said convention, when apprehended
by warrant of the sheriff of Edinbumi, in the
month of December last, being No. 1 of
the inventory of papers found in the posees-
sion of the said William Skirvine, and made
up in presence of the sheriff of £dinbiiig;h,
upon the 5th of December last, with the said
inventory itself, and the whole of the other
papers and writings therdn contained; as
also, an inventory of sundry papers found in
the custody of Charles Sinclair, one of the
members of the said convention, ai^ made
up in presence of the sheriff of Edinburgh,
upon the 7th of December, 1793, consistmg
of twenty-one articles, with the whole of the
said twentv-one articles themselves, being all
to be used in evidence against the saidJo-
seph Gerrald on his trial, will, for that pur-
pose, in due time be lodged with the clerk of
the hieh court of justiciary, before which he
is to be tried, that he may have an opportu-
nity of seeing the same. At least, times and
places above-mentioned, the said acts of se«
dition were committed, and the said Joseph
Gerrald is guilty actor, or art and part thereof.
All which, or part thereof, being found proven
by the vodict of an assize, TOfore our lord
justice genera], lord justice clerk, and lords
commissioners of justiciary, in a court of jus-
tidarv to be holden by tlriem within the cri-
minal court-house of Edinburgh, upon the
seventeenth day of February instant, the said
Joseph Gerrald, above complained uoon,
ought to be punished with the pains of law,
to deter others from committing the like
crimes in all time coming. Our will is here*
fore, &c.
LIST OF WITNESSES.
1. Harry Davidson, esq. sheriff-substitute,
or late sheriff-substitute, of the county
of Edinburgh,
9. William Scott, procurator-fiscal of the
county of Edinburgh.
3. James Williamson, clerk to the said Wi]«
liam Scott.
4. Archibald Welsh, also clerk to the said
William Scott.
5. John Dingwall, writer in Edinburgh.
6. Joseph Mack, writer in Edinburgh.
7. James Lyon, messenger in Edinburgh.
8. John McDonald, residenter in Edinburgh.
9. Neil M'Glashan, residenter in Edinburgh.
10. Alexander Williamson, sheriff-officer in
Edinburgh.
11. Georse Ross, clerk in the gazetteer-office^
Edinburgh. '
1 3. William Ross, clerk intheGaxetteer-office,
' Edinburgh.
13. Alexander Aitcbeson, student of medi-
cine, residing in Canongatc of Ed'm-
burgh.
14. Mitchell Young, punter in Edinburgh,
15. John Wardlaw, writer in Edinburgh.
825]
fit Senium*
A. D. 17M*
t82S
16. John Laiogy wrig^t in Nkhobon's-streety
Edinburgh.
17. John Clarky mason in Edinburth.
IB. Wiiliam Romanes^ UMrchant, fawn-mar-
ket, Edinburgh.
19. Thonms Cockbum, m^chant^Lawn-mar-
kety Edinburgh.
30. Samuel Patersoni merchant in Edin-
burgh.
SI. Andrew Newton, formerly tobacconist in
Dunse, now residing m 8t. Patrick's
square, Edinburgh.
222. Alex. Reid, joiner and cabinet-maker, re-
siding in Edinburgh.
93. John Oourlaj, watch-maker in Edin-
burgh.
54. ArehiMdd Binnie, type-founder, in Edin-
burgh.
25. David Downie, goldsmith in Edinburgh.
96. John Buchanan, baker in Canongate of
Edinburgh.
itr. Alexander Fortune, leather merchant in
CanoDgage of Eainbuijh.
58. John M'Intyre, teacher in CoUege-wynd
of Edinburgh.
59. The right hon. Thomas Elder, lord pro-
vost of the city of Edinburgh.
do. Niel M'Vicar, esq. one of the magutrates
of Edinburgh.
01. James Lmiik, one of the deputy city
clerks of Edinbureh.
S9, John Campbell, residenter in Edinburgh.
55. John Fraser, residenter in Edinburgh.
^4. Benjamin Rise, residenter in Edinburgh.
LIST OF EXCULPATORY WITNESSES. *
Right hon. Robert M'Queen, lord justice
clerk.
jSIr Philip Ainslie, bart.
Miss Charlotte Ainslie, daughter to sir
Philip.
Mrs. Watson, alias Rochead, widow of
Rochead, esq. of Inverleith.
Mrs. Christian Dundas, sister to the secretary
of state.
Miss Dundas, niece to do.
Ch&rles Hay, esq. advocate.
Davidson, clerk to Charles Hay, esq.
WUn€$fei to prove the charge in the declina-
ture againU lord justice clerk.
Dr. Yule.
George Sinclair, son to the late Robert Man-
son Sinclair, of Bridge End.
To ditproroe the papers alleged to liaoe been
taken from Charles Sinclair ; and to prove
that the messenger^ Lyon^ had rrfuud to shorn
the warranty although Sinclair had frequently
desired it^ alleging he had orders from the
sheriff and procurator fiscal, not to show it,
John Pringle, esq. late sheriff of the county
of Edinburgh.
Hairy Davidson, esq. sheriff-substitute.
* In the original edition, this list was
placed at the end of the trial.
To prtyte that they had delvoered a paper to
Gerraldj out of Charles Sinclair's papers^wkich
he (GerraldJ claimed as his own, prior to
Charles Sinctaif^s extra-judicial ej^amination.
George Rois^ clerk. Gazetteer-office.
To prove that Girrald was a member of the
same section with himself^ and never onu at^
tended a meeting qfsach section.
LIST or ASSISE.
James Donaldson, bookseller in Edin-
burgh.
David Ramsay, /printer there.
David Deuchar, seal engraver there.
Peter Hill, bookseller tl^e.
!^ Alexander Wight, baker there.
Thomas Tibbets, hatter there.
John Bell, bookseller there.
Alexander iPitcaim, insurance -broker
there.
David Bridges, merchant there.
10 James Hunter, merchant there.
Hector Gavin, engraver there.
James Cunningham, baker there*
Andrew MiUigan, watch-case maker there.
Sir William For^s, hart, banker there.
15 Alexander Spence, jeweller there.
Peter Mathie, jeweller there.
John Millar, optician there.
Alexander Gardner, jeweller there*
William Creech, bookseller there.
SO Thomas Hutchison, merchant there«
Andrew Kay, Glazier there.
William Cuinins;, shoemaker there.
Thomas Kennedy, glover there.
• jQhn Hutchison, merchant there.
S5 James FvfcL merchant there.
John SibWd, smith there.
Alexander Nisbet, manu&cturer there.^
James Collier, merchant in Edinbui^h.
John Little, merchant there.
SO Alexander Dudgeon, baker there.
William Ranken, taylor there.
Patrick Main, painter there.
Alexander Smith, baker there.
John Spence, painter there.
S5 James Hunter, baker there.
Alexander Wright, wine-merphant there^
James Craig, architect there.
William Murray, baker there.
Thomas Hunter, grocer there.
40 William Calder, merchant there.
John Sinclair, merchant there.
James Simpson, baker there.
Thomas Malcolm, shoemaker there.
William Crawford, smith there.
45 Archibald Campbell, brewer there.
Rob. M^ocen.
Albx. MoitnAY.
Dav, Ra£.
Lord Justice C/crA.— Joseph Genald, what
io you say to this? Are you guilty or i»t
guilty?
Mr. Gerrald.^Not guilty^ my lord.
827] S4 GEOEGE UL
ProceetBngs ^punti Jtmph Gerrald
[828
Mr. OtJto.^— My lords, in a case like tlie
present, which has been pleaded by counsel
of the very first eminence, and which has al-
ready leoeiTed the solemn consideratica of
this Gocirt, it is a difficult task for any coun-
sel, and especially for a young counsel, to go
over the same erounds again, and that too
with the view of directly and strongly main-
taining, that other views oimht to have guided
your fordships iudgment formerly, and that
other views ought te guide it now. Added to
this, is that firmly-rooted and wide-spread no-
tion of the guilt of all those who stand at this
«bar accused of sedition. The temper of men*s
minds, firom many obvious causes, is such,
that they consider a person at this bar, under
this accusation, as already condemned ;— that
it is almost unnecessary to plead for him, ex-
4xpt as Koin^ through the forms; while he,
whose fortune it is to undertake such a cause,
is considered as, in e^ct, a sharer of the
crimes imputed to him whom he defends, and,
by doing his duty, may incur all the conse*
juences that oueht only to follow his not do-
ing it. — A3 to the panels thus brought before
you, the public eye considers them as the
personal enemies of us all.— They do not aim,
«s we are taucht to think, at the ruin of this
or that indiviaual — we have not merely a re-
mote interest in their destruction, but it is
absolutely essential to our own personal safety.
Our properties, our lives, our all, are repre-
sented as the objects of their violence : and
aninst danger so near, and danger so dread-
ful, we should not be scrupulous about our
means of defence. The strongest feelings of
our nature, those Qf self-preservation itself,
are thus called into instant energy amongst
us all. It is difficult in such circumstances
to iudge right; and the difficulties are alto-
gether on another side irom what takes place
commonly. In the common case, the chief
danger is of injustice arising from compassion
and mercy. Here the danger is of injustice
being done (unwillingly done, yet done effec-
tually) from motives of fear, and of anger
agains) those who have caused that fear. In
such a case it behoves us to examine our-
selves ; to be sure of the grounds upon whidi
we proceed ; to banish the least appearance
of passion; and to renounce a judgment,
however deliberately considered, if an after
deliberation show it to be even doubtful. It
4a impossible to deliberate too much.
Knowing well that in these respects your
lordships think exactly as I do, and encou-
raged by this consideration, I studl go on to
* He was appointed a lord of session on
93d November, 1811, — One of the lords com-
missioners of justiciary on 3d March, 1812, —
And one of the lords commissioners of the
jury court on 26th June, 1816.— There were
one or two slight errors in the printed report
of this argument, which have been kindlv
po'mted out to me by lord Gillies, and whicn
are here corrected.
state, as well as I can, such arguments as
have occurred to me in favour of ue unfortu*
nate eentleman who stands at your krdshms
bar. 1 hope to show your lord&ips, that Um
indictment is altogether irrelevant^at any
rate that it is irrelevant to infer that punisb-
ment which has been indicted in the other
cases of sedition.
The crime charged in the major proposition
of this indictment, is sedition, in vague and
general terms, — I know ver^r well, that by the
laws of this country, explained as they are,
and ought to be, by the practice of this Court,
the* crime in this part of the indictment may
be charged in general terms. I know that
many crimes are so : in cases of robl>eiy and
murder, for instance, it is not necessary to
state these crimes particularly, or to refer to
the statutes, which prohibit the commission
and affix the punishment due to these offences.
But where the law has annexed different de-
grees of punishment to different species or do*
grees of the same offisnce, then, if the crime
IS charged in general in the major proposition
of the indictment, the least culpable species
of the offence must be meant, and the lessejr
punishment only can be inflicted. Thus, in
the case of theft, simple theft is not a capital
crime; but if aggravated by house-breaking^
it is punished with death. Now, if theft is
charged generally, without this aegravation,
the arbitrary punishment due to u\e offence
of simple theft, is, all that your lordships can
award. In the same manner, with regard Xq
sedition, I believe it is laid down, by every
writer of eminence, that there are two species
of sedition, verbal and real — a smaller and a
greater offence, to which our laws have an-
nexed two different degrees of punishment.
The punishment of the first ofience, verbal
sedition, is fixed by a statute which I shall af-
terwards mention particularly; and as sedi-
tion is charged generally in this indictment,
the lesser oflteuce must be understood. Upon
this ground alone, I trust the punishment
must DC restricted to the lesser species of the
crime; for if.it was intended to accuse this
gentleman of a greater offence, the greater of-
feoce ought to have been stated ; it cannot,
therefore, be construed into any thing more
than verbal sedition, or leasing-making, and
the lesser degree of punishment can only be
inflicted.
I trust, from this arsument, that it must
be considered as verbal sedition. It will at
least be admitted, that where a crime is
charged in general, the degree and species
must be gathered from the particulars charged
in the minor proposition. The questions,
therefore, now to be submitted to your lord»
ships consideration, are these : —
In the first place — ^Whetlier tlie facts stated
in the minor proposition, amount to any
crime at all? — whether they amount to sedi-
tion of any kind whatever ?
In the next place— Whether, if they are
criminal^ they amoimt to verbal or xeal sedi-
SSSfi
JarSiditkm.
A. D. 1794.
[8SQ
tion? and if ihey amount only to ireilMil sedi-i
fion, what is the punishment affixed by our
law to that crime?
The first charge in the indictment is, that
^ the said Joseph Gerrald, above complained
upon, has presumed to commit, and is guilty
actor, or art and part, of the foresaid crime,
in so far as a number of seditious and evil-
disposed persons having illegally assembled
at Edinburgh, during tm months of October,
November, and December, 1799, the said
Joseph GenUd, above complained upon, did
ceme into this country, for the purpose of
joining and assisting these persons, and be-
came a member of tneir illeeal and seditious
association and meetine; which illeaal and
seditious association and meeting, at first as-
sembled under the designation of a General
Convention of the Friends of the People, but
thereafter, presumptuously and seditiously as*
Bumed the name of the British Convention of
the Delegates of the People, associated to ob-
tain Universal Sufiinge and Annual ParUa-
ments."
My lord, the illegality and sedition laid to
the charge of the British convention, must
consist either in the meeting itself being ille-
gal, or it must consist in the illegality of the
object which they had in view — that is, the
obtaining univer^l suffrage and annual par-
liaments,— a reform in the representation of
the Commons House of Parliament.
Setting aside the object of the convention,
the first question is^ whether such a meeting
b or is not legal ? whether is it allowed, or
whether is it punishable by the laws of this
country? Laying out of consideration the
object which they had in view, the question
atfects everyone who hears me; for who is
there amongst us who has not been present
at some convocation without legal authority f
If this is to be punished as sedition, every
one present is liable to that punishment.
The actions of tiiese men so assembled to-
gether (I sliall speak afterwards of their
speeches and resolutions, but I say their ac-
tions) were inoffensive and orderly ; they are
not accused even of the slightest breach of
the peace. No doubt that, by the ancient
statutes of this country, convocations within
boroughs were prohibited; but what was the
nature of those convocations will appear from
the statutes themselves. I shall therefore
read the act 1563, ch. 85 : — *^ It is statute
and ordained, that nane of our soveraine
ladie's lieges presume, pretende or take upon
hand to roake onie privie conventiones nor
assemblies within burgh, put on armour,
cleeith themselves with weapons, or make
-sound of trumpet, or talbrone, or use culver-
inees, displayed banners, hand seingies, or
utners instruments bellical quhat-sumcver in
•onie time hereafter, without the special li-
cence of our said soveraine ladic and her
bienes' magistrates within the burgh quhair
*ihe said tumult and uproar chauncis to be had
^and obtained thereto, under tbe paiue of
I
death.^— Sir Geo. Mackemie, in hii observa-
tion upon this act, ssfys^ — ** It secmsy that
mere convocations or assemblies are not, pcf
sf, punishable by death, without putting on
armour or displaying banners." — Thus, in or-
der to bring the British convention withia
this enactment) its members must have ap-
peared in armour, and with banners^ sttr«
roonded with all the ** pride, pomp, and cis*
cumstance of war." The appearance of their
meeting was surely very different. Their only
armour was their tongues and their pens, and
a few blotted and blurred sheets of paper the
only banners which they displayed. It is not
upon this act then that any proceeding against
tnis convention can be founded. Unarmed
convocations were not at this time prohibited
by an^ law whatever, nor were they declared
to be illegal until the accession of James 6th«
It was we wish of that monarch, as yout
lordships know, to abolis^ nresbyterv, and
to repress the powers of Ecclesiastical juria-
diction vested in the presbyterian cler^.
The disputes which thus arose betwixt him
and the cleray, was the occasion of a statute
upon this subject. By the act 1594, ch..lS],
^ It is atatute and ordained be our said sove-
raine lord and his three estaites that nane of
his hienes sulgects of quhat-suroever qualitie,
estaito or function thev be of, spiritual or teni*
poral, presume or tauk upon hand to cenvo-
cate, conveene or assemble themselves to*
^ddir, for balding of councelles, conven-
tiones, or assemblies, to treat, consult and
determinat in ony matter of estaite civile or
ecclesiastical (except in the ordinar judge-
ment) without his majesties special comr
mandement or expresse licence, had andob*
teined to that effect, under the paines or-
dained be the lawes and actes of parliament
against sik as unlawfully convocatis thekingis
lieges."
After this an act was passed in the same
reign, 1606, chap. 17, by which the act of
1584 was confirmed, with an addition that
I shall now read to your lordships. ** That
na person nor persons within burgh, what-
somever rank, quality, or condition they be
of, presume nor take upon hand from this
forth, under whatsomever cullour or pre-
text, to convocate or assemble themselves
together at any occasion, except they make
due intimation of the lawful causes of their
meetings to the provost and bailUes of that
burgh, and obtein their licence thereto, and
that na thing be done nor attempted by them
in their saids meetings, whilk may tend to
the derogation or violation of the actes of
parliament, lawes, and constitution made for
the well and quyetness of the saids burghs.
Declaring by thir presents, the saids unlawful
meetings and tbe persons present thereat to
be factious and seditious, and all proceedings
therein to be null and of nane availl. And
the saids persons to be punished in their
bodies, goods, and geare, with all ri§our oo|V*
forqae to the lawes of this realme."
t
9Si] 34 GE0B6E IJt,
ProeeeHngi tigmui Jmepk Gtmid
[sat
"^ Your lordships Me, i^jaX by this act^ all
pcffSDDS aie prohibited of any lank, quality,
or condition^ from coovocating or assembhiig
themselves together, upon any occasion,
except they give due intimation to the provost
and magistrates.
My lords, it is no doubt true, that- if these
acts are still in force, they apply directly to
the British convention ; but it these acts are
still in force, they apply not merely to the
British convenUon, but to nine-tenths of all
^^the meetings that are held in Edinburgh.
These statutes, if enforced, would be attend-
ed with effects at once the most serious and
ludicrous. We might be conveyed from the
rooms in Georee's-street, or George's-^quare,
to. the Tolbooth, from the Tolbooth to your
lordship*s bar, from your lordship's bar to the
htriks at Woolwich, and from the hulks to
Botany-bay, with a catastrophe very dissimi*
lar from the commencement.
Upon these statutes sir George Mackeniie
says, *^ this crime of simple convocation is
orainarily pursued before the council, and is
seldom punished, either by the council or
justice court, twnquam crimen per sc, but as
the aggravating quality of a riot or other
crime.*^ My lords, this was the case before
the revolution ; that it was never prosecuted
but as the agmvating quaUty of anoti^er
crime. Since the revolution, I believe there
has been no trial whatever for this offimce ; I
apprehend therefore that prosecutions upon
inese statutes are prohibited by a passage in
the claim of rights, which I shall now read
to your lordships. In the claim of rights is
the following passage: — ^^That the causing
pursue and forfeit persons upon stretches of
old and obsolete laws, upon frivolous and
weak pretences, upon hune and defective
probation, as particularly the late earl of
Ar^le,* are contrary to law." My lords, if
before the revolution the meeting in unarmed
convocations was only punished as an ag^nt-
vating quality of another crime, and since
has not been punished at all, we must neces-
sarily conclude that it falls within this en-
actment, in the claim of rijghts, of obsolete
statutes. As an aggravatmg quality of a
crime, it may operate to prevent the mitiga-
tion, or to increase the severity of a punish-
ment;—but though it may increase the de-
gree of llie crime, it cannot alter the nature
of it; it cannot convert verbal sedition into
real sedition.
But. if any thing farther is necessary to
show that no man can now be tried upon
these old statutes, it will fully appear from
two acts that I am now to mention. The
act a^inst conventicles, 1670, chap. 5, has
the follawing preamble :—'< Forsameikle as
the assembling and convocating of his ma-
jesty's subjects, without his majesty's war-
rand and authority, is a most dangerous and
• See his case in this €k>llectios. Vol 8,
p. 843. ' '
w^wful practice, prohilift and diiebarnA
by several laws and acts of parliament, under
high and great pains. And that aotwitb-
steodii^ thereof divers disaffected and sedi-
tious persons, under the specious but fakio
pretences of religion, and reiif^us exercbes^
presume to make, and be present at, con-
venticies and unwarrantable meetings, and
conventiotis of the subjects, which are the
ordinary seminaries of separation and rebel-
lion, tendins to the prejudice of the public
worship of God in the churches.*
Your lordships will observe, that In this
preamble, it is positively declared that oan-
venticles fell within these old statutes made
r* 1st unarmed convocatioBs, previous to
statute. Those conventicles were sub-
ject to punishment, as being unarmed con-
vocations of the people, aiM fiftlEnff within
the statute I formerly read to your lordships
enacted in the reign of James 6th. In the
rei^ of William and Mary, this act against
rehgious conventicles was expressly repSiled;
but I say the repeal of that act is of no avails
if these old statutes are still in force. It is of
DO avail, because men who so meet in com
venticles may be punished under the old
statutes passed in the rdgn of Jaaoes 6Ul«
Unless therefore this statute, which was con*
sidered at the time as a great atfeunment to
the liberties of the country, unless it is ooq*
sidered as nugatory, we must understand that
idl those statutes against unarmed convoca-
tions are now obsolete. In consequence of
these acts every dei^eyman, who b not a
member of the established church of this
country, might be punished for holding un-
armed convocations. By the act passed under
James 6th against such convocations, the
preacher miffht be carried from the pulpit^
and the auotence from their seats, to this
bar, and punished with death ! The act of
William and Mary, therefore, is of no avail,
if those old statutes against unarmed conven-
tions are still in existence. Indeed, from the
absurdity to which ^ey would lead, it must
be demonstrable to your lordships, that they
can be no longer put in force.
Holding, therefore, that the simple act of
meetine in convention, as these persons are
said to have done, in itself contains notiiing
criminal. The question that next remains
to be considered is, whether criminality is
attached to them on account of the professed
object which they had in view, the obtaining
universal su£Brage and annual parliaments, —
a reform in the representation of the Com-
mons House of Parliament.
My lords, this is a question of politics on
which I have no occasion to deliver my own
opuiion. All that I have now to inquire ia^
whether the particular charges, prefenod
against the panel in this indictment, amouot
to the generic crime of which he is accused
The panel is here said to have been guilty of
sedition, because he associated witii a number
of oibeQ) in order to obtain uniieera^ suffiraga
83S]
jbf a^SWUHU
A. D. I7M.
[834
and Mininl pariiaaaents. Tfait Mempt maiy
ia one sense of the word be tenned illegal---
inasmHch as it certainly had for its object an
alteration of the existing laws of this country.
But in this sense of the word, the proposal
of eveiy new law may be equally tenned
"Illegal. It must therefore be a deferent spe-
cies of illegality firom this that tlie public
Srosecutor annexes to this convention, when
e oUto it an illepl and seditious meeting ;
and yet, my lords, if there is any new law,
or any alteration more than another upon our
present laws, in the propriety of which a
iDMority, aaKl a great one too^ of every de-
scnption of the people of this country has
concurred, it is in this one thinj; — of a re-
fimn in the representation of parliament.
Men of all ranks and descriptions, from the
highest to*the lowest, from the most learned
to die worst informed, have at one period or
another declared their approbation of this
measure. As to the mode or degree in which
it should be attempted, different opinions
have been held by different men; and this
difference as to the mode has hitherto pre-
vented the object itself from being attained.
Upon this point, all the eminent men who
at present shine in the councils of our nation
have declared their opinions, at one time or
another, and almost all of them have ac-
knowledged the necessity of ^ reform. Mr.
Pitt, who enjoys at present the favour of the
crown, and the confidence of parliament,
has given his opinion, not merely in favour
of reform, but decidedly in favour of that
species of reform which consists in intro-
ducing universal suffrage and annual parlia-
ments.* Mr. Fox has also declared himself
a friend to reform, though not to tlie same
length which Mr. Pitt has gone; and, on
this account, the gentleman at the bar has
spoken of this great statesman in terms of
considerable disapprobation. In the course
of a long political life, which might be re-
garded as unfortunate, if the enjoyment of
true glory were not to be preferred to the
possession of power, Mr. Fox has all alonff
declared himself an enemjr to universe
suffrage, and if I am not mistaken, to an-
nual parliaments. Where such great men
differ, it is not for us to decide ; but surely |
much blame cannot be imputed to the man
whose opinions are sanctioned by either of
such authorities. It would be hard, indeed,
if this i^ntleman were to be punished, merely
lor having adopted the opinions of Mr. Pitt in
preference to those of Mr. Fox — that the
aame sentiments which have served to place
one man at the head of the nation, should
expose another to the vengeance of her laws
* This mistake as to the opinions of Mr.
Pitt on the question of parliamentary reform,
I believe, originated in the expressions or
one of the counsel who defended Daniel
Holt— ^e his case, antl Vol. $9, p. 1228,
and the note, p. 1198 of the same volume.
VOL. XXIII.
— fhat they should raise the one person to the
height of preferment, to the pinnacle of his
ambition, and plunge the other into the
deepest abyss of human wretchedness.
My lords, what I am gping to read will
show you, that these sentiments have been
held bv men of the first eminence, in point
of rank, in point of reputed abihties, fortune,
and of power. The pamphlet from which I
read was published under the auspices of a
society which owed its formation in a great
measure to the duke of Richmond and Mr.
Pitt ; and of which they were long the lead-
ing members. The language does not dis*
erace its authors : — <' Every application, there-
fore, for the redress of the present grievances
of the nation, that shall be made to a body
of men, no longer under the influence of
their constituents, but, on the contrary, uni-
formly acting in subserviency to the viewa
and interests of the crown, must of necessity
be unsuccessful ; and firom the natural effect
of disappointment upon the human mind,
will probably impair the vigour of every fu-
ture exertion.'' In another passage, '^ that
the restoration of the Commons' House of
Parliament to 'freedom and independency, by
interposition of the great collective body of
the nation, is essentially necessary to our
existence as a free people.'^ I shall only
read one other passage : — ^ An equal repre-
sentation of the people in the great council
of the nation, annual elections and the uni-
versal right of sufirage, appear so reasonable
to the natural feelings of mankind, that no
sophistry can elude the force of the aigu-
ments which are urged in their favour ; and
they are rights of so tianscendent a nature,
that, in opposition to the claim of the
people, to their enjoyment, the longjest period
of proscription is pleaded in vain. They
were substantially enjoyed in the times of
the immortal Alfred ; they were cherished by
the wisest princes of the Norman line ; they
form the grand palladium of our nation ; they
onght not to be esteemed the grant of royal
favour; nor were they at first extorted by
violence from the hand of power. They are
the birthright of Englishmen, their best in-
heritance, which without the complicated
crimes of treason to their country, and injus-
tice to their posterity, tliey cannot alienate
or resien. They form that triple cord of
strengtn, which alone can be relied on, to
hold, in times of tempest, the vessel of the
state.*'
My lord, this charge then of having wished
for universal sufii*age and annual parliaments
contains nothing criminal, nothing relevant
to infer any punishment at all; and much
less the punishment that has been inflicted
on the crime of sedition. I am not now
maintaining that a reform in parliament is
expedient, and still less that annual p^iriia-
ments and universal suffrage should oe the
mode of that reform. That mode may b^
improper-- ao Mr. Fox thinks it; iu opposition
3 H
835] S4 GEORGE III. Proceeding ogaiM Joieph Gerrald
\m
to what Mr. Pitt thiiduy or at least.most cer-
tainly thought; and so your lordships, in
opposition to Mr. Pitt, may also thmk it.
But, if the duration of parliaments has been
different at different times, if the elective
franchise has also been different at different
times, and if our laws have centimes va-
ried and altered both, and may in future
vary and alter them again ; then this is a
Subject upon which every inhabitant of the
country is at liberty to form his own opinion,
and take such measures as he thinks- proper
for promoting those changes of which he
approves. In a matter of this kind, open to
the deliberation of all, the only question is,
whether the measures taken are legal. If
illegal measures are employed either to pro-
mote or oppose a reform, the^ are equally
punishable in the one case as m the other.
My lords, it is here stated, that, it was cri-
minid to propose this reform in the conven-
tion ; and as actions, innocent in themselves,
may be made criminal by their relations and
accompaniments — so the public prosecutor
maintains that tliis convention gives the tin^e
of criminality to the proposed reform, m
itself perfectly blameless. But your lord-
ships will attend to where tiiis argument
leads. It has been shown, and I trust will
scarcely be denied, that to meet in a conven-
tion for innocent purposes is entirely inno-
cent ; on the other hand, it has been eaiudly
shown, that it is not criminal to wisn for
annual parliaments, or universal suffrajge;
but, says the public prosecutor, it is crimmal
to wish, or to express a wish, for universal
suffrage in a convention. This is strange
arguin^-rit is innocent tC> meet in a conven-
tion; It is innocent to wish for universal
suffrage and annual parliaments; but it is
criminal to meet in a convention, and there
to wish for universal sufirage and annual par-
liaments. So that these two actions, perfectiy
innocent in themselves, when joined toge-
ther, form a crime. It is a common saying,
that two blacks cannot make a white ; but it
seetns the converse holds good, that two
whites may make a black. It appears tiiat
these men have wished for universal suf -^ ; But where would have been the crime, even
irage and annual parliaments, and that they
have wished for it in a convention ; but if it
be lawful to meet in a convention, without
be innocent, it is totally impossible, that
these two acts, in themselves innocent, can
form a crime. As in arithmetic, a thousand
cyphers will not make a single unit, so in
morals and in law, a thousand innocent ac-
tions can never constitute one crime. I
aoprehend, therefore, that I have shown
ttiat the great and general charge in this in-
dictment^ of having become a member of
this association, for the purpose of obtaining
universal suffrage and annual parliaments,
contains in it nothing illegal whatever.
It now remains to inquire, whether the
resolutions, sud to have been adopted, and
the speeches, said to have been ms(de by the
genUeman at your lordships bar, contam ia
themselves any thing criminal ; whether they
show that he had any intention contrary to,
or different from the professed object of the
convention, of which ne was a member, that
professed object being innocent.
The indictment goes on to state, that /^ io
the whole form and manner of their proce-
dure, as well as in the principles they avowed
and propagated, clearly and unequivocally de-
monstrate, that their purposes were' of the
most danserous and destructive tendency,
hostile to uie peace and happiness, and tend-
ing to subvert the constitution of this realm ;
imitating, in the form and tenor of their pro-
ceedings, the convention of France, the public:
and avowed enemies of this country; and
with whom Great Britun then was, and still
is, at war. The members calling each other,
at their meetings, by the name of citizen,
dividing themselves into sections, receiving
reports from said sections, some of which bear
date. Liberty Court, Liberty Stairs, liberty
Hall, first year of the British convention, one
and indivisible; andsomeof which have vive
la convention prefixed, and end with ^ ira ;
instituting primary societies, provincial as-
semblies, and departments,'^ and so forth.
My lord, as to the words liberty court, and
liberty hall, they surely contain nothinz cri-
minal. Liberty, both the word and the thing,
has long been known, and I hope, lone wul
be so in this country ; there is nothing Irench
in it. As to the French pliraoes, I aomit that
they are very foolish ; I cannot conceive that
a person of the abilities of this gcntlemaa
could have made use of them ; and I believe
it will be proved (if this cause goes to proof)
that he had no concern in them. When the
old despotism subsbted in France, French
phrases were frequentiy used; but nobody
ever supposed that they who then adopted this
foolish phraseology, had any intention of intro-
ducing French oespotism into this country.
Folly and guilt are very different things. The
use of such phrases may expose one to deserv-
ed ridicule, but not to punishment.
if the resolutions of this convention had been
written in French altogether ? However much
we may abhor French principles, we are not
expressing such a wish, and if the v^ishitselC now making war upon the French language i
such contest would resemble the wars of the
Greeks and Trojans ; not those recorded by
Homer, and which have immortalized the
plains of Ilium ; but those battles of a later
date, commemorated bv our own countryman,
the Spectator, and which were fought with
less bloodshea in the streets of Oxford. W hea
it was first attempted to introduce die study
of Greek into that lyiiversity, the attempt, as
your lordships know, was violently opposed.
Gracum ett^ non potest Ugi was then tne sen-
tence of condemnation pronounced upon a
book, and the signal of hostili^ against all
who presumed to read it. The Trojans, how-
837]
for Sediiion.
A. D* 1794.
£838
ever^ v^n defeated * the stud^ of the Greele>|»
was introduced, and has flourished at Oxford,
and no sedition has followed it.
BIy lords, the indictment has been read,
and therefore I will not go at len^h into it.
Here is a long speech, said to have oeen utter-
ed by the gentleman at the l>ar, which con-
tains a great deal of matter, tending, no doubt,
to make all persons who heani it, form an
opinion in favour of annual parUaments and
universal sufirage. The conclusion of this
speech winds up the whole matter. " Let u^
tnen endeavour to instruct the people in their
rights, and to inform them of our views and
our intentions ; they will come and sign our
petitions, and we shall be enabled to send
them up subscribed by a majority of the
people. The voice of the people will be heard
wherever it is spoken in the language of truth,
and by a number so respectable as to command
attention ; and it will soon have that respecta-
bility if we have reason on our side.'' I see
that the word command is here put in italics,
as if it implied or suggested the least idea thtfl*
violence or force was intended. The word
must be explained by its correlative, the sub-
stantive which it governs, — attention. It can-
not imply that he was to make use of force to
gain attention, but to seek for numbers, as
convinced of the truth and utility of what he
proposed ; and if numbers and truth cannot
procure attention, what can ? The tenor of
this paraeraph, as I have sidd, sums up the
import of his whole speech, and shows that
nothing like force was intended. It expressly
states ** let us then endeavour to instruct the
people in their rights, and to inform them of
our views and our intentions ; they will come
and si^ our petitions.^' It is not m the form
of petition that those persons appear who
mean to use violence: it is impossible, there-
fore, that a word used figuratively can imply
that violence was meant, or could possibly bie
intended.
• But if I am rightly informed, considerable
stress has been laid in former trials upon this
resolution, said to have been come to by the
convention . The indictment states, that '< the
siud association, or meeting, did wickedly and
feloniously, then and there, all the members
standing on their feet, solemnly and unani-
mously come to a resolution of the following
import or tenor, That this convention, con-
sidering the calamitous consequences of any
act of the legislature which may tend to de>
prive the whole, or any part of the people, of
their undoubted right to meet, either by them-
selves, or by delegation, to discuss any matter
relative to their common interest, whether of
a public or private nature, and holding the
same to be totally inconsistent with the first
principles and safety of society, and also sub-
versive of our known and aclmowledged con-
stitutional liberties, do hereby declare, before
God and the world, that we shall follow the
wholesome example tf former times, b^ pay-
ing no segacd to any act whiich shall miUtatc
against the constitution of our country ; and
shall continue to assemble, and consider of
the best means by which we can accomplish
a real representation of the people, and an-
nual election, until compelled to desist by su-
perior force.'' Now what is contained in this
resolution? It contains a declaration, that
they will not yield obedience to an act which
has never yet even been proposed in our par-
liament; and which, I trust, the situation
of this countiy will never be such as to render
necessary. What they say is this, they will
not yield obedience to an act if it should pass,
not to an act of parliament in existence, but
an act which exist in potentiA only, which is
no more law than the most extravagant pro-
position that can be conceived. If this is
criminal, it is a crime of a most anomalous
and extraordinary nature. They would not
yield obedience to that which, perhaps, never
might be a law : this, I say, is a crime of such
an anomalous and non-descript nature, that I
know not under what term, or what degree of
punishment it can fall. But at any rate, cer-
tainly the crime of saying that I will not
yield obedience to an act, if it should pass,
cannot be equivalent to disobeying an aet
after it is passed. Now to what consequences
mav 'this lead? I shall suppose that an act
hadi passed prohibiting conventions; that it
had said that no convention was to assemble,
to deliberate upon any public subject; and
that any persons who might afterwards meet,
should be liable to a fine of 20/., and imprison-
ment for a month. After this law a conven-
tion meets, in opposition to the act; they are
accordingly dispersed, and the persons guilty
are punished according to the penality stated
in the act ; but these meu who have not dis-
obeyed any act, they having only resolved to
disobey such an act if it should be passed, are
to be punished with fourteen years transporta-
tion to Botany Bay ! Such are the conse-
quences that may follow; the members of
tnis convention are to undergo a punishment
beyond all ordinary bounds, for only having
declared their intention to disobey an act, not
in existence ; while those, who in fact should
disobey it, might be liable only in a trifling
pensdty.
My lords, I say again, that it is impossible
that any violence could have been here intend-
ed, because if they were to disobey this sup-
posed act, how were they to disobey it ? They
must have met in an unarmed and peaceable
convention; for it is by so meeting alone,
that they could act in disobedien6e of such a
statute. If they had assembled, or if they,
or any other persons should be bold enough
to assemble now, in an armed convention,
they would not disobey a statute similar to
that passed in Ireland ; they could only dis-
obey that by meeting in a peaceable, quiet,
and orderly manner, to deliberate on public
afi^rs. But if they had met violently and
armed, it would have been in opposition to
statutes that have Ipng existed in this countiy;
699]
S4 6E0RGB m.
Proeeedmgt againit Jetq^ Gerrald
[840
and of which the enactments are fuHy com-
petent to repress all such ilieeU violence.
My lords, this is taking tne resolution in
its very worst sense; but take this, which
inay be considered as the preamble of the re-
solutions, and let it be explained as in fairness
it ouzht to be, by the resolutions which follow :
the first resolution here is, '' that the first
notice given for the introduction of a conven-
tion* bill, or any bill of a similar tendencv to
that passed in Ireland,in the last session of their
parliament, or any bill for the suspension of
the Habeas Corpus act, or the act for prevent-
ing wrongous imprisonment, and against un-
^ue delays in trials in North Britain, or in
case of an invasion, or the admission of any
foreign troops whatever into Great Britain or
Ireland ; all, or any one of these calamitous
circumstances shall be a signal to the different
delegates, to repair to such place as the
secret committee of this convention shall
appoint."
*-^Now, your lordships will observe, when,
and on what occasion they were to meet—
they were to meet, not after the statute had
passed, but when a bill -was introduced for
passing it — what could be the object of such
meeting ? It must be to prevent it passing
into a law, and to remonstrate, as they had a
right to do, a^nst the passing of it. They
meant to petition parliament, supported by
aich numbers, undoubtedly, as they could pro-
-v^cvre, to prevent such a bill from becoming
the law of the land. The object of their meet-
ing, therefore, was to use their best endea-
your9, in a constitutional manner, to prevent
this bill from beins passed into a law ; and
this resolution clearlv proves that they meant
to meet when the bill was brought in, not for
the purpose of disobeying an act, but to pre-
vent it, by all lawful means, from being made
an act binding the subjects of this country to
obedience. They were to meet upon the in-
troduction of a convention bill, or of a bill
for the suspension of the Habeas Corpus act,
or of the act for preventing wrongous im-
prisonment; that is, they were to meet in
order to remonstrate, in a constitutional maot-
ner, with parliament against the repeal of
those salutary statutes which guard the riffhts
and liberties of us all. Again^ in case of an
invasion, the folly of the resolution is also
stated in tlie indictment as criminal, that ^* the
first seven members shall have power to de-
clare the sittings permanent, and twenty-one
shall constitute a convention, and proceed to
husiness.'' Instead of any thing criminal
here, all is innocence. If twenty-one were to
constitute a convention, they could not surely
l^e an armed force to assist the invaders, they
could with difficulty even have repelled them.
There is also stated in this indictment, a
second speech, said to be made by the gentle-
man at the bar, of which I sliall read the con-
clusion. It is printed in italic, and therefore,
I presume the public prosecutor meant to lay
f articular alreM ufna it, '' If the aertilit^ of
the people had been less, if th^ \md dan4
to meet, and in place of murmuring, to hav*
told their rulers that there was d&ngn m
seeking to' deprive them of their liberties, we
would not have had to adopt this resolution
to-night, but when I saw the calm deliberate
countenances of all present, and the solemn
manner in which it was passed, I was con*
vinced that it would not only be a resolution
of words, but a rule of action." Now, what
is a resolution but a rule of action ? My lord,
every resolution is, or ought to be, a rule of
action, and is intended to be such when it b
formed: this, therefore, is a very proper ez^
pression to enforce, and explain more fuUy
the deliberate nature of the resolution entered
into, to meet and endeavour to oppose such a
bill from passing into a law, a bill to prevent
peaceable and unarmed conventions from
meeting in this country.
The indictment goes on to state, that the
said meeting came to a resolution, ** That a
secret committee of three and the secretary,
be appointed to determine the place where
such convention of emergency shall meet.
That such place shall remain a secret with
them, and with the secretary of this conven-^
tion, and that each delegate shall^ at ^e
breaking up of the present session, be
entrust^ with a sealed letter, containing
the name of the place of meeting. This
letter shall be delivered unopened to his
constituents, the receipt of which shall be ac-
knowledged by a letter to the secretary, pre-
served in the same state, until the period shall
arrive at which it shall be deemed necessary
for the delegate to set out.'' Here is much
secrecy, but nothing else. And secrecy was
necessary, if peaceable conventions were to
be prohibited. But an armed force cannot
meet in secrecy, unless we are to suppose that
the members of this convention were to as-
semble like the troops of Mr. Bayes, in dis*
g;iiise. The secrecy which they here observe,
is the surest proof of their innocence and
peaceable intentions.
My lord, in going through the whole of
this indictment, I can perceive nothing rde»
vant in it to infer the crime of sedition, or
any other crime. The meeting itself was in*
nocent, the object thev had in view was in-
nocent, and the speeches and resolutions said
to have been maoe are also innocent ; inas-
much as they were merely calculated to pro^
mote the avowed object of the convention.
They wished for the support of numbers ; but
for what^ To petition parliament They
were anxious that a bill should not be brought
into parliament to prevent peaceable assem<>
blies from meeting ; and therefore they say
they will prevent such bill, as far as they cao',
firom passmg into a law. This also was neces*
sary tor the attainment of their object. All
that can be said against them, thevefi>re^
amounts to this, that they took the best mea*-
sures th^ could for accompUshing their puiw
pose of obtaining a parliamentaiy nfonn ; •
Ml]
far SedUi&iu
A. O. 17M.
[842
nurpeee lesal in kself, and which, od aU
haads^ U aiamitted to he, in a certain degree,
necessary.
At ail events^ I humbly apprehend, that
the ^ts stated in this indictment can only
amount to verbal s^ition — ^that there has
been, in this case, no commotion, no rising
of the people, and that speeches uttered, Or
resolutions formed, can onlv amount to ver-
bal sedition, or leasiuf^ makmg.
In order to show this, I must trouble your
lordships with reading the definitions given of
sedition bv our law-writers, comparing them
vrith the charges set forth in the indictment,
and also with the statutes respecting verbal
sedition.
The first is sir George Mackenue, book 1,
title 7, who says, ** sedition is a commotion
of tiie people, without authority ; and if it be
such as tends to the disturbing of the govern^
ment, * ad entium principis vel senatorum
* ejus & mutationera reipublicse,' it is treason ;
but if it only be raised upon any private ac-
count, it is not properly called treason, but it
is, with us, called a convocation of the
lieges."
Sedition, therefore, is a commotion of the
peoi>le, or a rising of the peo])le, without au-
thority, according to the definition given of it
by this great lawyer.
A similar dennition is given by Forbes,
book S, title 9, sect 1, ^ sedition is a commo-
tion or nsineof the people, without authority,
in order to & any thing tending to a disturb-
ance of the public peace, though the design be
not executed, which is rused upon the public
or private account."
According to Erskine, the crime consists in
raismg isonunotions or disturbances in the
state.
I believe a definition more full and more
•ccurate is given of this crime by Dr. fioyd,
^n his Justice of Peace, in book 1 , title 5, *^ Se-
dition is any commotion or rising of ti:^ peo-
ple, without lawful authority, and which
tends to the disturbance of the public peace of
the kingdom."
My lord, every one of these definitions re<*
presents sedition, not as consisting in peace-
able convocations, or in the speeches and re-
solutions of such convocations, but as con-
aisting in commotions or risings of the people.
Accordingly there is a most material dis-
tinction to be made between commotions and
risings, and speeches and resolutions tending
to excite commotions and risings. These
speeches are termed seditious, but Qie expres-
sion is figurative : they are seditious merely on
luxount of their tenciency to excite coinmo-
tions and risings of the people, .which is
really sedition; and this distinction is ex-
pressly pointed out by several of our statutes.
A man who makes speeches and resolu-
tbns, the tendency of which is to excite com«
notions, is euilty of verbal sedition, but is
not guilty of that crime which he has failed
tacoBunit; he is not guilty of those commo-
tions which his seditious speeches tended in-
effectually to produce. If a person excites
another to murder, and the deed is not per-
Ketrated, he is not an accessary to the muraer ;
e may be punished undoubteily bv the Utws
of this country, but he is not guil^ of that
murder which he instigated, but which he in-
stigated in vain. In the same manner, these
people may be guilty of having endeavoured
to excite disturbances, but they cannot be
punished guilty of those commotions which
have not existed. This important distinction
is fully rebognized in several of our acts of
pu-hament. In the act 1555, chap. 60, in the
reign of Queen Mary :
^ For sa^meikle as diverse seditious per-
sones hes, in times bypast, raised amangst
the commoun people, murmures and sclan-
ders, speaking against the quenis grace, and
sawing evil brute anent the maist christian
king of France, his subjeetes sent in this
realme for the commoun weill, and suppres-
sing of the auld enemies foorth of the samin,
tei]ding throw nusing of sik rumours to steir
the hearts of the subjeetes to hatrent against
the i»rince, und sedition betwixt the lieges of
this reabne and the maist christian ungis
lieges foresaidis : and, for eschewing of sik
inconvenientes as micht follow thereupon : it
is devised, statute and ordained, that gif onie
persones in times cumming, bee hearda
speakand sik unreasonable commoning,^uAat>-
throw the people may take occasion of sifc
prievie cons{»racie against the prince, or se^
dition against the mabt christian kii^is sub-
jeetes foresaidis. the saroin, being proven,
sail bee punished according to the qualitie of
the feulte, in their bodies and gudes, at the
queenis grace pleasure: and, in case the
hearer thereof report not the samin unto the
queenis grace or her officiares to the effect
that the samin may bee punished, as accor-
dis, that he sail incurre the saidis paines,
quhilkis the principal speaker or raiser of
sik murmures deservis.'' In no less than two
places this is pointed out, ** tending throw
raising sik murmures," to excite sedition,
and again^ ^ quhair-throw, the people may
take occasion of sik prievie consptracie."
Lord Justice Clerk. — What is the punish-
ment f
Mr. Oiliies. — In their bodies and goods at
the queen's grace pleasure. The next is the
act of 1584, chap. 134 ; this act points out still
more cleariy the distinction I just now stated.
^ For-sa-meikle as it is understand to our
soveraine lord and his three estaites, assem-
bled in this present parliament, quhat great
harme and inconveniente hes fallen in this
realme, chiefly sen the beginning of the civile
troubles occurred in the time of his hienes
minortte, throw the mcked and licentious
publick and private speaches, and untrew ca-
lumnies of divers his subjeetes, to the di$-
daine, contempt, and rejproch of his majesty,
his councel and proceedings, ' and to the dis-
honour and prejudice of his hienes^ his parents.
843]
34 GEORGE IH.
Proceedingi ttgiiinH J(^h Gerrdd
[844
progenitours, and estaite; steiiriog up his
hienes subjectes theirby to mislikine, sedition,
unquietnes, and to cast off their dew obedi-
ence to his majestic to their evident perrel,
tinsel, and destruction, his hienes continuing
alwaies in love and clemencie, towards all
his gude subjectes, and maist willing to seek
the safetie and preservation of them all,
quhilkis wilfully needles, and upon plaine
malice, after his hienes mercy and pardon,
ofl times afoir granted hes procured them-
selves be their treasonable deeds to bee cut off
as corrupt members of this common weill:
Therefore, it is statute and ordained bee our
soveraine lord, and his three estaites, in this
present parliament, that nane of his subjectes
(of quhat-sumever function, degree, or qiuu
litie, in time-cmnming,) sail presume, or take
upon hand privatly or publicKly, in sermones,
declamationes, or familiar conferences, to utter
ony false, slanderous, or untrew speeches, to
.the disdaine, reproche, and contempt of his
miyestie, his councel, and proceedings, or to
the dishonor, hurt, or prejudice of his hienes,
bis parents, and progenitoures, or to meddle
in the affaires of his hienes and his estate
present, by-gane and in time cummin^, under
the peines conteined in the actes ot parlia-
ment, against makers and tellers of feesin-
ges : Certifieing them that sail be tryed con-
traveners theirof, or that beans sik slander-
ous speaches, and reportes not the same
with diligence^ the said paine sail be executed
against them with all rigour, in ezemple of
utheris.''
In consequence of the union of the two
crowns, in the reign of James 6th. another
act passed, to prevent national differences
between the Scotch and English, from being
excited by speeches and narangue, 1609,
chap 9. The preamble of the act shows that
it was historically such as I have stated to
your lordship. << For remeed and preventing
whereof, his miyestie remembrine how strait
and severe punishment, hes by the laws and
actes of his maist royall progenitors, kings of
this realme heretofore, bene ordeined to be
inflicted upon sik as should devise or utter
false and slanderous speeches and writtes,
.to make dissentions betwene the prince add
his subjects, or raise sedition in the realme,
and considderine that all sik purposes and
writtes, as may breed dislyking betwene the
inhabitants of the saids kmgdomes of Scot-
land and England, being now all become his
majesties liege people, equallie subject and
equallie beloved ot his heighnes, tends to
maist dangerous disscntion and sedition
amangs his subjects ; therefore, his majestie,
with advyce and consent of the haill estaites
of this parliament, statutes and ordeines, that
whasoever shall hereafter, by word or write,
.devise, utter, or publish, any false, slander-
.ou$, or reprochfiill speeches or writtes, of
the estate, people, or countric of England or
of any counsetier thereof, tending to the re-
membrance of the auucieut grudge .borne in
tyme of by-'past troubles (the occasion where-
of is now happilie abolished by the blessed
conjunction ot the saids kingdomes, under his
majesties soveraignitie and obedience) or to
the hinderance of the wished accomplish-
ment of the perfect union of the saids king-
domes, or to the slander or reproch of the
estate, people, or countrie of England, or
dishonor, or prejudice of any counseiler of the
said kingdome whereby hatred may be fos-
tred and intertained, or mislyking rused be-
twene his majesties faithful! subjects of thit
isle. The authors of sik seditious, slanderous,
and injurious speeches or writtes, or dispersert
thereof, after tryell taken of their offence,
either before his majesties justice, or the
lords of his hienes privie councell, shall be
severehe punished in their persones and
gudes, by imprisonment, banishment, iyning
or mair rigorous corporall paine.''
These are the statutes that point ont, as I
said before, and iully recognize the evident
distinction that exists between commotions
and risings of the people, and speeches or
writings, tending to excite those commotions.
Your lordships will also observe, that the
crime stated m the act 1606 counts in en-
deavouring to excite disturbances, by ser^^
mons, declamations, or famUiar conferences.
Now, the declamations here mentioned, as
distinct firom sermons, upon the one hand,
or familiar conferences on the other, must be
precisely the same as the speech said to have
been made by this gentleman, or the resolu-
tions of the other members of the convention.
It cannot be supposed that persons would de-
claim in the fields where there were none to
hear them. Their declamations must have
been addressed to an assembly of the people,
met togetiier, like this convention, in a room ;
or which would have been still more criminal,
and of still more dangerous tendency, they
must have been addressed to any accidental
assemblage of people upon the public streets.
But it is charged against this convention,
that their object, though professed to be a
reform in the representation of the Commons
House of Parliament, was really to overturn
the government, and subvert the constitution
of this country; and, it hs^s been said, that
the tendency of these speeches, joined to the
intention with which they were uttered, con-
verts this crime from verbal, into real sedi-
tion ; that this circumstance takes it out of
the case of leasin^-making, where speeches
are uttered, not with the evil intention that
is ascribed to these persons, of subverting the
constitution of the countiy, and changes it
into real sedition, a crime of a different natuie,
and of a flacker dye.
My lords, if those persons formed a plan,
and entered into a resolution, of overturning
this constitution, and if that resolution is indi-
cated by their actions, they are not guilty of
sedition, but of high treason; and for that
crime let them be indicted. I say agajin, if
they fonoed this intention to oyerturB tho
849]
Jar Seditkm.
A^D. 1794
[846
government of this country, and if this inten-
tion appears from their nroceedinni, they
ought not to have heen triea on an indictment
such as this, but on a charge of high treason
itself; a crime for which no punishment your
lordships can here inflict is at all adequate.
In the proceedings of the convention itself
there is no proof of any such design. If such
an intention was proved from their proceed-
ings, the crime would be treason. The con-
sequences are obvious. If the intention is
not proved, the public prosecutor is not en-
titled to presume it, and arguing upon that
presumption, to accuse this ^ntleman of
a greater crime than what arises from bis
speeches, according to their plain and direct
meaning. The intention ot subverting the
government is not here indicated in the way
that the laws of treason require ; that is, there
is no sufficient proof of it, not even a vestige
of evidence that could enable the public pro-
secutor to bring my client to trial for high
treason. Did there exist any such proof,
then the public prosecutor has neglected his
duty, in not bringing an indictment for this
crime. He cannot be permitted to say, that
the proof of high treason being defective, he
was obliged to charge for another offence,
which very offence was to be aegravated by
the treasonable intention he could not prove :
the want of proof of one crime is not the
proof of another crime. This would be to over-
turn all judicial procedure, to subvert every
notion of jurisprudence. The members of
this convention have formed that intention
which is ascribed to them, of overturning the
fovernment of this country, or they have not.
*heir liaving formed it, is proved, or it is not
proved. If it is proved, they are guilty of
ni^ treasop. If it is not proved, this cri-
minal intention must be laid out of consider-
ation altogether, and cannot be permitted to
aggravate the dejgree, much less to alter the
nature of the offence charged in the indict-
ment. The deficiency of proof of one crime
can never give rise to a new. or a different
crime ; if I am accused of muraer, and if evi-
dence of the fact, that I committed the homi-
cide is wanting, will that ever constitute a
charge of manslaughter ? I say that the de-
ficient proof of a greater crime can never con-
stitute a lesser crime — let the lesser crime be
charged and punished as such, or let the
greater crime be charged and punished as
such.^ If it was the intention of the members
of this convention to overturn the govern-
ment of this country, they are guilty of trea-
son.— If it was not their intention it ought
not to be charged ; and they are guilty otno
crime at all.
Whether this gentleman at the bar has
ever formed such intention is known to his
own breast. Whether he has ever formed such
intention is known also to that Being, and to
that Being alone, who can search the hearts
of men, (uid without aid of external circum-
■tances; pronounce upon the secret motives
of their conduct. But no human judge can
assume this prerogative,— can presume guilt
from constructions put upon speeches ; con-
structions which may be aifferent by different
persons, and at different times; no man can
lay his hand upon his heart, and upon con-
structions of this sort say, that this gentle-
man has formed any such intention. Even
whatever may be his own o|Hnion, he is not
entitled to act upon that opinion here; as no
legal proof of any sort has been brought, and
no constructive proof of treason is known to -
our laws. I am speaking here as if the
strange and illegal practice could be permit-
ted, of bringing forward a higher crime, not
to be punished itself, but as the a^ravation
of an mferior offence. Bven in- such preposte-
rous proceedings, could this prs^tice be coun-
tenanced for a moment, there is, in the pre-
sent case^ no evidence on which such aggra-
vation could be placed.
My lords, the whole actions and proceed-
ings of this convention may fairly, and with
probability, and so far as it strikes my mind,
can only be ascribed to their wishes to attain
the proposed object which they had in view,
— ^a reform in the House of Commons, by the
introduction of universal suffrage, and annual
parliaments. They may also have proceeded
from the treasonable intention ascribed to
them. But where these matters are doubts
ful, where the writings and resolutions of
men may be ascribed either to bad or good
motives, humaniw and justice both require
that thev should be ascribed to motives that
are good. When these resolutions express
an avowed purpose, and when tliese men
declare, in sul their speeches and motions,
that they wished not to subvert, but to re-
form the constitution, will you say from those
very speeches and resolutions, that this was
not their purpose ? Are you, from speeshes
containing declarations that they wished for
reform, to conclude that they did not wish
for reform ? Are you from speeches contain-
ing declarations that they wished to support
the constitution, to conclude that they wished
to subvert it ? This is straining constructive
evidence to a great length indeed. Those
are questions upon which men, in their clo-
sets, and in private life, mav entertain dif-
ferent opinions; but your lordships know,
much better than I do, what the strictness of
judicial evidence requires. We cannot re*
ceive in evidence those things which in pri-
vate life may convince us of the truth or
probability of^any fact. I say now, therefore,
as I said before, that could the proof of such
intention be admitted, as aggravating the
lesser offence charged, still there is no proof of
the aggravation.
Mylord, it may be stated that the circum-
stances of the times in another country, may
afford a proof of the intentions of these men.
Upon this it does not become me to speak in
this place; but, with regard to the French
revolution, I shall only say, that two views
8i7]
S4 GEORGE UL
Proceeda^t agaiMU Jot^^errdd
tM8
may be taken of it in as far as it respects I
England. — Those scenes of bloodshed that
have been ^diibited tliere, may show us the
danger of innovation on the one hand ; but
the vny same drcumstances may show us,
on the other hand, the propriety of adopting
» timely and moderate reform. A delay of
reformation, may, as many think, have pro-
duced those transactions which we all in
common deplore. Some men may be im-
pressed with this event, so as to sjtine all de-
sire of reformation. To others, with equally
virtuous views, it may appear that this very
revolution is an additional argument for ob^.
taining a moderate and timely reform in the
representation. — Here again the case comes
to be the same as before. Who is entitled
to search into this man's breast f He, per-
haps, can lay his hand upon his bosom and
say, that he viewed the French revolution, as
holding out to us a warning not to be too
dflatovy in obtaininf^ a moderate reform, be-
fore mt peo^e are stirred up to those excesses
'irhsch have been committed in France.
The circumstances of the times thto which
are brought forward to agj^vate tlte offences
of these men, may in their own breasts form
their justification ; because they may conader
the French revolution as evincing tlie neces-
sity and propriety of adopting a moderate
and timely reform. Here then I apprehend
that no stress can be laid upon circumstances
which operate in two ways; which in oue
view, mav operate to criminate this gentle-
man, and in another view, may be the very
proofs of his innocence and virtue.
My lord, setting aside this intention of
overturning the constitution, no vestige of a
crime remains. Even witn this intention,
since there has been no commotion, no rising
of the people, and since words spoken, what-
ever may oe their purport, can never consti-
tute real sedition, still the onlv offence is ver-
bal sedition* This has not been a firequent
crime ; but it is a crime not altogether un«
known to our laws. In the recoras of this
court there are two instances of trials for
leasing-making or verbal sedition, upon a
statute which I shall hereafter have occasion
io notice; the act 1703. The offences which
were in those cases charsed agvnst the pai^
^, I ^prebend to have oeen at least as cri-
minal as those which are laid to the chaige
of this gentleman.
On ^bruary 1st, 1715. John Graham and
others* were indicted ior leasing making
and slanderous speeches, tendinj; to excite
sedition, and alienate the affections of his
majesty's subjects from his nerson and go-
venunenty by setting up the false pretensions
of another. The corpus (2e/tcfi was, drinking
the pretender's health at the Tron Church,
by the name of James 8th, and his happy
restoratioo. Hiis was a crime which was
* See their case in this Collection; Vol. 17,
p. 1.
then thoueht to amount to leasing- making,
and accordingly it was tried upon that statute.
Upon the 27th Jime, in the same year,
John OUphant, Alelander Wilson, William
Ramsev, baillies of Dundee, William Lyon,
of Ogiil, treasurer, and J. Watson, vintner,*
were incQcted upon the same statute, and the
same offence Of^leasing-making;, inasmuch as
for abetting the pretender's right, they did
fo upon the 10th of June (the pretender's
irth-day) to tiie cross of Dundee, and, in a
solemn manner, drank his health, by the
title of Ring James 8th, king of those r^ms;
and on the 90th of June 1715, a thanks^
giving appointed bv parliament for the king's
accession, when the bells were ringing, they
went up and prevented their ringing, and
cursed the king.
I shall leave it to your lordship to decide,
whether the crimes pf which these men were
convicted be not far more atrocious than the
offences charged against this gentleman ; and
at a time too when rebellion raged in thb
country: — ^at that very time they were thought
to amount to leasing-making or verbal se-
dition only.
My lord, I now come to inquire as to the
punishment to be inflicted. Punishments
upon the old acts are prohibited by a passage
in the claim of rights, which I formerly read,
and shall now read again to your lordships.
Having particularly in their view this provF-
^n in the bill of* rights, the legislature pas-
sed the act 1703, chap. 4. lR(»ds]. « Ouf
soveraine ladie considering tnat by the acts
of parliament following," reciting a number
of acts, ^ the crimes therein mentioned are
made capital, and punishable by death and
confiscation, and that the saids laws have
been liable to streatehes, and that in respect
of their generality, and the various construe*
tion which the same ma^r admit, they toxy
be, as to the foresaid capital punishment, of
dangerous consequence, doth therefore, with
advice and consent of the estates of parlia-
ment, abrogate and discharge, in all time
coming, the foresaid sanction and pain of
deatii and confiscation, contained in the said
acts ; and statutes and ordains, that the pu^
nishment of the crimes mentioned shall, for
hereafter, only be arbitrary, according to the
demerit of the transgression; that is, b^
fining, imprisonment, or banishment; or if
the party offender be poor, and not able to
-pKV a fine, then to be punished in his body
(life and limb always preserved)/'
My lord, one of the acts repealed by this
statute is the act of 1584, chap J 34, where
the offence was, as I formerly stated, directly
the tome as that charged here, that is, de-
claiming in public against the government of
the country. I ne^ not again repeat that
declamations cannot be uttered in a desart,
where nobody can hear them, or in a jHivata
* See their case ia thia G^Uection^ VoL tr,
p. 769,
849]
Jw Sedition.
A. D. 1794.
[850
room, to a private company : they must be
addressed either to such au assembly as this
convention, or to the world at large, in the
streets, which would have been still more
daneerous ; and therefore, this act being one
of those repealed by the statute of 1708, the
punishment of this last statute can alone be
inflicted upon the crime.
The question comes then to be what is the
punishment enacted by this statute, under the
word banishment. With regard to transpor-
tation, your lordships know this was a pu-
nishment altogether unknown in this coun-
try till the reign of Charles 8d. It was then
introduced bv the privy council, in imitation
of what had been done in England, for^ the
purpose of repressing the religious sectaries.
Upon this subject the authority of sir
George Mackenzie seems to be decisive : " But
with us no judge can confine a man whom
he banisheth to any place without his juris-
diction ; because he hath no jurisdiction over
other countries, and so cannot make any acts,
nor pronounce any sentences relative to
them.'' Again, in another place, he says,
^ As to the sending away people to the plan-
tations. It is answered, that none were sent
Hwav but such as were taken at Botliwel
Bridj^e, or in Argyle's rebellion; and the
turning capital punishment into exile, was an
act of clemency, not of cruelty.'' If transporta-
tion had been a punishment at common law, I
apprehend, sir George Mackenzie must have
been too well acquainted with that law to
think an apologjr for government necessary.
The apology which he makes is, that these
men had committed a capital offence, and
therefore, saj^s he, the turnmg capital punish-
ment into exile was an act of clemency and
mercy, as otherwise thev might have been
punished by death. I tnerefore apprehend,
that the punishment of transportation could
only be inflicted in the case, tnat sir George
Mackenzie states, or where it is expressly
pointed out by statutes or in cases, where
the punishment is altogether discretionary,
which is not under the act 1703.
The Roman law has, as your lordships
know, made a material distinction between
oanisbment and transportation. Under a law
authorizing the punishment of relegatio mere-
ly, the more severe punishment ot deportath
in insulam could not have been inflicted.
In judging of a matter of this kind, where
a statute has expressly declared, that the
punishment of these oftences is to be banish-
ment, the first thing to be done is, to inquire
into the common signification of the word
*' banishment." My lord, this is not a legal or
a technical phrase : the whole world are bound
to understand it : and it ought not so much
to be referred to law-writers as to common
sense, and the etymology of the EngUsh
language. It is a question of philology, ra-
ther than of law ; and holding it to be such,
I refer to the authority of Dr. Johnson. He
gives the following ezplaaatk>n : <'To banish,
VOL, xxni.
to condemn to leave one's own country ;**
not a word of sending to another country.
The examples 'given are the words addressed
by Macdun to Malcolm :
" 0 fare thee well ?
" Those evils thou repeat'st upon thyself,
" Have banished me from Scotland."
Another signification of the same word is
" to drive away :"
'< Banish business, banbh sorrow^
" To the gods belongs to-morrow."
If your lordships could banish businessf
and banish sorrow along with it to Botany
Bay, we should bill be much obliged to you.
My lord, with regard to the statute 1709,
chap. 4, I apprehend, that by the recital of
the acts therein dven, there is demonstrative
evidence afforded of the meaning of the word
banishment. The statute 1609, chap. 9,
which is quoted and its penalty partly r&«
pealed by the act of queen Anne, 1703, de-
clares that the persons convicted under it
** shall be severely punished in their persons
and goods, by imprisonment, banishment^
fining, or more rigorous corporal pain." At
the time this statute was passed, in 1609, it.
cannot be maintained, and is not pretended,
that transportation was known in this coui^
try; because this country had then no juria*
diction beyond itself. It banishment, there*
fore, in the act 1703, signifies transportation,
it must be made use of at once, in two difie*
rent and contradictory senses. - In the' act
1609, banishment merely means, and can
only mean, exile from Scotland. In the other
acts recited in the repealing statute 1703,
banishment, according to the public prosecu*
tor, means transportation ; that is, impriton*
ment in some foreign country, attended with
every thins that is ignominious and painful.
The term, Danishment, thus, in the act 1703,
means, by this construction, both or either
of these punishments, altogether different in
themselves, and of which we know certamly,
that the one was not meant in one of the
statutes repealed, and no evidence is brought
that it was meant in any of the others.
Such a construction is unsufferable. The
word banishment must be understood in one
simple sense; and that is the sense in which
it is employed in the act 1609.
Were it otherwise, the consequences are as
absurd as they are dreadful. It the word ba-
nishment cannot be employed in two senses
in the accurate language of a repealing sta-
tute, and if its simple sense be not exile from
Scotland, but transportation, theii an act^ io^
tended, and bearing, to be a mitigation or pu*
nishment, would increase, and m an enor*
mous degree, the severity of punishment*
The act 1609, repealed for its severity, is ren*
dered still more severe. Transportation
comes in place of banishment ; and thus the
legislature, who, in passing the statute 1703,
intended it as an act of mercy, have in reality
committed an act of cruelty ; instead of les*
3 I
85J} 84 GEORGE HI. Procteda^t agaaut Jotefh Gerrdd
[85fl
dening, they have iDcreased the sereri^ of
the puniehment which then existed.
My lord, it has been said, that to sentence
these men merely to exile from Scotland,
would be preposterous, as h would not be an
adequate punishment, and because it would
leave them opportunities of committing the
same ofiences in England. But if this is a
preposterous penalty, I am sure the same
preposterous tning is committed twenty times
every year by your lordships ; for how oflen
is it that you banish thieves and pickpockets
£»rth of Scotland, leaving them at liberty to
go to Bngknd, where, as people's pockets are
generally better filled than they are here,
persons of this description will be enabled to
eaevcifle their .profession with much greater
advantage and success? But, my lords, a
pottishinBiit so well known, in our own law,
9ttd in the laws of every country, as banish-
■Mnt, oan never be called preposterous.
I stated two trials in the banning of the
ireseni century; John Oraham was indicted
tor '^ leasing-making, and the utterance of
slanderous speeches, tending to excite sedi-
tian, and alienate the affections of his ma-
jesty's subjects from his person and govem-
laent ; aettinff up the false and scandalous
pnclenfiions of another, by drinking the pre-
tender's health, at the Tron church, by the
aaoM of iaroes dth, and his hanpy restora-
tion/' Jtfjr lord, there were otner persons
concerned in this crime besides him ; tlie
vaidiot was, " the crime not proven against
Gfaham and Hay, but found proven against
Grawford, upon his own confession;'' the
seotsnoe iras, ** that he be emerciated in a
fifte of SO/, sterling, and imprisoned till secu-
rity found for payment * My lords, in the
elier case of **• John Oliphant, Alexander
Wilson, and William Ramsav, baillies of
Hundee, WiUiam Lyon, of Ogill, treasurer, J.
Walson, vintoec, indicted on the statute of
Anne, and the acts contained in it, of leasing-
nalnnKy &c. inasmuch as for abetting the
nrotenaor'B right, they did go on the 10th of
Jane, the pretender's birth-day, to the cross
of IXmdee, and in a solemn manner, drink
kis lieahh by the title of king James Bth,
king of these realms ; and on the SOth of
Jbne, 1715, a thanksgiving appointed by par-
liament for the king's accession, when the
belb were ringing, oTiphant went up to the
steeple, and prevented their ringing, and cursed
theJdng/'
12/&JttZy, 1715.
'' The k)rd8 justice clerk, and commis-
sioners of justiciary, having considered the
verdict of assize, returned on the 5th of July
instant, against the said John Oliphant, &c.
fwnels, they, in respect thereof, by the mouth
of Charles Kinross, macer of court, deprive
the said John Oliphant, &c. of their offices of
baiAles of Dunaec, and the said William
* See Vol. 17, p. 30.
Lyon, of his office ^ treasurer of the said
burgh, and declare the said John Oliphant
incapable of enjoying any public office or
trust within the said bnreh, or within that
part of Great Britain, called Scotland, in all
time coming. And declare the said Alex*
ander Watson, and Mr. Thomas Wilson^ in*
capable of enjoying any pubUc office or trust,
within the said burgh of Dnndee, in all time
cominff. And also declare the said Mr. Wil'
liam Ramsay, and Mr. William Lyon, inca^
pable of enjoying any public office or treaty
within the said burgh, for the space of three
years next after the date hereor. And ndr-
like, the said lords fine and emerciate the nid
John Oliphant, in the sum of two hundred
merks, Scots, and the said Alexander Watson,
in the sum of 100/. Scots, and the said Mr.
Thomas Wilson, in the sum of one hundred
merks Scots money, foresaid, to be paid to his
majesty's receiver-general for his highness use :
and ordain the said John Oliphant^ Alexander
Watson, and Mr. W^illiam Ramsay, William
Lyon, and Mr. Thomas Wilson, to be carried
to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh, there to remain
until the 10th of August next, inclusive: and
the said John Oliphant, Alexander Watson,
and Mr. Thomas Wilson, to remain there*
afier in the said prison, until they make pay*
ment of their said respective fines : and ocw
•dain the magistrates of Edinburgh to set the
persons of the said Mr. William Ramsay, and*
William Lyon, at libertv, furth of the said
Tolbooth, aAer the said day : and also to set
the persons of the other three panels at li-
berty, after elapsing of the said day, upon
producing their respective discharges of the
said fines, which is pronounced for doom."*
In these cases your lordships will observe,
that an enormous offence had been commitl^
against the government ; and you have heard
the punishment that was inflicted ; whether
it was, or was not equivalent to the offence, I
leave entirelv to your impartial consideration.
But, my lord, certsdnly the circumstances of
the times then were at least as dangerous as
the present. Actual rebellion followed, and
many unfortunate men fell in the contest.
If any circumstances could justify the extreme
severity of a sentence they were those which
then existed. But all that it was thought
necessary to do then was, to infiict the small
punishment which your lordships have heard.
I may also notice, that in the last of these
cases, the panels had been convicted of two
offences, leasing-making, and a malversation
in office as magistrates. Being thus guilty of
two crimes, the accumulated punishments of
fining, deprivation, and imprisonment were
inflicted upon them. —
Havinjg said so much, I shall now conchide.
Before sitting down I must yet mention one
consideration personal to this unfortunate
ffentleman himself. His state of health is
reeble> and in regard even to this there ought
• Sec Vol. 17, pp. TOO, T8«.
fiS3]
far Sedition.
A. D. 179*-
[854
^o be some measure of the punishineiU^
Should he reach his place of exile,^ his punish*
vient will indeed be severe. A man of high
talents, of a cultivated understanding, is to oe
condemned to the communion of thieves and
irillains, the reAise and dregs of the human
nee ! In such society he is to be sent to the
desolate shores of the remote southern ocean.
From those hapless regions it ma^,. perhaps,
be possible to return ; but from his state of
lieelth it is highly probable that this gentle*
man will never even arrive at his miserable
4e9tination. His sentence of exile will have
been to that '' undiscovered country from
whose bourn no traveller returns."
- 1 know that the humanity of your lordshipa
will make you pause before you pronounce a
Judgment of which such must be the cons&-
4}uences.
Lord JuiHee Clerk. — Mr. Gillies, you have
'done ample justice to your client; you have
managed his defence in a very able manner.
Mr. Montgomery, — My lord, ^ftcr the very
S)ble and full discussion which ihis Question
imderwent a fortnight ago, not only oy your
positions : in the first place that there is nor-
thing criminal set forth in the indictment,
and that therefore it ought to be dismissed
entirely, because it contains nothing upon
wliich punishment can be inflicted.
In the second place, that if there is any
thing criminal, it can- only amount to leasing
raakmg, which infers a smaller punishment^
and not to real sedition, which infers a greater
punishment.
And the object of both these proposidone
was, to make way for the last and main object,
namely, to show that under the term banish*
ment in the act 17 OS, exile from Scotland,
only, and not transportation was intended.
My lord, with regard to the first, that there
is nothing criminal charged in the libel; I
should thmk it an indignity offered to your
lordships, and to the jurors who tried the for-
mer cases, and found those persons guilty, to
take up much time in proving that it contains
matter highly criminal, and deserving of very
great punishment. Mr. Gillies asked if there
was any thing wicked, if there was an}[ thin^
seditious, or if there was any thing criminal
iordships, but by the counsel on both sides, I in using the words ga ira, or in using French
«bould consider myself much to blame were I
to consume a great deal of your lordships
time, by entering at large a^ain into the field
of argument then stated, because I feel my-
self incapable of giving any additional illus-
eo ably stated by the solicitor-general.
My lords, the counsel for the panel has en-
deavoured to maintain before your lordships
A. variety of propositions, all of which it is in«
cumbent upon him to make out beibre his
client can derive any benefit from them.
The first was. that this libel was too generaL
that it includes verbal sedition, and that
therefore such a general indictment ought not
to be found relevant to the knowledge of an
a^cise. It is very true both verbal and real
sedition are known to the laws of this coun-
try ; but it is not from the major proposition
alone that he is to learn which is meant to
be charged ; but he is to look to the minor
proposition, and if there is such a thing ex-
isting in the law of this country as real sedi-
tion, he will there find it.
His next proposition is, that if this indict-
ment is not on account of its generality to
be laid aside entirely, it roust be presumed
that simple sedition, or leasing-making, only
is the crime laid, and that your lordship in
the interlocutor would so find U ; and he in-
stanced the case by an example which I
should have taken to prove the contrary ; for
it is very well known, that, for the crime of
theft, either a capital or an arbitrary punish-
ment may be inflicted. The usual mode of
laying indictments is the same, that the
cnme is of a heinous nature, and severely
punishable ; and from the minor proposition
jou are to learn whether it is such a crime as
will infer an arbitrary or a capital punishment.
terms in this convention, unless the object of
their meeting was criminal.
My lord, in order to judge of the eiirainalhy
of this libel, I apprehend we should lay the
whole of the facts together, and I will appeal
tration or adding weight to the argument then . to the understanding of every man, whether
he can figure to himself a more fiagitieus
crime than that cliarged against the panel ;
namely, joining a conspiracy against the go*
vemment of this country, which they have
endeavoured to promote to the utmost of their
power. Using French terms vive la conventi&n,
fa ira^ Liberty Hall, Liberty Stairs, and set
on, as general circumstances, go to prove
that the panel at the bar, with other persons,
have met for the detestable purpose of over*'
turning the constitution.
My lord, my brother has endeavoured to
take off the effect of this most extraordinary
declaration, which those gentlemen were not
satisfied with simply res^ving, but thought
necessary to bind themselves to the perror*'
mance of, by an oath. He says, in arguing
the relevancy, they made this resolution no
doubt, but the act, the passing of which they
meant to oppose, has not yet taken place,
and therefore it is no crime. That is not the
fact here siated. The charge here stated, is
an attempt to intimidate the government of
ihe country ; that if a law passed, which they
foresaw must pass, if their operations were
not put an end to, they are declaring and
binding themselves, that if such an act pass-
ed, they would still continue to meet, to in-
troduce annual parliaments and imiversal
suffrage, till such time as they were compell-
ed to desist by superior force. The gentlemen
say, that their object was merely to bring it
about by peaceable means. — Is it by peaceable
means that they intend to do it, • when they
My loids, be hae stated luee different pro- j ull you that nothiug will prevent them but
8551
S4 GEORGE HI.
Proceedingt against Joseph Gerrald
[856
superior force. Is that peaceable metiis? Is
that the language of a man who means to re-
monstrate ? No ; it is held out as a threat
against the government of the country, daring
them to do an act which they know must
crush their proceedings.
My lonls, my brother has gone on to sub-
sequent resolutions, and one instance he gives,
that they had only peaceable objects in view ;
that thev were not to meet afler the act was
passed, but that they were to act immediately
upon the first notice given of a convention-
bill ; that their object was, to procure a num-
ber of subscriptions, in order tnat they might
go up to parliament with such force as to pre-
vent the possibility of miscarriage. That is
bis argument, and ingenious it may be, were
it not contradicted by circumstances. From
the indictment your lordship sees, that the
members of this convention are to be entrust-
ed with a sealed letter, to be given to their
constituents, containing the name of the place
ill which they are to meet in secret, which
themselves are not to know, much less the
▼ast number of persons whose subscriptions
they are to eet ; and that is the mode which
is to have the effect of preventing, or rather
of resisting the execution of this act.
My lord, it is farther said, that they had
another object in view,— the resistance of au
invasion ; and that this letter must be under-
stood to have applied to a meeting of the
convention for that purpose. A very likely
story, that a meeting of seven, bein^ all that
was required to declare their meetings per-
manent, or at most twenty-one, that such a
meeting was to resist, far less repel an invasion
made upon this country. My lord, I appre-
hend nothing farther need be said with regard
to the criminality of the charge as stated in
this indictment. My lord, the gentleman
himself has given sufficient evidence, that
they were not to meet for the purpose of pe-
titioning parhament, which is legal and con-
stitutioi^ and there are meetings for that
purpose which are attended by people of tiie
greatest respectability. But this seems not
to be their object; for the gentleman himself
says, . that this measure of theirs may be
thought by some a bold, by others a daring
measure. Did the gentleman mean, when he
said this, that the people were to believe that
the object they had in view, was merely to
petition parliament ? No; and he could not
have described it in more emphatical language,
which, I am sure, every person who hears it
will feel highly applicable to the proceedings
of the British convention.
My lord, with regard to the next proposi-
tion, namely, that this is leasing making only,
and that the act 1703, should have been
specially libelled on, my answer is very
snort — that it is not leasing making, but real
sedition ; a crime well known to our laws
long before the existence of any statute.
Every lawyer who has treated upon the sub-
JQcty has not only made a distinction between
Ittsing making and real sediticn, but between
real sedition and high treason.
My lord, much, no doubt, may be said with
regard to the definition of real sedition ; for,
from the great variety of shapes which this
crime may assume, and the various de^ees of
guilt which the actors incur who commit these
crimes, it is absolutely impossible to give any
just definition of the crime, so .as to coropre*
bend every possible case ; but there are to be
found treatises in the criminal law which
point out a clear distinction, and show that
the charge here laid comes within the crime
of reals^ition.
My lord, I will beg leave to read the defi-
nition of Erskine — the first I shall read is in
his small compend. He says^ '' It consists
in raising commotions, or disturbances in
the state i it is either verbal or real. Verbal
sedition, or leasing making, is inferred from
the uttering of woras tending to create discord
between the kins and his people. It was for-
merly punished by death, and the forfeiture of
goods, but now, either by imprisonment, fine,
or banishment, at the discretion of the judge.
Real sedition is generally committed, by con*
vocating any considerable number of people,
without lawful authority, under the pretence
of redressing some public grievance, to the
disturbing of the public peace.'^
My loitl, in his larger work, he says, ** The
crime of sedition consists in raising conuno-
tions and disturbances in the state. It is
either real or verbal. Real sedition is in«
ferred from an irre^lar convocation of a
number of people, without lawful author!^,
tending to obstruct or trouble the peace of the
community. Such commotions as are aimed
directly against the sovereign or state, amount
to high treason; but where they arg raised
mereW to address some supposed grievance,
it is the crime which falls properly under the
term sedition.^' In like manner a small book,
noticed formerly by one of your lordships,
Bayne, ssiys, " Sedition is an irregular com-
motion 01 the people, or convocation of a
number of citizens, assembled without lawful
authority, tending to disturb the peace and
order of society." Is not this the very crime
here stated ? I apprehend, what has led my •
brother into an error, has been the confound-
ing of the different senses of the term com-
motion. Commotion, in an enlarged sense,
may no doubt signify a rising in arms against
the government of Uie country ; but, in ano-
ther sense, it may signify an illegal convoca*
tion of people, without lawful authority, tend- -
ing to disturb the peace and order of society.
I say, if it was otherwise, there could be no
such thing as real sedition; because, the
moment, according to them, that it becomes
real sedition, it ceases to be sedition, it is high
treason, not only by the treason laws as they
now stand, but is clearly high treason in the
old treason laws. Therefore, I apprehend,
the distinction between real sedition, and ver-
bal sedition, is perfectly obvious. It is not
857]
J6r Sedition^
A. D. 1794.
[858
necessary, in order to constitute real seditioo,
that there should he a rising in arms ; for the
moment there is a rising in arms, it ceases to
be sedition. Leasing making, on the other
hand, implies this, and no more, the uttering
or streaking, either in convocations, or spread-
injg hy means of libels or hand-hills, anv
wicked, false, scandalous speeches, which
lend to introduce jealousies among the people,
and to overturn the state. But sedition may
exist without uttering any scandalous and
fdUsc speeches; as, &r instance, when this
gentleman declared and bound himself by an
oath, to resist any act that might pass to pre-
vent the meeting of this convention — ^this was
not a false speech ; it contained, in a melan-
choly truth, that these people set themselves
up in defiance of the law oi the country, and
declared they would not desist from their
wicked proceedings till they were compelled
by superior force.
My lord, it is not necessary to look to our
statute book, for the exact definition of sedi-
tion, or when it was first introduced into the
law of Scotland ; for it has been well observ-
ed, by all of your lordships, that it must have
existed, not onlv in this, but in every country;
that it is coeval with the existence of society
itself, because it is impossible that any countiy
can exist, if the crime of sedition be allowed
to pass without any punishment at all. In the
law of Scotland, it existed for many genera-
tions, before it became the object of statute
law, till the punishment applicable b^ the
eommon law was not sufficient to restrain the
vices and wickedness of people ; and then acts
were made only regarding these particular
species of sedition which appeared to be most
criminal, and which appeared to be most
levelled agjainsf the government of the country.
At that time it never occurred to the justice
of the legislature, and it would have been
unjust if It had, to have framed an act so
comprehensive as to include every species^ of
crime, which could fall under the term of sedi-
tion, because they must have known that it
is a crime, not onlv infinito in its variety, but
also infinite in its degrees and shades of guilt.
Particular acts of semtion were declared to be
capital, and with respect to some of them, I
must adl your lordsnips attention, for they
contain a particular specification of the crime
here charged; and had this gentleman been
tried, prior to 1709, when the old treason
laws existed in this country, he must have
been tried for high treason, and punished with
death.
My lord, the first of these statutes was
stated by the solicitor general, when he first
argued the case to your lordships, 1584, ch.
ISO, — ^^ Therefoir it is statute and ordained,
bee our said soveraine lord, and his saidis
three estaites in this present parliament, that
nane of his lieges and subjectes presume or
tak upon hand to impuzne the dignitie and
the authoritie of the saidu three estaites, or to
fieek or procure the innovation or diminution
of the power and authoritie of the same three
estaites, or ony of them, in time cumming,
under the paine of treason.'' Does not Uns
gentleman, I would ask, impugn the dignity
of the estates of parliament, when he says,
that they would pay no regard to the wisdom
of parliament, and that they would continue
to meet till such time as they were compelled
to desist by superior force ? — ^and he does not
content himself with that, but justifies tlieir
doing so upon the laws of God and right rea-
son : he says — ** If such a law were suffered
to
pass.
if men were not allowed to utter
their complaints, a number of fierce and ran-
corous passions would arise, and we would
seek to appeal to that last terrible decision,
the event of which is uncertain, but which
God and nature allow.'' Here the gentleman
is not only saying, but binding himself by an
oath, that if the legislature should enact a
particular statute, tnev would resist it, by
continuing to meet, till they were compelled
to desist oy superior force. Here they are
telling the whole country, that their resis-
tance is sanctioned by the laws of God and
the laws of reason. I apprehend it to be
clear, therefore, that if he had been tried
prior to that act, he must have been tried and
punished for high treason, according to the
statute 1 have now read, which inmcts the
punishment of death. But, my lord, there is
another act applicable to the present case ; it
is the act of 1662, ch. 8,— << An act for the
preservation of his majesty's person, autho*
rity, and government And since the rise
and progress of the late troubles, did, in a
great measure, proceed firom some treason-
able and seditious positions infused into the
people, that it was lawful to subjects for re-
formation to enter into covenants and leagues,
or to take up arms against the king, or those
commissioned by him, and such like;" and so
on, till it comes to the following enactments :
" Like as bis migestyand estates of parlia-
ment, reflecting on the sad consequences of
tliese rebellious courses, and being careful to
prevent the like for the future, have therefore
statute and ordained, and bjf tliese presents
statutes and ordains, that if any person or
persons shall hereafter plot, contrive, or in«
tend death, or destruction, to the king's ma-
jesty, or any bodily harm tending to death or
destruction, or any restraint upon his royal
person, or to deprive, depose, or suspend him
from the style, honour, and kingly name, of
the imperial crown of tms realm, or any others
his majesty's dominions, or to 'suspend him
from the exercise of his royal government, or
to levy war, or take up arms, against his ma-
jes^, or any commissioned by him, or shall
entice any strangers or others to invade any
of his majcs^s dominions, and shall, by
writing, prinUng, preaching, or other mali-
cious and devised speaking, express or declare
such their treasonable intentions, that then
these persons are to suffer death, as in cases
of treason.". Have not the gentlemen ex-
S69] Si GEORGE III; Proeeedingt against J^Ufh Gerrald
fmo
pres8ed| iu the strongest termsy and bound
themselves by oath, that they would resist
the government^ and that they would resbt it
by force ? And they justify force bv the laws
of God and reason. Is not this then an in-
tention of levying war against the king?
therefore, if the gentleman had been tried
upon this statute, prior to the statute of 1709,
he might have been punished as a traitor ;
because he has declared his intention to be, to
make war against the government, till supe-
rior force compelled them to desist. If the
gentleman haa been tried, even after the
passing of the act 1703, and before 1709, he
must have been tried and punished as a trai*
tor. And, my lord, what effect is the intro-
duction of the treason laws into this country
to have ? Are these acts of sedition, of such
a^ aggravated nature, as are declared treason
by law, not to be liable to any punishment
whatever? for, my lord, admitting that there
is no such thing as real sedition, then, I say,
the act of 1703, give it the widest range pos-
sible, never can reach those acts of sedition,
which were declared treason by former acts.
But, my lord, the natural consequence of the
operation of the treason laws of England
coming into this country, is, not to have the
effect of leaving these crimes without punish-
ment at all, but leaves them exactly in the
same situation in which they were before this
act of parliament was introduced ; and your
lordship is m titled to punish, at common
law, as vour lordship would have done if the
case had been tried prior to the passing of
these acts.
My lord, if I am right in this position, tliat
this crime is real sedition, and that falling
under those acts it might have been punished
as treason, it is matter of very little conse-
quence what is meant by the word banish-
ment ; because, in the first place, I apprehend
this case is not leasiug-makmg, as I have en-
deavoured to show your lordship : but suppose
the case were leaaing-making,. I am not
bound, in this case, to lay the libel upon the
leasing-making statutes; for, although it was
well observed by all your lordships, that
where an act creates a crime, and specifies
the punishment to be annexed upon the con-
viction of such a crime, we must apply the
statutory punishment) yet, my lord, itoflen
happens, that acts of parliament are intro-
duced where the crime existed at common
law before ; and, in these cases, whether the
acts introduced a higher or a lesser punish-
ment, unless the act specially takes away the
crime at common law, specially deprives you
of the jurisdiction inherent in this court, of
trying at common law, there is no occasion
for laying the libel upon that statute. Your
lordships know^ when the crime is made
greater, I may charge it either upon the sta-
tute or the common law ; and it often hap- |
pens, that the object of the statute is, to aive
jurisdiction to a court that it had. not before,
oc u> lAtroduee a mare summary, mode of
punishment; and, in that case^ unless the
act declares that you are not to try at com**
mon law, it is not to be presumed that the
common law power is taken away. For, in
the case of bribing excise officers, though it is
punishable at common law, there are statutes
imposing severe fines; and your lordship will
recollect, in tlie case of Mr. Stein, for bribing
Mr. Bonar, it was strongly urged, that as the
act introduces the punishment of severe fine»
you are not entitled to disregard this act, and
go to a trial at common law, but you must
lay the libel upon this statute, and confine
yourself to the punishment inflicted by that
statute ; but it was held, that your lordshipa
common law powers arc not taxen away, and
therefore you are entitled to try and punish
that gentleman at common law.
My lord, I may exemplify this case by aii»
instance which has been introduced by my
brother ; in pleading this case, he mentioned
the case of several people tried upon the leas-
injg-making statutes. Those persons were not
tried upon the leasing-making statutes alpne,
for they were tried upon the laws of God, and
upon the laws of this and every other well*
governed realm. I will also refer the gentle-^
^man to another case, in 1713, when the party
tried, and the able counsel who defended him-
knew perfectly well, the meaning of the word
banishment. His indictment is laid upon the
act 1703, and is also laid upon the laws of
G<^d, and of this and every other well-go-
verned realm. The counsel for that genUe-
man pleaded a variety of objections to the te*-
levancy of that indictment ; but it never oc-
curred to the gentleman to state, that it was
not competent for the court to try him both
upon the common law of this land, and upoa
the statute law. My lord, it never occurred
to him that the punishment was different by
the common law ; they never asked your lord-
ships to di^niss the indictment, because it
was laid upon both laws; nor did they areue
that your lordships ought to define and dec&re
to the jury, that the term banishment, in this
act, was exile, and not transportation :— No
such thing ; and it cannot be supposed that it
was through ignorance, for they were men
learned in the law, and living at the very time
the acts were made.
My lord, this, in my mind, affords a strong^
argument, not only to show that an indict-
ment is relevant at common law, altliough
an act of parliament has been introdueed,^
making it a crime, and stating a particular
punishment, unless that act destroys your
lordship's power at common law : it goes to
show, that under the word banishment, trans-
portation is likewise included, or the gentle-
men would certainly have insisted upon so
material a thing for the safety of their client.
My lord, this leads me to take notice of
the last proposition, which is the main.object:
of the whole argument in this caee^ eeiBely..
that exile, or banishment from Scotlaad*
oniy^ou^t to betbepimiahment>
rn^i
for Set&ian*
A. D. 1794.
[869
Mj lord, t win not follow the gentleman
into dictionaries to look for the term ; and
the one that he has found does not seem to
afford him any assistance. But, if I can show
that transportation was considered as included
in the term hy the lawyers of the times, and
hy historians of the times, there is an end of
this question ^ for, independent of the various
sentences which were read to your lordships
upon the last occasion, and which I shall
not consume your lordship's time by reading
again, from ine books of adjournal of this
eourt, not only prior to the passing of the
actirOd, but down to 1756, when the pu-
Bbhmentof transportation was introduceo, I
^hall refer your lordship to the sentences of
the court of session, which show that they
understood banishment in the very same
sense ; and prior to 1756, there are a variety
of cases which show, that from the incidental
jurisdiction they had in the punishment of
forgery, they are entitled at common law,
witnout the aid of any statute, to send people
to the plantations ; and the uniform form of
the sentence is in these words, " ordain that
be be carried back toprison, there to remain
till an opportunity ofiers of carrying him to
some of the plantations in America, there to
be banished tor ever/' In some cases it is
banished for ever, in other cases, for a cer-
tain number of years.
My lord, I might also resort to the histo-
rians of the times — ^I will read to your lord-
ship one passage from Guthrie's History,
which clearly ^ows that he imderst(»od
transportation to be included in the word
banisnment. Immediately after the execu-
tion of the duke [earl] of Argyle, in 1685,
Guthrie, speaking of what acts of parliament
had declared, says, " they declared their
abhorrence and detestation of all resistance,
tipon whatever pretext, by deed, word, or
writing ; and, at last, they passed an act to
approve whatever had been done by his
majesty's privy council, justice court, and
those commissionated by them in banishing
Imprisoning or fining such as refused to take
and swear the oath of allegiance, and to
assert the royal prerogative m their utmost
extent."
Your lordship knows, that in this reign,
and m the reign of his brother Charles 2ncL a
number of unfortunate people, because they
would not subscribe bonds of peace and the
oath of allegiance, were sent by the privy
council to the plantations, by ship-loads ; and
also a number of conventiclers were remand-
ed back to prison, till an opportunity should
be afforded of transporting, them to Barba-
does, where no less than eighty of them
were lying for transportation. The king
would never ratify a deed of the privy coun-
cil, who banished a man from his dominions
hx Scotland to his dominions in England,
because he would not swear the oath of al-
leg^nce. It is perfectlv well known, that
Emiflreds of our iellow<uizeBs vrere seat in
those days to the plantations. My lord, I do
not read this as an example for imitation; no
roan can justify such arbitrary proceedings ;
but no' man, I am sure, was ever sent from
Scotland to England, because he refused to
take the oath of allegiance. I will say there
is no instance of such a -case to be found;
they were all sent to the plantations ; and,
then your lordship sees tnis author, when
speakmg of those tmnsportations, makes use
of the word banishing only; and therefore,
it is very clear that his idea of the word was
the very same which I am now contending for
before your lordship, namely, that the word
« banishment is a general term; that trans,
portation is only one mode of carrying it into
effect, and that under the term banishment^
tmnsportation was intended by the act 1703.
My lord, independent of that, I might ask
your lordship, is it natural to suppose, if it
was their intention under this act, that no
man should be transported, that they would
have made use of the very terra which this
Court have uniformly used when they inflict-
ed the punishment of transportation. No,
my lord, the very reverse is tne natural sup-
position. Besides, I might state to youf
lordships, that the object of the legislature
was merely to take away the capital part of
the punishment ; that is perfectly clear frorti
the words of the act itself. It says, " that
in respect of their generality, and the various
construction which the same may admit, thcjr
may be as to the foresaid capital punishment,
of dangerous consequence, doth, therefore;,
with advice and consent of the estates of
parliament, abrogate and discharge, in aQ
time coming, the foresaid sanction and pain
of death and confiscation contained in the
saids acts ; and statutes and ordains, that the
punishment of the crimes therein mentioned,
shall for hereafter only be arbitrary," and
then enumerates the punishment of banish^
ment, fining, and imprisonment, which were
the common law punishments then in use.
My lord, I beg leave to refer your lordshipa
to the act 1701, where the power of tran»-
portation by this court is expressly recognized.
'' As also that no person be transportea furth
of this kingdom, except with his own con-
sent, given before a judge, or by legal sen-.
tence. I woul(J ask the gentleman where is
the legal statute which authorizes trans-
portation ? — I may, perhaps, be told, that the
act 1670 authorizes transportation, because
they were to be banished to the Indies ; but
I will remind them, that that act was re*
scinded in 1690, the second act of the second
parliament of Charles 2d. Here is the only-
act which mentions the banishing a man to
the plantations, rescinded in 1690 ; and ^et^
in 1701, we find an act expressly recognizing;
the power of transportation ; because it say$^
that no man is to be transported but bv hxs
own consent, or by legal sentence, where
then is the statute that authorizes transporta-
tion? I say there is' no such Ihing; and
863] 34 GEORGE III* Proceedings, agfiinsi Joseph Gerrald
[864
therefore it is clear that it is included in the
term banishmeut, otherwise there can be no
Jegal sentence of transportation. The gen-
tleman says, that by tne act 1703, banish*
ment is to be understood ; and when an act
enumerates banishment, fining, and impri-
sonment, that you are not to enlarge^those,
or introduce any other punishments which
are not there specifically mentioned. I should
be glad to know what explanation they are to
give of the last clause of the act 1670, with
respect to their refusing to depone as to con-
venticles. The object of that act was to dis-
cover meeUngs of conventiclers, and to de-
clare the punishment to be inflicted upon
those who should refuse, when called upon,
to say what they knew respecting these con-
venticles; the punishment is to be nnine, close
imprisonment, or banishment. The legisla-
ture foresaw that when the man was ^Ued
jpon to declare what he knew, he might
include and blame himself by so doing, and
^erefore it was thought necessary to enact
a clause freeing him irom the punishment,
and therefore it was provided, that no man's
declaration against any other person should
infer s^ainst himself the loss ot life, or limb,
or banishment.
My brother has told your lordship, upon
ihe authority of sir George Mackenzie, that
banishment by transportation was illeg^,
because it is impossible to confine a man to
any place to which he is banished, as though
your lordship had a jurisdiction over him
while he is in that place undergoing the sen-
tence of banishment ; but that is not the
case, for from the moment that he has once
landed, your lordship has no farther autho-
rity; you are not confining him there; he
may go where he likes, provided he does not
return to this country. My lord, he has also
appealed to another passage iu Mackenzie,
to show that this was an illegal sentence, in
his justification of the reign of Charles 8d.
where it is said, that people were sent abroaa
from a principle of mercy, because these
people might otherwise have been punished
Dy death ; and, my lord, it is very true as
applied to those people who were taken at
Bothwell bridge in 1679; because historians
tell us, that about 1300 of them were taken
with arms in their hands, and in open rebel-
lion ; it was therefore mercy to send them
abroad and not try them for their lives ; but
it was only those persons who refused to
subscribe declarations that bv the act 1670
were to be sent abroad, and the privy council
had an express power of sending them to the
plantations.
My lord, it is a mistake to say, that send-
ing people to the plantations was for the
first time only introduced at the time of the
rebellion at Bothwell bridge; for all those
who were taken a ^eat many years before,
at the rebellion which was crushed at the
Pentland Hills in 1667, I think, were sent
there likewise. And if your lordship reads
the histonr of this countnr prior to 1660,
you will find a variety of'^ instances where
people were sent to the plantations for refu»-
mg to subscribe bonds of^ peace, and refusing
to take the oath of allegiance. When was
the first time it was introduced into this
country, I know not ; however, I know from
history, that it was not upon the passing of
that act 1660 ; because, my lord, I rcacF of
ship loads of unfortunate people having been
sent away, who thouzht it inconsbtent with
their duty to subscribe bonds of peace. My
brother has referred to the act of 1609, which
mentions banishment; and his argument is
that transportation could not have been intend-
ed, because transportation was unknown ia
those days, and therefore it appears singular
that .the act 1609, when repealed by the act
1703, on account of the severity of its sen-
tence, should have enacted a punishment much
more severe than the former. Upon what
foundation or authority the gentleman says.
a person could not have been transported
under the act 1609, 1 am at a loss to discover ;
for they had just as much a power, and just
as much an opportunity of transporting in
1609 as they had in 1660, when I know a
great many transportations took place.
My lonl, I see no reason why transporta-
tion could not have been indicted uncler in
the year 1701, as well as 1660. But I will
read to your lordship the last clause of the act
1609. " And nevertheless, finding therein
sik malicious letts as the devilc and his sup-
posts do usually suggest to the hindrance of
all just and godlie interpryses, specially, by
the false and calumnious brutes; speeches,
and writs, craftelie uttered and dispersed by
some laulessondsauUes people of this realme,
as well in privat conferences as in their meet-
ings at taverns ail houses and playes, and by
their pasquills, lybels, rymes, cockalans, com^
medies, and siklyke occasions, whereby they
slander, roaligne, and revile the people, es*
taite, and country of England, and divers his
m£uesties honourable counsellers, magistrates
and worthie subjects, of that his msyesties
kingdoroc. The continuance whereof being
able to incense the people of England to just
grief and miscontentment, may not onlv hin-
der the intended union of all the good sub-
jects of this monarchic^ but stir up in them
sik irreconciliable evil will, as with time
might bring forth maist dangerous and harm^
ful efrects.'^Can your lordship believe, that
as a punishment to men who had produced'
such irreconcileable hatred between the two
kingdoms, this act intended that they should
be banished into England, where they would
have a much better opportunity of complet-
ing their purpose than they could have in
Scotland. I am perfectly sure a judge would
have been laughed at who had sent such a
man into England. I am satisfied that no
sentence ever was passed upon this act. It
was an act passed by Scotland, under the im-
pression that England would pronounce asiffiir-
865]
for SeJkiofh
A. tt. Vf9i.
[866
Jar judgm«Dt In evidence of this I shall read
to your lordship what sir Georj^e Mack^iude
says. " But, in my opinion, this att reaches
only such as speak reproacbfuny of their na-
tion, country, and counsellors ; but the whole
act ought to be abrogated by our parliamenL
as being past by in expectation that Eng^ana
would make such an act in their parliament,
which they never did ; and upon which ac-
count, it was never in observance with ua."
I am perfectly satisfied that if this act had
ever heen put in force, if any sentence had
ever been imposed, it must have been trans-
portation.
My lord, I do not feel it necessary to trovt-
ble y<|ur lordship anv fiirther, neither of the
positions laid down by ray brother being ap-
J^Ucable to the present case, because it b not
easing making, but sedition, so near the
crimeoftreason, thatby the ancient treason
laws of So^and, it woiud amount to treason.
The act at common law remains in full force,
and I am perfectly clear, whether you take
the intention of the legislature, or whether
|FOU take the words themselves as explained
by historians, by the legislature itself, and by
the sentences of this court and the court of
aession, your lordships cannot have a doubt,
but that under the act of 170S. you have it in
your power to send this gentleman, or any
other who may be found guilty of sedition,
to transport him beyond seas.
Lord Justice Cierk. — Mr. Montgomery, yon
have gone into it very ably and very fully.
Mr. SolicUar General. — My lords, the points
which you have now heard debated, are points
upon which I have made up my mind most
Atlly, and which I should not be afraid to ar«
gue in any court, in any place, or aeainst any
opponent But, my lord, when I consider
thai this matter underwent a very full dis-
cussion this day fortnight, and when I eon-
aider that your lordships then heard these
points stated with all the ability which the
oar could furnish (and I cannot suppose that
your lordships have drank so deeply of the
waters of Lethe, as to have forgot what passed
"Upon that occasion]^ I think it unnecessary to
.trouble vour lordship with many words, mo^
especially as so much justice has been done lo
it^ by the gentleman who has already spoken.
My lord, as to the first point, whether there
is such a crime known in our law as that of se-
dition, I shall not say a single word, because
no person who knows any thing of our law
can entertain a single doubt.
The next point is, whether the &ct8 charge
€d in this indictment do amount to tiie crime
of sedition, yea or no ? and after what we
have heard so fiiUy discussed, and sher what
^MMir lordships have determined upon the sub-
ject, I cannot suppose that any argument is
necessary upon this branch of the sulgect
My lord, you have been told that all the
crime which this panel has committed, is the
•ntertaming ideas favourable to universal suf-
frage and annual parliaments, and in which
VOL. xxm.
ideashe wM satetionedby the mostrespectable
names. My lord, whatever opinions those
persons may privately entertain, I have no
opportunity to know, but I beg lespre to ask
of the counsel on the other side, whoy I dai^
say are better informed l^an I anr. Hat«
Mr. Pitt and the duke of Richmond ever
formed any convention in England? Have
they ever called themselves the British Codi*
vention? Have they ever called themselvea
the representatives of the body of tiie peoplef
Have they ever told the parliament ei Great
Britain, that they shall not presume to dis-
perse then»? Have they ever told them that
if thef dared to bring into parliament a ce»->
tain bill, they will resist it by force ? Or
have they told the public, that in case of aft
invasion, they will meet in a secret place f If
they have done so, it has been unKuown to
me, and if they have^ it says very little fbr
those to whom the criminal laws of England
are entrusted, but as far as I know, no such
thing has ever happened.
My brother Gillies, who pleaded the cause
with very gr^at ability, told your lordship^
that even if the facts stated were proved, aa
well as the criminal intention (which I admit
is absolutely essential), that in that case, thcf
libel ought not to be sustained as relevant, in
so far as the charges amount to high treason^
Now, my lord, I will so far agree with my
brother, that in making out this charge before
the jurv, it will be necessary for me to sattsQr
them that he had a eriminal intention i and
if my broUier can show me that the fiM^
charged in this indictment do come within
tho treason act of Edward 3d, we shall very
soon make a short argument of this case, be^
cause I shall immediately desert the diet.—
We shall have no more trial upon this indict-
ment, but I shall immediately apply to your
lordships, that that gentleman be committed
for high treason. It is a thing J have fully
considered, and I am perfectly satisfied. I
have no doubt of provme the intention, of
which the jury will juc&e, and that they
amount to something whicTi is very near trea-
son, the most ag^vated species of sedition
that can be imagined.
My lord, the only other point for eonside*
«^tyon relates to the degree of punishment
which your lordships have power to inflict,
supposing the crime to be proved. Now, my
lora, I apprehend it is perfectly well estab-
lished, that banishment by transportation,
which I say is a particular tnoit of banish-
ment, is known to the common law of Soot*
land ; it was a power exercised by the eourt
of session without a statute, and exercised by
all the criminal courts in Scotland* When
this practice was first introduced, it is impos*^
sible for roe to say : but, I believe, much car*
lier than is generally supposed. It is suifict«
ent for me to state, that transportation is
known to the law of Scotland, ana is acknow-
ledged and recognized in the fullest manner,
by the act of 1701.
867]
S4 GEORGE m.
Proaedingt agAinsi Joseph Gerrald
[868
The question therefore is^ whether your
lordships, in judeing of the crime of sedition,
are restrained mm inflicting that punish-
ment, sup{K>sine it to he a legS one. I must
first show it to oe a legal one, and then, whe-
ther there is any statute which restrains the
power of the court; and this leads roe to con-
sider the act 1703, which is the single act
that the gentlemen found upon, as limiting
the power of the court ; and, upon this sta-
tute, it is necessary for me to sav very ^ttle.
Upon lookins at the enacting clause, it ap-
pears to me, that the only purpose of the sta-
tute was, to take away the capital part of it.
It is very true, the act says that the court
shall inflict the punishment bv fine, imprison-
ment, or banishment; and mj brother
tells your lordship, that there is a very
material difierence between banishment
and transportation; and he shows your
lordship from Johnson's Dictionary, Shakes-
pcare. and other respectable authorities, that
banishment and transportation are different
thin^ ; but I take it to be a very clear point
that m judging of the statute law of Scotland,
we are not to go to an English dictionary, or
to poetical writings — tliere can be but one
authority, which is neither more nor less than
the language of the common law of Scotland;
and where are we to find it? We are to find
it in the records of this supreme court; search
has been made in those records, and by that
search it is made clear, I shoula suppose, be-
yond the possibility of contradiction, that ac-
cording to the law language of Scotland, be-
fore the statute, at the time of the statute,
and after the statute, banishment did include
transportation.
My lord, instances were pointed out to your
lordship, which it will be unnecessary to re-
peat, because it is impossible that they can be
forgotten, in all of wnich your lordships in-
flicted the punishment of banishment; and,
in order to carry that into execution, you or-
dain and appoint the persons to be banished
beyond seas.
My lord. I shall beg leave to mention one
case which has not occurred* before, and
that is a case which happened in the month
of February 1704, which your lordship will
observe, was just five months after pass-
ing the act upon which the gentlemen found,
the act of 1703, having been passed in the
month of September, and this case was deter*
mined in the February following. It was a
case which occurred before the privy council
of Scotland, which your lordships know was
at that time a court invested with a jurisdic-
tion of a vei;y. considerable extent. It was a
trial for leasing makinj; (the very crime upon
which the gentlemen found their argument),
i^Kin the 4th of February 1704, a libel against
a Mr. David Baillie,t brother to captain Ro-
• So in Orig. Edit.
t In the appendix to the original edition of
Oefold'a tnal tooe account of David BaJllie's
bert Baillie of Manor-hall, for leading making,
and the conclusion of it, after setting iotxti
the fiict is, that the aforesnid David Baillie,
ought to be severely punished for the same,
with the pains of law, at least conform to the
4th act of the last session of the current par-
liament, intituled " act anent leasing maKCrs
and slanderers.'' Here your lordship seirs
this libel specially refers to the statute
1703, and prays, upon the party being con-
victed, that he should be severely punished
for the same, with the pains of law, at least
conform to the 4th act of the last session of
the current parliament. My lords, this was
tried before a court who did not sit at the
distance of ninety years, but who sat within
five months after the act passed ; and there-
fore it is natural to suppose, that they under-
stood its meaning ; and my lord, I observe by
the sederunt, that the president of the court
of session was there, the lord justice clerk
was there, and many other of the judges, and
therefore it is impossible they could mistdce
its meaning. In the first place, the party ac-
knowledges the ofience ; and, therefore, there
was no need of any trial as to his milt ; and,
in the next place, ne was assisted by no less
than six able counsel, and a great deal of ar-
gument there was upon it — but when yon
come to the sentence, '^ the hbel having been
found relevant to infer an arbitrary punisb-
ment, that the two letters libelled on were all
his hand writing, the court hereby ordain and
adjudge, that the said David Baillie be tranv
ported to the West Indies, that he be set in
the pillory from eleven to twelve in the ibre>
noon, and in case the person cannot ]»y the
fine, to be transported, and to be kept in the
prison of Ayr, until he be so transported."
My lord, I know very well that it is not
the mshion of the times, to think a great deal
of our ancestors; but I shall admit, that in
point of wisdom, in point of philology, iu point
of philosophy, and many other fine specula-
tive ideas,— I will admit that our fordathers
were by no means comparable to us in those
fine theories which modem f^tlosophy has
found out witli regard to religion and goven>-
ment ; witness the glorious state of France at
this moment But, my lords, can we under-
stand that act better than they did? Did
not they know their own meaning better than
we dor And yet your lordship sees the
judees who sat in that very parliament, witb-
m five months after sitting in a court of ju»>
tice, upon a case in point, they understood
the meaning of banishment, and they trans-
ported him to the West Indies. And, my
lord, this is not all, I see^ at this time, the
gentleman was not undefended, he was as-
sisted by six able counsel, and not one of them
case was inserted; but having been already
printed in Vol. 14 p. 1055 of this Collection.
It is here omitted. The sentence passed upoM
Baillie by the privy council will be found in
Vol. 14; p. 1053.
869]
Jht SedtttM'
A. D. 17M.
[870
pretends to say he had the smallest doubt
aboAt it; they argued many points of law,
but this was not so much as mentioned, it was
clear beyond the possibility of doubt that it in-
cluded transportation. I cannot have a doubt,
but that your lordships, upon the fair con-
struction of this act, lukve the power, in case
this panel should be convicted by the verdict
of a jury : but it will be with your lordships
to judge whether you think he merits it or
not. This is a complete answer to the two
cases the gentlemen has cited. The act does
not bind ^ou to transport, but it is an arbi-
trary punishment in the discretion of the
court; and, in the present case, it will be
witli your lordships to judge whether you
think the extent or the crune merits such du-
nishment. Your lordships can have veiy litp
tie doubt about the matter, and, I think the
proper time for that determination, would be
after the verdict of the jury.
. Mr. Laing. — My lord justice clerk. By your
lordship's appointment I have undertaken a
cause which I at first declined, not only from
personal considerations, which I forbear to
mention, but because my recent avocations
have been very different Irom the pursuits of
this bar. The cause of my client, though un-
dertaken bv vour order, is now my own ; and
I will plead for him, as I would for myself,
were I placed in his situation at the bar. No
considerations shall now defter me, nor shall
thefear of obloquy relax my efibrts to esta-
blish his innocence, and oveiWn the prepos-
terous charges of this indictment.
The arguments maintained on the relevan-
cy may be reduced to three propositions, to
which, whatever illustrations or additionsJ ar-
guments my recollection and my strength
may enable me to contribute, shall be speci-
fically directed.
1. That the facts charged in the indictment
are not of a criminal nature ; or, if criminal,
that they constitute merely a statutory of-
fence.
9. Tliat where the crime is provided for by
statute, a severer^ or a different punishment,
cannot legally be inflicted at common law.
3. That the punishment of the facts charged
in the indictment, if indeed criminal, are, as
regulated by 1703, ch. 4, fine, imprisonment,
or Danishment ; meaning thereby oanishment
forth of the realm alone.
1. My lord, on the first proposition, that
the facts chained in the indictment, if crimi-
nal, constitute a statutory offence, the ar^-
. ment of the prosecutor amounts to this, tnat
sedition is a technical or generic term, com-
prehending a variety of different crimes; yet
unsusceptible, at the same time, ofadefini-
' tion applicable to every crime. That there is
no dennition of sedition strictlj^ applicable to
each case, 1 shall readily admit; for the de-
finitions given by our lawyers are foundkl on
a previous distinction between real and verbal
sedition. The former is uniformly described
as an actual commotion^ or jising of the
people; the latter, the utterance of false re-
ports, or the publication of writings tending
to excite such commotions, or to overturn the
established constitution or 0)vernment. My
lord, this is not an ideal aistinction ; it ori-
ginates from the very nature of crimes ; fit)m
the difference between the attempt and the
deed ; from the necessity of distinguishing
between what is actually committed, and that
which is perhaps an abortive attempt to effect
the deed. In murder, a conspiracy against
our neighbour's life, when earned into execu-
tion, must be distinguished from an attempt
to instigate another to the commission of
murder. So in perjury, subornation of evi-
dence is a crime of a vety different com-
plexion from perjury itself. Here, then, is a
distinction never to be removed from the na-
ture of crimes; the intention alone does not
constitute the crime ; unless it is carried into
execution, it cannot amount to the crime
which it'failed to accomplish. This distinc-
tion is also founded in the nature of
crimes against the state, which, I observe,
are all reducible to sedition, to treason, and
to verbal sedition. Whatever tends to the
destruction of the state, may be termed sedi-
tion : but there are acts of sedition exalted to
treason, ennobled on account of their dan-
gerous consequences, and punished as trea-
son, by attainder, forfeiture, and a rigorous
death. Sedition itself is a popular commo-
tion, to the obstruction of law, or the inter-
ruption of public tranquillity ; not directed,
however, against the constitution, nor amount-
ing to treason. — Thus an insurrection, though
in arms, to destroy an inclosure, is in Eng-
land a riot, in Scotland sedition; but an in-
surrection to destroy all inclosures constitutes
treason.— But there is a crime different from
this ; there is an attempt to excite, or to com-
mit sedition ; an attempt which, in treason,
and in treason alone, is converted into an
overt act, and, on account of its dangerous
consequences, punished by statute as treason
itself. State crimes, therefore, are either se-
dition or the attempt to excite it, or certain
actions, converted, tor the preservation of th«
state, into treason. I conclude, therefore,
both firom the nature of crimes in general,
and from the distinctions essential to crimes
against the state, that an attempt to commit
sedition, never can constitute actual sedition.
This distinction, and these definitions, may
be variously illustrated. Nor, in a question
conceminfl; the signification of terms, will
your lordsnips reject the assistance of philo-
logy, or of any science that ascertains their
common acceptation, or their proper import.
If we resort, then, to the acceptation of the
word in our own language, sedition is defined ^
by Johnson, our greatest philologist, ^* a tu-
mult, an insurrection, a popular commotion,
an uproar.'' Here an actual commotion is
specified, not that seditious attempt, the ten-
dency or the design of which is to excite com-
motiop. if we examipa its etymology, sedi-
671]
84 GEORGE IQ.
Proceedings e^fu^ Josepk Gerrdd
|BT8
tioD, teonum itiOf is a separation or secession
from the body of the people; and in this
aense the secession of the Roman people to
the Aventine mount, would have been a se-
dition, had not the cause of the people ulti-
mately triumphed. But the speeches of Sici>
sius, which produced that secession, what-
ever was their tendency, could never with
propriety be denominated sedition. The sedi-
tion described by Virgil —
Ac veluti magno in {>op.ulo cum sfepe cootta est
6editio, saeviUjue animis ignobile valgus,
J amque faces et saxa volant, furor anna mi-
nistrat ;
the actual commotion described in this si-
soile, is very different from that attempt to
jcreate sedition, of which the brutal Appius
accuses the father and the lover of Virginia. —
" Certis indiciis compertum se habere, nocte
toti coetus in urbe uctos ad movendam sedi-
tionem." — ^Livy. Convocations were formed
In the city, and during the night, butVirgi-
nius and Icilius were only accused of attempt-
ing ^y ^^^^ nocturnal convocations^ to stir
up the people to acUial sedition.
My lord, the application of this distinction
is sufficient to determine the nature of the
£rime. If the corpus delicti consists in opi-
nions and speeches, or in resolutions, tne
concurrents of opinions and result of speeches,
these are criminal on account of their ten-
.dency to excite sedition or disturbance in the
^tate. The tendencj of the offence consti-
tutes the guilt; for I maintain, that in them-
aelves the speeches are not criminal. The
xesolutions^ if locked up in the breast^^the
speeches, if uttered to the winds of tne de-
sert^-^the writings, if concealed in our repo-
aitories from human observation, are neither
criminal nor obnoxious to punishment. In
the celebrated case of Algernon Sydney,* the
papers discovered in bis cabinet and never
fromulgated, afforded bo legal evidence of
treason, and would have constituted no spe-
cies whatever of sedition. I repeat it, there-
fere, that tlie speeches are not m themselves
criminal. The man who writes, without at-
tempting to disseminate, or to publish, a se-
ditious composition, may remain in the coun-
tiy as an innocent citizen ; and, however dis*
a&eUd in secret U> government, vdll still en-
joy the protection ofits law^ Your lord&bips
will thecefore observe, that it is not the malus
enimtM which is punishable, not that mind
which is hostile to the state, but the declara-
tion of thai hostile disposition, tmuIo ardmOf to
the effect of exciting disturbance, or with a
.design xo generate similar hostility in the
niads of others. The hci itself may be in-
^ .oflfensiye; theattemot may be impotent; but
the attempt, though frustrated, then becomes
criminal when dangerous to society ; and its
tendency is thip circumstance which oonsta*
tutes the crime.
^^^fmmmim
^ $Sfi VqL 9, p. 817| of this Collection.
My lord, the principle which I havn tknt
endeavoured to establish, is fully recogmaed
in the law of England, in which contempts or
misprisions ajgainst the kins or govemmeat*
ofiences equivalent to veroal sedition, are
punished on account of their tendency uone.
" Contempts and misprisions," says Blade*.
stone, '' against the kin^*s person and gOTem-
ment, may be by speakmg or writing against
them, cursing or wishing him ill, givins; out
scandalous stories concerning him, or aoing
any thing that ma^ tend to lessen him in the
esteem of his subjects, may weaken his go*
vemment, or may raise jwousies between
him and his people."* Though denied in ar*
gument, the principle is acknowledged in the
mdictment itself. The cM-pus deticH is there
stated, as ** of the most dangerous and de-
structive tendency, hostile to the peace and
happiness of society, and tending to siAvert
the constitution of the realm.'' In eveiy
other indictment for verbal sedition, the tame
tendency has been unifonnly charged.
BuL m opposition to the concurrent antho*
rity of lawyers, in contradiction to that eseen*
tisl distinction between a crime attempted,
and actually committed, sedition, it is said,
is a technical epithet, expressive of a varie^
of distinct crimes, but incapable of a defini-
tion to which every seditious olfenee may be
reduced. Sedition is represented as a hydra^
united below in a common tnmk, but dis*
parted above into a thousand heads. Of the
seditious it is said,
Their aims are various, as the paths they
take
In journeying through life.
Nor aie their crimes, though obnoxious to
legal penalties, reducible to any legal defini*
tion or standard.
My answer is this, that the supposed va-
riety, so unsusceptible of definition, proceeds
from the creation of various statutoi^ acts of
sedition, just as lesser offences are sometimes
converted into statutory treasons. Simple
convocation, unarmed conventions net tu-
midiuous, bonds and leagues among subjects,
are acts of seditkm created by statute, and
certainly not included in the (tgied definition
affixed to sedition ;-^«n actual commotion or
insurrection of the people. Butj at common
law, the definition is not the less true, that
certain acts« not comprehended under it,
have been declared by statute tantamount to
sedition, and sanctioned by the penalties at-
taohed to that crime. In treason, ofwlucb
the definition, contrary to what has been for*
merly asserted, is precise and explicity-«'ia
treason, which consists in counteracting, or
betraying, that allegiance due from the subp>
departed from this its primitiva
idea.'' To assert that the legislature cannot
* See4Bl.Conun.133.
8TS]
Jbr SetSUotu
A. D. 1794.
[874
Imit or alter tlie nccttsbn, b a sMolory
traaaon, not cpmpfcehendod under its legal de-
finition. But the legal definition is not there-
fore deatroyed.
My lord, the authority of Erskine and of
Bayiie has heen also quoted, to prove that
real sedition is a eonvocation without autho-
ritT, tending to disturb the tranquillity of the
public. Had the gentleman quoted the {>re-
cedjng sentence from &8kine, that ** sedition
consists in raising oommotions or disturbances
in the state,** your lordship would have per-
ceived from tbs context, ** such commotions
as are fUrectiy against the sovereign or the
state, amount to high treason; but where
raised to redreas some supposed grievance,
are properly seditk>n,'' that the intermediate
pasnge related, not to peaceful and unarmed
conventions, — but to those irregular and tu-
multuous convocations, that are always riot-
ous. Bayne, whose institutions are a brief
and imperfect ^Mtract from M*Kenne's, has
obviously confounded sedition «t common law
with a statutory offmce. Popular commo-
tioflo, to the obstruction of law, or the dis-
turbance of public peace, were punished at
eomBMm law; unarmed conventions (what-
ever was their teadeocir) prohibited by statute.
Happily the laws a^nst peaceful unarmed
conventions are consigned to oblivion ; but to
the definition of real sedition at common law,
Bayne has added, a coovocatioB of citiaens
without authority; and to render it illegal,
specifies its tendency to disturb society. If
tumultuous, the convocation was illegal at
common law ; but the statutory crime of con-
vention, to which the definition of sedition is
thus aibitrarily extended, was illegal, what-
ever was its tendency, whether directed to the
worship of God, or to the obstruction of pub-
lie tranqtulUty and iustice.
8uch then, my lord, is the law. I shall
pow proceed to examine the facts specified
in the indictment, whether, and how mr thc^
amount to the crime of which my client is
accused. The first is his accession to an il-
legal and seditious convention ; for I will not
presume, that a peaceable convention of an
innocent tendency constitutes acriminal charge
to-day. The illegality of such a convention
inust consist in the objects to which it was
directed, its seditious nature in the measures
adopted to attain these objects. I shall
therefore examine, first, the objects proposed
by the conventwn, and then the moae in
which these were pursued.
And here, mv lord, I affirm that annual
parliaments and universal suffnige, the sole
objects proposed by the convention, are le^-
timate and constitutional objects of pursuit
' These are principles recognixed in the theory
of our constitution, nor questionable unless
as expedient in practice^ Annual parliaments
are confessedly a question of mere expediency,
like those of a triennial or septennial duration.
They were appointed, and their legitimacy
resognixed. by difiEeient statoles. ^ 3rd and
«
and 34th of Edward 3rd, and continued till
Richard find, in whose unfortunate reign the
use of long parliaments was first intnMUced.
Your lordsmps cannot be ignorant that mo-
tions for annual parliaments have been an-
nually renewed in the House of Commons;
nor is it necessary for me to assert the con«
stitutional nature of a question, which, in
1745, when agitated in the House of Com*
mons, on the motion of Mr. Carew, was ne«
gatived only by a majority of thirty-two.*
But your lordships hitherto have uniformly
reprobated universal sufirage, as an ill^tl
object, repugnant to the principles of our
happy constitution, productive of anarchv,
the sources of mise^; and, as no poople
have a right to will their own miserj^, it is
inferred, that none are entitled to universal
sufirage. Without controverting thu logical
deduction, I shall argue, not to a politaod^
but to a legal effect, that universal sufirage
is a principle conformable to the spirit, and
reeognixea in the theory of our constitution,
though, firom motives of expediency, not
adopted in practice to its utmost extent
What is the object proposed by universal suf-
finage } That neemen, who possess an inde^
pendent will, not subjugated to the power of
another, shall enjoy, each his suffittge, in the
election of those representatives by whose acts
they are bound, by whom their property is
disposed of, and their conduct regidated.
Who are excluded in this scheme of repre-
sentation f Ideots, minors, paupers, and cri-
minals,— all those who have no will of their
own, or what is equivalent, no honest or in-
dependent will. What then is the theory of
representation in the British constitution f
That those only shall be excluded from voting,
whose situation is such that they cannot be
presumed to have a will of their own. Each
proceeds ou this common principle, that the
persons of freemen are represented, not their
property, and each aspires to this subliiiie
id^ that the system or representation should
be established on a basis as broad as its su-
perstructure. The practice of our constitu-
tion has desenerateo, it is true, from its theo-
retical penection, whether, as some suppose,
from the imperfection natural to the human
race, or, as others imagine, from the decay
and decrepitude of every human institution.
But the principles, my lord, are the same.
Idiots and criminals are excluded in the
scheme of universal sufiirafie, on the principle
that they have no will of weir own; and on
the same presumption, poverty, in the prac-
tice of our constitution, is a cause of exclu-
sion. Qualifications of property are therefore
* See in the New Parliamentary History,
Vol. 13, p- 1050, the debate on Mr. Carew's
motion ** for leave to brine in a bill to enforce
the calling of a new paraament every year,
after the expiration of this present parlia-
ment" On a di^^on, the numbers were,
for the mation, 113{ agatast it, 145.
875]
Si GEORGE III.
Proceedings agtumt Joseph Gerrald
[876
no principle in our constitution, but a test of
that principle which our constitution requires.
Instead of constituting, as has been errone-
ously asserted, the right of suffrage, they are
merely a test of that independent sumage,
which, by the principles of our constitution,
is considered as the inherent birth-right of
every British freeman.
My lord, this is no new doctrine which I
now maintain. It is supported by the most
popular, and let me add, the most orthodox
writers on the English constitution. Mon-
tesquieu, in a passage (which as the French
may implicate sedition, I shall translate to
your loraship) maintains *. '' That in England,
all the citizens in their different districts,
ought to have a right of suffrage in the choice
of their representatives ; tho&e only excepted,
whose situation is so vile, that they must be
reputed to have no will of their own.* To
the same purport Blackstone informs us, '* as
to the qualincations of the electors. The
true reason of requiring any qualification,
with regard to property in voters, is to ex-
clude such persons as are in so mean a situa-
tion that they are esteemed to have no will
of their own. If these persons had votes,
thev would be tempted to dispose of them
under some undue influence or other. This
would cive a ereat, an artful, or a wealtliy
man, a larser share in elections than is con-
sistent with general liberty. If it were pro-
bable that every man would give his vote
freely, and without influence of any kind,
then, upon the true theory and genuine prin-
ciples of liberty, every member of the com-
munity, however poor, should have a vote in
electing those delegates, to whose charge is
committed the disposal of his property, his
liberty, and his life. But since that can
hardly be expected in persons of indigent for-
tunes, or such as are under the immediate
dominion of others, all popular states have
been obliged to establish certain qualifications ;
whereby some, who are suspected to have no
will of their own, are excluded from voting
in order to set other individuals, whose wills
may be supposed independent, more tho-
roughly upon a level with each other.^'
'' This,'' he continues, '' is the spirit of our
constitution : not that I assert it is in fact
quite so perfect as I have endeavoured to de-
scribe it; for, if any alteration might be
wished or suggested m the present frame of
parliaments, it should be in favour of a more
complete representation of the people.'' f
Here, my lord, universal sufirage is repre-
sented by Blackstone as congenial to free-
dom, and the spirit of our constitution; qua-
lifications, as the test of an independent suf-
frage. But why this test I Not that an uni-
versal equality of suffrage is productive of
anarchy, anarchy of misery ; but without such
test, that the opulent would arrogate an undue
* Spirit of Laws, book 11, chap. 6*
t 1. BL CouuD. in, m.
influence moonsistent with liberty. The test
is justified, not as preclusive of a dangerous
equality, but because it restores, to those that
are independent, their equali^ of suffrage.
The question which Blackstone has thus
determined, is decided differently by a
judge in India. Sir William Jones has
asserted the expediency, as well as the
right of universal suftrafe,* nor is that
accomplished and celebrated scholar singular
in a question agitated so variously by the
ablest politicians. While the principle has
ever been acknowledged in theoiy, the expe-
diency of universal suffrage has been deter-
minea, in tlie negative by Mr. Fox, in the
affirmative publicly, in resolutions issued
from such a convention as the present, by his
opponent Mr. Pitt, f
But to what purpose do I quote these pas-
sages, or appeal to the authority of these dis-
tinguished names } To demonstrate to your
lordships, tliat univeral suffrage and annual
parliaments, the professed object of the Bri-
tish convention, are legitimate and constitu-
tional objects of pursuit. It is to convince
your lordships that these obiects are strictly
constitutional, and acknowledged in theory ;
and that their expediency in practice is the
only question. But, my lord, niis is a question
to be debated between man and man,— «
Question fit for discussion in the House of
ommons not for the cognizance of a court
of law. It is a question on which the wisest
and the greatest nave differed ; but let it nut
be told in England, that universal suffrage, a
principle essential in the theory of its consti-
tution, has been arraigned as seditious, and
proscribed as unconstitutional, in a Scottish
court.
Such then, my lord, were the professed
principles, and such the ostensible objects of
the British convention. It remains to exa-
mine the mode proposed, or the measures
adopted, to accomplish these legal constitu-
tional objects. But in the speeches and reso-
lutions charged as seditious in this indictment,
what is there to indicate that the secret mo-
tives of the convention were different, that its
designs were criminal, or as the public pro-
secutors has hardily asserted, that a plan was
deliberately formed to subvert the constitu-
tion ? I shall examine, my lord, as concisely
as possible, the resolutions and speeches con-
tained in the indictment.
The first is a speech extracted from the
Gazetteer, and ascribed to Mr. Gerrald, in
the British convention. My lord, I affirm
that this speech is legal and constitutional
throughout, and pcrfecSy conformable to the
professed object of that association. It be-
gins by stating, that after the union of the
crowns, on the accession of James to the
throne of England, '* the people of both
* See the case of the dean of St. As^P^y
Vol. SI, p. 847, of this Collection,
t 6ut seiB the note, arU^^ p. 833*
8771
for Sediiion.
A. D. 17d4..
[878
countries were deprived of some of their roost
Yaluable privileges." And who will deny,
that during the sanguinary reign of the
Stuarts, the most dangerous encroachments
were made on our liberties f Who will main-
tain that the privileges of the people were
not then invaded ; — privileges^ wnich in some
instances, the revolution has not entirely re-
stored ? But the speech proceeds to estaolish
universal suffrage, not only as our birth-right
by nature, but as a right actually enjoyed
under the Saxon government, and exercised
till the Norman conquest or robbery (a rob-
ber)[, my lord, it undoubtedly was), abridged
the inheritance of our Saxon ancestors. To
restore this natural right, to recover this in-
herent principle, as it is termed, of our con-
stitution, it proposes the most peaceable and
legal means, that the people should be in-
structed in its importance, and persuaded to
solicit its restitution by petitions to parlia-
ment. My lord, this is not the language of
sedition, but an assertion of our unalienable
right to petition either branch of the legisla-
ture. But there are passages supposed to in-
dicate a different intention. Xhe petitions
were to be subscribed by a majority of the
people, ** by a number so respectable as to
command attention; and it will soon have
that respectabilit)r, if we have reason on our
side.** On this invidious construction, my
brother and my friend has sufficiently com-
mented. Were command (than which I
know not a happier phrase) expressive of a
compulsive force to overawe the legislature,
its correlative would be obey; but Tiere the
attention which truth and numbers may be
figuratively said to command or enforce, and
which certainly they strongly solicit, is yielded
bv parliament, whose attention is said to
The next article of the indictment discloses
the grand arcana of sedition, — ^the resolution
ascribed to the convention of resisting the
authority of the legislature; concerning which
I ^hall first examine its import, and men its
criminal amount and complexion. I must
premise, however, that in a case like the pre-
sent, wherever a declaration is equally sus-
ceptible of two constructions, that which is
innocent is to be received as its genuine in-
terpretation and sense. Your lordships may
remember the trial of lord Strafford.* An ac-
cusation against him was, that he said in the
public ball-room at York, " that the little
finger of prerogative should lie heavier upon
them than the loins of the law." By invert-
ing the expression thus, that ^* the little finger
•I the law was heavier than the loins of
prerogative," he fairly explained it away.
The Commons persisted in this accusation;
but their illiberal construction of a sentence
susceptible of a different meaning, has been
repTopated by every historian as oppressive
and illegal. If words^ therefore, can admit
1 ■ - - - I _ '
• Sec Vol. S, p. 1381 of this Collection.
of two constructions, that which is most fa-
vourable to innocence must always be
adopted.
My lord, to proceed to the resolution, the
first part of it states, in general, that " if any
unconstitutional act be proposed in parliar
ment, inconsistent with, or subversive of our
known constitutional liberties, we declare,
before God and the world, that we shall
follow the wholesome example of former
times, by paying no regard to any act which
shall militate against the constitution of the
country : and shall continue to assemble, and
consider of the best means by which we can
accomplish a real representation of the peo-
ple, and aimual election, until compelled to
desist by superior force." What is the im-
port, then, of following ** the wholesome
example of former times ?" They meant, it
is saia, to fiy in the face of all constituted au-
thority, and to resist the government. But
is this the wholesome example of former
times? No, this is not the case; fortheex*
pression is immediately explained by the con-
text, " by paying no regard to any act which*'
—shall do what?— « Which shall militate
against the constitution of this country ;''
and how disregard it? Not by active and for-
cible resistance; but with all the resigna-
tion of a quaker ; bv that passive resistance
which a quaker woiud show, were he to enter
the court, and remain with his head covered,
till your lordships' macer should take off
his hat. He submits passively to the laws of
his country, when exerted; to which, at the
same time, he pays no previous regard. But
the resolution amounts to this, that the mem-
bers associated, or delegated, to obtain uni-
versal suffrage and annual parliaments, on
the first notice of a bill to suppress their coiv-
vention, and to frustrate these their constitu-
tional objects, shall assemble immediately,
nor depart till the law, in the event of its
bein^ enacted, shall receive its full operation
on them. They assemble on the first notice
of the bill, for this obvious reason, that no
meeting could take place when it passed into
a law. They assemble to deprecate, and, by
every legal endeavour, to prevent its passing.
But they will continue to assemble till com-
pelled to desist by superior force. To discover
the criminal nature of this passive resistance,
of this resolution to obey upon compulsion
only, let us suppose, for a moment, that an
act obviously unconstitutional were adopted
by legislature; that monarchy, no matter how
improbable, were abrogated for ever, what
would be the conduct ot eveiv peaceable citi-
zen interested in its support? I would appeal
to your lordships, sworn as you are to abide by
monarchy, that you would resist, passively at
least, though not perhaps forciblv, that act
which you thought unconstitutional, and con-
tinue to meet m court, by legal authority,
*^ till compelled to desist by superior force.'^
Such woiUd undoubtedly be your lordships'
conduct, andsuch is the precise conduct whach
879] 54 GEORGE III. Proceedings agaisui Joseph Gerrald
[880
the convention observed. Their ideas of re^
sUtance, their resolution not to desist till
compelled by superior force, are explained,
and the extent of both ascertained, by the
compulsion in consequence of which they de-
sisted, and the force by which they were ac-
tuallj dispersed. Their resolution was not
to retist ; it was not to desist till compelled by
force: and when my friend Mr. Davidson^
the sherifl^ laid hold of the president's arm,
to remove him from the chair, " No, Sir,"
says the president, ^ this is not force enough;
a little more if you please;^' accordingly the
sheriii^ by a very gentle exertion, removed
him from the chair. The whole was a scenic
exhibition; and truly, my lord, where the
force wa^soludicrousy^a resolution not to de-
sist till such force was exerted, can never be
criminaL
My lord, the resolution proceeds — *' and in
case of an invasion to reassemble in conven-
tion." The construction imposed upon this,
is, that the convention meant to join, or
as«st the invaders. My explanation is very
different, that it was the intention c€ the
members, by every effort in their power, to
resist an invasion. The resplution concludes
thus, " that all, or any one of these calami-
tous circumstances,'' (and an invasion is one
of the preceding circumstances), '' shall be a
signal for the members to meet in conven-
tion." But whv calamitous, if they did not
consider it reaflv as such? If they did not
mean to avert tnat calamity, why represent
it to the peo{4e or to themselves, as a most
calamitous circumstance? Can any thins
more explicitly point out their intention!
Or when the whole resolution is considered,
can your lordships impose any other construe*
tionthan this upon it, that the intention of
the members wsw, by every possible exertion,
to avert that which they justly represented as
a national calamitv ?
Now, my lord, having determined the
sense and import, let us examine the crimi-
nal amount of a resolution considered as so
alarming and dangerous^ that the constitu-
tion, in the opinion of some wise men, totters
already to its very foundation. A refusal to
yield an implicit uncempeUed obedience,
to an act whose existence is onl^ potential, on
the supposition too of its proving an uncon-
stitutional act, is charged to-day as a direct
attack on the authority of the legislature, con-
stituting a species of real and atrocious sedi-
tion. To impi^n the authority of the three
estates, or to attempt a diminution of their
power or dignity, waS| by i584| chap. ISO,
declared to be treason; and the prosecutor
maintains an argument sustained by your
lordships on a former trial, that although the
act ie superseded by the Introduction of the
English statutes respecting treason, the of-
fence that ceases to be treasonable, must, still
subsist as sedition at common law. My lord,
let me explain, the origin of this act, whose
very abrogation, it soens, is productive of a
new species of sedition. It was obtained by
James 6th to preserve the ecclesiastical es-
tate, or rather the episcopal power, in parlia-
ment, then in danger ot being subverted by
the efforts of our presbjfterian ancestors. The
dignity of the estates might be variously im-
pugned, by violence, by publications and
speeches, or by resolutions in parliament. A
variety of inferior offences, or of actions in
themselves indifferent, were therefore con-
verted by this act into treason. But these
offences, when the act was abolished, were
again restored to their primitive state. Popu-
lar commotions directed against an estate of
parliament, would return as^formerly to real
sedition; speeches, or publications, deroga-
tory to either of the tpree estates, to their
original situatioa as verbal sedition. By the
act immediately preceding this statute, to
decline the autbonty of the council was trea-
son ; but how absurd US maintain, that be^
cause the act is abolished, the offence, origi-
nally a contempt of court, subsists at com-
mon law as a species of real, and atrocious
sedition ! I conclude, therefore, that the va*
rious offences comprehended in this act, must
revert to their original situation at comraon
law, like him whose patent of nobility is for^
felted, and whose descendants return to the
common herd of mankind.
But, my lord, I do not like this act, nor
its introduction in this trial. And! will tell
you why. The earl of Argyle was arraigned
on this statute, and convicted of treason be-
cause he bestowed an explanation of his ow&
on a religious test, prescribed by parliament,
whose authority he thus invaded, and whose
power he impugned.* But his conviction dis-
honoured the justice of the nation; and the
act itself, instead of being superseded by the
English law, was abrogated previously by our
claim of rights, or rather declared. to have
been an obsolete and dead statute at the very
time he waa tried. The claim of rights do>
ckres, that James 7th had forfeited his light
to the crown, among other things, ** by caus-
ing pursue, and fbrlault several persons upois
stretches of old and obsolete laws, upon fri-
volous and weak ppetences, upon, lame and
defective probation, as particularly the laie
earl of Aygyle, to the scandal and reproach
of the justice of the nation**' Thus tne ewi
of Argyle, to the reproach of justice, was
condemned on the stretch of an obsolete law.
But in this enlightened period, the gentleman
at the bar, more unfortunate even than the
earl of Argyle, is to be convicted of a crima
that has survived this oki and obsolete act;—
an unknown seditbn that springs like a phoAi.
nix firom the embers of treason. Argyle was
convicted.because he impugned an existinglaw,
but my client is arraigned, because he in^
pugais an act whose existence as yet is ei^
tirely potential. But, my lord, the offenets
* See his case in this Collection^ Vol 1^
881]
Jbr Sedition.
A. D. 1794.
[883
mccumulated on the British conymtion, must
return to that situation which they held he-
fore this ohsolete statute was enacted ; com-
motions to real, publications and speeches to
verbal sedition.
Not to exhaust your lordships patience, I
shall observe of the speech that succeeds this
resolution, and of the convention of emer-
gency, that the first, by enumerating the re-
straints imposed by a convention bill on
the right of petitioning, coincides exactly
with the interpretation bestowed on the pre-
cedinjg resolution ; — that the convention, by
constitutional means, would endeavour to pre-
vent the introduction of a law to intercept
their petitions, and to frustrate the ultimate
attainment of their objects. As to the other,
it was natural for ^^ : convention, in the event
of their dispersion in one countiy (which, as
their objects were constitutional, they must
•have considered as illegal), to provide secretly
and beforehand, for re-assembling in another,
beyond the jurisdiction of the sheriff bv whom
they were dispersed. School boys, when dis-
persed iu one parish, will repair privatelv to
the adjoining, where they may renew their
bickerings without molestation.
But what is the amount of this, and of
every other article contained in the indict-
ment? Their French epithets, used perhaps
foolishly, their resolutions, and their speeches
indicate, it is stud, a design to subvert the
constitution or government. The solicitor ge-
neral undertakes to prove that a plan was
formed to subvert the constitution. Let me
tell him, that his evidence will not, and can-
not exceed the indictment, that '' the whole
form and mantier of their procedure, as well
as the principles they avowed and propagated,
clearly, and 'unequivocallv demonstrate, that
their purposes were of the most dangerous
and destructive tendency, hostile to the peace
and happiness, and tending to subvert the
constitution of this realm.*' Their principles,
and the tenor of their procedure is the only
evidence from which a plan to subvert the
constitution is inferred. But if such a conspi-
racy were formed, if such a design were en-
tertained, it amounts to treason, and should
be tried as such. But a charge of treason, let
xne tell your lordship, cannot, and dare not
be maintained ; not that a concerted design
to subvert the constitution, is not an overt
act tantamount to treason, but because there
is no kgal proof, nor any evidence whatever,
to establish that design. The testimony of
two concurrent witnesses, whether in treason
or misprision of treason, is essential to con-
viction ; but here, I repeat it again, there is
ao witness, and under the present indictment
none can be adduced, to prove a conspiracy
to subvert the state. Sedition therefore is
charged to^ay, and the crime is to be estab-
lished, not b^ legal evidence, not by the tes-
timony reauisite in treason, but by inferences
from resolutions, by innuendos capriciously
Attached to speeches, either innocent in them-
voL xxin.
selves, or, if criminal, constituting a very
different offence. A design to subvert the
constitution, if susceptible of proof, would
amount to treason. Speeches and resolutions
are punishable only as verbal sedition. But
an intermediate crime, a constructive species
of sedition is ^created; and from speeches
amounting only in themselves to leasing ma-
king, a new crime, incapable of proo^ and
unluiown in law, is extorted by inference.
The tendency, which alone is criminal in
these speeches, is not submitted to the con-
sideration of the jury ; but the supposdi mo-
tives from which they originated, are to be
converted by an arbitrary and capricious in-
ference, an inference necessarily influenced
by fear, prejudice, and passion, into con-
structive sedition. My lord, I affirm that
this is subversive of all judicial procedure.
Constructive treasons are now no more ; but
a crime against the state may still, it seems,
be established by construction, and tiiat
which constitutes m itself an inferior offence,
be rendered the evidence of this constructive
crime. In the unjust, and ever memor-
able trial of Algernon Sidney, innuendos
from his writings composed the chief evidence,
but sir John Hawlesjustiy remarks, that
" as this indictment was an original in the
particular before-mentioned, so it was a se-
cond of an innuendo indictment of treason;
Fitzharris was the first. The prosecution
against Car, as I remember, was an infor-
mation, and judgment arrested aAer a ver-
dict, because it was by innuendo, of which
no precedent could be produced; and although
in actions for words it was permitted, yet in
criminal matters, being penal, it was resolved
it ought not to be permitted, and certainly
much less in treason.*'* In criminal matters,
no innuendo is therefore admissible, much
less in treason. Mjr lord, our own practice
corresponds with this. Oliphant and others
accuscKi of drinking the pretender's health in'
public, *^ with an intention of abetting his
claim to the crown," were tried and convicted
of verbal sedition.f The tendency of their
speeches to excite disturbance constituted
tneir sole offence ; but the treasonable inten-
tion inferred from their speeches, of abetting
the pretender's claim to the crown, was hot
then charged as a constructive species of real
sedition.
My lord, an authority occurs on this sub-
ject, not usual in a court of justice, yet so ap-
posite, that I shall quote it without hesita-
tion. It is the Monthly lieview for Febru-
aiy, wherein a pamphlet is reviewed, the
composition of a Mr. Play fair, a man whom I
know not, but who exhorts the nation to
wage an eternal war. Mr. Playfair asserts
that ** it is only a matter of regret, that those
* See Sir John Hawles's Remarks on the
Trial of Algernon Sidney, anii Vol. IX.
page 1009.
t AhU Vol. 17, p. 763.
3 L
889]
S4 GEORGE lU.
Procee^ngi agaimt Jo$eph Gerrald
[SM
who undemune our government cannot be
treated i lafran^Qi$e^ since it is the French
system that they have taken for their model/'
What 81^ the reviewers to tliis humane pro-
posal ? Their honest indignation breaks forth
m a stream of argument and eloquence : <' A
powerful stream of the milk of human kind-
ness flows through this sentiment of regret
tiiat the guillotine cannot be set to work in
this country, on those who do— what? Betray
their country? No; for they are already lia-
ble to the penalties of treaaoo, and to a death
infinitely more painful than that which is
produced by the guillotine. Who adhere to
the king's enemies? No; for they are in the
same predicament. Who by overt acts at-
tempt to overturn our government F No; for
that also is treason. ^ whose heads then are
those which the national raior should shave
in Engltmdy if the pious wish of Mr. Playfair
could have effect? Tlie heads of those who
undermine our government; an eipression
not known in our law, and of course not to
be found in the index of the criminal code."
iiad these reviewers directed their eyes to
Scotland, they would have seen, that, to un-
dermine the government, though, under that
denomination, unknown in law, nor to be
found in the index of our criminal code, is
created hy implication a crime against the
state. They wouki see that the most iniqui-
tous attainders of former times, might have
been converted into a capital, thouch inferior
trimt. Sidney and Stranbrd were lK)th con-
Tictcd, though at different periodsi of con-
ftructive treason. But Sidney, thoueh un-
jbstly attainted, might have been condemned
for sedition, on those innuendos derived from
bis writings, which in treason were not ad-
gnissible as legal evidence. Strafford too, if
bis sentence was iniquitous, might have been
legally convicted of constructive seditran;
aul if this crime has a legal existence, ^ese
men might have perished unlamented on the
icafibld. Strafford was. accused, and on con-
structive evidence, of an endeavour to sub-
vert the fundamental laws ; a crime on which
the statute of treasons was totally silent.
Arbitrarily to introduce it into the fatal ca-
talogue was, in itself, according to historians,
« subversion of all law. But wherein does
this differ from the charge against my client
of a design to subvert the constitution and
eovemment? Where has this law lain so
long concealed, that it now bursts forth to
the destruction of this innocent man ? Where
is the precedent for this unknown law, or
tiie landmark by which he could discover its
existence? Is it sufficient for his protection,
or for our security, that this new crime of
tubvertinz government is prosecuted, not as
treason, but sedition? Or is this new law
less a snare to the unwary, because the ca^
pital punishment attached to sedition, may
oe restricted by the humanity of Court, to
whatever arbitrary punishment the Court
may unpose? ]Au3t he suffsr for a crime
that had no exietence before, by a law created
for the occasion, that may burst at last on
our own heails, and involve us in its rains?
My lord, let th« speeches, if criminal, be pu*
nished as such; but let not a oonstracttve
species of guilt be deduced by inference from
these speeches, nor a crime established that
is unknown in law.
S. These speeches, if criminal, are compre-
bended, as my brother has already demon*
strated, under the acts 1584 chap. 134, and
1585, chap. 10, on which I maintain, as my
second proposition, that where the offence Is
provided for by statute, a severer or adif*
ferent punishment cannot be inflicted at
common law. To establish this proposition
will not require any long deduction. Nor
would 1 condescend to an argument on a
proposition almost intuitive, Imt for an opi-
nion delivered on a former trial, that vrbere
the indictment is founded, and sedition charge*
ed,' on the common law, the Court are pro*
eluded from resorting to statutes. My lord,
the common law is a collection of usages, the
origin of which is uncertain, but of which
the existence is preserved by tradition. The
statute, is a superaddition to the common
law; <K5claratory either of its meaning, or
remedial of its imperfections. If declaratory,
it ascertains precisely what the common law
is; nor can' your lordship, in your interpre*
tations of die common law, travel beyond tHe
limits prescribed by statute. Again, if re-
medial, it either enlarges and supplies the
deficiencies, or corrects the luxuriance, by
retrenching the superfluous excess of the
common law. Remedial statutes are there-
fore again divided into the law of England,
into statutes enlarging and restraining the
common law. As an enlarging statute in'*
flicts a greater penalty than was otherwise
competent, the crime, as in stealing firom
bleachfields, and other statutory thefts, may,
from motives of humanity, be chained at
common law, to the effect of inflictmg the
inferior punishment. Thus, in Eneland, aS
a misprision is contained in every felonv, it
is held that the indictment may proceed on
the lesser oflence. But a restraining statute
limits the penalty formerly competent; nor
can a severer punishment be inflicted at com-
mon law, than that to which tiie restraining
act has already reduced it. A different pu«
nishment cannot even be inflicted; for the
judge, whose hands are thus tied up, has no
power to deviate from the statute. Other-
wise the consequences would be most dange«-
rous; the effect of the statute would be en-
tirely frustrated; the law would depend on
the passions, the caprice, or the interest of
the man who prosecutes, the punishment on
the discretion,^ of the judge wno pronounces
the sentence.
* As to whkh see the opinions of Gibbon,
lord Camden, and Burke, an^l^ Vol. 6, p. M,
fiole. ■
86&I
Jut Sediiion.
S. But the puntshment, as regulated by
170i, chap. 4, is fining, imprisonment, or
banishment, meaning toereby banishment
forth of the realm alone. This is the third
moposition, which I proposed to illustrate.
The argument muntamed for the crown is
this, that banishment by the mode of trans-
portation is prohibited neither by the spirit
nor the letter of the act ; that the spirit^ as
expressed in the preamble^ meant only to
abcogate confiscation and capital punish-
nientSy the letter to specify the most usual
aibitrary punishments as then understood;
and it is asked with an air of triumph, who
will sav, that by banishment the Court was
limited to the inferior of two modes of punish-
ment comprehended under that generic
term?
My lord, the statute itself shall refute this
argument. The preamble recites, that from
their generality, and the various constructions
of which they are susceptible, the laws against
leasing-making (which are previously enume-
rated) as inferring death and confiscation,
may be of dangerous consequences, and the
enacting clause proceeds according1)r to abro-
Sftte the punishments of confiscation and
eath. So far the supposed spirit, and the
letter are consistent. But the enacting clause
goes farther, not merely to specify the arbi-
trary punishments usually employed, but as
a restraining statute, to limit these to an al-
ternative penalty, to banishment, or impri-
sonment, or a fine, or on the inability of the
party to discharge a fine, to a corporal pu-
nbhment miti^ted, and expressly limitea to
the preservation of life and limb. Your
lordships will therefore observe, that the sta-
tute extends fiirther tlian the supposed spirit
ascribed to the preamble. A ime mav be
inflicted^ banishment may be [inflictedf, or
imprisonment inflicted; but these penal-
ties cannot be accumulated, nor corporal pu-
nishment superadded to banishment, or indeed
inflicted, uiuess on the alternative of the
party beine poor and unable to pay a fine.
The spirit Uierefore, ascribed to the preamble
is contradicted by the letter of this restrain-
ing statute, restrictive even as to that alter-
native punishment with which it entrusts
your lordships. The question therefore is,
what is the meaning of the term banishment
in the act of queen Anne?
And on this question, the argument from
the act 1609, so fully illustrated by my
brother, is to roe decisive. I bold, that the
banishment prescribed by that statute is from
Scotland alone; as transportation, a punish-
ment unknown when it passed, was not then
In the contemplation of the legislature This
statute is the last enumerated in the act of
q;iieen Anne, wherein the epithet banishment
occurs but once. Were transportation there-
fore, as implied in that generic epithet, to
be inflicted under the other acts against leas-
ing-making then this absurdity would take
place, that baniflhnien^ thou^ em^oyed
A. D. l*m. [866
but once, has a double signification In tlie
act of queen Anne. If applied to 1609, it
imports no more than exclusion firom Scotp
land ; but when applied to the other statutes
which the same act enumerates, it implies
not only a seclusion from Scotland, but ba*
nishinent beyond seas, transportation to the
plantations^ loss of hberty, and personal ser-
vitude. Corporal punishments are limited to
the alternative of the party being unable to
pay a fine : yet tills greatest and most igno*
minlous of corporal punishments is entrusted
to your lordships as a mode of banishment.
But, my lord, were banishment, as employed
in the act of queen Anne, an> expression
either disputable or doubt^ its precise inv»
port is thus ascertained. When tne act 1600
was in the special contemplation^ and under-
went the revision of parliament, that signifi*
cation which was iooplied, or that punish-
ment which was prescribed,, in banbhment,
must in dubio be presumed to have been
affixed to the same word, when employed
by parliament in the act of queen Anne. If
banishment, by the act of 1609, be simple
exUe, or exclusion from the realm^ there is
no reason to suppose that it acquired the ad-
ditional sense ot transportation beyond seas^
when that statute was revised by the act of
queen Anne.
To this argument, my lord, I have heard
no answer, and I hold it decisive. But the
act against wrongous imprisonment, and ano-
ther of Charles 2d, inflicting banishment t»
the plantations on those who refused to de-
pone against dehnquents, have been prepos-
terously quoted. The first, by banishing to
the plantations, demonstrates the solicitude
of parliament to distinguish transportatiosi
a punishment recently introduced, from simt
1>Ie banishment as understood at common
aw ; in the other, an act against wrongous
transportation, as well as wrongous imprisoni-
ment, the expression banishment is not onee
introduced.
But, my lord, if transportation, which I
hold to be a punishment superadded to ba-
nishment, be a mode of banishment com-
prehended under that generic term; if undet
a statute, sanctioned merelv by banishment,
your lordships are entitlen to inflict trans-
portation; then, under a sentence of youo
lordships inflicting banishment, those to
whom the execution of the laws is entrusted,
would be entitled, equally with your lord-
ships, to transport to the plantations the
man whom your sentence has merely ba»
nisbed. My lord, the consequence follows
ineyitably from the argument, and my client^
banished to-day by your lordships, may be
transported to-morrow by the executive power.
But a ease from the records of the privy
council has been quoted as decisive. Baillie, a
few (months afier the act of queen Anne, was
convicted of leasing making, and condenined
by the privy council, to be banished and trans*
ported^ placed in the pillory, and a4judged
887] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings against Joseph GerraUt
[888
infamous.* I mean not to impuen the
aulhori^ of a court of law, when i assert
that this sentence was most unjust and il-
legal. The privy council was necessarily ar-
bitrary, unitinv the executive power to its
judicial authority. The trials in that court
were without jury, and the sentence was
pronounced when Uie party was withdrawn.
But a more illegal sentence than the one
proposed to your lordships as a precedent,
cannot be conceived. In every article it
violates the act of queen Anne. Banish-
ment, or imprisonment, could only be inflicts
ed alternativelv, and cor|K>ral punishment,
in the particular alternative of the party
being poor and unable to pay a; fine ! But a
gentleman certainly not too poor to dis-
charge his fine, is declared infamous, a pu-
nishment which the statute has not autho-
rized, and condemned to the pillory, a corpo-
ral punishment replete wiUi infamy. Trans-
portation, infamy, and the pillory are all ac-
cumulated on his unhappy head; and as if
to refute the plea that transportation was
an alternative mode of banishment, he is
first banished from the kingdom, and then
ordained to be transported to the plantations.
But instead of the illegal sentence of a court
abolished as oppressive and tyrannical, if
your lordships regard the just and lenient
decisions of your predecessors, what is the
conclusion? That the spirit of the statute,
as interpreted twelve years after its enacts
ment, is niild and equitable, when offences
not less heinous than those in the indictment,
committed too on the eve of rebellion, were
80 mercifully punished.
My lord, a reference has also been made
to decisions recited on a former trial, to the
effect of proving that in these cases, trans-
portation was the mode in which banishment,
the generic punishment, received execution.
I observed that the sentences, as in the case
of Rankin, were precisely to this effect :—
-^" The court adjudge the panel to be ba-
nished forth of the realm, and ordain him to
return to prison, and to be confined therein
till occasion be had for his transportation to
the plantations." We are told that the last
part of this sentence is an explanation, decla-
ratory of the first; and confinement till an
opportunity offer for transportation, as well
as transportation itself, is interpreted as the
mode in which banishment forth of the
realm must receive execution. Now, my
lord, it appears to me that this inference is
not logical; for banishment forth of one
country, never can imply transportation to
another. My explanation is this ; transporta-
tion to the plantations, as inflicted in the
latter part of^ the sentence, is supplemental,
not declaratory ; an additional parti of the
sentence of banishment forth of the realm ;
not explanatory of its meaning, or of the
- —
^ See his case in this Collection, Vol. 14,
p. ludd.
mode in which it was to be carried into exe-
cution. The crimes thus punished by trans-
portation are immaterial; they were either
capital, and mitigated to less than death, or
offences of which the punishment is arbitra-
ry and without control ; for thus, without the
intervention of statute, transportation was
first introduced into our law.
With your lordship's permission, there are
yet two cinnimstances to which I shall ad-
vert ; — ^the motive or the expediency of the
pimishment which I deprecate, and its dis-
proportion to the offence. The motive hi-
therto uniformly assigned for transportation
is, that there is no security, nor advantage to
be obtained, by banishing across the Tweed,
those who will still disseminate their sedition
in England. My lord, has England no laws
for her own preservation, that she must be
indebted for protection to the severe vigilance
of a sister kingdom ! Is it requisite that the
laws of Scotland should interpose to prevent
the future repetition of crimes in England ?
Sedition in Scotland is sufficiently repressed
by expulsion from Scotland ; but must Eng-
land be secured by your sentence, even from
the apprehensions of similar sedition ? To
prevent the future commission of crimes in
England, you impose a punishment which,
if tne crimes were actually committed, the
laws of that country would not authorize, and
could not infiiet. It is the spirit of true pu-
nishment to prevent the future, by exhibiting
a corrective example of the past ; not by in-
flicting the penalty previous to the appre-
hended crime. With us the offence as bail-
able does not amount to felony ; in England
it could not be ptmished with banishment.
Why then inflict a punishment appropriated
to felony, as preventive of a crime appre-
hended in England, — a punishment which
could not be inflicted in England, were the
crime committed ?
My lord, on this immense disproportion
between the punishment and the offence, let
me suggest a distinction which I am too
much exhausted to illustrate. — Clarendon*
was banished, Barrington transported. Cla-
rendon, when exiled by a vicious Court and a
venal monarch, lived abroad, to himself and
to his country, to illustrate the annals of
British story. Bolingbroke,f though expelled
for treason, lived to return, and, in a corrupt
age, to revive the flame of patriotism in every
English breast. Atterbury,} though in exile,
and under discountenance, closed the ho-
noured remainder of his life in dignity and
peace. But a man whose offence is inferior,
whose abilities are equal, and his integrity,
I am bold to say, superior to Bolingbroke's.
whose genius may distinguish his name, and
* See his case in this Collection, Vol. 6, p.
391.
t See his case, antlj Vol. 15, p. 998.
t See the proceedings against him, ant^.
Vol 16, J. 323.
y
889]
J'of Sedition*
A. D. 1794.
[890
enrich the literature of his ceuntry, depends
vn vour sentence, whether his future life shall
be lost to society, himself doomed to a recep-
tacle of vice and misery, and transported to
a shore irom which apparently there is no
return. From the state of his health, I must
add, that a ' sentence of transportation is to
him, in all human probability^ a sentence of
death.
Lord Ifenrfer/anA— My lord, the subject of
our present connderation is not as to the guilt
or the innocence of the panel at the bar, but
as to the relevancy of the libel; and, my
lord, I shall be very short in what I have to
say. It is certainly necessary to examine
every criminal libel that comes before us, for
crimes may be charged in a different way ; a
charge may be relevantly laid in one indict-
ment and not in another ; and, my lord, in a
crime of this kind, which relates to a society
or convention, the views of which society
may change very much, and the views of Uie
members may be very different, men mided
by folly, or misguideo by faction, may have
tone into meetings, into conventions of this
ind, not aware of the views which they
roi^ht have ; not aware of the consequences
which they might draw from it, may, at last,
come . to feel nie hollow ground upon which
they stood, the dangerous footing that they
were upon, and the consequence of them,
^ilt might be very various indeed ; there-
fore it becomes me to examine this libel
closely.
My lord, the question is, is it relevant or
not? that is, do the facts charged in the
minor proposition come up to the crime
charged in the major proposition ? that is all
m^ province, I have nothing more to do
with it.
My lord, this libel charges the crime of
sedition, and the general import of the minor
proposition is, that this person has been
guilty in so far as he has been an active
member in a seditious society ; — a society, or
convention, that is charged in the libel to be
seditious. With respect to the logical con-
clusion, there cannot be a doubt; for, I
think, this proposition may be fairly assumed,
that whoever is an active member of a sedi-
tious society is guilty of sedition : by active,
I mean concurring in those measures which
Tender and characterize that society to be a
seditious one ; but I should not be satisfied
with an indictment laid in that way.
My lord, if an indictment was to charge
murder in the major proposition, and in the
minor proposition it was said to be, inso-
much as he murdered such a man upon such
a day, no doubt the conclusion would be lo-
gical ; but I do not think it would be a fair
one ; because it is the duty of the public
prosecutor to specify the particular circum-
stances^ If it said he was guilty of murder,
in so far as he murdered such a man, upon
«iich a day, by running him through the body
■with a sword, of which he died in a few days
after, that is a proper and relevant libel.
Suppose it were to say, in so far as he thrust
sucn a person through the body with a sword
upon such a day, of which wound he died,
that would be a relevant libel ; because, al-
though the term murder, or the felonious
intent is not repeated, it is and must be the
construction of law and common sense, un-
less he be able to set up a defence against it,
and establish that it was done by accident,
which, to be sure, would be a relevant defence.
Now, my lord, the capital object in every
indictment is, to consider the facts specified
in the minor proposition, and how far they
come up to the general charge in the major
proposition. We have heara a great deal
about sedition, real and verbal; custinctions
which are tasen by systematic writers for
perspicuity and clearness ; but the true way
to judge of sedition is to take it from the
object before you ; that is the fair way; for
I can conceive verbal sedition as criminal,
as dangerous, as any that can be committed
by actions. Suppose a man to run into the
streets, and csiu out " To arms ! to arms !
kingly power is useless ; it is cumbersome,
it ought to be laid aside. Parliament is venal
and corrupt Let us name a body of our
own to assume the power which they have
improperly taken. Rouse and assert your
rights." Why, my lord, it may be said this
is out words; but suppose he gets people to
follow him, then, to be sure, if they proceed
to overt acts, it would be rebellion, it would
be treason ; but suppose nobody follows him,
is there no criminality ? Is there no danger
to society? Is there no injury to govern-
ment if such proceedings are tolerated? Can
any man doubt that this would be a sedition
totall;^ different from any thing that I can con-
ceive with respect to.leasin^-making ?
My lord, I hold it perfectly clear, taking
that systematic distinction that authors as-
sume for their conscience, that there is a se-
dition by words totally different and distinct
in common sense and reason from leasing-
making. My lord, in the same way the im«
pugning the authority of parliament, or of
any of the states, that is a crime that cannot
be suffered; as long as parliaments exist,
they mubt be defend^ against it by the com-
mon principles of that government which
they have assumed: it requires no statute;
it requires no usage; it follows from the
nature of the thing, that the impugning of
that authority is a crime, and is the crime of
sedition : and I care not whether it be merely
in words, or whether it be followed by
actions.
My lord, I lay out of the question the act
1.584, which declared it to be punished as
treason; but 'I say it is part of the common
law, and, as was well expressed by the young
gentleman who spoke on the part of the
crown, must be part of the connnon law of
every state, of every society, of every go-
vernment that can exist in the world«
I
895]
34 OEOSQE m.
Proceeding* againsi Joseph Gerrald
[896
and French tenns in this manBer, might at
one time af>pear merdy as signs of foUy, and
at another it might appear to admit of another
construction : hut if you attend to it, you will
observe it is imitating a body of men with
whom we are at war, and who have rendered
themselves objects of horror throughout all
Europe. I would be glad to know what could
he the meaning of having primary assemblies,
departments, and so on, unless they meant
to form a sort of legislative body among them-
selves ; and to what end their deliberations
were to be applied, we are to judge upon the
subsequent facts in this indictment, and upon
them alone; namelv, the resolution which
they took, and the plan which they were pur-
suing,— they were endeavouring to obtain
universal suffrage and annual parliaments.
My lord, as to universal suffi^ge, so far as I
know, I never heard that it had obtained in
the British constitutiou,' or that it can obtain
without overthrowing the constitution; and
therefore, thoush it may be lawful to obtain
a change, yet if it is a change of that sort, it
^oes to show that it was not their intention to
improve the constitution, but to subvert and
overthrow it; for it is that which I never
heard obtained in the constitution, at the
happy era of the revolution. My lord, they
thought it necessary that they should have a
convention ;— a pretty thing m this country —
a convention; not a convention of men com-
ing together merely, but they were the repre-
sentatives elected by others; and, my lord,
this is thought so important a matter, thai
they are afraid of any tning happening to pre-
vent their meetings, and therefore here fol-
lows, in this libel, a resolution, that if an act
should pass to prevent meetings of conven-
tions, tney were determined to resist it.
My lord, the libel sets forth this resolution :
'^ That this convention, considering the ca-
lamitous consequences of any act of tlie legis-
lature which may tend to deprive the whole,
or any part of the people, of their undoubted
right to meet, either by themselves or by de-
legation, to discuss any matter relative to their
common interest, whether of a public or pri-
vate nature, and holding the same to be to-
tally inconsistent with the £rst principles and
safety of society, and also subversive of our
known and acknowledged constitutional li-
berties, do hereby declare, before God and
the world, that we shall follow the wholesome
example of former time*^,by paying no regard
to any act which shall militate against the
constitution of our country; and shall con-
tinue to assemble, and consider of the best
means, by which we can accomplish a real
representation of the people, and annual elec-
tion, until compelleu to desist by superior
force."
Now, my lord, this determination, if words
are plain, is a resolution not to disobey a law
already made, but to disobey a law which
they expected to pass when it should pass ;
and when tliere is any notice given of it, then
there is to be a secret oonventioB assembled ;
that secret convention to declare their sittings
permanent, after the manner of the French
convention, and thev are to continue to sit
till they are compelled to desist by superior
force. And, in the twelfth page of the libel,
it is stated that this panel, at the end of a long
speech, immediately after this resolution, told
them, " and though by some it may be thought
a bold, by some a daring measure, yet it will
be found the best for securing tlie peace of
our country ; for, if such a law were suffered
to pass, if men were not allowed to utter their
complaints, a number of fierce and rancorous
passions would arise, and we would seek to
appeal to that last terrible decision, the event
of which is uncertain^ but which God and
nature allows.
*' If the servility of the people had been
less; if they had dared to meet, and in place
of murmuring, to have told their rulers that
there was danger in seeking to deprive them
of their liberties, we would not have had to
adopt this resolution to-night; but, when I
saw the calm deliberate countenances of all
present, and the solemn manner in which it
was passed, I was convinced that it would
not only be a resolution of words, but a rule
of action."
My lord, I must confess that I can put but
one construction upon these words ; that they
meant to appeal to the terrible decision of the
sword. My lord I shall add no more upon
the general relevancy of this charge ; I am
clearly of opinion that this is sedition, and se-
dition of the most a^ravated nature. My lord,
much has been saidof real sedition and verbal
sedition ; some gentlemen seem to think that
there can be no such thing as real sedition,
for that it would amount to treason. But, my
lord, supposing a man to have wrote a paper
saying, 1 propose you shall meet in con\*en-
tiou, and you shall have primary assemblies,
and sliall resolve to resist any law that may
pass to disperse them, why, that would be
exciting sedition ; but here is a body of men
actually met together, a combination and
conspiracy of a hundred, or a hundred and
fifty people in the form of a convention of
delegates, resolving to resist the government
established by law.
My lord, I am clearly of opinion, that that
species of ofrence,--cali it sedition or what
you will, I call it the greatest of all sedition, —
would have been punishable by the acts of
parliament already spoken to by my brother ;
and I have no doubt that this resolution to
oppose the authority of the legislature, to pre*
vent them from making laws, or disobeying
those laws when made, is a resolution and a
conduct that would have be^n punishable
capitally in former times, and is punishable
independent of all the acts regarding leading
making, or what I call calumny of the king
and his ministers. But, my lord, it is not
only this resolution that I call sedition ; but
there is another thing, your lordship wiU ofa^-
em
for SMMiMi.
A. D. 17M.
[898
aerve wliat is siud in mie of the speeches of
ibU KeoUeniMiy set forth m thb libel. ^ Let
us toen endeavour to ioatruct the people in
Ih^ir rights, and to inform them of our views
and our intentions/' Your lordship sees they
were to instruct the people, and teach them
their principles, to inform the country of what
their principles and doctrines were, so that if
their principles were bad, leasing making; is
a much inferior species of offence than this.
In the last plae&, as to what your lordship
mav propose (if the libel be proven) as a pu-
nishment, your lordships nave given your
opinions on a former occasion, that there is
no law restraining you from inflicting banish-
ment by the mode of transportation. If I had
iiad any difficulty before, I own, an authority
quoted this day by Mr. Solicitor-General
would at once have done awav every hesita-
tion upon the sulgect Your lordship heard
the authority of a judgment of the privy coun^
cil, which was read upon a libel, laia upon
this very act of parliament, and pronounced
Imt judges who were sitting (no doubt most of
them) m parliament at the time that act was
passed ; and therefore, I think there can be
no doubt that your lordsMps are authorized
to sentence to banishment by transportation.
One of. the gentlemen said, that the act of
1703 made it an alternative punishment^
either banishment, fine, or imprisonment;
but, my lord, the men who drank the preten-
der's faiealth were condemned to fine, to im-
prisonment, and also the disqualifications of
office, and therefore it was by no means con-
fined to any one of them. I am of opinion,
in this case, that your lordship should fina
the libel relevant to infer the pains of law
which is restricted to an arbitrary punish-
ment.
Lord Smnion. — My lord, the question now
under tlie consideration of this court is as to
the relevancy of the libel. My lords, in the
short time that I have sat here as judgje,
three of these cases have occurred; Muir,
Skirving, and Margarot. In each of them I
gave my opinion upon the relevancy, as also
upon tms punishment, and it is veiy disagrce-
ame lo so over the same ground again, espe-
ciidly when gentlemen of more abilities than
myself have already done it: for that reason
I shall be eicceding short, and only go to
where I think the essence of the crime lies.
My lord, the crime charged in the major
proposition is, in general, sraition. The facts
duurged in the mmor proposition amount, in
my opinion, to this, to a cnarge of a seditious
conspiracy to overturn the established go>
▼emment, the happy government of this
country, by force and outrage, if it cannot be
done otherwise. I say it amounts to a sedi-
tk)us conspiracy to overturn the constitution
by force and outrage if it canftot be done
otherwise.
My lord, whether these facts are relevant
to infer the pains of law, needs very little
consideration. My lord, that it is a *'*
VOL. xxra.
oonspincy to overturn the oonstitution, one
need only read the aim and intention of this
BriUsh Convention, as it is called, ^ the Bri-
tish Convention of Delegates of the Peopl^
associated to obtain Universal Suffiage and
Annual Parliaments.'' The gentlemen who
have appeared, and displayed so much ability
for the panel, have taken a great deal of paids
to fritter down what is meant bv universal
sufiirage. My lords^ I maintain that it is not
only inconsistent with the British constitu<*
tion, but inconsistent with every constitution
or government that ever did exist, or ever can
exist, that every mortal who has arms, and
legs, and head (and we are all equal, — all of
like passions and like judements with one
another), that every one of them shall have
equal soffirajge — In what ? Not only in the
election of fisblators, but of magistrates, of
ministers^MO of judees too. Universal sui^
firage, accoroing to their meaning, is a suf-
^firi^e to rejudge what judges may do ; also to
'udge whether they will ooey an act of par*
lament or not, and whether the acts of these
annual pariiaments are agreeable to their
mind or not. I will tell you what, — anniml
parliaments are inconsistent with any govern*
ment at all; because, if these parliaments
should pass an act which these universal suf-
fragants disliked, they have a right, from na*
ture to meet and say this is a wrong act — ^we
did choose these people, but they have gone
contrary to our universal sufiirage, ancf we
have a right to rejudge them, and overturn
what they have done. And I will give it you
in the prisoner's own words, if it be true as
charged in the libel, in his supposed speech.
^ If you appoint a man to act aayour agent^
and make his situation such that he has every
temptation to betray you, without incurring
the danger of beins called ' to an account, the
probabihty is, that he will sacrifice your inte*
rests to his own. It is therefore that a free
sufirage of the people is what every man
ought to desire, as that alone can make the
interest of the representative and his consti-
tuents the same.'* — ^Now mark this, " The
great art oC government, I apprehend, is this,
Uiat all should be governed oy all.*' That is
to say, that the whole of the suffragants, the
whole voters, shall be governed by the whole
voters. — ^What is this but say ins, that the
mob shall be governed by the mob, the mul-
titude shall be governed by the multitude?—
Who would be chose a judce by such gover-*
nors ? Because they would rejudge him.— «
There has been one instance in France, whera
the revolutionary tribunal and the jury, hav«
ing found that the people were innocent,
these suffrannts, these general voters thought
the judges did wrong:, and .they judged them
over again; and if the account we have be
true, every one of them were carried to the
lamp-post. So the plan is, that there should
be an appeal from tiie guillotine to the lamp
post ; that is the plan of this universal go-
vernment. He says^ *^ Were all mankind to
3 M
80§]
S4 GBORGB III.
Proceedingi ^igakiti Joieph GerraU
[MO
wnemble in voblic neetiags, one of ttvo
things must follow, either they wiU behcve
properly or improperly; if properly, their
vieeting will tend to do good, if irni^roperly^
It carries ite own cure uouj; with it. The
nle will be soon brought into n better toe-
by a sense of self preservation, by wMch
they will correct the errors into whieh they
haam iklien." That is to say, they- Would cut
tpm mnotfaei's throaty and the few thait re-
nMUned would see their foH^< But, my loi^
haribotj this motion of rejudeing of tffeij
thing, and of tha conduct of parliament is car-
had through the resolution which they came
to, before God and the worlds that if there
ehouldbe any proposition for bringing into
parliament a oonventioa bitt they wouM resist
si. But, my lords, you need only to read these
thingai they do not heed argumett. I am
ihereibre deatly of opinion that it is sedition*
not only: tending to overturn the British go-
vernment, but every government; and that
it is most surely relevant to infer the pahw of
Ja^*
Lerd Dmiuinmuk.^—My lords, the censide-
hMioB of this very point was so ktely before
us^ and the Court gave the same opinidil
%rhich your lordships have now given, thet I
think it is unnecessary for me to say more, than
tbrat I think, in this case, as I did in that, that
ehis mdicthieflt contains knatter relevant to
Wet the orhne of sedition.
Lord AbefetoiHhie.^My fords, the question
%hich has been so ably argued to day is pre*
eisely the same that has been argued Itefore
^ur lordships Ih the forhier cases. And, my
feiti, in the first pfoce, I am now, as I wa^
then, deeidedly of opinion, that no good ob-
Jeelion has been stated to the relevancy of
this iodicthient. In Uie second place, I am
ofo^nion, that the objection to the punish-
lAeiit ef transportation, founded upon the
Mt of 1708, has no gbod foundation; imd I
think so for two reasons. In the first place,
that tt deeA not epply to the crime eharjged
a^hst the panel. The erime charged agamst
%im is sedition, and sedition of the most ag^
tftavated oattfre. A man may be guilty ^
Aafisng-making without beine guilty of sedi*
tioti; and eirtf vefM, he may be ^ilty of se^
diUon without being guilty of leasmg^-making.
fin the next place, stipposing that act to ap-
ply to this precise case, I am of opinion that
the sole ana whofo puh[>ose of that statute was
to take away the punisnment of death, leaving
ti)e power to inHict, according to the circum*
ilanees of the case, either simple banishment
fof^ ef the realm, or banishment by transport-
tatfon.
My lord, it was said, tiiat upon tooking
into dictionaries, it appeared tliat banishment
did net extend to transnortation. But, my
lord, every body knows mat the same word
ftiay mean one thing in common language,
end haVe a Very difforent interpretation in a
statute; for, to e^ve one example, my lord,
heir apparent, I bdieve^ iii the -English lan>-
gui^s^ Big^iflM a penoB tlie eldest md of u»
etbef ding bis iailiefslife^ Mthepnceof
Walsa is heir nppamit to the orown ; but
your lofdsbip kBowe^ that hev apparent in thd
statute law of SeotAand hae a very dMuum
iotsrprelstien; for,by thehiwef Scothud, ft
man i^ not heir appaMnt to hie iMlict till hie
fother be ia the nrnve, and he may possosi
his estate for half aeentury in the eharaclsr
of heir appelant; and many other inatanoeo
might be given^ Bveh if we kiok into John-
son's Dktionary ht the weid traaspomiiott^
he says ft is banishment fot felonyi Yont
fordehip sees» that even If we were at Kbei^
strictly to adhere to the eomnMn fonM of
speeeh, the argument would not hokl soedi
I have not the stnallost doubt that your loi^
ships have a power to banish by tnmsport^
tkm.
My lords, the leamedeoonsd fM* Ihe Miel,
both of them, concluded a very long and Mt
argument, with a circumstance which I Owit
I heard witli regret, because I always refttet
any circumstance t^hich in my mind tends to
aggravate the guilt of a person standing in
the nnfottunate situation ef the panel. Botft
the one and the other of bis leinned eoansei^
in speaking of the punishment of transpenai-
tion, stated that his cane would be extremely
hayd| because he was a gentleman, a man vrfae
p^esessed talents, qualities, and virtues wlucH
wouki be useful and Ornamental to sotiety.
My lord, I am very sorry that such a man
should be in his situation, because if he should
be Convicted it aggravates his crime highly.
Had he been a man ignorant and uninfortoed,
it might have been some apology for his of-
fonce; and though such a man, when he
tnmeffresaes againaft the laws of his eotmlry,
must be punished, yet it would have been i
good reason for infiktin^ the mildest punish-
ment that we couM, consistently with onr dnty^
inflict • but, my lord^ if such are the quaMfica^
tions of the panel now at ^ur bar, so mu^
the deet>er and more aggravated is his gfidit ;
for, mv lotd, we all know ftom the highest
authorityy that to whom mUch is given, of
him much will be required.
Lord JuaHee Clerk. — Mv fords, when tiie
question was before us this day week, the
panel applied for counsel, and I was veiY
nappy to hear Aat it coincided entirely with
the opinion of all your lordships. My lords',
I have attended with the greatest attention to
all these questions of sedition, from the first
ef them down to the present dav, and we
heard similar questions upon the relevancy of
Charles Sinclair's indictment discussed with
great abilities at the bar, and also fuUv ^Rs«>
cussed by the Court ; and I do own, — although
I hope I am always open to convictfon, m
every question that comes before me,wheti)er
civil or criminal, ret I lay I do own,r-4faat
from the first to the last ot these questions. I
never, *li any period, entertained two differ-
Cnt sentiments. With respect to the fifrf
point, lamsurethat much Jess than what ie
I
IM ta tkt thiilop fHi»p6«lioQ would agpport
t)m crime ci)»i9e(} io tbe m^or fMrapoe»Uioii 3
ffld with rovpect to the judgnent your lord-
•hiip« b»vcgiin8D« 1 shall only my, that I am
yery dfipr we have fuU poorer to proiM)ul»e
that sentence^ and that we should not hava
4i9i6iB juttiee to ibe colinCry if we had pro-
nounead a amalier nmieheoefit upo9 any «of
th<MKe caaee. f shall IkeFefore not add any
more, but that I concur with ygur lordship?
in ilie opinion thai 4he libel is relevant \o iu-
^^e pains ef Jaw.
Thursday, March IS, 1794.
, When the Gsurtsiet, the interloowkor 00
Ihe Bekrancy was fead evnr, ai^ the fo]iovr<
ing gentlemen were chosen as jurors : —
X)avid Deuchan seal-engraver, Edinburgh.
PeUr Hilly bookseller there.
John Bell, bookseller there.
j£unes Hunter, merchant there.
Andrew MilHgep, watch-case-maker there.
$ir William Forbes, bart. banker there,
peter Mathie, jeweller there.
Alexander Gardner, jeweUer tjicre.
W91iam Creech, booKseller there,
lipomas Hutchison, merchant there,
Mv. Gmt^d.-'-Uf kcil, I ol^ect (e Mr.
WiHiaBB Oeech ; I ipderstand be has rcpear
Cedly decfoied, in private coofversalions, that
)ie would condemn any nemher of the Bri-
tish poBvenlion, if he should he caiied io pass
upon their assize ; and I wish to refer it te
bispwaeeoscienoe, and hie oath, .whefher he
has not prejudged the pdnci|>]fii upon which
I am to be tried.
Lord Henderland, — My lord» the objection
is, that he tias prejudged the principles upon
wrich Mr. Gernud is to be tried ; that he said
he iRoaid ronrdemn every member of the Bri^
igah convention ; it is stated in ^ loose way, it
is not stated that he amd he would do so whe-
ther they were guiltv or not; I cannot see
that it is a relevant objection ; ifhe had Sjaid,
he wopld condemn them ivhcther they were
dlty or not, it would have been a good ob-
}n, but at pMsenA it is 4oo generally
id.
Lord Eskgrove, — ^If the allegation had been,
tot Wtr. Creech had said he would convict
Mr. Gecnld^ rieht or wrong, the objectioil
emuld be good; nut if it was only in common
conveiiation that he had eueh an opinion of
the inlentioDs oi 4he British convention, it b
not a good oi^ctbn.
Loid SwinUn.-^ am of the aatne apAniiNi.
Lord DiinsmiMBa.«-I perfectly coincide wiMl
jrour lontobips.
Lord Abercrombie. — I am of the same opi-
nion. -
Lard Jtutkfi CU^k, — As this objection is
stated, I hope there is not a gentleman of the
jary, or any man in this court, who has not
expressed the same sentiments*
*jiMe .whfLt occurrpd in Tu^ctin'^ case.
A- D- 179*.
f80»
Mr« 0«rfwi!d.— Th^ my trial would ben
qiatier 9^ forq? merely, because a jurypHUii
by saying put of ^uocs that he would condemii
every memhsr of .tl^ British convention*
tAJts^ for granted that very principle whlph
remains to he proved. If a juryman tw4
averited galy that ke would condepop al^ the
4isturb^rs of the puhljp peaise, no deubt M
would be well warranted in making th^t,|^
sertiouj but, he say^ he will jcoiQd^mn
theip, not bjscause they ware distuihers of thil
public peace, but because they were menihtfV
of a convention, tlie ilJepsUiy of wbi<::h yet re-*
mains to be established. So that your lord-
ships must s^ thst siiic^ a gjen^vl declara-
tioo operates to the same conclusion^ that he
would condemn a man for that which may
turn out to have been legai and constitutional.
Mr. Cr^dck. — My (ofd, I never said so s i| is
impossible that I ever cou^ say such a WB^
|iOrd HenderlMHd^—i thi^k.Mr. Gerrald 1^
very ill advised in th(e w^y ip wh^ch he stat^
the objection^ hec^i^ss hie h^ in fact, ac-
knowledged himself a me^nher of )he coAt
Yimtion.
[The obje^tiop yr^A repelled.}
John Hutchison, merchant, Edinbiirgh.
JohnSihbald, ssBith there.
Alexander Nishet, maQuifictiirer there^
William Rankin, tayW there.
Arcl^hald Campbell, brewer there.
LoTdJj/Lilicp Clerk. — Po y^^u object to fu^y
of these gentlemen?
Mr. Gerrald. — ¥«S) my lord, I object to
>Villiam iUnki^ ; and the ground of my od-
jeUion is this, and { ^fi^ sustain ^i,by both
Srecedent ^ind princij^e. It consists in t^i^^
|r. jiankin is taylor to the Icing; and, Oi
course, bein^ jn the pay of the crown, h^4i^
oGoasionaify m the habift of reoeiyiqg ffivoura
friO^i it, he ciinnot be |i fit person to p^s upoa
my assise.* And, my lord, I will sii^stain it
\ky precedent Ip the tjr4al of Ajgfrnopi»idf
^ey, which, I trust, will ^lev^ be adduced a*
a precedent, except to he violated, ii is stated
tlMt << the colonel excepted to several of the
jury, to some as not heing freeholders, and
others as heiqg in the king'^s service, and re*
ceiving wages from hi$ pajestv.'' And I iind/
by the act of parliament, which took plaqs
immediately after the glorious revolution fot
reversing <iie -attainder of Alge^^^on Sidi^ey^
tlie very first causes sj^ted ^s a ground of ror
versing the attainder, arc, ** Whereas Alg^^
npn Sidney, esq. in the term of St. Micl^^
■ ■ I ■ ■ ■ ■ • 11 111! ip^
« » * • *
Vol. Uj page 1101, and Ifawk. P^.Cr. them
refei^ed Iq. See also the case of O'Comw
aod others, a. n. 1708, i^d.
* I9 the case of D€»paid> a. d. 1603, ^fr^p
Edward Kiupe, esq. was on the part of fthe
prisoner objected to as a jurof , on the groiii^d^
that he held a place in the lard chamber-
laun's QfiEke during pleasured hulthe olyec-
tion was overruled. See also Vol. 2^ p.
1038 of this CoUfiGti4».
msi
SiGEORGBin,
Ptoctedmgs ngainst Jaepk GerraU
{)904
ID the thirty-fifUi year of the leign of our late
soveieign king Charles ^d, in the court of
King's-bench at Westminster, by means of an
unlawful return of jurors, and by denial of his
lawful challen^s," and so on. For thue
reasons the attainder was reversed.
Lord Hcnderlaud. — ^I'he very same objec-
tion * was stated in the ease of Mr. Muir, and
was then repelled.
I/n-d Justice Ckrlc^lf it had been the
kine himself, I do not see that it could be a
valid obl»ction.f
(The objection was repelled.]
EVIDEVCB FOft THB CROWV.
WiUkm Sccitf sworn. — Examined by Mr.
MofUgimiay,
Does it consist with your knowledge that a
warrant was issued to apprehend the panel at
the bar ?— Yes, he was apprehended on the
morning of the 5th of December.
Were you present at the declaration emit-
ted by him that day? — ^Yes.
Was it emitted voluntarily and firedy?— It
Was he sober and in his senses at the
time ? — He was.
Look and see if that is it — ^It is ; it was
emitted upon the 5th of December, and he
found bail the same evening.
Dki you see him next day ?— I did : on the
eveniojg of the next day I went to the meet-
ing ofthe British convention, accompanied
by the lord provost, sheriff-substitute, and
magistrates, m ladv Lawson's yard; wlien
we went in we found that whoever had been
in the chair had left it. Mr. Gerrald was
standing near the chair speaking to the
meeting. Mr. Margarot said, they were met
upon a constitutional business to address the
king, or something to that purpose, and
somebody called out that nothmg could be
done till the chair was full. Mr. Margarot
was called to the chair, and took it. Mr.
Davidson then asked if that was the meeting
ealling themselves the British convention;
ibey replied that they were ; upon that he
B^idy ** if that is the case, you must dismiss ;
we are come here for that purpose." Then
there was a call for Mr. Gerrald to go on,
hut Mr. Davidson opposed it, and took Mr.
Margarot, who was m the chair, bv the hand,
and pulled him out, and then there was a
call for Mr. Gerrald to take the chair, which
he did, and Mr. Davidson made use of the
same means to induce him to leave the chair,
as he had done to Mr. Margarot, and be sub-
mitted to the compulsion; the^ considered
it as sufficient that he was desired to leave
the chair, and was taken by the hand. It was
then said that it was usual, before dismissing
the convention, that they should pray, which
* But see Muir*s case^ p. 133 of this vo*
Imne.
t iSp in the original ^tioo.
Mr. Gerrald did,* and then left the chair;
but before he left the chair, as well as at the
beginning of the meeting, it was called out
that they would rememb^ that the meeting
had voted themselves permanent the night
before.
Does it consist with your knowledge, tiuit
on the evenine prior to this, the conventioii
were dismissed oy the magistrates? — I was
informed so.
When Mr. Gerrald was brought for exaiu-
nation to the sheriff clerk's office, were there
any papers brought? — Yes, when Lyon the
messenger, and other officers executed the
warrant upon Mr. Margarot and Mr. Gerrald,
they brought them to the office, with their
papers.
what became of those papers? — ^After Mr.
Grerrald and Mr. Margarot were examined,
it was proposed that the trunk should -be
opened, but Mr. Margarot refused to deliver
up the key; the trunk was kept till next day,
when a warrant was issued to send him to
gaol till he did deliver it up; he refused still
to give it, but finding there was a warrant
issued, he held it in his hand and said, if
you choose to take it you may ; be stepped
aside a litUe till it was opened, and when he
returned he saw the papers looked over,
and those that did not apply to the business
in hand were given up to them again.
Was it opened in yoiur presence ?<-<-Yes^
and in the presence of Mr, Davidson, the
sheriff-substitute.
Look at that oaper.>— It is the inventory of
the napers founa in the trunk.
Were all the papers that were inventoried
marked ? — ^Yes.
Would you know .them asain ? — Yes.
Mr. SoUcUoT'Geiural.'^Look them over
carefiilly by the inventory, andaeeiftheae
are the papers so inventoried--ere they
marked with your initials ?— Yee.
[The witness then examined the paper&^
and compared them with the inventory of
the papers found in Mr. Margarot's trunk.]
Witnets. — The first seven articles were
claimed by Mr. Gerrald, and the others by
Mr. Marsarot.
Mr. Montgomenf, — Were any other papers
brought to the sheriff clerk's office.—* Yes;
when the warrant was executed against this
sentieman^ one was executed against Mr.
Sinclair also, at the Black Bull, wJMJn^as very
much indisposed at the time, and liis papers
remained at the office till he was in -n situa-
tion to come to be examined.
Were you present when his papers were
inventoried? — I was.
Was Mr. Sinclair present?— He was.
Had he an opportunity of perusing it?—
It was read over to him.
Did he object to any of the articles beiiig
put into it ? — No.
* See the prayer
pasc^ afU^,p. 47L
in Sidmng's
905]
JbrSei^kn*
A. D. 1794.
[906
Look at tbftt^Thst is the inventory of
Mr. Sinckdr's papers.
[The witness examiQed the papers, and
compared them with the inyeDtory.j
Do you know that there was a warrant
issued to apprehend Mr. Skirving?— Yes, at
the same tune.
Were any papers of his found ? — ^Yes, the
warrant was executed by Lyon the m^ssen^,
accompanied by Fraser, Mack, and Ding-
wall.
Were you present when the inventory of
those papers was made up ?~Yes.
Who Drought them to the sheriff clerk's
office? — ^The officers brought Mr. Skirvine,
with the papers in a bi^. Mr. Dingwall
put his seal upon them, and Mr. Skirving
also, and they remained sealed up in that
bag till they were taken out before the
sheriff.
Were they taken out in tus presence? —
tcs.
Are they marked with your initials ? — ^Yee,
they are ; this is the inventory of them.
Mr. Clerk. — My lord, I understand that
the convention was not established under
the denomination of the British convention,
till 19th November, 1793. Now one and
all of these papers, as I understand then,
that Mr. Scott is going to prove, are of dates
anterior to the existence of the British con-
vention, private papers ef Mr. Skirving's,
which cannot affect this cause.
Mr. 8olicitor»General.^lf these papers
were produced for the purpose of rearing up
a charge of guilt, foundea upon these papers,
the objection would be ^ood, because tie is
only charged with sedition m the convention;
but that is not the purpose for which they
are produced ; they are produced as papers
not constituting guilt of themselves, but as
circumstances of evidence, which, though I
tlunk they are not decisive ones, ought to be
laid before the jury.
Lord Jiutice Clerk.-^Att they libelled
Vfonf
Mr. SoUcUar-GeneraL^They ar/ all libel-
led upon.
Lord JutHce Clerk. — ^You know you are
entitled to prove every fact and circumstance
that may establish the panel's guilt, as being
art and part in the crime.
Mr. SiflieUor-General. — It is very possible
that the panel may find something among
them that may be useful to himself; I do not
know whether he will or not ; there are nine-
tenths of them that I shall not say a word
ahout.
[The witness examined and compared the
papers found in Mr. Skirving's possession
with the inventory.]
William Scott cross-examined by Mr. Clerk.
When dkl you first see Mr. Sinclair's pa-
pers?—On the morning of the 5th of De-
cembirlhey wene Inrought to theofficei with
Mr, MargaroVs and Mr. Genrald's ; but as
Mr. Sinckir could not be brought to the
office at that time, his papers were not open-
ed till about the 7th or 8tb, when he was
able to come.
How were the papers secured when you
first saw them ? — ^Wrapped loosely in a towel.
Were they sealed? — No.
In whose hands did they remain from the
5th to the 7th ?— They remained in the she-
riff-clerk's chamber, in a locked room.
You said they were inventoried in the pre-
sence of Mr. Sinclair?— Yes.
Did he ofier any protest upon that occa«
sion ? — ^I cannot recollect.
Try and recollects— I know he declined an»
swenng questions.
Did lie offei^ to take a protest that these
were not his papers I — ^I do not recollect it
You do not recollect the circumstance of a
protest at all ?-^No.
Who were present besides you ? — ^Mr. Da-
vidson, Mack, and Lyon.
I wish to tak whether, when you went to
this meeting, you sffw any sign of violence,
riott or disorder ?— -No. I saw no confusion
till the magistrates came there, there was no
appearance of a riot.
bo you know whether Mr. Sinclair's papers
were opened, by any person whatever, ndbre
he saw them? — No, not that I know of—
they were locked up and sealed.
Mr. Gillies. — ^Does it consist with your
knowledge, that a paper was given to Mr.
Gerrald out of the bundle, previous to taking
tiie inventory ? — ^No, not previous to taking
the inventory; among the papers there was
one which he said was very material to him,
and we thought it was of no conseauence,
and therefore gave it up to him upon the 6th,
and a receipt was given for it.
Harry DavidsoUf sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Montgomery.
You are sheriff-substitute of the county of
Edinburgh ? — ^I am.
Do you know that a warrant was issued
against Mr. Gerrald ?~Ye8.
Was he brought before you in consequence
of that warrant?— He was.
Look at that; is that the declaration that
he emitted when he was brought before you t
i— Yes.
Was it emitted freely and voluntarily ?— «
Yes.
Did he appear to be sober and in his sensea
at the time? — ^Yes.
Did you observe upon what day that decla-
ration was taken?— 4 think it was upon the
5th of December.
Did you see Mr. Gerrald next day ?— I did,
in the evening, at a meeting of the British
convention, in a wright's shop, in lady Law-
son's yard, at the. south side of the town. I
went were with the lord provost and some cf
the maeistrates^ with a number of peaoe-offi-
en; tnera was a sreiy great crowdi tISeahop
907J 34 GEORGE IIL
Proceedingi 9gimtt JegBph Gerrald
09O8
msqtiite filled wkenXwtalia; Mr*0«rr»ld
vtft fpeiLkings I eaw. « mimber of people
irbooi I had seea the fuditbefart » fvtioular-
1^ Mr. Mftrgu-ot, and llr, Gerrald. I ftiked
if that was the British conventioii? I was
told UmI it was. Itoldtfaeml wasthe sheriif-
sufasti^iileoftbecxaiiitjr; fipoa tiiaft» Mr. Oetw
raid went on speakiog. I iMgged tkiu I Blight
be heard ; that I was tbe sheri£f«4iih8titute of
the couiityy and wae come to disperse the
meeting. I addressed mjrself priociittUy to
Mr. MareaiDt, as he teeoied to be the chief
person tnere; I ttfld him I conaidered llie
meeting as an iikgal meetiagy and I ordered
the people to disperse ; aome ooBwrsation eo-
sned upon that, aad he told me they weee a
r&aceable and constitutional meeliDg; that if
voald hear what was then ^Ibc on, I should
be.mfibfied that thajruwrewhatae said they
wen, and that they w«re then meeting upon
a petition to parliament ; .and he showed me
a paiwr^ lyii^ tmon the tahle, with the words
** petition to parFianient'' written upon it. I
• told Ihem thai I eame fiir the purpose of dis-
pemiDg them, aad that I was determined to
r> maJB them till they wem dispersed ; ^ding
that I was determined to dicjMtae them, Mr.
Margaret, with the approbatioB «f the raeeiU
log, took the chair, aad said they should not
diseolve till force was used. I told them I
hofied force (would not he necessary ; that i
had force with aae, hut should be somr to be
under the naoessity of using it. He said some
mark offeree was necessary to be used; ujpoa
which I took him bw the hand, and deatrad
him to come loutof the chair : it was a frieiMi-
ly shake of tbe hand, but he tltought that was
too sli^ ; I then put ray hand to his shoulder,
and he came out; they seemed to think that
I kad cammitled an assault upon them, and
threatened to prosecute me; I laughed at
them. Mr. Gerrald was then caHedTto the
chair, and I made use of the same kind of
force with him ; after that he made a prayer,
which they said was the usual way o£ ^ureak-
ing up the assembly, and I certainly allow
that I afeaid till I saw them all out of the
room ; I then locked the door and took the
key* Mr. Margaret said it was unnecessary
to disperse them, for they had declared ^m^
selves pennanent. In answer to tha^ I said
it might .be so, but they ^ertatnly shoald ntft
meet any where in the county ; that if they
did, they should be dispersed m the aame way
that they were that night.
When Mr.rQtrrald was brought before you,
were there any papers brought with him? —
Yes, Lyon, the messenger, who apprehended
Mr. Margarot, Mr. Gertald^aod Mr. Siaclair,
brought a number of papers in a locked trunk;
wbion, he said, <contaiQed the papers of Mr.
Margarot aad Mr. Gerr^Ad; they west not
•opened till 'the toeat <lay.
Who had tbie key ?-^Mr. Maosgarot ; he m-
iused to give it /up tin a waaratit «ras issued to
•flpen it by ^eme.
Was it. opened neat dayia|»urpmqiB&fle'?
*-It was.
Wae 4mw a# Ipvtnl^iy made ^f- them ^-
Yes.
Was Mr. Manganot and Mr. Gerrald pre-
sent?— ^They were both present.
Look at that paper. — ^This is the inventory.
Did yov sign it f^Yes, Mr. S^pott selecled
tho^e which be thought any way neoessaiyp
or connected with the charge against him,
and gaye tbe rest baok; ao inventory was
made of tho^e that were retained, which ia
this in my ha^. |[ see the pap^s that he*
longed to Mr. Grerrald, have not my initials.
Were thcQr^maikedbsr Mr. $oott?'-^Ve8,
they are mtgrked both with JAr.Simti's and
liyoa's ioitials; tboee cMmed by Mr. Mar-
garet, ere piarkfd with my imtiala.
Were there any papers said to have bieloflg*
ed to Mr. Sinclair ?--Yes, seme of them Wfn
^visn.baek to him, aad eoDie of them ivera
retained.
Is that paper an inventory of them ?-^YeS9
it is aaarked with my toilials.
Was Mr. Sinclair present when they were
SO marked ? — Yes, he was.
Do. vou know of any papers of Mr^ Skirving*a
being brought ta the omce ?— Yes.
Were they inweptoried before you ? — Yes,
ihey were,
. Look at that.--*This is the inyeate^ of
them, aod this is the ssroU of the Bumutas pf
the convenltoji which waa found at Mr. Skir*
viAg's»
, Was Mr^SkirvipgpraaeBtwhsii that iaveft*
tory was made iu»t? — Yes,
Mr. Ckrk^-^my lords, w9m of the papers
libelled iqiipa are not here. 2n the iftweoic^
of papers thene is oae mentioned, ^ The nde^
oraers, and regulaUoM of the n^oet^ caUsc)
the British OMiventioo," which is wanting;
for any thing I know that may he a veiy ma*
terial piece iS' evidence, Ito ^hoiiv what w«e tha
particular aakure of the oonveation, ami^ wiih
what partipahwr views, and for what partioiilar
purppses they met; and i^ is a very great 40*
feet in tbe evidence indeed, that iJi^ pMbUe
prosecutor^ after J^beiliag upon these v^iJlinga
and inventorying them, has not produq^ so
material b faper as ttu^. I w»s 4)a|itied to
come here, trusting that this paper would ba
produced by the f^tmc pGOBec«tor. 2 say that
paper contaio'mg the rules, orders, a^d fig^
tionsoftbe BritishoonvenMoo, is AmMeriai
paper, and he does not produce ijt.
Mr. SoUdtcr Oe»erW.--Xhe liM bears,
that oertain miveateriaB ace tp be pnediva^
and the papers taentlooed j$i thoae iavcjf-
tories; the gctpvlemea might have kiaown two
or throe 4ty*-«go, wh^t ff^ t» he prodW9ed»
and what not; and it was incumbent upa^
him to have inspected them ; and, if any were
wanting, to apply for a j^^ence to enforce
their production.
Lord Justice C2erA.-— Tbe public prosectrtor
libels upon such and aooh papers ; rt was your
4uty to see if those ^peni ^Kuie in the cferk's
haa^aodift^^werepoty y<m oeukLhawa
mqdied to .ihe-Cai|rt^ mi i^#4^SWl^^
the recovery of it.
069}
fif Sttdklams
A.IXnM.
[910
Mr. MMHi* Omttalj^KtiA iM» baf ]^fM
to b« ft ^Med pttp^, 6f whieh they tmnt
have 0^ haadrta d^pveft in l^ir posMtBioo.
Mt^. L^nf^^ do ndt kilow hdw w« w^rt
to get a diligence when we did BOt kAOir ill
Wliode BOssesMoh it \f«4.
Mr. Mofif jDm^.^Here it is^ iHy k>fd> I
hstifi fbund it tttneng tbe 'piip^ ; here are
eleven copies of it ; in going over the piipen
Mr. 8eott happened to taiss it.
Sarry Davidson, cross-eKamined by lilr.
CUrk.
It is hardly necessary to a^k, vi^helher you
oiiierved any thiilg Kke seeAes xA riot or tii*
itofiH id the conventkfn r^^Nc^e -at all.
When did you Grst see Mr. Sinolair'^ papers f
■-The messenger, LyOn, brobght them alons
with the other papers, at th<$ time Mr. Oerrala
Mtd-W^. Maifarot wereapprehetidtid ; hui^Mr.
SiQclair being unwell, and confined to his
ttiduk, he wail net, on that aceount, brought
to the sjieriff-clerk's office at tha% time.
Pfk what way ^^re th^ brought to the office }
»^t1ed il}l in a handkerchief. Lyon told me
Ihey ^tlte papers of Mr. Sinclair's, but I did
net touch ^em. They were Wmpped up and
tied, but I did not observe any seal.
I think you said they were inventoried ifk
Mr. Sinclair's presence ? — ^Tes.
Were you- present ?*-Yea.
Did he sign it?— «No.
What did Mr. Stndah* 9ay?-^lid he deny
those papers to behis?*— Ido hot recollect
that I think he acknowledged that they
were his; because, when the pajiers were
selected, and part of them given back to him,
he reoeived tnem as his.
Was any mention made by Mr. Slnclah* of
a protest ?— I really do not know ; one of the
geiitlemen did, hut there were so many of
wiein, that I eannot say whether it was Mr.
8melair or not.
Yoii are uncertain whether he took a prtK
test or offered oi^e ?— I cannot say. I do not
think Mr. Gerrald made use of the word
protest; either Mr. Sinclair, Mr. Slcirvinj,
Or Mr. Margarot did, but I cannot say which.
Do you recollect that he gave any reason
Ibr not signing the inventory ?*-He refused
t» sign it, because he thought it was a wrong
atep, contrary to law.
Did he say any thing more as a reason for
Hot vigQi]!^ it?— Hpon my word I do not re-
coiiect. The sum of what he said was put
down in his declaration.
Can you say, from your own knowledge,
Aat an proper, and necessary means were
used in order to pi^vent any other papers
being introduced into the bundle; or, on the
tfther hana, to preveni any papers from being
taken away from that bundle ?-^I cannot say
that I had any particular access to know the
ftct, for I did not see them till tiiey were
afterwards opened in my pres^ee.
Were they sealed up before they were
e^enod?^!' do^ not think hie papers were
sealed.
bit tm \umif lit thMtt citteB. ta teal up
jthe papers to prevent any from neing taken
away, aiul to pffifaiit others from bemg put
in?— Yes.
How was It thai it was dmitted upon this
ocaasion ?-— I cannot say ; there was a great
deal to do in the ottce ; I was there from h%^
fore nine in the morning, till between nine
and ten at night; the papers were lodged "by
the messenger in the sheriff-clerk's hands.
Mr. S6iUmoi^ GaMra/^— You say they were
opened ia the presefkce of Mr^ Sinclur ^— Yed.
Did he say thera wens any of the papers
that were tm his.^^Mr. Getndd, Mr. Maq^
rot, and Mr. Sinclair staid in the same house
tog^har) and I remamber one or otiier of
them •ayiaji there was a paper that waa wit
Ms, t^t tt belonged to one of th« other gen-
tlemen.
Did Mr. Sinclair acknowledge thoto papera
tobehis.^-^When Mr. Scott seleoted them^
Ifr. Sifielair lat by him ; and what papers
Mr. Scott M not think necessary to retain^
he gave hack to Mr. Sinclair.
Lofd Danstna«fi.-^Did Mr. Sinclair aetf
and know that they were marked as his pa*
pers, and made no objection to them ?-^Yct.
One 0f ike Jtiry.-^What length of tima •
might elapse between the time that the pa^
pers were brought to the office, and the time
when they were opened ?— -They were taketf
unon the Thursday, and they were not o^en^
M till he was able to tome for examination^
which was on the Saturday forenoon.
Do you know, of your own knowlediee,
who brought those papers ^ — was it Lyon N-4
Lyon brought them into the ofBce hinssify
in my presence^ and said they were Mr. Sin«
elair's papen.
Did Mr. Sinclair take any concern in what
was passing, as to the inventoiyf — ^k>tanjf
thing farther than putti)ag into hit pock^
those that Mr. Scott returned to him.
Lord Henderland,-^Do you know where
they were kept, from Thursday to SaturdkyI
•^I do not of my own knowledge ; but I tlunk^
when, I asked Mr. Mack, he said l^y had
been under his own lock and key.
Mr. Gillies, — Was Mr. Sinclair desired;
upon that oeeasien, to sign the inyent<Mry ^^
Yes he was.
Did he sigift it ? — ^I think he did not In
the first place he declined to sign his decla-
ration, because he considered hunself impro^
perly brought before me; and I think he
mentioned, that as he had declined to sied
his declaration, he should decline to sign tne
inventory of course.
Mr. SDlicitar General — ^Dtd he complain
<£ papers being taken from him under a ge«
neral warrant as an illegal thing f — I do not
know that he said any thing about general
warrants ; Mr. Marggrot did, but Mr. binciair
was much milder.
Mr. Gt//jei.-»The wimess has sud he re-
lied to sign the inventory for the same rea-
son tkit be refut^ to sign the declarationr
91 q
84 GEORGE IIL
Pfooeeib^M^UM Jmqflk Gtfratd
pn
Now, tiie fact is, that the dachtfition b afn-
ed b/ Mr. Sinclair.
ITtfiieo.— That is a cimmtfrtanee that I
had forgotten.
. Mr. Solicitor Ceiteral.'^Tht lact is, he
signed the first page of the dechu^tion, and
renised to sign the rest; that is the ftct.
James Lyon sworn. — ^Examined by Mr.
^ Montgomery.
Did you execute a warrant against Mr.
Genrald and Mr. Mai]gaiot? — ^Yes; I went
to the Black Bull to inquire for these gen-
tlemen; the waiter acknowledged they were
in the house, hut declined going with me to
their rooms; he told me the number of their
rooms, and the first room 1 went to was Mr.
Gerald and Mr. Mai^an>f s. I knocked at
the door, and they desired me to come in,
which I did. I told them I had a warrant to
carry them before the sheriff; they were in
bed; they got up immediately; I collecled
together the papers that were in the room.
Mr. Mai^rot proposed putting them in a
trunkf and asked Mr. Gerrald if he would
put his into it, he consented ; they were nil
put in, and Mr. Margarot took the key into
Lis possession. When he was comine away,
says he, '' I do not g^ve you the truiuc, you
may take it at your peril.'' I told him I was
not scrupulous about that, and immediately
gave the trunk to a chairman, to put it into
a coach. I kwked out Mr. Sinclair's papers
likewise^ and took them at the same time.
. Speak to Mr. Gerrald'sand Mr. Margarot's
papers first. — I must rehearse this: when
we came to the sheriff-clerk's o£&ce in the
coach, I left the tnmk and the other papers
in the office, and sent a message to- Mr. Scott
to inform him of what I had done, and then
I got a messa^ from him to brinjg Mr. Sin*
dair in a chair. I went to Mr. Smclair and
told him ; and theii there came a message
that they wondered I was so long ; and then
there came another message to let him re-
main at his lodging, which I did till between
9 and 10 o'clock at night.
When was the trunk opened ?— I think it
was two days afler.
Were you present when it was opened ?—
I was.
Who had the key ?— Mr. Margarot.
All the time ? — ^I know nothing to the con-
trary.
Was there any inventory made up of the
papers? — ^Yes, at the sheriff-clerk's office;
there was none made at their lodgings.
When the trunk was to be opened, Mr. Mar-
^srot would not give up the key, and it was
proposed to get a smith to break it open, but
It was delayed that day. The next day Mr.
Margarot was brought before the sherin-sub-
stitute and Mr. Scott ; he said he would not
give it up, but held it in his hand, so [repre-
senting the manner of it], and said it must be
taken from him by force ; Mr. Scott was
going to take it from him; but Mr, Davidson
sttdao^ hem«ftnotdo it^aoneoter body
must do it, and then Sfr. Blade gave a grip*
at ity and took it firom him; it was then open*
ed, an inventory was made^ and I put my
initiab at the back of it
Look at these papers, and see if these am
the papers you round in Mr. Gerrald's room.
— ^Yesy thy are; they have my initials upon
them.
Was Mr. Sinclair in a separate room frooi
Mr. Gerrald and Mr. Margarot when you exe-
cuted the warrant?— Yes.
Were the papers separate ?— Yes.
And yoQ brought them with you to the
sheriff-clerk*s office ?— Yes ; and Mr. Marjga*
rot and Mr. Gerndd weie ia the chanot
with me.
What did you do with Mr. Sinclair's pa*
pers?— I left tham in the sheriff^erk's office.
Were you present afterwards, when thay
were opened? — Yes.
Howlongafler, wasit? — ^I am not certaia;
it mieht be a few days after.
Did they seem to be in the same situation
as when you brought them into the office ?— r
They appeared to me so; they were in my
handkerchief, my name was in the handkes*
chief.
Were you present when the inventoiy of
them was made out? — Yes.
Was Mr. Sinclair there ?— Yes.
Were any papers given back to him ? — Yes*
Did he take them? — ^Ue took all that were .
given him, which was some that were not
considered material to the business in hand.
/offtet I^foii, cross-examined by Mr. Clerk,
You have said that you carried Mr. Sindair'f
papers to the office yoursdf ?— Yes.
And left them there? — Yes.
Was there any objection made bv any per-
son concerning the manner in which vou nad
secured those papers in the sherisMrlerk'a
office;^ or any where elsa?-^did nobody tell
you It was exceedingly danMous to keep
those papers unsealea up ?«--I do not recol-
lect any such thing.
Did nobody say that other papers might be
ut in, that did not belong to Mr. Sinclair? —
o the best of ray remembrance no person
stated any such thing: and, with humble
submission to you, my lord, I went from th^
sheriff-clerk's office to bring off Mr. Sinclair,
and I was not back till 0 or 10 o'clock at
nieht, so that the papers were in the sheriflPa*
office all that time.
Did you take any notice of Mr. Sinclair's
papers when you seized them/ — I found some
of them lying upon the deskj and one paper
I got lying below the bed.
Have you any other means of knowing
that these are the same but that' of knowing
your own handkerchief? — Upon my word!
do not think there was any thing else.
Mr. SolicUor Genertd. — ^At the sheriff
clerk's office, did you deliver them into any
body's custody ?-»*There wave two of Mf»
«
#]S)
J^^ IB99lK9^^K^k
ji. lb. vtdi.
(914
9nA¥; but I vnt^iSo Ultttifedl w«» Hot ihe^, F
Atfesay, fi^ni!diffie»; butf I thiiik P d^afa^d
A day or two afteiHrsrds^ wlltfn^ you sow
€itk butidie^ of^ned^< hifd you any reason! to
l[>eUefe or sustoeet- that siiy akeratlon had
hMi TU^f-^sfo, done af all ; th^y appeared
to ipe to'bein tSie same state.
Mr. Gt^Jw^Did'ytusee M^. G^6rte Sin-
i^lair at any time with Bit. Chalrles Siociair? —
Yes.
Did he say %ny thing' to you upon this
Mg^ ri)0tt4^ theip being tiea up loosely?—
recollect yourself. — I will. Hare patience^
Md I wiU itedllecf.
iard Jkstke Clerk.^Vfho is Mr. O«ot^
Sinclair ? — H^ i$ Mr, Sinclair of Bridee End.
f haVe some fiitnt- remembriMieethat'he said
something about an inventory, but I do not
l^edlleet that it was while I waa with Mr.
Charles Sinclair; I do not know but' it vras
ifltef they Were examined, T am not sore.
Mt Cleffc. — Was Mr. George Sinclair pre^
9eut when the inventory was taken?— ^Ift
was not in the sberiff^lerk's chamber that
day.
Did' yoQ ste Ml** George Sinclair either
btlbre or after taking the mventory ?— I saw
hhB' ^hal dm' that I was waiting with Mrl
Charles Sinclair ; and^ if I mistake not, he
was over at the office, but I think not the
dkythat die papeH were examined.
ttave vou any recollection of any thing of
this kind being said by Mr. Geor^ Sinclair?
-^I cannot ear; I cannot be positire; I am
ppon my oath, and I must be guarded in
etery resp^cl
Did he not tell you that it was wrong and
diUigeilHis not to inventory these papers
when they were seized? — To the best of my
recollection he said something, that it was a
|iity but' there had been an inventory, or
eomethmg of that nature.
• Ju^k Mttck'smmt, -Examined by Mr.
Montgomery,
Do you attend the sheriff-cletk's office ?—
;X^es.
,You are clerk>ther6?^Yes.
Were you present at the execution of the
warrant against William Skirving, secretary
Id the British convention ? — Wi.
Did you seethe papers found in hispos-
•l^on ? — ^Yes.
Was there an' inventory made of them ?—
Yes ; they were put into a bag, and sdUed by
Mr*. Dingwall ana Mr. Skirving.
Did you see the inventory of them P— I
came in while the declaration was making^
aM T saw the inventory made out.
Were' the papers acknowledged by Skir-
Ving?— ^Yes ; and the papers that were of no
conseqtience were given oack to him.
I)|d ne acknowledge these papers to be the
^tdfe thai were put into the bs^ ?— Yes;
Wet% you uifthe'sheti£Merk's office when
VOL. XXIII.
9oih(» papet9 were bhHighthi a trunk?-— Yes.*
Who brought them?-— I believe it was
James Lyon; AM messeitgo*^ lh^ tnink cama
intb liiy possession vety Sbon^ afkef.
Did you writ»an inyeatoi^ of thj» paperl
in that boii ? — ^Yesi
Were smy other papera brbdght bemde)
those that came Ito the boxP'^Therti vi*ere
aonle napers which came in a napMil.
Did you keep those papers ?—-Ye^.
Dkl you' keep thdm' locked up?^--Yds.
Did you- see an inventory made of thetjft
likewise P— Yes.
And 'they were in your possession till th^
inventory was made f— Yes, and after it too.
Lord JEtkgrove. — During the time it was
in your possession, were th^^ atiy papery
taken out or any put in ?i-^None'.
Mr. SoUeiior Generat,-^VlB9 it under your
lOtk and key all the time?^It wa^.
Mr. ilfon^f omisry.^-Have you the ehat|;e in
general of all the papers in that office ?^^Yes.
Is that the inventojy that \i^^toade up of
Mr. Sincldr's papers ? — It is;
Look at the bundle of papers and aee if
they are the papers in the inventory.— [Looks
over them.] My initials are upon the back
of every one of these papers.
Dd you see Mr. Scott's initisd^ upon them
likewise ?-^Yes, and Mr. Davidson's likewise.
Joseph IMack cross-examined by Mr. Clerk.
You spoke of some papers hditQ biK)n&ht
loose in a napkin. — ^W^re you' in the omc#
when tbev were brought?— I cannot say po^
sitively that I was in the office!, but I got
them soon after.
You cannot recollect then, nositively, who
put them into your hands ?— I Wieve I found
them in the sheriff^sroom-
Lord Justice Clerk. — ^Was th^ fi[heriff there
himself? — Mr. David ton, Mr. Scott, and Mr.
Dingwall were in the room.
Mr. Clerk, — ^Were they u^der the charge of
any particular pcfton ? — ^No; they wc^ ^ring
in the room, and I took them away.
I think you said these pap^irs wiett after-
. wards locked up ? — ^Yes.
When did you lock thcrt up f— After th*
examinations that day were fmish^d.
At what time was that?— I cannot exactly
recollect ; it might be about nine o^clock.
Lyon broufffat these papers Idbse in a nap-
kin, and the box was locked ? — Yes.
Lard Jtatice Clerkj—Aod the napkin wai
not locked? — ^No.
l^r. C/frAc.— Is it not usual when you seiae
papers to seal them up ? — ^Ves.
Were you present when the inventory was
taken ?7-Yes.
And Mr. Sinclair was present? — ^Yes.
Were you present when an objection waa
taken, either by Mr. Sinclair or for htm, upon
the ground that the papers were not sealed
'up ?-^I do not recollect it.
Do you itcoltect Mr. Sinclair's declaration
upon taking the inventory ?— Yes.
3 N
91 1] S4 GEORGE IIL Proeeedb^^gabia JmjA Gemtd
[91*
Now, tile fact is, that the dgrlartlinn b afn-
ed b/ Mr. Sinclair.
frifnot.— That is a circamstanoe that I
had forgotten.
. Mr. SoUeitor Genera/.— The lacl is, he
signed the first page of the dechuation, and
refused to sign the rest; that is the ftct.
James Lyon sworn. — ^Examined by Mr.
Montgomery,
Did you execute a warrant against Mr.
Gerrald and Mr. Mai]gaiot? — ^Yes ; I went
to the Black Bull to inquire for these gen-
tlemen ; the waiter acknowledged they were
in the house, but declined going with me to
their rooms; he told me the number of their
rooms, and the first room 1 went to was Mr.
Gerrald and Mr. Mai^arot's. I knocked at
the door, and thev desired me to come in,
which I did. I told them I had a warrant to
carry them before the sheriff; they were in
bed; they got up immediately; I collected
logether the papers that were in the room.
Mr. Margaret proposed putting them in a
trunkf and asked Mr. Gerrald if he would
put his into it, he consented ; they were wSl
put in, and Mr. Margarot took the key into
his possession. When he was coming away,
says he, '' I do not give you the trunk, you
may take it at your peril.'' I told him I was
not scrupulous about that, and immediately
gave the trunk to a chairman, to put it into
a coach. I kwked out Mr. Sinclair's papers
likewise, and took them at the same time.
. Speak to Mr. Gerrald*sand Mr. Margarot's
papers first. — I must rehearse this: when
we came to the sheriff-clerk's o£&ce in the
coach, I left the trunk and the other papers
in the office, and sent a message to^Mr. Scott
to inform him of what I had done, and then
I got a messa^ from him to briujg Mr. Sin-»
dur in a chair. I went to Mr. Smclair and
told him ; and theii there came a message
that they wondered I was so long ; and then
there came another message to let him re-
main at his lodging, which I did till between
9 and 10 o'clock at night.
When was the trunk opened ?— I think it
was two days afler.
Were you present when it was opened ?—
Iwas.
Who had the key ?— Mr. Margarot.
All the time ? — I know nothing to the con-
trary.
Was there any inventory made up of the
papers? — ^Yes, at the sheriff-clerk's office;
there was none made at their lodgings.
When the trunk was to be opened, Mr. Mar-
gjarot would not give up the key, and it was
proposed to get a smith to break it open, but
It was delayed that day. The Dext day Mr.
Margarot was brought before the sheriff-sub-
stitute and Mr. Scott; he said he would not
give it up, but held it in his hand, so [repre-
senting the manner of it], and said it must be
taken from him by force ; Mr. Scott was
going to take it from himi but Mr. Davidson
sttdao^ liem«ftnotdo it^ some oter body
must do it, and then Sfr. Mack gave a grip#
at ity and took it from him; it was then opec^
ed, an inventory was made^ and I put my
initials at the back of it
Look at these papers, and see if these ava
the papers you round in Mr. Gerrald's room.
— Yesy thy are; they have my initials upoo
them.
Was Mr. Sinclair in a separate room firooa
Mr. Gerrald and Mr. Margarot when you exe-
cuted the warrant?— Yes.
Were the papers separate ?— Yes.
AoA yeia brought them with you to tlia
sheriff-clerk*s office ?— Yes ; and Mr. Mai^gpb*
rot and Mr. Gerndd weie in the chanot
with me.
What did you do with Mr. Sinclair's pa-
pers?—I left tham in the sheriff-derk's office.
Were you present afterwards, when they
were opened? — Yes.
How long after, was it ?— I am not certaia;
it mieht be a few davs after.
Did they seem to be in the same situatian
as when you brought them into the office ?— r
They appeared to me so; they were in my
handkerchief, my name was in the handkes*
chief.
Were you present when the inventoiy of
them vras made out? — ^Yes.
Was Mr. Sinclair there ?— Yes.
Were any papers given back to him ? — Yjes.
Did he take them? — He took all that were .
given him, which was some that were mi
considered material to the business in hand.
Jama LyoHj cross-examined by Mr. Clerk.
You have said that you carried Mr. Sinclair^
papers to the office yourself ?<— Yes,
And left them there? — Yes.
Was there any objection made by any per-
son concerning the manner in which you nad
secured those papers in the sherittclerk'a
office^ or any where else?— did nobody tell
you It was exceedingly dangerous to keep
those papers unsealed up ?— I do not recol-
lect any such thing.
Did nobody say ituX other papers might be
ut in, that aid not belong to Mr. Sinclair? —
o the best of ray remembrance no person
stated any such thing: and, with humble
submission to you, my loid, I went firom th^
sheriff-clerk's office to bring off Mr. Sinclair,
and I was not back till 9 or 10 o'clock at
night, so that the papers were in the sheriffa-
office all that time.
Did you take any notice of Mr. Sinclair's
papers when you seized them^ — ^I found soma
of them lying upon the desk, and one paper
I cot lying below the bed.
Have you any other means of koo^nns
that these are the same but that' of kaevriDg
your own handkerchief? — Upon my waolS
do not think there was any thing elsa* .
Mr. Solicitor GeneraL-^Ai ttm *
clerk's office, did you deliver
body's custody ?-»*There weoo
«
tlSj
J^'^ wplwpfw^w
jfi. ]»: tiu.
Cdi4
8^K>tf8 dUiE» tliei%, -HlV. ilflcfcatad XTi*. IDing.
1^1^ bill I iTB^to lUtttifedl w«» Hot Ihe^, F
di^say, fi^nikiQliM^; b4i« I think P dbiMKi
IbeHl^ Oy tiak<» cttte'of tfa^n.
, A day or two afWvrardii^ WMtfn you sow
life fitttidte-' o)Mned>> lufd you aby'reBSon: to
1l>eUefe or susbeel- that any akeration had
b^' madls MbTo, done aV all '; th^y tq[(peMed
to me to be in tSie sai^e iftate.
' Mr.Otl{«Bii<^Dt<ry6useeM^. G^ree Sin-
<^lair at any time withBfr. Charies Sfaiclair? —
Yes*
Did he say s^dy thing' to you upon^ this
Mg^ ri)dtti^ thw beinje tied up loosely ?—
recollect yourself. — I wUl. Have patience-^
Mtttf I Will itedllecf.
L^^ TuHke C/eHb;-^Who is Mr. George
Sii^clatr ?— He is M)r. ^nchur of Bridjee End.
I'ilaVe 8omefttnt'femembriMi(»^that'he said
something about an inventory, but I do not
l^edlleet uiat it was while I waft with Mr.
Charles Sinclair'; I do not know but' it vns
#fler' they SAreie examined, I am not sore.
M^ C2erft.^ Was' Mr. George Sinclair |>re»
sent when the Inventory was taken f—Hfe
was not in the sberiff<lerk's chamber that
day,
Did^ yoti ste lifh George Sinclair eitW
b^lbreor after taking the mventory?— I saW
hha fiuil d^ thatiwas waStine with Mr'.
Charles Sinclair ; and; if I mistake not, he
was over at the office, but I think not the
dky that die pap^H were examined.
Have you any recollection of any thing of
this kind being said by Mr. Gebr^ Sinclair?
-^I cannot sar^ I cannot be positive;-! am
Vpon my oath, and I must be guarded in
every respect:
Did he not tell you that it w%s wrong and
^mg^eitHis not to inventory these papers
when they were seized f — To the best of my
reeoliection he said something, that it was a
|iity but' there had been an inventory, or
something of that nature.
' 'Jm^k Mack 9wom. -Examined by Mr.
Do you attend ^e sheriff-cletk's office ?—
tes. "^
,You are derkthert?— Yes.
Were you present at the execution of the
warrant agaUkst William Skirving, secretary
16 the British cdAvention ?— Yeii.
Did you seethe papers found in his pos-
session f — ^Yes.
Wks therfe an' inventory made of them ?—
Yes ; they were not into a bag, and siealed by
Mr*. Dingwall ana Hf. Skirvmg.
Did you ' see the inventory of them P— I
came in while the declaration w4s making^
aMI saw the inventory made out
Were' the papers acknowledged by Skir-
Vingf— ^Yes; and the papers that were of no
conseqtience were ^ven' oack to him.
Iji}d ne acknowledge these papers to be the
^tAe that were put into the bs^ ?— Yes.
Were youitf the shei'iff^erk's office \^hto
VOL. XXIII.
soihe papers were bhHight in a trunk'?— -Yes.*
Who brought themr— I believe it was
James Lyonim messenger; liia tnmk came
intb liiy possession very Sbon> aAer .
Didyou writean inveiitoi^ of the paperl
in that bos ^— Yes.
Were smy otKer papers brdUght be^es
those that came ita the boxMTheni vi*eie
sonle itapers which came in a naj^il.
Did you keep those papers ?---Ye^.
Did ybu'keep them locked up?^--Y^s.
Did you'See an inventory made of thetjtfi
likewise P— Yes.
And'they werein yoiu' possession till th^
inventory was made iU~Yes,-and after it too.
Lord Eskgrote. — Durmg the time it was
in your ]k>ssession, were th^ akiiy papers
taken oqt or any put in ?i-^None.
Mr. Solicitor Oeturtd.^-'W^ it imder your
Idcfc and key all the time?^It wa»;
Mr. Montsoniery.'-^fixve you the ehatge in
general of all the papers in that offlee?^^Yes.
Is that the inventory that wai^^nde up of
Mr. Sinclair's papers ? — It is;
Look at the bundle of papers and see if
they are the papers in the inventory.— [Looks
over them, j My initials are upon the back
of every one of these papers.
Do you see Mr. Scott's initials upon them
likewise ?•— Yes, and Mr. Davidson's likewise^
Josepk Mack cross-examined by Mr. Clerks
You spoke of some papers bcfhi^ b^n^ht
loose in a napkin. — ^Were you' in the omc^
when they were brought ? — I cannot say poi>
sitively that I was in the office, but I got
them soon after.
You cannot recollect then, positively, who
put them into your hands ?-"I oelieve I found
them in the sheriff^s room.
Lord Justice CUrk. — ^Was the sheriflF there
himself? — Mt, Davidton, Mr. Scott, and Mr.
Dingwall were in the room.
Mr. Clerk. — ^Were they under the chuge of
any particular peHon ? — ^No; they wc^ lying
in the room, and I took them awaiy.
I think you said these papei^ wetfe aSler-
. wards locked up ? — ^Yes.
When did you lock thcrt up f— After th*
examinations that day were finished.
At what time was that?— I cannot exactly
recollect ; it might be about nine o^clock.
Lyon broufffat these papers Idbse in a nap-
kin, and the box was locked ? — Yes.
Lord Jtatice Clerkj—And the napkin wai
not locked? — ^No.
Afr. Clerk, — Is it not usual when you seise
papers to seal them up ? — ^Ves.
were you present when the inventory wa6
taken ?— Yes.
And Mr. Sinclair was present?— Yes.
Were you present when an objection was
taken, either by Mr. Sinclair or for htm, upon
the ground that the papers were not sealed
up ? — =1 do not recollect it.
Do you recollect Mr. Sinclair's declaration
upon taking the inventory ?-« Yes.
3 N
915]
54 GEORGE III.
ProceedtMgM agahM Jo§eph Gtrraid
[9ie
What did he say when this was doing? —
He seemed veiy easy upon the busiiiess, and
behaved very much like a gentleman
Did he say the papers were his ? — He did
not deny that they were his ; he took back
the papers that were returned to him.
Did he say any thing about a protest ?**
Yesy he offered to take a protest, and Mr.
Davidson told him it was not usual to receive
protests in diese cases.
Upon what ground did he offer to take a
nrotest? — Because his papers were taken
from him, as he imagined illegally.
John Dingwall sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Montgomery.
Were you present at a search made in Mr.
Skirving's house for papers? — ^Yes.
Did you find any papers there? — ^Yes.
Were they put into a bag in your presence?
— Thev were put into two bags.
And were tney sealed ? — ^Yes.
In Mr. Skirving's presence? — Yes, I put
my seal upon one end, and he put his seal
upon the other.
Did you see those ba^s afterwards ? — Yes.
Where?— In the sheriff- clerk's office.
Ix>ok and see if these are any part of them ?
— liiis paper, or scroll of minutes, I found
lying upon the table in Mr. Skirving's room.
Did you see an inventory made up of these
papers ?— Yes.
tt was fairly made up ? — ^Yes.
Did you assist in making it up ? — ^I made
out Mr. Skirving's declaration.
Were you present when Mr. Sindur's
papers were brought into the sheriff-clerk's
Mce ?— No.
Thama» Cockhum swom.-^£xamined by Mr.
AnUrmtker.
Did you belong to the society of the Friends
of the reople ?--I was a memner of that so-
cietv.
Were you a deleflite to the convention
that met in Edinburgh in October last? — Yes.
Did you attend that that afterwards met in
November? — Yes; the British convention.
What was the occasion of the meeting of
the second convention in November ? — The
occasion, so far as occurs to me was, the ar-
rival of some delegates from England.
Was the panel at the bar one of those de-
legates from England, in consequence of
whose arrival that second convention met ? —
I dways understood that Mr. Gerrald was
one of them.
When you first met in October^ what did
you call yourselves ? — ^The convention of the
friends of the People; and afterwards the
British Convention, as I understood, but I
was not present at the time.
Did you attend frequently? — I attended
freauentlv, and was absent frequently.
And wnat title did you give each other ?—
There were various designations, but citizen
was the one they most commonly used.
When you were divided lata smaller bodies
what did you odl yourselves ?*--They were
first, I think, denominated diviaons ; after-
wards sections, and there was another name
which I do not recollect.
What name were they most frequently
called by ? — I do not recollect at present.
Do yon recollect any institution of what
was called Primary assemblies; — ^No.
Do you recollect their being divided into
Primary Societies ? — ^No.
Did you ever hear departments mentioned?
— -I do not recollect. *
Had you different kinds of committees ap-
pointed ? — ^Yes.
Do you recollect the names of any of those
committees ? — ^I think there was one of them
designed the committee of union.
Had you any committee of organization ?^>
I think there was.
Was there any that took charge of your
money matters ; how viras tiiat Signed ?^-
They were not very regular; but there was a
committee instituted for that purpose, which
was usually called the committee of finance.
And likewise committees of instruction ? — I
do not recollect that.
For instructing different parts of the king-
dom, such as the Highlands, and giving them
political knowledge?— There was a motion, I
recollect, for promoting constitutional know-
led^.
Do you recollect that there was a commit-
tee for that purpose ? — So &r as I recollect at
present there was mention made of a com-
mittee for promoting constitutional know-
ledge.
Had you likewise a committee of secrecy ?
— ^It may be called a committee of secrecy,
but there was no name that I know of given
to it by the convention.
Which carried on its proceedings more j^ri-
yately than the other committees, from which
it got its name, I suppose of a committee of
secrecy? — Yes.
When you met what did you call your
meetings?— They were most frequentiy called
Sittings ; but I paid very litUe attention to
that circumstance.
Did you ever hear of any person who had
deserved well getting the honours of the sit-*
ting ?---I think I have heard in one of the
committees some such thins of a single per-
son ; humorously it might have been men-
tioned by some numourous man, and I do
not doubt but it might he taken down in the
minutes, but those minutes were never au-
thenticated by tlie convention, because it
was designed that they were to have a conr-
mittee to revise them. ,
Lord Eskgrove, — Was any person, a stranger,
ever admitted to a sitting in the convention '^
— All I recollect is, that the honours of the
sitting were mentioned.
• Lord Etkgrave. -^To the best of your recol-
lection, was any stranger ever allowed to si$
in the convention, upon a motion of that
917]
Jbr StdUwn.
sort?— I do fiot recollect. I thiDk I recoiled
it was rather honourable mention tlian ho-
nours of the sitting that I heard.
' Mr. AnHruthtr^ — ^When you received pe-
cuniary assistance, was honourable mention
made of it? — It is that that occurs to my re-
collection most, but I cannot be very positive;
I only recollect something of the word ho-
Bourable mention, or soipething of that na-
ture.
How did you date your proceeding on
what took place in the convention P Did you
take the year of God in the common way, or
in any other way? — I cannot recollect.
Did you ever hear of the first yeat of the
British convention, for example?^— I cannot
recollect; I never looked in the minutes.
Was it not the practice in the convention
to read over the subsequent day what passed
the day before ? I was not there till the bu-
smess of the day was generally over.
Did you never hear what was the manner
of their daUn^ their minutes?—! do not re-
collect any thmg about it ; I cannot say either
one vrav or the other ; I was seldom present
when that business was done ; but I once re-
member hearing it read before the conven-
tion went to busmess.
Lord Jutiiee CUrk, — Have you no recoUee-
lion of hearing of the first year of the Britisb
convention? — I think I i^member hearing
something of that kind ; but I cannot say
iipon what occasion.
Mr. Anstruiher,-^JM yoii ever see the
panel there ? — ^Yes.
Did he frequently speak there?— Not so
iirequently as others.
Did he ever act as preses ? — ^I do not recol-
lect ever seeing him act as chairman in my
life.
Did you ever see him act as chairman at
any of the committees ?»I was not a mem-
ber of any of the committees.
Did you happen to be present at a meeting
on the 81 St ot November, when the measure
of a general meeting of the Scotch and £ng-
Ush delegates was proposed ?-~There was a
committee of union appointed to draw up
regulations with respect to the people in
England and the people in Scotland, whose
minds mieht be one, with respect to the sub-
ject of reform, in order that they might be
united in their endeavours.
Do you recollect upon that occasion the
panel at the bar makme a speech ? and you
say he made a few speeches, so that ^ou will
be the better able to recollect ? — I said he did
not speak so ft-equently as some.
Do you remember that speech? — ^I think
there was a conversation one evening with
respect to the union, and to the best of my
jeoollection he did speak upon that occasion ;
I was there part of the time.
' Were you at that time in the practice of
reading the Gazetteer when published?— I
lised to read part of them.
Did you read thai in which Mr. Gerrakl's
A. D. 179^ [918
speech appeared, of which you say you heard
a part? — I cannot say but I mieht nave seea
it, but at this distance of time f can say very
little about it. I make no doubt but I read
it.
Did you think that the account you saw
in the paper agreed with what you heard in
the meeting? — Mv memory is not so tena-
cious as to recollect a long speech; I cannot
be very positive.
But in substance did it appear to you to be
the same that was delivered by Mr. Gerrald?
— All I can say is, that I am ready to give a
candid answer to any thing that I Icnbw ; but
as to what may be read from a newspaper, I
cannot say.
Mr. Solicitor General. — The question iSy
whether the account given in the Gaaetieer
agreed with what you heard in the conven-
tion ? — So far as I recollect, I did not observe
any thing remarkably deficient in it.
Look at that paper and read it. — ^With re-
spect to newspapers, 1 hope the Court wiif
allow roe this, wnich I think is fair, that any
question that is put to me, .or read to me, I
snail endeavour to eive a nor answer ; but as
for reading it, I wilfnot be concerned with it.'
Mr.AiutnUher, — ^Wereyou present when a
motion was made, by Mr. Callender, to this
purpose, '' that in case the minister, or any
other member, bring into the House of Com-
mons a motion for a convention bill, as
passed in Ireland, for preventing the people
from meeting according to their just rients
by the revolution, the same motion shall be
noticed to the delegates of the respective so-
cieties, immediately to meet in convention to
assert their rights ?— To the best of my recol-
lection, I heard a motion of Mr. Callender's
read one night to that purport.
Was that motion made the subject of dis-
cussion at a future meeting ? — ^I do not recol-
lect being present upon that business till it
was taken up as a report returned from a
committee.
Who was it that read that report? — ^I think
it was Mr. Sinclair.
Did you read those parts in which the mi-
nutes of this convention were given an ac-
count of? — Yes.
Was any resolution adopted in the conven-
tion in consequence of this re|)ort? — So far as
I recollect, the convention conversed up-
on the report a long time ; and, if I remem-
ber right, they agreed, that in case of a con-
vention bilL similar to that which had passed
in the parliament of Ireland, being brought
into the parliament of England, that that
should be considered as a reason why they
should hold a meeting, which was mentioned
as a meeting of emergency.
Did you near of any other cases in which
they were to meet? — I think there were
others in the report; but I am not able to
say positively whether they were taken into
the consideratk)n of the convcntbn.
Do you recollect any other cases ?-*! think
IM^ M GSi9iKGJi& IS* Proceedhgs liffAuf Jof^
C^S»
one of ilbmi WW » ^isp^naiom of Ui> gabe^a | otMOB^iKAatfihfeaaMiM^i^^
And I think there way JDeotWn pftsM?— So w «s I ^moUoo^ V^. 4;mnl|
^orpusact;
naoe of the laiid\iD^ of foreign troops^ or » fo*
t^m invasion, I «mi not certain wnich.
ijori Justice Ckrk.—Did you think they
omht Aot be both used? — I cannot say.
Sir. idfufni^^er.— What tioof» did you sup-
pose 4ho8e foreign troops were? — 1 cannot
9^y i .^t ipight be the troops of fuoy i^ountry ; it
was in a general sense.
. Did you suppose they were to meet won
tlie landing of trootps who w^tp our aUios^
though 4aot firitish troops ; A>r tfistanc^ ties^
siansajui Hanoverians ?'-^s to ikhe intenlion
of that, it is what I cs^piB^ enter into.
Upon the oath you have now takeat did
you hear -that t^e jconveoJion were 4o ^eet
uypon the landing of HcssisAS or Uanoyerians
in this country? — I cannot recollect.
You )iav;C anentioned thiee cases of emer*
^ncy ; was any nention made of ibe sttspen-
sioa of the act for preventing wrongous w-
prisonment? — I do not recollect.
Wher^ were they W meet?-r-I knpw aot.
Who was to fix the place of meeting ?-^To
the best of my re^ocUon, lihere was tkcom-
xnijLUe appointed lor that purpose.
Were tjo^y to keep it secret till it ha|i|»eaod f
—They were aot to tell it ; there was a qobA?
d^njUal trust reposed in #> few, that th^y wete
to fix the pl^uce ^d &d4 ways and oieaas.
Was th^e any meig^tioa of sealed letters
bijeio^ delifered to them, fikiog ttie pllkoe of
laeeiing, which weriB aot to he opened till dor
livered tw the delc^^MJOS to their constituents?
-^ tbink I heard ^ ^oeation n^de of sealed
letters* but then I do npt say that tb^t waa
the nsode that was dejtermin^.
. Wh^ numbj^ WM U) proceed Do bo^uMM
in case of these events happening ?*r-I caiiaot
be positive upon that sut^ect.
W^ this resolution come to in ^ vore so-
Umn manner than any other resohitioos ia
the cooArention ?-T-So far iss I recollect, the
convention deliberated upon it in ^ very de»
ceat, serious roaiuier; and at last, tiiey re-
solved it standing;.
They all .stood up, to declare their purpose
of cariyins it into execution more solemnly
than usual? — We all stood up ; and I thinly
we did so upon another occasioB.
Dp you recollect what that other occasion
was ? — I rather have heard of it tha^ w^ pre-
sent at it.
Was it at the propos^ for a uikipn f-r-I was
npt present.
Or upon tbeir chan^ng the deaigaation of
thei^ meeting to that of the Britiso Goavea-
tion ? — I was not preseat,
Did they, in passiag this resolution, declare
before God ana the world, that they would
do so and so? — ^I recollect th^ expressions be-
fore God and the world were made us^ of.
Did you ever hpar such solemn expressioas
Iliads |ise of upoa aay other occasions ?-r»I do
B(it recollect.
Did the panel mako a (ipqa^b upMi th^t 9*
Old speak, after the resohitioa.
Did you fa^ attei^n to his .spcie<^?*—
Yos.
Did you aftarwtKls «Q^d ^^ BpQ9(^ ia tha
Gaoetteer ?--I do 90i doubt but X ai^l^ ia
readine the Gaietteer.
Ana did the acoouAt 4a the Goaet^eor 9Wcb
dififbr from what you had heard ?— I can fMf
no .move than I h9.ve already aaid, that } «|id
not observe any thing xe«w^kably fpronewa
ia-it.
Was it a cool delibm^te lapd of speech, or
W9a it warm and anim^d ?— I do not nool-
lea; but Mr. Gevsakl spake ia 1»^ usual
tone.
THoinai Cocibfti^ni cross-esamiaed by Mr.
Ckrk.
You said you were a s^eaibtf of the mnh
ipantioo; what did you uaderstand to b« tiie
paijposes lor which they iniet?t-The puiyeita
iV gieaeral, for vftifh the oaavention oi^
was a reform ia the British fii^Mse of Cobl-
mo^s.
By what meaas dU the cooveation iatead
to accomplish this reform? — ^The meaas, s0
fiv as I understood, that they iateodod ia use
was, to endeavour to ooliect the minds ff th*
people who were of tbe •eauxe Qpinion^ aad, ^^
legal methods, . lo obtain tber ohjed, m a.
peaceable manner, so far 9s I aaderstood.
Were they to oetition {MurUameut ?— It was
agreed upon in the convention, lis I uadsr-
sjtood, in Qclober ; but I wsis aot present.
What did vou understand to be the ol^ocl
of the Bivtish convanftpan which a«Dt in No-
vao^ber.'-rl understood aothiag es^ajUaiiy'
different from tbe convention that metb^
fore; the only diflereoce was the accessjoa
of a number of delegates from England ; thair
design I anderstooalo be the same.
You have been asked, whether Mr. Gerraid
made a speech upon the 91st of November;
now I beg leave to read it over to you, ami
then tell me if you recollect Mr. GerraM
making such a speech? — If there are aay
words that I recollect I shall tell you.
Mr. Bumeti.-^Ht has already said^ thil
whea he read the Gaac^eer, there was aor.
thing essentially dififereot
Mr. Clerk.— lie said, that he senerally read
the Gaaettcer, and he perceived notliing le-
markably d^ficient; he spoke geoerally. I
have not yet heard the witness say, tliat ha
heard Mr. Oerrald oiake this speedi^ whidh
seems to be pnocipaliy founded on in the ithn
dictment ; and therefore X conceive it neces-
sary, that the fact should bo asaefftaiaedy
whether the witness heard that apeecht ye*
or not
Mr. Solicitor GeneraL^ini can certainly haira.
noolyeetion, exqept this, that the witi^NS has
been eirqTwiatd oa the part of the prosecutar/^
and has given all tha aasiKsrs that ha
»l]
^&Amii»
A« s. a7».
Hm
^0A I 4h^ xaake to Ihe ^eaUoipen «f Ihe
jury ; tliat this wilness bi» ftk^finded -QjciKfyiU
0MelAO88'Of>ihe4x>DV6&tioB,«iid wihpn he sras
tho^ ^r- Gerrald mtde Aoave flpeedhiB^
^kJwougb ooit a» mwg as some ojterfieepl^
^; and fa|p teUt you h|B vm iaaductd ip md
4he iOazetteer, at least, sp far m lelaAiod lo
the ;Moeefl^Usg8 ^f Mm QaDvealMn. Hhe
flpeedies mMte j^»«iiii^t ane ^ub]i»tafid ia tbe
Qiwetteor to<«iQpvpW| «Bd I w>ould 4t6k ^mh^
tb^MT ttiat wit6^8'« fiooifwcaUne view «/ tbe
Meec)ies at iha^ tme, lor «» loag ftter^ i» vuMiik
Mkelytoberight.
lAr. J^^Atf n^Ife sap theva wm uttll^g
semarkikbly «rH>nef«i»: smmt 4ha(t mpjmmmv io
me clearly to imply that there ^vaarwnn^thmg
J>4 JuK^ice i;iedb.-^It does tto -stick «hia|^
I^id ^l^4erfimj|f.»<^Th€ wmt that I hmt
^^n k d#iw is tkiS) thffct ibie ifid Mil ekssms
any thing remarkably deficient or erroMtiB
Ip iHe 4»«MM3he$ its the 4^a«et«tff»r; thetlhe
^pe0 iK>i douki biit }» vsof have iMsd it ia
S Gazetteer, and did not recoUect^MJMsa-
al xKfteMSH)^.
Mr. J/«r<;4er.*-0^(}Hr knM^p <v«U atif^
to explain my meaning': the w^rde J»e, itiwt
ke obaeM)^ ii^lbisig irsmarkslUy «rr««caii8 ;
I puhmt j» your loiial^, Md ta-emsif smu
vh9 bears jme, if ihat tdees «at ttnflf ikat
tftiere wys sosaeitbisig eff!o»eDus; it«a»/ shere-
iore happen, ihait upoa ceadkig %mfw is lAie
vitAeas, ke ociay say th«t ihpae fStfts ebsr^
as most criminsu are erroneous.
. Lord Ju9tiae C/crft.-^i deity Afae teockisvn
Mr. Fletcher has 4rawxi from his fnesoirBeB;
ihe plaki vioajiiiig ia, •!»& Chcae was •• re-
WsrkaWe dilfemsce.
Mr. Gillies. — It is certekily tme» that his
aecollecfeioo •must haVe been more accaimte
theo th»a at present; hut this is equally ine,
that the witness, havine just heard theee
speeehes, wotild oot reao them with that et-
tiattion diat he might if he new read ibem e
ftr m wm share, in such circumstances I
itoild isot have nead it at ^tt.
Lord Justice Clerk. — I think the witness's
own idea of the floatter is very different t he
says, he Dead over the Gazetteer aSad /observed
nothinjg remarkably deficient. What do your
lerdships say ? 4haU it be read, yea or nay 9
Lord Hemierland.-^l do sot see anv paiv
tkailar veasoo wi^ it should not be Teal.
^r, SoUcltor-GeneraL^ljSi the v^itness «ad
it himself.
No, I beg to besKCHaedi I think I ahould
famember it better by hearing it laad tba& by
Madiug it.
{The clerk of the court then read the spc^li
'^dm the Gazetteer]
Mr. C/er%. — Do you ncollect reading the
speech you have now heard b tha Gaaetteer?
— ^I thksk; so fiff «e I sacoUecty tfaatjt ia Iba
l^ojrau 4bioic4A has miststod anviUMM; Aat
WB ^oaHverad da the 4pMBKkf— 4. ^ii^ if
the ooarse of iieadine,IrecoUeotA:£Be«t«iM[y
words interspersed trough this speech, that
I MQoUect Mr. Gemld mke JB'the soiiose of
a speech one eveovig^ ihut Iido tnatateao fto
id^tifjr Ihe whokiyfSech.
You moBtiQBad-ajnotioa«tf''Mr.'Oallander*a
wben you ware pseseatiuJibflafdA-aMttfMS
anade wbdoh I oindecstood >ito be a jnolkkO of
Mr. Callender's.
It wm xead fto ^ou tfrcanUhe indictasent, 'but
I shall read it to fouL i|gpiift«-J<^Ihsetin<QMB
lbesoHaQ0tor9"te. [nadsihejoMitionfraai the
iodktfneot. j<-4 tbkk voa said, 4o >the boat
of your aeniimfaraiic^ ahis was the subatanoa
of the 4BsojUcii j^ou bMod^wY^.
I shall now read it iJNNtt tbO'imnutes of Abe
eonvention; *< l*hat jn case fhe jninister
bring into the Ccffomona ttonse trf^Parliament
aiooliooioroflaovontiaabil^ JtabaUbeno*
ticed immediately to the delcgatas." ¥«att«iil
observe 4hi6 as a oucb ohorter inolioQp «nd
something different; now which of Ibese^
aocordim to yoor ffqaoUsotiaa waa Ibe oieal
owytioD ^o boaid at ^ftirs iicsef-^Wko bad
the management of the business I joanaot
say ; but the thing that <was ifrst read 4raS si-
mihuT'lo what i b^rd.
lifr. S^UciUtr Oenetal^yu, Clerk has bad
ooe speecb oead to this :||flntlefaaB» Iidasira
that the other osay be i^A^ voA he ibHU aay
wheither he racoUects aof naierial rcrrara.
I^nie -clerklfttGn read the otfher speech firom
ibetjazetteer.^
Mr. Solicitor Genera/.— Now, ss this acaify
tlio MiUattce ? or do you socollaet any great
difierenoe f — I recollect €oneidemU|r 1|BSS of
that than I doof the other ; Ihe begmaiiig of
it I do not recollect at ail.
Lord Justice Clerk, — Did you read the Ga»
zaUoer when it was first puhiiabed ?— I was ia
the habit ofreadiat the Gaaetteer.
Lorjd JuMiee CUrk^-^i gives me great pies'!
sure to hear a witness, who was a meanlMr ot
a convention like this, eve his evidence fiudy,
like on honest man ?-«3 wash the gentlemen
of the jury to understand that I have not
identified the speeches in the Gazetteer.
Mr. Soliiitor Generml.-^Vfe know yoo faav^
not; nor shall any body say that you have.
A|r. Cieric —I observe • f^aat many sen-
tences in this indictment printed in italics;
and I take notiee of this, that the juryjooay
be upon their guard, aod aotsuffer tbenualvaa
to bo misled by that meaaa.
Mr. iSo/icftor General^^lL is very wrongs
that there was any part of it printed m itattcs,
and how it happened I do not know ; but all I
can say is, .to desive the genttemea of tha jury
to pay no regard to them*
Alexander Aitcheton sworn.
Lord DumintHm.'^'Hoa any body olTe^
you any lowar^l, or promise of reward^ for
giving evideoce here ?•— None.
999]
M GEORGE III. ProeeeStigi agMnH Jouph GerraU
19U
Has any body told you or instnicied yoa
what to say ? — ^Ir his majesty himself had in-
structed me what to say, I would not have
regarded it.
Have you any malice or ill-will aj^ainst the
fratnel at the bar ?— No, for from it ; I con-
sider him as a second Lrcuaous, a voluntary
exile for the good of his country, and for the
same reason too ; — a wish to give a better code
of laws to his countrymen than they have
hitherto enjoyed.
You were a member of the British conven-
tion ? — ^Yes, I had that honour.
Lord l>»nimfuiA.r— You will remember that
whatever you may say regarding your own
conduct, you cannot be made an object of
prosecution for. — ^My fiunily is doubtRss ob-
liged to the public prosecutor.
Examined by Mr. Amtrutker,
You were a member of the convention of
October? — ^Yes.
That was given up f — Yes, after they had
tat four days.
• When was it returned again ? — ^I do not at
present recoUect, but it was some time in No-
vember.
Were you a delegate ?— Yes.
Did not you j^ve in a resignation ? — ^Yes, I
gave in my resignation, as I had not time to
attend regularly, but it was not accepted, and
I did therefore attend occasionally.
What was the occasion of their meeting
the second time ?~Because ^e delegates
from England did not arrive in time enougl^
and therefore we were oiled together again
upon their arrival.
Who were those delegates ?— There were
four or five of them *. there was citizen Mar-
earot, citizen Yorke,* who I believe has since
oied abroad, citizen Browne, citizen Sinclair,
and the panel at the bar.
When you first met in October, and after-
wards in November, by what designation did
you pass ?— The convention of delegates.
Did you change that designation r--Yes, to
4;hat of the British convention.
What was the purpose of your meeting?-^
To obtain a reform in parliament, by annual
parliaments and universal suffiraee.
Who acted as secretaiy ?— Citizen Skir-
▼in£.
Had he any assistant ^— Yes, I had that
honour.
Did you firequenily attend in that capacity i
^-I did, as often as I could.
Ware there any minutes of the proceedings/
-r-Yes, there was a scroll of minutes.
Should you know them again ?— Yes, cer-
tainly.
. You wrote part of it j;ourtelf?— Yet.
Wat it not the practice in the British con-
vention always on the subsequent day, to
*Yorke was not ttien dead; be waa in
1795 tried at York for • conspirwy. See bis
t
read over the minutes of what passed the day
befi>re? — It was the general practice, but waa
sometimes neglected.
Were there ever any observations or re-
marks made ?•— Corrections were firequentiy
suggested at the time, and other corrections
were delayed till the conunittee should meet
to correct the whole
From what you know of those minutes,
that you had occasion to take down yourself,
do you think the account they gave was a fair
and. accurate account ^— As far as my me-
mory could serve me, though no doubt I may
have made many mistakes.
Had you occasion to hear the minutes read
over, ot what passed wh«i you were present ?
—Yes, frequently.
Did the pand at the bar frequently attend
the meetings of the convention? was he
constantiy attending ?-*Whether he was con-
stant or not I cannot say ; 1 have seen him
there.
Did betake an active rart in the business ?
—He took an active, and a very public spi-
rited part.
Dia he act as preses or chairman ? — ^I do
not recollect his being called to the duur, I
rather think he was not.
* Do you recollect, on any of the nights that
you attended the ih-itish conventiou, any pn>«
posal having been made for a union between
the delesates of the two countries, England
and ScoUand ? — Some such proposal I believe
was made when I was absent, but I think I
heard of it
Did you come in during the evening when
itwascanvatsed?— Yes^ I did.
Did you hear any thing of a committee of
unk>n to be appointed ?—! heard that there
was such a thing |»roposed.
You were not in when the proposal waa
made?— I am not certain, but I ratner think
not
Were you present when the panel made
any speech? — ^I was present when he made
several ; and I was told he had made many
when I was absent, which I regretted that I
had not heard.
Do you remember that he made any upOQ*
this proposal of union ?— I cannot cfavge my
memory with it.
If you came in, in the course of the niebt^
when the proposal was made, it is possible
you may recollect ?^I came in upon this oc-
casion, while Mr. Gerrald was speaking.
If the speech, or a part of it, was read to
you, you could possibly tell whether it was
accurate or not? — ^I cannot say»
Take a elance over that paper, and tell us
if you recollect it? — I think you had better
show me the indictment : he certainly is not
indicted upon the newspaper account [looks
it over ] I think I can say that I recollect
nothing of it but these words, '< The voice of
the people may be wrong when their under-
standings are perverted by inrietlcraft, or dark-
ened by political toperstition, like the voice
985]
Jer SidiAm^
A. D. 1794.
t9S6
ence heard id Jtmutleta of cnicify him, cni-
cify him." The striking allittion that was
made by the panel to that important transac*
^xmf makes me recollect it. As to any thing
else that passed that evening I cannot recoE
lect. Itnink I came in a little before this
part of the speech.
Do you think that was the night on which
the motion for a anion ¥ras canvassed ? — ^I
cannot say.
Did you read the Gazetteer at that time ? —
Not when Uiey were published; I had very
little time.
Do you recollect after this, a anotion being
made m the convention, said to be a motion
of Mr. Callander's, in the followine words^ or
words of a similar import [reads Callander's
motion from the indictment?] — I donotre->
collect whether I was present at that time or
Bot ; I know that such a motion ¥ras made by
If r. Callender.
Do you know if it was referred to a com-
mittee to make .any amendments or altera-
tions ?^Yes.
Was there any report ? — Mr. Callender was
very much enrsLged that his motion was not
adopted precise)^ in his own words.
By whom was the report given in ? — ^I can-
not sav.
Look at that [Callander's motion in the
minutes.]— That is my hand-writing.
That reeards the motion we are now talk-
ing of? — ^xes, it does.
Look at Chat [Mr. Sinclair's amendments^]
it seeems to have been in your possession,
and marked in your hand- writing ? — ^Yea,
Mr. SolicUor General, — That is one of the
papers that was found in Sinclair's posses-
sion.
Witnets — It was handed to me as assistant
secretary.
Mr. AfuinUlier, — ^Were you present when
this amended resolution was discussed, and
did you continue there during the evening ?—
I cannot say, I rather think not ; for almost
every evening I was obliged to go away upon
the business of a respectable gentleman.
Do you recollect having been present at
that convention, when there was any proposal
to burn a motion ?— I think I recollect it.
Whom was that motion made by?— Mr.
Sinclair. I opposed it, because we haa hither-
to done every thing with openness and candor.
Do you recollect the nature of that motion
that was proposed to be burnt ? — ^I think it
related to the calling a convention of emer-
gency.
Ha4 you any idea of. the reason why he
made such a proposal ?— Owing to some arbi-
trary stretches of power that had been tiireat-
ened.
Do you remember a motion made by citizen
Margarot, of the following import : << That a
Secret Committee of Three, and the Secretary
be appointed," &c. [Reads it from the in-
dictment]? Was any resolution adopted for
e^rrying that ipto execution? Was there a
conunittaa appointed ?— I believe there was a
committee of three or four.
By what name waa it called P— A Committee
of Kmergency.
In what cases was this committee to assemi
ble the convention?—! believe one was in
case any illegal attempt should be made to
(hsperse the convention. Another occasion
was in case of a foreign invasion ; and I heard
next day that another was, in case the Ha-
beas Corpus act happens to be suspended, or
the act for preventmg wrongous imprison-
ment. In any of these cases the convention
of emergency were to meet.
How was this convention of emergency to
be assembled ? — I know of no particuEir mode
in which they were to be assembled. • -
Do you recollect what number tiiey were
to consist of ?•— There were just three, and
the. secretary appointed on this business.
You had no idea of the place where the coo*
vention were to meet ? — ^No.
That was kept secret ?— Yea.
And this4o the best of your recollection,
was the motion proposed to be burnt f — Yes.
You said the reason of proposing that mea-
sure, waa, that some arnitrary stretches of
power had been made?-— No, they had not
Deen made; they were only threatened.
Do you recollect how yo«) generally desig-
nated each other in th^ convention? — We a^
dressed each other in different modes, very
often Sir, very often Mr. such a thing, fre^
fluently Citizen; and I recollect farther, that
tne person who. introduced the word fellow-
citizens among us, was a very respectable
young noblenum, lord Daer ; and he used it
singly for a long time, like the man who
waUced near thirtv years with an umbrelU
over his head, and nobody followed his ex-
ample.
When you were divided into smaller par-
ties, what were they called ? — They were first
called divisions, and then classes, aflerwards
the word sections was adopted as preferable.
Did you ever use the word sittings ? — ^Yes ;
and I suppose you call this a sitting of the
court of justiciary.
You had in your official capacity an oppor-
tunity of seeine papers given in ; how were
they dated ?— Variously, according to the
fancy of the writer.
Here is one dated firom Liberty Court —
Very good; — ^but, my lord, what objection
have you to the word Liberty Court? Is the
very name of Uberty become unpopular ? A nd
here is another dated Liberty Stairs. Now.
my lord, we have a number of new titles, ana
new streets, both in Edinburgh and Leith. 1
have been in Merehant-stree^ where I believe
no merehant ever lived, and where I am sure
there is not a single merchant's shop ; I have
been in Quali^-street,' where not a person of
quality rc^es ; I have been in Princes-street,
where a prince never walked ; I have been in
Queen-street, where her most gracious ma-
jesty never set her foot Besides these, we
9tTi M GfifflSGS K. Proeeedit^t agtlnttjm/i GenaU
am
St. JamesVsqiiare^ St. PfttHck-stieeCy^-—
Im^Jmhce Cln^A.-^-What is^all thi» idle
harangue to the purpose ?^My. lord, I must
aagFV i^ ^ exceedingly improper (I be^ pardon
ibr- Mying it)^ to intemipt a- man upon oath.
It ie surprising, that the words Liberty Court
ahonld IDkb found' fault with, when we have se
flMay new^treetaflamed after saints, ahhough
the jnajoitty of their inhabitants, so far from
hein^ saints^ are in raallty of the flwhionable
reiieion^ that ia the FVench reHgion, as your
lor£hiB perhaps would call it, or in plain
English, of no religion at all. It is certainly
l^tiper to sive a oourt that had no name, the
naine of liberty; nothing seditious- can be in-
ferred from it, any more than any thing su-
perstitious oan be drawn from the streets
named'affenthe Roman Catholic saints.
Lord Jutiice Clerk, — ^You are not' come
lMett> eive dissertations, dther on one side
or the other: you are to answer to faets^ ac-
cording to the best of your recollection, and
«ccordmg to the. great oath you have taken,
answer the ^ts that are asked of you. — My
lord, I wish to pay all due respect to your
krdfthip and thisv^ourt, but I ■ consider mysdf
as-in the presence not* only of your lordship,
but tUso as iiTthe presence of the King of longs
and Lord of lords ; and therefore, aa bound
by my oath^ to say every thing that 1 can ooo-
alstently with truth, to exculpate this- pand^
-vfao I am sure is an innocent man.
Mr. SoUeUor Genera/.— -Many thines* yon
Itave now said, will, in my opinion, teaS'to do
oiore hurt than good to the 'panel.
If»fiieif.-^f thatj the gentlemen of the
juiT vnll iudg^.
Lord frntHceCterh-^MT. Solicitor General,
it is needless tb put airf' more- questions tb
this man.
Mh SoUdk^r Genetm,-^ shall putnomore,
my lord.
[The witness waatben ordered to with*
draw.l
Lord Jkttiee Ckrk.-^Vvnr^m out then I
Put him out I
l^lUam Km- sworn.— SxaouBtd by Ar.
BumeU,
What profession are you of f-^-^ printer.
Were you clerk in the Gazetteer office? —
Tes;
Who had the management of that paper?
— Alexander Scott.
Were you a member of the meethig of thte
Friends of the People?— Yes.
Were you a member of the oonTentronr?-:-
Yjw.
And of the Bi'itish convention ? — Yes:
Did you act in any capacity*in eithlerx)f tliteee
meetings } — No.
Do you write short hand ?— Yes.
Were joti in the use of taking' down the
Abates m the conyention?— I took notc$ &
the convention.
Vbr miliar |hiifese>dM'JN»rtlJctflhesrAcAee^
*Mi-For my own amusement.
Did yuu not take them fbr the pumoee^cpf
poblitation i» the paper ?-^l M pubUih atf
aoeount of them in tlie Gaaetteer.
Then you took those notes- for the sake-oT
publishing them ?
LordfJuitke ClBrk.'^'Vake hisoWftworis;
hesays be took thein for his own anMsemeB^
and published them in the Gazetteer;
Mr. Burtuti^l believe you have a brother
in this towQ.^Yes.
Was he in the use of attending the British
convention ^-*Yeew
Did he assist ooeaslonidly as' secret^fy N^
I^cannotsay whether he aoteiil as seeietary er
net:
DitThe assist in «»y'riiaipe?^r have sdeil
seen hlmtaking notea^ antf writing.
Did'hetldfenetes of the debate?— Yes.
When you published the d^batiea in llie
Gazetteer, did you state them as aecwately as
ymi-could ?--*I cannot say fbr the accufftcyef
them.
Did you intend to make thein as aceilrata
as ym»«diild ?— I^did.
Did you revise the proof^Meets oAhepaperf
-^Sometinieafldk)^ T had W^alk^rv an op-
portunity.
Are yiouacquslnted' whK HfeK Geirald; the
panel at the bar ?— Yes.
Was he a member of the Bfitlsh oemvtn*
tion ? — ^I have seen him there.
Did he take a leading and aietive part in
the bnsioess, as fkr as you saw ?i-~I caittiot
say that I observed him t^ce any leadhig part
more than others;
Did' he make speeches?*^! have heard hioa
speak in the convention.
So fitf as you recollect, did you take notes
of his speech and publish them in the Gaaet^
tearf— I published in the Gazetteer speeches
of different persons, and I suppose Mr.
Gerrald's among the rest.
Did you ever see Mr, Gerrald aict'as pretest
^^l cannot recollect.
Do you remember'amotfon'madi^by Mr.
GaHender in the oonventien?-^ think I do ;
but it is at such a distance of time that I
cannot Recollect nmch about it.
Do yeu remember any debate with regard
tb a question of union ?— I think I do.
Do you renvember if Mr. Genrald made
any speech upon that subject ?-^I remember
his speaking; but what his speech was I
cannot 'say.
Lopk at that newspaper ; is that, to the
best of your belief, the speech that you wrote
out for the Gazetteer? — I canitot say.
' This paper is published by yotf; it it not ?-^
It appears to be so.
' Lord Dunnnnan. — Was it an accurate'ac-
icount? Did you intend to makeitinacofr-
rate?— I did not intend it; but from circum-
stances I am sure it is not accurate.
Lord Etkgrove. — Did you intend to put Mf
tUng J9 that did not -pass f-^I had lakan a
999]
fir Sedition,
A. D. 179i.
[930
cold and did not hear well ; and, not beine
practised in the short-hand-writipg, I filled
It up as I thought suited the occasion.
Mr. Burnett. — Do you remember any
amendments being made upon that motion
of Callendcr's ! — 1 have some recollection of
this motion of Caliender's.
Was that motion passed as given in bv
him, or were there amendments? I will
read it from your own paper [reads it]. Were
you present when these observations were
made by Mr. Sinclair ? — I was.
And did you write that» as far as you recol-
lect?— I thmk I wrote that part of the Ga-
zetteer; but I cannot answer for the accu-
racy of it.
Mr. Solicitor-General, — Do you remember
any thing about a convention of emergency
bemg appointed to meet in certain cases ? —
Yes.
Tell us the cases in which they were to
meet? — I recollect something of it, from
having told it in this court before.
Was the suspension of the Habeas Corpus
act one .^— It was mentioned.
Was a suspension of the act for preventing
wrongous imprisonment mentioned? — I be-
lieve It was.
Was an invasion mentioned ?— I do not
recollect hearing of that
Was there any thin^ about landing foreign
troops? — I think foreign troops were men-
tioned.
Was the passing an act similar to the Irish
convention bill one ? — Yes.
William Rots cross-examined by Mr. Clerk,
Had you access to know that Mr. Gerrald
was much indisposed, during the meeting of
the convention, and frequently absent from
the meetings? — I suppose Mr. Gerrald's
health was not in a very good state; ever
since I first saw him I imagined he was not
in a very good state of health.
I suppose you attended these meetings
pretty regularly, by your taking down the
debates in short-hand. — I was a good deal
there.
Did you observe that Mr. Gerrald was fre-
quently absent from those meetings? — It
might be so.
Tell the jury again the circumstances on
account of which you did not publish it as
accurately as you wished. — I had not sufii-
cient practice in short hand to write it accu-
rately; and another thins was, I was just
recovered from a fever, and had a severe cold
that I could not hear well.
You mean to sav, that what you published,
is in substance the same that you heard in
the convention, but that a good deal was
filled up from supposition ? — ^Yes, a great deal
of it was; and I cannot now say what part
of it was 80 filled up; I filled it up as I
thouriit suited the nature of the question.
Did the convention authonze the publi
VOL. XXIII.
tion of those debates in the Gazetteer — ?
They did not ; the convention had no con-
cern with them.
Do vou know any instance in which it was
moved that their proceedings should not be
allowed to be published in Uie Gazetteer ? —
I heard a debate one evening; it was late
when I came in, concerning taking the votes,
and I thought it alluded to me.
Do you recollect any thing of a motion
returning thanks to Mr. Scott for the publi-
cation of the Gazetteer ?— To the best of my
recollection I never heard such a motion.
Mr. Gilliet. — ^Were you present upon the
4tli of December, 1793, wnen the following
motion was proposed -.->'< That the moment
of any illegal dispersion of the present con^
vention, shall be considered as a summons to
the delegates to repair to the place of meet^
ing, appointed for the convention of emer-
Sency, by the secret committee, and that
iie secret committee be instructed to pro*
ceed without delay to fix .the place of meet-
ing ?'' — I cannot recollect that I was, but I
think I have heard of the motion.
Do you think, upon the 4th of' December,
that Mr. Gerrald was present? or. do you re-
member his being ill at that time, and ab-
sent from the meeting on that account ?— I
cannot say; all that 1 recollect about Mr,
Oerrald's absence is, that I always thought
he was in a bad state of health, out
when he was absent or present I cannot re-
collect
One of ike Jury, — ^I would ask you, in the
first place, were the convention acquainted
with your intention to publish their proceed-
ings, previous to publication? and, in the
next place, did they ever complain of its
bein^ inaccurate? — I dare say they knew
nothmg of it previous to publication.
Lord Justice Clerk. — But did any of them
complain to you or Mr. Scott that they were
inaccurately taken down? — I have already
said, I came into the convention one evening^
and there was a talk about the notes being
taken, and the impropriety of it, and I
thought they alluded to me.
Mr. SoUcitor-General.—^jyx^. you, upon
that, discontinue taking notes? — No.
You continued taking them till they were
dispersed ?— 'The day they were dispersed I
was taken before the shenfF.
Lord Abercromhie, — Did any member, or
did the convention, complain that you had
not taken them accurately ? — ^Yes ; one mem-
ber, particularly spoke ot my inaccuracy re-
specting the number of delegates from Shef-
field, and a number of inaccuracies.
What were the others? — I cannot recol-
lect.
What was the nature of the inaocuiacies f
—They were inaccuracies in words.
Mr. Gillies, — Did Mr. Sinclair ever com-
plain of the general inaccuracy of taking
down the debates ?-*! do not recollect any
particular person.
3 0 —
931]
34 GEORGE in.
Proceedingt agamti Joieph Gerrald
toae
George Ron $worn. — Examined by Mr.
Burnett,
You were clerk In the Guetteer office? —
Yes.
You were a member of the British conven-
tion ? — ^Yes.
Were you in the use of assisting the se-
cretary ? — Yes ; I sometimes assisted the
secretary, and so did several other persons.
Was your brother one ? — No, never.
Is that your hand-writing?— [Reads.! —
^ Citizen Gerrald appointed chairman.'' Yes
it is.
Did you ever hear him make speeches in
the convention ? — ^I have heard him speak in
the convention.
Do you remember any debate about a
union ? — I recoHeet something about a union
of the societies of England and Scotland.
Do you remember Air. Gerrald speaking
upon that subject > — ^I do not recollect whe-
ther he did or not.
Do you remember a motion made by Mr.
Callender about a convention bill?— Mr.
Callender made a motion, that in case any
motion was made in parliament to brine in a
bill, such as the convention bill in Irdand,
that the convention should meet and petition
parliament to prevent it.
Was that motion referred to a committee ?
«-I do not recollect.
What was done with it?^I do not recollect
at present.
Do vou remember Mr. Sinclair making any
amendments upon it? — ^I believe there were
amendments proposed.
Bv Mr. Sinclair?—! cannot recoUect.
Were tliose amendments passed? — I believe
they were ; but I am not very certain.
Do you remember any thing about the
amendments ?— No, I do not.
llead that— [Reads.] — " Citizen Sinclair
read the amendments upon citizen Callander's
motion,'' — ^and then comes another person's
band-writing.
How much of that is your hand-writing?—
The three last lines.
Do you recollect nothing at all about it? —
I do not recollect the particulars of the motion.
Was there any thing in Mr. Sinclair's
amendment about a convention of emergen-
cy ?-*-! do not remember it.
Did any other body mention it?— I remem-
ber a convention of emergency being men-
tioned.
And when was it to meet? — ^Incase of a
bill being brought into parliament similar to
that passed in Ireland.
In any pther case were they to meet? — In
case of Hessians and Hanoverians being
landed in this country, they were to petition
parliament.
In case of the suspension of the Habeas
Corpus act? — I do not recollect
Or of the act for preventing wrongous im-
prisonment?— I do not recollect.
Or in case of a fore^ invasion? — ^I do not
Read that.— [Reads.]— <' Citizen Gerrald,
in a very energetic and animated address, ex-
pressed his happiness at the motion passed.'^
That is your hand-writing? — ^Yes.
Do you know the reason of that blank be-
ing left in the minutes ? — I cannot tell that ;
but if you would have allowed the convention
to sit and publish their minuleS| it would have
been filled up.
Lord Juttice C/«rAr.— Remember you ace
upon vour oath. — I know that very well; I
come here to tell the truth. All I know about
it isp it must either have been left to be put
in at a future period, or, from hurry, or soma
reason, it coiUd not be put in at that time.
Mr. Bamef/.— Were the speeches, made in
the convention, published in the Gazetteer?
— Yes, what my brother took down.
Did you ever read them in the Gazetteeri
— I have read them, but I have very little
time to read.
Did there appear to you to be any thing
stated in the Gazetteer that vou did' not hear
in the convention?— If I had read them par-
ticularly over, I perhaps could have answered
to that.
One of the Jury. -^ Who corrected the
speeches for publication? — ^I believe my bro-
ther, at least I suppose so.
Did you ever correct them yourself? — ^I do
not know whether I ever did or not; perhaps
in reading over the proof I might.
Mr. Burnett, — Here is a paper with ** vivc
la convention," and ** ^ ira, George Ross;" is
that your hand-writing ? — ^Yes.
George Ross cross-examined by Mr. Gillies.
Those words, *' vive la convention," and
'^ ^k ira," were written by you at one of the
sections? — ^Yes.
Was Mr. Gerrald ever present at this sec-
tion ? — No.
Did the convention authorize these expres-
sions?— No, they never did. I believe Mr.
Gerrald never belonged to ai^y of the sec*
tions.
How came you to put these expressions? —
Tliere was no harm in Uiat.
Was it a fancy of your own ? — It was, with-
out any orders, just a fancy of my own.
W^s any thing of that kind stated in the
minutes of the convention ? — They were writ-
ten by me before either the convention or the
panel could know any thing of them.
Were they afterwards read over and ap«
proved of bv the convention? — ^There were
several members thought them very fooUsh.
Mr. Solicitor GeneraL — But they were read
over and lodged with the secretary as official
papers? — Yes.
Mr. Gillies. — Were these expressions, '^viv«
la convention" and ** ^ ira" read over to
the convention, or only the report firom the
section? — It depended upon tJie person wIki
read them.
99^
for SeiUtan.
A. D. 1794..
[934
Lord Henierland, — ^When theY were read,
Vfns the person reading in the habit of coof
cealing any part of it?— I cannot stc^,
Mr. Burnett. — Here is a paper, " first year
of British hherty, one and indivisible, by the
appointment of the rabble of sans culottes/'
Mr. Gillies. — Was the panel concerned in
writing that paper ? — I cannot sav.
Mr. Burnett, — Were notthe whole conven-
tion divided into sections ?— Yes.
At what time did the section meet, of
which you were a member? — ^In the fore-
tuootk.
And they made their report in the evening ?
Yes.
Mr. Gillies. — Did yoa ever see Mr. Gerrald
«t any of these sections? — I never saw him
atone.
[The declaration of the panel was then
sead.]
' Mr. Solieitcr General. — Gentlemen of the
jury, you are now about to exercise the most
important function that private persons can
be called upon to exercise; — to determine
with regard to the guilt or innocence of the
unhappy person who stands at this bar ; and
were the case at all difficult, in proportion to
its importance, I should consider your situa-
tion, gentlemen, to be at thi^s moment of a
very hazardous and a very delicate nature ;
but you are not, upon this occasion, obliged,
as Jurymen sometimes are, to wade through
a difficult proof, through a variety of contra-
dictory eviaence, to balance deposition against
deposition, and from a long train of circum-
stances, with a tremblins step, to investi^te
where the truth lies. This, ^ntlemen, is a
province which often falls to the lot of jury-
men; and, to be sure, calls for the utmost
attention with which the human mind can be
vested. This is a case which commonly hap-
pens, where those who break the laws of
their country trust to being able to conceal
the offence of which they nave been guilty
for impunity, and of course it must require a
difficult, a laborious investigation.
Gentlemen, the present case is of a dif-
ferent kind ; the offences charged against this
panel were of too public a nature ; they trusted
not to concealing the truth for impunity, but
to circumstances of futurity, by which they
hoped to set criminal justice at defiance ; but
their hopes have been defeated, and I have
this day to lay before you a proof so complete,
that which I shall have the honour of
stating to you.
Grentlemen,- it will be necessary for me to
take up more of your time than at first might
be imagined, because the most material part
of the proof you have not yet heard ; it lies
not so much in the parole evidence that has
been given, as in the written evidence lying
upon the table ; and, before I enter upon the
{^articular parts of the evidence, I believe it
will be proper to lay under your view a gene-
ric statemeat of the written evidence which
has been adduced, and the manner in which
it has been authenticated ; doing it in this
manner, in the beginning of what 1 have to
say, will save repetitions, and will save you
the trouble of again and again recurring to
the same matter.
Gentlemen, the written evidence, upon
which I chiefly rely, consists, in the nrst
place, of the minutes of the convention (call
it scroll, or what you please), made up by
the secretary of the convention, and by his
assistants. I say, gentlemen, this important
document, fortunately for the sake of^ public
justice, has been recovered out of the nands
of the secretary, and is now lying upon the
table.
Gentlemen, when it Y^as seen that the au-
dacity of the British convention had come to
such a height, that it was impossible for the
magistrates and ofi^cers of the law not to take
measures against them, one of the first steps
resolved upon was, to take proper measures
for getting hold of the vn-itten documents lik
Skirving*s possession ; and by those proper
measures, so taken by the ofilicers of tlie law,
has this evidence been secured, and now lies
before you, completely authenticated. The
authentication of it is perfectly complete; you
have the evidence of the persons who seized
it in the possession of Skirving; you have
them, traced to the sheriff Clerk's office^ and
there you have them inventoried and signed
in the presence of the parties ; and therefore
I shall hold these minutes as completely au-
thenticated, and shall have occasion to refer
to them again and ag^ain in support of the
charge I am to maintain.
You have, in the second place, the evidence
of the papers recovered out of the possession,
partly of the panel, and partly of his com-
panion Margarot, which were got by Lyon^
and opened by the key out of Margaret's
pocket, in the sheriff clerk's office, all which
now lie upon the tabic completely authenti-
cated.
In the third place, you have the writings
found in the possession of Sinclair, by Lyon
the messenger, at the time he attended the
execution ot the warrant, put into a napkin,
and by him carried to the sheriff-clerk's office,
not inventoried that day, because Sinclair
was indisposed, but inventoried two days after;
they are also completely authenticated. I am
sure, from the nature of the case, it is impos-
sible any alteration could have been made,
and among those papers you will find some
very important and very decisive documents
of evidence indeed. And,
In the last place, — if it may be called writ-
ten evidence, — there is the evidence arising
from those numbers of the gazetteer which
are also produced. It is very true, that in
general, accounts given in a newspaper can-
not be received before a jury; but you will
observe, this is a newspaper in a very parti-
cular situation, published by a member of
the convention wno is now under sentence of
035i] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings agwut Joseph Gerrald
[930
fiigitatloQ on that account* and recoj;vused
by the convention itself. Gentlemen, it may
be necessary to point out to you in what way
this was recognized by the convention, as
^ving a fair account of their proceedings. I
see there appears in the minutes many reso-
lutions about supporting the Gazetteer, as a
paper of their party ; and, in one of the mi-
nutes, a person of the name of Colin Nory
having applied for a copy of the minutes, the
answer returned to him is this, that it will
be unnecessary, because they will find them
in the Gazetteer. I say, then, you cannot
liave a doubt but that it contains as fair and
.accurate an account as you can expect;
at least accurate enough for all the purposes
for which I shall read them.
Now, gentlemen, having thus stated and
^iven you some account of the evidence
which I have to rely upon, I shall now pro-
ceed to consider the charge brought against
this panel, and the evidence by which I
say every part of it is most completely and
without contradiction substantiated. The
general amount of the charge comes to this,
that in the months of November and Decem-
!ber last, a set of seditious persons assembled
in this city, and assumed to themselves the
name of *' the British Convention of the
Delegates of the People, associated to obtain
Universal Suffrage and Annual Parliaments.*'
That such a meeting was held in this city is
fi fact too notorious and too well remembered
by every one of us to admit of contradiction ;
jthat this panel was a constituent member of
this meeting is equally clear and indisputable,
having come here by delegation from one of
^e societies in J^ondon, — I believe the Cor-
responding Society ; but it matters not which,
«— and that he at^nded and took an activer
part in the resolutions of those meetings will
bot be disputed by him'^lf. I believe that
)ie took an active part, and I must say, that
from the talents which this gentleman has
fiho wn, and from the cbaracter given him by his
counsel, I h^ve no doubt 'that his abiUtierfrolution. At that period our forefathers
>
and education qualified him to take a very
distinguished part in the convention, as one
4)f the leaders and prime movers among them.
Gentlemen, I say, if nothing more had
been proved against this panel than his
taking an active part in the proceedings of
B meeting of this kind, upon that I would
maintain that he is guilty ot sedition; because
I say the meeting itself, from the very nature
p( it, and the part he took in it, is suflOicient
to constijtute a charge of sedition against
-^im. For what was this meeting? What
is the name that they assume to themselves }
They called themselves ** the British Con-
tention of the Delegates of the People;"
plainly conveying an idpa that they were the
representatives of the great body of the peo-
ple at lar^e, and endeavouring to vest them-
selves with legal authority, f say this alone
is seditious and contrary to law *. the people
pf Gjcat Britain .are represented b^ their de^
le^tes in parliament; there their represea-
tation lies, and an attempt of any other body
of men to call themselves the representatives
of the people is seditious — ^is illegal. A con-
vention, it is very true, is not a name so c&*
tirely new in Scotland as might iiave beea
imagined; a convention was a Ic^al name ia
ScoUand, given to a leeal body, invested by
the sovereign with parliamentary powers, in
some degree, at least with powers very little
short of those vested in the parliament. We
know it was a convention of the delegates of
the people in Scotland which accomplished
the revolution. At that period, the people
of Scotland alarmed at an indignant invasion
of their rights, seeing their privueges in church
and state invaded and threatened y/i\h the
establishment of a despotic power; at that
period, — that memorable period to which we
all look back, at least in name, with reve-
rence,— at that period, the people of Scot-
land, all that was great and good and wise ia
this country, assembled; at that time WQ
needed not delegates from corresponding so-
cieties in London ; there was then no occa-
sion for inflammatory hand-bills and two-
penny pamphlet^; the people of Scotland
know when their rights are invaded ; at that
time their constitution was attacked, and a
despotic power threatened them ; at that
time a convention met of every thing great»
respectable, and good ; and the^ established
the principles of the Claim of Rights, and
provided against any encroachment upon
that constitution, by such gusu-ds as appeared
to them to be perfectly sufficient.
But, gentlemen, what is the object of this
British convention of the delegates of the
people? We are told it is to obtain universal
suffrage. I say, gentlemen, that universal
su^rage is not only contrary to, not only not
authorized by the constitution of Great BrU
tain, but a complete subversion of that form
of government under which we live, and
which was established at the time, of the
published to the world their ideas of eovem*
ment in the Claim of Rights ; they £clared
openly and manfully what thev thought suf-»
ficient to make them a free and a happy peo-
ple, and to support the constitution. And^
give me leave to say, and tell many of those
peonle who talk so loudly of the Claim of
Rients which they never read, that every
rignt then stipulated for by our forefathers,
every tittle of them is at this moment enjoyed
by the poorest wretch that breathes in Scot- .
land. If the gentleman can show me one
single instance m which the Claim of Rights
is invaded, I will thb moment si^^ down and
give up the argument.
But we are told that universal suffrage is
a speculative opinion with respect to govern-
ment; that wise men differ upon it, and that
it is a part of the freedom which we .enjoy to
have the liberty of fairly discussing every
political subject, and tfus ^unpng the rcsl»
AST]
fw SedUioH,
A. D. 17d4«
[938
0«ntleineiiy this is a proposition which I will
take the liberty to deny. I will take the li-
berty to say, that the maintaiiiiDg the free-
i]ora of discussion of political questions to
that length which is subversive of the con-
stitution is most illegal and most unconsti-
tutbnal ; for, what is the situation in which
we all standi We are not here in a state of
liature, we are not savages, and now for the
£rst time to choose a constitution for our-
selves; not like a man shipwrecked upon a
desert island, free to choose any mode of
government we please. No; we are all of
us born subjects of the British empire, sub-
jects of Great Britain, which is the most
inestimable blessing, and the most inesti-
mable birth-right that can be bestowed upon
us. From oiu- birth we owe allegiance to the
constitution established at the revolution;
we are not to venture to sa^ that another
constitution would do better m its place. I
say, by law we owe allegiance to it from our
birth, and by law we are bound to prevent it
being encroached upon, and that no body of
men have a liberty to say we will indulge in
speculation, and thereis no harm in speculation.
I say, that subjects of Great Britain, born un-
der allegiance to the constitution, have no
such liberty. Now, gentlemen, I ask, was
universal suffrage any part of the constitu-
tion established at the revolution ? Was it
ever so murh as thought of? Was it ever so
much as mentioned among those rights which
our ancestors have established ? Not a
word. The patriots of those days to whom
we are so much indebted, had too much good
sense not to see that anv scheme of that
kind was inconsistent with that species of
government, composed of monarchy, aristo-
cracy, and democracy, which was then es-
tablished ; they saw that any scheme of that
kind would be inconsistent with it, and that
it would be dangerous and chimerical : but
what their good sense led them to see and to
shun we are able to jud^e of upon much
surer grounds. This topic is no loneer a
matter of theory; in which men will indulge,
as they please, their different opinions ; it is
a-matter which has been brought to the test
of experience, in the only case in which it
has been tried since the world began (for
the (Anglo-Saxon government knew of no
such thing) : one experiment has been tried,
in the government of France, and the result
of that experiment I shall not mention ; it
is a subject from which I turn aside with
horror and detestation, and yet this is the
time, after this experiment has been tried,
after it has produced those horrible mischiefs
in a neighbouring country, which we cannot
think ot. without shuddenng, this is the very
time when this British convention will lif\ up
their own mad opinions against the experi-
ence of ages; when they say in spite of^ the
revolution, in spite of their principles then
established, and in spite of what has happen-
*^.in France, we will obtain this universal
stifirage, which, if obtained in any country
in the world, would iust produce the same
conse€[aences, or nearly the same that it has
done in that unhappy ill-fated country which
I just now alluded to.
Gentlemen, I shall only suppose, that in
place of associating themselves for the pur-
pose of obtaining universal sufirage, as they
tell us, suppose uiey had entitled themselves
an association, in order to obtain a demolition
of kindly power and of nobility ; to be sure
•they might have told us it was mere matter
of speculation;*- that many good men had
thought we were much better without kines
and without nobles ; but I am sure, living in
this countr^f, and under the constitution of
Great Britain, any proposition of that kind
maintained by any body of men, would be il-
legal and seditious.
Gentlemen, having shown you that the
object of this association was LUegal, let us
now consider tlie means which they took to
accomplish their object, which include the
different acts of sedition charged aeainst this
panel, because every one and all of those
steps which they took, towards obtaining this
favourite object^ are gross and aggravated in-
stances of sedition.
Gentlemen, the title which this meetinj^
assumed to itself, 1 have already spoke of;
and which was, I apprehend, in itself illegal,
as calling themselves the delegates of the
people, that is to say, the delegates of the
people at large.
* But the libel farther states, " and did in
the whole form and manner of their proce-
dure, as well as in the principles they avowed
and propagated, clearly and unequivocally
demonstrate, that their purposes were of the
most dangerous and destructive tendency,
hostile to the peace and happiness, and tend-*
ing to subvert the tonstitulion of this realm,
imitating in the form and tenor of their pro-
ceedings, the convention of France, the pub-
lic and avowed enemies of this country, and
with whom Great Britain then was. and still
is at war, the members callinj^ each ot^er at
their meetings by the name of citizen, divid-
ing themselves into sections, receiving reports
from said sections,'' and so on. Gentlemen,
for evidence of this, besides the testimony of
the witnesses that was delivered in your pre-
sence, I only refer vou to the minutes of
the convention, which will be lying before
you when you deliberate upon this subject.
Turn to every page, and you will see there is
no part of it tne language of Great Britain,
but all of it this new-fangled jargon which
has been accompanied with so much confu-
sion. We find committees of finance, of or-
?mization^ primary assemblies, and so on.
ou will nnd, by lookine at the minutes, or
these reports of sections found in the posses-
sion of Skirving, the most complete evidence
of this; and I believe there is not a sin|;le
phrase of mischief, consecrated to every thinz
that b bad in France, but has been adopted
by the members of the British convention.
DSff]
34 GEORGE lU.
Proceedings agatnti Jcuph Qerrpld
1940
Gentlemen, it is very true, that thia mode
of imitation is not, by the law of Scotland, a
crime in itself, nor do t charge it as such ; it
is only mentioned in the libel as a circum-
stance of evidence, in order to show to the
jury the general views and intentions of the
parties. There is nothing wrong in the word
convention, there is nothmg wrong in orga-
nization, or in liberty and equality ; there is
nothing wrong in these words, nor any other
in the whole English dictionary ; it is the im-
proper association of them, which I apprehend
here go to mark the dark and dangerous de-
signs, which these people have not been able
to conceal. Pnidence might have told them,
^at whatever alterations they meant to make
in this country, they should not have borrow-
ed these expressions of France ; but the fury
of reformation was so mad, and so rapidly did
the torrent run, that they were always speak-
ing out the beloved object they had in view ;
axSl thus we have committees of finance,
of instruction, of organization^ and all the
rest.
Gentlemen, you were told the other day,
by a very ingenious counsel on the part of
Mr. Gerrald, that this imitation of French
manners, was by no means new in this coun-
try; that something of the same kind had
taken place before, and nobody ever found
fault with it. It is true, we may all remem-
ber when all the fopperies of the fashions of
France were our objects of imitation ; but did
they endanger the constitution of this coun-
try? Was it ever pretended that they were
to give laws to Britain, and alter her consti-
tution } Did the taylors, the milliners, or the
frizeurs ever pretend to legislate for this coun-
try? Did they ever pretend any thing but to
make oiur coats or powder our heads i* That
species of imitation may be ridiculous, as it
certainly was ; but it was perfectly innocent ;
it had not the smallest resemblance to that
of which these gentlemen have been guilty ;
it no more resembles it, than if a man shonld
choose to please himself with the diverting
tricks of a monkey; this might be innocent,
but it does not follow that in society he would
be allowed to imitate the savage ferocity of a
tyeer; the one may be ridiculous, but the
other is detestable and dangerous : it is on
that account, and not because it was an imi-
tation of French manners, that it is charged
as pointing out the mischievous views and
intentions which actuated the minds of these
people.
Gentlemen, the libel next proceeds to state
several speeches made by this panel, who, by
all accounts, appeared to have a talent for
public speaking, of which you in all proba-
Dility will soon have a specimen ; and ne cer-
tainly has a talent for composition ; of that
we can all judge. It is stated, that on the
SI St of November, he made the speech
which is engrossed at length in the libel,
and which has been read berore you, this day.
Gentlemen, the evidence that he made the
speech, does not rest solely on the testimony^
of the Gazetteer, although even that I should
have thought sufficient evidence to establisk
the eeneral import and substance of the
speech ; because, I will read to you an abridg-
ment of that speech, taken from an authority
which the gentlemen will not pretend to ques-
tion, I mean the minutes of the convention,
which is just as bad, or rather worse if any
thin^, than that published in the Gazetteer :
[reads from the minutes] <' Mr. Gerrald ob-
served, that whatever difference of opinioa
might exist within those walls, we ean never
forget that our friends and our enemies are
in common, and that our object is equally the
same; — he took a view of the meuis we
should take to g^ ottr object— entered fully
into our r^t to annual parliaments — minute*
ly investigated the principles of government
—asserted that the end of all government is
the good of the governed,'' which is certunly
very true — *^ that if money is taken out of
our pockets, it signifies not whether it is
taken by the robber on the heath, or the
monarch on the throne— made many remarks
on the revolution-settlement, and the benefits
derived from the revolution, but clearly de-
monstrated that they are now totally taken
away," which agrees with the words in the
Gazetteer, '* that the present form of govern-
ment no more resembles the revolution, than
a dead putrid carcase does a living body."
Now, if you compare these together, you will
find, that this short account is a most faithfiil
and accurate abridgment of Mr. Gerrald's
speech, as stated in the Gazetteer, which I
snail not trouble you with reading again —
there are just two single passages I beg leave
to call your attention to : << It was justly oh*
served by citizen Callender, that, soon aAer
the union of the crowns of EnglaiKi and Scot-
land, the people of both counuies were de^
prived of some of their most valuable privi-
leges. It was from that period, that the
greatest encroachments bej^an to be made
upon public liberty, but, it that union has
operated to rob us of our rights, let it be the
object of the present one to regain them. If
the event exists for our shame, as it has ex-
isted for our chastisement, let it also exist for
our instruction.''
Now, gentlemen, I here say, that that is a
most abominable libel upon the union of the
two kingdoms, one of the most auspicious
events that ever happened ; to say, that *' fivm
that period, the greatest encroachments be-
gan to be made upon public liberty,'' is an
assertion that is most false and seditious ; for
since that period, there have been no en-
croachments upon public liberty, and no in*
dividual citizen has been depriv^ of any of
his most valuable privileges.
Gentlemen, the only other passage that I
shall take notice of in this speech is this :
*' It has been observed, that the revolution of
1688, did not produce the advantages which
might hvve been expected from snch an event.
X
941]
Jbr Sedition*
A. D. 179i.
[942
It is true that, at the cevolutiQny universil
sufifnue was not dispensed to the people with
that uberaliiy whicn it ought to have been ;
but still, the present form of government, in
my opinion, no more resembles the revolu-
tion, than a dead putrid carcase does a living
body:" which is just saying in other and more
flond words what is stated in the mimites,
that the blessings obtained by the revolution-
settlement were now totally done away.
Gentlemen, the next branch of the indict-
,meQt which we shall proceed to, which is the
most material and the most inexcusable of the
whole, which carries the deepest ^ilt against
this panel, is what relates to citizen GetUcn-
der's motion, the proceedings of the conveur
tion which followed upon it, and the share
which this panel took in its proceedings.
Gentlemen, in order that you pnay have a
complete view of this important branch of
the cause you have to try, I shall state from
the minutes, proeressiveiy, the history of the
proceedings which took place with regard to
this motion of citizen Caliender's. The busi-
ness originated in a motion made by citizen
Callend^, a gentleman now under sentence
of fiigitation, ror the part he took in this busi-
ness; he did not dare to stand his trial:
Citizen A. Callender moved, ^ That in case
the minister bring into the Commons House
of Parliament a motion for a convention bill,
it shall he noticed immediately to the dele-
^tes.'' This is the general substance of Mr.
Callender's motion, as taken down in the mi-
nutes of the convention, upon the Sdth of
November; and upon the 'J 7 th it is debated
in the convention. '' Mr. Callender's motion
being then taken under consideration, amend-
-ments were proposed by citizens Downie,
Sinclair, Margarot,and Gactley. Citizen Mar-
garet was for adopting the spirit of the mo-
tion, but thought it more expedient to post-
pone it till the conclusion of the convention
DMsiness, and moved that a committee, con-
sisting of the mover, seconder, and those who
had moved for amendments, be appointed to
draw up a motion that may probabljr meet the
ideas of all. After some consideration it was
agreed, upon the motion of Mr. Callender,
that the sense of the House should be taken,
^rst upon the spirit of the motion, secondly,
upon the words of the motion, and thirdly upon
Mr. Margarot's motion. Upon the first mo-
tion it was carried unanimously to adopt the
motion as to its spirit; secondly, by a great
ptiajority not to adopt the words of it; and
thirdly, that the amendments be referred to
a committee as above." So that you see, gen-
tlemen, the result of this debate upon Callen-
der's motion is to adopt the spirit of it, but
with respect to amendments, to refer it to a
committee.
Then, gentlemen, let us see what the mi-
nutes say forther upon this subject: ^ Upon
the 28ta of November the motion is again
taken into consideration, and the report of the
committee, to whom it was refeired to loake
ihe amendments upon Callender's motion, is
brought up: ** Citizen Sinclair read the amend«-
ments upon citizen Callender's motion, as
agreed upon by the committee, and it was
aereed upon the motion of citizen Blank, Uiat
tne house should resolve itself into a com-
mittee for its mature consideration. In ibe
course of the conversation, citizen Brown
gave a history of the Habeas Corpus act.
AAer au excellent discussion of the question^
pertinent remarks, and amendments, the con-
vention was resumed, and the whole, as
amended, being read over, the members
stood upon their feet, and solemnly and una-
nimously passed the resolution as follows."
After this there is a blank of a page and up-
wards, which I shall afterwaros fill up to
your satisfaction: in the mean time, I shall
go on with the minutes.
'^ Citizen Gerrald, in a veir energetic and
animated address, expressed his happiness at
the motion passed; citizen Brown followed
him in a manly speech, and proved the in-
fluence of the executive government over the
parliament ; citizen Margarot then read, and
proposed the following motion : That a com-
mittee of three and the secretary, be appointed
to determine the place where such convention
of emergency shall meet, that such place
shall remain a secret with them, and with
the secretary of the convention, and that each
delegate shall, at the breaking up of the pre-
sent session, be entrusted with a sealed letter^
containing the name of the place of meeting ;
^his letter shall be delivered unopened to his
constituents, the receipt of which shidl be ac-
knowledged by a letter to the secretary pre-
served in the same state until the period shall
arrive, at which it shall be deemed necessary
for the delegate to set off. This motion was
seconded by citizen Moffat and passed unani-
mously.'' Now, gentlemen, let us go back
to the blank, which I shall now be able to fill
up, as I believe, to the full satisfaction of
everv man who hears me : the blank is to be
filled up by the amended resolution pro-
posed by Smclair, which amended resolu-
tion is one of the papers, two copies. of which
were found in Sinclair's possession when he
was apprehended by Lyon, and carried to the
sheriff-clerk's office, there inventoried, and
now lie upon the table : one of them appears
to be a good deal blotted and interlmed,
which is entitled at the back, in the hand-
writing of Mr. Aitcheson, ^' Mr. Sinclair's
sunendment of Mr. Callender's motion," and
that important paper I must now beg to read
to you, fully autnenticated as it is : " Re-
solved, tliat the following declaration and re-
solutions be inserted at the end of your mi-
nutes." And you will now attend to a para-
§raph in the Gazetteer, which Ross took
own. and whic^ he says he does not recol-
lect, but which you have in the minutes, in
the Gazetteer, and in the indictment. <^ Re-
solved, that tn is convention considering the
itous consequences of any act of the
943]
S4 GEORGE III.
Proeeedingi against Joseph Gerrald
ledslature which may tend to deprive tiie
whole, or any part of the people, of their un-
doubted right to meet, either by themselves
or by delegation, to discuss any matter relative
to their common interest, whether of a pub-
lic or private nature, and holding the same to
be totally inconsistent with the nrst principles
and safety of society, and also subversive of
our own and acknowledged constitutional li-
berties, do hereby declare, before God and
the world, that we shall follow the wholesome
example of former times, by paying no re-
gard to any act which shall militate against
tne constitution of our country ; and shall
continue to assemble, and consider of the
best means by which we can accomplish a real
representation of the people, and annual
election, until compelled to desist by superior
force.
'' And we do resolve,
' . ^ That the first notice given for the intro-
duction of a convention oill, or any bill of*a^
similar tendency to tiiat passed in Ireland, in
the last session of their parliament ;
*^ Or any bill for the suspension of the Ha-
beas Corpus act, or the act for wrcmgotu im-
fritonmentf and against undue delays in triats
tit North Britain ;
** Or in the case of an invasion ;
" Or the admission of any foreign troops
whatsoever into Great Britain or Ireumd ; all,
or any one of these calamitous circumstances,
shall be a signal to the different delegates to
repair to such place as the secret committee
of this convention shall appoint ; and the first
seven members shall have power to declare the
sittings permanent; and twenty-one shall
constitute a convention, and proceed to bu-
siness.
'^The convention doth therefore resolve.
That each delegate, immediately on his re-
turn home, do convene bis constituents, and
explain to them the necessity of electing a de-
legate, or delegates, and of establishing a
fund without (lelay, against any of these
emergencies, for his or their expense; and
that tney do instruct the said delegate or de-
legates, to hold themselves ready to depart
at one hour's warning.'' This is the resolution
which, even the audacity of the convention
dares not insert in the minutes; and I am noi
surprised at it, — a more daring insult to the
established government of the country never
existed. Gentlemen, upon the first part of it,
an attempt, or something like one, was mtde
by the counsel to quibble away the import of
it, that they would pay no regard to any
act of the legislature ; that is, that as soon as
such a bill was brought in, they would meet,
and endeavour to prevent it from passing;
but if you attend, you will see this could not
be the meaning of it; it is as plain as words
tan make it, a resolution upon the part of
these gentlemen, to bid defiance to the legis-
lature of Great Britain.— That we who know
better than you, will oppose force to force,
and instead of paying regard to it, will make
It a signal for us to hold' a' convention of
emergency, to be held at a place unknown to
the parties themselves, to be fixed by a secr^
committee, and tliat each of the delegates
shall be entrusted with a sealed letter con-
taining the name of the place of meeting.
This is one occasion of the meeting of the
convention of emergency, but it is not the
only one ; there is another which well deserves
^your serious consideration ; one of the cases
specified in which this convention were to
meet, in a place unknown to any but a choseft
few of their own number, is in case of an in^
vasion. Gentlemen, this is not entirely a
fancied case ; we all know that an invasion of
this country has been projected, was thetf,
and is yet in agitation (when it will be at-
tempted God only knows) by its most inve-
terate foes, not as in former times proceeding
firom a rivalship in arms^a contest of ambr-
tion — no, the object of the invasion as de-
clared bv themselves, is no less than to anni-
hilate the government of Great Britain ; to
cut it up as a monstrous piece of tyranny, to
destroy that favourite of liberty and of wisdom
that was reared by our ancestors, and which
has so long been the glory and pride of eveiy
Briton and the admiration of mankind ; and
which, for that reason, has been so long the
envy of our foes. This constitution, in the
ftreservation of which is involved every privi-
ege, every public right, and I will add to it
every domestic comfort, is by this invasion to
be swept away at once ; a calamity which, if
it should happen (which I trust it never wiU*,
but no thanks to those ^ntlemen) than com*
pared with which, what is there in the history
of man to equal it ? Of all the calamities, of
all the punishments that ever were inflicted
upon a nation, if the whole vials of divine
vengeance were to be exhausted upon any
}>eople, or all the calamities that can proceed
'vom the convulsions of nature, or pestilence,
or still more desolating fisimine; I say the
whole of these calamities compared with a
successful French invasion, I mieht for my
own part, consider as visitations of kindness
and compassion ; and yet this is one of the
cases which their resolution provides- for. This
is the crisis, this is the moment which, if
ever it should occur, and it may God knows
how soon, when the power of Britain must be
exerted. Let me suppose the event, that the
French assembled near our coasts ; suppose
them (which God forbid) either to vanquish
Britain or defeat her visilance and arrive,
and prepare to laud ; — in tnat awful moment,
when the armies of Britain, I trdst, under
their sovereign shall muster upon the coast to
repel the foe, shall carry with tnem the wishes
of^every good citizen, every thing that is wise
and good in the country giving every assist-
ance in their power ; in that dreadful hour
where are we to find the British convention ^
Do we find them assembling under the ban-
ners of our constitution? rfo, they tell us,
that it is their resolution^ that they have '
9453
fiir Sediiion,
A. D. 1794.
[916
dared belbre God and the worlds that in that
hour they will, conspirator-like, slink into a
corner, shun their tellow citizens, form a
iKxly of their own, and meet in a place which
they themselves know not, and is only to be
unfolded by the opening of a sealed letter
when the hour arrives.
Gentlemen, though the mind of man can
only be view^ by that All-seeing Eve which
can pierce into it, yet a human tribunal can
judge of intentions from^actions; and taking
the actions of those men, as proved by the
most authentic documents, they were dark,
th^ were dangerous.
Gentlemen, it has been said that it might
be* their intention to unite themselves to repel
a foreign — ^to repel an invasion. Had that
been their intention, would they have chosen
to secrete themselves from the rest of their
countrymen f Were they so mad (and mad I
admit they were in many things) as to think
that a hundred men, or whatever their num-
ber was, were sufficient to repel an invasion ?
No ; to a foreign foe, such a force as
theirs must appear contemptible. It is true,
they were formidable, not by their numbers,
not b;^ their arms, but they were formidable
by being an enemy within our own bosoms.
This, this alone made them formidable. As
to its being their intention to sepel the inva-
aion, it is too eccentric, I am sure, to gain
oredit from any man.
Gentlemen, what mighty motives had thb
convention to strfhd forth to repel this host
coming against us? Suppose the period ar-
rived, they behold the power of Britain assem-
bled under its lawful sovereign ; there they
aee a king, a government which they consider
as no better tnan a dead carcase ; there they
see an aristocracy which is hateful to them.
Do the^r see universal suffrage ? No ; it is
that which can never be allowed by the con-
stitution of Britain. But what is tlie case?
They meet in a dark place. What do they
meet for? To obtain umvcrsal suffrage. What
do the invaders offer them ? Universal suf-
frage;— ^you shall have it from the pure foun-
tain head, from the soiu-ce of every thing that
is wise of nolitical instructions, from the
ibuntain head, the convention of Paris. You
shall liave no aristocracy ; — you shall have no
religion, if you please; lAit of that I say no-
ting;— you shall have primary assemblies ;
— you shall have every one of these things
wmch you appear to be so remarkably fond
of. Gentlemen, it is unnecessary for me to
carry the matter so far as to suppose that this
panel, or the other members came to the
dark, the desperate, the wicked resolution of
joining the foes of Britain, in case of an in-
vasion; it is by no means necessary. But sup-
posing they.meantto go no farther than what
they declared, — to meet in a secret place, un-
known to the government of this country,
perhaps to negociate with a foreign enemy ;
m dtber way their intention was dark, it
was wicked^ it was criminal. GenUemen.
VOL. XXIII. .
with rewd to many of the members, I do ia
charityl)elieve, that they concurred in this
resolution, not seeing the precipice on which
they stood, 'unconscious of the end to which
it tended. But I am sorry to say that i& an
apology that will not do for Mr. uerrald ; he
is a man who supports this resolution, and fol-
lows it up by an inflammatoi^ speech ; it is
impossible that he could be ignorant of the
point to which it led ; it is impossible he
could be innocent, he must be more or less
criminal, and the smallest criminality that can
be ascribed is very great indeed, far more
than sufficient to support the charge of sedition
which I have made against him.
Now, sentlemen, the next thing is the
speech of which the minutes very shortly say.
^ Citixen Gerrald, in a very energetic ana
animated address, expressed his happiness at
the motion passed.'' Gentlemen, I snail only
read one or two expressions in it, and
you will attend to the occasion upon which
this speech was made ; it was made just after
tile convention had passed thi^ solemn resolu-
tion and declaration before God and the world.
In this state, when their minds were in this
situation, in a state of avowed hostility, Mr.
Gerrald rose up and made a speech, addine
fuel to the flame; he says, " Tnoueh I could
not get a copy of this bill, the heads which I
have read are sufficiently explanatory of its
detestable principles; and I hope the mea«
sures which have passed this night will con*
vince the minister, that we are determined to
guard against every attempt that may be
made to deprive us of our rights. And
though by some it may be thought a bold»
by some a daring measure, yet it will be
found the best for the securing the peace of
our countiy ; for if such a law were suffered
to pass, if men were not allowed to utter their
complaints, a number of fierce and rancorous
passions would arise, and we would seek to
appeal to that last terrible decision, the event
of which is uncertain/but which God and na-
ture allows.
** If the servility of the people had been
less ; if they had dared to meet^ and, in place
of murmunng, to have told their rulers that
there was danger in seekine to deprive them
of their liberties, we would not have had to
adopt this resolution to night; but when I
saw the calm deliberate countenances of all
present, and the solemn manner in which it
was passed, I was convinced that it would
not only be a resolution of words^ but a rule
of action."
Gentlemen, upon the reading of this
speech, you will consider that it was address-
ed to a number of persons who had. a few
minutes before, come to the resolution of fly-
ing in the face of the legislature, which is so
plain that I shall say no more about it.
Gentiemen, I have now gone through the
charges in the indictment, and I thuk I
have established eveiy one of them in such
a way as niuat have given you satisfaction.
3 P
847]
34 GEORQE III.
Proceedings againet Joseph GerrM
(MB
The only pvt of the chai^ that remains is,
that at the time the magistrates came to dis-
perse them, even afWr that, Mr. Gerrald
a£ain takes the chair, and would not leave it
till he was turned out ; they declaring that
the dispersion was of no consequence, for
they had declared themselves permanent.
Upon that it is unnecessary to say any thing,
because you heard the evidence that was
given upon it; and you will give it such
attention as you think proper.
Thus I have endeavoured to lay before you
what appeared to me to be the most material
parts or the charge against this gentleman,
aabstantiated by thai evidence which appears
to me so satisfactory. And as the panel has
produced no evidence, it is impossible for me
to sea what defence he may make : I sbal^
Mily say, in general, that if ho disputes the
ftct, I refer vou to the evidence now Wing
vpon the table. If he says that tlie facts,
•apposing they are true, are not criminal, I
appeal to your own common sense, I appeal
to your own judgments, to the judgments of
every court of law who have ever decided in
^mmal cases. If he should say, notwith-
standing all (for his counsel insinuated some-
thing of the kind), that he acted from the
purest intentions, and that his intentions
were innocent, I must tell you, that with
se^peurd to the absolute purity of his intenti<Hi,
it u impossible for human penetration to see ;
thai must be reserved in every case to the
last day, when fevery troth must come out;
but you, as well as every other tribunal, must
judee accordine to the evidence and according
to toe facts as they lie before yon ; and from
those iacts I think I have satisfied you, that
their intentions were seditious, wicked, and
criminal. I shall trouble you no farther
ttpon this case, but leave it to your decision.
I have stated the grounds upon which I
think myself entitled to demand a verdict of
«iK:
ur. G«rra2flf.— Gentlemen of the jury;
Mr. Solicitor-General has told you, with great
truth and solemnity, that the cause of which
you are at present the judges, is one of the
most important which ever came before man
for the nuqiose of determination.
Gentlemen, if at an early period of my
life it had been announced to me^ that the
task of defending the rights and privileges of
sine millions of peo|>le would have devolved
upon me, a simple individual, I ^ould cer-
tainly, from my youth up, have devoted my
whole time, with unremitting application^
that I might be enabled to execute so sacrecl
and important a trust. Unfortunatelv,* though
a considerable period has intervened between
the time of my being served with an indict-
ment and my trial, yet I have been, in a
great measure, distracted by various avoca-
tions, and my health much impaired by con-
tinual fiickness. From my outy, however,
no earthly consideration shall induce me to
shrink. I, this day> come forward to advo*
cate a cause, than whk:h the sun never sboov
upon one of more deep and general con-
cernment ; and, impressed with this awiitl
consideration, I advance to it with a tremor
that shakes every fibre of my fiame. Bat
whatever be the result of this day's deliboa*
tion, I shall always look back to the part
which I have taken, with the eonsciousness
of a man who has endeaTOured well; for,
however weak the flesh may be, the spirit is
strongly inclined to the service.
Genuemen, the state prosecutions whicb
agitated and disgraced the middle of the last
century, were by no means of the same in^
portance with those of the present day.
The contest between Jonn Hampaen and
the crown rested solely upon this question;
whether the crown or the parliament should
have the power of raising tne aupplies ;* but
it was always idlowed, that the object of
these supplies was the advancement of the
general happiness. The cause which yoa are
called to decide upon is not merely a matter
of pecuniary consideration; you are called
upon to decide whether man, who is by hie
nature social and rational, shall meet in so*
ciety for the purpose of improving his fitcol-
ties, and exercismg those powers of reasoQ
which the common Father of us all has srren
us, to enlighten our understandings ana en-
noble our hearts ; or whether, by relinquish-
ing every thing that is virtuous, every thing
that is praiseworthy, every thing that is va-
luable in the condition of our humanity, we
shall be reduced to a situation beneath the
beasts that perish.
Gentlemen, as an Englishman, I ^il not
say a stranger in this country, — ^fi>r, fixmi
being members of the same community, we
have the same friends and the same foes;
and the articles of the Union, I believe, say,
that the natives of both countries are entitled
to the same privileges, — yet, as an English*
man^ I cannot but consider my situation as
varying in some measure from that of a
native of this country. In England, had I
committed the supposed crime charged
against me, the process would have been
very different. The present legal process too
much resembles those instituted in the last
centui^, when prosecutions upon prosecutions
were institutea for the purpose of destroying
the freedom of our country t I say, the pro-
ceedings of the High Court of Justiciary too
much resemble the proceedings of the Stap-
chamber before it was abolished. We have
not in tHis country the advantage which we
have in England of the bills being originally
found by a grand jury. ' We have not after-
wards the privilege of a petty jury selected
entirely by the sheriff; but I understand that
the assize* is first appointed hji the public
prosecutor, from whicn fifteen are aftenrard)
selected by the Court.*
■ t
* See the case of ship-money^ VoL 9, p*
835, of this Collection.
f See Vol. 19, p. 11. note..
Mff]
Jw Sedition*
A* D. 17M.
[990
Tluft circuQisUoee did not, howeycry deter {
me (though it was frequently ureed amongst
ciber arguments) fromxommg down here to
take my trial. No; when the scourges of
the late prosecutions, and the melancholy
fate of the prosecuted were held over my
bead, I was not to be deterred from doing n^
duty ; though by many I was consider^ as
devoted a victim as Regulus departing into
voluntary exile, or like Curtius plunging into
the gulph for the salvation of his country.
.GentiemeD, informations began in Eng-
land during the reign of one of our worst
{Nrinces, Henry VII. who £lled his private
coffers by the plunder of his subjects. In
conlbrmity to this process, I am sorry to
acquaint Youy that I was brought before tlRT
sheriff of this county by the operation, not
by the regular service, of a warrant. When
I was taken up I asked for the warrant, but
it was refused. My temper, I trust, is mild
luod peaceful; though in England, had***-
similar process taken place, the officer might
have paid for his irreeular conduct with the
forfeiture of his Ufe. But that was not my
purpose ; for as truth is my only object, so
reason is my only weapon. My papers were
taken out of my bureau and carried before
the sheriff. Knowing that those papers could
Contain nothing to criminate me, I claimed
them as my property, and signed the claim
without any hesitation. I am shocked, how-
ever, to think that so gross a proceeding
should take place in any country as a discW
sore of secrets bv takmg private papers.
Since the original seizure oi my papers, a
private letter has been arrested in its passage
to me from London, and in an attempt to see
the contents, has been destroyed without its
ever reaching me. I demanded what could
be the object of this procedure. I was in-
Ibrmed that it was for the jf urpose of collecting
evidence against me. This collection of evi-
dence then, it seems, may be made with ini*
punity in Scotland, bv as gross a violation
of the laws of the Una, as certain other col-
lections are made, of which the collectors,
when taken, are aiierwards hanged.
Gentlemen, the solicitor-general acknow-
ledged with much candour, that if hejcould
not prove the criminal intention, he could
prove nothing. It is upon this grand prin-
ciple that I rest my defence: it is neither
upon legal chicanery nor legal quibbles;
these would be unworthy of the cause in
which I am engaged. If the criminality of
the intention alone can constitute the offence,
either in a legal or moral point of view, I
trust I shall be able to make out so clear a
case, notwithstanding the calumnies which
the lying breath of rumour may have cast
npon me, that you yourselves, discarding
pr^udices which it is possible you may have
imbibed, will retire from this court as fully
satisfied of my innocence as I am myself.
Gentlemen, if fugitation is in the eye of
law deemed a presumption of guilt, appeiu:*
aoce, by parity of leason, must be deemed a
presumption of innocence. Notwithstanding
the pressing solicitations and strong induce-
ments held out to me by the societ)r who
delegated roe, and who would have paid my
bail, I determined to come down and appear
be£9re you. Can there then exist a stronger
proof of the consciousness of the puri^ of
my own intentions, than my having volui»-
tarily appeared before that tribunal which I
might have shunned, and firom which inno-
cence itself has oiWn fied?
Gentlemen, though it does not come im^
mediately before you, I do conceive that my
being: brought to trial at tliis particular time
is a harsh and rigorous measure; and it is
rather remarkable that on the last Monday, a
period which was marked for the first day of
my trial, and when I appeared here before
the court, our representatives in parliament
were .in fiu:t sitting in judgment upon these
very judges; nor do I think it would have
degraded the dignity of their function^ if
they had acted with less heat and with more
deliberation, and had patiently waited till
the result of the proceedings of the high
court of parliament had been known upoa
their conouct.
Gentlemen, the history of Britain furnishes
us with abundant instances of the interfer-
ence of the legislature to correct judicial
errors. In the case of Hampden, which was
a period that must be dear and valuable to
every Englishman, the parliament, by their
interference, prevented the robbery of the
subject by the arbitrary fiat of the crown. It
is not fit, I own, that thev should interfere
where the public is not deeply interested;
but where it is^ they are bound to do so in
justice to their representatives, and they
always have done so. Nay, they have gone
farther, and where the necessit^r was gr«it»
thev have even come to a resolution in point
of law, contrary to the Judgment of a court
of law, and to the opinion of ten out of
twelve judges. In case tlie judges violated
the law (a circumstance which m the late
cases is yet to be determined), or where they
suspected any undue indigence, either in the
exertion or the support of the urerogdlive, by
officers of the crown, or by judges, they have
always interposed. Is it possible to forget or
to controvert either their conduct, or the pro-
priety of it, in the great case of ship-money,
which was first brought into question by Mr.
Hampden, a private gentleman, who. so hi
from regarding the trumpery, petty-fogging
consideration of damages, declared, that he
would not pay it were it but one farthing, if
pretended to be demanded of ri^ht, and by
colour of law ; and yet proceeded, according
to my lord Claren&n's own account, with
freat temper and moderation in tliat suit
[is lordship adds, ^' and all the world knows
that never any cause had been debated and
argued more solemnly before ^e judges,
whO| afkr long deliberation among thenir*
951]
84 GEORGE m.
Proceedingi against Jo$efh Gerrald
{9Si
selves, and being attended with the records
which had been cited on both sides, delivered
each man his opinion and judement publicly
in court, and so largely, that but two judges
argued in a da^/' Ten of them solemnly
pronounced their opinion for the risht claim-
ed bv the crown, and which it haa regularly
exercised for four years immediately preced-
ing: but, as lord Clarendon observes (lord
Clarendon was a monarchical man, much
attached to Charles IstA ** the judgment
proved of more credit ana advantage to the
genUeman condemned than to the kin^s
service ; however," adds he, ** these errors in
government were not to be imputed to the
court at that time, but to the spirit and over
activity of the lawyers of the privyniounciL
who should more carefully have preserved
their profession and its professors from being
profaned by those services which have ren-
dered both so obnoxious to reproach/'
Gentlemen, this circumstance, I appre-
hend, is an object very important for your
consideration, and whicfa^ I trust, will have
some influence in the guidance and direction
of your verdict ; inasmuch as you find that
in England, in a case where ten out of twelve
of the judges gave their opinions against the
defendant, yet, still their sentence was re-
versed at a higher tribunsd, that of parlia^
ment. The sentence was reversed, and even
Clarendon, a monarchical man, who comes
down to us under great purity of character,
tells you, *^ that these prosecutions were in-
stituted and carried on by the crown lawyers,
who were over active in the execution of their
dutjT, and had subjected them and the pro-
fession as obnoxious to reproach."
Gentlemen, the indictment contains against
inefour charges. I shall endeavour briefly
(in order that I may take up as little of your
time as possible) to state these charges speci-
fically, and to give as specific answers to tnose
charges, as the combined operation of my
understanding, and my conscience direct me
to jeive.
The first charge is of so extraordinary anature,
that it was some time before I could bring
myself to sit down to a serious refutation ot
it ; and upon any occasion not so important
as the present, I should either have combated
it with the weapon of ridicule (of which,
even, it is hardly deserving), or have thrown
it behind me with silent, contempt. I have
been charged with making use of French
terms, though it has been proved, as I shall
presently show, that this charge, ridiculous as
it is, is also fallacious.
Gentlemen, it is a most extraordinary thing,
that such a char^ should be made in a coun-
try, azainst a native of that part of the kine-
dum, I speak not of Scotland, but of England,
where all our old law-proceeaings are in that
very language. The writings of the venerable
Littleton, whose Tenures contun the whole
doctrine of our law of landed property, upon
which my lord Coke, the great oracle of En-
I glish law, has written his Commentaries, are
' m the French language.
Britton, and o&cr writers of as great au-
thority, though of more remote antiquity, and
who are deemed the Jejgal patriarchs (as it
were) in the history of jurisprudence, wrote
in French; and the king himself, even at
this period, never gives his assent or refusal,
to any act of parliament which binds the suV«
ject, without expressing himself in the laQ*
guage of that country.
C^ntlemen, I say not this for the purpose
of vindicating mysaf firom these charges, for
it has been proved to you, clearly, from the
evidence of ROss, that these French terms
were of his own insertion. But I cannot help
thinking that a spirit of malevolence dictated
that part of the charge, and that these invi-
dious insertions were made for the purpose of
infusing into your minds an idea that t wisb-
ed to co-operate with France, with whom we
are now at war : and I am the more autho-
rized to state this, as the first indictment,with
which I was served, was totally devoid of these
charges, and they have only been introduced
in the second. %t these terms were the
pepper and salt to season the dish, for the
gratification of the palate of the crown law-
yers, and I, it seems, was to be ofiered up,
like another Theyestes, as a victim for the
banquet
Gentlemen, the next charge against me is«
that of having used the word citizen. It was sua
upon a former occasion by the solicitor gene-
ral, that the use of the term was in itself in*
nocent, and in many circumstances might
undoubtedly be proper; but here again, tie
made a distinction. If a man, in tne 3^ear
1745 (said he) had walked the streets with a
white cockade, it would have been highly cri-'
muiaf ; but now the action would be perfectly
harmless, because there is no party existinjg
amongst us, of an attachment to whom it
might be interpreted as an emblem.
But, genUemen, I hope your understand-
^ ings will not be perverted by language of this
kind, as you must see a most material and
essential difference, between marchmg up the
street with a white cockade, and usmg the
term citizen. The using of this terra, though
it may by some be deemed ridiculous, can, by
none, be judged criminal. The word citizeo
is a term of peace, and denotes that relation-
ship in whicli we stand to each other, as
members of the same community, for the
performance of our civil duties ; whereas the
wearing of a cockade is the emblem of a mi- ^
litary occupation, and in the year 1745, was a
particular and avowed emblem of hostility to
the government of the country.
Gentlemen, the next part of the charge is,
that these meetings were illegal and seditious.
Now their illegality, I apprehend, must de-
pend either upon one or other of these three
principles; either on the name Convention
which we took, the principles which tha^
convention intended to establish^ or the man-
S^S]
far Sediiiott*
A. D. 1794.
[954
ner ki ivliieli theyeoBducted themaelveB
^eymet. Take away these tluee things, aod
DO charge remunsy copsequentlyno ground
«f cricninaltty.
With regard to the first, our assumption of
the name of Convention. I am sure your own
understandinss will inform you, and it is a
position to which the crown lawyers have as-
{sentedy that to take a particular name does
not constitute a crime. Many respectable
gentlemen, in pomt of fortune and talents,
met in a convention, expresd|y so called^ for a
reform in the Scottish boroughs, in Edin-
burgh ; and though their views were different
from ours, still it shows, that the bare as-
Aimption of that name, does not constitute
an offence in the eye of the law. Our crime
must then depend, either upon the principles
which the British convention intended to es-
tablish, or the manner in which they conduct-
ed themselves when met.
Gentlemen, in a cause so sacred es the pre-
sent, I would scorn to tetl a lie to save my
life. I boldly avow, and I hope tiie reasons
oa which 1 shall defend the principles, will
be equal to the confidence with which I make
the assertion, that our Object was, to procure,
by peacefiil means, anniud parliaments and
wiivorsal sufiirage; and, in so doing, notwith-
standing all the declamation that has been
urged against it, I shall endeavour to convince
you that the establishment of these principles
IS not only conformable to every maxim of
sound government, but congenial to the spirit
of the British constitution itself. In order,
gentlemen, to ascertain the first point, that
universal sufiirage (persons incapacitated by
-crimes and insanity excepted) is in fact con-
sonant to the first principles of all good so-
vemment, it will be necessary that we tuce
some short review of the fundamental prin-
ciples of society itself. The great object of
the social institution, the great object for
which men form themselves into society is, I
apprehend, the safe enjoyment of their lives
and property. If, then, m the earliest stages
of societjr, every man possessed a risht to the
preservation of'^his life, and also to tne peace-
able enjoyment of his property, it follows of
course, that the mode of government, which
is best calculated for the attainment of those
ends for which government itself was insti-
tuted, must be preciselv that very mode of
government, which all reasonable beings
would wish to see universally adopted amongst
men. Now, as every man claims from nature
a right of judging for himself, on the best
manner of promoting his own interest, and
as no individual ijs born with any distin^ish-
■ing mark of pre-eminence over his fellow-*
men, or with any character of exemption from
the ordinary frailties of human nature, so
^ .every act of authority exercised by one man
over another, or by a legislature over the col-
lective body of the people, unless it be exer-
cised bv the consent of the individual, or of
• ihe cdlective body of the people governed,
aAefSmusI
be an act of tyrsnny. The right of the
exercise of the understandinjg, is the noblest
privilege of ova nature, and indeed is insepa-
rable nrom our condition as moral agents;
moral agency, in ^t, being nothing else, but
the being guided by the dictates of our own
understandings and consciences, in preference
to those of another. And if, after the enact-
ment of positive law, we submit to its au-
thority, from which our private judgment
may Kave revolted, it is only because a greater
number of reasonable persons consenting to
the law, than of those dissenting from it, car-
ries with it the strongest presumption, that
the passing such law has been the result of a
greater portion of reason, than its refection
would have been — tiiat it is founded injustice
and truth, and therefore more conducive to
the great ends of society, inasmuch as it has
received the authoritative stamp of tb^ appro-
bation of the creater number or its memDcun^
who, in all well regulated communitieS| being
equally entiUed to a participation of its be<«
nefits, must of course oe equally interested in
promoting its welfare.
It is not true, that when men agree to ereet
a ^vemment, they give up any portion of
their rishts. No ; they only adopt a difierent
mode of emoying thenii They give up no-
thing; but by combining their own particular
force with the force of^othem, they adopt a
plan, by which they are enabled to possess
their rights in greater security. All just go-
vernment, therefore, being only a delegation,
it cannot be armed with more power than it
derives from the consent of them over whom
it is exercised. Now, as prior to the esta-
blishment of government, no man had a right
to take from another any property without
his consent, and as all just authori^ exercised
by any government must be derived from the
people, so the government (which is, in other
words, a natiomd association for genera] eood)
cannot of right exercise any power, whicn one
individual, before government was establish"
ed, was not authorized to exercise over ano-
ther. Hooker, to whom aueen Elizabeth al-
ways applied the just epitnets of learned and
judicious, asserts, that the principle which I
nave just stated, is the only solid foundation
of all legislative authority. Laws they are
not, says he, which public approbation bath'
not made so.— Hooker's Eeel€$. Pol, lib. t,
sect. 10. And Mr. Locke expressly says, that
** as government cannot be supported without
great charge ( a truth which we, Grod knows !
teel every day to our cost), so it is fit that
every one who enjoys his snare of the protec*
tion, should pa^ out of his estate his propor-
tion fur the maintenance of it. But still it
must be with his own consent, i. e. the con-
sent of the majority, giving it either by thenw
selves, or tiieir representatives chosen by
them. For if any one shall claim a power to
lay and levy taxes on the people, by his own
authority, and without such consent of the
people, he thereby iayades the fimdamental
955]
34 GEORGB IIL
Proceedings agamtt Jottph Gerrald
£SS6
law of property, axkl subverts the end of go-
vernment. For what propert^y have I in that
which another may, by right, take when he
pleases to himself?'' Here then, gentlemen,
IS the doctrine of universal suffrage expressly
laid down. For as no man, in a state of so-
ciety, can be altogether without property,
either inherited or acquired by his daily la-
bour, and as every man in the country pays a
tax to government, either directly to the tax-
gatherer, or indirectly through the commo-
ities which he consumes, which all taxes
ultimately affect, so it appeacs to me clear as
the light of heaven, that every man of adult
years, not incapacitated by crimes or insanity,
has a right to a vote; otherwise he may ex-
claim, in the language of Mr. Locke, '* what
property have I m Uiat which another may
Dv right take when he pleases to himself?"
11^ government, then, gentlemen, which is
not a government of consent, must of neces-
sity, be a government of usurpation. — ^Afler
all, there are but three modes (except a man
allows himself to be a public menaicant) in
which money passes from man to man ; bv
fierce, by fraua, or consent The first, it will
not be contended, except by conquerors or
highwaymen, can ever estabUsh a just ground
ofpossession. Bjr the operation of the second
principle, I am airaid, it does pass, whenever
a man pays a tax in a government in which
he is not represented. During the American
war, lord Camden, the first law autliority in
England, and now president of the council,
repeatedly asserted, that '' taxation and repre-
sentation were inseparable." Now, if his
lordship meant anj^ tning by the word repre-
sentation, he certainly must have meant ade-
quate representation, for no other deserves
Ine name, or answers the end ; which adequate
representation is well explained by sir Thomas
Smith, a writer of great note and authority,
in his Commonwealth of England, p. 37.
" Every Englishman,'' says he, '' is intended
to be present in parharoent, either in person,
or by procuration and attorney, of wnatever
pre-eminence, state, dignity, or quality soever
he be, from the prince, to the lowest person
in England. And the consent of the parlia-
ment IS taken to be every man's consent."
Here is the doctrine of universal suffrasc, laid
down in words as strong as the English lan-
guage can afford. It was then to repair these
ravages, which time, whom my lord Bacon
terms the greatest innovator, had occasioned,
that the British convention sat ; it was not to
deform our constitution, but to restore it; it
was not to promote, but to prevent its des-
truction, that we assembled. Besides, gentle-
men, if the principle which Mr. Locke asain
states (see book on Government, p. 356.) be
just, *' that the preservation of property be-
ing the great end for which men enters into
societv," It necessarilv supposes and requires,
that the people shoula have property, without
wliich they must be supposed to lose that by
entering into society, which wa/i the end for
which they entered into it; too gross an ub*
surdity for any man to own. Men, therefore,
in society, having property, thev have such a
right to the goo<S, which, by the law of the
community are theirs, nobody bath a right te
take their substance, or any part of it from
them, without their own consent. If suck
then, gentlemen, la the principle which ought
to regulate the intercourse between mftn and
man. in the common affairs of life ; by how
much more ought that principle to be observ-
ed by the legis&ture itself, to whom the mosi
sacred of all truths has been committed, and
whose breach of any sound and saltttapy prin-
ciple will be the more criminal, in proportion
as such breach will be more extensively nd^
chievous ?
These are the principles of a roan who has
a long time deservedly passed for one of the
greatest masters of reasoning which £i|£^4
ever prodliced ; who wrote in express viodi^
cation of the revolution; and who, after*
wards, held a place under king William (and
would to God places had been always as wop-
thilv bestowed !) until he went to receive Uie
final reward of his labours, lirom that Being
who will always confer it upon those who de*
serve it well. Gentlemen, it is worthy of re-
mark, that, not only speculative writers upoji
government, but writers upon municipal law^
sir William Blackstone himself, ajudge, should
lay down the same principle, not in expreae
terms, indeed, but, as you will see, very strongly
by impUcation. He says^ ^ In a free state, every
man who is supposed a free agent/' (and unlesa
a man is incapacitated by crimes or insaniU^
every rational being may be so denominatea)
^' ought to be in some measure hb own gov
vemor.'* Black. Comment. Vol. 1, p. 15&
Now, if words have any meaning what does
this establish but the doctrine of universal
suffrage? For I know of no other definition
of liberty, than that tliose who are bound bj
the law, should have a share in the m^dng
of it, either j^rsonally, or bv deputy | and no
other idea of slavery than tnat state in which
men are governed without this consent Men
who make laws for me, may indeed impu-
dently tell me that I am free, far men may
lie ; but unless I have some share in the ap-
pointment of those who are to govern me, I
can, in no sense, be said to be my own go^*
vemor; but, on the contrary, have no more
concern with the sovemment of my country,
than I have with tnose of Turkey or Morocco.
Now, if the strict observance of thb principle
be necessary to give government a moral
right to take away the property of the subject,
in how far greater degree should the same
principle be observed, as alone constituting a
solid ground of authority, which can ero»
power the legislation to frame law^ for a
breach of which men are to be deprived of
theh lives? — It has been said also that the
plan of universal sufiBn^ge is visionary and im*'
practicable. But thb observation, if |nie^
thou(^ it may maik the plan itself as ab3ur^
95TI far
must neeessftrily discham ffpom blame all
those who have proposed iL For a nonentity
like a phantom, is not to be dreaded, and a
plan that is attended with no danger is cer-
tainly no object of legal prosecution. No,
genttemen, our Creator, I am confident, has
placed every thing that is valuable, every
thine that is necessary ibr our happiness,
wiUim the grasp of human attainment. If
then we should wantonly indulge wishes, and
pursue objects, which are neither proper for
CIS, nor attainable, the true and only punish-
ment should be (as it must be) the frustration
of our hopes, ana the anguish of our disap-
pointment. If, like children, we cry for the
moon, like children we should cry on.
But, fortunately fnr me, gentlemen, my ex-
perience enables me to give a flat contradic-
tion to the position advanced. I myself re-
■ded, during four years, in a country where
every man who paia taxes had a right to vote ;
I mean the oommonwealth of Pennsylvania,
t was an e^^e-witness of manv elections which
took place in Philadelphia, the capital of the
stale, an industrious and populous city, and
can safely assert, that no one riot ever en-
sued. For in truth, gentlemen, the represen-
tative had no interest distinct from his con-
stituents; the office which he undertook was
rather a burthen than a benefit, and as the
government was too poor to purchase, and
the people too vhrtuous to barter away their
liberties (even if the case had been otherwise)
to the deputy, though he had every opportu-
nity to serve, had no temptation to sell his
constituents. What then has been found
hy experience to be ¥rholesome food for Ame-
licans, can never prove hurtful or poisonous
to Britons, the parent stock from wlK>m Ame-
ricans are descended.
• Gentlemen, I am aware that every practice
and institution is alone defensible upon its
ewn intrinsic merits, and the reason of the
thing; yet the adopUon of any principle, by
men eminent for virtue and learning, is cer-.
tainly no small presumption of the soundness
of the principle itself. Gentlemen, sir Wil-
Ram Jones, a name too distineuished in lite-
rature to derive splendour From any enco-
mimns I can bestow upon it, and who has
acted as a judge for more than twelve years
in India, previously to his departure published
a tract in which he vindicated the doctrine of
ttiiversal sufirage. At a vciy early period of
my life, I was honoured with the friendship
and patronage of this gentleman, and I am
•ure he would deeply feel, even aAer this
lon^ separation, any calamity which might
befai me ; a calamity (if it be one) certainly
not altogether, but in some measure, perhaps,
produced by conversation with those whose
practices were pure, and whose principles I
eonceived to be just, and who were therefore
ebjects of reverence among men. Yet this
tery gentleman, at this very period, holds an
•flSoe of great trust and great emolument in
lus majes^s important settlement of Bengal,
t
A. D. 1794.
[958
and unseals those sacred fountsdns of justice
which gladden and refiresh fifteen millions of
men.
Oentlemcn, having now proved to you that
the principles of which I am accused must
be, in fact, the principles of all good govern-
ment, and that they have been supported by
the greatest of all human authorities; I shall
now prove, I tnist, equally to your satisfac-
tion, from incontrovertible historical docu-
ments, that they are also congenial to the
spirit of our constitution.
Gentlemen, Montesqtiieu has told us, that
the rudiments of our excellent constitution
are to be sought and found in the woods of
Germany ; where, as Tacitus informs us, all
were free, and where all were entitled to de-
liberate upon matters of national importance.
No proposal could pass into a law, binding
upon the people, which had not been ap-
proved by the people.
^ De Germania. De minoribus rebus/^rtV
eipet consultant, de majoribus omnes, Ita
tamen ut ea, quoque, quorum penes plebei»»
arbitrium est apud pnncipes proiractentur.^
I have adopted the reading of Golems and
£adalius in preference to the common read-
ing which is pertraoterUury and which corres-
ponds to the cj-foCBXtoto'deKf of the Greeks^ the
proper business of the ancient senates.
Gentlemen, in the earliest stages of society,
when commerce was scarce budding, almost
every inhabitant held a certain portion of
land : and as land alone, in those days, wa»
the fund from which taxes were raised to
support the expenses of government, so every,
lana-holder (or which description was almost
every member of the community) had a i^ht
to vote. Squire, in his view of the Anglo-
Saxon jgovernment, a book of very profound
research, — sentlemen. Squire was archdeacon
of Bath, and afterwards bishop of St. David's,
and it is certainly no part of the episcopal
function to ' disseminate seditious doctrines
among the people,— Squire tells us, the affairs
of the country were, at that time, conducted'
by the king;, the wilenagcmot and the mycle-
gemot. The witenagemot, or kind's court,
was an assembly of the best and the wisest
men in the nation, corresponding to what our
privy council is, or (I beg pardon of ourances^
tors) corresponding to what a privy council
ought to be. The rayclegeraot, on the other
hand , were a body chosen by the people at large,i
corresponding to what the principles of our con-
stitution suppose the parliament should foe, a
real representation of^the people. " The wi-
tenagemot (says Squire, see p. 100) were per-
sons supposed to be best acquainted with the
exigencies of the public. It was their duty
to propose what they thought most expedient
for the good of the whole ; the new laws, es-
pecially, seem all to have been drawn up and
prepared by them, though nothing which they
did of this kind was obligatory to the com-
munity, until it had receiv^ the general con-
firmation.'' How was this general confirma-
Dl t] 84 GEORGE UL Pneteib^M^Umt JMfh Gamtd
Plf
17ciw,tiie fact is, that tkededaiatioB issigu-
ed by Mr. Sinclair.
fTiffiett.-— That is a ciiciSBistaiKe that I
had forgotten.
. Mr. SoUeU&r Ge»eral,-^Tht lact is, he
signed the first page of the declaration^ and
refused to sign the rest ; that is the fact.
James Lyon sworn. — Examined by Mr.
MoTUgamery,
Did you execute a warrant against Blr.
Gerrald and Mr. Margarot? — ^Yes; I went
to the Black Bull to inquire for these gen-
tlemen ; the waiter acknowledged they were
in the house, but declined going with me to
their rooms; he told me the number of tbdr
rooms, and the first room I went to was Mr.
Gerrald and Mr. MargaroVs. I knocked at
the door, and thev desired me to come in,
which I did. I toid them I had a warrant to
carry them before the sheriff; they were in
bed; they got up immediately; I coUected
fogether the papers that were in the room.
Mr. Margarot proposed putting them in a
trunk, and asked Mr. Gerrald if he would
put ius into it, he consented ; they were dl
put in, and Mr. Margarot took the key into
Lis possession. When he was comins away,
says he, '* I do not give you the trunk, you
may take it at your peril.'' I told him I was
not scrupulous about that, and immediately
gave the trunk to a chairman, to put it into
|k coach. I looked out Mr. Sinclair's papers
likewise, and took them at the same time.
. Speak to Mr. Gerrald's and Mr. Margarot's
papers first. — ^I must rehearse this: when
we came to the sheriff-clerk's office in the
coach, I left the trunk and the other papers
in the office, and sent a message to-Mr. Scott
io infcHrm him of what I had done, and then
I got a messajge from him to brinj Mr. Sin*
dair in a cbau-. I went to Mr. Smclair and
told him ; and theii there came a message
that they wondered I was so long ; and then
there came another message to let him re^
main at his lodging, which I did till between
9 and 10 o'clock at night.
When was the trunk opened ? — I think it
itras two days after.
Were you present when it was opened ?—
Iwas.
Who had the key ?— Mr. Margarot.
All the time ? — 1 know nothing to the con*
trary.
Was there any inventory made up of the
papers? — ^Yes, at the sheriff-clerk's office;
there was none made at their lodgings.
When the trunk was to be opened, Mr. Mar-
garot would not give up the key, and it was
proposed to get a smith to break it open, but
It was delayed that day. The next day Mr.
Margarot was brought before the sheriff-sub-
stitute and Mr. Soott; he said he would not
give it up, but held it in his hand, so [repre-
senting the manner of it], and said it must be
taken from him by force; Mr. Scott was
going to take it from him^ but Mr. Davidson
said aoy he m«st not do it| some oter body
must do it, and then Mr. Mack gave a grips
at it, and took it fipom him; it was then open-
ed, an inventory was made^ and I put my
initials at the back of it
Look at these papers, and see if these an
the papers you round in Mr. Gerrald's room.
— ^Yesy thy are; they have my initials upoa
them.
Was Mr. Sinclair in a separate room firom
Mr. Gerrald and Mr. Margarot when you exe-
cuted the warrant ?— Yes.
Were the oapers separate ?— Yes.
Aad yoo Drought them with you to the
8heriff-clerk*s office ?*-Yes; and Mr. Mar)^
rot and Mr. Genakl were in the chanot
with me.
What did you do with Mr. Sinclair's pa->
pers?^I left them in the sheriff^derk's office.
Were you present afterwards, when they
were opened? — Yes.
How long after, was it? — I am not certain;
it might be a few days after.
Did they seem to be in the same situadoQ
as when you brought them into the office ?— r
They appeared to me so; they were in my
handkerchief, my name was in the handfces*
chief.
Were you present when the inventojy of
them was made outP — ^Yes.
Was Mr. Sinclair there ?— Yes.
Were any papers given back to him ? — Yes.
Did he take them? — ^He took all that were .
given him, which was some that were not
considered material to the business in hand.
Jamei Zyonf cross-examined by Mr. CUrk.
You have said that you carried Mr. Sinclair'a
papers to the office yourself ?— Yes.
And left them there? — Yes.
Was there any objection made by any per-
son concerning the manner in which you nad
secured those papers in the sherifrclerk'a
office^ or any where else?-^d nobody tell
you It was exceedingly dangerous to keep
those papers unsealed up ?— i do not recot*
lect any such thing.
Did nobody say that other papers might b6
put in, that md not belong to Mr. Sinclair? —
To the best of my remembrance no person
stated any such thing: and, with humble
submission to you, my lord, I went from th^
sheriff-clerk's office to bring off Mr. Sinclair,
and I was not back till 9 or 10 o'clock at
night, so that the papers were in the sheriff*^*
office all that time.
Did you take any notice of Mr. Sinclair's
papers when you seized them,? — ^I found some
of them lying upon the desk^ and one paper
I got lying below the bed.
Have you any othfjr means of knowing
that these are the same but that- of kaowing
your own handkerchief? — Upon my word!
do not think there was any thing else.
Mr. SolicUor GeneraL — ^At the sheriffs
clerk's office, did you deliver them into any
body's custody ?—• There were two ^of Mf»
1
^m
J^fw ffPfflMP^^^Pb
i(. d: tm.
Cd]4
il«^ bill I #8^!to AUttifed'I wft»ilottlie)f«v F
dbktssay, fi^ihftatft6»; MMflthiak Pd^aii^
fbetfr f(y likto cit^'of^ thetn.
A day or two afteiHrardft^ wki^ii ydu sow
-iifh^' bukidte^ 6)^ned)* htfd you attyreasott to
1>eUe^ or su^beel- Itiai aiiy alteration had
b^n madle MNo, i&obe af all ; ^^y ajipMred
to me to 1)9 in the sinne iftate.
Hr.Ofif«eji«^Did*}fwseeMk'. G^brce Sin*
i^lair at any time with'lkbr. CliaHe» Eclair? —
Yes.
Did he say i^ny thing' to you iipon this
Mge^^ aboul^ theli< beins tied up loosely?^
recollect yourself. — ^I will. Have patience;
Ittfd I Will i%edlleel-
t&r^ JUHkt CArAc^Who is Mr. GeoM
Sii^clair ? — ^He is Mt. Sinclair of Bridee End.
f naVe some fiiint* remeftibranee that' he said
somethine about an inventory, but I do not
l^edlleet that it was while I was with Mr.
Charles Sindftir; I do not know but' it was
itfler tKev'iiirere examined. Tarn not sure.
Mt ChfJe, — War Mr. George Sinclair pre^
9etit when the inventory was taken P—H^
was not in the stteriff^lerk's chamber that
day.
Did- yoQ' fke lifh George Sinclair tither
Ikffbreor after taking the mventory?— I saw
him ^at dav that! was waStine with Mr!
Charles Shiclair ; and^ if I mbtake not, he
was over at the office, but I think not the
diay'that the papefs were examined.
Ravevou any recollection of any thing of
this kind being said by Mr. Goor^ Sinclair?
-^I cannot sav; I cannot be positive;-! am
ppon my oath, and I must be guarded in
every respect:
Did he not tell you that it was wrong and
dingeflMis not to inventory these papers
when they were seized ?— To the best of my
redoHeetiob he said something, that it was a
jiHy but' there had been an inventory, or
something of that nature.
• 'J$upk Mgekwmim, -Examined by Mr.
^ Mantgimiery.
Do yon attend the sheriff-cletk's office ?-—
tes.
, You ate'derk ther6?^Yes.
Were you present at the execution of the
warrant against William Skirving, secretary
V> the British convention ?~Veil.
Did you seethe papers found in his pos-
session f — Yes.
Was therfe an' inventory made of them ? —
Ves ; they were put into a bag, and s^ed by
Mr*. Dragwall and Mr. Skirving.
Did you' see the inventory of them?— I
came in while the declaration wi&s making',
uAd I sa# the inventory made out.
Were' the pApers acknowledged by Sklr-
Vln^f— ^Yes; and the papers that were of no
consequence were given oack to him.
limine acknowledge these papers to be the
pixitt ihat were put mio the ba^ ?— Yes.
Wet* you' inf the shei'iflkierk's office ^f^heh
VOL. xxm.
somi» papers were brought in a tnmkit_Yes.'
Who brought them r— I believe it was
James Lyon; th^ messenger ^ tha trunk cam«
intb ihy possession vety soon* afler.
Didyou writoan inveatoi^ of the papers
in that box I — ^Yes=.
Were saay other papers brddght beside^
those tftot came ib the box?— ^Therd \$en
sonle papers which came in a na^^ii.
Dia you keep those papers?—- le^.
Did ybu'keep them locleedup^?^ Y^s.
Did you- see an inventory made of thetA
likewise ?— Yea.
And 'they were in your possession till th^
inventory was made li^-Yes, and after it too.
Lord Eskgrove. — During the time it was
in youi< possession, were there any paper?
taken oqt or any put in N-^None.
Mr. Siflicitor' Qenerat. — ^Was it under your
Itick and key all the timei^It wa».
Mr. Mantgoniety.'^Vlxve you the chatge in
general of all the papers in that office ?^^Yes.
Is that the inventory that itas^nade up of
Mr. Sinclair's papers ? — It is;
Look at the bundle of papers and see if
they are tbepaperain the inventory'.-^[Looks
over them.] My initials are upon the back
of every one of these papers.
Dd you see Mt. Scott's initials upon them
likewise ? — ^Yes, and Mr. Davidson's likewise^
Joseph Mack cross-examined by Mr. Clerk,
You spoke of some papers beSng brbught
loose in a napkin. — ^Were you' in the omco
when they were brought? — I cannot say po^
sitively that I was in the office, bdt I got
them soon after.
You cannot recollect then, positively, who
put them into your bands ?-*-! believe 1 found
them' in the sheriff's room.
Lord Juitice CUrk. — Was the sheriff there
himself ?— Mr. Davidton, Mr. Scott, and Mr.
Dingwall were in the room.
Mr. Clerk, — ^Were they upder the chaige of
any particular person ?— No; they w^^ing
in the room, and I took them owajr .
I think you said these papers wM aller-
. wards locked up ? — ^Yes.
When did you lock them up f— After th%
examinations that day were finish^.
At what time was that?— 'I cannot exactly
recollect ; it might be about nine oVlock.
Lyon brought these papers l6b^ in a nap-
kin, and the Box was locked ? — Yes.
Ixtrd Justice Cltrk.^-^And the napkin wai
not locked? — ^No.
Afr. Clerk, — Is it not usual when you seise
papers to seal them up ? — ^Ves.
were you present when the inventory wai
taken ? — Yes.
And Mr. Sinclsir was present? — Yes.
Were you present when an obiection was
taken, either by Mr. Sinclair or for him, upon
the ground that the papers were not sealed
up ? — I do not recollect it.
Do you recollect Mr. Sinclair's declaration
upon taking the inventory?— Yes.
3 N
915]
34 GEORGE m.
Proceedings againti Joeeph GerrM
[916
What did he say when this was dbing? —
He seemed veiy easy upon the businesSy and
behaved very much like a gentleman
Did he say the papers were his } — ^He did
not deny that they were his; he took back
the papers that were returned to him.
Did he say any thing about a protest ?^-
YeSy he offered to take a protest and Mr.
Davidson told him it was not usual to receive
protests in these cases.
Upon what ground did he ofier to take a
nrotesl? — Because his papers were taken
rrom him, as he imaginea illegally.
_ •
John Dingmall sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Mowtgomefy,
Were you present at a search made in Mr.
Skirving^s house for papers ? — ^Yes.
Did you find any papers there? — ^Yes.
Were they put into a has in your presence?
—They were put into two ba^.
And were they sealed ? — ^Yes.
In Mr. Skirving's presence? — ^Yes, I put
my seal upon one end, and he put his seal
upon the other.
Did you see those bags afterwards ?— Yes.
Where? — ^In the sheriff- clerk's office.
Look and see if these are any part of them ?
— -litis paper, or scroll of minutes, I found
lying upon the table in Mr. Skirvingf s room.
Did you see an inventory made up of these
papers ? — ^Yes.
it was fiurly made up?^Yes.
Did you assist in making it up ? — ^I Ottde
out Mr. Skirving's declaration.
Were you present when Mr. Sinclair*s
papers were brought into the sheriff-clerk's
omce ?— No.
Thomas Cockhum sworn.— -Examined by Mr.
Afultrmther,
Did you belong to the society of the Friends
of the People ?— I was a member of that so-
ciety.
Were you a delegate to the convention
that met in Edinburgh in October last? — ^Yes.
Did you attend that that afterwards met in
November? — ^Yes; the British convention.
What was the occasion of the meetii^ of
the second convention in November ? — The
occasion, so far as occurs to me was, the ar-
rival of some deleeate^ from England.
Was the panel at the bar one of those de-
legates from England, in consequence of
whose arrival that second convention met ? —
I always understood that Mr. Gerrald was
one of them.
When you were divided lata smaller bodies
what did you call yourselves ?---They were
first,! think, denominated divinons; afler-
wards sections, and there was another name
which I do not recollect.
What name were they most frequently
called by ? — ^I do not recollect at present
Do yon recollect any institution of what
vras called Primary assemblies; — No.
Do you recollect their being divided into
Primary Societies ? — No.
Did you ever hear departments mentioned?
— I do not recollect. '
Had you different kinds of committees ap-
pointed ? — ^Yes.
Do you recollect the names of any of those
committees ? — I think there was one of them
designed the committee of union.
Had you any committee of organization?*-
I think there was.
Was there any that took charge of your
money matters ; how was tliat oesignea ? —
They were not very regular ; but there was a
committee instituted for that purpose, which
was usually called the committee of finance.
And likewise committees of instruction ? — I
do not recollect that.
For instructing different parts of the king-
dom, such as the Highlands, and giving them
political knowledge?-— There was a motion, I
recollect, for promoting constitutbnal know-
ledge.
Do you recollect that there was a commit-
tee for that purpose ? — So far as I recollect at
present there was mention made of a com-
mittee for promoting constitutional know-
ledge.
Had you likewise a committee of secrecy ^
— ^It may be called a committee of secrecy,
but there was no name that I know of given
to it by the convention.
Which carried on its proceedings more pri-
vately than the other committees, from whieh
it got its name, I suppose of a committee of
secrecy? — Yes.
When you met what did you call your
meetings ?— They were most frequently called
Sittings ; but I paid very little attention to
that circumstance.
Did you ever hear of any person who had
deserved well getting the honours of the sit^
ting?--I think I have heard in one of the
committees some such thing of a single per-
son ; humorously it might nave been men-
Uoned by some humourous man, and I do
not doubt but it might he taken down in the
minutes, but those minutes were never au-
When you first met in October^ what did I thenticated by tlie convention, because it
you call yourselves ? — The convention of the
Friends of the People; and afterwards the
British Convention, as I understood, but I
was not present at the time.
Did you attend frequently? — I attended
frequently, and was absent frequently.
And what title did you give each other ? —
There were various designations, but citizen
was the one they most commonly used*
viras designed that they were to have a com*-
mittee to revise them. ,
Lord Etkgrove, — Was any person, a stranger*
ever admitted to a sitting in the convention ^
— All I recollect is, that the honours of the
sitting were mentioned.
• Lord Eikgravc-^To the best of your recol-
lection, was any stranger ever allowed to sijt
in the convention, upon a motion of that
917]
Jar Sedifiaiu
sort ?— I do sot TecoUect. I think I recollect
it WW rather honourable mention than ho-
nours of the sitting that I heard.
• Mr. Anitruther, — ^When you received pe-
cuniary assistance, was honourable mention
made of itP — ^It is that that occurs to my re-
collection most, but I cannot be rery positive;
I only recollect something of the word ho-
nouraDle mention, or something of that na-
ture.
How did you date your proceeding on
what took place in the convention f Did you
take the year of God in the common way, or
in any other way? — I cannot recollect.
Did you ever hear of the first yeaf of the
British convention, for example? — I cannot
recollect ; I never looked in the minutes.
Was it not the practice in the convention
to read over the subsequent day what passed
the day before ? I was not there till the bu-
siness of the day was generally over.
Did you never hear what was the manner
of their dating their minutes ?— 1 do not re-
collect any thmg about it ; I cannot say either
one wav or the other ; I was seldom present
when that business was ifme ; but I once re-
member hearing it read before the conven-
tion went to busmess.
Lord Juttiu Clerk, — Have you no recollec-
tion of hearing of the first year of the British
convention? — I think I remember hearing
something of that kind ; but I cannot say
upon what occasion.
Mr. Anitnaker.-^IM you ever see the
panel there ? — Yes.
Did he frequently speak there?— Not so
frequently as others.
Did he ever act as preses ? — ^I do not recol-
lect ever seeing him act as chabman in my
life.
Did you ever see him act as chairman at
any of the committees ?— I was not a mem-
ber of any of the committees.
Did you happen to be present at a meeting
on the 8 1st or November, when the measure
of a seueral meeting of the Scotch and Eng-
lish delegates was proposed ? — ^There was a
committee of union appointed to draw up
regulations with respect to the people in
England and the people in Scotland, whose
minds mis^t be one, with respect to the sub-
ject of reform, in order that they might be
united in their endeavours.
Do you recollect upon that occasion the
panel at the bar makme a speech ? and you
say he made a few speeches, so that ^ou will
be the better able to recollect ? — I said he did
not speak so frequently as some.
Do you remember that speech? — ^I think
there was a conversation one evening with
respect to the union, and to the best of my
xeoollection he did speak upon that occasion ;
I was there part of the time.
' Were you at that time in the practice of
reading the Gazetteer when published? — I
tised to read part of them.
Pid prou read that in which Mr. Gerndd's
A. D. 17M. [918
speech appeared, of which you say you heard
a part? — I cannot say but I might have seen.
it, but at this distance of time 1 can say very
little about it. I make no doubt but I read
it.
Did you think that the account you saw
in the paper agreed with what you heard in
the meeting? — Mv memory is not so tena-
cious as to recollect a long speech; I cannot
be very positive.
But in substance did it appear to you to be
the same that was deliverea by Mr. Gerrald?
— ^All I can say is* that I am ready to give a
candid answer to any thing that I know ; but
as to what may be read fi^m a newspaper, I
cannot say.
Mr. Solicitor Oeneral, — The question is,
whether the account given in the Gaaetteer
agreed with what you heard in the conven-
tion ? — So far as I recollect, I did not observe
any thing remarkably deficient in it.
Look at that paper and read it. — ^With re-
spect to newspapers, 1 hope the Court will
allow me this, which I think is fair, that any
question that is put to me,. or read to me, I
snail endeavour to give a fair answer; but as
for reading it, I willnot be concerned with it.'
"Mr. Arutruther, — Were you present when a
motion was made, by Mr. Cailender, to this
purpose, '' that in case the minister, or any
other member, bring into the House of Comr
mons a motion for a convention bill, as
passed in Ireland, for preventing the people
from meeting according to their just rients
by the revolution, the same motion shall be
noticed to the delegates of the respective so-
cieties, immediately to meet in convention to
assert their rights ? — To the best of my recol-
lection, I heard a motion of Mr. Callender's
read one night to that purport.
Was that motion made the subject of dis-
cussion at a future meeting ? — ^I do not recol-
lect being present upon that business till it
was taken up as a report returned from a
committee.
Who was it that read that report? — I think
it was Mr. Sinclair.
Did you read those parts in which the mi-
nutes of this convention were given an ac-
count of? — ^Yes.
Was any resolution adopted in the conven-
tion in consequence of this re|>ort? — So far as
I recollect, the convention conversed up-
on the report a long time ; and, if I remem-
ber right, they agreed, that in case of a con-
vention bill. simUar to that which had passed
in the parliament of Ireland, being brousht
into the parliament of England, that that
should be considered as a reason why they
should hold a meeting, which was mentioned
as a meeting of emergency.
Did you bear of any other cases in which
they were to meet? — I think there were
others in the report; but I am not able to
say positively whether they were taken into
the consideration of the convention.
Do you recollect any other cases?*-! think
94^ 84 GW9fi»
rtoeeedingt,i(gim4 Jttiepk Qtnald
^9»
oMqf ]lh«9 w«8|i ^augp^Mioa ofikm fliUit
(porous act; and I think there waf jDentH»n
iDade of the laqdy;)^ of foreign troops, or a fo*
r^^ invasion, I ^X3^ Aot certain which.
Lori Justice C^rft.— Did you think thej
nMEhtnot be both used? — I cannot saf.
JHr. Anttruthfir, — What troGf» did you sup-
pose ftbose foreign troops were? — I cannot
0^y ; H ipight he the troops ^ any country ; it
was in a general sense.
• Did you auppose they were to meet won
the landing of trooftt who were our c^iMs»
though Aot British troo^ ; f^r ifistanc^ iica-
siaosaod Qanoverians? — ^As to <the intention
of that, it is what f canoot enter into.
Upon the oath you have now taken, did
you hear that t^ cosvention were to a^eet
li^KMi the landii^ of Hessians or Hanoyeriana
in this country? — I cannot recollect.
You ^yft ttneotioned three cases of emer*
g^ency ; was any aention made of the sttapejfr-
aioa of the act for preventing wropgoqa uii-
PP'isonnient? — I do not recollect
Where were th^ la meet?-rrl kn^w aot.
Who was to fix the place of meeting ?— To
the best of my refoWectioOy libere was acon-
mijtlee appointed (ox that purpose.
Were thtey to keep it secret till it ha^^eMl ?
-r-They were not to lell it ; there was a oeaA-
denjUaf trust repQsed in a few, that th^ were
to £x the place and imA ways and aieans.
Was there any mei^ti^ of sealed letters
bjOAf delivered to It^m, fiaii^ the pla/oa of
meeting which were not t/9 he opened till de-
livered Iw^ the deletes to their oonstituents?
-vl think I heard a vieatioB made i>f aesJed
letters, but then I do npt sav that Ih^t was
tbs mode that was de^ermioau.
^ , What number was tp proceed to bMsiness
in case of these events happening ?-r-I cannot
be positive upon that sul^ect.
Was this resolution come to in a wore so-
Umn manner than any other resolutioos in
the cooyention ?-:-So far as I recollect, the
convention deliberated upon it in a very de»
cent, serious manner; and at last, they re-
solved it standing;.
Tliey all sUMMf up, to declare their purpose
of carryins it into execution more solemnly
than usual? — We all stood up; and I think
we did so upon another occasion.
Do you recollect what that other occasion
was ? — I rather have heard of it than was pne-
sent at it.
Wa9 it at the propos^ for a unipn f-rri was
npt present.
Or upon their changing the deugaation of
theit iKieetiug to that oT tKe Britisa Conven-
tion ? — 1 was not presoDt,
Did they, in passing this resolution, deckre
before God ana the world, that they would
dp so and so ? — 1 recollect thp expressions be-
iere God and the world were made use of.
Did you ever h^ar such solemn expressions
OMd^ use of upon any other occasions ?<^I do
iK»t recollect.
Pid t|ke papal iwUqs a spqpcb up^n th^t OP^
I oaeiqB, <rf>Br |(iip iesfli«|p» .w»a<e» ^^to»|l^|r
oasaed?— So £ur as I rece^leo^ Mr. XTanqri^
did speak, after the resohitioflL
JM you pi^ atten^n to ^ spa^M^^i?^-
Yes.
Did you afterwuds «ea4 that apqe(^ ig tha
Gaaetteer?— 4 do i|M>t ^ouht but I m^a^ ja
readins the Gaaettecr.
Aodl^d the account iiB the GaBot^eer inHcb
differ firom what you had heard ? — I can <»
no more -than I have already aaid, that \ i^m
pot observe aoythimgxeaiarkably apnoni^aw*
ipit.
Was it a cool dettbai»le kipdofsyiwohj or
waa it warqi and aniinated.?--4 4o iMt leool-
lect; but Mr. Genald spakf in his iisvit
tone.
SHbaMS Cocib5«fii cross-eniniQed by Mr.
Ckrk.
You said you were a s^embcr of the cai^
iwntion; what did you understand to be 4^
puiiposes lor which they nwt?-^The puiye>aa
vi general, for whidi the ooAventiop jpM^
was % reform in the British fifaiase of Kiomf
mo^is.
By what means dM the convention iataiid
to accomplish this reform? — The means, #0
% as I understood, that they intended to use
was, to endeavour to collect the minds af th*
people who were of the wa» opinion, uA, ipf-
I^al methods, . ta obtain ther phjeol, ii| %
peaceable manner, so far as I «i9den4ood.
Were they to petitipo fafiiftmeikt ?— It was
agreed upon in tne convention, as I under-
stooil, in Oclaber; but I waa mH present.
What did vou understand to be the ob|ecl
of the Biitish convamion which met in No-
vember?— I wAderstood M/thJag es«>eBtiai)jr
different from the convention that met ban
fore ; the only difiereoce was the accesrioii
of a number of del^ates from £ngland ; thair
design I nnderstooalo be the same.
You haye been aaked, whether Mr. Gerraki
made a speech upon the 91st of November;
now I beg leave to read it over to you, ami
then tell me if you recollect Mr. GenaU
making such a speech? — If there are any
words that I recollect I shall tell you.
Mr. Sameff.— He has already said, thai
when he read the Gaae^teer, theie was nOr
thing essentially difierent
Mr. CUrJt, — tie said, that he geperally read
the Gaaettcer, and he perceived nothing le-
markably deficient; he spoke generally. I
have not yet heard the witness lay, that Im
heard Mr. Gerrald make t;his speeeh^ whiala
seems to be ppiocipally founded on in the ilin
dictment ; and therefore X conceive it necea-
sary, that the fact should ha asaertainad,
whether the witness heard that speech* yan
or not
Mr. Solicitor General.^ can certainly hnro.
Qool^eetion, except this, that the witnatehaa
been axamiiia^ oa the part of the pipsactUiMVi
and has given all tha aasvers toia im
gim
tM]
^ feiBtfjUt
A. D. m96t.
[Mt
^JUM I nh^ >nuke to the feaUenHio «f the
jyry ; that this witness h«» «^tttBudiod «eiM«id
iMeViag8-of>tfoe4XMiventAony and wlwn he was
^oge, Jtfr. Gerrald made «ane jpeaahe^
^khioygh «at M maiiF as some olhtMrfaeple
4id» and fa|^ tdk yctu hte was induced Ip md
4he iGrazetteer, at least, sp far ai lelaled to
tbe :oroce«diBgs ^f J^ oaovealMQ. Dhe
me<me8 taade le^oi^ht ai$ ^ iiblisbi^ tf^ th^
Otilpetteer tp-«DQ|Tpw, and I «wild Ask ^«hi^
tb«r that witofees'^ a)inpac»ti^ view nH the
uaecbes at ith^ «uii«, or ^ JAOg afbsr, i« iBoeft
likely to be right.
I4r. i?^i^r«^I|^ 8air» t^Mie waa nod^fcuttig
KmarM^ly «n><onei«i9 s now tJM Appears to
me clearly to imply that there waaADinelhiiag
^iTopeoi«s.
Jj^i Juitke {^ierk.'^JX doe$ ao^OGk Amf^
JAtrd il^4er(imilv«*-The iwagir lUiat i itame
!^en it d#«!» is tbw» that Jbe -did ftat abacnm
any thing remarkably deficient or erromaMS
ki the ifiaohfiS ^ the Oaaetieer; ihatihe
dpee OQi doubt hut h» ma^ hav^ jiead it ia
the Gazetteer, and did not recollect #07 AMh
%«ial iliie0Qm>e.
Mr. >F/«rol«r .i^yow lordahiip mil aUaw me
to explain my meaning*, tbe wards ase, Abat
ke obaaM/ied nalbu»c irsmaritfbl/ ^nMCMs ;
I piibfpftt )o your Ipfi^l^yipf JLSkd to.eHr«if man
ythg bears jaw» if ibat 4»qb Aot «nplf AbaA
tdbere w«s something ensoakeoua; it At/ tbeve-
ibre happen, that upoa yeading ifimw la tkm
witfiess, beanay say that thpaefnrtsdur^Bd
as most criminal are erroneous.
. Lord Jv$tioe Cierk.-^l doty A» coBduiion
Mr. Fletcher has idrawfiffom tofHresMaes;
Ibe i^alA aaeaBiag ia, UmU theoe litas aa re-
Mr. Gillies, — It is «ertaialjr true, that htB
aecollie«4;ioo rnnet haVe been more accumte
tben th0A at present ; bat this is equally tme,
that the witness, having just heard theae
apeeehts, would not Feaatham with thatet-
tjaition diat he might if he now read tbem c
IJNT aa(y «wii share, in such ctrcumf»ta&ces I
^mx\i tokot have nead it at ^ii.
Lord Justice Clerk. — I think the vh]ieaa*8
own idea of the natter is very different: iie
says, be oead over the Gazetteer stad obaervad
nothinjg remarkably deficient Wiiat do ydiir
lardshipfi say ? ehau st be read, yea or nay f
Lord Henderlund.'-^l do not see anv pav^
ticailar reason why it should not be read.
^|r, SoUettor-GeneraL^'Lei the Witness laad
it himself.
No, I beg to be ftunHad^ X tiiiiik I ahooU
aamember it beUerby hearing it read than by
imding iL
{The clerk of the court then read ibe sp^Bcb
1h)m the Gazetteer]
Mr. CUrh-^Do you recollect reeding the
-speech you have now beard In tfan Geaatteer?
—I think; ao &r «a I mcMa^ that jt ia tlia
l>ajrou 4hwlc4t bas raiitBtadany>UMJM;,ftat
W» ^cbHverad da tbe iip«neb'?**-4 ihijBK» if
the ooarae of ceading,! recoUeot A}0ieat«iMi^
words interspersed mrough this speeob, tbat
I laonUect Mr; GemUd mkedl&rtLeaoiiistt of
a ^ecb one evemng^ ibut Iido Aot laefta t^
iAantily the whcdee|teech.
You mantianad-amotion^if lilr.'Oallender'a
nbffQ you ware psete&ti^-^-IAMiafdA'matiflii
aaade whk^ I imdecstoad to be amatioft af
Mr. Callender's.
It i9fm ssfA iko ^Qu ifiromflhe lindictnenty but
I shall read it to you KSMim«>'XheftiQ'OMiB
ttbe ciuoiifiter9''ioc. {laadB ihe jootion from the
iiidk:tBieDt.3*^I thmk y»jx aud, 4a vthe batt
af your neoombrancc^ fUiiawafi the suMuaoa
of the notion j^ou hnid ^«-Y«8.
I shall now read it item the maOrn^ nf Abe
convention; ** t'hat in case the minister
bring into IJbe Commons ttonse trf^Psrliament
amoiaoniar«fieDaviintiaabil^ it shall be no*
ticed immediately to the delegates." ttaniwiil
observethis as a onicb ahortermatioi^ And
something different ; now whiijk of tkeicy
according to year MoaUealiaa was Mm aiM
motion i^tt ImnmkI at l&m iime f-— Wbn had
the management of the business IiOMMOt
say; but the thing that ^wasifitrst read 4rat si-
milar *tD what i beard.
W, Solicitor Oeneral^^/lt, Ckrk has bad
one speech «ead to this -.^cmtleaaA^ Iidaiira
that the other <nay be jread« and he-wiil aay
wbethor be recoUecto ajof material «rran.
[The clerk iSbcn read the other speech firom
ihe Gazetteer.]
Mr. Solicitor General. — ^Now, as this ncarfy
ttie aubtance ? or do you Mcollaet *dw gireat
dtfTereaoe t — I recollect conaiderftUy ]pB% tt
tbat than I do of the other ; the beginning of
it I do not recollect at ail.
Lord Justice Clerk. — Did y;oii read the Ga»
zalleer when it was first published ?<--I wat in
the habit of reading the Gaaetteer.
Lord JuMiee CUrk^'^i ^vesme great p}ea.«
sure to hear a witness, who was a member ot
a convention like thb, «ve his eridenoe fiuriy,
like an honest man ?--4 wash the gentlemen
of the jury to understand that 1 have not
identified the speeches in Ihe Gazetteer.
Mr. Soiiiitor Geiterc/.— -We.know yon tmv^
not; nor shall any body say that you have.
Mr. Cietii —1 x>hBerve a great many aen*
tences in this indictment printed in italica ;
and I take notice of thie^ that the jury may
be upon their guard, and notauffcr toeotfalvaa
to be misled by that meana.
Mr. SoUdtar Gtneralr^h, is veiy wrongs
that there was any part of it printed m itaJics,
and how it happened I do not know ; but ail I
can say is,.to desire the gentfemen of the jyry
to pay no regard to them.
Alexander Aitckeson sworn.
Lord DanfinfMm.<»'Hias any body offered
you any n^war^ or promiae of reward, for
giving evidence bere ?— -None.
971] S4 GEORGE III. ProeeedtHgi i^mtt Jaupk GerraM
[9n
inteeiity of its fint prmciples; but they
ouebt to have exammed, whether that prin-
ciple be good or evil, or so good that npuilng
can be ever added to it, which none ever
was ; and this being so, those who will admit
of no change would render errors perpetual,
and deprivuig nuunkind of the beneits of
wisdom, industry, experience, and the riglit
use of reason, oblige all to continue in the
miserable barbarity of their ancestors, which
suits better with the nature of a wolf th^n
that of a man/' — Sidney on Government,
quarto edit. p. 405.
Gentlemen, we all know that the human
mind is suffered to be active in the improve-
ment of those civil arts, which conduce to the
comfort and happiness of human life, I mean
the mechanical arts : and shall the grand art
of all, that of makii^ men secure in the en-
joyment of their acquisitions, I mean the art
of government^ be alone neglected, alone
compelled to be stationair ? But abandoning
i^e pnnci|de and reason of the cases, the facts
themselves contradict the assertions of our
adversaries. 01^ constitution has never been
stationary. It has been in a gradual state of
improvement; and a writer to whom this
countiy had the honour of giving birth, I
mean Hume, expresslv tells us, tlutt the his-
tory of England is little else *' than a history
jof reversals.'^ Do we not know that acts of
parliament ^re frequently set aside, and others
directly contrary passed in their stead ? By
the treaty of Troyes, after the battle of Agin-
court, which was regularly ratified and con-
firmed, and no opposition made to it, either
by France or England, the two kingdoms
were for ever unrepeEdably united imder Henry
6th. Where is now the unrepealable union
between En^gland and France? Oaths were
beaped upon oaths to bind the nobility of
England never to violate any of the constitu-
tions of Richard Snd as Rapin assures us (vol. 1.
[Age 245); where are his constitutions now ?
During three successive reigns, the national
religion was three times successively changed
by act of parliament. A more compleat 1^.
lanny cannot be conceived than what Wil-
liam the Conqueror established over the peo-
ple of England. Yet but a f^w reigns pass
away, and the barons establish a legal right
to redress their grievances by force. Magna
Charta says *' Vestringent et gravahunt not,^
&c. The barons complaining, and failing of
redress, shall lawfiilly distress and aggrieve
the king all manner of ways, as by taking
his castles, land possessions, ^c. till redress
is granted. After *the restoration comes the
corporation act, and declares all resistance
unlawful. The same doctrine is preached in
the act of attainder, and militia acts. Not
thirty years aAer this comes the revolution,
Aid abolishes the whole system of passive-
obedience aod non-resistance; sends the
whole royal family a-packing, and brings i|i
the house of Nassau. The liberty of the pres^
«raji taken nw^y by the ld|h CJwfl^ dad. The
liberty of petitioning was aVoUsbe^ ^
year; and then the corporation charters yfw
taken away. All the^ were, restored by tho
Bill of Rights. Do not then, gentlemes,
these facts prove Mr. Hume's words, ^ That
the history of Engli^id is Utile bettor than a
histoiy of reversals ?'' There are some m/BBf
I know, who see a spectre in every bush.*
Lord Nottingham, when the Union was in
agitation, decUuced that the chaa^inf of the
term England to that of Great Bntain wouU
subvert SH the laws of England. And in our
own days there are of the same descriptiop
of men of whom we |nay say, that the woid
innovation, to use Mortimer's e^pressioa,
** has frosen up their souls like fish in a
pond." After aU, the mo6$ useful discoveries
m philosophy, the most important changes in
the moral history of man^ nave been innova-
tions. The revolution was an innovation;
the reformation was an innovation; Christi-
anity itself was an innovation-^
Lord Justice C/erle.— -You would have beeii
stopped long before this» if you had not been
a stranger. All that you have been saying i»
sedition; and now, my lords^ be is attacking
Christianity.
Lord Henderland, — I allow him all the
benefit of his defence ; but to compare the
present situation of this country with what
happened at the revolution, when the fonna
of civil government, and the liberties of thff
subject were done away by the infringement
of all law ; or with that period, in which the
sovereign is said to have fbrfeitod his life ! — ^I
cannot ■ sit here without obsferving, as w«a
done in England, in the year 1745, when the
rebels were tried— I cannot nt here^ as a
judge, and as a man, without ^ayipg that Is
a most indecent defence. It is my duty to oIh
serve thie ; but I amfor thys panel going on in
hi9 own way.
Mr. GfrrM, — I conceive myself m vii>^
eating the rights of Britons at large; anjll
solemnly disdaim $dl intentioqi of* a^taflging
Christianity. I wa^ mevely stating the fret*
Ifird JuUice Ciirk, — Go op in your oirii
way.
Mr. GerrM.--l tihink I msy b^ allowed
that at least.
Lord Jut^e Clerk,-^Qp on, .sir.
Mr. Gtrrald. — I should ^ave been gpiog
on if your lordship had not internu|KiM I9e*.
Gentlemen, the gi;eat^harge agUQSt fot ia^
that J came down here for Abe purpose of g|ui-
jying on reform ; and if I «^m not eflowed I0
go into a viji^dication of these ge^en4 prind-
fles» and an eniimeration W*iiarticalar abiise%
may be condemned indeed, but 1 certainljf
am not he«i^d. I wfis o|i^y aiding thft thp
supposed principles ohaigpd upon mewerp
sucn as have been adoptod <by the bevit aod
wisest of men; and if ^hey qui show ni/^
from higher s^uthority, .that they ase vno^^
stitutionali I would mataptly become ja ooor
■^w
•^VoiL9,i».95^
vrs]
Jbr SediwH*
A. I>i 119*.
[974
tert to their dOctrfoe^; biitmlsoii aldfii^, ind
not assertion, can conrert me. I shall now
endeavour tb prove to tdu that our (Object was
perfectly constitutiional.
■^ Gentlemen, by a return of the representa-
tion in naxiiament, an object whicn ^e feel
^ally interested in with all other British
Subjects, given us by a society called the
Friends of the People, many of whom are mem-
bers of parlument, and, among others, the
iilustrions Sheridan (the brilliancy of whose
talents can only be equalled by his disinterest-
ed attachment to the liberties of his country)
it appears that in England 9,611 persons —
return to parliament S^t members, and in
Scotland !>8 persons elect 15, and the re-
maining SO are elected by about 1,400.
This IS not an adequate representation *, but
Amockety of representation* and therefore
not &uch a representation as tne origuial prin-
ciples of our constitution intended, or as the
Involution was meant to pron^ote. Surely,
gentlemei^, it is not the semblance of a parlia-
ment that we want, not the mere name of a
parliament, t!ic nmgUtrutuum vocethHla^ as
Tstdtufl wdH expresses it; but such a parlia-
ment as shall preserve our interests, and ex-
liress our wiHs. IT the cooiVs eoveming with-
otit a pdfrlbment, was fmnerly l9xe object of
oar terror; if its^^e^ine witb t parliament
is as Jtetly the o^ect of {ur #idA^ ; its go-
verning by a parhament is an infallible me*
IhuJI, not ofniv to oottipass, tun give sanction
|6 our ruin. With re^m to the fim of these
fioVem^ents, oar terrors have lotig slumbered ;
tor, while we so freely ^ve, why should the
aovereig^ t&kef But if ever the period
ahoidd arrive, when the House of Commons
should invid-i^ly answer to the calls of the
crown, tho«rgh they should be deaf to the
cries of tiie peoiple; that they should pur-
ehase on one hand, only to sell on the other ;
that instead of redressing grievances, they
sbbold authorize them ; inst^ of prosecuting
male^tors, they should screen them; and
instead of protecting and defending the rights
ctf* their condiments, thev should perfidiously
betray them; if ever such a period should ar-
rive, I say, we might still amuse ourselves
%ith the word constdtntion ; but hope itself
nvould sicken, as the constitution in fact must
be every where uhdermined, and at the first
sound of the trumpet of despotism, like the
Wlls of Jericho, woiild sink into a heap of
ruins.
Gentlemen, I was not drawing any pa-
rallel, when the bench interrapted me, oe-
tween the state of this countrv at this time,
«nd the state of it at the revolution ; but, 1
"Was laying down a principle, that if persons
in any given period had a ri^t to meet for
the purpose of bettering their government,
the^ had the same right at every subsequent
'period. The revolution was carried into
cffeiJt by open force, but here there was too
idea of force, which, I trust, I sh^l be able to
prove. In otr meet'mgs there was no idea of
any forte at all^ and th«r^fore, insteld of
drawing a parallel between the situation of the
country at that time, and at this, or of incuU
eating the propriety of having recourse to force^
we were doing directly the reverse.
Gentlemen, I shall now briefly examine
the principles, which the report of my speeches
in tne convention attributes to me. It is
there stated, that I said ^* no meeting of the
]>eople can be called a mob, if their deliberar
tions be directed towards the public good ;
but if men meet for an opposite purpose, for
promoting the misery or the destruction of.
the human race, though they sit down with
crowns on their heads and sceptres in their
liands, they are truly a mob."
These, gentlemen, I hold to be moral and
self-evident propositions; that it is not the
possession, but the just exercise of power,
which should render it an object of reverence
among men ; and that the essential principles
of vice and virtue are not alterea by the
practices of persons in high stations. — ^ Pro-
mote justitiSl (says St. Austin) quid sunt regn&
nisi marna latrocinia ?'' ^' If justice were
laid asicK,'^ as this venerable father has well
said, ** the governments of the world would re-
semble dens of robbers; and men 'would folr
low only those who can inflict the greatest
punishments, or give the greatest rewards.**
But since the reception of such opinion^
would be the extirpation of all that can be
called good, we must look for another rede of
our ol>edience ; and we shall find that only to
be the law (I mean what Tiilly calb the tartctio
recta J whicn being founded upon that eternal
principle of reason and truth, whence the rule
of justice, ^hich is sacred and pure, ought to
be deduced, and not fit)m the depravec will,
of man, which fluctuating, according to the
different interests, humours, and passions,
that at several times reirn in several nations,
one day abrogates what nad been enacted the
other. This sentiment, then, just and reason*
able in itself, can never be construed into a
reflection upon the present government ; un-
less you suppose that which I never asserted,
namely, ti^at it is applicable to the present
government ; in which case you must commit
the very offence which you are called upon to
condemn, and attribute those motives to the
particular ms^istrates of our own country^
which I only supposed might occasionally inr
fluence the conduct of many.
I am next charged with saying *^ were all
mankind to assexnble in public meetings, one
of two things must follow; either they will
"behave properly or improperly ; if properly,
'their meetin;^ will tend to good; if impro-
perly, it carries its own cure along with it.
The people will be soon brought into a better
-method by a sense of self-preservation, by
^hich they will correct the errors into which
they have fallen." Than this sentiment, gen-
tlemen, I conceive nothing can be more inno-
cent, or more strictly and logically true. By
the ^ ass^nbly of the whole community/' I
975]
S4 GEORGE m.
Proceedings dgainsi Joseph Gerrald
[976
certainly did not mean what a learned lord,
in his argument on the relevancy, erroneously,
I hoi>e nut intentionally, stated to he my
meaning, the meeting of all the people in
their collective capacity, which would impede
business, and give rise to tumults. No. I
meant the meeting of the people in their re-
presentative capacity — but, such a represen-
tation as should collect and express their
wills> as really and truly as if they had been
assembled in their collective capacity. A fair,
full, and complete representation— not a de-
lusive vision, an empty phantom, an unreal
mockery. This I can also inform his lord-
ship was the onl^ sense conveyed by my
words, " the great art of government is that
all should be governed by all;''* words
which his lordship thought proper to ridicule
because he did not understand them^and
which, besides their own intrinsic weight,
have been adopted by wise and virtuous men,
both in ancient and in modem times. '' This,
therefore," (says sir William Temple, when
speaking of the constitution of the ancient
Uermans, from which our own is, as we
have seen, derived) '^ is that^ constitution,
which has been celebrated as the truest and
thejustest temper that has ever been found out
between dominion and liberty ; and it seems
to be a strain of what Heraclitus said was the
only skill, or knowledge of any value in po-
litics, which was the secret of governing all
by all.'' (Sir William Temple, Miscellanies^
part 2, p. 255.} Surely, if ever there was a
principle of plain sense, this is one ; for who
80 likely to promote their own interests as the
persons most concerned in it ? Who so eager
to apply the cure, as those who feel most
acutely the smart of the disorder ?
Gentlemen, I am farther charged with hav-
ing said, that *' if governments were to in-
struct the poor, instead of hanging up their
bodies on gibbets, the voice ot the people
would then be the voice of God." Now, what
do these words amount to ? Why, that since
every government claims a right tp punish, it
IS previously bound to instruct the subject in
what he should do to avoid it. For, as the
iust powers of government, as we have before
bad occasion to observe, are derived from the
people; so, no neople either will delegate, or
can have a rignt to delegate^ to any set of
i^en, the power of wantonly inflicting pain
upon them; which, undoubtedly, would be
the case, if the subiect could, without injus-
tice, suffer the penalty of a law, even though
be had not been previously told of its exis-
tence. I speak not, now, of those moral
laws which pure native intellect enables us to
discover, and which may be read, as Dry den
says, without the " spectacles of books," but
merely of tliose positive regulations of society,
which mere human intellect alone cannot
know to be breaches of duty, unless previously
instructed. In these cases, then, to withhold
^— i*- ■■Mil ■ ■ I ■!■ I I I H
* See Lord Swinton's speech^ p. 69&
instruction is, on the part of govemmtnt, not
merely the omissioQ of a duty, but the com-
mission of a Clime ; and society sins against
the man, before the man can sw against so*
ciety. I therefore infer, that instruction
alone can constitute a duty, and that laws
can enforce no obedience but where they are^
explained. This, my lords, is not factious
doctrine, nor calculated to weaken the prii^
ciple of obedience to the laws. They are pre«
cisely the sentiments of sir WiUiam Black-
stone, a jud^ whose principles were most
unquestionably loyal, and who makes exactly
the same distinction as I have done, between
the mala prokibita^ and the raala in <e, (Black-
stone's Commentaries, vol. 4, p*8.); betwcea
offences against the law of nature, and o£%
fences against the state. The lawfulness of
punishing criminals, says he, is founded upoa
this principle, that " the law, by whi::h ibey
suffer, was miade bv their own consent; it is
a part of the original contract into which they
entered, when Irst they engaged in society ;
it was calculated for, and lias long contributed
to their own security." Now, il the consent
of the punished be the onlv lawful principle
of authority on the part of the ponisher, that
consent must be either express or implied.
That it is an exnress consent, it can never be
contended; ana as to an implied consent, we
are sUll authorized to ask, what is the ground
of the implication?
The publication of an act of parliament (tha
only mode-of publication which government
condescends to make use of), by the king's
printer only — ^in the old German character,
which fow men can read — and which is sola
at a price which as few can a£ford to pav;
rather resembles the behaviour of CaJ^uktp
the Roman tyrant, who (according to Ixioa
Cassius) wrote his laws in a very small cba*
racter, and hung them up on high pillars, the
more effectually to ensnare the people; thai)
the conductof a legislature, whose authority,
being founded on the consent of the people,
must, of course, break their trust, whenever
they violate the principle which created them.
To read to the prisoner, for the first time»
when he stands at the tribunal, any act, for
the breach of which he is arraigned, is to him
precisely the same thine as it woukl be to
originate it at the time by the same tribunal,
for the express purpose of condemnation. In
such case, indeed, he may perish by the
forms, but certainly not bv the principles, of
justice. Sir WillUin Blackstone also regrets,
the frequency of capital punishments to bf
found in our code; and feelingly says, that
" it is a melancholy truth, that> among th^
variety of actions which men are daily liable
to commit, no less than one hundred an^
sixty have oeen declared by act of parliament
to be worthy of instant death ;" and add%
^ that so dreadful a list, instead of diroinisb*
ing, incieases the number of ofienders."*
f 4 SL Comm. p. 18.
fi77]
Jwr Sedition*
, • GeaUeoeDr '^ waa upon a paiolul cen^ew
aT this subject, that I asserted, that ^' govern-
ment had far better instruct the people, tlwi
,)uLDg up their bodies on gibbets.^' For as
jthere is something in the nature of man, that
ao severe punishments have never been found
/efifectual to prevent any sort of crimfc ; the
most effectual way to prevent crimes is, to
|)reveni the temptation ; to take care that the
people be educated in virtuous principles, and
jevery man brought up, and inured to labour
And industry, that has no estate to subsist on.
If tbds be not done, laws may be avenged, but
caoDot be obeyed; thev may inspire terror,
jbut can never commana respect.
Gentlemen, I must observe, and I think it
)ies within the compass of my defence to state
^ you, that we can only be mnocent in com-
ing down for the purpose of procuring reform,
upon this supposition --that reform was ne-
cessaryj and if I had not been allowed to fp
into the proof of that fact, I should stand m
this melancholy situation — that a charge
would be brought against me, and the only
proper means of repelling that charge would
be aenied me.
Gentlemen, I now come to the dissection
of the evidence ; which, I trust, you will find
to be so scanty and insufficient, as that it is
impossible to fix upon me any well-grounded
ana colourable charge of sedition.
' Gentlemen, the phantom conjured up to
terrify the timid ; the Medusa's head, which
b to petrify you all with horror and astonish-
ment, is the motion attributed to Mr. Sin-
i;lair — but which, I shall sbortl^r prove to you,
never .passed — which not only inculcated the
principle of resistance, but which the British
convention, it is asserted, meant to carry into
/execution.
I was not a little surprised, to-day, to hear
this legal and constitutional principle denied,
in roulid and unqualified terms; when it
should be recollected, that it is to this prin-
ciple we owe our hberties. The right of self-
preservation, is a right of which no human
institution can divest us, since human insti-
tutions themselves were forfned onlv the
more completely to accomplish that end. To
support any political institution, therefore, by
the destruction of that principle, would beah-
«urdly to sacrifice the end to the means. '' If
the laws of God ao^ men,'' says Sidney,
** when the magistracy is left at liberty to
break them-r-and if the lusts of those, who
are too strong ibr the tribunals of justice,
cannot be otherwise restrained than by sedi-
tion, tumults, and wars — those seditions, tu-
mults, and wars, are justified by the laws of
God and man/' Sidney on Government,
p. 188. — ¥fx as all magpstrates are set up for
the good of the people; so, whenever they
aetcontnuy tothe end of their institution,
H^^' may be Uwfiillv opposed ; ^ Quia eate-
nus," as Grotius well observes, '' non habent
impetium." De Jure Belli, Ll. c. 4.— Here,
then, gentlemen, you see the principles of re-
vol: xxin.
A. D. 179*. {978
aistapce laid down by a writer on the civil
Jaw (with whose works, their lordships are
possibly far better acquainted than I), and
recoghued aJsQ by that sage and hero, the
immortal Si^lney, why, after a life spent in a
continual struggle against vice, tyranny, an4
faction^ fell a martyr at last to the liberties
of his country. Tlie sentence passed upon
him, however, by the infamous Jei£&ries, has
met with the unanimous execration of poste-
rity, and his attainder was accordii^ly re-
pealed among the first acts which took plac^
at tlie revolution.
Gentlemen, were I called upon to give a
definition of sedition or of rebelUqp, I would
frankly avow, that J know of no other than
this : the conspiracy of the law s^inst the
interests of the many. And this rebellion
may be equally carried .on by those who are
entrusted with the power of the state, as b/
those who originally conferred it, and who
are the objects of its exercise. ^ If tlv>se
who by force tsdce away the le^slature,'' says
Xiocke, <' are rebels, the legislators themr
selves, as has been shown, can be no less e^
teemed so, when they who were set up for
the protection and preservation of the people,
their liberties and properties, shall invade
and endeavour to take them away; and so
they, putting themselves in a state of war
with those, who made them the protectors
and guardians of their peace, are properly^
and with the greatest aggravation, rebels.*'
Treatise on Government, octavo edition, p.
894-5.
This principle of resistance, gentlemen, is
deeply interwoven in our constitution, an4 is
as strongly 4aid down, even by writers on our
municipal law, as it is by those who are phi-
losophical and speculative. '* The liberties
of Englishmen," says Blackstone (vol. 1. p.
144) *< should be perfectly known and consir
dered by every man of nmk or property, lest
his ignorance of the points whereon they an
founded, should hurry him into faction and
licentiousness on the one hand, or . a pusill^
nimous indifference, and criminal submissioi^
on tlie other." Nor do I apprehend, that this
knowledge of the rights of Britons, is to be
limited merely to men of rank and property;
since the poor roan is^ and bv the same
means too, equally entitWd to the preserva-
tion of his mite, as the rich man to tlie ex^
joyment of his millions. And of this opi-
nion, also, seems to be the learned judge,
when, shortly after, he says, '< to vindicate
these rights, when actually violated or at-
tacked, the subjects of England are entitled,
in the first place," (the word subjects is cer-
tainly equally applicable to all descriptk)ns»
high and k>w, rich and poor), " to the re^Iar
administration and free course of justice in the
courts of law; next, to the right of petition-
ing the king and parliament for redress of
grievances; and lastly, to Me rigid of having
and u$iug arms for Melf-preuroation and de.
ftnceJ' Vol. 1. p. 144.— Thus you see, gen-
3 K
979] 34 GEORGE Ul. Proceedings sgaitat Joseph GerraU
[98^
tiemen, that these prindples are neither new
nor dangerous; not new, oecause co-eval with
the revolution ; not dangerous, hecause avow-
ed by a calm philosophical writer, who en-
jojred the favour and patronage of his sove-
reign, and since supported by the authority
of an eminent writer, whose office it was to
lay down the principles of law, and adminis-
ter justice to the subjects of these realms.
Gentlemen, I defy our bitterest enemies to
prove that it was ever our intention to make
any practical apolication of these doctrines ;
for, as the same learned judee' well observes,
*' all oppressions, which may happen to spring
from any branch of the sovereign power,
must necessarily be out of the reach of any
stated rule, or express legal provision ;*' so I
say with him also, that ^ if ever they unfor-
tunately happen, the prudence of the tones
must provide new remedies upon new emer-
gencies." Blackstone, Vol. 1. p. t45.
Gentlemen, I shall now state to vou, as
shortly as I can, what was said by the wit-
nesses. Mr. Scott says, I think, among other
things, that when he came into the conven-
tion, on the 6th of December, he asked the
chairman the object of our meeting ? The re-
ply was, that we were met for the purpose of
addressing the king.
Mr. Davidson tells you, indeed, that he
came for the purpose of disfyersing the meet-
ing. He was asked, also, if there was any
appearance of tumult. He answers in the
negative; that there was no appearance of
tumult a^id disorder, though tne president
was forcibly taken out of the chair; to whom
he, at first gave a friendly shake, though he
was afterwards obliged to convert it into a
Cornish hug. We, then, eentlemen, were
the persons who were forcib^ assaulted ; but
we aid not make use of force for the purpose
of repelling force.
Gentlemen, the external proofs that have
been alleged, particularly or this resolution
which was saia to have passed, amount to
what? They amount, in fact, merely, to this;
that a number of papers were taken from a
public inn by the officer, and put into a loose
Dundle; then taken by him to the sheriff ^s
office, where tliey were left for some time,
without any particular attention being paid to
them ; certamly in so loose a state tteit it was
*very possible for any other papers to have
been put in ; consequently all degree of cre-
dibility due to the evidence is done away, in-
asmuch as they were not sealed, though I
understand it is always the custom to seal up
f»apers, as it appeared firom the evidence de-
ivered to-day at the bar. For, 1 conceive
that, af\er th^y have been in that loose state,
It is impossible ever to identify these papers,
unless the man has the faculty of looking
.through a pocket handkerchief How is it
possible, if the papers luid been taken and put
into a loose bundle, and suffered to lie a con-
•iderable time without any actual inspection,
and several persons being inUie room ;— >how
is it posable, I say, that these papeiscan be
proved to be the same that were taken out of
the room of Mr. Sinclair ?
Gentiemen, you will find one material cir-
cumstance, however, to which, I trust, yoa
will give your most mature consideration;
which is, that an attempt to identify those
papers should, by all regular and due coarse
of evidence, have been made, before they are
produced to the jury, as the ground of crimi^
natine an^ panel at this bar ; for, if they are
not identified, I do not see with what colour
of justice they can be brought forward for
the purpose of criminating any person. This
paper is not proved ever to have been adopted
as 8 resohition by the convention. It no
where appears, even in what is called the mi^
nutes or the convention, but which I deny to
be the minutes of the convention; nor is
there any proof that ever they were adopted
by tiie convention as their minutes. It ought
to have been proved to be1n the hand-writins
of Mr. Sinclair, who is the reputed author at
this motion ; and even if an attempt to iden-
tify his hand-writing had been made, even
then I say, the evidence would still have rest-
ed upon a very precarious foundation. In the
case of Algernon Sidney, it was a similarity
of hand-writing that was the prindpal ground
of his conviction. That very cucumstance
also, gentlemen, is recited in the act of par^
liament as one of the principal grounds of
reversing his attainder; though the paper
alluded to, was found in the cbset of colonel
Sidney, as this paper is said to have been
found in the room of Mr. Sinclair. Sidney
himself well observes, upon his trial, that
similitude of hands is nothing; as hands may
be so counterfeited, that no man shall know
even his own hand. *' A genUeman^ that is
now dead,'' says he, '* told me tiiat mv lord
Arlington, about five vears a^, desired him
to write a letter, and seal it as well as he
could. He wrote it with care, and sealed it
with a wafer and wax upon it ; and within a
few days mv lord Arlington brought him five
letters, and he did not know which was his
own/' * If then, gentlemen, even if there had
been actual proof, that this was in the luuid-
writing of Mr. Sinclair (a circumstance which
never could be proved, and which has not this
day been attempted to be proved), if such
actual proof, I say, would not have been ad-
mitted as sufficient evidence to criminate Mr.
Sinclair, inasmuch as the motion in question
never became part of the minutes of tne con-
vention— far less should this scroll of paper
condemn me, who am only accused oi ver-
bally supporting the written motion, which
Mr. Sinclair is said to have made. If upon
the trial of this excellent young man, who, at
a period of life, which the greater part of
mankind consume in frivolous or vicious di^
sipation, is dedicating his whole time to pro-
• See the case of Algernon Sidney, Vol %
p. 865> of this Collection.
SSI]
Jbr Seditkn*
A. D. 179*,
[988
mote the happiness of his fellow creatures;
— ^if upNtm a suoseouent trial, an honest and
irapartiaJ jury shally as they must, acquit him
pf the cbarge, both upon a ^neral conviction
of his innocence, and particularly, upon the
insufficiency of the eviaence brought against
him ; «what must be the remorse, what the
anguish of that jury, who shall have con-
demned the accessary upon that very evi-
dence, which, on the fullest investigation,
shall have been found incompetent to the
conviction of the principal ? This event, were
it possible to happen, I should most deeply
deplore, not merely on account of my own
personal sufferings, but for the scandal it
would affix to the administration of justice,
for the disgrace it would brine upon our com-
mon country; and, above all, for the deep
And lasting infamy that it would entail upon
?ou, my countrymen, gentlemen of the jury,
n such case, the principle of my condemna-
tion, would even be worse than that of Sid-
ney ; posterity would review it with equal ab-
horrence, and therefore let me conjure you,
as you tender not. only my safety', but your
own personal reputation, suffer not the ini-
quities of those times to be revived and im-
puted to these.
Mr. Mack telle you, that he did not get the
papers from Lyon, that they were lying in the
joom in the sheriff-clerk's office carelessly.
Mr. Skirving's papers were sealed, it seems:
but this motion, upon which the sreat ground
x)f criminality is laid, is suffered to lie loose.
If that precaution was not taken equally in all
cases, I certainly ou^ht not to suffer for the
negligence of the officer.
There is one certain and infallible proof,
gentlemen, that this motion, upon which so
much stress is laid, never did, in reality, pass
in the convention. It has come out in the
.evidence that the motion was marked by Mr.
Aitcheson ; — if then it was marked by him,
it dearly could not have been adopted by the
convention ; for if it had, it would have gone
.into the hands of the secretary, who would
have marked it with his own signature, and
it would have constituted part of tlie minutes.
. On the contrary, you have strong circumstan-
tial proof (the best that the nature of the case
will admit) that so far from passing in the
convention, it was even laid aside; inasmuch
as it was only marked by Aitcheson, and not
. by the secretary, whose practice it was invari-
. ably, to mark them as an essential prepara-
uve to their insertion in the minutes. Besides,
fentlemen, where was this paper found?
I^as it found in the possession of Mr. Skir-
ling, when all his papers were seized, and to
whose custody all resolutions that passed in
.the convention were regularly committed?
X^o; it was not even pretended to have
been so found; it is stated to have been
found in the custody of Mr. Sinclair alone,
who was a simple member of the convention,
and who was never entrusted with the guar-
.dianship of its minutes. This smgle &ct
renders all reasoning upon the subject un-*
necessary. It amounts to a moral demon-
stration of what I advance; and he who
would not be convinced by proof so glaring,
and facts so undeniable, would not receive
eonviction, though one shoiUd rise from the
dead.
Gentlemen, you, no doubt, are well aware,
that it is the duty of jurymen to find the ver-
dict, secundum allegata ft probata^ << according
to facts alleged anaproved.'' Many principles
contained in those speeches attributed to o^,
I glory in having uttered, as they are perfect-
ly reconcileable with the soundest pnnciplcs
of government and good order : But there are
parts of those speeches which are false and
spurious. Animated, as I am, with a love of
truth, and determined to tell it at whatever
hazard, I will neither assume what I have
not said, nor deny what I have said. If then,
YOU give me credit, which, I am sure, as
honest men you cannot withhold fiom me, for
my veracity and openness in one instance,
you have no right to mistrust me in another.
I have already told you, that as jurymen
you are bound to find a verdict according to
facts alleged and proved. I now, eentlemei),
will seriously ask, what evidence nave you,
that the speeches charged in the indictment,
and which are copied from the Gazetteer, are
the real speeches which I made in the con*
vention? What is the mode of proof? Tho-
mas Cockburn tells you that he had a general
recollection, when he was in the habit of read*
ing the Gazetteer, that they bore a resem-
blance to the speeches which he has heard
me make in the convention. Gentlemen, I
trust you are well aware of the sacred duty
which you are now to execute, and that you
will be of opinion that in a case so solemn as
the presenl^ a bare general recollection of
what is said, or supposed to be said, in the
heat of debate^ will never constitute a suffi-
cient ground of^criminal conviction. I allow,
that in the ordinary intercourses of life a ge-
neral recollection is certainly sufficient ground
whereon to form a judgment, otherwise
human af&irs must stand still. But you are
not now met for the ordinary purposes of life:
you are met to determine the guilt or innof
cence of a man, accused, on the one hand,
of having disturbed the peace, and esteemed
on the other, for having attempted to pro-
mote the good of his country ; and upon your
determination will rest, not only his fortune
and his fame, but, in all probability, his lite
itself. What then is the evidence upon which
tliis great stake depends? Mr. Cockburn,
when pressed by my counsel, who, through
the whole course of tne cause have conducted
themselves, not only like able counsel, but
like firm and inflexible patriots, says, that he
cannot identify one single passage. What
does this confession amount top That he
cannot swear they are the speeches t made ;
for, if the terms " eeneral recollection*' have
any meaning at al^ I apprehend they have
ggS] 84 GEORCB lit
Proeeedtngi
[984
this meaning, th«t all semral reeolleetions
are composed of the recollectioD of some )Mtr-
ticiilar passages. Now, he docs not identify
one single passage. Some of them yoii may
deem crimina], and others innocent; nay,
even meritorions ; and therefore, I presume
you cannot convict any panel upon such loose
indeterminate evidence ; which is, at least, as
likely to fix upon him what is praise-worthy,
as it is to charge him with what is criminal.
But he recollects " a great many words in-
terspersed in that speech." Why doubtless,
gentlemen, when Mr. Cockbum had heard
any person speak fbr a considerable length of
time, he must have some recollection upon
his mind of what had passed ; but I trust tnat
words interspersed through a speech are cer-
tainly too k>ose to found a verdict of convic-
tion of a far less crime than that of which I
am accused, and to autliorize a punishment
•f far less severity than such as if convicted
] shall inevitably suffer.
This, gentlemen, is so &r as concerns tiie
first speech. Btit of the second speech he
to,ys he recollects less than of any other ;
though this is the speech upon trhich Mr.
Solicitor General chiefly founds his charge,
and against which he has planted the whole
artillery of the law. Afler all, vcntlemcn,
the witness, though closely pressed in his ex-
amination bv the crown lawyers, closes his
evidence with these remarkable words, ** that
he does not mean to identify any of the
Speeches.'*
' Gentlemen, if the freedom and lives of
firittsh subiects are dependent upon the loose
And general recollection of words — spoken too
at a considerable distance of time,— we may,
indeed, boast our liberties and the benignity
of our law», but they are merely an empty
b^ast, and not a solid and substantial good.
But, gentlemen, there is one circumstance
fitili stronger than any I have stated to you.
If any person might be supposed to retain an
accurate recollection of the speeches, it must
be William Ross, who being able to write
ihoJrt-hand, woifld in all probability carry
^way with him, with more accuracy than any
other person, the speeches which are attri-
buted tb me. Ross tells you, he never took
notes by the express direction of the conven-
tion, nt*'evcr published them by their order.
Now, if charges of criminality are to be
brought forward against men upon such loose
evidence as this^tne unauthorixed transcript
of a short-hand writer, and which transcript,
or even verbal evidence, is to be taken as
proof— we must deem the judicial process of
our country not a shield of protection, but a
rod of chastisement. Persons actuated by
malicious motives, the retainers of a profligate
administration, may enter the meetings by a
short-hand writer, and, for a small gratifica-
tion, may induce him tu take down, as the
speeches of any member, words highly cri-
hiinal, but which at the same time have never
been spoken ; and afleivards, by procuring
them to be inserted in a newspaper, may
mibjeet the party to a state prosecution.
Against this engine of persecution what re-^
medy has innocence? Why, the pvty a£-
F-ieved may prosecute the printer for a ubelt
mean if he has money, for that is a neces*
sary ingredient to the attainment of justice ;
and if he has none, however deep the injury,
and calamitous its consequence, he must sit
down silent tinder the charge, until he has
an opportunity of vindicating his innocence
in court, when the lord advocate, who is ejt
officio the guardian of onr liberties, ^all be
eraciousl^ pleased to drag him, as the ill-
mted victim of a state prosecution.
Gentlemen, the rules of evidence, being all
founded upon the plain principles of common
sense, must, in aft countries, be neariy the
same. In an English court of judicature, the
evidence producra against me would, I am
certain, be deemed incompetent to a convic-
tion on the slightest charge. Why then, in
Scotland, should not an equal measure of jus-
tice be meted out to me, an EnglishmaTTy
which you, though Scotsmen, would in Eng-
land readily obtain ?
Furthermore, Ross, the short <hand writer,
swears that he is not very well skilled in his
art — which, even in the most skilful, is a fal-
lacious mode of identifying a speech^ nay,
that he was afiBicted with a deafness when he
attended the convention, and having fre-
q,uently lost the thread of my discourse, in-
serted, of his own invention, a great part of that
which appeared in his paper. Gentlemen, is
not this sinde confession sufficient totally to
destrov the identity of the speeches, and conse-
quently the solidity of the evidence against me ?
— A question was asked by one of^thc jurr-
nien, which carried with it an apparent weight
— whether any of the members of the conven-
tion had complained that their speeches wei^
inserted or misrepresented ? To which Ross
answered, no. I am sure you cannot but be
aware, that if the members of the convention
had been in the constant habit of complain-
ing of all the misrepresentations whicn the
lying breath of rumour had circulated against
them,— if they had thought it necessary fi)r-
mallv to contradict whatever malice propa-
gated, and credulity received, — the object of
their mission must have been entirely aban-
doned ; and instead of asserting those prin-
ciples which we felt to be just, our time
would have been consumed in refuting asper-
sions which we knew to be false. No, gen-
tlemen, we rested upon the consciousness of
our innocence, and upon the broad basis of
public confidence, to which our honest and
disinterested exertions had given us a claim.
George Ross depones, that I had no know-
ledge of the insertion of the words, ^a ifv,
vive la convention, liberty hall, ifC, but thlt
he himself was the person who inserted thern,
I should not have repeated this insignifiraiit
circumstance, but that I observe un&r infe-
rences have been drawn firom theib, in ordiSr
to load us with additional guilt.
J>85j ,/6r Sediiwth
OentlenicfD, I hoM this to be a 9oand pria-
ciple both of reason and of Isw^ that if Jon can
once prove that any meeting ^nw in itself
legal, though after the meetins any illegal re-
e<mition8 trcre adopted, providfed it cannot be
proved that you were present at those meet-
ings, aiding and abetting those illegal resolu-
tions so passed, no degree of criminality can
possibly attach to you.
You are then to advert to the general prin-
ciple which proves the legality of the meeting,
and not to th6 particular resolution, which if
you did not support, can never be brought in
evidence against you. Much stress has been
tefd upon this committee of secrecy, uuon
which very Strange and contradictory tan-
kage has been held by the public prosecutor.
Sometimes we arc represented as a set of des-
peradoes, who met in open day for the pur-
pose of violating the laws and the subsisting
constitution of the country ; at other times
that we met in holes and corners, as our pro-
jects were so nefarious that they could not
bear the light. To round the circle of contra-
dictions, a learned iudge upon the bench has
declared, that, '• however criminal our in-
tentions, our conduct was open, and in this
respect our imprudence was equal to our
guilt.'' By these various and even opposite
charges, the punishment inflicted by the Si-
cilian tyrant, is realized upon the unfortunate
members of the convention — stretched upon
the iron bed of legal torture, if too Ions we
are lopt, — if too snort we are stretched. If
we act with openness, there our candour is
audacious guilt ; if secrettv, we only refrain
from insultmg our country by the publicity of
our measures, that we may in greater security
accomplish her ruin. Seven men, it seems,
were aeemed sufficient, by this resolution, to
constitute a convention, which was to over-
turn the government ! Absurd and impossible
Supposition ! Were our rebellious truops, like
those of Mr. Bayes at Brentford, to start up
when called for ^ Or, is it supposed that we
were to realize the fable of Pyrrha and Deu-
calion, and generate men by casting stones
behind us? The very supposition of your
giving the smallest degree of credit to this
absurd allegation, would reflect such disgrace
upon your understandings, and is so highly
derogatory to the British constitutioM, the
principles of which are the objects of univer-
sal reverence, that I cannot entertain it for a
moment. For feeble, indeed, must the foun-
dation of that constitution be, which can be
^^en endangered, much more overturned, by
a meeting of no more than seven individuals!
Gentlemen, from a particular expression
stated in this indictment, ^'calamitous circum-
Btances," you must see that we looked upon
every invasion to be calamitous, from wnat-
ever quarter it proceeded ;— but, if we had in-
tended to make an open opposition to the
laws of our country, or were plotting its ^es-
frOdion secretly and in the dark, we should
certaxkily nertT ha^e used «n epithet «ftiiat
A. I>. 17^4*.
t98S
diescription. The very insertion of the term
ealaimtoiis proves to a mora! demonstration
that all invasions, from whatever quarter,
would have been deemed objects not of ap-
probation, but of regret.
Gentlemen^ it has been said, that the ad-
mission of foreign troops into Great Britain
was also one oftfae calamitous circumstances
which would induce the convention to meet
a^in. To this charge, if it will avail any
thing to the public prosecutor, I freely plead
guilty. Asa Briton I shall ever think myself
poimd to watch with anxious attention the
introduction of any foreign troops; and upon
this plain principle, that I conceive the native
valour of Britons is always adequate to tiieir
own orotection. If it he otherwise, we hold
our freedom by the most brittle tenure ;— .for
as foreigners can have no common interest
with Bntons, the same mercenary arm which
protects us for pay, may enslave us for plun-
der. But what does this resolution stated
That we will do any thing unconstitutional >
Far from it. It states that " we shall foflow
the wholesome example of our ancestors, by
paying no regard to any act which shall mili-
tate against tne constitution of our country.''
Now, before government can properly make
this resolution a ground of cnminal accusa-
tion against us, they must confess that they
either had passed, or meaned to pass an act
militating against the constitution. For un-
der no other circumstance was any opposition
mentioned or intended. Is it not rather sin-
gular then that before they can infer ourjguilt,
uiey must confess their own ? Acts ot par-
liament are in general sacred things, but they
may be, in particular cases, so grievous and
oppressive, that human nature will revolt from
tnem. The constitution, as treasurer Bur-
leigh long since observed, can never be un-
done but oy a parliament; which proves how-
ever, that parliament may undo it. In the
reign of Henry 8th an act of parliament was
passed, giving to the proclamations of the
crown the validity of a law. It was also made
a capital offence for any person to foretel the
death of the king; — in conse<^uence of which,
sir Anthony Denny, his physician, when he
lay at the point of death, was afraid to men-
tion to him the danger of bis situation. To
jud^e or believe that Anne Cleve? was not a
virgin when she married him was declared
high treason. Until very lately for a gipsey
tu remain twelve months within the kingdom
was declared felony without benefit of clergy.
In Scotland, Evenus, the third king of that
name, caused a law to pass, by wliich the
wives and daughters of noblemen were ex-
posed to his lust, and those of the commons
to the lust of his nobility.* *' Tulit legem
Evenus ut cuivis liceret, pro opibus, quot uere
posset, uxdres ducere; ut rex ante nuptias
sponsarum nobilium, nobilis plebeiarum prseli-
barent pudicitiam, ut plebeiorum uxores cum
* riif^iuldekida ut the end of this Volume.
9B7}
S4 GEORGE IIL
ProeeetUngiMgaind JoiqA GerraU
[9BB
nobilitoies commuiijes tui^pL** Buch. 1. 4. c.
14. Many other acts might be mentioned
which have long blotted and disgraced the
etatute book : are these acts, then, m the eye
of reason, proper objects of obedience ? Nay,
are they not rather honoured in the breach
than the observance ? ** Laws," savs Hooker,
** must be obeyed, unless there be reason
showed that the law of reason, or of God, doth
enjoin the contrary/' Eccles. Pol. b. 1. sec
16. Which plainly implies that there are
bounds to the civil obedience of the subject.
Acts, then, which are subversive of our happi-
ness, are contrary to every right of civil soci-
ety and comfort, utterly incompatible with all
jaws either moral or revealed, and therefore
mere acts of power, having neither the force
nor vaUdity of a law. But I deny that it was
ever the intention of the convention to resist
any acts by force. The words of the resolu-
tion are, *^ unless compelled to desist by su-
perior force.'' What was this force to be su-
perior to? Why, forsooth, to twenty-one
members peaceably met, and peaceably dis-
cussing political subjects, r^ay, do not
the very words themselves plainly import,
that though the mere mandate of the magis-
trate (as such mandate would be a gross vio*
lation of the law which he was bound to ob-
serve) would be disregarded by the conven-
tion, vet the appearance of force would be the
signal of dispersion? For upon what prin-
ciple of common sense, or probabilities, can it
be supposed that we should have wantonly
exposed our lives to certain destruction by an
Appeal to arms ; we, few in number, peaceful
in intention, without ability to act^ without
hope to succeed, without power, without in-
fluence, without motive^ without means ?
But the sincerity or this declaration has
been alr^y evinced by a fact of recent date
and public notoriety. When Mr. sheriff Dar
vidson, on the last evening on which the con-
vention sat. entered the hall, attended by con-
stables and other ojfficers, belonging to the
civil power only, did the slightest symptom ap-
pear of an inclination to resist? No; Mr.
Margaret and myself, who successively acted
as presidents that evening, were indeed for-
cibly pulled out of the chair ; because as we
were conscious^ that we could not be legally
ordered to qmt it, a voluntary abdication
ivould have been justly interpreted as a dere-
liction of our risht. But did we resist, I again
repeat ? No ; Mr. Davidson's testimony this
day, has confirmed my assertion. We dis-
persed, he telb you, without tumult or disor-
der. It was we, then, against whom force
was employed, but who employed none. We
suffered injury but offered none.
The introduction of foreign troops into the
kingdom, without the sanction of parliament,
is an infringement of the bill of rights, and a
violation of the constitution of our country.
Doctrines, I know^ have been openly avowed
by the minister, justifying the measure as
legal and constitutional i but this ayowal, I
beKeve, stiuck everyone who heard himp
his own creatures excepted, with horror and.
astonishment; nor do I apprehend, that at a~
future though not distant period, he will be
fond of repeating what in the plenitude axul
insolence of power he has lately advanced.
Lord Stanhope who is a member of that
legislature which ought to be the peculiar
fuardian of our rights and privileges, and who,
believe, is as incorrupt a senator as ever this
country gave birth to, since, like another So«
crates at Athens, he preserves himself free
from the contagion which is every where ra*
eing around him ; lord Stanhope, I say, with
his accustomed honest daring thus expressed
himself upon the subject of which I am now
speaking : *' Armies (said he) have in all ages
been the engines of tyranny, and by them me
civil rights and liberties of all nations have
been ^stroyed. The measure is of itself
such a flagrant violation of the constitution^
that if the same arguments are used in sup-
port of it in this House which have been used
m another place, I make no difficulty in de*
daring that the authors and abettors of sudi
blasphemous doctrines ought not to survive
their treason. I feel (continued he) as little
difficulty in declaring that if those treasonable
doctrines are attempted to be put into eaecia-
tion by the executive government, it then be-
comes the duty of the people to resbt force
by force." It then, this excellent man could
hold with impunity, in the senate itself, and
in the presence of the great officers of state^
these bold. but constitutional doctrinces, upoa
what pretext of law, or under what colow of
justice can you presume to punish me, who
have merely stated hypothetically, what he
has advanced, plainly, openly, uncondition*
ally ?
Gentlemen^ I cannot but observe one very
unfair suspicion which the crown lawyers
have endeavoured to infuse into your mmds
during the course of these trials. In order to
inflame your passions, at the same time that
they may assume to themselves an appear*
ance of lenity, they tell you that the cnmes
with which we stand charged approach veiy
nearlv to high treason : and an appeal, not
very honourable I think to the appellants, is
continually made to old and obsolete statutes,
on which state prosecutions were groimded
when tyranny was. at its height, to prove, that
had we fallen, like the apostles of freedom,
in the last century, on those ** evil days," like
them too we should have been the victims of
a legal tyranny. This procedure I must con-
sider as abhorrent, from the cool and sober
rules of justice. Suffer not, therefore, I con^
jure you^ your tempers to be inflamed, to the
destruction of an innocent man, because the
{mbUc prosecutor, in the rage and phrenzy of
oyalty, has thought proper to dig into the
dusty rubbish of antiquity, under which the
eml)ers of despotism have long been smother*
ed, and to ** awaken those sleeping lions bv
rattling up a company of old rec^ds irhkh
989]
JOT OmnmOn*
A. D. 1794.
[990
have Udn for so niaijy ages by the weU negf-
lected and forgotten."*
Gentlemen, another circomstance, upon
"which much stress has been laid, is that of a
blank appearing among the minutes ; and as
this blank followed after the resolution which
ire have just now been discussing, it has
been unfairly inferred, that it was our inten-
tion to fill it up with matter, at a proper and
conTement season, the publication or which
would have amounted to high treason. But,
gentlemen, if you will turn to the minutes,
you will find that there is not one blank
alone, but many. And this circumstance,
when coupled with the observation of the
solicitor-general, must convince vou how
extremely dangerous it is to conaemn any
man upon the evidence of these minutes,
which have been so long in the possession of
those who are the officers and dependents of
government. For, as state prosecutions are
nequently the instruments by which a orofli-
2;ate administration sacrifice the bold and
incorruptible exposers of their measures, so
it is always in the power, as no doubt it must
be frequently in the inclination of the public
prosecutor, to fill up the blanks with more
Leavy ana additional matter, which being
confounded with the original minutes, may
be offered in evidence to a jury, as a sufficient
ground of conviction for high treason.
The difference of process and of the cri-
minal codes of Scotland and England must,
to every thinkine mind, be a subject of most
serious alarm. In the southern part of the
kingdom, nay, in the capital itself, the seat
of the legislature, and the fountain head of
all justice, men are suffered to meet under
the very beard of the secretary of state, and
to pass with impunity resolutions exactly cor-
responding in principle, and equally strong in
expression, with those which, if passea in
Scotland, will send both the mover and
seconder, in company with thieves, felons,
and murderers, to toil and perish on the bleak
and inhospitable shores of New Holland.
ts the Tweed, then, which the God of nature
has made only to be a geographical separation
between the two countries, by the folly and
wickedness of man, to be perverted into a
legal, a moral, a political separation? The
resolution to which I have just now alluded
was a resolution passed by the London Cor-
resDonding Society, and is as follows: —
^ Tnat during the ensuing session of parlia-
ment, the general commUtee of this society
do meet daUy, for the purpose of watching
the proceedings of the parliament and of the
administration of the government of this
country. And that upon the first introduc-
tion of any bill, or motion inimical to the
liberties of the people, such as, for landinz
foreign troops in Great Britain or Ireland,
for repealing the Habeas Corpus act, for pro-
^ II ■ •.»■ ^1 ■ II
- ♦ 8ee lord Strafford's speech, anUy Vol. 3.
p. 1466. .
t
claiming martial law, or for preventing the
]>eople from meeting in societies for constitu-
tioxud information, or any other innovation of
a similar nature; that, on any of these
emergencies, the general committee shall
issue summonses to the delegates of each
division, and also to the secretaries of the
different societies affiliated and corresponding-
with this society, forthwith to call a genersu
convention of the people, to be held at such
place, and in such a manner as shall be spe-
cified in the summons, for the purpose of
taking such measures into their considerar
tion.
'' Resolved — That the preceding address
and resolution be signed by the chairman,
and printed and published. — ^J. Martin, diair«
man. T. Hardy,* secretary."
Upon these resolutions, tliough circulated
throughout the united kingdoms, no prosecu-
tion has been grounded. Are we not then
to infer, either Uiat the secretary of state has
been criminally negligent of his duty, and
that though he crushes sedition in Scotland,
he tolerates it in England? or — for upon no
other principle can he be excused,— *^tnat the
resolutions and the publication of them is
perfectly harmless, and that the code of
Scotland, which marks them out as ot^ccta
of punishment, like that of Draco^ is wnttea
in blood ?
Gentlemen, during my trial a principle has
been laid down by the lord justice clerk^
which I deem to be, in the highest degree,
reprehensible, as it strikes at the root of that
confidence which all men should repose in
law, and of that security which all men have
a ri^ht to expect from it The lord justice
clerk declared, that the judges had a discre-
tionary power in annexing the punishment
to the particular crime of sedition. Had ^
judge in England held a similar doctrine,
the judcpent^seat would have tottered under
him. I? law be a certsdn rule of action, de-
fining the offence and annexing the punish-
ment, the degree and nature of the punish-
ment should be specified, with equal preci^
sion as the degree and nature of the offence ;
otherwise we nold our freedom as mere te-
nants at the will of a judge, and not as we
ought, bv the known and explicit declaration
of the laws. Lord Camden^ the first law
authority in England, has said, that <* Dis-
cretion is the law of tyrants ; in the best mea
it is caprice ; in the worst it is every foUy;
vice, and infirmity to which human nature is
liablc."t
Gentlemen, let not the word discretion
mislead you. Legal discretion is hot the ar-
bitrarv discretion of the judge. No ; it is,
as well defined by Lord Coke, ditcemere per
legem quid titjustum^ " to* discover through
the medium of'^the law that which is just and
»■ mil ■» I. i.» ^.^—^1 • . » 11
* See his trial for high treason, a. d. 1794,
infra,
t See Vol. 8, p. 67.
mi
Si GEORGE m.
Proceedings iigaitut Joteph Gerrald
t99*
proper.^ ''Judges must ^edesinlxie/' <aaj«
tbe preamble to an old statute of Henry 7tb,)
'' not by tbc crooked cord of discretion, but
by tlie golden met-wand of the Jaw/' A
beautiful expression, and full of intrinsic
wisdom.
'* Misera est servUus (says lord Coke), ubi
jus VQgum aigtie incognitum est :^' ^' wherever
the law is vague and uncertain, the people
are in a state of wretched slavery.*' And
that law is certainly vague and imcertain,
which, not specifying the punishment as well
as the crime, leaves it to the arbitrary dis-
cretion of the judge.
GentlemeOy my feelings, my exertions,
and mv state of health have exhausted me.
Lord Mcnderhmd, — You may sit down, Mr.
Gerrald, and take a litUe breath.
Mr. GtrraltL^l thank your lordship.
[Mr. Geiraid having rested a few minutes,
proceeded as follows :]
Gentlemen, I trust that I have now proved
to your conviction, the general purity of my
intention, of which the object was, to carry
Into execution a constitutional reform in a
Seaceful manner; that, however, we may
ifier as men and citizens upon speculative
principles of government, yei the doctrines
which I have advanced are founded upon the
great and immutable princiules of reason and
of truth; that they are tne sentiments of
the most revered writers, liocke, Sidney,
Jones— that even Mr. Pitt and the duke of
Richmond formerly professed to act upon
ihem ; that they are perfectly congenial to
the spirit of the Anglo-Saxon government,
^nd not in a great degree differins from the
principles of the old constitution <» Scotland,
as Dr. Stewart has proved to you; that our
peaceful resolution of obtaining a reform was
never violated by our practice, as the testU
toony of sheriff Davidson evinoes ; for when
assailed by the civil power we repelled not
force Bv force — that uie officers of the law
violated the law in their illegal assault upon
our persons ; and that even then such was
our desire to preserve the public peace, that
Wi chose rather to suSer than to act; though
we could have acted under the shelter of
those laws which we are falsely cha^d with
having a design to subvert.
As men whose rights and security are
interwoven with our own, advert, I beseech
you, to the circumstances of our dispersion.
The first magistrate in this city, attended by
a posse of constables, enters the convention
hall, when the members who composed that
convention were assembled upon a legal
pindple, for a constitutional purpose, and
conduct!^ themselves in a calm and peace-
ful manner. Without reading the rbt act,
/or which indeed he could have no pretext,
from the object and conduct of the meeting,
he forcibly drags the president firem the^
chair, and disperses the convention. At a
future duy, when a meeting is ;%dvertised to
f take place, not as the British coDrrcotion,
' but 01 the Friends of the People, the magis-
trates of Edinbure)), attended by the town
guard, block up the passage to the house
which we had aired as a place for our calzn
and peaceful discussion, and, though not the
slightest appearance ot tumult existed, forcir
bly prevent the noembers from assembling.
Gentlemen, if the principle upon which
these magistrates acted, be a principle au-
1 thorized by any human code, I say that its
oj}eration and effect must be the abasemeat
of the human species and the extinction of
civilized society . It divests us of the right
of exercising our powers of reason, and
places us in a situation beneath the beasts
that perish. If the ma^strato of any counr
try oiakes supposed principles and not actions
the object of coercion ; if upon his own loose
constructions and speculations of danger, he
commits outrage, under pretence of pre*
venting it ; if instead of arguing from the
consequence to the principle, he inverts every
rule of right reason, and infers the conse-
quence from what he thinks proper to adjudge
the principle, the safety and freedom of
human action is at an ena In such case the
magistrate takes upon himself todeteanine
that wliich is undeterminable ; to mark as aa
object of punishment, not a present an4
actual, but a future, possible, and continent
consequence; and, ny punishing motived
which have not displayed their qualities by
their effects^ to arrogate to bis own limited
and shortrsighted capacity a privilege which,
belongs only to fiternal'Omnisclencc.
Feeble, indeed, must be that civil govern-
ment, which depends, for support, upon every
trivial occasion, upon the aia pf the military
arm. But, in the case alluded to, we had
at least one consohition; the soldiery who
interposed were not a foreign but a British
soldiery ; and I trust, that Kowe^r the latter
may be, for a time, deluded, they will recol*
Icct, upon all great and trying occasions,
that though necessity may have made them
soldiers, yet society lias made them citizens,
and nature has made them men.* But not
on(y are the principles which I defended
pure; but even had they been otiierwise,
the evidence, I affirm, wnich has been pro*
duced in order to fix them upon me, has been
incompetent to its avowed purpose. Not the
slightest evidence has been afforded, thai
the convention either published, or caused to
be published by their authority, these scrolls,
of paper attributed to them as their minutes.
They never authorized the publication of any
speeches which were made in the convention ^
* The pi-eoediag sentence bears strong re-
semblance to a passage in the '^ Address from
the United Irishmen at Dublin to the voluo^
teers of Ireland :** £br publishing which, Mr.
Hamilton Rowan was brought to trial.^— See
the ** Address,'' &c. in the informMiond^^uflSl
Mr. Bowan, atU^, Vol. SS^ p. 1036. .
WW]
JbrSeddiait*
A. D. 179«w
199*
aor doM it appeftr, l^ any testimony, 1i»i;
the speeches printed in the Oaaetteer were
identKadly the speeches delivered in the con-
vention. On the contrary^ Ross, the short-
hand writer^ swears^ that he frequently in-
terted^ fiom his own mind, words and senti*
nients which never fell nt>m the speaker.
There is no proof that the motion attributed
to Mr. Sinclur, which is ther great ground for.
ctiminatili^ riie, ever passed the convention;
and even if it had, an attempt to identify
that motion with the paper produced, should
certeinly have preceded its being produced in
en^nce. Why was this attempt not made ?
llie reason is obvious ; it must of necessity
bavefiuled. For was it not nrovedtojou,
that aU Sinclair's papers which were seued,
were thrown into a loose bundle, unsealed,
tossed for a considerable time about the she-
riiPs dffice, in a state in which it was very
(easy for anv person to have inserted other
papers not belonong to Mr. Sinclair, conse-
quently all possibuitv of proving the identity
of the papers is absolutely destroyed ?
With respect to the speeches attributed to
me, not one witness would identify upon oath
any one single passage which they contain.
And even Cockbum, whose testimony upon
that point is Uie strongest, declares, that he
has only a general loose recollection of what
passed ; a eround certainly too scanty and in^
sufficient tor the conviction of a man whom
the laws of his country presume to be inno-
cent; and which presumption can never
be destroyed but by the establishment of
stronger proof. ^ Stabitur prssumptioni donee
probitur m contrarium :" ** The presumption
stands till the contraiy is proved.'' Co. litt.
But the particular circumstance to which I
b^ to cbam dovm your attention, is the as-
sertion of the public prosecutor, that if you
were oonvincea that my intentions were pure,
you were bound in duty to pronounce my ac-
quittal. Yes, gentlemen, this is the solid
rock of my defence ; — ^the puritv of the inten-
tion by which I was actuated. Could any
thing but an ardent love of truth, and a de-
sire of promoting the happiness or my fellow-
creatum, have induced me to brave the pre-
sent prosecuUon, and by dnpelling the mist
of prejudices which 6urkens their understand-
ings, promote the happiness even of my pro*
aecutors themselves i In tiiis glwious thoujgh
arduous undertaking, by what possible motive
of gain or ambition could I have been acto-
atra? Examples have not been wanting of
men of whom the world was not worthy, who
have fiillen victims to an active and aalous
virtue; hut their &te will never deter firm
and well regulated minds from the perfonn-
ance of that which they will consider as
the most sacred of duties, the fulfilment of
their engagements to their oppressed and in-
aulied country. These were the sentiments
which actuated the conduct of our common
master when he wept over the city. ** O Je-
nisalem, Jerasakm ! thou ^t stonest the
VOL.XXIIL
piepblts, and slayest them that are senf
unto thee ; how often would I have gathered
ye, even as the ben gathereth the chickens
under her wing, but ye would not!''
In every relative situation of iife^ we should
do our duty, however hazardous, and leave
the consequences, which must be ultimately
beneficial, to the Supreme Disposer of all hv^
man events.
Oentkmen, when you consider that one
great object of the convention was, to promote
a -more close and sincere union between Eng^
land and Scotland, you cannot reasonably
convict, as a disturber of the public peace,
any man engaged in so laudable an under*
taking. Yes^ it is our pride and our boast,
that the extinction of those national prdu*
dices, which have too long disturbed and w*
graced both parts of the kingdom, was one
great motive of our honest exertions. And,
surely, our time is far better consumed in
strengthening the cement of affection which,
as inhabitants of the same island, it is so na«
tural for us to feel, than in wasting and ex«
hausting ourselves in the wrangles and con*
tentions of the continent, by which w«
abandon our local advantages as in Flanders,
and ultimately expose ourselves to become the
prev of some foreign or domestic invader. To
atchieve mighty conquests, is the lot of few ;
because few there are, who have eithe*
ability or opportunity to obtain them. But to
cherish ana disseminate the principles of
peace and eood will towards all men, is cew*
tainly the duty of all, because it lies within
the power of all, and must contribute to the
happiness of alL Moderate talents, steady
exertion, and good intentions, are ililly adfr*
quate to this end. This was all to which the
members of the convention made pretence $
and they repose themselves with confidence
upon the judgment which their country may
pass upon their conduct, whether the powers
which they displayed, and the means which
the^r adopted, were not well calculated for ita
attainment.
The solicitor-general, indeed, during the
course of this trial, has distineuished me b^^
a marked and particular compliment ; but it
was coupled with a charge, that, if I am*
guilty, must render me doubly so; that m^
e£brts were exerted to disturb the peace of.
my eountnr. No, g«ntleinen; whatever por*
tion of talents OckI has thought proper to
confer upon me, has never yet b^n prosti*
tilted to so infamous a purpose; and i turn
with horror from a compliment to my undei^
standing, which can only be purchased by the
extinction of every generous sentiment of the
heart, and the sacrifice of all things that ard>
sacred among men.
Gentlemen, when I look forward to the
pohtical hodaon, the prospect seems awful
and gloomy to a degree, at which the best
men muat shudder, and the ablest men mnsi
feel themselves incompetent to describe. Every
thing is turbid and portentous. Indeed n
3S
995J
S4 GEORGE III. Proceedings agabut Joseph Gerrald [996
blacker cloud never faune ov^ this island.
Those who are versed in Uie history of their
country, in the history of the human race,
must know, that rigorous state prosecutions
have always preened the sra of convulsion :
and this sra, I fear, will be accelerated by
the folly and madness of our rulers. If the
people are discontented, the proper mode of
quieting their discontents is, not by institu-
ting rigorous and sanguinary prosecutions, but
by -redressing their wrongs, and conciliating
their affections. Courts oijustice, indeed, may
be called in to the aid of ministerial ven-
geance ; but if once the purity of their pro-
ceedings is suspected, they . will cease to
be obiects of reverence to the nation ; they
will degenerate into empty and expensive
pageantry, and become the nartial instru-
ments of vexatious oppression. Whatevermay
become of me, my prmciples will last for ever.
Individuals may perish ; but truth is eternal.
The rude blasts of tyranny may blow from*
every quarter; but freedom is that hardy
plant which will survive the tempest, and
strike an everlasting root into the most unfa-
vourable soil.
Impressed with the justice of these senti-
ments, dungeons, fetters, exile, carry no
horror to me ; for I say, with the immortal
Sidney, that '* though I have a particular
love to ray country, of which, I hope, that I
have given some testimony ; though I tliink
that being exiled from it is a neat evil, from
which I would redeem myselfwith the loss of
a great deal of my blood; yet, when that
country of mine, which used to be esteemed
a paradise, is now like to be made a stage of
imury; the liberty which we hoped to s-
tablish oppressed; the best of our nation
made a prey to the worst; the parliament,
court, and army corrupted; the people en*
slaved ; all things vendible, and no man safe,
but by such evif and infamous means as flat-
tery and bribery; what joy can I have ip my
own country in this condition ? . Is it a plea-
sure to see all that I love in the world sold
and destroyed? Shall' I renounce all my old
principles, learn the vile court arts, and make
my peace by bribing some of the crew ? Shall
their corruptions and vice be my safety? Ah !
BO ; better is a life among strangers, than in
lay own country upon such conditions. Whilst
I live I will endeavour to preserve my li-
berty; or, at least, not consent to the de-
stroying of it. I hope I shall die in the same
principles in which I have lived, and will live
no longer than they can preserve me. I have
in my life been guuty ot many follies, but as
I think, of no meanness. I will not blot and
defile that which is past, by endeavouring to
provide for the future. I have ever heard in
my mind,, that shbutd God cast me into
such a condition, as that I cannot save my
life, but by doing an indecent thinjg, he shows
me the time is come when I should resign it ;
and when I cannot live in my own country,
but by .such ineans i^ are worse than dying
in it ; I think be shows me I ou^t to keep*
myself out of it." See Sidney's Letten. «
Gentlemen, I am in your bands, I feel not
the slightest anxiety; if it would promote the
the cause, I woi:dd chearfully make the sacri-
fice ; for, if I perish on an occasion like the
present, out of my ashes will arise a flame to
consume the tyrants and oppressors of my'
country.
Moral light is as irresistible by the mind,
as physical by the eye. All attempts to im--
pede its progress are vain. It will roll ra-
pidly along; and as well may tyrants imagine/ '
that by placing their feet upon the earth, they
can stop its diurnal motion, as that they shaU
be able, by e£krts the most virulent and per-.
tinacious, to extinguish the light of reason and'
philosophy, which happily for mankind is
every where Spreading aroimd us.
Surely the experience of all ages shouid
have taught our rulers, that persecutions*
never can efface principles ; and that the
thunders of the state will prove impotent^
when wielded acunst patriotism, innocence,
and firmness. Whether, therefore, I shall be
permitted to elide gently down the current of
life, in the bosom of my native country,
among those kindred spirits whose approbiJa-
tion constitutes the greatest comfort of my
living ; or whether I be doomed to dra^ out
the remainder of my existence amidst thieves
and murderere, a wandering exile on the bleak
and melancholy shores of New-Holland, my
MiKD, equal to either fortune, is prepared to
meet the destiny that awaits it.
^^ Seu me tranquilla senectus
'' Expectat, seu mors atns circumvolat alis ;
*^ Dives, inops; Romae, seu fors it^ jusserit
" EXUL."
To be torn a bleeding member from that'
country which we love, is indeed, upon the
first view, pidnful in the extreme ; but all
things cease to be painful, when we are sup-
ported by the consciousness that we have
done our duty to our fellow-creatures ; and a
wise man rising superior to all local preju-
dices, if asked for his country, will turn h:s
eyes from ^* this dim spot which men call
earth, and will point, like Anaxagoras, to the
heavens.'' Milton,
Gentlemen, my cause is in your hands^ —
You are Britons. — You are freemen. — No-
thine more therefore is necessary to be sud.
You nave heard the charge ; you have heard
the evidence ; and you know the punishment
which follows upon conviction. Weigh well,
then, whether tne charge itself involves any
guilt ; whether the evi&nce produced affixes
that charge upon me ; and above all, whe-
ther, in case of conviction, the punishment
which I am to sufier, is not more than pro-
portionate to the ofience.
Before I take my leave of you this nifi^t,'
•—perhaps for ever,-— let me remind you, tnafc
justice is in ever)[ situation, and in none more
than that of a jury, to be adminbtered in.
mercy. Upon your strict attention to thia
997]
Jitf SeditiOH.
A. D. 1794.
[99»
mod moral maxim, depends your own final
oo<>mand\inalterableaUoUnent; and to those
"wbo leftise to practise it, ** the throne of
mer<;7 will be inaccessible, and the Saviour
of the world, will have been bom in vain.''
Rambler,
ft Lord Jwtice C^A.-^6eDtlemen of the
jury, you have heard a great deal, and I will
not keep you much longer, because I consider
itis as very unnecessary, in speaking to gentle-
men of your sound sense and understanding ;
you have given very particular attention, and
art as able to judge of it as I am. The libel
has been found rSevant, afler the most de-
liberate discussion by counsel at great length;
and it was also considered very lully from the
bench: it was found relevant to infer the
pains of law, and is now submitted to you, to
try whether d:ie panel is guilty of the crime
libelled, yea or no.
Gentlemen, the crime charged is sedition,
and^ very heinous crime itis; and nothing
can strike more at the peace and quiet of
society, and indeed it tends to subvert society
altogether. The public prosecutor, in justice
to the i>anel, that he nnght be prepared for
his defence, has charged different facts and
circumstances, from which he infers the
crime of sedition; and the libel concludes,
** all which, or part thereof, being found pro-
ven, he ought to be punished with the pains
of law,'' wnich in this case is an arbitrary
punishment : the meaning of this is, that aU
though the puUic proseaitor libels a variety
of facts and circumstances, ^ret, if he^ brings
a proof of such facts and circumstances as
you shall be of opinion sufficiently supports
the charge of sedition, you will find the panel
guilty, or the libel proven ; and, if you. think
there is nothing to substantiate the charee,
you will find the libel not proven, or find the
panel not guilty.
. Gentlemen, the first thing you have to en-
quire into is, whether you think that meeting
that denominated itself *' The British Con-
vention of the Delegates of the People, associ-
ated to obtain UniverBal Suffrage and Annual
Parliaments,*' was a seditious meeting ; and if
you think it is not a seditious meetine, then,
to be sure, you will acquit the panel, oecause
yrhat is charged against him is the part he
took in that seditious meeting ; but if you
think it is a seditious meeting, then you will
inquire whether the panel is accessary art
and paf t or not.
Gentiemen, as to the first question, Imw
£ur there is evidence to establish this conven-
tion of delegates to be a se^tious meeting ;
it will occur to yourselves, eentlemen, that
there have been already, no less than two of
your fellow-subjects convicted of the erime of
sedition, as members of that convention^ and
accordingly condemned to transportation;
and that there are other two indicted for the
same crime, but did not think proper to stand
their trial, and they accordii^ly stand fugi-
Uted by a judgment of this Court, Blr. Cal^
lender and Mr. Scott $ you h«ve, therefore,
eentlfnnen, the verdicts of two very respecta^
ble juries, stamping upon this meeting the
character of seditious.
Gentiemen, it has been said, and much in-
sisted upon, that it is contrary to the rights
of mankind ^l general, not to be allowed to
apply to parliament. I do not say that is a
criminal act, if it rested there alone ; but,
gentiemen, I would submit to your own feel-
mgs, — it is not a matter that rests upon evi*
dence, but upon your own feelings, — as men,
as members of society, and as subjects of this
kingdom, whether you feel any grievances,
that this country labours under, that should
entitie them to make such a cry agamst the
govemnient of the country. For 'my own
part (and I appeal to your own feelings if it
18 not a just observation), I have always oon-
sidered this country as the envy of the world
at large, as the happiest kin^m upon the
face of the earth ; and I submit to you, whe-
ther or not as much happiness does not exist
in this kingdom as ever did ? Every man is
sure of enjoying every thing he has in perfect
security : his life is secure, and his liberty is
secure, by the laws of the country', and his
property is also secure ; he is absolutely cer-
tain that nothing will be taken from him that
he has any right to enjoy. And I submit it
to you whether or not, even if there had been
ground for complaints, it was a proper time to
ring forward those complaints, at a time
when we were involved in a war with a fe-
rocious and cruel nation, at present setting
the rest of Europe at defiance; and when tha
greatest unanimity, among the sulgects of
mis kingdom, is absolutely necessary to put
an end to that war ; I submit to you, whether
any good member of society, would prefer his
complaint against the government of the
oountrv at such a time. But if you feel as I
feel, that the complaints are groundless, and
that the country is livins in a state of tran-
quillity, secure of their lives and properties
against every attack whatever; I submit to
you, whether is that man innocent who calls
the people together, and impresses their
minds, with ideas hostile to the government
of the country, — with ideas of mal-adminis-
tration on the part of the kin^, the parlia-
ment, and the administrators of public affiurs,
to impress their minds with an ioea that all is
corrupt, and that xi reform is absolutely ne-
cessary, by annual pariiaments and universtd
sufiVage, a thing that never can be obtained
by the consent of parliament : and if you con-
sider a moment, I am very sure that if the
people were to obtain it, they would them-
selves feel the bad effects of it before a
twelve-month was over, and they would be
glad to have the old constitution re-establish-
ed ; and therefore, if persons call such meet-
ings of the people together, I submit to you,
whether that is innocent, when the conse-
quence is alienating their affections from the
king and constitution, and from the gpvern^
990]
S4 6SOSGB III.
s 0gahid Joseph GerraU
ment of the eoimtiy^ excitiiig fhtm to rm
up, and oTertuTD the govenment by superior
£»rce?
GcDtlemen, it is said, that the deicrip-
tioD of their meetings, calling themselves
citisensy dividing themselves into sections,
making conventions of emeigencj^ secret
committees and all the rest of it, are in-
nocent things in themselves ; and I do not
think his majesty's advocate has laid them as
a crime, unconnected with any other circum-
stance; but, gentlemen, the text is always
best understood by the context; too are not
tp take this paracraph in the inmctment by
itself, but from ue whole, as laid and as
proved, you are to judge of the meaning and
intention of the parties here. And when
you find meetings established in this country,
^^ under denominations never before knpwn, as
#^ committees of emergency, of orgaaixation, of
finance, and all the rest of it ; when you see
that assumed at a (>eriod when we are in an
open declared war with France, when we ken
that it is borrowed firom the convention of
France, and when you compare it with the
vbole of their conduct, particularly the reso>
]utk>ns of that meeting and the speeches, I
81^, you will consider, whether, upon a fair
oonstruction of the whole, they were not imi-
tating France in the form of their govern-
qient, and that the object of their meetmg
v^i hke France, to overturn the established
oonstitution, and put every thing upon the
same footing with France, where aristocracy
is reviled, the king reviled, and indeed wheie
there is no constitution at all. That, gentle*
men, is the great object of your inquiry ; and
ifhen you attend to the whole of the resolu-
tions and motions, as they appear upon tiie
face of the minutesi which were recovered
out of the hands of their own secretary, and
compare them with the f>aper8 found m the
ppBsession of Margaret, Sinchtir, and Oerrald,
and also, with the parole evidence that has
been given in this c^e, you will judge whe-
tber» upon the whole, ittloes not appear to you,
that these people were imitating the French
convention, and that they meant to follow the
Opirit of the French, in establishing their form
Qf«»verament.
. Uentlemen, there is a number of seditious
resolutions and speeches in this indictment,
and one of them a very capital one, which J
think borders as near upon high treason as
any thing I ever saw: *« That this convention,
considering the calamitous consequences of
any aor of the legislature which may tend to
deprive the whole, or any part of the people,
of their undoubted right to meet, either by
themselves, or by delegation, to <&8cuss any
matter xelative to their common interest,
whether of a public or a private nature, and
holding the same to be totally inconsistent
^th the first principles and safety of society,
and also subversive of our known and ac-
knowledsed constitutional liberties, do hereby
dfidami ne&jsa Cod and the world* that we
now
shall foUov the wbdenma amapleftf htmar
times, by paying no remrd to any act winA
shall nuUtate against ue ooQsliSutiott af i«tir
eountiy ; and tSall continue to assemUey aen^
consider of the best means b^ vrfaich w« tarn
accomplish a real representation of the people
and annual electna, until compelled to
by superior force.*' The lannniga of this t«*
solution is too plain to need any iUurtntkn*
It is absurd to suppose that tbey meant to
cany any thing by strength of anns| §09
what could such a small number do against
the military force of thu coontry ?-^toiaoi^
one is the number to precede the actimi
but that is not the numner of people lo be
engaged in this action, for they were onl^ iIm
debgates of the people; anditanpearsthat
these delegates, wnen they openea their ee*
cret letters, were to convene theic oonstituenta
and repair to the place of meeting. I hope
thcfe were not many of them ; hut if they
had been allowed to go on, I daxe ssf thej^
would have been fouiu to he the- represeatft*
tives of a great many more than I could wiib
for.
Now, gentlemen, when you consider the
whole of this resolution^ and the Bpeechesjy
and the sealed letter to be given to eitichdeitt-'
Ete, the contents of which are net to be
kown^ and when the very emergency has
happened upon which they were to meet (for
the landine of foreign troops is one of tbein)^
is it possible for you to Delieve that it waa
merely a reform in parliement thattfa^in^
tended? ifitwas, thm was no oocasioii for
any secrecy at all ; but on the other hand, if
a rising of the people was intended, then I
conceive that a committee of secrecy, and a
convention of emergency, are necessary and
prudent^ and the idea of a reform in parlia*
ment is all nonsense ; for if that was then in*
tention, thev would have made their appln
cation openly to parliament, and pailiament
would have granted or withheld their petition.
. Gentlemen, it is veiy observable that there
is a blank in the minutes t now, in order to
supply tha^ there is a paper recovered fh>m
the possession of Charles Sinclair, ** That in
case the minister, or any other member o(
either House of Farliament, bring forward at
motion for leave to bring in a convention* bill,
such as has passed in Ireland, to prevent the
people from meeting according to their just
rights by the revolution, the same motieo
shall be notice to the delegates to meet in
convention to assert their rights.''
Gentlemen, it is said that this paper is not
authenticated : and to be sure, if you think it
is not, you will lay it out of your consideration t
but in the first ptoce, it was found in Mr. Saa«
dair's chamber, tied up in a handkerchief
and brouffht in a chaise along with Mr. Ger*
laid and Mr. Matgarot to the sheriff clerfc1»
office. Mr. Mack generally had the kesphlff
of the papers there ; says he, I do not thinK
I was thm when the papers were iMDUghtin,
butlcameiayeQraooftafter; tberte"inine"'
1001]
Jw SedUion*
a;d. iYd4^
[1002
taons were goims 00, and it vas put tnto my
hand; tbe naodkerchief was laid upon the
ihmS cleric^ table» tbe sheriff was sit-
ling there, and the clerks, the procurator*
^scal, and so on. Is it possible to suppose
that th^se persons — all men of character —
would do that, in order to convkt an innocent
Bnn, for which they ought to be hanged, by
extlacting eYidence and putting false evidence
hi its place ? Mack says, thsft he locked it up,
and it was under his lock and key till il was
mened uid inventoried in presence of Sin*
euir himsdf, and other persons. This naper
it Hiarked at the back by Aitcheson ; and Ail*
cheion told you, that he acted as assistant-
secretary; so that this paper is endorsed by
Aitcheson in character of secretary to the
convention, and ailerwards found in Sinclair's
possesnon, aS he was the mover I think of
the amendments upon Callender's motion.
Bi^' gentlemen, thait is not all, for here are
two or three witnesses tell you precisely that
it was debated in the convention, and resolved
on, that in certain cases this convention of
emergency was to meet; and one of those
cases is. If uxy Inll should be brought into
nscliament siaular to that which passed in
the parliament of Ireland, and this is con-
firmed by the evidence of more than one or
two witnesses. Whv, eentlemen, this paper,
so well authenticated, found in the possession
of Charles Sinclair, brought to the sheriff*
clesk's office, committed to the care of the
gentlemanwho is the usual keeper of papers
m that office, and kept ander his lock and key
till they were opened oefore Mr. Sinclair him-
self I submit to vott whether that is not very
good evidence, that this paper (which is of
the hiffhest importance, aula which borders
upon high tveason) is sufficiently authentic
cated to your satisfaction. And indeed^ sen-
Uem^n, there is a great deal more than mat,
because there is even Mr. Genald^s first
speech, which is at such great length in the
indictment, of which Cockbum swears that
he rscollects thai a number of paragraphs in
it wePB delivered in the meeting, and he does
not pretend to say that there is any thing
Aiateriall^ diffenent in the paper kota what
he heard in the meeting; thousth he will not
identify the whole of it, he did not see any
thine remarkably erroneous in it ; that is, he
eoold not say it was terbatim the same, but
m point of substance he could not discover
any difierence. Then, gentlemen, there is
William Ross, a member of the convention,
who writes the short-hand, he swears he took
this speech down i<i shortrhand, uid ftom
that published it in the Gazetteer, and the
public prosecutor copied it from the Gasetteer ;
this is pretty gpod evidence to show that that
speech was delivered in that meeting. This
is the speech, ^ I rise to congratulate the
convention," &c. [reads it fh)m the indict-
ment}.
Now, gentlemen, m the first place, this is
published in the Gazetteer; 9M taken by the
public prosecutor 'verbtaim ftom the Gazetteer*
and it IS confirmed by the parole evidence, as
aiso by the minutes of the convention, wii^re
you will find the substance of it; and I sub-
mit to you whether there is not sufficient
matter to establish this meetmg to be a sedi-
tious meeting; and if you are satisfied that it
is a seditious meeting, the next question is.
whether \his panel is guilty actor, or art and
part in the proceedings of such meeting.
(Gentlemen, the concluding of the libel- is.
that if he is found gail^, actor, or art and
part of the crimes cluaged,that is sufficient to
mfer the pains of law : ^nd the law is that if
any unlawfiil act is committed where a number
are concerned, one person may be more active
in the commission of the iact than others, but
in the eye of the law they are all considered
as guilty, art and part in the crimes charged,
and all liable to suffer the pains of law.
Gentlemen, I have anticipated a good deal
of the evidence upon this head already.
When yon see Mr. Gerrald taking a very ac^
tive part, and making speeches such as you
have heard to day, I look upon him as a very
dangerous member of society ; for I dare say
he has eloipience enough to persuade the
people to rise in arms.
Mr. Gerrald. — Oh my lord ! my lord ! thi^
is a very improper way of addreflsing a jury *
it is descending < to personal abuse. — God
forbid that mv eloquence shoirid ever be made
use of for such a purpose !
Lord Justice Ctert, — Mr. Gerrald, I do not
say that you did so, but that you liad abilities
to do it.
Gentlemen, he has no relation, nor the
least property in the country, but he comes
here to disturb the peace of the country, as a
dele^te from a society in Bndand to raise
sedition in this country : I say he appears to
me to be much more criminal than Muir or
Palmer or Skirving, because they were all na-
tives <4' this oouQtry.
' Gentlemen, if you are satisfied that this
meetiiig is a seditious meetings I do not w^
how it 18 possible to avoid the consequence of
fihding this panel gidHy art and part of the
crime charged : but, gentlemen, it is hot my
verdi»ct that b to be returned, you will return
such a verdict as your own consciences, will
direct.
Fridayj March 14, 1794. — EUven o'clock.
The Court having met pursuant to adjourn-
ment, and the names of tlie jury having been
called over, they brought in the following
VERDICT.
Edinburgh^ March 14, 1704.
The above assize having been enclosed,
made choice of tbe- said sir WilHam Forbes to
be their chancellor, and tiie said Peter Rill to
be their clerk, and having considered the cri-
iBfidal libel, raised and pursued at the iiistancc
of his majesty*8 advocate for his m%iesty*s in-
terest, agatnM Joseph Gerrald, panel;; the in-
terlocutor of relevancy prenemiced thereupon
1003] 34 GflORGE in.
Proceedii^t.0fftiMit Jotepk Qerrald
iiOOi
by the Courty and the evidence adduced in
proof of the liiM^l, they all in one voice find
the panel Joseph Gerrald Guilty of the crimes
libelled; in witness whereof, their said chan-
cellor and clerk have subscribed these pre-
sents, in their names, and by their appemt-
ment, place and date as above.
(Signed) William Forbes, chancellor.
Peter Hill, Clerk.*
Lord Justice Clerk,-^ Gentlemen, I am per-
ifectly satisfied that you have given that at-
tention to this case which it aeserved ; and
now you are at liberty to go about your bu«
ainess.
Mr. Gerrald, now is your time to speak, if
you have any thing to say.
Mr. Gillies, — My lords, I have an objection
to state to this verdict I need scarcely say
that I mean no reflection upon the sentfemen
of the iury who have delivered in the verdict,
and who, I have no doubt meant to discharp
their duty conscientiously, to the best of their
knowledge. I state tlus objection with the
more confidence, that it is not so much an
obiection to the words or the form as to the
substance of the verdict It is essentially
requisite bv the laws of this and every other
country, that the Jury should conader the
whole evidence be^ore them ; and so much is
this the case, that even if they do consider it,
yet if the verdict does not expressly bear tint
they did so, vour lordship knows better than
I do that such a verdict is void. This verdict
bears that the jury have << conudered the cri-
minal libel raised and pursued by his majes-
ty's advocate, for his majesty's interest, agaiast
Joseph Gerrald, panel, the interlocutor of re-
levancy pronounced thereupon by the Court,
and the evidence adduced in proof of the
libel."
My lord, they oueht also to have consider-
ed the defence whicn was stated, and the evi-
dence adduced or referred to, on the part of
the panel; 'and they not only oueht to have
considered these in fact, but their verdict
ou^ht to have stated^ that they did consider
this evidence, and that they did take into
consideration this defence.
But, my lords, this is not all. In a common
case I know well, that^ if a verdict is returned
to your lordships, stating that the jury have
considered the evidence before them, no proof
can be received that they liave not consiaered
that evidence. It must be taken forgranted that
the jury have considered it, as the verdict states
that they have done so. The evidence of the
verdict itself cannot in the common case be
redargued, because I cannot be permitted to
lead a»proof of what passed among the jury
after they were inclosed. No such proof can
be received, in opposition to what the verdict
itself bears. But what is the case here?
There was here a most voluminous body of
written evidence laid upon this table ; these
writings, it was admitted by the candour of
the public prosecutor, might, and I will be
bold to say, did contain much evidence in fii^
vour of the unfortunate gentleman at your
lordships bar. This written evidence consisted
of several hundred pages, which , could not
have been read in less than six or seven
hours. I must say therefore, in point of fact,
that the jury neither did, nor could consider
the sreat body of written evidence that waa
laid oefore them. If I saw a man in this
room last night, and if I see him here aaun
this morning, I cannot believe that he nas
been at Botanjr Bay in the interim ; in the
same manner, if a jury inclose for twenty mi*
nutes, and aflerwards return and say the/
have considered the body of written evidence,
which it must have taken seveiml . hours to
consider, I cannot believe them : we know
that the fact must be otherwise ; and the
proof which I offer is complete, that the jury
were only inclosed for twenty minute& a space
of time in which it was not possible tor tnem
to have read the evidence which was laid be-
fore them, and which it was their duty to read
and to consider. It was the more necessaiy
for the jury to have considered this body of
written evidence, because the panel did not
take the advantage of a counsel . to state his
defence ; and however great his talents may
be, he is not, he cannot be possessed of that
leoil knowledge and of those professional
htu>itsnecessary to enable any man to comment
upon evidence. It was still the more neces*
sary for them to consider this written evidence,
as the public prosecutor admitted before them,
that it might contain a great deal of exculpa-
tory proot^ upon considering which, I am en-
titled to conclude, that the jury would either
have found this gentleman not guilty, or have
returned a special verdict, finding part of the
crime libelled on proved, and part not proved.
I need not enlarge upon what I have now
stated. The jury were bound by every prin-
ciple of justice, by every rule of law to con-
sider this evidence ; and I offer to prove that
they did not consider it, that they were in-
closed only twenty minutes, a space of time
in which it was impossible for any human be-
ing to consider it.
Mr. Solicitor General, — My lords, I shall
trouble vou with a verv few words in answer
to the objections stated by my brother. The
first is, that the verdict does not specially
bear that the jury had considered the evi-
dence on the part of the'panel. It is a pretty
good answer to that, that there was no evi-
dence adduced on the part of the panel ; the
only evidence Uiat was adduced, was on the
part of the prosecutor, upon which evidence
the panel was willing his defence should rest
The next objection is, that the verdict bears
that they have considered the evidence ad-
duced in proof of the libel, when it was im-
possible tney could have done so, from the
time that they were inclosed. .My lord, it was
perfectly unnecessary that' they should con-
sider every word of this voluminous body of
evidence. The evidence which I Tounded
1005]
fcfr Sedition*
A. D. 1794.
[1006
upon on the part of the prosecution could be
considered in five minutes, as 'well as in five
years. ' And as to the panel, I do not remem-
ber that he founded upon any one part of it ;
and if he did, I am sure the jury haa a perfect
opportunity of consideration.
Mr. John CUrk. — My lords, I shall trouble
your lordships with but few words, and before
I begin, I must take the liberty of making the.
•ame profession that Mr. Gilues did, thaX I
have no doubt but this jury meant to dis-
charge their duty most conscientiously and
and most faithfully ; but a jury of the most
honest as well as fsuthfiil men may be mis-
taken in the dtscharge of that duty.
My lords, I must in the first place speak
with respect to what Mr. Solicitor General
said, that there was no evidence adduced on
the partof thenanel. It is true there was
not: but he maae a defence, and a very long
and able defence it was, and there is nothing
in that verdict which shows that the jury
have taken that evidence into consideration.
With regard to thie next point, it is very true
that the most material parts of that evidence
might have been comprehended in a very small
compass ; but how was this matter to be deter-
mined? It could only be determined by read-
ing over the whole of the evidence; and the
more so, because the greater part*of that*evi-
dence was incompetent to be produced, and
•ught not to have been produced, inasmuch
as they referred to a period long before the
«anel had any connexion with the convention.
my lords, the public prosecutor himself said
it might comprehend a great deal of excul-
patory matter — after which concession was it
not their duty to read through that evidence
in order to discover that exculpatory mat-
ter? My lords, it is sud that he did not
found upon these papers: it is true he did
not; but he made a defence of three hours
and a half, in which he exhausted himself
upon other subjects, leaving it to the jury, trust-
ing that they would supply the defects of his
evidence, and that they would consider the
written evidence Iving before them.
Lard Justice Clerk, — What do your lord-
ships say to this?
l^rd Henderland. — My lord, the jury in re-
turning their verdict were not bound to say
any thing farther than that upon considering
the evidence they found so and so. With
Kspect to the panel's defence, he was fully
4ieard, and it is impossible to suppose it was
not considered . With respect to the evidence
that was lying upon the table, they have
formed an opinion, a constitutional opinion,
which they were entitled to form, and we are
bound to presume that it was partly formed
upon that evidence.
Lord JSjAgrorc— My lord, I think, that
with respect to this verdict, the jury have re-
turned a very proper verdict; for my lord, it
is neither necessary nor customary to say,
that they centered the arguments used,
either on one side or th^ other— if they .had
said that they had considered what the panel
had said at the bar they must also have stat-
ed that they had considered what his majes-
ty's solicitor general had stated in support of
the charge. They are supposed to have con-
sidered both, but it is not customary to state
more than they have here stated ; • you must
believe that the jury considered every thing .
proved and every thing stated on both sides.
As to what time they took I know not, nor
is it my duty to inquire ; they would take as
much time as they thought proper ; they have
declared that they did so ; and I am of opinion
that there is no relevancy in the objection.
Lord SwirUon, — My lord, the jury have'
stated in this verdict, that they considered all
that was laid before them, the libel, the inter-
locutor of relevancy, and the evidence. It is
not usual for them to say that they have con-
sidered'the arguments. As to the time that
they took to consider we have no rieht
to inquire; they could look at the material
parts of the evidence in a very few minutes ;
and whether they looked at it or not we have -
no business to inquire ; if it was on thehr me* .
mory it was sufficient. I am convinced that'
they have acted honestly and faithfully, as
they were bound by their religion and their
oath to do.
Lord Dunsinnan, — ^My lord, an intelligent
and respectable jury have, upon their great'
oath, returned a verdict beanng to proceed'
upon the evidence, and the only evidence
that was laid before them, which was the-
evidence in support of the prosecution : every
body present knows that there was none oi«
fered on the part of the panel, and they could
not consider evidence wnich was not laid be-
fore them. As to what fell from the pane),
they have no doubt considered it; ana they
have returned a verdict which appears to me
a very proper one.
Lord Abercrvmbie, — ^I am of the same opi-
nion.
ILord Justice Clerk, — My lords, I should have
been veiy much surprised if this panel should
be acquitted upon a blunder in a verdict ; but
the verdict appears to me to be most unexcep*
tionable, ana the objection is founded in a
misapprehension of the case altogether. The
panel and his counsel declared uiey had not
any proof; if they' had any proof by parole
evidence, it was tneir duty to have brought it
forward, and if they had meant to have found-
ed upon the written evidence on the table,
they oueht to have pointed out what parts of
that evidence they meant to found upon; an<l
therefore you must consider that he had no
evidence to bring in exculpation, and all that-
the jury had to consider was, the evidence on
the part of the prosecution.
The public prosecutor libels upon a bundle
of papers, ana because two or three hundred
pages of writing are produced in all, and ten
lines of that is necessary to- found upon . in
support of the eharae, can itbe necessary that
the jury should go Uirough it all? Iq cases of
IQOT] 84 GEORGE IIL Proceedingi ugainsi Jc9eph GerraU
[1008
ibi]gery it vpMj be necesaaiy to produce vety
long writings^ sod perhaps only two or three
lioes of it may be founded upon for the sup-
port of the charge; but can it be supposed
that it is necessary for the juiy to read over
the whole of it? The thing is too gross to
be listened to bv any court whatever. The
JU17 considered aU that it was necessary for
t)>ein to consider; they considered the libel^
the interlocutor of relevancy, and the proof
on the part of the prosecutor. Then, they
say, there was a kttg defence, and they should
have stated that they bad considered that<—
My lords, the jury did their duty in not con-
sidering that defence t it wss adefence against
the televancy of the indictment, and the irst
two hours of his speech v^t to show that
all |bat he had done was innocent But, my
lords, was not it offiored to the Court in a
very long plea^pg and found relevant? I
^preheM the iuiy have done their du^
properly: they nave a power, to be sure, if
they thmk proper,even after the libel is found
relmnt, they may acquit, but the duties of a
jury and of a judge are distinct; it is the bu-
siness of the Court to determine tlie law as
to the relevancy of the libel, and of the jury
to judge of the ftet; and as it was found re*
levant by the Court, the juiy had no more to
4o bitt to consider the evidence, aikl, in my
opinion, they have returned a very proper
verdict, finding the panel guil^.
Mr. Genak^ if you have any thing to say,
now is the time.
Mr* Gerra/if.— My lord, I have very little
to say. I am as little hurt, as I am surprised,
aft the verdict retunied; inasmuch as I &id
that the public prosecutor himself, in the
Qouse of Commons, anticipated the fkte
which I was to OMet, but my lord, I trust
that amoral and enlightened world, collect! ve-
ly, will do justice to the purity of the motives
which have actiided my conduct; and I glonr
in being the advocate of a cause, with which
is complicated truth, justice, atid fireedom,
which I icnow must and will ultimately
triumph.
Lord Jutiee Cfarft.r-Your lordships will
now proceed to ^ive your opinions upon the
punishment which you thmk in this case
audit to be inflicted.
Lord HewUrUnd,r^My k>rd, Ifie panel at
the bar is found guilty of the crime libelled,
which is seditioiL And my lord, after the
ve^y able argument and sound constitutional
law which you heacd firom the solicitor ge-
neral, it would be highly improper in me, as
it would be irksome to your loraships, diat I
should eiilaigq upon the nature of this char|Be.
. My lord, vre are to consider of (he puniSi-
ment due to that crime, of which we have
had so' many miserable eiamples before us,
that I can prooose nc^hing else but this, that
the prisoner snaU be recommitted lo prison,
and there remain till an opportunity shall
offer for carrying the sentence that I propose
sliall be pronounced against him of Inmish-
ment, by transportation, for the spate ef ftur-r
teen years, into execution.
My lord, it appears to me, that by nt^
means an adequate punishment can be m*'
flicted for this offence; and even if this has
the appearance of severity, which I cannon
think It has, it is the only judgment that
could be pronounced in such a case, to secure
the safety of this country from the commis*
sion of such crimes. I am convinced that
the people of this country, who are an in-
telligent an acute, and a sensible people,-
however much they mav be led away by se-
ditious persons, when mej come to refleoS
coolly, dispassionately, and fiurly, upon tlia
nature of this crime, upon the danger that
arises from the commission of it, and upon
the security and the safety they enjoy; bj the
exercise of that discretionary power, which is
vested in this Court by law, will be of opinkns
that the judgment we pronounce this day is
a just ana a proper one.
Lord £i^prove.— My lord, I am extremelyt
happy, that this centleman has had a ftdl mod
a fair trial, and £at he has acted with the pro^
priety of calling in the assistance of able coon-*
sel, who have done honour to themselves/
and justice to their client; and, my lord, 1
understand (ibr my state of health did noc
permit me to remam in Court the whole ef
the time) that the gentleman himself is •
man of great aiMities, and that he was in«
dulged by the Court, in stating every thhi^
that he wished to stale. My lord, I appre-
hend, that afler the arguments we have
heard, there can be no doubt that, this Courts
by the law of this country, whatever it may
be in other countries, are authorised to infyct
the punishment of banishment by tnuispor«>
tstion^ and that this is the only proper pu«
nishment that can be inflicted fur the aimer
here charged, to prevent others from com-i
mitting the same crime, and to keep peace
and tranquillity within this part of the king*
dom. And, my lord, in consequence of what
your lordships have uniformly pronounced
upon cases ot this land j[which I am hear^jr
sdrry there has been occasioa for), I cannot
see any thing in this case tiiat could autho^'.
rise me to deviate firom the same mode of
punishment that your lordships have inflicted'
m the ether c^ses.
My lord, as to this verdict of the jury, by
which he is found g;uilty, taking under con-
sideration all the circumstances, I am of the
same opinion that has been given by my
lu>noureble brethren.
Lord Swinion. — My lord, in considering
this crime about which your lordships have-
heard so much, the more I consider, and the-*
more I turn my mind to it, the more I am^
ccmVinced that this Court did right originally
in imposins the sentence that they did im<^
pose. My lord, in considering this case, and
comparing the nnnishment with the erime^ L
hardly know want putiishmetit is adequate to
it, ItrwKs weUsaad fay one of the ablest amb
tooq
Jhr SftbtioM*
g^ieKtesI men that ever lived, that tedition
vas like Pandora's hoz, it ooataios every evil,
k coBtainB every vice. My lord, it is said,
that he is to be sent among pickpockets,
tiiieves and robbers ; but my lord, this crime
is not to be compared with th<»r's, it com^
Cehends every sort of crime, murder, rob^
ry, rape, every thin^ that is crimioal. I
think, my lord, the punishment that has been
proposed is the mildest that can be inflicted,
and I hope will be sufficient to deter others
firoro committing the same crime.
Lord Duntinnan. — My lord^ llie crime of
which this unhappy man now stands con-
victed, is a crime for which, within a few
months, two persons have been tried at that
bar, who have been convicted, and upon those
convictions, the court have pronounced the
judgment of the law. My lord, it would give
flie great pleasure if there were any circum*-
stances in the case of this panel that could
distinguish it favourably from those upon
which we have had occasion to pronounce
judgment before: but the circumstances of
this case tend rather to aggravate it. My
lord, he i^ one of those persons who came
into this country, for the purpose of exciting
civil discord, by inflaming the minds of tlie
people. We have had an opportunity of
seeing that he possesses talents, which ren-
der him exceedingly capable of mischief; the
harangue which we heard last night, though
addressed to the jury, was, I believe, rather
intended for another part of tins court ; we
eaw that his political principles are extremely
dangerous : and my lord, if there is any other
country, which does not inflict such a punish-
ment for such a crime, lam happy that I
live in such a country as this ; and if I were
to propose any difference of punishment, it
would DC rather to increase than diminish it
I am of opinion, doubtless, that the same pu-
nishment should be inflicted in this case as
in the former.
Lord Abercrombie.-^My lord, a legal ob-
jection was stated to the punishment now
proposed; that objection was argued with
uncommon ability, by the learned counsel
for the panel, and your lordships gave vour
judgment upon it. But, my lords, that fe^l
objection was grounded upon this, that Uie
punishment was too severe for the offence of
which he stands convicted by the unanimous
voice of his country. ^
My lord, it has been said, within these
walls, that his intentions all along were inno-
cent, that they were perfectly pure and ho*
]X)urable ; and that had the same crime been
committed in England, it would either have
passed with impunity, or with a very small
punishment, as imprisonment or pillory. My
lord, upon that I shall sav a very few words.
With respect to the panel's motives, I shall,
finr a moment, suppose that his intentions
were pure, and perfectly innocent ; but even
considering the case in that view, I must give
it as my opinion, sitting here as a judge, that
VOL. XXIIL I
A. D. 1794; flOIt)
it would aibrd no motive ibr amitigationof pu*
nishment.* My lord, we all know it is a iacf,
undoubtedly undeniable, that a mistaken prin-
ciple, either in religion or in politics, has often
led the way, with the best of intentions, to com«-
mit crimes of the deepest atrocity. My lord, the
history of this country affords manv instanced
and many examples of this kind ; for exam«-
ple', in the case of the powder plotf many of
the conspirators were men of charaeter, sir
Everard Digby was one of the most accom-
plished, one of the most virtuous men in
England, and my loipd, he was sentenced t6
die as a tmitor, fur the part he took in that
plot ; and on the eve of his execution he wrote a
letter to his wife, in which he expresses hiny-
self in these precise terms : <' Now for my in-
tention, let nM tell you, that if I had thought
there had been the least sin in the plot, I
would not have been of it for all the world:
and no other cause drew me to hazard my
fortune and life, but zeal to God's religion.^'
My lord, this letter, written at that fatal pe^
riod, b^ a man who was beloved by every
person in Europe, leaves no room to doubt of
the sincerity of this confession. Then my
lord, as to this man who lives at the distance
of two centuries from the commission of that
crime, will any person who now hears md
say that the innocency of his intention or the
purity of his motives ought to be urged as a
reason againft executing that sentence?
My lord, I shall just take the liberty of
stating, though I am sorry to ^ive any opi-
nion upon such a point, upon the most cool
and deliberate observations, were I called to
give my opinion upon the point, I would say:
that if this conspiracy, in which the unhappy
man at the bar was an active leader, had been
carried into effect, if that conspiracy had been
followed with entire success, there is not a cor*^
ner of this kingdom in which a degree of misery
and wretchedness must not have followed.
My lord, we have the example ofourowri
times also ; I need not remind your lordships
of 1745 and 1715,} when many men, whd
IMi««
«■)
• " Though civil government'' says Bishop
Butler*^ be supposed to take cognizance of ac-*
tions in no other view'than as prejudicial t^
society, without respect to the immorality of
them ; yet as sneh actions are immoral, so the
sense which m^n have of the immorality of
them^ very greatly contributes, in different
wa^s, to bring offenders to justice: and, that
entire absence of all c imeandguiltin the moral
sense, when plainly appearing, will almost of
course procure, and circumstances of aggra-
vated guilt prevent, a remission of the penal-
ties annexed to civil crimes, in many cases;
though by no means in all." Analogy^ part
1, chap. 3, p. 76, edition of 1791,
f See the case of sir Everard Digby, and
the other consinrators, ante Vol. j^, p. 159.
X See the proceedings against the rebels of
1T15 and' 1745, in Vols. 15 and 18 of this
Collection. *
3T
S4 GEORGE IIL ProoeetUng* against Joteph GerraU.
101 11
hud acted with the best inltntioDS, died the
death of traitors.
My lord, I sav, although the panel could
have established by the clearest and the
.most satisfactory evidence, that his intentions
.were all along perfectly innocent, and his
motives perfectly pure, it would have afforded
no ground whatever for mitigation of punish*
ment ; but I am sorry to say that I can dis-
cover no proof of such innocence of intention.
JVIy lord, we in this world can onljr judge of
the intentions of men from their actions ; and
viewing the actions of this panel, no man of
the least observation can lay his hand upon
his hearty and say, that the evidence affords
.the smallest proof of such purity of motive.
. My lord, with regard to the other point,
it is our province and our duty to judge of this
ai\d every other case by the law of our
country ; we have nothing to do with the law
of any other country, and I cannot think that
the law of England would suffer an offence of
this magnitude either to pass with impunity,
or be punished with a slighter punish-
ment ; and I heartily concur with the rest of
vour lordships in the punishment that your
lordships have proposed.
Lord Juttice ClerL — My lords, in com-
paring this case with the others, I cannot find
an^ Uiing that can possibly make it less cri-
minal. My lords, transportation is, no doubt,
a very severe punishment; we consider it as
the niehest arbitrary punishment that the
laws of this country can inflict ; but I think
it is no more th/m adequate to the offence
which has been proved against this panel,
and of which he has been convicted bv the
verdict of a very respectable jury. My fords,
I feel for the distresses of convicts as much
as any man who hears me : but, my lords,
the happiness of the innocent part of man-
kind requires of us to punish the guilty, and
protect the innocent; and we cannot ^ive
that protection to the innocent part of society
ynless we inflict adequate punishments upon
crimes committed a^amst society.
. M^ lords, in all these cases, I was very
sensible that transportation was a great pu-
nishment ; but, alter considering all the oif-
(erent punishments that the Uwa^ of this
country can inflict, I did not see any one pu-
nishment we could inflict wkach could an-
swer the purpose of ch^ckinjg thia evil, unless
it was by inflicting the puxushment of tians-
vortation alone ; any otner punishment would
nave been a very imperfect one. Simple ba-
nisliment from this countrjr is not at all
proper ; lonja; imprisonment is a thing not
known in this country, and very hurtfiil to the
country as well, because we Imow a seditious
rsrson in prison may do a gjreat deal of harm*
cannot have the least hesitation in thinking
that the punishment of transportation for
fourteen years is the leaot that we can inflict
in this case.
My lords, we have heard a great deal of the
[1012
atelv before me, that taking his own accouat
oftne matter to be just, supposing tha^he
has acted from principle, andtliat his motives
are pure, I do say that he becomes a more
dangerous member of society than if his om^
duct was really criminal, and acting from
criminal motives. A man acting from crixm-
nal motives is not so daneerous a member of
society as a man who thinks he is acting from
principle : for when a man is so misguided in
his principles he overturns society ismd go-
vernment itself. I say *^ sains puipuli supreme
leXf" and it bepomes us. let his intentions be
as pure as they possibly can be, to remove
that man from society, and put it out of his
power to disseminate these daneerous prinei-
ples. I do not know whether his princii^es
are so pure as he professed or not, but if they
are, I think it justifies this punishment just
as much as if he had acted firom the wmrst of
motives, and therefore any other punishment
would be insufficient
SENTENCE t
The lord justice clerk and lords commis-
sioners ofiusticiary having considered the fore-
going veraict, whereby the assize all in one
voice find the panel Guilty of the crimes C-
belied : the said lords, in respect of the said
verdict, in terms of an act passed in the 25th
year of his present majesty, entitled *^ An act
for the more eflectual transportation of felons
and other offenders, in that part of Great Bri*
tain called Scotland," ordain and adjudge that
the said Joseph Gerrald be transported be-
yond seas to such place as his majesty, with
the advice of his privy-council, snail declare
and appoint, and that for the space of four-
teen years from this date, with certification to
him, if after being so transported, he shall re-
turn to, and be found at large within any part
of Great Britain, during flie said fourteen
years, without some lawful cause, and be
thereby lawfully convicted, he shall suffer
death, as in oases of felony, without benefit
of clergy, by the law of England : and or-
dains the said Joseph Gerrald to be carried
back to the Tolbooth of Edinburgh, therein
to be detained till he is delivered over for
beins so transported ; fur which this shall be,
to all concerned, a sufficient warrant.
(Signed) Robekt M'Qoeen.
Innocence of his intentions
aereati
; but it
was justly
observed by my brother who spoke inua«dx- ] Volume,
The legality of the sentences passed upon
G«:Tald, and the other convicts, his.as8ociates,
was much questioned at the time ; and the sub-
iect was more than once discussed in both
nouses of parlkment, particularly in the
House of Commons, on March 10th 1794 ;
Professor Hume has since publbhed a learned
and able defence of the doctrines established
on this occasion by the court of justiciaiy.
See his Com. on the law of Scotland respect-
ing the dee. and pun. of Crimes, Vol. 8, On. 10.
Such particulars as I have collected respect-
ing the fate of Gerrald and the others, will be
found in the Addenda at the end of thia
1015] Proeeedmgi agaimi Da$M Isaac S^OH. A. D. 1794.
rioi4
600. Trial of Daniel Isaac Eaton on an Indictment for pub-
lishing a Seditious Libel^ intituled^ '^ Politics for the People^
or Hqg's Wash/' Tried at Justice Hall in the Old Bailey,
befor^Sir John William Rose^ Serjeant at Law, Recorder
of the City of London, February 24tb : S4 George III.
A. D. 1794.* ^
Damtzl Isaac Eaton was put to the bar.*
Mr. Recorder, — I have ordered the whole
panel to attend, in consequence of the defen-
dant having challenji^d some of the iurymeh
on a former day ; therefore the jurv should be
called, not as they have served, but as they
stand upon the panel.
The panel was called, and the followmg
twelve gentlemen, being the first who ap-
peared, were sworn : —
* A brief account of this case will be found
in the Sessions Paper of the mayoralty of Mr.
Alderman Lc Mesurier, [a. d. 1793, 1794.]
p. 540.
f Prefixed to the original edition of this
trial was the following advertisement : —
The indictment was found by the grand
jury in December sessions 179d ; as soon as it
was returned into court, Mr. Knowlys, of
counsel for the crown, moved Mr. Justice
Ashhurstto direct in what sum the defendant
should be held to bail ; the indictment was
read, and the sum named by Mr. Justice Ash-
hurst was, the defendant himself in one thou-
sand Dounds, and two sureties in five hundred
pounds each. The same night the defendant
was apprehended and lodged in Newgate,
where ne lay till the next session, not being
able to procure bail to so large an amount.
When the trial was to have come on, Mr.
Vaughan was too ill to conduct the defence ;
it therefore devolved on Mr. Gurney.
In January session the defendant was put
to the bar, and the jury were about to be
sworn, when the defendant challenged two of
the jurors peremptorily; the recorder disal-
lowed peremptory challenges, and called upon
him to assign a cause ; the cause the defen-
dant assigned was, that those jurymen had
made declarations which rendered them un-
fit to sit upon a jury to try a man charged
with having published a libel. Though the
defendant had no proof of these declarations'
having been made, Mr. Fielding very liberally
consented to allow the challenges; the re-
mainder of the jury having been discharged,
the trial went off for defect of jurors to Fe-
bniarv session, and the defendant was re-
manded to Newgate.
As Mr. Gumey had prepared himself to
lead the defence at the January session, Mr.
Vaughan in compliment to hhn, wotdd not re-
sume it afterwards. .
Juay.
Rol^ert Ryder.
Thomas Maniey^
Joseph Stafibrd.
James Chabot,
"William Hopkins,
James Alex. Dixwell.
Thomas Nelson,
John Capron,
John Thomas,
George Higginbottom
John Farmer,
Joseph Harris.
Counsel for the Prosecution. — Mr. Fielding,
Mr. Knowlys, Mr. Raine.
Solicitor. -^m. White, Solicitor to the Trea^
sury.
Counsel for the Defendant. — Mr. Felix
Vaughan, Mr. Gumey, Mr. Woodhouse.
Solicitor. — Mr. Bonney, Percy-street.
The indictment was read at length by the
clerk of arraigns, at the desire of toe counsel
for the defenaant, and was as follows : —
INDICTICENT.
London. — ^Atthe general sessions of over and
terminer of our lord the king, hofden for
the city of London, at Justice Hall, in the
Old Bailey, within the parish of Saint
Sepulchre, in the ward of Farrin^oa
Without, in London aforesaid, on Wed*,
nesda^ the fourth day of December^ in
the thirty-fourth year of the rcien of our
sovereign lord George the third, king of
Great Britain, &c.
London^ } ThE jurors for our lord the king,
to wit. ) upon their oath present, that Da-
niel Isaac Eaton, late of London, bookseller,
being a malicious, seditious^ and evil-disposed
person, and greatly disaffected^ to our said
lord the king, and to his administration of
government of this kingdom, and unlawfully,
maliciously, and seditiously contriving, de«
vising, and intending to scandalize, traduce^
and vilify, our said lord the king, and the
regal power and office establish^ by law
within this realm, and to represent our said
lord the king as sanguinary, tyrannical, op«
pressive, cruel, and despotic ; and thereby
to stir up and excite discontents and seditions
amongst the subjects of our said lord the kingp
and to alienate and withdraw the fidelity, a£>
fection, and allegianca, of his said migesty^g
subjects firom his said majesty's person and
government, on the eighteenth day of No-
vember in the year of our Lord one thousand
seven hundred fuid ninety-throe, at LcHUdoa
aforesaid, in the parish of St. Mary4e-Bov
10 15] 34 GEORGE UL AMfl»A«« ugmmi DMmd Isaac SaM [1016
in the ward of Cheap, unlawfully) maliciously,
and seditiously did publish, and cause to be
pliblisbed, a certain pamphlet, intitled, ** Po-
tties for the People ; or. Hog's Wash ;" con -
tikininv therein, among other things, certain
scandalous, malicious, inflammatory, and se-
ditbus matters, of and c(mcerning our said
lord the king ; that is to say,
" You must known then,'' [meaning know]
** that I used, together with a variety of
youthful attachments, to be very fond of
birds and poultry ; and among other things
of this kind, I had a very fine majestic kind of
animal, a game cock,'' [meaning thereby to
denote and represent our said lord the king],
** a haiieht^, sanguinary tyrant^ nursttd in
blood and slaughter from his infancy, fond of
foreign wars and domestic rebellions, into
which he would sometimes drive his subjects,
b}r his oppressive obstinacy, in hopes that be
might increase his power and glory by their
suppression ; now, this haughtv old tyrant,"
[again meaning our said lord the kin^],
" would never let my farm-yard be quiet; for
not content with devouring by far the greater
part of the grain that was scattered tor the
morning and evening repast, and snatching
at ever^ little treasure, that the toil of more
industrious birds mi^ht happen to scratch out
of the bowels of the earth, the restless des-
pot" [meaning our said lord the king] " must
be always picking and cuffing at the poor
doves and pullets, and little defenceless
chickens, so that thev could never eat the
scanty remnant, which his inordinate taxa-
tion lefl them, in peace and quietness : now,
though there were some aristocratic prejudices
hanging about me from my education, so that
I could not help looking, with some consi-
derable reverence, upon the majestic decora-
tions of the person of king Chaunticlere,"
(meaning our said lord the king], ** such as
iis ermine spotted breast, the hne gold trap-
pings about his neck and shoulders, the flow-
ing robe of plumage tucked up at his rump,
and, above all, that fine ornamented thing
about his head there, his crown, or coxcomb,
I believe you call it (however, the distinction
is not very important), yet I had, even at that
time. Some lurking principles of aversion to
bare-faced despotism struggling at my heart,
which would sometimes wiusper to me, that
the best thing one could do, either for cocks
and heh^, or men and women, was, to rid
the world of tyrants" [meaning our said
lord the king, among others], " whose shrill
inartial clarions (the provocatives to fame and
ftwrder) distufb<id the repose, and destroyed*
the happiness, of their respective communi-
ties; so, t believe, if guillotines had been in
fashion, I should certainly have guillotined
hiraj being desirous to be merciful even in
the stroke of death ; afid knowing, the instant
the brain is separated from the heart (which,
ivith this instrument, is done in a moment).
Sain and consciousness is at an ehd^ while
^e linj^ering toUure of the rope inay procras-
tinate the pane for half an hour; howerer^
I managed the nusinets very well, i&r I cmAt
Mr. Tyrant by the head, and dragging -Baa
immediately to the block, with a heavy knife
in my hand, separated his neck at a bbw ;
and what will 8urpri9e you very much, when
his fine trappings were stripped off, I found
he was no better than |ekGomiion scratch
dunghill puUet; no, nor ISaXf so good; for
he was tough and oil3r, and rank with the
pollutions of his luxuriovs vices;" — ^in con-
tempt of our said lord the king, and his laws,
to the evil and pernicious example of all others
in the hke case ofiending, and a^unattbe
peace of our said lord the king, his crown,
and dignity.
And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath
aforesaid, do farther present, that the said
Daniel Isaac Eaton, so being such person as
aforesaid, and so devising, contriving, and
intending, as aforesaid, afterwards, to wit,
on the said eighteenth day of November, in
the said year et otir Lord, one thousand seven
hundred and ninety-three, at London afore-
said, in the parish and ward aforesaid, unlaw-
fully, maficiously, and seditiously, did oub-
lish, and cause and procure to be publisned,
a certain other printed pamphlet, containing
therein, amongst other things, certain scan-
dalous, malicious, inflammatory, and seditious
matters, of and concerning our said lord the
king, according, to the tenor and effect follow-
ing ; that is to say :
** I had a very fine majestic kind of animal,
a game cock" [meaning thereby to denote
and represent our said lord the king], " a
haughty, sanguinary tyrant, nursed in blood
and slaughter from his infancy ; fond ol fo-
reign wars and domestic rebellions, into which
he" [meaning our said lord the king] " would
sometimes drive his subjects bv his oppress
sive obstinacy, in hopes that he might in-
crease his power and glory by their suppres-
sion ;" — in contempt of our said lord the king
and his laws, to tlie evil and pernicious exam-
pfe of all others in the like case offending^
and ag^nst the peace of our said lord the king,
his crown, and dignity.
And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oath
aforesaid, do farther prcsent,that the said Daniel
Isaac Eaton, so being such person as aforesaid,
and so devising, contriving, and intending, as
aforesaid, afterwards, to wit, on the same eigh-
teenth day of November, in the said year of our
Lord one thousand seven himdrcd and ninety-
three, at London aforesaid, in the parish and
ward aforesaid, unlawfully, maliciously, and
seditiously, did publish, and cause ty> be
published, a certain other printed pampldet,
containing therein, among other thmgs, cer«
tain scan£iloas. malicious, and inflammatory
matters, of and concerning our lord the kin^
among others, according to tlie tenor and
effect following; that is to say :
<^ The Reflexions of a True Briton."-*
*^ Kings" [meaning, among others, our s(^
vereign lora the kmg] ^ are wolf shepheids^
JirfMMHgd aeOkmusLOA
1017]
Hornet «tvleB ItuBOL diwoarera of the people;
aud they do not appetr to have lost their oii-
Mtti tftste ;" m eontempt of oiir said lord the
£og and bis laws, to the evil and pernicious
eninple of all others, in the like case offend-
ing, And against the peace of our said lord the
king, bis crown^ and dignity.
The indictment having been opened by Mr.
R^tie,
Mr. Fidding. — Gentlemen of the jary, your
attention^ as a jury of the city of London, is
called to another prosecution for the publics^
tion of a mischievous and seditious libel. I
say another, for true it is, there have been
lately many prosecutions for ofiences of this
d^cription, and unless it be that your ser-
vants^ the servants of the public in responsi-
ve situations in sovemment, and particu-
larly that servant of the public, the attomey-
fleneral, should be remiss where he ought to
Se aictive, should be sluggish where he ought
to be alerts or be asleep when he ought to be
awake, prosecutions of this nature must come
before ymi. When they do come before you,
thev come before the tribunal best calculated
to aetermiue upon every thing that such a
BTosecution imputes, and before the tribunal
vest calculated to determine upon the inno-
cence or guilt of the accused.
Gentlemen, I take upon me to assure my-
self, that you are well aware of the nature
and extent of the dut^r you are now exercising.
There have been agitations lately about the
power of a iury, ami the interposition of a
^ourt ; the differences always seemed to me
extremely trifling; but now there is no kind
of hesitation as to the extent of the proper
province of a jur^ upon such occasions as the
present :— it is this, and God forbid it should
ne otherwise, that in the very frame-work of
the crime, the jury should have a full cogni-
sance of it, and a fiill jurisdiction over it;
that the jury should be alone the judges, as
to tlie nature and extent of the criminality
charged; that neither the book itself, nor a
paragraph selected from the book, nor any ex-
pression, shall be said to be criminal, unless
the iury go with tliat idea, which forms a part
of the indictment, imputing to the publisher
the criminal intention ascribed upon that in-
dictment. God be praised, that power is
fully acknowledged. All that the officer of
^be crown has done in this instance is— and
with a vigilance becoming him — ^to see that
the matter imputed to the prisoner now,
should come before a jury of the city of Lonr
don for their determination. What the duty
of ihe attorney-general was, in the fim in-
stance, is as it were your duty now. You are
to look at the circumstances as he has done ;
but you have a greater power than he has, dot
you are to det^nine upon the guilt or ituMk*
cence of the party accused.
Gentlemea, I confess, in the agitBtion of
questions relative to libel, it baa frequently
struck my mind, that some things perhaps
A. D. 17M.
[1018
had been better ^viAhout prosecution, and
that prosecutions ought to be directed affliinst
others ; but in the result of all these inqui-
ries, as far as my mind has enabled me to
come to a result, I can only lament the im«
perfection of all possible human establish*
ments.
If sedition were suffered to .be scattered
abroad among the people in any possible
way, to be sure any man of common sonse
must easily and readily go along with me in
saying, that infinite mischief must follow.
What then is to be done ? It is the duty of
that great law officer of the country^ the
attomey-getieral, when he has information
from the different persons who are employed
under him, and by his directions to mform
him of those thioes that are going on in
society, if they sHould appear to liave a
dangerous tendency, it highly becomes him
to put them in a state of inquiry, that punish-*
ment may follow where pumshment is deserv-
ed, and punishment may follow under the ad-
ministration of justice in this country, accord-
ing: only to the law ; that idea is conveyed ift
a uiort Latin sentence, which I will bes leave
to translate : punishment is only intencfed ** mt
prniM in paucos, meius iti cmnes ineidiU ;^ ChaH
18, that the punishment which must follow
the conviction of the crime, should only foil
upon a few, and falling upon a few glaring
offenders, that all should apprehend the
daneer of transgressing.
The attorney-general (who cannot do him-
self the honour of attending before you to^
day, and therefore it devolves upon me, in
my humble station, to represent this case to
vou) would have said this, if he had been
nere, which I will say for him. I have now
discharged my duty, I only submit the quef^
tion to you, and it is for you to decide ; he
can do no more, and I am sure you will do
your duty, as he has done bis.
Gentlemen, the particular charge which
has been stated by my friend, and had be-
fore been stated to you by the officer of the
court, I shall beg the liberty of calling your
attention to again. But before 1 do this, let
me remark, that when a man is prosecuted
for words spoken, it seldom happens, unless
the behaviour of the person has furnished
evidence against himself, either by the man-
ner in which he has spoken the words, the
place in which he has spoken the words, or
other circumstances, that the evidehce of
intention can so foirly be got at, as 'to Imvc
no doubt whatever. In a publication, like-
vrise, it may sometimes be difficult to eome
at the intent of the author; but in order to
do that, you must necessarily go into the
context, and into the whole nublicatiotl.
Where it can arise as a defente for the man
accused, that the words which are selected
for prosecution convey a differeni meaning
when taken in detached sentences^ f^om what
they bear in connexion with the general
eontext, it is fair that he should have that
J019] S4 GEORGE III. Proceedbigi agabut Bamd liaac Eaian [lOSOT
defence; he should have the advantage of
the whole being taken together. So, on the
contrary, if the whole being taken together,
manifests the intention of a part, it is equally
proper, that as the evidence on one side may
oe in his favour, so on the other side it is
to be considered whether it is not against
him. '
Gentlemen, the paragraphs selected here,
and which are stated upon this indictment
by necessary innuendos, as they are called in
law, that is, when a part is said to be offen-
sive, it is necessary, m point of law, that
that very expression should be so pointed out,
and should be said to be so far criminal, as
that it means so and so ; whether the mean-
ing be fair or not, it is . your province to de-
termine. Now, gentlemen, in the present
instance, the paragraph which has been se-
lected is of this nature.
" You must know then that I used, toge-
ther with a variety of youthful attachments,
to be very fond of birds and poultry, and
among other things of this kind I had a very
fine majestic kind of animal, a game cock,''
— ** meaning thereby," as we have taken
upon us to state upon this record, to allude
to the person of his majesty. — Gentlemen,
this is the meaning which is ascribed to it,
whether it bears this meaning is your pro«-
vince, as I said before, to determine. Then,
gentlemen, you are to judg6of it in this way;
it makes its appearance in a pamphlet, price
two-pence, intituled,'' Politics for the People,"
•^Politics for the People. For whom is it
meant? Is it not meant to be circulated
among the people ? according to the common
acceptation of the term People. PoUtics—
circumstances of public agitation submitted
to the consideration of the lowest class of
society.
Then the first part of the title is,—'' Poli-
tics for the People/' it goes on, " or Hog's
Wash." I dare say, gentlemen, that many
of you can account for the adoption of that
term, Hog*8 Wash. I confess tnat it strikes
me, it has been taken up by the author of
this book, as a sort of comment upon a term
or terms which escaped in the heat of debate
in parliament from some member there. I
remember some expression being made use
of which has undergone a variety of com-
ments, where the Swinish Multitude had
been the term made use of. I confess I
would not have been the person to have made
use of such an expression ; but, however, it
does not seem to me to convey such an idea
as justifies the following it up with such com-
. ments, for it has been followed up with a
continuance of comment which has extended
the meaning, I am persuaded, infinitely be-
yond the intention or beyond the mind of
the gentleman who made use of it ; it misht
have been reprehensible, I do not say but
it was reprehensible, but the intention as-
cribed here is infinitely worse, usins the
words in tliis way is much more hkSy to
produce the very efiect which we aay
libel is calculated to produce.
Gentlemen, you see the title of this
pamphlet is, " Politics for the People; or,-
Hog's Wash ;" indeed it is intituled " Number -
£ignt," so as to manifest that there have
been many preceding this publication ; it is*
price two-pence. It begins indeed with poetey,
which you will have an opportunity of seeine
by-and-by if you please, but as I have much
to say to you upon the present prosecution, I
will not waste your time by adverting to those*
circumstances that are immatenal. The
poetiy, in the first part, I am contented yoti
shall read at your leisure ; if there is any '
thing that can render it pleasant to the ima*
gination, or improving to the mind, or in
any shape have a tendency to favour the'
defendant in the least degree, I beseech you
to read it and give him the advantage of it.
Gentlemen, then we come to Uie second
page, at the top of which there appears thisr
— '^ King Chaunteclere, or the Fate of Ty-
ranny ;** and it is supposed to be, " An anec-
dote related by citizen Thelwall at the Capel-
court society, during the discussion of a ques-
tion relative to the comparative influence of
the love of life and liberty, and of the fair
sex on the actions of mankind." I shall not
waste much of your time in commentiBg*
upon either the passage I have read, or what
follows, saving this, that Mr. Thelwall* iar
represented as discussing this Question, and
as discussing those matters which may be
supposed to relate to the love of life and
liberty. You will have, as I stated before,
the pamphlet in your hand ; look, I beseech
you, a httlc to the agitation of the question
of the love of life and the love of liberty,
and if you can put any other interpretation
upon it, than that which readilv starts into
my mind^ for God's sake do it; but see if it
be not this, if the very agitation of that ques*
tion is not to beget a sort of indifierence
about the shedding of human blood, drivings
as it were, the mind to a contempt of danger,
and setting up an ideal liberty, not a real one;
but making you suppose, or attempting to
make you suppose, that every other thing
but liberty, as they are pleased to call it, is
to be held in contempt, that every tlung
which stands in the way of it^ that anv thing
which may under any possibility be deemed
likely to beget tyranny, is to be got rid of^
inasmuch as it is in .the way of that lib«*ty,
and that kings are in the way of liberty^ and
are only to be got rid of by death, by cutting
off the bead.
Gentlemen, it would be impertinent in me
to suppose, that you are not as conversant as
myself with the evils that pervade a neigh-
bouring country. — ^It would be impertinent in
me to suppose you. are not equally apprised of
r - , , I I , III — ^
* With respect to this person, see the cases
of Hardy and Horns Tooke, a. n; 1794|
I08I]
'. for publishing a Seditious Libel.
A. D. 1794.
[1022
the faLt»\f and melancholy catastrophe attend-
ing the late king of France ; but before I
comment farther upon this passage, let me
call your attention to another little paragraph
appearing in this book, which I declare to
God, when I first read, I could not get over
without tears ; the circumstance is mention-
ed in such a flippant way, and so opposite to
the feelings of a man of common humanity,
that I think you will go with me in your feel-
ings as soon as ever I state this little para-
graph to you.
You have heard that there was a man on
the other side of the water, of the name of
M. Condorcet— this is a paragraph that the
author of this book has inserted under the
title of—'' Reflections of a true Briton ;'* but
before I read the paragraph, I will confess
that my mind is relieved a little in not being
obliged to look upon that man as the author,
I prosecute him only as the publisher ; if I
were to look upon him as the author, my eye
could hardly turn towards him without a flash
of indisnation, but I am relieved from tliat
by his being prosecuted as the publisher, and
not as the author. Now, gentlemen, ob-
serve the flippant, the unfeeling, the cruel
manner in wnich a transaction Tike that to
which I have alluded, is mentioned — ** M.
Condorcet, when he announced in his Gazette,
that our theatres had been shut up, on the
news of Louis Capet's death, pleasantly
observed, 'That it was not the common
* players who acted in the farce of that
€ day,'"
. Now what does this betoken? A mind
looking at a transaction of that sort, with a
degree of pleasure and unconcern; there is
a common idea, and I am sure it is impressed
upon eveiy man's mind, from the hignest to
the k^west in society, and which frequently
manifests itself in an expression of that sort :
** liad my doe met with such a fate, I should
have regretted him''— but heavenly God ! can
yre divest ourselves of those feelings that grow
vp with us in society, and under the indul-
gence of which we are indebted for every
possible human felicity ; for without feelinss
of tenderness and compassion, what would
the human being be ? — Gentlemen, we have
at this day, but too many opportunities of
seeing what a beast a human being is, when
he breaks loose from the bonds of society, and
betakes himself to those courses which follow
from anarchy and confusion.
This paragraph, therefore, is found in this
book, I say that is lamentable indeed, but it
is found in a chapter thus described— <' The
Keflections of a true Briton."— God forbid tliat
that cliaracter which stands almost above all
others in the world, a Briton, a manly, a true
Briton— God forbid that he should ever be
found to have a heart like that, a character-
istic which impeaches the humanity and feel-
ing of the being^tbat can never be the re-
flection of a true Briton; but the author,
whoever he be, that h^s assumed this cha-
racter, has traduced the name and character
of a true Briton, when be assumes himself to
be such, and follows a course like that which
I have represented to you.
Gentlemen> this chapter contains that
which is the subject of another count in this
indictment — " Kings are wolf shepherds."
Will vou permit me for a moment, to digress
a little into that which I hope will ever re-
main a subject unattacked— shall it be allow-
ed to a man to impose upon fair understand-
ings, having mischief in his mind, and having
no possible earthly good purpose ; shall it be
allowed to such a man to say. Here I am as a
friend of mankind agitating a fair question ?
God forbid that fair discussion should be ever
the subject of an attack, or should ever call
upon you for your deliberation; fairdiscu»-
sion upon points of government, is as open to
the subject, and as allowable as the agitation
of any other questions, and I will beoold to
say, that never vet was it supposed from the
beginning of civil society to tne present hour,
that the man who meant fairly, whose heart
moved honestly, who was a useful member of
socie^, who could be said to be a good father,
a good husband^ a kind neighbour, and who
was endowed with the common social feel-
ings, it never yet was said, that there ooukl
be a doubt, whether such a man meant fairly
when discussing topics of this description.
Many attempts have been made to pervert
the understancling of those who have the ul-
timate jurisdiction; for God knows, it has
happened but too frequently in our profes-
sion, that ingenuity has been carfied to the
utmost height, a thing allowable in the ad-
vocate, to give the most plausible interpreta-
tion, or the most favourable comment, where
there has.been any pretence for calling the
work under prosecution, fair discussion. But
I need not trouble you on this subject, inas-
much as this varies, as much from every
species of libel of that kind, as any thing the
most insignificant, can from the most im-
portant.
Gentlemen, now let me call your attention
a little, to that which is the specific subject of
the indictment, and see whether you can affix
any other, than that very meaning that is put
upon the whole of this sentence by the ih-
nuendos; — ^if you can, you will; but judge of
it fairly, and see if it does not import this^
for I. think it cannot import any thing else.—
** You must know Uien that I used, together
with a variety of youthful attachments, to be
very fond of birds and poultry, and among
other thines of this kind, I had a very fine
majestic loiid of animal, a game cock, a
haughty sanguinary tyrsmt, nursed in- blood
and slaughter from his infancy, fond of
foreign wars and domestic rebellions^ into
which he would sometimes drive his subjects
by his oppressive obstinacy, in hopes that he
n^ght increase his power and glory by their
suppression."
Gentlemen^ without going any farther, in
109S] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings agaimt Danid lumc Sahn [I0S4
stating that whicli is the particiilar. and spe-
cific ground of this indictment, can you have
a doubt upon this I Then so far I am sure
I may take the liberty of saying, that I have
not a doubt, but your minds will go with me
as to the meaning which is affixd to these
words.
Then come to that which is the nudo part
of the inquiry, and of every jury's inquiry
upon a subject of this sort ; the intention of
the man. If the author were standing before
you, it would be impossible in the nature of
things, for any ingenuity upon earth to say,
thai he had a fair, a kind, or a eood inten-
tion. What is it calculated— what is it in-
tended for ? To go among the people, to be
bought up by them at two-pence a piece : so
it is to be circulated, and whatever is to be
inferred ^on this story is to be impressed
upon their minds.
Gentlemen, I confess verv lately when I
was looking over a French publication, a pam-
phlet of M. Brissot, there was a passage in it
that struck me with astonishment, at the
neatness of the description and the justness of
the remark, as to the consequence which
must take place, wherever the circumstan-
ees exist which gave rise to the observa-
lioa ; it struck me, I say, with astonishment
^ is speaking of the terrible want of order in
tbatcountnr, of the manner in which discon-
tents are disseminated; and he carries his
attention down to the poor cottager, who, be-
ing poisoned himself, carries the contagion
not only to his own home, but spreads it
around his little hut. So it is with every
thing of this sort, so it is indeed, to make use
of a simile if a stone be thrown into the
water, at first we perceive a little circle upon
the surface, another still succeeds, and then
another, UU Ihe whole circumference, which
is immense, is described in that circle ; and,
gentlemen, when we look at the possibility of
disseminating discontents, we must always
see that the beginning must be of this nature.
What then is this calculated for ? Not to
meet the eye ; not to reach the ear ; not to
be an object of search of any man of literature,
of any gentlemen such as you; but it is cal-
culated to find its way among the lowest of
the people, to excite them to discontents and
commotioQS ; such and such only can be its
purpose ; Uie very nature of the publication,
' the price, the title of it, all manifest this. If
it were to come to the attention, if it were to
ML before the eye of any men better inform-
ed than the rude and vulgar, perhaps they
would have looked upon it as coq|eroptihIe ;
but although it is so contemptible, it does not
£>Uow thatit is not the less mischievous ; the
observation I make to you for your approba-
tioii isy that it is infinitely more mischievous,
the mote the thing is calculated to harass
and disturb tite lower order of the people.
Gentlemeny na man is hardy enough to
expose himself at once to the immediate fang
of the law ; bad minds have always their con-
trivances about them; but, God be praiswb
ibr the benefit of society those contrivances
seldom are capable of avail ; they freouent^
expose their authors to punishment, so it is
here ; not that this man, or the author, who*
ever he may have been, would dare openly to
have attacked the king of this conntry, or
would dare openW to say to any part of tho
multitude, ** do this or that ;" nor would be
do so in his writing ; but there is a contriT*
ance made use of; it is written in a species
of fable; aspeciesof simile or allegory, as it
is called, is used to convey those sentiments;
but whatever the contrivance may be, we aie
to resort to that which is capable of unnvel-
ling the mystery in both instances ; namely^
the fair and soher inquiry of a jury ; and
whatever the nature of the concealment
may be, if a man/ makes use of a similitude,
if ne is charged with meaning Uie lung
bjr the character of a cock, — it "is for you
fairly to say whether he had not this mean-
ing, and therefore it is, that there is no pos«
sible device or artifice of a man that shall
screen him from the investigation of a juiy,
and if a juiy conceive he- has so wrought up
this matter by patting upon it any sort of
flimsy conceaifnent, they will strip the veil
from it, they will look at it, and see what the
matter is that is so concealed. So in this
case the author has endeavoured, by tdlod-
ing to a game cock, to conceal his intention.
But, genUemen, I call your attention most
earnestly to that 'which citisen Thelwall, 4S
he is supposed to be, is discussing in tlii^
libel : you will see from the part which pre-
cedes, and the circumstances that follow,
there could have been no other object in the
mind of the author, than those objects to
which I have alluded.
Gentlemen, when- you travel a little fiirthef
on in this publication (the book is not large,
it would not take you up above ten minuted
to read it all through), I will not indeed ht*
suit you by supposing that any of you hav^
read it with any attention, though it may have
gpt by accident into you? hands very fairly,
and you may have loolced at it, and may have
laughed at part of it; but you will find ane<«
ther part which manifests what the intentkMi
of the man is — he fs, first of all, commenting
upon the nature of the right which every sub-:
ject has in this country, to insist upon a free
and open discussion. God forbid that free
and open discussion should ever be abridged ;
and how can it be abridged ? it can never be
but b^ those men who are the worst enemies
to society, abusing the liberty of discussion.
So it is with the freedom ot the press, the
most invaluable blessing, at the mention of
which every man is alive. There is no mao
can check another's publication of his thoughts
whatever his thoughts may be ; but if thoso
thoughts turn out to be mischievous to the
public, and instead of serving the purposes
of mankind, threaten their nun and destrac-
tion; G^ forWd thst those thoughts so pio«
1025]
Jbr puhtUhing a Sediiioug Ltbeh
A* D. 179*.
[I02ff
mulgated shotild not provoke an inquiry, for
then they become the fair objects of punish-
f inent.
The liberty of the press, that l>oast, and
• highest boast almost of an Englishman, how
is that to be endangered? It may be in
; dsinger, for an^ht I know^ in succeeding ge-
nerations; and I am sure, if et^er it is put in
. danger, it will be by the abuses of those who
are the greatest enemies to it, at the very
time they are putting on the, audacious ef-
frontery of pretending to be its friends; those
men who are the authors and publishers of
' thin^ like this, are at all times the men to
stand forward with the most unblushing ef-
frontery, and say, the liberty of the press is
violated in our persons; conscious as they
are that they are the men whose conduct,
originating in the worst motives, is calculated
to produce mischiefs innumerable to society ;
well knowing that they deserve no protection,
being in the very fibuse of that which ought
to be looked upon as the chiefest blessing of
the country. So it is with publications of
this sort; this' circumstance is assumed in
another part of the book. Mr. Thelwall, the
character supposed to be in being here, and
upon the scene, is represented as attacked
durin|[ the discussion of the question, and
there is a sentiment which he brings forward
in consequence of that attack, which is of an
e]^emely dangerous nature indeed. Ahtx
having mentioned what had passed in the
society, he says :
'' These circumstances are important to be
generally known ; since they prove, that not-
withstanding the false appearances whicli
have been artfully assumed by intriguing and
interested individuals, pretending to more au-
thority than they have, there is no power in
this country that can openly and legally in-
terfere to prevent the freedom of political dis-
cussion, itindividuals will have spirit enough
to assert it."
What is this but saying to any parcel of
people that may be collected together in any
place, <* gentlemen, if you have individually
spirit enough to assert, and insist upon any
sort of freedom that you think proper, have
but that spirit in the individual, the accumu-
lated spirit of those individuals must be capable
of carrying into effect whatever your intention
may be." Is it any thmg else, is it short of
that? Then you see that these few pages
contain nothing but political matters, and no-
thing on those subjects but such sort of ideas
as are calculated to disturb and harass the
I)ublic mind. What is this ? it is called " Po-
Itics for the People f to be ^scattered among
the people.
Oentlemen, I think I need n<|t farther ad-
vert either to the pamphlet, to the charge, or
to that which arises out of the pamphlet, or
out of the charge. I will make a few obser-
vations upon the nature of these prosecutions,
and upon the defences set up. These prose-
cutions, I say, must be instrtnied, because
VOL, 2uaii.
there is no other mode in this country, or
upon earth, by which publications of this sort
can be checked. If you think fit, or if you
think society would' be benefitted by these
things havino; their iie^ course uninterrupted^
your wishes, if they should incline that way,
may, for what I know, act upon your minds
so as to prevail upon you to believe, that there
can be no harm in this pamphlet ; but I am
persuaded that it is impossible in minds likv
yours.
It has been ssud, and truly, that whenever
a libel is prosecuted, it draws it into a second
course ot adtation, and that the very obser-
vations made upon the hbel in a court of jus-
tice, become, as it were, a promulgation or
the libel itself. That is extremely true, and
it has happened over and over again ; it has
happened within my own time, and happened,
I akn sure, in times before, that the very
matter being brought forth, and the observa-
tions nl^e upon it, which are indeed neces*
sary, and my learned friend, who is counsel
for the defendant to-day, I am sure will ex-'
ercise his ingenuity; and in doing so he will
do no more than nis duty to his client. Hi»
ingenuity is equal to much; I venture to
thmk his display of talents upon this occa-
sion will be such as to excite adrmration, and
the more admmition it is attended with, I
hope I know myself when I say the more
Eleasnre I shall feel. I shall be extremely
appy to find, that my friend, in the observa-
tions he can possibly ofier to you upon the
present occasion, shall deserve your approba-^
tion, and shall deserve your admiration.
Gentlemen, whatever the talents maybe
when they are exerted in a case, where exer-
tion can hardly produce any effect, and where
the influence of that exertion, however you-'
may admire the talents of the advocate, can-^
not possibly go the length of convincing your
judgments, or in any measure of altering the '
determination YOU are to make; wearhnire
the advocate wno is on the wrong side of the
question for the eloquence and learning which
he shows : but thank God, in this country,
there is a tribunal which is to decide^ after all
the exertions of the advocate. You will in-^ '
quire into the naked fact ; the present case is,
indeed, more complicated ; but in the exami-
nation you are to make, the question must
be stripped at last of all the observations that
I can make, feeble as thev are, and it will be
equally stripped of ail the observations my
learned friend will make, strong as they will
be ; puttm^ all those out of the case, at the
same time judging and 'determitiing whether
I have called upon you to exercise either your
feelings or your judgments, and understand-
ings, in any way but m a fair and impartial-'
manner, you will decide this case.
Gentlemen, I have not read the whole 6f
the passage to you that is selected from thiii
pamphlet, and put upon the record, because
It goes down at last to those allusions ' "^
are so palp^ble^ that it is impossible^
3 U
10271
Proeeedingt againU Dauid haac SaUm [tOSS*
nuture of things^ that they can be mistaken ;
the trappings of royalty are mentioned ; there
is every sort of similitude, and evenr sort of
allusion, from whence to infer, that tne trap-
pings are meant to apply to royalty, and
royalty as existing in this counti^ ; tnat the
kine himself is tliat species oi tyrant that
ougnt to be got rid of, and that is only to be
got rid of, by that instrument which is alluded
to in another part of the little book, which you,
I am sure, wul see when you come to look at
it, to be the unavoidable meaning to be affixed
to it.
Gentlemen, I would not wish to aggravate
any case to you;, but does not this appear to
be ferocious and savage? Supposing it to
have that allusion which I have attributed to
it^ and to be distributed among; the people,
what are the ends that the writer proposes
bv it ? The ends of it are to render the peo-
Sle ferocious, to render them bloody, to ren-
er them cruel, and to dispose them to carry
into effect such an act of cruelty as would
plungje this country into a state of wretched-
itess indeed. This I would say is the end
.proposed, the inevitable consequences that
must take place from the circulation of a
bdok of this sort among the people. I have
stated that it is most evidently calculated for
the lowest of the people, imu not to reach
any higher circles, and therefore, it is infi-
nitely more mischievous than any, except
one, libel that was ever prosecuted^ which
was calculated for another purpose, and that
wa» defended under an idea of the freedom
of discussion, though not justified. Justifica-
tion will hardly ever follow, and I am sure,
when minds like your's, view the subject
fairly, and see that when what b said, is not
to be palliated, is not to be excused, and can-
not be justified, something may be said upon
a question, however obvious it may be^ how-
ever plain a proposition may be to my mind,
something may be said upon it ; and I may
hesitate a little; but with a fair discusuon of
axommon understanding, looking at all points
which are the fair objects of human contem-
plation, the human mind will be at last capa-
ole of coming to a true conclusion.
Without reading any more of this bo<^ to
ou, which you will read af\er you have re-
erred to those parts to which I have more
immediately alluded, the conclusion seems to
present itself to the mind in only one shape,
and it is not in the power of quibble, of inge-
nuity, or wit, or any species of faculty that
belongs to the human mind, to put any other
interpretation upon it than that given by the
record.
Gentlemen, there will be one more subject
of your inquiry, and of your attention ; but
as I am perfectly assured that observations
nilative to that will come from ihe learned
judge who tries this indictment, with infinitely
more force than they can come from me, I
may spare you the time of attending to such
observations as these; that is upon Sie nature
I
in
and the character of the first magistrate
this country. It is highly indecorous^ that I
am sure you will go with me in sayine^ Ibr
any one in the least degree to speak msre-
spectfully of another against whom he can
have no cause of complaint ; but to spealc
disrespectfully of tlie first maigistrate of this
country, is deemed highly indecorous and in-
decent, and his character therefore is for the
wisest purposes particularly protected.
Then tracing this firom tne lowest degree
of misdemeanor that can be committed
against the king, tracing it from the lowest
state to the highest, passing over the inter*
mediate depees of offences, many of them,
that are trifling, and still stopping short of
that which comes within the verge of treason,,
can there be an ofience more aggravated in
its kind than this? It b not only treating
disrespectfully, but it is treating with a de-
gree of sarcasm in l^e first instance, which
manifests a strong malevolence to the charac-
ter ; and in the next place, it is ^ving to the
mind of every man, that can be impressed by
such a publication as this, not only an indif-
ference to the character of the king, but a
perfect detestation of such character, and
suggesting that the means of getting rid of
such a character must be by a stroke siniilar
to that which has taken place in a neigh-
bouring unhappy country.
Gentlemen, I shall therefore abstain from
all observations upon the royal character, as
to the manner in which it is protected here,
as to the utility of the office, and as to the
benefit and the advantage derived from it by
the inhabitants of this country, because, sure
I am, you are equally conversant with the
intercourses of commerce, and with the vast
and important objects that result from com-
mercial intercourse, under the blessings of a
free constitution like our's, where respect to
government insures that tranquillity under
which alone those commercial benefits can
arise, and happiness to man take place. I
say, therefore, with the effects of the consti-
tution, you are much better acquainted than
I am ; my walk is in a more confined way
than your*s ; I see not so much of the manu-
factures and merchandise of the country-, as
day af\er day are to be found in the city of
London, and which I will be bold to say, are
only to be found in this city; and I will be
bold again to say, that it is alone owing to
the form of eovernment that we live under;
and a^ain, that unless the royal person, the
sovereign of this country, were at the head
of that constitution, the efiects would not be
what they are.
/ Then, gentlemen, to what other circum-
stances need I advert? I am sure my friend^
who is advocate for the defendant, will never
suppose, that by calling your attention to
these words, he can fritter them away. I
think it may be suggested, because I have
heard it before suggested, that here, where
the cock is mentioned^ and we say in our in-
10»]
^or publishing a Seditious Libel.
A. D. 1794.
[103d
dktmtot that it means the king; good God !
the advocate may say (because an advocate
can always affect astonishment), wh^ should
you suppose the king is meant by this cock ?
' — ^I can only say I will leave it to the deter-
mination of twelve gentlemen, to say, whether
it be so or not, I am sure it cannot be other-
wise; and though he may please to say, by
your legal operation of an innuendo, you may
charge that the cock means the king, why
you are the hbeller yourself, by puttinjg it
upon the record;— I can onl^^ observe it is
extremely ingenious; but you, gentlemen,
will be to determine between us : therefore let
ingenuity be exercised, let it have its fair
course. I am sure my friend will be inge-
nious. I am sure in his address to you there
will be much to admire ; but it happens, in-
.deed, to be a subject where there cannot be
any great benefit resulting to his client from
it. When my friend has done his duty, I do
'confess, feeling this prosecution as a matter
of infinite importance, I shall look with ex-
treme earnestness for your verdict. — I pre-
sume I shall not have any occasion to trouble
ymi again, thercfi)re it is fit I should make
all the observations I have to offer now; it is
upon that account you will pardon me for the
length of time I have taken up.
I have already hinted to you, that we pro-
secute this man as the publisher. N^ow, gen-
tlemen, when the book is sold at his house,
if he be not there, he is as much guilty as if
he were. This is a matter very well known
.to be law from the earliest time ; it is one of
the cases in law, where a master may be cri-
minated by the act of his servant, even thoueh
he himself be not present. If his wife sells
the libel, he is criminal ; and unless it were
"60, the law would, you see, be frustrated in
thousands of instances : the law is, that the
owner of the shop, the man having the profit
of the business, shall be answerable; but
here the book appears to be printed for the
▼eiy man at the oar, and I dare say, he will
hardly deny it : from the manner in which
he bears himself I do not know, whether he
might not absolutely triumph in it. .But.
however, with respect to the criminality, ana |
the law attaching upon that criminality, there
can be no doubt.
The evidence I shall have to lay before you,
will be the most simple imaeioable, that is,
that the book was bought at nis shop. What
relates to the manner m which his business is
generally carried on, I forbear to state. You
perceive that with respect to these two
charees, I have not even stated them to you
at full length, because the book, if you please
to have it, may be delivered to you, and you
may there satisfy your own curiosity.
I have said before, I felt myself relieved
that I had not to prosecute that man as the
author ; he may not be the author, I hope in
God^ he is not; although he is criminal as the
publisher, andalthougn the j^ubliaher does
mfioitely more mischief^ sometimes, than the i
author, and often has it happened that the
Eublisher is a stimulator'tothe author ; yet I
ope he has not the heart to be the author of
some of these paragraphs.
Gentlemen, you have the case before yon,
I have done my duty, the attorney general
has done his, and those gentlemen who have
been engaged in order to bring the pro-
secution into a shape before you, discharge
their duty when they submit it to you, and
when they do that, 1 am sure it is in perfectly
safe hands, and it would be most impertinent
in me to suggest a possibility of your doing
otherwise than your duty.
THE EVIDEHCE POR THE PROSECUTIOV.
John BouU, sworn. — Examined by Mr,
Knowlys,
Be so good as to h)ok at that book, and
teU me whether you bought it, and where ? —
Yes, I bought it.
Where ? — ^At No. 8J, Bishopsgate-street.
At the time you bought it aid you make
any writine upoif it to enable you to know it
again ?— Yes, within half an hour afterwaxds.
Is that your writing ? — ^Yes.
Who kept that shop > — ^Daniel Isaac Eaton.
The defendant at the bar?— Yes.
When did you buy it ?— On the 18th of
November last — ^I boueht numbers 6, 7, and
8, for a gentleman, at the same time.
Of Politics for the People, or Hog's Wash!
—Yes.
Was this a separate number at the time
you bought it? — ^Yes.
And you bought other numbers of the
same sort at the same time ? — Yes, numbers
6, 7, and 8.
Mr. Recorder.'^'The pamphlet he is now
prosecuted for is No. 8.
Mr. Knowfys, — ^Itis.
Cross-examinatI<Hi by Mr. Woodhouse.
What are you?— A news-carrier.
You get your livelihood by that?— Yes*
What induced you to go for these books ?
—I went to buy them for a gentleman.
Who was that gentleman? — One. Mr.
Bevan,
Is he a news-carrier? — No.
Did you ever appear here before ? — ^No.
You get your hvelihood solely by selling
books ? — ^Yes.
That is your sole trade ?•— Yes.
You never got any thing by informing, I
suppose ? — ^No, never.
Mr. Knoalys, — The gentleman has asked
you, why you went to that shop ? Did not
you go to it because it was the shop where
those things were sold ? — Yes.
Mr. Gurney. — I desire that the whole of
the speech of Mr. Thelwall may be read^ a
part only of which is included in the indict-
ment.
Mr. Fielding. — ^You may read it as part of
your evidence^
Mr. Gurfiey.— I know I may; but I con-
909]
S4 GBORGB UL
Proctedingt t^pamt Jotejik GerrtM
HOW
incot of the coimtiyi exdtiiig tbini to tm
up, and oveiturD the gorerament bjr flupefkr
fi>rce?
Gentlemen, it is said* that the deicrip-
tioD of their meetings, callinjn themselves
citizensy dividing themselves into sections,
ipakinj; conventions of emei^ncj^ secret
gommittees and all the rest of it, are in>
^ocent things in themselves ; and I do not
think his miyestj's advocate has laid them as
a crime, unconnected with any other circum-
stance; but, gentlemen, the teit b always
best understood by the context; yon are not
tp take this paragraph in the inmctment by
ifself, but from Uie whole, as laid and as
proved, you are to jud^ of the meaning and
intention of the parties here. And when
you 6nd meetings established in this country,
^ under denominations never before knpwn, as
^r- committees of emergency, of organisatkm, of
finance, and all the rest of it ; when you see
that assumed at a period when we are in an
qpen declared war with France, when we ken
tJBaA it is borrowed from the convention of
France, and when you compare it with the
vhole of their conduct, particularly Uie reso-
lutions of that meeting and Vtm speeches. I
fii^, you will consider, whether, upon a Uir
qonstruction of the whole, thev were not imi-
tiiting France in the form ot their govem-
qient, and that the object of their meethig
w^ like France, to overturn tlw established
. constitution, and put everything upon the
same footing with France, where aristocracy
is reviled, the king reviled, and indeed where
there is no constitution at all. That, gentle-
ilien, is the great object of your inquiry ; and
If hen you attend to the whole of the resolu-
tions and motions, as they appear upon the
face of the minutes^ which were recovered
out of the hands of their own secretary, and
compare them with the papers found m the
possession of Margaret, Sinclair, and Oerrald,
and also, with the parole evidence that has
been given in this case, you will judge whe*
ther, upon the whole, itdues not appear to you,
that these people were imitating the French
convention, and that they meant to follow the
spirit of the French, in establishing their form
of government.
• Gentlemen, there is a number of seditious
resolutions and speeches in this indKtment,
and one of them a very capital one, which. I
tUnk borders as near upon high treason as
any thii^ I ever saw: ^ That this convention,
considering the calamitous consequences of
any act of the legislature which may tend to
deprive the whole, or any part of the people,
of their undoubted right to meet, eitner by
themselves, or by delegation, to discuss any
matter relative to their common interest,
whether of a public or a private nature, and
holding the same to be totally inconsistent
^th the first principles and safety of society,
and also subversive of our known and ac-
knowledeed constitutional liberties, do hereby
^«da»| hefojpa Cod and the world; that ve
ihill fnllnn thri whnlrinmn nTimpln of fumi
times, by paying bo remurd to any act iK
shall militate against me constilukioa «f
eountiy ; and sosll continue to assemble,
consider of the best means by which we
accomplish a real representotion of the peo]iiar
and annual electkm, until compelled to daaai
by superior force." The language of this s<e*
solution is too plain to need any iUurtntknu
It is absurd to suppose that tney meant to
cany any thing by strength of armsi te
what could such a small number do aganst
the military force of thb country N-^twamj*.
one is the number to precede the aoti«i|
but that is not the number of people-to be
engaged in this action, for they were onl^ IIm
de&gates of the people; and it appears tbit
these delegates, wnen they opened their as*
cret letters, were to convene theit oonstitue^ts
and repair to the place of meeting. I hope
there were not many of them ; but if they
had been allowed to «> on, I daie s^ they
would have been fouiM to he the* representn*
tives of a great many more than I could wiib
for.
Now, flentlemeii. when you conaider the
whole ofthis Ksouition, and the epeechen^
and the sealed letter to be ^ven to emdele'
ete, the contento of which ate uet to be
owu^ and when the very emergency has
happened upon which they were to meet (for
the landing of forogn troons is one of tMii)|
is it possible for you to Delieve that it waa
mere] V a reform in parliament that they in*
tended? if itwas, thme was bo oocasien for
an;^ secrecy at aU ; but on the other hand, if
a rising of the people was intended, then I
conceive that a committee of secreqf, and a
convention of emergency, are necessaiy and
prudent, and the idea of a reform in peiii»-
ment is all nonsense ; for if that was their in*
tention, thev would have made their appli-*
cation openly to parliament, and pariiament
woukl have granted or withheld their petitioD.
. Gentlemen, it is very observable that theie
is a blank in the minntes : now, in order to
supply that^ there is a paper recovered fh>tt
the possession of Charles Sinclair, ^ That in
case the minister, or any other member of
either House of Parliament, bring forward tf
aM>tion for leave to bring in a convention' bill,
such as has passed Ib Ireland, to prevent the
people from meeting according to their just
rights by the revmutaon, the same motioB
shall be notice to the delesates to meetia
convention to assert their rights."
Gentlemen, it is said that this paper is not
authenticated : and to be sure, if you think it
is not, you will lay it out of your consideration i
but in the first puce, it was found in Mr. Sin*
clair's chamber, tied up in a handkerchief
and brouffbt in a chaise along with Mr. Geiu
raU and Mr. Matgarot to the sheriff derk**
ofiice. Mr. Mack generally had the kecphlff
of the papers there ; says he, I do not tfaiw
I was thm when the papers weie brought in,
but I came ia very iooB after j sbe-eewaiM^'
1001]
fw SetSHon.
a;d. lYS*.
[1008
ikkDB were goiAff on, and it was put into my
hand; the nanokerchief was laid upon tlie
ibenff dock's table^ the sheriff was siu
ling then, «id ihe clerks, the procnrator-
Ascal, and so on. Is it possible to suppose
that th^se persons — all men of character —
would do that, in order to convict an innocent
nntn, for which they ought to be han^d, by
extsacliDg evidence and putting false evidence
in its place ? Mack says, that he locked it up,
and it was under his lock and key till il was
ried and inventoried in presence of Sin-
bimscilf, and other persons. This paper
is marked at the back by Aitcheson; and Ait*
dieson told you, ttaX he acted as assistant-
secretary; so that this paper is endorsed by
Aitcheson in character of secretary to the
convention, and afterwards found in Sinclair's
possession, aS he was the mover I think of
the amendments upon Callender's motion.
' But; gentlemen, that is not all, for here are
two or three witnesses tell you precisely that
it was debated in the convention, and resolved
on, that in certain cases this convention of
emergency was to meet; and one of those
eases is, if an^ bill should be brought into
aailiament similar to that which passed in
the paihament of Ireland, and this is con-
firmed by the evidence of more than one or
two witnesses. Why, gentlemen, this paf»er,
so well authenticated, found in the jpossesnon
of Charles Sindair, brought to the sheriff'
clock's office, committed to the care of the
gentleman who is the usual keeper of papers
m that office, and kept under his lock and key
till they were opened oefere Mr. Sioelair him-
self I submit to you whether that is not very
good evidence, that this paper (which is of
the highest importance, aiid which borders
upon nigh treason) is suffldently authenti-
cated to your satisfaction. And indeed, een-
tlemen, there is a great deal more than Uiat,
because there is even Mr. Oemld^s first
speecln which is at such great length in the
indictment, of which Cockbiim swears that
he recollects that a number of paragraphs in
it were delivered in the meeting, and he does
not pretend to say that there is any thing
maleriall^ different in the paper firom what
he heard in the meeting; thou^th he will not
identify the whole of it, he did not see any
thine remarkably erroneous in it; that is, he
eoola not say it was verbatim the same, but
in point of substance be could not discover
any di0erence. Then, gentlemen, there is
William Ross, a member of the convention,
who writes the short-hand, he swears be took
this speech down in short^hand, and from
that fMiblished it in the Oasetteer, and the
public prosecutor copied it from the Gasetteer ;
tUs is pretty eood evidence to show that that
speech was ddivered in that meetine. This
h the speech, « I rise to congratulate the
convention,'' &c. [reads it fk>m the indict^
ment}.
Now, gentlemen, m the first place, this is
published in the GazeHecT; and taken by the
public prosecutor verbatim fiom the Gasetteen
and it is confirmed by the parole ei^dence, as
adso by the minutes of the coinvention, vrftiere
you Will find the substance of it; and I sub-
mit to you whether there is not sufficient
matter to establish this meeting to be a sedi-
tious meeting ; and if you are satisfied that it
is a seditious meeting, the ne](t question is,
wheUier \bis panel is guilty actor, or art and
part in the proceedings of such meeting.
Gentlemen, the concluding of the Imel is.
that if he is found guilty, actor, or art and
part of the crimes charged, that is sufficient to
infer the pains of law i (ind the law is that if
any unlawfiil act is committed where a number
are concerned, one person may be more active
in the commission of the fiu;t than others, but
in the eye of the law they are all considered
as euilty, art and part in the crimes charged,
ana all liabb to suffer the pains of law.
Gentlemen, I have antidpated a good deal
of the evidence upon this head already.
When yon see Mr. Gerrald taking a very ao>-
tive part, and making speeches stich as yOu
have heard to day, I look upon him as a veiy
dangerous member of society ; fiir I dare say
he nas doquence enough to persuade the
people to rise in arms.
Mi. Gerrald. — Oh my lord ! my lord ! this
is a very improper way of addhesdng a jury *
it is descending to personal abuse. — God
forbid that my doquence shoidd ever be made
use of for such a purpose !
Lord Judice CUrt, — Mr. Gerrald, I do not
say tiaat you did so, but that you had abilities
todoit
Gentlemen, he has no relation, nor the
least property in the country, but he comes
heie to disturb the peace of the country, as a
delegfate from a society in Bnsland to raise
sedition in this country : I say he appears to
me to be much more criminal than Muir or
Palmer or Skirving, because tfaoy were all na^
tives c$' this oountty.
' Gentlemen, if you are satisfied that this
meeting is a seditious meeling^ I do not w^
how it IB possible to avoid the consequence of
finding this panel gulHy art and part of the
crime charged : but, gentlemen, it is hot my
verdict that is to be returned^ you will return
such a verdict as yonr own consciences, will
direct.
Friday^ March 14, 1794. — Ekven o'clock.
The Court having met pursuant to adjourn-
ment, and the names of tlie jury havii^ been
called over, they brought in the following
VEBDICT.
Edinburgh^ March 14, 17P4.
The above assize having been enclosed,
made choice of the said sir WilKam Forbes to
be their chancellor, and the said I^ter Rill to
bo their clerk, and having ocmsidered the cri-
Mirial libel, raised and pursued at tixe iiistance
of his majesty's advocate for his m^sty's in-
terest, agftkiM Joseph Gerrald, panel, the in-
terlocutor of relevancy pronounced thereupon
10S61 34 GEORGE III. Prooeeiingi agaitut Danid Isaac Satan 1 1035
Inauendos have in former times gone such
lengths as to draw down some degree of ridi-
cule upon them, but never before, I believe,
have they gone the length of the inniiendos in
this indictment The sole purpose of an in-
nuendo is, to fix the true meaning. An in-
nuendo is not to be an arbitrary thing at the
pleasure of the drawer of an indictment;
•It must be warranted by the context; ft
must be conformable to the sense of the
paper : the sense of the paper must not be
TOTced or strained ; it must be the natural, the
-plain, the obvious, the necessary sense.
This art of drawing indictments, and con •
triving innuendos, ana so manufacturing libels.
is indeed a curious art. I do not know, and
J reallv am at a loss to conjecture, who could
have been the drawer of thb indictment.
From its internal evidence, I am led to sup-
pose, it must have been the author of the
Arabian Nights Entertainments, or some per-
aon equally 'Oonversant in the wild and extra-
vagant fictions of the East. He must have
have given unbridled and unbounded licence
to iui imagination the most wanton and the
most heated, before he could have sat down
to ascribe meanings to this pimer, so foreign
and indeed so ridioilous. All orthe innubndos,
in my opinion, are far from innocent, but
one of them contains the most seditious as-
certion I have ever seen.
The drawer of this indictment might just as
well have employed himself, like Dean
^Swift's projector, m attempting tb extract
sun- beams from cucumbers, as in attempting
to extract sedition from this story of the game
cock.
This story of the game cock appears to
have been related at a debating society, in
answer to a story that had been told of a ne-
fro slave enduring the tortures of afiying-pan.
he story was apUy introduced to answer the
purpose of the moment, in reply to a prece-
ding speaker. But as the story of the negro
islave Old natural! v introduce the story of Sie
^me cock, the allusion to it is not included
m this inaictment, because it was the busi-
ness of this indictment to conceal from you
the real intention with which the story was
introduced, in order to impose upon you a
belief, that it was then told, and afterwards
published with the criminal intentions im-
puted. With this view the story of the ^me
cock is not only introduced into the indict-
ment abniptly, but it closes abruptly too ;
for it stops short of that part which applies it
to the preceding stoi^ of the slave. These
observations wiU be impressed more forcibly
upon your minds, if when you retire to de-
liberate on your verdict, you take with vou
the pamphlet itself, and compare it with a
copy of the indictment.
skit, gentlemen, I do not mean to con-
tend that the author of this story intended
merely to allude to the immediate subject be-
fiNne him, the tyranny exercised on a negro
slave. No— the defence of my client c^s
not on me to attempt to circumscribe, far h
to explain away zny meaning which these
words, taken in their* utmost latitude, -can
implv. I will concede that the mind of tbe
speaker, in adverting to one species of ty*
ranny, was naturally, and I maintain lauda-
bly led to contemplate tyranny in general, and
that this story which he relates was cadcuiated
to expose the evil consequences of tyranny, and
to pomt out the iust punishment of tyrants.
And- surely Englishmen must have undergone
a strange transformation, if they can endure
to hear the right of doing this csuled in ques*
tion. Why do we look back to our ancestors
with such enthusiasm and veneration.^ but
because in opposing tyranny and tyrants they
fought, they Died, they conquered. It was
their ardent love of libertjr, it was their un-
daunted courage, it was their unshaken forti-
tude, it was their profound wisdom, thatcom->
bined to rear that grand political fiibric, the
constitution of our country, which we have
been accustomed to view with equal reverence
and delight, upon the possession of which we
have pnded ourselves, but which I am sure
we shall not transmit to our posteritv, if we
suffer the liberty of the press, which is its
comer-stone, to be rudely torn away; and
torn away it will be, if such prosecutions as
these can succeed. What language do our an-
cestors hold out to us by Magna Charta, l^
the Habeas Corpus act, by the Bill of Rights,
and above all by the Revolution, but this.
" We have found monarchy, unlimited ana
unfettered, incompatible with rational free-
dom and social oraer; we have therefore pre-
scribed limits to it, that you and posterity
may be free and happy.''
ft is not necessary ror me to go so &r back
as the Revolfition for this language ? it has
been held in k feebler tone perhaps^ cer-
tainly with less effect, >eithin the memory of
most of us. In the year 1783, the House of
Commons voted " that the influence of the
Crown had increased, was increasing, and
ought to be diminished.'' Whether they foU
lowed up that vote with such restrictions as
were requisite to curtail and check that in»
creasing influence, is not now a subject of ixt-
quiry. But it affords all I want for my ar-
gument, that every complaint of unlimited
power, or of limited power transgressing the
limits assigned to it, evenf detection of the
fact, and every exposure of*^ the consequence,
is consistent with the spirit of the constitu-
tion, is warranted by precedents the most ap-
proved, and. is dlowed by law. It is not
merely allowed, it is commanded by a law
that is paramount to all human lawy»the law
written by thefinger of Godon the heart of man.
But why is it to be supposed that this game
cock, who is described as an haughty and
sanguinarv tvrant, nursed from his infimcy in
bloMi ana slaughter, must necessarily mean
the present mild and merciful king of Great
Britain? If we survey the immense conti«
nentof Asia, nay, if we confine our view to
1037]
^r puUUhing a SecUiioui LUhd.
A. D- 1704.,
L1088
the continent of Europe, shall we find no ty-
rants whom this game cock m^y be intended
to denote ? — ^None '* fond of foreign wars/' if
not of ** domestic rebellions V None who
devour ** the greater part of the grain scatter*
ed'^ by Providence *' for the morning and
evening repast*' of their fellow-creatures^
None who are '' always picking and cuffing"
at those about them, who have not strengu
to defend themselves? Shall we find none
who have sported with obligations the most
solemn, who have trampled on rishts the most
sacred, who in the (>ursuit of their fell and
foul conspiracies against the peace and hap-
piness ofihe human race, hav6 disregarded
every principle of justice, have outraged every
feeling of humanity, have defied every man-
date of their God ?
But this speaker says, he thinks the best
thing one could do for men and women, is to
rid the world of tyrants. Is that so criminal ?
Then I am criminal; for I think so too. Ty-
rants, in any form, I believe, are much too
bad to be mended, and I think the best way
of disposing of them, is to send them out of a
world to wnich they are a curse, and which
they can henefit only by leaving it. If this
lesson were learned and were practised by
everv people groaning under tyranny, soon
would freedom, which is now confined to a
narrow spot, difiiise her blessings through the
world.
The first politicial truth that is enpraven on
the soul of man is, that all power nows from
the people, and is a trust for their benefit,
and that wnen that trust is abused, resistance
is not only a right, but a duty. The revolu-
tion in 1688, was a practical essay upon that
principle. Then was that right exercised,
then was that duty fulfilled. The trust re-
posed in a king was abused, the king became
a tyrant, the people expelled him : and if he
had ever dared to return, he would have ex-
piated, and justly expiated, his crimes upon
the scaffold.
But whv^ J ask again, is it to be supposed
that the King of Great Britain, is meant by
. this tyrant of the farm-yard ? Is there any
thing in the animal selected for this story,
being a cock ? That will not serve the pur-
pose of the prosecution. For never was the
king of Great Britain represented by the em-
blem of a cock. The kingof Great Britain has
always been denoted by a lion, and the king of
France by a cock: the reason of which, I
suppose, waS| that gallus, as you well know,
is latin for a cock. None of us, I am sure,
can have forgot that which we were taught in
our youth, tiuit the crowing of the gallic cock,
should be silenced by the tremendous roaring
of the britishlion.
Gentlemen, we are justpast the anniversary
of an event to which my learned friend haa
adverted, I mean the execution of the last
monarch of France. The apphcation of this
story to that tragical event, cannot fail to
Strike evei^ mind that pauses a moment for
reflection; and if the author had a view to-
any person in particular, unquestionably it
must have been to him ; and whatever yoii
or I may think of that monarch or his &te,
we cannot deny to any man the right of
thinking or speaking of nim, and of his fate,
as he pleases.
But if when any man pubhshes a paper on .
tyranny in general, or Louis the sixteenth in
particular, he is to be charged by an innuendo
of this sort with meaning king George tho
third, what will become of the security and
feaceful exercise of the freedom of the press? *
f when any man becomes obnoxious to the
ministry, every thing he says or publishes
is to be thus strained and perverted for the
purpose of ministerial vengeance, who can
De safe? It is not bookselkrs only who are
liable to prosecution for publishing, any of
you who may happen to give a book to one •
of your children may be prosecuted, and -
your children may be draggjed into this court
to lay you in gaol by their evidence; and
this, perhaps, for giving them a book which -
no disinterested, no impartial man would
conjecture to have any tendency to sedition,
or even any relation to politics.
Upon the principle of this prosecution, if
it has any principle, a book which, JT dare •
say, once aJOforded us much pleasure and
instruction, I mean .£sop'8 Fables, is the .
most seditious book that ever was published.
Wo to Mr. Eaton, if he has ever sold that
book ; wo to any man 'that has sold it, if he
has g^en offence to the ministers, or to any >
of tlwse spies and informers who now infest
this country, as locusts, or the plague do some
others. There b scarcely a table that will
not furnish an indictment. One of them
occurs to me at this moment ; it is the fiib]%
of the Ape, who was made king. To punish
him for nis presumption in aspiring to that
character, the fox led him into a trap; and •
when reproached by the ape for disloyidty^
he went off with a sneer, saying, ''You a
king, and not understand trapP'^Put this
fable into sn indictment, and call it a '' scan-
dalous, malicious, inflammatoiy, and seditious .
libel, of and concerning our sovereign lord -
the king ;" state in the innuendos that Uie
ape is intended to denote our said lord, the
king ; and that not understanding trap, means
ignorance of the regal functions; and garnish .•
^1 this with '* against the peace of our said
lord the king, his crown and dignity ;" and
then you have patched up a most notable
libel. With this receipt for drawing indict-
ments, I could go through the book^ and draw
five hundred.
Gentlemen, in this way a man may be pro*
secuted for publishing the sacred scriptures .-
themselves. For wherever mention b madp
of a wicked king, and mention is made of -
many wicked kings, an indictment may be
drawn, charging it to be a libel upon the king
of Great Bntam^ and by innuendos applying
the expressions to him. But I ask again
1039] 84 GEORGE III. Pn
what man can be safe, if meanings like these
are to be affixed to every thing ne pabtishes,
or every thing he says ?
Let us looK at thtj lan^ge of the story,
and see the meanings which aft affixed by
the indictment.-^*' You must knowthen, that
I used, together with a variety of youthful
attachments, to b^ very fond of birds and
pouhry : and among other thinss of this kind,
I had a very fine majestic kind of animal, a
ganie cock (meaning thereby,' says the indict^
ment, * to denote and represent our said lord
' ' the king') a haughtv, sanguinary, tyrant,
nursed in blood and slaughter from his in-
fancy, fond of foreign wars and domestic re-
bellions, into-which he would sometimes drive
his subjects by his opfiressive obstinacy, in
hopes that he might increase his power and
glory by their suppression. Now this haughty
old tyrant — (siffain/ says the indictment,
* meaning our said lord the kin^)." Never,
I believe, since prosecutions for libels had
existence, has sucn an imlictment, containing
such innuendos as these, made its appearance
in an English court of justice.
The only ground on which these innuendos
can be attempted to be supported, is a ground
which the prosecutors will not venture to state,
a jjTound which they cannot state; namely,
that there is so nupable a resemblance of
chanu:tcr and conauct in this game cock to our
sovereign lord the king, that that man must
be blind who does not see the real object, and
the true application. If the innuendos had
stopped here^ I should have thought this in-
dictment by no means an innocent prodnc-
tioQ. But what must I think, what must you
thinky when you find an innuendo in terms
the most unequivocal, charging the king with
being a tyrant ? *^ Yet I had even at that
time some lurking principles of aversion to
barefiused despotism, struggling at my heart,
wbich' would sometimes whis]per to me that
the l>est thing one could do either for cocks
asd hens,' or men and women was, to rid the .
world of tyrants-*- ' meaning' the indictment
says, ' our said lord the kine among others.' **
— *Which is the libel now? Not that paper
published bv Mr. Eaton : for if all that is
charged could be substantiated, its guilt would
sink into nothing in comparison with the
eoilt of this indictment, which contains a
libel upon record, in a court of justice, that
will be handed down to the latest posterity.
Gentlemen, I now come to the close oflhis-
indicimenL and it is a close worthy of it. A
little detached sentence of three lines is lugged
into bolster up this miserable prosecution.
** Kings are wolf shepherds. Homer styles
them devourers of the people, and they do
not appear to have lost tneir original taste."
To the four first words of this, " kings are
wolf sfaepherd8r,"the indictment has applkd an
iifbuetido, * meaning, among others, our sove-
reign lord the kmg/' Never was a proposi-
tion stated more evidently false than that a
^^enend remark^ must have an universalsppli*
again^ Daniel Isaac Eaton [1040
cation. If I sn^ak of kmgs in general, am t ta
be understooa to speak of all km^s? Certainly
net. My omittin^to sav all ibi»^s,demonstrates
that I mean to exclude some ; if to exclude
any, clearly to exclude those to whom the re-
mark is no longer appHcable.
The empress of Russia is the shepherdess of
a vast fiock; but as it was not sufficiently
numerous for the exercise of her boundless
philanthropy, she has lately, by a little gen*
tie compulsion, augmented it by a considerable
number of the Polish breed. She and our
worthy ally the king of Prussia have gone
hand in hand in this blessed work of increas-
ing their flocks. Possibly neither you nor I
shoitld choose to call these two momarchs,
'^ wolf shepherds;" but I fancy we should none
of us be disposed to punish very severely the
man who did.
All mankind have found, by fatal expe-
rience, that kings are wolf shepherds, if they
are suffered to possess Unlimited power; and
therefore our ancestors employed themselves
very wisely in fastening limitations on dieir
power. But it is of kings whose power is not
limited that this sentence spep.ks. For it is
illustrated by an expression of Homer's, ** de-
vourers of the people,'' which applies to Idngs
whose powers are not limited as the powers
of the kms of Great Britain are. The king
of Great Britain sustains a character totally
different from that of any other king, and
therefore general observations upon kings
never have been, and never can be understood
to apply to him. On the contrarv, they ne-
cessarily exclude him. It is not long since
such an application would ,have been consi-
dered as lioetlous, and I rely with confidence
on the spirit and loyalty of Britons for lepel-
line an application so unfounded, and a com-
panson so degrading — degrading not only to
the king, but to the people, ^r if it were
admitt^ that our king resembled kings, in
ceneral, it would be admitted that he was a
despot, from which it would follow, as a ne-
cessary consequence, that the people were
8laves«
I have bestowed some pains in searching
for an indictment like the present, and I can
find none even in that sink of iniquity, the
coileetion of indictments in the reign of
Charles Snd. I believe neither the records
of the star chambe)', nor the annals of Jeffe-
ries will furnish an indictment in which a
general reflection upon the nature and ten-
encv of tvranny, or the desert of tyrants,
has been deemed a libel upon the king of
Great Britain.
Gentlemen of the jury; — In every case
where a' charge is made, that an act has been
done which tne law forbids, after it has been
ascertained that the act has been done, and
done by the party abcused, the next question
is, with what intention be did the act It^ is
the intention which clothes the act with in-
nocence or guilt If you try a man fof mur-
der, you do not content yourscltes with as--
IMt]
JbrpMiMngaSedkimiiLiieL
A. Th 1794.
[lOlS
ctfrtMoh^ llie fnt of dur decontd kanring
kcm IdlM; and killed b^ the prisoner joa
U9 tfying ^ but you esaunne into thedicum^
jt^neea of the case, to know the intentioii
whfa which he killed him. If you find his
inlention was vmlicioiia, you pronounce him
guilty of morder ; if he was provoked by a
certam degree of irritatioD, you ponounce
kim gmhy of man^ug^tcr; but it you find
he M it accidentally, or in self-defence, you
pponouBce him not-^tlty.-^If this be so in a
inatlerofsuriidiaep importance to the public
as the loss of a citizen, and where prima facie
so black a erime as murder has been perpe-
tnledy how much more in the case of a mis-
Anneanor, a misbehaTionr, which is an of-
fmce of the most trivial nature that the law
ttdces cognizance of? If this be so in a mat-
ter wbere at first view liie motives are the
most diabolical that can predominate in the
human breast, how much more in a case where
the intentwn is on the first blush indifferent.
and where it is always with hesitation ana
doubt that a jury will pronounce it to be cri*
minid? — in a case wnere though one roar
consider it to be criminad, another will think
it innocent, and a third will believe it to be
meiitoiious, according to the difierent pd»>
tieal principles they kave embraced, according
to the extent and range which in their respec-
tiire opinions ought to be allowed to political
diicuasion?
Genttemen, when you are tmvelling in
thia dark and intricate road, you will proceed
vHtfa the utmost posuble circumspection, lest
von flfaottkl be entangled in an inextricable la-
oyrinth. When you are called upon to peno*
trate into the inmost recesses of a man^s soul,
and deoide on what passes there, with what
awe will you ad<h«s8 yourselves to the task f
Recollect what is required of you by the
prosecutors. You are reouired to determine
upon the inspection of tnis paper^ that the
Mtndant ^ maliciously and seditiously con-
triving, devising, and intending to scandalise,
truluce and vihfV our lord the king, and the
regal power and office established by ^arw
within this realm, and to represent our said
Imd the kine as sangiuirary, tyraimical, op^
pressive, cruel, and despotic ; and therei^ to
stir up and excite discontents and seditions
am<mgM the subjects of our said lord the king,
and to alienate and withdraw the fidelity, a£ke^
tfon, and allegiance cd his iaid ma^ty's sub-
jects fi-om hi^ said majesty's person and govern*
vent, unlawfully, maliciously, and seditiously^
did publish this pamphlet. Can you, as ho*
Best and conscientious men, ran you, as men
who have duties to fulfil, as men who bive
Qf^tsto guard, bring your minds to propo-
ntions so monstrous and so extravagant?
But if this construction were not so eviikntly
tidkulous and absurd, if it were only doubtfiil,
and doubtftil in the mind of any one of vou^
then you are bound to acquit the defiendaaC;
By that admirable institunon^ trial byjuiy,
OP man can be fbnod guiHy, but Inr tixe un»*
VOX. XXIIL
ninduB, the decided; tfnd undoubting opinion
of twelve cf hiseqinds. Where* there ensta
a partble of doubt, it is your doty, as you
ha^e been frequently told from the bench, to
lean to the side of mercy.
Gentlemen, some cases have lately oc-
curred which make it incumbent on me to
sky a word or two respecting the vc^cts of
juries in cases of libel.
Whenover the exercise of a right has suB-
ieredintarfuptionv its revival is attended with
some inconveniences and some errors. That
has been tiie case with respect to the functions
of juries in cases of libel. The ancient law of
Hbel did not difier from other criminal law,
bat when the invention of printing had'intro-
dnced political discussion, and when seditioua
publications (that is to say, publications ex-
posing the corruptions and abuses of govern-
ment and the profligacy of ministers) made
their appeamnce, the control of the press was
placed m admirable hands, a licenser, the
Jdne*s attorney- genera], and a court of in-
quisition, called the Star Chamber. The li*
censer was to stifle m its birth every thing
obnoxious to the ministers. But if any thing
happened to escape his hands, tlien the a^>
torney- general, by his information es MciOy
carried the unfortunate author or publisher
befsre the boaid of inquisitors, who never
failed to administer a sentence, adapted by itft
seterity to deter others firom similar enorts
to enlighten the people.
It was in that infernal inquisition, that the
purity of the law of libel was debauched. It
was there that that monstrous maxim was
first broached, that truth couM be a fals«,
scandalous, malicious, and seditious HbeU
Thank God, iniquity always defeats itiwif.
The intolerable oppression of this inquisition
brousht on its violent, I cannot say un-
timely, death. But unfortunately some of its
practices survived it. The attorney-genend
was allowed still to canv his informations
est officio into the Coon oi Krng's-bench, and
the doctrines of the star-chamber were, afW
a v«ry long interval, revived, and continued in
existencs till wittiin these two years, when
they were, I trust; completely destroyed by
that act of parlianeni, ror whicli we are in*
debted to the bright ornament of the English
bar, and the great model of its eloouence-^
an act which has assured and connrmed to
every Englishman the right of being tried by
•jury ofiiis equals, when accused of having
written or pubhshed a libeL
Gentlemen, that act of paHiament enacts,
that a jury may give a verdict ** upon the
whole' matter put in issue by the indictment**
Of what does that ^ whole matter^ consist?
It proposes four questions to the consider*
ation ofthejury.
The first question you are asked is, did the
defendant publish the pamphlet that has been
produced in evidence? if he did not, you must
acmiithim.
secandlyy is the sense ascribed to- the pas^
S X
10iS\ 34 GEORGE IIL Proceedmgs againit
lioqc ISgion [1044
sage, inserted in the indictment^ by' the innu:-
«ndos, the true, the genuine, the necessary
sense? if it is not, you must acquit him.
V Thirdly, is the pamphlet, even if that
sense be the proper one, a ** scandalous, ma-
licious, inflammatory, and seditious" libel?
if it is not, you must acquit him.
. Fourthly and lastly, did the defendant pub-
lish the pamphlet with the criminal motives
•and intentions imputed by this indictment?
if he did not, even then you must acquit
.him.
Gentlemen, in sayins this, I am sure I
shidl not be contradicted by the Bench, that a
verdict of guilty must be compounded of an
answer to each of those four questions in the
.affirmative, and that if ^ou disbelieve any one
of the imputations, nay if you doubt any one,
you are bound to sicquit the defendant.
It is the practice tnat had obtained before
the passing of the libel bill, that has intro-
duced any confusion into this plain and sim-
ple matter. - Juries were directed b;^ the
judges to find the defendant guilty, if the
•fact of publication was proved, and they be-
lieved the meanin sassigned by the innuendos
. was correct, and thence juries have errone-
.ously thoueht, that if the &ct of publication
was proved, they were bound to nnd thcrde-
•fendant guilty of publishing. Gentlemen,
.there is no guilt in publishing. Merely pub-
iishing a paper is in itself innocent, it is
onlv the baa quality of the paper published^
'and the evil intention with which it is pub-
lished, that can make a publication crimmal.
Therefore it is the duty of a jury, unless they
we clearly convinced, not only of the foct of
.publication, but of the truth of the innuendos^
and of the paper being a libel, and of the in-
.tention of the defen<£tnt being criminal, to
pronounce him not guilty.
Gentlemen, these prosecutions are totally
unlike all other prosecutions that come be-
fore you. All tnose indictments that you
hAve hitherto tried, were preferred for pur-
poses of public justice, to vindicate offended
law, and punish the violation of public order
and private property. Those prosecutions are
always brought forward to answer the inte-
rest«l and temporaiy purpose of the party in
Mftsession of power; and if it should so
iiappen that that party, before it had attuned
its power, had avowed principles to which
thdr present practices are hostile, the publi-
cation of those principles b then deemed se-
ditious, and the publishers arc prosecuted.
The prosecutions of the present ^, are
indeed part of' the ways and means ofcarry-
ing on tills disastrous war. They were not
opened by the minister with his budget, be-
pause they are means which he has not yet
the courage to avow.
« I understand that the reason why Mr.
Eaton is singled out and prosecuted with such
unezamplea severity is, that he has com-
mitted that sin which is not to be foigiven.
.Convinced by Mr, Pitt's speeches, and the
duke of Riefamond's letters, thkt the floUti*
cat salvation of this country depends, on aa
parliamenOuy reform, he has frankly de«
dared that conviction. That has been caug^
up by one of Uiese sedition hunters, who are
hircd^ prowl about the streets, whodropped
the information into the Kon's mouth at the
Crown and Anchor.
Gentlemen, we look back to the prosecu*
tions for sedition in the reigns of the Stuarts
with detestation and horror. Are we abso-
lutely certain that our posterity will look back
upon the prosecutions of the present day with
very favourable sentiments ? There was tbeoi
the same cry of sedition, there was then the'
same pretence of conspiraciesand plots, wbea
all the time the sediuon was the sedition of
the ministers against the people, and the
conspiracies and plots were tneir's, to subvert
the constitutional liberty of the countiy. Has
this prodigious dread of sedition slept from
the time of Charies the «d, until now, and
is it to awake precisely at the present liMK
ment? Were libels so abundant then? Have
they been so scarce from that time to this?
and do they now suddenly abound again ? Na
such thing. Publications reprobating ^fra&ny
and tyrants, and amizninff the conduct of
ministers, have never &iea to issue from the
press. But it is not all ministers who have
been troubled with the same irritability of
temper, or been haunted with -the same
dreaid of a iree discussion of their merits and
demerits. It is a bad omen when ministers
wish to stop the current of free inquinr. It i»
a sure sign that their conduct is such as will
not stand the test of that inquiry. There
have been ministers of this country who have
thought a free press Uieir best safeguard, who
have feared no libels, because their conduct
challenged investigation, and would pass the
fiery ordeal with honour. If this is no longer
the case, if the ministers of the (vesent &y
dread the consequence of a rigid examinatibn
and comparison of their professions and their
actions, if they wish to shut out the sun be-
cause they cannot bear the light, let them^
open and honest, let them avow their mean-
ing, let them speak out, let them not, bo-
cause the groit pillar that supports the Bri«
tisb constitution is hateful to them, seek upon
fiJse pretences to level the glorious fobric with
the dust.
But I am sure the lofly and intrepid spirit
of Britons b not to be subdued by any such,
means. I am sure the means are very ill
adapted to the end. Never yet was the fre-
quency of political publications lessened by
prosecution, but on thecontraiy they have'
always been increased ten-fold. If the minis^
ters wish to extract the sting from these pub-
lications, they should adopt a system exactly
the reverse of that which has provoked them,
liet them not cherish every canker that has
crept into the constitution, which mars its
i>eflLUty, and is eating out its vitals. Let them
not cfing to eveiy corruption and every abiMv
1045]
Jbrpmtl&king a Sedkiom JUbeL
A. D; 1794.
[1046
ftsifconuptkm and abuse were the end and
perfection of govenunenU Let them not pur*
BHe.thoM measures which induce the neces*
81^ of increasing that heavy load of taxes
which extorts from the poor the scanty sub-
jHStence that their labour can procure. Above
all, let them not pursue those measures which
deprive the industrious poor of those very
means of subsistence, and throw them upon
the benevolence of a generous public for their
vecy bnad. If they will avoid splitting upon
these rocks, they Will- disann political publi-
caliops of every thing offensive, and we shall
then hear no more ot the prevalence of libels.
But allow me to inquire, why prosecutions
are all on one side, way it is that those pam-
phlets only are prosecuted as libels which
reflect, or are supposed to reflect, upon the
regal or anstocratical branches of the consti-
tution. Does it not hence appear that to pro-
secute libels upon the constitution is no part
of the svstem of administration ? For if a
man will but exalt the regal and aristocratical
pat:M of the constitution at the expense of the
democratical part, he may libel the constitu-
tion with impunity. The democratical part
of the constitution is not a favourite sufficient,
at present, with those, who have the manafte-
.ment of a&irs, to induce them to stand tor-
ward as its avengers.
The " Majesty of the Public"— Gentle-
men, I am not usins an expression coined by
the republicans and levellers of the day, if any
such there be ; I am using the expression of
that great lawyer, Mr. Justice Blackstone,
whose authority is constantly appealed to on
these occasions by the counsel for tlie crown
— ^*'Tbe Majesty of the Public" may be
Jibelled. '< The Mfgesty of the Public*' has
no attorney general to file informations ex
q^io. against tlie libeller. The sacred rights
.of the people may be insulted, degraded, and
vilified^ and no prosecution is thought of. Yet
let but a. sarcasm be thought to nil on the
power and authority of kings or nobles, and
ministerial vengeance is instantlv hurled at
the head of the unfortunate offender.
Gentlemen, are such prosecutions as these
.for calling tyranny by its name, intended to
spread that torpor over the mind which is re-
quisite to its introduction ? Are they designed
'** to stop the current of all the passions but
fear ?" — Let us then resolve ratner to cease
.to live than live in chains.
. View in ancient history the glorious effect
.of freedom. See the heroic actions it inspired.
See tiie consequences in the perfection of
every art and science that could confer dig-
nity on man, or contribute to bis comfort.
Obaerye the dreadful contrast that is now
exhibited by those countries which have lost
it. Where you saw blooming fields, stately
edifices, commercial cities, you now see a de-
sart. Where you saw a people, adorned by
every manly and social excellence, whose ex-
amples we to this day hold up to our youth
..as^obj^ts pf .admirjition anil. imitation| you
i
now see a de^nerate race of beings, posses"
ains the form indeed, but devoid of the prin«>
ciptes and feelings of men.
To what is it we owe the unexampled ele*
vation which we have attained, but that.tran«
scendent freedom which has made us. the
envy and admiration o£ the world ? What ia
it that enables North America to proceed with
such gisantic strides to a state of prosperity;
at whicn Europe will soon j^aze with wonder
and astonishment, but the invincible energies
of freedom ? What is it that renders South
America such a dreadful reverse of that happy
state, but the ignorance and consequent sub*
very in which the people are held by their
unfeeling tyrants ?
. To at£icK the freedom of Ahc press,, and I
conceive it is attacked most violently by this
prosecution, is to aim a fatal stroke at liberty
Itself. And is it now at the close of tlie
eighteenth century, in an age which boasts
ofbeing the most enlightened the world ever
saw,. that liberty is to be proscribed in its
most favoured residence i No, gentlemen, so
long as we preserve those bulwarks of our
constitution the hberty of the press, and trial
by jury, and juries preserve their indepen*
dence, I am sure ail the efforts of tyrannv to
obtain a footing in this island will prove aboD*
tive.
Gentlemen, this is not vain and empty
declamation. The jexistence of every right
we possess depends in the first instance upon
the freedom of the press. While we possess
that unim|)aired, we can never be enslaved.
If we lose it we cannot be free. While the
press, which has been beautifully and empha-
tically styled '' the eye of the political body,''
continues to inspect and watch with diligence
the administration of public affairs, some hope
remains that those affairs may be adniinis-
tered with some attention to tlie public inte*
rest. But if it is destroyed or constantly
harrassed in the performance of its necessary
functions, we may abandon ourselves to dea-
pondency and despair. . .
Gentlemen, it vou find the defendant
Aiilty, consider what you determine, un-
3er me awful sanction of an attestation of
Uie Supreme Being. You swear to the trutb
of every word and syllable in this indictment.
You swear that by this game cock, this
haughty and sanguinary tyrant, nursed from
his infancy in blood and slauehter, is meant
the king of Great Britain, and no other. You
swear too that that king is a tyrant (for so the
indictment charges him to be). You swear
that an observation on kings in general must
necessarily include him. Besides that, ,yoti
not only swear that you so understand all this,
but that so did the defendant mean.
Canyoulay your hands upon your hearts,
and swear dl this ? Can you lie dowi\ upoa
your pillows without feclins thorns .in the
rdlection, that Uiat man who nas already been
imprisoned near three months upon tliis.lA-
dictmentf is to be impriseo$d Iwq or thc^
1M7] 84 6B0BGB JIL Proeimlbig$ ^igmmi Dmmd Lauc Eatom [104S
years loncer, and his wife and chiMwn to*
duced to u^gary and want» because you haae
fancied that a sense -primi facie so foreign,
may possibly* belong to this paper ?
why is It, that that insUtiition, trial by
jury, has challenged such universal admira
tion ? Because men are called upon to try
others by the same law by which they may
themselves be tried, and therefore it is con-
cluded that no man would be so mad or so
wicked as to wrest the law either for acquittal
or conviction; because in the former case he
would suffer as a member of that political so-
ciety which cannot exist if its laws are not
•niorced ; in the latter case he would be ex-
posed to the hazard of suffering as an indivi-
dual, and becoming the victim of his own
guilt.
Where that man stands to-day, you your*
•elves mav stand to-morrow. For there is
not a word you utter, which may not be tor-
tured into sedition, with as nmch reason as
-liie paper now under your consideratioo.
In pronouncing your verdict upon this case,
you will recollect that ever appUcable precept
of the great Author of our religion,—^ Do
unto others as you would wish them to do
4jntoyou." Sitting in the judement seat,
you will mete out to the defendant the
same measure of justice which you would
think be ou^ht to mete out to you, were
you in his situation and he in yours. If
you were standing at that bar, accused
of having uttered generalexpressions, prompt-
ed by the generous leelings of your
hearts, in detestation of tyranny and tyrants,
to which the despotic ingenuity of a special
pleader had affixed a seditious meaning by
auch innuendos as appear upon this iiMict-
nent, would you not claim as a first principle
-of justice that ^our words should be taken in
the most £ivourable sense, and not be per-
verted fixim their primary meaning, for the
purpose of incarcerating you in that strong
mansion ? I am sure y<M would, and there-
fore I claim the same justice for the defen-
•^ant. I claim it of you, because the verdict
must be yours, and yours alone, as you will
answer it to your country, to your consciences
•nd your God.
Gentlemen, I have endeavoured to dis-
charge my duty. 1 fear I have done it feebly
and imperfectly. You will nevertheless do
your's, and I am confident you will add to
the number of shining instances we have
lately witnessed, that an innocent individual
is never more safe than when bis conduct is
ciAitiitted to ttie enlightened and impartial
judgment of an English juiy.
SUMMIKO UP.
ICr. Recorder. — Gentlemen of tlie jury,
this is an indictment against Daniel Isaac
Eaton, who is charged with having published
this libel. — It cannot be necessary tor me to
state the •charge, you have heard it-opened by
the learned counael for the pro8ecutie% asd
fon haive afttwiawilB faewdthie ywta idaeh
aie offeDave, and which ofaiy, sndhiMiiipvm
the prisooer, particularly stated and s«ad %•
you. The pamphlet has been produced^ and
It will be put into your hands ; therelon it
would be a mere waste of time for me to raa
over the wofdaof the charge ; I shall take^iw
granted that you are pemctly masters joC
them ; and bemg so, the first psort «f my 4ni^
I conceive to be, to state to ymi what ia lfa«
evidence in support of this prosecution; aad
when I have done thut, I ehall state move
particularly what I conceive to be the giat-ctf
the crime.
To piove the publication, they 4Nily call
one witness ;---4ie says he bounbt it at ^le
ahon which is kept by the nefcndant, ia
Bisnopegale-street, on the 18th of Noiai
ber; — it is Numbor 6.— Upon the
mination, he aa^Fs, he is not an info
hut a man who lives by canying about :
papers. This is the whole evidence of the
puolication.
Before I state to you the miesdon of |inbli->
cation, for of that you must ne sattified nposi
the evidence, I will state what I conceive to
he particularly the nature of the crime, the
nature of the sedition, imputed fee the pri*
soner. — It is, as cbar^ in the tndictmaH^
that of vilifying and traducins the king and
the regal office, as established by law.
Now as to the first, traducing the king, the
last count in the indictment seems to apply
particularly to that; the parti allude to is
this: — ** Kinffs are wolf shepherds; — ^Horner
styles them devourcrs of tne people; and
they do not appear to have lost their ori^nnl
taste.'^
Now, gentlemen, as to this part of th^
question, by the constitution of this country,
and by the settled law of this countiT, to vnrite
any thine positively apd decidedly disrespect-
ful, to viiity or tradtice, to render ignoble, or
disgrace in the eyes of the People, who are
governed, the first branch or the lenslatnra^
me king, is, by the law of the laM, an o^
fence, and this is the offence imputed to the
Srisoner. The sort of sedition imputed to
im is, that he cfideavoured thereby to weakea
the hands of government.
You know vei^ well, gentlemen, that this
constitution is formed of king, lords, and
commons ; and it is very necessary, the law
has considered it such, and wisdom and pofi-
cy reouire that it should be so, that every
brancn of the lefislabure should be held in
equal respect. I nave no doubt to state to
you, that in a state of civil society, where
there exists a government, there must be si»-
periority and inferiority ; it is for the advaa*
tage and the ^ood of the whole that it should
exist ; and it is for that reason that the con-
stitution and the law of this country have ftr-
tified^nd given a partacular and strong ]No-
tedion to the character whidi commands ns
iJhe chief magietrate, taoA controls these wlm
ace governecT in this cotmtiy. I do net «»•
iai»i
JarftttUkkimg a SmMi^m LibeL
A. D« 17M.
[1050
iBigt ttpofi ffkiB 'fiidveit, b^cmwe I am sure
Uie iaonied adrportfr for the defendant cannot
eanlMPBri this;— 4hiKt beii^ so. you will -be
to judge whether, upon the reeaing this pern-
pfaM, which yen ottght, in my opinion, to
ready with your minds not at ail heated^
ailber with the address of the counsel on the
fuX of the prosecution, or with the address of
the couAsel on the part of the defendant, but
you ^MMild read the book precisely in^be way
as if jrou had it in your own priysle ellamber,
and wished to make yourselves completely,
maalsis of the whole sulyec^ : see what the
impression on your mincb i^ then, and see
whelhe»a person, using the language which
is nsed in this second count, does or does not
mean to vilify and traduce that l»ranchof the
eoBstitution which the defendant is charged
with doing in the indictment.
You are not onl^ to read the passages
eiiaif ed to be libelkms, but to read the whole
IHunphlet; and if, upon reading the whole,
you ipan appl v this to any thing but the go-
vernment of this country, and that branch of
it named — ^to be sure it dioes not impute any
thing to the defendant.
An observation occurred to the counsel for
the defendant, which he urged with great in*
genuity ; he thought it his duty to state to
you, that this has so aeneral an application,
%hat it is not to be applied to the government
«f this country.— -Now you should read a
pamphlet of tras sort, chamd to be a libel,
with exactly the same indifierence as you
would any other book,*-then see liowyou are
to apply that language in the way it is here
a^leo— ^ The lUiflexions of a true Briton —
Kings are wolf shepherds.*' and so on — whe-
«ther you would not apply that to all kings?
The learned counsel has told you, that the
word ^ ally** shouAd have been usea for you
to have put that construction upon it; — now
that is entirely a matter of iact upon which
you are to decide; but the observati(»i really
strikes me the odier way ; because it strikes
«ie, that if a person uses the general term in
that way, and makes no exception, that it is
applicable to all persons of that description.
It appears therefore to me, and you will judge
^ that, reading this with the whole of the
pamphlet, whether you do not consider this
as a direct attack upon one branch of the le-
gislature, and that the person who wrote this
(I shall come to the publisher by-and-bjr), did
not thereby mean to say that kings, this de-
'^cription of people, were devourers of the
people, and so on; — whether, being in that
general way, it is not, in the common con-
struction of language, to be applied to the
'^vemment of this country ? If you think it
IS, then it is, by the law of the land, indis-
putably a libel ; and how far the prisoner may
Be answerable for it, it is for you to consider.
I shall make one more observation to you
upon this part of the case, that it is vour
duty certamly to read the whole pampnlet,
bec^osethe innuendos^ the sent uiat ta im-
puted to the Jperson who writes this book, is
entirely to be oecided by you. So much for
that part of the case which imputes sedition
to the government of this country.
It appears to me that sedition is imputed in
another way, and that is upon the personal
executive power, upon the kine nimself.
This indktment charges the author of this
pamphlet with charging the king of Eneland,
among others, with oemg a tyrant; and after
stating that su<^ a tyrant is guilty of oppres-
sion by taxation, and so on, he seems to in^
timato pretty broadly as his opinion, that
such a person should suffer death by the euiU
lotine^-^And he says afterwards, describing
all this by the figure of a cock, that such a
person, when his trappings were stripped off,
was found to be rank with the pollution of his
luxurious vices, and so on. The second count
only makes a part of the same charge ; it will
be for you to consider, reading the book in an
indifierent manner ; for there is no evidence
given in explanation of the book one wav or
other; youbavenothing but the speeches of the
learned counsel upon it. As to what passes
in the world, you are competent and fair
judges Then reading this book, called Poli-
tics for the People, and the Reflexions of a
True Briton, and so on, considering the time
when it was published, you will be to decide
upon all the observatioBS you have heard on
both sides, whether this is fairly or not impu-
table, as it is charged in this indictment, to
the king of this country, and whether the
author who wrote it^ meant to apply it to the
king of this country.
With respect to innuendos, it must be a
factalways for a jury to decide ^i4iat is the sense
and meaning of a libel ; for man in tiie high-
est extravagance of compliment, beyond a
doubt may write such a pamphlet as shall be
a g^s libel. A man may use such language,
as in the plain terms of it at first may ajmear
to be no tihtA ; but yet, perhaps, by kiokfng
into some other expression, or takine the in-
tention of the party in the whole of the book,
it will be impossible not to see, that though
he uses language that is ironical, yet that you
perfectly understand, he means exactiy the
reverse of what he says; and if from the
whole of the work you can collect, and think
yourselves bound to collect, reading it feirly,
that such was the intention of the party, that
will be a libel.
Gentlemen, it is in matters of sedition as
it Is in other crimes.^ Few men are boM and
h'ardy enough to use language of such sort as
will subject them to very severe penalties,
without some sort of cover. God forbid that
I should (for it is not my province) impute that
to the defendant upon tne present occasion ;
but it is my duly to sUte to you, that if a
pamphlet is written in that way, tou have
a rignt to take off the mask, if you think it h
a mask : and it is your duty, reading it
with indifference and with temper, to see
what the iatentioD is, whatever the Tcil may
1051] 34 GEORGE III. PrcUedings ogihui Danid Aaae JSaian [lOfit
be, whatever the cover may be, whether it it
under an ape, or whether it ia by allegory, or
»fiflnire; whatever colour or complexion the
book may take, it is intirely for you to decide
what is the fair meaning of that book, and
what is the sense in which the author wrote it..
Gentlemen; you see here is a figurative
description of a cock, and so on ; and this is
imputed by the indictment to apply to the
sovereign of this country, and to mipute to
him taxation, and other things, as oppres-
sion ; and that he ought to be taken on by
the guillotine. — ^Upon the observation made
on both sides of tne question, and consider-
ing that the book is entitled *< Politics for the
People,'' and " The Reflexions of a True
Briton," you will be to judge whether that is
iairly imputable to the sovereign of this
country ; if it is not, certainlj^ it is not a libel ;
if it is, on the other hand, it is indisputably a
libel, and you will find the defendant guUty
of that count.
Gentlemen, you have heard a great many
observations in this case respecting the liberty
of the press. I am sure I think it my duty to
atate» tliat the liberty of the press is the
greatest blessing this country can enjoy ; but
.on the other hand, I must state to you, that
the hcentiousness of the press is the greatest
curse. And I am sure your good sense will
teach you this, that if men are permitted to
say any thing, ihey will very soon go the
length of doing any thing ; and where that is
the situation of affairs in any country, there is
an end of all government; and therefore you
must judge in a case of this sort of the sense
of Uie libel, of the intention of the party, and
your decision on this indictment one way or
other will not, in my opinion, affect that
ijuestion which has been stated to you of the
bberty of the press.
This, you see, is not charged to be a libel
upon ministers, but it is a direct charge, in
one part of it, upon one branch of the govern-
ment ; and, in another part of it, in an oppres-
sive exercise of the duties of that branch of the
government ; and therefore if it fairly applies
to the king of this countiy, it seems to me
very difficult for any jury to say, that a per-
son who writes a book with an intention to
make a direct attack upon the government,
or to charge the executive government of
this country with oppression, it seems very
difficult to say that that comes within th^
liberlv of the press. I conceive the law to be
completely otnerwise, and that the executive
government of the country is protected by the
law, that every individual is protected from
aiich an attack, and the executive government
of a country, the first magistrate, a character
that stands so high, must necessarily be so
protected; therefore it comes, and always
must come to the question, whether a direct
offensive attack is made upon that govern-
ment.
if you shall be of opinion that this is not
written in a mere speculative way, but th^
it is written with the imentioB cbargol itt tko
indictment, to render contemptihle tfaai.cb»<*
racter, and to charge that chancier witli op*
pression, it seems to me that this is do ques-
tion of speculation which involves the libeil^
of the press, but it seems to be that sort o€
Question which gives the gp-by to it; aad
tnat you must be decided intirely in your ajpi^
nion upon the evidence which is before you*
Gentlemen, much has been aaid about the
cheapness of the hbel ; tha^ is out of tke
question; if you should be satisfied upon the
whole, that it is a libel applied to the fowent^
mentof this country, it must be certainlj an
agg^ravation of the offence, but thai cannot
decide the question of libel one wsty or tiie
other. But then there, is another question
for your consideration, and that is the intent
tion of the party. Now you will observe the
person before you is the pubhsher, and not
the author of the libel ; but as to the ques-
tion of the sedition in the libel, that roust
first be disposed of; aad it is my duty to stale
to you, that if you should think this appii*
cable to the government of this country^ tnat
then the publisher of it, if it is a libel, js mi^
swerable tor the consequences of that publica-
tion; and it will be very difficult, in mj
opinion, for you to say, when once the &ct is
settled, that the work is libellous, that the
person who sends into the world that sort of
publication to disturb the peace of the couDtiy,
could do it with any v^ry good intention.
The learned counsel for the defendant has
told you, that since the act of parhament has
taken place, this is to be decidied in the same
way as anv other crime, and he has thought
fit to put the crime of murder as the example
Now taking that as the example, how would
it be? Suppose a man commits a murder with
a very offensive weapon, I take it to be clear
s^d settled law that his evil intent wiH
tberebv be presumed ; and if the law in the
case where a murder is committed with a veiy
offensive weapon, would presume that the
party using it nad an intention to do the mis-
chief, I should think, if a man sends poison
into the world, that may do a great deal of
mischief, that a jury would not gp any great
length in presuming upon the evidence, un-
less he could, on his part, show some evH
dence to get rid of the presumption, that lie
was influenced by that criminal inteutiop
which the law presumes, in that case, as it
docs in the case of libel.
It will be for you, therefore, first to make
up your minds upon this pamphlet, whether
it does apply to the kin^ and the government
of this country; and if it doea^ then the nei^
question for you to consider is, whether the
)risoner is the publisher of it ; now as to th^
le certainly is answerable in law as the puh-
isher, if it is sold in his shop. There has
been nothing proved on the part of the pri-
soner to show that he is not at all responsibly
for it; and unless he disproves the fact qf
publication, it is a publication for which he js
1053]
^ pkiHshing a }SddiU«Ui LibeL
A. D. 1794.
[1054
bound to answer ; and as to his intention, I
Bbidl certainly leave it to you to determine
upon the case stated by the counsel, if you
are satisfied that this is alibellmis work, and if
vou are satisfied that these innuendo^are proper
nmuendos, and feirly made out, whether you
can think a man publishing such a pamphlet
as this charged to have, and having in your
opinion a seditious tendency, does it with
such an innocent intention as the law will
support.
There is one more observation that has
been made by the counsel for the defendant.
•—You have heard a good deal about the star-
thamber, and so on ; now I think it is but
(kit to say that this has been brought before
yoii by a grand jury. God forbid that you
;ihoula decide the question against the pri-
soner because a grand jury has found the
bill; but so far as concerns the attorney
gentral, it is on the part of the public cer-
mnly the mildest method of proceeding,
because it is giving the prisoner the most
£ivourable opportunity of being tried by
jiis equals. I cannot, therefore, -conceive
that this prosecution can in any wav be con-
sidered to look at all like any of those pro-
secutions of which we have heard so much,
becuise I think all that is done away by the
xnanner in which the present attorney general
has thought fit to prosecute this man.
There was another observation made by
the counsel for the defendant, respecting the
taxes and adminutration, and so on. I can
onlv say, that I think that observation was a
little unfortunate^ because the whole of the
def(»ice seemed to me, upon this occasion, to
turn upon this ; and it is the strongest part
of the argument which has been put by the
counsel for the defendant, that these mnuendos,
applying these passages to the kins and go-
vernment of this country, are not fairly ap-
])lied. Now it seems to me, in such a de-
fence as that, rather an aukward circumstance ;
and it looks as if the mind, in reading this
pamphlet, could not but feel that it is meant
to convey sentiments unfavourable to the
fovenimeiit of this <;ountry; and what
strengthens that opinion is, that in^the sub-
sequent part something farther is jstated re-ir
specting those taxes mentioned in this very
hbcl.
You have had another observation made
with respect to the state of this man*s family;
now as all that is to be considered as an at-
tack upon your passions, either on one side
or the other, you have too much jgood sense
to attend to it. You are to consider the si-
tuation of the country at large, the good go-
vernment of the countiT on one hand, and
the situation of the defendant on the other,
and I have no doubt that you will do jus-
tice between them both, and that you will
not be horried away by the idea of a family,
or any thing of tliat sort, which in a criminal
icase can make no consideration at all. All
that the prosecutor can ask of you, and all
that I can ask of vou, is this*, to read this book
as you would read it if jou wanted to make
yourselves masters of it in your own private
chambers, see what the impression is on your
minds, and if you think these innucndos are
fairly made out, as applied to this pamphlet,
the;^ certainly charge the defendant with pub-
lishing a seditious libel. You will judge of
the whole; if you think him guilty you will
find him so ; if vou think this is not made
out to be applicable to the king and govern-
ment of this countiy, vou will then acquit him.
Mr. Gurney. — I beg the jury may take
out with them a copy of the indictment as
well as the pamphlet.
Mr. Fielding. — ^Your lordship will decide
upon that.
Mr. Gumev, — ^Upon the trial of this defen-
dant at Guildhall, lord Kenyon expressly de-
sired the jury to take with them a copy of the
information.
Foreman of the Jury, — We beg we may
have a copy of the indictment.
Mr. Fielding, — Certainly gentlemen you
shall.
The jury retired, taking with them the
pamphlet and a copy of the indictment ; in
about an hour they returned with a verdict
of-N(Jt.Guilty.
1055] 84 GEORGE in. ProceedimgiifmManoi.iF'wBkp'Mdiaheri^ [1066
601. Proceedings on the Trial of an Indictment against Twomam
Walker of Manchester^ Merchant^ Wiluam Paul^ Samcti,
Jackson, James Cheetham, Outer Pearsaix^ Bekjamih
BooTH^ and Joseph Collier, for a Conspiracy to overthrow
the Constitution and GoTemment, and to Aid and Aoswt
the French (being the King's Enemies), in case they aheoU
invade this Kingdom. Tried at Lancaster, before the Hoo.
John Heath, Esq. one of the Justices of his Majesty's Court
of Common Pleas,* April 3 : 34 George III. a. d. 179*.
Cojf^ of the Indictment aeainst T!ioma$ Walker
and otKers.
jMncitthirt > X HE jurors for our lord the king
towU {upon their oath present, that
Thomas Walker,! Iftte of Manchester, in the
* Taken in shortrhand bj Joseph Gumey.
t There was a warrant on a charge of high
treason issued against, but not executed upon,
this defendant : as to the proceedings upon
which, the folldwing documents were inserted
in the original edition of this trial :
No. I.*— Ck>P7 of Mr. Walker's firtt letter to
Mr. Secretary Duvda&
Bate$ Hotely t7ih June^ 1793.
Sir; — ^I have been for some time absent
frojp home, on account of business which has
required my presence in London. I £nd by
mv letters or last Saturday (the contents of
which are still more strongly confirmed by
those of to-day), that a report has been in-
dustriously circulated in Manchester of a
charge of high treason, made against me,
before the magistrates of that town.
I am extremely sorry to occupy your time
with the frivolous rumours that idle and igno-
rant, or bigotted and malevolent |)eop]e, may
amuse themselves with propagating at the
expense of my character, i But the report
above mentioned is in itself so serious, and
has been the topic of so much conversation
at Manchester, that I tliink it right, injustice
to myself, and to obviate any &se construe-
tion which my enemies may put upon my ab-
sence from home, to inform you, sir, that my
residence is as above-mentioned, and that I
bhall be not merely ready and willing, but
desirous to meet any chiarge that may be
made against me from whatever quarter it
may proceed. I shdl be upon changre at the
usual time almost every day this week, and I
shall be this evenuig in the lobby of the
House of Commons, or in the gallery there.
— ^I have the honour to he, sit, your most
obedient servant,
(Signed) Thomas Walker.
The right honble. ffenry Dundai,
principal secretary of state for
tbe liomo de|»w(iaea^ &a. ^c.
county of Lancaster, merchant; George
MK^uIlum, late of the same place, labourer;
No. II.— Copy of Mr. Waucbe's seoond ieb>
ter to Mr. Sccietaiy Dumdas.
Bate^s Hotel, 99nd June, 1795.
Sir; — ^In consequence of repeated advice
from Manchester of warrants for high treason
having been issued against me, I thought it
right to inform you by letter on Monday last;
that I resided, during my stay in town, at
Bate's hotel, and that I should be at the
House of Commons on that evening, and on
change at the usnal hours almost every daj
of the week. I have kept my promise.
I confess I am somewhst surprised, under
all the circumstances of my situation, that I
have not been favoured with an answer to
that letter, but had the business rested there,
I should probably have troubled you no fkr-
thcr.
By a letter, however, firom my attorney in
Manchester J sent yesterday under cover to a
friend of mine, I learn officially that a war-
rant upon a charge of high treason has cer*-
tainly been issued against me at Manchester,
and I have eveiy reason to suppose (if my in-
formation be true) that the mtent of the
charge in the first instance, and the subse-
quent delay in proceedine upon it, is not t»
punish me for a political onence, of which I
know I am not guilty, but to injure my ge-
neral character and reputation; indirectly
indeed, but irrevocably.
The character and credit of a commercial
man, ur, is too delicate to be triBed with.
Hitherto mine has been unsullied ; and I
trust it vnW remain so by any conduct of my
own. But the principle of harassing a British
merchant by vague reports, industriously ciiw
culated, of crimes he has never committed;
by charges unfounded, and threats unexecuted,
is so base, so detestably maligiuint, that I
hope, for the honour of the national character,
it is confined to my enemies at Manchester.
It is highly improbable that any charge of
so criminal a nature can have been made
X'nst me^ without its being known at the
e of his majesty't secretary of state. I
10572
^ftr o iAMfjpvw^4
A. D. 1794.
[I0S6
.iphn Snuibf^Bte of the fame plioe, labourtr ;
William Paul»t ^"^ of the aaine place, P^P^*
do, theiefbie, eacnestly intreat, that Imay be
kept no longer in susp^se ; that I nav be
treated forthwith according; to law, if there
be any lenl accuaation minst me, or if there
be none, Siat I may be informed of it without
delay. I think i have a right, after what haa
passed, to require, as an act of common jut-
tioe,that my mind maybe set at case, and
that I may be enabled to attend to my commer-
cial coocerns, without the perpetual anxiety
attendant upon reports and suspicions most
injurious ana unfounded.
Mr. Wharton will do me the favour to de-
liver this, and wait for an answer.* — Tn the
mean time I am, sir, your obedient servant,
fSigned) ' Thomas Walker.'
The right nonble. Henry DundaSf
his majesty's principal secretary
of state for the home depart-
ment, &c. &c.
No. III.— Copy of a letter from Mr. Walker
to Mr. Wbarton.
BaU^i Hiftel^ Ltrndan, t6th Jui^, 1793.
Dear Sir; I have no doubt you will be
much^surpnsed, when I inform you, that I
am still without any answer to the letter you
did me the honor to take to Mr. Dundas (at
secretary of state for the home department)
upon the %%d ult. and several of my friendsp
being not less surprised than myself at the
silence of Mr. Dundas, are anxious to know
what passed between you and him upon thede-
livery of my letter. I shall, therefore, consider
myself particularly oblig^, if yeu will favour
me, as nearly as you can recollect, with the
aubstuice of the conversation which took
place on that occasion. — With much respect
and esteem believe me, dear sir, -very sin-
cerely your's,
(Signed) Thomas Wai.K£B*
John Wharionf taq, M. P. Skelton
Castle, near Guisborougb, York-
shirew
No. rv, — Copy of Mr. WnAftTOM's Answer to
Mr. Walker.
Dr« Sir ; I am much surprised to find that
you have not yet heard from the secretary of
state's office in reply to the letter I delivered
firom ydu to Mr. Dundas, on the S9d ult The
conversation that passed between us on that
occasiota, you desire tliat I should repeat to
you ; it is impossible for me to undertake to
do it verl>atim ; but the substance was, that
I presented tb^e letter at your request, in con*
sequence of your not having received any
repiy to one of a similar purport, that you
had written to him on the preceding Mondlay ;
- • While Mr. Wharton went into Mr. Dun-
das, Mr. WaUcer, and Mr. Cooper as his friend,
waited near the door of the board of control,
till Mr. Wharton came o«tr-Or^< Ed.
VOL. XXIH.
ataloar ; Samual Jackson,t late t>f the same
place, chapman; James Cheetham,|| late of
and that hmng kept in a state of suspense om
a subject of so serious a nature, was highly
injunotts to you as an Englishman and a mer-
chant.— Mr. Dundas read the letter, and said
that it was impossible for him to make any
other reply to it than this, that he had re-
ceived serious and criminal charges against
yeu 5 that he had consequently taken such
steps as his official duty required, to have
those charges investiffated, and that I might
'assure you, that no official delay should ansa,
and that when .any determination was taken
respecting them, vou should be apprized of it.
I said you wishea for nothing more than a
speedv determination on the steps to be taken,
and tnat you did not wish lo escape the jus-
tice of your country, if you had offended it ;
and I added that you had accompanied me ta
his office, and that I was ready to deliver up
the culprit, if he considered vo« as such, ii»-
mediately; but I apprehended that upon a
full investigation of the charges a^inst you,
it would appear that personsd enmity to you,
and jealousy of your commercial connexions,
had instigated persons who had failed in their
attempts to iiyure you commercially, to make
this attempt to take away your life; Mr.
Dundas said it was very possible that there
might be low and personal motives for iJie
Eresecution, and that he (from ever^ thing ha
ad heretofore heard or known of you) had
too good an opinion of your understanding, to
suppose you would subject yourself to the
penalties of high treason. I then thanked him
for his candour and politeness, and took my
leave.
I shall be very happy to hear from you,lf
any thing further is done in this business, and
remain, dear sir, with great regard, youi^S|
very sincerely,
(Signed) Jbnir Whartov.
Skelton Castle, July 81st, 179S.
J%mmn WMer^ esq. Bate's Hotels
Adelphi, London.
No. V. — Copy of a third Letter from Mr.
Walkek, to Mr. Secretary DvvDAs.
Bait'i Hotel, 8M July, 1703.
S'ur; fnom Mr. Wharton's account oi the
oonvecsation that passed between you and
him, on his delivenns to you ny letter of the
9Sd ult I was inducea to expect an early inti^*
matton of the intended proceedings against
me, or of their having been relinquished ; I
i^ould be much surprised that no decision
had yet taken place on this business, if I w^ra
not conscious that the more strictly the accu-
aaUona were inveatigated, the more iutile they
would appear.
My business in London, will occupy me
till Sunday next, when I shall set out for Lan-
eatsl^i^unless some notice, from the office of
his miyest^s aecvetaries of state should detain
3 Y
1
3059] 34 GEORGE m. Proceedings agauui Tkot. fFalter and others, [1060
SaHbrdyinthesaid county^ labourer ; Ofiver
Pearson^ late of Manchester aforeaaid^ lar
me longer in town.^— I have the honor to be,
air^ your most obedient servant,
(Signed) Thomas Walkeb.
The right honble. Henry Dundas,
his Majesty's Principal Secretary
of State for the Home DeparV-
menty &c. &c.
Mr. Walker not having received an an-
swer from Mr. Dundas to any of his three
letters, and judging that Mr. Oundas's testi*
mony might be essential, directed him to
be subpoenaed to appear as a witness on this
trial at Lancaster. The following are copies
4>f two subpoenas with which Mr. Dundas was
served, together with the copies of two letters,
the one from Messrs. Ward, Dennetts and
Oreaves, agents to Messrs. Duckworth and
Dennett, and the other from Mr. White, so-
licitor tathe treasury, to Messrs. Ward^ Den*
netts and Greaves, upon this subject.
Ko.TI.->Copy of the first Subpcena with which
Mr. Dundas was served.
Oeoree the Uiird, by the mce of God, of
Great Britain, France, and Ireland king, de-
fender of the (aith, &c. to the risht honourable
Henry Dtmdas, our principal secretery of
state for the home department, greeting, we
command you, that laying aside all other bu-
siness, excuses, and delays whatsoever, you be
and personally appear before our justices at
Lancaster, the first day of the next general
session of assizes of oyer and terminer, and
gentfal gaol delivery, there to be holden, to
testify and speak the truth between us and
Thomas Walker, George M^CuUum, John
Smith, William Paul, Samuel Jackson, James
Cheetham, Oliver Pearson, Benjamin Booth,
Henry Yorke, and Joseph Collier, on the part
sndbehalf of the said Thomas, George, Jo^n,
William, Samuel, James, Oliver, Benjamin,
Henry, and Joseph, upon all such matters and
things whereupon you shall be examined ; and
that you bring with you and produce upon the
said trial, three several letters, purporting to be
written by the said Thomas Walker to you,
one of wnich is dated in the words and figures
following, << Bate's Hotel, ITthJune. 1793,"
and u signed and subscribed with tne name
^ Thomas Walker," and is directed to you
by the description of the rieht honble. Henry
DundaSyprincmal secretary of state for the home
department, &c. another of which said letters
h dated in the words and figures following,
^ Bate's Hotel, 89d June 1799," and is sienS
and subscribed with the name^ Thomas Wal-
ker," and is directed to you 6y the descrip-
tion of ** the right honble. Henry Dnndu,
his mayesty's principal secretary of state for
the home department, &c. &c." and the other
of which said letters is dated in the words
spd figures following, ^ Bate's Hotel, S9th July
179S/ and b signed and subscribed with the
bourer ; Benjamin Booth,1f late of the
place, labourer; Henry York, late of the
name ** Thomas Walker," and is directed to
Siu by the description of ** the right lionble.
enry Dundas, his majesty's principal secie-
taiy of state for the home department &c. ftc.**
And this you are not to omit, under the pe-
naltv of one hundred pounds. Witnesa^ air
Arcnibald MacdonakI, knight, at Lancaster,
the fifteenth day of August, in tbethirty-thini
year of our reign.
Batt,
(Endorsed)
March 84th. 1794.— Served this subpcenii
on Mr. Dundas, at his house at Wimbledon,
and at the same time offered him thirty gui«
neaSy which he refused.
(Signed) J. Deknett.
No. VIId--Copy of the second Subpoena with
whicli Mr. Dundas was served.
George the third, by the £race of God, of
Great Britain, France, and Iceland king, de-
fender of the faith, &c. To the right honble.
Henry Dundas, onr principal secretary of
state of the home department, greeting, we
command you, that laying aside all other tnH
siness. excuses^ and delavs whatsoever, ^o«
be ana personally appear before our justicea
at Lancaster, the first day of the next general
session of assizes of oyer and terminer, and »-
neral gaol delivery there to beholden, to tes^r
and speak the truth between us and Thomaa
Walker, Geon^e M'Cullum, John Smith,
William Paul, Samuel Jackson, James Cheei-
ham, Oliver Pearson, Benjamin Booth,
Henry Yorke, and Joseph Collier, on the part
and behalf of the said Thom^, Geoigc, Joho,
William, Samuel, James, Oliver, foijamio^
Henry, and Joseph^ upon all such matters and
things whereupon you shall be examined;
And also that you bring with you and pro-
duce upon the trial of this traverse, all infi>r-
mations and examinations, and copies of in-
formations and examinations, taken on oath
or otherwise, of Thomas Dunn^ or any other
person or persons as;ainst the said defendants,
or any of them, either for high treason, con*
•piracy, or any other crime or misdemeanor,
transmitted and delivered to you, either as
the secretary of state, or otherwise, and all
warrants, or copies of warrants issued thereon,
and all other proceedings had and^ taken
thereon. — And this you are not to omil undw
the penalty of one hundred pounds. Witness^
sir Archibald Macdonald, knight^ at Lanms-
ter, the fifteenth day of August, in the thirty*
third year of our reign.
Batt.
(Endorsed.)
March S5th, 1794. — Served this subpoena,
by delivering cop^ to Mr. Nepean, who un-
dertook to accept it as if served on Mr. Duda
das*
m (Signed) J. Dbxhett.
1061]
far a Compirae^
pkce, gentleman; and Joseph CoIHer, late of
tftie same pbce, surgeon, being wicked^ sedi*
No. VIII. — Copy of Messrs. Ward, Dennetts,
and Greaves'^ Letter to Messrs. Duck-
worth and Dennett.
The King againtt Walker and others.
Grentlemen ;— *We could not get to see Mr.
Dundas to serve the last subpoena upon him,
but Mr. Nepean received it, and he under-
took to accept it as good service, since which
we have received the inclosed letter from the
solicitor to the treasury, which admits the
service of both subpcsnas. — ^We are, dear sirs,
your's sincerely,
(signed) Ward, Dennetts and GbeaveS;
CaoeiU Garden, March 97, 1794.
We return you the subpoena.
Messrs. DuckzDorth and Denneiif
Manchester.
No. IX- — Copy of Mr. White's Letter to
- Messrs. Ward, Dennetts, and Greaves.
The King against Paul and others.
Sirs ; — The subpoena which you served on
Mr. Dundas, requiring him to flloduce three
letters, sent by Mr. Walker, one of the defen-
dants, to Mr. Dundas, as secretary of state,
hath been sent to me, together with Mr.
- Walker's letters.
I beg leave to acquaint you, that these let-
ters shall be produced on the trial, if called
for, and I will instruct his majesty's counsel
to admit that they were received by Mr. Dun-
das, hi his capacity of secretary of state, and
that both subpoenas have been served. — I am,
sirs, your roost humble servant,
(Siened) Jos. White.
No. 6. lincMs Inn, 27 March, 1794
Mesirs. Ward, Dennetts, and GreaveSy
solicitors, Covent Garden.
No. X.— 'Particulars of several applications
made by Mr. Richard Walker, respecting
hisbrother^JVIr. Thomas Walker, to the
rev. John Griffith, one of bis majesty's
justices of the peace.
On Thursday July 18th 1793, 1 went to the
rev. John Griffith's house a little before ten
in the morning, accompanied by Mr. William
Seddon, but finding Mr. Griffith was gone to
church, we waited m the church yard till he
«ame out,' when Mr. Seddon told him we
wanted to speak to him, on which Mr. Grif-
fith took us into a public house in the church
yard, where 'Mr. Seddon informed him that as
we understood he had granted a warrant
against Mr.- Walker, we came to let him know
tfiuat Mr. Walker was in London, and where
he was to be met with ; that he^Mr. Griffith)
might get the same served upon him there.
Mr. Griffith replied, that there certainly was
a warrant signed by him against Mr. Thomas
Walker, for high treason, and when he came
home^ it woulcTbe put in force ; that there
had been a person waitmg in the market
A. D. 1794w [1068
tious, and ill-disposed persons, and disaffected
to our sovereign lord tne now king, and the
place* to apprehend him, at a time when it
was reported he was fetumed home, that
Unite, a deputy constable, had either been at
Barlow or m the neighbourhood, as it was
said Mr. Walker had been there, and that he
had also been seen in Manchester. I told
him it was perfectly untrue ; that my brother
had never been out of London or the nei^h-
bourhood, since he first went up ; ' Mr. Gnf*
fith said, << I do not hesitate to aeclare that at
the matter now stands we cannot ccmvict
either Mr. Paul or any other person of
high treason as we have only one wit-
ness at present*' I then read him the
annexed paper, and gave him my bro-
ther's address on a card, in my brother's
own hand writing. Mr. Griffith said, h^
did not see why ue should* act out of hia
own district, and that I had better give the
card to Unite, who had the warrant, and
might do as he pleased; I rephed, I should
have nothing to do with Unite, or any such
people, that he (Mr. Griffith) had declare he
nad granted a warrant for my brother's ap*
prehension, and therefore I let\ the card with
him. lie persisted in saying, he saw no rea-
son for his acting ; Mr. Seddon replied, he
thought if Mr. Walker had really been guilty
of high treason, he ought to have been taken
up, or to be so immediately , wherever he was,
and prosecuted at the expense of the public.
Mr. Griffith said, he did not see that ; he had
sent copies of the informations to government,
and could not tell why they did not act, and
why they seemed to wish to throw the busi<>
ness on a country justice. Mr. Seddon de«
clared he thought it very strange, and a most
malevolent piece of business throughout, and
observed, that had a warrant been issued
against any person on a charge of bastardy,
he (Mr. Griffith) would have taken care to
have it backed, and the person apprehended
at the charge of the parish. Mr. Griffith re*
plied. " that would be for the security of the
parish." Mr. Seddon said, « true, and thia
being on a charge of high treason, is for the
security of the kmgdom, and ought to be at
the expense of the public." Mr. Griffith stilt
said, they had only one witness ; on which I
remarked, that with all the pains which it
was reported he, the rev. Mr. Griffith, had
taken, it was surpridng he could not get ano*
ther witness as good as the one they Had, but
that I thought no candid or dispassionate
person was at a loss to what motive to attri-
bute the present proceedings. I also men*
tioned my brother's having given notice to
Mr. Dundas, of his being in London.
* The market place in Manchester is con-
sidered as the exchange, where the merchants
and manufacturers meet to transact their bu«^
siness. Grig, Ed,
1068] M GSORQE UL Proceedings ag^mtt Thos. WMer and others [106ft
constitutioil and coveniment of this kingdomi
as by Uw eslabUwed^ and unbwiuUy contrit -
The rev Mc. Griffith said, ^ that so far
from bis acting in London, was he there, and
^ad a sufficient acquaintance with Mr. Tho*
jnas Walker, be should not thiiik it uiyustifi-
able or improper to call on him at his own
hotel, and dine with him/' On which Mr.
Seddon said, *' What ! dine with a traitor '/'
and I added, *' and one against whom you
£ounelf have issued a warrant for his appre-
lension !'* he replied, " I mean as a private
gentleman;'' we both repeated " woiud you
ine with a traitor?''
Mr. Griffith tlien said, it was not incumbent
on him to take any steps to apprehend Mr.
Thomas Walker out ot his own neighbour-
liood, on which Mr. Seddon observed, that
the warrant beine for conspiring or compas-
sing the death of the king, as he (Mr. Griffith)
liad acknowledged, and Mr. Thomas Walker
being in London so near the king's person,
be might more easily have an opportunity of
putting his wicked intentions into execution,
Vut that a traitor ought to be taken into cu»-
tod^ wherever he was, as soon a!^ possible ;
ftaa I said it showed little regard for the safe*
ty of the king's person, to suffer those who
!ivere accused of conspiring against his Kfe, to
be at large so near him without interruption.
The rev. Mr. Griffith also declar^, that
Unite had followed Mrs. Jackson's funeral to
have apprehended Mr. Jackson, had he fol-
lowed her to the grave; that he wished
Unite not to interrupt the ceremony, as he
thought it would be rather indelicate, but to
follow Mr. Jackson, and take him up as he
returned home, or at his own house. Mr.
Griffitli also said, he was persuaded that trea-
son had been actually committed at Mr. Wal-
ker's house, but that Mr. Walker was not
present at the time. I replied, that was not
the hctf for neither my brother nor I, had any
connexion with people guilty of treason. Mr.
Griffith said it had been reported he had an
indemnity from government for what he had
done, but that was not the case.
Mr. Seddon mentioned Mr. PauPs treat-
ment, and Mr. Griffith's having refused a
copy of the information, and the reports which
bad been so shamefully spread, respecting
dlffia«nt people being apprehended here for
high treason, and that the ,nfa|ter ought cer-
tainly to be brought to a conclusion. Afler
repeating the general purport of the paper
alluded to, and Mr. Griffith again declanng
that he should give the card to Unite, who
might act as he thought proper, we left him.
1 again went on the 31st of July with Mr.
Birch and Mr. Sanderson, to Mr. Griffith and
fave him notice in their presence that my
rother would be at Lancaster at the ensuing
assizes.
On the 5th of August I again informed Mr.
Griffitli, that my brother would be iu Man-
chester on the Thursday or Fiiday following;
ing and iateAding, as much is in theai lay, «^
break the peace and disturb thfc traoqiiiUitgr
Mr. Griffith asked where he would Ihs, to
which I replied, that I could not tell procwely
where he would be, but that he would be id
Manchester; Mr. Griffith said, ^ Will he be
upon change ?" I said, *^ Why should he be
upon change ? he will be in Maaohester.'^ Mr.
Griffith further asked, *' Will your brother
pledge himself to take his trial tor sedition mt
the ensuing assises ? for I have two charjgss
against him, one for high treason, and ane-
tner for sedition.'' I replied ** he will be ia
Mapchester at the dme I mention, on Thurs-
day or Friday next."
On Thureday my brother returned Irom
London to Barlow, and on Friday moroiiBc he
came to Manchester, of wluch I gave Mr.
Griffith immediate notice.
RiCBARO Walkeb.
No. XI. — Copy of the paper read by Mr.
AicHAao Walkjce, to the rev. Johk GaiF-
FiTH, upon the 18th of July 1793, in the
presence of Mr. William Sedboit.
I imderstand from the infcmnatiiNi of sev^
rsd respectable persons, that there is a war-
rant out i^ainst my brother Mr. Thomas
Walker, signed by you, on a criminal cbai^ge
of some kind or other ; my brother has re-
ceived the same information : as this report
is now generally current in Maneheater, I
think it rizht to acquaint you, that my bro-
ther Mr. 1 iioms Walker, resides «t present et
Bate's hotel, in the Adelphi, London ; tint his
business will detain him in London some
time ; that he wishes himself, and I wish on
his account, that no uncertainty respecting
the place of his abode, may delay the course
of justice ; and therefore if there be any wwr«
rant against him, you may have the opportu-
nity ot getting it properly backed, and served
upon him wiUiout delay, as he will certainly
remain in London a sumcient lenj^th of time
to enable this to be done. He is generally
upon the Royal Exchange every day at the
usual hours.
If there be no charge agamst my brother, I
think I have a dght to call upon you to sm-
so, as my commercial reputation is involvsd,
as well as his, in the present reports against
him. That yoia may not possibly make ai^
mistake, I avt you this card, with his address
in his own nana writing.
(Copy of the Card).
16 July, iros,
about 11 o'clock^
A.M.
Mr. Walker,
of Manchester,
Bate's Hotel,
Adelphi,
JLo&don.
»^"<^
.wMaViWavlMWIPIIMapi
t* There was a warrant lor high traasuiKi
executed upon this defuidant, as lo which lili»
following articles were inserled in tbe sf-
1065]
Jar a Camfiraey.
A. D. 1794.
[1066
of this kiDgdoiDi did, 00 tlie .fim <lflj of No-
vombcr Jin ^ thirty-Uiird year of the reign of
pendix to ths ongiaal editioit of this case : —
William Paul is a paper-stainer ia Manches-
ter. On the 14th of June 1793, he vas torn
from his wife and family, in con^iequeace of a
wwrrant $^fc^ by the rev. John Griffith,
charipng htra with hi^h treason, *^ by com-
passing; the death of his present mi^sty/' on
the sm oath of Thomas Dunn. Mr. Paul was
that day and night confined in an apartment
beioQjgiog to the New Bailey prison ; the next
morning he was ccnnmitted to that prison,
and orders were given to treat him as a com-
mon felon. Upon the 17th of the same
month, a commitment was made out ibr him
to the castle of Lancaster; but some davs
being allowed him to settle his books, &c. he
was not sent there until the S3rd, when he was
taken out of his cell at one o'clock in the
morning, without any previous notice.
Mr. Paul remained m the county gaol at
Lancaster, till the ensuing assises in August,
when no indictment for hi^ treason being pre-
ferred against him, he was discharged. Many
of Mr. Paul's iriends were ready to have givea
bail; but as in cases of treason, no bail can
be taken, it is hardly necessary to observe,
that by the^e means a man may be confined
from the close of one assises to the com-
mencement of another, on an accusation of
this crime; .and although it requires two
witnesses to convict a man, one only is suffi*
oient to have him committed.
Mr. Paul being indicted at the August
assizes, for a conspiracy with Mr. Thomas
Walker and others, be was held to bail with
the other defendants, and with them ho-
nourably acquitted in April last.
During ih% time which Mr. Paul continued
in the New Bailey prison, neither his wife nor
his children were permitted to see him, with-
out some of the keepers being present; and
he was forced to sleep in one of the cells of
the felons, which having been fresh washed,
there being no glass in ue windows, and the
window shutter much broken, gave Mr. Paul
a cold, which afterwards terminated in a vio-
lent inflammation in his eyes, one of which
he was in the greatest danger of loosing ; he
was confined to his bed for three weeks, and to
bis room for near three months.
This defendant has a wife and four chil-
dren.
Copy of the warrant by which Ma. Paul was
apprehended.
Lancashire, to wit. To the constables of
the township of Manchester, in the said
county, and to each and every of them.
You are hereby required, in his ra%)estv^
name, to apprehend and biin^ before me John
Orifiith, clerk, one of his majesty's justices of
the peace in and for the said ceunty, William
Paul, <^ Manchester, in the said county, pa-
per-stamer^ to answer to suoh matters as are
our said present sovereign lord the now king,
and on divers other days and times between
^—i .^i^w.— I ■ ■■■■■II — — .^-^i ■■ I.I »»—■—■. ■■ ■ ■ <
and shall be objected against him, for having
committed hkh treason in the township of
Manchester aferesaid, by compassing the death
of his present majesty. And also for divers
contempts against our said lord the king.
Given under my hand and seal, the 13th day
of June, one thousand seven hundred and
ninety-three.
(L. S.) JOBH GaiFFITR.
Copy of Mr. Paul's commitment to Lan^
caster.
Lancashhre, to wit. To the constables of
the township of Manchester, and also to
the gaoler, or keeper of his majesty's
gaol, the castle of liincaster, in the said
county t
These are in his majesty's name to require
and command you the said constables, to con-
vey the body of William Paul, of Manchester,
in the said county, paper-steiner, to his ma-
jesty's gaol tl)e castle of Lancaster, and him
there- to deliver to the eaoler or keeper
thereof. He, the said William Paul, bemg
charged before me on the oath of Thomas
Dunn, with having committed high treason,
by compassing the death of the present king,
at the township of Manchester aforesaidf.
And you the said gaoler, or keeper of the said
gaol, are hereby required to receive into your
custody in the said gaol, the said William
Paul, and him there safely keep until he
shall be thence discharged by due course of
law. Given under my hand and seal, at the
township of Manchester aforesaid, the seven-
teenth day of June, one thousand seven hun-
dred and ninety-three.
(L. S.) John Griffith.
{ There appears to have been a warrant
for high treason against this defendant issued,
but not executed :— this warrant, as well as
those before-mentioned, was issued by the
rev. John Griffith, one of his majesty^s
justices of the peace (at that time one of the
chaplains to the collegiate church in Man-
chester, since elected a fellow thereof) upon
the sole informatk)n of Thomas Dunn, and
for the same accusations which are charged
in this indictment as a couspirac)r.
In the appendix to original edition the fol->
lowing article was inserted :—
Samuel Jackson.— This defendant being
informed that a warrant for high treason was
issued against him, as well as against Mr.
Walker and Mr. Paul, remwnea with his
fiimily, who were then in the country about
five miles from Manchester, on account of
the dmgerous state of health of his wife, and
whose death was greatly accelerated by her
anxiety on this occasion. He, however, im-
mediately on receiving the information, de-
sired his solicitors, Messrs. Duckworth and
Dennett, to give notice to the rev. John
1067] 34 GEORGE III. Proeeedingt agdiui Tkoi. Wdker and oAergf [I06S
that day and the twelfth day of June then
next following, with force and arms at Alan-
Griffith, the magistrate who was said to have
issued the wanant, and to his clerk, and also
to the agents to the solicitor for the prosecu*
tion, that if the warrant was for a bailable of-
fence, he would instantly give bail, or if not,
he would appear to meet the charge at the
assizes ; which notice was accordingly given,
and his solicitors were informed that the
charee was for high treason.
After the deatn of Mrs. Jackson (in the
beginning of July), at whose funeral in Man>
Chester, the deputy constable attended by
order of the above magistrate, for the purpose
of apprehending Mr. Jackson, he still re-
mained in the country, though goins about
pd)licly, visited by his friends from l£uiches-
ter, and the place of his residence known to
Mr. Griffith.
On the 19th of July, his solitifcors gave
written notices to the rev. John Griffith, and
his clerk, and also to the agents to the solici-
tor for the prosecution, that thb defendant
would attend at the following assizes, to meet
any charee that misht be broueht against
him; ancTon the 7 th of August lils brother
gave another notice in writine to Mr. Griffith
to inform him, that he (the defendant) would
be in Manchester the next day, and the day
following. — On the 8th of Aueust, Mr. Jack-
son came to Manchester, and the next day
sent a message to the magistrate, to let him
know where he was; but not being appre-
hended, he accompanied Mr. Walker to the
assizes at Lancaster on the following day;
when the charge of high treason being aban-
doned, and^abill for a conspiracy found by
the grand jury, he gave bail with the other
defendants, to try the same at the following
assizes, and was with them honourably ac-
^ quitted.
To the assertion which the attorney-general
for the county palatine of Lancaster was in-
structed to make in his opening on the trial
and which was afterwaros attempted to be
substantiated by Dunn, in his eviaence that
the works of Paine, and many other works
of a similar tendency were read by this de-
fendant to the societies ; he has only to ob-
serve, that the whole is untrue.
II AS to the treatment of this defendant,
the following article was inserted in the ap-
pendix to the original edition :—
James Cheetham is a hatter in Manches-
ter. He was committed on the 83d day of
July 179S, to the New fiailey prison, by the
rev. John Griffith, on the oath of Thomas
Dunn, for speaking contemptuous words of
his present miijesty. He expected to be tried
at the same time (viz. at the ensuing quarter
sessions) with Benjamin Booth and Oliver
Pearsall, both of whom were charged with ex-
pressions almost word for word thesame^ but
Chester albtesald, in the eoont^of LtnoMter
aforesaid, unlawfiilly, malkioosly, and aed»-
■ — -■ -*
instead of beinc brought to trial as he expect-
ed, for which he was fidly prepared, and Ind
incurred the necessuy cSqpenses, he was,
without having any previous notice, or boi^
permitted to send to his wife or' friends^ re-
moved at one o'dock in the morning of'ttw
f 5th of July, to Lancaster castle, where he
continued ml the assizes following, braig im-
prisoned more than three weeks.
Although there was a vacant bed in the
room whm he lodged the night of his arrival
at Lancaster, he was remora) Into another
room the night after, where he was obliged
either to sleep upon the floor, or in the same
bed with the common hangman.
He was indicted at the assises in Augost
1793, for damning the king, and also for the
fore^ng conspiracy, and was bailed on both
charges. At tne assizes in April last he was
honourably acquitted of the latter indictment^
with the other defendants The former for
which he had been committed, no evidence
was brought in support of.
§ This defendant's name is Oliver Pear-
sall ; as to the treatment he experienced, the
following article was inserted in the appendix
to the ongmal edition : —
Oliver Pearsall is a native of Kidderminster,
in Worcestershire, and by trade a weaver.
He came to Manchester in June 179S, for the
purpose of working in the manu&ctures there.
Upou the Slst of December 1799, he became
a member of the Reformation society, by
which means Thomas Dunn came to know
him. In March following he left Manches-
ter, and returned to Kidderminster.
On the 39th of Juue 1793, the wife of Dunn,
accompanied by one Parker, who, Pearsall
has since learned, was a constable, and CaU
laghan an Irishman, came to him at Kidder-
mmster; Dunn's wife pretending it *was ne-
cessary for him to eive evidence at Manches-
ter, on behalf of her husband, who she said
was in the New Bailev prison upon a false
accusation, and would rather see nim (Pear-
salh than receive five hundred pounds, as his
eviaence would clear him. This Pearsall de-
clared himself ready to comply with, and
went with them to a public house, where he
was told, he should have all his expenses
paid, and should return back on the Wednes-
dav following. Previous to setting off, Pear*
sail wanted to go home to get some clothes,
which Parker refused, and then said, he had
some tackling (meaning handcuffiO in his
pocket, which he would out on him if de was
saucy; Parker never snowed any warrant,
and repeatedly refused to take Pearsall beftre
a magistrate, though several times asked to -
do so. On his arrival at Manchester, he was
carried before the rev. John Griffith, who wel*
comed him to Manchester, and asked, him if
he did not belong to the Reformation socie^^
1069]
fi^a Cmufima/*
A. D. 179*.
[1070
tkmaly conspire, ccMnbiiiey and amfederate
with each other, and also whh dircrs dis*
to which he answered in the affirmative. Mr.
justice Griffith then questioned him if he had
not seen arms in Mr. Walker's house, and if
he had not exercised men there, to both
which be answered in the negative. He was
then carried to the New Biiley prison, where
he was kept till the 5th of July, when he was
committed, and remained there till the 9th
of Aueust.
While in this prison, Parker, Dunn, and
' Calli^an, had frequent interviews with him,
the two latter instigating him to depose to
having seen arms, and to having exercised
men at Mr. Walker's. Calhighan in particular
desired him to come forward in the cause,
and confirm what Dunn had been putting to
him, observing, if he did not, it would be the
worse for him. The day after this, one of
the deputy constables came to him, and asked
him, whether he recollected what Dunn had
aaid the night before? Pearsall replied, he
recollected what Dunn had said very well,
but that it was impossible for him to recol-
lect things which had never happened. The
constable then said, that he had freauently
^aeen the shining of firelocks in Mr. Walker's
"trarehouse, as he returned home late in the
evemne ; and fiirther said, that a person was
come from Yorkshire, and had sworn to the
tnithof what Dunn had said; that he was
2>aid twelve guineas, and had returned home
with the money. Pearsall answered 4o this,
** if he has sworn fidsely, I cannot, for my
soul is concerned."
In one of these conversations Dunn said,
Pearsall seemed uneasy at the interrogations;
that they would leave him for the present,
and begged him to consider of it Pearsall
aaid, he could not consider on a false subject,
when Dunn replied, ** we will drop the sub-
ject of exercisine the men," and then began
to talk about a fetter from the Irish to the
Scotch. .
At other times, Callaghan and Dunn came
to him, givine him the same advice; the
former teUiug nim, that if he did not confirm
Dunn's testimony, Dunn was ^oing to swear
high treason agsunst him, which Dunn con-
firmed. >
He was also informed that if he would join
Dunn, it would be as eood as a pension to
him as long as he livM. At this conduct
Pearsall grew angry, and desired them to
leave the room ; oii which they said, if he
would not acknowledge these things, Uiey
wished he was at home again.
On Thursday the 4lh of July, Callaghan
and Dunn came to him again, and brouc^ht
pipes and tobacco, and a quantity of liquor.
Be was desired to drink, and smoke freely
to keep up his spirits, which he refused. One
of them Informed him» that the rev. justice
Griffiths would come to the prison that night
iwd take his examinatk^n. Aoconlingly al^ut
affected, and tll*disposed subjects of our said
lord the king, whose names are to the jurcva
seven o'clock the rev. John Griffith came^
with pen, ink, and paper. Mr. Griffith shook
hands very familiarly with Dunn, clapped
him on the back, and said he was an honest
fellow. Mr. Griffith asked if their liquor was
out, and seeing it was, he threw down a shil-
ling, and ordered the turnkey to fetch ^some
more, which was done; when it came the
rev. Mr. Griffith drank with them, and afWr-*
wards asked Pearsall, whether he reCoUecflid
anything relative to the questions Dunn had
put to him ; to which Pearsall said, that he
could not, on which thev all left the room.
On Friday evening the rev. Mr. Justice
Griffith, came again to the prison, «nd ex-
amined Pearsall as before, who answered that
he knew nothing of the kind, the justice then
told him, that Dunn had sworn against him
^Pearsall) for having damned the present king
in his (Dunn's) house ; and therefore, that
his commitment should be made out imme-*-
diatelv, which was done accordingly.
Before Pearsall was committed by Mr.
Griffith, he had of the best to eat and drink,
but afterwards he hail only the gaol sdlowance.
At the ensuing quarter sessions in July
1793, Pearsall gave notice of his intention to
take his trial on the indictment found against
him, on the charge of having damned the
king. The same day was fixM for the trials
of hnnand Booth. The expenses of the at*
tomey and coimsel were incurred, and every
thing prepared for the trial, when the defend-
ant was informed, that by a process called a
certiorari^ this indictment was removed from
the sessions into the court of King's-bench,
but was given to understand, that it was not
intended to be proceeded on.
The defendenty Pearsall, was, notwithstand-
ing this, detained in prison until Fridav the
9tn of Au^st, when Mr. Griffith wanted him
to give bail for his appearence in the Kin^V
bench. This beiug resisted bv his solicitor
as illegal, and an application being made by
him to the clerk of the peace,- for a copy of
the magistrates names attending the sessions,
for the purpose of making an application to
the court of King's-bench, to compel the ma«
gistrates to do their duty;— the rev. John
Griffith sent to let /Pearsall know that he
might be liberated without bail, upon his en-
tenng into a recognizance to appear to the
mdictment in the King's-bench. Pearsall en-
tered into the recognizance, and was liberated.
Pursuant to his recognizance, he appeared,
in the King's bench, and pleaded not guilty.
The issue was made up, out although two
assizes have since elapsed, the prosecutors
have not thought it expedienttotry bun upon
this indictment.
At the assizes in August 1793, Pearsall
went to Lancaster as a witness, to prove the
attempts which had been made to sahom
him to give false evidence against Mr, Wal-
1071] 34 GEOKGB lU. Proceedings agabut TAof. Wdher and others f^IOTS
alcrcsaid at jM^ient unknown, to overtluow
the constitution and government of tbis king.
ker. Dunn!B evidence bong still unsupported,
and likely to be destroyed by this witnese^
the prosecution against Mr. Walker for high
treason was dropped ; and Pearsall was pre-
vented from givmg evidence, by being made
a defendant in the indictment for a conspira-
cy. He was then bailed, and afterwards
liobooiably acquitted.
-It r ------ ■ ^
t As to this defendant, the following arU«
des were inserted in the appendix to the ori-
ginal edition:^
Benjamin Booth. — On the Sth day of June,
1793, this defendant was apprehended by
virtue of a warrant issued by the rev. John
Griffith, upon a charge of having distributed
a paper on the subject of war, which paper
was alleged to be seditious; for this cnarge
he was bailed upon the 19th of that month ;
and about eleven o'clock on the very same
nighty he was again taken from his wife and
children, under another warrant, signed by
the same reverend ma^strate, and was the
next day committed by nim to the New Bai-
ley prison, on the oath of Thomas Dunn, on
a charge of having ^ damned the king,'' and
saying, ** he would guillotine him if he
coukl."
At the door of Mr. Griffith's house, a per-
son who had been present during Booth's. exa-
mination, said to the constaole who was
taking bun to prison, *' Expose him to the
iury oi the populace." The constable led
him throu^ the most public streets in the
town, and R«(]uently adoressed himself to the
mob, in very inflammatory language respect-
ingBooth.
The rev. John Griffith refused, in the most
Kflitive terms, to admit this defendant to
il (which was offered), and he was confined
in the New Bailey prison until the 19th of
that month, when Mr. Griffith thought pro-
per to receive baiU*
During the gveater part of this interval.
Booth wa^ kept in a separate place; he was
locked up two hours sooner, and let out of his
cell two hours later, than the rest of the pri-
soners. The threats and temptations held
out to induce him to confirm Dunn's evi-
dence, were various and frequent. He was
told that others had done so, aod that he had
but a few hours to determine whether he
would or not, that otherwise he would most
certainly be banged, aiM that it was the only
y^y to save his wife and children from ruin.
Mi*. Paul ifbea in confinement) was shown to
him at one of the windows in another part of
the prison. Booth was informed that Mr.
Paul was committed for hieh treason, that
JjjLr. Walker and others had fled lirom the ac«
t^
^ The bail insisted upon and given, was
Bo«th in 500/. and two sureties in d50/.
each. — Qrig. Ed.
dom,as Inrlaw establidied, and to aid
assist the French, then and there bang
cusation; that in treaaoit there were no
series, all were prmcipals; and that if lie
would turn king's evidence without delsy,
and join Dunn, Mr. Griffith would nrrxle Hot
Jiispardon.
The rev. Mr. Griffith told Booth, ^ lie
wanted the great men, he wanted to pick fass
birds."
At length, by promises and threats, by b^>
ing told the parties aociised were either ap-
prehended, or had fled from the chat«s
aflainst them ; and being freauently remioMd
of the helpless situation to wnich bis wile and
children would be exposed, a promise was
wrung from him to join Dunn's evidence.
Upon Booth stating his ignorance of what
evidence Dunn had given, Dunn and he vrere
put together, that Dunn might inform him;
and oraers were given that Booth shoirid now
be better treated, and have a moderate alkrw-
ance of liquor, but not so as to make Dusm
jealous.
Booth bdng afterwards bailed, an indict*
ment was preferred against him at the enso^
ing quarter sessions^ on the accusation of hav-
ing ** damned the kmg," &c. and immedialelj
meeting the charge, tfaoi^ he might have
traversed to the following sessions, he was
tried and foand euilty on the sole testimmy
of Dtmn, aitfaotuHi Dunn was flatly oontnr
dieted by Mary Booth, the defendant's sister,
who was present when the words were said to
be spoken^ aad swore positively they were
made use of by Dunn himself, and not by her
brother.
No indictment was preferred upon tbe £rst
accusatwn, of distributing the paper, poiiit»
ing out the evils which were likely to resoH
from the war.
It is remarkable, that Dunn aconsed five or
six cMerent people of using precisely the same
otpressions respecting the- king, at difeent
times, and when not in company with each
other.
The chairman of the Manchester quarter
sessions, in passing sentence, observed, that
Booth had been fmmd guilty to the salinfoc*
tionof the whole bench, and the jud|;nentof
the court was, twelve months imprisonment
in Lancaster castle.
Benjamin Booth, Ahus imprisoned, wu
again indicted for the conspiracy with the
oUier defendants, at tbe next assizes, aad
with them acquitted on the trial. At thepe*
nod of his acquittal, more than nine months
of his imprisonnoent had eiap^.
Benjamin Booth being thus indicted, both
at Manchester and at Lancaster, was efleo*
tuall^ precluded from giving evidenee of the
practices made use of (whilst he was in prisoa)
to prevail upon bun to give false teslimsny
against some of the other defendants.
It is perhaps not unwor^y of remark, tlist '
tbe chaionan of. the Maacherter quarter
Ji^r a Cte^MM^y.
1073]
mies t<s and in open war with, our said lord
the king againat our said lord the king,
siont should aflerwards b^ one of the grand
Jury who found the bills of indictment against
the defendants in tliis trial ; he was likewise
fi>renian of the grand jurj who found the bill
of indictment against Dunn for perjury.
So well aware were the prosecutors^^ of the
mode in which Booth's declaration, m sup-
port of Dump's evidence, had been extorted
from him (which he never reflects upon but
with shame and contrition, and which he ac-
knowledges to be utterly false), that they did
not produce it on this trial, nor did it prevent
the crown from granting Booth a pardon.
After Dunn (whose conduct was reprobated
hy the whole court) was committed for per-
jury by the judge of assize, the chairman of
the Manchester ouarter sessions wrote (it is
^d) as well as toe attorney-general for the
county palatine of Lancaster, to the secretary
of state, for Benjamin Booth's pardon.
On tiie Sd of May last. Booth was set at
liberty, in consequence of a pardon, of which
the following is a copy :-*
fL. 8.) GEORGE It.
Wnereas Benjamin Booth was, at a quarter
sessions of the peace held at Manchester,
tried and convicted of sedition, and is now in
Lancaster gaol, under sentence of imprison-
ment for file same; and whereas some ia^
vourable circumstances have been humbly
represented unto us in his behalf, inducing
us to extend our grace and mercy unto him.
and to grant him our free pardon for his saia
crime; our will and pleasure therefore is,
that you cause him, the said Benjamin
Booth, to be forthwith discharged out of cus-
tody, and for so doing this shall be your war-
rant Given at our court at St. James's, the
twenty-fifUi day of April, 1794, inthethirty-
iburth year of our reign.
To our trusty and well-beloved the
chairman of the quarter sessions
of the peace at Lancaster, the high
sheriff of the said county, and all
others whom it may con^
By his majestv's command,
(Signed) Henry Duvdas.
Benjamin Booth has a wife and four small
children.
Cheetham, Pearsall, and Booth, were all
committed by the rev. John Griffith, upon
the sole information of Thomas Dunn.
On the 4th of October, J793, Benjamin
Booth, while in Lancaster castle, received a
letter from Mr. Cartwright, of Shrewsbury,
who is a surgeon and apothecary, and a non-
juring bishop, of which the following is a
copy. The reader wiU make his own reflec-
tions upon its objects and principles,
Ko. XXI.-r-Copy of Mr. William Cart-
wright's letter to Benjamiv Booth, dated
Shrewsbury, 97th September, 1793. i
VOL. XXttL
JL a 1794k [1074
in 6isa such eoemies should enter into
and invade this kingdom in a warlike and
Wh^n YOU wrote to me, soon afler the
death of bishop Price, I little suspected that
ever I should have seen your name in the
public papers, ou such an occasion as that
which has rendered you so conspicuous ; and
reduced you to that /situation which your cri-
inioal conduct has so justly deserved.
I begin this address to you in this manner,
with no otlier design than to express nty ab*
horrence and detestation of those principles
which e.xcited you to this conduct, for which'
the laws of vour country are now punishing
YOU ; and which, without sincere repentance,
leavea you obnosuous to the just judgment of
the Almighty, whose holy laws you nave so
flagrantly violated, and thereby brought a
scandal ou that sound branch of the Catholic
church, of which you were a member.
You well know, or once did know^ that uiv-
feigned allegjiance, in all civil matters, to your
rightful andiawful soverei^, is an essential
doctrine and duty of Christianity ; anti that all
coercive resistance to him and his laws, in
all cases whatsoever, and under the most try-
ing circumstances, is threatened with damna-
tion.
I am quite at a loss to conceive on what
mund you can possibly justifv or excuse your
late conduct Sure I am thai before you
could adopt the maxims and piinciples of
Paine, ana such men, you must either have
made shipwreck of faith, and virtually re-
nounced all reverence for the revealed will of
God; or lulled your conscience into a very
irreligious degree of torpor.
I thought I had sufiBcientlv exposed the
atheism of Paine's. wicked book, in that paper
of mine signed '< Phileleutherus Christianus/'
which was printed and dispersed in Manchea-
tec as a IuukI bill, in May 1791.
I grant you there is much plausible reason^
Ing in Fame's writings; nsany unsavouiy
truths, mixed with vile falsehoods, and groas
misrepresentations: but his reasoning is en-
tirely of that sort, with, wbkh the adversaigr
of souls always endeavours to deceive the uii<*
wary. However, it is such as can have no
influence, but upon thdse who have first with-
drawn their minds from that dependanoe
upon God, which is always our duty, and our
best security against the temptations of Satan,
the allurements of the worid, and the corrupt
propensities of our £&Uen and deprated na-
tura The uoisaroarv truths disseminated in
hb writings are such as, more or less, eoust
in all governments in the woiid, and aver
will, tillthere shaU be an entire' renovation
of the fallen sons of Adam. The sfwculatigns
of those who call themselves philosophen,
promise us mighty fine thines indeed. But
the world was not created by 'human wisdom,
neither can it be reformed by such means as
thoae of Thomas Paine. Eefoonation is 4^
finewQid; y«a,«Bda gpod. thing toiHiWhca
1075] S4 GEORGE IH. Pncndingn agaimt Thoi. WMer and others, [107&
hostile manner; and the said Thotnis Wal- 1
ker, George M'CuUum, John Smith, William
Paiil^ Samuel Jackson, James Cheetham,
Oliver Pearson, Benjamin Booth, Hennr York,
and Joseph Collier, m pursuance of the said
conspiracy, combination, and agreement, did
on those several days and times at Manches-
ter aforesaid, in the county aforesaid, cause.
incite, and encourage divqps disaffected ana
ill-disposed subjects to the jurors aforesaid,
unknown, to learn and practice and to be in-
structed in the use of arms and military exer-
cises, for the purpose of assisting his said ma-
jesty's aaid enemies afiunst his said mijesty,
in case they should enter into and in-
vade this kingdom in contempt of our said
lord the king and his laws, to the evil and
pernicious example of all others in the like
o^se offending, and against the peace of our
said lord ' the king, his crown and dignitjr*
And the jurors aforesaid, up<jn their oatH
aforesaid, do further present, that the said
Thomas Walker, George M* Cullura, John
Smith, William Paul, Samuel Jackson, Jambs
Cheetham, Oliver Pearson, Benjamin Booths
Henry York, and Joseph Collier, so being
such persons as aforesaid, and so contriving
and intending as aforesaid, did on the said
first day of November, in the^thirty-third year
aforesaid, and on divers other days and times
between that day and the twelfth dav of Jun«
then next following, with force and arms at
Manchester aforesaid, in the coiwty afore-
said, unlawfully, maliciously, and seditiously
conspire, combine, and confederate with each
other, and also with divers disaffected and
ill-disposed subjects of our said lord the
king, whose names are to the said jurors at
properiy set about: but the experience of
France should surely teach us the folly as
well as wickedness of all popular attempts at
it. L^t every individual strive to reform him-
self, and leave the rest to God. While he is
doing this, he is in the way of his duty : but
whoever attempts to reform his superiors, and
the governing powers by the arm of flesh,
will only fall from one wickedness to another,
and will not come into the way of righteous-
ness.
Possibly you may deceive yourself 'with a
' notion that you were doing right, in endea-
vouring to overturn the present established
System of government, because some of our
religious predecessors attempted, in the years
17 15 and 1745 to dethrone tne then reigning
family. But ^ve me leave ta tell you that
those attempts, whether right or wrong, whe-
ther justifiaole or not, were undertaken on
entire different and opposite principles to
those on which you must have engaged with
the new disturbers of the public peace. The
* former attempts were not undertaken to over-
turn or alter the constitution of the govem-
meut of this country. No ! it was a compe-
tition between a claimant to the throne, who
was thought to have been unjustly and ille-
gally dispossessed of his right, and him who
withhela that supposed right from him. That
competition, you well know, b now at an
end. The one family being as good as en-
tirely extinct, and the other having been so
long a time in uninterrupted possession^ surely
me need iK>t now hesitate which of these God
has chosen to reign over us. He has declared
^ by me kings reign." And I believe there
is not now one person of our communion who
does not recognise king George as the only
xightful kins of Great Britain, ac.
< In considexation of this unquestionable
truth, and of your late seditious and rebellious
practices, it is my duty, however painftri, to
tell you that you lie under the censure of the
greater excommunication. The consequences
of such a state I need not explain to you, any
/fiirthw than to toll you that without an ex-
emplary repentance there can be no pardon
for you either in this world or that wnicb is
to come. By an exemplary repentance, I
mean not onlv a sincere contrition, such as is
described in the cxlth lesson, page 400, of our
catechism, but also the most effectual restitu*
tion and satisfaction, which it may be in your
power to make to that government which you
have insulted, and the laws which you have
violated. And this can no other way be done
than by disclosing to a proper magistmte
everv thing which you know of seditious and
rebellious plots ; and endeavouring, not for
the sake of revenge or malice, but for the
sake of justice, and better security of the
public peace, to bring dl your associates ia
iniquity, to such punishment as the law pre-
scru)es.
Thus have I Duthfully admonished you, in
love to your soul and body too, and delivered
my own soul on this occasion. I pray God
to eiyc you a right understanding m these,
ana in all things concerning your eternal wel-
fare, and am — Your faithfiu but afflicted pas-
tor and friend.
(Signed) William Cartwrigbt.
I shall send this to you under the cover of
a (rank, directed to an old, sensible, and very
worthy friexld of mine, whom I have not seen
for above twenty-three years last. His name
is Langshaw, now organist of Lancaster. I
shall request him to give you the most effir»>
ciotts advice he can ; 1 am penuad^ it will
be good and friendly: and I believe him te
be as capable of convincing you of those delu-
sive errors into which you have fallen^ as I
am. If you have a due sense of your cnmes»
it will give me some consolation to receive a
letter from you : otherwise not.
I believe it is not permitted to persons in
your situation to send or receive letters, with-
out the inspection of the eovemor, and I have
no objection that he should see this. - 1 skali
send it unsealed to Mr. Lang^w. '
To Mr. Benfamin Booth,
Lancaster Castle.
107?1
^jw a \Ain^pTOcy*
A. D. 1794.
[1078
preseot iinkoown; to OTerthrow by fbnfe and
arms the constttutioa and government of this
kingdom, as bv law established : and the said
Thomas Walker, George M'Cullumy John
Smith, William Paul, Samuel Jackson, James
Cheetham, Oliver Pearson, Benjamin Booth,
Henry York, and Joseph Collier, in pur-
suanc^e of the said last-mentioned conspi-
facy, combination, and agreement, did, on
those sevnal davs and times at Manches-
ter aforesaid, in the county aforesaid, cause,
incite, and encourage, divers disafifected and
ill-disposed subject^ to the jurors aforesaid
unknown, to learn, and practice, and to be
instructed in the use ot arms and military
exercises, for the purpose of overthrowing by
force and arms, the constitution and govern-
ment of this kingdom as bv law established,
In contempt of our said lord the king and his
laws, to the evil and pernicious example of all
others in the like case offendinj^, and ag^nst
tHe peace of our said lord the king, his crown
and dignity. And the jurors aforesaid, upon
their oath aforesaid, do forther present tnat
4he said Thomas Walker, George M*Cullum,
John Smith, William Paul, Samuel Jackson,
James Cheetham, Oliver Pearson, Benjamin
Booth, Heniy York, and Joseph Collier, so
.being such persons as aforesaid, and so con-
triving and mtending as afcnresaid, did, on the
said irstday of November, in the thirty-third
year foresaid, and on divers other davs add
times between that day and the twelfth day
•f June then next following, witii force and
.alW, at Manchester aforesaid, in the county
aforesaid, unlawfullv, maliciously, uid sediti-
ously conspire, combine, and confederate with
each other, and also with divers disaffected
ill-disposed subjects of our s^d lord the king,
•whose names are to tlic said jurors at present
unknown, to raise and stir up an insurrection
and rebellion of his majesty's sutyects, against
his said majesty, and to aid and assist in such
' insurrection and rebellion, for the purpose of
overthrowing by force and arms, the constitu-
tion and government of this kingdom as by
law established, iacontemptof our said lord
the king and. his laws, to tne evil and perni-
cious example of all others in the like case
oiTending, and against the peace of our said
lord the king his crown and dignity/ And
the jurors aforesaid, u)K)n their oath aforesaid,
do further present, that the said Thomas
Walker, George M*Cullum, John Smith, WU-
liam Paul, Samuel Jackson, James Cheetham,
Oliver Pearson, Benjamin Booth,Henry York,
and Joseph Collier, so being such persons as
aforesaid, and so contriving, and intending as
aforesaid, did, on the said nrst day of Novem-
ber, in ihe thirty-third year aforesaid, and on
divers other days and times between that day
a|id the twelfth dav of June then next follow-
ing, with force and arms at Manchester afore-
said, in the county aforesaid, unlawfully, ma-
liciqoBly, and seditiously conspire, combine,
and confederate with each other, and also
with diyere disaffected and iU* disposed sub-
jects of our said lord the king, whose names'
are to the said jurors at present unknown^
unlawfully to overthrow the constitution and
eovemment of this kingdom as by law esta-
blished, in contempt of our said lord the king,
and his laws, to the evil and pernicious ex-*
ample of all others in the like case offending,
and aesunst the peace of oar said lord the
king, his crown and dignity.
Batt.
Witnesses Thomas Duvk.
Thomas Kinnastov.
Copy of the Indictment against Thoma$ Wal-
ker.
Lancashire 7 The jurors for our lord the king»
to wit. y upon their oath present^ that
Thomas Walker, late of Manchester, m the
county of Lancaster, merchant, being a perni-
cious, seditious, and ill-disposed person, and
greatly disaffected to our said lord the king,
and contriving, and intending to move ana
incite the liege subjects of our said lord ^e
king, to hatred and dislike of the person of
our said lord Uie king on the first day of June^
in the thirty-third year of the reign of our
said lord the king, at Manchester aforesaid,
in the county aforesiud, in the presence, and
hearing of divers liege subjects of our said
lord the king, maliciously, and seditious! v did
utter, publish, and declare, the words follow*
ing, 01 and concerning our sadd lord the king^
that is to say, ^ What are kings, damn the king
(meaning our said lord the now king), what
is he (meaning our said lord the king) to us.
if I (meaning the said Thomas Walker) had
him (meaning our said lord the king) in my
power, I (meaning the said Thomas Walker)
would as soon take his ^eaning our said lord
the king's) head off as I (meaning the said
Thomas Walker) would tear this paper," he
the said Thomas Walker, then and there tear-
ing; in pieces a piece of paper which he then
and there had, and held m his hand to the
great scandal of our said lord the kine, in con-
tempt of our said lord the king, and nis laws^
to the evil and pernicious example of all others
in the like case offending, and against the
peace of our said lord the king, his crown^
and dignity. And the jurors aroresaid, unon
their oath 'aforesaid, do further present, tnat
the said Thomas Walker, so bein^ such per-
son as aforesaid, and so contrivmg and in-
tendins as aforesaid, aAerwards, to wit on the
same day and year aforesaid, at Manchester
aforesaid, in the county aforesaid, in the pre-
sence and hearing of divers other liege sub-
jects of our said lord the king, maliciously,
and seditiously did utter, publish, and declare,
the words following, of and concerning our
said lord the king, that is to say, '' Damn the
king^' (meaning our said lord the kine) to the
great scandal of our said lord the Kinz, in
contempt of our said lord the king, and his
laws, to the evil and pernicious example of
all others in the like case offending, and
againit the peace of our said lord the kingi
1079]
ProceaSng^
his crown and digmty. .AjmI tiie jmtns ato»*
said, upon their cM\th aforesaid, do Anther fws^
sent, that tile said Thomas Walker, so beii^
such person as aforesaid, and so contimn|;,
and intending as aforesaid, afterwards, to wtt
on the same dav and year aforesaid, at Man«
Chester aforesaid, in the county aforesaid, in
the presence and bearing of divers other liwe
subjects of our said lord the king, maliciously,
and seditiously, did utter, publish, and declare,
the words following, of and concerning our
said lord the king, that is to say, " If I (mean-
ing the said Thomas Walker) had him (mean-
ing our said lord the king) in, my power, I
(meaning the said Thomas Walker) would as
soon take his (meaning our said lord the
king's) head off as I would tear this piece of
paper/' he the said Thomas Walker, then and
there, tearine a piece of paper, which he then
and there had in his hand, to the great scan-
dal of our said lord the king, in contempt of
our said lord the king, and his laws, to the
evil and pernicious example of all others in
the like case ofiending, and against the peace
of our said lord the king^ his crown and di^«
nity. And the iurors aforesaid, upon their
oath aforesud, do further present that the
said Thomas Walker, so being such person as
aforesaid, and so contriving and intendins as
aforesaid, afterwards, to wit on the same day
and year aforesaid, at Manchester aforesaid,
in the county aforesaid, in the presence and
hearing of divers other liege subjects of our
said lord the king, maliciously and seditiously
did utter, publish and declare the words foU
lowing, of and concerning our said lord the
king, that is to say *^ There ought to be no king*'
(meaning that there ought to be no king of
this realm) to the great scandal of our said
lord the king, in contempt of our said lord the
king, and his laws, to the evil and pernicious
example of all others in the like case offend-
ing, and asainst the peace of our said lord
the king, his crown and dignity*
Batt.
WitnessTnoKAs Dunit,
Copy of the Indictment against James Ckeetham^
Ltmcashire, > The Jurors for our lord the king
to wit. > upon their oath present that
James Cheetham, late of Salford, in the
-county of Lancaster^ labourer, being a pemi-
•cious, seditious^ and ilkdisposed person^ and
greatly disaffected to our said lord the now
ing, and contriving and intending to move
-and incite the liege subjects of our said lord
•the kineto hatred and dislike of the person of
xmr saia iosd the king, on the tenth day of
,June, in th^ thirty^- third year of the reign of
our said lord the king, at Manchester, in the
county of Lancaster aforesaid, in the presence
and hearing of divers liege subjects of our said
lord the kin^, did utter, publish, and declare,
the words iollowing, of and concerning our
said lord the king, that is to say ** Damn the
king (meaning our said lord the king), I
(meaning hinaself tha said James Cheethain)
#iBh he (mdaajng nor «dd lort the kii
iathe New Baikj fHson, ntftead «f __^,^
tein Booth, to the giMt seandai of oar saod
k>cd the kinc, in eonSempfof oar said lofd
the king andhis Isws, to the «fil and yefgii>
cious example of all others in the like csttse
offBnding, and against the peace of our d^d
loid the kk^, kis crown and liignlty. And
the jurors aforesaid. Upon thiif asth sfinii wtM,
do further present that the said Janes Cteet.
ham, so being such |Mrson as aforesaid, mad
so contrivinjg and intending as stftireasid, nl^er-'
wards, to wit, on the same daviuid mra^we-
said, at Msaohestar aforesaid, inlfae coonty
afwesaid, in the presaDce and healing of dtvcrv
other liege suhjeets of our said lord the king, by
whom the wotd guillotined, hersiuifVer men-
tioned, was underslood to maso put to
death; did utter, nublish, anddeolare, the
words following, or and concerning otir saiid
lord the king(tMti8to say) ** I (meaning him*
self the said J^mes Cheetham) wish he (mean*
ing our said lord the king) was guillotined**
(meaning put to death) to the great scandal of
our said lord the kins, in contempt of our
said lord the king, anif his laws, to the evil
and pernicious example of sAl others in the
like case offending, and against the peaee of
our said lord the king, his crown ana dignity.
And the jurors aforesaid, upon their oatfk
aforesaid, do further present, that the said
James Cheetham,sobeing such person as aftve-
said, and so contriving and intending as albr».
said, afterwards to wit. on the same day and
year aforesaid, at Manchester afbr^iaid, in the
county aforesaid^ in the presence toA heating
of divers other liege subjects of our said lord
the king, dki utter, publish and declsre the
words following, of and coneenung our sakl
lord the king, that is to say, " Damn the king^
(meaning our said lord the king) to the ^eat
scandal of our said lord the king, to the evil
and pernicious example of all others m the
hke case offending;, and against the peace of
our said lord the king, his crown and dignity,
Batt.
Witness, Tboxas Dvkk.
The three preceding indictments were found
by the grand jury, of which the following
is a list : —
Sir Henry Hoghton, baronet, of HoghtoOj,
foreman.
Thomas Butterworth Bayley, esq. of Hope*
Henry Blundell, esq. of Liverpool.
William Bankes, esq. of Winstanley.
Samuel Bailey, esq. of Lancaster.
Richard Crosse, esq. of Adlington.
Robert Fletcher, esq. of Preston.
Heniy Philip Hoghton, esq. of Hoghton.
Daniel Hoghton, esq. of same.
Edward Gregg Hopwood, esq. of Hopwood;
Geoffrey Hornby, sen. esq. orPreston.
William Hulton, esq. of Hulton.
Bold Fleetwood Hesketh, esq. of Rossall,
Abraham Rawlinson, esq. or£llel-halU
Williattt^CUlw^n8on, Esq. of Ancoats.
ieei]
fir 4l ConipihKjf*
Ttiomas Sftnl, esq. of UaMasifft.
RieiitTd ShMtre) eM|. ofPraMOO.
ThoimiA Stajrkie, esq. offreiichW(:N)d.
GtoTton T«H«eMi,^Mq. oriiv«rp<»l.
Panlei Wilson, esq. of Dilham Towsr.
Jc^itr.
WnHam Harper, of Everton.
Cd^rard Entwisle, of Dameud, in Hibchester.
John Jolly, ofMyihrop.
Richard Dixon, of Foulton.
John Ellison, of Liverpool.
James Pkrke, of Preesall.
Alexander Tomlinson, of Oswaldtwistle.
John Williamson, of Scotforth.
John Carter, of Hambleton.
William Culshaw, of North Meols.
Nicholas Heys, ofUphoUand.
Joseph Brown, of Potilton.
Counteljbr ihe CrMm«^Mr. La#> attorney-
general for ^e county palatine of Lancas-
ter; Mr. Wood^ Mr. Topping, Mr. Johnson,
Mr. James.
SolkUor.^Ut. White, solicitor to the Trea-
dmiuel far tAe DefendtnUw.'-^The honour-
able Thomas Erskine; Mr. Mijeant Cockcll,
Mr. Chambre, Mr. Lkiyd, Mr. Felix Vfl(U|han.
SolkUon.'-^M.eBm, Duckworth aad Deo^
tlel^ Mr. William Seddon.
The indictment havinff be«n opened by Mr.
. James, Mr: Law stated the case as follows i-^
May it please your lordship ; gentlemen
of the jury. — ^The indictment wnicn has been
read to you, imputes to the defendants a spe-
des of treasonable misdemeanor, second only
in depee, and inferior onl^^ in malignity, to
the crime of high treason itself. It imputes
to them a conspiracy for the purpose of ad-
hering with effect to the king's enemies, in
case the calamity of foreign invasion or of in-
ternal and domestic tumult should afford
them the desired opportunity of so doing — a
conspiracy for the purpose of employing
against our countiy those arms which should
be devoted to its defence ; and of overthrow-
ing a constitution, the work of long^continued
wisdom and virtue in the ages that have gone
before us, and wliich, I trust, the sober-mind-
ed virtue and wisdom of the present age will
transmit unimpaired to ages that are yet to
succeed us. It imputes to them a conspiracy,
'not indeed levelledT at the person and life of
our sovereign, but at that constitutk>n at the
|iead of whicn he is placed, and at tliat sys-
tem of beneficial laws which it is his pride and
bis duty to administer; — ^at that constitution
which makes us what we are, a great, free,
and, I trusty with a few exceptions only, a
happ^ and united people. Gentlemen, a
conspiracy formed for these purposes, and
to be effected eventually b^ means of arms ;
j7-a conspiracy which had either for its imme-
diate aim Or probable conseqaenee, the intro-
A* D. VM. [1082
tfactioninto this couAtry, upon the model of
lYance, of all the mtoeiies that disgrace and
desolate that unhappy famd, is 1^ trifaie for
which the defendants stand arraigned before
you this day ; and it is for you to say, in
the first instance, and for my lord heiisaf^r,
what shall be the result and effisct in respect
to persons, against whom a conspiracy of such
enormous ma^itude and miscnief shall be
Bubstantiated in evidence.
Gentlemen, whatever subjects of political
difference mav subsist wnonget us, I trost we
are in general agreed in venerating the great
prioeiples of our constitution, and in wish-
ing to sustain and render them porroanent.
Whatever toleration and indulgence we may
be willing to allow to difflorences in matters of
less importance, upon some subjects we can
allow none;— to the friends of France, letted
in nnity of council, inclination, and interest
with France, against the arms and interests of
our country, however tolerant in other respects,
we canafibrd no grains of allowance, no senti*
ments of indulgence, or toleration whatsoever ;
to do so, at a time when those arms and coun-
cils are directed against our political and dvil,
against not our national only, but our na-
tural existence (and at such a period you will
find that the very conspimcy now under con-
sideration was formed), would be equally in-
consistent with every rule of law and every
principle of self-preservation !— it would be
at once to authorize every description of
mischievous persons to carry their destructive
principles into immediate and fatal e^ct;
m other words, it woukl be to sign the doom
and downfall of that constitution which pro-
tects us all.
I am sure, therefore, that for the crime,
such as I have represented it to be, mv learn-
ed friend will not, in the exercise of hi^^wn
good sense, choose to offer any defence or
apology ; but he will endeavour to make the
evidence I shall lay before you, appear in ano-
ther point of view : — he will endeavour to
conceal and soften much of that malignity
which I impute, and I think justly, to the in-
tentions and actinp of these defendants.
It was about the close of the vear 179S,
tliat the French nation thought nt to hold
out to all the nations on the giobe, or rather,
I should say, to the discontented subjects of
all those nations, an encouragement to con-
federate and combine together.for the purpose
of subverting all regular established authority
amongst them, by a decree of that nation of
the 19th of November 1793, which I consider
as the immediate source and origin of this
and other mischievous societies. 1 nftt nation,
in convention, pledged to the discontented in-
habitants of other countries, its protection
and assistance, in case they should be disposed
to innovate and change the form of govern-
ment under which they had heretofore lived.
Under the influence of this fostering encou-
ragement, and meanmg, I must suppose, to
aviil themselves of the protection fend as-
lOSS] 84 6B0RGB IIL Proceedk^ offdnd Thou Walker miMen^ [108#
slstanoe tfaUs hdd out to them, this and
other daagerous societies sprang up and
spread themselTes wtthiii the bosom of this
realm.
GenUemeiiy it was about the period I men-
tioned, or shortly after, I mean m the month
of December, which fdlowed close upon the
promulgation of this detestable decree, that
the soaely on which I am about to comment,
— ^ten members of which are nowpresented in
trial before you^ — ^was formed.* Thevi|;ilance
of those to whom the administration of justice,
and the immediate care of the police of the
country is primarily intrusted, had already
prevented or dispersed every numerous as-
aembiy of persons which resorted to public-
hoittesliDr such purposes; it theref<we became
necessary for persons thus disposed, to as-
semble themselves, if at all, within the walls
of some private mansion. The president and,
head of this society, Mr. Thomas Walker,
raised to that bad eminence bv a species of
merit which will not meet with much fiivour
or encouragement here, opened his doors to
receive a socie^ of this sort at Manchester,
miscalled the Reformation Society: the name
mav, in some senses, indeed import and be
understood to mean a society formed for the
puniose of beneficial reform; but what the
real purposes of this society were, you will
presently learn, from their declared senti-
ments and criminal actings. He opened his
doors, then, to receive this society ;-— they
assembled, ni^ht after nieht, in numbers to
an amount which you will hear from the wit-
nesses: sometimes, I believe, the extended
number of such assemblies amounting to
more than a hundred persons. There were
three cQpsiderable rooms allotted for their re-
ception. In the lower part of the house,
where they were first admitted, they sat upon
business of less moment, and requiring the
presence of smaller numbers ; — ^in the upper
part, they assembled in greatec multituocs,
and read, as in a school, and as it were to
fashion and perfect themselves in every thing
that is seditious and mischievous, those writ-
ings which have been already reprobated by
other juries, sitting in this and other places,
by the courts of law, and in effect oy the
united voice of both Houses of Parliament.
They read, amongst other works, particularly
the works of au author, whose name is in the
mouth of evenr body in this country ; I mean
the works of Thomas Paine ; an author who,
in the gloom of a French prison, is now con-
templating the foil effects and experiencing
all tne miseries of that disorganizing system
of which he is, in some respect, the parent —
certainly the great advocate and promoter.
The works of this author, and many other
works of a similar tendency, were read aloud
■ ■ ' ■■■■■■ I
* The Manchester Constitutionid Society
was instituted in October 1790 ; the Reforma-
tion Society, in March 1792 ; the Patriotic,
Society^ in April 1799. Orif^.Ed.
by a person of the name of Jackson, wlio cac*
erdsed upon tbose occasions the miachievotn
fonction of reader to this society. Otbers of
the defendants had difeient fimctionsasaigii-
ed them ; some were busied in training theiia
to the use of arms, for the purpose, avow«dlj,
in case there should be eitbier a lamting of
the French, with whom we were then, I thmk,
actually at war or about to be immediately wX
war; or in case there should take place a re-
volt in the kingdoms of Ireland or Scotlandy
to minister to tneir assistance, either to sucjx
invasion or to such revolt That they met
for such purposes is not only clear firom the
writings that were read aloud to them, and
the oonversatMns that were held, but br the
purposes which were expressly declavea and
avowed by tbose who may be considexxed aa
the mouth-pieces and organs of the society
upon these occasions.
The first time, I think, that the witnen,
Dunn^ whom I shall presently vroduoe t^
you. saw the defendant Mr. walker, Mr.
Walker declared to him, ** that he hoped tbey
should soon overthrow the conatitution.''
The witness I have alluded to, was iotrodjioed
to the society bv two persons, I think of the
names of M'Callum and Smith, and who, if I
am not misinformed, have since tmken their
flight firom this country to America. The
first night he was there, he did not see their
president Mr. Walker, but <a the aecond
night that he went there, Mr. Walker met
him as he entered the door, and observing;
from his dialect, that he was a native of Ire-
land, Mr. Walker inquired of him how the
volunteers went on and said, vrith a snule,
as be passed him in his way up stairs to the
rest of the associated members, ^ We shall
overthrow the constitution by-and-by.'* The
witness was then ushered into this room,
where he saw assembled nearly to the num-
ber of a hundred or a hundred and fifty per-
sons. The room was, I understand, a large
warehouse at the top of the house ; there were
about fourteen or fitteen persons then actually
under arms, and some of those whose names
are to be found in this record were employed
in teaching others the military exendse. ^ It
would be endless, as well as useless, to relate
to you the whole of what passed at these s^
veral meetings.
Upon some occasions, Mr. Walker would
talk in the most contumelious and abominable
language of the sacred person of our sovereini.
In one instance when talking of monarchy,l]e
said, « Damn kings ! what have we to do with
them, what are they to us V* and, to ahow
the contempt in which he held the lives of all
kings, and particularly that of our own soto-
reign, Uking a piece of paper in his hand,
and tearing it he said, « If Iliad the king
here, I would cut off his head, as readily as 1
tear this paper."
Upon other occasions, others of the mem-
bers, and particularly a person of the name of
Paol^ who I beli^eve is now in court,, beid
1085]
Jw a Conspiracy*
A. D. 17M.
[1086
similar language:— damning the king; — re-
viling and deTaming him in the execution of
his nigh office; — ^representing the whole
system of our puhlic government as a system
of plimder ana rapacity; — representing, par-
ticularly, the administration of a neighhour'-
ing" kingdom hy a lord- lieutenant, as a scheme
ana device merely invented to. corrupt the
people, and to enrich and aggrandize the
mdividual to whose care the government of
that kingdom is more immediately delegated ;
•-^in short, arraigning ev^ part of our public
economy as directly productive of misgovern^
ment and 6ppression« The king himself was
sometimes more particularly pointed at by
Mr. Walker. He related of him a strange,
incredible, and foolish fable, which I never
heard suggested from any other quarter: —
** That his majesty was possessed of seventeen
millions of money in some bank or other at
Vienna, which he kept locked up there, and
would not bestow a single penny of it to re-
lieve the distresses and indigence of any part
of his own subjects.'' Many other assertions
of this sort were made, and conversations of a
similar import held, between Mr. Walker and
the persons thus assembled.
About three months aftet- the formation, as
far as I can recollect it, of this society, that
is,, about the month of March 1793, a person
of the name of Yorke — ^Yorke of Derby, I
think, he is caUed,-*arrived at Manchester,
with all the apparatus of a kind of apostolic
mission, addressed to the various assemblies
of seditious persons in that quarter of the
kingdom. He haransued them upon such
topics as were most likely to interest and in-
flame them ;--he explamcd to them the ob-
ject of the journey he was then making
through the country ;-^he said, he was come
40 visit all the combined societies, in order to
learn the numbers they could respectively
muster, in case there should be an mvasion
by the French, which was then talked of,
and is yet, I am afraid, talked of but upon
too much foundation ;— -to know, in short,
what number they could add to the arms of
France, in case these arms should be hostile-
ly directed against Great Britain itself ;— he
stated that the French were about to land in
.this country to the number of forty or fifty
thousand men, and that he was collecting, in
the different societies, the names of such per-
sons as could be best depended upon; in
order to ascertain what number in the whole
could actually be brought into the field upon
such an emergency.
When this person was present, there seems
to have been a sort of holiday and festival of
sedition : each member strove with his fellow
which should express sentiments the most inju-
rious and hostile to the peace and happiness
of their country. Dunn, the witness I have
^readyalludedto, vriUspeaktotheactualcom-
-munication of all the several persons who are
defendants upon this record m most, of the
mischievous councils which were th<h held,
and which are the subject of this prosecution.
They met during a considerable length of
time he attended (and here you will not be
called upon to dve credit to a loose and casual
recollection of a few random expressions,
uttered iipon one or two accidental occasionsi
capable of an innocent or doubtfiil construc-
tion); but he attended, I believe, at nearly
forty of these meetings; — he attended them'
from about the montti of Deeember or Ja-
nuary, down to the month of June, vfhen,.
either throueh compunction for the share he
had himself pome in those mischievous pro-
ceedings, or whatever else might be his mo-
tive— I trust it was an honourable one, uid
that it will in its effects prove beneficial to his
country,^ he came forward and detailed .this
business to the magistrates of this county.
It became them, having such circumstances-
related to them, and having it also confirmed
by other evidence, that there were numerous
nightly meetings of this sort held at stated
intervals at the house of Mr. Walker, upon
having the objects of these meetings detailed
and verified to them— it became them, I say^-
to use means for suppressing a mischief of
such extent and magnitude, it was accord-
ingly thought proper to institute this prosecu-
tion for the purpose of bringing these enor-
mous proceedings into pubhc discussion and
inquiry, before a jury ot the country, and for
the purpose of eventually bringing to condign
punishment the persons immecUately con-
cerned in them.
Gentlemen, the evidence of this person^
the witness I have mentioned, will unques-^
tionably be assailed and attacked by a great
deal of attempted contradiction ; — his charac-
ter will, I have no doubt, be arraigned and
drawn in question from the earliest period to
which the defendants can have any opportiH
nities of access, for materials respecting it«
Upon nothing but upon the effectual impeach-
ment of the character of this witness, can
they bottom any probable expectations of ac-
quittal ; — ^to that point, thereioref, their efforts
will be mainly directed. I wish their efforts
had been hitherto directed innocently towards
the attainment of this object, and that no
opportunities had been recently taken, in oc-
casional meetings and conversations, to at-
tempt to tamper with the testimony of this
witness. There are other practices, whichy
next to an actual tampering with the testimo-
ny of a witness, are extremely mischievous
to the regular course and administration o€
justice — 1 mean attempts to lure a witness
into conversations respecting the subject of
his testimonv ■ of this we have seen many
very blameable instances in the course of the
present circuit, where conversations have
Deen set on foot for the purpose of catching
at some particular expressions,* inadvertently
dropt by a witness, and of afterwards bring-
ing them forward, separately and detach^
ftt>m the rest of tiie conversation, iii orde^
to give a diffoient colpur and cotn]^exion to
1067;) 34 GSOBGE HL ProeeedUgs4{fftmi^ Thti. WJktr and Men, [1088
Ibe cftct aod cradil of the whole.
GeoUeflMDy tbeto atlttnpts we too coa»-
mooljr Oiado;— hftpf^Uy, however, for puhlic
juHiMb tb^ are oeBmon^ Mngnrreatfiti;
beceiMO they do aod muil, wilb evciy honoeiiw
abio mind, leooU upoA the party making
lhen« Private applicalkma to m penoniMia
OB^kaowaloboaa advene witneta, but to
be the verj wilnass u|ion whote ciedit the
peeeecutioa apoat nalenaUj dependa; private
copveraatioiia with aich a witoete, tor the
purfoee of geHiDg ftom him dedacatiooB
wbfcbmajr be aftengardaeppoaed in seeming
cootradictMm to bia aakno tettimooy upon
oalh, are of tbemaelvea ao difhonomrabk,
tbal, with every weU*diapoied and well-judg*
ins mindv thqr will iialiirmlly produce an
efect dirmtiiy contrary to the espectationa of
the peraooa who make tbeaa.
Imom, Motleoien, whatlheve most to
lear upon this oocasioii; I know the vigour
and eneigv of the mind of my learned friend,
wl have long felt and admired the powerfid
effisct of his various tUenta—I know the ia»
ffriueus sophistry by which he can mislead^
and the mscinadoa of that eloquence by
which he can subdue the minds or those to
whom he addresses himselC— 1 know what he
aaa do to-day, by aeeing what he has done
upon man; oiiier occasions before. fiut» at
the same time, gentlemen^ knowing what he
i^ I am somewfiat consoM in knowing you.
I have practised for several years in this
place ; I know the sound discretion and judg-
ment by which your verdicts are general^
governed ; and upon the credit of that ex*
perience. I trust that it will not be in the
power or my friend, by any arts he is able to
employ, to seduce you a single step from the
sober paths of truth and justice. You will
hear the evidence with the attention which
becomes men who are deciding on the fote
of others. Ifthese defendants be innocent,
and iny learned friend is able to substantiate
their innocence, to your satisfaction, for God's
sake kt them be acquitted; but if that inno-
cence cannot be dearljr and satisfactorily es*
tablished, I stand here interested as I am in
common with him in the acquittal of inno*
cence, at the same time however demanding
the rights of public justice against the ^ilty.
It imports the safety of yourselves, — it im*-
ports the safety ol' our country,'— it im«
ports the existence and security of every
thing that is dear to us, if these men be not
innocent, that no considerations of tender-
ness and humanity, — ^no considerations of any
sort short of what the actual abstract justice of
tlie case may require, should prevent the
hand of punishment firom falling heavy on
them.
Having, therefore, gentlemen, nven ^ou
tills short detail and eKphmation of the prin- '
cipal facts which are about to be laid before
jQu in evidence, I will now ckee the first part
of the trouble I must give you. I shall by«
a«d-by,iribea my learned friend baa adduced
that evidence by which be will attempt to
aaaail the rhararter and credit of tlie principal
witaeas for the prosecution, have an opporto*
nity of addressing you again ; and, I trust, m
the mean time, whatever attention jin amy
be disposed to pay to the exertions of those
who wdl labour to estabhsb the innocenre of
the persons now arraigned before you, thai
you will at the same time, steadily bear in
mind the duties which you owe to youraehrea
and to your country; — ^recollecting, as I am
sure you will, that we all look up to your
firmaesaand integrity at this moment^ for the
protection of that constitution from which we
derive every blessing we individually or collec-
tively eiyoy.
EVIJ>EKCB rom TBB CBOWV.
l%fmat Dunn, sworn. — Kiaminffd by Mr.
Wood.
I believe you are a weaver, and liveat MLan-
Chester? — ^Yes.
Were youatamr time introduced to any
society at Mr. Wauwr'a house there —Yea I
was
Do you recollect when it was? — ^I believe
in the latter end of September in the jear
179«.
Whom were you introduced by >'^MK^*
lum and Smith.
What was this society called ?--The Relor^
mation socie^.
What b become of M<CalhnB and Snutb?
—I cannot tell; the last time I saw tben^
they told me they were going to AoaericsL
What number of people might there be
when you were first mtrodued ;-'^metiiifeea
there were more, sometimes less ; I canmot
tell the exact number.
How many do you tliink there were the
first time when you were introduced by
M'Callum and Smith ?->-Perbap5 fifty or sixty .
Were you all in the same room, or ia difie*
rent rooms ?-^In different rooms.
How many different rooms might you be
in ? — In two as for as J can recollect, 4haa
nieht
What was going forward in these dtfieseao.
rooms ?--As mr as I could see there were po-
litics spoken of^ and other men were leanuDg
disciplme.
What had they to leant their ^iy4pllnr
with?— -Firefocka.
How many might there be leaiaing their
discipline ? — About six or seven.
Was that in the room in which ihmj were
talking politics ?-*No, in a different room.
Do you recollect what sort of politics wicie
talked?— They were reading a paper; I oam-
not exactly tell the words ; the whole cf the
meetmg was entirely with respect to a icfiwi-
mation in parliaflptent; the motive vraa «i»-
tirely that, as far as I eould undtfstaad.
Didyott Mgr the motive waa eatitel^ fbt^i
1089]
Jor a Conspiracy*
A. D. 1794.
[1090
'—Yes, as far as I could understand ' it that
night.
llow long might you be there that night }
— ^I cannot recollect the time : I never stop-
ped above an hour or two there, my employ
called, me that I could not come there before
eight o'clock ; I commonly went back again
to get home again about ten.
When was the next time you were there ?
•*-I went there the Monday following.
Was Monday the day of meeting ?— Yes,
the particular day.
Did you see Mr. Walker at that time ? —
^bt the first day I did not ; I saw him the
second time.
Where did you see him ? — I knocked at his
door, and I met him at the door within the
house.
What did Mr. Walker say to you .^—He
"wanted to know my business. I told him I
.wished to go to the society ; he said he per-
ceived I was an Irishman; I said yes I
was ; he said, had I any account from Ireland
•lately, and how the volunteers were going
on ^ I tokl him I thought . thev were goins
on very prosperous; upon that he just waved
his hand, and said, we would overthrow the
constitution by-and-by ; upon that I went up
•to the society room : there was a candle and
candlestick in every passaee up the stairs.
Did you see any body there ? — Yes, a great
many people.
How many do you suppose there were at
that time ? — I think there mij;ht be above a
hundred and fifly there that night.
What were they ^doing? — Some one thing,
some another, there were about fifWen or six-
teen under arms.
What were they doing under arms ? — Go-
ine through the manual exercise.
Was there any body there to instruct them
in it ? — O yes, one Oliver Pearsall.
Did Mr. Walker come among you ? — Yes,
Do you remember one Samuel Jackson ? —
Yes.
Was he there at this time ? — I do not know
but he mieht come there,
Do you know wheth,er he was there or not?
I actually cannot tell whether I saw him there
at that time or not.
Was there any thing done at that meeting
except learning the exercise ?— No.
How long might you stay that nig^t?-^
Not very long, I never stopped very long.
Did you go again after that? — ^Yes, very
often.
^ Did you sec Mr. Walker there ? — ^Ycs^ every
night; I never missed Mr. Walker but one
night.
Did you ever hear Mr. Walker say any
thing relative to what was going forward
there about these people learning tne use of
arms ? — I do not know what you mean.
You have said, there were people there
learning their exercise ?^Ycs.
Have you heard Mr. Walker say for what
purpose It was ?— Yes I have.
VOL. XXIII.
What did he say?-— I have heard him say
so far as this, that it was his intention and
the desien was to forward and to aid the
French, n they would land here.
Do you know Cheetham ?— Yes, very well.
And Booth ?— Yes,
Did you see them there ? — ^Yes.
And Paul ?— -Yes, I saw him there
Did you see them there frequently, or only
once or twice? — Frequently.
Did you see Collier there ?— I did.
Have you ever seen Jackson at any of these
meetings.*— O yes, he was a very great reader
in politics.
Did he read to the people that were there }
—Yes.
What sort of books might he read?-—'
Faine's Works, and a man, I forget htm noW,
and Cooper's Reply to Mr. Burke's Invective,
and other matters; he always had something
new.
Was it declared what was the intent of this
societv ? — I absolutely just will inform you,
candidly, in my opinion, as far as I can learn,
when I came to imderstand myself properly,
that it was to overthrow the whole constitu*
tion.
Did you understand it so ? — I understand it
so now, but not at that time.
What did you understand then was the ob-
ject and design of this meeting ? — I understood
at that time that it was to serve poor people.
How were the poor people to be servea ?—
By association together, I thought, and to
have so far as this to be neighbourly, and no
further ; 1 thought so.
Did you ever hear any thing said about the
Irish or the Scotch ? — ^Al what time ?
At any of those meetings ? — ^Yes I did.
What was said about them ? — I recollect to
hear a letter read, an address from the United
Irishmen to Scotland.
Who read that?— Mr. Paul I think, to the
best of my recollection ; it Was either he, or
Jackson; but however, Mr. Paul came out
with these expressions, which I will relate to,
the whole court ; the matter stood thus, when*
the letter was read I cannot say, whether he,
or Paul might read it himself, I cannot
pretend to say, but Mr. Paul ssud, that if ever
we should have a revolt, it would be fron^ the
Irish; he says, I have property in Ire-
land myself, and he wondered the Irishmen
there mentioned did not exert themselyes
more than ^y did do ; I happened to be the
very next man to him, I said I am an Irish*
man myself; he said, I know you are, he said,
if ever we should have a revolt, it should be
through the Irish'; they have sent a deputy
to Ireland as a king ; damn him, sud he, and
all kings.
Do you remember Mr. Yorke— Henry
Yorke f — ^Yes I do ; I will not pretend to say
that I should know die man; I never saw
him but one nieht for about an hour.
Whom was ne introduced by.?— By Mr.
Thomas Walker.
4 A
1091] 34 GEORGE m. Proceedings agaimt Thos. Walker and dkere^ [1092
• Wbat was he introduced for ?— It WM that
▼ery night that he happened to come, it ha]>-
pened to.be very thin of people; but howso^
ever he was introduced, and took by his arm
into our place ; he was introduced as a gentle-
man of tne same principles ; and all hands
were put up that he should be the chairman.
And did be take the chair ? — ^He did.
What did he say to you ?— He mentioned
he was glad to see so many loyalists ; he was
glad to see so many friends; hehadiustcome
from Sheffield ; he said he was only a short
time from France; that he lay a fortnight in
Paine's house in Paris. At this time there
were different opinions with respect to whe-
ther they should draw up a petition to recom-
mend for a' refbrm ; he said, there was that
heisht of petitions [describing it] from Scot-
land and other parts.
Had he those petitions with him ? — No» he
told us it was so in Sheffield, different copies ;
he said nothing will do but a reform— a re-
formation then was clapped — he said, that he
was going through the three kingdoms, to see
what aid they could have to assist the French,
if they should land here.
Mr. Ertkine, — Repeat that over again. -^To
aid and assist, to know the aid that might be
for the French.
Mr. Wood. — ^Did he say any thing about the
number of French that might be expected ? —
Fifty thousand.
Were there a great many members present
that night? — Not a great many, I cannot say
the exact number ; Uiere might be about fifly,
It was a very wet night,, I recollect that.
Was there any exercises learned that night ?
— yes, there was.
Hotr many different meetings might you
attend in all, think you ? — I dare say forty or
fiiW, I can be safe upon that.
Do you remember Benjamin Booth's being
taken into custody?— I do.
Did vou apply to the society upon that oc-
casion r— I oia.
What was your application for him ?— To
get him some money.
Did you get any money for him?— There
was some money got for him that night.
Do you rememMr being there at any other
time, when there was any conversation about
the king ? — Many times ; I do not suppose
there was any night but there was something
of that kind.
Recollect something that was said about
the king. — Upon what night ?
When any thing was said about the king.
— I remember bemg there one night in par-
ticular, when Mr. Thomas Walker was speak-
ing with respect to war ; he disapproved of
the war entirely, and he thought the ministry
was highly to blame, and the whole to involve
us in a war. That he had seventeen million
of money in the bank of Vienna.
Who had seventeen million of monev ? —
The king, in the bank of Vienna, and he
would not give one penny to serve the poor;
damD him, and all kings. He hid a bit of
paper in his hand ; he said he woidd as noam
take his head off as he would thal| and be
tore the paper.
Do you recollect hew many people were
present then? — ^I caanot pietendtosaybow
inany there were.
Did you hear any thing said that nigbt
about Ireland ?— I do not recollect I did.
Did you hear him at any other time aav
any thins abo^t Ireland ? did you hear Wil-
liam Paid say any thing?— I mentioned thai;
I will say it over again, if you please.
Do so.— There was ahaddpess of the United
Irishmen to Scotland.
You said that before; do you remember
being at a meeting afkr the death of the lale
French king ? — Yes.
Who was there then?— *>A good many.
Was Collier there? — ^Yes,lie came in, we
were discoursing the matter, and all r^oidiig
upon it; he came into the place ; he tnou^it
he was the first, in one sense^ to announce to
the company that it was so ; ne nassed round,
he damned him, and wished all kings were
served so.
Do you remember whether Jackeon re-
commended any thine to the meeting ? — He
recommended every thing to be very candid^
and keep every thing very secret, that we
should be unanimous one to another.
Did you go openly and publicly to Mf.
Walker's house?— No, latterly we went tbesB
as private as possible since.
Which door did you go in at ? — ^At the back
door.
Since what time was it that you went pri-
vately ? — Since it was known so publicly, us^t
we were called Painites, when we were turned
out of the public-houses, that we could not
meet there.
Then you went to Mr. Walker's ?-*Yes, he
opened that house for us.
What door did you go in at? — ^The back
door in general; I never went in at the iront
door in my life, but at the second time.
Did others ^ in at the back door or not?
— Some went m at the front, some at the back
door.
What were you afraid of? — I was afkaid, as
much as any thins, of the constables.
Do you know wnether they were watching
you or not? — I knew they were.
What constables were watching you ? — The
differentconstablesof the town; I think the
deputy of Salford was watching us as much
as any body; Mr. Walker sent out difierent
men to watch them ; there are men in the
bar, that if they would speak the truth, know
they went out to watch them.
J%ema» Dunm, •^ Cross-examined by Mr.
Enkine.
What is your christian name?— Thomas
Dunn.
Whv do you call it vour christian name ?-^
I was brought up by that.
1093]
for a Contjjtrtttg,
A. D. 1794<.
[1091
. Were you evler chmtened ?— I hope so.
- Then you forgot that circucnstance for-
inerly--do you hear me ? — ^Yea.
You forgot that circumstance once of vour
baying been christened. — Have I f how long
since?
Do you remember .ever haying been asked
the question? — I remember you asked me
^hat my name was, and I answered you that
my name was Thomas Dunn.
Were you never asked at any other time,
and by any body else ?•— Veiy well, and sup-
pose I choose to tell this or that.
But you happened to be upon your oath at
the time I am speakinjg of? — I am speaking
now, that my name is Thomas Dunn, and
upon my oath I am speakine, I know what
you are upon Mr. Erskine ; I tell you in this
place that I defy vou, though the learned Mr.
Crskine is come down here to insult me.
Mr. Justice Heath. — You must behave pro-
perly.— I have served his majesty for years,
and would serve him to-day ; is Mr. Erskine
to disprove my name ?
Mr. Justice Heath. — You must not put
yourself in a passion, but behave decently.
Mr. Erskine, — I wish this worthy gentle-
man may be left to himself, subject only to
2 our lordship*s interposition when he misbe-
aves. You will find I am not so easily put
out as you fancy ; therefore I will resume my
question again : Were you never asked, when
you were sworn to speak the truth, whether
you had been christened or not^ and what
answer did you give ? — ^No, never m my life.
Do you mean to swear, that such a ques*
tion was never put to you in a court of justice,
vrhen you came forward to convict one of
tbese innocent men that you are now a wit-
ness against ?^Innocent!
That his lordship and the juiy are to try.
Was that question ever put to you, and did
you give it any, and what axiswer ? I am in
no hurry ; his lordship will have the goodness
ta wait for you. — ^If you will speak the words
over again.
Were you never asked, when sworn upon
the gospels to speak the truth, whether you
were christened or.no, and what answer did
you ^ve? — I tell you I never was in my life.
Never was what ? — I never was asked whe-
ther I was christened or not*
You can read, I take it for granted ?^No, I
can neither read nor write.
There is somethine wrote up there [opposite
the witness box], wnich otherwise x would
have recommended to your perusal? f — I am
quite an illiterate man.
Who was it that told you I was come down
* When Beiyamin Booth was convibted at
the Mioichester sessions, upon Dunn's sole
evidence, Dunn was asked if he had ever been
bapjdsed ; to which he replied in the negative.
-^i)rig. Ed.
t ^Thou shalt not bear false witness
agsdnst thy neighbour.'^— ^^. £<j.
here for the purpose of insulUng you ? — ^What,
Mr. Erskine.
You seem perfectly fomiliar with my name.
— ^Yes, and I know your person too.
Who told you that? — No gentleman here
told me.
How came you to know? — I was acquainted
the night before last where you lodged at
Preston.
Who told You» so ? — ^The landlord, that you
and Mr. Walker were there together.
You never knew any thing of me before
that ? — O yes, I saw you before ; I know more
of you than you fancy.
Did you ever see mc before or oot?-^ saw
your picture.
That is all?— Yes.
Was that all you meant when you said you
knew more of me than I fancied? — No, I
could tell you more. [Here Mr. Justice Heath
interrupted Mr. Erskine by saying we have
nothing to do with this.]
It was in the month of September you first
went to this meeting? — I do not know but it
might.
Do you mean to swear that it was ? — No, I
I do not mean to swear about it.
Do you know what month it was in ? — ^No.
Do you know what year it was in? — ^la
1799.
Do you remember the riot at Manchester?
—Yes.
When Mr. Walker's house was surrounded
and attacked? — ^I remember to have heard
of it.
Was it before or after that ? — ^AAer.
You are certain of that ? — Very certain.
The first time you were at this society was
aficr the riot?— Yes.
How long do you think it might be after
the riot P some week^, was it not? — I think
it was a few days.
Are you quite sure it was after the riot? —
Yes,
And you .think about a few days ? — ^Yes.
Which society did you belong to ? — ^Thc
Beformation Society.
Were you elected into it, or did you go
upon the invitation of any body ? — ^1 went
upon the invitation of one Smith and
M'Callum.
Nobody else knew you there, of course^
that constituted this societ^r ? — ^I knew two or
three of them when I went in.
The rest were strangers to you ? — Yes.
So much so, that you did not even know
their names, nor they you ? — ^I knew them by
sight ; their names I did not know.
At the next meeting you saw Mr. Walker ?
^Yes.
At the door of his house, I think you tell
us, you met him. Was he acquainted with
you, or you with him ? — I never saw the man
m my life before, not to know him.
He found out that you were an Irishman
by your toneue, of course ? — ^Yes.
And aakea your business ?— -Yes.
1095] 34< GEORGB Ui. Proceedings agaimst Tkos. Walker and others, [1096
You told him you were going lo the society ?
—Yes.
Were Smith or M'Calkim with you at that
time ?— No person but myself.
Then Mr. Walker knew nothing of you but
what you told him ? — ^Just so.
He asked you whether you had heard from
Ireland lately about the volunteers ? — Yes.
And immediately upon that he rapped out
what you told us' a little while ago about the
constitution ?— Yes.
And then you went to the society, and Mr.
Yorke took the chair ?^It was not that night
that Mr. Yorke took the chair.
How long after was it that Mr. Yorke took
the chair ^ — A very little, time afler.
What passed the night of the day you saw
Mr. Walker? — Nothinc transpired more than
was customary in the place.
You said it appeared to you the object of
the meeting was a reform of parliament for
the benefit of the poor ? — ^I thought so at the
first go off, or I should never have joined it.
You were not a man of those bad princi-
ples, were you ? — I do not know what you
may call bad principles.
You were not a man that would wish to
overthrow the constitution, were you ? — ^No,
I absolutely was not never to overture it ; I
think we never could have a better.
So I think too. Then you always were of
that mind ? — Yes, I was always of that prin-
ciple.
That it would be better to reform our con-
stitution by petitions to parliament to reform
it, than to overthrow it ? — ^Yes, but I never saw
a design of that in our society.
You never saw a design to overturn the con-
stitution?— No, I never saw any design, or
the least motion moved to petition parlia-
ment for a reform.
How many times did you attend ?*I can-
not tell the number ; but I dare say forty or
fifty.
During all the time you met, what do you
believe was the intention of these people? —
I believed at the first go off, that it was for a
reform ; that a petition might be sent up to
parliament, for a reform in parliament ; then
1 perceived every thing that was to overthrow
the constitution.
How soon did you find out this ?«-I forsook
it as soon as ever I found it out.
When you found that they did not mean a
petition to parliament, you determined to have
nothing more to do with it after that ?—No.
Then how came you ever to go again,
when Mr. Walker, who was at the head of it,
told you before, when you went there the se-
cond time, that he would overthrow the con-
stitution by-and>by ? — ^I did not <x)noeive the
word ; I was not absolutely up to that word ;
I did not know the meaning of the word, till
Jate,
• So, when he asked you how the volunteers
were jgoing on, and you told him, very well,
he said, we shall overthrow the constitution
by-and-by ; what did yoii think he meant ? —
I dkl not know what he meant ; I thought
we mieht have a refonn ; that was wiuat T
wanted.
You thought when Mr. Walker said, «pb
shall overthrow the constitution by-and-fay,
that he meant a reform ? — ^I did indrad^ upon
my oath.
When you heard him sav, that he woold
think no more of cutting the king's bead xtS,
than he would of tearing a piece of paper,
you still thought he was perfectly friendly to
the constitution? — A letter was read with re-
spect to the king of France ;.I did not know
but he might be guilty? they had every infor-
mation from France.
I am not talking of the king of France. —
No, I am speaking that there were letters
every night tnat the society met, coming from
France. I thoueht he was perfectly ri^nt.
I am not speakins of the king of t'rance,
but of our king. When you heard Mr. Wal-
ker say, that he should think no more, as
you tell us, of cutting the king of England's
head off, than of tearing a piece of paper, how
came you to go afterwards?— Many things
might induce me.
You were always a friend to the king and
constitution?— Yes, I alwavs served his ma'
jesty, and will serve him still.
And always thought, till you left the so-
ciety, that they were people that meant well
to government, and meant to reform ? — Yes.
You havinff served the king by sea and
land, bavins lought for him, and being ready
to fight for him i^ain, how came you to eo
within the walls otthat place, after hearing ]£r.
Walker make use of those expressions ofiiim,
and hearing those other persons talk in the
manner you say that they did, of your own
sovereign ? You attended forty or £3ty times
after that, you say ? — Suppose I did, peiba|is I
went there to learn ? I do not know wtiat I
might do.
After you had been present, and heard, ac-
cording to your own account, abominable
treason against the chief magistrate of the
country, your own gracious sovereign, tou
went there to leani, did you ? Now when
you heard Mr. ' Yorke say he was going
through the three kingdoms, to know what
force could be collected among the difieiesl
societies, to bring in the French, and to aid
them, if the French landed, how came you to
go to this place as a lover of your king and
country ? — I own myself in a fault to attend
them.
You said just now, you thought at fird
going off they were good people, and you
never left them till you found the contrsjy;
now did you leave them, did you voluntafily
fo and give any information about what yon
new in this place, or did you not coDtin«e
with the socie^ as you becan it, till you were
taken up and put in custo^ ? — I was not put
in custody.
Were you taken up ?— Yes.
1097]
for a Can^piraeif*
A.D. 1794.
1098
Yon wece amstad ?— Tes.
Did you ever open your mouth, friend as
you were to your King, and a lover of your
country, after you heard these people damn-
ing the king every night for months, that
the chairman stated he would go round and
collect force to destroy his majesty, and bring
in the French, did you ever utter one syllable
of this till you were taken up and arrested? —
I was arrested, but not put m custody.
Were you not carried oefore a magistrate ^
— ^I was ; I will acknowledge every thing that
la lawful and Just.
So, all this time you were a perfect &K)d
friend to your king and country ?--I had an
opinion quite different a long time before.
In what ?— Against what I saw ; I did not
like the French; I think if they were to come
here, if we had the same as thev are getting
in France, we should be verv bacf.
So we all think ; so you always did ? — I did
not always; not for some little time, a very
little time.
I suppose you stayed in the society a great
while after you saw all this ? — No, I did not ;
there was one or another hanging after me to
belong to the society.
Dia not you stay in the society, and attend
the meetings, till you were taken up for dis-
tributing a paper? — ^It was a considerable
time before that.
Ilad you never given an account of any
thing you are giving to-day, till after you was
taken up and earned before a magistrate? —
You were never in prison ? — No, never in
my life.
Nor threatened to be imprisoned ?'— No.
What were you taken up for? — were not
you threatened to be imprisoned for distri^
buting a hand-bill, and were not you actiudly
in cu&tody ? — ^What kind of hand-bill ?
No matter what knid of hand-bill ; were
you not taken up and carried before Mr. Gri^
fith?— Yes.
Do you mean to say you were never in pri-
son upon that? — ^No, he gave me any liberty
I chose.
Allowed you to go where you pleased P — ^Yes.
Then you never were committed, were
you ? — ^No*
Were not you in the New Bailey ?— Yes.
How long ? — ^A considerable time. *
And yet not a prisoner ?— I walked in and
out as I pleased.
How came you to choose to be there ; what
were you there for ? — I was in dread.
Of what?— ^f the opposite party; I was
in doubt whether they would not destroy me.
And so you walked out when you pleased ?
— Occanonally, when I saw my own oppor-
tuniQr.
You might have gone away where you
would?— <>rtainly I might.
fiow much drmk had you the day you
^ot into prison, before you made your con£M-
ston P^i mi^t have tome drink. *
Who gave it you?— My own pocket.
It was your own money, was it? — ^Yes.
Nobody else gave you any?— No, upon my
oatii; that is plump.
Nobody gave you any shrub ?^Not that
day.
Who gave you the shrub the next day? — .
Suppose a gentleman was so friendly as to
give me a gmss of shrub, is that any thing f
I am not finding fault with it. Who was
it ?— I do not know whether that is to be an-
swered or not.
Mr. Law. — ^Yes, it is.
Mr. Erikine,'-4. do not wish to press the
gentleman.
I got a glass of shrub, certsdnly; I do not
suppose that is any material matter.
Mr. Justice Heath. — ^You have nothing to
do whether it is material or no ; answer the
question.
I got a glass of shrub from Mr. Griffith's
house, to be sure. *■
Tell me whether I misunderstood, you, or'
no, that you had served the king, you ^wish to
serve him, you love htm as every subject ought
to love him, and that you heard Hi these ex->
pressions of danger to his authority mentioned
in this place, then you must necessarily have
thought Mr. Walker a very dangerous and
wicked man from thisP — ^I always thought
him a good man.
Not after that, did you ?— Yes.
What ! after you heard him say that he
would think no more of breaking the oath
which he had sworn to the king, that you-
think hitn a good roan after that ; then you
think him a good man now, perhaps? — I
hope there may be a reformation m him.
You thought him then^ no doubt, and think
now, that he is a very wicked man ; but you
hope, as every good man, should, that there
may be a reformation in him } — ^That is my
hope.
Have you always been of that way of think-
ing ; it is your wish he should reform ; you
are conscioos of his wickedness; is that so?
You know, if that be true, you have done
nothing more than your duty to God and your
country, in the oa^h you have taken to-day,
and the oath you took before the grand jury,
you know that. — 1 know that very well.
You know you are bound to do it by every
thing that is sacred ; if that be so, give me*
leave to ask you how you came to be desirous
of askins pardon of Mr. Walker for having
wroneed hnn, for having sworn falsely against
him, oelieving him to be what you tell my
lord and these gentlemen now: you never
perhaps asked him pardon for the oath you
took before the grand jury ? — ^Never in my life.
You never went down upon your knees
before him, and begged for his forgiveness for
* the crimes which you had committed to his
I prejudice? — Never; nor I never will.
I You never said, did you, that you could
never sleep until you had done him justice,
and that^ou were determined to go that night
to £nd bun out?— No^ never in my life.
1099]
Proceeduigi agmtui
Then, of course, it is nottraey tint you
irent down upon your knees, that you wept,
and held your hands before your faoe^ when
you confessed the perjury that you had com-
initted? — ^I do not know what you may say;
you may say just as you please.
It is all a falsehood, and an invention of
mine. I came down here to insult you, and
am keeping my word.— Yes.
You never said that Mr. Walker never had
been guilty of any of those crimes that you
had imputed to him ? — ^No, I never did.
It is entirely fidse ? — ^I sJlow it to be false,
the greatest fiusehood that ever was eipressed
lu a court.
Have I understood you right, that three of
them had damned the king, at the early parts
of the meeting, Mr. Paul, Mr. Walker, and
Mr. Jackson ?— I do not recollect
Then do you not recollect that Mr. Jack-
son or Mr. Paul, damn'd the king?— Yes, I
do Teiy well.
Mr. Collier damn'd the king?— Yes.
Let us hear what he said. Collier is a good
deal eiven to swearing, is not he?— I never
heard him in my life swear before that
What did he say? — He came in, and walked
round, and said, he is guillotined ; damn him,
and all kin» ! I wish they were all guillo-
tined ; I wish they were all served so, he said.
nomot Dvnn.— Re-examined by Mr. Wood,
Were you introduced to Mr. Walker and his
brother at any time lately ?— Yes, I was.
When was that?— It was, I think, a fort-
niffht this day.
Who was It that brought you to them ? —
OneTwiss.
Who is he ? — He lives close by him.
Is he a servant of Mr. Walker's? — ^He
work^ for him, I think.
When you were brought there to Mr. Wal*
ker, what did they say to you ?— They did not
say a great deal ; only two or three words
passed; Richard Walker said he wondered I
should deviate from my former principles,
what he had taken me to be.
Was there only Thomas Walker there, and
Richani Walker, and Twiss?— I do not recol-
lect any more. There were some words in
the indictment, he said, that were not right,
and I corrected them the next day.
You mean the information I suppose.
Mr. Serjeant CockelL What has Richard
Walker to do with Mr. Thomas Walker ?
Mr. Wood. Was Mr. Thomas Walker
there?— He was.
Mr. Ertkine, I have no ol^ection to your
askine him any thing about Richard Walker.
Did you never go by the name of Litch-
field ? — No, never.
Where were these arms placed? — ^In the
warehouse.
Mr. Wood* How high was the warehouse?
*— Three or four stories nigh.
At a considerable heisht f •— Yes.
Could they shoulder their anas in it ?— Yei.
Mr. Enkine, PM^y near as hig^ as ibis
place ?— Not quite.
Thomas Kinnasian sworn. — Examined by
Mr. Topping.
You are, I behevei the deputy-constable of
Saltbrd ?-Yes.
And have been so some time? — Some
years.
Do you remember at any time in the
months of January and February last watch-
ing about the house of Mr. Thomas Walker ?
—Yes, in the months of January and Febru-
aiy 1793, 1 dkl.
You watched as a constable, for the purpose
of seeing who went in and out there ? — I did.
At wliat time of the nig^t have you used to
watch there? — ^I went a little after six, and
generally stayed till nine.
Did you watch repeatedly during these
months? — ^Yes, I went frequently, once or
twice a week.
Upon the nights that you have used to
watch there, once or twice a week, whom
have you seen go into Mr. Walker's house ^
— ^I saw a great number that I did not know.
I saw the utte witness, Dunn, gp in.
Have you seen M'Callum go m ? — ^Yes.
Did you know John Smith ? — ^No.
Do you know William Paul ?^Yes, welL
Have you seen him go in ? — ^Yes.
Have you seen Samuel Jackson? — Yes.
Cheetham?— Yes.
Oliver Pearsall ?— Yea^ I did not know him
at that time ; I have since known his name.
Beqjamin Booth?— Yes.
Did you know Henry Yorke? — ^No.
Do you know Dr. Collier?— He lives next
door to Mr. Walker.
You do not recollect whether you have seen
himor not?— No.
Have you seen these people repeatedly go
into Mr. Walker's upon the nights you have
been watching? — I nave, some of them many
times.
Which door had they used to go in at? — ^At
the front door.
Have you seen them come out? — Yes, I
have seen them come out.
How had they used to come out? — ^At the
same door.
How were they admitted ? — ^A very gentle
tap at the door; there appeared to me to be a
servant attending at the ooor, who seemed to
know their faces perfectly well.
How long had they used to renudn there ?
— From the time I saw them go in, to the
time of their coming out, has been more than
two hours ; they sometimes came out and
went in again.
And sometimes stayed a longer, sometimes
a shorter time, I suppose? — ^Yes.
Have you seen various other persons besides
the persons vou mentioned, go there ? — ^I saw
a great number of persons whom I did not
know.
How many in number do you think you
1101]
Ji(r a Cmtfiracy*
liave teen go in of to evening ?— I believe I
Iwve seen more than fifty^
Were tliese tradesmen of the town that you
-were acquainted with, or of the lower class of
people ?~-A great majority seemed to be of
the lower class of people; they appeared to
tne a great majority to be mechanics of the
lower order.
Did you never see them come in or go out
at any door but at the front door?— I have
seen people come out, but they might be hb
servants out of the warehouse, come out of
the back door.
You have seen people come out at the back
door?— I have, but they might be Mr. Wal-
ker's servants for aught I know.
Thomoi Xmnosf Oft— cross-examined by Mr.
Serjeant Cockell,
Did you ever knock at the door ?— I never
did.
Where might you stand at this time— you
are rather hard of hearing ? — ^I am.
How did you hear this very gentle tap ? — ^I
was not deaf then.
Were you close to the door ? — There was a
wall close to the door ; I leaned against that
wsdl frequently.
Did you know the persons of these men —
had you seen them before ? — ^Yes many times.
Where had you seen them before ?— Fre-
quently in the streets.
Do not you know they had their clubs at
gublic-bouses, and till they got a room, it was
eld at Mr. Walker's ? — I never saw them, at
the public'hooses ; I believe I should not
have been admitted.
Were those persons that you saw so into
Mr. Walker's house, members of the club ?—
I believe they were.
Thev were prevented holding the clubs at
the public-houses ? — I do not know that.
You must know that — ^No, I was not
present.
Have not you seen the public advertise-
ments appearmg in the papers ?— I have.
Do not you know that these dubs were
transferred to Mr. Walker's house, till they
could find some place at whicb to meet? — I
do not upon my word ; I know the landlords
signed their names in the public papers, that
thev would not admit such clubs, but I know
nothing of the acyoumments.
Do not you know, that afler the landlords
had so refused to receive them, at the desire
of the maj;istrates, th^t they met at a private
hou^, which was attacked by a mob and in a
great measure destroyed? — ^No, I do not.
Thomoi Kinnatton, — re-examined by Mr.
Topping,
You had not an opportunity, from the situ-
ation in which you was out of doors, of
observing any thing that was going on above
stairs?— r^o; Mr. Walker's warehouse win-
dows are in the yard at the back part of the
house.
A. I>. 17M.
DEFSHCE'.
[1102
The Hotf. Tkomas Unibiiie.*— Gentlemen
of the Jury; Ilislened with the greatest at*
tentum (and in honour of my \tmed &md
I must say with the greatest approbation) to
much of his address to you in tne opening of
this cause ; — ^it was canctid and manly, sod
contained many truths which I have no in-
terest to deny; one in particidar which in«
volves in it indeed the very principle of the
defence,— the value of that nappy constitu^
tion of government which has so lone existed
in this island. I hope that none of us will
ever forget the gratitude whidh we owe to the
Divine Providence, and, under its blessing, to
the wisdom of our forefathers, for the happy
establishment of law and justice under whicn
we live ; and under which, thank God, mj
clients are this day to be judged : great indeed
will be the condemnation of any man who
does not feel and act as he ought to do upon
this subject ; for surelv if there be one privi-
lege greater than another which the benevo^
lent Author of our being has been pleased to
dispense to his creatures since the existence
o^the earth which we inhabit, it is to have
cast our lots in this ag^e and country:^ — ^for
myself, I would in spirit prostrate myself
daily and liourly before Heaven to acknow«-
ledee it ; and instead of coming from the house
of Mr. Walker, and accompanying him at
Preston (the only tnitl^s which the witness
has uttered since he came into court), if I be-
lieved him capable of committing tne crimes
he is charged with, I would raih^ have gone
inV> my erave than have been found as a
friend vanaer his roof.
Gentlemen, the crime imnuted to the de«
fendant is a serious onti indeed: — ^Mr.Law
has told you, and told you truly* that this in-
dictment has not at all lor its object to con*
demnorto ouestion .the particmar opinions
which Mr. Walker and the other defendants
may entertain concerning the principles of
this government, or the reforms which the
wisest governments may from time to time
require : he is indeed a man of too enlarged
a mind to think for a moment that his coun-
try can be served by interrupting the current
of liberal opinion, or overawing l^e legal
freedom of English sentiment by the terrors
of criminal prosecution: he openly disavows
such a system, and has, I thmk, even more
than hinted to us that there may be seasons
when an attention to reform may be salutary^
and that eveir individual under our happy
establishment has a right upon this important
subject to think for himself.
fThe defendants therefore are not arrugped
before you, nor even censured in observation,
for having associated at Manchester to pro*
mote what they felt to be the cause of reli-
* I have, as on former occasions, availed my-
self of the report of this speech published m
the Snd edition of << Erskine's Speeches."
1 lOSJ 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings againH Thos. Walker and olhers, \l 104
giousand civil liberty ;»nor are they anraign-
ed or censured for seeking to collect the sen-
timents of their neighbours and the public
concerning the nec«si»ty of a reform in the
constitution of parliament; these sentiments
and objects are wholly out of the question :
but they are charged with bavins unlawfully
confederated and conspired to destroy and
overthrow the ffovemment of the kingdom' by
open force and rebellion^ and that to effect
thb wicked purpose they exercised the king*s
subjects witn arms, perverting that which is
our birthright, for the protection of our lives
tind property, to the malignant purpose
of supporting the enemies of this king-
dom in case of an invasion : in order, as my
friend has truly said (for I admit tbe conse-
quence if the fact be established), in order to
mdce our country that scene of confusion and
desolation which fills every man's heart with
dismay and horror, when he only reads or
thinks of what is transacting at a distance
upon the bloody theatre of the war that is
now desolating the world .--ThiS| and nothing
different or less than this, is the charge
'whichismade upon the defendants, at the
head of whom stands before you a merchant,
of honour, property, character, and respect;
•^who has long engoyed the countenance and
friendship of many of the worthiest and most
illustrious persons in the kingdom, and whose
principles and conduct have more than once
Deen publidj^ and gratefully acknowledged by
the community of^ which he is a member, as
the friend of their commerce and liberties,
and the protector of the most essential privi-
leges which Englishmen can enjoy under the
laws. .
Gentlemeti, such a prosecutwn against
such a person ought to have had a strong
foundation: putting private justice and all
respect of persons wholly out of the question,
it should not, but upon the most clear con-
viction and the most ureent necessitv, have
been instituted at all.— -We are at this mo-
ment in a most awful and fearfiil crisis of af-
fairs ; — we are told authentically by the sove-
reign from the throne, that our enemies in
France are meditating an invasion, and the
kingdom from one end to another is in mo*
tionto repel it — In such a state of things, and
when the public transactions of government
and justice in the two countries pass and re-
pass from one another as if upon the wings of
the wind, is it politic to prepare this solemn
array of justice upon such a dangerous subject,
without a reasonable foundation, or rather
tvithout an urgent call ? At a time when it is
our common interest that France should be-
lieve us to be, what we are and ever have
been, one heart and soul to protect our coun-
try and our constitution — is it wise or prudent,
putting private histice wholly out of the ques-
tion, that it should appear to the councils of
Ftrance (apt enough to exaggerate advantages)
that the judge representing the government
in the northern district of this kingdom should
be sitting here in judgment in the presence of
all the gentlemen whose property lies in thb
isreat county, to trace and to punish the exist-
ence of a rebellious conspiracy to support an
invasion from France? — a conspiracy not
existing in a single district alone, but nsain-
taining itself by criminal concert and corre»>
pondence in every district, town, and city in
the kingdom ; — ^projecting nothing less than
the utter destruction and subversion of the
government. — Good God ! can it be for the
interest of government that such an account
of the state of this country should go forth ?
Unfortunately, the rumour and efiect of this
day's business will spread where the evidence
may not travel with it, to serve as an antidote
to the mischief; for certainly the scene whic^
we have tliis day witnessed can never be ima-
gined in France or in Ei^rope, where tbe
spirit of our law is known and understood ; —
it never will be credited that all this serious
process has no foundation either in fact or
probability, and that it stands upon the sin-
gle evidence of a common soldier, or rather a
common iMi^<i6oR</,. discharged as unfit to be
a soldier; — of a wretch, lost to all reverence
for God and religion, who avovt, that be las
none for either, and who is incapable of ob^
serving even common decency as a witness
in the court: — this will never be believed;
and the country, whose best etrength at home
and abroad is the soundness of all ita mem-
bers, will suffer from tbe very credit which
government will receive for the justice of this
proceeding.
What then can be more beneficial than
that you should make haste, as public and
private men, to undeceive the world, to do
justice to your fellow-subjects, and to vindl-
cate your country ? — ^what can be more benefi-
cial, than that you, as' honest men, should
upon your oaths pronounce and record by
your verdict, that, nowever Englishmen may
differ in religious opinions, which in such a
land of thinking ever must be the case ; —
that however they may separate in political
speculations as to the wisest and best forma-
tion of a House of Commons ; — that though
some may think highly of the church and its
establishment, whilst others, but with equal
sincerity, prefer the worship of God with otner
ceremonies, or without any ceremonies; —
that though some may think it unsafe to
touch the constitution at this particular mo-
ment, and some, that at no time it is safe to
touch it, while others think that its very
existence depends upon immediate reforma-
tion : — what, I repeal can be more beneficial,
than that your verdict should establish, that
thou{;h the country is thus divided upon these
political subjects, as it ever has been in everv
age and period of our history, yet that we au
recollect our duty to the land which onr
fathers have lef^ us as an inheritance ; — that
we all know and feel we have one common
duty and one conunon interest f This will be
the language of youi veidict^ whatever jms
1105]
Jot a ColUfirhcy*
3rcMirselves may thmk upon these topics con-
nected ivitb, but still collateral to the cause.
•^-Whether you shall approve or disapprove
«f the opinions or objects of the defendants,
J know that you will still with one mind re-
-volt with indignation at the evidence vou have
•lieardy when you shall have heard also the ob-
Mervations I have to make upon U^ and, what
18 far more important, the /acts I shall bring
forward to encounter it. To these last words
I beg your particular attention : — I say, when
ymi shall hear the Jacti with which 1 mean to
encounter the evidence. My learned friend
lias supposed that I had nothing wherewith
to support the cause, but by railing at his
-witness, and endeavouring to traduce his cha-
racter by calling others to reproach it : he
has told you, that I cotild encounter his testi-
jnony by no one fact^ but that he had only
to apprehend the influence which my address
mignt have upon you ; — as if I, an utter stran-
ger here, could have any possible weight or
influence, to oppose to him, who has been so
lo^ known and honoured in this place.
But althoueh my learned friend seems to
have expected no adverse evidence, he ap-
pears to have been apprehensive for the
credit and consistency of his own; since he
has told you that we have drawn this man
into a lure not uncommon for the purpose of
entrapping witnesses into a contradiction of
testimony ; — that we have ensnared him into
the company of persons who have drawn him
in by insidious questions, and written down
what he has been made to declare to them in
destniction of his original evidence, for the
wicked purpose of attacking the sworn tes-
timony of truth, and cuttine down the conse-
auences which would have followed from it to
le defendants. If such a scene of wickedness
had been practised, it must have been known
to the witness himself; yet my learned fHend
will recollect, that though he made this charze
in his hearing before his examination, he
poutively denied the whole of it ;— -I put it to
nim point by point, pursuing the opening as
my guide, — and he denied that he had been
drawn inro any lure;— he denied that any
trap had been laid for him; — he denied that
he had been asked any questions by any body.
— ^If I am mistaken, I desire to be corrected,
and particularly so by my learned friend, be-
cause I wisli to state the evidence as it was
S'lven. He has then denied all these things ,
c has farther sworn that he never acknow-
ledged to Mr. Walker that he had wronged or
injured him, or that the evidence he hadgiven
against him was false ; — that he never had
^one down upon his knees in his presence, to
implore his forgiveness; — ^that he never held
his bands before his face, to hide the tears
that were flowing down his cheeks in the mo-
ment of contrition, or of terror at the conse-
quence of his crimes : all this he has posi-
tively and repeatedly sworn in answer to
questions deliberately put to him ; and instead
of answering with douDt, or as trying to recol-
VOL XXIII.
A. D. 1794. [1106
lect whether any thing approaching such a
representation had happened, he put his hands
to his sides> and laughed, as you saw, at me
who put the questions, with tluit sneer of con*
tempt and insolence which accompanied the
whole of his evidence, on my part at least of
his examination. — If nothing therefore was
•at stake but the destniction of this man's evi-
dence, and with it the prosecution which rests
for its whole existence upon it, I should pro-
ceed at once to confound him with testimony,
the truth of which my learned friend himself
will I am sure, not bring; into question ; but
as I wish the whole conduct of my clients to
stand fairly before you, and not to rest merely
upon positive swearing destructive of opposite
testimony ; and as I wish the evidence i mean
to brinj; before you, and the falsehood of that
which it opposes, to be clearly understood ; I
will state to you how it has happened that
this strange prosecution has come oefore you.
The town of Manchester has been long ex*
tremely divided in religious and civil opinions;
and ^hile I wish to vindicate those whom I
represent in this place, I desire not to inflame
dinerences which I hope in a short season will
be forgotten ; I am desirous, on the contrary,
that every thing which proceeds from me
may be the means of conciliating rather than
exasperating disseutions which nave already
produced much mischief, and which perhaps,
but for the lesson of to-day, might have pro-
duced much more.
Gentlemen, you all know that there have
been for centuries past in this country various
sects of Christians worshipping God in different
forms, and holding a diversity of religious opi-
nions; and that the law has for a lone season
deprived numerous classes, even of his ma-
jesty's Protestant subjects, of privileges which
It confers upon the rest of the public, setting
as it were a mark upon them, and keeping
them below the level of the community, by
shutting them out from offices of trust and
confidence in the country. — Whether these
laws ^be wise or unwbe,— whether they
ought to be continued or abolished, are
questions for the legislature, and not for us;
but thus much I am warranted in saying, that
it is the undoubted privilege of every man or
class of men in England, to petition parlia-
ment for the removal of any system or law,
which either actually does aggrieve, or which
is thought to be a grievance. Impressed with
the sense of this inherent privilege, this very
ConstitutionaPSociety, which is supposed by
my learned friend the attorney-general to
have started up on the breaking out of the
war with France, for the purpose of destroy-
ing the constitution — this very society owed
its birth to the assertion of this indisputable
birthright of Englishmen, which the authors
of this prosecution most rashly thought pro>
per to stigmatize and resist. It is well known
that in 1790 the dissenters in the different
parts of the kingdom were solicitous to bring
oefore parliament their applicatipn to put an
4 B
1107} 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings against That. Walker and others, QllQB
end for ever to all divisions upon religious
subjects, and to make us all, what I look for-
ward yet to see, one harmonious body, living
tike one fiunilv together. It is also well re-
membered with what zeal and eloquence that
ereat question was managed in the House of
Commons by Mr. Fox, and the large majority
with which the repeal of the Test Acts was
rejected; it seems therefore strange that the
period of this rejection should be considered
as an era either of danger to the church or
of religious triumph to Christians; never-
theless, a large body of gentlemen and others
at Manchester, whose motives I am far from
wishing to scrutinize or condemn, considered
this very wish of the dissenters as injurious
to their rights, and as daneerous to the church
and state; — they published advertisements
txprcssive of these sentiments, and the rejec-
tion of the bill in the Commons produced a
society styled the Church and King Club,
which met for the first time to celebrate what
tiiey called the glorious decision of the House
•f Commons in rejecting the prayer of their
dissenting brethren.
Gentlemen, it is not for me to say, that it
was unjust or impolitic in parliament to re-
ject the application ; but surely I may without
offence suggest, that it was hardly a fit sub-
ject of triumph, that a great numbeit of fellow-
subjects, amounting, Ibelieve, to more than
a million in this country, bad miscarried in
an object which they thought beneficial, and
which they had a most un<|uestionable ri^ht
to submit to the government under which
thev lived ; yet for this cause alone (France
and every other topic of controversy being
yet unborn) the church and king were held
forth to be in danger ; a society was instituted
for their protection, and a uniform ap-
pointed with the church of Manchester upon
the button.
Gentlemen, without calling for any censure
upon this proceeding, but leaving it to every
man's own reflecUon, is it to be wondered at
or condemned, that those who thought more
lareely and liberally on subjects of freedom,
botn civil and religious, but who found them-
selves persecuted for sentiments and conduct
the most avowedly leoal and constitutional,
should associate for the support of their
rights and privileges as £nglisnmen, and as-
semble to consider how they might best ob-
tain a more adequate representation of the
' people of Great Britain in parliament ?
Gentlemen, this society continued with
these objects in view until the issuing of the
5 proclamation against Republicans anoLevel-
ers, calling upon the magistrates to exert
themselves throughout the kingdom to avert
some danger with which, it seems, our rulers
thought this kingdom was likely to be visited.
Of this danger, or the probabihty of it, either
generally or at Manchester in particular, my
learned friend has given no evidence from
any quarter but that of Mr. Dunn ; — he has
not proved that there has been in any one
part of the kingdom any thing which
lead government to apprehend that me
existra for the purposes pointed at
that is out of the question ;---govem]xiexit had
a right to think for itself, and to issue the
prodamation. — ^The publicans howevet Cms it
appears upon the cross-examination ox the
witness), probably directed by the magistimt^
thought fit to shut up their houses opened bj
immemorial law to all the king's subjects, ana
to refuse admission to all the g|aitleiiien and
tradesmen of the town who did not associate
under the banners of this Church and Kiag
Club. — ^This illegal proceeding vras accom-
panied with an advertisement containing a
vehement libel against all those persons, who,
under the protection of the laws, thooght
themselves as much at liberty to censida'
their various privileges, as others were to
maintain the establishment of the church. —
Upon this occasion Mr. Walker honourabfy
stood forth, and opened his house to the
Constitutional Societv at a time when they
must otherwise have been ia the streets by a
combination of the pubUcans to reject them.
— ^Now, gentlemen, I put it to you as men of'
houour, whether it can be justlv attributed to
Mr. Walker as seditious, that he opened bis
house to a society of gentlemen and trades-
men, whose gooa principles he was acquainted
with, — ^whu nad oeen wantonly opposed by
this Church and King Club, whose privileges
they had never invaded or questioned, — and
against whom, in this day ot trial, there is no
man to be found who can come forward to
impeach anv thing they have done, or a syl-
lable they have uttered. Vehement as the
desire most apparently has been, to bring this
gentleman and his associates, as they are
called, to justice, yet not one magistrate, — ^no
man of property or figure in this town or its
neighbourhood, — no person having the king^
authority in tlie country, has appeared to
prove one fact or circumstance firom whence
even the vaguest suspicion could arise, that
any thing criminal hao been intended or trans-
acted:— no constable, who had ever been
sent to guard, lest the peace might be broken,
or to make inquiries for its preservation ? not
a paper seized throughout England, nor any
other prosecution instituted except upon the
unsupported evidence of the same miserable
wretch who* stands before you : — the town,
neighbourhood, and county, remaining in
the same profound state of tranquillity as it is
at the moment I am addressing you.
Gentlemen, when parliament assembled at
the end of 1799, previous to the commence-
ment of the war, these unhappy differences
were suddenly (and, as vou will see, from no
fault of Mr. Walker*s) Drought to the crisis
which produced this trial : — a meeting was
held in Manchester to prepare an address of
thanks to the king for having embodied the
militia during the recess of parliament, and
for having put the kingdom into a posture of
defence ; I do not seek to question the mea«
IIOC^j
fir a Cofu^racy*
A. D. 179*.
£1110
«ure of goveroinaiit whkh ^ve rise to this
Approbation or the appfobatioQ itself which
4ne approvers had a right to bestow; but
-others had an equal rieht to entertain
other opinions. On all punlic measures the
decision undoubtedly is with government;
but the people at the same time have a
right to think upon thbn, and to express
What they think; surely war, of all other
subjects^ is one which the people have a
jright to consider; surely, it can be no of-
fence for those whose properties are to be
taxed, and whose inheritances are to be les-
sened by it, to pause a little upon the eve of
a contest, the end of which no man can fore-
«ee» — the expenses of which no man can cal-
culate, or estimate the blood to flow from its
calamities. — Surely it is a liberty secured to
us bv the first principles of our constitution,
to aadress the sovereign, or instruct our repre-
sentatives, 4o avert the greatest evil that can
impend over a nation.
Uentlemen, one of those societies, called
the Reformation Society, met to exercise this
undoubted privilege, and in my mind upon
the fittest occasion that ever presented itself;
jet mark the moderation of Mr. Walker,
whose violence is arraigned before you. —
Thoush he was no member of that body, and
thougn he agreed in the propriety of the mea-
sure m a^tation, yet he suggested to them,
that their opposition mightTO made a pre-
tence for tumult,— -that tranquillity in such a
4U'isis, was by every means to be promoted,
and therefore advised them to abstain from
the meeting; so that the other meeting was
left to carry its approbation of jgovernment
and of the war, without a dissenting voice. —
If ever therefore there was a time when the
church and kins might be said to be out of
danger at Manchester, it was at this moment :
—yet on this very day thev hoisted the ban-
ners of alarm to both; — they paraded with
them through every quarter of the town ; —
mobs by degrees were collected, and in the
evening of this very eleventh of December,
the houses of Mr. Walker and others were
atUcked. You will observe, that before this
day no man has talked about arms at Mr .Wal-
ker's :— ifan honourable gentleman upon the
jury who has been carefully taking notes of
the evidence, will have the goodness to refer
to them, he will find that it was not till near
a week after this (so Dunn expresses it) that
a single firelock had been seen; nor indeed
does any part of the evidence eo back beyond
this time, when Mr. Walker's nouse was thus
surrounded and attacked by a riotous and dis-
orderly mob. He was aware of the probable
consequences of such an attack ;— he knew,
by the recent example of Birmingham, what
he and others professing sentiments of free-
dom had to expect; — he therefore cot toge-
ther a few firenarms, which he had long had
publicly by him, and an inventory of wLich,
with the rest of his furniture at Barlow HaU,
had been taken by a sworn appraiser, long
before any thing connected with this indict-
ment had an existence; and with these,
and the assistance of a few steady friends,
he stood upon his defence. He was ad-
vised indeed to retire for safety ; but know-
ing his own innocence, and recollecting the
duty he owed to himself, his family, ana the
public, he declared he would remain there, to
support the laws and to defend his property,
— ^and that he would perish, rather then sur-
render those privileges, which every member
of the community is bouna, both from interest
^and duty, to maintain. — To ^larm the multi-
tude, he fired from the windows over their
heads, and dispersed them; but when, the
next morning, they assembled in very great
numbers betore his house, and when a man
got upon the churchyard wall, and read a>
most violent and inflammatory paper, inciting
the populace to pull the House down, Mr.
Walker went out amongst them, and expos-
tulated with them, and asked why they had
disgraced themselves so much by attacking
him the nio^ht before; adding, that if he had
done any of them, or any person whom they
knew, any injury, he was, upon proof of it,
ready to make them every satisfaction in his
power : — he also told them, that he had fired
upon them the night before, because they
were mad as well as diunk ; that, if they at-
tacked him again, he would, under the same
circumstances, act as he had done before;
but that he was then alone and unarmed in
the midst of them ; and if he had done any
thing wrong, they were then sober, and had
him completely in their power.
Gentlemen, this was most meritorious con-
duct You all live at a distance from the me-
tropolis, and were probably, therefore, fortu-
nate enough neither to be within or near it
in 1780, when, from beginnings smaller than
those which exhibited themselves at Bir-
mingham, or even at Manchester, the metro-
polis of the country, and with it the country
itself, had nearly b€«n undone : the begin-
ning of these things is the season for exer-
tion : I shall never indeed forget what I have
heard the late mild and venerable magistrate
lord Mansfield say upon this subject, whose
house V9S one of the first attacked in Lon-
don ; I have more than once heard him sav,
that perhaps some blame might have attach-
ed upon himself and others in authority, for
their forbearance in not having directed force
to have been 4tt the first moment repelled bv
force, it being the highest humanity to check
the infancy of tumults.
Gentlemen, Mr. Walker's conduct had the
desired eflect : he watched again on the tSth
of December, but the mob returned no more,
and the next morning the arms were locked
.up in a bedchamber in his house, where they
have remained ever since, and where, of
course, they never could have been seen by
the witness, whose whole evidence eommences
abooe a week subsequent to the tUh of Decern"
ber, wAc» they were finally put aside. This is
1 1 1 11 34 GEORGE UL Proceedings agand T^. Walker and dhers, ^1112
parcel of arms of different soiti and sises as
a man collecting amongst his friends, for his
defence against tlie sudden violence of a
riotous multitude, might be expected to liaire
collected : here la^ three or four rusty gims
of different dimensions, and here and tliere
a bayonet or brcMid-sword, covered over with
dust and rust, so as to be almost iindistm-
guishable; for, notwithstanding what this
the genuine history of the business ; and it
must therefore not a little surprise you, that
when the charge is wholly confined to the
use of arms, Mr. Law should not even have
hinted to you that Mr. Walker's house had
been attacked, and that he was driven to
stand upon his defence, as if such a thing had
never had an existence; — indeed the armoury
which must have been exhibited in such a
statement, would have but ill suited the in-
dictment or the evidence, and I must there-
fore undertake the description of it myself.
The arms having been locked up, as I told
you, in the bedchamber, I was shown last
week into this house of conspiracy, — treason,
— and death, and saw exposed to view the
mighty armoury which was to level the beau-
tiful fabric of our constitution, and to destroy
the lives and properties of ten millions of
people. — It consisted, first, of six little swivels
purchased two years ago at the sale of Live,
sey, Hargrave, and 0>. (of whom we have
all heard so much), by Mr. Jackson, a gentle-
man of Manchester, who is also one of the
defendants, and who gave them to master
Walker, a boy about ten years of age; —
swivels, you know, are guns so called because
they turn upon api vot ; but these were taken off
their props, were painted, and put upon blocks
resembling carriages of heavy caroion, and in
that shape may oe furly called children's
toys : you frequently see them in the neigh-
bourhood of London adorning the houses of
sober citizens, who, strangers to Mr. Brown
and his improvements, and preferring gran-
deur to taste, place them upon their ramparts
at Mile-End or Islington. Having, like Mr.
Dunn (I hope I resemble him m nothing
else), having, like him, served his majesty as
a soldier (and I am ready to serve again if
my country's safety should require it), I took
a closer review of all I saw, and observing
that the muzzle of one of them was broke off,
I was curious to know how far this famous
conspiracy had proceeded, and whether tbev
had come into action, when I found the accf-
dent had happened on firing a feu de joie
upon his majesty's happy recovery, and that
they had been afterwards fired upon the
prince of Wales's birth-da;>^ These are the
only times, that, in the hands of these con-
spirators, these cannon, big with destruction,
had opened their little mouths ;— once to
commemorate the indulgent and benign
favour of Providence in ttie recovery of the
sovereign, and once as a congratulation to the
heir apparent of his crown on the anniversaiy
of his birth.
I went nex^ under the protection of the
jnaster-genenil of this ordnance (Mr. Walker's
chamber-maid), to visit the rebt of this tbr-
midable array of death, and found a little
oaqsketoon about so high fdescribing it] ; I
put my thumb upon it, when out starred a
little bayonet like a Jack-in-a-box which we
buy for children at a fair ; in short, not to
weary you, gentlemen, there was just such a
fnfamotts wretch has sworn, we wiU
by witness after witness, till you desire us to
finish, that they were principally collected on
the 1 1th of December, the day of the rio^
and that horn the ISth in the evenine, or the
13th in the morning, they have Jain iii»-
touched, as I have described them ; — that
their use began and ended with the necessity,
and that, from that time to the present, there
never has been a fire-arm in the warehouse
of any sort or description. This is the whole
on which has been built a proceeding that
might have brought the defendants to the
punishment of death, for both the charge and
the evidence amount to high treason, — high
treason, indeed, under almost every branch
of the statute; since the facts amount to
levying war aeainst the king — by a couspi-
racy to wrest by force the government out of
his -hands, — to an adherence to the Idbe^s
enemies,— and to a compassing of his deam,
which is a necessary consequence of an in-
vading amw of republicans or of any other
enemies of the state;— yet ndtwithstandine
the notoriety of these tacts, the un-namea
prosecutors (and indeed I am afraid to slan*
der any man or body of men, by even a guess
upon the subject) have been beating up as
for volunteers, to procure another witness
to destroy the lives of the gentlemen before
you, against many of whom warrants for
high treason were issued to apprehend them ;
Mr. Walker, among the rest, was the subject
of such a warrant, and as soon as he knew i^
he behaved (as he has throughout, like a
man and an Englishman; — ^he wrote imme-
diately to the secretary of state, who was
summoned here to-day, and whose absence I
do not complain of, because we have by con-
sent the benefit of his testimony ; — he wrote
three letters to Mr. Dundas, one of which was
delivered by Mr. Wharton, informing him
that he was in London on his business as a
merchant; — that if any warrant had been
issued against him, he was ready to meet it,
and for that purpose delivered his address
where it might be executed. This Mr. Wal-
ker did when the prosecutors were in search
of another witness, and when this Mr. Dunn
was walking like a tame sparrow through the
New Bailey, fed at the public or some other
expense, and suffered to go at large, though
arrested upon a criminal charge, and sent
into custody under it.
And to what other circumstances need I
appeal for the purity of the defendants, than
thaty under the charge of a conspiracy, exten*
sive enough to comprehend la lU traosao*
1113]
Jhf a Con^rac^M
A. D. 17M.
11114
tiqns (if ^^y existed) the whole compass of
England, the tour of which was to have
been made hy Mr. Yorke, there has not heen
atie man found to utter a syllable about them,
no not one man, thanks be to God, who has so
framed the characteristics of Englishmen,
except the solitary infamous witness before
you, who, from what I heard since I began to
address you, may have spoken the troth when
he claimed my acquaintance, as I have reason
to think he has seen me before in a criminnl
court of justice.
Having now, for the satisfaction of the
defendants rather than from the necessity of
the case, given you an account of their whole
proceedings, as I shall establish them by
proof; let us examine the evidence that has
tie en given aeainst them, and see how the
truth of it could stand with reason or proba-
bility, supposing it to have been sworn to by
a witness the most respectable.
According to Dunn's own account, Mr. Wal-
ker had not been at the first meeting, so that
when he first saw Dunn he did not Know ei«
ther his person or his name ; he might have
been a spy (God knows there are enow of
them), and at that season in particular, in-
formers were to be expected: — ^Mr. Walker
is supposed to have said to him, '* What is
your business here?** to which he an-
swered, '' I am going to the society," which
entitled him at once to admission without
farther ceremony ; — ^there was nobody to stop
him : — was he asked his name } — was he bal-
lotted for ? — was he questioned as to his prin-
ciples ^ No, he walked in at once ; but first,
it seems, Mr. Walken who had never before
seen him, inquired of^him the news from Ire-
land (observmg by his voice that he was an
Irishman), and asked what the volunteers were
about, as if Mr. Walker could possibly suppose
that such a person was likely to have been in
a correspondence with Ireund, which tuld
him more than report must have told every
body else. Mr. Dunn tells you indeed he
was HO such person, he was a friend, as he
says, to the kmg and constitution, which Mr.
Walker would have found by asking another
question ; but, without farther inquiry, he is
supposed to have said to him at once, '' We
shall overthrow the constitution by and by ; "
which the moment Dunn had heard, up
walked that affectionate subject of our so«
vereign lord the king into Mr. Walker's house,
where the constitution was to be so overthrown ;
but then he tells you he thought there was
no harm to be done, that it was only for the
benefit of the poor and the public good ; —
but how could he think so after what ne had
that moment heard? but be did not know, it
seems, what Mr. Walker meant. Gentlemen,
do you collect, from Mr. Dunn's discourse
and deportment to^lay, that, he could not tell
but that a man meant good when he had
heard even him express a wish to overthrow
the government? would you pull a feather
out oTa sparrow'3 wing upon the o^ of a
man, who swears that he believed a person to
have been a good su^ect in the very moment
he was telling him of an intended rebellion f
But why should I fight a phantom with ar-
gument?— Could any man but a driveller,
have possibly given such an answer as is put
into Mr. Walker's mouth, to a man he had
never seen in his life P However many may
differ from Mr. Walker in opinion, every
body, I believe, will admit, that he is an acute,
intelligent man, with an extensive knowledge
of the world, and not at all likely to have con-
ducted himself like an ideot. What follows
next ? — another night he went into the ware-
house, where he saw Mr. Yorke called to the
chair, who said he was goinz the tour of
the kinjgdoro, in order to tr^ tnc strength of
the different societies, to join fifly-thousand
luen that were expected to land from Prance
in this country, and that Mr. Walker then
said, *^ Damn all kings — I know our king has
seventeen millions of money in the bank of
Vienna, although he won't afford any of it to
the poor." Gentlemen, is this the laneuage
of a man of sense and education? If Mr.
Walker had the malignity of a demon, would
he think of givins effect to it by such a
senseless lie? — Wnen we know that, from
the immense expense attending his miyesty's
numerous and iUustrious family, and the great
necessities of the state, he has been obuged
over and over again to have recourse to the
generosity and justice of parliament to main-
tain the dignity of the crown; could Mr. Wal-
ker ever have thought of inventing this non-
sense about the bank of Vienna, when there
is a bank too in our own country, where he
mieht legally invest his property for himself
and his heirs ? But Mr. Walker did not stop
there; — he went on and said, '' I should
think no more of taking off the kin^s head
than I should of tearing this piece of^paper.'^
All this happened soon after his admission ;
yet this man, who represents himself to you
upon his oath this day, as having been uni-
formly a friend to the constitution, as far as
he understood it ; — as having lef^ the society
as soon as he saw their mischievous inclina*
tions, — and as having voluntarily informed
against them, I say this same friend of the con^
stitution tells you, almost in the same breath,
that he continued to attend their meetings
from thirty to forty times, where high treason
was committing tnth open doors ; and that, in-
stead of giving information of his own free
choice, he was arrested in the very act of dis-
tributing some seditious publication.
Gentlemen, it is really a serious conside-
ration, that upon such testimony a man should
even be put upon his defence in the courts of
this country; — upon such principles what
man is safe? I was indeed but ill at ease
myself when Mr. Dunn told me he knew me
better than I supposed. — What 8(ecurity have
I at this moment that \k^ should not swear
that he had met me under some gateway in
Laacasteri and that I had said to him, *< Well,
1 1 15] S4 GEORGE HI. ProceetUngs agabui Tkoi. Watker and dthert^ [1 1 14!
Dtmiiy I hope you will not swear against Mr.
Walker, but tliat you will stick to the good
cause ; damn all Kings : damn the constitu-
tion :" — if the witness were now to swear this,
into gaol I must go ; and if my client is in
danger from what has been sworn againt Aioiy
what safety would there be for mc f — the evi-
dence would be egualljr positive, and I am
equallv an object ofsuspicion as Mr. Walker:
it IS said of Aim, that he has been a member
of a society for the reform of parliament ; so
have I, and so am I at this moment, and so
at all hazards I will continue to be, and I will
tell you why, gentlemen — because I hold it
to be essential to the preservation of all the
ranks and orders of the state, — alike essential
to the prince and to the people : I have the
honour to be allied to nis majesty in blood,
and my family has been for centuries a part
of what is now called the aristocracy of the
country ; I can therefore have no interest in
the destruction of the constitution.
In pursuing the probability of this story
(unce it must be pursued), let us next advert
to whether anytlung appears to have been
done in other places which might have been
exposed by this man's information. The
whole kingdom is under the eye and domi-
nion of maffislracy, awakened at that time to
an extraorcunary vigilance ; yet has any one
man been arrestea even upon the suspicion
of any correspondence with the societies of
Manchester, good, bad, or indifferent? or
has any person within the four seas come to
swear that any such correspondence existed ?
So that you are desired to believe, upon Mr.
Dunn's single declaration, that gentlemen of
the description I am representing, without
any end or object, or concert with others,
were resolved to put their lives into the hands
of any miscreant who might be disposed to
swear them away, by holding public meetings
of conspiracy with open doors, and in the pre-
sence of all mankind, liable to be handed
over to justice every moment of their lives,
since every tap at the door might have intro-
duced a constable as readily as a member ;
and, to finish the absurdity, these gentlemen
are made to discourse in a manner that would
disgrace the lowest and most uninformed
classes of the community.
Let us next see what interest Mr. Walker
has in the proposed invasion of this peaceable
country : has Mr. Law proved that Mr. Wal-
ker had any reason to expect protection from
the French from any secret correspondence or
communication more than you or I have, or
that he had prepared any means of resisting
the troops of this country? — how was he to
have welcomed these strangers into our land?
— what, with this dozen or rusty muskets, or
with those conspirators whom he exercised ?
—but who are they ? — they are, it seems, as
my learned friend who drew this indictment
has called them, <' to the jurors unknown,*'
^d be might have added, who will ever rs^
nmn uHknowrk4o them. — But has Mr. Walk«r
nothing to lose, like other men who dreatd as
invasion ? Ue has long had the acqiwintanice
and friendship of some of the best nneD ia
this kingdom, who would be destroyed if mch
an invasion siiould take place. — Has be, like
other men, no ties of a neajttr description ?-^
Alas, gentlemen ! I feel at this moment tbai
he has many: Mr. Dunn told you that I ^ras
with Mr. Walker at Manchester; ainl it
enables me to say, of my ovm kiiowledge»
that it is impossible he could have bad &e
designs imputed to him. — ^I have been under
his roof, wnere I have seen him the husband
of aa amiable and affectionate woman, and
the happy parent of six engaeine children ;
and it hurts me not a little to tninlc what they
must feel at this moment — Before proseca-
tions are set on foot, those things cHight to
be considered;— we ought not, like the fool
in the Proverbs, to scatter firebrands and
death, and say, ''Ami not in sport ? " Could
we look at this moment into the dweUing of
this unfortunate eentleman, for so I must call
him, I ^m persuaded the scene would distrns
us ; — his family cannot but be unhappy ;^-
they have seen prosecutions equally uxyust as
even this is, attended with a success of equal
iqjustice, and we have seen those proceeding
I am afraid by those who are at the bottom
of this indictment, put forward for your imi-
tation. I saw to my astonishment, at Pre^
ton, where, as a traveller, I called for a news*
paper» that this immaculate society (the Man-
chester Church and King Club) bad a meeting
lately, and had published to the world the
toasts and sentiments which they dnnk;
some of them I like : some of them deserve
reprobation : " The Church and King;" very
well. '' The Queen and Royal Family;^ be
it so. " The Duke of York and the Army ;**
be it so. But what do you think came next I
[Here Mr. Justice Heath interrupted Mr.
Erskine, by saying, *' We are not to go into
this, of which you cannot g^ve evidence."]
Mr. Ertkine. — I do not know what effect
these publications may have upon the admi-
nistration of justice ; why drink '' The Lord
Advocate and the Court of Justiciary in Scot-
landf* * just when your lordship is called
upon to administer justice according to the
laws of England ; ii I had seen the king and
his judges upon the northern circuit published
as a toast
Mr. Justice Heath, — ^You know you cannot
give this in evidence.
Mr. Erthine» — Gentlemen, considering the
situation in which my clients stand at this
moment, I expressed the idea which occurred
to me, and which I thought it right not to
suppress* — but let it pass;— this is not the
moment for controversy ;— it is my interest
to submit to any course his lordship may
think proper to dictate ; the evidence is more
than enough for my purpose; — so mainly
improbable, so contrary to every thing in the
■ ■ ' " ..-.-. .1. ... I ... .1 ■ - ■ ■ r
* See the preceding cases.
1117]
Jw a Coniptracjf.
A. D. 179i.
[1118
conne of hiiman affairs, that I know you will
reject it, even if it stood unanswerea ; what
then will you say, when I shall prove to you
by the oaths of the various persons who at-
tended these societies, that no proposilions of
the sort insinuated oythis witness ever ex-
isted ; — ^t|iat no hint, directly or iiidirectlv, of
any ille^^ tendency, was ever whispered; —
that their real objects were just what were
openly prrfeaed, be they right or wron^, be
they wise or mistaken,* namely, reformatum in
the comtUuiion cf the House if Commons,
which my learned friend admitted they had a
rieht by constitutional means to promote. —
Tnis was their object ; they neither desired to
touch the king's authority, nor the existence
or privileges of the House of Lords ; but they
wished that those numerous classes of the
community, who (by the law as it now stands)
are excluded from an^ share in the choice of
members to the parliament, should have an
equal right with others, in concerns where
their interests are equal. Gentlemen, this
very county furnishes a familiar instance;
there are, I believe, at least thirty thousand
freeholders in Lancashire, each of whom has
a vote for two members of parliament ; and
there are two boroughs within it (if I mistake
not),Clithero and Newton, containing a hand-
ful of men who are at the beck of two indi*
viduals ; yet these two little places send for
themselves, or rather for these tivo persons^Xvro
members each, which makes four against the
,whole power and interest of this county in
parliament, touching any measure, how
deeply soever it may concern their prosperity.
Can there be any onence in meeting together
to consider of a representation to parliament,
suggesting the wisdom of alteration and
amendment in such a system ?
Mr. Justice Heath. — ^There can be no doubt
but that a petition to parliament, for reform
or any thin^ else, can be no offence.
Mr. Ersktne, Gentiemen, I expected this
interruption from the learning of the judge ;
certainly it can be no offence, and conse-
quently my clients can be no offenders.
Having now exposed the weakness of
Dunn's evidence, from its own intrinsic de-
fects, and from tbe positive contradiction eveiy
fart of it is to receive from many witnesses,
shall conclude with the still more positive
and unequivocal contradiction which the
whole of it has received from Dunn himself.
You remember that I repeatedly asked him
whether he had not confessed that the whole
he had sworn to-day was utterly false ; whe-
ther he had not confessed it to be so with
tears of contrition, and whether he had not
kneeled down before Mr. Walker, to implore
his forgiveness. My learned friend, knowing
that this would be proved upon him, made a
shrewd and artful observation, to avoid the
effects of it;— he said, that such things had
Men often under the observation of the
Court upon the circuit, where witnesses had
been drawn into similar snares by artful peo-
ple to invalidate their testimony ;-;>4his may
oe true, but the answer to its application is,
that not only the witness himself hias positive*
\y denied that any such snare was laid for
him, but the witnesses I have to call, both in
respect of number and credit, will put a total
end to such a suggestion. If I had indeed but
one witness, my friend the attorney-general
might undoubt^y put it to you m reply,
whether his or mine, ynn to be believed ; but I
will call to you, not one hui four or five; or,
if necessary, six witnes$es, above all suspi-
cion, in whose presence Dunn voluntarily
confessed the falsehood of his testimony, and,
with tears of apparent repentance, offered to
make any reparation to these injured and un-
fortunate defendants. This I pledge myself
to prove to your satisfaction.
uentlemen, the object of all public trial
and punishment is the security of mankind in
social life. We are not assembled here for
the purposes of vengeance, but for the ends of
justice ; — ^to give tranquilUty to human life,
which is the scope of all government and law;'
— you will take care therefore, how, in the
veiy administration of justice, you disappoint
that which is the very foundation of its msti-
tution;— you will take care, that in the very
moment you are trjring a man as a disturber
of the public happiness, you do not vio)ate
the rules which secure it.
The last evidence I have been stating ought
by itself to put an instant end to this cause : I
remember a case, very lately, which was so
brought to its conclusion, where, upon a trial
for perjury of a witness who had sworn against
a captain of a vessel in the African trade, it
appeared that the witnesses, who swore to
the peijury against the defenaants, had them-
selves made deliberate declarations, which
materially clashed with the testimony they
were giving; lord Kenyon, who tried the
cause, would after this proceed no farther, and
asked me, who was counsel for the prosecu-
tion, whether I would urge it farther ; saying
emphatically, what I hope everjr judge under
similar circumstances will think it his duty to
say also, " No man ought or can be convicted
in England, unless the judge and the jury
have a firm assurance that innocence cannot
by any possibility be the victim of falsehood
and injustice." And how can the jury or
his lordship have that assurance here, when
the only source of it is brought into such
serious doubt and question? Upon the whole,
then, I cannot help hoping, ttiat my friend
the attornev-^neral, wnen he shall hear my
proofs, will feel that a prosecution like this
ought not to be offered for the seal and sanc-
tion of vour verdict Unjust prosecutions
lead to the ruin of all governments. Who-
ever will look back to the history of the world
in general, and of our own particular country,
wiu be convinced, that exactly as prosecu-
tions have been cruel and oppressive, and
maintained bv inadequate and unrighteous,
evidence^ in the same proportion, and by the
11 19} ^GEORGE m. ProceediMgs againtt T%at. Walker and otien^ It 130
same means, their authors have heen destro^^
ed instead of bein^ supported by them. As
oAen as the principles of our ancient laws
have been departed from in weak and wicked
times, so often the governments that have
violated them have been suddenly crumbled
into dust ; and therefore wishing, as I roost
sincerely do, the preservation and prospe-
rity of our happy constitution, I desire to
enter my protest against its being supported
by means that arp likely to destroy it. Vio*
lent proceedings bring on the bitterness of
retaliaUon, until all justice and moderation
are trampled down and subverted ; — witness
those sanguinary prosecutions previous to the
awful period in the last century, when Charles
the first fell : that unfortunate prince lived to
lament those vindictive judgments by which
his impolitic, infatuated foDowers imagined
they were supporting his throne: — he lived to
see how they destroyed it; — his throne, un-
dermined by violence, sunk under him ; and
those who shook it were guilty in their turn
(such is the natural order of injustice) not
only of similar but of worse and more violent
wrongs; witness the fate of the unhappy earl
of Strafford, * who, when he could not be
reached by the ordinary laws, was impeached
in the House of Commons, and who, when
still beyond the consequences of that judicial
proceeding, was at last destroyed by the arbi'
trary wicked mandate of the legulature. James
the second lived to ask assistance in the hour
of his distress, from those who had been cut
•ff from the means of giving it by unjust pro-
secutions ; he lived to ask support from the
earl of Bedford after his son, the unfortunate
lord Russell,f had fallen under the axe of in-
justice: '' I once had a son," said that noble
person. " who could have served your majesty
^pon this occasion," but there was then none
to assist him.
I cannot possibly tell how others feel upon
these subjects, but I do know how it is their
interest to feel concerning them ; we ou^ht
to be persuaded that the onlv way bv which
government can be honourably or sarel^ sup-
ported, is by cultivating the love and aftection
of the people ; — by showing them the value
of the constitution by its protection; — by
making them understand its principles by the
practiod benefits derived from tnem ; — and
above aU, bj^ letting them feel their security
in the administration of law and justice. —
What is it in the present state of tliat unhappy
kingdom, the contagion of which fills us with
such alarm, that is tiie just object of terror ?
-*what, but that accusation and conviction
are the same, and that a false witness or
Sower without evidence is. a warrant for
eath ! Not so here ; — ^long may the coun-
tries differ ! and I am asking fot nothing more
* See his case, Vol. 3, p. 1381, of this Col-
lection.
t See his case Vol. 9, p. 577, of this Col-
lection.
I than that you should dedde acoordii^ to our
own wholesome rules, by which oui]goyemment
was established, and by which il has beat
ever protected. — ^Put yourselves, geoftlemen^
in the place of the defendants, and let me
ask, if you were brought before your coisntiy^
upon a chaipe supported by no other evidenoe
than that which you liave heard UMlay, and
encountered by that which I have stated to
you, what would you say, or your childfea
aft«r you, if you were touched in your persons
or your properties by a conviction ? — may yoo
never be put to such reflections, nor the coun-
try to such disaracc ! The best service we
can render to the public b, that we should
live like one harmoniooafamiljr, that we should
banish all animosities, jealousies, and susdi-
cions of one another; and that, living undcF
the protection of a mild and imoartial justice,
we should endeavour with oneneart, accord-
ing to our best judgments, to advance the
freedom and maintain the security of Greet
Britain.
Gentlemen, I will trouble you do &ther :
I am afraid indeed I have too long trespassed
on your patience, I will therefore proceed to
call my witnesses.
EVIDEKCa FOB tBZ DEFEKDAHT8.
Mr. George Wakefield sworn. — ^Examined by
Mr. Serjeant Cockell,
You are a merchant in Manchester I u&«
derstand ? — I have been.
Do you remember the time of the riots
when Mr. Walker's house was attacked ? — X
do.
After that ni^t do you know whether the
constitutional society which had been formed
in Manchester, met at 'hSj. Walker's ? — Yes.
Were you a member of that society? — ^I
was.
What was the object of that society? — A,
parliamentary reform.
How happened it that after that time the
meetings were held at Mr. Walker's ? — I do
not know particularly; some of the public
houses had refused to let us have a room any
longer.
However in point of fact the meetings then
were held at Mr. Walker's? — They were.
We have heard of the time of the riots, you
will speak to the day as nearly as you remem-
ber?— I believe it was on Tuesday the lltL
of December.
How often did the socieW meet ? — Once a
week or once a fortnight, I declare I do not
recollect which.
Did you ever attend those meetings ?-~
Pretty regularlv.
How long did you continue to attend them ?
—Till nearly the last meeting, I believe,
which was some time in the spring of last
year.
Was there a free admission to any person
who might choose to come?— ^Not that I
know of.
To members of the society ?— There was^
IlSll
Jar a Conxprae^.
A. D. 179*.
\nn
We have heard that men exercised with
vrms in the warehouse were drilled in the use
of arms ; is that true ? — ^Not that I know of.
I>id vou ever see such a thing?— No.
In what part of Mr. Walker's house were
the meetings held \ — In the upper room in
the warehouse.
"What passed at those meetings? — ^The dif^
ferent businesses respecting the society.
Was the kins damned ?
liilr. Lam. — ^You must not put that.
Mr. Serjeant CockelL — Tell us what was
said about the king. — I do not recollect hear-
ing any thing said about the king.
Did you ever hear any thing said about
overthrowing the constitution by means of arms
or otherwise ? — I never heard an^ such thing.
Was any thing said about inviting the
IFrench to mvade the kingdom ? — ^No.
Did you ever hear any thing of the sort?—
Ko, not a syllable.
If men had been drilled in the use of fire-
anns, must you not have seen it ? — I must.
Did you ever see any ? — ^No.
Ever hear of any ? — ^No.
If any persons had been drilled in arms for
the purpose of offence, or destroying the go-
vernment, wou)d you have continued a mem-
ber of that society? — ^No, not a moment.
^ Did you ever hear any thing said about in-
viting an invasion from France ?
Mr. Law, — Ask what did pass there when
this man was present.
Mr. Serjeant CockelL — I have no wbh to
lead.
Mr. Enkine. — I should be sorry to offer
any testimonv that is not in the ordinary
course, but when a witness comes to contra-
dict to a particular point, how can we act any
other way ?
^ Mr. Justice Heath.-yKe has said, no men-
tion was made of any invasion.
Mr. Serjeant Cockell — ^What was the sole
object of your meeting? — As far as I under-
stood it, a parliamentary reform.
Was there any act done at your meeting to
your knowledge that was directed otherwise
than to that end ? — No.
Did you at any time, or any person in your
hearing, in that room, say or do any thing to
overturn the government of the country ? —
No, never.
What was the reform that you sought, and
by what means ?— That is a point upon which
few people are agreed ; but it was a parlia-
mentary reform.
By means of menacing government ? — ^No.
Inviting a foreign enemy? — No.
Was it m any other way than such means
as you suppose the law to allow ? — ^No, by no
other means, than what we apprehend to be
constitutional, nothing but what the law
allows.
Mr. Erskine.'-The witness has said it was
to be done by no other means than what in
his apprehensions the law allowed ; we can
go no farther if we were to stay here a month.
VOL. xxni.
Mr. Serjeant CockelL-^You attended pretty
constantly you have said. What have yoa
heard Mr. Walker say at any time ?
Mr. Justice Kea/A.-— You may ask him, did
he hear Mr. Walker say any tl^g about the
kins.
Mr. Serjeant Cockell.-^WhdX number of
men might there be seaerally ?— Sometimes
more, and sometimes less ; I have seen twen-
ty in the society, and I have seen more, the
numbers differmg at different times.
Did you ever see any men exercised in the
useofarms?-rNo.
Did you ever hear any thing of the sort
mentioned ? — No, if I had, merely to learn
the use of arms, I should have been one niy«
self probably, but I never heard any thins
ofit. . ^ o
Did you ever hear Paul or any othei
person say that be knew there would be a re-
volt firom Ireland? — I do not recollect any
such thing.
Did you ever hear any one t&y if we had a
revolt it would be through the Irish ?— No.
Did you ever hear any one say they had sent
a deputy to Ireland as a king, and damn him
and all kings? — ^No.
Could any such expressions have been
made use of without your hearing of them ?-^
No, I am sure there could not.
Did you ever hear Mr. Walker damn the
king?— No.
At any time ?— No.
Did you ever hear it said either by Mf.
Walkeror any other person, that Mr. Yorke
was going through the three kingdoms to
know the aid that there might be for the
French ? — No.
Mr. Law, — Were you there when Mr. Yorke
was by ?
Mr. Serjeant CockelL — ^Dunn said, thert
were every night conversations about the king.
Mr. Walker.— Did you ever hear me sa^
any thing unbecoming an honest man apd a
good citizen ?
Mr. Xav— We cannot ask that.
Mr. Serjeant Cockell, — Do you remember
the time when Mr. Yorke was m the chair? —
I do not recollect that I was there at that
time.
Did you use to skulk in privately and se-
cretly?— No.
Did you go in always the same way ?•— I
cannot say whether 1 did at all tihies, I went
in at different doors ; I was not going about
any thing I was ashamed of.
Mr. George Wakefield, cross-examined by
Mr. Laa>.
You are or were a partner with Mr. Grant ?
—Yes.
He is a brother in law of Mr. Walker ?'—
Yes.
Have you attended at most of those meet*
in^ ? — ^At many of them.
Did you see Dunn there at any of them ?•—
I do not remember that I ever did.
4C
i }S3J 34 GfiORG£ tn. Proceedings agairui Thas. WaUeer and oiherst [t i£4
Nc^t at any ? — I l^elieTe he was not a mem-
ber of the same society.
Are you of the Refciriioation Society ? — ^No;
of the Constitutional Society.
Did that Miciety uieet at the house of Mr.
Walker ?— Yes.
They met on different nights, did they ? — ^I
believe so ; I was not a member of any other
society.
Whether yon saw Mr. Yorke at that meet-
ins that you attended? — I do not recollect
femg him there at all.
Do you kuow him > — I do not know him.
How came you to have no doubt you had
Seen him more than once ? — I do not recollect
I said any such thing.
I took you down that Yorke was by ? — I
did not say so.
You do not know whether Yorke was pre-
sent at any meeting f I beheve he was pre-
aairt at a meeting, but I do not recollect being
there when he was.
' Mr. Justice HeafA.-— It was a different so-
ciety.
' Mr. ^wAfine.— They met in the same room
M the same time.
Mr, iiiw.— Do YOU mean to say the Refor-
iniltion Society and the Constitutional Society
met at the same place and time under the
Toof of Mr, Walker ? — ^Yea, occasionally ; 1
Itavescen the Reformation Society there at
the same time, and in the same room.
As you resorted tberte frequently, and the
societies frequently i^et there, if this man
Dunn had gone to Mr. Walker's, you might
J>robably hare seen him ? — ^Probably I might.
Is his person familiar with you? — I saw
bim Xhh morning.
' You do not recollect him ?— I do not.
What time of the year, did you attend at
these meetings ? — Almost all thie year.
From September up to June ?— I do not
recollect particularly.
' Do >t>u recollect the time when Yerke was
at Manchester ? — ^No.
Whether you have not declared you were
^yresent when Mr. Yorke was at one of these
meetings ? — ^No.
Have you not said so in this court ? — ^f f you
have taken it down so, you have taken it
Tlown wrong; I do not know him.
Mr. Thomas Walker you have seen of
course there ? — Yes.
Mr. Chectham ?— Yes.
Mr. Jackson f — ^Yes.
PearsallP — I do not know him; I may
hnotf his person.
M'Callum and Smith } — I have seen them
there.
Do you know where they arc now ?— No.
Bootli you have seen there } — Yes.
' And Paul .^— Yes.
And Collier ? — Yes.
Have you seen them very often > — Several
times, some of them very often.
ftit you do not recollect whether you ever
•aw Dunn there ?•— No.
i
You know Mr. Kinnaston ? — ^Yes.
I )>elieve you will not t^fuse bim the testi^
mony that every man will give in his favour^
that he is a man of credit and cimradter ? — ^I
do not know him, but personally.
However you take upon you to swear there
were never any men drilled while you ^rere
by?— Never.
How many hours were you there at a time^
— About two hours.
You say twenty men might be there^-'
cannot you extend their number to fifty or
sixty ?— I may perhaps have seen fifW or sixty.
What is the different object of the socie-
ties? the Constitutional Society is for a re-
form in parliament; what was the Refbrma-^
lion Society for ? — ^I was not a member of the
Reformation Society.
It is cotnmonly called the Subversion or
Overthrow Societv, is it not ? — ^I do not know
what you may call it.
Being at these meetings so held jointly, the
Reformation and Constitutbnal Societies, yon
never knew the objects for which the Refor-
mation Society was formed ? — I did not at-
tend to the objects of the Reformation So-
ciety at all. ^
Then you 'do not know the object for which
it was formed ? — ^How should I when I was
not a member of it ? they met there to join
the Constitutional Society when any itaembe^
of that society took the chair. I had nothii^^
to do with it, and did not attend to it.
And yoHwere even a stranger to the ob«
jects of It ? — Yes.
You are a partner with Mr. Walker's bro-
tlier-in-kiw, and being present at their assent
blies, you did not know what they assembled
for? — I assembled there to meet the Conslitu^
tional Society, and their objects were the
Move I sboula suppose.
Mr. George Wakefield^ re-examined by Mr.
Serjeant CockcUn
Although you were not a member of the
Reformation Society, but of the Constitutional
ik>ciety, did you ever when the Reformatmn
Society was there, hear or see any person
exercising themselves in arms? — Never.
George Clark sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Cliamhre,
You arc a member of the society called the
Reformation Society at Manchester ? — Yes.
When did you )>ecome a member of that
society? — About Easter 179$.
When was the society instituted ? — Either
in Easter week, or about a week before, and
I was a member about the second or third
meeting.
How often did you meet ? — I was a veiy
constant attendant.
At what periods did you meet? — ^We had
weekly meetings.
Did you continue a pretty constant attend^
ing member during tne whole time of tba
exQteneeof that soaety ?-^I did.
iies]
Jbr a Conspiracy*
A, D. 1794..
[1196
Where di<l you meet when you first became
A lucipber? — A.t the Old Poar's-head.
Did you remove from that place ? — ^Yes, to
John Stacey's.
What was the occasion of your removing
to John Stacey's. — In cansequence of an ad-
«rertisement published by the publicans, we
^removed to John Stacey*s.
Do you know about what time it was you
vwent to John Stacey's? — I cannot tell.
Did you continue at John Stacey's ? — Not
looe.
where did you go next ? — ^To the house of
William Gorae in Newton-street.
Is that a private or a public house ? — A
private house.
You know Mr. Walker, Mr. Collier, and
Mr. Paul?— I do.
Do you know whether they at any time
received any invitation to attend the meeting
of vour society ? — I cannot say I do.
When did you first see them present at
your society P — I never saw them Wore the
10th of December at Gorse's.
What did you understand them to be? —
Members of the Constitutional Society; I
Relieve Mr. Cheetham was there, but I am
hot confident, the other three were there at
that time.
Do you know what was the subject of the
deliberation of that particular meeting? — ^The
particular subject ot that meeting was, there
was a public meeting called at the Bull's-
head the day following, to address his Ma-
jesty upon his second proclamation ; a mo-
tion was made whether we should attend that
meeting at the BulPs-head or not; it was
unanimously negatived.
Did Mr. Walker take any part or assisn
any reason ? — Mr. Walker and Mr. Paul spoie
against attending that meeting, and assigned
4neir reasons.
- Mr. Law, — Does any of our evidence let in
this? — we have given no evidence, but of
meetings in Mr. Walker^s bouse; they arc
givins evidence of meetings at another place,
probably for other purposes.
Mr. Erskine, — I should have thought this
too plain for argument. — If my friend insists
upon his objection, we must be heard upon
it; the offeiKe imputed to* Mr. Walker is,
that a few days after the 11th of December,
the witness, Dunn, found him haranguing
the Reformation Society in the seditious
ynanner stated by the witness, speaking of
the king in the manner he has deposed to,
and men exercising with arms in his presence.
Js it not evidence, to show that this very
Reformation Society was instituted for other
purposes than those imputed to it, and tlmt
there was no man who had been so coun-
^Ued or received any such instructions ?
Mr. Justice Heath. — I think it i^ not evi-
dence what they did three days before, be-
cay^e a man may. express his loyalty in one
meeting, and if he has bad intentions he may
JO and act traitorously in another ; I do not
say that these defendants did, I only say this
to show that it is not evidence.
Mr. Erskine. Though we cannot prove
what Mr. Walker said at this meeting, for the
reason your lordship has been pleased to
assign, yet may we not be permitted to provfe
that this Reformation Society, within Ihp
knowledge of the witness, three days before
that time, had no such objects ?
Mr. Justice Heath. — I do not care what ob-
ject they had in meeting, people may meeJ
very innocently, and proceed to criminal acts
afterwards.
Mr. Chamkre, — Was that meeting of the
10th of December the last meeting you had in
the house of Corse? — ^Yes.
What were the general purposes of the- in-
stitution of that society ?
Mr. Law — A question couched in words so
general, I conceive cannot be put to a witness:
they may examine as to facts, as to what was
done and said^ what measures were adopted
by the people there— tlie purposes^ind objects
are matters of the heart.
Mr. Justice Heath,—! think they may show
what is the declared purpose when people
meet together.
Mr. Enkine, — We are going to every meeU
ing where Dunn was, to show that no sucli
purposes as he states either were the avowed
or tne expressed objects.
Mr., Justice Heath. — ^Take it up when Dunn
came.
Mr. Erskine. — ^If he had stated the particular
day on which he was at any meeting, we
should not have troubled your lordship with
any other evidence.
Mr. Justice Heath. — ^You fixed it by the
day after the attack upon Mr. Walker's house.
Mr. Chambre. —The 10th of December you
say was the last meeting you had at Gorse*9
house ; where did you remove to when you
left Gorse*s house ? — ^To Mr. Walker's ware-
house. • ,
How did that happen, and what was the
occasion of that removal? — Some person exr
pressed a wish in the Reformation Society——
Mr. Zgw.— That I object to — ^you removed
the society ?
Mr. CAaw6rc.— Was Mr. Walker applied to?
— Some person said
^Ir. Law. — Go to the first meeting at Mr,
Walker's.
When did you first meet at Mr, Walker's f
— On the 11th of December.
And from that time, as long as the society
existed, you continued to attend the meetings?
— [ continued attending the meetings till the
25lh of March, with very great strictness.
Mr. Erskine. — That comprehends the whole
time that Dunn speaks to.
After the 25th of March did you attend ? — J
attended a few times after that, but cannot
tell how many.
But with great regularity till the 25th of
March ? — Yes.
liow long did you use to attend at a tim^
1 127] S4 GEORGE UL Proceedings against Thos. Walker and oihert^ [L
ft8 near ts you can recollect?-— It was the
general rule to meet at seven, and the busi-
ness of the meeting to begin at half past; I
was scarcely^ ever out of the meetings at the
time the buuness began.
And did you stay till the conclusion^ or
near the conclusion } — I never, to my know-
ledge, went away before the conclusion of the
meeting.
What were the avowed purposes of this
meeting ? — To obtain a reform in parliament.
Now during all this period of your atten-
dance there, did vou ever hear Mr. Walker or
any of tlie defendants in this indictment, pro-
nose any other than peaceable means of re-
form ? — No, I never did.
Did ^ou ever hear them make use of any
expressions that had in your judgment any
tendency to excite any boay to acts of rebel-
lion ?— No, I did not.
Was any mention made of an expected in-
vasion of the French, and of any attempts to
assist them in that invasion? — No, there was
not
Did you ever hear any thing like it pro-
posed at any time? — ^No, I never did.
Had that been the subject of your delibera-
tions, or had such expressions been used
by Mr. Walker, or any of the persons there
•-do you think you must not have heard tliem,
and must not have remembered them ? — ^I am
certain any thing of that sort could not have
happened without my. observation, I attended
to strictly.
Upon the 11th of December the riot hap-
pened, I believe?— It did.
Were you in Mr. Walker's house at that
time ?— I was.
What hapoened on the night of the 11th ?
— ^About half past six o'clock I went from
my house into the town ; when I got into the
market place, I saw several people throwing
stones at the windows and doors of Messrs.
Falkner and Birch*s* shop in the Market-
place ; I went as soon as I saw what was
going on there, to Mr. Walker's, and I was
iiere till the rioters approached his house;
when they first approached it, I was up stairs
in the warehouse ; I very well recollect there
came somebody up and told Mr. Walker the
rioters were before his house, and I well recol-
lect he went down, but he was not long be-
fore he came up again, and said, they had
only broke a few panes of the windows and
vrere gone off again.
Did any mischief happen that night, the
Jlth?---They attacked the house foiir diffe-
rent times ; I was up in the warehouse while
it was attacked three times, before I went
down ; but the fourth time I was in the house
when it was attacked ; it was attacked with
very great violence^
* Messrs. Falkner and Birch were stationers
Sn Manchester, and the sole proprietors and
publishers of the Manchester Herald. Orig.
On that night were there any arms ixi the
bouse that were used for resistmg this mobf
— I saw no arms in the house, only a^souple of
blunderbusses, and I think I recollect »
thing of a pistol, that was all I saw.
Do you know whether any attempt
made.on that night to obtain assistance from
the civil power, from the magistrates ; 'wrere
you present at any requisition of that sort ? —
I was not.
After the riot, to the 85th of Marcfa, dM
you attend the meetings at Mr. Walker's ?— *
X es.
Did you see at any time any arms used at
Mr. Walker*8 house for any other purpose thaa
to protect the Bouse \ — ^No, I never did.
When did you see any arms there used for
that purpose? — I never saw any arms but
upon the 11th of December.
Were there at any time, to your knowledge^
any men exercised or instructed in the use of
arms ? — ^No, there never were.
Could such a thing possibly have existed
at any of the meetings, without your know-
ledge ? — No, it was impossible it should exist
without my knowledge.
Do you know what the arms were that Mr.
Walker had in his house ? — I never saw anr
fire arms, except these blunderbusses, and
some swivels.
I believe you do not know in what way
Mr. Walker became possessed of these
swivels ? — No.
But whatever the arms were, were thej
ever brought out or used for the purpose of
exercise, or any other purpose, to your know-
ledge, except on the 11th of December? —
— ^They were not.
This you are perfectly certain of, that there
never was any training or exercising of men
there ? — ^There never was.
Did you ever hear Mr. Walker, or any body
else belonging to the society, declare a pur-
pose of that sort ? — ^No.
Do you remember Dunn being at any cif
these meetings ? — I have seen Dunn there.
When he was attending there, when yoa
saw him, can you take upon you to say, that
if any declarations of any purpose of tliat sort
had been made, or if there had been any
exercise of arms, you must have seen it and
known it ? — Yes.
If you had heard amongst the members of
this society any proposition or intention to
assist the French in an invasion, would yoa
have continued a member of that society f-^
No, I certainly would not.
Were vou present at the time when a per-
son who has been named, a Mr. Yorke, was
at the meeting ? — Yes, I was. '
Do you know whether he attended one or
more meetings ? — X never saw him there but
once.
Did he take the chair?-— There was no
person in the chsur that night to ipy know*
ledge.
Did Mr. Yorke talk any thing of visiting
1129]
far a Cofupiraey*
the three kin^omSy to see whether there
were persons that would assist the French in
case of an im^asion ? — ^No^ he did not.
Did he speak any thing of an invasion of
the French with finy thousand, or any other
numher of men ? — ^He did not.
Did he express an^ purpose or wish in any
way whatever to assist them in any of the
three kingdoms ? — He did not.
If he had made any public declaration of
that sort, are you certain you must have
heard him ?— ^Yes.
George Clark cross-examined by Mr. Wood,
You continued to meet prettv constantly
from December till Hie S5th of March, did
you ? — ^Yes.
You met every night, once a week? — ^I
inissed two nights.
Had you a chairman at every time of your
meeting? — We did not vote a chairman every
night.
How happened that? — Sometimes we had
no business to do.
How came you to meet so often as once a
week? — We met to discourse on our own
husiness, to discourse on political matters.
You discoursed on political matters from
half past seven till nine, and then went away?
— Yes, we generally broke up about that
time.
You never read anv thing, I suppose?— I
never heard but very few things read.
There were some few things read, were
there? — ^Yes, I have heard a letter or two
read, and I heard an excellent piece that
came from Sheffield, signed *^ A Reformer,"
read.*
^~— — ■ ■ —
• Copy of the paper here referred to.
To the Reforming Societies in Sheffield, and
other persons who concur with them in
sentiment.
Allow a sincere well-wisher to the liberties
of mankind, and particularly to the happiness
and freedom of this country, most earnestly
to exhort you, his fellow townsmen, to conti-
nue to testify, by the whole of your beha-
viour, that " the true spirit of liberty is a
spirit of order," as your Society for Constitu-
tional Information has well expressed It. Be
this your invariable method of refuting and
defeating the numerous calumnies of tnose,
who, from mistaking your views, or other
motives, misrepresent your real designs. You
may be assured, that nothing will chagrin
such as are indeed your enemies, so much as
to find, that you keep steadily, on all occa-
sions, to a strict dbservance of the laws, and
a peaceable conduct; nor would any thing
gratify them more, or be so essentially inju-
rious to the cause of that reform which you
wish to obtain, than for you to be so fer mis-
led, as to commit any act of riot or tumult.
Promote with firmness, by all just, legal,
and peaceable means, a reform in the repre-
sentation of the people, maintainthe fimlom
A,D. 1794. [IISO
You never heard any thing else read ? — Not
to my knowledge.
You mean to swear you never heard any
thing else read ? — ^No, nothing but that and
letters.
You had a good many letters ? — ^No, very
few. '^
Who produced those letters ? Did you all
produce letters ? — We had no letter, unless it
came from Sheffield, or some other society.
How many societies did you correspond
with ? — That I cannot tell.
Did you ever come to any resolutions in
writing at your meetings ? — We had general
ruleSj that were read every night of our
meeting.
Did you come to any resolutions at your
meetings ? — ^Yes.
Mr. Ertkine, — You shall have them all
read.
Mr. Law. — How can you make them evi-
dence?
Mr. Wood. — ^Who kept your resolutions?—
The secretary.
Who was he ? — John Cheetham was secre-
tary one part of the time.
Who was secretary the other part of the
time ?— John Stacey and George M^Callum.
Where is George M'Callum? — I cannot
tell.
Is not he gone to America? — X dp not
know.
George Clark re-examined by Mr. Chamhre.
Did yofi ever at any time see Mr. Walker,
or any other defendant, do any one act that
was inconsistent with the dut^ of a peaceable
citizen ? — No.
of the press — that indispensable safeguard to
your liberties — and assert, in the like calm
and peaceable way, your right to firee discus-
sion on political subjects. But, at the same
time, do all this with propriety and discretion.
Do nothing which can be conceived by others
(except from wilful perversion) to be inimical
to that constitution, one branch of which you
profess it to be your design to restore to its due
purity by constitutional renovation. When
events happen favourable, as you think, to
just and universal liberty, avoid public re-
joicings and processions, because they may
prove offensive instead of conciliating to those
of your fellowcitizens who do not view such
occurrences in the same light that you do ;
because they may afford your opponents, and
those who wish you ill, an opportunity to ex-
cite confusion and disorder; whereby the per-
sons or property of your neighbours might be
injured, wmch Vould be lud to your charge,
though you might be quite clear of any inten-
tionskl harm, and- because they may, from
circumstances attending such processions and
rejoicings, be construed into an insult to the
government of your own country, notwith-
standing you may mean nothing of the kind.
Leavesdl tumult and disturbaAce, all injury
1 ISi] 34 GEORGE III. Proceedings agcimt Tkos. Walker andotherSf 11132
m
Mr. Zoat.-^Does your lordship think it is
proper to put such a question ?
li/ir. Erskine. — Mr. Walker is inflicted be-
fore your lordship and his countrv, for having
confederated ana conspired, with the other
defendants, and others unknown, to over-
throw by force the constitution of this king^
dom. The evidence is, that this confederacy
to those who differ from you, either in politics
•r reUgion, to men of a very different aescrip-
tion from yourselves — ^to men who level the
property and endanger the persons of inno-
cent and meritorious citizens, for exercising
the right of private judgment, to those who
oppose all reform, to those who are zealots
for acknowledged abuses. To such men as
these, let it be left to prove themselves the
only levellers to bo found in this country.—
How contrasted is the spirit of such men, to
that liberal one of moderation and social in-
tercourse, which happily prevails among per-
sons, of all opinions m this town and neigh-
bourhood.
As no instance of outrage and violence can
be justly alleged against the friends of reform
during the ale and still existing alarms, do
you carefully support that honourable and
peaceful character. Manifest to all that you
do not entertain the levelling principles you
are charged with, by a constant regard to the
safety of the persons and property of all
around you. — Protect, but do not destroy. —
Bear reproach with manly firmness, but do
no injury yourselves. Convince by peaceable
behaviour, by obedience to legal authority,
and by that dignity of conduct "which is be-
coming those who are influenced by the prin-
ciples of genuine liberty.
Your townsmen and neighbours, at their
meeting this day, have done nothing un-
friendly to liberty or reform^ but have ex-
pressed a confidence in the peaceable dispo-
sition of the inhabitants of the town. It is
your part to continue to show that you are
worthy of that confidence. They have de-
clared their firm attachment to the govern-
ment and constitution of their country, one
grand principle of which is, to amend what
may be amiss, firom the lapse of time or other
circumstances, and their abhorrence of all
riot and tumult, with a resolution to assist
the civil magistrate in queUing every thing of
that nature. These declarations are agreea*
bletd the sentiments contained in some of
the publications of your Society for Constitu-
tional Information. In confirmation of which,
one of the members of that society gave his
approbation to the proceedings of tlie meeting
)n a manner highly to his credit; and the ge*
neral concurrence, as well fis the handsome
behaviour of the others who attended; ought
not to pass unnoticed.
Permit me to add a few words more. —
What is the object of political reform, but by
suitable regulations to guard more effectually
against oppressioni t9 produce faore g^sa^ral
and conspiracy existed and was bff9i%bt into
overt act. at meetipga, at every one ot whicli
this worthy man was present. X say I have %
right, in defence of my clients, and till his
lordship rules the contrary, I will insist iipoa
that right, that this witness shall say, whe-
ther, at any of these times, he ever heard
Mr. Walker utter ^ny word, or speak incoi^
sistent with the duty of a good subject?
comfort and happiness, to prevent future un-
necessary burdens on the subject, aad'gr^
dually, as well as rationally, and with due
respect to safety as well as justice, to diminish
those which aheady exist.— To the industri-
ous, economical, regular, and orderly mecha-
nic, such a reform would become an essential
benefit, as he could then, by moderate hut
constant labour, enjoy more comfort, main-
tain his familv better, aud be able to provide
a sufficiency for sickness and old ase ; but t«
the idly-disposed, the profligate and drunken
workman, on the supposition of his continu-
ing to be so, it could be of no advantage.
May I then farther urge upon you the ne-
cessity of letting personal amendment go
hand-m-hand with political reform and iiw
formation. When you examine the errors
of government, do not forget to cast an eye
u])on your own failings. These you may cor-
rect by sincere efforts, for this is within your
own power. Your endeavours to reform the
other, though also laudable,' may not be cer-
tain of success. However, you will b6 much
more likely to succeed in public reformatioDy
when you have abandoneu whatever is de-
grading to your own characters. From your
general behaviour, let no one be able to point
out a reformer, or a member of one of your
societies, without, at the same time, be shall
point to an industrious, regular man, ofseb^
manners, and fin orderly, peaceable disposi-
tion. By being meritorious servants, good
masters, kind husbands, and provident fa-
thers, you will acquire a respectability which
will conquer the prejudices of those who now
traduce your intentions. These are means by
which you n^ay indeed put yourselves on an
equality with men. in higher stations^ and but
too frequently become their superiors, in res}
worth and usefulness, in actual comfort and
enjovment, and by the ppssessiop of true in**
dep&dence. This should be your ambitioD.
and in this may you succeed, both in sel&
reformation, and, united with your feliow*
citizens, in that of the representation of the
people, to the extent that will most conduce
to individual, as well as to public happiness
and prosperity, is ib^ cordial wish of
Dec&fiber^l, (Signed) A REFoaMBit. .
1793.
The sentiments contained in the above par*
per, were so much approved by the Mancbes-'
ter Constitutional, Reformation, ai|d Patriotic
Societies, that they uniinimoi|sly <Hf^f^ ^^
thousand copies to be printed snd distri'^ ^^
•-« 113^
Jtrra Cwisptrtteg
A. D. 1^9*.
11134
ni
^i
Mr. Zair.— Then I objcet to thHt.
Mr. Erifeine.— Good God ! whew atn I f
Am I in a British court of jostice ? How is a
man to defend himself under such a charge?
How arc my clients to be exculpated ?
Mr. Xflw.— by legal evidence.
Mr. Justice HfafA.— I think that question
is admissible enough.
Mr. CAow^e.— Did you, at any one of those
Jncctings, see Mr. Walker, Mr. Jackson, Mr.
Paul, or any of those persons that are now in-
dicted, do any one act inconsistent with the
charactcrofapeaceable subject?— No; I have
often heard Mr. Walker
Mr. Justice HmM.— That is hrepilar.
Mr. Ertkine. — Your lordship knows the
constitution of the country gives me no oppor-
tunity of addressing myselito any other court
for any roasion, and therefore I have a better
title to be heatd ; I will prove that Mr. Wal-
ker made use-of expressions there of a direct
contrary tendency.
Mr. Justice Heath.^You should have exa-
mined to that in chief; you are Coming to
particulars now upon a re-examination.
Mr. Erffcine.— It arises upon Mr. Wood's
cross-examination. I am elad to hear that
"we have yow lordship's authority to examine
ha chief to it; we have a great many more
witnesses to eiamme.
Mr. Justice Heath.^lf you have a mind,
ask that general question.
Mr. JLav. — ^It a a com|>lei question, em-
bfacing the witness's idea of what may become
an honest man, pointing at no particular fact
or ekprelsion, which any ihan may answer
accerai»e to his vague ideas of propriety.
Mr. ^f^n^ -^When a n^an is indteted for
^citing sedition and rebellion, is it hot evi-
dence to show that he held alanguage directly
te'pugnant to any sudi i9ta f If he had said
Qod bless the king, woifld not that be evi-
dence?
Mr. Justice HmtA.— If ift was at that meet-
ing.
' Mr. Lam, — ^If it goes to the whole tenor of
hid conduct ; but a man shall not be justified
by saying, God bless the king, in the street
when he has been damning him in his house.
Mr. Justice HeaiA.-»AMc him to their ge-
neral declarations.
Mr. Chamhre. — ^At those meetings, when
Mr. Walker was present, did you hear him
say or do any thing that had a tendency to
disturb the peace of the kingdom ; I am exa-
mining to the meetings of the Reformation
Society between the 11th of December and
the 25th of March ? — When Mr. Walker came
to our meetings he generally addressed us to
attend to peace and good order.
Did you, or did you not hear Mr. Walker
say any thing inconsistent with peace and
fiood order, or any thing against the king and
his government, or any thmg that tended to
subvert it^-or say any thine to excite people to
tdce up arms agsttnst the kine. or to destroy
ibe con8titutk>n f--I never did in my Bfe.
Mn Er$kine.^Vf btXher the witness has not
a right to go on and say, but on the contivrr
he said so and so, am I not at hberty to ask
that?
Mr. Justice Heath.^^tfat in this stage.
One nftke JaVy.— What is the height of the
wai«house in which you used to meet? — I
never took notice how high it was, how many
pair of stairs up.
The height of the room from the floor to
the ceiling r
Mr. Ertkine^^We will give evidence of
that.
James Lomax sworn. — Examined by Mr. Lloyd,
Where do you live ? — In Salford.
Are you a member of any of these societies ?
-—Yes, the Reformation Society.
, When did you become a ihember of that
society?— The first rfght I met, was the
Monday night after Mr. Walker was so ill
used at the riots in Manchester— the 17th of
December I think, and I entered about three
nights after, we met every Monday night.
Did vouoflen attend the societies? — Yes,
I think I did not miss above once, till the
latter end of March, or the beginning of April,
for there were some resolutions signed, that
were put into the last paper Mr. FaUcner
printed; I believe I chd not miss but one
night ; that was somewhere towards February,
but I am not eertafn which ntght it wais.
At what time did you generally go to th6
meeting? — ^About seven o'clock; the last
Monday in the month was my box night, t
either then went at eight, or at seven and left
the place at eight.
How long did you stay ? — I eeneraHy staid
till the end, till they were all goings and I
saw nothing else likely to he done.
What was the avowed object of this society }
— To gain a reform in parliament.
Do you know Dunn by sight ? — ^Yes.
Did you ever sec him there ?— Yes, and one
night lie and I were a good deal together ; I
recollected hkn when I saw hhn to-day : t
have never seen him since.
You have seen Mr. WaBcer there ?— Yes.
Have you ever heard Mr. Walker damn the
king ? — ^No.
Did you ever see any persons exercise with
arms there P — No.
Did you ever see any firelocks there ? — No ;
only tlus first nidit I went, I stopped by the
desire of Mr. Walker that ni&;ht, for he ex-
pected another riot;^ they broke one of his
windows, we went out, and whether Mr.
Walker had a pistol in bis hand when we
went out to find the person, or not, I cannpt
tell ; I saw nothing except in his warehouse
there were six pieces of some sort^ but not
firelocks.
What do you call them ? what lencth ai^
they ?— About this length [describing them to
be about eighteen inches long].
You never saw any person exercising there
with firelocks ?— Never.
I
+
+
] 135] 84 GEORGE In. Proceeding agmmi Thcs. WMer and oihers, [} 13^
Did you ever hear any recommendatioil of
beginning to exercise ? — No.
If there had been such in the society, you
i^ust have seen it? — Yes, and I would btave
scorned to have tarried in it.
Did you ever hear Mr. Walker, or any
other, say they would overthrow the consti-
tution } — I never did.
Would you have stayed in the society if
such a proposal had been made ? — I do not
believe I should one moment.
Did you ever hear Mr. Walker or the others
who were there say or do any thing inconsis-
tent with the duty of good subjects ? — No ; I
have heard Mr. Walker many times advise us
to be peaceable, and say many times he had
no doubt we should be peaceable; I never
saw any thins in that society that they need
to be ashamea of either before God or man.
Did you ever hear them talk of exciting
the people to sedition or rebellion ?— No.
Or exciting the people to take up arms ? —
No.
Did you ever hear them talk of assisting
the French ? — I never did*
If you had heard them talk of assisting the
Prench, would you have stayed with them ?
—No; my principles are those that I would
neither have war offensive nor defensive.
Do you know Mr. Collier? — ^I believe I do ;
be is a tall man.
Do you know what region he is of? — A
Quaker.
Have you heard him swear often ? — ^No, I
never did in my life.
James Lomax cross-examined by Mr. Topping,
Where do you live ? — In Salford.
What business are you ? — A weaver.
You had attendea these meetings then
before you became a member ?-?Yes, I think
it was the third night, but I cannot be po-
sitive.
Then people were admitted to attend these
meetings who were not actually members ? —
I never saw any denied; I nave taken a
man twice myself.
They were admitted to these meetings,
although they were not members? — ^Yes.
Before you became a member you were
admitted, and afler you became a member
you took people wiUi you ? — ^I took one man
with me that had a desire to go.
Upon the 17 th of December you became a
member? — ^No.
You said you went on the 17th, and went
before you became a member ? — No, I never
attendea till the 17th of December.
When did you become a member ? — ^I believe
it was the third night afler.
Did Mr. Walker ask you to become a
member? — No, I went of my own free will;
I do not know that any man asked me.
Do you remember Paine's works being
ffead there ? — ^No, I never saw them there.
Did you hear them read ?«^I never did bear
them read there.
Did you ever hear any part of Paine*s book
read there ? — No.
Have not you, upon your oalliL heard books
read there, which you understood to be Paine*s
books ? — I never did.
That you swear? — I do; I have beardf
books read, I did not know whose thev were ;
if they had been Paine's they would have
mentioned that, I suppose.
You mean to say no books of Paine's were
read there? — ^If it had been Paine's Rights of
Man, I should have known that.
Was it your knowledge of the contents of
that book that entitled you to be a member
of this society ; — ^No.
Had you the knowledge of Paine's book be-
fore you became a memoer of this society, or
after ? — Before, I believe.
Upon your oath, have you never beard
Jackson, one of the defendants, read Painc*s
Rights of Man there ?— No, I never have
that I know of.
You say you know Paioe*s Rights of Man
perfectly well ? — ^Ycs.
Will you venture to swear that you never
heard Jackson read any part of that book
there ?~I never have as I know oC
Do not you know ? — He has read books.
Has he read books repeatedly at these meet«
ings ?^ I only heard one or two read, and those
were abstracts.
Were they not abstracts out of Paine's
Rights of Man ?— They were not.
what was the subject he was reading about
to you ? — ^There was one book, I remember,
that came from London, concerning the un-
equal representation of the people, VbaX came
from the Friends of the People.
Mr. Tcpping, — That came from the Priends
of the PeopleT
Mr. Erikine. — I presume it did, as I believe
a packet was transmitted from the Friends of
the People to the Constitutional Society in
Manchester. I am a member of the Friends
of the People, and if you have any questions
to ask relative to that society, swear me, and
I will answer them.
Mr. rq/)pin^.— Who read that? — Mr. Jack-
son.
Was he the jgeneral reader at the meeting ?
who read besides him? — I have heard Mf.
Walker read newspapers.
Sometimes Mr. Walker read, and some-
times Mr. Jackson? — We had nothing else
to pass our time away with ; and to see bovr
public af&irs were going on.
Jame» Lomax^ re-examined by Mr. Uoyd.
What night was it you saw Mr. W^alker go
out, and you suppose with a pistol ?^It was
on the 17th of December.
Were the riots then continued? — Tbej
broke one of Mr. Walker's windows thai
nisht.
You were not a member then ?-^No.
You went as a fhend to defend Mr. Walkei^s
bouse?— I did.
]
1137]
far a Coufimegt
A. D. 17M.
[1138
ThelMok v<m heard read was, yon eay, the
publication by the seoMty «f the WnaaAs of
Ihe Pepple in London?— It wa9.
Jfjonm B4>bertf sworn. .-^Ezamiped hf Mr.
Vaughan*
Are you a member of the Eeibrmation So*
€3e^ at Manchester ?— Yes.
iIdw k>ne have you been a member of that
Bociety ?— I entered, I believe, on the Slst of
December 1799.
Have you rMilariy attended the meetings
of diat society f—I attesded very veguAarly,
From this time in December till what
"tiBse?— *Tili the 10th davof June 1796.
What was the avowed object of the meet-
ings of this sodetW—To obtun, by constitu-
tional means, a rair «nd adequate refireseft-
tation of the people.
Do you icnow Mr. Thomas Walker ?— Yes.
H^re you seen liim at yo«r Reformation
society? — ^Very irequeotly.
Up to what time did you see Mr. Walker
there ?— Till the SOth day of April.
Have you seen Thomas Dunn thererl — ^Yes
I have.
Have you been present when Dvnnwas
•present?— Yes.
Pid you at any of these times, when Tho-
mas Dunn was present, see any exercising of
men with arms-? — No, never.
Or at any other time, when Dunn was not
there, did you see any exereiaing of men with
arms ? — ^Never.
Did you at any time hear anv language
whatever from Mx;. Thomas Walter, or any
other persons, inciting the society to exercise
with arms, for any purpose, and what ?-^No,
I ne¥er saw tiiem exercise with arms.
In wl^ place did this Reformation 6ociety
meet?— In Mr. Thomas Walker's ware-
house. %
Up stairs, or below stairs? — Above stairs.
* Do vou know the height of this warehouse,
from the floor to the ceUine ? — 1 4io not.
Did yoii ever hear from Mr. Thomas Wal-
ker, or any other persons whatever, anylan-
euage relative to cutting off the head of the
kin^ or any thing of a similar tendency ? —
Never-in my life.
Did you ever hear or see from Mr. Thomas
Walker, «sy language or conduct whi^ever,
that tended to incite the people against Ihe
goi^mment, or to any similar purpose? — I
never did^
Did you ever see in Mr. Thomas Walker, or
any other persons whatever attending that so-
ciety, any conduct imbecoming honest men
and good subjects? — ^Never.
Im you ever see any arms at any time in
the wvehouse ? — Just after the riot I saw
tome pieces of cannon ; tliere were five or six.
What sort of cannon were they, twenty-
ibur or forty-eight pounders?— ^I dio not pio-
perly understand them.
What length were they?«^bout thrae
fiarten of a yard long.
VOL. XXIII.
Did youever see any rausketiy there ^-^No,
nevertut pa the twefrth of December.
You never saw any musketry at any tin^e
during your attendance, but on the sight of
the not, or the night after f — ^No, that was
OBemudcetia Mr. Walker's kitchen.
How often did you see that ?-— Never biit
once.
James Roberit cros^-examined by Mr. Jf^hnaon^
What are you ? — I am in a warehouse.
What trade are you? — ^I am in a ware-
house.
What aie you ? — A warehouseman.
Whom do you l^ve with ? — Messrs. Nichols
and Roberts.
Who introdueed ybu into this society? — ^I
was not introduoed by anv person.
How came you to zo there ?•— I went there
the lath of December, die mght foUowing
the first riot.
Were there more riots than one ?-»The n>ob
met two days together.
I asked who introduced you to this society ;
you said nobody. When did you go to it first ?
-^The 18th of December was the £rst time I
went to Mr. Walker's.
When was the first time yau went to the
society ?•— The 80th of December.
Were you a member then? — No, I didnbt
become a measber until the S 1st of December.
You said, just now, you became a member
on the S Ist of January 1793 ?
Mr. Serjeant CochtU^^Yan have taken him
down -vnipng.
Mr. Johnson, — ^What was your inducement
to become a member of this Reformation
Society ?-*They wished a &ir representation
of the people in pariiament.
Mr. Justicse luaiA.r-Do not let us inquire
into that
Mr. ^p^hine. — It ii evidence ibr the defen-
daots, and if the gentlemen choose to ask it^
I have a right to the evidence.
On the 18th of December, as I was at work,
I saw a great concourse of people met in the
Market-place; I thought there would be. a
riot in the evening ; I went out, went into the
1 Chuvch-yavd, and went to Mr. Walker*^ house
; that night; and I saw such conduct in Mr.
Walker and the people that were there, that
it made me determine to enter among them^
Mr. Jo^MM.— Yott say you saw no exer-
cising;, but you did see arms? — \ never aav
any wMirms, but one musket.
Did you see no other fire-anas ?^Yes, br
piece? of cannon.
Were they large enough to carry a pound
ban?—! cannot tell, I was never used to
thorn.
Did you see any blunderbusses there P-^
J do not «eoQdlect seeing any blunderbusses
there.
Did you ever hear any books read theie?—
I heard one book read.
What was it ?— They caUed it the Irish Ad-
dress to the Scotch,
4 D
1 ISSf] 84 GEORGE HI. Proc€$£ng$ ^ainsi Thou WMer and ahen^ [Ji 140
Who read that ?— Mr. Walker did.
Perhaps ^ou cannot recollect aay particular
passage in it ? — No.
Mr. Erskine,--! dare say you recollect that
is no evidence, therefore you ask it.
Mr. Lav.— -It confirms him as to the read*
ins of books there.
Mr. Justice Heath, — ^There ' is no doubt,
your witness was there.
Mr. Johnson, — ^You heard that read by Mr.
Walker?— Yes.
Mr. Voiigkmn. — ^Tbey did not sbouUer these
swivels^ did they ? — No, never.
Mary Denham sworn. — ^Examined by Mr.
Erskine,
How long have you lived as a servant with
Mr. Walker? — For two years upon the lOlh
of March last.
Do you remember the attack made upon
your master's house ? — ^Yes.
Were you in the house at .that time ?— Yes.
I suppose you were pretty much frightened.^
— Yes, I was.
Do you remember any cannon?-— Yes.
W hen were these cannon brought to town ?
— The day after the riot
Where were they before ? — ^In the country.
At Barlow-Hal J, where Mr. Walker lives ?—
Yes.
They are little tbinn upon carriages ? — Yes.
They were brought mto town the day
after the riot? — Yes.
Before the time that these cannon came, do
you remember seeing fire-arms in your mas-
ter's house ?— No.
Were you admitted to all the parts of the
warehouse, and the house — you went where
you pleased, I suppose ?^-Yes.
• Did you ever see any men' exercising with
arms there? — ^No.
Did you ever hear of any thing like it ?— No.
Did you ever see anv anna tfaece before
the time of the riots? — No.
1 f any such exercise of people with arms had
taken place, must you not have known it f —
Yes.
Why should you have known it? -They
ecmld not do it in the warehouse, or house,
without my seeing or hearing it.
. Did you ever either see any such thing
done, or hear of its being done r — No, never.
- Can you take upon you to swear that it was
not done? — Yes.
After the riots, we understand these cannon,
and some muskets, and other arms were
brought for the purpose of defending the
bouse ? — Yes.
What was done with them ailer the 19tb
of December? — ^They went into the country
again I believe.
What was it that went into the oountiy
again ? — ^The cannon.
What became of the blunderbusses, pistols,
and muskets ? — I never saw any.
You never saw any after the riot, nor be-
fore ?— No.
You do not know whete these fSaiinoa wou
lo?— ^No, (saw no more of them.
Maty Denham cross-examined by Mr. Jdaso.
Were you a member of any of these Refor-
mation Societies ? — ^No.
Did you ever attend them ?— No.
How could you tell what was going Uxwmm^
at any of those meetings? you did not gene-
rally attend the warehouse? — No.
Your business was in the house ?^-Yes.
But how can you pretend to say what was
done in the warehouse; they niisht Inve
been in the warehouse for what you Know ?—
Not to exercise they could not ; I must have
seen them through the windows.
Have you been accustomed to see asca
exercise ? — ^I have seen the soldiers esercise.
They did not always fire when they exe^
cised?— No.
Have you not seen them exercise, when
they made very little noise ?— No^ I do nst
know that I have.
Have you never seen them present, ani
rise, and kneel, and so on> you say there
were no blunderbusses or muskets ?*-! acvsr
saw any.
And if there were, you must have seen
them, must you ? — ^Yes.
Mr. Ertkine. Is there not a double ligiit
throueh the warehouse? — Yes.
If tney had been exercising with fiie-ams
there, must you not have seen and heaid
them ? — ^Yes.
Martha Wilkinson sworn. — Examined by Mr.
Serjeant CockelL
I understand yo« live in the service of Mr.
Walker; you attend the Miss Walkers^ as
their maid ? — Yes.
How long have you lived in Mr. Walker's
service ? — More than three years and a halC
Where were you at the time of the riot, the
first night Mr. Walker's house was al>
tacked ? — ^At Barlow.
Mr. Walker's country residence ? — ^Yes.
When did you return from Barlow? — The
day after.
How long did you continue after you had
returned from Barlow ? — Till the beginning of
May,
Durins that period you lived in his house
at Manchester ?^I did.
Do you remember after your return from
Barlow, whether any arms of any sort weie
sent for?— No.
Do you remember the cannon? — Yes.
'Where did they come from? — From Bac-
low, before I came.
Hvw long before?— The same day I came^
That was the day after the riot?*-Yes.
You know Mr. Walker's warehouse ?-*Yes.
Can you, from any room in the house, see
into the warehouse r— >Yes.
Is the warehouse so near to that part of the
house, from whence you can see into the
warehouse^ that if any noise, for instance the
1141]
Jfrrn Conspiracy*
clattering of rararw^s, or any thing of that
soict had happened, you could have heard
them? — Yes.
You have seen soldiers exercise at Man-
chester ? — I cannot say I ever did.
But if there had been any noise of that
sort, you were near enough to have heard,
and to have seen I — Yes,
Did you ever hear or see at any time in
your life, any men exercising in arms at Mr.
Walker*8 ?— No, never.
If such a thing had happened when these
weekly meetings were helri, must you not at
some time or other have heard it? — Most
certainly I must.
' And you are prepared, safely and conscien-
tiously to swear, that no such thing happen*
*ed ? — I am.
Describe the situation of this window?—
There is but a narrow yard that parts the
warehouse and the house, and the windows
of the warehouse, and the windows .of the
room in which I was. were opposite.
Then if any thing <» that sort had happened,
you must have seen and heard it? — I cer-
tainly should.
Do you know the height of the warehouse?
^-I do not.
You know the gentlemen who came to Mr.
Walker's? you know that clubs were held
there? — ^Ycs.
I confine myself to the time during the
holding of the clubs; did you ever bear any
tioise tntn of arms ? — -N^ver.
Did you ever see any exercising of men
at those times, or at any other ? — Never.
Martha Wilkinson cross-examined by Mr.
Law,
»
In what room do you usually live ? — In the
nursery ; the nursery in general.
Is the nursery higher or lower than the
warehouse ? — Fromahe nursery windows we
can see into several rooms of the warehouse.
Is it high<9 or lower ?~It is higher than
one part of the warehouse, and lower than
•another.
Is it as high as the upper room of the
warehouse ?— ^I t is not quite so high.
Will you say, that you can conveniently,
from that room, see into the upper room of
the warehouse ? — ^We can see into it.
Can you see from one end to the other of
the warehouse, from the nursery ?—^Yes,
from one end to the other of the. upper ware-
house.
• The upper warehouse' of all ? — ^Yes.
And were you every night, for fortv nights
together, when these persons were there, so
watcbine their proceedings, that you could
4now if a person had put a musket to his
shoulder? — I was not constantly watching,
init I have no dOubt if there had been such a
thing I should have known it.
Did you observe all that passed there ?—
*We frequently watched then.
What did they 4p wh^n you watched
A. D. 1794. [1142^
them ?— We never saw but they were sitting
still.
Talking?— Yes.
You saw books, I take it for granted ?— No,
I did not.
You never saw any thing read ? — Never.
But if there had been Paine's book, or any
other book read, you must have seen it ? — I
did not see any book.
If they had been so employed, you must
have seen that too ? — I cannot say.
Why could not you see a book held up,
judt as well as see a musket held up ? — I never
did see a book read.
How many might there be in the room
at a time? — I cannot say the exact number.
• You have seen Dunn there ? — ^No.
Were there twenty, thirty, forty, fifly there?
— I carmot tell.
Do you think there weie so many as forty
or fifty ?— I do not know.
Had you never the curiosity to count them
when there was a ^ood number ? — Never.
But if there had oeen books, you think you
must have seen them, and you never saw any
read ? — I never saw any book read.
Martha Wilkinson re-.exgpained by Mir. Ser-.
jeant CochelL
From this nursery, in which vou frequently
were in the evenings, if there had been men
exercising, you must have seen them ? — Yes. '
What sort of windows are the warehouse
window^-?— Nearly the length of the ware-
house.
Francis RoberU sworn .-^Examined by Mr.
Chambre.
You are a servant to Mr. Walker? — ^Ycs.
How long have you lived with him ?— I
came to live with Mr. Walker in the ye^r
1791 ; I have lived with him ever since.
You were a servant to him, of course, when
the riots happened in Manchester? — ^I was.
Mr. Walicer has a house at Manchester,
and a country-house at Barlow ?— He has.
At the ^ime of the riots were you at Man*
Chester, or Barlow ? — At Barlow.
When did you come from Barlow ?*-^The
morning following.
Do you know what fire-arms Mr. Walker
had for the protection of 1>oth hb houses ?---
There was notlung for the protection of httf
house exoept two pistols, and two blunder-
busses, and two fowling-pieces, that I ever
saw.
Had he any swivels? — Yes, half a dozen. "
Where were the swivels at the time when
the riot happened ?— At Barlow-Hall.
When were they removed from Barlow to
Manchester ? — ^The day after the riots.
You do not know how he became possessed
of those swivels ? — I do not.
When you came from Barlow, how long
did you continue at Manchester?— We cam^
tb^ 19th of Decembej*, and returned back the
5th of May, . . >•
114S] M GEORGE UL ProeeeAgi &gntui Thm. Wdker and Men^ {1 144
loiinediately after you came od the IfiUi
of t)eceiDber, and for some time after, was
there any watch kept at Mr. Walker's bouse,
to preTeot any mischief being done to the
house — did people sit up all night? — ^Yes^
th^ did.
Did you sit up for the protectioa of the
house sometimes? — ^Yes.
How long were they obliged, for the sacu-
riiy of the house, to keep up this sort of
watch ? — For the course of a month, or tber»>
abputs.
Were you often among those who sal up ?
—I was.
Of course you were in the house at all the
roeetines of the Reformation Society, that
tooK place between the ISth of December
and the 5th of May ? — I was.
Had you ever occasion to £0 into the room
where these meetings were held ? — I had fre-
quent occasion. ■•
Were these meetings held with open doors,
or were the doors locked?—! always found
the doors wide open.
There was no sort of secrecy about the pur*
posesof their meeting?~Not to my knowledge.
Have you stayeaahy time when people
were in the room, so as "to hear the conversa-
tion that passed ? — I cannot say I have.
Did yoo ever at any dene hear uy expres-
sions made use of, damning the king ? — No-
thing of the sort
Did you ever hear any expressions of any
sort made use of, to incite apy of the people
there to break the peace ? — I have no Know-
ledge of any thing of the sort.
- Wa% th^re atiy exercise of men with guns
ior other arms ? — Nothing of the sort.
Do you think yi>u must have known it, if
any such thing had been practised in the
place where these people met, or in any part
of your master's house? — I am sure such
things could not be made use of, but I should
have come to the knowledge of it, some how
or other.
Did you at any time whatever see or hear
any thmg done or said there, that had any
tendency to disturb the public peace? — ^I
never did.
JFranck Roberti cross-examined by Mr. Wood.
How many people micht there be at those
meetings when you saw Uiem ? — ^There might
be twenty or thirty, and sometimes more.
. How many men do you think there might
be, fifty or sixty, perhaps ? — I believe not so
many.
How many do you think ? — There might
he thirty-five, or so.
Is that the most you ever saw ? — I do not
icnow in particular that it is.
. Have you Qot seen sixiy» or more, th^e ? —
No.
Ybu will not go higher <tbaB thirty-five ? —
Uo^ I will not
Did you knoir those people who had got
^erej— No.
I bcfieve you weie very seldom at th«^^
■leetings; did you ever stay a meeting llu cu^^
from beemning to end ?— No.
How kmgmight you stav at a time ? — Ttluee
or four mimitfUy or so, while I delivcied mg
When yoo stayed up to protect the
what had you to protect it with? — ^We bed a
sword or two.
How many might stay up with joo ? dU
any of the people that attended t*
inss stay with you ?-^They aid.
The Reformation Society stayed _ ,
did thi^ ?— Some of those people tbmft inet
in the warehouse.
How many nights might thev stay up with
you ? — I cannot pretend to aay bow maoy.
How many may you have bad at a. IIbm t»
stay up with you? — ^Four or five.
Not always the same people I auppoac?— >
No.
Franeii Roberh re-enmined l^y Mf . Ckem
OtCt
You never particularly, I suppose^ oouotsd
the number, to know exactly how
there might be ? — ^I never did.
i
^
Mr. Edward Green sworn. — V-iratnW^^^
Mr. Lloyd.
You, I believe, were apprentice to Mr.
Walker, and brought up in his wanAwuee?—
Yes.
How long have you been with hasi ? — It
will be eight years in July.
Do you Kmember the night of the ciols ?—
Yes.
Do you remember whether there were any
armseot to defend Mr.Walk^s house? —
Yes, were were some got
bo you know what arms they were?— Tbey
were muskets.
Were there any swivels?— No.
Not that ni|ht ?— No.
Mr. Justice neatL^^Uow many muaketaf—
I do not know the number.
Mr. Ltwd. — ^Were you in the house theiiist
night of the riot? — I was.
Do you know when the swiveh wcie
bought?— They were a present to Master
Walker, by Mr. Jackson ; tliey were bongfat
at Mr. Livesey's sale.
Do you know any occasion upon which
those swivels were fired ? — I remember they
were fired upon the anaivevsary of the repeal
of the fustian tax.
At any other time .>'— I was not preeent at
anv oth^ time.
What is your business at Mr. Walker's^
chiefly?— In the foreign counting house.
Is that up stairs^ er below^ m his wai^
house ?— Up stairs.
Mr. Justice Htatki^jyo you live \n thi
house ? — ^I lived in the house five years.
Mr. XA^ref.— In what part of the waM^ouse
is the foreien counting-house ?-^Itloeks-l»*
watodsSallaiiy uptwopairefstairk
1145]
for a Campiracjf*
A* D. 17M.
[1146
Do you know the loom wbK» tk» aorialies
metP— 4t wasinAVOom up aaolfaer pur of
slainiy whore tho seeielies met.
Have you ever nad oceafiion to go into that
room whea they were met?— -I had fiequeiit
occaeiooflto go up lo Mr. Walker upon bu^
sinesd.
Did you find the door either locked or fkst-
ened ?— Never.
Did they eeeia to be about secret huatnees ?
—Not at all.
Did you go in without iutemipttoil ?— Yes.
Have you had docaeion to go in more than
once in an evening? I may have gone two
or three timee, not finding Mr. Walfcer in the
first time..
How near it that room to the room where
you used to lit mitkig?««-Up another pair of
stdirs.
Is part of that room, over the room that
yew weNi in f^t id.
Did you ever see any men exercising with
erme when you went up ?<■— Never.
When you weie writing, did you ever hear
any arms clashing ?-^Never.
Were there carpets upon the floor, or any
thing of that kind, to prevent the sound ?««
No.
I understand that you never saw any men
'ezereieing with arms f'-^Nevtr.
Do you know what is the height of that
room ?*^1 do not know.
Do you know whether it is such a room
that a man could ehouldor a firelock }^1 do
not know ; I never took partieulor notice.
Did j[Ou tend word before veu went in, or
^ in without giving notice /•-•Without giv-
ing notice.
When you went in, did you hear aav con*
vertation--H!lid you ever hear Mr. Walker
damn the king ?-^Ntf.
Or talk of overturning the cooititiitioo f«»
Nevefj
Did jreu hear atiy oonverslition of aiding
and assisting the French \ — ^No.
You never heard any thine of the kind f-^
No. ^
When you went in, did they seem inaitantW
to cease their conversation, or to |go on with
it P— They went on with the business they
twcJte about
Whenever you went in, did you hear Mr.
Walker, or any other person, say any thing
to exfcite disturbance of the peace ^^-^Notal
all
Or exciting them to take up arms lo aid the
Prench ?^ No, . never.
Or for any other purpose ?<^No, by ne
means, I never heard any thing of the kind.
Or to ovcithrow the constitution ?«-^o.
Mr. Kdward Green cross-examined by Mr.
Topping,
If I understand you, yosi have been tevnal
Mtffs with Mr. Walker f--^Yes, I have known
mri Walker eleven years.
• You. were a persoo, thereibfs^ perfecUy
well known as one of Mr. Walker's family f —
Yes.
Can you take upon you to say, how many
people ydo have ever seen mssembM at any
one time?— < Very likely seventeen, eighteen,
or twenty.
Will you take upon yourself to say, ^ou
have not seen to the number of fifly or sixty
et a time f — Upon the night of the riots there
were a good many.
Can you take upon you to say, yon have
not seen to the number of fiAy or sixty assem-
bled P-^I will take upon me to swearliiave
not seen, what I conceive to be such a num*
ber as tfaat.
You do not mean to say you can form an^
accurate estimate of the number ?-^No.
You were not a member of this society ?—
I was not.
You never went up to this room, unless
you had occasion to speak to Mr. Walker,
then vou went, and he vras called out lo you f
-**I always went in to him.
My fnend has asked you as to havipg
heard, or not, expressions used about the
king ; now can you take upon you to swear
what they were doing, from what you heard ?
•—Their conversation seemed to turn upon the
question of a reform in parliament.
Whether you mean to swear, that you knew
or ever heard from any individual there, any
particular expressions used at all, that you
can relate to the jury ?->-I do not.
You were not a member of the society?— >
No.
Your object in goins there was not to learn
what they were doing f— No.
When you did so there, it was merely to
speak to Mr. Walker about his own business
as a merchant ?-^Yes.
What size is the room in which this society
was held ?— It is a long room.
And will hold a sreat number of people,
will it not ? —It will hold a good many people.
Is it the leneth, or half the length of this
room ?--*I thinX: it is nearly the lei^;th of tlus
Is there not another room opon the same
floor ( does all the attic story make only one
room ?-**There is another room.
There is another room upott the same floor,
besides the room in which the society was
heU?--Yes, tiiereb.
You said you thoueht part of it was over
the ooonting iKmse i^ere youare ?<^Ycs, part
of it is over that room.
Mr. Edward Green re-examined by Mr.
Lloyd.
The reason why you think the warehouse
Is over the countmg-hoose is, that both
soonwlook into Salibrd?— Yes both rooms
come to the end of the buildinj^.
Was it any part of yonrbusmeeito see that
all the fires were out in this warehouse, and
to lock up At tiightt^-4tis itiy general custom
togothrMi^thewarehoiieey endto lockitup*
1143] MGBORGEUL PnutSmp H^>ut Th^ W^kernd oAen, |
I bdieve jou were -nrj wldMi it
e«tiop;didjau ever ste^ameeUagllN
ftam bcgjinnin^ to end ? — No.
bnnedwtely Bfter fou oum oo tbe IflUi
of December, and for some time tittx, ww
there any watch kept at Mr. Walket'i house,
to prcTeoi any miachief beiac dnte to tfoe
house — did people ut up alf night?— Yea^
they did.
Did yaa lit up for the protectioD of the
houM sometioiea? — Ym.
How long were tbej obbgcd, for the aocu-
rily uf the house, to keep up this aoct of
watch r— For the course of a otonth, or tbete-
abfHita.
Were you often among those wbo Mt up f
—1 was.
Of course ]mu were in the house at all the
ineetiDgs of the Befonnation Society, that
tooic place between the lath of Decaoiber
and the Sth of Hay ?_I was.
Had you ever occaeion to ro into the room
where these meoliog* were held i — 1 bad fre-
quent occasion. >
Were these moetinga held with open doon,
or were the doar* locked!— I always found
the doori wide open.
There was no sort of Mcrecy about the pur-
posesoftbeiriDeetiasP— Not tomy knowledge.
Have you stayea any time when people
were hi the rooni, so as to hear the conversa-
tion that passed i — I caiiBot say I have.
Did yoQ ever at any time h(»i any aipres-
■ions made use of, danniog the kiqgi — No-
thing of the tort.
. Did you ever hear any expressions of any
sort made use of, to incite any of tbe peopM
there to break the peace} — 1 have no know-
ledge of any thiog of the sort.
■ Was thtre afiy exercise of men with gtms
or other annsP — Nothing of the sort.
Do you think you must have known it, if
any such thing bad been practised in the
(lace where these people met, or in any part
of your niacier's houw? — I am sure such
things could not be made use of, but I abould
have come to the knowledge of it, some how
or other.
Did you at any time whatever see or bear
say thing done or said there, that had any
teodeocy tb disturb tbe public peace P—X
Franck Robertt cro3s,exaroineU by Mr. Wood.
How uHoy people miKbt there be at those
meetings when you nw Uiem ?— There might
be twenty or thirty, and sometimes more.
Ho« many men do you think there might
be, 11% or suty, perhaps P— I believe not to
many.
How Kiaay do you tiiink i — There might
be thuty-Gve, or su.
Is that the most you ever saw f—l <Id not
know in particular tha^ it b.
. Ha«e you sot seen sixty, or toon, th«i« l~
No-
you Btmy U *
' ao, while I
WbenyonaUyed up to protea thel
what had you to protect it with I — We I
How many mi^t stay up witb jou
any of the people tbst atteiKkd tbese,
iuHslw wdh you ? — ^Thej did.
The RefonnaUon Society stayed with
did they! — Sonw of thoae people thai
in the warehouse.
How many nights miofat they stay up
you !— I cannot pieteacTto ssy now mai^
How many may you have bad at a Ha
stay up with you?— Four or five.
Not always tbe aame people I lujipv
Franeit Roierti n-tuxminod try Mr. O.
tbe number, to know
there might be ? — I nevsr did.
Mr. Edvard Grttn swom. — ^Exafflttrf
Mr. UoyA
Walker, and brousht up ii
Yes.
How long have you beoi vritb !>■>/--'
will be eight years in July.
Do you remember the tughlof tbeiiols!-
Yea. I
Do you tanember whether there wen m
aims got to defend Mr.Walk^'s hooK^
Yea, Uiere were some got
i>o you know what arms they wtfef—W]
i 145] Jbr a Camprae^
Do yM kww tin mom wbH* tka ucMei
roetP— ^tt wmim»KwiD up aaotbat pair cf
stairi, whtratiM MciflttM met.
Hava ywi ewet tiad occuwn to fO into Ibat
, wbcD they won owtf—I had fiequwit
' — <to go up u Mr. Walker upm bu<
bid you find the door mUmt lodud or faet-
ened f— Never.
Did thay Hen to to about Mcrat buatnM) ?
— MotataU.
Did j'ou go in without iutemipliMl !•— Ysi.
Ban yon had OocaMMt to go in more than
once in an eveningf I maj have mbs two
«r three linM, not finding Mr. W^kai in the
first time.
H»w Mar ie tbit room to the room «rfaere
yoHUMct toMI«ntiag^— UpaaotboT pair of
stairs.
Is part of that room, over the room that
ytw wete in f—tt ii.
Did you ever we any men exerciung with
M ma wtteo you went up F'— Narar.
When you veie wriung, didyou ever bear
any anna dashing f— Na»er.
Ware there onrseli upon the fioor, or n
thing of that kino, to prevent the Mundf-
Jfo.
I underttatid that you neiar saw any ibea
'eieruiing with atmi f— Never.
D«you know what U tbe bMght of that
room f— I do not know.
Do you know whether it ie wch*]
thAt a man could tbooldar a firektck i—1 do
not know ; I never took particular notice.
Did jKiu tend word before you went in, __
^ in without giving aotioer— Witbout giv^
ins notice.
When yuu went in, did you bear any c«k
verlation— -did you ercr hear Ur. Walker
damn the king ^--Nd.
Or talk of svertuming tbe cooititiitioo f-»
Did jrau hear any eonwnuioa of aiifing
and asakting the Frenab tSo.
You never heard any thing of the kind t—-
No.
When jrou went in, did tbcy lecm inBtantly
to ceaae their convtrwtien, or to go on with
it?— They went on with the busUKts they
wOe about
Whenever you went in, dkl you liear Mr.
"' Iher, or any other perwn, say any tiling
»ite dietwibaoce of the peece F— Not at
ir exciting tbem to take up annt to Bill tiie
it^"
A. D. 179t. t*I*6
aaoneef Hr. Walkn's hmilyF—
Can you take upon you In aay, how ■
pMplc yon bava e*er seen aiaemUed i
one time P— Very likely seventeen, eighteen,
or twenty.
Will you take upon youTKlf to say, you
have sot wen to the number of fifty or aiily
M a time '—Upon ihe night of tbe riots there
neagood many.
Can you take upon you to aay, yon lave
not wen to the number of 6Ay or sixty amem-
bled N-'I will take upon me to swear I have
not seen, what 1 conceive to be such a num-
ber as that.
You do nut mean to i^ you can fom any
Bccnrato eslimata of the number f— No.
You were not a member of ihU aodety i—
You never went up to this nom, ooleia
you bad Dccnsion to ipeak to Mr. Walker,
then Tou went, and he was called out to you f
~I always went in to him.
My fnend baa asked you as to havipg
heard, or not, expressions used about the
king ; now can yuu toke upon you to swear
what they were doing, from what you heard f
— Their conversation seemed to turn upon the
(|ueBtion of a reform in parliament.
Whether you mean lo swear, that vmi knew
or ever heard from any individual tnere, any
particular expressions used at all, that you
can relate to tbe jury f ~I do not.
You were not a member of the society ?-•
No.
Your object in going there was not to learn
what they were doing 1— No.
When you did go there, it was merely to
speak to Mr. WaUter about his own business
at a merchaot P— Yes.
What size is tbe room in wbicb tfii* society
was held ?— It is a long nram.
And will hold a great oumber of people,
will itnotf-Itwillliold agood many people.
Is it tbe length, or half lb* »«ngth of tbis
room !~I think it a aear^ tbe length of this
room.
Is there not another mw "Ppn the same
fioor { does aU the aitie atorj make only one
room f-There is anolia''"^- ,
There is another »<x«."f<", """ •««e flow,
besides the room in 'bicb the aocwty wi
held'— Yei, tbata-
You said yoothDU^»l»rt of n wa**^
tbe (wrnliiW'"*" wherer
ofkiswffttaliWD.
tercyouarer — YcM** s.
m n«wi wby you think the ««*?
I ;. ««■ rte eoontsnjrJionse i^ •v' '=
ZA**^ Sal^f-Yes *s*J^ «
^guibatad of the buildii^ ^,.-i^ ■'^
BWil*"/ P»t of yowUuSi^—
'Ihefiie* wero out inthii^?^
Ni up It nigbtf-~lt ii «^
sl&roqgb the wnreb^^
1147]
Proceedings agabtd
Did you find any arms lyine there, when
you went through the rooms to lock all up? —
Never.
Did you go into this room generally ? — ^Yes,
I did.
And you did not see any arms lying there?
— Never.
Mr. peorge Duckworth sworn. — Examined by
Mr. Vaughan,
Are you acquainted with the house of Mr.
Walker, at Manchester ? — 1 am.
You are also acquainted with the ware-
house of that house, and the height of it?—
Yes, Mr. Walker took me through the house
and warehouse a few days ago, to show them
to me ; I had not seen the warehouse before,
only occasionally when I went on business.
Mr. Walker showed me the different rooms
of the warehouse upon every story. I mea-
sured the height of two stories, which ap-
peared to be the highest, and the lowest.
The highest room, to the best of my recollec-
tion (for I did not expect to be examined here^
was nine feet high between the beams, ana
eight feet six inches high under the beams.
Mr. Law. — ^You did not measure them ? —
Yes, I did.
Did you make any minute ? — No. The low-
est story was seven feet six inches high under
the beams, and eight feet between the beams ;
I took a musket out of the room in which
Mr. Walker had put the arms, and fixed the
bayonet, to shoulder it : when I shouldered
it, the point of the bayonet touched the ceil*
ing : if 1 had thrown it up to my shoulder in
the manner they do in the manual exercise,
the bayonet would have stuck into the ceil-
ing ; I could not poise it. This was the high-
est room in the warehouse. The rooms in the
uppermost story are the highest.
Mr. George Duckworth, cross-examined by
Mr. Law.
You had no idea of giving any account of
this at Lancaster, when you made the mea-
surement ? — No. I desired Mr. Walker to get
9ome person to make the measurement.
Are you not the attorney for Mr. Walker?
— I am, but I did not examine the whole of
the evidence. Mr. Seddon examined some of
the witnesses.
You say you made no minute in writing of
this ? — ^I did not.
Where did you get the musket that you tried
with ? — Out of the room where Mr. Walker
had the small collection of arms, which he
informed me were what he had at the time of
the riots.
So you had a musket !— Yes.
How many did you see in the armoury ?—
About a dozen, I believe, of one sort or other.
The arms were covered with dust. The room
was full of dust The arms were of different
sorts.
There were twelve muskets? — ^No, not
twelve muskets, but different kinds of fire
arms*
With bayooM all ?— There were scmse inii»-
ketooQB with spriac bayonets.
Mr. Walker. — I nave an infeatoi^ in mv
pocket, of the arms I had at the tiixfte oftix
riets ; I have the arms now. The inweniofy
[oiSering it to Mr. Law] is veiy much at jcnr
service.
Mr. Lam. — ^Tbe beam of this room cocoes
very deep down doesit ?'7-About six inches.
Suppo^ngtliere had been no beams coining
down, the room would have been the lieigbt
of nine feet? — ^Yes.
What did you measure with ? — ^Hr. m^alker
had a four-foot rule.
You made no minute at the time ? — ^I did
not.
Did you advise a carpenter to be sent far to
measure it — ^I desired Mr. Walker wotxld get
some person to measure it.
Mr. Duckworth, re-examined bjr Mri
Vaughaiu
What arms were they that you saw there t
were they different sorts of arms ? — ^A ftv
muskets, a few musketoons,
What are musketoons? something of the
nature of a blunderbuss ? — ^Yes.
Mr. Justice Heath. — There is one obv
I shoukl be glad to hear what Mr. '.
upon it^it struck me early in the course of
this business — I did not mention it out of ten-
derness to the defendant, that he might luive
an opportunity of clearinjg his character by
calling his witnesses, but it appears to one tlat
this can be nothing else than nigh treason.
Mr. Law. — I submit to your lordship that it
is not high treason ; but at the same time, if
these facts could be so understood, the crown
might prosecute as foir a misdemeanor ; that
was settled in the case of the king against
Hampden,* and it has been laid down in a
great number of cases. I could cite authoii-
* The precedent here alluded to, is the trial
of Mr. Hampden, for a misdemeanor, in tha
latter end of the reign of Charles 'id, February
the 6th, 1683, before judge Jefferies : when
Mr. Hampden was fined by him and the rest
of the judges of the King's bench, in the sura
of forty thousand pounds !
Mr. Hampden remarked to the court that
his father being alive, his fortune was but
small, and that merely a life estate. To this
Mr. Justice Withins said that they could not
take cognizance of what his estate was ; the
punishment was to be proportioned to the
offence, and the chief justice (Jefferies) adde^
that considering some verdicts, this would be
thought a moderate fine.
On passine this sentence, Mr. Hampden
was told by the court, that the matter ot th^
offence was such as would have made him
guilty of high treason, had there been two
witnesses. The essence of a crime therefore
(according to this precedent) does not consist
in the nature of the.act committed, but is tp
be at one time high treason^ at another some*
nm
Jbt a Ckf^sprmei/t
A.D. 179*,
tiiso
ties from lord chief justice Hale, and other
books, where the crown has prosecuted as for
a mi^demeaDor — that the crown, in cases of
felony, might drop some of the circumstances,
and prosecute as for a misdemeanor~*the
crown may elect to prosecute the crime in its
mildest form. This is a point of such maeni*
tude, and having been solemnly decided in
eases I could refer to in the State Trials, I beg
your lordship to have the s;oodness to let this
be found- upon a special verdict.
m — — I. . I. I 11 ■ II I
thing else, as the prosecutor is prepared with
one or more witnesses to prove it.
]tf r. Hampden remainea in prison, and un-
der execution for the fine, till the 30th of De-
cember 1685, the first year of James the se-
<^nd, when a new witness appearing, he was
a^n indicted for the same onence, but then
laid as high treason. *' His friends offered
money for his pardon to some in power, who
were the lord (judge) Jefferies, and Mr. Petre,
the sum was six thousand pounds, and that
was effectual. It is not possible for a man to
suffer more than he did/'
'' By the help of the mone^, on condition
he would plead guilty to his indictment, he
was to come off; whereupon, pleading guilty,
he was discharged ; payuig 300/. or 400/. to
Burton and Graham for the charge of his par-
don."
*' His abject submission did indeed procure
him apardon ; but the shame of such a mean
behaviour so sunk and disordered his spirits,
that he was never quite right after it; and
about ten years after he cut his own throat.''
The fine of forty thousand pounds, without
regarding the amount of a man's fortune, and
the doctrine of converting high treason into a
misdemeanor, both stand upon the same pre-
cedent— ^The one is as justinable as the otner.
But is it consistent with the spirit of the
laws of England, that the difference of the
technical phrases in an indictment, shall put
a man into the peril of that judicial discretion
which may fine him forty thousand pounds,
whether he has it or not, and commit him '
until it be paid ? thai is^ in other words^ which j
ma^ imprison him for life. |
Since Mr. Hampden's trial, and soon after !
the Revolution, viz. in the 7th of VVm. 3d, an
act was passed *' for regulating trials in cases
of treason, and misprision of treason,'' where-
in it ivas enacted, that every person accused
and indicted for high treason, or misprision
of treason, should have a true copy of the
whole indictment delivered to him nve days
at the least before his trial ; and that no per- <
son should be indicted, tried, or attainted of
^high treason, or misprision of treason, but by
and upon the oaths and testimony of two law-
. ful witnesses, either both of them to Uie same
overt act, or one of them to one, and the
. other of them to another overt act of the same
treason. And that every person, who should
be 80 accused, indicted, and tried, should have
|ft copy of the panel of the jurors returned to
Mr. EnJUne, — ^No^no.
Mr. Lam. — ^I want to have the fact found—*
I pray it with the joint advice of some of the
most learned persons in the profession, I mean
Mr. Serjeant Hill, the attorney and solicitor
general.*
Mr. Erskine, — Whatever opinion I may en-
tertain upon the argument Mr. Law has offer-
ed to your lordship, I will not controvert it
here; but I shall insist upon the twelve ho-
nourable gentlemen in that box, telling the
try him, delivered to him two days at the
least before his trial, and that no evidence
should be admitted or given of any overt act,
not expressly laid in the indictment And by
an act passed in the 7th of Anne, ^ for im-
proving the union of the two kingdoms^'' it
was further enacted, that every person indict-
ed for high treason, or misprision of trea*
son, should have a list of the witnessea
to be produced on the trial for proving the
said indictment, and also a list of the jury,
with the names, professions, and places of
abode of the witnesses and jurors, together
with a copy of the indictment; and that the
same should be delivered to the party indicted,
ten days before the trial, in the presence of
two or more credible witnesses.
But these statutes aro no loneer a protec-
tion for the subject, if he may ne proceeded
against for a conspiracy, which is only another
name for the same accusation, while it re-
moves and destroys these salutary provisions
and safeguards of the people.
It was unnecessary for Mr. Walker and the
other defendants, indeed it would not have be-
come them, to avoid the verdict of a jury, by
resorting to any legal objections ; yet if the
doctrine laid down in the case of Hampden
be at this day law, how many innocent men
under a state prosecution, without any pre-
vious knowledge of the jurymen and their po-
litical partialities, may upon the perjury of a
single witness, be thus sent to prison for the
rest of their days ? and where are the benefits
of the acts of William and Anne, if they are
to be evaded, under a precedent established
before those acts were passed, in the most in-
famous times, and by tne most iniquitous of
judges ? Orig, Edit,
* It seems not a little extraordinary that
the attorney-general for the county palatine of
Lancaster should pray to let the fact be found
upon a special veruict — that is, in other words,
to let Dunn's evidence be admitted as true,
though even in this stage of the trial, it had
been positively disproved by so many respect-
able witnesses, and Dunn was (while in court)
committed by tlie judge for perjury. The
defendants would by this means, have sub-
jected thebaselves to be punished, as if they
had been actually guilty of the crime they
were accused of, although they were peifectly
innocent of every part of the charge, and were
in consequence honourably acquitted.— Orig.
1 151] S4 G£ORGE tIL Proceedings again^ Thss. Welfter and olhers, {I tdi
people of England whelher aye or no my
ctieBls ougtit to be convicted, ai^r the testi-
mony I am in the course of giving.
Mr. Xmv. — ^I an equally l^ore those gen-
tkineB and the people of GiigkHid. ibr the
protection of the people of England ; if vou
fiee jn this tone, 1 can speak as loudly and as
eni^tically— I will prosecute these men
mm all the liberality of a gentleman, there is
notbhig has betrayed improper pas^on on my
party hSt no tone or Huanner ehall put me
down.
Mr. frsJbine.— I am not accusing Mr. Law
cf any impropriety or illiberality of conduct
at iJl; I hare said nothinz to that effect ; for
tiie only time in which I have named his
samCi or hinted at it, I have spoken of hkn
with respect*; nothing can be mterpreted to
the contrary : Imt a man, if he is not made of
vtone, must have some feelings in a case cff
this sort In whatever wav your lordship
may rule this point, I shall be satisfied ^ i
might have asked your lordship's opinion
early, but the same reason d>at induced your
lordship so liberally and graciously not to
communicate your own opinion, governed
me.
Mr. Justice Heath, — ^You wish it to go to
the jury.
Mr. JSrfftme.^Yes, I most certainly do.
Mr. Walker 4 — ^I am before my country, and
I wiU «> to the jury. In our situation, even
the de&y of justice would be ^e height of in*
Justice.
Mr. Law.^l cannot find it standing ttpon
any authority but a case in Dyer.
Mr. Justice Heath. — ^It has been always
held that the misdemeanor is merged in the
felony.
Mr. £rt)kt7t«.— When Mr. Law has heard
the evidence out, for we have by no means
done, if he should then think it becomes the
crown to go on, he will do so, and then let the
point of Taw be reserved in any way roost
agreeable to your lordship ; but I will have the
fact before the jury.
Mr. Law, — If it ends in your clients' excul-
pation, I shall be as happy as you ; but I shall
see that it does so.
Mr. WiUiam Seddon swora.--£xaauDed 1)^ Mr.
Have you ever seen this man, Dunn, who
has been examined to-day ? — I hAve.
How did it happen that you saw hinv^ —
Mr. Walker, Mr. Richard Walker, Mr. Duck-
worth, Mr. Jackson, and myself, were upon
business at my house, on Tuesday the 18tn of
December last; I was particularly busy in my
office preparing for the assizes, but I was de-
sired to come out upon a matter of moment.
When I came into the house, I was told by
Mr. Walker ■
Did Thofnas Dunn come ?— No, not to my
houtie ; I went down to Mr. Richard Walker's
with Mr. Duckworth ; I stayed there some
time : when I came there^ I understood Duon
was in the parlour with Itr. Wislkcr, iff.
Richard Walker, Mr. Joiiea^ and Mr. Rjd^
wayjuB.
Mr. 1^^— What is the paper yov «je re-
ferring to } — ^Ndtes I took down at the ime
Mr. Duckworth, Mr. Jones the attorney, and
Mr. Ridgway the attorney, wera* with me at
Mr. Richard Walker's ; but Mr, Ridgway aad
Mr. Jones were not present at any part «f ihe
conversation I am speaking to.
Mr. Erskine. — Suose^fuent to tlHS tkne, 4iA
Thomas Dunn, the man who has been en-
mined to-day, come into the house ?^ — He
came the second time about eleveo oVJock,
Mr. Walker, Mr. Duckworth, Mr. Rkkard
Walker, and myself werepresent — he knocked
at the door, and came into the K»om ; he fet
wanted to speak to Mr. Walker alone, or to
Mr. Richara WaHcer; on being desired to
speak, he repeatedly objected, knA dedared
he would say notitung befove so mai^ wit-
nesses ; Mr. Walker told him he must speak
before tiiem, or not at all — hedien desirea Mr.
Walker to sit along side of him, and tie would
esteem it an honour, and tdl him everv tiling.
Mr. Walker refiised. Dunn then stood up and
desired Mr. Walker to give him his -haiid — I
amjust now informed that I ssud this faap>
pened on the 18th of December ; if I dSd, I
made a mistake, it was on the t6th of last
month.
Did you take these notes at the time?—
I took down the latter part of the eon^ersa-
tioD, which I have not yet come te, froiD
Dunn's own lips, I made a minute of tbis imr
mediatelv after be was gone.
Mr. Erskine, — Then I conceive I am al-
lowed to desire the witness to look at that
paper to refresh his memory.
Mr. Xa«7. — How soon afterwards did joo
put it down ?-— This part [the witness hoMBng
a paper in one hand] the moment he wa:>
gone ; the other | showing another paper] 1
took from his own lips. Dunn stoon up and
desired Mr. Walker to give him his liendp
and he should esteem it a greater honour
than ifGcoree the third did. This Mr. Wrf-
ker again remsed, and told him he had sworn
falsely against him ; Dunn acknowledged he
had, anathat he had not had a quiet nsht
for thirteen weeks. He then rose fromnb
chair, and threw himself upon his knees, aad
seized both Mr. Walker's hands, and , ex-
claimed with a great deal of emotion, ** I fas^
done you injustice, and I beg your pardon f^
he then cried excessively, and audressii^
himself to the defendant Mr. Walker, sai{
* My heart is almost broken, I am unhappy;
I have certainly done vou wrong ;" he then
went down upon his knees to Mr. Walker
again. Mr. Richard Walker then put tlm
question to him, Who instigated you? Bumi
replied, '* I am afraid to teU that, I have not
slept a contented night these thirteen vreeks
together, on your brother's account. Do not
you know I wished him well ? I have lodged
an indictment against him^ bat it is a daimM
j|^ 4«ws^ up<i» 9k tsiblci, «^d was in aa 4pp%-
ilft^v^ed b^ 9«fmd very conoposed i^nd see
^l(W in^^ is^vc w tbsn be URAS bef<^Q. As
ri 99 be lifted his bead tsova the table (after
had done ^rying)^ Mr. Tb^tmas W^ker
Sliced bin) if be did OQt feel easier ? Xx> whicb
}m> ii%de n9 particidv answer^ but said) ^ Tbe
fibMfO V94 t^kei) down wrong at M^nche^-
^.^ Mr. Ricbvd Walker thea But tbis
^m^tifm t0 U^Sf ^' How eould you, wbeii yo«
ji^ you wished wj brother so well, be fure-
wM upoa t» ncf use him so wrongfully ?'' to
^vbvb Puop fMi)8wered» '* that is a ^ry cress
^|U6s^ii/' The same question was put again
l^y Mr. Richard Walker, to wbicb Dunn said,
^* I want Mr. Walker to forgive om, and I
^Ul do biia justiee. hereafter. I Vi'isk you
would gut a eonstable to take xne up» and let
1119 be tfied/* Mr. Walker tben said, *" ^ou
admit you have done me an injury V* tQ wbicb
Punn replied, '^yes, I have, every person
iimws it, expept Xorke. Wbat I swore in
my first examination, and at Lancaster, were
ym different, w»t nt all alike. I was called
berore tbc grand jury three times ; I will
9fiW! 90 to' l^nfsaster ^t tbe assizes, and let
Griffith and tbe rest of them do as tbev pleasf
find be daodQed." Mr. Richard Wdtker re^
fieftted this question to him, ^' Wbo instigated
ye^l to dn wrong V* Dunn said, ^ I won't
answer sucb questions." I then asked him
.Vtoti day be had eharged tbe offence es com-
mitted i . His answer to me was, ^^ between
^ 99tb •Pd tbe 80tb of January, 1793/'
Dunn then, of bis own accord, speaking to
Mr. Walker, «^, ^ What shall I say to you,
I bave done you an iq}ury, and I am
sorry^ ^bat can I say more?'* I then
said to him, ^ who set ' vou on f" Dunn
answered, ^* I know I behaved ill, I was
bribed to il, that is plunp ; but I will oet tell
who did it, that shall for ever rest in my own
bneMrt.'^ AfU9 tbe above conversation was
en'd^^ vhidb I took down verbatim, in quesi
twn and answer, Dunn lefl the room.
. . Thomat Dunn called up agun.
Mr. Justice Heath. —Well Dunn, you bave
bcerd this evidence; did th«t pass^or any
part of it }
Dimii.^Ko, nei&ing at ^t^yesi some-
thing of it passed.
. Mr. Justiee Eeatk — How much of it
passed ? — I went there when I was intoxicated,
tbe same as I an now.
Mr. La».^Have you been out of tbe oeuvt f
—Yes, I have.
Mr. Justief irea^A.*-How kmg have you
btfn iutoxicaled )^Kot veiy lone ; I have my
ftooUestsNi about msi ^oueb it may seem
^ the C3ouit ^t i mi^ be ill, or may ntai.
Mm. Jnaliee JHeo^-s-Were you intoxicnted
when yoH gave your evidence just now^— I
wasnot.
VOL. xxni.
3lt Oa I79€*
cn»
Mr. Justice Ad^V^Yoi^ tete been in
toxicated since tben ? — ^Yes.
Mr. Law, — ^How much of tbs^t conversation
is tiu9? there is spme wrt you say 19 true. —
I was at Mr. Wsdker's house abjC^t a fortnighlt
hence; I went in to Mr. Walker; I was
brought ij^ bj^ ^ eonstable i^f Manchester, 4nd
upon that I n^et Mr. ]^cbard Walker> brother
to Mr. Thomas Walker.
Wiwtt is the constable's name ? — One Xwiss.
Mr. ^<^ajed Walker as]i;e4 me, Dunn, do not
you recollect that you have done an injury le
m]f brother ? or to that pumose ; welL says I,
upon the first examination I lodged the first
indiptmeiM; against hiqi.
Mr. Ji|stiee Heo^A.— Has t^ body been
with yoii while you were out ? — ^No. /
Mr. irtkins. — I should be glad to. tmce
where he has been^I do not believe be bsis
been out of court
Mr. Justice Hco^A.— Where have you been ?
.r^I have been dowi?^ thd town. .
Mr. Serjeant CM^l-^l^Q we3 told to stay
in court
Mr. Justice Heo^^— Where did you dine }^
Below the change; I do not know the bouse*
Mr. Justice HeatL^U it a bou^ you frer
quented before ? — ^Yes.
Mr. JErs/ctne.— Who dined with you ?— Tbe
man's name is Foster.
Any body ^Ise ?->Yes, Mr» Spdebotknn.
Who else ? — Nobody.
Who are Sidebottom and Foster ?•
Mr. Za».— You say Mr. Seddon and Mr.
Duckworth were by at Seddon*8 house ? — ^No,
he was at Mr. WaUcer's ; all that passed Was
this ; he brought me, this Twbs, he intended
to take me in, and to bribe nie over; he
fave me some money upon il, on Mr. WaU
er's aceount, drunk cir sober I will speak the
truth. '
Mr. Justice Heath,-^! do not kOow bow
we can examine a man th^t is drunk.
Mr. Xa».— What w^ you to da for that
money ?— To go out of the way, and not sqp*
pear here at these assizes.
Did you beg Mr. Walker to sit along side
of you, and say you would esteem it as greet
an honour as if George .the third did l^l
never said that upon my oath.
Mr. Justice H^^A.-^Hbw can you Mr. Law
examine him, after he has told you he is in-
toxicated; he has made bianself so exceed-
ingly drunk, it is impassible to examine him;
Mr. JSrs^ne.-r-He deued positively he had
ever been at Mr. Walker's^ or was ever lured
by any body to make a confession.
Mr. Lew* — ^Did you ever confess that the
charge you made against Mr. Walker, was
unfounoed and &]ser— Never.
Mr. £rriki'iie.— Then what this genlieman
* Foster and Sklebottoro were in tbe tistof
iritnesses for the coown, delivered in court at
the commencemeDt of the trial, by the attar-
niei iqt the f roaecutiotk.rrr^ij^. JErd.
4 £
115S] S^GKORGSm. Proeeedbigt agrimsi TSct. WaOer awd aikin, pUfi
faasMudisfiilseyisit?—- Idonotkoow; when
when was that ?
Mr. SeddoH,-4)n the 18th of Mafch.
Mr. Law, — Did Twiss bring you thereupon
that occasion ?
J>»iin. — ^Yes.
Is he in any employ for Mr. Walker f
Dunn, — ^He was employed five naonths upon
this business.
Mr. JBnAnne.— Hear this read over, and
stand up, and remember you are in the pre-
aence of God.
[Mr. William Seddon read his notes agun.]
Mr. Enkine. — ^Is that true ? — ^Ko, I never
entered into any part of the hotise, onTy the
dooi\ and which was just opened for me.
Mr. Ertkine. — ^Mr. Seddon is swearing
falsely, is he ? — ^I cannot tell what he may
do ; he is swearinefalse if he swears that.
Mr. JErfJbne.— %id you go down on your
knees, and cryibr ten minutes?— You may
«8 well tell me tiiat I am a woman.
Did you do that ?-^ No, all he asked me, all
I told him was this—Did not you lodge an
information, so and so, and some particular
wo,rd8; you were drunk: I said, I will cor-
rect it next morning, that is all that ever
happened.
You never said you had wronged Mr. Wal-
ker, and went down upon your knees T— I
never did.
Mr. Duckwof^h called again. — Cross-exa-
mined by Mr. Law,
Were vou present when this man, Doim,
answered the questions put to him, in the
manner Mr. Seddon has sworn just now ?-^
I was.
To the best of your memory and recollec-
tion, is the account that Mr. Seddon has
{liven of it, the truth?— I looked it over, and
It agreed with Mr. Walker's, Mr. Ricluird
Walker's, and my recollection.
Mr. Duckworth re-examined by Mr. Enkine,
I ask you-^(though the attorney for Mr.
Walker, you are a Christian, I trust)— I ask
you, in the presence of God Almighty, is it
true or false r^It is true.
Mr. Duckworth cross-examined by Mr. Law.
How came you all there, and how came
Twiss to bring this man ?— Mr. Thomas Wal-
ker and I had gone up to Mr. Seddon's. Mr.
Jackson, I think, was there when I went in.
Mr. Seddon was in his office. When we had
been there a few minutes, Mr. Richard Wal-
ker came in, and said a message had been
sent to his house, that Dunn wanted to go to
Batlow, to see his brother, Mr. Walker : we
agreed that Mr. Jones and Mr. Ridgway, ju-
nior, who had nothing to do with the prose-
cution, should be requested to be present, to
hear Mat passed. Mr. Seddon and I foir
lowed after.
Do you think it profestionally proper, when
you knew that an indictment was feund dpofe
the testimony of this witness, and that he warn
to be the witness to sustain it at the next as-
sizes, for yon two, the attorneys for the'd^
fendant, to have him alone witkyou, witfaem
any person on his behalf, and to •^flwiinr
him m this manner ?-*We thought it fitter
that he should say what he ehose to say, im
the presence of some other person, than Mr.
Sedaon and mvself ; and therefore we desired
Mr. Jones and Mr. Ridgway, twcr gentleoiea
of unimpeachable character, to be present
I did believe Dunn had perjured HiirnHI^
from the knowled^ I had of the cause; tfacvfr-
fere, I thought it nght, that what he dbc9t to
say, as a confession of his guilt, should be
heard. When Mr. Jones ami Mr. Ridcwsy
had heard what he had to sav, and hadDeeo
gone from Mr. Richard Wadker's about half
an hour, there was a knock at the door;
Dunn .came in again alone; then Mr. Seddon
and I, from necessity, and not from choice,
went into the room.
Had Mr. Jones and Mr. Ridgway taken his
examination? — ^Theyhad, about ludf an hour
before this time.
Mr. Enkine, — ^Did yon send for this man?
—No.
Did yon empby any body to bring liim td
you ? — No.
But when a man had sworn fidsely agunst
Mr. Walker, you thoueht it raht to hear Us
confession of his guilt r — ^I did; I thought he
had peijured himself.
Dunn says, that Twiss does work for Mr.
Walker?— I never heard that he did.
Mr. Walker. — Dunn said, Twiss was cfl>»
ployed by me in this business.
Mn JLiiv. — A man, who is your fustian-
cutter, is employed by yo«.
John Spink sworn. Examined by Mr. Ser-
jeant Cockeli.
Have you any acquaintance with Mr. Tlko*
mas Walker? — I have none at idl.
He is a gentieman who is a perfect stranger
to VQU ?— Yes; I only know htm by sight.
Have you any acquaintance or coDnezion
with him ? — ^None at all.
Do you know a man of the name of John
Twiss.'— Yes.
I understand he and you are neighbours?—
We are.
Did yotf happen, on the tsth of Mareh,
1794, to go toTwiss*s?— I dkl.
Was t&t matter of accident ?-^It was-an
accident.
Who did you find at tiie hoose of Twiss ?—
I found Thomas Dunn.
That man behhid you ? — ^Yes«
' Be so good as to relate what passed at that
time. — Dunn said, he was sonqr that he had
iigused Mr. Walker's character in the manaar
he had done; that he had never seen aagf
thing that was bad by him. He asked me to
CO to Barlow-hali with him that night, to se
Mr. Walker.
iisn
JUra Cotupiraeift
A. O. 1794.
[1158
Did that request come from him to you ? —
It did ; I told mm I would not go with him
at tha^ time of night, but if he chose, I would
go with him the neat day; he said, no, he
wouU see Mr. Walker before he slept; I said,
be had better send to see whether Mr. Wal-
ker was in town or not, to save him the la*
bour of going. Esther Ottey went to see
whether Mr. Walker was at home ; she went
to Mr. Thomas Walker's house in town; the
servant told her he was in town, but he was
gone out to tea and supper; when she came
ack, Dunn desired !^ther Ottey and me to
go to Mr. Richard Walker's, and see if he
was at home.
Did you, ordidTwiss, at this time, force
the conversation, or was iJt entirely from him-
self.^— ^He said it voluntarily of himself.
Did you draw him ou by any thing ? — ^Not
i^t all— -
Mr. Enkine, — Speak up.
One €f the Jury. — It aoes not signify, we
&ave been satisfied a lone while.
— ^I went out with Esther Ottey to Mr. Ei*
4;hanl Walker's; he said, if Thomas Dunn
wanted to see him. he might come up in the
course of half an hour, and he would let his
brother know. I suppose he did let him
know. Esther Ottey went up to see if he
was come in half an hour. He was not at
home; she waited a little time; then we took
Dunn there, John Twiss and me, and hd
him at Mr. Richard Walker's door.
Was he carried in custody at aUP—No,
he desired us to go with him.
And you went and left him at Mr. Richard
Walker's?— Yes.
WhatXime in the evening was this?—
About- nine o'clock, as near as I can guess ;
U might be half an hour before, or Imlf an
hour afler.
Did you observe, during the conversation
you have been relating, whether Dunn ap-
peared to be cool or was sigitated ? — ^He seemed
vjery much to want to go.
Did he appear to be much moved? — He
seemed to be very much affected for doing
what he had done; he seemed to relent
Were you in cottmanv, or did you see Dunn
upon the 28th of March?— No, I saw him on
the 20th.
At what time of day ?*-About five o'clock.
What passed then? — He was in at John
Twiss's again ; Twiss sent for me in ; Dunn
said he hsul seen Mr. Kinnaston, and he had
challenged him with beine acquainted with
John Twiss, which he said ne denied.
Did you see whether he had cried, or ob-
serve an^r thing of that sort?— Yes, I saw
tears in his eyes several times.
John Spink cross-examined by Mr. Wood.
You do not know how long he had been at
Twiss's, when you found him there on the
18th of March?— No.
Nor how much liquor he had dnuik?«-No,
Idoi^U
Do you know whether be had drank any ?
— He had had a little, but he was quite sen-
sible ; he knew what he was saying and doing.
Just as much as he knows now ? — He was
not hajf so much in liquor then as he is
DOW.
How came Twiss to have him in his ca^ ?
— I suppose Dunn came to seek Twiss.
What connexion has Twiss with Mr. WaU
ker ?— I do not know that he has any.
Is not he a workman of Mr. Walker's? —
I dare say he is.
How long had he been after this man to
get hold oi him?— I cannot tell any thing
about it.
When you saw him aeaiu, he was with Mr.
Walker's clerk?— On tne 19th, Dunn said
Kinnaston had challenged him with being
with Mr. Walker's clerk.
Was he with Mr. Walker's clerk then ?—
He was; but I was not there till late in the
evening.
Was he drunk then ? — ^No, a& sober as I
am now.
Was it late? — It was about nine o'clock.
He did not appear to have drank any thing ^
—He might have had some drink, but he was
perfectly sober.
John I\a?is9 sworn.— .Examined by Mr. Cham*
bre.
You live at Manchester, do not you ? — Yes
Are you one of the special constables of
Manchester } — Yes.
There have been several appointed within
the town, two hundred or thereabouts, I be-
lieve ? — I do not know just the number.
Do you know Dunn the witness, who has
been examined ?— I know tliis man Thomas
Dunn.
Were you with him on the 18th to March ?
— ^I was.
How happened you to come together on
that day ? — ^Thomas Dunn called at my house ;
I was lying on the bed ; I was sick ; he came,
and said he had a shilling to spend.
You did not take him mto custody?— No.
It is not usual, is it,.for people to come to a
special constable for the purpose of being
taken into custody ? — I went along with him
to Welch's; he began reiiecting upon his
bad conduct — that h^ had used Mr. Walker
very ill.
Did he begin of bis own accord ?— Yes, he
did; he repeatedly said, he had used Mr. Wal-
ker very ill, that he was sorry for it, and
would ask Mr. Walker pardon. I said, if
thou hast used him ill, thou had better ask
his pardoti in the public newspaper.
Did he express any desire to see Mr. Wal-
ker ? — ^Yes he did, and he would see him, and
he wanted me to go to Barlow-Hall with him,
and he would pay my expenses.
How far is Barlow-Hall from Manchester ?
I do not know— I was never there. — I said it
was lather too late; if he would content Jhim**
6df| I would go with him in the morning*
1156] S^ GBORGB III. Proceedings agimi n<m.W9Uir and aihers, [T10D
Was "Spink witti you at that ^e?— Sfwhlc
was in my ho»*5c, we -came from Welch's;
8ptnk came intx> my house, he desired Spink
lilcewise to go along with him.
Did you ever give him anytnoncy, «r madce
Sm any promises, to induce him to say any
ing upon the subject ?— "Never a farthmg in
my Q&ySf but otherwise — ^I told him I would
not, I never gave him a halfpenny in my life ;
I lent him thirteen shillings at different times
-^part of the money before I knew any thine
about Mr. Walker's affair, that was on tne dOth
6f October last, on a Sunday ni^bt ; I lent it
to him and Sidebottcmi, and Uiey went and
spent it ; it was on a Sunday night.
After tliat time^ did you ever l«id bite any
Aiing ?—! lent him nine shillings sh)ce.
John Twin cross-enrnine^ by Mr. To^^mg^
Yoa are I belteve a fustian^ctftte^ oT Itr.
Waik!er*s?^By buinnessf am. '
How long have yoQ worked for Mr. Waf^
ker?~-I worked fbr Mt Walket^— that is I
work for Esther Otley, abd %ht has bad wdlAc
from that house for about six years.
You was saying SN^mdhiAg about the maHi
of Jaauary ? — I have not told you aught atout
it yet
Were yoo W9th DnCm u^foa the nhMlitif
January? — I was.
Where f— At IJhe White Bear opposite th^
Infirmary ; frem thence we took a *<MBc 16
Fimdleton Pole.
You were with him *up0nlhenih\lk«)f J^
Wieh was the last time you lent him =«ny Quary ? — ^Yes, atid the leighth likewise.
monev? — The last time was the S 1st ofi Htra you been drinking with- htm at both
March. | these public-houses? — On the eighth I dranlr
How lon^ before the 18th of March, had share of a pint of porter, and left him.
you lent him money ? — I had never lent , How came you to be seeking his cotnpany^
Aim u halfpenny, but four shillinss. upon the eighth and ninth ? — He fell into tty
Had you lent him any thine between the ; company on the eighth^ I had been at livcr-
SOth of October, and the 18th of March ? — pool, and delhrered a message from Ldke
Not a halfpenny, nor never promised him aiiy Foster, and that was the reason 1 saw him,
thing. I Udou the 40th of October, or tfaereabM^
You did not go with him to Barlow that you had lent this man some money ?'«-^M]r
night ? — ^No—Dunn proposed to Esther Ottey, shillings.
to go and see if Mr. Wa[lker was at home — Had you any manner of knowte(%e ti
I was not taking every notice in the world. Dunn ? — Seeing him last assizes.
I think she said, I saw Mr. Walker in the ' And yet, upon the 20th of October, yon
town to-day, had not somebody better go and lent him moncff ? — ^Yes, I did ; I have Mt
see if he is in Manchester; he desired her to many a four shilling to different people.
|o, she went, when she came back the in- Having no kuowledg^ of him, but what tun
formation, to the bes\ of my knowledge was, had at tl^ last assizes nere, you lent him four
she said Mr. Walker is gone out to supper, shillings upon the 20th of October? — ^Peier
*ind it will be late before ne returns. Upon Sidebottom was in company with me.
this ihmn was determined h^ wotrM see him ' You say you were 'at Liverpool ; did not
he said before he slept ; he sent her a second Dunn go from Mandiester to Liverpool with
time to go to Mr. Richard Walker, and John you ?— -Not with me.
Spink and she went to the best of ray know- You went after him ? — ^Xo.
ledee; they returned back, and told him Mr. ' Will you swear, you never went to Liver*
Ridiard Walker was at home, and Spink and pool after Dunn ? — At what time ?
me might brine him up; we went ana brought Will you swear you never went to Liver-
him up, and left him at the door. pool after Dunn ?-^I have been there aAer
Was' all this done entirely upon his own him, within these eight days — with a subpccna
Bolrcitation, and at his own request ? — ^Upon in my pocket to subpoena him.
JQ[iy oath it was at his own request, not one | You were with him drinking upon the 8th
word of interrogation. I and 9th of January ?-^Yes.
Had you ever any sort of conversation with I Upon the 18th of March you were ag^
Mr, TTiomas Walker I— I never spoke to Mr. '; with him at Welch'*? — ^Yes, I told yoa be
Thomas Walker since he was born, but at one | called upon me and, I went off the bed With
titae ; there was a fire at a new building at i him.
the bottom of Bridge-street I did not see a
constable, or any one assisting but myself.
♦he genticraen were beating up for the ma-
rine corps. Mr. Thomas Walker arid Mr. Ri-
chard Walker came up, and a brutish kind of
^ man knocked another man down in
Mddge. Mr. Thomas Walker said to me,
« do you know that man?" ** I do not, sir."
That b every word I ever changed Wi^ Mr,
Thomas Walker in my life.
Mr^ Erskiue to Pttn».— Wlfet tfbyou say
lb this now ?
tlhtMu Dunni-^jl-sv^r fti8'faw,f?V«y titord
fit it.
Who was in company with you at WeleliM
John Spink, and me, and one James Soott.
When you were with Dunn at this piflylio*
house, do vou remember Mr. Walkers ^erk,
Moses Eadon, eomix^ ?-^I do, but nottiptm
the the I8th.
Was that upon the lOthr^Yes.
And the 20th too, I believe, you wrera
drinktngtogether?— Inever saw Rim liefbce
the dose'ofthe evehing of the ^Oth, ^Ansii^e
came to our house.
Was Bifoses ixt^dh, IfMr. VtAwHs^lerk, -vHih
you upon the 18th, or not till the tMi^Wi.
Upon the 19th.
J1611
fir ft CofMflN^^
A. D. IfM*
Cll ^
Upon findoa^s tsortAtMg In, did ll«t Eaddn go
into tnolhvi* room, Md idid n^y^u tip Blum
upon tht sh(Ailder, und dertt«he ^nnild go
with you into another room ? — I did.
ti«# much liquor h«dy<Mi1)6gMlyertttMft
publl^house upon the 19ih ?-^At this tiine
we hftd had i«iVhtt]e.
How liiueh money was Bpetit> before you
parted ^r^I eanaot possibly tell.
Do Bot you know, that kf&t^st^ or fifteen
chlHtegs wete spent by Mr. Walker's clerk
^t this meetiB)^ upon tie 19th ?— ^Mr. Walker's
^lefk n^^ver paid a penny to xtiy knowledge^—
I pcHd mo^ of it.
YoQ treated Duun, did you ?-^I paid tire
«hot, anKl treated him.
How much did you pay ?— leaimot ¥Xi to
^shHlingorWp.
* Was it twenty shillings?— No.
Was it fifteen shillings ? — ^1 cannot say.
'■' Was it above half a euinea f— It was.
Was it not fifteen shillings \ — It might be
4oic what I know, I cannot tell.
Did not you tell Dunn, you- wished he
Would get out of the way, till the assices
were over?— Never, no such matter.
You swear, that at no time you ever told
Dunn, you wished he would get out of the
way, till the assizes' were over ? — ^Never^ in
my days— I wished otherwise.
• Do you mean to swear upon ^rour oath, that
jou did not advise him to remain at Preston?
•— I did not ; he said he wouM go to Preston,
for he said, he would not be subpoina'd by
Imy party ; of all things, I said, you vrill stand
forth at the trial ; he sud, I will, bat I will
not be subpcMia'd by any partv.
Upon the 19th of March he toki you he
Would not ba subpcena'd by any body r— That
was on the SOlh, and he said the same on the.
ftlst in the* morning.
When did you lend him this other monev ?
£—1 lent him one part on Wednesday night,
somewhere about tne 19th, and he had the
remuning part some on Thursday, and the
remaining part on the Friday morning.
How much has he had in the whole from
ou ?— 'Thirteen shillings^ from the fitst to the
ast.
And all this, after this meeting at Welch's,
the Hare and Hounds?— No, he had only nine
shillings then.
Have you never received from any person
whatever, either the money that you spent at
the Hare and the Hounds, or the money you
lent Dunn ?-^I have not upon my eath«
Nor no promise ?— Nor no promise of any
thing. Dunn promised he would pay me my
inoney1:>ack agam.
You never had, from any cither person
}ivine, a promise tifr^-payment of the money
ientf—No, never.
Have yon never reoeived any money 1)adc
ttnft you spent?— No, neYier, Aom man,
woman /tior child.
'^ ^t.SftkiM to ^Mr. btrdtoorlft. Wtoeti
you heard Itaat • it- ^«wrepo^«ed, thtft 4tt^
I
IhktiWhM nrti awiiy» ami wts ttot eomiiig to
tbe iMiias» did yaw aike bay atep in eoiiae-
ffuence?-^! had heard he was gone to Prasttm
and would stay there till the assiaes. W^
were muebafiaid he would nin off. I went to
Preston to desire Mr. Cross, the protbonotary,
woiiM de^dsa sbmejpiiaiiis of keeping hkn in hta
custody by a bailiff, or in some otMr manner^
Mr. Oros6 woold not do that, but advised tte
to subpona Dunn ; we sued out a subpama,
and endeavoured 40 serve him with it. Mr.
Twiss was sent to Liverpool, to endeavour to
subponabim there. lie covdd not be found.
It bad been repeited that we had bribed
Dunn 10 keep out of the way.
Mr. Justice MeatK 1 cannot tfaitfk there
iamuch in the thirteen shillings, for if Domi
was so cornipl that thirteen shillings weidd
infiuence his testimony, his ciedit is not w€fth
mach%
Mr. Tkomoi Jones sworn.— Examined by Mr.
lAcyd.
Were you at Mr. Walker^ on the imh of
March P — I was.
Was Dunn, the man who stands bebttMl
you, there ? — Yes, he was, he came aoon after
I eot there.
Did you hear him say, he had sworn true
or false, arainst Mr. Walker? wliat did ha
say about Mr. Walker f^When he first came
into the room, he seemed as if he was rather
intoaicaled . I thought he reeled across^ fVom
the door towards the window; he sat fannsdf
down, and in a little time a <|uestion was
proposed, I think by myself; Whether he had
not something to say to Mr. Walker ? hesaid,
he had wronged Mr. Walker. I asked him
in what manner he had wronged Mr. Walker f
he said, he had accused him fiilsely. Imme^
diately as be said tliat, he fell down upon his
knees, and begged his pardon. Mr. Walker
desired him to get up. Several other ques-
tions were put to him, in what manner he
had falsely sworn against Mr. Walker, he did
not cive any answer to them.
Was he broueht into the room by force, or
did he appear of his own free-wfll?-^ under-
stood he came of his own free-will ; he knocked
at the door, and was introduced into the
room; be said he had been bribed to do
what he done.
Dki he seem afieeted — ^was- be in tears f —
He seemed very much agitated when he
entered the room. I asked Dunn, vibo had
bribed him, he would not give me an answer
to that question.
Mr. Jonei cross-examined by ]\fr, Xaapi,
Was Mr. Twbs, the nonstable, there-?— ^He
was not there. The persons present In the
room, when I was there, were Mr. Waikef,
Mr. ftichard Walker, Mr. Ridgwoy the attor-
ticy, myself, and Dunn.
1 only wanfted to Icnow whtftfaer Twha ««$
^faere ; you need not mention who weivihere,
fortlie'puifMe^f eanfimnig what ^ou say.
1 I6SJ S4 GBORGE lU. Proeee£ng$ ogtAf^ TAof* Wdker and olhertf fllG^
Did be seem lo you, 90 hi leooUected "bX the
time be talked with you^ as to be aware of
the import of what he was saying? — Yes, I
thought he was, perfectly.
Did he specify any particulars, in which he
had accused Mr. Walker falsely? — He did
not; I asked him thatqi^tion: he did not
give an answer to it; he seemed very desi-
rous of rommunicating what be had to sav
to Mr. Walker alone; he seemed veiy loth
to say any Uiiog to any questions put to him,
while Mr. Kidgway ana I were there ; he
frequently desired that Mr. Walker and be
might confer together ; Mr. Walker did not
choose to trust himself with him alone.
You have no sort of doubt in tout recollec-
tion, that Dunn used those words that he had
accused Mr. Walker falsely ?^He did.
Was there any conversation, respecting the
indictment that was depending at Lancaster
at that time ? — ^I did not hear any thing said
about an indictment. There was a question
8ut to Dunn, either by Mr. Walker or Mr.
Lidcway, I believe, by Mr» Bidgway, whether
he had ever heard Mr. Walker damn the
king ? he said, he never had, he had heard
him speak disrespectfully of him. I asked
him in what manner he had spoken disres-
pectfully of him ; but to that question he
gave no answer.
Was there any mention made at that time
of any assemblies held at the house of Mr.
Walker, for the purpose of exercising with
arms f — Not a sy lutble.
Was any thing said of Mr. Yorke beinc at
Mr. Walker's ? be so good as tcU me all tnat
jwssed at that meetine. — ^There was a ques-
tion asked about Mr, Yorke ; it was asked by
Dunn himself— instead of directly answering
Mr. Walker's questions, he seemed to evade
them by putting the question whether Mr.
Yorke had been m town or no ? or whether be
had seen him within a few days ? Mr. Walker
did not give him any answer to that question.
Nothing was said then about Yorkers having
been at the meeting at Mr. Walker's house!
—No.
How long might Dunn be with you in the
whole? — ^I fancy he was about twenty minutes
or half an hour in the room ; the questions I
bave mentioned, were frequentl^r put to him.
.Did you take any thing down in writing of
what passed ?— I did that night when I got
home.
Have you a minute of it ? — I have*
Be so eood as to let me look at that minute ;
it is not From any doubt of your giving me
the best of your recollection, I wish to see
it for another purpose.
[Mr. Jones gave Mr. Law hb minutes.]
xou mention here, I see, that you went
with Mr. Richard Walker, Dunn was soon
introduced, by whom was he introduced ? — I
think Mr. Richard Walker showed him into
the room, if I recollect right; somebody
knocked at the door very soon, after we got
there; I understood it was Dunn; he came
immediately into the room.
Who introduced him? — i think Mr.
Richard Walker opened the door wbea
Dunn came into the loom. I was doubw
ful towards the end of the business, wb&.
ther he was drunk, or onlv feianed to be
so ; for towards the latter end of it ne appeared
more steady, and seemed perfectly collected
in every thing he said ; he was particulaiiy
urgent with Mr. Walker to beblone with hini«
Finding that could not be obtained, he wished
to be with the two Walkers; that was refused ;
then he desired he might be with Mr. Richard
Walker alone, which was also refused, and
Mr. Walker peremptorily told him he wo«dd
not sufEer himself to be in his company alone.
The man seemed very much vexed at it, and
he came out with a threat upon the occasion ;
be said Mr. Walker would repent of it, fcr it
would be a damned deal worse for hiin, let
him bring as many witnesses as he would.
Mr. £ri^t»«.'— Mr. Thomas Dunn, is this
true or false ?-«-False.
This gentleman is penured then— it is ail
false?— Yes.
Mr. Lam, — ^I know the character of several
of the eentlemen wlio have been ^-*arpT«v^,
partiqJarly Mr. Jones ; I cannot expect one
witness alone, unconfirmed, to stand against
the testimony, of these witnesses; I ought not
to expect it.
Mr. Justice Heath. — ^You act very properly,
Mr. Law.
The Jury inunediately gave their verdict
Not Guilty.
Mr. Vaughan.^1 pray that Dunn may be
committed.
Mr. JErtAtne.— We will undertake to prose-
cute him for perjurv.
Mr. Justice HtatL — Let him be committed ;
and 1 hope, Mr. Walker, that 'this will be an
admonition to you, to keep better companj
in future.
Mr. Walker. — I have been in no bad com^
pany, my lord, except in that of the wretch
who stands behind me ; nor is there a word
or an action of my life, in which the public are
at all interested, that I wish unsaid, or undone,
or that under similar circumstances I would,
not repeat.
Mr. Justice Heath, — You have been honour^
ably acquitted, sir. and the witness against
you is committed for perjury.*
Immediately after the above verdict was
given, the same jury was again impanelled,
* Mr. Walker was an eminent merchant at
Manchester, and a truly honest and respect-
able man ; and nothing can show the fever of
those times, more than Uie alarmins prosecu-
tion of such a person upon such evidence. It
is not to every attorney-general, that such a
case could have been Mkfelv trusted. — ^The
conduct of Mr. Law was highly to his honour,
and a prognostic of his future character as a
judge,— J&. <f^ Erskin^s Sp€eche$:\
1165]
^if n CoiHtpiifOCjf*
A. IX 11§t.
[1166
and 8wora to try Mr. Walker u|K>n the sepa-
rate indictmenty charging him with damning
the kinsi and saying, he would as soon take
his head off, as tear a bit of paper.*
Thomas Dunn, the only evidence for the
Crown on this indictment, having been com-
mitted for perjury, the jury instantly retoraed
their verdict, Not Guilty.
The Jury 'were again impanelled and
sworn to try James Cheetham, upon the sepa-
rate indictment agunst him, for damning the
king, and wishing he was suiUotined, but the
witness for the Crown, Mr. Dunn, haying
been committed for penury, the jury imme-
diately found the defendant Not Guihy.
Upon Saturday, the 5th of April 1794, a
bin of indictment was preferred against Tho.
mas Dunn, for perjury; and found by the
Grand Jury, of which the following is a list : —
Thomas Butterworth Bayley, esq. of Hope,
Foreman.
Nicholas Ashton, esq. of Woolton.
William Assheton, esq. of Cuerdale-lodge.
Edward Buckley, esq. of Lancaster.
Daniel Bayley, esq. of Hope.
Joseph Brookes, esq. of Everton.
Charles Gibson, esq. of Lancaster.
Geoffrey Hombjr, sen. esq. of Preston.
John Fowden Hindle, esq. of Blackburn.
Henry Hulton, esq. of Preston.
Bobert Hesketh, Esq. of Lancaster.
John Machell, ^. of Pennybvidge.
Thomas John Parke, esq. of Highfield.
Edmund Rigby, esq. of Grange.
Abraham Rawlinson, esq. of £llel-hall.
William Rawlinson, esq. of Ancoats.
Nicholas Starkie, esq. of Frenchwood.
Robinson Shuttleworth. esq. of Preston,
Henry Sudell, esq. of Blackburn.
John Walmesley, esq. of Preston.
James Whalley, esq. of Clark-hill.
Joseph James Vernon, ^sq. of Preston.
* Mr. Walker had the most incontro-
vertible evidence to prove, he was in London
at the time Dunn swore that the words laid
in this indictment, were spoken by Mr. Walker
in Manchester. — Ori^. Ed.
Shortly afVer the preceding trial, Mr.
Walker published a pamphlet intituled, " A
Review of some of the Political Events which
have occurred in Manchester during the last
five years; being a Sequel to the Trial of
Thomas Walker and others, for a Conspiracy
to overthrow Uie Constitution and Govern-
ment of this Country and to aid and assist
the French, beine the King's Enemies. By
Thomas Walker.^ I extract from this pub-
lication the following account of Dunn's
trial:!—
" Dunn was tried at the autumn assizes
1794, upon an indictment containing no less
than ten several perjuries, which he had
sworn, upon the trial against Mr. Walker and
others.
To prove the &lsdK)od of the facts sworn
to by Dunn, various witnesses were called;
and first, as to his reading^ and writing. The
rev. Mr. Griffith ^the magistrate before whom
Dunn's ii^cnmations were tdcen, and who
uDon them issued warrants against Mr.
Walker, Mr. Paul, Mr. Jackson, and several
others, for high treason) swore, that he had
attested informations siened by Dunn in his
presence, and that he haa no doubt of his beinff
able to read and write. This was confirmed
by Mr. Griffith's clerk, Mr. Paynte^ who had
seen Dunn write his name, and haa also seeil
letters which he believed to have been wriltea
by him. — ^Two other witnessed deposed to the
same effect.
Mr. Jones and Mr. Ridgeway, two gentle-
men of great worth and respectability, stated
that they saw Dunn at the house of Mr.
Walker's brother, on the 18th of March;
that Dunn fell upon his knees, and beeged
Mr. Walker's pardon; said that he haoin*
jured his character; that he had accused him
falsely, and that he had been bribed to do
what he had done: and that when Mr.
Walker refused to be alone with him, Dtmn
threatened Idr. Walker, and said, that it
should be worse forhim. Several other wit-
nesses were called, who proved the other fkcts
in the indictment.
The jury found Dunn guilty; and the sen-
tence of Mr. Justice Itooke was, that he
should stand ohce in the pillory, and be im-
prisoned for two years in Lancaster Castle,"-—
Jtemem, 4*c. p. 89, note.
11S7] 84 6S0&GRIH.
Proeeedk^ Wgfimi lUert Walt
Cil»
602. Trial of Rowrt Wati for Higt Treason. At a Special
Commission of Oyer and Tcrrainer^^ holden at Edinbursb^
August MXh^ 15lh, IKSnd, «7tb, and September 3jrd : S4
<Si»ioB HI. A. p. 1794.«
Proceedings at a special session of Ojrer 9x4
Tc#inh]er,'held at Mihbti^gh, en Thursday
the J4th of August, IT94, before III^
Camf beUa lord president of thi; college of
justice; Robert Macqueen, lord jgatice
clerk; Afeiander Murray, lord Hender-
land ; David Rac, lord Eskgrove j;8f\erwards
lord JHStiw clerkj j John Swinton, lord
awlotsn.i air William NatrOi loid Dvnaio*
iia*| Alexander Abererombiey levi Aber-
croipbie; James Mont^pmei^y lord chief
b^uro^i aiul boo. Fletclw Norton, senior
*baron.
PbDCLAMATION being msde» tbe com-
miisiMi was opened by Mr. Knapp» tbe derk
•ftkeconMnietiMi. Itwataanlkwa:
COMVItSlOK OF OtSR AVnTBaMIVER.
George tbe third, by the erace of God. king
pf Greai Britain, France apa Iidsnd, defender
of the faith. &c^ to our right trusty and right
well Moved ooi)sin and counsellor David, earl
pr Mafi^ld, our justiee general, of ti^at part
of our kmgdom of GreatBritain called Scot-
Mq4» or Pivjustic« general for the 4fqe bring ;
Jjay Cami^ll, e^. of Succoth, pr?si<leqt of
ovr cpUe^ yf ju^tM^r, or the president of our
goUege of jgatice for tbe time being; James
]|rskwc, «i9q. of Alv^ senior senator of our
vm wftegQ of juHice^ Vio^n M'Queeo, e3q.
pr Brafield, 9ur justics clerk, gr oiv justice
clerk for the time being ; AlexaiMlfr ftfurray,
9m\. of Penderlwd ; iMvid JUe, e#4|<, of Qsk-
f3Vf ; John Swinton, esq. of $wii^tpn; sir
illulpi Naifp, of DMn^ini^fW, bsTopet; and
Alexsiider Aborcrombic^ esq.of Aber^iYHnbie,
commissioners of justic^ry ; J^mes Montgo-
mery, esq. of. Stanhope, chief baron of our
court of exchequer, in the aforesaid part of
our kingdom aforesaid, or our chief baron of
our court of exchequer aforesaid, for the time
being; and Fletcher Norton, esq. senior baron
of our said court of exchequer, greeting : —
* Taken in short-hand by Blanchard. For
corrections of some errors in the original edi-
tion of tins trial, I am indebted to Mr. Robert
Hamilton, who was one of the counsel for the
prisoner. Another but very imperfect ac-
count of this trial, was published, purporting
to have been ^ taken m short-band by an
English barrister."
KoQW ye, that we^ !» virtue, spd %Qoori'
ing to the form of tbe statute, made in
the seventh year of the reign of our nyv4l
predecessor, Anne, late queen of Great &>•
tain, &0. intituled " an Act for iioptovii^ the
union of the two kingdoqis,'' have assigned
you, m^ any three or ipore of yoiL(of wMn
we will that ^ny of you the saiq I>avid earl
of Mansfield, or our justice general for tibe
time beins ; Ilav Campbell, or our presideot
ofoureol!^n of justice for the tii«ic
Robert McQueen, or our justice clerk for
time being; Alexander Murray and Unvii
Rae shall be one) our justices, to m^nve by
the oath of good and lawftd men of our shoe
or foiinty orEdinbuigh, in that part of Greet
Britain called Seotland ; and by other wmy%
means, and methods by which you sliali or
may better know (as well within liberty as
without), by whom the trutii of the matter
may be better known and inquired iiMd of al
high treasons and mispriuons of higk treasons
within the shire or county aforesmd, as vdi
within liberties as without, by whomsoeei^
and in what manner soever, and by wikoa^
when, bow, and afler what manner dom^
committed or ]>erpetrated; and of all other
articles and circumstances concenung tbe
premises, and everv of them or any of them
m any manner whatsoever; and the same
high treasons and misprisions of high trea-
sons, according to the form of tbe aforesaid
statute, to hear and determine. And Uier»-
fore we command you, that ^t a certain dsy
and place within the sud shire or county
which you, or any three or more of yon (of
whpn» we will, th|t anv of ypii the atoretaid
P^vid e^ of Man&fiela, or our justice gemv
ral for the lime being; Ilay Campbell, or oyr
presideni of our college of justice for the tiiae
oeine; Robert McQueen, or our justice ckik
for uie time beine ; Alexander Murray anii
David Rae shall be one), shall appoint ier
that purpose, you meet together, and dUi-
genUy make inquiries about the premises,
and hear and determine all and singular the
said premises, and do and fulfil them, doing
therem what to justice appertains, saving to us
the amerciaments ana other thines from
thence to us accruing ; for, we finniy com-
mand all and sinffulw, sheriffs officers, mi-
nisters, and our subjects, by virtue of these
presents, that they be attending, advising,
aiding, and assisting to vou in the execution
of the premises as it becomes them. We
command also by virtue of these presents^ the
1-160]
fit tiigjk treatoHi
A.X>. If 94.
[1170
sh^fTof our shire or ooanty afofdsaid, that at
a ceitata day and place which jou, or atiy
three or more of you (of whom any of you
the albresaid Datid earl of Mansfieldy or our
justice eetieral for the time being; Hay
Campbell^ or our president of our college
<A justice for the time being; Robert
M'Queen, or our justice cleric for the time^
being; Alexander Murray and David Rae^
shaUbe one) shall make known to him, he
cause to come before you, or any three or
hm^ of you (of whom we will that any of
jou, the aforesaid David earl of Mansfield, or
our justice general for the time being ; Hay
CampbeHy or our president of our college of
justice for the time being, Robert McQueen,
or our justice clerk for the time behie ; Alex-
ander Murray and David Rae shall be one),
so many and such good and lawful men of
our saia shire or county of Edinburgh (as well
within the liberties as without), by whom the
truth of the matter in the premises may be <
better known and inquired into. In witness
whereof, we have cansed these our letters to be
made patent Witness ourself, at Westmin-
ster, the twenty-fourth day of July, in the
thirty-fourth year of our reign. — By the king
himself^ * YoRKE.
The sheriff of Ihe county of Edinburgh then
returned the precept, which had issued to
him to summon the justices of the county,
the grand jury, and constables to attend.
The precept was as follows :
Precept for the Grand Jury.
£din^rgA,> Alexander Murray, esq. of
to wif. ( Henderland, David R^e, esq. of
Eskgrpve, John Swinton, esq. of Swinton, sir
William Naime, baronet, and Alexander Aber-
crombie, esa. of Abercrombie, commissioners
of our lord the king, of justiciary, in that part
o^the kingdom of Great Britain, called Scot-
land, justices of our said lord the king;, as-
sijgned by letters patent of our said lord the
kiD^, under the ^eat seal of Great Britain,
made by virtue of, and according to the form
of the statute, made in the seventh year of
the reign of the lady Anne, late queen of
Great Britain, &c. intituled, '< an Act for \m*
proving the union of the two kingdoms ;" to
us and others, in the same letters patent,
named, and to any three or more of us, and
them directed (of whom our said lord the
king willed that one of us, the said Alexander
Murray, and David Rae, should be one), to
inquire by the oath 6f good tod lawful men,
of the county of Edinburgh, in that part of
Great Britain called Scotland, and by other
ways, means, and methods, by which we and
others, our fellows justices aforesaid, shall, or
may better know, as well within liberties as
without, by whom the truth of the matter
may be t^e better known, and inquired into,
of all high treasons, *and misprisions of high
treasons, within the county aforesaid, as well
within liberties as without, by whomsoever,
VOL. XXIII.
and in what maimer soever, and by whom,
when, how, and after what manner done,
committed, or perpetrated, and of all other
articles and circumstances concerning the
premises, and every of them, or any of
them, ib any manner whatsoever; and
the same high treasons, and misprisions of
high treasons, accorditig to the form of the
afcn'esaid statute to hear and determine: to
the shenfF of Edinburgh, greeting : — We, on
the behalf of our said lord the king, do com-
mand you, firmly enjoining you, that you do
not omit,^ by reason of any liberty in your
bailiwick, tiitt, that you cause to come before
us, and others, our follows justices aforesaid,
in the Said letters patent named and assigned,
or before any three or more of us, and
thefn (of whom ouiP said lord the king
willed that one of \is the said Alexander
Murray, and David Rae, should be one),
at the town and city of Edinburgh, in your
said county, on Thursday, the fourteenth
day of August next, twenty-four good and
lafj^ men of your s^id bailiwick, to inquire,
pr^Rit, do, and execute, all and singular thoss
things with which they shall be then and
there charged and enjoined: and that you
give notice to all justices of the peace, and
chief constables m your said county, that
they be then and there, in their proper per-
sons, to do, whatsoever to their respective of-
fices, in this behalf appertain to be done :
and that you yourself, together with your mi-
nisters and officers be on the same day, at
the place aforesaid, in your proper persons,
to do and execute those things, which to your
office, in this behalf, appertain to be done (
and that you have, then there, the names
of the said jurors, justices, of the peace, and
chief constables ; and also this precept. Given
under our hands and seals, at Edinburgh, this
twenty-ninth day of July, in the thirty-fourth
year of the reign of our sovereign lord George
the third, now king of Great Britain France^
and Ireland^ defender of the faith, and so
forth.
(S. L.) Alex. Murrat,
(S. L.) Dav. Rae.
(S. L.) John Swintow.
(S. L.) Wm. Nairne.
(8. L.) Alex. Abercrombie.
The justices names were then called over.
Then those of the grand jury, and the fol-
lowing persons were sworn in : —
Sir John Inglis, bt. of Cramond, foreman.
Andrew Wauchope, of Niddery Marshal.
Charles Watson, of Saughton. '
George Ramsay, the younger, of Barnton.'
John Trotter, of Mortonhall.
Gilbert I nnes, of Stow.
Robert Trotter, of Castlelaw.
James, Walker, of Dairy.
William Simpson, Royal Bank.
Walter Brown, of Currie.
George Hiompsoni of Burnhouse,
4 F
1171] 84 GEORGE UL
William PresUm, of Gorton.
James Kerr, of Biackahiells.
John Davie, of GaTieside.
John Dayiflon, of Rayelrig.
- Charles Brown, of CoalstowDk
John Balfour, the younger of Pilrig.
John Newton, of Curriehill.
James Pitullo, of Hayfield.
Alexander Reid, of liatho.
Alexander Keith, of Kavelstom
Simon Fraser, of Ford.
Thomas M'Millaii, of Soonhope,-
ProeeM^ againsi Rohert WaH
[1178
The Lord President then addressed the
grand juty in the following words : —
Gentlemen of the grand jury ;«*The duty
which you are called upon at this time to dis-
charge* however important, must be in a
nreat measure new to you. It will not there-
-fore be improper, that I trouble vou with a
few words, in order to point out what I con-
ceive to be the leading principles and objects
of the commission under which you are to act.
At tlie same time you will not fail to keep
in view, that whatever suggestions may come
from me, in the way of general information,
chieflv upon matter of law and of lc»al form,
that the nature of the business may be under-
stood ; to you alone, gentlemen, belongs tiie
right of applvine these to the individiud
charges when laid before you, and to the evi-
dence adduced in support of Uiose charges, as
it will rest with you to determine by the
EQSwer which you are to make, agreeably to
the solemn oaths which you have taken, and
to the honourable dictates of your own minds,
whether there is, or b not, sufficient ground
for any farther proceedings against the par-
ties accused.
Hitherto, gentlemen, it has been our good
fortime to be little acquainted with high trea-
son, or the modes of mauirine into it ; in so
much, that our knowleage of that crime is
derived almost ooly from the Statute-book,
with the comments upon it by learned and
eminent writers on the law, and the history
of trials, mostly of an ancient (kte. The
reason is obvious, few attempts having been
made in our time to disturb the public tran-
quillity; the people of this country were
satisfied, and good cause they had to be so,
with the blessmgs which they enjoyed, under
a system of laws, and a form of p>vernment,
the essence of which is liberty. Every man's
right, — every man's franchise ; — the fruits of
his industry ;-r-the safety of his person ; — ^the
exercise of his religion ; — bis liberty ;- his
£BLme ; — all have been secured to the utmost
extent of his wish. — What fair pretence then
could any man have to seek for a change ?
During the same period, and as a necessary
consequence of these inestimable advantages,
the country has continued to prosper more
and more ; for notwithstandine the wars, in
which, from various causes, and chiefly from
the turbulence or ambition of our neighbours,
we have been too often engaged^ it is a fact
indisputable, that tiiis country has advflUBOBd
not Slowly, or in a sUght degree, but lapidlj
and conspioMiualy, in commerce, in aig;ricu*-
ture. in eveiyusenil art, in pojmlatioiiy and m
wealth, so thai the powing mcome, and m-
creaaed industry of the country, have not only
kept pace with, but fiv exceeded a^y addi-
tional burthen arising from the aecesaaxy ib-
crease of national expenditure.
Gentlemen, it is not my intention, nor d»
I think it in any degree necessary^ in addreaa-
ing myself to you, to enlarp upon tbttat
topics, or to consume your time, by going
into minute details concerning the Bxxtiab
constitution, and the admirable maaktubr, m
which the powers of the state, l^islative and
executive, are combined and balanced^ whar^
the liberty of every individual is complcteiy
secured ; I mean that liberty which akuie can
be enjoyed by men living In a state of society;
civil iibertv, whicn, as the celebraled Mon-
tesquieu oiKBerves, is founded in secuiitj,
which consists in every man's doinCy not wlal
he wills but what he ouebt to wil^ the i^^
of doin£ whitever the laws permit, and na
more; for if one could do what the Jaws
forbid, he would no longer be possessed of
liberty, because every other man would ha^
exactly the same powers
But, eentlemen, it will po-haps be said,
why do I make these observations ? Has any
sudden change of circumstances happened ?
Is there any imminent danger of our bemg
deprived ot those inestimable lights whicfa
have been described? I hope not; we ^
have the same laws, the same constitution,
the same gracious sovereign upon the thnxK
who has reicncd for years past. Recent
events too, nave shown that our sailors and
our soldiers, are not yet deficient in vakmr,
nor their officers in good conduct, and it b
not to be doubted, tluit the great tMody of the
people, have sufficient good sense azid spins,
to resist the madness of innovation, and effet-
tually to oppose the wicked atleropts of ene-
mies, without or within.
But, gentlemen, it is to be remeniberedi
that we are engaged in war, with an inveterate^
a cruel, and a vindictive enemy ; an enemy,
whose object seems to be, to spread dest^tiaa
far and wide; whose l^ers, if thej ever
were in quest of liberty, have been very ua-
successful in finding it ; who upon the ruins
of their ancient monarchy, and even of their
own improved constitution, have now raisc4
up something, which one is at a loss to naiM
or understand, unless it be either complete
anarchy, or the most ferodous tyranny.
It may be said, what is all tl^is to the state
of Great Britain ?— Perhaps nothing at all, if
we take care that the contagion does not
reach us. But if it be true, as hsis baen as-
serted, that they have, by a formal decie^
established their National Convention, as a
grand committee of general insurrection &r
the purpose of overthrowing every existinc
government in £urope; if it be true thatth^
1178]
fit High TreoMK.
A. O. 1794.
£1174
have abettors in this country, who either in
connexion with France, or from similar views
and imaginations, formed in their own minds,
are busy in promoting the same wild and
destructive projects here, is it not high time
that we should look with some degree of
anxiety to our own situation, and to our
safety?
It 16 difficult for us to conceive, ^lat British
subjects, who are not desperate or insane,
should foe so lost to all sense of duty; so
biind to every fair interest that men can
have; or so abandoned to wickedness, as to
enter deliberately and knowingly into the
horrid conspiracy of destroyinjg the constitu-
tion of their country, and rising in rebellion
agadnst their sovereign. Yet report says,
that such daring plans nave been formed, and
you, gentlemen, the grand jury of the county
of Edmburgh, are met this day for the purpose
of making a solemn, dispassionate, ana candid
inquiry, in the manner directed by law, whe-
tiier any such treason has been committed
within the district to which you belong, and
* whether the persons now meant to be charged
ought or ougnt not to be put upon trial for so
^ttrocious an offence.
If I have expressed myself strongly agsunst
^e crime which is undoubtedly the higMst of
* any, as it goes not merely to a partial breach
'of the law, or to ati injury against individuals,
but tends to the utter subversion of all law
and government, and the dissolution of the
bon£ of society, I hope it will not be under-
stood, that I mean m any deeree to excite
your passions against those who may have
the misfortune to be accused, so as to lead
you to a hasty or ill-founded opinion against
them : on the contrary, it is my dutj to ad-
•monish you against undue prepossession, and
'to request that you may keep in view, that
the presuroptiou of innocence is an essential
and avakiaole rule of criminal jurisprudence,
which rule is not in any degree weakened by
the atrocity of the crime.
* Gentlemen, as to all previous inquiries be-
fore the House of Commons or elsewhere,
^concerning this alleged treason, and all re-
ports made upon those inquiries, if any of you
iiave had occasion to read or to hear of them,
you are to lay them out of your minds, as you
cannot proceed upon any thing extra-judicial,
but can only take under your view, the proofs
•w^kh are actually brought before you in a
legal shape.
* At the same time it is necessary for you to
Jceep in view, that it is not your province to
try the parties accused, or any of them J You
are only to hear the evidence on the part of
the Crown, for the purpose of satisfying you,
whether such probable circumstances or guilt
-appear aeainst the prisoner, as to justify the
sending him to another jury, whe-ara ap-
tpointed hjT law to hear the evidence on both
sides, and to say whether the person charged
he guilty or not of the crime imputed to him
In the indictmant ; and, if upon such trial.
any advantage can be derived to the prisoner,
either from legal defences, or from favourable
circumstances in point of fact, it will be the
duty of the Court, as well as of those acting for
the parties, to take care that the same be
fully stated and understood. Your present-
ment, if you find a true bill, is not of the
nature of a conviction, but is an authority to
tlie accusation, merely to the effect of bnng-
ing the prisoner to a fair and full trial. On
the one hand, it is not your duty upon slight
Surmise, or mere suspicion, to bring any per-
son into the disagreeable predicament ot being
tried for his life upon a charge of high treason.
On the other band, you are not tied down
so strictly to all the niceties of evidence, as if
you were trying the whole issue, but may and
ou^ht to proceed upon what you think a pro-
bable and reasonaule cause for putting the
accused party on his trial. Such is the des«
cription of your duty, as given by every con-
stitutional writer on this important branch of
the law.
By an act of the 7th of king William, two
witnesses are required to make out a charge
of treason, but two witnesses are not neces-
sary to each act, for the statute expressly says,
that it is enough, if '* either both of them
swear to the same overt act, or one of them
to one, and the other to another overt act of
the same treason," so that one witness to
each of two different acts of the same treason
is sufficient.
- I presume, gentlemen, aH of you know, that
in consequence of the Union between the two
kingdoms of Scotland and England in 1707,
the English law of treason, and the forms of
proceeding with respect to inquiring into, and
trying the crime, came to be adopted by us as
a matter of high expediency and justice, that
the subjects ot both parts of the United King-
doms, who were bound to the same duty of
alleeiance might be under thC'Same law, and
triea in the same manner, in case of any
alleged breach of that duty. Accordingly it
was so settled by the act 7 queen Anne, c.
SI, which is the authority under which this
E resent commission of Oyer and Terminer
as been issued by his Majesty in the precise
form and manner prescribed by that statute.
The method of proceeding under such a com-
mission, is likewise well known. One advan-
tage 4:he- prisoner certainly has by it, namely,
that of passing through the hands of two
different juries before he can be convicted.
The kin^s advocate in every other case,
exerotses the power of a grand jury in Scot-
laud, and it is believed no advocate has ever
yet abused that power. But in cases of high
treason, none ot us will regret that so high
and momentous a trust is committed to no
individual whatever.
The treason law of England, which is now
also the law of Scotland, was fixed by a statute,
in the 85th year of Edward 3rd, firom the pre-
amble of which we learn, that, before his tune,
and while matters rested upon the iboting of
1175} 34 GEORGE HL
ProeuHt^ tigmnd RoihtH WaH
CllTi
common law, the definitions of treason were
yarious and imaettled, different opinions being
occasionally entertained upon the subject,
whereby the safety of individuals was much
endangered, as they did not precisely know
what actions were treasonable, and what were
otherwise. It was therefore thought proper,
in the rei^n of that wise and able prince, that
the descriptions of treason should be precise
and clear, and with that intent, this impor«
tant statute was made, which arranges and
describes the crime under different heads. Il
is needless to trouble you with the whole of
them^ as there are two only that have any
application to the present business. The first
IS m these words, <* When a man doth com^
pass or imagine the death of our lord the
King, or of our lady hb queen, or of their
eldest son and heir.'* The second, ^ Or if a
jnau levy war aeainst our lord the king in his
realm, or be adherent to the king's enemies
in his realm, giving to them aid and comfort
in the realm, or elsewhere, and thereof be
proveably attainted of open deed by the
people of their condition/'
Whether the indictment be laid upon the
one or the other of these heads, an overt act
must be charged and proved.
As tu tiie first, we are told by lord chief
justice Hale, in his excellent book upon the
Pleas of the Crown, that ^' Compassing the
death of the king is high treason, though it
be not effected ; but Mcause the compass-
ing is only an act of the mind, and cannot of
itself be tried without some overt act to evi*
deuce it, such an overt act is requisite to make
such compassing, or imagination, high trea-
son.*' And judge Foster, in his Crown Law,
another book of great authority, says, '* The
care the law halh taken for the personal
safety of the king is not confined to actions,
or attempts of the more flagitious kind, to
assassination, or poison, or other attempts,
directly and immediately aimino; at his life.
It is extended to every thing wilfully and de-
liberately done, or attempted, whereby his
lii'e may be endangered ; and therefore tha
entering into measures for deposing or im-
prisoniue him, or to get his person into the
power of the conspirators, these offences are
«vert ^cts of treason, within this branch of
the statute ; for experience has shown, that
'^ between the prison a^d the grav^of piinces
the dbtance is ve/y small.*'
As to the second head, both these learned
writers agree, that a bare conspiracy, or oon<-
sultation of persons, to levy a war, is not suf*
ficient to bring the case within that branch of
the statute ; but they also agree, that in qbt-
tain circumstances such a conspiracy or con^
sultation niav amount to an avert act of com-
passing the king's death, and so to bring the
case within the first branch. Thus lord chief
justice Ilale says, " An assembly to levy war
against the king, cither to depose or restrain,
.or enforce him to any act, or to come to his
jpj^e^jBi^ to remove his counsieUojns or minis*
ten, or to fight ayunst the kingf •
or militaiy commissiosate officers, in an
act proving the nnmpaiswing of the death of ^
king; for sucbi a war is directed againattiie
very person of the king, and he that rffi^w to
fight against the king, cannot but know at
least it must hazard his life,''
And judge Foster tells us, '' Every ipaui-
rection which, in judgment of law, is intended
u;punst the person ot the king, he it to de-
throne or imprison him, or to oblige faiaa to
alter his measures of govemment, or to n-
move evil counsellors firom about faim; ibeK
risings all amount to levying war within the
statute : whether attended with the pomp and
circumstances of open war or no. And ofciy
cantpiraey to levy war for these purpoic^
though not treason within the clause ot levy-
ing war, is yet an overt act wUhim the edir
cum$9 oj compasiing the king^t death. For
those purposes cannot be effected by numbcn
and open force, without manifest dangier to
bis person.'*
In like manner, judge BlackstonOy in apeik-
ing to the second branch of the stati.titi^ ujt*
that '^ A bare conspiiacy to levy war does osi
amount to this species of treason : but, if pw
ticularly pointed at the person of the kin& er
his government, it falls within the first, ti
compassing or imagining; the king's de^'
In short, a conspiracy to lev^ war against ihr
king for the purpose of restraining hun io vf
shape, is held equivalent to a coptpify
against his life.
Another species of insunectioo mar Idv
place, which not being so imaediatolj
pointed against the king, but only by oona^
quence, such as an insurrection to raise the
price of wages ; to open prisons; to destraj
meeting houses; to throw down adl ii
sures ; to alter the established law in any
ticular; or to redress any supposed grieve
it was more doubtful whether this sort wodd
fall under any clause of the statute. By cq»
struction of law, however, even this on sfi»
count of its tendency, has been held to be a
levying of war under the second clause, if dn
rising has actually taken place; but a facR
conspiracy to effect such a rising is not heU
as an overt act of compassing thelcing'sdeall^
the parties concerned not beios suppoeed to
have in contemplation any attaoc against the
king, or his royal authority, so as to put hit
person in hasard, unless this also be caaiged
and proved.
These distinctions have at different times
been the subject of a good deal of discussion;
but they seem to be founded in a just con-
struction of the treason law. — ^In every case,
therefore, of a charge for high treason upoo
the first branch of the statute, t. e. that of
compassing the king's death, when a conspb'
racy or consultation to levy war is allied as
the overt act, it is necessary to inquire what
sort of rising was intended, and what was the
object or purpose in view.
It does not belong to me to m;^, nor do I
1177]
for Higfi Treason*
A. D. 1794..
[1178
know wbat fMrecise inalien wlU be brought in
evidenoe bdbre you upoo the bills of indict*
menty which are to be 4be subject of your
consideiatioa; but in general, as high trea-
8<Hi u the charge, and as circum&Unces will
probably be brought in view tending to make
It appear that the parties accused were en«
gaeed in a conspiracy^ or had formed plans
and projects of rising in hostility against the
kins and his government, perh^s, under the
maskof refonn, but no matter what the pre-
tence was ; you will first satisfy yourselves as
to the evidence of the fact, and the nature of
the design^ and then you will consider what
the probable consequences would have been,
had such a design been carried into efiect. If
you see reason to think that the object of
those conoemedy firom the measures which
they took, was, by force of arms and of
numbers, to seize the government of the
ceimtry, and of course, to supersede the
king's authority, and to take the power of the
state into their own hands for a timcy ^ou
can scarcely hesitate to be also of opinion,
not only that the king's person would, by the
execution of so despente a project, have been
put into the moet imminent daneer, but that
the probable consequences would nave been to
deluge the land with blood 1
If the case appear to you in that light, you
will consider whether it is not your duty to
find a bill. If it appear to be of a different
description, your answer will be accordingly.
The character which all of vou bear, leaves
not the smidkst room to doubt that the pub-
Ik will be completely satisfied whatever your
determination may be.
Mr. Anttrmtker moved, that A rthur M'Ewan,
William Bonthom^ John Fairley, William
Brown, Robert Orrock, and Martin Tod, pri-
soners, now detained for hich treason, might
be admitted witnesses on benalf of the crown,
and be convejred before the grand juiy to give
evidence on bills of indictment aeainst Robert
Watt, David Downie, and John Edmonds
Stock, for high treason; whidi was orderMi
accordingly.
The before>mentioned witnesses were then
brought into court to be sworn, but revised to
be sworn according to the English form;
upon which the lord president swore each of
them according to the Scottish form.
Then the erand jury requested, that Mr.
Knapp, the cferk of the commission, and Mr.
Warrender, the erown agent,* might attend
them during their examination of the bills of
indictment.
Mr. AfutrtUher moved the Court for the
same. It was accordingly ordered.
The Court then adjourned until seven of the
dock the same evening, in order to give the
grand jury time to consider of the bills; but
* As to this, see the cases of the Reei-
cides in this Collection, Vol. 5, p. 97S; the
earl of Shaftesbury, Vol. 8, p. p. 774^ 773; and
Colonel Raynard, Vol. 14, p. 477.
at the same time the lord preddent intimated
the wish of the Court thatthey would not over
hurry themselves, but if they should not be
agreed at that time, that then the Court
would adjourn over to the next morning.
The same day at seven o'clock the Court
met, pursuant to their adjournment, when
the same commissioners were present. The
grand jury tlien came into court, and their
names being called over, they presented two
bills of indictment One against Robert Watt
and David Downie, and the other against
John Edmonds Stock, for high treason, en*
dorsed. True bills. The Court then ordered
the sheriff to have the bodies of Watt and
Downie brought from the Castle and set to
the bar, tp be informed that there were bills
of indictment found against them. They were
accordingly brought to the bar, and were in-
formed by the Lord President, thatthey were
entitled to have counsel to defend them, and
that the Court would assign them any they
would name ; but it appearing to the Court
that' they were not then prepared to name
their counsel, the Court indulged them till
eleven o'clock the next day to do so ; and it
was ordered by the Court in the mean time,
that their agents should have access to them
in prison, at anv reasonable times. The Court
also informed them, that they were entitled to
a copy of their indictment, and list of the wit-
nesses to be produced against them, and a list
of the jury iu tended to try them, delivered ten
days before their trial. Then a. copy of their
indictment, together with the caption of the
Court, and a list of the witnesses, containing
their names, professions^ and jidaces of abode ;
and a list of the jury, containing their names,
professions, and peaces of abode were then de-
livered to each of the prisoners in Court. -
Then the Court acljourned until eleven
o'clock on Friday muming.
Proceedings of the Court on Friday the 15th
instant at eleven o'clock in the forenoon.
' Present, — ^The lord president, the lord jus-
tice clerk, lord Henderland, lord Swinton,
lord Dunsinnan, and the lord chief baron.
The two prisoners, Watt and Downie, were
then put to the bar.
Robert Watt desired the Court to assign as
counsel for him, William Robertson,^ esq.
and William Ecskine, esq. and in case of the
non-«ttcndance of both those gentlemen on
his behalf, then he named Archibald Fletcher,
esq. instead of either of them who mi^ht be
absent; and he named John M'Ritchie as
his agent, which the Court consented to, and
ordered accordingly.
Then the prisoner David Downie delivered
in a list of the names of several advocates,
and denred the Court would assign any two
of them to assist him in making lis defence.
— — »^i.— «i ■ ■■■III 1 ..■ — ^.— — ^.»."
* Afterwards Lord Robertson.
1179] 34 GEORGE IIL
Proeeedingi agamd lUhrt WM
[1180
The Court named, at his request, John Clerk,
esq. and Archibald Fletcher, esq. to be his
counsel, and in case either of them should not
be able to attend, Robert Cullen,* esq. in
their stead, and named John Dillon to be his
aeent, which the Court ordered accordingly,
llien it Mras ordered by tlie Court, that the
several counsel and agents should hare access
to the prisoners at all seasonable hours ; at the
same time, giving them leave to take the ad-
vice and the assistance of any other advocate
whom they might think proper, and if any of
those advocates so appomted should not be
able to attend, that then the Court would, at
the requisition of the prisoners, assign any
other they should name. The prisoners were
then informed, that they would be broueht
up to plead to their indictment on Wednesday
the 87th instant, but that they were not then
to be tried . The Court then adjourned to Fri-
day the tad mstanty at 11 o'clock in the fore-
noon.
Pn)ceedJngs of the Court on Friday the 3td
August.
Present,— The lord justice clerk, lord Dun-
•innan, lord Abercrombie, and the lord chief
baron.
Mr. William Robertttm. — My lords, I have
been appointed by your lordships as one of the
counsel for Robert Watt, but I wish to submit
to the Court whether, as I have the honour of
being solicitor-general for his royal highness
the prince of Wales, for Scotland, I can be
assigned as counsel for a prisoner who is in-
dicted for high treason. The duties of the
station I hold seem to me to be repugnant to
those I might be called upon to exercise as
^unsel for the prisoner at the bar. I hope
your lordships will think this a sufficient ex-
cuse for my not appearing as counsel for him.
TAc Lord Chief Baron, — ^I hope notice has
bten given of this to the prisoner, that he may
name some other person for the appointment
of the Court to supply your place, as your
objection is very proper.
• Mr. William Ertkine,— My lords, I attend
as counsel for the prisoner Robert Watt,
along with Mr. Robertson. X beg leave to in-
form the Court that, in consequence of early
notice having been sent to Robert Watt, that
Mr. Robertson could not attend, he has named
Mr. Robert Hamilton to be one of his counsel.
To which the counsel for the crown readily
consented, and he was assigned accordingly.
Lord Advocate, — ^The purpose of your Tord>
ships a4Journine to this particular day, was
on the motion oT the counsel for the prosecu-
tion ; they at that time having reason to be-
lieve it would have been in their power to
liave brought some business before your lord-
ships to-day, but they have been disappointed
in their expectations. The person they in-
* Afterwards Lord Culleu. .
tended to have brought to your lordships bar
to-day is not yet taken. I tiave therefore no*
thing more to trouble the Court with to-day,
and am soiiy that the Court have had the
trouble of attending.
Lord Chief Barom, — Then it will be pro-
per for the Court to make the order of ad-
journment.
Mr. Enkine.^-^My lord, I observe in this
indictment against Watt, there are aevenl
papers foundra on by the counsel for the pro-
secution alleged to be of a treasonable nature,
which he is accused of having written and
published. I should submit by ^e fbrms of
this court, whether we are not entitled to
see those papers before the prisoner is put
upon his defence.
Mr. AnMtruiker. — It is almost unnecessary
for me to say one word in answer to what is
proposed by the counsel for the prisoners;
such a proposition has never been noade be-
fore in any such case. The prisoner is enti-
tled to a copy of the indictment and a list of
the witnesses to be produced against him,
but he is not entitled to see the evidence the
counsel for the crown mean to produce ; tfaey
will produce it in proper time : at present,
with all due deference, it is not in the power
of the Court to call upon the prosecutors for
a disclosure of the written testimony or the
oral evidence they mean to produce. These-
fore this motion cannot have success. If the
counsel for the prisoner desire to have any
paper produced which they rely on as evi-
dence, ther nay, by means of a sobpcena dmtm
teaimy call upon any witness to produce such
gapers at the trial ; but before, it is impossi^
le to have the papers in our possession, or to
have a disclosure of the evidence on which we
mean ro rely.
Mr. Er$kine —I do not know that I am en-
titled to press my present motion. It is weU
known to your lordships, that the counsel for
the crown could not by the laws of this coun-
try produce a single paper against a prisoner
on his trial, which his counsel have not had
an opportunity of seeing. The genUemen on
the other side have asserted t&t a difierent
rule prevails in England. Your lordships will
judee between us.
Lord Chief Baron. — ^Thc counsel for the
prosecution may consent to a production of
particular papers in their custodv.
. Lord Advocate, — ^Unquestionably, so for as
any papers in our custody are proper to
be produced, or shewn, we can have no ob-
jection to their being produced to the prisoner.
Lord Chief Baron, — ^They may call for it aa
evidence in defence.
Mr. AnttnUher. — ^They are to do as they
think fit - '
Lord Chief Baron. — ^What those papers are,
Mr. Erskine wishes to see, I know nothing
about. I have not seen the indictment;
whatever way it may be laid, the prisoner is
entitled to see nothing without the consent of
the counsel. for the crown— they are lopro*
1181]
Jar High TrcatoH,
A. D. 1794.
[1182
duce whatever evidence they think proper. —
If the prisoner's counsel think it material,
-Uie moae of coining at it is laid down hy
the counsel for the crown, that they may
liave the common process, and may be pre-
pared to make use of it, when the trial comes
on.
Mr. AnstrtUher. — ^W^ propose to bring up
the prisoners on Wednesday next, in ot&t to
their being arraigned. The act of narliaroent
allows ten days from the time of delivering
the copy of the indictment, which was done
on Thursday last. Ten clear days and the
two Sundays carry us to Wednesday the S7th
iostant, as the earliest day upon which they
can be arraigned.
The Court was then adjourned to Wednes-
day the 97 th of August at eleven o*clock in
the forenoon.
Wednesday August 97M, ^794,
The Court met according to adjournment,
when the following commissioners were
present: —
Lord Justice Clerk, Mr. Baron Fletcher
Norton, Lord Eskgrove, Lord Swinton, Lord
Dunsinnan and Lora Abercrombie.
The prisoners were then brought to the bar
and arraigned
Lord Mtke C/erfc— ^Gentlemen of counsel
for the prisoners, have you any motion to
make?
Mr. FUtdter. — ^Formerly your lordship ap-
pointed Mr. Clerk and myself as counsel, and
m case either of us could not attend, the priso-
ner requested Mr. Cullen might be appomted,
aad your lordship did appoint Mr. Cullen in
the place of Mr. Clerk for David Downie.
Mr. Knapp, — ^He was appointed provision-
ally.
Mr. Hamilton. — There is a witness, who is
extremely important for the defence of the
prisoner, (to wit) Watt, for whom I appear;
nis name is Kennedy ; he is a witness tor the
crown; but I understand, he is not to be
found.' — I wish to know if the counsel for the
crown have any reasonable expectation of
gjetting him brought forward as a witness for
the crown. — ^If they have, he will be also
ready for the prisoner.
Mr. Anstruther. — Kennedy is named among
ihe list of witnesses, and the counsel for the
crown have made every inquiry, both in Eng-
land and here, to have his person ; whether
they will be successful in finding him I can-
not say, bat most undoubtedly, no means
hav^ been spared for the purpose.
Mr. Hamilton,'^! have received a satisfac-
tory answer from the counsel for the crown ;
the reason for my motion was that the wit^
ness's testimonv is of great consequence for
the defence of the prisoner, and if so I appre-
hend I should be well founded in grounding
my motion for the delay of this trial.— I
will not say X shall not iu a subsequent stage
of this trial make such motion. I under-
stood by the law of England, when a witness
is not present, who it is necessary should be
produced, if there is any expectation of get-
ting him, I should be entitled to move for
a delay of the trial, for such time as mu^ht
he necessary to bring such witness forward.
Mr. Fletcher. •^My lords, as Mr. Downie,
my client, has the same dependancc upon the
testimony of Kennedy as Mr. Watt has, if
there is any delay granted to the one, I
should move the same may be granted to the
other.
Mr. Anstruther, — ^It is not necessary for me
in this state of the business, to object to a
motion not now made, but announced as in-
tended to be made ; but I wish to be candid,
and to inform the counsel for the prisoners,
that if ever such a motion shall be made^ I
shall oppose it to the utmost of my power ;
and I have no scruple in stating one of the
rounds on which I shall oppose the motion.-—
wish the Court to be informed, that this Mr .
Kennedy is a person, who upon the first dis-
covery of the treasonable acts charged on the
gentlemen at your lordships bar (and who is
now stated to be a material witness), thought
proper to elope from this country, and to fiy
irom justice, which was in search of him ;
from the 1st of May to the present hour,
none of the officers of justice, either in Scot-
land or England, ever could lay hands upon,
or get sight of Kennedy, or gain the least
intelligence where be is to be found, — rewards
have oeen offered for his apprehension, which
have not yet had efiect; — therefore, when-
ever a motion to delay the trial, shall be made
upoii the ground of his absence I shall op-
pose it, and the more so, if it is made three
wedks after the notice of the day of trial. If
the counsel for the prisoners know where he
is to be found, I can only say, we shall be ex-
tremely obliged to them for such information,
and I will answer for it, if he is to be found.'
he shall be brought in custody to the bar.
Mr. . Hamilton. — I have had an answer
which is satisfactory ; I only mentioned that
in case it was likeW for him to be produced, I
might perhaps make such a motion.
Mr. Vundas. — The counsel for the prisoners
will exercise their own discretion as to their
motions in future ; 1 can only say, if such a
motion is to be made, and it should succeed,
the trial may be deferred for ever : large re.>
wards have heen offered for Kennedy's appro,
hension in vain.
Mr. Hamilton. — My motion was in case the
counsel for the crown had any reasonable ex-
pectation of getting him.
Lord Justice C/erA.^— Have you any other
motion to make?
Mr. Fleteher.-^l understand the defendants
are to be separately tried.
Lord Aivocate.^-They nmfft be sepaiately
tried. ^£
Mr. Knapp. — If they join in their chal-
lenges, they may be tried together.
1183] 34 GEORGE IlL
Proceedings agaima Robert Watt
CI 184
Mr. JnstnUker.-^Vnak respect to that,
your lordships know, on trials for hi^ trea-
80D, every prisoner may challenge thirty-five.
It beeomes extremely inconvenient to try two
persons together, because, if they differ in
their challenges, it would be attended with
great difficulty. The counsel for the crown,
uierefore, mean to desire two several panels
for the trial of the two prisoners; if thev
agree, they would be bound down to one chaf-
lenee for both. We do not ask them to do
aucn a thing.
Mr. Fletcher. — ^I believe they will not agree
in their challenges. What we wish to know,
as counsel for the defendants, is, which is to
be tried firsts
Lord Advocate, — I have no objection at all
to state to Mr. Fletcher, that our intention is
to bring Mr. Watt to trial first
PRECBPT FOa THE PeTIT JuRT.
Edinburgh^ > Rob. McQueen, esq. justice clerk
to wit, { of our loni the king ; David Rae,
esq. of Eskgrove; John Swinton,- esq. of
Swmton; sir^illiam Naime, ofDunsinnan,
baronet; Alexander Abercrombie, esq. of
Abercrombie ; commissioners of iusticiary of
our said lord the king; and Fletcher Norton,
esq. senior baron of our said lord the king, of
his court of excheauer. in that part of Great
Britain called Scotland, iustices of our said
lord the king, assigned by letters patent of
our said lord the king, under the great seal of
Great Britain, made by virtue of, and accord-
ing to the form of the statute, made in the
seventh year of the reign of the lady Anne,
late queen of Great Britain, &c. intituled,
'' An Act for improving the Union of the two
Kmgdoms,'' to us andothers our fellows jus-
tices of our said lord the king, in the said let-
ters patent named, and to any three or more
of us and them made and directed (of whom
our said lord the king willed that one of us,
the said Robert Macqueen and David Rae,
amonest others in the said betters patent
named should be one), to inquire by the oath
of good and lawful men of the county Edin-
burgh, in that nart of Great Britain called
Scotland, and oy other ways, means, and
methods, by which we and others, our fellows
justkes aforesaid, should or rai^ht better
know (as well within liberties as without) by
whom the truth of the matter may be better
known and inquired into, of all high treasons
and misprisions of high treasons within the
county aforesaid (as well within liberties as
without), by whomsoever, and in what man-
ner soever, and by whom, when, how, and
after what manner done, committed, or per-
petrated, and of all other articles ana circum-
stances concerning the premises, and every
of them, or any of them, in any manner what-
soever; and the same high treasons and mis-
prisions of high treasons, according to the
iOTtno^ the aforesaid statute, to hear and de-
termine ; To the sheriff of the said county of
Edinburgh, greeting ; We, on the behalf of
our said lord the king^ eommand you, that
you do not omit, by reason of any liberty in
your bailiwkk, but that you cause 1o oome
before us and others our fellows justices albr&-
said, in the said letters patent named wad
assigned, or before any three or more of us
and them (of whom our said lord the king*
willed, that one of ns, the said Robert Blac-
' queen and David Rae, amongst others in the
said letters patent named, should be one), al
the town and city of Ediiibor^h, in your said
county, on Wedn^aj the third dav of Sep*
tember next, twelve cood and lawful men, of
the neighbourhood of the parish of St. OiJes»
in your said county, every one of whom most
have lands and tenements within your said
county, of the yearly value of forty shillings
sterling at least, by whom the truUi of the
matter may be the better known and inmiired
into, and who are not of kin to Robert Watt,
late of the said parish of St. Giles, in your
said county, wine merchant, to try upon thetr
oath, whether the said Robert Watt be guilty
of a certain high treason, whereof before us,
and others our fellows justices aforesaid, he
stands indicted or not, because the said Ro-
bert Watt hath put himself upon that Jury,
and have you then there the names of the
said jurors, and this precept. Given under
our hands and seals, at Edinburgh aforesaid,
this twenty-seventh day of August, in the
thirty-fourth year of the reim of our aovereign
lord George the third, by tne grace of God^
king of Great Britain, France and Irelaodt,
defender of the faith, and so forth.
(S. L.) Rob. Macqveeh.
(S. L.) David Rae,
(S. L.) JOSK SWINTON.
(S. L.) Alex. Abekcrombie.
(S. L.) WfLLiAV Nairve. -
(S. L.) Fletcuer Nortov.
Lord Justice C/«rA:.— The Court will now
adjourn to Wednesday next, at eight o'clock.
The rest of the judges then agreed to R^iom
to Wednesday, at eight o'clock in the morn-
ing precisely.
Proclamation was then made accordingly^
by the cryer of the court
Wednesday, September the Sd, 1794.
Present — ^Lord President, Lord Chief Baron^
Lord Justice Clerk, 'Mr. Baron Norton, Lord
Eskmve, Lord Swinton, Lord Dunsinnao^
Lora A bercombie.
Couruelfor the Cronm. — The Lord Adnv
cate [Dundas, afterwards lord chief baron},
Mr. sblidtor General [Blair, afterwards lonl
president], Mr. Anstruther, Mr. Dundas.—
Agentf Mr. Wanender.
Counul for the Prisoner. — Mr. Hamiliol^
Mr. Erskine. — Jgent, Mr. M'JUtchie.
Clerk of Arraigns. — You, the prisoner H
the bar, these good men that yon shall heir
J
1 185]; Jbr N^ Treoiom.
<}fllM, aad penonalbF appear^ srotofMsW
tweca our sovereign lord the king and jon,
upott the Urial ofywxt life and death ; ify.ther»<
foT^' you will ohallengQ them^ or any o#
them,' your time i» to speak unto theni, as
they eome to the book to be swbrn^ and be-
fore they are sworn.
The July were then caHed", as foUows: —
Geofge Gardner — Prisoner^ I challenge him.
Jobn Beil — PriMotter^ I ehallenge him.
Tbi>. Muir, esq^ — Prisoner, I challenge hitti;
Alexander Houston, did not appear.
Benjamin Ytile— Pruoner, I challenge him.
l>oiial^ Smith— PrMofier, I challenge him.
Junes Carfraa — Primmer, I challenge him.
Sir W. Forbes, bt — Prisoner, I challenge him.
Bob. Young— PrudfMT, I challenge him.
Alaa..Wal£ce — Prisoner, I ehaOenee him.
William Mitchell was called, anaa certifi-
oate of bad health was produoed, from- Mr.
Cheyne, a sunseon; Mr. Mitchell war accord-
ingly excused by the Court.
Adolphus Scales ; he was from home wheal
inmtQoeed. There is a letter from his bro«
ther, that he had been absent for three
weeks.
. To tiiesummDning officer, Andrew Scott.— <•
Did you leare a summons at Mr. Scales's
houBe?-— Yes.
What number is it?— I will tell you; No.
15 ; sumtnoned the SSth of August last.
. Was he at home?— No.
. You left it with the servant?— Yes. (No
iuther notice was taken by the Court)
Patffkk Inglis; a melancholy erent had
prevented his attendance.
James Mansfield did not answer*
1. David Clark was sworn in.
8. William Hunter was sworn in.
> 3. James Mitchell was sworn in.
4. John Scougall was sworn in.
5. William Sibbald was sworn in.
6. John Homer was sworn in^
7. Thonaa Hutchinson was sworn in*
8. Aiehibald Campbell was sworo in.
9i 6eoi]ge Kinnear was sworn in.
10. William Frazer was swiom in.
11. John Andrew was sworn in.
13. William Lamb was swohi in«
Clerk of Arraigns. — Count these. He then
called over the names of the jurors sworn;
they were accordingly counted.
Cierk of 4rro»gn^,'^tyes, make procla^
: nation.
Cfyer. — Oyes ! If any one can inform my
lord the king's advocate general, or this in«
tjuest now to be taken, of the Ingh treason
Whereof the prisoner at the bar stands in^
dieted, let them come forth, and they shall
be heard^ for now the prisoner stands at the
bar upon his deliverance, and all others that
are bound, hy recognisance, to give evidence
. agamst the jirisoner at the bar, let them come
forA an^ give Umr evidence, er else they
forfeit their recogninnce, and all jurymen
VOL. xxm.
jild: i7Mi
[ins
dlatf have bean cafled^ and have lippearetb
and are not sworn, nlay depart the court.
Cierk ef u^rraijgtu.— Robert Watt, hold up
yourhlmd! (which he did.)
Clerk ofArrasgnM, to the Jury. — ^CenHenben^
you that are sworn, look upon the prisoner,
and hearken to his chaige. He stands in«
dieted by the name of Robert Watt,, late of
Edinburgh, in the county of Edinbur^, not
having the fear of God in his heart, nor
wMghing the duty of his allegiance, but being
moved asafiilse traitor against our lord' the
king, and wholly withdrawing the cordial
love, and true and due obedience, fidelity
and ailegianoe, which every true and faithful
subject should, and of right ouaht, tb bear
towavda our lord the king, and wickedly*,
maliciouslVy and trtutoroiisiy contriving td
break and disturb the peace, and to change^
subvert, and overthrow the government ha!p4
pily established in this kingdom^ and to ex^
cite, move, and raise insunrection and rebel*
lion, and to depose our lord the king from tho
government or Great Britain, and to put him
to death, on the first day of March last, and
on divers other days.
The first overt act is, that he, on the first
of March, did nudiciously, wickedly, and trai*
torously meet, conspire, consult, and agree
to cause and procure a meeting of divers sub-
jects, to be assembled and held, within this
kingdom of Great Britain, under the name of
a Convention, for the puq)ose of assuming to
theaoselves, at such meeting, the powers of
aovemment and legislation over thirking^
dom (independent and in defiance of the
authority, and against the whole of thepar*
liament of tins kmgdom), and of subvertins
and altering the rule and gpvemment, anl
deposing pur Lord the King »om the govern^
ment and royal state.
The seoona overt act is, that he met, and
conscdted to instigate, incite, enconraee^ and
persnade the subjects of our lord the king to
cause and procure divers meetings and assem-
blies, for the purpose of choosmg dedegatef
from among tnemselvee^ to meet in a m^et*
VM, under the name or a conventiosy to ba
h(3d for the purpose of assuming to themselvea
the powers of government and legislatioB^
and of deponng Uie king.
The third overt act is^ that he met and as«
semblad to choose a convention to be held;
theobject of which was, to redress national
grievances by usurping to themselves tha
powers of government and legislation of this
kingdom, m defiance of the authority of par*
liament.
The fourth overt act is, consulting to bring
about in such a convention to be held with*
out the consent of parliament, an aheratioil
and change in the mode of representatioa,
and instigating and incitinjg persons to said
delegates to such convention for the sama
purpose.
The fifth overt act, that he conspired with
other false traitors by force to oblige the king
4 G
1187] 54 6E0AGE UL
Froceedimgi ugaimi Robert WaU
liiak
tosher the measurai of govenuBtDt, and Ur
comply with certain unlawful demands, pro*
positions, and measures to be thereafter made
by him, relating to the king's administntion
of the government of this kingdom. •
« The sixUi overt act is, that he conspired to
nuse and make insurrection and reballion
against our lord the king.
The seventh overt act is, that he conspired
to oblige tlic king by force to comply with
certain demands to be made by him, and con-
sent to the introduction of regulations and
measures respecting the government of this
kinedom.
The eiehth overt act is, that he conspired,
consulted, and agreed with other false traitors,
to seize and take the castle of Edinbui^h into
his possession by force of arms, with guns,
pikes, spears, battle-axes, and other offen-
sive weapons, and to provide leaders to be ap-
pointed and instructed by him, and to lay m
wait and surprise the forces of our lord the
king, stationed in the said castle of Edin-
burgh, and to attack and fi^ht them, and to
take into his possession by torce the public
banks and excise office, and 1o seize and im-
prison the justice clerk, the lords of council
and session and justiciary, and the lord pro-
vost of Edinburgh.
. The ninth overt act is, that he did instigate
and incite divers subjects of our lord the king,
to consent to, and approve the last mention-
ed traitorous proposals, and to aid and assist
kim in effecting and carrying the same into
execution.
' The tenth overt act is, that he conspired
and consulted with other false traitors, to pro-
cure arms for the purpose of arming himsell
And others to enable nim to resist the kins
in the legal exercise of his royal power ana
authority.
The eleventh overt act is, that he conspir-
ed to raise and levy money, the better to carry
into effect his traitorous purposes aforesaid^
• ' The twelfth overt act is, that he composed,^
Srinted, published and dispersed certain ma-
cious, wicked and treasonable papers and
addresses amone the sul^jects of our lord the
kins, inciting them to contribute and sub-
scribe money for the use of him and other
false traitors, and to appoint collectors to col-
lect'and receive such money, and to remit
and pay the same to him, with intent that
such money should be accounted for and dis-
bursed in such way as should be most calcu-
lated to make and raise insurrection and re-
bellion a^inst the king.
The thirteenth overt act is, that he hired
and employed John Fairley to carry and dis-
perse such papers as last aforesaid, and de-
livered him a great quantity for that purpose,
with intent to incite the subjects of our saia
lord the king, forcibly to resist the king in
the exercise of his authority, and to assist in
prosecuting an attempt to be made to sub-
vert fhejgovernment. -
The fourteenth overt act is^ that he io- 1
stnictod tbe said John Fairley t» in
. incite the subjects of our said lord 4be kinA
to eive assurance and support, and to reni
sucn money ais should be collected to bim.
The fifteenth overt act is, that he
ed the said. John Fairley to instigate auaci
cite the subjects of our said lord tbe kixi^
to procure arms, and to arm themselves I0
resist the king, and to aid and assist bim ja
subverting the government.
The sixteenth overt act is, that be employ.
ed William Brown to make and procure aims
for armins himself and other false tndtoasy
and paid tnem money for the same. .
The seventeenth overt act is, that be em-
ployed Jlobert Orrock te make arnis for the
same purpose.
The eighteenth overt act is, that be oob-
tinued and got into his possession arms, and
kept them concealed in his dwelling bouse,
in readiness to be made use of for tbe traito*
rous purposes aforesaid, against the duty of
his allegiance, against the form of tbesta*
tttte in such case made and provided, against
the peace of our said lord the king, his
crown and dimity. .
Upon this indictment he hath been ana»-
ed, and thereuxito hath pleaded not gum,
and for his trial hath put himself upon God
and the country, which country you are.
Your chargje is to itfquire whether be be gial-
ty of this high treason whereof he atands ia*
dieted or not guilty ; if you find hiin gMflty,
vou are to inquire what goods and chattdsi
lands, and tenements he had at the time the
high treason was committed^ or at any tina
since ; if you find him not guilty, you are l»
inquire if he fled for it, you are to iDquire.of
his goods and chattels as if you bad fbuiid
him guilty^ if you find him not guilty, and
that be did not flv for it, you are to say so
and no more, and hearken to the evideoce.
Mr. DatMbf.— Gentlemen of the jury, this b
an indictment against the prisoner at the bar
for high treason. As the officer has read .the
^ae versa overt acte of high treason, and .the
several acts of the defendant, to cany into
effect his .treasonable purposes, it becomes
necessary for roe to do no more than state the
substance of this indictment, which, if! do
not deceive myself, I shall be able to slate
in almost one sentence.
The indictment states that the prisoner coi^'
spired to endeavour to call a conrention^
which convention .was to usurp the powers of
legislation in this country, and to take inttf
their own hands the ledress of certain »^>*"*t*^1
grievances which this defendant alleged to
exist. The indictment states that the de-
fendant has conspired .to procure arms to be
placed in .the hands of the subject against the
sovereign, to reust the exercise of royal an-
tliority, to compel his nu^esty to change the
measures of his government^ to force him to
adopt such plans and such sdiemes as to this
deff^ndant and his associates it m%ht seem
expedient to propose. ;
iisfo
Jor High Treastm*
OetiUemen, that I may not waste your
^ime, 841 the task of erplaining the law de-
-voWes into the hands of a person better quali-
-fied, J will state, finally, gentlemen, that the
•defendant had conspired with other associates,
-to concert measures to overawe and restrain
the conduct of the ^oyernmcnt, and to en-
danger the person of his majesty, which, as
•the language of the indictment, and which
the law states, is to compass and imagine the
death of 4he king — to this indictment the de-
•^ndant has pleaded not guilty. You will
Jiesu'ken to the evidence, and give your ver-
dict accordingly^
- MtrAnttruther, — My lords, andeenUemen
<of the jury ;— It is my duty upon the present
occasion, to lay before you tne state of the
case which the counsel for the crown think
they shall be able to prove against the prison-
er at the bar.
In doing this, gentlemen, it will be neces*
4sary for- me to bespeak a considerable portion
-of your attention, and that of the Court ; be-
•cause such has been the happy state of this
country, such has been the peace and pros-
■^pority with which this nation hath been Itles-
<8ecl, under that constitution which the prison-
er at the bar is charged with attempting to
overturn, that the law of treason lives not in
Ahe experience of any of us. It is now nearly
iialf a century since, in this country, there
'was occasion to bring any person to trial for
such an c^ence. It is therefore necessary for
me to state to you fully, and explain to you
•distinctly what the law is of which we charge
the prisoner with having committed a breach,
and then I shall lay before you, those facts
.which we mean to prove as breaches of that
iaw.
In doing this I have already stated, I shall
have occasion to request a considerable por-
tion of your patience, because I possess none
.of those powers of oratory which could en-
.gage your attention for the length of time
which it may be necessary to consume. If I
did possess any such powers, gentlemen, I
should abstain Jrom the use of them upon the
present occasion. It is not my duty ; I am
not sent here for that purpose; and I am
sure I should ill execute the trust which is re-
posed in me, I should ill perform the duty
which I owe to the sovereign whom I serve,
if I endeavoured to excite your passions
against the prisoner at the bar. It is my duty
to give ^ou a plain and dry statement of the
law ; it is my duty to give you a succinct nar-
rative of the &ct, accompanied with such ob-
servations as may be necessary to explain
those fiicts and that law to you, and there my
duty for tlie present ends.
I ou all know that the law of treason has
been, since the beginning of this century, the
same both in this country and in England.
After the union of the two kingdoms, it was
thoi^t wise and expedient^ that as we all
owed the same duties to our sovereign, the
JiiMsure and extent of those duties should be
A. D. 179*. [H90
one and the same in all parts of the kingdom*
As we serve one master, as we obey one so-
vereign, and are living under one legislature,
it was thought proper, not only that we should
have the same duties to perform, but that the
same modes and means of trial and punish*
ment for the breach of those duties should
take place in both countries. Therefore I am
under the nesessity of stating to you the law
of treason, as it exists in the law of England,
because the law of England has been the law
of Scotland upon that subject for near a centu-
ry past. And give me leave to remind you, that
it was a wise and beneficent act to the sub-
ject which extended the English law of trea-
son to this country. I need not tell the learn-
ed bench I address, I need hardly tell any
man of common education who hears me,
that the law of treason as it existed in Scot-
land, anterior to the happy period I am speak-'
ing of, was a law infinitely more severe, in-
fimtely more oppressive and more hard upon
the subject than the law that existed in Eng-
land at the same period. We are therefore
indebted to the wisdom, to the beneficence,
and to the humanity of that legislature which
extended to us the advantages already enjoy-
ed b^ our fellow subjects in the other end of
the island.
Gentlemen, the law of treason lies in a
short compass ; it has existed merely in its
present form in England ever since the reign
of Edward 3d, when it was reduced to a
certainty, and stated in a short act of parlia^
ment, which has been little altered from that
period to the present day. That act states
three distinct species of treason, independent
of that species of treason which has no con-
nexion with the present case, namely, coun-
terfeiting the coin. The first is compassing
and imagining the death of tlie king. The
second is levying war acainst the king. The
third is adhering to the King's enemies: who*
ever shall be found guilty of any of these
three species of offence is guilty of treason. •
With the two last of these, it will not be
necessary that I should trouble you at all.
Levying war against the king is not the offence
which the indictment charges against the pri-
soner at the bar, neither is the adhering to
the enemies of the king the offence you are
now to try.
The single species of treason charged
against the prisoner at the bar, is compassing
and imagining the death of the king.
Gentlemen, the charge I say, is compassing
and imagining the death of the king. You cant-
not but take notice of the singularity of the
phrase which constitutes the crime in this
instance.
Compassing and imaeining the death of
the king,— that is, he who intends, he into
whose imagination it enters, he who con?*
ceives the design of destroying the sovereigjifr
upon the throne is ^uiJt;^ of the crime. It is
the intention and imagination of the persoa
upon which the law amzes the guilt. . And
1191] MGEO&GE m.
PfOceeHngs ngdnsk Retort WaU
CllflB
therefore) it is that ibe law uses tbe obvise--
compassing and imagining the deatn of the
king.
Gentlemen^ the law has been thus cautious
and thus anxious to preserve the life of his
majesty, because the law knows the danser
to which we must all be exposed ; the ELw
knows the bloodshed and ruin into wluch this
country must be involved, if such compassings
und imaginations take effect, and therefore
has gone beyond its usual limits in its care
/or the preservation of the person of his ma-
jesty, and has 6xed the crime upon the in*
Mention, and not upon the act done.
But whilst it has been thus cauCiowi and
4hu8 anxious to preserve the life of his ma-
jesty, whilst it has gone ttie length of fixing
the crime upon the intention of tM person, it
has been equally anxious for the lite of the
«ubject ? and tfaiough it sayv the intentioD of
the subject is the crime it punishes, yet it
does not rashly 4»r lightly oc^lect that in-
tention; it does not gather the imagining
the death of tkie king from 'loose or vague
suspicion; for the statute of Edward Srd
aays, ** no man shall be found guilty of com-
passing or imaginine the death of the king,
iuiIms he be proveably attaint bv open deed,
before men ot his condition.'' Therefore it is
necessary that I should explain to vou what
that open deed is, or what it is which is called
in the language of the law, an overt act of
high treason. Every indictment must con-
tain in it the overt acts charged rupon the
prisoner, and the truth or the falsenood of
those now stated you are to try.
Gentlemen, an overt act m high treason,
is the means that are used for efiectuatlng
the purpose of the mind. If a person barely
conceives the idea of compassing and imagin-
ing the king's death, that b not treason, but
h^comes treason, and punishable as such
the moment he employs any means, what-
ever they may be, to effectuate the purpose
of his mind ; what the law calls an overt act
in its own language, is then in common lan-
guage, no more than the means the person
takes to effectuate the purpose of his heart.
And the overt acts stated to you in this in-
dictment, are the means which we charge
this defendant has employed to carry his in-
tention into practice. Gentlemen, you have
heard the phrase compass and imagine
She kiog's death. Now, you are not to sup-
pose from this that it is necessary for me to
;stale some direct or positive design to poison
or assassinate the king, or to put an end to his
life by any direct method. It is not necessary
i shcMsld prove an attempt to assassinate or
destroy him directly, because I have told you
the cnihe is in the imagination of the person,
and the overt act is the means used to carry it
•into effect. If he incendc^d to do that which,
4n its natural coose(}uence, endangers tiie life
•of the .king; if he used means to accomplish
9l pu^pos^ .whioh placed his mi^estyin a
sltuatieaofp^ril, and those moans be stetied
in the in&tment, lie must beffaundgaWgr; ftr
men shall not be lUlowadto attempt to place the
sovereign in such skiiatkws, and then ma^ fibay
did not compass the death of the kins, te.
cause they oid not intend the natuivX i
necessary consequences rccMiting froB
acts.
Hierefore, if I produce etvideDce to
you of such intention in the prisoner eift tiie
bar, and if I have charged in the indietineDl,
and prove in ^t what amounts in ^point sf
law, to means used to eiiMlMile that axtcn-
tion and that purpoasy it wHl be yonr dmbf Ss
find him guilty.
These are not my ideas, these are not my
words, these are not my espiaoations of Sks
law; tor standing in the situation in wriudiT
stand, in the peculiar circumskanoes in wbiehl
am now adaressing a jury of my ocHial^-
men, I should feel myself highly crimiBal in*
deed, gentlemen, if i stretched the law ok
word l^yond its fair bearing. I wish you li
take no construction of mine into yeoar con-
sideration. I will prove what I have said H
be the law bv the opinions and writinei of
^le and skilful men, at all periods of ay
constitution, and by the words of learned mk
wise judges at different times upon dif-
ferent trius.
Gentlemen, Mr. Justice Foster, one of the
hest writers upon the criminal law ot* Englaait,
and a roan not more famous lor correctoes
and elegance of writing, than for the love sf
liberty and the constitution of his couotiy
says, '' The care the law hath taken for tie
personal safety of the king is not confined ID
actions or attempts of the more fiagitisv
kind to assassination or poison, or other at-
tempts directly and immediately aimine st
his life ; it is extended to every thing wiltollv
and deliberately done or attempted, wkevd^
his life may be endaneered." He goes on tb
•say, ^ and therefore tne entering into mea-
sures for deposing the king, or imprisooiBg
him, or to get his person into the power sf
the conspirators ; these offences are overt acts
of treason within the branch of the statote;
for experience hath shown, that between the
prisons and the graves of pritoces the distance
IS very small." But, eentlemen, he does Ml
even stop here, for he goes on to tell yw,
*< That offences which are not so persunal to
the king as those already mentioned, have
been with great propriety brought within the
same nile, as having a tendency, thoujgh net
so immediately, to the same fiital end." ile
puts this case, which in my opinion^ iUio-
trates the law hetter than any case i en
state to you. The case he puts is this; ^ A
person entering into measures in ooaoeitamlli
forei^ers or othen, in onler to an invasion of
the kingdom, or going into a foreign countnr,
or even proposing to go thither to that eua,
and tal^og any steps ioorder theseto ; theseef-
fences are overt acts of osmpassiagthe kiott^
death.^' You will observe, genrtsmso, Iffte
person abiead happensd tohe a peisoasrfas
ai«8]
JirlSgli Trta»on»
A. D. 179tfi*
XI 19*
16 «t mx^ wkh lilt Caown of EaklaBd, the
fiid it noeaai pould doI be for adhering to
4he cDemies of tha km§, Iwraiiif in truth the
MTsons adhored to were sot eoemiee of the
lung; buty saji Mr. Juetice Foster, ^ Men who
do such acAs ought to be, and may be, and
-oiaDy persooSy upon auoh a case, have been in-
4iiotod and found guihv of coropaasifM; and
imagining the death of the kutf . Whv f--4>e-
43auae those ads iiave a manifest tendency to
^yAinyr the person of the king, and therefore
upon the deasest principlee of substantial
«od political juatipe are brought within Uiat
fipccies of treason of conpassiiy the kinf*B
-death, ^ ha quid detnraanti re^ubliciL
^papiat."
Tbeseare tbe words of this learned judse.
And npoin his authority I state, that if i
should lay before you any thine that has a
maniiest tendency to endanger &e person of
Jibe sovemi^, it will he |»our duty lo find ;the
prisoner guilty of this species of treason. This
IS not the langup.ge of Mr. Justice Fpster only ;
and, aentlemen, you will excuse me for being
a littte tedious upon the present occasion, be-
cause I am anxious every thins should be
^lly and perfectly understood, f am anxious
Co oottom myself upon the audiority of great
and approved writers; if it be thought that I
am gome too much over the same ground,
ibe novelty and singularity of this case will, I
bo]ie, be -an apoloey with you and the Court.
This is iiot only the language of Foster in
George the id's time, but the language of
iord chief justice Hale bimseif, the steatest
,aad best iud^e that ever sat in Enguuid, in
.Charles Sas time ; be tells you ^ Though the
i»Bspiracy be not immediately and directly,
and expressly the death of the king, but the
conspiracy is of something that, in all proba-
l>illty, must induce it, and the overt act b of
auch a thing that must induce it; this is an
overt aa to prove the compassing of the
king's death,'' which is high treason, in his
^gungo. Therefore, if I prove a conspiracy
•by the prisoner at the bar, that in all proba-
bility, niiffht induce tlie death of the king,
that is hi^ treason in the language of this
creat master of the law. In another part of
flis book he tells us, '* An assembly to levy war
agunst the king, either to depose, or restrain,
or enforce him to any act, or to come to his
presence, to remove his counsellors or minis-
tera, or to fight against the king's lieutenant
or military aiuimissionate officers, is an overt
act proving the compassins the death of the
king; for such a war is directly against the
very person of the king, and he that designs
to ^ht against the king, cannot but know at
least it must haxard his life.''
Gentlemen, the same is the langiuige.of all
the writers of all periods of time; it is the
kaguage of serjeant Hawkins in his correct
tnalise of theCrown Law of England. ** Such
oompasnae the^king^s death maybe snani*
fested, jiot oii1y% overt actaof adireet 4toa-
spiraoy tx>4ake aM«y his iife^ bat atoo ^ sudi
ae thorn saeh design as casmot be executed
without the apparent peril thereof.'' What I
have to coBcIiide with is, if, in the language
of Foster, I state any tb'me deliberately done,
whereby the person of the King may be in dan-
'^t — ii I state any facts of manileat tendency
to endanger the royal Ufe^f, in the languaae
of Uale, I state any thing that in all probafoy«
litf must induce the death of the king*— if, in
the language o^iiawkins, I show any design
that .cannot be aoeompUshed without apparent
peril of the life of bis majesty, then, if I prove
the foots against the prisoner at the « bar, it
will be your duty to find him (^Ity-
Gentlemen, in trials of this sort, persons
jiaiiding in the situation of the prisoner, have
often set forward a spedes of diefeuce arising
•from a aupposed construction of the law, upon
which it is necessary I should sa^ a few worda
It has oflen been said, upon trials of this sort,
that a conspiracy to levy war (I wish tibe iuiiy
would mark mv words), a conspiracy to levy
war, is not high treason. Now, gentlemea,
roost iinqestionably, in some sense, tliat pro-
position IS correctly true. If the prisoner was
indicted for levymg war aeainst the king,
most unquestionably he could not bo found
euilty of high treason, unless war was actually
uvied. Under such an indictment, for the
^ecies of treason for levying war aeainst the
kmg, a conspiracy to levy war would not be
eitlier an overt act in itself, nor would it be
admissible in evidence, because the crime
charged upon the prisoner is levying war
against the king ; and before be can be found
euilty of that crime, war must be actually
^vied. The prisoner here is not indicted for
levying war against the king, but for com-
passing and imagining the death of the king,
which is the first species of treason; and
under a variety of circumstances, a conspiraoy
to levy war may or may not be an overt aet of
compassing or imagining the dcatfi of the
king. I have slated to you, that an overt aet
is tne means used to effectuate the purpose
of the mind. I have stated to you, that any
means used to an end which has an apparent
tendency toput the king's life in danger is an
overt act of high treaaon ; and a conspiracy
to levy war in many instances, and under
BU^ny circumstances, may show a desian
wbidi has an apparent tendency to put the
king's life in danj^r, or which cannot be exe-
cuted without pattjiug his person in peril — If
it be aconuiiracy to levy war against the oon-
stiUition ot the kingdom, of which he is an
integral part, if it be a conspiracy against the
three branches of the legishiture, how can
that be a design which can be executed with-
out apparent peril of his muesty's life? I
otate tnis to you, because I know this is a
point which has been started in difiereat
trials, in former periods of our history, and
some quotations from books have been found
to countenance the opinioa, that a conspiracy
to levy war is not treason. But I take the
JUw.(o be, that iti$ an oMti acdtof high tree-
1195] 34 GEORGE UI.
Pneetding* agtdiid' Robert Watt
\\m
ton whenever the de«gn is such as cannot be
executed without apparent peril of his ma-
jesty's life. Gentlemen, not to walk without
authority, and being anxious to state nothing
bnt what I can prove by great authority, I
will take the liberty to state, that this is no
new idea raised up lo meet the case of the
prisoner at the bar, but is as old as the con-
stitution itself.
Gentlemen very early in the reign of queen
Elizabeth, the principle was laid down, and
from that period it has been followed up ever
since. In the 1 3th of Elizabeth all the ludges
were consulted upon a case similar to the one
I have stated to you from Mr. Justice Foster;
a subject of this realm bdnz beyond sea,
practised with the prince of a roreign country
to invade this realm, with a mat pow^r, and
'his practising declared by what means, and
how and in what place the invasion should
be, and if such an invasion should be, there
were many subjects there who would assist
and adhere to him, but there was no such in-
vasion aflerwards. The judges were of opi-
nion that these offences were treason ; for an
invasion with foreign powers cannot be but of
necessity it will tend to the destruction or
great peril oi the prince. I give you the words
of the report, ana the principle which I take
to be laid down is, that every thing which of
necessity tends to the destruction or the great
peril of the person of the prince is, if an overt
act be laid and proved, high treason ; whether
a eonspiracy to levy war, necessarily tends, if
carriea intoeffisct,to the great peril of theprince,
will be according to the circumstances of that
conspiracy; but if t be conspiracy be such as
is directly against the person of the prince, or
be such as is directly against the government,
of which he is a part, and which it is his duty
to defend, it can hardly be contended that it
is not such a desien as puts the person of the
king in great peril, and it is, if proved by an
overt act, high treason. The same thing is
said by lord chief justice Hale ; I will use the
freedom of reading his words : — *^ That yet
such a conspiracy, or compassing to levy war
against the king directly, or s^nst his forces,
and meeting and consulting for the effecting
of it, whether the number of the conspirators
be more or less, or disguised under any pre-
tence whatsoever, as of reformation of abuses,
casting down inclosures, particular or gene-
rallv— Nay, of wrestling, foot-ball playing,
cock fighting— Yet if it can appear that they
consulted or resolved to raise a power imme-
diately against the king, or the liberty or the
aafetv ofnis person, this congregating of the
peonle for this intent, though no war be ac-
tually levied, is an overt act to maintain an
indictment for compassing the king's death
within the first clause of the statute of the
35th of Edward 3d, for it is a kind of natural
or necessary consequence that the attempts to
subdue and conquer the king, cannot intend
less than the takmg awav his life." At other
timesy and by other judges the same thing
has been said. Hawkins says, ^ That the
levving war aga^st the long's person," (I
rather choose to give tbem in other mea'i
words than my own, which aje rooce aocunu
than any I can use) ; Hawkins says, ^ That
the levying war against the lung's person, at
the bare consulting to levy such war,orinee(>
ing together and consulting the means todtti'
troy the king- and his government, or assea-
bling with others and procuring them to at-
tempt the kLi2*s death, or listing men in or-
der to depose the king, or printing treasonable
positions, as that the king is accountable to
the people, and that they ought to take the
government into their own bands, &c. or pub-
lishing a book to prove that the king's eo-
vemment is anti-christian and heretiol, &e.
may be alleged as overt ftcts to prove the
compassing the king*s death.'' It I shouM
prove consulting, agreeing to levy war, vak
show means us^ to destroy the gnvemfnen^
of which the king is a part — if I show means
used directly to destroy the constitutioo of
the country-^I have laid before you a case of
high treason ; because, whether it be called
a conspiracy to levy war or not, I shall Inve
laid before you the means used by the prbo-
ner at the bar, to effectuate his end, which
end is such a design as in its apparent sod
natural tendency must endanger the life of
the king, and cannot be executed without ap-
parent peril to the person of his majes^*
Therefore, if you should, in the progress of
this case, hear any thing concerning a coft*
spiracy to levy war, not lieing high treason
you will understand it under the restrictiop^
and in the manner in which I have stated it;
if that conspiracy be of levying a war, which
if levied, has a direct tendency to destroj the
life of his majesty, there is no doubt such a
conspiracy is an overt act of high tr^son, a
proposition supported by every authority froo
the reign of Elizabeth to this hour in which I
am speaking.
I wish, before I conclude this point, to state
to you the law upon the subject of conspirt*
cies to levy war, from the very highest autlio^
rity ; because it is the only point, upon which
I conceive any controversy can arise; there*
fore, I wish to state it not only from the dictt
of writers ot' high authority, but to state ft
from, the lanjjuage of judges of the first emi-
nence. Probably you have all heard of toe
fame of lord chief justice Holt, whose abihiy
and integrity, at a period of life earlier, per-
haps, than any one that ever filled that iw.
situation, raised him in the glorious lei^ ^
king William, to the office of chief jusUceJ
the KingVbench, which he filled with dim
and integrity, that may have been equall»
but never surpassed, by any one that hss ^
there since. In the case of some person* wdo
were tried for being concerned, more or ^
in a plot for assassinating l^iog WilliasM^
defence was set forward^ and it was ^^^
before him, tlu4 a conspiracy to- ^^'-y, **^«5
not an overt act of high tieason; he »r
1197]
Jhr High Trtawn*
A. D. 1794..
[1198
tiiiSy* ^ And thete is another matter the pri-
soner at the bar inasted upon, and that is
matter of law; the statute of the 25th
of Edward Srd was read, wluch is the great
statute about treasons, and that does con-
tain divers species of treason, and de-
clares what shail be treason; one treason
is the compassing and imagining the death
of the king, — another is the levying war.
— ^Now, the prisoner says, there is no war
levied, and a bare conspiracy, or design to
levy war, does not come within this law
against treason.— ^Now, for that I must tell
you, if there be only a conspiracy to levy war,
U is not treason, but if the aesign and conspi-
racy be either to kill the king, or to depose
bim, or imprison him, or put any force or res-
traint upon him, and the way and method of
effecting of the.se is by levymg of war, there
the consultation, and the conspiracy to levy
war for that purpose is hieh treason, though
no war be leviea, for such consultation and
conspiracy is an overt act, proving the com-
passmg the death of the kmg, which is the
first treason mentioned in the statute of the
S5th of Edvrard Sd ; for the words of that sta-
tute are : that if any man shall compass or
imagine the death of the king;— Now, be-
cause a man designs the death, deposition or
destruction of the king, and to that design,
aerees and consults to levy war, that this
should not be high treason, if a war be not
actually levied, is a very strange doctrine, and
the contrary has always been held to be law.
There may be a war levied, without any de«
skn upon the king's person, or endangering
of it, which if actually levied, is high treason,
but a bare designing to levy war, without
more, will not be treason,-— as, for example,
if persons do assemble themselves, and act
with force in opposition to some law which'
Xhty think inconvenient, and hope thereby to
get it repealed, this is levying of war, and
treason, though purposing and designing it
is not so; so when they endeavour, m great
numbers, with force to make some reforma-
tion of their own heads, without pursuing the
methods of the law, that is levying war, and
treason, but the purposes and designs of it are
Bot so. — ^But if there he (as I have said to you)
a purpose and design to destroy the king, and
lo depose him from his throne, or to restrain
him, or have any power over- him, which is
purposed or designed to be effected by war
that is to be levied, such a conspiracy and
consultation to levy war, for the brmgipg this
to pass, is an overt act of high treason; so
that, eentlemen, as to that objection that
he makes in point of law, it is of no force, if
there be evidence sufficient to convince you
that he did conspire to levy war, for such an
end."
In the reign of George 1st, on the case of a
perton of the name of Layer,-!" who was in-
* See »the case of sir John Friend, anit'
Vol 13, p. 61.
^ 4nCi, Vol 16, p. W,
dieted for a conspiracy against his majesty,
it was also attempted to be ai^ed before lord
chief justice Pratt, the then chief justice of the
Common Pleas, that a conspiracy to levy war
was not high treason.*^ lie told the counsel^
that the contrary had been decided, a huii-
dred and a hundred times; that he did not
sit there to overturn what had been deter*
mined at all periods of our constitution; that
a design to levy war against the person of the
king, or any desisn to put the king's person
in peril, was high treason, let whatever opi-
nions have been to the contrary. — ^Therefore
it is, that at all periods of our constitution, ik
design or conspuracy to raise an insurrection
within the kingdom has been held an overt
act of high treason ; because, if raised, it
must put the king's person in peril. — If I
were to go over the numberless indictments
in books which now lie before me, I could
show you hundreds of them, where a conspi-
racy to raise an insurrection has been in aQ
times, and by all means, uniformly laid down
to be high treason.
In Layer's case, it was laid in the indictment,
as an overt act of high treason, that Mr. layer,
in the county of Essex, did publish a paper,
with a' design to seize the commander in chief,
the Tower, and sir RobertWalpole, and lord
Carteret, and some principal persons about
the king.-*The pUbhcation of that treason^
able paper, which said not a word about the
person of bis majesty, was distinctly laid as
an overt act of hish treason. — I know there
were other acts laid in that indictment, as
hieh treason, but I know also, that thatpapec
published by Layer at Laytonstone in Bssex,
was laid as an overt act of high treason, ae**
parately and distinctly, and that paper, as
proved b)ra pex^n of the name of Lynch, did
not contain a single word respecting the pep^
son of the king ; and the judges who tried jt,
and the counsel who dfew it, and the coun-'
sel who defended Mr. Layer, never doubted
the publication of that treasonable paper^ which
contained nothing but a design to seize the
Tower, to lay hold of the commander in chief,
sir Ilobert Walpole, and lord Carteret, and the
other ministers of the king, — I say. they ne<
ver doubted that the publication of that paper
alone was a sufficient overt act of high trea-
son ; therefore, upon the whole of the mattel*,
after making an apology for the time I have
been obliged to consume, if I can lay before
you any design, which in its direct and natu-
ral tendency, would endanger the life of the
king, and any means used for carrying it into
execution, or an^ Conspiracy for executing a
design, which, if executed, would put the
person of his majesty in peril, these are overt
acts of high treason.
My lords the judges, when they oome to
state the law, will correct me if I am wrono;,
if Ihave over-stated in any particular,! sbodid
be sorry not to be. corrected. I have eiKlea-
voured to be as accurate as I could ; if I have
not succeeded, my lords the ju^es will tell
n«f\ 34 GEOKeK nt
Proeeedh^ i^gmM JbA^ Wait
[HMW
^Q, wbcD the]r eome to delmr Ura ctta^
ih whad I have done 6o.
Having said so much opod the hrar of the
east, il is now iacuinbeiM upon me, tm state
to yon the fact which I mean to bring within
the law, only preiaismg, that consulting and
tfgv^eHig to such a cunspirery and plan as I
have stated, is an overt aet of high treason,
because siich consultation and agreement are
flieans taken by the prisoner at the bar, if
ytwed against him, to efiectuate the iaten-
tioBs of his mind ; therefore, if I should lay
befors you, proof of such conspiracy, or if I
ahonld lay before you proof of the prisoner at
the bar's agreement to such a conspiracy, or his
4oasul(inf^ for the parpone of eiecuting' such a
oonspiracy as leads to a design to put the per-
son of the kins In apparent danger, these are
#teit act9 of high treason in point of law;
whether I shall prove them in point of fact, is
for yoit to determine ; I shall endeavour to
slate the hcu to yon as shortly as in my
power.
Gentlemen, the facts which I have to lay
btefore you, are not of a small conspiracy of a
law obscore individuals, in an obscnre comer
of this metropohs, it is a conspiracy that has
arisen, indeea, from a small beginning, which
nt first put on the appearance of a desire to
pursue legal objects^ wtiich has bees carried
en|by connexion aad conjunction with the
seditious persons in tkns^and other parts of the
country, which has been fostered by means of
dubs, which has been raised by means of
sommitlees, whioh h^ been carried on by the
neam of the circaktkm of various sMtious
papers, industriously spread through the ooun-
isy, by seditious and treasonable societies^ botii
here and else^hetl^ and which at last, f\f%m
taudl beiinnings, has grown into a design to
overset tne constitution of the country, and
-^Akkhf but for the vimlant interforence of tho
Biagistratesappointeaby the constitution ef the
oountry to euaitl the publk peace,was nearly bei>
ing earriecfinto execution, and might, in its di'^
rect consequences, and immediate tendency,
Iwve deluged this kiosdom, fti>m the one end to
the other^ with blooo. Such is the conspiraty
t mean to charge upon the prisoner at the
bur; — sorry I am to he obliged to state add
prove ity but such m the naiure of the eriake I
mean to prove ; and in deing this, I shall first
slate to you the plan and conspiracy itself,
and then lay before yoQ, the part which the
prisoner acted in it, when and how for he ac-
ceeded to it^ and the means housed to render
it successful, and carry it into execution.
You must know there have been for some
time past, in this country, meetings calling
themselves by various names, and assuming
various forms, but in general, calling tbem^
8elv0s,*or miscallin(E themselves, by the name
of— >the Friends of uie People.
You are not ignonmt, that their first object,
their first pretended object at least was, to
petition parliament to obtain what they call
a reform in 4he representation of the people.
vour
-— Yoo alvnM ignonsit^genlienleibi, llisiit fliese.
petitions, whether tbey were piieseiited reaiiy
to obtafai a reform, or whether they were Pre-
, sented for the purpose of being rejected,- 1 db
not know, but you are not ignorant that- Iheee
I petitions did not pik>cure that redress which
the petitioners de8ired.-*Soon after, early i»
• the year 1793, a new scheme, and a- o^w"
plan took place — ^The first piece of evidence
I which 1 sba\\ lay before you, is the beginniiig
; and commenoeoient of that plan, in order to
I show you where it began, and how it gi^vr to
tlie magnitude to which it afterwards attain-
ed.— The first dawnings of the plan i have to
lay before you, will be found in a letter wisicb
was sent to this country, by a person of tbe
name of Hardy/ who was secretary to a
I seditious society in London, of great magni
I tude. — Hardy wrote to a person every body
knows in this country, one Skirvii^'f m-
formine him, — ** Our petitions, you vrm bane
learned, have been all of them unsuccessM;
our attention must therefore be
some more eflectual means ; from
ciety we would willingly learn theas,
on your part, may depend upon our
the firmest measures, provided they
stitiitional/'— To this letter Mr. 8kirraig «-
turns an answer, and pooorts out what bs
thought were nlote efiectual means.
Mr. lf«mi/^«m.— My Loid Presideat, as *•
counsel has said nothing yet npon these lit-
ters, your kudsfaip will deckle whetiber it if
fit to read letters of any kind if they aie an
to be used as evidence.
Mr. iln<fnflAer.— ^hey aie to be read m
evidence* I do not mesa to staiie to yuu the
ooDtents of a dii^e paper which I de asl
mean to use in ovKlence.
Mr. Kamltcnt'-'l sid^mit to your loidsbip
if it be proper to read thos« letters.
Lord Pre$ideni to the Jury. — Gentlemcs,
you will not pay any attention to lence,
unless they be aitorwards reg^olarly piwisri
before you.
Mr. Fleteher.-^ln this port of the tisnisfiii.
tho jurjr sbonki sbstain frsw taking notes cf
any thing that peases.
Mr. AntinUKer, — ^At present it ia my doTf
to state the evidence I mean to lay Mbft*
you. I shall state the contents of no letter
and the words of no paper which I do doI
mean to prove ; but as the letter^ and papers ;
make a part of my story, and I cannot slallj
the case without I state the contento e£itirf]
letters, I racier choose to do it ftoA- tfal
words of the letters themselves, thaa sM
the purport from any recollection of mine.
Oentiemen,. I have told you the first lemt
written upon this subject, was a letter wludl
talked of more eifectual means. In
to that letter, the person to whom it was
* See bis trial for hig^ treason, Voi. M
this Collection,
t See bb triii ftr sedittoB^ p. 391^ of Hi
volume. ^t
1901]
Jlur Hifh^B^€m(m.
A« !>• 17M.
[IMS
dvcMod, nboMduuncter imd stuniMD I wiB
prove to JDU, and wboae haod-wridng I wUl
alto pioye» ic^tureed an answer to his'corres-
poodeot in London, in which, he .MrfecUy
ames with him, Uiat more effectaM means
of reform were now to be turned to. He
theo goes on to state, that the meetings in
Sngland are what be calls an aristocracy for
the ffood of the people; but the meetings in
Scouand are the peeple themselves. He
then stales^ that he foresaw the downfiill of
the whole of this goremment, and that they
in this country l5id at once perfected the
pian of their organization ; and the reason of
perfecting the fuan of their otganixation was,
thai when that time came &ey might be
ready to act with uaanimity, and not be occu-
fMed about organisation, without which how-
ever anarchy must ensue. The letter will
be laid before tou, and in that letter you will
aee the first dawnings of a meeting which
ealis itself a convention. It was no wonder,
flentlemen, that they turned their eyes to
thla instrument, as more efiectual than pets-
tioning; th^ had seen the power^l eflfect
of a convention in other countries, and they
therefore turned their eyes to it as a more
effectual means of a reform ; and I grant it
vroakl be more effectual in carrying on tiiis
plan than any petition whatever. You vdtt
see throughout the whole of this letter I
have to lay before you, the first project of a
convention; you will see that a meeting was
not intended fi>r the purposes of reform, by
petition to parliament^ or by legal means;
when the government of this country was to
be dissolved and be at an end, an event they
looked to not cmly as certain, but desirable,
then the gentlemen were to be ready with
their plan of organisation ; then they were to
act as a convention assembled from, and le-
presenting, all parts of the kingdom. These
papers, I say, contain the first project Of calU
ing a convention of the people of this coun-
try ; the only observation 1 shall make on
them is this, that you will see from them i|
was Dot the iatention of the persons calhng
themselves a convenikio, it was not the in*
tention of these persons to proceed by peti-
tion to parliament, but their intent was, to
praeeed by their own force and authority,
and not b)r the means of the local or|;aii8 of
this constitution ; to proceed by their own
vill, and not by that or the legal government
of the country, to supersede the legislature
in all ito functions, and to have reouurse to
means of reform, to use their own words>
. anore efiectual than petitioning. If their de^
aign was, to prooeea by their own authority,
and that desi^ is proved to you,— if theif
toyi was to take into their hands the no^
vemmeni of the country, or to supersede lor
ever, or a time, the eiisting govemmentef
the Gounuy; these are desi^ which couU
not be effected without apparent danger of
the king's life, and I have no scruple to say
are high treason : whether such a design be
vot. xxni.
fRoved^in the sequel of tbi* trial, wUl be a
matter for you to connder.
Gentletoen, soon after this plan was form-
ed, a body, unknown to this constitution, met
in £dinbut];h, calHng itself a British oonven-.
tion ;* at tot it did not assume that hame»
but it met towards the latter end of last year,
composed of persons deputed from different
parts of this kingdom, of different societies in
Englandand Scotland; its views and objects,
ite plana and intentions, vou will have, to
judae ef. If^ upon the whole matter, you
shflLU be of opinion its views were legal, if the
raaana . intended for the execution ot those
views were peaceable and constitutional, then
there is no harm in that society ; but, if you
should be of opinion, upon the whole matter^
that its views were uacoostitutioaal end ille-
gal, that the meaps by which the^ intended
to carry those objects and views into execuf
tion, were to supersede the legislature of
which his lyiajesty ia a part, to carry on ite
plans by ite own force, power, and authority ;
It is nothing more nor less but an intention
to supersede the legislation, to take into ite
hands the power of government, and, at least
lor a time, to depose and put aside his maf
jesty from the legal authority vested in him
by the eonstitutioo i wheth^ tliat was. the
purpose of the convention or not, will be foe
you to judge* J shall point out soaie of ite
acte.
Oeollemen* when this meetiag was Ibrroed,
I have said it was attended by pers<»s from
various parte of this kiqgdom, some from
England and sodie firom Scotland ; and I
must call your attention to a part of the in-
stractioas from the London Corresponding
Society, to which Hardy, the writer of the
first letter I have mentioned, to Margaret
and GerrakLf their delegates, was secretary,
dated the Mth of October, 1708, These in*
structiooa will be proved; they contain a
direction to those delegates to resist the aiH
thority of the legislature, ia case the legia-
kture should do a particular act.. Sect T, iji
these instructions, slates, *' That it is the duty
of the people to resist aqy act of parliament
repugnant to the original principles of the
constitution, as would be every attempt to
prohibit associations for the purpose of re«
term." Is this any thing more or less than
a moiution to resist the legislature of this
oountiy In the esercise of lU authoiitv, a
conspira^ to^ intimidate the legislatoie from
acting fairly in the execution of its duties^
and a determination to set at defiance kkig.
lords, and commons, and the 4aw itself, aiM
to resist their authority, if they did not act^
as this self-created convention might tliink,
constitotbnally. With these instructions
their delegates came down to this countiy S
•*^
^See the trials of Skirving and his asso^
ciates in this Volume.
t See their trials, pp. 90S and 803 of thie
• Volume.
4li
ISOS] S4 GEORGE III.
Pfoceedingi ogMnU Robert WaH
[WM.
when they arrived, this oonTeDtkm formed
itself upon the model of another cooTention
in another country, and took the name of the
British Convention^ and formed itsdf into
departments ; it used all the cant phrases
and forms used in France, had its sections, its
departments, granted honors of the sitting;
had its primary assemblies and provincial &-
Mrtments, and absurdly dated its minutes.
iSrst year of the British Convention one and
indiviable. I know you may be told, be-
cause juries have been told, there is no harm
in using French phrases, there is no harm in
using cant names. Taking that as an ab-
stract proposition, it is unquestionably true ;
but you who are set there to judge of the
views, intentions, and plans of men ; you can
judge of the intentions of men by no other
means than by the acts of men : therefore if
you see men adopting the acts, following the
plans and schemes, and taking the names
and forms of particular societies of a particu-
lar description, I do not think you will have
much difficulty in drawing the inference,
what the views and objects of these men are.
It is not from names and forms atone you
will collect the views and intentions of this
assembly; you will find these men, after
they took the name of the British Convene
tiou, diKussing and settling the plan for the
meeting of future conventions in other cir-
cumstances and places, as if a convention
was to be a permanent body in the l^slatore
of this country ; in the early part of it, before
it had assumed that name^ motions were
made, some for the purpose of petitioning
parliament for a reform ; and what I would
call your attention to is this, that firom the
moment it assumed the name of the British
Convention, all idea of petitioning parliament
for a reform was abandoned : whenever pro-
posed, the order of the day followed ; when-
ever hinted at, it was negatived. Afler this
convention had proceeded some steps farther,
after it had assumed the form which I have
described, after it had done the acts which
shall be given in evidence to you, and from
which you will be able to judge of their in-
tentions and views, some resolutions were
proposed and adopted with a singular and ex-
tmordinary degree of solemnity, too bold
even for the convention itself to venture to
place them upon their minutes. V^hether
this resolution amounts to proof of a conspi-
la^ to resist the legislature of this kinedom,
and to resist and oppose the laws of this
country, will be for you to iudee; to me it
seems decisive evidence of a design not to
rest satisfied with the wholesome laws of their
ancestors, not to petition the houses of par-
liament, or apply for redress by le^ and
constitutional means, but a settled conspiracy
to oppose every act of parliament that should
nililate against what they should please to
call the constitution of these kingdoms, and
not only to proceed in their conspiracy, until
compelled tp desist by superior force, but to
provide Aidfenns of re^stance andataodeaf*
rebellion, mease the cxertkmsof kcalsuUa-
rity and the constitutional powers of the oe-
cutive magbtrale should disperse and scatkr
them. Some of the resolutions I sllode to, I
will read to you.
^ Resolved, that the following decbnlka
and resolutions be inserted at the end of cw
minutes, viz.
<< That this convention considering tbe
calamitous consequences of any act of da
Wislature which may tend to deprifethe'
whole or any part of the people of their on.
doubted right to mee^ either by themsdiu
or by delegation, to discuss any matter itli-
tive to their common interest, whether of i
public or private nature, and hoMing the sue
to be totally inconsistent with the first pm-
ciples and safety of the society, and also »•
versive of our known and acknowledged cofr
stitutk)nal liberties, do hereby declare, beibre
God and the world, tliatwe shall Mowtbr
wholesome example of former times, bypi^
ing no regard to any act which shall milittit
against the constitution of ourcountiT^iflj
shall continue to assemble and coosioer tf
the best means by .which we can accoom
a real representation of the people and annv
election, until compelled to desist by supoar
force.
•* And, we do resolve, that the first ootw
given for the introduction of a conwntta
bill, or any bill of a similar tendency to tttf
passed in Ireland, in the last session of uxv
parliament ; . .
** Or any bill for the suspension of w
Habeas Corpus act, or the act for .l"*'*'^^^
wrongous imprisonment, and against ttsdue
delays in trial in North Britain ; .
** Or. in case of an invauon, or thead^J'
sion of any foreign troops whatsoever u»
Great Britain or Ireland ;
«« All, or any one of these calamilort ^
cumstances shall be a signal to tbe ser^
delegates to repair to such place as ^J^,
committee of this convention shall ^fP^
and the first seven members shall w"
power to declare the sittings pc™**"^
shall constitute a convention, and tweoiy'<'**
proceed to business.'' ^
These resolutions are of such a ^^''^?|
hardly a man who hears me, can ^ ,^
they disclose a conspiracy to disobey ^ *^
iature in the execution of its duty, a c<»^P^
to be carried on and supported by force > W
say, they will reast until compelled ^{tJS
by superior force; force sCipenor to whstf wi^
superior to that force which they hwr
bnng against it;— how is it Possible to w^
stnie these words, without being of ofSJ^
that they point directly to supporting^
designs by arms, and that they were tff^
mined to meet in spite of the Isw^.oJ j^
country, till the fate of battic should d
who was to have the rule of this n«**Jr'
Now, let me ask whether this be to? ^
short of a conspiracy against the consUlow**
1206]
Joft Hi^ TrcMon.
A. D. 1794.
[120&
-of thb kingdom^ sliul whether H be not & de-
sign which could not posaiblr be canied into
e&ct, without appotent peru to the life of
liis iDiyesfcy ? If it was successful for an in-
stant^ he was in fact deposed from his throne,
'<liis authority as king eone, and the constitu-
tion he has sworn to defend, and which it is
his du^i as I am sure it is his wish to support
at the hazard of his life itself, absolutely
•mnnihilated. But it does not stop here, there
is a iiirther part of the conspiracy, to which I
must call your attention. ^< This convention
doth therefore resolve, that every delegate,
upon return home, do convene his const^
-tuents, and explain to them the necessity of
electing a delente or delefi:ates, and of esta^
blishing a fiuuF without delay, against either
of these emergencies, for his or their expenses,
and that they do instruct such delegates to
hold themselves in readiness, at one hour's
.'warning."^ It is necessary to call your atten-
tion to this, not only because you will find
the prisoner at the bar, adopting this resolu"
•tion, acceding to it, and acting under it,
taking means to elect that delegate, taking
.means to prepare that fund to provide against
the emergency stated in this paper ; but, be-
cause it clearly points out the means that
were to be used to render this conspiracy
aucoessful, funds Were to be provided, leaders
"Were to be elected, who were to be ready at
one hour's warning, to step fomvCrd whenever
the event happened, which was to rouse them
into rebellion a^inst the law, the constitu-
tion, and the king. To every part of this
resolution, I will show the prisoner at the
bar's complete accession, and I shall lay be-
fore you, all the means he took to cany it
into effect ; and what I have to charge upon
him here is, a conspiracy to resist the legisla-
ture of this kingdom by force, and t&ing
measures and providing means -for cariying
that conspiracy into execution. . You are not
ignorant that this meeting or convention was
put an end to, and dispersed by the boldness
and activity of the person who then held the
situation of the first magistrate of this city, a
person I am sure I need not name to you,
one with whose merit you ^re well acquainted,
and to whose conduct, on that occasion, his
country is as much obliged, as perhaps it
ever was to any person that ever filled that
high station, I mean Provost Elder. I may
be told, perhaps, what have I to do with this
convention at present, or what had the pri-
soner at the bar to do with it ? It was dis-
persed and at an end ; but I shall show you,
that that convention, although dispersed, was
still alive : the resolution I have read, and
another which immediately followed, and
which was imanimously agreed to, is, that the
moment of any illegal dispersion of the Bri-
tish Convention, should oe considered as a
summons to the delegates to repur to the
place of meeting, appomted for tne conven-
tion of emergency by th^ secret committee.
These two resolutions pntvided against the
event which took place, they kept allve'the
conspiracy in another form, and furnished the
means offuture rebellion. I shall prove to
you, that the prisoner at the bar adopted
those resolutions, followed out those piansy
took means to collect that fund, and elect
those deleeates who were to set the legisla*
ture at defiance, and provided and collected
arms to render their plans sucoessful, and
their resistance effectual. — ^The British Con*
▼ention bein^ dispersed, a plan resulting from
those resolutions, and grounded on the dis-
persion of the British Convention, took place
m England, of calling a convention there;
the nature of that convention I shall lay be*
fore you, and it is necessary I should, because
it will explain to you the nature of that con-
vention, to which the prisoner at the bar was
to send a delegate, for the support of whom
he was to provide a fiind, and for the main*
tenance of which, he was to send money and
collect arms. You will see, that although a
similar plan had been in contemplation in
Eneland, although the societies there in-
tended a convention to be called, yet the im*
mediate cause of that measure, the peculiar
reason which made it in their idea more im-
mediately necessary arose from the dispersion
of the British Convention, and that the reso-
lution I have just read to you was acted upon,
and the conspiracy I have stated kept alive
and proceededr on with vigor in both parts of
the United Kingdom. The first considerable
meeting, after the period I am talking of, for
the purpose of calling this new convention ia
England, was held at a place called the Globe
Tavern in London. There the London Cor-
responding Society, one of those fiictioua
societies which had sent delegates to the Bri-
tish Convention, met and came to certain
resolutions for the purpose of calling another
convention ; these shsul be laid before you. I
have only to state at present, that the leading
feature of them was a resolution to call a
general convention, to take the government
of this country into their own hands, to form
a government of their own, independent of
Ring, Lords, and Commons, ana to iran^
their own laws and constitution. They say
they must have a convention of the people^
ana whj^P because they will have redress
from their own laws, and not firom the laws of
their phinderers, enemies, and oppressors.
From the papers which will be laid before
you, you will have no difficulty to discover
who they mean by their plunderers, enemies,
and oppressors ; they inean neither more nor
less than the King, Lords, and Commons of
this kingdom ; and if this be their meanings
you cannot doubt, that if they were to form
their own laws, it was not by the authority of
the legidature of this country, but by their
own power and authority. They were to
procure their own laws, not by the medkun
of King, Lords, and Commons, but by form-
ing laws Uiemselves; The convention, there-
fore, which they proposed to call, was meant
ISOT] U 6B01GS IIL
JVaciiJiif f 0%0mii ttmtmri Wa»
[IfOB
tosnpeftode tiM legislalnra tutfaoii^ in tht
ciercue of all iu fuoctioot.
Wheo you come |o read tbeee nsolutiona,
AowiDg from the very aocietv which seat dele-
gates to Edinburgh* signed by the very person
who signed the instructions to those dele*
gales, it will be impossihle for you not to re-
mark the singular and esact coincidence be-
tween these resolutions, and those of the B^-
tish Convention I have read to you. The
Convention is^ (say they) rendered neoessaiy,
by the dispersion of that in Edinbuigh. It u
to meet on the same events^ it is to resist the
giverniaenton the same pretences, to assume
e same powers, and to be composed in the
aame manner as the Convention proposed hw
the resolution I have read to you, ana to such
a convention was the prisoner at the bar to
fend a delegate, for the support of such a
body was he to provide a fund, and while the
London Corresponding Society, and other
bodies oonnectea with the British Convention
were playing their parts in the other end of
the island, the prisoner and his asaocialct
were not behind hand with them in this.
The neit important step in London, was, at
% place called Chalk Farm, where the same
society met, and came to some resolutbns,
not vei^ different from those of the British
oonvention, and as directly contradicting the
authority of King, Lords, and Commoiis, in
All their branch^; and they there too de-
clared that i:ertaio laws they will not abide
by, thcgr will not submit to, whether they
have or have not the consent of parliament.
Now, gentlemen, I have stated to you a
conspiracy, which has existed in this country,
the tendency and object of which was, to
supersede the authority of the legidature, and
to resist its decrees by force, aAer the dis-
Jiersion of that meeting, by the spirit and
Ozertion of the first magistrate of this city. I
have stated to vou the means that were taken,
by those who had been sent delegates to that
convention, as it called itself, to call another
convention, to meet at another place ; the
nature of that convention, when called, what
it was meant to be by those who meant to
form it; what its nature and purposes were,
jrou will learn, from the incontrovertible evi-
9enoe of their own resolutions, fiom which
you cannot fail to see, that their object was
to form laws for themsehres, to support them*
selves by their own authority, to resist and
fepel^ to supersede and destroy the authority
of tfao legislature of this kingdom; as the
resolutions at the Globe Tavern, the resolu-
tions at ChaUc Farm in the neighboiirHood ef
liondon, where th^ expressly resolved to
jKsist certain laws, whether those laws took
place with or without the consent of parlia-
ment, distinctly mark out what it is they
Meant to destroy, .and they meant to super-
sede; tbey meant to supersede what they
call the hereditary senators of this kingdom,
lh«r meant to supersede. what -ihey caS the
jptmid maiiorities of pretopded fq^reeentativci
of the poopH ^SbfBf neaafr to supsnefe tb
legisfauive Mithority» aii4 4o raise thenMiwi
«p, as tiie gQvemiiig power of this ooaotiiii
its stead, to enact auco laws as thntba^
proper, to disobey such as they disliU,vilb
out the least hist that they meant to km
the least trace of the constitution, usdv
which you now live^ standiiic. If joq iIbI
be of opinion tlint this is the mir resutsftk
papers! shall lay beftMeyou,if yeuthalibc
of opinion they meant to supersede th
authori^ of the legblature, and me antboo^
of Kinc, Lerdsy and Conunons^ you amk
iloubt \xal this ia such a design, wbkb^ i
carried into execution, has a manifest ta»
dency to put his nu^iesty's life in dttgeryii
truth it IS nothing short of dqiesiog tb
King from the throne, and putting aaeodli
the authority of the government imder vkak
we live.
Such were the proceedings (which I dsnt
stote more at length, because thegr ^ bi
read to you) of those societiBS in LooAi^
which met for the purpose of calhngseifr
vention.
While these proceedings were carryiiijo^
and these resolutions adopted, letten^^^
by the name of Hardy, were written, sm »
persed all over this eountrv, to inctle tke p«^
pie to call another British Conveotico; I
mark these words— calling together anellMr
British Convention—because, if I can shsi
the prisoner acting upon this letter, or^Mi
the resolution of the British CodvcdUis
which has been read to you, of the nslufv*
the oonvention he meant to call, yw ^''^
doubt it was to be another British CoDmit»||
of the same nature, and tendency, sod m
the same views and objects as the first— w
letter speaks for itself; its meaning no M
can mistake ; I will read it to you witboot i
comment: —
." Citizens; The critical moment is arnM
and Britons must either assert, with zeal soo
firmness, their cUims to liberty, or 7^
without resistance to the Chains that n^
nisterial usurpation is forging f(X toeo.
Will you cooperate with us m the ow
peaceable measure* that now presents JtseU
with any prospect of success? ^« ^
not intimate to you, that notwithstaQODK
the unparalleled audaci^ of a coii^>
and over -bearing faction, which at P**^
tramples on the rights and Ubcrtics of tj«
people, our meetings cannot, in Englsoo, w
mterrupted without the previous aaoptioft«
a convention bill, a measure it is our o"V^
anticipate, that the ties of union ^^^
more firmly drawn, and the sentiments »w
views of the different societies throughout uw
nation be compared, while it is yet i^^
power, 80 as to ffuide and direct the wturs
operations of the Friends of Freedom.— Bows
then, to one exertbn more, and let «* **' j5
our consciousness of thb important trulh.--^
we are to be beaten down with thtestSjpJJ^
secutionsy and illegal sentences, we «« ^
idod]
fi/r ir^ IVeiKm.
A. D. 1794.
tlSlO
werthy/ivift «« iiica|Mible of libert;r* We
otwst, httwever, b« eipeditkNls; HeMiani and
AtMlriaM ate already MDone us; and, if we
tami^ subitait, a ckrad of these aitned bar^
\iMriaiis may shortly be poured in upon us.
\jfA US form, tiien, aaother British Conyen.
tion ; we have a central situation in our Tiew,
"Which we beUeve would be most oonTenient
Ibr the whole island; but which we forbear
to mentioD (entreating your confidence in
"ibis particular), till we have the answer of the
•octettes with which we are in correspondence.
l^eC us have your answer, then, by the 90th
ma larlbest, earlier if possible, whether you
«^|Mnove of the measure, and how many dele-
gates you can send, with the number also^ if
possible, of your societies. We remain yours,
ifi Cx^ aflection,
'* «sa LONDov coaafispoHnivo sociarr,
<* T. HAaDT, Secretary.^
** For the management of this business, we
tiftve appointed a secret committee ; you will
judMhoir ftr it is necessaiy for you to do the
I may hen be told, what is all diis to the
Erisoaer at tba bar ^ and if I were to stop
ere, I should be told truly ; but it is neces-
sary I should shdiw to you, first, the existence
of a conspiracy^, the existence of a plan to
supersede the legislative power ; and then, to
show you the part the prisoner played ia
the execution of it : and gentlemen, perh^
you may be surprised to hear that the pri-
soner at the bar had any share insuch a con-
spiracy, but you will not be more surprised
tnan 1 was when I heard that he was at all
concerned in carrying on a plan of this nature.
For it is no less strange than true, that hardly so
fnucb as two years ago, the prisoner at the bar
pretended to be a friend to the exbting^vern*
ment of this country, and to be particularly
interested in the safety and welfore of a person
in a very eminent situation in this kingdom,
known to you all. He pretended to nave a
particular regard, not only for the constitution
of his count^, but to the person, and to the
character of the respectable and illustrious
person who fills the office of one of his ma>
jesty's secretaries of state ;* he pretended. I
say, to be particularly interested m his welrare
and did certainlv, about two years a^, write
to him certain letters, ofiering to give him
information, -respeoting the proceedings of
societies, who then called themselves by the
name of the Friends of the People.
Gentlemen, it is unquestionably true that,
that illustrious person (as it was his duty to
do in lus situation) did return an answer to
the letter written to him by the prisoner at
the bar ; tha^ letter will be read to you ; it is
such a letter as it was his duty to write, and
it is such a letter as, being his duly to write,
I am sure be would write; becatise in every
* Mr. Dundas. See Ub trial ▲. D. 1806,
pOm»
■tuation wlach be holds I am sure he will do
his duty to his sovereign and to the public.
The answer from the secretary of state in-
formed him that he should be happy to have
any Information he thought it fit government
should know, leaving it to him to give what
information he thought proper. After this
period, the prisoner at the bar had some cor*
respondence with my learned friend who ftita
next me, and some information he did |;ive
him respecting the proceedings of a society
which calls it^f the Friends of the People,
and some information he did give personally
to Mr. Dundas himself. What Uiat was, as tiie
prisoner has thought fit to subpoena my
learned friend near me, when he is examined
he will state; and the whole correspondence
that took place between them, its nature^
contents, and limits, though he mi{;ht shelter
himself under his situation, and might demur
till he knew the questions that migb^ bt
asked him, he will state and lay befom you»
I have his authority for saying there is no
question he will not readilv answer that can
be asked, or any correspondence which took
place he will not lay before you, if he has it,
if not, he will state to you its contents to the
beet of his recollection and belief.
Whether the prisoner conveyed true or
folse intelligence to m^ learned friend is not
for me to determine; if he is examined he
will state what that information was. That
corres(>ondence, such as it was, continued till
some time about the middle of the ^ear 170S.
Anterior to the meetine of the fintish Con*
ventbn, anterior to the treasonid>le con*
spiracy which I have stated to exist in this
country, anterior to those resolutions to resist
the legislature and all legal authority, all
correspondence bad c^sed between thepri*
soner at the bar and my learned friend. Why
that correspondence cessed is not for mie to
say, I do not choose to state to yott either
the applications which were made by the
prisoner at the bar to my learned firiendl, or
the consequences and event of those applica*
tions. Wtiatever they were, if the nrisoner
at the bar wishes them to be laid before yofl,
my learned firiend will state them to voa
fiurly and fully. I say nothing more than
this, that from the month of September last,
or thereabouts, all communication, all conres^
pondence of any klifd ceased between the
prisoner at the bu and my learned friend or
the other officers of government*
Now, gentlemen, it is my duty, and very
short I snail be in stating to you the conduct
of the prisoner at the bar, prior to the ceaslns
of the correspondence I nave mentioned. I
do not know that Mr. Watt was a member of
the meetinz called the Friends of the People,
and unless 1 can connect him with tbe acts of
the British Convention, unless I can show
you his intention of calling anotiier convene
tion, and the means he took to elect delegates
and pTOvide fiinds for their support, and con-
nect nim with the conspiracy mrmed in this
18111 34 GBOBGE UL
the cMlMg y mtm nf
tbe stale, I caaooi ciU upoo jraa far » verdict
upoa tbe fint part of this ifMbctnent But
jni know, lod ny kwdft will tell jon, it is not
necMuy for me to prove every overt act
laid in tbe indictment ; if I prove only one
of the overt actb hid in the indictment^ if that
be an overt act suflkient in law, it is vonr
do^ to find him cuilty. For this I shall,
before 1 proceed nftber, give you a direct
and short authority. Mr. Justice Foster mys,
** if divers overt acts are laid, and but one
rred* it will be sufficient, and there must
a TCfdict for the crown; and therefeie
Ihougb divers overt acts are laid and the
indictment is faulty as to some of them, it
shall not be quashed, because that would
deprive the crown of the opportunity of
moving other overt acts that are well laid."
If I prove that the prisoner took certain
means which in law are foil evidence of hb
liaikfrous intentions and compassings, and
whidi are laid in the indictments overt acts
of high treason, it is of no importance whe-
ther I fail in the proof of others or not;
because I have then proved enough to support
the verdict of guilty— -if I do m>t couple the
prisoner at the b^ with a conspiracy in this
country » and if I do not couple the prisoner
with a conspiracy in another country, it is
your dutjr to find him not guilty, unless I
prove acainst him other overt acts of high
treason laid in this indictment. I trust how-
ever I shall have no difficulty in proving htm
guilty of every part of it, as well as acting' his
part m the conspiracy to supersede and over-
turn the constitution of the kingdom by
means of a convention as in the more direct
but not less flagrant and wicked plans and
schemes set foith in the latter part of the
indictment you are now to try.
. As soon as the activity of the magistrates
and the force of the law had dispersed the
British Convention^ that body ceased to exist
in the form of a convenUon, but did not cease
to exist in fact ; for vtrv soon after its disper-
sion, tbe societies which had sent members to
the convention, and many of the members of
the conventk>n itself, fonned themselves into
another body for the purpose, as I shall prove
to you, of carrying into effect various objects
of the British Convention, of keeping its
spirit alive, and of calling another convention
similar to that which was just dispersed, the
Tiews and objects of which I have described
to you ; what name Ihey took immediately
after the destruction of this British Conven-
tion I cannot exactly tell, but I believe they
called themselves the Committee of Corres-
pondence, or a General Committee; but
whatever mi^ht be the name of that com-
mittee, the prisoner at the bar was a meipber
of it; the nature of it will be proved to you
l>y the witnesses. I state to you its objects
t^be to carry into effect the views and pro-
jects of the British Convention, to elect a
delegate or delegates 1^6 send to apother con-
to bededed toicpreaenttfaeiraoae^islh
and to provide aU
fivtbe^xpenaeaofauchddegate. Sachm
the obwct of tbe British ConvcoliflB, oi
such the object of the fwwaittir I Mr
therefore that the Gcoenl CamauttBeff
of CorrespoodoDce, did watdm
juenceof and forthe purpose of onjiis
intoefiecttbereaoiulioaor the British Cn-
▼ention. Mr. Watt was a member of lb
Committee of Correspoodeooe; hebecsnit
member of that commitiee for the napw if
carrying into efiect the reaototmn I URa
often mentioned, acceding therein to h
wholeoontenUof that resolution, and scoefas
to, and acting in, the conspiracy to lesitf lb
legislature of the country, to repel the liv,
to resist by force, and to elect anothar^
vention to be called a British Conventios 1i
meet in England, vrith the Tiews, under tte
circumstances, with the powers and fa *
purposes I have mentioned alresdy a I
prove that committee exis^ng, sno W
acting in it, if I prove the British Conwato
destroyed in one shape and raised up m !»•
other, if I prove Watt acting won tw
views, I prove him actine and aoceding to w
whole of what I stated If thatcooqiin^
be a traitorous conspiracy, and ^^^7^
of it was, to supersede tbe legishiture ofw
country, 1 have proved enough to iof*^
him in all the consequences <>'^*^'*2L*S
however fiital they may be. Soon ijterw
Committee of Correspondence met, Mr. win
himself moved for the formation of s tw-
mittee of Umon, the object of which •»»
the purpose of collecUng the sense of w
Friends of the People throughout Edinwg»
to forther the views of the British Con'«»2
to further the schemes planned by ^^JJJr
above all, for the purpose of aiding sDdssss-
ingincalline another British Convenlwo*
meet in England. , .1^
You wiir remark I use the words ^^
British Convention, because the pii*^'
Watt, may possibly state to you ^^
meant by a convention an innocent ""^"j
that he meant a convention for the P"5*^
petitioning, that he meant a <^^*jVJ^ Z
legal purposes, and to pursue its ^PtJ!
ordinary means. I state to you WJ^ '^
and gentlemen of the jury, and I ^'"•^VS
be able to lay before you evidence to sw^
you that Mr. Watt could have no I^^^J^.
in view, because he completely •^^•^^hidi
resolution of the British Convention, ^^
was a resolution to act by force, '^^ \^
the authority of the legtshitufe. . '*«5S
f Ictely acceded to the calling another i»im-
1215]
Jor High Treason.
A. D, 1794
[I2]4
Convention, of the meaning of which he could
jiot be ignorant. You can baidlv believe that
& person would accede to the calling another
Svitish Convention, without knowing what the
naiufe of that convention was, without know-
ing its views, and without having examined
its objects. Th^ only possible conclusion
ftom the facts I have to lay before you is,
that Watt acceded in calling another British
Convention, and that he knew the nature of
that convention, that was so meant to be
called by all those persons engaged in the con*
spiracY, to be what I have statml, and I trust
I sbali Drove it to be a direct conspiracy
mgjainst the government and constitution of
this country.
The formation, or ormnization as they call
it, of the Committee of Union, I shall lay be-
fore you; and among other things, special
care seems to be taken in the veryl>eginning
for the protection of the memfclers of that
committee. Their powers are so laree that I
do not know what farther remained to oe given ;
their powers are thus described : " As re-
presentatives the Committee of Union are in-
vested with every power their constituents
can claim. The will of the constituent, at the
appointment of his representative is, that he
watch over his interest as a member of the
community.'' —
Mr. Hamilton, — Mr. Anstruther has stated
a Terv considerable portion of tiie printed book
which lies upon the table, and is now eoing
en with papers ; but I do submit humbly to
jfonr lordships, that the jura's minds are not
to be impressed with a repetition of evidence,
which it is said is meant to be eiven. I sav,
the counsel for the crown are only entitled in
this stage of the case, to state what is the
substance they mean to bring forward ; I take
it thev will mention none but what is intended
to be'brought forward ; to state it generally is
all they have a ri^ht to do, otherwise there
would be a repetition of it, which I under-
stand to be contrary to law.
Lord Justice Clerk. — Is it contrary to law
for a counsel to state what he means to prove
for the benefit of the Court and jury, that they
may know what is meant to be proved ?
Mr,'^ Hamilton, — He is entitled to state ihe
sum and substance, but not to read the papers
themselves.
Mr, Anstruther. — ^The nature of the objec-
tion is such, that I do not think it necessary
to state much in answer to it It is my duty
to lav before you the case I mean to prove
for tne crown ; I trust I shall not state any
thing to you which I cannot prove, but 1 have
a right to state to you and the jury every
thing which I mean to prove.
: Oeotiemen,! was statmgto you what was the
nature of the Committee of Union, of which
Watt was a member, and I cannot state to
you more correctiy the nature of that com-
initt^, than by stating their own words, and
giving their own account of themselves ; it
might be said, if I were to iiiake comments or
paraphrases upon the words of the Committee
of Union, I was straining the evidence meant
to be laid before you. I therefore give you
their own account of themselves ; their own
acts will speak what they intended to do^ and
you will draw the conclusion.
'' Fun DAMEKTAL PRINCIPLES of the socicties*.
^ First, the Committee of Union is com-
{>osed of persons appointed by the people to
ook after their interest ; and are consequentiy
amenable for their conduct to the people.
Therefore the people have the power of da-
posing, by means of a petition to the presi-
dent of the Committee of Union, and by hin^
reported to the societies, for misconduct in any
of the representatives.
*' Second, as representatives, the Committee
of Union are invested with every power tiieir
constituents can claim ; the wiU of the con-
stituent, at the appointment of his represen-i
tative is, that he watch over his interest, as
a member of the community ; but the will of
the constituent is the constituent himself-^
Therefore, if a representative is attacked in
the discharge of his duty, his constituents are
bound by nature, reason, and honour to defend
hJm."
Gentlemen, the other reguktbns for the
formation of this Committee of Union will be
proved and laid before you ; but I must call
your attention to this, that in the very outset,
care is taken to provide for the defence of the
Committee of Union itself. It is established
as a principle to which every person who sent a
delegate to that committee aid accede, that if
the representative was attacked in the dis-
charge of his dut^, his constituents were
bound to defend him by nature, by reason
and honour. Those representatives in the
Committee of Union claimed every power tbs
constituents themselves could claim ; the ex-
tent of that power they have not defined, and
I cannot state. This committee, with all the
powers their constituents could claim, met
for the purpose of procuring delegates to be
elected to another convention, and for the
purpose of providing money for the expense of
such dele^tes. >Not content however with
the formation of such a committee as I have
described to you, another committee was
chosen, of which Watt was also a member,
called by the name of the committee of ways,
and means. It was chosen by the Committee
of Union, from amoncst its own members ;
the societies at large chose the Committee of
Union, the Committee of Union chose the
Committee of Ways and Means. Watt was a
member of the Committee of Union, and a
member of the Committee of Ways and
Means. This last was a secret committee;,
it kept no books, it committed nothing to
writing; it bad a power of expelling any of
its own members; it was a permanent com-
mittee, and had the power of filling; up the.
vacancies which might take place in its own
body ; it was to trans^ all the money mat-
ters of the Friends of the People; it was to
191S] 94 GEORGE UL
Proceedkigi ^gmM RtAirt WM
[IS16
eollect money for defming Um expentes of
delegates } it was to collect mooey for all the
other purpoaes whateveri epga^ in by the
Friepos of the People ; and particularly it was
to oollect money (ot the support of wkukt they
termed the great cause.
The Committee of Ways and Mean^ whi^h
was formed some time about the beginning of
March last, proceeded immediately to act;
it proceeded to elect a person to be their
treasurer, whose name was Downie. Watt
was not treasurer, Downie was treasurer of
tihat committee; that committee, af^rit had
expressly met to regulale all the money mat-
ters of the Friends of the People, thought it
right to commumcate with all the dirorent
societies that existed in the dilierent parts of
this kingdom. Its first act, as far as I know,
for I have told you it was a secret committee,
was to send round to the different parts of the
oountnr, to recommend rules which it had
Iramed for the regulation of all the other so-
deties. The object was, to make itself the
centre of the rriends of the People, the
point of union for all the disaffected in Scot-
hnd, and to be the medium from whence all
instructions were to be given. I beg particu-
larly to call your attention to this, that the
committee of ways and Means, of which Watt
was a member, took upon itself to be the me-
dium through which directions and instruc-
tions were to be given to all the Friends of
the People throughout the kingdom; it de-
sired all neople to put their money into the
)umds or its treasurer, Mr. Downie, which
was ix>t to be accounted for or disbursed at
the will of the person that gave it, but was
to be disbursed in such a manner as should
be most calculated to promote the great
cause. It directed the different committees in
the country to inform the committee of Ways
and Means how many Friends they had, upon
whose patriotism they could rely with most
explicit confidence, and who would spare no
exertions in promoting the great cause. It
consisted of five membm only. You therefore
see, that if this plan was to be carried into
execution, all Friends of the People in Scot-
land were to trust, and implicitly obey the
orders of the committee, who were to dis-
burse their money as they thought fit, and
who dispersed their directions from one end
of Scotland to the other.
This plan and ^ese directions will be laid
before you in a printed circular letter, sent by
the prisoner at the bar to the different parts
of tne countiy, by one of the ambassadors of
this self<reated committee, to every word of
which I request your particular attention.
As one leading part of the duty of this
committee was, to use means to procure an*
other convention, as it was part or their pro-
ject to carry into effect the last resolution of
the British Convention, and to co-operate
with the disaffected and seditious in every part
of the kingdom, in the execution of this
scheme, whde on the one hand it formed it-
self as the focus of sedition in Soodn^«
the other it clooely omnected itself vitkik
seditious in England. I have aliesdj stthd
to you the letter signed by Hardy, whidiw
sent to this country. One of the fint uni
Mr. Watt and his committee was. Is Bed k
the purpose of anaweriog that iettcr, fiailk
purpose of opening a correspondence withth
ImdoB societies^ for the purpose of aiiif
their views and furtheiing their pi^ri
odling am^r British Conveation. InM
his pngect and theirs were one aad the w
namely, to procure another ooavcntitt i
meet to wemal the authority of die dA{
govemmettt, and mould the ooiistitu|ioii
Its will. And having coupled Watt wilhlki
British CoovcDtioQ, by hia adoptipgitsm
and folbwiog up its ol^iepts, having cnfld
him with this meeting, for the pwpne^
electing delegates aad collecting mooej ■
the expense of those del^sMes wbeactoa
I connect Watt again with the taaam
that was to me^ in England; fori wpM
him sitting in committee and in cqpww^
for the purpose of entering into a csncfo
dence with Thomas Hardy, for the ptvpwi
have stated, of caliii^ a British Oooictfa
to meet in England, of the naturesodi*
the powers and lor the purposes tbei m
been explained to jovl
Another of the acU of the conuwj**
ways and means was an attempt ^^^''"^
the soldiers of this countiy, to «•*»■ "I
Fencibles, who were then on tbeir ■■«*•
England, and were aciually Quaittfw ^^^
keith. I will prove that Watt id* oj
members of that committee me^ 232J1
printed, and circulated a paper, c^^^j^
seduce from their duty the soldien *"
mme&ty, called the Fencibles, while tfl^
atDadkeith. llie inleotion of thtfpifV
so plain, that I shall make no coiD*e»"r
it ; it will be laid before you, and U is«P
sible you can read it and "n***"^* J^'S*
I leave it to your good sense to *«•" *"^'J
per and say whether it does not sttf«F
instil into the minds of the soldMiBi"
that if they left this countiy, tiic goj^JJ
or its friends and supporters vouW d^
their wives and children whom tbey d*^
behind them ; and whaher il ^^^
gate them to mutiny and revolt, and n«»
to them the promise of the support otb^
sands in their rebellion. Sucbist|»w" ,
deavoured to be conveyed, and ""■yT;
will bring home distinctly to Mr. w»
will prove the types from which it wwfj
ed, set. and standing in his ^1^*^ 0
int>ve his beinz present when it ^ ^,
rectione, and h&vmg receivea ^°^^g^0
ried them by the direction of ^^^j^ni
of ways and means to I>alkeitb, sfla^||,
them into the hands of the ^ffff^.^
wiUl tnoethe paper ffon the ptw^"^
1217]
>r is^ Ttmrn*
tmr, td fhe hnds of tbe soldiers ^t Qalkektt.
This wis Bot the six&gle act of Watt, actiiis
in fa^ ioctividual eapeci^, but tbe act of WaU
in wb|^ he called bis representative charactw^
acting as a member of a pablic body, called
n Committee of Ways and Means. After this
committee bad taken the measures I have
stated, for tbe purpose of callins another con-
vention ; aft^ it nad organized itself as the
centre of section in Scotland; after it had set
*-§oiog an attempt to debauch tlie army, at
the very meeting which was called for the
purpose of answering Hardy's letter, and en-
tering ii^to a corre8|)ondence relative to a new
convenfioD, Watt himseify at that time, anfi
tinder these circumstances, laid before the
committee a distinct and deliberate plan for
destroying and oversetting the existing eo*
vemment of this country ; the parts of tnis
plan will be proved to you ; I state them to
t>e these \ — Mr. Watt, at a meeting q{ that
committee, acting as a memher of Uiat com-
mittee^ prndiiced a plan, to be carried into
eiecution by the Friends of the People, the
oujdines of which were, that a fire was to be
lighted at, or some place near, the excise of-
.fice, to atbnct the soldiers in the castle; when
they marched out to extinguish the fire, they
were to be met by a party of the Friends of
the People. Mr. Watt, a member of the
committee of ways and means, acting for the
Friends of the People, proposed that anum-
• ber of them should meet tbe soldiers on their
march to the excise office, another party were
to be stationed near the head of the West
Bow, another at the Luckenbooths; the sol-
diers were to be inclosed between these bo-
dies, to be surprised, destroyed, or made pri-
soners : this none, tbe judges, and particu-
krlv my lord justice clerk, were to be seped
oi^d imprisoned ; then thej^ were to seif e
every banking house in the city of Edinburgh.
and to get possession of the castle itself, ana
a procUmiation waa to be issued and dispersed
by couriers all over the country, jordenng all
the farmers and dealers in com, grain, and
meal, within this kingdom, to bring in their
grain and com to market as u^ual, upon pain
of death, and commanding all country gen-
tlemen to keep in their houses, or at least
not to depart from them to any distance ex- j
feeding three miles,, if nder the same penalty.
When this plan was carried, and when these |
objects were obtained, an address was to be i
sent to his majesty, commanding his majesty
< to put an end to the war, change his minis- |
ters, pr take the consequences. Such was |
ihe plan of Mr. Watt, proposed in the com- ;
mittee of ways and means. I will prove it •
distinctly, by evidence which cannot oe m.v >
. laken, and then I will leave to you to say,
whether it is not a c<H)spiracy to overturn tbe
rverament of this country, and whether, if
were to drpp every thing relative to the
' convention, I have not shown a scheme, and
laid before you a, plan, which must, in its
OUktural consequence and apparent tendency,
YOU XXIIl. ^
At 9. iTWk
put tb^ Uft ^f Ui# tai)9 w ^m i^ p«n)|
« pteo to d^pof^ the bug ffon^w npyal aii.
thority, % plan for the purpose of restr^ning
bis maiesty, coinpelling him \a do cei'tai^
affts ^th^rwise tha<ii h^ wpuld 4o if left to
himself. Biit vqi} capnot forget that this ii
not the plan of a solitary individual, not the
plan of W^tt only, or those three or ^r
people that met in the conimittee of ways aQ4
mean), but the plan of a representative of tb^
FrieiEids of the People, a^tiufc for the purpo^
of calling another convention, and for th^
nose mT bavina delegates to meet in Eng^
, and doiqg sdl this at one and the sam^
time. Then let me ask, whether ^ be po^
sible fi)f any n^an to say, that the»e persoi^
bad innocent objects in view in the calliqg
this convention, wh^ they took spch meai^
to carry their objeets into efiject and execit-
tioo ? Before this plan was to take e&ct, ail
the Friends of the People wei^e to be arined;
indeed you wUl naturajjy imagine, that such
a plan could not be successfiil without ann«;
but that is not all ; to perf<9ct the plan and to
acquire forces to carry it into e/fect, a peraop
of the name of Fairley was sei^t on a ciycupt
or embassv round the country; he carried
with him the circular letter ana other papers
I have mentioned, from the committee of
ways and means ; he was empowered to coj-
leet whatever sioney he could, jo^d send it to
the committee of ways and means, for the
support of the great cause, to circulate the
papers I have mentioned, to discover the aen-
tink^ts nf the different societies, to sound
them upon the subjett of ftni^ing* and to find
out how many in each place might be de-
pended upon for the execution of the grand
phn which waa about to be execMteq, aqd
w^ch pfioyUed, as they termed it, for evesy
thing. Us- Watt 9ad the memhers of thjit
committee took uypn themselves to fct us If
they were alreadly w^ ppsses^on of all the au-
thority which the S1ICC9S9 of Iheir prc^t
could give thtm» and g^ve, under their hiinf s
and seals, the in8itnu;tJ((%ea to direct hfm in his
p^regrinatiims through the country; what the
mslnictioBs w^r^^ w3l be prayed ; I sh^ net
state them more at Imgth. What the grand
plan WHS* which was t^ ptovide for evcvr
thing, what the erealt cause wa« in whkm
they were eogageo, wh^tt the prqject was for
which ntmes «ere to he ^ll^eted, whose ut-
most eaunrtiops might be relied on, what the
object was for which arms wei:o, upon various
pnetei^crs, to be placed in the hands of the
Friends of the Pecple« yov wj^ be at no Jods
to disoovjar. Fairtey ^thiiiUy performed hb
embassy; he went to Stirling, to Campsie,
to St. rlinian's, to Glassow, Paisley, and
other places; what he did at some of those
pjacee. and partiidularlv at Starliae, will be
proved to yoii. Upon his return, like 4 faith-
fyl messenger, he made his report to the
«oiniPittee of ways and means, and restored,
as he was directed, his instructions andcre-
dc8atlals« Upon tfaat^io order %o indMce the
41
181b) 34 GEdBOS III. PrtKeeibip agmd UobeA WaU
[IflO
MMiAe more rtmdStj to m^ and in order to
ftciliute the pbn^ reMrts were spread amoog
the societies of the Friends of the People,
ttiat the gentlemen of Goldsmith»>faail were
FBtting arms. Reports were mread of the
rench landing ; that the Friends of the Peo-
ple would be put in a double situation of dan*
ger, that thcv would be liutchered br aristo-
crats on one nand, and by the French on the
other, because the French would not know
them. All these reports were spread for ex-
citing the people to adopt the plan more rea*
dHy. Mr. Watt and the committee of ways
and means, about the time that Fairley was
-sent upon that missicm, employed persons for
the purpose of making arms. Watt went to
a person of the name of Orrock, who will be
produced to you, and informed him^ he had
an order from Perth for making four thou-
sand pikes, employed him to make a number
to be sent thither, and loM him that more
would be wanting, to be disposed of hoe.
Many pikes were made by Orroc^, and many
will be produced to you here, which were
found, some at Orrock's, and some at Watt's.
It will be proved, that Orrock was not the
only person employed in thisbusmess; Mr.
Brown, in* another part of tlus city, was also
employed in making pikes. For what pur-
pose these pikes were to be used, you can
Iiardly doubt; the witnesses will tell you
they understood they were to be used for the
purpose of the great plan, which would pro-
vide for all and answer for all. About the
same time of the mission of Fairley, another
officer of the Friends orthe People w!as elect-
ed, called a collector; every district was to
furnish one for every ten or twenty of its
mtmbers; they were to communicate directly
with the committee of ways and means, to
have a permanent preses, and be immedktely
under Us authority. Thet)usiness of these
collectors was, to collect (to use their own
phrase) ume and money y the opinions of the
people, and what money they could ; but an-
other, not less important part of their busi-
ness, which was more secret, and only com-
mimiQOed to the permanent preses of these
collectors, was, that they were to have the
distribution of the pikes and the command of
the' narties. A number of those pikes will be
J reduced before you. whioli Watt desired to
e carried down to the meeting of the collec-
tors ; the answer was. ** I willnot take them
now, I cannot tnist tne collectors as yet^
Gentlemen, these are the facts I have to
iajv before you; I trust I shall prove them,
and if I do, vou can hardly doubt they will
•mount to high treason.
I state the plan to be, to overturn the le-
f'tshture of this coimtry, to supersede the
ing in his authority, and to supersede the
legislature in the exercise of all its Amctious.
I atate the committee of ways and means lo
be acting for that object, and- Mr. Watt, at
one of that committee of ways and means, as
one of that secret committee of t|^ Frienas of
the People, to have met and cemiMto
overturn the cxmatitution, not as so infiri-
dual, but as a member of that oommtteeof
union, and of the committee of w»i a^
means, to accelerate the downfall of Uiecoa
stitution, to focilitate the meeting of that c»
vention, which vras to frame its own h«i^ s
render easy the election of those delegilB,
who were to resist the united autbontj of Ik
legislature, to assist the great cause; At
castle was to be seized, the judges sad »•
gistretes destroyed^ and the fioe himd
compelled to yield to the demands of thecal-
spirators; arms were bought and profiddi
persons were sent round the countiy to col-
lect force, and seduce the subjects from tbdr
allegiance ; pikes were to be distribuled, id
lea£rs were appointed. I shall lesn h ts
mj[ lords the Jjudges to state, wbette, ii
pomt of law, tlus was not a sort of coiupiarf,
which, if executed, necessarily pits tbepe-
son of the king in danger and penl ; and vbe*
thcr, in point of law, these hicts, if |ironi
be any tiling short of high treasoo. I«
sure, you gentlemen of the jury, when ^
come to consider the law and the fact, via
do honour to yoiuselves and to your couob^
by whatever verdict you shall think it fa
duty to pronounce. 1 ahall now proceed^
callthe evidence in the order I havestav;
it was necessary I should state it atinie
length) in order that you shouMseetbtlo-
dencv of it as it is given ; but I have oiu^J^
conclude with this single observation, ^
I desire you to rememher distinctly ;-!»*
laid before you the facts, which I think I ob
prove, for the purpose of explaining y^T^
understanding the bearings of the evidoitt;
but you will recollect, tliat although I w*
steted the (acts asasortof cJuefortheptf-
pjse of vour understanding the cvidenc^J•[
are to lay out of your nunds all *^.^
have sUted if I do not prove them; ^^^SL
the evidence you are to determine, ana m
that alone. .
Mr. Hamilion,-^! wbh to give notice to W
other side of the bar, that the evidence for t»
crown should be enclosed. . r
Lord Advonte.-^l gave such directioiV
hope they are so. I shall not proceed a s«F
further, till I know that all the other wttfj-
sesare enclosed, except tho lord provost, tfB
Mr. Sheriff Clerk.
Mr. Edward Lauzun sworn.
Mr. ^astrtfiAer.— Who aie you?— Ia»*^
of his msjesty's messengers. a
Do vou know a person of the name"
Hardy r— Yes I do sir. j-
Did you seize any papers in bis bouse,
the course of last summer?—! did, oov"
13th of May, on a Monday moroinS'
Have you any of tliose papers W *"
them in my hand. . , u
Mr. HamiAon.^My Loids, itism^W,"
discharging the trust tliat is reposed inp^Jj
the prisoner at the bar, to see thai tntf *•*
1S»1]
^r High Treason.
A. D. 1*794.
11382
is condHOled in the most regular manner, luid
that no circumstances may be kdd hold of
that may prejudice Mm; and also, that no
reBections may be made upon myself, tending
to show that I have not oischar^ my duty
with profMiety. — I understand it to be the
practice, and understand it to be the law,
with respect to high treason, laid down hj the
atatule of Henry €th as well as by that of king
WUliam that there must be two witnesses
produced to an oyert act. I understand Mr.
Anstrutber also, when he says one witness to
one overt act, another to another is sufficient ;
but I understand, the prosecutor b not enti-
tled to lead an^ evidence to an overt act not
laid in the indictment. I admit there is an
exception to that eeneral rule, according to
the practice of the law. Though he is not en-
siled to lead evidence with respect to an act
not laid in the indictment, you may lead evi-
dence with respect to an act, provided it tends
to corroborate that which is specifically laid in
the indictment.— There is another point
which I contend is in my favour.— I say you
cannot lead any evidence in regard to any ex-
traneous fact, foreign to the issue, until such
time as you have established and proved an
overt act laid in the iadictment.
And. now I come to the objection in point
of order.
The objection is, it is necessary for the pro-
secutor, in the first place, to substantiate and
move an overt act laid in the indictment
prought home to the prisoner at the bar, be-
fore he goes to extraneous matter, whether
done in London, or in any quarter of the globe,
whether within twelve months, or done a cen-
tury back from hence.
Mr. AnttrutAer^^l do not exactly know
faow the objection can arise to the question
Iwae about to put — lam sure nobody will
suppoas it is necessary for Mr. Hamilton to
Bav any thin^ for the purposeof clearing him-
self from the miputation being cast upon him ;
*~^eie is nobody here who does not know
. his ability and readiness to perform his duty.
As to tiie statementof the law, aslaid downiby
Mr. Hamilton, Itakeitto be perfectly correct.
The statute requires two witnesses before a
person can be found guilty of high treason;
out, at the same time, Mr. Hamilton fairly
and candidly staited also, that one witness to
one overt act, and one witness to another overt
act, are all tbat is necessary. — It is also true,
an overt act pot laid in the mdictment, cannot
be proved, that is to sav, it cannot be proved
as an overt act ; but a laet, not laid in the in*
dictment, may tend to prove an overt act laid ?
neither of these points, however, are the
^imds of objection.-— Mr. Hamilton's ob-
jection is, tliat I must prove an overt act laid in
the indictment, before I can produce any jBvi-
dence whatever. — If I do not prove an overt
act laid in the indictment, the prisoner must
be acquitted, but it is impossible I can begin
at the wrong end of a story«-^I am to prove
Watt's accessbn to a treasonable conspiracy ;
before I can prove tbat, I m«ist prove such a
thine as a conspiracy to exist — I am entitled
to snow a plot in general, before I come to
give evidence of the prisoner being concerned
m it. — ^All the judges of England, in the House
of Lords at the trial of viscount Stafford,*
held the law to be so. — ^The very objection
was made against giving evidence of a plot»
without showing the prisoner was implicated
in it ; — the answer was, it is time enough to
make your objection, when I come tp that part
which implicates you. J believe the same
course was followed, both by the House of
Lords and the judges in t745, and 1746 ; in
those trials, the course was, to prove a lebeU
lion in Scotland, and then to prove the part
the prisoner had in that rebellion.
Mr. Barcn Norton^ — I do not imderstand
the evidence that is to be objected to ; it is
not vet brought before us.
Mr. Ham&on, — ^The objection strikes me
thus.-*Bf this evidence, a plot is said to be
existuag in Enj^land, not a plot existing in
ScotlaiM ; and it is surely the overt act of a
plot existing in Scotland that the prosecutor
IS to give evidence of, but not of a plot in
Eneland.
. Lord AdtfocaU. — ^Mr. Anstrutber explicitly
opened that a conspiracy did^ and has existed
in Great Britain, which conspiracy whether
in Ensland or Scotland, is what the prisoner
at the oar is accessary t^; there is no <^jec-
tion made to the plot bemg in Ensl^nd, it is
a plot in this great empire, to wbicn, both in
England and Scotland, we shall prove Watt
accessary.
J/frd Chi^ Baron. — ^As to the stating of Mr.
Anstrutber, it appears to me perfectly proper
— so far as I can conjecture, the questions
that have been put are proper, and he is tak-
ing a proper method to proceed; he has
stated a plot in England, which was trans*
ferred to Scotland, and to which the prisoner
at the bar is accessary ; and what is proper,
to be done in this case ? the whole plot may
be brought before the jury^ and it is neces*
sary to prove a plot first existed.— this I con-
jecture from Mr. Anstruther's statement, and
I am clearlj^ of opinion, he is right in examin-
ning the evidence as he is doing.
Lord FrciiderU^ — ^It appears to be an ob-
jection no ways matertat— It appears to me
the examination begins in the proper way.
Lord Chi^ Baron. — ^I apprenend Mr. An-
strutber will conduct it in the way most intel-
ligible to the court and juiy ; the fiurand pro^
rr way is^ to prove the corput delkH.^^-
know of no oraer in a criminal prooWing;
he may examine witnesses in what mannec
he thinks proper to prove the charge.
Mr. Anttruther to Mjr. Edward .Layzun.
— Did you search Hardy's house?— Yes, I
did, sir.
Did you find any papers there ?— These are
part of them that I nave in my hand.
mmm
* See his case; ani}^ V0L7. p. 1293,
iS25} 34 o£Org£ m.
VtodeetUMp itfaimtUbM WaU
P«M
ty\d ytm fitid amoiig tB^th 6 l«tt«r> dmted
ikSth Majy 1799. and sigted by a pMob of
the name of SkirviDg?^l8 that theletter,
^ir, you mean ? (The witness produces a let-
tcrl
That is not the letter t mean— I mea& one
6f the 85th of May, 17M.— -This is it I be-
lieve.
See if that is dated ?->^tt is the 25th of
May, IfQS,
How is it signed f^WillUm Skimng.
Will you loML if you have a letter Of th^
loth of June, 1793, signed by Marfftirotand
Hah]y ;— hare yon gOt it in yout hand ?— Yes,
I have.
How is it signed ?— Thet^ is ho tiame to it,
itisM.M.andT.H.
Did you find any printed papers in Hardy's
possession ?-*^everal, sir
Did you find any printed circular letter^i
ti^ed T. Hardy ? — I oelieve I did, sit.
Did you find that letter ?-^Yes, sir.
^ That letter you found inHardy's posses-
sion ? [Showing him another letter.] — ^Yes.
Sir, that letter I found in Hardy's possession.
• Mr.Knepp. — It is a printed letter, signed
"T.Hardy.^
. Mr. Ansiruther, — I inean to pfovc it Was
found also at Perth, and difl^nt places in
Stotland, which Will be evidence of the gene-
i^ityoftheplot.
Lord Advocate. — I desire this witness to re*
ttudn ih court, if yoti have no objection.
• Mr. Atistruther to Lausen. — You must
take those papers with yoO, and bring them
in again.-r-It will be necessarv, as this wit-
itfess IS lo be produced in another cause, he
^Quld keep tne papers in his own custody.
William Scott sworn.
iJo you remember in December 1799, Mr
Skirvinfe beifag apprehended .?^Yes, I do.
Till tne story ^urself, iu your own way.
-^-On the 4th of December 1793, a kneeting
tfebk place with the lord advocate, the then
sfetBriffof Edinbiirgh, Mr. Pringle, and myself,
tA tOilsider what wa^ proper to be done as to
th* tafeetihg then sitting at JSdinburgh, styling
th^selvesthe British Convention ; when it
was agreed upbtt and coh^idercd to be abso^
hiteiy requisite that the leaders of that meet-
lYig should be taken into custody and then*
paijets sefciit^a. In consequence whereof I,
as is usual in such eases, oirectly applied to,
and obtained fh)tii the )»heriff; the warhmts
reo^ilsiltt, but which wen^ not to be executed
till next morhinz, as iho^se acjainst whom
they were directenmight not be found in their
Ibdgings that night, or the babers wanted se-
cured. On the morning of thfe 5th, pretty
ekrfy, \ne warrants were given off to the pro-
]^r oncers, with instructions how to cxiicute
the same; apd as there was reason to suppose
that Ifit minultes of the Coiiventioil, with
other paptet^ of consequence, would be ftnind
in Skirvmg's possession, two of the clerks in
the ^leriff clerk's office, vix. Mr. DiiigwaU
and Mr. Mnk^ wm tent Mbg tMk tlte
cer, who got the warrant aguiat 8inr«ii^ t«
aasiM In securing bis papen, which wu^ tt9
be put into bags, carried with them. Ibr fh€
puqK>se, and broutht to the ofidfe alon with
him for examination and inaptelMHi boferc
the sheriff, as it ^as considered that m mk
dute inspection of the pa|)erB woold tales a 040-
siderable time^ He was aocordte^ly sypi^
bended that tkioming in hl» own hotate, his
papers secimjd, and be taid tb«y takn '
mediately to thfe office, iftthe tiMoi
ed, for examination and inspMtioti io
of the ^h^riff.
What followed then ?— te soon as ihm she-
flff came to the ofllcei Mr. 8kirviDg -mmB ex*
amined, the seals removed flrom the b^
cotitaibing his papers, and the papcts intpart*
ed, wheh an inventovv of stiMi as afipaand
coonected with the btisinfess ati faand «ai
taken; these papM markM and detained,
and the others deliveinad to Mr. Skirring.
Wfere you jMfesekitf — ^I was pmentat <»eD*
itig the bags containing the pafMa, aoM a^
sisted at inspecting wa4 invmtut^hig tha
same.
Was Skirvittg ptatent>-^a waa.
What becaitie Of themf^^Tbey ntmafaiEd
in my tiistody and the than sbiariflPa untfl
sent to the crown agent, with the praoogni*
tioif to prepare for the triais ; ami atoca the
trials were over, I borrowed part of theaa fnm
the clerks of the JusticiaTTy ind go^ thafe>
mainder from Mr. Wairrendfer the crown agm,
sikice which they have been in my pruiiraiioiL
ShouM you know them agaiii ^-^Y^ Unm
their being marked by me wben inventoried
as above.
Have you any nowK-^Yes, I have.
Produce those ynu ha;ve.<^'< Here ia what
is intituled. Scroll Minutes of the Bridah Con-
vention.'** It consists of 95 pagea, and as
that was considered a matetial naper, i»e aH
digned our names on the back of it at fui
length; that is, the eheriff subatitiile Mr.
Davidson, Mr. Dingwall, Mr. Mack, and my»
•elf.
Whatisthat^-Thatis miautea of debate
of the general committee which met at Edin-
burgh afler the axtival of the feaghah dele-
gates.
Mr. HatitUt^.^'M^ lord, it appeva to nt
th&t the evidence as to th^se papers ik entiiely
lost, the chain is broken; so long aa they
remained in Scott's possession, it will amhet^
ticAte thetn, as b^ing fbund in Skirvingf^ |>o».
session ; but out of Seotfb pOMealon, tha
chain is dissolved, aAd you canhoi aaend h
again. It was mentioned to the last witnaei
that it was necessary he should kaep thi
bape)rs for th)^ sAke of^another triat to iy% had |
but hfe did not sb formeriy, eo the Hnk ia
gone, and it is Imposbiblte ibr him to auihtti*
* Se« it ^ebxed tO the larial of Shiivinft
1S89]
fit High Treason*
A. D. 1794.
[12S6
ticaAe thtfsejMpert) ttrtd to ]»ove them ftntnd
ill M r« Skinringf 8 poasetMon.
Mr. Dundai,^*^A fthort qimllon will make
▼«ry clear.
.' I>M yoa mairktiMin?— I did*
Lf9rd PresufeiU.— Let 8cott be asked wbe-
tlier tb^ are or are not the same, and what
reason he has to believe they are the lame
papers P*-Thij are the identical papers I
found —my initials are upon them.
. What is the printed paper 7—It is minutes
of the j;eneral committee wrote upon one
df$klrTing*s letters. There is a letted from
B. Stuart, dated London, 16th October 1798,
to Mr. Skinring at the head of Home Wynd,
Edinburgh! another from Thomas mrdy
from theXknrrespondingSocie^, lAth Novem-
ber 170S; another letter from Thomas Hardy
of the SOth November 1705.
Addressed to whom ^--^Additmed to Mar-
gpffdtand Gemdd, del^^ates; the other was
also addressed to Margarotand Geriald, dele*
gates.
. What is that in your huid P«^A letter ftom
Henry Shipley. Nottingham, dated 6th July
1793, also adorcssed to Mr. Skirving— this is
tiie Resolutions of the extraordinary eeneral
meeting of the society for constitutions infor-
ipation lield at the Crown and Anchor Tavern
London, and directions to their delegates to
tbe British Convention.
Was that paper taken out of Skirving's
papers ^-*It was.
what date is it^^The SSth October 179$.
Look at these papers, and see if you recog^
niee theee, and bv what means you do so-*-
what is that vou have in your hand ?*~It b a
letter from Tnomas Hardy to Mr. Skirving,
addressed on the back to William Skirving,
aecnetafy to the Convention and the Friends
of the People, Edinbuigh, dated London, I7th
May 1793. Here is another lette^lrom the
sum aentleman, of the 54h October 1793,
directed to William Skirving, at the fa^ of
Horse WVnd, EdinbutjEh, This is instruc
tkus to citizen Oemdd from the London Coi^
re8[MHidiDg Societv, dated !i4th October 1793,
signed Riebard Hodson, chairman, and Tho-
mas Hardy, secrfetsry, which is also marked
eitissn QefTald*s commission from the Lon*
don Corresponding society^ Mtii October ir93
Mgned by Thomas Hanay : another letter
from Mr. Hardy, dated e4th October 1793,
directed ibr Mr. SkirvinB, head of Horse
Wynd, Edinburgh, and that is the whole*
Mr. £)iiiMla«.^Dtd you seise any papers of
Mr. Marsarat^ Mr. Scott?— Yes, I did.
Look M those and eee if you know them
ag^, and tell us how you eot tbemf^^n
this same morning of ThUFsday the 4th of
December, another offioer was seat to seiieh
the elace where Margitfot and Geirald reM^
«d, being at the Btek Bull Inn, Leith*
klieet.
What is his name f^Lytm ; he Ibrnid Mar-
jamt and GeitaM in the «ame imi, he took
them into custodyi and lOso their papere ;
when cotntlig away with the papers, Mr. Mar-
g»n>t said it would be more convenient to
cany them in a trunk ; accordingly they were
Kt in a tnmk, which Margerot locked and
j>t the key ; after being examined in the
Mc6f he was desired to deliver up the key,
so as the papers might be inspected, which
he refused to do; &rther proceedings were
delayed till next day, in hopes that he would
then eive up the key. But finding that he
would not do so^ I applied for and obtain«i
from the sheriff a warrant to open the trunks
and to bring Margaret and Oerrald to the
office to be present ; they came there, and
the key beine still refused, a smith was sent
for to opeo tne trunk, when Margaret took
the key out of his pocket, held it in his hand,
saying, if the messenger took it from hkn he
might have it, but not otherwavs: then the
messenger did take the key, and opened the
trunk, m presence of the sherilT, Margaro^
Oerrald, myself and others; the papers were
then inspected, and such as appeared applic»-
bleto the business on hand were inventoried,
and the others given up to BAargarot and
Gerrald.
What is that ?--It is a letter aigned Thomas
Hardy, dated S4th November 1796, directed,
Mr. Marsarot and Mr. Gerrald, delegates
from Lonoon.
Did you get any of Mr. Sinclair's papers f
— ^Yes, he was lodged in the sanie house with
Margarot and Gerndd.
wis he one of the persons apprehended on
the warnmts which you obtained ? — ^Yes, be
was, and was a member of the British con-
vention.
What messenger took him into custody ?•—
Mr. Laiven. Aur. Sinclair could not attend
for examination that day, but his papers were
brought by the officer the same morning to
the sherm clerk's office, and remmned tmre
till Sinclair was well enough to be exaauned
and have hi* papers inspected and invento-
ried.
WHnemi^^^ce is Mr. Sinclair^ amendment
of Mr. Callender^ motion ; it was then mark*
ed by Mr. Davidson, by Mack and myself.
Old Siaciair find any of his pkpers there
when he came to be- examined ? — ^I think he
did.
There is another paper intitxiled ^ a Mo-
tion of A. Callender f was that among Sin^
dair^ Wem too?*— Yes, it was also found
amongst bis papers.
Mr. AMrfai.'— Were you in Nidiolson-
street at the dispenion of the convention ?
were you employed in that business? — On
Thursday, the 5th Deoember. 1793, the Bri-
tish Conventioil was dispersed by thb magis-
trates of Edinbufgh^ when assembled in theu-
vsud place of meetmg, in BladLftiafs^wynd
in Edmburch; and the ttight ibttowtng, the
obnveutbn bavng met in a wn|^t*s shop in
theCross<aasew«y,I aeeompanied Mr. Da-
vidson, the sfaeriiHMbatitote, witii others^ io
assist in dispersing the same,
IStT] 84 GEORGE IIL
Proeeeditigs ogOmMi RoUH Watt
Where is that? — ^It wn in lady Ltwson's
yard in the Cross-causeway. Mr. Davidson
went into the meeting before me, and on my
coming in, I tound the place quite crowded to
the door.
Who was in the chair when yon went there?
—When I came into the room no person was
in the ch^r, but Margarot standing very near
it^-^the first thing I heard said was, that the
meetinz were desired to recollect thev voted
themsmcs a permanent convention the IsAt
night
AVas it Margarot you heard say this?— Yes,
he also addressed himself to the meeting to
this efiect. As there was no person in the
chair, he would take it ; — he was therefore
called unanimously to take it, and he did so.
He moved they should prooeed in their busi-
ness, saying it was a petition to parliament or
to the king, that was under oonsidera-
tion« and Mr. Gerrald was going to pro-
ceed when Mr. Davidson asked of Marga-
rot whether this ¥ras the British Convention,
and being told it was, he said he came there
as sherittsubstitute of%the county to disperse
them, and if they did not do so he would
OMnpel them ; Margarot said force was ne-
cesaarv to be used ; whereupon Mr. Davidson
took Maq^t by the hand, and led him out
of the chair, after which the meeting dis-
persed.
Do you know Skirving's hand-writing? —
Yes, I do.
Mr. Ahstnither produced some papers again
to Mr. Scott, and asked him if they were of
Mr. Skirving's hand-writing. — ^There is none
of these Mr. Skirving's hand-writing, except
hb subscription to one of them.
You know it to be his subscription ?— Yes ;
neither of them in my opinion are Mr. Skir-
ving's hand-writing, but there is his subscrip-
tion to a letter addressed to Mr. Hardy, dated
Bdinbuigh, 95th Bfay, 1703.
. Coarf. —*Is that subscription to that letter
Lis subscription? — In my opinion it is.
What u that letter? what is the date?—
The 36th May 1793 [the three papers were
put in]. .
Mr. 4ns'rttf A«r.—- We must read that letter.
Cross-examined by Mr. Hamilion.
How do you kiiow Skirving's subscription?
—1 have seen his hand-writing often.
. Mr. JCnkia«.— Have you seen him write ?
—I have.
lard Advocate,r^Ut says he has seen him
write, it is legal evidence.
John Tm^lor sworn.
Mr. ilfuenrfAer.-f-Where doyou live? — ^In
f leet^street, in the city of London.
What is your nrotesnon?<«I am not in
any, I have a smaU independency.
You live upon your property ? — ^I do so, «r.
Do you k]K>w such a society in London, as
the London Corresponding Society?— I do,
sir.
[m
Are you a mcmbfr of that society?--! m
Do you know » peraon of the miKflf
Hardy amon^ them ? — ^I do, skr.
What is his firat name? — Thooai.
Is he a membo' of the London ConespQBft
ins Society ? — He was.
In what character did he act.^— As koS'
taiy to the society at large.
Have you seen him act as such ?— I hm^
sir.
Do you know hia hand- writing Mr. T^
lor ?— I do, sir.
Look at that? — To the best of mj bdU
this is his hand-writing. I have seeobi
write on the divisions several timeSjtsda
the best of nfy belief it is his hand-wntiD§.
Mr. Wmrrendtr. — ^This is the certifiote if
ciUien Bfai^garofs election to be a delegitel»
the convenUon ; that is one of the papers *i»
duced by Scott The next is a letter m
Mr. Hardy to Skirving, dated 35thOeUta;
t79S.
Is that his hand-writing ? — It is.
Mr. AmtnUMer. — This is a certifiote tf
Genald, to be a dek^ate of the BnUA m
vention. [Another shown Mr. Taylor].
Mr. rayor.— That I believe to be hii
Those are the articles of instructiofl pm
to Mr. Gerrald by the Lond<m Coirespom
Society. The signature at bottom at
Hardy, secretary ?— That alsois hi» [IobUiJ
at the paper].
Mr. AnUruther.^That is a letter to Wifc
Skirving, secretary to the Friends of the m
pie at £linburgh, in ansvrer to the letter a
the 6th of May; also a letter from H»2"
Skirving, dated the 5th of October, Vt^
are there any more?— This I also ki»w;i
believe that to be his hand-writiiw.
Mr. JiiifnrfAer. — This is a letter m
Hardy to Marearot and Gerrald, deletftf
from London, dated November 8tb lT9St
ffiTiiecf .— From the jgeneral character «
this, I believe it to be his hand^writipg.
Those initials?— Yes. t^
Mr. Jn$irutker.^Ywi believe this to W
Hanibr's hand-wriung?— Yes; it is a W»
from Hardy signed, M. M. C. T. H. S.
Coaafe/.— Which we say is Mwice »^
garot, chairman, and Thomas Hardy, f^
tary ; it is dated London, 10th June, it^
foiind amongst Hardy's papers. .i.
Mr. Amtruther.^Wil\ jon explain to^
s
ponding Societv was a very larjc ^^
people ; that they were divided into s«T^
divisions: I understood as manyB5 ta«^
and numbered 1, 9, 3, 4, 5, and ao ou.
leading divisions were the Sod and ^^
those two I constantly attended •^.'"^.
of the 8nd. division and vbitorofthe**^
but I believe the whole amounted to vb^
41. I took minutes of what passed g^^
always when I took them it was after qui^
the place among them, I have got a no^
IS80] M Hi^ TreoMotu
of ttie divisions wrote down, which I have in
my pocket if necessary to produce. When
thev met, there was a general committee, I
understood to be a permanent one, consisting
of a delegate from each division. This met
on a Thursdajr, the proceedings and conduct
of that committee on that day were always
reported by a delegate of that division on the
following meeting night. There was a Com*
jnittee of Correspondence and a Committee
of Secrecy, and lately there was a Committee
of Emergency.
When was the Committee of Emergency
formed ?— On the 13th of May, in the Snd di-
vision, and on the 13th May in the 39th, in
May last I hope I may have indulgencjs to
refer to my notes.
Do you recollect a meeting of the society
«t the Grlobe tavern } — ^I do.
Was that a general meeting i — ^A general
meeting, advertised as such.
Who was in the chair at that meeting ? — A
person of the name of Martin, whom I after-
wards learnt was an attocney by profession.
Was Mr. Hardy there ?— Mr. Hardy I saw
there, I was not on that day a member of the
aociety.
May last?— May 1794.
Wlutt date was the meeting? — ^Upon the
90th January, 1794, at the Globe tavern.
Do you recollect what passed at that meet-
ing, and what number were present ?•— What
number were present ! there were a thousand
people ; the crowd was so mat that the floor
in one room gave way, and they moved from
the lower room to the upper one, usually un^
decstpod as the assembly room ; the chair-
man and twelve persons, Thelwall and Richter
stood in the orchestra^ thev moved the reso-
lutions that were afterwards published.
These resolutions you say were agreed to
by the meeting, and aAerwards printed ? —
They were,
Mr. ifatfrti/Aer. -^ What passed at that
metting ? — ^The chairman introduced a small
|>relace as to the intention of the meetine,
which was to have these resolutions or ad-
dress, as it was termed, read to the meeting,
and to take their opinion.
Was that address read ?— It was by K chter,
«nd afterwards Thelwall the chairman put
the question, and they were carried l^ a show
of hands, unanimously.
Do you recollect the substance of any of
4he speeches that were made? — The time has
so Ions elapsed, or some particular passages I
should, doe of the resolutions was the ge-
neral or permanent committee, of whicti I
have before spoken, was to meet every day,
in order to watch the motions of parliament,
and if they saw any bill introduced to bring
over foreign troops, or suspend the Habeas
Corpus act, or prevent meetings for constitu-
. tional information, then they were to oppoie
that, and repel force by force.
You have said that Uiose resolutions were
. afterwards printed ?— I have, sir.
A. D. ITdi.
[1S30
Have you any copies of these printed reso-
lutions ? — ^I have, sir [A copy shown him].
Mr. Taylor. — ^Thatisone.
From whom did you receive that copy of
the resolutions?'—! received this from the
hands of a person of the n^aae of Moore, in
the presence of Hardy the secretaiy,and upon*
my requesting him to give me one, I saw se-
veral of those resolutions thrown about the
room, and distributed bv Thelwall andEichter,
lo the best of my recollection. I saw one in
another person's hands, and I believe this to
be the same ; I asked Thelwall for one, and at
that time he said he had none left.
You received it from a person of the name
of Moore, and you saw several of those reso-
lutions thrown about the room and distributed
by Thelwall and Richter ?---Yes.
Did you receive it as a resolution of that
meeting? — ^I did.
You went there on purpose to get it?^I
did. I made an application on Uie 93nd.
On the 38d I receivea it. I can state the con-
versation that passed at that meeting.
State the conversation 4hat passed at the
time of your receiving it from Moore in the
presence of Hardy. — On my meeting Mr.
Moore at the comer of the old Bailey,! ask^
him for one, he said he had not got one; but
if I would apply to Mr. Hardy and use his
name, he would give me one ; in consequence
of which ! call^ on Hardy, he said he had
none by him, but he would eo to the printer's
that evening, and if I woulS look in on liie
following mominfi ! should have one; I went
to his s1k>p, and Isaid I came for one of those
addresses — Hardy sud to Moore, who was pro-
sent, have you any ? — He said, if the person
will ffo to my house ! will give him one. — Mr.
Harc^ said, have you one in your pocket ;«-
He said he had. — He pulled it out, and gave it
to me, and Uiis is the paper marked by me.
Do you remember being present at a meet-
ing of the London Corresponding Society
that was held at Chalk Farm ?— Yes.
On what day ?— On the 14th of April 1794.
Where is Chalk Farm ?'-!t is in tlie road
leading from Tottenham Court Road to Hamp-
stead, about a quarter of a mile out of the
main road.
How far is it from London? — ^About two
miles, or a mile and a half.
What was that meeting ? — It was exactly
of the same nature as the one at the Globe
Tavern, — ^it was for convening together the
society at large, upon which several re8oli»-
tions were moved and entered ipto.
How many people were supposed to be
there ?-— ! h€»rd three thousand, and I appre-
hend about two thousand. — It was held upon
the bowling place.
Who was in the chair ?— A person of the
name of liovett.
Was Lovett a member of the London
Corresponding Society ? — I understood he was.
And was Haidv there ? — ^Hardy was there;
but I did not see nim act inany capacity.
101] M GBCWGB DL
Yoiaarihcf
Wete tbcj nadi^'Otj
WbiehoTllK
■iW.
Bjllie
you any copj oi tboae veMlotMiBir— -
did jTM indvcliioae papcnf-^ ' wd look iiiMes» but wbfllher W lU «^^
I have wmAt upon iL 1 . is catilkd to mm gtidra afiAt fM|^j
mDeifeddi»ftoaiThoaMsii«dy«itbt9iM thsl aeriod : then bhj lispt bcoi icM >
aT April, the MoiidBy wtoMdnf. | H»d^ aot potting » fm^ vfan *>^
WImk did you reccffc than ^—Al these- was voted.
dmaoii of the Loodon CofrespoodiBg Lfrd FraHad, — The Joiy b««« hv
!^. cveiy thiiar the vitBtai said absidiL
OrbowaMoyaui^thatooamst?— AhoB- Jmry.—Hmw do yoo fcoowh vss ooltt
and t«eh«.r— It was proved bgr the book sMBeaslheteaohrtwMif ^^
of the sub sectetaiy, Ptoaice,oo the 12tt of, Mr. Ambmiktr. Kradagaiathed<ba«
May— I beg pavdoii, I meaBttossy.itwas between the prinlad soiDotes, saddvact*
what I uadcritoad lo be eflective menbcrs.— resolutiop that paaaad z if I oodcfslMiv
I andcntand that dimion had 700 beto^giag pankaMwrfthB jwy thatiswhstthy*
to it— It at that moaacDt coosisled of Iff, it
pwB proved, €nm their haviog paid their
^aaitnage money oa the SMh of Alaich pie-
Bknr iiiiidi was the qoartenfe aKNMy ? —
One shiUtDg and a penay.
These reaohiticMis yoo s»r you reeeived frnn
Usffdy ?-I did.
to
I
Mr. T^itr.^lx was thevefcie f*^^
tlie present aiiaistnrwas guilty af^*^
soo; theseeBpmswofdsIbeheveiR^*
the priated eviilowx, bat beiaa iBr«n^*
my meBBory I thii^ I can speak ft^^*
*- Being iiu|iicMci iff
Did you leoeive them as the lesohKions I your memoiy you think you can y^f^
nt ?— Yes I did. I tively to theai?-*The woidi «cRaDF*»"
that had passed at Chalk Fana
Are they die same j— Nearly ao.-^To the
best of mjrreeoUsctiony I think there b some
trifling variatioas.
8tatethem.-«lflkakatmy mkmteslcan
tell.
Did jrou make them at the time^— >Inuaa-
diately upon my coming hoBM.
What IS the vaiwtioB helwaen the printed
copy of the nrinotas you got horn Hardy and
the others ?*-In sense aad substance it was
thusy as I understood the sense of it, — that
the ministers havins advised the Ring to such
conduct ss brought Charles 1st to the Mock,
and drove tlie prince his soa from the throne ;
therefore, the minttteis have been f^dky of
high treaMn.
Mr. MamilioH, — I submit to the Court, that
'the examination should be confined aoMy to
tliat paper, and the witness has no right to go
to any extraneous eiaminatioiL
Mr. AnttnUktr, — I mean topsoveioihe
Court and Jury what passed at the meeting at
i:UA\g^ Fitrm.— The wHoess tdi» you, he re-
upoa my meoMvy.
Ce«f<.— The Jmy wiB ondusisaii
isyetputsoastoaiecttbepriMiaff. ,
Mr. ii8ier«t*<r^I stated to Jjbf M"
would prove the prisoner oaacemcd in * n
ta catt soother British oonventiea,>»]*^
prove who wero the persons who tiM^iVO;
plan, and what sort of a oauteDUm * ^
thcj meant should meet. . a.
JUrd Jdfofe-^At the n^'!'^ A^
Gfebe tavern, was aoy resobtiea J**^
your hearing with regard to the Bpy'Tj
papers intended to be printed?-! iii»»*^
lOO^W to the best of my receUectioo^
One haadred thousand copies "T^ir
solutions eateiad mto that aigb^ *^
printed ^— Yes.
Did you knew or understsnd ^^^^
Cietbey weae to be printed?— 'F^**^^
ted to the society s the friends sao •*^^
of the socie^. _k**itff ^
Iwili put tiie wt^yt p^astio^r^^^^
resolutions enlcffed into at Chslk '"^
jsaaf]
Jbr High Treuoff.
A. D. vm.
[1234
giDted?— In the close of the business^ Mr.
ichter moved two hundred thousand copies
should be printed, observing one hundred
thousand had not been fouzui sufficient^ as
voted at the Globe tavern for distribution of
them to the body at large.
Was that resolution agreed to? — It was.
Of the division No. 3, of the London CoN
l-esponding Society those that had pai^ quar-
terage were 1 12 persons whilst the members
4>f that division were 700, you said ? — I did.
What was the reason of your making that
H distinction of the effective members of that
division? — For this reason; Hardy, who I
understood was the secretaiy at large of the
society, was arrested, and Pearce, who received
the collections on the 1st of April as sub-se-
cretary, had been a delegate, but resigned on
the first of Apn], then was appointed as sub-
secretaiy; the societv met then in the cop»-
mittee roofai, and a chairman was apjwinted;
any indiscriminate person that voluntarily came
forward was nominated a delegate, who al-
ivays acted and did the business when Hardy
waa not present The delegate acted as dele-
gate and secretary. The delegate then read
the report of the committee ; afler that had
been oone, Pearce moved that one member
out of ten should be chose to add to the
standing permanent committee, in order to
make at that time a committee of emergency,
that their proceedings might be more firm
and positive ; he produced a book, in which
book was the names of the members entered
which had paid the precedine quarter. He
took up a book, and said, I nnd here is lis,
in consequence of which, one out of ten was
to be appointed out of that aggregate number ?
he used this expression, '* I have got this book,
God knows what is become of the rest,
I suppose Mr. Dundas and Mr. Pitt have
got tnem.''
It was upon the evening of Hardy's arrest
this measure was taken in the second division
of the London Corresponding Society ? — Cer*
tainly. This was the reason of the com-
mittee of emergency ; taking one out often,
and making them a committee of emergency.
Have you ever heard ot military divisions ?
—X have.
In what division of the society? — It was
the S9th division of the society. I under-
stood there was produced an instrument, a
kind of pike and snortstick to act as a walking
stick, it had at the end a brass ferule and ano-
ther at the head of it; it struck me, I thought
it exceedingly well executed. I was given
to understand, a short or long dagger was to
be screwed into it, and its execution would be
done momentarily. Then this altercation
upon a triflins matter arose from a man of
the name of Oxlade, who appeared in clothes
of a red colour. Some member objected to it,
as bearing marks of aristocracy; he said he
ha«l been in a military line, and held a place
in the society, he said, in the same. situation.
That the London Corresponding Society was
VOL XXIIL
not v^thout places of a military resort. I asked
where, as he seemed to be speaking of it as to
Sersons that did not know. Spence of Middle
^ow had a direction, and he was a dele-
gate of the third division, and he gave me to
understand it was situated somewhere in
&int George's Fields.
Cross-examination by Mr. Hamilton.
Vou say you have a little competency to
live upon m London ? — I have.
Will you explain that; — I have East India
Company's stock 1,350/. produces annually
94/. a year : it is in two names, Mary Ann
Halliday and anotlier.
Pray, what brought you to Scotland?— I
was directed to come here.
By whom?
Mr. AmthUier, — ^I brought liim to Scot*
land, there is no doubt about It I brought
the gentleman here, and I have a right to
bring my witnesses from whatever part I can
get tnem.
I wbh to have the printed minutes read of
Chalk Farm, and the Globe tavern.
A printed paper was then read of the pro-
ceedings at the Globe tavern^ Strand, ad
follows 1—
^' At a eeneral meeeting of the Loiuion
Corresponoins Society heQ at the Globe
tavern, Strand, on Monday the 20th day of
January 1784, citizen John Martin in the
chair ; the following address to the people of
Great Britain and Ireland^ was read and
agreed to. — Citizens; We find the nation
involved in a war, by which in the course of
one campaign immeiue numbers of our
countrymen have been slaughtered, a vast ex-*
pense has been incurred, our trade, commerce
and manufactures are almost destro^red,
and many of our manufacturers and artists
are ruined and their families starving.
^< To add to our affliction, we have reason to
expect that other taxes will soon be added to
the intoleiiable load of imposts and impositions
with which we are already overwhelmed; for
the purpose of defiraying the expenses which
have been incurred in a fruitless crusade, to
re-establish the odious despotism of France.
^ When we contemplate the principles of this
war, we confess ourselves to be unable to ap-
Sroveofit, as a measure either of justice or
iscretion. And if we are to form our calcu^
lation of the result, fh>m what has already
passed we can only look forward to defeat
and the eternal disgrace of the British name,
** While we are thus engaged in an expensive
and ruinous foreigti war, our state at home is
not less deplorable.
^ We are every day told by those persona
who are interested in supporting the corrup-
tion list, and an innumerable host of sinecure
placemen, that the constitution of England is
the perfection of human wisdom? that our
laws (we should rather sav theb laws) are the
perfection of justice ; ana that their adminiS'*
4K
I9SS1 Si GEORGE III.
ProeeMigt <^iuiui tUAm Watt
m
tr&tion of those laws is so iin|Mrtnl, and so
read}[, as to afford an equal remedy both to
the rich and to the poor, by means of whkh
we are said to be placed in a state of absolute
freedom, and that our rights and liberties are
so well secured unto us, as to render all inva-
sion of them impossible.
'* When we ask how we eqjoy these trtn-
scendant privileges? — we are referred to
Magna Charter, and Uie Bill of Rights ; and
the glorious Revolution in the year 1688 is
held out to us as the bulwark of British
liberty.
^'Citizens ; We have referred to Magna Char-
ter, to the Bill of Rights, and to the Revolli-
tioft, and we certainly do find that our ances-
tors did establish wise and wholesome laws ;
but we certainly find, that of the venerable
constitution of our ancestors hardly a vestige I
remains.
^ The only chapters of the Great Charter
which are now in legal existence are the 14th
and S9th.
«The important provision of the 14th
chapter runs thus :
'< A freeman shall not be amerced for a
•mall fault, but aAer the manner of the fiuilt ;
luid for a great fault, af\er the greatness
thereoll savmg to him his contcnement, and
h merchant likewise, ravine to him his mer-
chandize^ and any other vilUiin than ours shall
be likewise amerced, saving to him his wain-
age ; and none of the amerciaments shall ht
assessed, but by the oath of honest and law-
fill men of the vicinage.
** By the usurped power of the judges, in
assessmg fines (and what fines!) in the cases
of misdemeanor, this glorious right of the
subject, of having these fines assessed by the
Jury (the only possible protection from slavery
and tne vilest oppression), is unjustly and in-
fiunously ravished from 4is.
'< The provision of the 99th chapter runs
thus:
'' No freeman shall be taken or imprisoned,
or be disseized of his freehold, or liberties, or
free aistoms, or be outlawed or exiled, or any
otherwise destroyed, nor we will not pass up-
on him, nor condemn him, but by the lawful
iudment of his peers, or by the law of tfie
lano, we will sell no ma»^ we will not deny
or defer to any man, either justice or right.*
^ The various methods now in constant
practice by which the benefits of this provision
are totally defeated and destroyed, might in-
duce us to suppose that the Great Charter has
been repealea ; if we did not assuredly know
that it is the fundamental basis of our consti-
tution, which even the real representatives of
the people (much less the miserable nominees
of Helstone and Old Sarum| have not the
right, nor (as we trust it will be found by ex-
perience) the power to reped. Yet what do we
find in practice } Unconstitutional and illegal
informations ex cffiew^ that is the arbitraiy
will of the king's attorney general, usurping
the office of the accosing fis^ -, and the mte-
rested will of a vile common informer, tJA
the judgment of as vile a common trsAi^o
pensioned justice, substituted in the nm i
our birthright, an impartial trial by our oaa
try. Add to this, that the exort>itaiiteipen
of judicial proceedings, the novel pncUte d
armtrarily and repeatedly annulling the lo-
diets of juries, ana the dilatory prsmeof tbe
courts, most openly and shamefidly cooto-
dict the clause which forbids the denial, lb
delay, and ^e sale of justice.
^ A man accused of felony (for wtiAhf
the common law of England, hh fife n
goods are fisrf^ted) may be hailed ob Ut^
two sureties fbr Ibrty pounds each; hit mm
a charge of misdemeanor by words oahr, IB
to the amount of one thousand poimn b
I been demanded.
^ Upon conrtctioii also fbr such ntis^
ttieanor enormous fines, long and cnid lop
sonments, unknown to our ancient hwifiM
unsanctioned by any new statutes, hwe «
late (and but of'^late). been too frem]eBt}ffl<
too oppressively inflicted ; and all thv»
though by the Bill of Rigfatapt is dcchwl,*
etcessive hail shall not be demuM, ■
cruel and unusual punishments inflwla-
•* If welooktolrelimd, wefindttataciw^
ledged privilege of tlie people to t«el]«*
support and protection of theirrights and liw-
tics, is attempted by terror to be t«k« Jj
by a late infamous act of partiamenl; vW
6tles of honour,— no, but of dishonowaff*
vished; and new sources of comiptioncp
ed, to gratify the greedy prosthoUan « w*
who are the instruments of this opprBSj*
" In Scotland, the wicked band of poj"
has been impudently exerted, witbonl ew
the wretched formality of an «^*rj2?
ment; magistrates have forcibly »*"'^ir
to the peaceful and lawful meetings oIKJ
men, and by force (not only '^'*'^*?/^
against law) have under colour *>^^^^2!
terial office, interrupted their deDbciw>»>
and prevented their association. f i^aj.
** The wisdom and good conduct w we^
tish Convention at Edinburgh, has been sj
as to defy their bitterest enemies *> o*"^
law whiA they have broken ; notwitli«»2
which their papers have been s^^f •J
made use of as evidence against *°^^-^
many virtuous and meritorious ^^^^^^
have been, as cruelly, as unjustly, wT. ^
virtuous actions, dismced and ^^^^^Z^
infamous and ille^f sentences oftrtf^^
tion, and these unjust and wicked J^^^
have been executed, with a w*^?^J"? god
lignity never before known in this "^^^ i
our respectable and beloved ^^'^TJ^^ *
have been cast fettered into J??^
amongst felons in the hulks, to vrtwcn v^i
were sentenced. ..„^it
« Citizens ; We all approve the s^^^
and are daily repeating the words '^V,^
these our respectable and valuaWc w^^^
are thus unjustly and inhumanly ^r^^
Wc loo associate in order to obum »
*88?1
fof Ifigh Treaum^
A. IX 17©*.
[12S8
firte, and ^lU re[^reH&ta^oii of the pt ople in ^
bouse of real na^onal representatives. Ar^
we also willing to be treated as feigns for
cktipmig thi^ our inherent right, which we are
determined never to forego, but with our lives,
and which none but thieves an4 traitors can
. wi^b to withhold from us ? Consider it is one
and the same corrupt and corrupting influence
wbipb at this time cioaiinaersmIreIand»Sootr
landy and England ^ can you beUeve that
tbo^e who send virtupus Irishmen and Scotchr
|nen fettered with felons to Botany Bay, do not
meditate, and will not attempt to seize the first
pioipept tosend us $ifter them ? or if we had not
justcauae to apprehend the same inhuman
treatment, if instead of the most imminent
danger,, we were in perfect safety from it,
should we not disdain to emoy any liberQr or
privilege whatsoever, in which our honest Irish
and Scotch brethren did not ec^ually, and as
fully participate with ms? Their cause then,
and ours is tlie same ; and it is both our duty
, and our interest, to stand or fall to|^ther.
' The Irisb parliament, and the Scotch judges
actuated ny the same English influence^
bave brought us direptly to the point. There
is no farther step beyond that which they
bave taken ; we are at issue. We must now
chopse at once, either liberty or slavery, for
ourselves and our posterity. — ^Will you wait
till barracks are erected ia every villaj;e, and
till si^bsidized I^essians and Hanoverians are
upon us ?
^* You may ask perhaps by what means
shall we seek redress?
«< We answer, that men in a state of civi-
lized society are boMnd to seek redress of grie-
vances from the laws, as long as any remess
can be obtained by the laws. But our com-
mon master whom we serve (whose law is a
law 01 liberty, and whose service is perfect
freedom) has taught us not to expect to gather
grapes from thorns, or figs from thistles. We
must have redress from our own laws, and not
from the Uws of our pl^nderers, enemies, and
oppressors.
** There is no redress for a nation circum-
stanced as we are, but in a fair, free, and full
representation of the people. Eesolved, that
during the ensuing session of parliament the
eeneral committee of this societv, do meet
daily for the purpose of watching the proceed-
ings of the parliament, and of die administra-
tion of the flovemment of this country ; a^d
that upon the first introduction of any bill or
motioin inimical to the liberties of the people,
wch aS| for landing foreign troops in Great
Britain or Ireland, for suspending the Habeas
Corpus act, for proclaiming martial law, or for
preventing the people from meeting in socie-
ties for constitutional information, or any
other innovation of a similar nature, that in
any of those emergencies, the general com-
mittee shall issue summonses to the delegates
of such division, and also to the ^ecretanes of
j||be di^Ter^nt ^cieties, affiliatod and corres-
j^nding with this societj^^ ftythwith to call a
general convention of th^ people to be held at
such nUce m^ in sqch a manner ^s shall be
specified in the sununox^s, for the purpose fjf
taking such measures ii^to their considerar
tion.
" Resolved, that the preceding address and
rpsqlutions be signed by the chairman, and
printed and published.
** J. Martin, Chairman.
^ T. Hardy, Secretary '*
Mr. HamiUoi^* — ^You said you took notes
upon some of these occi^ion^ ?'Yes, I did. .
Is it usually allowed to dp so? — ^No, H ib
not. I have occasionally gone and put tnen|
down in a eoffe^bouae.
Whftt was the occasion of your taking
notes ? — ^I was introduced into the society ;
when I w^t fkway I m^^ th^se memo*
randums.
Did yo)9 communicate them immediately ?
— ^Not immediately. I was sent for to the sof
cretarv's of 9tate.
Pio you ever take any notes of any thing
in any other meeting ? — Not in convivis4
maetiag?. I copceivS in suQh meetings
there v^as not such necessity.
Did ypu think apy thing isippftant enough
for yeur taking those notes r — I did. I thovgnt
the intent was a parliamentary reform, but it
occurred tome they had very difierent objects.
SVhy did you remain in the society when
you found th^ir intpption to dojap ?— I thought
I should be ready, if called upon, to giveno^
tice of what they said pgncerning the repre-
sentation in parliament.
Did you mean to quit the room when yon
found their objects not so bounded? — I did
not, by any means, join in their sentiments
and opinioi^.
But you went there? — I did.
Why } — I said before, partly for amusement,
and partly inclination.
To whom did you communicate this after«>
wards ? — I never did to any body, till called
vpon by a mandate from the secretary of
state's orders.
Mr. Atntruther, — He was taken up by a se-
cretary of state's privy council warrant.
Mr. HamiUan. — Have you been served with
a writ of SMbposna, to give your evidence here?
— No. I dia not receive a subpcspay I was in-
structed to come here.
Mr* J2ium/^oa.^~The Court will take notice,
this witness is not here by any legal authority.
Mr. An^nUker. — What does tiuit signify ? —
I produce my witnesses, — those wno wi)l
come voluntarily, I take them, if they wfll not
come so, I subpcena them if they are within
the jjurisdiction. — The judgss know, every
witness from England tfi Scotland must come
voluntarily, there is no mode of compelling
them.
Whom did you come with ?^ came dowp
with Mr. Gumell.
Who is Mr. Gumell ?*He is a messenger.
Mr. Taylor, you say you took those minutes
fbr your own inforpay^tion ?«-^Ye8.
1SS9] S4 GBORGfi m.
PMI
Had yon any other reaaoB?— No.
Birt flmr you had been befonthe secrofames
of stale you took notes?~No I never at-
teuded them at all afterwMds.
Mr. HoMtitoa— Had you any other motiTe
in taking those notes? — ^None at all, but only
to speak to the point; I bad no interest in R
but mdination.
£dmard Gotlimg sworn.
Mr. l>Ka42af— What n your profesaionf— I
am clerk to Mr. Wickham.
Who is Mr. Wickhamf— Mr. Wickham b a
magistrate in London.
Were you present at the meeting of the
London Corresponding Society atChdkFann
in April lastf — Yes, I was.
Did you hear any resolutions read there f
—I dki.
By whom?— A man, I was informed whose
name was Richter.
Look at these, and see if they are the same
you hav« heard read? — No, these are not the
same.
Look at tfiem.— These appear to be the
same resolutions ; I had a copy similar to this
iBlerwards at one of those divisions.
Who gave you a amy ? — ^I had it from that
division from one Hillyard.
You attended those divisions afterwards?—
I have. Sir.
What was the stjjle of conversation genor
rally at those divisions? — ^In general there
was less said at the divisions than in private
conversations, but on the night following the
14th of April it was the meeting at Cnalk
Farm? on l^esday afWr I had attended one
of ihe divisions — ^I heard it was their inten-
tion to arm in the same manner as they
had done in Paris.
Repeat tliat again.«-I understood that there
was a convention to be called, and it was the
design of the society to arm themselves for
the purpose of protecting that assembly in the
same manner tne French Assembly have been
protected by the people of Paris.
Cross-examined by Mr. HamiUon.
m
Where was it you heard these conversa-
tions ? — ^At the house of Holt, who keeps a
house in Northampton Street.
How maoy might be present? — ^I cannot
teU exactly ; there might De thirty, there w^
BO such conversation as that at the general
meeting of the division at Chalk Farm : it was
the following day after the meeting of CSialk
Farm.
It was a meeting in private, of two or three
people P — No, it was a regular meeting of the
eleventh division of the London Correspond-
ing Society.
Were you served with any writ to give your
evidence here? — Wo answer.] — Have you
been subpoenaed r — I did not receive any
thing, I came down at the desire of the soli-
citor of the Treasury.
J^ow long were you a member ofihisso-
defy ?— I becaone a member die dij ifter ^
meetmg of Chalk Farm.
What waa yrour intention of bckomto
it ? — ^It was OQ aceottnt of the curiouba-
guage I heard h^d at Chalk Farm.
Were you not a meml>er of that soortf fe
fore you were at Chalk Farm?— No^Ibnc
not.
How came yoa to be there?— I met iJA
a friend of that society I knew, I dethinboifa
with him, and I vraa so taken with the fr
course of the oaeeting, I intended sooied^
before to be a member of the socie^.
Mr. Ertkiwt, — Did he tell you diejr beU
constitutional language ? You say, the^ kU
curious hmeuage, and you were so cbnn^
you intended to belong to the society?
VitMamUon, — ^Was it vour intentioDio p
into the society, to see what they had to ayf
—I did not Sir.
When did you leave the society ?— Ifcetea
I paid was up at Midsununer. I did not K-
t«id their society afterwards.
Did you give information relative to the
proceedings going on there? — ^I meotiooed
the circgmstance to Mr. Wickbsio, tf I
thought it my duty.
How frequently have you been at tbosi »•
cieties, and how often did you give iafonBi-
tion of what passed ? — I cannot eiscdyigi
I generally attended the divisions once tveec.
You gave information of what took phce)
—Yes.
Did he prescribe any rule of coodoct Id
you, how to act in future ? — ^He did not >7
any thing particulariy, whether I was to c»
tinue in it or not; he observed, so &r, i> woe
was any thing dangerous going forward,! «>>
to communicate it to him ^f of adangenws le^
dencv. I should not have dgne it, if h^ °||J
not desired me. I had not an idea when I &i»
went there I should meet with any tb^
that kind; I was informed I should meet w
improvement, and there were books to w
read, and I went there for the purpose «
spending an hour or two of an evening*
Alexander Aitckuon sworn.
Were you a member of the British Cofc
vention? — Yes.
I believe you were secretary or sab-fieo^
tsry ?— I was assist^t-secretary to Mr. aw^
ving.
. Did you write the minutes of that con^efr
tion ? — ^A considerable part of them.
Will you look at that paper, Mr. A'^5
and tell me whether the bulk of it»Jf^
hand-writing?— The bulk of it i« y* ^
hand-writing, a great msoy page* f^'\JJ
my hand-writtog, part of it wrote by w»*»
people. -r-
Did you ever see that paper before rr*^
I saw it before in this court, or the jttsuai^
court, and the British ConyentioD. ^^
Does that |Miper, as fiur as it isof your ^^
writing, contain an account of what P^l;
the British CkmTention?--][ceriaio9^^
1211]
A. D. 1794.
[1S42
have made imuij mistftkes In taking down hj
bcanay, but to the b68t of my knowledge, it
contains the truth.
Who was the secretaiy? — Mr. William
Skirving.
Did any body assist you in taking those
minutes? — ^Yes, several people appointed by
the convention.
Look through the minutes, and tell if
you know any other person's hand-writing
besides your owni — ^I do not recollect any
other persons hands except Mr. George Ross.
Lately of the Gazetteer-office ?— Yes.
Was Mr. Callender a member? — ^Yes.
1)0 you recollect any motion made by him f
— I recollect several motions, but do not re-
«)ollect any put down in the minutes.
Do you recollect any amendment made to
these motions ? — I remember well an amend-
ment made on a motion of Callender^s, which
eaused a good deal of difference of sentiment,
and a great many different motions.
Do you remember that motion being sub-
mitted to a committee ? — ^Yes.
Do you remember the members } was Sin-
clurone? — Yes, he was.
Look at that. What is that?— Mr. Sin-
clair's amendment of Callender's motion.
Reads, ^ That the convention considerine the
calamitous consequences of any act of the legis-
lature which may tend to deprive the whole or
any part of the people of their undoubted rijht
to meet either by themselves or by delegation,
to discuss any matter relative to their com-
mon interest, whether of a public or private
nature; and holdine the same to be totally
inconsistent with tne first principles and
safety of society ; and also subversive of our
known and acknowledged constitutional li-
berties, do hereby declare, before God and
the world, that we shall follow the wholesome
example of former times^ b)r paying no regard
to any act which shall militate against the
constitution of our country, and shall conti-
nue to assemble and consider of the best
means by which we can accomplish a real
representation of the people and annual elec-
tion until compelled to desist by superior
ibrce.
^' And we further resolve, that the first no*
tice ^ven for the introduction of a convention
bill, of a similar tendency to that passed in
Ireland since the last session of their parlia-
ment ; the suspension of the Habeas Corpus
act, or the act for preventing wrongous im-
prisonment in North Britain, and aeainst
undue delays in trial, which will render all
the laws for the protection of our lives and
our liberties nugatory, and as some have
avowed their intention of introducins^ a mo-
tion for the repeal of one of them, or in case
of an invasion, or the admission of any fo-
reign troops whatsoever into Great "Bniun or
Ireland ; all or any of those shall be a signaJ
to the several delegates to repair to such
places as the convention shall appoint, and
seven members shall have power to dedwe
fhfi convention permanent
^ Resolved, that the delegates to any qon-
▼ention, meeting under any of those calami-
tous circumstances, shall immediately repair
to the place of sittings and there continue
until their number be twenty-one and then
proceed to business.
^The convention doth therefore resolve,
that each delegate immediately on his return
iiome,do convene his constituents and ex-
J)lain to them the necessity of electing a de-
egate or delegates, and or establishing a fund
without delay against any of those emergen-
cies, for his or their expenses ; and that Uiey
do instruct the said delegate or delegates, to
hold themselves ready to depart at an hour's
warning."
I do not recollect ever having read that
paper before, I certainly have seen it, be-
eause my own hand-wnting b on the back
of it.
Mr. Soliciior Genera/.— Do you recollect a
resolution having passed of^ that purport
in the convention? — Some amendment of
Callender's motion did pass, but whether that
is it I cannot say.
Do you know whether it was entered in
the mmutes of the convention ? — ^I am not
sure.
Whose hand-writing is that?-^It is Mr.
Ross's.
Reads, '< Citizen Sinclair read the amend-
ments upon citizen Callender's motion, as
agreed upon by the committee, and it was
agreed upon the motion of *
That the house should resolve itself into a
committee for its mature consideration. In
the course of conversation, citizen Brown
gave a history of the Habeas Corpus act;
after an excellent discussion of the question,
pertinent remarks and amendments, the con*
vention was resumed, and the whole, as
amended, was read over.''
Then, all that appears from the minutes as
they stand is — ^there is a resolution of all the
members standing upon their legs, which re>
solution is blank ?
Witne$t. The reason that page Is hfi
blank, is owing to my coming in at that very
time ; I remember the circumstance, it was
left that I might fill it in, if not taken notice
of by the other clerks, and therefore it does
not appear in the minutes ; that b the truth.
Mr. Anttnaher. -^Thsit motion was handed
to you as sub^secretary by citizen Sinclair, and
you endorsed it upon the back ? — I did.
Were you present when the provost of
Edinburgh came into the British Convention ^
*^xes»
Did he disperse that convention ? — Yes.
Where did you go to aHer that?— I was
told that the convention went down to some
place in the Canongate.
Where did vou go?-^I went home.
Where did the convention meet afterwards?
—I was not present at the next meeting.
Do<you know Mr. Watt the prisoner at the
bar there?— Yes.
1S4SJ M GEORGE UI.
roct§diiuti
ri2M
Were youtver in any oommitlee with him ?
— I was apiwinted a member gf the Comr
mittee of Unioa along with him.
When?«-X think in the month of January
last.
How long was that aRer the dispersion of
the British Conventien ?— I tiunk that dis-
persion happened the beduining of December|
and the Committee of Union was appointed
early in Januaiy.
Lord Advocat€j^^\M\A that' again.
Mr. Andrutktr. — ^Was Watt a member of
that committee ? — ^Yes, I think he was.
You have seen him there ? — ^Yes.
What was the business of that committee ?
— ^The business of that committee was» to pr^
aerve certainly an union among the Friends
of Refonn, and to correspond.
For what purposes did they meet? — ^I can-
not say, for I gave verv little attendance, aiy)
verv httie attention to the business.
Did the Friends of the People ever meet ?
J— They met occasionally in some private
societies.
Who sent you to the committee?— It was
the chairman of the societies No. 1, and S, of
the Canongate division.
About what was the committee to correa-
TOnd? — About the reform proposed by Mr.
ritt and the duke of Richmond ; we never
proposed going further.
who were the delegates?— Mr. Watt was
one, Archibald Wrieht another, and I had the
misfortune to be w third; three of each
society met
Do you remember any one you ever saw
there ? — ^Yes. I have seen Mr. Bonthorn, and
I have seen Mr. Downie, and I could hardly
name you a third person out of the thirty.
Did you ever see Mr. Wright there? — ^I
never saw Mr. Wright there.
Did you ever l^w of a committee, called a
Committee of Ways and Means ? — Yes.
Were you a member of it ? — Yes.
What was the purpose of that committee ?
—To jraise money.
For what? — ^To pay our past debts.
Was that the only purpose ? — ^Why, in case
there were future emergencies and further
demands to answer, the purpose of paying
them too.
What were the demands to be ? — ^It is es-
tremely diiikult to state what it was. J
never attended it but once.
Was it for the purpose of paying delegates
to the convention?*-! have heard so at some
occasions] accidental meetings.
Where was the convention to be held? —
Some where in England, that was the report
of the day.
Were those meetings composed of the
Friends of Liberty, not others .'—Certainly,
Sir.
Who are they you call the Friends of li-
berty ?-f-W by » it is difficult to ascertain who
arc the Friends of Liberty, a man may be so
pne d^y, and another day in another ^ay.
Who were they ?— AU that piofesaed ti
think as we did. ,
Was that the thing pointed out ia the i^
hition youliave just read ? You have reuillR
resolution of the committee just now, fboiit
a convention or meeting of emergeQcj,aboQt
paying the expense of delegates, wss tbatdK
convention? — I cannot say.
Was i| the British Convention, or aaotlvrl
—It was another, but it was to be held »i
British convention, tha^ was the idea.
Was it for the same objects sod xmm
as the British Convention ? — Certaiofy so.
Mr. Downie was a member of the Britiib
Convention ?— Yes.
Mr. Bonthorn?^Ye8.
Are you sure of it ? — ^I only believe he nt
I am not certain.
Did you ever l^ear where this conveniifli ,
was to meet? — ^No, somewhere in Engiaai
And it was for the same purposes as ^
British ConvenUon met last year?— The snr
purpose as William Pitt and the duke flf
Richmond had before.
Was it or not for the same objects ntiK
British Convention ?— The British CoanS'
tion had the same ol^ect in view Fittiadtk
duke of Richmond had twelve yean afo,»
they meant if ever they met, to folio* *
other plan.
I want to know whether you have evff
beard any conversation about arms?-^N«*B
in any of these committees. .
Did you ever hear any elsewhere?— W
have in occasional accidental meelingso)^ j"!
doors, among people not connected with tbt
British Convention or those committee.
What were the conversations, and «»
whom?— I cannot condescend upon a sing*
individual, I had conversation with so mv
Can you swear that ? -^ I «'^"^T
swear that I have heard it spoke a «»
years ago, when Pitt's reform was first spow
of. I have heard it said no suck thing.JJJJ
be done without a convulsion, and ^v»^
arms. . -. »
Did you ever hear it six months ago, «
nine months?— No, neither eight o'*^^ ^
Did you ever see a pike?— Ib»^* ^
pike in George Ross*s house. ^^
Did not a Committee of Union meet tfloj-
—It was not in their hearing nor anjr oi ^
members. «^j
Did you ever see a pike in Otat^*^
bouse? — ^Yes. -^
Did you ever see more than one f-'* • '
When was that ?— On a Saturday fvew
in possession of half a dozen blacks ^
whose names I do not know.— GeorgP
was not present. -. -jie
What sort of pikes were \hty.-f^
something like the head of a halpert .
Now,7id the Committee of Union m«^
George Ross's? — No. . mr^
Did the committee of Ways afld »^
meet at Georae Ross's ?— Yes. i^
Now, I ask you^ whether you even*
12(5]
fw High Treastm.
any conversation about pikes manufacturing
in Edinburgh, for the purpose of arming the
Friends of the People ?■— I have heard it out
of doors, perhaps at the Cross.
Did you ever hear such conversation any
vhese else ? — ^Upon my great oath, I cannot
day who spoke it.
Did you ever hear such convexsation ?— I
liave.
For what purposes were they to arm ? —
There were various purposes mentioned.
What were they ? — ^I remember, when earl
Stanhope mentioned, in his speech in the
House of Peers, it was the duty of tlie jpeople
to have arms, he urged it, £5 a duty mcum-
bentupon Britons, to be armed, to defend
themselves in case liberty was to be attacked.
For what purpose were they to have arms ?
-^Very diffierent purposes. <*- 1 have heard
some say, they would take up arms against
the French, as well as Hanoverians or Hes-
sians. In all mixed bodies there are people of
different opinions.
Mr. Hamilton, — My lord president, I shall
trouble your lordship with but one observa-
tion, I do it with a view of making this proof
as short as it possibl^^ can be, and nist submit
to your lordship's opinion, that all this man
has been saying anout arms, is nothing to
the purpose; for what is it? — It is merely
rumour, he talks of some proposal, but does
he say it is about a rising of any body or set
of men? It is improper to bring forward
auch evidence to substantiate any one charge
in ^e indictment, or to prove the overt acts.
It proves arms were provided to be put into
divers peoples hands, but is it proved that
this gentleman attempted to put them into
any one*s hands P this witness says, he has
heard this only from people of no description
-whatever. It is not, therefore, such evidence
as can he brought forward to substantiate the
Ikct.
Mr. Antiruther, — I shall examine him as
to any conversation among the Friends of the
People, with respect to arms ; whether I shall
bring that home to the prisoner is another
question, but I must be permitted to go on
with my examination, in order to make it evi-
dence, if it can be made evidence.
Mr. Hamilton.— Such kind of conversation
as this man heard is not evidence.
Cottrt .— -Docs Mr. Hamilton mean to object
to the competency? aye or no.
Mr. Hamilton, — I object to the competency.
Lord President. — ^The answer to tne ques-
tion may be very insignificant; I shall tn'mk
it my duty to say so to the jury, if it be such
as Mr. Hamilton has described it, nothing
more than report; but still the question may
be put.
Mr. Anstrtaher.^The objection goes to the
effect of the evidence ; at present, I have not
inade any thing of arming against Mr. Watt;
I will, if I am allowed to go on.
Court .—Go on with your examination.
Mr. Amtruthtr. To Mr, Aitchesoa.-Y«u
A. D- 1794.. [1246
will recollect you are upon your oath, and
you know the consequences of being so. I
therefore desire you would distinctly and ex*
plicitly answer the questions that are put to
you. I asked you befbre, whether you had
ever heard, among the Friends of the Peoples
any conversations about arms ; you have told
me, there were different opinions upon th«
subject; and told me, one set said they
wouM as readily arm a^nsC a Frenchman if
he came here, as against Hessians or Hano-
verians^ I want to know what the others
said.
The opinion of others was, that we should
arm in favour of liberty, but we never came
to a specific resolution upon that subject. —
I beg pardon. — I think it hard, that I, who
was not allowed to give opinions npon tiie
former processes, shouui now be obliged to give
them, when the opinions are statea for facts :
you ask the people for opinions over a pot
of porter or glass of whisky, to criminate peo-
ple. I never spoke upon the subject to tnpse
two prisoners.
Lord Pren<fent.— That is not the question ;
the question is, whether you heard, m any of
these meetings, any thins said of reasons for
putting arms in the hands of the Friends of
the People, and what they were ; you hav^
been giving an account of*^ different reasons,
and one reason you assigned, as given by
some persons, was, that they might be used
in support of liberty.
Certainly, that I have declared.
Mr. Anstnither, — ^You recollect, when I am
askins what .another roan said, I am speaking
to a fact. — 1 ask who were the persons you
had that conversation with ? — As I am to an-
swer at the great day, I cannot answer to any
sinsle individual.
Were there many of them ? — ^Not above five
or six, at the time of the accidental meetings.
How oflen did these conversations happen ?
— I cannot say.
Did they happen more than once or twice ?
— The public news of the day, the prosecu-
tions against the parties; every thing brought
the conversation on the board. — If a man is
known to be attached to freedom at all, he is
asked his opinion.
Were you ever present at- the meeting of
the Sub-committee, or Committee of Ways
and Means, with Mr. Watt/— Never but
once.
Now, upon your oath, what was the con-
versation tnen held in that committee ? — Upon
the oath, as I shall answer to God at the
great d^y, I cannot tell a word of it, it was
merely preliminary.
What do you mean by preliminary? — Just,
talking over a pot of porter ; we must meet
this day week ; wis must do something.
What was it you were to do ? — I cannot telL
you, this was in company with seven people,
of whom I was one. I never met vrith them
again.
Lord Advocate.^AhoixX what time of the
iSIT] M GEORGE IlL Praceedimgt ifdM Robert WaU
jrear was this only meetiog you had with
Watt?— When the committees were first ap-
pointed.
About what period was that ?— About the
beaiDning of Januaiy ?
Mr. ilaif ni^A^. — Were you never at a
meeting of the Sub^committeey but at the be-
finning of January? — To the best of my
nowledge and belief, I never was.
Had you any conversation with the mem-
bersoftoat committee respecting the business
that was to come before themr— *^Not that I
recollect
You had better recollect yourself ?— No.
Were you ever in Mr. Watt's house ? — ^Yes.
Had you ever any conversation with Watt
in his house ? — Yes.
Was it before or after the meeting of that
committee ? — I cannot say.
What conversation was it you had with Mr.
Watt ?— -Upon the news of the day.
What was the news of the day r— I cannot
recollect; is a man obliged to recollect an ac-
cidental conversation over a dish of tea a year
alter?
Do you recollect or not recollect ? — ^I do
not recollect.
And you say so upon your great oath ?— I
certainly do.
Was any thins said about arming ? — I be*
lieve that was about the time lord Stanhope's
speech was made in the House of Peers.
Lord Chirf Baron. — I wish you to say no-
thing against the prisoner that is not founded
in fact, but, sir, if it be founded in fact you are
called upon, and you are now iii the presence
of God, to answer the truth, let the conse-
quence be what it may. I ask you to the
best of vour memory bad you any coaversa*
tion witK the prisoner about preparing arms,
or anv thing to that purpose when you were
with him ?--^My lord,ncither your lordship nor
any person in this court need inform me of
the nature of an oath ; I am not an atheist,
not one of French principles. I know we
shall all stand up at tlie great day of God,
and this oath warns me to beware of saying
what is not the truth, and whether it hurts
roe or the prisoner at the bar, I shall speak
the tsuth ; if you will take the trouble to re*
peat the question, I will answer it.
Lord (Aief Baron, — ^Do you remember when
you were with the prisoner having any con-
versation witK him about preparing arms or
using arms? if you recollect any thmg, how-
<ever trivial it may be, you are bound to speak
it out. — I can recollect none, not a single cir-
cumstance, but thai Mr. Watt said something
of importance would soon be upon the%arpet.
Nothine mentioned about arms ? — No, only
about lord Stanhope's speech, and the news
of the day.
Did you see any arms^ any pikes, or any
things of that sort in his housed — ^i never
did.
Did he mention anv thing of any pikes
being in his possession ?— He never did.
[m
Mr. Jatfricf Aer.— You have told the Coott
and me that you have had conversstioavitk
Mr. Watt upon the nevrs of the day ; it isia-
possible for me or the Court to know vk
tliat conversation ¥ras, if vou will not desoiie
the purport of it ; but tell me what conven-
tion you had with Mr. Watt upon the OGa>
sion?
Wiineu. — ^It is a very strange ouestion.
What was the news of the aajr?— Itns
lord Stanhope's speech in the House «f
Lords.
What was said about it?— That certaio^
lord Stanhope had stood up for the rights i^
Britons, which had been too much iniiiogtd
upon.
What more ? — I cannot recolIecL
Upon what occasion was it that Wattsud
something of importance was upon the m-
pet?~It IS very extraordinary that such i
tea-table discourse should come in qaesliop.
Did he mention the carpet, that something
of importance was upon the carpet ?-^
words to that purpose, is it possible for a man
to remember every word? I have told ^the
word carpet, but that perhaps was not oied
by Mr. Watt
Before whom was it to be brought m
the carpet /—Before the public, before w
world certainly.
Who was to bring it before the worldM
caimot answer.
Lord PrefiVfen/.— The words I took doia
are, that Watt said somethmg of impor^
would soon be upon the carpet, or wonis to
tliat efifect ; did you say so ? — Yes.
Mr. Attstruther.^l think you abseoW
yourself from the meeting of the comnultee/
—Yes. .
I want to know what was your ^^J*" "JJ
it ?-Here again my opinion is asked; Y^
your question again.
You absented yourself from the n***™]?
of the committee,! want to know your wis»
for absenting yourself from that comimtt^
Lord PrwMfen/.— The question is, ^^J^
son was there for you to leave it?— Is ""^
cessaiy, upon a trial for Ufe and ^sm '''
state It ? ,
Mr. Ansirtaher.-StaXt the reason wrjw
leaving that committee. — I heard, in ^
or eight days afterwards, there ^^"
something important done, or *c*^ JS
publicly. I heard there was to be sect^^
ness before the committee, and from tn8t»;
forward I never attended the committee.
You heard from Mr. Watt, ^^^'^^^f^
business was soon to be upon the carpet, ^
you heard a report out of doors, that so^ .
portent secret business was to he ^^''
committee?— I heard that, and the convo*
tion I had with Mr. Watt was three wonw*
afterwards. , t^
With whom had you the converseUon s^
the secret business, that was to come v^
the committee?— I could not tell joo " ^^
Ufe were depending upon it.
1S49]
for High Treason*
A. 0. im.
Liao
D^yoti B\(Fesrthat?--I do.
You swear that you do not know the per-t
sons from whom you beard that secret busi*
jiess was to come before the committee \ —
I solemnly swear that.
Did you ever ask any of the members of
tlte committee whether that was true or not?
•I— I never did. I have already assigned my
reason; I wished, whatever concern I had
with public reform, it should be open and
fair, and not secret business.
How did you know there was to be secret
business, if not informed by the members of
it > — ^I took it for granted.
Coarf .— Did you ask Mr. Watt what that
business of importance was ? — ^No.
Did you understand it from him?— I did
not.
Lord Pretident. — You said first that some
secret business was to be before the ^mmit^
tee, and then said you heard it oat of doors i
—Yes.
I think you said aftenvards you heard it
iirom one of the committee f — ^No.
Mr. AndnUher. — Then I desire you to an-
swer me upon oath, and take care of the an-
swer yott give this question, whctlier you have
not given a different account of your conver-
sation with Watt, and your reason for leaving
the committee, from what you have now
fiven ? — I cannot recollect, but this is the so*-
itan truth I declare npon oath.
Answer me this question i Do yoo swear
you never gave a different account of this con-
versatwn at another place?— To the best of
my recollection I did not, and consistent with
truth I could not, because it is not true ; if I
was to be guillotined for it I will stand by
that.
. Mr. Ertkine, — In arguing every branch of
this cause, we must feel ourselves under very
great difficulties, because we are on the in-
stant obliged to resort to a law, of which, till
this prosecution, we knew nothing. The
question put by Mr. Anstruthcr is undoubtedly
not competent by the law of Scotland ; and
accordingly we are told every day, in the
court of justiciary, if we attempt to shake the
testimony of a witness, by showing a discre-
ptancyon former occasions, that such ques-
tkins are not jpertinent to the issue, as he has
bound himselt by his solemn oath to speak
the truth. My acquaintance with the law of
England has bisen short and imperfect, but I
am satisfied it concurs with om^s.
Mr. Antttuther* — I understand Mr. Er^
skine's objections to be grounded on the law
of Scotland, bv which I understand a witness
has a right to have his examination before the
magistrate destroyed before he eives bis evi-
dence. By the law of Enplane? he has no
such right; he may be indicted for perjury
upon \X, and I have a right to make use of
every information I can gain from it.
Lord FrenderU^ — ^I ceruinij was under a
difficulty with respect to this matter; for
judgmg by our own pnctice^ I should have
VOL. XXIII.
eotieeived h to be as Mr. Erskine has stated
it I believe the practice in England to b^
different in this particular; but I wish the
king's' counsel to consider,- whether it would
not be right to abstain from questions which
are exceptionable aceordmg to our ideas ?
Mr. Amtmther. — I have stated what I taker
to be the law of England, but shall implicitly
follow your lordship's wishes upon the sul>-
ject. I must say, this witness nas given his
evidence in a manner that does not entitle
him to much attention from the jury.
Mr. Baron Nortan,^-ln general, no witness
is attempted to be discredited by bis own
cooBSel.
Mr. Anttrnthtr.—'I thought it necessary
to bring him to this point, that the jury might
see exactly the character of the witness.
Mr. Hamilton, — I submit it is not compe-
tent for Mr. Anstruther to speak upon this
ntiatter now; the lord advocate will' sum up
the evidence upon the part of the crown, but
now he is anticipating; a part of the charge,
and skating tliat tne witness is not to be at->
tended to. '
Court. — ^If vott cm say he has given any
thing favourable to you, you may have the
benefit of it; but, says Mr. Anstruther, I
have broueht him forward to prove my in»
dictment, out from the manner he gives his
evidence, I place little reliance upon- mm. .
Mr. Anstrnther, — ^The counsel for the pri«
soner are entitled tamake any use they think
proner of the evidence of tim witness, but I
shall not desire thejurv torpay much attention
to any thing he has said^imless he is confirmed
by other witnesses. We shall now read part
of the minutes of the British Convention.
LordAdvocai€,^lt might save the Court
and jury some time, if it was reserved for me
to quote from the minutes of the British Con-
vention, those parts which appear to me to
establish a charge, as I am to speak last.
Court. — If you are to speak last, and do
not now tell the juxy what you mean to lay
hold of, you have an advantage; you have
proved these minutes to be the minutes of
the convention, and you ought to read
them.
[The clefk of the Arraigns read the paper.]
Ut Day*f SUtingj 19th Nao. 1799.
Mr. Dtiacfof.— There was a previous meet-
ing before. Look farther, you will see Mr.
Margaret moved, '' That previous to publish-
ing an address to the public, a committee be
forthwith appointed to consider the means,
and draw up the outlines of a plan of general
union and co-operation between the two na-
tions, in their constitutional pursuit of a tho<
rough parliamentary reform, which was una-
nimously agreed to."
G€org€ Bou sworn, examined by t)ie
Lord Advocate^
Look at those papers; do you see your
hand^writing there?—- There is part of mind
4 L
I8SI] 84 GEORGE la
Proeudu^ ogmM ttoh£H tVaii
[»
berei this it my hadd-mliag, dated tSth
JNoT. ITM ; Mme parts are nine.
[Part of tiiat paper read as foIIowB :)
<< Cititen Sinclair read the atnendmenta
upon citisen Cailender^ BDotioa, aa agreed
upon by the comniitteey and it waa agreed
npon tie motion of citiien , that the
hoiuie retolve itself into a ootnttittae far its
mature oonaideration. In the oourse of live
oonversation. citizen Brown cave a history of
the Uabeaa Corpus act. Ailer an txoalient
discussion of the question, pertinent remarks
and amendoients, Uie conventioii was re-
sumed, and the whole, as amended, baiiig
leadorer, the memberi stood upon their fiset,
and nlemnhr and uoaanmoiisly pasted the re-
solution as miowB :
[Here a page leA blank.]
^ Citiaen Gerrakl, in an energetic and ani-
auted address, eiptessed his happiness at tiie
motion passed, and exposed the act of the
Irish parliament, called a Convention BilK
** And citizen Brown followed him in a
manly speech, and proved tlie mfluence of the
eiecutive government over the parliament.
Citizen Maigarot read and proposed the feU
lowing motion, viz. That a secret eoraraitlee
of three and the secretary be apitointad, to de-
termme the pfau% where such convention of
emer^D<7 shall meet; that such place shall
remain a secret with them and with the se-
cretary of this convention, and that each de-
legate shall, at the breaking up of the present
session, be entrusted wi& a sealed ieller,
containing the name of the place of meeting.
This letter shall be delivered unopened to lus
constituents, the receipt of which shdl be
acknowledaed by a letter to the secretary, pre-
served in the same stste until the period shidl
arrive at which it shall be deemed necessary
for the delegate to set off. This motion was
seconded by citizen Mafibtl, and the same
was paased unanimously.
•* The following dtieens were nominated,
with the secnetsry, a Seevet Committee en
tois bnsineBs, viz. Margarot, JohnCtork, and
Brown; and they were requested to devise
the best possible means of conveying this in-
thnatioR to those societies whose views were
the same with oar's, hut may aot have dele-
gates at this convention.^
I/n-d Advocaie.'-Do you know the prisoner
at the bar ?— Yes, sir. ^ ^^
When and where did you know him ?— It is
not long since. I am not intimately acquaint-
ed with nira. I have seen him sometimes in
my house.
At what particular period did you first see
him m your own house ?— I think about the
beginning of this year, or the end of last
year.
Pmy, Mr, do y<ou knew any thng of a
committee of the Friends of the People, who
were represented in the British Convention,
meeting in your house after the dispersion of
that convention ?-«Yes; luWenlDDdsiti-
antleebf tbe Friandt of the People isitiiar
house.
About what period?— Abaot the poioit
mentioned before.
Does it conwiat witb jovr koDwlaj^tti
Watt was a meoiber c£ that oomaitlM?*!
have heard that Mr. WaU was amndnii
that committee, and seen hhn ileeivi
other people Eft mj house, bat iae«vri«
present at any aoaely w1m> nsde ^imati
Imn, and never was preaant at^ conaifet
myself.
Do you remember any others tint mki
the sMie time with Mr. Watt?*-Tcs.
Give their naoKa. — Mr. Omwk, Ik
M'£wan, and Mr. Downie.
Where does Orrtick live?— At the War
ofLsith.
WhatisM'Ewasi?— [N9 aaswcrl.
Have you seen tbem tOffetfacrMtii
best of my knowledge, they did meeto^
Do you know wtiet the name of thst c$tm
tee was ?— I uBderstood it was a Ceeaipii
of the Friends of the People, I nstcr iv
ao^ other name.
Did you ever bear any other nttse atf*
tionedr— I cannot aaj; it had Momc pattt
lar name, whether it vi^aa this or nc4,l^,ai
know ; it was caUed a cooimittee of laa
this I heard of at that tiaie.
When those peracMsa assetfibted Aft
house, dkl they go tnfeo an apartment by Ibis-
selves ?— They fid. ^
Did you ever bear or know of sfijr v"'
or subordinate ooounittee b^^^'LT
house, other than the Commitlee aOJwt-*
I cannot say whether there were oas iMf
committees, — as far as I recollect, I w^a
there were twa,— they met at m bei»^_^
there weie two, or that part of tbembdayt
to each. j.
If there were two comarittees, ^^^
composed of the saaae condition ^fff^j
societies, or were they the same MnW*
persons ?*--I mean the aame persons.
Yea must captain it.^A part of t^J*
oomposed one committee composed v»^
Were the whole of those persons nm^
ofbothcomttittee6?-~Iam not ^^^'^^'^i
ther they were two osmmittees «'*^»v2
know there was fewer of them met n ^
time, and a mater number ^^^^''^'^'^^Life
You say they began toassembfe iMiR«^
beginn'mg of the year at your h«**"'^
long, and how oAen dkl they «b*»»*!1 t
so thereafter ?--^SomeUmes 4h^ <n^ ^"^
week, and aomethnes iM>t. _^;^
When did they disoontiane their weOf^
ultimately and anally?^! do not »>^Q
Mi £dinbuM;h myself, some time H^ ^
before that there had been a meetiag;
Ilad Watt been apprehended ^^ ^
left Edinbiwgh?— Yes.
Downie the saasei-^Tes.
Had M'Ewan ?-4 cannot asy. a.
Did those nun continue to meety wioi ^
J96SI
Jkr High TfiMicm.
A. D. 179^
[ISM
«M«cdW«|if^M. ^ftrasl can Kcd;-
lect, there were meetings previous to their
A short time before ^-^Y^s. I think there
Nov, sir, you were a raemher of the Britbb
CooTenliMi^-^VeSy sir.
, W«re allor a&yof those you saw at your
house at that time, members of that oonven*
iion }^I do not think Watt was.
* Waa Downie i — ^Yes» I think he was.
Was M'Ewan }— Yes, I thiak be was.
Bo you recollect the names of any other
paraoBB who appeared to be members of the
convention, who attended your house at Uie
aame time Downie did^-^xes, I believe ane
Bonthome.
What is ha ?•— I believe a teacher.
Any other person ? — I am not sure whether
Mr. AJtcheson was not oae of them.
. il0 you 4naw a person of the name of
Stock r^Yae.
J Bid he attend the above meatBues in your
luawB, auich about the tiase that Watt, 2>ow-
nie, Bonthome, Orrock and M^fiwan attend*
odN— Yes. I have seen him twice or thrice
Afker the dispersion of the British Gcnven*
lion, does it come within your knowledee,
that the societies of this city, who sent d^e^
fcates to Uiat conventkm, continued to meet ?
I believe two societies did.
Who were they f— ^neoa dteeottth aide of
thetewa^ and the other at my houK.
' Doyouknuw a place called Symon'a-scjuare,
an the south side of the town ?•— Yes, it was
tbereahe society met
Were you ever present at anv of their meet-
>ogs?-*Yes. As the society which met at my
house gave up, very few bavins come to it.
- Did th^ continue to meet there, while the
trials of Garrald, Skirving, and Majq^arot were
pending f — ^I cannot answer the question put
mibatway.
From the time Skirving was triod^ to Jtbe
10th of March, when Gerndd was tried, did
the Symcm-square society continue to meet?
-^ cannot say.
Upon4hosa occaakms when you were there,
what numbers metf — The loom might he
M,"^ was a small room.
What number might be therel— I dare say,
when, vary .aowded, then might.be, peshaps,
siity or seventy people.
Bo you know aperaen of the name.of Har- i
dy, in London ?— I have wmte to him.r^I do ^
aaiiknow him, I bane wvoto to him once.
When f — I believe it might be about the
aad^fiast ^ear,.or beginning of 'this.
Pra^r, sir, did Mr. iiaidy ever transmit to
ym, ainee ^the beginning of this year, any
psckage,papars,orlet%Bm whkh he desued
900 taoRuiate?— No,iie never did.
Did .you ever leoeive any httan or ^mpers
eftbatdaaoiptkni, with thajignatuwjofJ^-
dy to them ?--iYjes. 2 jncoUeat aane footed
lettea signed T. liardy.
What time of the year did you get these ? —
I suppose about Febniary, or March, or April.
How did you receive thpm, and irom
whom?— If I recollect properly I think it was
Mr. Stock save them roe.
What dia you do with these letters ?-i-I s,ent
some of them into the country, as the letter
s^l&med to indicate its purpose.
How many miebt there be ? — About haif a
dozen I sent in that maimer*
To whoip did you think it your duty, and
did you actually send them f — ^I sent them tp
the members of the different societies of the
Friends of the People in the country.
Do you recollect any town or pe^cular
person m that town^ to whom you sent that
fetter f — ^I sent one to Penh, one to Paisley^
one to Strathaven, and I think one to Dundee.
Do you recollect to what particular person
you addressed tliat letter to Perth ? — I am
not vei^ certain whether it l^as to Sandiknd^
or to Walter Miller at Perth, (^e was shown
the printed letters here and interrogated about
the mmd-writing on the inside of i^ before hfe
was asked about the direction on the back.! '
Whose hand-writing is it upon the back ?
—It is mine also.
Do yoii believe that to be one of those re-
ceived from Stock ?— I suppbse I received it
among the rest.
Yoii say you sent one to Pusley, do you re^
collect whom you sent it to ?— I do not.
Do you recollect to whom you sent it at
Strathaven.— To James Wilson, I think.
And you sent it by poist ? — ^Yes, I suppose I
did.
You did not send a private hand with them?
-•No.
Do you recollect to whom you addressed
one to Dundee ?— I do not.
Do you recollect any other towns you sent
that paper to ?-— I do not recollect at presents
Do you know a man of the nameofPairley,
a caA)inet maker?— Yes.
Was he a member of thai committee?— I
am not certain if he was.
Do you know or did you ever hear in any
conversation amon^ the Friends of the Peo-
ple, or those societies, of an intention of ann-
mg about that time ?— No, I did not.
Had you any occasion ever .to see any arms
in the hands of the prisoner, or any other
member of the societies? — :No, I did not. ,
Mr. ^autralA«r.— We shall Jcead the letter,
and another letter found in the pgssession of
Hardy.
Cross-examined by Mr. Erskine.
Il^ve ^ou not said Watt was not a member
of the British Convention ?-^No, sir.
You tolked of two societies, ooe at your
house the other at Symon's-amiare, was he a
m^mber.ofeither?— Idoiiot Imow that he
The British Convention bc^aa in .October
I beliflve?— Ahmit Noieeaiber.
When was it dispersed ?— It was about tha
beginning of the last year.
1255J S4 GEOfiGB lU.
Proeetimp agaimii' Robert WM
{m
■ Doyoa know wbethnr mil £heir proeoedkigs
.were inserted regularly in the papers ?-*-Tbey
4id appear in the public papers.
Just JO, and there was no other public in-
timation given of any of the praceedings of
«aoy of ^em?^No.
[Letter read.]
^' Fellow citizens ; The society in Strath-
aven received your circular letter some time
ago, respecting another British Convention to
he held in England, and finding it would be
injconvenlent Tor them to send a delegate for
themselves alone, the cause being much sup-
pressed here by prosecutions^ which we are
subject to from the petty sheriffs in our neighr
bourhood, we have united ourselves with
the societies in Kilmarnocli, Galston, New-
milns, and Dervill ; accordingly a meeting of
delegates from these societies, and that in
Strathaven was convened on the first current,
when the measures met with the fullest ap-
probation, and a delegate was elected for
the general convention, and a secret com-
mittee appointed to conduct the business;
you will therefore forward your orders to us,
when and where the convention is to meet,
with any other instructions or inforniation
you may judge necessary; we shall instruct
our delegate res]>ecting the number and
Strength of our societies, and are happy to fra-
ternize with you in any thing that may tend to
promote the general good.— -We remain yours,
"Alex. Mitchell.Scc.
^ In the cause of Liberty for the Unitep
Societies as above.
« Dated Strathaven, 9th April 179i/'
Mr. AnUruthtr, — We will read the other pa^
per to which this was the answer.
Lord Advocate, — It is the same gentleman
produces it, Lauzun. It was found in the
possession of Hardy.
, Mr. Ertkinfi, — It is needless to read it.
[Here Hardy's circular letter was read.]
Mr. Lauzan called.
Did you find a paper among Hardy's papers
signed Alexander Mitchell—of what date is
it r-^No sir, one Mr. Gurnall found it.
. Mr. Jama Gurnall sworn.
What are you ? — A king's messenger.
Look at those two papers lyine before you,
marked with your name, tell me where you got
Jhem ? — I got this paper in Mr. Hardy's house.
• Look at the other. — ^This I got there also.
Alexander Mitchell sworn.
Mr. Antlruther, — Mr. Mitchell, is that your
hand-writine? — I could not positively say sir,
I am persuaded it is.
Mr. Mitchell, what business are you ?^A
manufacturer in Strathaven.
•What letter .was it written in answer to } —
It was written in answer to a circular letter
received by post.
Was that a written or a printed letter ?-'II
^as a printed letter.
Look al that letter and say whedier itii
likeH? is it hke that letter?— Yes; Ibdim
it was similar.
In answer to such aletter as thatyoawnk
this letter ?-*Ye8y sir.
Do you recollect the name of the poai
affixed to that printed letter ?-lt wis Badj.
In consequeiu:e of that letter, was there t
meeting ofthe socaety at Stiatfaavenf-Ie^
there was> air.
Did you and the other societies in tfat
neighbourhood choose a delegate?— Th»iv
a general meeting held, and it m i|^
upon at that meeting to choose a dek^
A delegate to what?— To wbatvastsfld
a British convention.
Inconsequence of that letter, yoe dl«i
delegate to another British confentiooma
the societies in your nciehtjourhood^--^
Mr Baron Norton.^l do notthinktbcwtta
is bound to say any thing to criminate flinwt
Witmm.^My lonl, I cannot cowflit
wherein the present question hassny*wj
relation to the object of my evidence, Wi
appeal to the judgment of the Court w «i»
I shall answer or not.
L#rrf PretUUni.^Yuu are in no daif»«
all, you have taken an oath to speak Ibe Wt,
and you ought to do so. . j.
Did you do any thing in consequence oliw
letter ?— Yes I did. ...
You were secretary to the meeting, I tiiBt
—Yes. ^
You wrote that letter as secrettiy'-J^
sir, directed to Mr. T. Hardy, shoesiiw.
No. 9. Piccadilly, London, for the WM»
Corresponding .Society. Direct to Alenwj
Mitchell, manufacturer, Strathaven, coaniy*
Lanark. .j,^!*.
Mr. AwitrutJUr.-^From whom dwywjT
ceive the printed letter ?— I do not kflOWj^
came by post, I suppose ; and it ^•*^'j
perly directed to me, «* came to anollic^
was not secretary to the society of Stn^^
but to the meeting ofthe societies mcnw^
in the letter.
Mr. Lockhart sworn.
What are you ?— The depute shcnff^<^
Had you ever any occasion tosesrcB
house of Mr. Watt ?— Yes. . ^
Upon what occasion did V^J'^^zZ
house ? — It was upon 'occasion of ^J"*2
for some goods of a bankrupt, that toey»*
was secreted in Watt's house? ^^j
What did you find there?— I found* w*^
goods, and I found some pikes. u
Where are those pikes ?— There ai« ^^'^
I found upon the first search. j^^a
Were did you find them ? -In a locked pw»
in one of Mr. Watt's rooms. ^^
Had you ever occasion to make siHW"^
search in Watt's house ? —Yes, sir. ^
Upon what occasion? — I went ^*]^ jj
same evening to see the windows ^^'^^
was between twelve and one o*ck)C»; *
dered aeloset to be broke open.
1257]
Jw 'High TreatpH.
A. D. 1794.
[1258
After "fiiidhig the first parcel, what did you
do ?«— I took it away with me, and carried it to
the sheriff, and showed what I had found,
and there was a warrant for a further search.
Upon that further search, what did you find?
— ^Two halbert- headed things, and nu>re single
pikes. .
W here did you • find them ?-*In a ck>set
upon the second search. •
This was about mid- night? — Between
twelve and one«
What month was it?— Upon the 15th of
May.
Did^ou try that pike and that stick? — I
did, before I came out of the house.
What did you try it with ? — I found this
one first and tried tfaiat on it.
' Put it on now. — It is a smaller one that
screwed into the hole, and the large one went
over it ^
- Show that to the eentlemen of the jury.
^a complete small faamrt.] Shew them how
It fits the lai^eone with the halberthcad.
••—It screwed on in the same manner as the
small one did.
(To Lockhart] Does the scrcNr of that large
erne fit the screw of that other? — ^Yes.
What is that other thing ?— -I fancy it is
meant as a dagger.
So that it would fit any other pike?-— Yes.
You found these in Mr. Watt's house ? —
Yes Sir.
Where did you carry those pikes ta from
Mr. Watt's house?— To the sheriff clerk's
ofiice.
Did you find any thing else theve ? — ^There
was a fount of types.
A foufit of types?— 'They were entire at
the time.
Were those types set when you found
them ? — ^Yes, they were.
How came they to be in the state they are ?
— I lifted ttiem rather rashly the other day,
when I went to exhibit them before the grand
jury, and they broke down.
Lord Fresideni. — Are there any standing?
—Yes. ,
Mr. A nttruthtr, — ^W hat did you do with those
types when you found them ? — They were
loueed in the sheriff clerk's offiae.
What was done with those types when they
were in the office ? — I was not present at any
thing done there with them.
Mr. Andruther, — I will prove an impression
taken of them.
William Middleion, sheriffs officer, sworn.
Mr. Anttruther. — Had you ever any occa*
sioD to search the house of a person of the
name of Orrock ?— Yes, I had m the evening
of the 15th May last
Under what warrant ? — ^Under the sheriff^s
. warrant. Robert Orrock, he is a smith at
Dean. Before I went to Orrock% I searched
Watfs house.
' What did you find ?— I found in a closet in
the under story of Watt's house a dozen of
spears, ?
Was Lockhart with you?— Mr. William
Lockhart was with me.
What did you find there?— There were
twelve spears found in Watt's house on the
first searai, and upon the second search four
others found, sixteen in all.
Are those the instruments ?— Those are the
identical instruments.
Did you ever find any thing else in Watt's
house?— There were, m the presence of the
sheriff and Lockhart, a set of types found. I
seriously believe these are the same, but thev
are not m the same situation as when foimd,
they have been accidently broke down, they
were set and entire when they were found.
Did you search the house of Orrock on the
15th May? — ^The smiddy of Ormck was
searched, and I. think there were fiileen of
these ; these are the instruments found in the
smiddy of Orrock.
How many ? — I think S3 unfinished in- this
state.
All halbert heads ?— Those are part of them
in the highest finialied state.
Show them that are in the finished state,
and those unfinished ? — ^Here are those in the
unfinished state,.aad the others more finished.
You found these in the house of Robert
Orrock ? — In the smiddy of Oirodc.
Not in the house ?-*-No, we found nothing
there, but in the smiddy. He was brought to
the sheriff clerk's ofiice, along with those
articles.
Had you ever occasion to search the house
of Walter Miller?— I did not search there.
In what part did you find the types in . the
house of Watt? — In the upper story^^^th^
were found by the sheriff himself, on a shelf
in a cfoset in tlie upper story. I lodged the
Wpes in the sheriffs office, and carriM them
from Watt's house to it
Mr iiiufrit/Aer.— Those found in Watt's
were found in the press — those in Orrock's all
in the smiddy? — ^Yes.
Were they in a concealed place in the
smiddy ?— These two were rather in a con-
cealed wav under the ashes upon the hearth in
the smiddy, but the others were in a box in the
back part of the smiddy, and did not seem to
have any thing to eover or conceal them.
What became of those types after you car-
ried them to the sheriff clerk's office ?-*-! bo*
lieve they were carried to the sheriff clerk's
office, and remained there ever since for any
thine 1 know.
Were you present when any impcessien was
made of them ?-*No.
Jamei Walker sworn.
What is your name ?~ James Walker.
Did you ever tee a fount of types in the
sheriff clerk's office ? — ^Yes.
When ? — I think it was in May about the
30th, some time after the 90th or 3dd May I
think, I could not say the day, but it was
some time in May.
What are you bv profession ?-*I am » wri-
ter in the sheriff clerk's office.
18.59] 34 GEORGB UL
Proaedu^ maiusi Rah$fi Watt
m
Wbttbeoune of thtt fount of i7|Mt?«-I
do not know what becamo of Umoi.
Did jTou 866 wmj ittipreMon taken off? —
Yes, I saw a doaen MnpseMioiM lakaii oft
In ^t^nom hands did jou sea tbal fount of
types?— 'I saw it in Um shentiPs baiMls, and if
IfiooUeet I oaniod it up to Campbell Deno*
van's printing office.
What distance is that?— Not for, it is just
in the same ekiee.
Is it as far as to the window there?— No,
it is forther ; we first go up the close a littlot
and then up a sla»<asa to the printing office.
Did TOH see the impressions taken afi* at
that omce ?««>Yes.
Look at thil?— Yes, I taw this one.
Did jou put jrour name to it ? — ^Yes.
Dkl you |Rit It at that time ?'-! put it when
my dodaratkm was taken.
Are you sure it is the paper you saw taken
off ?-^Yes, I am certain it is.
Jamet CUrk, esq. sheriff depute, sworn.
Mr. Ansiruther.^^Vid you ever receive a
fiamt of types in your office, Mr. Clerk f— I
found a fount of tyaes in Mr. Watt's houm
upon the eveniag of the 15th of May. Mr.
lockhart, the sheriff clerk depute, came with
a pike to the office while I was there, which
he said he had found in Watf^ housie, upon
which I granted a warrant to apprehm Mr.
Watt himself, and to seareh his iK>use, which
was accordingly done ; and other pikes being
found, were also brought to the office, where
Mr. Watt was likewise brought forcxamina*
tion. After which the house was arderod to
be secured 'till the neit day; accordingly it
was so, and next day I went with Mr. Lock-
haft, Middleton, and Watf s maid, to inspea
his ptpen, and likewise to secure any thing
else found in the house that mi^^bt appear
naleriaL In the course of this search, and
in an upper dosel, whether upon a shdf or
on the floor I do not recollect, we found a
fount of typos set up for printin|; finding
this in a house that was not a prwter^s lea
me to«xamlne the fount oftvpes, iN^nch I en-
deavaured to read. I ooula read Dundee,
Sflth April at that time, and a line soma-
thing to this purport : ^ for thai purpose
afone you are iohsted," it was in mm to
that purport
These were in capital letters ?---Ye8 1 could
not raad the small letters, I read the large
letters.
State what you did with the fount N-^There
was a multiplicity of business going on, the
fount and types were put in a place where I
had the key, and afterwards I sent a lad, a
younjK ttum that writes in the office, and a
Mr. Wishart to Campbell Denovan^ printing
office in the same dose, and desired them to
thit)# off 18 Mpiis t they did it ih the course
of a fow minutes whifo I was them ; and hav-
ing retuitted the fount t6 me, I then lodsed
up thetjpes, and they were impt in my poa-
sessloD tili sent to the grand Jury.
Did yott givn the lad the feuntef tjina'
actly inthe sane alate, in which yni W
it in Mr. Watt*a bouae?<-~£iactly ia theoai
stale, and there ereie twrive cepies ^km
liromit, attfaattkne.
Isthatonaof the cepicsf readiisior^
It is dated Dundee, April 12th, 1794.
Is it in prhuing or in wfitiBg?--Itiiii
print.
"^ FHenda and btethiai*4t u with tk
{greatest pleasure that your oooaliTflMBat
mformed, that sudt Is youratischncsturf
love to them and to your native countrj^tiyi
youmanfiilfy and firmly msolve nottokm
It uDon any teroM eontnay to thoieifn
whkm yon were at first engaged.— Yoei an-
trymen love you, and tMir hearts whU k
as much wounded to fart with you, ss 3ms
wouM be to be se^amted fiom them; th^
well know that they are safe under the ■»
teetwn of their fothera, their sons, tfanrm-
thers in arma, and they neither wish an 4^
sire any other defondera^-^they hope md h>
have that your heada are filled with lie um
sentiments.
** The mat maas ef the pesple Am
amongst amom you hsve been eniiM, hm
been sepieBtnted to you, aa your ^oaaK^-
believe not the assertion, they ^** ^
taught to consider you aa foes, l^^lj^J^
not fear finding ftmnda amongit tbdr in>
thren.
** Their cause and yours is the Mm^-T^
are poor, but ihey have honest hearts ; M|
which sympathise in vour cause ; they mj*
the same fiHttdship and ihetmt§pB^
in you.
« They njokt to hear, that you ait b««J"
ing daily more convinced of the grest t[^
that the Uw ought to be the same to tbem
lander, and to the lowlander, to the ncMn
to the poor, and no man can be coo^Pf^
take up arms, by any authori^ ''^**|?'*5
unless his nwn im^jnatinns pioflBpt vn «
""This truth has been hitbeito <^
concealed from you, but it is not t^**?vj;,
tain, the wiU of your laird caooot vitt0U
your own consent, separate you "^tun r"
fiunilies and friends, although »«>ViSi
BHiy have esperienced the eiertioiis^i^
power, however imjust, and however coiuw?
to law. . r_u
*" We respect and admiie thai f^
which induces you (though necwsji^
compelled you to take up arms) »J5j!5fii
sist m remaining to defend your ^v^^
home, end net to quit a country
pledges so dear.
tkeir*'
" When you are gppe, whero i#. ^.Z,
fence ? They may be eithar left without F^
toctian, or nmy Mm see their ^xmdVI^
tun %y foreign troeps, auch iB m ^^J^
haveafaendy shad the blood cTyour ^^,
without provocation, and without .r«Do^'
a*d who would foel perbdps ss h^^
punctioft in shaddiog yours.
1261]
JorlBgk TreoMoiL
A. D. 17M.
nsee
^ Preptfed for eveiy^laed of hMor, time
^Mwign mereaiariesiiuiy violMe the ciKtsftity
cf your wives, your sisters^ end your deMgh*-
tc», ami wfaeii desire is eetietedyerueltym^
resume its place in their hearts^ ae experience
hmB too well and too &toIiy ebowii, and friends,
yiTBDtfly children, bfodiers may be invohed
nk •&• common slaaghter.
** The cruel massacre of Gleocoe cannot
yet be fiwgotten ; are there not amongst you,
whose forefathers perbhed there f their hurts
thfoWbiag with kindness and hospitalitT were
pierced with the daggers of their treacherous
^HuestSy and the feast, Mpared bv the hand
4»f unsuspecting ftiendsmp, was closed with a
flceaeofWood; such is the letum for kind-
ness and hospitality, such the protection
which your fiuniises hawe to caqiect !
** How will they look around in vain for
your protecting care, when perhaps you are
lighting at a distance in « foeeign land«-*But
they hope you will net forsake them, stay,
oh stay^ and defiosd your fiunilies and your
friends. F6r that purpose alene yeu were i»-
listed, they are ready to come forward for
you io the Ttndieation of your rights.
** Thousands join in the same sentiments
with yoat, and ardently wish for your eon-
SiHuance among them*-Tbe oirciimstances
which might reqinre you to quit your country
have not yet taken plaee'-4io invasion has
yet happened, you cannot he compelled to
^o-*leaye not your country — assert your in-
«ependenee.-wYottr counteymen will look up
to vwi as their protectors and guardians, and
will iniheir turn lift up their arms to protect
and assist you.
^ Pundety April 12th, 1794/'
Jamei Sommerville sworn.
Mr. Anitruther — What is your nameP-*
James Sommenrille.
What are you inr profession ?*— A printer.
Did yeu ever take off any impressions f^om
a fount of types at Campbdl Donovan's
Ivinting office ?^Yes.
Are you aaeppeentice of his P — ^Yes.
Lord Advocate. — Did you ever take impres-
sions from a fount of types brought from the
sheriff ckrk'e office ?— Yes.
Who brought it to you?--'I went to the
sheriffs office for it
'Whom did you get it from?— From the
sheriff and some other gentlemen.
Is that one ? — ^Yes, we took several.
Is that one of them?— Yes.
Is that your hand-writing ?— Yes.
WilUam Wtttmn sworn.
hfrd Adoocate, — Where do Vou reside? —
In Ihilkeitii. ^
Do you know the prisoner at the bar?— •
Wmoi is hel
That person that is standing up. Do you
miowthat person ?—Noy I cannot positively
say I know him.
Did you ever setf him?— YeS; I once ^w
him at his tiwo house, a psfson they called
Watt.
Is that the person you saw ?— I oaanol say^
I oouki not say upon my oath that is the
person.
Had you ever occasion to see a man of the
name of Watt?— Yes.
When and where dkl you see that per^
SOD ?'~-It was at his own door.
Where is his own doorP-^Why, it is in the
north side of the street.
Is it in £dinbuk*ghf— Tes.
Upon the north ekle of the street ?'**-Yes.
Do you know the North Bridg^e ?<^Yes.
Is it above or bek>w the North Brictoe?-^
It was bekm the North Bridge.
Who sent you there?— Why, I went with
Mr. Downie.
Who is Mr.- Downie ?^-He is a
and goklamith in Edinburgh.
In what part of Edinburgh did Mr. Downie
then reside?^! do not know, but I have
heard it said he lived in the Parltamem
Square.
At what particular time was it you went
with Downie, to the house of tms Watt?
—I couid not reaoember the very partku-
lar time.
Was it not a year ago ?— No, sir, it wis not
B ycnr a^.
Wasitsix months ago?**I do not remember
Was it in winter or summer ? — It was in
summer, some time in the beginning of sum-
mer.
Had you occasion to bear soon afierthsil
time of Welt and Downie being taken into
custody?— Yes.
How long before that time was it ?— I can-
not positively say.
Was h a longtime ?--4 do not remember.
How long IS it since Watt and Downie
were taken mto custody ?-»-I do not know.
Was it Ions afler ?— No.
Would it Ee a month sfter your visit to
Watt, along with Downie ? — I cannot posi-
tively say.
Yon reside at Dalkeith ?— Yes.
Do you remember a foncible regiment
quartered at Dalkeith ?— Yes.
When was it ? — I could not possibly say the
time when they cdme.
Was it a year ago?— No, it was much
about that time.
About the time the regiment of fencibles
were in Dalkeith you went with Downie to
Watt's house ? — ^Much about that time
What regimient wasthaA? Do you know
by whom it was commanded? — It was lord
nopetoun's.
where did you meet with Downie before
you went into Watt's house ?-4 was in the
Lawn Market, and I saw him eo by a shop
door where I then wits and haa heiud of a
Whose shop door? — It was Mr. Rkchic's.
What paper was it you heard of ?— A hand-
btfl about the feneibles.
1S63] S4 GEORGE IH.
Proeeidiagi agaitut JMai WM
[1264
And Downie ptssed the shop door?— >Yes.
What did you say to Downie F — I heard
of the faand-biiT, and l hemg curious to see it,
went and asked Downie if he could satisfy my
curiosity, and show me one.
The witness says, being in the shop of one
Ritchie in the Lawn Mancet, about the time
d lord Hopetoun's fenctbles being at Dal-
keith, he observed Downie pass the shop, and
went to him in order that he might satisfy his
cuiiosit^? — Yes.
But Downie said he could not then P-^Yes,
but he possibly might if I would foUow him.
Did Downie and you go to any place and
where 7 — ^Yes^ he said he was going down the
street, and if I would go down with him he
mi^t possibly get it
Where did he go with you? — ^He went to
the place which he called Mr. Watt's house.
Vfow, sir, when you went to this man's
house of the name of Watt, did you see that
man? — ^Yes, I saw him, Mr. Downie went in,
I followed him ; it was just in the entry ;
whether Watt knew whether I got it or no, I
do not know. Mr. Downie came down m a
few minutes.
. Did you see this Watt at that house ? — Yes,
I saw a man they called Mr. Watt
Then, upon the great oath you have taken,
say whether that is the man you saw, and I
desire you to give an answer? — Upon the
-great oath I have taken, I could not positively
say, it might be the man.
Is it like him ? — I could not remember the
features of ihe man.
What did you do after this, Downie and
you?— Mr. Downie came down the South
Bridge.
Were you present when Mr. Downie put
any Questions to this Mr. Watt?— I do not
^recollect what they said ; he asked about the
news of the day ; or whether he asked Watt
where he could get them, I cannot say.
Did you hear any discourse between Watt
iind Downie about the hand-bill ? whether he
asked Watt if he could furnish him or not
with one ? — I do not know ; Mr. Watt went
in and Downie followed him ;. when X went in.
Mr. Downie said he could not get them
there.
I ask you, did you in this short space of
time while you were with Dowuie, hear that
man Watt open his lips or not? — ^I dare say
he opened his lips.
You dare say I— did he or did he not ?— Yes,
I believe he did.
Then I ask what was the purport of what
he said; did it relate to that hand-bill, the
object of your visit to Mr. Watt ?— Mr. Downie
was commg away, and he asked Watt how he
did, and then Mr. Downie asked me to come
away with him.
You went into this man's house to whom
you were a stranger, for the purpose of getting
a hand-bill relative to the fencibles along with
Downie, who said he would cany you to a
place where you would be satisfied; what
answer did Watt make to yonr question, or
did be say anj thing more after tiwt pee-
liminaiy^ question was put fay Downie? — As
it was a trivial question, I did not take any
particular notice.
It is a trivial question, and therdbre I ask
you, was there any more importaDt questisa
Kut by Downie,— after Downie asked Im
ow be dkl?— >did he not ask Watt wfaette
he could satisfy your curiosity ? — ^I do not ns-
derstand you.
Lcrd PreiidaU, — ^Lord Advocate, 3^00 had
better go on.
Afteryou heard Downie ask this man, Vf^
how he did, did Dowue put any move im-
portant question to Mr. Watt ? — ^No ; I do aol
think he did.
Did he put any question at all to Mr. Wait
further?— No; I do not recollect that be dii
put any.
Did he leave him directly? — He cant
along with me, he viras a little before me.
L^d Prmdent, — Did yott ask Downie if he
had got the hand- bill iifom Watt ? — ^Yes, and
he said he had not
That was the import of your conrersatioB?
— ^Yes,
Was there any direction given to Downie
in your hearing, as to the place where tfae
hand-bill might be got, which you weie ia
search of ?— I did not hear any thing else, bol
Downie asked him how he did.
You came out with Downie ? — ^Yes.
Where did you go to ? — We went to a ahcf
upon the South Bridge belonging to Kennedy
or in the management of him, his name is w
the shop door.
Did yt>u know Kennedy?— I nerer siv
him before.
What conversation passed between you and
Downie, and Kennedy ? — ^Downie went mto
the back shop, I went in, and Mr. JCfniM^tr
gave me some of these things.
Pray were you a member of these clubs at
Dalkeith ?— Yes, I was,
Mr. Anstruther, — You went from Mr. Watt^
to Kennedy's, and Mr. Kennedy gave yda a
parcel? — ^Yes.
How did he give it you ?— He threw it
down upon the floor and said, you had hettv
take it up and say you found it, lor fear any
evil should accrue to any body from it
Now what was in that parcel I — Why a
kind of address- to the fencibles not to go oat
of the country.
What did you do with it? — I gave it to
several of my friends round me.
[An objection arose to his being asked soch
questions, as might criminate himsdfL]
Mr. Afutruther.'^lle need notanawer aqy
that may criminate himself; did you eive
them to a person of the name of SommcrvSk?
— No, sir. ^
Did you give them to a person of thenanr
of Johnston ?
Mr. £rrA»fi^.— -Iconoeive.it to be of aB
ISfifi^
High TrefUfOu
A. D. I794t.
[126(1
lihl»9i tti^ tdteet «ii4 most 8iiMrilu«ii», to re-
fyigltmt M % pmcipl^ of k»w ^at ft witness 13
not to answer a question that mi^ht criquoate
V^il^elfi mthout at tbe imi» ^roe, warnkig
buKi'wliat nu^t or not be a (jiiMtiony where
tjoea Hfi^wmx miffht ciinwMt^ hiinself.
' Mr. AfUtrtiiker. — Most unqestioj(uibiy the
'witness is not bound to answer a question to
«rft«Mitate him^fy and he is to iudge for him-
self whether it does or not, and then he may
apifwwp if he pl«9a^.
Mr. Ergkine. — In the case of lord George
Gordon a p^tsoA was brought as a witoess,
and the question was put to him whether he
^tms a Romlui C^ittM^k, aj;id there was no ob-
jection tQ it from the person himself; but
kijird Kenton ai^i Mr. &rsJw9 objected to the
question, u|)on this ground, that if M^ Hay *
answered i^ he 'would ' snk^t himself to
"pennltirs
Mr. An9$mtkir^Mx. I^rski^^ forgets the
^es^on caiii^ from lord ijjeorge's counsel,
whether the person ¥ras a Roman Catholic
or not; the witness asked whether he was
^Wd to answer the questicp^ the Court told
nim if ihe answer would svbject him to
yW^^Yf^i ^^ ^^. ^^ answer.
Mr. Enkine,'^! care not from whom the
qi^euif)!;^ c^fsip; hefrause yrl^ther from the
crown or tlie prisoner, the pnnciple is just the
Lord PreMi4cnt, — ^I ^sh to kn<^ wljiether
^e \ord Advocate means to pros^cnte this
witness.
Xor<( Mi0eafe.^Vfi\h the exception of
Ddwnie a^d S^Qck, the persons a^nst whom
^W jpf^sl^s, knoyr bills of inaictmeot are
found; [do not mean to bring any prose-
eM^|i^9S ^gm9t other per^^s upon this ac-
count.
' l^E. f rfftfar.—!^ lords, another lord ad-
vocate vaay be appointed to^morrow» and I
Sould be glad to - know whether ano*
er lord advocate, uptwitbst^ding whfU the
^lopmirfible gfeptlem^n 1^^ now 4^^, wopld
xmt be competent to w osecii^te an^ person he
thoufdi^ proper; lord cbief JV^Q^ JefiQuriof
llSobioitea a question of the sune sort, be-
cause it would subject the witness to pc^
l^Atmtruthr^r^l^ is in^^s^ble that it c^n
^ rule 9f law, that a witness i^ prohibited
B^' answering such questions; that would
he to prevent an ^iccomijUce from giving evi*
qeqc;^ m anj[case; hp is i^ lihei% to give
^ evidence if be'bleues.
]Jkib/I)iciidM.—-1^eC9urtbas given warning
ihat he nesd no| g^ve a^y answer that may
qmii^te himself* ^^
M|r. jprj^tiie. — A witness majr answer the
question, but he ougbt to b^ in^qcmed he
* Neithcir ikis stalemept of Mr. Erskine
nor that of Mr. Anstruther is correct. Seethe
fxsmin^tioo of % . Hay on ^ Uial of lord
George Gordon, anil Vol. SI; p. 519.
need not aMwec i^ imbss ht (dbases to crhni^ '
nate himself.
Mr. Anttrutker.-^Mr, Watson, I have told
you that you are not bound to answer any
question that criminates, yourself; you have
told me that you gave one of those papers to
a person 0/ the name of Johnston } — ^Yes* i
Now, answer me, whether Mr. Watt evet
told you, or told Downie, in your hearing,
whether you would set these papers, where
they weie to .be found ; or whether be told
Mr. Downie any thine about any papers int
vour hearing ?-r-No. I do ^ot recollect tluit
he did.
But you went from Watt's house to Ken-
nedy's shop, there what passed you men*
tioned ? — ^Yes. ,
You got a parcel of them ?— Yes.
Now, was there any other paper? Do you
know a committee, called a Committee of
Ways and Means ? — No.
Were you a member of the convention ?---*
Yes, I was.
Were you a secretary to the Friends of the
People at Dalkeitli ? — I was secretary once.
William Johnston sworn.
Mr. AnUruther.'-^Do you know a'person of
the ni^me of William Watson ? — ^Yes.
Is he the oaan that was here just now ? — Yes.
Did you see him in the next room ?— Yes.
I^d you ever receive a printed paper from
him ? — ^Yes. f
What did you. dQ with it?— I giive it to
James Sandilands.
Do you remember what it related to in
ejper^l ? — I think it w^ an address to the
Fencibies or something of Chat nature.
^X wb9t period of timo was this ? — ^I can-
not tell the dme; it was probably in the
Spring Qf the year; I cannot recollect the
tim^-
Was it about the time that lord Hopctoun's
Fencibl^ were i^t Dalkeith?— Yes. I dare
say it wa3.
C^ yoH lecpUect where the paper was
da^4?*--I tjhi^k DAind^.
Jemei Sftndilandt sworn.
Iktiwi kopw ^> pflrspnof the nameof WII«
liam Johnston? — Yes, ^, I do.
Did you see bim IQ the other room? — ^Yes,
m I di4.
Did you ever at aiy time receive a^y printed
p«>er trom him?'-Yes; I did.
Wbe9 ?— I do 9fiX perfectly recollect the
time.
About what time was it ?— About the month
of April or Mi^.
Wm it a( the tlmo the Fencibies went
through Dalkeith ?— Yes. It was about thai
What sort of a paper was it?-— I do not
know. I never looked at the paper ; we had
«ome coQYersation about it.
What was the conversation . between you
about?— One William Johnston asked me if
4 M
1839] S4 6E0RG£ m.
ProeeMm iUfmrnti Roieri WmH
Had 3roa any oUier reuoB?— No.
But uW ycHi bad been befbrathe seeralariet
of state you took notes?— No I never at-
tended them at all afterwards.
Mr. tfiMit&oa— Had you any pther motire
in tainng Uiose notes f — ^None at all, but only
to speak to the point; I had no inters in K
but inclination.
Edward Goding sworn.
Mr. Daiulaf— What is your {irolessiont — ^I
am clerk to Mr. Wickham.
Who is Mr. Wickfaam?— Mr. Wkkham is a
maffistrate in London.
Were you present at the meeting of the
London Corresponding Society at Cli^ Farm
in Apiil last? — Yes, I was.
Did you hear any resolutions read there f
—I did.
By whom? — A man, I was informed whose
same was Kichter.
Look at these, and see if they are the same
^u haie heard read?— -No, these are not the
same.
Look at them.— These appear to be the
same resolutions ; I had a copy similar to dus
iCherwards at one of those divisions.
Who gave you a C(K>y ? — I had it from that
division from one Hillyard.
You attended those divisicms afterwards?—-
I have,^ir.
What was the st^rle of conversation genet-
rally at those divisions? — ^In general there
was less said at the divisions than in private
conversations, but on the night foUowine the
14th of April it was the meeting at Cnalk
Farm? on l^esday after I had attended one
of Uie divisions — I heard it was their inten-
tion to arm in the same manner as they
had done in Paris.
Repeat that again. — I understood tiiat there
was a convention to be called, and it was the
design of the society to arm themselves for
the purpose of protecting that assembly in the
flame manner the French Assembly have been
protected by the people of Paris.
Cross-examined by Mr. HamiUon,
Where was it you heard these conversa-
tions ? — At the house of Holt, vho keeps a
liouse in Northampton Street.
How maoy might be present? — ^I cannot
tell exactly ; there might t>e thirty, there w^
BO si^ conversation as that at the general
meetine of the division at Chalk Farm : it was
the fol&wing day after the meeting or Chalk
Farm.
It was a meeting in private, of two or three
people t — No, it was a regular meeting of the
eleventh division of the London Correspond-
ing Society.
Were you served with any writ to give your
evidence here? — [No answer.}— Have you
been subpoenaed r — I did not recdve any
thing, I came down at the desire of the soU-
icitor of the Treasury.
J^ow long were you a laember ofthisso-
dety?*-! hmrmmm m membertiieday sftgjh
meeting of Clialk Fann.
What wma jour intention of bdonw i
it ? — It was on account of the corioas n
guage I heard heM at Chalk Fann.
Were you not a memlier of that son^k
fore you were at Chalk Farm?— No^Ilin
aot.
How came jou to be there?— I met wA
a friend of that aocuety I knew, I deah inteob
with him, and I was so taken with tbe dis-
course of the meeting, I intended somedigi
before to be a member of the society.
Mr. Erskine, — Did he tell you tbej ImU
constitutional language ? You say, tbeyhM
curious language, and you were so cbDoe^
you intends to belong to the society?
MT.Hamiton. — Was it vour intentioo to p
into the society, to see what they faadtoaj?
—I did not Sir.
When did you leave the society ?--Thelfl«
I paid was up at Midsummer. I did not !!•
tend their society afterwards.
Did you give information relative to ik
proceedings going on there? — I meDtinieJ
tbe circumstance to Mr. Wickhani; as I
thought it my duty.
How frequently have you been at tbo* 8»»
cieties, and how often did you give infonia-
tion of what passed ? — I cannot exsct^^y
I generally attended the divisions once a veeL
You gave information of what took pbcef
—Yes.
Did he prescribe any rule of condod 1i»
you, how to act in future ? — He did nol »y
any thing particulariy, whether I ''■^ ]|? fj*
tinue in it or not; he observed, so fer, rftneR
was any thing dangerous going ibrward,! «*
to communicate it to him JF of a daDgeiwo g
dencv. I should not have dgne it, if w 'JJ
not desired me. I had not an idea when Id^
went there J should meet with any tw^
that kind; I was informed I should meet wnB
improvement, and there were books to »
read, and I went there for the piirpw* *
spending an hour or two of an evening.
Alexander A^ckeum sworn-
Were you a member of the British Coo*
vention ? — Yes. l *-frt.
I believe you were secretaiy or s™''**^!
tary?— I was assistant-secretary to Mr. ao^
ving.
. Did you write the minutes of that convet
tion ? — A considerable part of them.
Witt you look at that paper, Mr. A'K*^
and tell me whether the bulk of it » jw
hand-writipg?— The bulk of it is not ^
hand-writing, a great nuiny pages ^^ ^^
my hand-wnttog, part of it wrote by ^"**
people. Yes,
Did you ever see that paper before rr-'PJ
I saw it before in this court, or tbe juswo^
court, and the British Convention. . ^
Does that paper, as &r as it is of your DW"^
writing, contain an account of what P*^*^
the British Ck»iiyeBtton?-. I certBio9<^
1241] Jbir Hif^ TreoMmu
have made maiiT ndstekes In taking down bj
hearsay, but to the best of my knowledge, it
contains the truth.
Who was the secretary ? — Bfr. William
Skirving.
Did any body assist you in taking those
minutes? — ^Yes, several people appointed by
the convention.
Look through the minutes, and tell if
^oii know any other person's hand-writing
besides your own? — ^I do not recollect any
other persons hands except Mr. George Ross.
Lately of the Gazetteer-office ?— Yes.
Was Mr. Callender a member!— Yes.
Do you recollect any motion made by him f
— I recollect several motions, but do not re-
collect any put down in the minutes.
Do you i-ecoUect any amendment made to
these motions ? — I remember well an amend-
ment made on a motion of Callender's, which
caused a good deal of difference of sentiment,
and a great many different motions.
Do you remember that motion being sub-
mitted to a committee ? — ^Yes.
Do you remember the members ? was Sin-
clair.one ? — ^Yes, he was.
Look at that. What is that ?— Mr. Sin-
clair's amendment of Callender's motion.
Reads, ^ That the convention considering the
calamitous consequences of any act of the legis-
lature which may tend to deprive the whole or
any part of the people of their undoubted right
to meet either by themselves or by delegation,
to discuss any matter relative to their com-
mon interest, whether of a public or private
nature; and holding the same to be totally
inconsistent with the first principles and
safety of society; and also subversive of our
known and acknowledged constitutional li-
berties, do hereby declare, before God and
the world, that we shall follow tbe wholesome
example of former times^ bjr paying no regard
to any act which shall militate against the
constitution of our country, and shall conti-
nue to assemble and consider of the best
means by which we can accomplish a real
representation of the people and annual elec-
tion until compelled to desist by superior
force.
** And we further resolve, that the first no-
tice given for the introduction of a convention
bill, of a similar tendency to that passed in
Ireland since the last session of their parlia-
ment ; the suspension of the Habeas Corpus
act, or the act for preventin|; wrongous im-
prisonment in North Britam, ana aeainst
undue delays in trial, which will render all ^
the laws for the protection of our lives and
our liberties nugatory, and as some have
avowed their intention of introducing| a mo-
tion for tbe repeal of one of them, or m case
of an invasion, or the admission of any fo-
reign troops whatsoever into Great Britain or
Ireland ; all or any of those shall be a signaJ
to the several delegates to repur to such
places as the convention shall appoint, and
•even members shall have power to declare
^ cooventioD permaseDt
A. D. 17M.
[124S
^ Resolved, that the delegates to anyqpn-
Tention, meeting under any of those calami-
tous circumstances, shall immediately repair
to the place of sittings and there continue
until their number be twenty-one and then
proceed to business.
''The convention doth therefore resolve,
that each delegate immediately on his return
home, do convene his constituents and ex-
plain to them the necessi^ of electing a de-
lepte or delegates, and of establishing a fund
without delay agunst any of those emergen-
cies, for his or their expenses ; and that uiey
do instruct the said delegate or delegates, to
hold themselves ready to depart at an hour's
warning.''
I do not recollect ever having read that
paper before, I certainly have seen it, be-
cause my own hand-wnting b on the back
of it.
Mr. SoUciior General.'^'Do you recollect a
resoludon having passed of that purport
in the convention? — Some amendment of
Callender's motion did pass, but whether that
15 it I cannot say.
Do ^ou know whether it was entered in
the mmutes of tbe convention ? — ^I am not
Whose hand-writing is that?— -It is Mr.
Ross's.
Reads, ** Citizen Sinclair read the amend*
ments upon citizen Callender's motion, as
agreed upon by the committee, and it was
agreed upon the motion of '
That the house should resolve itself into a
committee for its mature consideration. In
the course of conversation, citizen Brown
gave a history of the Habeas Corpus act;
after an excellent discussion of the question,
pertinent remarks and amendments, the con*
vention was resumed, and the whole, as
amended, was read over.''
Then, ail that appears from the minutes as
they stand is — ^there is a resolution of all the
members standing upon their legs, which le*
solution is blank ?
Witneu. The reason that page is left
blank, is owing to my coming in at that very
time; I remember the circumstance, it was
left that I might fill it in, if not taken notice
of by the other clerks, and therefore it does
not appear in the minutes ; that is the truth.
Mr. Antiruther.'^ThdX motion was handed
to you as sub*secretary by citizen Sinclair, and
you endorsed it upon the back ? — I did.
Were you present when the provost of
Edinburgh came into the British Convention ^
"■"Yes.
Did he disperse that convention ?— Yes.
Where did you go to after that?— I was
told that the convention went down to some
place in the Canongate.
Where did vou go?-^I went home.
Wjiere did the convention meet afterwards?
-—I was not present at the next meeting.
Do*you know Mr. Watt the prisonet at the'
bar there?-— Yes.
1071] 34 6EO&GBIU.
flamationrun? by «bf4 mthwlf 9r ifbat
person was to sign it ? — ^No^ I hetrd of no
person that was to figa it*
Kow, at the time when this pkn was tlw
^l^tofcoQYefsatioo, or read inthecom-
mitt^ was any thing said about araung the
committee? — ^No.
Was any thing said about addraaaing the
king? — Yesy there was upob the other, side,
t cannot be positive.
What was the nature of the address to the
Icing ?-->The nature of the addrtts to the king
was thus: to disinisfi his Bainiiton^ to put aa
end to the present war, or to meet bad oonae-
quencesy or expect bad codsec^upace^.
Jury. — The witness aays he heasd nothing
about arming, we have not heard how they
were to attack the soldiers.
Was there a^y ^ueetioa made about the
arms to be used ?^-No^
At any otfier time had you conversation
with Watt about procuring arms, or did he
tal^e any means ? — I never anew that he did,
or that It was in conversation till he Asked me
to go to Robert Orrook, a smith iu the Dean,
what was the, purpose? — He did not men-
tion the purpose to me, I went with him^ as
he asked me the ikvour to go with him.
What conversation had he with him? — ^He
wished hin^ to make some j^es, and fiobert
Orrock drew a model of a pdce upon the tabi^,
and Mr. Wajtt asked him to ifork asJiA as he
could, for he had 4,000 to CM^nd to Perth, be-
ttdes what he wanted to dtstribiAB about
Bdinbuish, and ordered Qrreck to be busv,
and as fast as he brought them in he flhould
have the money.
What did he aay?-^He said he had 4,000 to
send to Perth, besides what he had to distri*
bute about Edinburgh.
Was it Orrock that drew the drawing of
the pike or Watt ?— It was Qnrpck.
. Were you eveir back at Orrock'a house
again except that time ? — ^No.
Do vouknow any thing of Orrock making
the pikes ? — I heard him get the order, I ne
ver saw him working at one of them, only
one day I was going up to the Dean, and we
had some other business with him, a man
and we were standing at the door of the tmid^
dvy I saw a roan worung at a tiling similar to
this, and lord Swinton*s servant asked the
lad what it was, what was the use of it, and
he told him U wi|s to put oo ^ g^e.
Did you ever see any of them upon any
other occasion than this ^ — No.
Did ^ou ever see. ^y of them in Watt's
possession ? — Yes.
Are you acquainted with John Fairley ? —
No, I am not acqi^ainted with him*
Did you ever see him ?-— Yea.
A Wright ?-7-Yes-
Did you ever see him in your committee of
Ways and Means? — Yes, .
whatdidyou understand to bctbe business ?
«^ What I understood .wq% he had been stnt
to the west country — before I saw hin^ I
Proeeedkigt igaimi Rmtnt WaU (MR
uiidefsieed %tet. I>^ Ml lieco mi;I»^«H|
but what his orden weretothewestliiii
know.
Had you any reuoa io know it}-^4ist11
I heard himsett •
Tbatwaa QR#tt bis rcAum ?— Yes*
Mr. Afutn£ker.—Wms Watt presoit-Ta
When he ([Fairlej) fotumed fium tfovH,
and made h^ rafiort to the CeaMmUct i
Ways And MeaiM^ vbat dOd he «(]-[>>
S*ve you but a very small detail— he >«lh
id been to viiata ViBSft number of tikee8;lfc
Watt took a note of them down upcn fip^
I think of the pbU:«8; ttee waft Qfim
fenr, Falkirk, JLiky^ Stirling 8t Niai^
KickhitulWch^ Gampeie^ Glasgow, Psuiy.
Was there any toing particular msrtMj
with respect fe Paiaic^ or the oth«n.^
said that Paisley wa3 ina alileof gnstn*
ncss.
Did he mention any tlung about vtsj w
pkce?— No. ....
What did you madefeitaiid by thor b«
in raadineas?— I cannot teii whatbi9««B
were, I do not knofw whM they werfc
Mr, Antiruther.—Did you ew lwi»!
other conversation abamt armiag f— Na !•
not remember ^y. _ _ ^ ,. ^ * ^
You d^proved of it P— Yes, I did;
^en that paper was first rei^l^P^J^
agreed to any thing tending to disttn •
peace, to tendmg to shad &e bkMid sf tj
countrymen. . .j.
Jaiy— Did you thihk somcthM rf Ig
nature was propK>sed?--Tfae P^P^JSJ* ^
read in my presence led me to think *^"
my w^ opinion. ;. ^l.
Mr. -dnj^ratAcr.— What business wwtfw
Committee of Ways and Means met iipw»
night Mr. Watt proposed this P^Jj'^S
met upon no other business^^A^J rSJa
Sub-Committee was appointed, they www
meet every Tuesday mght. . -^ ^
Did not they do something that nigWF ^
he read tliat paper?— O aye. ^ _ ., ^
Did he not write some letter r-I*"*
recollect it. • t^utu
Do you remember seeing anjr fowa^
signed by Hardy in the Committee ?-Wft
Then you do not know the «n?^'*^^
did vou ever see a printed tetter »" *^^*?!^
mittee of Ways and Means ?— Yes, I ^^
the Committee, I heard it read ia the Lobk^
tee of Ways and Means. ^gi
Was Mr. Watt present?— He ^ f^
when the answer was wrdte. , uj-.
Who wrote it ?— He wrote it P?"*^^-JJJ34
self, and aflw he wrote it, be said "® , hk/
read it over a^in, and he wouid <''^'^ !1| '%
I never saw it more; I have "^^^^jjif
since :— 1 think i\ is veiy dmflar to ^^
bsfore. ' ,-^
Have you heard of any set of t^^^t^
collectors ?— I do not know whst they '*'*'
dov I oaDBot give any posittv^ mswer^ ^
Where did you hear il?--.Ii ^ *
Conumttee of Union.
LSTSQ
fi%* ZVmiqiu
. Iiard •jMBMtte^.a&lftfl W|fl p^«fM&l \vfeen
you iMttrd ^ImIm penoii9«dled eolltscUn nett*
tioned ? — I cannot say.
, De you know of a^jr lEodney that was col-
lected by the Comnkitte^ ef Ways Md Means ?
-^Yes, thte aoeiet^ of the Wate^^Leilftgave
me 15s. to |Miy inta thte Cokumitvee^ fdr thc^
wer^ of o^ibhrn with «ie, as I sud l>efore, it
was to go for the benefit of Mrs. SkBh^g
under tiib direction of thai Commitvee^ I ^
cdliect hdtte but that and a bill of ibL they
itmived fretn Perth.
For wK&t purpose was thM money? — ^I stijp^
jsosfe tluB Comittitli^ ^tf^^ lo look into the ar-
ccmastmiieeB of Mfs:^kirrhie»ahd giVe her the
xnonev as they thought pruoent.
* Dra you evet see & printed t>&per called Ftin-
deskieutal Priniety»les ?— Yes.
Was that the principles of your Committee?
— The Committee ? I ike^et saw them take it
up.
' Was it p^t)duced in the Comhiittee ? — Tes.
By whom ?— It was produced by Mr. Watt.
It was pTtKtuced by Mr. Watt in the Com-
mittee, you then being present ? — Yes.
Now IS that the paper ? — That is the rery
IMifver I have seeh the)re produced by Mr.
Watt. .
' [Here he was shown the papers entitled Fun-
damental Fnnciples.]
I Mr. Bontkome sworn.
'.— Whatare you?— A teacher.
Now take your own time— I believe you were
member of some committee of the Friends of
the Peopk in the beginning of this year ? — I
I believe vou thought it right to come to a
leaolution to with£aw yourself from that
committee ?-— Yes.
About what time was it you formed thai
resolution tD withdraw yourself? — Perhaps
about (I cannot posiUWly say^ but perhaps
about) the 17th of April.
I do not want you to be particular as to a
day — was Mr. Watt a member of that conl-
mittee?~rWfoich committee?
That committee you determined to with-
draw yourself fnom P—- He Was.
What was the name of that committee?—
The Sub-Committee.
' Had it any other name ? — ^Kot that I know
ofy I understood it had another name^ but I
did not hear it.
what Was the other bAme ?— I have heard
it since I was in confinement, it was called
the Committee of Ways and Means.
Have you ever heard of a committee of
Union ?->-Yes.
Who chose tb^ fiub-Oemknittee ?— The com-
mittee of Union.
Who were the member df that Sub-Com-
mitiee?— Mr. A&tehesoi^, Mr. Stock, Mr. Burke
or Burt, I am not certain which, Mr. ftobert
Walt, I think, Mr. David Ddwnie, Artftm*
M'fiwan.
A. D. MM* [IS74
Lori Jialtkt Ok^*^ls that theRbbert
Waitf i^^fThe Witikese looking at him) Yes,
and myself.
Now, Mri Bonthorne, had any tiding passed
in that committee that induted you to come
to a resolution to withdraw yourself firoih it?
•>->I thoileht so, mjr lord.
Now wnat was it that passed in that coni-*
ihlttleef— There wete ^ifierenfc thihgs Uiat
passed in that odtAmittee, that I could not pre*
sently say.
Did you ever hear Mr. Watt, in that com*
Aiittee, ptopose any plan ?-*-^No, I never heattt
him propose any plan.
Did Vou ever near Mm re^ any plan?—
I have heard him read a paper, my lord.
Now, what was tliat paper ?-— I cannot say
what that paper waft, it is a considerable time
since.
lArd Preiidim^.— Hiecollect the substance
of it as well as you catt.'^My lord, if yt>u wll!
ptbaae to ask ktte a question about it, I will
answer.
Mr. Anttruthtr, — ^I rather wish you to re-
collect yourself? — I thought my oath re^
qwred me to answer questions.
How much do you remember of the purport
of that paper?— I remember veiy little more
abeiit it, necause upon the hearing of it, t
was in such confiision, U has cut aSmy re-
collection.
What was the purport of ttiat paper?— I
know nothing what the purport was.
What was it, as near as you can recollect?
— I can say very little about it.
. XordTAtfooccie. — ^You are under an oath to
God to tell th^ tnith, and nothing but the
truth, if you conceal the truth you are criitai-
nal.
Lord Pretident. — ^Did that paper say any
^ing iabout the Friends of the People irising;
upon any occasion-, and to do what? — ^No,
it I recollect, it rather went upon a supposi-
tion that such a thing could be done.
What Was it that could be done ? — My lord,
I looked upon the whole as if it had been a
kind of pnrcnzy, or something of that kind,
and it stnick me with such confusion.
Lord Pretident. — ^You ate bound to tell'
whatever it was. — Yes, as soon as t can Ire-
collect it.
Was there any thine about sddngthe Cas-
tle in it?-^If 1 mistake not, my lord, there
was.
Surely you can tell whether there was or
not?— 1 tnink there was.
What was it?— ^Nothing at all that I can
recollect.
Lord Pre»i<fen*.— It is my duty to tell you,
sir, that you are in very great danger. Every
body must be sensible that you heard soiUe*
thing, and can tell something, and you are
bound to tell it. I must out you upon your
guard. The Court will take it up. Did that
paper contain any thine;, br did it not, about
seizing the Castle r — I think s6, my lord.
What did it Say upoil that subject ?— I can-
iUT] S4 GEORGE IIL Proeee&tg$ ^priM Robert WaU
jretr wm this only meetiiig you had with
Wattf— Whea the oommiitees wore first ap*
poiDtedy
About what period was that ?— About the
tmiuning of January ?
Mr. iifiif rWAer. -— Were you never at a
meeting of the Sub-comroittee, but at the be-
finning of January? — ^To the best of my
nowMge and belief, I never was.
Had vou any conversation with the mem-
bers of that committee respecting the business
that was to oome before them r— *Not that I
recollect
You had better recollect yourself ?— No.
Were you ever in Mr. Watt's house ? — ^Yes.
Had you ever any conversation with Watt
in his house? — Yes.
Was it before or after the meeting of that
committee ? — ^I cannot say.
What conversation was it you had with Mr.
Watt ? — Upon the news of the day.
What was the news of the day r--I cannot
recollect ; is a man obliged to recollect an ac-
cidental conversation over a dish of tea a year
after?
Do you recollect or not recollect ?-*! do
not recollect.
And you say so upon your great oath ?— I
certainly do.
Was any thine said about arming ? — I be^
lieve that was about the time lord Stanhope's
speech was made in the House of Peers.
Lord Chief JBaron. — I wish you to say no-
thing acainst the prisoner that is not founded
in hcifimt^ sir, if it be founded in &ct you are
called upon^ and you are now iix the presence
of Gody to answer the truth, let the conse-
quence be what it may. I ask you to the
best of vour memory had you any conversa*
tion witn the prisoner about preparing arms,
or an V thing to that purpose when you were
with him ?'---My lord,neither your lordship nor
any person in this court need inform me of
the nature of an oath ; I am not an atheist,
not one of French principles. I know we
shall all stand up at the great day of God,
and this oath warns me to beware of saying
what is not the truth, and whether it hurts
roe or the prisoner at the bar, I shall spoJc
the tnith ; if you will take the trouble to re-
peat the question, I will answer it.
Lord Chief Baron. — ^Do you remember when
you were with the prisoner having any con-
versation witK him about preparing arms or
using arms? if you recollect any thmg, how-
<ever trivial it may be, you are t>ound to speak
it out. — I can recollect none, not a single cir-
cumstance, but that Mr. Watt said something
of importance would soon be upon the%arpet.
Nothing mentioned about arms ? — ^No, only
about lord Stanhope's speech, and the news
of the day.
Did you see any arms^ any pikes, or any
things of that sort in his housed — ^I never
did.
Did he mention any thing of any pikes
being in his possession?— He never did.
[i'946
Mr. Jmfntf Aer.— You have told the Cost
and me that you have had conversation titli
Mr. Watt upon the news of the day ; it isia.
possible for me or the Court to know vlut
tliat conversation was, if vou will not dexxk
the purport of it ; but tell me what conveni>
tion you had with Mr. Watt upoa the ocft
sion?
Ifi^fiect.— It is a very strange auestion.
What was the news of the aa^Mtwa
lord Stanhope's speech in the House «f
Lords.
What was said about it ?— That certiin^
lord Stanhope had stood up for the nsMs«i'
Britons, which had been too much mss^
iipon.
What more? — I cannot recollect
Upon what occasion was it that W&tt aid
sometiiing of importance was upon the cv-
pet?— It IS very extraordinary thatsucbi
tea-table discourse should come in qoeslioo.
Did he mention the carpet, that sQmetbiai
of importance was upon the caipet?-(^
words to that purpose, is it possible for b mai
to remember every word ? I have told ynik
word carpet, but that perhaps was not ion
by Mr. Watt.
Before whom was it to be brought im
the carpet /—Before the public, hefoie tb
world certainly.
Who was to bring it before the world?-!
cannot answer.
Lord Pretidemt^The words I taok dowa
are, that Watt said something of iHi|Wtew
would soon be upon the carpet, or woidsw
tiiat effect ; did you say so ? — Yes.
Mr. Jtutruther.^1 think you abseDW
yourself from the meeting of the comnutttt'
I want to know what was your ^^^
it?— Here again my opinion is asked j p
your question ae^in. ^^
You absented yourself from the <n**J2
of the committee,! want to know youri«»
for absenting yourself from that committW'
Lord Preudent.—The question is, what »»
son was there for you to 'c*^®*^^ j ,! ^
cessai;y, upon a trial for life and dcatoi »
state It ? .
Mr. Anstnaher.-'Staie the reason wtj»
leavins; that committee.— I heard, in ^
or eight days afterwards, there ^^
something important done, or **^.!2,
publicly. I heard there was to be ae^ J'r
ness before the committee, and from tM»»^
forward I never attended the comnuttfi««
You heard from Mr. Watt, ^batim^'^J
business was soon to be uoon the c«rp^ |^
you heard a report out of doors, ^\^^ti)e
portant secret business was to be "^'L..
committee?— I heard that, andthcconw*
tion I had with Mr. Watt was thiec n^*^
aficrwards i.»^
Witii whom had you the conversation i*«J
the secret business, that was to cotoe f^
the committee?— I could not tell J<h> " '^^
life were depending upon it.
12491
fut ttigh Tteatoti*
A. 0. I7W.
QI250
!>• yoa 8\(rear tbat?~I do.
You swear that you do sot know the per->
sons from whom you beard thai secret bu8»-
j&ess was to come before the committee ^—
I solemnly swear that.
Did you ever ask any of the members of
Hie committee whether that was true or not ?
•i— I never did. I have ahready assigned my
reason-; I wished, whatever concern I haa
with public reform, it should be open and
lair, and not secret business.
How did you know there was to be secret
business, if not informed by the members of
it ? — I took it for granted.
Court. — Did . you ask Mr. Watt what that
butineas of importance was? — No.
Did you understand it from him ? — I did
not.
Lord Prettdeii/.— You said first that some
aecret business was to be before the temmit-
tee, and then said you heard it out of doors ?
—Yes.
I think you said afterwards you heard it
from one of the committee ? — 'So,
Mr. An$trtUher.—^Then I desire you to an-
swer nre upon oath, and take care of the an-
awer you give this question, whether you have
not given a different account of your conver-
sation with Watt^ and your reason for leaving
the committee* from what you have now
g'ven ? — I cannot recollect, but this is the so*-
mn truth I declare upon oath.
Answer me this question : Do yon swear
you never gave a different account of this con-
trersation at another place?— To the best of
my recollection I did not, and consistent with
truth I coukl not, because it is not true ; if I
was to be guillotined for it I wiil stand by
that.
Mr. Ertkine. — ^In arguing every branch of
this cause, we must feel ourselves under very
great difficulties, because we are on the in-
stant obliged to resort to a law, of which, till
this prosecution, we knew nothing. The
question put by Mr. Anstruther is undoubtedly
not competent by the law of Scotland ; and
accordingly we are told every day, in the
court of justiciary, if we attempt to shake the
testimony of a witness, by showing a discre-
pancy on former occasions, that such ques-
tions are not j^rtinent to the issae, as he has
bound himself by his solemn oath to speak
the troth. My acquaintance with the law of
England has been short and imperfect, but I
am satisfied it concurs with our*s.
Mr. Antituiher — I understand Mr. £r-
skine's objections to be grounded on the law
of Scotland, by which I understand a witness
has a right to have his examination before the
magistrate destroyed before he gives his evi>
dence. By the law of EnglaiitT he has no
such right ; he may be indicted for perjury
upon i^ and I have a right to make use of
every information I can gain from it.
lird Frttideni, — ^I c^ainly was under a
difficulty with respect to this matter; for
judging by our own pnctice, I should have
VOL. xxiir.
eoMeived ft to be as Mr. Erakine has stated
it. I believe the practice in England to b^
different in this particular; but I wish the
king's counsel to considery whether it would
not ne light to abstain from questions which
are exceptionable areonfing to our ideas ?
Mr. AnUmther. — I have stated what I take
to be the law of En^and, but shall implicitly
follow your lordship's wishes upon the sub^
ject. I must say, this witness nas given his
evidence in a manner that does not entitle
him to much attention from the jury.
Mr. Baron Aiorioa.— In general, no witncsa
is attempted to be discredited by his own
oouBSeL
Mr. Anttrmthtr,-^! thought it necessaiy
to bring him to this point, that the jury might
see exactly the character of the witness.
Mr. HamiUan, — I submit it is not compe-
tent for Mr. Anstruther to speak upon this
matter now; the lord advocate wiU sUmup
the evidence upon the part of the crown, but
now he is anticipating a part of the charge,
and stating that toe witness is not to be at«
tended to. '
CauH. — If you can say he has given any
thing favourable Co you, you may have tlie
benefit of it; but, says Mr. Anstruther, I
iMive broueht him forward to prove my in*
dictment, but from the manner h^ gives his
evidence, I place little reliance upon nim. .
Mr, Anitrutker, — ^The counsel for thepri«
soner are entitled to make an^ use they think
proper of the evidence of this witness, but 1
shall not desire thejurvtopay much attention
to any thing he has said, unless he is confirmed
by other witnesses. We shall now read part
of the minutes of the British Convention.
L&rd AdvQcate.^lt might save the Court
and jury some time, if it was reserved for me
to quote from the minutes of the British Con-
vention, those parts which appear to me to
establish a charge, as I am to speak last.
Coar^. — If you are to speak last, and do
not now tell the jury what you mean to lay
hold of, you have an advantage; you have
proved these minutes to be me minutes of
the conveotiony and you ought to read
them.
[The clefk of the Arraigns reaJ the paper.]
Id Day$ Sitting, 19tk Nao. 1793.
Mr. Dundoi. — ^There was a previous meet*
ing before. Look farther, you will see Mr.
Margarot moved, " That previous to publish-
ing an address to the public, a committee be
forthwith appointed to consider the means,
and draw up the outlines of a plan of general
union and co-operation between the two na-
tions, in their constitutional pursuit of a tho-
rough parliamentary reform^ which was una-
nimously agreed to.''
*
Georgg jRotf sworn, examined by ^e
Lord Advocate.
Look at those papers; do you see your
hand-writing there ?— There is part of mind
4 L
1875] 34 GE0B6B m.
JVvQMflfiMi MMii Moiirt W§U
ptn
pol reooUecCy ay kid, p«tioulai|j whit it
aaidy I juti looked upon Una tuppotition,
that it could be done.
By whom ? — ^Bty a ninnbery if they could
be collected; it was upon asuppoution that
a number could be ooliected for the purpose.
A number of whom?— A number of per-
Did you fiuppoee this meant the Friends of
the People ? — I suppose so, my lord.
Did It say any thiitt about seisiiM^ sur-
rounding, or attackincc the soldiers in tne Cas-
tle ? — I do not recoUect any thing of that
kind.
Did it say any thing about lighting a fire,
or doing anv thing in order to draw the sol-
diers out of the Castle ? — I am not certain
whether there was not some expression about
the register office.
Abmitwhat? — ^About raising an alarm by
fire at the r^ister*office.
For what purpose? — ^I mippose it was to
bring the soloiers from the Castle.
And in case they should be brought from
the Castle, what do you suppose was then to
happen? — ^I suppose to take possession of the
Castle.
Did vou suppose any attack would be made
upon the soloiers themselves, or any attempt
to take possession of them?— -I do not re-
member any thing of that
Was there any thing said about the lord
provost or the judges, or any body in power ?
—I recollect no persons.
Was there any description of persons, such
as jud^ and magistrates ? — I oo not recol-
lect any thing of it
Was there any thins said about banks?—*
Ye& perhaps, my lora, the word buxk or
bulks was in it
What expression was in it? — ^I think about
seising the bank or banks.
Was there any thing about seizing the ex-
cise-office?— I am not certain but there was.
Mr« AtutnUhtr. — Was there any thing
about possessing themselves of places w
tnist ? — I am not positive of it
What was the general design of the plan
or paper ? — ^I cannot say, my Im.
What was it that frightened you so much ?
—The appearance of it in generaL
The appearance of what?— Of a paper read.
What sort of a paper?-— A paper that has
been just now quoted.
Lord Advocate, — That was the thing fright-
ened him so much, and induced him to leave
the committee.
Mr. Anstruther. — ^What were the contents
of that paper f-—I have endeavoured to an-
swer the different questions.
Was the purport of that paper to seize the
Castle?— That I believe I said.
Was it to seize the people of note or name
about Edinburgh ? Was it to seize any body ?
—Not one, that I recollect.
What were they to do?— Indeed I know
not, it struck me with such a confusion, it
put me from my recollection altogether.
WasaaylbiMrsMil
or about the bailbea or aMCpstailBsl^
Any thing about officers f— No.
Aiur mention of lord justice ckdi?-4Ioi
not that I recollect, I bttiefe the wbokojf!!
went upon a supposition, if sudi a mts
were or could be ooUeded.
What were tfa^ to do ?— Those tUi|^ fa.
meriy mentioned.
Do I understsnd you ridit,tliitlk|li
was, that if a oartain number coold be d
lected, th^ were to seiae those pison Ita
have beim mentioned ^-^ undenlood n.
Do you recoUect any thing of wfafll <k
numbers were?— No^ I do not molkt^
number.
Do yon know whether they were kfti
small numbers?— I do not recollect tbeaa
bers.
Were they large numbers or snisDn
bers ? — I cannot give the numbers.
Did this plan lOarm you, or did it aolM
alarmed me.
Now, tell me what it was that sknsei js
in that plan?— The whole of xt,ss 6r»l
understood or heard.
What did you do upon reading that idn!
— ^As fitf as I recollect, there wss spetf
that showed an opposition to it
Who was that?— Arthur M'Ewsn sM
an opposition to it
You agreed with Arthur M<E«sbM»
peated the words, ** No, no,** I think flo.
Then the pUn you said "no,oo''^i"
the same pUm that Arthur M'Bwsd teo»
iiom? — It was the same paper.
What was the business of the Coo^
of Ways and Means ? — The Su^CoiiwiU«»
you mean.
Yes. — ^As fiur as ever I undexstood^iJ'J
just to transact the business of the Fncntss
the People. ^
Was It to collect money or was it ^-"jf^
my lord, I dkl not understand it was tocowa
money.
Do you know anything thatwsswnj*
or read in that committee of a I^P?.^
was afterwards printed?— Name it,vr
Qaied a circular letter?--! could sot flji
unless I saw it
(The circular letter from the CommjtW*
Ways and Means shown bim-j
Yes, my lord.
jdnL
You have seen that paper ?— Yes, *»/ «^
itJ^thinklto^e'^
Where did ^ou
it in manuscript . , jw.
Where did you see it in mamtfcnP*^"^
haps in the Gazetteer-office. / a^
Did you ever see it at a m««^|J*?
committee ?— It is the committee I *?Ju-gi
Whose office did you see it inM^^.
know I ever had it in my hand, I w**!**^
when it was read. , g.^v
Who wrote it?— I think it was Mr. ^^s
I ask if the place where the amD^^"^
was in the Gazetteer-office ?— Yes, it ^
Jbr tfigh Treatm.
9ir[
It WB9 not there that the' other paper
rzB read ?-^What do you allude to ?
The paper that frightened you so much. —
t was not there, it was in Mr. Watt*s house.
Lard President ^WhnX did Watt do with
t after he had read it, and you said, no, no —
rhat did Watt say ? — ^If I rememher right,
le rose from his chair, and put into a press.
IMd you and M'Ewan come away upon
hat ? — We did not till we j^aited.
What did you do when you went home ?
IxfTd Advocate.— Yon sav you were very
nuch alanned and confounded at the import
>f the paper Watt read. You said before you
were so eonfased when you heard the paper
^ead, it took away almost all your recoUec*
tion? — ^Yes.
I ask you this question ; in consequence of
this alann, did you take any step immediately
for satisfying tbe public, you were no longer
an asnstant to those persons ? — ^No, I took
no step, but soon after IcA the meeting al»
tosether.
Did you advertise in the public newspapers
that you had so done f—I aid not.
Did you take any steps towards doing so ?
^— Yes, my lord.
State to the jury what step it was you took
or intended to take towards that purpose ? —
The alarm this paper gave me, causea me to
resolve in my own mind to quit die meeting
Altogether ; and I resolved a few days after
to make such an advertisement ; but afler I
bad done so, an acquaintance of mine called
upon me, and told me he was going a jaunt
to the west country, and made some applica-
tion to me, and I wrote a line or two to him
to call upon Mr. Watt to advance him a few
shillings. He was an intimate acquaintance
of mine, and he thought he might be short
of mon^ upon some business he was going
about, whicn he did not make known to me,
and from the interest I had with him,! wrote
a line or two after I had withdrawn myself
from the meetine dtonther, to Mr. Watt to
advance him a few shillings^ for which he
' would account on his return.
! How did that prevent you from taking the
' step you have just now stated ? Why should
writing to Watt, to get Watt to advance you
' a lew shillings tor a friend of yours who was
vgoine to the west, prevent your doing that?
I •— I had taken a farewell of all the com-
; mitteea.
Did you compose any advertisement for ths
puTDose I have just now stated to you f^Yes,
I my lord, that same week I did.
' Was there any particular newspaper in
which you proposed to insert that, was it the
I Edinburgh Advertiser?-^ It was the Edin-
bureh Advertiser.
I Ypu did not insert it in that, because you
I afterwards wrote to Watt to advance a sum
I of money to a friend of yours going to the
! west country?— Yes.
Who. was. that ftiend?-'An intimate ac-
' quaintance-^ohn Fairley was his name.
A^ D. 1794.
[1278
A journey V> the West?— He told me he
was goine to Fidkirk to see a sister of his
own ; and he added, he proposed going a little
farther.
And did he say besides a visit to his sister^
he had any other business ? — ^No, he did not ;
he told me he had a commission from Watt,
but what that commission was he did not
state.
Did he make any application to yon ibr
money to make this journey ? — From the inti-
macy between him and* I, I would have lent
it him, but it was not in my power, for that
reason I wrote to Watt.
Did yon give those reasons toFairley?— I
did.
Did Fdrley teave you to go to Watt ?— Yes.
Did you see Fairley after he performed th^
journey ?— I did not.
I thought you said before he went away
youdid?->Yes.
But after he came back, did you or not
meet with Fairley ?— Yes.
Did Fairley communicate to yoti the names
of the places where he had been in the course
of thatjouroey ? — ^He did not.
Did he mention the names of the persons
he met in the course of that journey ? — ^No he
did not.
Did be state that Watt had complied with
the request for money or not ? — ^He did not.
You did not ask him ? — ^I did not ask him.
Would you know the advertisement again
you prepared after hearing that alarming pa-
per reacL and before you wrote that note of
latroducUon to Fairley, if you saw it again ? —
I certainly should.
Is, that the very paper? — [Showing him a
paper] Yes, my lora.
Your own hand-writing ? — ^Yes.
• That paper was read as follows :
^' BrauehtaHf AprU 81.
<'To tbe public; I William Bonthome^
teacher in Broughton, was chosen a member
of the Committee of Union in March last, and
Sub-committee; but for reasons of weight
with me, declare that I have dropped all con-
nexion or communication with the sidd com*
mittees. William Bohthorve.^'
Is that the paper you prepared for inser-
tion ? — ^Yes,
Was there any particular reason why yon
applied to Watt to advance a sum of money
to Fairley for this journey, in preference to
any other person? — It was purely out of
friendshp to Fairley.
I ask you why you selected Watt to be the
person to lend money to Fairley rather than
anyotlier person? — Because he told me he
was going to Watt, or was going to receive a
commission from Mr. Watt. .
Did you ever hear of a man of the name of
Hardy !L.Yes.
In what place have you heard of that per-
son's name ?•— I cannot fix upon a particular
place.
1S8S1 9i GEORGE IB.
PncetJugi agakut JToftrf WM
{m
Is tiiere a society of FrieiMk M tho Pm|pI€
thore ^ — ^Yea.
Were yon a momber ofikt Bittirii Comreft-
tktt that met lastyev ?— -Yes.
^Tere yoH ft Bienbet ef UMtt oonveiiliciiy
when it was dispersed bj the lord provost
and other roapstrales of this dty ?«-Yes.
Did tte medibers of ^le eoDvoitiott mest
ftfVerthat?— Yes.
Can yoD tett when it was?— I fMnk it was
in the nuflflh of Deceasher.
And yea say your society eoatiniied still to
flieet after that convention was dispersed?
—Yes.
Were yon diosen m any oAee after the dis-
persion of the oonventiott? irere yon ipade
collector^— Yes, I was.
£»»lain what was the meaning of tiasofSce
of collector; what were you to do?— When
I cane into the Broughton socie^ (I never
beard of the eoUectors before) thev were jpst
choosing ; they had chosen one, and beginnint
to choose another, and thev chose nie. I
asked the business, Mr. Bontnrone came for-
ward and told me they were to collect money,
and to collect sentiments.
By sentiments do you mean sense of
the people?— What I understood by it was,
that there were a great many of the societies
who were as wannly attached to the cause so
ever, but on account of business, could not
ipe attendance reguUvly, but at the same
twie were so attacMd as to contribute money
ibr the expenses ; that was the reason of hav-
ing collectors ; and for the collection of sen'
timents. Bonthrone said, we want to know
who will be for procuring universal suffrage
and annual parliaments: there were two c3-
lectors for our society.
Did the other societies appoint collectors
also ? — I understand so, but 1 could not at-
tend any other societies but my own ; there
was one or two meetings held.
Who was chosen preses of the meeting •f
collectors? — were you?— Yes.
Were vou chosen president of the com-
mittee of Union ?— No, I was not
Do you know that there was a Committee
of Union, and of Ways and Means that met
at George Ross's ?— Yes, there were commit-
tees that went by that designation, but I w«i
Dot at the founding of thenib
Hadyouany occasion to do bosinesa with
the Committee of Ways and Means ? — ^I ww
twice at the Committee of Ways and Means.
Among other persons, was Watt presoit
when you attended there ?— Yes I thjok be
was there.
Pray, Mr. Fairley, had you any ocoaskm
to have any oonY^rsatioaaaBongst yourselves
about the Friends of the People amnag tiien-
selvas, soon af^ yau were appointed collec-
tor, or about that time?— Had we conversa-
tion abbut armtne?
Yes, about armlne the Friends of the Peo-
ple?—I never beard any thii]|g«bout anting
«ie FMendsof the Ftopiie. I hoal ihs
were some pikea getting rsady.
Wert you wall acquainted witkWtQ^al
when did you first hotome auaBSiDlul %ii
hkn F— ft was not very long btless I «in.
nrehendsd, thai I became anjiimiii wa
Did Watt ciH mod ym. respsccbg ta
pikes ?— Yes, Mr. WaM called upon am.
Did Mr. Watt meniioA to you ssgr tlB|
about a mimber of pikes hafii« Isa
provided, and what number; i ceiid «
fl^y that he mentMand any tfarag sktitti
number. I do not rvoollett Waitipsd(^%
any particular number of pikes.
asid Watt relative to tba pilie»-Didla«i
yon there were pikea prcpuing te ihtw*
Uie Friends of the P«^K*4Ieflboeiiii
some pikes first
Had he ever mentioned the sabjeel ft P
before ?— Yes, we had epafcc aboiittkiii^
ject before.
Did Watt oome to ywor shop udmbi
drawing of a pike aa yoor prescaceMt
BenthKme had been talking.abeiit li I*
not know whether I drew a plan of the i*
according to the description 1 had tan w
Md. fioolhome aaid I might ^w «
and he woidd take it I met with llr. M
in the street one day, and I was teilJo§ ■
I had been mentioning so Mr. BdMbint i?
dmwingsome. I cannot say wbil siiaivi
nve me ; bat sometime ailcr he csntttg
shopanddesiredmelodrawone. I^*^
one npenaslale. I toM faiml^»|
two or three upon a piece of papoy •■• ^
it up to Mr. Watt ^
Did you accordinaly do sa*; J***^
drawings, and see if you know *gK fj
those the drawings you saadr »r wmf^
think they are. ^^
These are the designs Iband b^*|
possesion. Now, Mr. F^arky •* ^2-
when you carried this paper to Wstl<»«"rj
ing the drawings of tnese instrunaes^^,
eonversation had you with him aponm^
ject of pikes and aims, sad in v'Mi ^
nerwere they to be used? tell sPy^
to these gentiemen.— I cannot reiagj*'^
particular conversation we had^w^F^|^
Did he mention to yon what assj*f^
aaade of them, by putting them into *^"2
m the people?— He said th^ wmtv^
m self delence. »^ g
And did he tell y«ith^«o«^?7l
be put into the hands of tha fnm^zZ
People ?^Mr. Watt said to me «^T^
penon to nt them but soeh asiitif*>*^
and woukipay for them. . ^^^^
Did you eipress any fwof HtwJJJ^
thb oeomion? did yon ssy ^J^^
Mr. WaU about what was swd ? ^S^S
sflQT yon were aftaid of bk)od8he<ir-^ ^
ttaiy w«e iatsDdcd for self dofeoce.
isa$3
^ High TreawL
A. D. 1794.
[1S86
Pid jrotf m niqr thing at all abotii Uood*
sliedy and what answer did Watt make upoQ
t)&8 «K:f:ask>p ? di4 Y^u aajr aaj thing al^ut
your fear of bloodshed when too heard of
thepe ivaaipoQs being mentioned ?— Watt and
1 were oince taUung toigether about different
^biags J I could not say the particular wcrdSy
put I will tell you the meaaipg— I wasesprea-
sia^ nj fears that the present measures of
govef nment would drive tne people to despair
mad; I vaa afhud for the oonsequence— I
could aot say what the particular words wezc^
it unia aonethi^g to that purpose.
And what did Watt say? — He sud, be
lu»ed there would be no bloodshed.
t>id be sav the plan could be executed
^thout bloodshed ? — I do not reooliect the
nvttcular words now; it is the substance.*-
Vobody can remember words. — When I was
expressing my fears for the consequences^ be
said tbey woiud be imprisoned.
Who would be imprisoned F—Those, I un-
derstood, that were most active against the
cause of the people.
Whp said sometiiing of your apprelieiision
of bloodshed ? repeat what you said just now
about certain persons being seiaed?— AU I
VQ^oliea is, X was afraid the present measures
of government would drive the people to
despair^ and I was expressing my fears tor tlie
conseouences*
What did Watt sav ?— He said he hoped
no blood would be shed, for they would bt
imprisoned.
Who were they that were to be imprisoned ?
-^Those that were most active against the
cause of the people.
Pray, sir, dia you say anv thing at all
about the soldiers being any obstacle to com-
pleting your plan ; and what did Watt say
about them ?— I eoul4 not say: I might be
saying something about the soldiers,— that if
thqr oad any fears about an extremity, I would
not be for omring anv violence to the soldiers,
—I would iust speak to them, and I hoped
there woula be no occasion for violence.
What did Watt say?«-I do not recollect
what Watt said.
Seoollect as well as you can.— -I cannot
leooUect the particular words.
But the substance, as well as you can,
about the dispute between you and the
soldiers ?^I thmk all that was said about the
soldian, was, that I said, I would be just for
ipeaking to them, for they would be as i^
or freedom as we would be.
Was it aAer.your wemies had been impri-
soned, that this was to happen, you were to
mnk to the soldiers?— I had given my opi-
nion to Mr. Watt ; I never beard it befi>re;
I gave it as my opinion.
W|M there a deputiUion to be sent to the
Castle f-^I just said, if ma^swes came to an
extremity, and that the sddiers were called
out sgsinst us, and there wovM be rsaaoo to
suspect they would, I would juet send up
siKPsbodj to siMMk to them, whether in or
out of the Castle.
To prevail' vifon tbem to do what?—- To
speak to them, so that they m^t not harm
us.
Lord TraUerU. — ^I should be glad to knoV^
wbaa the witness sud, that the soldiers would
be aa fond of freedom as they were, whether
it was his meaning, that there was any body
in this country not free? — My lord, the cause
in which we were engaged, was for procuring
universal suffrage ana annual parliaments,
and till that was obtained, I thought it was
my right, as a subject of a froe state, to have
a share in the representation of my country;
and I considered, if I had it not, I was not
free.
You mean then, that you were entitled to
oppose those who were against annual parlia-
ments and universal sufn^e? — ^I did not say
so.
Did Mr. Watt propose any thing violent
with respect to the soldiers ?— There were
reports going, that the Friends of the People
were to be attacked,— and different things.
What things?— There were reports goin^
that the Friends of the People were to be
attack^,— and different things,— ^and we did
not know in what manner,— and I just gave
it as my opinion, if matters came to that
extremity, we had reason to expect the soldiers
would be called out :— if they were, I Would
be just for speaking to them. — I cannot nay
the exaet words.
Mr. SoUcUor General— The prisoner I sup*-
pose means to ask a question, but he had
oetter wait till oiir examination is over.
Court. — ^He must wait; you will be allowed
to ask any question when the examination is
over.
Mr. SolkUor General, — ^Ilad you any con-
versation with Mr. Watt about this plan of
seiung those enemies of the people? Was
there any proposition made for seizing them
in different parts of Scotland at one time ?— I
do not recollect saying they were to be seized
in different parts of Sa>tland at one time.
Court,-— The Court does not hear you.
You heard that question, give me the an-
swer to it? — I have some idea of something
being mentioned, though I i:annot be quite
sure of it We entered into a sort of conver-
sation. I cannot say exactly what I saidy or
whathessud.
Was there something said about couriers f
—Yes.
After seizing upon these people, you were
to send couriers to all parts of^ the country
about what had been cfone? — I think them
was something of that kind mentioned.
Was any thmg mentioned about what the
collectors were to do?— Mr. Watt once said
to me he would ^ve me some of the arms
to show the collectors.
^ These were pretty unportant conversations ?
— ^I mean to speak fairly. I cannot recollect
what I said.
Mr. Am$tnUher.^We dp not wantthe veiy
words.
lord .iifopcofc— The substance and purport
ISST] M GEORGE HL
PfvCdMft^^^mii tMM Wa»
im
of what YOU saidy to the best <tf your fecoUec-
tkm, al the tkne when Watt |>rop09ed thowing
the arms to the collectors ? — ^We talked about
it at different times ; U was MV. Bonthron
Who first talked to me aboot showing them
to the collectors ; and Mr. Watt n)0#ed lAe
some, and my answer was, there was no harm
in settling any thtne by way of tnerchandi^,
and that expiesdon ne onderstood tdatSre to
the pikes.
t>id Mr. Watt accordingly t^o^ the eoBec^
tors some of the instruments ? — ^I cooid not
aay whether he shewed some to them or not.
£>id he show them to you?— Yes.
Where were they ? — In his own liouse.
What were they like?— They were not
exactly like these. -(Looking at some pikes on
the taft>le.]
Look at those pikes?— I cannot say whe-
ther they were them or not, they were made
aAer that form.
Did he desire you to carry them any where ,
to show any bodv ?— It might be at that time '
iie said he would give Ihem to me to show the
collectors.
Did you ever cany any to Ross's?- No.
Were you ever asked to carry any to Ross's ?
— ^I should imagine it would be at that time
when they were given to me to show the col-
lectors. I understood I was to take them to •
the collectors.
And what were the collectors to do ?— I was
only to show them to the collectors, and the
method I was told was — I was to shew them,
and if itoy person asked, would I sell one
of those, I would have done it ; if no person
asked, I was 'to bring them back \ if any col-
lector said they wanted sudi an instrument, '
I was to give it him. I was to sell there ; if \
not, I was to bring them back to Mr. Watt's. \
Did you accordingly do so ?— No, f did ,
not. ' I
What was your reason for refusing tb cari^ ■
these articles of merchandfze, efnd allowing
them to btiy thein if they chOife ?— I made
some objection.
Thch^ou rtinst tell to the Court and the
jury whit that objection was,you carinot htfvfe
forgot it— I do not recollect What the <ftrjcc-
tion was, bijt the fact of the matter Was, I did
hot wish to take them.
Why did you not wish to take theto ?^1
did not takfe them ait that time.
Did you take them at any other tifafe*?— «
No, I m not.
What wife ydur objection? I knb^*r you did
hbt take thehi at'Oiat tiiiib, you say th^ yoii
had aabbjection.-^Becausenoneoflteeolfec-
tbrs had asked me, and 1 wanted to "sdeak to
the collectors bcfdrel would think of aofnjg ft.
Dheh did'j'oircver^lieak to anyodc <5dlW
jtor upon the sutiject ?— i do ridt rc^cdlfedt.
Then I put this fliJostion 'to you. Was the
teason why yoli objected tb difryioir *fhdse
pikes from Watt's house to the coUetftofs,
that you tholieht ituhsafe and daft^^firoos'for
you to ^o so? Now^ answer this quti^tion,
was It, or WIS it not ?-»I did not inrii ksak
them.
Was H for the reason yon have heifin»
tioned?— ^PNo ahswerj.
Lord AdvorMe. You can sayaMfaeril
waa, or not the rouion?— I did notlSunk f^
self of doing any harm with thett,lMftI «
nol wish to taketlMem to the coUedm; ttg
would h^fcave said that I had been Imf^
them tor the puip^ae of diabibtttingthBB.
Lord PrtMent. If the eoUeclBrs iiM
Cb have them, you wei« to sell tbem; ii
there any price specified .?-^I do aet reoriki!
any, I suppose it waa whatever price ik|
proposed.
L&td JOtoeate. Did Ws^ teU ;« Ibi
cost ?— No, he dM not.
Fs it a coinmbn trade fer people U) all a
ticlbs of that sort kxfmXLfiX ttepikelii!
isbst ?— (Nib answer].
Cimrt. Had yt^ no profit upon the Infci
—I had an objection.
• What objeoion ?-i-That aHholJgfcl iMj
no harm in it myself, if I took thoBjIiq
would be saying I Wiahcld fnini^Mtbf
eoUectors hefoi^ they i^kted me.
Pmy, were ;jro« ever sent to th^ westia*
ttji by the Co^mitlee of Way« ind MeiB?-
WheHier I was se*t fey the Cwterfttee rf
Ways and MeMis, l know not. I wee M
to the west country to see a friend jf **'
Airth. the mirhtbeforc I set ou^ I M»2
m company with Mr. Boothfrnwe^ ^'J?*"
he had a letter or something of thai vm ■
send to BortrowstbufiYieas. ItoMhiteiJ*
going to the west, and «wfM Uke attyw
for him. The next morniWig f «^^*°*
^^atJfs, and toTd him I wa^ grt»g to the vj
c^mti^, and asked if he ^oiutd givteW*»»*
ler ; he said lie wOuld. 1 eHW, whatetff »
had to tsfke fiir him, he was to k*^ «VS"
Cami^cirs, the hatter, at the UK*«ttwj"J
and 1 would gattte <eaM he was ti«» *»
the time I w&t €Way. I wetat to Mr. OJ
MSr%, the hat«er,-and got a part«ilx>"*^
ried welst. . _,
XVhiA didtbift wnrdel^orittin?— th^**^
different copies of papers. . ^^
Should yon kn<*w them agaii^, lo» «* T;
paper, was that <«e of the Jtape^s %i w r
M ?— 1 thirfc il Was One er thirt*» .^
Was tlicre any wioi^ tInJft che »pj«^
eanndt say th^ litiraber. , ^
Might tbei<e he 4en or «WeoQ'f*v2
!rpoak to Kfowai<ds dft<fa, hWI I ts»» r
to the number. ^^ u^
Look at thto oMr )^p«f-^ *** ^
Was aiiotiier pc^r . ^
"Hitf yOu more than ohe«>|jy*^«**^
paper?— Ves. -^
Might there be ten <Wp»«<6f thdft N^t'J
Mr. ^»i«ri/#*^.--Oefttlein«»,«h<r2tJ
rs that liaMe he«i 'prowsd t>y • varwj'^
pers
people, Ittit httve «dt ydt be«a rm- ^ ^
Mr. Sbtfc&of V^«WH<(.-Jhow w««J J<" '^
di^pOise^r^ho* papers ?^*4ie said*^ ..^
19891
Jblr High TWmoii.
A. D. 1794.
[1S90
I went -ID Mr. CampbtlPsy «od asked if he
luud teft h ; he said yes, he had leftsomethiDe
for me y6ild«r» at Mr Cam^bell^ which I
^vouM know what to do with.
What was it you were to do with them ? —
That waa what Watt said to me, I knew what
t6 dd ^ith them.
What were you to do with them }—'l will
%«Il yt^ what I did, I called upon different
people in the w«it country.
At what diffisrent places of the w^st eoiin-
try ? — At Queensferry, Stirling, Saint Niaians,
Kiiavthy Kirkintulloeh, Canipsie, Glasgow,
Psusley, and Falkirk.
What ^d you do at all those pbcea ?--I
gave tbem a copy of each of these.
Yon gave a copy of each of thMe, at each
place YOU have namad ?— *Ye9.
Had you any written iiietnictkms when you
w««it to the west ?^In the tame parcel there
^vere two bits of paper.
What Were dieyf^Inatniciions. It is so
long aiace I do not nsmember particularly.
But the substance f— The sub!^nce was
to correspond with Mr. Downie, and to send
tnoaey to him.
Wher^ were they foundf^Iii the packets
hc^ft atCampbelrs.
There you found written instructions F — In
the parCtt.
What did you do wHh the writleD instruc-
tions ? -I returned them to Watt.
After yoiir retam from the w«st f -^Yes.
When did you first open this packet f— -I
•pened it first at the Qoeeosfenyy aad then
found these instructions.
Who WW thisCampbell? washeamenW
of the British Convention ?— He was.
Was iliere any thing mentioiied . about
sounding the 'sense of the people ? — ^Tes.
L^Kmihose plans you had been formcn-ly
taHctng with Mr, Watt >al)out, regarding a
pand plan : recollect yourself, the vfoestion
IS plain. -^I could aot wy he spoke about
aodading. I thhdt tliore waa aomelhing
about a number of patridts, there was ssfme-
thing about that.
Now, in all the ditferewt iflaoea, <M you
hufinte for the patriots, to tal^ an accemt of
the namber ^--vnever asked alboirt«iiy nam-
l)cr.
l0rd Jtfvocafe.-^-Kow, sir, you say Watt
told you, you would find a tpiniel 'at Camp-
itt\\\ Ihe 'hatter^ aod you (bund one. Did
Watt 'tell ;you any particular towns in tfhe
west, to 'which yon -weie to gof — 'No, »he did
not.
Did that 'paper of instniotionB contain fhe
names of any particular towns or;pflaceB to
which you *w.are to go^^-4<do nut TceoUect
getting any names.
Then ft was perfeetbr Mt to^youtto 'go to
any place ytm pleased in»the«w«at iff 'Scot-
land?—I suppose it was Mt to my own dis-
cretion.
Did ai^ penon recommend you tOM to
BoffowstDUDDessi— tl -do not tacdilaot any
more about going to fiorrowitoqnness than
what I have said.
Did you so to Borrowstounness.^-^I went
first to Stirling, and came through Borrow*
stounness in coming back.
You were in Queensferry } Did you show
anv of those papers in Queensferry f— No, I
did not
Did you distribute any in Stirling ?^I think
I did.
Did you or not ? I will not take that ao-
swer.-^I think I gave some in Stirhng.
You did not leave any in Queensfeny ? —
Because I dad not see any person there in
partkular.
Had you any particular person that you
were directed to at the Queensfeny?— No, I
had not, I had an acquaintance at Queens*
ferry.
Then you went to Stirling ?-— Yes.
Did you or not give one pr more of these
papers to any person in Stirhngf-^Yes, I
gave them to all the folks I calieaat.
Now, sir, do you, upon your oath, recollect
Um name of any single person in' Stirling to
whom you tave the paper ?*^There was a Dr.
FMrest, andthere were two or three more there,
I gave one or two. I just gave them in the
moniing.
In whose house was it you gave the papers
tA Dr. Forrest and the others?— It was m Dr.
Forrest's house.
Pray had you ever seen him befim f — No.
Then how came you to go to his house ?-^I
had heard him spoken amnit before in Edin-
burgh.
I ask you — ^was it not in the committee of
Ways and Means Dr. Forrest's name was
snenlioned^— Dr. Fonest's name. waa not
mentioned to nie tiiere.
Was it Mr. Watt who meBtaooed die name
of Dr. Forrest to you ?— No, sir.
Do you aay that upon your oath ?— Yes.
Did yini meotiaii to htm any thing with
respect to the committees that were estab*
liahedinfiMburgh?— I soppose that letter
would tell him.
Did you do it yowadf ?-*I sq>pose I might
tell him so.
Did you ask of Forrest the aumbar of pa-
tndts in SlirHog'?--! could nst aay whether I
askod 4)ia the parHoilar oumber or no^I
asked him how the society was fioorishing
there, or something of that aaaare.
Did you ask him aay «hiag ^se ahoot the
society^— <<do not aecoHact askiag him any
thing more dboat it
D070U not secdlect aakkig iiim any tiling
else?— Other persons were present in For*
seats liouse at that time.
Who were those persons *do yau nememr
her themP — ^Doctor Forrest went with doae
and gotthemi^ ahiflk^here was^oneofl^m
Ihey called'Thomson.
How mai^ ^were these ^f ^heml'— Ilisie
were two or .Ihsee ibcjsidesahat Mr. VhonpwMi.
How long might you remain in CMOfmy
1291] 84 GEORGE UI.
with these pcEiMnf^We ougbi b» Iheie ta
hour or two.
Pkl you undentaod these persoiii to be
what they aili FMriots, or Fxieods ci Che
People? — Yes.
Whfli wai the sttbetaaee of your convena-
tion in eenerel ?-*They vtoM begun with the
news ofStirlingy and I was telllEg them the
oews of EdloburKb.
Do you recollect in general any one ar«
cmnBtaaoe relative to the committees io Edin-
burgh which yoH Mated to Forrest, and
ThMiODy and o4hers?^-I have no doubt I
would tell them about the committees, but I
sppke to Dr. Forrest about the pUm I have
already told you.
What was tiiat ?— 'About imprisoning those
that I Iwive already spoke of.
Well, what did Forrest say ?— I am sure I do
not recollecc what he said.
Did Forrest say any thing in reply ?-«I do
not recollect.
You mectkmed that plan to Forrest f-^Yee^^
I mentioned it to him.
Did you mention anv thing in that com-
pany with respect to the plan of arming in
Fdinburgb, whether for self defence or any
thing elae?-*-! may have told them that I
heara the Friends of the People had offered
their service to the duke of Buodeugh, or
something of that sort^I might also have
told them what was done in Perth.
While talking to Dr. Forrest or any one
else, did you. or did you not draw upon pa-
per or upon the table, m company witn one of
these men in Stirling a drawing of that pike
or battle-axe similar to what you had seen in
Edinburgh ?— take care before you give the
answer, it is very material you should take
care ? — I recollect it — I believe I did.
Lord Atkocate^-^Ht now recollects in con-
sequence of a specific question I put to him
—he recollects making a drawinu^ of those
weapons which he had seen in Emnburgh to
show Dr. Forrest
Where did 3fou go to from Stirling ? — I went
to St. Ninians.
Whom dkl you see these ?— A Mr. AfCross.
What is her — A minister.
Did you show him any of the papers, or
leave a copy with him ?— I read it to him, and
as far as i can recollect, I left papers with all
the gentlemen.
Was M'Crosa a relief minister, or minister
of the parish f— A relief minister.
Fray, was M^Cross an acquaintance of
your's before that period ?^-No, he was not.
Did you ever see him in your life before f —
No.
How came you to go to MHI!ross ?— It was
some of the folks of Stirling gave me a direc-
You went to KirkinCullocb or Gampsie or
8t. Ninians ; pray, whom did you odl on
there ?— I edled upon a Mr. M'Ewan, a mi-
nister, and Mr. Wheeler, a ministery a " '
miaislsr.
agaha fioiert WM
{i9aA
Did yeil«var tee them before P<— No.
Who directed yon tq lhem?^I thsak it «m
Mr. M<^rosa--themaaat St Nioiaea.
Where did you go QfHt^ — I went to
Gampsie,
To whom tb«t ?«— I do not know the mmet
of any in Campsie, Mr. M'Ewaa went with
me.
What kind of people did you wish to be in-
troduced to ?--The Friends of the People.
You went to Obisgow and Paisley at last?
— ^Yes.
Was that the utmost extent ofyiwr tour?
you went no farther westf -^No.
Had you say acquaintance in Pmslej be-
fore?—No.
And whom did you go to there? — I called
first at a Mr. Hasty *s there.
Was he a Friend of the People ?-«-Yea.
Was he a member of the British Conveiw
tion ?— Yes.
And you left papers with him ?— Yea.
Now, after vou were at Paialesr vhat did
you do next } did you come heme a^ain ? —
Come home ? I came to Obscow.
Why not to Edinburgh ? why net atraidhl
home }'^l came home by the eaoal, butmd
not call on any^ body, ana came home to Edin-
burgh.
When you came back to Edinburg;b where
did you go first?— Straight home to my
father's.
How long did you remain at home ?— Just
a short tim^ after resting.
Where dki you go tbeil?-^To Uie Com*
roittee of Ways and Means.
Was it the usual night of the eommitlee's
meeting ?«-Yes.
Did you find any of them aaaembled? —
Yes.
Who were they that were assembled?-^
Those that were there, were Mr. M'Ewai^
Mr. Downie, and Mr. Watt
You remember those three ?— Yea.
Now, sir« did you report to them the resuh
of your journ^ ?-r-Yes.
Did you give any one of them the instrae*
tions you had fiound enclosed in the packet
y;ou received at Campbell's? — ^Not at that
time, I gave them to Mr. Wati some daya
after.
Did you, after your journey waa over, or od
your way, or in the committee, make up a list
of the places and persons to whom jou g^vo
those papers, whom yon had seen in the
course of your embassy ?•— I took a list aa I
wentalons.
What (Gd you do with that liatf-^I gave
the list to Mr. Watt also.
You talked of instructions you found in that
packet, was there any other paper yoo fcu«d
m that packet, different from the two co^es
you intended to distribuia ?*— There wai
ther paper, authorixing^me to caU at the
cieties.
Did you shew that paper to the di(iemit
societies you ^w in the course of your fiOp
Ifi033
JtfrH^ IVaaoif.
A. D. 17M.
[1294
grcM^ «» yMr "mttmaaHf^l ftenr was in the '
••cietiesy but I showed them to th« penons I
spoke with.
Do you rememher what the general purport
«ind tenor of that commission was ?— It was
juat deairiag me to cnU st tbem.
Do yott recoltect any thing dbe in it 7«-It
just Erected me tocau at theas, and tali whaft
I did when I came back again.
W*a tb« purport of this cortunisskniy thai
they might pay credit to y«u and iMiTc
yoci f — I siippofia ao.
Waa that comonsian ligiied hj any persoA
er peraons?-^ do noi recollect it bang sigii-
^ by any petaott or poraons.
You da oat racattaci whother it ma 8igMA
cv not^— Na.
Do yoofocotteet wlia^icr it was sealed or
not ?-— There were seaAi at it.
Were than aa ■aoiea oppoeite to those
' ^cala?-— No. Not as I recolloet.
Wlpian yau viihed pafions in the aourse of
\ your |aui«My, whom Old yott stale yooraulho-
' tity to come from ? — I said it was from the
' Coflmnttee of Ways and Ifeaai, and it was
' 'sealed.-^I widcrstood it was something to
^ that purpose.
* And the people you showed it to, thought
^ ao too ? — Yes.
Whom did yoa eive that cooamission to ? —
f I gave it back to Mr. Watt also.
i After ^our return ?-— Yes.
Pray, air, did yo« defray the eipenee of this
i journey out of yoor own pocket, or out of
what nmd?— I received mm. Mr. Downie,
I About 90 afaillinas.
By whose onhn'did you cot that money f—
t lir. Bbmhrone gsnra me anne to Mr. Watt,
and Mr. Watt gave me a hoe to Mr. Downie,
I and Mr. Doarnie gave me the money.
Look at that papcr,and refrmh yoorme-
I Mv.~That is the list I gave in to Mr. Watt.
I ^ Mr. itfurntlAfr.— Is that ;^our hand-wril>
ing?— Yes, it ia my hand-wrilmg.
) What is that a Ust of?— Some of the folks
I I did, and some of them I did not call at
Did you call at all of those places ^— No.
I I did not call at any other of Ifao phtoes, than
^ what I told yon.
I For what purpose did you make out timt
( list?— I made it out that th^ might be cor-
fomodedwith.
( who were to conespond with themf->The
I leommittee.
( Now^ this is your haad«writing, is it? —
I Yes.
Now, read the two first lines.
£0rrfJJo06ale.^Beg^ at the top and read
the three or ibur first hnes legibly and ai»-
dibly to the jiny.— << SlirliDg, support by mo-
ney,*
Tell me what word that is that is next to
mon^ ?-^It is a Idank.
Whst is the meaning of that blank f there
are three letters and a stroke between them,
eeeilfaatitisandmakettoiitfirom tbemf—
i aoppwe it ia^ counig^*'*
Lari JUroca<«.— Read it OA now.
ff^ilwMi.— « Stirling, support by money,
oonrago not great.''
Mr. Amtrmiher, -^Oentktnen, there la
^ S ^r which be faalh filled up with the
word, SCn-ling; then it goes on" aapport by
mmsey," at fidl leMth; then Mlows
'< C-— ge,'' which he tnls vou, means eon^
iwe; tmm he tells you the bne would ran i
^Stirhng, support by money, courage not
gw»t."
What da you mean by courage not gieatf
perhaps that paper may refresh your memoiy
as to what passed with Forrest and the rest ;
tell me what is the next word, you say there
ia Slsrlinc, support by money, courage not
great; wniat comes nesit ?
Xard JVondeae.— What paper is that?
Mr. SoHcit9r 0«aerai.-»lt is his own report,
it means Stirling, suppmtby money, but coi»-
raee not great.
Mr. Amtruiker, — ^TeH me what is tfie nett
word. — 1 s«7ppose it means ^ support.*^
Cannot you tell us ? — It is a blank.
You have filled up two blanks after a little
difficulQr, now ffi up that— That is «* snp-
port,'' I wppose. ^ ^ ,
And what are the words that am next M-
^ Not certain."
There are two otiier Kttle words f-^" sup-
port as yet not certain.'^
Then the first beginmae of this paper deli-
vered back to Watt is, " Stirling, support by
money, courage not grea^ 8upp(»t as yet
not certain." Now, tell me, why ^ you
leave those three woidS blank ?— I left them
blank.
Why did yon leave them bhmk? vrasit,
that it was not very sale to fill them up ?-*[Nb
answer.]
Lord Advmate, — Give an answer to the
ouestion, tell us whether your reason was,
that you thought it not safe or what? say one
thinrortheother.— -Ididnothketobe writ-
ing that in the list.
Jdr. .diufrarAtfr.— The Jury will look at the
names. You have said there were tvro papers
in this bundle, one your commission, the
other your instructions? Did you ever show
those instructions to anybody? — I showed
them to the difRerent pei^e I called upon.
Did you show your mstructions to Dr.
Foiveat r— Yes, I showed them to aH th«t oeo-
pie I called upon, and showed them to him
among the rest, no doubt.
You showed your commimion to Dr. For«
rest and all the reat ? — Yes* '
Do you xecoUect no mora of those inslruc-
tioos than you have told us? because if you
do, I desue you totsll them nCm^— if you do
not somebody else will.
Xsrrf Jd^poc^tf.— Take caie whal yeusay,
they ril mw your instructmns.
iriraaf.— Those instructions I tfiink spoke
sorootking about a plan, but I do not reeoflect
the particular words..
Mr. Anttrutker,-^ 4o not want tbem; I do
1S95] 34 GEOttOE III.
ProceedUigi ill[tthiif JMerl WaH
not desire the ptrlkular words ; bill tell me
wfaat the geneikl purport of your inttiuctions
was as far as you recollect, and what plan it
was it referred to ?— I did not say the plan.
What did it say about a plan? — It was
•peaking about a plan, but I cannot speak the
words. I have it m my idea, it spoke some-
thing about a pian, but I cannot say.
Did it call it a g^eat plan» or a grand plan,
iir something like thatr— did it or notr«^I
have an idea of that word being in, but I eao-
Doitallcxaetly that there wad the word grand
plan.
What was the gmod plan todo?-*What
that waa to do, I could not tell.
Was it to settle every th3ng?-T*I do not
mind of its just speaking in thai way.
What did ywt understand ft 40 mean at that
timer whettit plan wa3 mentioned in your in-
ataetioQs l-^ tmdeiMood Mr. Watt spgitliiog
tome.
fiut what dad you understand it to mean ?
-*-It might b^ihatftei Mr. Watt was telling
LtKPd Ads)oo0i€i.'--Y^ia will see what he says.
Mi an jhotir a^ter aitdif the (p»«itiQ6.
Mr. Afutnaktr.^Did it say any thing about
Abe jCftmsMttee of eoerecy? — It spoke aome-
tbine about a committee.
Wbat sort <>f ^ op«imiiiiee.?«<^ spoke about,
I do not know whether jit was secret or not ;
itis mpos^Ue^ I dMsot keep in my mind
yefvf limg,
What did you g^^ibowtA jmmminge? iry
dit a^iia.^^I haMe «ome id$a that tt 'Spiokfi
4Qmet;hing^bouft aoPKimittee of secrecy.
Did it say any thing about Britain bcang
froe-? yfjiiX Jiiave tcAd us thuit it spoke about
Ahe grand plan which Mr. Watt ep«ke about
— did it tell any thing about being free ?
Li^^dwGfite, — Ciayyesor no whicJii .ever
y^ lik^.^ think I cemcwb^r of its saying
aomethivg «ibout that.
W9» B^tain lo (be Iree when that plan was
executed or not ; was the plsMi you mentiojQ^
^Msfose jlo<be Mr. W^tf s, wasitbat the plan thAt
-was to make jBritain free or ^ot ?-r-I tell you
wha^ I ^ijQHiember, viz. f^bput its speaking
something about those ithings, rbut t ofwnot
say what.
X]|id it say Britain iwas ito be foe^ what
.was it* that .was to .make Britain f^f^i was it
•this plfUii.or jnot?^! cannot recoUect ^ jeit-
pressions.
Lord Advocate^-^h^ was it that was to
m^ke .Piritain ^ffe« i was it ^e gn^ad plan ?—
It said something about it.
Wbut ^ was it that was .tp ^anake Britain free
—the substance-^rthe sefise ?--I think they
were .di^ecent SQfit^oos as tfar #0 I cQuld
make them out.
What .was.the sensei^all 4he4i^i«fU sen-
tences ?— It saiKlithey hoped Britain wQuldibe
fre6»- spmeihing, of thatjkind.
;^t ^^ ounnpt sp^ whetbor theTplan wae
to do it or not? — ^It did Apt say, whether
■the phm mn ^to dp .it pr not, it might mean
that.
toss
Whom ware tilia oommittsc of secncy to
correspcod witlif-^They weie t^corrcspomf
with Mr. Downie.
Cross-examined f»y Bfr. Hamikon.
I wish to know Mr* Fairlev, did Mr.
Watt at any timo say to you be had any in-
tention of mastering the soldiery any wiwie,
of making himself master of the st^diere ? you
mentioMlo in the former part of yoor d^wsi-
tioD you had some apprehension about the
soldiers, and Watt said ne had no £ear, aftd he
conceived them ware a g^eat many fne^a,
and repasled it. I wish to know wfanthar
Watt expressed htnwelf m that he proposed
the spldiors shpukl be got the better of. ^
I do not recollect his ever saying any thi^
about getting the better of the forces.
Mr. Enktne. — ^I think he said he ande the
tpur of those different places without mnw in-
structions from Mr. Watty but merely of hs
fvoper mptlve I wish to know if you hare
not sworn this ^— He gave me no iastnie-
tions.
YpM said ypu had no instrocliona to go t»
sll thpse p|js«:es?rr-I just went and told them
to correspond with Mr. Downie.
Dr. Forr€d sworn.
Mr. >lii#^f«a«r.-f^Wbti9 4o yoo fiv&?^Ii»
Stirling.
You are by profipsdon a Surgeon f ^^Yes.
Dp ytm kmwr a person of the n^noe of Fav-
Jey ?-* A pt^ivw ofthe name of Faifiey called
V^me mme time ago» I am not nbsoliitdy
certain. I think about the beginninr of
May ksty I think Faarley called upon me pien.
Mr. AnUnUker.-r-Giyt the answer to the
qgestion Or- Forrest.
Did Mr. Failiey produce So ymi any
written or printed papem ^ — ^A wiitt^t pof^i'
he produced, after talking of some little mat-
ters of indi&rence.
In what p^nnisr pr character did Fairley
iMTjO^uce himself to you? — He said be was
desiff^ $fi call upon me by aMjr. fiettof Edio-
hnrffh.
Whtt was the eenemlpAnsportoftbeooo-
versation? — I cannot recollect at thia dia-
'tM^^
Did he jteil you for wbsA purfioso he came
to Stirling? — ^I think he mentioned it was
wijth a yiew tp show in what situation the so-
cio^ was.
Xism mean the society of the Fnen^ of the
People? — ^The Friends of the People^ m^
lord.
Didheahowyoaany written paper^rrHe
^ve me three copies, of |he nuiobcr I am
jBQt jftbsplutely certain, I think tlapt^ mad n
letter, a printed letter ; I think it resenhka
Miis v«iry mudi.
Look at that — And that likewise. . *
iThe papers he gave you were dfatroyrd?—
Yes*. I destroyed them and the oopy of 9km
Jett^y and the cppy of the zqgulatiQiia I
to one Douglas, those .that cemained
slroyad by my friends,
taoffx
JorH^iTtuumu
A.P. ITMr
Cl«8^
Nowy did he shoir yoa any ^ttien f»per ?
^ACoUect as near as yau cao^ not thtf ^srords,
1 do not vront them if you eannot exactly
state them, but stale as well as you can, the
MrpDVt of t&e ^^tten paper he shewed yon. —
I cannot fwetend to stale the real purport, I
^ff ill state tlie general purport of the paper.
"What 'wfeia H about? — ^Ue menttonea that
some money iivas wanted. I think he men-
tawaed Mr. Skirtine and some other sufferers
In the cause of n«edom» and wished the
society ^aould endeavour to procure aometluQg
for that fmrpoae.
Mr. jtnatrufAer.— That is not thewritlen
instsuctionSy but cosrenation ; I want you
to state idle contents of his written instvue-
tiona. — There isnothin^ particular that I can
recollect of his wiitten mstructions, except it
be one part of his instructions.
Speak out, and state that part of his in^
structions you do renienaber. — ^Why I an not
absolutely certain of it. That there were to
be collectors of a certain number^ whether
fourteen or not I cannot say, and they were
I to be provided with ■■■
What f — I cannot say, it was a blank.
What did Ton say ? — ^Provided with, or pro-
vide themaehres wtth.
I Jwi^.-— Who were to be provided ?-— The
collectors or the people, I do not recollect
, exactly which.
\ Mr. jfnifrtilAer.— Provided with what? — I
J did not see any thing,
f Was it a Iflank ^-^Yes, it appeared to me a
, blank.
J Now, Dr. Forrest, what conversation had
J you with Mr. Fairiey on that subject } — I do
not remember the conf ersation particular^ ;
I I am ready to answer any question so far as
, I know, but I cannot pretend to state the
whole of a conversation I do not particularly
remember.
What was the import of Fairley's convenm-
tion with you ?— The unpcnrt seemed to me to
be to know in what state StirUng was, and to
procure money for the relief of thotethtA
suffered in the cause of reform.
Did it appttr toyou to be proper or impnv
per comrertatton ?— I do not Icnow whether I
am a proper jod^ or not.
How did it strike yourself; was it any thing
about arming ?— I do not reoollect that any
thintf about arms was mentioned.
what occurred to you at the time to be the
meamog of that blank f*— Am I here to state
Acts I positivel;^ know» or fill up that blrak
with what I conjecture, or not?
LtrdPraideat. The meaning of that con-
versation, you are bound if you know it, to
expfano. (No answer.]
Lord Justice CMk.^You must have hid
some ideaat thetime^ tdl tiie Court and juiy
what it was.'
Did you ask Fairiey what that blank was?
-<*l realty did not, i was nfther adverse to
•iklng faun any questions about it.
VOL. XXIII.
I
Why were you advene ?— It seemed a little
odd there should have been any blank.
What construction did von put upon it ? — ^I
fancied it might be sometoing that ni^|ht not
be i«op^ for me to investigate or inquire into.
Im'd President. — ^What do you mean by
that soroethia^? — I suppose, bad it been a
proper thing, it would natunilly have been
filled up.
Did you suppose it was arms ?-^Yes. my
lord, I did. '
Why did you not mention it before?—^!
thought I was not to give any coi;oectures<
Mr. Anstruther. — ^You have told me yo|i
supposed the blank was to be filled up with
the word arms, what did you sa;^ to Fairiey
upon that?— «I do not recollect immedialely^
what passed.
Lard Adfoocate. — It havinjg occurred to you
this blank meant acms, did vou or did you
not prohibit Fairiey to proceed any farther?-^
It was mentioned to him. I believe I mei^
tioned it to< him myself. I did not wish to
ha^e it in our power to injure an^ one; but
he shoidd be cautious of wbat he said»
Now, sir, did Fairiey accordingly stop
upon that caution which you gave mm?—)!
do not remember what particularly followed
that.
Did he ask you any thing with regudte
the number of friends in StininE or its n^gh
bourhood, or with regard to the friends in
whom they could place any reliance? — I ain
really not certain whether be did or not.
Then, did Fairiey mention to you any
thins with respect to pikes being manufs^
tured or provided in Edinburgh ? — I do not
recollect the word pikes was mentioned.
Arms of aoykind? — ^Arms^ I do not ror
collect*
• Weapons ? — ^No, my loird^^he made some-
thing of a fiurm like one of these upon^bil
ofpaper.
eay that out to the juiy, I hppe you are noft
concealing the truth ? — ^It was something lilqB
a soldier*s halbert ; we - wen talking Stout
an invasion, or some such thing, and we weije
asking about such thinga for Uio purpose of
do&noe.
And he drew something like this, upon jl
paper upon the table ?-*Yes.
After he drew that iosUrument, what did
bo say&Hher; did he say any number of
those were provided or providing ; and where
were they so providing? — ^I do not recollect
any particular number; if I recollect righl^
he said he knew some person who could pro-
cure instruments of that kind.
Did he mention the name of the person, <k
place where he resided? — He did not men*
tion the name uf the person that I recollect.
Did he convey to you, or did you unde»<
stand where that person resided, from Fair*
. ley's conversation ? — ^The idea I had at th^
time, wasy it was somewhere about F^in-
burgh ; I cannot pr^end to (;ive it positive ;
it was my conjecture,
4 0
¥
1990} 34 OtOAG^ fix. Proceedtngi agohui Ro^ri Wm
[laoo
Mr. .^iMfnf<Aer.>— Now, Dr Forreflf, did
Mr. Faiiriey remain with you after the com^
patfywpa^Ud?-— Yes. He slept in my house.
Now, I want you to tell rae what conver-
sation passed between you and Mr. Fairley,
after the coni]>any separated ^—VeI7 little.
It was about midnjffht, and I went very soon
tobed. *
Did be say «ny thing about collectors? — It
tras mentioned ; I am not certain whether it
was mentioned in the printed or written in-
strueUons.
Did Fairley say any thing about them ? — ^He
'mentioned something about them.
Did he say any thmg to you ; and I desire
you to recollect, that you are a person in a
considerable situation of life, that you are
speakine in a great audience, wholiearyou,
— ^and above all, upon your oath ; answer ttiis
question distinctly, did Mr. Fairley or not,
say to you any thing relative to a rising of the
people, in any way whatsoever^. Now an-
swer that question distinctly and plainly. —
Something was stated to tnat purpose ; but
whether he asserted it was a thing agreed
upon ; or as a ^ng that mieht possibly be
done, or as a thing tnat might nappen, I can-
not say upon my oath.
Now^ aid he, or not, say any thine to you,
respecting disarming the soldiers ?— That was
mention^.
• Whom was it mentioned by? — If I recol-
lect it was Fairley.
Now, what was mentioned about disarm-
ing the soldiers?— That, my lord. I hsve
hwd so frequently in other places, and in
the common conversation of the day, I can-
not pretend to say the particulars Fairley ]«-
iatea ; but it occurs to me, he mentioned that
circumstance about disarming the soldiers.
Who was to disarm them 7— I do not know
whether he said that it could foe done, by
taking their arms while they were absent, or
in the night s^fMon ; I am not absolutely cer-
tain of it.
Who was to do it? — He did not state who
was to do it, if I recollect.
Was it the Friends of the People, or was it
not f — He did not mention the rriends of the
People.
was it the people that sent Fau-ley there,
or not ? — ^He aid not say.
Did you understand, from the conversa-
tion that you had with Fairley, that this plan,
such as it was, was to be effected by the peo-
ple who had sent Fairley there ? — I cannot
"Bay, upon my oath, whether it was an agreed
plan.
Zorcf ilifooc«ie.-*-That is a different thins.
' Mr. AfKArvXhcr, — ^I do not ask whether it
was an agreed thing or not— or whether a
thing thatoHght be done— or was to be done
'---if It ever was done who did you understand
it was to be done by — Did you not understand
if it was ever done, it was to be done by the
persons who sent Fairley there ?— Perhaps.
Do not you tell me perhapa-«.waa that your
idea r—Yes; my lord.
Did F^ley teU you an^ thing or not
pecting imprisoning certam people at I
Inirgh T— So fiur as I reeoUect he menlkned
some people were to be pot up ; bat be did
not state names aa fiir as I recMect.
But some people were to be put op— .to be
imprisoned ?— That is what I meant.
Whom were they to be put up by ? — I sop-
pose the same people that were to seise aod
take the soldiers arms.
Did you understand from the convenatiHi
this was to be done by the people who sent
Fwrley to the country ?— Yes, my kird.
Did Mr. Fairley tell you any thtng^HM* aaj
any thing to you about certain people in Eiho-
bun; repentine of their conduct ?-^Yea» my
lor£— that probably some would Tepent — or
regret their conduct — or some soch words.
Now if I understand you— were not those
people who were to be made to repent thcar
conduct the people that were meant to be
put up ?— I understood so.
Certainly it would have been nnich better
for a gentleman in vonr situation of lile to
liave told this story puunly, than to have had
it screwed out of you in the manner it has
been. I ask you now, whom Fairlev desued
jTOU to correspond with ? — I tbinlc he men-
tioned, what money was to be collected on the
behalf and relief of suffering friends, was to
be sent to a Mr. Downie.
Now, I ask }[ou agsun ; and I desire you to
recollect, what it was tairley said to jou with
respect to collectors; or what their duty was
to DC, what they were to do? Were they to
be for every fourteen or fifteen members the
society consisted of ?— Yes.
What were those collectors to do over these
fourteen or fifteen? — He did not state what
they were to do.
Were they to ccUect nothing but money ?—
He did not say any tiling else but money.
Upon your oath were the collectors to com-
mand the people whether they were to riae or
not? — ^He did not say so.
Did you understand that from him?— >I had
that idea.
Did you gather that idea from the oonver-
sation you had with Fairley ?— Yes, I did.
Mr. AnMtrvXhtr to the Jury. — He gathered
the idea that the collectors were to bead iMd
command the people when they did rise, from
the conversation with Fairley.
Had you no other conversation about aim-
ing?—None that I recollect.
What led to the conversation between Fair-
ley and you, upon which Fairley drew the
plan of a pike upon the table ? — The sulgect
we were talking of was, the prospect of an in-
vasion.
Had you any conversation about a oonveo*
tion ?— The convention was mentioned.
What was said about a convention > — ^1 do
not recollect ; there was some talk about it;
I cannot recollect it
Was it that there was to be a conventioD or
none ?— They expect^ there was to be
vention.
13011
M
Treoionu
A. D. 1794f.
[J302
"Where was the conventioii to me^t?-*lt
not known.
W^as it to mci^ in SooUaod or England?—-!
do not know.
Mad you no ooav^mtion about it ?«— Yes.
What was it?—- Little more than what I
have told you.
You have told me nothing yet; youhsre
told me you had a conversation about a con-
vention ; what was it ? — It waa said a con-
vention was to meet, but no time nor place
mentioned.
What sort of convention was it, was it of
the Royal Burdis? — ^It was a convention si-
milar to ^ha« which met in Edinburgh, of the
Friends of the People.
You were a member of that convention ? —
No.
You were a member of the society of the
Triends of the People ? —Yes, I, was.
Cross-examined by Mr. Hamilton.
Pray, was it your own conjecture, or did
j Fairley tell you there were concerted mea-
sures taken; that it was absolutely a fixed
, matter there was to be a rising here?— I ga-
, thered that from the purport of his Ian-
«^h
,/hat did you nther?— That the people
who were provided with such instruments
mieht defend themselves in case of an at-
tadc.
That was the conjecture you eatheied from
the conversation of Fairley wi& you? — [No
answer.!
Mr. Anttruiker, — Did you or not, from the
purport of Fairley's conversation, ^ther that
there was to be a rising of the people, and
seizine the soldiers arms? — ^Yes.
Did you ever see a circular letter signed
** T. Hardy?"— I do not recollect it
Did you ever see that letter, or a similar
letter ? [showing him a letter .]---No, my loid,
I never saw it.
I want now to read this circular letter,
which has been proved by witnesses,and is also
proved to have been carried bv Fairley round
the country. It is the orinted piroilar letter
from the Committee or Ways and Means.
^ Fellow Citizens ;
^' At a time when power seems to be
making such rapid strides amongst us, while
the friends of freedom are persecuted and
hunted down on every side, and the genuine
£rinciples of the constitution repeatedly vio-
kted oy those who, at the time they are pro-
fessing their attachment to it, are aiming the
secret blow which undermines it, the finends
of peace and reform in Edinburgh call upon
their brethren throughout the kinedom: we
call upon you to warn you of your £nger ; we
would remind you of the present melancholy
state of affiiirs, our commerce diminished,
our manufactures drooping, the industrious
poor wanting bread, and the mingled cries of
the widow and orphan assailing the ears of
heaven ! These, these are only a part of the
cruel efiects of the most disastrous and bloody
war, the end of which is wrapped up in a
gloomy obscurity, which has scarcely one ray.
of hope to penetrate or illumine : in the mean '
time, we behold armed associations forming
in different furts of the country ; we see the
partial selection of citizens, who are entrusted
with arms, and shudder in contemplating
what may be the motive of this alarming and
novel procedure.
** Under these circumstances, what is our
resource? Citizens, there is but one thing
that can rescue us, a complete reform in par-,
liament Let us not be awed into a servile
submissipn by any illegal artifices. Let us
not sink before the blast of oppression, but
let us unite firmer than ever, and the number
of voices that call for redress of our grievances
shall yet be heard; but never let us relinquish
this ereat work.
** Rememher, that till we are hn\\ repre-
sented, no check can ever be opposed to the
strides of power; but we may be crushed be-
neath its weight, like a worm beneath Uie
foot of the passenger.
" In the mean time, we send you a few
rules, which are drawn up for the use of our
own societies ; we recommend them to you^
and hope th^ will be equally serviceable. A
committee of union is appomted here, to ex-
press the united wishes of the several socie-
ties; and a sub-committee, which is called
the Committee of Ways and Means, as trea-
surers for the united societies, and a centre
of union for all firiends in Scotland. Through
their medium, directions and instructions will
he given. The money put into their hands
will be accounted for, and disbursed in such-
a way as shall be most calculated to promote
our great cause. If, therefore, you have any
sums collected beyond what your immediate,
exigencies reguire. or if you can collect any
among your friendB, though they should not
be members of socie^s, you are reauested to
remit the same to Mr. Edinburgh,
who is appointed to receive the several sums
for the committee.
<< We should also wish to be informed of
the number of friends which you have^ on
whose patriotism you can rely with the most
implicit confidence, and wno you are sure
will spare no exertion whatever m promoting
the great cause in which we are engaged.
<< We would thank you to commumcate the
best method of making our mutual sentiments
known to each other, and the person to whom
our letters may be addressed with the neatest
safety. Direct your letters as above,lbr Mr.
We beg for aii answer with all
convenient speed, and remain, your brethrea
and feUow citizens,
** The Conunittee of W. and M.*'
Which means Ways and Means.
Mr. AtuinUher. — ^We will read a paragraph
or two of this paper, called ** Fundamental
Principles or Regulations of the Societies ;*
1303] 34 GEORGE UL
ProeeedU^ agamtt Robert Watt
[t9M
ihfe two first RgulatkNM tftAr the ihtro-
dlucUon.
^< FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF THE societies/'
** The Committee of Union is composed of
persons appointed by the people to look after
^cir interest ; and are consequently amenable
for their conduct to the people. Therefore
the people have the power of deposins by
means of a petition to the President or tlie
Committee of Union, and by him reported to
^e societies for misconduct in any of their
representatives.
*' Second, As representatives, the Com-
mittee of Union are mvested with every power
^eir constituents can claim ; the will of the
constituent at the appointment of his repre-
sentative is, that he watch over his interest as
a member of the community, but the will of
the constituent is the constituent himself.
Therefore if a representative is attacked in
the discharge of his duty, his constituents are
bound by nature, reason, and honour to defend
him.''
Mr. Afutruther, — ^I would call your atten*
tton to the appointment of collectors, and
particularly a tommittee of Ways and Means.
*' Each society shall appoint one or more
persons, the most active and intelligent to
ne collectors of money, and each of those col-
lectors are to have the superintendance of
fifteen or twenty persons, whom they are
enjoined to sit as oil as their time may allow.
What money they may collect is to be deli-
vered to the treasurer of their different socie*
ties every week.
*^ find. Such collectors are permanent,
unless disqualified by inattention or otherwise.
They are to meet with the Committee of
Ways and Means to report progress, once
«very three weeks.
*< V.—Of the Ext€ut cf Delegation,
" *^ 1st. The election of delegates, to the
Committee of Union, takes place on the first
Thursday of February, May, August, and
)ilovember, annually.
^ 9nd. Each 'society shall send a delegate
Jbr every twelve members to the Committee
of Union, with a letter, signed by the presi-
dent and secretary, for the time being. How
toon |m addition of twelve is made to any
society, that society is entitled to send an
additional delegate. But no society, however
liumerous, can send more than three repie-
aentatives.
** Srd. llie powers of such representatives
shall continue only fbr three months, at which
period, they must either be re-elected, or
ethers chosen in their room.
XVI.
u
1st. The aacietiet shall adbpl such regu-
lations, and adhere to such instructions as
the Committee of Ways and Means may think
proper to issue, afier being sanctioned by the
Committee oi' UmoQ.
** Snd. No nember altt)i introdaoe rdipoos
topics into debatCi nor motion for ptajrcti to be
said, either ai the gatheiing or di9HU«sioo of
the societies, because every thing that tends lo
strife and diversion must be avoided.
'' Lawi relative lo the Committee of Jlnian.
^ 1st. The Commitlee of Onion shell meet
once a week and elect a president every ineel*
ine, according as their names ata&d in the
roU. No member is to «ba«it hioM^f, with-
out assigning satisfactory reasons.
^9nd. The secretary shall continue in
office three months, during which period, he
has the keeping of the books.
'^ 3rd. It skwll be eligible, in anjr person,
properly delegated from any part of the thiee
kingdoms, toM members of this committee,
-^mit no foteigner can be admitted.
** 4th. No delegate shall send aiDother
person in his room, when he is prevented
from attending himself.
^ Ath. Both the presideiit snd aecretsiy are
subject to the same laws that legant the pi^
sident and aecretarv of societies.
^ 6th. None is allowed to speak in the dis-
cussion of any question but once, unless to
explain.
'^ 7th. The roll is to be re$d by the secrsp
tary at every meeting, so soon as the presi-
dent takes the chair, — ^which he must do pie»
cisely at eight o'clock, after which the minntes
of the preceding meeting are read, nnd tiie
order of the day called .
^ 8tb. The Committee of Ways and Meens
must report progress once a week.
^ 9th. No member is allowed to seeuss or
make any injurious reileotions on anotherp
neither in the Committee of Unitm, or in the
societies, without first sobmitttng the crounds
of his accusation to the Committee of Ways
and Means, and they to report to the Com-
mittee of Union, if, upon examination, ^ej
see sufficient reasons assigned,
** 10th. The name of the accuser is not to
be made public, unless the Cemmittee of
Ways and Means consider the grounds of
accusation wqrth^ of the attention of the
Committee of Union.
** 11th. Disinterestedneae, condescension^
and afieotion to one enother, must prevnil^ not
only amongst the members of the Conuaaitlce
of Union, mit amongst all the societies.
^ 19th. Heroism, and magnanimity of seal
must be cultivated, and every one most en*
deavour, in a prudent manner, to vie, who
will be moftt instrumental in forwsrdlne the
eloriom cause; — ^for, independent ann en-
brged minds give heneur and prefercnge od^
to merit.
^' Xoatf relatieoe to the CommiUen (jf Wi^ end
** 1st. The Oonamitlee of Ways and Means
is permanent, «nd the members of it havetita
power of expelling any one or more of its
members; for misconduct or iasttention.
1305]
fift High Treoion.
A. D. 1794.
[1306
^ tnd. Tliey have the neaHOBlkm to any
vacmcy in their <ywn body, also a diacretionary
power to laeet where, and when they please.
^ Std. It shall oeiuist of bo more than
seveDy nor of leas than four KTBons.
** 4th. The preadeot and Mcretaiy of the
Committiee ot Union, shall examine the
laoney fianaactions of the Committee of Ways
and Means, once every four weeks/'
Robert Orrock, sworn.
Mr. 2>ttaila0.— I think you are a smith ?«—
Yea.
You live at the Dean ?— Yes.
You are a member of the Water <^ Leith
Society f — Yes.
And I believe, a member of the Committee
of Union f — ^Yes.
And also a member of the Convention f--
Yes.
Now Robert, recollect yourself, do you
remember being present at the Committee of
15n\on, about the beginning of May, when
I they talked of sending arms mto the country f
—No.
You do not recollect that? — ^No ; I do not.
When did you first hear about arms at all ?
—It was before that.
At what time was it ?— I dare say it was in
March. I suppose it was about the latter end
of March.
Where was it? — ^It was in Geor^ Ross*s.
About what time in March was it ? — I sup-
pose it was near the end of March.
Do you recollect who was present at George
Ross's, when this conversation took place ? —
The first time that ever I heard it mentioned,
was at a reading of the newspapers, when
where present, Mr. Watt, Mr. M'Ewan, and
Mr. Downie, I believe^
Do you recollect what was said at that
time? tell us as near as vou can remember,
j&e sense and purport of the conversation.
The sense of the conversation was, — it was
in the news about an Invasion, — they began
to speak about it, and they were a saying,
that there were arms come to the Goldsmiths-
hall gentlemen ; — that was the sense, I believe,
to the best of my recollection.
Any thine more sdd to the best of your re-
collection, Robert?— Any thing more .>— Yes
*^the nextthine I heard said, but I could not
say positively who it was that said it,— We
had better appiv for some of them. It was
likewise said, that there was none that was
for a reform, that need apply, to the best of
Biy recollection.
Do you recollect an v thing more passing ?
•^Yes. I recollect of its l^ng said, but I
could not positively say by whom, — ^whether
it was Mr. Watt that said, that there was no
law in being, that could hinder us from getting
arms,— I am not certain.
Now, did Mr. Watt come to yon at the
Dean, in the course of the montii of April, or
soon after that time? — ^Yes.
Do you remember his coming to inquire
if you had made a certain weapon ?'— Yes.
What did he say?— He asked if I had.
What time might that be? — Sometime in
April.
What did you say to that ?-^I said I had.
And what passed then ? — He asked me to
make one of another pattern.
You sliowed him one as a pattern ?-*No ; be
did not see it.
How did he know what pattern?— »He
asked, I suppose he was told before I showed
him.
What said Watt to that?— He said he
thought such a pattern would be better ; it
was a kind of draft.
He showed you a draft of a different pat-
tern?-^ Yes.
What did he say ? — He asked me to make
one, and brin^ it in to show him.
Did you bnng in what you had made ?— >•
Yea.
Where to?— To George Ross*a
Who were there present when you brought
it ?-~There was Mr. Watt^ Mr. Downie, Mr.
Bonthrone, Mr. M'Ewan, and another man,
that I did not know.
What did you do ? — ^I showed them It.
And what did they say to that?— *He wAs
looking at it, and asked me.--
Who asked you ?— Mr. Watt.
Asked vou for what? — H^ desired me to go
out, after looking, which I did. He asked me,
before I went away, if I would leave it with
him all night, and I said I would, and did so.
When (fid you see Mr. Watt again ?— I saw
him that same nieht again.
And when dia you see him, after that
again ?— >I do not know, but it was at George
Iu>ss*s I saw him after that
Do you remember Mr. Watt coming to
your shop at the Dean, a few days aft^r that ?
—Yes.
Do you remember it? — ^Yes.
How long after that might it be, speakin<;
to your recollection ?-^About the first of May,
He came to your shop at the Dean, and
what did he desire you to do?-^He desired
me, that night at George Ross's, to make a
few of them.
A few of what?-^A few of these weapons.
These cross pikes?— Yes ;«-a few, without
anynumber.
Did he desire you to make any 6iheT sort
of pike ?— Yes.
How many of that other sort?— He said
two or three doeen.
Did he ask you how many you could make
in a week ?*»-'Ye8. Me, and nw two men.
What did you say?«— I said nfty.
Did you see Mr. watt sometime after that?
—Oh ! but there was more passed then.
Tell all that passed.— Wnen he said how
many could I make in a week and my m^n,
I said that quantity but I said possibly none ;
oh, said he, I am not upon that; that is not my
meaning; I took ft he conjectured he had
asked tne the price ; and I was really con*
sidering at the same time he was etkiilating
the price what I could a£brd them at; because.
1907] 34 GEORGE III.
ProceeiiMp againti Robert Watt
[1906
when I told him with respect to the price^
— ^possibly I might make none.
Was there any thing else passed ?-*He did
ask me to make two or three dozen of each
kind.
Now, you saw Mr. Watt sometime af^er*
wards ; did you not?-— Yes. And he likewise
spoke, and asked me, if I could get any sticks
for them ; I said, I dare say I might; that I
could.
Did any thing more pass at that time ?— I
do not recollect.
Do you recollect Mr. Watt coming to
inquire at your shop afterwards, if you had
made any process in your work? — It was the
day he was mquiring whether I had made
any progress, in GecNree Ross's. He asked
me to make a few, and then, when he came,
he asked me what progress 1 had made.
Do vou remember receiving a message
from Watt, by a person you did not know ? —
Yes.
What message was then brought to you ? —
He was twice there— When he came first, it
was askine, if there was something done,
which I dia not like to do at that time, when
Mr. Watt was out with me; I told him I had
not made any, for there was one of my men
away ; he said that was a pity, and he asked
me, whether I could get one ; I said I sup-
posed I might; I had not been in the town;
—I did not say he was to seek a man;— but
Mr. M'Ewan, some days after, said, Mr. Watt
had a kind of a man for me ; out I never saw
Mr. Watt, nor did he tell me that he had.
I ask you, what the message was, this un-
known person brought you from Mr. Watt ?—
[No answer.]
CotiW.-t-How do you know it was a me»-
lage from Mr. Watt, if you did not know the
roan ? — [No answer.]
Lord Advocate, — How did you know this
person came from Watt ? — He told me.
Mr. Ertkine. — ^That is hearsay.
Mr. AnstrtUher, — ^Let us ascertain the de-
livery of the message ; the man is not &r off,
and he will tell you from whom he received
it. — ^He was askmg me about making the in-
struments ; if I had ^t any of them ready ;
I said they were making.
Who was that person r— it was Martin Todd.
What message did Martin Todd bring to
you ? — It was asking me what I had made, or
St made, or was I making them ; that was
s first message ; I told him, 1 was making
them.
Whom did he say he brought this message
from ?— From Mr. Watt.
Whom was the second message from? —
The second message was showing me two
weapons.
Look upon the table, and see if you can
see one ot them?— I see one of them.
What did he tell you? — He desired I would
make mine in like manner ; — I said I wonld
not, and if I had known it, 1 would have
made none of them* .
Why would not you make tihcm of tbat
sort, Mr. Orrock?— I had a little more alatm
in myself at that time.
Now, what was your alarai for at that time ?
— ^I can give you that;-*I did not at fim
know how many there was of tkem.
When did you take the alami f — ^It was
when with him, William Brown came out to
me.
Who was he ? — A smith.
Where did he live ?— He Ihresat Goosedab.
— ^I say William Brown came out to me, and
asking me ; says he, you are makine so and
so; I was at a meetine of the Friendlj
Society that night ; and ne sent for me out,
and he asked me, if I was making so and ao
for Watt; and then asked me, what would
we do for sticks ;— and I said, what was U»
hinder us to get sticks ? He said there woaU
be thousands wanted.
Mr. AnstnUker.'^l am de&irins him to ex-
plain the cause of his alarm. Why were joa
alarmed ? — Because thousands would be
wanted in the first place. I am telling you
when Watt spoke to me, be spoke m no
sort of secret way, but very open. William
Brown seemed all in hidlings.
Why were you fnehtened, Robert? yoa.
know, if thousMMls of 3iem were wanted, jou
would have more trade. — It was not for tbac^
beoause, if there had been thousands viranted,
I coukl make thousands as well as fifty, that
did not alarm me in the least.
What did alarm you ?— I will give you that ,
because, in making them, I did not like it
being in such a hidling concealed manner ; I
thought Uiere need not be so much hidling.
How many of tliese pikes did Watt order
from you altogether ?--kr. Watt said, to my
knowledge, you can make three dozen in one
week, and theahe canle to five dozen.
Did you ever hear any this^ ^bout their
being for the top of a gate ?— Yes.
Now, who told you any thing about their
being for the top of a gatef—Mr. Watt.
What did he say ?-^He said, what would I
say when I was makiiu; them, supposing none
of them finished ? what would I say to in-
?uisitive people that would be asking of me?
answered I do not know.
What did he then sav to you?— That I
miffht say they were for tne top of a gate or a
railing.
Did you ever see such things as these
upon tlie top of a gnite ?-— I have seen aoma-
xhlof like tne stiaignt ones.
Did you ^er see the cross ones on the top
ofajgate?— Ko.
Did you ever see any of the crossrones
upon thie head of a halbert ? — ^Yes.
Was there any thing said about laying
them by ?— He said, I might lay them by or
put them by as soon as nuue.
Did not you think it very odd that he should
tell you these were for the top of a gate ?—
No, I was never much alarmed at that.
What weie the sticks for ?--[No answer.]
ISOOQ
J^ H^h Treoion.
A. D. 17S4^
[1310
Had you an order-for anymore of tlMee
than five dozen ?— -I had no more,
You got ialarroed about them ?«^Ye8.
AVhy were you alarmed f ^hat purpose did
you tlaink they were fori when they were be-
spoke ? — I thought they were defensive wea*
pons for the <:ountry incase of invasion.
What did you think?— I did not think
thr re was occasion for any secrecy.
Did you not think they were for another
purpose?^-! did.
f- Where were they to send the pikes? — He
did not say. .
He never mentioned any number? who
was to pay you for these pikes ? — ^Mr. Watt,
1 knew, no other, I suspected him to be the
pavmaster.
Were you ever told somebody else was to
be vour paymaster ? — I was by Mr. M'Ewan.
And whom were you to be paid by ? — By
Mr. Downie.
Did you not think it a very odd thing pikes
should be ordered by one man and paid for
, .by another ? — ^That was part of my reason, as
, I told you before, for my bein^; alarmed.
You thought it an odd thmg that pikes
should be onlered by one man, and paid for
by another? who was to get those piKes ? — I
do not know what he intended, but he did
not say to me who was to get them.
Did you ever take home any pikes? —
Home ! where.
To Mr. Watt's ?— I never did.
What became of those which you made?
.were they seized by any sheriff officer P^Yes.
Were you taken up at the sameUme? —
Yes, there were some in the shop that were
not finished.
Were all that were in your shop got ?— No,
they were not all found.
Some of those on the table are of your
making ? — Yes.
What became of those that were not gpt ?
— That is what I cannot tell.
Robert, were you a member of the Com-
mittee of Union? — ^Yes.
Where did it meet?-- >It met in George
Ross's.
What was the purpose of that Committee
( of Union ?^ — There was no other purpose than
meeting and getting news from ptner socie-
ties ; and there was to be a convention ; and
the getting up money for the delegates that
were to go to it.
) Lord Freiident.'^lle said all in his shop
< pWere not found? — ^I know certainlv they
were not all got I came in along with what
Did you know where the rest were ?— The
rest weie iust in the shop.
Were they all open in tlie shop ?— There
were none hidden.
How came they to take some and leave
.others ?— Because they were not in the same
pkce.
How came they not to be in the same
place ?-*-They were lying under the vice-
board. Always when we soflen any iron^ we
shoot them in the ashes, and there were two
or three of them lying in the ashes, and the
rest were below the vice-board. I will give
you all candidly.
Now, you say, this Committee of Union
was to choose members from another com-
mittee to collect money for them?:— No, I
understand it was always in the other com-
mittee; they were leading men, and there
was money given; they got 15s. from us.
What was that convention to do ? — I never
heard it was for any thing but to meet for
universal reform.
Now, Robert, did you ever hear of any
Committee of Ways and Means ? — ^Yes.
Do you know of any Committee of Ways
and Means ? — ^Yes.
Do you know that Watt was a member?—
Yes.
Do you know that Downie was a member?
-^Yes.
Now, Robert, who was to make the sticks
for these ? — I said I could eet them made by
different persons ; to the best of my recol-
lection I mentioned Mr. Black.
How many sticks were to be wanted ?— I
was to get sticks for as many as I was to
make.
Did you ever hear any thing about some
thousand sticks wanted ? — ^Yes.
Then, I believe you were determined not
to make any more pikes after what you had
heard ? — Yes.
Why did you determine so ?— I thought it
at first was not for that intent, and I began
to be alarmed as to the hidlings of them. I
could not positively say what they were for.
Did you not begin to be frightened because
you thought a few pikes might just as well
fet the end you had m view, as a petition ?««
never had that in view.
You began to be frightened?— I did, be-
cause I did not know what use he intended to
make of them.
Did Mr. Watt ever give you any orders for
pikes before ?— Never.
Did ever any other body give you orders for
pikes ?— No.
Did you ever know any other body that
dealt in that manufacture ? — ^No.
Now, Robert, you said somethihg about a
pike which you had made before Mr. Watt
bespoke this of you? — Yes.
What has become of that ? — I do not know,
it was left with Mr. Watt
That was the pike you left with Mr. Watt
the first night ? — Yes.
Who employed you to make that?-^I did
it immediately myself. I told you that ia
my first declaration.
I know nothing of a declaration you made
any where but here; who employed you to
make that pike f-— Nobody.
You made it for yourself? — ^Ycs, when th^y
were speaking of arms, I said I would make
arms for myself.
]S11] S4 GEORGE III.
Proceedmgs againti Rokert Watt
Cisis
Mir. Amintiiar^-^hi the Committee of
Union, there was a diecourM about making
of arms. He told the committee he would
muke aitns for himself ; Watt wanted to see
a pike he had made*-he saw that, aid em-
ployed hmu
Watisaw the first pike you made ?-— Yes.
Clross-examined by Mr. HamiUon,
Tou said Watt told you, you might say they
were for the top of a gate. — ^Yes.
How did he express himself, did he seem
serious or in iest^ — ^No, he did not seem se-
rious ; he dia not say they were to be made
in a concealed manner^ but just to tell any
officious person they were made for the top
ofa eate.
When you are making any thing in your
shop, is it common for you to say it is made
for one thing wlien it is made for another ?
—When a man comes and asks such ques-
tions, I oeJI it fishing—that I thought they
had very little business with.
Is it toe usual direction of those who em-
ploy you, to tell those who ask you about it,
that you are making such work for one pur-
pose when you are making it for another ? —
No, sir.
Mr. Amtrtaher. — Ue has never said people
gave him that direction.
Mr. Hamiitott. — Do vou sometimes get di-
rections from people tnat employ you to say
things are made for one purpose that are
made for another ? — ^To inquisitive people I
have, in certain thing;^ ; but it is not common
nor a customary thing.
Martin Todd sworn.
Mr. Dundoi,^-! understand you do not hear
easily? — ^No, I am hard of hearing.
You are a smith are not you ? — Yes, sir.
And I believe you bdongod to the CaJton
eociety of the Friends of the People, did not
you ? — ^Yes, sir.
Do you remember receiving a messaee
from Mr. Watt to carry to Mr. Orrock f recol-
lect yourself and take your time. — I remember
goine with one.
What did you go for ?— -I went to Mr. Or-
rock with a bundle and parcel.
For what?— I cannot say what it was.
What did Watt desire you to say to Orrock f
^I do not remember any thing materiid he
desired roe to say : he ordered me to give him
a parcel. I gave it to Mr. Orrock.
What was the parcel ?— I do not know per-
fectly what it was. I believe it was one of
these things. [Looking at the pikes on the
table in courti]
Mr. Anitnuher.—We should call that a
pike, not a parcel ? — But it was in a parcel
when I had it.
Was it opened by Orrock in your presence?
— It was.
What was the messa^ ? — ^He ordered me
to take it back to Mr. Watt with ■ his compli*
ments, and tlut he was going on wilh the
things as fast aa post ible.
What thinga?— The things that wvre in
the narcel.
What things? — Things like this I aippoee.
[Pointitte to toe weapons on the table.)
What Mcame of them then? — ^I brow^
tbem back, and gave them ta» Mr. WaU.
There were two messages you earned ?--^
No, sb, nottfaat I rameawer »t prcseai. I
do not think there were two.
Mr. Diiiula*.— Did you ODdentand that Or-
rock was to employ you ? — ^No.
William Brown, senior, called.
Brown, — My lords, I want my liberty 1
have been kept these four months in gaol.
Lord Advocate. — ^You are called here to
five your evidence, do you refiise it ? — ^No, I
o not.
WilUaTn Broam, sworn.
Do you know a person of the name of Bo-
bertson ? — ^Yes.
Did Mr. Robertson ever ask you abcHit flak-
ing any spears ?-^Yes.
What aid he say ?— He asked me if I wo«U
make some spears for a Mr. Watt.
What did you say to that?— I said I did
not know.
What more did you say?— I do not it-
member
What did Mr. Robertson say to you ? — ^He
said, if I was in the town, I might call iipoo
Mr. Watt and see himself.
Did you ever see Mr. Watt after that ? Bid
you call upon him ? — Yes.
And what oassed between you and
Mr. Watt ? — He snowed me a spear, aad asluti
me if I would make some like that.
What sort ofa spear did he show yoa? see
if you see any thing like that lying npoB the
table there, turn them over. — I do not see it
here.
What conversation had you wilb Robert-
son about Watt? — Robertson said he was a
merchant.
Where ?~*Below the New Bridge^ on the
north side of the High-street.
Where did you call upon him ?— When I
was down a little belbw- the close.
What close ? — Below Canubber's close.
Now, when you called upon Watt in tha
close, what conversation bad you with faim >
I do not think I was above five miaiitca
with him.
Did he show you a pike ? — He showed me
a pike, but I-do net see it, it was like that one,
a screw one with a spike halbert-head> a loi%
pike.
What did Watt sav ?— He asked if I weuld
make one like that, bat a little larger.
What did you say ?— That I would see aai
make them.
Did you make aay ?-— I-madeone:
See if yott cansce one like, it?— I
131S]
Jbr H^h Treoim.
it, tbere was no patticular malic
A. D. 1794*
[1314
Obox is
upon it.
Did that ferrule screw off in your's ?— It
was just the satne.
- Did it screw off ?-^Whether it be that or no
I do not know^ I made another one, but then
Mr. Watt did not get it/
Did you ever nuikd another screw for it }
—No.
Did you ever make another stick for it?
—No.
How many of these did Watt order ftom
you? — He set no quantity, he said two or
three.
Wa^ it half a dozen ?-^I took it to be there*
abouts.
Did he say half a dozen ? — ^He did not
seem to say. any quantity of them.
That you call a cross pike^ do not you ? —
I do not know what you call it, but it must be
cross, I do not know what name to put to it
Did you ever see Watt again ? — ^Yes.
U]^!! ^Hat occasion?-^! saw him some
I tioie afterwards. He came to see if I had
made any.
I Where do you live ?— At the Goosedub. I
ahowed him 6ne similar to it, half done.
. Did you ever see him a^n ? — ^Yes.
J Had you any conversation with him about
I the pik^s.or spcar-heads bein^; ready ?— That
was wh^ he came out at this time, when I
showed this half done. I did not choose to
make any more of them of that kind. He
said he md not want any more of them. He
wanted mole spears straight. I did not know
what it was for, and I did not choose to make
' any more of that kind.
' Did you ever ask Mr. Watt what they were
for ?— No.
I ' How many did you make ?— I made only
one for Mr. Watt, but there was another that
went another wav.
' Who took that away?— There was a
plumber's apprentice took it away.
What was his name?— Of the name of
Allan. He took it away at the time.
Allan did not pav you at that time? — ^No.
Did YOU ever make any other spears ? — He
ordered me to make some mole spears.
Did he order you to make any straisht
spears? — I said that was4nole spears. He
answered, yes. He wanted some straight
spears with a socket like a fork. I said that
was like mole spears, and he answered, ves.
Did you ever make any mole spears ?•»!
sud, I would make some and bring them in,
and see if they were the things he meant.
Did you make any? — ^I made two, and
brought them in.
How many did you make ? — Fourteen al-
together. The first two^ I took in, he said,
would do.
How came you to make the fourteen?— I
delivered the two first to him, and then a do-
zen of the straight ones.
Were you paid for them?— Yes.
Who paid you ?«— Mr. Watt said, he was
VOLXXin.
sorry, when I went in, that he had not mo-
ney to pay me. I told him I was needing
money. He sud, if that was the case, he
would give me a line upon one Mr. Downie,
and he would give me the money, as he had it
not.
Did you get the money ? — ^Yes.
from whom ? — Mr. Downie.
Who was he ? — A jeweller in Parliament
square.
Where did you carry these pikes ? — ^I carried .
them to that house where Mr. Watt was.
Look at them, and see if you know your
own work ? — I have no particular mark, they
were of the same shape, make, and size.
Did you ever make a mole spear like that ?
—Yes.
For whom ? — I cannot tell.
Ast>ig as that ? — Much the same.
How many did you mak^ ? — I cannot say,
some people make them one shape, some ano-
ther ; some smaller and some larger.
How many cross pikes did Watt order ?— He
did not mention any ouantity, he said two or'
three. I took it to be half a dozen. I did not
understand it to be any quantity.
Did you ever see Robert Orrock ?-7-Yes.
Had you ever anv conversation with him
about these spears ?— Yes.
What was that?— I was at the Water of
Leith about some business, and we werc^
spedcing about it, and I said I was making
some mole spears ; he said he was making
some for the top of a rail, and some cross
ones. I never had seen any of them, but he
did not tell me who he was making them for.
Did Yoii tell him who you were making
your's ror? — I am not very certain whether I
did or not.
Dkl Mr. Watt ever tell you any thing more ?
—No.
Were you making no more for Watt ? — No.
Had you an order for making more?— I do
not know that I had, whether ne ordered me
to make some more or not I cannot be posi-
tive to that point ; whether he bid me make
a dozen or half a dozen more or not I am not
positive.
Did any body ever tell you about any or-
ders that Mr. Watt had got from tiie coun-
try ?— No.
Do not you recollect that?— No, I do not
recollect that.
Cross-examined by Mr. HandUon*
You said you had some conversation with
Orrock ; did you ever see any pikes of his
making?— I never did.
Had you any conversation with Orrock
about pikes ?— I had some conversation with
Orrock about pikes, he said they were for the
top of a rail.
Had you any conversation with him abouf
sticks ? — No, none that I remember.-
Mr. Amtruther, — I have just now been in-
formed that one of the*witnesses (Fairley) de-
sires he may be called in to correct some part
4P
1315] S4 GEORGE lil.
Proceedingi agi^ii Robert Watt
[isie
of bis evidence. I shall not saj a word to
him.
Lard Adtccate. — ^I shall not put a single
question to him.
[Fairley brought into court.]
Lord Pretident.-^Mr. Fairley, a message
has come from you, desiring leave to explain
something in your former evi4encey what was
it?
lVur^.-^I recollect Mr. Watt saying the
banks and public offices were to be seized.
Court, — C^n you recollect any other cir-
cumstances ? — X cannot recollect any other
particulars, unless a question was put* I re-
collect Watt said those who were most active
against us were to be imprisoned.
Say that again.— Those who were most
active aeaiust us were to be imprisoned^ and
the banEs and public offices to be seized ; and
that couriers were to go into the country.
Mr. Hamilton — .When did he say that? —
He said there would be more who would start
up; and that those most active against us
were to be seized ; and couriers were to be
sent to announce it, or that couriers were to
be sent to the country to announce this.
Mr. Hamilton. — ^Have you had any conver-
sation with any person since you went oat of
the room ? — No, sir, I have not.
Who did you understand was meant by
** those that were a«unst us/' who were to be
seized at that time F— That is, those that were
against us were to be arrested or something
of that kind.
Did he mention any particular person? — I
do not know that he did.
Did he mention anv particular person ?— I
cannot say whether he mentioned the ma^
gistrates of Edinbiirsh. I do not recollect any
other persons. I wink the nuu^stratea of
Edinburgh were spoken of. Dia he express
bimself as if they had any particular resent-
ment against them for any particular cause, or
why those persons were to be sei^ ? — He did
not sav.
i^xplain that -. was it expressed as animosity
a^nst those persons on account of proceedings
inimical to tliem ? — 1 suppose so.
WiUiam Robertion, sworn.
Mr. Angtruther. — Do you know Robert
Watt?— I have seen Robert Watt
Had you any conversation with him about
spears f — Once.
What was that conversation, Mr. Robc^rt-
8on ?— He asked me if I knew any smith that
would make those things.
What things?— Spears.
What did you say ?— I said I did, I knew
ppe William Brown. '
Had you any conversation with Brown upon
the subject? — I spoke to him about it, and
asked if he would make them.
. Did you do that by Mr. Watf s desire ?—
Ko.
Now, what conversation had you with
Blown upon that snbject ?-^I asked him if her
would make them.
What did Brown say ?— He ssid he was not
very sure at that time.
Had you any other conversation with Watt
about it? — ^Yes, once he asked me if I had
spoke to Brovm.
What said you?— That I had.
S))oke to Brown about what ? — ^About speart.
Did Watt tell you what those spears woe
for ? — ^No — he did not.
Did you ever ask Watt what they were f«t
—No, I never did.
Did it not strike you it was an odd thiols
man in Watt's situation should be ordering
spears ? — I did not think any thing aboatitat
tnat time.
Did you think any thing about it aince?-
No.
Had you no conversation with Watt about it
at alU-o-No, I did not ask him any queadoo
at all.
I believe yon were a member of the Biitisb
Convention ?-«Yes.
Do you know a person of thenameofSkir'
vine ?— Yes.
You have written him some letters?— One
letter.
Where do you live > What part of thetown
do you live in ? — ^In SymonVsquare.
Now, sit down and read that letter quielljr.
Tell me first whether it is your band- writing?
—It is. « Edinburgh, April Wh 1794."
[The witness looked over the letter.]
Lord .iiApocatt.— Did you write that leOer
of the date it bears ?^-Yes, I did write thai
letter.
Now. what was the number of your Soaetr
at the dispersion of the British CoDventioor
—I do not recoUeet particularly what tba
number was.
About how many ?— I could not really saj
how many at that time.
About how many Mr, Robertson? x«|
could tell Mr. Skhring, you might as weH
tell me.— I could not be positive how nuny
at that time. . ^
Was it from thirteen to twenty ?— It nugK
be twenty, or between thirteen and twenty.
Did it mcrease much after the dispersfflg*^
the British Convention ?— It increased vflj
fast. 1^
Thcv increased very fnst after that? to hot
many iid they increase ?— They might be dot
one hundred. ,
I believe your school was the phicc wtierB
the British Convention met the day alter u
was dispersed ? — No, it was not.
It met in your neighbourhood ?— Yes.
Did it meet in your school nStec^^°^^^
No, it never did. . _„
The Friends of the People met in y<»ff
school? — A society met . .^lj
That is the society that increased so in«oii
—Yes.
Now, what was the olgect of that
BSirj
fbrHi^ TrtM9fm»
A. D. 1794^
[1918
— I know -df iio olject bat to obtain a re-
(form.
What sort of a reform P^-Universal Sufiira^
4uul Annual Parliaments.
Was there any obstacle to the fnsosecytion
4>f that end ?-^ do not know. There was a
meeting.
Was there aay ohstade to it? — ^There lA'as
no obstacle, but a petition to narliament.
But what was the obstacle that stood in the
tway of it? — I did not see any, but to petition
.parliament.
You could tell Skirving, now, you may as
'well tell me?*I could not say what was the
iotmtacle.
Did you think that poverty was the obsta-
wcle ? — They could not get their petitions made
up so soon owing to that
Did you ever hear of a Committee ofUnion?
— I have heard of it.
Were you ever at it? — I never was at it.
1 know it was a Committee of Union.
Were you ever at the General Committee ?
— ^Yes, it went from Januar)[ to March by the
name of the General Committee.
I ^ink you were secretary to that General
Committee? — I never was secretary except
4>ne night.
Ana Stock was president of preses that
night ? — I do not recollect
Do you recollect any motion made that
night? See if you remember that motion
made in the committee ? — ^Yes. I remember
€here was some motion of that kind.
There was a motion to that effect ?— Yes.
Was that motion carried ?— Not that night.
It is not in my memory.
Who proposed it ? — I cannot say who pro-
posed it first.
Was it proposed by a person whose name
is there ? read that, and tell me whether it
was proposed by the person named there?
— I do not know whether it was Mr. Watt
that proposed that motion that night or not.
Was he there ? — ^I think he was, but I can-
not be certain whether he proposed that mo-
tion or not.
Mr. Anttryiher.'^lX is the paper that lias
been read already for the institution of that
committee.
Did your society send delegates to the con*
-vention ?--They sent three.
Do you recollect their names? — I think
Mr. Stock was a delegate.
Mr. Stock was a detegate from your society ?
—Yes.
Who was the other ? — One Mr. Hardvman.
Who was the other ?— I cannot recollect
Have you ever heard any tfain^ of a Com-
mittee of Ways and Means ?~-I have heard
of it
What was it ? — I have heard no more but
that there was such a committee.
Now, what was the purpose of that com-
mittee, to which you sent delegates ? — It was
to fomi a correspondence among tiie societies
m Edinburf h.
Do you know of any correspondence in the
countiy with that committee ? — ^No, I do not.
Do you know any thing of one person going
to the north and another to the west?-!
heard of them going, but did not know them.
Whom did you hear of them from ?— I
heard of them from several.
Name them ? -I cannot name them.
Who were the persons that told you of one
person ^ing to the north and another to the
west ?— -I believe I heard it openly in the so-
ciety ; I cannot recollect any person in parti-
cular.
You do not /ecollect^ you say, who it was ?
— No, I do not.
Do you know any thing about greater se-
cresy being observed in your proceedings now
than formerly ? — I might have said something
to that purpose, it was merely myself, no
other po'son has said it, I could not say but
there might be more seeresy.
Do not you know that there was ? — I can-
not answer that question.
[No cross-examination.]
Cowrt. — Should you know Mr. Watt if you '
saw him a^n ? — ^Yes, I believe I would.
Look and see if you see him at the bar. Is
that Mr. Watt ?— Yes.
Mr. Anttruiher, — ^Is that the person that
gave you the message to Brown ? — ^Yes.
Walter Miller caUed.
Walter Miller. — My lords, I have some
difficulties, before I can submit to be a wit-
ness in this trial ; when I am called an ho-
nest man, and abiding b^ the laws, I have no
objection to give my evidence ; but when I
have been imprisoned for several months past,
it ma^ appear I come here guihy of all
the crimes laid to those men; it that be the
intention of the prosecutor, I beg he will in-
dict me.
LiMKi Advocate. — ^I have no such intention.
Walter Miller^ merchant, sworn.
Mr. Anttruther. — ^Now, Mr. Miller,. I wijl
tell you before you begin, that you are not-
bound to answer any questions that tend to
criminate yourself. The first question I ask
you is, whether that letter ever came to you
by post [showing him a letter] ? — Yes^ that
letter certainly came to me.
How did it come to you ? — By post.
Look» at it, there is no post mark ?— There
is undoubtedly a post mark.
Do you know whom it came from ?*— It is
signed by the gentleman that sent it, I sup-
pose.
Look carefully at it, and look at the back
of it, then the side of it, do not be in such a
hurry. — ^The answer was to be sent to Ross,
Liberty-court
Was there an answer sent to London ?—
There was none sent to Edinburgh ; there
was an answer sent to London, I believe.
Do you believe it was ^ent^ were you at'
1319] S4f GEORGE IIL
ProceediMgM agmnsi Robert WaU
[ISSO
the meetiD^ that resolved upon writing an
answer to it ? — Yes^ I certainly was at the
meeting.
Was it an answer agreeing with the letter
or not ? — ^Yes, it was an answer so far that if
a convention was called, we resolved to send
a delegate.
Did vou ever remit any money to Edin-
burgh for the purpose of the Friends of the
People? — ^Yes, I aid.
. In consequence of what did you remit it,
and by whose directions did you remit it ? —
"Why, I remitted the money in consequence
of being appointed treasurer for the society of
the Friends of the People at Perth.
How much? — Fifteen pounds sterling.
To whom did you remit it ?— To Mr. Dow-
nie.
Why was it to be remitted to Mr. Downie ?
—Because I understood some instructions
had come to our place to some person or
other to send any money we were sending to
Edinburgh to Mr. Downie. We understood
he was treasurer of those societies.
What societies ? — SocieUes of the Friends
of the People.
What was the purpose of remitting that,
money ? — For relief of patriots, and support
of the cause of freedom.
Did not those instructions come to your-
self?—No.
Did that letter ever come to you, Mr. Miller ?
— ^Yes, it did.
Was it before or after that letter came to
you that you remitted the money? — ^As to
that I do not know, but it was a considerable
time before this letter came to me that this
money was gathered for that purpose.
Was it before or after that letter came to
you, you remitted it ? — It was certsdnly ailer,
lor no letter came directed to me before I re-
mitted the monejr.
How were you informed that Downie was
treasurer for the Friends of the People ?— I
told you before some people in PcrUi got it
by word of mouth or letter.
Mr. AmtnUker.-^Thc letter is signed, ^* T.
Hardy."
Cross-examined by, Mr. Hamilton,
^ You mentioned you had agreed in your so-
cieties to choose a delegate to send to the
convention ? — ^Yes.
Did not you understand in that convention,
it was their intent to procure a reform by
lejgal means ? — Certainly it was for the cause
ofa reform, for carrying it on.
Did you think or did you suppose the ob-
ject and intent of that convention to which
the delegates were to be sent was, to subvert
the authority of this kingdom? — I had no
supposition of it at all.
Arthur M^Ewan e?camined again.
The night when the Committee of Ways
and Means raet^ when Watt told you of tne
plan you have told us of already^ for what
purpose did it meet that ni^>-— I do not
know what purpose it met for, only it was m
use to meet weekly.
Was it not toranswer a circular letter that,
nisht ? — I do not know of it.
Did you ever see a letter signed ^ T*
Hardy ?"— No.
Did you ever know of an answer sent to
Hardy ? — ^No, never.'
Did you ever know of any conversation re-
specting the mode in which the correspon-
dence between your society and Hardy was to
be carried on? — I never heard it till Mr.
Stuck said be was to do every thing in hb
power to open a correspondence between
Watt and Hardy.
Was it that night the committee met or
not? — It was the last night that the com*
mittee met.
Was it not that night they were to answer
a letter from Hardy ? — ^No, there was no letter
wrote that night.
Was not Stock to carry a letter to Hardy }
-^Not that I know of.
How was that correspondence between
Hardy and Watt to be carried on, did Stock
plan some mode of correspondence between
Hardy and Watt ; what passed upon that co-
coon ? — I could not make it distinct how
he was to carry it on, it was to be done in
such a droll wa^, I could not make it distinct;
if I recollect right he had a oiece of paper,
and it was like dividing down tnis way [draw-
ing his finjger down the centre of the paper in
a perpendicular line] the aristocrats amng so
and so on one side, and the democrats doing
so and so on the other side.
Then the correspondence was to be carried
on in two columns? — ^Yes, I suppose so firom
the mode he proposed tliat night.
What was the meaning of canyingona
correspondence in such away } — ^I cannot telL
Did it not strike you as odd to be canTing
on sucH a correspondence ? — It did, sir.
Prisoner, -^Hil^^y I put a question to that
man?
Court, — Certainly.
Prisoner.— You are asked whether or not
any correspondence was to take place be-
tween Haray and me, rather than any other
person ? — ^I mentioned this, that Stock did
say, you wished to have a correspondcnoa
with Mr. Hardy, and you could not seUfe
upon a sure plan how you could correspond,
and Mr. Stock drew out that model upon
which you could correspond with safety. Jlr.
Stock drew the plan. I thought the design
fixed on his part^ was to carry on that corres-
pondence, notwithstanding that plan drawn
out by Stock. I did not see it, but Mr. Stock
drew out the plan by which you should cor-
respond with Mr. Hardy.
Prisoner, — That I did wish to correspond
with Mr. Hardy? — That you wished to cor-
respond with Mr. Hardy.
The Lord Advocate, — ^I think it my duty to
the Court and jury to stale, that we mean to.
I
19213
fvr High Treason.
leave the diarge i^nst the prisoner at the
jbar, upon the evidence written and parole that
Jias now been given to the jury.
Mr. Ertkine then inforined the Court, that
xmly one of the counsel for Mr. Watt proj^oeed
to address the jury, which Mr. Uainiiton
would do, when the evidence for the prisoner
was closed. Being desired by the Court to
«tate in general the points to which he meant
to call evidence for the prisoner, he stated
that in genera), he would infomi the Court
and jury, that Mr. Watt first of all applied to
Mr.Dundas, then secretary of state, convey- I das's answer.
A. D. 1794. [1323
Is that a scroll of a letter to Mr. Dundas f
— ^Yes, it is a scroll of a letter. I brought here
all the papers I found.
Mr. krutruther, — ^What is it they are ask-
ing for ?
Mr. Ertkine, — ^It is a letter to Mr. Dundas
we wish to have.
Mr. Anstnaher, — ^I have not the least ob-
jection to your making use of any letter of
Watt's in evidence.
Mr. Sheriff Clerk^^Tbvt appears to roe to
be the letter that was the cause of Mr. Dun-
hag cert^n intelligence with regard to the
proceedings of certun societies, which ap-
peared to Mr. WaUjof a seditious nature; and
that he was recommended by Mr. Dundas to
;the lord advocate both by letter and conver-
sation. This communication with the lord
advocate continued from the end of 1798,
to the end of 1793, when the British Con^
vention met, whose proceedings their loid-
ahips would recollect, were all published
in the newspapers; from that time there
was no communication with Mr. Watt.
Then Mr. Watt became a member of the
Committee of Ways and Means, the lord
advocate went to London, Mr. Watt would
have conveyed such an account of the pro-
ceedings, but from the beginning of Marcri to
the 15th of May, the lord advocate was in
London : Watt when taken up by Mr. Sheriff
Clerk, said, he could not say any thing in
answer to him till the lord advocate eame to
town. This is in general the proof meant ta
be adduced.
Mr. Sheriff CUrk called as a witness for the
Defendant.
Mr. Erffcmc— You searched Mr. Watt's
house? — Yes.
You foiuid some papers ? — ^Yes.
Did you find any letter firom Mr. Dundas to
Mr. Watt ?— I found one among others.
Did you find this ? — I do not recollect any
iChing of that paper, there is no maxk on it.
Mr. Watt was examined before you ? — ^Mr.
Watt was examined.
Was he open to you upon the subject ? —
^r. Watt was brought up upon the 15th of
May, along with tne arms found in his
house, and was interrogated by me respect-
ing them. He declineo giving any explana-
tion, and save for answer that he communi-
cated with Mr. Dundas and the lonl advo-
cate about certain circumstances, he did not
choose to give an answer. I told him ih\s
would not do, and that these arms were a
very suspicious circumstance. I desired to
know what use he intended jto make of them,
when he told me, you will tnd l}ang upon
my table, an advertisement for the news-
napers, intimating that pikes were to be sold
ny me at so muah a-piece. I think it is a
laudable thing of me as a merchant in fair
trade, and I as a merchant am entitled to
jdoit.
Lord Advocate,'~'l have no objection to its
production.
Mr. Knapp.'^li is dated August the 31st
1792.
Mr. JiMfm/Aer.-- That paper as it stands is
not, and I believe, cannot be made evidence;
it is a paper in Watfs hand-writing, found in
his house^ purporting to be a letter to some-
body; it IS attemp'ted to be made evidence by
proving that ^e contents of that letter, seem
to relate to a letter of Mr. Dundas's found in
the possession of the prisoner ; that could not
in any view of the case make it evidence, all
the papers found in the possession of the pri*
soner are evidence against him, but it is un-
possible pretended copies of letters, said to be
written by him, found in his possession, in
his own hand-writing, can be evidence with-
out something more ; at the same time, so
fiu- from the counsd for the crown, on the
present occasion, wishing to press things
against the prisoner, or preclude the prisoner
from producm^ any thing he may think tends
to exculpate him, whether it be legal evidence
or not, that they have not the smallest ob-
jection to these being read. I onl^ thought
it necessary to state this, not to object to the
papers being read whicn I know not to be
legal evidence, but to prevent the doing of it
in this case, firom being stated as a ground
for its beins done in another trial.
Mr. En&ne to Lord Advocate.— I must call
upon your lordship. '
Mr. Afutf^her.-^'Do you mean to read the
letter.
Mr. Ertkine. — ^Yes.
Jjfrd Pretident, — ^You said all the circum-
stances of the pikes being found, happened
between February and l&y. I understand
that was during the ceasing of the correspon-
dence between the prisoner and Mr. Dundas ?
Lord Advocate^ — Yes.
[That letter read*, dated August 3 Ist, 1792.]
** Although I have not the honour of being
known by you, yet firom my attachment to
the constitution of Ais country, and of which
I have the happiness of being a native, and
the fears I entertain of its constitution oeing
* See Burnett's ^ Treatise on Various Bran-
ches of the Criminal Law of Scotland/* chap,
xziv.
ISSSJ S4 GEORGE Itt.
ProceeXngi agtanst Robert WaU
[ISM,
subverted • have hereby taken Ihe liberty *of
laying betoreyou facts which merit your most
serious attention. For some years I have ob-
served accounts of associations formed in
different boroughs in Scotland for petitioning
parliament for the redress of gnevances, but
knowing the character and comparatively the
smallness of the number of those who compose
the society at Perth, from a residence there of
eleven years at my education, and of those in
Edinburgh from a residence of eleven years in
business, part of which acting as a clerk to a
respectable house, and the remainder on my
own account, and from the year 1789, have
informed myself of the character of many of
those who compose the societies at Glasgow,
and Dundee, ousiness, requiring me to be
frequently in these and other parts of the
country, I was satisfied to find that Perth did
firom year to year oppose petitions that had no
other tendency than to vitiate the morals of
the inhabitants, and get into the magistracy,
men of weak heads and factious minds; but
sir, when I see and hear of societies forming
in conjunction with those already mentioned
in this city and in other parts of the country,
when principles strike at the very root of the
British Constitution ; I cannot, as a friend to
my country, but inform you of their proceed-
ings and intentions ; the leaders of these fac-
tious clubs have the audacity to go from house
to house, endeavouring to enamour the weak
in understanding, and to inflame factions in
minds by representing to them certain sup-
posed grievances, and enforcing, by suspicious
arguments, the evil consequences that will un-
avoidably result to the nation if they are not
speedily redrest; being visited b^ Mr. William
Johnson, the chairman of their committee
here, accompanied by another gentleman, I
was, aflersome conversation,invited to attend
the committee which was to meet in Mather's
Tavern that evening, the S4th current ; from
a desire of knowing more particularly the na-
ture and tendency of sucli an association I
complied ; thd only business before them was,
the readiujg of a letter from the chairman of
the societies at Glasgow and Perth, and ap-
pointing the time and place of a general
meeting here ; after business was over I pro-
posed to Mr. Johnson and four gentlemen to
whom he seemed to pay more than ordinary
attention te sup together, to which they
agreed ; my intention in this was, to learn if
possible their secret designs, in which I was
in some measure successful, their sentiments
on politics were such as astoiushed me how
any reasonable man living under the ^tish
government could adopt and have the assur-
ance to express; the ministry must be dis-
placed; government expenses retrenched;
none beloDciug to the treasury should have a
seat in parfiament. The following expression
of one of the gentlemen, in a committee of
fourteen, met kst n^ht in the same tavern,
and received with gre«t applause, will inform
you of the secret purposes much better than
anylangiia^ofmiDecan do. It b a auuuni
of mine (said he) that a king ^ould be sacri-
ficed to the nation once in every hundr^.
years. These are his own words, for I was
personally present at the time ; their naeaoii^
must be oDvious to every thinking mind;
they propose to accomplish their hellish de-
signs by pretending moderation at first u-
tl^ demands and proceedines, and by de-
grees, artfuUy to insinuate tneir dangeroua
ideas into the minds of their adbereo^ md
when they suppose themselves sufiicieiitljr
powerful, then to attack perforce [the throne
and the friends of the constitution; this thej
think they can do with more ease and safety
than evvathe French; that I might be abis
to give you ais fuO an account as possible c»f
their proceedings, I attended their general
meeting in the Burbers Hall on the 28th io-
stant, where there were present about two
hunOTed persons of various descriptions, a Mr..
Clerk in the chair, the plan of oreanization
was laid before the meeting and retared with
amendments to a committee, and to be laid
by them before the general meeting which ia
to take place on the 5th of September, as also
a letter to Mr. Gray, the secretary to the
London Society ; as they expect their mnnber
to increase greatly : the society to be divided
mto smaller ones, for the more easy dispatch
of business, and their fiiture committees to
consist of one or two delegates front each of
these societies, they are to put their declara-
tion to the public into the newspapers after it
is approved of by the j;eneral meeting on the
5th of September ; as f could not be prevailed
on to subscribe their book of admission, not-
withstanding their using several argjuments to
that effect on three different occasions, thej
sent me for my conviction and information
Paine's Rights of Man, Mcintosh's Answer to
Burke,and Flower's publication, expecting that
against next general meeting I will subscribe.
Be pleased to advise lady Arnston (yotur mo-
ther) not to eo to Mr. Elder, the bookseller,
shop, to looK after eeditious books, suffice it
to say, that that fellow has at one of these se-
ditious committees where I was present, irri*
tated the risibility of the company at the ex-
pense of your's and her ladyship's character;
Elder is ^eir bookseller. Thus I have, with-
out the knowledge of any one, done myaelf
the honour of stating to you the proceedings
of this dangerous bo<^ of men, and the motives
that actuate their leaders, that you may have
it more in your power to take cautious, vi-
gorous, and effectual measures to baffie theiT
wicked intentions.* I trust you will not reveal
my correspondence with you to any but sncli
as you can positively rely on, and be assured
that I will, with the utmost secresy, infimai
you irom time to time of their proceedings, if
you are pleased to honour me with your cona*
mands, by addressing to me Mercbaat, Bdio^
burgh.
1925]
fir High Treason,
A. D. 17M.
[1326
Letter read, dated London^ 5th September
1792) addressed to Robbbt Watt^ North
Gray's Close, Edinburgh.
Sir; — I have received your letter of the 31st
ultimo, and shall feel indebted on behalf of
the public, for any communication you may
find It convenient to make to me. I trust the
number of evil disposed persons you describe
are not great, but it is still necessary to keep
a watchful eye over them. You may rest
assured, you are perfectly safe in any corres-
pondence you may hold with me. I am,
with respect, your most obedient humble ser-
vant, Hekky Dundas.
Another letter was read, dated Horse^
Guards, August 89, 1794.
Sir; — I have the receipt of your's, of the
1^6th instant^ and lose no time in informing
you, that having made a distinct search, I do
not find, that I am in possession of any one of
the letters addrest to me by Mr. Watt, or the
copy of any one of my letters to him ; to the
best of my recollection, all Mr. Watt's letters
vrere put mto the hand of the lord advocate.
I am, sir, your obedient humble servant,
Henry Dundas.
To John M Ritchie y esq. Edinburgh.
Lord Advocate sworn.
Mr. Enkine, — Your Lordship has heard
-what I have stated, respecting the communi-
cation between your lordship and Mr. Watt;
be so good as inform us of.it.
Lord Advocate. —In the month of October
1799, Mr. Dundas came to Scotland, and I
had repeated conversations with him, during
that month, and till his return to London in
the beginning of December, with respect to
the then situation of this country. — If I recol-
lect right, Mr. Pringle, then sheri£f of the
county, was present at most of those conver-
sations, the particular subject whereof was
about the meetings of the Friends of the Peo-
ple, then taking place in the west country to
a great degree, and the general alarm occa-
sioned by these meetings. This was a short
while before the meeting of parliament. He
mentioned to me, he h^ received a letter, a
^hort time before, from a roan of the name of
Watt, a merchant in Edinburgh, he desired
me and Mr. Pringle to inouire who Watt was,
and whether he was a safe person to have any
correspondence with; the result of those in-
quiries, which were made as accurately as we
possibly could, were such as to induce us to
put a confidence in Mr. Watt ; and from that
period to the month of May last, when I re-
ceived in London, when attending the secret
Committees of the House of Commons, infor-
mation of what had been discovered here,
I never apprehended that confidence was mis-
placed.
Do vou recollect receiving any letter fi-om
llr. Watt when vou were m I>unkeld?— In
consequence of those inquiries we made,- 6i
Mr. Dundas going to London, the duty de-
volved upon me, and I conceived it my duty
to carry on a correspondence with Watt and
any person that was of the description of Watt.
In the course of those inquiries, I remember
receiving Watt one night in my own house,
when he gave me a variety of information,
I do not mean to mention it, nor the names
informed against by him, unless he think it
necessary. He informed me, that at a meet-
ing in James's Court about the beginning of
November 1T9S 1
Mr. Hamilton, — I do not ask you what
were the particulars of the information that
Watt gave you.
Lord Advocate. — ^He once gave me in writ-
ing several informations in regard to the
state of those parts of the country in which
he had lately been, particularly the counties
of Fife, Perth and other places, and one
piece of information he cave me, I thought it
my duty to transmit to Mr. Secretary Dundas.
What I mean to ask is (I hope with pro«
priety), whether you did not think the infor»
mation you got froin Watt to be from a per-
son you had no reason to doubt? — I stated
before that I had no reason to hesitate about
the confidence I had placed in Watt, with re-
spect to the information which I transmitted
to Mr. Dundas at that period; it was to the
following purpose : that a party of soldiers
comine from Chatham through England to
Perthsnire, had been tampered with at several
places in England and Scotland, by persons \tk
whose company they had been, to mutiny,
and particularly a certain number of them
statea, in their march at a certain place in
Fifeshire; that if they were called out to sup-
press any riot, such as was said to have taken
place in Dundee, they would not fight or do-
their duty. I considered this as so material
and important that I transmitted it to Mr.
Dundas. I received in a few days a letter
written by his order, enclosing a letter written
by general Fox, then commanding at Chatham
mrracks, stating the names or the parties
who had left Chatham some time before, and
pointing out those who had gone to Perth. I
communicated this to the Commander in
Chief, lord Adam Gordon ; he brought the
soldiers to Edinburgh, amon^ them he brought
,the corporal of a regiment ; it was a regiment
then serving in India, in which colonel
M'Leod was the lieutenant-colonel. Lord
Adam Gordon sent to me privatelv when they
were come ; I went down to the Abbey, where
his lordship and I examined the men sepa^
rately ; ana as they completely denied every
single particular of'^the information which!
had received from Watt, nothing farther was
done upon the subject.
Lord President. — This was when .>— This
was in December 1793, or January 1793.
Mr. Erskine. — Does your lordship recollect
any communication with respect to the plan
of seizing the banks ?— -Never ; please to re«
peat your question.
1327J Si GEORGE ID.
Mr SnJbfi«.«- Whether jmm
ceiTed from Mr. Watt «ny oodununiditioii
with respect to a pkn for Kiung the beaks
while you were at Dunkeld in September
1703 ?— I was at Dunkeld in September 1793.
I do not recollect having received any letter
form Mr. Watt, or having seen Mr. Watt, since
June or July 1793 ; it may be otherwise, but
I do not recollect it.
Do ymi remember having seen any letter
from him when you were m London? — Iq
February 1793, l>efore going to London, I
saw Mr. Watt at nagbt once or twice. I
cannot tell the numbor of times. At that
time the trials were gomg on against
Craie and Anderson and other persons of a
simiuir desoiption; Mr. Muir and others
were busy at Glasgow, and I heard that a good
deal of money was going amongst those peo-
ple. I thouffht the money must come nom
some copceslsd quarter. I was desirous to
know, and I stated, that I was pretty positive
it must come either from iPranoe or London,
and I desired him to direct his attention parti-
cularly to that object. In March, about the
end of it when in London, J received a letter
from Mr. Watt ; he sUted that he had been
in company with certain individuals, their
names I shall not mention, unless the counsel
desire me so to do; two of them were of that
description whom he watched, and whose pro-
ceedings he communicated. He wrote me
that two of them had eiven him reason to be-
lieve that something of a very serious nature
was going on which they were acquainted
with, and which they were inclined to jlivulge,
but which they would not discover unless
they received a thousand pounds sterling
down, or some very large sum I am sure it
was. It occurred to me uiis was not a propo-
sal to which I could hsten ; I did not suspect
Mr. Watt ; it occurred to me that the men de-
ceived Watt, and that probably afier hav-
ing received the money (if the money could
be ^iven) the intelligence misht not be worth
havmg; before I returned the answer, I
shewed the letter to the secretary of state, and
to the chancellor of the exchequer, and they
having both concurred in the same opinion, I
returned that answer, and I heard no more of
Watt till I returned to Scotland. In the month
of M^ or June, Watt mentioned to me that
he had been obliged to accept a bill, on account '
of these men, of SOL sterling, which he would
be obliged to pay. I wrote to a person in
Edinburgh to pay that sum, and it was accord-
ingly paid.
Mr. Enkine, — ^Have you any letter written
by Watt to Mr. Diindasf
Lord Advocate, — ^After having recdved my
subpcena, I searched every place where
J tnouj^ht it possible, and ordered my clerk
to do the same. I searched every place where
I thouj^ht any correspondence with Watt
could exist. I wished to get every eorrespon-
dence between us, and there is what I nave
b^60 able to lind»
Proaeibtp agmd Eokrt WM
[m
Mr. fr^ttiie.— I should htetMUnAymf
to take up the time of the Court to read te
papers, and the prisoner says he <k)es not viA
them to be read.
Bfr.Hoii/^oii.— The lord advocate has
ooteiossva
oorrespooDCBK
a sufficient account of the
that passed between Watt and him
Lord Adcocatc^l do not ^mgl hrresia
or heud from Mr. Watt since June v}if
last year; I may have received a letter fiw
him at Dunkeld ; if I did it has escaped bj
recollection completely.
Mr. HamUton,-^l shall trouble your lort-
ship with only one questsonr more ; wbrtk
Watt, in the interviews he had with your W
ship, did not ask of you, how he was to as-
duct himself, and whether he did not ante
himself in the mode that was prescribed k
him ; Whefiier he had" not offered to It
Secretary Dundas, to give him thcinfomalw
that ^hoold appear to him to be impolai
upon the occasion f
Lord AdvoaUe^^lh the way I amctok
introduced to him , and knowing I considcw
him as a person giving informatiOD «> gofo^
ment voluntarily, of what was goiiff flM
considered him as anmnofrespccttfledjj
racter, in consequence of the inquiries I U
made about it.
Mr,Anttrvther,—My Lord Advocate, iH*
derstood your lordship right you said, the oap
information you thought material whi^^
received from Mr. Watt, was that viwi
respected the soldiers which you haw ffl*
tioned. — Yes, , .■ »»
And that, I understand your lord^»
have said, upon enquiry, turned oat, $sm»
you could discover, to be void of fouodsW^
It certainly did. j.
Did I understand your lordship rigbt, ^
you said, that Mr. Watt, in the moott*
March last, had made an appUcatioD to^
stating that some persons would mft >
disclosure, provided tncy could receive a sbs
; of money ? — ^In March 1793. ^
I That was not accepted?— I wrote toU*
I declining to do it j.
t Have you had, to the best of your/eco^
' tion, any letter from, or any ■™***"'tjl5
Mr. Watt since the meeting of the Bnwj
! Convention that met in October If^-^jj
mentioned already, I think I h»'«.^*^
him, nor received i ' " - u:- d
June or July 1793,
ceived a letter from „.^ „. *, , ^^
I gave for answer, tliat I do not recoils? *%
ing received any such ; but I am P?**^
have neither received any infonnstioa ov
him nor seen him since October l^^^* _l.
Mr. AnstnUker to the prisoner's couDseC'
Do yon call any body else }
Mr. Erikinc-^No. ^ .u
Mr. ftaii/^on.—My Lord PrcsidcDt, G«n«^
men of the Jury ;— The case that has tW^ "J
come before you, is one more deserving^ JT
attention, than any that ever, pab>P> ^
heard within these walla«
3993
Jbtt Hif^ Tretutm*
A. D. 1794.
[ISSO
OeaUcmcaDU H is m case of perfect novel^;
or I can venture to aay, that, though near
>ne hundred years have elapsed, since the
aw of treason in £n2land ana Scotland have
6een declared to be the same (except in one
^aae, relating to the established coinage)^ the
present is the first trial for that crime that
oas occurred in the criminal annals of this
country.
It is a case, s^tlemen, of singular impor-
tance indeed ; for, as it is the highest crime
known in society, so it is necessarily attend-
ed with the most severe and deepest punisb«
ment.
Gentlenien, it is a case of blood, and you
are, this day, by your verdict to decide the
fate of the nriaoner at the bar; you are t# de«
termine, whether thegatesof eternity are to
be immediately thrown open to him, or if he
is to be allowed to pass tne remainder of his
days in peace^ till the due course of nature,
and dispensation of Providence, shall call him
at length to the grave.
I have been appointed, bv the Court, conn*
sel for the prisoner at the bar; in that situa-
tion, I am bound to do him all the service
that I can ; and I can safely lay my hand
t upon mv heart, and, as a man of honour, de-
, Clare, tnat I shall du him all the justice that
lies in my power. It is a duty I owe to the
^ feelings of my own mind ; it is a duty which
, 1 owe to the profet^siou to which I have the
^ honour to belong; and, above ali, it is a
^ duty I owe to the prisoner before you, who
^ has entrusted the defence of his. precious ex->
istence io my charge. I do not mean to make
any apology for my appearance here ; but
from the anxiety I must feel, io the situation
in which I stand, I may perhaps be led into
error, in more respects tnan one. The pri-
soner may rest assured, that nothing shall be
left undone on my part ; and I hope that he
will pardon me, if, from inability or inexpe-
rience, I shall say too little ; and I hope, gen-
tlemen, to meet with your indulgence, and
with tnat of the Court, if, from perhaps a
laudable anxiety, I shall say too much.
The crime charged is High Treason, an at-
tempt to overUun the government of this
country, the most important of all events, as
it loosens the bands of society, and under-
mines all security. You, eentlemen, who
live utider, and enjoy the blessings of this
happy constitution, can you suppose, that
any one should attempt to cut himself off from
such advantages ? where the road to prospe-
rity and happiness is laid open to all ; where
the lives or the subjects are not wantonly
sported with ; but wfaiere securitv and stabi-
lity exist, and, I trust, ever will remain, as
the desirable and ultimate object of all our
wishes and desires! No,, gentlemen, yon
will, from these circumstances, infer the
strongest presumption to the contrary; you
will not imagine it possible that the panel,
who hss been living within the mild admini*
titmtionof thb country^-should strive to over*
VOL xxni.
turn its constitution. It is not a thing you
will liehtly presume, but, on the contrary^
you win require the stron^t evidence that
can be figured, of such a wild intention.
If lam entitled to lay hold of this, as one
general presumption, I am equally well entii
ed Io state another:
The crime, gentlemen, charged in this case^
is the atrociotts crime of high treason. But,
when we look into the melancholy annals of
our own history, where the crime of high
treason stains even the darkest pagjss of our
criminal records, we do not find that such
men as those now at the bar, have stirred the
mighty mischief OAen, too often, has the
best, the noblest blood of our country, from
mistaken notions, streamed upon the scaf>
fiold ; but never till now, have we heard of
men of k>w pretensions, endeavouring to rear
themselves mto importance by such unsuita*
ble attempts; such, however, is the person
now before you; vou know his situation, and
you will not easily presume, that he should
eneage in attempts entirely out of his reach,
and which his sphere in life cut off and de-
prived of all protMbility or possibility of sue*
cess.
Gentlemen, the crime charged in the case
is not (and I am happy it is not) a direct at-
tempt upon the lite of his sacred majestv.
Had it been such, I, for one, declare, I would
not have appeared as his advocate at this bar ;
as I now stand, I am bound no doubt to do
as much as in me lies, in my capacity as an
advocate ; but had the charge been otherwise,
I could not have so far disguised my feelings-;
I could not, I avow, have lifted up my voice
to defend one w^o could, either in thought or
idea, have meant to attempt the life of that
gracious sovereign, whom, m a former period
of my life, I am proud to say, I served, in
what I shall ever esteem the most honourable
of all stations. But the crime charged is of
a different complexion. It is a charge of con-
structive treason, which bears not personally
against the sovereign, and which is only
brought within the measure and compass of
the law, if it is brought at all, by the most ar«
tificial and strained chain of argument.
It is indeed said in the indictment, and
which was so ably urged and enforced by Mr.
Anstrutber, who spoke so fully on this case,
that the prisoner was guiltv of compassing
and imagmin^ the death of the king.*' Ye^
notwithstaadmg the high expressions of that
honourable gentleman, and though he pos-
sesses many advantages I can never hope to
attain, havmE the knowledge of every parti-
cular of the law of England, and especiall;r
that knowledge he has of the subject of this
day, which he has ursed so forcibly and. so
well, I shall, nevertheleife, be bold enough to
exert my best endeavours in controverting
the doctrine he has been pleased to lay
down.
I shall accordingly set out with what I take
to be the htw of this kin^m^ aa to that spe^
4Q
ISSl] 34 GEOROB HI.
Proceedbtgi Bgaind Robert WM
tlS39
ties of treason which fatts under the indict-
nnent submitted to jour considemtioD.
The iftdictment is laid upon the statute of
the S5th of Edward dd, wherein it is enacted,
<• That the compassing and imagining the
death of the king shall be high treason r but
where only the imagination of the crime
exists, and it can exist only in the mind, it is
necessary that it should be manifested in
some sufficient manner; it requires a suffi-
cient indication, and a sufficient oveit-act, to
bring it within the compass or inteadment of
the statute*
Gentlemen, t need scarce inform ^, that
by the hi^py union of this cotmtry with Eng-
land, the laws of England and Scotland, with
regard to high treason, are declared to be the
same. This is hy the seventh of queen Anne,
the intent of which you well know. But, gen-
tlemen, I must get you to consider what the
hnport of that statute is ; it strikes me that
this statute, which declares the laws of the
two countries shall be one, has reference only
to the laws as established by the siMutes
which constituted that law. It will be asked
me'by the beneh^ as a grand leading proposi*
tion, why we argue upon a matter that stands
aJready m so clmr a lieht, the^ judicial pro-
ceedings of a court, ana a long train of prac-
tice which will establish it? Practice is, no
doubt, in general, the rule of decision in the
law ; but 1 apprehend, when the ground and
foundation or that law, and especially in cii-
minal cases, is a statute or statutes, ytsa are
tied down explicitly to the tenor and import
of the words of such statutes : ** Judkan^km
etf le^^Unu non exemplii,^* This I appn^end
to be the l^al nde, and therefore I consider
the law of tne two kingdokns made one and
the same, in so iar only as the express enacV
ments could apply in letter and construction.
All that was demanded by the enactment of
queen Anne was, that the law of high treason,
as expressed in the statutes then in force,
should be adopted into the law of this coun-
try, and no more. More explicitly what I
mean to say is this : that this country did not
expressly adopt or ^ve complete and full
sanction, even to writers I shall afterwaords
have occasion to mention to you, nor did it
give up or imphcitly go into cases afterwards
regarded as precedents. The opinions of wri-
ters upon any science will no doubt be ivgiml*
cd, and the opinions of judges meet wilh due
respect; but you are not tied down hv them,
you are toreg^ them if you please, out you
are at the same time bound to consider, to
weigh well, and use your own judgment and
disoetion to •decide upon the law of treason,
as applicable to any paiticular ease which oc-
curs m this countnr. You are in ftet to be
bound by the words and spirit of the statutes,
and not to regard all the former precedents
Suoted to you as the established law, not of
tiis country but of another, whose statirte I
admit you have adopted, but #hose <n)inion
upon that statute yon are at libeny ^ther lo
choose or tmect In tAiorU so Ihr is tht __
tiite SSth or Edward r«gulates the law of h^
treason, it is to be remded ; hut tou ndmiled
only that statute, and not the wYiote or tbe
hiw of England, opinions and precedepti
upon that important branch of crimiiiil fos-
tioe.
- If t am right and successful in maiMainii^
this legal proposition, there is an end of Usf
present quesUoD. For, if the words otily of
the statute are to be r^arded, as to CDoapasa
ing and imagining the Mith itfthe king;, what
must be the twM Must not the &ct$
chargjed have a direct tendency to endwngef
the kmg*s person ? Must they not cgptttsiy
mdicate ^e worst of ctlmes ?•— the endeavi«w
ing to seek or procure the death of the king?
If that was the case, if the fkcts charged hat
amounted to such t^k and daring atiMlf ,
there would bo an end of the cause; iHstlha
is not the case. It is not attempted to be
said, that the lifo of the king is, or ever has
been, the object of the present attack; it is
not the compassihe and imadning of die
death of the kingi directly with an intent tt
kill, but it is a constructive imastnatioD only.
It is not here a levying of war. niat is trcasea
independently and altogether, but the contrive
ing and conspiring to levy war, which, in the
construction that is contended for, is endan-
gering the life of the sovereign, and tfaerebf
compassing his death. The words then of the
statute appear in every sense that ki^gOBBB
can admit of, to have a pointed relation onrjf
to an immediate desigii against the toval per-
son, and the overt act must show, that the
mind had an equally definite, and certain re*
lation to the accomplishing of such a de-
sttji.
Af any authorities were <|uoted by Mr. An-
struther, who opened this case, and these
Hvsrs no doubt of hish renute in the law of
England, and made formidable mention of;
many also were passed over which were eqad-
ly weB etititled to be duly regarded. Thou^
I do not build upon them, I am not afraid to
investigate their import; I weQ know they
confirm and support, in tlie stronger tcnnS|
tbe construction of the law of treason winch
I have hitherto contended for. One d die
most ancient writers on the law of Vjfcjr>¥«d
Was entirely passed over, that b, lord &ke^
I will take notice of him, as he is an <dder
writer than amcthat have been taken notice
of this day. I shall take the liberty to stste
his opinion, and I have no doubt liut that it
will have a good deal of weight in your minds
on this occasion.
In his third Iostitnl& page 9, he tresits of
the law of treason, and takes notice of the
present statute. By the common law, he
mentions, that a compassing or conspiracy to
levy war is no treason, for there must he a
levying of war in facto; nor is this cootraiy
to what the gentleman sdd who spoke bdfove
me. ''2tftefwsrds, in page It, he mentioos
the modeof compassing the king's death, and
issai
jar Kigh Tfiosotu
A. D. 17&4.
[1SS4
bow it i» to be mvid. ^ In this btuieb.
fj^at tUiDM are to oe obaenr«d ; first, tbis ward
(provenbienQeot) provably, that is, upon direct
and rnani^t proof, not upon conjectural pre-
sumptiona or inforencefl^ or strains of wit, but
^ipoa Rood and sufficient proof; and hetein
tlie adverb (proyablement) provably, bath a
gveat force, and significth a direct and plain
woof » wbich words the King, the Lords, and
CospinoQsiQ Parliament did use; for that the
offence was so heinous, and was so heavily
^nd severely punished, as none other the
IlJi^e ; iM^d inerefore the offender must prova-
bily be attainted, which words are as forcible
es MPoa direct and manifest proof. Note, the
word is not (probably), for then eanwune ar-
ffumeniasi might have served, but the word is
(provab)y) be attainted/'
. TlMae are the special words to ascertain this
mme, and regard also the mode in which it is
to be brought to punishment, which shows
how Yery exactly and critically that high
<Hrune was in those days to be judged of and
I punished. In the same treatise, tatog notice
oi what he had before said, and taking also no-
, tke of the same statute, he asqs, (p. 14.) ** The
, €|Qfnpo0iiiofi and conneiion of the words are to
I be observed, viz. [thereof be attainted by overt-
^ deed} this relateth to the sevecal and distinct
I treasons before expressed, (and especial^ to
41m conopassing and imagination of the death
of the kmg, &c. for that it is secret in the
heart) and therefore one of them cannot be an
qvert act for another: as for example, a con-
I i^phacy is had to levy war (thia^ as hath been
I nidy and so resolved), is no treason by tins
^ %ci until it be levied; therefore it is no overt
I act or manifest proof of the compassing the
' death of the kude within this act; for the
^ords be (de ceo, Sec.) that is, of the compas-
^ sing of the death. For this were to confound
i th^ several classes, or ** membra dividentia et
> sic d« csetsris/'
< And he also mentions, " And the wisdom
^ qf the makers of this low would not make
i words only to be treason, seeing such variety
f amongst the witnesses are about the same,
( as few of them agree together. But if the
I ^sme be set down m writing by the delinij^uent
I himsellj this is a sufficient overt act within
i ifiU statute.'' In the passage I mentioned
beCbfe concerning high treason in the quota-
I tion I nead to you, you will observe,- gentle-
men, it is said expressly, that conspirmg to
I levy war sgainst the king shall not be deemed
I an overt act of treason within the statute ;
tb^eifore it is clear by plain coastructioa that
this crioM shall not oe inferred. A con*
^ifD^ t9 lev ^v^^ ^ ^ ^^ misdemeanor,
and on account of the danger wliich may be
the residty should be considered^ no doubt, as
a crime of a doep and s^ous nature, and
sbouU not go pnpuniabed; but aocording
te .this author, who considers the point
mute)y> sucha conspiracy,ujiloss the war was
%ctiati|} levied, folis nat.iiKitbia the statute^
Xhii %tpu anvhopty is'tita . oldest we have id
the latr of England as to treason, of any
weight; he was chief justice in the reign of
James 1st, at which period of our history,
it will not be pretended but that as high uid
mighty ideas were entertained of the royal
prerogative and authority as in any reig^ we
know of
Lord chief justice Hale was referred to by
the gentleman who opened the case in point
of law, and I also hope, geatlemen, that you
will find him of some service to you in judg-
ing of this case; you will *pay a good deal of
attention to what that great iudgis writes upon
the sul^jeet in his hisUuy of the Pleas of the
Crown. This author was chief justice, and
wrote in the reign of Charles 2nd, and we
know that in that reign, any matter which
related to the prerogative would not be over*
looked. The passage I mean to take notice
of, is that which was read by Mr. Anstruther,
page 109, and upon which he rested as an
auuiority in his fiivour. The words are,
^ Thou^ the conspiracy be not immediately
and directly and expressly the death of the
king, but the conspiracy is somethins that in
all probabili^ must induce it, and fie overt
act is of such a thing that must induce it;
tiiis is an overt act, to prove the compassing
of the king's death, which will be better ex-
plained by the instances themselves^ and
therefore,
*' If men conspire to impison the kine by
force and a strong hand till he hath yieuled
to certain demands, and for that purpose
gather company or write letters, this is an
overt act to prove the compassing of the
king's death,'' &c.
"niis passage, you will perceive, treats of a
conspiracy against the king's life ; and though
by this tiiM, the writers upon the law of
treason had begun to diverse somewhat firom
the plain and unequivocaf construction pni
upon the statute of treason by sir Edward
Coke, still it is clear that the immediate per-
sonal danger of the sovereign was the object
in view. The passage I have read 'points not
to any strained and forced oonstruction of cir-
cumstances firom which the kim^s life might
be remotely put in peril, but rerars positively
and pmtediy to such drcumstajBces -and
situations wliere the life of the king is exh
pressly pointed at, and where his deam could
not fail to be the certain consequence. ** The
conspiracy," savs he, " should be of somob
thing, that in all probability must induce il^
and the overt act is. of sadi a thmgas aijf9t
positively induce the death of the king.T
Here there is no straining or laboured con*
atniction, but a plain and positive direetioa
which affirms what no one will deny,, that a
conspiracy to levy war, which in its efieot
must be immediately directed against the
king's person, or according to lord ijale'^
words, roast induce hisdeat^ is high tneasoo.
I witt therefoie rest upon the authori^ of this
gseat author, for I think it is positive and e»>
pres^y in fiLvouc of tl\e oofuSnietiefi which
13SS] 34 GEORGE lU.
Fraceeimff agaiad JMer$ Wm
[1S96
can tnily be put upoo the criminal kws of
this kingdom.
Gentlemen, I am sorrv to trouble you with
so much reference to books, but I feel it
necceaaiy in this case, and the niore so, as
the law was very largely argued from them
by the gentleman who openM this case ufnn
the part of the Crewn. He took some notice
of this writer, and- 1 must observe, thai this
same respectable judge, in another passage,
gives a most positive and direct opinion as Id
the expediency and propriety in giving a
proper explanation and just construction of
the statute of treason. Talking of the 95th
of Edirard, and of constructive levying of war,
he says, ** These resolutions being made and
settled, we must acquiesce in them ; but in
my opinion, if new cases happen for the
future that have not an express resolution in
point, nor are expressly within the words of
9Ath of J&lward 8rd, though they may seem
)o . baVe a parity of reason, it is the safest \ tk>ned in the paasap I have now read, to wil^
way and most agreeable to the wisdom of the deposing, imprisonrng^ or gettioff hia penoa
great act of 25 Edward Sd, first to consult the into their power, necessarilvimpfy immediale
parliament^and have tJlieir declaration, and to violence ; and consequent danger to the |wr-
be very wary in multiplying constructive and son is then most properly re^rded as nigh
interpretive treasons, ifor we know not where treason, and will, I trust, ever be the lav of
it will end." this country.
Serjeant Hawkins was referred to by the In the next chanter, where he treats of
honourable gentleman upon the other side, levyine war, the learned judce mentiaoa
and from what I could learn, and I could wlutt kind of insurrections and rimngs yMr
learn but very little, only from one part I' amounttoalevyin^of war within the statute^
learnt that *< a conspiracy to levy war against > as also, when and m what cases a conamracy^
the kin^s person may be stated as an overt to levy war for such and such purposes, tnoi^
act of high treason." I have given all along not treason within the clause of levying^ iayet
what I conceive to be the true construction an overt act of compassing or imagiBing
and meaning of the law, which this opinion of the death of the king. To the distinctioii
Hawkins perfectly co-incides with; it takes here fixed, 1 must, eentlemen, call your earn*
notice of the king's person, and only draws a | est attention : *' Insurrections," sajs he.
fined to aotioDB or attempts of the more
tioua kind, to asaaaaioationor poison, or other
attempts directly and immediately aiming «t
his life. It is extended to every thing wil-
fiiUy and deliberately done or attenpted,
whereby his life may be endangered. And
therefore the entering into measures for de-
posing or imprisoning him, or to get bis per-
son into the power of the conspirators, those
offences are overt acts of treason within tfaia
branch of the statute."
Now^ the truth and justice of this legk
opinion cannot, nor shall it be denied ; and
what does it come to Mt amounts to no more
than what I have all along mentioned^ that tfaa
law of treason, that branch of the atatnte
which respects the compassing or imaginia^
had a relation onl v to such acto, attempta^ or
designs, as had a hostile tendencv to the per-
son of tl^ sovereign ; and vou will not ftu la
notice, gentlemen, that ail the cases
(page 811) *' in order to throw down au inclo-
sures, to alter the established law, or change
religion, to enhance the price of all labourg^or
to open all prisons, all rising in order to enect
these innovations of a public and genial oon-
eern by an armed force, are in construction of
law high treason, within the daose of le^
vying war. For though they are not leveUed
conclusion when the person should be put in
danger; and by mentioning the person with-
out affinity or relation to ffovemment or any
thing else, it is a plain inference that he un-
derstood the statute meant to apply only to a
case where the royal person is in^mediately
and particularly in danger.
- Juagn Foster, in his excellent discourse on , _
crownlaw, is the great authority referred to I at the person of the king, they are against
and relied on this day, by the gentlemen on the | royal majesty ; and, besides they have a direct
other side of the bar, and though, perhaps, at \ tendency to dissolve all the bonds of society,
the first view, it may seem that he iK»rs . and to destroy all property and all govemmeDt
bard upon the doctrine I have been main* I too, by numbers ana armed force. Insonep-
taining, as to what is or ought to be deemed ' tions likewise for redressing national griev^
an overt act of compassing the king's death i ances, or for the expulsion of toreignersinooi^
in terms of the statute; yet, whui more j ral, or indeed of any sinsle nation Imho uving
n^Mmtely examined, it will be found that this under the protection of the king, or finr the
judge draws the very distinction I have been reformation of real or imaginaiy evils^iofa
all alonj; contending for. He draws a marked public nature, and in which the insurgents
^stinction between a conspiracy to levy a have no special interest Risings to eftct
these ends bv force and numbers, are, by con-
struction of law, within the clause of levying
war. For they are levelled at the king'a
crown and royal dignity .** He then goes on
to notice Benatead's case, where an inaunec-
tion was raised to seise archbishop Land at
Lambeth4iouB6y and which was a^udged
high titaaon. OentiaBMi I call yow aHettr
.war immediately and directly against the
king's person, or which is the same thing,
when uie king'a personal safety must neees^
sarily and of consequence be endangered, so
.that he never loses sisht of what was the
4iriginal intendment of Uieetatute. His words
are rpage 1D5) «" The care the law hath taken
ibribe ^eraanal safety of the kiagi ianot conr
1SS7]
/orHig^ Tretwm.
A. D. 1794>.
[IS38
^on to this passage, and I requesi of you to
«on8Mler whether some of the cases there
enumerated, do or do not very strictly resem-
ble the' object for whkh a risiD}; was said to
be intended, as charged in this mdktment.
But, gentlemen, you inil obserre, that the
learned judge in the passage I have now read,
is spealung of an actuallevymg of war, wherean
insurrection has been raised, and war actually
levied, which makes the criminality and brings
the cases within the statute; and in the very
next page and section, what are his words?
*' But a bare conspiracy for effecting a rising
for the- purpoaes mentioned in the two pre-
^^eding sections, and in the neit, is not an
overt act of compassing the king's death, nor
will it come witnin any species of treason
within the 85th of Bdward Sd, unless the ris-
ing be effected, and in that case the conspi-
rators^ as well as the actors, will ail be equally
guilty ; for in high treason of all kinds, all the
pmrtteipeB eriminii are principles;'* and he
refers to the case of Damaree and Purchase,
upon the trial of Doctor Sacheverell, which
would not have been high treaflpn unless a
rising had actually taken place. Gentlemen
this IS a pointed and great authority, and I am
well plcfised with this opinion, for it suits exr
actly the case before you. It is not said that
any war has been actually levied, but that
there has been a conspiracy only to levy
war. Gentlemen, you will judee if the exis-
tence of that conspiracy is matfe out by evi-
dence, and although it was, altliough 'there
was some appearance of some design to efiec-
tuate some kind of rising, sure I am, you will
never believe or imagine that it was a war of
the greater deeree, directly tending to endan-
ger the king himself, but, if at all, of the
foaser species only, as distinguished by,
Foster, which never having been levied,
amoimts to no overt act so as to indicate
a compassing of the king's death in terms of
the statute.
I am confirmed in the inference I draw from
this evident distinction by the opinion of a
great lawyer indeed, quoted to you by the
^ntleman on the other side of the bar, chief
' nistice Holt; he was not one who wrote books,
mi he was one upon whose authority books
have been written • I will shortly take notice
of the paMase in his charge to the jury on the
trial of sir John Friend, which bears on this,
case ; his doctrine is laid down in very strong
and I think, very clear and expressive terms,
and applies most pointedly to the case now
before you, so that you vrill therefore weigh it
with sufficient attention. Taking notice of
the argument that had been used for sir John
Ff iend, he says, ** here is another thing that
he did ioMstupon, and that is matter of
law. The statute of Edward 3d, was read,
which is the great sutute about treason^ that
does contain divers species of treasons, and
declares what shall be treason ; one treason
is the compassing and imagining the death of
the king, another 18 thelevymg wax. Now^says
he, here i^ no war actually levied; and a bare
conspiracy or design to levy war, does not
come witnin this law of high treason. Now,
for that I must teU you, if there be only a
conspiracy to levr war, it is not treason ; but
if the design and conspiracy be either to kill
the king or ti^ depose nim, or imprison him,
or put any force or restraint npcm him, and
the way and method of eifocting these is by
levying a war, there the consultation or con-
spiracy to levy a war for that purpose is high
treason, though no war be levied ; for such
consultation wl conspiracy is an overt act
proving the compassing the death of the king,
which IS the first treason mentioned in the
statute of Edward Srd; for the words of
that statute are, that if any man shall com*
pasa or imagine the death of the king. Now,
because a man designs the death, depositkm
or destruction of the king, and to that design,
agrees and consults to levy war, that this
should not be high treason, if a war be not
actually levied, is a very strange doctrine, and
the contrary has always been beM to be law.''
Now, to this doctrine I most cordially sub-
scribe, for you will observe that this is the
mater degree of war he is speakins of, which
the words he has used eviaently snow bears
directly upon the king's personal safety, who
by such a war must either be deatroyea or put
in extreme danger.
He then proceeds to draw the distinctfon ;
'^ There may,'' says he, **be a war levied
without any design upon the king's person or
endangering of it; which if actually levied is
high treason; but a bare. designing to levy
war without more, will not be treason. As,
for example, if persons do assemble them*
selves and act with foree in opposition to some
law which they think inconvenient, and hope
thereby to get it repealed $ this is a levying of
war, and treason, though purposing and design->
ing it is not so ; so when ttiey endeavour in
great numbers with force to make some refor-
mation of their own heads without ptirsuine
the methods of the law, that is a levying S
war and treason, but the purposing and de-
siniing it is not so."
If ere, eentlcmen, do I close my legal au-
thorities, for I am sure there is no occasion to
close them with one stronger in my &vour
than that I last mentioned. It establishes
expressly the distinction contended for of the
nu^ar anid minui degree of war, to levy which
a conspiracy may w on foot ; having done so
I leave you to draw the conclusion, and I am
confident you will not hesitate to think but
that the case before you witib all its circum-
stances clearly foils under the last of these
domes, and cannot therefore be attended
either with conviction or punishment.
Gentlemen, you have, t believe, all the au«
thorities on both sides before you, and as vou
are entitled to iudge both of the law and fact,
in this case I thought it a part of my duty to
state what I thought applicable, that you
mieht have at leastl)oth sides of the question
fioriy submitted to your own judgment and
discretiooi
1339] 34 GEORGE III.
ProcecHiig* agoiHid Bohett Wall
[1340
Itis$aid» genUemen, that compaismg to
levy war, nigst filwa^ s be held a9 an overt act
qi compa^siQg ihf king's death ; bi|t, geptle*
mefi, I cannot agree to this, for the (^onstriictioo
Fhich I apprehend is to he given to this 9ti^
tute qf Eaward 3d, is fortified hy another «r^
gument of very great importance. It contains
two specie^ of treason ; it contains a coropav
sing the death of the king, which is trca&OQ
9f a most dangerous nitture; and it contains
^so a levying of war against the king, wUcb
^rffio Vk treason ; but if a conspiracy to levy war
was sufficient to bring any one within tiio
other clause of the statute, the compassine the
king's death, the making the levying of war
also treason, is an eijfactment peifectl v supera^
bundant ana uimeces^ary ; it nein ^ absolutely
pecessary that before a war is levied there b«
a conspiracy to levy that war. In this view then
the statute is absurd, and though short and
most important, is yet in the very outset over*
wbeUneo with inexplicable language and un-
necessary redundancy. Gentlemen, I have a
higher respect and esteem for the wisdom of
our ancestors than to so into this idea. I
do not think thev wouhl throw away their
words in vain, and without intending that th«y
should liave some effect or meaning, yet, ac«
^rding to the meanins of the clause which
the gentlemen contend for, they have been
grossly guilty of misapplying their words to no
puipose, I cannot presume this, and I must,
on the contrary, conclude that the leaslaUire
of England, at that time as well as in utter pe-
riods,, really understood that there was a ais*
tinct difference as to what was meant to be
expressed in the two branches of the statute,
that they were different species of crimes aU
tpgether, and could not be taken by implica-
tion and strained construction to explain, aid,
andiissist one another.
Gentlemen, the same opinion and idea is
confirmed and powerfully strengthened by the
consideration of one or two statutes in subse*
quent periods. By the statue of 13th of Elixa*
beth, I dare say I have no occasion to read
it, I will state what I conceive to be the im-
port of it, but I stand under the correction of
the gentlemen on the other side if wroi^, by
that act it was declared that a bare conspiracv
to levy war of itself should be deemed hiEh
treason. G^tlemen, did not this import the
consideration, the construction, and under-
standing of the nation at large, and the opinion
of the legislature and sa^es of the law that
made this statute, that at that time a bare con-
spiracy to levy war could not be brought fmy
how within ;the clause of compassing or ima-
gining the king or queen's death ?
What occasion was there for that statute if
the l^w stood as it is now contended it does,
that a conspiracy to levy war without anv dis«
tinction, was a cprnpassmg of the king's deathi
and came under the statute of Edward 8d!
but this was under the view of those who
enacted the statute of the i3th of Elizabeth, it
wa^ ynder their cQUsideratioUi but still they
tboughl it necessary to make sud^ a
This statute waa oidy for the }ah of the
so th^l on heir demise, and upon thai statute"*
e^cpirine, the question reverts to what was tba
law before that statute was enacted; and thia
I have endeavoured^ I think upon acniDd^ ve»->
son and constfuction, fidly to jMiBt'oixt.
Again, gentlemen, in the 13th of Charks «d.
another statute was enacted similar to that of
Eliiabeth, whereby it was decbnd, <* That
whoever should compass or inoagine to levy
war against' his majesty, within the realm or
without, should be deemed guilty of hig^
treason.''
Here again the enactine of this law bear*
me out in Uiis case as well as in the former ;
for it waa understood and must have been
acknowledged to be the law by our ancestora^
and the lawyers both in the reign of queea
Elisabeth and of Charles II. tliat by the S5lk
of Edward drd, a compassing to levy war was
not high treason, nor could fall under the
spirit or tenor of the statute of treason.
Here also the same conclusion folk>v5, that
act was only made for the life of €^harb» the
Snd, so that having expired, the law reverts to
Uiat construction which I say it should faavev
and which according to my argument, it cer-
tainly had before these temporary acts were
passed.
Gentlemen, I do not really think I am
straining the matter too far, and God forbid
that even in a case of death, which it must be
if the prisoner is found guilty, God forbid, I
say, that I should strain the matter too herd
where a conspiracy it is said comes in oooi-
petition, a conspiracy against the life of our
gracious king; but from authorities I have
een at some pains to discover and digest in
my own mind, I do believe I am not press-
ing this matter farther than I ought. 1 have
examined a good many precedents and cases
which have occurred since the period I was
tdking of, but I will not refer you further
back, as I do not wish to en^e much of
your time, than to the reign of Charles the
2d ; and it appears to me, that wherever there
has been an mdictment upon the compassing
and imaginmg the death of the kin^ there
has always been a direct reference to soipo
attempt upon the persoi^ of the sovereign^ or
some relation to it in some circumstances, so
that imminent danger to him must have fo^
lowed firoin the measures pursued.
lu the Rjre-house plot business^ so weQ
known in history an attempt vraa made to
assassinate Charles the dd; in that case,
there was no occasion for using any strained
construcuon, or of bringing proof of any overt
act, which, by inference might have perha|iB
accomplished the king's death; there was a
direct attempt against the liie of the soisereigii,
a violent attem]^ to .cut off and assastinste
him, but which however never took eifect;
no doubt two trials folto^ed those of WaUcot.
Hone» and others, who were concei^ned in the
Bye-hQitaie plot; I mean the trial of Algeraop
1341]
Jfer JBi^ Treoioti.
A. D. 1794.
[1344
bidne^, and Idrd RittSel. These irere Uted
upon indicUnents for high treatoft, aiid an
overt 'act was endeaTOurea to be |m)<red upon
^m) Russel, that he had been in conversation
about seisins of the king's guards ; and that
was held to be an overt act of compassing the
king's death. But you will not be led away
by considering that case as a case of preee*
dent in point of law, for we know well that
the attainder and the proceedings against that
noble lord were reprobated and reversed in the
next reign, and the ground of the reversal, both
in that case and in that of Sydney and Arm-
Strong, was the -having flown in direct opposi*
tion to law.
The next case that strikes me, as having
an^ relation to the present case, is that of
lord Preston, who, in the reign of William 8d,
endeavoored to support the mterest of the
exiled moilarch. James Sad.
Now, it is a lact, gentlemen, that the chief
charge laid in that indictment, was, his
having endeavoured to bring in the Pretender,
for 80 James 9d, was then called. It is no
doubt true, that the indictment was framed
also, upon his having been guilty of eompas*
sing the kind's death ; but this is easily ex^
plamed, for there the direct effect which lord
fteston's attempt must have had upon the
life of the sovereign, was so obvious, that it
would admit of no odier construction ; it was
to brine in James Sd, it was as much as to say,
we wilfattempt to take awav the life of the
I sovereign, kln^ William; for there cannot
' be two kings m this country, one or other
must fiill ? 90 that in ^t, it may not entirely
! have »>ne according to the judgment which,
' by iarerence, was formed upon tnat fact^ and,
' I do believe, upon looking into the record, it
' went upon the other ground, to wit, endea-
' vouring to bring in the Pretender, and not at
all upon the ground of his compassing and
hnarining the king's death.
I The next great instance which occurred,
' was the assassination plot, in the rei^ of
f William 8d, you must be well acquamted
I with the circumstances. Those who were
> first tried, to wit, Chamock, King, and Keys,
I were accused of a conspiracy to assassinate
I the king ; the indictment was laid upon an
attempt to compass the king's death ; it was
I proved there were positive and direct acts^ in
order to take away the life of the sovereign,
by compleat assassination ; it says, it was by
having that in view. on1y,and not any attempt
against the life of the soverei^, by construc-
tive reasoning^ or far fetched mference, which
would at alt times admit of dubiety. A good
many cases were tried at the same time, to
wit| the cases of Rockwood, Cranbourne.
Lowiek, Cooke, and Knightly, but they all
went neari^ upon the same point: ibr in
these^ the indictment was laid, both on the
plot for assassinating the lung, and for ad-
iiering[ to the king's enemies, being then at
war with France ; so that, upon eitror branch
' there iras no oecanoa for any strained or
irtiftcial diain of argument. The ease of sir
Wilham Parkynswas precisely similar, arid
then it was that the opinion of lord chief
justice Holt, in the case of Mend, formerly
noticed) made its appearance. That opinion^
so far ftoha militatmg Upon my argument,
confirms it ; for, in that case, the indictment
was laid, both upon compassing ai^d imag^-
ing the king's death, and upon adhering t6
the enemies of the king, and it is well-known;
sir John Friend had as high a connexion as
possible, with the persons contemed in the
assassination plot; but, although that wa^
not, perhaps, completely proved, certaitt it is,
that m that case, there was adistinet ground
of treason, that of adhering, and cortes}x>nd«>
in^ with our enemies. And as to sir John
Fnend, it was proved,, that he had a <Jommis^
sion firom James 3d, and enlisted men for his
service. This was, in tact, an attempt t6
levy war, agaitist the Intereaft of William dd.
It comes to the case of Preston and Asbton^
where there wss an intention to dethrone one '
muty, whkh was to be done, by introducing
James 9d, and it is clear, that had as direct a
tendency to endanger the personal safety of
the^ sovereio;n, as can be- brought bv ^ir con*-
struction within that branch of^ the statute
which relmes to compassing or imagining the
king's death.
Mr. Anstruther took notice of a later case
than any of these, the case of Chrislophei'
Layer, in the year 1799. This, I believe, has
always been considered as a leading case, and
certain it is, that it is by no means a short
one.
» This gentleman was indicted, 1st, for comt-
passing the khig's death ; 2d, for an attempt
to bring in the pretender.
Now, as these were two grand conclusions.
I am surely not tied down to conclude that it
went entirely either upon the one or the other
of the two charges ; and one or the other, are
e<|uaUy and sufficiently broad to bring it
within the measure of high treason : accord-
ingly* *he acts laid were very numerous, nd
less than five difierent acts were charged : that
be conspired to stir an insurrection ; to bring
in the pretender ; enlisted' men for him ;
published a treasonable declaration; and
oMhfy conspired to seize the person of the
king. The conspiracy to bring in the Pre-
tender, and the enlisting men for him were
proved, so that here he fell within two
clauses of the treason law, the bringing in
the pretender, and adhering to the kin|'$i
enemies, and the charge of com passing, might
be lefl out altogether : the publishing of the
treasonable declaration, and conspiring to
seize the king's person, were proved by Lynch,
the chief witness, so that here was a complete
case, naj^, the completest of all cases, no less
than a direct attempt to take away the life bf
the king, by seizing his person, an act which
I must always construe, as putting him in
soch danger that death may soon be expected
to follow ; nor do I deny what is so well said
IMS] Si GEORGE III.
Proceeduiff^ against Robert WaU
n^M
by the leamad judge Foster, *^ ttukt between
tbe priaons and the graves of princes, the di»-
tanee ia very small/'
I trusty geatiemeDy thai these cases will
have Gonsimrable weight upon your minds,
in judgine of that which is now before vou ;
for though I have attentively considered the
indictment which lies before you, yet I do not
think it is such an indictment, as bears so
exactly, or in any degree bears so much upon
the personal danger of the king, as any one of
those cases I have mentioned. — If there
should be a defect in the law of this kingdom,
lam soriy for it ; and if it should be necea-
saiv, as in the tSth of the reign of Elizabeth,
and 14th of Charles 8d, let an act be passed
for the temporal life of the sovereien, or let
it be perpetual, declaring, that a bare con-
spiracy to levy war, shafl be high treason;
let it be so, and in God's name, let the lieges
know which way the law is to oo, tliat they
may not find a precipice under Uieir feet— 1
hope and trust, nowever, that there will be
no occasion for any addition to the voluminous
Senai code of this kingdom ; for I am cons-
ent, that his majesty rests securely in the
bosom of his country, and requires no farther
support, than that which I am sure he de-
servedly enjovs, the love, affection, and loyalty
of his faithful subjects.
Having taken up so much of your, time,
gentlemen, in stating what I conceive to be
the law of treason, as applicable to this case,
and the piarticular view you are to take of the
construction, allowed to be given to the in«
dictment, which has been preferred against
this man, I now call your attention to the
construction you are to allow your minds to
eive to the import of the evidence that has
been given this day ; and indoin^ so, I shall
endeavour, not to trespass much farther upon
your time or patience.
The accusation contained in the indictment,
in order to make out the proposition, that
there has been a compassing and imagining
of the king's death, seems, according to my
ideas, to resolve itself into four heads. That
there have been means used, and actual mea-
sures taken, in order to raise and establish a
convention inimical to the present govern-
ment of. this kingdom. That a conspiracy
has been also entered into, by certain persons,
the prisoner being alleged to be one, for
seizing the Castle of Edinburgh, for fighting
with the forces, drawing them out of the
Castle, and putting them in such a situation
as to get an advantage over them ; and for
seizing tliej udges, magistrates, the banks, and
exciseH>ffice in this place. Another charge
is, for publishing addresses of an inflammatory
and* treasonable tendency, to draw off the
a^tent;on of the soldiers fi-om their dutv, and
stir up mutiny among them. And the last is,
Imving taken measures to provide arms, in
oHer to carry these proceedings into effect.
In the outset of this case, much evidence was
brought forward^ relative to what took place
in LondoD some time ago. in a society called
the London Corresponding Society. Thaa
evidence, aU along, appeared to me, totally
unconnected with the present quesdon, but
when ol^ected to as such, it was tnen avowed^
by the gentleman who opened the caae»
that it was done^ with a view to ooniiect
the prisoner at Uie bar with the proc«»l-
ings that took place between tbe London
Cwresponding Society, and the British Coo-
vention here. I am satisfied such was the
intention, but at the same time, I find I
have no occasion, and shall therefore take no
notice whatever, of that society, nor any of
their proceedings : let their intentions bie as
wicked as what that gentleman may figjure
them, it is of no consequence to my aw-
ment ; for I say, no connexion whatever has
been establishra between that society and the
prisoner at this bar, and tbe mode in which
It was attempted to be made out, aa dearly,
nay, still more clearly showed, that the mea-
sure had failed. We mean, say they, to firova
a connexion, betwixt the London Corres-
ponding Society, and the prisoner at the bor^
by means of the British Convention in Edin-
burgh, and evidence was led to make out this
proposition. That evidence, however, made
out no such point; on the contrary, it at
once established, that the prisoner, Mr. Watt,
never was, or had been a member of the Bri-
tish Convention at all. It is needlesa, there*
fore, for me to take notice of any thing that
took place in respect to the London Coiie»»
ponding Society, or of any correspondence or
communication that was carried on betwixt
• that society, and the British Convention, at
Edinburgh, for with that convention, and its
measures, whatever they were, he had no
connexion.
When the British Convention was put aa
end to in the close of the year 1 793, it has
been said that on the back of that^ there arose
other meetings, and that the private societies
were not only more numerous than before^
but they were also better and more punctually
attended than ever; that there then arode
two several meetings, the one called a Com-
mittee of Union, out of which was formed
another, called the Committee of Ways sod
Means; and it is stated that tbe prisoner at
the bar was a member of both, and having
been at one and the other of these meetings^
i^ to be implicated in all tbe guilt which can
be affixed to their proceedings.
Gentlemen, I shall not I trust be long in
stating what I conceive to be the import of
the evidence laid before you upon that head,
and I shall do it the more readily, as It is a
duty incumbent upon me for the satisfyine nf
your minds, as well as of my own. But what
was attempted to be carried into efiect by
these two meetings, the Committee of Union,
and the Committee of Ways and Means ? We
were told in the opening of thb case, that it
was to seize the^ whole power of government
into their own hands; and to mould the law
13451
^r High TreatoHi
A. D. im.
Il8i&
nto their Ofwn form and shape. This is the
node in which this point was opened in the
Dutsety but I do not find any support given by
the evidence, to such a high strained and
overbeaurin^ hypothesis. I sec no evidence
ef there being any danger whatever of such a
design. This supposition, however, was en-
deavoured to be supported by proving an
atteuipt to seize the Castle, the excise office,
the banks, the niag;istrates, and judses ; still,
however, I do not mid any evidence that brines
the actual attempt for seizing of the CasUe
home to this gentleman. Ttore was an ac-
count given, no doubt, that this gentleman
had brought forward some kind of plan of that
•ort, but the witnesses for the crowd, both
Mr^ Bonthrone and M'EiHran say nothing that
can be construed into a plan of that nature
having been a2;reed upon, digested and put in
tmn; so as to be canned into ultimate effect.
If it could even have been mentioned at all,
it is impossible to conceive that the practica-
ViUty of so absurd and ridiculous a plan could
^ have eoteied into the head of man. I have
taken down what was said when this strange
phun was talked of; Arthur M'Ewan said no-
I t^LDgparticularwas said about seizing the Gas*
tie, and no time was mentioned wMn it was
to be done. Now^ if this had been an esta-
aished plan, would not something have been
me in order that it might actinlly be car-
ifed into eifect? some time would have
t been fixed, some measures taken, and some
; preparations made, but there is not one wit-
ness to speak to an allegation of that nature :
all tluftt they point at is a conversation about
SiAch a plan, if it was thought it might be prac-
ticdi>te, and if its success and effect depended
upon its practicability, I am sure it could
bava no existence wbatever, even in the most
visionary imagination.
Aocorain^ to my understanding of the mat-
ter, I conceive it was meant never to be car-
ried into execution, it existed only in the most
speculative form imaginable, if at all, but
tnere was no system or correct plan laid down,
no particluar act proposed, no means pre*
pared^ for that extrava^nt wild scheme that
IS brought into evidence. In this evidence of
Bonthrone's, he takes notice of hb having
been at the Sub-Committee, which I under-
stand to be the Committee of Ways and
Means, consisting of Watt, Downie. Stock.
Fairly, Burke, M'Ewan and himself, in all
seven persons : that he never heard Watt pro-
pose any^ plan about seising the Castle, but
iieard him savs he, make some kind of
proposal, but does not say (and I will stand
oorrecteaby the ^ndeman that has taken
down the depositions) he ever heard him
propose any plan about seizing the Castle. Is
not this conclusive that there was not in fiact
any serious determination to make such a rash
attempt? It appears conclusive'tbattherenevcr
was such a proposition, and ^rou must of course
lay it out of your minds in weighing ai^
judging of this ease dl^gelfaer.
VOL xxin.
Ttis also said an attempt was to be made
to attack the king's sokliers, a party to be at
the Luckenbooths, and a party at the west
bow. From this gentleman's evidence (Bon-
throne) a witness for the crown, whose name I
would wish you to take notice, I perceive is
more frequently mentioned in all the meet*
ings that took place than that of any other of
the members^ so that he must- know the
amount and sum total of every thin? that
was talked of at these meetings, he tells you
hardly any thing at all about attacking the sol-'
diers : he tells you of some wild kind of scheme
of kindling a fire at the excise office, and t^t
this would naturally draw out the soldiers to
extinguish the fire, so that an opportunity
would be given to carry on the dtangerous
scheme intended. This would bring the sol^
diers iit>m the Castle, and then he supposes
(he is a gentleman who makes < many suppo-
sitions) Sie soldiers being drawn out of the
Castle, perhaps the party he belongs to would
take a part in the proposed scheme. Gen-
tlemen, it will not be pretended to be said,
that taking a castle by force or without force,
are one and the same thins; if they found
this castle •empty, they might be entitled to
go there as well as to any other place. This
would not however have been a levying of
war, for the only characteristic equality of levy-
ing war, being using force, atid m this case it
is clear there was none used, nor any such
thing either done or proposed to be done ; but
only an intention, it is said, of a conspiracy
to seize the castle (I have it from his evi-
dence), not to be done, if such a mad scheme
were ever in agitation, by force ; and he ex-
pressly says he he»d nothing, nor knew no-
thing of attacking the kine's soldiers at alL
Therefore, gentlemen, I liave a right to call
upon you to lay out of your minds altf^tber
that rhodomontade scheme, if it ever existed,
of seising the Castle. Could there be a more
ridiculous absurdity than supposing the potii-
bility of such an attempt ! in oraer to ac-
'complish this mighty effort of human strength
and ingenuity, the onl^ force is seven men.
With seven men to seize one of the strongest
castles in the kinfi;dom ! I see no more pro-
duced to you by the evidence than seven men ;
these seven men, who compose the Committee
of Ways and Means, meet, and then they lay
their wise heads together, it is said, in order
to lay hold of the Q»tle of Edinburgh. It is
too absurd a scheme in fact to be got over, or
to come into the heads of men to conceive.
It was so absurd and ridiculous, I am sur-
prised it could be laid in this indictment
And then, gentlemen, be pleased to consider
what is the evidence brought forward of this
mighty conspiracy ? Who are the witnesses
who spoke at all to this strange coniiised and
inconsistent scheme ^ The witnesses which the
crown entirely relies upon are Bonthrone and
M*£wan, who are supposed to be accomplices
in this intended conspiracy. They are both
partmptt crvmnuy if there has reauy been any
4 B
1347] 34 GEORGE UL
Proeeedingi agttimi Roiert Walt
CIMS
crime in conteraplaUon, and on that account
not entitled to or deserving of any credit in
your minds. If again there has been no crime
committed, if no scheme of this nature ever
was in agitation, they are still less to be cre-
dited; for they have so far volunteered in the
mysterious story, that they cannot now with
any consistency entirely fall back from the
strange tale, absurd and unaccountable as it
turns out to be.
But, eentlemen, I dread not their evidence ;
flottie of these are not very ready in their
story, and though in a situation where they
lutve no interest to be very delicate, cither in
evasion or in concealment, yet when interro-
gated and desired to speak out boldly, they
t^U you they cannot positively say, or they
cannot tell, they suppose so, — ^but their depo-
sitions are even more favourable to support
iny argument, for they positively say they
never saw any scheme that was proposed or
agreed to be put in execution, or any at-
tempt made to carry into effect the mighly
project of seizing the Castle of Edinburgh.
A great deal of evidence was produced as to
a supposed conspiracy for seizing of the banks.
I need not trouble you, gentlemen, with reca-
pitulating that evidence, nor with what related
to the seizing of the excise otfice which stands
precisely in the same situation. But I do
maintain, that if this case is to be brought
within the description of a conspiracy to levy
war against the king, which is tnence said to
be an overt act of compassins the death of the
king ; I have nothing to tell you more than
that the actual seising of the banks would
not be levying of war according to the law of
£ngland« The banks are the private property
of individuals, and a burglary of a dangerous
mfid aggravated nature might have been com-
BsitteaT The injury in such a case might to
some individuals be greater than to others,
but I trust that it never will be laid down for
bw# that the seizing of the banks or open
Sttackof any such building or repository, or
afiy other building of a private nature would
bealevyinsof war. It might amount to a
riot, and if it was done secretly to a bur-
glary, but no more. But the case is a thou-
sand degrees stronger, for it has not been
said, that any attempt or attack was actually
made upon the public banks ; no gentlemen,
no such thing has been alleged; it is only
said that there was a conspiracy or design to
seize the banks, but which you well know
never was carried into effect.
liow then does the question rest, even upon
the crown's own supposition ? There is the
intention to do an act which had it been done
would have been so far criminal, but which it
is agreed never was effected ; without going
farther therefore it is enough to say that there
is not the slightest resemblance ot a criminal
act before you, far less such a one as would
tend to establish and fill up the deep accusa-
tion of high treason. I need not I am sure,
g^Uemen, labour this which is so clear a
point any longer, but the saoie observatiMft
was made as to the design to seise the «*¥cit6
office, and the same observation in answer
precisely applies. It is the king's bouse no
doubt for a certain branch of his revemie, but
it is not a place of strengtn belonging to llie
king. I am equally strong here, the positive
attack upon such a house, upon such a repo-
sitory, could not be levying v^ar ; and althou^
it was proved, it wUl never bear the coostnio*
tion intended to be put u|M>n it in order to
make out the case which is a case of h^
treason. It does not appear to me there is
any proof to show any such intention as seis-
ing either the one or the other of these two
punlic buildings, so that whether the fact is
admitted or denied, the legal conclusioa is ia
either case, equally strong in the prisonei'*
favour.
Much was said of a design supposed to be
connected with this alleged ptan, aod of
which the witnesses speak equivocally, that
is, a design to seize some of the very honour-
able judges upon this bench, and the honoui^
ablechief magistrate of the city. I am sum
I should be extremely sorry if ever %b»
lightest harm came to any one of thcise ho-
nourable persons ; it would give me, I am sura
much pain ; but I am speaking of a case <^
law, and I must observe in point of argomenl^
that an attack upon any one of the honoat-
able judges or magistrates whom I now sea
before me, would not, though attend^ widi
force, amount to an act of high treason. Wa
know well that any violent attempt upon the
person of a judge b^ the statute is high treason,
out only when sitting in judgment. Bat if
not sitting in judgment, then it is dear that
though attended with even the most &tal
consequences, which God for ever depfccaiev
it would not be an act of high treason. If
the actual perpetration of such a crime would
not have amounted to a charge of hi^h trea-
son, far less can the bare design to muce such
an attack as might be attended with ftdtal
consequences, be deemed according to the
constraction of law an act of high treason.
But the case is infinitely stronger, fhr the
attempt was to do what? It was to sdae the
person of the judges and that of the chief ma-
gistrate of the city : this is a degree immensely
remote firom the crime of high treason, and
though deserving of exemplary punishment, if
it had taken effect yet would not fall within
the description of a crime of that heinous na-
ture. But this is not all, for it was only said
there was a conspiracy to seize the persons of
the judges and magistrates, not that any actual
attempt was made to seize them. What then
does this accusation come to ? It comes to
nothing at all ; it is frittered down to the most
harmless accusation in point of law that can
be figured to the supposed conversation about
doing what would have been a misdemeanor
but which never either was effected or at-
tempted to be carried into effect. Upon this
I need say no more, for whatever crvidenca
13493
fir High Treaton.
A. D. 17M.
[ISSO
enight be l^rought «pon that char^, it is on^
Lhat cannot weigh in your minds id the pre-
sent shape bf this indictment, it must have
been brought forward in a different form and
shape, aua not upon the face of this indict-
ment wlilch is the only one for your final de-
leimination.
Gentlemen, you have heard much of the
instruments that are now heforc me upon the
table ; they have been tumbled, held up and
brandishea about in order to convince you
that there was here a dangerous conspiracy
lurking in tiie bowels of the country, whicn
might in its tendency and efiect, deprive us
^U of life; and in order to make tnis out,
.these weapons were brought forward and laid
upon the table, and evidence brought of the
persons by whom made, Orrock and Brown,
and of the persons by whom they were or-
, dered. Gentlemen, in the outset, 1 would re«
,' quire no more to show you the absfurdity of
^ rearing any argument upon such a supposition
, than wis, that bat a very small number of
I these weapons, dangerous as they may ap-
pear to be, and every weapon of that sort ap-
J»ears dangerous to those who are unused to
ook at them : but if I can make it appear
that this is all false apprehension, and I trust
t can do so, these instruments will not ^ive
the alarm they did when first brought mto
this court. It was said, but not clearly estab*
lished, that Watt went to Orrock and desired
him to make one or two of a certain construc-
tion, and these beins done, then a few more;
and that Brown maoe some others ; but what
does the whole number of these dangerous
hostile weapons amount to ? even with all the
attention paid to find them out, and I am sure
the sheriff has used the greatest attention to
&nd all that could be found, how many are
produced? about 46 or 47 pikes, not I am
sure 50, and these were to be put into the
bands of how man^ men ? I have paid all the
attention to the evidence that was possible,
and I have been able to discover only seven
men that are alleged to have borne any chief
part in this coubpiracy ; I cannot find upon
recollection there was any evidence produced,
so as to make you believe there were more
•poncerned in the plot than that number, yet
every thing, however, was to be accomplished
and achieved by these seven men, armed
with 4/ pikes. Gentlemen, you have seen
before you this day those seven conspirators,
and it does not strike me that they bear any
resemblance to those heroes of antiquity
which we read of in romance, and who might,
perhaps, in days of yore, have been able to
accomplish such a wonderful adventure ; yet
these seven champions were to perform won-
ders; they were to use forty-seven pikes* and
with these were to take the Castle of £din»
burgh; with these forty-seven pikes they
were to way-lay all the soldiers who were to
be marched out for fear of some fire at the
excise-office; then these seven men are to
^€€ur6 Mat banksi and with these forty-geven
pikes ate to lay hold of the whol6 govemmen
of this country ; nay, it was to be carried to a
still greater extent; they were to usurp the
management of the whole kingdom, were to
lay waste, if resisted, the whole country ; were to
change the king's ministers, force him to
alter his measures, and to make peace, be-
sides every thin^ else which they should re-
quire. Now this clearly appears to be one of
the most absurd, inconsistent stories that was
ever heard of. 1 need do no more than state
it, taking it as stated by the evidence, to con-
vince vou it never could be a scheme that
could have any tendency to success ; and if
they could not excite the people to run their
heads into danger on a mad scheme that could
never be carriS into efiiect, what had they to
hope ? Here it appears that the evidence on
the part of the crown is extremely lame ; for,
notwithstanding all the discoveries that have
been made, these forty-seven pikes are the
whole that are to be found. I leave it to you
to judge how it can be supposed these arms
were meant and intended to be applied in the
advancement of these hazardous attempts
of this Committee of Ways and Means. It is
impossible for a moment to believe that tlu^
were provided for, or even meant to be used
in the wild scheme so often mentioned,' if
ever such a frantic proposal had any exist*
ence. No, they were most certainlv pro^
vided for some other purpose, and here I
will direct your attention to what the witness
Aitcheson says ; he is a man of a good deal of
knowledge, he is a witness for the crown, and
is not to be impeached; I hold him to be a
good witness, and he says he thought they
were well advised in procuring some arms $
some people it is true were not fit to be U'usted^
but he thought it fit to procure some arms to
prevent an assault by a foreign invasion, or
otherwise. Would to God, gentlemen, that
the happy situation of this country was such
that every one might be trusted with arms in
his hands or in his houso! We might then be
^ natMual militia altogether, we might do
without the fatigue and expend of a standing
army, and exist in security and mutual confi*
dence with one another. But, it is sflid,the8^
people are not fit to be trusted with them^
perhaps it may be so, perhaps not, but such,
says Mr. Aitcheson, were the purposes for
which these arms, if obtained, were to be ap-
plied.
I have endeavoured, gentlemen, to ^ivo
you what I conceive to be the true and just
notion of this supposed plan, of this supposed
committee of people, met, it is said, and
framing a conspiracy to overturn the govern-
ment of this country, and you have heard
what it was said to be by some of the witnesses
I addressed, and from their description you
will judge of its practicability, and if it really
ever dicTexist, either in idea or in contempla->
tion. But I say there is not evidence before
you to show that there was an attempt of that
nature that ever was intended to be carried
15&I] 34 GEORGE HI.
Proeeedii^s againtt Rthert Watt
tl35S
into efiect I know the right honourable een-
tkman on my lefi hand will put it, andthe
other honourable gentleman did put it, that
this scheme, had it been forwarded, was a
levying of war; but although that might per-
haps imve been the case, had the matter been
pushed on, as these gentlemen say it was in-
tended to be pushed, yet the rude, undigested,
wild, and absurd scheme, of which there is no
doubt some mention made by the evidence,
was no^ng that could be called a conspiracy
to levy war ; it might be called by some name
of inferior degree, that might in time perhaps
rise up to something of a dangerous descrip-
tion and tendency, out in the way in which
you now must view it upon the evidence, it
cannot be called such a conspiracy to levy war
as to fall within the statute, and subject all
that are principals or accessories to the dread-
ful pains and penalties of high treason.
Much has been said of an address or hand«
bill, which it is alleged was artfully and insi-
diously circulated among the fencible regi-
ments of this country, in order to draw them
from their duty and allegiance, and a strange
attempt has been made to trace this transmis-
sion and circulation to Hardy, a serjeant of
the Hopetoun fencibles. But, gentlemen, it
appws that it is impossible to trace this
publication, whatever its tendency may be,
either to Hardy or from the prisoner at the
bar ; and I have not yet begun- to take notice
of its tendency, but whatever that may be, it
is nothine to the prisoner at the bar, as it is
not brought home to him in any one shape.
The only evidence upon this point is, that of
William Watson, wno tells you a story witii
respect to a hand- bill or paper, containing
such an address, and wishing to see it, goes
with Downie, who says, p^iaps I may be
able to procure you one ; ne does not seem to
be very certain about it; when he is shown
Watt at the bar, and asked if he knew him,
he says, heeould not say he did, or if that was
him; he then goes to his house and Mr.
Downie with him. I do qot know, however,
thai it was Watt, I do not go upon the supposi-
tion it was not him, but it might be anottier ;
but as to the alleeed conversation between
Downie and Watt about it. I see no evidence
whatever. Downie turns his back and comes
out and takes Watson up to a shop in the
South Bridge, to the shop of one Kennedy,
and he says I will get you one ; but very cau-
tiously, Downie throws some of them down
upon the fUor, and says, *' take up one ;"
Watson accordingly takes up one ana gives it
to one Johnson, wno it seems gives it to one
Sandilands, and he gives it to a serjeant
Hardy. This is the chain, but there u no
proof of any connexion that the prisoner had
'with these persons, not even of this man
Watson's getting it from him. He gets it, I
will prove by a strict legal alihiy he eets it
from Kennedy by means of Downie, tnen it
goes to the hands of Johnson, and so to sei^
jeant Uardy. He does iiot tell you what he
did with it, he might put it in his podet or
destro;^ it As to the serjeant, I must sup-
pose mm, being a non-commissioned officer,
to be a good soldier, and if so, he would not,
I am sure, circulate a paper which might
create a mutuious spirit in the corps, and ac-
cordingly he tells you in express terms, that
this was the only one of these papers that was
seen, and I am pretty positive as to that, nor
will it, I believe, be controverted.
But although I were to allow this had been
a hand-bill of the nK>st dangerous tendency
and inflammatory nature, is it meant to be
said by the honourable prosecutor on mj left
hand, that this is treason, or a sufficient
ground to make out the case of a oonspim^
to levy war ? I will venture to say, it cannoC
be considered as a thing of that nature. I
have read the address, and I will again make
bold to sayt it is a very complete and well
penned address to excite that regiment or aaj
other regiment into mutinv ; mutiny, I weU
know, is, by the mutiny bill, punishable with
death, but this is not mutiny, and though I
have no hesitation in saving, that an attempt
of this nature is at all events a high misde-
meanor, and punishable in a most serious de-
See ; yet I know of no capital punishmeot
at could be put upon that attempt; I know
nothing like it in any law whatever, whether
civil or mihtary, that can draw on the dread-
ful consequence of high treason. The ex-
citing soldiers to desert, is a crime that would
meet with an exemplary and fixed punish-
ment, and I would have no hesitation Ao saj,
it is entided to meet a very severe punish-
ment; but it is clear this address or hand-bill
is not pressed upon them in any conclusive
manner, in fact, m no manner whatever; for
it is lost in the oijtset, in one or two trans-
missions, and never heard of a^in ; therefore
it can have no weight with you in niaking any
proof, or of aggravating the chaige laid in the
indictment.
Gentlemen, much stress was laid upon
what also seemed to have been a part of this
proposed plan, which it is said, was to be atlri-
Duted to the unfortunate prisoner at the bar,
after they had seised the Castle and pcd>lic
banks, and the persons of the judges ; this
was in publishing some declarations, enact-
ing laws, and taking upon themselves the
powers of government and of l^islators;
that no person should leave the town under
pain of aeath. All the absurd tenor of tfab
scheme, if there ever was such a scheme in
existence, is it not all of a piece ? Who could
suppose such a wild Don Quixote scheme as
that of seizing the Castle, and all the other
consequences, and is not this one in eveiy
respect tinged with the same absurd com-
plexion } I shall not trouble you with further
observations upon it. If the seizing of the
Castle was in net suggested, they never cooM
be supposed to be in earnest upon it; if there
is that absurdity upon the face of the plan
spoken to ty their own two witae»e%
1S5S1
^ High Treason*
A. D. 1794.
[1S54
M^wan snd Bondmrne, the 'detail of their
own plan is stiU less worthy of meeting witli
^any aegree of credit and bdief from you. I
have so far endeavoured to show you that the
-evidence on tiie pait of the crown has not
filled uo the measure of the facts cfaareed in
'the inoicrtinenty and if I have succeeded in
^at, my case is good; because I succeed
equally by a failure on the part of the Crown,
-as by establishing any defence of my own ;
and if I have done so^ I think, notwithstand-
ing all the suspicious circumstances in this
case, I must ultimately prevail. That there
are some suspicious circumstances in this
case, 1 have not the least hesitation to ac- '
Imowledge ; but at the ss^e time, I will take
it upon me to affirm, thatthe^ are not such as
will allow you, gentlemen, thinking with seri-
ous deliberation upon the result of this man's
Actions, that he snould be guilty of such at-
^mpts, or 3iis mind bent upon such purposes,
as could be construed ihto any act or oon-
spiiing to levy war, fbr the purpose of over*
turning this truly blessed, happy, and long es-
tablished government.
Gentlemen, I rest not here, and you might
petceive from the evidence in exculpation of
this man at your bar, that he stands in a dif-
ferent situation from any other prisoner; and
though you were to conclude that all these
matters he is said to have done and acquiesced
in are true, and that the^ were to be aggra-
vated to every degree of apprehension and
danger in which yon can figure them ; though
all those matters were fixed perfectly by proof;
I say, he stands in such a situation, as in my
idea, must render him safe. It is an esta-
blished principle of law, that it is the animtu
with which any person commits an offence or
accedes to it, that is the teat whether such
act is criminal or not.
Now, I say, Uie situation in which this
man stood, was such, as notwithstanding
the appearance of external circumstances
against him, was sufficient to excuse him
from ail the participation be seemingl v took
in the measures of those with whom he was
appiarently connected, if you should think,
which I by no means concede, that these
measures were in themselves criminal and
deserving of punishment.
The nght honourable the lord advocate's
evidence, and that of Mr. Clerk the sheriff,
establishes completely the situation in which
Mr. Watt stands. Though that evidence
relates to a correspondence he carried on in
the outset of matters, when disturbances began
in this country, yet it will be found, he was
all along faithAil to that cause in which he
had embarked. Mr. Henry Dundas's letter
he has produced, in answer to one which he
wrote him in September 1792, and it was
admitted on the ^rt of the crown, most
handsomely, to be that right hon. gentleman's
writmg and subscription. This letter then
tuider the hand and seal of Mr. Henry Dundas
is now before you, -wherein Mr. Dmidas
4e8ire8 Mr. Watt to persevere and to proceed
in those measures he had held out he would
do ; that he would be doing well of his country,
and that he would be in perfect security m
following them up. This letter of the nght
hon. secretary, was in every respect a proper
letter ; it was the answer not only of a states-
man, but of a man ; it neither rashly rejected
information, which might perhaps be attended
with advantage to the country, nor did it
betray any anxious apprehensions or unseem-
ing eagerness for a continuation of the prof,
fered intelligence and correspondence. Upon
that letter Mr. Watt relied and followed the
line of conduct which that letter prescribed,
and this account is supported by the evidence
of the right hon. the lord advocate, who was
so obliging as to g^ve information upon the
matter; he says, in consequence of a com-
munication with Mr. Dundas, who mentioned
this matter to him, and he desired him, when
hewent to Scotland, to inquire him out. The
lonl advocate and Mr. Watt have accordingly
had several different meetings; Mr. Watt
gives his lordship information upon several
particulars, which the lord advocate himself
says were &cts of importance, and upon
which his lordship took such measures as the
importance of the case seemed to require and
dictate. Mr. Watt aoeordinely fairly enters
into this correspondence wiu the officers of
the crown, and I am authorized to sav, con-
tinued in it; and if so, I am equally well
authorized, I think, to presume and "^be be*
lieved,when I state to you, gentlemen, that
he had not deserted this lin^ of conduct, nor
had taken up any other line which stood in
opposition or contradiction to it In the
situation Mr. Watt stood, he bad not surely
nor ever had an intention of deserting that
line of conduct he had chalked out for himself^
nor will it easily and rashly be presumed,
that he had changed his mind, and had fkllen
back from that chain of correspondence and
communication, which I have proved, firas
established betwixt him and the honourable
secretary and the lord advocate of this country.
Gentlemen, I state to you, simply the fact,a5
I am desired to state it, and you may perhaps
be nevertheless inclined to conclude, that this
gentleman's professions and story, arc contra-
icted by that line and chain of conduct he
has ostensibly, and apparently subsequently
pursued. But this, gentlemen, is what I
cannot possibly allow. For, when I find that
a man is fairly embarked in a parUcular line
of conduct, I must suppose, that he follows
that line up, more especially, when you find
circumstances so strong in that situation, as
to preclude any idea whatever of his having
betrayed his tntst. You must not, therefore,
be led away by external appearances, nor are
you entitled to conclude, that a person, in
that dangerous and delicate situation, is not
acting with strict fidelity, merely because he
appears under negative colours, and gives no
positive and active indications of the amcerity
of his conduct.
But this argument, gentlemen, is to be
1355J M GEOKGB Ifi.
Proceedmgi^agauut Robari WaH
[USi
carried still farther ; for» though I should di^-
cover such a |)erson to be acting, to all appear-
ance, in manifest and direct opposition to his
secret professions, vet I am not, from thence,
entitled to conclude that he has made an
absolute and total desertion. The very
reverse holds; for, let it be supposed, that
the unhappy times of the rebellion in the
year 1745, and 1746, were to return to this
country ; and suppose, that it was necessary
or expedient, that one of the royal army
shoulci intrude himself into the enemy's army,
in the character of a spy, how, I pray you,
was he to discharge his duty as such, with
effect to the party he meant to serve, and
safety to himself?
There is but one, but one mode and line of
conduct, in foUowing which he could be of
any service, and that is by dissuise and de-
ception ; no otherwise could ne be of any
advantage; for if ever he appeared in his
true character of an enemy, it cut him off
from all confidence, and rendered him inca>
pKsble of gainiog any intelligence in the capa-
city of a spy, which it was intended he should
act in. Por such a person, therefore, it would
be necessary, not only tliat he should aban-
don all appearance of connexion with his
own parly, but that be should even adopt,
and go into every measure of that party he
was employed to vratch. He woula - be ob-
aed to enrol himself in the corps of the
versary, to forego his own distinction of
dress, and adopt theirs, as the only means of
lafety from detection. An adverse case to
this has occurred within my own remem-
brance ; it was by failing to take these neces-
sary precautions, that an honourable gentle-
man, and most valuable officer, with whom I
was well acquainted, was laid hold of, as a
lamentable instance of severe punishment,
and at length suffered a cruel and ignominious
death.
You must at once, therefore, gentlemen,
perceive, and it surely does not require much
illustration, that in order to act with effect,
in a situation of this nature, it is necessary,
seemingly totally to desert and abandon that
cause which he had really at heart; and
suppose a roan, engaged in such an adventure
was to be found m the situation described
in the uniform of an enemy, and even in
arms, that would no doubt be a strong case,
a very strons case, and one wherein there
would be much ground for suspicion of fide*
lity ; yet strone and even strange as it would
appear, it would not be sufficiently strone for
vou to presume tliat he was acting deceitiully,
but on the contrary, you would l^ tied down
to believe, that he was still acting iu character
as that particular situation, in which he was
found, was. the only one that could enable him
to follow up the line he was in, and give that
effectual service which was intend^. Had
such a person appeared in any other descrip-
tion or character he then unavoidably lost the
opportunity of doing that servioe^ aad of fol*
]owmg up that duty be was stncUyliOQBiii
discnarge.
This, gentlemen, is a strong case, Vut i
strictly applies to that which is dow bcfae
vou, strone as it may be put. It was admitkd
by the lord advocate, who said be beM
the prisoner was such a character as could be
relied on, that at the time he w-as in canQ*
pNondeuce with hira, he believed him to be
sincere. Can you, gentlemen, suppose, th<
without any cause, he was led away by (4
disposed persons, and adopted another Imeflf
conduct? Vou are not, nor can you sum
that he was so. He appareoUy folM
what was the onl^ line ot rendenot senict
to the cause in which he was engaged, udiK
was to follow this up, and then to ukea
opportunity of disclosing, when the e&d
came near to a dangerous tendeocf. Y«
are not to suppose a person in that situatui
has abandoned his ioraier trust, sod Ia;»
that as long as there is no open and m&^
declaration upon his part, he is to be presuaw
faithful iu that trust. This correspondoee
with these honourable persons, is carried os if
lateasjuly, 1793. Then comes thciMiuw<<
stating tlie proceedings of the British C»
vention, which were openly published o tti
Edinburgh Gazetteer. It is well known Um
proceedings were never kept secret, ore*
cealed, so that, for this period, from JuiJ m
December 1793, when the conventionjw
dissolved, nothing was carried on of » .*oJ
nature, which he could give infonnsW**
The convention is dissolved ; and then il ■»
resolved, soon after, to wit, on the Slbtf
December 1793, as appears by ^f^^
and infonnation laid before you, to fonn ™
Committee of Union, and immediaielj suwj
quent thereto, the Committee of ^^^^V^
Means is raised up, sometime in the nj*J
of January, 17D-I. Their proceedings »«»«•
ingly go on, and Mr. Watt showed th»lv^
same incli nation of following up tbe i^^^°^
he set out with ; he became a '"^'"^
both, of one and the other of these commiwo
and though perhaps, he did not in fact, yew
have not the smallest doubt to say, '< ^r^
intention to give the necessary i^'*?"^"?!!
when the proper period for doing it ^r"\
occur. If there had been that coosp^g
actually existing, which is V^^^^'^'^^
then most certainly have given that "*^JJ
tion in due and proper time, to ^*|"*^
this country, that they might ukc *^^
of it, and be prepared ; he would, in^hw^^
have given all the insight into ^^^*|v^
and mysterious plot, that would Iw^® \i^
quired, had such a plot really ^^^^
ence, or had it occurred to him, ^^ ^^^IjAe
period was arrived, when the secret sw>u»
divulged. ^^
If, gentlemen, you can possibly cooobj^
18671
fiir High Treoion*
A. D. irw.
[1S58
tbe forced ^iijppotinoQ that he was not act-
ing with fidelity. If you give belief to Mr.
l/l^tt's aituatioD, then I state to yoo, that he
airas known to the public officers of the crown,
as one who was in their employ and service, as
(Kte who secretly paid attention to the matters
which were going on, and who gave informa-
tion to the rulers of this counti^, when time
and opportunity served. Persons of that de«
scription have m some instances endeavoured
to conceal themselves with secrecy, and may
perhaps have succeeded. But he was a per-
son that was well known, and could have no
hope or expectation that he could betray his
trust without the attendance of a great and
dreadful consequence as the ultimate result.
What temptation had he, therefore, to play
doubly false ? did not eve^ motive whatever
incline him to be true to his employers
nnder government, and what inducement bad
he to act otherwise ? He was known to the
officers of the crown, as well as the situation
w which he was acting. Can you, therefore,
gentlemen, suppose, that with a millstone
about his neck, he should voluntarily, and
without any temptation whatever, sink- him-
self to the lowest pit of ruin, disgrace, and
death ? No, gentlemen, you canDot,even for
a moment, indulge such a rank supposition ;
unless he had been completely insane, he
could not possibly have acted in this manner,
it was so absurd, so strange, and past all hu-
Hian belief. Had he really meant to act in
I this irrational manner, he must be perfectly
mad. **The fool in scripture who scatters
Hrebrands and death, and sayeth am I not in
I sport," was a wise man to him, or to any one,
who without any earthly object could foolishly
I consign his fame and existence to utter and
I certain destruction. If this gentleman, in
I short, had possessed one particle uf sense, he
could not possibly have acted as it is pre-
' itended ; the presumption is so strong, I hold
I it 60 conclusive, that I do in fact th'mk there
/Cannot be anything more said upon it; and I
do say farther, that Ft will turn out to be a matter
l>f extreme danger, if this man is to be aban-
I doned to his fate.
I Gentlemen, I have some idea that this un«
I fortunate and unhappv man has been deceiv-
ing himself, and that he did not openly make
a full and fair discovery of all the particulars
I and circumstances with which he was ac-
2uainted, when examined by Mr. Sheriff
'lerk. This conduct is easily explained and
accounted for; the sheriff says he was unwil-
ling to speak out ; so he was, but what was
the reason? it was because the person he
Jcept up correspondence with, the lord advo-
cate, was not present, to whom alone he very
naturallv wished to disclose himself. I do
not at all wonder at his refusing to speak out
to the sheriff upon his examination ; and of
his desire to delav till he had an opportunity
of seeing the lord advocate himself; He was
In a habit of correspondence with that ho-
nourable lord; if he was oonacious that he was
acting in the character of a spy (for I will not
mince the matter), it was extremely natural
that he should wish on every account to
make his situation known to as iew persons
as possible } he is accordingly unsatisfactory
to the sheriff, which must to allowed in this
case to be at least a pardonable instance of
caution. He does not say any thin^; but he
expected the lord advocate in town in a day
or two, and then he would tell his case.
It is also said that when examined by the
sheriff, he would not give an account of the
arms that were found m his house. Here the
same answer as that given just now most
aptljr and readily occurs. He', very wisely
considering the delicate situation in which he
stood, woiud not give intelligence to any one,
but to the fountain head, to him only with
whom he was in the habit to communicate ;
he would give his information to him alone,
and I have given a veiy good reason why he
should wish to communicate it only to that
gentleman. His wish for a temporary con-
cealment, sufficiently explains the evasive ac-
count he gave of the pikes when first exa-
mined ; for it was not a true account with re-
s|>ect to these pikes which he then gave. I
will not allow nim to say, that he meant to
sell them or make a trade of them, but I will
say he had them in his house, and for what
purpose ? that he might have them in secu-
rity, in such a situation that no danger should
happen to this country; it is in evidence
they were in a clothes' press, locked up, and
not left in the way of any wild or rash young
men, who might use them to bad purposes ;
they were put there till he should have an.
opportunity of giving his account to the lord
advocate, and this examination of the she-
riff accounts for and explains the fact in the
most conclusive manner. Gentlemen, I will
and must lay a great deal of stress upon the
situation in which this person was placed ; I
will also mention, that very dangerous con-
sequences would ensue were this unfortunate
man to be abandoned to that fate which now
dismally hangs over his head ; we all know
that in the present political state and govern-
ment of this countiy, it is absolutely neces-
sary that those who have the superintendence
and management of public affairs, should bo
furnished with secret intelligence from every
quarter of the kingdom where danger of any
kind may possibly take root: without this
advantage, which I must consider as in every
respect a necessary one, the rulers of the land
would, in many instances, be less able as well
to ward offer resist the impending storm, as
to cut the root of the evil by tne cautious
expedient of timely and seasonable preven*
tion. For this purpose are persons, such as
the prisoner at tbe bar, unquestionably ne<«
cessary; but if he falls, I auestion if any one
will again be found so haroy as to enter the
list in such a dangerous employment. Gen-
tlemen, I state to you the fact only, and leave
the application to yoiv deep consideration.
1S59J M G£0R6B IJL Pre
Gentlemen, I aiA h»ppy to tiink» both
upon your aooounty and roVown. tbat I am
now arrived at the close of my labours^ and
that I shall have little or no occasion to
trouble you farther upon this case ; if, gentle*
men, I am right in what I maintain to oe the
true and just constinction of the law of Eng-
land as to high treason, there is an end of
the question ; as the overt atcts, laid in thb
indictment, bear not at all upon the personal
danger of our gracious sovereign, neither do
these acts come up to the measure of what is
necessary to make out a conspiracy to levy
war of the first or highest degree noticed in
the distinction. If, on the other hand again,
there is not evidence suflkient to make out
tha overt acts chai^ged, the man is safe ; for
the failure of the crown to rear up their
fyJbnCj makes a sufficient case in my mvour.
Agaic^ if you shall be of opinion that the facts
laid and charged in the indictment, and of
which there is no doubt some proof, were
such as would have been attended with dan-
Serous consequences, only if followed up, I
o think that the prisoner may stand firm
and cool in that situation in which he is now
placed ; for the whole mass of the evidence
undoubtedly shows, that the plans in con*
tsmplation, if ever seriously thought of. were
such as never could have been attended with
success^ so that the alleged danger to the
constitution never had in fact any existence.
Now, whatever, gentlemen, shall be your
opinion up<m the case before you, certain I
am that ^ou know well your duty; and
though it IS, I bcHeve, the first time you have
sat in a court regulated by English procedure,
you have nevertheless all of you been upon
juries of your own country, where the fate, life
and character of an individual was at stake ;
you know what are your powers, your privi-
leges, and your duties ; you know you are en-
tiued to brinjg in whatever verdict shall be
consistent with the dictates of the human
mind and your own consciences ; you may
brinff it in either specially or generally as you
shall think fit; if you find that the facts
charged iu the indictment are proved, you
may also find the defence I have made out
for the prisoner, and I think fully made out,
also proved ; or, you may steer the safest of
all courses, and find a general verdict of Not-
Guilty. Gentlemen, you are to judge your-
selves of the verdict you are to pronounce this
day; you have paid due resard to the evi-
dence, and you have honoured me with that
attention in endeavouring to throw this addi-
tional light on the case, that I can have no
doubt but that the judgment you are now to
eive will be founded on justice, tempered,
Eowever, I trust, with a due portion of
mercy.
But one thing more, gentlemen, and I am
done ; though we are engaged in a bloody
war with an ancient, inveterate, and formi-
dable foe abroad ; and though it is rumoured
about that a treacherous enemyi fraught with
eeditigi agtoMd RoUri WM {1X0
danger, lurks within; aiid though yoaBit
alfio wcU know that there have beea axk
deeds done in aneajghbowingcouDtiyttaBHi
to leave a threateniog and impcndiia dap
louring over this our dhtive land ; tmtt
misfortunes which we must all as good ds-
zens regret and strive to avert, buttbef ai
such as you are not in thb case at iM ton-
card; they are circuinatafioes which mji
feet the public mind, hut can have no ve^
upon your judgment; for, gentlcme9,ja
have fully studied this casse, you are nes M
property and high respectabilKy, Toa bm
God and a good eonacience before your ej^
and you cannotfiul to do rijght, and toactjo^
If, then^ you are of opinion that the piib
accuser both in law and evidence hai oa^
out his case, your determikialion will thocbf
be fixed; but if not, which I trust is tht&ct
your ultimate resolve must he equally fiiedni
decided; whichever of these shsJl be thei^^
to you^ gentlemen, as fellow-creaturo^ son
subjects, and honest men, sitting in joor »
preme tribunal, does the prisoner at the H
with willing confidence submit If I'm (f
of iniquity is full, bitter, bitter indeed n^
be the draught* but if it is not, aod that9«i!r
I trust, will this day be your opinioii, I hn",
that I shall see the just and humane sns «
the law dash it untasted from his lips.
REPLY.
The Lord Advocate^Uy Lords, sndG*
tleraen of the Jury;— However mucblaj
differ in point of law from my ^^^^^^jP
just sat down, however much I."*/j5
from him in many of the projpositioiu m
be assumed in his opening oi the defeao^ «
will be to me, in many respects, a ■**!'•?
ful task to review the evidence which hew
day been laid before you, on the impona
which Mr. Hamilton and I arc t^J^^
riance.
There is one observation^ with whidbh
concluded, to which I must profess mv^
complete and most hearty assent Is ^
case, of any kind whatever, submitted,!^
course of criminal proceeding, to the cow-
deration of juiymen — and much "*^ 5j.
case of this awful and solemn i>*^"|!^«^
you are at present to try— God ^"''"» ij
from the circumstances which have ^'^^^
in another countiy, or firom the <^""*^""'22
which may occur in this country, •°y.S^
opinion,, or any general prejudice, p®*^
laudable that opinion or that pftjaoice ^
be, should lead your attention, for one "^
ment, from the cool, the candid, and tw "J
{artial consideration of the evidence 'SiM^
aid before you, which is the ^^^^Jj^^
which you can look, and the only s"*^J*^
which you are at liberty to decide. ^V^-ju
I state this, sentlemen, I know that n/^
follow from tne same motive, and ^\^^
flow from the same principle, that be toe c^
sequence of that verdict, which y^ ^
and your conscience; and your du9^^
13611
Jur High Treaiont
A. D. 1794.
[1362
country lead you to sive, what thc^ may, if
justice demands a verdict aeainst the prisoner
•at the bar, you must satisfy your oaths and
your consciences^ and will return that verdict
against him.
In a trial nirhich has lasted now for seven-
teen or eighteen hours, I hope, in summing
up the evidence, which it is my duty to do,
and in replying to those observations which
have been Just now stated upon the part of
this unhappy prisoner, that I shall consume
as little or your time as I possibly can; and I
have determined, upon that account chiefly,
though still, I trust, without departing from
xny duty, vrhich upon all occasions must be
the only rule of my conduct, to abridge veiy
much what, in the course of hearing Uie evi-
dcnce read and the testimony given, it was
my intention, at an earlier period of the trial,
to have stated for your consideration. I shall
confine myself to those points of the case
which have all alon^ strucK my mind as deci-
sive of the guilt of the prisoner; which, in
spile of every wish that, as an individual, I
entertained to excuse in my own mind the of-
fence, and explain away the facts which have
been imputed to him, and which I have not,
till the present moment^ been able to satisfy
my own mind upon, which do not press upon
it still as forcibly as when the circumstances
first came under my consideration ; and which,
exclusive of those circumstances, which in de-
fence have been stated for him, and with
which his counsel concluded, but which ap-
pear to me to be circumstanees which do not
exculpate the eentleman, have, aAer all the
attention I could give to his former situation,
od) V tended to agmvate. not to extenuate his
fullt. If you shsul be of an opposite opinion,
shall most heartily acquiesce. .
If it should be your opmion, either that this
scheme was, as m^ friend has attempted to
? persuade you, a wild, absurd rhodomontade,
brmed in frenzy, conceived in madness, and
never seriouslv intended to be carried into exe-
cution; or, if you should think that the part
this man played in it was merelv for the pur-
pose of detecting it, and in due time to do
nis 4uty to his king and country by divulging
it, in God's name return your verdict in his
favour ; and, I repeat it a^ln, most sincerelv
shall I rejoice if your own impartial minds will
permit you to do so.
I stated that one respect in which I differed
from my friend was, on the law which he in
this part laid down ; that a conspiracy to levy
war was not an overt act, tending to show
Let it not then be said, or as it was said to-
night, let not your minds be misled by the
idea that the law of treason, according to that
definition of it which was siven by mv bro-
ther in the morning of this day, and which I
shall also give in a few minutes, not in my
own words, but in those of the oest of men
and lawyers that ever existed, holds out pre-
cipices under the feet of the subjects of U^is
country, which they are not aware of, and
which they cannot discover, till they drop
into the pit which has been laid for them. I
never can conceive, that a consultation for a.
traitorous purpose, for levying war iigainst the
king or government of this countty, or taking
steps to compel the king or the goverameni
to alter their measures by force, or that a con-
sultation for a purpose directly touching the
personal safety of the king, is not an overt
act sufficient, in the common sense of every
man who hears me, to prove an intention up-
on the part of the consulter, to compass and
to imazine the death of the kine. The doc-
trine wnich my learned friend laid down, I
understand to be this : that unless a war is ac-
tually levied, a consultation to levy that war,
is not an overt act of compassing and imagin*
ingthe king's death. Ifthe war (whether it
be with the pomp of war or not. is perfectly
immaterial) be directed against tne person of
the kingj or if the consultation or scheme haa^
in its object and tendency, such measures as
must necessarily, in the completion of them,,
bring him under restraint or into danger, the
best and most established authorities we have
in the law of England, uniformly concur in
declarins, that it is an overt act of compass-
ing his oeath ; and although it is not material
for me to show, that the consultation was di-
rectly and immediately intended to the mur-
der of the king in his natural capacity, vet, I
think, if I attended to the evidence af all, the
proof this day laid before you did, distinctly
and positively, go that length. That upon
the part of the person who was the prinapal
framer and ringleader of this conspiracy, there
was a serious consultation for puttine restraint
upon the king by force, and compelling him^
by intimidaUon, to alter the measures of his
government, under the penalty of taking the
consequences if he dared to reflise ; that pre-
cise fact was broueht out in evidence, and
brought out by evidence directly against the
man who is now standing upon his trial be-
fore you.
Gentlemen, I shall beg leave to read two
passages, both of ^m are short, the words
compassing or imagining the death of the so- of Mr. Justice Froster and the words of Mr.
vereign. It is one pf the peculiar blessings of Serjeant Hawkins, because they put the law
the constitution under which we live, that the in such plain and distinct terms to the under*
lai^ of treason — although occasionally, during i standing of everv body, that I am sure, when
some centuries, additional statutes were passed I read them, I shall not have a word more to
which added to the code of law upon that sub- say in explanation or in illustration of them,
ject— that from the days of Edward 3d, to the Mr. Justice Foster, after stating that risings
present nwment, the same code of laws sub- or insurrections for a particular purpose, ob
sists which existed th«Q, and which, I trust, not fall under the idea of high treason, vl^
will continue toesustaslong'as Britain is free, pressly lays it down, — *' But every insunec«
VOL. xxni. 4 S
i30S\ S4 GEORGB IflL
PrceeeJIngi ag^nd tUAeH Wett
[ISN
tioD, wUick in judgment of law is intended
toiinsl the person df tbe kin^ be it to de-
throne or imprison him, or oblige him to alter
Ids measures of government, or to remove evil
Counsellors from about him. these rbing^ all
Urauunt to levying war Within the statute,
Whether attend with the pomp and circom-
stances of open war or not And everr con-
spiracy to levy war for these purposes, though
fiot treason within the clause of levying war,
k yet an overt act within the other clause of
Compassing the king*s death ; for these pur-
jk)6e8 cannot be effected by numbers and
Open force, without manifest danger to his
fferson.'*
Gentlemen, I hope, when vou come to
cbnsider the evidence, you will keeb this
short, this distinct summary of that law of
^«ason in your minds ; and if the facts which
are proved, and which I shall feel it mv duty
to recapitulate, do not amount and apply pre-
dsely, ^ and almost in the very words, to the
authority which I have just now stated, then
I shall have no objection to abandon my cause,
ami the cause of ray coublry altogether.
I said that I would read the Words of Mr.
Serjeant Hawkins, as the only quotation I
jhall farther give; he says — ^ As to the first
]^ht, that o7 conspiring the king's death^ it
^ems clearly agreed by all, that conspinng
tfie king's death, and providing weapons to
^^ect it, or sending letters to incite others to
^h>cure it, or actually assembling people in
drder to lidce the king into their power, and
t^ll other such like notorious facts, done in
pursuance of a treasonable purpose against
the king's person, may be alleged as overt acts,
lO prove the compassing his aeath«
'*' It has also been ainudged, that the levy-
fflg war against the kiii^'s person, or the bare
insulting to kvv such vrar ; or meeting to-
"ither and consulting the means to destroy
le kii^ and his government, or assembling
£
{>eople, and that they ought to take the go-
ternment into their own bands, may be al-
leged as overt acts, to prove the compassing
the kind's death."
Oentiemen, the authority of lord Coke was
referred to, in order to controvert this proposi-
^on. Is it likely, gentlemen, that this opinion of
lord Coke's, had it been a solid and well-found-
ed opinion, would not have -been held to have
been law at this moment, or that you would
li^lve found subsequent writers declaring the
teverse, and quoting, in supjport of their pro-
positions, not the trials ot treason alone,
which have occurred between the days of lord
Coke and the present moment, but cases be«
fore that perioci, and particularly a case that
is quoted by loxxl Holt and chief justice t^ratt,
two of the first lawyers and best of men that
^Sn^and ever saw at the head of her courts of
justice, which existed long before the time of
lordCok^ thecaseofbrdCobbam, in which
^is very -pc^nt Wiks futty disttisrtd, stf M
txed aud settled upon a fbmMtatkm iKnt% i
be shaken? t will state to you the traristf I
diief justice Pratt, in the noted oseofQifr
topher Layer, who viras indicted itoderstail
or circamstaaces, for compasshig thekii|fi
deatli, similar, in tome respect ts te
stated in the tndietmettt agai&st the pnioai
at your bar, but dissinotar in this imd
only, that when you come to comtiire IM
together, the case of Layer, and tie dtaa
stances of consultation proved agunsthia
and for which he waa convicted, aul sufae^
shrink to nothing in cotaparison with Ihtfo-
tentof conspiracy, that degree tosd«faAi
IfUitorous scheme now before von had li-
vanced towards completion ; and thst sm
and well-ananged svstem of ffleasmes,«l)tt
was not only devised, but aetiially in tom^
ness, and carried ]Murtly into exectition, bytk
orders, and under the directions^ of the{b>
soner at the bar.
Gentlemen, I blame not myledniedli»
ther for arguing as he has done, tsA eilra»
ly well, and stating every thing be qukU}
a ease where a man standi in th<t (btidU
situation, in which the ptisoner nov oa
But when he has stated M hiw, what I i|ip»
bend is not ; and brought forward to 5«b ^
tention points, which, if ever dobknis or »
bateable, hiive long since been ^eitwf m
put t6 rest, it is my duty to set the mute •
rights, and t shldi do ^ in the wonh of tt
chief justice who presided in the tns/of IflBi
where the self-same plea in law wasurgN^
Mr. Hungerfofd, counsel for Layer, toinw
of judgment.
10 that particular case, what were tte
words of the chief juiUee?—* Mr. Hia»IJ
ford, we would hear you on every tt^ttefjj*
consider whether you are not offering a turn
in arrest of judgment, that hath l>«fl *{*;
mined against youa hundred tidies? B^>
not been constantly alk>wed, as JUij>wrt »
of treason, in compassing &»d imsgtiuDg^
death of the king, if the parties d»* ""ff^JJ
consult, and agree to levy war? Hath rtj
constantly been agreed, and doth it not »■
allowed? Now to persuade us, *^"^"*Jj
to overthrow the resolutions takcl^ ^If
decessors, is such a thing as is not ^y.
*« Do yon think we will give » jWjJ;
contrary to what our learned P'^^J'^
have given in cases of the greatest ^J"^
" If I thought it was of any effect I v*J
not grudge spending lime to hear j«t*»
you must agree it has beett over-mleaaD"'
dred limes.*^ . z-^-
Standing upon this authority In P<^«^'|fi
and liable to the correction ©^"^^r'SLl
am vrrong In stating it, t come to ^J*i^
my peculiar duty, in this stage o^^ Vj*'-^
*■ sum up the evidence:, and to reply ^r^^
servatlons stated against it, on the pari <^ '^
prisoner. . j.
Gentlemen, though the indictinfj T
^ched out, into a variety of .^ftrept o^
136&3
Tfctnw*
A.Q. um.
urn
acts inlea^cd, \n foint Qf fQnQ> U> embrace
^^ery posslib)^ ciKums^^nc^ we hi^d to prove
a^^ip&t bifn. «Aii cdcuUl^ put of mercy; nay
out of jiiatlce to tb^ prisoner, to expuun to
\i\m every thing which we had to urg^ against
him ; y^% H is vnatarial for you to knM;>w/ that
^f we succeed in proviDg onlv ope overt act
•«ve ^re entitle^ iboiigh a^I the other seven-
teen (as J belleye there are ekhteen) were not
proved, to a verdict against toe prisoner.
But the matter rests not upon such narrow
.l^rouiul ; because if I consider this evidejoce
Tight, every word that is stated in that indict-
ment, however diversified in expression, and
varied in form, is completely, and fully, and
^stinctly proved before yoM.
Gentlemen, the charge agamst this man ia
coxnprehendea nnder ^wo dlstinet heads :
la the first plape, a conspiracy existing i|i
•this couutnr, not confined to Scotland alone,
y>ui extengVed also to England for calling a
new British CoQventioa, aa the writings and
witnessea have told us, th^ purpose ofwhich
CoBventioD is distinctly spoken out by a]l
tho^e writings to have been nothing less thap
^ bpld, audacious and desperate attempt tp
introduce something liM the French ggv^rn-
xnent aiqong us, to l^ve) the present order
and establishment of things, and, in the appre-
hensioi) of the conspirators themselves, U>
briivg upoQ this opuptfy all the evils of aoar-
I cby, unless prevented by the wild, the abs^^]•
\ and the ndiculoufi scheme which those con-
I spirators bad devised, in th^ moment of the
^ dissolution of the present eovernment, for
^ substituting in its stead something which they
fancied waa to be more permanent and free,
I and morP pali^ated for the good of their
j 4:oi|ntry, apd ^r the good of mankind, than
that for the downfall of which they were conr
j «pjring.
I lEentlemen^ if I stopped here and want no
' farther, I should be entitled to say I have pn>
vedmycase: for th^ kine being, what I trust
he will always remain to oe, an esseptial and
I a component part of the British legislature, if
. I prove this man accessary to a conspiracy.
, which had for its object th^ subversion ana
j overthrow of the legislative authority, of which
1 the king forms a part, I have proved him
2 guilty by the sound construction of the statute
I of Edward 3d. of compassing and imagio-
> ing the death of the king; because he coi|ld
I not hurl the kipg from uiat place which he
' holds in the legislature, and reduce him for $i
* time t9 bpndattP, without bringing bis per-
^ sonal safety and life into danger, and which
^ amounts to what is dascribed in the act of
parliameiit, which passed five centuries ago.
I la Edward 34's time, as compassing ami
I imagining the xl^h of the Icing.
* • Tnis I tak^ to b<p the spimd cpfistruciipo of
' tha u\ of parliament. The law of England,
' wl;^ IS now th^ law of thia country in matr
^ ter30f tinaaspn» and baa jnstly b§efi so aj^e
the vpion, wlM^n pi^r Hllemaa^f was the sam^*
nished in the aaipe manner, is p^cuKaf W iea«
)ous of the safety of the moparch. wiUi
what justice it is sp. with . what g9od
s^i^se, with what tEnowlcoge of poaokinil th^
parliament of Edward this 3d, who wer^ so fa-
mous fQr passing this and Qtq^ sgp)) st^t^tpf,
as to obtam in hist9ry tbp appellai^oi^ pf th^
blessed parliamentf and which, I bo{}e it copr
tinues to deserve, aeclaret^ the bare imai^i^)^
tion of measures tending to efiect th^ Jifi^ ^f
the sovereign to amount to high trea^n, |^
fullv evinced, not only by the history oi pucr
ceeding ages, but by the receat exp^rieppa of
those things which have happened in f
neighbouring country, and to wnich I am ai^
titled to adver^and which justifies that jea-
lousy with which they guarded the life ^
their monarch, and erec^d a barrier ag94q^
ieven th^ consultation of the subjects of thi^
cpgntrv to any f^t^^nipt which could fall under
the dennition of compassing or imagi^iidg th^
death of the king,
Will you thea, gentlemen, permit this ma^L
and others engaged in such a detestable ap^
dangerous qpnspiracv, to be excused upder tb^
idea of an idle ana absurd rhodomontade?
will you |iermit them to go firee under th^
more snecious but false prflsat pf general r^i-
form ot national grievances, or sulFer aiti^f
restless ambition, or tha mad d^ire of ipmv
vation to break through that barrier of strapgth*
of respect and of security with whiph th9 wja-
dom and policy of our ancestors hav? l^pci^
cled the person of the Pf'mca, and established
the stability of our constitution ? We hav^
not indeed far tp go back for evidence 9f x\kp
dapgisr to which auph measures are liable i f^
if the banier pf loyaltv and respect is on^^
permitted to be assailed with impunity bjr
ev^ry one who takes it ip his het^ to dp so, u
will soon indeed be brpkan completpjy
through, the constitution and KQVf mment iu
self suDvertedt and the life ofth^ mpparc||i
pot only eoaangered^ but forfeited, merely
because he has the m^rtane to be tbe cbiff
magistrate.
G^ntlem^n. I hi^ve just ppw stajta^} wht^t th^
parliament of ^gland has done, io its justipi^
mr the safety pf the kina. I have bow t^
sUle, what to its ixpmortai hpnour it biM hH^
done for the most unbounoed security to th^
person ^ccysed of treason. Look to Uia
forms of the law of treason which now* IPT
the first time since the union with ^^l^m^
we have the misfortune to be in pra^tic^ acr
auainted with; cc^sider the manner in which
le charge b preferred against him; eonsider
the time for preparing his defence with whicl^
he is indulged ; that ne has a list of the witr
nesses apd of the jurors who ara tp serve udoq
his trial furxpshea to him, at least ten aaya
beforo it ; consider h\s unbounded power of
challenge, as large as can be admitted of, coitf
sistent with the administration of justice;
that twelve men sitting upon his trial mus^
concur in fipding him guilty, apd I ventiire tQ
t^fyg^, that tba cOMAVy P^er ie^ted,9f tb«A
13^ 34 GEORGE in.
Proceedings agahut Robert WaU
nsB
history tells us of, where the safety of the
subject was under such a charge so amply
protected, where we are tied down to prove
every thing we aver against him, and lost of
all, an overt act is to be found by you, to have
•been committed before you can find a verdict
against him; and I sa^ the human mind
cannot conceive a possibility of trial more fair
for the prisoner, or a system of law provided
that could be more effectual to secure, I had
almost said the imdeomity of aroan who is
guilty.
Gentlemen, I stated that the first point was
the conspirine to call another British con-
tention. And if I have proved that which I
stated in point of law, such would have been,
by the construction of the statute, an overt act
of compassing the death of the kinc. But I
rest not upon that alone, because I say the
other not more but equally material polut of
the cause is, that in this country a consulta-
tion did take place, not onlv for the purpose
^compelling the king to alter his measures
by force, and a consultation alone would have
been of itself sufficient, but in that con-
sultation the person of the king was directly
poinlcd at, his personal safety was to be
t^rought into question and danger ; and I go
farther, and stale, that short of the actual
completion of that plan, short of an actual
insurrection, short of an actual arming of
every person in Scotland, who, by emissaries,
they could arm for that purpose, the consulta-
tion was followed up, and prosecuted to the
utmost possible extent. ^1t was prosecuted to
an alarming extent. God knows where it
would have stopped, if it had not been for the
goodness of Providence, for it was stopped by
an accidental discover]^. It was stopped by a
most extraordinary discovery, and af\er the
measures which they had taken in the prose-
xution of the consultation had been, though
but for a very short time, actually in a state
of execution. I f these things are proved (leav-
ing at present Watt's defence out of the
question) I shall be at a loss to discover how
you can hesitate in the smallest degree upon
the subject. I shall run over the evidence
upon the first point very briefly, because it
consists chiefly of written evidence, and that
evidence has already been read to you by the
prooer officers of the court ; and because I
douDt not you will, when you deliberate upon
your verdict, if you find it necessary, your-
selves look over those material papers.
' You will remember in general, that as early
as the 17th of May, 1793 and immediately
af^r the House of Commons had thought it
consistent with their duty to reject the peti-
tions for a reform in parliament, a letter ap-
pears from a Mr. Hardy, secretary of the Lon-
don Correfipondmg Society, asking from Mr.
8kirving, with whom we are all acquainted,
what more efTecUial measures could he now
attempted. You will remember Mr. Skir-
ving's answer of the «5th May, equally well
proved and of his hand-writingy proved to be
found in the possession of Hardy, xs^Mr Ijs-
zim has told you, when Uardy
bended under a warrant from the
state. You will read that letter ; I
to state upon it, I had marked several pK*
sages of it as fit for your attention, but v^±
at this early hour, I shall omit, inakTCg m
this letter only one observation, that the
writer of it seems to have been a very wiki «&
thusiast to have seriously fixed in his idea, tkc
the present government was to fall into nsas,
and that anarchy would ensue in consetnaesn
unless they in the mean time, unless H»^
and Skirving, with the aid of those soriflipi
much too numerous I am afraid for the pda&r
good, should be prepared with their new sjs-
.tem of government with which they were oc-
cupied. After reading that letter, it -A
be for you, gentlemen, to consider vHiet^
these men were engaged in a wild, linsmi
rhodomontade ; or, whether they were not se-
riously occupied in forming a plan of orgioi'
zation, as Skirving terms it, which they wo?
to be ready to substitute in lieu of the eda&B
they thought was about to fall into destnc-
tion. I shall pass over several of the i^is
letters that are proved to have passed amoqg
these people, between the months of June
and November last, when the British convea-
tion of eternal and notorious fame was esli-
blished in this city. You find Mr. Skirvki^
then corresponding with Mr. Hardy, the se-
cretary of the London Society, which as Tajte
and Gosling told you, met in January last,tii
thcnumberof 1,900 people at the Globe tavsn,
and as late as April, to more than 9,000 per-
sons. You find this London Correspon^^
Society choosing members to go to that Con-
vention. To us it is matter of notoriety that
those two delegates are suffering this momest
for their conduct in that Convention, that just
punishment which the justice dt Scotoad
awarded against them. You find by the e^
dence of Scott and others, there wreie atber
societies in England who sent delegates ts
this Scotch Convention. You have it in evi-
dence from that Mr. Aitcheson whom we sav
to-day, and who acknowledged a paper with
his hand-writing upon the back of it, iDtituM
'' Citizen Sinclair's Amendment of Citizen Cal-
lendar*s Motion ;'' and you have the minutes
of the Convention itself proved to be the wri-
ting of Ross and Aitcheson. From these tod
from the evidence of Ross and Aitcheson, it ap-
pears that this motion of Sinclair's with whidi
you are so well acquainted, was solemnly zssA
deliberately adopted by the Convention ; and
followed up on the 28th November, by a mo-
tion from citizen Margaro^ viz. '' That a se-
cret committee of three, with the secretvy,
be appointed to determine the place where
such Convention of Emergency shall meet :
that such place shall remain a secret with
them, and with the secretary of this-conreih
tion ; and that each delegate shall, at the
breaking up of the present session, be en-
trusted with a sealed letter^ contaiiung the
19691
J^ High Treaton;
A. D. 179*.
[IS?0
name of the place of meetins : that this letter
shall be delivered unopenea to his constitu-
entSy the receipt of which shall be acknow-
ledged by a letter to the secretary, preserved
in the same state until the period shall arrive,
at which it shall be deemed necessary for the
delegates to set off." You have it proved by
Scott that they were dispersed bjr tnc magis-
trates and sheriff on two successive days. It
is proved that this Convention attempted once
Xo assemble in the face of lawful authority,
and that upon the second occasion, Margarot
called out expressly to the Convention to re-
collect they had the preceding evening voted
themselves permanent, and tney were not at
liberty to retire. You will consider these cir-
ctimstances, and connect with them the two
other printed papers on the table, proved to
contain the proceedings at the Globe tavern a
few weeks thereafter, and the proceedings at
Chalk Farm the 14th of April. I will not
iatigue your attention or distress you at this
hour of the morning, by reading the one or
the other of these papers ; much had I to say
much had I to argue on each, but I leave both
to your impartial consideration.
The resolutions at the first, amount to a di-
I rect attack on the legal proceedings of the
, courts of law in your own country, assert in se-
veral passages in the strongest terms, their de-
I termination to resist the leeal authority of this
country, and justify the Convention for that
; conduct for which the juir of Scotland had
convicted their delegate Margarot, and for
I which he was sentenced to Botany Bay.
They take upon themselves the whole ment,
' and state the whole proceedings of the British
' Convention to be such as to demand applause,
and avow they will continue to foirow them in
' all particulars till the last moment. The reso-
lutions on the 14th April, attack in terms still
j more violent and outrageous, the proceedings,
which thej say disgrace the supreme court of
criminal lustice in Scotland, and declare that
these ougnt to be considered as dissolving en-
tirely the social compact between the English
government and the people, and driving them
to appeal to that uncontrovertible maxim of
eternal justice, that the safety of the people
is the supreme, and in cases of necessity, the
only law ; that a measure then under the con-
sideration of parliament, the employing Emi-
grants in British pay, on which measure par-
liament had alone the power to determine,
they state, that on no pretence whatever,
ought the people to submit to it ; they state,
as a question of doubt, what Mr. Taylor told
you was at first a direct assertion, that the
Icine and his ministers had been guilty of
high treason in raising money by subscrip-
tion ; and this, and arming one part of the
country against the other, were the measures
which brought Charles 1st to the block, and
drove James Snd and his posterity from the
throne. If arming a free and \0y2l nation
agunsta foreign enemy, be the measure
which thete person^ consider as armiug[ one
part of the people against the other ; and it
they favour the cause, and are desirous to
bring that enemy into this country, then they
have a right to say they are a part of the peo-
ple against which the others are armed. Since
they take it to themselves, it is for you, gen-
tlemen, to consider to what extent this reso-
lution goes, and of what complexion are the
members of this London' Corresponding So-
ciety. The concluding resolution states their
conviction, ** That a steady perseverance in
the same bold and energetic sentiments
avowed by the Friends of Freedom, cannot
fail of crowning with ultimate triumph the
virtuous cause m which we are engaged."
What cause ? the cause of the British Conven-
tion, which in the preceding resolutions they
have so warmly extolled as being in strict con-
formity to the wishes and instructions of the
society ; and they conclude this inflammatory
and treasonable paper, by observing^, since;
" whatever may be the interested opinion of
hereditary senators, or packed majorities of.
pretended representatives, truth and liberty
m an a^e so enlightened 83 the present,
must be invincible and omnipotent."
In a subsequent part of their address to Jo-
seph Gerrald, they have expressly stated,
^ The equal laws of this country have for ases
past been the boast of its inhabitants, but
whither are they now fled ? We are animated
by the same sentiments," (talking of the Bri-
tish Convention,) " we are daily repeating the
same words, and committing the same actions
for which you are thus infamously sentenced,
and we will repeat and commit them until we
have obtained redress ; yet we are unpunish-
ed! Either therefore, the law is unjust to-
ward you, in inflicting punishment oh the ex-
ertions of virtue and talents, or it ought not to
deprive us of our share in the glory of the
martyrdom."
What is this but falsely stating that the
laws of the country are not administered with
equality and justice ? What is it but vindicat-
ing and making their own, the whole proceed-
ings of the British Convention, and those per*
sons who have been punished for those pro-
ceedinj^, and avowuig their determination to
commit and persevere in the same criminal
conduct, till they obtain redress ? They hope
to have their share in the glory of the martyr-
dom ! I hope that the last part of their prayer
is not far distant. What I have readf now,
is from the resolution of the 14th of April at a
meeting at Chalk 'Farm, where it is proved
there were no less than 2,000 people present.
At the meeting at the Globe tavern in January,
they adopted a similar resolution to that on
your table, which was proved to be Aitches6n's
o^n hand writing, which was for calling a ge-
neral convention, which in fact was to assume
all the powers of legislation over Uiis country,
and to exercise a supreme authority in any
manner it might think nroper ; and which, in
case parliament should think fit to land foreign *
troops,- in case they shouM think -fit to sus-
1571] M 6E0IUSS m.
Proceedingi tign$u^ Robert WM
im
peodtbeH«beMCoqiu>Acl,wbkbb«$ bem
done (an4 Cor tbe wudom and occewi^ of
that KiMsurBt noed I refer you to an^r wng
elae« but what this day's evidence has present-
ed to you?^ and ia several other given cases,
was immediatelj to be summoned for the
dear and indubitable purpose of r^Uion
agunst the legislature of Great Britain.
Before I leave thisi attend also to the lettw
of Hardy, I mean the printed letter which we
have tracisd home to tlie possession of Miller
of Perth, and Mitcbel of Strathaycn ; that
paper, combined with those resohitions which
\ We iust now read, appears to me, and I
(rust and know it must appear to you^ as no*
thing less than sounding the alarm mr a re^
bellion in thiacounti^-
« Citisens, the critical moment is arrived.
an4 Britons must either assert with zeal and
firmness their claims to liberty, or yield with-
out resistance to the claims that ministe-
lial usurpation is forging for them. Will you
OH>peiate with us in the only peaceable mea*
sure that now presents itself with any pros*.
pact of sufleess. We need not intimate to
you, that notwithstanding the unparalleled
audseity of a comipt and overbearing ^tiou
which at present tramples on the rights and
liberties ot the people, our meetings cannot
in England be interrupted, without the prop
Tious adoption of a Convention bill, a mesr
sure it is our duty to anticipate, tbat the ties of
union may be more firmly drawn, and the sen-
timents and views of the difiierent societies
throughout the nation be compared while it
is yet m our power, so as to guide and direct
the future operations of the Friends of Free-
dom* Bouse then to one exertion more,
and let us show our consciousness of this
important truth. If we arc to be beaten
d^vwn by threats, prosecutions, and illenl
sentences, we are unworthy, we are incapable
oflibiNiy. Wf must however be expeditious,
Hessians and Austrians are already among us,
and if we tamely submit, a cloud of those
armed barbsrians tc^^ shortly be poured in
upon us. Let us form then another British
Convention. We have a centrical situation in
our view, which we believe, would be most
convenient for the whole island; but which
we forbear tomentbn, intreatinc your confi-
dence in this particular, till we nave the an-
awer of the societies with which we are .in cor^
respondence. Let us have your answer then
l>y the SQth at farthest; earlier if possible,
wnether vqu approve of the measure, and how
many delmtes you can send, with the num-
ber also, u possible, of your societies.-^ We
remain yours in pure affiBctiQUr-^The London
Corresponding Society^
^ T. HAavr, fiecrelvy.'^
* For the maiia|emeBt of this business we
have appointed a Secret Commktae; yon
will jud^ how ibr It is pece^sarjr fi>r yo« to
do4he same**
. VwFu )msm MtaMyhiii thii elm mm
with tbeta>do^CorrcH>ni»dingjEtocie^,qBitot
in the same measureS| sending oelcgstes to tie
same place, and taking up the csqsaoftix
British Convention where thej left it, loi
corresponding again with every put of fti
GQunt^, let us consider what are tbe iofacS'
ces which you are to draw from these Droced
ings. Aittr the evidence was resa torn
you could have no doubt, tbat this other ni
tish Convention, which was to rouse itself to
one exertion more, was to be a ConveotiQ^
not only as strong but more effectusl tfasntbi
one in £dinburghy dispersed six months bdai&
Tliis letter of Hatdy^s appears to bsvelws
sent to Stock, and a number of copies givci
by him to George Boss, the man in wmk
bouse the Committee of Union mtif lodii
whose house the CoR>mittee of Wsts ib^
Means met; a fact whieh one of the viu
nesses, with a very mean equivocs^, ^
tempted lo deny, for, when I asked bim if b
went to the Committee of Ways and Meio^
he answered, no, he went to the OsseUeer
Office; but it turned out, that the Gas^leei
Office was the very place where these CoD'
mittees always met ; George Ross was s ibs3>
her of tbe British Convention, and of tht
Committee of Union also : and Geoiye Ba9
told you, he sent these printed letUn ^wr
ferent places in Scotland, particularly Pertly
Paisley, Strathaven, and Dundee. Jb ttejw
find him confirmed by the evidence of ma
and Mitchell. Tbe copy sent to Perlhw«
the table, addressed in the hand-wriuog a
George Boss : and Miller admits, that be re-
ceived it from Edinburgh by post, end be ay^
in consequence of that invitation, t^ ^^'^
Perth agreed to choose a delegate, who «»
to be ready to set out, anH to attend w wj
place, then kept a secret where Mr. W«7
should afterwards notify the CoDvcntoJ
should assemble. This happened in ^^t^.
the little man, Taylor, I believe toWyoM^
it was understood in London, tbat »**^f^
Committee bad fixed the place, and tW »
Convention of Emergency was apW^
meet about the beginning of May. 1^
his words down, for tbe coincidence oi »r
struck me to be extremely materyj; *2
have it in evidence, that Mitchell of SUsi^
ven received sudi another letter ; be *^7
chairman of tbe United Societies ef S»lW«n,
and various other villages in that P?w"*?
hood, who met, as Mitchell say»»"*/^
quence of that letter, and likewise «?o^
wegate, to attend the proposed Cflpveapw*
TbeWr itself, signed hym^if^Z
patehed by bim to London, ^^^^if%^
eleotion of the dekgate, was afierwsfW «»r
by the messengers m Hardy's P<»f?**Sh(J
is n9w on the taWe. l^^^^^TZ
April, which talUes Main ew^ ^^
periods of Miller and Taylor- . f^^„^^
From hpw many other towns ^^^^
and from how many ^wns in f'w*5j* i
bl4 re«eivad assurances of ^O'^V^PIXjii^
istai
Jbt £%& nrMKm.
A. 1>. IW*.
tl374
not nefce^d^fernaeioinqtnte; hhetiofUg^
for me to hare proved what 1 have done, and
I now leave it for Vout consldention^ whether
1 have not, clearly atid satisfactorily, made
out, ivhat t hope the fMrosecutor always v^lt,
in such a c^se be obliged to make out, ere he
cati ask a Jury to believe the existence of a
conspiracy or treasonable plot ; ode of as seri-
ous, as alarming, ai^d as ettensive a nattire
as ever wlis formed in the annals of our his-
tory. I confess, gentlemen, that when in a
dinerent capacity,! first heard of the existence
of this extraordinary scheme, ft struck me^ that
it could not be serious, as it bore all the marks,
and the sitnilitude of fancy and madness. But
the evidence this day has proved, that this
schen^e ivas tiot the fancy of the moment, not
the etfon of any one, two, or three individuals
in a corner, actinjj under the influence of an
overheated imagmation, but part of a serious,
and a deep conspiracy, which began eighteen
fiK>nths &go, which gradually grew.in matu-
lity, as the parties, of which it was composed,
contitiued to increase in activity, and bold-
fiess ; atid has now, by dint of unwearied in-
dustry, extended to numbers which we should
have esteemed incredible: when you find
one meeting of i,300 persons publishing
J 00,000 copies of theb resolutions, to be sent
all over the country ^ and a second, of 8,000
jUdd Upwards, publishing no less than 200.000,
because tlie former had not been sufficient ;
when you find it thus gradually increasing,
ivill you, gentlemen, permit this conspiracy
to go on in its progress? will you suffer it to
rear its head any longer against the legal con-
jHituted authority of the state; to hold in ton-
tempt» and attack with impunity, the laws
and the justice of the country, and to justify
the conduct of condemned criminals, with an
avowed determiuatiott to repeat the same
crimes, and never to desist, till they have
Obtained their object ?— All this you have in
evidence ; and the point fit for you, as a jury,
to consider is^ bow hx it is brought home
a»iinstWatt. It is brought home ag^nst
Watt, by this evidence ^ in the Committee of
Ways and Means, which assembled in the
house of George Ross, the man who re-
ceived the paper from Stock, that letter was
laid before tne meeting, in the presence of Bon-
throne^ Slock, Watt, and Downie, where an
answer was concerted to that letter, and Watt,
who is proved to have been alarmed with
respect to corresponding with Hardy, hesitated^
tin advised by Stock, whom I am entitled to
fttate as a traitor, because the grand jury
have found a bill oi indictment against him,
removed his doubts, by assuring him he had
devised a proper mode, in which Hardy and
Watt coula correspond with safety. This cir-
cumstance, 1 am afraid, proves tt^t this mam
artful and cunning as he was, knew suf-
ficientlv well the crimiDal nature of the cor-
respondence in which he was engaged, and
from the peculiar mode in which wEwan an-
swered the question put by the prisoner him-
^^ hev^s, fiotwlcbitanmAg, iUlly resolved
to carry it on. If the eitctise of Ignuraiice
#aft admitoible tx all, some kind oT apology
might periiaps be found for a person, such as
Bonthrone, such as M*£wan, or a man similar
to Mr. Aitcheson, or any of those persons,
who, after being milled bv others more de-^
signingthanthemselves, embarked in schemes,
of the guih of which they were mterly uica-
pacitat^ to judge; and which, fVom theit
situation, they could tiot discover; who were
gradually led as many of the British Convene
fion were from less to mote, without knowing
the full extent of the crime they haA com-
mitted. But could Watt plead that apology t
He waa tK>t a member of the British Conven-
tion, but he knew the proceedhigs of it He
coufd not be ignorant of the ptmishmeot of
the ringleaders of that Convention s and yet
you find him, after the sword of justice had
reached those men. engaged in the same
measures, and carrying them on, in that very
place in which they had stitfered for tlieir o(
fence, by a sentence more lenient than it
merited. It was with his eves open, there^
fere, he must have done all this.
The only nse punishment ever t^tts con-
trived for m this world, for the sake of ex-
ample to others, had completely failed in re*
gard to him. When you find him hi this Com"
mittee of Union, when you find him in th^
Committee of Ways and Means, assisting at
that committee with Stock, eoneertifig the
answer to be given to one of those letters, atid
consulting as to the safe and proper mooe. of
corresponding with Hardy, and agteeing with
Stock, that he was to carry whh him to Haidv
the answer which was dmwn up tipon ^la
occasion; if you think this was an accession
on the part of this man to the scheme of cal-
ling a new British Convention ; if yon think
that his becoming a member of the Com-
mittees of Union and of Wajrs and Meana^
taking uo the cause of the British Convention
where tney lefl H; and persevering, as he
clearly did in the self same system is proved '
against him, you will then Judge if he is iio(
deeply engaged in this conspiracy, and if you
will not hold him answerable for the conse-
quences of the offence laid to his charge. I
nave been dwelUns perhaps too long upon
this part of the evidence : I hope I shall not
be so long upon what remains. 1 state tQ
you with perfect confidence, that if you look
alone to the evidence of Bonthione and
M'Ewan, a case cannot be figured, where the
facts are more completely proved than those
which have come out in the evidence this day
laid before you. By the laws of this country^
two witnesses are necessary to prove one
crime. By the law of Bngland in commou
cases, one credible vritness to a crime, en**
Uties a jury to convict : but though in mattera
of treason, the concurrent testimonies of two
witnesses are rec[uisite, it has been uniformly
held, that one witness to one overt act, and
a&otner to fmother gf the same species of
1375] S4 6E0BGE lU.
Proceeditigi qgamit Robert WaH
[1376
treason, is suffident Inthefwesenicaaejou
have three witDesses to the treason.
M'Ewan was the first witness. I am sure
when I in a few words bring to your recollec«
tion the mannelr in which he gave his testi-
mony, you will join with me m paying that
compliment to him I cannot pay to Bon-
throne or Fairley; that he seemed desirous
to tell the truth, and nothing but the truth.
If you look at your notes, you will find one
particular thing only excepted, which Bon-
throne did not recollect, vou will find every
part of his story confirmed by Bonthrone, and
indeed by all the others beyond the possibility
of doubt.
This Committee of Ways and Means^ like
a self elected committee m France, was in •
vested with full flowers to conduct the busi*
jiess of the party in Scotland, was to turn out
old members and bring in new ones at |ilca-
fiure, and was not to be responsible or ac-
countable to the persons that chose them. It
consisted of seven persons, Bonthrone, Downie,
Stocky Watty M'Ewan, Aitcheson, and Burke;
the two last however soon gave up their at-
tendance,'and if it is worth while to build anjf
thing on the testimony of Aitcheson, his
reason for retiring was by no < means a bad
one. His testimony however I shall leave
perfectly out of the case. I refer you to better
evidence, and evidence not to be shaken,
when I direct your attention to that of
M'Ewan, who tells you the purport of the
plan Watt proposed, when Downie, Stotk and
iBon throne were present; he tells you It was
peither more nor less (it is needless for me
minutely to go over the circumstances of it,
than a conspiracy, not only to compel the
king to iJter the measures of his government,
but to constrain him by force ; to seize during
the night the Castle, the banks, and public i
offices, and to send couriers to excite a jge- |
neral insurrection through the country, and to \
issue a proclamation to the country gentle-
men, fanners, and others to the purpose
J\I'£wan has told us. An address was next
to be sent to the king, stating what had hap-
pened, and if he did not dismiss his ministers
and put a stop to the war, the words are, '' he
4nust either abide by the consequences, or stand
to the peril of the consequences." In almost \
every particular was M'Ewan confirmed bV I
Bonthrone, although he was not surely a wif- '
Ting witness for me, and equivocated as much I
in giving his testimony as ever a witness did '
in a court of justice, who was not sent to gaol
for perjury or prevarication. He corroborated,
however, the account of M*£wan at least m
all its material points, though with the utmost '
difficulty, and a difficulty Which will, on your
minds, have the same effect it had upon mine ;
that this witness said nothing but what was
strictly true, and meant to keep close every '
circumstance he possibly could, which might |
be prejudicial to the prisoner, whose conduct '
he meant to conceal, but which, by that very
reluctance, Bonthrone clearly showed he felt
X
to be highlv criioiiia], and whicL batfortk
obligation he was under to speak the troth,
he Old every thing in his power to coonL
He concurs also vnth M'Ewan in descnbn;
what he felt respecting the scheme Watt pro-
posed to them, and which, to the eteiu!
honour of M'Ewan, he instantly opposed, bj
declaring he never w&uld agree to uj
measure which tended to dbturb the peu
of the country, and to lay his county
in blood ; for Bonthrone declares that M'Ehb
strongly disapproved of that plan, and tint
he joined him in doing so. Bonthm
does not tell you indeed any tiling with le-
pect to the address to the king, but heteDs
you he was so frightened and alarro^ whs
he heard this scheme proposed, that it is not
extraordinary that if this address to tbekio|
was read in his presence, it should Iwe
escaped bis memory. It does not vM
exactly appear whether this address was rad
£it this first meeting, or not till the neiitdij,
in which case the address was not divul^ti
Bonthrone at all, and he never heard of ^
But when you nnd M^Ewan supported ia
every thing by Bonthrone, one circumstaiw
only excepted that does not take from the
credibility of the evidence of M'Ewan, ootbe
contrary it confirms him, and shows MJE«fl
has been telling the truth : for how is it p^
sible to belieye, that where be does » ia
every other part of the testimony, in whi^
Bonthrone and he perfectly comcide w
asree, that in this particular he was telling x
falsehood ?
We had a third witness, Mr. Fairley, a»
here I must repeat with a stronger degree of
application the observation I made on tbe
conduct of Bonthrone : did that man, duiin|
an hour or more that he stood at the foot «
that table, did he or did he not conceal tbe
truth ? you saw his behaviour while under
examination, and you will think, I tnist,tfl
do, that he was determined to conceal tv
truth.
We forced it out of him at last in sjte «
his heart; and material and condusi«»
his evidence is, decisive as it is in every cir-
cumstance, even the most minute, of tl»
guilt of the prisoner^ I will not recapituw
one of them ; observing only in g^^'^W
he has deponed to every thing to whw
M<£wan and Bonthrone had sworn bew
with this only difference, it cost him an Iwj
and a halPs work to tell yon what he «#
and ousht to have done in ten minutcsjjw
he wellknew was no idle plan, butascwoj
the criminal nature of which ^^ ''•* Sj
ciently aware of, and which he wished toWJ
in eternal oblivion. Bonthrone says, he^
so alarmed on hearing the plan read, thstw
went home immediately ana wrote an ao^
tisement for the purpose of '°*^^°§.AJ
Donaldson's next paper, but that be ^^
put it in. Being asked the reason, he sai«i w*
before he had time to carry it to the pnn»^
Fairley had coxoej meptioiigig that be wtf v
1377]
fot High Treamn*
A. D. 17M«
turn
go upon a joamey to see his fnends, in the
course of which he was to do some business for
Watt; and, that having, in consejquence of Fair-
ley's solicitation, given him a line to Watt for
tome money, he considered this as to a certain
deeree of new engaging with the committee,
and on that account kept the advertisement
by him. But that paper he produced, which,
he said, he drew ud at the time, datea 31st of
April, a short whue before stock appears to
have lef\ the city, and on the import of which
I need not say one word. In short, take the
evidence of these three men, Bonthrone,
M'Ewan, and Fairley, compare and combine
them together, and if you hesitate a moment
in believing every thing they have statc^i to
you, to be true, any ar^ment which I could
offer to you on the subject, would be in my
apprehension, extreme) v idle and unnecessary.
Now, it has been said in defence of the pri-
soner, that granting all this to be true, it is at
best an idle, incredible, and impracticable
plan, and a mere consultation or measures
never intended to be carried into execution.
If it he a consultation for the purpose of levy-
ing war against the king, it is enough for my
purpose ; for that of itself is an overt act to
prove the compassing and imagining the
death of the kin^. But it is impossime for
me to agree to this state of the case. I have
proved Siat the matter did not rest at a mere
consultation, but that the consultation was
acted upon and followed up as far as the pri-
soner and his accomplices could go, and to
the utmost extent in their power, till their
progress was stopped by bems thrown into
separate custodv, where they have remained
ever since. It has been said that the scheme
is incredible. Not long ago it would have
been incredible. But let me ask you, gentle-
men, have not things equally incredible lately
happened ? I ask you, could you have believed
in the month of May 1793, that Skirving and
Hardy were then conspirine against the state?
Could you have supposed last winter, when
the British Convention met here, that they
would have dared to have openly passed a
resolution in the face of the country, avowing
a determination to resist the British legislature
by force ? Could you have believed, till the
fact actually happened, that in London, there
would be found men, bold, wicked, and daring
enough to meet in public assembly, to the ;
amount of J,000 persons, to pass resolutions '
in almost the self- same woros, to vindicate I
the crinie of those men whom the supreme !
court of jnstice in Scotland had condemned to
transportation, and avowed their determina-
tion to commit the same offence f Could vou
have believed, if it had not been proved to
you, that they should since have attempted
to assemble anoiher, and a more numerous
British Convention^ similar in its nature and
objects to the former, and for the purposes
stated in the letters I have read ? Kecollect
these thinss, and judge betwixt us, of tlie
merit of this plea of general improbability.
VOL. XXIIL
Recollect also, that we live not in the age of
high families or powerful subjects conspiring,
as m times of old, against their lawful sove-
reign, but in a time unparalleled not in the
history of this kingdom alone, but in that of
the world, when a system, originating in that
country which has excited a convulsion in
every part of £uro|)e, has with a zeal propor-
tioned to the magnitude of the object, and the
desperation of its adherents, been attempted
to be introduced into Britsdn by inflaming the
inultitude, by setting every man of low situa-
tion against his immediate superior, by hold*
ing out to the people the delusive idea of
eouality, not only of rights, but of property ;
which proposes to renounce all rank uid
order in society, and to establish what implies
in it the destruction of the constitution onhis
country, and without which, some of the wit-
nesses nave told you, they were taught to
believe they were not free, annual parliaments
and universal suffirage, the false and specious
pretext under whicn is hardly concwed a
plan to introduce that confusion and anarchy
which have deluged another country in blooci,
and which it must long continue to lament,
it is the conspiracy and treason of the da^r
which I impute to this man. Tell me not
then that Bonthrone, Watt, and the others are
iiot to be believed serious in their attempt to
lii^ their hands against the government, when
we find that the means by which the treason
was to be carried on in every town and vil-
lage in this country, was by seducing the
ignorant and unwary, and deluding the people
to obtain what, if they ever coiud obtain it.
would end in their own desolation, ruin, and
destruction. Tell me not that this scheme is
unlikely on the ground that the actors appa*
rently have not me power to be mischievous.
If you show me that it is impracticable in the
execution, I acree to your holding it to be an
unlikely plan Doth in its formation and struc-
ture. But if you tell me it is unlikely to be
serious merely because this Committee of
Ways and Means consisted only of seven men,
recollect, I beg of you, gentlemen, in what
situation these men were placed, and in What
character they acted. They state themselves
to be the representative of the constituent^
whom the constituent is bound to protect
against every attack made against him, be*
cause the will of the representative is the will
of the constituent It is proved that the
Committee of Ways and Means was a Secret
Committee armed with the most uncon-
trolled and absolute authority over those who
either directly or indirectly concurred in its
nomination. That it possessed a power of
disposing of mone^. collected under various
false pretences, to any fhrpose however trea-
sonable without being called to any account
for it; and that with the utmost artifice and
caution, it devised and directed eveiy possible
step by which the multitude dispersed m clubs
ana societies throughout the country, could
be brought to act together vith vigour and
4T
IS79J 34 GEORGE IIL
Proceedingi agdmi Robert WaU
[1380
by iiirprifliB against the established authority
and covemmeDt of the state.
When I look to the circumstances proved
this day beyond the reach of doubty can we
hesitate in beios of opinion, that there existed
in the bosom of Watt and this Committee of
Ways and Means^ a scheme which bears all
the features of serious, black, dreadful treason,
in every Jine and in every step which they
took to carry it into execution. You find
them by means of an inflammatory paper
attemplmg to seduce the Fencibles from their
duty. You find in the closet of this delinauent
a font of types disco\'ered, which the snerifF
tells you he took into his possession, conceiv-
ing it something extraorainarv, that a mer-
chant and spirit dealer should have any use
for such a machine, and you find the Fencihle
paper taken from that set of types. My bro-
ther was pleased to say, there was nothing
seditious in that paper ; but had he for^t the
peculiar situation of the Fencihle regiments
on the 13th of April when this paper is dated,
and will he slill venture to assert, that the
paper is not seditious? What else than sedi-
tion^ and what less than treason can you im-
pute to the man who at so critical a time,
when all the Fencible regiments had hesi-
tated, some been induced to refuse, and a few
Mtd to their honour agreed to march to Eng-
land, to join in protecting the country at large
under a threatened invasion, could be base
enough, criminal enough, and daring enough,
deliberately to sit down to compose, print,
and publish such a paper, exciting the soldiery
under false pretences not to cross the Tweed
to assist in repelling a foreign invader : which
holds out to tnem m the most infiammatory
language, the danger of Scotland being over-
run by foreign troops, as the only object
against which they ought to guard ; and what
foreign troops } Not the troops of France, the
only foreign enemy whose mvasion we had
to defend against, and to whom, from the
beginning to the end of this paper there is
not the most indirect or distant allusion, but
foreign mercenaries^ as they are termed, an
expression, of which, on reading that paper,
1^ a soldier in the ranks could mistake the
Ihie meaning. To render the meaning still
more obvious, these foreign troops are de-
scribed to be such as have m times past shed
the blood of our ancestors^ and immediately is
introduced the cruel massacre of Glenco, where
the troops of king William were guilty of an
act which has fixed a stain which will not be
soon removed from the annals of this country.
They were not French troops then, but men
in the utuation of king William's troops;
foreigners indeed, but auxiliaries, and who
alone could be introduced into this country
in the hour of extreme danger and the last
necessity, and by the authority of parliament,
whom, under the appellation of foreign troops
and foreign mercenaries it was to ^ard
against, and whom alone the author hsA in
nu eye, jNrheB he composed this printed
address to the Feticibles. Will yoa be of
opinion that there was nothing seditious in
this paper, when you find the parties them-
selves concerned in the publication of it, eoo-
scious of their danger? Remember the evi-
dence given by Watson, who told vou that
while he was standing in a shop in the Lawa
Market, he saw Downie pass by, and having
the curiosity to inquire after that naper or
hand-bill, he followed him and asked for it.
This curious gentleman is a Friend of the
People and lived at Dalkeith, where 300 of
lord liopetoun's Fencibles were at that
moment quartered on their march to England.
Downie tells him ** I have none of them,
but I will take you to a place where you may
get them.'' \frhcre ilo they go? Wataoa
could not or would not swear to the person of
the prisoner ; but he says, that Downie cax^^
ried him to the house of a man who lived a
little below the North Bridge, the very place
where Watt lives ; that after remaining there
a few minutes, Downie and he came out.
He says he did not hear Watt say any thing,
or direct them where to go ; but he admits
understanding he was eoing to have his
curiosity satisfied, which had not been done
at Watf s house, as Downie had led liim ta
expect : that they went directly finoni thence
to Montgomery's shop, on the South Brideey
where Kennedy, a person who absconded &e
evening afler Watt was seized, and who after
every exertion remains concealed, and has
probably by this time escaped beyond the
reach of the justice of this country, went with
Downie into the back shop, and in two
minutes they called Watson in, when Downie
threw a parcel down upon the floor, and said,
he woulcl not jive it him, but desired him to
take it up, addme, that <' if any body asks you
how you came Ey it, tell him you found it.*^
For what reason Mr. Downie was ^otto give
the parcel to Watson, but he was yo find it, I
leave, gentlemen, to your own coiisideration ;
the parcel contained a number of copies of
the address to the Fencibles, which Mr. Wat-
son admits, he lost no time in distributing at
Dalkeith, and one of which we have tn^ed
out of his hands, directly and completely, to
the person of serjeant Hardy, who produced
and identified the copy, and which is proved
to be the same as those struck off by order of
the sheriff, from the font of types discovered
in Watt's house, and is the very paper. Is it
possible you can ask, or expect greater evi-
dence of guilt? My brother stated, that the
circulation of this paper, if it was criminal,
was a crime against martial law, and deserved
severe <niHtary punishment. Watt is not a
soldier, and I am not trying him for an offence
by martial law ; but I am trying him for hig^
treason, and as a circumstance showing hisi
guilt, I have proved him to be the man to
whom Downie directly went for the papers'
Watson asked for^and these papers are faixoA
to have been imprinted and cast off from the
font of types discovered In his possession : I'
• >
1381]
for tf^h Treason*
found on this circumstance, among a Tariety
of others, as convincing evidence of Watt's
treason; and I maintain that the whole of
them completely disproved the defence set up
for him by my brother, that the plan was an
absurd, ime rnodomontade ; on the contrary,
thai he and his associates were engaged in a
«erioua deliberate scheme of addressmg the
king, compelling him by force to alter his
jgovernmcnt, and of exciting and raising an
waurrection against him.
But the evidence of Fairley is of itself de-
cisive of his guilt ; and, if the circumstances
he has sworn to, and in which he is completely
confirmed, can, upon the nart of Watt, be
reconciled by you, to the idea that he was in
Jest, and which, from the first moment I knew
them, to the present, I have reflected on again
and again I am bold to say, with every pos-
«ible wish to excuse, in my own mind, the
conduct of a man, to whom I once looked
with a favourable eye, and on whom myduty,
as a servant of the crown and the public, led
me to bestow confidence, but without my ever
Jbeing able to do so, if you can still teach me
how to believe him pardonable, innocent of
the treason, and that he was not completely
determined in the scheme he had proposed,
instruct me in that lesson, if you can, and,
most truly and sincerely will I thank you.
He sends Fairlev to the west country, and
upon what errand I need not remind you, nor
of the reluctance with which Fairley was
compelled to speak out. He corroborated, in
every thing, what Bontbrone and M<£wan had
formerly told us, except the circumstance of
eeizing the banks and public offices, which,
though questioned for half an hour, by my
brother, the solicitor general, he swore, after
repeated cautions, that he did not remember
any thing about ; and yet, after having left
the court, he voluntarily came back, and de-
clared, upon recollection, he remembered that
also. He proves, that be was directed by this
secret coroniittee, to advise, in the different
towns he visited, the establishment of collec-
tors, to levy and remit to the Committee of
Ways and Means, money to carry on the
great cause ; and, although he admitted that
he did not know even a single person in the
varu>us towns and villages to which he was
sent, it is singular that he stumbles upon the
Friends of the People, and the most active
ringleaders of the British Convention,
wherever he goes, and is by them courteously
entertained, and received' with open arms.
What does Dr. Forrest state? He states,
what if any doubt could remain in your minds,
as to the seriousness and guilt of this conspi-
rscv, must completely remove all hesitation ;
and which of itself is a damning circumstance
to the prisoner at your bar : he states, and
jbe statra it with a reluctance which showed
he did not wish to load the prisoner, very
much the reverse, that Mr. Fairley did com-
municate to him written instructions that
they should provide themselves witb^wbat?
A. D. 1794. [1S8S
A blank followed, which Forrest understood
to mean — arms: that an insurrection was
soon to take place in Edinburgh ; that the
soldiers were cither to be disarmed, or brought
over to join the insurgents ; a circumstance
which tends also to snow, for what purpose,
and with what intention the address to the
Fencibles was composed and circulated, and
which proves Watt and Downie's confidence
in the probable success of the wicked and
treasonable undertaking in which they were
engaged.
From whom does Fairley receive the
money necessary for defraying the charges of
this treasonable embassy ? He eets a line, I
think from Bonthrone, addressed to the pri-
soner, who consigns him — to whom? To
Downie the treasurer of the Committee of
Ways and Means. From whom, and in what
circumstances and manner does he receive
his instructions f Watt directs him to a shop
in Edinburgh, kept by one Campbell, a hal-
ter, one of the same kidney with themsehres;
and on the counter, Mr. Fairley finds a parcel
lyin^, which he immediately takes up, and
carries away with him, in order, I presume,
that in the event of his being Questioned re-
garding its contents, Mr. Fairley might, by
the same ingenious device practised with Mr.
Watson, be enabled to satisfy his contoience
in denying that he had received it firom Watt,
though in truth it came from Watt alone.
He goes as far as the Queensferry^ ere he
opens this parcel, which was to direet his
whole journey; and he finds instructions, of
a direct treasonable purpose, and a parcel of
printed papers, directing, among other things,
the societies in the country to wpoint collec-
tors over every fourteen or fifteen persons,
who were to conduct and superintend their
proceedings. Dr. Forrest swears to the same
thing pointedly, and tells you what this in-
stitution meant: That these collectors were
to be appointed over small divisions of four-
teen or fiflecn people, for the pretended pur-
pose of collecting money and sentiments,
out chiefly to act as commai^ers in the pro-
posed insurrection. Thus were vou to have
a system of insurrection established, which,
if such a plan could ever be carried into exe-
cution, did ample honour to the ability of the
contriver ; for it was not a plan, partial in its
nature, and contrived to excite tumult and
disorder in one city or district alone ; but a
conspiracy, calculated to include all Scotland,
at least, and constructed in the best way to
insure success, when carried into execution.
It is proved, that the societies were to be
previously subdivided into small bands or de-
tachments, ftt)m twelve to twenty, each
headed by their collector, who, when the
moment of insurrection arrived, was to act as
their leader : that these coilec tors were again
to meet in a separate body, with a prases at
their head, who was to communicate with the
Secret Committee of Ways and Means, and
receive, and convey to the other ooUeolors its
1383] 34 Gfi<MlGB IlL
ProceediMgs tigmui BiAeri VTm
CL3M
directioiiB and orders. The reuoa of Terting
this secvet oommitteey with that supreme con-
trolling power which they ve proved to have
possessed, is now obvious. A conspiracy of
this magnitude and extent, could not be con-
ducted and managed, unless such a small
number was placed at the head of it, as could
ensure secrecy, till it was ripe for execution ;
unless tbeite men were vested with uncon-
trolled powers, unless they had devised a mode
of setting the machine m motion in a mo-
ment, and of conveying, instantaneously and
•uddenly, through proper channels, to the
multitude, withmit whose prompt co-opera-
tion, it could not succeed, the steps they were
to take, and the orders they were to obey.
By the means proved this evening before you,
did this committee, not unreasonably ho|>e
and expect, to make the people, not in this
€ity and country alone, but throughout Scot-
land, for aught we know, perhaps in London,
and all the towns in the kingdom to operate
under them, as if acted upon by one mind,
whilst the scheme itself was safely con-
fined to the breasts of the secret committee,
and was only divulged in the moment of
its bursting into rebellion. Such is the
conspiracy, the particulars of wliicfa have
been fully laid before you, which was to
have been acted upon, in the way I have
•tated, and to the extent I have just now
observed.
In reviewing the evidence, I had almost
omitted meationius; the circumstance of arm-
ing, which, though hardly necessary to the
ostablisfament uf his guilt, is indisputably,
and directly brought home to Watt. What
purpose could he have in view, in providing
those dangerous and extraordinary weapons r
He said for the purpose of merchandise. Did
the countryman, Orrock, believe them in*
tended for the purpose of merchandise ? No.
Did Bcown believe itf No. By whom were
they paid ? By Downie, the treasurer of the
Committee of Ways and Means, the self same
treasurer who received and disposed of the
money for th^ advancement or that grand
cause, which was to be carried into execution,
bv means of privately and secretly arming
tne Friends of the People, under different
false pretences, unnecessary for me to reca-
pitulate, bat in truth, for the purpose you
oave heard so fully and distinctly proved this
ovenioff. Brown tells you the manner in
which ne was first employed in this new ma-
nufacture; and under what suspicious cir-
cumstances, Robertson, the schoolmaster, pre-
vailed upon him to undertake executing the
order, which is proved to have come from
Watt. I shall not dwell on the evidence of
Orrock, confirm^ as he is by a variety of
witnesses, farther than requesting you to give
ijue weight to the orders he received, for fitr
|tin£ his instruiDenls all to the same screw ;
•^nd the complaints made by Mr. Watt, and
liis emissaries, that his first productions were
noX SMfficiontl^ fihaqpened, j) is jftsm^ also,
tint Orrock finding, on an accidental
satioo with Brown, that he was also employjed
in the same business, took alarm at tte hid-
ling way (to use the witness's own words) n
which the manufacture was going forward,
and had resolved to give it up, when the dis-
covery prevented him. Is it not proved, that
Watt went, of his own accord, to Orrock, and
desired this man to say, if any person asked
him what these instruments were iDtended
for, that they were making for the top of a
gentleman's gate ? And can you, g^tlemeo,
in the face of all these, and every circnm*
stance in the conduct of this man, believe for
a moment, that these arms were intended as
merchandise, or for the purposes of legal sdf
defence? I know you cannot: Your oath
and your conscience will not permit you.
I have gone through, I think, every thing
which appeared to me necessary to observe
in general on the evidence : I regret 1 could
not say it in fewer words. Last of all comes
the defence he has stated, and instructed his
counsel to maintain, upon a former connenm
with the secretary of state for the home de-
partment and myself That he volunteetad
in forming this connexion is admitted by
himself; is proved by the copy of the letter
which was found in bis own posaession, and
which, without objection on our part, he
Sve in evidence, and it is corroborated bj
e letter of Mr. Secretary Dundas, of the 5th
of September, which appears to have been its
answer. For having given him my evidence,
and having waved any privilege wnich I un-
derstand would have authorized the attorney
general of England to have refused it,"* I take
no merit ; it was my duty to give this man,
circumstanced as he and I once were, the be-
nefit of my evidence upon oath, since he eoo-
sidered it as material, and to tell you every
thing I know regarding him. You have
heara my evidence, and upon that subject it
is impossible I can say one word. Yon will
consider whether it is within the bounds of
the most distant probability to believe the
story he has instnicted his counsel to tell for
him, that he meant to communicate in due
time to me or the ministers of this country,
the designs of these men, and that he was
only watching them for the public good.
From the month of July, most assuredly
since the month of October last, he chose to
discontinue his attendance upon me ; tbouafa
the proceedings of that period were suffi-
ciently momentous, and such as to call for
both his attention and mine. He says; I
went to London in March, and since , that
could not see me ; and as the proceedings of
the convention were printed in the Edinburgh
newspapers, his more early attendance was
unnecessary. But a letter would have
reached me in London in three days : and
you are at full liberty to sustain, if you can,
* See thecaseof Mr.Uomefiiralibel^aiit^
VoL80,p.740^
13853
fift nlffi IVtfffiOll*
«iifficient,'the apology he has offered for i
absence from October to March, whilst I
he and I were resident in this city, and when
be was sure I was ready to receive liim with
anjr cocnmuuication he chose to give me, and
which, as a faithful servant of the king and
of the county, I felt it mv duty to receive
firoin him. Can it be doubted, afler what
you have heard this night, that he was the
principal actor and prime mover of ail these
plans, conducted with an artifice and cunning
t harcily ever knew eaualled ; and is it within
the reach of the most charitable credulity to be-
lieve he was there for the purpose of giving
information to government? and with what
other purpose, or from what motive, he con-
ductea these proceedinj;s, and took the lead
in these counsels, it is for you to determine,
hardly necessary for roe to hint at or inquire;
but whether he did it in order to keep well
with both sides, and ultimately prefer that
moat likely to prevail, the most charitable
and advantaseous' view you can take of his
conduct, or whether recurring to the ori^nal
habits, or being misled by the conversation
of those with whom he associated before he
wrote to Mr. Jhindas ; whatever may have
been the cause of the alteration of that line
of conduct, I know of no circumstance occur-
ring in that period, nor have I heard any ar-
gument deduced from it, which so far m>m
extenuating, does not, to my mind aggravate
the guilt wnich has been so distinctly made
out against him. If he states that which
cannot be seriously stated for him, which my
brother's discernment would not allow him
directly to state, though the inference neces-
-sarily flowed firom his argument, that in all
this he was playing the part of the spy and
informer, that he was graaualhr l^iding these
men into the criminalitv of a scheme of
treason for their ruin, and for his own advan-
tage, I ask you, gentlemen, will the utmost
exertion of mercy on your part admit of your
swallowing so incredible a story, or reconcil-
ing it to the active share he had in this bu-
siness ? If you can do so, fi;ood God, what
■opinion are you to form of the man before
you, who could coolly and deliberately devise
fuch an infernal scheme, from which human
nature revolts with horror : a scheme which
was calculated to involve innocent, or at least
deluded men, in the most certain and dreadful
ruin, whose lives he was to sacrifice to h»
own sordid views of advantage ! No eentle-
men ; guilty as this man is against Uie life
of his sovereign and the existence of the state,
^he neither is nor can be guilty to such a
horrid extent as this defence wotdd involve
him. When you find him persevering with
his associates in this conspiracy, long after
he had full opportunities of discovering it ;
when you find iiim, long afier the measure of
iniquity was fiill, and the treason of those it is
supposed he meant to betray, perfectly com-
plete, not only concealing the consultation,
which of itielf wassuOcieotfor thatiaftmoua
A.D. HM. [1986
purpose, but acting upon it in every particular,
and devising and executing every «step which
could lead to serious execution, and insure its
being successfully carried into effect; I leave it
with you to consider if you can, like honest men
with the oath of God upon you, and with jus-
tice to your country, listen to, and believe, so
absurd, so incredible, and so schocking a dc*
fence.
Gentlemen, painful and severe as the task
is which the law and justice of your country
imposes on you, I know that if necessary, vou
will not shrink from performing it. In this,
as in every other case, you will m presence of
your God and your country, return a verdict
according to the evidence, which in this case
is so clear and satisfactory, that it is impos-
sible for me to discover where you can have
the smallest doubt. The reasons for being of
that opinion I have fully laid before you. If
on these we diflfer, it is your right and your
dut^r to acquit him of the charge, and I shall
be sincerely happy if you can do what, I repeat
again, it has not been in my power, after the
most anxious and painful reflection to bring
my mind to. But the verdict is yours not
mme, and for its truth and its justice you
alone are answerable. Be that verdict what
it may, sure I am it will be that of honest
men ; you will do what appears to you con-^
sistentwith truth and with justice, "^ypu will
do that which will satisfy your consciences ia
every future hour of your hfe.
SUIIUIKO UP.
XorrfPrefu/«n/.— Gentlemen of the Juiy ; —
In consequence of an indictment found against
this nrisoner, by the grand jury of the county
of Edinburgh, upon a charee of high treasoa
he now stands tnal for his life ; and the proofs
on both sides beins closed, it remuns with
you to consider, andby your verdict to declare
whether that charge has been sufficiently
made out against him, yea or not.
I need scarcely observe, that this is a trust
of a hi^h and important nature, which is re-
posed m you by the laws of your country, and
that of course' you must feel yourselves bound,
as honest men, by ever3r tie of duty and of
conscience, to discharge it with strict fidelitv
by returning a verdict according to the truth
of the case, and the conviction of your own
minds, without regard to any otiier conside-
ration whatever.
In order that you may be enabled so to
do, it is necessary in the first place, that you
have a distinct view of the law of treason, I
mean that branch of it which is connected
with the present subject; and in the next
place, that you take into your most deliberate
consideration, the whole amount of the evi-
dence, and every circumstance attending^ it,
whether it be for the prisoner or against him.
With regard to the law of treason much has
been said, and with great ability, by the gen-
tlemen at the bar, but as it couM scarcely be
ei^ected that they should b^ at one in their
1S87J 34 GEORGE lU.
Proceeding* agaimt Roiert Watt
f;i^88
concluftiODSy it is tny duty to lay a state of it
l)efore you, which I ,hope will appear to you
not to be attended with much dimculty.
It must be obvious to you, that the king
stands at the head of the constitution of this
country. The executive government is placed
entirely in his hands, for the due execution
of which the minister^ chosen by him are
responsible.
The king also forms one branch of the le-
|:islative power, which vou know is composed
of three estates, king, lords, and commons;
so that in more than one capacity, the kin^ is
an essential and integral nart of the constitu-
tion, without which it could not for a moment
exist. Indeed no part of the system can be
disturbed or encroached upon, without manl-
iest danger to the whole.
Of late, great pains have been taken to inr
troduce amon^ us the odious terms and dis-
tinctions of aristocrate and democrate. But,
gentleman, no good subject of this country is
either an aristocrate or a democrate ; he is
both the one and the other, and a rpyaJist
too. Every British subject enjoys the pro-
tection of the king*s government as defined by
law, and on the other hand, he owes the duty
of allej^iance to the soverei^ as inseparable
from his condition ; and bemg the subject not
of an absolute monarchy, but of one which is
fimited and circumscribed by law, his rights,
and his liberties, religious and civil, are com-
pletely secured.
You have heard a great deal about another
distinction. Some men have affected to call
themselves the Friends of the People. Friends
of the People ! gentlemen, if by that terra is
meant that those assuming it are friends of
the whole, that is, friends of th^ king and of
all ranks of men in this country without ex-
ception, then it may be allowed that they are
good subjects and friends to the constitution ;
Sut why they assume to themselves exclu-
sively, a name which ought equally to belong
to everv British subject, one is at a loss to see.
If on tne other hand, their affection be only
i>artial, if they come with friendship in the one
hand and daggers in the other ; if they mean
to adopt only one part of the constitution and
to reject another, then may it truly be asserted
that they are the bitterest enemies the people
of this country ever saw.
Gentlemen, what a wretched delusion is it
that has taken possession of the minds of many
men in this country, who say that they want
liberty, when their own proceedings are proof
of the reverse, and who think their condition
is to be some how made better, and their
situation to be amended ; by what? By the
destniction of government, by the introduc-
tion of democracy, and establishing a French
convention in this country, which would be
the infallible consequence of their measures,
vere they to take effect.
But, gentlemen, without going farther upon
ihese general topicsi I now come more closely
to the poial in quentioot
It has been explained to yoa bf the
sel at the bar, that the law of treason which
we are to iudge and act upon, is the Emglisb
law, which was made ours, in consequence of
the union in 1707 ; and it surely cannot bt a
part only of that law, as thrown out by one of
the gqptlemen, but the whole which we have
adopted; because it is now impossible that the
law of treason can in any particular be one
thing in England and another thing in Sco^
land.
The statute of Edward 3d like most other
laws of an ancient date, being conctaie and
shortly expressed, we must have recourse to
the explanations which it has receivcMl by a
variety of adjudged cases, and eminent aiitbo»
rities in the course of four centuries.
Gentlemen, to compass the death of the
king, if such compassing be manifested by
any overt act, is by the express terms of the
statute itself^ high treason; but what b or is
not a sufficient overt act, within the intent
of the statute, must always be open to infer-
ence and construction, according to the cir-
cumstances of each case as proved ; for the
statute does not say precisely what is an overt
act, but it says, to compass the death of the
king is treason, if accompanied by some oveit
act. The mere compassing or imagining the
d^ath of the king, so long as it remains an
act of the mind only, cannot be reached by
proof, and is not a proper subject of trial ;
out if it be manifested by a positive act, sudi
as conspiring, plotting, forming plans, or. pro*
viding arms, &c. these are circumstances ca-
pable of proof, and we must ticcordiogly in-
quire into the nature of such circumstances^
and see whether they do or do not amotmt to
that which in the construction of the statute
has been held sufficient as an overt act, to
prove this branch of treason, although the dfr>
sign may not have been carried into full e&ct.
The different authorities from the law books
have been read to you from the bar, partioi-
larly those of k»d chief justice Hale and Judge
Foster, upon that part of the law. Thej
amount to this, that so much care does the
law take of the personal safety of the king,
tliat it is not confined to such attempts as are
directly aimed at his life, but is extended to
tliose whereby his person may be endanger-
ed ; and therefore, says the last of these ao-
thors, ** every insurrection which in judgment
of law is intended against the person of the
king, be it to dethrone or imprison him, or to
oblige him to alter his measures of government,
or to remove evil counsellors from about him,
these risings all amount to* a levving war
within the statute, whether attended wiih the
pomp and circumstances of open war or no;
and every conspiracy to levy war for those
purposes, though not treason within the danse
of levying war, is yet an overt act within the
other clause ofcompas^ngtheki^'s death,
for those purposes cannot be enected by
numbers and open force without ift'anife^
danger to his peinon." The doctiins is thew
1380]
Jw H%A TrtoMn.
A. D. 1794.
[1390
laid down in plain and intelligible terms/
which apply Yei^ closely to the present case,
viz, thai a conspiracv to levy war for the pur-
pose of compelling the king to alter his go-
vernment, whether there be any direct ioten-
Uon of kiUing him or not, amounts' to an overt
act of compassing the king's death, in the
sense of the statute. ^
It is very true that there may be rising of
the people for the purpose of obtaining redress
of grievances of a certain kind, euch as to ob-
tain a repeal of particular laws, or for obtain-
ing other ends of a public nature, which do
king, by force ot arms, to alter the measures
of government, to introduce new laws, and to
comply with certain demands.
Thirdly, — ^That* they consulted and con-
spired al)out seizing the Castle of Edinburgh,
attacking and surprising the king's forces,
and taking possession of certain public offices,
-^and certain persons in authority.
Fourthly, — ^That he and others, instigated
aiid excited a number of persons to assist in
their measures, employing one Fairley, to g^
about as an emissary, to divers parts of the
_ country, to collect money and opinio^is ; and
not, in the construction of law, amount to an ' that, in prosecution of the same measures,
they caused pikes, spears, and other warlike
instruments to be provided, to enable them,
forcibly to resist the king and his govern-
ment.
Gentlemen, if these acts, or any of them
have been proved against the prisoner, it will
then be necessary fur you, to deliberate upon
overt act of compassing the king's death,
there heinjg no view to the disturbance of go-
vernment m general, or to bring the king's
person into hazard; which risings however,
if they do take place, are held as constructive
treason, on account of their dangerous ten-
dency, though a bare conspiracy or plan to
effect such a rising, is not held to be an overt i the effect of such proof; but first, we are
act under the 6rst branch of the statute. But : to examine what eviaence has been adduced
a conspiracy to rise in rebellious war against
the king and his government, for the purpose
of new modelling or altering the frame ot the
Evernment, which necessarily includes the
ng as a part of it, or to usurp the nowers
of government and legislation, which of course
must supersede the authority of the sovereign,
at least during that period ; such conspiracy,
I sav, must be held as an act of compassing
the king's death, and is high treason, by the
plain sense of the statute, and upon every
construction it has ever received ; for it goes
▼irtually and necessarily to a deposing of the
king, by depriving him of his royal authority
and fimctions, which it is the kmgfs dtUy to
resist by force of arms, and he is even bound
by his coronation oath so to do, as he must ,
> govern by the existing laws and constitution
of the country ; so that in such a case his
life must be put into the most imminent dan-
cer, and civil war must be the consequence.
If such a design is carried into execution, the
country is in a state of rebellion, and the king's
person and government directly invaded. A
conspiracy therefore to put the country into
that state, must be a treasonable conspiracy
of the most dangerous kind.
In the present case, a number of overt acts
are laid in the indictment, which seem to be
of the nature that I have stated, they are di-
vided into no less than eighteen different ar-
ticles ^ but I think several of them may be
compressed into one, and they will appear
more simple, when they are classed under
fewer heaas, such as the following : —
First,— That the prisoner, alone with others,
conspired, consulted, and agreea to procure a
meeting to be held, under the name of a Con-
vention, for the purpose of usurping the pow-
ers of tovcmment and legislation, redressing
alleged grievances, and brmging about certain
changes.
Secondly,— 'That the prisoner and others did
aeet, consult, and agree, about compelling the
for substantiating the different branches of the
charge. ,
As to the first, viz. the project of a convent
tion, to usurp or control the powers of go-
vernment and legislation, a doubt was stated
from the bar, whether it could apply to the
case of the prisoner, who was no member of
the convention held at Edinburgh, which was
dispersed in December, 1793, without being
followed by any subsequent convention. But
it has been clearly proved by M'Ewan, Bon<-
throne, Fairley, and others, that the prisoner,
within a very short time after the convention
at Edinburgli^ called the British Convention,
was dispersed, became a very active and zea-
lous member of a certain committee, or sub«
committee of the Friends of the People, calle<f
the Committee of Ways and Means, the ob-
ject of which was to raise money; and Aitchs«
son, who was one of the memoers of it, has
expressly sworn, that one of the purposes, to
which that money was to be* applied, was ^ to
pay the delegates to a future convention, to be
neld somewhere in England.'' The existence
of different societies, ooth in England and
Scotland, for the ostensible purposes of re-
form, but truly for controlling ana overawing
^vernment, such as the Corresponding So-
ciety in London, the Friends of the People at
Edinburgh, &c. is clearly instructed by written
evidence,, viz. their minutes, and letters of
correspondence, which also pretty clearly point
out wnat their ultimate objects were, ana that
a more general convention was in view, to
consist of delegates from all the particular so-
cieties, and consequently to act by representar
tion, and to treat, of matters of state, a privi-
lege which belongs to no other body, except
the Commons of England in parliament as-
sembled, who, by the nature ot the constitu*
tion, are represented from the boroughs and
counties. — Delegates, met in a convention,
for public purposes, and to consult upon pub- *
Ik measures; while we have a king' and par-
1301] 34 GEORGE lU.
Prouedrngi ^gmna Rgkrt WaU
[US
liamenty cannot poisibljr exist, without in-
troducing a new power into the etttte, para-
mount to that of parliament itaell^ and conae-
ouently adverse to every idea and principle of
txkt constitution. The circumstance or this
prisoner's beine a member of the Committee
of Ways and Means, and the active assistance
which he gave in carrying on the buuneas of
that committee, must leave in your minds
very httle room to doubt of his accession to
the project of a new General Convention. But
if you have any doubt of hit guilt, in this
particular, it wtil be your duty to lean to the
nvourable side, and to lay this branch of the
charee out of your view, which, however,
will be of no material consequence to the pri-
soner, if you are of opinion, that the other
overt acts are sufficientlv proved agunst him.
It is stated, under the subsequent headq,
which, (in viewing the evidence), may be
taken together, that they did, in fact, meet,
consult, and agree about compelling the king,
by force of arms, to alter the measures of go-
vernment, to introduce new laws, and to com-
plv with certain demands, with a view to
which, they also consulted and treated about
the necessary means of carryinz their plan
into execution ; such as seizing tne Castle of
Edinburgh, the public offices, &c
The proof of these facts arises, chiefly from
the eviaence of some of those very men who
assisted in the deliberations. Aitcheson is tho
first witness upon this part of the charge. lie
was a little sparing of his words, and he seems
to have proceeded with caution. He was told
by the prisoner, *< that something of impor-
tance would soon be upon the carpet;" and
he also heard, out of doors, ** that some se-
cret business was to be before the committee,
i>T which reason, as he acted upon public
grounds, he did not choose to attend their
meetiogs any longer."
The next witness, and a very material one,
is M'Ewan, who was himself a member of the
Committee of Ways and Means, and had oc-
casion to be at the meetings of that com-
mittee, where the prisoner attended. He
states^ that at one ot these meetings, consist-
ing or Stock, Downie, Bonthrone, the witness
himself, and the prisoner at the bar, the pri-
soner took a paper out of his pocket, which he
read; that it contained a plan for seizing upon
the lord provost of Edinburgh, and the iudjges ;
that in order to draw the soldiers out of the
Castle, a fire was to be lighted at the Excise-
office; that certain persons were to be sta-
tioned at the Weigh-house, and other places,
and the soldiers were to be surrounued by
them; that they were to seize oh the Ex-
cise-office, and banks, and to demand money
of the bankers. As to the design of seizing
the Castle, this witness is silent, but in speak
ing of the attack to be made upon the sol
diers, when they were drawn out, he says,
he was told what was to be the mode of doin^
it, which he describes; and, Uiat the pn-
aonor^ afler having read this paper, made
•oraeconectioDSupottit with histtB, .
seems to denote, that he lumself vsi the
author ofit, or that he bad a right to me tha
liberty with it; and he then put it up ini
press, in the room where the compaay voe.
The witness goes on to state, that, n
another night, in the s^me house, be aad
Downie bemg present, the prisoocr icid
another paper, containing a notice, in the fin
of prockimation (one of the highest eieidxi
of sovereign authority), wluch was tobemb
'^ for the purpose of intimating to the ktoBO,
to bring sii their grain to market, and for the
eentlemen residing in the country, not to
leave their houses, or at least not to lo nm
than the distance of two or three mues &aa
home ;*' and he adds, that there vss tbe
form <^an address to the king, <* todisBW
his ministers, and put an end to the wiriilh
France, for, that it he did not, he mustAife
the consequences, or that worae cooseqneooei
would ensue.*'
He fiirther states, that the prisoner c»-
ducted him to tlie shop of Orsock, the snitfa,
with whom he had a conversation about nsk*
ing pikes; that Orrock drew a modelspn
the table, and the prisoner desired him to
be busy about them, for that he wss to
send four thousand of them to Perth, besids
what were to be distributed at EdioburgiL
That the witness was in Orrock's shop, wh«
lord Swinton's servant came in, and cbsttV'
ing one of the pikes, asked what it wts» ud
Orrock said it was for a gentleman's gate.
This extraordinary narrative was given ^
the witness with great clearness and fueo-
sion, and in such a manner as roust hsre
carried conviction to your minds, of the toith
and candour with which he spoke, sad, it
the same time, of the alarm which be «
under, he himself having expressed huoB-
sent to any measure by which the bww a
his countrymen might be shed.
I cannot bestow Uie same encomiiun apot
the next witness, who spoke to the ane
facts, viz. William Bonthrone, who, sftari
good deal of hesitatiou, and with the utoja
ifficulty, acknowledged that he heart tie
paper redd by the prisoner, and in substBitt
concurred with the preceding witness tf»
the tenor of it, with this addiUon, that »»
lieved it contained a plan for seizing upon m
Castle. This witness, in the same way «J
M*£wan, appears to have been vciy maa
alarmed indeed ; he says his confiisioa «v
such, that it deprived him of the P^'^ ,f?!
collection, and he seems desirous ^ 'r
should account for the manner in wmcn w
gave hb evidence. That the witness t«s
averse to the plan, is evident from the ciroBa*
stance of the adverUsemeut which be (u^
outandsiened, though, for reasons giyeoV
him, he did not actually, publish it lo ^
newspapers. .
The next is Fairley, whose evidence w^*
tremely material ; for you will recolkct, tnj*
he was employed as an ambassadpri top *^
1393]
Jbf High Treason^
A. D. 1794.
[IS94
dilferent parts of the eountry, upon the busi-
ness of the Committee of Ways and Means,
with written instructions from them, which though it appears, that there was at a certain
}ie got from the orisoner. He, with no small
reluctance and nesitation, gave an account
of this mission, of the places to which he
went, and some of the conferences which he
had with the persons to whom he w^ di-
rected, particularly at Stirling. That his in-
struc^ous bore something about a grand plan,
'' which might be what the prisoner had pre-
viously informed him of/' meaning the plan
already mentioned, of seising the public of-
fices, &c. which he said Watt told him might
be accomplished without bloodshed, ^* as it
would be enough to speak to the soldiers, who
would be as glad of freedom as the people
were.'' He refers also to the report which he
made to the Committee of Ways and Means,
a paper of a verv curious tenor, some parts of
which were read to you. His evidence, so far
as regards what passed at Stirling, is corrobo-
ratecl by that of Forrest, the sureeon, whose
difficulty in speaking out was no less remark-
able.
Gentlemen, this is a concurrence of several
witnesses, to the very material circumstances
of that plan or project, which was read and
proposed by the prisoner Watt. There is one
thing in Bonthrone's evidence which struck
me at first, as tending to create a doubt, whe-
ther the paper read by the prisoner contained
any serious proposition to the effect men-
tioned in it, the witness himself affecting to
consider it as mere phrenzy, or as no more
than a chimerical suggestion of what was pos-
sible to be done in certain circumstances.
But 1 am afraid there are other parts of the
evidence which leave litUe room to doubt of
the seriousness of the plan. M^Ewan and
Pairley speak of it as a plan formed, of doing
those things which the writing specified ; ana
the procurmg of arms for the express purpose
of making some such hostile attempt, which
arms were bespoke by the prisoner himself in
peraon, as swum to by Orrock and others, is
a circumstance which seems to be conclusive
upon this head. The whole, I am afraid,
hangs together; the parole and written proofs
all go to one point i^inst the prisoner, and
those with whom he associated; that they
were employed in carrying on certain mea-
sures, unquestionably hostile to the king and
^vemment, and calculated for nothing less
than, by forcible means, to overset the go-
vernment of this country. The providing
those dangerous weapons which lie on your
table, the mvstery and disguise which appear
in some of their minutes, and the blanks in
Fairley's Journal, are so many circumstances
of real evidence, which speak a language still
more forcible than the direct testimony of
witnesses.
cious in him to state that defence, at l^st as
far as I could understand the result of it ; for
the part of the prisoner, founded on his cor-
respondence witn the lord advocate, I confess
it did not appear to me that it was very judi-
VOL. XXIII.
period such a correspondence, it is equally
clear that all communication ceased when the
lord advocate either had. become suspicious
of the truth of his information, or did not
choose to comply with his demands; after
which we find the prisoner going, with great
activity and zeal, into the most destnictive
and hostile plans. Whether his conduct in
this particular was actuated by resentment,
or by what other motive, it is not worth while
to inquire.
Such, gentiemen, being the amount of the
evidence, vou will wei^h all the circumstances
and all the observations which have come
either from the Court or from the bar, as well
as those which occur to yourselves upon the
various matters which have been proved be-
fore you. If it appears to you that the pri-
soner, and those with whom he associated,
have not entered into anj^ undue combination,
for effectuating those lUe^l and desperate
purposes whicn are specihed in the indict-
ment, or any of them, it will be your duty to
find a verdict in his favour. v
But if, on the other hand, you think there
is sufficient evidence of his having been acces-
sary to, and an active person in, forming a
most dangerous and destnictive plan of rais-
ing insurrection in the country, seizing upon
the government by force of arms, compelling
an uteration of measures, in short, conspiring
to overturn the constitution, and to involve us
in ruin, misery, and bloodshed, I need not tell
you what your dutv is as honest men, and
that you are bound, by the solemn oath which
you have takeu, to return a verdict agreeable
to the truth.
If the case be in your opinion doubtful in
point of evidence, you will naturally be in-
clined to the mercihil side ; but if it be not
doubtful, your own sense of duty will dic-
tate to you the verdict you ought to pro:**
nounce.
The jury then withdrew for about ten mi-
nutes, and brought in their verdict — Guilty.
See the proceedings on , Mr. Hamilton's
motion in arrest of judgment, at the end of
Downie^ trial, in the next volume.
To the original edition of this trial was
annexed, by way of appendix. Watt's Declara-
tion and Confession. It was likewise, se-
parately published by Authority with the fol-
lowing tiUe :
With regard to the evidence brought on The Declaration and Confession of
^ t ^r *i^_ : r j_j iS . ._ - _
Robert Watt, written, subscribed, and
delivered by himself, the eyening before
4 U
1395] 34 G£ORGB UI.
hi$ executioOy for High Treason at
burgh ; October 15, 1794, attested by the
Rev. Dr. Baird, principal of the uniyersity
of Edinbiffgh ; aod the Rev. T. S. Jones,
one of the ministers of Lady OloBorcfaie's
chapel.
The following Declaration, was pat up under
a sealed cover, addressed on the out side to
James Clerk, esq. sheriff depute, Geo.
square. — In the inside of the cover was
wrKten the foHowing letter by Robert
Watt to him :
Sir:— The inclosed papers, with another
parcel, containing sundiy miscellaneous letters
and papers, I commit to you; requesting
they may be transmitted to principal Bairc^
and the rev. Mr. Jones, to do witn them aa
they mav find proper. The Iktle emohi-
ments which may arise from them, I am
persuaded they will give to Riaaing who at-
tended me.
My watch and my clothes, and any little
effects I may leave behind me, I request them
to be xiven to Mr. James Stalker, at Mr. Wil-
son's, naker in Crosfr<auseway, to whom I
owe money per bill; and to whom I gave •
disposition to these, and other effects, before
my condemnation. I have the honour to
be, sir, your obedient humble servant,
(Signed) Robert Watt.
Edinburgh CastU Oct. 14, 1794.
Proceedmgi agamdRoieri Watt
[1396
We, who are referred to in the above letter
and who subscribe this note, do hereby at-
test, that tile contents of the following De-
claration are transcribed verbatim from the
manuscript of Robert Watt, transmitted to us
by the sheriff.-
George Baird.
T. S. JovEs.
No sooner is the aoul aeparatfid fma lb
body, than she is diaoonaeeied with the p»-
suils of mortala, and entefaan hithgteia-
Imown scene,— and her i»wei' s ofjwiafliBB
aod oomoiunicatioB am tMii eafamd, ia ^
portion to the suUimily nnd grepMr of Ua
o^ectseahibiledtoherview. With astoaisb-
ment and prying curiosity, ahe travek imt
the vast expanse of the heATenly Jemiriai,
collecting (ran the aaost sacaent and 'mefi-
gcmt of its inhabitaots, every mfamatioD tk^
can communicate of the myateries of Vtm-
denoe and Redemption, while she seens^ a
her knowledge increases, to nae in bcr a^
cents of praise.
I was influenced by religioB when wrr
young. A leflective diaoovefy of the ^
ness of God, in his interposition when in vet
imminent dangers, and of my inzratitnkjl
exceeded my companions in youthfidMEe^
bat could never bear swearing first led ne to
cry for OMTcy. M v convictions were cnee^
ingly strong; so that I would in the spaceof
two hours be three or four times at frayo;
drowned in penitential tears. I have slvajs
fimod, that my penitential Joy was in pwpf*
tion to mycontritioa for am. For a m^
space of time, I was not a dfty (if I reDiemto
ndit) without assurance of a saving intertfta
Chiiat ; and, at times, my feelings and wets
were more like an heavcnl^Ti than an etft&ff
inhabitant. On such occasions, I had iso-
nressible discoveries of the infinitude and bo*
uness of God, and of my own vileness. fwcfr
dered, admired, adored, lamented, and rejoiod
at one and the same time.
No sooner did my convictions take phce,
than I was, as it were, compelled tow
some particular hours every oay to itmf
the scriptures, mediution, seU^exafluaslioo,
and prayer. These hours I found to be the
lifo of my soul. I learned fix>m ezpaiM
that foith must be the gift of God. T^
could as soon take up my personal w^j*°*
in the sun, as trulv believe in Chris^ or nxi^
heart on him in the exercise of faith* W
unbelief and treadiery of heart drew t«is »
sorrow ftom my eyes.
Tboueh my pleasure in religion was f^
my grief from satanical suggestions ^^^Jt
praved nature was also so. I was stro^
tempted to despair and suicide > ^^7^
keepeth Israel preserved me amidst afse
storms. J,
Relieion did no sooner opmte on siy ninw,
than I nated the ways of sin, aod w«^
DECLARATION, &C.
As the best service I can now do to reli-
gion, Wtiich I have injured by the unhappy
conduct which has brought me to my present
unfortunate situation, — to piy christian ac-
quaintances, whom I particularly esteem, and
by whose company and conversation I have
been both improved and comforted ; — and to
my country, for which I have had more than ...^ ,_^^ ^. ^
ordinary attachment, I shall give a general, ' pany of the pmfane; and sought, sccordig
but concise history of the most material part > to my then knowledge, the comfwny «' ^
of my life, and disclose fully the unfortunate I wise and good. Though my plessarc •*
circumstances that have been the cause of i particularly in devotional exercises, «»" ^.
terminating my life in such a melancholy ! such complUiy; yet I spent a great part*
manner, in the middle of my days. my time, in boyish pursuits and plc«sui«»
Having but four days before 1 am absorbed with my school-companions ; but in tbes^
in eternity, I hope that what follows will be my devotional frame of mind never left »*
received as the truth.— In the view of such an and how soon I came home, I retired tyJ^J"
awful prospect, it cannot be supposed I can seif, and wept over my vanity of con<hicL .
have any interest whatever Jo conceal it. Even in school, the thought of inj ^^
1897]
fiir Htgjk Trea$(m.
ly jng the Lord of g^onr by »By often bathed
xn^ eyes in tean^ and impeUed me to pray
'wilb my head leamng on a table. — The sense
c^ bia Ipve, and the injuiy done him produced
in me a sseal for the salvation of others-— to
such a degree, that I established the wdlrsbip
of G«d in some families I lodged with, vho
never had it before. — ^I was often surprised to
aee the same eiSaets nc4 vfoduced on the
nuadB of others in reading the scriptures, &e.
as on QiTself— Bat this aroae from my ignc^
ranee of the sovereignty of God.
As I advanced in knowledge, ray high ea-
joyments were the less frequent; and the in-
stability of my mind in exercises of devotion
became ipoie and mere peroep^e. These
amtl exeicises, less or more have continued
"vitb me amidst grievous provocations, and
sore backslidings.
I shall now proceed to state the caases of
n^ backslidings, so far as I can trace them.
A reserved disposition^ founded on pride,
seems to have been lay constitutional sin —
In my earliest youth it discovered itself, by
taking pleasure in veaun^ my guardians when
ihev crossed my inclination. I was so much
under the influence of this base passien, that
more than once I gave them the greatest
alarm and vexation of mind, by concealin|r
myself, and previously saying that I would
put an end to my life by personal violence ;
and enduring sore personal chastisement
without disclosing any secret entrusted to me.
Sometime after I knew the mce of God,
this passion disappeared ; yet it was not de-
stroved—but manifested itself in opposition
to the inclination of my fHends to send me
abroad.
My friends proposed to send me either to
the East or West uidies, but refusing to com-
ply, on the ground of a weak constitution ; but
toe true motive with mysdf was the fear of not
eiyc^ing the means of graces-After which
they proposed to send me to London ; but not
executing this proposal in the time I wished
(though their deuty undoubtedly proceeded
from the best of motives), I resolved to act in-
dependently of them. Accordingly, I came
to Edinburgh in the year 1786, where I re-
mained for a considerable time without their
knowledge, and not into business without
their assistance.— §o far was my vanity gra-
tified.
Here I digress and beg leave to observe,
though perhaps it mi^ be unnecessary, that
parents or guardians should be particularly
carefiil to studv the ruling passions of young
peiBeos under their charge ; and, should they
be aueh as tend to hurt Uieir morals or blind
thehr best judgment, to correct them by timely,
proper, and wholesome instruction. But
above all things, they should study to learn
the inclination of their mind as to business,
and to put them early to it. Because tills
will give a fiill scope to the young mind in the
msuit of fortune, in a way connstent with
bis profiession ; whereas when not put early to
A. D. 179^. [1398
business, thev arc apt to seek af\er her by in-
direct methods.
Af^r I began busii^ss on my own account,
I adopted every method that my ingenuity
could suggest, to arrive at some eminence
in society.
For one, I studied the dispositions and
ruling passions of individuals; and, not
having the gift of speech equal with others, I
spoke but little when in company, lest I
should either speak improperly, or hurt the
feelings of anotner by interruption.
From what I have said, the reader will
easily discern the foUowing passions to have
borne rule in my conduct, viz. pride and am-
bition.
Pride is the fruitful mother of all the other
irregular passions — It was the origin of re-
belhon in heaven, and the thunderbolt that
hurried Satan into the bottomless pit; and
stript innocent Adam of his original purity.
Ever since, it more or less holds a place m
every human breast
It is capable of assuming various forms—
At times It assumes the garb of humility,
rigiditjr, and moderatMn. But none can trace
its various evolutions so well, or discover its
inalignity, as the sincere christian. It may
fMssmly keep him company in all his devo-
tional exercises; and, even under the spe^
cbus pretext of humility, may be u>t to drive
him from Ged^ as jud^g himaeH^unworthy
of eternal life.
But its infiuenceover me was remarkable-^
— ^I oould not brook the idea to be indebted to
any person for advice, even in difficult and
doubtful cases. I therefore very seldom con-
sulted any person, thousb many consulted
me. Had I acted the priMent part^ I should
have consulted intelligent and disinterested
men, previously chosen. — The friendship and
esteem of some such I have had the honour
to enjoy.
Ambition— Though this passion be the off-
spring of pride, it is to be no less watched
against than its source. It blinds our best
judgment by the appearance of utility, and is
apt to drive to acts of injustice in the pursuit
of the wished-for object; while it is but a dis-
trusting of, and a contending aeainst Divine
Providence. Influenced >b^ this base passion^
under the semblance of utility, I was induced
to carry on a secret correspondence with Mr.
Dundas and the lord advocate.
This conduct, I confess, was alto^ther in«
jconsistent with the spirit and design of Chris-
^tianity, whicb requires the most unbounded
simplicity, integrity, and love to my fellow-
creatures.
My first connexion with the Friends of the
People was in the year 1T91 or 1798. I se-
veral times attended the committee which
met in Mather's Tavern; but would never
subscribe my name, though repeatedly re>
quired to do it. This was the aera of my cor^
respondence with Mr. Dundas. Two reasons
induced me to thi^ unhappy conduct. One, a
1399] SI GEORGE UI.
Proeeedhgi agavM^ Robert WaU
[1400
love of the peace of society — ^I apprehended,
that if they were permitted to continue their
meetings, the public tranquillity would be
interrupted. This opinion was founded on my
ignorance of the many abuses in the adminis-
trative— the offspring of corruption in the le-
gislative branch of government. For when
the legislative becomes more corrupted than
the executive, there is an end of true liberty.
-^And that the people had a right to meet and
deliberate on, ana to obtain a redress of
grievances. — ^The other reason, to obtain Mr.
Dundas's favour, that I might the sooner ar-
rive at that station in society to which my
views were directed. Some may imagine that
I had personal hatred at some of the Friends
of the People, but this was by no means the
Mr. Dimdas wished me to correspond with
the lord advocate, and accordingly recom-
mended me to him. My correspondence
with him continued to August or September
1793, when it was discontinued.
My mind being then changed in favour of
reform, I entered into the committees of
Union and Ways and Means,* in order to co-
operate with them to the obtaining of a re-
form. Naturally ambitious and enterprising,
I was soon the leader of these committees.
By my advice the Committee of Ways and
Means, or Secret Committee, was formed ;
and its regulations drawn up by me. These
regulations contained also directions to the
Primary Societies, and to the Committee of
Union. The Circulars Letter, though com-
posed by Mr. Stock, was advised by me.
And thoueh the Address to the Fencibles was
not moved by me, I heartily approved of it
All these papers I got printed ; and the whole
impression was dispersed, but the Address to
the Fencibles, of which I knew nothing, afWr
printed.
My plans, I doubt not, would, when ripe
for execution, be effectual. Bloodshed was
what I abhorred from the bottom of my
ftoul ; they therefore guarded asainst that
evil as much as may be. I shall here nar-
rate them. — Other persons, as Archibald
Wright, weaver, in Edinburgh, and —
Craie, Perth, besides John Fairley, were sent
at different times through the country, to
sound the public mind, and to give instruc-
tions. The intelligence brought me, from
time to time, by these persons, from every
Quarter of the kingdom, was more and more
favourable. All their instructions were deli-
vered by myself— but such as I knew I could
fully confide in, their instructions went far-
tfier than those of others. Indeed, at the
time I was apprehended, there were but very
few places thai information was not received
from ; and there reniaine<l almost nothiug to
do, for the execution of the whole, but a visit
to England and Ireland, by intelligent and
confidential persons.
• Of Iho Friends of tbePoople.--Orig. Ed.
The first movement was intended to W
made in Edinburgh, London, and Mil;
while eveiy town throughout thekiogdoai
were in readiness to w^ according to Ae
plan, on the very first notice, which vis to
be ei^n by couriers dtspatcbed by eipm.
The nature of the plan was this:— Abii^
of men, to the number of four or five Ibn*
sand, were to be assembled in a phcetok
fixed on. These were to be armed with pibv
guns, erenadcA — to be properly divided, vilk
proper leaders. In regard to Edinbiirgh, tbs
were to be placed at the Gadk cbapd, had
of the West Bow, Tolhooth, or bead of tte
High-street,— that when the Castle sottn
came out, they might be surrounded, la or-
der to prevent bloodshed, means were tok
used to gun as many of the soldiers ts ]»•
sible over to their side. The regiment wis b
be enticed out by companies. But, prem
to this, the magistrates, lords of josfioB^,
commander in chief, and many otbena
town to be selected, were to be appTthended;
but to be treated, in every respect, becooiis
their stotion in life, and detained till tk
mind of the ensuing convention, or nths
parliament, was known. There was do in-
tentkm whatever to put any to death; tatr
found guilty of oppression and injustice to tk
patriots, to share a similar fate with tiM^
viz. transportation.
The manner in which the soldiers were 1b
be induced to leave the Castle, was bymefls
of a letter, either signed by the lord prorwt
or commander in chief, previouslv in castodr,
ordering the commandant to send a compu?;
without anj^ ammunition, to a fire that wa^
be kindled in St. Andrew's-square, ^^^
pretence of its being a house on fiie; sodtk
said company to be sectnred and disansed n
the mean time. The roost of the rciMin*
to be drawn out in the same ^''^^wl
means of fires kindled in succession in omr
quarters of the city.
But in case they either could not be dri«B
out of the Castle, or bad obtained iofonnaW*
of what was a^doing, they were to **w
pelled to surrender, by being ^'^P"^'*^
victuals; — ^the incarceration of the <*°'"*^
in chief, and the influence o( party ^^^^
themselves favouring the plan. .
The public offices and the banks were toW
secured, by placing proper persons as '^^'JJ
over them, till the proprietors and manip
appeared next morning. The same wtfc
be consulted with by qualified P«"°"^ J^f
previouslv chosen. The property of **'*^'
sons, either residing in town or "JJ""?^
deemed inimical to liberty, in ^''^T^L
bankers, was to be sealed up, but «otf
necessary for their maintenance, till thciriw
was known. ^^
The post-office was to be taken J^***^
of; as thereby all intercourse would b^ 2^
between such as were hostile to the P* |^
while the channel of conuouoicalioB ^
open for thenu
14013
for High Treasofu
A. D. 1794<.
[14Q2
Ai\er these things were effected in Edin-
burgh, London, ana Dublin, in one and the
same nijght ; and which was expected to be
accomplished about six or seven o'clock in the
morning, — couriers were immediately to be
dispatched throughout the whole nation, to
the leaders in other parts ; while troops were
to be marched from places to be fixed on, that
could spare them to the assistance of such as
-would oe deemed necessary. No sooner was
the plan executed in the three metropolisses,
than proclamations, previously prepared, were
to be issued to the landholders, and oiiicers
under government, as did not cordially unite
with the patriots in their views and designs,
not to go above three miles beyond their
dwelling-places, under pain of death; — ^to
farmers, not to conceal or export any grain; —
to ship-masters, not to carry any person
coast-ways, without giving intimation of the
same ; place come from, and where going to,
of such person or persons, within a reasonable
time after such intimation was given, to the
nearest justice of peace, that the same misht
be called to an examination, under a simnar
penalty ; — to such persons as were authorized
to levy men, to deliver up their commissions
and men to persons to be nominated, under
the same penalty.
There was preparing an Address to be made
to the King at toe same time, consisting of a
long catalogue of abuses, both in the legisla-
tive and executive branches of government ;
and requesting of him the dismissal of his pre-
sent servants, and a dissolution of parliament,
the same to be replaced by men in whom
the people could con6de.
With regard to the pikes, I got them made
both for sale and distribution. I do not at
present recollect what instructions I might
nave eiven at the making of them. 'What-
ever Uiese instructions were, I am certain
that none I had were ever distributed.*
There was no person concerned in these
things but the Com. of W. and M.— Be-
cause I was morally certain, from the aspect
of afibirs, that how soon the operations were
commenced, persons in the various ranks of
society would carry it on. — I have therefore
no new discoveries to make.
I can judge of my intentions from my feel-
ings,— my views were the good of society ;
and not robbery or murder. I will not say
but my own interest was blended in these
views; for who is he, tliat if he serves society,
but will naturally expect a reward? But
Divine Providence has been pleased to permit
me to be brought into circumstances of misery
and woe — I hope they have been the best re-
ward that could be conferred on me. I how-
* The pikes were found in my house, when
the sberifi^s officers were in search of the
goods of a bankrupt in Musselburgh, sent to
my house, about an eight days before, under
the pretence of their being to be forwarded to
Glasgow. Orig^ Ed.
ever patiently, and I hope thankfully, accept
of these as coming from God, not only as the
Sovereign Disposer of all events^ but as my
merciful Redeemer.
In reflection, I see that althoueh m}r inten-
tions were eood, and probable evils en-
deavoured to Be guarded against, yet circum-
stances miffht have provM such, as would
have caused me to rep>ent my having gone so
far, although my person were safe, which I
sincerely do this day.
Though the part I acted proceeded from
the best of motives; yet, on reflection, I per-
ceive that I erred in taking such an active
part, without maturely weighing the probable
consequences. Bloodshed and rapine might
have ensued. This would liave involved me in
guilt; bein^ somewhat accessory to themi
though not intentionally so.
The duty of all sincere Christians is, ^* to
lead quiet and peacable lives in all godliness
and honesty, giving honour to whom honour
is due, and fear to whom fear.'' To leave the
reformation of abuses in the state to those
who mind only earthly things, except when
called to assist in a legal manner. At the'
throne of grace they may be of more real
utility, than either in the cabinet or field of
battle.
Had my life been prolonged, I think this
would have been my mode of conduct And
I bless God for timely preventing me goine
the perhaps awful lenfi;tn ray ambitious ana
enterprising mind might have induced me.
I have given no private ofience that I
know of. Indeed, my sympathising mind,
thoueh compoimded of pride and ambition,
would soon relent. I may truly say, if I
know my own deceitful heart, that sympathy
to the unfortunate was one cause of my
adopting the part that has brought me to my
present fate. Reflection on the hardships of
others has ofUn brought tears of sympathy
from my eyes. Nor liave I borrowea money,
nor purchased goods, but with the most up-
right intentions. — For the satisfaction of my
creditors, I will observe, that I had views of
being able to pay what I had either borrowed
or purchased, had I lived, altogether discon-
nected with the matter that has broueht me
to my present unfortunate situation ; but in
this situation it would be improper to mention
what these views were.
Though I have always kept up the worship
of God, at stated times both in the closet
and family, and bad honest intentions towards
my creditors; yet I am convinced, that my
departures from God have been very great;
and that, in the glass of his holy law, ttey are
innumerable and hishly ajgmvated. And
especially the crime tor which I am about to
suffer, as viewed in its probable consequences.
I humbly hope, that the spirit of God has
given me a saving discovery of my sins ; and
that, in the spirit of genuine contrition, I am
led to the precious blood of sprinkling.
In tht foregoing nanative, if any article
140JI 34 GEORGE III.
Ptocc^nngt sgouui Robttt Woit*
\m
appean imperfect or obBcun, I ho^ tlat iai-
pierfectioD or obscuri^ will be awnbed to the
uijgeiit pmsure of the occaskm on which
this pitper is written. It itafirst copy ; and
alas ! there is not now time to revise or cor-
rect—Of the minutes of life that yet remain
to me» even the writmg of this senleiice has
consumed one. But you who now read or
bear of this account^ remember as you read,
that the period is conuii^ when death shdl
be as near to you as it u to me; and, be
assured, you will find that a period when you
wiU shnnk with honw from the idea of du-
plicity or deception. With candour then con-
sider this solemn declamtion of a dying man.
Nor let prqjudiceSy which appearances have
produced against me, lead you to suppose,
that, on the brink of eternity, with the thione
of judgment in my view, I dare to approach
the Omnipotent with a lie in my right
band.
Thoee who^ in an official character, began
and managed my prosecution, I freely for-
give.
Fofgive me, my fellow Christians^ for the
«f roach thrown by my conduct on rehjgiott.
M V prayer to God is, that be may inspire
MJX the people with a spirit of subordination
and loyalty: and teach them to lead, under
the powers that be, 4iuiet and peaceid)le lives
in godliness and honesty.
OGod! soon shall my body be given to the
dust, and my soul will ascend U> wee. Thou
knowest my sincerity in the narrative I have
siven ; thou seest my sorrow for all my sins.
Bear me mciously-^And, for the sake of
the Lord Xeaus Christ, receive my soul to
everlasting gloiy.-^Amen.
This is tnith, and the whole truth, as &r
as I recollect, I declare as a dying man*
(Signed) Robekt Watt.
Ti»€9i^ Ev&mng^ Oct. \Uk^
9imt 8 if clock at uigki. 17M.
In legpud of sending pikes to Perth, toihe
best of my recollection, I talked with Ciii|
about them, and that be told me they sbouklbi
sent secretly; but I cannot say to what du»
her, nor to whoou
2r0re.*-Althoag^ Watt, soon after hit as-
damnation, promised the clergyman who vi-
sited him, to write a confession of his aina,
he delayed the coaunencement of it tiE
within eight or nine days of his death. Os
the Wednesday before that event, be kid
written one sheet; tfais^ it is supposed, lie
destroyed, as it was not among the pspenk
left behind him; hitherto be appeared ea^ia
his mind; but on the Friday, Satunhor and
lord's day, much agitated. On this bst dij be
Main b^sn to write, but advanced no fintbcr
tGsn the account he baa given of his cluldhood,
&C. By what he said aflerwards, it is plus»
his hesitation arose from the vain hope oft
reprieve. On Monday morning be tain ap-
peared calm, and in good spirits; anaaaid be
bad at last detennined to declare ail be koevi
and employed the morning of that dsj in
writing what is now given to the public.— In
the evening, the order for his execution vxs
officially intimated to him.— On Tuesday be
continued writing; and in the eveoingi b^
tween seven and eight o'clock, finished aod
subscribed the paper now published, and pot
it under a cover to the sheris — On Wedoesdaj,
15th October, he was executed— The /apff
was sealed up in Watt's presence, together vito
another parcel, containing the letters be I^
ceived whilst in prison, and otlier papers of
no importance. Both parcels were oy,^^
himself addressed to the sheriff, andddiTcred
to the commanding officer of the Csstie, vbo
sent them to the sheriff on the Tuesday evw*
ingagreeahle to Watt's own particular reque»
— C^. Edit.
ADDENDA
TO VOLUME XXIII.
ADDENDA TO Mum's CASE.
To the word certification, p. 936, /. 15 from fofi
torn should h€ affixed the following note.
** The certification.*' says professor Hume,
Comm. Tr. for Cr» Vol. «, p. 867, " of old, in
case of the convict's return to Scotland before
the expiration of his term, was invariably
death. Afterwards, other penalties came to
be occasionally applied, and sometimes that of
perpetual imprisonment; as in the sentence
of Isobel Nicolson, August 6th 1711, and of
Campbell of Burnbank, March 31st, 1731.
*' The words in Nicolson*s case are : * she
* shall be condemned to perpetual impriton'
* menif and to be scourged by the hana of the
' common hangman, the first Wednesday of
* July yearly, being a lawful day, and feflzio-
' ing thereof the first lawful day thereafter.'
** And these are the words in Campbell's
case : * And from thence to be transported
< firom sherifi' to sheriff, till he be brought to
^ Edinburgh, and there to be committed pri-
' soner within the Tolbooth thereof, therein
' to remain during life, whijk is pronounced
* for doom/
** It was not, however, till towards the mid-
dle of the present [18tn] century, that the
capital certification came to be entirely laid
aside, for that of conveyance to the gaol
from which the convict was carried abroad,
scourging on the next market day after
commitment thereto, and on the first
market day of every succeeding month,
until an om>ortunity should offer of retrans-
porting. But now, in virtue of the stat. S5,
George dd. c. 46, the certification is again
made capital, and this not only as of old, in
case of returnmg to Scotland aifter transporta^
tion, but more generally, < if the offender
who shall be so ordered by such court as
aforesaid, to be transported beyond the seas,
&c. &c. shall be afterwards at large, within
any part of the kingdom of Great Britain or
Ireland, without some lawful cause;' so that
ht is liable to suffer death if he even break
gaol after his sentence, to avoid transportation,
and be found at large within these r^ms, or
any of them. It seems, however, to be doubt-
ful, by the words of the act, whether this high
denunciation does not apply to those offen-
ders only, who have haa judgment of trans-
portation in pursuance of trial and conviction
ofacrime, or who have entered into a con-
tract to transport themselves, and not to such
who are ordered to be transported on their
own petition, wi^out trial. The same sta-
tute in eflfect empowers the lords of justiciaiT
to decern for transportation eenersJly, to such
l^oe as his majestf , with advice of lus privy
oouiicil, shaM think fit; as also to adjudge
tiie services of (tie convict, to such person as
shall contract for the due performance of sueh
transportation: and, last of all, it equitab^
orders that the time of Uie convict's confine-
ment in gaol, under such senteiice, sball be
reckoned in discharge of his tenb of odle.
^ To this of transportation to parts abroad,
I natnralW subjoin the punishment, though
certainly far from being next in degree, of
nmple nanishment forth of Scotbnd , a sort
of sentence of still greater antiquity in our
practice than the other, and which naturally
took its rise in our state of hostility to Eng«
land, and has been since continued, to say
the truth, in no very friendly or neighbourly
way, after the union of the two crowns, and
even that of the two kingdoms into one
reslm. Happilv they have not yet tfaou^t
in England, of taking that ample and ae*
vere revenge on us which ^y have in tbair
power, if they were disposed to retaliation.'^
There is an appearance of incongruity be«
tween that part of the preceding extract in
which perpetual imprisonment is mentioned,
and the following passage, which oooura at p.
377 of the same volume.
" Another of our ordinaiy punishments, is,
that of imprisonment or loss of liberty; whidi
is not properly a punbhment in the person.
It is applied chiefly to the inferior onences;
yet, when protracted to a long period of time,
It cannot justly be accounted a slight reproof
as well on account of the depression of spirits
and loss of comfort which attend a tedious con-
finement, as on account of the probable in-
jury in point of health, and the loss to the
mdigent offender, of the means of subsistence
to his family, not to mention Uie prejudice to
his fame, not soon to be recoverea. Accord-
uiglyy if I mistake not, our legislature have
not m any instance thought it fit to prolong
this state of durance beyond the space of one
vear. Neither can I find that our judges
have ever been in the use of dooming - to im-
prisonment for those long terms of four and
nve years, of which instances have sometimes
happened in the practice of our neighbouring
kingdom ; but in any case where there was
need of severity, have rather thought it better
1407] S4 GEORGE UL
to eke out the sentence with the addiiioB of
some corporal chastisement, or other penalty
suitable to the offence. Indeed, the examples
have not been many, of sentence of imprison-
ment for more than tweWe months: and as
&r as I have observed, except in the siagle
case of Mary Nicol, (Feb. 19th 1705) who had
been convicted of something not very remote
horn child«murder, and was ordered to be
soouigecL and confined for three years in the
house of correction, there is no record of the
time of durance being extended to more than
two. It b true, that as a certification in case
of return from banishment or transportation,
mention is made of imprisonment for a loi^r
time, nay for all the days even of the priso-
ner's life. But these excessive, and I think
exceptionable denunciations, seam to have
been issued tn tarrartMj rather than with any
serious purpose of carrying them into effect,
not to mention, that this sort of provisional
order is very different from an absolute and
irrevocable sentence. It is also true, that in one
instance, imprisonment for life is a lawful
sentence, namely for misprision of treason,
but this we have only received as an article
of the English system of treason law, now
made ours by statute.''
Addoida io [1408
Mr. Hume, in the same part of fats woik,
makes mention of one case, that of Alexander
Stewart and Donald M'Donald, in wbicfa the
punishment of death was commuted to tliat
of perpetual servitude, during which it appeals
that each of the convicts wore round his neck
a metal collar, with an inscription denotiiig
his &te. See. S Comment 378, and Appeo&x
No. 3.
To the n&tep. 145 thtmld be added.
** Lord Royston mentions in his notes^ that
in the case of the Glasgow rioters, in Se^
tember and October 17 nS, a quaker was ad-
mitted a witness upon his affinaalion, t^
m'lstake. He also mentions, in another pas-
sage, that in the trial of Captain P«yrteoas^
[See it in this Collection, Vol. xvii. p. 9S3.]
*' one Christie, a quaker, was refiised to be
received a witness for the panel ; ad. p.
365, and p. S50. By mistake, a qukker wis
admitted on his amrmation, in the trial of
Mealroaker in 1797." Hume's Commentaries^
Trial for Crimes, chap. IS, Vol. 9, p. 187, U
noi.
See Atcheson v. Everitt, B. R. 16 G. ^
Cowp. 382.
ADDENDUM TO MARGAUOTS CASE.
To the name Margarot p. 710, L tB^from
bottom thould he affixed the following nie.
According to Mr. Burnett [Treatise on
nous branches of the Criminal Iaw of Scot-
land, chap. 13, p. t50.] ** Margarot chose to
stale his own defence^ without the aid of
counsel, and of course the tenor of his ob|ee->
tioDs was equally absurd and intemperate.
His whole conduct indeed and demeanour
during his trial was a paradeful triumph over
justice" — See in Vol. 30, p. 779 of this CoUec-
tioD, Thurlow's Speech against Home.
ADDENDA TO GERRALD'S CASE.
lb tkenottp. 909, shauld be added.
" Our judges were formerly in the use of
weighing all those circumstances in the situ-
ation or an assizer^ which might tend in any
wise to bias his voice, or beget an undue fa-
vour to the prosecutors cause : as that he was
the prosecutor's tenant, especialljr if he were
remuveable at the pleasure of his landlord ;
or that he was servant or attendant in any
shape, to any of the prosecutor's near relations.
In later times, I find no mention made of any
plea of this complexion ; unless it be in the trial
of Joseph Gerrald, who beine prosecuted at
the instance of his majesty's advocate, for se-
dition, absurdly objected to the naming of
William Rankine, his majesty's tailor, for one
of his assize.'' Hume's Commentaries on the
Law of Scotland, respecting Trial for Crimes;
Vol. 2, pp. 96,97.
Note to the word nobility tn Gerrald's com, p.
986, /. 6 from bottom,
Bocthhis appears to have been the first re-
later of this story. Blackstone (Comm. B. 2,
c. 6, Vol. 2. p. 83) sa^s (upon the authority
of the Regiam Majestatem, b. 4, c 31,
and Seldcn's Titles of Honour, 2, 1, 47), thai
the custom for the lord of the fee to have a
right of concubinage with his tenant's wife on
her wedding night, certainly prevailed in Scot-
land under the name of mercheta or mar-
cheta), till abolished by Malcolm 3d, though as
he states in the same sentence he cou^not
learn that ever such custom prevailed in Eng-
land.
The account given of this in the Regiam
Majestatem is as follows : —
^ liber Quartus, cap. 31.— De Marcheto Mu-
lierum.
" Sciendum est, quod secundum assisam
terrs Scotis, quaecunque mulicr fuerit, sive
nobilis, sive serva, sive mercenaria, marcbeta
sua erit unajuvenca, vel 3 solidi, et rectum
servientis 3 denarii.
** 2. Et si filia liberi sit, et non domini vills
marcheta sua erit una vacca, vel sex solidi, et
rectum servientis sex denarii.
]4aS[} GmtldU due.
^ 3. Itenn nwtAiftK iUui Thaa^ vd Ogih
Ihsrii," Ohii word it raiid«red Ocbioray m
Sk«iM and Du Cim2» aty * jsquipamlw
Thano^) ** U vicca tcT IS 8olidi| et rectum
servientis IS deoaru.
** 4. It^niiaMicbetafilMeCofnitistttBefUMei
^ Annotetio^ (l^ Skene).
A. 13. 1794w
[1410
** Mmrek equum liflnificat |>risG& Seoloniiii
lingnfty wl dixi de veroor. sipificatione. Hinc
demicta motaphora ab eqiutando^ Mareheta
mulieiiB, dicitur Virginalis pudiciti» prima
w>Istio et delibatio^ qus ab Eveno Rase, Do*
miiiis Cafntalibas (to the King ana othar
OverlovdiB^ ms some writii) fuit impi^ per-
miaaa^ de omnibus noris nuptis primft nuptia-
xitna nocte. Sed pife a Malcolmod, sublata
'iiiit : et in hoc capite, certo vaocarum nnmero,
et quaal nretio redimitur/'
£ord Hailes has written a learned disserta-
tion [See it in the Appendix, No. 1, to the Ist
Vol. of his Annals] for the puipose of proyine
that this privilege never existed m Scotland, ima
he aq^ues with much ingenuity that the oj>i-
juona which had been entertained of its exist-
enee in several other parts of Europe, were
also erroneous^ and in his Annals under the
jear 1008, he speaks of Evtnus as an imagi-
mty kmg. He is of opinion that the word
mapified the fine paid to the lord by the
▼fllain a Sokman, when his dai^ter was
manied or debauched; and with hua
anees Dr. Jamieson ; See his Dictionaiy, voa
Du Cange appears to have been thoroughly
yerowaded of tne existence of this privitege,
and forces words from their natural sipiifica-
tion| in order to give strength to his opmi<m.
Blount, in his Tenures, under Worthynbury
interprels the Amobragium in the same
manner. Under Thurguton and HorsepoU,
he mentions that every naif or the viludn,
that Seek a husband, or eommilled fomication,
paid merchet for redemption of her blood,
mve-alttllings and four«Miice, and the dau^ter
ef a cottacerpsid but half a merchet And
nnder Fisserton and Moreton, he speaks of a
hlDs custom. In Berk-holt, indeed, he speaks
of the Mercheta Mulieram as the nrst mriit's
Mgmg vnth the bride, which the lordTan-
mntly claimed in some manours: but under
Worthynbuiy he says that he believes there
sever was any European nation (in the pe-
Bods this custom is pretended to exist) so
nrfaaroos as to admit it
If this custom ever existed, it might 'cast
ioaie doubt on the paterniqr of thefirst-bom
cbUdren of marria^ subjected to iu operation s
aadineontemplalion of such a consequence,
31 has been alleged that from this custom on*
gmi«ed the anomabus, though ancient des-
cent of tenements holdcn in Borough Eittlish,
to which tenements upon the death of the
nther, the youngest son succeeds, in prefer^
VMS not merriy to the fir8t4x>rn child, but to
ili the elder sons of a maniage ;> a ftndfol in-
"VOL.XXUI, I
fosence Ulogically deduced from a Q{%tuitou|i
and I believe, a groundless assumptipn.
Whitaker [History of Manchester^ book t,
cb. 8y sec. 3, p. 965, as cited in a note tp
Blount^ edition of 1784] says that the Mer-
cheta IS apparently nothing more than the
Mercb-ed or Howel Dha, the dsughterhood,
or the fine for the marriage of a daughter ;
upon which Lord Hailes observes he cannot
ima^e that in the Wel^h kngui^e f4 im-
plies a fine for a marriage.
Mr. Daines Barrington [Observstions on
Stat 1 Rich. S.] tells us, that in somemanouis
the lord had ^* jus luxanda coxq sj^nsarum
vassallonim." but h^ cites no authpn^ for it,
and I recollect not to have met with |^
phrase elsewhere.
Mr. Chalmers [Caledoma, Book 9 ch. 9,
VoL l,p. 449] defines the 'merchet of women'
to be a di^ paid to the superior l^ the to*
nants or vileyns, on the marriage of their
daughters. With Davies and Owen he de-
rives the term MwtheU from Mtrek (Brit) a
woman, or daughter; and he. notices that to
so late a period as the reim of our James.th^
1st, the existence of this auty may be traced
in proper Scotland, and also m the country of
the Strathduyd &itons (an extensive district
composed of the south western extremity of
Scotland, and the north western of Endand;
see CaledoniiL b. S. c S^ Vol. 1. p. ^7), the ap-
propriate hma of the Pict% where the British
people remained long urmiixed. In proof of
this, he enumerates various grants^ from the
close of the twelfth century to the year 1610,
by which were conveyed, among other mat-
t^ the mercheta nmlkrvm or defikmbui,
Voltaire, in his ^ Dictbrmaire Philospphi-
que/' art ** Cuissage ou Culage.^— /< Droit de
mUbatMn, de Marouette," &c. says ^ II est
^tonnant que dans l^urope chr^tienne on ait
fiut tr^s-lorig-tems une esj^ce de loi ffodale,
et que du moins on ait r^jard^ comine un
droftcoutiunier, Ihisate d'avoir le pucelage de
sa vassale. La premftre nuit des iioces de la
fiUe au villain appartenait sans contn^ au
seigneur.'' He seemsy however, to think that
as a law it never had existence, cpnd^ding
the article with this maxim, '' Des lois ab-
surdesy ridicules, barbares, vous en trouv^ rjea
par-tout ; des Ipis centre les inoeurs nulle ptft"
Herodotus (Melpomene § 168) tpeakiz^
of the AdyrmachijsB, a people of Africa, ii^
habiting a district which acyoins to JSgyn^
B^y^ 'f CifiXir *mi Wfjkm /MfXMmv wvfmM
I extract the followiiig passage en this suh-
ject fi-om a publication mtituleo, "^ The Bcais>
ties of Enghuid and Wales/' by the Bev> J|.
Svan^ vol. 17, part ], p. 769.
^ A custom, late retained in this district
serves as a clue to the tone and tenor of the
times; and brings conviction hwn demonstca>
tion, tliat law^ mandates, grants, &e. are a
mirror finom which is reflectea the general cha*
4X
1411] S4 GfiO&GE ni.
Tacter ortociety. This was the Amohr, a tenn
compounded of am, because, or on account
•of, woA gobr^ price, or reward, in a contracted
firm, otherwise expressed, ^eher-merchy the
latter term meaning any female, originally
perhaps a daugjhter. This in the recorch
of Caernarvon is denominated amobragium^
and is represented as the fine exacted
by the manorial lord, <it»n any one violating
the chastity jof a female, senra, or villain, or
for obtaining her hand alone in marriage. It
is there mentioned under the term * vectigal,'
by ^e phrases of ' merces fceminarum, jpre-
^ tium vninitatis/ and * pretium pro delicto
* scortanm/ Dr. Davies attempts to account
to the custom in the following way: — ^This
mulct, due to the proprietor of the soil, with the
•%enantry annexed according to the usages of the
ancient Britons, descended from the exercised ^
tyrannical power attached to feudal lords, i
prior to the introduction of Christianity, on- {
ginating out pf the right, or rather claim, of
aeOing the vireinity of their ifemale clients to
whomsoever tney pleased. But in account-
ing for the origin, the author makes use of a
mipposition tmit painfully affects the mind,
because it furnishes such a picture of human
nature, as appals by the darkness of its co-
louring. He supposes not only the capability,
but the practice of parents prostituting their
children. * Hoc pretium virginitatis patri de-
' bitum (uisse existimo si vivus esset, raortiio
^ natri domino solvendum. Hinc forte virgo
'dicitur, diffaith brenhin, descrtum regis/*
Perhaps not one of the least beneficial
duties of a topographer, is that of detecting
historical inaccuracies, correcting errors aris-
ing from implicit confidence, or an indolent
mode of quotation ; and thus preventing, to a
certain extent, the propagation of falsehood.
Trom this feudal usage, some writers have
•first imagined, and then deduced, the savage
idea, * ut domini in suis territoriis sponsarum
' omnium virginitatem prelibarent.' And
Hector Boethius [Historia, lib 3] asserts, that
this custom, which outrages barbarity, was
authorized by law in the time of Evenus the
third, who succeeded his father Ederus in the
throne of Scotkind, twelve vears antecedent
to the advent of Christ, and by an enactment
of Malcolm in the year 1080, under the in-
fluence of his Gueen the custom was abolished,
or rendered redeemable, by a fixed pecuniary
commutation, Aa/f a morlp, whence the terra
* marcheta mulierum* But from better au-
thority it appears, that no such abominable
custom ever existed in Scotland, nor probably
4n any other place. Tlie term meant, first,
the fine paid by a sokeroan, or villein, when
his daugnter wfortunately was seduced ; se-
condly, an acknov^ledgment for such a person
to have permission for bestowing his aaugh-
ter in marriage lo a stranger, or a fine, as a
icompensatioa for so doing, without such leave
* See his Dictionarium Dupl» in voc.
Amobr.
Aihiendaio
[UK
obtained [Dalrymple's Annals of Seodudy
Because at a eertain period of cor faiMij,
servile tenants coukl neither nve their an
education, nor dispose of their dui^Haia
marriage, without an express hcei^ ftn
their superior lord \ Kennet's Glossaxy].
** This Amobyr certainly was an ancMBtlli-
tish custom, answerable to the fyn-w^fU i
the Saxons, and the marcktta muUmm of the
NormaiM. But the Welsh code of iavsiii
far from encouraging either adulteiy or kh
nication, endeavoured to check, by wm
fines, every indecorous liberty with the %
sex; and the umobyr was legtslati?elj is*
tended to prevent the mischievaus eftdi i
libidinous propensity [Lef^ps WaUics likilc
i, where numerous provisions are BMde»
specting the hix sex, that are imliko flf
thing contained in the English juridicsloede;
and which, while they bespeak a stroogaeaa
of the importance of paying regard to deconn,
participate of achivalrous spint of legislitiail
It is strange a custom opprobrious to li
human feeling, should have coatinoedir
long. Richard Pulesdon, in the reigs i
Edward the second, held certain lands btfai
district, by a tenure, consisting of certain m*
vices, including per amahrogium,
'< Under thisoommutatiTerestriclioiifGiftat
de Maisnil paid ten marks, in silver, to Ho?
the third, for obtaining the king's iesvelotttt
a wife ; and Cicely, widow of Bmgk P«*|^
a large douceur, for liceiH:e to many •«•
she pleased. In the best legal Mihwitja-
tant fTomlins's Law Dictionary], this o«|J
b defined to be < a custom in the Iwi^^
' Clun, an adjacent district belongfog lo tte
< earls of Arundel; which custom Hemyw
' of Arundel only released to his teiiaali7» *
< late as the year 1557/"
At the end of page 10 H, ni^M thefMmH
panage.
Of the subsequent adventures o*'***JJf!
iles, I regret that I cannot furnish t****^
with a very particular account. The J*^'*!?
Ftsh E Palm EE has already been detaiied,|k^
Moia soon after bis arrival lo^
South Wales, effected his escape to W*
America, whence he took a passage ^ ^^
During this vo^ge in an action ''•^^J fioa
frijgate, he receivMl a wound in the beta ; »«»
this he recovered ; but on his anrivsl »^
place of his destination, he was cast into pn^
by the Spanish authorities, and reniauifia »
confinement until on the applic^^o''^^
Talleyrand, in the name of the tb^S^
ment of France he obtained his '^'^^Jl^Lii;
then returned to France and died at BwffJJ'J^
Gessald {who at the time of b*J*'"L-Q
boured under very ill health) and S^J^
died soon after their arrival in Nc«^ zZ*
Maurice Margabot, whoapp<*^||'^^
conduct^ himself tbrou^iout, with vo»^
abandoned and shamekaw proflig^* ^^^^
only one of these convicts who '•'"'"SL
Great Britain. In the year 181S» aPQB»>^
1413]
Gerrald'i Caie*
A. D. 1794.
[14 1«
of the House of Commons having been ap-
pointed to inquire into the manner in which
sentences of transportation are executed, and
the effects which nave been produced by that
mode of punishment, amongst the witnesses
examined by that committee in the course of
their inquines, I find the name of Maeoabot.
By his testimony, it appears that he remained
in New South Wales until the year 1810, and
that tiie expense attending his return from that
colony to London, amountedj[within a few shil-
lings), to four hundred and nfty pounds sterl-
line.* This worthless man died soon after
(I believe in Nov. 1815) while a subKription
was raising for his relief.
Some curious particulars relative to Palmer
and Skirvine, wUl be found in a pamphlet in-
tituled '' A Narrative of the Suffering} of T. F.
Palmer, and W. Skirving, during a voyage to
New South Wales, 1794, on board the Sur-
Srize Transport By Thomas Fyshe Palmer,
L A. late senior Fellow of Queen's College
Cambridge, 9nd ed. A. D. 1797," which was
published by Mr. Jeremiah Joyce. At the
end of his mtroductory pre&ce, Mr. Joyce iOi-
•erted the following letter :— -
(Copt.)
Sir,— It iswithpeculiaranxiety that, through
your medium, we, whose names are hereunto
subscribed, communicate to the public tiie
leasonsof our total separation from Mr. Mar-
garot.
Of the conduct of P. Campbell, the master
of the Surprise Transport, we nave no language
sufficiently strong to express our disapproba-
tion. With this man Mr. Maigarot had
forced the most friendly intercourse. Against
the two last subscribers, an accusation as un-
expected as it was horrible in its nature,
was preferred ; via. of leading a conspiracy to
murder the master and the crew, in order that
th^ might carr^ the ship into some foreign
harbour ; for which they were confined in such
a manner, as not merely to threaten the ruin
of their constitution, but to justify in their
minds the continual alarm of assassination
It is not however their intention in this
place, to give a detailed account of their per-
* See the Report from the Select Commit-
tee on Transportation, ordered by the House
of Commons to be printed, 10 July, 181«, pp.
58 et seq.
sonai sufferings, fiut that sacred regard to
justice which they owe to their country^ — ^that
mviolable honour attached to their common
situation, call on them to declare that Mr.
Margarot was an accessary to the wrongs thejr
have suffered, was even an instigator of their
accusation, and acted in complete collusion
with the master of the transport.
Let not Mr. Margarot, therefore, complain
of caprice in the subscribers. Let him not
presume to expect to pollute the holy and im-
mortal cause of liberty, by the association of
his name with those of its present defenders.
He knows well, and it is meet that the world
at large should know, that upon the justest
grounds, he stands a man rejected and expelled
Srom our society.
We deeply regret that our first letter^ of a
Eublic nature, should be on atopic sopamfiil;
ut sensibility must yield to principle. Man,
weak individual man, may suffer, and may
fall, but principles are eternal, and events
the most disastrous, have a tendency only to
accelerate their march, and to operate upon
their purifieationw— We are, sir your hnoiUe
servants,
Thomas Muia.
Sydney Cove Tbomas Ftsbb PALMift*
November 9, 1794. W. Sxiavms.
To Mr. Jerewtiah Jojfce,
^ In a letter,^ proceeds Mr. Jcyct,'' which
Thomas Hardy lately recdved from Mr. Mar-
Srot, dated December 1795, the names of
uir. Palmer, and Skirving, are not even meiv-
tioned ; they are, however, probably the per<<
sons alluded to in the following paragraph :
^ * Gerrald is arrived, the same as you and I
have long known him ; he has fled my habi-
tation, and the fraternal re(;pption I gave hhn,
to join others, who may, perhaps, m return
for those good thin« he has brought with
him, encoursjge his nilings, and feed hb va-
nity with insidious praise. Gerrald will, how-
ever, soon feel the destructive effects.' ^ A Na«
rative, &c. pp. xi, xii.
In a periodical publication, intituled The
Monthly Kepository, Vol. xii. p. 5204, will be
found a letter written bv Palmer, on board the
Hulk at Woolwich the day before his transpor-
tation, and in pp. 20 1 et seq. of the same Volume
are inserted some letters, written by Muir and
Palmer, in which the latter ^ves an account
of the manner in which he was received on
his arrival in New South WsJes,
EKD OF VOL. XXra.
Priatad by T. C Hansard, Peterborougb-CoQit,
H<Ct-Stf 6gt, liOOdOD.
27 ^31STL
« 511,
Ei
^-VSl
a bios Ob QSH 752 3